Miss
ionS
tudy
2011
First Presbyterian ChurchOf Arlington Heights
First Presbyterian Church of Arlington Heights
Mission Study 2011December 14, 2011
Contents
Introduction.............................................................................................................................................................3
Vision Statement......................................................................................................................................................4
Ministry Initiatives....................................................................................................................................................5
Biblical and Theological Foundation.........................................................................................................................6
Historical Perspective...............................................................................................................................................8
Building History....................................................................................................................................................8
Leadership Style and Impact of Recent Pastors....................................................................................................9
First Presbyterian Timeline.................................................................................................................................11
Community and Congregation................................................................................................................................15
Demographic Comparisons................................................................................................................................15
Community Perceptions.....................................................................................................................................18
Congregational Demographics...........................................................................................................................19
Life and Ministry.....................................................................................................................................................23
Congregational Survey........................................................................................................................................23
PCUSA Ten-Year Trend Statistics for First Pres...................................................................................................33
Congregational Discussions – Who are We?......................................................................................................36
Congregational Discussions – Who are we called to be?....................................................................................40
Groups, Ministries and Activities............................................................................................................................43
Office and Person of the Pastor..............................................................................................................................44
Appendices.............................................................................................................................................................45
Demographic Statistics.......................................................................................................................................46
Congregational Life Survey.................................................................................................................................48
“Who Are We?” Notes........................................................................................................................................55
“What are we called to be and do?” notes.........................................................................................................74
Groups, Ministries, and Activities.......................................................................................................................79
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 2
Introduction
In the past eighteen months, numerous changes among the pastoral staff at First Pres have forced the congregation to investigate a new course for our church. As with all new opportunities, grief and sadness for the loss of the familiar occurs. A bit of apprehension or anxiety about the new situation often develops. But by sharing the process as a congregation, praying for guidance, and looking expectantly toward the future the change can be made easier and filled with excitement.
In April 2011, Session tasked the Planning and Coordinating Committee with naming individuals to the Mission Study Task Force. The Mission Study Task Force was then charged with preparing a report detailing who we are as a church and what God is calling us to do.
To complete the report, the task force studied Scriptures, engaged the congregation to participate in conversations, and researched the historical development as well as current trends of our membership. The group of nine members and Interim Pastor David Horne worked together throughout the summer months and into the fall to finalize the report.
The committee members who devoted their time and talents to this report include Wendy Blanck, Luke Chen, Chuck Cooper (chair), Buzz Detrick, Kelsey Henrikson, Carrie Martinka, Aaron Mikulsky, Teri Stanley (Secretary), and Jody Stauzenbach.
The components to be included are:
Biblical and Theological discernment U.S. Congregational Life Survey Demographics outside the church, focusing on the local community Demographics within the church Historical Insights of the Church and Congregation Conversations – discussing the values and norms of the church, who we are and who is
God calling us to be
The finished report includes a Vision Statement and Ministry Initiatives that were created during our officer retreat held in November 2011. Over 60 officers participated in the development of the vision statement. Throughout this entire process, the task force, church officers, and congregation have focused on the future. The words of Jeremiah 29: 11 speak to us again, "For I know the plans I have for you," declares the LORD, "plans to prosper you and not to harm you, plans to give you hope and a future." We present this report to be used as a tool in our discernment of God’s plan for First Pres’ future.
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 3
Vision Statement
Inspired by Christ’s love, First Presbyterian Church of Arlington Heights seeks to welcome and faithfully serve all people and to glorify God through worship, education and mission.
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 4
Ministry Initiatives
Internal Initiatives
First Presbyterian Church needs to:
1. Become a deeply welcoming congregational culture, receptive to all – a place where strangers can become friends.
2. Foster the caring ministry of our church - be each other’s angels.3. Grow the spirituality of individuals and the congregation.4. Foster a greater learning community through
a. Enhanced and improved educational offerings.b. Marketing and promotion of these in the community.
5. Provide a choice of worship styles, experiences, and venues.
External Initiatives
First Presbyterian Church needs to:
1. Expand participation in mission and service in our local area with emphasis ranging from compassionate service through advocacy.
2. Identify, develop and strengthen ministry and mission partnerships with civic and religious groups to further both the work and visibility of our church.
3. Connect with young adults and families to ensure that they feel a part of the friendship, fellowship, and mission of the church.
4. Present a dynamic and relevant presence in the community.
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 5
Biblical and Theological Foundation
How does a mission study task force begin? Where do we go for help as we take on the awesome assignment of helping to chart the future of our precious congregation? The most logical place to begin in our minds is with Scripture. What did Christ say to his disciples and to early Christians? What is God asking us to do today? As we considered several Scripture passages, what stood out to most of our group are the words of Christ when asked, “Teacher, which commandment in the law is the greatest?” And Christ answered, “You shall love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul, and with all your mind." This is the greatest and first commandment. And a second is like it: ‘You shall love your neighbor as yourself.’ On these two commandments hang all the law and the prophets.”
First Presbyterian Church is a place where we worship, learn and serve. In worship we bring our hearts – our emotions, our feelings, our affection, our praise to God. Through hearing the Word preached and studying in a variety of settings on Sunday morning and throughout the week, we strive to have a mind for Christ – as we study the history of God’s mighty acts of love, compassion and forgiveness. In fellowship with the Holy Spirit and with members of our church, we care for one another, sharing one another’s burdens, helping and encouraging. As we experience God’s love ourselves we want to respond by reaching to others witnessing to this love. Our mission programs grow out of our desire to love our neighbors whether they are in our own congregation, our community or half way across the world. “I became its servant according to God’s commission that was given to me for you, to make the word of God fully known, the mystery that has been hidden throughout the ages and generations but has now been revealed to his saints. To them God chose to make known how great among the Gentiles are the riches of the glory of this mystery, which is Christ in you, the hope of glory. It is he whom we proclaim, warning everyone and teaching everyone in all wisdom, so that we may present everyone mature in Christ. For this I toil and struggle with all the energy that he powerfully inspires within me.” Colossians 1:25-29. As Paul knew his work as a servant of God was to proclaim Christ’s strength, our congregation knows its mission is to make the word of God known in our own congregation, our community and half way across the world.
In the early church described in Acts 2, the members devoted themselves to the apostles teaching and fellowship, to the breaking of bread and prayers. They spent time together in the temple and broke bread at home and ate their food with glad and generous hearts. They had the goodwill of all people in mind. And through the work of the Holy Spirit their numbers increased greatly. Acts 2:42-47. This is a picture of what our church can be today—a fellowship of members caring for and learning from one another, praising God and being thankful for God’s amazing generosity to us, and responding to God’s generosity by reaching out to others to meet their needs.
Another source of revelation to the task force is the Book of Confessions. The Confession of 67 states in Section 9.48, “Jesus Christ has given the church preaching and teaching, praise and prayer and Baptism and the Lord’s Supper as means of fulfilling its service of God among men. These gifts remain, but the church is obliged to change the forms of its service in ways appropriate to different generations and cultures.” FPC is fortunate to have a long history of inspiring worship services. Our fine music program is known throughout the community. We treasure our old hymns and sing them with great gusto. We have been blessed with dynamic preaching. But there is a significant group of people in the congregation who desire that we explore alternative approaches to
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 6
worship more in keeping with our current culture. We have been gifted with a variety of resources that enable us to have a fine Christian education program for all ages. Our program for children has been recognized for innovative teaching styles designed to capture the interest of today’s youth. In Jesus’ words, “Let the little children come to me.”
At this time in 2011 we have a unique opportunity to step back and look into the future for our church. How do we move forward being faithful to what God calls us to do while being relevant to our current and potential members? We can be guided by words from the Confession of 1967, section 9.49, “God instructs his church and equips it for mission through preaching and teaching. By these, when they are carried on in fidelity to the Scriptures and dependence upon the Holy Spirit, the people hear the word of God and accept and follow Christ. The message is addressed to men in particular situations. Therefore, effective preaching, teaching and personal witness require disciplined study of both the Bible and the contemporary world. All acts of public worship should be conducive to men’s hearing of the gospel in a particular time and place and responding with fitting obedience.”
While all Churches are part of the Body of Christ and share many beliefs in common, the Book of Order also declares that “every Christian Church, or union or association of particular churches, is entitled to declare the terms of admission into its communion, and the qualifications of its ministers and members, as well as the whole system of its internal government which Christ hath appointed;” G-1.0302. Our Mission Study Task Force has spent months discerning who we are as a Church, and What God is Calling Us to Be. The Book of Order allows us as a separate church to make the decisions and qualifications for who will join in our communion, who will join us as our minister, and this is the goal of our process as a Task Force.
Our church has experienced challenging times in the last year—losing her entire pastoral staff. Our Task Force reflected on the difficult journey Paul experienced sailing to Rome as documented in Acts 27. During Paul’s trip, most on the boat are fearful, concerned about the lack of food and the difficult weather affecting the journey. While our congregation is literally on solid ground, most of us feel the unease that the passengers on Paul’s journey to Rome felt. But just as an angel of God comforted Paul during his passage, our Task Force and our congregation can be comforted by Paul’s words, “So keep up your courage, men, for I have faith in God that it will be exactly as I have been told.” Although the loss of beloved staff members is profound and difficult for many, we are consoled and guided by Scripture. In Isaiah 41:10 we hear, “So do not fear, for I am with you; do not be dismayed, for I am your God, I will strengthen you and help you; I will uphold you with my righteous right hand.” Every challenge is a new opportunity and we go forward with hope, not fear, and with joyful anticipation of the future for First Presbyterian Church of Arlington Heights.
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 7
Historical Perspective
Building HistorySixty years ago the population of Arlington Heights was on the rise, as the Baby Boom took off. The membership of First Presbyterian Church expanded along with the growth in the community. In 1949, with a membership of 892, the church launched a campaign to build a new sanctuary. A mere four years after the financial campaign began the sanctuary was dedicated on December 20, 1953, almost sixty years ago. The membership now exceeded over 1,000 members. As much as the new sanctuary provided for a beautiful location for worship, space for the church school program was in very short supply. Less than ten years after the completion of the sanctuary construction the Christian Education Building was dedicated on October 29, 1961. The Christian Education Wing created a variety of classroom spaces for Sunday school as well as a nursery for childcare. The building was much needed in the 1960’s as the church school program saw an average of 750 children each Sunday! Prior to construction of the CE Wing, as it is referred today, the congregation determined that the Sanctuary would be the focal point of the church and the construction project would not change the character of the Sanctuary. In the fifty years since the completion of the CE Wing, minor updates have occurred and many of the rooms have been repurposed to provide the current space for The Kingdom, Y-Search and Senior High.
In January 1990, the Session received the report of the Ad Hoc Facilities Planning Committee that outlined the Long Range Facilities Plan for First Pres at that time. While the long list of action items on that plan have not all been achieved, many of them have been accomplished in the twenty years since the Long Range Plan was developed. One of the objectives of the Long Range Plan was to rebuild or renovate the Chapel and administrative area. By 1991, the staff consisted of four full-time pastors, a Director of Music, a Director of Children’s Ministries and several administrative personnel. The rooms next to the Chapel and in the hallway connecting the Chapel to the gymnasium were used as offices for the pastors and the administrative staff. With four pastors on staff, the space quickly filled up and didn’t allow for the best function. In 1994 construction on the Parish Center began and was dedicated only a year later. While the congregation had not grown significantly from the height of membership of approximately 1,600, the needs of the congregation had grown exponentially. The Parish center increased the size of the church facility by 40%.
Not only did the 3-story addition provide ample office space for each of the pastors, but also created more room for the administrative business of the church. The Parish Center addition included the Choir Auditorium, Choir Music Storage Room and large storage areas for the robes of each of the various choirs. To provide a music rehearsal room and other dedicated rooms were top priority objectives of the Long Range Plan in 1990. The benefit of this project to the music program is still felt today, over 15 years after completion. The Parish Center addition expanded the space available for fellowship gatherings and expanded the Narthex to provide a designated spot to welcome newcomers. Each Sunday the Parlor is used for coffee hour, relocating “Mid Hour” as it was termed in 1974 from the Fellowship Hall to the Parlor and Narthex. Throughout the year it’s used for wedding celebrations, funeral receptions and a gathering place for all members. The Narthex provides a visible location for the Welcome Center, a
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 8
friendly place for visitors and newcomers to see a congenial face, ask a question, or learn how to become involved with First Pres. The church library, which had been located in a small room in the Christian Education Wing, was moved to a dedicated spot in the Parish Center. Gardeners in the congregation enjoy the beauty of another garden located between the sanctuary and the administrative wing. Known as the Memorial Prayer Garden, the sheltered gardens on the church grounds allow for the final resting place for many of our members who have placed the cremains in the garden. The history of our church membership is felt throughout the facility. The Parish Center connected to the Sanctuary, but aside from extending the north walkway out of the balcony, this major construction project also avoided changes to the Sanctuary.
Even though the major projects did not change the primary focus of the Sanctuary, it has undergone changes as well. Originally, the choir sat in the Chancel and was divided into two sections, facing each other, as opposed to today’s arrangement facing the congregation. The current pipe organ was installed nearly forty years ago, with additional pipes added in the past decade. The large, simple wooden cross which hangs in the Sanctuary was installed over thirty years ago. In 2005, in celebration of the congregation’s 150th anniversary, the golden rays enhanced the cross, turning it into a Gaelic Cross, in the Scottish Presbyterian tradition. The chapel, the oldest portion of the current church, had a sloped floor with installed pews about fifty years ago. Today, the congregation faces the stained glass windows on the east side of the room and many technological updates have been installed including audio visual equipment and air conditioning. Some members recall that during the 1960’s the Chapel had the latest technology allowing the overflow from the Sanctuary to watch Easter morning services on closed-circuit television!
Standing on the corner of Dunton and Eastman, it’s easy to think the church looks as it did in 1961. You must walk further along Dunton toward St. James Street to see the expansion of the Parish Center. A glance east across Dunton Avenue will allow you to look to the future of the congregation, a parking lot with potential to serve our congregation in unknown ways. In July 2011 our church encountered a challenging situation when excessive rains caused flooding in Fellowship Hall, the kitchen, and the PADS area. Like many unexpected changes, the “Great Flood of 2011” may create a great opportunity for growth and expansion within the physical structure of the church allowing 4:11, PADS, and other programs to be better served.
Leadership Style and Impact of Recent PastorsReverend Paul L. Stumpf – He arrived in 1955 and served for 18 years until retiring in 1974 and remains the longest serving pastor in First Pres. History. Reverend Stumpf is remembered as an authentic individual, a very good preacher who gently led the church with a firm hand, a pastor who “walked the walk and talked the talk.” Serving as head pastor during the Baby Boom, he saw incredible growth in church membership and Sunday school participants. He also oversaw the fundraising efforts and building of the Christian Education Wing. Nearly forty years after his ministry at the church ended he is still remembered for the personal visits he made to member’s homes and the caring he showed during those visits.
Dr. James Martin – Elected in 1974 and served for over a decade until his death. Nearly every single member in the church who can recall Dr. Martin recalls the fact that he could remember each congregant’s name, an impressive fact considering the church membership was over 1,000 at the time.
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 9
During his time as head pastor church membership grew significantly, a direct response to his excellent preaching. His personal emphasis was on family ministry and adult education. Dr. Martin’s friendly and welcoming nature encouraged the growth of the congregation. Members describe him as charismatic; he was very visible within the church and attempted to attend everything, a busy and difficult task to achieve.
Dr. Harry Thompson – Dr. Thompson was called to First Presbyterian Church in 1984 and served until his retirement in 1995. Under Dr. Thompson’s guidance the Parish Center Building was planned, funded, and built, expanding the physical size of the facility by 40%. He recognized the importance of a large enough structure for the church to be able to serve its purpose as membership was close to 2,000 members during his tenure. Dr. Thompson is remembered as an excellent administrator, always advising the officers to work toward the best interests of the church members, even if that meant not acting solely for the best interests of the pastors.
Dr. John G. McFayden – Installed in 1998 and served as head pastor until May 2010, Dr. McFayden is remembered for his inspired preaching. Most members recall his sermons as very thought-provoking and that he called the congregation to action. Very often he shared his personal struggles in his sermons, allowing most of the congregation to relate to similar challenges in their own lives. But without fail, each March a member need not watch the NCAA basketball tournament to know whether or not the North Carolina Tar Heels were competing in the tournament. If they were, it was mentioned in the sermon, and if they were doing well, it was mentioned more than once. Not everyone in the congregation could relate to his passion for basketball but most were familiar with such a loyalty to one’s alma mater. Some members of the congregation who served as church officers during his tenure felt that Dr. McFayden efficiently ran Session and committee meetings as well as served as an effective manager of the pastoral staff and clerical staff of the church.
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 10
First Presbyterian TimelineNovember 1855
First Pastor, Rev. David H. Kingley; served from 1856-1860
January 1856Building plans and fundraising for first church structure began
September 1856First Presbyterian Church of Dunton formally
organized by Presbytery of Chicago
1875Dunton became Arlington Heights; church
changed name to match the town’s new name
1887Church membership 77;
over 200 enrolled in Sunday School
1912New church building dedicated June 23, 1912 with membership now at 128; “new building” still exists today as The Chapel; total construction cost of $13,574.54
1927-28Congregation approved expansion of the church by building a parish house to provide space for Sunday School membership of 250; including a gymnasium, dining room and kitchen; trustees campaign was titled “an investment in our boys and girls” Dedicated on March 11, 1928
1930'sThe Great Depression affected Arl. Hts. And
the church. Membership dropped more than 20% from 283 to 223, Sunday school
attendance lagged and financial problems plagued the church.
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 11
September 1931The 75th Anniversary celebrated
as the Diamond Jubilee
1937Church was $42,000 in debt, nearly declared
bankruptcy; began a Loyalty Campaign by the Save Our Church committee
1940'sOver 41 soldiers from Arl. Hts died in WWII;
2 church members died;
May 1946Mortgage paid off in full, only nine years
after nearly filing bankruptcy
June 1946First Director of Christian Education
Eleanor Uhlig hired
1947Pastor Victor Brown began his call, serving until 1955;
membership expanded from 391 to approximately 1,200 during his tenure
1949
Building Campaign to build a new Sanctuary began; membership of 892 outgrew the Chapel space
December 20, 1953Dedication of the Sanctuary
1953Average Sunday School attendance of
more than 400 students
1955Reverend Paul Stumpf began his call
October 29, 1961Christian Education Building dedicated; the fifth building cost for the church within 100 years; total cost of $382,784.73
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 12
2001Phyllis Green hired as the Director of Children’s
Ministries, serving for 10 years
2003Associate Pastor Nicole Bates hired
September 2005150th Anniversary celebration
Oct-05East parking lot purchased with assistance from "Angel"
2006Reverend Sean Miller hired as Youth Ministry Pastor
and began the 4:11 program
2007Associate Pastor Jihyun Oh hired
2009Pastor Oh leaves and Pastor McFayden leaves to join
Presbytery Pension Board
2011 2011Pastors Deardorff, Shields and Miller
leave, retire and/or pursue other callsFlood in Fellowship Hall, Kitchen and PADS site leading to new opportunities
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 13
Community and Congregation
Demographic ComparisonsComparing the demographics of FPCAH with the community of Arlington Heights enables us to better understand ourselves, our community and our opportunities. The age distribution of the FPCAH congregation is consistent with the distribution within Arlington Heights. However, as shown below, a majority of the Congregational Surveys were completed by individuals over 65 years old.
Community Comparison of Age Distribution
Arlington Heights
Un d er 5 yea rs o ldUn d er 1 8 ye a rs o ldB e tw e en 1 8 & 6 4 yea rs o ld65 y ears o ld & o v er
F PCAH
Survey Respondents
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 14
The only available race comparison of FPCAH to Arlington Heights is the survey responses and as shown below, FPCAH does not reflect the diversity of our community.
Community Comparison of Race/Ethnic Origin
A rlington Heights
88 .20 %
7.10%5.70 %
W hiteA sianHispanic or Latino orig inB lackA merican Ind ian & A laska NativeP ersons reporting two or m ore races
Survey Respondents
98%
White
As ia n
O th er
Overall, FPCAH’s congregation has a higher level of education and slightly smaller household size than the Arlington Heights community.
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 15
Finally, Arlington Heights is a wealthier community than the United States as a whole as shown below.
78% Home ownership rate in Arlington Heights vs. 66.9% in U.S. Medium value of home $372,300 vs. $185,400 in U.S. Medium household income $78,765 vs. $50,221 in U.S. Person below poverty level 3.6% vs. 14.3% in U.S.
Additional Arlington Heights, U.S. and Illinois demographic information is included in the appendix.
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 16
Community PerceptionsThese are the common themes heard from the local Hospital, Park District, Village, Racetrack, Arlington Heights and Mount Prospect restaurants, shop owners, schools, banks, hair salons, and other sources sorted by frequency of occurrence.
Known for having a good children’s program “Don’t know much/anything about it” Known for its music venues and concerts Vacation Bible School in summer Good choir “Just another church” Beautifies downtown area Knows nice people who go there Homeless shelter on Tuesday nights, i.e. PADS Parent’s Day/Night Out
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 17
Congregational DemographicsThe following congregational statistics are based on membership data contained in the ACS Technologies church database as of July 2011.
Congregational Age Distribution of Member Families
54
97
145
7183 84
152
115
272
340
139
210
187
In fa n ts (les s th an 1 )
P resc h o o l
K -3
G ra d es 4 -5
G ra d es 6 -8
G ra d es 9 -1 2
Ag es 18 -23
Ag es 24 -30
Ag es 31 -44
Ag es 45 -59
Ag es 60 -66
Ag es 67 -78
Ag es 79 +
No birth date = 328
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 18
Congregational Age Distribution of Member FamiliesSummarized
23.50%
11.70%
26.90%
23.50%
In fan t-G ra d e 12 Y ou n g Ad u lts (18 -3 0) Age s 3 1-5 9 6 0 & O ver
No birth date = 14.4%
26.9% of the active FPCAH family members are within the 31-59 year old age group
Household Marital Status
6%
68%
17%
9%
D ivorced Married S ing le W idow ed
68% of FPCAH households are married couples or families.5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 19
Longevity in the ChurchNumber of Years a Member
18.50%
17.10%
15.10%
8.00% 8.30%
5.10%
9.40%
4.80%
5.50%
3.20%
5.10%
0-4 5-9 10-14 15-19 20-24 25-29 30-34 35-39 40-44 45-49 50 and u p
Although over 40% have been FPCAH members 20 or more years, almost 20% have joined in the past four.
Membership Distribution by City
Arlin g to n He ig h ts
5 4 .9 3%
P ala tin e 10 .35 %
M o u n t P ro s p e ct
7 .42 %
Arlin gto n He ig h ts P a la tin e M o u n t P ro sp ec t B u ffa lo G ro ve Ro llin g M e ad o w s Ho ffm an E s ta tes In ve rn e ss E lk G ro v e V illag e P ros p e ct He ig h ts S ch au m b u rg Wh e e lin g D es P la in e s L a ke Zu r ic h O the r Zip s w ith 4 -1 4 O the r ILNo n IL & B lk
Almost 73% of the congregation lives in one of the three surrounding suburbs: Arlington Heights, Mount Prospect and Palatine.
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 20
Membership Distribution by Zip Code
60004 32 .73%
60005 22 .13%60067 7 .73%
60056 7 .42%
60004 60005 600 6760056 60010 600 0860007 60070 600 4760090 Zip s w ith 4 -14 Ho u seh o lds O th er ILNo n IL & B lan k
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 21
Life and Ministry
Congregational SurveyDuring late June and early July 2011, almost 1,200 surveys were distributed to members and attendees at First Presbyterian Church of Arlington Heights. 637 surveys were returned and the results compiled by US Congregational Life Survey. Of the total responses, 34 were between the ages of 15-24, 71 from 25-44, 184 from 45-64 and 327 respondents were over the age of 65. The following charts highlight responses to some of the key questions:
1. How often do you go to worship services at this congregation?
55%
19%
7% 7% 7%4%
0%
Usually e very w ee k
T w o o r th re e tim e s a m on th
Hard ly e ve r o r sp e c ia lo ccas ion s o n lyL ess th a n o n ce a m on th
O n ce a m o n th
M o re th an o nc e a w ee k
T h is is m y firs t tim e
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 22
2. How long have you been going to worship services or activities at this congregation?
49%
20%
16%
9%
3% 2%0% 0%
M ore th an 20 ye ars
11-20 years
6 -10 years
3 -5 years
1 -2 years
L ess th an 1 year
I am v is iting fro m ano th ercon g reg atio nI am v is iting an d d o n o treg u la r ly go an yw here e lse
6. Do you currently have any of the following roles here?
(Mark all that apply).
53%
14% 14% 13%10%
8% 6%
No ne
M em ber o f a c ong rega tion a l co m m itte e o r tas k fo rc e
C h o ir m em b er, m us ic ian , o r cho ir d ire c to r
O th er ro le no t lis ted h ere
O ffic er o r lead er o f m en 's , w o m en 's , yo u th o r o ther g rou p
M em ber o f th e gov ern ing bo ard
S u nda y s cho o l, chu rch sch o o l o r S ab b ath sch oo l te ache r
Lea d in g o r as s is ting in w ors h ip
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 23
9. Over the last year, how much have you grown in your faith?
(Mark only one.)
49%
20%18%
8%5%
S om e g row th
No rea l g ro w th
M u ch g row th , m a in ly th ro ug h th is c on g re ga tio n
M u ch g row th , m a in ly th ro ug h m y o w n pr iva teac tiv itiesM u ch g row th , m a in ly th ro ug h o the r g ro up s o rco ng reg ation s
10. Which statement comes closest to your view of the Bible?
(Mark only one.)
47%
34%
7% 7%
3% 2% 0%
The B ib le is the w ord o f God , to b e in terpreted in th e ligh t o f itsh isto rical context and the ch urch 's teachings
The B ib le is the w ord o f God , to b e in terpreted in th e ligh t o f itsh isto rical context
The B ib le is the w ord o f God , to b e taken literally w ord fo r w ord
The B ib le is the not w ord o f God , bu t contain s God 's w o rd to u s
The B ib le is the not w ord o f God , bu t is a valu ab le book
D on 't know
The B ib le is an ancien t book w ith little value today
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 24
11. Do you agree or disagree with this statement: "All the different religions are equally good ways of helping
a person find ultimate truth"?
9%
35%
24% 25%
7%
S tro ng ly Ag ree
Agree
Neu tra l o r u ns ure
D isag re e
S tro ng ly D isag ree
51% of respondents agree to some extent.
12. Do you agree or disagree: "My spiritual needs are being met in this congregation or parish"?
11%
46%
27%
13%
3%
Stro ng ly ag ree
Ag ree
Ne utra l o r u n su re
D isag ree
Stro ng ly d isag ree
60% of respondents agree to some extent.
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 25
20. Does this congregation have a clear vision, goals or direction for its ministry and mission?
39%
22%
17% 17%
5%
T he re a re id e as b u t n o c lea r v is ion , go a ls o r d ire ctio n
I a m n ot a w are o f s uc h a v is io n , g oa ls o r d ire c tio n
Y e s , a nd I am s tro ng ly c om m itte d to them
Y e s , a nd I am p artly c om m ite d to them
Y e s , b u t I am no t c o m m itted to the m
61% of respondents are either not aware of a vision, goal or direction for or believe there is none.
22. Do you have a strong sense of belonging to this congregation?
36%
28%
17%
8%7%
3% 1%
Y es , b u t p erh ap s n o t as s tro n g as in th e p as t
Y es , a s tro n g se n se - a b o u t th e sam e a s las t y ear
Y es , a s tro n g se n se o f b e lo n g in g th a t is g ro w in g
No , an d I w ish I d id b y n o w
No , b u t I am h ap p y as I am
No , b u t I am n ew h ere
No t ap p lic ab le
81% of the respondents have a strong sense of belonging but that sense may not be growing.
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 26
23. Which two styles of music do you prefer in congregational worship?
Top four categories summarized by age
80%
38%
28%
19%
50%
64%
15%
24%
73%
51%
23%17%
74%
48%
21% 21%
88%
26%34%
18%
All Ag es 15-24 y rs o ld 25-44 y rs o ld 45 -64 y rs o ld 65 y rs o r o ld er
T rad itio n a l h ym n s C o n tem p o ra ry h y m n s & m u s icC la ss ic a l m u s ic o r ch o ra les P ra ise m u s ic o r ch o ru ses
25. Which of the following aspects of this congregation do you personally most value?
(Mark up to three.)Responses greater than 6% shown
65%
40%
29% 29%
21% 20% 18%16%
15%
Trad itional sty le o f w orsh ip or m usic
S erm o ns, p reach ing or h om ilies
S harin g in H o ly C om m un io n , E u charist o r the L ord 's S upper
Min istry fo r ch ild ren or youth
S ocial activ ities o r m eeting n ew peo p le
W ider com m un ity care or soc ial jus tice em phasis
B ib le study or p rayer g roups, o ther d iscuss ion groups
P ractical care fo r o ne another in tim es o f need
C on tem porary sty le o f w o rsh ip or m u sic
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 27
41. About how much do you give financially to this congregation?
40%
34%
11%9%
5%
I g ive less th an 5 % of n e t in co m e reg u la r ly
I g ive ab o u t 5% to 9% o f n e t in co m e reg u la r ly
I g ive a sm all am o u nt w h en eve r I am here
I g ive 10% or m o re o f n e t in co m e reg u la r ly
I d o n ot c on tr ib u te fin an c ia lly h ere
48. Compared to 2 years ago, do you think you participate in activities of the congregation more, less, or about the same amount
as you did then?
17%
44%
38%
2%
P artic ip ate m ore
Abou t the sam e p artic ip ation
P artic ip ate less
N ot app licab le (been co m ing less than 2 years)
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 28
52. Do you agree or disagree: "I have a sense of excitement about our congregation's future"?
11%
30%
46%
10%
3%
S tro n g ly ag ree
Ag ree
Ne utra l o r u ns u re
D is a gre e
S tro n g ly d isa gree
41% of respondents have a sense of excitement about the future.
55. Do you agree or disagree: "This congregation is always ready to try something new"?
2%
25%
47%
22%
5%
S tro n g ly ag ree
Ag re e
Neu tra l o r un s ure
D isagree
S tro n g ly d is ag ree
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 29
How satisfied are you with the following at this congregation? (satisfied and very satisfied)
Page 1
4 1%
42 %
4 4%
4 4%
45 %
45 %
47 %
50 %
54 %
5 6 %
74 %
D eaco n 's M in istry
P W & W o m en 's Circ les
Ch ild ren 's P ro g ra m
P h y sic al Fa ciliti es o f th e Ch u rch
M id d le S ch o o l P ro g ra m
M issio n O u trea ch & Im p ac t
Sen io r H ig h P ro g ram
Va ca ti o n B ib le S ch o o l
Ea se o f P ark in g
Ch u rch co m m u n ica ti o n s, Ch im es & W eb site
M u sic P ro g ra m
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 30
How satisfied are you with the following at this congregation? (satisfied and very satisfied)
Page 2
2 3 %
2 4 %
2 4 %
2 8 %
2 9 %
3 0 %
3 1 %
32 %
32 %
P asto r Visitati o n
In t eg rati o n o f N ewM em b ers
Co n greg ati o n alIn v o lvem en t
W o rsh ip
Co m m u n tyIn v o lv em en t
Fello w sh ip Gro u p s
A d u lt Ed u cati o nP ro g ram
S m all G ro u p s S tu d y
P rayer L ife
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 31
PCUSA Ten-Year Trend Statistics for First Pres
1 ,9942 ,016
1 ,988 1,960
1 ,685 1 ,659 1 ,648 1,647 1 ,638 1,631 1 ,662
200 0 200 1 200 2 200 3 200 4 200 5 200 6 200 7 200 8 200 9 201 0
Average PC USA congregation had 191 members in 2010. Only one other church in Chicago Presbytery has more members.
Total Membership
The average PC USA congregation had 191 members in 2010. Although Lake Forest and Libertyville are close in membership, only one other church (Fourth) in the Presbytery has more members than First Pres in 2010.
Membership for the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) and its predecessor denominations (the UPCUSA and the PCUS) peaked in the early 1960s then began a steady, slow decline. From 2000 to 2010, PCUSA membership has declined by about 1.9% annually. In general, smaller-membership congregations (less than 250 members) were more likely to experience net losses in the last ten years and larger-membership congregations (more than 250 members) were more likely to experience net gains. Nonetheless, a majority of all congregations (including larger-membership congregations) experienced net losses over this period.
FPCAH membership declined an average of 1.7% per year over this time period, but has remained stable over the past six years.
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 32
1,994
706
2,016
723
1,988
729
1,960
730
1,68 5
734
1,659
684
1,64 8
696
1,647
676
1,63 8
700
1,631
669
1,662
634
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 20 09 20 10
Mem bers W orship A ttendance
Members and Worship Attendance
Worship attendance at FPCAH as a percentage of membership has increased from 35.4% in 2000 to 38.1% in 2010 with a peak of 43.6% in 2004.
983961 949
902
832
907
804
1 ,023
1 ,062 1 ,070 1 ,07 0
2000 200 1 20 02 20 03 2 004 20 05 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
Average PC USA Christian Education Enrollment is 111.
Christian Education Enrollment
FPCAH Christian Education Enrollment has increased from 983 in 2000 to 1,070 in 2010 despite a decline in membership.
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 33
$1 .41 $1 .44$1 .48
$1 .61
$1 .7 0$1 .74
$1 .77
$1 .6 9$1 .75 $1 .75 $1 .75
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
Average PC USA contributions in 2010 were $236,446. FPCAH contributions were $1,748,119
Total Contributions ($ in millions)
$706
$1 ,993
$714
$1 ,992
$743
$2 ,025
$821
$2 ,205
$1 ,011
$2 ,321
$1,052
$2 ,551
$1 ,074
$2,542
$1 ,026
$2 ,500
$1 ,066
$2 ,495
$1 ,071
$2,611
$1 ,052
$2,757
20 0 0 200 1 20 0 2 20 0 3 20 0 4 20 05 200 6 20 0 7 20 0 8 20 09 20 1 0
Per Mem ber C o n trib utio ns ($ ) C on trib . P er W orsh ip Atend ance ($)
The average PC USA contribution per member in 2010 was $1,122 and per worship attendee was $2,214.
Contributions per Person
FPCAH contribution per worship attendee, reflecting a more accurate picture of the giving level of active members of the church, exceeded the PC USA average and increased 38% over the last ten years
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 34
Congregational Discussions – Who are We?Following are summaries of discussion questions from congregational roundtable discussions held in July 2011 on the topics shown. These discussions addressed areas of interest from a current perspective. Comments received largely describe the “now” of our congregation. Detailed notes from each of these discussions is included in the appendix
#1: Children and Youth:
With approximately 180 people participating in the first round of congregational conversations, the members of First Pres had much to share. In many of the conversations, the question about the role of children and youth in our congregation brought forth the comment “the children are our future.” Many members of the conversations would also like the children to be an integral part of worship, either by attending with parents and being a part of Children’s Time, participating as ushers or lay liturgists, as well as having the children’s choirs participate more frequently. Several individuals that participated in this conversation recognized that more and more activities put constraints and priorities on parent’s time and children’s availability. A lot of enthusiasm was mentioned regarding Vacation Bible School, the 4:11 program, and the new Choir Camp. An area for improvement that was indicated in nearly all conversation groups is that the physical location of some of the activities in the Christian Education wing needs to be updated and made accessible for children with physical limitations. Twenty-one high school members participated in a conversation while on their week-long youth conference and most of the young people mentioned a generally positive attitude toward 4:11, the youth sports teams, and the intergenerational contacts at First Pres. Most members recognized that in order to maintain the positive energy around these programs, strong support from staff or a specific youth leader is needed.
#2: Roles of Men & Women, Families, Singles, Retirees
The question of what are the roles of men and women in the church brought forth a fair amount of discussion, though most of the members’ participating did not see one specific role for men or one specific role for women. It was noted that the church officers are generally spread equally between both men and women. The Presbyterian Women and Men’s Bible Study were each mentioned as specific groups for each gender to have a specific Bible study. When discussing the roles of different age groups in the church, much of the discussion focused on the various social groups available. Some members like that a variety of groups are available depending on the age and stage in life that a member can join. Others felt as though the groups should be more interest driven, should strive for intergenerational participation, and be less narrowly defined. The need to provide more programming or specific programming geared toward singles/young singles was mentioned in several conversations. The Connections group was mentioned as a wonderful opportunity for senior participation but that more communication about the group is needed to keep adding to its members. 4:11 is another program that has participants from all ages and both men and women, parents and non-parents, seniors and young adults all volunteer with the 4:11 program.
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 35
#3 Conflict (How are differences of opinion dealt with or resolved? What confrontational behavior is expected? What topics are taboo?)
Majority of participants agreed that we have not handled some situations well over last few years. However, some people don’t believe there has been any kind of conflict or our church has handled conflict well. This has been an emotional topic for many people in our congregation because of Rev. Jeff Deardorff’s situation and suspending the chapel service. People felt like they are in the dark due to the lack of information received and/or how the information is received. Participants mentioned that gossip or parking lot chatter drove many conflicts. People also feel like that church avoided addressing taboo topics. Also, people are frustrated that they could not voice their concerns and opinions.
“Better communication” has come up in all round table discussion groups as an action item for conflict resolution. People feel strongly that we need to be an open and transparent church, and pastoral staff should take leadership in it. Some people mentioned that they would like to have a better understanding about Session and be informed about any decision Session makes. It has come up few times that church needs to communicate decisions to the congregation and explain the reasons behind it. We agreed that people are diverse and we all have difference in our opinions. We need to learn how to respect one another and put ourselves in other’s shoe. Participants also agreed that we need to create an environment/avenue for people to feel comfortable voicing their concerns or opinions.
#4 Money (How much money are people expected to give? How is money managed and spent? Which efforts have higher priority than others? Who gets to decide how money is spent?)
We received many different suggestions and ideas on how First Presbyterian Church should manage its financial resources and what is expected from its own members. Most participants agreed that we need to continue encourage our members to pledge. Pledging from our members is important, and it enables our church to have accurate planning and budgeting. Some people mentioned that they are glad that there is no pressure on giving expected amount. On the other hand, tithing and expected giving have been mentioned several times in our discussion groups. Special commitment opportunities, where members could give to specific program/ministry, have received positive feedback during our discussions. The top issue from the discussions is that we want our church to be fiscally responsible. People also suggested that congregation would like to receive more information on budget and financial statement from our church. It would be great if it were categorized by programs/ministries and on the monthly basis. We gathered that people would like more transparency in regards to the financial aspect. Participants also suggested that we need to educate our congregation on how much money the church needs to run its operations. Most people do not have a clear idea about the maintenance costs and daily operation costs.
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 36
#5 Expectation/Relationships with Clergy (What behavior is expected of clergy? Of their families? Do congregants take advantage of them? Do we expect clergy to be everything to everybody?):
The congregation that participated in this discussion wants a strong, dynamic preacher for the Head Pastor role, someone who is charismatic with the ability to draw people in by speaking on relevant topics that touch everyday lives. There is a desire to have a pastor that is able to inspire a congregation into action so that everything does not fall on to the pastors to lead and take care of.
There was a strong agreement and theme throughout that the congregation expects too much from the pastors. It was stated several times that all pastor’s roles should be distinct and clearly defined. While people want to be able to go to pastors for empathy and direction…the congregation needs to be more willing, inspired and have more opportunity to take on more leadership roles. Many times throughout the conversations it was agreed that pastors cannot be everything to everybody. There was more of a split feeling on what the congregation expects from the pastor’s families. While some wanted to see more involvement, others stated that the pastor’s spouses are individuals on their own faith journey and need not be as present.
#6 Who is Welcome Here? (Newcomers-What behavior is expected of them? What limits are placed on their power? Are we welcoming to newcomers?):
When reviewing data on this question, there was not a lot of response as to what behavior is expected of newcomers or what limits are placed on them. There was some indication however that the church might expect newcomers to get too involved with bigger roles right away instead of easing in through smaller ones. Many members who participated in this conversation expressed a desire to bring back friendship pads as well as have name tags on officers and bring back Name Tag Sunday. Participants expressed a great approval of the welcome center stating it is essential. Some even suggested the possibility of adding another station of some sort near the Dunton entrance to connect with folks entering there.
There was a strong feeling throughout all discussion groups that we may not be as friendly and welcoming a church as we think we are. Many questioned if there was actually a process or person in charge of following up with new people long term. Those who expressed that we are a friendly church stated that we can also fall easily into cliques that can make it difficult for people to find a group to join. Across the board people agreed that it should be everyone’s job to notice and welcome newcomers, not just pastors.
#7 Worship: (Music, Preaching, Worship Sections - What is important?):
The members who participated in this conversation expressed that the music at First Presbyterian Church is the “true cornerstone”. Words like: invaluable, wonderful, great and awesome were used throughout. Many compliments to Ken Whitney and the music staff were stated. Another strong theme throughout is that the preaching must be dynamic and relevant to everyday living…not just an explanation of included scripture. People want to walk away with something that challenges them for the week.
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 37
During the congregational conversations sentiment was shared that people want more lay leadership during services with the addition of more roles for children…particularly youth. This ties in with question #5 on expectation of clergy in that the congregation feels it is essential for the preaching to” inspire the congregation into action”. People should feel motivated to serve in these capacities.
Much discussion was had on the feeling that the most recent worship schedule time change caused much disruption. There is confusion as to why we have what usually seems to be two half empty traditional services while having no contemporary service. The 8:30 service time is too early for many and having education hour at 11 has reduced it to basically nothing. Many people feel strongly that in addition to the traditional service, the church needs a contemporary service with contemporary music. It was stated that many area churches seem to be able to provide this and there is question as to why we can’t seem to provide this. There is strong feeling that there is a division at 1st Pres. between Traditional and Contemporary and that this is not productive or necessary. People commented that both service types should be able to co-exist and support each other for the better and future growth of the church.
#8 Use of Building (How is space used? How is space maintained?)
Many positive comments were made to the fact that First Presbyterian Church is a beautiful building with a lot of usable space. Many weekly groups are able to function because of this. At the same time comments were made across the board that the building lacks handicap accessibility. Comments were made on this particular defect in most every discussion.
As far as maintenance, people commented that there are many little things throughout the building that could use refreshing. Several comments were made that Fellowship Hall needs brightening and that the kitchen needs serious updating.
A proactive idea was suggested that a committee be formed to take a serious look at all these needs and come up with a list of needs and a plan to raise money to update.
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 38
Congregational Discussions – Who are we called to be?
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 39
Our second round of congregational discussions focused on the future of First Presbyterian Church. Participants in these groups were asked to give their views on what God was calling our church to be in the future. A number of themes recurred throughout ten congregational discussions of this topic. Participants in these sessions envision our church in ten to fifteen years as:
Intentionally fostering movement by all toward a closer relationship with God. Exhibiting a strong presence in the community, seen as a leader in Christian thinking, an active
community participant through service projects and other efforts, viewed as a desirable place to be. A broadly involved and empowered congregation. Always striving for relevance. Continuing to emphasize education for all including ongoing innovation. Applying visionary technology across all ministry areas. Emphasizing justice issues, seen as a “beacon for justice”. Still known for our music program, then including contemporary congregational music. Still known for our youth program, continuing to provide opportunities to hang out and “grow up
together” in the Christian faith. Diverse along multiple dimensions, including theological and worldview, demographically aligned
with our local community. Proactive in local and international mission with specific community outreach efforts. Known for family-friendly breadth of worship experience including opportunities for meditation and
quiet reflection. A church of size with critical mass and resources, including financial, for rich program diversity, while
maintaining a small church feel. Cooperative in intra and extra-denominational partnerships and interfaith activities; involved in the
Presbyterian Church USA, including transformational efforts. A thriving, welcoming, inclusive, energetic, agile, discerning, supportive, creative, contemporary,
accepting, caring, compassionate, forgiving, healing, reconciling, communicative, and fun and joy-filled family of faith.
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 40
Participants in these same discussions were also asked to describe their vision of what God called the church to do in ten to fifteen years. Some spoke in terms of what we needed to do in order to become the vision. Others focused on their sense of how best to be the church in the early 21 st century.
There were five common themes discussed when members of FPCAH were asked this question during our congregational conversations:
Mission/Outreach Worship Education Fellowship Leadership
These discussions revolved around the future of FPCAH, growth, and increasing our influence in our community and throughout the world. We realize this can only be accomplished with a gifted leader (i.e. senior pastor) at the helm. Leadership is the catalyst of the four other areas and their success. The congregation seeks a senior pastor who is a visionary and natural leader, one who is a dynamic and inspiring orator, excels at storytelling and relating his/her message to modern-day events.
Many emphasized the great importance of their worship time, wanting the options of a traditional and contemporary service, enjoying first-rate music, and seeking inspiration and joy. Many are affiliated with FPCAH for fellowship and want more opportunities to expand their friendships and relationships with those in the congregation. There’s an opportunity for us to be more welcoming to all, encouraging people to join us in fellowship, worship, outreach, and education.
Mission/outreach and education are seen as two areas of strength for First Pres that we want to continue and reinforce our focus on. Increased spiritual growth and wisdom for all members is an area of prominence and, in turn, teaching others about God’s word and love. Connecting with our community and world by serving others, giving back, and sharing God’s love is an inspirational focal point at FPCAH that can grow and impact more lives.
Transcribed notes from all congregational discussion groups are included in the appendices to this report.
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 41
Groups, Ministries and Activities
First Presbyterian Church has a long standing tradition of having groups available for church members of all ages and interests. These include social groups, fellowship groups, Bible study groups, Commune groups, musical groups and mission opportunities. The groups and opportunities available meet the needs of children through adults of all ages. They provide fellowship, spiritual growth, opportunities for service, social connections and worship enhancement. Many of the groups have been in place for several years, while some are new in 2011. They can also change, grow and follow with members as they go through new phases in life.
The groups at First Pres have always been an invitation for church members to make friends, grow in their faith and live out ministry callings. Through these experiences church members discover gifts and talents and engage with their church community. More than just a beautiful building, the church is people bound together like a family in and outside its walls. Having opportunities available to members of the church allows this bond to form between individuals of all generations.
Music opportunities are a response to worshipping God. Music is also a way to pray and fully participate in the worship service. There are many opportunities for people of all ages to join a variety of choirs. Service and mission groups provide an opportunity for people to share Christ’s love while serving others. Social and fellowship groups connect people and deepen friendships.
First Presbyterian Church has between 20-30 groups at any given time. This number can fluctuate with the season and is always evolving. When someone at First Pres has an idea for a group they are welcome to pursue the opportunity to make it come alive! Our groups arise out of the needs of church and community members with God lighting the path.
Children, Youth and Senior High also have many opportunities in 4:11 (from 1 John 4:11), mission trips and choir. There are social, fellowship, service and spiritual groups for young adults, singles, young families, families with older children, and on up through all generations of the church.
The appendix includes a representative listing of groups, ministries and other activities at First Presbyterian.
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 42
Office and Person of the Pastor
Our congregation has benefited from the excellent preaching strengths of many senior and associate pastors. As the most broadly visible aspect of the senior pastor, this strength also scores very highly in our congregational survey and gets frequent mention in our roundtable discussions. Presbyterians have long valued the depth of biblical and contemporary content in sermons, which are often models for public speaking, and First Pres is no exception. It is considered important for these weekly messages to reinforce the breadth of our Christian practice. Specifics mentioned by members include:
Inspire to action Communicate biblical messages with an appreciation for the role the Bible plays in our faith, yet mindful
of “How should this affect my thought and behavior in the coming week”. Communicate relevance, incorporating scripture as it relates to the issue(s) of our time. Deliver comfortably in traditional, contemporary, and emerging worship formats.
However, the role of the pastor, especially the senior pastor, goes well beyond sermon delivery. The pastor’s message of Christian practice should extend outside the walls of the sanctuary through both community involvement and modern technology.
Involvement with the Presbytery and larger denomination are also important. Ours is a connectional church, and while that remains one of our strengths, many new Presbyterians don’t recognize this. All pastors, especially the senior pastor, are encouraged both to participate in denomination leadership activities and to foster member involvement in similar activities including multi-church cooperative efforts.
As Head of Staff, the pastor generally practices collegial decision-making with occasional needs to be the executive decision maker. Good ministry managers are mentors and advocates for their clergy colleagues and elicit the best from all.
As Session Moderator, the pastor gives voice to all and fosters wise group decision making while being mindful of the agenda and schedule. Session and other congregational group leadership brings out the best of Presbyterian governance and builds a cadre of engaged church lay leaders.
Other attributes and items mentioned in discussion groups include:
Conflict resolution skills Approachability by all Mission focus Education advocacy Congregational care team building with hands-on involvement as needed A touch of personal counseling when called for Recognition of the importance of the pastor’s personal growth and career development Understanding that pastors’ families have lives and careers of their own, they are welcomed into
whatever level of participation in the life of the church they find appropriate.
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 43
Appendices
Demographic Statistics
Congregational Survey Results, Questions 1-60
Round Table Discussion Notes: Who are we?
Round Table Discussion Notes: What are we called to be and to do?
Listing of Groups, Opportunities, and Ministries
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 44
Demographic Statistics
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 45
Comparisons of US, Illinois, Arlington Heights, and First Presbyterian Church
from various sources
Demographic Data USA IllinoisArlington Heights ACS
FPCAH ACS %
FPCAH Survey
Population 2010308,745,53
812,830,63
2 75,101
1,949
Population 2000281,424,60
212,419,65
8 76,031Persons under 5 years old, percent, 2009 6.90% 6.90% 7.10% 151 7.7%Persons under 18 years old, percent, 2009 24.30% 24.60% 23.90% 383 19.7%Persons 65 years old and over, percent, 2009 12.90% 12.40% 16.70% 397 20.4% 53%Female persons, percent, 2009 50.70% 50.70% 52.30% 55.5% 61%
White persons, percent, 2010 72.40% 71.50% 88.20% 98%Black persons, percent, 2010 12.60% 14.50% 1.30%American Indian and Alaska Native persons, percent, 2010 0.90% 0.30% 0.10%Asian persons, percent, 2010 4.80% 4.60% 7.10% 1%Native Hawaiian and Other Pacific Islander, percent, 2010 0.20% 0.00% 0.00%Persons reporting two or more races, percent, 2010 2.90% 2.30% 1.50%Persons of Hispanic or Latino origin, percent, 2010 16.30% 15.80% 5.70%White persons not Hispanic, persons, 2010 63.70% 63.70%
Living in same house 1 year ago, pct 1 yr old & over, 2005-2009 83.80% 85.50% 60.60%Foreign born persons, percent, 2005-2009 12.40% 13.40% 17.00% 3%Language other than English spoken at home, pct age 5+, 2005-2009 19.60% 21.30% 22.10%High school graduates, percent of persons age 25+, 2005-2009 84.60% 85.70% 94.40%Bachelor's degree or higher, pct of persons age 25+, 2005-2009 27.50% 29.80% 50.40% 78%Veterans, 2005-2009 22,894,578 811,879 4,439Mean travel time to work (minutes), workers age 16+, 2005-2009 25.2 28.1 28
Housing units, 2009129,969,65
3 5,292,016 30,506Homeownership rate, 2005-2009 66.90% 69.30% 78.00%Housing units in multi-unit structures, percent, 2005-2009 25.90% 33.20%Median value of owner-occupied housing units, 2005-2009 $185,400 $200,400 $372,300
Households, 2005-2009112,611,02
9 4,749,388 28,746Persons per household, 2005-2009 2.6 2.62 2.52 2.28Per capita money income in past 12 months (2009 dollars) 2005-2009 $27,041 $28,469 $39,973 Median household income, 2009 $50,221 $53,974 $78,765 Persons below poverty level, percent, 2009 14.30% 13.30% 3.60%
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 46
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 47
Congregational Life Survey
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 48
Results for Questions 1-60Completed by Members and Worshipers
at First Presbyterian ChurchJune - July 2011
US Congregational Life SurveyFIRST PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH 637 total responses.ARLINGTON HEIGHTS, ILLINOIS
ID Number: V567
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 49
You and Your Congregation
1. How often do you go to worship services at this congregation?
0% This is my first time7% Hardly ever or special occasions only7% Less than once a month7% Once a month
19% Two or three times a month55% Usually every week
4% More than once a week
2. How long have you been going to worship services or activities at this congregation?
2% Less than 1 year3% 1-2 years9% 3-5 years
16% 6-10 years20% 11-20 years49% More than 20 years<1% I am visiting from another congregation<1% I am visiting and do not regularly go anywhere else
3. Are you currently a member of this congregation?
95% Yes<1% No, but I'm in the process of becoming a member
3% No, but I regularly participate here2% No
4. Are you regularly involved in any group activities here? (Mark all that apply.)
18% Yes, in Sunday school, church school, or Sabbath school
28% Yes, in prayer, discussion, or Bible study groups35% Yes, in fellowships, clubs, or other social groups
7% No, we have no group activities39% No, I am not regularly involved in group activities
5. Do you regularly take part in any activities of this congregation that reach out to the wider community (visitation, evangelism, outreach, community service, social justice)? (Mark all that apply.)
15% Yes, in evangelism or outreach activities33% Yes, in community service, social justice, or
advocacy activities of this congregation6% No, we don't have such activities
54% No, I am not regularly involved
6. Do you currently have any of the following roles here? (Mark all that apply.)
8% Member of the governing board14% Member of a congregational committee or task force
3% Leading or assisting in worship10% Officer or leader of men's, women's, youth, or other
group14% Choir member, musician, or choir director
6% Sunday school, church school, or Sabbath school teacher
13% Other role not listed here53% None
7. To what extent do the worship services or activities of this congregation help you with everyday living?
34% A great extent44% Some extent17% A small extent
5% Not at all
About Your Faith
8. How often do you spend time in private devotional activities (such as prayer, meditation, reading the Bible alone)?
37% Every day or most days19% A few times a week
6% Once a week25% Occasionally11% Hardly ever
3% Never
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 50
US Congregational Life SurveyFIRST PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH 637 total responses.ARLINGTON HEIGHTS, ILLINOIS
ID Number: V567
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 51
9. Over the last year, how much have you grown in your faith? (Mark only one.)
20% No real growth49% Some growth18% Much growth, mainly through this congregation
5% Much growth, mainly through other groups or congregations
8% Much growth, mainly through my own private activities
10. Which statement comes closest to your view of theBible? (Mark only one.)
7% The Bible is the word of God, to be taken literally word for word
47% The Bible is the word of God, to be interpreted in the light of its historical context and the Church's teachings
34% The Bible is the word of God, to be interpreted in the light of its historical and cultural context
7% The Bible is not the word of God, but contains God's word to us
3% The Bible is not the word of God, but is a valuable book
<1% The Bible is an ancient book with little value today2% Don't know
11. Do you agree or disagree with this statement: "All the different religions are equally good ways of helping a person find ultimate truth"?
9% Strongly agree35% Agree24% Neutral or unsure25% Disagree
7% Strongly disagree
12. Do you agree or disagree: "My spiritual needs are being met in this congregation or parish"?
11% Strongly agree46% Agree27% Neutral or unsure13% Disagree
3% Strongly disagree
13. Which one of the following best describes your readiness to talk to others about your faith? (Mark only one.)
<1% I do not have faith, so the question is not applicable19% I do not talk about my faith; my life and actions are
sufficient19% I find it hard to talk about my faith in ordinary
language55% I mostly feel at ease talking about my faith and do
so if it comes up8% I feel at ease talking about my faith and seek
opportunities to do so
14. Have you ever had a conversion experience or a moment of decisive faith commitment?
38% Yes42% No20% Not sure
About Your Involvement
15. Are you involved in any community service, social service, or advocacy groups not connected to this congregation? (Mark all that apply.)
42% Yes, social service or charity groups7% Yes, advocacy, justice, or lobbying groups
56% No, I'm not involved with such groups
16. Would you be prepared to invite to a worship service here any of your friends and relatives who do not now attend a congregation?
26% Yes, and I have done so in the past 12 months50% Yes, but I have not done so in the past 12 months17% No, probably not
2% No, definitely not5% Don't know
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 52
US Congregational Life SurveyFIRST PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH 637 total responses.ARLINGTON HEIGHTS, ILLINOIS
ID Number: V567
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 53
17. In the past 12 months, have you done any of the following? (Mark all that apply.)
13% Loaned money to someone outside your family17% Cared for someone outside your family who was
very sick17% Helped someone outside your family find a job54% Donated or prepared food for someone outside your
family or congregation90% Will vote or did vote in the 2008 presidential election87% Donated money to a charitable organization (other
than this congregation)18% Worked with others to try to solve a community
problem27% Contacted an elected official about a public issue22% Contributed money to a political party or candidate16% Spoke at a decision-making meeting of this
congregation13% Went on a mission or service trip
18. How satisfied are you with what is offered here for children and youth (less than 19 years of age)?
21% Very satisfied38% Satisfied15% Mixed feelings
1% Dissatisfied<1% Very dissatisfied25% Not sure or not applicable
19. Do you have any close friends in this congregation?
10% No, I have little contact with others from this congregation outside of activities here
22% No, I have some friends in this congregation, but my closest friends are not involved here
58% Yes, I have some close friends here as well as other close friends who are not part of this congregation
10% Yes, most of my closest friends are part of this congregation
20. Does this congregation have a clear vision, goals, or direction for its ministry and mission?
22% I am not aware of such a vision, goals, or direction39% There are ideas but no clear vision, goals, or
direction17% Yes, and I am strongly committed to them17% Yes, and I am partly committed to them
5% Yes, but I am not committed to them
21. Which one statement best describes your involvement in the making of important decisions in this congregation?
13% I have been given the opportunity and often participate in decision-making
28% I have been given the opportunity and occasionally get involved in decision-making
26% I have been given the opportunity but don't usually get involved in decision-making
25% I have not been given an opportunity to be involved and this is fine with me
8% I have not been given an opportunity to be involved and I am not happy about this
22. Do you have a strong sense of belonging to this congregation?
17% Yes, a strong sense of belonging that is growing28% Yes, a strong sense--about the same as last year36% Yes, but perhaps not as strong as in the past
3% No, but I am new here8% No, and I wish I did by now7% No, but I am happy as I am1% Not applicable
23. While you may value many different styles of music, which two of the following do you prefer in congregational worship? (Mark up to two.)
80% Traditional hymns19% Praise music or choruses25% Contemporary hymns13% Other contemporary music or songs (not hymns)
1% Sung responsorial psalms28% Classical music or chorales
2% Contemplative chants (Taizé, Iona)7% Music or songs from a variety of cultures
13% Gospel music<1% No music or songs<1% Don't know
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 54
US Congregational Life SurveyFIRST PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH 637 total responses.ARLINGTON HEIGHTS, ILLINOIS
ID Number: V567
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 55
24. Do you agree or disagree: "In general, there is a good match between our congregation and our minister, pastor, priest, or rabbi"?
3% Strongly agree13% Agree11% Neutral or unsure
3% Disagree1% Strongly disagree
69% There is currently no leader here
25. Which of the following aspects of this congregation do you personally most value? (Mark up to three.)
20% Wider community care or social justice emphasis4% Reaching those who do not attend church
65% Traditional style of worship or music15% Contemporary style of worship or music29% Sharing in Holy Communion, Eucharist, or the
Lord's Supper21% Social activities or meeting new people40% Sermons, preaching, or homilies18% Bible study or prayer groups, other discussion
groups29% Ministry for children or youth
5% Prayer ministry for one another16% Practical care for one another in times of need
3% The congregation's school or pre-school6% Openness to social diversity5% Adult church-school or Sabbath-school classes
26. Before you started coming to this congregation, were you participating in another congregation?
14% No, I've come here for most or all of my life14% No, before coming here I had not been attending
any congregation for several years5% No, before coming here I had never regularly
attended67% Yes, immediately prior to coming here, I was
participating in another congregation
27. Before you started coming here, what type of congregation did you attend? (Mark only one.)
<1% Assembly of God2% Baptist4% Catholic1% Episcopal5% Lutheran
14% Methodist0% Nazarene4% Non-denominational
<1% Pentecostal49% Presbyterian
0% Seventh-day Adventist8% United Church of Christ6% Other9% I did not attend another congregation before coming
here
About You
28. Age of worshipers:
6% 15-2412% 25-4430% 45-6453% 65 and above
29. Gender of worshipers:
61% Female39% Male
30. What is your employment status? (Mark all that apply.)
29% Employed or self-employed full-time13% Employed or self-employed part-time
2% Unemployed48% Retired
8% Full-time homemaker4% Student1% Other
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 56
US Congregational Life SurveyFIRST PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH 637 total responses.ARLINGTON HEIGHTS, ILLINOIS
ID Number: V567
31. What is the highest educational level you have completed? (reported for worshipers age 25 and older)
0% No formal schooling<1% Primary school through 8th grade (K-8)
1% Some high school12% Completed high school
2% Trade certificate7% Associate degree
44% Bachelor's degree from a university or college34% Master's, Doctorate, or other graduate degree
32. What is your present marital status?
12% Never married60% In first marriage
7% Remarried after divorce1% Remarried after death of spouse1% Living in a committed relationship
<1% Separated5% Divorced
13% Widowed
33. Do you have a spouse or partner who is also completing a survey here?
55% Yes45% No
34. What is your race or origin? (Mark all that apply.)
1% Asian or Pacific Islander<1% Black or African American<1% Hispanic, Latino, or Spanish origin
0% Indian (American) or Alaska Native98% White or Caucasian
1% Some other race
35. Where were you born?
97% In the United States1% In another English-speaking country2% In a non-English-speaking country
36. Where were your parents born?
90% Both born in the United States2% Only father born in the United States2% Only mother born in the United States6% Both father and mother born in another country
37. Where did you live when you were 5 years old?
98% In the United States2% In another country
38. When you were 5 years old, was English your primary language?
98% Yes2% No
39. Which statement best describes the people who currently live in your household?
20% I live alone42% A couple without children
4% One adult with child/children29% Two or more adults with child/children
6% Some adults living in the same household
40. Most often reported ZIP codes of worshipers:
33% 6000422% 600058% 600676% 600564% 600743% 600893% 600072% 600082% 600102% 60070
41. About how much do you give financially to this congregation?
9% I give 10% or more of net income regularly34% I give about 5% to 9% of net income regularly40% I give less than 5% of net income regularly11% I give a small amount whenever I am here
5% I do not contribute financially here
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 57
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 58
US Congregational Life SurveyFIRST PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH 637 total responses.ARLINGTON HEIGHTS, ILLINOIS
ID Number: V567
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 59
42. Which of the following describes your total annual household income before taxes?
2% Less than $10,0007% $10,000 to $24,999
15% $25,000 to $49,99921% $50,000 to $74,99915% $75,000 to $99,99911% $100,000 to $124,999
7% $125,000 to $149,99921% $150,000 or more
43. Respondents with at least one household member: (adjusted for multiple responses per household)
6% Less than 6 years old12% 6 to 12 years old17% 13 to 18 years old13% 19 to 24 years old99% 25 years old or older
44. Respondents with at least one household member participating here: (adjusted for multiple responses per household)
6% Less than 6 years old12% 6 to 12 years old17% 13 to 18 years old
9% 19 to 24 years old97% 25 years old or older
45. How many children of any age do you have, whether they live at home or elsewhere? (adjusted for multiple responses per household)
20% None9% One
39% Two23% Three
9% Four or more
46. How many of your children of any age live at home with you? (adjusted for multiple responses per household)
72% None12% One12% Two
4% Three<1% Four or more
Some Final Questions
47. How long does it usually take you to get here?
20% 1-5 minutes32% 6-10 minutes23% 11-15 minutes14% 16-20 minutes
8% 21-30 minutes4% More than 30 minutes
48. Compared to 2 years ago, do you think you participate in activities of the congregation more, less, or about the same amount as you did then?
17% Participate more44% About the same participation38% Participate less
2% Not applicable (been coming less than 2 years)
49. Have this congregation's leaders encouraged you to find and use your gifts and skills here?
19% Yes, to a great extent31% Yes, to some extent24% Yes, to a small extent18% Not at all
8% Don't know
50. How often do you experience the following during worship services at this congregation? (Always or Usually)
55% A sense of God's presence46% Inspiration
9% Boredom9% Awe or mystery
47% Joy7% Frustration
11% Spontaneity47% A sense of fulfilling my obligation
51. Do you agree or disagree: "Only followers of JesusChrist can be saved"?
12% Strongly agree22% Agree24% Neutral or unsure30% Disagree13% Strongly disagree
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 60
“Who Are We?” Notes
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 61
US Congregational Life SurveyFIRST PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH 637 total responses.ARLINGTON HEIGHTS, ILLINOIS
ID Number: V567
52. Do you agree or disagree: "I have a sense of excitement about our congregation's future"?
11% Strongly agree30% Agree46% Neutral or unsure10% Disagree
3% Strongly disagree
53. Over the last two years, has there been any conflict in this congregation? (Mark only one.)
9% No conflict that I am aware of29% Some minor conflict14% Major conflict33% Major conflict, with leaders or people leaving14% Don't know
54. Of the following, which one best describes your opinion of the future directions of this congregation?
5% We need to get back to the way we did things in the past
2% We are faithfully maintaining past directions42% We are currently deciding on new directions
8% We are currently moving in new directions18% We need to rethink where we are heading14% Our future is very unclear or doubtful11% Don't know
55. Do you agree or disagree: "This congregation is always ready to try something new"?
2% Strongly agree25% Agree47% Neutral or unsure22% Disagree
5% Strongly disagree
56. To what extent does the minister, pastor, or priest here take into account the ideas of those who worship here?
3% A great extent8% Some extent3% A small extent1% Not at all8% Don't know
77% There is currently no leader here
57. Which of the following is the best description of the style of leadership of your pastor, minister, or priest?
1% Leadership that tends to take charge4% Leadership that inspires people to take action4% Leadership that acts on goals that people here have
been involved in setting<1% Leadership where the people start most things80% There is currently no leader here11% Don't know
58. Do you agree or disagree: "God is directly involved in worldly affairs"?
21% Strongly agree37% Agree30% Neutral or unsure
9% Disagree3% Strongly disagree
<1% I don't believe in God
59. Do you agree or disagree: "God is angered by human sin"?
14% Strongly agree40% Agree31% Neutral or unsure10% Disagree
4% Strongly disagree<1% I don't believe in God
60. Which of the following terms best describes your current stand on theological issues?
6% Very conservative37% Conservative34% Right in the middle18% Liberal
4% Very liberal
For questions with multiple responses possible, percentages usually total well over 100. On other questions, totals may not equal 100 due to rounding.
7/24 8:30 am, Teri w/Carrie, 9 participants 7/24 10 am, Teri, 10 participants mixed age
7/26 2 pm, Teri, mature,12 participants
7/24 Aaron 10 participants
7/24 Buzz, notes from 2 groupsCh
ildre
n an
d Yo
uth
Situated off in the corner; help them feel welcome; not exclusionary viewed; help make them part of the process – use them as ushers, lay liturgists so they can “have a buy in”
Good to have a fun space togetherInclusive of children in lots of what we doDo their own thing – most teenagers want space apart from parentsGlad kids have a place to hang out that is within the churchCan make friends from other schools; separated from cliquesLearning useful skills hereMeaningful participationYouth spaces are great; children areas are less than ideal, not handicap
accessibleCommunication needs work for children's programs/Sunday
school/Kingdom activities Across the board impressed with VBS and the communication regarding
VBSLots of communication already thereEnergy from VBS; need to continue it throughout the year;
physical space inadequate
crowdednon-handicapped
accessibleparking lot purchase vs.
building stage #2 …WHY?
Choir Sunday no children were recognized…WHY?
should participate in worship and be in worship with family
could be collectors of offerings
they need to feel part of church
children’s choir more often
music must be funneeds of children have
changed-activities compete for time
children are not always tolerated
other times children are welcome
children used to be expected to be in worship with families and this promoted children’s growth
8:30 is too early for parents
children are not always valued
contemporary service seemed to welcome children more than traditional
facilities are goodfacilities are accessiblegood reports on 4:11
program
are the foundation of our faithThere’s a great need to figure a way
to get/keep our young adults (18-30) involved in some way. Capture their interest somehow.
Need to modernize and update the kingdom area and rooms. Comments: dingy, dirty yellow bricks, need colorful inviting rooms.
hire a very capable youth leader to motivate and attract excitement/interest
Pastor needs to be able to relate to our young. He/she needs a broad range of interests. A more contemporary minister
*** Bring the children back into the sanctuary and be involved in service with adults. At the very least part of the time. Balance with the Chapel service.*** THIS WAS IMPORTANT TO BOTH SESSIONS
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 62
7/24 8:30 am, Teri w/Carrie, 9 participants 7/24 10 am, Teri, 10 participants mixed age
7/26 2 pm, Teri, mature,12 participants
7/24 Aaron 10 participants
7/24 Buzz, notes from 2 groupsM
en &
wom
en
Connections did a fabulous job with helping for the Rummage SaleSeniors – feel they have value “they’re a rocking here!”Seniors work with youth wonderfullyCommunicants and Shepherds– multigenerational, needs to be more
widely known about thisConnections needs better publicity; not everyone know who/what they doFamilies – get to know each other through KingdomSingles probably needs more effort – need church organization in pulling it
together and getting committedFamily things are pretty self-organizedBack in the day, there was a huge singles group at 4th Pres. Church
downtown and many of them attend here today as couples that met/formed from that singles group
Families have shared interest – easier to get together; singles don’t necessarily have that connection
Age Categories – where do we go from here? How do we define groups, The Bridge, Young Adults, PTL,
Should be with your age and with your stage in lifeFit with the program for where you are in life
Women’s groups are very much involved/flowers/cleaning/worship, etc.
responsibilities should not be restricted to “sex”
miss men’s group activities
roles of men and women are equitable/balanced…both have opportunities to serve
ages and skills are recognized
First Forum was a plusabsence of officers
attending First Forum
singles do not have enough attention
in past, singles programs attracted members
do not like organization by men/woman, single/married, age
groups should be more interest driven
do not define groups narrowly
activities should be oriented around purpose and mission
should strive for intergenerational
inclusive of retireesseniors and parents both
need emergency backup programs
too pastor dependent when caring for members
need follow ups for absent members
need a 24 hour contact at church
Number of women and men on session and trustees is relatively equal. Less so on Deacons. Stereotyped as women's service.
concern that ordination standards in Presbytery have changed allowing and promoting gays and lesbians in leadership positions
Provide child care for those mostly mothers, who cannot attend early evening meetings due to taking care of family and/or young children. No time to get over to church.
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 63
7/24 8:30 am, Teri w/Carrie, 9 participants 7/24 10 am, Teri, 10 participants mixed age
7/26 2 pm, Teri, mature,12 participants
7/24 Aaron 10 participants
7/24 Buzz, notes from 2 groupsCo
nflic
t
No good process to bring out conflict or resolve itAgree that people have different opinions and go forward even if people
possibly disagree but need to recognize the difference in opinion, make the decision the put it to an end;
Never going to have 100% consensusDon’t always understand other pieces of puzzle, which leads to conflictMake decisions for the group as a whole, rather than individual members –
can lead to conflictPeople want to feel like your voice should be heard then can accept the
decisionGreat example – glad we are doing roundtablesLots of emotion with in a churchMake decision and why that decision is made vs. best intentions but little
to no explanationNot huge issue but can be improvedOpenness and explaining the why is key to conflict resolutionSession is an open body – put ideas on the table very clearly; use logic and
transparency in their decision making, more people should be reminded that Session is open for all to attend
Too much holding onto angst/backroom chatterSession may operate clearly but whole church may not get the whole
pictureCongregation can be more engaged w/Session minutes/attendance;
Session could also proactively give out infoPeople need to see processCommunication important to both directionsHR issues are private
most trouble is hidden; there is a lack of transparency people are confused unless they are on a committee
no topics are really taboo
conflict not handled well here
only loudest voices are heard
differences needed to be talked through
next pastor needs background and expertise in conflict management
volunteers on lists are not being called because they are “blackballed”
Who is in charge of what?
lack of accountabilityGood that worship time
was taken to fill out surveys
like MSTF roundtable time
need more opportunities to express opinions
need strong leaders
difference is not resolved just avoided
should address issue directly to person
session needs an emailsession leaves us outdon’t know who is on
deacons/trustees/session
once a year list is not efficient
session is not on websitePresbytery lawsuit is
taboomany are only concerned
about own church and not good of the whole church
difference of opinions not always tolerated such as opinions about pastors
"Address it, stoke" Up to Pastors to bring conflicted issues to the surface so they can be resolved.
Share info among all groups. Many members feel in the dark about issues/problems that arise. COMMUNICATE BETTER
Bring problems to membership, discuss what is going on with situations/conflicts
Bring back the parish system led in each case by a deacon or elder.
what is being addressed from the pulpit
Avoid gossip. Need more transparency.
Be more open with congregation. No hidden information
Members are too cliquish. Same groups sit with one another each Sunday. Others not included.
A need for a church ombudsman or liaison between pastors and congregation. Someone people can feel comfortable going to...as opposed to being nervous about talking to leaders about concerns.
Who to go to if a member has a problem with a pastor?
Again, what happened to Parish system? Personal visits by Deacons/elders/trustees or others to people in parish. Used to be twice a year
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 64
7/24 8:30 am, Teri w/Carrie, 9 participants 7/24 10 am, Teri, 10 participants mixed age
7/26 2 pm, Teri, mature,12 participants
7/24 Aaron 10 participants
7/24 Buzz, notes from 2 groupsM
oney
Extra Commitment Opportunities beyond the regular pledge is a fantastic idea; allows people to see what else needs to be done, if we have the money; leads to more money for specific projects
Give more specifics on budgetTrustees decide how money spent; they do the balancing; have the
perspectivesNeed to keep in mind that Church is the congregation as opposed to a
business relationship More transparency is goodMore willing to support if see the transparencyCould do more specific things – again the extra commitment opportunitiesImportant to know costs to run the whole churchNeed to feel part of it & know what it costs to get the church together
there is no expected amount to give and that is a good thing
there is a perception that the sanctuary takes precedence over all else
session and trustees decide where money goes
age of officers deciding may influence decisions
most elders and trustees are older
officers (netted?) according to how much money the candidate pledged
Nominating Committee-vetted has to do with pledging, not amount
regular giving should be part of being an officer
education and music are priorities
like leadership from within the church
needs are met when issues are raised, for example, roof, A/C
need new blood with new ideas on committees
Please do not go into debt
At present, there is no doubt
Conservative; we spend money wisely
Expected giving – all should participate
Confidentiality on giving dollars by individuals is good
Communication of budget and needs is important
We do not stress tithe
Presbytery control questioned
Pledging is very important for planning budget.
setup pledging on lineWe’re weak on mission in our "own
backyard". Need to spend more $ closer to home where there is great need also.
Identify the amount of money spent on missions
take credit more for what our dollars do for mission
Focus on why we give.
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 65
7/24 8:30 am, Teri w/Carrie, 9 participants 7/24 10 am, Teri, 10 participants mixed age
7/26 2 pm, Teri, mature,12 participants
7/24 Aaron 10 participants
7/24 Buzz, notes from 2 groupsEx
pect
ation
s of/
rela
tions
with
cler
gy
Each minister has/had a set roleEach should be open to talk with individual membersPastors can be spread too thinCongregation relies on clergy too much – should have more lay people
involvedActive visible present members; members have a special gift within
themselves that clergy can help bring out; Pastors need to ask!All members have a ministryDo a better job with respecting pastor’s time including their days off and
during their working hoursNeed a Sabbath for the pastorsOur church has been lucky with its long tenure from recent associates; it’s
been a blessing to have them so long; educate members how rare our situation was; the average term for a senior pastor is 8 years
Change provides opportunities for growthSeeking what God wants us to do in time of new leadershipWant a strong Teacher, Message from the Pastor
like pastors that you can talk to and relate to
need to be sincere and approachable
we expect too much from our pastors
having a relationship with the pastors brings meaning to the service
they need to be strong biblically
They need to be strong preachers
nice when then remember names
nice when then bring and teach the message
it is important for the families of clergy to be involved and attend services
clergy should relate to all/have a connection
clergy DO NOT need to run everything
should inspire congregation into action
can be everything to everybody but should not have to do everything for everybody
associate pastors need clearly defined roles
everything to everybody-yes
need role descriptionspriorities for each
positionpassion for faith and
expresses itcharismaticdifferent giftsHead pastor needs to be
a preacher!need more volunteers to
support pastors and programs
someone who loves people
needs to instill love of God
should be a shepherd
To be “all things to all people”
Participate in events (spouses too)
Be fantastic preachers, leaders, etc.
Become involved when possible; exposure to all groups
head pastor should be the conflict resolver
All pastors need to preach about today's events in the world. Make sermons relate to issues of the day. People go on Sundays and want to hear wisdom and words about today's problems that affect their lives.
We need at least 3 pastors.Head pastor has to be well rounded
person and good leaderDYNAMIC SPEAKER - HEAD PASTOR!!Head pastor should have close
relationship with congregants.Head pastor should have control of
staff, good control of church, and communicate well, know what is going on in church.
he needs to establish a friendly and nurturing philosophy
The clergy sets the tone of the Church!!
Pastor should know the Bible, and imparts a message each Sunday we Will remember.
Clergy needs to be approachable and empathetic.
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 66
7/24 8:30 am, Teri w/Carrie, 9 participants 7/24 10 am, Teri, 10 participants mixed age
7/26 2 pm, Teri, mature,12 participants
7/24 Aaron 10 participants
7/24 Buzz, notes from 2 groupsW
ho is
wel
com
e
Very friendly but need connectionsFriendship pads – coming back Yea!Chapel had name tags for a whileName Tag Sunday should be brought backOfficers should wear their officer name badges, opportunity to step up
during this transition timeBe approachableFlexible – some visitors just want to visit; others want to be greeted and
welcomed and engagedGreeters need to clue in to who may be visiting, needs assistanceMost people don’t view our church as pushy, we’re adaptable Get New Members class connected to groups works well – the Liz
Armstrong model of involvement; great custom with room for improvement
Able to connect even in transition time; may be a challengeGood with checking in but don’t want to overwhelm; can lead to
uncomfortable situations and awkwardness; some just want to participate or just attend
Follow up procedures for New Members? Is this happening; is it workingNew Christians – not everyone familiar with the Service; hand a Hymnal to
your neighbor if they seem confused; people new in their faith might t appreciate guidance; might add to the new member class some information on the actual service
What happened to Ambassadors of Christ?
we rely too much on surface stuff to attract people
there is no follow up here
reputation of not being friendly
bringing back friendship pads is a great idea
Takes a while for newcomers to find a niche
need to welcome people through people not programs or things
be more welcoming to children and youth
need to move process of getting new pastors along so we will attract new people
we are not good at welcoming new people
need follow up with new ones
there is a built in unfriendliness
Very homogenous/socio economic, age, etc.
new people need to weave through groups of people in the Narthex in order to get to the 10:30 service…can be intimidating
there are many clicksnew ideas get stifledwant attendance pad
back
Not all are welcomeOn first visit was
greeted warmlyFriendship pads are
importantWelcome Center is
vitalNew member class is
informative and brings awareness of opportunities / follow-up is necessary
Homeless worship – do we accept them?
We are not welcoming as a Church!!Head Pastor should be more
welcoming from the pulpit.What happened to the
friendship pads/booklets that used to be passed down the pew at each service??
We need a much warmer greeting of everyone at the front and side doors.
Greet and talk to the people next to you, in front and behind. We used to do this as lead from the pulpit, but no more.
we don't have enough extended families in church
Needed to shake hands more with current and newer people
Pass "peace of Christ"Change the mechanics of welcoming
in our churchNeed more members involved in
welcomingPastor should walk up and down the
aisle before and after service, greeting people
INVOLVE YOUTH IN SERVICES. Contemporary and traditional services separate groups!
Need dynamic exciting sermons
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 67
7/24 8:30 am, Teri w/Carrie, 9 participants 7/24 10 am, Teri, 10 participants mixed age
7/26 2 pm, Teri, mature,12 participants
7/24 Aaron 10 participants
7/24 Buzz, notes from 2 groupsW
orsh
ip
Wonderful music – great staff on the music; music is a true corner stoneConcerts/outside groups for the music are greatMiss the chapel service – family values the contemporary worship
service/informal styleWant to bring the Chapel service but with real permanenceTough to meet all the needs of all the peopleSome have noticed a feeling of some members needs met for some time,
and then some other groups of members needs met following a changeMusic at this church is awesome in all modesDiverse group of membersToo many styles into 1 service results in nothing – doesn’t work, lose both
stylesStrong Preacher/Teacher key to worship; it’s the primary take away from
Sunday morningBalance talents of the pastors within the serviceStrength in the past to understanding of today to make sermons/prayers
current and relevantFor many people the last straw was moving the service times; seem to be
losing people or losing attendance at 8:30 service; it’s just too early; complaining with their feet;
Critical Mass – need to change up services in summer; half empty sanctuary doesn’t feel right or look right to visitors
Great with the whole service having one theme from the prayers to the sermon, the Scripture, worship bags, the hymns all tied together well
So glad the worship bags were promoted and explained in children’s time
contemporary music and service is a MUST
need to focus more on new members
have one traditional space/music and one contemporary space/music done in many other churches with no problem
need preacher for sermon
should deal with current ways to deal with things going on the world
need varietycongregation needs to be
challengeddo not emphasize
material thingswant communion more
oftencontemporary* (+define)more lay participation
neededmore lay readers
Music in generalChildren’s message is
importantVisitors view –
“church is not evangelical”
Meaning of “evangelical”?
Need a more modern hymnal
Incorporate young people in serviceDon't let the separate services
(traditional/contemporary) divide the church
Do we need 2 traditional services???Baptisms should be
warmer/friendlier. Include young people in the front to see what's going on.
Sermons RELEVANCE
Use
of b
uild
ing
Space/Building FacilitiesNeed renovations but it’s all dependant on the moneyMaintained as good as it can beWork on accessibility issuesShort term vs. long term needsNeed more capitalNot everyone has a church site of this size; the great gym is an assetIt’s functioning todayMoney and transparency can accomplish some goals as evidenced by the
parking lot acquisitionPeople willing to invest in a planCompared to others a very nice place but needs upgrades
have one traditional space/music and one contemporary space/music done in many other churches with no problem
need better accessibility for Men’s Bible Study (older adults)
1 traditional and 1 contemporary will relieve parking
Not conveniently located but I still come
Central locationSignificant structurePhysical limitations –
aging and youth (Vail Street)
Parking lot needs more lighting
Dutton Street parking too many steps
NEED NEW KITCHENFix up Fellowship HallIssue of stairs. Make handicapped
accessible.Upkeep of older buildingsNeed 10 year and 20 year plans.
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 68
7/24 Luke w/Kristi DeBoer, 10 participants
7/24 10 am, Carrie w/Jeff, 10 participants 7/24 10 am, Jody w/Tom, 9 participants 7/26 Montreat, Chuck w/Mike N,21 youth/4 adults
7/13, MSTF group
Child
ren
and
Yout
h
Our best strength is the programming for our children and youth
Children and youth should be the priority for our church
We need to change few things on Sunday morning in order to keep kids engaged:
Rotation of the classroom for Kingdom
Variety of topics and lesson planningDifferent activitiesWe need to get words out about our
youth programIf we have outreaches to the kids,
then we could reach out to more parents
Children are the church’s future;Provide facility and personnel to support them;Separation of space now, used to be more cohesive and
more interaction amongst age groupsParents of Kingdom kids are the volunteers; would like to
diversify and include more peopleChildren’s Time during the service is important;Age gap in volunteers Different family time constraints and priorities on parents’
times these daysChoir camp is a positive new activity Size of children’s choir groups concerning; want to
encourage young ages to be involved but worried at some point it could become exclusionary with auditions, etc.
Well received (4:11)Good interactions & relationships with
confirmands and shepherdsStrength of youth program attracts
people to churchFriendship/bonds between kids in
programImportant to have strong youth
programChildren’s moment in worship service +Strong music/choir program for youthKingdom programMission & work trips attract youth and
are valuable to kids
No negatives in adult-children/youth relationship(s) mentioned
4:11 admired, deemed very desirable
Sports (youth) viewed positively
General feeling that intergenerational contact and activities were welcomed at First Pres
Presence of 21 youth and 4 adults at Montreat, observed group relationships and interactions with others suggest a strong youth program continues.
Visitors/members impressed with space for all groups
Lots of opportunities – classes, mission, music
Need to find more ways to integrate children and youth in worship
Children seem very comfortable
Lots of parent supportGood leadership
Men
& w
omen
Lacking programs for young adultsThere will be advantage in creating a
group for young professionalsWe should look into Fourth
Presbyterian Church’s programming and see how they have provided different opportunities for all ages
Coffee Grounds provides good opportunities for discussion and learning for family with young kids
Church should be a mix of groupsSocial groups are important for all agesPastor leadership should be diverseKingdom volunteers are fairly equally represented between
moms and dadsMonthly day-trips were a nice activity for retirees, social
outingsNo need to cater social groups to each specific age
demographic, don’t over-organize people; members will participate/volunteer when they can
PW – strong, good programhelps build relationshipsopportunity to meet othersMen’s – men’s Monday morning bible
studyValue meeting new people, study, etcLarge part of social lifeLike that there isn’t a hierarchy – good
diversitySingles –may not feel as included, welcomednot considered, not inclusive, invited,
supportedHave we decided this audience is a
priority or not?Balance???
Minimal comments. No opportunity differentiation identified.
Have work to do in young adults and singles → environment seems more comfortable for married than singles
Trendsetters is inclusive – intentional (“Couples Club”)
Couples with no children – “families”
Do we do a good enough job defining what does family mean?
Men and women both participate in youth activities – cross generation
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 69
7/24 Luke w/Kristi DeBoer, 10 participants
7/24 10 am, Carrie w/Jeff, 10 participants 7/24 10 am, Jody w/Tom, 9 participants 7/26 Montreat, Chuck w/Mike N,21 youth/4 adults
7/13, MSTF group
Confl
ict
We have different opinions but we need to learn how to respect one another
Communication is keyPeople feel like they are not
informed about church activities, news, and programming
Maybe we could have what’s happening for our church in the Chimes
More information and use multiple channels to keep all informed (for example, announcement from pulpit, bulletin, email, …)
Issues develop under the radar; driven by gossip, causes problems but never brought to the surface and cleared out
Some people make resolution or voice their dissatisfaction by “voting with their feet” rather than addressing the issue or concern out loud.
Staff should encourage personal interaction; bring problems directly to pastors rather than gossip
Issues are magnified when not discussed openlySeems to be a different ways of sharing conflicting ideas
amongst the ages; parents of young kids get email chains while older groups may gossip together
Some not comfortable with confrontation; better to keep quiet and not rock the boat rather than make the public statement of disagreement;
Some feel the church is very open and just that some people don’t want to participate.
My church, my spiritual life – concern that some conflict is related to “change”. Are we obligated/committed to working together to address issues versus leaving church
Approach conflict with optimismMore you get involved, the more you
know the issuesCould have better communicationOverall we have been open, transparentWe deal with conflict openly – maybe
not smooth & quick but openCommunicationSometimes not knowing is better. Many
aren’t aware those conflicts exist.Communication channel – need to be
fed informationConcern when we hide behind
Presbytery secrecy & confidentialityPresbyterian system – don’t hide behind
that communication/rulesChurch “family” vs. business – how do
we balance?
Both losses and delayed restoration of chapel service seen as a source of conflict.
Communication shortcomings in chapel service handling noted with perceived lack of resolution.
Communication shortcomings in Jeff Deardorff departure filled by misinformation. Seen as a “taboo” subject. More communication needed, even if communication must be that certain items are personal or confidential.
Sometimes we avoid it directly, but address on the side
Anger comes from not having enough information
Side conversations not good/healthy
Intentional conversations we do well
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 70
7/24 Luke w/Kristi DeBoer, 10 participants
7/24 10 am, Carrie w/Jeff, 10 participants 7/24 10 am, Jody w/Tom, 9 participants 7/26 Montreat, Chuck w/Mike N,21 youth/4 adults
7/13, MSTF group
Mon
ey
There should be an effort to let people know how money is spent and congregation need a voice in how money should be spent
Most people don’t realize the cost of running and maintaining our church building
Make people aware of maintenance costs for our church
We need to spend money on the priorities, and it seems like sometime we don’t spent on the priorities
Church should be more open about giving amounts expected; maybe a class to guide people on what they should give;
Add more focus to teaching young generations about tithing, donating,
Would like month-to-month budgets, whether on target or not
Trustees are overseeing how the money gets spent; trust the trustees and their decisions
Encourage tithing at Sunday school; kingdom should have an offering opportunity
Stewardship is a yearlong commitment; should remind the congregation more than once a year
Provide quarterly reports, perhaps with quarterly giving statements
Encourage the auto-debit giving; can be giving even if not attending often enough;
Make sure that people who sign up for auto-debit have envelopes/opportunities to give to special offerings
New creative ways to bring in money; look into options within the law or lobby to change the laws
We have been responsive to the monetary impact on our member families.
Giving remains generousWe need more personal
communication/stories around pledging/money
Get away from dollar amounts and discuss needs for programs and what we do with the money
Session – manages money input from trustees, deacons, others
Responsible on how we allocate fund ++
No comments beyond “it seems tight”, implicitly suggesting that information about sources and uses is lacking
Good job financing east parking lot
Confine conversations re: money only in pledging week and mission special offerings
We are fiscally responsible
Some people don’t know or aren’t focused on money
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 71
7/24 Luke w/Kristi DeBoer, 10 participants
7/24 10 am, Carrie w/Jeff, 10 participants 7/24 10 am, Jody w/Tom, 9 participants 7/26 Montreat, Chuck w/Mike N,21 youth/4 adults
7/13, MSTF group
Expe
ctati
ons o
f/re
latio
ns w
ith cl
ergy
The new senior pastor needs to be a strong leader and have strengths in:
LeadershipPreachingMissionEducationPastors need to have variety of
preaching styles. That way we could meet all needs.
We are blessed to have many long tenure pastors
Pastors need to be accessible when needed (be able to call them in the time of crisis)
Members to take a bigger role in outreaching and caring for our congregation. Something similar to Steven Ministry.
Delicate balance between personal and professional livesSome felt spouses should participate at the same level as
other members of the church; others acknowledged that spouses have an individual relationship with God and their own faith journey and the spouse has a different calling than the pastor.
Session leads the church but people go to the pastors for conflict resolution; people should go through proper channels when they do feel they have a conflict; some people might take advantage of the pastors based on his/her role in the church
Some have had pastor roles conflicting with personal needs; thought because she had a closer personal relationship with one specific pastor she would ask that individual for help but that pastor said “it's more so-and-so’s job” and then she didn’t feel her needs were really met with the other pastor.
Pastors should be involved with all aspects of the church; don’t have to lead but be involved; be something to everybody vs. everything to everybody;
Some pastoral conflicts due to church and staff size, unable to have all pastors at all services or know everybody when there is so much going on
We put on pedestal and expect them to meet our needs
Forget they are human – they have needs
Expect a lotWe respect family – don’t overstep
there or expect/demand of them (positive)
Expect them to be charismatic, engaging – to draw people
Personal/spiritual/monetary problems – listen, available, access, true, listen to heart, without Presbyterian issues ++
Different pastors bring different strengths
Head of staff – want terrific preachers. Get excitement
Associates – different expectationsYouth pastor must be charismaticMust define priorities/characteristics for
each individual associate pastor role
Difficulty in handling lost relationships - especially Sean, despite sense that it was well handled and appreciation for his career progress.
Flurry of change in past twelve months – unsettling.
Lack of clarity about “interim”, what it means.
General confusion about the current situation and process.
Some interest in more (youth) visibility of pastors
Mixed comments on need for dedicated Youth Pastor.
Because of staff size, perception is that ministers have different strengths
Perception depends on member’s involvement
Different perceptionsWe have had unrealistic
expectationsRe: clergy – too many
roles played by clergyLike diversity of clergy
and their rolesRely too much on our
clergy to do most/all work → difference in reality and perception
Important to identify pastors and their roles
Pastors are a lifeline – way of connecting
People look to pastors - they are empathetic, approachable
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 72
7/24 Luke w/Kristi DeBoer, 10 participants
7/24 10 am, Carrie w/Jeff, 10 participants 7/24 10 am, Jody w/Tom, 9 participants 7/26 Montreat, Chuck w/Mike N,21 youth/4 adults
7/13, MSTF group
Who
is w
elco
me
A welcoming church for the most part
People might think we are welcoming to new people, but we are only nice to people we know
Identify new people & welcome.It is everyone’s job to greet one
another especially new visitorsNeed to make more of an effort to
make people feel that they are welcome here
Like the friendship padWe all could find ways to connect
with different people (i.e. Striking up a conversation, …)
Most of visitors seem to enter through Dunton Street door. Maybe we should have greeters by the front door
Get people involved in something small instead of asking them to be an elder or a deacon right away
Members should push beyond comfort zone to welcome new people
People really want the friendship pad back; easier to locate new people and get to know neighbors
Welcome desk is a great addition; better with a one-on-one as opposed to those churches who make visitors announce to everyone they are new;
Do we advertise? How are we encouraging people to attend; look to what works at other churches like EV Free or Willow Creek to see how we could be more welcoming
Important to have good members; quality over quantityMembers should be students of the Word; maintain focus on
theology
Street bulletin board (sign) talks to our members –
Should it talk to community, passersby?Church info for guests. Source of times.Note: only comments one participate
made – was waiting on this subjectNewcomers – don’t know how good we
are at introducing, welcoming ++Different service, group, generations –
don’t know necessarily who is newcomer or regular
Jeff was good at recognizing and connecting
Identify them and ask them to get involved and follow-up
Generally seen as welcoming.
Some felt initial welcome was lacking, but grew over time.
We think we are more welcoming than we are
Some new members are assimilated quickly and other don’t
We don’t have staff people long-term to help new members
Pastors are key connection to new members
Do we have people to follow-up with new members?
DeaconsLiz ArmstrongPastors have been
recruiters in the pastIs there a life cycle of
membership – are we intentional about process?
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 73
7/24 Luke w/Kristi DeBoer, 10 participants
7/24 10 am, Carrie w/Jeff, 10 participants 7/24 10 am, Jody w/Tom, 9 participants 7/26 Montreat, Chuck w/Mike N,21 youth/4 adults
7/13, MSTF group
Wor
ship
We have great music hereSomeone suggested that Hymns we
use at church is out dated. Another person strongly disagreed.
Spiritual growth should be the primary purpose of church
Encourage people to have a closer relationship with God
Worship should be relevant to our lives
Sermon should be different than a bible study. We should focus on how Bible applies to our life instead of just explaining verses.
Preaching is a top prioritySermon and Scripture is a strong draw for new membersMusic is awesome; music increases giving unitsShould include children in the worship service; glad to have
worship bags and the children time back in serviceSome concern with length of Prayers, prayers of the people
can be so inclusive that a newcomer is lost or bored with the specificity of it
Strong preaching is important, need Biblical knowledge and references, rather than “preachy” preacher
Know that the sermons and prayers are sincere but some think the fact that everything being read is not as sincere and not off the cuff from the heart.
Music is important – brings people inWould like us sometimes to step outside
“order” of worship to make it more personal (mention names)
Community life – prefer t the beginning of the service, show life of church
Concerts – include belief, express belief in our music program; belief system – showcase we are a church
More contemporary music from chapel into sanctuary
Like adding “spirituals” music into traditional
Hard to blend with proportion of those that like it
How do we make sure we aren’t two separate entities?
Sanctuary worship style seen as boring (note: Montreat Youth Conference is a tough environment for comparison).
Congregation is diverse – different people want/look for different things
“Frozen Chosen” – worship out of date?
1950 ca. hymnalComfort with worshipLike music – traditional
serviceChange is challenging –
acceptance of “Thanks be to God”
Do not like blended worship
Need wine in communionWonderful music in
traditional service – and organ music
Use
of b
uild
ing
Moving mid-hour to parlor from Fellowship Hall is a good idea. It might be noisy, but it demonstrates a welcoming space for visitors
We need air condition on 3rd floorPhysical layout is difficult for people
with disabilityOur building should be a
wheelchair/walker friendly place
A member of Connections noted that lots of areas of the building are falling apart; maintenance needs to be improved
Committee should be formed to determine what needs to be repaired; get a budget together for long term maintenance or new buildings
Adequate space for all activities.
Grandiose ideas visiting mega churchespeople in the church make it wonderfulGood patienceMake great with the facilities we haveBeautiful and huge – Lots of weekday activitiesUsed by other groupsLetting people use our spaceWell furnishedLook at blessings of buildingPhysical limitations – accessibility
No specific comments
BeautifulHandicap accessibility is a
problemFeel very blessed with all
of the space – diverse uses
Fun place for young people
Modernization needs – kitchen, etc.
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 74
7/24 8:30 am, Tom Pardo, 6 participants 7/24 10 am, Tom Pardo, 6 participants 7/27 Wed, 10am,Jody, 8 participants 7/28 Aaron, 23 participants
Child
ren
and
Yout
h
Even when you are not aware of the programs, seeing happy children and young families means it is going well.
Need to have Sunday School at times when parents can worship.
Advertising – getting the word out to the community helps bring families in.
Seems like the High School Choir (Westminster Youth Chorale) is struggling.
Interest in Presbyterian camping ministry needs to be revisited.
Figure out what the children and youth relate to: maintain a balance between learning and having fun.
Children bring their parents.
Youth bags during worship services are a good idea.PDO is important.Appreciate hearing about mission trip experiences during
worship – should be extended to adult trips as well.Very impressed with Confirmands serving Communion.Make the youth more visible in various aspects of worship.
Involve them more on Sunday mornings.Losing Sean is hard on the congregation. In many respects, his
ministry encouraged a “Pied Piper Syndrome” in the congregation – members wanting to keep him here forever.
Youth were not consulted in the selection of Ken Whitney.Greater efforts should be made in integrating youth in the
governance of the church, i.e., youth council or nomination of youth to boards.
Choices for youth don’t begin until high school.Losing the mission to Mexico was difficult for the youth. The
boys really like the construction projects.
Was very inclusive (when participant was young); separated appropriately by age; made a difference in her life
Seems like a lot going on and variety of opportunities +
Mission committee receives positive comments about youth mission and what Sean brought to the program. Hope for next minister to bring the same
challenge to keep up momentumget different view of world with varietyreading scripture during service and serving
communion are wonderfulkeep congregation aware of youthopportunity to communicate to rest of
church what is going on with both children & youth – opportunity to include both in the service more, especially without chapel
in past – was a separation – children didn’t go to church – a challenge for some
provide options for children during service – not all kids can or want to worship in sanctuary – some parents may not want kids in church
kingdom – canceling creates issues – some children don’t have another option – need to ensure kingdom runs every week
consider needs of kids with challengesChimes – does good job of including kids of
all ages – great way to show what’s being done for youth and what they appreciate
Contemporary service – was great for youth and families = future
Children’s budget – low in comparison to other programs – consider future
Music (5)Sense of communityMission (4)“Feels like home”Traditional worship
serviceLibrary and
educational opportunities
Children’s education (2)
Adult education (2)Offers various activities
(2) / Diversity“A place where one
learns what it takes to be a Christian”
A wonderful place to raise children
The people / friendships
Christmas nativity service
“The senior pastor is the most important factor in joining the church”
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 75
7/24 8:30 am, Tom Pardo, 6 participants 7/24 10 am, Tom Pardo, 6 participants 7/27 Wed, 10am,Jody, 8 participants 7/28 Aaron, 23 participants
Men
& w
omen
Women have Circles. Fewer opportunities for men besides Monday Morning Men’s Bible Study and Connections.
Men’s retreats.How do we attract younger men and women?Regeneration – many of the items we are discussing have
changed and will keep changing in order to keep things fresh.
There are opportunities – sometimes it takes a personal invitation and sometimes people just need to be asked.
Some start with a short-term commitment; some are also drawn to longer-term commitments.
Continued need for coffee/fellowship time after both services, not just between the services.
It is good and important to integrate new members rapidly.Commune groups are a positive experience. It is good that
many have a mixture of men and women.Small groups for new members are a good way to ensure
integration.PW Circles are good, but sometimes it is difficult to break into
a Circle because of established friendships, cliques, etc.The church is a comfortable place for men and women.“Breaking Bread Together” is a wonderful fellowship
experience.
New members – PW goes to new member classes to discuss PW and women’s bible study –
could do this as individuals - meeting new people and making music dept and PW visible
Connections – need time (such as during service) to invite people to join group ; other groups need visible – personal ways to connect
Friendship pads – glad coming back – can we include email? If so, need to immediately follow-up
Connect in right way with correct age group – based on demographics
No distinction between roles of men/women/youth – on all boards, etc; all opportunities open to all
Small groups are crucial – communicate these group
Communication – need to strategically look at communication and understand different ways there are to communicate
An opportunity – push informationDo not communicate very wellAre trying – some people tune it outWhat do you want to knowHow do we participate in our community
(AH, etc) – take our place in the community – need to look at this more
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 76
7/24 8:30 am, Tom Pardo, 6 participants 7/24 10 am, Tom Pardo, 6 participants 7/27 Wed, 10am,Jody, 8 participants 7/28 Aaron, 23 participants
Confl
ict
The matter involving Jeff Deardorff and other issues were handled poorly.
When people are upset, it is not confronted or addressed but rather washed over.
Once something is done, if you like the result it is not conflict; if you don’t like the result it is conflict.
For each controversial matter or major initiative, leadership needs to ask two questions: What could we have done better? What have we learned from this experience?
People think of leaving the church rather than staying and working the problem out.
Need more information continuously.The issue of ordination change (10-A), it was not discussed
with the congregation.Session business needs to be better communicated before
decisions are made.
Need more communication with the congregation on major developments.
The matter involving Jeff Deardorff was not communicated well, but the financial arrangements for Jeff were handled very well.
There needs to be much more education given to the congregation about the transition process, particularly the Mission Study and PNC, than simply publishing Chimes articles.
The congregation needs to know how and why the transition process works and to occasionally have progress reports given during worship services as has been done in the past.
Rules are rules, but they need to be better communicated using a variety of platforms – classes, web site, email, Chimes, etc.
Congregational survey was too broad. Need opportunities, like these gatherings, to express how the congregation feels about our church
.
Ties into communicationHad recent conflict – (Jeff) communication
was not enoughLetting people speak and air concerns –
were well respected and listened toOpportunity for leadership training in
conflict with members alsoConflict vs. difference of opinion – how to
navigate when parents have different opinions (CM example)
Taboo topics = pastors & personnel – private employment arrangement should not be open for general discussion (unless both parties agree) – same with health issues
Conflicts are sometimes resolved by vote at Gen Assembly and we accept
People don’t know where to go to voice concerns (presbytery, other members, etc) – gets back to communication
We tend to shy away from conflict
We need to have more open forums to discuss tough issues (e.g. homosexuality)
Pastors need more courage to talk about controversial issues
Need to be accepting of all regardless; no judgment
Taboo topics – homosexuality
True leaders deal with conflict; they don’t avoid it
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 77
7/24 8:30 am, Tom Pardo, 6 participants 7/24 10 am, Tom Pardo, 6 participants 7/27 Wed, 10am,Jody, 8 participants 7/28 Aaron, 23 participants
Mon
ey
Money is managed well, especially with the upkeep of the facilities.
Utilities, staff expenses (benefits), mission disbursements should be broken out from broader categories in the financial reports. More detailed information on the budget needs to be provided so the congregation is better informed.
Need to emphasize pledging on a personal basis. We treat stewardship almost as an apology rather than a commitment to the church’s work. Call on people personally if they have not pledged during the Stewardship Campaign.
Too much paper is used for the worship bulletin – not good stewardship.
It seems like we have weathered the financial crisis (recession) well.
The church should not depend upon those few members who are major contributors. We should not commit to capital campaigns with the idea that someone will come forward to make a major donation and rescue the church.
When financial resources are tight, it seems that the mission budget is the first item that gets reduced. That is not fair or right.
There is a concern that the older members of the congregation are carrying the financial burden of the church. What happens as they are unable to do this? Younger members need to better understand the church’s budget and their responsibility. The church needs to also understand that there are very different viewpoints about giving today
No “requirements” for donations – think specifying expectation is a good idea
Education – dynamics of family have changed, so knowledge of giving at family level has changed – need to educate what it takes to run a church
New members – give them this infoMany members don’t pledge – should
encourage pledgingSpecial commitment opportunities – likeWay to specify more where money is usedDifficult discussionsResponsibility of members to look at
financial data & see where $ go
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 78
7/24 8:30 am, Tom Pardo, 6 participants 7/24 10 am, Tom Pardo, 6 participants 7/27 Wed, 10am,Jody, 8 participants 7/28 Aaron, 23 participants
Expe
ctati
ons o
f/re
latio
ns w
ith c
lerg
y
Congregation needs pastoral leadership to oversee various aspects of mission and ministry (youth, preaching, counseling, education, etc.)
Would like the opportunity to make an appointment to talk to the pastors about personal counseling. Counseling has been outsourced for several years. It would be nice to talk about personal problems once again with a pastor.
More theology in worship, less story-telling. Connect scripture to everyday living, but delve more into the meaning of the scriptures.
Need a good youth leader.Pastors need to call more on visitors directly.Pastors change, but our faith remains.Anxiety over having funerals conducted by the interim
pastors.All five called pastors leaving over a relatively short period
of time (1.5 years) makes people think that something is fundamentally wrong with our church.
The number one priority is excellence in preaching, both content and delivery. It is the key to bringing people into the church.
More emphasis upon scripture, analyzing its meaning and connecting it to everyday life.
Pastors need to exhibit more of a personal touch with the congregation. Be more engaging and not aloof.
The leadership of the church needs to decide the future staffing plan: how many pastors, roles and responsibilities of each pastor.
Is it important that all pastors can preach?More meaty sermons that link scripture to everyday living.Do not think that the pastor’s family needs to be involved in
the life of the church. It is nice, but not necessary.
Music program; deacons “thank you” for support of their program – good things going on
Communicate roles of clergy – who is contact for what
What is role of clergy on committees?Want – 1st good sermonizer – draws people
inClergy needs to lead us in Christian
principles – what is our priorityWhat does that mean and how does that
translate to child & youth?A special placeShould be approachableConflict resolution/management skillsA face to everyone – like Jeff – always
approached everyoneSomeone who understands – shepherds –
intergenerational - pastor leadNeed childcareNeed pastor able to relate to all ages &
understand businessEncourage congregation for
intercommunication, enabler, outgoing, engaging
Name tags - want
We expect too much of them
They can’t be “all things to all people”
Expectations are too high
Session needs to do a better job setting clear expectations, roles, and responsibilities.
Need a diverse team of pastors each with some distinct roles that play to each of their strengths
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 79
7/24 8:30 am, Tom Pardo, 6 participants 7/24 10 am, Tom Pardo, 6 participants 7/27 Wed, 10am,Jody, 8 participants 7/28 Aaron, 23 participants
Who
is w
elco
me
People being welcomed personally is a major plus (Liz Armstrong).
Friendship pads need to come back.A limitation to some mission and education opportunities
is that new members of less than 6 months cannot participate because of a provision in the child protection policy.
Everyone has responsibility to welcome people – in the pew and during coffee hour. Don’t let people feel awkward. Meet someone now.
Our physical space in the Narthex and the church as a whole is not set up well to welcome visitors. Too many entrances - easy for visitors to get lost in the shuffle.
It is difficult to know who is new to the church.New member class is a definite plus.Welcoming gifts – mug and key chains distributed at
Community Presbyterian in Mount Prospect.Pastors need to reach out to visitors when they come to
church.It is our job as members to greet people, even if we risk
introducing ourselves to long-time members by mistake.Members of the congregation need to be at each outside door
to greet people, especially newcomers.Name tags for visitors?Extending personal invitations to come to church.
We tend to fall into cliques
Friendship pads / attendance books are important
Coffee hour in the parlor is more welcoming and accessible to all
Liz Armstrong is awesome
Need to get newer people involved early
Participation in small groups is extremely important
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 80
7/24 8:30 am, Tom Pardo, 6 participants 7/24 10 am, Tom Pardo, 6 participants 7/27 Wed, 10am,Jody, 8 participants 7/28 Aaron, 23 participants
Wor
ship
Loves the old order of worship when the sermon was given earlier in the service.
Overwhelmed by too much paper in the worship bulletin and wants to see a simpler design to the bulletin.
Hard to find hymns when they are printed in the bulletin.We should stand to sing all hymns.We should have only one service in the summer.Try to find a solution to the sound system for the choir.
The position of the speakers above the pulpit and lectern are not placed properly for the choir to hear. It would be better if they were placed along the wall just below the organ pipes on both sides.
It is still difficult to hear in the Sanctuary.The names of instrumentalists and others need to be
printed in the bulletin.Music is integral to the worship experience. It is holding
the church together now.Chant and response parts of the service are too
mechanical – too Catholic.Prayers of Confession are awful. They seem overly harsh
and not relevant.
There have been too many changes in the order of worship.Likes old order of worship where the sermon was not at the
end.Would like to have more contemporary and praise music
offered in worshipPreaching is most important.Traditional worship is important; need to maintain a
separation between traditional and contemporary.There needs to be a raising of the energy level in worship with
more contemporary music and using different statements of faith/creeds.
We need to have a variety of worship experiences.There is a concern about contemporary worship in the Chapel.
If more young people attend contemporary worship regularly, they will not learn about reformed worship. Fear expressed that contemporary worship is creating a lot of Baptists.
Don’t chase after membership. Reformed worship appeals to a certain group. To lose that experience would be very bad.
Preaching is critical; we need to be challenged spiritually
Preaching must be biblical-based but relates to current events in today’s world
Balance is good and needed going forward
Traditional service is great
Would like to be known as “the Fourth Presbyterian Church of the Northwest” (Fourth Presbyterian Church in Chicago has tripled its membership while appealing to the traditional service minded folk, why and how?)
A contemporary worship service is critical and needed for growth
Needs to appeal to the children
Need a stellar youth pastor – the children are our future
Need a two minute meet-and-greet during worship
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 81
7/24 8:30 am, Tom Pardo, 6 participants 7/24 10 am, Tom Pardo, 6 participants 7/27 Wed, 10am,Jody, 8 participants 7/28 Aaron, 23 participants
Use
of b
uild
ing
An elevator in the Christian Education Building is a necessity.
It is challenging to get around.The staff lounge has changed and now there is no space
for the groom and his attendants to change and wait prior to weddings.
A bench located on the outside of the north entrance to the church would be nice to have for people who are waiting to be picked up. (The Jollys have a bench they would be happy to donate to the church for this purpose.)
We should be more open to the community and have more community events take place in our space.
Maintaining the upkeep of the facility is critically important.
Having the necessary funding for unexpected “rainy day” maintenance situations is important.
The facility is big, old and expensive to maintain.Being a downtown church, it has a great location with
excellent potential for community outreach.The facility is confusing and hard to get around.The facility is well used by many different groups.There are so many doors which makes it difficult for
newcomers to know how to navigate. Security issues make it challenging.
The church needs an elevator in the Christian Education building.
Many parts of the building are in assessable to handicapped
No reserve fund for maintenance; many times it’s the first to get cut
We need to keep the building well-maintained
It’s a beautiful buildingWe need to better use
fellowship hallLikes the Kingdom in
education wing facility
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 82
“What are we called to be and do?” notes
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 83
Wendy w/Bruce 8/21 at 8:30 (10 people)
Wendy w/Betty L 8/21 at 10(8 people)
Aaron 8/25/11(apx. 10 people) Carrie w/Jeff 8/21 at 10 (8 people) Kelsey w/Jenny 8/21 10 am (3 youth)
Calle
d to
BE
Core community leaderLocation, facility, resources,
peopleIn good position to bring people
to God through our programsSource of revelation of God’s
wordExpectations for followersWelcoming and inclusive—not
judgmentalWho we are—Christ’s familySource of education for all agesLeader in innovative ways to
teachPlace where people can identify
their spiritual gifts so all may be involved
Lay people are empoweredLeaders are developedActive participation of seniorsBible studies
Compassionate and forgiving place
Community perceptionLeader in Christian thoughts
and ideasDiversity of thinkingOutreach to communityThrough education – 4:11 and
VBS good examples
Opportunities in addition to Sunday am for worship, study, fellowship
Inspiring preaching and participation of pastors
Reaching out to the “unchurched”
Adult education – available to all on Sunday and beyond
Programs for youth and children
Demographics of church closer to demographics of the community
Reinstate contemporary serviceWorship includes involvement
of families and community – especially contemporary
New hymn booksBoth traditional and
contemporary and perhaps also blended
Family participation in worship
Church sign speaks to visitors, seeker – need outreach
Need bigger presence in population of community – help make AH a stronger place
Make people comfortable—concerts, 1st Forum, contemporary worship, anniversary speakers
Great preachingReaching and encouraging
people where they areTime schedule that gives
people options on Sunday
Great Commission – how it looks at 1st Pres. – Have an ongoing local service project where people are involved in the community on a regular basis
Energy and enthusiasmAccessibility in buildingBuilding that meets the needs
of our congregants
witness to the community - setting an example
inclusive ministryappeals to all ages - those
who want a contemporary service
viable for the youthsetting the social climatebe the church of Jesus Christbe approachable, welcoming
and inclusiveneed to change our make-upneed to be more ecumenical
in our thinkingneed to accentuate our
similarities vs. differencesbiblical basedchange the world and touch
livesan engaging churchhave more prayer groupsneed to align to the marketdrop the "First Presbyterian
Church" from our name - create a name with more pizazz
break away from the Presbytery
expand our community outreach (e.g. buy the lot across the street)
Present actions determine our future;Need a multigenerational congregationChurch needs to be more responsive; speed up
church processes; speed up leadership changesNeed a space for PADSThe world moves faster, the church should move
faster alsoGod is calling us to be a caring church;
compassionate within the communityContinue small groups/Bible Studies/Discipleship;Need new ways to communicate our church’s
message;Technology – utilize what we have;Adapt to new generationsOther churches have used technology to better
communicate message, to get new members, to make the worship more dynamic;
Leadership – need a minister to lead church;Church needs outside the box thinking, off the
wall ideas;Modernize the facility; our location is important
and valuable; update the facility;Leadership – communicate with the next
generation through technology; example Methodist church in Kansas City where the Minister used audio and visual presentation in a modern way to communicate with younger generations;
Church laws – examine Presbyterian rules; evaluate specifically pastoral call selection committee;
Younger leadership may have a lasting presence; dynamic person to lead;
Would like a multigenerational congregation;Screens for the Hymns/hymnal;Energetic atmosphere throughout service;Relevancy – want to be relevant; relevant to
congregation, the community, subgroups; without relevancy it sets the congregation back;
Church needs to be friendly and open; involve new people in church activities;
New member classes should be asked about their interests to get them involved;
Personal invitations get people involved;
Strong committed membersPeople open to each other (people
don’t tend to be open to everyone-like the youth)
Mission trips that are strongWell attended services where people
connectOpen, caring pastorsA pastor who participates in all ages
of the congregation (especially kids)More contemporary musicServices look more like chapel todayActive community presenceMore athletics (competitions with
other churches)Thought of as a “home away from
home”Strong youth leader4:11 (worried it won’t be as strong
with Sean’s departure)Reoccurring theme: Youth programs
staying strong (mission trips and retreats are a broad attraction to youth)
Strong attendance for “my kids;” we want our kids to know each other
Current welcoming group is good and we’d like to see it continue for new visitors
Older kids in youth group still treat the younger ones like they are a part of the group (like today’s youth)
Goal for families to start their children’s church experience from them they are very small so they can “grow up together” in the church
Strong programs for all agesA fun place to come!!“Home” – a place to hang out even
without a schedules activityA place for quiet reflection
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 84
Wendy w/Bruce 8/21 at 8:30 (10 people)
Wendy w/Betty L 8/21 at 10 (8 people)
Aaron 8/25/11 (apx. 10 people)
Carrie w/Jeff 8/21 at 10 (8 people) Kelsey w/Jenny 8/21 10 am (3 youth)
Calle
d to
Do
Reach out to inactive and homebound
Create connections to meet people’s needs—Christian education, contemporary worship
Develop important relationships with youth so they desire a continuing relationship with 1st Presb.
Have a modern facility to meet our needs
Be involved in mission –both close by in our community and in international settings
Inspiring worshipVariety of worship formsInnovatorsFormat, familiarityVariety vs. capacityMeditation – how God
reaches usNew hymn booksDynamic pastoral leadership –
adequate number of staffHave a clear direction of
where we want to go. Have a clear understanding of where PCUSA stands on various issues.
Strong senior high programs4:11 or that type of program
that welcomes kids—involved with pastors
Key programs that reach out to the community
4:11 type program for other groups – such as retired (include social)
Fellowship within program groups
Visiting elderly regularlyPastors who are involvedLeadership development to
sustain programs such as BBT
Develop NEW leadersDevelop “MOMs” – managers
of managersExpectations for all members
to be involvedCooperative leadership with
pastors and lay peopleGive new members specific
jobsEnvironment of expectation
that brings joy in serviceAdvertise needsPerhaps shorter terms—
shorter than 3 years
more faith-based community outreach
engage more with the community to connect people with our church
be more welcoming, inclusive and diverse
more mission-minded activities
grow people spirituallyencourage disabled to attend
and participate
Be “fleet of foot,” need to change quickly;
Be caring; taking care of people from cradle to grave; more spiritual outreach;
Make church un-complicated – simplify the spiritual experience;
Church should be to connect to God every week;
Variety of small groups to get people involved/connected, service day groups could be a monthly opportunity;
As church congregation ages, facilities need to be updated and accessible;
Continue to minister to shut-ins/older members with homebound communion;
Web-casting makes church service accessible to more people;
Build on past success – PADS, music, The Kingdom, leverage what you’re good at;
Partner with other churches with mission work;
Sell ourselves in the community; Market what we do; have a brand name;
Put money, time and effort into branding/marketing;
Appeal to newcomers;New members need a
personal connection;Advertise when we have a
new senior pastor “come meet our new pastor” signs
Finding strong leaders – very hard acts to follow (Sean, Diane, etc.). No one can replace them but we need to find someone strong)
Community involvement – Parade, assist community (e.g., PADS)Invest in our facility to update - basement flood is a concern (very worried
about basement impact on PADS; our kitchen is old; our technology is oldNeed to continue to invest in technology – in 15 years technology will be
very differentInvest in another facility to create more space – the youth combined with
the very young is often crowdedYouth group facility – just for youth; could attract more youth to our church
(help with noise too)Mission trips – let youth have more input on where to travel; better to be
further away from home to get kids out of their comfort zone to reflectMore volunteering and fund raising activities for youth and whole church –
car washes, bake sales, Habitat for Humanity; senior center visits; fix up church days
Reopening of the Chapel – allows us to laugh openly; more personal experience; more intimate than the sanctuary including joys and concerns. Can clap and express emotion. Great to see everyone with so much faith and showing it. Easier to connect with someone next to you in Chapel
Sanctuary Service – make it less traditional; add something newBring back Children’s Circle – it’s nice for the kids to be able to go to the
service and the KingdomContinue to build on the KingdomAdult classes – interesting variety of classes (e.g., Spanish); perhaps a class
on international faith where we study different faiths around the world and see how they differ
Youth book review classes – study a book (other than the Bible)Bible study – read and study more action storiesUpdate facility – our building needs to be more accessible to the disabled;
today some older people are not able to come up to see where the youth are; maybe an elevator
More diversity – we need to attract a more diverse congregation; we are a very “white” church today. Our church services do not attract a diverse group (e.g., African Americans); for example, we won’t even clap for celebrations
In the chapel you get more of a voice than in the sanctuary; the sanctuary service should be more open to expressing yourself; the older people in the church don’t seem to want to change; the hope is that the new pastor will open people up to change
Youth pastor – don’t want them to be too young but must be able to relate to the youth but also be able to be a leader
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 85
Luke w/Stephanie 8/21 at 8:30(11 people)
Luke w/Stephanie 8/21 at 10:0(9 people)
Teri 8/23 at 2 p.m. (7 people) Buzz 8/24 at 10 am (12 people) Chuck w/Pam 8/21 at 10 am(apx. 10 people)
Calle
d to
BE
Be a place for people to feel at home/community
Be heard in the communityA church that stands for somethingKnown to be involved in social justice issues
A welcoming church and attracting new members
Organization that can change and be efficient with process
Discerning church (considers what God is doing in the world today)
Agile and flexible churchA church that is supportiveHealing church and reconcile
brokennessAdvocating education for both adult
and youth
Be relevant to everyoneOpen to change and be adaptable Current with technologyConsistent with our theologyConsistent with our missionA gathering place that provides sense
of community and connectionHub to communityPillar in communityPlace of worshipBe a contemporary churchBe a place that people want to come
back to again and againBe or not to be part of [Presbyterian]
denominationBe good listeners of what God is calling
us to be
Be a body of Christ in a Presbyterian Church, not so much a business model, teach about Book of Order, awareness of current policies, and promote importance of its understanding.
Relevant in everyday lives.Lively witnesses to Jesus.Draws attention of people.A family of faith.An active church.An accepting church.Good leadership.Church where people feel empowered
to lead and be involved.Church with good communication. Responsive to world community.Proactive in mission and for future.Involved with justice issues.Willingness to thoughtful change.Attract people to church through
programming.To be a teaching church.To be diverse among community.Continuation of strong music program.A facility where mission can be done.Offer a variety of worship
styles/services.A giving church: Time, Talent, Treasure;
supportive of missions; having resource for missions; individuals would feel generous to give.
Sharing abundance of God’s gifts.Church with a vision that God will
provide.Joy-filled church.Accepting of others in congregation
with different viewpoints-go out of comfort zone.
A thriving church; sustained membership; and continuing to bring in new members
A beacon for justice Be involved in social concernsBe a part of, if not a leader of a
coalition of AH churches and the municipality of AH in establishing permanent housing for the homeless and less fortunate.
Welcome diversity (a supportive church of interfaith marriages)
Continual support of local and international mission emphasis.
Continuing our quality music program – Keep Ken
Continue our strong adult education
A church with appeal to a broad age group.
With a strong music programActive in the local community with
programs to draw interest and create awareness of what we do and are about.
A church that fosters spiritual growth and intentional movement toward a closer relationship with God, appealing to those who are in different places spiritually.
A church that engages people in a variety of inspirational worship experiences without the need to be everything to everyone every day.
Large enough to provide many opportunities to engage with the church, but not a mega church.
In cooperation with other churches, both Presbyterian and others.
A sponsor of interfaith relations with a global worldview.
Satisfied with our physical facilities.The sponsor of activities during the
week that draw people.RobustEngaged in social and justice issues.Open to dialogue and discernment.Strongly missional.
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 86
Luke w/Stephanie 8/21 at 8:30(11 people)
Luke w/Stephanie 8/21 at 10:0(9 people)
Teri 8/23 at 2 p.m. (7 people) Buzz 8/24 at 10 am (12 people) Chuck w/Pam 8/21 at 10 am(apx. 10 people)
Calle
d to
DO
Attract younger familiesEmulate growing churchProvide counseling, guidance, and
ways to get helpProviding answers: environmental,
morally, etc. to community and members
Greeting people during serviceResearch other Presbyterian churches
for strategies and ideas for growthReach out to those people unfamiliar
with ChristianityBridging across groups (i.e.: different
services, bring generations together, blended service)
New hymnals and biblesMaking PADS yearlong Mail marketing programs to let people
know what we can offerPrograms/groups for 20s and 30sBroadcasting our resources for
members and non-membersConnecting with other churches for
events, groups, etc.
Format change (delivery of message, worship elements, etc.,)
Open to activities and programs from community
Providing different worship opportunities
Fun and exciting programsSupport each other through business
referrals and networkingVolunteer coordination – make best
use of our talents, needs, and wantsEducating people on volunteer
opportunitiesProvide mechanism for people to
connect and support each otherSeek additional support and resources
from presbyteryFlatten and restructure organization
chart for the denominationLess procedures and more actionsContinue to provide education
opportunities for all agesContinue music programContinue missionReconfigure space for programs and
activitiesFind out and research what is working
for other successful churchesNew hymnal with aid of new
technology (e.g., iPad)Find and attract additional financial
resourcesContinue to seek feedback from the
congregation (surveys, polls, …)Record past practices in order to
transfer knowledgeBalance of running the church while
being biblically soundInspire people through message
Like Dianne said, “Just Do It!”-don’t think too much and dig a hole.
Develop and follow a plan.Have an ongoing way to get voices
heard…suggestion box of sorts.Develop and “Interest team” to plan
and coordinate mission work. Not just for youth but adults, too.
Make an environment where new interest groups can be started and developed.
Communicate when new groups or things begin.
Session should be aware of ALL things going on.
Interact with other churches to develop and promote groups.
Reach out to other faiths.Re-energize and re-define all social
groups; group by interest as well as age.
Raise money to update facility.
Use the latest technology and media; keep current - staff too.
Promote coalition of churchesConsider changing the climate of
volunteerism. Acknowledge workload, childcare and elder care responsibilities outside the church.
Continue program opportunities for all ages, tastes, and personalities.
Have a thriving contemporary serviceUpdated hymnals available.All level accessibility: including
handicap accessibility as well as young, and more direct paths to various rooms, etc.
Promote and maintain a level of staff involvement in community activities.
Encourage individuals to champion ideas and issues that are important to them.
Continue youth mission involvement, possibly in different locations each year.
Focus our local mission efforts to areas with greatest current need.
Target specific mission goals and programs.
Promote educational experiences that increase our understanding of diverse peoples and cultures.
Seek a high energy senior pastor and ministry staff with an appreciation for church technology to lead the church into this future.
Review other church strategies. Consider partnerships or mergers. Think beyond our walls.
Foster increased communication both from and to church and between members. Technology seen as key.
Maintain sound financial strategy.Upgrade facilities to include current
technology (presumably worship, communications, etc.?).
Increase local community involvement engaging congregation as well as Deacons. More direct, focused and energetic.
Address worship issues, recognizing the preferences of all.
Promote our music programs through partner churches and directly to the community.
Secure guest speakers from other faiths.
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 87
Groups, Ministries, and Activities
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 88
Representative groups, ministries, and activities at First Presbyterian Church
Small Groups and Study Groups
Commune GroupsMondays, 1:30pm Moorings Leader: Tom Pardo
Contact: Pat Makeever Study Lectionary scriptures for coming Sunday so Moorings Residents can understand & enjoy worship. Lively discussions. Ages: 70-90 Group size: 10-13
Tuesdays, 7pm Parlor Leader: RotatesContact: Larry Hayes or Sue KoganLiving the Questions DVD and discussion.Ages: 40-70Group size: 10-12
Wednesdays, 1 pm Boardroom Contact: Linda ByusBible Study/Covenant Group/Choose own curriculumAges: 60-70Group size: 15-20
Thursdays, 9am Parlor Leader: RotatesContact: Peggy KiblerScripture focus for coming SundayGroup size: 10
Disciple Bible StudyWednesdays, 1 pm Room 101-103
with childcare provided
Contact: Kate Ingemunson
Wednesdays, 7 pm Boardroom Contact: Jayne WellmanStudying Jesus in the GospelsAges: 40’s-70’sGroup size: 9
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 89
Women’s and Men’s Groups
Women’s Summer Book StudyThursdays, 7 pm, summer Contact: Teri Stanley
Spiritual growth, fellowship and book discussionAges: AllGroup size: 15-20
Presbyterian WomenContact: Bonnie SchaapCombines Bible Study, fellowship and mission outreachAges: 60-90, Group Size: 80
3rd Wednesday, 9:30 am Fellowship Hall Circles 1,2 and 33rd Tuesday, 7 pm Member homes Hall Circle 63rd Wednesday, 7 pm Parlor Circle 7
Kindred SpiritsContact: Nancy WilliamsWomen’s spiritual growth group. Reading discussion.Centering time built around music.Ages: All Group size: 6-12
Men’s Bible StudyMonday, 6:30 - 7:30 am Church Parlor Contact: Mike Beecher
Study lectionary scripture readings for upcoming SundayAges: 30-80Group size: 14-24
Men’s Christmas BreakfastSaturday in December Fellowship Hall Contact: Mike Beecher or Matt McCormick
Breakfast served by Boy Scout Troop with a meditation and carols provided by Chris Urban & Ken Whitney
ConnectionsContact: Cindy KoernerGroup of primarily retired men who meet weekly for fellowship and who perform a variety of “handyman” type projects, saving the church thousands of dollars in maintenance & repair.Ages: 60-85Group size: 10
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 90
Fellowship and Life Stage Affinity GroupsPathways
Contact: Lauren HaasSocial and service group for families, couples and individuals.Monthly service projects and gatherings. Will add Bible Study in future.Ages: 20’s-30’s Group size: 18
The BridgeSunday, 10am Contact: Kelly Dean
25-35 families participate at various times of year
Just FriendsSaturdays Contact: Pam Miller
Singles Social Group with Saturday social activitiesAges: 50+Group Size: 5-10
TrendsettersEvery 3rd Saturday Fellowship Hall Contact: Dick Hennessy
Edie Jolly & Nancy Conning also contactsSocial group with small groups within take turns planning.Ages: 60+Group Size: 30-40
Prime Time LiveQuarterly Contact: Chuck Cooper or Rich Reinschmidt
Social group for singles and couples. Events in member’s homes as well as outings like RaviniaAges: 50’s-60’sGroup size: 40-50
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 91
Mission Activities
South Dakota MissionSummer Contact: Richard Scott
Cooperative effort of Dakota Partnership which includesKnox Presbyterian Church, Pullman Presbyterian and the Native American churches In the Dakota Presbytery. Construction projects and assistance with VBS.Ages: Youth thru adultGroup size: 20-30
Ghana MissionContact: Sue MinarikCooperative effort of First Pres, Good Shepherd and Knox Various mission type tasks, group evolves with timeAges: Sr. High and upGroup size: 5-10
Dominican RepublicContact: Roger BertelsonAlmost 30 years in existence, this partnership with churches in the DR performs construction projects, provides ESL training, leads children’s programs and Bible schools and much more.Ages: Sr. High and upGroup size: 5-10
Congo SupportContact: Phyllis GreenVaried ways to be involved.Ages: All
PADSTuesdays, October - April Contact: Linda Downie
Provides meals and shelter one night per week in Fellowship Hall from October thru April 30th.Ages: young adult – seniorsGroup size: 250+ volunteers in database
Meals on WheelsContact: Mary Krigas or Pat GiovanniniDeliver food to the homebound on weekdays
Habitat for HumanityContact Nancy AsheHelps build & repair houses for low income families
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 92
Middle School MissionYear round (local) Summer (local & away) Contacts: Emily Karstens or Beth Freese Dammers
Throughout the year, youth take part in various mission activities in our surrounding communities. During the summer, youth travel to various parts of the country to serve those in need, enabling youth to grow closer to God, one another, the people they serve and create lifelong memories. 6th, 7th and 8th gradersSummer 2011: 10 youth 3 adults;2011-2012 school year: 20-25
Senior High Mission:Year round (local) Summer (local & away) Contacts: Emily Karstens or Beth Freese Dammers
Throughout the year, youth take part in various mission activities in our surrounding communities. During the summer, youth travel to various parts of the country to serve those in need, enabling youth to grow closer to God, one another, the people they serve and create lifelong memories.9th, 10th, 11th, 12th graders2011: 15 youth 3 adults; school year: about 20-25
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 93
Youth Activities and Education
Middle School & Senior High Youth Groups, 4:11Wednesdays during school year Contacts: Emily Karstens or Beth Freese Dammers
Weekly youth group (4:11) is a time for youth to gather together for fun and fellowship. Through a shared meal, worship and small group discussion time, the youth are able to talk about what it means to be a Christian in today’s world.
Senior High Sunday SchoolSundays during school year Contacts: Emily Karstens or Beth Freese Dammers
Every Sunday senior high youth gather for food, prayer, Bible study and fellowship. Together they look at how the Bible intersects with their daily lives and what it means to be created in God’s image. 9th – 12th graders25-40 youth
Montreat Youth ConferenceSummer Contacts: Emily Karstens or Beth Freese Dammers
Senior High and recent HS graduates attend this weeklong conference in the mountains of North Carolina together with around 1000 other Presbyterian youth. With daily thought-provoking keynote messages, small group sessions, recreation, and worship, this is a great opportunity to connect with other Presbyterians, both youth and adults from around the country.9th grade – recent graduates2011: 25 youth and adult advisors
Y-Search Sunday SchoolSundays during school year Contacts: Emily Karstens or Beth Freese Dammers
Every Sunday, 6th and 7th graders gather for a time to grow in faith. By asking questions and searching, youth are able to transition toward taking ownership of their faith and making decisions about what they believe, who God is and how to live faithfully in the world.6th and 7th graders20-30 youth
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 94
Confirmation ClassSundays during school year Contacts: Beth Freese Dammers
A year-long Confirmation program focuses on preparing 8th graders for adult membership in the church. Through worship, fellowship opportunities and weekly class time youth are able to grow in their faith and understanding of membership in the church.8th grade15-25 youth
Children’s Activities and Education
KingdomSundays during school year Contacts: Beth Freese Dammers
Children in kindergarten through 5th grade meet on the upper level of the Christian Education building for Kingdom, a Workshop Rotation model Sunday School. First Pres was identified by Time Magazine as an innovator and early adopter of this approach to children’s Christian education.Kindergarten – 5th graders
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 95
Adult Education
First ForumSundays during school year Contacts: Beth Freese Dammers
First Forum is a center for adult learning. Its purpose is to foster lifelong spiritual growth for both members and community friends of all faiths. Opportunities are designed for persons at all stages of their faith journeys with a variety of needs Adult participants
Anniversary Speaker SeriesContacts: Beth Freese DammersFeatures well known speakers of both church and community interest.Adult and youth participants
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 96
First Presbyterian Music Ministries
Adult Choirs/Musical opportunities for Adults: Director and Contact: Ken Whitney
Chancel Choir (70 singers) The Chancel Choir is the foundation of the music program at FPCAH. This dedicated group of singers provides musical leadership primarily at the 10:00 a.m. worship service and occasionally at the 8:30 a.m. worship service. Additionally, special worship services and concerts are scheduled during the year, which feature the Chancel Choir, soloists, and full orchestra. Rehearsals are held each Thursday from 7:30-9 p.m. in the Choir Rehearsal Room.Chamber Singers (24 singers) The Chambers Singers are a small auditioned group of about 20 that sings a wide variety of music. Chamber singers participate in worship twice a month at either the 8:30 or 10:00 a.m. worship service. They also participate in the Christmas and spring choral concerts. Rehearsals are held the second and fourth Tuesday of the month from 7:30-8:30 p.m. in the Choir Rehearsal Room.Men's Chorus (20 singers) The Men's Chorus sings once every eight weeks at either the 8:30 or 10:00 a.m. worship service. Rehearsals are held the first and the third Thursday of the month from 6:30-7:20 p.m. in the Chapel Choir Room, preceding the Chancel Choir rehearsal.
Chancel Hand bell Choir (10 players) Contact: Jo ChristianThe Chancel Hand bell Choir rings about every six weeks for the 8:30 & 10:00 a.m. worship services. Persons interested in this group should have music reading skill and be able to follow a line of music; however, previous ringing experience is not necessary. Rehearsals are held each Thursday from 6:30-7:30 p.m. in the Hand bell Rehearsal Room, preceding the Chancel Choir rehearsal
Youth Choir (20 singers)The Westminster Youth Chorale is First Presbyterian’s newest choir, featuring selected singers from grades 6-12. Members learn and perform outstanding music for concert and worship performances. The Chorale sings a repertoire of all styles and genres, including works by master composers, multicultural music, gospel, vocal jazz, etc. Singers at this level work to develop a wider vocal range and a more mature tone, and develop strong habits of teamwork and performance style.
Children's Choirs (30 singers) providing religious, educational, and recreational opportunities for the children developing an understanding of worship encouraging a sense of personal responsibility and cooperation and presenting worthy music, well-prepared, to the glory of God
Cherub Choir-Age group: K-3rd grade, Rehearsal: Wednesday 4:45-5:15, Place: Choir RehearsalCarol Choir-Age group: 4th & 5th grade, Rehearsal: Wednesday 4:45-5:15, Place: Choir Rehearsal
5/6/2023 First Presbyterian Church – Mission Study 2011 Page 97