Download - In search of intimate streets
-
8/8/2019 In search of intimate streets
1/14
Comrades from Jakarta, let us build a Jakarta into the greatest city possible. Great not just from a material
point of view; great, not just because of its skyscrapers; great not just because it has boulevards and beautiful
streets; great not just because it has beautiful monuments; great in every respect, even in the little houses of the
workers of Jakarta there must be a sense of greatness Give Jakarta an extraordinary place in the minds of the
Indonesian people, because Jakarta belongs to the people of Jakarta. Jakarta belongs to the whole Indonesian
people. More than that, Jakarta is becoming the beacon of the whole of mankind. Yes, the beacon of the New
Emerging Forces.
-President Sukarno, Cited in Abeyasekere p.168
-
8/8/2019 In search of intimate streets
2/14
ThevoiceofIndonesiasrstPresident,Soekarno,
slowly fades out, overwhelmed by honking cars and rumbling
engines. I kept walking on the elevated pedestrian way, sensing
the remnants of Soekarnos ambition that have become vast,
desolatespaces.Agroupofofceworkersgotoutofthebus,
and continued onto the platform. As they were heavily climbing
the stairs, their eyes looked tired, expressing dullness and
disappointment.Atthebackground,anunnishedskyscraper
stood out, haunting the street view with its bare concrete
columns, recalling the past economic downfall. I looked down
to the 10-lanes wide street below me. The streams of cars and
motorbikes kept going and rushing, swallowing any othervoices. The inhabitants, including myself, are awake from the
dream of a greatest city possible, only to face the ordeal of
reality.
The capital of Indonesia, Jakarta, has lured me into her
cataclysmic modernity. The idea of opening up opportunities of
sustainable utopia in Jakarta is discouraged upon witnessing
that the city is deemed as a locus of crisis, a labyrinth in
which anyone who heroically attempts to alleviate a mess will
inevitably end up in a bigger one (Agung Hujatnikajennong,
in Helmond p.11). A Jakartan could survive either on the
possession of a private car or determination to bear the
scorching sun heat, the polluted air, the risk of being assaulted,
andtheseeminglyinnitedistanceunreachablebymeans
of walking. Through violent historical events and corruptive
fundamentals, the city had been severely traumatized during its
premature stage in the dawn of the nations independence and
thus grew into a vast, dismal megalopolis stretched apart by
the horde of private cars. The problems of Jakarta are very well
engraved in her history that they have become a fateful persona
of the city and of the citizens.
I most vividly remember my experiences exploring
the city out of curiosity, especially those when I took public
transport. Before Transjakarta Bus was popularized in
2004, getting around the major parts of the city would be an
impossibly exhaustive experience. In the older vehicle, the lackofair-conditioningampliedthejumbleofactivitiesinsideinto
a nerve-wracking crowd. The street parade was happening
inside the bus: a vendor offering peanuts and cigarettes; heat
and moist coming in and out of my lungs, often trying to
chokeme;motorbikeshonkingtheirwaythroughthetrafc
jam outside precariously; street musician shouting songs like
protests; and bule, the local term for foreign tourists, holding
on to an enormous backpack possibly containing one month
supply of food, considering the city is a sublime, wild nature.
But in the new bus, air-conditioned passengers enjoy the tour
along the front faade of the streets, where we can see the
glitz and glam of malls and bars, the somber and authoritative
municipal buildings, and the limp and abandoned parts of the
-
8/8/2019 In search of intimate streets
3/14
oldcity.Whileitrunsonitsownlane,trafcfreesometimes,
the bus pierces through the street scenes outside: hours
longtrafccongestionsofcars,taxis,trucks,minibuses,and
vendors and snarls of motorbikes weaving through the small
openings, creating physical chaos. The bus ride clearly briefs
the characters of Jakarta: its highly opulent and ephemeral
imitations of Western extravagance, and in contrast, the
stretch of barren areas behind walls and below highways where
dubious street-dwellers lurk. It was a much more animated
experience compared to taking a taxi or driving a car, where
shut car windows mutes the streets, deafening our ears,
pampering us with the luxury of privacy. The people who takepublic transports are those obligated due to their low income
and the need to commute from rural areas or the citys vicinity
to center. Those who can afford greater luxury wont take the
chance and rely instead on private vehicles. This is still the case
even in the newer bus system that transports group of people
with the same low income, but cleaner and more orderly. While
they share the same street, there is a clear separation between
public and private vehicles, between the bus driver and the
chauffeur, between the chaos and the silence.
The sheer social imbalance between the high-class
societytolowerclasspeopleisnotonlyreectedinthetwo
separate transportation group, the privatized cars for the
rich, and motorbikes and minibuses for the poor, but also
illuminated in an inevitable cycle that empowers the social gap.
-
8/8/2019 In search of intimate streets
4/14
The more people use private cars, the worse the conditions of
thestreetsastrafcjamsintervalsincrease.Thebuilthighways
to temporarily relieve the congestion destroy pedestrian
accessibilities and the value of the area, hindering people to
walk on the streets and encouraging dissident dwellings among
the barren infrastructure, under the highways and behind
the wall gates. The owners of private cars have taken refuge
in vehicles to protect themselves from the discomfort and
danger of the streets outside. The city is transformed into a big
wild-animal reservations of Africa, where tourists are warned
to leave their cars under no circumstances until they reach a
lodge (Jacobs, p. 46). In fact, most of my acquaintances havenever taken a public transport even once after living in the city
for18-20yearsbecausethereisagoodamountofjustiable
reason that goes along with their contemplation. The image of
the streets as being dangerous, dirty, and unpleasant has been
embedded in the mind of most Jakartans like an inerasable
trauma.
During the year of living dangerously, a period of
time during the transition of power when Suharto took the
leadership over Sukarno by eradicating the Communist Party
and any of his supporters in 1966, violent acts of massacre
of over half a million Indonesians on the streets had greatly
affected on how Jakartas streets function and what activities
can and cannot happen. A novel and a movie with the same
title, The Year of Living Dangerously by Christopher Koch,
portray the tumult and violence during the oppression of the
New Order regime by injecting the image of fear of the streets
to the viewers and readers. The space of the street as the
locus of Sukarnos revolution has been turned into the site of
disturbance. It became a dangerous place, which, in the
name of national security, demanded constant anticipation
from the government. With the end of populist politics,
Sukarnos revolutionary subject was decapitated and the street,
where they used to parade, was criminalized (Kusno. p.104).
Now, as the streets are no longer used for parades or leisure
they need to become longer and wider to accommodate largestreamsoftrafcandtoconnectpeopleandtransportgoods
between gated suburbs, where wealthy community takes
shelter, without a sense of guilt since the streets had been
cursed with political violence. Smaller streets grow larger, and
big streets never transform to intimate streets.
Ofcoursethereareareasspecicallydesignatedfor
pedestrians. Ironically however, visitors must drive and park
their car on a nearby parking lot to reach these places. Within
the center of the city, most of the streets are not pedestrian
friendly. One time I tried to prove myself that the citys streets
are not dangerous but I couldnt. The scenes of the streets
kept alienating me, giving a sense that I dont belong here or
that Ive trespassed someones territory. One minute I was
-
8/8/2019 In search of intimate streets
5/14
walking in front of a glitzy mall complex, complete with signs
of clothing lines like Louis Vuitton, Salvatore Ferragamo, and
Debenhams, labeling the building like nametags. Due to past
events of terrorist bombing in public places such as this mall,
security guards were scattered along the entrances, checking
each persons purse and bag with a metal detector. Another
minute, only a few steps from the dazzling mall, I arrived
ataslumdwellingcomplex.Mysurroundingswerelthy.A
row of three-story slum houses was on my left side, and dark
black open sewage, bordered by rigid concrete wall was on my
right side. Behind the wall is a vast, green range, reserved for
playing golf. The stench of rotten garbage and wastewater washaunting my nose. Some eyes were peering from the balcony
of the slum houses; dogs and chickens were scavenging the
trash pile. I continued walking for about three hours, among
gated neighborhood and highways, only to realize that none of
the streets were expecting pedestrians. I didnt see any people
walking beside some street dwellers and street urchins, aimless
and desolated, lurking in the shadows, hoping that their
presence went unnoticed.
When I tried to solve the problems of Jakarta, I
was discouraged and frustrated by the limitless issue that
permeates throughout the entire city. Just like the city
dwellerisfrustratedwhenhecannotndhumanorderinhis
environment (Maki p.29). I realized then that the problems
of Jakarta are also triggered by the need of escape from the
-
8/8/2019 In search of intimate streets
6/14
problems as quickly as possible. The businesses here welcome
any global prospective investors who are offered greater luxury
that costs much less compared to many other mega cities in
the world. Globalization and foreign exchange become the
powerhouse of the citys development. There is a need to
transform the look of Jakarta by mending and patching certain
areas, removing unwanted parts, like plastic surgery. New
suburban developments thrived, and modern skyscrapers and
apartments were placed along the arterial roads, squashing
any low income houses before them. However, what they
(major developers) fail to observe is that there is nothing less
urbane, nothing less productive of cosmopolitan mixture, than
raw renewal, which displaces, destroys, and replaces, in that
mechanistic order (Maki p.34). The fear of the streets has
propelled exclusive communities to isolate themselves from the
the streets by creating formal separations, and thus creating
disconnections in the citys environment itself. A renowned
poet, Goenawan Mohamad, also stated the capitals cruelty:
Jakarta does not seem to offer any meaningful sense ofconnection; there is nothing that must be retained andmust not be lost The city is alienating and it cannotstand alone, it is neither controlled by the Dutch-style fortress nor by the spirit of the ancient JavaneseMataram Kingdom, but by something else, somethingstronger the economic and political forces around it,that made us all foreigners here.
(Cited in Kusno p.162)
INTIMATE STREETS
In one sense, Jakarta is a city that doesnt function properly.
There are more separations and restricting political forces
than linkages. These moments of separations alienate city-
dwellers and when he sees only the results of mechanical and
economic processes controlling the form and feel of his place,
he must feel estranged, and outside (Maki p.29). When the
citys streets cannot function to link different things together,
when walls and mega structures block the streets potentials,
the city also stop operating to bring people together. After all,
the formal quality of a city is the agglomerate of decisions (and
abnegations from decisions) in the past concerning the way in
whichthingsttogether,orarelinked(Makip.29).Thesame
way that Jakartas streets become separators that encourage
trafcjams,pollution,socialdiscrepancy,politicalturmoil,
and the fear of the streets, they could also become links that
are adhesive. Any parts of the city could become a link, but the
streets, especially in Jakarta, are the main glue of the city that
unite all the layers of activity and resulting physical form in
the city (Maki p.35).
In search of intimate streets, I enjoyed the experience
walking along some of Jakartas alleys that develop into
a line of market stalls and small restaurants. An alley in
Glodok area in Jakarta for instance, although still displayed
a slum-like quality, was bustling with traders, children, and
-
8/8/2019 In search of intimate streets
7/14
possibly maids, who was told to buy ingredients for dinner.
Glodok is known as the Chinatown of Jakarta, yet overtime,
there seems to be a mix of business between the local native
Indonesians and the local Chinese-Indonesians regardless of
the past tension between the two groups. The need of variety
and mutual trading in this area has slowly diminished racial
segregation, that wasnt caused by differences in skin color
or physical features, but political upheavals of the past and
social contrasts. In this street, where people tend to look
inward and have the same average income, a community is
formed out of local needs. Most of the small streets in Jakarta
however,arelledwithslumswithoutproperlight,water,
and sanitation, especially in the city center. There is no clarity
between private and public spaces and everything just clutters
into a discomfort. There is no mix of activities nor mutual
relationship between each person and the alleys dont welcome
strangers. Trapped between tall skyscrapers and arterial roads,
the condition worsens overtime as they could only sulk and
tuck away the slums deeper into the crevices.
Another example of an intimate street is the vibrant
display of gluttony on Smith Street, Singapore. During the
day, the street functions normally to allow cars and public
transports passing through. But at night, the street is closed
offbyrowsofseatingslledwithhungrylocalsandtourists.
Small shops and restaurants on both sides of the street are
actively serving customers while illuminated by hanging
traditional Chinese lanterns above, acting as a visual roof. The
location of the street and how it connects one spot to another
are integral factors to popularize the street. The same method
was encouraged in one of the streets in my hometown, but due
to the location of the street in the old city neighborhood, the
street failed to revive itself over a stigma of the area being old
and scummy.
The Istiklal Avenue in Istanbul is a prime example of a
successfulpedestrianstreet.Nearlythreemillionvisitorsll
the entire street in a single day over the course of weekends.
Bars, restaurants, galleries, boutiques, cinemas, bookstores,
music stores, night clubs, cafes, and hostels occupy not
only both sides of the street but also every single alleys
branching out from Istiklal Avenue. Although the crowd seems
insurmountable, I felt constant safety walking among these
unknown people. People perform music, watch independent
lmprojectedonalargecanvas,anddancewithstrangers.
Certain times during the day, a parade marches through the
street to celebrate. In any other times, the pack of visitors,
orderly bustling in different directions, transform the street
into a festival, as if they celebrate to the city itself. It happened
that the street also connects two busy tram stations on
both ends of the street, and two monuments: a historically
important tower, and a politically important Monument of
Independence. The street ends to a large city square, where
bus stations, tram stations, streets and parks interact with each
-
8/8/2019 In search of intimate streets
8/14
-
8/8/2019 In search of intimate streets
9/14
-
8/8/2019 In search of intimate streets
10/14
other. Only when a street is linking different things and once
a street is well equipped to handle strangers, once it had both a
good, effective demarcation between private and public spaces
and has a basic supply of activity and eyes, the more strangers
the merrier. (Jacobs p.40)
A similar example is the Dotonbori street in Osaka,
which runs along the Dotonbori canal and between two
bridges. As a principal tourist destination and main
entertainment district, it also displays a festive quality. The
backstreets of Dotonbori are always cleaned and illuminated,
and even though they are only about eight feet wide, the
walking experience was pleasant and comfortable. All the
streets Ive mentioned above have a strong bonding capability.
Some of them might be wider, and some of them narrower,
but they all link the surrounding environment and encourage
mutual activities in the community. I imagined that the alleys
in Jakartas slums could potentially transform into one of
the interactive market streets, like Glodok, but instead they
become dark pits that isolate people. The alleys of Jakarta
dont provide link within the environment. Strangers and
public interventions become interrupting forces and the slum
dwellers, having seen as an outcast from the society, are further
alienated by major streets and highways.
To comprehend how slums could possibly transform to
a street in Glodok, I took Jane Jacobs argument that there is
an unslumming process that happens when there is enough
energy to retain the dwellers. Most of the dissident dwellings
in Jakarta consist of people with the least choice, forced by
poverty or discrimination to overcrowd, who come into an
unpopular area (Jacobs p.276). However, people who move to
an overcrowded area cannot expect to stay there for a long time
and those who overcome the economic necessity to overcrowd
get out, instead of improving their lot within the neighborhood.
They are quickly replaced by others who currently have little
economic choice (p.276). Due to the obligation to move into
the slum areas, people wouldnt give up another day to stay in
their crummy houses once they have the chance to get out. At
the same time, when too many people move out of slums too
fast, they leave a community in a perpetually embryonic stage,
or perpetually regressing to helpless infancy (Jacobs p.277).
This isnt the case on Glodok streets as people could actually
stay within the area while their small businesses thrive.
Jacobs also mentioned that the foundation for unslumming
is a slum lively enough to be able to enjoy city public life and
sidewalksafety(p.279).Itisclearlyreectedonhowthe
streets in Glodok welcome visitors while the slum alleys reject.
These ideas are very relatable to many cities in the world
and opportunistic due to the logic of economy. The idea of
liberating the slum dwellers from slums could be realized by
preserving the shared reliance within the community and to
imbue them with as much linkage as possible. Often times a
link couldnt happen naturally and there is a need to radically
-
8/8/2019 In search of intimate streets
11/14
change the form of Jakarta by redesigning the streets, the
facade, the accessibility, and, indirectly, the mentality of the
inhabitants.
HORIZONTAL LINK
The general form of contrast in Jakarta is a long arterial road
whereapartments,ofcesandmallsareplacedalongthe
street, creating an illusion of a modern metropolis. Behind
these buildings are sprawls of low-income housings; some are
informal, connected by countless networks of alleyways and
in between spaces. The large arterial roads dont reduce in
size gradually, but simply cutting a network of small streets,
creating jalan tikus (rats streets) which drivers coined when
taking these small alleys as shortcuts if theyre trapped
inatrafcjam.Thereisacompletedisjunction,literally
demarcated by perimeter walls between the vertical buildings
and the horizontal slum dwellings. There is a formal separation
andasocialseparationthatlimitsaccessibility.Theofcetower
userscouldnotcarelessabouttheirlthysurroundingsandthe slum dwellers have nothing to do with the apartments next
to them.
First of all, there is a need to relieve the slums from
the curtain of skyscrapers and high-rise buildings. By clearing
a way through the building and the slums behind it, there
isaporositythatnallyrevealsandlinkstheslumstothe
arterial road. This clearing would ideally continue until it
meets another arterial road and thus becoming physical link
that mediates the two roads. However, in order to encourage
pedestrian accessibility, the clearing wouldnt allow cars or
any other vehicles to pass through. Not only that the new
street connects two major roads, but on each end, a bus
station allows visitors to reach the place easily. Secondly,
on both sides of the new pedestrian street, local businesses
would be encouraged to start and thus economically support
the area with new job opportunities. These businesses would
vary in price and functions. Small businesses like souvenirs,
electronics, household appliances, fabric, drink, food, etc.
wouldfulllthenecessitytomaintainthecrowdandcustomers
during night and day, and thus preventing the area from
becoming dead, dull, and dubious when less shops are open.
The idea here is also to attract different kinds of customers
and mutual relationships between each local stores. When a
dependency towards high-class customers started to occur,
there is a tendency that the businesses would amplify the social
gap and the place could potentially be akin to red light district.
Every so often, the street would open up to a public square,
where local facilities are located, such as schools, mosques,
administrations,andsmalleldsforceremoniesandbazaars
to happen. Just like the olden days, goods are transported
manually by carts, while pedestrians and bikers voluntarily
share the same street.
-
8/8/2019 In search of intimate streets
12/14
VERTICAL LINK
(sociallink,jobs,owofmoney,tree+mushroom,housingfor
the poor, housing for the rich, )
CARSGarage or station of rapid transit system as stop, is a
link between the highway (or train) and pedestrian movement
(p.33) (includes bus station, car station)
ATTRITION OF CARS(explaintrafcjams,andthenhow?)
SEQUENTIAL PATH(from bedroom, to work, to parks, to
shopping, back to bedroom)
DESIGNING DECAY(old and new buildings integrated, old
and new city integrated)
ANIMATED CITY(lledwithmovements,andgrowsand
dies over time)
Small shops, stores and restaurants - mostly one or two
stories high - occasionally mingled with small factories,
make continuous linear development along with the streets
where street cars (artery) and bus system run. Attached small
residences behind commercial structures are occupied in
general by those who own the shops or who are in low income
groups. These areas are subject to becoming slum areas.
(Maki p.60-61)
-
8/8/2019 In search of intimate streets
13/14
-
8/8/2019 In search of intimate streets
14/14
BIBILIOGRAPHY
Abeyasekere, Susan. 1987. Jakarta: A History. Singapore:
Oxford U P.
Cortes, Jose Miguel. Dissident Cartographies. Pap/Cdr ed.
New York: Seacex, 2008. Print.
Helmond, Arjan van and Stani Michiel. Jakarta Megalopolis:
Horizontal and Vertical Observations. Amsterdam: Valiz Publishing,
2007.
Jacobs, Jane.Death and Life of Great American Cities. New
York: Random House, 1961.
Knapp, Ronald G.Asias Old Dwellings: Tradition,
Resilience, and Change. New York: Oxford University Press, 2003.
Kurokawa, Kisho. Metabolism in Architecture. Oxford:
Westview Press, 1977. Print.
Kusno, Abidin.Behind the Postcolonial: Architecture, urban
space and political culture. London: Routledge, 2000.
Maki, Fumihiko. Investigations in Collective Form. St. Louis:
Washington University, 1964.