Welcome to
RISE WEEK 2012
How to Create Products That Don’t Suck A Discovery Process for Creating Breakthrough Products
(For Start-ups through Big Enterprises)
Hosted by Tom Evans
Principal, Lûcrum Marketing @compellingmktr
High New Product Failure Rate
• Only one product concept out of seven becomes a new
product winner; and 44% of businesses’ product
development projects fail to achieve their profit targets.
• One out of four development projects succeeds
commercially. (75% failure rate)
Robert G Cooper
Copyright 2012 - LÛCRUM MARKETING
High New Product Failure Rate
• Only one product concept out of seven becomes a new
product winner; and 44% of businesses’ product
development projects fail to achieve their profit targets.
• One out of four development projects succeeds
commercially. (75% failure rate)
Robert G Cooper
Copyright 2012 - LÛCRUM MARKETING
Why Do So Many Products Suck?
1. Idea to Product
Why Do So Many Products Suck?
1. Idea to Product
2. One point of market evidence to idea to product
Why Do So Many Products Suck?
1. Idea to Product
2. One point of market evidence to idea to product
3. Market evidence & validation to product
Why Do So Many Products Suck?
1. Idea to Product
2. One point of market evidence to idea to product
3. Market evidence & validation to product
4. Market evidence & validation, product validation, no
clear market strategy
Why Do So Many Products Suck?
1. Idea to Product
2. One point of market evidence to idea to product
3. Market evidence & validation to product
4. Market evidence & validation, product validation, no clear market
strategy
5. Market evidence & validation, product validation, no
profitable business model
Keys to Products That Don’t Suck
• Compelling Market Opportunity
– Big painful issues
– That many in your target market
– Are willing to pay to solve
• Compelling Solution
– Differentiated Value Proposition
– Profitable business model
– Time to market
• Compelling Market Strategy
– Motivates target market
– To solve problem with your solution
Discovery
+
Validation
Model for Discovery
Four Key Steps
Validate
Hypothesis Plan Strategy Build Solution To Market
Fo
ur
Ke
y P
illa
rs
Market Problem
Product
Business
Model
Market Strategy
Validation
Valid Hypothesis Valid Market
Opportunity
Ready to
Launch Market Growth
Product-to-Market™ Model
Product-to-Market is a trademark of Lûcrum Marketing
Four Key Pillars
• Market Problem – if you’re not solving a problem, there is
no need for a product!
• Product – How do you solve the market problem in a
valuable and differentiated manner?
• Business Model – How do you deliver the product and
profitably capture the value?
• Market Strategy – Who is going to buy it and why?
Example
Model for Discovery
Four Key Steps
Validate
Hypothesis Plan Strategy Build Solution To Market
Fo
ur
Ke
y P
illa
rs
Market Problem
Product
Business
Model
Market Strategy
Validation
Valid Hypothesis Valid Market
Opportunity
Ready to
Launch Market Growth
Product-to-Market™ Model
Product-to-Market is a trademark of Lûcrum Marketing
Market Evidence (of Market Problem)
• Sources of Market Evidence
– Customers
– Non-customers
– Market trends/shifts
– Unexpected occurrences
– New technologies
– Competitors
– Personal experience
– Etc.
Market Evidence (of Market Problem)
• Sources of Market Evidence
– Customers
– Non-customers
– Market trends/shifts
– Unexpected occurrences
– New technologies
– Competitors
– Personal experience
– Etc.
Start With Hypothesis
– Buyer/User ‘W’
– In Market Segment “X”
– Has problem “Y”
– That happens when “Z” occurs
– We can solve it by creating/delivering solution “A”
E.g.: Owners of small manufacturing operations that
use hot water & steam are unable to manage
manufacturing costs due to the volatility of fuel prices.
We can solve this by providing a high temperature
solar heating system under a lease agreement.
Exercise 1
• Create a Hypothesis for a New Opportunity
– Buyer/User
– Market Segment
– Market Problem
– When it happens
Screening
• Alignment with company
– Strategy
– Target markets
– Core competencies
• Potential Competition
– Does someone already do this?
– Are there other ways to address this problem?
Validate the Hypothesis (1)
• Market problem and market segment(s)
• Speaking to potential customers (buyers & users)
– Most companies don’t and won’t do this
• Significant time investment
– Requires many conversations (cold calling)
• Minimum: 20 conversations
• May take over 100 conversations
• Iterate until validated or rejected
Copyright 2012 - LÛCRUM MARKETING
Exercise 2
• How are we going to get someone to talk to us?
Henry Ford’s Quote
“If I had asked people what they wanted,
they would have said faster horses.”
Copyright 2011 - LÛCRUM MARKETING
What Do They Need (To Do)?
“People don't want to buy a
quarter-inch drill. They
want a quarter-inch hole!”
–Theodore Levitt
Copyright 2011 - LÛCRUM MARKETING
What We Want to Identify
• Problems, Goals, Needs
– What do they want to do that they can’t do?
– What do they want to improve (decrease/increase)?
• Why is this P/G/N important?
• When does this happen (usage scenarios)
• How do you currently do this?
• What is your current satisfaction?
• What is the impact?
• Who are they (Personas)?
Copyright 2011 - LÛCRUM MARKETING
Whom to Ask?
• Strategic/Financial (Executives)
• Operational (Managers)
• Task Performers (Front-line)
Copyright 2011 - LÛCRUM MARKETING
Discover Personal Needs
Copyright 2011 - LÛCRUM MARKETING
Source: http://www.teach-nology.com/tutorials/teaching/whatareneeds.html
Exercise 3
• Conduct a short interview to validate hypothesis
– Groups of 3 (potential customer, interviewer, observer)
Validate Hypothesis (2)
• Create product & business model concept
– Low cost way of presenting product concept
– Mockup, prototype, wire frame, story board,
presentation, product description
• Validate product & business model concept
– Present concept and receive feedback
• Does the problem still resonate?
• Does the approach solve the problem?
• What is the Minimum Viable Product (MVP)
• Iterate until validated or rejected
Plan Strategy
• Define & discover at greater depth
• Competitive research (strategy, position, strength)
• Validate the market opportunity
– Business Case - Can it be profitable?
• Detailed design of product & business model
– Market requirements, product requirements, user
stories, etc.
– Pricing model, delivery mechanism, costs to deliver,
etc.
• Iterate until validated or rejected
Build Solution
• Define Minimum Viable Product (MVP)
– Just enough functionality to solve the most important
market problems
– For small segment of market (early adopters, etc.)
– Willing to pay for this functionality
– Fast to market
– Learning
• Continue to discover, validate, refine!
To Market
• Sell your first customers
• Based upon market validation work
• Targeted Market Development Plan
– Well defined target market
– Clear understanding of buyer roles and their
challenges/goals/needs
– Compelling reason to buy from you
• Value Proposition – what we do for you
• Positioning & Differentiation – why buy our solution
• Continue to discover, validate, refine!
Positioning Statement
• For (target customer)
• Who (statement of need or opportunity)
• The (product name) is a (product category)
• That (statement of key benefit – that is compelling reason
to buy)
• Unlike (primary competitive alternative)
• Our product (statement of primary differentiation)
Geoffrey Moore: “Crossing the Chasm”
Exercise 4
• Write a positioning statement
Model for Discovery
Four Key Steps
Validate
Hypothesis Plan Strategy Build Solution To Market
Fo
ur
Ke
y P
illa
rs
Market Problem
Product
Business
Model
Market Strategy
Validation
Valid Hypothesis Valid Market
Opportunity
Ready to
Launch Market Growth
Product-to-Market™ Model
Product-to-Market is a trademark of Lûcrum Marketing
Key Principles
• Hypothesis – Discovery – Validate
• Continuous engagement with target market
– Validate important decisions
• Planning is good, but learning is better
• Fail fast – discover fast!
Additional References
Copyright 2012 - LÛCRUM MARKETING
Thank You!
Tom Evans
Lûcrum Marketing
+1.512.961.5267
@compellingmktr
COMMUNITY SUPPORT
Did you enjoy this session?
Please support your local entrepreneurs and help us to keep this conference free.
RISE Global is a non-profit organization, and your contributions help us continue delivering the value of a high-dollar conference with an unbeatable price tag.
Please donate at www.riseglobal.org/donate
Be sure to check out our other sessions and special events
during RISE Week 2012 at www.riseglobal.org/austin!
The mission of RISE is to inspire and empower entrepreneurs at all stages.