Download - Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
-
7/28/2019 Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
1/32
9
E Fu Ig
N Kj E I
Keta M
T g g v u vg vu g -
. I u -
g , gu v ug
. T g
u vu v gu , u vu
gu u u g
-u
. H, v gu ,
qu gv
v . N , g u- v u -
v, , g
, v, , , , gu x
g g , -
g. T g u g
x u g .
O u g N
Kj (19001990), g J g. E
-
7/28/2019 Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
2/32
10 | Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
I (K to soku), N u
, v g g gg
u g. H g
g ug g. A ,
v ug.
I , x u N ,
I u u u
u g ug. T
uu , u g g
qu u g
v. T u u qu
gug g u.
Emptiness, sky, and the simile of the two rooms
T u u E
I v
Bu (nya). N u Bu x v g u
g (Bild) x . H gu
, , -
. I , v ,
D g -
, ju , . T -
E I.
N u vgg .
H gu ug xg
v gv x
(nkc 12: 131). P x ug .
F , ,
1. T, ug u , I - qu . T u g I
u.
-
7/28/2019 Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
3/32
keta masako | 11
u v gv. I -
, N gu,
g u. T qu
u g g. Tx u, N g .
T u . S
x a b, g
a. W x, ,
x b a. A ,
v, x x b, g a,
g a. S a ,
a, a uu. W
g u b. S g b
b uu. Pg,
b. Bu , v, y,
b a, a
b. I x a b. (N
2000, 1967).
T u g - .
Bu u
g x
. Ag, g
I uu g
vu g.
L u N x. H u,
u, x uu u : uu ju ju. N u
u -
, ju, uu
g .
T u Religion
and Nothingness, N , -
x g .
T g u
-
7/28/2019 Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
4/32
12 | Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
(nkc 10: 166). T , g
u x g u vu
u g. F -
v, g gu. Bu . Tg v g, uu
. A u g, N,
ug g .
I u Hu -
g D . T
u Fg Huayan wujiaozhang
g uu g
g, u Hu Bu. T g u
v x, -
v vg vg (Fazhan 199, 96).
T u u g,
g . T -
, , u g,
g .
W u u, uj - , uj -
. A , , v ,
uj. I g
uj , uj,
g uj v. W u v
ug , g uu .
T, u, Fg v. I -
g, v u-, u u u. Muu
g,
v u u v u, -
u u u. I uu
Hu
Bu x u g u
u u.
I E I, N
-
7/28/2019 Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
5/32
keta masako | 13
uu u . T
v Hu u N
. R, u u
N ug. I u, -u ,
v, v N.
T u u-
ju, v, vg
u . I -
, ,
u u,
ug u, , gg g -
. Mv,
x a b
g. I gu (
u ),
a b, c, d,
, u, g g . T
u u. T u , -
. T g ug -
v ( ,
, g , vu -
), g u x .
W ju u x .
W N
g g a b g ,
a u b (nkc 12: 133). a a ,
b, c, ., v u -. Bu -
g : a
b? N g g. I
, u ahineinbildt
b. I gg a. I gg u u-
u . T
-
7/28/2019 Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
6/32
14 | Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
u N ug ,
, v
g.
I Religion and NothingnessN u , g , g
g. Bu , u
g v -
u (nkc 10: 17). T u
vu v,
, g g -
. I ug. S g u
gu g u, g v. I , N
g g ,
g v u , u
g. I , g g
v g g u-
.
N u ,
g g u, g
g u, g
. W g N gv -
g v vg M E
Bild(g, ). I God and Absolute Nothingness
(19), N E G
u, xg x
G ( S G) v Gg, u g G G u
g g . T g, g
, u:
B u G Bild(G -j) u,
G uv bilden( g
g) Bild gv g Bild. I -gvg
u S G
ug u G. (nkc 7: 6)
-
7/28/2019 Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
7/32
keta masako | 15
T gg u
E I. I ug gg
u uu .
I Religion and Nothingness u uu -
vg u . W
E I u u
uu u .
W g, , gv gg? I
, vg uu -
u u .
The strctre of world relationship
F N uu x
logos D- u
. T u ,
u ,
, , uu -
, -, u
2. Cg E , W u G, G, N :
A g logos , u g -g g uv G . H G -g. T u G g -g (Bild) , , g . T Bild G G
S , Bild G W. A g-g g G Bildg G S. G S G . A g -g g , G,g S G, G Bild. (nkz 7: 60.)
I , g E Bild logos. A , g v g logos, Bild g v.
3. N g : I E , ahineinbildt b gg
a (nkz 13: 13).
-
7/28/2019 Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
8/32
16 | Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
-u. Muu N
uu j ug
g . I Hu , ,
x uu .4 N u u uu
uu g
uu :
. T u
g uv
. I u ,
g g v, uu -
g u g. I , u
g. I u x,
u vu,
( x uu
g ). N
uu g
uu . Bu
u , u uu u-
qu vu. H g g x
.
I logos D-
u
. Ag N, logos
. S
ug u g
ug gg uu , xg
ug logos gug, g u
. W
u g, u-
. I u ,
. I g uu x g u: ,
.
-
7/28/2019 Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
9/32
keta masako | 17
u g. T
g
u u x ug .
T , N logos logos u -
, g x
. Mv, logos x . I
g ,
u
u . S, g
logos gug u . Fu,
gu logos- u g.
A u u.
T v Hu , , g -
g, uv
(Kimra 1992, 223).5 N -
x g , g
vg
g , g . T g u g uv. N
g
g . I -
u N . T , I v,
N g u x
g vgg .
N x noesis noeseos. T -
g x g u u, g u , g
u u v
. Ev Hu , g u. I v, - g v. A , u , u, qu u ,
vu gu g.
-
7/28/2019 Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
10/32
18 | Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
g. O g u
g g . T u
noesis noeseos.
T noesis noeseosg A, N-P Pu, v u -
Hg u g (nkc 13: 1). T
, vg
g , g , u u v
g. A u u
g, u
g u (aufgehoben), v
u u g, u g. I , N
uv vu
g . A , ug
, x
u .
T uu , u
logos D- u -
, . W , v g, x g,
, uu ,
.
L u uu . T g uu
uu. T -
uu g
u u . E
u u g v. W u u-
u , g
. W vu x g
, toposg u. M-
v, g g u v. I
, g , u
g , g -
u v. S u
-
7/28/2019 Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
11/32
keta masako | 19
uu u v uu
g, v -u.
T ,
g . O u g
. T , -u, u-
. A v, , u uu
u-
u, u u u
-u. T u u
x g v x -
u vu. A x, g - v gv u ju ;
g u, g
g . N u .
F , x vu g -
u -u.
I , u uu u-
, g
u vug. T , gg
g . W x g -
g u ,
u . T
u -u
. H
. Au -u g . I , N g
:
6. N u things facts u. H g v x, g v x u u - g , g . I , x, g , , u g x-
, (nkz 13: 10).
-
7/28/2019 Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
12/32
20 | Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
T , u -
uu u
u -u, . T
u u uu uu -. T u
g vu. T
u , -u
g, . T
g, x, (
g, ), ,
g topos g
v, u u g -g ,
u g. O ,
g u g u -
g -
u -u
g u
g . T
u g.
(nkc 13: 1.)
T v
u g vu x u
u -
, v, -
. M
-u ,
u g. S ,
u .
I, logos -u
, g g g
v . T -
x uu u -
u . W qu logos u
g . Bu -
-
7/28/2019 Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
13/32
keta masako | 21
u -u g uu
. T
. I , g u
u logos g v.N u u v -. T
u v gg ,
u u u
-u u. T
-u , , uu v-
g u ,
vg , , uu g, v
u . T uv x-
g vg u
. T , g -
u , N D-
u g. T -u
u x ; ,
u g x
-. I , -u- u
u g.
W u u u g D-
u g. S u
D- Hu g
u g ug u g g
gu u , N D-
u g u g , g, x v D-
u .
A g N ? A , N-
D- u
g u D-
7. Ev Hu Bu, u,
uv g g g. S Kimra 1992, 22.
-
7/28/2019 Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
14/32
22 | Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
u , D-
u g
v - vg
D- u . W D-
u g u g,
u u N
u g.
I g g
g, gug logos u g
v. H, -
g D u D-
u g.
Hv, u
u
uu. I
D-
u D-
u g, u u g u
. Bu g u
u , -
u u ?
Cg u D- Hu -
, N
D- u g.
F N, , D- u g gu u . I
u , N
ug Hu Z . Hv,
N u g-
. Aug u , N
g, g g
.
H N, v
-
7/28/2019 Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
15/32
keta masako | 23
,
g u -u -
. I , Hu Z u-
u qu .N -
, u ug, v N-
g E I
Z g u
u -
, u .
H N u
u g u gg,
-u g.
Makin eistence transparentand fndamental imaination
Su , , vu x -u . Bu
x ,
u -, u g ,
g
. T v -
, vu x ,
N g x . T
u g x x . I , x
u g. I ,
g, , -
v g (nkc 13: 11). W u u-
x g,
. I
g , logos- -u
-
7/28/2019 Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
16/32
24 | Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
vu
uu gg.
Ug x Hu , N
-u g u M. A M. B g u, u
, gv j-
g. T x u vg g
v u. Aug -u g
u g u
, g u g. T
g u u
logos. B M. A M. B g u,
, logos- u u . I
u. T u u u x-
g g u
. W u
g g.
Pu , uu g
u u v v g g u-, g , u u g u
u g g u g g
v . Pu
, g u x ,
g g
u gg g u g
.
N v g ,
v M. A M.
B. g u. I
. T u g u
u . Bu
g u u g u
. F x, M. A M. B ,
u u, u
-
7/28/2019 Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
17/32
keta masako | 25
. I g x,
u u ggg u .
W ugg u, g g
ju g u , g . P u
g g , g -
g, , u gg,
uu Ru O u (Otto 1979). T
uu u g u, vg ,
-, u u. T x
v
x g ug . Mv, g x v u vu g.
I g, v, u v-
v u . N-
u, g g -
g,
u .8 T g
N ,
u g D , g
D g u.
W u x u-
g -
g g u -u,
v g g
g? T
g u g x
g. Fu, uu
. N u -u g Hu , u -u E x u (ohne Hindernisse). I God and Absolute Nothingness, N: S M wesentlich( u , x-, x G), u . H g u u g g v g v g G
(nkz 7: 90).
-
7/28/2019 Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
18/32
26 | Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
u
g u g
. T
g g. I x u g
g : u g g -
x g , u -
g u u .
T x -u
u u , -u
vg, g
g . T g u g g u
u g. I ,
u g gg g
, g g u .
F g x
g ug u g uu
g g . A g
, v -v u u ,
, .
S, u g u
u g, v
, , u
g. T v
u u g
g . T g . A , -
u g uu
g g
vg. W
, u g.
T -u g, , u -
g u , u
g . Hv, v g. T
-
7/28/2019 Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
19/32
keta masako | 27
u g , u g -
v. T ugg Z u F u
T . Ju u-
g g, g -g g. B g g, N
gg g-
, u g A
v K Hgg.
N u g E I-
. Bu g
sensus communis,
v g A (g uu ug ). Ig
, N
,
g
, g , -
v g. (nkc 13: 1)
T , g g g u , v
- g g.
T g, N
u . H gu , -
, g x u
g g, , g x
u . Fg
ug, g g .Ig u g g
. A g -
v u u u g
. F N, u g
. A v, g ug g-
gu gv
, u
. C g, g,
-
7/28/2019 Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
20/32
28 | Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
u u g ,
u .
W, , ? I Studies
on Aristotle, N x (- ) g (g g) A
g : T v u -
g ug , v
. T -
g v v
u g. W v
g , g g-
(nkc : 6). W g , sensus communis u. T sensus communis
u vg vu (
g, u, ), u g v
v u. T, sensus com-
munis u vu . Mv, g
sensus communis (nkc : 7, 6). T
g sensus communis Studies
on Aristotle g N g E
I. S u
u .
I u g-
u. T u u
g D-
u g. Bu N
x u g g.
I T P Ev (192) N
, x u u g
g u g (nkc 6: 22-6).
T , , u -u u g,
u , u u u u
g, , v, g v. Bu
u ,
-
7/28/2019 Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
21/32
keta masako | 29
u, , g ,
x. Eg xv v -ug.
A u -ug , u g
u . T u- u u u u
u g. Iu g
, -
g. T N
u .
T ug g u u
K. I K, v, g g-
g vg g u v. T g u g-
g j u. I ,
N g g :
u g vg
u . I ,
, x, v vuu
, v
g u u -g. Tu, u
x u ,
u u g.
Ig g K
v. Bu g v
u x. T -
- g -
ug , u v . H ujv -
g -. I -
g , g ug -,
, - , u
u u. T u
g N u . T g
-g , uj
, g u, ug
-
7/28/2019 Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
22/32
30 | Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
-g, u -g
v -g . F , N
u g
g.I N , g u
g u. Hv
u u . I g
D- u
g. T g, g-
u u , . I-
u g
u, g u g g . I u g g u
u g, v
g ug v u.
T -g g -,
u u
. T u g u g-
-. T g u
. A gu g u u - , v , . T
g u . T g
u -, -g,
. I v v x
, u gv .
U g, g
g, g D-
u g g v g v . Cg u v,
u v g g
. W u g g
u g u
v. I v ,
v g g
u g v u
g.
-
7/28/2019 Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
23/32
keta masako | 31
T u g , v, -
v u u ug N u
u g E I. T
, ug g, ( ug), uu ,
v g. I u-
g vg u
, g
D- u g
vg u-
g u
g.T u u u
u
u g, g-
u g: g
g (g - g). I
g, g u gg g
u . H v g -.
Bgg u u g,
g , ,
u g. O, u g g-
u g. I , u-
g u g u u
g g g gu .
W u qu g,
g ,
u u.
Emptiness and transferrin and reflectin
T -u g
, g , u ,
g, u v -
, , , . I
-
7/28/2019 Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
24/32
32 | Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
, Bu g -
u g gu u g
u g . Wu g,
u v u uu uug.W, , u u
g g u u gu g
u, ? T g g, N -
u u g
, v u u:
T, uu . O ,
u g g, vu. O , v ,
g g ,
, g -
. Hv, -
-u
. (nkc 13: 1)
T logos. S u
logos -u - x u
g, v
logosu . I-
u , -u
g u g . I -
, uu v g .
Hv, gu
x. I u g , x, v . T
u , u, uu
. T g , uu v--
v u logos. T -
gu uu .
T u qu uu
u g -g v . T-
, uu u g
-
7/28/2019 Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
25/32
keta masako | 33
, u u g u
u (ug u -g g -g).
T uu u g u
u u u . Aug u, - u , u
v . O u, v
, , -g v
g. W v u
v, u
. Bu , u
u u . I,
u , u . I uu u
g v uu u v g,
u gv ug
g u. G g, v,
uu u g v u .
Ev , -
gg u .
I , u g Z u . T Z g, v
u g, u g
. T
u x D-
u . R,
u u
u , ug u .
T , u, - u g u .
T u (sekaisei) Z u g
u . I v,
g ug g
g g g
u make themselves present in the opening of the world. I
g, ug
g u. I
-
7/28/2019 Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
26/32
34 | Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
u u Z gu.
S u,
u Z gu u, -
, v u. I g u Z u g
vu. W ,
v point from which ,
v v u , u .
Iu u,
u . A logos
. I g Z -
gug Z gu, u ju g g . F , ug g
g,
Z v u u .
W g Z gu ,
vuu g . T vu v, g
u u . I ,
v , u
u , vu v u g. W v vu-
Z u g
, v
u vg g. T N
.
T , ug g u u
x , u g u v u g g
Z u g. (nkc 13: 160)
T u , u u
v uggv . N u
J utsusu (utsusu
) (utsusu). S -
gu , u g -
(utsusareru) g ,
-
7/28/2019 Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
27/32
keta masako | 35
(utsusareru) u u (nkc 10: 17). Bu
(), g -
v u g.
I x Hu , (utsusu) (utsusu) u v -
g u. F x, Fg Huayan wujiao-
zhang, u (parinipanna) u
: g , v g
g (v g), u (Fazhan 199, 63).
L, j I u -
u
x (Kimra 199, 117). F ,
g I , g j. T j
, j u
, u. T
. H, j g
(utsusu) g (utsuru) g , u
j, g
g v. I , v -
v u v v. I
j, g g
g.
W g u
j v u-
x j
x. Bu x u , Huayan Stra u-
x x v u .S g u xg
x . Bu g
N , g g
uu v
9. T I j Hu qu Z . Xu u D- -u g, Xgxu u
u P Su O V.
-
7/28/2019 Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
28/32
36 | Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
g. T x -
u g , v ug
, gg. W
g ug v v g -
g. F ,
g u g.
R N K -
, u u j. Bu
u , v. N,
, u Hu x. I
ug u E N . N E u
Bild G u u Bild -
u u, uv bilden Bild
gv g Bild. T vu
. T u u g -
g v.
T . T
g a, xg b, g a. T b g a
g a. W u, b, g,
a, b . Uu b
g a, gv -
b . Bu u
g a g g b , a
g g b. T g-
g . Mv, uu u g u -
. T
g , P g. I v
u g
.
W u , g, i, g
gv u. I g g
g g. O u,
-
7/28/2019 Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
29/32
keta masako | 37
g g, g gv .
T g ; g exists
u , u existence ug
g gg. Sug A sensus communis g g-
v E I, u
g g (
g j g u), g -
g u sensus
communis u. I g
u sensus communis. T u
gg g . I , gg, u,
g .
I , g g u-
u ug g, g u
g g.
T ugg :
g a b . F
a , u uu . T , . A a, u-
u b. D
u u, g a
g a g x b,
g b g b g x
a, g . T
g g u .
T g g g- . C g g
, ? T
.
10. I v g g , u g .T gu g g g g uu v
v.
-
7/28/2019 Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
30/32
38 | Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
A v, u uu, Z u
g u . T u Z
u g u g g. S
g u , u g uu . Fu g u u
u g g g . I
u u gv g g
g . T,
u g u g.
Mg x a
a. Bu ; . T -u g ,
v g uv,
v . I
. A u , u
ug g g v
g g g uv.
T g
. T ,
Z g g,
Z g, g-
, . R
v u
g g
. O .
A
Z g.
Conclsion
T g g
. I g g
g , g
g vuu. T uu x
-
7/28/2019 Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
31/32
keta masako | 39
qu g x v
vv , ju .
N u u
u g u g u . C -
g Z Hu Bu.
Tg g ju u, -
, . I , ,
v. Bu g g
g u u uv g-
v g g u . I u
u u v N g g u v.
I g -
g g, , N ,
v u g g
. I , u
u ug g
g u g ,
g g , g u g.
T u -
gu
v .
Aug N v g g
, gg g g v
g . W
ug uu uu g v, utsusu (utsusu) -
g uggv g. I g
I, I j v,
g u x u-g, u-
, u . T -
g g
g. W N g
.
-
7/28/2019 Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
32/32
40 | Emptiness and Fundamental Imagination
References
Abbreviation
nkc[C N Kj] (T: Su-, 196-199), 26 v.
Other Sources
Fazhan
199[C v g Kg -
] J , Ku K ,
[M Bu x: C J] (T: C
K), v. 7.
Kimra K 1992[A C Hu] (K: Huj
S).
Nishitani Kj
2000 E S, M M, Modern Jap-anese Aesthetics(Huu: Uv H P), 179217.
Otto, Ru
1979 Das Heilige: ber das irrationale in der Idee des Gttlichen und Verhlt-
nis zen Rationalen(M: C. H. B).
[translated by Robert F. Rhodes]