Philippine Appliance Corporation (PHILACOR) vs. CAFacts:PHILACOR is a domestic corporation engaged in manufacturing refrigerators, freezers, and washing machines while United Philacor Worers Union!"A#LU is the dul$ elected collecti%e &argaining representati%e of the compan$'s emplo$ees(In the )**+ collecti%e &argaining negotiations of the management and the union, PHILACOR o,ered P-,...(.. to each emplo$ee as an /earl$ conclusion &onus(01he &onus was a unilateral incenti%e for speeding up the collecti%e &argaining negotiations and to encourage the union to e2ert its &est e,orts to conclude a C3A according to the PHILACOR(Upon the e2piration of their C3A, PHILACOR and the union &egan their negotiations(Howe%er, after )) meetings, the parties failed to reach an agreement forcing the union to declare a deadloc(Conse4uentl$, the union 5led a "otice of 6trie(7%en with the help of "C83, the parties still failed to reach an agreement regarding wages, rice su&sid$, and signing and retroacti%e &onus( And for thesecond time, the union 5led a "otice of 6trie(1he said strie lasted for )) da$s(La&or 6ecretar$ Laguesma assumed 9urisdiction o%er the dispute(He issued a return to wor order directing the emplo$ees to return to wor within :- hours and the compan$ to accept the said emplo$ees(On April )-, :..., 6ecretar$ Laguesma issued an order to &e incorporated in the C3A(One of which is the awarding of P;,...(.. signing &onus to e%er$ emplo$ee of the compan$(PHILACOR's argument