-
This article was downloaded by: [Nanyang Technological University]On: 27 April 2015, At: 16:46Publisher: RoutledgeInforma Ltd Registered in England and Wales Registered Number: 1072954 Registeredoffice: Mortimer House, 37-41 Mortimer Street, London W1T 3JH, UK
Cold War HistoryPublication details, including instructions for authors andsubscription information:http://www.tandfonline.com/loi/fcwh20
Gorbachev and the End of the ColdWar: Perspectives on History andPersonalityV. ZubokPublished online: 06 Sep 2010.
To cite this article: V. Zubok (2002) Gorbachev and the End of the Cold War: Perspectives onHistory and Personality, Cold War History, 2:2, 61-100
To link to this article: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/713999954
PLEASE SCROLL DOWN FOR ARTICLE
Taylor & Francis makes every effort to ensure the accuracy of all the information (theContent) contained in the publications on our platform. However, Taylor & Francis,our agents, and our licensors make no representations or warranties whatsoever as tothe accuracy, completeness, or suitability for any purpose of the Content. Any opinionsand views expressed in this publication are the opinions and views of the authors,and are not the views of or endorsed by Taylor & Francis. The accuracy of the Contentshould not be relied upon and should be independently verified with primary sourcesof information. Taylor and Francis shall not be liable for any losses, actions, claims,proceedings, demands, costs, expenses, damages, and other liabilities whatsoeveror howsoever caused arising directly or indirectly in connection with, in relation to orarising out of the use of the Content.
This article may be used for research, teaching, and private study purposes. Anysubstantial or systematic reproduction, redistribution, reselling, loan, sub-licensing,systematic supply, or distribution in any form to anyone is expressly forbidden. Terms& Conditions of access and use can be found at http://www.tandfonline.com/page/terms-and-conditions
-
!""#$#%"#'" ! "" # " ( ')"!() "# * ') "'#"+ ! " !G46'"#""(#'"##""$#%-"#(++''"+""""*)''#("!"")"###"!#)("+""* !'""#""*. !-)!"+(#)"*)"+"#("'"#"#"+$#%/'""#"%"#'"""*"'#"* "# ! "" "# $# % " "* '"## '+ !"* )"# !-"*"" '"##'"( "#"0'#+"
"" '" '" ' + !" +'/'*#'"+"'*!"## '"""#"+"#)" 1 " "() "&"#") !'") "( #+ "# !" " '" * " 2++&!*1"# 3"-) "" "+ " )"#("""!*#*'("#) !( * # * 3+ "- '*####*)"*"('##"# "* " " ( 0'"'"0#""'*
"+ " " +' +! !"+)"#"("+*"#"+ 3## " "*" "# $#% (" 4 "# %-) "
$#%5*)6)7689"'*6::6;)G46?7$) 77
22cwh03.qxd 07/02/02 12:17 Page 61D
ownl
oade
d by
[Nan
yang
Tec
hnolo
gical
Unive
rsity]
at 16
:46 27
Apr
il 201
5
-
("""'#*)G46
> #(## !-!"(+" * "#) '"+*) " #'"+ " !- ) (" * "* + "" "#"!#2 !3-"'#*)"'" "+""#=
/ '" "*. ! "" '# "## !* # ( ' !"+ "*/*('!"' !'" * (' !'"+ " ( #*"'"# '@ ( A'"+ "* $"*!) *"#'! !-" !))3("B+"C"A'(""#- ' 3'# + "-) "# 3"*-6 *+"!!#") * ) 2 ! 3 " + "#) ' ( ( %' # "* # '"#"# -+"!(3")"+)"#( !-'"A'""!""D
' #" " ( (* !- &"&+"*#"#$#% # " " #' "##"" $# %- "# ( ++ ''"+ " """ *) '' # (" ! "") "# # # " !#) ("+ " " " '""# !-"*"#"+"""*.#)!"+((##" "#( "* "# "'"#"#"+$#% ""*#"* !"" '"## * #"+ * " !
?+' *#&=EF:# '" # #* " !' "# "# %?!#"#!""!* """#"++"( ('%
$%?5?>
-
%""#!#() '+ !'"#"(*
!')(!)#"+" ""+ '*")"!"""=EF:("(""=EG:)(")#!"+()*"""("# +"%*## !""(%("#""""@7*)(!)#"""")!*() #" (" * "# " ( + "#"#"# *"*""+!)""#) !) *#!+"+ ! "+ "# ""#)"*)""!#""" *#&=EF:
" *1#"+'(#"#!""1(#'# *+#!#"=EF=1FG"# " * '#' "# 3++!- !'?+"#""""+"" " "# "#%# %) >' "#! "# * "! "# +"* ' .!*"#!"+3+*-("# "&'G (!""3$' ""-=E
-
( "# ) ! #) "# #+' """ '" "# 3+!- !"#"+ $"*!) ! " * " !# 3' "- ( " 3""- "# 3- "# 3- 3'# ('""+(-I
(#"'") ##'"!#)("#'"*"-###"" "+'("#) ''"+3 "+-"# '#"*&"#'"#'! "* ") * " ")"## "# +#' !".# *) ' # +#' "# " !* "# " 0* "* " %"+"'# "# # '" =EFE ( * ( ! ""## #F "##) " "("" !-+'" / '#'"+=EF
-
(' !)("9""#G46?'#!*"0"""K "( '"# +") ' " ' "* ( '" ! -=:
'" "# " *"#""#!#"*")()')"! * =EFH ? 1 +'# * "+& * 1 ( '( "* " * " "# !-#)#"#"*## ' "# " #) "+ *+'."#$(? ).#(!*#!"+'"#""+ '# ! # ! '"* "#"#"#"#""#"""" ) ( " /#" ?+" "# ') ( +"" ! "") "# $#%+!#!'"#==
3# ''- "" '!) ' ! ) ) 3''- """ * "&" # * +! ")"")"# +""* ("=EF
-
=EFF "# " !-3#-("+"=G
"# !" ( "* "# "" " #") !""'#)'"=EFF)"" /"L#"(""#"+("#" ! * '"+ =EFF '" "+##*2 !- #" '" # "#+!"" ) '# ( ! *""'")#!"#"+"#"'+ ( "'"!'"11"+'#!# "* #*# ! * '("""""!""(""" '""A'" "# " "+" " G46+""4#'#!#"#.#&=EFF)3("("'"###')( +".(('# *("#!"!'+("*("""#%(##(*)(('#! "'##%# "#-=H
"# 3#''-#""+"!#"#$# % " ! 4!" ! "# " ! #!# ! "#!#"#. ' " ! 3"#- " $' )4) +"") "# ") ! #""""'#)!"(*) ' "#"#'**A'"" !)!#"#.)"####'"+=EFE)=EE:)"#!"=EE=="' " " " ! '++# !"'"# !3+"*-('#! "#* 3 "# 5 "* " ( &
$%?5?>
-
"") "* ' " ('# ! " "# ""' -=I "# "+ # ) ! * #"+ !*3#*-!#""'M"#3'- " '+ " "#"" "+" '"# !"* +" !# ) "# +("+ + ""' " "#"" !!"+(' ' "# +"" "#')""+*# #)%"+"#"#%"' ""
" ') + ! "#+) ! #'# ""+ "# "" #'# .#?"## *"*'("#(" ()" "#"* *" !-'""#"*
#"##"""#$#%#"+!#) #'"+"'"#+*"#& *' =EFI1FE'" !-3"(""+-###!3"*-)"' #+ ' 3 '++- "# "! *(#-#!""3(-*"(""+(#'*)+ "#"#")"#"#! '*(#""'+? 4"+#") "( # ' (#" # "# ! " "# "+" =EG: "# =EH:=F " ' ! # 3"( ""+- !' """' "# &"## #! # !-"!"(+"#!8G46" "#) ?# 7") + ) ?0!"#; " " " !- "'!'"=E (" !- 3* ""+-6: 5 * +# 3"( ""+- " "& 3''-"""#$#%6=
"##) # " "+"+ ! """ !' ( + ' !" ( "+ . ' ' *) ! # * *# " " ! !' *
?$5475447G4654$%?
-
#" " "* # " " "+"+) ' '" " " ' " " # !) ' " "*'#"##("
0" # #+* '# ! # +"# '#)!"3?- #"*""##""#"#'"3"-%"+#"=EFG"'## '"( !) ('* #( A'"+ # /" " !' 3"""-66 >'!+"*"=EFF(/"-#'(+*#"# '#(" " "#&=EFI !( # ""# '"!+"""" #""(0'"##(##)(?('#**"# "# 7" ('# +" ' " (#) !#"3!'"*&-#'"( A'*" # 3 " ?("* "#+ ) "((##-6D
"(#+!+"*##""*#0"'"#0"("""G46 !-#)""#!) "# +' " / ' "=EFH1FF)3- #""+)")"# "(( !" " " '" #+* * # '("#')")" '3-! "# 3" """- " #+) !0#""*'""3'++-) '&")3?-
""+""3"(""+-#! "# !- #* "* ' "'#' (+#"#**(*( !"A'"(("#("""#"#!#"G46"#1"#'"#"#"*)"' " ( * '## "#"'# * '" +" ( ' " !- ) *!# (" # '# ! #"+#3"(""+-
$%?5?>
-
() "*) #" " *(" # "+ '+ "+ ('# ("+* +"+("#!*'"#"" + 0 4!" "") !-)#03(#!'"-"=E=F *"+ " ( !) (!) ##**"+=EFE !'!"")("+"!+""##!""*$"*!"*=EFE("#*("+'"#."2 3"##""#+("+)" !"#5# + ' ( # "@ 5 ! (# B'"# *C'*(( "# "+ -6G ' =EE= "#' A'"*?'!##+"
G46"
"##"""#$#%""# "* 1 # ) ) "#"' "+ " ( !- ' "* "## * ('+ (' "## !"! *"(*0' # " "" "# +" ' "3"+-"#)!)"'#3* *#""+ N $#%"#'"O(""+"!"#?'"#!"?)( " '" * "# ! " "#!#'-6H
>++!(3""".+.+'#*( !-"("""#')"'#"+ !-"A'-6< " +"( #'"'"##"*."+ "*)"#"'"#'""
'("+ '"* "") !-"!)' - G46'"*) !!#""!'" !-""+"#(*# "! !G46'"#"!""* " #"))"##'" !-"1"*$"*!)+*".!)
?$5475447G4654$%?
-
##!#!)"#?"*)" #"/ '" 8#" / ' " '"! " ! /#" ?'"G46#";(#)"# ' #""'' ' # " "! " !G46'"#"!"=EED1E+ +!) &/#" ""#*>"!) '* G46+" " +* "") !-" #*&+'# # #!#!) "# "* 1 (# ' #"+6I !" !- "#"""# $"*!)+".!)##!#!)"#!) "# ! # "## "##"#(""#(6F
!* " ' " !- "* "' " * " / ' " "# # !-"!"(+"#"#' +') " ' #) " ! " ! ! G46'"#" " ( G46"*) " ' " !- "* ""' ! '+ * '* # #'") "# " " * "(# "+""*4!"'+"++ "#"#"*$/"#/#"*?)'" *"*)( '"A' !' "# #' !" #*
$%?5?>I:
22cwh03.qxd 07/02/02 12:17 Page 70D
ownl
oade
d by
[Nan
yang
Tec
hnolo
gical
Unive
rsity]
at 16
:46 27
Apr
il 201
5
-
?'"" "#6E ("+* "# " ") ! ! " !'"'"("+
+'"+#"+ !-"*'(# * "#) ) "# ) #! ' "# "#*"*%-!"'# "(")('# ##"#+"# !("+""#"+ #"* !- " '" '"#$#%#) !'"' ' "# '"!"# '#* "* "#" " "* " ' #"+ '# ++""#*"#"'"*"+!"?'
")'" !-"*' #('""* *3"+'"+-"+!* ' 1 ("+ ') "") "# " 1 ( " # !- !'")"'+ "'#
%"" !7'!'+#""+""")#'")"#*) *## "##! "+ " ""2" +'"#) " "# ! '+)'"++"+ "# '" &"#") !'"+" ! ) "# &"## " ""!"# * ! " ")'"+ " ( '! "# "+ " " ?' 3"-#3*-
" '# + # "# ' #+"'" "# #" *) +*) "# *+* G46 "") ?'" 7* .! "* '## #) ) "# (" !#" " ' ." ?'""*"?'"#(#3"!."-# &"+"#* **'"+" +)('"'"#""+7('' "!."( '""+(# 3#* !+ - 3''- "# + '*'# "'(# *=ED:"#"#%#%"#"
?$5475447G4654$%? I=
22cwh03.qxd 07/02/02 12:17 Page 71D
ownl
oade
d by
[Nan
yang
Tec
hnolo
gical
Unive
rsity]
at 16
:46 27
Apr
il 201
5
-
=EH:)#'"+"+!' "."""!* "# "! " 3#- "# 3"- 3''#-#' # #" #) *")#' &""+ ' "D: '! "# !'# '+
+' * " ' !- "*( 5 *3'-)3 '" -) ( #"* " " "# "#""!" ( +" # ! (* # '*")!""+ +"+("+5##"')"###"#"=EFE23!"+#!#'!"=EFH-')A'*###)#' ( 3" #'"+ "* !'"-D= 5 * "#"'*#"#"+/ '#M!"!' +"""'"##*( )#*!#/ '+'D6
*+ '"#" "# *+*"#*""#' #*)""#!#') !!**+"#* !' "# "!"" !# " 8( "!*)+"' ""'?')/ '(( *'"+ ; #*&""*)#'"++"+"("*'#
G46("+ " ) # *) ( !-"' "##"") #"'"!"#!*("* +# "# * "# (&"""# ( "$"*!-") !-3"'NO#""#" "* # * "+ " * ) '+ A'# BC-DD "" !# # * # ( #!* ( (' "#' ( 3*- '"# ( ! !# "$"*!- (#2 3 ! ( !* * "*)** "# * N"#O '# +"'" !"+*)""#(!* #*#!()('"!# "+*+("!#("#0"#'"+*"#- !'" +" "+ +) ""' $"*!)"#3 "-'"+ !"")#"*"+""##*DG
$%?5?>I6
22cwh03.qxd 07/02/02 12:17 Page 72D
ownl
oade
d by
[Nan
yang
Tec
hnolo
gical
Unive
rsity]
at 16
:46 27
Apr
il 201
5
- "# * '#) " "" ') ( "")+*".!)"" ) "+ !- 3"! " +'-""-DH ""*+' " (* '"#"# !-3'"-+"*"") (""""#"!'$#%"""+(A'* !!#'?+" *&"#' "! ) +!" "'+ " ') "# ?+" '#+ "+$#%""#!#*!"'# " ' ## + (" "#%" #("A'"#"##" ("!"""#%"'"5""#""(" =EF
-
!')( '*+"(*)' *'+'( !')'#*"!" / ( -DE "##) " "' "1"*##'("#*+"#"#""+*!" #1 !""'!'3"(""+-"(#)'"#''"*(&!#"G:
( " ') ' "" ( "# !- # =EFE*." """"# ''"#!''" !' !'!#"*"""(1"#.#)"#+1("("1!"')3-)"#'"++"+#""'##'+"# !"#$"*!"*3""-#!-'"*=EFEG=
! " * #" + * *" "#"'! !' (# ' #""#"+"+!+' !3##"!" "* '"#"#"+ ( #' NO- ('# G6 !- $ $"* *#")#"'*##!#!)"#>" ) " '"") !) ')#*#"" " "0* ''') *""'"#!#!-!() !(" 3#- " " * ()#!#! !)'"#*++ (""# ! 0* ! #!#! ( !)'"."!)'" (!(#) '#"+%"GD
!-"#+".(' !-"*( 8"# ; ++# ( " ?'"&! "* ' * # ( ) " ( $"*!) "") #" ! * 3 " '#-)3'".#'"(NO+!&*+*-" "" "#) ! # "5'"("+* '"#!*!"5*"#3 '#-"+"#+!')$"*!""#)("! 2*'"#' "(*#M"(""+(# !" ) ! '# " * *
$%?5?>IG
22cwh03.qxd 07/02/02 12:17 Page 74D
ownl
oade
d by
[Nan
yang
Tec
hnolo
gical
Unive
rsity]
at 16
:46 27
Apr
il 201
5
-
("3 '#-!*("#(")'"+!*"+" (*GG " ' +' ! # 3&"##- "# 3'""+- 3 * "# ("#-"#3!"+!(-('# *#!*"++#GH
G46 "# "# # !- " ""#"+"*"*++*
! !-""#"!*2 3#-) "+" "+&"+ + ") "#!" # +!"""* +". 3- # " " "# 3"( ""+- ( !+' "#'# " +'# !- !') # 3'"# *#$ ( 3 #!- "#3 " "- N O "* ! " / ' #'") ( "!" (" ! "# #!) #" !0'++#("*""+#"#") '#"(#"! +"G< 5##' ('# 0'("#((3-"'"#!##" '
4!" *. # *+ '" '# !- " " * ' ) *' '"# "# '+&'++")!"*+#*"##+ #(""*$"*!- ( '" "# "++"+ #' ' GI
!)()# +"""+'"(" '# '"# "+) ."!1"#!1* ( " +"" 3 !- (-) >" "! " "+ ( # ### #GF ) *.("'(*+'"" #*"(("3"-'"*)'# #" "* * "# ) " (# "*.) 3 ( ! ## '# "* ! "#"(''*!"+*"##"+ # # ' !*"+) " '+ !'"!"#)*'#"!!'"#"-GE
P' !'*)" !- #""'"" #*'#!##*M "*'# #*#""(*"
?$5475447G4654$%? IH
22cwh03.qxd 07/02/02 12:17 Page 75D
ownl
oade
d by
[Nan
yang
Tec
hnolo
gical
Unive
rsity]
at 16
:46 27
Apr
il 201
5
-
" * () ! ) " "###'")+#(3"!*"#'"-""'#"*'#3"(""+-5## # * " # .""=EFF) '("*?#(3# * #+"#- 3(' N!O -() #) 3(('#!#'!4!"("#'#"("#* #''1*""'+K'+"'!"* '""## '*!+-H:
' * '" ( ! ! !#" ("* """ "!*"#*"=EFI1FF! !)"(#*"#"*#"*(!' "+ !- '* " * ""'H= * ! !- .+.+)"") "# " ( * ( " !- ) '""+ * "+!(3 "+)"+(* !")( " !--H6 """!(###2
%" "! "+ "#) ! "#(#**"" ("# "*. ( # *) ( ( "' *5("#'")"'#''" ("* (+" #("* "" " * (" # "# " "*) ' '"#' + !)'"'"*)#A'*HD
*'!"#( ' !-3'!""#"*) "-HG
"!"# " * #) ( "+"##"#)('#!#'+#"* 3- '# ! '+ ' 3#J"- ( %"#+#'*"#$'"*"#!"") ')'" !)('#*"+'"#"("#('"+"#
$%?5?>IIF
22cwh03.qxd 07/02/02 12:17 Page 78D
ownl
oade
d by
[Nan
yang
Tec
hnolo
gical
Unive
rsity]
at 16
:46 27
Apr
il 201
5
- ( ! # (# # "# 8 !" # "+ 1$' "";
-
$"*! ! !- "' %") * "(!"+(%)!##*"#$#%5(#"'"#* ' !-" "+"#*"(%"$"5') !) "3"( ""+- " +" * ( " +" * "(%("((#!*)"#"# * ! *) '# A'* "# #!* ' !"*
%"(!"+N !"#O"'" "+"'" "+8''*;)**(""+"((#('++)#+*)"# " +" * "# "* " "+ #"""#"+&'""+'"#
- (3 '+-"+"*')3 !- #* " # (" #( "# "# -
-
"-I= "!"1" !?'1"#"*)(+("+"#(#""&) ""&!" '# " "- #) (" ! "# ""+ #+* +" (" '#)!"()3+((*'+'##!-I6
> !"#'"' "##) ( "# " ""'"#""""&!" ( " "* !- " ) "# '"#"#"#+") '# " 3#- !- "# ".3!#" ##("""" !-) 3 !"'"("+"# #( " "* " ' "#" "!!" "- !)* !)(""#' "'+>)3 *("" ""*'"+#') '!""+#&"#"!"-M 3 "# ## " " !- !3#"+' #-)!"("(## *$ID
"#"" !-"'""( " " "! "A'" "( ""+ #!' (' "#' ""' "# ##" ! !- '0" ( "' "# !" " G46"") +* /". # !- #" 3 +- 4" 4' ''"'*) #) ! 3 #'"-1 )"+"#)"#1 "'$'')$")"#!""3 #'* ( "" - !-"!*) (!) "# /"#- " )#'")"#23G46"N%O("*"''"*?')"""!""-IG
$# % ( "#"+ " 4') '#"!(""#"?)" ) !- 1 "# "* 1*#0"#"#" "#+!)! ##"+ ("(+2 "#$#%"#''""!""
$%?5?>F6
22cwh03.qxd 07/02/02 12:17 Page 82D
ownl
oade
d by
[Nan
yang
Tec
hnolo
gical
Unive
rsity]
at 16
:46 27
Apr
il 201
5
-
" ( #""&!" ( ""'" !- " !" '"+ +#* " " =EFE 8(" ?'" # +" '" # +" ""#"""##+"!";) !## " ' ) !" '+"" +" '"*5#/ '23%!#!""+"*"!NO)*""*)("""#("-IH
!' ) !##"( "*'"#*"(
%"")'*'"#)'"##!*( ' !- " "# ''*#)"")''++# ! +""- +" " ( '!" +"#"#"#"#"?(!" "+&"#"+ " 1! ") """3""-'(')(!)'"# 3 ('# ! ''"#"#"+ *' -) # 3'# " /('# #''""#"(*)"('#!*'!*'""+"*#'-" "" ' ( "# " " "" !- 3"(""+-) !" " 1!""(+ #) !#* +# ') ( " '"#"#"+ " ('# " "* "")("'" !"#'"+"#"+( IE6
22cwh03.qxd 07/02/02 12:17 Page 92D
ownl
oade
d by
[Nan
yang
Tec
hnolo
gical
Unive
rsity]
at 16
:46 27
Apr
il 201
5
-
!" +!"") #*- !' ("+""/"=EG:2
'NO-!!("'+"+(#."?'" " +") N"#O " " "'5 +"# " ') '+ *+KB"(*C)-!!#"!' ! "/ '+ " '=E=IB%"#"'?'"#"!"K ( #(" ( '" ' (K /
((""0'"#+(* !"+C ( # * (# * # +!"" " #' "' (" '+ "+"'+"")" ( "# B%C N ! " ""&!"'"#"*'"O=:I
?"*) " ?'" +) ) ( ' ! " " * ! * 8## * # #>'"*!;2 3 ! ""'# ! " (# '"5 '+#( )" .+.+('#("() " ) ++"#. - #" + '"""*"%"2
!-#"("""('*'+'+"A'"?)("+ ( !#)#?) ('# + " '" '# ' !# ! "()!"+#!# " ( "+ #(") ('# ! #!*"+"'#"#" =:F
"* 0'#+" " !) ! ) '# A'# *"#"%' !)#""+ $# % ('# " ! "# A'* ## #""'#! "!*#"'""# ' !""('# ! # !"#*'('#$#%G46")"# """ (" '( "# "+ " $'" # "( '") "# "( "#(
?$5475447G4654$%? ED
22cwh03.qxd 07/02/02 12:17 Page 93D
ownl
oade
d by
[Nan
yang
Tec
hnolo
gical
Unive
rsity]
at 16
:46 27
Apr
il 201
5
-
"+!" !#"""* '"++""A'"""#""&"4!*+')")3-!'#"+( * "A'" ! "" "A'""*" '"A' !-"A'"# $#%"#! "" ' !- """" * " "!+'"*?'1'"*)+') " " (") *") '") "#* '!#'"# * !-"
74
= (") G46
8"#"2 # "!* /) =EE)""#')=EE2#")=EEF;M
$%?5?>EG
22cwh03.qxd 07/02/02 12:17 Page 94D
ownl
oade
d by
[Nan
yang
Tec
hnolo
gical
Unive
rsity]
at 16
:46 27
Apr
il 201
5
-
"* ?*"# ) . 1:*#' 8%"+")$2"+"'"/)=EEG;
=6 + ".!) * % 5 % N% ?' "# %' O8(2 +') 6::=;) 6EG1E:,--, N!""25*/(O8(2.#!?)=EE24 ) =EEF;) 661D)=2$' "!*/)6:::;
=E ?#"!" !(/#"G46"#)I9'*=EF
-
"#O8(2?')=EEG;M+"")# N#7 * * "#O 8(2 /*) =EEG;M + *! "#+ "") % 5 ? N'+4*"#2$" G46+" /* ? "# =EFHO 8(2 .#'"#"* "") =EE6;M + "")2?"#5'T ) =EEH: "# ?'" #"2 * . 0 % *1 @,-AB:,-2A "C 8(2 !) =EEI;)'#" "!((!#'# *5* /0 " 4"# $# % '"# # +!!'"#'"'"5*)#*")"#("7"'*!)+%"+""!*
6F "*$"*!) 3G46"" ! ! " #!- N/""" ! #O) (% )%) I 8=EED;M #) * + . % N > ( !2 *7O 8(2 /+&'') =EED;M #),--, . / % ***#8(24??&?' ) =EEI;M+ ".!)*"#% N/G46#2 !- ?" " * "O 8(2 ?&') =EEDM##!#!)0.0%% N" !-2("#O8(2*")=EEG;M#)#.%D %$ N("2 5( # $ ' " 3%# *-O 8(2 .#'"#" "") =EEG;M "# >!!)6 6 N/) (") O 8(2 7!)=EE6;M4#'#!#"#.)(%5 N*$""*"#G46#O8(2"!)=EE=;M"#!)/%"7% NG467("%'24/#"O 8(2 /+2 '') =EEG;M #)
- D: 77.!)%*"% N5." 4!*#* ! 42 $'O 8(2 "' /*)=EE
-
$#%"""5*/0)%#(%""""$")%"+")$)=EEE)=:1==
HE 5 # / ' " 6= 9" =EFE "+ 3"# # ?1"#"'!4'5(""+9")"*)")"# '( " ) "# ) ' " +" 34'" # " !- 3% '# ( " "+ ' -) !"'##)3 '"'(*('#"-)4'"('# " 3" "* (" "# !4'-$"*!-")! !G46'"#"M#"+"*$"*!) !"(""#""+-)'')=HF1E
"!*
/)=EEF;)6:GID "!(("#>!!"#"#!# *(""
G46
) DFD1GM # >+!) / ' 7&.G$ 8$+)=EED;M".!))=GI
IG )6E1D:)++!)=I=EEF)'*+!!IE #)*1"F: J!A')',-2-66F= "!((+!M"!#""'"+3"!!-
") * '' "# '' * +" *#)$*"4#"#!"#")'*% 8"!* /) /2 /""*!" "!* /) =EEI;)I=1EF
F6 ?#"" (" !"# $$
$%?5?>EF
22cwh03.qxd 07/02/02 12:17 Page 98D
ownl
oade
d by
[Nan
yang
Tec
hnolo
gical
Unive
rsity]
at 16
:46 27
Apr
il 201
5
-
5'"+" %- /*) " $'" " /-?' 5'"+*7)6D=EFE)$"*!-")! !G46'"#"
FD #!#!) 3?#-) =I=M$"*!-*) H =EFE)! !G46'"#"
FG #!#!)#)=E=FH ! !G46'"#")"#6)6F< !"7'.")2 /'"-) =EEH;) =GG1H6M ' "#()1)=ID
=:: #"+#"("#?)7')DEF1EE
=:= ! # "!" ( /#" + ' 8"&&" "&!";)6=EFE)! !G46'"#")("#" !) " '"" /! /." ("#"!"M'"#()1)=
-
=:6 '"#()1)D=I=:D ! # "!" ( /#" + ' 8"&&"
"!";)6=EFE)! !G46'"#")(=:G ( ""=E66(""*"#!""'
+" "# %"'"=:H >'("*)0*.'/ N2
O)"5#"#5'4"+8"2#)=EED;)=