Thesis director:
Mr. Fayçal DERBEL
Presented by:
Moez Fakhfakh
UNIVERSITE DE SFAX
FACULTE DES SCIENCES ECONOMIQUES ET DE GESTION
Thesis presented for the obtention of the NATIONAL DIPLOMA Of CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT
The compliance of Tunisian banks with IFRS rules regarding customer’s loans operations:
Innovative principles and necessary adaptation of local
accounting standards
11
2
2
3
Thesis Issues
Thesis Interests 1
4
5
6
Thesis Objectives
Thesis Plan
Presentation of business processess and accounting
policies for customer’s loans operations in Tunisian Banks
Compliance of Tunisian Banks with IFRS accounting
policies related to customer’s loans operations
Case study : Objectives and Conclusions7
Added value of the Thesis8
THESIS PRESENTATION PLAN
3
1. In order to maximise its contribution to the financial sector
stability, the Tunisian banks should ensure:
The compliance with Basle II rules but also
The application of an recognized international accounting
standard (i. e IAS/IFRS) to reinforce the foreign investor’s
trust on bank’s financial reporting processess.
I- Thesis Interest
4
2. The effects of IFRS on the accounting policies of customer’s
loans operations is an interesting issue for the followings
reasons:
The great impact of customer’s loans transactions on
Tunisian banks financial performances.
The significant changes observed during the last ten years
regarding the accounting and regulatory rules of such
financial instruments.
I -Thesis Interest
5
3. The continuous amendment of accounting principles and
banking regulations is a challenging opportunity for the
chartered accountant to gain a sufficient knowledge of IFRS
rules. Such effort is required for the conducting of the following
audit engagements:
Audit of bank’s financial statements prepared according to
IFRS rules.
Assist the bank in the implementation of a new information
system compliant with IFRS principles.
I -Thesis Interest
6
« What is the bank’s startegy that ensure compliance with IFRS
principles knowing that :
The Tunisian accounting principles are largely defined by
two different regulatory instances( i.e. the CBT’s accounting
policies and the Tunisian accounting system).
The bank’s financial reporting processess should be
harmonious with Basle II principles.
II- Thesis issues
7
1. What are the gaps between the tunisian accounting methods
and IFRS principles regarding the customer’s loans ?
2. What are the effects of IFRS rules on credit information systems,
internal control process and accounting policies of Tunisian
banks?
3. What are the main guidelines that should be followed by
Tunisian banks to succeed in implementing a global banking
solution compliant with IFRS rules?
II- Thesis issues
8
1. Carrying out a critical analysis of the Tunisian accounting principles.
2. Presenting in depth the IFRS principles.
3. Proposing guidelines for the application of IFRS rules regarding cutomer’s loans.
III-Thesis Objectives
9
IV- Thesis Plan
10
The customer’s loans process is governed by a specific
banking regulation that encompass CBT circulars, banking
laws, and international standards.
Therefore, the Tunisian banks must have a internal control
process that identify, evaluate and analyze the credit activity
risks.
1- Customer’s loans particularities
11
The accounting principles mentioned in some CBT circulars
(mainly CBT circulars N° 91-24, N°93-08 and N° 2006-19)
The accounting policies of the Tunisian accounting system
(mainly banking accounting standards N°21 and N°25).
2- The customer’s loans accounting rules 2- The customer’s loans accounting rules
12
The customer’s rating and therefore the loan provision
calculation based on the past due aging ignore the fair value
amount, which is equal to the total estimated cash-flow
discounted at the effective loan interest rate.
A- Customer’s loans assessement method
13
The information included in Tunisian banks financial
statements have the following deficiencies:
The assessment of nature and extent of credit risk are not well defined.
The risk concentration criteria as well as risks mitigation methods are not communicated.
The risk assessment methods are not regrouped by counterparts that have similar characteristics.
B- Poor Quality of Financial information
14
The information included in bank’s financial statements are
provided only to explain figures and therefore is insufficient
compared to the requirements of pillar 3 of Basle II.
The Tunisian banks must publish sufficient, relevant and
usefull information regarding:
The nature, the volume and methods used for credit risk
management.
The adequacy of bank’s equity with the credit risk level.
C- Non compliance with Basel II principles
15
The application of IFRS standards should be considered as a
wide entreprise project .
Besides the accounting issues, compliance with IFRS requires
the improvement of the companies' information systems
quality.
First part conclusion:
16
With reference to IFRS rules, customer’s loans are recorded
initially at fair value plus transaction costs that are directly
attributable to the acquisition or issue of the financial asset.
The incorporation of these incremental costs permits to
determine the initial effective interest rate.
A- 1 : Initial loan evaluation
17
According to IFRS rules, the loans are valued at their amortized cost ,which equal to :
The amount at which this financial asset is measured at
initial recognition .
plus or minus the cumulative amortisation using the effective interest method of any difference between that initial amount and the maturity amount
Minus repayments.
Minus any reduction (directly or through the use of an allowance account) for impairment or uncollectibility.
A- 2 : Loans evaluation
18
An entity first assesses whether objective evidence of
impairment exists individually for financial assets that are
individually significant, and individually or collectively for
financial assets that are not individually significant .
If an entity determines that no objective evidence of
impairment exists for an individually assessed financial asset,
it includes the asset in a group of financial assets with similar
credit risk characteristics and collectively assesses them for
impairment.
A- 3 : Impairment and uncollectibility of financial assets
19
A financial asset or a group of financial assets is impaired and impairment losses are incurred if and only if :
There is objective evidence of impairment as a result of one or more events that occurred after the initial recognition of the asset (a ‘loss event’).
That loss event (or events) has an impact on the estimated future cash flows of the financial asset or group of financial assets that can be reliably estimated.
The amount of the loss is measured as the difference between the asset’s carrying amount and the present value of estimated future cash flows discounted at the financial asset’s original effective interest rate;
A- 3 : Impairment and uncollectibility of financial assets
20
An commun methodlogy of credit risks assessment in order :
To ensure coherence between Basle II and IFRS defintions and rules.
The determination of collective assessment of impairment as required by IFRS based on the criteria defined within the framework of Basle II.
The production of the information required by IFRS regarding the credit risk management based on the methodologies, data and tools developed within the framework of Basle II.
B- Links between IFRS et Basle II
21
Given the great volume of data processing, the application of
IFRS principles for customer’s loan operations requires to
implement a global banking solution .
In order to guarantee the success of such project, the banks
should cleary identify all the needed steps.
C-Startegy of compliance with IFRS principles
22
A. GAP analysis activities and preliminary impacts measurement of such project on bank’s organization and process.
B. Defining the project planning.
C. Implementing the global banking solution.
D. Follow-up of the project performance.
2- Appproach for applying IFRS rules to credit operations
23
A implementation of a new customer’s loans application.
Upgrading the internal control system.
A- GAP analysis and preliminary effects on the bank’s organization
24
Be compliant with IFRS principles.
Satisfy the specific requirements of the accounting and credits
departments of the bank.
B- Defining the project planning
25
Migration of all existing data into the new information system.
The definition of all accounting parameters.
Satisfying all specific tasks required by accounting and credit
departments.
C- Implentation project phase
26
The capacity of the information system to produce financial
statements prepared in conformity of several accounting
principles (IFRS,local accounting system,….).
Ensuring continous training sessions.
Ensuring that the new information system is capable to
follow the bank strategy changement.
D- The follow-up of the project performance.
27
Collecting and analyzing interviewees opinion on tunisan
accounting principles regarding the customer’s loan
operations.
Identifying the advantages of IFRS rules.
Defining the keys success factors for conducting projects of
implementing a new global banking solution compliant with
IFRS principles.
VII- Questionnaire Goals
28
The improvement of the financial information quality requires
an update of the tunisian accounting methods.
The IFRS rules should be adpated to the specific context of the
Tunisian banks. The adoption of IFRS Full version should be
restricted for the preparation of head office reporting (if it is
required by the law in force of the mother company).
Compliance with IFRS principles should be considered as a
global project that have effects on employee’s attitude,
department’s organization and company’s procedures.
VII- Questionnaire conclusions:
29
A relevant analysis of the credit process to decise which
approach should be choosen for the global banking
implementation process.
A precise and concise defintion of budgeted time, materials
and human resources.
Questionnaire conclusions:
30
1. Summarizing the tunisian accounting practices in force
regarding customer’s loans operations.
2. Identifying the weakness of these practices compared to the
advantages of IFRS rules.
VIII- Theorical Added Value of the thesis
31
Assisting banks in implementing global banking solutions compliant with IFRS rules.
Financial audit of the financial statements prepared according IFRS principles.
Added value for the chartered accountants profession