![Page 1: Groundfish ABC’s FY 2013 2015archive.nefmc.org/tech/council_mtg_docs/Sept 2012/5_Presentation... · • Mohn’s rho values: SSB 0.68, F ‐0.19, R 0.34 • Retro adjusted (not](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051910/5fff173ca94c7c401f454243/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Groundfish ABC’sFY 2013 ‐ 2015
New England Fishery Management Council
Science and Statistical CommitteeSeptember 13, 2012
![Page 2: Groundfish ABC’s FY 2013 2015archive.nefmc.org/tech/council_mtg_docs/Sept 2012/5_Presentation... · • Mohn’s rho values: SSB 0.68, F ‐0.19, R 0.34 • Retro adjusted (not](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051910/5fff173ca94c7c401f454243/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
GB Yellowtail Flounder
• Retrospective pattern increasing• Have not achieved Fref/FMSY with catches below projection output
• Recruitment assumption may be optimistic• Range of 200‐500 mt seems necessary• Higher end of range less likely to end overfishing
![Page 3: Groundfish ABC’s FY 2013 2015archive.nefmc.org/tech/council_mtg_docs/Sept 2012/5_Presentation... · • Mohn’s rho values: SSB 0.68, F ‐0.19, R 0.34 • Retro adjusted (not](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051910/5fff173ca94c7c401f454243/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
SNEMA YTF Catches
![Page 4: Groundfish ABC’s FY 2013 2015archive.nefmc.org/tech/council_mtg_docs/Sept 2012/5_Presentation... · • Mohn’s rho values: SSB 0.68, F ‐0.19, R 0.34 • Retro adjusted (not](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051910/5fff173ca94c7c401f454243/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
SNEMA YTF Recommendation
• 700 – 770 mt– Differs from default control rule– Similar to long‐term catch under recent recruitment
– Consistent with MSY if recent recruitment is likely– Should allow stock increases if two‐stanza recruitment is more likely
![Page 5: Groundfish ABC’s FY 2013 2015archive.nefmc.org/tech/council_mtg_docs/Sept 2012/5_Presentation... · • Mohn’s rho values: SSB 0.68, F ‐0.19, R 0.34 • Retro adjusted (not](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051910/5fff173ca94c7c401f454243/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
SNE/MA YTF Projections
• Two possible recruitment scenarios– Recent– Two stanza– Affect catches after 2013
• 75 pct of FMSY
![Page 6: Groundfish ABC’s FY 2013 2015archive.nefmc.org/tech/council_mtg_docs/Sept 2012/5_Presentation... · • Mohn’s rho values: SSB 0.68, F ‐0.19, R 0.34 • Retro adjusted (not](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051910/5fff173ca94c7c401f454243/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Overview
• Short recap of last meeting• OFLs/ABCs for four stocks
– GOM haddock, plaice, witch flounder, white hake
• FY 2013 – FY 2015• ABCs for seven stocks addressed in March; three stocks address in August
• GOM and GB cod, white hake addressed after benchmarks this winter
![Page 7: Groundfish ABC’s FY 2013 2015archive.nefmc.org/tech/council_mtg_docs/Sept 2012/5_Presentation... · • Mohn’s rho values: SSB 0.68, F ‐0.19, R 0.34 • Retro adjusted (not](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051910/5fff173ca94c7c401f454243/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
General Comments
• Past work showed projections unreliable, particularly in out‐years
• Two alternatives considered, but not successful:– Time series– Best stock size/best fishing mortality
• Back to using projections to inform catch advice
![Page 8: Groundfish ABC’s FY 2013 2015archive.nefmc.org/tech/council_mtg_docs/Sept 2012/5_Presentation... · • Mohn’s rho values: SSB 0.68, F ‐0.19, R 0.34 • Retro adjusted (not](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051910/5fff173ca94c7c401f454243/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
How Far Off Were the OFLs/ABCs?
• American Plaice: in 2010, catching 57 percent of the ABC resulted in ~75 pct of FMSY
• PDT examined other stocks in report• OFL/ABC should have been set well below median projection output (exception: redfish)
![Page 9: Groundfish ABC’s FY 2013 2015archive.nefmc.org/tech/council_mtg_docs/Sept 2012/5_Presentation... · • Mohn’s rho values: SSB 0.68, F ‐0.19, R 0.34 • Retro adjusted (not](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051910/5fff173ca94c7c401f454243/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
• Fterm/Freference: how far off the realized F was from the projection input F at the realized catch
• Catch/(Fterm/Freference): approximate what the catch should have been to get the Freference)
• Catch (should have been)/Catch(target): An adjustment to get the right catch
![Page 10: Groundfish ABC’s FY 2013 2015archive.nefmc.org/tech/council_mtg_docs/Sept 2012/5_Presentation... · • Mohn’s rho values: SSB 0.68, F ‐0.19, R 0.34 • Retro adjusted (not](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051910/5fff173ca94c7c401f454243/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
![Page 11: Groundfish ABC’s FY 2013 2015archive.nefmc.org/tech/council_mtg_docs/Sept 2012/5_Presentation... · • Mohn’s rho values: SSB 0.68, F ‐0.19, R 0.34 • Retro adjusted (not](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051910/5fff173ca94c7c401f454243/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Best Stock Size Estimate
• Does not account for expected changes in stock size
![Page 12: Groundfish ABC’s FY 2013 2015archive.nefmc.org/tech/council_mtg_docs/Sept 2012/5_Presentation... · • Mohn’s rho values: SSB 0.68, F ‐0.19, R 0.34 • Retro adjusted (not](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051910/5fff173ca94c7c401f454243/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Data Inputs• 2 years of catch at age • Weight at age data.• Recruitment in year t and t+1.• 2 years of effort data (F as a proxy for effort).
• Approximation of a projection model.• TAC estimate in year T+1 at the status quo F.
Leapfrog TACs (Pope 1983)
![Page 13: Groundfish ABC’s FY 2013 2015archive.nefmc.org/tech/council_mtg_docs/Sept 2012/5_Presentation... · • Mohn’s rho values: SSB 0.68, F ‐0.19, R 0.34 • Retro adjusted (not](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051910/5fff173ca94c7c401f454243/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
![Page 14: Groundfish ABC’s FY 2013 2015archive.nefmc.org/tech/council_mtg_docs/Sept 2012/5_Presentation... · • Mohn’s rho values: SSB 0.68, F ‐0.19, R 0.34 • Retro adjusted (not](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051910/5fff173ca94c7c401f454243/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Summary
• Time series analysis not completed• No recommendation which approach would work best
• In most cases the standard projections have not worked well and the median catch from those projections would not be expected to achieve mortality targets
![Page 15: Groundfish ABC’s FY 2013 2015archive.nefmc.org/tech/council_mtg_docs/Sept 2012/5_Presentation... · • Mohn’s rho values: SSB 0.68, F ‐0.19, R 0.34 • Retro adjusted (not](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051910/5fff173ca94c7c401f454243/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
CC/GOM Yellowtail Flounder
• VPA• Two inshore survey strata dropped• Residuals show patterning with blocks• Mohn’s rho values: SSB 0.68, F ‐0.19, R 0.34• Retro adjusted (not necessary at GARM III)• Updated reference points:
– FMSY proxy: 0.26 (0.239)– SSBMY proxy: 7,080mt (7,790 mt)– MSY : 1,600mt (1,720 mt)
![Page 16: Groundfish ABC’s FY 2013 2015archive.nefmc.org/tech/council_mtg_docs/Sept 2012/5_Presentation... · • Mohn’s rho values: SSB 0.68, F ‐0.19, R 0.34 • Retro adjusted (not](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051910/5fff173ca94c7c401f454243/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
CC/GOM YTF Results
• Overfished, SSB 1,680 mt• Overfishing, F=0.36
![Page 17: Groundfish ABC’s FY 2013 2015archive.nefmc.org/tech/council_mtg_docs/Sept 2012/5_Presentation... · • Mohn’s rho values: SSB 0.68, F ‐0.19, R 0.34 • Retro adjusted (not](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051910/5fff173ca94c7c401f454243/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
CC/GOM YTF Projections
• No unusual conditions/assumptions• NAA rho‐adjusted• Frebuild above F75%; latter used for catch projections
• Decision made to use projected F Y2013 ABC for FY 2013‐2015
• OFL question: update or constant?
![Page 18: Groundfish ABC’s FY 2013 2015archive.nefmc.org/tech/council_mtg_docs/Sept 2012/5_Presentation... · • Mohn’s rho values: SSB 0.68, F ‐0.19, R 0.34 • Retro adjusted (not](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051910/5fff173ca94c7c401f454243/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
CC/GOM YTF Projection Output
OFL Total ABC U.S. ABC TotalCY Catch
2011 2011 1,355 1,041 1,032.8*
2012 2012 1,508 1,1592013 2013 713 5482014 2014 934 7172015 2014 1,153 887
![Page 19: Groundfish ABC’s FY 2013 2015archive.nefmc.org/tech/council_mtg_docs/Sept 2012/5_Presentation... · • Mohn’s rho values: SSB 0.68, F ‐0.19, R 0.34 • Retro adjusted (not](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051910/5fff173ca94c7c401f454243/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
GOM Haddock
• VPA• Minor change to survey +group in VPA• No residual patterning• F based on unweighted average (change)• Mohn’s rho values: SSB ‐0.218, F 0.95, R 4.62• Updated reference points:
– FMSY proxy: 0.46 (0.43)– SSBMY proxy: 4,904 mt (5,900 mt)– MSY : 1,177mt (1,360 mt)
![Page 20: Groundfish ABC’s FY 2013 2015archive.nefmc.org/tech/council_mtg_docs/Sept 2012/5_Presentation... · • Mohn’s rho values: SSB 0.68, F ‐0.19, R 0.34 • Retro adjusted (not](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051910/5fff173ca94c7c401f454243/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
GOM Haddock Results
• Approaching Overfished, SSB 2,868 mt• Overfishing, F=0.82
![Page 21: Groundfish ABC’s FY 2013 2015archive.nefmc.org/tech/council_mtg_docs/Sept 2012/5_Presentation... · • Mohn’s rho values: SSB 0.68, F ‐0.19, R 0.34 • Retro adjusted (not](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051910/5fff173ca94c7c401f454243/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
GOM Haddock Projections
• No unusual conditions/assumptions• F75%
![Page 22: Groundfish ABC’s FY 2013 2015archive.nefmc.org/tech/council_mtg_docs/Sept 2012/5_Presentation... · • Mohn’s rho values: SSB 0.68, F ‐0.19, R 0.34 • Retro adjusted (not](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051910/5fff173ca94c7c401f454243/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
GOM Haddock Projection Output
OFL Total ABC TotalCY Catch
2011 1,536 1,206 695.6
2012 1,296 1,013
2013 371 290
2014 440 341
2015 561 435
![Page 23: Groundfish ABC’s FY 2013 2015archive.nefmc.org/tech/council_mtg_docs/Sept 2012/5_Presentation... · • Mohn’s rho values: SSB 0.68, F ‐0.19, R 0.34 • Retro adjusted (not](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051910/5fff173ca94c7c401f454243/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
American Plaice
• VPA• Residual patterning (‐ early/+ late)• Mohn’s rho values: SSB 0.62, F ‐0.35, R 1.24• Updated reference points:
– FMSY proxy: 0.18 (0.19)– SSBMY proxy: 18,398 mt (22,243 mt)– MSY : 3,385mt (4,059 mt)
![Page 24: Groundfish ABC’s FY 2013 2015archive.nefmc.org/tech/council_mtg_docs/Sept 2012/5_Presentation... · • Mohn’s rho values: SSB 0.68, F ‐0.19, R 0.34 • Retro adjusted (not](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051910/5fff173ca94c7c401f454243/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Plaice Results
• Not Overfished, SSB 10,805 mt (rho adjusted)• No Overfishing, F=0.13 (rho adjusted)
![Page 25: Groundfish ABC’s FY 2013 2015archive.nefmc.org/tech/council_mtg_docs/Sept 2012/5_Presentation... · • Mohn’s rho values: SSB 0.68, F ‐0.19, R 0.34 • Retro adjusted (not](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051910/5fff173ca94c7c401f454243/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Plaice Projections
• No unusual conditions/assumptions• Retro adjusted NAA• F75%
![Page 26: Groundfish ABC’s FY 2013 2015archive.nefmc.org/tech/council_mtg_docs/Sept 2012/5_Presentation... · • Mohn’s rho values: SSB 0.68, F ‐0.19, R 0.34 • Retro adjusted (not](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051910/5fff173ca94c7c401f454243/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Plaice Projection Output
OFL Total ABC TotalCY Catch
2011 4,483 3,444 1,893.1*
2012 4,727 3,444
2013 2,035 1,557
2014 1,981 1,515
2015 2,021 1,544
![Page 27: Groundfish ABC’s FY 2013 2015archive.nefmc.org/tech/council_mtg_docs/Sept 2012/5_Presentation... · • Mohn’s rho values: SSB 0.68, F ‐0.19, R 0.34 • Retro adjusted (not](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051910/5fff173ca94c7c401f454243/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Witch Flounder
• VPA, split survey• Residual blocks for ages 7 and 10• Mohn’s rho values: SSB 0.61, F ‐0.33, R 0.06• Updated reference points:
– FMSY proxy: 0.27 (0.20)– SSBMY proxy: 10,051 mt (11,447 mt)– MSY : 2,075mt (2,352 mt)
![Page 28: Groundfish ABC’s FY 2013 2015archive.nefmc.org/tech/council_mtg_docs/Sept 2012/5_Presentation... · • Mohn’s rho values: SSB 0.68, F ‐0.19, R 0.34 • Retro adjusted (not](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051910/5fff173ca94c7c401f454243/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Witch Flounder Results
• Overfished, SSB 4,099 mt• Overfishing, F=0.47
![Page 29: Groundfish ABC’s FY 2013 2015archive.nefmc.org/tech/council_mtg_docs/Sept 2012/5_Presentation... · • Mohn’s rho values: SSB 0.68, F ‐0.19, R 0.34 • Retro adjusted (not](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051910/5fff173ca94c7c401f454243/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
Witch Flounder Projections
• No unusual conditions/assumptions• As a sensitivity run, geometric mean recruitment results in lower Frebuild and catch advice;
• Frebuild
![Page 30: Groundfish ABC’s FY 2013 2015archive.nefmc.org/tech/council_mtg_docs/Sept 2012/5_Presentation... · • Mohn’s rho values: SSB 0.68, F ‐0.19, R 0.34 • Retro adjusted (not](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051910/5fff173ca94c7c401f454243/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
Witch Flounder Projection Output
OFL Total ABC TotalCY Catch
2011 1,792 1,369 1,069.0
2012 2,141 1,639
2013 1,196 783
2014 1,506 984
2015 1,800 1,176
![Page 31: Groundfish ABC’s FY 2013 2015archive.nefmc.org/tech/council_mtg_docs/Sept 2012/5_Presentation... · • Mohn’s rho values: SSB 0.68, F ‐0.19, R 0.34 • Retro adjusted (not](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051910/5fff173ca94c7c401f454243/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
![Page 32: Groundfish ABC’s FY 2013 2015archive.nefmc.org/tech/council_mtg_docs/Sept 2012/5_Presentation... · • Mohn’s rho values: SSB 0.68, F ‐0.19, R 0.34 • Retro adjusted (not](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051910/5fff173ca94c7c401f454243/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
White Hake
• SCAA• No updated assessment• Rebuilding program• Benchmark planned for February 2013 ,may lead to adjusted ABC in 2013
• Recommend keep OFL/ABC at 2012 values until assessment completed
![Page 33: Groundfish ABC’s FY 2013 2015archive.nefmc.org/tech/council_mtg_docs/Sept 2012/5_Presentation... · • Mohn’s rho values: SSB 0.68, F ‐0.19, R 0.34 • Retro adjusted (not](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051910/5fff173ca94c7c401f454243/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
![Page 34: Groundfish ABC’s FY 2013 2015archive.nefmc.org/tech/council_mtg_docs/Sept 2012/5_Presentation... · • Mohn’s rho values: SSB 0.68, F ‐0.19, R 0.34 • Retro adjusted (not](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051910/5fff173ca94c7c401f454243/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
White Hake Catch/Index
![Page 35: Groundfish ABC’s FY 2013 2015archive.nefmc.org/tech/council_mtg_docs/Sept 2012/5_Presentation... · • Mohn’s rho values: SSB 0.68, F ‐0.19, R 0.34 • Retro adjusted (not](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051910/5fff173ca94c7c401f454243/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
White Hake
OFL Total ABC TotalCY Catch
2010 4,130 2,832 2057
2011 4,805 3,295 2,903.1*
2012 5,306 3,638
2013 5,306 3,638