-
[ID 204] Evaluation of ADREA-HF LES against Hydrogen release dispersionMr. Nektarios Koutsourakis1,2Dr. Alexander Venetsanos2 Prof. John G. Bartzis1
4th International Conference on Hydrogen SafetySan Francisco, California, September 12-14, 2011
1 University of West Macedonia Greece2 NCSR Demokritos Greece
HARMO 13 - ADREA LES
-
ADREA-HF CFD CODEConstantly developingLatest additions:LES (Large Eddy Simulation)Parallel solverArbitrary number of speciesCombustionBack trackingGUI pre and post processor (called EDes)Advantages:Robust, powerful and generalSpecialization in environmental applications
HARMO 13 - ADREA LES
-
ADREA-HF CFD CODEADREA specializes in dispersion applications
HARMO 13 - ADREA LES
1
0
1
1
2
2
3
6
6
9
13
13
24
32
61
211
, "dispersion"
Number of publications in SCOPUS
Publications containing in key words, in title or in summary, the word "dispersion" ( c = commercial code)
0
1
1
211
61
32
24
13
13
9
6
6
3
2
2
1
CFD , "dispersion"
FLOTHERM (c)0
FLOVENT (c)1
WIND-US1
CLAWPACK2
OPENFOAM2
CHENSI3
FLOW-3D (c)6
MERCURE6
MIMO9
STAR-CD (c)13
MISKAM (c)13
PHOENICS(c)24
ADREA32
CFX (c)61
FLUENT (c)211
1
, "dispersion"
Number of publications in SCOPUS
Publications containing in key words, in title or in summary, the word "dispersion" ( c = commercial code)
2
2
3
6
6
9
13
13
24
32
61
211
1
1
0
2
3
-
ADREA-HF CFD CODEGUI environment for pre and post processing
HARMO 13 - ADREA LES
-
LARGE EDDY SIMULATIONBetween DNS and RANSNavier-Stokes math. analysis: impossibly difficultDNS:Fully-resolved NSCost Re2.75 (for wall-bounded flows Re3.5)RANS:Time-averaged NSFast, widely tested, usually accurate enoughLES:Spatially-filtered NSCost near wall: Re2.4 ! (at outer layer Re0.5)Converges to DNS. As in DNS, LES needs: a) averaging b) demanding boundary conditionsSuggested were RANS fails: transient, separated flow
HARMO 13 - ADREA LES
-
ENERGY CASCADELES solves most of the turbulence
HARMO 13 - ADREA LES
-
LES EQUATIONS AT ADREA-HFCompressible volume-filtered Navier-Stokes
HARMO 13 - ADREA LES
-
LES EQUATIONS AT ADREA-HFAlternative subgrid model: RNG-LES
HARMO 13 - ADREA LES
-
LES AT ADREA-HFNumericsADREA/SIMPLER algorithmSolver: Parallel BiCGstab with parallel Schwarz preconditioner. Speedup with 2 CPUs up to 1.7Numerics:Deferred correction central scheme for convectionCrank-Nicolson 2d order for time advancementLinear upwind with VanLeer limiter for concentrationFor more:Venetsanos, A. G., E. Papanikolaou and J. G. Bartzis, 2010: The ADREA-HF CFD code for consequence assessment of hydrogen applications. Int. J. Hydrogen Energy, 35, 3908.
HARMO 13 - ADREA LES
-
TEST CASEHySafe INERIS-6C experiment1g/s H2 for 240sJet 20mmRoom 3.78 * 7.2 * 2.88m
HARMO 13 - ADREA LES
-
TEST CASE SETUPSimulation detailsStandard Smagorinsky with Cs=0.1Total number of cells in the room: 130000CFLmax=0.3Minimum mesh resolution: 0.02*0.02*0.053 mSimulation time in a workstation: 15 days for the release phase (240s); dtav1= 0.0005s + 2 days for the first 260s of the post-release phase
HARMO 13 - ADREA LES
-
TEST CASE SETUPGeometry, sensors, part of the grid
HARMO 13 - ADREA LES
-
RESULTSComparison with experimentPhoto from experimentADREA LES
HARMO 13 - ADREA LES
-
RESULTSVideo of the Hydrogen propagation
HARMO 13 - ADREA LES
-
RESULTSConcentration contours animation
HARMO 13 - ADREA LES
-
RESULTSComparison with sensors
HARMO 13 - ADREA LES
-
DISCUSSIONSome remarksIn general very good agreementHigh turbulence during release phase, onlyRelease overestimated, especially near source. Very difficult for CFD and for turbulence modelling to capture the physical processes next to the sourceDiffusion underestimated (possible experimental asymmetry?) - improvement with better gridBetter agreement is prevented from experimental inaccuracies and numerical discrepancies
HARMO 13 - ADREA LES
-
FURTHER EXAMINATION Cs value influence (release phase -coarse grid)Sensor 16Sensor 14Sensor 13Sensor 1Sensor 4Sensor 6Sensor 7Sensor 8Sensor 9Sensor 10Sensor 12Jet axis sensorsCeiling sensorsSide wall sensors
HARMO 13 - ADREA LES
2
1.355247491.25750701891.08603630691.7165706131
1.34305349541.24223291861.10096120782.0414100383
1.16670327081.0601743770.97945422061.6831237647
1.35658473981.2539054071.16382364911.8449786768
0.89398425220.88844003270.8582487670.891941033
0.93994096930.95279436440.93410471410.988236012
0.76340028660.77228599210.75578172410.8022781945
0.79438952110.80944480770.78923988510.8479109654
1.41308037031.40635038961.41502189211.53441939
1.45069273961.40955253471.47196649071.2649467252
0.95722966351.34542803171.33537253061.2746463215
Cs=0.08
Cs=0.1
Cs=0.12
Cs=0.2
Sensors along route
Cp/Co
Geom
Avgs
sensorAv releaseAv diffusionAv release *100expCp/CoSensorCoCp run12Cp run17Cp run15Cp run11Cp run14Cp run16SensorLESRNG LEScoarse Cs=0.08coar Cs=0.1coar Cs=0.12coar Cs=0.2SensorLESRNG LEScoarse Cs=0.08coarse Cs=0.1coarse Cs=0.12coarse Cs=0.2RouteCexpRouteCs=0.08Cs=0.1Cs=0.12Cs=0.2RouteLESRNG LESRouteLESLES coarseSensorRMS run12RMS run17RMS run15RMS run11RMS run14RMS run16SensorVAR run12VAR run17VAR run15VAR run11VAR run14VAR run16
10.08904240420.06957617198.90424041675.98189832291.48853088716.84111527150.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0010.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+001.00E+001.30E+001.24E+001.36E+001.25E+001.16E+001.84E+00R1(s16)16.47R1(s16)1.361.261.091.72R1(s16)1.29690877921.160045616R1(s16)1.29690877921.2618.83E+008.44919627059.34737738478.68378791347.999387870612.508468206611.45E+001.36583733471.24480776971.6066807540.98708355950.7414616171
20.08461360830.06951848938.4613608333222R2(s14)7.63R2(s14)1.341.241.102.04R2(s14)1.30209698461.1882737639R2(s14)1.30209698461.2428.47E+008.04269946488.82239761518.22642935537.860050702611.210295434721.17E+001.08235389561.03578816031.28229091661.16223948211.0577754308
30.075934360.06952752617.593436333R3(s13)7.77R3(s13)1.171.060.981.68R3(s13)1.12043044351.0486100431R3(s13)1.12043044351.0637.58E+007.33197373117.72266209467.50526634827.19713751858.44360328738.67E-011.04496150070.90638643331.2047736931.02376568730.7447003523
40.06328481920.06947924866.32848191676.32053777331.001256877847.15351887920.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0040.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0040.89156278890.88312144260.89398425220.88844003270.8582487670.891941033R4(s1)6.84R4(s1)1.361.251.161.84R4(s1)1.30E+001.24E+00R4(s1)1.30E+001.2546.47E+006.37700296796.44485117176.44432059266.20290737576.63866456247.40E-010.77253284480.63837765010.7847930130.45047955770.5016174019
50.0535340510.06942896645.3534051555R5(s4)7.15R5(s4)0.890.890.860.89R5(s4)0.89156278890.8831214426R5(s4)0.89156278890.8955.51E+005.28927076595.13215607575.17634028795.15186166115.320212058654.91E-010.55367029360.48730889540.50996739120.4463213060.4819262842All the game is a balance between resolved and unresolved turbulence...
60.04819253650.06936678624.81925364814.45208262851.082471744264.75804576740.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0060.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0061.02744791930.99415508650.93994096930.95279436440.93410471410.988236012R6(s6)4.76R6(s6)0.940.950.930.99R6(s6)1.02744791930.9941550865R6(s6)1.02744791930.9564.97E+004.82539480924.5236881344.60524708794.55758779684.85701344564.18E-010.49484257350.46244669930.49073505450.4050295490.4790216778
70.0462443980.0693800834.62443980295.14945807120.898043976575.67829783370.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0070.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0070.82626990010.79933030640.76340028660.77228599210.75578172410.8022781945R7(s7)5.68R7(s7)0.760.770.760.80R7(s7)0.82626990010.7993303064R7(s7)0.82626990010.7774.81E+004.63293427564.38448228234.4602204734.39330684424.690915318773.79E-010.47440870760.43307079130.4500243490.37577953180.4885653634VARIANCE IS A MEASURE OF RESOLVED TURBULENCE - if total turbulence is higher, it means that the SGS (unresolved) is higher.
80.03877551520.06885231863.87755152294.37319637950.886663023284.6344004320.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0080.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0080.84735364250.83450199870.79438952110.80944480770.78923988510.8479109654R8(s8)4.63R8(s8)0.790.810.790.85R8(s8)0.84735364250.8345019987R8(s8)0.84735364250.8184.06E+004.00711903423.73929910563.88487927513.79196011034.100041441384.11E-010.49119766520.42877462450.48130601320.42093606510.5155630788
90.03285444650.06712805733.28544465352.76649384321.187584299892.51550539160.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0090.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0091.33229469591.30732890921.41308037031.40635038961.41502189211.53441939R9(s9)2.52R9(s9)1.411.411.421.53R9(s9)1.33229469591.3073289092R9(s9)1.33229469591.4193.50E+003.43582284183.62539265343.64267101113.71070831954.086138339394.84E-010.57680177840.50821046630.44048952920.5008026720.5484720528
100.02907749820.05994459052.90774982132.52446926491.1518261924102.26280325840.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+00100.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+00101.30217568041.26245156331.45069273961.40955253471.47196649071.2649467252R10(s10)2.26R10(s10)1.451.411.471.26R10(s10)1.30217568041.2624515633R10(s10)1.30217568041.41103.13E+003.02920527613.37820166173.33130886683.56127152372.9327300261105.62E-010.57956149070.63657192540.69658456850.49953901850.4279822964
110.01215113740.03746897981.21511373530.51515708952.358724669110.13815530680.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+00110.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0011R11(s12)0.06R11(s12)0.961.351.341.27R11(s12)0.56334183870.8678711305R11(s12)0.56334183871.35119.02E-011.09145545881.43808517431.41179714491.42600803511.178658578112.24E-010.3281942210.34663591550.3649511630.45145695660.2689870394
120.00066863670.00698175870.06686367380.06575186911.016909096120.0605801950.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+00120.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+00120.56334183870.86787113050.95722966351.34542803171.33537253061.2746463215122.63E-020.05626761050.10363459040.08291156540.05034337680.0608383324124.55E-040.00184078420.00737738570.00492814410.001605670.0026426834
130.087285760.068991038.7285766.81147142031.2814523414137.77313759260.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+00130.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+00131.12043044351.04861004311.16670327081.0601743770.97945422061.6831237647138.75E+008.15731923179.1742479438.28599495347.715560513112.8483355048131.72E+001.91294406331.92106093161.75033461781.80788411961.3837500073
140.09961215120.06706874079.9612151256.57218533321.5156625414147.63084513080.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+00140.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+00141.30209698461.18827376391.34305349541.24223291861.10096120782.0414100383141.00E+019.213766989210.39889657079.50456446478.693760953115.3641654391143.64E+003.12746595073.10256689113.85025162753.01037740181.4327616157
150.13524045580.060348323313.5240455833151515151.40E+0112.152141727113.986809649713.141147122211.804771626321.0422089393158.29E+006.00750470566.00945406146.7903895446.02802342141.6494965686
160.21687470540.037643184221.687470541713.81444860721.56991213751616.47109782070.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+00160.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+00161.29690877921.1600456161.355247491.25750701891.08603630691.7165706131162.15E+0119.939475933322.676666656420.767173839618.132998277328.3160802761162.06E+0118.12239651515.941044817819.792103097515.95663895680.9593939278
expWITH NO SENSOR 11
sensor1-0.00466229543.3195858622
6.64383401986.8411152715
7.03839652327.7849938351
8.5315911469
sensor40.05571310883.1375718323
6.21943055577.1535188792
8.08760720278.6705226086
9.2534380145
60.08118064441.8401733618
3.59916607924.7580457674
5.91692545566.7580287563
7.599132057
70.01975175172.3965773711
4.77340299055.6782978337
6.58319267697.3734990086
8.1638053403
8-0.06057833881.7543304219RNG has higher resolved in more laminar parts and lower resolved in turbulent parts (*)
3.56923918274.634400432
5.69956168126.7308582845
7.7621548878
9-0.00835222070.0782546137
0.1648614482.5155053916
4.86614933525.7057215243
6.5452937134
100.00351172920.166443308
0.32937488692.2628032584
4.19623162995.1441612282
6.0920908266
110.10394269340.1031470512
0.10235140910.1381553068
0.17395920461.3041689104
2.4343786162
120.05540852090.0585910896
0.06177365830.060580195
0.05938673170.0780843228
0.0967819138
130.09439498733.4750785776
6.85576216797.7731375926
8.69051301739.1861980907
9.6818831641
14-0.00835222073.6825225985
7.37339741767.6308451308
7.8882928448.4031882704
8.9180836968
16-0.01938184338.4001036244
16.819589092216.4710978207
16.122606549216.5721443766
17.021682204
Avgs
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
nk: (from 80s and 160s observations)
nk:Average from 40 to 200
nk:Cs = 0.08 coarse
nk:Cs = 0.1 coarse
nk:Cs = 0.12 coarse
nk:Cs = 0.2 coarse
nk:RNG LES
LES
RNG LES
coarse Cs=0.08
coar Cs=0.1
coar Cs=0.12
coar Cs=0.2
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
LES
RNG LES
coarse Cs=0.08
coarse Cs=0.1
coarse Cs=0.12
coarse Cs=0.2
Cexp
Sensors along route
C
Cexp (80s and 160s measurements only)
Cs=0.08
Cs=0.1
Cs=0.12
Cs=0.2
Sensors along route
Cp/Co
LES
RNG LES
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
LES
LES coarse
- LES close with coarse- In ceiling Cp is higher due to exp asymmetry- In ceiling buoyancy wins turbulence;all models sam- Release: need better turb capture and more diffusion- Cs 0.12>0.1>0.08>0.2Lower t,sgs may result to low turb or high resolv(also depends on the grid)
RMS run12
RMS run17
RMS run15
RMS run11
RMS run14
RMS run16
RMS
VAR run12
VAR run17
VAR run15
VAR run11
VAR run14
VAR run16
VAR run12
VAR run17
VAR run15
VAR run11
VAR run14
VAR run16
1
16.4710978207
7.6308451308
7.7731375926
6.8411152715
7.1535188792
4.7580457674
5.6782978337
4.634400432
2.5155053916
2.2628032584
0.060580195
Cexp
Sensors along route
Co
Cexp (40s - 200s average)
Avgs
sensorAv releaseAv diffusionAv release *100expCp/CoSensorCoCp run12Cp run17Cp run15Cp run11Cp run14Cp run16SensorLESRNG LEScoarse Cs=0.08coar Cs=0.1coar Cs=0.12coar Cs=0.2SensorLESRNG LEScoarse Cs=0.08coarse Cs=0.1coarse Cs=0.12coarse Cs=0.2RouteCexpRouteCs=0.08Cs=0.1Cs=0.12Cs=0.2RouteLESRNG LESRouteLESLES coarseSensorRMS run12RMS run17RMS run15RMS run11RMS run14RMS run16SensorVAR run12VAR run17VAR run15VAR run11VAR run14VAR run16
10.08904240420.06957617198.90424041675.98189832291.48853088716.84111527150.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0010.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+001.00E+001.30E+001.24E+001.36E+001.25E+001.16E+001.84E+00R1(s16)16.47R1(s16)1.361.261.091.72R1(s16)1.29690877921.160045616R1(s16)1.29690877921.2618.83E+008.44919627059.34737738478.68378791347.999387870612.508468206611.451.36583733471.24480776971.6066807540.98708355950.7414616171
20.08461360830.06951848938.4613608333222R2(s14)7.63R2(s14)1.341.241.102.04R2(s14)1.30209698461.1882737639R2(s14)1.30209698461.2428.47E+008.04269946488.82239761518.22642935537.860050702611.210295434721.171.08235389561.03578816031.28229091661.16223948211.0577754308
30.075934360.06952752617.593436333R3(s13)7.77R3(s13)1.171.060.981.68R3(s13)1.12043044351.0486100431R3(s13)1.12043044351.0637.58E+007.33197373117.72266209467.50526634827.19713751858.44360328730.871.04496150070.90638643331.2047736931.02376568730.7447003523
40.06328481920.06947924866.32848191676.32053777331.001256877847.15351887920.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0040.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0040.89156278890.88312144260.89398425220.88844003270.8582487670.891941033R4(s1)6.84R4(s1)1.361.251.161.84R4(s1)1.30E+001.24E+00R4(s1)1.30E+001.2546.47E+006.37700296796.44485117176.44432059266.20290737576.63866456240.740.77253284480.63837765010.7847930130.45047955770.5016174019
50.0535340510.06942896645.3534051555R5(s4)7.15R5(s4)0.890.890.860.89R5(s4)0.89156278890.8831214426R5(s4)0.89156278890.8955.51E+005.28927076595.13215607575.17634028795.15186166115.320212058650.490.55367029360.48730889540.50996739120.4463213060.4819262842All the game is a balance between resolved and unresolved turbulence...
60.04819253650.06936678624.81925364814.45208262851.082471744264.75804576740.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0060.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0061.02744791930.99415508650.93994096930.95279436440.93410471410.988236012R6(s6)4.76R6(s6)0.940.950.930.99R6(s6)1.02744791930.9941550865R6(s6)1.02744791930.9564.97E+004.82539480924.5236881344.60524708794.55758779684.85701344560.420.49484257350.46244669930.49073505450.4050295490.4790216778
70.0462443980.0693800834.62443980295.14945807120.898043976575.67829783370.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0070.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0070.82626990010.79933030640.76340028660.77228599210.75578172410.8022781945R7(s7)5.68R7(s7)0.760.770.760.80R7(s7)0.82626990010.7993303064R7(s7)0.82626990010.7774.81E+004.63293427564.38448228234.4602204734.39330684424.690915318770.380.47440870760.43307079130.4500243490.37577953180.4885653634VARIANCE IS A MEASURE OF RESOLVED TURBULENCE - if total turbulence is higher, it means that the SGS (unresolved) is higher.
80.03877551520.06885231863.87755152294.37319637950.886663023284.6344004320.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0080.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0080.84735364250.83450199870.79438952110.80944480770.78923988510.8479109654R8(s8)4.63R8(s8)0.790.810.790.85R8(s8)0.84735364250.8345019987R8(s8)0.84735364250.8184.06E+004.00711903423.73929910563.88487927513.79196011034.100041441380.410.49119766520.42877462450.48130601320.42093606510.5155630788
90.03285444650.06712805733.28544465352.76649384321.187584299892.51550539160.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0090.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0091.33229469591.30732890921.41308037031.40635038961.41502189211.53441939R9(s9)2.52R9(s9)1.411.411.421.53R9(s9)1.33229469591.3073289092R9(s9)1.33229469591.4193.50E+003.43582284183.62539265343.64267101113.71070831954.086138339390.480.57680177840.50821046630.44048952920.5008026720.5484720528
100.02907749820.05994459052.90774982132.52446926491.1518261924102.26280325840.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+00100.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+00101.30217568041.26245156331.45069273961.40955253471.47196649071.2649467252R10(s10)2.26R10(s10)1.451.411.471.26R10(s10)1.30217568041.2624515633R10(s10)1.30217568041.41103.13E+003.02920527613.37820166173.33130886683.56127152372.9327300261100.560.57956149070.63657192540.69658456850.49953901850.4279822964
110.01215113740.03746897981.21511373530.51515708952.358724669110.13815530680.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+00110.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0011R11(s12)0.06R11(s12)0.961.351.341.27R11(s12)0.56334183870.8678711305R11(s12)0.56334183871.35119.02E-011.09145545881.43808517431.41179714491.42600803511.178658578110.220.3281942210.34663591550.3649511630.45145695660.2689870394
120.00066863670.00698175870.06686367380.06575186911.016909096120.0605801950.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+00120.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+00120.56334183870.86787113050.95722966351.34542803171.33537253061.2746463215122.63E-020.05626761050.10363459040.08291156540.05034337680.0608383324120.000.00184078420.00737738570.00492814410.001605670.0026426834
130.087285760.068991038.7285766.81147142031.2814523414137.77313759260.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+00130.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+00131.12043044351.04861004311.16670327081.0601743770.97945422061.6831237647138.75E+008.15731923179.1742479438.28599495347.715560513112.8483355048131.721.91294406331.92106093161.75033461781.80788411961.3837500073
140.09961215120.06706874079.9612151256.57218533321.5156625414147.63084513080.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+00140.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+00141.30209698461.18827376391.34305349541.24223291861.10096120782.0414100383141.00E+019.213766989210.39889657079.50456446478.693760953115.3641654391143.643.12746595073.10256689113.85025162753.01037740181.4327616157
150.13524045580.060348323313.5240455833151515151.40E+0112.152141727113.986809649713.141147122211.804771626321.0422089393158.296.00750470566.00945406146.7903895446.02802342141.6494965686
160.21687470540.037643184221.687470541713.81444860721.56991213751616.47109782070.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+00160.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+00161.29690877921.1600456161.355247491.25750701891.08603630691.7165706131162.15E+0119.939475933322.676666656420.767173839618.132998277328.31608027611620.6018.12239651515.941044817819.792103097515.95663895680.9593939278
Route
expWITH NO SENSOR 11R1(s16)20.6018.12239651515.941044817819.792103097515.95663895680.9593939278
sensor1-0.00466229543.3195858622R2(s14)3.643.12746595073.10256689113.85025162753.01037740181.4327616157
6.64383401986.8411152715R3(s13)1.721.91294406331.92106093161.75033461781.80788411961.3837500073
7.03839652327.7849938351R4(s1)1.451.36583733471.24480776971.6066807540.98708355950.7414616171
8.5315911469R5(s4)0.740.77253284480.63837765010.7847930130.45047955770.5016174019
R6(s6)0.420.49484257350.46244669930.49073505450.4050295490.4790216778
sensor40.05571310883.1375718323R7(s7)0.380.47440870760.43307079130.4500243490.37577953180.4885653634
6.21943055577.1535188792R8(s8)0.410.49119766520.42877462450.48130601320.42093606510.5155630788
8.08760720278.6705226086R9(s9)0.480.57680177840.50821046630.44048952920.5008026720.5484720528
9.2534380145R10(s10)0.560.57956149070.63657192540.69658456850.49953901850.4279822964
R11(s12)0.000.00184078420.00737738570.00492814410.001605670.0026426834
60.08118064441.8401733618
3.59916607924.7580457674
5.91692545566.7580287563
7.599132057
70.01975175172.3965773711
4.77340299055.6782978337
6.58319267697.3734990086
8.1638053403
8-0.06057833881.7543304219RNG has higher resolved in more laminar parts and lower resolved in turbulent parts (*)
3.56923918274.634400432
5.69956168126.7308582845
7.7621548878
9-0.00835222070.0782546137
0.1648614482.5155053916
4.86614933525.7057215243
6.5452937134
100.00351172920.166443308
0.32937488692.2628032584
4.19623162995.1441612282
6.0920908266
110.10394269340.1031470512
0.10235140910.1381553068
0.17395920461.3041689104
2.4343786162
120.05540852090.0585910896
0.06177365830.060580195
0.05938673170.0780843228
0.0967819138
130.09439498733.4750785776
6.85576216797.7731375926
8.69051301739.1861980907
9.6818831641
14-0.00835222073.6825225985
7.37339741767.6308451308
7.8882928448.4031882704
8.9180836968
16-0.01938184338.4001036244
16.819589092216.4710978207
16.122606549216.5721443766
17.021682204
nk: (from 80s and 160s observations)
nk:Average from 40 to 200
nk:Cs = 0.08 coarse
nk:Cs = 0.1 coarse
nk:Cs = 0.12 coarse
nk:Cs = 0.2 coarse
nk:RNG LES
Avgs
Cexp
Sensors along route
Co
Cexp (40s - 200s average)
000000
000000
000000
000000
000000
000000
000000
000000
000000
000000
000000
000000
000000
000000
000000
000000
- LES close with coarse- In ceiling Cp is higher due to exp asymmetry- In ceiling buoyancy wins turbulence;all models sam- Release: need better turb capture and more diffusion- Cs 0.12>0.1>0.08>0.2Lower t,sgs may result to low turb or high resolv(also depends on the grid)
VAR run12
VAR run17
VAR run15
VAR run11
VAR run14
VAR run16
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
VAR run12
VAR run17
VAR run15
VAR run11
VAR run14
VAR run16
0000
0000
0000
0000
0000
0000
0000
0000
0000
0000
0000
0000
0000
0000
0000
0000
Cs=0.08
Cs=0.1
Cs=0.12
Cs=0.2
0000
0000
0000
0000
0000
0000
0000
0000
0000
0000
0000
Cs=0.08
Cs=0.1
Cs=0.12
Cs=0.2
Sensors along route
C Variance
-
DISCUSSIONCs affects the resultsCs (SGS modelling in general) important near jetAt the ceiling, no Cs influence (buoyancy dominates)Non-monotonic behaviour (increasing the Cs gives better results, but up to a limit)Worst Cs by far: 0.2
HARMO 13 - ADREA LES
-
FURTHER EXAMINATIONC variances for each CsC variance = mean (Ci2)
HARMO 13 - ADREA LES
7
15.941044817819.792103097515.95663895680.9593939278
3.10256689113.85025162753.01037740181.4327616157
1.92106093161.75033461781.80788411961.3837500073
1.24480776971.6066807540.98708355950.7414616171
0.63837765010.7847930130.45047955770.5016174019
0.46244669930.49073505450.4050295490.4790216778
0.43307079130.4500243490.37577953180.4885653634
0.42877462450.48130601320.42093606510.5155630788
0.50821046630.44048952920.5008026720.5484720528
0.63657192540.69658456850.49953901850.4279822964
0.00737738570.00492814410.001605670.0026426834
Cs=0.08
Cs=0.1
Cs=0.12
Cs=0.2
Sensors along route
C Variance
Geom
Avgs
sensorAv releaseAv diffusionAv release *100expCp/CoSensorCoCp run12Cp run17Cp run15Cp run11Cp run14Cp run16SensorLESRNG LEScoarse Cs=0.08coar Cs=0.1coar Cs=0.12coar Cs=0.2SensorLESRNG LEScoarse Cs=0.08coarse Cs=0.1coarse Cs=0.12coarse Cs=0.2RouteCexpRouteCs=0.08Cs=0.1Cs=0.12Cs=0.2RouteLESRNG LESRouteLESLES coarseSensorRMS run12RMS run17RMS run15RMS run11RMS run14RMS run16SensorVAR run12VAR run17VAR run15VAR run11VAR run14VAR run16
10.08904240420.06957617198.90424041675.98189832291.48853088716.84111527150.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0010.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+001.00E+001.30E+001.24E+001.36E+001.25E+001.16E+001.84E+00R1(s16)16.47R1(s16)1.361.261.091.72R1(s16)1.29690877921.160045616R1(s16)1.29690877921.2618.83E+008.44919627059.34737738478.68378791347.999387870612.508468206611.451.36583733471.24480776971.6066807540.98708355950.7414616171
20.08461360830.06951848938.4613608333222R2(s14)7.63R2(s14)1.341.241.102.04R2(s14)1.30209698461.1882737639R2(s14)1.30209698461.2428.47E+008.04269946488.82239761518.22642935537.860050702611.210295434721.171.08235389561.03578816031.28229091661.16223948211.0577754308
30.075934360.06952752617.593436333R3(s13)7.77R3(s13)1.171.060.981.68R3(s13)1.12043044351.0486100431R3(s13)1.12043044351.0637.58E+007.33197373117.72266209467.50526634827.19713751858.44360328730.871.04496150070.90638643331.2047736931.02376568730.7447003523
40.06328481920.06947924866.32848191676.32053777331.001256877847.15351887920.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0040.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0040.89156278890.88312144260.89398425220.88844003270.8582487670.891941033R4(s1)6.84R4(s1)1.361.251.161.84R4(s1)1.30E+001.24E+00R4(s1)1.30E+001.2546.47E+006.37700296796.44485117176.44432059266.20290737576.63866456240.740.77253284480.63837765010.7847930130.45047955770.5016174019
50.0535340510.06942896645.3534051555R5(s4)7.15R5(s4)0.890.890.860.89R5(s4)0.89156278890.8831214426R5(s4)0.89156278890.8955.51E+005.28927076595.13215607575.17634028795.15186166115.320212058650.490.55367029360.48730889540.50996739120.4463213060.4819262842All the game is a balance between resolved and unresolved turbulence...
60.04819253650.06936678624.81925364814.45208262851.082471744264.75804576740.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0060.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0061.02744791930.99415508650.93994096930.95279436440.93410471410.988236012R6(s6)4.76R6(s6)0.940.950.930.99R6(s6)1.02744791930.9941550865R6(s6)1.02744791930.9564.97E+004.82539480924.5236881344.60524708794.55758779684.85701344560.420.49484257350.46244669930.49073505450.4050295490.4790216778
70.0462443980.0693800834.62443980295.14945807120.898043976575.67829783370.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0070.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0070.82626990010.79933030640.76340028660.77228599210.75578172410.8022781945R7(s7)5.68R7(s7)0.760.770.760.80R7(s7)0.82626990010.7993303064R7(s7)0.82626990010.7774.81E+004.63293427564.38448228234.4602204734.39330684424.690915318770.380.47440870760.43307079130.4500243490.37577953180.4885653634VARIANCE IS A MEASURE OF RESOLVED TURBULENCE - if total turbulence is higher, it means that the SGS (unresolved) is higher.
80.03877551520.06885231863.87755152294.37319637950.886663023284.6344004320.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0080.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0080.84735364250.83450199870.79438952110.80944480770.78923988510.8479109654R8(s8)4.63R8(s8)0.790.810.790.85R8(s8)0.84735364250.8345019987R8(s8)0.84735364250.8184.06E+004.00711903423.73929910563.88487927513.79196011034.100041441380.410.49119766520.42877462450.48130601320.42093606510.5155630788
90.03285444650.06712805733.28544465352.76649384321.187584299892.51550539160.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0090.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0091.33229469591.30732890921.41308037031.40635038961.41502189211.53441939R9(s9)2.52R9(s9)1.411.411.421.53R9(s9)1.33229469591.3073289092R9(s9)1.33229469591.4193.50E+003.43582284183.62539265343.64267101113.71070831954.086138339390.480.57680177840.50821046630.44048952920.5008026720.5484720528
100.02907749820.05994459052.90774982132.52446926491.1518261924102.26280325840.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+00100.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+00101.30217568041.26245156331.45069273961.40955253471.47196649071.2649467252R10(s10)2.26R10(s10)1.451.411.471.26R10(s10)1.30217568041.2624515633R10(s10)1.30217568041.41103.13E+003.02920527613.37820166173.33130886683.56127152372.9327300261100.560.57956149070.63657192540.69658456850.49953901850.4279822964
110.01215113740.03746897981.21511373530.51515708952.358724669110.13815530680.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+00110.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0011R11(s12)0.06R11(s12)0.961.351.341.27R11(s12)0.56334183870.8678711305R11(s12)0.56334183871.35119.02E-011.09145545881.43808517431.41179714491.42600803511.178658578110.220.3281942210.34663591550.3649511630.45145695660.2689870394
120.00066863670.00698175870.06686367380.06575186911.016909096120.0605801950.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+00120.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+00120.56334183870.86787113050.95722966351.34542803171.33537253061.2746463215122.63E-020.05626761050.10363459040.08291156540.05034337680.0608383324120.000.00184078420.00737738570.00492814410.001605670.0026426834
130.087285760.068991038.7285766.81147142031.2814523414137.77313759260.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+00130.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+00131.12043044351.04861004311.16670327081.0601743770.97945422061.6831237647138.75E+008.15731923179.1742479438.28599495347.715560513112.8483355048131.721.91294406331.92106093161.75033461781.80788411961.3837500073
140.09961215120.06706874079.9612151256.57218533321.5156625414147.63084513080.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+00140.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+00141.30209698461.18827376391.34305349541.24223291861.10096120782.0414100383141.00E+019.213766989210.39889657079.50456446478.693760953115.3641654391143.643.12746595073.10256689113.85025162753.01037740181.4327616157
150.13524045580.060348323313.5240455833151515151.40E+0112.152141727113.986809649713.141147122211.804771626321.0422089393158.296.00750470566.00945406146.7903895446.02802342141.6494965686
160.21687470540.037643184221.687470541713.81444860721.56991213751616.47109782070.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+00160.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+00161.29690877921.1600456161.355247491.25750701891.08603630691.7165706131162.15E+0119.939475933322.676666656420.767173839618.132998277328.31608027611620.6018.12239651515.941044817819.792103097515.95663895680.9593939278
Route
expWITH NO SENSOR 11R1(s16)20.6018.12239651515.941044817819.792103097515.95663895680.9593939278
sensor1-0.00466229543.3195858622R2(s14)3.643.12746595073.10256689113.85025162753.01037740181.4327616157
6.64383401986.8411152715R3(s13)1.721.91294406331.92106093161.75033461781.80788411961.3837500073
7.03839652327.7849938351R4(s1)1.451.36583733471.24480776971.6066807540.98708355950.7414616171
8.5315911469R5(s4)0.740.77253284480.63837765010.7847930130.45047955770.5016174019
R6(s6)0.420.49484257350.46244669930.49073505450.4050295490.4790216778
sensor40.05571310883.1375718323R7(s7)0.380.47440870760.43307079130.4500243490.37577953180.4885653634
6.21943055577.1535188792R8(s8)0.410.49119766520.42877462450.48130601320.42093606510.5155630788
8.08760720278.6705226086R9(s9)0.480.57680177840.50821046630.44048952920.5008026720.5484720528
9.2534380145R10(s10)0.560.57956149070.63657192540.69658456850.49953901850.4279822964
R11(s12)0.000.00184078420.00737738570.00492814410.001605670.0026426834
60.08118064441.8401733618
3.59916607924.7580457674
5.91692545566.7580287563
7.599132057
70.01975175172.3965773711
4.77340299055.6782978337
6.58319267697.3734990086
8.1638053403
8-0.06057833881.7543304219RNG has higher resolved in more laminar parts and lower resolved in turbulent parts (*)
3.56923918274.634400432
5.69956168126.7308582845
7.7621548878
9-0.00835222070.0782546137
0.1648614482.5155053916
4.86614933525.7057215243
6.5452937134
100.00351172920.166443308
0.32937488692.2628032584
4.19623162995.1441612282
6.0920908266
110.10394269340.1031470512
0.10235140910.1381553068
0.17395920461.3041689104
2.4343786162
120.05540852090.0585910896
0.06177365830.060580195
0.05938673170.0780843228
0.0967819138
130.09439498733.4750785776
6.85576216797.7731375926
8.69051301739.1861980907
9.6818831641
14-0.00835222073.6825225985
7.37339741767.6308451308
7.8882928448.4031882704
8.9180836968
16-0.01938184338.4001036244
16.819589092216.4710978207
16.122606549216.5721443766
17.021682204
Avgs
nk: (from 80s and 160s observations)
nk:Average from 40 to 200
nk:Cs = 0.08 coarse
nk:Cs = 0.1 coarse
nk:Cs = 0.12 coarse
nk:Cs = 0.2 coarse
nk:RNG LES
LES
RNG LES
coarse Cs=0.08
coar Cs=0.1
coar Cs=0.12
coar Cs=0.2
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
LES
RNG LES
coarse Cs=0.08
coarse Cs=0.1
coarse Cs=0.12
coarse Cs=0.2
Cexp
Sensors along route
Co
Cexp (80s & 160s meas. only)
Cs=0.08
Cs=0.1
Cs=0.12
Cs=0.2
Sensors along route
Cp/Co
LES
RNG LES
LES
LES coarse
- LES close with coarse- In ceiling Cp is higher due to exp asymmetry- In ceiling buoyancy wins turbulence;all models sam- Release: need better turb capture and more diffusion- Cs 0.12>0.1>0.08>0.2Lower t,sgs may result to low turb or high resolv(also depends on the grid)
RMS run12
RMS run17
RMS run15
RMS run11
RMS run14
RMS run16
RMS
VAR run12
VAR run17
VAR run15
VAR run11
VAR run14
VAR run16
VAR run12
VAR run17
VAR run15
VAR run11
VAR run14
VAR run16
Cs=0.08
Cs=0.1
Cs=0.12
Cs=0.2
Cs=0.08
Cs=0.1
Cs=0.12
Cs=0.2
Sensors along route
C Variance
-
DISCUSSIONA critical balance: resolved vs. SGS turbulenceAs we go away from the jet, variance (and resolved turbulence intensity) dropsTwo mechanisms compete: - Modelled SGS turbulence - Resolved turbulence (generally low if SGS is high)With Cs=0.2, very high artificial viscosity causes more laminar flow and lower fluctuations
HARMO 13 - ADREA LES
-
FURTHER EXAMINATIONEvaluation of RNG-LES (run not finished yet)
HARMO 13 - ADREA LES
11
1.29690877921.160045616
1.30209698461.1882737639
1.12043044351.0486100431
1.29837100561.2390704312
0.89156278890.8831214426
1.02744791930.9941550865
0.82626990010.7993303064
0.84735364250.8345019987
1.33229469591.3073289092
1.30217568041.2624515633
0.56334183870.8678711305
LES
RNG LES
Sensors along route
Cp/Co
Geom
Avgs
sensorAv releaseAv diffusionAv release *100expCp/CoSensorCoCp run12Cp run17Cp run15Cp run11Cp run14Cp run16SensorLESRNG LEScoarse Cs=0.08coar Cs=0.1coar Cs=0.12coar Cs=0.2SensorLESRNG LEScoarse Cs=0.08coarse Cs=0.1coarse Cs=0.12coarse Cs=0.2RouteCexpRouteCs=0.08Cs=0.1Cs=0.12Cs=0.2RouteLESRNG LESRouteLESLES coarseSensorRMS run12RMS run17RMS run15RMS run11RMS run14RMS run16SensorVAR run12VAR run17VAR run15VAR run11VAR run14VAR run16
10.08904240420.06957617198.90424041675.98189832291.48853088716.84111527150.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0010.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+001.00E+001.30E+001.24E+001.36E+001.25E+001.16E+001.84E+00R1(s16)16.47R1(s16)1.361.261.091.72R1(s16)1.29690877921.160045616R1(s16)1.29690877921.2618.83E+008.44919627059.34737738478.68378791347.999387870612.508468206611.451.36583733471.24480776971.6066807540.98708355950.7414616171
20.08461360830.06951848938.4613608333222R2(s14)7.63R2(s14)1.341.241.102.04R2(s14)1.30209698461.1882737639R2(s14)1.30209698461.2428.47E+008.04269946488.82239761518.22642935537.860050702611.210295434721.171.08235389561.03578816031.28229091661.16223948211.0577754308
30.075934360.06952752617.593436333R3(s13)7.77R3(s13)1.171.060.981.68R3(s13)1.12043044351.0486100431R3(s13)1.12043044351.0637.58E+007.33197373117.72266209467.50526634827.19713751858.44360328730.871.04496150070.90638643331.2047736931.02376568730.7447003523
40.06328481920.06947924866.32848191676.32053777331.001256877847.15351887920.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0040.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0040.89156278890.88312144260.89398425220.88844003270.8582487670.891941033R4(s1)6.84R4(s1)1.361.251.161.84R4(s1)1.30E+001.24E+00R4(s1)1.30E+001.2546.47E+006.37700296796.44485117176.44432059266.20290737576.63866456240.740.77253284480.63837765010.7847930130.45047955770.5016174019
50.0535340510.06942896645.3534051555R5(s4)7.15R5(s4)0.890.890.860.89R5(s4)0.89156278890.8831214426R5(s4)0.89156278890.8955.51E+005.28927076595.13215607575.17634028795.15186166115.320212058650.490.55367029360.48730889540.50996739120.4463213060.4819262842All the game is a balance between resolved and unresolved turbulence...
60.04819253650.06936678624.81925364814.45208262851.082471744264.75804576740.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0060.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0061.02744791930.99415508650.93994096930.95279436440.93410471410.988236012R6(s6)4.76R6(s6)0.940.950.930.99R6(s6)1.02744791930.9941550865R6(s6)1.02744791930.9564.97E+004.82539480924.5236881344.60524708794.55758779684.85701344560.420.49484257350.46244669930.49073505450.4050295490.4790216778
70.0462443980.0693800834.62443980295.14945807120.898043976575.67829783370.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0070.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0070.82626990010.79933030640.76340028660.77228599210.75578172410.8022781945R7(s7)5.68R7(s7)0.760.770.760.80R7(s7)0.82626990010.7993303064R7(s7)0.82626990010.7774.81E+004.63293427564.38448228234.4602204734.39330684424.690915318770.380.47440870760.43307079130.4500243490.37577953180.4885653634VARIANCE IS A MEASURE OF RESOLVED TURBULENCE - if total turbulence is higher, it means that the SGS (unresolved) is higher.
80.03877551520.06885231863.87755152294.37319637950.886663023284.6344004320.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0080.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0080.84735364250.83450199870.79438952110.80944480770.78923988510.8479109654R8(s8)4.63R8(s8)0.790.810.790.85R8(s8)0.84735364250.8345019987R8(s8)0.84735364250.8184.06E+004.00711903423.73929910563.88487927513.79196011034.100041441380.410.49119766520.42877462450.48130601320.42093606510.5155630788
90.03285444650.06712805733.28544465352.76649384321.187584299892.51550539160.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0090.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0091.33229469591.30732890921.41308037031.40635038961.41502189211.53441939R9(s9)2.52R9(s9)1.411.411.421.53R9(s9)1.33229469591.3073289092R9(s9)1.33229469591.4193.50E+003.43582284183.62539265343.64267101113.71070831954.086138339390.480.57680177840.50821046630.44048952920.5008026720.5484720528
100.02907749820.05994459052.90774982132.52446926491.1518261924102.26280325840.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+00100.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+00101.30217568041.26245156331.45069273961.40955253471.47196649071.2649467252R10(s10)2.26R10(s10)1.451.411.471.26R10(s10)1.30217568041.2624515633R10(s10)1.30217568041.41103.13E+003.02920527613.37820166173.33130886683.56127152372.9327300261100.560.57956149070.63657192540.69658456850.49953901850.4279822964
110.01215113740.03746897981.21511373530.51515708952.358724669110.13815530680.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+00110.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+0011R11(s12)0.06R11(s12)0.961.351.341.27R11(s12)0.56334183870.8678711305R11(s12)0.56334183871.35119.02E-011.09145545881.43808517431.41179714491.42600803511.178658578110.220.3281942210.34663591550.3649511630.45145695660.2689870394
120.00066863670.00698175870.06686367380.06575186911.016909096120.0605801950.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+00120.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+00120.56334183870.86787113050.95722966351.34542803171.33537253061.2746463215122.63E-020.05626761050.10363459040.08291156540.05034337680.0608383324120.000.00184078420.00737738570.00492814410.001605670.0026426834
130.087285760.068991038.7285766.81147142031.2814523414137.77313759260.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+00130.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+00131.12043044351.04861004311.16670327081.0601743770.97945422061.6831237647138.75E+008.15731923179.1742479438.28599495347.715560513112.8483355048131.721.91294406331.92106093161.75033461781.80788411961.3837500073
140.09961215120.06706874079.9612151256.57218533321.5156625414147.63084513080.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+00140.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+00141.30209698461.18827376391.34305349541.24223291861.10096120782.0414100383141.00E+019.213766989210.39889657079.50456446478.693760953115.3641654391143.643.12746595073.10256689113.85025162753.01037740181.4327616157
150.13524045580.060348323313.5240455833151515151.40E+0112.152141727113.986809649713.141147122211.804771626321.0422089393158.296.00750470566.00945406146.7903895446.02802342141.6494965686
160.21687470540.037643184221.687470541713.81444860721.56991213751616.47109782070.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+00160.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+000.00E+00161.29690877921.1600456161.355247491.25750701891.08603630691.7165706131162.15E+0119.939475933322.676666656420.767173839618.132998277328.31608027611620.6018.12239651515.941044817819.792103097515.95663895680.9593939278
Route
expWITH NO SENSOR 11R1(s16)20.6018.12239651515.941044817819.792103097515.95663895680.9593939278
sensor1-0.00466229543.3195858622R2(s14)3.643.12746595073.10256689113.85025162753.01037740181.4327616157
6.64383401986.8411152715R3(s13)1.721.91294406331.92106093161.75033461781.80788411961.3837500073
7.03839652327.7849938351R4(s1)1.451.36583733471.24480776971.6066807540.98708355950.7414616171
8.5315911469R5(s4)0.740.77253284480.63837765010.7847930130.45047955770.5016174019
R6(s6)0.420.49484257350.46244669930.49073505450.4050295490.4790216778
sensor40.05571310883.1375718323R7(s7)0.380.47440870760.43307079130.4500243490.37577953180.4885653634
6.21943055577.1535188792R8(s8)0.410.49119766520.42877462450.48130601320.42093606510.5155630788
8.08760720278.6705226086R9(s9)0.480.57680177840.50821046630.44048952920.5008026720.5484720528
9.2534380145R10(s10)0.560.57956149070.63657192540.69658456850.49953901850.4279822964
R11(s12)0.000.00184078420.00737738570.00492814410.001605670.0026426834
60.08118064441.8401733618
3.59916607924.7580457674
5.91692545566.7580287563
7.599132057
70.01975175172.3965773711
4.77340299055.6782978337
6.58319267697.3734990086
8.1638053403
8-0.06057833881.7543304219RNG has higher resolved in more laminar parts and lower resolved in turbulent parts (*)
3.56923918274.634400432
5.69956168126.7308582845
7.7621548878
9-0.00835222070.0782546137
0.1648614482.5155053916
4.86614933525.7057215243
6.5452937134
100.00351172920.166443308
0.32937488692.2628032584
4.19623162995.1441612282
6.0920908266
110.10394269340.1031470512
0.10235140910.1381553068
0.17395920461.3041689104
2.4343786162
120.05540852090.0585910896
0.06177365830.060580195
0.05938673170.0780843228
0.0967819138
130.09439498733.4750785776
6.85576216797.7731375926
8.69051301739.1861980907
9.6818831641
14-0.00835222073.6825225985
7.37339741767.6308451308
7.8882928448.4031882704
8.9180836968
16-0.01938184338.4001036244
16.819589092216.4710978207
16.122606549216.5721443766
17.021682204
Avgs
nk: (from 80s and 160s observations)
nk:Average from 40 to 200
nk:Cs = 0.08 coarse
nk:Cs = 0.1 coarse
nk:Cs = 0.12 coarse
nk:Cs = 0.2 coarse
nk:RNG LES
LES
RNG LES
coarse Cs=0.08
coar Cs=0.1
coar Cs=0.12
coar Cs=0.2
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
LES
RNG LES
coarse Cs=0.08
coarse Cs=0.1
coarse Cs=0.12
coarse Cs=0.2
Cexp
Sensors along route
Co
Cexp (80s & 160s meas. only)
Cs=0.08
Cs=0.1
Cs=0.12
Cs=0.2
Sensors along route
Cp/Co
LES
RNG LES
Sensors along route
Cp/Co
LES
LES coarse
- LES close with coarse- In ceiling Cp is higher due to exp asymmetry- In ceiling buoyancy wins turbulence;all models sam- Release: need better turb capture and more diffusion- Cs 0.12>0.1>0.08>0.2Lower t,sgs may result to low turb or high resolv(also depends on the grid)
RMS run12
RMS run17
RMS run15
RMS run11
RMS run14
RMS run16
RMS
VAR run12
VAR run17
VAR run15
VAR run11
VAR run14
VAR run16
VAR run12
VAR run17
VAR run15
VAR run11
VAR run14
VAR run16
Cs=0.08
Cs=0.1
Cs=0.12
Cs=0.2
Cs=0.08
Cs=0.1
Cs=0.12
Cs=0.2
Sensors along route
C Variance
LES
RNG LES
Sensors along route
C Variance
LES
RNG LES
Sensors along route
C Variance
1
20.598165746618.122396515
3.64015407333.1274659507
1.71609990941.9129440633
1.45105459551.3658373347
0.74038311540.7725328448
0.41787618080.4948425735
0.3788818990.4744087076
0.41105921610.4911976652
0.48407150260.5768017784
0.5621493060.5795614907
0.00045511940.0018407842
LES
RNG LES
Sensors along route
C Variance
Figures
Figures
-0.00466229540.0003037510.0000000070
6.64383401980.004308336.606749.16697
7.03839652320.01375714.660444.5586
8.53159114690.02765867.89997.04619
7.62275855420.04547218.038028.26434
8.14017884310.06893118.333027.49647
8.13072824420.1034537.038247.45837
8.11655234590.1655366.684838.61508
8.05827365280.3355469.064397.35073
8.05276080351.706677.191966.96293
8.03622225544.324227.534967.61931
7.9629801144.720778.095046.14662
7.96061746435.077238.156676.56811
7.91572711965.3771310.6477.43875
7.88973797275.619545.03017.4556
7.87083677495.818046.844826.77188
7.82122113085.981046.519297.97622
7.77948098576.115156.802465.31982
7.76451753756.226147.592116.09277
7.72435249226.317616.496327.54801
7.69600069566.394145.723536.447
7.66528624926.462628.349427.26725
7.65819836.523348.673687.74591
7.63220915316.575610.22915.39309
7.62512120396.62038.326066.95747
7.59204410786.658637.762395.86832
7.57314291016.69166.257926.3666
7.55424171236.720016.715838.34297
7.5227397166.7446510.3727.20274
7.50856381776.765657.825367.01096
7.47863692126.783084.863466.30052
7.46209837326.797258.582687.69187
7.43610922626.808268.411647.29306
7.43138392686.816345.343237.50309
7.42193332796.821299.536656.7168
7.38413093246.823158.154997.48963
7.36995503416.821687.242396.67807
7.34869118666.816357.54346.93077
7.3368779386.80637.499355.9205
7.30852614136.790247.20249.10242
7.2943502436.76478.554529.30929
7.28253699446.727938.738917.07901
7.24552214876.681878.127745.98722
7.21165750276.635487.140937.27928
7.19039365526.605377.59679.07625
7.1667671586.556289.335567.20041
7.16912980786.471278.171487.26849
7.12187681336.387610.56617.09994
7.11478886426.360516.209487.18826
7.08643706756.409067.698616.68405
7.05572262116.534619.859295.62602
7.0486346726.688777.558528.59603
7.03209612396.823098.188239.42649
7.00846962676.92178.964627.40409
6.97539253066.993417.888226.81183
6.92577688657.052118.578599.10493
6.91396363797.102036.528317.94507
6.91238853817.141468.958978.13204
6.87616124237.168879.089287.87559
6.90293793927.183387.646327.13424
6.82182029887.183398.594046.59605
6.81473234967.167768.762038.12097
6.76511670547.147949.454886.79414
6.75094080717.126469.446856.34953
6.73676490887.104799.691817.38256
6.69896251337.086348.699248.69341
6.65800991817.073819.5337.58375
6.6162697737.064969.096646.95651
6.5997312257.063378.68947.20168
6.59264327587.065828.770677.35168
6.52412643397.079368.249119.93087
6.50758788587.106427.70588.18628
6.48632403847.1404311.1938.61391
6.46506019097.1781510.309810.0105
6.45088429257.217199.329228.01104
6.40126864847.254576.33939.43026
6.39024294977.289656.7208310.1286
6.36740400247.320769.900439.711
6.32566385737.343188.959738.90095
6.3114879597.353229.238877.62462
6.27604821327.347797.805977.14953
6.25005906627.328699.398349.62252
6.22170726967.305318.797096.12515
6.18863017357.284268.96168.15265
6.17681692497.265177.582316.36831
6.15555307747.248877.543957.87994
6.16264102667.234988.595588.28972
7.22527.394346.85035
7.221345.426286.74119
7.225649.834246.37733
7.237337.939357.87174
7.255726.676698.13277
7.279227.83927.34691
7.303857.489115.72148
7.323927.318446.86804
7.336147.100356.56998
7.343777.585798.67247
7.351577.631558.41918
7.362237.656297.07263
7.375286.823657.39981
7.3895310.33879.57703
7.405287.145488.06078
7.4229511.69089.65769
7.442037.323619.77843
7.460867.919519.19443
7.476758.722547.1736
7.488069.034227.94534
7.4941311.34546.37477
7.497049.257157.89228
7.500058.899539.86825
7.506358.500577.79453
7.518357.311257.90401
7.53838.291138.85347
7.567427.236287.27816
7.602148.864377.77962
7.6389711.020910.1351
7.672599.253748.53786
7.697418.822816.87092
7.711268.256118.55921
7.7093910.02817.66037
7.695579.46367.25015
7.680249.100168.85505
7.669079.270039.33791
7.665268.786767.31018
7.669849.580228.58146
7.681498.293058.70742
7.698259.707887.99985
7.717347.876247.00083
7.738199.969928.25778
7.758539.274828.80333
7.776189.365417.2186
7.7896810.07576.83642
7.79917.430638.21291
7.805868.178098.98309
7.813699.261049.04892
7.8260910.05138.99109
7.844698.18797.51582
7.868678.1314711.424
7.896889.603047.83363
7.926287.42528.27675
7.953018.427899.89678
7.974219.620298.3759
7.98869.122968.051
7.995679.619889.3305
7.9964410.878911.4334
7.9943911.36518.92958
7.993689.851359.538
7.996948.704048.62734
8.005188.335489.39296
8.018538.8590110.9888
8.0370410.2257.97948
8.060659.379539.9435
8.088479.038.13059
8.118638.098138.34616
8.149067.821118.15619
8.177427.631038.10754
8.201438.023148.14462
8.219568.319137.36338
8.231727.693899.94628
8.239238.190468.91742
8.245099.186377.47442
8.251579.827210.2872
8.259529.492828.75463
8.2693210.67889.56625
8.2810310.1218.40407
8.2950210.55769.34639
8.3120411.50910.5923
8.332658.960029.55117
8.35648.994968.43499
8.381699.033699.79585
8.406269.2382412.8301
8.4283910.80548.94546
8.446869.970518.67122
8.460888.295898.34694
8.4707310.183210.3083
8.477258.7237210.2096
8.481878.580469.21366
8.48649.2948810.125
8.492018.178489.37312
8.499911.80798.13595
8.5109210.81658.40633
8.5251610.07459.39105
8.541378.638419.35173
8.558588.767969.01221
8.576319.3518710.2413
8.594998.4907110.052
8.613969.6548610.0349
8.6338710.03899.86052
8.654739.89664
8.676929.22631
8.699729.45872
8.7212310.7844
8.739759.0462
8.753739.03454
8.762199.53451
8.7662710.7113
8.767789.97886
8.770139.92053
8.776098.47213
8.7880210.5347
8.806779.11346
8.8315711.5166
8.8603510.9936
8.89039.72788
8.9186811.7696
8.94310.7128
8.9617610.7856
8.97499.99608
8.9833910.396
8.9891710.83
8.9950910.2743
9.002411.0201
9.012648.9081
9.026768.98888
9.045059.77418
9.066819.42412
9.0909211.0969
9.1157410.0391
9.1395110.2846
9.161112.0354
9.18019.9282
9.1968711.9973
9.21211.0024
9.226339.29302
9.2405511.5675
9.2555110.0516
9.271749.78436
9.288839.45721
9.3060510.3615
9.3224710.8732
9.3378210.9313
9.3527211.0345
9.3683510.6834
9.3859611.0223
9.4071210.8651
9.4315511.5775
9.4223712.0279
8.009559.9179
5.9917310.0477
4.8205210.2059
4.703519.81359
5.024628.0522
5.732867.4048
6.265647.00035
6.587886.64284
6.773016.61428
6.877476.61127
6.938236.63714
6.980826.73078
7.012436.72213
7.036956.73907
7.056946.73588
7.072836.79174
7.086686.81548
7.099416.84162
7.111566.84572
7.122856.83537
7.132516.84141
7.140376.84881
7.147926.85702
7.155966.86371
7.164296.87837
7.173746.878
7.184616.88468
7.196126.9024
7.206756.92501
7.215776.91158
7.224036.93461
7.232996.93913
7.243836.95473
7.257146.9554
7.272996.95978
7.290746.96051
7.308536.9563
7.323746.9502
7.334486.95029
7.340726.95229
7.343866.95913
7.345596.9764
7.347076.9881
7.348836.98574
7.351036.983
7.353596.99174
7.35627.00689
7.358547.00726
7.360317.005
7.361177.00204
7.360846.9993
7.359066.99638
7.355666.9943
7.350516.99187
7.343656.9906
7.335186.98563
7.325686.98417
7.316276.98427
7.30836.98193
7.302746.98029
7.300146.98063
7.300426.98393
7.302966.98591
7.306576.98166
7.309856.97462
7.311546.97653
7.310986.98171
7.308626.97717
7.304876.96915
7.3016.96728
7.298016.96778
7.29566.96966
7.293456.97143
7.290636.97347
7.286556.97532
7.281496.97625
7.276056.97719
7.270846.97828
7.266066.97831
7.26186.97794
7.257936.97763
7.254556.97751
7.251476.97738
7.248666.97697
7.246116.97647
7.243756.97629
7.241596.97645
7.239616.97941
7.237856.98185
7.236326.98311
7.234996.98427
7.233846.98411
7.232786.97988
7.231756.97634
7.23076.97407
7.229616.97191
7.228446.96982
7.227186.96858
7.225816.96911
7.224336.97094
7.222766.97289
7.221156.97404
7.219556.97449
7.217976.97468
7.216446.97488
7.214986.9751
7.21366.97497
7.21236.97449
7.211116.97457
7.210096.97789
7.209296.98237
7.208596.98374
7.207936.9829
7.207246.98085
7.20656.97882
7.205686.97764
7.204786.97776
7.203836.97743
7.202886.9759
7.201976.97423
7.201116.97291
7.200276.97193
7.199496.97127
7.198786.97081
7.198166.97047
7.197636.97021
7.19726.97
7.196876.96977
7.196626.96942
7.196446.969
7.196316.96858
7.196216.96819
7.196146.96791
7.196076.96771
7.1966.9675
7.195936.96706
7.195846.96595
7.195756.96446
7.195686.96275
7.195646.96098
7.19576.95928
7.195836.95748
7.196136.95565
7.196596.95385
7.197156.9522
7.197776.95068
7.198366.9493
7.198876.94818
7.199236.94723
7.199426.94652
7.199486.94607
7.199446.9458
7.199366.94565
7.19936.94554
7.199276.94548
7.199296.94545
7.199336.94545
7.199396.94546
7.199426.94547
7.199416.94547
7.199336.94544
7.199176.94536
7.198926.94528
7.198616.94521
7.198266.94516
7.197876.94519
7.197486.94529
7.197096.94545
7.196716.94561
7.196356.9456
7.1966.94525
7.195676.94456
7.195346.94362
7.195016.94255
7.194686.94153
7.194356.94067
7.193996.94009
7.193616.93976
7.19326.9395
7.192756.9393
7.192276.93917
7.191766.93911
7.191226.9391
7.190696.93911
7.190196.93909
7.189746.93904
7.189336.93895
7.188966.93881
7.18866.93861
7.188246.93835
7.187866.93803
7.187476.93766
7.187076.93726
7.186696.9368
7.186376.93632
7.186126.93583
7.185956.93539
7.185846.935
7.185796.93467
7.18586.93442
7.185846.93425
7.185896.93414
7.185916.93409
7.185876.93407
7.185766.93405
7.185586.93399
7.185326.93384
7.185016.93357
7.184656.93319
7.184246.93269
7.183746.93212
7.183166.93139
7.182526.9306
7.181816.92975
7.181056.92892
7.180246.92817
7.179416.92749
7.178576.9269
7.177756.92643
7.176976.92608
7.176266.92582
7.175626.92561
7.175036.92542
7.174496.92521
7.173976.92498
7.173456.92473
7.172926.92444
7.172376.92412
7.17186.92376
7.17126.92338
7.170586.92298
7.169956.92256
7.169326.92214
7.16876.92173
7.168096.92133
7.16756.92098
7.166936.92067
7.166396.92037
7.165886.92009
7.16546.91982
7.164966.91955
7.164556.91931
7.164186.91914
7.163856.91903
7.163546.91899
7.163256.91898
7.162986.91896
7.162746.91891
7.16256.9188
7.162276.91864
7.162056.91845
7.161826.91826
7.161586.91809
7.161346.91795
7.161086.91782
7.16086.91768
7.16049
7.16013
7.1597
7.15918
7.15857
7.15787
7.15711
7.15635
7.15565
7.15506
7.15457
7.15429
7.1542
7.15424
7.15432
7.15439
7.15441
7.15439
7.15429
7.15412
7.15388
7.15357
7.15321
7.1528
7.15234
7.15183
7.1513
7.15071
7.15009
7.14944
7.14876
7.14809
7.14742
7.14677
7.14615
7.14557
7.14502
7.1445
7.14401
7.14355
7.14311
7.14269
7.14229
7.14191
7.14155
7.14121
7.14088
7.14058
7.14029
7.14
7.13973
7.13946
7.13919
7.13894
7.13869
7.13847
7.13826
7.13806
7.13786
7.13767
7.13748
7.1373
7.13711
7.13691
7.13671
7.13649
7.13627
7.13602
7.13577
7.1355
7.13523
7.13494
7.13465
7.13436
7.13406
7.13377
7.13348
7.13319
7.13291
7.13262
7.13231
7.132
7.13167
7.13132
7.13097
7.13061
7.13024
7.12986
7.12946
7.12906
7.12866
7.12824
7.12783
7.12742
7.12701
7.12661
7.12622
7.12585
7.12549
7.12515
7.12483
7.12453
7.12424
7.12397
7.12372
7.12348
7.12324
7.123
7.12277
7.12253
7.12228
7.12202
7.12175
7.12147
7.12118
7.12088
7.12057
7.12025
7.11992
7.11959
7.11926
7.11893
7.11861
7.11829
7.11798
7.11768
7.11737
7.11706
7.11673
7.11639
7.11605
7.11571
7.11536
7.11502
7.11467
7.11432
7.11398
7.11363
7.11329
7.11295
7.11261
7.11228
7.11196
7.11165
7.11135
7.11107
7.11078
7.11048
7.11018
7.10989
7.10959
7.1093
7.10901
7.10871
7.10841
7.10811
7.10781
7.1075
7.10718
7.10686
7.10654
7.10621
7.10587
7.10554
7.1052
7.10487
7.10454
7.10422
7.10391
7.10361
7.10331
7.10303
7.10275
7.10248
7.10221
7.10195
7.10168
7.10142
7.10116
7.10089
7.10061
7.10032
7.10002
7.09972
7.0994
7.09909
7.09878
7.09846
7.09814
7.09782
7.09748
7.09715
7.09681
7.09647
7.09612
7.09578
7.09544
7.0951
7.09476
7.09442
7.09409
7.09376
7.09343
7.09311
7.09278
7.09246
7.09215
7.09183
7.09151
7.09118
7.09085
7.09051
7.09017
7.0898
7.08941
7.089
7.08856
7.0881
7.08762
7.08714
7.08666
7.08618
7.08571
7.08527
7.08484
7.08444
7.08405
7.08368
7.08333
7.08298
7.08265
7.08232
7.08198
7.08166
7.08133
7.081
7.08067
7.08033
7.08001
7.07968
7.07935
7.07902
7.07869
7.07837
7.07804
7.07771
7.07738
7.07705
7.07671
7.07638
7.07605
7.07572
7.07539
7.07506
7.07474
7.07441
7.07408
7.07376
7.07343
7.07311
7.07279
7.07247
7.07215
7.07184
7.07154
7.07123
7.07092
7.07061
7.0703
7.06998
7.06965
7.06931
7.06894
7.06856
7.06816
7.06774
7.06732
7.06688
7.06644
7.06599
7.06555
7.06511
7.06468
7.06427
7.06387
7.06349
7.06313
7.06278
7.06246
7.06216
7.06187
7.06158
7.06128
7.06098
7.06068
7.06037
7.06007
7.05976
7.05945
7.05915
7.05885
7.05855
7.05826
7.05798
7.0577
7.05742
7.05715
7.05688
7.05661
7.05634
7.05606
7.05579
7.0555
7.05521
7.05492
7.05462
7.05433
7.05403
7.05374
7.05344
7.05316
7.05288
7.0526
7.05233
7.05206
7.0518
7.05153
7.05127
7.05101
7.05074
7.05046
7.05019
7.0499
7.04961
7.04932
7.04903
7.04872
7.04838
7.04803
7.04765
7.04725
7.04684
7.04641
7.04597
7.04552
7.04506
7.04459
7.04411
7.04363
7.04315
7.04268
7.04221
7.04175
7.04131
7.04089
7.04049
7.04012
7.03976
7.03942
7.03907
7.03874
7.03841
7.03808
7.03776
7.03745
7.03713
7.03682
7.03651
7.0362
7.03589
7.03558
7.03528
7.03498
7.03468
7.03438
7.03407
7.03377
7.03346
7.03314
7.03282
7.0325
7.03218
7.03186
7.03154
7.03122
7.0309
7.03059
7.03028
7.02997
7.02966
7.02935
7.02904
7.02873
7.02843
7.02812
7.02782
7.02752
7.02722
7.02692
7.02662
7.02631
7.02601
7.0257
7.02538
7.02506
7.02473
7.0244
7.02407
7.02371
7.02334
7.02295
7.02256
7.02216
7.02175
7.02135
7.02095
7.02057
7.0202
7.01984
7.01952
7.01919
7.01885
7.01852
7.01818
7.01783
7.01748
7.01713
7.01676
7.01639
7.01601
7.01563
7.01525
7.01486
7.01448
7.0141
7.01372
7.01336
7.01301
7.01266
7.01231
7.01198
7.01165
7.01132
7.01101
7.01069
7.01038
7.01007
7.00975
7.00943
7.00911
7.00879
7.00845
7.00812
7.00777
7.00742
7.00706
7.00669
7.00632
7.00594
7.00556
7.00516
7.00476
7.00436
7.00394
7.00352
7.00309
7.00265
7.00222
7.00178
7.00135
7.00093
7.00051
7.00009
6.99967
6.99926
6.99885
6.99845
6.99806
6.99767
6.9973
6.99692
6.99656
6.9962
6.99585
6.9955
6.99516
6.99482
6.99448
6.99414
6.99381
6.99348
6.99315
6.99282
6.99249
6.99216
6.99182
6.99147
6.99112
6.99077
6.99041
6.99005
6.98968
6.9893
6.98893
6.98855
6.98817
6.9878
6.98744
6.98709
6.98674
6.9864
6.98605
6.9857
6.98535
6.985
6.98465
6.9843
6.98393
6.98355
6.98316
6.98276
6.98234
6.98192
6.9815
6.98106
6.98062
6.98018
6.97973
6.97928
6.97883
6.97837
6.97792
6.97746
6.977
6.97655
6.97609
6.97564
6.9752
6.97477
6.97434
6.97393
6.97352
6.97313
6.97275
6.97237
6.97201
6.97165
6.97129
6.97094
6.97059
6.97024
6.9699
6.96957
6.96924
6.96891
6.96857
6.96822
6.96787
6.96753
6.96718
6.96684
6.9665
6.96616
6.96583
6.96548
6.96513
6.96477
6.96439
6.96401
6.96361
6.96322
6.96282
6.96241
6.962
6.96159
6.96118
6.96078
6.96037
6.95997
6.95957
6.95917
6.95878
6.95839
6.958
6.95761
6.95722
6.95683
6.95643
6.95602
6.9556
6.95517
6.95474
6.95429
6.95385
6.9534
6.95295
6.9525
6.95206
6.95162
6.95117
6.95073
6.9503
6.94987
6.94945
6.94904
6.94863
6.94823
6.94784
6.94745
6.94707
6.9467
6.94634
6.94598
6.94562
6.94527
6.94492
6.94456
6.9442
6.94384
6.94348
6.94311
6.94274
6.94237
6.94199
6.9416
6.94122
6.94083
6.94043
6.94003
6.93963
6.93922
6.93882
6.9384
6.93799
6.93758
6.93716
6.93675
6.93633
6.93592
6.93551
6.93511
6.9347
6.9343
6.93391
6.93352
6.93314
6.93275
6.93237
6.932
6.93162
6.93125
6.93088
6.93051
6.93014
6.92976
6.92939
6.92902
6.92865
6.92828
6.9279
6.92753
6.92715
6.92676
6.92638
6.92599
6.92559
6.92519
6.92479
6.92439
6.92399
6.92358
6.92318
6.92277
6.92237
6.92197
6.92157
6.92117
6.92077
6.92037
6.91998
6.91958
6.91918
6.91878
6.91838
6.91796
6.91755
6.91713
6.9167
6.91628
6.91584
6.91541
6.91498
6.91454
6.91411
6.91367
6.91324
6.91281
6.91239
6.91197
6.91154
6.91113
6.91071
6.9103
6.9099
6.9095
6.90911
6.90872
6.90834
6.90796
6.90759
6.90721
6.90685
6.90648
6.90612
6.90577
6.90541
6.90504
6.90467
6.9043
6.90392
6.90354
6.90317
6.90279
6.90242
6.90205
6.90169
6.90133
6.90095
6.90056
6.90016
6.89975
6.89933
6.89892
6.8985
6.89808
6.89766
6.89724
6.89682
6.8964
6.89598
6.89555
6.89513
6.8947
6.89427
6.89384
6.89341
6.89298
6.89255
6.89213
6.89172
6.8913
6.89089
6.89048
6.89008
6.88968
6.88928
6.88889
6.8885
6.88811
6.88773
6.88735
6.88697
6.88658
6.88618
6.88579
6.88538
6.88497
6.88456
6.88415
6.88374
6.88333
6.88291
6.8825
6.88209
6.88168
6.88127
6.88086
6.88045
6.88003
6.87962
6.8792
6.87879
6.87838
6.87797
6.87757
6.87718
6.87679
6.87641
6.87603
6.87565
6.87526
6.87487
6.87448
6.87408
6.87369
6.87329
6.87289
6.87249
6.87209
6.87169
6.87128
6.87087
6.87044
6.87001
6.86957
6.86913
6.86868
6.86824
6.8678
6.86737
6.86694
6.86652
6.86611
6.86571
6.8653
6.86491
6.86452
6.86414
6.86376
6.86338
6.86301
6.86264
6.86227
6.8619
6.86152
6.86114
6.86075
6.86035
6.85995
6.85955
6.85913
6.85872
6.85829
6.85787
6.85744
6.857
6.85657
6.85613
6.8557
6.85527
6.85483
6.85441
6.85398
6.85356
6.85314
6.85272
6.85231
6.85189
6.85148
6.85107
6.85065
6.85024
6.84984
6.84943
6.84904
6.84864
6.84825
6.84786
6.84748
6.8471
6.84672
6.84635
6.84597
6.84559
6.84521
6.84482
6.84442
6.84402
6.84361
6.84319
6.84277
6.84234
6.84191
6.84147
6.84104
6.8406
6.84017
6.83975
6.83933
6.83892
6.83851
6.8381
6.8377
6.83729
6.83689
6.8365
6.8361
6.83571
6.83531
6.83492
6.83453
6.83413
6.83372
6.83331
6.83289
6.83247
6.83205
6.83162
6.83119
6.83076
6.83033
6.82991
6.82948
6.82906
6.82863
6.82821
6.82778
6.82736
6.82694
6.82652
6.8261
6.82568
6.82526
6.82483
6.82441
6.82399
6.82357
6.82315
6.82273
6.82231
6.8219
6.8215
6.8211
6.8207
6.82029
6.81988
6.81947
6.81907
6.81866
6.81825
6.81784
6.81743
6.81702
6.8166
6.81617
6.81575
6.81532
6.8149
6.81447
6.81403
6.8136
6.81316
6.81273
6.81231
6.81189
6.81147
6.81105
6.81063
6.81021
6.8098
6.80939
6.80898
6.80858
6.80817
6.80776
6.80734
6.80692
6.80649
6.80606
6.80562
6.80518
6.80474
6.8043
6.80386
6.80341
6.80297
6.80254
6.8021
6.80167
6.80123
6.8008
6.80037
6.79994
6.79951
6.79907
6.79864
6.79821
6.79778
6.79735
6.79692
6.7965
6.79607
6.79565
6.79523
6.79481
6.79441
6.79401
6.7936
6.79319
6.79276
6.79233
6.7919
6.79147
6.79104
6.79061
6.79019
6.78977
6.78936
6.78895
6.78854
6.78814
6.78775
6.78734
6.78693
6.78652
6.7861
6.78568
6.78526
6.78484
6.78441
6.78399
6.78356
6.78313
6.7827
6.78227
6.78184
6.78141
6.78099
6.78058
6.78016
6.77975
6.77935
6.77894
6.77854
6.77814
6.77774
6.77735
6.77695
6.77656
6.77616
6.77577
6.77537
6.77497
6.77456
6.77415
6.77372
6.77329
6.77285
6.77241
6.77196
6.77151
6.77106
6.77061
6.77017
6.76972
6.76928
6.76885
6.76842
6.76799
6.76756
6.76714
6.76671
6.76628
6.76585
6.76542
6.76498
6.76455
6.76411
6.76367
6.76324
6.7628
6.76238
6.76195
6.76154
6.76114
6.76074
6.76034
6.75994
6.75955
6.75915
6.75874
6.75833
6.7579
6.75748
6.75704
6.75661
6.75617
6.75573
6.7553
6.75486
6.75443
6.754
6.75357
6.75315
6.75274
6.75233
6.75193
6.75154
6.75114
6.75074
6.75034
6.74993
6.74952
6.7491
6.74869
6.74828
6.74787
6.74745
6.74704
6.74663
6.74621
6.7458
6.74539
6.74497
6.74454
6.74411
6.74367
6.74323
6.7428
6.74236
6.74193
6.74149
6.74106
6.74062
6.74017
6.73973
6.73927
6.73881
6.73835
6.73788
6.73741
6.73694
6.73648
6.73602
6.73557
6.73512
6.73469
6.73426
6.73385
6.73344
6.73304
6.73265
6.73227
6.73188
6.73149
6.73109
6.73069
6.73028
6.72986
6.72945
6.72902
6.72859
6.72816
6.72772
6.72728
6.72684
6.7264
6.72595
6.7255
6.72505
6.7246
6.72415
6.72371
6.72328
6.72286
6.72244
6.72202
6.72161
6.7212
6.72081
6.72041
6.72002
6.71964
6.71925
6.71886
6.71847
6.71807
6.71766
6.71725
6.71683
6.7164
6.71597
6.71554
6.7151
6.71466
6.71422
6.71378
6.71333
6.71287
6.71242
6.71195
6.71148
6.71101
6.71054
6.71007
6.70961
6.70915
6.7087
6.70825
6.70782
6.7074
6.70699
6.70658
6.70618
6.70579
6.7054
6.705
6.70459
6.70418
6.70377
6.70335
6.70293
6.7025
6.70207
6.70164
6.70121
6.70077
6.70034
6.6999
6.69947
6.69903
6.6986
6.69816
6.69772
6.69727
6.69682
6.69638
6.69594
6.69551
6.69508
6.69465
6.69422
6.69379
6.69337
6.69295
6.69253
6.69211
6.6917
6.69128
6.69088
6.69047
6.69007
6.68967
6.68928
6.68889
6.68849
6.68809
6.68767
6.68725
6.68682
6.68639
6.68595
6.6855
6.68506
6.68461
6.68415
6.68369
6.68322
6.68276
6.6823
6.68185
6.6814
6.68096
6.68052
6.6801
6.67967
6.67925
6.67883
6.67841
6.678
6.67758
6.67717
6.67676
6.67635
6.67594
6.67552
6.6751
6.67468
6.67426
6.67384
6.67342
6.67299
6.67257
6.67214
6.67171
6.67128
6.67085
6.67041
6.66998
6.66954
6.66911
6.66867
6.66824
6.66781
6.66738
6.66694
6.66651
6.66608
6.66565
6.66522
6.66478
6.66435
6.66392
6.6635
6.66308
6.66266
6.66225
6.66185
6.66144
6.66103
6.66061
6.6602
6.65978
6.65936
6.65893
6.65851
6.65808
6.65765
6.65722
6.65678
6.65633
6.65587
6.6554
6.65494
6.65447
6.65401
6.65355
6.6531
6.65264
6.6522
6.65175
6.65132
6.65089
6.65045
6.65002
6.64959
6.64916
6.64874
6.64831
6.64789
6.64747
6.64704
6.64661
6.64617
6.64572
6.64528
6.64484
6.6444
6.64397
6.64354
6.64311
6.6427
6.64228
6.64187
6.64146
6.64106
6.64065
6.64023
6.63981
6.63939
6.63897
6.63854
6.63811
6.63768
6.63724
6.63681
6.63637
6.63594
6.63551
6.63508
6.63464
6.63422
6.63379
6.63336
6.63294
6.63251
6.63208
6.63165
6.63121
6.63077
6.63033
6.62989
6.62946
6.62902
6.62859
6.62817
6.62775
6.62733
6.62692
6.62651
6.6261
6.62571
6.62531
6.62492
6.62452
6.62411
6.6237
6.62328
6.62285
6.62241
6.62196
6.6215
6.62104
6.62057
6.62009
6.61961
6.61914
6.61866
6.6182
6.61774
6.61729
6.61685
6.61642
6.616
6.61559
6.61519
6.61479
6.61439
6.61399
6.61359
6.61319
6.61278
6.61238
6.61198
6.61158
6.61118
6.61076
6.61034
6.60991
6.60948
6.60904
6.60859
6.60814
6.60769
6.60723
6.60678
6.60633
6.60588
6.60543
6.60499
6.60456
6.60413
6.60371
6.60328
6.60286
6.60244
6.60202
6.6016
6.60118
6.60077
6.60036
6.59996
6.59955
6.59915
6.59875
6.59834
6.59794
6.59754
6.59713
6.59673
6.59632
6.59591
6.5955
6.59508
6.59465
6.59422
6.59377
6.59332
6.59286
6.59239
6.59193
6.59146
6.591
6.59054
6.59008
6.58964
6.5892
6.58877
6.58835
6.58794
6.58753
6.58712
6.58672
6.58631
6.5859
6.5855
6.58509
6.58469
6.58428
6.58388
6.58347
6.58307
6.58266
6.58224
6.58182
6.58141
6.58099
6.58057
6.58014
6.57971
6.57928
6.57884
6.57839
6.57795
6.5775
6.57705
6.5766
6.57615
6.5757
6.57525
6.5748
6.57436
6.57391
6.57347
6.57303
6.57259
6.57215
6.57173
6.57131
6.57089
6.57049
6.57009
6.56969
6.56928
6.56887
6.56846
6.56805
6.56763
6.56721
6.56679
6.56637
6.56593
6.56549
6.56504
6.56459
6.56413
6.56366
6.5632
6.56274
6.56229
6.56184
6.56139
6.56095
6.56052
6.5601
6.55968
6.55926
6.55884
6.55842
6.55801
6.5576
6.55719
6.55678
6.55638
6.55597
6.55557
6.55515
6.55474
6.55432
6.5539
6.55348
6.55305
6.55262
6.5522
6.55177
6.55134
6.55091
6.55048
6.55005
6.54962
6.5492
6.54877
6.54835
6.54792
6.5475
6.54707
6.54664
6.54621
6.54578
6.54534
6.54491
6.54448
6.54406
6.54363
6.54322
6.5428
6.5424
6.54199
6.54159
6.54118
6.54076
6.54034
6.53991
6.53948
6.53905
6.53861
6.53817
6.53772
6.53728
6.53683
6.53639
6.53595
6.53551
6.53507
6.53464
6.53421
6.53379
6.53337
6.53296
6.53255
6.53214
6.53172
6.53131
6.53089
6.53047
6.53005
6.52962
6.52919
6.52876
6.52833
6.52789
6.52746
6.52702
6.52659
6.52616
6.52573
6.52531
6.52489
6.52448
6.52407
6.52365
6.52324
6.52283
6.52241
6.522
6.52158
6.52116
6.52075
6.52032
6.5199
6.51947
6.51904
6.51861
6.51818
6.51774
6.51731
6.51687
6.51644
6.51601
6.51558
6.51515
6.51472
6.5143
6.51388
6.51346
6.51304
6.51263
6.51222
6.5118
6.51139
6.51098
6.51057
6.51016
6.50974
6.50933
6.5089
6.50848
6.50805
6.50762
6.5072
6.50677
6.50635
6.50593
6.50551
6.5051
6.50469
6.50427
6.50385
6.50342
6.503
6.50257