![Page 1: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY
February 28, 2019
As required by § 28-83, D.R.M.C., of the Denver city ordinance, the Division of Small Business Opportunity (DSBO) in the Office of Economic Development (OED) is required to conduct a disparity study approximately every 5 years to evaluate the utilization of minority and women-owned contractors in city procurement of construction, professional design, and goods and services. The results of the study are used to collect evidence of the city’s current contracting practices and assess the need for, and continuation of, the DSBO Minority and Women Business Enterprise (MWBE) program.
OED engaged BBC Research & Consulting (BBC) to conduct a 2018 Disparity Study that examined:
1) The city’s procurement of construction, professional design, goods and services from 2012-2016
2) DSBO’s goal-setting process for contracting with small, minority and woman-owned businesses from 2012-2016
3) Legal precedents and analysis of federal law, state law, Denver city ordinance and case law, including Adarand Constructors, Inc. v. Slater, 228 F.3d 1147 (10th Cir. 2000); Concrete Works of Colorado, Inc. v. City and County of Denver, 321 F.3d 950 (2003), and any recent updates
4) Quantitative and qualitative analysis of the availability, utilization and disparity of minority and women-owned businesses
5) General market-conditions for the seven-county metro Denver business community The findings of the study demonstrate that a disparity still exists in the use of MWBE firms in city procurement practices--and affirms the need to continue DSBO’s use of programmatic measures that are race and gender conscious.
“Information from the disparity study will help the city to continue to encourage the participation of minority and women owned businesses in its contracting and procurement. In addition, it will help the city implement the MWBE and federal DBE programs effectively and in a legally-defensible manner.”
– BBC Research and Consulting, 2018 Disparity Study, City and County of Denver
Next Steps:
Business Equity Leadership Team
At the direction of Mayor Michael B. Hancock, the executive leadership of the largest city agencies and capital programs have convened to form the Business Equity Leadership Team (BELT). Public Works, Denver International Airport, Parks & Recreation, Arts & Venues, General Services, the Elevate Denver Bond project, Department of Finance, and the Mayor’s Office of the National Western Center compose BELT’s membership.
BELT is developing a Master Utilization Plan that will align recommendations from the community and the disparity study to ensure that small, minority and woman-owned businesses are engaged and afforded more opportunities for equitable participation in city contracts. Over the next two years, these agencies and programs will be accountable in implementing BELT’s strategies and tactics and will provide quarterly updates to the Mayor and community. BELT will be releasing the Master Utilization plan in the Spring of 2019.
2019 DSBO Priorities
In response to the results of the 2018 Disparity Study and in cooperation with the Mayor’s Office, Denver City Council, supporting agencies and community partners, DSBO has identified the following priorities for 2019:
![Page 2: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance, implement rules, regulations, policies and programs.
2) Restructure Goal Setting Procedures – DSBO will set project-specific goals based on scopes of work, market data/considerations and the availability of certified firms.
3) Develop and Implement a Mentor Protégé Program – In coordination with other agencies and programs, DSBO will develop a Mentor Protégé program that will allow small, minority and woman-owned businesses to build capacity and working relationships.
4) Selection Criteria and RFP Language – Re-evaluate and revise the selection criteria and RFP language to adhere to the city’s values supporting business equity.
5) Revising Goods and Services Ordinance – Revise the city’s ordinance to foster greater participation of small, minority and women owned businesses in General Services contracts for goods and services.
6) Unbundling Procurements – Create a pipeline of opportunities for small, minority and woman-owned businesses to prime on city contracts.
7) Contract Compliance – Formalize internal processes that will support the integrity of the DSBO program and ensure that small, minority and woman-owned businesses can perform successfully on contracts.
8) Education and Outreach to Small Business Community – Develop community-friendly tools to help small, minority and woman-owned businesses learn about city contracting processes and bid opportunities.
9) DSBO Staffing – Identify staff and other resources needed to ensure that DSBO’s 2019 priorities are met.
10) Construction Empowerment Initiative (CEI) Recommendations – Review, prioritize, and implement CEI’s recommendations that are in alignment with the city’s mission to create an equitable path to prosperity for all business and residents.
DSBO will continue to keep the community apprised and solicit feedback from stakeholders as it implements these priorities.
The City and County of Denver values the important role that minority, woman and small business enterprises play in the local economy. Their success is essential to job creation and economic growth. The Office of Economic Development’s Division of Small Business Opportunity is committed to advancing the policies, processes, training, compliance, certification and community engagement necessary to propel small businesses forward.
Our team is honored to lead this work and will continue to advance a vibrant economy that works for everyone.
If you have any questions about the 2018 Disparity Study, please contact us at [email protected].
Best,
Eric Hiraga
Executive Director, Denver Office of Economic Development
![Page 3: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
FINAL REPORT
2018 Disparity Study
City and County of Denver
![Page 4: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Final Report
February 2018
2018 City and County of Denver Disparity Study
Prepared for City and County of Denver Prepared by BBC Research & Consulting 1999 Broadway, Suite 2200 Denver, Colorado 80202‐9750 303.321.2547 fax 303.399.0448 www.bbcresearch.com [email protected]
![Page 5: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Table of Contents
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT i
ES. Executive Summary
A. Analyses in the Disparity Study ........................................................................................... ES–2
B. Availability Analysis Results ................................................................................................. ES–3
C. Utilization Analysis Results .................................................................................................. ES–5
D. Disparity Analysis Results .................................................................................................... ES–7
E. Program Implementation .................................................................................................. ES–11
1. Introduction
A. Background ........................................................................................................................... 1–2
B. Study Scope ........................................................................................................................... 1–4
C. Study Team Members ........................................................................................................... 1–7
2. Legal Analysis
Programs that Rely Only on Race‐ and Gender‐Neutral Measures ........................................... 2–1
Programs that Rely on Race‐ and Gender‐Neutral and Race‐ and Gender‐Conscious Measures ............................................................................................................................ 2–1
3. Marketplace Conditions
A. Human Capital ....................................................................................................................... 3–2
B. Financial Capital .................................................................................................................... 3–6
C. Business Ownership .............................................................................................................. 3–9
D. Business Success ................................................................................................................. 3–11
E. Summary .............................................................................................................................. 3–13
4. Collection and Analysis of Contract Data
A. Overview of Contracting and Procurement Policies ............................................................. 4–1
B. Collection and Analysis of Contract Data and Procurement Data......................................... 4–5
C. Collection of Vendor Data ..................................................................................................... 4–6
D. Relevant Geographic Market Area ........................................................................................ 4–7
E. Relevant Types of Work ......................................................................................................... 4–7
F. Collection of Bid and Proposal Data .................................................................................... 4–10
G. Agency Review Process ....................................................................................................... 4–10
5. Availability Analysis
A. Purpose of the Availability Analysis ...................................................................................... 5–1
B. Potentially Available Businesses ........................................................................................... 5–1
C. Businesses in the Availability Database ................................................................................. 5–3
D. Availability Calculations ........................................................................................................ 5–3
E. Availability Results ................................................................................................................. 5–6
![Page 6: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Table of Contents
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT ii
6. Utilization Analysis
Overall Results ........................................................................................................................... 6–1
Contract Goals ........................................................................................................................... 6–1
Contract Role ............................................................................................................................. 6–2
DEN Contracts ........................................................................................................................... 6–3
Industry ..................................................................................................................................... 6–3
Time Period ............................................................................................................................... 6–4
Concentration of Dollars ........................................................................................................... 6–4
7. Disparity Analysis
A. Overview ............................................................................................................................... 7–1
B. Disparity Analysis Results ...................................................................................................... 7–5
C. Statistical Significance ......................................................................................................... 7–11
D. Bid/Proposal Processes ....................................................................................................... 7–13
8. Program Measures
A. Program Overview................................................................................................................. 8–1
B. Race‐ and Gender‐Neutral Measures .................................................................................... 8–2
C. Race‐ and Gender‐Conscious Measures ................................................................................ 8–5
D. Other Organizations’ Program Measures ............................................................................. 8–5
9. Program Implementation
Aspirational MWBE and DBE Goals ........................................................................................... 9–1
Other Program Considerations .................................................................................................. 9–4
Appendices
A. Definitions of Terms
B. Legal Framework and Analysis
C. Quantitative Analysis
D. Qualitative Information about Marketplace Conditions
E. Availability Analysis Approach
F. Disparity Tables
![Page 7: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
CHAPTER ES.
Executive Summary
![Page 8: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER ES, PAGE 1
CHAPTER ES. Executive Summary
TheCityandCountyofDenver(TheCity)retainedBBCResearch&Consulting(BBC)toconductadisparitystudytohelprefinetheorganization’simplementationoftheMinority‐andWomen‐ownedBusinessEnterprise(MWBE)Program,theEmergingBusinessEnterprise(EBE)Program,andtheSmallBusinessEnterprise(SBE)Programforitslocally‐fundedcontractsandtheFederalDisadvantagedBusinessEnterprise(DBE)ProgramfortheFederalAviationAdministration(FAA)‐fundedcontractsthattheDenverInternationalAirport(DEN)awards.Theprimaryobjectivesofthoseprogramsrevolvearoundencouragingtheparticipationofsmallbusinessesandminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinCitycontracting.1Tomeetthatobjective,theCityusesacombinationofrace‐andgender‐neutralandrace‐andgender‐consciousprogrammeasuresaspartofitscontractingpractices.Inthecontextofcontracting,race‐andgender‐neutralmeasuresaremeasuresdesignedtoencouragetheparticipationofsmallbusinessesinagovernmentorganization’scontracting,regardlessoftherace/ethnicityorgenderofthebusinesses’owners.Incontrasttorace‐andgender‐neutralmeasures,race‐andgender‐consciousmeasuresaremeasuresspecificallydesignedtoencouragetheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesingovernmentcontracting,suchasMWBEcontractgoals.
Aspartofthedisparitystudy,BBCassessedwhethertherewereanydisparitiesbetween:
ThepercentageofcontractdollarsthattheCityspentwithminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesduringthestudyperiodbetweenJanuary1,2012andDecember31,2016(i.e.,utilization,orparticipation);and
Thepercentageofcontractdollarsthatminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesmightbeexpectedtoreceivebasedontheiravailabilitytoperformspecifictypesandsizesoftheCity’sprimecontractsandsubcontracts(i.e.,availability).
Thedisparitystudyalsoexaminedotherquantitativeandqualitativeinformationrelatedto:
ThelegalframeworkrelatedtotheCity’simplementationoftheMWBE,EBE,SBE,andFederalDBEPrograms;
Localmarketplaceconditionsforminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesses;and
ContractingpracticesandbusinessassistanceprogramsthattheCitycurrentlyhasinplace.
TheCitycoulduseinformationfromthestudytohelprefineitsimplementationoftheMWBE,EBE,SBE,andFederalDBEPrograms,includingsettingaspirationalgoalsfortheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinCitycontracting;determiningwhichprogrammeasurestousetoencouragetheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesin
1“Woman‐ownedbusinesses”referstonon‐Hispanicwhitewomanownedbusinesses.Informationandresultsforminoritywoman‐ownedbusinessesareincludedalongwiththeircorrespondingracial/ethnicgroups.
![Page 9: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER ES, PAGE 2
Citycontracting;and,ifappropriate,determiningwhichracial/ethnicandgendergroupswouldbeeligibletoparticipateinanyrace‐orgender‐consciousprogrammeasuresthattheCitymightcontinueusinginthefuture.
BBCsummarizeskeyinformationfromthe2018CityofDenverDisparityStudyinfiveparts:
A. Analysesinthedisparitystudy;
B. Availabilityanalysisresults;
C. Utilizationanalysisresults;
D. Disparityanalysisresults;and
E. Programimplementation.
A. Analyses in the Disparity Study
Alongwithmeasuringdisparitiesbetweentheparticipationandavailabilityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinCitycontracts,BBCalsoexaminedotherinformationrelatedtotheCity’simplementationoftheMWBE,EBE,SBE,andFederalDBEPrograms:
Thestudyteamconductedananalysisoffederalregulations,caselaw,andotherinformationtoguidethemethodologyforthedisparitystudy.Theanalysisincludedareviewoflegalrequirementsrelatedtosmallbusinessandminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessprograms,includingtheMWBE,EBE,SBE,andFederalDBEPrograms(seeChapter2andAppendixB).
BBCconductedquantitativeanalysesofoutcomesforminorities;women;andminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesthroughouttherelevantgeographicmarketarea.2Inaddition,thestudyteamcollectedqualitativeinformationaboutpotentialbarriersfacedbyminorities;women;andminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinthelocalmarketplacethroughin‐depthinterviews,telephonesurveys,publicmeetings,andwrittentestimony(seeChapter3,AppendixC,andAppendixD).
BBCanalyzedthepercentageofrelevantCitycontractingdollarsthatminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesareavailabletoperform.Thatanalysiswasbasedontelephonesurveysthatthestudyteamcompletedwithnearly900businessesthatworkinindustriesrelatedtothespecifictypesofconstruction;professionalservices;andgoodsandservicescontractsthattheCityawards(seeChapter5andAppendixE).
BBCanalyzedthedollarsthatminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesreceivedonmorethan22,000construction;professionalservices;andgoodsandservicescontractsthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiod(seeChapter6).
BBCexaminedwhethertherewereanydisparitiesbetweentheparticipationandavailabilityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesonconstruction;professional
2BBCidentifiedtherelevantgeographicmarketareaforthedisparitystudyasAdams,Arapahoe,Boulder,Broomfield,Denver,Douglas,andJeffersonCountiesinColorado.
![Page 10: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER ES, PAGE 3
services;andgoodsandservicescontractsthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiod(seeChapter7).
BBCreviewedthemeasuresthattheCityusestoencouragetheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinitscontractingaswellasmeasuresthatotherorganizationsintheregionuse(seeChapter8).
BBCprovidedguidancerelatedtoadditionalprogramoptionsandpotentialchangestocurrentcontractingpracticesfortheCity’sconsideration(seeChapter9).
B. Availability Analysis Results
BBCusedacustomcensusapproachtoanalyzetheavailabilityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesforCityprimecontractsandsubcontracts.BBC’sapproachreliedoninformationfromsurveysthatthestudyteamconductedwithpotentiallyavailablebusinesseslocatedintherelevantgeographicmarketareathatperformworkwithinrelevantsubindustries.ThatapproachallowedBBCtodeveloparepresentativeandunbiaseddatabaseofpotentiallyavailablebusinessestoestimatetheavailabilityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinastatistically‐validmanner.
Overall.FigureES‐1presentsdollar‐weightedavailabilityestimatesbyrelevantracial/ethnicandgendergroupforallCitycontractsandprocurements.Overall,theavailabilityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesforCitycontractsandprocurementsis23.7percent,indicatingthatminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesmightbeexpectedtoreceive23.7percentofthedollarsthattheCityawardsinconstruction;professionalservices;andgoodsandservices.Non‐Hispanicwhitewoman‐ownedbusinesses(10.9%)andHispanicAmerican‐ownedbusinesses(6.2%)exhibitedthehighestavailabilitypercentagesamongallgroups.
Figure ES‐1. Overall availability estimates by racial/ethnic and gender group
Note:
Numbers rounded to nearest tenth of 1 percent and thus may not sum exactly to totals.
For more detail and results by group, see Figure F‐2 in Appendix F.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting availability analysis.
Contract goals.Duringthestudyperiod,theCityusedMWBEandDBEcontractgoalstoawardmanylocally‐fundedandfederally‐fundedcontracts,respectively,toencouragetheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesses.TheCity’suseofsuchcontractgoalsisarace‐andgender‐consciousmeasure.ItisusefultoexamineavailabilityanalysisresultsseparatelyforcontractsthattheCityawardswiththeuseofcontractgoals(goalscontracts)andcontractsthattheCityawardswithouttheuseofgoals(no‐goalscontracts).FigureES‐2presentsavailabilityestimatesseparatelyforgoalsandno‐goalscontracts.AsshowninFigureES‐2,theavailabilityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesconsideredtogetherisapproximatelyequalacrossgoalscontracts(23.1%)andno‐goalscontracts(24.1%).
Business group
Non‐Hispanic white woman‐owned 10.9 %
Asian American‐owned 3.2 %
Black American‐owned 3.3 %
Hispanic American‐owned 6.2 %
Native American‐owned 0.1 %
Total Minority‐ and Woman‐owned 23.7 %
Availability %
![Page 11: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER ES, PAGE 4
Figure ES‐2. Availability estimates by contract goal status
Note:
Numbers rounded to nearest tenth of 1 percent. Numbers may not sum exactly to totals.
For more detail, see Figures F‐16 and F‐17 in Appendix F.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting availability analysis.
Contract role. Manyminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesaresmallbusinessesandthusoftenoperateassubcontractors.Becauseofthattendency,itisusefultoexamineavailabilityestimatesseparatelyforprimecontractsandsubcontracts.FigureES‐3presentsthoseresults.AsshowninFigureES‐3,theavailabilityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesconsideredtogetherissimilarforCityprimecontracts(23.6%)andsubcontracts(24.4%).
Figure ES‐3. Availability estimates by contract role
Note:
Numbers rounded to nearest tenth of 1 percent. Numbers may not sum exactly to totals.
For more detail, see Figures F‐8 and F‐9 in Appendix F.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting availability analysis.
Industry.BBCexaminedavailabilityanalysisresultsseparatelyfortheCity’sconstruction;professionalservices;andgoodsandservicescontracts.TheprojectteamcombinedresultsforgoodsandservicescontractsbecausetheCityusessimilarprocurementprocessestoawardthosecontracts.AsshowninFigureES‐4,theavailabilityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesconsideredtogetherishighestfortheCity’sprofessionalservicescontracts(40.4%)andlowestforconstructioncontracts(19.0%).
Figure ES‐4. Availability estimates by relevant industry
Note:
Numbers rounded to nearest tenth of 1 percent. Numbers may not sum exactly to totals.
For more detail, see Figures F‐5, F‐6, and F‐7 in Appendix F.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting availability analysis.
Business group
Non‐Hispanic white woman‐owned 12.2 % 10.0 %
Asian American‐owned 2.0 % 4.0 %
Black American‐owned 2.3 % 4.1 %
Hispanic American‐owned 6.4 % 6.0 %
Native American‐owned 0.2 % 0.1 %
Total Minority‐ and Woman‐owned 23.1 % 24.1 %
Goal Status
Goals
contracts
No‐goals
contracts
Business group
Non‐Hispanic white woman‐owned 10.8 % 11.4 %
Asian American‐owned 3.4 % 2.2 %
Black American‐owned 3.2 % 3.9 %
Hispanic American‐owned 6.1 % 6.4 %
Native American‐owned 0.1 % 0.5 %
Total Minority‐ and Woman‐owned 23.6 % 24.4 %
Contract Role
Prime
contracts Subcontracts
Business group
Non‐Hispanic white woman‐owned 10.8 % 15.8 % 7.6 %
Asian American‐owned 1.6 % 2.6 % 8.5 %
Black American‐owned 1.9 % 11.5 % 2.2 %
Hispanic American‐owned 4.6 % 10.4 % 7.9 %
Native American‐owned 0.2 % 0.1 % 0.1 %
Total Minority‐ and Woman‐owned 19.0 % 40.4 % 26.3 %
Industry
Construction
Professional
services
Goods and
services
![Page 12: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER ES, PAGE 5
C. Utilization Analysis Results
BBCmeasuredtheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinCitycontractingintermsofutilization—thepercentageofdollarsthatthosebusinessesreceivedonCityprimecontractsandsubcontractsduringthestudyperiod.BBCmeasuredtheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinCitycontractsregardlessofwhethertheywerecertifiedassuchwiththeCity.
Overall.FigureES‐5presentsthepercentageofcontractingdollarsthatminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesses,consideredtogether,receivedonconstruction;professionalservices;andgoodsandservicescontractsandprocurementsthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiod.AsshowninFigureES‐5,overall,minority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesconsideredtogetherreceived14.8percentoftherelevantcontractingdollarsthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiod.HispanicAmerican‐ownedbusinesses(6.3%)andnon‐Hispanicwhitewoman‐ownedbusinesses(5.3%)exhibitedhigherlevelsofparticipationinCitycontractsthanallothergroups.
Figure ES‐5. Overall utilization results by racial/ethnic and gender group
Note:
Numbers rounded to nearest tenth of 1 percent. Numbers may not sum exactly to totals.
For more detail, see Figure F‐2 in Appendix F.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting utilization analysis.
Contract goals.Duringthestudyperiod,theCityusedMWBEandDBEcontractgoalstoawardmanylocally‐fundedandfederally‐fundedcontracts,respectively,toencouragetheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesses.Itisusefultoexamineutilizationanalysisresultsseparatelyforgoalscontractsandno‐goalscontracts,becausedoingsoprovidesinformationaboutoutcomesforminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesoncontractsthattheCityawardedinarace‐andgender‐neutralenvironmentandtheefficacyofMWBEandDBEcontractgoalsinencouragingtheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinCitycontractsandprocurements.
AsshowninFigureES‐6,minority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesconsideredtogethershowedhigherparticipationingoalscontracts(24.1%)thaninno‐goalcontracts(8.4%).Thoseresultsmightindicatetheeffectivenessofcontractgoalsinencouragingtheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinCitycontractsandprocurements.However,examiningdisparityanalysisresultsprovidesabetterassessmentoftheefficacyofcontractgoals,becausethoseresultsalsotakeintoaccounttheavailabilityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesforgoalsandno‐goalscontracts.
Business group
Non‐Hispanic white woman‐owned 5.3 %
Asian American‐owned 1.2 %
Black American‐owned 1.6 %
Hispanic American‐owned 6.3 %
Native American‐owned 0.5 %
Total Minority‐ and Woman‐owned 14.8 %
Utilization %
![Page 13: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER ES, PAGE 6
Figure ES‐6. Utilization results by contract goal status
Note:
Numbers rounded to nearest tenth of 1 percent. Numbers may not sum exactly to totals.
For more detail, see Figures F‐16 and F‐17 in Appendix F.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting utilization analysis.
Contract role.Manyminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesaresmallbusinessesandthusoftenoperateassubcontractors.Becauseofthattendency,itisusefultoexamineutilizationresultsseparatelyforprimecontractsandsubcontracts.AsshowninFigureES‐7,theparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesconsideredtogetherwasmuchhigherintheCity’ssubcontracts(42.9%)thanintheCity’sprimecontracts(8.7%).ThevastmajorityofcontractingdollarsthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiodwereassociatedwithprimecontracts.
Figure ES‐7. Utilization results by contract role
Note:
Numbers rounded to nearest tenth of 1 percent. Numbers may not sum exactly to totals.
For more detail, see Figures F‐8 and F‐9 in Appendix F.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting utilization analysis.
Industry.BBCexaminedutilizationresultsseparatelyfortheCity’sconstruction;professionalservices;andgoodsandservicescontracts.Theprojectteamcombinedresultsforgoodsandservicescontracts,becausetheCityusessimilarprocurementprocessestoawardthosecontracts.AsshowninFigureES‐8,theparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesconsideredtogetherwashighestintheCity’sprofessionalservicescontracts(19.4%)andlowestingoodsandgeneralservicescontracts(10.6%).ThemajorityofcontractingdollarsthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiodwereinconstruction,inwhichtheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesseswas15.2percent.
Business group
Non‐Hispanic white woman‐owned 8.1 % 3.3 %
Asian American‐owned 1.2 % 1.2 %
Black American‐owned 1.9 % 1.5 %
Hispanic American‐owned 12.1 % 2.1 %
Native American‐owned 0.8 % 0.3 %
Total Minority‐ and Woman‐owned 24.1 % 8.4 %
Goal Status
Goals
contracts
No‐goals
contracts
Business group
Non‐Hispanic white woman‐owned 3.5 % 13.5 %
Asian American‐owned 1.0 % 2.2 %
Black American‐owned 1.1 % 3.9 %
Hispanic American‐owned 2.7 % 22.4 %
Native American‐owned 0.4 % 0.9 %
Total Minority‐ and Woman‐owned 8.7 % 42.9 %
Contract Role
Prime
contracts Subcontracts
![Page 14: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER ES, PAGE 7
Figure ES‐8. Utilization results by relevant industry
Note:
Numbers rounded to nearest tenth of 1 percent. Numbers may not sum exactly to totals.
For more detail, see Figures F‐5, F‐6, and F‐7 in Appendix F.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting utilization analysis.
D. Disparity Analysis Results
Althoughinformationabouttheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinCitycontractsisusefulonitsown,itisevenmoreusefulwhencomparedwiththelevelofparticipationthatmightbeexpectedbasedonthesebusinesses’availabilityforCitywork.BBCcalculateddisparityindicesforeachrelevantbusinessgroupandforvariouscontractsetsbydividingpercentparticipationbypercentavailabilityandmultiplyingby100.Adisparityindexof100indicatesanexactmatchbetweenparticipationandavailabilityforaparticulargroupforaparticularcontractset(referredtoasparity).Adisparityindexoflessthan100indicatesadisparitybetweenparticipationandavailability.Adisparityindexoflessthan80indicatesasubstantialdisparitybetweenparticipationandavailability.
Overall.FigureES‐9presentsdisparityindicesforallrelevantprimecontractsandsubcontractsthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiod.Thelinedownthecenterofthegraphshowsadisparityindexlevelof100,whichindicatesparitybetweenparticipationandavailability.Forreference,thereisalinedrawnatadisparityindexof100(lineofparity)andatadisparityindexlevelof80(lineofsubstantialdisparity).AsshowninFigureES‐9,overall,theparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesincontractsthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiodwassubstantiallylowerthanwhatonemightexpectbasedontheiravailabilityforthatwork.Thedisparityindexof63indicatesthatminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesreceivedapproximately$0.63foreverydollarthattheymightbeexpectedtoreceivebasedontheiravailabilityfortherelevantprimecontractsandsubcontractsthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiod.Disparityanalysisresultsbyindividualgroupindicatedthat:
Threegroupsexhibiteddisparityindicessubstantiallybelowparity:non‐Hispanicwhitewoman‐ownedbusinesses(disparityindexof48),AsianAmerican‐ownedbusinesses(disparityindexof38),andBlackAmerican‐ownedbusinesses(disparityindexof48).
HispanicAmerican‐ownedbusinesses(disparityindexof102)andNativeAmerican‐ownedbusinesses(disparityindexof200+)didnotexhibitadisparity.
Business group
Non‐Hispanic white woman‐owned 4.9 % 6.5 % 5.5 %
Asian American‐owned 0.6 % 2.0 % 2.9 %
Black American‐owned 0.7 % 7.3 % 0.4 %
Hispanic American‐owned 8.3 % 3.6 % 1.7 %
Native American‐owned 0.8 % 0.0 % 0.1 %
Total Minority‐ and Woman‐owned 15.2 % 19.4 % 10.6 %
Industry
Construction
Professional
services
Goods and
services
![Page 15: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER ES, PAGE 8
Figure ES‐9. Disparity indices by racial/ ethnic and gender group
Note:
Numbers rounded to nearest whole number.
For more detail, see Figure F‐2 in Appendix F.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting disparity analysis.
Contract goals.Duringthestudyperiod,theCityusedMWBEandDBEcontractgoalstoawardmanylocally‐fundedandfederally‐fundedcontracts,respectively,toencouragetheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesses.Itisusefultoexaminedisparityanalysisresultsseparatelyforgoalscontractsandno‐goalscontracts.Assessingwhetheranydisparitiesexistforno‐goalcontractsprovidesusefulinformationaboutoutcomesforminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesoncontractsthattheCityawardedinarace‐andgender‐neutralenvironmentandwhetherthereisevidencethatcertaingroupsfacebarriersaspartoftheagency’scontracting.AsshowninFigureES‐10,minority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesconsideredtogethershowedparityongoalscontracts(disparityindexof104),butexhibitedasubstantialdisparityonno‐goalscontracts(disparityindexof35).Disparityanalysisresultsbyindividualgroupindicatedthat:
Non‐Hispanicwhitewoman‐ownedbusinesses(disparityindexof67)andAsianAmerican‐ownedbusinesses(disparityindexof59)exhibitedsubstantialdisparitiesongoalscontracts.BlackAmerican‐ownedbusinessalsoexhibitedadisparitythatwasclosetothethresholdofbeingconsideredsubstantial(disparityindexof82)ongoalscontracts;and
AllgroupsexceptNativeAmerican‐ownedbusinesses(disparityindexof200+)exhibitedsubstantialdisparitiesonno‐goalscontracts.
![Page 16: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER ES, PAGE 9
Figure ES‐10. Disparity indices by contract goal status
Note:
Numbers rounded to nearest whole number.
For more detail, see Figures F‐16 and F‐17 in Appendix F.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting disparity analysis.
Takentogether,theresultspresentedinFigureES‐10showthattheCity’suseofMWBEandDBEcontractgoalsissomewhateffectiveinencouragingtheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinitscontracts.Moreover,theresultsindicatethatwhentheCitydoesnotuserace‐andgender‐consciousmeasures,nearlyallrelevantbusinessgroupssufferfromsubstantialunderutilizationinCitycontractingandprocurement.
Contract role. Subcontractstendtobemuchsmallerinsizethanprimecontracts.Asaresult,subcontractsareoftenmoreaccessiblethanprimecontractstominority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesses.Inaddition,theCityusedMWBEandDBEcontractgoalswhenawardingmanycontractsduringthestudyperiod,whichprimarilyaffectsubcontractopportunitiesforminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesses.Thus,itmightbereasonabletoexpectbetteroutcomesforminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesonsubcontractsthanonprimecontracts.FigureES‐11presentsdisparityindicesforallrelevantgroupsseparatelyforprimecontractsandsubcontracts.AsshowninFigureES‐11,minority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesconsideredtogethershowedasubstantialdisparityforprimecontracts(disparityindexof37)butnotforsubcontracts(disparityindexof176).Resultsforindividualgroupsindicatedthat:
AllgroupsshowedsubstantialdisparitiesonprimecontractsexceptforNativeAmerican‐ownedbusinesses(disparityindexof200+).
Nogroupsexhibitedsubstantialdisparitiesonsubcontracts.
![Page 17: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER ES, PAGE 10
Figure ES‐11. Disparity indices by contract role
Note:
Numbers rounded to nearest whole number.
For more detail, see Figures F‐8 and F‐9 in Appendix F.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting disparity analysis.
Industry.BBCexamineddisparityanalysisresultsseparatelyfortheCity’sconstruction;professionalservices;andgoodsandservicescontracts.TheprojectteamcombinedresultsforgoodsandservicescontractsbecausetheCityusessimilarprocurementprocessestoawardthosecontracts.FigureES‐12presentsdisparityindicesforallrelevantgroupsbycontractingarea.Disparityanalysesresultsdifferedbycontractingareaandgroup:
Minority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesconsideredtogethershowedadisparityonconstructioncontracts(disparityindexof80).Threeindividualgroupsshowedsubstantialdisparities:non‐Hispanicwhitewoman‐ownedbusinesses(disparityindexof45),AsianAmerican‐ownedbusinesses(disparityindexof36),andBlackAmerican‐ownedbusinesses(disparityindexof37).
Minority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesconsideredtogethershowedasubstantialdisparityonprofessionalservicescontracts(disparityindexof48).Allindividualgroupsshowedsubstantialdisparitiesonthosecontracts.
Minority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesconsideredtogethershowedasubstantialdisparityongoodsandservicescontracts(disparityindexof40).AllindividualgroupsshowedsubstantialdisparitiesexceptforNativeAmerican‐ownedbusinesses(disparityindexof105).
![Page 18: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER ES, PAGE 11
Figure ES‐12. Disparity indices by relevant industry
Note: Numbers rounded to nearest whole number.
For more detail, see Figures F‐5, F‐6, and F‐7 in Appendix F.
Source: BBC Research & Consulting disparity analysis.
E. Program Implementation
TheCityshouldreviewstudyresultsandotherrelevantinformationinconnectionwithmakingdecisionsconcerningitsimplementationoftheMWBE,EBE,SBE,andFederalDBEPrograms.Keyconsiderationsofpotentialrefinementarediscussedbelow.Inmakingthoseconsiderations,theCityshouldalsoassesswhetheradditionalresources,changesininternalpolicy,orchangesinstatelawmayberequired.
Aspirational MWBE and DBE goals.TheCityestablishesaspirationalannualgoalsfortheparticipationofcertifiedMBEsandWBEsaspartoftheMWBEProgramandfortheparticipationofcertifiedDBEsaspartofitsimplementationoftheFederalDBEProgram.Resultsfromthedisparitystudy—particularlytheavailabilityanalysisandanalysesofmarketplaceconditions—canbehelpfultotheCityinsettingitsnextaspirationalMWBEandDBEgoals.
Aspirational MWBE goals.TheCitysetsaspirationalannualMWBEgoalsseparatelyforitslocally‐fundedconstruction;professionalservices;andgoodsandservicescontractsandprocurements.Currently,theCityhassetthosegoalsat24percentforconstruction,33percent
![Page 19: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER ES, PAGE 12
forprofessionalservices,and8percentforgoodsandservices.InformationfromtheavailabilityanalysisprovidedinformationthattheCitycanuseasabasisforitsaspirationalMWBEgoals.Forthepurposesofaspirationalgoal‐setting,BBCcalculatedtheavailabilityofpotentialMWBEs—minority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesthatarecurrentlyMWBE‐certifiedorappearthattheycouldbeMWBE‐certifiedbasedonrevenuerequirementssetforthintheCity’sMWBEProgram—forlocally‐fundedprimecontractsandsubcontractsthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiod.ThatanalysisindicatedthatpotentialMWBEsmightbeexpectedtoreceive20.5percentoftheCity’slocally‐fundedcontractingdollarsbasedontheiravailabilityforthatwork.TheavailabilityofpotentialMWBEsis16.5percentforlocally‐fundedconstructioncontracts;39.5percentforlocally‐fundedprofessionalservicescontracts;and19.8percentforlocally‐fundedgoodsandgeneralservicescontracts.TheCityshouldconsiderthatinformationasitsetsitsnextaspirationalMWBEgoals.
Overall DBE goal.TheCityalsosetsanoverallannualDBEgoalfortheFAA‐fundedcontractsthatDENawards.Currently,theCityhassetthatgoalat14.04percent.ForthepurposesofhelpingtheCitydetermineabasisforitsoverallDBEgoal,BBCcalculatedtheavailabilityofpotentialDBEs—minority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesthatarecurrentlyDBE‐certifiedorappearthattheycouldbeDBE‐certifiedbasedonrevenuerequirementssetforthin49CodeofFederalRegulationsPart26.65—forFAA‐fundedprimecontractsandsubcontractsthatDENawardedduringthestudyperiod.ThatanalysisindicatedthatpotentialDBEsmightbeexpectedtoreceived16.2percentoftheCity’sFAA‐fundedprimecontractandsubcontractdollarsbasedontheiravailabilityforthatwork.TheCityshouldconsiderthatinformationasitsetsitsnextoverallDBEgoalsforDEN’sFAA‐fundedcontracts.
Goal adjustments. Insettingaspirationalannualgoals,organizationsoftenexamineavailableevidencetodeterminewhetheranadjustmenttoavailabilityisnecessarytoaccountforpastparticipationofminority‐andwomanownedbusinessesintheircontracting;currentconditionsinthelocalmarketplaceforminorities,women,minority‐ownedbusinesses,andwoman‐ownedbusinesses;andotherrelevantfactors.TheFederalDBEProgram—whichorganizationsoftenuseasamodeltosetandadjusttheiraspirationalannualgoals—outlinesseveralfactorsthatorganizationsmightconsiderwhenassessingwhethertoadjusttheirgoals:
1. Volumeofworkminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesseshaveperformedinrecentyears;
2. Informationrelatedtoemployment,self‐employment,education,training,andunions;
3. Informationrelatedtofinancing,bonding,andinsurance;and
4. Otherrelevantdata.3
BBCcompletedananalysisofeachoftheabovefactors.MuchoftheinformationthatBBCexaminedwasnoteasilyquantifiablebutisstillrelevanttotheCityasitdetermineswhethertoadjustitsaspirationalMWBEandDBEgoals.DetailedinformationaboutthoseanalysesarepresentedinChapter9.
349CFRSection26.45.
![Page 20: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER ES, PAGE 13
Data collection.TheCitymaintainscomprehensivedataontheprimecontractsandprocurementsthatitawardsandmaintainsthosedatainawell‐organizedandintuitivemanner.However,theCityonlymaintainsdataonthosesubcontractsthatareassociatedwithprimecontractsthatitawardsusingMWBEorDBEcontractgoals.TheCityshouldconsidercollectingcomprehensivedataonallsubcontracts,regardlessofwhethertheyareperformedbyminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesandregardlessofwhethertheyareassociatedwithgoalscontracts.CollectingdataonallsubcontractswillhelpensurethattheCitymonitorstheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesasaccuratelyaspossible.Collectingthefollowingdataonallsubcontractswouldbeappropriate:
Subcontractorname,address,phonenumber,andemailaddress;
Typeofassociatedwork;
Subcontractawardamount;and
Subcontractpaidamount.
TheCityshouldconsidercollectingthosedataaspartofbidsbutalsorequiringprimecontractorstosubmitdataonsubcontractsaspartoftheinvoicingprocessforallcontracts.TheCityshouldtrainrelevantdepartmentstafftocollectandentersubcontractdataaccuratelyandconsistently.
Monitoring minority‐ and woman‐owned business participation. TheCityonlymonitorsminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessparticipationongoalscontracts,whichresultsinaskewedrepresentationoftheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinCitycontractingoverall.Disparitystudyresultsindicatethat,duringthestudyperiod,theparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesseswasmuchlowerincontractsthattheCityawardedwithouttheuseofMWBEorDBEcontractgoalsthaningoalscontracts,despitetheavailabilityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesbeingverysimilarforbothcontractsets.ThatresultunderscorestheimportancefortheCitytomonitortheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinallcontracts,regardlessofwhethercontractgoalsareusedtoawardthem.DoingsowillhelpensurethattheCitymonitorstheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesasaccuratelyaspossible.
Prime contract opportunities.Disparityanalysisresultsindicatedsubstantialdisparitiesformostracial/ethnicandgendergroupsontheprimecontractsthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiod.TheCityhasestablishedaDefinedSelectionPoolProgram,whichlimitscompetitiononcertainconstructionandgoodsandservicesprimecontractstocertifiedSBEsorEBEs.TheCityshouldconsidercontinuingandevenexpandingtheuseoftheprogramtofurtherencouragetheparticipationofsmallbusinesses,includingmanyminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesses.
Subcontract opportunities.Overall,minority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesdidnotshowdisparitiesonthesubcontractsthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiod.However,subcontractingaccountedforarelativelysmallpercentageofthetotalcontractingdollarsthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiod.Toincreasethenumberofsubcontractopportunities,theCitycouldconsiderimplementingaprogramthatrequiresprimecontractorstosubcontractacertainamountofprojectworkaspartoftheirbidsandproposals,regardlessofthe
![Page 21: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER ES, PAGE 14
race/ethnicityorgenderofsubcontractorowners.Forspecifictypesofcontractswheresubcontractingorpartnershipopportunitiesmightexist,theCitycouldsetaminimumpercentageofworktobesubcontracted.Primecontractorswouldthenhavetomeetorexceedthisthresholdinorderfortheirbidstobeconsideredresponsive.IftheCityweretoimplementsuchaprogram,itshouldincludeflexibilityprovisionssuchasagoodfaitheffortsprocess.
Contract goals.TheCityusesMWBEandDBEcontractgoalsonmanyofthecontractsthatitawards.PrimecontractorscanmeetthosegoalsbyeithermakingsubcontractingcommitmentswithcertifiedMWBEorDBEsubcontractorsatthetimeofbidorbysubmittingwaiversshowingthattheymadereasonablegoodfaitheffortstofulfillthegoalsbutcouldnotdoso.Disparityanalysisresultsshowedthatoutcomesforminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesseswerebetterongoalscontractsthanno‐goalscontractsduringthestudyperiod,indicatingthattheuseofcontractgoalsisaneffectivemeasureinencouragingtheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinCitycontracts,particularlyforHispanicAmerican‐ownedbusinesses.TheCityshouldconsidercontinuingitsuseofMWBEandDBEcontractgoalsinthefuture.TheCitywillneedtoensurethattheuseofthosegoalsisnarrowlytailoredandconsistentwithotherrelevantlegalstandards(fordetails,seeChapter2andAppendixB).ItisalsoimportantfortheCitytocontinuetotreatcontractgoalsasonlyonetacticamongmanytoencourageminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessparticipationinitscontractingandtonottreattheuseofsuchgoalsasasubstituteforothermeasuresthatmighthelpbuildthecapacityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesforCitywork,suchastechnicalassistanceprograms,mentor‐protégéprograms,andfinancialassistance.
Unbundling large contracts.Ingeneral,minority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesexhibitedreducedavailabilityforrelativelylargecontractsthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiod.Inaddition,aspartofin‐depthinterviewsandpublicforums,severalminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesreportedthatthesizeofgovernmentcontractsoftenservesasabarriertotheirsuccess(fordetails,seeAppendixD).Tofurtherencouragetheparticipationofsmallbusinesses,includingmanyminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesses,theCityshouldconsidermakingeffortstounbundlerelativelylargeprimecontractsandevensubcontractsintoseveralsmallercontracts.Forexample,theCityofCharlotte,NorthCarolinaencouragesprimecontractorstounbundlesubcontractingopportunitiesintosmallercontractpiecesthataremorefeasibleforsmallbusinessesandminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessestoworkonandacceptssuchattemptsasgoodfaithefforts.Doingsowouldresultinthatworkbeingmoreaccessibletosmallbusinesses,whichinturnmightincreaseopportunitiesforminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesandresultingreaterminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessparticipation.
Prompt payment.Aspartofin‐depthinterviews,severalbusinesses,includingmanyminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesses,reporteddifficultieswithreceivingpaymentinatimelymanneronCitycontracts,bothwhenworkingasprimecontractorsandassubcontractors(fordetails,seeAppendixD).Manybusinessesalsocommentedthathavingcapitalonhandiscrucialtosmallbusinesssuccess.TheCityshouldconsiderreinforcingitspromptpaymentpolicieswithitsprocurementstaffandprimecontractorsandcouldalsoconsiderautomatingpaymentsdirectlytosubcontractors.Doingsomighthelpensurethatbothprimecontractorsandsubcontractorsreceivepaymentinatimelymanner.Itmayalsohelpensurethatminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesseshaveenoughoperatingcapitaltoremainsuccessful.
![Page 22: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
CHAPTER 1.
Introduction
![Page 23: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 1, PAGE 1
CHAPTER 1. Introduction
Withapopulationofnearly3millionpeopleinitsmetropolitanarea,Denver,ColoradoisoneofthelargestandfastestgrowingcitiesintheUnitedStates.WithitscloseproximitytotheRockyMountains,Denverhasanationalreputationforbeinganactive,outdoor‐orientedcitywithabustlingeconomy.Thecity’sprimaryindustriesincludeaerospaceandaviation;energy;financialservices;informationtechnology;andtelecommunications.Italsoboastsasubstantialgovernmentpresencewithmanyfederalagencieshavingofficesintheregion.
TheCityandCountyofDenver(TheCity)providesmyriadservicestotheresidentswholiveandworkintheregion.Toprovidethoseservices,theCitytypicallyspendsnearly$1billioneachyearincontractdollarstoprocurevariousgoodsandservicesinconstruction;professionalservices;andgoodsandservices.Aspartofitscontractingandprocurement,theCityusesvariousstrategiesandeffortstoencouragetheparticipationofsmallbusinessesandminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesses,includingimplementingtheMinority‐andWomen‐ownedBusinessEnterprise(MWBE)Program,theEmergingBusinessEnterprise(EBE)Program,andtheSmallBusinessEnterprise(SBE)Programforitslocally‐fundedcontractsandtheFederalDisadvantagedBusinessEnterprise(DBE)ProgramfortheFederalAviationAdministration(FAA)‐fundedcontractsthattheDenverInternationalAirport(DEN)awards.1,2
TheCityretainedBBCResearch&Consulting(BBC)toconductadisparitystudytohelpevaluatetheeffectivenessofitsimplementationoftheMWBE,EBE,SBE,andFederalDBEProgramsinencouragingtheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinitscontractsandprocurements.Aspartofthestudy,BBCexaminedwhetherthereareanydisparitiesbetween:
ThepercentageofcontractdollarsthattheCityspentwithminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesduringthestudyperiod(i.e.,utilization);and
Thepercentageofcontractdollarsthatminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesmightbeexpectedtoreceivebasedontheiravailabilitytoperformspecifictypesandsizesoftheCity’sprimecontractsandsubcontracts(i.e.,availability).
BBCalsoassessedotherquantitativeandqualitativeinformationrelatedto:
ThelegalframeworkrelatedtotheCity’simplementationoftheMWBE,EBE,SBE,andFederalDBEPrograms;
Localmarketplaceconditionsforminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesses;and
ContractingpracticesandbusinessassistanceprogramsthattheCitycurrentlyhasinplace.
1https://library.municode.com/co/denver/codes/code_of_ordinances?nodeId=TITIIREMUCO_CH28HURI_ARTIIINOCOCOREREPRDECOSE
2https://www.ecfr.gov/cgi‐bin/text‐idx?tpl=/ecfrbrowse/Title49/49cfr26_main_02.tpl
![Page 24: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 1, PAGE 2
ThereareseveralreasonswhythedisparitystudywillbeusefultotheCity:
Thedisparitystudyprovidesanindependentreviewoftheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesintheCity’scontractingandprocurement,whichwillbevaluabletoCityleadershipandexternalstakeholders;
InformationfromthedisparitystudywillbeusefultotheCityasitmakesdecisionsabouttheMWBE,EBE,SBE,andFederalDBEPrograms(e.g.,determiningwhethertheuseofrace‐andgender‐consciousgoalsmightstillbeappropriateinthefuture);
Thedisparitystudyprovidesinsightsintohowtoincreasecontractingopportunitiesforminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesses;and
Organizationsthathavesuccessfullydefendedtheirimplementationsofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessprogramsincourthavetypicallyreliedoninformationfromdisparitystudies.
BBCintroducestheCityofDenverDisparityStudyinthreeparts:
A. Background;
B. Studyscope;and
C. Studyteammembers.
A. Background
TheCityimplementstheMWBEProgramforlocally‐fundedcontractsandtheFederalDBEProgramforFAA‐fundedcontractsthatDENawards.ThedisparitystudyincludesinformationthatisrelevanttorefiningtheCity’simplementationofbothprograms.
MWBE Program.Since1991,theCityhasmadevariouseffortstodeterminewhetherrace‐orgender‐baseddiscriminationaffectsthesuccessofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesattemptingtoparticipateinCitycontractsandprocurements.In1996,theDenverCityCouncilenactedasetofordinancestopromotenondiscriminationintheCity’sconstruction;professionalservices;andgoodsandservicescontractsandprocurements.Thatprogram—referredtohereinastheMWBEProgram—isdesignedtopreventrace‐andgender‐baseddiscriminationagainstminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesandencouragetheirparticipationinCitycontractsandprocurements.
Aspartoftheprogram,theCitysetsaspirationalannualgoalsfortheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinitsconstruction;professionalservices;andgoodsandservicescontractsandprocurements.Currently,theCityhasseta24percentgoalforconstructioncontracts,a33percentgoalforprofessionalservicescontracts,a5percentgoalforgoodsprocurements,andan8percentgoalforservicesprocurements.ThosegoalsarebasedoninformationfromanavailabilityanalysisthattheCityconductedin2012.FailuretomeetthosegoalsdoesnotautomaticallycausechangesinhowtheCityimplementstheMWBEProgram.However,theCitycontinuouslyconsiderswaystofurtherencouragetheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinitscontractingandprocurement.
![Page 25: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 1, PAGE 3
Federal DBE Program.TheFederalDBEProgramisaprogramdesignedtoincreasetheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinUnitedStatesDepartmentofTransportation(USDOT)‐fundedcontracts.TheCityreceivesfundsfromtheFAAtooperateDENandisthusrequiredtoimplementtheFederalDBEProgram.3SimilartotheMWBEProgram,akeycomponentoftheCity’simplementationoftheFederalDBEProgramissettinganoverallaspirationalgoalforDBEparticipationinitsFAA‐fundedcontracts.TheCityisrequiredtosetthegoaleverythreeyears,butthegoalisanannualgoalinthattheCitymustmonitorDBEparticipationinitsFAA‐fundedcontractseveryyear.IfDBEparticipationforaparticularyearislessthantheoverallDBEgoalforthatyear,thentheCitymustanalyzethereasonsforthedifferenceandestablishspecificmeasurestoaddressthedifferenceandenableittomeetthegoalinthenextyear.
TheFederalDBEProgramdescribesthestepsanagencymustfollowinestablishingitsoverallgoal.Tobeginthegoal‐settingprocess,anorganizationmustdevelopabasefigurebasedondemonstrableevidenceoftheavailabilityofDBEstoparticipateinitsUSDOT‐fundedcontracts.Then,afterconsideringvariousrelevantfactors,theorganizationcanmakeanupward,downward,ornoadjustmenttoitsbasefigureasitdeterminesitsoverallDBEgoal(referredtoasastep‐2adjustment).Currently,theCityhassetitsoverallDBEgoalat11.9percent,basedoninformationfromanavailabilityanalysisthattheCityconductedin2012.
Program measures. InanefforttomeetitsaspirationalannualgoalsaspartoftheMWBEandFederalDBEPrograms,theCityusesacombinationofrace‐andgender‐neutralmeasuresandrace‐andgender‐consciousmeasurestoencouragetheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinitscontracting.Race‐andgender‐neutralmeasuresaremeasuresthataredesignedtoencouragetheparticipationofsmallbusinessesinanorganization’scontracting,regardlessoftherace/ethnicityorgenderofbusinesses’owners.Theunderlyinglogicofusingsuchmeasuresisthat,becausemostminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesaresmallbusinesses,implementingmeasuresthatencouragetheparticipationofallsmallbusinessesinanorganization’scontractingwillresultintheincreasedparticipationofalargenumberofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesses.Incontrasttorace‐andgender‐neutralmeasures,race‐andgender‐consciousmeasuresaremeasuresthatarespecificallydesignedtoencouragetheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesingovernmentcontracting(e.g.,participationgoalsforminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessonindividualcontracts).4
Race‐ and gender‐neutral measures.TheCityusesvariousrace‐andgender‐neutralmeasuresaspartoftheMWBE,EBE,SBE,andFederalDBEPrograms.Thosemeasuresaredesignedtoencouragetheparticipationofsmallbusinesses—includingmanyminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesses—inCitycontractingandprocurement.Specifictypesofrace‐andgender‐neutralmeasuresthattheCityusesinclude:
3TheCityalsoimplementstheAirportConcessionsDisadvantagedBusinessEnterprise(ACDBE)Programtoencouragetheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinconcessionsagreementsatDEN,butanalysesaroundconcessionswereoutsidethescopeofthisstudy.
4AspartoftheFederalDBEProgram,theCityisrequiredtomeetthemaximumfeasibleportionofitsoverallDBEgoalthroughtheuseofrace‐andgender‐neutralprogrammeasures.IftheCitycanmeetitsgoalsolelythroughtheuseofrace‐andgender‐neutralmeasures,itcannotimplementrace‐orgender‐consciousmeasuresaspartoftheprogram.
![Page 26: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 1, PAGE 4
Contractinginformationandassistance;
Monitoring,evaluation,andreporting;
Technicalassistanceandtraining;
Financeandbondingassistance;and
Networkingandoutreach.
Race‐ and gender‐conscious measures.AspartofboththeMWBEandFederalDBEPrograms,theCitysetsgoalsfortheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesassubcontractorsoncertainindividualcontracts(i.e.,MWBEorDBEcontractgoals).Primecontractorsbiddingoncontractsthatincludesuchgoalsmusteithermeetthegoalsbymakingsubcontractingcommitmentstominority‐or‐woman‐ownedbusinessesorbyrequestinggoodfaitheffortswaivers.TheDivisionofSmallBusinessOpportunity(DSBO)reviewswaiverrequestsandwillgrantwaiversifprimecontractorsdemonstrategoodfaitheffortstowardscompliancewiththegoals.Ifprimecontractorsdonotmeetthegoalsthroughsubcontractingcommitmentsanddonotsubmitacceptablegoodfaitheffortwaivers,thenDSBOmayrejecttheirbids.
IftheCitydeterminesthatthecontinueduseofrace‐orgender‐consciousmeasuresisappropriateforitsimplementationoftheMWBEandFederalDBEPrograms,thenitmustalsodeterminewhichracial/ethnicorgendergroupsareeligibleforparticipationinthosemeasures.Eligibilityforsuchmeasuresislimitedtoonlythoseracial/ethnicorgendergroupsforwhichcompellingevidenceofdiscriminationexistsinthelocalmarketplace.
B. Study Scope
InformationfromthedisparitystudywillhelptheCitycontinuetoencouragetheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinitscontractingandprocurement.Inaddition,itwillhelptheCityimplementtheMWBE,EBE,SBE,andFederalDBEProgramseffectivelyandinalegally‐defensiblemanner.
Definitions of minority‐ and woman‐owned businesses.Tointerpretthecoreanalysespresentedinthedisparitystudy,itisusefultounderstandhowBBCtreatedminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesandbusinessesthatarecertifiedasminority‐ownedbusinessenterprises(MBEs)andwoman‐ownedbusinessenterprises(WBEs)inthestudy.ItisalsoimportanttounderstandhowBBCtreatedbusinessesownedbyminoritywomen.
Minority‐ and woman‐owned businesses.BBCfocuseditsanalysesontheminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessgroupsthatareincludedaspartoftheCity’sMWBEProgram:AsianAmerican‐,BlackAmerican‐,HispanicAmerican‐,NativeAmerican‐,andwoman‐ownedbusinesses.BBCanalyzedthepossibilitythatrace‐orgender‐baseddiscriminationaffectedtheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinCitycontractsandprocurementsbasedspecificallyontherace/ethnicityandgenderofbusinessownership.Therefore,BBCcountedbusinessesasminority‐orwoman‐ownedregardlessofwhethertheywere,orcouldbe,certifiedasMBEs,WBEs,orDBEs.Analyzingtheparticipationandavailabilityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesregardlessofcertificationstatusallowedBBCtoassesswhetherthere
![Page 27: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 1, PAGE 5
arebarriersaffectingminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesspecificallybecauseoftherace/ethnicityandgenderoftheirownersandnottheircertification.
Minority woman‐owned businesses. BBCconsideredfouroptionswhenconsideringhowtoclassifybusinessesownedbyminoritywomen:
1) Classifyingthosebusinessesasbothminority‐ownedandwoman‐owned;
2) Creatinguniquegroupsofminoritywoman‐ownedbusinesses;
3) Classifyingminoritywoman‐ownedbusinesseswithotherwoman‐ownedbusinesses;and
4) Classifyingminoritywoman‐ownedbusinesseswiththeircorrespondingminoritygroups.
RegardingOption1,BBCchosenottocodebusinessesasbothwoman‐ownedandminority‐ownedtoavoiddouble‐countingcertainbusinesseswhenreportingdisparitystudyresults.BBCalsochoseagainstOption2—creatinggroupsofminoritywoman‐ownedbusinessesthatweredistinctfrombusinessesownedbyminoritymen(e.g.,BlackAmericanwoman‐ownedbusinessesversusbusinessesownedbyBlackAmericanmen)—becausethepopulationsizesofsomebusinessgroupswerealreadysolowthatfurtherdisaggregationbygenderwouldhavemadeitevenmoredifficulttointerpretresults.BBCthenconsideredwhethertogroupminoritywoman‐ownedbusinesseswithallotherwoman‐ownedbusinesses(Option3)orwiththeircorrespondingminoritygroups(Option4).BBCchoseOption4(e.g.,groupingBlackAmericanwoman‐ownedbusinesseswithallotherBlackAmerican‐ownedbusinesses).Asaresult,inthisreport,thetermwoman‐ownedbusinessesrefersspecificallytonon‐Hispanicwhitewoman‐ownedbusinesses.
MBE and WBEs.MBEandWBEsareminority‐ownedbusinessesandwoman‐ownedbusinessesthatarespecificallycertifiedassuchbytheCity.AdeterminationofMWBEeligibilityincludesassessingbusinesses’grossrevenuesandbusinessowners’personalnetworth.Someminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesdonotqualifyasMWBEsbecauseofgrossrevenueornetworthrequirementssetforthbytheUnitedStatesSmallBusinessAdministration(SBA).BusinessesseekingMWBEcertificationarerequiredtosubmitanapplicationtoDSBO.Theapplicationisavailableonlineandrequiresbusinessestosubmitvariousinformationincludingbusinessname;contactinformation;licenseinformation;financialinformation;workspecializations;andrace/ethnicityandgenderoftheirowners.DSBOreviewseachapplicationforapproval.Thereviewprocessmayinvolveon‐sitemeetingsandadditionaldocumentationtoconfirmrequiredbusinessinformation.
DBEs.DBEsareminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesthatarespecificallycertifiedassuchthroughtheColoradoUnifiedCertificationProgram(UCP).5AswithMWBEcertification,adeterminationofDBEeligibilityincludesassessingbusinesses’grossrevenuesandbusinessowners’personalnetworth.BusinessesseekingDBEcertificationinColoradoarerequiredtosubmitanapplicationtoeitherDSBOortheColoradoDepartmentofTransportation(CDOT).Theapplicationisavailableonlineandrequiresbusinessestosubmitvariousinformation,including
5Businessesownedbynon‐HispanicwhitemencanbecertifiedasDBEsifthosebusinessesmeettherequirementsin49CodeofFederalRegulationsPart26.
![Page 28: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 1, PAGE 6
businessname;contactinformation;taxinformation;workspecializations;andrace/ethnicityandgenderoftheowners.DSBOorCDOTreviewseachapplicationforapproval.Thereviewprocessmayinvolveon‐sitemeetingsandadditionaldocumentationtoconfirmrequiredbusinessinformation.
Potential MWBE/DBEs.PotentialMWBE/DBEsareminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesthatareMWBE/DBE‐certifiedorappearthattheycouldbecertifiedbasedonrevenuerequirementssetforthbytheSBA(regardlessofactualcertification).ThestudyteamdidnotcountbusinessesthathavebeendecertifiedorhavegraduatedfromtheMWBEorFederalDBEProgramsaspotentialMWBE/DBEsinthestudy.BBCexaminedtheavailabilityofpotentialMWBE/DBEsaspartofhelpingtheCityestablishaspirationalannualgoalsfortheMWBEandFederalDBEPrograms.
Majority‐owned businesses.Majority‐ownedbusinessesarebusinessesthatarenotownedbyminoritiesorwomen(i.e.,businessesownedbynon‐Hispanicwhitemen).
Analyses in the disparity study.Thestudyteamexaminedwhetherthereareanydisparitiesbetweentheparticipationandavailabilityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesonCitycontracts.Inaddition,thestudyteamalsoconducted:
AreviewoflegalissuesrelatedtotheCity’simplementationoftheMWBE,EBE,SBE,andFederalDBEPrograms;
Ananalysisoflocalmarketplaceconditionsforminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesses;
AnassessmentoftheCity’scontractingpracticesandbusinessassistanceprograms;and
OtherinformationfortheCitytoconsiderasitrefinesitsimplementationoftheMWBE,EBE,SBE,andFederalDBEPrograms.
Thedisparitystudyfocusedonconstruction;professionalservices;andgoodsandservicescontractsandprocurementsthattheCityawardedbetweenJanuary1,2012andDecember31,2016(i.e.,thestudyperiod).Informationfromthedisparitystudyisorganizedasfollows:
Legal framework and analysis.Thestudyteamconductedadetailedanalysisofrelevantfederalregulations,caselaw,statelaw,andotherinformationtoguidethemethodologyforthedisparitystudy.Theanalysisincludedareviewoffederalandstaterequirementsconcerningtheimplementationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessprograms.ThelegalframeworkandanalysisissummarizedinChapter2andpresentedindetailinAppendixB.
Marketplace conditions.BBCconductedquantitativeanalysesofthesuccessofminoritiesandwomenaswellasminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinthelocalcontractingandprocurementindustries.BBCcomparedbusinessoutcomesforminoritiesandwomenaswellasminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessestooutcomesfornon‐Hispanicwhitemenandbusinessesownedbynon‐Hispanicwhitemen.Inaddition,thestudyteamcollectedqualitativeinformationaboutpotentialbarriersthatminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesfaceintheDenverregionthroughin‐depthinterviewsandpublicmeetings.InformationaboutmarketplaceconditionsispresentedinChapter3,AppendixC,andAppendixD.
![Page 29: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 1, PAGE 7
Data collection.BBCcollectedcomprehensivedataontheprimecontractsandsubcontractsthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiodaswellasinformationonthebusinessesthatparticipatedinthosecontracts.ThescopeofBBC’sdatacollectioneffortsispresentedinChapter4.
Availability analysis.BBCassessedthedegreetowhichminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesareready,willing,andabletoperformonCityprimecontractsandsubcontracts.ThatanalysiswasbasedonCitydataandtelephonesurveysthatthestudyteamconductedwiththousandsofbusinessesthatarelocatedintheDenverregionandthatworkinindustriesrelatedtothetypesofcontractsandprocurementsthattheCityawards.ResultsfromtheavailabilityanalysisarepresentedinChapter5andAppendixE.
Utilization analysis.BBCanalyzedprimecontractandsubcontractdollarsthattheCityspentwithminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesoncontractsthatitawardedduringthestudyperiod.ResultsfromtheutilizationanalysisarepresentedinChapter6.
Disparity analysis.BBCexaminedwhethertherewereanydisparitiesbetweentheutilizationandavailabilityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesonprimecontractsandsubcontractsthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiod.Thestudyteamalsoassessedwhetheranyobserveddisparitieswerestatisticallysignificant.ResultsfromthedisparityanalysisarepresentedinChapter7andAppendixF.
Program measures. BBCreviewedthemeasuresthattheCityusestoencouragetheparticipationofsmallbusinesses—includingmanyminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesses—initscontractingaswellasmeasuresthatotherorganizationsacrossthecountryuse.ThatinformationispresentedinChapter8.
Aspirational annual goals.Basedoninformationfromtheavailabilityanalysisandotherresearch,BBCprovidedtheCitywithinformationthatwillhelpsetaspirationalannualgoalsinconnectionwiththeMWBEandFederalDBEPrograms,includingbasefigurecalculationsandconsiderationsofstep‐2adjustments.InformationabouttheCity’saspirationalannualgoalsispresentedinChapter9.
Program implementation.BBCreviewedtheCity’scontractingpracticesandprogrammeasuresthatarepartofitsimplementationoftheMWBE,EBE,SBE,andFederalDBEPrograms.BBCprovidedguidancerelatedtoadditionalprogramoptionsandchangestocurrentcontractingpractices.Thestudyteam’sreviewandguidanceforbothprogramsispresentedinChapter10.
C. Study Team Members
TheBBCdisparitystudyteamwasmadeupofsixfirmsthat,collectively,possessdecadesofexperiencerelatedtoconductingdisparitystudiesinconnectionwithminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessprograms.
BBC (prime consultant).BBCisaDenver‐baseddisparitystudyandeconomicresearchfirm.BBChadoverallresponsibilityforthedisparitystudyandperformedallofthequantitativeanalyses.
![Page 30: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 1, PAGE 8
Zann & Associates.Zann&AssociatesisaBlackAmericanwoman‐ownedmanagementconsultingfirmbasedinDenver.Zann&Associatesconductedin‐depthinterviewswithbusinesslocatedintheDenverregionaspartofthestudyteam’squalitativeanalysesofmarketplaceconditions.Inaddition,thefirmhelpedfacilitatevariouscommunityengagementefforts.
KDJK Strategies. KDJKStrategiesisaHispanicAmericanwoman‐ownedprofessionalservicesfirmbasedinDenver.Thefirmconductedin‐depthinterviewswithbusinesslocatedintheDenverregionaspartofthestudyteam’squalitativeanalysesofmarketplaceconditions.
Holland & Knight. Holland&Knightisalawfirmwithofficesthroughoutthecountry.Holland&Knightconductedthelegalanalysisthatprovidedthebasisforthestudy.
Customer Research International (CRI).CRIisaSubcontinentAsianAmerican‐ownedsurveyfieldworkfirmbasedinSanMarcos,Texas.CRIconductedtelephonesurveyswiththousandsofbusinesseslocatedintheDenverregiontogatherinformationfortheutilizationandavailabilityanalyses.
Keen Independent Research (Keen Independent). KeenIndependentisanArizona‐basedresearchfirm.KeenIndependenthelpedmanagethein‐depthinterviewprocessaspartofthestudyteam’squalitativeanalysesofmarketplaceconditions.
![Page 31: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
CHAPTER 2.
Legal Analysis
![Page 32: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 2, PAGE 1
CHAPTER 2. Legal Analysis
TheCityandCountyofDenver(TheCity)operatestheMinority‐andWoman‐ownedBusinessEnterprise(MWBE)ProgramandtheFederalDisadvantagedBusinessEnterprise(DBE)Programtoencouragetheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinitslocally‐fundedandFederalAirportAdministration(FAA)‐fundedcontracts,respectively.1Todoso,theCityreliesonacombinationofrace‐andgender‐neutralmeasuresandrace‐andgender‐consciousmeasuresaspartofitsimplementationofbothprograms.Race‐andgender‐neutralmeasuresaremeasuresthataredesignedtoencouragetheparticipationofsmallbusinessesinanorganization’scontracting,regardlessoftherace/ethnicityorgenderofbusinesses’owners.Incontrast,race‐andgender‐consciousmeasuresaredesignedtospecificallyencouragetheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesintheorganization’scontracting.
TheCity’suseofMWBEandDBEgoalsonindividualcontractsisconsideredarace‐orgender‐consciousmeasure.Itisinstructivetoreviewlegalstandardssurroundingtheiruse,becausetherearedifferentlegalstandardsfordeterminingtheconstitutionalityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessprogramsdependingonwhethertheyrelyonlyonrace‐andgender‐neutralmeasuresoracombinationofbothrace‐andgender‐neutralandrace‐andgender‐consciousmeasures.
Programs that Rely Only on Race‐ and Gender‐Neutral Measures
Governmentorganizationsthatimplementcontractingprogramsthatrelyonlyonrace‐andgender‐neutralmeasurestoencouragetheparticipationofsmallbusinessesregardlessoftherace/ethnicityorgenderofbusinessownersmustshowarationalbasisfortheirprograms.Showingarationalbasisrequiresorganizationstodemonstratethattheircontractingprogramsarerationallyrelatedtoalegitimategovernmentinterest.Itisthelowestthresholdforevaluatingthelegalityofgovernmentcontractingprograms.Whencourtsreviewprogramsbasedonarationalbasis,onlythemostegregiousviolationsleadtoprogramsbeingdeemedunconstitutional.
Programs that Rely on Race‐ and Gender‐Neutral and Race‐ and Gender‐Conscious Measures
TheUnitedStatesSupremeCourthasestablishedthatcontractingprogramsthatincludebothrace‐andgender‐neutralandrace‐andgender‐consciousmeasuresmustmeetthestrictscrutinystandardofconstitutionalreview.2Incontrasttoarationalbasisreview,thestrictscrutinystandardpresentsthehighestthresholdforevaluatingthelegalityofgovernmentcontracting
1TheCityalsoimplementstheAirportConcessionsDisadvantagedBusinessEnterprise(ACDBE)Programtoencouragetheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinconcessionsagreementsatDEN,butanalysesaroundconcessionswereoutsidethescopeofthisstudy.
2CertainFederalCourtsofAppealsapplytheintermediatescrutinystandardtogender‐consciousprograms.AppendixBdescribestheintermediatescrutinystandardindetail.
![Page 33: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 2, PAGE 2
programsshortofprohibitingthemaltogether.ThetwokeyUnitedStatesSupremeCourtcasesthatestablishedthestrictscrutinystandardforsuchprogramsare:
The1989decisioninCityofRichmondv.J.A.CrosonCompany,whichestablishedthestrictscrutinystandardofreviewforrace‐consciousprogramsadoptedbystateandlocalgovernments;3and
The1995decisioninAdarandConstructors,Inc.v.Peña,whichestablishedthestrictscrutinystandardofreviewforfederalrace‐consciousprograms.4
Underthestrictscrutinystandard,agovernmentorganizationmustshowacompellinggovernmentalinteresttouserace‐andgender‐consciousmeasuresandensurethatitsuseofrace‐andgender‐consciousmeasuresisnarrowtailored.Aprogramthatfailstomeeteithercomponentisunconstitutional.
Compelling governmental interest. Agovernmentorganizationmustdemonstrateacompellinggovernmentalinterestinremedyingpastidentifieddiscriminationinordertoimplementrace‐orgender‐consciousmeasures.Anorganizationthatusesrace‐orgender‐consciousmeasuresaspartofaminority‐orwoman‐ownedbusinessprogramhastheinitialburdenofshowingevidenceofdiscrimination—includingstatisticalandanecdotalevidence—thatsupportstheuseofsuchmeasures.Organizationscannotrelyonnationalstatisticsofdiscriminationinanindustrytodrawconclusionsabouttheprevailingmarketconditionsintheirownregions.Rather,theymustassessdiscriminationwithintheirownrelevantmarketareas.5Itisnotnecessaryforagovernmentorganizationitselftohavediscriminatedagainstminority‐orwoman‐ownedbusinessesforittoact.InCityofRichmondv.J.A.CrosonCompany,theSupremeCourtfound,“if[theorganization]couldshowthatithadessentiallybecomea‘passiveparticipant’inasystemofracialexclusionpracticedbyelementsofthelocalconstructionindustry…[i]tcouldtakeaffirmativestepstodismantlesuchasystem.”
Narrow tailoring.Inadditiontodemonstratingacompellinggovernmentalinterest,agovernmentagencymustalsodemonstratethatitsuseofrace‐andgender‐consciousmeasuresisnarrowlytailored.Thereareanumberoffactorsthatacourtconsiderswhendeterminingwhethertheuseofsuchmeasuresisnarrowlytailoredincluding:
Thenecessityofsuchmeasuresandtheefficacyofalternative,race‐andgender‐neutralmeasures;
Thedegreetowhichtheuseofsuchmeasuresislimitedtothosegroupsthatactuallysufferdiscriminationinthelocalmarketplace;
Thedegreetowhichtheuseofsuchmeasuresisflexibleandlimitedinduration,includingtheavailabilityofwaiversandsunsetprovisions;
3CityofRichmondv.J.A.CrosonCompany,488U.S.469(1989).
4AdarandConstructors,Inc.v.Peña,515U.S.200(1995).
5Seee.g.,ConcreteWorks,Inc.v.CityandCountyofDenver(“ConcreteWorksI”),36F.3d1513,1520(10thCir.1994).
![Page 34: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 2, PAGE 3
Therelationshipofanynumericalgoalstotherelevantbusinessmarketplace;and
Theimpactofsuchmeasuresontherightsofthirdparties.6
Manygovernmentorganizationshaveusedinformationfromdisparitystudiesaspartofdeterminingwhethertheircontractingpracticesareaffectedbyrace‐orgender‐baseddiscriminationandensuringthattheiruseofrace‐andgender‐consciousmeasuresisnarrowlytailored.Specifically,organizationshaveassessedevidenceofanydisparitiesbetweentheparticipationandavailabilityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesfortheircontractsandprocurements.InCityofRichmondv.J.A.CrosonCompany,theUnitedStatesSupremeCourtheldthat,“[w]herethereisasignificantstatisticaldisparitybetweenthenumberofqualifiedminoritycontractorswillingandabletoperformaparticularserviceandthenumberofsuchcontractorsactuallyengagedbythelocalityorthelocality’sprimecontractors,aninferenceofdiscriminatoryexclusioncouldarise.”LowercourtdecisionssinceCityofRichmondv.J.A.CrosonCompanyhaveheldthatacompellinggovernmentalinterestmustbeestablishedforeachracial/ethnicandgendergrouptowhichrace‐andgender‐consciousmeasuresapply.
Meeting the strict scrutiny standard.Manyprogramshavefailedtomeetthestrictscrutinystandard,becausetheyhavefailedtomeetthecompellinggovernmentalinterestrequirement,thenarrowtailoringrequirement,orboth.However,manyotherprogramshavemetthestrictscrutinystandardandcourtshavedeemedthemtobeconstitutional.OnesuchprogramistheCityofDenver’sMWBEProgram,whichwaschallengedinConcreteWorks,Inc.v.CityandCountyofDenver.Inthecase,ConcreteWorks,Inc.challengedtheconstitutionalityofanaffirmativeactionordinancethatestablishedparticipationgoalsforminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesforcertainCityconstructionandprofessionalservicescontracts.TheordinanceandsubsequentordinanceswerebasedinpartoninformationfromaseriesofdisparitystudiesthattheCityconductedbeginningin1989.
ThedistrictcourtruledinfavorofConcreteWorks,Inc.andconcludedthattheordinancesviolatedtheFourteenthAmendment.However,theCityappealedtherulingtotheTenthCircuitCourtofAppeals,andtheCourtofAppealsheldthattheCityhadestablishedacompellinggovernmentalinteresttohavearace‐andgender‐consciousprogramtolimitrace‐andgender‐baseddiscrimination.7ConcreteWorks,Inc.v.CityandCountyofDenverisinstructive,becauseitisoneoftheonlydecisionstoupholdthevalidityofalocalminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessprogram.AppendixBpresentstheConcreteWorkscaseandotherrelevantcaselawingreaterdetail.
6See,e.g.,AGC,SDCv.Caltrans,713F.3dat1198‐1199;Rothe,545F.3dat1036;WesternStatesPaving,407F3dat993‐995;SherbrookeTurf,345F.3dat971;AdarandVII,228F.3dat1181;Eng’gContractorsAss’n,122F.3dat927(internalquotationsandcitationsomitted).
7TheCourtofAppealsdidnotaddresstheissueofwhethertheordinanceswerenarrowlytailored,becauseitheldthedistrictcourtwasbarredunderthelawofthecasedoctrinefromconsideringthatissuesinceitwasnotraisedonappealbyConcreteWorks,Inc.aftertheyhadlostthatissueonsummaryjudgmentinanearlierdecision.
![Page 35: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
CHAPTER 3.
Marketplace Conditions
![Page 36: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 3, PAGE 1
CHAPTER 3. Marketplace Conditions
Historically,therehavebeenmyriadlegal,economic,andsocialobstaclesthathaveimpededminoritiesandwomenfromacquiringthehumanandfinancialcapitalnecessarytostartandoperatesuccessfulbusinesses.Barrierssuchasslavery,racialoppression,segregation,race‐baseddisplacement,andlabormarketdiscriminationproducedsubstantialdisparitiesforminoritiesandwomen,theeffectsofwhicharestillapparenttoday.Thosebarrierslimitedopportunitiesforminoritiesintermsofbotheducationandworkplaceexperience.1,2,3,4
Similarly,manywomenwererestrictedtoeitherbeinghomemakersortakinggender‐specificjobswithlowpayandlittlechanceforadvancement.5
Inthe19thandearly20thcenturies,minoritiesinColoradofacedbarriersthatweresimilartothosethatminoritiesfacednationwide.DiscriminatorytreatmentwascommonforminoritiesinDenver.BlackAmericanswereforcedtoliveinracially‐segregatedneighborhoods;sendtheirchildrentosegregatedschools;anduseseparatefacilitiesatarearestaurantsandculturalinstitutions.Disparatetreatmentalsoextendedintothelabormarket.Minoritieswereconcentratedinlowwageworkwithfewopportunitiesforadvancement.6,7,8
Inthemiddleofthe20thcentury,manylegalandworkplacereformsopenedupnewopportunitiesforminoritiesandwomennationwide.Brownv.BoardofEducation,TheEqualPayAct,TheCivilRightsAct,andTheWomen’sEducationalEquityActoutlawedmanyformsofrace‐andgender‐baseddiscrimination.Workplacesadoptedformalizedpersonnelpoliciesandimplementedprogramstodiversifytheirstaffs.9Thosereformsincreaseddiversityinworkplacesandreducededucationalandemploymentdisparitiesforminoritiesandwomen10,11,12,13However,despitethoseimprovements,minoritiesandwomencontinuetofacebarriers—suchasincarceration,residentialsegregation,andfamilyresponsibilities—thathavemadeitmoredifficulttoacquirethehumanandfinancialcapitalnecessarytostartandoperatebusinessessuccessfully.14,15,16
FederalCourtsandtheUnitedStatesCongresshaveconsideredbarriersthatminorities;women;andminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesfaceinalocalmarketplaceasevidencefortheexistenceofrace‐andgender‐baseddiscriminationinthatmarketplace.17,18,19TheUnitedStatesSupremeCourtandotherfederalcourtshaveheldthatanalysesofconditionsinalocalmarketplaceforminorities;women;andminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesareinstructiveindeterminingwhetheragencies’implementationsofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessprogramsareappropriateandjustified.Thoseanalyseshelpagenciesdeterminewhethertheyarepassivelyparticipatinginanyrace‐orgender‐baseddiscriminationthatmakesitmoredifficultforminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessestosuccessfullycompetefortheircontracts.Passiveparticipationindiscriminationreferstoagenciesunintentionallyperpetuatingrace‐orgender‐baseddiscriminationsimplybyoperatingwithindiscriminatorymarketplaces.Manycourtshaveheldthatpassiveparticipationinanyrace‐orgender‐baseddiscrimination
![Page 37: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 3, PAGE 2
establishesacompellinggovernmentalinterestforagenciestotakeremedialactiontoaddresssuchdiscrimination.20,21,22
Thestudyteamconductedquantitativeandqualitativeanalysestoassesswhetherminorities;women;andminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesfaceanybarriersintheDenverconstruction;professionalservices;andgoodsandservicesindustries.Thestudyteamalsoexaminedthepotentialeffectsthatanysuchbarriershaveontheformationandsuccessofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesandontheirparticipationin,andavailabilityfor,contractsthattheCityofDenverawards.Thestudyteamexaminedlocalmarketplaceconditionsprimarilyinfourareas:
Humancapital,toassesswhetherminoritiesandwomenfaceanybarriersrelatedtoeducation,employment,andgainingmanagerialexperienceinrelevantindustries;
Financialcapital,toassesswhetherminoritiesandwomenfaceanybarriersrelatedtowages,homeownership,personalwealth,andaccesstofinancing;
Businessownershiptoassesswhetherminoritiesandwomenownbusinessesatratesthatarecomparabletothatofnon‐Hispanicwhitemen;and
Successofbusinessestoassesswhetherminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesseshaveoutcomesthataresimilartothoseofbusinessesownedbynon‐Hispanicwhitemen.
TheinformationinChapter3comesfromexistingresearchintheareaofrace‐andgender‐baseddiscriminationaswellasfromprimaryresearchthatthestudyteamconductedofcurrentmarketplaceconditions.AdditionalquantitativeandqualitativeanalysesofmarketplaceconditionsarepresentedinAppendixCandAppendixD,respectively.
A. Human Capital
Humancapitalisthecollectionofpersonalknowledge,behavior,experience,andcharacteristicsthatmakeupanindividual’sabilitytoperformandsucceedinparticularlabormarkets.Humancapitalfactorssuchaseducation,businessexperience,andmanagerialexperiencehavebeenshowntoberelatedtobusinesssuccess.23,24,25,26Anyrace‐orgender‐basedbarriersinthoseareasmaymakeitmoredifficultforminoritiesandwomentoworkinrelevantindustriesandpreventsomeofthemfromstartingandoperatingbusinessessuccessfully.
Education.Barriersassociatedwitheducationalattainmentmayprecludeentryoradvancementincertainindustries,becausemanyoccupationsrequireatleastahighschooldiploma,andsomeoccupations—suchasoccupationsinprofessionalservices—requireatleastafour‐yearcollegedegree.Inaddition,educationalattainmentisastrongpredictorofbothincomeandpersonalwealth,whicharebothshowntoberelatedtobusinessformationandsuccess.27,28Nationally,minoritieslagbehindnon‐Hispanicwhitesintermsofbotheducationalattainmentandthequalityofeducationthattheyreceive.29,30Minoritiesarefarmorelikelythannon‐Hispanicwhitestoattendschoolsthatdonotprovideaccesstocoreclassesinscienceandmath.31Inaddition,BlackAmericanstudentsaremorethanthreetimesmorelikelythannon‐Hispanicwhitestobeexpelledorsuspendedfromhighschool.32Forthoseandotherreasons,minoritiesarefarlesslikelythannon‐Hispanicwhitestoattendcollege;enrollathighly‐ormoderatelyselectivefour‐yearinstitutions;orearncollegedegrees.33
![Page 38: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 3, PAGE 3
EducationaloutcomesforminoritiesinDenveraresimilartothoseforminoritiesnationwide.Thestudyteam’sanalysesoftheDenverlaborforceindicatethatcertainminoritygroupsarefarlesslikelythannon‐Hispanicwhitestoearnacollegedegree.Figure3‐1presentsthepercentageofDenverworkersthathaveearnedafour‐yearcollegedegreebyracial/ethnicandgendergroup.AsshowninFigure3‐1,BlackAmerican,AsianPacificAmerican,HispanicAmerican,andNativeAmericanworkersinDenveraresubstantiallylesslikelythannon‐Hispanicwhiteworkerstohavefour‐yearcollegedegrees.
Figure 3‐1. Percentage of workers 25 and older with at least a four‐year college degree, Denver, 2012‐2016
Note:
** Denotes that the difference in proportions between the minority group and non‐Hispanic whites (or between women and men) is statistically significant at the 95% confidence level.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting from 2012‐2016 ACS 5% Public Use Microdata sample. The raw data extract was obtained through the IPUMS program of the MN Population Center: http://usa.ipums.org/usa/.
Employment and management experience.Animportantprecursortobusinessownershipandsuccessisacquiringdirectworkandmanagementexperienceinrelevantindustries.Anybarriersthatlimitminoritiesandwomenfromacquiringthatexperiencecouldpreventthemfromstartingandoperatingrelatedbusinessesinthefuture.
Employment.Onanationallevel,priorindustryexperiencehasbeenshowntobeanimportantindicatorforbusinessownershipandsuccess.However,minoritiesandwomenareoftenunabletoacquirerelevantworkexperience.Minoritiesandwomenaresometimesdiscriminatedagainstinhiringdecisions,whichimpedestheirentryintothelabormarket.34,35,36Whenemployed,minoritiesandwomenareoftenrelegatedtoperipheralpositionsinthelabormarketandtoindustriesthatexhibitalreadyhighconcentrationsofminoritiesorwomen.37,38,39,40,41Inaddition,minoritiesareincarceratedatahigherratethannon‐HispanicwhitesinColoradoandnationwide,whichcontributestoanumberoflabordifficulties,includingdifficultiesfindingsjobsandrelativelyslowwagegrowth.42,43,44,45
Thestudyteam’sanalysesofthelaborforceinDenverarelargelyconsistentwiththosefindings.Figures3‐2and3‐3presenttherepresentationsofminorityandwomenworkersinvariousDenverindustries.AsshowninFigure3‐2,theDenverindustrieswiththehighestrepresentationsofminorityworkersareconstruction;otherservices;andchildcare,hair,andnails.TheDenverindustrieswiththelowestrepresentationsofminorityworkersareextractionandagriculture;education;andarchitectureandengineering.
![Page 39: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 3, PAGE 4
Figure 3‐2. Percent representation of minorities in various industries, Denver, 2012‐2016
Note: *, ** Denotes that the difference in proportions between minority workers in the specified industry and all industries is statistically significant at the 90% and 95% confidence level, respectively.
The representation of minorities among all Denver workers is 5 percent for Black Americans, 19 percent for Hispanic Americans, 4 percent for Asian Pacific Americans, 1 percent for Subcontinent Asian Americans, 1 percent for Native Americans, 0 percent for Other race minorities, and 30 percent for all minorities considered together.
Workers in the finance, insurance, real estate, legal services, accounting, advertising, architecture, management, and scientific research industries were combined to one category of Professional Services. Workers in the rental and leasing; travel; investigation; waste remediation; arts; entertainment; recreation; accommodations; food services; and select other services were combined into one category of other services. Workers in child day care services, barber shops, beauty salons, nail salons, and other personal were combined into one category of childcare, hair, and nails.
Source: BBC Research & Consulting from 2012‐2016 ACS 5% Public Use Microdata sample. The raw data extract was obtained through the IPUMS program of the MN Population Center: http://usa.ipums.org/usa/.
Figures3‐3indicatesthattheDenverindustrieswiththehighestrepresentationsofwomenworkersarechildcare,hair,andnails;healthcare;andeducation.TheDenverindustrieswiththelowestrepresentationsofwomenworkersareextractionandagriculture;manufacturing;andconstruction.
Management experience.Managerialexperienceisanessentialpredictorofbusinesssuccess.However,race‐andgender‐baseddiscriminationremainsapersistentobstacletogreaterdiversityinmanagementpositions.46,47,48Nationally,minoritiesandwomenarefarlesslikelythannon‐Hispanicwhitementoworkinmanagementpositions.49,50SimilaroutcomesappeartoexistforminoritiesandwomeninDenver.ThestudyteamexaminedtheconcentrationofminoritiesandwomeninmanagementpositionsintheDenverconstruction;professionalservices;andgoodsandservicesindustries.Figure3‐4presentsthoseresults.
![Page 40: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 3, PAGE 5
Figure 3‐3. Percent representation of women in various industries, Denver, 2012‐2016
Note: ** Denotes that the difference in proportions between women workers in the specified industry and all industries is statistically significant at the 95% confidence level.
The representation of women among all Denver workers is 46 percent.
Workers in the finance, insurance, real estate, legal services, accounting, advertising, architecture, management, and scientific research industries were combined to one category of Professional Services. Workers in the rental and leasing; travel; investigation; waste remediation; arts; entertainment; recreation; accommodations; food services; and select other services were combined into one category of other services. Workers in child day care services, barber shops, beauty salons, nail salons, and other personal were combined into one category of childcare, hair, and nails.
Source: BBC Research & Consulting from 2012‐2016 ACS 5% Public Use Microdata sample. The raw data extract was obtained through the IPUMS program of the MN Population Center: http://usa.ipums.org/usa/.
AsshowninFigure3‐4:
Comparedtonon‐Hispanicwhites,smallerpercentagesofBlackAmericans,HispanicAmericans,andNativeAmericansworkasmanagersintheDenverconstructionindustry.Inaddition,alargerpercentageofwomenthanmenworkasmanagersintheDenverconstructionindustry.
Comparedtonon‐Hispanicwhites,smallerpercentagesofBlackAmericans,AsianPacificAmericans,andHispanicAmericansworkasmanagersintheDenverprofessionalservicesindustry.
Comparedtonon‐Hispanicwhites,smallerpercentagesofBlackAmericans,AsianPacificAmericans,HispanicAmericans,NativeAmericans,andotherraceminoritiesworkasmanagersintheDenvergoodsandservicesindustry.Inaddition,asmallerpercentageofwomenthanmenworkasmanagersintheDenvergoodsandservicesindustry.
![Page 41: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 3, PAGE 6
Figure 3‐4. Percentage of workers who worked as a manager in Denver, 2012‐2016
Note:
*, ** Denotes that the difference in proportions between the minority group and non‐Hispanic whites (or between women and men) is statistically significant at the 90% and 95% confidence level, respectively.
† Denotes that significant differences in proportions were not reported due to small sample size.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting from 2012‐2016 ACS 5% Public Use Microdata sample. The raw data extract was obtained through the IPUMS program of the MN Population Center: http://usa.ipums.org/usa/.
Intergenerational business experience.Havingafamilymemberwhoownsabusinessandisworkinginthatbusinessisanimportantpredictorofbusinessownershipandbusinesssuccess.Suchexperienceshelpentrepreneursgainaccesstoimportantopportunitynetworks;obtainknowledgeofbestpracticesandbusinessetiquette;andreceivehands‐onexperienceinhelpingtorunbusinesses.However,atleastnationally,minoritieshavesubstantiallyfewerfamilymemberswhoownbusinessesandbothminoritiesandwomenhavefeweropportunitiestobeinvolvedwiththosebusinesses.51,52Thatlackofexperiencemakesitmoredifficultforminoritiesandwomentosubsequentlystarttheirownbusinessesandoperatethemsuccessfully.
B. Financial Capital
Inadditiontohumancapital,financialcapitalhasbeenshowntobeanimportantindicatorofbusinessformationandsuccess.53,54,55Individualscanacquirefinancialcapitalthroughmanysources,includingemploymentwages,personalwealth,homeownership,andfinancing.Ifrace‐orgender‐baseddiscriminationexistsinthosecapitalmarkets,minoritiesandwomenmayhavedifficultyacquiringthecapitalnecessarytostart,operate,orexpandbusinesses.
Wages and income.Wageandincomegapsbetweenminoritiesandnon‐Hispanicwhitesandbetweenwomenandmenarewell‐documentedthroughoutthecountry,evenwhenresearchershavestatisticallycontrolledforvariousfactorsunrelatedtoraceandgender.56,57,58Forexample,nationalincomedataindicatethat,onaverage,BlackAmericansandHispanicAmericanshavehouseholdincomesthatarelessthantwo‐thirdsthoseofnon‐Hispanicwhites.59,60Womenhavealsofacedconsistentwageandincomegapsrelativetomen.Nationally,themedianhourlywageofwomenisstillonly84percentthemedianhourlywageofmen.61Suchdisparitiesmakeitdifficultforminoritiesandwomentouseemploymentwagesasasourceofbusinesscapital.
BBCobservedwagegapsinDenverconsistentwiththosethatresearchershaveobservednationally.Figure3‐5presentsmeanannualwagesforDenverworkersbyrace/ethnicityandgender.AsshowninFigure3‐5,BlackAmericans,HispanicAmericans,NativeAmericans,andotherraceminoritiesinDenverearnsubstantiallylessthannon‐Hispanicwhites.Inaddition,womenworkersearnsubstantiallylessthanmen.BBCalsoconductedregressionanalysesto
Denver
Race/ethnicity
Black American 5.6 % ** 6.2 % ** 3.7 % **
Asian Pacific American 12.2 % 5.8 % ** 4.4 % **
Subcontinent Asian American 0.0 % † 9.0 % 9.7 %
Hispanic American 2.6 % ** 6.4 % ** 2.5 % **
Native American 3.9 % ** 11.3 % 3.3 % **
Other Race Minority 6.9 % † 0.0 % † 0.0 % *
Non‐Hispanic white 16.8 % 9.8 % 8.6 %
Gender
Women 14.5 % ** 8.7 % 6.3 % *
Men 10.5 % 9.5 % 7.3 %
All individuals 10.9 % 9.2 % 6.9 %
Goods &
ServicesConstruction
Professional
Services
![Page 42: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 3, PAGE 7
assesswhetherwagedisparitiesexistevenafteraccountingforvariousrace‐andgender‐neutralfactorssuchasage,education,andfamilystatus.ThoseanalysesindicatedthatbeingBlackAmerican,AsianPacificAmerican,SubcontinentAsianAmerican,HispanicAmerican,NativeAmerican,orotherraceminoritywasassociatedwithsubstantiallylowerwagesthanbeingnon‐Hispanicwhite,evenafteraccountingforvariousrace‐andgender‐neutralfactors.Similarly,beingawomanwasassociatedwithlowerearningsthanbeingaman(fordetails,seeFigureC‐10inAppendixC).
Figure 3‐5. Mean annual wages, Denver, 2012‐2016
Note:
The sample universe is all non‐institutionalized, employed individuals aged 25‐64 that are not in school, the military, or self‐employed.
** Denotes statistically significant differences from non‐Hispanic whites (for minority groups) or from men (for women) at the 95% confidence level.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting from 2012‐2016 ACS 5% Public Use Microdata sample. The raw data extract was obtained through the IPUMS program of the MN Population Center: http://usa.ipums.org/usa/.
Personal wealth.Anotherimportantpotentialsourceofbusinesscapitalispersonalwealth.Aswithwagesandincome,therearesubstantialdisparitiesbetweenminoritiesandnon‐Hispanicwhitesandbetweenwomenandmenintermsofpersonalwealth.62,63Forexample,in2010,BlackAmericansandHispanicAmericansacrossthecountryexhibitedaveragehouseholdnetworththatwas5percentand1percentthatofnon‐Hispanicwhites,respectively.InColoradoandnationwide,approximatelyone‐quarterofBlackAmericansandHispanicAmericansarelivinginpoverty,aboutdoublethecomparableratesfornon‐Hispanicwhites.64Wealthinequalitiesalsoexistforwomenrelativetomen.Forexample,themedianwealthofnon‐marriedwomennationallyisapproximatelyone‐thirdthatofnon‐marriedmen.65
Homeownership.Homeownershipandhomeequityhavebeenshowntobekeysourcesofbusinesscapital.66,67However,minoritiesappeartofacesubstantialbarriersnationwideinowninghomes.Forexample,BlackAmericansandHispanicAmericansownhomesatlessthantwo‐thirdstherateofnon‐Hispanicwhites.68Discriminationisatleastpartlytoblameforthosedisparities.Researchindicatesthatminoritiescontinuetobegivenlessinformationonprospectivehomesandhavetheirpurchaseoffersrejectedbecauseoftheirrace.69,70Minoritieswhoownhomestendtoownhomesthatareworthsubstantiallylessthanthoseofnon‐Hispanicwhitesandalsotendtoaccruesubstantiallylessequity.71,72Differencesinhomevaluesandequitybetweenminoritiesandnon‐Hispanicwhitescanbeattributed—atleast,inpart—tothedepressedpropertyvaluesthattendtoexistinracially‐segregatedneighborhoods.73,74
![Page 43: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/43.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 3, PAGE 8
MinoritiesappeartofacehomeownershipbarriersinDenverthataresimilartothoseobservednationally.BBCexaminedhomeownershipratesinDenverforrelevantracial/ethnicgroups.AsshowninFigure3‐6,BlackAmericans,AsianPacificAmericans,SubcontinentAsianAmericans,HispanicAmericans,andNativeAmericansinDenverexhibithomeownershipratesthataresignificantlylowerthanthatofnon‐Hispanicwhites.
Figure 3‐6. Home Ownership Rates, Denver, 2012‐2016
Note:
The sample universe is all households.
** Denotes statistically significant differences from non‐Hispanic whites at the 95% confidence level.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting from 2012‐2016 ACS 5% Public Use Microdata sample. The raw data extract was obtained through the IPUMS program of the MN Population Center: http://usa.ipums.org/usa/.
Figure3‐7presentsmedianhomevaluesamonghomeownersofdifferentracial/ethnicgroupsinDenver.Consistentwithnationaltrends,homeownersofcertainminoritygroups—BlackAmericans,HispanicAmericans,NativeAmericans,andotherraceminorities—ownhomesthat,onaverage,areworthsubstantiallylessthanthoseofnon‐Hispanicwhites.
Figure 3‐7. Median home values, Denver Region, 2012‐2016
Note:
The sample universe is all owner‐occupied housing units.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting from 2012‐2016 ACS 5% Public Use Microdata sample. The raw data extract was obtained through the IPUMS program of the MN Population Center: http://usa.ipums.org/usa/.
Access to financing. Minoritiesandwomenfacemanybarriersintryingtoaccesscreditandfinancing,bothforhomepurchasesandforbusinesscapital.Researchershaveoftenattributedthosebarrierstovariousformsofrace‐andgender‐baseddiscriminationthatexistincreditmarkets.75,76,77,78,79,80Thestudyteamsummarizesresultsrelatedtodifficultiesthatminorities;women;andminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesfaceinthehomecreditandbusinesscreditmarkets.
Home credit.Minoritiesandwomencontinuetofacebarrierswhentryingtoaccesscredittopurchasehomes.Examplesofsuchbarriersincludediscriminatorytreatmentofminoritiesandwomenduringthepre‐applicationphaseanddisproportionatetargetingofminorityandwomenborrowersforsubprimehomeloans.81,82,83,84,85Race‐andgender‐basedbarriersinhomecredit
![Page 44: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/44.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 3, PAGE 9
markets,aswellastherecentforeclosurecrisis,haveledtodecreasesinhomeownershipamongminoritiesandwomenandhaveerodedtheirlevelsofpersonalwealth.86,87,88,89
Toexaminehowminoritiesfareinthehomecreditmarketrelativetonon‐Hispanicwhites,thestudyteamanalyzedhomeloandenialratesforhigh‐incomehouseholdsbyrace/ethnicity.ThestudyteamanalyzedthosedataforDenverandtheUnitedStatesasawhole.AsshowninFigure3‐8,allrelevantminoritygroupsexhibithigherhomeloandenialratesthannon‐HispanicwhiteswhenconsideringboththeUnitedStatesandDenverinparticular.Inaddition,thestudyteam’sanalysesindicatethatcertainminoritygroupsinDenveraremorelikelythannon‐Hispanicwhitestoreceivesubprimemortgages(fordetails,seeFigureC‐14inAppendixC).
Figure 3‐8. Denial rates of conventional purchase loans for high‐income households, Denver and the United States, 2016
Note:
High‐income borrowers are those households with 120% or more of the HUD area median family income (MFI).
Source:
FFIEC HMDA data. The raw data extract was obtained from the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau HMDA data tool: http://www.consumerfinance.gov/hmda/explore.
Business credit.Minority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesfacesubstantialdifficultiesaccessingbusinesscreditaswell.Forexample,duringloanpre‐applicationmeetings,minority‐ownedbusinessesaregivenlessinformationaboutloanproducts,aresubjectedtomorecreditinformationrequests,andareofferedlesssupportthantheirnon‐Hispanicwhitecounterparts.90
ResearchershaveshownthatBlackAmerican‐ownedbusinessesandHispanicAmerican‐ownedbusinessesaremorelikelytoforegosubmittingbusinessloanapplicationsandaremorelikelytobedeniedbusinesscreditwhentheydoseekloans,evenafteraccountingforvariousrace‐andgender‐neutralfactors.91,92,93Inaddition,womenarelesslikelytoapplyforcreditandreceiveloansoflessvaluewhentheydo.94,95Withoutequalaccesstobusinesscapital,minority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesmustoperatewithlesscapitalthanbusinessesownedbynon‐Hispanicwhitemenandrelymoreonpersonalfinances.96,97,98,99
C. Business Ownership
Nationally,therehasbeensubstantialgrowthinthenumberofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinrecentyears.Forexample,from2007to2012,thenumberofwoman‐ownedbusinessesincreasedby27percent,thenumberofBlackAmerican‐ownedbusinessesincreasedby35percent,andthenumberofHispanicAmerican‐ownedbusinessesincreasedby46percent.100Despitetheprogressthatminoritiesandwomenhavemadewithregardtobusinessownership,importantbarriersinstartingandoperatingbusinessesremain.BlackAmericans,HispanicAmericans,andwomenarestilllesslikelytostartbusinessesthannon‐Hispanicwhitemen.101,102,103,104Inaddition,althoughratesofbusinessownershiphaveincreasedamong
![Page 45: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/45.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 3, PAGE 10
minoritiesandwomen,theyhavebeenunabletopenetrateallindustriesevenly.Minoritiesandwomendisproportionatelyownbusinessesinindustriesthatrequirelesshumanandfinancialcapitaltobesuccessfulandthatalreadyincludelargeconcentrationsofindividualsfromdisadvantagedgroups.105,106,107ThestudyteamexaminedratesofbusinessownershipintheDenverconstruction;professionalservices;andgoodsandservicesindustriesbyrace/ethnicityandgender.AsshowninFigure3‐9:
BlackAmericans,AsianPacificAmericans,andHispanicAmericansexhibitlowerratesofbusinessownershipthannon‐HispanicwhitesintheDenverconstructionindustry.Inaddition,womenexhibitlowerratesofbusinessownershipthanmen.
BlackAmericans,AsianPacificAmericans,SubcontinentAsianAmericans,andHispanicAmericansexhibitlowerratesofbusinessownershipthannon‐HispanicwhitesintheDenverprofessionalservicesindustry.
BlackAmericans,SubcontinentAsianAmericans,andHispanicAmericansexhibitlowerratesofbusinessownershipthannon‐HispanicwhitesintheDenvergoodsandservicesindustry.
Figure 3‐9. Self‐employment rates in Denver, 2012‐2016
Note:
*,** Denotes that the difference in proportions between the minority group and non‐Hispanic whites (or between women and men) is statistically significant at the 90% and 95% confidence levels, respectively.
† Denotes that significant differences in proportions were not reported due to small sample size.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting from 2012‐2016 ACS 5% Public Use Microdata samples. The raw data extract was obtained through the IPUMS program of the MN Population Center: http://usa.ipums.org/usa/.
BBCalsoconductedregressionanalysestodeterminewhetherdifferencesinbusinessownershipratesbetweenminoritiesandnon‐Hispanicwhitesandbetweenwomenandmenexistevenafterstatisticallycontrollingforvariousrace‐andgender‐neutralfactorssuchasincome,education,andfamilialstatus.Thestudyteamconductedthoseanalysesseparatelyforeachrelevantindustry.Figure3‐10presentstherace/ethnicityandgenderfactorsthatweresignificantlyandindependentlyrelatedtobusinessownershipforeachrelevantindustry.
Denver
Race/ethnicity
Black American 14.3 % ** 7.9 % ** 6.8 % **
Asian Pacific American 17.9 % * 7.8 % ** 11.3 %
Subcontinent Asian American 0.0 % † 3.3 % ** 5.8 % **
Hispanic American 11.8 % ** 11.8 % ** 10.3 % **
Native American 18.2 % 15.5 % 16.3 %
Other Race Minority 23.9 % † 4.8 % † 6.6 %
Non‐Hispanic white 27.3 % 20.0 % 14.2 %
Gender
Women 16.4 % ** 19.4 % ** 13.3 %
Men 21.4 % 16.9 % 12.5 %
All individuals 20.9 % 17.9 % 12.8 %
Construction
Goods &
Services
Professional
Services
![Page 46: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/46.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 3, PAGE 11
Figure 3‐10. Statistically significant relationships between race/ethnicity and gender and business ownership in study‐related industries in Denver, 2012‐2016
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting from 2012‐2016 ACS 5% Public Use Microdata samples. The raw data extract was obtained through the IPUMS program of the MN Population Center: http://usa.ipums.org/usa/.
AsshowninFigure3‐10,evenafteraccountingforrace‐andgender‐neutralfactors:
BeingHispanicAmericanorawomanwasassociatedwithlowerratesofbusinessownershipintheconstructionindustry.
BeingBlackAmerican,AsianPacificAmerican,orSubcontinentAsianAmericanwasassociatedwithlowerratesofbusinessownershipintheprofessionalservicesindustry.
BeingBlackAmericanorSubcontinentAsianAmericanwasassociatedwithlowerratesofbusinessownershipinthegoodsandservicesindustry.
Thus,disparitiesinbusinessownershipratesbetweenminoritiesandnon‐Hispanicwhitesandbetweenwomenandmenarenotcompletelyexplainedbydifferencesinrace‐andgender‐neutralfactorssuchasincome,education,andfamilialstatus.Disparitiesinbusinessownershipratesexistforseveralgroupsinallrelevantindustriesevenafteraccountingforsuchfactors.
D. Business Success
Thereisagreatdealofresearchindicatingthat,nationally,minority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesfareworsethanbusinessesownedbynon‐Hispanicwhitemen.Forexample,BlackAmericans,NativeAmericans,HispanicAmericans,andwomenexhibithigherratesofmovingfrombusinessownershiptounemploymentthannon‐Hispanicwhitesandmen.Inaddition,minority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesseshavebeenshowntobelesssuccessfulthanbusinessesownedbynon‐Hispanicwhitesandmenusinganumberofdifferentindicatorssuchasprofits,closurerates,andbusinesssize(butalsoseeRobbandWatson2012).108,109,110Thestudyteamexamineddataonbusinessclosure,businessreceipts,andbusinessownerearningstofurtherexplorethesuccessofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinDenver.
Business closure. ThestudyteamexaminedtheratesofclosureamongColoradobusinessesbytherace/ethnicityandgenderoftheowners.Figure3‐11presentsthoseresults.AsshowninFigure3‐11,BlackAmerican‐ownedbusinesses,AsianAmerican‐ownedbusinesses,andHispanicAmerican‐ownedbusinessesinColoradoappeartocloseathigherratesthannon‐Hispanicwhite‐ownedbusinesses.Inaddition,woman‐ownedbusinessesinColoradoappeartocloseathigherratesthanbusinessesownedbymen.Increasedratesofbusinessclosureamong
Industry and Group
Construction
Hispanic American ‐0.3820
Women ‐0.4076
Professional Services
Black American ‐0.3617
Asian Pacific American ‐0.4676
Subcontinent Asian American ‐0.7729
Goods and Services
Black American ‐0.3303
Subcontinent Asian American ‐0.4132
Coefficient
![Page 47: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/47.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 3, PAGE 12
minority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesmayhaveimportanteffectsontheiravailabilityforgovernmentcontractsinColoradoandDenver.
Figure 3‐11. Rates of business closure in Colorado, 2002‐2006
Note:
Data include only to non‐publicly held businesses.
Equal Gender Ownership refers to those businesses for which ownership is split evenly between women and men.
Statistical significance of these results cannot be determined, because sample sizes were not reported.
Source:
Lowrey, Ying. 2010. “Race/Ethnicity and Establishment Dynamics, 2002‐2006.” U.S. Small Business Administration Office of Advocacy. Washington D.C.
Lowrey, Ying. 2014. "Gender and Establishment Dynamics, 2002‐2006." U.S. Small Business Administration Office of Advocacy. Washington D.C.
Business receipts. BBCalsoexamineddataonbusinessreceiptstoassesswhetherminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinDenverearnasmuchasbusinessesownedbywhitesorbusinessesownedbymen,respectively.Figure3‐12showsmeanannualreceiptsforDenverbusinessesbytherace/ethnicityandgenderofowners.Thoseresultsindicatethatin2012allrelevantminoritygroupsinDenvershowedlowermeanannualbusinessreceiptsthanbusinessesownedbywhites.Inaddition,woman‐ownedbusinessesinDenvershowedlowermeanannualbusinessreceiptsthanbusinessesownedbymen.
Figure 3‐12. Mean annual business receipts (in thousands), Denver‐Aurora, CO CSA, 2012
Note:
Includes employer and non‐employer firms. Does not include publicly‐traded companies or other firms not classifiable by race/ethnicity and gender.
Source:
2012 Survey of Business Owners, part of the U.S. Census Bureau’s 2012 Economic Census.
Business owner earnings.ThestudyteamanalyzedbusinessownerearningstoassesswhetherminoritiesandwomeninDenverearnasmuchfromthebusinessesthattheyownasnon‐Hispanicwhitesandmendo.AsshowninFigure3‐13,BlackAmericans,HispanicAmericans,andNativeAmericansearnedlessonaveragefromtheirbusinessesthannon‐Hispanicwhitesearnedfromtheirbusinesses.Inaddition,womeninDenverearnedlessfromtheirbusinessesthanmenearnedfromtheirbusinesses.BBCalsoconductedregressionanalysestodeterminewhetherearningsdisparitiesinDenverexistevenafterstatisticallycontrollingfor
![Page 48: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/48.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 3, PAGE 13
variousrace‐andgender‐neutralfactorssuchasage,education,andfamilystatus.TheresultsofthoseanalysesindicatedthatbeingBlackAmericanorawomanwasassociatedwithsubstantiallylowerbusinessownerearnings(fordetails,seeFigureC‐27inAppendixC).
Figure 3‐13. Mean annual business owner earnings, Denver, 2012‐2016
Note:
The sample universe is business owners age 16 and older who reported positive earnings. All amounts in 2016 dollars.
** Denotes statistically significant differences from non‐Hispanic whites (for minority groups) or from men (for women) at the 95% confidence level.
† Denotes that significant differences in proportions were not reported due to small sample size.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting from 2012‐2016 ACS 5% Public Use Microdata sample. The raw data extract was obtained through the IPUMS program of the MN Population Center: http://usa.ipums.org/usa/.
E. Summary
BBC’sanalysesofmarketplaceconditionsindicatethatminorities;women;andminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesfacesubstantialbarriersnationwideandinDenver.Existingresearch,aswellasprimaryresearchthatthestudyteamconducted,indicatethatrace‐andgender‐baseddisparitiesexistintermsofacquiringhumancapital,accruingfinancialcapital,owningbusinesses,andoperatingsuccessfulbusinesses.Inmanycases,thereisevidencethatthosedisparitiesexistevenafteraccountingforvariousrace‐andgender‐neutralfactorssuchasage,income,education,andfamilialstatus.Thereisalsoevidencethatmanydisparitiesaredue—atleast,inpart—torace‐andgender‐baseddiscrimination.
BarriersinthemarketplacelikelyhaveimportanteffectsontheabilityofminoritiesandwomentostartbusinessesinrelevantDenverindustries—construction;professionalservices;andgoodsandservices—andoperatingthosebusinessessuccessfully.Anydifficultiesthatminoritiesandwomenfaceinstartingandoperatingbusinessesmayreducetheiravailabilityforgovernmentagencyworkandmayalsoreducethedegreetowhichtheyareabletosuccessfullycompeteforgovernmentcontracts.Inaddition,theexistenceofbarriersintheDenvermarketplaceindicatesthatgovernmentagenciesinthestatearepassivelyparticipatinginrace‐andgender‐baseddiscriminationthatmakesitmoredifficultforminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessestosuccessfullycompetefortheircontracts.Manycourtshaveheldthatpassiveparticipationinanyrace‐orgender‐baseddiscriminationestablishesacompellinggovernmentalinterestforagenciestotakeremedialactiontoaddresssuchdiscrimination.
![Page 49: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/49.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 3, PAGE 14
1Haney‐López,Ian.2006.WhitebyLaw:TheLegalConstructionofRace.NewYork:NYUPress.
2Woodward,ComerVann.1955.TheStrangeCareerofJimCrow.Oxford:OxfordUniversityPress.
3Prucha,FrancisPaul.1986.TheGreatFather:TheUnitedStatesGovernmentandtheAmericanIndians.Lincoln:UniversityofNebraskaPress.
4Lee,Erika.2003.AtAmerica’sGates:ChineseImmigrationDuringtheExclusionEra,1882‐1943.ChapelHill,NC:UniversityofColoradoPress.
5Goldin,Claudia.2006.“TheQuietRevolutionThatTransformedWomen’sEmployment,Education,andFamily.”TheAmericanEconomicReview96(2):1–21.
6Berwanger,EugeneH.2007.TheRiseoftheCentennialState;ColoradoTerritory,1861‐76.UrbanaandChicago:UniversityofIllinoisPress.
7Goldberg,RobertAlan.1982.HoodedEmpire:TheKuKluxKlaninColorado.Urbana,IL:UniversityofIllinoisPress.
8Ubbelohde,Carl,Benson,Maxine,andSmith,DuaneA.2006.AColoradoHistory.Boulder,CO:PruettPublishingCompany.
9Dobbin,Frank.2009.InventingEqualOpportunity.Princeton:PrincetonUniversityPress.
10Holzer,HarryandDavidNeumark.2000.“AssessingAffirmativeAction.”JournalofEconomicLiterature38(3):483–568
11Kalev,Alexandra,FrankDobbin,andErinKelly.2006.“BestPracticesorBestGuesses?AssessingtheEfficacyofCorporateAffirmativeActionandDiversityPolicies.”AmericanSociologicalReview71(4):589–617.
12Kao,GraceandJenniferS.Thompson.2003.“RacialandEthnicStratificationinEducationalAchievementandAttainment.”AnnualReviewofSociology29(1):417–42.
13DiPrete,ThomasA.andClaudiaBuchmann.2013.TheRiseofWomen:TheGrowingGenderGapinEducationandWhatItMeansforAmericanSchools.NewYork:RussellSageFoundation.
14Travis,Jeremy,BruceWestern,andSteveRedburn.2014.TheGrowthofIncarcerationintheUnitedStates:ExploringCausesandConsequences.NationalResearchCouncil.WashingtonD.C.:DivisionofBehavioralandSocialSciencesandEducation.RetrievedJanuary6,2015(http://www.nap.edu/booksearch.php?booksearch=1&record_id=18613&term=Black&chapter=33‐69).
15Charles,CamilleZubrinsky.2003.“TheDynamicsofRacialResidentialSegregation.”AnnualReviewofSociology29:167–207.
16Bianchi,SuzanneM.,LianaC.Sayer,MelissaA.Milkie,andJohnP.Robinson.2012.“Housework:WhoDid,DoesorWillDoIt,andHowMuchDoesItMatter?”SocialForces91(1):55–63.
17AdarandVII,228F.3dat1167–76;seealsoWesternStatesPaving,407F.3dat992(Congress“explicitlyreliedupon”theDepartmentofJusticestudythat“documentedthediscriminatoryhurdlesthatminoritiesmustovercometosecurefederallyfundedcontracts”);MidwestFenceCorp.v.U.S.DOT,IllinoisDOT,etal.,2015WL1396376,appealpending.
18AdarandVII,228F.3d.at1168‐70;WesternStatesPaving,407F.3dat992;seeDynaLantic,885F.Supp.2d237;MidwestFenceCorp.v.U.S.DOT,IllinoisDOT,etal.,2015WL1396376,appealpending;GeyerSignal,2014WL130909297at*14.
19AdarandVIIat1170‐72;seeDynaLantic,885F.Supp.2d237;GeyerSignal,2014WL1309092at*14.
20CityofRichmondv.J.A.CrosonCo.,488U.S.469(1989).
21ConcreteWorksofColo.,Inc.v.CityandCountyofDenver,36F.3d1513,1524(10thCir.1994).
22RotheDevelopmentCorpv.U.S.DeptofDefense,545F.3d1023,1041.
23Fairlie,RobertW.andAliciaM.Robb.2007.“WhyAreBlack‐OwnedBusinessesLessSuccessfulthanWhite‐OwnedBusinesses?TheRoleofFamilies,Inheritances,andBusinessHumanCapital.”JournalofLaborEconomics25(2):289–323.
24Fairlie,RobertW.andAliciaM.Robb.2008.RaceandEntrepreneurialSuccess:Black‐,Asian‐,andWhite‐OwnedBusinessesintheUnitedStates.Cambridge,Mass.:MITPress.
25Fairlie,RobertW.andAliciaM.Robb.2009.“GenderDifferencesinBusinessPerformance:EvidenceFromtheCharacteristicsofBusinessOwnersSurvey.”SmallBusinessEconomics33(4):375–95.
26Hout,MichaelandHarveyRosen.2000.“Self‐Employment,FamilyBackground,andRace.”JournalofHumanResources35(4):670–92.
27Emmons,WilliamR.andBryanJ.Noeth.2015.WhyDidn'tHigherEducationProtectHispanicandBlackWealth?St.Louis,MO:CenterforHouseholdFinancialStability.RetrievedAugust20,2015(https://www.stlouisfed.org/~/media/Publications/In%20the%20Balance/Images/Issue_12/ITB_August_2015.pdf).
![Page 50: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/50.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 3, PAGE 15
28Shapiro,Thomas,TatjanaMeschede,andSamOsoro.2013.TheRootsoftheWideningRacialWealthGap:ExplainingtheBlack‐WhiteEconomicDivide.Waltham,MA:InstituteonAssetsandSocialPolicy.RetrievedJanuary2,2015(http://iasp.brandeis.edu/pdfs/Author/shapiro‐thomas‐m/racialwealthgapbrief.pdf).29NationalCenterforEducationStatistics.2010.StatusandTrendsintheEducationofRacialandEthnicMinorities.NationalCenterforEducationStatistics.RetrievedJanuary20,2015(http://nces.ed.gov/pubs2010/2010015/tables.asp).
30Kao,GraceandJenniferS.Thompson.2003.“RacialandEthnicStratificationinEducationalAchievementandAttainment.”AnnualReviewofSociology29(1):417–42.31U.S.DepartmentofEducationOfficeforCivilRights.2014a.CollegeandCareerReadiness.WashingtonD.C.:U.S.DepartmentofEducation.RetrievedJanuary3,2015(http://www2.ed.gov/about/offices/list/ocr/docs/crdc‐college‐and‐career‐readiness‐snapshot.pdf).
32U.S.DepartmentofEducationOfficeforCivilRights.2014b.SchoolDiscipline,Restraint,andSeclusionHighlights.WashingtonD.C.:U.S.DepartmentofEducation.RetrievedJanuary3,2015(http://ocrdata.ed.gov/Downloads/CRDC‐School‐Discipline‐Snapshot.pdf).
33Bozkick,RobertandErichLauff.2007.EducationLongitudinalStudyof2002(ELS:2002):AFirstLookattheInitialPostsecondaryExperiencesoftheHighSchoolSophomoreClassof2002.NationalCenterforEducationStatistics.RetrievedJanuary20,2015(http://nces.ed.gov/pubsearch/pubsinfo.asp?pubid=2008308).
34Correll,ShelleyJ.,StephenBenard,andInPaik.2007.“GettingaJob:IsThereaMotherhoodPenalty?”AmericanJournalofSociology112(5):1297–1339.35Pager,Devah,BruceWestern,andBartBonikowski.2009.“DiscriminationinaLow‐WageLaborMarketAFieldExperiment.”AmericanSociologicalReview74(5):777–99.36Bertrand,MarianneandSendhilMullainathan.2004.“AreEmilyandGregMoreEmployableThanLakishaandJamal?AFieldExperimentonLaborMarketDiscrimination.”AmericanEconomicReview94(4):991–1013.37Scheider,JessicaandEliseGould.2016.“’Women’sWork’andtheGenderPayGap:HowDiscrimination,SocietalNorms,andOtherForcesaffectWomen’sOccupationalChoices.”WashingtonD.C.:EconomicPolicyInstitute.RetrievedJuly25,2016(http://www.epi.org/publication/womens‐work‐and‐the‐gender‐pay‐gap‐how‐discrimination‐societal‐norms‐and‐other‐forces‐affect‐womens‐occupational‐choices‐and‐their‐pay/).38Beck,E.M.,PatrickM.Horan,andCharlesM.TolbertII.1980.“IndustrialSegmentationandLaborMarketDiscrimination.”SocialProblems28(2):113–30.
39Catanzarite,Lisa.2003.“Race‐GenderCompositionandOccupationalPayDegradation.”SocialProblems50(1):14–37.40Cohen,PhilipN.andMattL.Huffman.2003.“OccupationalSegregationandtheDevaluationofWomen’sWorkacrossU.S.LaborMarkets.”SocialForces81(3):881–908.
41Huffman,MattL.andPhilipN.Cohen.2004.“RacialWageInequality:JobSegregationandDevaluationacrossU.S.LaborMarkets.”AmericanJournalofSociology109(4):902–36.
42Travis,Jeremy,BruceWestern,andSteveRedburn.2014.TheGrowthofIncarcerationintheUnitedStates:ExploringCausesandConsequences.NationalResearchCouncil.WashingtonD.C.:DivisionofBehavioralandSocialSciencesandEducation.RetrievedJanuary6,2015(http://www.nap.edu/booksearch.php?booksearch=1&record_id=18613&term=Black&chapter=33‐69).
43Sakala,Leah.2014.BreakingDownMassIncarcerationinthe2010Census:State‐by‐StateIncarcerationRatesbyRace/Ethnicity.Northampton,MA:PrisonPolicyInitiative.RetrievedJuly26,2015(http://www.prisonpolicy.org/reports/rates.html).
44Pager,Devah.2003.“TheMarkofaCriminalRecord.”AmericanJournalofSociology108(5):937–75.
45Western,BruceandBeckyPettit.2010.“Incarceration&SocialInequality.”Daedalus139(3):8–19.
46Wilson,GeorgeandDebraBranchMcBrier.2005.“RaceandLossofPrivilege:AfricanAmerican/WhiteDifferencesintheDeterminantsofJobLayoffsFromUpper‐TierOccupations.”SociologicalForum20(2):301–21.47Roscigno,VincentJ.,LisetteM.Garcia,andDonnaBobbitt‐Zeher.“SocialClosureandProcessesofRace/SexEmploymentDiscrimination.”TheAnnalsoftheAmericanAcademyofPoliticalandSocialScience609(1):16‐48.
48Roscigno,VincentJ.LisaM.Williams,andReginaldA.Byron.2012.“WorkplaceRacialDiscriminationandMiddleClassVulnerability.”AmericanBehavioralScientist56(5):696‐710.
49Smith,RyanA.2002.“Race,Gender,andAuthorityintheWorkplace:TheoryandResearch.”AnnualReviewofSociology28:509–42.
50Wilson,George.1997.“PathwaystoPower:RacialDifferencesintheDeterminantsofJobAuthority.”SocialProblems44(1):38–54.
![Page 51: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/51.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 3, PAGE 16
51Hout,MichaelandHarveyRosen.2000.“Self‐Employment,FamilyBackground,andRace.”JournalofHumanResources35(4):670–92.52Fairlie,RobertW.andAliciaM.Robb.2007.“WhyAreBlack‐OwnedBusinessesLessSuccessfulthanWhite‐OwnedBusinesses?TheRoleofFamilies,Inheritances,andBusinessHumanCapital.”JournalofLaborEconomics25(2):289–323.53Robb,AliciaandRobertFairlie.2007.“AccesstoFinancialCapitalamongU.S.Businesses:TheCaseofAfricanAmericanFirms.”TheAnnalsoftheAmericanAcademyofPoliticalandSocialScience613(1):47–72.
54Fairlie,RobertW.andHarryA.Krashinsky.2012.“LiquidityConstraints,HouseholdWealth,andEntrepreneurshipRevisited.”ReviewofIncome&Wealth58(2):279–306.55Bahn,Kate,ReginaWillensky,andAnnieMcgrew.2016.AProgressiveAgendaforInclusiveandDiverseEntrepreneurship.WashingtonD.C.:CenterforAmericanProgress.RetrievedDecember1,2016(https://www.americanprogress.org/issues/economy/reports/2016/10/13/146019/a‐progressive‐agenda‐for‐inclusive‐and‐diverse‐entrepreneurship/).
56Cha,YoungjooandKimA.Weeden.2014.“OverworkandtheSlowConvergenceintheGenderGapinWages.”AmericanSociologicalReview79(3):457–84.
57McCall,Leslie.2001.“SourcesofRacialWageInequalityinMetropolitanLaborMarkets:Racial,Ethnic,andGenderDifferences.”AmericanSociologicalReview66(4):520–41.
58Tomaskovic‐Devey,Donald.1993b.“TheGenderandRaceCompositionofJobsandtheMale/Female,White/BlackPayGaps.”SocialForces72(1):45–76.
59EconomicPolicyInstitute.2012a.AfricanAmericans.WashingtonD.C.:EconomicPolicyInstitute.RetrievedJanuary20,2015(http://stateofworkingamerica.org/files/book/factsheets/african‐americans.pdf).
60EconomicPolicyInstitute.2012b.Latinos.WashingtonD.C.:EconomicPolicyInstitute.RetrievedJanuary20,2015(http://www.stateofworkingamerica.org/fact‐sheets/latinos/).
61EconomicPolicyInstitute.2012c.Women.WashingtonD.C.:EconomicPolicyInstitute.RetrievedJanuary20,2015(http://www.stateofworkingamerica.org/fact‐sheets/women/).
62Shapiro,Thomas,TatjanaMeschede,andSamOsoro.2013.TheRootsoftheWideningRacialWealthGap:ExplainingtheBlack‐WhiteEconomicDivide.Waltham,MA:InstituteonAssetsandSocialPolicy.RetrievedJanuary2,2015(http://iasp.brandeis.edu/pdfs/Author/shapiro‐thomas‐m/racialwealthgapbrief.pdf).63Sullivan,Laura,TatjanaMeschede,LarsDietrich,ThomasShapiro,AmyTraub,CatherineRuetschlin,andTamaraDraut.2015.TheRacialWealthGap:WhyPolicyMatters.NewYork:Demos.RetrievedAugust28,2015(http://www.demos.org/sites/default/files/publications/RacialWealthGap_1.pdf)64KaiserHealthFoundation.2015.“PovertybyRace/Ethnicity.”RetrievedMay10,2016(http://kff.org/other/state‐indicator/poverty‐rate‐by‐raceethnicity/).
65Chang,MarikoLin.2010.Shortchanged:WhyWomenHaveLessWealthandWhatCanBeDoneAboutIt.Oxford:OxfordUniversityPress.
66Berger,AllenN.andGregoryF.Udell.1998.“TheEconomicsofSmallBusinessFinance:TheRolesofPrivateEquityandDebtMarketsintheFinancialGrowthCycle.”JournalofBanking&Finance22(6–8):613–73.
67Fairlie,RobertW.andHarryA.Krashinsky.2012.“LiquidityConstraints,HouseholdWealth,andEntrepreneurshipRevisited.”ReviewofIncome&Wealth58(2):279–306.
68U.S.CensusBureau.2013a.“AmericanCommunitySurvey20131YearEstimates.”RetrievedJanuary20,2015(http://factfinder.census.gov/faces/nav/jsf/pages/searchresults.xhtml?refresh=t).
69Turner,MargeryAusten,RobSantos,andDianeK.Levy,DougWissoker,ClaudiaAranda,andRobPitingolo.2013.HousingDiscriminationAgainstRacialandEthnicMinorities2012.Washington,D.C.:U.S.DepartmentofHousingandUrbanDevelopment.RetrievedJanuary2,2015(http://www.huduser.org/portal/publications/fairhsg/hsg_discrimination_2012.html).70Roscigno,VincentJ.,DianaL.Karafin,andGriffTester.2009.“TheComplexitiesandProcessesofRacialHousingDiscrimination.”SocialProblems56(1):49‐69.71Kochhar,RakeshandRichardFry.2014.“WealthInequalityHasWidenedalongRacial,EthnicLinessinceEndofGreatRecession.”PewResearchCenter.RetrievedDecember29,2014(http://www.pewresearch.org/fact‐tank/2014/12/12/racial‐wealth‐gaps‐great‐recession/).
72Burd‐Sharps,SarahandRebeccaRasch.2015.ImpactoftheUSHousingCrisisontheRacialWealthGapAcrossGenerations.Brooklyn,NY:SocialScienceResearchCouncil.RetrievedJune23,2015.(http://www.ssrc.org/publications/view/129CDF74‐1F11‐E511‐940A‐005056AB4B80/).
![Page 52: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/52.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 3, PAGE 17
73Charles,CamilleZubrinsky.2003.“TheDynamicsofRacialResidentialSegregation.”AnnualReviewofSociology29:167–207.
74Shapiro,Thomas,TatjanaMeschede,andSamOsoro.2013.TheRootsoftheWideningRacialWealthGap:ExplainingtheBlack‐WhiteEconomicDivide.Waltham,MA:InstituteonAssetsandSocialPolicy.RetrievedJanuary2,2015(http://iasp.brandeis.edu/pdfs/Author/shapiro‐thomas‐m/racialwealthgapbrief.pdf).
75Blanchard,Lloyd,BoZhao,andJohnYinger.2008.“DoLendersDiscriminateAgainstMinorityandWomanEntrepreneurs?”JournalofUrbanEconomics63(2):467–97.
76Cavalluzzo,KenS.,LindaC.Cavalluzzo,andJohnD.Wolken.2002.“Competition,SmallBusinessFinancing,andDiscrimination:EvidencefromaNewSurvey.”TheJournalofBusiness75(4):641–79.
77Cavalluzzo,KenandJohnWolken.2005.“SmallBusinessLoanTurndowns,PersonalWealth,andDiscrimination.”TheJournalofBusiness78(6):2153–78.
78GruensteinBocian,Debbie,WeiLi,CarolinaReid,andRobertG.Quercia.2011.LostGround,2011:DisparitiesinMortgageLendingandForeclosures.WashingtonD.C.:CenterforResponsibleLending.RetrievedJanuary21,2015(https://www.responsiblelending.org/mortgage‐lending/research‐analysis/Lost‐Ground‐2011.pdf).
79Mijid,NaranchimegandAlexandraBernasek.2013.“GenderandtheCreditRationingofSmallBusinesses.”TheSocialScienceJournal50(1):55–65.
80Ross,StephenL.andJohnYinger.2002.TheColorofCredit:MortgageDiscrimination,ResearchMethodology,andFair‐LendingEnforcement.Cambridge,MA:MITPress.
81Ross,StephenL.,MargeryAustinTurner,ErinGodfrey,andRobinR.Smith.2008.“MortgageLendinginChicagoandLosAngeles:APairedTestingStudyofthePre‐ApplicationProcess.”JournalofUrbanEconomics63(3):902–19.
82Dymski,Gary,JesusHernandez,andLisaMohanty.2013.“Race,Gender,Power,andtheUSSubprimeMortgageandForeclosureCrisis:AMesoAnalysis.”FeministEconomics19(3):124–51.
83Fishbein,AllenJ.andPatrickWoodall.2006.WomenarePrimeTargetsSubprime:WomenAreDisproportionatelyRepresentedinHigh‐CostMortgageMarket.WashingtonD.C.:ConsumerFederationofAmerica.RetrievedJanuary5,2015(http://policylinkcontent.s3.amazonaws.com/WomenPrimeTargetsSubprimeLending_CFA_0.pdf).
84Williams,Richard,ReynoldNesiba,andEileenDiazMcConnell.2005.“TheChangingFaceofInequalityinHomeMortgageLending.”SocialProblems52(2):181–208.
85Wyly,ElvinandC.S.Ponder.2011.“Gender,Age,andRaceinSubprimeAmerica.”HousingPolicyDebate21(4):529–64.
86Baker,AmyCastro.2011.TearingDowntheWealthofWomen.NewYork:Women’sMediaCenter.RetrievedJanuary5,2015(http://www.womensmediacenter.com/feature/entry/tearing‐down‐the‐wealth‐of‐women).
87Baker,AmyCastro.2014.“ErodingtheWealthofWomen:GenderandtheSubprimeForeclosureCrisis.”SocialServiceReview88(1):59–91.
88Rugh,JacobS.andDouglasS.Massey.2010.“RacialSegregationandtheAmericanForeclosureCrisis.”AmericanSociologicalReview75(5):629–51.
89Burd‐Sharps,SarahandRebeccaRasch.2015.ImpactoftheUSHousingCrisisontheRacialWealthGapAcrossGenerations.Brooklyn,NY:SocialScienceResearchCouncil.RetrievedJune23,2015.(http://www.ssrc.org/publications/view/129CDF74‐1F11‐E511‐940A‐005056AB4B80/).
90Bone,SterlingA.,GlennL.Christensen,andJeromeD.Williams.2014.“Rejected,Shackled,andAlone:TheImpactofSystematicRestrictedChoiceonMinorityConsumers’ConstructionofSelf.”JournalofConsumerResearch41(2):451‐474.91Blanchard,Lloyd,BoZhao,andJohnYinger.2008.“DoLendersDiscriminateAgainstMinorityandWomanEntrepreneurs?”JournalofUrbanEconomics63(2):467–97.
92Blanchflower,DavidG.,PhillipB.Levine,andDavidJ.Zimmerman.2003.“DiscriminationintheSmallBusinessCreditMarket.”TheReviewofEconomicsandStatistics85(4):930–43.
93Bates,TimothyandAliciaRobb.2016.“ImpactsofOwnerRaceandGeographicContextonAccesstoSmallBusinessFinancing.”EconomicDevelopmentQuarterly30(2):159‐170.94Mijid,NaranchimegandAlexandraBernasek.2013.“GenderandtheCreditRationingofSmallBusinesses.”TheSocialScienceJournal50(1):55–65.95Treichel,MonicaZimmermanandJonathanA.Scott.2006.“Women‐OwnedBusinessesandAccesstoBankCredit:EvidencefromThreeSurveysSince1987.”VentureCapital8(1):51–67.
96Coleman,SusanandAliciaRobb.2009.“AComparisonofNewFirmFinancingbyGender:EvidencefromtheKauffmanFirmSurveyData.”SmallBusinessEconomics33(4):397–411.
![Page 53: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/53.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 3, PAGE 18
97Robb,AliciaandRobertFairlie.2007.“AccesstoFinancialCapitalamongU.S.Businesses:TheCaseofAfricanAmericanFirms.”TheAnnalsoftheAmericanAcademyofPoliticalandSocialScience613(1):47–72.
98Robb,Alicia,SusanColeman,andDaneStangler.2014.SourcesofEconomicHope:Women’sEntrepreneurship.KansasCity,KS:EwingMarionKauffmanFoundation.RetrievedNovember3,2016(http://www.kauffman.org/what‐we‐do/research/2014/11/sources‐of‐economic‐hope‐womens‐entrepreneurship).
99Robb,Alicia.2013.AccesstoCapitalamongYoungFirms,Minority‐ownedFirms,Woman‐ownedFirms,andHigh‐techFirms.WashingtonD.C.:SmallBusinessAdministrationOfficeofAdvocacy.RetrievedJanuary5,2015(https://www.sba.gov/sites/default/files/files/rs403tot(2).pdf).
100PublicInformationOffice.2015.NumberofMinority‐andWoman‐OwnedFirmsEachIncreasesbyMoreThan2MillionNationally.WashingtonD.C.:UnitedStatesCensusBureau.RetrievedNovember11,2016(http://www.census.gov/newsroom/press‐releases/2015/cb15‐209.html).
101Fairlie,RobertW.andAliciaM.Robb.2009b.“GenderDifferencesinBusinessPerformance:EvidencefromtheCharacteristicsofBusinessOwnersSurvey.”SmallBusinessEconomics33(4):375–95.
102Fairlie,RobertW.2006.“EntrepreneurshipamongDisadvantagedGroups:Women,Minorities,andtheLessEducated.”Pp.437–75inTheLifeCycleofEntrepreneurialVentures,editedbySimonParker.SpringerScience&BusinessMedia.
103Fairlie,RobertW.andAliciaM.Robb.2008.RaceandEntrepreneurialSuccess:Black‐,Asian‐,andWhite‐OwnedBusinessesintheUnitedStates.Cambridge,Mass.:MITPress.
104Bahn,Kate,ReginaWillensky,andAnnieMcgrew.2016.AProgressiveAgendaforInclusiveandDiverseEntrepreneurship.WashingtonD.C.:CenterforAmericanProgress.RetrievedDecember1,2016(https://www.americanprogress.org/issues/economy/reports/2016/10/13/146019/a‐progressive‐agenda‐for‐inclusive‐and‐diverse‐entrepreneurship/).105Budig,MichelleJ.2006b.“IntersectionsontheRoadtoSelf‐Employment:Gender,FamilyandOccupationalClass.”SocialForces84(4):2223–39.
106Lofstrom,MagnusandTimothyBates.2013.“AfricanAmericans’PursuitofSelf‐Employment.”SmallBusinessEconomics40(1):73–86.
107Bahn,Kate,ReginaWillensky,andAnnieMcgrew.2016.AProgressiveAgendaforInclusiveandDiverseEntrepreneurship.WashingtonD.C.:CenterforAmericanProgress.RetrievedDecember1,2016(https://www.americanprogress.org/issues/economy/reports/2016/10/13/146019/a‐progressive‐agenda‐for‐inclusive‐and‐diverse‐entrepreneurship/).108Fairlie,RobertW.andAliciaM.Robb.2008.RaceandEntrepreneurialSuccess:Black‐,Asian‐,andWhite‐OwnedBusinessesintheUnitedStates.Cambridge,Mass.:MITPress.
109Coleman,SusanandAliciaRobb.2009.“AComparisonofNewFirmFinancingbyGender:EvidencefromtheKauffmanFirmSurveyData.”SmallBusinessEconomics33(4):397–411.
110Robb,AliciaM.andJohnWatson.2012.“GenderDifferencesinFirmPerformance:EvidencefromNewVenturesintheUnitedStates.”JournalofBusinessVenturing27(5):544–58.
![Page 54: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/54.jpg)
CHAPTER 4.
Collection and Analysis of Contract Data
![Page 55: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/55.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 4, PAGE 1
CHAPTER 4. Collection and Analysis of Contract Data
Chapter4providesanoverviewofthepoliciesthattheCityandCountyofDenver(theCity)usestoawardcontractsandprocurements;thecontractsandprocurementsthatthestudyteamanalyzedaspartofthedisparitystudy;andtheprocessthatthestudyteamusedtocollectrelevantprimecontractandsubcontractdataforthedisparitystudy.Chapter4isorganizedintosevenparts:
A. Overviewofcontractingandprocurementpolicies;
B. Collectionandanalysisofcontractandprocurementdata;
C. Collectionofvendordata;
D. Relevantgeographicmarketarea;
E. Relevanttypesofwork;
F. Collectionofbidandproposaldata;and
G. Agencyreviewprocess.
A. Overview of Contracting and Procurement Policies
TheCityandCountyofDenver’sDivisionofSmallBusinessOpportunity(DSBO)providesguidancetoalldepartmentsandcontractingofficerstoensureconsistencyinprocurementproceduresandcompliancewithCitycoderegardingcontractingandprocurement.TheCityhasdevelopeddetailedguidelinesforprocuringconstructionanddesignservicesaswellasgoodsandservices.ThoseguidelineswerelastupdatedinMay2011andarefoundinExecutiveOrder8,MemorandumA.
SeveraldepartmentswithintheCityawardcontractswithinconstruction;professionalservices;andgoodsandservices.However,themajorityofthosecontractsareprocuredthroughtheDepartmentofPublicWorks,DenverInternationalAirport(DEN),andthePurchasingDepartment.Contractsthatthosethreedepartmentsawardedduringthestudyperiodaccountedfor88percentofthecontractsthatthestudyteamanalyzedaspartofthedisparitystudy.Thecontractingpoliciesofthosethreedepartmentsaredescribedbelow.
Public Works. CityCouncilandtheMayor’sOfficeprovideoversightonallcontractsandprocurementsthatPublicWorksawards.Forallconstructionanddesignservicescontracts,PublicWorksadvertisessolicitationsintheDailyJournal;onWork4Denver,whichisthePublicWorksContractAdministrationwebpage;andthroughQwestCDN,whichisanonlinebidplatform.VendorsmustdownloadsolicitationsthroughQwestCDNandarechargedafeetodoso.Solicitationsincludeadescriptionoftherequiredservices,evaluationcriteria,submissioninformation,andcontactinformationforaCityrepresentative.
Construction.PublicWorksawardsconstructionsolicitationsthroughhardbid,constructionmanager/generalcontractor,design/build,ormasteron‐call/integratedcontractingprocesses,
![Page 56: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/56.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 4, PAGE 2
althoughthemajorityofPublicWorkscontractsareawardedthroughahardbidprocess(i.e.,tothelowestresponsiveandresponsiblebidder).Aspartofahardbidprocess,thecontractadministratorandprojectmanagerareresponsibleforpreparingeachconstructionsolicitationandadvertisingitthroughtheappropriatechannels.Theybegineachsolicitationbyconductingapre‐bidconferencetobringtogetherpotentialbiddersandsubcontractorstolearnmoreabouttheopportunity.Allqualifiedbiddersarethenrequiredtosubmitasealedbidbytheduedatetobeconsideredforthecontract.PublicworkscollectsallbidsandsendsthemtotheprojectmanagerandDSBO.Thedepartmentthenawardsthecontracttothelowestresponsiveandresponsiblebidder.
Professional services.Professionalservicessolicitationsareawardedthroughqualifications‐basedselectionprocesses(i.e.,factorsotherthancostaretakenintoconsideration).Aqualifications‐basedselectionprocessallowsPublicWorkstonegotiateacontractforprofessionalservicesatafairandreasonablepricewiththebestqualifiedfirm.Therearetwotypesofqualifications‐basedselectionprocessesthatPublicWorksuses:
PublicWorkssometimesusesadirectselectionprocessbywhichthedepartmentselectsanawardeefromwrittenproposalsanddoesnotrequireinterviews;or
PublicWorksusesamulti‐stepselectionprocessbywhichinterestedconsultantssubmitproposals,andthenthedepartmentdevelopsashortlistofthethreemostqualifiedfirmsandinterviewsthembeforeselectinganawardee.
RegardlessofwhetherPublicWorksusesadirectselectionprocessoramulti‐stepselectionprocess,thecontractadministratorisresponsibleforpreparingeachsolicitationandadvertisingitthroughtheappropriatechannels.PublicWorkscollectsallresponsesandsendsthemtotheprojectmanagerandDSBO.Aselectioncommitteeconvenestorevieweachproposalinordertoensureafairandopenselectionprocess.Thecommitteedevelopsevaluationcriteriaandscoreseachproposalbasedonthosecriteria.Oncethecommitteeselectsaconsultant,theprojectmanagernegotiatesfairandreasonablecompensationforthedesiredservices.
DEN.CityCouncilandtheMayor’sOfficealsoprovideoversightonallcontractsandprocurementsthatDENawards.TheCityhassetthefollowingthresholdsforwhenCityCouncilapprovalisrequiredforDENcontractsandprocurements:
Constructioncontractsworth$5millionormore;
Professionalservicescontractsworth$500,000ormore;and
Allrevenueagreements,grants,landagreements.
DENcurrentlyawardsthreetypesofcontractsandprocurements:expenditurecontracts,whichincludebothlargeconstructionandprofessionalservicescontracts;informalprocurements,whichincludesmallprofessionalservicescontracts;andrevenuecontracts.Revenuecontractswerenotincludedaspartofthedisparitystudyandsoarenotdiscussedfurther.
Expenditure contracts.Expenditurecontractsincludelargeconstructionandprofessionalservicecontractsandareawardedusingformalbidprocesses.Formalbidprocessesincludedifferentprocurementvehiclessuchasrequestsforproposals(RFPs),requestsforinformation
![Page 57: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/57.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 4, PAGE 3
(RFIs),invitationsforbids(IFBs),andrequestsforquotes(RFQs),whichareallreferredtohereinasRFxs.PriortothereleaseofanRFx,DENhostsoutreachsessionstoinformthecommunityoftheupcomingopportunity.Fourtosixweekspriortotheduedate,theRFxisadvertisedonDEN’swebsite.Ifnecessary,apre‐proposalconferenceisheldtwoweeksafterRFxadvertisingtoexplainprocurementrequirementsandanswerpotentialproposers’questions.Inaddition,thereisaquestion‐and‐answerperiodtoallowinterestedbusinessestosubmitquestionspertainingtotheRFx.RFxresponsescanbesubmittedinpersontotheAirportOfficeBuilding,bymailtotheDENCopyCenter,orthroughDEN’selectronicportal.
Toensureafairandopenprocess,theContractAdministratorfortheRFxwillconvenecommunitymembersandairlinememberstoserveonanevaluationpanel.ThelistofpanelmembersissubmittedtoDEN’sChiefExecutiveOfficer(CEO)forapproval.Panelmembersthenparticipateinatrainingtoprovideguidanceontheirrolesandtheevaluationprocess.Theevaluationpanelreviewsandscoreseachproposalbasedonthecriteriasetbythecontractadministrator.Insomeinstances,theevaluationpanelwillinterviewrespondersandscoretheirinterviewsaspartoftheevaluationprocess.Thecontractadministratorwillcomputescoresandconductameetingwiththeprojectmanager,sponsoringSeniorVicePresident,andotherstakeholders.ThegroupwilldraftaSelectionRecommendationMemo,whichitthensubmitstotheCEOforapproval.Thesuccessfulrespondentwillthenbenotifiedofcontractaward.
Informal procurements.DENawardsprofessionalservicescontractsworthlessthan$100,000usinginformationprocesses.Aspartoftheprocess,thecontractadministratorcollectsatleastthreebidsfromvendorswhoareknowntoperformthedesiredwork.Allbidsarereviewedandevaluatedbytheprojectmanagementteam,anditthenselectsthebidfromthemostqualifiedvendor.
Purchasing. TheCity’sPurchasingDivisionisresponsibleforthepurchasesofgoodsandservices.PurchasingfollowstheprocurementpoliciesoutlinedintheCharter,DenverRevisedMunicipalCode(D.R.M.C.),ExecutiveOrders,andtheFiscalAccountabilityRules.Goodsandgeneralservicepurchasescanbecategorizedintothreecategories:
Procurementsworth$10,000orless(openmarket);
Procurementsworthmorethan$10,000butlessthan$50,000(informalsolicitations);and
Procurementsworth$50,000ormore(formalsolicitations).
Open market. Forgoodsandservicesworth$10,000orless,aCitybuyerdetermineswhetherasolicitationisnecessary.Openmarketproceduresdonotrequireformaladvertisingnoraretheyrequiredtobeopentothepublic.Inmanycases,openmarketprocurementsdonotrequireproofofinsuranceorbonding.
Informal solicitations.Forgoodsandservicesworthmorethan$10,000butlessthan$50,000,Purchasingusesaninformalsolicitationprocess.ACitybuyercansolicitvendorsforbidsviae‐mail,fax,mail,ortelephone.Informalsolicitationsarenotrequiredtobeadvertisednoraretheyopentothepublic.Inmanycases,informalsolicitationsdonotrequireproofofinsuranceorbonding.
![Page 58: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/58.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 4, PAGE 4
Formal solicitations.Forgoodsandservicesworth$50,000ormore,formalsolicitationsarerequired.Aformalsolicitationincludesasealedproposal,aformaladvertisement,and,inmanycases,proofofinsuranceandbonding.PurchasingadvertisesallformalsolicitationsintheOfficeCityNoticeorotherappropriatemedia.InformationregardingformalsolicitationscanbefoundonBidNet.Alternatively,vendorscanobtainformalsolicitationsfromthePurchasingofficeorcanrequestthatsolicitationsbemailedtothem.Purchasingawardsformalsolicitationstothelowestresponsive,responsible,andqualifiedbidder.
Other procurements.ThePurchasingdepartmentprocuresseveralothertypesofgoodsandservicesusingoneofthefollowingprocesses.
Individualpurchaseorder.IndividualpurchaseorderscanberequestedbyaCitydepartmentforanykindofsolicitation.IndividualpurchaseordersaretheprimarywayinwhichPurchasingprocuresgoodsandservicesonbehalfoftheCity.
Contracts.Purchasingusescontractsfortheprocurementofeitherone‐timeorrecurringservicesthatCitydepartmentsmightrequest.WhenPurchasingcreatesacontract,itisthenheldandmanagedbytheCitydepartmentthatrequestedtheassociatedservices.
Masterpurchaseorder.Purchasingusesmasterpurchaseorderstocontractwithvendorsforgoodsorservicesinconnectionwithanothergoodthathasalreadybeenpurchases(e.g.,installationofthealready‐purchasedgood).Masterpurchaseordersareconsideredopen‐endedandthusallowtheCitytopurchasefromasuccessfulvendoronanas‐neededbasisduringthecontract’seffectivedates.Masterpurchaseordersareonlyusedforpurchasesworth$50,000ormoreusingaformalsolicitationprocess.
Blanketpurchaseorder.PurchasingusesblanketpurchaseordersthatCitydepartmentscanuseonanas‐neededbasisforproductsthatarepartofaparticularfamilyofproducts.Aspartofthatprocess,Purchasingrequestsafirmpricefromavendorandthenissuesablanketpurchaseordercoveringtheamount,althoughthetotalamountmaynotbespent.
Procurementcards(p‐cards).SomeCitypersonnelhavep‐cards,whichareusedtopurchasecertaingoodsandservicesworthlessthan$2,000andthathavebeenidentifiedandapprovedbytheManagerofGeneralServices.Thosepurchasesaretypicallyonanon‐recurringbasisandusuallycannotbecoveredbyanexistingmasterpurchaseorder,blanketpurchaseorder,orcontract.1P‐cardpurchaseswerenotincludedaspartofdisparitystudyanalyses.
Cooperativepurchasing.UndertheCodeofOrdinanceSection20‐64.5,Purchasingcanauthorizetheprocurementofagoodorgeneralservicethatispartofanintergovernmentalagreement,shouldthatpurchasebeinthebestinterestoftheCity.
1Undercertaincircumstances,p‐cardscanbecomepartofamasterpurchaseorderthatcoversgoodsthattheCitydepartmentispurchasing.
![Page 59: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/59.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 4, PAGE 5
B. Collection and Analysis of Contract Data and Procurement Data
BBCResearch&Consulting(BBC)collectedcontractingandvendordatafromtheCity’sAlfresco,B2Gnow,andPeopleSoftdatasystemstoserveasthebasisofkeydisparitystudyanalyses,includingtheutilization,availability,anddisparityanalyses.ThestudyteamcollectedthemostcomprehensivedatathatwasavailableonprimecontractsandsubcontractsthattheCityawardedbetweenJanuary1,2012andDecember31,2016.BBCsoughtdatathatincludedinformationaboutprimecontractorsandsubcontractors,regardlessoftherace/ethnicityandgenderoftheirownersortheirstatusesascertifiedminority‐ownedbusinessenterprises(MBEs)orwoman‐ownedbusinessenterprises(WBEs).Thestudyteamcollecteddataonconstruction;professionalservices;andgoodsandservicesprimecontractsandsubcontractsthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiod.Thestudyteam’sanalysesincludedallcontractsandpaymentsworth$5,000ormore.2
Prime contract data collection.TheCityprovidedthestudyteamwithelectronicdataonconstruction;professionalservices;andgoodsandservicesprimecontractsthattheagencyawardedduringthestudyperiod.Asavailable,BBCcollectedthefollowinginformationabouteachrelevantprimecontract:
Contractorpurchaseordernumber;
Descriptionofwork;
Awarddate;
Awardamount(includingchangeordersandamendments);
Amountpaid‐to‐date;
WhetherMWBEorDisadvantagedBusinessEnterprisecontractgoalswereused;
Fundingsource(federalorlocalfunding);
Primecontractorname;and
Primecontractoridentificationnumber,suchasavendornumber.
TheCityalsoprovidedthestudyteamwithinformationaboutpaymentsthattheCitymadeduringthestudyperiodoncontractsthatwereawardedusingcontractgoals(i.e.,goalscontracts)andonallprocurements.TheCityadvisedthestudyteamonhowtointerprettheprovideddata,includinghowtoidentifyuniquebidopportunitiesandhowtoaggregaterelatedpaymentamounts.Whenpossible,thestudyteamaggregatedindividualpaymentsintolarger,relatedpurchases.Ininstanceswherepaymentinformationcouldnotbeaggregated,thestudyteamtreatedpaymentrecordsasindividualpurchases.
Subcontract data collection.TheCityprovidedthestudyteamwithelectronicdataonsubcontractsrelatedtogoalscontractsthatitawardedduringthestudyperiod.Togather
2Thestudyteamchose$5,000asitsanalysisthresholdbecausemanypurchasesworthlessthan$5,000representedarelativelysmallamountofthecontractingdollarsthattheCityspentduringthestudyperiod.Purchasesworth$5,000ormoreaccountedformorethan99percentofallCitycontractingdollarsthattheCityspentduringthestudyperiod.
![Page 60: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/60.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 4, PAGE 6
comprehensivesubcontractdataoncontractsthattheCityawardedwithouttheuseofcontractgoals(i.e.,no‐goalscontracts),thestudyteamconductedsurveyswithprimecontractorstocollectinformationonthesubcontractsthatwereassociatedwiththecontractsonwhichtheyworkedduringthestudyperiod.BBCsentoutsurveystorequestsubcontractdataon325no‐goalscontractsthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiod.Afterthefirstroundofsurveys,BBCworkedwiththeCitytocontacttheremainingunresponsiveprimecontractorswiththehighestvaluedcontracts.BBCcollectedthefollowinginformationabouteachrelevantsubcontractaspartofthesurveyprocess:
Associatedprimecontractnumber;
Amountawardedonthesubcontract;
Amountpaidonthesubcontract;
Descriptionofwork;
Subcontractorname;and
Subcontractorcontactinformation.
Thosecontractsaccountedforapproximately$858millioncontractdollarsduringthestudyperiod.Throughthesurveyeffort,BBCcollectedsubcontractdataassociatedwithmorethan$595million,or69percent,ofthosecontractdollars.
Contracts included in study analyses. Thestudyteamcollectedinformationon18,799relevantprimecontractelementsand2,991associatedsubcontractsthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiodintheareasofconstruction;professionalservices;andgoodsandservices.Thosecontractsaccountedforapproximately$3.5billionofcontractingdollarsawardedbytheCityduringthestudyperiod.Figure4‐1presentsdollarsbyrelevantcontractingareafortheprimecontractandsubcontractelementsthatthestudyteamincludedinitsanalyses.ThestudyteamcombineditsanalysesforgoodsandservicescontractsbecausetheCityusessimilarprocurementprocessestoawardthosecontracts.
Figure 4‐1. Number of City contracts included in the study
Note:
Numbers rounded to nearest dollar and thus may not sum exactly to totals.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting from City contract and payment data.
C. Collection of Vendor Data
TheCitymaintainsacomprehensivelistofallbusinessesthathavedonebusinessorexpressedinterestindoingbusinesswiththeCity.ThestudyteamcompiledvendordatathattheCityAttorney’sOfficeprovided.ThestudyteamcompiledthefollowinginformationonbusinessesthatparticipatedinrelevantCitycontractsduringthestudyperiod:
Businessname;
Contract Type
Construction 9,218 $2,233,136
Construction‐related professional services 4,480 $520,234
Goods and general services 8,092 $744,182
Total 21,790 $3,497,551
Number of
Contract
Elements
Dollars
(in thousands)
![Page 61: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/61.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 4, PAGE 7
Physicaladdresses,emailaddresses,andphonenumbers;
Ownershipstatus(i.e.,whethereachbusinesswasminority‐ownedorwoman‐owned);
Ethnicityofownership(ifminority‐owned);
MWBEcertificationstatus;
Primarylinesofwork;
Businesssize;and
Yearofestablishment.
BBCreliedonavarietyofsourcesforthatinformation,including:
Citycontractandvendordata;
Citycertifiedfirmdirectory;
StateofColoradoUnifiedCertificationProgramdirectory;
SmallBusinessAdministrationcertificationandownershiplists,including8(a)HUBZoneandself‐certificationlists;
Dun&Bradstreet(D&B)businesslistingsandotherbusinessinformationsources;
Telephonesurveysthatthestudyteamconductedwithbusinessownersandmanagersaspartoftheutilizationandavailabilityanalyses;and
Businesswebsites.
D. Relevant Geographic Market Area
ThestudyteamusedtheCity’scontractingandvendordatatohelpdeterminetherelevantgeographicmarketarea—thegeographicalareainwhichtheagencyspendsthemajorityofitscontractingdollars—forthestudy.Thestudyteam’sanalysisshowedthat87percentofrelevantcontractingdollarsduringthestudyperiodwenttobusinesseswithlocationsintheseven‐countyDenverMetropolitanStatisticalArea(MSA),indicatingthattheDenverMSAshouldbeconsideredtherelevantgeographicmarketareaforthestudy.3BBC’sanalysesfocusedontheDenverMSA.
E. Relevant Types of Work
Foreachprimecontractandsubcontract,thestudyteamdeterminedthesubindustrythatbestcharacterizedthebusiness’sprimarylineofwork(e.g.,heavyconstruction).BBCidentifiedsubindustriesbasedonCitycontractdata;telephonesurveysthatBBCconductedwithprimecontractorsandsubcontractors;businesscertificationlists;D&Bbusinesslistings;andothersources.BBCdevelopedsubindustriesbasedinparton8‐digitD&Bindustryclassificationcodes.Figure4‐2presentsthedollarsthatthestudyteamexaminedinthevariousconstruction;professionalservices;andgoodsandservicessubindustriesthatBBCincludedinitsanalyses.
3TheDenverMSAincludesAdams,Arapahoe,Boulder,Broomfield,Denver,Douglas,andJeffersoncountiesinColorado.
![Page 62: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/62.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 4, PAGE 8
Figure 4‐2. City contract dollars by subindustry
Note:
Numbers rounded to nearest dollar and thus may not sum exactly to totals.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting from City contract data.
Industry
Construction
Building construction $541,639
Parking services $333,582
Highway and street construction $314,758
Bridge construction $141,087
Heavy construction $96,123
Wrecking, demolition, excavation, drilling $90,589
Electrical work $80,738
Concrete and related products $67,298
Plumbing and HVAC $56,885
Heavy construction equipment $54,581
Other construction services $51,594
Elevators and conveyors $46,347
Landscape services $39,753
Water, sewer, and utility lines $35,331
Other construction materials $34,821
Electrical equipment and supplies $32,671
Industrial equipment and machinery $23,734
Environmental cleaning $22,289
Trucking, hauling and storage $20,412
Traffic flagging and safety $19,434
Lawn, garden, and irrigation supplies $18,937
Landscape architecture $18,393
Fencing, guardrails and signs $17,057
Carpet and floors $15,663
Painting $14,757
Masonry, drywall and stonework $11,633
Roofing $10,814
Windows and doors $10,115
Structural metals $10,014
Street cleaning $2,088
Total construction $2,233,136
Professional services
Engineering $198,477
Business services and consulting $108,015
Architectural and design services $65,291
Advertising, marketing and public relations $47,715
Construction management $31,217
Environmental services and transportation planning $25,342
Human resources and job training services $17,753
Finance and accounting $16,172
Testing services $5,683
Medical testing, laboratories, and pharmaceutical services $2,953
Surveying and mapmaking $1,617
Total other professional services $520,234
Total
(in Thousands)
![Page 63: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/63.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 4, PAGE 9
Figure 4‐2. City contract dollars by subindustry (continued)
Note:
Numbers rounded to nearest dollar and thus may not sum exactly to totals.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting from City contract data.
Thestudyteamcombinedrelatedsubindustriesthataccountedforrelativelysmallpercentagesoftotalcontractingdollarsintofour“other”subindustries:“otherconstructionservices,”“otherconstructionmaterials,”“otherservices,”and“othergoods.”Forexample,thecontractingdollarsthattheCityawardedtocontractorsfor“fireproofingbuildings”representedlessthan1percentofthetotalCitydollarsthatBBCexaminedinthestudy.BBCcombined“fireproofingbuildings”withotherconstructionservicessubindustriesthatalsoaccountedforrelativelysmallpercentagesoftotaldollars,andthatwererelativelydissimilartoothersubindustries,intothe“otherconstructionservices”subindustry.
TherewerealsocontractsthatwerecategorizedinvarioussubindustriesthatBBCdidnotincludeaspartofitsanalyses,becausetheyarenottypicallyanalyzedaspartofdisparitystudies.BBCdidnotincludecontractsinitsanalysesthat:
TheCityawardedtouniversities,governmentagencies,orothernonprofitorganizations($650millionofassociateddollars);
Wereclassifiedinsubindustriesthatreflectednationalmarkets(i.e.,subindustriesthataredominatedbylargenationalorinternationalbusinesses)orwereclassifiedinsubindustries
Industry
Goods and services
Computer and IT services $175,157
Cleaning and janitorial services $135,595
Automobiles $59,136
Communications equipment $47,173
Catering $43,652
Petroleum and petroleum products $41,692
Other services $40,031
Security guard services $39,497
Security systems $30,831
Vehicle parts and supplies $25,387
Other goods $18,124
Furniture $16,232
Food $15,425
Office equipment and supplies $14,996
Vehicle repair shops $11,754
Uniforms $9,889
Printing and copying $9,575
Towing services $5,101
Cleaning and janitorial supplies $4,249
Communication services $685
Total other services $744,182
GRAND TOTAL $3,497,551
Total
(in Thousands)
![Page 64: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/64.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 4, PAGE 10
forwhichtheCityawardedthemajorityofcontractingdollarstobusinesseslocatedoutsideoftheDenverMSA($290millionofassociateddollars);4
Wereclassifiedinsubindustrieswhichoftenincludepropertypurchases,leases,orotherpass‐throughdollars(e.g.,realestateorlegalservices;$882millionofassociateddollars);
Representedutilities,broadcastandcommunicationsservices,andotherheavily‐regulatedindustries($306millionofassociateddollars);or
WereclassifiedinsubindustriesthatarenottypicallyincludedindisparitystudiesandaccountforsmallproportionsoftheCity’scontractingdollars($65millionofassociateddollars).5
F. Collection of Bid and Proposal Data
BBCconductedacasestudyanalysisofbidsandproposalsforasampleofcontractsthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiod.TheCityprovideddocumentsrelatedtobid,proposal,andotherrelatedinformationtothestudyteamforthosecontracts.BBCsuccessfullycollectedandexaminedbidandproposalinformationfor51PublicWorkscontracts,84DENcontracts,and160goodsandservicescontracts.
G. Agency Review Process
TheCityreviewedBBC’scontractingandpaymentdataseveraltimesduringthestudyprocess.TheBBCstudyteammetwithCitystafftoreviewthedatacollectionprocess,informationthatthestudyteamgathered,andsummaryresults.Citystaffalsoreviewedcontractandvendorinformation.BBCincorporatedtheCity’sfeedbackinthefinalcontractandvendordatathatthestudyteamusedaspartofthedisparitystudy.
4Examplesofsuchindustriesincludebanking,insurance,transitbusesandlightrailvehicles,andsoftware.5Examplesofsuchindustriesincluderetailstores,farms,andmiscellaneousgoodspurchases.
![Page 65: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/65.jpg)
CHAPTER 5.
Availability Analysis
![Page 66: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/66.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 5, PAGE 1
CHAPTER 5. Availability Analysis
BBCResearch&Consulting(BBC)analyzedtheavailabilityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesthatareready,willing,andabletoperformonCityandCountyofDenver(City)construction;professionalservices;andgoodsandservicesprimecontractsandsubcontracts.1Chapter5describestheavailabilityanalysisinfiveparts:
A. Purposeoftheavailabilityanalysis;
B. Potentiallyavailablebusinesses;
C. Availabilitydatabase;
D. Availabilitycalculations;and
E. Availabilityresults.
AppendixEprovidessupportinginformationrelatedtotheavailabilityanalysis.
A. Purpose of the Availability Analysis
BBCexaminedtheavailabilityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesforCityprimecontractsandsubcontractstoinformitsimplementationoftheMinority‐andWomen‐ownedBusinessEnterprise,theEmergingBusinessEnterprise,theSmallBusinessEnterprise,andFederalDisadvantagedBusinessEnterprise(DBE)Program.Inaddition,BBCusedavailabilityanalysisresultsasinputsinthedisparityanalysis.Inthedisparityanalysis,BBCcomparedthepercentageofCitycontractdollarsthatwenttominority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesduringthestudyperiod(i.e.,participation,orutilization)tothepercentageofdollarsthatonemightexpectthosebusinessestoreceivebasedontheiravailabilityforspecifictypesandsizesofCityprimecontractsandsubcontracts.ThestudyperiodincludedcontractsthattheCityawardedbetweenJanuary1,2012andDecember31,2016.ComparisonsbetweenparticipationandavailabilityallowedBBCtodeterminewhetheranyminority‐orwoman‐ownedbusinessgroupswereunderutilizedduringthestudyperiodrelativetotheiravailabilityforCitywork(fordetails,seeChapter7).
B. Potentially Available Businesses
BBC’savailabilityanalysisfocusedonspecificareasofwork(i.e.,subindustries)relatedtotherelevanttypesofcontractsandprocurementsthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiod.BBCbegantheavailabilityanalysisbyidentifyingthespecificsubindustriesinwhichtheCityspendsthemajorityofitscontractingdollars(fordetails,seeChapter4)aswellasthe
1“Woman‐ownedbusinesses”referstonon‐Hispanicwhitewomanownedbusinesses.Informationandresultsforminoritywoman‐ownedbusinessesareincludedalongwiththeircorrespondingracial/ethnicgroups.
![Page 67: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/67.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 5, PAGE 2
geographicareasinwhichthemajorityofthebusinesseswithwhichtheCityspendsthosecontractingdollarsarelocated(i.e.,therelevantgeographicmarketarea).2
BBCthenconductedextensivesurveystodeveloparepresentative,unbiased,andstatistically‐validdatabaseofpotentiallyavailablebusinesseslocatedintherelevantgeographicmarketareathatperformworkwithinrelevantsubindustries.Thatmethodofexaminingavailabilityisreferredtoasacustomcensusandhasbeenacceptedinfederalcourtasthepreferredmethodologyforconductingavailabilityanalyses.Theobjectiveoftheavailabilitysurveywasnottocollectinformationfromeachandeveryrelevantbusinessthatisoperatinginthelocalmarketplace,butrathertocollectinformationfromanunbiasedsubsetofthebusinesspopulationthatappropriatelyrepresentstheentirebusinesspopulationoperatinginthelocalmarketplace.ThatapproachallowedBBCtoestimatetheavailabilityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinanaccurate,statistically‐validmanner.
Overview of availability surveys. ThestudyteamconductedtelephonesurveyswithbusinessownersandmanagerstoidentifylocalbusinessesthatarepotentiallyavailableforCityprimecontractsandsubcontracts.3BBCbeganthesurveyprocessbycompilingacomprehensiveandunbiasedphonebookofallbusinesses—regardlessofownership—thatperformworkinrelevantindustriesandhavealocationwithintherelevantgeographicmarketarea.BBCdevelopedthatphonebookbasedoninformationfromavarietyofdatasourcesincludingDun&Bradstreet(D&B)MarketplaceandtheCity’svendorregistrationlist.BBCcollectedinformationaboutallbusinessestablishmentslistedunder8‐digitworkspecializationcodes(asdevelopedbyD&B)thatweremostrelatedtothecontractsthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiod.BBCobtainedlistingson7,320localbusinessesthatdoworkrelatedtothoseworkspecializations.Removingatotalof1,168duplicate,non‐working,orincorrectphonenumbersresultedinalistof6,152businesseswithwhichBBCattemptedavailabilitysurveys.
Availability survey information.BBCworkedwithCustomerResearchInternationaltoconducttelephonesurveyswiththeownersormanagersoftheidentifiedbusinessestablishments.Surveyquestionscoveredmanytopicsabouteachbusiness,including:
Statusasaprivatebusiness(asopposedtoapublicagencyornonprofitorganization);
Statusasasubsidiaryorbranchofanothercompany;
Primarylinesofwork;
InterestinperformingworkfortheCityandothergovernmentagencies;
Workasaprimecontractororsubcontractor;
Largestprimecontractorsubcontractbidonorperformedinthepreviousfiveyears;and
Race/ethnicityandgenderofownership.
2BBCidentifiedtherelevantgeographicmarketareaforthedisparitystudyasAdams,Arapahoe,Boulder,Broomfield,Denver,Douglas,andJeffersonCountiesinColorado.
3Thestudyteamofferedbusinessrepresentativestheoptionofcompletingsurveysviafaxore‐mailiftheypreferrednottocompletesurveysviatelephone.
![Page 68: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/68.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 5, PAGE 3
Potentially available businesses.BBCconsideredbusinessestobepotentiallyavailableforCityprimecontractsorsubcontractsiftheyreportedhavingalocationintherelevantgeographicmarketareaandreportedpossessingallofthefollowingcharacteristics:
Beingaprivatesectorbusiness(asopposedtoagovernmentorganizationnonprofitorganization);
HavingperformedworkrelevanttoCityconstruction;professionalservices;orgoodsandservicescontractingorprocurement;
Havingbidonorperformedconstruction;professionalservices;orgoodandservicesprimecontractsorsubcontractsineitherthepublicorprivatesectorintherelevantgeographicmarketareainthepastfiveyears;and
BeinginterestedinworkfortheCityorothergovernmentagencies.4
BBCalsoconsideredthefollowinginformationaboutbusinessestodetermineiftheywerepotentiallyavailableforspecificprimecontractsandsubcontractsthattheCityawards:
Theroleinwhichtheywork(i.e.,asaprimecontractor,subcontractor,orboth);and
Thelargestcontracttheybidonorperformedinthepastfiveyears.
C. Businesses in the Availability Database
Afterconductingavailabilitysurveyswiththousandsoflocalbusinesses,BBCdevelopedadatabaseofinformationaboutbusinessesthatarepotentiallyavailableforCityconstruction;professionalservices;andgoodsandservicescontractsandprocurements.InformationfromthedatabaseallowedBBCtoassessbusinessesthatareready,willing,andabletoperformworkfortheCity.Figure5‐1presentsthepercentageofbusinessesintheavailabilitydatabasethatwereminority‐orwoman‐owned.TheinformationinFigure5‐1reflectsasimpleheadcountofbusinesseswithnoanalysisoftheiravailabilityforspecificCitycontracts.Thus,itrepresentsonlyafirststeptowardanalyzingtheavailabilityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesforCitywork.Thestudyteam’sanalysisincluded597businessesthatarepotentiallyavailableforspecificconstruction;professionalservices;andgoodsandservicescontractsandprocurementsthattheCityawards.AsshowninFigure5‐1,ofthosebusinesses,29.6percentwereminority‐orwoman‐owned.
D. Availability Calculations
BBCanalyzedinformationfromtheavailabilitydatabasetodevelopdollar‐weightedestimatesoftheavailabilityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesforCitywork.ThoseestimatesrepresentthepercentageofCitycontractingandprocurementdollarsthatminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesseswouldbeexpectedtoreceivebasedontheiravailabilityforspecifictypesandsizesofCityprimecontractsandsubcontracts.
4Thatinformationwasgatheredseparatelyforprimecontractandsubcontractwork.
![Page 69: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/69.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 5, PAGE 4
Figure 5‐1. Percentage of businesses in the availability database that are minority‐ or woman‐owned
Note:
Numbers rounded to nearest tenth of 1 percent. Numbers may not sum exactly to totals.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting availability analysis.
Steps to calculating availability.BBCusedabottomup,contract‐by‐contractmatchingapproachtocalculateavailability.OnlyaportionofthebusinessesintheavailabilitydatabasewasconsideredpotentiallyavailableforanygivenCityprimecontractorsubcontract.BBCfirstexaminedthecharacteristicsofeachspecificprimecontractorsubcontract(referredtogenerallyasacontractelement),includingtypeofworkandcontractsize.BBCthenidentifiedbusinessesintheavailabilitydatabasethatperformworkofthattype,inthatrole(i.e.,asaprimecontractororsubcontractor),andofthatsize.
BBCidentifiedthespecificcharacteristicsofeachprimecontractandsubcontractincludedaspartofthedisparitystudyandthentookthefollowingstepstocalculateavailabilityforeachcontractelement:
1. Foreachcontractelement,thestudyteamidentifiedbusinessesintheavailabilitydatabasethatreportedthatthey:
Areinterestedinperformingconstruction;professionalservices;orgoodsandservicesworkinthatparticularroleforthatspecifictypeofworkfortheCity;and
Havebidonorperformedworkofthatsizeinthepastfiveyears.
2. BBCthencountedthenumberofminority‐ownedbusinesses(separatelybyrace/ethnicity)andnon‐Hispanicwhitewoman‐ownedbusinessesamongthebusinessesthatmetthecriteriainStep1.
3. BBCtranslatedthenumericavailabilityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesforthecontractelementintopercentageavailability.
BBCrepeatedthosestepsforeachcontractelementthatthestudyteamexaminedaspartofthedisparitystudy.BBCmultipliedthepercentageavailabilityforeachcontractelementbythedollarsassociatedwiththecontractelement,addedresultsacrossallcontractelements,anddividedbythetotaldollarsforallcontractelements.Theresultwasdollar‐weightedestimatesoftheavailabilityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesses,bothoverallandseparatelyforeachracial/ethnicandgendergroup.Figure5‐2providesanexampleofhowBBCcalculatedavailabilityforaspecificsubcontractassociatedwithaconstructionprimecontractthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiod.
BBC’savailabilitycalculationsarebasedonprimecontractsandsubcontractsthattheCityawardedbetweenJanuary1,2012andDecember31,2016.AkeyassumptionoftheavailabilityanalysisisthatthecontractsandprocurementsthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiodarerepresentativeofthecontractsandprocurementsthattheCitywillawardinthefuture.
Business group
Non‐Hispanic white woman‐owned 12.4 %
Asian American‐owned 2.3 %
Black American‐owned 4.2 %
Hispanic American‐owned 9.4 %
Native American‐owned 1.0 %
Total Minority‐ and Woman‐owned 29.6 %
% of
businesses
![Page 70: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/70.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 5, PAGE 5
IfthetypesandsizesofthecontractsandprocurementsthattheCityawardsinthefuturediffersubstantiallyfromthosethattheyawardedinthepast,thentheCityshouldadjustavailabilitycalculationsaccordinglytoaccountforthosedifferences.
Improvements on a simple head count of businesses.BBCusedacustomcensusapproachtocalculatetheavailabilityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesforCityworkratherthanusingasimpleheadcountapproach(e.g.,simplycalculatingthepercentageofalllocalbusinessesthatareminority‐orwoman‐owned).ThereareseveralimportantwaysinwhichBBC’scustomcensusapproachtomeasuringavailabilityismoreprecisethancompletingasimpleheadcount.
BBC’s approach accounts for type of work.Federalregulationssuggestcalculatingavailabilitybasedonbusinesses’abilitiestoperformspecifictypesofwork.BBCtooktypeofworkintoaccountbyexamining65differentsubindustriesrelatedtoconstruction;professionalservices;andgoodsandservicesaspartofestimatingavailabilityforCityprimecontractsandsubcontracts.
BBC’s approach accounts for contractor role.Thestudyteamcollectedinformationonwhetherbusinessesworkasprimecontractors,subcontractors,orboth.BusinessesthatreportedworkingasprimecontractorswereconsideredpotentiallyavailableforCityprimecontracts.BusinessesthatreportedworkingassubcontractorswereconsideredpotentiallyavailableforCitysubcontracts.BusinessesthatreportedworkingasbothprimecontractorsandsubcontractorswereconsideredpotentiallyavailableforbothCityprimecontractsandsubcontracts.
BBC’s approach accounts for the relative capacity of businesses.ToaccountforthecapacityofbusinessestoworkonCitycontracts,BBCconsideredthesize—intermsofdollarvalue—oftheprimecontractsandsubcontractsthatabusinessbidonorreceivedinthepreviousfiveyearswhendeterminingwhethertocountthatbusinessasavailableforparticularprimecontractsorsubcontracts.Foreachcontractelement,BBCconsideredwhetherbusinesseshadpreviouslybidonorreceivedatleastonecontractofanequivalentorgreaterdollarvalue.BBC’sapproachtoaccountingforcapacityisconsistentwithmanyrecent,keycourtdecisionsthathavefoundsuchmeasurestobeimportanttomeasuringavailability(e.g.,AssociatedGeneralContractorsofAmerica,SanDiegoChaptervs.CaliforniaDepartmentofTransportation,etal.,5WesternStates
5AGC,SanDiegoChapterv.CaliforniaDOT,2013WL1607239(9thCir.April16,2013).
Figure 5‐2. Example of an availability calculation for a City subcontract
On a contract that the City awarded in 2012, the prime
contractor awarded a subcontract worth $60,005 for
electrical work. To determine the overall availability of
minority‐ and woman‐owned businesses for that
subcontract, the study team identified businesses in the
availability database that:
a. Were in business in 2016;
b. Indicated that they performed electrical work;
c. Reported bidding on work of similar or greater size
in the past; and
d. Reported interest in working as a subcontractor on
City or other government agency projects.
The study team found 22 businesses in the availability
database that met those criteria. Of those businesses,
eight were minority‐ or woman‐owned businesses.
Thus, the availability of minority‐ and woman‐owned
businesses for the subcontract was 36 percent (i.e.,
8/22 X 100 = 36).
![Page 71: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/71.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 5, PAGE 6
PavingCompanyv.WashingtonStateDOT,6RotheDevelopmentCorp.v.U.S.DepartmentofDefense,7andEngineeringContractorsAssociationofS.Fla.Inc.vs.MetroDadeCounty8).
BBC’s approach accounts for interest in relevant work.ThestudyteamcollectedinformationonwhetherbusinessesareinterestedinworkingonCityconstruction;professionalservices;andgoodsandserviceswork(inadditiontoconsideringseveralotherfactorsrelatedtoCityprimecontractsandsubcontracts,suchascontracttypeandsize).BusinesseshadtoindicatethattheyareinterestedinperformingsuchworkfortheCityinordertobeconsideredpotentiallyavailableforCitycontractsandprocurements.
BBC’s approach generates dollar‐weighted results.BBCexaminedavailabilityonacontract‐by‐contractbasisandthendollar‐weightedtheresultsfordifferentsetsofcontractelements.Thus,theresultsofrelativelylargecontractelementscontributedmoretooverallavailabilityestimatesthanthoseofrelativelysmallcontractelements.Thatapproachisconsistentwithrelevantcaselawandfederalregulations.
E. Availability Results
BBCestimatedtheavailabilityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesforthe21,790construction;professionalservices;andgoodsandservicesprimecontractsandsubcontractsthattheCityawardedbetweenJanuary1,2012andDecember31,2016.
Overall results.Figure5‐3presentsoveralldollar‐weightedavailabilityestimatesbyracial/ethnicandgendergroupforCitycontractsandprocurements.Overall,theavailabilityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesfortheCity’scontractsandprocurementsis23.7percent.Non‐Hispanicwhitewoman‐ownedbusinesses(10.9%)andHispanicAmerican‐ownedbusinesses(6.2%)exhibitedthehighestavailabilitypercentagesamongallgroups.
Figure 5‐3. Overall availability estimates by racial/ethnic and gender group
Note:
Numbers rounded to nearest tenth of 1 percent. Numbers may not sum exactly to totals.
For more detail, see Figure F‐2 in Appendix F.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting availability analysis.
Contract goals.Duringthestudyperiod,theCityusedMWBEandDBEcontractgoalstoawardmanylocally‐fundedandfederally‐fundedcontracts,respectively,toencouragetheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesses.TheCity’suseofthosecontractgoalsisarace‐andgender‐consciousmeasure.ItisusefultoexamineavailabilityanalysisresultsseparatelyforcontractsthattheCityawardswiththeuseofcontractgoals(goalscontracts)andcontractsthat
6WesternStatesPavingCo.v.WashingtonStateDOT,407F.3d983(9thCir.2005),cert.denied,546U.S.1170(2006).7RotheDevelopmentCorp.v.U.S.DepartmentofDefense,545F.3d1023(Fed.Cir.2008).
8EngineeringContractorsAssociationofS.Fla.Inc.vs.MetroDadeCounty,943F.Supp.1546(S.D.Fla.1996).
Business group
Non‐Hispanic white woman‐owned 10.9 %
Asian American‐owned 3.2 %
Black American‐owned 3.3 %
Hispanic American‐owned 6.2 %
Native American‐owned 0.1 %
Total Minority‐ and Woman‐owned 23.7 %
Availability %
![Page 72: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/72.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 5, PAGE 7
theCityawardswithouttheuseofgoals(no‐goalscontracts).Figure5‐4presentsavailabilityestimatesseparatelyforgoalsandno‐goalscontracts.AsshowninFigure5‐4,theavailabilityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesconsideredtogetherisapproximatelyequalacrossgoalscontracts(23.1%)andno‐goalscontracts(24.1%).
Figure 5‐4. Availability estimates by contract goal status
Note:
Numbers rounded to nearest tenth of 1 percent. Numbers may not sum exactly to totals.
For more detail, see Figures F‐16 and F‐17 in Appendix F.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting availability analysis.
Contract role. Manyminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesaresmallbusinessesandthusoftenworkassubcontractors.Becauseofthattendency,itisusefultoexamineavailabilityestimatesseparatelyforprimecontractsandsubcontracts.Figure5‐5presentsthoseresults.AsshowninFigure5‐5,theavailabilityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesconsideredtogetherissimilarforCityprimecontracts(23.6%)andCitysubcontracts(24.4%).
Figure 5‐5. Availability estimates by contract role
Note:
Numbers rounded to nearest tenth of 1 percent. Numbers may not sum exactly to totals.
For more detail, see Figures F‐8 and F‐9 in Appendix F.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting availability analysis.
Denver international Airport (DEN) contracts. BBCanalyzedtheavailabilityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesforbothFAA‐andstate‐fundedDENcontractsaswellasnon‐DENcontracts.Figure5‐6presentstheoverallavailabilityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesforcontractsthatDENawardedduringthestudyperiod(includingbothprimecontractsandsubcontracts)comparedtothosebusinesses’availabilityforcontractsawardedbyotherCitydepartmentsandGeneralServices.AsshowninFigure5‐6,theavailabilityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesconsideredtogetherisslightlylowerforDENcontracts(20.9%)thannon‐DENcontracts(26.0%).
Business group
Non‐Hispanic white woman‐owned 12.2 % 10.0 %
Asian American‐owned 2.0 % 4.0 %
Black American‐owned 2.3 % 4.1 %
Hispanic American‐owned 6.4 % 6.0 %
Native American‐owned 0.2 % 0.1 %
Total Minority‐ and Woman‐owned 23.1 % 24.1 %
Goal Status
Goals
contracts
No‐goals
contracts
Business group
Non‐Hispanic white woman‐owned 10.8 % 11.4 %
Asian American‐owned 3.4 % 2.2 %
Black American‐owned 3.2 % 3.9 %
Hispanic American‐owned 6.1 % 6.4 %
Native American‐owned 0.1 % 0.5 %
Total Minority‐ and Woman‐owned 23.6 % 24.4 %
Contract Role
Prime
contracts Subcontracts
![Page 73: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/73.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 5, PAGE 8
Figure 5‐6. Availability estimates by department
Note:
Numbers rounded to nearest tenth of 1 percent. Numbers may not sum exactly to totals.
For more detail, see Figures F‐12 and F‐13 in Appendix F.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting availability analysis.
Industry.BBCexaminedavailabilityanalysisresultsseparatelyfortheCity’sconstruction;professionalservices;andgoodsandservicescontracts.Theprojectteamcombinedresultsforgoodsandservicescontracts,becausetheCityusessimilarprocurementprocessestoawardthosecontracts.AsshowninFigure5‐7,theavailabilityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesconsideredtogetherishighestfortheCity’sprofessionalservicescontracts(40.4%)andlowestforconstructioncontracts(19.0%).
Figure 5‐7. Availability estimates by industry
Note:
Numbers rounded to nearest tenth of 1 percent. Numbers may not sum exactly to totals.
For more detail, see Figures F‐5, F‐6, and F‐7 in Appendix F.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting availability analysis.
Time period.BBCexaminedavailabilityanalysisresultsseparatelyforcontractsandprocurementsthattheCityawardedintheearlystudyperiod(i.e.,January1,2012–June30,2014)andthelatestudyperiod(i.e.,July1,2014–December31,2016)todeterminewhetherthetypesandsizesofcontractsthattheCityawardedacrossthestudyperiodchangedovertime,whichinturnwouldaffectavailability.AsshowninFigure5‐8,theavailabilityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesconsideredtogetherissomewhatlowerintheearlystudyperiod(23.1%)thaninthelatestudyperiod(24.4%).
Figure 5‐8. Availability estimates by time period
Note:
Numbers rounded to nearest tenth of 1 percent. Numbers may not sum exactly to totals.
For more detail, see Figures F‐3 and F‐4 in Appendix F.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting availability analysis.
Business group
Non‐Hispanic white woman‐owned 12.7 % 9.5 %
Asian American‐owned 1.1 % 4.8 %
Black American‐owned 2.6 % 3.9 %
Hispanic American‐owned 4.4 % 7.5 %
Native American‐owned 0.1 % 0.2 %
Total Minority‐ and Woman‐owned 20.9 % 26.0 %
Department
DEN Non‐DEN
Business group
Non‐Hispanic white woman‐owned 10.8 % 15.8 % 7.6 %
Asian American‐owned 1.6 % 2.6 % 8.5 %
Black American‐owned 1.9 % 11.5 % 2.2 %
Hispanic American‐owned 4.6 % 10.4 % 7.9 %
Native American‐owned 0.2 % 0.1 % 0.1 %
Total Minority‐ and Woman‐owned 19.0 % 40.4 % 26.3 %
Industry
Construction
Professional
services
Goods and
services
Business group
Non‐Hispanic white woman‐owned 11.5 % 10.2 %
Asian American‐owned 3.0 % 3.4 %
Black American‐owned 3.5 % 3.2 %
Hispanic American‐owned 4.9 % 7.4 %
Native American‐owned 0.1 % 0.2 %
Total Minority‐ and Woman‐owned 23.1 % 24.4 %
Time Period
Early Late
![Page 74: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/74.jpg)
CHAPTER 6.
Utilization Analysis
![Page 75: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/75.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 6, PAGE 1
CHAPTER 6. Utilization Analysis
Chapter6presentsinformationabouttheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinconstruction;professionalservices;andgoodsandservicescontractsandprocurementsthattheCityandCountyofDenver(theCity)awardedbetweenJanuary1,2012andDecember31,2016.BBCResearch&Consulting(BBC)measuredtheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinCitycontractingintermsofutilization—thepercentageofprimecontractandsubcontractdollarsthatminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesreceivedonCityprimecontractsandsubcontractsduringthestudyperiod.1Forexample,if5percentofCityprimecontractandsubcontractdollarswenttonon‐Hispanicwhitewoman‐ownedbusinessesonaparticularsetofcontracts,utilizationofnon‐Hispanicwhitewoman‐ownedbusinessesforthatsetofcontractswouldbe5percent.BBCconsideredutilizationresultsontheirownandasinputsinthedisparityanalysis(fordetails,seeChapter7).
BBCmeasuredtheparticipationofallminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinCitycontractsregardlessofwhethertheywerecertifiedasminority‐ownedbusinessenterprises(MBEs),woman‐ownedbusinessenterprises(WBEs),orDisadvantagedBusinessEnterprises(DBEs).BBCalsomeasuredparticipationseparatelyforminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesthatwereMWBE‐certified.
Overall Results
Figure6‐1presentsthepercentageofcontractingdollarsthatminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesconsideredtogetherreceivedonconstruction;professionalservices;andgoodsandservicescontractsandprocurementsthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiod(includingbothprimecontractsandsubcontracts).AsshowninFigure6‐1,overall,minority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesconsideredtogetherreceived14.8percentoftherelevantcontractingdollarsthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiod.(Themajorityofthosecontractingdollars—10.1percent—wenttocertifiedMWBEs.)HispanicAmerican‐ownedbusinesses(6.3%)andnon‐Hispanicwhitewoman‐ownedbusinesses(5.3%)exhibitedhigherlevelsofparticipationinCitycontractsthanallothergroups.
Contract Goals
Duringthestudyperiod,theCityusedMWBEandDBEcontractgoalstoawardmanylocally‐fundedandfederally‐fundedcontracts,respectively,toencouragetheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesses.TheCity’suseofthosecontractgoalsisarace‐andgender‐consciousmeasure.ItisusefultoexamineutilizationanalysisresultsseparatelyforcontractsthattheCityawardswiththeuseofcontractgoals(goalscontracts)andcontractsthattheCityawardswithouttheuseofgoals(no‐goalscontracts).Doingsoprovidesusefulinformationabout
1“Woman‐ownedbusinesses”referstonon‐Hispanicwhitewomanownedbusinesses.Informationandresultsforminoritywoman‐ownedbusinessesareincludedalongwiththeircorrespondingracial/ethnicgroups.
![Page 76: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/76.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 6, PAGE 2
outcomesforminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesoncontractsthattheCityawardedinarace‐andgender‐neutralenvironmentandtheefficacyofMWBEandDBEcontractgoalsinencouragingtheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinCitycontractsandprocurements.
Figure 6‐1. Overall utilization results
Note:
Numbers rounded to nearest tenth of 1 percent. Numbers may not sum exactly to totals.
For more detail, see Figure F‐2 in Appendix F.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting utilization analysis.
Figure6‐2presentsutilizationresultsseparatelyforgoalscontractsandno‐goalscontracts.AsshowninFigure6‐2,minority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesconsideredtogethershowedhigherparticipationingoalscontracts(24.1%)thaninno‐goalcontracts(8.4%).Thoseresultsmightindicatetheeffectivenessofcontractgoalsinencouragingtheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinCitycontractsandprocurements.Note,however,thatexaminingdisparityanalysisresultsprovidesabetterassessmentoftheefficacyofcontractgoals,becausethoseresultsalsotaketheavailabilityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesforgoalsandno‐goalscontractsintoaccount.
Figure 6‐2. Utilization results by contract goal status
Note:
Numbers rounded to nearest tenth of 1 percent. Numbers may not sum exactly to totals.
For more detail, see Figures F‐16 and F‐17 in Appendix F.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting utilization analysis.
Contract Role
Manyminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesaresmallbusinessesand,thus,oftenworkassubcontractors.Becauseofthattendency,itisusefultoexamineutilizationresultsseparatelyforprimecontractsandsubcontracts.Figure6‐3presentsthoseresults.AsshowninFigure6‐3,theparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesconsideredtogetherwasmuchhigherintheCity’ssubcontracts(42.9%)thanintheCity’sprimecontracts(8.7%).ThevastmajorityofcontractingdollarsthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiodwereassociatedwithprimecontracts.
Business group
Non‐Hispanic white woman‐owned 5.3 %
Asian American‐owned 1.2 %
Black American‐owned 1.6 %
Hispanic American‐owned 6.3 %
Native American‐owned 0.5 %
Total Minority‐ and Woman‐owned 14.8 %
Utilization %
Business group
Non‐Hispanic white woman‐owned 8.1 % 3.3 %
Asian American‐owned 1.2 % 1.2 %
Black American‐owned 1.9 % 1.5 %
Hispanic American‐owned 12.1 % 2.1 %
Native American‐owned 0.8 % 0.3 %
Total Minority‐ and Woman‐owned 24.1 % 8.4 %
Goal Status
Goals
contracts
No‐goals
contracts
![Page 77: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/77.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 6, PAGE 3
Figure 6‐3. Utilization results by contract role
Note:
Numbers rounded to nearest tenth of 1 percent. Numbers may not sum exactly to totals.
For more detail, see Figures F‐8 and F‐9 in Appendix F.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting utilization analysis.
DEN Contracts
BBCalsoanalyzedtheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesincontractsthattheDenverInternationalAirport(DEN)awardedandcontractsthatotherCitydepartmentsawarded.Figure6‐4presentsthoseresults.AsshowninFigure6‐4,minority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesexhibitedsomewhatlowerlevelsofparticipationinDENcontracts(14.1%)whencomparedtoallotherCitycontracts(15.4%).
Figure 6‐4. Utilization results by department
Note:
Numbers rounded to nearest tenth of 1 percent. Numbers may not sum exactly to totals.
For more detail, see Figures F‐12 and F‐13 in Appendix F.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting utilization analysis.
Industry
BBCexaminedutilizationresultsseparatelyfortheCity’sconstruction;professionalservices;andgoodsandservicescontracts.Theprojectteamcombinedresultsforgoodsandservicescontracts,becausetheCityusessimilarprocurementprocessestoawardthosecontracts.AsshowninFigure6‐5,theparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesconsideredtogetherwashighestintheCity’sprofessionalservicescontracts(19.4%)andlowestingoodsandservicescontracts(10.6%).ThemajorityofcontractingdollarsthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiodwereinconstruction,inwhichtheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesseswas15.2percent.
Business group
Non‐Hispanic white woman‐owned 3.5 % 13.5 %
Asian American‐owned 1.0 % 2.2 %
Black American‐owned 1.1 % 3.9 %
Hispanic American‐owned 2.7 % 22.4 %
Native American‐owned 0.4 % 0.9 %
Total Minority‐ and Woman‐owned 8.7 % 42.9 %
Contract Role
Prime
contracts Subcontracts
Business group
Non‐Hispanic white woman‐owned 3.7 % 6.5 %
Asian American‐owned 0.5 % 1.8 %
Black American‐owned 2.1 % 1.2 %
Hispanic American‐owned 7.2 % 5.5 %
Native American‐owned 0.6 % 0.4 %
Total Minority‐ and Woman‐owned 14.1 % 15.4 %
Department
DEN Non‐DEN
![Page 78: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/78.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 6, PAGE 4
Figure 6‐5. Utilization results by relevant industry
Note:
Numbers rounded to nearest tenth of 1 percent. Numbers may not sum exactly to totals.
For more detail, see Figures F‐5, F‐6, and F‐7 in Appendix F.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting utilization analysis.
Time Period
BBCexaminedutilizationresultsseparatelyforcontractsandprocurementsthattheCityawardedintheearlystudyperiod(i.e.,January1,2012–June30,2014)andthelatestudyperiod(i.e.,July1,2014–December31,2016)todeterminewhethertheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinCitycontractschangedovertime.AsshowninFigure6‐6,theparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesconsideredtogetherwassimilarbetweentheearly(12.8%)andlate(16.9%)studyperiods.
Figure 6‐6. Utilization results by time period
Note:
Numbers rounded to nearest tenth of 1 percent. Numbers may not sum exactly to totals.
For more detail, see Figures F‐3 and F‐4 in Appendix F.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting utilization analysis.
Concentration of Dollars
BBCanalyzedwhetherthedollarsthateachrelevantbusinessreceivedonCitycontractsduringthestudyperiodwerespreadacrossarelativelylargenumberofbusinessesorwereconcentratedwitharelativelysmallnumberofbusinesses.Thestudyteamassessedthatquestionbycalculating:
Thenumberofdifferentbusinesseswithineachrelevantgroupthatreceivedcontractingdollarsduringthestudyperiod;and
Thenumberofdifferentbusinesseswithineachrelevantgroupthataccountedfor75percentofthegroup’stotalcontractingdollarsduringthestudyperiod.
Figure6‐7presentsthoseresults.Overall,639differentminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesparticipatedinCitycontractsduringthestudyperiod.86ofthosebusinesses,or13.5percentofallutilizedminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesses,accountedfor75percentofthetotalcontractingdollarsthatminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesreceivedduringthestudyperiod.
Business group
Non‐Hispanic white woman‐owned 4.9 % 6.5 % 5.5 %
Asian American‐owned 0.6 % 2.0 % 2.9 %
Black American‐owned 0.7 % 7.3 % 0.4 %
Hispanic American‐owned 8.3 % 3.6 % 1.7 %
Native American‐owned 0.8 % 0.0 % 0.1 %
Total Minority‐ and Woman‐owned 15.2 % 19.4 % 10.6 %
Industry
Construction
Professional
services
Goods and
services
Business group
Non‐Hispanic white woman‐owned 4.5 % 6.1 %
Asian American‐owned 0.7 % 1.8 %
Black American‐owned 2.1 % 1.1 %
Hispanic American‐owned 5.2 % 7.4 %
Native American‐owned 0.4 % 0.7 %
Total Minority‐ and Woman‐owned 12.8 % 16.9 %
Time Period
Early Late
![Page 79: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/79.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 6, PAGE 5
Figure 6‐7. Concentration of dollars that went to minority‐ and woman‐owned businesses
Note:
The sum of utilized businesses by group is not equal to total utilized minority‐ and woman‐owned businesses, because 32 minority‐owned businesses that received work during the study period were of unknown race/ethnicity.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting utilization analysis.
Business group
Non‐Hispanic white woman‐owned 292 53 18.2%
Asian American‐owned 51 8 15.7%
Black American‐owned 60 5 8.3%
Hispanic American‐owned 188 23 12.2%
Native American‐owned 16 2 12.5%
Total Minority‐ and Woman‐owned 639 86 13.5%
Utilized
businesses
Number of
businesses
accounting for
75% of dollars
% of
businesses
accounting for
75% of dollars
![Page 80: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/80.jpg)
CHAPTER 7.
Disparity Analysis
![Page 81: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/81.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 7, PAGE 1
CHAPTER 7. Disparity Analysis
Thedisparityanalysiscomparedtheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesincontractsthattheCityandCountyofDenver(theCity)awardedbetweenJanuary1,2012andDecember31,2016(i.e.,thestudyperiod)towhatthosebusinessesmightbeexpectedtoreceivebasedontheiravailabilityforthatwork.Theanalysisfocusedonconstruction;professionalservices;andgoodsandservicescontractsandprocurements.Chapter7presentsthedisparityanalysisinfourparts:
A. Overview;
B. DisparityAnalysisResults;
C. StatisticalSignificance;and
D. Bid/ProposalProcesses.
A. Overview
Aspartofthedisparityanalysis,BBCResearch&Consulting(BBC)comparedtheactualparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinCityprimecontractsandsubcontractswiththepercentageofcontractdollarsthatthosebusinessesmightbeexpectedtoreceivebasedontheiravailabilityforthatwork.1BBCmadethosecomparisonsforeachrelevantracial/ethnicandgendergroup.BBCexpressedbothactualparticipationandavailabilityaspercentagesofthetotaldollarsassociatedwithaparticularsetofcontracts.(e.g.,5%participationcomparedwith4%availability).BBCthencalculatedadisparityindextohelpcompareparticipationandavailabilityresultsacrossrelevantracial/ethnicandgendergroupsanddifferentcontractsetsusingthefollowingformula:
Adisparityindexof100indicatesparitybetweenactualparticipation,orutilization,andavailability.Thatis,participationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesseswaslargelyinlinewithavailability.Adisparityindexoflessthan100indicatesadisparitybetweenparticipationandavailability.Thatis,minority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesseswereunderutilizedrelativetotheiravailability.Finally,adisparityindexoflessthan80indicatesasubstantialdisparity
1“Woman‐ownedbusinesses”referstonon‐Hispanicwhitewomanownedbusinesses.Informationandresultsforminoritywoman‐ownedbusinessesareincludedalongwiththeircorrespondingracial/ethnicgroups.
%participation
%availabilityx100
![Page 82: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/82.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 7, PAGE 2
betweenparticipationandavailability.Thatis,minority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesweresubstantiallyunderutilizedrelativetotheiravailability.2
ThedisparityanalysisresultsthatBBCpresentsinChapter7summarizedetailedresultstablesthatarepresentedinAppendixF.EachtableinAppendixFpresentsdisparityanalysisresultsforadifferentsetofcontracts.Forexample,Figure7‐1,whichisidenticaltoFigureF‐2inAppendixF,presentsdisparityanalysisresultsforallCitycontractsthatBBCexaminedaspartofthestudy.AppendixFincludesanalogoustablesfordifferentsubsetsofcontractsincluding:
Construction;professionalservices;andgoodsandservices;
Primecontractsandsubcontracts;and
ContractsthattheCityawardedindifferentstudyperiodyears.
TheheadingofeachtableinAppendixFprovidesadescriptionofthesubsetofcontractsthatBBCanalyzedforthatparticulartable.
AreviewofFigure7‐1helpstointroducethecalculationsandformatofallofthedisparityanalysistablesinAppendixF.AsillustratedinFigure7‐1,thedisparityanalysistablespresentinformationabouteachrelevantracial/ethnicandgendergroup(aswellasaboutallbusinesses)inseparaterows:
“Allbusinesses”inrow(1)pertainstoinformationaboutallbusinessesregardlessoftherace/ethnicityandgenderoftheirowners.
Row(2)presentsresultsforallminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesconsideredtogether,regardlessofwhethertheywerecertifiedasminority‐ownedbusinessenterprises(MBEs),woman‐ownedbusinessenterprises(WBEs),orDisadvantagedBusinessEnterprises(DBEs).
Row(3)presentsresultsforallnon‐Hispanicwhitewoman‐ownedbusinesses,regardlessofwhethertheywerecertifiedasWBEsorDBEs.
Row(4)presentsresultsforallminority‐ownedbusinesses,regardlessofwhethertheywerecertifiedasMBEsorDBEs.
Rows(5)through(9)presentresultsforbusinessesofeachindividualracial/ethnicgroup,regardlessofwhethertheywerecertifiedasMBEs.
2Manycourtshavedeemeddisparityindicesbelow80asbeingsubstantialandhaveacceptedsuchoutcomesasevidenceofadverseconditionsforminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesses(e.g.,seeRotheDevelopmentCorpv.U.S.DeptofDefense,545F.3d1023,1041;Eng’gContractorsAss’nofSouthFlorida,Inc.v.MetropolitanDadeCounty,122F.3dat914,923(11thCircuit1997);andConcreteWorksofColo.,Inc.v.CityandCountyofDenver,36F.3d1513,1524(10thCir.1994).SeeAppendixBforadditionaldiscussionofthoseandothercases.
![Page 83: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/83.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 7, PAGE 3
Figure 7‐1. Example of a disparity analysis table from Appendix F (same as Figure F‐2 in Appendix F)
Note: Numbers are rounded to the nearest thousand dollars or tenth of one percent. “woman‐owned” refers to non‐Hispanic white woman‐owned.
* Unknown minority‐owned businesses and unknown MBEs were allocated to minority and MBE subgroups proportional to the known total dollars of those groups. For example, if total dollars of Black American‐owned businesses (column b, row 5) accounted for 25 percent of total minority‐owned business dollars (column b, row 4), then 25 percent of column b, row 10 would be added to column b, row 5 and the sum would be shown in column c, row 5.
Source: BBC Research & Consulting disparity analysis.
(1) All businesses 21,790 $3,497,551 $3,497,551
(2) Minority and woman‐owned businesses 4,543 $519,020 $519,020 14.8 23.7 ‐8.9 62.6
(3) Non‐Hispanic white woman‐owned 2,235 $184,110 $184,110 5.3 10.9 ‐5.6 48.4
(4) Minority‐owned 2,308 $334,911 $334,911 9.6 12.8 ‐3.3 74.5
(5) Asian American‐owned 397 $40,636 $42,054 1.2 3.2 ‐2.0 37.6
(6) Black American‐owned 234 $54,199 $56,089 1.6 3.3 ‐1.7 47.9
(7) Hispanic American‐owned 1,298 $211,314 $218,683 6.3 6.2 0.1 101.6
(8) Native American‐owned 87 $17,475 $18,084 0.5 0.1 0.4 200+
(9) Unknown minority‐owned 292 $11,287
(10) MWBE‐certified 2,572 $354,141 $354,141 10.1
(11) Non‐Hispanic white woman‐owned 1,028 $112,018 $112,018 3.2
(12) Minority‐owned MWBE 1,544 $242,123 $242,123 6.9
(13) Asian American‐owned MWBE 254 $16,522 $16,522 0.5
(14) Black American‐owned MWBE 185 $40,315 $40,341 1.2
(15) Hispanic American‐owned MWBE 1,038 $174,415 $174,528 5.0
(16) Native American‐owned MWBE 60 $10,714 $10,721 0.3
(17) Unknown minority‐owned MWBE 7 $156
(c)
total dollars
(a) (b)
(thousands)*
Estimated
Business Group
Number of contractelements
dollarsTotal
(thousands)
(e)(d) (g)
Disparityindex
(f)
Utilization ‐Availability
Availabilitypercentagepercentage
Utilization
![Page 84: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/84.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 7, PAGE 4
Utilization results.Eachdisparityanalysistableincludesthesamecolumnsandrows:
Column(a)presentsthetotalnumberofprimecontractsandsubcontracts(i.e.,contractelements)thatBBCanalyzedaspartofthecontractset.Asshowninrow(1)ofcolumn(a)ofFigure7‐1,BBCanalyzed21,790contractelements.Thevaluepresentedincolumn(a)foreachindividualracial/ethnicandgendergrouprepresentsthenumberofcontractelementsinwhichbusinessesofthatparticulargroupparticipated(e.g.,asshowninrow(6)ofcolumn(a),BlackAmerican‐ownedbusinessesparticipatedin234primecontractsandsubcontracts).
Column(b)presentsthedollars(inthousands)thatwereassociatedwiththesetofcontractelements.Asshowninrow(1)ofcolumn(b)ofFigure7‐1,BBCexaminedapproximately$3.5billionfortheentiresetofcontractelements.Thedollartotalsincludebothprimecontractandsubcontractdollars.Thevaluepresentedincolumn(b)foreachindividualracial/ethnicandgendergrouprepresentsthedollarsthatthebusinessesofthatparticulargroupreceivedonthesetofcontractelements(e.g.,asshowninrow(6)ofcolumn(b),BlackAmerican‐ownedbusinessesreceivedapproximately$54million).
Column(c)presentsthedollars(inthousands)thatwereassociatedwiththesetofcontractelementsafteradjustingthosedollarsforbusinessesthatBBCidentifiedasminority‐ownedorMBEsbutforwhichspecificrace/ethnicityinformationwasnotavailable.Thedollartotalsincludebothprimecontractandsubcontractdollars.
Column(d)presentstheparticipationofeachracial/ethnicandgendergroupasapercentageoftotaldollarsassociatedwiththesetofcontractelements.BBCcalculatedeachpercentageincolumn(d)bydividingthedollarsgoingtoaparticulargroupincolumn(c)bythetotaldollarsassociatedwiththesetofcontractelementsshowninrow(1)ofcolumn(c),andthenexpressingtheresultasapercentage(e.g.,forBlackAmerican‐ownedbusinesses,thestudyteamdivided$56millionby$3.5billionandmultipliedby100foraresultof1.6%,asshowninrow(6)ofcolumn(d)).
ThebottomhalfofFigure7‐1presentsutilizationresultsforbusinessesthatwerecertifiedasMWBEs.
Availability results.Column(e)ofFigure7‐1presentstheavailabilityofeachrelevantracial/ethnicandgendergroupforallcontractelementsthatthestudyteamanalyzedaspartofthecontractset.Availabilityestimates,whicharerepresentedasapercentageofthetotalcontractingdollarsassociatedwiththesetofcontracts,serveasbenchmarksagainstwhichtocomparetheparticipationofspecificgroupsforspecificsetsofcontracts(e.g.,asshowninrow(6)ofcolumn(e),theavailabilityofBlackAmerican‐ownedbusinessesis3.3%).
Differences between participation and availability.Thenextstepinanalyzingwhethertherewasadisparitybetweentheparticipationandavailabilityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesistosubtracttheparticipationpercentagefromtheavailabilitypercentage.Column(f)ofFigure7‐1presentsthepercentagepointdifferencebetweenparticipationandavailabilityforeachrelevantracial/ethnicandgendergroup.Forexample,aspresentedinrow(6)ofcolumn(f)ofFigure7‐1,theparticipationofBlackAmerican‐ownedbusinessesinCitycontractswas1.7percentagepointslessthantheiravailability.
![Page 85: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/85.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 7, PAGE 5
Disparity indices.Itissometimesdifficulttointerpretabsolutepercentagedifferencesbetweenparticipationandavailability.Therefore,BBCalsocalculatedadisparityindexforeachrelevantracial/ethnicandgendergroup.Column(g)ofFigure7‐1presentsthedisparityindexforeachrelevantracial/ethnicandgendergroup.Forexample,asreportedinrow(6)ofcolumn(g),thedisparityindexforBlackAmerican‐ownedbusinesseswasapproximately48,indicatingthatBlackAmerican‐ownedbusinessesactuallyreceivedapproximately$0.48foreverydollarthattheymightbeexpectedtoreceivebasedontheiravailabilityforprimecontractsandsubcontractsthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiod.
BBCappliedthefollowingruleswhendisparityindiceswereexceedinglylargeorcouldnotbecalculated,becausethestudyteamdidnotidentifyanybusinessesofaparticulargroupasavailableforaparticularcontractset:
WhenBBC’scalculationsshowedadisparityindexexceeding200,BBCreportedanindexof200+.Adisparityindexof200+meansthatparticipationwasmorethantwiceasmuchasavailabilityforaparticulargroupforaparticularsetofcontracts.
Whentherewasnoparticipationandnoavailabilityforaparticulargroupforaparticularsetofcontracts,BBCreportedadisparityindexof100,indicatingparity.
B. Disparity Analysis Results
BBCmeasureddisparitiesbetweentheparticipationandavailabilityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesforvarioussetsofcontractsthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiod.Thestudyteammeasureddisparitiesforminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesconsideredtogetherandseparatelyforeachrelevantracial/ethnicandgendergroup.
Overall.Figure7‐2presentsdisparityindicesforallrelevantprimecontractsandsubcontractsthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiod.Thelinedownthecenterofthegraphshowsadisparityindexlevelof100,whichindicatesparitybetweenparticipationandavailability.Disparityindicesoflessthan100indicatedisparitiesbetweenparticipationandavailability(i.e.,underutilization).Forreference,alineisalsodrawnatadisparityindexlevelof80,becausesomecourtsuse80asthethresholdforwhatindicatesasubstantialdisparity.
AsshowninFigure7‐2,overall,theparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesincontractsthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiodwassubstantiallylowerthanwhatonemightexpectbasedontheavailabilityofthosebusinessesforthatwork.Thedisparityindexof63indicatesthatminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesreceivedapproximately$0.63foreverydollarthattheymightbeexpectedtoreceivebasedontheiravailabilityfortherelevantprimecontractsandsubcontractsthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiod.Disparityanalysisresultsbyindividualgroupindicatedthat:
Threegroupsexhibiteddisparityindicessubstantiallybelowparity:non‐Hispanicwhitewoman‐ownedbusinesses(disparityindexof48),AsianAmerican‐ownedbusinesses(disparityindexof38),andBlackAmerican‐ownedbusinesses(disparityindexof48).
HispanicAmerican‐ownedbusinesses(disparityindexof102)andNativeAmerican‐ownedbusinesses(disparityindexof200+)didnotexhibitadisparity.
![Page 86: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/86.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 7, PAGE 6
Figure 7‐2. Disparity indices by group
Note:
Numbers rounded to nearest whole number.
For more detail, see Figure F‐2 in Appendix F.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting disparity analysis.
Contract goals.Duringthestudyperiod,theCityusedMWBEandDBEcontractgoalstoawardmanylocally‐fundedandfederally‐fundedcontracts,respectively,toencouragetheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesses.TheCity’suseofthosecontractgoalsisarace‐andgender‐consciousmeasure.ItisusefultoexaminedisparityanalysisresultsseparatelyforcontractsthattheCityawardswiththeuseofMWBEorDBEcontractgoals(goalscontracts)andcontractsthattheCityawardswithouttheuseofgoals(no‐goalscontracts).Assessingwhetheranydisparitiesexistforno‐goalcontractsprovidesusefulinformationaboutoutcomesforminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesoncontractsthattheCityawardedinarace‐andgender‐neutralenvironmentandwhetherthereisevidencethatcertaingroupsfaceanydiscriminationorbarriersaspartoftheagency’scontracting.3,4,5
Figure7‐3presentsdisparityanalysisresultsseparatelyforgoalsandno‐goalscontracts.AsshowninFigure7‐3,whereasminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesconsideredtogethershowedparityongoalscontracts(disparityindexof104),theyexhibitedasubstantialdisparityonno‐goalscontracts(disparityindexof35).Disparityanalysisresultsbyindividualgroupindicatedthat:
Non‐Hispanicwhitewoman‐ownedbusinesses(disparityindexof67)andAsianAmerican‐ownedbusinesses(disparityindexof59)exhibitedsubstantialdisparitiesongoalscontracts.BlackAmerican‐ownedbusinessalsoexhibitedadisparitythatwasclosetothethresholdofbeingconsideredsubstantial(disparityindexof82);and
AllgroupsexceptNativeAmerican‐ownedbusinesses(disparityindexof200+)exhibitedsubstantialdisparitiesonno‐goalscontracts.
3AssociatedGeneralContractorsofAmerica,SanDiegoChapter,Inc.v.CaliforniaDepartmentofTransportation,etal.,713F.3d1187,1192,1196(9thCir.2013). 4ConcreteWorksofColorado,Inc.v.CityandCountyofDenver,321F.3d950,985,987‐88(10thCir.2003),cert.denied,540U.S.1027,124S.Ct.556(2003).5H.B.RoweCo.,Inc.v.W.LyndoTippett,NCDOT,etal.,615F.3d233,246(4thCir.2010).
![Page 87: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/87.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 7, PAGE 7
Figure 7‐3. Disparity indices for goal and no‐goal contracts
Note:
Numbers rounded to nearest whole number.
For more detail, see Figures F‐16 and F‐17 in Appendix F.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting disparity analysis.
Takentogether,theresultspresentedinFigure7‐3showthattheCity’suseofMWBEandDBEcontractgoalsissomewhateffectiveinencouragingtheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinitscontracts.Moreover,theresultsindicatethatwhentheCitydoesnotuserace‐andgender‐consciousmeasures,nearlyallrelevantbusinessgroupssufferfromsubstantialunderutilizationinCitycontractingandprocurement.
Contract role. Subcontractstendtobemuchsmallerinsizethanprimecontracts.Asaresult,subcontractsareoftenmoreaccessiblethanprimecontractstominority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesses.Inaddition,theCityusedMWBEandDBEcontractgoalswhenawardingmanycontractsduringthestudyperiod,whichprimarilyaffectsubcontractopportunitiesforminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesses.Thus,itmightbereasonabletoexpectbetteroutcomesforminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesonsubcontractsthanonprimecontracts.Figure7‐4presentsdisparityindicesforallrelevantgroupsseparatelyforprimecontractsandsubcontracts.AsshowninFigure7‐4,minority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesconsideredtogethershowedasubstantialdisparityforprimecontracts(disparityindexof37)butnotforsubcontracts(disparityindexof176).Resultsforindividualgroupsindicatedthat:
AllgroupsshowedsubstantialdisparitiesonprimecontractsexceptforNativeAmerican‐ownedbusinesses(disparityindexof200+).
Nogroupsexhibitedsubstantialdisparitiesonsubcontracts.
![Page 88: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/88.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 7, PAGE 8
Figure 7‐4. Disparity indices for prime contracts and subcontracts
Note:
Numbers rounded to nearest whole number.
For more detail, see Figures F‐8 and F‐9 in Appendix F.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting disparity analysis.
DEN contracts.BBCexamineddisparityanalysisresultsseparatelyforcontractsthattheDenverInternationalAirport(DEN)awardedandcontractsthatotherCityagenciesawarded.Figure7‐5presentsthoseresults.AsshowninFigure7‐5,minority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesconsideredtogetherexhibitedsubstantialdisparitiesforbothDENcontracts(disparityindexof68)andnon‐DENcontracts(disparityindexof59).Disparityanalysisresultsbyindividualgroupindicatedthat:
ThreeindividualgroupsshowedsubstantialdisparitiesforDENcontracts:non‐Hispanicwhitewoman‐ownedbusinesses(disparityindexof29),AsianAmerican‐ownedbusinesses(disparityindexof50),andBlackAmerican‐ownedbusinesses(disparityindexof79).
Allindividualgroupsexhibitedsubstantialdisparitiesonnon‐DENcontracts,withtheexceptionofNativeAmerican‐ownedbusinesses(disparityindexof200+).
![Page 89: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/89.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 7, PAGE 9
Figure 7‐5. Disparity indices for DEN and non‐DEN contracts
Note:
Numbers rounded to nearest whole number.
For more detail, see Figures F‐12 and F‐13 in Appendix F.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting disparity analysis.
Industry.BBCexamineddisparityanalysisresultsseparatelyfortheCity’sconstruction;professionalservices;andgoodsandservicescontracts.Theprojectteamcombinedresultsforgoodsandservicescontracts,becausetheCityusessimilarprocurementprocessestoawardthosecontracts.Figure7‐6presentsdisparityindicesforallrelevantgroupsbycontractingarea.Disparityanalysesresultsdifferedbycontractingareaandgroup:
Minority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesconsideredtogethershowedadisparityonconstructioncontracts(disparityindexof80).Threeindividualgroupsshowedsubstantialdisparities:non‐Hispanicwhitewoman‐ownedbusinesses(disparityindexof45),AsianAmerican‐ownedbusinesses(disparityindexof36),andBlackAmerican‐ownedbusinesses(disparityindexof37).
Minority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesconsideredtogethershowedasubstantialdisparityonprofessionalservicescontracts(disparityindexof48).Allindividualgroupsshowedsubstantialdisparitiesonthosecontracts.
Minority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesconsideredtogethershowedasubstantialdisparityongoodsandservicescontracts(disparityindexof40).AllindividualgroupsshowedsubstantialdisparitiesexceptforNativeAmerican‐ownedbusinesses(disparityindexof105).
![Page 90: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/90.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 7, PAGE 10
Figure 7‐6. Disparity analysis results by relevant industry
Note: Numbers rounded to nearest whole number.
For more detail, see Figures F‐5, F‐6, and F‐7 in Appendix F.
Source: BBC Research & Consulting disparity analysis.
Time period.BBCalsoexamineddisparityanalysisresultsseparatelyfortwoseparatetimeperiods:January1,2012throughJune30,2014(earlystudyperiod)andJuly1,2014throughDecember31,2016(latestudyperiod).ThatinformationmighthelptheCitydeterminewhetherthereweredifferentoutcomesforminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesasthecountrymovedfurtherandfurtherfromtheeconomicdownturnthatbeganin2008.Figure7‐7presentsdisparityindicesforallrelevantracial/ethnicandgendergroupsseparatelyfortheearlyandlatestudyperiods.AsshowninFigure7‐7,minority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesshowedsubstantialdisparitiesforintheearlystudyperiod(disparityindexof56)andinthelatestudyperiod(disparityindexof69).Resultsforindividualgroupsindicatedthat:
Threegroupsexhibitedsubstantialdisparitiesintheearlystudyperiod:non‐Hispanicwhitewoman‐ownedbusinesses(disparityindexof39),AsianAmerican‐ownedbusinesses(disparityindexof22),andBlackAmerican‐ownedbusinesses(disparityindexof60).
Thosesamethreegroupsshowedsubstantialdisparitiesforlatestudyperiodcontracts.
![Page 91: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/91.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 7, PAGE 11
Figure 7‐7. Disparity indices for early and late study period
Note:
Numbers rounded to nearest whole number.
For more detail, see Figures F‐3 and F‐4 in Appendix F.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting disparity analysis.
C. Statistical Significance
Statisticalsignificancetestsallowresearcherstotestthedegreetowhichtheycanrejectrandomchanceasanexplanationforanyobservedquantitativedifferences.Inotherwords,astatisticallysignificantdifferenceisonethatonecanconsidertobereliableorreal.BBCusedananalysisthatreliesonrepeated,randomsimulationstoexaminethestatisticalsignificanceofdisparityanalysisresults.ThatapproachisreferredtoasaMonteCarloanalysis.Figure7‐8describeshowthestudyteamusedMonteCarlototestthestatisticalsignificanceofdisparityanalysisresults.
Results.BBCusedMonteCarloanalysistotestwhetherthedisparitiesthatthestudyteamobservedonallcontractsconsideredtogetherandno‐goalscontractswerestatisticallysignificant.BBCidentifiedsubstantialdisparitiesforminority‐ownedbusinessesandwoman‐ownedbusinessesconsideredtogetherandforcertainracial/ethnicandgendergroupsconsideredseparatelyonthosecontractsets.Examiningwhetherdisparitiesarestatisticallysignificantisparticularlyinstructiveforno‐goalscontractsandprimecontracts,becausetheyprovideinformationaboutoutcomesforminority‐ownedbusinessesandwoman‐ownedbusinessesintheabsenceoftheCity’suseofrace‐consciousandgender‐consciousmeasures.Figure7‐9presentsresultsfromtheMonteCarloanalysisastheyrelatetothestatisticalsignificanceofdisparitiesthatthestudyteamobservedforminority‐ownedandwoman‐ownedbusinessesconsideredtogetherandseparatelyforeachrelevantracial/ethnicandgendergrouponallcontractsconsideredtogetherandno‐goalscontracts.
![Page 92: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/92.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 7, PAGE 12
Figure 7‐8. Monte Carlo Analysis
BBC used a Monte Carlo approach to randomly select businesses to win each individual contract element that the study team included in its analyses. For each contract element, BBC’s availability database provided information on individual businesses that are available for that contract element based on type of work, contractor role, and contract size. BBC assumed that each available business had an equal chance of winning the contract element, so the odds of a business from a certain group winning it were equal to the number of businesses from that group available for it divided by the total number of businesses available for it. The Monte Carlo simulation then randomly chose a business from the pool of available businesses to win the contract element.
The Monte Carlo simulation repeated the above process for all contract elements in a particular contract set. The output of a single Monte Carlo simulation for all contract elements in the set represented the simulated participation of minority‐ and woman‐owned businesses for that set of contract elements. The entire Monte Carlo simulation was then repeated 1 million times for each contract set. The combined output from all 1 million simulations represented a probability distribution of the overall participation of minority‐ and woman‐owned businesses if contracts were awarded randomly based only on the availability of relevant businesses working in the local marketplace.
The output of the Monte Carlo simulations represents the number of simulations out of 1 million that produced simulated participation that was equal or below the actual observed participation for each racial/ethnic and gender group and for each set of contracts. If that number was less than or equal to 25,000 (i.e., 2.5% of the total number of simulations), then BBC considered the corresponding disparity index to be statistically significant at the 95 percent confidence level. If that number was less than or equal to 50,000 (i.e., 5.0% of the total number of simulations), then BBC considered that disparity index to be statistically significant at the 90 percent confidence level.
Figure 7‐9. Monte Carlo simulation results for disparity analysis results
Source: BBC Research & Consulting disparity analysis.
Contract set and business group
All contracts
Minority‐owned and woman‐owned 63 0 <0.1 %
Non‐Hispanic white woman‐owned 48 45 <0.1 %
Minority‐owned 75 0 <0.1 %
Asian American‐owned 38 0 <0.1 %
Black American‐owned 48 0 <0.1 %
Hispanic American‐owned 102 N/A N/A
Native American‐owned 200+ N/A N/A
No‐goals contracts
Minority‐owned and woman‐owned 35 0 <0.1 %
Non‐Hispanic white woman‐owned 33 45 <0.1 %
Minority‐owned 36 0 <0.1 %
Asian American‐owned 31 0 <0.1 %
Black American‐owned 36 0 <0.1 %
Hispanic American‐owned 35 0 <0.1 %
Native American‐owned 200+ N/A N/A
Probability of observed
disparity occurring due
to "chance"
Disparity
index
Number of simulation runs out
of one million that replicated
observed utilization
![Page 93: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/93.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 7, PAGE 13
D. Bid/Proposal Processes
BBCcompletedacasestudyanalysistoassesswhethercharacteristicsoftheCity’sbidandproposalprocesseshelpexplainthedisparitiesthatthestudyteamobservedforprimecontracts.BBCanalyzedbidandproposalinformationforasampleofthecontractsthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiod.
DEN.BBCexaminedbidinformationforasampleof84contractsthatDENawardedduringthestudyperiod.Intotal,DENreceived337bidsforthosecontracts.
Number of bids from minority‐ and woman‐owned businesses.Minority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessessubmitted74ofthe337bids(22%)thatthestudyteamexamined:
Fifty‐fourbids(16%ofallbids)camefromminority‐ownedbusinesses(36differentbusinesses);and
Twentybids(6%ofallbids)camefromnon‐Hispanicwhitewoman‐ownedbusinesses(19differentbusinesses).
Success of bids.BBCexaminedthepercentageofbidsthatminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessessubmittedthatresultedinawards.AsshowninFigure7‐10,19percentofthebidsthatminority‐ownedbusinessessubmittedresultedincontractawardsand20percentofthebidsthatnon‐Hispanicwhitewoman‐ownedbusinessessubmittedresultedincontractawards.
Figure 7‐10. Percentage of bids on DEN contracts that resulted in contract awards
Note:
Based on analysis of 337 bids on 84 construction contracts.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting from entity contracting data.
Department of Public Works (Public Works).BBCexaminedproposalinformationforasampleof51PublicWorkscontractsthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiod.Intotal,PublicWorksreceived168proposalsforthosecontracts.
Number of proposals from minority‐ and woman‐owned businesses.Minority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessessubmitted39ofthe168proposals(23%)thatthestudyteamexamined:
Thirty‐sixproposals(21%ofallproposals)camefromminority‐ownedbusinesses(11differentbusinesses);and
Threeproposals(2%ofallproposals)camefromanon‐Hispanicwhitewoman‐ownedbusiness(onebusiness).
Success of bids.BBCalsoexaminedthepercentageofproposalsthatminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessessubmittedthatresultedincontractawards.AsshowninFigure7‐11,31percentoftheproposalsthatminority‐ownedbusinessessubmittedresultedincontractawards,
![Page 94: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/94.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 7, PAGE 14
Oftheproposalsthatnon‐Hispanicwhitewoman‐ownedbusinessessubmitted,33percentresultedincontractawards.
Figure 7‐11. Percentage of bids on Public Works contracts that resulted in contract awards
Note:
Based on analysis of 168 bids on 51 professional service contracts.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting from entity contracting data.
General Services.BBCexaminedbidinformationforasampleof160GeneralServicescontractsthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiod.Intotal,theCityreceived828bidsforthosecontracts.
Number of bids from minority‐ and woman‐owned businesses.Minority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessessubmitted168ofthe828bids(20%)thatthestudyteamexamined:
Eightbids(1%ofallbids)camefromminority‐ownedbusinesses(fourbusinesses);and
One‐hundred‐sixtybids(19%ofallbids)camefromnon‐Hispanicwhitewoman‐ownedbusinesses(fourteenbusinesses).
Success of bids.BBCalsoexaminedthepercentageofbidsthatminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessessubmittedthatresultedincontractawards.AsshowninFigure7‐12,63percentoftheproposalsthatminority‐ownedbusinessessubmittedresultedincontractawards.Oftheproposalsthatnon‐Hispanicwhitewoman‐ownedbusinessessubmitted,28percentresultedincontractawards.
Figure 7‐12. Percentage of bids on goods and other service contracts that resulted in contract awards
Note:
Based on analysis of 828 bids on 160 goods and other services contracts.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting from entity contracting data.
![Page 95: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/95.jpg)
CHAPTER 8.
Program Measures
![Page 96: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/96.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 8, PAGE 1
CHAPTER 8. Program Measures
TheCityandCountyofDenver(theCity)usesacombinationofrace‐andgender‐neutralandrace‐andgender‐consciousmeasurestoencouragetheparticipationofsmallbusinesses,minority‐ownedbusinesses,andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinitscontracting.1Race‐andgender‐neutralmeasuresaremeasuresthataredesignedtoencouragetheparticipationofallbusinesses—or,allsmallbusinesses—inanorganization’scontracting.Participationinsuchmeasuresisnotlimitedtominority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesses.Incontrast,race‐andgender‐consciousmeasuresaremeasuresthataredesignedtospecificallyencouragetheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinanorganization’scontracting(e.g.,usingminority‐ownedbusinesssubcontractinggoalsonindividualcontracts).
Aspartofmeetingthenarrowtailoringrequirementofthestrictscrutinystandardofconstitutionalreview,organizationsthatimplementminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessprogramsmustmaximizetheuseofrace‐andgender‐neutralmeasuresintryingtoencouragetheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesses(fordetails,seeChapter2andAppendixB).Ifanagencycannotsufficientlyaddressbarriersthatminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesfaceinitscontractingthroughtheuseofrace‐neutralandgender‐neutralmeasuresalone,thenitcanalsoconsiderusingrace‐andgender‐consciousmeasures.
BBCResearch&Consulting(BBC)reviewedmeasuresthattheCitycurrentlyusestoencouragetheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinitscontracting.Inaddition,BBCreviewedrace‐andgender‐neutralmeasuresthatotherorganizationsintheregionuse.Thatinformationisinstructive,becauseitallowsanassessmentofthemeasuresthattheCityiscurrentlyusingandanassessmentofadditionalmeasuresthattheorganizationcouldconsiderusinginthefuture.BBCreviewstheCity’sprogrammeasuresinfourparts:
A. Programoverview;
B. Race‐andgender‐neutralmeasures;
C. Race‐andgender‐consciousmeasures;and
D. Otherorganizations’programmeasures.
A. Program Overview
TheCity’sOfficeofEconomicDevelopment(OED)DivisionofSmallBusinessOpportunities(DSBO)operatestheCity’sMinority‐andWomen‐OwnedBusinessEnterprise(MWBE),EmergingBusinessEnterprise(EBE),andSmallBusinessEnterprise(SBE)Programstoencouragetheparticipationofsmallbusinessesminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinCitycontracting.AspartoftheMWBEProgram,DSBOalsoestablishesaspirationalannualgoalsfor
1“Woman‐ownedbusinesses”referstonon‐Hispanicwhitewomanownedbusinesses.
![Page 97: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/97.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 8, PAGE 2
theparticipationofthosebusinessesinconstruction;professionalservices;andgoodsandgeneralservicescontractsandusesacombinationofrace‐andgender‐neutralandrace‐andgender‐consciousmeasurestomeetthosegoalseachyear.TheCitycertifiesbusinessesasminority‐ownedbusinessenterprises(MBEs),woman‐ownedbusinessenterprises(WBEs),smallbusinessenterprises(SBEs),oremergingbusinessenterprises(EBEs),asappropriate,tohelpmeettheobjectivesoftheprogram.DSBO’sresponsibilitiesalsoinclude:
MonitoringtheparticipationofMBEs,WBEs,SBEs,andEBEsinCitycontracts;
ProvidingguidancerelatedtosettingaspirationalMBE,WBE,SBE,andEBEgoalsandcontract‐specificgoalstoallCitydepartments;
ProvidinginformationandassistancetoMBEs,WBEs,SBEs,EBEs,andotherbusinessesrelatingtocitycontractingpoliciesaswellasbidspecificationsandrequirements;
Receiving,reviewing,andactingoncomplaintsandsuggestionsconcerningvariousCitybusinessprograms;and
DevelopingtechnicalassistanceprogramstoassistMBEs,WBEs,SBEs,EBEs,andotherbusinessesrelatingtocontractingaswellasbusinessandprofessionaldevelopment.
B. Race‐ and Gender‐Neutral Measures
TheCityusesmyriadrace‐andgender‐neutralmeasuresaspartoftheMWBE,EBE,andSBEProgramstoencouragetheparticipationofsmallbusinesses—includingmanyminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesses—initscontracting.TheCityusesthefollowingtypesofrace‐andgender‐neutralmeasures:
SBEandEBEcertification;
Advocacyandoutreach;
Businessdevelopment;
Educationandtraining;and
Financialassistance.
SBE and EBE certification. DSBOcertifiessmallbusinessesasSBEsandEBEs.TheprimarydifferencebetweenSBEandEBEcertificationisthatEBEcertificationisreservedforsmallbusinesseswhoseannualrevenuesarelessthan$3million,whereasSBEcertificationisavailabletosmallbusinesseswhoseannualrevenuesareinlinewithSmallBusinessAdministrationrevenuethresholds,whichcanfarexceed$3milliondependingonindustry.Inadditiontorevenuerequirements,businessesmustpossessthefollowingcharacteristicstoqualifyforSBEandEBEcertification:
Businessesmustbeactivelyinbusinessforatleastsixmonths.
Themajorityofbusinessownersmusthavepersonalnetworthoflessthan$1.32million(excludingequityinprimaryresidenceandownershipinapplicantbusinesses).
Businessesmustperformworkinconstruction;professionalservices;orgoodsandservices.
![Page 98: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/98.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 8, PAGE 3
BenefitsofSBEcertificationincludebusinessesbeinglistingintheCity’scertifiedvendordatabase;increasedvisibilityandnotificationofCitycontractingandsubcontractingopportunities;freenetworkingeventsforsmallbusinessowners;andpotentialaccesstoworkingcapitalloansfromtheCity.Inaddition,theCityhasestablishedtheDefinedSelectionPoolProgram,whichlimitscompetitiononcertainconstructionandgoodsandservicescontractstocertifiedSBEs.Similarly,theCitylimitscompetitiononcertainconstructionandprofessionalservicescontractstocertifiedEBEs.
Advocacy and outreach.TheCityparticipatesinvariousadvocacyandoutreacheffortsaspartoftheMWBE,EBE,andSBEPrograms.
Construction Empowerment Initiative (CEI). CEIwasestablishedin2006asanadvisorypanelconsistingofcommunityandbusinessmembers.ThepurposeofCEIistoworkwiththeCitytohelpensurethatconstructionanddesigncontractopportunitieswiththeCityaremadeavailabletolocalsmallbusinessesandminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesses.CEImeetswiththeCityonamonthlybasistoprovidepolicyandprocedurerecommendations.ThegroupisalsointegrallyinvolvedwiththedevelopmentandrefinementoftheCity’sMWBEOrdinance.
Newsletter to certified firms. DSBOpublishesamonthlynewsletterthatprovidesinformationrelatedtoDSBOactivities,Cityprojects,andupcomingoutreachevents.ThenewsletterisdisseminatedtoallMBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedbusinesses.
General Services Business Opportunity Fair. TheDepartmentofGeneralServicesorganizesandhostsanannualbusinessoutreachevent.BusinessescanlearnabouthowbesttoworkwithGeneralServices,includinghowtosubmitinvoices,howtomeetprevailingwagerequirements,andhowtofindorapplyforloansavailabletolocalsmallbusinesses.Animportantcomponentoftheeventisanopenquestion‐and‐answersessionduringwhichDenverbusinessescanaskquestionsofGeneralServices’staff.GeneralServiceshaspreviouslyinvitedotherCitydepartmentstoparticipateintheeventaswell.
Mega project outreach. DSBOpartnerswithlocalagenciesandotherCitydepartmentstoprovideoutreachrelatedtotheCity’smegaprojects.Attheoutreachevents,DSBOdiscussesanyMWBEgoalsforthecontract,DSBOrequirementsfortheproject,andcertificationprocesses.
Outreach event participation.DSBOandotherCitydepartments,includingGeneralServices,participateinoutreacheventswiththeColoradoDepartmentofTransportation,theRegionalTransportationDistrict–Denver,andtheDenverHealthandHospitalAuthority.Citystaffalsoregularlyattendmeetingssponsoredbylocalorganizationsrepresentingminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesandshareinformationregardingcontractingopportunitieswiththeCity.Suchorganizationsinclude:
CEI;
TheHispanicContractorsofColorado;
TheOpportunityCouncil;
ConstructionBlackChamberofCommerce;
AsianChamberofCommerce;
![Page 99: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/99.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 8, PAGE 4
WomenChamberofCommerce;
RockyMountainChamberofCommerce;and
TheBlackBusinessInitiative.
Department websites.OED’swebsiteprovidesinformationaboutcertificationprocesses;acertifiedfirmdirectory;complianceinformation;informationaboutcontractingopportunities;policiesandforms;businessresources;andinformationaboutupcomingeventsandnews.GeneralServices’websitelistscurrentandupcomingcontractingsolicitations.Anyupdatesoncontractingopportunitiesaree‐maileddirectlytothemorethan350businessesthathaveregisteredtoreceiveinformationfromtheCity.ThoseupdatesarealsosharedontheCity’sLinkedInpageandtheCity’swebsite.
Business development programs.AbenefitofMBE,WBE,SBE,andEBEcertificationisthatcertifiedbusinesseshaveaccesstotheCity’sbusinessdevelopmentopportunities.
Capacity building outreach. DSBOprovidesassistanceandresourcestosmallbusinessestohelpbuildtheircapacity.Onceamonth,businessescanattendafreecapacity‐buildingadvisoryeventthattheCityhosts.Businessescanaccessone‐on‐oneadvisorysessionsandworkshopsontheresourcesavailablefromvariouspublicandnon‐profitorganizations.Inadditiontotheadvisoryevents,DSBOhascreatedtheDefinedSelectionPoolProgramtooffersmallbusinessesprimecontractingopportunitieswiththeCity.
One‐on‐one business meetings.Businesseshavetheopportunitytomeetone‐on‐onewithrepresentativesfromGeneralServicessothatGeneralServicescanlearnmoreaboutindividualbusinesses,providetailoredadvicetobusinessesabouthowtheycanbemorecompetitiveonCitycontractingopportunities,andinvitebusinessestoaskquestionsaboutspecificcontractingopportunities.
Mentor‐Protégé Program.In2015,DSBOdevelopedaMentor‐ProtégéProgramtobuildeffectiveworkingrelationshipsbetweenleadersofmature,establishedbusinessesandemergingminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesses.Theobjectiveoftheprogramisforminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessestobenefitfromtheknowledge,experience,andsocialcapitalofmoreestablishedbusinessesandtobuildcapacityamongminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesseswithintheconstructionandprofessionalservicesindustries.MentorsprovidecoachingonwaysforprotégéstocompetemoresuccessfullyonCitycontracts,includingcoachingonpubliccontractapplicationsandcontractperformanceaswellasawidearrayofotherbusiness‐managementtopics,fromstrategicplanningtofinancialmanagementandmarketing.
Education and training.DSBOandotherCitydepartmentsprovidetrainingandeducationtobusinesseswhoareinterestedinbecomingcertifiedordoingworkwiththeCity.
Business certification training sessions.DSBOprovidesfree,two‐hourtrainingsessionseverymonthonhowbusinessescanbecomecertifiedasMBEs,WBEs,SBEs,andEBEs.Thetrainingsessionsincludeanoverviewofdifferentcertificationprograms,theCEIOrdinance,andawalk‐throughoftheUnifiedCertificationProcess(UCP)Application.
![Page 100: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/100.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 8, PAGE 5
5 Steps for Doing Business with the City.GeneralServiceshasdevelopedthe5StepsforDoingBusinesswiththeCitytrainingtoeducatebusinessesonhowtheCityprocuresconstructionservices;professionalservices;andgoodsandservices.Thetwo‐hourtrainingisofferedmonthlyattheCity’sofficesandotherlocationsaroundDenver.
Financial assistance.OED'sBusinessDevelopmentteamhascreatedtheRevolvingLoanfund,whichoffersgapfinancingforestablishedbusinessesthatrelocateorexpandintocertainindustrialorcommercialbusinessareaswithinDenver.Theprogramworksbylendingupto25percentofprojectcostsandencouragingbankstoprovidethebulkoftheremainingfinancing.TheprogramalsoassistsbusinessesthatrelocatetoDenverwithpermitting.
C. Race‐ and Gender‐Conscious Measures
TheCitycurrentlyusesSBE,MBE,WBE,andDisadvantagedBusinessEnterprise(DBE)contractgoalstoawardmanyofitscontracts.2Contractinggoalsforeachcontractareestablishedaccordingtocontractsize;worktypesinvolved;potentialsubcontractingopportunities;theavailabilityofSBEs,MBEs,andWBEsforthecontract;andSBE,MBE,andWBEparticipationonsimilarprojectsthattheCityhasawardedinthepast.Primecontractorscanmeetcontractinggoalsbyeitherself‐performingtheworkiftheyarecertifiedasSBEs,MBEs,orWBEsorbymakingsubcontractingcommitmentswithcertifiedSBE,MBE,orWBEsubcontractorsatthetimeofbid.IftheprimecontractorcannotsuccessfullymakesubcontractingcommitmentswithcertifiedSBEs,MBEs,orWBEs,thentheymustdocumentsufficientGoodFaithEfforts(GFEs)towardachievingtheestablishedcontractinggoals.DSBOthenreviewsGFEdocumentationtodetermineiftheprimecontractor’seffortsweresufficient.
Toadviseongoal‐settingforspecificcontracts,theCityhasestablishedagoalcommitteecomprisingindividualswhoareengagedinthelocalconstruction;reconstructionandremodeling;andarchitecturalandengineeringindustries.TheOEDDirectormayusethegoalcommittee’sadviceongoal‐settingaswellasotherrelevantinformation.
D. Other Organizations’ Program Measures
Inadditiontotherace‐andgender‐neutralmeasuresthattheCitycurrentlyuses,thereareanumberofrace‐andgender‐neutralprogrammeasuresthatotherorganizationsinDenverusetoencouragetheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesingovernmentcontracts.Figure8‐1providesexamplesofthosemeasures.
2SBEcontractgoalsarenotconsideredtoberace‐orgender‐consciousmeasures.
![Page 101: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/101.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 8, PAGE 6
Figure 8‐1. Examples of race‐ and gender‐neutral program measures that other organizations in Denver use
Type Program
The Denver Minority Business Development Agency facilitates greater access to the goods and
services of minority‐owned businesses for diverse corporate and government organizations,
fostering the development of lasting and mutually beneficial business relationships. Core business
services include global business development, access to capital, access to contracts, access to
markets, and strategic business consulting.
The Minority Business Office Colorado is located within the Colorado Office of Economic
Development and International Trade and dedicated to advancing the efforts of Colorado's minority‐
and woman‐owned businesses. The office features an established network of public, private, and
government resources that can be leveraged by businesses of all types and sizes. It also provides
information and counseling on certifications available for minority‐ and woman‐owned businesses.
Asian Chamber of Commerce ‐ Colorado (ACC) is a membership organization whose mission is to
provide economic development and business opportunities for its members. The ACC partners with
community organizations and non‐profits to help promote and cross‐resource programs and
initiatives; connects with member business units to help support their diversity and inclusion
efforts; represents its community and region with local and state government; participates in
delegations to help foster international trade; and provides networking, marketing, and
promotional opportunities for its members.
The Colorado Unified Certification Program was established to facilitate statewide DBE certification
and eliminate the need for DBE applicants to obtain certification from multiple agencies.
Black Business Initiative is an economic revitalization program for the Black community and by the
Black community with a mission to grow Black owned businesses through education, mentorship,
investment, community, and need.
The vision of the Colorado Black Chamber of Commerce (CBCC) is to serve the needs of Black
American‐owned businesses and provide economic opportunity and support to them and the
communities they serve. The CBCC's mission is to support the initiatives of Black American business
owners and foster an enterprise that focuses on success and viability. CBCC provides access to
education and training that keeps Black American business owners in step with the ever‐changing
requirements of Colorado’s economic playing field.
The Hispanic Contractors of Colorado's mission is helping small, diverse contractors learn how to do
business with public organizations and large corporations.
The Hispanic Chamber of Commerce of Metro Denver is a membership driven organization that
comprises small‐business owners, corporate representatives, community leaders, and association
members representing various professions. The chamber supports the development and growth of
member businesses through initiatives that encourage and promote business and economic
development. In addition, it is a strong advocate of legislation affecting small businesses. The
chamber also provides access to valuable information, business leaders, procurement
opportunities, and education training. Not only does the chamber give small businesses viability in
the business community, it gives them a voice, unity and strength.
Mi Casa Women's Business Center is a women's business center partially funded by the United
States Small Business Administration and is a member of the Association of Women's Business
Centers. The center offers entrepreneurial training, individual business counseling, technology
training, and networking opportunities to help aspiring entrepreneurs and emerging businesses
achieve their goals.
The Denver Water Supplier Diversity Program seeks to provide small businesses and businesses
owned by minorities and women an opportunity to work for Denver Water as prime contractors,
subcontractors, and suppliers. It includes an outreach database to help Denver Water staff identify
small, minority‐ and woman‐owned businesses that are available for Denver Water work.
The Denver Public Schools Office of Business Diversity is a program to help promote diversity in
construction and related contracting for various bond‐funded capital improvement projects.
Advocacy and
Outreach
![Page 102: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/102.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 8, PAGE 7
Figure 8‐1. (continued) Examples of race‐ and gender‐neutral program measures that other organizations in Denver use
Type Program
Spanning long‐term financial planning, the Small Business Administration's CDC/504 Programs
provide a platform for the development of the community as a whole. The loans sanctioned under
the program provides small businesses with fixed‐rate financing, which are then used to acquire
assets which are mainly aimed at modernization, such as commercial mortgages and street‐
improvement utilities.
The SBA Microloan Program provides small, short‐term loans that can be used for:
• Purchasing supplies or inventory
• Purchasing machinery
• Purchase of furniture
The Microloan fund cannot be used for the purchase of real estate or for paying off existing debts.
The maximum Microloan amount is $50,000.
Businesses with special requirements (such as those in exports or operating in rural areas) are
covered under the SBA 7(a) Loan Programs. The program is considered to be the most flexible
choice and also the most suitable for emerging businesses. The different 7(a) loan programs are:
• Special Purpose Loans, which offer loans to businesses which have been affected by NAFTA to
assist Employee Stock Ownership plans and other initiatives.
• Export Loan Programs, which offer loans to further expand export activities.
• Rural Business Loans, which are aimed at providing a simpler and more streamlined process to
acquire loans for businesses operating in the rural areas.
The Colorado Microfinance Alliance is a consortium of microfinance practitioners, donors,
educators, students, and professionals that facilitates learning opportunities for the public,
microfinance practitioners, and their clients. The website offers information about the Alliance's
partner organizations; a central calendar of microfinance‐related activities in Colorado; and
collaborative tools designed for networking and practical use.
The Denver Capital Matrix is a resource directory of funding sources for Denver small businesses
and entrepreneurs. The matrix identifies funding sources to include traditional bank lending,
venture capital firms, private equity firms, angel investors, mezzanine sources, and others that have
funded Colorado businesses and provides contact information and categorizes the investment focus
of each listed organization.
Colorado Lending Source is a free membership‐based organization made up of lenders, small
businesses, community organizations, and government groups.
The Community Economic Development Company of Colorado is a SBA‐certified non‐profit which
provides loans under the 504 program. Loans are provided below market rates, have long‐term
financing, and a low down payment on office, commercial, and industrial assets located in Colorado.
The Colorado Enterprise Fund is a non‐profit lending source which specializes in loans for small
businesses and startups unable to secure traditional bank financing.
The Rocky Mountain Microfinance Institute creates economic and social mobility through
entrepreneurship support. It has a Business Builder loan program to provide microloans to
entrepreneurs in need of financing to launch or expand their businesses.
The Colorado Housing and Finance Authority (CHFA) Business Lending Program's Community
Development team partners with lenders and economic developers to provide small businesses
with the financing needed for future growth. It offers the following programs:
• Loan programs to help businesses finance owner‐occupied commercial real estate acquisition,
renovations, and equipment purchases.
• Tax exempt bonds to help manufacturing businesses and nonprofits take advantage of low
interest financing available for real estate.
• Cash Collateral Support program to acquire additional collateral to secure financing and connect
with lenders actively serving small business customers.
• New markets tax credits to encourage private investment in underserved communities.
Capital,
Bonding, and
Insurance
![Page 103: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/103.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 8, PAGE 8
Figure 8‐1. (continued) Examples of race‐ and gender‐neutral program measures that other organizations in Denver use
Type Program
The Metro Denver Urban Economic Development Corporation (EDC) is an affiliate of the Denver
Metro Chamber of Commerce whose mission is to enhance the regional economy through the
expansion and retention of primary jobs and capital investment. The EDC provides extensive
services to help site selectors and companies with location, expansion, and market decisions. The
EDC has a property database for business site selection; provides proprietary market research and
analysis; and assists with advocacy, access, and community involvement.
The CDOT Emerging Small Business Program provides specific small business programs authorized
by the Colorado legislature to promote competition for CDOT construction, professional service,
and research contracts. The Connect2DOT Program is a partnership between CDOT and the Colorado Small Business
Development Center Network designed to help small businesses in the transportation industry
become more competitive and successful in bidding and contracting with CDOT and other local
transportation agencies. The program offers free consulting and business training as well as online
resources and events tailored to construction contractors and professional design, architecture, and
engineering businesses.
The Colorado Small Business Development Center (SBDC) Network is dedicated to helping existing
and new businesses grow and prosper in Colorado by providing free and confidential consulting and
no‐ or low‐cost training programs. The SBDC combines information and resources from federal,
state, and local governments with those of the education system and private sector to meet the
specialized and complex needs of the small business community.
The Colorado Procurement Technical Assistance Center (PTAC) helps small businesses grow with
federal, state, and local government contracts. The core of the procurement assistance program is
counseling and education, with support in the following areas:
• Determining Suitability for Government Contracting
• Securing Necessary Registrations
• Identifying Bid Opportunities
• Teaming or Joint Venture Arrangements
• SDB, 8(a), HUBzone, CDOT and other certifications
• Proposal Techniques and Review
• Reviewing Contract Terms & Conditions
• Government Contract Performance Issues
• Networking & Business Development
• Preparing for Audit
The SBA ‐ Colorado District Office has small business loan and assistance programs; special outreach
efforts; and initiatives to aid and inform small businesses. Services include:
• Financial assistance for businesses through guaranteed loans made by area lenders
• Free counseling, advice, and information on starting, better operating, or expanding small
businesses through Counselors to America’s Small Business.
• Business training and counseling through the SBDC
• Assistance to socially and economically disadvantaged businesses through the 8(a) Business
Development Program
• Advice to women business owners
• Special loan programs for businesses involved in international trade
Rocky Mountain E‐Purchasing System (BidNet) is where all participating local government
purchasing departments invite interested vendors to register for exclusive access to RFPs and
information on bids and awards. Registered vendors benefit from more bid information in a central
location, less paperwork, and an easier method of doing business with local governments.
SCORE Denver is a non‐profit resource partner of the SBA that offers one‐on‐one counseling; cost
effective seminars and workshops; and for existing businesses, business "checkups." SCORE
Denver's mentors will customize one‐on‐one confidential mentoring for anyone planning to start a
business and to those already in business who are looking to improve their performance. SCORE's
workshops include a broad range of topics for small business owners and aspiring entrepreneurs.
SCORE also offers a free resource library which features a wide variety of documents and templates
to assist in starting or growing a business.
Technical
Assistance
![Page 104: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/104.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 8, PAGE 9
Figure 8‐1. (continued) Examples of race‐ and gender‐neutral program measures that other organizations in Denver use
Type Program
Mentor‐
Protégé
The Colorado Department of Transportation's (CDOT's) Emerging Small Business Mentor‐Protégé
program provides opportunities for emerging small businesses to hone their business skills by
working closely with established businesses in highway construction and professional services.
CDOT does not match mentors and protégés. Businesses are responsible for identifying and forming
a team and applying to CDOT for formal approval.
Approved mentor‐protégé teams must identify the goals of their relationships and create a plan to
achieve the identified goals. Mentor‐protégé teams will be responsible for managing and tracking
progress against the plan by providing quarterly update surveys to CDOT via Survey Monkey. As
described in the 'Incentives' page linked below, mentor‐protégé teams may receive various benefits
and incentives for participating in the program.
A maximum of six teams are selected each year for the program. A mentor‐protégé team will be
monitored for one calendar year but may continue longer.
![Page 105: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/105.jpg)
CHAPTER 9.
Program Implementation
![Page 106: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/106.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 9, PAGE 1
CHAPTER 9. Program Implementation
TheCityandCountyofDenver(theCity)operatestheMinority‐andWomen‐ownedBusinessEnterprise(MWBE),EmergingBusinessEnterprise(EBE),andSmallBusinessEnterprise(SBE)Programstoencouragetheparticipationofsmallbusinessesandminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinitslocally‐fundedcontractsandimplementstheFederalDisadvantagedBusinessEnterprise(DBE)Programtoencouragetheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinFederalAviationAdministration(FAA)‐fundedcontractsthattheDenverInternationalAirport(DEN)awards.The2018CityofDenverDisparityStudyprovidesinformationthattheCityshouldconsiderinrefiningitsimplementationofbothprograms.
Aspirational MWBE and DBE Goals
TheCityestablishesaspirationalannualgoalsfortheparticipationofcertifiedminority‐ownedbusinessenterprises(MBEs)andwoman‐ownedbusinessenterprises(WBEs)aspartoftheMWBEProgramandfortheparticipationofcertifiedDBEsaspartofitsimplementationoftheFederalDBEProgram.TheCityusesmyriadrace‐andgender‐neutralmeasuresaswellasrace‐andgender‐consciousmeasurestoencouragetheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinitscontractsinanefforttomeetthosegoals.Resultsfromthedisparitystudy—particularlytheavailabilityanalysisandanalysesofmarketplaceconditions—canbehelpfultotheCityinsettingitsnextaspirationalMWBEandDBEgoals.
Aspirational MWBE goals.TheCitysetsaspirationalannualMWBEgoalsseparatelyforitslocally‐fundedconstruction;professionalservices;andgoodsandservicescontractsandprocurements.Currently,theCityhassetthosegoalsat24percentforconstruction,33percentforprofessionalservices,and8percentforgoodsandservices.InformationfromtheavailabilityanalysisprovidedinformationthattheCitycanuseasabasisforitsaspirationalMWBEgoals.Forthepurposesofaspirationalgoal‐setting,BBCResearch&Consulting(BBC)calculatedtheavailabilityofpotentialMWBEs—minority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesthatarecurrentlyMWBE‐certifiedorappearthattheycouldbeMWBE‐certifiedbasedonrevenuerequirementssetforthintheCity’sMWBEProgram—forlocally‐fundedprimecontractsandsubcontractsthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiod.
Figure9‐1presentstheavailabilityofpotentialMWBEsforthelocally‐fundedconstruction;professionalservices;andgoodsandgeneralservicesprimecontractsandsubcontractsthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiod.AsshowninFigure9‐1,potentialMWBEsmightbeexpectedtoreceive20.5percentoftheCity’slocally‐fundedcontractingdollarsbasedontheiravailabilityforthatwork.TheavailabilityofpotentialMWBEsis16.5percentforlocally‐fundedconstructioncontracts;39.5percentforlocally‐fundedprofessionalservicescontracts;and19.8percentforlocally‐fundedgoodsandgeneralservicescontracts.TheCityshouldconsiderthatinformationasitsetsitsnextaspirationalMWBEgoalsforitslocally‐fundedcontracts.
![Page 107: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/107.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 9, PAGE 2
Figure 9‐1. Availability of potential MWBEs for locally‐funded contracts
Note: Numbers rounded to nearest tenth of 1 percent and thus may not sum exactly to totals.
Total availability represents a dollar‐weighted aggregation of the availability percentages associated with each relevant industry based on the actual locally‐funded dollars that the City spent in each industry during the study period.
For details, see Figures F‐19, F‐20, F‐21, and F‐22 in Appendix F.
Source: BBC Research & Consulting availability analysis.
Overall DBE goal.TheCityalsosetsanoverallannualDBEgoalfortheFAA‐fundedcontractsthatDENawards.Currently,theCityhassetthatgoalat14.04percent.ForthepurposesofhelpingtheCitydetermineabasisforitsoverallDBEgoal,BBCcalculatedtheavailabilityofpotentialDBEs—minority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesthatarecurrentlyDBE‐certifiedorappearthattheycouldbeDBE‐certifiedbasedonrevenuerequirementssetforthin49CodeofFederalRegulationsPart26.65—forFAA‐fundedprimecontractsandsubcontractsthatDENawardedduringthestudyperiod.AsshowninFigure9‐2,thatanalysisindicatedthatpotentialDBEsmightbeexpectedtoreceived16.2percentoftheCity’sFAA‐fundedprimecontractandsubcontractdollarsbasedontheiravailabilityforthatwork.TheCityshouldconsiderthatinformationasitsetsitsnextoverallDBEgoalsforDEN’sFAA‐fundedcontracts.
Figure 9‐2. Availability of potential DBEs for FAA‐funded contracts
Note:
Numbers rounded to nearest tenth of 1 percent. Numbers may not sum exactly to totals.
For more detail, see Figure F‐18 in Appendix F.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting availability analysis.
Goal adjustments. Insettingaspirationalannualgoals,organizationsoftenexamineavailableevidencetodeterminewhetheranadjustmenttoavailabilityisnecessarytoaccountforpastparticipationofminority‐andwomanownedbusinessesintheircontracting;currentconditionsinthelocalmarketplaceforminorities,women,minority‐ownedbusinesses,andwoman‐ownedbusinesses;andotherrelevantfactors.TheFederalDBEProgram—whichorganizationsoftenuseasamodeltosetandadjusttheiraspirationalannualgoals—outlinesseveralfactorsthatorganizationsmightconsiderwhenassessingwhethertoadjusttheirgoals:
1. Volumeofworkminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesseshaveperformedinrecentyears;
2. Informationrelatedtoemployment,self‐employment,education,training,andunions;
Business group
Asian American‐owned 1.5 % 2.9 % 8.0 % 3.2 %
Black American‐owned 1.8 % 11.2 % 2.2 % 3.2 %
Hispanic American‐owned 3.2 % 9.9 % 1.9 % 3.8 %
Native American‐owned 0.2 % 0.1 % 0.1 % 0.1 %
Non‐Hispanic white woman‐owned 9.8 % 15.5 % 7.6 % 10.1 %
Total Minority‐ and Woman‐owned 16.5 % 39.5 % 19.8 % 20.5 %
Industry
Construction
Professional
services Total
Goods and
general services
Business group
Asian American‐owned 1.6 %
Black American‐owned 2.4 %
Hispanic American‐owned 5.1 %
Native American‐owned 0.2 %
Non‐Hispanic white woman‐owned 6.9 %
Total DBEs 16.2 %
Total
![Page 108: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/108.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 9, PAGE 3
3. Informationrelatedtofinancing,bonding,andinsurance;and
4. Otherrelevantdata.1
BBCcompletedananalysisofeachoftheabovefactors.MuchoftheinformationthatBBCexaminedwasnoteasilyquantifiablebutisstillrelevanttotheCityasitdetermineswhethertoadjustitsaspirationalMWBEandDBEgoals.
1. Volume of work minority‐ and woman‐owned businesses have performed in recent years.TheUnitedStatesDepartmentofTransportation’s(USDOT’s)“TipsforGoal‐Setting”suggeststhatorganizationsshouldexaminedataonpastparticipationofcertifiedminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesintheircontractsinrecentyears.USDOTfurthersuggeststhatorganizationsshouldchoosethemedianlevelofannualminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessparticipationforthoseyearsasthemeasureofpastparticipation:
Yourgoalsettingprocesswillbemoreaccurateifyouusethemedian(insteadoftheaverageormean)ofyourpastparticipationtomakeyouradjustmentbecausetheprocessofdeterminingthemedianexcludesalloutlier(abnormallyhighorabnormallylow)pastparticipationpercentages.2
IftheCityweretouseanapproachsimilartotheonethatUSDOToutlinesin“TipsforGoalsSetting,”itmightconsidertakingtheaverageofeachofitsaspirationalannualgoalswiththemedianpastparticipationforeachcorrespondingindustryandgoaltypetoadjustitsgoals.
2. Information related to employment, self‐employment, education, training, and unions.Chapter3summarizesinformationaboutconditionsinthelocalcontractingindustryforminorities,women,andminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesses.AdditionalinformationaboutquantitativeandqualitativeanalysesofconditionsinthelocalmarketplacearepresentedinAppendicesCandD.BBC’sanalysesindicatethattherearebarriersthatcertainminoritygroupsandwomenfacerelatedtohumancapital,financialcapital,andbusinessownershipintheDenvermarketplace.Suchbarriersmaydecreasetheavailabilityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessestoobtainandperformthecontractsthattheCityawards.TheCityshouldconsiderthatinformationcarefullyindeterminingwhetheranyadjustmentstoitsaspirationalMWBEandDBEgoalsarewarranted.
3. Information related to financing, bonding, and insurance. BBC’sanalysisofaccesstofinancing,bonding,andinsurancealsorevealedquantitativeandqualitativeevidencethatminorities,women,andminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinDenverdonothavethesameaccesstothosebusinessinputsasnon‐Hispanicwhitemenandbusinessesownedbynon‐Hispanicwhitemen(fordetails,seeChapter3andAppendicesCandD).Anybarrierstoobtainingfinancing,bonding,andinsurancemightlimitopportunitiesforminoritiesandwomentosuccessfullyformandoperatebusinessesinthelocalmarketplace.SuchbarrierswouldalsoplacethosebusinessesatadisadvantageincompetingforCityprimecontractsandsubcontracts.
149CFRSection26.45.
2SectionIII(A)(5)(c)inUSDOT’s“TipsforGoal‐SettingintheFederalDisadvantagedEnterprise(DBE)Program.”http://www.osdbu.dot.gov/DBEProgram/tips.cfm.
![Page 109: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/109.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 9, PAGE 4
Thus,theCityshouldalsoconsiderinformationaboutfinancing,bonding,andinsuranceindeterminingwhethertomakeanyadjustmentstoitsaspirationalMWBEandDBEgoals.
4. Other factors.TheFederalDBEProgramsuggeststhatorganizationsalsoexamine“otherfactors”whendeterminingwhethertoadjusttheiraspirationalannualgoals.Forexample,thereisquantitativeevidencethatcertaingroupsofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesarelesssuccessfulthanbusinessesownedbynon‐Hispanicwhitemenandfacegreaterbarriersinthemarketplace,evenafteraccountingforrace‐andgender‐neutralfactors.Chapter3summarizesthatevidenceandAppendixCpresentscorrespondingquantitativeanalyses.Thereisalsoqualitativeevidenceofbarrierstothesuccessofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesses,aspresentedinAppendixD.Someofthatinformationsuggeststhatdiscriminationonthebasisofrace/ethnicityandgenderadverselyaffectsminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinthelocalcontractingindustry.
Other Program Considerations
BBCprovidesvariousconsiderationsthattheCityshouldmakebasedondisparitystudyresultsandthestudyteam’sreviewoftheCity’scontractingpracticesandprogrammeasures.Inmakingthoseconsiderations,theCityshouldassesswhetheradditionalresources,changesininternalpolicy,orchangesinlawmayberequired.
Networking and outreach. TheCityhostsandparticipatesinmanynetworkingandoutreacheventsthatincludeinformationaboutmarketing,MWBEandDBEcertificationprocesses,doingbusinesswiththeCity,andavailablebidopportunities.ManybusinessesthatthestudyteaminterviewedaspartofthedisparitystudycomplimentedtheCityonitsoutreacheffortsthroughoutthelocalmarketplace(fordetails,seeAppendixD).TheCityshouldconsidercontinuingthoseeffortsbutmightalsoconsiderbroadeningitseffortstoincludemorepartnershipswithlocaltradeorganizationsandotherpublicorganizationsthathaveinitiativesinplacetoencourageminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessdevelopment,includingtheDenverMinorityBusinessDevelopmentAgency,theMinorityBusinessOfficewiththeStateofColorado,theBlackBusinessInitiative,theColoradoBlackChamberofCommerce,theHispanicContractorsofColorado,theAsianChamberofCommerce–Colorado,DenverWater,andDenverPublicSchools.TheCitymightalsoconsidercreatingaconsortiumoflocalorganizationsthatwouldjointlyhostquarterlyoutreachandnetworkingeventsaswellastrainingsessionsforbusinessesseekingpublicsectorcontracts.Inaddition,theCityshouldconsiderwaysthatitcanbetterleveragetechnologytonetworkmoreeffectivelywithbusinessesthroughouttheregion.TheCitycouldconsidermakinguseofonlineprocurementfairs,webinars,conferencecalls,andothertoolstoprovideoutreachandtechnicalassistance.
Data collection.TheCitymaintainscomprehensivedataontheprimecontractsandprocurementsthatitawardsandmaintainsthosedatainawell‐organizedandintuitivemanner.However,theCityonlymaintainsdataonthosesubcontractsthatareassociatedwithprimecontractsthatitawardsusingMWBEorDBEcontractgoals(i.e.,goalscontracts).TheCityshouldconsidercollectingcomprehensivedataonallsubcontracts,regardlessofwhethertheyareperformedbyminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesandregardlessofwhethertheyareassociatedwithgoalscontracts.CollectingdataonallsubcontractswillhelpensurethattheCity
![Page 110: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/110.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 9, PAGE 5
monitorstheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesasaccuratelyaspossible.Collectingthefollowingdataonallsubcontractswouldbeappropriate:
Subcontractorname,address,phonenumber,andemailaddress;
Typeofassociatedwork;
Subcontractawardamount;and
Subcontractpaidamount.
TheCityshouldconsidercollectingthosedataaspartofbidsbutalsorequiringprimecontractorstosubmitdataonsubcontractsaspartoftheinvoicingprocessforallcontracts.TheCityshouldtrainrelevantdepartmentstafftocollectandentersubcontractdataaccuratelyandconsistently.
Monitoring minority‐ and woman‐owned business participation. TheCityonlymonitorsminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessparticipationongoalscontracts,whichresultsinaskewedrepresentationoftheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinCitycontractingoverall.Disparitystudyresultsindicatethat,duringthestudyperiod,theparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesseswasmuchlowerincontractsthattheCityawardedwithouttheuseofMWBEorDBEcontractgoals(i.e.,nogoalscontracts)thaningoalscontracts,despitetheavailabilityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesbeingverysimilarforbothcontractsets.ThatresultunderscorestheimportancefortheCitytomonitortheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinallcontracts,regardlessofwhethertheyuseanytypeofcontractgoalstoawardthem.DoingsowillhelpensurethattheCitymonitorstheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesasaccuratelyaspossible.
Growth monitoring.Alongwithworkingtoimproveitscontractingandvendordatasystems,theCitymightalsoconsidercollectingdataontheimpactthattheMWBEandDBEProgramshaveonthegrowthofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesovertime.DoingsowouldrequiretheCitytocollectbaselineinformationoncertifiedMWBEsandDBEs—suchasrevenue,numberoflocations,numberofemployees,andemployeedemographics—andthencontinuetocollectthatinformationfromeachbusinessonanannualbasis.SuchmetricswouldallowtheCitytoassesswhethertheprogramishelpingminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesgrowandalsohelprefinethemeasuresthattheCityusesaspartoftheMWBEandDBEPrograms.
Prime contract opportunities.Disparityanalysisresultsindicatedsubstantialdisparitiesformostracial/ethnicandgendergroupsontheprimecontractsthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiod.TheCityhasestablishedaDefinedSelectionPoolProgram,whichlimitscompetitiononcertainconstructionandgoodsandservicesprimecontractstocertifiedSBEsorEBEs.TheCityshouldconsidercontinuingandevenexpandingtheuseoftheprogramtofurtherencouragetheparticipationofsmallbusinesses,includingmanyminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesses
Subcontract opportunities.Overall,minority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesdidnotshowdisparitiesonthesubcontractsthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiod.However,subcontractingaccountedforarelativelysmallpercentageofthetotalcontractingdollarsthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiod.Toincreasethenumberofsubcontractopportunities,
![Page 111: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/111.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 9, PAGE 6
theCitycouldconsiderimplementingaprogramthatrequiresprimecontractorstosubcontractacertainamountofprojectworkaspartoftheirbidsandproposals,regardlessoftherace/ethnicityorgenderofsubcontractorowners.Forspecifictypesofcontractswheresubcontractingorpartnershipopportunitiesmightexist,theCitycouldsetaminimumpercentageofworktobesubcontracted.Primecontractorswouldthenhavetomeetorexceedthisthresholdinorderfortheirbidstobeconsideredresponsive.IftheCityweretoimplementsuchaprogram,itshouldincludeflexibilityprovisionssuchasagoodfaitheffortsprocess.
Contract goals.TheCityusesMWBEandDBEcontractgoalsonmanyofthecontractsthatitawards.PrimecontractorscanmeetthosegoalsbyeithermakingsubcontractingcommitmentswithcertifiedMWBEorDBEsubcontractorsatthetimeofbidorbysubmittingwaiversshowingthattheymadereasonablegoodfaitheffortstofulfillthegoalsbutcouldnotdoso.Disparityanalysisresultsshowedthatoutcomesforminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesseswerebetterongoalscontractsthannogoalscontractsduringthestudyperiod,indicatingthattheuseofcontractgoalsisaneffectivemeasureinencouragingtheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinCitycontracts,particularlyforHispanicAmerican‐ownedbusinesses.TheCityshouldconsidercontinuingitsuseofMWBEandDBEcontractgoalsinthefuture.TheCitywillneedtoensurethattheuseofthosegoalsisnarrowlytailoredandconsistentwithotherrelevantlegalstandards(fordetails,seeChapter2andAppendixB).ItisalsoimportantfortheCitytocontinuetotreatcontractgoalsasonlyonetacticamongmanytoencourageminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessparticipationinitscontractingandtonottreattheuseofsuchgoalsasasubstituteforothermeasuresthatmighthelpbuildthecapacityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesforCitywork,suchastechnicalassistanceprograms,mentor‐protégéprograms,andfinancialassistance.
MWBE and DBE certification.Aspartofin‐depthinterviewsandpublicmeetings,someminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessescharacterizedtheCity’sMWBEandDBEcertificationprocessesasdifficultandcumbersome.TheCityshouldconsidermeasurestosimplifyandstreamlinetheprocess—particularlyforrecertification—tomakeiteasierforminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessestobecomecertifiedandfullyparticipateintheMWBEProgramandtheFederalDBEProgram.TheCityshouldalsoconsiderworkingwiththeColoradoDepartmentofTransportation(CDOT)toexamineanycollaborationopportunitiestorefineDBEcertificationprocesses.
Unbundling large contracts.Ingeneral,minority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesexhibitedreducedavailabilityforrelativelylargecontractsthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiod.Inaddition,aspartofin‐depthinterviewsandpublicforums,severalminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesreportedthatthesizeofgovernmentcontractsoftenservesasabarriertotheirsuccess(fordetails,seeAppendixD).Tofurtherencouragetheparticipationofsmallbusinesses,includingmanyminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesses,theCityshouldconsidermakingeffortstounbundlerelativelylargeprimecontractsandevensubcontractsintoseveralsmallercontracts.Forexample,theCityofCharlotte,NorthCarolinaencouragesprimecontractorstounbundlesubcontractingopportunitiesintosmallercontractpiecesthataremorefeasibleforsmallbusinessesandminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessestoworkonandacceptssuchattemptsasgoodfaithefforts.Doingsowouldresultinthatworkbeingmoreaccessibletosmallbusinesses,whichinturnmightincreaseopportunitiesforminority‐and
![Page 112: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/112.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT CHAPTER 9, PAGE 7
woman‐ownedbusinessesandresultingreaterminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessparticipation.
Prompt payment.Aspartofin‐depthinterviews,severalbusinesses,includingmanyminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesses,reporteddifficultieswithreceivingpaymentinatimelymanneronCitycontracts,bothwhentheyworkasprimecontractorsandassubcontractors(fordetails,seeAppendixD).Manybusinessesalsocommentedthathavingcapitalonhandiscrucialtosmallbusinesssuccess.TheCityshouldconsiderreinforcingitspromptpaymentpolicieswithitsprocurementstaffandprimecontractorsandcouldalsoconsiderautomatingpaymentsdirectlytosubcontractors.Doingsomighthelpensurethatbothprimecontractorsandsubcontractorsreceivepaymentinatimelymanner.Itmayalsohelpensurethatminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesseshaveenoughoperatingcapitaltoremainsuccessful.
Diversity language in bid and proposal documents.SomeintervieweesandpublicmeetingparticipantsindicatedthattheCitydoesnotdoenoughtoencourageprimecontractorstomakegenuineeffortstopartnerwithminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesaspartofCitycontracting.OnestepthattheCitycouldconsidertakingtoemphasizetheimportanceofdiversityinitscontractingistodescribeitsdiversityobjectivesandtheeffortsthatitexpectsprimecontractorstomaketopartnerwithminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesaspartofallofitsbidandproposaldocuments.DoingsowillhelpmakeitcleartoprimecontractorsthatcontractingdiversityisaprioritytotheCityandwillalsohelpensurethatprimecontractorsgobeyondperfunctoryeffortstoworkwithminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesses.
![Page 113: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/113.jpg)
APPENDIX A.
Definitions of Terms
![Page 114: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/114.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX A, PAGE 1
APPENDIX A. Definitions of Terms
AppendixAdefinestermsthatareusefultounderstandingtheCityofDenverDisparityStudyreport.Thefollowingdefinitionsareonlyrelevantinthecontextofthisreport.
49 Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) Part 26
49CFRPart26arethefederalregulationsthatsetforththeFederalDisadvantagedBusinessEnterpriseProgram.Theobjectivesof49CFRPart26areto:
EnsurenondiscriminationintheawardandadministrationofUnitedStatesDepartmentofTransportation‐assistedcontracts;
CreatealevelplayingfieldonwhichDisadvantagedBusinessEnterprisescancompetefairlyforUnitedStatesDepartmentofTransportation‐assistedcontracts;
EnsurethattheFederalDisadvantagedBusinessEnterpriseProgramisnarrowlytailoredinaccordancewithapplicablelaw;
EnsurethatonlybusinessesthatfullymeeteligibilitystandardsarepermittedtoparticipateasDisadvantagedBusinessEnterprises;
HelpremovebarrierstotheparticipationofDisadvantagedBusinessEnterprisesinUnitedStatesDepartmentofTransportation‐assistedcontracts;
PromotetheuseofDisadvantagedBusinessEnterprisesinalltypesoffederally‐assistedcontractsandprocurements;
AssistinthedevelopmentofbusinessessothattheycancompeteoutsideoftheFederalDisadvantagedBusinessEnterpriseProgram;and
ProvideappropriateflexibilitytoagenciesimplementingtheFederalDisadvantagedBusinessEnterpriseProgram.
Anecdotal Information
Anecdotalinformationincludespersonalqualitativeaccountsandperceptionsofspecificincidents—includinganyincidentsofdiscrimination—sharedbyindividualintervieweesorparticipants.
Availability Analysis
Anavailabilityanalysisassessesthepercentageofdollarsthatonemightexpectaspecificgroupofbusinessestoreceiveoncontractsorprocurementsthataparticularorganizationawards.TheavailabilityanalysisinthisreportisbasedonthematchbetweenvariouscharacteristicsofpotentiallyavailablebusinessesandofprimecontractsandsubcontractsthattheCityofDenverawardedduringthestudyperiod.
![Page 115: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/115.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX A, PAGE 2
Business
Abusinessisafor‐profitenterpriseincludingallofitsestablishmentsorlocationsandincludingsoleproprietorships,corporations,professionalcorporations,limitedliabilitycompanies,limitedpartnerships,limitedliabilitypartnerships,oranyotherpartnershipsregardlessofwhethertheywereformedunderthelawsoftheStateofColorado.
Business Listing
Abusinesslistingisarecordinadatabaseofbusinessinformation.Arecordisconsideredalistinguntilthestudyteamdeterminesthatthelistingactuallyrepresentsabusinessestablishmentwithaworkingphonenumber.
Business Establishment
Abusinessestablishmentisaplaceofbusinesswithanaddressandaworkingphonenumber.Asinglebusiness,orfirm,canhavemanybusinessestablishments,orlocations.
City and County of Denver (The City)
Denver,ColoradoisoneofthelargestcitiesintheUnitedStateswitharegionalpopulationofnearly3millionpeople.TheCityandCountyofDenverprovidesmyriadservicestotheresidentswholiveandworkintheregion.Toprovidethoseservices,theCitytypicallyspendsnearly$1billioneachyearincontractdollarstoprocurevariousgoodsandservicesinconstruction;professionalservices;andgoodsandservices.
Compelling Governmental Interest
Aspartofthestrictscrutinystandardofconstitutionalreview,agovernmentorganizationmustdemonstrateacompellinggovernmentalinterestinremedyingpastidentifieddiscriminationinordertoimplementrace‐orgender‐consciousmeasuresaspartofaminority‐orwoman‐ownedbusinessprogram.Anorganizationthatusessuchmeasureshastheinitialburdenofshowingevidenceofdiscrimination—includingstatisticalandanecdotalevidence—thatsupportstheiruse.Theorganizationmustassesssuchdiscriminationwithinitsownrelevantgeographicmarketarea.
Consultant
Aconsultantisabusinessthatperformsprofessionalservicescontracts.
Contract
Acontractisalegallybindingrelationshipbetweenthesellerofgoodsorservicesandabuyer.Thestudyteamoftenusesthetermcontractsynonymouslywithprocurement.
Contract Element
Acontractelementiseitheraprimecontractorsubcontract.
Contractor
Acontractorisabusinessthatperformsconstructioncontracts.
![Page 116: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/116.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX A, PAGE 3
Control
Controlmeansexercisingmanagementandexecutiveauthorityofabusiness.
Custom Census Availability Analysis
Acustomcensusavailabilityanalysisisoneinwhichresearchersattemptsurveyswithpotentiallyavailablebusinessesworkinginthelocalmarketplacetocollectinformationaboutkeybusinesscharacteristics.Researchersthentakesurveyinformationaboutpotentiallyavailablebusinessesandmatchthemtothecharacteristicsofprimecontractsandsubcontractsthatanorganizationactuallyawardedduringthestudyperiodtoassessthepercentageofdollarsthatonemightexpectaspecificgroupofbusinessestoreceiveoncontractsorprocurementsthattheorganizationawards.Acustomcensusavailabilityanalysisisacceptedintheindustryasthepreferredmethodforconductingavailabilityanalyses,becauseittakesseveraldifferentfactorsintoaccount,includingbusinesses’primarylinesofworkandtheircapacitytoperformonanorganization’scontracts.
Denver International Airport (DEN)
DENisoneofthenation’sbusiestinternationalairports.Itoffersnonstopservicetonearly200destinationsthroughoutNorthAmerica,LatinAmerica,Europe,andAsia.TheCity’sDepartmentofAviationownsandoperatesDEN.
Disadvantaged Business Enterprise (DBE)
ADBEisabusinessthatisownedandcontrolledbyoneormoreindividualswhoaresociallyandeconomicallydisadvantagedaccordingtotheguidelinesintheFederalDBEProgram(49CFRPart26)andthatiscertifiedassuchthroughtheCity’sDivisionofSmallBusinessOpportunityortheColoradoDepartmentofTransportation.ThefollowinggroupsarepresumedtobesociallyandeconomicallydisadvantagedaccordingtotheFederalDBEProgram:
AsianPacificAmericans;
BlackAmericans;
HispanicAmericans;
NativeAmericans;
SubcontinentAsianAmericans;and
Womenofanyraceorethnicity.
Adeterminationofeconomicdisadvantagealsoincludesassessingbusiness’grossrevenuesandbusinessowners’personalnetworth.Someminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesdonotqualifyasDBEsbecauseofgrossrevenueornetworthrequirements.Businessesownedbynon‐HispanicwhitemencanalsobecertifiedasDBEsifthosebusinessesmeettherequirementsin49CFRPart26.
Division of Small Business Opportunity (DSBO)
DSBOisadivisionoftheCitythatisresponsibleforimplementingvariousprogramsandmeasuresdesignedtoencouragetheparticipationofsmallbusinessesaswellasminority‐and
![Page 117: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/117.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX A, PAGE 4
woman‐ownedbusinessesinCitycontractingandprocurement,includingimplementingtheMinorityandWoman‐ownedBusinessEnterpriseProgram,theEmergingBusinessEnterpriseProgram,theSmallBusinessEnterpriseProgram,andtheFederalDisadvantagedBusinessEnterpriseProgram.
Disparity
Adisparityisadifferenceorgapbetweenanactualoutcomeandsomebenchmark.Inthisreport,thetermdisparityreferstoadifferencebetweentheparticipationofaspecificgroupofbusinessesinCitycontractingandtheavailabilityofthatgroupforCitywork.
Disparity Analysis
AdisparityanalysisexamineswhetherthereareanydifferencesbetweentheparticipationofaspecificgroupofbusinessesinCitycontractingandtheavailabilityofthatgroupforCitywork.
Disparity Index
AdisparityindexiscomputedbydividingtheactualparticipationofaspecificgroupofbusinessesinCitycontractingbytheavailabilityofthatgroupforCityworkandmultiplyingtheresultby100.Smallerdisparityindicesindicatelargerdisparities.
Dun & Bradstreet (D&B)
D&Bistheleadingglobalprovideroflistsofbusinessestablishmentsandotherbusinessinformationforspecificindustrieswithinspecificgeographicalareas(fordetails,seewww.dnb.com).
Federal Aviation Administration (FAA)
TheFAAisanagencyoftheUnitedStatesDepartmentofTransportationthatservesasthenationalaviationauthorityoftheUnitedStates.TheFAAhasauthoritytoregulateandoverseeallaspectsofcivilaviationintheUnitedStates.DENisarecipientofFAAfunds.
Federal DBE Program
TheFederalDBEProgramwasestablishedbytheUnitedStatesDepartmentofTransportationafterenactmentoftheTransportationEquityActforthe21stCentury(TEA‐21)asamendedin1998.RegulationsfortheFederalDBEProgramaresetforthin49CFRPart26.
Firm
Seebusiness.
Industry
Anindustryisabroadclassificationforbusinessesprovidingrelatedgoodsorservices(e.g.,constructionorprofessionalservices).
Local Marketplace
Seerelevantgeographicmarketarea.
![Page 118: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/118.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX A, PAGE 5
Locally‐funded Contract
Alocally‐fundedcontractisanycontractorprojectthatiswhollyfundedwithlocal,non‐federalfunds—thatis,theydonotincludeUnitedStatesDepartmentofTransportationoranyotherfederalfunds.
Majority‐owned Business
Amajority‐ownedbusinessisafor‐profitbusinessthatisatleast51percentownedandcontrolledbynon‐Hispanicwhitemen.
Minority
Aminorityisanindividualwhoidentifieswithoneoftheracial/ethnicgroupsspecifiedbytheCity’sMinority‐andWoman‐ownedBusinessEnterpriseProgram:
AsianAmericans;
BlackAmericans;
HispanicAmericans;and
NativeAmericans.
Minority‐ and Woman‐owned Business Enterprise (MWBE) Program
TheCity’sMWBEProgramisdesignedtopreventrace‐orgender‐baseddiscriminationagainstminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesandencouragetheirparticipationinCitycontractsandprocurements.Aspartoftheprogram,theCitysetsaspirationalannualgoalsfortheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinitscontractsandprocurementsandreliesonavarietyofmeasuresinanefforttomeetthosegoals.
Minority‐owned Business
Aminority‐ownedbusinessisabusinesswithatleast51percentownershipandcontrolbyindividualswhoidentifythemselveswithoneoftheracial/ethnicgroupsspecifiedbytheCity’sMWBEProgram.Abusinessdoesnothavetobecertifiedasaminority‐ownedbusinessenterprisetobeconsideredaminority‐ownedbusinessinthisstudy.(Thestudyteamconsideredbusinessesownedbyminoritywomenasminority‐ownedbusinesses.)
Minority‐owned Business Enterprise (MBE)
AnMBEisaminority‐ownedbusinessthathasbeencertifiedassuchbyDSBO.
Narrow Tailoring
Aspartofthestrictscrutinystandardofconstitutionalreview,agovernmentorganizationmustdemonstratethatitsuseofrace‐andgender‐consciousmeasuresisnarrowlytailored.Thereareanumberoffactorsthatacourtconsiderswhendeterminingwhethertheuseofsuchmeasuresisnarrowlytailored,including:
a) Thenecessityofsuchmeasuresandtheefficacyofalternative,race‐andgender‐neutralmeasures;
![Page 119: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/119.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX A, PAGE 6
b) Thedegreetowhichtheuseofsuchmeasuresislimitedtothosegroupsthatactuallysufferdiscriminationinthelocalmarketplace;
c) Thedegreetowhichtheuseofsuchmeasuresisflexibleandlimitedinduration,includingtheavailabilityofwaiversandsunsetprovisions;
d) Therelationshipofanynumericalgoalstotherelevantbusinessmarketplace;and
e) Theimpactofsuchmeasuresontherightsofthirdparties.1
Participation
Seeutilization.
Prime Consultant
Aprimeconsultantisaprofessionalservicesbusinessthatperformsprofessionalservicesprimecontractsdirectlyforendusers,suchastheCity.
Prime Contract
Aprimecontractisacontractbetweenaprimecontractor,orprimeconsultant,andanenduser,suchastheCity.
Prime Contractor
Aprimecontractorisaconstructionbusinessthatperformsprimecontractsdirectlyforendusers,suchastheCity.
Project
Aprojectreferstoaconstruction;professionalservices;goodsorservicesendeavorthattheCitybidoutduringthestudyperiod.Aprojectcouldincludeoneormoreprimecontractsandcorrespondingsubcontracts.
Race‐ and Gender‐conscious Measures
Race‐andgender‐consciousmeasuresarecontractingmeasuresthatarespecificallydesignedtoincreasetheparticipationofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesingovernmentcontracting.Businessesownedbymembersofcertainracial/ethnicgroupsmightbeeligibleforsuchmeasuresbutothersmightnot.Similarly,businessesownedbywomenmightbeeligiblebutbusinessesownedbymenmightnot.Theuseofcontractgoalsisoneexampleofarace‐andgender‐consciousmeasure.
Race‐ and Gender‐neutral Measures
Race‐andgender‐neutralmeasuresaremeasuresthataredesignedtoremovepotentialbarriersforallbusinessesattemptingtodoworkwithanorganizationormeasuresthataredesignedtoremovepotentialbarriersforsmalloremergingbusinesses,regardlessoftherace/ethnicityor
1See,e.g.,AGC,SDCv.Caltrans,713F.3dat1198‐1199;Rothe,545F.3dat1036;WesternStatesPaving,407F3dat993‐995;SherbrookeTurf,345F.3dat971;AdarandVII,228F.3dat1181;Eng’gContractorsAss’n,122F.3dat927(internalquotationsandcitationsomitted).
![Page 120: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/120.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX A, PAGE 7
genderoftheowners.Race‐andgender‐neutralmeasuresmayincludeassistanceinovercomingbondingandfinancingobstacles;simplifyingbiddingprocedures;providingtechnicalassistance;establishingprogramstoassiststart‐ups;andothermethodsopentoallbusinesses,regardlessoftherace/ethnicityorgenderoftheowners.
Rational Basis
Governmentorganizationsthatimplementcontractingprogramsthatrelyonlyonrace‐andgender‐neutralmeasurestoencouragetheparticipationofsmallbusinesses,regardlessoftherace/ethnicityorgenderofbusinessowners,mustshowarationalbasisfortheirprograms.Showingarationalbasisrequiresorganizationstodemonstratethattheircontractingprogramsarerationallyrelatedtoalegitimategovernmentinterest.Itisthelowestthresholdforevaluatingthelegalityofgovernmentcontractingprograms.Whencourtsreviewprogramsbasedonarationalbasis,onlythemostegregiousviolationsleadtoprogramsbeingdeemedunconstitutional.
Relevant Geographic Market Area
TherelevantgeographicmarketareaisthegeographicareainwhichthebusinessestowhichtheCityawardsmostofitscontractingdollarsarelocated.Therelevantgeographicmarketareaisalsoreferredtoasthelocalmarketplace.Caselawrelatedtominority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessprogramsaswellasdisparitystudiesrequiresdisparitystudyanalysestofocusontherelevantgeographicmarketarea.TherelevantgeographicmarketareaforthedisparitystudyisAdams,Arapahoe,Boulder,Broomfield,Denver,Douglas,andJeffersonCountiesinColorado.
Statistically Significant Difference
Astatisticallysignificantdifferencereferstoaquantitativedifferenceforwhichthereisa0.95or0.90probabilitythatchancecanbecorrectlyrejectedasanexplanationforthedifference(meaningthatthereisa0.05or0.10probability,respectively,thatchanceinthesamplingprocesscouldcorrectlyaccountforthedifference).
Strict Scrutiny
Strictscrutinyisthelegalstandardthatagovernmentorganization’suseofrace‐andgender‐consciousmeasuresmustmeetinorderforittobeconsideredconstitutional.Strictscrutinyrepresentsthehighestthresholdforevaluatingthelegalityofrace‐andgender‐consciousmeasuresshortofprohibitingthemaltogether.Underthestrictscrutinystandard,anorganizationmust:
a) Haveacompellinggovernmentalinterestinremedyingpastidentifieddiscriminationoritspresenteffects;and
b) Establishthattheuseofanysuchmeasuresisnarrowlytailoredtoachievethegoalofremedyingtheidentifieddiscrimination.
Anorganization’suseofrace‐andgender‐consciousmeasuresmustmeetboththecompellinggovernmentalinterestandthenarrowtailoringcomponentsofthestrictscrutinystandardforittobeconsideredconstitutional.
![Page 121: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/121.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX A, PAGE 8
Study Period
Thestudyperiodisthetimeperiodonwhichthestudyteamfocusedfortheutilization,availability,anddisparityanalyses.TheCityhadtohaveawardedacontractduringthestudyperiodforthecontracttobeincludedinthestudyteam’sanalyses.ThestudyperiodforthedisparitystudywasJanuary1,2012throughDecember31,2016.
Subconsultant
Asubconsultantisaprofessionalservicesbusinessthatperformsservicesforprimeconsultantsaspartoflargerprofessionalservicescontracts.
Subcontract
Asubcontractisacontractbetweenaprimecontractororprimeconsultantandanotherbusinesssellinggoodsorservicestotheprimecontractororprimeconsultantaspartofalargercontract.
Subcontractor
Asubcontractorisabusinessthatperformsservicesforprimecontractorsaspartoflargercontracts.
Subindustry
Asubindustryisaspecificclassificationforbusinessesprovidingrelatedgoodsorserviceswithinaparticularindustry(e.g.,water,sewer,andutilitylinesisasubindustryofconstruction).
United States Departments of Transportation (USDOT)
USDOTisafederalcabinetdepartmentoftheUnitedStatesgovernmentthatoverseesfederalhighway,air,railroad,maritime,andothertransportationadministrationfunctions.FAAisaUSDOTagency.
Utilization
Utilizationreferstothepercentageoftotalcontractingdollarsthatwereassociatedwithaparticularsetofcontractsthatwenttoaspecificgroupofbusinesses.
Vendor
AvendorisabusinessthatsellsgoodseithertoaprimecontractororprimeconsultantortoanendusersuchastheCity.
Woman‐owned Business
Awoman‐ownedbusinessisabusinesswithatleast51percentownershipandcontrolbynon‐Hispanicwhitewomen.Abusinessdoesnothavetobecertifiedasawoman‐ownedbusinessenterprisetobeconsideredawoman‐ownedbusiness.(Thestudyteamconsideredbusinessesownedbyminoritywomenasminority‐ownedbusinesses.)
![Page 122: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/122.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX A, PAGE 9
Woman‐owned Business Enterprise (WBE)
AWBEisawoman‐ownedbusinessthathasbeencertifiedassuchbyDSBO.
![Page 123: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/123.jpg)
APPENDIX B.
Legal Framework and Analysis
![Page 124: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/124.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE i
Table of Contents TABLEOFCONTENTS.........................................................................................................................................................................................I
APPENDIXB.LEGALFRAMEWORKANDANALYSIS............................................................................................................................1
EXECUTIVESUMMARY.....................................................................................................................................................................................1
A.Introduction...............................................................................................................................................................................................1
B.U.S.SupremeCourtCases.....................................................................................................................................................................3
1.CityofRichmondv.J.A.CrosonCo.,488U.S.469(1989)...................................................................................................3
2.AdarandConstructors,Inc.v.Pena(“AdarandI”),515U.S.200(1995).....................................................................5
C.TheLegalFrameworkAppliedtoStateandLocalGovernmentMBE/WBE/DBEProgramsandtheFederalDBEandACDBEPrograms......................................................................................................................................................5
1.Strictscrutinyanalysis.....................................................................................................................................................................5
2.Intermediatescrutinyanalysis..................................................................................................................................................28
3.Rationalbasisanalysis...................................................................................................................................................................30
4.Pendingcases(atthetimeofthisreport).............................................................................................................................33
SUMMARIESOFRECENTDECISIONS......................................................................................................................................................36
D.RecentDecisionsInvolvingStateorLocalGovernmentMBE/WBE/DBEProgramsintheTenthCircuitCourtofAppeals..........................................................................................................................................................................36
1.ConcreteWorksofColorado,Inc.v.CityandCountyofDenver,321F.3d950(10thCir.2003),cert.denied,540U.S.1027,124S.Ct.556(2003)(Scalia,JusticewithwhomtheChiefJusticeRehnquist,joined,dissentingfromthedenialofcertiorari)..............................................................................................36
2.AdarandConstructors,Inc.v.Slater,228F.3d1147(10thCir.2000)cert.grantedthendismissedasimprovidentlygrantedsubnom.AdarandConstructors,Inc.v.Mineta,532U.S.941,534U.S.103(2001).............................................................................................................................................................................48
3.ConcreteWorksofColorado,Inc.v.CityandCountyofDenver,36F.3d1513(10thCir.1994)....................57
4.KlaverConstruction,Inc.v.KansasDOT,211F.Supp.2d1296(D.Kan.2002).....................................................67
5.KornhassConstruction,Inc.v.StateofOklahoma,DepartmentofCentralServices,140F.Supp.2d1232(W.D.OK.2001)...................................................................................................................................................68
E.RecentDecisionsInvolvingStateorLocalGovernmentMBE/WBE/DBEProgramsinOtherJurisdictions.................................................................................................................................................................................................73
RecentDecisionsinFederalCircuitCourtsofAppeal...........................................................................................................73
1.H.B.RoweCo.,Inc.v.W.LyndoTippett,NCDOT,etal.,615F.3d233(4thCir.2010).......................................73
2.Jana‐RockConstruction,Inc.v.NewYorkStateDept.ofEconomicDevelopment,438F.3d195(2dCir.2006).........................................................................................................................................................................................84
3.RapidTestProds.,Inc.v.DurhamSch.Servs.,Inc.,460F.3d859(7thCir.2006)..................................................85
4.Virdiv.DeKalbCountySchoolDistrict,135Fed.Appx.262,2005WL138942(11thCir.2005)(unpublishedopinion).......................................................................................................................................................................86
5.InreCityofMemphis,293F.3d345(6thCir.2002)........................................................................................................88
6.BuildersAss’nofGreaterChicagov.CountyofCook,Chicago,256F.3d642(7thCir.2001).........................88
7.AssociatedGen.Contractorsv.Drabik,214F.3d730(6thCir.2000),affirmingCaseNo.C2‐98‐943,998WL812241(S.D.Ohio1998)........................................................................................................................................90
8.W.H.ScottConstr.Co.v.CityofJackson,Mississippi,199F.3d206(5thCir.1999)...........................................94
9.MontereyMechanicalv.Wilson,125F.3d702(9thCir.1997).....................................................................................97
![Page 125: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/125.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE ii
10.Eng’gContractorsAss’nofS.Floridav.Metro.DadeCounty,122F.3d895(11thCir.1997)......................98
11.AssociatedGen.ContractorsofCalifornia,Inc.v.CoalitionforEcon.Equity(“AGCC”),950F.2d1401(9thCir.1991).........................................................................................................................................................................109
12.CoralConstructionCo.v.KingCounty,941F.2d910(9thCir.1991)..................................................................112
RecentDistrictCourtDecisions...................................................................................................................................................116
13.KossmanContractingCo.,Inc.v.CityofHouston,2016WL1104363(S.D.Tex.2016)...............................116
14.H.B.RoweCorp.,Inc.v.W.LyndoTippett,NorthCarolinaDOT,etal.,589F.Supp.2d587(E.D.N.C.2008),affirmedinpart,reversedinpart,andremanded,615F.3d233(4thCir.2010).................123
15.Thomasv.CityofSaintPaul,526F.Supp.2d959(D.Minn2007),affirmed,321Fed.Appx.541,2009WL777932(8thCir.March26,2009)(unpublishedopinion),cert.denied,130S.Ct.408(2009).....................................................................................................................................................................................................128
16.ThompsonBuildingWreckingCo.v.Augusta,Georgia,No.1:07CV019,2007WL926153(S.D.Ga.Mar.14,2007)(Slip.Op.).........................................................................................................................................................130
17.HershellGillConsultingEngineers,Inc.v.Miami‐DadeCounty,333F.Supp.2d1305(S.D.Fla.2004)......................................................................................................................................................................................................132
18.FloridaA.G.C.Council,Inc.v.StateofFlorida,303F.Supp.2d1307(N.D.Fla.2004)...................................137
19.TheBuildersAss’nofGreaterChicagov.TheCityofChicago,298F.Supp.2d725(N.D.Ill.2003)......................................................................................................................................................................................................138
20.AssociatedUtilityContractorsofMaryland,Inc.v.MayorandCityCouncilofBaltimore,218F.Supp.2d749(D.Md.2002)............................................................................................................................................................139
21.AssociatedUtilityContractorsofMaryland,Inc.v.TheMayorandCityCouncilofBaltimoreandMarylandMinorityContractorsAssociation,Inc.,83F.Supp.2d613(D.Md.2000)...................................140
22.Websterv.FultonCounty,51F.Supp.2d1354(N.D.Ga.1999),affirmedpercuriam218F.3d1267(11thCir.2000)......................................................................................................................................................................147
23.AssociatedGen.Contractorsv.Drabik,50F.Supp.2d741(S.D.Ohio1999)....................................................150
24.Phillips&Jordan,Inc.v.Watts,13F.Supp.2d1308(N.D.Fla.1998)...................................................................153
F.RecentDecisionsInvolvingtheFederalDBEProgramanditsImplementationbyStateandLocalGovernments............................................................................................................................................................................................153
RecentDecisionsinFederalCircuitCourtsofAppeal........................................................................................................154
1.MountainWestHoldingCo.,Inc.v.TheStateofMontana,MontanaDOT,etal.,2017WL2179120(9thCir.May16,2017),Memorandumopinion,(NotforPublication)UnitedStatesCourtofAppealsfortheNinthCircuit,May16,2017,DocketNos.14‐26097and15‐35003,dismissinginpart,reversinginpartandremandingtheU.S.DistrictCourtdecisionat2014WL6686734(D.Mont.Nov.26,2014)........................................................................................................................................................................154
2.MidwestFenceCorporationv.U.S.DepartmentofTransportation,IllinoisDepartmentofTransportation,IllinoisStateTollHighwayAuthority,840F.3d932,2016WL6543514(7thCir.2016),cert.denied,2017WL497345(2017).......................................................................................................................160
3.DunnetBayConstructionCompanyv.Borggren,IllinoisDOT,etal.,799F.3d676,2015WL4934560(7thCir.2015),cert.denied,DunnetBayConstructionCo.v.Blankenhorn,RandallS.,etal.,2016WL193809(Oct.3,2016)...........................................................................................................................................170
4.AssociatedGeneralContractorsofAmerica,SanDiegoChapter,Inc.v.CaliforniaDepartmentofTransportation,etal.,713F.3d1187(9thCir.2013)........................................................................................................175
5.Braunsteinv.ArizonaDOT,683F.3d1177(9thCir.2012)........................................................................................182
6.NorthernContracting,Inc.v.Illinois,473F.3d715(7thCir.2007).........................................................................183
7.WesternStatesPavingCo.v.WashingtonStateDOT,407F.3d983(9thCir.2005),cert.denied,546U.S.1170(2006).......................................................................................................................................................................186
![Page 126: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/126.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE iii
8.SherbrookeTurf,Inc.v.MinnesotaDOT,andGrossSeedCompanyv.NebraskaDepartmentofRoads,345F.3d964(8thCir.2003),cert.denied,541U.S.1041(2004)...................................................................190
RecentDistrictCourtDecisions...................................................................................................................................................194
9.MidwestFenceCorporationv.UnitedStatesDOTandFederalHighwayAdministration,theIllinoisDOT,theIllinoisStateTollHighwayAuthority,etal.,84F.Supp.3d705,2015WL1396376(N.D.Ill,2015),affirmed,840F.3d932(7thCir.2016)..................................................................................194
10.GeyerSignal,Inc.v.Minnesota,DOT,2014WL1309092(D.Minn.March31,2014)..................................204
11.DunnetBayConstructionCompanyv.GaryHannig,initsofficialcapacityasSecretaryofTransportationfortheIllinoisDOTandtheIllinoisDOT,2014WL552213(C.D.Ill.2014),affirmed,DunnetBayConstructionCo.v.Borggren,IllinoisDOT,etal.,799F.3d676,2015WL4934560(7thCir.2015)..................................................................................................................................................................212
12.M.K.WeedenConstructionv.StateofMontana,MontanaDepartmentofTransportation,etal.,2013WL4774517(D.Mont.)(September4,2013)...........................................................................................................217
13.AssociatedGeneralContractorsofAmerica,SanDiegoChapter,Inc.v.CaliforniaDepartmentofTransportation,etal.,U.S.D.C.,E.D.Cal.CivilActionNo.S‐09‐1622,SlipOpinion(E.D.Cal.April20,2011),appealdismissedbasedonstanding,onothergroundsNinthCircuitheldCaltrans’DBEProgramconstitutional,AssociatedGeneralContractorsofAmerica,SanDiegoChapter,Inc.v.CaliforniaDepartmentofTransportation,etal.,713F.3d1187(9thCir.2013).....................................................220
14.GeodCorporationv.NewJerseyTransitCorporation,etal.,746F.Supp.2d642,2010WL4193051(D.N.J.October19,2010)..........................................................................................................................................222
15.GeodCorporationv.NewJerseyTransitCorporation,etseq.678F.Supp.2d276,2009WL2595607(D.N.J.August20,2009)..............................................................................................................................................227
16.SouthFloridaChapteroftheAssociatedGeneralContractorsv.BrowardCounty,Florida,544F.Supp.2d1336(S.D.Fla.2008).................................................................................................................................................231
17.WesternStatesPavingCo.v.WashingtonDOT,USDOT&FHWA,2006WL1734163(W.D.Wash.June23,2006)(unpublishedopinion)........................................................................................................................233
18.NorthernContracting,Inc.v.Illinois,2005WL2230195(N.D.Ill.,2005),affirmed,473F.3d715(7thCir.2007).............................................................................................................................................................................234
19.NorthernContracting,Inc.v.StateofIllinois,IllinoisDOT,andUSDOT,2004WL422704(N.D.Ill.March3,2004).............................................................................................................................................................................240
20.SherbrookeTurf,Inc.v.MinnesotaDOT,2001WL1502841,No.00‐CV‐1026(D.Minn.2001)(unpublishedopinion),affirmed345F.3d964(8thCir.2003).......................................................................................242
21.GrossSeedCo.v.NebraskaDepartmentofRoads,CivilActionFileNo.4:00CV3073(D.Neb.May6,2002),affirmed345F.3d964(8thCir.2003)..........................................................................................................243
G.RecentDecisionsandAuthoritiesInvolvingFederalProcurementThatMayImpactDBEandMBE/WBEPrograms............................................................................................................................................................................244
1.RotheDevelopment,Inc.v.U.S.Dept.ofDefense,U.S.SmallBusinessAdministration,etal.,836F3d57,2016WL4719049(D.C.Cir.2016),cert.denied,2017WL1375832(2017),affirmingonothergrounds,RotheDevelopment,Inc.v.U.S.Dept.ofDefense,U.S.SmallBusinessAdministration,etal.,107F.Supp.3d183(D.D.C.2015).................................................................................................244
2.RotheDevelopmentCorp.v.U.S.Dept.ofDefense,etal.,545F.3d1023(Fed.Cir.2008).............................247
3.RotheDevelopment,Inc.v.U.S.Dept.ofDefenseandSmallBusinessAdministration,107F.Supp.3d183,2015WL3536271(D.D.C.2015),affirmedonothergrounds,836F.3d57,2016WL4719049(D.C.Cir.2016)................................................................................................................................................................256
4.DynaLanticCorp.v.UnitedStatesDept.ofDefense,etal.,885F.Supp.2d237,2012WL3356813(D.D.C.,2012),appealsvoluntarilydismissed,UnitedStatesCourtofAppeals,DistrictofColumbia,DocketNumbers12‐5329and12‐5330(2014)...................................................................................................................261
5.DynaLanticCorp.v.UnitedStatesDept.ofDefense,etal.,503F.Supp.2d262(D.D.C.2007).....................269
![Page 127: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/127.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 1
APPENDIX B. Legal Framework and Analysis
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
A. Introduction
Inthisappendix,Holland&KnightLLPanalyzesrecentcasesinvolvinglocalandstategovernmentminorityandwomen‐ownedanddisadvantaged‐ownedbusinessenterprise(“MBE/WBE/DBE”)programs.Theappendixalsoreviewsrecentcases,whichareinstructivetothestudyandMBE/WBE/DBEprograms,regardingtheFederalDisadvantagedBusinessEnterprise(“FederalDBE”)Program1andtheFederalAirportConcessionsDisadvantagedBusinessEnterprise(FederalACDBE)Program,2andtheimplementationoftheFederalDBEandACDBEProgramsbylocalandstategovernments.TheFederalDBEProgramrecentlywascontinuedandreauthorizedbytheFixingAmerica’sSurfaceTransportationAct(FASTAct)3.TheappendixprovidesasummaryofthelegalframeworkforthedisparitystudyasapplicabletotheCityandCountyofDenver.
AppendixBbeginswithareviewofthelandmarkUnitedStatesSupremeCourtdecisioninCityofRichmondv.J.A.Croson.4Crosonsetsforththestrictscrutinyconstitutionalanalysisapplicableinthelegalframeworkforconductingadisparitystudy.ThissectionalsonotestheUnitedStatesSupremeCourtdecisioninAdarandConstructors,Inc.v.Pena,5(“AdarandI”),whichappliedthestrictscrutinyanalysissetforthinCrosontofederalprogramsthatprovidefederalassistancetoarecipientoffederalfunds.TheSupremeCourt’sdecisionsinAdarandIandCroson,andsubsequentcasesandauthoritiesprovidethebasisforthelegalanalysisinconnectionwiththestudy.
Thelegalframeworkanalyzesandreviewssignificantrecentcourtdecisionsthathavefollowed,interpreted,andappliedCrosonandAdarandItothepresentandthatareapplicabletothisdisparitystudy,MBE/WBE/DBEPrograms,theFederalDBEProgram,theFederalACDBEProgram,andthestrictscrutinyanalysis.ThisanalysisreviewstheTenthCircuitCourtofAppealsdecisionsinAdarandConstructors,Inc.v.Slater(“AdarandVII”),6ConcreteWorksof
149CFRPart26(ParticipationbyDisadvantagedBusinessEnterprisesinDepartmentofTransportationFinancialAssistancePrograms(“FederalDBEProgram”).SeetheTransportationEquityActforthe21stCentury(TEA‐21)asamendedandreauthorized(“MAP‐21,”“SAFETEA”and“SAFETEA‐LU”),andtheUnitedStatesDepartmentofTransportation(“USDOT”or“DOT”)regulationspromulgatedtoimplementTEA‐21theFederalregulationsknownasMovingAheadforProgressinthe21stCenturyAct(“MAP‐21”),PubL.112‐141,H.R.4348,§1101(b),July6,2012,126Stat405.;precededbyPubL.109‐59,TitleI,§1101(b),August10,2005,119Stat.1156;precededbyPubL.105‐178,TitleI,§1101(b),June9,1998,112Stat.107.
249CFRPart23(ParticipationofDisadvantagedBusinessEnterprisesinAirportConcessions).
3Pub.L.114‐94,H.R.22,§1101(b),December4,2015,129Stat.1312.
4CityofRichmondv.J.A.Croson,488U.S.469(1989).
5AdarandConstructors,Inc.v.Pena,515U.S.200(1995).
6AdarandConstructors,Inc.v.Slater,228F.3d1147(10thCir.2000)(“AdarandVII”).
![Page 128: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/128.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 2
Colorado,Inc.v.CityandCountyofDenver7regardingMBE/WBE/DBEprograms,theFederalDBEProgram,andlocalandstategovernmentrecipientsoffederalfundsintheirimplementationoftheFederalDBEProgram.TheanalysisalsoreviewsrecentcourtdecisionsthatinvolvedchallengestoMBE/WBE/DBEprogramsinotherjuridictionsinSectionEbelow,whichareinformativetothestudy.
Inaddition,theanalysisreviewsinSectionFbelowotherrecentfederalcasesthathaveconsideredthevalidityoftheFederalDBEProgramanditsimplementationbyastateorlocalgovernmentagencyorarecipientoffederalfunds,including:DunnetBayConstructionCo.v.IllinoisDOT,8AssociatedGeneralContractorsofAmerica,SanDiegoChapter,Inc.v.CaliforniaDepartmentofTransportation(“Caltrans”),etal.,9WesternStatesPavingCo.v.WashingtonStateDOT,10MountainWestHoldingCo.v.Montana,MontanaDOT,etal.,11M.K.WeedenConstructionv.Montana,MontanaDOT,etal.,12NorthernContracting,Inc.v.IllinoisDOT,13SherbrookeTurf,Inc.v.MinnDOTandGrossSeedv.NebraskaDepartmentofRoads,14MidwestFenceCorp.v.U.S.DOT,FHWA,IllinoisDOT,IllinoisStateTollHighwayAuthority,etal.,15GeyerSignal,Inc.v.MinnesotaDOT,16GeodCorporationv.NewJerseyTransitCorporation,17andSouthFloridaChapteroftheA.G.C.v.BrowardCounty,Florida.18
Theanalysesoftheseandotherrecentcasessummarizedbelow,includingtheTenthCircuitdecisionsinAdarandConstructors,Inc.v.SlaterandConcreteWorksofColoradov.CityandCountyofDenver,areinstructivetothedisparitystudybecausetheyarethemostrecentandsignificantdecisionsbycourtssettingforththelegalframeworkappliedtoMBE/WBE/DBEPrograms,theFederalDBEandACDBEProgramsandtheirimplementationbylocalandstategovernmentsreceivingU.S.DOTfunds,disparitystudies,andconstruingthevalidityofgovernmentprogramsinvolvingMBE/WBE/DBEs/ACDBEs.Theyalsoareapplicableintermsofthepreparationofa
7ConcreteWorksofColorado,Inc.v.CityandCountyofDenver,321F.3d950(10thCir.2003),cert.denied,540U.S.1027,124S.Ct.556(2003)(Scalia,JusticewithwhomtheChiefJusticeRehnquist,joined,dissentingfromthedenialofcertiorari;ConcreteWorksofColorado,Inc.v.CityandCountyofDenver,36F.3d1513(10thCir.1994).
8DunnetBayConstructionCo.v.Borggren,IllinoisDOT,etal.,799F.3d676,2015WL4934560(7thCir.,2015),cert.denied,137S.Ct.31,2016WL193809,(October3,2016),DocketNo.15‐906;DunnetBayConstructionCo.v.IllinoisDOT,etal.2014WL552213(C.D.Ill.2014),affirmedbyDunnetBay,2015WL4934560(7thCir.,2015).
9AssociatedGeneralContractorsofAmerica,SanDiegoChapter,Inc.v.CaliforniaDepartmentofTransportation,etal.,713F.3d1187,(9thCir.2013);U.S.D.,C.,E.D.Cal,CivilActionNo.S‐09‐1622,SlipOpinionTranscript(E.D.Cal.April20,2011),appealdismissedbasedonstanding,onothergroundsNinthCircuitheldCaltrans’DBEProgramconstitutional,AssociatedGeneralContractorsofAmerica,SanDiegoChapter,Inc.v.CaliforniaDepartmentofTransportation,etal.,F.3d1187,(9thCir.2013).
10WesternStatesPavingCo.v.WashingtonStateDOT,407F.3d983(9thCir.2005),cert.denied,546U.S.1170(2006).
11MountainWestHoldingCo.,Inc.v.Montana,2017WL2179120(9thCir.May16,2017),Memorandum,(NotforPublication)U.S.CourtofAppealsfortheNinthCircuit,May16,2017,DocketNos.14‐26097and15‐35003,dismissinginpart,reversinginpartandremandingtheU.S.DistrictCourtdecisionat2014WL6686734(D.Mont.2014).
12M.K.WeedenConstructionv.StateofMontana,MontanaDOT,2013WL4774517(D.Mont.2013).
13NorthernContracting,Inc.v.IllinoisDOT,473F.3d715(7thCir.2007).
14SherbrookeTurf,Inc.v.Minn.DOTandGrossSeedv.NebraskaDepartmentofRoads,345F.3d964(8thCir.2003),cert.denied,
541U.S.1041(2004).
15MidwestFenceCorp.v.U.S.DOT,FHWA,IllinoisDOT,IllinoisStateTollHighwayAuthority,etal.,840F.3d932,2016WL6543514(7thCir.2016).MidwestFencefiledaPetitionforaWritofCertiorariwiththeU.S.SupremeCourt,see2017WL511931(Feb.2,2017),whichwasdenied,2017WL497345(June26,2017)..
16GeyerSignal,Inc.v.MinnesotaDOT,2014W.L.1309092(D.Minn.2014).
17GeodCorporationv.NewJerseyTransitCorporation,766F.Supp.2d642(D.N.J.2010).
18SouthFloridaChapteroftheA.G.C.v.BrowardCounty,Florida,544F.Supp.2d1336(S.D.Fla.2008).
![Page 129: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/129.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 3
DBEProgramandACDBEProgrambyDenversubmittedincompliancewiththefederalDBEandACDBEregulations.
AlthoughthesecasesdidnotinvolvespecificchallengestotheFederalACDBEProgram,theyareapplicableandinstructivetothestudyinconnectionwiththeimplementationoftheFederalACDBEProgrambyrecipientsofU.S.DOTfundsgovernedby49CFRPart23(“ParticipationofDisadvantagedBusinessEnterpriseinAirportConcessions”).TheFederalDBEProgramandtheFederalACDBEProgramaresimilarinmanyrespectsandtheACDBEPrograminitsregulationslocatedat49CFRPart23expresslyincorporatesmanyofthefederalregulationslocatedin49CFRPart26.
B. U.S. Supreme Court Cases
1. City of Richmond v. J.A. Croson Co., 488 U.S. 469 (1989)
InCroson,theU.S.SupremeCourtstruckdowntheCityofRichmond’s“set‐aside”programasunconstitutionalbecauseitdidnotsatisfythestrictscrutinyanalysisappliedto“race‐based”governmentalprograms.19J.A.CrosonCo.(“Croson”)challengedtheCityofRichmond’sminoritycontractingpreferenceplan,whichrequiredprimecontractorstosubcontractatleast30percentofthedollaramountofcontractstooneormoreMinorityBusinessEnterprises(“MBE”).Inenactingtheplan,theCitycitedpastdiscriminationandanintenttoincreaseminoritybusinessparticipationinconstructionprojectsasmotivatingfactors.
TheSupremeCourtheldtheCityofRichmond’s“set‐aside”actionplanviolatedtheEqualProtectionClauseoftheFourteenthAmendment.TheCourtappliedthe“strictscrutiny”standard,generallyapplicabletoanyrace‐basedclassification,whichrequiresagovernmentalentitytohavea“compellinggovernmentalinterest”inremedyingpastidentifieddiscriminationandthatanyprogramadoptedbyalocalorstategovernmentmustbe“narrowlytailored”toachievethegoalofremedyingtheidentifieddiscrimination.
TheCourtdeterminedthattheplanneitherserveda“compellinggovernmentalinterest”noroffereda“narrowlytailored”remedytopastdiscrimination.TheCourtfoundno“compellinggovernmentalinterest”becausetheCityhadnotprovided“astrongbasisinevidenceforitsconclusionthat[race‐based]remedialactionwasnecessary.”20TheCourtheldtheCitypresentednodirectevidenceofanyracediscriminationonitspartinawardingconstructioncontractsoranyevidencethattheCity’sprimecontractorshaddiscriminatedagainstminority‐ownedsubcontractors.21TheCourtalsofoundtherewereonlygeneralizedallegationsofsocietalandindustrydiscriminationcoupledwithpositivelegislativemotives.TheCourtconcludedthatthiswasinsufficientevidencetodemonstrateacompellinginterestinawardingpubliccontractsonthebasisofrace.
Similarly,theCourtheldtheCityfailedtodemonstratethattheplanwas“narrowlytailored”forseveralreasons,includingbecausetheredidnotappeartohavebeenanyconsiderationofrace‐
19488U.S.469(1989).
20488U.S.at500,510.
21488U.S.at480,505.
![Page 130: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/130.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 4
neutralmeanstoincreaseminoritybusinessparticipationincitycontracting,andbecauseoftheoverinclusivenessofcertainminoritiesinthe“preference”program(forexample,Aleuts)withoutanyevidencetheysuffereddiscriminationinRichmond.22
TheCourtstatedthatrelianceonthedisparitybetweenthenumberofprimecontractsawardedtominorityfirmsandtheminoritypopulationoftheCityofRichmondwasmisplaced.Thereisnodoubt,theCourtheld,that“[w]heregrossstatisticaldisparitiescanbeshown,theyaloneinapropercasemayconstituteprimafacieproofofapatternorpracticeofdiscrimination”underTitleVII.,23.Butitisequallyclearthat“[w]henspecialqualificationsarerequiredtofillparticularjobs,comparisonstothegeneralpopulation(ratherthantothesmallergroupofindividualswhopossessthenecessaryqualifications)mayhavelittleprobativevalue.”24
TheCourtconcludedthatwherespecialqualificationsarenecessary,therelevantstatisticalpoolforpurposesofdemonstratingdiscriminatoryexclusionmustbethenumberofminoritiesqualifiedtoundertaketheparticulartask.TheCourtnotedthat“thecitydoesnotevenknowhowmanyMBE’sintherelevantmarketarequalifiedtoundertakeprimeorsubcontractingworkinpublicconstructionprojects.”25“Nordoesthecityknowwhatpercentageoftotalcityconstructiondollarsminorityfirmsnowreceiveassubcontractorsonprimecontractsletbythecity.”26
TheSupremeCourtstatedthatitdidnotintenditsdecisiontoprecludeastateorlocalgovernmentfrom“takingactiontorectifytheeffectsofidentifieddiscriminationwithinitsjurisdiction.”27TheCourtheldthat“[w]herethereisasignificantstatisticaldisparitybetweenthenumberofqualifiedminoritycontractorswillingandabletoperformaparticularserviceandthenumberofsuchcontractorsactuallyengagedbythelocalityorthelocality’sprimecontractors,aninferenceofdiscriminatoryexclusioncouldarise.”28
TheCourtsaid:“IftheCityofRichmondhadevidencebeforeitthatnonminoritycontractorsweresystematicallyexcludingminoritybusinessesfromsubcontractingopportunitiesitcouldtakeactiontoendthediscriminatoryexclusion.”29“Undersuchcircumstances,thecitycouldacttodismantletheclosedbusinesssystembytakingappropriatemeasuresagainstthosewhodiscriminateonthebasisofraceorotherillegitimatecriteria.”“Intheextremecase,someformofnarrowlytailoredracialpreferencemightbenecessarytobreakdownpatternsofdeliberateexclusion.”30
22488U.S.at507‐510.
23488U.S.at501,quotingHazelwoodSchoolDist.v.UnitedStates,433U.S.299,307–308,97S.Ct.2736,2741.
24488U.S.at501quotingHazelwood,433U.S.at308,n.13,97S.Ct.,at2742,n.13.
25488U.S.at502.
26Id.
27488U.S.at509.
28Id.
29488U.S.at509.
30Id.
![Page 131: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/131.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 5
TheCourtfurtherfound“iftheCitycouldshowthatithadessentiallybecomea‘passiveparticipant’inasystemofracialexclusionpracticedbyelementsofthelocalconstructionindustry,wethinkitclearthattheCitycouldtakeaffirmativestepstodismantlesuchasystem.Itisbeyonddisputethatanypublicentity,stateorfederal,hasacompellinginterestinassuringthatpublicdollars,drawnfromthetaxcontributionsofallcitizens,donotservetofinancetheevilofprivateprejudice.”31
2. Adarand Constructors, Inc. v. Pena (“Adarand I”), 515 U.S. 200 (1995)
InAdarandI,theU.S.SupremeCourtextendedtheholdinginCrosonandruledthatallfederalgovernmentprogramsthatuseracialorethniccriteriaasfactorsinprocurementdecisionsmustpassatestofstrictscrutinyinordertosurviveconstitutionalmuster.
ThecasesinterpretingCrosonandAdarandIarethemostrecentandsignificantdecisionsbyfederalcourtssettingforththelegalframeworkfordisparitystudiesaswellasthepredicatetosatisfytheconstitutionalstrictscrutinystandardofreview,whichappliestotheimplementationoftheFederalDBEProgramandACDBEProgrambyrecipientsoffederalfunds.
C. The Legal Framework Applied to State and Local Government MBE/WBE/DBE Programs and the Federal DBE and ACDBE Programs
ThefollowingprovidesananalysisforthelegalframeworkfocusingonrecentkeycasesregardingstateandlocalMBE/WBE/DBEprograms,andtheirimplicationsforadisparitystudy.Therecentdecisionsinvolvingtheseprograms,theFederalDBEProgram,anditsimplementationbystateandlocalprograms,areinstructivebecausetheyconcernthestrictscrutinyanalysis,thelegalframeworkinthisarea,challengestothevalidityofMBE/WBE/DBEprograms,andananalysisofdisparitystudies,andimplementationoftheFederalDBEandACDBEProgramsbylocalgovernmentrecipientsoffederalfinancialassistance(U.S.DOTfunds)basedon49CFRPart26and49CFRPart23.
1. Strict scrutiny analysis
Arace‐andethnicity‐basedprogramimplementedbyastateorlocalgovernmentissubjecttothestrictscrutinyconstitutionalanalysis.32Thestrictscrutinyanalysisiscomprisedoftwoprongs:
Theprogrammustserveanestablishedcompellinggovernmentalinterest;and
31488U.S.at492.
32Croson,448U.S.at492‐493;AdarandConstructors,Inc.v.Pena(AdarandI),515U.S.200,227(1995);see,e.g.,Fisherv.UniversityofTexas,133S.Ct.2411(2013);MidwestFencev.IllinoisDOT,840F.3d932,935,948‐954(7thCir.2016);AGC,SDCv.Caltrans,713F.3d1187,1195‐1200(9thCir.2013);H.B.RoweCo.,Inc.v.NCDOT,615F.3d233,241‐242(4thCir.2010);NorthernContracting,473F.3dat721;WesternStatesPaving,407F.3dat991;SherbrookeTurf,345F.3dat969;AdarandVII,228F.3dat1176(10thCir.2000);W.H.ScottConstr.Co.v.CityofJackson,Mississippi,199F.3d206(5thCir.1999);ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia(“CAEPII”),91F.3d586(3d.Cir.1996);ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia(“CAEPI”),6F.3d990(3d.Cir.1993).
![Page 132: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/132.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 6
Theprogrammustbenarrowlytailoredtoachievethatcompellinggovernmentinterest.33
a. The Compelling Governmental Interest Requirement
Thefirstprongofthestrictscrutinyanalysisrequiresagovernmentalentitytohavea“compellinggovernmentalinterest”inremedyingpastidentifieddiscriminationinordertoimplementarace‐andethnicity‐basedprogram.34Stateandlocalgovernmentscannotrelyonnationalstatisticsofdiscriminationinanindustrytodrawconclusionsabouttheprevailingmarketconditionsintheirownregions.35Rather,stateandlocalgovernmentsmustmeasurediscriminationintheirstateorlocalmarket.However,thatisnotnecessarilyconfinedbythejurisdiction’sboundaries.36
ItisinstructivetoreviewthetypeofevidenceutilizedbyCongressandconsideredbythecourtstosupporttheFederalDBEProgram,anditsimplementationbylocalandstategovernmentsandagencies,whichissimilartoevidenceconsideredbycasesrulingonthevalidityofMBE/WBE/DBEprograms.ThefederalcourtsfoundCongress“spentdecadescompilingevidenceofracediscriminationingovernmenthighwaycontracting,ofbarrierstotheformationofminority‐ownedconstructionbusinesses,andofbarrierstoentry.”37Theevidencefoundtosatisfythecompellingintereststandardincludednumerouscongressionalinvestigationsandhearings,andoutsidestudiesofstatisticalandanecdotalevidence(e.g.,disparitystudies).38TheevidentiarybasisonwhichCongressreliedtosupportitsfindingofdiscriminationincludes:
Barriers to minority business formation. Congressfoundthatdiscriminationbyprimecontractors,unions,andlendershaswoefullyimpededtheformationofqualifiedminoritybusinessenterprisesinthesubcontractingmarketnationwide,notingtheexistenceof“goodol’boy”networks,fromwhichminorityfirmshavetraditionallybeenexcluded,andtherace‐baseddenialofaccesstocapital,whichaffectstheformationofminoritysubcontractingenterprise.39
Barriers to competition for existing minority enterprises.Congressfoundevidenceshowingsystematicexclusionanddiscriminationbyprimecontractors,privatesectorcustomers,businessnetworks,suppliers,andbondingcompaniesprecludingminority
33AdarandI,515U.S.200,227(1995);MidwestFencev.IllinoisDOT,840F.3d932,935,948‐954(7thCir.2016);AGC,SDCv.Caltrans,713F.3d1187,1195‐1200(9thCir.2013);H.B.RoweCo.,Inc.v.NCDOT,615F.3d233,241‐242(4thCir.2010);NorthernContracting,473F.3dat721;WesternStatesPaving,407F.3dat991(9thCir.2005);SherbrookeTurf,345F.3dat969;AdarandVII,228F.3dat1176(10thCir.2000);AssociatedGen.ContractorsofOhio,Inc.v.Drabik(“DrabikII”),214F.3d730(6thCir.2000);W.H.ScottConstr.Co.v.CityofJackson,Mississippi,199F.3d206(5thCir.1999);Eng’gContractorsAss’nofSouthFlorida,Inc.v.Metro.DadeCounty,122F.3d895(11thCir.1997);ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia(“CAEPII”),91F.3d586(3d.Cir.1996);ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia(“CAEPI”),6F.3d990(3d.Cir.1993).
34Id.
35Id.;see,e.g.,ConcreteWorks,Inc.v.CityandCountyofDenver(“ConcreteWorksI”),36F.3d1513,1520(10thCir.1994).
36See,e.g.,ConcreteWorksI,36F.3dat1520.
37SherbrookeTurf,345F.3dat970,(citingAdarandVII,228F.3dat1167–76(10thCir.2000);WesternStatesPaving,407F.3dat992‐93.
38See,e.g.,AdarandVII,228F.3dat1167–76(10thCir.2000);seealsoWesternStatesPaving,407F.3dat992(Congress“explicitlyreliedupon”theDepartmentofJusticestudythat“documentedthediscriminatoryhurdlesthatminoritiesmustovercometosecurefederallyfundedcontracts”);GeyerSignal,Inc.,2014WL1309092.
39AdarandVII,228F.3d.at1168‐70(10thCir.2000);WesternStatesPaving,407F.3dat992;seeGeyerSignal,Inc.,2014WL1309092;DynaLantic,885F.Supp.2d237.
![Page 133: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/133.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 7
enterprisesfromopportunitiestobid.Whenminorityfirmsarepermittedtobidonsubcontracts,primecontractorsoftenresistworkingwiththem.Congressfoundevidenceofthesameprimecontractorusingaminoritybusinessenterpriseonagovernmentcontractnotusingthatminoritybusinessenterpriseonaprivatecontract,despitebeingsatisfiedwiththatsubcontractor’swork.Congressfoundthatinformal,raciallyexclusionarybusinessnetworksdominatethesubcontractingconstructionindustry.40
Local disparity studies. Congressfoundthatlocalstudiesthroughoutthecountrytendtoshowadisparitybetweenutilizationandavailabilityofminority‐ownedfirms,raisinganinferenceofdiscrimination.41
Results of removing affirmative action programs. Congressfoundevidencethatwhenrace‐consciouspubliccontractingprogramsarestruckdownordiscontinued,minoritybusinessparticipationintherelevantmarketdropssharplyorevendisappears,whichcourtshavefoundstronglysupportsthegovernment’sclaimthattherearesignificantbarrierstominoritycompetition,raisingthespecterofdiscrimination.42
FAST Act and MAP‐21.InDecember2015andinJuly2012,CongresspassedtheFASTActandMAP‐21,respectively(seeabove),whichmade“Findings”that“discriminationandrelatedbarrierscontinuetoposesignificantobstaclesforminority‐andwomen‐ownedbusinessesseekingtodobusinessinfederally‐assistedsurfacetransportationmarkets,”andthatthecontinuingbarriers“meritthecontinuation”oftheFederalDBEProgram.43CongressalsofoundinboththeFASTActandMAP‐21thatitreceivedandreviewedtestimonyanddocumentationofraceandgenderdiscriminationwhich“provideastrongbasisthatthereisacompellingneedforthecontinuationofthe”FederalDBEProgram.44
The Federal DBE Program (and ACDBE Program). AftertheAdaranddecision,theU.S.DepartmentofJusticein1996conductedastudyofevidenceontheissueofdiscriminationingovernmentconstructionprocurementcontracts,whichCongressrelieduponasdocumentingacompellinggovernmentalinteresttohaveafederalprogramtoremedytheeffectsofcurrentandpastdiscriminationinthetransportationcontractingindustryforfederally‐fundedcontracts.45Subsequently,in1998,CongresspassedtheTransportationEquityActforthe21stCentury(“TEA‐21”),whichauthorizedtheUnitedStatesDepartmentofTransportationtoexpendfundsforfederalhighwayprogramsfor1998‐2003.Pub.L.105‐178,TitleI,§1101(b),112Stat.107,113(1998).TheUSDOTpromulgatednewregulationsin1999containedat49CFRPart26toestablishthecurrentFederalDBEProgram.TheTEA‐21wassubsequentlyextendedin2003,2005and2012.ThereauthorizationofTEA‐21in2005wasforafive‐yearperiodfrom2005to2009.Pub.L.109‐59,TitleI,§1101(b),August10,2005,119Stat.1153‐57(“SAFETEA”).InJuly
40AdarandVII,at1170‐72(10thCir.2000);seeDynaLantic,885F.Supp.2d237.
41Id.at1172‐74(10thCir.2000);seeDynaLantic,885F.Supp.2d237;GeyerSignal,Inc.,2014WL1309092.
42AdarandVII,228F.3dat1174‐75(10thCir.2000);see,H.B.Rowe,615F.3d233,247‐258(4thCir.2010);SherbrookeTurf,345F.3dat973‐4.
43PubL.114‐94,H.R.22,§1101(b),December4,2015,129Stat1312;PubL.112‐141,H.R.4348,§1101(b),July6,2012,126Stat405.
44Id.at§1101(b)(1).
45Appendix‐TheCompellingInterestforAffirmativeActioninFederalProcurement,61Fed.Reg.26,050,26,051‐63&nn.1‐136(May23,1996)(hereinafter“TheCompellingInterest”);seeAdarandVII,228F.3dat1167‐1176,citingTheCompellingInterest.
![Page 134: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/134.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 8
2012,CongresspassedtheMovingAheadforProgressinthe21stCenturyAct(“MAP‐21”).46InDecember2015,CongresspassedtheFixingAmerica’sSurfaceTransportationAct(“FASTAct”).47
TheFederalDBEProgramasamendedchangedcertainrequirementsforfederalaidrecipientsandaccordinglychangedhowrecipientsoffederalfundsimplementedtheFederalDBEProgramforfederally‐assistedcontracts.Thefederalgovernmentdeterminedthatthereisacompellinggovernmentalinterestforrace‐andgender‐basedprogramsatthenationallevel,andthattheprogramisnarrowlytailoredbecauseofthefederalregulations,includingtheflexibilityinimplementationprovidedtoindividualfederalaidrecipientsbytheregulations.Stateandlocalgovernmentsarenotrequiredtoimplementrace‐andgender‐basedmeasureswheretheyarenotnecessarytoachieveDBEgoalsandthosegoalsmaybeachievedbyrace‐andgender‐neutralmeasures.48
TheFederalDBEandACDBEProgramsestablishedresponsibilityforimplementingtheDBEandACDBEProgramstostateandlocalgovernmentrecipientsoffederalfunds.ArecipientoffederalfinancialassistancemustsetanannualDBEand/orACDBEgoalsspecifictoconditionsintherelevantmarketplace.Eventhoughanoverallannual10percentaspirationalgoalappliesatthefederallevel,itdoesnotaffectthegoalsestablishedbyindividualstateorlocalgovernmentalrecipients.TheFederalDBEandACDBEProgramsoutlinecertainstepsastateorlocalgovernmentrecipientcanfollowinestablishingagoal,andUSDOTconsidersandmustapprovethegoalandtherecipient’sDBEandACDBEprograms.TheimplementationoftheFederalDBEandACDBEProgramsaresubstantiallyinthehandsofthestateorlocalgovernmentrecipientandissetforthindetailinthefederalregulations,including49CFRPart26andsection26.45,and49CFR§§23.41‐51.
Providedin49CFR§26.45and49CFR§§23.41‐51areinstructionsastohowrecipientsoffederalfundsshouldsettheoverallgoalsfortheirDBEprograms.Insummary,therecipientestablishesabasefigureforrelativeavailabilityofDBEs.49Thisisaccomplishedbydeterminingtherelativenumberofready,willing,andableDBEsandACDBEsintherecipient’smarket.50Second,therecipientmustdetermineanappropriateadjustment,ifany,tothebasefiguretoarriveattheoverallgoal.51Therearemanytypesofevidenceconsideredwhendeterminingifanadjustmentisappropriate,accordingto49CFR§26.45(d)and49CFR§23.51(d).Theseinclude,amongothertypes,thecurrentcapacityofDBEsandACDBEstoperformworkontherecipient’scontractsasmeasuredbythevolumeofworkDBEsandACDBEshaveperformedinrecentyears.Ifavailable,recipientsconsiderevidencefromrelatedfieldsthataffecttheopportunitiesforDBEsandACDBEstoform,grow,andcompete,suchasstatisticaldisparitiesbetweentheabilityofDBEsandACDBEstoobtainfinancing,bonding,andinsurance,aswellasdataonemployment,
46PubL.112‐141,H.R.4348,§1101(b),July6,2012,126Stat405.
47Pub.L.114‐94,H.R.22,§1101(b),December4,2015,129Stat.1312.
4849CFR§26.51;see49CFR§23.25.
4949CFR§26.45(a),(b),(c);49CFR§23.51(a),(b),(c).
50Id.
51Id.at§26.45(d);Id.at§23.51(d).
![Page 135: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/135.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 9
education,andtraining.52Thisprocess,basedonthefederalregulations,aimstoestablishagoalthatreflectsadeterminationofthelevelofDBEandACDBEparticipationonewouldexpectabsenttheeffectsofdiscrimination.53
Further,theFederalDBEandACDBEProgramsrequirestateandlocalgovernmentrecipientsoffederalfundstoassesshowmuchoftheDBEandACDBEgoalscanbemetthroughrace‐andgender‐neutraleffortsandwhatpercentage,ifany,shouldbemetthroughrace‐andgender‐basedefforts.54Astateorlocalgovernmentrecipientisresponsibleforseriouslyconsideringanddeterminingrace‐andgender‐neutralmeasuresthatcanbeimplemented.55
FederalaidrecipientsaretocertifyDBEsandACDBEsaccordingtotheirrace/gender,size,networthandotherfactorsrelatedtodefininganeconomicallyandsociallydisadvantagedbusinessasoutlinedin49CFR§§26.61‐26.73.56
Fixing America's Surface Transportation Act'' or the ``FAST Act'' (December 4, 2015).OnDecember3,2015,theFixingAmerica'sSurfaceTransportationAct''orthe``FASTAct''waspassedbyCongress,anditwassignedbythePresidentonDecember4,2015,asthenewfive‐yearsurfacetransportationauthorizationlaw.TheFASTActcontinuestheFederalDBEProgramandmakesthefollowing“Findings”inSection1101(b)oftheAct:
SEC. 1101. AUTHORIZATION OF APPROPRIATIONS.
(b)DisadvantagedBusinessEnterprises‐
(1)FINDINGS‐Congressfindsthat—
(A)whilesignificantprogresshasoccurredduetotheestablishmentofthedisadvantagedbusinessenterpriseprogram,discriminationandrelatedbarrierscontinuetoposesignificantobstaclesforminority‐andwomen‐ownedbusinessesseekingtodobusinessinfederallyassistedsurfacetransportationmarketsacrosstheUnitedStates;
(B)thecontinuingbarriersdescribedinsubparagraph(A)meritthecontinuationofthedisadvantagedbusinessenterpriseprogram;
(C)Congresshasreceivedandreviewedtestimonyanddocumentationofraceandgenderdiscriminationfromnumeroussources,includingcongressionalhearingsandroundtables,scientificreports,reportsissuedbypublicandprivateagencies,newsstories,reportsofdiscriminationbyorganizationsandindividuals,anddiscriminationlawsuits,whichshowthatrace‐andgender‐neutraleffortsaloneareinsufficienttoaddresstheproblem;
52Id.
5349CFR§26.45(b)‐(d);49CFR§23.51.
5449CFR§26.51;49CFR§23.51(a).
5549CFR§26.51(b);49CFR§23.25.
5649CFR§§26.61‐26.73;49CFR§§23.31‐23.39.
![Page 136: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/136.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 10
(D)thetestimonyanddocumentationdescribedinsubparagraph(C)demonstratethatdiscriminationacrosstheUnitedStatesposesabarriertofullandfairparticipationinsurfacetransportation‐relatedbusinessesofwomenbusinessownersandminoritybusinessownersandhasimpactedfirmdevelopmentandmanyaspectsofsurfacetransportation‐relatedbusinessinthepublicandprivatemarkets;and
(E)thetestimonyanddocumentationdescribedinsubparagraph(C)provideastrongbasisthatthereisacompellingneedforthecontinuationofthedisadvantagedbusinessenterpriseprogramtoaddressraceandgenderdiscriminationinsurfacetransportation‐relatedbusiness.
Therefore,CongressintheFASTActpassedonDecember3,2015,foundbasedontestimony,evidenceanddocumentationupdatedsinceMAP‐21wasadoptedin2012asfollows:(1)discriminationandrelatedbarrierscontinuetoposesignificantobstaclesforminority‐andwomen‐ownedbusinessesseekingtodobusinessinfederallyassistedsurfacetransportationmarketsacrosstheUnitedStates;(2)thecontinuingbarriersdescribedin§1101(b),subparagraph(A)abovemeritthecontinuationofthedisadvantagedbusinessenterpriseprogram;and(3)thereisacompellingneedforthecontinuationofthedisadvantagedbusinessenterpriseprogramtoaddressraceandgenderdiscriminationinsurfacetransportation‐relatedbusiness.57
MAP‐21 (July 2012).Inthe2012MovingAheadforProgressinthe21stCenturyAct(MAP‐21),Congressprovided“Findings”that“discriminationandrelatedbarriers”“meritthecontinuationofthe”FederalDBEProgram.58InMAP‐21,Congressspecificallyfoundasfollows:
“(A) while significant progress has occurred due to the establishment of thedisadvantagedbusiness enterpriseprogram,discrimination and relatedbarrierscontinuetoposesignificantobstaclesforminority‐andwomen‐ownedbusinessesseekingtodobusinessinfederally‐assistedsurfacetransportationmarketsacrosstheUnitedStates;
(B)thecontinuingbarriersdescribedinsubparagraph(A)meritthecontinuationofthedisadvantagedbusinessenterpriseprogram;
(C)Congresshasreceivedandreviewedtestimonyanddocumentationofraceandgenderdiscrimination fromnumeroussources, includingcongressionalhearingsandroundtables,scientificreports,reportsissuedbypublicandprivateagencies,news stories, reports of discrimination by organizations and individuals, anddiscrimination lawsuits,which show that race‐ and gender‐neutral efforts aloneareinsufficienttoaddresstheproblem;
(D)thetestimonyanddocumentationdescribedinsubparagraph(C)demonstratethat discrimination across the United States poses a barrier to full and fairparticipation in surface transportation‐related businesses of women businessowners andminority business owners and has impacted firmdevelopment and
57PubL.114‐94,H.R.22,§1101(b),December4,2015,129Stat1312.
58PubL.112‐141,H.R.4348,§1101(b),July6,2012,126Stat405.
![Page 137: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/137.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 11
manyaspectsofsurfacetransportation‐relatedbusinessinthepublicandprivatemarkets;and
(E) the testimony and documentation described in subparagraph (C) provide astrong basis that there is a compelling need for the continuation of thedisadvantaged business enterprise program to address race and genderdiscriminationinsurfacetransportation‐relatedbusiness.”59
Thus,CongressinMAP‐21determinedbasedontestimonyanddocumentationofraceandgenderdiscriminationthattherewas“acompellingneedforthecontinuationofthe”FederalDBEProgram.60
USDOT Final Rule, 76 Fed. Reg. 5083 (January 28, 2011). TheUnitedStatesDepartmentofTransportationpromulgatedaFinalRuleonJanuary28,2011,effectiveFebruary28,2011,76Fed.Reg.5083(January28,2011)(“2011FinalRule”)amendingtheFederalDBEProgramat49CFRPart26.
TheDepartmentstatedinthe2011FinalRulewithregardtodisparitystudiesandincalculatinggoals,thatitagrees“itisreasonable,incalculatinggoalsandindoingdisparitystudies,toconsiderpotentialDBEs(e.g.,firmsapparentlyownedandcontrolledbyminoritiesorwomenthathavenotbeencertifiedundertheDBEprogram)aswellascertifiedDBEs.ThisisconsistentwithgoodpracticeinthefieldaswellaswithDOTguidance.”61
TheUnitedStatesDOTinthe2011FinalRulestatedthattherewasacontinuingcompellingneedfortheDBEprogram.62TheDOTconcludedthat,ascourtdecisionshavenoted,theDOT’sDBEregulationsandthestatutesauthorizingthem,“aresupportedbyacompellingneedtoaddressdiscriminationanditseffects.”63TheDOTsaidthatthe“basisfortheprogramhasbeenestablishedbyCongressandappliesonanationwidebasis…”,notedthatboththeHouseandSenateFederalAviationAdministration(“FAA”)ReauthorizationBillscontainedfindingsreaffirmingthecompellingneedfortheprogram,andreferencedadditionalinformationpresentedtotheHouseofRepresentativesinaMarch26,2009hearingbeforetheTransportationandInfrastructureCommittee,andaDepartmentofJusticedocumententitled“TheCompellingInterestforRace‐andGender‐ConsciousFederalContractingPrograms:ADecadeLaterAnUpdatetotheMay23,1996ReviewofBarriersforMinority‐andWomen‐OwnedBusinesses.”64Thisinformation,theDOTstated,“confirmsthecontinuingcompellingneedforrace‐andgender‐consciousprogramssuchastheDOTDBEprogram.”65
Burden of proof.Underthestrictscrutinyanalysis,andtotheextentastateorlocalgovernmentalentityhasimplementedarace‐andgender‐consciousprogram,thegovernmental
59PubL.112‐141,H.R.4348,§1101(b),July6,2012,126Stat405.
60Id.
6176F.R.at5092.
6276F.R.at5095.
6376F.R.at5095.
64Id.
65Id.
![Page 138: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/138.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 12
entityhastheinitialburdenofshowingastrongbasisinevidence(includingstatisticalandanecdotalevidence)tosupportitsremedialaction.66Ifthegovernmentmakesitsinitialshowing,theburdenshiftstothechallengertorebutthatshowing.67Thechallengerbearstheultimateburdenofshowingthatthegovernmentalentity’sevidence“didnotsupportaninferenceofpriordiscrimination.”68
Inapplyingthestrictscrutinyanalysis,thecourtsholdthattheburdenisonthegovernmenttoshowbothacompellinginterestandnarrowtailoring.69Itiswellestablishedthat“remedyingtheeffectsofpastorpresentracialdiscrimination”isacompellinginterest.70Inaddition,thegovernmentmustalsodemonstrate“astrongbasisinevidenceforitsconclusionthatremedialaction[is]necessary.”71
SincethedecisionbytheSupremeCourtinCroson,“numerouscourtshaverecognizedthatdisparitystudiesprovideprobativeevidenceofdiscrimination.”72“Aninferenceofdiscriminationmaybemadewithempiricalevidencethatdemonstrates‘asignificantstatisticaldisparitybetweenanumberofqualifiedminoritycontractors…andthenumberofsuchcontractorsactuallyengagedbythelocalityorthelocality’sprimecontractors.’”73Anecdotal
66SeeAGC,SDCv.Caltrans,713F.3rdat1195;H.B.RoweCo.,Inc.v.NCDOT,615F.3d233,241‐242,247‐258(4thCir.2010);RotheDevelopmentCorp.v.DepartmentofDefense,545F.3d1023,1036(Fed.Cir.2008);N.Contracting,Inc.Illinois,473F.3dat715,721(7thCir.2007)(FederalDBEProgram);WesternStatesPavingCo.v.WashingtonStateDOT,407F.3d983,990‐991(9thCir.2005)(FederalDBEProgram);SherbrookeTurf,Inc.v.MinnesotaDOT,345F.3d964,969(8thCir.2003)(FederalDBEProgram);AdarandConstructorsInc.v.Slater(“AdarandVII”),228F.3d1147,1166(10thCir.2000)(FederalDBEProgram);Eng’gContractorsAss’n,122F.3dat916;MontereyMechanicalCo.v.Wilson,125F.3d702,713(9thCir.1997);ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia(“CAEPII”),91F.3d586,596‐598(3d.Cir.1996);ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia(“CAEPI”),6F.3d996,1005‐1007(3d.Cir.1993);GeyerSignal,Inc.,2014WL1309092;DynaLantic,885F.Supp.2d237,2012WL3356813;HershellGillConsultingEngineers,Inc.v.MiamiDadeCounty,333F.Supp.2d1305,1316(S.D.Fla.2004).
67AdarandVII,228F.3dat1166;ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia(“CAEPII”),91F.3d586,596‐598(3d.Cir.1996);ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia(“CAEPI”),6F.3d996,1005‐1007(3d.Cir.1993);Eng’gContractorsAss’n,122F.3dat916;GeyerSignal,Inc.,2014WL1309092.
68See,e.g.,AdarandVII,228F.3dat1166;ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia(“CAEPII”),91F.3d586,596‐598(3d.Cir.1996);ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia(“CAEPI”),6F.3d996,1005‐1007(3d.Cir.1993);Eng’gContractorsAss’n,122F.3dat916;seealsoSherbrookeTurf,345F.3dat971;N.Contracting,473F.3dat721;GeyerSignal,Inc.,2014WL1309092.
69Id.;MidwestFence,840F.3d932,935,948‐954(7thCir.2016);H.B.RoweCo.,Inc.v.NCDOT,615F.3d233,241‐242(4thCir.2010);WesternStatesPaving,407F.3dat990;SeealsoMajeskev.CityofChicago,218F.3d816,820(7thCir.2000);GeyerSignal,Inc.,2014WL1309092.
70Shawv.V.Hunt,517U.S.899,909(1996);CityofRichmondv.J.A.CrosonCo.,488U.S.469,492(1989);see,e.g.,MidwestFence,840F.3d932,935,948‐954(7thCir.2016);ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia(“CAEPII”),91F.3d586,596‐598(3d.Cir.1996);ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia(“CAEPI”),6F.3d996,1005‐1007(3d.Cir.1993).
71Croson,488U.S.at500;see,e.g.,MidwestFence,840F.3d932,935,948‐954(7thCir.2016);H.B.RoweCo.,Inc.v.NCDOT,615F.3d233,241‐242;SherbrookeTurf,345F.3dat971‐972;ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia(“CAEPII”),91F.3d586,596‐598(3d.Cir.1996);ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia(“CAEPI”),6F.3d996,1005‐1007(3d.Cir.1993);GeyerSignal,Inc.,2014WL1309092.
72MidwestFence,2015W.L.1396376at*7(N.D.Ill.2015),affirmed,840F.3d932,2016WL6543514(7thCir.2016);see,e.g.,MidwestFence,840F.3d932,935,948‐954(7thCir.2016);AGC,SDCv.Caltrans,713F.3rdat1195‐1200;H.B.RoweCo.,Inc.v.NCDOT,615F.3d233,241‐242(4thCir.2010);ConcreteWorksofColo.Inc.v.CityandCountyofDenver,36F.3d1513,1522(10thCir.1994),GeyerSignal,2014WL1309092(D.Minn,2014);seealso,ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia(“CAEPII”),91F.3d586,596‐598(3d.Cir.1996);ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia(“CAEPI”),6F.3d996,1005‐1007(3d.Cir.1993).
73Seee.g.,H.B.Rowev.NCDOT,615F.3d233,241‐242(4thCir.2010);MidwestFence,2015W.L.1396376at*7,quotingConcreteWorks;36F.3d1513,1522(quotingCroson,488U.S.at509),affirmed,840F.3d932,2016WL6543514(7thCir.2016);seealso,SherbrookeTurf,345F.3d233,241‐242(8thCir.2003);ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia(“CAEPII”),91F.3d586,596‐598(3d.Cir.1996);ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia(“CAEPI”),6F.3d996,1005‐1007(3d.Cir.1993).
![Page 139: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/139.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 13
evidencemaybeusedincombinationwithstatisticalevidencetoestablishacompellinggovernmentalinterest.74
Inadditiontoproviding“hardproof”tosupportitscompellinginterest,thegovernmentmustalsoshowthatthechallengedprogramisnarrowlytailored.75Oncethegovernmentalentityhasshownacceptableproofofacompellinginterestandremedyingpastdiscriminationandillustratedthatitsplanisnarrowlytailoredtoachievethisgoal,thepartychallengingtheaffirmativeactionplanbearstheultimateburdenofprovingthattheplanisunconstitutional.76Therefore,notwithstandingtheburdenofinitialproductionrestswiththegovernment,theultimateburdenremainswiththepartychallengingtheapplicationofaDBEorMBE/WBEProgramtodemonstratetheunconstitutionalityofanaffirmative‐actiontypeprogram.77
Tosuccessfullyrebutthegovernment’sevidence,thecourtshold,includingtheTenthCircuitCourtofAppealsinConcreteWorksv.CityandCountyofDenver,andAdarandConstructorsv.Slater,thatachallengermustintroduce“credible,particularizedevidence”ofitsownthatrebutsthegovernment’sshowingofastrongbasisinevidenceforthenecessityofremedialaction.78ThisrebuttalcanbeaccomplishedbyprovidinganeutralexplanationforthedisparitybetweenMBE/WBE/DBEutilizationandavailability,showingthatthegovernment’sdataisflawed,demonstratingthattheobserveddisparitiesarestatisticallyinsignificant,orpresentingcontrastingstatisticaldata.79Conjectureandunsupportedcriticismsofthegovernment’smethodologyareinsufficient.80Thecourts,includingintheTenthCircuitinConcreteWorks,have
74Croson,488U.S.at509;see,e.g.,AGC,SDCv.Caltrans,713R.3dat1196;H.B.Rowev.NCDOT,615F.3d233,241‐242(4thCir.2010);MidwestFence,84F.Supp.3d705,2015WL1396376at*7,affirmed,840F.3d932,2016WL6543514(7thCir.2016);ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia(“CAEPII”),91F.3d586,596‐598(3d.Cir.1996);ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia(“CAEPI”),6F.3d996,1005‐1007(3d.Cir.1993).
75AdarandConstructors,Inc.v.Pena,(“AdarandIII”),515U.S.200at235(1995);see,e.g.,MidwestFence,840F.3d932,952‐954(7thCir.2016);Majeskev.CityofChicago,218F.3dat820;ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia(“CAEPII”),91F.3d586,596‐598(3d.Cir.1996);ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia(“CAEPI”),6F.3d996,1005‐1007(3d.Cir.1993).
76Majeske,218F.3dat820;see,e.g.Wygantv.JacksonBd.OfEduc.,476U.S.267,277‐78;MidwestFence,840F.3d932,952‐954(7thCir.2016);MidwestFence,2015WL1396376*7,affirmed,840F.3d932,2016WL6543514(7thCir.2016);GeyerSignal,Inc.,2014WL1309092;ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia(“CAEPII”),91F.3d586,596‐598;603;(3d.Cir.1996);ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia(“CAEPI”),6F.3d996,1002‐1007(3d.Cir.1993).
77Id.;AdarandVII,228F.3dat1166(10thCir.2000).
78See,e.g.,H.B.Rowev.NCDOT,615F.3d233,at241‐242(4thCir.2010);ConcreteWorks,321F.3d950,959(quotingAdarandConstructors,Inc.vs.Slater,228F.3d1147,1175(10thCir.2000));ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia,91F.3d586,596‐598,603(3dCir.1996);ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia,6F.3d996,1002‐1007(3dCir.1993);MidwestFence,84F.Supp.3d705,2015W.L.1396376at*7,affirmed,840F.3d932,2016WL6543514(7thCir.2016);seealso,SherbrookeTurf,345F.3dat971‐974;GeyerSignal,Inc.,2014WL1309092.
79See,e.g.,H.B.Rowev.NCDOT,615F.3d233,at241‐242(4thCir.2010);ConcreteWorks,321F.3d950,959(quotingAdarandConstructors,Inc.vs.Slater,228F.3d1147,1175(10thCir.2000));ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia(“CAEPII”),91F.3d586,596‐598;603;(3d.Cir.1996);ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia(“CAEPI”),6F.3d996,1002‐1007(3d.Cir.1993);MidwestFence,84F.Supp.3d705,2015W.L.1396376at*7,affirmed,840F.3d932,2016WL6543514(7thCir.2016);seealso,SherbrookeTurf,345F.3dat971‐974;GeyerSignal,Inc.,2014WL1309092;see,generally,EngineeringContractors,122F.3dat916;CoralConstruction,Co.v.KingCounty,941F.2d910,921(9thCir.1991).
80Id.;H.B.Rowe,615F.3dat242;seealso,MidwestFence,840F.3d932,952‐954(7thCir.2016);SherbrookeTurf,345F.3dat971‐974;ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia,91F.3d586,596‐598,603(3dCir.1996);ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia,6F.3d996,1002‐1007(3dCir.1993);KossmanContractingCo.,Inc.v.CityofHouston,2016WL1104363(S.D.Tex.2016);GeyerSignal,2014WL1309092.
![Page 140: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/140.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 14
heldthatmerespeculationthegovernment’sevidenceisinsufficientormethodologicallyflaweddoesnotsufficetorebutagovernment’sshowing.81
Thecourtshavenotedthat“thereisno‘precisemathematicalformulatoassessthequantumofevidencethatrisestotheCroson‘strongbasisinevidence’benchmark.’”82TheTenthCircuitandothercourtsholdthatastateneednotconclusivelyprovetheexistenceofpastorpresentracialdiscriminationtoestablishastrongbasisinevidenceforconcludingthatremedialactionisnecessary.83Instead,theSupremeCourtstatedthatagovernmentmaymeetitsburdenbyrelyingon“asignificantstatisticaldisparity”betweentheavailabilityofqualified,willing,andableminoritysubcontractorsandtheutilizationofsuchsubcontractorsbythegovernmentalentityoritsprimecontractors.84Ithasbeenfurtherheldbythecourtsthatthestatisticalevidencebe“corroboratedbysignificantanecdotalevidenceofracialdiscrimination”orbolsteredbyanecdotalevidencesupportinganinferenceofdiscrimination.85
Thecourts,includingtheTenthCircuitinConcreteWorksandAdarandVII,havestatedthestrictscrutinystandardisapplicabletojustifyarace‐consciousmeasure,andthatitisasubstantialburdenbutnotautomatically“fatalinfact.”86Insoacting,agovernmentalentitymustdemonstrateithadacompellinginterestin“remedyingtheeffectsofpastorpresentracialdiscrimination.”87
Thus,theTenthCircuitholdsthattojustifyarace‐consciousmeasure,agovernmentmustidentifythatdiscrimination,publicorprivate,withsomespecificity,andmusthaveastrongbasisinevidenceforitsconclusionthatremedialactionisnecessary.88ThecourtinConcreteWorksfoundthatitwasnotrequiredtoattempttocrafta‘precisemathematicalformulatoassessthequantumofevidencethatrisestotheCroson‘strongbasisinevidence’benchmark,
81H.B.Rowe,615F.3dat242;seeMidwestFence,840F.3d932,952‐954(7thCir.2016);ConcreteWorks,321F.3dat991;seealso,SherbrookeTurf,345F.3dat971‐974;GeyerSignal,Inc.,2014WL1309092;KossmanContractingCo.,Inc.v.CityofHouston,2016WL1104363(S.D.Tex.2016).
82H.B.Rowe,615F.3dat241,quotingRotheDev.Corp.v.Dep’tofDef.,545F.3d1023,1049(Fed.Cir.2008)(quotingW.H.ScottConstr.Co.v.CityofJackson,199F.3d206,218n.11(5thCir.1999));W.H.ScottConstr.Co.v.CityofJackson,Mississippi,199F.3d206,217‐218(5thCir.1999);see,ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia,91F.3d586,596‐598,603(3dCir.1996);ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia,6F.3d996,1002‐1007(3dCir.1993).
83H.B.RoweCo.,615F.3dat241;see,e.g.,MidwestFence,840F.3d932,952‐954(7thCir.2016);ConcreteWorks,321F.3dat958(10thCir.2003);,ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia,91F.3d586,596‐598,603(3dCir.1996);ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia,6F.3d996,1002‐1007(3dCir.1993).
84Croson,488U.S.509,see,e.g.,MidwestFence,840F.3d932,952‐954(7thCir.2016);H.B.Rowe,615F.3dat241;ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia,91F.3d586,596‐598,603(3dCir.1996);ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia,6F.3d996,1002‐1007(3dCir.1993).
85H.B.Rowe,615F.3dat241,quotingMarylandTroopersAssociation,Inc.v.Evans,993F.2d1072,1077(4thCir.1993);see,e.g.,MidwestFence,840F.3d932,952‐954(7thCir.2016);AGC,SanDiegov.Caltrans,713F.3dat1196;seealso,ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia,91F.3d586,596‐598,603(3dCir.1996);ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia,6F.3d996,1002‐1007(3dCir.1993);KossmanContractingCo.,Inc.v.CityofHouston,2016WL1104363(S.D.Tex.2016).
86See,e.g.,ConcreteWorksofColoradov.CityandCountyofDenver,321F.3dat957‐959(10thCir.2003);AdarandVII,228F.3d1147(10thCir.2000);see,e.g.,H.B.Rowe,615F.3dat241;615F.3d233at241.
87See,e.g.,ConcreteWorksofColoradov.CityandCountyofDenver,321F.3dat957‐959(10thCir.2003);AdarandVII,228F.3d1147(10thCir.2000);see,e.g.,H.B.Rowe;quotingShawv.Hunt,517U.S.899,909(1996).
88See,e.g.,ConcreteWorksofColoradov.CityandCountyofDenver,321F.3dat957‐959(10thCir.2003);AdarandVII,228F.3d1147(10thCir.2000);H.B.Rowe;615F.3d233at241quoting,Croson,488U.S.at504andWygantv.JacksonBoardofEducation,476U.S.267,277(1986)(pluralityopinion);see,ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia,91F.3d586,596‐605(3dCir.1996);ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia,6F.3d990,999,1002,1005‐1008(3dCir.1993).
![Page 141: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/141.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 15
andothercourtshavestatedthesufficiencyoftheState’sevidenceofdiscrimination“mustbeevaluatedonacase‐by‐casebasis.”89
TheTenthCircuitCourtofAppealsinConcreteWorksappliedstrictscrutinytorace‐basedmeasuresandintermediatescrutinytothegender‐basedmeasures.90TheCourtofAppealsalsocitedRichmondv.J.A.CrosonCo.,forthepropositionthatagovernmentalentity“canuseitsspendingpowerstoremedyprivatediscrimination,ifitidentifiesthatdiscriminationwiththeparticularityrequiredbytheFourteenthAmendment.”91Because“anefforttoalleviatetheeffectsofsocietaldiscriminationisnotacompellinginterest,”theCourtofAppealsheldthatDenvercoulddemonstratethatitsinterestiscompellingonlyifit(1)identifiedthepastorpresentdiscrimination“withsomespecificity,”and(2)demonstratedthata“strongbasisinevidence”supportsitsconclusionthatremedialactionisnecessary.92
TheTenthCircuitheldthatDenvercouldmeetitsburdenwithoutconclusivelyprovingtheexistenceofpastorpresentracialdiscrimination.93Rather,Denvercouldrelyon“empiricalevidencethatdemonstrates‘asignificantstatisticaldisparitybetweenthenumberofqualifiedminoritycontractors…andthenumberofsuchcontractorsactuallyengagedbythelocalityorthelocality’sprimecontractors.’”94(pluralityopinion).Furthermore,theCourtofAppealsstatedthatDenvercouldrelyonstatisticalevidencegatheredfromthesix‐countyDenverMetropolitanStatisticalArea(MSA)andcouldsupplementthestatisticalevidencewithanecdotalevidenceofpublicandprivatediscrimination.95
TheTenthCircuitinConcreteWorksheldthatDenvercouldestablishitscompellinginterestbypresentingevidenceofitsowndirectparticipationinracialdiscriminationoritspassiveparticipationinprivatediscrimination.96TheCourtofAppealssaidthatonceDenvermetitsburden,ConcreteWorksCompany(“CWC”)hadtointroduce“credible,particularizedevidencetorebut[Denver’s]initialshowingoftheexistenceofacompellinginterest,whichcouldconsistofaneutralexplanationforthestatisticaldisparities.”97(internalcitationsandquotationsomitted).TheCourtofAppealsfoundthatCWCcouldalsorebutDenver’sstatisticalevidence“by(1)showingthatthestatisticsareflawed;(2)demonstratingthatthedisparitiesshownbythestatisticsarenotsignificantoractionable;or(3)presentingcontrastingstatisticaldata.”98TheCourtofAppealsheldthattheburdenofproofatalltimesremainedwithCWCtodemonstratetheunconstitutionalityoftheordinances.99
89ConcreteWorksofColoradov.CityandCountyofDenver,36F.3d1513,1522(10thCir.1994);H.B.Rowe,615F.3dat241.(internalquotationmarksomitted).
90ConcreteWorks,321F.3d950,at957‐58,959(10thCir.2003).
91488U.S.469,492(1989)(pluralityopinion).
92ConcreteWorks,321F.3d950,at958,quotingShawv.Hunt,517U.S.899,909‐10(1996).
93Id.
94Id.,quotingCroson,488U.S.at509
95Id.
96Id.
97Id.
98ConcreteWorks,321F.3d950,958(10thCir.2003)(internalcitationsandquotationsomitted).
99Id.at960.
![Page 142: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/142.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 16
TheTenthCircuitfoundthatthedistrictcourtincorrectlybelievedDenverwasrequiredtoprovetheexistenceofdiscrimination.InsteadofconsideringwhetherDenverhaddemonstratedstrongevidencefromwhichaninferenceofpastorpresentdiscriminationcouldbedrawn,thedistrictcourtanalyzedwhetherDenver’sevidenceshowedthatthereispervasivediscrimination.100TheTenthCircuit,quotingits1994decisioninConcreteWorksII,statedthat“theFourteenthAmendmentdoesnotrequireacourttomakeanultimatefindingofdiscriminationbeforeamunicipalitymaytakeaffirmativestepstoeradicatediscrimination.”101
Denver’sinitialburdenwastodemonstratethatstrongevidenceofdiscriminationsupporteditsconclusionthatremedialmeasureswerenecessary.Strongevidenceisthat“approachingaprimafaciecaseofaconstitutionalorstatutoryviolation,”notirrefutableordefinitiveproofofdiscrimination.102TheburdenofproofatalltimesremainedwiththecontractorplaintifftoprovebyapreponderanceoftheevidencethatDenver’s“evidencedidnotsupportaninferenceofpriordiscriminationandthusaremedialpurpose.”103
Statistical evidence.Statisticalevidenceofdiscriminationisaprimarymethodusedtodeterminewhetherornotastrongbasisinevidenceexiststodevelop,adoptandsupportaremedialprogram(i.e.,toproveacompellinggovernmentalinterest),orinthecaseofarecipientcomplyingwiththeFederalDBEProgram,toprovenarrowtailoringofprogramimplementationatthestaterecipientlevel.104“Wheregrossstatisticaldisparitiescanbeshown,theyaloneinapropercasemayconstituteprimafacieproofofapatternorpracticeofdiscrimination.”105
Oneformofstatisticalevidenceisthecomparisonofagovernment’sutilizationofMBE/WBEscomparedtotherelativeavailabilityofqualified,willingandableMBE/WBEs.106Thefederalcourtshaveheldthatasignificantstatisticaldisparitybetweentheutilizationandavailabilityof
100Id.at970.
101Id.at970,quotingConcreteWorksII,36F.3d1513,1522(10thCir.1994).
102Id.at97,quotingCroson,488U.S.at500.
103Id.,quotingAdarandVII,228F.3dat1176.
104See,e.g.,Croson,488U.S.at509;MidwestFence,840F.3d932,935,948‐954(7thCir.2016);AGC,SDCv.Caltrans,713F.3dat1195‐1196;N.Contracting,473F.3dat718‐19,723‐24;WesternStatesPaving,407F.3dat991;SherbrookeTurf,345F.3dat973‐974;AdarandVII,228F.3dat1166;W.H.ScottConstr.Co.v.CityofJackson,Mississippi,199F.3d206,217‐218(5thCir.1999);ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia,91F.3d586,596‐605(3dCir.1996);ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia,6F.3d990,999,1002,1005‐1008(3dCir.1993);seealso,ConcreteWorks,321F.3d950,959(10thCir.2003);KossmanContractingCo.,Inc.v.CityofHouston,2016WL1104363(S.D.Tex.2016);GeyerSignal,2014WL1309092.
105Croson,488U.S.at501,quotingHazelwoodSchoolDist.v.UnitedStates,433U.S.299,307‐08(1977);seeMidwestFence,840F.3d932,948‐954(7thCir.2016);AGC,SDCv.Caltrans,713F.3dat1196‐1197;N.Contracting,473F.3dat718‐19,723‐24;WesternStatesPaving,407F.3dat991;SherbrookeTurf,345F.3dat973‐974;AdarandVII,228F.3dat1166;W.H.ScottConstr.Co.v.CityofJackson,Mississippi,199F.3d206,217‐218(5thCir.1999).
106Croson,448U.S.at509;seeMidwestFence,840F.3d932,935,948‐954(7thCir.2016);AGC,SDCv.Caltrans,713F.3dat1191‐1197;H.B.Rowev.NCDOT,615F.3d233,241‐244(4thCir.2010);Rothe,545F.3dat1041‐1042;ConcreteWorksofColo.,Inc.v.CityandCountyofDenver(“ConcreteWorksII”),321F.3d950,959(10thCir.2003);DrabikII,214F.3d730,734‐736;W.H.ScottConstr.Co.v.CityofJackson,Mississippi,199F.3d206,217‐218(5thCir.1999);ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia,91F.3d586,596‐605(3dCir.1996);ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia,6F.3d990,999,1002,1005‐1008(3dCir.1993);seealso,KossmanContractingCo.,Inc.v.CityofHouston,2016WL1104363(S.D.Tex.2016).
![Page 143: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/143.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 17
minority‐andwomen‐ownedfirmsmayraiseaninferenceofdiscriminatoryexclusion.107However,asmallstatisticaldisparity,standingalone,maybeinsufficienttoestablishdiscrimination.108
Otherconsiderationsregardingstatisticalevidenceinclude:
Availability analysis.Adisparityindexrequiresanavailabilityanalysis.MBE/WBEandDBE/ACDBEavailabilitymeasurestherelativenumberofMBE/WBEs/DBEsandACDBEsamongallfirmsready,willingandabletoperformacertaintypeofworkwithinaparticulargeographicmarketarea.109Thereisauthoritythatmeasuresofavailabilitymaybeapproachedwithdifferentlevelsofspecificityandthepracticalityofvariousapproachesmustbeconsidered,110“Ananalysisisnotdevoidofprobativevaluesimplybecauseitmaytheoreticallybepossibletoadoptamorerefinedapproach.”111
Utilization analysis.Courtshaveacceptedmeasuringutilizationbasedontheproportionofanagency’scontractdollarsgoingtoMBE/WBEsandDBEs.112
Disparity index.Animportantcomponentofstatisticalevidenceisthe“disparityindex.”113Adisparityindexisdefinedastheratioofthepercentutilizationtothepercentavailabilitytimes100.Adisparityindexbelow80hasbeenacceptedasevidenceofadverseimpact.Thishasbeenreferredtoas“TheRuleofThumb”or“The80percentRule.”114
107See,e.g.,Croson,488U.S.at509;MidwestFence,840F.3d932,935,948‐954(7thCir.2016);AGC,SDCv.Caltrans,713F.3dat1191‐1197;H.B.Rowev.NCDOT,615F.3d233,241‐244(4thCir.2010);Rothe,545F.3dat1041;ConcreteWorksII,321F.3dat970;W.H.ScottConstr.Co.v.CityofJackson,Mississippi,199F.3d206,217‐218(5thCir.1999);ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia,91F.3d586,596‐605(3dCir.1996);ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia,6F.3d990,999,1002,1005‐1008(3d.Cir.1993);seealsoWesternStatesPaving,407F.3dat1001;KossmanContracting,2016WL1104363(S.D.Tex.2016).
108WesternStatesPaving,407F.3dat1001.
109See,e.g.,Croson,448U.S.at509;49CFR§26.35;AGC,SDCv.Caltrans,713F.3dat1191‐1197;Rothe,545F.3dat1041‐1042;N.Contracting,473F.3dat718,722‐23;WesternStatesPaving,407F.3dat995;W.H.ScottConstr.Co.v.CityofJackson,Mississippi,199F.3d206,217‐218(5thCir.1999);ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia,91F.3d586,602‐603(3d.Cir.1996);seealso,KossmanContractingCo.,Inc.v.CityofHouston,2016WL1104363(S.D.Tex.2016).
110ContractorsAss’nofEasternPennsylvania,Inc.v.CityofPhiladelphia(“CAEPII”),91F.3d586,603(3dCir.1996);see,e.g.,AGC,SDCv.Caltrans,713F.3dat1197,quotingCroson,488U.S.at706(“degreeofspecificityrequiredinthefindingsofdiscrimination…mayvary.”);H.B.Rowe,v.NCDOT,615F.3d233,241‐244(4thCir.2010);W.H.ScottConstr.Co.v.CityofJackson,Mississippi,199F.3d206,217‐218(5thCir.1999);seealso,KossmanContractingCo.,Inc.v.CityofHouston,2016WL1104363(S.D.Tex.2016).
111ContractorsAss’nofEasternPennsylvania,Inc.v.CityofPhiladelphia(“CAEPII”),91F.3d586,603(3dCir.1996);see,e.g.,AGC,SDCv.Caltrans,713F.3dat1197,quotingCroson,488U.S.at706(“degreeofspecificityrequiredinthefindingsofdiscrimination…mayvary.”);H.B.Rowe,v.NCDOT,615F.3d233,241‐244(4thCir.2010);W.H.ScottConstr.Co.v.CityofJackson,Mississippi,199F.3d206,217‐218(5thCir.1999);seealso,KossmanContractingCo.,Inc.v.CityofHouston,2016WL1104363(S.D.Tex.2016).
112SeeMidwestFence,840F.3d932,949‐953(7thCir.2016);AGC,SDCv.Caltrans,713F.3dat1191‐1197;H.B.Rowe,v.NCDOT,615F.3d233,241‐244(4thCir.2010);ConcreteWorks,321F.3dat958,963‐968,971‐972(10thCir.2003);Eng’gContractorsAss’n,122F.3dat912;N.Contracting,473F.3dat717‐720;SherbrookeTurf,345F.3dat973.
113MidwestFence,840F.3d932,949‐953(7thCir.2016);H.B.Rowe,v.NCDOT,615F.3d233,241‐244(4thCir.2010);ConcreteWorks,321F.3dat958,963‐968,971‐972(10thCir.2003);Eng’gContractorsAss’n,122F.3dat914;W.H.ScottConstr.Co.v.CityofJackson,199F.3d206,218(5thCir.1999);ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia,91F.3d586,602‐603(3d.Cir.1996);ContractorsAss’nofEasternPennsylvania,Inc.v.CityofPhiladelphia,6F.3d990at1005(3rdCir.1993).
114See,e.g.,Ricciv.DeStefano,557U.S.557,129S.Ct.2658,2678(2009);MidwestFence,840F.3d932,950(7thCir.2016);H.B.Rowe,v.NCDOT,615F.3d233,241‐244(4thCir.2010);AGC,SDCv.Caltrans,713F.3dat1191;Rothe,545F.3dat1041;Eng’gContractorsAss’n,122F.3dat914,923;ConcreteWorksI,36F.3dat1524.
![Page 144: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/144.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 18
Two standard deviation test.Thestandarddeviationfiguredescribestheprobabilitythatthemeasureddisparityistheresultofmerechance.Somecourtshaveheldthatastatisticaldisparitycorrespondingtoastandarddeviationoflessthantwoisnotconsideredstatisticallysignificant.115
Intermsofstatisticalevidence,thecourts,includingtheTenthCircuit,haveheldthatastate“neednotconclusivelyprovetheexistenceofpastorpresentracialdiscriminationtoestablishastrongbasisinevidence”,butratheritmayrelyon“asignificantstatisticaldisparity”betweentheavailabilityofqualified,willing,andableminoritysubcontractorsandtheutilizationofsuchsubcontractorsbythegovernmentalentityoritsprimecontractors.116.
TheTenthCircuitinConcreteWorksnotedtheSupremeCourthasstatedthattheinferenceofdiscriminatoryexclusioncanarisefromstatisticaldisparities.117Accordingly,itconcludedthatDenvercouldmeetitsburdenthroughtheintroductionofstatisticalandanecdotalevidence.TotheextentthedistrictcourtrequiredDenvertointroduceadditionalevidencetoshowdiscriminatorymotiveorintentonthepartofprivateconstructionfirms,thedistrictcourterred.Denver,accordingtotheCourt,wasundernoburdentoidentifyanyspecificpracticeorpolicythatresultedindiscrimination.NeitherwasDenverrequiredtodemonstratethatthepurposeofanysuchpracticeorpolicywastodisadvantagewomenorminorities.118
ThecourtfoundDenver’sstatisticalandanecdotalevidencerelevantbecauseitidentifiesdiscriminationinthelocalconstructionindustry,notsimplydiscriminationinsociety.ThecourtheldthegenesisoftheidentifieddiscriminationisirrelevantandthedistrictcourterredwhenitdiscountedDenver’sevidenceonthatbasis.119
Marketplace discrimination and data. TheTenthCircuitinConcreteWorksheldthedistrictcourterroneouslyrejectedtheevidenceDenverpresentedonmarketplacediscrimination.120Thecourtrejectedthedistrictcourt’s“erroneous”legalconclusionthatamunicipalitymayonlyremedyitsowndiscrimination.Thecourtstatedthisconclusioniscontrarytotheholdingsinits1994decisioninConcreteWorksIIandthepluralityopinioninCroson.121Thecourthelditpreviouslyrecognizedinthiscasethat“amunicipalityhasacompellinginterestintakingaffirmativestepstoremedybothpublicandprivatediscriminationspecificallyidentifiedinits
115See,e.g.,H.B.Rowe,v.NCDOT,615F.3d233,241‐244(4thCir.2010);Eng’gContractorsAss’n,122F.3dat914,917,923.TheEleventhCircuitfoundthatadisparitygreaterthantwoorthreestandarddeviationshasbeenheldtobestatisticallysignificantandmaycreateapresumptionofdiscriminatoryconduct;Peightalv.MetropolitanEng’gContractorsAss’n,26F.3d1545,1556(11thCir.1994).TheSeventhCircuitCourtofAppealsinKadasv.MCISystemhouseCorp.,255F.3d359(7thCir.2001),raisedquestionsastotheuseofthestandarddeviationtestaloneasacontrollingfactorindeterminingtheadmissibilityofstatisticalevidencetoshowdiscrimination.Rather,theCourtconcludeditisforthejudgetosay,onthebasisofthestatisticalevidence,whetheraparticularsignificancelevel,inthecontextofaparticularstudyinaparticularcase,istoolowtomakethestudyworththeconsiderationofjudgeorjury.255F.3dat363.
116See,e.g.,H.B.Rowe,615F.3d233at241,citingCroson,488U.S.at509(pluralityopinion),andcitingConcreteWorks,321F.3dat958;ConcreteWorks,321F.3dat958,963‐968,971‐972(10thCir.2003);ConcreteWorks,36F.3dat1529(10thCir.1994).
117ConcreteWorks,321F.3d950,citingCroson,488U.S.at503.
118Id.at972.
119Id.
120Id.at973.
121Id.
![Page 145: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/145.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 19
area.”122InConcreteWorksII,thecourtstatedthat“wedonotreadCrosonasrequiringthemunicipalitytoidentifyanexactlinkagebetweenitsawardofpubliccontractsandprivatediscrimination.”123
ThecourtstatedthatDenvercouldmeetitsburdenofdemonstratingitscompellinginterestwithevidenceofprivatediscriminationinthelocalconstructionindustrycoupledwithevidencethatithasbecomeapassiveparticipantinthatdiscrimination.124Thus,Denverwasnotrequiredtodemonstratethatitis“guiltyofprohibiteddiscrimination”tomeetitsinitialburden.125
Additionally,thecourthadpreviouslyconcludedthatDenver’sstatisticalstudies,whichcomparedutilizationofMBE/WBEstoavailability,supportedtheinferencethat“localprimecontractors”areengagedinracialandgenderdiscrimination.126Thus,thecourtheldDenver’sdisparitystudiesshouldnothavebeendiscountedbecausetheyfailedtospecificallyidentifythoseindividualsorfirmsresponsibleforthediscrimination.127
Thecourtheldthedistrictcourt,interalia,erroneouslyconcludedthatthedisparitystudiesuponwhichDenverreliedweresignificantlyflawedbecausetheymeasureddiscriminationintheoverallDenverMSAconstructionindustry,notdiscriminationbytheCityitself.128Thecourtfoundthatthedistrictcourt’sconclusionwasdirectlycontrarytotheholdinginAdarandVIIthatevidenceofbothpublicandprivatediscriminationintheconstructionindustryisrelevant.129
InAdarandVII,theTenthCircuitnoteditconcludedthatevidenceofmarketplacediscriminationcanbeusedtosupportacompellinginterestinremedyingpastorpresentdiscriminationthroughtheuseofaffirmativeactionlegislation.130(“[W]emayconsiderpublicandprivatediscriminationnotonlyinthespecificareaofgovernmentprocurementcontractsbutalsointheconstructionindustrygenerally;thusanyfindingsCongresshasmadeastotheentireconstructionindustryarerelevant.”131.Further,thecourtpointedoutthatitearlierrejectedtheargumentCWCreassertedthatmarketplacedataareirrelevant,andremandedthecasetothedistrictcourttodeterminewhetherDenvercouldlinkitspublicspendingto“theDenverMSAevidenceofindustry‐widediscrimination.”132Thecourtstatedthatevidenceexplaining“theDenvergovernment’sroleincontributingtotheunderutilizationofMBEsandWBEsintheprivate
122Id.,quotingConcreteWorksII,36F.3dat1529(emphasisadded).
123ConcreteWorks,321F.3d950,973(10thCir.2003),quotingConcreteWorksII,36F.3dat1529(10thCir.1994).
124Id.at973.
125Id.
126Id.at974,quotingConcreteWorksII,36F.3dat1529.
127Id.
128Id.at974.
129Id.,citingAdarandVII,228F.3dat1166‐67.
130ConcreteWorks,321F.3dat976,citingAdarandVII,228F.3dat1166‐67.
131Id.(emphasisadded).
132Id.,quotingConcreteWorksII,36F.3dat1529.
![Page 146: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/146.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 20
constructionmarketintheDenverMSA”wasrelevanttoDenver’sburdenofproducingstrongevidence.133
Consistentwiththecourt’smandateinConcreteWorksII,Denverattemptedtoshowattrialthatit“indirectlycontributedtoprivatediscriminationbyawardingpubliccontractstofirmsthatinturndiscriminatedagainstMBEand/orWBEsubcontractorsinotherprivateportionsoftheirbusiness.”134TheTenthCircuitruledthattheCitycandemonstratethatitisa“‘passiveparticipant’inasystemofracialexclusionpracticedbyelementsofthelocalconstructionindustry”bycompilingevidenceofmarketplacediscriminationandthenlinkingitsspendingpracticestotheprivatediscrimination.135
ThecourtinConcreteWorksrejectedtheargumentthatthelendingdiscriminationstudiesandbusinessformationstudiespresentedbyDenverwereirrelevant.InAdarandVII,theTenthCircuitconcludedthatevidenceofdiscriminatorybarrierstotheformationofbusinessesbyminoritiesandwomenandfaircompetitionbetweenMBE/WBEsandmajority‐ownedconstructionfirmsshowsa“stronglink”betweenagovernment’s“disbursementsofpublicfundsforconstructioncontractsandthechannelingofthosefundsduetoprivatediscrimination.”136
ThecourtfoundthatevidencethatprivatediscriminationresultedinbarrierstobusinessformationisrelevantbecauseitdemonstratesthatMBE/WBEsareprecludedattheoutsetfromcompetingforpublicconstructioncontracts.ThecourtalsofoundthatevidenceofbarrierstofaircompetitionisrelevantbecauseitagaindemonstratesthatexistingMBE/WBEsareprecludedfromcompetingforpubliccontracts.Thus,likethestudiesmeasuringdisparitiesintheutilizationofMBE/WBEsintheDenverMSAconstructionindustry,studiesshowingthatdiscriminatorybarrierstobusinessformationexistintheDenverconstructionindustryarerelevanttotheCity’sshowingthatitindirectlyparticipatesinindustrydiscrimination.137
InConcreteWorks,DenverpresentedevidenceoflendingdiscriminationtosupportitspositionthatMBE/WBEsintheDenverMSAconstructionindustryfacediscriminatorybarrierstobusinessformation.Denverintroducedadisparitystudy.Thestudyultimatelyconcludedthat“despitethefactthatloanapplicantsofthreedifferentracial/ethnicbackgroundsinthissamplewerenotappreciablydifferentasbusinesspeople,theywereultimatelytreateddifferentlybythelendersonthecrucialissueofloanapprovalordenial.”138InAdarandVII,thecourtconcludedthatthisstudy,amongotherevidence,“stronglysupport[ed]aninitialshowingofdiscriminationinlending.”139
TheTenthCircuitinConcreteWorksconcludedthatdiscriminatorymotivecanbeinferredfromtheresultsshownindisparitystudies.ThecourtnotedthatinAdarandVIIittook“judicialnotice
133Id.,quotingConcreteWorksII,36F.3dat1530(emphasisadded).
134Id.
135ConcreteWorks,321F.3dat976,quotingCroson,488U.S.at492.
136Id.at977,quotingAdarandVII,228F.3dat1167‐68.
137Id.at977.
138Id.at977‐78.
139Id.at978,quoting,AdarandVII,228F.3dat1170,n.13.
![Page 147: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/147.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 21
oftheobviouscausalconnectionbetweenaccesstocapitalandabilitytoimplementpublicworksconstructionprojects.”140
DenveralsointroducedevidenceofdiscriminatorybarrierstocompetitionfacedbyMBE/WBEsintheformofbusinessformationstudies.Thecourtheldthatthedistrictcourt’sconclusionthatthebusinessformationstudiescouldnotbeusedtojustifytheordinancesconflictswithitsholdinginAdarandVII.“[T]heexistenceofevidenceindicatingthatthenumberof[MBEs]wouldbesignificantly(butunquantifiably)higherbutforsuchbarriersisneverthelessrelevanttotheassessmentofwhetheradisparityissufficientlysignificanttogiverisetoaninferenceofdiscriminatoryexclusion.141
Insum,theTenthCircuitheldthedistrictcourterredwhenitrefusedtoconsiderorgivesufficientweighttothelendingdiscriminationstudy,thebusinessformationstudies,andthestudiesmeasuringmarketplacediscrimination.ThatevidencewaslegallyrelevanttotheCity’sburdenofdemonstratingastrongbasisinevidencetosupportitsconclusionthatremediallegislationwasnecessary.142
Anecdotal evidence.Anecdotalevidenceincludespersonalaccountsofincidents,includingofdiscrimination,toldfromthewitness’perspective.Anecdotalevidenceofdiscrimination,standingalone,generallyisinsufficienttoshowasystematicpatternofdiscrimination.143Butpersonalaccountsofactualdiscriminationmaycomplementempiricalevidenceandplayanimportantroleinbolsteringstatisticalevidence.144Ithasbeenheldthatanecdotalevidenceofalocalorstategovernment’sinstitutionalpracticesthatexacerbatediscriminatorymarketconditionsareoftenparticularlyprobative.145
Examplesofanecdotalevidencemayinclude:
TestimonyofMBE/WBEorDBEownersregardingwhethertheyfacedifficultiesorbarriers;
DescriptionsofinstancesinwhichMBE/WBEorDBEownersbelievetheyweretreatedunfairlyorwerediscriminatedagainstbasedontheirrace,ethnicity,orgenderorbelievetheyweretreatedfairlywithoutregardtorace,ethnicity,orgender;
Statementsregardingwhetherfirmssolicit,orfailtosolicit,bidsorpricequotesfromMBE/WBEsorDBEsonnon‐goalprojects;and
140Id.at978,quotingAdarandVII,228F.3dat1170.
141Id.at979,quotingAdarandVII,228F.3dat1174.
142Id.at979‐80.
143See,e.g.,AGC,SDCv.Caltrans,713F.3dat1192,1196‐1198;Eng’gContractorsAss’n,122F.3dat924‐25;ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia,6F.3d990,1002‐1003(3d.Cir.1993);CoralConstr.Co.v.KingCounty,941F.2d910,919(9thCir.1991);O’DonnelConstr.Co.v.DistrictofColumbia,963F.2d420,427(D.C.Cir.1992).
144See,e.g.,MidwestFence,840F.3d932,953(7thCir.2016);AGC,SDCv.Caltrans,713F.3dat1192,1196‐1198;H.B.Rowe,615F.3d233,248‐249;ConcreteWorks,321F.3d950,989‐990(10thCir.2003);Eng’gContractorsAss’n,122F.3dat925‐26;ConcreteWorks,36F.3dat1520(10thCir.1994);ContractorsAss’n,6F.3dat1003;CoralConstr.Co.v.KingCounty,941F.2d910,919(9thCir.1991);seealso,KossmanContractingCo.,Inc.v.CityofHouston,2016WL1104363(S.D.Tex.2016).
145ConcreteWorksI,36F.3dat1520.
![Page 148: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/148.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 22
Statementsregardingwhetherthereareinstancesofdiscriminationinbiddingonspecificcontractsandinthefinancingandinsurancemarkets.146
Courtshaveacceptedandrecognizethatanecdotalevidenceisthewitness’narrativeofincidentstoldfromhisorherperspective,includingthewitness’thoughts,feelings,andperceptions,andthusanecdotalevidenceneednotbeverified.147
Theanecdotalevidence,accordingtotheTenthCircuit,presentedinConcreteWorksincludedseveralincidentsinvolving“profoundlydisturbing”behavioronthepartoflenders,majority‐ownedfirms,andindividualemployees.148Thecourtfoundthattheanecdotaltestimonyrevealedbehaviorthatwasnotmerelysophomoricorinsensitive,butwhichresultedinrealeconomicorphysicalharm.WhileConcreteWorks(“CWC”)alsoarguedthatallneworsmallcontractorshavedifficultyobtainingcreditandthattreatmentthewitnessescharacterizedasdiscriminatoryisexperiencedbyallcontractors,Denver’switnessestestifiedthattheybelievedtheincidentstheyexperiencedweremotivatedbyraceorgenderdiscrimination.Thecourtfoundtheysupportedthosebeliefswithtestimonythatmajority‐ownedfirmswerenotsubjecttothesamerequirementsimposedonthem.149
TheTenthCircuitheldtherewasnomerittoCWC’sargumentthatthewitnesses’accountsmustbeverifiedtoprovidesupportforDenver’sburden.Thecourtstatedthatanecdotalevidenceisnothingmorethanawitness’narrativeofanincidenttoldfromthewitness’perspectiveandincludingthewitness’perceptions.150
AfterconsideringDenver’sanecdotalevidence,thedistrictcourtinConcreteWorksfoundthattheevidence“showsthatrace,ethnicityandgenderaffecttheconstructionindustryandthosewhoworkinit”andthattheegregiousmistreatmentofminorityandwomenemployees“haddirectfinancialconsequences”onconstructionfirms.151Basedonthedistrictcourt’sfindingsregardingDenver’sanecdotalevidenceanditsreviewoftherecord,theTenthCircuitconcludedthattheanecdotalevidenceprovidedpersuasive,unrebuttedsupportforDenver’sinitialburden.152
146See,e.g.,AGC,SDCv.Caltrans,713F.3dat1197;H.B.Rowe,615F.3d233,241‐242;249‐251;NorthernContracting,2005WL2230195,at13‐15(N.D.Ill.2005),affirmed,473F.3d715(7thCir.2007);e.g.,ConcreteWorks,321F.3dat989;AdarandVII,228F.3dat1166‐76.Foradditionalexamplesofanecdotalevidence,seeEng’gContractorsAss’n,122F.3dat924;ConcreteWorks,36F.3dat1520;ConeCorp.v.HillsboroughCounty,908F.2d908,915(11thCir.1990);DynaLantic,885F.Supp.2d237;FloridaA.G.C.Council,Inc.v.StateofFlorida,303F.Supp.2d1307,1325(N.D.Fla.2004).
147See,e.g.,AGC,SDCv.Caltrans,713F.3dat1197;H.B.Rowe,615F.3d233,241‐242,248‐249;ConcreteWorksII,321F.3dat989;Eng’gContractorsAss’n,122F.3dat924‐26;ConeCorp.,908F.2dat915;NorthernContracting,Inc.v.Illinois,2005WL2230195at*21,N.32(N.D.Ill.Sept.8,2005),aff’d473F.3d715(7thCir.2007).
148ConcreteWorks,321F.3dat989.
149Id.
150Id.
151Id.at989,quotingConcreteWorksIII,86F.Supp.2dat1074,1073.
152Id.at989‐90,citingInt’lBhd.ofTeamstersv.UnitedStates,431U.S.324,339(1977)(concludingthatanecdotalevidencepresentedinapatternorpractivediscriminationcasewaspersuasivebecauseit“broughtthecold[statistics]convincinglytolife”).
![Page 149: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/149.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 23
b. The Narrow Tailoring Requirement.
Thesecondprongofthestrictscrutinyanalysisrequiresthatarace‐orethnicity‐basedprogramorlegislationimplementedtoremedypastidentifieddiscriminationintherelevantmarketbe“narrowlytailored”toreachthatobjective.
Thenarrowtailoringrequirementhasseveralcomponentsandthecourts,includingtheTenthCircuitCourtofAppeals,analyzeseveralcriteriaorfactorsindeterminingwhetheraprogramorlegislationsatisfiesthisrequirementincluding:
Thenecessityforthereliefandtheefficacyofalternativerace‐,ethnicity‐,andgender‐neutralremedies;
Theflexibilityanddurationoftherelief,includingtheavailabilityofwaiverprovisions;
Therelationshipofnumericalgoalstotherelevantlabormarket;and
Theimpactofarace‐,ethnicity‐,orgender‐consciousremedyontherightsofthirdparties.153
TosatisfythenarrowlytailoredprongofthestrictscrutinyanalysisinthecontextoftheFederalDBEProgram,whichisinstructivetothestudy,thefederalcourtsthathaveevaluatedstateandlocalDBEProgramsandtheirimplementationoftheFederalDBEProgram,heldthefollowingfactorsarepertinent:
Evidenceofdiscriminationoritseffectsinthestatetransportationcontractingindustry;
Flexibilityanddurationofarace‐orethnicity‐consciousremedy;
RelationshipofanynumericalDBEgoalstotherelevantmarket;
Effectivenessofalternativerace‐andethnicity‐neutralremedies;
Impactofarace‐orethnicity‐consciousremedyonthirdparties;and
Applicationofanyrace‐orethnicity‐consciousprogramtoonlythoseminoritygroupswhohaveactuallysuffereddiscrimination.154
TheEleventhCircuitdescribedthe“theessenceofthe‘narrowlytailored’inquiry[as]thenotionthatexplicitlyracialpreferences…mustonlybea‘lastresort’option.”155Courtshavefoundthat“[w]hilenarrowtailoringdoesnotrequireexhaustionofeveryconceivablerace‐neutral
153See,e.g.,MidwestFence,840F.3d932,942,953‐954(7thCir.2016);AGC,SDCv.Caltrans,713F.3dat1198‐1199;H.B.Rowe,615F.3d233,252‐255;Rothe,545F.3dat1036;WesternStatesPaving,407F3dat993‐995;SherbrookeTurf,345F.3dat971;AdarandVII,228F.3dat1181(10thCir.2000);W.H.ScottConstr.Co.v.CityofJackson,Mississippi,199F.3d206(5thCir.1999);Eng’gContractorsAss’n,122F.3dat927(internalquotationsandcitationsomitted);ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia,91F.3d586,605‐610(3d.Cir.1996);ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia,6F.3d990,1008‐1009(3d.Cir.1993);seealso,GeyerSignal,Inc.,2014WL1309092.
154See,e.g.,MidwestFence,840F.3d932,942,953‐954(7thCir.2016);AGC,SDCv.Caltrans,713F.3dat1198‐1199;H.B.Rowe,615F.3d233,243‐245,252‐255;WesternStatesPaving,407F.3dat998;SherbrookeTurf,345F.3dat971;AdarandVII,228F.3dat1181;KornhassConstruction,Inc.v.StateofOklahoma,DepartmentofCentralServices,140F.Supp.2dat1247‐1248;seealsoGeyerSignal,Inc.,2014WL1309092.
155Eng’gContractorsAss’n,122F.3dat926(internalcitationsomitted);seealsoVirdiv.DeKalbCountySchoolDistrict,135Fed.Appx.262,264,2005WL138942(11thCir.2005)(unpublishedopinion);Websterv.FultonCounty,51F.Supp.2d1354,1380(N.D.Ga.1999),aff’dpercuriam218F.3d1267(11thCir.2000).
![Page 150: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/150.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 24
alternative,itdoesrequireserious,goodfaithconsiderationofwhethersuchalternativescouldservethegovernmentalinterestatstake.”156
Similarly,theSixthCircuitCourtofAppealsinAssociatedGen.Contractorsv.Drabik(“DrabikII”),stated:“Adarandteachesthatacourtcalledupontoaddressthequestionofnarrowtailoringmustask,“forexample,whethertherewas‘anyconsiderationoftheuseofrace‐neutralmeanstoincreaseminoritybusinessparticipation’ingovernmentcontracting…orwhethertheprogramwasappropriatelylimitedsuchthatit‘willnotlastlongerthanthediscriminatoryeffectsitisdesignedtoeliminate.’”157
TheSupremeCourtinParentsInvolvedinCommunitySchoolsv.SeattleSchoolDistrict158alsofoundthatrace‐andethnicity‐basedmeasuresshouldbeemployedasalastresort.Themajorityopinionstated:“Narrowtailoringrequires‘serious,goodfaithconsiderationofworkablerace‐neutralalternatives,’andyetinSeattleseveralalternativeassignmentplans—manyofwhichwouldnothaveusedexpressracialclassifications—wererejectedwithlittleornoconsideration.”159TheCourtfoundthattheDistrictfailedtoshowitseriouslyconsideredrace‐neutralmeasures.
The“narrowlytailored”analysisisinstructiveintermsofdevelopinganypotentiallegislationorprogramsthatinvolveMBE/WBE/DBEsorinconnectionwithdeterminingappropriateremedialmeasurestoachievelegislativeobjectives.
Implementation of the Federal DBE Program: Narrow tailoring.ThesecondprongofthestrictscrutinyanalysisrequirestheimplementationoftheFederalDBEProgrambyrecipientsoffederalfundsbe“narrowlytailored”toremedyidentifieddiscriminationintheparticularrecipient’scontractingandprocurementmarket.160Thenarrowtailoringrequirementhasseveralcomponents.
InWesternStatesPaving,theNinthCircuitheldtherecipientoffederalfundsmusthaveindependentevidenceofdiscriminationwithintherecipient’sowntransportationcontractingandprocurementmarketplaceinordertodeterminewhetherornotthereistheneedforrace‐,ethnicity‐,orgender‐consciousremedialaction.161Thus,theNinthCircuitheldinWesternStatesPavingthatmerecompliancewiththeFederalDBEProgramdoesnotsatisfystrictscrutiny.162
156SeeGrutterv.Bollinger,539U.S.306,339(2003);Richmondv.J.A.CrosonCo.,488U.S.469,509‐10(1989);H.B.Rowe,615F.3d233,252‐255;WesternStatesPaving,407F.3dat993;SherbrookeTurf,345F.3dat972;seealsoAdarandI,515U.S.at237‐38.
157AssociatedGen.ContractorsofOhio,Inc.v.Drabik(“DrabikII”),214F.3d730,738(6thCir.2000).
158551U.S.701,734‐37,127S.Ct.2738,2760‐61(2007).
159551U.S.701,734‐37,127S.Ct.at2760‐61;seealsoFisherv.UniversityofTexas,133S.Ct.2411(2013);Grutterv.Bollinger,539U.S.305(2003).
160WesternStatesPaving,407F3dat995‐998;SherbrookeTurf,345F.3dat970‐71;see,e.g.,MidwestFence,840F.3d932,949‐953.
161WesternStatesPaving,407F.3dat997‐98,1002‐03;seeAGC,SDCv.Caltrans,713F.3dat1197‐1199.
162Id.at995‐1003.TheSeventhCircuitCourtofAppealsinNorthernContractingstatedinafootnotethatthecourtinWesternStatesPaving“misread”thedecisioninMilwaukeeCountyPavers.473F.3dat722,n.5.
![Page 151: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/151.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 25
InWesternStatesPaving,andinAGC,SDCv.Caltrans,theCourtfoundthatevenwhereevidenceofdiscriminationispresentinarecipient’smarket,anarrowlytailoredprogrammustapplyonlytothoseminoritygroupswhohaveactuallysuffereddiscrimination.Thus,underarace‐orethnicity‐consciousprogram,foreachoftheminoritygroupstobeincludedinanyrace‐orethnicity‐consciouselementsinarecipient’simplementationoftheFederalDBEProgram,theremustbeevidencethattheminoritygroupsuffereddiscriminationwithintherecipient’smarketplace.163
InNorthernContractingdecision(2007)theSeventhCircuitCourtofAppealsciteditsearlierprecedentinMilwaukeeCountyPaversv.Fieldertohold“thatastateisinsulatedfrom[anarrowtailoring]constitutionalattack,absentashowingthatthestateexceededitsfederalauthority.IDOT[IllinoisDOT]hereisactingasaninstrumentoffederalpolicyandNorthernContracting(NCI)cannotcollaterallyattackthefederalregulationsthroughachallengetoIDOT’sprogram.”164TheSeventhCircuitCourtofAppealsdistinguishedboththeNinthCircuitCourtofAppealsdecisioninWesternStatesPavingandtheEighthCircuitCourtofAppealsdecisioninSherbrookeTurf,relatingtoanas‐appliednarrowtailoringanalysis.
TheSeventhCircuitCourtofAppealsheldthatthestateDOT’s[IllinoisDOT]applicationofafederallymandatedprogramislimitedtothequestionofwhetherthestateexceededitsgrantoffederalauthorityundertheFederalDBEProgram.165TheSeventhCircuitCourtofAppealsanalyzedIDOT’scompliancewiththefederalregulationsregardingcalculationoftheavailabilityofDBEs,adjustmentofitsgoalbasedonlocalmarketconditionsanditsuseofrace‐neutralmethodssetforthinthefederalregulations.166ThecourtheldNCIfailedtodemonstratethatIDOTdidnotsatisfycompliancewiththefederalregulations(49CFRPart26).167Accordingly,theSeventhCircuitCourtofAppealsaffirmedthedistrictcourt’sdecisionupholdingthevalidityofIDOT’sDBEprogram.168
Therecent2015and2016SeventhCircuitCourtofAppealsdecisionsinDunnetBayConstructionCompanyv.Borggren,IllinoisDOT,etalandMidwestFenceCorp.v.U.S.DOT,FederalHighwayAdministration,IllinoisDOTfollowedtherulinginNorthernContractingthatastateDOTimplementingtheFederalDBEProgramisinsulatedfromaconstitutionalchallengeabsentashowingthatthestateexceededitsfederalauthority.169ThecourtheldtheIllinoisDOTDBEProgramimplementingtheFederalDBEProgramwasvalid,findingtherewasnotsufficientevidencetoshowtheIllinoisDOTexceededitsauthorityunderthefederalregulations.170ThecourtfoundDunnetBayhadnotestablishedsufficientevidencethatIDOT’simplementationof
163407F.3dat996‐1000;SeeAGC,SDCv.Caltrans,713F.3dat1197‐1199.
164473F.3dat722.
165Id.at722.
166Id.at723‐24.
167Id.
168Id.;See,e.g.,MidwestFence,840F.3d932(7thCir.2016);MidwestFence,84F.Supp.3d705,2015WL1396376(N.D.Ill.2015),affirmed,840F.3d932(7thCir.2016);GeodCorp.v.NewJerseyTransitCorp.,etal.,746F.Supp2d642(D.N.J.2010);SouthFloridaChapteroftheA.G.C.v.BrowardCounty,Florida,544F.Supp.2d1336(S.D.Fla.2008).
169MidwestFence,840F.3d932(7thCir.2016);DunnetBayConstructionCompanyv.Borggren,IllinoisDOT,etal.,799F.3d676,2015WL4934560at**18‐22(7thCir.2015).
170DunnetBay,799F.3d676,2015WL4934560at**18‐22.
![Page 152: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/152.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 26
theFederalDBEProgramconstitutedunlawfuldiscrimination.171Inaddition,thecourtinMidwestFenceupheldtheconstitutionalityoftheFederalDBEProgram,andupheldtheIllinoisDOTDBEProgramandIllinoisStateTollwayHighwayAuthorityDBEProgramthatdidnotinvolvefederalfundsundertheFederalDBEProgram.172
TosatisfythenarrowlytailoredprongofthestrictscrutinyanalysisinthecontextoftheFederalDBEProgram,whichisinstructivetothestudy,thefederalcourtsthathaveevaluatedstateandlocalDBEProgramsandtheirimplementationoftheFederalDBEProgram,heldthefollowingfactorsarepertinent:
Evidenceofdiscriminationoritseffectsinthestatetransportationcontractingindustry;
Flexibilityanddurationofarace‐orethnicity‐consciousremedy;
RelationshipofanynumericalDBEgoalstotherelevantmarket;
Effectivenessofalternativerace‐andethnicity‐neutralremedies;
Impactofarace‐orethnicity‐consciousremedyonthirdparties;and
Applicationofanyrace‐orethnicity‐consciousprogramtoonlythoseminoritygroupswhohaveactuallysuffereddiscrimination.173
Race‐, ethnicity‐, and gender‐neutral measures.Totheextenta“strongbasisinevidence”existsconcerningdiscriminationinalocalorstategovernment’srelevantcontractingandprocurementmarket,thecourtsanalyzeseveralcriteriaorfactorstodeterminewhetherastate’simplementationofarace‐orethnicity‐consciousprogramisnecessaryandthusnarrowlytailoredtoachieveremedyingidentifieddiscrimination.Oneofthekeyfactorsdiscussedaboveisconsiderationofrace‐,ethnicity‐andgender‐neutralmeasures.
Thecourtsrequirethatalocalorstategovernmentseriouslyconsiderrace‐,ethnicity‐andgender‐neutraleffortstoremedyidentifieddiscrimination.174Andthecourtshaveheldunconstitutionalthoserace‐andethnicity‐consciousprogramsimplementedwithoutconsiderationofrace‐andethnicity‐neutralalternativestoincreaseminoritybusinessparticipationinstateandlocalcontracting.175
171Id.
172840F.3d932(7thCir.2016).
173See,e.g.,MidwestFence,840F.3d932,942,953‐954(7thCir.2016);AGC,SDCv.Caltrans,713F.3dat1198‐1199;H.B.Rowe,615F.3d233,243‐245,252‐255;WesternStatesPaving,407F.3dat998;SherbrookeTurf,345F.3dat971;AdarandVII,228F.3dat1181;KornhassConstruction,Inc.v.StateofOklahoma,DepartmentofCentralServices,140F.Supp.2dat1247‐1248;seealsoGeyerSignal,Inc.,2014WL1309092.
174See,e.g.,MidwestFence,840F.3d932,937‐938,953‐954(7thCir.2016);AGC,SDCv.Caltrans,713F.3dat1199;H.B.Rowe,615F.3d233,252‐255;WesternStatesPaving,407F.3dat993;SherbrookeTurf,345F.3dat972;AdarandVII,228F.3dat1179(10thCir.2000);Eng’gContractorsAss’n,122F.3dat927;ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia(CAEPII),91F.3dat608‐609(3d.Cir.1996);ContractorsAss’n(CAEPI),6F.3dat1008‐1009(3d.Cir.1993);CoralConstr.,941F.2dat923.
175See,Croson,488U.S.at507;DrabikI,214F.3dat738(citationsandinternalquotationsomitted);seealso,Eng’gContractorsAss’n,122F.3dat927;Virdi,135Fed.Appx.At268;ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia(CAEPII),91F.3dat608‐609(3d.Cir.1996);ContractorsAss’n(CAEPI),6F.3dat1008‐1009(3d.Cir.1993).
![Page 153: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/153.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 27
TheCourtinCrosonfollowedbydecisionsfromfederalcourtsofappealfoundthatlocalandstategovernmentshaveattheirdisposala“wholearrayofrace‐neutraldevicestoincreasetheaccessibilityofcitycontractingopportunitiestosmallentrepreneursofallraces.”176
Examplesofrace‐,ethnicity‐,andgender‐neutralalternativesinclude,butarenotlimitedto,thefollowing:
Providingassistanceinovercomingbondingandfinancingobstacles;
Relaxationofbondingrequirements;
Providingtechnical,managerialandfinancialassistance;
Establishingprogramstoassiststart‐upfirms;
Simplificationofbiddingprocedures;
Trainingandfinancialaidforalldisadvantagedentrepreneurs;
Non‐discriminationprovisionsincontractsandinstatelaw;
Mentor‐protégéprogramsandmentoring;
Effortstoaddresspromptpaymentstosmallerbusinesses;
Smallcontractsolicitationstomakecontractsmoreaccessibletosmallerbusinesses;
Expansionofadvertisementofbusinessopportunities;
Outreachprogramsandefforts;
“Howtodobusiness”seminars;
Sponsoringnetworkingsessionsthroughoutthestateacquaintsmallfirmswithlargefirms;
CreationanddistributionofMBE/WBEandDBEdirectories;and
Streamliningandimprovingtheaccessibilityofcontractstoincreasesmallbusinessparticipation.177
Thecourtshaveheldthatwhilethenarrowtailoringanalysisdoesnotrequireagovernmentalentitytoexhausteverypossiblerace‐,ethnicity‐,andgender‐neutralalternative,itdoes“requireserious,goodfaithconsiderationofworkablerace‐neutralalternatives.178
Additional factors considered under narrow tailoring.Inadditiontotherequiredconsiderationofthenecessityforthereliefandtheefficacyofalternativeremedies(race‐andethnicity‐neutral
176Croson,488U.S.at509‐510.
177See,e.g.,Croson,488U.S.at509‐510;H.B.Rowe,615F.3d233,252‐255;N.Contracting,473F.3dat724;AdarandVII,228F.3d1179(10thCir.2000);49CFR§26.51(b);seealso,Eng’gContractorsAss’n,122F.3dat927‐29;ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia,91F.3dat608‐609(3d.Cir.1996);ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia,6F.3dat1008‐1009(3d.Cir.1993).
178ParentsInvolvedinCommunitySchoolsv.SeattleSchoolDistrict,551U.S.701,732‐47,127S.Ct2738,2760‐61(2007);AGC,SDCv.Caltrans,713F.3dat1199,citingGrutterv.Bollinger,539U.S.306,339(2003);H.B.Rowe,615F.3d233,252‐255;WesternStatesPaving,407F.3dat993;SherbrookeTurf,345F.3dat972;Eng’gContractorsAss’n,122F.3dat927.
![Page 154: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/154.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 28
efforts),thecourtsrequireevaluationofadditionalfactorsaslistedabove.179Forexample,tobeconsiderednarrowlytailored,courtshaveheldthataMBE/WBE‐orDBE‐typeprogramshouldinclude:(1)built‐inflexibility;180(2)goodfaitheffortsprovisions;181(3)waiverprovisions;182(4)arationalbasisforgoals;183(5)graduationprovisions;184(6)remediesonlyforgroupsforwhichtherewerefindingsofdiscrimination;185(7)sunsetprovisions;186and(8)limitationinitsgeographicalscopetotheboundariesoftheenactingjurisdiction.187
2. Intermediate scrutiny analysis
CertainFederalCourtsofAppeal,includingtheTenthCircuitCourtofAppeals,applyintermediatescrutinytogender‐consciousprograms.188TheTenthCircuithasapplied“intermediatescrutiny”toclassificationsbasedongender.189Restrictionssubjecttointermediatescrutinyarepermissiblesolongastheyaresubstantiallyrelatedtoserveanimportantgovernmentalinterest.190
179SeeMidwestFence,840F.3d932,937‐939,947‐954(7thCir.2016);H.B.Rowe,615F.3d233,252‐255;SherbrookeTurf,345F.3dat971‐972;Eng’gContractorsAss’n,122F.3dat927;ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia,91F.3dat608‐609(3d.Cir.1996);ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia,6F.3dat1008‐1009(3d.Cir.1993).
180MidwestFence,840F.3d932,937‐939,947‐954(7thCir.2016);H.B.Rowe,615F.3d233,253;SherbrookeTurf,345F.3dat971‐972;CAEPI,6F.3dat1009;AssociatedGen.ContractorsofCa.,Inc.v.CoalitionforEconomicEquality(“AGCofCa.”),950F.2d1401,1417(9thCir.1991);CoralConstr.Co.v.KingCounty,941F.2d910,923(9thCir.1991);ConeCorp.v.HillsboroughCounty,908F.2d908,917(11thCir.1990).
181MidwestFence,840F.3d932,937‐939,947‐954(7thCir.2016);H.B.Rowe,615F.3d233,253;SherbrookeTurf,345F.3dat971‐972;CAEPI,6F.3dat1019;ConeCorp.,908F.2dat917.
182MidwestFence,840F.3d932,937‐939,947‐954(7thCir.2016);H.B.Rowe,615F.3d233,253;AGCofCa.,950F.2dat1417;ConeCorp.,908F.2dat917;ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia,91F.3dat606‐608(3d.Cir.1996);ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia,6F.3dat1008‐1009(3d.Cir.1993).
183Id.;SherbrookeTurf,345F.3dat971‐973;ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia,91F.3dat606‐608(3d.Cir.1996);ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia,6F.3dat1008‐1009(3d.Cir.1993).
184Id.
185See,e.g.,AGC,SDCv.Caltrans,713F.3dat1198‐1199;H.B.Rowe,615F.3d233,253‐255;WesternStatesPaving,407F.3dat998;AGCofCa.,950F.2dat1417;ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia,91F.3dat593‐594,605‐609(3d.Cir.1996);ContractorsAss’n(CAEPI),6F.3dat1009,1012(3d.Cir.1993);KossmanContractingCo.,Inc.,v.CityofHouston,2016WL1104363(W.D.Tex.2016);SherbrookeTurf,2001WL150284(unpublishedopinion),aff’d345F.3d964.
186See,e.g.,H.B.Rowe,615F.3d233,254;SherbrookeTurf,345F.3dat971‐972;Peightal,26F.3dat1559;.seealso,KossmanContractingCo.,Inc.v.CityofHouston,2016WL1104363(W.D.Tex.2016).
187CoralConstr.,941F.2dat925.
188ConcreteWorks,321F.3d950,960(10thCir.2003);ConcreteWorks,36F.3d1513,1519(10thCir.1994);see,e.g.,H.B.RoweCo.,Inc.v.NCDOT,615F.3d233,242(4thCir.2010);AssociatedUtilityContractorsofMaryland,Inc.v.TheMayorandCityCouncilofBaltimore,etal.,83F.Supp.2d613,619‐620(2000);Seegenerally,AGC,SDCv.Caltrans,713F.3dat1195;WesternStatesPaving,407F.3dat990n.6;CoralConstr.Co.,941F.2dat931‐932(9thCir.1991);Equal.Found.v.CityofCincinnati,128F.3d289(6thCir.1997);Eng’gContractorsAss’n,122F.3dat905,908,910;EnsleyBranchN.A.A.C.P.v.Seibels,31F.3d1548(11thCir.1994);ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia,6F.3dat1009‐1011(3dCir.1993);seealsoU.S.v.Virginia,518U.S.515,532andn.6(1996)(“exceedinglypersuasivejustification.”);GeyerSignal,2014WL1309092.
189ConcreteWorks,321F.3d950,960(10thCir.2003);ConcreteWorks,36F.3d1513,1519(10thCir.1994);see,e.g.,H.B.RoweCo.,Inc.v.NCDOT,615F.3d233,242(4thCir.2010);AssociatedUtilityContractorsofMaryland,Inc.v.TheMayorandCityCouncilofBaltimore,etal.,83F.Supp.2d613,619‐620(2000);see,ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia,6F.3dat1009‐1011(3dCir.1993);Cunninghamv.Beavers,858F.2d269,273(5thCir.1988),cert.denied,489U.S.1067(1989)(citingCraigv.Boren,429U.S.190(1976),andLalliv.Lalli,439U.S.259(1978)).
190ConcreteWorks,321F.3d950,960(10thCir.2003);ConcreteWorks,36F.3d1513,1519(10thCir.1994);see,e.g.,H.B.RoweCo.,Inc.v.NCDOT,615F.3d233,242(4thCir.2010);AssociatedUtilityContractorsofMaryland,Inc.v.TheMayorandCityCouncilofBaltimore,etal.,83F.Supp.2d613,619‐620(2000);see,Serv.Emp.Int’lUnion,Local5v.CityofHous.,595F.3d588,596(5thCir.2010);ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia,6F.3dat1009‐1011(3dCir.1993).
![Page 155: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/155.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 29
Thecourtshaveinterpretedthisintermediatescrutinystandardtorequirethatgender‐basedclassificationsbe:
1. Supportedbyboth“sufficientprobative”evidenceor“exceedinglypersuasivejustification”insupportofthestatedrationalefortheprogram;and
2. Substantiallyrelatedtotheachievementofthatunderlyingobjective.191
Underthetraditionalintermediatescrutinystandard,thecourtreviewsagender‐consciousprogrambyanalyzingwhetherthestateactorhasestablishedasufficientfactualpredicatefortheclaimthatfemale‐ownedbusinesseshavesuffereddiscrimination,andwhetherthegender‐consciousremedyisanappropriateresponsetosuchdiscrimination.Thisstandardrequiresthestateactortopresent“sufficientprobative”evidenceinsupportofitsstatedrationalefortheprogram.192
Intermediatescrutiny,asinterpretedbyfederalcircuitcourtsofappeal,requiresadirect,substantialrelationshipbetweentheobjectiveofthegenderpreferenceandthemeanschosentoaccomplishtheobjective.193Themeasureofevidencerequiredtosatisfyintermediatescrutinyislessthanthatnecessarytosatisfystrictscrutiny.Unlikestrictscrutiny,ithasbeenheldthattheintermediatescrutinystandarddoesnotrequireashowingofgovernmentinvolvement,activeorpassive,inthediscriminationitseekstoremedy.194
TheTenthCircuitinConcreteWorks,statedwithregardevidenceastowoman‐ownedbusinessenterprisesasfollows:
“We do not have the benefit of relevant authority with which to compareDenver’sdisparity indices forWBEs. SeeContractorsAss’n,6F.3dat1009–11(reviewingcaselawandnotingthat“itisunclearwhetherstatisticalevidenceaswellasanecdotalevidenceisrequiredtoestablishthediscriminationnecessaryto satisfy intermediate scrutiny, and if so, how much statistical evidence isnecessary”). Nevertheless, Denver’s data indicates significant WBEunderutilization such that the Ordinance’s gender classification arises from“reasonedanalysisratherthanthroughthemechanicalapplicationoftraditional,ofteninaccurate,assumptions.”MississippiUniv.ofWomen,458U.S.at726,102
191ConcreteWorks,321F.3d950,960(10thCir.2003);ConcreteWorks,36F.3d1513,1519(10thCir.1994);see,e.g.,AGC,SDCv.Caltrans,713F.3dat1195;H.B.RoweCo.,Inc.v.NCDOT,615F.3d233,242(4thCir.2010);WesternStatesPaving,407F.3dat990n.6;CoralConstr.Co.,941F.2dat931‐932(9thCir.1991);Equal.Found.v.CityofCincinnati,128F.3d289(6thCir.1997);Eng’gContractorsAss’n,122F.3dat905,908,910;EnsleyBranchN.A.A.C.P.v.Seibels,31F.3d1548(11thCir.1994);ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.v.CityofPhiladelphia,6F.3dat1009‐1011(3dCir.1993);AssociatedUtilityContractorsofMaryland,Inc.v.TheMayorandCityCouncilofBaltimore,etal.,83F.Supp.2d613,619‐620(2000);seealsoU.S.v.Virginia,518U.S.515,532andn.6(1996)(“exceedinglypersuasivejustification.”).
192Id.TheSeventhCircuitCourtofAppeals,however,inBuildersAss’nofGreaterChicagov.CountyofCook,Chicago,didnotholdthereisadifferentlevelofscrutinyforgenderdiscriminationorgenderbasedprograms.256F.3d642,644‐45(7thCir.2001).TheCourtinBuildersAss’nrejectedthedistinctionappliedbytheEleventhCircuitinEngineeringContractors.
193See,e.g.,AGC,SDCv.Caltrans,713F.3dat1195;H.B.Rowe,Inc.v.NCDOT,615F.3d233,242(4thCir.2010);WesternStatesPaving,407F.3dat990n.6;CoralConstr.Co.,941F.2dat931‐932(9thCir.1991);Equal.Found.v.CityofCincinnati,128F.3d289(6thCir.1997);Eng’gContractorsAss’n,122F.3dat905,908,910;EnsleyBranchN.A.A.C.P.v.Seibels,31F.3d1548(11thCir.1994);Assoc.UtilityContractorsofMaryland,Inc.v.TheMayorandCityCouncilofBaltimore,etal.,83F.Supp2d613,619‐620(2000);see,also,U.S.v.Virginia,518U.S.515,532andn.6(1996)(“exceedinglypersuasivejustification.”)
194CoralConstr.Co.,941F.2dat931‐932;seeEng’gContractorsAss’n,122F.3dat910.
![Page 156: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/156.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 30
S.Ct. at3337(strikingdown,under the intermediate scrutiny standard, a statestatute that excluded males from enrolling in a state‐supported professionalnursingschool).”
TheFourthCircuitciteswithapprovaltheguidancefromtheEleventhCircuitthathasheld“[w]henagender‐consciousaffirmativeactionprogramrestsonsufficientevidentiaryfoundation,thegovernmentisnotrequiredtoimplementtheprogramonlyasalastresort….Additionally,underintermediatescrutiny,agender‐consciousprogramneednotcloselytieitsnumericalgoalstotheproportionofqualifiedwomeninthemarket.”195
TheSupremeCourthasstatedthatanaffirmativeactionprogramsurvivesintermediatescrutinyiftheproponentcanshowitwas“aproductofanalysisratherthanastereotypedreactionbasedonhabit.”196TheThirdCircuitfoundthisstandardrequiredtheCityofPhiladelphiatopresentprobativeevidenceinsupportofitsstatedrationaleforthegenderpreference,discriminationagainstwomen‐ownedcontractors.197TheCourtinContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.(CAEPI)heldtheCityhadnotproducedenoughevidenceofdiscrimination,notingthatinitsbrief,theCityreliedonstatisticsintheCityCouncilFinanceCommitteeReportandoneaffidavitfromawomanengagedinthecateringbusiness,buttheCourtfoundthisevidenceonlyreflectedtheparticipationofwomeninCitycontractinggenerally,ratherthanintheconstructionindustry,whichwastheonlycognizableissueinthatcase.198
TheThirdCircuitinCAEPIheldtheevidenceofferedbytheCityofPhiladelphiaregardingwomen‐ownedconstructionbusinesseswasinsufficienttocreateanissueoffact.ThestudyinCAEPIcontainednodisparityindexforwomen‐ownedconstructionbusinessesinCitycontracting,suchasthatpresentedforminority‐ownedbusinesses.199Giventheabsenceofprobativestatisticalevidence,theCity,accordingtotheCourt,mustrelysolelyonanecdotalevidencetoestablishgenderdiscriminationnecessarytosupporttheOrdinance.200Buttherecordcontainedonlyonethree‐pageaffidavitalleginggenderdiscriminationintheconstructionindustry.201Theonlyothertestimonyonthissubject,theCourtfoundinCAEPI,consistedofasingle,conclusorysentenceofonewitnesswhoappearedataCityCouncilhearing.202ThisevidencetheCourtheldwasnotenoughtocreateatriableissueoffactregardinggenderdiscriminationundertheintermediatescrutinystandard.
3. Rational basis analysis
Whereachallengetotheconstitutionalityofastatuteoraregulationdoesnotinvolveafundamentalrightorasuspectclass,theappropriatelevelofscrutinytoapplyistherational
195615F.3d233,242;122F.3dat929(internalcitationsomitted).
196ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.(CAEPI),6F.3dat1010(3d.Cir.1993).
197ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.(CAEPI),6F.3dat1010(3d.Cir.1993).
198ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.(CAEPI),6F.3dat1011(3d.Cir.1993).
199ContractorsAss’nofE.Pa.(CAEPI),6F.3dat1011(3d.Cir.1993).
200Id.
201Id.
202Id.
![Page 157: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/157.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 31
basisstandard.203WhenapplyingrationalbasisreviewundertheEqualProtectionClauseoftheFourteenthAmendmentoftheUnitedStatesConstitution,acourtisrequiredtoinquirewhetherthechallengedclassificationhasalegitimatepurposeandwhetheritwasreasonableforthelegislaturetobelievethatuseofthechallengedclassificationwouldpromotethatpurpose.204
ThecourtsinColoradoandtheTenthCircuitCourtofAppealsinapplyingtherationalbasistestgenerallyfindthatachallengedlawisupheld“aslongastherecouldbesomerationalbasisforenacting[it],”thatis,that“thelawinquestionisrationallyrelatedtoalegitimategovernmentpurpose.”205Solongasagovernmentlegislaturehadareasonablebasisforadoptingtheclassificationthelawwillpassconstitutionalmuster.206
Undertherationalbasistest,“astatutoryclassificationispresumedconstitutionalanddoesnotviolateequalprotectionunlessitisprovenbeyondareasonabledoubtthattheclassificationdoesnotbeararationalrelationshiptoalegitimatelegislativepurpose.”207“[T]heburdenisonclaimant,asthechallengingparty,toprovethestatuteisunconstitutionalbeyondareasonabledoubt.”208
Inapplyingrationalbasisreview,“wedonotdecidewhetherthelegislaturehaschosenthebestroutetoaccomplishitsobjectives.”209Instead,“[o]urinquiryislimitedtowhethertheschemeasconstitutedfurthersalegitimatestatepurposeinarationalmanner.”210
“[T]heburdenisontheoneattackingthelegislativearrangementtonegativeeveryconceivablebasiswhichmightsupportit,whetherornotthebasishasafoundationintherecord.”211Moreover,“courtsarecompelledunderrational‐basisreviewtoacceptalegislature’sgeneralizationsevenwhenthereisanimperfectfitbetweenmeansandends.Aclassification
203Price‐Cornelisonv.Brooks,524F.3d1103,1110(10thCir.1996);Whitev.Colorado,157F.3d1226,(10thCir.1998);ColoradoInsuranceGuarantyAssociationv.SunstateEquipment,LLC,405P.2d320,328‐329,331‐332(Colo.App.2016);Sanchezv.IndustrialClaimAppealsOfficeofColorado,411P.2d245,252(Colo.App.2017);see,e.g.,Hellerv.Doe,509U.S.312,320(1993);Hettingav.UnitedStates,677F.3d471,478(D.C.Cir2012);Cunninghamv.Beavers858F.2d269,273(5thCir.1988);seealsoLundeenv.CanadianPac.R.Co.,532F.3d682,689(8thCir.2008)(statingthatfederalcourtsreviewlegislationregulatingeconomicandbusinessaffairsundera‘highlydeferentialrationalbasis’standardofreview.”);H.B.Rowe,Inc.v.NCDOT,615F.3d233at254.
204See,Price‐Cornelisonv.Brooks,524F.3d1103,1110(10thCir.1996);Whitev.Colorado,157F.3d1226,(10thCir.1998);see,e.g.,Hellerv.Doe,509U.S.312,320(1993);Hettingav.UnitedStates,677F.3d471,478(D.C.Cir2012);Cunninghamv.Beavers,858F.2d269,273(5thCir.1988).
205See,Price‐Cornelisonv.Brooks,524F.3d1103,1110(10thCir.1996);Whitev.Colorado,157F.3d1226,(10thCir.1998);see,e.g.,Kadrmasv.DickinsonPublicSchools,487U.S.450,457‐58(1998);Zerbav.DillonCompanies,Inc.,292P.3d1051,1055(Colo.2012);seealsoCityofCleburnev.CleburneLivingCtr.,Inc.,473U.S.432,440,(1985)(citationsomitted);Hellerv.Doe,509U.S.312,318‐321(1993)(Underrationalbasisstandard,alegislativeclassificationisaccordedastrongpresumptionofvalidity).
206Id.,Zerbav.DillonCompanies,Inc.,292P.3d1051,1055(Colo.2012);Wilkinsv.Gaddy,734F.3d344,347(4thCir.2013),(citingFCCv.BeachCommc'ns,Inc.,508U.S.307,315(1993));
207Sanchezv.IndustrialClaimAppealsOffice,411P.3d245(2017),quoting,PaceMembershipWarehousev.Axelson,938P.2d504,506(Colo.1997).
208Sanchezv.IndustrialClaimAppealsOffice,411P.3d245(2017),quoting,Pepperv.Indus.ClaimAppealsOffice,131P.3d1137,1139(Colo.App.2005),aff’donothergroundssubnom.CityofFlorencev.Pepper,145P.3d654(Colo.2006).
209Sanchezv.IndustrialClaimAppealsOffice,411P.3d245(2017)quoting,Deanv.People,2016CO,¶13,366P.3d593.
210Id.
211UnitedStatesv.Timms,664F.3d436,448‐49(4thCir.2012),cert.denied,133S.Ct.189(2012)(citingHellerv.Doe,509U.S.312,320‐21(1993))(quotationmarksandcitationomitted);Grayv.CommonwealthofVirginia,274Va.at308‐9,645S.E.2dat460.
![Page 158: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/158.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 32
doesnotfailrational‐basisreviewbecauseitisnotmadewithmathematicalnicetyorbecauseinpracticeitresultsinsomeinequality”.212
Underarationalbasisreviewstandard,alegislativeclassificationwillbeupheld“ifthereisarationalrelationshipbetweenthedisparityoftreatmentandsomelegitimategovernmentalpurpose.”213Becausealllegislationclassifiesitsobjects,differentialtreatmentisjustifiedby“anyreasonablyconceivablestateoffacts.”214
Afederalcourtdecision,whichisinstructivetothestudy,involvedachallengetoandtheapplicationofasmallbusinessgoalinapre‐bidprocessforafederalprocurement.FirstlineTransportationSecurity,Inc.v.UnitedStates,isinstructiveandanalogoustosomeoftheissuesinasmallbusinessprogram.Thecaseisinformativeastotheuse,estimationanddeterminationofgoals(smallbusinessgoals,includingveteranpreferencegoals)inaprocurementundertheFederalAcquisitionRegulations(“FAR”)215.
Firstlineinvolvedasolicitationthatestablishedasmallbusinesssubcontractinggoalrequirement.InFirstline,theTransportationSecurityAdministration(“TSA”)issuedasolicitationforsecurityscreeningservicesattheKansasCityAirport.Thesolicitationstatedthatthe:“GovernmentanticipatesanoverallSmallBusinessgoalof40percent,”andthat“[w]ithinthatgoal,thegovernmentanticipatesfurthersmallbusinessgoalsof:Small,Disadvantagedbusiness[:]14.5%;WomanOwned[:]5percent:HUBZone[:]3percent;ServiceDisabled,VeteranOwned[:]3percent.”216
ThecourtappliedtherationalbasistestinconstruingthechallengetotheestablishmentbytheTSAofa40percentsmallbusinessparticipationgoalasunlawfulandirrational.217Thecourtstatedit“cannotsaythattheagency’sapproachisclearlyunlawful,orthattheapproachlacksarationalbasis.”218
Thecourtfoundthat“anagencymayrationallyestablishaspirationalsmallbusinesssubcontractinggoalsforprospectiveofferors….”Consequently,thecourtheldonerationalmethodbywhichtheGovernmentmayattempttomaximizesmallbusinessparticipation(includingveteranpreferencegoals)istoestablisharoughsubcontractinggoalforagivencontract,andthenallowpotentialcontractorstocompeteindesigninginnovatewaystostructureandmaximizesmallbusinesssubcontractingwithintheirproposals.219Thecourt,inanexerciseofjudicialrestraint,foundthe“40percentgoalisarationalexpressionoftheGovernment’spolicyofaffordingsmallbusinessconcerns…themaximumpracticable
212Hellerv.Doe,509U.S.312,321(1993).
213Hellerv.Doe,509U.S.312,320(1993);see,e.g.,Hettingav.UnitedStates,677F.3d471,478(D.C.Cir2012).
214Id.;see,Grayv.CommonwealthofVirginia,274Va.at308,645S.E.2dat459.
2152012WL5939228(Fed.Cl.2012).
216Id.
217Id.
218Id.
219Id.
![Page 159: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/159.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 33
opportunitytoparticipateassubcontractors….”220
4. Pending cases (at the time of this report)
Therearenosignificantpendingcasesonappealatthetimeofthisreportthatmaypotentiallydirectlyimpactandbeinstructivetothestudy.Themostrecentcase,citedbelow,wassettledandvoluntarilydismissedinMarch2018byorderofthedistrictcourtandstipulatedtobytheparties,afterremandfromtheNinthCircuitCourtofAppeals.
Mountain West Holding Co., Inc. v. Montana, 2017 WL 2179120 (9th Cir. May 16, 2017),
Memorandum Opinion (Not For Publication), U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, May 16,
2017, Docket Nos. 14‐26097 and 15‐35003, dismissing in part, reversing in part and remanding
the U.S. District Court decision at 2014 WL 6686734 (D. Mont. 2014).PetitionforPanelRehearingandRehearingEnBancfiledwiththeU.S.CourtofAppealsfortheNinthCircuitbyMontanaDOT,May30,2017,deniedonJune27,2017.ThecaseonremandwasvoluntarilydismissedbystipulationofthepartiesafterthepartiesenteredintoaSettlementAgreement(February23,2018).ThecasewasordereddismissedbythedistrictcourtonMarch14,2018afterthepartiesperformedtheSettlementAgreement.(SeeSectionFbelow.)
UnitedStatesv.Taylor,232F.Supp.3d741(W.D.Penn.2017).ItisinstructivetothestudytonotetherecentdecisionbythefederalDistrictCourtfortheWesternDistrictofPennsylvaniainUnitedStatesv.Taylor,232F.Supp.3d741(W.D.Penn.2017).ThecourtupheldtheIndictmentbytheUnitedStatesagainstDefendantTaylorwhohadbeenindictedonmultiplecountsarisingoutofaschemetodefraudtheUnitedStatesDepartmentofTransportation’sDisadvantagedBusinessEnterpriseProgram(“FederalDBEProgram”).UnitedStatesv.Taylor,232F.Supp.3d741,743(W.D.Penn.2017).ThecourtindenyingthemotiontodismisstheIndictmentupheldthefederalDBEregulationsinissueagainstachallengetotheFederalDBEProgram.
ThecourtrejectedachallengetotheauthorityoftheU.S.DOTtopromulgatethefederalDBEregulationsclaimingtheU.S.DOTexceededitsauthority.232F.Supp.at757.ThecourtfoundthatthelegislativehistoryandexecutiverulemakingwithrespecttotherelevantstatutoryprovisionsandregulationsweresufficienttodemonstratethatthefederalDBEregulationsweremadeunderthebroadgrantofrightsauthorizedbyCongressionalstatutes.Id.at757,citing,49U.S.C.Section322,23U.S.C.Section304,and23U.S.C.Section315.
Inaddition,thecourtinTaylor,pointedoutthattheFederalDBEProgramhasbeenupheldinvariouscontexts,“evensurvivingstrictscrutiny,”withmultiplecourtsholdingthattheDBEProgramisnarrowlytailoredtofurthercompellinggovernmentalinterests.Id.at757,citing,MidwestFenceCorp.,840F.3dat942(citingWesternStatesPavingCo.v.WashingtonStateDep’tofTransportation,407F.3d983,993(9thCir.2005);SherbrookeTurf,Inc.v.MinnesotaDep’tofTransportation,345F.3d964,973(8thCir.2003);AdarandConstructors,Inc.v.Slater,228F.3d1147,1155(10thCir.2000)).
AfterthecourtdeniedDefendantTaylor’smotiontodismisstheIndictment,theDefendantsubsequentlypleadedguilty.RecentlyonMarch13,2018,thecourtissuedthefinalJudgment
220Id.
![Page 160: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/160.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 34
sentencingtheDefendant,andorderedrestitutionandafine.ThecasealsowasterminatedonMarch13,2018.
RotheDevelopment,Inc.v.U.S.D.O.D.andS.B.A.,2016WL4719049(D.C.Cir.2016).Also,itisinstructivetothestudytopointouttherecentdecisioninRotheDevelopment,Inc.v.U.S.DepartmentofDefenseandSmallBusinessAdministration,2016WL4719049(D.C.Cir.Sept.9,2016),affirmingonothergrounds,RotheDevelopment,Inc.v.UnitedStatesDepartmentofDefense,U.S.SmallBusinessAdministration,etal,107F.Supp.3d183,2015WL3536271(D.D.C.,2015),certiorarideniedin2017.
RothefiledthisactionagainsttheU.S.DepartmentofDefenseandtheU.S.SmallBusinessAdministrationchallengingtheconstitutionalityoftheSection8(a)Programonitsface.TheRothecaseisnearlyidenticaltothechallengebroughtinDynaLanticCorp.v.U.S.DepartmentofDefense,885F.Supp.2d237(D.D.C.2012).DynaLantic’scourtrejectedtheplaintiff’sfacialattackandheldtheSection8(a)Programfaciallyconstitutional.
PlaintiffRothereliesonsubstantiallythesamerecordevidenceandnearlyidenticallegalargumentsasinDynaLanticandurgedthecourttostrikedowntherace‐consciousprovisionsofSection8(a)ontheirface.ThedistrictcourtinRotheagreedwiththecourt’sfindings,holdingsandreasoninginDynaLantic,andthusconcludedthatSection8(a)isconstitutionalonitsface.
Thedistrictcourtconcludedthatplaintiff’sfacialconstitutionalchallengetotheSection8(a)Programfailed,thatthegovernmentdemonstratedacompellinginterestfortheracialclassification,theneedforremedialactionissupportedbystrongandunrebuttedevidence,andtheSection8(a)programisnarrowlytailored.
RotheappealedthedecisiontotheUnitedStatesCourtofAppealsfortheDistrictofColumbiaCircuit.Themajorityofthethreejudgepanelaffirmedthedistrictcourt’sdecision,butonothergrounds.221
TheCourtofAppealsinRothefoundthatthechallengewasonlytotheSection8(a)statute,nottheimplementingregulations,andthusheldtheSection8(a)statutewasrace‐neutral.222Therefore,thecourtheldtherationalbasistestappliedandnotstrictscrutiny.223Thecourtaffirmedthegrantofsummaryjudgmenttothegovernmentdefendantsapplyingtherationalbasisstandard,andupheldthevalidityofSection8(a)basedonthelimitedchallengebyRothetothestatuteandnottheregulations.
TheCourtofAppealsheldthatSection8(a)oftheSmallBusinessActdoesnotwarrantstrictscrutinybecauseitdoesnotonitsfaceclassifyindividualsbyrace.224Section8(a),theCourtsaid,unliketheimplementingregulations,usesfaciallyrace‐neutraltermsofeligibilitytoidentify
2212016WL4719049(September9,2016).
2222016WL4719049,at*1‐2.
223Id.
2242016WL4719049at**1‐2.
![Page 161: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/161.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 35
individualvictimsofdiscrimination,prejudice,orbias,withoutpresumingthatmembersofcertainracial,ethnic,orculturalgroupsqualifyassuch.225SeeSectionGbelow.
RothefiledaPetitionforRehearingandRehearingEnBanctothefullCourtofAppeals.ThecourtdeniedthePetition.RothethenfiledaPetitionforaWritofCertioraritotheU.S.SupremeCourt,whichwasdeniedonOctober16,2017.2017WL1375832.
Ongoing review.TheaboverepresentsasummaryofthelegalframeworkpertinenttothestudyandimplementationofDBE/MBE/WBE,orrace‐,ethnicity‐,orgender‐neutralprograms,theFederalDBEProgram,theFederalACDBEProgram,andtheimplementationoftheFederalDBEandACDBEProgramsbystateDOTsandlocalgovernmentrecipientsoffederalfunds.Becausethisisadynamicareaofthelaw,theframeworkissubjecttoongoingreviewasthelawcontinuestoevolve.Thefollowingprovidesmoredetailedsummariesofkeyrecentdecisions.
225Id.
![Page 162: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/162.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 36
SUMMARIES OF RECENT DECISIONS
D. Recent Decisions Involving State or Local Government MBE/WBE/DBE Programs in the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals
1. Concrete Works of Colorado, Inc. v. City and County of Denver, 321 F.3d 950 (10th Cir. 2003), cert. denied, 540 U.S. 1027, 124 S. Ct. 556 (2003) (Scalia, Justice with whom the Chief Justice Rehnquist, joined, dissenting from the denial of certiorari)
ThiscaseisinstructivetothedisparitystudybecauseitisarecentdecisionthatupheldthevalidityofalocalgovernmentMBE/WBEprogram.ItissignificanttonotethattheTenthCircuitdidnotapplythenarrowlytailoredtestandthusdidnotruleonanapplicationofthenarrowlytailoredtest,insteadfindingthattheplaintiffhadwaivedthatchallengeinoneoftheearlierdecisionsinthecase.ThiscasealsoisoneoftheonlycasestohavefoundprivatesectormarketplacediscriminationasabasistoupholdanMBE/WBE‐typeprogram.
InConcreteWorkstheUnitedStatesCourtofAppealsfortheTenthCircuitheldthattheCityandCountyofDenverhadacompellinginterestinlimitingracediscriminationintheconstructionindustry,thattheCityhadanimportantgovernmentalinterestinremedyinggenderdiscriminationintheconstructionindustry,andfoundthattheCityandCountyofDenverhadestablishedacompellinggovernmentalinteresttohavearace‐andgender‐basedprogram.InConcreteWorks,theCourtofAppealsdidnotaddresstheissueofwhethertheMWBEOrdinancewasnarrowlytailoredbecauseitheldthedistrictcourtwasbarredunderthelawofthecasedoctrinefromconsideringthatissuesinceitwasnotraisedonappealbytheplaintiffconstructioncompaniesaftertheyhadlostthatissueonsummaryjudgmentinanearlierdecision.Therefore,theCourtofAppealsdidnotreachadecisionastonarrowlytailoringorconsiderthatissueinthecase.
Case history.Plaintiff,ConcreteWorksofColorado,Inc.(“CWC”)challengedtheconstitutionalityofan“affirmativeaction”ordinanceenactedbytheCityandCountyofDenver(hereinafterthe“City”or“Denver”).321F.3d950,954(10thCir.2003).TheordinanceestablishedparticipationgoalsforracialminoritiesandwomenoncertainCityconstructionandprofessionaldesignprojects.Id.
TheCityenactedanOrdinanceNo.513(“1990Ordinance”)containingannualgoalsforMBE/WBEutilizationonallcompetitivelybidprojects.Id.at956.Aprimecontractorcouldalsosatisfythe1990Ordinancerequirementsbyusing“goodfaithefforts.”Id.In1996,theCityreplacedthe1990OrdinancewithOrdinanceNo.304(the“1996Ordinance”).Thedistrictcourtstatedthatthe1996Ordinancedifferedfromthe1990OrdinancebyexpandingthedefinitionofcoveredcontractstoincludesomeprivatelyfinancedcontractsonCity‐ownedland;addedupdatedinformationandfindingstothestatementoffactualsupportforcontinuingtheprogram;refinedtherequirementsforMBE/WBEcertificationandgraduation;mandatedtheuseofMBEsandWBEsonchangeorders;andexpandedsanctionsforimproperbehaviorbyMBEs,WBEsormajority‐ownedcontractorsinfailingtoperformtheaffirmativeactioncommitmentsmadeonCityprojects.Id.at956‐57.
![Page 163: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/163.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 37
The1996Ordinancewasamendedin1998byOrdinanceNo.948(the“1998Ordinance”).The1998OrdinancereducedannualpercentagegoalsandprohibitedanMBEoraWBE,actingasabidder,fromcountingself‐performedworktowardprojectgoals.Id.at957.
CWCfiledsuitchallengingtheconstitutionalityofthe1990Ordinance.Id.Thedistrictcourtconductedabenchtrialontheconstitutionalityofthethreeordinances.Id.ThedistrictcourtruledinfavorofCWCandconcludedthattheordinancesviolatedtheFourteenthAmendment.Id.TheCitythenappealedtotheTenthCircuitCourtofAppeals.Id.TheCourtofAppealsreversedandremanded.Id.at954.
TheCourtofAppealsappliedstrictscrutinytorace‐basedmeasuresandintermediatescrutinytothegender‐basedmeasures.Id.at957‐58,959.TheCourtofAppealsalsocitedRichmondv.J.A.CrosonCo.,forthepropositionthatagovernmentalentity“canuseitsspendingpowerstoremedyprivatediscrimination,ifitidentifiesthatdiscriminationwiththeparticularityrequiredbytheFourteenthAmendment.”488U.S.469,492(1989)(pluralityopinion).Because“anefforttoalleviatetheeffectsofsocietaldiscriminationisnotacompellinginterest,”theCourtofAppealsheldthatDenvercoulddemonstratethatitsinterestiscompellingonlyifit(1)identifiedthepastorpresentdiscrimination“withsomespecificity,”and(2)demonstratedthata“strongbasisinevidence”supportsitsconclusionthatremedialactionisnecessary.Id.at958,quotingShawv.Hunt,517U.S.899,909‐10(1996).
ThecourtheldthatDenvercouldmeetitsburdenwithoutconclusivelyprovingtheexistenceofpastorpresentracialdiscrimination.Id.Rather,Denvercouldrelyon“empiricalevidencethatdemonstrates‘asignificantstatisticaldisparitybetweenthenumberofqualifiedminoritycontractors…andthenumberofsuchcontractorsactuallyengagedbythelocalityorthelocality’sprimecontractors.’”Id.,quotingCroson,488U.S.at509(pluralityopinion).Furthermore,theCourtofAppealsheldthatDenvercouldrelyonstatisticalevidencegatheredfromthesix‐countyDenverMetropolitanStatisticalArea(MSA)andcouldsupplementthestatisticalevidencewithanecdotalevidenceofpublicandprivatediscrimination.Id.
TheCourtofAppealsheldthatDenvercouldestablishitscompellinginterestbypresentingevidenceofitsowndirectparticipationinracialdiscriminationoritspassiveparticipationinprivatediscrimination.Id.TheCourtofAppealsheldthatonceDenvermetitsburden,CWChadtointroduce“credible,particularizedevidencetorebut[Denver’s]initialshowingoftheexistenceofacompellinginterest,whichcouldconsistofaneutralexplanationforthestatisticaldisparities.”Id.(internalcitationsandquotationsomitted).TheCourtofAppealsheldthatCWCcouldalsorebutDenver’sstatisticalevidence“by(1)showingthatthestatisticsareflawed;(2)demonstratingthatthedisparitiesshownbythestatisticsarenotsignificantoractionable;or(3)presentingcontrastingstatisticaldata.”Id.(internalcitationsandquotationsomitted).TheCourtofAppealsheldthattheburdenofproofatalltimesremainedwithCWCtodemonstratetheunconstitutionalityoftheordinances.Id.at960.
TheCourtofAppealsheldthattomeetitsburdenofdemonstratinganimportantgovernmentalinterestpertheintermediatescrutinyanalysis,Denvermustshowthatthegender‐basedmeasuresintheordinanceswerebasedon“reasonedanalysisratherthanthroughthemechanicalapplicationoftraditional,ofteninaccurate,assumptions.”Id.,quotingMiss.Univ.forWomenv.Hogan,458U.S.718,726(1982).
![Page 164: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/164.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 38
The studies.Denverpresentedhistorical,statisticalandanecdotalevidenceinsupportofitsMBE/WBEprograms.DenvercommissionedanumberofstudiestoassessitsMBE/WBEprograms.Id.at962.TheconsultingfirmhiredbyDenverutilizeddisparityindicesinpart.Id.at962.The1990StudyalsoexaminedMBEandWBEutilizationintheoverallDenverMSAconstructionmarket,bothpublicandprivate.Id.at963.
TheconsultingfirmalsointerviewedrepresentativesofMBEs,WBEs,majority‐ownedconstructionfirms,andgovernmentofficials.Id.Basedonthisinformation,the1990Studyconcludedthat,despiteDenver’seffortstoincreaseMBEandWBEparticipationinDenverPublicWorksprojects,someDenveremployeesandprivatecontractorsengagedinconductdesignedtocircumventthegoalsprogram.Id.Afterreviewingthestatisticalandanecdotalevidencecontainedinthe1990Study,theCityCouncilenactedthe1990Ordinance.Id.
AftertheTenthCircuitdecidedConcreteWorksII,Denvercommissionedanotherstudy(the“1995Study”).Id.at963.Using1987CensusBureaudata,the1995StudyagainexaminedutilizationofMBEsandWBEsintheconstructionandprofessionaldesignindustrieswithintheDenverMSA.Id.The1995StudyconcludedthatMBEsandWBEsweremorelikelytobeone‐personorfamily‐runbusinesses.TheStudyconcludedthatHispanic‐ownedfirmswerelesslikelytohavepaidemployeesthanwhite‐ownedfirmsbutthatAsian/NativeAmerican‐ownedfirmsweremorelikelytohavepaidemployeesthanwhite‐orotherminority‐ownedfirms.Todeterminewhetherthesefactorsexplainedoverallmarketdisparities,the1995StudyusedtheCensusdatatocalculatedisparityindicesforallfirmsintheDenverMSAconstructionindustryandseparatelycalculateddisparityindicesforfirmswithpaidemployeesandfirmswithnopaidemployees.Id.at964.
TheCensusBureauinformationwasalsousedtoexamineaveragerevenuesperemployeeforDenverMSAconstructionfirmswithpaidemployees.Hispanic‐,Asian‐,NativeAmerican‐,andwomen‐ownedfirmswithpaidemployeesallreportedlowerrevenuesperemployeethanmajority‐ownedfirms.The1995Studyalsoused1990Censusdatatocalculateratesofself‐employmentwithintheDenverMSAconstructionindustry.TheStudyconcludedthatthedisparitiesintheratesofself‐employmentforblacks,Hispanics,andwomenpersistedevenaftercontrollingforeducationandlengthofworkexperience.The1995StudycontrolledforthesevariablesandreportedthatblacksandHispanicsworkingintheDenverMSAconstructionindustrywerelessthanhalfaslikelytoowntheirownbusinessesaswerewhitesofcomparableeducationandexperience.Id.
Inlate1994andearly1995,atelephonesurveyofconstructionfirmsdoingbusinessintheDenverMSAwasconducted.Id.at965.Basedoninformationobtainedfromthesurvey,theconsultantcalculatedpercentageutilizationandpercentageavailabilityofMBEsandWBEs.Percentageutilizationwascalculatedfromrevenueinformationprovidedbytherespondingfirms.PercentageavailabilitywascalculatedbasedonthenumberofMBEsandWBEsthatrespondedtothesurveyquestionregardingrevenues.Usingtheseutilizationandavailabilitypercentages,the1995Studyshoweddisparityindicesof64forMBEsand70forWBEsintheconstructionindustry.Intheprofessionaldesignindustry,disparityindiceswere67forMBEsand69forWBEs.The1995Studyconcludedthatthedisparityindicesobtainedfromthetelephonesurveydataweremoreaccuratethanthoseobtainedfromthe1987Censusdatabecausethedataobtainedfromthetelephonesurveyweremorerecent,hadanarrowerfocus,
![Page 165: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/165.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 39
andincludeddataonCcorporations.Additionally,itwaspossibletocalculatedisparityindicesforprofessionaldesignfirmsfromthesurveydata.Id.
In1997,theCityconductedanotherstudytoestimatetheavailabilityofMBEsandWBEsandtoexamine,interalia,whetherraceandgenderdiscriminationlimitedtheparticipationofMBEsandWBEsinconstructionprojectsofthetypetypicallyundertakenbytheCity(the“1997Study”).Id.at966.The1997StudyusedgeographicandspecializationinformationtocalculateMBE/WBEavailability.Availabilitywasdefinedas“theratioofMBE/WBEfirmstothetotalnumberoffirmsinthefour‐digitSICcodesandgeographicmarketarearelevanttotheCity’scontracts.”Id.
The1997StudycomparedMBE/WBEavailabilityandutilizationintheColoradoconstructionindustry.Id.ThestatewidemarketwasusedbecausenecessaryinformationwasunavailablefortheDenverMSA.Id.at967.Additionally,datacollectedin1987bytheCensusBureauwasusedbecausemorecurrentdatawasunavailable.TheStudycalculateddisparityindicesforthestatewideconstructionmarketinColoradoasfollows:41forAfricanAmericanfirms,40forHispanicfirms,14forAsianandotherminorities,and74forwomen‐ownedfirms.Id.
The1997StudyalsocontainedananalysisofwhetherAfricanAmericans,Hispanics,orAsianAmericansworkingintheconstructionindustryarelesslikelytobeself‐employedthansimilarlysituatedwhites.Id.UsingdatafromthePublicUseMicrodataSamples(“PUMS”)ofthe1990CensusofPopulationandHousing,theStudyusedasampleofindividualsworkingintheconstructionindustry.TheStudyconcludedthatinbothColoradoandtheDenverMSA,AfricanAmericans,Hispanics,andNativeAmericansworkingintheconstructionindustryhadlowerself‐employmentratesthanwhites.AsianAmericanshadhigherself‐employmentratesthanwhites.
UsingtheavailabilityfigurescalculatedearlierintheStudy,theStudythencomparedtheactualavailabilityofMBE/WBEsintheDenverMSAwiththepotentialavailabilityofMBE/WBEsiftheyformedbusinessesatthesamerateaswhiteswiththesamecharacteristics.Id.Finally,theStudyexaminedwhetherself‐employedminoritiesandwomenintheconstructionindustryhavelowerearningsthanwhitemaleswithsimilarcharacteristics.Id.at968.Usinglinearregressionanalysis,theStudycomparedbusinessownerswithsimilaryearsofeducation,ofsimilarage,doingbusinessinthesamegeographicarea,andhavingothersimilardemographiccharacteristics.Evenaftercontrollingforseveralfactors,theresultsshowedthatself‐employedAfricanAmericans,Hispanics,NativeAmericans,andwomenhadlowerearningsthanwhitemales.Id.
The1997StudyalsoconductedamailsurveyofbothMBE/WBEsandnon‐MBE/WBEstoobtaininformationontheirexperiencesintheconstructionindustry.OftheMBE/WBEswhoresponded,35percentindicatedthattheyhadexperiencedatleastoneincidentofdisparatetreatmentwithinthelastfiveyearswhileengagedinbusinessactivities.Thesurveyalsoposedthefollowingquestion:“Howoftendoprimecontractorswhouseyourfirmasasubcontractoronpublicsectorprojectswith[MBE/WBE]goalsorrequirements…alsouseyourfirmonpublicsectororprivatesectorprojectswithout[MBE/WBE]goalsorrequirements?”Fifty‐eightpercentofminoritiesand41percentofwhitewomenwhorespondedtothisquestionindicatedtheywere“seldomornever”usedonnon‐goalsprojects.Id.
![Page 166: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/166.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 40
MBE/WBEswerealsoaskedwhetherthefollowingaspectsofprocurementmadeitmoredifficultorimpossibletoobtainconstructioncontracts:(1)bondingrequirements,(2)insurancerequirements,(3)largeprojectsize,(4)costofcompletingproposals,(5)obtainingworkingcapital,(6)lengthofnotificationforbiddeadlines,(7)prequalificationrequirements,and(8)previousdealingswithanagency.Thisquestionwasalsoaskedofnon‐MBE/WBEsinaseparatesurvey.Withoneexception,MBE/WBEsconsideredeachaspectofprocurementmoreproblematicthannon‐MBE/WBEs.Todeterminewhetherafirm’ssizeorexperienceexplainedthedifferentresponses,aregressionanalysiswasconductedthatcontrolledforageofthefirm,numberofemployees,andlevelofrevenues.Theresultsagainshowedthatwiththesame,singleexception,MBE/WBEshadmoredifficultiesthannon‐MBE/WBEswiththesamecharacteristics.Id.at968‐69.
Afterthe1997Studywascompleted,theCityenactedthe1998Ordinance.The1998Ordinancereducedtheannualgoalsto10percentforbothMBEsandWBEsandeliminatedaprovisionwhichpreviouslyallowedMBE/WBEstocounttheirownworktowardprojectgoals.Id.at969.
Theanecdotalevidenceincludedthetestimonyoftheseniorvice‐presidentofalarge,majority‐ownedconstructionfirmwhostatedthatwhenheworkedinDenver,hereceivedcrediblecomplaintsfromminorityandwomen‐ownedconstructionfirmsthattheyweresubjecttodifferentworkrulesthanmajority‐ownedfirms.Id.HealsotestifiedthathefrequentlyobservedgraffiticontainingracialorgenderepithetswrittenonjobsitesintheDenvermetropolitanarea.Further,hestatedthathebelieved,basedonhispersonalexperiences,thatmanymajority‐ownedfirmsrefusedtohireminority‐orwomen‐ownedsubcontractorsbecausetheybelievedthosefirmswerenotcompetent.Id.
SeveralMBE/WBEwitnessestestifiedthattheyexperienceddifficultyprequalifyingforprivatesectorprojectsandprojectswiththeCityandothergovernmentalentitiesinColorado.Oneindividualtestifiedthathercompanywasrequiredtoprequalifyforaprivatesectorprojectwhilenosimilarrequirementwasimposedonmajority‐ownedfirms.Severalotherstestifiedthattheyattemptedtoprequalifyforprojectsbuttheirapplicationsweredeniedeventhoughtheymettheprequalificationrequirements.Id.
OtherMBE/WBEstestifiedthattheirbidswererejectedevenwhentheywerethelowestbidder;thattheybelievedtheywerepaidmoreslowlythanmajority‐ownedfirmsonbothCityprojectsandprivatesectorprojects;thattheywerechargedmoreforsuppliesandmaterials;thattheywererequiredtodoadditionalworknotpartofthesubcontractingarrangement;andthattheyfounditdifficulttojoinunionsandtradeassociations.Id.TherewastestimonydetailingthedifficultiesMBE/WBEsexperiencedinobtaininglinesofcredit.OneWBEtestifiedthatshewasgivenafalseexplanationofwhyherloanwasdeclined;anothertestifiedthatthelendinginstitutionrequiredtheco‐signatureofherhusbandeventhoughherhusband,whoalsoownedaconstructionfirm,wasnotrequiredtoobtainherco‐signature;athirdtestifiedthatthebankrequiredherfathertobeinvolvedinthelendingnegotiations.Id.
Thecourtalsopointedoutanecdotaltestimonyinvolvingrecitationsofracially‐andgender‐motivatedharassmentexperiencedbyMBE/WBEsatworksites.Therewastestimonythatminorityandfemaleemployeesworkingonconstructionprojectswerephysicallyassaultedand
![Page 167: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/167.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 41
fondled,spatuponwithchewingtobacco,andpeltedwithtwo‐inchboltsthrownbymalesfromaheightof80feet.Id.at969‐70.
The legal framework applied by the court.TheCourtheldthatthedistrictcourtincorrectlybelievedDenverwasrequiredtoprovetheexistenceofdiscrimination.InsteadofconsideringwhetherDenverhaddemonstratedstrongevidencefromwhichaninferenceofpastorpresentdiscriminationcouldbedrawn,thedistrictcourtanalyzedwhetherDenver’sevidenceshowedthatthereispervasivediscrimination.Id.at970.Thecourt,quotingConcreteWorksII,statedthat“theFourteenthAmendmentdoesnotrequireacourttomakeanultimatefindingofdiscriminationbeforeamunicipalitymaytakeaffirmativestepstoeradicatediscrimination.”Id.at970,quotingConcreteWorksII,36F.3d1513,1522(10thCir.1994).Denver’sinitialburdenwastodemonstratethatstrongevidenceofdiscriminationsupporteditsconclusionthatremedialmeasureswerenecessary.Strongevidenceisthat“approachingaprimafaciecaseofaconstitutionalorstatutoryviolation,”notirrefutableordefinitiveproofofdiscrimination.Id.at97,quotingCroson,488U.S.at500.TheburdenofproofatalltimesremainedwiththecontractorplaintifftoprovebyapreponderanceoftheevidencethatDenver’s“evidencedidnotsupportaninferenceofpriordiscriminationandthusaremedialpurpose.”Id.,quotingAdarandVII,228F.3dat1176.
Denver,theCourtheld,didintroduceevidenceofdiscriminationagainsteachgroupincludedintheordinances.Id.at971.Thus,Denver’sevidencedidnotsufferfromtheproblemdiscussedbythecourtinCroson.TheCourtheldthedistrictcourterroneouslyconcludedthatDenvermustdemonstratethattheprivatefirmsdirectlyengagedinanydiscriminationinwhichDenverpassivelyparticipatesdosointentionally,withthepurposeofdisadvantagingminoritiesandwomen.TheCrosonmajorityconcludedthata“citywouldhaveacompellinginterestinpreventingitstaxdollarsfromassisting[localtrade]organizationsinmaintainingaraciallysegregatedconstructionmarket.”Id.at971,quotingCroson,488U.S.503.Thus,theCourtheldDenver’sburdenwastointroduceevidencewhichraisedtheinferenceofdiscriminatoryexclusioninthelocalconstructionindustryandlinkeditsspendingtothatdiscrimination.Id.
TheCourtnotedtheSupremeCourthasstatedthattheinferenceofdiscriminatoryexclusioncanarisefromstatisticaldisparities.Id.,citingCroson,488U.S.at503.Accordingly,itconcludedthatDenvercouldmeetitsburdenthroughtheintroductionofstatisticalandanecdotalevidence.TotheextentthedistrictcourtrequiredDenvertointroduceadditionalevidencetoshowdiscriminatorymotiveorintentonthepartofprivateconstructionfirms,thedistrictcourterred.Denver,accordingtotheCourt,wasundernoburdentoidentifyanyspecificpracticeorpolicythatresultedindiscrimination.NeitherwasDenverrequiredtodemonstratethatthepurposeofanysuchpracticeorpolicywastodisadvantagewomenorminorities.Id.at972.
ThecourtfoundDenver’sstatisticalandanecdotalevidencerelevantbecauseitidentifiesdiscriminationinthelocalconstructionindustry,notsimplydiscriminationinsociety.ThecourtheldthegenesisoftheidentifieddiscriminationisirrelevantandthedistrictcourterredwhenitdiscountedDenver’sevidenceonthatbasis.Id.
ThecourtheldthedistrictcourterroneouslyrejectedtheevidenceDenverpresentedonmarketplacediscrimination.Id.at973.Thecourtrejectedthedistrictcourt’serroneouslegalconclusionthatamunicipalitymayonlyremedyitsowndiscrimination.Thecourtstatedthis
![Page 168: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/168.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 42
conclusioniscontrarytotheholdingsinConcreteWorksIIandthepluralityopinioninCroson.Id.Thecourthelditpreviouslyrecognizedinthiscasethat“amunicipalityhasacompellinginterestintakingaffirmativestepstoremedybothpublicandprivatediscriminationspecificallyidentifiedinitsarea.”Id.,quotingConcreteWorksII,36F.3dat1529(emphasisadded).InConcreteWorksII,thecourtstatedthat“wedonotreadCrosonasrequiringthemunicipalitytoidentifyanexactlinkagebetweenitsawardofpubliccontractsandprivatediscrimination.”Id.,quotingConcreteWorksII,36F.3dat1529.
ThecourtstatedthatDenvercouldmeetitsburdenofdemonstratingitscompellinginterestwithevidenceofprivatediscriminationinthelocalconstructionindustrycoupledwithevidencethatithasbecomeapassiveparticipantinthatdiscrimination.Id.at973.Thus,Denverwasnotrequiredtodemonstratethatitis“guiltyofprohibiteddiscrimination”tomeetitsinitialburden.Id.
Additionally,thecourthadpreviouslyconcludedthatDenver’sstatisticalstudies,whichcomparedutilizationofMBE/WBEstoavailability,supportedtheinferencethat“localprimecontractors”areengagedinracialandgenderdiscrimination.Id.at974,quotingConcreteWorksII,36F.3dat1529.Thus,thecourtheldDenver’sdisparitystudiesshouldnothavebeendiscountedbecausetheyfailedtospecificallyidentifythoseindividualsorfirmsresponsibleforthediscrimination.Id.
The Court’s rejection of CWC’s arguments and the district court findings.
Use of marketplace data.Thecourtheldthedistrictcourt,interalia,erroneouslyconcludedthatthedisparitystudiesuponwhichDenverreliedweresignificantlyflawedbecausetheymeasureddiscriminationintheoverallDenverMSAconstructionindustry,notdiscriminationbytheCityitself.Id.at974.Thecourtfoundthatthedistrictcourt’sconclusionwasdirectlycontrarytotheholdinginAdarandVIIthatevidenceofbothpublicandprivatediscriminationintheconstructionindustryisrelevant.Id.,citingAdarandVII,228F.3dat1166‐67).
ThecourtheldtheconclusionreachedbythemajorityinCrosonthatmarketplacedataarerelevantinequalprotectionchallengestoaffirmativeactionprogramswasconsistentwiththeapproachlatertakenbythecourtinShawv.Hunt.Id.at975.InShaw,amajorityofthecourtreliedonthemajorityopinioninCrosonforthebroadpropositionthatagovernmentalentity’s“interestinremedyingtheeffectsofpastorpresentracialdiscriminationmayinthepropercasejustifyagovernment’suseofracialdistinctions.”Id.,quotingShaw,517U.S.at909.TheShawcourtdidnotadoptanyrequirementthatonlydiscriminationbythegovernmentalentity,eitherdirectlyorbyutilizingfirmsengagedindiscriminationonprojectsfundedbytheentity,wasremediable.Thecourt,however,didsetouttwoconditionsthatmustbemetforthegovernmentalentitytoshowacompellinginterest.“First,thediscriminationmustbeidentifieddiscrimination.”Id.at976,quotingShaw,517U.S.at910.TheCitycansatisfythisconditionbyidentifyingthediscrimination,“‘publicorprivate,withsomespecificity.’“Id.at976,citingShaw,517U.S.at910,quotingCroson,488U.S.at504(emphasisadded).Thegovernmentalentitymustalsohavea“strongbasisinevidencetoconcludethatremedialactionwasnecessary.”Id.Thus,thecourtconcludedShawspecificallystatedthatevidenceofeitherpublicorprivatediscriminationcouldbeusedtosatisfythemunicipality’sburdenofproducingstrongevidence.Id.at976.
![Page 169: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/169.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 43
InAdarandVII,thecourtnoteditconcludedthatevidenceofmarketplacediscriminationcanbeusedtosupportacompellinginterestinremedyingpastorpresentdiscriminationthroughtheuseofaffirmativeactionlegislation.Id.,citingAdarandVII,228F.3dat1166‐67(“[W]emayconsiderpublicandprivatediscriminationnotonlyinthespecificareaofgovernmentprocurementcontractsbutalsointheconstructionindustrygenerally;thusanyfindingsCongresshasmadeastotheentireconstructionindustryarerelevant.”(emphasisadded)).Further,thecourtpointedoutinthiscaseitearlierrejectedtheargumentCWCreassertedherethatmarketplacedataareirrelevantandremandedthecasetothedistrictcourttodeterminewhetherDenvercouldlinkitspublicspendingto“theDenverMSAevidenceofindustry‐widediscrimination.”Id.,quotingConcreteWorksII,36F.3dat1529.Thecourtstatedthatevidenceexplaining“theDenvergovernment’sroleincontributingtotheunderutilizationofMBEsandWBEsintheprivateconstructionmarketintheDenverMSA”wasrelevanttoDenver’sburdenofproducingstrongevidence.Id.,quotingConcreteWorksII,36F.3dat1530(emphasisadded).
Consistentwiththecourt’smandateinConcreteWorksII,theCityattemptedtoshowattrialthatit“indirectlycontributedtoprivatediscriminationbyawardingpubliccontractstofirmsthatinturndiscriminatedagainstMBEand/orWBEsubcontractorsinotherprivateportionsoftheirbusiness.”Id.TheCitycandemonstratethatitisa“‘passiveparticipant’inasystemofracialexclusionpracticedbyelementsofthelocalconstructionindustry”bycompilingevidenceofmarketplacediscriminationandthenlinkingitsspendingpracticestotheprivatediscrimination.Id.,quotingCroson,488U.S.at492.
ThecourtrejectedCWC’sargumentthatthelendingdiscriminationstudiesandbusinessformationstudiespresentedbyDenverwereirrelevant.InAdarandVII,thecourtconcludedthatevidenceofdiscriminatorybarrierstotheformationofbusinessesbyminoritiesandwomenandfaircompetitionbetweenMBE/WBEsandmajority‐ownedconstructionfirmsshowsa“stronglink”betweenagovernment’s“disbursementsofpublicfundsforconstructioncontractsandthechannelingofthosefundsduetoprivatediscrimination.”Id.at977,quotingAdarandVII,228F.3dat1167‐68.ThecourtfoundthatevidencethatprivatediscriminationresultedinbarrierstobusinessformationisrelevantbecauseitdemonstratesthatMBE/WBEsareprecludedattheoutsetfromcompetingforpublicconstructioncontracts.ThecourtalsofoundthatevidenceofbarrierstofaircompetitionisrelevantbecauseitagaindemonstratesthatexistingMBE/WBEsareprecludedfromcompetingforpubliccontracts.Thus,likethestudiesmeasuringdisparitiesintheutilizationofMBE/WBEsintheDenverMSAconstructionindustry,studiesshowingthatdiscriminatorybarrierstobusinessformationexistintheDenverconstructionindustryarerelevanttotheCity’sshowingthatitindirectlyparticipatesinindustrydiscrimination.Id.at977.
TheCitypresentedevidenceoflendingdiscriminationtosupportitspositionthatMBE/WBEsintheDenverMSAconstructionindustryfacediscriminatorybarrierstobusinessformation.Denverintroducedadisparitystudypreparedin1996andsponsoredbytheDenverCommunityReinvestmentAlliance,ColoradoCapitalInitiatives,andtheCity.TheStudyultimatelyconcludedthat“despitethefactthatloanapplicantsofthreedifferentracial/ethnicbackgroundsinthissamplewerenotappreciablydifferentasbusinesspeople,theywereultimatelytreateddifferentlybythelendersonthecrucialissueofloanapprovalordenial.”Id.at977‐78.InAdarandVII,thecourtconcludedthatthisstudy,amongotherevidence,“stronglysupport[ed]aninitialshowingofdiscriminationinlending.”Id.at978,quoting,AdarandVII,228F.3dat1170,n.13(“Lendingdiscriminationaloneofcoursedoesnotjustifyactionintheconstructionmarket.
![Page 170: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/170.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 44
However,thepersistenceofsuchdiscrimination…supportstheassertionthattheformation,aswellasutilization,ofminority‐ownedconstructionenterpriseshasbeenimpeded.”).TheCityalsointroducedanecdotalevidenceoflendingdiscriminationintheDenverconstructionindustry.
CWCdidnotpresentanyevidencethatunderminedthereliabilityofthelendingdiscriminationevidencebutsimplyrepeatedtheargument,foreclosedbycircuitprecedent,thatitisirrelevant.Thecourtrejectedthedistrictcourtcriticismoftheevidencebecauseitfailedtodeterminewhetherthediscriminationresultedfromdiscriminatoryattitudesorfromtheneutralapplicationofbankingregulations.Thecourtconcludedthatdiscriminatorymotivecanbeinferredfromtheresultsshownindisparitystudies.Thecourtheldthedistrictcourt’scriticismdidnotunderminethestudy’sreliabilityasanindicatorthattheCityispassivelyparticipatinginmarketplacediscrimination.ThecourtnotedthatinAdarandVIIittook“judicialnoticeoftheobviouscausalconnectionbetweenaccesstocapitalandabilitytoimplementpublicworksconstructionprojects.”Id.at978,quotingAdarandVII,228F.3dat1170.
DenveralsointroducedevidenceofdiscriminatorybarrierstocompetitionfacedbyMBE/WBEsintheformofbusinessformationstudies.The1990Studyandthe1995StudybothshowedthatallminoritygroupsintheDenverMSAformedtheirownconstructionfirmsatrateslowerthanthetotalpopulationbutthatwomenformedconstructionfirmsathigherrates.The1997Studyexaminedself‐employmentratesandcontrolledforgender,maritalstatus,education,availabilityofcapital,andpersonal/familyvariables.Asdiscussed,supra,theStudyconcludedthatAfricanAmericans,Hispanics,andNativeAmericansworkingintheconstructionindustryhavelowerratesofself‐employmentthansimilarlysituatedwhites.AsianAmericanshadhigherrates.The1997Studyalsoconcludedthatminorityandfemalebusinessownersintheconstructionindustry,withtheexceptionofAsianAmericanowners,havelowerearningsthanwhitemaleowners.Thisconclusionwasreachedaftercontrollingforeducation,age,maritalstatus,anddisabilities.Id.at978.
Thecourtheldthatthedistrictcourt’sconclusionthatthebusinessformationstudiescouldnotbeusedtojustifytheordinancesconflictswithitsholdinginAdarandVII.“[T]heexistenceofevidenceindicatingthatthenumberof[MBEs]wouldbesignificantly(butunquantifiably)higherbutforsuchbarriersisneverthelessrelevanttotheassessmentofwhetheradisparityissufficientlysignificanttogiverisetoaninferenceofdiscriminatoryexclusion.”Id.at979,quotingAdarandVII,228F.3dat1174.
Insum,thecourtheldthedistrictcourterredwhenitrefusedtoconsiderorgivesufficientweighttothelendingdiscriminationstudy,thebusinessformationstudies,andthestudiesmeasuringmarketplacediscrimination.ThatevidencewaslegallyrelevanttotheCity’sburdenofdemonstratingastrongbasisinevidencetosupportitsconclusionthatremediallegislationwasnecessary.Id.at979‐80.
Variables. CWCchallengedDenver’sdisparitystudiesasunreliablebecausethedisparitiesshowninthestudiesmaybeattributabletofirmsizeandexperienceratherthandiscrimination.Denvercountered,however,thatafirm’ssizehaslittleeffectonitsqualificationsoritsabilitytoprovideconstructionservicesandthatMBE/WBEs,likeallconstructionfirms,canperformmostserviceseitherbyhiringadditionalemployeesorbyemployingsubcontractors.CWCresponded
![Page 171: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/171.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 45
thatelasticityitselfisrelativetosizeandexperience;MBE/WBEsarelesscapableofexpandingbecausetheyaresmallerandlessexperienced.Id.at980.
ThecourtconcludedthatevenifitassumedthatMBE/WBEsarelessabletoexpandbecauseoftheirsmallersizeandmorelimitedexperience,CWCdidnotrespondtoDenver’sargumentandtheevidenceitpresentedshowingthatexperienceandsizearenotrace‐andgender‐neutralvariablesandthatMBE/WBEconstructionfirmsaregenerallysmallerandlessexperiencedbecauseofindustrydiscrimination.Id.at981.Thelendingdiscriminationandbusinessformationstudies,accordingtothecourt,bothstronglysupportedDenver’sargumentthatMBE/WBEsaresmallerandlessexperiencedbecauseofmarketplaceandindustrydiscrimination.Inaddition,Denver’sexperttestifiedthatdiscriminationbybanksorbondingcompanieswouldreduceafirm’srevenueandthenumberofemployeesitcouldhire.Id.
DenveralsoargueditsStudiescontrolledforsizeandthe1995Studycontrolledforexperience.Itassertedthatthe1990StudymeasuredrevenuesperemployeeforconstructionforMBE/WBEsandconcludedthattheresultingdisparities,“suggest[]thatevenamongfirmsofthesameemploymentsize,industryutilizationofMBEsandWBEswaslowerthanthatofnon‐minoritymale‐ownedfirms.”Id.at982.Similarly,the1995Studycontrolledforsize,calculating,interalia,disparityindicesforfirmswithnopaidemployeeswhichpresumablyarethesamesize.
Basedontheuncontrovertedevidencepresentedattrial,thecourtconcludedthatthedistrictcourtdidnotgivesufficientweighttoDenver’sdisparitystudiesbecauseofitserroneousconclusionthatthestudiesfailedtoadequatelycontrolforsizeandexperience.ThecourtheldthatDenverispermittedtomakeassumptionsaboutcapacityandqualificationofMBE/WBEstoperformconstructionservicesifitcansupportthoseassumptions.ThecourtfoundtheassumptionsmadeinthiscasewereconsistentwiththeevidencepresentedattrialandsupportedtheCity’spositionthatafirm’ssizedoesnotaffectitsqualifications,willingness,orabilitytoperformconstructionservicesandthatthesmallersizeandlesserexperienceofMBE/WBEsare,themselves,theresultofindustrydiscrimination.Further,thecourtpointedoutCWCdidnotconductitsowndisparitystudyusingmarketplacedataandthusdidnotdemonstratethatthedisparitiesshowninDenver’sstudieswoulddecreaseordisappearifthestudiescontrolledforsizeandexperiencetoCWC’ssatisfaction.Consequently,thecourtheldCWC’srebuttalevidencewasinsufficienttomeetitsburdenofdiscreditingDenver’sdisparitystudiesontheissueofsizeandexperience.Id.at982.
Specialization. ThedistrictcourtalsofaultedDenver’sdisparitystudiesbecausetheydidnotcontrolforfirmspecialization.Thecourtnotedthedistrictcourt’scriticismwouldbeappropriateonlyiftherewasevidencethatMBE/WBEsaremorelikelytospecializeincertainconstructionfields.Id.at982.
ThecourtfoundtherewasnoidentifiedevidenceshowingthatcertainconstructionspecializationsrequireskillslesslikelytobepossessedbyMBE/WBEs.ThecourtfoundrelevantthetestimonyoftheCity’sexpert,thatthedatahereviewedshowedthatMBEswererepresented“widelyacrossthedifferent[construction]specializations.”Id.at982‐83.TherewasnocontrarytestimonythataggregationbiascausedthedisparitiesshowninDenver’sstudies.Id.at983.
![Page 172: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/172.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 46
ThecourtheldthatCWCfailedtodemonstratethatthedisparitiesshowninDenver’sstudiesareeliminatedwhenthereiscontrolforfirmspecialization.Incontrast,oneoftheDenverstudies,whichcontrolledforSIC‐codesubspecialtyandstillshoweddisparities,providedsupportforDenver’sargumentthatfirmspecializationdoesnotexplainthedisparities.Id.at983.
Thecourtpointedoutthatdisparitystudiesmaymakeassumptionsaboutavailabilityaslongasthesameassumptionscanbemadeforallfirms.Id.at983.
Utilization of MBE/WBEs on City projects. CWCarguedthatDenvercouldnotdemonstrateacompellinginterestbecauseitoverutilizedMBE/WBEsonCityconstructionprojects.Thisargument,accordingtothecourt,wasanextensionofCWC’sargumentthatDenvercouldjustifytheordinancesonlybypresentingevidenceofdiscriminationbytheCityitselforbycontractorswhileworkingonCityprojects.BecausethecourtconcludedthatDenvercouldsatisfyitsburdenbyshowingthatitisanindirectparticipantinindustrydiscrimination,CWC’sargumentrelatingtotheutilizationofMBE/WBEsonCityprojectsgoesonlytotheweightofDenver’sevidence.Id.at984.
Consistentwiththecourt’smandateinConcreteWorksII,attrialDenversoughttodemonstratethattheutilizationdatafromprojectssubjecttothegoalsprogramweretaintedbytheprogramand“reflect[ed]theintendedremedialeffectonMBEandWBEutilization.”Id.at984,quotingConcreteWorksII,36F.3dat1526.Denverarguedthatthenon‐goalsdatawerethebetterindicatorofpastdiscriminationinpubliccontractingthanthedataonallCityconstructionprojects.Id.at984‐85.ThecourtconcludedthatDenverpresentedampleevidencetosupporttheconclusionthattheevidenceshowingMBE/WBEutilizationonCityprojectsnotsubjecttotheordinancesorthegoalsprogramsisthebetterindicatorofdiscriminationinCitycontracting.Id.at985.
ThecourtrejectedCWC’sargumentthatthemarketplacedatawereirrelevantbutagreedthatthenon‐goalsdatawerealsorelevanttoDenver’sburden.ThecourtnotedthatDenverdidnotrelyheavilyonthenon‐goalsdataattrialbutfocusedprimarilyonthemarketplacestudiestosupportitsburden.Id.at985.
Insum,thecourtheldDenverdemonstratedthattheutilizationofMBE/WBEsonCityprojectshadbeenaffectedbytheaffirmativeactionprogramsthathadbeeninplaceinoneformoranothersince1977.Thus,thenon‐goalsdatawerethebetterindicatorofdiscriminationinpubliccontracting.Thecourtconcludedthat,onbalance,thenon‐goalsdataprovidedsomesupportforDenver’spositionthatracialandgenderdiscriminationexistedinpubliccontractingbeforetheenactmentoftheordinances.Id.at987‐88.
Anecdotal evidence. Theanecdotalevidence,accordingtothecourt,includedseveralincidentsinvolvingprofoundlydisturbingbehavioronthepartoflenders,majority‐ownedfirms,andindividualemployees.Id.at989.Thecourtfoundthattheanecdotaltestimonyrevealedbehaviorthatwasnotmerelysophomoricorinsensitive,butwhichresultedinrealeconomicorphysicalharm.WhileCWCalsoarguedthatallneworsmallcontractorshavedifficultyobtainingcreditandthattreatmentthewitnessescharacterizedasdiscriminatoryisexperiencedbyallcontractors,Denver’switnessesspecificallytestifiedthattheybelievedtheincidentstheyexperiencedweremotivatedbyraceorgenderdiscrimination.Thecourtfoundtheysupported
![Page 173: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/173.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 47
thosebeliefswithtestimonythatmajority‐ownedfirmswerenotsubjecttothesamerequirementsimposedonthem.Id.
ThecourtheldtherewasnomerittoCWC’sargumentthatthewitnesses’accountsmustbeverifiedtoprovidesupportforDenver’sburden.Thecourtstatedthatanecdotalevidenceisnothingmorethanawitness’narrativeofanincidenttoldfromthewitness’perspectiveandincludingthewitness’perceptions.Id.
AfterconsideringDenver’sanecdotalevidence,thedistrictcourtfoundthattheevidence“showsthatrace,ethnicityandgenderaffecttheconstructionindustryandthosewhoworkinit”andthattheegregiousmistreatmentofminorityandwomenemployees“haddirectfinancialconsequences”onconstructionfirms.Id.at989,quotingConcreteWorksIII,86F.Supp.2dat1074,1073.Basedonthedistrictcourt’sfindingsregardingDenver’sanecdotalevidenceanditsreviewoftherecord,thecourtconcludedthattheanecdotalevidenceprovidedpersuasive,unrebuttedsupportforDenver’sinitialburden.Id.at989‐90,citingInt’lBhd.ofTeamstersv.UnitedStates,431U.S.324,339(1977)(concludingthatanecdotalevidencepresentedinapatternorpracticediscriminationcasewaspersuasivebecauseit“broughtthecold[statistics]convincinglytolife”).
Summary. ThecourtheqldtherecordcontainedextensiveevidencesupportingDenver’spositionthatithadastrongbasisinevidenceforconcludingthatthe1990Ordinanceandthe1998OrdinancewerenecessarytoremediatediscriminationagainstbothMBEsandWBEs.Id.at990.TheinformationavailabletoDenveranduponwhichtheordinanceswerepredicated,accordingtothecourt,indicatedthatdiscriminationwaspersistentinthelocalconstructionindustryandthatDenverwas,atleast,anindirectparticipantinthatdiscrimination.
TorebutDenver’sevidence,thecourtstatedCWCwasrequiredto“establishthatDenver’sevidencedidnotconstitutestrongevidenceofsuchdiscrimination.”Id.at991,quotingConcreteWorksII,36F.3dat1523.CWCcouldnotmeetitsburdenofproofthroughconjectureandunsupportedcriticismsofDenver’sevidence.Rather,itmustpresent“credible,particularizedevidence.”Id.,quotingAdarandVII,228F.3dat1175.ThecourtheldthatCWCdidnotmeetitsburden.CWChypothesizedthatthedisparitiesshowninthestudiesonwhichDenverreliescouldbeexplainedbyanynumberoffactorsotherthanracialdiscrimination.However,thecourtfounditdidnotconductitsownmarketplacedisparitystudycontrollingforthedisputedvariablesandpresentednootherevidencefromwhichthecourtcouldconcludethatsuchvariablesexplainthedisparities.Id.at991‐92.
Narrow tailoring. HavingconcludedthatDenverdemonstratedacompellinginterestintherace‐basedmeasuresandanimportantgovernmentalinterestinthegender‐basedmeasures,thecourthelditmustexaminewhethertheordinanceswerenarrowlytailoredtoservethecompellinginterestandaresubstantiallyrelatedtotheachievementoftheimportantgovernmentalinterest.Id.at992.
ThecourtstatedithadpreviouslyconcludedinitsearlierdecisionsthatDenver’sprogramwasnarrowlytailored.CWCappealedthegrantofsummaryjudgmentandthatappealculminatedinthedecisioninConcreteWorksII.Thecourtreversedthegrantofsummaryjudgmentonthecompelling‐interestissueandconcludedthatCWChadwaivedanychallengetothenarrow
![Page 174: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/174.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 48
tailoringconclusionreachedbythedistrictcourt.BecausethecourtfoundConcreteWorksdidnotchallengethedistrictcourt’sconclusionwithrespecttothesecondprongofCroson’sstrictscrutinystandard—i.e.,thattheOrdinanceisnarrowlytailoredtoremedypastandpresentdiscrimination—thecourthelditneednotaddressthisissue.Id.at992,citingConcreteWorksII,36F.3dat1531,n.24.
Thecourtconcludedthatthedistrictcourtlackedauthoritytoaddressthenarrowtailoringissueonremandbecausenoneoftheexceptionstothelawofthecasedoctrineareapplicable.Thedistrictcourt’searlierdeterminationthatDenver’saffirmative‐actionmeasureswerenarrowlytailoredislawofthecaseandbindingontheparties.
2. Adarand Constructors, Inc. v. Slater, 228 F.3d 1147 (10th Cir. 2000) cert. granted then dismissed as improvidently granted sub nom. Adarand Constructors, Inc. v. Mineta, 532 U.S. 941, 534 U.S. 103 (2001)
ThisistheAdaranddecisionbytheUnitedStatesCourtofAppealsfortheTenthCircuit,whichwasonremandfromtheearlierSupremeCourtdecisionapplyingthestrictscrutinyanalysistoanyconstitutionalchallengetotheFederalDBEProgram.SeeAdarandConstructors,Inc.v.Pena,515U.S.200(1995).ThedecisionoftheTenthCircuitinthiscasewasconsideredbytheUnitedStatesSupremeCourt,afterthatcourtgrantedcertioraritoconsidercertainissuesraisedonappeal.TheSupremeCourtsubsequentlydismissedthewritofcertiorari“asimprovidentlygranted”withoutreachingthemeritsofthecase.ThecourtdidnotdecidetheconstitutionalityoftheFederalDBEProgramasitappliestostateDOTsorlocalgovernments.
TheSupremeCourtheldthattheTenthCircuithadnotconsideredtheissuebeforetheSupremeCourtoncertiorari,namelywhetherarace‐basedprogramapplicabletodirectfederalcontractingisconstitutional.ThisissueisdistinguishedfromtheissueoftheconstitutionalityoftheUSDOTDBEProgramasitpertainstoprocurementoffederalfundsforhighwayprojectsletbystates,andtheimplementationoftheFederalDBEProgrambystateDOTs.Therefore,theSupremeCourthelditwouldnotreachthemeritsofachallengetofederallawsrelatingtodirectfederalprocurement.
TurningtotheTenthCircuitdecisioninAdarandConstructors,Inc.v.Slater,228F.3d1147(10thCir.2000),theTenthCircuitupheldingeneralthefacialconstitutionalityoftheFederalDBEProgram.Thecourtfoundthatthefederalgovernmenthadacompellinginterestinnotperpetuatingtheeffectsofracialdiscriminationinitsowndistributionoffederalfundsandinremediatingtheeffectsofpastdiscriminationingovernmentcontracting,andthattheevidencesupportedtheexistenceofpastandpresentdiscriminationsufficienttojustifytheFederalDBEProgram.ThecourtalsoheldthattheFederalDBEProgramis“narrowlytailored,”andthereforeupheldtheconstitutionalityoftheFederalDBEProgram.
FollowingtheSupremeCourt’svacationoftheTenthCircuit’sdismissalonmootnessgrounds,thecourtaddressedthemeritsofthisappeal,namely,thefederalgovernment’schallengetothedistrictcourt’sgrantofsummaryjudgmenttoplaintiff‐appelleeAdarandConstructors,Inc.Insodoing,thecourtresolvedtheconstitutionalityoftheuseinfederalsubcontractingprocurementoftheSubcontractorCompensationClause(“SCC”),whichemploysrace‐consciouspresumptionsdesignedtofavorminorityenterprisesandother“disadvantagedbusinessenterprises”(“DBEs”).
![Page 175: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/175.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 49
Thecourt’sevaluationoftheSCCprogramutilizesthe“strictscrutiny”standardofconstitutionalreviewenunciatedbytheSupremeCourtinanearlierdecisioninthiscase.Idat1155.
ThecourtaddressedtheconstitutionalityoftherelevantstatutoryprovisionsasappliedintheSCCprogram,aswellastheirfacialconstitutionality.Id.at1160.ItwasthejudgmentofthecourtthattheSCCprogramandtheDBEcertificationprogramsascurrentlystructured,thoughnotastheywerestructuredin1997whenthedistrictcourtlastrenderedjudgment,passedconstitutionalmuster:Thecourtheldtheywerenarrowlytailoredtoserveacompellinggovernmentalinterest.Id.
“CompellingInterest”inrace–consciousmeasuresdefined.Thecourtstatedthattheremaybeacompellinginterestthatsupportstheenactmentofrace‐consciousmeasures.JusticeO’Connorexplicitlystates:“Theunhappypersistenceofboththepracticeandthelingeringeffectsofracialdiscriminationagainstminoritygroupsinthiscountryisanunfortunatereality,andgovernmentisnotdisqualifiedfromactinginresponsetoit.”AdarandIII,515U.S.at237;seealsoShawv.Hunt,517U.S.899,909,(1996)(statingthat“remedyingtheeffectsofpastorpresentracialdiscriminationmayinthepropercasejustifyagovernment’suseofracialdistinctions”(citingCroson,488U.S.at498–506)).InterpretingCroson,thecourtrecognizedthat“theFourteenthAmendmentpermitsrace‐consciousprogramsthatseekbothtoeradicatediscriminationbythegovernmentalentityitselfandtopreventthepublicentityfromactingasa‘“passiveparticipant”inasystemofracialexclusionpracticedbyelementsofthelocalconstructionindustry’byallowingtaxdollars‘tofinancetheevilofprivateprejudice.’“ConcreteWorksofColo.,Inc.v.City&CountyofDenver,36F.3d1513,1519(10thCir.1994)(quotingCroson,488U.S.at492,109S.Ct.706).Id.at1164.
ThegovernmentidentifiedthecompellinginterestatstakeintheuseofracialpresumptionsintheSCCprogramas“remedyingtheeffectsofracialdiscriminationandopeningupfederalcontractingopportunitiestomembersofpreviouslyexcludedminoritygroups.”Id.
Evidencerequiredtoshowcompellinginterest.Whilethegovernment’sarticulatedinterestwascompellingasatheoreticalmatter,thecourtdeterminedwhethertheactualevidenceprofferedbythegovernmentsupportedtheexistenceofpastandpresentdiscriminationinthepublicly‐fundedhighwayconstructionsubcontractingmarket.Id.at1166.
The“benchmarkforjudgingtheadequacyofthegovernment’sfactualpredicateforaffirmativeactionlegislation[i]swhetherthereexistsa‘strongbasisinevidencefor[thegovernment’s]conclusionthatremedialactionwasnecessary.’“ConcreteWorks,36F.3dat1521(quotingCroson,488U.S.at500,(quoting(plurality)))(emphasisinConcreteWorks).Bothstatisticalandanecdotalevidenceareappropriateinthestrictscrutinycalculus,althoughanecdotalevidencebyitselfisnot.Id.at1166,citingConcreteWorks,36F.3dat1520–21.
Afterthegovernment’sinitialshowing,theburdenshiftedtoAdarandtorebutthatshowing:“Notwithstandingtheburdenofinitialproductionthatrests”withthegovernment,“[t]heultimateburden[ofproof]remainswith[thechallengingparty]todemonstratetheunconstitutionalityofanaffirmative‐actionprogram.”Id.(quotingWygant,476U.S.at277–78,(plurality)).“[T]henonminority[challengers]...continuetobeartheultimateburdenofpersuadingthecourtthat[thegovernmententity’s]evidencedidnotsupportaninferenceof
![Page 176: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/176.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 50
priordiscriminationandthusaremedialpurpose.”Id.at1166,quoting,ConcreteWorks,at1522–23.
Inaddressingthequestionofwhatevidenceofdiscriminationsupportsacompellinginterestinprovidingaremedy,thecourtconsideredbothdirectandcircumstantialevidence,includingpost‐enactmentevidenceintroducedbydefendantsaswellastheevidenceinthelegislativehistoryitself.Id.at1166,citing,ConcreteWorks,36F.3dat1521,1529n.23(consideringpost‐enactmentevidence).Thecourtstateditmayconsiderpublicandprivatediscriminationnotonlyinthespecificareaofgovernmentprocurementcontractsbutalsointheconstructionindustrygenerally;thus,anyfindingsCongresshasmadeastotheentireconstructionindustryarerelevant.Idat1166‐67citing,ConcreteWorks,at1523,1529,andCroson,488U.S.at492(Op.ofO’Connor,J.).
Evidenceinthepresentcase.Therecanbenodoubt,thecourtfound,thatCongressrepeatedlyhasconsideredtheissueofdiscriminationingovernmentconstructionprocurementcontracts,findingthatracialdiscriminationanditscontinuingeffectshavedistortedthemarketforpubliccontracts—especiallyconstructioncontracts—necessitatingarace‐consciousremedy.Id.at1167,citing,Appendix—TheCompellingInterestforAffirmativeActioninFederalProcurement,61Fed.Reg.26,050,26,051–52&nn.12–21(1996)(“TheCompellingInterest“)(citingapproximatelythirtycongressionalhearingssince1980concerningminority‐ownedbusinesses).But,thecourtsaid,thequestionisnotmerelywhetherthegovernmenthasconsideredevidence,butratherthenatureandextentoftheevidenceithasconsidered.Id.
InConcreteWorks,thecourtnotedthat:
NeitherCrosonnoritsprogenyclearlystatewhetherprivatediscriminationthatis innoway fundedwithpublic taxdollarscan,by itself,provide therequisitestrongbasis inevidencenecessary to justifyamunicipality’saffirmativeactionprogram.Aplurality inCroson simplysuggested that remedialmeasures couldbe justified upon a municipality’s showing that “it had essentially become a‘passiveparticipant’inasystemofracialexclusionpracticedbyelementsofthelocalconstructionindustry.”Croson,488U.S.at492,109S.Ct.706.Althoughwedo not read Croson as requiring the municipality to identify an exact linkagebetweenitsawardofpubliccontractsandprivatediscrimination,suchevidencewould at least enhance the municipality’s factual predicate for a race‐ andgender‐consciousprogram.
Id.at1167,quoting,ConcreteWorks,36F.3dat1529.
UnlikeConcreteWorks,theevidencepresentedbythegovernmentinthepresentcasedemonstratedtheexistenceoftwokindsofdiscriminatorybarrierstominoritysubcontractingenterprises,bothofwhichshowastronglinkbetweenracialdisparitiesinthefederalgovernment’sdisbursementsofpublicfundsforconstructioncontractsandthechannelingofthosefundsduetoprivatediscrimination.Id.at1168.Thefirstdiscriminatorybarriersaretotheformationofqualifiedminoritysubcontractingenterprisesduetoprivatediscrimination,precludingfromtheoutsetcompetitionforpublicconstructioncontractsbyminorityenterprises.Theseconddiscriminatorybarriersaretofaircompetitionbetweenminorityandnon‐minoritysubcontractingenterprises,againduetoprivatediscrimination,precluding
![Page 177: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/177.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 51
existingminorityfirmsfromeffectivelycompetingforpublicconstructioncontracts.Thegovernmentalsopresentedfurtherevidenceintheformoflocaldisparitystudiesofminoritysubcontractingandstudiesoflocalsubcontractingmarketsaftertheremovalofaffirmativeactionprograms.Id.at1168.
a. Barriers to minority business formation in construction subcontracting.Astothefirstkindofbarrier,thegovernment’sevidenceconsistedofnumerouscongressionalinvestigationsandhearingsaswellasoutsidestudiesofstatisticalandanecdotalevidence—citedanddiscussedinTheCompellingInterest,61Fed.Reg.26,054–58—anddemonstratedthatdiscriminationbyprimecontractors,unions,andlendershaswoefullyimpededtheformationofqualifiedminoritybusinessenterprisesinthesubcontractingmarketnationwide.Id.at1168.Theevidencedemonstratedthatprimecontractorsintheconstructionindustryoftenrefusetoemployminoritysubcontractorsdueto“oldboy”networks—basedonafamilialhistoryofparticipationinthesubcontractingmarket—fromwhichminorityfirmshavetraditionallybeenexcluded.Id.
Also,thecourtfound,subcontractors’unionsplacedbeforeminorityfirmsaplethoraofbarrierstomembership,therebyeffectivelyblockingthemfromparticipationinasubcontractingmarketinwhichunionmembershipisanimportantconditionforsuccess.Id.at1169.Thecourtstatedthatthegovernment’sevidencewasparticularlystrikingintheareaoftherace‐baseddenialofaccesstocapital,withoutwhichtheformationofminoritysubcontractingenterprisesisstymied.Id.at1169.
b. Barriers to competition by existing minority enterprises.Withregardtobarriersfacedbyexistingminorityenterprises,thegovernmentpresentedevidencetendingtoshowthatdiscriminationbyprimecontractors,privatesectorcustomers,businessnetworks,suppliers,andbondingcompaniesfostersadecidedlyunevenplayingfieldforminoritysubcontractingenterprisesseekingtocompeteintheareaoffederalconstructionsubcontracts.Id.at1170.ThecourtsaiditwasclearthatCongressdevotedconsiderableenergytoinvestigatingandconsideringthissystematicexclusionofexistingminorityenterprisesfromopportunitiestobidonconstructionprojectsresultingfromtheinsularityandsometimesoutrightracismofnon‐minorityfirmsintheconstructionindustry.Id.at1171.
Thegovernment’sevidence,thecourtfound,stronglysupportedthethesisthatinformal,raciallyexclusionarybusinessnetworksdominatethesubcontractingconstructionindustry,shuttingoutcompetitionfromminorityfirms.Id.Minoritysubcontractingenterprisesintheconstructionindustry,thecourtpointedout,foundthemselvesunabletocompetewithnon‐minorityfirmsonanequalplayingfieldduetoracialdiscriminationbybondingcompanies,withoutwhomthoseminorityenterprisescannotobtainsubcontractingopportunities.Thegovernmentpresentedevidencethatbondingisanessentialrequirementofparticipationinfederalsubcontractingprocurement.Id.Finally,thegovernmentpresentedevidenceofdiscriminationbysuppliers,theresultofwhichwasthatnonminoritysubcontractorsreceivedspecialpricesanddiscountsfromsuppliersnotavailabletominoritysubcontractors,drivingup“anticipatedcosts,andthereforethebid,forminority‐ownedbusinesses.”Id.at1172.
ContrarytoAdarand’scontentions,onthebasisoftheforegoingsurveyofevidenceregardingminoritybusinessformationandcompetitioninthesubcontractingindustry,thecourtfoundthegovernment’sevidenceastothekindsofobstaclesminoritysubcontractingbusinessesface
![Page 178: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/178.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 52
constitutedastrongbasisfortheconclusionthatthoseobstaclesarenot“thesameproblemsfacedbyanynewbusiness,regardlessoftheraceoftheowners.”Id.at1172.
c. Local disparity studies.ThecourtnotedthatfollowingtheSupremeCourt’sdecisioninCroson,numerousstateandlocalgovernmentsundertookstatisticalstudiestoassessthedisparity,ifany,betweenavailabilityandutilizationofminority‐ownedbusinessesingovernmentcontracting.Id.at1172.Thegovernment’sreviewofthosestudiesrevealedthatalthoughsuchdisparitywasleastglaringinthecategoryofconstructionsubcontracting,eveninthatarea“minorityfirmsstillreceiveonly87centsforeverydollartheywouldbeexpectedtoreceive”basedontheiravailability.TheCompellingInterest,61Fed.Reg.at26,062.Id.Inthatregard,theCrosonmajoritystatedthat“[w]herethereisasignificantstatisticaldisparitybetweenthenumberofqualifiedminoritycontractorswillingandabletoperformaparticularserviceandthenumberofsuchcontractorsactuallyengagedbythe[government]orthe[government’s]primecontractors,aninferenceofdiscriminatoryexclusioncouldarise.”Id.quoting,488U.S.at509(Op.ofO’Connor,J.)(citationsomitted).
Thecourtsaidthatitwasmindfulthat“wherespecialqualificationsarenecessary,therelevantstatisticalpoolforpurposesofdemonstratingdiscriminatoryexclusionmustbethenumberofminoritiesqualifiedtoundertaketheparticulartask.”Id.at1172,quoting,Crosonat501–02.Butthecourtfoundthathere,itwasunawareofsuch“specialqualifications”asidefromthegeneralqualificationsnecessarytooperateaconstructionsubcontractingbusiness.Id.Ataminimum,thedisparityindicatedthattherehadbeenunder‐utilizationoftheexistingpoolofminoritysubcontractors;andthereisnoevidenceeitherintherecordonappealorinthelegislativehistorybeforethecourtthatthoseminoritysubcontractorswhohavebeenutilizedhaveperformedinadequatelyorotherwisedemonstratedalackofnecessaryqualifications.Id.at1173.
ThecourtfoundthedisparitybetweenminorityDBEavailabilityandmarketutilizationinthesubcontractingindustryraisedaninferencethatthevariousdiscriminatoryfactorsthegovernmentciteshavecreatedthatdisparity.Id.at1173.InConcreteWorks,thecourtstatedthat“[w]eagreewiththeothercircuitswhichhaveinterpretedCrosonimpliedlytopermitamunicipalitytorely...ongeneraldatareflectingthenumberofMBEsandWBEsinthemarketplacetodefeatthechallenger’ssummaryjudgmentmotion,”andthecourtheresaiditdidnotseeanydifferentstandardinthecaseofananalogoussuitagainstthefederalgovernment.Id.at1173,citing,ConcreteWorks,36F.3dat1528.Althoughthegovernment’saggregatefigureofa13%disparitybetweenminorityenterpriseavailabilityandutilizationwasnotoverwhelmingevidence,thecourtstateditwassignificant.Id.
Itwasmademoresignificantbytheevidenceshowingthatdiscriminatoryfactorsdiscouragebothenterpriseformationofminoritybusinessesandutilizationofexistingminorityenterprisesinpubliccontracting.Id.at1173.Thecourtsaidthatitwouldbe“sheerspeculation”toevenattempttoattachaparticularfiguretothehypotheticalnumberofminorityenterprisesthatwouldexistwithoutdiscriminatorybarrierstominorityDBEformation.Id.at1173,quoting,Croson,488U.S.at499.However,theexistenceofevidenceindicatingthatthenumberofminorityDBEswouldbesignificantly(butunquantifiably)higherbutforsuchbarriers,thecourtfoundwasneverthelessrelevanttotheassessmentofwhetheradisparitywassufficientlysignificanttogiverisetoaninferenceofdiscriminatoryexclusion.Id.at1174.
![Page 179: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/179.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 53
d. Results of removing affirmative action programs.Thecourttooknoticeofanadditionalsourceofevidenceofthelinkbetweencompellinginterestandremedy.Therewasampleevidencethatwhenrace‐consciouspubliccontractingprogramsarestruckdownordiscontinued,minoritybusinessparticipationintherelevantmarketdropssharplyorevendisappears.Id.at1174.Althoughthatevidencestandingalonethecourtfoundwasnotdispositive,itstronglysupportedthegovernment’sclaimthattherearesignificantbarrierstominoritycompetitioninthepublicsubcontractingmarket,raisingthespecterofracialdiscrimination.Id.“Wherethereisasignificantstatisticaldisparitybetweenthenumberofqualifiedminoritycontractorswillingandabletoperformaparticularserviceandthenumberofsuchcontractorsactuallyengagedbythelocalityorthelocality’sprimecontractors,aninferenceofdiscriminatoryexclusioncouldarise.”Id.at1174,quoting,Croson,488U.S.at509(Op.ofO’Connor,J.)(citationsomitted).
Insum,onthebasisoftheforegoingbodyofevidence,thecourtconcludedthatthegovernmenthadmetitsinitialburdenofpresentinga“strongbasisinevidence”sufficienttosupportitsarticulated,constitutionallyvalid,compellinginterest.Id.at1175,citing,Croson,488U.S.at500(quotingWygant,476U.S.at277).
Adarand’s rebuttal failed to meet their burden.Adarand,thecourtfoundutterlyfailedtomeettheir“ultimateburden”ofintroducingcredible,particularizedevidencetorebutthegovernment’sinitialshowingoftheexistenceofacompellinginterestinremedyingthenationwideeffectsofpastandpresentdiscriminationinthefederalconstructionprocurementsubcontractingmarket.Id.at1175.ThecourtrejectedAdarand’scharacterizationofvariouscongressionalreportsandfindingsasconclusoryanditshighlygeneralcriticismofthemethodologyofnumerous“disparitystudies”citedbythegovernmentanditsamicicuriaeassupplementalevidenceofdiscrimination.Id.Theevidencecitedbythegovernmentanditsamicicuriaeandexaminedbythecourtonlyreinforcedtheconclusionthat“racialdiscriminationanditseffectscontinuetoimpairtheabilityofminority‐ownedbusinessestocompeteinthenation’scontractingmarkets.”Id.
Thegovernment’sevidencepermittedafindingthatasamatteroflawCongresshadtherequisitestrongbasisinevidencetotakeactiontoremedyracialdiscriminationanditslingeringeffectsintheconstructionindustry.Id.at1175.Thisevidencedemonstratedthatboththerace‐basedbarrierstoentryandtheongoingrace‐basedimpedimentstosuccessfacedbyminoritysubcontractingenterprises—bothdiscussedabove—werecausedeitherbycontinuingdiscriminationorthelingeringeffectsofpastdiscriminationontherelevantmarket.Id.at1176.Congresswasnotlimitedtosimplyproscribingfederaldiscriminationagainstminoritycontractors,asithadalreadydone.ThecourtheldthattheConstitutiondoesnotobligateCongresstostandidlybyandcontinuetopourmoneyintoanindustrysoshapedbytheeffectsofdiscriminationthattheprofitstobederivedfromcongressionalappropriationsaccrueexclusivelytothebeneficiaries,howeverpersonallyinnocent,oftheeffectsofracialprejudice.Id.at1176.
ThecourtalsorejectedAdarand’scontentionthatCongressmustmakespecificfindingsregardingdiscriminationagainsteverysinglesub‐categoryofindividualswithinthebroadracialandethniccategoriesdesignatedbystatuteandaddressedbytherelevantlegislativefindings.Id.at1176.IfCongresshadvalidevidence,forexamplethatAsian–Americanindividualsaresubject
![Page 180: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/180.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 54
todiscriminationbecauseoftheirstatusasAsian–Americans,thecourtnoteditmakesnosensetorequiresub‐findingsthatsubcategoriesofthatclassexperienceparticularizeddiscriminationbecauseoftheirstatusas,forexample,AmericansfromBhutan.Id.“Race”thecourtsaidisoftenaclassificationofdubiousvalidity—scientifically,legally,andmorally.Thecourtdidnotimpartexcesslegitimacytoracialclassificationsbytakingnoticeoftheharshfactthatracialdiscriminationcommonlyoccursalongthelinesofthebroadcategoriesidentified:“BlackAmericans,HispanicAmericans,NativeAmericans,AsianPacificAmericans,andotherminorities.”Id.at1176,note18,citing,15U.S.C.§637(d)(3)(C).
Thecourtstatedthatitwasnotsuggestingthattheevidencecitedbythegovernmentwasunrebuttable.Id.at1176.Rather,thecourtindicateditwaspointingoutthatunderprecedentitisforAdarandtorebutthatevidence,andithasnotdonesototheextentrequiredtoraiseagenuineissueofmaterialfactastowhetherthegovernmenthasmetitsevidentiaryburden.Id.Thecourtreiteratedthat“[t]heultimateburden[ofproof]remainswith[thechallengingparty]todemonstratetheunconstitutionalityofanaffirmative‐actionprogram.”Id.at1522(quotingWygant,476U.S.at277–78,106S.Ct.1842(plurality)).“[T]henonminority[challengers]...continuetobeartheultimateburdenofpersuadingthecourtthat[thegovernmententity’s]evidencedidnotsupportaninferenceofpriordiscriminationandthusaremedialpurpose.”Id.(quotingWygant,476U.S.at293,106S.Ct.1842(O’Connor,J.,concurring)).BecauseAdarandhadfailedutterlytomeetitsburden,thecourtheldthegovernment’sinitialshowingstands.Id.
Insum,guidedbyConcreteWorks,thecourtconcludedthattheevidencecitedbythegovernmentanditsamici,particularlythatcontainedinTheCompellingInterest,61Fed.Reg.26,050,morethansatisfiedthegovernment’sburdenofproductionregardingthecompellinginterestforarace‐consciousremedy.Id.at1176.Congresshadacompellinginterestineradicatingtheeconomicrootsofracialdiscriminationinhighwaytransportationprogramsfundedbyfederalmonies.Id.Thecourtthereforeaffirmedthedistrictcourt’sfindingofacompellinginterest.Id.
Narrow Tailoring.ThecourtstateditwasguidedinitsinquirybytheSupremeCourtcasesthathaveappliedthenarrow‐tailoringanalysistogovernmentaffirmativeactionprograms.Id.at1177.Inapplyingstrictscrutinytoacourt‐orderedprogramremedyingthefailuretopromoteblackpoliceofficers,apluralityoftheCourtstatedthat
[i]ndeterminingwhetherrace‐conscious remediesareappropriate,we look toseveral factors, including the necessity for the relief and the efficacy ofalternative remedies; the flexibility and duration of the relief, including theavailabilityofwaiverprovisions; therelationshipof thenumericalgoals to therelevantlabormarket;andtheimpactofthereliefontherightsofthirdparties.
Id.at1177,quoting,Paradise,480U.S.at171(1986)(pluralityop.ofBrennan,J.)(citationsomitted).
Regardingflexibility,“theavailabilityofwaiver”isofparticularimportance.Id.Asfornumericalproportionality,Crosonadmonishedthecourtstobewareofthecompletelyunrealisticassumptionthatminoritieswillchooseaparticulartradeinlockstepproportiontotheirrepresentationinthelocalpopulation.”Id.,quoting,Croson,488U.S.at507(quotingSheetMetal
![Page 181: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/181.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 55
Workers’,478U.S.at494(O’Connor,J.,concurringinpartanddissentinginpart)).Inthatcontext,a“rigidnumericalquota,”thecourtnotedparticularlydisservesthecauseofnarrowtailoring.Id.at1177,citing,Croson,508,Asforburdensimposedonthirdparties,thecourtpointedtoapluralityoftheCourtinWygantthatstated:
AspartofthisNation’sdedicationtoeradicatingracialdiscrimination,innocentpersonsmaybecalledupontobearsomeof theburdenof theremedy.“Wheneffectuatinga limitedandproperly tailoredremedytocure theeffectsofpriordiscrimination, such a ‘sharing of the burden’ by innocent parties is notimpermissible.”476U.S.at280–81(Op.ofPowell,J.)(quotingFullilove,448U.S.at484(plurality))(furtherquotationsandfootnoteomitted).Weareguidedbythatbenchmark.
Id.at1177.
JusticeO’Connor’smajorityopinioninCrosonaddedafurtherfactortothecourt’sanalysis:under–orover‐inclusivenessoftheDBEclassification.Id.at1177.InCroson,theSupremeCourtstruckdownanaffirmativeactionprogramasinsufficientlynarrowlytailoredinpartbecause“thereisnoinquiryintowhetherornottheparticularMBEseekingaracialpreferencehassufferedfromtheeffectsofpastdiscrimination....[T]heinterestinavoidingthebureaucraticeffortnecessarytotailorremedialrelieftothosewhotrulyhavesufferedfromtheeffectsofpriordiscriminationcannotjustifyarigidlinedrawnonthebasisofasuspectclassification.”Id.,quoting,Croson,488U.S.at508(citationomitted).Thus,thecourtsaiditmustbeespeciallycarefultoinquireintowhethertherehasbeenanefforttoidentifyworthyparticipantsinDBEprogramsorwhethertheprogramsinquestionpaintwithtoobroad—ortoonarrow—abrush.Id.
ThecourtstatedmorespecificguidancewasfoundinAdarandIII,whereinremandingforstrictscrutiny,theSupremeCourtidentifiedtwoquestionsapparentlyofparticularimportanceintheinstantcase:(1)“[c]onsiderationoftheuseofrace‐neutralmeans;”and(2)“whethertheprogram[is]appropriatelylimited[soas]nottolastlongerthanthediscriminatoryeffectsitisdesignedtoeliminate.”Id.at1177,quoting,AdarandIII,515U.S.at237–38(internalquotationsandcitationsomitted).ThccourtthusengagedinathoroughanalysisofthefederalprograminlightofAdarandIII’sspecificquestionsonremand,andtheforegoingnarrow‐tailoringfactors:(1)theavailabilityofrace‐neutralalternativeremedies;(2)limitsonthedurationoftheSCCandDBEcertificationprograms;(3)flexibility;(4)numericalproportionality;(5)theburdenonthirdparties;and(6)over–orunder‐inclusiveness.Id.at1178.
ItissignificanttonotethatthecourtindeterminingtheFederalDBEProgramis“narrowlytailored”focusedonthefederalregulations,49CFRPart26,andinparticular§26.1(a),(b),and(f).Thecourtpointedoutthatthefederalregulationsinstructrecipientsasfollows:
[y]oumustmeetthemaximumfeasibleportionofyouroverallgoalbyusingrace‐neutralmeansof facilitatingDBEparticipation,49CFR§26.51(a)(2000);seealso49 CFR § 26.51(f)(2000) (if a recipient can meet its overall goal through race‐neutralmeans, itmust implement its programwithout the use of race‐consciouscontractingmeasures),andenumeratealistofrace‐neutralmeasures,see49CFR§
![Page 182: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/182.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 56
26.51(b)(2000). The current regulations also outline several race‐neutral meansavailable to program recipients including assistance in overcoming bonding andfinancingobstacles,providingtechnicalassistance,establishingprogramstoassiststart‐upfirms,andothermethods.See49CFR§26.51(b).Wethereforearedealinghere with revisions that emphasize the continuing need to employ non‐race‐consciousmethodsevenastheneedforrace‐consciousremediesisrecognized.
Idat1178‐1179.
InconsideringwhethertheFederalDBEProgramisnarrowlytailored,thecourtalsoaddressedtheargumentmadebythecontractorthattheprogramisover‐andunder‐inclusiveforseveralreasons,includingthatCongressdidnotinquireintodiscriminationagainsteachparticularminorityracialorethnicgroup.Thecourtheldthatinsofarasthescopeofinquirysuggestedwasaparticularstate’sconstructionindustryalone,thiswouldbeatoddswithitsholdingregardingthecompellinginterestinCongress’spowertoenactnationwidelegislation.Id.at1185‐1186.
Thecourtstatedthatbecauseofthe“unreliabilityofracialandethniccategoriesandthefactthatdiscriminationcommonlyoccursbasedonmuchbroaderracialclassifications,”extrapolatingfindingsofdiscriminationagainstthevariousethnicgroups“ismoreaquestionofnomenclaturethanofnarrowtailoring.”Id.Thecourtfoundthatthe“Constitutiondoesnoterectabarriertothegovernment’sefforttocombatdiscriminationbasedonbroadracialclassificationsthatmightpreventitfromenumeratingparticularethnicoriginsfallingwithinsuchclassifications.”Id.
Holding.MindfuloftheSupremeCourt’smandatetoexerciseparticularcareinexamininggovernmentalracialclassifications,thecourtconcludedthatthe1996SCCwasinsufficientlynarrowlytailoredasappliedinthiscase,andwasthusunconstitutionalunderAdarandIII‘sstrictstandardofscrutiny.Nonetheless,afterexaminingthecurrent(post1996)SCCandDBEcertificationprograms,thecourtheldthatthe1996defectshavebeenremedied,andthecurrentfederalDBEprogramsnowmettherequirementsofnarrowtailoring.Id.at1178.
Finally,theTenthCircuitdidnotspecificallyaddressachallengetothelettingoffederally‐fundedconstructioncontractsbystatedepartmentsoftransportation.ThecourtpointedoutthatplaintiffAdarand“concededthatitschallengeintheinstantcaseisto‘thefederalprogram,implementedbyfederalofficials,’andnottothelettingoffederally‐fundedconstructioncontractsbystateagencies.”228F.3dat1187.ThecourtheldthatitdidnothavebeforeitasufficientrecordtoenableittoevaluatetheseparatequestionofColoradoDOT’simplementationofrace‐consciouspolicies.Id.at1187‐1188.Therefore,thecourtdidnotaddresstheconstitutionalityofanasappliedattackontheimplementationofthefederalprogrambytheColoradoDOTorotherlocalorstategovernmentsimplementingtheFederalDBEProgram.
Thecourtthusreversedthedistrictcourtandremandedthecase.
![Page 183: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/183.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 57
3. Concrete Works of Colorado, Inc. v. City and County of Denver, 36 F.3d 1513 (10th Cir. 1994)
ThecourtconsideredwhethertheCityandCountyofDenver’srace‐andgender‐consciouspubliccontractawardprogramcompliedwiththeFourteenthAmendment’sguaranteeofequalprotectionofthelaws.Plaintiff‐AppellantConcreteWorksofColorado,Inc.(“ConcreteWorks”)appealedthedistrictcourt’ssummaryjudgmentorderupholdingtheconstitutionalityofDenver’spubliccontractprogram.ThecourtconcludedthatgenuineissuesofmaterialfactexistwithregardtotheevidentiarysupportthatDenverpresentstodemonstratethatitsprogramsatisfiestherequirementsofCityofRichmondv.J.A.CrosonCo.,488U.S.469(1989).Accordingly,thecourtreversedandremanded.36F.3d1513(10thCir.1994).
Background.In,1990,theDenverCityCouncilenactedOrdinance(“Ordinance”)toenablecertifiedracialminoritybusinessenterprises(“MBEs”)1andwomen‐ownedbusinessenterprises(“WBEs”)toparticipateinpublicworksprojects“toanextentapproximatingthelevelof[their]availabilityandcapacity.”Id.at1515.ThisOrdinancewasthemostrecentinaseriesofprovisionsthattheDenverCityCouncilhasadoptedsince1983toremedyperceivedraceandgenderdiscriminationinthedistributionofpublicandprivateconstructioncontracts.Id.at1516.
In1992,ConcreteWorks,anonminorityandmale‐ownedconstructionfirm,filedthisEqualProtectionClausechallengetotheOrdinance.Id.ConcreteWorksallegedthattheOrdinancecausedittolosethreeconstructioncontractsforfailuretocomplywitheitherthestatedMBEandWBEparticipationgoalsorthegood‐faithrequirements.RatherthanpursuingadministrativeorstatecourtreviewoftheOCC’sfindings,ConcreteWorksinitiatedthisaction,seekingapermanentinjunctionagainstenforcementoftheOrdinanceanddamagesforlostcontracts.Id.
In1993,andafterextensivediscovery,thedistrictcourtgrantedDenver’ssummaryjudgmentmotion.ConcreteWorks,Inc.v.CityandCountyofDenver,823F.Supp.821(D.Colo.1993).ThecourtconcludedthatConcreteWorkshadstandingtobringthisclaim.Id.Withrespecttothemerits,thecourtheldthatDenver’sprogramsatisfiedthestrictscrutinystandardembracedbyamajorityoftheSupremeCourtinCrosonbecauseitwasnarrowlytailoredtoachieveacompellinggovernmentinterest.Id.
Standing.Attheoutset,theTenthCircuitonappealconsideredDenver’scontentionthatConcreteWorksfailstosatisfyitsburdenofestablishingstandingtochallengetheOrdinance’sconstitutionality.Id.at1518.ThecourtconcludedthatConcreteWorksdemonstrated“injuryinfact”becauseitsubmittedbidsonthreeprojectsandtheOrdinancepreventeditfromcompetingonanequalbasiswithminorityandwomen‐ownedprimecontractors.Id.
Specifically,theunequalnatureofthebiddingprocessliedintheOrdinance’srequirementthatanonminorityprimecontractormustmeetMBEandWBEparticipationgoalsbyenteringintojointventureswithMBEsandWBEsorhiringthemassubcontractors(orsatisfyingtheten‐stepgoodfaithrequirement).Id.Incontrast,minorityandwomen‐ownedprimecontractorscouldusetheirownworktosatisfyMBEandWBEparticipationgoals.Id.Thus,theextrarequirements,
![Page 184: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/184.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 58
thecourtfoundimposedcostsandburdensonnonminorityfirmsthatprecludedthemfromcompetingwithMBEsandWBEsonanequalbasis.Id.at1519.
Inadditiontodemonstrating“injuryinfact,”ConcreteWorks,thecourtheld,alsosatisfiedthetworemainingelementstoestablishstanding:(1)acausalrelationshipbetweentheinjuryandthechallengedconduct;and(2)alikelihoodthattheinjurywillberedressedbyafavorableruling.Thus,thecourtconcludedthatConcreteWorkshadstandingtochallengetheconstitutionalityofDenver’srace‐andgender‐consciouscontractprogram.Id.
Equal Protection Clause Standards.Thecourtdeterminedtheappropriatestandardofequalprotectionreviewbyexaminingthenatureoftheclassificationsembodiedinthestatute.ThecourtappliedstrictscrutinytotheOrdinance’srace‐basedpreferencescheme,andthusinquiredwhetherthestatutewasnarrowlytailoredtoachieveacompellinggovernmentinterest.Id.Gender‐basedclassifications,incontrast,thecourtconcludedareevaluatedundertheintermediatescrutinyrubric,whichprovidesthatthelawmustbesubstantiallyrelatedtoanimportantgovernmentobjective.Id.
Permissible Evidence and Burdens of Proof.InCroson,apluralityoftheCourtconcludedthatstateandlocalgovernmentshaveacompellinginterestinremedyingidentifiedpastandpresentdiscriminationwithintheirborders.Id.citing,Croson,488U.S.at492,509,ThepluralityexplainedthattheFourteenthAmendmentpermitsrace‐consciousprogramsthatseekbothtoeradicatediscriminationbythegovernmentalentityitselfandtopreventthepublicentityfromactingasa“‘passiveparticipant’inasystemofracialexclusionpracticedbyelementsofthelocalconstructionindustry”byallowingtaxdollars“tofinancetheevilofprivateprejudice.”Id.citing,Crosonat492.
A.GeographicScopeoftheData.ConcreteWorkscontendedthatCrosonprecludedthecourtfromconsideringempiricalevidenceofdiscriminationinthesix‐countyDenverMetropolitanStatisticalArea(MSA).Instead,itarguedCrosonwouldallowDenveronlytousedatadescribingdiscriminationwithintheCityandCountyofDenver.Id.at1520.
ThecourtstatedthatamajorityinCrosonobservedthatbecausediscriminationvariesacrossmarketareas,stateandlocalgovernmentscannotrelyonnationalstatisticsofdiscriminationintheconstructionindustrytodrawconclusionsaboutprevailingmarketconditionsintheirownregions.Id.at1520,citingCrosonat504.Therelevantareainwhichtomeasurediscrimination,then,isthelocalconstructionmarket,butthatisnotnecessarilyconfinedbyjurisdictionalboundaries.Id.
ThecourtsaidthatCrosonsupporteditsconsiderationofdatafromtheDenverMSAbecausethisdatawassufficientlygeographicallytargetedtotherelevantmarketarea.Id.Therecordrevealedthatover80percentofDenverDepartmentofPublicWorks(“DPW”)constructionanddesigncontractswereawardedtofirmslocatedwithintheDenverMSA.Id.at1520.Toconfinethepermissibledatatoagovernmentalbody’sstrictgeographicalboundaries,thecourtfound,wouldignoretheeconomicrealitythatcontractsareoftenawardedtofirmssituatedinadjacentareas.Id.
![Page 185: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/185.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 59
Thecourtsaidthatitisimportantthatthepertinentdatacloselyrelatetothejurisdictionalareaofthemunicipalitywhoseprogramisscrutinized,buthereDenver’scontractingactivity,insofarasconstructionworkwasconcerned,wascloselyrelatedtotheDenverMSA.Id.at1520.Therefore,thecourtheldthatdatafromtheDenverMSAwasadequatelyparticularizedforstrictscrutinypurposes.Id.
B. Anecdotal Evidence.ConcreteWorksarguedthatthedistrictcourtcommittedreversibleerrorbyconsideringsuchnon‐empiricalevidenceofdiscriminationastestimonyfromminorityandwomen‐ownedfirmsdeliveredduringpublichearings,affidavitsfromMBEsandWBEs,summariesoftelephoneinterviewsthatDenverofficialsconductedwithMBEsandWBEs,andreportsgeneratedduringOfficeofAffirmativeActioncomplianceinvestigations.Id.
Thecourtstatedthatselectiveanecdotalevidenceaboutminoritycontractors’experiences,withoutmore,wouldnotprovideastrongbasisinevidencetodemonstratepublicorprivatediscriminationinDenver’sconstructionindustrysufficienttopassconstitutionalmusterunderCroson.Id.at1520.
Personalaccountsofactualdiscriminationortheeffectsofdiscriminatorypracticesmay,accordingtothecourt,however,vividlycomplementempiricalevidence.Id.Thecourtconcludedthatanecdotalevidenceofamunicipality’sinstitutionalpracticesthatexacerbatediscriminatorymarketconditionsareoftenparticularlyprobative.Id.Therefore,thegovernmentmayincludeanecdotalevidenceinitsevidentiarymosaicofpastorpresentdiscrimination.Id.
ThecourtpointedoutthatinthecontextofemploymentdiscriminationsuitsarisingunderTitleVIIoftheCivilRightsActof1964,theSupremeCourthasstatedthatanecdotalevidencemaybring“coldnumbersconvincinglytolife.”Id.at1520,quoting,InternationalBhd.ofTeamstersv.UnitedStates,431U.S.324,339(1977).Infact,thecourtfound,themajorityinCrosonimpliedlyendorsedtheinclusionofpersonalaccountsofdiscrimination.Id.at1521.Thecourtthusdeemedanecdotalevidenceofpublicandprivateraceandgenderdiscriminationappropriatesupplementaryevidenceinthestrictscrutinycalculus.Id.
C. Post–Enactment Evidence.ConcreteWorksarguedthatthecourtshouldconsideronlyevidenceofdiscriminationthatexistedpriortoDenver’senactmentoftheOrdinance.Id.InCroson,thecourtnotedthattheSupremeCourtunderscoredthatamunicipality“mustidentify[the]discrimination...withsomespecificitybefore[it]mayuserace‐consciousrelief.”Id.at1521,quoting,Croson,488U.S.at504(emphasisadded).Absentanypre‐enactmentevidenceofdiscrimination,thecourtsaidamunicipalitywouldbeunabletosatisfyCroson.Id.
However,thecourtdidnotreadCroson’sevidentiaryrequirementasforeclosingtheconsiderationofpost‐enactmentevidence.Id.at1521.Post‐enactmentevidence,ifcarefullyscrutinizedforitsaccuracy,thecourtfoundwouldoftenprovequiteusefulinevaluatingtheremedialeffectsorshortcomingsoftherace‐consciousprogram.Id.This,thecourtnotedwasespeciallytrueinthiscase,whereDenverfirstimplementedalimitedaffirmativeactionprogramin1983andhassincemodifiedandexpandeditsscope.Id.
Thecourtheldthestrongweightofauthorityendorsestheadmissibilityofpost‐enactmentevidencetodeterminewhetheranaffirmativeactioncontractprogramcomplieswithCroson.Id.
![Page 186: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/186.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 60
at1521.Thecourtagreedthatpost‐enactmentevidencemayproveusefulforacourt’sdeterminationofwhetheranordinance’sdeviationfromthenormofequaltreatmentisnecessary.Id.Thus,evidenceofdiscriminationexistingsubsequenttoenactmentofthe1990Ordinance,thecourtconcludedwasproperlybeforeit.Id.
D. Burdens of Production and Proof.ThecourtstatedthattheSupremeCourtinCrosonstruckdowntheCityofRichmond’sminorityset‐asideprogrambecausetheCityfailedtoprovideanadequateevidentiaryshowingofpastorpresentdiscrimination.Id.at1521,citing,Croson,488U.S.at498–506.ThecourtpointedoutthatbecausetheFourteenthAmendmentonlytoleratesrace‐consciousprogramsthatnarrowlyseektoremedyidentifieddiscrimination,theSupremeCourtinCrosonexplainedthatstateandlocalgovernments“mustidentifythatdiscrimination...withsomespecificitybeforetheymayuserace‐consciousrelief.”Id.,citingCroson,at504.ThecourtsaidthattheSupremeCourt’sbenchmarkforjudgingtheadequacyofthegovernment’sfactualpredicateforaffirmativeactionlegislationwaswhetherthereexistsa“strongbasisinevidencefor[thegovernment’s]conclusionthatremedialactionwasnecessary.”Id.,quoting,Croson,at500.
AlthoughCrosonplacestheburdenofproductiononthemunicipalitytodemonstratea“strongbasisinevidence”thatitsrace‐andgender‐consciouscontractprogramaimstoremedyspecificallyidentifiedpastorpresentdiscrimination,thecourtheldtheFourteenthAmendmentdoesnotrequireacourttomakeanultimatejudicialfindingofdiscriminationbeforeamunicipalitymaytakeaffirmativestepstoeradicatediscrimination.Id.at1521,citing,Wygant,476U.S.at292(O’Connor,J.,concurringinpartandconcurringinthejudgment).Anaffirmativeactionresponsetodiscriminationissustainableagainstanequalprotectionchallengesolongasitispredicateduponstrongevidenceofdiscrimination.Id.at1522,citing,Croson,488U.S.at504.
Aninferenceofdiscrimination,thecourtfound,maybemadewithempiricalevidencethatdemonstrates“asignificantstatisticaldisparitybetweenthenumberofqualifiedminoritycontractors...andthenumberofsuchcontractorsactuallyengagedbythelocalityorthelocality’sprimecontractors.”Id.at1522,quoting,Crosonat509(plurality).ThecourtconcludedthatitdidnotreadCrosontorequireanattempttocraftaprecisemathematicalformulatoassessthequantumofevidencethatrisestotheCroson“strongbasisinevidence”benchmark.Id.That,thecourtstated,mustbeevaluatedonacase‐by‐casebasis.Id.
Thecourtsaidthattheadequacyofamunicipality’sshowingofdiscriminationmustbeevaluatedinthecontextofthebreadthoftheremedialprogramadvancedbythemunicipality.Id.at1522,citing,Crosonat498.Ultimately,whetherastrongbasisinevidenceofpastorpresentdiscriminationexists,therebyestablishingacompellinginterestforthemunicipalitytoenactarace‐consciousordinance,thecourtfoundisaquestionoflaw.Id.Underlyingthatlegalconclusion,however,thecourtnotedarefactualdeterminationsabouttheaccuracyandvalidityofamunicipality’sevidentiarysupportforitsprogram.Id.
Notwithstandingtheburdenofinitialproductionthatrestswiththemunicipality,“[t]heultimateburden[ofproof]remainswith[thechallengingparty]todemonstratetheunconstitutionalityofanaffirmative‐actionprogram.”Id.at1522,quoting,Wygant,476U.S.at277–78(plurality).Thus,thecourtstatedthatonceDenverpresentedadequatestatisticalevidenceofpreciselydefined
![Page 187: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/187.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 61
discriminationintheDenverareaconstructionmarket,itbecameincumbentuponConcreteWorkseithertoestablishthatDenver’sevidencedidnotconstitutestrongevidenceofsuchdiscriminationorthattheremedialstatutewasnotnarrowlydrawn.Id.at1523.AbsentsuchashowingbyConcreteWorks,thecourtsaid,summaryjudgmentupholdingDenver’sOrdinancewouldbeappropriate.Id.
E. Evidentiary Predicate Underlying Denver’s Ordinance.TheevidenceofdiscriminationthatDenverpresentstodemonstrateacompellinggovernmentinterestinenactingtheOrdinanceconsistedofthreecategories:(1)evidenceofdiscriminationincitycontractingfromthemid–1970sto1990;(2)dataaboutMBEandWBEutilizationintheoverallDenverMSAconstructionmarketbetween1977and1992;and(3)anecdotalevidencethatincludedpersonalaccountsbyMBEsandWBEswhohaveexperiencedbothpublicandprivatediscriminationandtestimonyfromcityofficialswhodescribeinstitutionalgovernmentalpracticesthatperpetuatepublicdiscrimination.Id.at1523.
1. Discrimination in the Award of Public Contracts.ThecourtconsideredtheevidencethatDenverpresentedtodemonstrateunderutilizationofMBEsandWBEsintheawardofcitycontractsfromthemid1970sto1990.ThecourtfoundthatDenverofferedpersuasivepiecesofevidencethat,consideredintheabstract,couldgiverisetoaninferenceofrace‐andgender‐basedpublicdiscriminationonisolatedpublicworksprojects.Id.at1523.However,thecourtalsofoundtherecordshowedthatMBEandWBEutilizationonpubliccontractsasawholeduringthisperiodwasstrongincomparisontothetotalnumberofMBEsandWBEswithinthelocalconstructionindustry.Id.at1524.Denverofferedarebuttaltothismoregeneralevidence,butthecourtstateditwasclearthattheweighttobegivenbothtothegeneralevidenceandtothespecificevidencerelatingtoindividualcontractspresentedgenuinedisputesofmaterialfacts.
Thecourtthenengagedinananalysisofthefactualrecordandanidentificationofthegenuinematerialissuesoffactarisingfromtheparties’competingevidence.
(a) Federal Agency Reports of Discrimination in Denver.DenversubmittedfederalagencyreportsofdiscriminationinDenverpubliccontractawards.Id.at1524.Therecordcontainedasummaryofa1978studybytheUnitedStatesGeneralAccountingOffice(“GAO”),whichshowedthatbetween1975and1977minoritybusinessesweresignificantlyunderrepresentedintheperformanceofDenverpubliccontractsthatwerefinancedinwholeorinpartbyfederalgrants.Id.
ConcreteWorksarguedthatamaterialfactissuearoseaboutthevalidityofthisevidencebecause“the1978GAOReportwasnothingmorethanalistingoftheproblemsfacedbyallsmallfirms,firststartingoutinbusiness.”Id.at1524.Thecourtpointedout,however,ConcreteWorksignoredtheGAOReport’sempiricaldata,whichquantifiedtheactualdisparitybetweentheutilizationofminoritycontractorsandtheirrepresentationinthelocalconstructionindustry.Id.Inaddition,thecourtnotedthattheGAOReportreflectedthefindingsofanobjectivethirdparty.Id.Becausethisdataremaineduncontested,notwithstandingConcreteWorks’conclusoryallegationstothecontrary,thecourtfoundthe1978GAOReportprovidedevidencetosupportDenver’sshowingofdiscrimination.Id.
![Page 188: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/188.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 62
AddedtotheGAOfindingswasa1979letterfromtheUnitedStatesDepartmentofTransportation(“USDOT”)totheMayoroftheCityofDenver,describingtheUSDOTOfficeofCivilRights’studyofDenver’sdiscriminatorycontractingpracticesatStapletonInternationalAirport.Id.at1524.USDOTthreatenedtowithholdadditionalfederalfundingforStapletonbecauseDenverhad“deniedminoritycontractorsthebenefitsof,excludedthemfrom,orotherwisediscriminatedagainstthemconcerningcontractingopportunitiesatStapleton,”inviolationofTitleVIoftheCivilRightsActof1964andotherfederallaws.Id.
ThecourtdiscussedthefollowingdataasreflectedofthelowlevelofMBEandWBEutilizationonStapletoncontractspriortoDenver’sadoptionofanMBEandWBEgoalsprogramatStapletonin1981:fortheyears1977to1980,respectively,MBEutilizationwas0percent,3.8percent,.7percent,and2.1percent;dataonWBEutilizationwasunknownfortheyears1977to1979,anditwas.05percentfor1980.Id.at1524.
ThecourtstatedthatlikeitsunconvincingattempttodiscredittheGAOReport,ConcreteWorkspresentednoevidencetochallengethevalidityofUSDOT’sallegations.Id.ConcreteWorks,thecourtsaid,failedtointroduceevidencerefutingthesubstanceofUSDOT’sinformation,attackingitsmethodology,orchallengingthelowutilizationfiguresforMBEsatStapletonbefore1981.Id.at1525.Thus,accordingtothecourt,ConcreteWorksfailedtocreateagenuineissueoffactabouttheconclusionsintheUSDOT’sreport.Id.Insum,thecourtfoundthefederalagencyreportsofdiscriminationinDenver’scontractawardssupportedDenver’scontentionthatraceandgenderdiscriminationexistedpriortotheenactmentofthechallengedOrdinance.Id.
(b) Denver’s Reports of Discrimination.Denverpointedtoevidenceofpublicdiscriminationpriorto1983,theyearthatthefirstDenverordinancewasenacted.Id.at1525.A1979DPW“MajorBondProjectsFinalReport,”whichreviewedMBEandWBEutilizationonprojectsfundedbythe1972and1974bondreferendaandthe1975and1976revenuebonds,thecourtsaid,showedstrongevidenceofunderutilizationofMBEsandWBEs.Id.BasedonthisReport’sdescriptionoftheapproximately$85millionincontractawards,therewas0percentMBEandWBEutilizationforprofessionaldesignandconstructionmanagementprojects,andlessthan1percentutilizationforconstruction.Id.TheReportconcludedthatifMBEsandWBEshadbeenutilizedinthesameproportionasfoundintheconstructionindustry,5percentofthecontractdollarswouldhavebeenawardedtoMBEsandWBEs.Id.
Tounderminethisdata,ConcreteWorksallegedthattheDPWReportcontained“noinformationaboutthenumberofminorityorwomenownedfirmsthatwereused”onthesebondprojects.Id.at1525.However,thecourtconcludedtheReport’sdescriptionofMBEandWBEutilizationintermsofcontractdollarsprovidedamoreaccuratedepictionoftotalutilizationthanwouldthemerenumberofMBEandWBEfirmsparticipatingintheseprojects.Id.Thus,thecourtsaidthislineofattackbyConcreteWorkswasunavailing.Id.
ConcreteWorksalsoadvancedexperttestimonythatDenver’sdatademonstratedstrongMBEandWBEutilizationonthetotalDPWcontractsawardedbetween1978and1982.Id.Denverrespondedbypointingoutthatbecausefederalandcityaffirmativeactionprogramswereinplacefromthemid–1970stothepresent,thisoverallDPWdatareflectedtheintendedremedialeffectonMBEandWBEutilizationoftheseprograms.Id.at1526.BasedonitscontentionthattheoverallDPWdatawastherefore“tainted”anddistortedbythesepre‐existingaffirmative
![Page 189: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/189.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 63
actiongoalsprograms,Denveraskedthecourttofocusinsteadonthedatageneratedfromspecificpubliccontractprogramsthatwere,foronereasonoranother,insulatedfromfederalandlocalaffirmativeactiongoalsprograms,i.e.“non‐goalspublicprojects.”Id.
Giventhatthesamelocalconstructionindustryperformedbothgoalsandnon‐goalspubliccontracts,Denverarguedthatdatageneratedonnon‐goalspublicprojectsofferedacontrolgroupwithwhichthecourtcouldcompareMBEandWBEutilizationonpubliccontractsgovernedbyagoalsprogramandthoseinsulatedfromsuchgoalrequirements.Id.DenverarguedthattheutilizationofMBEsandWBEsonnon‐goalsprojectswasthebettertestofwhethertherehadbeendiscriminationhistoricallyinDenvercontractingpractices.Id.at1526.
DGS data.Thefirstsetofdatafromnon‐goalspublicprojectsthatDenveridentifiedwereMBEandWBEdisparityindicesonDenverDepartmentofGeneralServices(“DGS”)contracts,whichrepresentedone‐thirdofallcityconstructionfundingandwhich,priortotheenactmentofthe1990Ordinance,werenotsubjecttothegoalsprograminstitutedintheearlierordinancesforDPWcontracts.Id.at1526.TheDGSdata,thecourtfound,revealedextremelylowMBEandWBEutilization.Id.ForMBEs,theDGSdatashoweda.14disparityindexin1989anda.19disparityindexin1990—evidencethecourtstatedwasofsignificantunderutilization.Id.ForWBEs,thedisparityindexwas.47in1989and1.36in1990—thelatter,thecourtsaidshowedgreaterthanfullparticipationandtheformerdemonstratingunderutilization.Id.
ThecourtnotedthatitdidnothavethebenefitofrelevantauthoritywithwhichtocompareDenver’sdisparityindicesforWBEs.Nevertheless,thecourtconcludedDenver’sdataindicatedsignificantWBEunderutilizationsuchthattheOrdinance’sgenderclassificationarosefrom“reasonedanalysisratherthanthroughthemechanicalapplicationoftraditional,ofteninaccurate,assumptions.”Id.at1526,n.19,quoting,MississippiUniv.ofWomen,458U.S.at726.
DPW data.ThesecondsetofdatapresentedbyDenver,thecourtsaid,reflecteddistinctMBEandWBEunderutilizationonnon‐goalspublicprojectsconsistingofseparateDPWprojectsonwhichnogoalsprogramwasimposed.Id.at1527.ConcreteWorks,accordingtothecourt,attemptedtotrivializethesignificanceofthisdatabycontendingthattheprojects,indollarterms,reflectedasmallfractionofthetotalDenverMSAconstructionmarket.Id.But,thecourtnotedthatConcreteWorksmissedthepointbecausethedatawasnotintendedtoreflectconditionsintheoverallmarket.Id.Insteadthedatadealtsolelywiththeutilizationlevelsforcity‐fundedprojectsonwhichnoMBEandWBEgoalswereimposed.Id.Thecourtfoundthatitwasparticularlytellingthatthedisparityindexsignificantlydeterioratedonprojectsforwhichthecitydidnotestablishminorityandgenderparticipationgoals.Id.InsofarasConcreteWorksdidnotattackthedataonanyothergrounds,thecourtconsidereditwaspersuasiveevidenceofunderlyingdiscriminationintheDenverconstructionmarket.Id.
Empirical data.ThethirdevidentiaryitemsupportingDenver’scontentionthatpublicdiscriminationexistedpriortoenactmentofthechallengedOrdinancewasempiricaldatafrom1989,generatedafterDenvermodifieditsrace‐andgender‐consciousprogram.Id.at1527.InthewakeofCroson,DenveramendeditsprogrambyeliminatingtheminimumannualgoalsprogramforMBEandWBEparticipationandbyrequiringMBEsandWBEstodemonstratethattheyhadsufferedfrompastdiscrimination.Id.
![Page 190: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/190.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 64
Thismodification,thecourtsaid,resultedinanoticeabledeclineintheshareofDPWconstructiondollarsawardedtoMBEs.Id.From1985to1988(priortothe1989modificationofDenver’sprogram),DPWconstructiondollarsawardedtoMBEsrangedfrom17tonearly20percentoftotaldollars.Id.However,thecourtnotedthefiguredroppedto10.4percentin1989,aftertheprogrammodificationstookeffect.Id.at1527.LiketheDGSandnon‐goalsDPWprojects,this1989data,thecourtconcluded,furthersupportedtheinferencethatMBEandWBEutilizationsignificantlydeclinedafterdeletionofagoalsprogramorrelaxationoftheminimumMBEandWBEutilizationgoalrequirements.Id.
Nonetheless,thecourtstateditmustconsiderDenver’sempiricalsupportforitscontentionthatpublicdiscriminationexistedpriortotheenactmentoftheOrdinanceinthecontextoftheoverallDPWdata,whichshowedconsistentlystrongMBEandWBEutilizationfrom1978tothepresent.Id.at1528.ThecourtnotedthatalthoughDenver’sargumentmayprovepersuasiveattrialthatthenon‐goalsprojectswerethemostreliableindiciaofdiscrimination,therecordonsummaryjudgmentcontainedtwosetsofdata,onethatgaverisetoaninferenceofdiscriminationandtheotherthatunderminedsuchaninference.Id.Thisdiscrepancy,thecourtfound,highlightedwhysummaryjudgmentwasinappropriateonthisrecord.Id.
Availability data.ThecourtconcludedthatuncertaintyaboutthecapacityofMBEsandWBEsinthelocalmarkettocompetefor,andperform,thepublicprojectsforwhichtherewasunderutilizationofMBEsandWBEsfurtherhighlightedwhytherecordwasnotripeforsummaryjudgment.Id.at1528.AlthoughDenver’sdatausedasitsbaselinethepercentageoffirmsinthelocalconstructionmarketthatwereMBEsandWBEs,ConcreteWorksarguedthatamoreaccurateindicatorwouldconsiderthecapacityoflocalMBEsandWBEstoundertakethework.Id.ThecourtsaidthatuncertaintyaboutthecapacityofMBEsandWBEsinthelocalmarkettocompetefor,andperform,thepublicprojectsforwhichtherewasunderutilizationofMBEsandWBEsfurtherhighlightedwhytherecordwasnotripeforsummaryjudgment.Id.
ThecourtagreedwiththeothercircuitswhichhadatthattimeinterpretedCrosonimpliedlytopermitamunicipalitytorely,asdidDenver,ongeneraldatareflectingthenumberofMBEsandWBEsinthemarketplacetodefeatthechallenger’ssummaryjudgmentmotionorrequestforapreliminaryinjunction.Id.at1527citing,ContractorsAss’n,6F.3dat1005(comparingMBEparticipationincitycontractswiththe“percentageof[MBE]availabilityorcompositioninthe‘population’ofPhiladelphiaareaconstructionfirms”);AssociatedGen.Contractors,950F.2dat1414(relyingonavailabilitydatatoconcludethatcitypresented“detailedfindingsofpriordiscrimination”);ConeCorp.,908F.2dat916(statisticaldisparitybetween“thetotalpercentageofminoritiesinvolvedinconstructionandtheworkgoingtominorities”showsthat“theracialclassificationintheCountyplan[was]necessary”).
But,thecourtfoundConcreteWorkshadidentifiedalegitimatefactualdisputeabouttheaccuracyofDenver’sdataandquestionedwhetherDenver’srelianceonthepercentageofMBEsandWBEsavailableinthemarketplaceoverstated“theabilityofMBEsorWBEstoconductbusinessrelativetotheindustryasawholebecauseM/WBEstendtobesmallerandlessexperiencedthannonminority‐ownedfirms.”Id.at1528.Inotherwords,thecourtsaid,adisparityindexcalculatedonthebasisoftheabsolutenumberofMBEsinthelocalmarketmayshowgreaterunderutilizationthandoesdatathattakesintoconsiderationthesizeofMBEsandWBEs.Id.
![Page 191: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/191.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 65
ThecourtstatedthatitwasnotimplyingthatavailabilitywasnotanappropriatebarometertocalculateMBEandWBEutilization,nordiditcastaspersionsondatathatsimplyusedrawnumbersofMBEsandWBEscomparedtonumbersoftotalfirmsinthemarket.Id.Thecourtconcluded,however,oncecredibleinformationaboutthesizeorcapacityofthefirmswasintroducedintherecord,itbecameafactorthatthecourtshouldconsider.Id.
Denverpresentedseveralresponses.Id.at1528.Itarguedthataconstructionfirm’sprecise“capacity”atagivenmomentintimebeliedquantificationduetotheindustry’shighlyelasticnature.Id.DPWcontractsrepresentedlessthan4percentoftotalMBErevenuesandlessthan2percentofWBErevenuesin1989,therebythecourtsaid,stronglyimpliedthatMBEandWBEparticipationinDPWcontractsdidnotrenderthesefirmsincapableofconcurrentlyundertakingadditionalwork.Id.at1529.DenverpresentedevidencethatmostMBEsandWBEshadneverparticipatedincitycontracts,“althoughalmostallfirmscontactedindicatedthattheywereinterestedinCitywork.”Id.OfthoseMBEsandWBEswhohavereceivedworkfromDPW,availabledatashowedthatlessthan10percentoftheirtotalrevenueswerefromDPWcontracts.Id.
Thecourtheldallofthebackandforthargumentshighlightedthatthereweregenuineandmaterialfactualdisputesintherecord,andthatsuchdisputesabouttheaccuracyofDenver’sdatashouldnotberesolvedatsummaryjudgment.Id.at1529.
(c) Evidence of Private Discrimination in the Denver MSA.Inrecognitionthatamunicipalityhasacompellinginterestintakingaffirmativestepstoremedybothpublicandprivatediscriminationspecificallyidentifiedinitsarea,thecourtalsoconsidereddataaboutconditionsintheoverallDenverMSAconstructionindustrybetween1977and1992.Id.at1529.ThecourtstatedthatgivenDPWandDGSconstructioncontractsrepresentedapproximately2percentofallconstructionintheDenverMSA,DenverMSAindustrydatasharpenedthepictureoflocalmarketconditionsforMBEsandWBEs.Id.
AccordingtoDenver’sexpertaffidavits,theMBEdisparityindexintheDenverMSAwas.44in1977,.26in1982,and.43in1990.Id.ThecorrespondingWBEdisparityindiceswere.46in1977,.30in1982,and.42in1989.Id.Thispre‐enactmentevidenceoftheoverallDenverMSAconstructionmarket—i.e.combinedpublicandprivatesectorutilizationofMBEsandWBEs—thecourtfoundgaverisetoaninferencethatlocalprimecontractorsdiscriminatedonthebasisofraceandgender.Id.
Thecourtpointedoutthatratherthanofferinganyevidenceinrebuttal,ConcreteWorksmerelystatedthatthisempiricalevidencedidnotprovethattheDenvergovernmentitselfdiscriminatedagainstMBEsandWBEs.Id.at1529.ConcreteWorksaskedthecourttodefinetheappropriatemarketaslimitedtocontractswiththeCityandCountyofDenver.Id.But,thecourtsaidthatsucharequestignoredthelessonofCrosonthatamunicipalitymaydesignprogramstopreventtaxdollarsfrom“financ[ing]theevilofprivateprejudice.”Id.,quoting,Croson,488U.S.at492.
ThecourtfoundthatwhattheDenverMSAdatadidnotindicate,however,waswhethertherewasanylinkagebetweenDenver’sawardofpubliccontractsandtheDenverMSAevidenceofindustry‐widediscrimination.Id.at1529.ThecourtsaiditcouldnottellwhetherDenver
![Page 192: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/192.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 66
indirectlycontributedtoprivatediscriminationbyawardingpubliccontractstofirmsthatinturndiscriminatedagainstMBEand/orWBEsubcontractorsinotherprivateportionsoftheirbusinessorwhethertheprivatediscriminationwaspracticedbyfirmswhodidnotreceiveanypubliccontracts.Id.
NeitherCrosonnoritsprogeny,thecourtpointedout,clearlystatedwhetherprivatediscriminationthatwasinnowayfundedwithpublictaxdollarscould,byitself,providetherequisitestrongbasisinevidencenecessarytojustifyamunicipality’saffirmativeactionprogram.Id.ThecourtsaidapluralityinCrosonsuggestedthatremedialmeasurescouldbejustifieduponamunicipality’sshowingthat“ithadessentiallybecomea‘passiveparticipant’inasystemofracialexclusionpracticedbyelementsofthelocalconstructionindustry.”Id.at1529,quoting,Croson,488U.S.at492.
ThecourtconcludedthatCrosondidnotrequirethemunicipalitytoidentifyanexactlinkagebetweenitsawardofpubliccontractsandprivatediscrimination,butsuchevidencewouldatleastenhancethemunicipality’sfactualpredicateforarace‐andgender‐consciousprogram.Id.at1529.TherecordbeforethecourtdidnotexplaintheDenvergovernment’sroleincontributingtotheunderutilizationofMBEsandWBEsintheprivateconstructionmarketintheDenverMSA,andthecourtstatedthatthismaybeafruitfulissuetoexploreattrial.Id.at1530.
(d). Anecdotal Evidence.Therecord,accordingtothecourt,containednumerouspersonalaccountsbyMBEsandWBEs,aswellasprimecontractorsandcityofficials,describingdiscriminatorypracticesintheDenverconstructionindustry.Id.at1530.Suchanecdotalevidencewascollectedduringpublichearingsin1983and1988,interviews,thesubmissionofaffidavits,andcasestudiesperformedbyaconsultingfirmthatDenveremployedtoinvestigatepublicandprivatemarketconditionsin1990,priortotheenactmentofthe1990Ordinance.Id.
Thccourtindicatedagainthatanecdotalevidenceaboutminority‐andwomen‐ownedcontractors’experiencescouldbolsterempiricaldatathatgaverisetoaninferenceofdiscrimination.Id.at1530.Whileafactfinder,thecourtstated,shouldaccordlessweighttopersonalaccountsofdiscriminationthatreflectisolatedincidents,anecdotalevidenceofamunicipality’sinstitutionalpracticescarrymoreweightduetothesystemicimpactthatsuchinstitutionalpracticeshaveonmarketconditions.Id.
ThecourtnotedthatinadditiontotheindividualaccountsofdiscriminationthatMBEsandWBEshadencounteredintheDenverMSA,Cityaffirmativeactionofficialsexplainedthatchangeordersofferedaconvenientmeansofskirtingprojectgoalsbypermittingwhatwouldotherwisebeanewconstructionproject(andthussubjecttotheMBEandWBEparticipationrequirements)tobecharacterizedasanextensionofanexistingprojectandthuswithinDGS’sbailiwick.Id.at1530.Anassistantcityattorney,thecourtsaid,alsorevealedthatprojectshavebeenlabelled“remodeling,”asopposedto“reconstruction,”becausetheformerfallwithinDGS,andthuswerenotsubjecttoMBEandWBEgoalspriortotheenactmentofthe1990Ordinance.Id.at1530.ThecourtconcludedovertheobjectofConcreteWorksthatthisanecdotalevidencecouldbeconsideredinconjunctionwithDenver’sstatisticalanalysis.Id.
2. Summary.ThecourtsummarizeditsrulingbyindicatingDenverhadcompiledsubstantialevidencetosupportitscontentionthattheOrdinancewasenactedtoremedypastrace‐and
![Page 193: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/193.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 67
gender‐baseddiscrimination.Id.at1530.ThecourtfoundincontrasttothepredicatefactsonwhichRichmondunsuccessfullyreliedinCroson,thatDenver’sevidenceofdiscriminationbothintheawardofpubliccontractsandwithintheoverallDenverMSAwasparticularizedandgeographicallytargeted.Id.ThecourtemphasizedthatDenverneednotnegateallevidenceofnon‐discrimination,norwasitDenver’sburdentoprovejudiciallythatdiscriminationdidexist.Id.Rather,thecourtheld,Denverneedonlycomeforwardwitha“strongbasisinevidence”thatitsOrdinancewasanarrowly‐tailoredresponsetospecificallyidentifieddiscrimination.Id.Then,thecourtsaiditbecameConcreteWorks’burdentoshowthattherewasnosuchstrongbasisinevidencetosupportDenver’saffirmativeactionlegislation.Id.
ThecourtalsostatedthatConcreteWorkshadspecificallyidentifiedpotentialflawsinDenver’sdataandhadputforthevidencethatDenver’sdatafailedtosupportaninferenceofeitherpublicorprivatediscrimination.Id.at1530.WithrespecttoDenver’sevidenceofpublicdiscrimination,forexample,thecourtfoundoverallDPWdatademonstratedstrongMBEandWBEutilization,yetdataforisolatedDPWprojectsandDGScontractawardssuggestedtothecontrary.Id.Thepartiesofferedconflictingrationalesforthisdisparatedata,andthecourtconcludedtherecorddidnotprovideaclearexplanation.Id.Inaddition,thecourtsaidthatConcreteWorkspresentedalegitimatecontentionthatDenver’sdisparityindicesfailedtoconsidertherelativelysmallsizeofMBEsandWBEs,whichthecourtnotedfurtherimpededitsabilitytodrawconclusionsfromtheexistingrecord.Id.at1531.
Significantly,thecourtpointedoutthatbecauseConcreteWorksdidnotchallengethedistrictcourt’sconclusionwithrespecttothesecondprongofCroson’sstrictscrutinystandard—i.e.thattheOrdinancewasnarrowlytailoredtoremedypastandpresentdiscrimination—thecourtneednotanddidnotaddressthisissue.Id.at1531.
Onremand,thecourtstatedthepartiesshouldbepermittedtodevelopafactualrecordtosupporttheircompetinginterpretationsoftheempiricaldata.Id.at1531.Accordingly,thecourtreversedthedistrictcourtrulinggrantingsummaryjudgmentandremandedthecaseforfurtherproceedings.SeeConcreteWorksofColoradov.CityandCountyofDenver,321F.3d950(10thCir.2003).
4. Klaver Construction, Inc. v. Kansas DOT, 211 F. Supp.2d 1296 (D. Kan. 2002)
ThisisanothercasethatinvolvedachallengetotheUSDOTRegulationsthatimplementTEA‐21(49CFRPart26),inwhichtheplaintiffcontractorsoughttoenjointheKansasDepartmentofTransportation(“DOT”)fromenforcingitsDBEProgramonthegroundsthatitviolatestheEqualProtectionClauseundertheFourteenthAmendment.Thiscaseinvolvesadirectconstitutionalchallengetoracialandgenderpreferencesinfederally‐fundedstatehighwaycontracts.ThiscaseconcernedtheconstitutionalityoftheKansasDOT’simplementationoftheFederalDBEProgram,andtheconstitutionalityofthegender‐basedpoliciesofthefederalgovernmentandtherace‐andgender‐basedpoliciesoftheKansasDOT.Thecourtgrantedthefederalandstatedefendants’(USDOTandKansasDOT)MotionstoDismissbasedonlackofstanding.ThecourtheldthecontractorcouldnotshowthespecificaspectsoftheDBEProgramthatitcontendsareunconstitutionalhavecauseditsallegedinjuries.
![Page 194: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/194.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 68
5. Kornhass Construction, Inc. v. State of Oklahoma, Department of Central Services, 140 F.Supp.2d 1232 (W.D. OK. 2001)
Plaintiffs,non‐minoritycontractors,broughtthisactionagainsttheStateofOklahomachallengingminoritybidpreferenceprovisionsintheOklahomaMinorityBusinessEnterpriseAssistanceAct(“MBEAct”).TheOklahomaMBEActestablishedabidpreferenceprogrambywhichcertifiedminoritybusinessenterprisesaregivenfavorabletreatmentoncompetitivebidssubmittedtothestate.140F.Supp.2dat1235–36.UndertheMBEAct,thebidsofnon‐minoritycontractorswereraisedby5percent,placingthematacompetitivedisadvantageaccordingtothedistrictcourt.Id.at1235–1236.
Thenamedplaintiffsbidonstatecontractsinwhichtheirbidswereincreasedby5percentastheywerenon‐minoritybusinessenterprises.Althoughtheplaintiffsactuallysubmittedthelowestdollarbids,oncethe5percentfactorwasapplied,minoritybiddersbecamethesuccessfulbiddersoncertaincontracts.140F.Supp.at1237.
IndeterminingtheconstitutionalityorvalidityoftheOklahomaMBEAct,thedistrictcourtwasguidedinitsanalysisbytheTenthCircuitCourtofAppealsdecisioninAdarandConstructors,Inc.v.Slater,288F.3d1147(10thCir.2000).ThedistrictcourtpointedoutthatinAdarandVII,theTenthCircuitfoundcompellingevidenceofbarrierstobothminoritybusinessformationandexistingminoritybusinesses.Id.at1238.Insum,thedistrictcourtnotedthattheTenthCircuitconcludedthattheGovernmenthadmetitsburdenofpresentingastrongbasisinevidencesufficienttosupportitsarticulated,constitutionallyvalid,compellinginterest.140F.Supp.2dat1239,citingAdarandVII,228F.3d1147,1174.
Compelling state interest. Thedistrictcourt,followingAdarandVII,appliedthestrictscrutinyanalysis,arisingoutoftheFourteenthAmendment’sEqualProtectionClause,inwhicharace‐basedaffirmativeactionprogramwithstandsstrictscrutinyonlyifitisnarrowlytailoredtoserveacompellinggovernmentalinterest.Id.at1239.ThedistrictcourtpointedoutthatitisclearfromSupremeCourtprecedent,theremaybeacompellinginterestsufficienttojustifyrace‐consciousaffirmativeactionmeasures.Id.TheFourteenthAmendmentpermitsrace‐consciousprogramsthatseekbothtoeradicatediscriminationbythegovernmentalentityitselfandtopreventthegovernmentalentityfrombecominga“passiveparticipant”inasystemofracialexclusionpracticedbyprivatebusinesses.Id.at1240.Therefore,thedistrictcourtconcludedthatboththefederalandstategovernmentshaveacompellinginterestassuringthatpublicdollarsdonotservetofinancetheevilofprivateprejudice.Id.
Thedistrictcourtstatedthata“merestatisticaldisparityintheproportionofcontractsawardedtoaparticulargroup,standingalone,doesnotdemonstratetheevilofprivateorpublicracialprejudice.”Id.Rather,thecourtheldthatthe“benchmarkforjudgingtheadequacyofastate’sfactualpredicateforaffirmativeactionlegislationiswhetherthereexistsastrongbasisintheevidenceofthestate’sconclusionthatremedialactionwasnecessary.”Id.ThedistrictcourtfoundthattheSupremeCourtmadeitclearthatthestatebearstheburdenofdemonstratingastrongbasisinevidenceforitsconclusionthatremedialactionwasnecessarybyprovingeitherthatthestateitselfdiscriminatedinthepastorwas“apassiveparticipant”inprivateindustry’sdiscriminatorypractices.Id.at1240,citingtoAssociatedGeneralContractorsofOhio,Inc.v.
![Page 195: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/195.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 69
Drabik,214F.3d730,735(6thCir.2000)andCityofRichmondv.J.A.CrosonCompany,488U.S.469at486‐492(1989).
Withthisbackground,theStateofOklahomastatedthatitscompellingstateinterest“istopromotetheeconomyoftheStateandtoensurethatminoritybusinessenterprisesaregivenanopportunitytocompeteforstatecontracts.”Id.at1240.Thus,thedistrictcourtfoundtheStateadmittedthattheMBEAct’sbidpreference“isnotbasedonpastdiscrimination,”rather,itisbasedonadesireto“encourag[e]economicdevelopmentofminoritybusinessenterpriseswhichinturnwillbenefittheStateofOklahomaasawhole.”Id.InlightofAdarandVII,andprevailingSupremeCourtcaselaw,thedistrictcourtfoundthatthisarticulatedinterestisnot“compelling”intheabsenceofevidenceofpastorpresentracialdiscrimination.Id.
ThedistrictcourtconsideredtestimonypresentedbyIntervenorswhoparticipatedinthecaseforthedefendantsandassertedthattheOklahomalegislatureconductedaninterimstudypriortoadoptionoftheMBEAct,duringwhichtestimonyandevidencewerepresentedtomembersoftheOklahomaLegislativeBlackCaucusandotherparticipatinglegislators.Thestudywasconductedmorethan14yearspriortothecaseandtheIntervenorsdidnotactuallyofferanyoftheevidencetothecourtinthiscase.TheIntervenorssubmittedanaffidavitfromthewitnesswhoservesastheTitleVICoordinatorfortheOklahomaDepartmentofTransportation.Thecourtfoundthattheaffidavitfromthewitnessaverredingeneraltermsthatminoritybusinesseswerediscriminatedagainstintheawardingofstatecontracts.ThedistrictcourtfoundthattheIntervenorshavenotproduced—orindeedevendescribed—theevidenceofdiscrimination.Id.at1241.Thedistrictcourtfoundthatitcannotbediscernedfromthedocumentswhichminoritybusinesseswerethevictimsofdiscrimination,orwhichracialorethnicgroupsweretargetedbysuchallegeddiscrimination.Id.
ThecourtalsofoundthattheIntervenors’evidencedidnotindicatewhatdiscriminatoryactsorpracticesallegedlyoccurred,orwhentheyoccurred.Id.ThedistrictcourtstatedthattheIntervenorsdidnotidentify“asinglequalified,minority‐ownedbidderwhowasexcludedfromastatecontract.”Id.Thedistrictcourt,thus,heldthatbroadallegationsof“systematic”exclusionofminoritybusinesseswerenotsufficienttoconstituteacompellinggovernmentalinterestinremedyingpastorcurrentdiscrimination.Id.at1242.Thedistrictcourtstatedthatthiswasparticularlytrueinlightofthe“State’sadmissionherethattheState’sgovernmentalinterestwasnotinremedyingpastdiscriminationinthestatecompetitivebiddingprocess,butin‘encouragingeconomicdevelopmentofminoritybusinessenterpriseswhichinturnwillbenefittheStateofOklahomaasawhole.’”Id.at1242.
ThecourtfoundthattheStatedefendantsfailedtoproduceanyadmissibleevidenceofasingle,specificdiscriminatoryact,oranysubstantialevidenceshowingapatternofdeliberateexclusionfromstatecontractsofminority‐ownedbusinesses.Id.at1241‐1242,footnote11.
ThedistrictcourtalsonotedthattheSixthCircuitCourtofAppealsinDrabikrejectedOhio’sstatisticalevidenceofunderutilizationofminoritycontractorsbecausetheevidencedidnotreporttheactualuseofminorityfirms;rather,theyreportedonlytheuseofthoseminorityfirmsthathadgonetothetroubleofbeingcertifiedandlistedbythestate.Id.at1242,footnote12.Thedistrictcourtstatedthat,asinDrabik,theevidencepresentedinsupportoftheOklahomaMBEActfailedtoaccountforthepossibilitythatsomeminoritycontractorsmightnotregisterwith
![Page 196: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/196.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 70
thestate,andthestatisticsdidnotaccountforanycontractsawardedtobusinesseswithminorityownershipoflessthan51percent,orforcontractsperformedinlargepartbyminority‐ownedsubcontractorswheretheprimecontractorwasnotacertifiedminority‐ownedbusiness.Id.
ThedistrictcourtfoundthattheMBEAct’sminoritybiddingpreferencewasnotpredicateduponafindingofdiscriminationinanyparticularindustryorregionofthestate,ordiscriminationagainstanyparticularracialorethnicgroup.Thecourtstatedthattherewasnoevidenceofferedofactualdiscrimination,pastorpresent,againstthespecificracialandethnicgroupstowhomthepreferencewasextended,otherthananattempttoshowahistoryofdiscriminationagainstAfricanAmericans.Id.at1242.
Narrow tailoring. ThedistrictcourtfoundthateveniftheState’sgoalscouldnotbeconsidered“compelling,”theStatedidnotshowthattheMBEActwasnarrowlytailoredtoservethosegoals.ThecourtpointedoutthattheTenthCircuitinAdarandVIIidentifiedsixfactorsthecourtmustconsiderindeterminingwhethertheMBEAct’sminoritypreferenceprovisionsweresufficientlynarrowlytailoredtosatisfyequalprotection:(1)theavailabilityofrace‐neutralalternativeremedies;(2)limitsonthedurationofthechallengedpreferenceprovisions;(3)flexibilityofthepreferenceprovisions;(4)numericalproportionality;(5)theburdenonthirdparties;and(6)over‐orunder‐inclusiveness.Id.at1242‐1243.
First,intermsofrace‐neutralalternativeremedies,thecourtfoundthattheevidenceofferedshowed,atmost,thatnominaleffortsweremadetoassistminority‐ownedbusinessespriortotheadoptionoftheMBEAct’sracialpreferenceprogram.Id.at1243.ThecourtconsideredevidenceregardingtheMinorityAssistanceProgram,butfoundthattobeprimarilyinformationalservicesonly,andwasnotdesignedtoactuallyassistminoritiesorotherdisadvantagedcontractorstoobtaincontractswiththeStateofOklahoma.Id.at1243.Incontrasttothis“informational”program,thecourtnotedtheTenthCircuitinAdarandVIIfavorablyconsideredthefederalgovernment’suseofraciallyneutralalternativesaimedatdisadvantagedbusinesses,includingassistancewithobtainingprojectbonds,assistancewithsecuringcapitalfinancing,technicalassistance,andotherprogramsdesignedtoassiststart‐upbusinesses.Id.at1243citingAdarandVII,228F.3dat1178‐1179.
ThedistrictcourtfoundthatitdoesnotappearfromtheevidencethatOklahoma’sMinorityAssistanceProgramprovidedthetypeofrace‐neutralreliefrequiredbytheTenthCircuitinAdarandVII,intheSupremeCourtintheCrosondecision,nordoesitappearthattheProgramwasraciallyneutral.Id.at1243.ThecourtfoundthattheStateofOklahomadidnotshowanymeaningfulformofassistancetonewordisadvantagedbusinessespriortotheadoptionoftheMBEAct,andthus,thecourtfoundthatthestatedefendantshadnotshownthatOklahomaconsideredrace‐neutralalternativemeanstoachievethestate’sgoalpriortoadoptionoftheminoritybidpreferenceprovisions.Id.at1243.
Inafootnote,thedistrictcourtpointedoutthattheTenthCircuithasrecognizedraciallyneutralprogramsdesignedtoassistallneworfinanciallydisadvantagedbusinessesinobtaininggovernmentcontractstendtobenefitminority‐ownedbusinesses,andcanhelpalleviatetheeffectsofpastandpresent‐daydiscrimination.Id.at1243,footnote15citingAdarandVII.
![Page 197: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/197.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 71
Thecourtconsideredtheevidenceofferedofpost‐enactmenteffortsbytheStatetoincreaseminorityparticipationinStatecontracting.Thecourtfoundthatmostoftheseeffortsweredirectedtowardencouragingtheparticipationofcertifiedminoritybusinessenterprises,“andarethusnotraciallyneutral.ThisevidencefailstodemonstratethattheStateemployedrace‐neutralalternativemeasurespriortoorafteradoptingtheMinorityBusinessEnterpriseAssistanceAct.”Id.at1244.Someoftheeffortsthecourtfoundweredirectedtowardencouragingtheparticipationofcertifiedminoritybusinessenterprisesandthusnotraciallyneutral,includedmailingvendorregistrationformstominorityvendors,telephoningandmailingletterstominorityvendors,providingassistancetovendorsincompletingregistrationforms,assuringthevendorsreceivedbidinformation,preparingaminoritybusinessdirectoryanddistributingittoallstateagencies,periodicallymailingconstructionprojectinformationtominorityvendors,andprovidingcommodityinformationtominorityvendorsuponrequest.Id.at1244,footnote16.
Intermsofdurationallimitsandflexibility,thecourtfoundthatthe“goal”of10percentofthestate’scontractsbeingawardedtocertifiedminoritybusinessenterpriseshadneverbeenreached,orevenapproached,duringthethirteenyearssincetheMBEActwasimplemented.Id.at1244.Thecourtfoundthedefendantsofferednoevidencethatthebidpreferencewaslikelytoendatanytimeintheforeseeablefuture,orthatitisotherwiselimitedinitsduration.Id.UnlikethefederalprogramsatissueinAdarandVII,thecourtstatedtheOklahomaMBEActhasnoinherenttimelimit,andnoprovisionfordisadvantagedminority‐ownedbusinessesto“graduate”frompreferenceeligibility.Id.ThecourtfoundtheMBEActwasnotlimitedtothoseminority‐ownedbusinesseswhichareshowntobeeconomicallydisadvantaged.Id.
ThecourtstatedthattheMBEActmadenoattempttoaddressorremedyanyactual,demonstratedpastorpresentracialdiscrimination,andtheMBEAct’sdurationwasnottiedinanywaytotheeradicationofsuchdiscrimination.Id.Instead,thecourtfoundtheMBEActrestsonthe“questionableassumptionthat10percentofallstatecontractdollarsshouldbeawardedtocertifiedminority‐ownedandoperatedbusinesses,withoutanyshowingthatthisassumptionisreasonable.”Id.at1244.
BythetermsoftheMBEAct,theminoritypreferenceprovisionswouldcontinueinplaceforfiveyearsafterthegoalof10percentminorityparticipationwasreached,andthusthedistrictcourtconcludedthattheMBEAct’sminoritypreferenceprovisionslackedreasonabledurationallimits.Id.at1245.
Withregardtothefactorof“numericalproportionality”betweentheMBEAct’saspirationalgoalandthenumberofexistingavailableminority‐ownedbusinesses,thecourtfoundtheMBEAct’s10percentgoalwasnotbasedupondemonstrableevidenceoftheavailabilityofminoritycontractorswhowereeitherqualifiedtobidorwhowereready,willingandabletobecomequalifiedtobidonstatecontracts.Id.at1246–1247.ThecourtpointedoutthattheMBEActmadenoattempttodistinguishbetweenthefourminorityracialgroups,sothatcontractsawardedtomembersofallofthepreferredraceswereaggregatedindeterminingwhetherthe10percentaspirationalgoalhadbeenreached.Id.at1246.Inaddition,thecourtfoundtheMBEActaggregatedallstatecontractsforgoodsandservices,sothatminorityparticipationwasdeterminedbythetotalnumberofdollarsspentonstatecontracts.Id.
![Page 198: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/198.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 72
ThecourtstatedthatinAdarandVII,theTenthCircuitrejectedthecontentionthattheaspirationalgoalswererequiredtocorrespondtoanactualfindingastothenumberofexistingminority‐ownedbusinesses.Id.at1246.ThecourtnotedthatthegovernmentsubmittedevidenceinAdarandVII,thattheeffectsofpastdiscriminationhadexcludedminoritiesfromenteringtheconstructionindustry,andthatthenumberofavailableminoritysubcontractorsreflectedthatdiscrimination.Id.Inlightofthisevidence,thedistrictcourtsaidtheTenthCircuitheldthattheexistingpercentageofminority‐ownedbusinessesis“notnecessarilyanabsolutecap”onthepercentagethataremedialprogrammightlegitimatelyseektoachieve.Id.at1246,citingAdarandVII,228F.3dat1181.
UnlikeAdarandVII,thecourtfoundthattheOklahomaStatedefendantsdidnotoffer“substantialevidence”thattheminoritiesgivenpreferentialtreatmentundertheMBEActwereprevented,throughpastdiscrimination,fromenteringanyparticularindustry,orthatthenumberofavailableminoritysubcontractorsinthatindustryreflectsthatdiscrimination.140F.Supp.2dat1246.ThecourtconcludedthattheOklahomaStatedefendantsdidnotofferanyevidenceofthenumberofminority‐ownedbusinessesdoingbusinessinanyofthemanyindustriescoveredbytheMBEAct.Id.at1246–1247.
Withregardtotheimpactonthirdpartiesfactor,thecourtpointedouttheTenthCircuitinAdarandVIIstatedthemerepossibilitythatinnocentpartieswillsharetheburdenofaremedialprogramisitselfinsufficienttowarranttheconclusionthattheprogramisnotnarrowlytailored.Id.at1247.ThedistrictcourtfoundtheMBEAct’sbidpreferenceprovisionspreventednon‐minoritybusinessesfromcompetingonanequalbasiswithcertifiedminoritybusinessenterprises,andthatinsomeinstancesplaintiffshadbeenrequiredtolowertheirintendedbidsbecausetheyknewminorityfirmswerebidding.Id.Thecourtpointedoutthatthe5percentpreferenceisapplicabletoallcontractsawardedunderthestate’sCentralPurchasingActwithnotimelimitation.Id.
Intermsofthe“under‐andover‐inclusiveness”factor,thecourtobservedthattheMBEActextendeditsbiddingpreferencetoseveralracialminoritygroupswithoutregardtowhethereachofthosegroupshadsufferedfromtheeffectsofpastorpresentracialdiscrimination.Id.at1247.ThedistrictcourtreiteratedtheOklahomaStatedefendantsdidnotofferanyevidenceatallthattheminorityracialgroupsidentifiedintheActhadactuallysufferedfromdiscrimination.Id.
Second,thedistrictcourtfoundtheMBEAct’sbiddingpreferenceextendstoallcontractsforgoodsandservicesawardedundertheState’sCentralPurchasingAct,withoutregardtowhethermembersofthepreferredminoritygroupshadbeenthevictimsofpastorpresentdiscriminationwithinthatparticularindustryortrade.Id.
Third,thedistrictcourtnotedthepreferenceextendstoallbusinessescertifiedasminority‐ownedandcontrolled,withoutregardtowhetheraparticularbusinessiseconomicallyorsociallydisadvantaged,orhassufferedfromtheeffectsofpastorpresentdiscrimination.Id.Thecourtthusfoundthatthefactorofover‐inclusivenessweighsagainstafindingthattheMBEActwasnarrowlytailored.Id.
![Page 199: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/199.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 73
ThedistrictcourtinconclusionfoundthattheOklahomaMBEActviolatedtheConstitution’sFifthAmendmentguaranteeofequalprotectionandgrantedtheplaintiffs’MotionforSummaryJudgment.
E. Recent Decisions Involving State or Local Government MBE/WBE/DBE Programs in Other Jurisdictions
Recent Decisions in Federal Circuit Courts of Appeal
1. H. B. Rowe Co., Inc. v. W. Lyndo Tippett, NCDOT, et al., 615 F.3d 233 (4th Cir. 2010)
TheStateofNorthCarolinaenactedstatutorylegislationthatrequiredprimecontractorstoengageingoodfaitheffortstosatisfyparticipationgoalsforminorityandwomensubcontractorsonstate‐fundedprojects.(SeefactsasdetailedinthedecisionoftheUnitedStatesDistrictCourtfortheEasternDistrictofNorthCarolinadiscussedbelow.).Theplaintiff,aprimecontractor,broughtthisactionafterbeingdeniedacontractbecauseofitsfailuretodemonstrategoodfaitheffortstomeettheparticipationgoalssetonaparticularcontractthatitwasseekinganawardtoperformworkwiththeNorthCarolinaDepartmentofTransportation(“NCDOT”).PlaintiffassertedthattheparticipationgoalsviolatedtheEqualProtectionClauseandsoughtinjunctivereliefandmoneydamages.
Afterabenchtrial,thedistrictcourtheldthechallengedstatutoryschemeconstitutionalbothonitsfaceandasapplied,andtheplaintiffprimecontractorappealed.615F.3d233at236.TheCourtofAppealsheldthattheStatedidnotmeetitsburdenofproofinallrespectstoupholdthevalidityofthestatelegislation.But,theCourtagreedwiththedistrictcourtthattheStateproducedastrongbasisinevidencejustifyingthestatutoryschemeonitsface,andasappliedtoAfricanAmericanandNativeAmericansubcontractors,andthattheStatedemonstratedthatthelegislativeschemeisnarrowlytailoredtoserveitscompellinginterestinremedyingdiscriminationagainsttheseracialgroups.TheCourtthusaffirmedthedecisionofthedistrictcourtinpart,reverseditinpartandremandedforfurtherproceedingsconsistentwiththeopinion.Id.
TheCourtfoundthattheNorthCarolinastatutoryscheme“largelymirroredthefederalDisadvantagedBusinessEnterprise(“DBE”)program,withwhicheverystatemustcomplyinawardinghighwayconstructioncontractsthatutilizefederalfunds.”615F.3d233at236.TheCourtalsonotedthatfederalcourtsofappeal“haveuniformlyupheldtheFederalDBEProgramagainstequal‐protectionchallenges.”Id.,atfootnote1,citing,AdarandConstructors,Inc.v.Slater,228F.3d1147(10thCir.2000).
In2004,theStateretainedaconsultanttoprepareandissueathirdstudyofsubcontractorsemployedinNorthCarolina’shighwayconstructionindustry.Thestudy,accordingtotheCourt,marshaledevidencetoconcludethatdisparitiesintheutilizationofminoritysubcontractorspersisted.615F.3d233at238.TheCourtpointedoutthatinresponsetothestudy,theNorthCarolinaGeneralAssemblysubstantiallyamendedstatelegislationsection136‐28.4andthenewlawwentintoeffectin2006.Thenewstatutemodifiedthepreviousstatutoryscheme,accordingtotheCourtinfiveimportantrespects.Id.
![Page 200: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/200.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 74
First,theamendedstatuteexpresslyconditionsimplementationofanyparticipationgoalsonthefindingsofthe2004study.Second,theamendedstatuteeliminatesthe5and10percentannualgoalsthatweresetinthepredecessorstatute.615F.3d233at238‐239.Instead,asamended,thestatuterequirestheNCDOTto“establishannualaspirationalgoals,notmandatorygoals,…fortheoverallparticipationincontractsbydisadvantagedminority‐ownedandwomen‐ownedbusinesses…[that]shallnotbeappliedrigidlyonspecificcontractsorprojects.”Id.at239,quoting,N.C.Gen.Stat.§136‐28.4(b)(2010).ThestatutefurthermandatesthattheNCDOTset“contract‐specificgoalsorproject‐specificgoals…foreachdisadvantagedminority‐ownedandwomen‐ownedbusinesscategorythathasdemonstratedsignificantdisparityincontractutilization”basedonavailability,asdeterminedbythestudy.Id.
Third,theamendedstatutenarrowedthedefinitionof“minority”toencompassonlythosegroupsthathavesuffereddiscrimination.Id.at239.Theamendedstatutereplacedalistofdefinedminoritiestoanycertaingroupsbydefining“minority”as“onlythoseracialorethnicityclassificationsidentifiedby[thestudy]…thathavebeensubjectedtodiscriminationintherelevantmarketplaceandthathavebeenadverselyaffectedintheirabilitytoobtaincontractswiththeDepartment.”Id.at239quotingsection136‐28.4(c)(2)(2010).
Fourth,theamendedstatuterequiredtheNCDOTtoreevaluatetheProgramovertimeandrespondtochangingconditions.615F.3d233at239.Accordingly,theNCDOTmustconductastudysimilartothe2004studyatleasteveryfiveyears.Id.§136‐28.4(b).Finally,theamendedstatutecontainedasunsetprovisionwhichwassettoexpireonAugust31,2009,buttheGeneralAssemblysubsequentlyextendedthesunsetprovisiontoAugust31,2010.Id.Section136‐28.4(e)(2010).
TheCourtalsonotedthatthestatuterequiredonlygoodfaitheffortsbytheprimecontractorstoutilizesubcontractors,andthatthegoodfaithrequirement,theCourtfound,provedpermissiveinpractice:primecontractorssatisfiedtherequirementin98.5percentofcases,failingtodosoinonly13of878attempts.615F.3d233at239.
Strict scrutiny.TheCourtstatedthestrictscrutinystandardwasapplicabletojustifyarace‐consciousmeasure,andthatitisasubstantialburdenbutnotautomatically“fatalinfact.”615F.3d233at241.TheCourtpointedoutthat“[t]heunhappypersistenceofboththepracticeandthelingeringeffectsofracialdiscriminationagainstminoritygroupsinthiscountryisanunfortunatereality,andgovernmentisnotdisqualifiedfromactinginresponsetoit.”Id.at241quotingAlexanderv.Estepp,95F.3d312,315(4thCir.1996).Insoacting,agovernmentalentitymustdemonstrateithadacompellinginterestin“remedyingtheeffectsofpastorpresentracialdiscrimination.”Id.,quotingShawv.Hunt,517U.S.899,909(1996).
Thus,theCourtfoundthattojustifyarace‐consciousmeasure,astatemustidentifythatdiscrimination,publicorprivate,withsomespecificity,andmusthaveastrongbasisinevidenceforitsconclusionthatremedialactionisnecessary.615F.3d233at241quoting,Croson,488U.S.at504andWygantv.JacksonBoardofEducation,476U.S.267,277(1986)(pluralityopinion).
TheCourtsignificantlynotedthat:“Thereisno‘precisemathematicalformulatoassessthequantumofevidencethatrisestotheCroson‘strongbasisinevidence’benchmark.’”615F.3d233at241,quotingRotheDev.Corp.v.DepartmentofDefense,545F.3d1023,1049(Fed.Cir.
![Page 201: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/201.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 75
2008).TheCourtstatedthatthesufficiencyoftheState’sevidenceofdiscrimination“mustbeevaluatedonacase‐by‐casebasis.”Id.at241.(internalquotationmarksomitted).
TheCourtheldthatastate“neednotconclusivelyprovetheexistenceofpastorpresentracialdiscriminationtoestablishastrongbasisinevidenceforconcludingthatremedialactionisnecessary.615F.3d233at241,citingConcreteWorks,321F.3dat958.“Instead,astatemaymeetitsburdenbyrelyingon“asignificantstatisticaldisparity”betweentheavailabilityofqualified,willing,andableminoritysubcontractorsandtheutilizationofsuchsubcontractorsbythegovernmentalentityoritsprimecontractors.Id.at241,citingCroson,488U.S.at509(pluralityopinion).TheCourtstatedthatwe“furtherrequirethatsuchevidencebe‘corroboratedbysignificantanecdotalevidenceofracialdiscrimination.’”Id.at241,quotingMarylandTroopersAssociation,Inc.v.Evans,993F.2d1072,1077(4thCir.1993).
TheCourtpointedoutthatthosechallengingrace‐basedremedialmeasuresmust“introducecredible,particularizedevidencetorebut”thestate’sshowingofastrongbasisinevidenceforthenecessityforremedialaction.Id.at241‐242,citingConcreteWorks,321F.3dat959.Challengersmayofferaneutralexplanationforthestate’sevidence,presentcontrastingstatisticaldata,ordemonstratethattheevidenceisflawed,insignificant,ornotactionable.Id.at242(citationsomitted).However,theCourtstated“thatmerespeculationthatthestate’sevidenceisinsufficientormethodologicallyflaweddoesnotsufficetorebutastate’sshowing.Id.at242,citingConcreteWorks,321F.3dat991.
TheCourtheldthattosatisfystrictscrutiny,thestate’sstatutoryschememustalsobe“narrowlytailored”toservethestate’scompellinginterestinnotfinancingprivatediscriminationwithpublicfunds.615F.3d233at242,citingAlexander,95F.3dat315(citingAdarand,515U.S.at227).
Intermediate scrutiny.TheCourtheldthatcourtsapply“intermediatescrutiny”tostatutesthatclassifyonthebasisofgender.Id.at242.TheCourtfoundthatadefenderofastatutethatclassifiesonthebasisofgendermeetsthisintermediatescrutinyburden“byshowingatleastthattheclassificationservesimportantgovernmentalobjectivesandthatthediscriminatorymeansemployedaresubstantiallyrelatedtotheachievementofthoseobjectives.”Id.,quotingMississippiUniversityforWomenv.Hogan,458U.S.718,724(1982).TheCourtnotedthatintermediatescrutinyrequireslessofashowingthandoes“themostexacting”strictscrutinystandardofreview.Id.at242.TheCourtfoundthatits“sistercircuits”provideguidanceinformulatingagoverningevidentiarystandardforintermediatescrutiny.Thesecourtsagreethatsuchameasure“canrestsafelyonsomethinglessthanthe‘strongbasisinevidence’requiredtobeartheweightofarace‐orethnicity‐consciousprogram.”Id.at242,quotingEngineeringContractors,122F.3dat909(othercitationsomitted).
Indefiningwhatconstitutes“somethingless”thana‘strongbasisinevidence,’thecourts,…alsoagreethatthepartydefendingthestatutemust‘present[]sufficientprobativeevidenceinsupportofitsstatedrationaleforenactingagenderpreference,i.e.,…theevidence[mustbe]sufficienttoshowthatthepreferencerestsonevidence‐informedanalysisratherthanonstereotypicalgeneralizations.”615F.3d233at242quotingEngineeringContractors,122F.3dat910andConcreteWorks,321F.3dat959.Thegender‐basedmeasuresmustbebasedon
![Page 202: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/202.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 76
“reasonedanalysisratherthanonthemechanicalapplicationoftraditional,ofteninaccurate,assumptions.”Id.at242quotingHogan,458U.S.at726.
Plaintiff’s burden.TheCourtfoundthatwhenaplaintiffallegesthatastatuteviolatestheEqualProtectionClauseasappliedand,onitsface,theplaintiffbearsaheavyburden.Initsfacialchallenge,theCourtheldthataplaintiff“hasaveryheavyburdentocarry,andmustshowthat[astatutoryscheme]cannotoperateconstitutionallyunderanycircumstance.”Id.at243,quotingWestVirginiav.U.S.DepartmentofHealth&HumanServices,289F.3d281,292(4thCir.2002).
Statistical evidence.TheCourtexaminedtheState’sstatisticalevidenceofdiscriminationinpublic‐sectorsubcontracting,includingitsdisparityevidenceandregressionanalysis.TheCourtnotedthatthestatisticalanalysisanalyzedthedifferenceordisparitybetweentheamountofsubcontractingdollarsminority‐andwomen‐ownedbusinessesactuallywoninamarketandtheamountofsubcontractingdollarstheywouldbeexpectedtowingiventheirpresenceinthatmarket.615F.3d233at243.TheCourtfoundthatthestudygroundeditsanalysisinthe“disparityindex,”whichmeasurestheparticipationofagivenracial,ethnic,orgendergroupengagedinsubcontracting.Id.Incalculatingadisparityindex,thestudydividedthepercentageoftotalsubcontractingdollarsthataparticulargroupwonbythepercentthatgrouprepresentsintheavailablelaborpool,andmultipliedtheresultby100.Id.Theclosertheresultingindexisto100,thegreaterthatgroup’sparticipation.Id.
TheCourtheldthatafterCroson,anumberofoursistercircuitshaverecognizedtheutilityofthedisparityindexindeterminingstatisticaldisparitiesintheutilizationofminority‐andwomen‐ownedbusinesses.Id.at243‐244(Citationstomultiplefederalcircuitcourtdecisionsomitted.)TheCourtalsofoundthatgenerally“courtsconsideradisparityindexlowerthan80asanindicationofdiscrimination.”Id.at244.Accordingly,thestudyconsideredonlyadisparityindexlowerthan80aswarrantingfurtherinvestigation.Id.
TheCourtpointedoutthataftercalculatingthedisparityindexforeachrelevantracialorgendergroup,theconsultanttestedforthestatisticalsignificanceoftheresultsbyconductingstandarddeviationanalysisthroughtheuseoft‐tests.TheCourtnotedthatstandarddeviationanalysis“describestheprobabilitythatthemeasureddisparityistheresultofmerechance.”615F.3d233at244,quotingEng’gContractors,122F.3dat914.Theconsultantconsideredthefindingoftwostandarddeviationstodemonstrate“with95percentcertaintythatdisparity,asrepresentedbyeitheroverutilizationorunderutilization,isactuallypresent.”Id.,citingEng’gContractors,122F.3dat914.
ThestudyanalyzedtheparticipationofminorityandwomensubcontractorsinconstructioncontractsawardedandmanagedfromthecentralNCDOTofficeinRaleigh,NorthCarolina.615F.3d233at244.Todetermineutilizationofminorityandwomensubcontractors,theconsultantdevelopedamasterlistofcontractsmainlyfromState‐maintainedelectronicdatabasesandhardcopyfiles;thenselectedfromthatlistastatisticallyvalidsampleofcontracts,andcalculatedthepercentageofsubcontractingdollarsawardedtominority‐andwomen‐ownedbusinessesduringthe5‐yearperiodendinginJune2003.(Thestudywaspublishedin2004).Id.at244.
TheCourtfoundthattheuseofdataforcentrally‐awardedcontractswassufficientforitsanalysis.Itwasnotedthatdatafromconstructioncontractsawardedandmanagedfromthe
![Page 203: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/203.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 77
NCDOTdivisionsacrossthestateandfrompreconstructioncontracts,whichinvolveworkfromengineeringfirmsandarchitecturalfirmsonthedesignofhighways,wasincompleteandnotaccurate.615F.3d233at244,n.6.Thesedatawerenotrelieduponinformingtheopinionsrelatingtothestudy.Id.at244,n.6.
Toestimateavailability,whichtheCourtdefinedasthepercentageofaparticulargroupintherelevantmarketarea,theconsultantcreatedavendorlistcomprising:(1)subcontractorsapprovedbythedepartmenttoperformsubcontractworkonstate‐fundedprojects,(2)subcontractorsthatperformedsuchworkduringthestudyperiod,and(3)contractorsqualifiedtoperformprimeconstructionworkonstate‐fundedcontracts.615F.3d233at244.TheCourtnotedthatprimeconstructionworkonstate‐fundedcontractswasincludedbasedonthetestimonybytheconsultantthatprimecontractorsarequalifiedtoperformsubcontractingworkandoftendoperformsuchwork.Id.at245.TheCourtalsonotedthattheconsultantsubmitteditsmasterlisttotheNCDOTforverification.Id.at245.
Basedontheutilizationandavailabilityfigures,thestudypreparedthedisparityanalysiscomparingtheutilizationbasedonthepercentageofsubcontractingdollarsoverthefive‐yearperiod,determiningtheavailabilityinnumbersoffirmsandtheirpercentageofthelaborpool,adisparityindexwhichisthepercentageofutilizationindollarsdividedbythepercentageofavailabilitymultipliedby100,andaTValue.615F.3d233at245.
TheCourtconcludedthatthefiguresdemonstratedprimecontractorsunderutilizedalloftheminoritysubcontractorclassificationsonstate‐fundedconstructioncontractsduringthestudyperiod.615F.3d233245.Thedisparityindexforeachgroupwaslessthan80and,thus,theCourtfoundwarrantedfurtherinvestigation.Id.Thet‐testresults,however,demonstratedmarkedunderutilizationonlyofAfricanAmericanandNativeAmericansubcontractors.Id.ForAfricanAmericansthet‐valuefelloutsideoftwostandarddeviationsfromthemeanand,therefore,wasstatisticallysignificantata95percentconfidencelevel.Id.TheCourtfoundtherewasatleasta95percentprobabilitythatprimecontractors’underutilizationofAfricanAmericansubcontractorswasnottheresultofmerechance.Id.
ForNativeAmericansubcontractors,thet‐valueof1.41wassignificantataconfidencelevelofapproximately85percent.615F.3d233at245.Thet‐valuesforHispanicAmericanandAsianAmericansubcontractors,demonstratedsignificanceataconfidencelevelofapproximately60percent.Thedisparityindexforwomensubcontractorsfoundthattheywereoverutilizedduringthestudyperiod.Theoverutilizationwasstatisticallysignificantata95percentconfidencelevel.Id.
Tocorroboratethedisparitystudy,theconsultantconductedaregressionanalysisstudyingtheinfluenceofcertaincompanyandbusinesscharacteristics–withaparticularfocusonownerraceandgender–onafirm’sgrossrevenues.615F.3d233at246.TheconsultantobtainedthedatafromatelephonesurveyoffirmsthatconductedorattemptedtoconductbusinesswiththeNCDOT.Thesurveypoolconsistedofarandomsampleofsuchfirms.Id.
Theconsultantusedthefirms’grossrevenuesasthedependentvariableintheregressionanalysistotesttheeffectofothervariables,includingcompanyageandnumberoffull‐timeemployees,andtheowners’yearsofexperience,levelofeducation,race,ethnicity,andgender.
![Page 204: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/204.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 78
615F.3d233at246.Theanalysisrevealedthatminorityandwomenownershipuniversallyhadanegativeeffectonrevenue,andAfricanAmericanownershipofafirmhadthelargestnegativeeffectonthatfirm’sgrossrevenueofalltheindependentvariablesincludedintheregressionmodel.Id.ThesefindingsledtotheconclusionthatforAfricanAmericansthedisparityinfirmrevenuewasnotduetocapacity‐relatedormanagerialcharacteristicsalone.Id.
TheCourtrejectedtheargumentsbytheplaintiffsattackingtheavailabilityestimates.TheCourtrejectedtheplaintiff’sexpert,Dr.GeorgeLaNoue,whotestifiedthatbidderdata–reflectingthenumberofsubcontractorsthatactuallybidonDepartmentsubcontracts–estimatesavailabilitybetterthan“vendordata.”615F.3d233at246.Dr.LaNoueconceded,however,thattheStatedoesnotcompilebidderdataandthatbidderdataactuallyreflectsskewedavailabilityinthecontextofagoalsprogramthaturgesprimecontractorstosolicitbidsfromminorityandwomensubcontractors.Id.TheCourtfoundthattheplaintiff’sexpertdidnotdemonstratethatthevendordatausedinthestudywasunreliable,orthatthebidderdatawouldhaveyieldedlesssupportfortheconclusionsreached.Insum,theCourtheldthattheplaintiffschallengetotheavailabilityestimatefailedbecauseitcouldnotdemonstratethatthe2004study’savailabilityestimatewasinadequate.Id.at246.TheCourtcitedConcreteWorks,321F.3dat991forthepropositionthatachallengercannotmeetitsburdenofproofthroughconjectureandunsupportedcriticismsofthestate’sevidence,”andthattheplaintiffRowepresentednoviablealternativefordeterminingavailability.Id.at246‐247,citingConcreteWorks,321F.3d991andSherbrookeTurf,Inc.v.Minn.DepartmentofTransportation,345F.3d964,973(8thCir.2003).
TheCourtalsorejectedtheplaintiff’sargumentthatminoritysubcontractorsparticipatedonstate‐fundedprojectsatalevelconsistentwiththeiravailabilityintherelevantlaborpool,basedonthestate’sresponsethatevidenceastothenumberofminoritysubcontractorsworkingwithstate‐fundedprojectsdoesnoteffectivelyrebuttheevidenceofdiscriminationintermsofsubcontractingdollars.615F.3d233at247.TheStatepointedtoevidenceindicatingthatprimecontractorsusedminoritybusinessesforlow‐valueworkinordertocomplywiththegoals,andthatAfricanAmericanownershiphadasignificantnegativeimpactonfirmrevenueunrelatedtofirmcapacityorexperience.Id.TheCourtconcludedplaintiffdidnotofferanycontraryevidence.Id.
TheCourtfoundthattheStatebolstereditspositionbypresentingevidencethatminoritysubcontractorshavethecapacitytoperformhigher‐valuework.615F.3d233at247.Thestudyconcluded,basedonasampleofsubcontractsandreportsofannualfirmrevenue,thatexclusionofminoritysubcontractorsfromcontractsunder$500,000wasnotafunctionofcapacity.Id.at247.Further,theStateshowedthatover90percentoftheNCDOT’ssubcontractswerevaluedat$500,000orless,andthatcapacityconstraintsdonotoperatewiththesameforceonsubcontractsastheymayonprimecontractsbecausesubcontractstendtoberelativelysmall.Id.at247.TheCourtpointedoutthattheCourtinRotheII,545F.3dat1042‐45,faulteddisparityanalysesoftotalconstructiondollars,includingprimecontracts,forfailingtoaccountfortherelativecapacityoffirmsinthatcase.Id.at247.
TheCourtpointedoutthatinadditiontothestatisticalevidence,theStatealsopresentedevidencedemonstratingthatfrom1991to1993,duringtheProgram’ssuspension,primecontractorsawardedsubstantiallyfewersubcontractingdollarstominorityandwomensubcontractorsonstate‐fundedprojects.TheCourtrejectedtheplaintiff’sargumentthat
![Page 205: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/205.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 79
evidenceofadeclineinutilizationdoesnotraiseaninferenceofdiscrimination.615F.3d233at247‐248.TheCourtheldthattheverysignificantdeclineinutilizationofminorityandwomen‐subcontractors–nearly38percent–“surelyprovidesabasisforafactfindertoinferthatdiscriminationplayedsomeroleinprimecontractors’reducedutilizationofthesegroupsduringthesuspension.”Id.at248,citingAdarandv.Slater,228F.3dat1174(findingthatevidenceofdecliningminorityutilizationafteraprogramhasbeendiscontinued“stronglysupportsthegovernment’sclaimthattherearesignificantbarrierstominoritycompetitioninthepublicsubcontractingmarket,raisingthespecterofracialdiscrimination.”)TheCourtfoundsuchaninferenceisparticularlycompellingforminority‐ownedbusinessesbecause,evenduringthestudyperiod,primecontractorscontinuetounderutilizethemonstate‐fundedroadprojects.Id.at248.
Anecdotal evidence.TheStateadditionallyreliedonthreesourcesofanecdotalevidencecontainedinthestudy:atelephonesurvey,personalinterviews,andfocusgroups.TheCourtfoundtheanecdotalevidenceshowedaninformal“goodoldboy”networkofwhitecontractorsthatdiscriminatedagainstminoritysubcontractors.615F.3d233at248.TheCourtnotedthatthree‐quartersofAfricanAmericanrespondentstothetelephonesurveyagreedthataninformalnetworkofprimeandsubcontractorsexistedintheState,asdidthemajorityofotherminorities,thatmorethanhalfofAfricanAmericanrespondentsbelievedthenetworkexcludedtheircompaniesfrombiddingorawardingacontractasdidmanyoftheotherminorities.Id.at248.TheCourtfoundthatnearlyhalfofnonminoritymalerespondentscorroboratedtheexistenceofaninformalnetwork,however,only17percentofthembelievedthatthenetworkexcludedtheircompaniesfrombiddingorwinningcontracts.Id.
AnecdotalevidencealsoshowedalargemajorityofAfricanAmericanrespondentsreportedthatdoublestandardsinqualificationsandperformancemadeitmoredifficultforthemtowinbidsandcontracts,thatprimecontractorsviewminorityfirmsasbeinglesscompetentthannonminorityfirms,andthatnonminorityfirmschangetheirbidswhennotrequiredtohireminorityfirms.615F.3d233at248.Inaddition,theanecdotalevidenceshowedAfricanAmericanandNativeAmericanrespondentsbelievedthatprimecontractorssometimesdroppedminoritysubcontractorsafterwinningcontracts.Id.at248.TheCourtfoundthatinterviewandfocus‐groupresponsesechoedandunderscoredthesereports.Id.
Theanecdotalevidenceindicatedthatprimecontractorsalreadyknowwhotheywilluseonthecontractbeforetheysolicitbids:thatthe“goodoldboynetwork”affectsbusinessbecauseprimecontractorsjustpickupthephoneandcalltheirbuddies,whichexcludesothersfromthatmarketcompletely;thatprimecontractorsprefertouseotherlessqualifiedminority‐ownedfirmstoavoidsubcontractingwithAfricanAmerican‐ownedfirms;andthatprimecontractorsusetheirpreferredsubcontractorregardlessofthebidprice.615F.3d233at248‐249.Severalminoritysubcontractorsreportedthatprimecontractorsdonottreatminorityfirmsfairly,pointingtoinstancesinwhichprimecontractorssolicitedquotesthedaybeforebidsweredue,didnotrespondtobidsfromminoritysubcontractors,refusedtonegotiatepriceswiththem,orgaveminoritysubcontractorsinsufficientinformationregardingtheproject.Id.at249.
TheCourtrejectedtheplaintiffs’contentionthattheanecdotaldatawasflawedbecausethestudydidnotverifytheanecdotaldataandthattheconsultantoversampledminoritysubcontractorsincollectingthedata.TheCourtstatedthattheplaintiffsofferednorationaleas
![Page 206: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/206.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 80
towhyafactfindercouldnotrelyontheState’s“unverified”anecdotaldata,andpointedoutthatafactfindercouldverywellconcludethatanecdotalevidenceneednot‐andindeedcannot‐beverifiedbecauseit“isnothingmorethanawitness’narrativeofanincidenttoldfromthewitness’perspectiveandincludingthewitness’perceptions.”615F.3d233at249,quotingConcreteWorks,321F.3dat989.
TheCourtheldthatanecdotalevidencesimplysupplementsstatisticalevidenceofdiscrimination.Id.at249.TheCourtrejectedplaintiffs’argumentthatthestudyoversampledrepresentativesfromminoritygroups,andfoundthatsurveyingmorenon‐minoritymenwouldnothaveadvancedtheinquiry.Id.at249.Itwasnotedthatthesamplesoftheminoritygroupswererandomlyselected.Id.TheCourtfoundthestatehadcompellinganecdotalevidencethatminoritysubcontractorsfacerace‐basedobstaclestosuccessfulbidding.Id.at249.
Strong basis in evidence that the minority participation goals were necessary to remedy
discrimination.TheCourtheldthattheStatepresenteda“strongbasisinevidence”foritsconclusionthatminorityparticipationgoalswerenecessarytoremedydiscriminationagainstAfricanAmericanandNativeAmericansubcontractors.”615F.3d233at250.Therefore,theCourtheldthattheStatesatisfiedthestrictscrutinytest.TheCourtfoundthattheState’sdatademonstratedthatprimecontractorsgrosslyunderutilizedAfricanAmericanandNativeAmericansubcontractorsinpublicsectorsubcontractingduringthestudy.Id.at250.TheCourtnotedthatthesefindingshaveparticularresonancebecausesince1983,NorthCarolinahasencouragedminorityparticipationinstate‐fundedhighwayprojects,andyetAfricanAmericanandNativeAmericansubcontractorscontinuetobeunderutilizedonsuchprojects.Id.at250.
Inaddition,theCourtfoundthedisparityindexinthestudydemonstratedstatisticallysignificantunderutilizationofAfricanAmericansubcontractorsata95percentconfidencelevel,andofNativeAmericansubcontractorsataconfidencelevelofapproximately85percent.615F.3d233at250.TheCourtconcludedtheStatebolsteredthedisparityevidencewithregressionanalysisdemonstratingthatAfricanAmericanownershipcorrelatedwithasignificant,negativeimpactonfirmrevenue,anddemonstratedtherewasadramaticdeclineintheutilizationofminoritysubcontractorsduringthesuspensionoftheprograminthe1990s.Id.
Thus,theCourtheldtheState’sevidenceshowingagrossstatisticaldisparitybetweentheavailabilityofqualifiedAmericanandNativeAmericansubcontractorsandtheamountofsubcontractingdollarstheywinonpublicsectorcontractsestablishedthenecessarystatisticalfoundationforupholdingtheminorityparticipationgoalswithrespecttothesegroups.615F.3d233at250.TheCourtthenfoundthattheState’sanecdotalevidenceofdiscriminationagainstthesetwogroupssufficientlysupplementedtheState’sstatisticalshowing.Id.Thesurveyinthestudyexposedaninformal,raciallyexclusivenetworkthatsystemicallydisadvantagedminoritysubcontractors.Id.at251.TheCourtheldthattheStatecouldconcludewithgoodreasonthatsuchnetworksexertachronicandperniciousinfluenceonthemarketplacethatcallsforremedialaction.Id.TheCourtfoundtheanecdotalevidenceindicatedthatracialdiscriminationisacriticalfactorunderlyingthegrossstatisticaldisparitiespresentedinthestudy.Id.at251.Thus,theCourtheldthattheStatepresentedsubstantialstatisticalevidenceofgrossdisparity,corroboratedby“disturbing”anecdotalevidence.
![Page 207: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/207.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 81
TheCourtheldincircumstanceslikethese,theSupremeCourthasmadeitabundantlyclearastatecanremedyapubliccontractingsystemthatwithholdsopportunitiesfromminoritygroupsbecauseoftheirrace.615F.3d233at251‐252.
Narrowly tailored.TheCourtthenaddressedwhethertheNorthCarolinastatutoryschemewasnarrowlytailoredtoachievetheState’scompellinginterestinremedyingdiscriminationagainstAfricanAmericanandNativeAmericansubcontractorsinpublic‐sectorsubcontracting.Thefollowingfactorswereconsideredindeterminingwhetherthestatutoryschemewasnarrowlytailored.
Neutral measures.TheCourtheldthatnarrowlytailoringrequires“serious,goodfaithconsiderationofworkablerace‐neutralalternatives,”butastateneednot“exhaust[]…everyconceivablerace‐neutralalternative.”615F.3d233at252quotingGrutterv.Bollinger,539U.S.306,339(2003).TheCourtfoundthatthestudydetailsnumerousalternativerace‐neutralmeasuresaimedatenhancingthedevelopmentandcompetitivenessofsmallorotherwisedisadvantagedbusinessesinNorthCarolina.Id.at252.TheCourtpointedoutvariousrace‐neutralalternativesandmeasures,includingaSmallBusinessEnterpriseProgram;waivinginstitutionalbarriersofbondingandlicensingrequirementsoncertainsmallbusinesscontractsof$500,000orless;andtheDepartmentcontractsforsupportservicestoassistdisadvantagedbusinessenterpriseswithbookkeepingandaccounting,taxes,marketing,bidding,negotiation,andotheraspectsofentrepreneurialdevelopment.Id.at252.
TheCourtfoundthatplaintiffidentifiednoviablerace‐neutralalternativesthatNorthCarolinahadfailedtoconsiderandadopt.TheCourtalsofoundthattheStatehadundertakenmostoftherace‐neutralalternativesidentifiedbyUSDOTinitsregulationsgoverningtheFederalDBEProgram.615F.3d233at252,citing49CFR§26.51(b).TheCourtconcludedthattheStategaveseriousgoodfaithconsiderationtorace‐neutralalternativespriortoadoptingthestatutoryscheme.Id.
TheCourtconcludedthatdespitetheserace‐neutralefforts,thestudydemonstrateddisparitiescontinuetoexistintheutilizationofAfricanAmericanandNativeAmericansubcontractorsinstate‐fundedhighwayconstructionsubcontracting,andthatthese“persistentdisparitiesindicatethenecessityofarace‐consciousremedy.”615F.3d233at252.
Duration.TheCourtagreedwiththedistrictcourtthattheprogramwasnarrowlytailoredinthatitsetaspecificexpirationdateandrequiredanewdisparitystudyeveryfiveyears.615F.3d233at253.TheCourtfoundthattheprogram’sinherenttimelimitandprovisionsrequiringregularreevaluationensureitiscarefullydesignedtoendureonlyuntilthediscriminatoryimpacthasbeeneliminated.Id.at253,citingAdarandConstructorsv.Slater,228F.3dat1179(quotingUnitedStatesv.Paradise,480U.S.149,178(1987)).
Program’s goals related to percentage of minority subcontractors.TheCourtconcludedthattheStatehaddemonstratedthattheProgram’sparticipationgoalsarerelatedtothepercentageofminoritysubcontractorsintherelevantmarketsintheState.615F.3d233at253.TheCourtfoundthattheNCDOThadtakenconcretestepstoensurethatthesegoalsaccuratelyreflecttheavailabilityofminority‐ownedbusinessesonaproject‐by‐projectbasis.Id.
![Page 208: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/208.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 82
Flexibility.TheCourtheldthattheProgramwasflexibleandthussatisfiedthisindicatorofnarrowtailoring.615F.3d233at253.TheProgramcontemplatedawaiverofproject‐specificgoalswhenprimecontractorsmakegoodfaitheffortstomeetthosegoals,andthatthegoodfaitheffortsessentiallyrequireonlythattheprimecontractorsolicitandconsiderbidsfromminorities.Id.TheStatedoesnotrequireorexpecttheprimecontractortoacceptanybidfromanunqualifiedbidder,oranybidthatisnotthelowestbid.Id.TheCourtfoundtherewasalenientstandardandflexibilityofthe“goodfaith”requirement,andnotedtheevidenceshowedonly13of878goodfaithsubmissionsfailedtodemonstrategoodfaithefforts.Id.
Burden on non‐MWBE/DBEs.TheCourtrejectedthetwoargumentspresentedbyplaintiffthattheProgramcreatedoneroussolicitationandfollow‐uprequirements,findingthattherewasnoneedforadditionalemployeesdedicatedtothetaskofrunningthesolicitationprogramtoobtainMBE/WBEs,andthattherewasnoevidencetosupporttheclaimthatplaintiffwasrequiredtosubcontractmillionsofdollarsofworkthatitcouldperformitselfforlessmoney.615F.3d233at254.TheStateofferedevidencefromthestudythatprimecontractorsneednotsubmitsubcontractworkthattheycanself‐perform.Id.
Overinclusive.TheCourtfoundbyitsowntermsthestatutoryschemeisnotoverinclusivebecauseitlimitedrelieftoonlythoseracialorethnicityclassificationsthathavebeensubjectedtodiscriminationintherelevantmarketplaceandthathadbeenadverselyaffectedintheirabilitytoobtaincontractswiththeDepartment.615F.3d233at254.TheCourtconcludedthatintailoringtheremedythisway,thelegislaturedidnotrandomlyincluderacialgroupsthatmayneverhavesufferedfromdiscriminationintheconstructionindustry,butrather,contemplatedparticipationgoalsonlyforthosegroupsshowntohavesuffereddiscrimination.Id.
Insum,theCourtheldthatthestatutoryschemeisnarrowlytailoredtoachievetheState’scompellinginterestinremedyingdiscriminationinpublic‐sectorsubcontractingagainstAfricanAmericanandNativeAmericansubcontractors.Id.at254.
Women‐owned businesses overutilized.Thestudy’spublic‐sectordisparityanalysisdemonstratedthatwomen‐ownedbusinesseswonfarmorethantheirexpectedshareofsubcontractingdollarsduringthestudyperiod.615F.3d233at254.Inotherwords,theCourtconcludedthatprimecontractorssubstantiallyoverutilizedwomensubcontractorsonpublicroadconstructionprojects.Id.TheCourtfoundthepublic‐sectorevidencedidnotevincethe“exceedinglypersuasivejustification”theSupremeCourtrequires.Id.at255.
TheCourtnotedthattheStatereliedheavilyonprivate‐sectordatafromthestudyattemptingtodemonstratethatprimecontractorssignificantlyunderutilizedwomensubcontractorsinthegeneralconstructionindustrystatewideandintheAsheville,NorthCarolinaarea.615F.3d233at255.However,becausethestudydidnotprovideat‐testanalysisontheprivate‐sectordisparityfigurestocalculatestatisticalsignificance,theCourtcouldnotdeterminewhetherthisprivateunderutilizationwas“theresultofmerechance.”Id.at255.TheCourtfoundtroublingthe“evidentiarygap”thattherewasnoevidenceindicatingtheextenttowhichwomen‐ownedbusinessescompetingonpublic‐sectorroadprojectsviedforprivate‐sectorsubcontractsinthegeneralconstructionindustry.Id.at255.TheCourtalsofoundthattheStatedidnotpresentanyanecdotalevidenceindicatingthatwomensubcontractorssuccessfullybiddingonStatecontractsfacedprivate‐sectordiscrimination.Id.Inaddition,theCourtfoundmissingany
![Page 209: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/209.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 83
evidenceprimecontractorsthatdiscriminateagainstwomensubcontractorsintheprivatesectorneverthelesswinpublic‐sectorcontracts.Id.
TheCourtpointedoutthatitdidnotsuggestthattheproponentofagender‐consciousprogram“mustalwaystieprivatediscriminationtopublicaction.”615F.3d233at255,n.11.But,theCourtheldwhere,ashere,thereexistedsubstantialprobativeevidenceofoverutilizationintherelevantpublicsector,astatemustpresentsomethingmorethangeneralizedprivate‐sectordataunsupportedbycompellinganecdotalevidencetojustifyagender‐consciousprogram.Id.at255,n.11.
Moreover,theCourtfoundthestatefailedtoestablishtheamountofoverlapbetweengeneralconstructionandroadconstructionsubcontracting.615F.3d233at256.TheCourtsaidthatthedearthofevidenceastothecorrelationbetweenpublicroadconstructionsubcontractingandprivategeneralconstructionsubcontractingseverelylimitstheprivatedata’sprobativevalueinthiscase.Id.
Thus,theCourtheldthattheStatecouldnotovercomethestrongevidenceofoverutilizationinthepublicsectorintermsofgenderparticipationgoals,andthattheprofferedprivate‐sectordatafailedtoestablishdiscriminationintheparticularfieldinquestion.615F.3d233at256.Further,theanecdotalevidence,theCourtconcluded,indicatedthatmostwomensubcontractorsdonotexperiencediscrimination.Id.Thus,theCourtheldthattheStatefailedtopresentsufficientevidencetosupporttheProgram’scurrentinclusionofwomensubcontractorsinsettingparticipationgoals.Id.
Holding.TheCourtheldthatthestatelegislaturehadcraftedlegislationthatwithstoodtheconstitutionalscrutiny.615F.3d233at257.TheCourtconcludedthatinlightofthestatutoryscheme’sflexibilityandresponsivenesstotherealitiesofthemarketplace,andgiventheState’sstrongevidenceofdiscriminationagainAfricanAmericanandNativeAmericansubcontractorsinpublic‐sectorsubcontracting,theState’sapplicationofthestatutetothesegroupsisconstitutional.Id.at257.However,theCourtalsoheldthatbecausetheStatefailedtojustifyitsapplicationofthestatutoryschemetowomen,AsianAmerican,andHispanicAmericansubcontractors,theCourtfoundthoseapplicationswerenotconstitutional.
Therefore,theCourtaffirmedthejudgmentofthedistrictcourtwithregardtothefacialvalidityofthestatute,andwithregardtoitsapplicationtoAfricanAmericanandNativeAmericansubcontractors.615F.3d233at258.TheCourtreversedthedistrictcourt’sjudgmentinsofarasitupheldtheconstitutionalityofthestatelegislatureasappliedtowomen,AsianAmericanandHispanicAmericansubcontractors.Id.TheCourtthusremandedthecasetothedistrictcourttofashionanappropriateremedyconsistentwiththeopinion.Id.
Concurring opinions.ItshouldbepointedoutthatthereweretwoconcurringopinionsbythethreeJudgepanel:onejudgeconcurredinthejudgment,andtheotherjudgeconcurredfullyinthemajorityopinionandthejudgment.
![Page 210: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/210.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 84
2. Jana‐Rock Construction, Inc. v. New York State Dept. of Economic Development, 438 F.3d 195 (2d Cir. 2006)
ThisrecentcaseisinstructiveinconnectionwiththedeterminationofthegroupsthatmaybeincludedinaMBE/WBE‐typeprogram,andthestandardofanalysisutilizedtoevaluatealocalgovernment’snon‐inclusionofcertaingroups.Inthiscase,theSecondCircuitCourtofAppealsheldracialclassificationsthatarechallengedas“under‐inclusive”(i.e.,thosethatexcludepersonsfromaparticularracialclassification)aresubjecttoa“rationalbasis”review,notstrictscrutiny.
PlaintiffLuiere,a70percentshareholderofJana‐RockConstruction,Inc.(“JanaRock”)andthe“sonofaSpanishmotherwhoseparentswereborninSpain,”challengedtheconstitutionalityoftheStateofNewYork’sdefinitionof“Hispanic”underitslocalminority‐ownedbusinessprogram.438F.3d195,199‐200(2dCir.2006).UndertheUSDOTregulations,49CFR§26.5,“HispanicAmericans”aredefinedas“personsofMexican,PuertoRican,Cuban,Dominican,CentralorSouthAmerican,orotherSpanishorPortuguesecultureororigin,regardlessofrace.”Id.at201.Uponproperapplication,Jana‐RockwascertifiedbytheNewYorkDepartmentofTransportationasaDisadvantagedBusinessEnterprise(“DBE”)underthefederalregulations.Id.
However,unlikethefederalregulations,theStateofNewYork’slocalminority‐ownedbusinessprogramincludedinitsdefinitionofminorities“HispanicpersonsofMexican,PuertoRican,Dominican,Cuban,CentralorSouthAmericanofeitherIndianorHispanicorigin,regardlessofrace.”Thedefinitiondidnotincludeallpersonsfrom,ordescendantsofpersonsfrom,SpainorPortugal.Id.Accordingly,Jana‐RockwasdeniedMBEcertificationunderthelocalprogram;Jana‐RockfiledsuitallegingaviolationoftheEqualProtectionClause.Id.at202‐03.Theplaintiffconcededthattheoverallminority‐ownedbusinessprogramsatisfiedtherequisitestrictscrutiny,butarguedthatthedefinitionof“Hispanic”wasfatallyunder‐inclusive.Id.at205.
TheSecondCircuitfoundthatthenarrow‐tailoringprongofthestrictscrutinyanalysis“allowsNewYorktoidentifywhichgroupsitispreparedtoproveareinneedofaffirmativeactionwithoutdemonstratingthatnoothergroupsmeritconsiderationfortheprogram.”Id.at206.Thecourtfoundthatevaluatingunder‐inclusivenessasanelementofthestrictscrutinyanalysiswasatoddswiththeUnitedStatesSupremeCourtdecisioninCityofRichmondv.J.A.CrosonCo.,488U.S.469(1989)whichrequiredthataffirmativeactionprogramsbenobroaderthannecessary.Id.at207‐08.Thecourtsimilarlyrejectedtheargumentthatthestateshouldmirrorthefederaldefinitionof“Hispanic,”findingthatCongresshasmoreleewaythanthestatestomakebroaderclassificationsbecauseCongressismakingsuchclassificationsonthenationallevel.Id.at209.
Thecourtopined—withoutdeciding—thatitmaybeimpermissibleforNewYorktosimplyadoptthe“federalUSDOTdefinitionofHispanicwithoutatleastmakinganindependentassessmentofdiscriminationagainstHispanicsofSpanishOrigininNewYork.”Id.Additionally,findingthattheplaintifffailedtopointtoanydiscriminatorypurposebyNewYorkinfailingtoincludepersonsofSpanishorPortuguesedescent,thecourtdeterminedthattherationalbasisanalysiswasappropriate.Id.at213.
![Page 211: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/211.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 85
Thecourtheldthattheplaintifffailedtherationalbasistestforthreereasons:(1)becauseitwasnotirrationalnordiditdisplayanimustoexcludepersonsofSpanishandPortuguesedescentfromthedefinitionofHispanic;(2)becausethefacttheplaintiffcoulddemonstrateevidenceofdiscriminationthathepersonallyhadsuffereddidnotrenderNewYork’sdecisiontoexcludepersonsofSpanishandPortuguesedescentirrational;and(3)becausethefactNewYorkmayhavereliedonCensusdataincludingasmallpercentageofHispanicsofSpanishdescentdidnotmeanthatitwasirrationaltoconcludethatHispanicsofLatinAmericanoriginwereingreaterneedofremediallegislation.Id.at213‐14.Thus,theSecondCircuitaffirmedtheconclusionthatNewYorkhadarationalbasisforitsdefinitiontonotincludepersonsofSpanishandPortuguesedescent,andthusaffirmedthedistrictcourtdecisionupholdingtheconstitutionalityofthechallengeddefinition.
3. Rapid Test Prods., Inc. v. Durham Sch. Servs., Inc., 460 F.3d 859 (7th Cir. 2006)
InRapidTestProducts,Inc.v.DurhamSchoolServicesInc.,theSeventhCircuitCourtofAppealsheldthat42U.S.C.§1981(thefederalanti‐discriminationlaw)didnotprovidean“entitlement”indisadvantagedbusinessestoreceivecontractssubjecttosetasideprograms;rather,§1981providedaremedyforindividualswhoweresubjecttodiscrimination.
DurhamSchoolServices,Inc.(“Durham”),aprimecontractor,submittedabidforandwonacontractwithanIllinoisschooldistrict.Thecontractwassubjecttoaset‐asideprogramreservingsomeofthesubcontractsfordisadvantagedbusinessenterprises(arace‐andgender‐consciousprogram).Priortobidding,DurhamnegotiatedwithRapidTestProducts,Inc.(“RapidTest”),madeonepaymenttoRapidTestasanadvance,andincludedRapidTestinitsfinalbid.RapidTestbelievedithadreceivedthesubcontract.However,aftertheschooldistrictawardedthecontracttoDurham,DurhamgavethesubcontracttooneofRapidTest’scompetitor’s,abusinessownedbyanAsianmale.Theschooldistrictagreedtothesubstitution.RapidTestbroughtsuitagainstDurhamunder42U.S.C.§1981allegingthatDurhamdiscriminatedagainstitbecauseRapid’sownerwasablackwoman.
ThedistrictcourtgrantedsummaryjudgmentinfavorofDurhamholdingtheparties’dealinghadbeentooindefinitetocreateacontract.Onappeal,theSeventhCircuitCourtofAppealsstatedthat“§1981establishesaruleagainstdiscriminationincontractinganddoesnotcreateanyentitlementtobethebeneficiaryofacontractreservedforfirmsownedbyspecifiedracial,sexual,ethnic,orreligiousgroups.Argumentsthataparticularset‐asideprogramisalawfulremedyforpriordiscriminationmayormaynotprevailifapotentialsubcontractorclaimstohavebeenexcluded,butitistovictimsofdiscriminationratherthanfrustratedbeneficiariesthat§1981assignstherighttolitigate.”
ThecourtheldthatifraceorsexdiscriminationisthereasonwhyDurhamdidnotawardthesubcontracttoRapidTest,then§1981providesrelief.Havingfailedtoaddressthisissue,theSeventhCircuitCourtofAppealsremandedthecasetothedistrictcourttodeterminewhetherRapidTesthadevidencetobackupitsclaimthatraceandsexdiscrimination,ratherthananondiscriminatoryreasonsuchasinabilitytoperformtheservicesDurhamwanted,accountedforDurham’sdecisiontohireRapidTest’scompetitor.
![Page 212: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/212.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 86
4. Virdi v. DeKalb County School District, 135 Fed. Appx. 262, 2005 WL 138942 (11th Cir. 2005) (unpublished opinion)
Althoughitisanunpublishedopinion,Virdiv.DeKalbCountySchoolDistrictisarecentEleventhCircuitdecisionreviewingachallengetoalocalgovernmentMBE/WBE‐typeprogram,whichisinstructivetothedisparitystudy.InVirdi,theEleventhCircuitstruckdownaMBE/WBEgoalprogramthatthecourtheldcontainedracialclassifications.ThecourtbaseditsrulingprimarilyonthefailureoftheDeKalbCountySchoolDistrict(the“District”)toseriouslyconsiderandimplementarace‐neutralprogramandtotheinfinitedurationoftheprogram.
PlaintiffVirdi,anAsianAmericanarchitectofIndiandescent,filedsuitagainsttheDistrict,membersoftheDeKalbCountyBoardofEducation(bothindividuallyandintheirofficialcapacities)(the“Board”)andtheSuperintendent(bothindividuallyandinhisofficialcapacity)(collectively“defendants”)pursuantto42U.S.C.§§1981and1983andtheFourteenthAmendmentallegingthattheydiscriminatedagainsthimonthebasisofracewhenawardingarchitecturalcontracts.135Fed.Appx.262,264(11thCir.2005).Virdialsoallegedtheschooldistrict’sMinorityVendorInvolvementProgramwasfaciallyunconstitutional.Id.
Thedistrictcourtinitiallygrantedthedefendants’MotionsforSummaryJudgmentonallofVirdi’sclaimsandtheEleventhCircuitCourtofAppealsreversedinpart,vacatedinpart,andremanded.Id.Onremand,thedistrictcourtgrantedthedefendants’MotionforPartialSummaryJudgmentonthefacialchallenge,andthengrantedthedefendants’motionforajudgmentasamatteroflawontheremainingclaimsatthecloseofVirdi’scase.Id.
In1989,theBoardappointedtheTillmanCommittee(the“Committee”)tostudyparticipationoffemale‐andminority‐ownedbusinesseswiththeDistrict.Id.TheCommitteemetwithvariousDistrictdepartmentsandanumberofminoritycontractorswhoclaimedtheyhadunsuccessfullyattemptedtosolicitbusinesswiththeDistrict.Id.Basedupona“generalfeeling”thatminoritieswereunder‐represented,theCommitteeissuedtheTillmanReport(the“Report”)stating“theCommittee’simpressionthat‘[m]inoritiesha[d]notparticipatedinschoolboardpurchasesandcontractinginaratioreflectingtheminoritymake‐upofthecommunity.”Id.TheReportcontainednospecificevidenceofpastdiscriminationnoranyfactualfindingsofdiscrimination.Id.
TheReportrecommendedthattheDistrict:(1)Advertisebidsandpurchasingopportunitiesinnewspaperstargetingminorities,(2)conductperiodicseminarstoeducateminoritiesondoingbusinesswiththeDistrict,(3)notifyorganizationsrepresentingminorityfirmsregardingbiddingandpurchasingopportunities,and(4)publisha“howto”booklettobemadeavailabletoanybusinessinterestedindoingbusinesswiththeDistrict.
Id.TheReportalsorecommendedthattheDistrictadoptannual,aspirationalparticipationgoalsforwomen‐andminority‐ownedbusinesses.Id.TheReportcontainedstatementsindicatingtheselectionprocessshouldremainneutralandrecommendedthattheBoardadoptanon‐discriminationstatement.Id.
In1991,theBoardadoptedtheReportandimplementedseveraloftherecommendations,includingadvertisingintheAJC,conductingseminars,andpublishingthe“howto”booklet.Id.
![Page 213: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/213.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 87
TheBoardalsoimplementedtheMinorityVendorInvolvementProgram(the“MVP”)whichadoptedtheparticipationgoalssetforthintheReport.Id.at265.
TheBoarddelegatedtheresponsibilityofselectingarchitectstotheSuperintendent.Id.VirdisentalettertotheDistrictinOctober1991expressinginterestinobtainingarchitecturalcontracts.Id.VirdisentthelettertotheDistrictManagerandsentfollow‐upliterature;here‐contactedtheDistrictManagerin1992and1993.Id.InAugust1994,VirdisentaletterandaqualificationspackagetoaprojectmanageremployedbyHeeryInternational.Id.Inafollow‐upconversation,theprojectmanagerallegedlytoldVirdithathisfirmwasnotselectednotbaseduponhisqualifications,butbecausethe“Districtwasonlylookingfor‘black‐ownedfirms.’”Id.VirdisentalettertotheprojectmanagerrequestingconfirmationofhisstatementinwritingandtheprojectmanagerforwardedthelettertotheDistrict.Id.
AfteraseriesofmeetingswithDistrictofficials,in1997,VirdimetwiththenewlyhiredExecutiveDirector.Id.at266.UponrequestoftheExecutiveDirector,Virdire‐submittedhisqualificationsbutwasinformedthathewouldbeconsideredonlyforfutureprojects(PhaseIIISPLOSTprojects).Id.VirdithenfiledsuitbeforeanyPhaseIIISPLOSTprojectswereawarded.Id.
TheEleventhCircuitconsideredwhethertheMVPwasfaciallyunconstitutionalandwhetherthedefendantsintentionallydiscriminatedagainstVirdionthebasisofhisrace.Thecourtheldthatstrictscrutinyappliestoallracialclassificationsandisnotlimitedtomerelyset‐asidesormandatoryquotas;therefore,theMVPwassubjecttostrictscrutinybecauseitcontainedracialclassifications.Id.at267.Thecourtfirstquestionedwhethertheidentifiedgovernmentinterestwascompelling.Id.at268.However,thecourtdeclinedtoreachthatissuebecauseitfoundtherace‐basedparticipationgoalswerenotnarrowlytailoredtoachievingtheidentifiedgovernmentinterest.Id.
ThecourtheldtheMVPwasnotnarrowlytailoredfortworeasons.Id.First,becausenoevidenceexistedthattheDistrictconsideredrace‐neutralalternativesto“avoidunwittingdiscrimination.”Thecourtfoundthat“[w]hilenarrowtailoringdoesnotrequireexhaustionofeveryconceivablerace‐neutralalternative,itdoesrequireserious,goodfaithconsiderationofwhethersuchalternativescouldservethegovernmentalinterestatstake.”Id.,citingGrutterv.Bollinger,539U.S.306,339(2003),andRichmondv.J.A.CrosonCo.,488U.S.469,509‐10(1989).ThecourtfoundthatDistrictcouldhaveengagedinanynumberofequallyeffectiverace‐neutralalternatives,includingusingitsoutreachprocedureandtrackingtheparticipationandsuccessofminority‐ownedbusinessascomparedtonon‐minority‐ownedbusinesses.Id.at268,n.8.Accordingly,thecourtheldtheMVPwasnotnarrowlytailored.Id.at268.
Second,thecourtheldthattheunlimiteddurationoftheMVP’sracialgoalsnegatedafindingofnarrowtailoring.Id.“[R]aceconscious…policiesmustbelimitedintime.”Id.,citingGrutter,539U.S.at342,andWalkerv.CityofMesquite,TX,169F.3d973,982(5thCir.1999).Thecourtheldthatbecausethegovernmentinterestcouldhavebeenachievedutilizingrace‐neutralmeasures,andbecausetheracialgoalswerenottemporallylimited,theMVPcouldnotwithstandstrictscrutinyandwasunconstitutionalonitsface.Id.at268.
WithrespecttoVirdi’sclaimsofintentionaldiscrimination,thecourtheldthatalthoughtheMVPwasfaciallyunconstitutional,noevidenceexistedthattheMVPoritsunconstitutionalitycaused
![Page 214: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/214.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 88
Virditoloseacontractthathewouldhaveotherwisereceived.Id.Thus,becauseVirdifailedtoestablishacausalconnectionbetweentheunconstitutionalaspectoftheMVPandhisowninjuries,thecourtaffirmedthedistrictcourt’sgrantofjudgmentonthatissue.Id.at269.Similarly,thecourtfoundthatVirdipresentedinsufficientevidencetosustainhisclaimsagainsttheSuperintendentforintentionaldiscrimination.Id.
Thecourtreversedthedistrictcourt’sorderpertainingtothefacialconstitutionalityoftheMVP’sracialgoals,andaffirmedthedistrictcourt’sordergrantingdefendants’motionontheissueofintentionaldiscriminationagainstVirdi.Id.at270.
5. In re City of Memphis, 293 F.3d 345 (6th Cir. 2002)
Thiscaseisinstructivetothedisparitystudybasedonitsholdingthatalocalorstategovernmentmaybeprohibitedfromutilizingpost‐enactmentevidenceinsupportofaMBE/WBE‐typeprogram.293F.3dat350‐351.TheUnitedStatesCourtofAppealsfortheSixthCircuitheldthatpre‐enactmentevidencewasrequiredtojustifytheCityofMemphis’MBE/WBEProgram.Id.TheSixthCircuitheldthatagovernmentmusthavehadsufficientevidentiaryjustificationforaraciallyconsciousstatuteinadvanceofitspassage.
ThedistrictcourthadruledthattheCitycouldnotintroduceapost‐enactmentstudyasevidenceofacompellinginteresttojustifyitsMBE/WBEProgram.Id.at350‐351.TheSixthCircuitdeniedtheCity’sapplicationforaninterlocutoryappealonthedistrictcourt’sorderandrefusedtogranttheCity’srequesttoappealthisissue.Id.at350‐351.
TheCityarguedthatasubstantialgroundfordifferenceofopinionexistedinthefederalcourtsofappeal.293F.3dat350.Thecourtstatedsomecircuitspermitpost‐enactmentevidencetosupplmentpre‐enactmentevidence.Id.Thisissue,accordingtotheCourt,appearstohavebeenresolvedintheSixthCircuit.Id.TheCourtnotedtheSixthCircuitdecisioninAGCv.Drabik,214F.3d730(6thCir.2000),whichheldthatunderCrosonaStatemusthavesufficientevidentiaryjustificationforaracially‐consciousstatuteinadvanceofitsenactment,andthatgovernmentalentitiesmustidentifythatdiscriminationwithsomespecificitybeforetheymayuserace‐consciousrelief.Memphis,293F.3dat350‐351,citingDrabik,214F.3dat738.
TheCourtinMemphissaidthatalthoughDrabikdidnotdirectlyaddresstheadmissibilityofpost‐enactmentevidence,itheldagovernmentalentitymusthavepre‐enactmentevidencesufficienttojustifyaracially‐consciousstatute.293R.3dat351.ThecourtconcludedDrabikindicatestheSixthCircuitwouldnotfavorusingpost‐enactmentevidencetomakethatshowing.Id.at351.UnderDrabik,theCourtinMemphisheldtheCitymustpresentpre‐enactmentevidencetoshowacompellingstateinterest.Id.at351.
6. Builders Ass’n of Greater Chicago v. County of Cook, Chicago, 256 F.3d 642 (7th Cir. 2001)
ThiscaseisinstructivetothedisparitystudybecauseofitsanalysisoftheCookCountyMBE/WBEprogramandtheevidenceusedtosupportthatprogram.Thedecisionemphasizestheneedforanyrace‐consciousprogramtobebaseduponcredibleevidenceofdiscrimination
![Page 215: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/215.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 89
bythelocalgovernmentagainstMBE/WBEsandtobenarrowlytailoredtoremedyonlythatidentifieddiscrimination.
InBuildersAss’nofGreaterChicagov.CountyofCook,Chicago,256F.3d642(7thCir.2001)theUnitedStatesCourtofAppealsfortheSeventhCircuitheldtheCookCounty,ChicagoMBE/WBEProgramwasunconstitutional.Thecourtconcludedtherewasinsufficientevidenceofacompellinginterest.ThecourtheldtherewasnocredibleevidencethatCookCountyintheawardofconstructioncontactsdiscriminatedagainstanyofthegroups“favored”bytheProgram.ThecourtalsofoundthattheProgramwasnot“narrowlytailored”toremedythewrongsoughttoberedressed,inpartbecauseitwasover‐inclusiveinthedefinitionofminorities.ThecourtnotedthelistofminoritiesincludedgroupsthathavenotbeensubjecttodiscriminationbyCookCounty.
Thecourtconsideredasanunresolvedissuewhetheradifferent,andspecificallyamorepermissive,standardthanstrictscrutinyisapplicabletopreferentialtreatmentonthebasisofsex,ratherthanraceorethnicity.256F.3dat644.ThecourtnotedthattheUnitedStatesSupremeCourtinUnitedStatesv.Virginia(“VMI”),518U.S.515,532andn.6(1996),heldracialdiscriminationtoastricterstandardthansexdiscrimination,althoughthecourtinCookCountystatedthedifferencebetweentheapplicablestandardshasbecome“vanishinglysmall.”Id.ThecourtpointedoutthattheSupremeCourtsaidintheVMIcase,that“partieswhoseektodefendgender‐basedgovernmentactionmustdemonstratean‘exceedinglypersuasive’justificationforthataction…”and,realistically,thelawcanasknomoreofrace‐basedremedieseither.”256F.3dat644,quotinginpartVMI,518U.S.at533.ThecourtindicatedthattheEleventhCircuitCourtofAppealsintheEngineeringContractAssociationofSouthFlorida,Inc.v.MetropolitanDadeCounty,122F.3d895,910(11thCir.1997)decisioncreatedthe“paradoxthatapublicagencycanprovidestrongerremediesforsexdiscriminationthanforracediscrimination;itisdifficulttoseewhatsensethatmakes.”256F.3dat644.But,sinceCookCountydidnotargueforadifferentstandardfortheminorityandwomen’s“setasideprograms,”thewomen’sprogramthecourtdeterminedmustclearthesame“hurdles”astheminorityprogram.”256F.3dat644‐645.
Thecourtfoundthatsincetheordinancerequiresprimecontractorsonpublicprojectstoreserveasubstantialportionofthesubcontractsforminoritycontractors,whichisinapplicabletoprivateprojects,itis“tobeexpectedthattherewouldbemoresolicitingofthesecontractorsonpublicthanonprivateprojects.”Id.Therefore,thecourtdidnotfindpersuasivethattherewasdiscriminationbasedonthisdifferencealone.256F.3dat645.ThecourtpointedouttheCounty“concededthat[it]hadnospecificevidenceofpre‐enactmentdiscriminationtosupporttheordinance.”256F.3dat645quotingthedistrictcourtdecision,123F.Supp.2dat1093.Thecourtheldthata“publicagencymusthaveastrongevidentiarybasisforthinkingadiscriminatoryremedyappropriatebeforeitadoptstheremedy.”256F.3dat645(emphasisinoriginal).
Thecourtstatedthatminorityenterprisesintheconstructionindustry“tendtobesubcontractors,moreover,becauseasthedistrictcourtfoundnotclearlyerroneously,123F.Supp.2dat1115,theytendtobenewandthereforesmallandrelativelyuntested—factorsnotshowntobeattributabletodiscriminationbytheCounty.”256F.3dat645.ThecourtheldthattherewasnobasisforattributingtotheCountyanydiscriminationthatprimecontractorsmay
![Page 216: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/216.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 90
haveengagedin.Id.Thecourtnotedthat“[i]fprimecontractorsonCountyprojectswerediscriminatingagainstminoritiesandthiswasknowntotheCounty,whosefundingofthecontractsthusknowinglyperpetuatedthediscrimination,theCountymightbedeemedsufficientlycomplicit…tobeentitledtotakeremedialaction.”Id.But,thecourtfound“ofthatthereisnoevidenceeither.”Id.
ThecourtstatedthatiftheCountyhadbeencomplicitindiscriminationbyprimecontractors,itfound“puzzling”totrytoremedythatdiscriminationbyrequiringdiscriminationinfavorofminoritystockholders,asdistinctfromemployees.256F.3dat646.ThecourtheldthateveniftherecordmadeacaseforremedialactionofthegeneralsortfoundintheMWBEordinancebytheCounty,itwould“flunktheconstitutionaltest”bynotbeingcarefullydesignedtoachievetheostensibleremedialaimandnomore.256F.3dat646.ThecourtheldthatastateandlocalgovernmentthathasdiscriminatedjustagainstblacksmaynotbywayofremedydiscriminateinfavorofblacksandAsianAmericansandwomen.Id.Nor,thecourtstated,mayitdiscriminatemorethanisnecessarytocuretheeffectsoftheearlierdiscrimination.Id.“Normayitcontinuetheremedyinforceindefinitely,withnoefforttodeterminewhether,theremedialpurposeattained,continuedenforcementoftheremedywouldbeagratuitousdiscriminationagainstnonminoritypersons.”Id.Thecourt,therefore,heldthattheordinancewasnot“narrowlytailored”tothewrongthatitseekstocorrect.Id.
ThecourtthusfoundthattheCountybothfailedtoestablishthepremiseforaracialremedy,andalsothattheremedygoesfurtherthanisnecessarytoeliminatetheevilagainstwhichitisdirected.256F.3dat647.Thecourtheldthatthelistof“favoredminorities”includedgroupsthathaveneverbeensubjecttosignificantdiscriminationbyCookCounty.Id.Thecourtfounditunreasonableto“presume”discriminationagainstcertaingroupsmerelyonthebasisofhavinganancestorwhohadbeenborninaparticularcountry.Id.Therefore,thecourtheldtheordinancewasoverinclusive.
ThecourtfoundthattheCountydidnotmakeanyefforttoshowthat,wereitnotforahistoryofdiscrimination,minoritieswouldhave30percent,andwomen10percent,ofCountyconstructioncontracts.256F.3dat647.ThecourtalsorejectedthepropositionadvancedbytheCountyinthiscase—”thatacomparisonofthefractionofminoritysubcontractorsonpublicandprivateprojectsestablisheddiscriminationagainstminoritiesbyprimecontractorsonthelattertypeofproject.”256F.3dat647‐648.
7. Associated Gen. Contractors v. Drabik, 214 F.3d 730 (6th Cir. 2000), affirming Case No. C2‐98‐943, 998 WL 812241 (S.D. Ohio 1998)
ThiscaseisinstructivetothedisparitystudybasedontheanalysisappliedinfindingtheevidenceinsufficienttojustifyanMBE/WBEprogram,andtheapplicationofthenarrowlytailoredtest.TheSixthCircuitCourtofAppealsenjoinedtheenforcementofthestateMBEprogram,andinsodoingreversedstatecourtprecedentfindingtheprogramconstitutional.Thiscaseaffirmedadistrictcourtdecisionenjoiningtheawardofa“set‐aside”contractbasedontheStateofOhio’sMBEprogramwiththeawardofconstructioncontracts.
Thecourtheld,amongotherthings,thatthemereexistenceofsocietaldiscriminationwasinsufficienttosupportaracialclassification.Thecourtfoundthattheeconomicdatawere
![Page 217: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/217.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 91
insufficientandtoooutdated.ThecourtconcludedtheStatecouldnotestablishacompellinggovernmentalinterestandthatthestatutewasnotnarrowlytailored.Thecourtsaidthestatutefailedthenarrowtailoringtest,includingbecausetherewasnoevidencethattheStatehadconsideredrace‐neutralremedies.
ThiscaseinvolvesasuitbytheAssociatedGeneralContractorsofOhioandAssociatedGeneralContractorsofNorthwestOhio,representingOhiobuildingcontractorstostoptheawardofaconstructioncontractfortheToledoCorrectionalFacilitytoaminority‐ownedbusiness(“MBE”),inabiddingprocessfromwhichnon‐minority‐ownedfirmswerestatutorilyexcludedfromparticipatingunderOhio’sstateMinorityBusinessEnterpriseAct.214F.3dat733.
AGCofOhioandAGCofNorthwestOhio(Plaintiffs‐Appellees)claimedtheOhioMinorityBusinessEnterpriseAct(“MBEA”)wasunconstitutionalinviolationoftheEqualProtectionClauseoftheFourteenthAmendment.Thedistrictcourtagreed,andpermanentlyenjoinedthestatefromawardinganyconstructioncontractsundertheMBEA.Drabik,DirectoroftheOhioDepartmentofAdministrativeServicesandothersappealedthedistrictcourt’sOrder.Id.at733.TheSixthCircuitCourtofAppealsaffirmedtheOrderofthedistrictcourt,holdingunconstitutionaltheMBEAandenjoiningthestatefromawardinganyconstructioncontractsunderthatstatute.Id.
OhiopassedtheMBEAin1980.Id.at733.Thislegislation“setaside”5%,byvalue,ofallstateconstructionprojectsforbiddingbycertifiedMBEsexclusively.Id.PursuanttotheMBEA,thestatedecidedtosetaside,forMBEsonly,biddingforconstructionoftheToledoCorrectionalFacility’sAdministrationBuilding.Non‐MBEswereexcludedonracialgroundsfrombiddingonthataspectoftheprojectandrestrictedintheirparticipationassubcontractors.Id.
TheCourtnoteditruledin1983thattheMBEAwasconstitutional,seeOhioContractorsAss’nv.Keip,713F.2d167(6thCir.1983).Id.Subsequently,theUnitedStatesSupremeCourtintwolandmarkdecisionsappliedthecriteriaofstrictscrutinyunderwhichsuch“raciallypreferentialset‐asides”weretobeevaluated.Id.(seeCityofRichmondv.J.A.CrosonCo.(1989)andAdarandConstructors,Inc.v.Pena(1995),citationomitted.)TheCourtnotedthatthedecisioninKeipwasamorerelaxedtreatmentaccordedtoequalprotectionchallengestostatecontractingdisputespriortoCroson.Id.at733‐734.
Strict scrutiny.TheCourtfounditisclearagovernmenthasacompellinginterestinassuringthatpublicdollarsdonotservetofinancetheevilofprivateprejudice.Id.at734‐735,citingCroson,488U.S.at492.But,theCourtstated“statisticaldisparityintheproportionofcontractsawardedtoaparticulargroup,standingalonedoesnotdemonstratesuchanevil.”Id.at735.
TheCourtsaidthereisnoquestionthatremedyingtheeffectsofpastdiscriminationconstitutesacompellinggovernmentalinterest.Id.at735.TheCourtstatedtomakethisshowing,astatecannotrelyonmerespeculation,orlegislativepronouncements,ofpastdiscrimination,butrather,theSupremeCourthasheldthestatebearstheburdenofdemonstratingastrongbasisinevidenceforitsconclusionthatremedialactionwasnecessarybyprovingeitherthatthestateitselfdiscriminatedinthepastorwasapassiveparticipantinprivateindustry’sdiscriminatorypractices.Id.at735,quotingCroson,488U.S.at486‐92.
![Page 218: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/218.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 92
Thus,theCourtconcludedthatthelinchpinoftheCrosonanalysisisitsmandatingofstrictscrutiny,therequirementthataprogrambenarrowlytailoredtoachieveacompellinggovernmentinterest,butaboveallitsholdingthatgovernmentsmustidentifydiscriminationwithsomespecificitybeforetheymayuserace‐consciousrelief;explicitfindingsofaconstitutionalorstatutoryviolationmustbemade.Id.at735,quotingCroson,488U.S.at497.
Statistical evidence: compelling interest.TheCourtpointedoutthatproponentsof“raciallydiscriminatorysystems”suchastheMBEAhavesoughttogeneratethenecessaryevidencebyavarietyofmeans,however,sucheffortshavegenerallyfocusedon“mereunderrepresentation”byshowingalesserpercentageofcontractsawardedtoaparticulargroupthanthatgroup’spercentageinthegeneralpopulation.Id.at735.“Rawstatisticaldisparity”ofthissortispartoftheevidenceofferedbyOhiointhiscase,accordingtotheCourt.Id.at736.TheCourtstatedhowever,“suchevidenceofmerestatisticaldisparitieshasbeenfirmlyrejectedasinsufficientbytheSupremeCourt,particularlyinacontextsuchascontracting,wherespecialqualificationsaresorelevant.”Id.
TheCourtsaidthatalthoughOhio’smost“compelling”statisticalevidenceinthiscasecomparedthepercentageofcontractsawardedtominoritiestothepercentageofminority‐ownedbusinessesinOhio,whichtheCourtnotedprovidedstrongerstatisticsthanthestatisticsinCroson,itwasstillinsufficient.Id.at736.TheCourtfoundtheproblemwithOhio’sstatisticalcomparisonwasthatthepercentageofminority‐ownedbusinessesinOhio“didnottakeintoaccounthowmanyofthosebusinesseswereconstructioncompaniesofanysort,letalonehowmanywerequalified,willing,andabletoperformstateconstructioncontracts.”Id.
TheCourtheldthestatisticalevidencethattheOhiolegislaturehadbeforeitwhentheMBEAwasenactedconsistedofdatathatwasdeficient.Id.at736.TheCourtsaidthatmuchofthedatawasseverelylimitedinscope(ODOTcontracts)orwasirrelevanttothiscase(ODOTpurchasingcontracts).Id.TheCourtagainnotedthedatadidnotdistinguishminorityconstructioncontractorsfromminoritybusinessesgenerally,andtherefore“madenoattempttoidentifyminorityconstructioncontractingfirmsthatareready,willing,andabletoperformstateconstructioncontractsofanyparticularsize.”Id.TheCourtalsopointedouttheprogramwasnotnarrowlytailored,becausethestateconcededtheAGCshowedthattheStatehadnotperformedarecentstudy.Id.
TheCourtalsoconcludedthatevenstatisticalcomparisonsthatmightbeapparentlymorepertinent,suchaswiththepercentageofallfirmsqualified,insomeminimalsense,toperformtheworkinquestion,wouldalsofailtosatisfytheCourt’scriteria.Id.at736.“IfMBEscomprise10%ofthetotalnumberofcontractingfirmsinthestate,butonlyget3%ofthedollarvalueofcertaincontracts,thatdoesnotaloneshowdiscrimination,orevendisparity.Itdoesnotaccountfortherelativesizeofthefirms,eitherintermsoftheirabilitytodoparticularworkorintermsofthenumberoftaskstheyhavetheresourcestocomplete.”Id.at736.
TheCourtstatedtheonlycasesfoundtopresentthenecessary“compellinginterest”sufficienttojustifyanarrowlytailoredrace‐basedremedy,arethosethatexpose“pervasive,systematic,andobstinatediscriminatoryconduct.…”Id.at737,quotingAdarand,515U.S.at237.TheCourtsaidthatOhiohadmadenosuchshowinginthiscase.
![Page 219: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/219.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 93
Narrow tailoring.AsecondandseparatehurdlefortheMBEA,theCourtheld,isitsfailureofnarrowtailoring.TheCourtnotedtheSupremeCourtinAdarandtaughtthatacourtcalledupontoaddressthequestionofnarrowtailoringmustask,“forexample,whethertherewas‘anyconsiderationoftheuseofrace‐neutralmeanstoincreaseminoritybusinessparticipation’ingovernmentcontracting….”Id.at737,quotingCroson,488U.S.at507.TheCourtstatedanarrowly‐tailoredset‐asideprogrammustbeappropriatelylimitedsuchthatitwillnotlastlongerthanthediscriminatoryeffectsitisdesignedtoeliminateandmustbelinkedtoidentifieddiscrimination.Id.at737.TheCourtsaidthattheprogrammustalsonotsufferfrom“overinclusiveness.”Id.at737,quotingCroson,515U.S.at506.
TheCourtfoundtheMBEAsufferedfromdefectsbothofoverandunder‐inclusiveness.Id.at737.BylumpingtogetherthegroupsofBlacks,NativeAmericans,HispanicsandOrientals,theMBEAmaywellprovidepreferencewhere·therehasbeennodiscrimination,andmaynotproviderelieftogroupswherediscriminationmighthavebeenproven.Id.at737.Thus,theCourtsaid,theMBEAwassatisfiedifcontractorsofThaiorigin,whomightneverhavebeenseeninOhiountilrecently,receive10%ofstatecontracts,whileAfrican‐Americansreceivenone.Id.
Inaddition,theCourtfoundthatOhio’sownunderutilizationstatisticssufferfromafatalconceptualflaw:theydonotreporttheactualuseofminorityfirms;theyonlyreporttheuseofminorityfirmswhohavegonetothetroubleofbeingcertifiedandlistedamongthestate’s1,180MBEs.Id.at737.TheCourtsaidtherewasnoexaminationofwhethercontractsarebeingawardedtominorityfirmswhohaveneversoughtsuchpreferencetotakeadvantageofthespecialminorityprogram,forwhateverreason,andwhohavebeenawardedcontractsinopenbidding.Id.
TheCourtpointedoutthedistrictcourttooknoteoftheoutdatedcharacterofanyevidencethatmighthavebeenmarshaledinsupportoftheMBEA,andaddedthatevenifsuchdatahadbeensufficienttojustifythestatutetwentyyearsago,itwouldnotsufficetocontinuetojustifyitforever.Id.at737‐738.TheMBEA,theCourtnoted,hasremainedineffectfortwentyyearsandhasnosetexpiration.Id.at738.TheCourtreiteratedarace‐basedpreferenceprogrammustbeappropriatelylimitedsuchthatitwillnotlastlongerthanthediscriminatoryeffectsitisdesignedtoeliminate.Id.at737.
Finally,theCourtmentionedthatoneofthefactorsCrosonidentifiedasindicativeofnarrowtailoringiswhethernon‐race‐basedmeanswereconsideredasalternativestothegoal.Id.at738.TheCourtconcludedthehistoricalrecordcontainednoevidencethattheOhiolegislaturegaveanyconsiderationtothe·useofrace‐neutralmeanstoincreaseminorityparticipationinstatecontractingbeforeresortingtorace‐basedquotas.Id.at738.
Thedistrictcourthadfoundthatthesupplementationofthestate’sexistingdatawhichmightbeofferedgivenacontinuanceofthecasewouldnotsufficientlyenhancetherelevanceoftheevidencetojustifydelayinthedistrictcourt’shearing.Id.at738.TheCourtstatedthatunderCroson,thestatemusthavehadsufficientevidentiaryjustificationforaracially‐consciousstatuteinadvanceofitspassage.Id.TheCourtsaidthatCrosonrequiredgovernmentalentitiesmustidentifythatdiscriminationwithsomespecificitybeforetheymayuserace‐consciousrelief.Id.at738.
![Page 220: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/220.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 94
TheCourtalsoreferencedthedistrictcourtfindingthatthestatehadbeenlaxinmaintainingthetypeofstatisticsthatwouldbenecessarytoundergirditsaffirmativeactionprogram,andthatthepropermaintenanceofcurrentstatisticsisrelevanttotherequisitenarrowtailoringofsuchaprogram.Id.at738‐739.But,theCourtnotedthestatedoesnotknowhowmanyminority‐ownedbusinessesarenotcertifiedasMBEs,andhowmanyofthemhavebeensuccessfulinobtainingstatecontracts.Id.at739.
ThecourtwasmindfulofthefactitwasstrikingdownanentireclassofprogramsbydeclaringtheStateofOhioMBEstatuteinquestionunconstitutional,andnotedthatitsdecisionwas“notreconcilable”withtheOhioSupremeCourt’sdecisioninRitchieProduce,707N.E.2d871(Ohio1999)(upholdingtheOhioStateMBEProgram).
8. W.H. Scott Constr. Co. v. City of Jackson, Mississippi, 199 F.3d 206 (5th Cir. 1999)
Anon‐minoritygeneralcontractorbroughtthisactionagainsttheCityofJacksonandCityofficialsassertingthataCitypolicyanditsminoritybusinessenterpriseprogramforparticipationandconstructioncontractsviolatedtheEqualProtectionClauseoftheU.S.Constitution.
City of Jackson MBE Program.In1985theCityofJacksonadoptedaMBEProgram,whichinitiallyhadagoalof5percentofallcitycontracts.199F.3dat208.Id.The5percentgoalwasnotbasedonanyobjectivedata.Id.at209.Instead,itwasa“guess”thatwasadoptedbytheCity.Id.Thegoalwaslaterincreasedto15percentbecauseitwasfoundthat10percentofbusinessesinMississippiwereminority‐owned.Id.
AftertheMBEProgram’sadoption,theCity’sDepartmentofPublicWorksincludedaSpecialNoticetobiddersaspartofitsspecificationsforallCityconstructionprojects.Id.TheSpecialNoticeencouragedprimeconstructioncontractorstoincludeintheirbid15percentparticipationbysubcontractorscertifiedasDisadvantagedBusinessEnterprises(DBEs)and5percentparticipationbythosecertifiedasWBEs.Id.
TheSpecialNoticedefinedaDBEasasmallbusinessconcernthatisownedandcontrolledbysociallyandeconomicallydisadvantagedindividuals,whichhadthesamemeaningasunderSection8(d)oftheSmallBusinessActandsubcontractingregulationspromulgatedpursuanttothatAct.Id.ThecourtfoundthatSection8(d)oftheSBAstatesthatprimecontractorsaretopresumethatsociallyandeconomicallydisadvantagedindividualsincludecertainracialandethnicgroupsoranyotherindividualfoundtobedisadvantagedbytheSBA.Id.
In1991,theMississippilegislaturepassedabillthatwouldallowcitiestosetaside20percentofprocurementforminoritybusiness.Id.at209‐210.TheCityofJacksonCityCouncilvotedtoimplementtheset‐aside,contingentontheCity’sadoptionofadisparitystudy.Id.at210.TheCityconductedadisparitystudyin1994andconcludedthatthetotalunderutilizationofAfrican‐AmericanandAsian‐American‐ownedfirmswasstatisticallysignificant.Id.ThestudyrecommendedthattheCityimplementarangeofMBEgoalsfrom10‐15percent.Id.TheCity,however,wasnotsatisfiedwiththestudy,accordingtothecourt,andchosenottoadoptitsconclusions.Id.Instead,theCityretainedits15percentMBEgoalanddidnotadoptthedisparitystudy.Id.
![Page 221: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/221.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 95
W.H. Scott did not meet DBE goal.In1997theCityadvertisedfortheconstructionofaprojectandtheW.H.ScottConstructionCompany,Inc.(Scott)wasthelowestbidder.Id.Scottobtained11.5percentWBEparticipation,butitreportedthatthebidsfromDBEsubcontractorshadnotbeenlowbidsand,therefore,itsDBE‐participationpercentagewouldbeonly1percent.Id.
AlthoughScottdidnotachievetheDBEgoalandsubsequentlywouldnotconsidersuggestionsforincreasingitsminorityparticipation,theDepartmentofPublicWorksandtheMayor,aswellastheCity’sFinancialLegalDepartments,approvedScott’sbidanditwasplacedontheagendatobeapprovedbytheCityCouncil.Id.TheCityCouncilvotedagainsttheScottbidwithoutcomment.ScottallegedthatitwastoldtheCityrejecteditsbidbecauseitdidnotachievetheDBEgoal,buttheCityallegedthatitwasrejectedbecauseitexceededthebudgetfortheproject.Id.
TheCitysubsequentlycombinedtheprojectwithanotherrenovationprojectandawardedthatcombinedprojecttoadifferentconstructioncompany.Id.at210‐211.Scottmaintainedtherejectionofhisbidwasraciallymotivatedandfiledthissuit.Id.at211.
District court decision.ThedistrictcourtgrantedScott’smotionforsummaryjudgmentagreeingwithScottthattherelevantPolicyincludednotjusttheSpecialNotice,butthatitalsoincludedtheMBEProgramandPolicydocumentregardingMBEparticipation.Id.at211.ThedistrictcourtfoundthattheMBEPolicywasunconstitutionalbecauseitlackedrequisitefindingstojustifythe15%minority‐participationgoalandsurvivestrictscrutinybasedonthe1989decisionintheCityofRichmond,v.J.A.CrosonCo.Id.Thedistrictcourtstruckdownminority‐participationgoalsfortheCity’sconstructioncontractsonly.Id.at211.ThedistrictcourtfoundthatScott’sbidwasrejectedbecauseScottlackedsufficientminorityparticipation,notbecauseitexceededtheCity’sbudget.Id.Inaddition,thedistrictcourtawardedScottlostprofits.Id.
Standing. TheFifthCircuitdeterminedthatinequalprotectioncaseschallengingaffirmativeactionpolicies,“injuryinfact”forpurposesofestablishingstandingisdefinedastheinabilitytocompeteonanequalfootinginthebiddingprocess.Id.at213.ThecourtstatedthatScottneednotprovethatitlostcontractsbecauseofthePolicy,butonlyprovethattheSpecialNoticeforcesittocompeteonanunequalbasis.Id.Thequestion,therefore,thecourtsaidiswhethertheSpecialNoticeimposesanobligationthatisbornunequallybyDBEcontractorsandnon‐DBEcontractors.Id.at213.
Thecourtfoundthatifanon‐DBEcontractorisunabletoprocure15percentDBEparticipation,itmuststillsatisfytheCitythatadequategoodfaitheffortshavebeenmadetomeetthecontractgoalorriskterminationofitscontracts,andthatsucheffortsincludeengaginginadvertising,directsolicitationandfollow‐up,assistanceinattainingbondingorinsurancerequiredbythecontractor.Id.at214.ThecourtconcludedthatalthoughthelanguagedoesnotexpresslyauthorizeaDBEcontractortosatisfyDBE‐participationgoalsbykeepingtherequisitepercentageofworkforitself,itwouldbenonsensicaltointerpretitasprecludingaDBEcontractorfromdoingso.Id.at215.
IfaDBEcontractorperformed15percentofthecontractdollaramount,accordingtothecourt,itcouldsatisfytheparticipationgoalandavoidbothalossofprofitstosubcontractorsandthetimeandexpenseofcomplyingwiththegoodfaithrequirements.Id.at215.Thecourtsaidthat
![Page 222: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/222.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 96
non‐DBEcontractorsdonothavethisoption,andthus,Scottandothernon‐DBEcontractorsareatacompetitivedisadvantagewithDBEcontractors.Id.
Thecourt,therefore,foundScotthadsatisfiedstandingtobringthelawsuit.
Constitutional strict scrutiny analysis and guidance in determining types of evidence to justify
a remedial MBE program.ThecourtfirstrejectedtheCity’scontentionthattheSpecialNoticeshouldnotbesubjecttostrictscrutinybecauseitestablishesgoalsratherthanmandatequotasforDBEparticipation.Id.at215‐217.Thecourtstatedthedistinctionbetweengoalsorquotasisimmaterialbecausethesetechniquesinduceanemployertohirewithaneyetowardmeetinganumericaltarget,andassuch,theywillresultinindividualsbeinggrantedapreferencebecauseoftheirrace.Id.at215.ThecourtalsorejectedtheCity’sargumentthattheDBEclassificationcreatedapreferencebasedon“disadvantage,”notrace.Id.at215‐216.ThecourtfoundthattheSpecialNoticereliedonSection8(d)andSection8(a)oftheSmallBusinessAct,whichprovideexplicitlyforarace‐basedpresumptionofsocialdisadvantage,andthusrequiresstrictscrutiny.Id.at216‐217.
ThecourtdiscussedtheCityofRichmondv.CrosoncaseasprovidingguidanceindeterminingwhattypesofevidencewouldjustifytheenactmentofanMBE‐typeprogram.Id.at217‐218.ThecourtnotedtheSupremeCourtstressedthatagovernmentalentitymustestablishafactualpredicate,tyingitsset‐asidepercentagetoidentifiedinjuriesintheparticularlocalindustry.Id.at217.ThecourtpointedoutgiventheSupremeCourtinCroson’semphasisonstatisticalevidence,othercourtsconsideringequalprotectionchallengestominority‐participationprogramshavelookedtodisparityindices,ortocomputationsofdisparitypercentages,indeterminingwhetherCroson’sevidentiaryburdenissatisfied.Id.at218.Thecourtfoundthatdisparitystudiesareprobativeevidencefordiscriminationbecausetheyensurethatthe“relevantstatisticalpool,”ofqualifiedminoritycontractorsisbeingconsidered.Id.at218.
ThecourtinafootnotestatedthatitdidnotattempttocraftaprecisemathematicalformulatoassessthequantumofevidencethatrisestotheCroson“strongbasisinevidence”benchmark.Id.at218,n.11.Thesufficiencyofamunicipality’sfindingsofdiscriminationinalocalindustrymustbeevaluatedonacase‐by‐casebasis.Id.
TheCityarguedthatitwaserrorforthedistrictcourttoignoreitsstatisticalevidencesupportingtheuseofracialpresumptionsinitsDBE‐participationgoals,andhighlightedthedisparitystudyitcommissionedinresponsetoCroson.Id.at218.Thecourtstated,however,thatwhateverprobitythestudy’sfindingsmighthavehadontheanalysisisirrelevanttothecase,becausetheCityrefusedtoadoptthestudywhenitwasissuedin1995.Id.Inaddition,thecourtsaidthestudywasrestrictedtothelettingofprimecontractsbytheCityundertheCity’sProgram,anddidnotincludeananalysisoftheavailabilityandutilizationofqualifiedminoritysubcontractors,therelevantstatisticalpool,intheCity’sconstructionprojects.Id.at218.
ThecourtnotedthathadtheCityadoptedparticularizedfindingsofdiscriminationwithinitsvariousagencies,andsetparticipationgoalsforeachaccordingly,theoutcomeofthedecisionmighthavebeendifferent.Id.at219.AbsentsuchevidenceintheCity’sconstructionindustry,however,thecourtconcludedtheCitylackedthefactualpredicatesrequiredundertheEqualProtectionClausetosupporttheCity’s15%DBE‐participationgoal.Id.Thus,thecourtheldthe
![Page 223: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/223.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 97
CityfailedtoestablishacompellinginterestjustifyingtheMBEprogramortheSpecialNotice,andbecausetheCityfailedastrictscrutinyanalysisonthisground,thecourtdeclinedtoaddresswhethertheprogramwasnarrowlytailored.
Lost profits and damages.ScottsoughtdamagesfromtheCityunder42U.S.C.§1983,includinglostprofits.Id.at219.Thecourt,affirmingthedistrictcourt,concludedthatinlightoftheentirerecordtheCityCouncilrejectedScott’slowbidbecauseScottfailedtomeettheSpecialNotice’sDBE‐participationgoal,notbecauseScott’sbidexceededtheCity’sbudget.Id.at220.Thecourt,therefore,affirmedtheawardoflostprofitstoScott.
9. Monterey Mechanical v. Wilson, 125 F.3d 702 (9th Cir. 1997)
ThiscaseisinstructiveinthattheNinthCircuitanalyzedandheldinvalidtheenforcementofaMBE/WBE‐typeprogram.Althoughtheprogramatissueutilizedtheterm“goals”asopposedto“quotas,”theNinthCircuitrejectedsuchadistinction,holding“[t]herelevantquestionisnotwhetherastatuterequirestheuseofsuchmeasures,butwhetheritauthorizesorencouragesthem.”Thecasealsoisinstructivebecauseitfoundtheuseof“goals”andtheapplicationof“goodfaithefforts”inconnectionwithachievinggoalstotriggerstrictscrutiny.
MontereyMechanicalCo.(the“plaintiff”)submittedthelowbidforaconstructionprojectfortheCaliforniaPolytechnicStateUniversity(the“University”).125F.3d702,704(9thCir.1994).TheUniversityrejectedtheplaintiff’sbidbecausetheplaintifffailedtocomplywithastatestatuterequiringprimecontractorsonsuchconstructionprojectstosubcontract23percentoftheworktoMBE/WBEsor,alternatively,demonstrategoodfaithoutreachefforts.Id.Theplaintiffconductedgoodfaithoutreacheffortsbutfailedtoprovidetherequisitedocumentation;theawardeeprimecontractordidnotsubcontractanyportionoftheworktoMBE/WBEsbutdidincludedocumentationofgoodfaithoutreachefforts.Id.
Importantly,theUniversitydidnotconductadisparitystudy,andinsteadarguedthatbecause“the‘goalrequirements’ofthescheme‘[did]notinvolveracialorgenderquotas,set‐asidesorpreferences,’”theUniversitydidnotneedadisparitystudy.Id.at705.TheplaintiffprotestedthecontractawardandsuedtheUniversity’strustees,andanumberofotherindividuals(collectivelythe“defendants”)allegingthestatelawwasviolativeoftheEqualProtectionClause.Id.Thedistrictcourtdeniedtheplaintiff’smotionforaninterlocutoryinjunctionandtheplaintiffappealedtotheNinthCircuitCourtofAppeals.Id.
Thedefendantsfirstarguedthatthestatutewasconstitutionalbecauseittreatedallgeneralcontractorsalike,byrequiringalltocomplywiththeMBE/WBEparticipationgoals.Id.at708.Thecourtheld,however,thataminorityorwomenbusinessenterprisecouldsatisfytheparticipationgoalsbyallocatingtherequisitepercentageofworktoitself.Id.at709.Thecourtheldthatcontrarytothedistrictcourt’sfinding,suchadifferencewasnotdeminimis.Id.
Thedefendantsalsoarguedthatthestatutewasnotsubjecttostrictscrutinybecausethestatutedidnotimposerigidquotas,butratheronlyrequiredgoodfaithoutreachefforts.Id.at710.Thecourtrejectedtheargumentfindingthatalthoughthestatutepermittedawardstobidderswhodidnotmeetthepercentagegoals,“theyarerigidinrequiringpreciselydescribedandmonitoredeffortstoattainthosegoals.”Id.Thecourtciteditsownearlierprecedenttoholdthat
![Page 224: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/224.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 98
“theprovisionsarenotimmunizedfromscrutinybecausetheypurporttoestablishgoalsratherthanquotas…[T]herelevantquestionisnotwhetherastatuterequirestheuseofsuchmeasures,butwhetheritauthorizesorencouragesthem.”Id.at710‐11(internalcitationsandquotationsomitted).ThecourtfoundthatthestatuteencouragedsetasidesandcitedConcreteWorksofColoradov.Denver,36F.3d1512(10thCir.1994),asanalogoussupportfortheproposition.Id.at711.
Thecourtfoundthatthestatutetreatedcontractorsdifferentlybasedupontheirrace,ethnicityandgender,andalthough“wordedintermsofgoalsandgoodfaith,thestatuteimposesmandatoryrequirementswithconcreteness.”Id.Thecourtalsonotedthatthestatutemayimposeadditionalcomplianceexpensesuponnon‐MBE/WBEfirmswhoarerequiredtomakegoodfaithoutreachefforts(e.g.,advertising)toMBE/WBEfirms.Id.at712.
Thecourtthenconductedstrictscrutiny(race),andanintermediatescrutiny(gender)analyses.Id.at712‐13.ThecourtfoundtheUniversitypresented“noevidence”tojustifytherace‐andgender‐basedclassificationsandthusdidnotconsideradditionalissuesofproof.Id.at713.Thecourtfoundthatthestatutewasnotnarrowlytailoredbecausethedefinitionof“minority”wasoverbroad(e.g.,inclusionofAleuts).Id.at714,citingWygantv.JacksonBoardofEducation,476U.S.267,284,n.13(1986)andCityofRichmondv.J.A.Croson,Co.,488U.S.469,505‐06(1989).Thecourtfound“[a]broadprogramthatsweepsinallminoritieswitharemedythatisinnowayrelatedtopastharmscannotsurviveconstitutionalscrutiny.”Id.at714,citingHopwoodv.StateofTexas,78F.3d932,951(5thCir.1996).ThecourtheldthatthestatuteviolatedtheEqualProtectionClause.
10. Eng’g Contractors Ass’n of S. Florida v. Metro. Dade County, 122 F.3d 895 (11th Cir. 1997)
EngineeringContractorsAssociationofSouthFloridav.MetropolitanEngineeringContractorsAssociationisaparamountcaseintheEleventhCircuitandisinstructivetothedisparitystudy.ThisdecisionhasbeencitedandappliedbythecourtsinvariouscircuitsthathaveaddressedMBE/WBE‐typeprogramsorlegislationinvolvinglocalgovernmentcontractingandprocurement.
InEngineeringContractorsAssociation,sixtradeorganizations(the“plaintiffs”)filedsuitinthedistrictcourtfortheSouthernDistrictofFlorida,challengingthreeaffirmativeactionprogramsadministeredbyEngineeringContractorsAssociation,Florida,(the“County”)asviolativeoftheEqualProtectionClause.122F.3d895,900(11thCir.1997).ThethreeaffirmativeactionprogramschallengedweretheBlackBusinessEnterpriseprogram(“BBE”),theHispanicBusinessEnterpriseprogram(“HBE”),andtheWomanBusinessEnterpriseprogram,(“WBE”),(collectively“MWBE”programs).Id.TheplaintiffschallengedtheapplicationoftheprogramtoCountyconstructioncontracts.Id.
Forcertainclassesofconstructioncontractsvaluedover$25,000,theCountysetparticipationgoalsof15percentforBBEs,19percentforHBEs,and11percentforWBEs.Id.at901.TheCountyestablishedfive“contractmeasures”toreachtheparticipationgoals:(1)setasides,(2)subcontractorgoals,(3)projectgoals,(4)bidpreferences,and(5)selectionfactors.Onceacontractwasidentifiedascoveredbyaparticipationgoal,areviewcommitteewoulddetermine
![Page 225: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/225.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 99
whetheracontractmeasureshouldbeutilized.Id.TheCountyCommissionwouldmakethefinaldeterminationanditsdecisionwasappealabletotheCountyManager.Id.TheCountyreviewedtheefficacyoftheMWBEprogramsannually,andreevaluatedthecontinuingviabilityoftheMWBEprogramseveryfiveyears.Id.
Inabenchtrial,thedistrictcourtappliedstrictscrutinytotheBBEandHBEprogramsandheldthattheCountylackedtherequisite“strongbasisinevidence”tosupporttherace‐andethnicity‐consciousmeasures.Id.at902.ThedistrictcourtappliedintermediatescrutinytotheWBEprogramandfoundthatthe“Countyhadpresentedinsufficientprobativeevidencetosupportitsstatedrationaleforimplementingagenderpreference.”Id.Therefore,theCountyhadfailedtodemonstratea“compellinginterest”necessarytosupporttheBBEandHBEprograms,andfailedtodemonstratean“importantinterest”necessarytosupporttheWBEprogram.Id.ThedistrictcourtassumedtheexistenceofasufficientevidentiarybasistosupporttheexistenceoftheMWBEprogramsbutheldtheBBEandHBEprogramswerenotnarrowlytailoredtotheintereststheypurportedtoserve;thedistrictcourtheldtheWBEprogramwasnotsubstantiallyrelatedtoanimportantgovernmentinterest.Id.ThedistrictcourtenteredafinaljudgmentenjoiningtheCountyfromcontinuingtooperatetheMWBEprogramsandtheCountyappealed.TheEleventhCircuitCourtofAppealsaffirmed.Id.at900,903.
Onappeal,theEleventhCircuitconsideredfourmajorissues:
1. Whethertheplaintiffshadstanding.[TheEleventhCircuitansweredthisintheaffirmativeandthatportionoftheopinionisomittedfromthissummary];
2. WhetherthedistrictcourterredinfindingtheCountylackeda“strongbasisinevidence”tojustifytheexistenceoftheBBEandHBEprograms;
3. WhetherthedistrictcourterredinfindingtheCountylackeda“sufficientprobativebasisinevidence”tojustifytheexistenceoftheWBEprogram;and
4. WhethertheMWBEprogramswerenarrowlytailoredtotheintereststheywerepurportedtoserve.
Id.at903.
TheEleventhCircuitheldthattheBBEandHBEprogramsweresubjecttothestrictscrutinystandardenunciatedbytheU.S.SupremeCourtinCityofRichmondv.J.A.CrosonCo.,488U.S.469(1989).Id.at906.Underthisstandard,“anaffirmativeactionprogrammustbebasedupona‘compellinggovernmentinterest’andmustbe‘narrowlytailored’toachievethatinterest.”Id.TheEleventhCircuitfurthernoted:
“Inpractice,theinterestthatisallegedinsupportofracialpreferencesisalmostalways the same—remedyingpast orpresentdiscrimination.That interest iswidelyacceptedascompelling.Asaresult,thetruetestofanaffirmativeactionprogram isusuallynot thenatureof the government’s interest, but rather theadequacyoftheevidenceofdiscriminationofferedtoshowthatinterest.”
Id.(internalcitationsomitted).
![Page 226: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/226.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 100
Therefore,strictscrutinyrequiresafindingofa“‘strongbasisinevidence’tosupporttheconclusionthatremedialactionisnecessary.”Id.,citingCroson,488U.S.at500).Therequisite“‘strongbasisinevidence’cannotreston‘anamorphousclaimofsocietaldiscrimination,onsimplelegislativeassurancesofgoodintention,oroncongressionalfindingsofdiscriminationinthenationaleconomy.’”Id.at907,citingEnsleyBranch,NAACPv.Seibels,31F.3d1548,1565(11thCir.1994)(citingandapplyingCroson)).However,theEleventhCircuitfoundthatagovernmentalentitycan“justifyaffirmativeactionbydemonstrating‘grossstatisticaldisparities’betweentheproportionofminoritieshired…andtheproportionofminoritieswillingandabletodothework…Anecdotalevidencemayalsobeusedtodocumentdiscrimination,especiallyifbuttressedbyrelevantstatisticalevidence.”Id.(internalcitationsomitted).
Notwithstandingthe“exceedinglypersuasivejustification”languageutilizedbytheSupremeCourtinUnitedStatesv.Virginia,116S.Ct.2264(1996)(evaluatinggender‐basedgovernmentaction),theEleventhCircuitheldthattheWBEprogramwassubjecttotraditionalintermediatescrutiny.Id.at908.Underthisstandard,thegovernmentmustprovide“sufficientprobativeevidence”ofdiscrimination,whichisalesserstandardthanthe“strongbasisinevidence”understrictscrutiny.Id.at910.
TheCountyprovidedtwotypesofevidenceinsupportoftheMWBEprograms:(1)statisticalevidence,and(2)non‐statistical“anecdotal”evidence.Id.at911.Asaninitialmatter,theEleventhCircuitfoundthatinsupportoftheBBEprogram,theCountypermissiblyreliedonsubstantially“post‐enactment”evidence(i.e.,evidencebasedondatarelatedtoyearsfollowingtheinitialenactmentoftheBBEprogram).Id.However,“suchevidencecarrieswithitthehazardthattheprogramatissuemayitselfbemaskingdiscriminationthatmightotherwisebeoccurringintherelevantmarket.”Id.at912.Adistrictcourtshouldnot“speculateaboutwhatthedatamighthaveshownhadtheBBEprogramneverbeenenacted.”Id.
The statistical evidence.TheCountypresentedfivebasiccategoriesofstatisticalevidence:(1)Countycontractingstatistics;(2)Countysubcontractingstatistics;(3)marketplacedatastatistics;(4)TheWainwrightStudy;and(5)TheBrimmerStudy.Id.Insummary,theEleventhCircuitheldthattheCounty’sstatisticalevidence(describedmorefullybelow)wassubjecttomorethanoneinterpretation.Id.at924.Thedistrictcourtfoundthattheevidencewas“insufficienttoformtherequisitestrongbasisinevidenceforimplementingaracialorethnicpreference,andthatitwasinsufficientlyprobativetosupporttheCounty’sstatedrationaleforimposingagenderpreference.”Id.Thedistrictcourt’sviewoftheevidencewasapermissibleone.Id.
County contracting statistics.TheCountypresentedastudycomparingthreefactorsforCountynon‐procurementconstructioncontractsovertwotimeperiods(1981‐1991and1993):(1)thepercentageofbiddersthatwereMWBEfirms;(2)thepercentageofawardeesthatwereMWBEfirms;and(3)theproportionofCountycontractdollarsthathadbeenawardedtoMWBEfirms.Id.at912.
TheEleventhCircuitfoundthatnotably,fortheBBEandHBEstatistics,generallytherewereno“consistentlynegativedisparitiesbetweenthebidderandawardeepercentages.Infact,by1993,theBBEandHBEbiddersarebeingawardedmorethantheirproportionate‘share’…whenthe
![Page 227: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/227.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 101
bidderpercentagesareusedasthebaseline.”Id.at913.FortheWBEstatistics,thebidder/awardeestatisticswere“decidedlymixed”asacrosstherangeofCountyconstructioncontracts.Id.
TheCountythenrefinedthosestatisticsbyaddinginthetotalpercentageofannualCountyconstructiondollarsawardedtoMBE/WBEs,bycalculating“disparityindices”foreachprogramandclassificationofconstructioncontract.TheEleventhCircuitexplained:
“[A]disparity index compares theamountof contract awardsa groupactuallygot to the amount we would have expected it to get based on that group’sbidding activity and awardee success rate.More specifically, a disparity indexmeasurestheparticipationofagroupinCountycontractingdollarsbydividingthat group’s contract dollar percentage by the related bidder or awardeepercentage,andmultiplyingthatnumberby100percent.”
Id.at914.“Theutilityofdisparityindicesorsimilarmeasures…hasbeenrecognizedbyanumberoffederalcircuitcourts.”Id.
TheEleventhCircuitfoundthat“[i]ngeneral…disparityindicesof80percentorgreater,whichareclosetofullparticipation,arenotconsideredindicationsofdiscrimination.”Id.TheEleventhCircuitnotedthat“theEEOC’sdisparateimpactguidelinesusethe80percenttestastheboundarylinefordeterminingaprimafaciecaseofdiscrimination.”Id.,citing29CFR§1607.4D.Inaddition,nocircuitthathas“explicitlyendorsedtheuseofdisparityindices[has]indicatedthatanindexof80percentorgreatermightbeprobativeofdiscrimination.”Id.,citingConcreteWorksv.City&CountyofDenver,36F.3d1513,1524(10thCir.1994)(creditingdisparityindicesrangingfrom0%to3.8%);ContractorsAss’nv.CityofPhiladelphia,6F.3d990(3dCir.1993)(creditingdisparityindexof4%).
Aftercalculationofthedisparityindices,theCountyappliedastandarddeviationanalysistotestthestatisticalsignificanceoftheresults.Id.at914.“Thestandarddeviationfiguredescribestheprobabilitythatthemeasureddisparityistheresultofmerechance.”Id.TheEleventhCircuithadpreviouslyrecognized“[s]ocialscientistsconsiderafindingoftwostandarddeviationssignificant,meaningthereisaboutonechancein20thattheexplanationforthedeviationcouldberandomandthedeviationmustbeaccountedforbysomefactorotherthanchance.”Id.
ThestatisticspresentedbytheCountyindicated“statisticallysignificantunderutilizationofBBEsinCountyconstructioncontracting.”Id.at916.Theresultswere“lessdramatic”forHBEsandmixedasbetweenfavorableandunfavorableforWBEs.Id.
TheEleventhCircuitthenexplainedtheburdenofproof:
“[O]nce the proponent of affirmative action introduces its statistical proof asevidenceofitsremedialpurpose,therebysupplyingthe[district]courtwiththemeans for determining that [it] had a firm basis for concluding that remedialactionwasappropriate, it is incumbentuponthe[plaintiff]toprovetheircase;theycontinuetobeartheultimateburdenofpersuadingthe[district]courtthatthe[defendant’s]evidencedidnotsupportaninferenceofpriordiscrimination
![Page 228: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/228.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 102
and thus a remedial purpose, or that the plan instituted on the basis of thisevidencewasnotsufficiently‘narrowlytailored.”
Id.(internalcitationsomitted).
TheEleventhCircuitnotedthataplaintiffhasatleastthreemethodstorebuttheinferenceofdiscriminationwitha“neutralexplanation”by:“(1)showingthatthestatisticsareflawed;(2)demonstratingthatthedisparitiesshownbythestatisticsarenotsignificantoractionable;or(3)presentingcontrastingstatisticaldata.”Id.(internalquotationsandcitationsomitted).TheEleventhCircuitheldthattheplaintiffsproduced“sufficientevidencetoestablishaneutralexplanationforthedisparities.”Id.
Theplaintiffsallegedthatthedisparitieswere“betterexplainedbyfirmsizethanbydiscrimination…[because]minorityandfemale‐ownedfirmstendtobesmaller,andthatitstandstoreasonsmallerfirmswillwinsmallercontracts.”Id.at916‐17.TheplaintiffsproducedCensusdataindicating,onaverage,minority‐andfemale‐ownedconstructionfirmsinEngineeringContractorsAssociationweresmallerthannon‐MBE/WBEfirms.Id.at917.TheEleventhCircuitfoundthattheplaintiff’sexplanationofthedisparitieswasa“plausibleone,inlightoftheuncontrovertedevidencethatMBE/WBEconstructionfirmstendtobesubstantiallysmallerthannon‐MBE/WBEfirms.”Id.
Additionally,theEleventhCircuitnotedthattheCounty’sownexpertadmittedthat“firmsizeplaysasignificantroleindeterminingwhichfirmswincontracts.”Id.Theexpertstated:
Thesizeofthefirmhasgottobeamajordeterminantbecauseofcoursesomefirmsaregoingtobelarger,aregoingtobebetterprepared,aregoingtobeinagreaternaturalcapacitytobeabletoworkonsomeofthecontractswhileotherssimplybyvirtueoftheirsmallsizesimplywouldnotbeabletodoit.Id.
TheEleventhCircuitthensummarized:
Because they are bigger, bigger firms have a bigger chance to win biggercontracts. It follows that, all other factors being equal and in a perfectlynondiscriminatory market, one would expect the bigger (on average) non‐MWBEfirmstogetadisproportionatelyhigherpercentageoftotalconstructiondollarsawardedthanthesmallerMWBEfirms.Id.
Inanticipationofsuchanargument,theCountyconductedaregressionanalysistocontrolforfirmsize.Id.Aregressionanalysisis“astatisticalprocedurefordeterminingtherelationshipbetweenadependentandindependentvariable,e.g.,thedollarvalueofacontractawardandfirmsize.”Id.(internalcitationsomitted).Thepurposeoftheregressionanalysisis“todeterminewhethertherelationshipbetweenthetwovariablesisstatisticallymeaningful.”Id.
TheCounty’sregressionanalysissoughttoidentifydisparitiesthatcouldnotbeexplainedbyfirmsize,andtheoreticallyinsteadbasedonanotherfactor,suchasdiscrimination.Id.TheCountyconductedtworegressionanalysesusingtwodifferentproxiesforfirmsize:(1)totalawardedvalueofallcontractsbidon;and(2)largestsinglecontractawarded.Id.Theregression
![Page 229: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/229.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 103
analysesaccountedformostofthenegativedisparitiesregardingMBE/WBEparticipationinCountyconstructioncontracts(i.e.,mostoftheunfavorabledisparitiesbecamestatisticallyinsignificant,correspondingtostandarddeviationvalueslessthantwo).Id.
Basedonanevaluationoftheregressionanalysis,thedistrictcourtheldthatthedemonstrateddisparitieswereattributabletofirmsizeasopposedtodiscrimination.Id.at918.Thedistrictcourtconcludedthatthefewunexplaineddisparitiesthatremainedafterregressingforfirmsizewereinsufficienttoprovidetherequisite“strongbasisinevidence”ofdiscriminationofBBEsandHBEs.Id.TheEleventhCircuitheldthatthisdecisionwasnotclearlyerroneous.Id.
WithrespecttotheBBEstatistics,theregressionanalysisexplainedallbutonenegativedisparity,foronetypeofconstructioncontractbetween1989‐1991.Id.TheEleventhCircuitheldthedistrictcourtpermissiblyfoundthatthisdidnotconstitutea“strongbasisinevidence”ofdiscrimination.Id.
WithrespecttotheHBEstatistics,oneoftheregressionmethodsfailedtoexplaintheunfavorabledisparityforonetypeofcontractbetween1989‐1991,andbothregressionmethodsfailedtoexplaintheunfavorabledisparityforanothertypeofcontractduringthatsametimeperiod.Id.However,by1993,bothregressionmethodsaccountedforalloftheunfavorabledisparities,andoneofthedisparitiesforonetypeofcontractwasactuallyfavorableforHBEs.Id.TheEleventhCircuitheldthedistrictcourtpermissiblyfoundthatthisdidnotconstitutea“strongbasisinevidence”ofdiscrimination.Id.
Finally,withrespecttotheWBEstatistics,theregressionanalysisexplainedallbutonenegativedisparity,foronetypeofconstructioncontractinthe1993period.Id.Theregressionanalysisexplainedalloftheothernegativedisparities,andinthe1993period,adisparityforonetypeofcontractwasactuallyfavorabletoWBEs.Id.TheEleventhCircuitheldthedistrictcourtpermissiblyfoundthatthisevidencewasnot“sufficientlyprobativeofdiscrimination.”Id.
TheCountyarguedthatthedistrictcourterroneouslyreliedonthedisaggregateddata(i.e.,brokendownbycontracttype)asopposedtotheconsolidatedstatistics.Id.at919.ThedistrictcourtdeclinedtoassigndispositiveweighttotheaggregateddatafortheBBEstatisticsfor1989‐1991because(1)theaggregateddatafor1993didnotshownegativedisparitieswhenregressedforfirmsize,(2)theBBEdisaggregateddataleftonlyoneunexplainednegativedisparityforonetypeofcontractfor1989‐1991whenregressedforfirmsize,and(3)“theCounty’sownexperttestifiedastotheutilityofexaminingthedisaggregateddata‘insofarastheyreflectdifferentkindsofwork,differentbiddingpractices,perhapsavarietyofotherfactorsthatcouldmakethemheterogeneouswithoneanother.”Id.
Additionally,thedistrictcourtnoted,andtheEleventhCircuitfoundthat“theaggregationofdisparitystatisticsfornonheterogenousdatapopulationscangiverisetoastatisticalphenomenonknownas‘Simpson’sParadox,’whichleadstoillusorydisparitiesinimproperlyaggregateddatathatdisappearwhenthedataaredisaggregated.”Id.at919,n.4(internalcitationsomitted).“Underthosecircumstances,”theEleventhCircuitheldthatthedistrictcourtdidnoterrinassigninglessweighttotheaggregateddata,infindingtheaggregateddataforBBEsfor1989‐1991didnotprovidea“strongbasisinevidence”ofdiscrimination,orinfinding
![Page 230: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/230.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 104
thatthedisaggregateddataformedaninsufficientbasisofsupportforanyoftheMBE/WBEprogramsgiventheapplicableconstitutionalrequirements.Id.at919.
County subcontracting statistics. TheCountyperformedasubcontractingstudytomeasureMBE/WBEparticipationintheCounty’ssubcontractingbusinesses.ForeachMBE/WBEcategory(BBE,HBE,andWBE),“thestudycomparedtheproportionofthedesignatedgroupthatfiledasubcontractor’sreleaseoflienonaCountyconstructionprojectbetween1991and1994withtheproportionofsalesandreceiptdollarsthatthesamegroupreceivedduringthesametimeperiod.”Id.
Thedistrictcourtfoundthestatisticalevidenceinsufficienttosupporttheuseofrace‐andethnicity‐consciousmeasures,notingproblemswithsomeofthedatameasures.Id.at920.
Mostnotably, thedenominatorused in the calculationof theMWBE sales andreceiptspercentagesisbaseduponthetotalsalesandreceiptsfromallsourcesforthefirmfilingasubcontractor’sreleaseoflienwiththeCounty.Thatmeans,forinstance,thatifanationwidenon‐MWBEcompanyperforming99percentofitsbusinessoutsideofDadeCountyfiledasinglesubcontractor’sreleaseoflienwiththeCountyduringtherelevanttimeframe,allof itssalesandreceiptsforthat time frame would be counted in the denominator against which MWBEsalesandreceiptsarecompared.Asthedistrictcourtpointedout, that isnotareasonablewaytomeasureDadeCountysubcontractingparticipation.
Id.TheCounty’sargumentthatastrongmajority(72%)ofthesubcontractorswerelocatedinDadeCountydidnotrenderthedistrictcourt’sdecisiontofailtocreditthestudyerroneous.Id.
Marketplace data statistics. TheCountyconductedanotherstatisticalstudy“toseewhatthedifferencesareinthemarketplaceandwhattherelationshipsareinthemarketplace.”Id.Thestudywasbasedonasampleof568contractors,fromapoolof10,462firms,thathadfileda“certificateofcompetency”withDadeCountyasofJanuary1995.Id.Theselectedfirmsparticipatedinatelephonesurveyinquiringabouttherace,ethnicity,andgenderofthefirm’sowner,andaskedforinformationonthefirm’stotalsalesandreceiptsfromallsources.Id.TheCounty’sexpertthenstudiedthedatatodetermine“whethermeaningfulrelationshipsexistedbetween(1)therace,ethnicity,andgenderofthesurveyedfirmowners,and(2)thereportedsalesandreceiptsofthatfirm.Id.Theexpert’shypothesiswasthatunfavorabledisparitiesmaybeattributabletomarketplacediscrimination.Theexpertperformedaregressionanalysisusingthenumberofemployeesasaproxyforsize.Id.
TheEleventhCircuitfirstnotedthatthestatisticalpoolusedbytheCountywassubstantiallylargerthantheactualnumberoffirms,willing,able,andqualifiedtodotheworkasthestatisticalpoolrepresentedallthosefirmsmerelylicensedasaconstructioncontractor.Id.Althoughthisfactordidnotrenderthestudymeaningless,thedistrictcourtwasentitledtoconsiderthatinevaluatingtheweightofthestudy.Id.at921.TheEleventhCircuitquotedtheSupremeCourtforthefollowingproposition:“[w]henspecialqualificationsarerequiredtofillparticularjobs,comparisonstothegeneralpopulation(ratherthantothesmallergroupofindividualswhopossessthenecessaryqualifications)mayhavelittleprobativevalue.”Id.,
![Page 231: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/231.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 105
quotingCroson,488U.S.at501,quotingHazelwoodSch.Dist.v.UnitedStates,433U.S.299,308n.13(1977).
TheEleventhCircuitfoundthatafterregressingforfirmsize,neithertheBBEnorWBEdatashowedstatisticallysignificantunfavorabledisparities.Id.Althoughthemarketplacedatadidrevealunfavorabledisparitiesevenafteraregressionanalysis,thedistrictcourtwasnotrequiredtoassignthosedisparitiescontrollingweight,especiallyinlightofthedissimilarresultsoftheCountyContractingStatistics,discussedsupra.Id.
The Wainwright Study. TheCountyalsointroducedastatisticalanalysispreparedbyJonWainwright,analyzing“thepersonalandfinancialcharacteristicsofself‐employedpersonsworkingfull‐timeintheDadeCountyconstructionindustry,basedondatafromthe1990PublicUseMicrodataSampledatabase”(derivedfromthedecennialcensus).Id.Thestudy“(1)comparedconstructionbusinessownershipratesofMBE/WBEstothoseofnon‐MBE/WBEs,and(2)analyzeddisparitiesinpersonalincomebetweenMBE/WBEandnon‐MBE/WBEbusinessowners.”Id.“Thestudyconcludedthatblacks,Hispanics,andwomenarelesslikelytoownconstructionbusinessesthansimilarlysituatedwhitemales,andMBE/WBEsthatdoentertheconstructionbusinessearnlessmoneythansimilarlysituatedwhitemales.”Id.
Withrespecttothefirstconclusion,Wainwrightcontrolledfor“humancapital”variables(education,yearsoflabormarketexperience,maritalstatus,andEnglishproficiency)and“financialcapital”variables(interestanddividendincome,andhomeownership).Id.Theanalysisindicatedthatblacks,Hispanicsandwomenentertheconstructionbusinessatlowerratesthanwouldbeexpected,oncenumerosity,andidentifiedhumanandfinancialcapitalarecontrolledfor.Id.Thedisparitiesforblacksandwomen(butnotHispanics)weresubstantialandstatisticallysignificant.Id.at922.Theunderlyingtheoryofthisbusinessownershipcomponentofthestudyisthatanysignificantdisparitiesremainingaftercontrolofvariablesareduetotheongoingeffectsofpastandpresentdiscrimination.Id.
TheEleventhCircuitheld,inlightofCroson,thedistrictcourtneednothaveacceptedthistheory.Id.TheEleventhCircuitquotedCroson,inwhichtheSupremeCourtrespondedtoasimilarargumentadvancedbytheplaintiffsinthatcase:“Therearenumerousexplanationsforthisdearthofminorityparticipation,includingpastsocietaldiscriminationineducationandeconomicopportunitiesaswellasbothblackandwhitecareerandentrepreneurialchoices.Blacksmaybedisproportionatelyattractedtoindustriesotherthanconstruction.”Id.,quotingCroson,488U.S.at503.FollowingtheSupremeCourtinCroson,theEleventhCircuitheld“thedisproportionateattractionofaminoritygrouptonon‐constructionindustriesdoesnotmeanthatdiscriminationintheconstructionindustryisthereason.”Id.,quotingCroson,488U.S.at503.Additionally,thedistrictcourthadevidencethatbetween1982and1987,therewasasubstantialgrowthrateofMBE/WBEfirmsasopposedtonon‐MBE/WBEfirms,whichwouldfurthernegatethepropositionthattheconstructionindustrywasdiscriminatingagainstminority‐andwomen‐ownedfirms.Id.at922.
WithrespecttothepersonalincomecomponentoftheWainwrightstudy,afterregressionanalyseswereconducted,onlytheBBEstatisticsindicatedastatisticallysignificantdisparityratio.Id.at923.However,theEleventhCircuitheldthedistrictcourtwasnotrequiredtoassignthedisparitycontrollingweightbecausethestudydidnotregressforfirmsize,andinlightofthe
![Page 232: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/232.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 106
conflictingstatisticalevidenceintheCountyContractingStatisticsandMarketplaceDataStatistics,discussedsupra,whichdidregressforfirmsize.Id.
The Brimmer Study. ThefinalstudypresentedbytheCountywasconductedunderthesupervisionofDr.AndrewF.Brimmerandconcernedonlyblack‐ownedfirms.Id.Thekeycomponentofthestudywasananalysisofthebusinessreceiptsofblack‐ownedconstructionfirmsfortheyearsof1977,1982and1987,basedontheCensusBureau’sSurveyofMinority‐andWomen‐OwnedBusinesses,producedeveryfiveyears.Id.Thestudysoughttodeterminetheexistenceofdisparitiesbetweensalesandreceiptsofblack‐ownedfirmsinDadeCountycomparedtothesalesandreceiptsofallconstructionfirmsinDadeCounty.Id.
Thestudyindicatedsubstantialdisparitiesin1977and1987butnot1982.Id.TheCountyallegedthattheabsenceofdisparityin1982wasduetosubstantialrace‐consciousmeasuresforamajorconstructioncontract(Metrorailproject),andnotduetoalackofdiscriminationintheindustry.Id.However,thestudymadenoattempttofilterfortheMetrorailprojectand“complete[ly]fail[ed]”toaccountforfirmsize.Id.Accordingly,theEleventhCircuitfoundthedistrictcourtpermissiblydiscountedtheresultsoftheBrimmerstudy.Id.at924.
Anecdotal evidence. Inaddition,theCountypresentedasubstantialamountofanecdotalevidenceofperceiveddiscriminationagainstBBEs,asmallamountofsimilaranecdotalevidencepertainingtoWBEs,andnoanecdotalevidencepertainingtoHBEs.Id.TheCountypresentedthreebasicformsofanecdotalevidence:“(1)thetestimonyoftwoCountyemployeesresponsibleforadministeringtheMBE/WBEprograms;(2)thetestimony,primarilybyaffidavit,oftwenty‐threeMBE/WBEcontractorsandsubcontractors;and(3)asurveyofblack‐ownedconstructionfirms.”Id.
TheCountyemployeestestifiedthatthedecentralizedstructureoftheCountyconstructioncontractingsystemaffordsgreatdiscretiontoCountyemployees,whichinturncreatestheopportunityfordiscriminationtoinfectthesystem.Id.Theyalsotestifiedtospecificincidentsofdiscrimination,forexample,thatMBE/WBEscomplainedofreceivinglengthierpunchliststhantheirnon‐MBE/WBEcounterparts.Id.TheyalsotestifiedthatMBE/WBEsencounterdifficultiesinobtainingbondingandfinancing.Id.
TheMBE/WBEcontractorsandsubcontractorstestifiedtonumerousincidentsofperceiveddiscriminationintheDadeCountyconstructionmarket,including:
Situationsinwhichaprojectforemanwouldrefusetodealdirectlywithablackor female firm owner, instead preferring to deal with a white employee;instances in which an MWBE owner knew itself to be the low bidder on asubcontractingproject,butwasnotawarded the job; instances inwhicha lowbid by an MWBE was “shopped” to solicit even lower bids from non‐MWBEfirms; instances in which anMWBE owner received an invitation to bid on asubcontract within a day of the bid due date, together with a “letter ofunavailability”fortheMWBEownertosigninordertoobtainawaiverfromtheCounty;and instances inwhichanMWBEsubcontractorwashiredbyaprimecontractor, but subsequently was replaced with a non‐MWBE subcontractorwithindaysofstartingworkontheproject.
![Page 233: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/233.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 107
Id.at924‐25.
Finally,theCountysubmittedastudypreparedbyDr.JoeE.Feagin,comprisedofinterviewsof78certifiedblack‐ownedconstructionfirms.Id.at925.Theintervieweesreportedsimilarinstancesofperceiveddiscrimination,including:“difficultyinsecuringbondingandfinancing;slowpaymentbygeneralcontractors;unfairperformanceevaluationsthatweretaintedbyracialstereotypes;difficultyinobtaininginformationfromtheCountyoncontractingprocesses;andhigherpricesonequipmentandsuppliesthanwerebeingchargedtonon‐MBE/WBEfirms.”Id.
TheEleventhCircuitfoundthatnumerousblack‐andsomefemale‐ownedconstructionfirmsinDadeCountyperceivedthattheywerethevictimsofdiscriminationandtwoCountyemployeesalsobelievedthatdiscriminationcouldtainttheCounty’sconstructioncontractingprocess.Id.However,suchanecdotalevidenceishelpful“onlywhenit[is]combinedwithandreinforcedbysufficientlyprobativestatisticalevidence.”Id.InherpluralityopinioninCroson,JusticeO’Connorfoundthat“evidenceofapatternofindividualdiscriminatoryactscan,ifsupportedbyappropriatestatisticalproof,lendsupporttoalocalgovernment’sdeterminationthatbroaderremedialreliefisjustified.”Id.,quotingCroson,488U.S.at509(emphasisaddedbytheEleventhCircuit).Accordingly,theEleventhCircuitheldthat“anecdotalevidencecanplayanimportantroleinbolsteringstatisticalevidence,butthatonlyintherarecasewillanecdotalevidencesufficestandingalone.”Id.at925.TheEleventhCircuitalsocitedtoopinionsfromtheThird,NinthandTenthCircuitsassupportingthesameproposition.Id.at926.TheEleventhCircuitaffirmedthedecisionofthedistrictcourtenjoiningthecontinuedoperationoftheMBE/WBEprogramsbecausetheydidnotrestona“constitutionallysufficientevidentiaryfoundation.”Id.
AlthoughtheEleventhCircuitdeterminedthattheMBE/WBEprogramdidnotsurviveconstitutionalmusterduetotheabsenceofasufficientevidentiaryfoundation,theEleventhCircuitproceededwiththesecondprongofthestrictscrutinyanalysisofdeterminingwhethertheMBE/WBEprogramswerenarrowlytailored(BBEandHBEprograms)orsubstantiallyrelated(WBEprogram)tothelegitimategovernmentinteresttheypurportedtoserve,i.e.,“remedyingtheeffectsofpresentandpastdiscriminationagainstblacks,Hispanics,andwomenintheDadeCountyconstructionmarket.”Id.
Narrow tailoring. “Theessenceofthe‘narrowlytailored’inquiryisthenotionthatexplicitlyracialpreferences…mustonlybea‘lastresort’option.”Id.,quotingHayesv.NorthSideLawEnforcementOfficersAss’n,10F.3d207,217(4thCir.1993)andcitingCroson,488U.S.at519(Kennedy,J.,concurringinpartandconcurringinthejudgment)(“[T]hestrictscrutinystandard…forbidstheuseofevennarrowlydrawnracialclassificationsexceptasalastresort.”).
TheEleventhCircuithasidentifiedfourfactorstoevaluatewhetherarace‐orethnicity‐consciousaffirmativeactionprogramisnarrowlytailored:(1)“thenecessityforthereliefandtheefficacyofalternativeremedies;(2)theflexibilityanddurationoftherelief;(3)therelationshipofnumericalgoalstotherelevantlabormarket;and(4)theimpactofthereliefontherightsofinnocentthirdparties.”Id.at927,citingEnsleyBranch,31F.3dat1569.Thefourfactorsprovide“ausefulanalyticalstructure.”Id.at927.TheEleventhCircuitfocusedonlyonthefirstfactorinthepresentcase“becausethatiswheretheCounty’sMBE/WBEprogramsaremostproblematic.”Id.
![Page 234: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/234.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 108
TheEleventhCircuit
flatlyreject[ed]theCounty’sassertionthat‘givenastrongbasisinevidenceofarace‐basedproblem, a race‐based remedy isnecessary.’That is simplynot thelaw. Ifarace‐neutralremedy issufficient tocurearace‐basedproblem, thenarace‐conscious remedy can never be narrowly tailored to that problem.” Id.,citingCroson,488U.S.at507(holdingthataffirmativeactionprogramwasnotnarrowlytailoredwhere“theredoesnotappeartohavebeenanyconsiderationof theuseofrace‐neutralmeans to increaseminoritybusinessparticipation incity contracting”) … Supreme Court decisions teach that a race‐consciousremedy is not merely one of many equally acceptable medications thegovernmentmayusetotreatarace‐basedproblem.Instead,itisthestrongestofmedicines, with many potential side effects, and must be reserved for thoseseverecasesthatarehighlyresistanttoconventionaltreatment.
Id.at927.
TheEleventhCircuitheldthattheCounty“clearlyfailedtogiveseriousandgoodfaithconsiderationtotheuseofrace‐andethnicity‐neutralmeasures.”Id.Rather,thedeterminationofthenecessitytoestablishtheMWBEprogramswasbaseduponaconclusorylegislativestatementastoitsnecessity,whichinturnwasbaseduponan“equallyconclusoryanalysis”intheBrimmerstudy,andareportthattheSBAonlywasabletodirect5percentofSBAfinancingtoblack‐ownedbusinessesbetween1968‐1980.Id.
TheCountyadmitted,andtheEleventhCircuitconcluded,thattheCountyfailedtogiveanyconsiderationtoanyalternativetotheHBEaffirmativeactionprogram.Id.at928.Moreover,theEleventhCircuitfoundthatthetestimonyoftheCounty’sownwitnessesindicatedtheviabilityofrace‐andethnicity‐neutralmeasurestoremedymanyoftheproblemsfacingblack‐andHispanic‐ownedconstructionfirms.Id.TheCountyemployeesidentifiedproblems,virtuallyallofwhichwererelatedtotheCounty’sownprocessesandprocedures,including:“thedecentralizedCountycontractingsystem,whichaffordsahighlevelofdiscretiontoCountyemployees;thecomplexityofCountycontractspecifications;difficultyinobtainingbonding;difficultyinobtainingfinancing;unnecessarybidrestrictions;inefficientpaymentprocedures;andinsufficientorinefficientexchangeofinformation.”Id.TheEleventhCircuitfoundthattheproblemsfacingMBE/WBEcontractorswere“institutionalbarriers”toentryfacingeverynewentrantintotheconstructionmarket,andwereperhapsaffectingtheMBE/WBEcontractorsdisproportionatelyduetothe“institutionalyouth”ofblack‐andHispanic‐ownedconstructionfirms.Id.“Itfollowsthatthosefirmsshouldbehelpedthemostbydismantlingthosebarriers,somethingtheCountycoulddoatleastinsubstantialpart.”Id.
TheEleventhCircuitnotedthattherace‐andethnicity‐neutraloptionsavailabletotheCountymirroredthoseavailableandcitedbyJusticeO’ConnorinCroson:
[T]hecityhasatitsdisposalawholearrayofrace‐neutralmeasurestoincreasethe accessibility of city contracting opportunities to small entrepreneurs of allraces.Simplificationofbiddingprocedures,relaxationofbondingrequirements,and training and financial aid for disadvantaged entrepreneurs of all races
![Page 235: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/235.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 109
would open the public contractingmarket to all thosewho have suffered theeffects of past societal discrimination and neglect … The city may also act toprohibitdiscrimination in theprovisionofcreditorbondingby localsuppliersandbanks.
Id.,quotingCroson,488U.S.at509‐10.TheEleventhCircuitfoundthatexceptforsome“half‐heartedprograms”consistingof“limitedtechnicalandfinancialaidthatmightbenefitBBEsandHBEs,”theCountyhadnot“seriouslyconsidered”ortriedmostoftherace‐andethnicity‐neutralalternativesavailable.Id.at928.“Mostnotably…theCountyhasnottakenanyactionwhatsoevertoferretoutandrespondtoinstancesofdiscriminationifandwhentheyhaveoccurredintheCounty’sowncontractingprocess.”Id.
TheEleventhCircuitfoundthattheCountyhadtakennostepsto“inform,educate,discipline,orpenalize”discriminatorymisconductbyitsownemployees.Id.at929.NorhadtheCountypassedanylocalordinancesexpresslyprohibitingdiscriminationbylocalcontractors,subcontractors,suppliers,bankers,orinsurers.Id.“Insteadofturningtorace‐andethnicity‐consciousremediesasalastresort,theCountyhasturnedtothemasafirstresort.”Accordingly,theEleventhCircuitheldthateveniftheBBEandHBEprogramsweresupportedbytherequisiteevidentiaryfoundation,theyviolatedtheEqualProtectionClausebecausetheywerenotnarrowlytailored.Id.
Substantial relationship. TheEleventhCircuitheldthatduetotherelaxed“substantialrelationship”standardforgender‐consciousprograms,iftheWBEprogramresteduponasufficientevidentiaryfoundation,itcouldpassthesubstantialrelationshiprequirement.Id.However,becauseitdidnotrestuponasufficientevidentiaryfoundation,theWBEprogramcouldnotpassconstitutionalmuster.Id.
Foralloftheforegoingreasons,theEleventhCircuitaffirmedthedecisionofthedistrictcourtdeclaringtheMBE/WBEprogramsunconstitutionalandenjoiningtheircontinuedoperation.
11. Associated Gen. Contractors of California, Inc. v. Coalition for Econ. Equity (“AGCC”), 950 F.2d 1401 (9th Cir. 1991)
InAssociatedGen.ContractorsofCalifornia,Inc.v.CoalitionforEcon.Equity(“AGCC”),theNinthCircuitCourtofAppealsdeniedplaintiffsrequestforpreliminaryinjunctiontoenjoinenforcementofthecity’sbidpreferenceprogram.950F.2d1401(9thCir.1991).Althoughanoldercase,AGCCisinstructiveastotheanalysisconductedbytheNinthCircuit.Thecourtdiscussedtheutilizationofstatisticalevidenceandanecdotalevidenceinthecontextofthestrictscrutinyanalysis.Id.at1413‐18.
TheCityofSanFranciscoadoptedanordinancein1989providingbidpreferencestoprimecontractorswhoweremembersofgroupsfounddisadvantagedbypreviousbiddingpractices,andspecificallyprovideda5percentbidpreferenceforLBEs,WBEsandMBEs.950F.2dat1405.LocalMBEsandWBEswereeligiblefora10percenttotalbidpreference,representingthecumulativetotalofthefivepercentpreferencegivenLocalBusinessEnterprises(“LBEs”)andthe5percentpreferencegivenMBEsandWBEs.Id.Theordinancedefined“MBE”asaneconomicallydisadvantagedbusinessthatwasownedandcontrolledbyoneormoreminoritypersons,which
![Page 236: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/236.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 110
weredefinedtoincludeAsian,blacksandLatinos.“WBE”wasdefinedasaneconomicallydisadvantagedbusinessthatwasownedandcontrolledbyoneormorewomen.Economicallydisadvantagedwasdefinedasabusinesswithaveragegrossannualreceiptsthatdidnotexceed$14million.Id.
TheMotionforPreliminaryInjunctionchallengedtheconstitutionalityoftheMBEprovisionsofthe1989OrdinanceinsofarasitpertainedtoPublicWorksconstructioncontracts.Id.at1405.ThedistrictcourtdeniedtheMotionforPreliminaryInjunctionontheAGCC’sconstitutionalclaimonthegroundthatAGCCfailedtodemonstratealikelihoodofsuccessonthemerits.Id.at1412.
TheNinthCircuitCourtofAppealsappliedthestrictscrutinyanalysisfollowingthedecisionoftheU.S.SupremeCourtinCityofRichmondv.Croson.ThecourtstatedthataccordingtotheU.S.SupremeCourtinCroson,amunicipalityhasacompellinginterestinginredressing,notonlydiscriminationcommittedbythemunicipalityitself,butalsodiscriminationcommittedbyprivatepartieswithinthemunicipalities’legislativejurisdiction,solongasthemunicipalityinsomewayperpetuatedthediscriminationtoberemediedbytheprogram.Id.at1412‐13,citingCrosonat488U.S.at491‐92,537‐38.Tosatisfythisrequirement,“thegovernmentalactorneednotbeanactiveperpetratorofsuchdiscrimination;passiveparticipationwillsatisfythissub‐partofstrictscrutinyreview.”Id.at1413,quotingCoralConstructionCompanyv.KingCounty,941F.2d910at916(9thCir.1991).Inaddition,the[m]ereinfusionoftaxdollarsintoadiscriminatoryindustrymaybesufficientgovernmentalinvolvementtosatisfythisprong.”Id.at1413quotingCoralConstruction,941F.2dat916.
ThecourtpointedoutthattheCityhadmadedetailedfindingsofpriordiscriminationinconstructionandbuildingwithinitsborders,hadtestimonytakenatmorethantenpublichearingsandreceivednumerouswrittensubmissionsfromthepublicaspartofitsanecdotalevidence.Id.at1414.TheCityDepartmentscontinuedtodiscriminateagainstMBEsandWBEsandcontinuedtooperateunderthe“oldboynetwork”inawardingcontracts,therebydisadvantagingMBEsandWBEs.Id.And,theCityfoundthatlargestatisticaldisparitiesexistedbetweenthepercentageofcontractsawardedtoMBEsandthepercentageofavailableMBEs.950F.2dat1414.ThecourtstatedtheCityalsofound“discriminationintheprivatesectoragainstMBEsandWBEsthatismanifestedinandexacerbatedbytheCity’sprocurementpractices.”Id.at1414.
TheNinthCircuitfoundthestudycommissionedbytheCityindicatedtheexistenceoflargedisparitiesbetweentheawardofcitycontractstoavailablenon‐minoritybusinessesandtoMBEs.Id.at1414.UsingtheCityandCountyofSanFranciscoasthe“relevantmarket,”thestudycomparedthenumberofavailableMBEprimeconstructioncontractorsinSanFranciscowiththeamountofcontractdollarsawardedbytheCitytoSanFrancisco‐basedMBEsforaparticularyear.Id.at1414.ThestudyfoundthatavailableMBEsreceivedfarfewercitycontractsinproportiontotheirnumbersthantheiravailablenon‐minoritycounterparts.Id.Specifically,thestudyfoundthatwithrespecttoprimeconstructioncontracting,disparitiesbetweenthenumberofavailablelocalAsian‐,black‐andHispanic‐ownedfirmsandthenumberofcontractsawardedtosuchfirmswerestatisticallysignificantandsupportedaninferenceofdiscrimination.Id.Forexample,inprimecontractingforconstruction,althoughMBEavailabilitywasdeterminedtobeat49.5percent,MBEdollarparticipationwasonly11.1percent.Id.TheNinthCircuitstatedthan
![Page 237: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/237.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 111
initsdecisioninCoralConstruction,itemphasizedthatsuchstatisticaldisparitiesare“aninvaluabletoolanddemonstratingthediscriminationnecessarytoestablishacompellinginterest.Id.at1414,citingtoCoralConstruction,941F.2dat918andCroson,488U.S.at509.
Thecourtnotedthattherecorddocumentsavastnumberofindividualaccountsofdiscrimination,whichbring“thecoldnumbersconvincinglytolife.Id.at1414,quotingCoralConstruction,941F.2dat919.TheseaccountsincludenumerousreportsofMBEsbeingdeniedcontractsdespitebeingthelowbidder,MBEsbeingtoldtheywerenotqualifiedalthoughtheywerelaterfoundqualifiedwhenevaluatedbyoutsideparties,MBEsbeingrefusedworkevenaftertheywereawardedcontractsaslowbidder,andMBEsbeingharassedbycitypersonneltodiscouragethemfrombiddingoncitycontracts.Idat1415.TheCitypointedtonumerousindividualaccountsofdiscrimination,thatan“oldboynetwork”stillexists,andthatracialdiscriminationisstillprevalentwithintheSanFranciscoconstructionindustry.Id.Thecourtfoundthatsucha“combinationofconvincinganecdotalandstatisticalevidenceispotent.”Id.at1415quotingCoralConstruction,941F.2dat919.
Thecourtalsostatedthatthe1989OrdinanceappliesonlytoresidentMBEs.TheCity,therefore,accordingtothecourt,appropriatelyconfineditsstudytothecitylimitsinordertofocusonthosewhomthepreferenceschemetargeted.Id.at1415.ThecourtnotedthatthestatisticsrelieduponbytheCitytodemonstratediscriminationinitscontractingprocessesconsideredonlyMBEslocatedwithintheCityofSanFrancisco.Id.
ThecourtpointedouttheCity’sfindingswerebasedupondozensofspecificinstancesofdiscriminationthatarelaidoutwithparticularityintherecord,aswellasthesignificantstatisticaldisparitiesintheawardofcontracts.ThecourtnotedthattheCitymustsimplydemonstratetheexistenceofpastdiscriminationwithspecificity,butthereisnorequirementthatthelegislativefindingsspecificallydetaileachandeveryincidencethatthelegislativebodyhasrelieduponinsupportofthisdecisionthataffirmativeactionisnecessary.Id.at1416.
Initsanalysisofthe“narrowlytailored”requirement,thecourtfocusedonthreecharacteristicsidentifiedbythedecisioninCrosonasindicativeofnarrowtailoring.First,anMBEprogramshouldbeinstitutedeitherafter,orinconjunctionwith,race‐neutralmeansofincreasingminoritybusinessparticipationinpubliccontracting.Id.at1416.Second,theplanshouldavoidtheuseof“rigidnumericalquotas.”Id.AccordingtotheSupremeCourt,systemsthatpermitwaiverinappropriatecasesandthereforerequiresomeindividualizedconsiderationoftheapplicantsposealesserdangerofoffendingtheConstitution.Id.Mechanismsthatintroduceflexibilityintothesystemalsopreventtheimpositionofadisproportionateburdenonafewindividuals.Id.Third,“anMBEprogrammustbelimitedinitseffectivescopetotheboundariesoftheenactingjurisdiction.Id.at1416quotingCoralConstruction,941F.2dat922.
ThecourtfoundthattherecordshowedtheCityconsidered,butrejectedasnotviable,specificrace‐neutralalternativesincludingafundtoassistnewlyestablishedMBEsinmeetingbondingrequirements.Thecourtstatedthat“whilestrictscrutinyrequiresserious,goodfaithconsiderationofrace‐neutralalternatives,strictscrutinydoesnotrequireexhaustionofeverypossiblesuchalternative…howeverirrational,costly,unreasonable,andunlikelytosucceedsuchalternativemaybe.”Id.at1417quotingCoralConstruction,941F.2dat923.ThecourtfoundtheCitytenyearsbeforehadattemptedtoeradicatediscriminationincitycontracting
![Page 238: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/238.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 112
throughpassageofarace‐neutralordinancethatprohibitedcitycontractorsfromdiscriminatingagainsttheiremployeesonthebasisofraceandrequiredcontractorstotakestepstointegratetheirworkforce;andthattheCitymadeandcontinuestomakeeffortstoenforcetheanti‐discriminationordinance.Id.at1417.Thecourtstatedinclusionofsuchrace‐neutralmeasuresisonefactorsuggestingthatanMBEplanisnarrowlytailored.Id.at1417.
ThecourtalsofoundthattheOrdinancepossessedtherequisiteflexibility.Ratherthanarigidquotasystem,theCityadoptedamoremodestsystemaccordingtothecourt,thatofbidpreferences.Id.at1417.Thecourtpointedoutthattherewerenogoals,quotas,orset‐asidesandmoreover,theplanremediesonlyspecificallyidentifieddiscrimination:theCityprovidespreferencesonlytothoseminoritygroupsfoundtohavepreviouslyreceivedalowerpercentageofspecifictypesofcontractsthantheiravailabilitytoperformsuchworkwouldsuggest.Id.at1417.
ThecourtrejectedtheargumentofAGCCthattopassconstitutionalmusteranyremedymustprovideredressonlytospecificindividualswhohavebeenidentifiedasvictimsofdiscrimination.Id.at1417,n.12.TheNinthCircuitagreedwiththedistrictcourtthataniron‐cladrequirementlimitinganyremedytoindividualspersonallyproventohavesufferedpriordiscriminationwouldrenderanyrace‐consciousremedy“superfluous,”andwouldthwarttheSupremeCourt’sdirectiveinCrosonthatrace‐consciousremediesmaybepermittedinsomecircumstances.Id.at1417,n.12.Thecourtalsofoundthattheburdensofthebidpreferencesonthosenotentitledtothemappear“relativelylightandwelldistributed.”Id.at1417.ThecourtstatedthattheOrdinancewas“limitedinitsgeographicalscopetotheboundariesoftheenactingjurisdiction.Id.at1418,quotingCoralConstruction,941F.2dat925.ThecourtfoundthatSanFranciscohadcarefullylimitedtheordinancetobenefitonlythoseMBEslocatedwithintheCity’sborders.Id.1418.
12. Coral Construction Co. v. King County, 941 F.2d 910 (9th Cir. 1991)
InCoralConstructionCo.v.KingCounty,941F.2d910(9thCir.1991),theNinthCircuitexaminedtheconstitutionalityofKingCounty,Washington’sminorityandwomenbusinessset‐asideprograminlightofthestandardsetforthinCityofRichmondv.J.A.CrosonCo.ThecourtheldthatalthoughtheCountypresentedampleanecdotalevidenceofdisparatetreatmentofMBEcontractorsandsubcontractors,thetotalabsenceofpre‐programenactmentstatisticalevidencewasproblematictothecompellinggovernmentinterestcomponentofthestrictscrutinyanalysis.Thecourtremandedtothedistrictcourtforadeterminationofwhetherthepost‐programenactmentstudiesconstitutedasufficientcompellinggovernmentinterest.Perthenarrowtailoringprongofthestrictscrutinytest,thecourtfoundthatalthoughtheprogramincludedrace‐neutralalternativemeasuresandwasflexible(i.e.,includedawaiverprovision),theoverbreadthoftheprogramtoincludeMBEsoutsideofKingCountywasfataltothenarrowtailoringanalysis.
Thecourtalsoremandedontheissueofwhethertheplaintiffswereentitledtodamagesunder42U.S.C.§§1981and1983,andinparticulartodeterminewhetherevidenceofcausationexisted.WithrespecttotheWBEprogram,thecourtheldtheplaintiffhadstandingtochallengetheprogram,andapplyingtheintermediatescrutinyanalysis,heldtheWBEprogramsurvivedthefacialchallenge.
![Page 239: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/239.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 113
InfindingtheabsenceofanystatisticaldatainsupportoftheCounty’sMBEProgram,thecourtmadeitclearthatstatisticalanalyseshaveservedandwillcontinuetoserveanimportantroleincasesinwhichtheexistenceofdiscriminationisadisputedissue.941F.2dat918.Thecourtnotedthatithasrepeatedlyapprovedtheuseofstatisticalprooftoestablishaprimafaciecaseofdiscrimination.Id.ThecourtpointedoutthattheU.S.SupremeCourtinCrosonheldthatwhere“grossstatisticaldisparitiescanbeshown,theyalonemayinapropercaseconstituteprimafacieproofofapatternorpracticeofdiscrimination.”Id.at918,quotingHazelwoodSchoolDist.v.UnitedStates,433U.S.299,307‐08,andCroson,488U.S.at501.
Thecourtpointsoutthatstatisticalevidencemaynotfullyaccountforthecomplexfactorsandmotivationsguidingemploymentdecisions,manyofwhichmaybeentirelyrace‐neutral.Id.at919.Thecourtnotedthattherecordcontainedaplethoraofanecdotalevidence,butthatanecdotalevidence,standingalone,suffersthesameflawsasstatisticalevidence.Id.at919.Whileanecdotalevidencemaysufficetoproveindividualclaimsofdiscrimination,rarely,accordingtothecourt,ifever,cansuchevidenceshowasystemicpatternofdiscriminationnecessaryfortheadoptionofanaffirmativeactionplan.Id.
Nonetheless,thecourtheldthatthecombinationofconvincinganecdotalandstatisticalevidenceispotent.Id.at919.Thecourtpointedoutthatindividualswhotestifiedabouttheirpersonalexperiencesbroughtthecoldnumbersofstatistics“convincinglytolife.”Id.at919,quotingInternationalBrotherhoodofTeamstersv.UnitedStates,431U.S.324,339(1977).ThecourtalsopointedoutthattheEleventhCircuitCourtofAppeals,inpassinguponaminoritysetasideprogramsimilartotheoneinKingCounty,concludedthatthetestimonyregardingcomplaintsofdiscriminationcombinedwiththegrossstatisticaldisparitiesuncoveredbytheCountystudiesprovidedmorethanenoughevidenceonthequestionofpriordiscriminationandneedforracialclassificationtojustifythedenialofaMotionforSummaryJudgment.Id.at919,citingConeCorp.v.HillsboroughCounty,908F.2d908,916(11thCir.1990).
ThecourtfoundthattheMBEProgramoftheCountycouldnotstandwithoutaproperstatisticalfoundation.Id.at919.Thecourtaddressedwhetherpost‐enactmentstudiesdonebytheCountyofastatisticalfoundationcouldbeconsideredbythecourtinconnectionwithdeterminingthevalidityoftheCountyMBEProgram.Thecourtheldthatamunicipalitymusthavesomeconcreteevidenceofdiscriminationinaparticularindustrybeforeitmayadoptaremedialprogram.Id.at920.However,thecourtsaidthisrequirementofsomeevidencedoesnotmeanthataprogramwillbeautomaticallystruckdowniftheevidencebeforethemunicipalityatthetimeofenactmentdoesnotcompletelyfulfillbothprongsofthestrictscrutinytest.Id.Rather,thecourtheld,thefactualpredicatefortheprogramshouldbeevaluatedbaseduponallevidencepresentedtothedistrictcourt,whethersuchevidencewasadducedbeforeorafterenactmentoftheMBEProgram.Id.Therefore,thecourtadoptedarulethatamunicipalityshouldhavebeforeitsomeevidenceofdiscriminationbeforeadoptingarace‐consciousprogram,whileallowingpost‐adoptionevidencetobeconsideredinpassingontheconstitutionalityoftheprogram.Id.
Thecourt,therefore,remandedthecasetothedistrictcourtfordeterminationofwhethertheconsultantstudiesthatwereperformedaftertheenactmentoftheMBEProgramcouldprovideanadequatefactualjustificationtoestablisha“propellinggovernmentinterest”forKingCounty’sadoptingtheMBEProgram.Id.at922.
![Page 240: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/240.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 114
ThecourtalsofoundthatCrosondoesnotrequireashowingofactivediscriminationbytheenactingagency,andthatpassiveparticipation,suchastheinfusionoftaxdollarsintoadiscriminatoryindustry,suffices.Id.at922,citingCroson,488U.S.at492.ThecourtpointedoutthattheSupremeCourtinCrosonconcludedthatiftheCityhadevidencebeforeit,thatnon‐minoritycontractorsweresystematicallyexcludingminoritybusinessesfromsubcontractingopportunities,itcouldtakeactiontoendthediscriminatoryexclusion.Id.at922.Thecourtpointsoutthatiftherecordultimatelysupportedafindingofsystemicdiscrimination,theCountyadequatelylimiteditsprogramtothosebusinessesthatreceivetaxdollars,andtheprogramimposedobligationsupononlythosebusinesseswhichvoluntarilysoughtKingCountytaxdollarsbycontractingwiththeCounty.Id.
Thecourtaddressedseveralfactorsintermsofthenarrowlytailoredanalysis,andfoundthatfirst,anMBEprogramshouldbeinstitutedeitherafter,orinconjunctionwith,race‐neutralmeansofincreasingminoritybusinessparticipationandpubliccontracting.Id.at922,citingCroson,488U.S.at507.Thesecondcharacteristicofthenarrowly‐tailoredprogram,accordingtothecourt,istheuseofminorityutilizationgoalsonacase‐by‐casebasis,ratherthanuponasystemofrigidnumericalquotas.Id.Finally,thecourtstatedthatanMBEprogrammustbelimitedinitseffectivescopetotheboundariesoftheenactingjurisdiction.Id.
Amongthevariousnarrowlytailoredrequirements,thecourtheldconsiderationofrace‐neutralalternativesisamongthemostimportant.Id.at922.Nevertheless,thecourtstatedthatwhilestrictscrutinyrequiresserious,goodfaithconsiderationofrace‐neutralalternatives,strictscrutinydoesnotrequireexhaustionofeverypossiblesuchalternative.Id.at923.Thecourtnotedthatitdoesnotintendagovernmententityexhausteveryalternative,howeverirrational,costly,unreasonable,andunlikelytosucceedsuchalternativemightbe.Id.Thus,thecourtrequiredonlythatastateexhaustsrace‐neutralmeasuresthatthestateisauthorizedtoenact,andthathaveareasonablepossibilityofbeingeffective.Id.ThecourtnotedinthiscasetheCountyconsideredalternatives,butdeterminedthattheywerenotavailableasamatteroflaw.Id.TheCountycannotberequiredtoengageinconductthatmaybeillegal,norcanitbecompelledtoexpendprecioustaxdollarsonprojectswherepotentialforsuccessismarginalatbest.Id.
ThecourtnotedthatKingCountyhadadoptedsomerace‐neutralmeasuresinconjunctionwiththeMBEProgram,forexample,hostingoneortwotrainingsessionsforsmallbusinesses,coveringsuchtopicsasdoingbusinesswiththegovernment,smallbusinessmanagement,andaccountingtechniques.Id.at923.Inaddition,theCountyprovidedinformationonassessingSmallBusinessAssistancePrograms.Id.ThecourtfoundthatKingCountyfulfilleditsburdenofconsideringrace‐neutralalternativeprograms.Id.
Asecondindicatorofaprogram’snarrowlytailoringisprogramflexibility.Id.at924.Thecourtfoundthatanimportantmeansofachievingsuchflexibilityisthroughuseofcase‐by‐caseutilizationgoals,ratherthanrigidnumericalquotasorgoals.Id.at924.ThecourtpointedoutthatKingCountyuseda“percentagepreference”method,whichisnotaquota,andwhilethepreferenceislockedatfivepercent,suchafixedpreferenceisnotundulyrigidinlightofthewaiverprovisions.ThecourtfoundthatavalidMBEProgramshouldincludeawaiversystemthataccountsforboththeavailabilityofqualifiedMBEsandwhetherthequalifiedMBEshavesufferedfromtheeffectsofpastdiscriminationbytheCountyorprimecontractors.Id.at924.
![Page 241: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/241.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 115
ThecourtfoundthatKingCounty’sprogramprovidedwaiversinbothinstances,includingwhereneitherminoritynorawoman’sbusinessisavailabletoprovideneededgoodsorservicesandwhereavailableminorityand/orwomen’sbusinesseshavegivenpricequotesthatareunreasonablyhigh.Id.
ThecourtalsopointedoutotherattributesofthenarrowlytailoredandflexibleMBEprogram,includingabidderthatdoesnotmeetplannedgoals,maynonethelessbeawardedthecontractbydemonstratingagoodfaithefforttocomply.Id.TheactualpercentagesofrequiredMBEparticipationaredeterminedonacase‐by‐casebasis.Levelsofparticipationmaybereducediftheprescribedlevelsarenotfeasible,ifqualifiedMBEsareunavailable,orifMBEpricequotesarenotcompetitive.Id.
ThecourtconcludedthatanMBEprogrammustalsobelimitedinitsgeographicalscopetotheboundariesoftheenactingjurisdiction.Id.at925.HerethecourtheldthatKingCounty’sMBEprogramfailsthisthirdportionof“narrowlytailored”requirement.Thecourtfoundthedefinitionof“minoritybusiness”includedintheProgramindicatedthataminority‐ownedbusinessmayqualifyforpreferentialtreatmentifthebusinesshasbeendiscriminatedagainstintheparticulargeographicalareasinwhichitoperates.Thecourtheldthisdefinitionasoverlybroad.Id.at925.ThecourtheldthattheCountyshouldaskthequestionwhetherabusinesshasbeendiscriminatedagainstinKingCounty.Id.Thisdetermination,accordingtothecourt,isnotaninsurmountableburdenfortheCounty,astheruledoesnotrequirefindingspecificinstancesofdiscriminatoryexclusionforeachMBE.Id.Rather,iftheCountysuccessfullyprovesmalignantdiscriminationwithintheKingCountybusinesscommunity,anMBEwouldbepresumptivelyeligibleforreliefifithadpreviouslysoughttodobusinessintheCounty.Id.
Inotherwords,ifsystemicdiscriminationintheCountyisshown,thenitisfairtopresumethatanMBEwasvictimizedbythediscrimination.Id.at925.ForthepresumptiontoattachtotheMBE,however,itmustbeestablishedthattheMBEis,orattemptedtobecome,anactiveparticipantintheCounty’sbusinesscommunity.Id.BecauseKingCounty’sprogrampermittedMBEparticipationevenbyMBEsthathavenopriorcontactwithKingCounty,theprogramwasoverbroadtothatextent.Id.Therefore,thecourtreversedthegrantofsummaryjudgmenttoKingCountyontheMBEprogramonthebasisthatitwasgeographicallyoverbroad.
Thecourtconsideredthegender‐specificaspectoftheMBEprogram.Thecourtdeterminedthedegreeofjudicialscrutinyaffordedgender‐consciousprogramswasintermediatescrutiny,ratherthanstrictscrutiny.Id.at930.Underintermediatescrutiny,gender‐basedclassificationmustserveanimportantgovernmentalobjective,andtheremustbeadirect,substantialrelationshipbetweentheobjectiveandthemeanschosentoaccomplishtheobjective.Id.at931.
Inthiscase,thecourtconcluded,thatKingCounty’sWBEpreferencesurvivedafacialchallenge.Id.at932.ThecourtfoundthatKingCountyhadalegitimateandimportantinterestinremedyingthemanydisadvantagesthatconfrontwomenbusinessownersandthatthemeanschosenintheprogramweresubstantiallyrelatedtotheobjective.Id.ThecourtfoundtherecordadequatelyindicateddiscriminationagainstwomenintheKingCountyconstructionindustry,notingtheanecdotalevidenceincludinganaffidavitofthepresidentofaconsultingengineeringfirm.Id.at933.Therefore,thecourtupheldtheWBEportionoftheMBEprogramandaffirmedthedistrictcourt’sgrantofsummaryjudgmenttoKingCountyfortheWBEprogram.
![Page 242: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/242.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 116
Recent District Court Decisions
13. Kossman Contracting Co., Inc. v. City of Houston, 2016 WL 1104363 (S.D. Tex. 2016).
PlaintiffKossmanisacompanyengagedinthebusinessofprovidingerosioncontrolservicesandismajorityownedbyawhitemale.2016WL1104363at*1.KossmanbroughtthisactionasanequalprotectionchallengetotheCityofHouston’sMinorityandWomenOwnedBusinessEnterprise(“MWBE”)program.Id.TheMWBEprogramthatischallengedhasbeenineffectsince2013andsetsa34percentMWBEgoalforconstructionprojects.Id.Houstonsetthisgoalbasedonadisparitystudyissuedin2012.Id.Thestudyanalyzedthestatusofminority‐ownedandwomen‐ownedbusinessenterprisesinthegeographicandproductmarketsofHouston’sconstructioncontracts.Id.
KossmanallegesthattheMWBEprogramisunconstitutionalonthegroundthatitdeniesnon‐MWBEsequalprotectionofthelaw,andassertsthatithaslostbusinessasaresultoftheMWBEprogrambecauseprimecontractorsareunwillingtosubcontractworktoanon‐MWBEfirmlikeKossman.Id.at*1.Kossmanfiledamotionforsummaryjudgment;HoustonfiledamotiontoexcludethetestimonyofKossman’sexpert;andHoustonfiledamotionforsummaryjudgment.Id.
ThedistrictcourtreferredthesemotionstotheMagistrateJudge.TheMagistrateJudge,onFebruary17,2016,issueditsMemorandum&RecommendationtothedistrictcourtinwhichitfoundthatHouston’smotiontoexcludeKossman’sexpertshouldbegrantedbecausetheexpertarticulatednomethodandhadnotraininginstatisticsoreconomicsthatwouldallowhimtocommentonthevalidityofthedisparitystudy.Id.at*1TheMagistrateJudgealsofoundthattheMWBEprogramwasconstitutionalunderstrictscrutiny,exceptwithrespecttotheinclusionofNative‐American‐ownedbusinesses.Id.TheMagistrateJudgefoundtherewasinsufficientevidencetoestablishaneedforremedialactionforbusinessesownedbyNativeAmericans,butfoundtherewassufficientevidencetojustifyremedialactionandinclusionofotherracialandethnicminoritiesandwomen‐ownedbusinesses.Id.
AftertheMagistrateJudgeissueditsMemorandum&Recommendation,Kossmanfiledobjections,whichthedistrictcourtsubsequentlyinitsorderadoptingMemorandum&Recommendation,decidedonMarch22,2016,affirmedandadoptedtheMemorandum&RecommendationofthemagistratejudgeandoverruledtheobjectionsbyKossman.Id.at*2.
District court order adopting Memorandum & Recommendation of Magistrate Judge.
Dun & Bradstreet underlying data properly withheld and Kossman’s proposed expert properly
excluded.ThedistrictcourtfirstrejectedKossman’sobjectionthattheCityofHoustonimproperlywithheldtheDun&Bradstreetdatathatwasutilizedinthedisparitystudy.Thisrulingwasinconnectionwiththedistrictcourt’saffirmingthedecisionoftheMagistrateJudgegrantingthemotionofHoustontoexcludethetestimonyofKossman’sproposedexpert.KossmanhadconcededthattheMagistrateJudgecorrectlydeterminedthatKossman’sproposedexpertarticulatednomethodandreliedonuntestedhypotheses.Id.at*2.Kossmanalsoacknowledgedthattheexpertwasunabletoproducedatatoconfrontthedisparitystudy.Id.
![Page 243: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/243.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 117
KossmanhadallegedthatHoustonwithheldtheunderlyingdatafromDun&Bradstreet.ThecourtfoundthatunderthecontractualagreementbetweenHoustonanditsconsultant,theconsultantforHoustonhadalicensingagreementwithDun&BradstreetthatprohibiteditfromprovidingtheDun&Bradstreetdatatoanythird‐party.Id.at*2.Inaddition,thecourtagreedwithHoustonthatKossmanwouldnotbeabletoofferadmissibleanalysisoftheDun&Bradstreetdata,evenifithadaccesstothedata.Id.AstheMagistrateJudgepointedout,thecourtfoundKossman’sexperthadnotraininginstatisticsoreconomics,andthuswouldnotbequalifiedtointerprettheDun&Bradstreetdataorchallengethedisparitystudy’smethods.Id.Therefore,thecourtaffirmedthegrantofHouston’smotiontoexcludeKossman’sexpert.
Dun & Bradstreet data is reliable and accepted by courts; bidding data rejected as problematic.ThecourtrejectedKossman’sargumentthatthedisparitystudywasbasedoninsufficient,unverifiedinformationfurnishedbyothers,andrejectedKossman’sargumentthatbiddingdataisasuperiormeasureofdeterminingavailability.Id.at*3.
Thedistrictcourtheldthatbecausethedisparitystudyconsultantdidnotcollectthedata,butinsteadutilizeddatathatDun&Bradstreethadcollected,theconsultantcouldnotguaranteetheinformationitreliedonincreatingthestudyandrecommendations.Id.at*3.Theconsultant’srolewastoanalyzethatdataandmakerecommendationsbasedonthatanalysis,andithadnoreasontodoubttheauthenticityoraccuracyoftheDun&Bradstreetdata,norhadKossmanpresentedanyevidencethatwouldcallthatdataintoquestion.Id.AsHoustonpointedout,Dun&Bradstreetdataisextremelyreliable,isfrequentlyusedindisparitystudies,andhasbeenconsistentlyacceptedbycourtsthroughoutthecountry.Id.
KossmanpresentednoevidenceindicatingthatbiddingdataisacomparablymoreaccurateindicatorofavailabilitythantheDun&Bradstreetdata,butratherKossmanreliedonpureargument.Id.at*3.ThecourtagreedwiththeMagistrateJudgethatbiddingdataisinherentlyproblematicbecauseitreflectsonlythosefirmsactuallysolicitedforbids.Id.Therefore,thecourtfoundthebiddingdatawouldfailtoidentifythosefirmsthatwerenotsolicitedforbidsduetodiscrimination.Id.
The anecdotal evidence is valid and reliable.ThedistrictcourtrejectedKossman’sargumentthatthestudyimproperlyreliedonanecdotalevidence,inthattheevidencewasunreliableandunverified.Id.at*3.Thedistrictcourtheldthatanecdotalevidenceisavalidsupplementtothestatisticalstudy.Id.TheMWBEprogramissupportedbybothstatisticalandanecdotalevidence,andanecdotalevidenceprovidesavaluablenarrativeperspectivethatstatisticsalonecannotprovide.Id.
ThedistrictcourtalsofoundthatHoustonwasnotrequiredtoindependentlyverifytheanecdotes.Id.at*3.Kossman,thedistrictcourtconcluded,couldhavepresentedcontraryevidence,butitdidnot.Id.Thedistrictcourtcitedothercourtsforthepropositionthatthecombinationofanecdotalandstatisticalevidenceispotent,andthatanecdotalevidenceisnothingmorethanawitness’snarrativeofanincidenttoldfromthewitness’sperspectiveandincludingthewitness’sperceptions.Id.Also,thecourtheldthecitywasnotrequiredtopresentcorroboratingevidence,andtheplaintiffwasfreetopresentitsownwitnesstoeitherrefutetheincidentdescribedbythecity’switnessesortorelatetheirownperceptionsondiscriminationintheconstructionindustry.Id.
![Page 244: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/244.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 118
The data relied upon by the study was not stale.ThecourtrejectedKossman’sargumentthatthestudyreliedondatathatistoooldandnolongerrelevant.Id.at*4.Thecourtfoundthatthedatawasnotstaleandthatthestudyusedthemostcurrentavailabledataatthetimeofthestudy,includingCensusBureaudata(2006‐2008)andFederalReservedata(1993,1998and2003),andthestudyperformedregressionanalysesonthedata.Id.
Moreover,KossmanpresentednoevidencetosuggestthatHouston’sconsultantcouldhaveaccessedmorerecentdataorthattheconsultantwouldhavereacheddifferentconclusionswithmorerecentdata.Id.
The Houston MWBE program is narrowly tailored.ThedistrictcourtagreedwiththeMagistrateJudgethatthestudyprovidedsubstantialevidencethatHoustonengagedinrace‐neutralalternatives,whichwereinsufficienttoeliminatedisparities,andthatdespiterace‐neutralalternativesinplaceinHouston,adversedisparitiesforMWBEswereconsistentlyobserved.Id.at*4.Therefore,thecourtfoundtherewasstrongevidencethataremedialprogramwasnecessarytoaddressdiscriminationagainstMWBEs.Id.Moreover,Houstonwasnotrequiredtoexhausteverypossiblerace‐neutralalternativebeforeinstitutingtheMWBEprogram.Id.
ThedistrictcourtalsofoundthattheMWBEprogramdidnotplaceanundueburdenonKossmanorsimilarlysituatedcompanies.Id.at*4.UndertheMWBEprogram,aprimecontractormaysubstituteasmallbusinessenterpriselikeKossmanforanMWBEonaraceandgender‐neutralbasisforuptofourpercentofthevalueofacontract.Id.KossmandidnotpresentevidencethatheeverbidonmorethanfourpercentofaHoustoncontract.Id.Inaddition,thecourtstatedthefacttheMWBEprogramplacedsomeburdenonKossmanisinsufficienttosupporttheconclusionthattheprogramisnotnearlytailored.Id.ThecourtconcurredwiththeMagistrateJudge’sobservationthattheproportionalsharingofopportunitiesis,atthecore,thepointofaremedialprogram.Id.ThedistrictcourtagreedwiththeMagistrateJudge’sconclusionthattheMWBEprogramisnearlytailored.
Native‐American‐owned businesses.ThestudyfoundthatNative‐American‐ownedbusinesseswereutilizedatahigherrateinHouston’sconstructioncontractsthanwouldbeanticipatedbasedontheirrateofavailabilityintherelevantmarketarea.Id.at*4.ThecourtnotedthisfindingwouldtendtonegatethepresenceofdiscriminationagainstNativeAmericansinHouston’sconstructionindustry.Id.
ThisHoustondisparitystudyconsultantstatedthatthehighutilizationrateforNativeAmericansstemslargelyfromtheworkoftwoNative‐American‐ownedfirms.Id.TheHoustonconsultantsuggestedthatwithoutthesetwofirms,theutilizationrateforNativeAmericanswoulddeclinesignificantly,yieldingastatisticallysignificantdisparityratio.Id.
TheMagistrateJudge,accordingtothedistrictcourt,correctlyheldandfoundthattherewasinsufficientevidencetosupportincludingNativeAmericansintheMWBEprogram.Id.ThecourtapprovedandadoptedtheMagistrateJudgeexplanationthattheopinionofthedisparitystudyconsultantthatasignificantstatisticaldisparitywouldexistiftwoofthecontractingNative‐American‐ownedbusinessesweredisregarded,isnotevidenceoftheneedforremedialaction.Id.at*5.Thedistrictcourtfoundnoequal‐protectionsignificancetothefactthemajorityofcontractslettoNative‐American‐ownedbusinessesweretoonlytwofirms.Id.Therefore,the
![Page 245: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/245.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 119
utilizationgoalforbusinessesownedbyNativeAmericansisnotsupportedbyastrongevidentiarybasis.Id.at*5.
ThedistrictcourtagreedwiththeMagistrateJudge’srecommendationthatthedistrictcourtgrantsummaryjudgmentinfavorofKossmanwithrespecttotheutilizationgoalforNative‐American‐ownedbusiness.Id.ThecourtfoundtherewaslimitedsignificancetotheHoustonconsultant’sopinionthatutilizationofNative‐American‐ownedbusinesseswoulddroptostatisticallysignificantlevelsiftwoNative‐American‐ownedbusinesseswereignored.Id.at*5.
ThecourtstatedthesituationpresentedbytheHoustondisparitystudyconsultantofa“hypotheticalnon‐existence”ofthesefirmsisnotevidenceandcannotsatisfystrictscrutiny.Id.at*5.Therefore,thedistrictcourtadoptedtheMagistrateJudge’srecommendationwithrespecttoexcludingtheutilizationgoalforNative‐American‐ownedbusinesses.Id.ThecourtnotedthatapreferenceforNative‐American‐ownedbusinessescouldbecomeconstitutionallyvalidinthefutureifthereweresufficientevidenceofdiscriminationagainstNative‐American‐ownedbusinessesinHouston’sconstructioncontracts.Id.at*5.
Conclusion.ThedistrictcourtheldthattheMemorandum&RecommendationoftheMagistrateJudgeisadoptedinfull;Houston’smotiontoexcludetheKossman’sproposedexpertwitnessisgranted;Kossman’smotionforsummaryjudgmentisgrantedwithrespecttoexcludingtheutilizationgoalforNative‐American‐ownedbusinessesanddeniedinallotherrespects;Houston’smotionforsummaryjudgmentisdeniedwithrespecttoincludingtheutilizationgoalforNative‐American‐ownedbusinessesandgrantedinallotherrespectsastotheMWBEprogramforotherminoritiesandwomen‐ownedfirms.Id.at*5.
Memorandum and Recommendation by Magistrate Judge, dated February 17, 2016, S.D.
Texas, Civil Action No. H‐14‐1203.
Kossman’s proposed expert excluded and not admissible.Kossmaninitsmotionforsummaryjudgmentsolelyreliedonthetestimonyofitsproposedexpert,andsubmittednootherevidenceinsupportofitsmotion.TheMagistrateJudge(hereinafter“MJ”)grantedHouston’smotiontoexcludetestimonyofKossman’sproposedexpert,whichthedistrictcourtadoptedandapproved,formultiplereasons.TheMJfoundthathisexperiencedoesnotincludedesigningorconductingstatisticalstudies,andhehasnoeducationortraininginstatisticsoreconomics.See,MJ,MemorandumandRecommendation(“M&R”)byMJ,datedFebruary17,2016,at31,S.D.Texas,CivilActionNo.H‐14‐1203.TheMJfoundhewasnotqualifiedtocollect,organizeorinterpretnumericaldata,hasnoexperienceextrapolatinggeneralconclusionsaboutasubsetofthepopulationbysamplingit,hasdemonstratednoknowledgeofsamplingmethodsorunderstandingofthemathematicalconceptsusedintheinterpretationofrawdata,andthus,isnotqualifiedtochallengethemethodsandcalculationsofthedisparitystudy.Id.
TheMJfoundthattheproposedexpertreportisonlyatheoreticalattackonthestudywithnobasisandobjectiveevidence,suchasdatarortestimonyofconstructionfirmsintherelativemarketareathatsupporthisassumptionsregardingavailableMWBEsorcomparativestudiesthatcontrolthefactorsaboutwhichhecomplained.Id.at31.TheMJstatedthattheproposedexpertisnotaneconomistandthusisnotqualifiedtochallengethedisparitystudyexplanationofitseconomicconsiderations.Id.at31.Theproposedexpertfailedtoprovideeconometricsupportfortheuseofbidderdata,whichhearguedwasthebettersourcefordetermining
![Page 246: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/246.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 120
availability,citednopersonalexperiencefortheuseofbidderdata,andprovidednoproofthatwouldmoreaccuratelyreflectavailabilityofMWBEsabsentdiscriminatoryinfluence.Id.Moreover,heacknowledgedthatnobidderdatahadbeencollectedfortheyearscoveredbythestudy.Id.
Thecourtfoundthattheproposedexpertarticulatednomethodatalltodoadisparitystudy,butmerelyprovideduntestedhypotheses.Id.at33.Theproposedexpert’scriticismsofthestudy,accordingtotheMJ,werenotfoundedincitedprofessionalsocialscienceoreconometricstandards.Id.at33.TheMJconcludesthattheproposedexpertisnotqualifiedtooffertheopinionscontainedinhisreport,andthathisreportisnotrelevant,notreliable,and,therefore,notadmissible.Id.at34.
Relevant geographic market area.TheMJfoundthemarketareaofthedisparityanalysiswasgeographicallyconfinedtoareacodesinwhichthemajorityofthepubliccontractingconstructionfirmswerelocated.Id.at3‐4,51.Therelevantmarketarea,theMJsaid,wasweightedbyindustry,andthereforethestudylimitedtherelevantmarketareabygeographyandindustrybasedonHouston’spastyears’recordsfrompriorconstructioncontracts.Id.at3‐4,51.
Availability of MWBEs.TheMJconcludeddisparitystudiesthatcomparedtheavailabilityofMWBEsintherelevantmarketwiththeirutilizationinlocalpubliccontractinghavebeenwidelyrecognizedasstrongevidencetofindacompellinginterestbyagovernmentalentityformakingsurethatitspublicdollarsdonotfinanceracialdiscrimination.Id.at52‐53.Here,thestudydefinedthemarketareabyreviewingpastcontractinformation,anddefinedtherelevantmarketaccordingtotwocriticalfactors,geographyandindustry.Id.at3‐4,53.Thoseparameters,weightedbydollarsattributabletoeachindustry,wereusedtoidentifyforcomparisonMWBEsthatwereavailableandMWBEsthathadbeenutilizedinHouston’sconstructioncontractingoverthelastfiveandone‐halfyears.Id.at4‐6,53.Thestudyadjustedforownerlabormarketexperienceandeducationalattainmentinadditiontogeographiclocationandindustryaffiliation.Id.at6,53.
Kossmanproducednoevidencethattheavailabilityestimatewasinadequate.Id.at53.Plaintiff’scriticismsoftheavailabilityanalysis,includingforcapacity,thecourtstatedwasnotsupportedbyanycontraryevidenceorexpertopinion.Id.at53‐54.TheMJrejectedPlaintiff’sproposedexpert’ssuggestionthatanalysisofbidderdataisabetterwaytoidentifyMWBEs.Id.at54.TheMJnotedthatKossman’sproposedexpertpresentednocomparativeevidencebasedonbidderdata,andtheMJfoundthatbidderdatamayproduceavailabilitystatisticsthatareskewedbyactiveandpassivediscriminationinthemarket.Id.
Inadditiontobeingunderinclusiveduetodiscrimination,theMJsaidbidderdatamaybeoverinclusiveduetoinaccurateself‐evaluationbyfirmsofferingbidsdespitetheinabilitytofulfillthecontract.Id.at54.Itispossiblethatunqualifiedfirmswouldbeincludedintheavailabilityfiguresimplybecausetheybidonaparticularproject.Id.TheMJconcludedthatthelawdoesnotrequireanindividualizedapproachthatmeasureswhetherMWBEsarequalifiedonacontract‐by‐contractbasis.Id.at55.
![Page 247: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/247.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 121
Disparity analysis.ThestudyindicatedsignificantstatisticaladversedisparitiesastobusinessesownedbyAfricanAmericansandAsians,whichtheMJfoundprovidedaprimafaciecaseofastrongbasisinevidencethatjustifiedtheProgram’sutilizationgoalsforbusinessesownedbyAfricanAmericans,Asian‐PacificAmericans,andsubcontinentAsianAmericans.Id.at55.
ThedisparityanalysisdidnotreflectsignificantstatisticaldisparitiesastobusinessesownedbyHispanicAmericans,NativeAmericansornon‐minoritywomen.Id.at55‐56.TheMJfound,however,theevidenceofsignificantstatisticaladversedisparityintheutilizationofHispanic‐ownedbusinessesintheunremediated,privatesectormetHouston’sprimafacieburdenofproducingastrongevidentiarybasisforthecontinuedinclusionofbusinessesownedbyHispanicAmericans.Id.at56.TheMJsaidthedifferencebetweentheprivatesectorandHouston’sconstructioncontractingwasespeciallynotablebecausetheutilizationofHispanic‐ownedbusinessesbyHoustonhasbenefittedfromHouston’sremedialprogramformanyyears.Id.Withoutaremedialprogram,theMJstatedtheevidencesuggests,andnoevidencecontradicts,afindingthatutilizationwouldfallbacktoprivatesectorlevels.Id.
WithregardtobusinessesownedbyNativeAmericans,thestudyindicatedtheywereutilizedtoahigherpercentagethantheiravailabilityintherelevantmarketarea.Id.at56.AlthoughtheconsultantforHoustonsuggestedthatasignificantstatisticaldisparitywouldexistiftwoofthecontractingNative‐American‐ownedbusinessesweredisregarded,theMJfoundthatopinionisnotevidenceoftheneedforremedialaction.Id.at56.TheMJconcludedtherewasno‐equalprotectionsignificancetothefactthemajorityofcontractslettoNative‐American‐ownedbusinessesweretoonlytwofirms,whichwasindicatedbyHouston’sconsultant.Id.
Theutilizationofwomen‐ownedbusinesses(WBEs)declinedby50percentwhentheynolongerbenefittedfromremedialgoals.Id.at57.BecauseWBEswereeliminatedduringtheperiodstudied,thesignificanceofstatisticaldisparity,accordingtotheMJ,isnotreflectedinthenumbersfortheperiodasawhole.Id.at57.TheMJsaidduringthetimeWBEswerenotpartoftheprogram,thestatisticaldisparitybetweenavailabilityandutilizationwassignificant.Id.TheprecipitousdeclineintheutilizationofWBEsafterWBEswereeliminatedandthesignificantstatisticaldisparitywhenWBEsdidnotbenefitfrompreferentialtreatment,theMJfound,providedastrongbasisinevidenceforthenecessityofremedialaction.Id.at57.Kossman,theMJpointedout,offerednoevidenceofagender‐neutralreasonforthedecline.Id.
TheMJrejectedPlaintiff’sargumentthatprimecontractorandsubcontractordatashouldnothavebeencombined.Id.at57.TheMJsaidthatprimecontractorandsubcontractordataisnotrequiredtobeevaluatedseparately,butthattheevidenceshouldcontainreliablesubcontractordatatoindicatediscriminationbyprimecontractors.Id.at58.Here,thestudyidentifiedtheMWBEsthatcontractedwithHoustonbyindustryandthoseavailableintherelevantmarketbyindustry.Id.at58.Thedata,accordingtotheMJ,wasspecificandcomplete,andseparatelyconsideringprimecontractorsandsubcontractorsisnotonlyunnecessarybutmaybemisleading.Id.Theanecdotalevidenceindicatedthatconstructionfirmshadserved,ondifferentcontracts,inbothroles.Id.
TheMJstatedthelawrequiresthatthetargeteddiscriminationbeidentifiedwithparticularity,notthateveryinstanceofexplicitorimplicitdiscriminationbeexposed.Id.at58.Thestudy,theMJfound,definedtherelevantmarketatasufficientlevelofparticularitytoproduceevidenceof
![Page 248: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/248.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 122
pastdiscriminationinHouston’sawardingofconstructioncontractsandtoreachconstitutionallysoundresults.Id.
Anecdotal evidence.Kossmancriticizedtheanecdotalevidencewithwhichastudysupplementeditsstatisticalanalysisasnothavingbeenverifiedandinvestigated.Id.at58‐59.TheMJsaidthatKossmancouldhavepresenteditsownevidence,butdidnot.Id.at59.Kossmanpresentednocontrarybodyofanecdotalevidenceandpointedtonothingthatcalledintoquestionthespecificresultsofthemarketsurveysandfocusgroupsdoneinthestudy.Id.Thecourtrejectedanyrequirementthattheanecdotalevidencebeverifiedandinvestigated.Id.at59.
Regression analyses.Kossmanchallengedtheregressionanalysesdoneinthestudyofbusinessformation,earningsandcapitalmarkets.Id.at59.Kossmancriticizedtheregressionanalysesforfailingtopreciselypointtowheretheidentifieddiscriminationwasoccurring.Id.TheMJfoundthatthefocusonidentifyingwherediscriminationisoccurringmissesthepoint,asregressionanalysesisnotintendedtopointtospecificsourcesofdiscrimination,buttoeliminatefactorsotherthandiscriminationthatmightexplaindisparities.Id.at59‐60.Discrimination,theMJsaid,isnotrevealedthroughevidenceofexplicitdiscrimination,butisrevealedthroughunexplainabledisparity.Id.at60.
TheMJnotedthatdatausedintheregressionanalyseswerethemostcurrentavailabledataatthetime,andforthemostpartdatadatedfromwithinacoupleofyearsorlessofthestartofthestudyperiod.Id.at60.Again,theMJstated,Kossmanproducednoevidencethatthedataonwhichtheregressionanalyseswerebasedwereinvalid.Id.
Narrow Tailoring factors.TheMJfoundthattheHoustonMWBEprogramsatisfiedthenarrowtailoringprongofastrictscrutinyanalysis.TheMJsaidthatthe2013MWBEprogramcontainedavarietyofrace‐neutralremedies,includingmanyeducationalopportunities,butthattheevidenceoftheirefficacyorlackthereofisfoundinthedisparityanalyses.Id.at60‐61.TheMJconcludedthatwhiletherace‐neutralremediesmayhaveapositiveeffect,theyhavenoteliminatedthediscrimination.Id.at61.TheMJfoundHouston’srace‐neutralprogrammingsufficienttosatisfytherequirementsofnarrowtailoring.Id.
Astothefactorsofflexibilityanddurationofthe2013Program,theMJalsostatedtheseaspectssatisfynarrowtailoring.Id.at61.The2013Programemploysgoalsasopposedtoquotas,setsgoalsonacontract‐by‐contractbasis,allowssubstitutionofsmallbusinessenterprisesforMWBEsforuptofourpercentofthecontract,includesaprocessforallowinggood‐faithwaivers,andbuildsindueprocessforsuspensionsofcontractorswhofailtomakegood‐faitheffortstomeetcontractgoalsorMWSBEsthatfailtomakegood‐faitheffortstomeetallparticipationrequirements.Id.at61.Houstoncommittedtoreviewthe2013Programatleasteveryfiveyears,whichtheMJfoundtobeareasonablybriefdurationperiod.Id.
TheMJconcludedthatthe34percentannualgoalisproportionaltotheavailabilityofMWBEshistoricallysufferingdiscrimination.Id.at61.Finally,theMJfoundthattheeffectofthe2013Programonthirdpartiesisnotsogreatastoimposeanunconstitutionalburdenonnon‐minorities.Id.at62.Theburdenonnon‐minoritySBEs,suchasKossman,islessenedbythe4percentsubstitutionprovision.Id.at62.TheMJnotedanotherdistrictcourt’sopinionthatthe
![Page 249: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/249.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 123
merepossibilitythatinnocentpartieswillsharetheburdenofaremedialprogramisitselfinsufficienttowarranttheconclusionthattheprogramisnotnarrowlytailored.Id.at62.
Holding.TheMJheldthatHoustonestablishedaprimafaciecaseofcompellinginterestandnarrowtailoringforallaspectsoftheMWBEprogram,exceptgoalsforNative‐American‐ownedbusinesses.Id.at62.TheMJalsoheldthatPlaintifffailedtoproduceanyevidence,muchlessthegreaterweightofevidence,thatwouldcallintoquestiontheconstitutionalityofthe2013MWBEprogram.Id.at62.
14. H. B. Rowe Corp., Inc. v. W. Lyndo Tippett, North Carolina DOT, et al., 589 F. Supp.2d 587 (E.D.N.C. 2008), affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remanded, 615 F.3d 233 (4th Cir. 2010)
InH.B.RoweCompanyv.Tippett,NorthCarolinaDepartmentofTransportation,etal.(“Rowe”),theUnitedStatesDistrictCourtfortheEasternDistrictofNorthCarolina,WesternDivision,heardachallengetotheStateofNorthCarolinaMBEandWBEProgram,whichisaStateofNorthCarolina“affirmativeaction”programadministeredbytheNCDOT.TheNCDOTMWBEProgramchallengedinRoweinvolvesprojectsfundedsolelybytheStateofNorthCarolinaandnotfundedbytheUSDOT.589F.Supp.2d587.
Background. Inthiscaseplaintiff,afamily‐ownedroadconstructionbusiness,bidonaNCDOTinitiatedstate‐fundedproject.NCDOTrejectedplaintiff’sbidinfavorofthenextlowbidthathadproposedhigherminorityparticipationontheprojectaspartofitsbid.AccordingtoNCDOT,plaintiff’sbidwasrejectedbecauseofplaintiff’sfailuretodemonstrate“goodfaithefforts”toobtainpre‐designatedlevelsofminorityparticipationontheproject.
Asaprimecontractor,plaintiffRowewasobligatedundertheMWBEProgramtoeitherobtainparticipationofspecifiedlevelsofMBEandWBEparticipationassubcontractors,ortodemonstrategoodfaitheffortstodoso.Forthisparticularproject,NCDOThadsetMBEandWBEsubcontractorparticipationgoalsof10percentand5percent,respectively.Plaintiff’sbidincluded6.6percentWBEparticipation,butnoMBEparticipation.Thebidwasrejectedafterareviewofplaintiff’sgoodfaitheffortstoobtainMBEparticipation.Thenextlowestbiddersubmittedabidincluding3.3percentMBEparticipationand9.3percentWBEparticipation,andalthoughnotobtainingaspecifiedlevelofMBEparticipation,itwasdeterminedtohavemadegoodfaitheffortstodoso.(OrderoftheDistrictCourt,datedMarch29,2007).
NCDOT’sMWBEProgram“largelymirrors”theFederalDBEProgram,whichNCDOTisrequiredtocomplywithinawardingconstructioncontractsthatutilizeFederalfunds.(589F.Supp.2d587;OrderoftheDistrictCourt,datedSeptember28,2007).LiketheFederalDBEProgram,underNCDOT’sMWBEProgram,thegoalsforminorityandfemaleparticipationareaspirationalratherthanmandatory.Id.AnindividualtargetforMBEparticipationwassetforeachproject.Id.
Historically,NCDOThadengagedinseveraldisparitystudies.Themostrecentstudywasdonein2004.Id.The2004study,whichfollowedthestudyin1998,concludedthatdisparitiesinutilizationofMBEspersistandthatabasisremainsforcontinuationoftheMWBEProgram.Thenewstatuteasrevisedwasapprovedin2006,whichmodifiedthepreviousMBEstatutebyeliminatingthe10percentand5percentgoalsandestablishingafixedexpirationdateof2009.
![Page 250: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/250.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 124
Plaintifffileditscomplaintinthiscasein2003againsttheNCDOTandindividualsassociatedwiththeNCDOT,includingtheSecretaryofNCDOT,W.LyndoTippett.Initscomplaint,plaintiffallegedthattheMWBEstatuteforNCDOTwasunconstitutionalonitsfaceandasapplied.589F.Supp.2d587.
March 29, 2007 Order of the District Court. Themattercamebeforethedistrictcourtinitiallyonseveralmotions,includingthedefendants’MotiontoDismissorforPartialSummaryJudgment,defendants’MotiontoDismisstheClaimforMootnessandplaintiff’sMotionforSummaryJudgment.ThecourtinitsOctober2007Ordergrantedinpartanddeniedinpartdefendants’MotiontoDismissorforpartialsummaryjudgment;denieddefendants’MotiontoDismisstheClaimforMootness;anddismissedwithoutprejudiceplaintiff’sMotionforSummaryJudgment.
ThecourtheldtheEleventhAmendmenttotheUnitedStatesConstitutionbarsplaintifffromobtaininganyreliefagainstdefendantNCDOT,andfromobtainingaretrospectivedamagesawardagainstanyoftheindividualdefendantsintheirofficialcapacities.Thecourtruledthatplaintiff’sclaimsforreliefagainsttheNCDOTwerebarredbytheEleventhAmendment,andtheNCDOTwasdismissedfromthecaseasadefendant.Plaintiff’sclaimsforinterest,actualdamages,compensatorydamagesandpunitivedamagesagainsttheindividualdefendantssuedintheirofficialcapacitiesalsowasheldbarredbytheEleventhAmendmentandweredismissed.But,thecourtheldthatplaintiffwasentitledtosueforaninjunctiontopreventstateofficersfromviolatingafederallaw,andundertheExParteYoungexception,plaintiff’sclaimfordeclaratoryandinjunctivereliefwaspermittedtogoforwardasagainsttheindividualdefendantswhowereactinginanofficialcapacitywiththeNCDOT.Thecourtalsoheldthattheindividualdefendantswereentitledtoqualifiedimmunity,andthereforedismissedplaintiff’sclaimformoneydamagesagainsttheindividualdefendantsintheirindividualcapacities.OrderoftheDistrictCourt,datedMarch29,2007.
DefendantsarguedthattherecentamendmenttotheMWBEstatuterenderedplaintiff’sclaimfordeclaratoryinjunctivereliefmoot.ThenewMWBEstatuteadoptedin2006,accordingtothecourt,doesawaywithmanyoftheallegedshortcomingsarguedbytheplaintiffinthislawsuit.Thecourtfoundtheamendedstatutehasasunsetdatein2009;specificaspirationalparticipationgoalsbywomenandminoritiesareeliminated;defines“minority”asincludingonlythoseracialgroupswhichdisparitystudiesidentifyassubjecttounderutilizationinstateroadconstructioncontracts;explicitlyreferencesthefindingsofthe2004DisparityStudyandrequiressimilarstudiestobeconductedatleastonceeveryfiveyears;anddirectsNCDOTtoenactregulationstargetingdiscriminationidentifiedinthe2004andfuturestudies.
Thecourtheld,however,thatthe2004DisparityStudyandamendedMWBEstatutedonotremedytheprimaryproblemwhichtheplaintiffcomplainedof:theuseofremedialrace‐andgender‐basedpreferencesallegedlywithoutvalidevidenceofpastracialandgenderdiscrimination.Inthatsense,thecourtheldtheamendedMWBEstatutecontinuedtopresentalivecaseorcontroversy,andaccordinglydeniedthedefendants’MotiontoDismissClaimforMootnessastoplaintiff’ssuitforprospectiveinjunctiverelief.OrderoftheDistrictCourt,datedMarch29,2007.
![Page 251: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/251.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 125
ThecourtalsoheldthatsincetherehadbeennoanalysisoftheMWBEstatuteapartfromthebriefsregardingmootness,plaintiff’spendingMotionforSummaryJudgmentwasdismissedwithoutprejudice.OrderoftheDistrictCourt,datedMarch29,2007.
September 28, 2007 Order of the District Court. OnSeptember28,2007,thedistrictcourtissuedaneworderinwhichitdeniedboththeplaintiff’sandthedefendants’MotionsforSummaryJudgment.Plaintiffclaimedthatthe2004DisparityStudyisthesolebasisoftheMWBEstatute,thatthestudyisflawed,andthereforeitdoesnotsatisfythefirstprongofstrictscrutinyreview.Plaintiffalsoarguedthatthe2004studytendstoprovenon‐discriminationinthecaseofwomen;andfinallytheMWBEProgramfailsthesecondprongofstrictscrutinyreviewinthatitisnotnarrowlytailored.
Thecourtfoundsummaryjudgmentwasinappropriateforeitherpartyandthattherearegenuineissuesofmaterialfactfortrial.Thefirstandforemostissueofmaterialfact,accordingtothecourt,wastheadequacyofthe2004DisparityStudyasusedtojustifytheMWBEProgram.Therefore,becausethecourtfoundtherewasagenuineissueofmaterialfactregardingthe2004Study,summaryjudgmentwasdeniedonthisissue.
ThecourtalsoheldtherewasconfusionastothebasisoftheMWBEProgram,andwhetheritwasbasedsolelyonthe2004Studyoralsoonthe1993and1998DisparityStudies.Therefore,thecourtheldagenuineissueofmaterialfactexistedonthisissueanddeniedsummaryjudgment.OrderoftheDistrictCourt,datedSeptember28,2007.
December 9, 2008 Order of the District Court (589 F.Supp.2d 587). ThedistrictcourtonDecember9,2008,afterabenchtrial,issuedanOrderthatfoundasafactandconcludedasamatteroflawthatplaintifffailedtosatisfyitsburdenofproofthattheNorthCarolinaMinorityandWomen’sBusinessEnterpriseprogram,enactedbythestatelegislaturetoaffecttheawardingofcontractsandsubcontractsinstatehighwayconstruction,violatedtheUnitedStatesConstitution.
Plaintiff,initscomplaintfiledagainsttheNCDOTallegedthatN.C.Gen.St.§136‐28.4isunconstitutionalonitsfaceandasapplied,andthattheNCDOTwhileadministeringtheMWBEprogramviolatedplaintiff’srightsunderthefederallawandtheUnitedStatesConstitution.PlaintiffrequestedadeclaratoryjudgmentthattheMWBEprogramisinvalidandsoughtactualandpunitivedamages.
Asaprimecontractor,plaintiffwasobligatedundertheMWBEprogramtoeitherobtainparticipationofspecifiedlevelsofMBEandWBEsubcontractors,ortodemonstratethatgoodfaitheffortsweremadetodoso.Followingareviewofplaintiff’sgoodfaitheffortstoobtainminorityparticipationontheparticularcontractthatwasthesubjectofplaintiff’sbid,thebidwasrejected.Plaintiff’sbidwasrejectedinfavorofthenextlowestbid,whichhadproposedhigherminorityparticipationontheprojectaspartofitsbid.AccordingtoNCDOT,plaintiff’sbidwasrejectedbecauseofplaintiff’sfailuretodemonstrategoodfaitheffortstoobtainpre‐designatedlevelsofminorityparticipationontheproject.589F.Supp.2d587.
North Carolina’s MWBE program. TheMWBEprogramwasimplementedfollowingamendmentstoN.C.Gen.Stat.§136‐28.4.Pursuanttothedirectivesofthestatute,theNCDOTpromulgated
![Page 252: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/252.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 126
regulationsgoverningadministrationoftheMWBEprogram.SeeN.C.Admin.Codetit.19A,§2D.1101,etseq.TheregulationshadbeenamendedseveraltimesandprovidethatNCDOTshallensurethatMBEsandWBEshavethemaximumopportunitytoparticipateintheperformanceofcontractsfinancedwithnon‐federalfunds.N.C.Admin.CodeTit.19A§2D.1101.
NorthCarolina’sMWBEprogram,whichaffectedonlyhighwaybidsandcontractsfundedsolelywithstatemoney,accordingtothedistrictcourt,largelymirroredtheFederalDBEProgramwhichNCDOTisrequiredtocomplywithinawardingconstructioncontractsthatutilizefederalfunds.589F.Supp.2d587.LiketheFederalDBEProgram,underNorthCarolina’sMWBEprogram,thetargetsforminorityandfemaleparticipationwereaspirationalratherthanmandatory,andindividualtargetsfordisadvantagedbusinessparticipationweresetforeachindividualproject.N.C.Admin.Codetit.19A§2D.1108.IndeterminingwhatlevelofMBEandWBEparticipationwasappropriateforeachproject,NCDOTwouldtakeintoaccount“theapproximatedollarvalueofthecontract,thegeographicallocationoftheproposedwork,anumberoftheeligiblefundsinthegeographicalarea,andtheanticipatedvalueoftheitemsofworktobeincludedinthecontract.”Id.NCDOTwouldalsoconsider“theannualgoalsmandatedbyCongressandtheNorthCarolinaGeneralAssembly.”Id.
AfirmcouldbecertifiedasaMBEorWBEbyshowingNCDOTthatitis“ownercontrolledbyoneormoresociallyandeconomicallydisadvantagedindividuals.”NCAdmin.Codetit.1980,§2D.1102.
ThedistrictcourtstatedtheMWBEprogramdidnotdirectlydiscriminateinfavorofminorityandwomencontractors,butrather“encouragedprimecontractorstofavorMBEsandWBEsinsubcontractingbeforesubmittingbidstoNCDOT.”589F.Supp.2d587.Indeterminingwhetherthelowestbidderis“responsible,”NCDOTwouldconsiderwhetherthebidderobtainedthelevelofcertifiedMBEandWBEparticipationpreviouslyspecifiedintheNCDOTprojectproposal.Ifnot,NCDOTwouldconsiderwhetherthebiddermadegoodfaitheffortstosolicitMBEandWBEparticipation.N.C.Admin.Codetit.19A§2D.1108.
ThereweremultiplestudiesproducedandpresentedtotheNorthCarolinaGeneralAssemblyintheyears1993,1998and2004.The1998and2004studiesconcludedthatdisparitiesintheutilizationofminorityandwomencontractorspersist,andthatthereremainsabasisforcontinuationoftheMWBEprogram.TheMWBEprogramasamendedafterthe2004studyincludesprovisionsthateliminatedthe10percentand5percentgoalsandinsteadreplacedthemwithcontract‐specificparticipationgoalscreatedbyNCDOT;establishedasunsetprovisionthathasthestatuteexpiringonAugust31,2009;andprovidesrelianceonadisparitystudyproducedin2004.
TheMWBEprogram,asitstoodatthetimeofthisdecision,providesthatNCDOT“dictatestoprimecontractorstheexpressgoalofMBEandWBEsubcontractorstobeusedonagivenproject.However,insteadofthestatehiringtheMBEandWBEsubcontractorsitself,theNCDOTmakestheprimecontractorsolelyresponsibleforvettingandhiringthesesubcontractors.Ifaprimecontractorfailstohirethegoalamount,itmustsubmiteffortsof‘goodfaith’attemptstodoso.”589F.Supp.2d587.
![Page 253: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/253.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 127
Compelling interest. ThedistrictcourtheldthatNCDOTestablishedacompellinggovernmentalinteresttohavetheMWBEprogram.ThecourtnotedthattheUnitedStatesSupremeCourtinCrosonmadeclearthatastatelegislaturehasacompellinginterestineradicatingandremedyingprivatediscriminationintheprivatesubcontractinginherentinthelettingofroadconstructioncontracts.589F.Supp.2d587,citingCroson,488U.S.at492.ThedistrictcourtfoundthattheNorthCarolinaLegislatureestablisheditrelieduponastrongbasisofevidenceinconcludingthatpriorracediscriminationinNorthCarolina’sroadconstructionindustryexistedsoastorequireremedialaction.
Thecourtheldthatthe2004DisparityStudydemonstratedtheexistenceofpreviousdiscriminationinthespecificindustryandlocalityatissue.Thecourtstatedthatdisparityratiosprovidedforinthe2004DisparityStudyhighlightedtheunderutilizationofMBEsbyprimecontractorsbiddingonstatefundedhighwayprojects.Inaddition,thecourtfoundthatevidencerelieduponbythelegislaturedemonstratedadramaticdeclineintheutilizationofMBEsduringtheprogram’ssuspensionin1991.ThecourtalsofoundthatanecdotalsupportrelieduponbythelegislatureconfirmedandreinforcedthegeneraldatademonstratingtheunderutilizationofMBEs.ThecourtheldthattheNCDOTestablishedthat,“baseduponaclearandstronginferenceraisedbythisStudy,theyconcludedminoritycontractorssufferfromthelingeringeffectsofracialdiscrimination.”589F.Supp.2d587.
WithregardtoWBEs,thecourtappliedadifferentstandardofreview.ThecourtheldthelegislativeschemeasitrelatestoMWBEsmustserveanimportantgovernmentalinterestandmustbesubstantiallyrelatedtotheachievementofthoseobjectives.ThecourtfoundthatNCDOTestablishedanimportantgovernmentalinterest.The2004DisparityStudyprovidedthattheaveragecontractsawardedWBEsaresignificantlysmallerthanthoseawardednon‐WBEs.ThecourtheldthatNCDOTestablishedbaseduponaclearandstronginferenceraisedbytheStudy,womencontractorssufferfrompastgenderdiscriminationintheroadconstructionindustry.
Narrowly tailored. ThedistrictcourtnotedthattheFourthCircuitofAppealslistsanumberoffactorstoconsiderinanalyzingastatutefornarrowtailoring:(1)thenecessityofthepolicyandtheefficacyofalternativeraceneutralpolicies;(2)theplanneddurationofthepolicy;(3)therelationshipbetweenthenumericalgoalandthepercentageofminoritygroupmembersintherelevantpopulation;(4)theflexibilityofthepolicy,includingtheprovisionofwaiversifthegoalcannotbemet;and(5)theburdenofthepolicyoninnocentthirdparties.589F.Supp.2d587,quotingBelkv.Charlotte‐MecklenburgBoardofEducation,269F.3d305,344(4thCir.2001).
ThedistrictcourtheldthatthelegislativeschemeinN.C.Gen.Stat.§136‐28.4isnarrowlytailoredtoremedyprivatediscriminationofminoritiesandwomenintheprivatesubcontractinginherentinthelettingofroadconstructioncontracts.Thedistrictcourt’sanalysisfocusedonnarrowlytailoringfactors(2)and(4)above,namelythedurationofthepolicyandtheflexibilityofthepolicy.Withrespecttotheformer,thecourtheldthelegislativeschemeprovidestheprogrambereviewedatleasteveryfiveyearstorevisittheissueofutilizationofMWBEsintheroadconstructionindustry.N.C.Gen.Stat.§136‐28.4(b).Further,thelegislativeschemeincludesasunsetprovisionsothattheprogramwillexpireonAugust31,2009,unlessrenewedbyanactofthelegislature.Id.at§136‐28.4(e).Thecourtheldtheseprovisionsensuredthelegislativeschemelastnolongerthannecessary.
![Page 254: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/254.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 128
ThecourtalsofoundthatthelegislativeschemeenactedbytheNorthCarolinalegislatureprovidesflexibilityinsofarastheparticipationgoalsforagivencontractordeterminedonaprojectbyprojectbasis.§136‐28.4(b)(1).Additionally,thecourtfoundthelegislativeschemeinquestionisnotoverbroadbecausethestatuteappliesonlyto“thoseracialorethnicityclassificationsidentifiedbyastudyconductedinaccordancewiththissectionthathadbeensubjectedtodiscriminationinarelevantmarketplaceandthathadbeenadverselyaffectedintheirabilitytoobtaincontractswiththeDepartment.”§136‐28.4(c)(2).Thecourtfoundthatplaintifffailedtoprovideanyevidencethatindicatesminoritiesfromnon‐relevantracialgroupshadbeenawardedcontractsasaresultofthestatute.
Thecourtheldthatthelegislativeschemeisnarrowlytailoredtoremedyprivatediscriminationofminoritiesandwomenintheprivatesubcontractinginherentinthelettingofroadconstructioncontracts,andthereforefoundthat§136‐28.4isconstitutional.
ThedecisionofthedistrictcourtwasappealedtotheUnitedStatesCourtofAppealsfortheFourthCircuit,whichaffirmedinpartandreversedinpartthedecisionofthedistrictcourt.See615F3d233(4thCir.2010),discussedabove.
15. Thomas v. City of Saint Paul, 526 F. Supp.2d 959 (D. Minn 2007), affirmed, 321 Fed. Appx. 541, 2009 WL 777932 (8th Cir. March 26, 2009) (unpublished opinion), cert. denied, 130 S.Ct. 408 (2009)
InThomasv.CityofSaintPaul,theplaintiffsareAfricanAmericanbusinessownerswhobroughtthislawsuitclaimingthattheCityofSaintPaul,Minnesotadiscriminatedagainsttheminawardingpublicly‐fundedcontracts.TheCitymovedforsummaryjudgment,whichtheUnitedStatesDistrictCourtgrantedandissuedanorderdismissingtheplaintiff’slawsuitinDecember2007.
ThebackgroundofthecaseinvolvestheadoptionbytheCityofSaintPaulofaVendorOutreachProgram(“VOP”)thatwasdesignedtoassistminorityandothersmallbusinessownersincompetingforCitycontracts.PlaintiffswereVOP‐certifiedminoritybusinessowners.PlaintiffscontendedthattheCityengagedinraciallydiscriminatoryillegalconductinawardingCitycontractsforpublicly‐fundedprojects.PlaintiffThomasclaimedthattheCitydeniedhimopportunitiestoworkonprojectsbecauseofhisracearguingthattheCityfailedtoinvitehimtobidoncertainprojects,theCityfailedtoawardhimcontractsandthefactindependentdevelopershadnotcontractedwithhiscompany.526F.Supp.2dat962.TheCitycontendedthatThomaswasprovidedopportunitiestobidfortheCity’swork.
PlaintiffBrianConoverownedatruckingfirm,andheclaimedthatnoneofhisbidsasasubcontractoron22differentprojectstovariousindependentdeveloperswereaccepted.526F.Supp.2dat962.Thecourtfoundthatafteryearsofdiscovery,plaintiffConoverofferednoadmissibleevidencetosupporthisclaim,hadnotidentifiedthesubcontractorswhosebidswereaccepted,anddidnotofferanycomparisonshowingtheacceptedbidandthebidhesubmitted.Id.PlaintiffConoveralsocomplainedthathereceivedbiddinginvitationsonlyafewdaysbeforeabidwasdue,whichdidnotallowhimadequatetimetoprepareacompetitivebid.Id.Thecourtfound,however,hefailedtoidentifyanyparticularprojectforwhichhehadonlyasingledayofbid,anddidnotidentifyanysimilarlysituatedpersonofanyracewhowasaffordedalonger
![Page 255: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/255.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 129
periodoftimeinwhichtosubmitabid.Id.at963.PlaintiffNewellclaimedhesubmittednumerousbidsontheCity’sprojectsallofwhichwererejected.Id.Thecourtfound,however,thatheprovidednospecificsaboutwhyhedidnotreceivethework.Id.
The VOP. UndertheVOP,theCitysetsannualbenchmarksorlevelsofparticipationforthetargetedminoritiesgroups.Id.at963.TheVOPprohibitsquotasandimposesvarious“goodfaith”requirementsonprimecontractorswhobidforCityprojects.Id.at964.Inparticular,theVOPrequiresthatwhenaprimecontractorrejectsabidfromaVOP‐certifiedbusiness,thecontractormustgivetheCityitsbasisfortherejection,andevidencethattherejectionwasjustified.Id.TheVOPfurtherimposesobligationsontheCitywithrespecttovendorcontracts.Id.ThecourtfoundtheCitymustseekwherepossibleandlawfultoawardaportionofvendorcontractstoVOP‐certifiedbusinesses.Id.TheCitycontractmanagermustsolicitthesebidsbyphone,advertisementinalocalnewspaperorothermeans.Whereapplicable,thecontractmanagermayassistinterestedVOPparticipantsinobtainingbonds,linesofcreditorinsurancerequiredtoperformunderthecontract.Id.TheVOPordinanceprovidesthatwhenthecontractmanagerengagesinoneormorepossibleoutreachefforts,heorsheisincompliancewiththeordinance.Id.
Analysis and Order of the Court. ThedistrictcourtfoundthattheCityisentitledtosummaryjudgmentbecauseplaintiffslackstandingtobringtheseclaimsandthatnogenuineissueofmaterialfactremains.Id.at965.ThecourtheldthattheplaintiffshadnostandingtochallengetheVOPbecausetheyfailedtoshowtheyweredeprivedofanopportunitytocompete,orthattheirinabilitytoobtainanycontractresultedfromanactofdiscrimination.Id.Thecourtfoundtheyfailedtoshowanyinstanceinwhichtheirracewasadeterminantinthedenialofanycontract.Id.at966.Asaresult,thecourtheldplaintiffsfailedtodemonstratetheCityengagedindiscriminatoryconductorpolicywhichpreventedplaintiffsfromcompeting.Id.at965‐966.
Thecourtheldthatintheabsenceofanyshowingofintentionaldiscriminationbasedonrace,themerefacttheCitydidnotawardanycontractstoplaintiffsdoesnotfurnishthatcausalnexusnecessarytoestablishstanding.Id.at966.ThecourtheldthelawdoesnotrequiretheCitytovoluntarilyadopt“aggressiverace‐basedaffirmativeactionprograms”inordertoawardspecificgroupspublicly‐fundedcontracts.Id.at966.ThecourtfoundthatplaintiffshadfailedtoshowaviolationoftheVOPordinance,oranyillegalpolicyoractiononthepartoftheCity.Id.
Thecourtstatedthattheplaintiffsmustidentifyadiscriminatorypolicyineffect.Id.at966.Thecourtnoted,forexample,evenassumingtheCityfailedtogiveplaintiffsmorethanoneday’snoticetoenterabid,suchafailureisnot,perse,illegal.Id.Thecourtfoundtheplaintiffsofferednoevidencethatanyoneelseofanyotherracereceivedanearliernotice,orthathewasgiventhisallegedlytardynoticeasaresultofhisrace.Id.
ThecourtconcludedthatevenifplaintiffsmaynothavebeenhiredasasubcontractortoworkforprimecontractorsreceivingCitycontracts,thesewereindependentdevelopersandtheCityisnotrequiredtodefendtheallegedbadactsofothers.Id.Therefore,thecourtheldplaintiffshadnostandingtochallengetheVOP.Id.at966.
Plaintiff’s claims. Thecourtfoundthatevenassumingplaintiffspossessedstanding,theyfailedtoestablishfactswhichdemonstratedaneedforatrial,primarilybecauseeachtheoryof
![Page 256: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/256.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 130
recoveryisviableonlyiftheCity“intentionally”treatedplaintiffsunfavorablybecauseoftheirrace.Id.at967.Thecourtheldtoestablishaprimafacieviolationoftheequalprotectionclause,theremustbestateaction.Id.Plaintiffsmustofferfactsandevidencethatconstituteproofof“raciallydiscriminatoryintentorpurpose.”Id.at967.Here,thecourtfoundthatplaintifffailedtoallegeanysingleinstanceshowingtheCity“intentionally”rejectedVOPbidsbasedontheirrace.Id.
Thecourtalsofoundthatplaintiffsofferednoevidenceofaspecifictimewhenanyoneofthemsubmittedthelowestbidforacontractorasubcontract,orshowedanycasewheretheirbidswererejectedonthebasisofrace.Id.Thecourtheldtheallegedfailuretoplaceminoritycontractorsinapreferredposition,withoutmore,isinsufficienttosupportafindingthattheCityfailedtotreatthemequallybasedupontheirrace.Id.
TheCityrejectedtheplaintiff’sclaimsofdiscriminationbecausetheplaintiffsdidnotestablishbyevidencethattheCity“intentionally”rejectedtheirbidduetoraceorthattheCity“intentionally”discriminatedagainsttheseplaintiffs.Id.at967‐968.ThecourtheldthattheplaintiffsdidnotestablishasingleinstanceshowingtheCitydeprivedthemoftheirrights,andtheplaintiffsdidnotproduceevidenceofa“discriminatorymotive.”Id.at968.ThecourtconcludedthatplaintiffshadfailedtoshowthattheCity’sactionswere“raciallymotivated.”Id.
TheEighthCircuitCourtofAppealsaffirmedtherulingofthedistrictcourt.Thomasv.CityofSaintPaul,2009WL777932(8thCir.2009)(unpublishedopinion).TheEighthCircuitaffirmedbasedonthedecisionofthedistrictcourtandfindingnoreversibleerror.
16. Thompson Building Wrecking Co. v. Augusta, Georgia, No. 1:07CV019, 2007 WL 926153 (S.D. Ga. Mar. 14, 2007)(Slip. Op.)
ThiscaseconsideredthevalidityoftheCityofAugusta’slocalminorityDBEprogram.ThedistrictcourtenjoinedtheCityfromfavoringanycontractbidonthebasisofracialclassificationandbaseditsdecisionprincipallyupontheoutdatedandinsufficientdataprofferedbytheCityinsupportofitsprogram.2007WL926153at*9‐10.
TheCityofAugustaenactedalocalDBEprogrambasedupontheresultsofadisparitystudycompletedin1994.Thedisparitystudyexaminedthedisparityinsocioeconomicstatusamongraces,comparedblack‐ownedbusinessesinAugustawiththoseinotherregionsandthoseownedbyotherracialgroups,examined“Georgia’sracisthistory”incontractingandprocurement,andexaminedcertaindatarelatedtoAugusta’scontractingandprocurement.Id.at*1‐4.TheplaintiffcontractorsandsubcontractorschallengedtheconstitutionalityoftheDBEprogramandsoughttoextendatemporaryinjunctionenjoiningtheCity’simplementationofracialpreferencesinpublicbiddingandprocurement.
TheCitydefendedtheDBEprogramarguingthatitdidnotutilizeracialclassificationsbecauseitonlyrequiredvendorstomakea“goodfaitheffort”toensureDBEparticipation.Id.at*6.Thecourtrejectedthisargumentnotingthatbidderswererequiredtosubmita“ProposedDBEParticipation”formandthatbidscontainingDBEparticipationweretreatedmorefavorablythanthosebidswithoutDBEparticipation.Thecourtstated:“Becauseaperson’sbusinesscanqualify
![Page 257: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/257.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 131
forthefavorabletreatmentbasedonthatperson’srace,whileasimilarlysituatedpersonofanotherracewouldnotqualify,theprogramcontainsaracialclassification.”Id.
ThecourtnotedthattheDBEprogramharmedsubcontractorsintwoways:first,becauseprimecontractorswilldiscriminatebetweenDBEandnon‐DBEsubcontractorsandabidwithaDBEsubcontractorwouldbetreatedmorefavorably;andsecond,becausetheCitywouldfavorabidcontainingDBEparticipationoveranequalorevensuperiorbidcontainingnoDBEparticipation.Id.
ThecourtappliedthestrictscrutinystandardsetforthinCrosonandEngineeringContractorsAssociationtodeterminewhethertheCityhadacompellinginterestforitsprogramandwhethertheprogramwasnarrowlytailoredtothatend.ThecourtnotedthatpursuanttoCroson,theCitywouldhaveacompellinginterestinassuringthattaxdollarswouldnotperpetuateprivateprejudice.But,thecourtfound(citingtoCroson),thatastateorlocalgovernmentmustidentifythatdiscrimination,“publicorprivate,withsomespecificitybeforetheymayuserace‐consciousrelief.”ThecourtcitedtheEleventhCircuit’spositionthat“‘grossstatisticaldisparities’betweentheproportionofminoritieshiredbythepublicemployerandtheproportionofminoritieswillingandabletowork”mayjustifyanaffirmativeactionprogram.Id.at*7.Thecourtalsostatedthatanecdotalevidenceisrelevanttotheanalysis.
ThecourtdeterminedthatwhiletheCity’sdisparitystudyshowedsomestatisticaldisparitiesbuttressedbyanecdotalevidence,thestudysufferedfrommultipleissues.Id.at*7‐8.Specifically,thecourtfoundthatthoseportionsofthestudyexaminingdiscriminationoutsidetheareaofsubcontracting(e.g.,socioeconomicstatusofracialgroupsintheAugustaarea)wereirrelevantforpurposesofshowingacompellinginterest.Thecourtalsocitedthefailureofthestudytodifferentiatebetweendifferentminorityracesaswellastheimproperaggregationofrace‐andgender‐baseddiscriminationreferredtoasSimpson’sParadox.
ThecourtassumedforpurposesofitsanalysisthattheCitycouldshowacompellinginterestbutconcludedthattheprogramwasnotnarrowlytailoredandthuscouldnotsatisfystrictscrutiny.Thecourtfoundthatitneedlooknofurtherbeyondthefactofthethirteen‐yeardurationoftheprogramabsentfurtherinvestigation,andtheabsenceofasunsetorexpirationprovision,toconcludethattheDBEprogramwasnotnarrowlytailored.Id.at*8.Notingthataffirmativeactionispermittedonlysparingly,thecourtfound:“[i]twouldbeimpossibleforAugustatoarguethat,13yearsafterlaststudyingtheissue,racialdiscriminationissorampantintheAugustacontractingindustrythattheCitymustaffirmativelyacttoavoidbeingcomplicit.”Id.Thecourtheldinconclusion,thattheplaintiffswere“substantiallylikelytosucceedinprovingthat,whentheCityrequestsbidswithminorityparticipationandinfactfavorsbidswithsuch,theplaintiffswillsufferracialdiscriminationinviolationoftheEqualProtectionClause.”Id.at*9.
InasubsequentOrderdatedSeptember5,2007,thecourtdeniedtheCity’smotiontocontinueplaintiff’sMotionforSummaryJudgment,deniedtheCity’sRule12(b)(6)motiontodismiss,andstayedtheactionfor30dayspendingmediationbetweentheparties.Importantly,inthisOrder,thecourtreiteratedthatthefemale‐andlocally‐ownedbusinesscomponentsoftheprogram(challengedinplaintiff’sMotionforSummaryJudgment)wouldbesubjecttointermediatescrutinyandrationalbasisscrutiny,respectively.Thecourtalsoreiterateditsrejectionofthe
![Page 258: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/258.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 132
City’schallengetotheplaintiffs’standing.ThecourtnotedthatunderAdarand,preventingacontractorfromcompetingonanequalfootingsatisfiestheparticularizedinjuryprongofstanding.AndshowingthatthecontractorwillsometimeinthefuturebidonaCitycontract“thatoffersfinancialincentivestoaprimecontractorforhiringdisadvantagedsubcontractors”satisfiesthesecondrequirementthattheparticularizedinjurybeactualorimminent.Accordingly,thecourtconcludedthattheplaintiffshavestandingtopursuethisaction.
17. Hershell Gill Consulting Engineers, Inc. v. Miami‐Dade County, 333 F. Supp.2d 1305 (S.D. Fla. 2004)
ThedecisioninHershellGillConsultingEngineers,Inc.v.Miami‐DadeCounty,issignificanttothedisparitystudybecauseitappliedandfollowedtheEngineeringContractorsAssociationdecisioninthecontextofcontractingandprocurementforgoodsandservices(includingarchitectandengineerservices).Manyoftheothercasesfocusedonconstruction,andthusHershellGillisinstructiveastotheanalysisrelatingtoarchitectandengineeringservices.ThedecisioninHershellGillalsoinvolvedadistrictcourtintheEleventhCircuitimposingcompensatoryandpunitivedamagesuponindividualCountyCommissionersduetothedistrictcourt’sfindingoftheirwillfulfailuretoabrogateanunconstitutionalMBE/WBEProgram.Inaddition,thecaseisnoteworthybecausethedistrictcourtrefusedtofollowthe2003TenthCircuitCourtofAppealsdecisioninConcreteWorksofColorado,Inc.v.CityandCountyofDenver,321.3d950(10thCir.2003).Seediscussion,infra.
SixyearsafterthedecisioninEngineeringContractorsAssociation,twowhitemale‐ownedengineeringfirms(the“plaintiffs”)broughtsuitagainstEngineeringContractorsAssociation(the“County”),theformerCountyManager,andvariouscurrentCountyCommissioners(the“Commissioners”)intheirofficialandpersonalcapacities(collectivelythe“defendants”),seekingtoenjointhesame“participationgoals”inthesameMWBEprogramdeemedtoviolatetheFourteenthAmendmentintheearliercase.333F.Supp.1305,1310(S.D.Fla.2004).AftertheEleventhCircuit’sdecisioninEngineeringContractorsAssociationstrikingdowntheMWBEprogramsasappliedtoconstructioncontracts,theCountyenactedaCommunitySmallBusinessEnterprise(“CSBE”)programforconstructioncontracts,“butcontinuedtoapplyracial,ethnic,andgendercriteriatoitspurchasesofgoodsandservicesinotherareas,includingitsprocurementofA&Eservices.”Id.at1311.
TheplaintiffsbroughtsuitchallengingtheBlackBusinessEnterprise(BBE)program,theHispanicBusinessEnterprise(HBE)program,andtheWomenBusinessEnterprise(WBE)program(collectively“MBE/WBE”).Id.TheMBE/WBEprogramsappliedtoA&Econtractsinexcessof$25,000.Id.at1312.TheCountyestablishedfive“contractmeasures”toreachtheparticipationgoals:(1)setasides,(2)subcontractorgoals,(3)projectgoals,(4)bidpreferences,and(5)selectionfactors.Id.Onceacontractwasidentifiedascoveredbyaparticipationgoal,areviewcommitteewoulddeterminewhetheracontractmeasureshouldbeutilized.Id.TheCountywasrequiredtoreviewtheefficacyoftheMBE/WBEprogramsannually,andreevaluatedthecontinuingviabilityoftheMBE/WBEprogramseveryfiveyears.Id.at1313.However,thedistrictcourtfound“theparticipationgoalsforthethreeMBE/WBEprogramschallenged…remainedunchangedsince1994.”Id.
![Page 259: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/259.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 133
In1998,counselforplaintiffscontactedtheCountyCommissionersrequestingthediscontinuationofcontractmeasuresonA&Econtracts.Id.at1314.UponrequestoftheCommissioners,thecountymanagerthenmadetworeports(anoriginalandafollow‐up)measuringparityintermsofdollarsawardedanddollarspaidintheareasofA&Eforblacks,Hispanics,andwomen,andconcludedbothtimesthatthe“Countyhasreachedparityforblack,Hispanic,andWomen‐ownedfirmsintheareasof[A&E]services.”Thefinalreportfurtherstated“Basedonalltheanalysesthathavebeenperformed,theCountydoesnothaveabasisfortheestablishmentofparticipationgoalswhichwouldallowstafftoapplycontractmeasures.”Id.at1315.ThedistrictcourtalsofoundthattheCommissionerswereinformedthat“therewasevenlessevidencetosupport[theMBE/WBE]programsasappliedtoarchitectsandengineersthentherewasincontractconstruction.”Id.Nonetheless,theCommissionersvotedtocontinuetheMBE/WBEparticipationgoalsattheirpreviouslevels.Id.
InMayof2000(18monthsafterthelawsuitwasfiled),theCountycommissionedDr.ManuelJ.Carvajal,aneconometrician,tostudyarchitectsandengineersinthecounty.Hisfinalreporthadfourparts:
(1)dataidentificationandcollectionofmethodologyfordisplayingtheresearchresults;(2)presentationanddiscussionoftablespertainingtoarchitecture,civilengineering,structuralengineering,andawardsofcontractsinthoseareas;(3)analysisofthestructureandempiricalestimatesofvarioussetsofregressionequations,thecalculationofcorrespondingindices,andanassessmentoftheirimportance;and(4)aconclusionthatthereisdiscriminationagainstwomenandHispanics—butnotagainstblacks—inthefieldsofarchitectureandengineering.
Id.ThedistrictcourtissuedapreliminaryinjunctionenjoiningtheuseoftheMBE/WBEprogramsforA&Econtracts,pendingtheUnitedStatesSupremeCourtdecisionsinGratzv.Bollinger,539U.S.244(2003)andGrutterv.Bollinger,539U.S.306(2003).Id.at1316.
ThecourtconsideredwhethertheMBE/WBEprogramswereviolativeofTitleVIIoftheCivilRightsAct,andwhethertheCountyandtheCountyCommissionerswereliableforcompensatoryandpunitivedamages.
ThedistrictcourtfoundthattheSupremeCourtdecisionsinGratzandGrutterdidnotaltertheconstitutionalanalysisassetforthinAdarandandCroson.Id.at1317.Accordingly,therace‐andethnicity‐basedclassificationsweresubjecttostrictscrutiny,meaningtheCountymustpresent“astrongbasisofevidence”indicatingtheMBE/WBEprogramwasnecessaryandthatitwasnarrowlytailoredtoitspurportedpurpose.Id.at1316.Thegender‐basedclassificationsweresubjecttointermediatescrutiny,requiringtheCountytoshowthe“gender‐basedclassificationservesanimportantgovernmentalobjective,andthatitissubstantiallyrelatedtotheachievementofthatobjective.”Id.at1317(internalcitationsomitted).Thecourtfoundthattheproponentofagender‐basedaffirmativeactionprogrammustpresent“sufficientprobativeevidence”ofdiscrimination.Id.(internalcitationsomitted).Thecourtfoundthatundertheintermediatescrutinyanalysis,theCountymust(1)demonstratepastdiscriminationagainstwomenbutnotnecessarilyatthehandsoftheCounty,and(2)thatthegender‐consciousaffirmativeactionprogramneednotbeusedonlyasa“lastresort.”Id.
![Page 260: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/260.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 134
TheCountypresentedbothstatisticalandanecdotalevidence.Id.at1318.ThestatisticalevidenceconsistedofDr.Carvajal’sreport,mostofwhichconsistedof“post‐enactment”evidence.Id.Dr.Carvajal’sanalysissoughttodiscovertheexistenceofracial,ethnicandgenderdisparitiesintheA&Eindustry,andthentodeterminewhetheranysuchdisparitiescouldbeattributedtodiscrimination.Id.Thestudyusedfourdatasets:threeweredesignedtoestablishthemarketplaceavailabilityoffirms(architecture,structuralengineering,andcivilengineering),andthefourthfocusedonawardsissuedbytheCounty.Id.Dr.Carvajalusedthephonebook,alistcompiledbyinfoUSA,andalistoffirmsregisteredfortechnicalcertificationwiththeCounty’sDepartmentofPublicWorkstocompilealistofthe“universe”offirmscompetinginthemarket.Id.Forthearchitecturalfirmsonly,healsousedalistoffirmsthathadbeenissuedanarchitectureprofessionallicense.Id.
Dr.Carvajalthenconductedaphonesurveyoftheidentifiedfirms.Basedonhisdata,Dr.CarvajalconcludedthatdisparitiesexistedbetweenthepercentageofA&Efirmsownedbyblacks,Hispanics,andwomen,andthepercentageofannualbusinesstheyreceived.Id.Dr.Carvajalconductedregressionanalyses“inordertodeterminetheeffectafirmowner’sgenderorracehadoncertaindependentvariables.”Id.Dr.Carvajalusedthefirm’sannualvolumeofbusinessasadependentvariableanddeterminedthedisparitiesweredueineachcasetothefirm’sgenderand/orethnicclassification.Id.at1320.Healsoperformedvariantstotheequationsincluding:(1)usingcertificationratherthansurveydatafortheexperience/capacityindicators,(2)withtheoutliersdeleted,(3)withpublicly‐ownedfirmsdeleted,(4)withthedummyvariablesreversed,and(5)usingonlycurrentlycertifiedfirms.”Id.Dr.Carvajal’sresultsremainedsubstantiallyunchanged.Id.
Basedonhisanalysisofthemarketplacedata,Dr.Carvajalconcludedthatthe“grossstatisticaldisparities”intheannualbusinessvolumeforHispanic‐andwomen‐ownedfirmscouldbeattributedtodiscrimination;he“didnotfindsufficientevidenceofdiscriminationagainstblacks.”Id.
ThecourtheldthatDr.Carvajal’sstudyconstitutedneithera“strongbasisinevidence”ofdiscriminationnecessarytojustifyrace‐andethnicity‐consciousmeasures,nordiditconstitute“sufficientprobativeevidence”necessarytojustifythegender‐consciousmeasures.Id.ThecourtmadeaninitialfindingthatnodisparityexistedtoindicateunderutilizationofMBE/WBEsintheawardofA&EcontractsbytheCounty,norwasthereunderutilizationofMBE/WBEsinthecontractstheywereawarded.Id.Thecourtfoundthatananalysisoftheawarddataindicated,“[i]fanything,thedataindicatesanoverutilizationofminority‐ownedfirmsbytheCountyinrelationtotheirnumbersinthemarketplace.”Id.
Withrespecttothemarketplacedata,theCountyconcededthattherewasinsufficientevidenceofdiscriminationagainstblackstosupporttheBBEprogram.Id.at1321.WithrespecttothemarketplacedataforHispanicsandwomen,thecourtfoundit“unreliableandinaccurate”forthreereasons:(1)thedatafailedtoproperlymeasurethegeographicmarket,(2)thedatafailedtoproperlymeasuretheproductmarket,and(3)themarketplacesurveywasunreliable.Id.at1321‐25.
ThecourtruledthatitwouldnotfollowtheTenthCircuitdecisionofConcreteWorksofColorado,Inc.v.CityandCountyofDenver,321F.3d950(10thCir.2003),astheburdenofproofenunciated
![Page 261: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/261.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 135
bytheTenthCircuitconflictswiththatoftheEleventhCircuit,andthe“TenthCircuit’sdecisionisflawedforthereasonsarticulatedbyJusticeScaliainhisdissentfromthedenialofcertiorari.”Id.at1325(internalcitationsomitted).
ThedefendantintervenorspresentedanecdotalevidencepertainingonlytodiscriminationagainstwomenintheCounty’sA&Eindustry.Id.TheanecdotalevidenceconsistedofthetestimonyofthreeA&Eprofessionalwomen,“nearlyall”ofwhichwasrelatedtodiscriminationintheawardofCountycontracts.Id.at1326.However,thedistrictcourtfoundthattheanecdotalevidencecontradictedDr.Carvajal’sstudyindicatingthatnodisparityexistedwithrespecttotheawardofCountyA&Econtracts.Id.
ThecourtquotedtheEleventhCircuitinEngineeringContractorsAssociationfortheproposition“thatonlyintherarecasewillanecdotalevidencesufficestandingalone.”Id.(internalcitationsomitted).Thecourtheldthat“[t]hisisnotoneofthoserarecases.”Thedistrictcourtconcludedthatthestatisticalevidencewas“unreliableandfail[ed]toestablishtheexistenceofdiscrimination,”andtheanecdotalevidencewasinsufficientasitdidnotevenreachthelevelofanecdotalevidenceinEngineeringContractorsAssociationwheretheCountyemployeesthemselvestestified.Id.
ThecourtmadeaninitialfindingthatanumberofminoritygroupsprovidedpreferentialtreatmentwereinfactmajoritiesintheCountyintermsofpopulation,votingcapacity,andrepresentationontheCountyCommission.Id.at1326‐1329.Forpurposesonlyofconductingthestrictscrutinyanalysis,thecourtthenassumedthatDr.Carvajal’sreportdemonstrateddiscriminationagainstHispanics(notetheCountyhadconcededithadinsufficientevidenceofdiscriminationagainstblacks)andsoughttodeterminewhethertheHBEprogramwasnarrowlytailoredtoremedyingthatdiscrimination.Id.at1330.However,thecourtfoundthatbecausethestudyfailedto“identifywhoisengaginginthediscrimination,whatformthediscriminationmighttake,atwhatstageintheprocessitistakingplace,orhowthediscriminationisaccomplished…itisvirtuallyimpossibletonarrowlytailoranyremedy,andtheHBEprogramfailsonthisfactalone.”Id.
ThecourtfoundthatevenaftertheCountyManagersinformedtheCommissionersthattheCountyhadreachedparityintheA&Eindustry,theCommissionersdeclinedtoenactaCSBEordinance,arace‐neutralmeasureutilizedintheconstructionindustryafterEngineeringContractorsAssociation.Id.Instead,theCommissionersvotedtocontinuetheHBEprogram.Id.ThecourtheldthattheCounty’sfailuretoevenexploreaprogramsimilartotheCSBEordinanceindicatedthattheHBEprogramwasnotnarrowlytailored.Id.at1331.
ThecourtalsofoundthattheCountyenactedabroadanti‐discriminationordinanceimposingharshpenaltiesforaviolationthereof.Id.However,“notasinglewitnessattrialknewofanyinstanceofacomplaintbeingbroughtunderthisordinanceconcerningtheA&Eindustry,”leadingthecourttoconcludethattheordinancewaseithernotbeingenforced,ornodiscriminationexisted.Id.Undereitherscenario,theHBEprogramcouldnotbenarrowlytailored.Id.
ThecourtfoundthewaiverprovisionsintheHBEprograminflexibleinpractice.Id.Additionally,thecourtfoundtheCountyhadfailedtocomplywiththeprovisionsintheHBEprogram
![Page 262: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/262.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 136
requiringadjustmentofparticipationgoalsbasedonannualstudies,becausetheCountyhadnotinfactconductedannualstudiesforseveralyears.Id.Thecourtfoundthiseven“moreproblematic”becausetheHBEprogramdidnothaveabuilt‐indurationallimit,andthusblatantlyviolatedSupremeCourtjurisprudencerequiringthatracialandethnicpreferences“mustbelimitedintime.”Id.at1332,citingGrutter,123S.Ct.at2346.Fortheforegoingreasons,thecourtconcludedtheHBEprogramwasnotnarrowlytailored.Id.at1332.
WithrespecttotheWBEprogram,thecourtfoundthat“thefailureoftheCountytoidentifywhoisdiscriminatingandwhereintheprocessthediscriminationistakingplaceindicates(thoughnotconclusively)thattheWBEprogramisnotsubstantiallyrelatedtoeliminatingthatdiscrimination.”Id.at1333.Thecourtfoundthattheexistenceoftheanti‐discriminationordinance,therefusaltoenactasmallbusinessenterpriseordinance,andtheinflexibilityinsettingtheparticipationgoalsrenderedtheWBEprogramunabletosatisfythesubstantialrelationshiptest.Id.
ThecourtheldthattheCountywasliableforanycompensatorydamages.Id.at1333‐34.ThecourtheldthattheCommissionershadabsoluteimmunityfortheirlegislativeactions;however,theywerenotentitledtoqualifiedimmunityfortheiractionsinvotingtoapplytherace‐,ethnicity‐,andgender‐consciousmeasuresoftheMBE/WBEprogramsiftheiractionsviolated“clearlyestablishedstatutoryorconstitutionalrightsofwhichareasonablepersonwouldhaveknown…Accordingly,thequestioniswhetherthestateofthelawatthetimetheCommissionersvotedtoapply[race‐,ethnicity‐,andgender‐consciousmeasures]gavethem‘fairwarning’thattheiractionswereunconstitutional.“Id.at1335‐36(internalcitationsomitted).
ThecourtheldthattheCommissionerswerenotentitledtoqualifiedimmunitybecausethey“hadbeforethematleastthreecasesthatgavethemfairwarningthattheirapplicationoftheMBE/WBEprograms…wereunconstitutional:Croson,Adarandand[EngineeringContractorsAssociation].”Id.at1137.ThecourtfoundthattheCommissionersvotedtoapplythecontractmeasuresaftertheSupremeCourtdecidedbothCrosonandAdarand.Id.Moreover,theEleventhCircuithadalreadystruckdowntheconstructionprovisionsofthesameMBE/WBEprograms.Id.Thus,thecaselawwas“clearlyestablished”andgavetheCommissionersfairwarningthattheMBE/WBEprogramswereunconstitutional.Id.
ThecourtalsofoundtheCommissionershadspecificinformationfromtheCountyManagerandotherinternalstudiesindicatingtheproblemswiththeMBE/WBEprogramsandindicatingthatparityhadbeenachieved.Id.at1338.Additionally,theCommissionersdidnotconducttheannualstudiesmandatedbytheMBE/WBEordinanceitself.Id.Foralltheforegoingreasons,thecourtheldtheCommissionersweresubjecttoindividualliabilityforanycompensatoryandpunitivedamages.
ThedistrictcourtenjoinedtheCounty,theCommissioners,andtheCountyManagerfromusing,orrequiringtheuseof,gender,racial,orethniccriteriaindeciding(1)whetheraresponsetoanRFPsubmittedforA&Eworkisresponsive,(2)whethersucharesponsewillbeconsidered,and(3)whetheracontractwillbeawardedtoaconsultantsubmittingsucharesponse.Thecourtawardedtheplaintiffs$100eachinnominaldamagesandreasonableattorneys’feesandcosts,forwhichitheldtheCountyandtheCommissionersjointlyandseverallyliable.
![Page 263: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/263.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 137
18. Florida A.G.C. Council, Inc. v. State of Florida, 303 F. Supp.2d 1307 (N.D. Fla. 2004)
ThiscaseisinstructivetothedisparitystudyastothemannerinwhichdistrictcourtswithintheEleventhCircuitareinterpretingandapplyingEngineeringContractorsAssociation.Itisalsoinstructiveintermsofthetypeoflegislationtobeconsideredbythelocalandstategovernmentsastowhatthecourtsconsidertobea“race‐conscious”programand/orlegislation,aswellastothesignificanceoftheimplementationofthelegislationtotheanalysis.
Theplaintiffs,A.G.C.Council,Inc.andtheSouthFloridaChapteroftheAssociatedGeneralContractorsbroughtthiscasechallengingtheconstitutionalityofcertainprovisionsofaFloridastatute(Section287.09451,etseq.).TheplaintiffscontendedthatthestatuteviolatedtheEqualProtectionClauseoftheFourteenthAmendmentbyinstitutingrace‐andgender‐conscious“preferences”inordertoincreasethenumericrepresentationof“MBEs”incertainindustries.
Accordingtothecourt,theFloridaStatuteenactedrace‐consciousandgender‐consciousremedialprogramstoensureminorityparticipationinstatecontractsforthepurchaseofcommoditiesandinconstructioncontracts.TheStatecreatedtheOfficeofSupplierDiversity(“OSD”)toassistMBEstobecomesuppliersofcommodities,servicesandconstructiontothestategovernment.TheOSDhadcertainresponsibilities,includingadoptingrulesmeanttoassesswhetherstateagencieshavemadegoodfaitheffortstosolicitbusinessfromMBEs,andtomonitorwhethercontractorshavemadegoodfaitheffortstocomplywiththeobjectiveofgreateroverallMBEparticipation.
Thestatuteenumeratedmeasuresthatcontractorsshouldundertake,suchasminority‐centeredrecruitmentinadvertisingasameansofadvancingthestatute’spurpose.ThestatuteprovidedthateachStateagencyis“encouraged”tospend21percentofthemoniesactuallyexpendedforconstructioncontracts,25percentofthemoniesactuallyexpendedforarchitecturalandengineeringcontracts,24percentofthemoniesactuallyexpendedforcommoditiesand50.5percentofthemoniesactuallyexpendedforcontractualservicesduringthefiscalyearforthepurposeofenteringintocontractswithcertifiedMBEs.ThestatutealsoprovidedthatstateagenciesareallowedtoallocatecertainpercentagesforblackAmericans,HispanicAmericansandforAmericanwomen,andthegoalsarebrokendownbyconstructioncontracts,architecturalandengineeringcontracts,commoditiesandcontractualservices.
TheStatetookthepositionthatthespendinggoalswere“precatory.”Thecourtfoundthattheplaintiffshadstandingtomaintaintheactionandtopursueprospectiverelief.Thecourtheldthatthestatutewasunconstitutionalbasedonthefindingthatthespendinggoalswerenotnarrowlytailoredtoachieveagovernmentalinterest.Thecourtdidnotspecificallyaddresswhetherthearticulatedreasonsforthegoalscontainedinthestatutehadsufficientevidence,butinsteadfoundthatthearticulatedreasonwould,“iftrue,”constituteacompellinggovernmentalinterestnecessitatingrace‐consciousremedies.Ratherthanexploretheevidence,thecourtfocusedonthenarrowlytailoredrequirementandheldthatitwasnotsatisfiedbytheState.
ThecourtfoundthattherewasnoevidenceintherecordthattheStatecontemplatedrace‐neutralmeanstoaccomplishtheobjectivessetforthinSection287.09451etseq.,suchas
![Page 264: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/264.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 138
“‘simplificationofbiddingprocedures,relaxationofbondingrequirements,trainingorfinancialaidfordisadvantagedentrepreneursofallraces[which]wouldopenthepubliccontractingmarkettoallthosewhohavesufferedtheeffectsofpastdiscrimination.’”FloridaA.G.C.Council,303F.Supp.2dat1315,quotingEng’gContractorsAss’n,122F.3dat928,quotingCroson,488U.S.at509‐10.
ThecourtnotedthatdefendantsdidnotseemtodisagreewiththereportissuedbytheStateofFloridaSenatethatconcludedtherewaslittleevidencetosupportthespendinggoalsoutlinedinthestatute.Rather,theStateofFloridaarguedthatthestatuteis“permissive.”Thecourt,however,heldthat“thereisnodistinctionbetweenastatutethatisprecatoryversusonethatiscompulsorywhenthechallengedstatute‘inducesanemployertohirewithaneyetowardmeeting…[a]numericaltarget.’FloridaA.G.C.Council,303F.Supp.2dat1316.
ThecourtfoundthattheStateappliespressuretoStateagenciestomeetthelegislativeobjectivesofthestatuteextendingbeyondsimpleoutreachefforts.TheStateagencies,accordingtothecourt,wererequiredtocoordinatetheirMBEprocurementactivitieswiththeOSD,whichincludesadoptingaMBEutilizationplan.IftheStateagencydeviatedfromtheutilizationplanintwoconsecutiveandthreeoutoffivetotalfiscalyears,thentheOSDcouldreviewanyandallsolicitationsandcontractawardsoftheagencyasdeemednecessaryuntilsuchtimeastheagencymetitsutilizationplan.Thecourtheldthatbasedonthesefactors,althoughallegedtobe“permissive,”thestatutetextuallywasnot.
Therefore,thecourtfoundthatthestatutewasnotnarrowlytailoredtoserveacompellinggovernmentalinterest,andconsequentlyviolatedtheEqualProtectionClauseoftheFourteenthAmendment.
19. The Builders Ass’n of Greater Chicago v. The City of Chicago, 298 F. Supp.2d 725 (N.D. Ill. 2003)
Thiscaseisinstructivebecauseofthecourt’sfocusandanalysisonwhethertheCityofChicago’sMBE/WBEprogramwasnarrowlytailored.Thebasisofthecourt’sholdingthattheprogramwasnotnarrowlytailoredisinstructiveforanyprogramconsideredbecauseofthereasonsprovidedastowhytheprogramdidnotpassmuster.
Theplaintiff,theBuildersAssociationofGreaterChicago,broughtthissuitchallengingtheconstitutionalityoftheCityofChicago’sconstructionMinority‐andWomen‐OwnedBusiness(“MWBE”)Program.ThecourtheldthattheCityofChicago’sMWBEprogramwasunconstitutionalbecauseitdidnotsatisfytherequirementthatitbenarrowlytailoredtoachieveacompellinggovernmentalinterest.Thecourtheldthatitwasnotnarrowlytailoredforseveralreasons,includingbecausetherewasno“meaningfulindividualizedreview”ofMBE/WBEs;ithadnoterminationdatenordidithaveanymeansfordeterminingatermination;the“graduation”revenueamountforfirmstograduateoutoftheprogramwasveryhigh,$27,500,000,andinfactveryfewfirmsgraduated;therewasnonetworththreshold;and,waiverswererarelyornevergrantedonconstructioncontracts.ThecourtfoundthattheCityprogramwasa“rigidnumericalquota,”notrelatedtothenumberofavailable,willingandablefirms.Formulisticpercentages,thecourtheld,couldnotsurvivethestrictscrutiny.
![Page 265: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/265.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 139
Thecourtheldthatthegoalsplandidnotaddressissuesraisedastodiscriminationregardingmarketaccessandcredit.Thecourtfoundthatagoalsprogramdoesnotdirectlyimpactprimecontractor’sselectionofsubcontractorsonnon‐goalsprivateprojects.Thecourtfoundthataset‐asideorgoalsprogramdoesnotdirectlyimpactdifficultiesinaccessingcredit,anddoesnotaddressdiscriminatoryloandenialsorhigherinterestrates.ThecourtfoundtheCityhasnotsoughttoattackdiscriminationbyprimesdirectly,“butitcould.”298F.2d725.“TomonitorpossiblediscriminatoryconductitcouldmaintainitscertificationlistandrequirethosecontractingwiththeCitytoconsiderunsolicitedbids,tomaintainbiddingrecords,andtojustifyrejectionofanycertifiedfirmsubmittingthelowestbid.ItcouldalsorequirefirmsseekingCityworktopostprivatejobsaboveacertainminimumonawebsiteorotherwiseprovidepublicnotice…”Id.
Thecourtconcludedthatotherrace‐neutralmeanswereavailabletoimpactcredit,highinterestrates,andotherpotentialmarketplacediscrimination.Thecourtpointedtorace‐neutralmeansincludinglinkeddeposits,withtheCitybankingatinstitutionsmakingloanstostartupandsmallerfirms.Otherrace‐neutralprogramsreferencedincludedquickpayandcontractdownsizing;restrictingself‐performancebyprimecontractors;adirectloanprogram;waiverofbondsoncontractsunder$100,000;abankparticipationloanprogram;a2percentlocalbusinesspreference;outreachprogramsandtechnicalassistanceandworkshops;andseminarspresentedtonewconstructionfirms.
Thecourtheldthatraceandethnicitydomatter,butthatracialandethnicclassificationsarehighlysuspect,canbeusedonlyasalastresort,andcannotbemadebysomemechanicalformulation.Therefore,thecourtconcludedtheCity’sMWBEProgramcouldnotstandinitspresentguise.Thecourtheldthatthepresentprogramwasnotnarrowlytailoredtoremedypastdiscriminationandthediscriminationdemonstratedtonowexist.
Thecourtenteredaninjunction,butdelayedtheeffectivedateforsixmonthsfromthedateofitsOrder,December29,2003.ThecourtheldthattheCityhada“compellinginterestinnothavingitsconstructionprojectsslipbacktonearmonopolydominationbywhitemalefirms.”Thecourtruledabriefcontinuationoftheprogramforsixmonthswasappropriate“astheCityrethinksthemanytoolsofredressithasavailable.”Subsequently,thecourtdeclaredunconstitutionaltheCity’sMWBEProgramwithrespecttoconstructioncontractsandpermanentlyenjoinedtheCityfromenforcingtheProgram.2004WL757697(N.D.Ill2004).
20. Associated Utility Contractors of Maryland, Inc. v. Mayor and City Council of Baltimore, 218 F. Supp.2d 749 (D. Md. 2002)
ThiscaseisinstructivebecausethecourtfoundtheExecutiveOrderoftheMayoroftheCityofBaltimorewasprecatoryinnature(creatingnolegalobligationorduty)andcontainednoenforcementmechanismorpenaltiesfornoncomplianceandimposednosubstantialrestrictions;theExecutiveOrderannouncedgoalsthatwerefoundtobeaspirationalonly.
TheAssociatedUtilityContractorsofMaryland,Inc.(“AUC”)suedtheCityofBaltimorechallengingitsordinanceprovidingforminorityandwomen‐ownedbusinessenterprise(“MWBE”)participationincitycontracts.Previously,anearlierCityofBaltimoreMWBEprogramwasdeclaredunconstitutional.AssociatedUtilityContractorsofMaryland,Inc.v.MayorandCity
![Page 266: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/266.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 140
CouncilofBaltimore,83F.Supp.2d613(D.Md.2000).TheCityadoptedanewordinancethatprovidedfortheestablishmentofMWBEparticipationgoalsonacontract‐by‐contractbasis,andmadeseveralotherchangesfromthepreviousMWBEprogramdeclaredunconstitutionalintheearliercase.
Inaddition,theMayoroftheCityofBaltimoreissuedanExecutiveOrderthatannouncedagoalofawarding35percentofallCitycontractingdollarstoMBE/WBEs.Thecourtfoundthisgoalof35percentparticipationwasaspirationalonlyandtheExecutiveOrdercontainednoenforcementmechanismorpenaltiesfornoncompliance.TheExecutiveOrderalsospecifiedmany“noncoercive”outreachmeasurestobetakenbytheCityagenciesrelatingtoincreasingparticipationofMBE/WBEs.Thesemeasureswerefoundtobemerelyaspirationalandnoenforcementmechanismwasprovided.
ThecourtaddressedinthiscaseonlyamotiontodismissfiledbytheCityofBaltimorearguingthattheAssociatedUtilityContractorshadnostanding.ThecourtdeniedthemotiontodismissholdingthattheassociationhadstandingtochallengethenewMBE/WBEordinance,althoughthecourtnotedthatithadsignificantissueswiththeAUChavingrepresentationalstandingbecauseofthenatureoftheMBE/WBEplanandthefacttheAUCdidnothaveanyofitsindividualmembersnamedinthesuit.ThecourtalsoheldthattheAUCwasentitledtobringanasappliedchallengetotheExecutiveOrderoftheMayor,butrejectedithavingstandingtobringafacialchallengebasedonafindingthatitimposesnorequirement,createsnosanctions,anddoesnotinflictaninjuryuponanymemberoftheAUCinanyconcreteway.Therefore,theExecutiveOrderdidnotcreatea“caseorcontroversy”inconnectionwithafacialattack.ThecourtfoundthewordingoftheExecutiveOrdertobeprecatoryandimposingnosubstantiverestrictions.
AfterthisdecisiontheCityofBaltimoreandtheAUCenteredintoasettlementagreementandadismissalwithprejudiceofthecase.AnorderwasissuedbythecourtonOctober22,2003dismissingthecasewithprejudice.
21. Associated Utility Contractors of Maryland, Inc. v. The Mayor and City Council of Baltimore and Maryland Minority Contractors Association, Inc., 83 F. Supp.2d 613 (D. Md. 2000)
PlaintiffAssociatedUtilityContractorsofMaryland,Inc.(“AUC”)filedthisactiontochallengethecontinuedimplementationoftheaffirmativeactionprogramcreatedbyBaltimoreCityOrdinance(“theOrdinance”).83F.Supp.2d613(D.Md.2000)
TheOrdinancewasenactedin1990andauthorizedtheCitytoestablishannuallynumericalset‐asidegoalsapplicabletoawiderangeofpubliccontracts,includingconstructionsubcontracts.Id.
AUCfiledamotionforsummaryjudgment,whichtheCityandinterveningdefendantMarylandMinorityContractorsAssociation,Inc.(“MMCA”)opposed.Id.at614.In1999,thecourtissuedanordergrantinginpartanddenyinginpartthemotionforsummaryjudgment(“theDecemberinjunction”).Id.Specifically,astoconstructioncontractsenteredintobytheCity,thecourtenjoinedenforcementoftheOrdinance(and,consequently,continuedimplementationofthe
![Page 267: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/267.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 141
affirmativeactionprogramitauthorized)inrespecttotheCity’s1999numericalset‐asidegoalsforMinority‐andWomen–OwnedBusinessEnterprises(“MWBEs”),whichhadbeenestablishedat20%and3%,respectively.Id.Thecourtdeniedthemotionforsummaryjudgmentastotheplaintiff’sfacialattackontheconstitutionalityoftheOrdinance,concludingthatthereexisted“adisputeofmaterialfactastowhethertheenactmentoftheOrdinancewasadequatelysupportedbyafactualrecordofunlawfuldiscriminationproperlyremediablethroughrace‐andgender‐basedaffirmativeaction.”Id.
TheCityappealedtheentryoftheDecemberinjunctiontotheUnitedStatesCourtofAppealsfortheFourthCircuit.Inaddition,theCityfiledamotionforstayoftheinjunction.Id.Insupportofthemotionforstay,theCitycontendedthatAUClackedorganizationalstandingtochallengetheOrdinance.Thecourtheldtheplaintiffsatisfiedtherequirementsfororganizationalstandingastotheset‐asidegoalsestablishedbytheCityfor1999.Id.
TheCityalsocontendedthatthecourterredinfailingtoforebearfromtheadjudicationofthiscaseandofthemotionforsummaryjudgmentuntilafterithadcompletedanallegeddisparitystudywhich,itcontended,wouldestablishajustificationfortheset‐asidegoalsestablishedfor1999.Id.Thecourtsaidthisargument,whichthecourtrejected,restedonthenotionthatagovernmentalentitymightpermissiblyadoptanaffirmativeactionplanincludingset‐asidegoalsandwaituntilsuchaplanischallengedincourtbeforeundertakingthenecessarystudiesuponwhichtheconstitutionalityoftheplandepends.Id.
Therefore,becausetheCityofferednocontemporaneousjustificationforthe1999set‐asidegoalsitadoptedontheauthorityoftheOrdinance,thecourtissuedaninjunctioninits1999decisionanddeclinedtostayitseffectiveness.Id.SincetheinjunctionawardedcompleterelieftotheAUC,andanyefforttoadjudicatetheissueofwhethertheCitywouldadoptrevisedset‐asidegoalsontheauthorityoftheOrdinancewaswhollyspeculativeundertaking,thecourtdismissedthecasewithoutprejudice.Id.
Facts and Procedural History.In1986,theCityCouncilenactedinOrdinance790thefirstcity‐wideaffirmativeactionset‐asidegoals,whichrequired,interalia,thatforallCitycontracts,20%ofthevalueofsubcontractsbeawardedtoMinority–OwnedBusinessEnterprises(“MBEs”)and3%toWomen–OwnedBusinessEnterprises(“WBEs”).Id.at615.AspermittedunderthencontrollingSupremeCourtprecedent,thecourtsaidOrdinance790wasjustifiedbyafindingthatgeneralsocietaldiscriminationhaddisadvantagedMWBEs.Apparently,nodisparitystatisticswereofferedtojustifyOrdinance790.Id.
AftertheSupremeCourtannounceditsdecisioninCityofRichmondv.J.A.Croson,488U.S.469(1989),theCityconvenedaTaskForcetostudytheconstitutionalityofOrdinance790.Id.TheTaskForceheldhearingsandissuedaPublicCommentDraftReportonNovember1,1989.Id.Itheldadditionalhearings,reviewedpubliccommentsandissueditsfinalreportonApril11,1990,recommendingseveralamendmentstoOrdinance790.Id.TheCityCouncilconductedhearings,andinJune1990,enactedOrdinance610,thelawunderattackinthiscase.Id.
InenactingOrdinance610,theCityCouncilfoundthatitwasjustifiedasanappropriateremedyof“[p]astdiscriminationintheCity’scontractingprocessbyprimecontractorsagainstminorityandwomen’sbusinessenterprises....”Id.TheCityCouncilalsofoundthat“[m]inorityand
![Page 268: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/268.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 142
women’sbusinessenterprises...havehaddifficultiesinobtainingfinancing,bonding,creditandinsurance;”that“[t]heCityofBaltimorehascreatedanumberofdifferentassistanceprogramstohelpsmallbusinesseswiththeseproblems...[butthatt]heseassistanceprogramshavenotbeeneffectiveineitherremedyingtheeffectsofpastdiscrimination...orinpreventingongoingdiscrimination.”Id.
TheoperativesectionofOrdinance610relevanttothiscasemandatedaprocedurebywhichset‐asidegoalsweretobeestablishedeachyearforminorityandwomenownedbusinessparticipationinCitycontracts.Id.TheOrdinanceitselfdidnotestablishanygoals,butdirectedtheMayortoconsultwiththeChiefofEqualOpportunityComplianceand“contractauthorities”andtoannuallyspecifygoalsforeachseparatecategoryofcontracting“suchaspublicworks,professionalservices,concessionandpurchasingcontracts,aswellasanyothercategoriesthattheMayordeemsappropriate.”Id.
In1990,uponitsenactmentoftheOrdinance,theCityestablishedacross‐the‐boardset‐asidegoalsof20%MBEand3%WBEforallCitycontractswithnovariationbymarket.Id.ThecourtfoundtheCitysimplyreadoptedthe20%MBEand3%WBEsubcontractorparticipationgoalsfromthepriorlaw,Ordinance790,whichtheOrdinancehadspecificallyrepealed.Id.at616.Thesesameset‐asidegoals,thecourtsaid,wereadoptedwithoutchangeandwithoutfactualsupportineachsucceedingyearsince1990.Id.
Noannualstudyeverwasundertakentosupporttheimplementationoftheaffirmativeactionprogramgenerallyortosupporttheestablishmentofanyannualgoals,thecourtconcluded,andtheCitydidnotcollectthedatawhichcouldhavepermittedsuchfindings.Id.Nodisparitystudyexistedorwasundertakenuntilthecommencementofthislawsuit.Id.Thus,thecourtheldtheCityhadnoreliablerecordoftheavailabilityofMWBEsforeachcategoryofcontracting,andthusnowayofdeterminingwhetherits20%and3%goalswererationallyrelatedtoextantdiscrimination(orthecontinuingeffectsthereof)inthelettingofpublicconstructioncontracts.Id.
AUC has associational standing.AUCestablishedthatithadassociationalstandingtochallengetheset‐asidegoalsadoptedbytheCityin1999.Id.Specifically,AUCsufficientlyestablishedthatitsmemberswere“readyandable”tobidforCitypublicworkscontracts.Id.Nomore,thecourtnoted,wasrequired.Id.
ThecourtfoundthatAUC’smembersweredisadvantagedbythegoalsinthebiddingprocess,andthisalonewasacognizableinjury.Id.Forthepurposesofanequalprotectionchallengetoaffirmativeactionset‐asidegoals,thecourtstatedtheSupremeCourthasheldthatthe“‘injuryinfact’istheinabilitytocompeteonanequalfootinginthebiddingprocess...”Id.at617,quotingNortheasternFloridaChapter,508U.S.at666,andcitingAdarandConstructors,Inc.v.Pena,515U.S.200,211(1995).
TheSupremeCourtinNortheasternFloridaChapterheldthatindividualstandingisestablishedtochallengeaset‐asideprogramwhenapartydemonstrates“thatitisableandreadytobidoncontractsandthatadiscriminatorypolicypreventsitfromdoingsoonanequalbasis.”Id.at616quoting,Northeastern,508U.S.at666.TheSupremeCourtfurtherheldthatonceapartyshowsitis“readyandable”tobidinthiscontext,thepartywillhavesufficientlyshownthattheset‐
![Page 269: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/269.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 143
asidegoalsare“the‘cause’ofitsinjuryandthatajudicialdecreedirectingthecitytodiscontinueitsprogramwould‘redress’theinjury,”thussatisfyingtheremainingrequirementsforindividualstanding.Id.quotingNortheastern,at666&n.5.
ThecourtfoundtherewasampleevidencethatAUCmemberswere“readyandable”tobidonCitypublicworkscontractsbasedonseveraldocumentsintherecord,andthatmembersofAUCwouldhaveindividualstandingintheirownrighttochallengetheconstitutionalityoftheCity’sset‐asidegoalsapplicabletoconstructioncontracting,satisfyingtheassociationalstandingtest.Id.at617‐18.ThecourtheldAUChadassociationalstandingtochallengetheconstitutionalityofthepublicworkscontractsset‐asideprovisionsestablishedin1999.Id.at618.
Strict scrutiny analysis.AUCcomplainedthatsincetheirinitialpromulgationin1990,theCity’sset‐asidegoalsrequiredAUCmembersto“selectorrejectcertainsubcontractorsbasedupontherace,ethnicity,orgenderofsuchsubcontractors”inordertobidsuccessfullyonCitypublicworkscontractsforworkexceeding$25,000(“Citypublicworkscontracts”).Id.at618.AUCclaimed,therefore,thattheCity’sset‐asidegoalsviolatedtheFourteenthAmendment’sguaranteeofequalprotectionbecausetheyrequiredprimecontractorstoengageindiscriminationwhichthegovernmentitselfcannotperpetrate.Id.
Thecourtstatedthatgovernmentclassificationsbaseduponraceandethnicityarereviewedunderstrictscrutiny,citingtheSupremeCourtinAdarand,515U.S.at227;andthatthosebasedupongenderarereviewedunderthelessstringentintermediatescrutiny.Id.at618,citingUnitedStatesv.Virginia,518U.S.515,531(1996).Id.“[A]llracialclassifications,imposedbywhateverfederal,state,orlocalgovernmentalactor,mustbeanalyzedbyareviewingcourtunderstrictscrutiny.”Id.at619,quotingAdarand,515U.S.at227.Thegovernmentclassificationmustbenarrowlytailoredtoachieveacompellinggovernmentinterest.Id.citingCroson,488U.S.at493–95.ThecourtthennotedthattheFourthCircuithasexplained:
Therationaleforthisstringentstandardofreviewisplain.Ofallthecriteriabywhichmenandwomencanbe judged, themostpernicious is thatof race.Theinjusticeof judginghumanbeingsbythecolorof theirskin issoapparent thatracial classifications cannot be rationalized by the casual invocation of benignremedial aims.... While the inequities and indignities visited by pastdiscrimination are undeniable, the use of race as a reparational device risksperpetuatingtheveryrace‐consciousnesssucharemedypurportstoovercome.
Id.at619,quotingMarylandTroopersAss’n,Inc.v.Evans,993F.2d1072,1076(4thCir.1993)(citationomitted).
ThecourtalsopointedoutthatinCroson,apluralityoftheSupremeCourtconcludedthatstateandlocalgovernmentshaveacompellinginterestinremedyingidentifiedpastandpresentracediscriminationwithintheirborders.Id.at619,citingCroson,488U.S.at492.ThepluralityoftheSupremeCourt,accordingtothecourt,explainedthattheFourteenthAmendmentpermitsrace‐consciousprogramsthatseekbothtoeradicatediscriminationbythegovernmentalentityitself,andtopreventthepublicentityfromactingasa“‘passiveparticipant’inasystemofracialexclusionpracticedbyelementsofthelocalconstructionindustry”byallowingtaxdollars“tofinancetheevilofprivateprejudice.”Id.at619,quotingCroson,488U.S.at492.Thus,thecourt
![Page 270: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/270.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 144
foundCrosonmakesclearthattheCityhasacompellinginterestineradicatingandremedyingprivatediscriminationintheprivatesubcontractinginherentinthelettingofCityconstructioncontracts.Id.
TheFourthCircuit,thecourtstated,hasinterpretedCrosontoimposea“twostepanalysisforevaluatingarace‐consciousremedy.”Id.at619citingMarylandTroopersAss’n,993F.2dat1076.“First,the[government]musthavea‘strongbasisinevidenceforitsconclusionthatremedialaction[is]necessary....’‘Absentsearchingjudicialinquiryintothejustificationforsuchrace‐basedmeasures,thereissimplynowayofdeterminingwhatclassificationsare...infactmotivatedbyillegitimatenotionsofracialinferiorityorsimpleracialpolitics.’”Id.at619,quotingMarylandTroopersAss’n,993F.2dat1076(citingCroson).
ThesecondstepintheCrosonanalysis,accordingtothecourt,istodeterminewhetherthegovernmenthasadoptedprogramsthat“‘narrowlytailor’anypreferencesbasedonracetomeettheirremedialgoal.”Id.at619.ThecourtfoundthattheFourthCircuitsummarizedSupremeCourtjurisprudenceon“narrowtailoring”asfollows:
Thepreferencesmayremain ineffectonlyso longasnecessary toremedy thediscriminationatwhichtheyareaimed;theymaynottakeonalifeoftheirown.The numerical goals must be waivable if qualified minority applications arescarce,andsuchgoalsmustbearareasonablerelationtominoritypercentagesintherelevantqualifiedlaborpool,notinthepopulationasawhole.Finally,thepreferencesmaynotsupplantrace‐neutralalternativesforremedyingthesamediscrimination.
Id.at620,quotingMarylandTroopersAss’n,993F.2dat1076–77(citationsomitted).
Intermediate scrutiny analysis.Thecourtstatedtheintermediatescrutinyanalysisforgender‐baseddiscriminationasfollows:“Partieswhoseektodefendgender‐basedgovernmentactionmustdemonstratean‘exceedinglypersuasivejustification’forthataction.”Id.at620,quotingVirginia,518U.S.at531,116.Thisburdenisa“demanding[one]anditrestsentirelyontheState.”Id.at620quotingVirginia,518U.S.at533.
Althoughgenderisnot“aproscribedclassification,”inthewayraceorethnicityis,thecourtsnevertheless“carefullyinspect[]officialactionthatclosesadoorordeniesopportunity”onthebasisofgender.Id.at620,quotingVirginia,518U.S.at532‐533.Atbottom,thecourtconcluded,agovernmentwishingtodiscriminateonthebasisofgendermustdemonstratethatitsdoingsoserves“importantgovernmentalobjectivesandthatthediscriminatorymeansemployedaresubstantiallyrelatedtotheachievementofthoseobjectives.”Id.at620,quotingVirginia,518U.S.at533(citationsandquotationsomitted).
Aswiththestandardsforrace‐basedmeasures,thecourtfoundnoformulaexistsbywhichtodeterminewhatevidencewilljustifyeverydifferenttypeofgender‐consciousmeasure.Id.at620.However,astheThirdCircuithasexplained,“[l]ogically,acitymustbeabletorelyonlessevidenceinenactingagenderpreferencethanaracialpreferencebecauseapplyingCroson’sevidentiarystandardtoagenderpreferencewouldevisceratethedifferencebetweenstrictandintermediatescrutiny.”Id.at620,quotingContractorsAss’n,6F.3dat1010.
![Page 271: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/271.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 145
ThecourtpointedoutthattheSupremeCourthasstatedanaffirmativeactionprogramsurvivesintermediatescrutinyiftheproponentcanshowitwas“aproductofanalysisratherthanastereotypedreactionbasedonhabit.”Id.at620,quotingMetroBroadcasting,Inc.v.F.C.C.,497U.S.547,582–83(1990)(internalquotationsomitted).TheThirdCircuit,thecourtsaid,determinedthat“thisstandardrequirestheCitytopresentprobativeevidenceinsupportofitsstatedrationaleforthe[10%genderset‐aside]preference,discriminationagainstwomen‐ownedcontractors.”Id.at620,quotingContractorsAss’n,6F.3dat1010.
Preenactment versus postenactment evidence.InevaluatingthefirststepoftheCrosontest,whethertheCityhada“strongbasisinevidenceforitsconclusionthat[race‐conscious]remedialactionwasnecessary,”thecourtheldthatitmustlimititsinquirytoevidencewhichtheCityactuallyconsideredbeforeenactingthenumericalgoals.Id.at620.ThecourtfoundtheSupremeCourthasestablishedthestandardthatpreenactmentevidencemustprovidethe“strongbasisinevidence”thatrace‐basedremedialactionisnecessary.Id.at620‐621.
ThecourtnotedtheSupremeCourtinWygant,thepluralityopinion,joinedbyfourjusticesincludingJusticeO’Connor,heldthatastateentity“mustensurethat,beforeitembarksonanaffirmative‐actionprogram,ithasconvincingevidencethatremedialactioniswarranted.Thatis,itmusthavesufficientevidencetojustifytheconclusionthattherehasbeenpriordiscrimination.”Id.at621,quotingWygant,476U.S.at277.
Thecourtstatedthatbecauseofthiscontrollingprecedent,itwascompelledtoanalyzetheevidencebeforetheCitywhenitadoptedthe1999set‐asidegoalsspecifyingthe20%MBEparticipationinCityconstructionsubcontracts,andforanalogousreasons,the3%WBEpreferencemustalsobejustifiedbypreenactmentevidence.Id.at621.
ThecourtsaidtheFourthCircuithasnotruledontheissuewhetheraffirmativeactionmeasuresmustbejustifiedbyastrongbasisinpreenactmentevidence.ThecourtfoundthatintheFourthCircuitdecisionsinvalidatingstateaffirmativeactionpoliciesinPodbereskyv.Kirwan,38F.3d147(4thCir.1994),andMarylandTroopersAss’n,Inc.v.Evans,993F.2d1072(4thCir.1993),thecourtapparentlyreliedwithoutcommentuponpostenactmentevidencewhenevaluatingthepoliciesforCroson“strongbasisinevidence.”Id.at621,n.6,citingPodberesky,38F.3dat154(referringtopostenactmentsurveysofAfrican–AmericanstudentsatCollegeParkcampus);MarylandTroopers,993F.2dat1078(evaluatingstatisticsaboutthepercentageofblacktroopersin1991whendecidingwhethertherewasastatisticaldisparitygreatenoughtojustifytheaffirmativeactionmeasuresina1990consentdecree).Thecourtconcluded,however,thisissuewasapparentlynotraisedinthesecases,andbothweredecidedbeforethe1996SupremeCourtdecisioninShawv.Hunt,517U.S.899,whichclarifiedthattheWygantpluralitydecisionwascontrollingauthorityonthisissue.Id.at621,n.6.
Thecourtnotedthatthreecourtshadheld,priortoShaw,thatpostenactmentevidencemaybereliedupontosatisfytheCroson“strongbasisinevidence”requirement.ConcreteWorksofColorado,Inc.v.Denver,36F.3d1513(10thCir.1994),cert.denied,514U.S.1004,115S.Ct.1315,131L.Ed.2d196(1995);Harrison&BurrowesBridgeConstructors,Inc.v.Cuomo,981F.2d50,60(2dCir.1992);CoralConstructionCo.v.KingCounty,941F.2d910(9thCir.1991).Id.Inaddition,theEleventhCircuitheldin1997that“postenactmentevidenceisadmissibletodeterminewhetheranaffirmativeactionprogram”satisfiesCroson.EngineeringContractorsAss’nofSouth
![Page 272: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/272.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 146
Florida,Inc.v.MetropolitanDadeCounty,122F.3d895,911–12(11thCir.1997),cert.denied,523U.S.1004(1998).BecausethecourtbelievedthatShawandWygantprovidedcontrollingauthorityontheroleofpostenactmentevidenceinthe“strongbasisinevidence”inquiry,itdidnotfindthesecasespersuasive.Id.at621.
City did not satisfy strict or intermediate scrutiny: no disparity study was completed or
preenactment evidence established.Inthiscase.thecourtfoundthattheCityconsiderednoevidencein1999beforepromulgatingtheconstructionsubcontractingset‐asidegoalsof20%forMBEsand3%forWBEs.Id.at621.BasedontheabsenceofanyrecordofwhatevidencetheCityconsideredpriortopromulgatingtheset‐asidegoalsfor1999,thecourtheldtherewasnodisputeofmaterialfactforeclosingsummaryjudgmentinfavorofplaintiff.Id.Thecourtthusfoundthatthe20%preferenceisnotsupportedbya“strongbasisinevidence”showinganeedforarace‐consciousremedialplanin1999;noristhe3%preferenceshowntobe“substantiallyrelatedtoachievement”oftheimportantobjectiveofremedyinggenderdiscriminationin1999,intheconstructionindustryinBaltimore.Id.
ThecourtrejectedtheCity’sassertionsthroughoutthecasethatthecourtshouldupholdtheset‐asidegoalsbaseduponstatistics,whichtheCitywasintheprocessofgatheringinadisparitystudyithadcommissioned.Id.at622.ThecourtsaidtheCitydidnotprovideanylegalsupportforthepropositionthatagovernmentalentitymightpermissiblyadoptanaffirmativeactionplanincludingset‐asidegoalsandwaituntilsuchaplanischallengedincourtbeforeundertakingthenecessarystudiesuponwhichtheconstitutionalityoftheplandepends.Id.Theinprocessstudywasnotcompleteasofthedateofthisdecisionbythecourt.Id.ThecourtthusstatedthestudycouldnothaveproduceddatauponwhichtheCityactuallyreliedinestablishingtheset‐asidegoalsfor1999.Id.
Thecourtnotedthatifthedatathestudyproducedwerereliableandcomplete,theCitycouldhavethestatisticalbasisuponwhichtomakethefindingsOrdinance610required,andwhichcouldsatisfytheconstitutionallyrequiredstandardsforthepromulgationandimplementationofnarrowlytailoredset‐asiderace‐andgenderconsciousgoals.Id.at622.Nonetheless,astherecordstoodwhenthecourtenteredtheDecember1999injunctionandasitstoodasofthedateofthedecision,therewerenodatainevidenceshowingadisparity,letaloneagrossdisparity,betweenMWBEavailabilityandutilizationinthesubcontractingconstructionmarketinBaltimoreCity.Id.TheCitypossessednosuchevidencewhenitestablishedthe1999set‐asidegoalschallengedinthecase.Id.
Apercentageset‐asidemeasure,liketheMWBEgoalsatissue,thecourtheldcouldonlybejustifiedbyreferencetotheoverallavailabilityofminority‐andwomen‐ownedbusinessesintherelevantmarkets.Id.Intheabsenceofsuchfigures,the20%MBEand3%WBEsetasidefigureswerearbitraryandunenforceableinlightofcontrollingSupremeCourtandFourthCircuitauthority.Id.
Holding.ThecourtheldthatforthesereasonsitenteredtheinjunctionagainsttheCityonDecember1999anditremainedfullyineffect.Id.at622.Accordingly,theCity’smotionforstayoftheinjunctionorderwasdeniedandtheactionwasdismissedwithoutprejudice.Id.at622.
![Page 273: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/273.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 147
ThecourtheldunconstitutionaltheCityofBaltimore’s“affirmativeaction”program,whichhadconstructionsubcontracting“set‐aside”goalsof20percentforMBEsand3percentforWBEs.ThecourtheldtherewasnodataorstatisticalevidencesubmittedbytheCitypriortoenactmentoftheOrdinance.TherewasnoevidenceshowingadisparitybetweenMBE/WBEavailabilityandutilizationinthesubcontractingconstructionmarketinBaltimore.ThecourtenjoinedtheCityOrdinance.
22. Webster v. Fulton County, 51 F. Supp.2d 1354 (N.D. Ga. 1999), affirmed per curiam 218 F.3d 1267 (11th Cir. 2000)
Thiscaseisinstructiveasitisanotherinstanceinwhichacourthasconsidered,analyzed,andruleduponarace‐,ethnicity‐andgender‐consciousprogram,holdingthelocalgovernmentMBE/WBE‐typeprogramfailedtosatisfythestrictscrutinyconstitutionalstandard.ThecasealsoisinstructiveinitsapplicationoftheEngineeringContractorsAssociationcase,includingtoadisparityanalysis,theburdensofproofonthelocalgovernment,andthenarrowlytailoredprongofthestrictscrutinytest.
Inthiscase,plaintiffWebsterbroughtanactionchallengingtheconstitutionalityofFultonCounty’s(the“County”)minorityandfemalebusinessenterpriseprogram(“M/FBE”)program.51F.Supp.2d1354,1357(N.D.Ga.1999).[ThedistrictcourtfirstsetforththeprovisionsoftheM/FBEprogramandconductedastandinganalysisat51F.Supp.2dat1356‐62].
Thecourt,citingEngineeringContractorsAssociationofS.Florida,Inc.v.Metro.EngineeringContractorsAssociation,122F.3d895(11thCir.1997),heldthat“[e]xplicitracialpreferencesmaynotbeusedexceptasa‘lastresort.’”Id.at1362‐63.ThecourtthensetforththestrictscrutinystandardforevaluatingracialandethnicpreferencesandthefourfactorsenunciatedinEngineeringContractorsAssociation,andtheintermediatescrutinystandardforevaluatinggenderpreferences.Id.at1363.ThecourtfoundthatunderEngineeringContractorsAssociation,thegovernmentcouldutilizebothpost‐enactmentandpre‐enactmentevidencetomeetitsburdenofa“strongbasisinevidence”forstrictscrutiny,and“sufficientprobativeevidence”forintermediatescrutiny.Id.
Thecourtfoundthatthedefendantbearstheinitialburdenofsatisfyingtheaforementionedevidentiarystandard,andtheultimateburdenofproofremainswiththechallengingpartytodemonstratetheunconstitutionalityoftheM/FBEprogram.Id.at1364.Thecourtfoundthattheplaintiffhasatleastthreemethods“torebuttheinferenceofdiscriminationwithaneutralexplanation:(1)demonstratethatthestatisticsareflawed;(2)demonstratethatthedisparitiesshownbythestatisticsarenotsignificant;or(3)presentconflictingstatisticaldata.”Id.,citingEng’gContractorsAss’n,122F.3dat916.
[ThedistrictcourtthensetforththeEngineeringContractorsAssociationopinionindetail.]
ThecourtfirstnotedthattheEleventhCircuithasrecognizedthatdisparityindicesgreaterthan80percentaregenerallynotconsideredindicationsofdiscrimination.Id.at1368,citingEng’gContractorsAssoc.,122F.3dat914.ThecourtthenconsideredtheCounty’spre‐1994disparitystudy(the“Brimmer‐MarshallStudy”)andfoundthatitfailedtoestablishastrongbasisinevidencenecessarytosupporttheM/FBEprogram.Id.at1368.
![Page 274: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/274.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 148
First,thecourtfoundthatthestudyrestedontheinaccurateassumptionthatastatisticalshowingofunderutilizationofminoritiesinthemarketplaceasawholewassufficientevidenceofdiscrimination.Id.at1369.ThecourtcitedCityofRichmondv.J.A.CrosonCo.,488U.S.496(1989)forthepropositionthatdiscriminationmustbefocusedoncontractingbytheentitythatisconsideringthepreferenceprogram.Id.BecausetheBrimmer‐MarshallStudycontainednostatisticalevidenceofdiscriminationbytheCountyintheawardofcontracts,thecourtfoundtheCountymustshowthatitwasa“passiveparticipant”indiscriminationbytheprivatesector.Id.ThecourtfoundthattheCountycouldtakeremedialactionifithadevidencethatprimecontractorsweresystematicallyexcludingminority‐ownedbusinessesfromsubcontractingopportunities,orifithadevidencethatitsspendingpracticesare“exacerbatingapatternofpriordiscriminationthatcanbeidentifiedwithspecificity.”Id.However,thecourtfoundthattheBrimmer‐MarshallStudycontainednosuchdata.Id.
Second,theBrimmer‐Marshallstudycontainednoregressionanalysistoaccountforrelevantvariables,suchasfirmsize.Id.at1369‐70.Attrial,Dr.Marshallsubmittedafollow‐uptotheearlierdisparitystudy.However,thecourtfoundthestudyhadthesameflawinthatitdidnotcontainaregressionanalysis.Id.ThecourtthusconcludedthattheCountyfailedtopresenta“strongbasisinevidence”ofdiscriminationtojustifytheCounty’sracialandethnicpreferences.Id.
ThecourtnextconsideredtheCounty’spost‐1994disparitystudy.Id.at1371.Thestudyfirstsoughttodeterminetheavailabilityandutilizationofminority‐andfemale‐ownedfirms.Id.Thecourtexplained:
Two methods may be used to calculate availability: (1) bid analysis; or (2)bidder analysis. In a bid analysis, the analyst counts the number of bidssubmittedbyminorityorfemalefirmsoveraperiodoftimeanddividesitbythetotal number of bids submitted in the same period. In a bidder analysis, theanalyst counts the number of minority or female firms submitting bids anddivides it by the total number of firmswhich submitted bids during the sameperiod.
Id.ThecourtfoundthattheinformationprovidedinthestudywasinsufficienttoestablishafirmbasisinevidencetosupporttheM/FBEprogram.Id.at1371‐72.Thecourtalsofounditsignificanttoconductaregressionanalysistoshowwhetherthedisparitieswereeitherduetodiscriminationorotherneutralgrounds.Id.at1375‐76.
TheplaintiffandtheCountysubmittedstatisticalstudiesofdatacollectedbetween1994and1997.Id.at1376.ThecourtfoundthatthedatawerepotentiallyskewedduetotheoperationoftheM/FBEprogram.Id.Additionally,thecourtfoundthattheCounty’sstandarddeviationanalysisyieldednon‐statisticallysignificantresults(notingtheEleventhCircuithasstatedthatscientistsconsiderafindingoftwostandarddeviationssignificant).Id.(internalcitationsomitted).
ThecourtconsideredtheCounty’sanecdotalevidence,andquotedEngineeringContractorsAssociationforthepropositionthat“[a]necdotalevidencecanplayanimportantroleinbolsteringstatisticalevidence,butthatonlyintherarecasewillanecdotalevidencesuffice
![Page 275: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/275.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 149
standingalone.”Id.,quotingEng’gContractorsAss’n,122F.3dat907.TheBrimmer‐MarshallStudycontainedanecdotalevidence.Id.at1379.Additionally,theCountyheldhearingsbutafterreviewingthetaperecordingsofthehearings,thecourtconcludedthatonlytwoindividualstestifiedtodiscriminationbytheCounty;oneofthemcomplainedthattheCountyusedtheM/FBEprogramtoonlybenefitAfricanAmericans.Id.Thecourtfoundthemostcommoncomplaintsconcernedbarriersinbonding,financing,andinsuranceandslowpaymentbyprimecontractors.Id.ThecourtconcludedthattheanecdotalevidencewasinsufficientinandofitselftoestablishafirmbasisfortheM/FBEprogram.Id.
ThecourtalsoappliedanarrowtailoringanalysisoftheM/FBEprogram.“TheEleventhCircuithasmadeitclearthattheessenceofthisinquiryiswhetherracialpreferenceswereadoptedonlyasa‘lastresort.’”Id.at1380,citingEng’gContractorsAssoc.,122F.3dat926.ThecourtcitedtheEleventhCircuit’sfour‐parttestandconcludedthattheCounty’sM/FBEprogramfailedonseveralgrounds.First,thecourtfoundthatarace‐basedproblemdoesnotnecessarilyrequirearace‐basedsolution.“Ifarace‐neutralremedyissufficienttocurearace‐basedproblem,thenarace‐consciousremedycanneverbenarrowlytailoredtothatproblem.”Id.,quotingEng’gContractorsAss’n,122F.3dat927.ThecourtfoundthattherewasnoevidenceofdiscriminationbytheCounty.Id.at1380.
ThecourtfoundthateventhoughamajorityoftheCommissionersontheCountyBoardwereAfricanAmerican,theCountyhadcontinuedtheprogramfordecades.Id.ThecourtheldthattheCountyhadnotseriouslyconsideredrace‐neutralmeasures:
ThereisnoevidenceintherecordthatanyCommissionerhasofferedaresolutionduringthisperiodsubstitutingaprogramofrace‐neutralmeasuresasanalternativetonumericalset‐asidesbaseduponraceandethnicity.ThereisnoevidenceintherecordofanyproposalbythestaffofFultonCountyofsubstitutingaprogramofrace‐neutralmeasuresasanalternativetonumericalset‐asidesbaseduponraceandethnicity.TherehasbeennoevidenceofferedofanydebatewithintheCommissionaboutsubstitutingaprogramofrace‐neutralmeasuresasanalternativetonumericalset‐asidesbaseduponraceandethnicity….Id.
ThecourtfoundthattherandominclusionofethnicandracialgroupswhohadnotsuffereddiscriminationbytheCountyalsomitigatedagainstafindingofnarrowtailoring.Id.ThecourtfoundthattherewasnoevidencethattheCountyconsideredrace‐neutralalternativesasanalternativetorace‐consciousmeasuresnorthatrace‐neutralmeasureswereinitiatedandfailed.Id.at1381.ThecourtconcludedthatbecausetheM/FBEprogramwasnotadoptedasalastresort,itfailedthenarrowtailoringtest.Id.
Additionally,thecourtfoundthattherewasnosubstantialrelationshipbetweenthenumericalgoalsandtherelevantmarket.Id.ThecourtrejectedtheCounty’sargumentthatitsprogramwaspermissiblebecauseitset“goals”asopposedto“quotas,”becausetheprograminEngineeringContractorsAssociationalsoutilized“goals”andwasstruckdown.Id.
PertheM/FBEprogram’sgender‐basedpreferences,thecourtfoundthattheprogramwassufficientlyflexibletosatisfythesubstantialrelationshipprongoftheintermediatescrutinystandard.Id.at1383.However,thecourtheldthattheCountyfailedtopresent“sufficient
![Page 276: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/276.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 150
probativeevidence”ofdiscriminationnecessarytosustainthegender‐basedpreferencesportionoftheM/FBEprogram.Id.
ThecourtfoundtheCounty’sM/FBEprogramunconstitutionalandenteredapermanentinjunctioninfavoroftheplaintiff.Id.Onappeal,theEleventhCircuitaffirmedpercuriam,statingonlythatitaffirmedonthebasisofthedistrictcourt’sopinion.Websterv.FultonCounty,Georgia,218F.3d1267(11thCir.2000).
23. Associated Gen. Contractors v. Drabik, 50 F. Supp.2d 741 (S.D. Ohio 1999)
ThedistrictcourtinthiscasepointedoutthatithadstruckdownOhio’sMBEstatutethatprovidedrace‐basedpreferencesintheawardofstateconstructioncontractsin1998.50F.Supp.2dat744.Twoweeksearlier,thedistrictcourtfortheNorthernDistrictofOhio,likewise,foundthesameOhiolawunconstitutionalwhenitwasreliedupontosupportastatemandatedset‐asideprogramadoptedbytheCuyahogaCommunityCollege.SeeF.BuddieContracting,Ltd.v.CuyahogaCommunityCollegeDistrict,31F.Supp.2d571(N.D.Ohio1998).Id.at741.
Thestatedefendantsappealedthiscourt’sdecisiontotheUnitedStatescourtofAppealsfortheSixthCircuit.Id.Thereafter,theSupremeCourtofOhioheldinthecaseofRitcheyProduce,Co.,Inc.v.TheStateofOhio,DepartmentofAdministrative,704N.E.2d874(1999),thattheOhiostatute,whichprovidedrace‐basedpreferencesinthestate’spurchaseofnonconstruction‐relatedgoodsandservices,wasconstitutional.Id.at744.
Whilethiscourt’sdecisionrelatedtoconstructioncontractsandtheOhioSupremeCourt’sdecisionrelatedtoothergoodsandservices,thedecisionscouldnotbereconciled,accordingtothedistrictcourt.Id.at744.Subsequently,thestatedefendantsmovedthiscourttostayitsorderofNovember2,1998inlightoftheOhioStateSupremeCourt’sdecisioninRitcheyProduce.ThedistrictcourttooktheopportunityinthiscasetoreconsideritsdecisionofNovember2,1998,andtothereasonsgivenbytheSupremeCourtofOhioforreachingtheoppositeresultinRitcheyProduce,anddecideinthiscasethatitsoriginaldecisionwascorrect,andthatastayofitsorderwouldonlyservetoperpetuatea“blatantlyunconstitutionalprogramofrace‐basedbenefits.Id.at745.
Inthisdecision,thedistrictcourtreaffirmeditsearlierholdingthattheStateofOhio’sMBEprogramofconstructioncontractawardsisunconstitutional.ThecourtcitedtoF.BuddieContractingv.CuyahogaCommunityCollege,31F.Supp.2d571(N.D.Ohio1998),holdingasimilarlocalOhioprogramunconstitutional.ThecourtrepudiatedtheOhioSupremeCourt’sholdinginRitcheyProduce,707N.E.2d871(Ohio1999),whichheldthattheStateofOhio’sMBEprogramasappliedtothestate’spurchaseofnon‐construction‐relatedgoodsandserviceswasconstitutional.ThecourtfoundtheevidencetobeinsufficienttojustifytheOhioMBEprogram.ThecourtheldthattheprogramwasnotnarrowlytailoredbecausetherewasnoevidencethattheStatehadconsideredarace‐neutralalternative.
Strict Scrutiny.ThedistrictcourtheldthattheSupremeCourtofOhiodecisioninRitcheyProducewaswronglydecidedforthefollowingreasons:
![Page 277: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/277.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 151
(1)Ohio’sMBEprogramofrace‐basedpreferencesintheawardofstatecontractswasunconstitutionalbecauseitisunlimitedinduration.Id.at745.
(2)aprogramofrace‐basedbenefitscannotbesupportedbyevidenceofdiscriminationwhichisover20yearsold.Id.
(3)thestateSupremeCourtfoundthattherewasaseverenumericalimbalanceintheamountofbusinesstheStatedidwithminority‐ownedenterprises,basedonitsuncriticalacceptanceofessentially“worthlesscalculationscontainedinatwenty‐oneyear‐oldreport,whichmiscalculatedthepercentageofminority‐ownedbusinessesinOhioandmisrepresenteddataonthepercentageofstatepurchasecontractstheyhadreceived,allofwhichwaseasilydetectablebyexaminingthedatacitedbytheauthorsofthereport.”Id.at745.
(4)ThestateSupremeCourtfailedtorecognizethattheincorrectlycalculatedpercentageofminority‐ownedbusinessesinOhio(6.7percent)bearsnorelationshiptothe15percentset‐asidegoaloftheOhioAct.Id.
(5)thestateSupremeCourtappliedanincorrectruleoflawwhenitannouncedthatOhio’sprogrammustbeupheldunlessitisclearlyunconstitutionalbeyondareasonabledoubt,whereasaccordingtothedistrictcourtinthiscase,theSupremeCourtoftheUnitedStateshassaidthatallracialclassclassificationsarehighlysuspectandmustbesubjectedtostrictjudicialscrutiny.Id.
(6)theevidenceofpastdiscriminationthattheOhioGeneralAssemblyhadin1980didnotprovideafirmbasisinevidenceforarace‐basedremedy.Id.
Thus,thedistrictcourtdeterminedtheevidencecouldnotsupportacompellingstate‐interestforrace‐basedpreferencesforthestateofOhioMBEAct,inpartbasedonthefactevidenceofpastdiscriminationwasstaleandtwentyyearsold,andthestatisticalanalysiswasinsufficientbecausethestatedidnotknowhowmanyMBE’sintherelevantmarketarequalifiedtoundertakeprimeorsubcontractingworkinpublicconstructioncontracts.Id.at763‐771.ThestatisticalevidencewasfatallyflawedbecausetherelevantuniverseofminoritybuisnessesisnotallminoritybusinessesinthestateofOhio,butonlythosewillingandabletoenterintocontractswiththestateofOhio.Id.at761.Inthecaseofset‐asideprograminstateconstruction,therelevantuniverseisminority‐ownedconstructionfirmswillingandabletoenterintostateconstructioncontracts.Id.
Narrow Tailoring.Thecourtaddressedthesecondprongofthestrictscrutinyanalysis,andfoundthattheOhioMBEprogramatissuewasnotnarrowlytailored.Thecourtconcludedthatthestatecouldnotsatisfythefourfactorstobeconsideredindeterminingwhetherrace‐consciousremediesareappropriate.Id.at763.First,thecourtstatedthattherewasnoconsiderationofrace‐neutralalternativestoincreaseminorityparticipationinstatecontractingbeforeresortingto“race‐basedquotas.”Id.at763‐764.Thecourtheldthatfailuretoconsiderrace‐neutralmeanswasfataltotheset‐asideprograminCroson,andthefailureoftheStateofOhiotoconsiderrace‐neutralmeansbeforeadoptingtheMBEActin1980likewise“doomsOhio’sprogramofrace‐basedquotas”.Id.at765.
![Page 278: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/278.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 152
Second,thecourtfoundtheOhioMBEActwasnotflexible.Thecourtstatedthatinsteadofallowingflexibilitytoameliorateharmfuleffectsoftheprogram,theimprecisionofthestatutorygoalshasbeenusedtojustifybureaucraticdecisionswhichincreaseitsimpactonnon‐minoritybusiness.”Id.at765.ThecourtsaidthewaiversystemforprimecontractsfocusessolelyontheavailabilityofMBEs.Id.at766.Thecourtnotedtheawardingagencymayremovethecontractfromthesetasideprogramandopenitupforbiddingbynon‐minoritycontractorsifnocertifiedMBEsubmitsabid,orifallbidssubmittedbyMBEsareconsideredunacceptablyhigh.Id.But,ineitherevent,thecourtpointedouttheagencyisthenrequiredtosetasideadditionalcontractstosatisfythenumericalquotarequiredbythestatute.Id.ThecourtconcludedthatthereisnoconsiderationgiventowhethertheparticularMBEseekingaracialpreferencehassufferedfromtheeffectsofpastdiscriminationbythestateorprimecontractors.Id.
Third,thecourtfoundtheOhioMBEActwasnotappropriatelylimitedsuchthatitwillnotlastlongerthanthediscriminatoryeffectsitwasdesignedtoeliminate.Id.at766.Thecourtstatedthe1980MBEActisunlimitedinduration,andthereisnoevidencethestatehaseverreconsideredwhetheracompellingstateinterestexiststhatwouldjustifythecontinuationofarace‐basedremedyatanytimeduringthetwodecadestheActhasbeenineffect.Id.
Fourth,thecourtfoundthegoalsoftheOhioMBEActwerenotrelatedtotherelevantmarketandthattheActfailedthiselementofthe“narrowlytailored”requirementofstrictscrutiny.Id.at767‐768.Thecourtsaidthegoalof15percentfarexceedsthepercentageofavailableminorityfirms,andthusbearsnorelationshiptotherelevantmarket.Id.
Fifth,thecourtfoundtheconclusionoftheOhioSupremeCourtthattheburdensimposedonnon‐MBEsbyvirtueoftheset‐asiderequirementswererelativelylightwasincorrect.Id.at768.Thecourtconcludednon‐minoritycontractorsinvarioustradeswereeffectivelyexcludedfromtheopportunitytobidonanyworkfromlargestateagencies,departments,andinstitutionssolelybecauseoftheirrace.Id.at678.
Sixth,thecourtfoundtheOhioMBEActprovidedrace‐basedbenefitsbasedonarandominclusionofminoritygroups.Id.at770‐771.Thecourtstatedtherewasnoevidenceaboutthenumberofeachracialorethnicgrouportherespectivesharesofthetotalcapitalimprovementexpenditurestheyreceived.Id.at770.Noneofthestatisticalinformation,thecourtsaid,brokedownthepercentageofallfirmsthatwereownedbyspecificminoritygroupsorthedollaramountsofcontractsreceivedbyfirmsinspecificminoritygroups.Id.Thecourt,thus,concludedthattheOhioMBEActincludedminoritygroupsrandomlywithoutanyspecificevidencethatanygroupsufferedfromdiscriminationintheconstructionindustryinOhio.Id.at771.
Conclusion.Thecourtthusdeniedthemotionofthestatedefendantstostaythecourt’spriororderholdingunconstitutionaltheOhioMBEActpendingtheappealofthecourt’sorder.Id.at771.Thisopinionunderscoredthatgovernmentsmustshowseveralfactorstodemonstratenarrowtailoring:(1)thenecessityforthereliefandtheefficacyofalternativeremedies,(2)flexibilityanddurationoftherelief,(3)relationshipofnumericalgoalstotherelevantlabormarket,and(4)impactofthereliefontherightsofthirdparties.ThecourtheldtheOhioMBEprogramfailedtosatisfythistest.
![Page 279: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/279.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 153
24. Phillips & Jordan, Inc. v. Watts, 13 F. Supp.2d 1308 (N.D. Fla. 1998)
ThiscaseisinstructivebecauseitaddressedachallengetoastateandlocalgovernmentMBE/WBE‐typeprogramandconsideredtherequisiteevidentiarybasisnecessarytosupporttheprogram.InPhillips&Jordan,thedistrictcourtfortheNorthernDistrictofFloridaheldthattheFloridaDepartmentofTransportation’s(“FDOT”)programof“settingaside”certainhighwaymaintenancecontractsforAfricanAmerican‐andHispanic‐ownedbusinessesviolatedtheEqualProtectionClauseoftheFourteenthAmendmenttotheUnitedStatesConstitution.Thepartiesstipulatedthattheplaintiff,anon‐minoritybusiness,hadbeenexcludedinthepastandmaybeexcludedinthefuturefromcompetingforcertainhighwaymaintenancecontracts“setaside”forbusinessenterprisesownedbyHispanicandAfricanAmericanindividuals.ThecourtheldthattheevidenceofstatisticaldisparitieswasinsufficienttosupporttheFloridaDOTprogram.
ThedistrictcourtpointedoutthatFloridaDOTdidnotclaimthatithadevidenceofintentionaldiscriminationintheawardofitscontracts.ThecourtstatedthattheessenceofFDOT’sclaimwasthatthetwo‐yeardisparitystudyprovidedevidenceofadisparitybetweentheproportionofminoritiesawardedFDOTroadmaintenancecontractsandaportionoftheminorities“supposedlywillingandabletodoroadmaintenancework,”andthatFDOTdidnotitselfengageinanyracialorethnicdiscrimination,soFDOTmusthavebeenapassiveparticipantin“somebody’s”discriminatorypractices.
SinceitwasagreedinthecasethatFDOTdidnotdiscriminateagainstminoritycontractorsbiddingonroadmaintenancecontracts,thecourtfoundthattherecordcontainedinsufficientproofofdiscrimination.ThecourtfoundtheevidenceinsufficienttoestablishactsofdiscriminationagainstAfricanAmerican‐andHispanic‐ownedbusinesses.
Thecourtraisedquestionsconcerningthechoiceanduseofthestatisticalpoolofavailablefirmsrelieduponbythedisparitystudy.ThecourtexpressedconcernaboutwhetheritwasappropriatetouseCensusdatatoanalyzeanddeterminewhichfirmswereavailable(qualifiedand/orwillingandable)tobidonFDOTroadmaintenancecontracts.
F. Recent Decisions Involving the Federal DBE Program and its Implementation by State and Local Governments
ThereareseveralrecentandpendingcasesinvolvingchallengestotheUnitedStatesFederalDBEProgramanditsimplementationbythestatesandtheirgovernmentalentitiesforfederally‐fundedprojects.Thesecasescouldhaveasignificantimpactonthenatureandprovisionsofcontractingandprocurementonfederally‐fundedprojects,includingandrelatingtotheutilizationofDBEs.Inaddition,thesecasesprovideaninstructiveanalysisoftherecentapplicationofthestrictscrutinytesttoMBE/WBE‐andDBE‐typeprograms.
![Page 280: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/280.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 154
Recent Decisions in Federal Circuit Courts of Appeal
1. Mountain West Holding Co., Inc. v. The State of Montana, Montana DOT, et al., 2017 WL 2179120 (9th Cir. May 16, 2017), Memorandum opinion, (Not for Publication) United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, May 16, 2017, Docket Nos. 14‐26097 and 15‐35003, dismissing in part, reversing in part and remanding the U.S. District Court decision at 2014 WL 6686734 (D. Mont. Nov. 26, 2014)
Note: TheNinthCircuitCourtofAppealsMemorandumprovides:“ThisdispositionisnotappropriateforpublicationandisnotprecedentexceptasprovidedbyNinthCircuitRule36‐3.”
Introduction. MountainWestHoldingCompanyinstallssigns,guardrails,andconcretebarriersonhighwaysinMontana.ItcompetestowinsubcontractsfromprimecontractorswhohavecontractedwiththeState.Itisnotownedandcontrolledbywomenorminorities.Someofitscompetitorsaredisadvantagedbusinessenterprises(DBEs)ownedbywomenorminorities.InthiscaseitclaimsthatMontana’sDBEgoal‐settingprogramunconstitutionallyrequiredprimecontractorstogivepreferencetotheseminorityorfemale‐ownedcompetitors,whichMountainWestHoldingsCompanyarguesisaviolationoftheEqualProtectionClause,42U.S.C.§1983andTitleVIoftheCivilRightsActof1964,42U.S.C.§2000d,etseq.
Factual and procedural background.InMountainWestHoldingCo.,Inc.v.TheStateofMontana,MontanaDOT,etal.,2014WL6686734(D.Mont.Nov.26,2014);CaseNo.1:13‐CV‐00049‐DLC,UnitedStatesDistrictCourtfortheDistrictofMontana,BillingsDivision,plaintiffMountainWestHoldingCo.,Inc.(“MountainWest”),allegeditisacontractorthatprovidesconstruction‐specifictrafficplanningandstaffingforconstructionprojectsaswellastheinstallationofsigns,guardrails,andconcretebarriers.MountainWestsuedtheMontanaDepartmentofTransportation(“MDT”)andtheStateofMontana,challengingtheirimplementationoftheFederalDBEProgram.MountainWestbroughtthisactionallegingviolationoftheEqualProtectionClauseoftheFourteenthAmendmentoftheUnitedStatesConstitution,TitleVIoftheCivilRightsAct,42USC§2000(d)(7),and42USC§1983.
FollowingtheNinthCircuit’s2005decisioninWesternStatesPavingv.WashingtonDOT,etal.,MDTcommissionedadisparitystudywhichwascompletedin2009.MDTutilizedtheresultsofthedisparitystudytoestablishitsoverallDBEgoal.MDTdeterminedthattomeetitsoverallgoal,itwouldneedtoimplementrace‐consciouscontractspecificgoals.Baseduponthedisparitystudy,MountainWestallegestheStateofMontanautilizedrace,nationalorigin,andgender‐consciousgoalsinhighwayconstructioncontracts.MountainWestclaimstheStatedidnothaveastrongbasisinevidencetoshowtherewaspastdiscriminationinthehighwayconstructionindustryinMontanaandthattheimplementationofrace,gender,andnationaloriginpreferenceswerenecessaryorappropriate.MountainWestalsoallegesthatMontanahasinstitutedpoliciesandpracticeswhichexceedtheUnitedStatesDepartmentofTransportationDBErequirements.
MountainWestassertsthatthe2009studyconcludedall“relevant”minoritygroupswereunderutilizedin“professionalservices”andAsianPacificAmericansandHispanicAmericanswereunderutilizedin“businesscategoriescombined,”butitalsoconcludedthatall“relevant”
![Page 281: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/281.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 155
minoritygroupsweresignificantlyoverutilizedinconstruction.MountainWestthusallegesthatalthoughthedisparitystudydemonstratesthatDBEgroupsare“significantlyoverrepresented”inthehighwayconstructionfield,MDThasestablishedpreferencesforDBEconstructionsubcontractorfirmsovernon‐DBEconstructionsubcontractorfirmsintheawardofcontracts.
MountainWestalsoassertsthattheMontanaDBEProgramdoesnothaveavalidstatisticalbasisfortheestablishmentorinclusionofrace,nationalorigin,andgenderconsciousgoals,thatMDTinappropriatelyreliesuponthe2009studyasthebasisforitsDBEProgram,andthatthestudyisflawed.MountainWestclaimstheMontanaDBEProgramisnotnarrowlytailoredbecauseitdisregardslargedifferencesinDBEfirmutilizationinMDTcontractsasamongthreedifferentcategoriesofsubcontractors:businesscategoriescombined,construction,andprofessionalservices;theMDTDBEcertificationprocessdoesnotrequiretheapplicanttospecifyanyspecificracialorethnicprejudiceorculturalbiasthathadanegativeimpactuponhisorherbusinesssuccess;andthecertificationprocessdoesnotrequiretheapplicanttocertifythatheorshewasdiscriminatedagainstintheStateofMontanainhighwayconstruction.
MountainWestandtheStateofMontanaandtheMDTfiledcrossMotionsforSummaryJudgment.MountainWestassertsthattherewasnoevidencethatallrelevantminoritygroupshadsuffereddiscriminationinMontana’stransportationcontractingindustrybecause,whilethestudyhaddeterminedthereweresubstantialdisparitiesintheutilizationofallminoritygroupsinprofessionalservicescontracts,therewasnodisparityintheutilizationofminoritygroupsinconstructioncontracts.
AGC, San Diego v. California DOT and Western States Paving Co. v. Washington DOT.TheNinthCircuitandthedistrictcourtinMountainWestappliedthedecisioninWesternStates,407F.3d983(9thCir.2005),andthedecisioninAGC,SanDiegov.CaliforniaDOT,713F.3d1187(9thCir.2013)asestablishingthelawtobefollowedinthiscase.ThedistrictcourtnotedthatinWesternStates,theNinthCircuitheldthatastate’simplementationoftheFederalDBEProgramcanbesubjecttoanas‐appliedconstitutionalchallenge,despitethefacialvalidityoftheFederalDBEProgram.2014WL6686734at*2(D.Mont.November26,2014).TheNinthCircuitandthedistrictcourtstatedtheNinthCircuithasheldthatwhetherastate’simplementationoftheDBEProgram“isnarrowlytailoredtofurtherCongress’sremedialobjectivedependsuponthepresenceorabsenceofdiscriminationintheState’stransportationcontractingindustry.”MountainWest,2014WL6686734at*2,quotingWesternStates,at997‐998,andMountainWest,2017WL2179120at*2(9thCir.May16,2017)Memorandum,May16,2017,at5‐6,quotingAGC,SanDiegov.CaliforniaDOT,713F.3d1187,1196.TheNinthCircuitinMountainWestalsopointedoutithadheldthat“evenwhendiscriminationispresentwithinaState,aremedialprogramisonlynarrowlytailoredifitsapplicationislimitedtothoseminoritygroupsthathaveactuallysuffereddiscrimination.”MountainWest,2017WL2179120at*2,Memorandum,May16,2017,at6,and2014WL6686734at*2,quotingWesternStates,407F.3dat997‐999.
MDT study.MDTobtainedafirmtoconductadisparitystudythatwascompletedin2009.ThedistrictcourtinMountainWeststatedthattheresultsofthestudyindicatedsignificantunderutilizationofDBEsinallminoritygroupsin“professionalservices”contracts,significantunderutilizationofAsianPacificAmericansandHispanicAmericansin“businesscategoriescombined,”slightunderutilizationofnonminoritywomenin“businesscategoriescombined,”
![Page 282: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/282.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 156
andoverutilizationofallgroupsinsubcontractor“construction”contracts.MountainWest,2014WL6686734at*2.
Inadditiontothestatisticalevidence,the2009disparitystudygatheredanecdotalevidencethroughsurveysandothermeans.ThedistrictcourtstatedtheanecdotalevidencesuggestedvariousformsofdiscriminationexistedwithinMontana’stransportationcontractingindustry,includingevidenceofanexclusive“goodoleboynetwork”thatmadeitdifficultforDBEstobreakintothemarket.Id.at*3.Thedistrictcourtsaidthatdespitethesefindings,theconsultingfirmrecommendedthatMDTcontinuetomonitorDBEutilizationwhileemployingonlyrace‐neutralmeanstomeetitsoverallgoal.Id.TheconsultingfirmrecommendedthatMDTconsidertheuseofrace‐consciousmeasuresifDBEutilizationdecreasedordidnotimprove.
Montanafollowedtherecommendationsprovidedinthestudy,andcontinuedusingonlyrace‐neutralmeansinitsefforttoaccomplishitsoverallgoalforDBEutilization.Id.Basedonthestatisticalanalysisprovidedinthestudy,MontanaestablishedanoverallDBEutilizationgoalof5.83percent.Id.
Montana’s DBE utilization after ceasing the use of contract goals.Thedistrictcourtfoundthatin2006,MontanaachievedaDBEutilizationrateof13.1percent,however,afterMontanaceasedusingcontractgoalstoachieveitsoverallgoal,therateofDBEutilizationdeclinedsharply.2014WL6686734at*3.Theutilizationratedropped,accordingtothedistrictcourt,to5percentin2007,3percentin2008,2.5percentin2009,0.8percentin2010,andin2011,itwas2.8percentId.Inresponsetothisdecline,forfiscalyears2011‐2014,thedistrictcourtsaidMDTemployedcontractgoalsoncertainUSDOTcontractsinordertoachieve3.27percentagepointsofMontana’soverallgoalof5.83percentDBEutilization.
MDTthenconductedandpreparedanewGoalMethodologyforDBEutilizationforfederalfiscalyears2014‐2016.Id.USDOTapprovedthenewandcurrentgoalmethodologyforMDT,whichdoesnotprovidefortheuseofcontractgoalstomeettheoverallgoal.Id.Thus,thenewoverallgoalistobemadeentirelythroughtheuseofrace‐neutralmeans.Id.
Mountain West’s claims for relief.MountainWestsoughtdeclaratoryandinjunctiverelief,includingprospectiverelief,againsttheindividualdefendants,andsoughtmonetarydamagesagainsttheStateofMontanaandtheMDTforallegedviolationofTitleVI.2014WL6686734at*3.MountainWest’sclaimformonetarydamagesisbasedonitsclaimthatonthreeoccasionsitwasalow‐quotingsubcontractortoaprimecontractorsubmittingabidtotheMDTonaprojectthatutilizedcontractgoals,andthatdespitebeingalow‐quotingbidder,MountainWestwasnotawardedthecontract.Id.MountainWestbringsanas‐appliedchallengetoMontana’sDBEprogram.Id.
The two‐prong test to demonstrate that a DBE program is narrowly tailored.TheCourt,citingAGC,SanDiegov.CaliforniaDOT,713F.3d1187,1196,statedthatunderthetwo‐prongtestestablishedinWesternStates,inordertodemonstratethatitsDBEprogramisnarrowlytailored,(1)thestatemustestablishthepresenceofdiscriminationwithinitstransportationcontractingindustry,and(2)theremedialprogrammustbelimitedtothoseminoritygroupsthathaveactuallysuffereddiscrimination.MountainWest,2017WL2179120at*2,Memorandum,May16,2017,at6‐7.
![Page 283: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/283.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 157
District Court Holding in 2014 and the Appeal.ThedistrictcourtgrantedsummaryjudgmenttotheState,andMountainWestappealed.SeeMountainWestHoldingCo.,Inc.v.TheStateofMontana,MontanaDOT,etal.2014WL6686734(D.Mont.Nov.26,2014),dismissedinpart,reversedinpart,andremanded,U.S.CourtofAppeals,NinthCircuit,DocketNos.14‐36097and15‐35003,Memorandum2017WL2179120at**1‐4(9thCir.May16,2017).Montanaalsoappealedthedistrictcourt’sthresholddeterminationthatMountainWesthadaprivaterightofactionunderTitleVI,anditappealedthedistrictcourt’sdenialoftheState’smotiontostrikeanexpertreportsubmittedinsupportofMountainWest’smotion.
Ninth Circuit Holding.TheNinthCircuitCourtofAppealsinitsMemornadumopiniondismissedMountainWest’sappealasmoottotheextentMountainWestpursuesequitableremedies,affirmedthedistrictcourt’sdeterminationthatMountainWesthasaprivaterighttoenforceTitleVI,affirmedthedistrictcourt’sdecisiontoconsiderthedisputedexpertreportbyMountainWest’sexpertwitness,andreversedtheordergrantingsummaryjudgmenttotheState.2017WL2179120at**1‐4(9thCir.May16,2017),U.S.CourtofAppeals,NinthCircuit,DocketNos.14‐36097and15‐35003,Memorandum,at3,5,11.
Mootness.TheNinthCircuitfoundthatMontanadoesnotcurrentlyemploygender‐orrace‐consciousgoals,andthedataitrelieduponasjustificationforitspreviousgoalsarenowseveralyearsold.TheCourtthusheldthatMountainWest’sclaimsforinjunctiveanddeclaratoryreliefarethereforemoot.MountainWest,2017WL2179120at*2(9thCir.),Memorandum,May16,2017,at4.
TheCourtalsoheld,however,thatMountainWest’sTitleVIclaimfordamagesisnotmoot.2017WL2179120at**1‐2.TheCourtstatedthataplaintiffmayseekdamagestoremedyviolationsofTitleVI,see42U.S.C.§2000d‐7(a)(1)‐(2);andMountainWesthassoughtdamages.Claimsfordamages,accordingtotheCourt,donotbecomemootevenifchangestoachallengedprogrammakeclaimsforprospectivereliefmoot.Id.
Theappeal,theNinthCircuitheld,isthereforedismissedwithrespecttoMountainWest’sclaimsforinjunctiveanddeclaratoryrelief;andonlytheclaimfordamagesunderTitleVIremainsinthecase.MountainWest,2017WL2179120at**1(9thCir.),Memorandum,May16,2017,at4.
Private Right of Action and Discrimination under Title VI.TheCourtconcludedforthereasonsfoundinthedistrictcourt’sorderthatMountainWestmaystateaprivateclaimfordamagesagainstMontanaunderTitleVI.Id.at*2.ThedistrictcourthadgrantedsummaryjudgmenttoMontanaonMountainWest’sclaimsfordiscriminationunderTitleVI.
Montanadoesnotdisputethatitsprogramtookraceintoaccount.TheNinthCircuitheldthatclassificationsbasedonracearepermissible“onlyiftheyarenarrowlytailoredmeasuresthatfurthercompellinggovernmentalinterests.”MountainWest,2017WL2179120(9thCir.)at*2,Memorandum,May16,2017,at6‐7.W.StatesPaving,407F.3dat990(quotingAdarandConstructors,Inc.v.Peña,515U.S.200,227(1995)).AsinWesternStatesPaving,theCourtappliedthesametesttoclaimsofunconstitutionaldiscriminationanddiscriminationinviolationofTitleVI.MountainWest,2017WL2179120at*2,n.2,Memorandum,May16,2017,at6,n.2;see,407F.3dat987.
![Page 284: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/284.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 158
Montana,theCourtfoundbearstheburdentojustifyanyracialclassifications.Id.Inanas‐appliedchallengetoastate’sDBEcontractingprogram,“(1)thestatemustestablishthepresenceofdiscriminationwithinitstransportationcontractingindustry,and(2)theremedialprogrammustbe‘limitedtothoseminoritygroupsthathaveactuallysuffereddiscrimination.’”MountainWest,2017WL2179120at*2(9thCir.),Memorandum,May16,2017,at6‐7,quoting,Assoc.Gen.ContractorsofAm.v.Cal.Dep’tofTransp.,713F.3d1187,1196(9thCir.2013)(quotingW.StatesPaving,407F.3dat997‐99).Discriminationmaybeinferredfrom“asignificantstatisticaldisparitybetweenthenumberofqualifiedminoritycontractorswillingandabletoperformaparticularserviceandthenumberofsuchcontractorsactuallyengagedbythelocalityorthelocality’sprimecontractors.”MountainWest,2017WL2179120at*2(9thCir.),Memorandum,May16,2017,at6‐7,quoting,CityofRichmondv.J.A.CrosonCo.,488U.S.469,509(1989).
Here,thedistrictcourtheldthatMontanahadsatisfieditsburden.Inreachingthisconclusion,thedistrictcourtreliedonthreetypesofevidenceofferedbyMontana.First,itcitedastudy,whichreporteddisparitiesinprofessionalservicescontractawardsinMontana.Second,thedistrictcourtnotedthatparticipationbyDBEsdeclinedafterMontanaabandonedrace‐consciousgoalsintheyearsfollowingthedecisioninWesternStatesPaving,407F.3d983.Third,thedistrictcourtcitedanecdotesofa“goodol’boys”networkwithintheState’scontractingindustry.MountainWest,2017WL2179120at*3(9thCir.),Memorandum,May16,2017,at7.
TheNinthCircuitreversedthedistrictcourtandheldthatsummaryjudgmentwasimproperinlightofgenuinedisputesofmaterialfactastothestudy’sanalysis,andbecausethesecondtwocategoriesofevidencewereinsufficienttoproveahistoryofdiscrimination.MountainWest,2017WL2179120at*3(9thCir.),Memorandum,May16,2017,at7.
Disputes of fact as to study.MountainWest’sexperttestifiedthatthestudyreliedonseveralquestionableassumptionsandanopaquemethodologytoconcludethatprofessionalservicescontractswereawardedonadiscriminatorybasis.Id.at*3.TheNinthCircuitpointedoutafewexamplesthatitfoundillustratedtheareasinwhichtherearedisputesoffactastowhetherthestudysufficientlysupportedMontana’sactions:
1. NinthCircuitstatedthatitscasesrequirestatestoascertainwhetherlower‐than‐expectedDBEparticipationisattributabletofactorsotherthanraceorgender.W.StatesPaving,407F.3dat1000‐01.MountainWestarguesthatthestudydidnotexplainwhetherorhowitaccountedforagivenfirm’ssize,age,geography,orothersimilarfactors.Thereport’sauthorswereunabletoexplaintheiranalysisindepositionsforthiscase.Indeed,theCourtnoted,evenMontanaappearstohavequestionedthevalidityofthestudy’sstatisticalresultsMountainWest,2017WL2179120at*3(9thCir.),Memorandum,May16,2017,at8.
2. ThestudyreliedonatelephonesurveyofasampleofMontanacontractors.MountainWestarguedthat(a)itisunclearhowthestudyselectedthatsample,(b)onlyasmallpercentageofsurveyedcontractorsrespondedtoquestions,and(c)itisunclearwhetherresponsivecontractorswererepresentativeofnonresponsivecontractors.2017WL2179120at*3(9thCir.May16,2017),Memorandumat8‐9.
3. Thestudyreliedonverysmallsamplesizesbutdidnotestsforstatisticalsignificance,andthestudyconsultantadmittedthat“someofthepopulationsampleswereverysmalland
![Page 285: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/285.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 159
theresultmaynotbesignificantstatistically.”2017WL2179120at*3(9thCir.May16,2017),Memorandumat8‐9.
4. MountainWestarguedthatthestudygaveequalweighttoprofessionalservicescontractsandconstructioncontracts,butprofessionalservicescontractscomposedlessthantenpercentoftotalcontractvolumeintheState’stransportationcontractingindustry.2017WL2179120at*3(9thCir.May16,2017),Memorandumat9.
5. MountainWestarguedthatMontanaincorrectlycomparedtheproportionofavailablesubcontractorstotheproportionofprimecontractdollarsawarded.Thedistrictcourtdidnotaddressthiscriticismorexplainwhythestudy’scomparisonwasappropriate.2017WL2179120at*3(9thCir.May16,2017),Memorandumat9.
The post‐2005 decline in participation by DBEs.TheNinthCircuitwasunabletoaffirmthedistrictcourt’sorderinrelianceonthedecreaseinDBEparticipationafter2005.InWesternStatesPaving,itwasheldthatadeclineinDBEparticipationafterrace‐andgender‐basedpreferencesarehaltedisnotnecessarilyevidenceofdiscriminationagainstDBEs.MountainWest,2017WL2179120at*3(9thCir.),Memorandum,May16,2017,at9,quotingWesternStates,407F.3dat999(“If[minoritygroupshavenotsufferedfromdiscrimination],thentheDBEprogramprovidesminoritieswhohavenotencountereddiscriminatorybarrierswithanunconstitutionalcompetitiveadvantageattheexpenseofbothnon‐minoritiesandanyminoritygroupsthathaveactuallybeentargetedfordiscrimination.”);id.at1001(“ThedisparitybetweentheproportionofDBEperformanceoncontractsthatincludeaffirmativeactioncomponentsandonthosewithoutsuchprovisionsdoesnotprovideanyevidenceofdiscriminationagainstDBEs.”).Id.
TheNinthCircuitalsocitedtotheU.S.DOTstatementmadetotheCourtinWesternStates.MountainWest,2017WL2179120at*3(9thCir.),Memorandum,May16,2017,at10,quoting,U.S.Dep’tofTransp.,WesternStatesPavingCo.CaseQ&A(Dec.16,2014)(“IncalculatingavailabilityofDBEs,[astate’s]studyshouldnotrelyonnumbersthatmayhavebeeninflatedbyrace‐consciousprogramsthatmaynothavebeennarrowlytailored.”).
Anecdotal evidence of discrimination.TheNinthCircuitsaidthatwithoutastatisticalbasis,theStatecannotrelyonanecdotalevidencealone.MountainWest,2017WL2179120at*3(9thCir.),Memorandum,May16,2017,at10,quoting,CoralConst.Co.v.KingCty.,941F.2d910,919(9thCir.1991)(“Whileanecdotalevidencemaysufficetoproveindividualclaimsofdiscrimination,rarely,ifever,cansuchevidenceshowasystemicpatternofdiscriminationnecessaryfortheadoptionofanaffirmativeactionplan.”);andquoting,Croson,488U.S.at509(“[E]videnceofapatternofindividualdiscriminatoryactscan,ifsupportedbyappropriatestatisticalproof,lendsupporttoalocalgovernment’sdeterminationthatbroaderremedialreliefisjustified.”).Id.
Insum,theNinthCircuitfoundthatbecauseitmustviewtherecordinthelightmostfavorabletoMountainWest’scase,itconcludedthattherecordprovidesaninadequatebasisforsummaryjudgmentinMontana’sfavor.2017WL2179120at*3.
Conclusion.TheNinthCircuitthusreversedandremandedforthedistrictcourttoconductwhateverfurtherproceedingsitconsidersmostappropriate,includingtrialortheresumptionofpretriallitigation.Thus,thecasewasdismissedinpart,reversedinpart,andremandedtothe
![Page 286: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/286.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 160
districtcourt.MountainWest,2017WL2179120at*4(9thCir.),Memorandum,May16,2017,at11.
2. Midwest Fence Corporation v. U.S. Department of Transportation, Illinois Department of Transportation, Illinois State Toll Highway Authority, 840 F.3d 932, 2016 WL 6543514 (7th Cir. 2016), cert. denied, 2017 WL 497345 (2017)
PlaintiffMidwestFenceCorporationisaguardrailsandfencingspecialtycontractorthatusuallybidsonprojectsasasubcontractor.2016WL6543514at*1.MidwestFenceisnotaDBE.Id.MidwestFenceallegesthatthedefendants’DBEprogramsviolateditsFourteenthAmendmentrighttoequalprotectionunderthelaw,andchallengestheUnitedStatesDOTFederalDBEProgramandtheimplementationoftheFederalDBEProgrambytheIllinoisDOT(IDOT).Id.MidwestFencealsochallengestheIllinoisStateTollHighwayAuthority(Tollway)anditsimplementationofitsDBEProgram.Id.
Thedistrictcourtgrantedallthedefendants’motionsforsummaryjudgment.Id.at*1.SeeMidwestFenceCorp.v.U.S.DepartmentofTransportation,etal.,84F.Supp.3d705(N.D.Ill.2015)(seediscussionofdistrictcourtdecisionbelow).TheSeventhCircuitCourtofAppealsaffirmedthegrantofsummaryjudgmentbythedistrictcourt.Id.ThecourtheldthatitjoinstheotherfederalcircuitcourtsofappealinholdingthattheFederalDBEProgramisfaciallyconstitutional,theprogramservesacompellinggovernmentinterestinremedyingahistoryofdiscriminationinhighwayconstructioncontracting,theprogramprovidesstateswithamplediscretiontotailortheirDBEprogramstotherealitiesoftheirownmarketsandrequirestheuseofrace–andgender‐neutralmeasuresbeforeturningtorace‐andgender‐consciousmeasures.Id.
ThecourtofappealsalsoheldtheIDOTandTollwayprogramssurvivestrictscrutinybecausethesestatedefendantsestablishasubstantialbasisinevidencetosupporttheneedtoremedytheeffectsofpastdiscriminationintheirmarkets,andtheprogramsarenarrowlytailoredtoservethatremedialpurpose.Id.at*1.
Procedural history.MidwestFenceassertedthefollowingprimarytheoriesinitschallengetotheFederalDBEProgram,IDOT’simplementationofit,andtheTollway’sownprogram:
1. Thefederalregulationsprescribeamethodforsettingindividualcontractgoalsthatplacesanundueburdenonnon‐DBEsubcontractors,especiallycertainkindsofsubcontractors,includingguardrailandfencingcontractorslikeMidwestFence.
2. Thepresumptionofsocialandeconomicdisadvantageisnottailoredadequatelytoreflectdifferencesinthecircumstancesactuallyfacedbywomenandthevariousracialandethnicgroupswhoreceivethatpresumption.
3. Thefederalregulationsareunconstitutionallyvague,particularlywithrespecttogoodfaitheffortstojustifyafront‐endwaiver.
Id.at*3‐4.MidwestFencealsoassertedthatIDOT’simplementationoftheFederalDBEProgramisunconstitutionalforessentiallythesamereasons.And,MidwestFencechallengestheTollway’sprogramonitsfaceandasapplied.Id.at*4.
![Page 287: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/287.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 161
ThedistrictcourtfoundthatMidwestFencehadstandingtobringmostofitsclaimsandonthemerits,andthecourtupheldthefacialconstitutionalityoftheFederalDBEProgram.84F.Supp.3dat722‐23729;id.at*4.
ThedistrictcourtalsoconcludedMidwestFencedidnotrebuttheevidenceofdiscriminationthatIDOTofferedtojustifyitsprogram,andMidwestFencehadpresentedno“affirmativeevidence”thatIDOT’simplementationundulyburdenednon‐DBEs,failedtomakeuseofrace‐neutralalternatives,orlackedflexibility.84F.Supp.3dat733,737;id.at*4.
ThedistrictcourtnotedthatMidwestFence’schallengetotheTollway’sprogramparalleledthechallengetoIDOT’sprogram,andconcludedthattheTollway,likeIDOT,hadestablishedastrongbasisinevidenceforitsprogram.84F.Supp.3dat737,739;id.at*4.Inaddition,thecourtconcludedthat,likeIDOT’sprogram,theTollway’sprogramimposedaminimalburdenonnon‐DBEs,employedanumberofrace‐neutralmeasures,andofferedsubstantialflexibility.84F.Supp.3dat739‐740;id.at*4.
Standing to challenge the DBE Programs generally.ThedefendantsarguedthatMidwestFencelackedstanding.ThecourtofappealsheldthatthedistrictcourtcorrectlyfoundthatMidwestFencehasstanding.Id.at*5.Thecourtofappealsstatedthatbyallegingandthenofferingevidenceoflostbids,decreasedrevenue,difficultieskeepingitsbusinessafloatasaresultoftheDBEprogram,anditsinabilitytocompeteforcontractsonanequalfootingwithDBEs,MidwestFenceshowedbothcausationandredressability.Id.at*5.
ThecourtofappealsdistinguisheditsrulingintheDunnetBayConstructionCo.v.Borggren,799F.3d676(7thCir.2015),holdingthattherewasnostandingfortheplaintiffDunnetBaybasedonanunusualandcomplexsetoffactsunderwhichitwouldhavebeenimpossiblefortheplaintiffDunnetBaytohavewonthecontractitsoughtandforwhichitsoughtdamages.IDOTdidnotawardthecontracttoanyoneunderthefirstbidandhadre‐letthecontract,thusDunnetBaysufferednoinjurybecauseoftheDBEprograminthefirstbid.Id.at*5.ThecourtofappealsheldthiscaseisdistinguishablefromDunnetBaybecauseMidwestFenceseeksprospectivereliefthatwouldenableittocompetewithDBEsonanequalbasismoregenerallythaninDunnetBay.Id.at*5.
Standing to challenge the IDOT Target Market Program.ThedistrictcourthadcarvedoutonenarrowexceptiontoitsfindingthatMidwestFencehadstandinggenerally,findingthatMidwestFencelackedstandingtochallengetheIDOT“targetmarketprogram.”Id.at*6.ThecourtofappealsfoundthatnoevidenceintherecordestablishedMidwestFencebidonorlostanycontractssubjecttotheIDOTtargetmarketprogram.Id.at*6.ThecourtstatedthatIDOThadnotsetasideanyguardrailandfencingcontractsunderthetargetmarketprogram.Id.Therefore,MidwestFencedidnotshowthatithadsufferedfromaninabilitytocompeteonanequalfootinginthebiddingprocesswithrespecttocontractswithinthetargetmarketprogram.Id.
Facial versus as‐applied challenge to the USDOT Program.Inthisappeal,MidwestFencedidnotchallengewhetherUSDOThadestablisheda“compellinginterest”toremedytheeffectsofpastorpresentdiscrimination.Thus,itdidnotchallengethenationalcompellinginterestinremedyingpastdiscriminationinitsclaimsagainsttheFederalDBEProgram.Id.at*6.Therefore,thecourtofappealsfocusedonwhetherthefederalprogramisnarrowlytailored.Id.
![Page 288: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/288.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 162
First,thecourtaddressedapreliminaryissue,namely,whetherMidwestFencecouldmaintainanas‐appliedchallengeagainstUSDOTandtheFederalDBEProgramorwhether,asthedistrictcourtheld,theclaimagainstUSDOTislimitedtoafacialchallenge.Id.MidwestFencesoughtadeclarationthatthefederalregulationsareunconstitutionalasappliedinIllinois.Id.ThedistrictcourtrejectedtheattempttobringthatclaimagainstUSDOT,treatingitasapplyingonlytoIDOT.Id.at*6citingMidwestFence,84F.Supp.3dat718.Thecourtofappealsagreedwiththedistrictcourt.Id.
Thecourtofappealspointedoutthataprincipalfeatureofthefederalregulationsistheirflexibilityandadaptabilitytolocalconditions,andthatflexibilityisimportanttotheconstitutionalityoftheFederalDBEProgram,includingbecausearace‐andgender‐consciousprogrammustbenarrowlytailoredtoservethecompellinggovernmentalinterest.Id.at*6.Theflexibilityinregulations,accordingtothecourt,makesthestate,notUSDOT,primarilyresponsibleforimplementingtheirownprogramsinwaysthatcomplywiththeEqualProtectionClause.Id.at*6.Thecourtsaidthatastate,notUSDOT,isthecorrectpartytodefendachallengetoitsimplementationofitsprogram.Id.Thus,thecourtheldthedistrictcourtdidnoterrbytreatingtheclaimsagainstUSDOTasonlyafacialchallengetothefederalregulations.Id.
Federal DBE Program: Narrow Tailoring.TheSeventhCircuitnotedthattheEighth,Ninth,andTenthCircuitsallfoundtheFederalDBEProgramconstitutionalonitsface,andtheSeventhCircuitagreedwiththeseothercircuits.Id.at*7.Thecourtfoundthatnarrowtailoringrequires“aclosematchbetweentheevilagainstwhichtheremedyisdirectedandthetermsoftheremedy.”Id.Thecourtstateditlookstofourfactorsindeterminingnarrowtailoring:(a)“thenecessityforthereliefandtheefficacyofalternative[race‐neutral]remedies,”(b)“theflexibilityanddurationoftherelief,includingtheavailabilityofwaiverprovisions,”(c)“therelationshipofthenumericalgoalstotherelevantlabor[orhere,contracting]market,”and(d)“theimpactofthereliefontherightsofthirdparties.”Id.at*7quotingUnitedStatesv.Paradise,480U.S.149,171(1987).TheSeventhCircuitalsopointedoutthattheTenthCircuitaddedtothisanalysisthequestionofover‐orunder‐inclusiveness.Id.at*7.
Inapplyingthesefactorstodeterminenarrowtailoring,thecourtsaidthatfirst,theFederalDBEProgramrequiresstatestomeetasmuchaspossibleoftheiroverallDBEparticipationgoalsthroughrace‐andgender‐neutralmeans.Id.at*7,citing49C.F.R.§26.51(a).Next,onitsface,thefederalprogramisbothflexibleandlimitedinduration.Id.Quotasareflatlyprohibited,andstatesmayapplyforwaivers,includingwaiversof“anyprovisionsregardingadministrativerequirements,overallgoals,contractgoalsorgoodfaithefforts,”§26.15(b).Id.at*7.Theregulationsalsorequirestatestoremainflexibleastheyadministertheprogramoverthecourseoftheyear,includingcontinuallyreassessingtheirDBEparticipationgoalsandwhethercontractgoalsarenecessary.Id.
ThecourtpointedoutthatastateneednotsetacontractgoaloneveryUSDOT‐assistedcontract,normusttheysetthosegoalsatthesamepercentageastheoverallparticipationgoal.Id.at*7.Together,thecourtfound,alloftheseprovisionsallowforsignificantandongoingflexibility.Id.at*8.StatesarenotlockedintotheirinitialDBEparticipationgoals.Id.Theiruseofcontractgoalsismeanttoremainfluid,reflectingastate’sprogresstowardsoverallDBEgoal.Id.
![Page 289: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/289.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 163
Asforduration,thecourtsaidthatCongresshasrepeatedlyreauthorizedtheprogramaftertakingnewlooksattheneedforit.Id.at*8.And,asnoted,statesmustmonitorprogresstowardmeetingDBEgoalsonaregularbasisandalterthegoalsifnecessary.Id.Theymuststopusingrace‐andgender‐consciousmeasuresifthosemeasuresarenolongerneeded.Id.
Thecourtfoundthatthenumericalgoalsarealsotiedtotherelevantmarkets.Id.at*8.Inaddition,theregulationsprescribeaprocessforsettingaDBEparticipationgoalthatfocusesoninformationaboutthespecificmarket,andthatitisintendedtoreflectthelevelofDBEparticipationyouwouldexpectabsenttheeffectsofdiscrimination.Id.at*8,citing§26.45(b).ThecourtstatedthattheregulationsthusinstructstatestosettheirDBEparticipationgoalstoreflectactualDBEavailabilityintheirjurisdictions,asmodifiedbyotherrelevantfactorslikeDBEcapacity.Id.at*8.
Midwest Fence “mismatch” argument: burden on third parties.MidwestFence,thecourtsaid,focusesitscriticismontheburdenofthirdpartiesandarguestheprogramisover‐inclusive.Id.at*8.But,thecourtfound,theregulationsincludemechanismstominimizetheburdenstheprogramplacesonnon‐DBEthirdparties.Id.Aprimaryexample,thecourtpointsout,issuppliedin§26.33(a),whichrequiresstatestotakestepstoaddressoverconcentrationofDBEsincertaintypesofworkiftheoverconcentrationundulyburdensnon‐DBEstothepointthattheycannolongerparticipateinthemarket.Id.at*8.Thecourtconcludedthatstandardscanberelaxedifuncompromisingenforcementwouldyieldnegativeconsequences,forexample,statescanobtainwaiversifspecialcircumstancesmakethestate’scompliancewithpartofthefederalprogram“impractical,”andcontractorswhofailtomeetaDBEcontractgoalcanstillbeawardedthecontractiftheyhavedocumentedgoodfaitheffortstomeetthegoal.Id.at*8,citing§26.51(a)and§26.53(a)(2).
MidwestFencearguedthata“mismatch”inthewaycontractgoalsarecalculatedresultsinaburdenthatfallsdisproportionatelyonspecialtysubcontractors.Id.at*8.Underthefederalregulations,thecourtnoted,states’overallgoalsaresetasapercentageofalltheirUSDOT‐assistedcontracts.Id.However,statesmaysetcontractgoals“onlyonthose[USDOT]‐assistedcontractsthathavesubcontractingpossibilities.”Id.,quoting§26.51(e)(1)(emphasisadded).
MidwestFencearguedthatbecauseDBEsmustbesmall,theyaregenerallyunabletocompeteforprimecontracts,andthistheyargueisthe“mismatch.”Id.at*8.WherecontractgoalsarenecessarytomeetanoverallDBEparticipationgoal,thosecontractgoalsaremetalmostentirelywithsubcontractordollars,which,MidwestFenceasserts,placesaheavyburdenonnon‐DBEsubcontractorswhileleavingnon‐DBEprimecontractorsintheclear.Id.at*8.
ThecourtgoesthroughahypotheticalexampletoexplaintheissueMidwestFencehasraisedasamismatchthatimposesadisproportionateburdenonspecialtysubcontractorslikeMidwestFence.Id.at*8.Intheexampleprovidedbythecourt,theoverallparticipationgoalforastatecallsforDBEstoreceiveacertainpercentageoftotalfunds,butinpracticeinthehypotheticalitrequiresthestatetoawardDBEsforlessthanalloftheavailablesubcontractorfundsbecauseitdeterminesthattherearenosubcontractingpossibilitiesonhalfthecontracts,thusrenderingthemineligibleforcontractgoals.Id.Themismatchisthatthefederalprogramrequiresthestatetosetitsoverallgoalonallfundsitwillspendoncontracts,butatthesametimethecontractseligibleforcontractgoalsmustbeonesthathavesubcontractingpossibilities.Id.Therefore,
![Page 290: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/290.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 164
accordingtoMidwestFence,inpracticetheparticipationgoalssetwouldrequirethestatetoawardDBEsfromtheavailablesubcontractorfundswhiletakingnobusinessawayfromtheprimecontractors.Id.
Thecourtstatedthatitfound“[t]hisprospectistroubling.”Id.at*9.ThecourtsaidthattheDBEprogramcanimposeadisproportionateburdenonsmall,specializednon‐DBEsubcontractors,especiallywhencomparedtolargerprimecontractorswithwhomDBEswouldcompetelessfrequently.Id.Thispotential,accordingtothecourt,foradisproportionateburden,however,doesnotrendertheprogramfaciallyunconstitutional.Id.ThecourtsaidthattheconstitutionalityoftheFederalDBEProgramdependsonhowitisimplemented.Id.
Thecourtpointedoutthatsomeofthesuggestedrace‐andgender‐neutralmeansthatstatescanuseunderthefederalprogramaredesignedtoincreaseDBEparticipationinprimecontractingandotherfieldswhereDBEparticipationhashistoricallybeenlow,suchasspecificallyencouragingstatestomakecontractsmoreaccessibletosmallbusinesses.Id.at*9,citing§26.39(b).ThecourtalsonotedthatthefederalprogramcontemplatesDBEs’abilitytocompeteequallyrequiringstatestoreportDBEparticipationasprimecontractorsandmakeseffortstodevelopthatpotential.Id.at*9.
ThecourtstatedthatstateswillcontinuetoresorttocontractgoalsthatopenthedoortothetypeofmismatchthatMidwestFencedescribes,buttheprogramonitsfacedoesnotcompelanunfairdistributionofburdens.Id.at*9.SmallspecialtycontractorsmayhavetobearatleastsomeoftheburdenscreatedbyremedyingpastdiscriminationundertheFederalDBEProgram,buttheSupremeCourthasindicatedthatinnocentthirdpartiesmayconstitutionallyberequiredtobearatleastsomeoftheburdenoftheremedy.Id.at*9.
Over‐Inclusive argument.MidwestFencealsoarguedthatthefederalprogramisover‐inclusivebecauseitgrantspreferencestogroupswithoutanalyzingtheextenttowhicheachgroupisactuallydisadvantaged.Id.at*9.Inresponse,thecourtmentionedtwofederal‐specificarguments,notingthatMidwestFence’scriticismsarebestanalyzedaspartofitsas‐appliedchallengeagainstthestatedefendants.Id.First,MidwestFencecontendsnothingprovesthatthedisparitiesrelieduponbythestudyconsultantwerecausedbydiscrimination.Id.at*9.Thecourtfoundthattojustifyitsprogram,USDOTdoesnotneeddefinitiveproofofdiscrimination,butmusthaveastrongbasisinevidencethatremedialactionisnecessarytoremedypastdiscrimination.Id.
Second,MidwestFenceattackswhatitperceivesastheone‐size‐fits‐allnatureoftheprogram,suggestingthattheregulationsoughttoprovidedifferentremediesfordifferentgroups,butinsteadthefederalprogramoffersasingleapproachtoallthedisadvantagedgroups,regardlessofthedegreeofdisparities.Id.at*9.ThecourtpointedoutMidwestFencedidnotarguethatanyofthegroupswerenotinfactdisadvantagedatall,andthatthefederalregulationsultimatelyrequireindividualizeddeterminations.Id.at*10.Eachpresumptivelydisadvantagedfirmownermustcertifythatheorsheis,infact,sociallyandeconomicallydisadvantaged,andthatpresumptioncanberebutted.Id.Inthisway,thecourtsaid,thefederalprogramrequiresstatestoextendbenefitsonlytothosewhoareactuallydisadvantaged.Id.
![Page 291: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/291.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 165
ThereforethecourtagreedwiththedistrictcourtthattheFederalDBEProgramisnarrowlytailoredonitsface,soitsurvivesstrictscrutiny.
Claims against IDOT and the Tollway: void for vagueness.MidwestFencearguedthatthefederalregulationsareunconstitutionallyvagueasappliedbyIDOTbecausetheregulationsfailtospecifywhatgoodfaitheffortsacontractormustmaketoqualifyforawaiver,andfocusesitsattackontheprovisionsoftheregulations,whichaddresspossiblecostdifferentialsintheuseofDBEs.Id.at*11.MidwestFencearguedthatAppendixAof49C.F.R.,Part26at¶IV(D)(2)istoovagueinitslanguageonwhenadifferenceinpriceissignificantenoughtojustifyfallingshortoftheDBEcontractgoal.Id.Thecourtfoundifthestandardseemsvague,thatislikelybecauseitwasmeanttobeflexible,andamorerigidstandardcouldeasilybetooarbitraryandhinderprimecontractors’abilitytoadjusttheirapproachestothecircumstancesofparticularprojects.Id.at*11.
ThecourtsaidMidwestFence’srealargumentseemstobethatinpractice,primecontractorserrtoofaronthesideofcaution,grantingsignificantpricepreferencestoDBEsinsteadoftakingtheriskoflosingacontractforfailuretomeettheDBEgoal.Id.at*12.MidwestFencecontendsthiscreatesadefactosystemofquotasbecausecontractorsbelievetheymustmeettheDBEgoalorlosethecontract.Id.ButAppendixAtotheregulations,thecourtnoted,cautionsagainstthisveryapproach.Id.Thecourtfoundflexibilityandtheavailabilityofwaiversaffectwhetheraprogramisnarrowlytailored,andthattheregulationscautionagainstquotas,provideexamplesofgoodfaitheffortsprimecontractorscanmakeandstatescanconsider,andinstructabiddertousegoodbusinessjudgmenttodecidewhetherapricedifferenceisreasonableorexcessive.Id.Forpurposesofcontractawards,thecourtholdsthisisenoughtogivefairnoticeofconductthatisforbiddenorrequired.Id.at*12.
Equal Protection challenge: compelling interest with strong basis in evidence.InrulingonthemeritsofMidwestFence’sequalprotectionclaimsbasedontheactionsofIDOTandtheTollway,thefirstissuethecourtaddressesiswhetherthestatedefendantshadacompellinginterestinenactingtheirprograms.Id.at*12.Thecourtstatedthatit,alongwiththeothercircuitcourtsofappeal,haveheldastateagencyisentitledtorelyonthefederalgovernment’scompellinginterestinremedyingtheeffectsofpastdiscriminationtojustifyitsownDBEplanforhighwayconstructioncontracting.Id.But,sincenotallofIDOT’scontractsarefederallyfunded,andtheTollwaydidnotreceivefederalfundingatall,withrespecttothosecontracts,thecourtsaiditmustconsiderwhetherIDOTandtheTollwayestablishedastrongbasisinevidencetosupporttheirprograms.Id.
IDOT program.IDOTreliedonanavailabilityandadisparitystudytosupportitsprogram.ThedisparitystudyfoundthatDBEsweresignificantlyunderutilizedasprimecontractorscomparingfirmavailabilityofprimecontractorsintheconstructionfieldtotheamountofdollarstheyreceivedinprimecontracts.Thedisparitystudycollectedutilizationrecords,definedIDOT’smarketarea,identifiedbusinessesthatwerewillingandabletoprovideneededservices,weightedfirmavailabilitytoreflectIDOT’scontractingpatternwithweightsassignedtodifferentareasbasedonthepercentageofdollarsexpendedinthoseareas,determinedwhethertherewasastatisticallysignificantunder‐utilizationofDBEsbycalculatingthedollarseachgroupwouldbeexpectedtoreceivebasedonavailability,calculatedthedifferencebetween
![Page 292: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/292.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 166
theexpectedandactualamountofcontractdollarsreceived,andensuredthatresultswerenotattributabletochance.Id.at*13.
ThecourtsaidthatthedisparitystudydetermineddisparityratiosthatwerestatisticallysignificantandthestudyfoundthatDBEsweresignificantlyunderutilizedasprimecontractors,notingthatafigurebelow0.80isgenerallyconsidered“solidevidenceofsystematicunder‐utilizationcallingforaffirmativeactiontocorrectit.”Id.at*13.ThestudyfoundthatDBEsmadeup25.55%ofprimecontractorsintheconstructionfield,received9.13%ofprimecontractsvaluedbelow$500,000and8.25%oftheavailablecontractdollarsinthatrange,yieldingadisparityratioof0.32forprimecontractsunder$500,000.Id.
Intherealmofcontractionsubcontracting,thestudyshowedthatDBEsmayhave29.24%ofavailablesubcontractors,andintheconstructionindustrytheyreceive44.62%ofavailablesubcontracts,butthosesubcontractsamountedtoonly10.65%ofavailablesubcontractingdollars.Id.at*13.This,accordingtothestudy,yieldedastatisticallysignificantdisparityratioof0.36,whichthecourtfoundlowenoughtosignalsystemicunder‐utilization.Id.
IDOTreliedonadditionaldatatojustifyitsprogram,includingconductingazero‐goalexperimentin2002andin2003,whenitdidnotapplyDBEgoalstocontracts.Id.at*13.Withoutcontractgoals,theshareofthecontracts’valuethatDBEsreceiveddroppeddramatically,tojust1.5%ofthetotalvalueofthecontracts.Id.at*13.AndinthosecontractsadvertisedwithoutaDBEgoal,theDBEsubcontractorparticipationratewas0.84%.
Tollway program.TollwayalsoreliedonadisparitystudylimitedtotheTollway’scontractingmarketarea.Thestudyuseda“customcensus”process,creatingadatabaseofrepresentativeprojects,identifyinggeographicandproductmarkets,countingbusinessesinthosemarkets,identifyingandverifyingwhichbusinessesareminority‐andwomen‐owned,andverifyingtheownershipstatusofalltheotherfirms.Id.at*13.ThestudyexaminedtheTollway’shistoricalcontractdata,reporteditsDBEutilizationasapercentageofcontractdollars,andcomparedDBEutilizationandDBEavailability,comingupwithdisparityindicesdividedbyraceandsex,aswellasbyindustrygroup.Id.
Thestudyfoundthatoutof115disparityindices,80showedstatisticallysignificantunder‐utilizationofDBEs.Id.at*14.Thestudydiscussedstatisticaldisparitiesinearningsandtheformationofbusinessesbyminoritiesandwomen,andconcludedthatastatisticallysignificantadverseimpactonearningswasobservedinboththeeconomyatlargeandintheconstructionandconstruction‐relatedprofessionalservicessector.”Id.at*14.Thestudyalsofoundwomenandminoritiesarenotaslikelytostarttheirownbusiness,andthatminoritybusinessformationrateswouldlikelybesubstantiallyandsignificantlyhigherifmarketsoperatedinarace‐andsex‐neutralmanner.Id.
Thestudyusedregressionanalysistoassessdifferencesinwages,business‐ownerearnings,andbusiness‐formationratesbetweenwhitemenandminoritiesandwomeninthewiderconstructioneconomy.Id.at*14.Thestudyfoundstatisticallysignificantdisparitiesremainedbetweenwhitemenandothergroups,controllingforvariousindependentvariablessuchasage,education,location,industryaffiliation,andtime.Id.Thedisparities,accordingtothestudy,wereconsistentwithamarketaffectedbydiscrimination.Id.
![Page 293: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/293.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 167
TheTollwayalsopresentedadditionalevidence,includingthattheTollwaysetaspirationalparticipationgoalsonasmallnumberofcontracts,andthoseattemptsfailed.Id.at*14.In2004,thecourtnotedtheTollwaydidnotawardasingleprimecontractorsubcontracttoaDBE,andtheDBEparticipationratein2005was0.01%acrossallconstructioncontracts.Id.Inaddition,theTollwayalsoconsidered,likeIDOT,anecdotalevidencethatprovidedtestimonyofseveralDBEownersregardingbarriersthattheythemselvesfaced.Id.
Midwest Fence’s criticisms.MidwestFence’sexpertconsultantarguedthatthestudyconsultantfailedtoaccountforDBEs’readiness,willingness,andabilitytodobusinesswithIDOTandtheTollway,andthatthemethodofassessingreadinessandwillingnesswasflawed.Id.at*14.Inaddition,theconsultantforMidwestFencearguedthatoneofthestudiesfailedtoaccountforDBEs’relativecapacity,“meaningafirm’sabilitytotakeonmorethanonecontractatatime.”Thecourtnotedthatoneofthestudyconsultantsdidnotaccountforfirmcapacityandtheotherstudyconsultantfoundnoeffectivewaytoaccountforcapacity.Id.at*14,n.2.Thecourtsaidonestudydidperformaregressionanalysistomeasurerelativecapacityandlimiteditsdisparityanalysistocontractsunder$500,000,whichwas,accordingtothestudyconsultant,totakecapacityintoaccounttotheextentpossible.Id.
ThecourtpointedoutthatonemajorproblemwithMidwestFence’sreportisthattheconsultantdidnotperformanysubstantiveanalysisofhisown.Id.at*15.TheevidenceofferedbyMidwestFenceanditsconsultantwas,accordingtothecourt,“speculativeatbest.”Id.at*15.Thecourtsaidtheconsultant’srelativecapacityanalysiswassimilarlyspeculative,arguingthattheassumptionthatfirmshavethesameabilitytoprovideservicesupto$500,000maynotbetrueinpractice,andthatiftheestimatesofcapacityaretoolowtheresultingdisparityindexoverstatesthedegreeofdisparitythatexists.Id.at*15.
ThecourtstatedMidwestFence’sexpertsimilarlyarguedthattheexistenceoftheDBEprogram“may”causeanupwardbiasinavailability,thatanyobservationsofthepublicsectoringeneral“may”beaffectedbytheDBEprogram’sexistence,andthatdatabecomelessrelevantastimepasses.Id.at*15.ThecourtfoundthatgiventhesubstantialutilizationdisparityasshowninthereportsbyIDOTandtheTollwaydefendants,MidwestFence’sspeculativecritiquesdidnotraiseagenuineissueoffactastowhetherthedefendantshadasubstantialbasisinevidencetobelievethatactionwasneededtoremedydiscrimination.Id.at*15.
ThecourtrejectedMidwestFence’sargumentthatrequiringittoprovideanindependentstatisticalanalysisplacesanimpossibleburdenonitduetothetimeandexpensethatwouldberequired.Id.at*15.Thecourtnotedthattheburdenisinitiallyonthegovernmenttojustifyitsprograms,andthatsincethestatedefendantsofferedevidencetodoso,theburdenthenshiftedtoMidwestFencetoshowagenuineissueofmaterialfactastowhetherthestatedefendantshadasubstantialbasisinevidenceforadoptingtheirDBEprograms.Id.Speculativecriticismaboutpotentialproblems,thecourtfound,willnotcarrythatburden.Id.
Withregardtothecapacityquestion,thecourtnoteditwasMidwestFence’sstrongestcriticismandthatcourtshadrecognizeditasaseriousprobleminothercontexts.Id.at*15.Thecourtsaidthefailuretoaccountforrelativecapacitydidnotunderminethesubstantialbasisinevidenceinthisparticularcase.Id.at*15.MidwestFencedidnotexplainhowtoaccountfor
![Page 294: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/294.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 168
relativecapacity.Id.Inaddition,ithasbeenrecognized,thecourtstated,thatdefectsincapacityanalysesarenotfatalinandofthemselves.Id.at*15.
Thecourtconcludedthatthestudiesshowstrikingutilizationdisparitiesinspecificindustriesintherelevantgeographicmarketareas,andtheyareconsistentwiththeanecdotalandlessformalevidencedefendantshadoffered.Id.at*15.ThecourtfoundMidwestFence’sexpert’s“speculation”thatfailuretoaccountforrelativecapacitymighthavebiasedDBEavailabilityupwarddoesnotunderminethestatisticalcoreofthestrongbasisinevidencerequired.Id.
Inaddition,thecourtrejectedMidwestFence’sargumentthatthedisparitystudiesdonotprovediscrimination,notingagainthatastateneednotconclusivelyprovetheexistenceofdiscriminationtoestablishastrongbasisinevidenceforconcludingthatremedialactionisnecessary,andthatwheregrossstatisticaldisparitiescanbeshown,theyalonemayconstituteprimafacieproofofapatternorpracticeofdiscrimination.Id.at*15.ThecourtalsorejectedMidwestFence’sattackontheanecdotalevidencestatingthattheanecdotalevidencebolstersthestatedefendants’statisticalanalyses.Id.at*15.
InconnectionwithMidwestFence’sargumentrelatingtotheTollwaydefendant,MidwestFencearguedthattheTollway’ssupportingdatawasfrombeforeitinstituteditsDBEprogram.Id.at*16.TheTollwayrespondedbyarguingthatitusedthebestdataavailableandthatinanyeventitsdatasetsshowdisparities.Id.at*16.ThecourtfoundthispointpersuasiveevenassumingsomeoftheTollway’sdatawerenotexact.Id.ThecourtsaidthatwhileeverysinglenumberintheTollway’s“arsenalofevidence”maynotbeexact,theoverallpicturestillshowsbeyondreasonabledisputeamarketplacewithsystemicunder‐utilizationofDBEsfarbelowthedisparityindexlowerthan80asanindicationofdiscrimination,andthatMidwestFence’s“abstractcriticisms”donotunderminethatcoreofevidence.Id.at*16.
Narrow Tailoring.ThecourtappliedthenarrowtailoringfactorstodeterminewhetherIDOT’sandtheTollway’simplementationoftheirDBEprogramsyieldedaclosematchbetweentheevilagainstwhichtheremedyisdirectedandthetermsoftheremedy.Id.at*16.Firstthecourtaddressedthenecessityforthereliefandtheefficacyofalternativerace‐neutralremediesfactor.Id.ThecourtreiteratedthatMidwestFencehasnotunderminedthedefendants’strongcombinationofstatisticalandotherevidencetoshowthattheirprogramsareneededtoremedydiscrimination.Id.
BothIDOTandtheTollway,accordingtothecourt,userace‐andgender‐neutralalternatives,andtheundisputedfactsshowthatthosealternativeshavenotbeensufficienttoremedydiscrimination.Id.ThecourtnotedthattherecordshowsIDOTusesnearlyallofthemethodsdescribedinthefederalregulationstomaximizeaportionofthegoalthatwillbeachievedthroughrace‐neutralmeans.Id.
Asforflexibility,bothIDOTandtheTollwaymakefront‐endwaiversavailablewhenacontractorhasmadegoodfaitheffortstocomplywithaDBEgoal.Id.at*17.ThecourtrejectedMidwestFence’sargumentsthattherewerealownumberofwaiversgranted,andthatcontractorsfearofhavingawaiverdeniedshowedthesystemwasadefactoquotasystem.Id.ThecourtfoundthatIDOTandtheTollwayhavenotgrantedlargenumbersofwaivers,buttherewasalsonoevidencethattheyhavedeniedlargenumbersofwaivers.Id.Thecourtpointedoutthatthe
![Page 295: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/295.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 169
evidencefromMidwestFencedoesnotshowthatdefendantsareresponsibleforfailingtograntfront‐endwaiversthatthecontractorsdonotrequest.Id.
Thecourtstatedintheabsenceofevidencethatdefendantsfailedtoadheretothegeneralgoodfaitheffortguidelinesandarbitrarilydenyordiscouragefront‐endwaiverrequests,MidwestFence’scontentionthatcontractorsfearlosingcontractsiftheyaskforawaiverdoesnotmakethesystemaquotasystem.Id.at*17.MidwestFence’sownevidence,thecourtstated,showsthatIDOTgrantedin2007,57of63front‐endwaiverrequests,andin2010,itgranted21of35front‐endwaiverrequests.Id.at*17.Inaddition,theTollwaygrantedatleastsomefront‐endwaiversinvolving1.02%ofcontractdollars.Id.Withoutevidencethatfarmorewaiverswererequested,thecourtwassatisfiedthateventhislowtotalbytheTollwaydoesnotraiseagenuinedisputeoffact.Id.
Thecourtalsorejectedas“underdeveloped”MidwestFence’sargumentthatthecourtshouldlookatthedollarvalueofwaiversgrantedratherthantherawnumberofwaiversgranted.Id.at*17.Thecourtfoundthatthisargumentdoesnotsupportadifferentoutcomeinthiscasebecausethedefendantsgrantmorefront‐endwaiverrequeststhantheydeny,regardlessofthedollaramountsthoserequestsencompass.MidwestFencepresentednoevidencethatIDOTandtheTollwayhaveanunwrittenpolicyofgrantingonlylow‐valuewaivers.Id.
ThecourtstatedthatMidwest’s“bestargument”againstnarrowedtailoringisits“mismatch”argument,whichwasdiscussedabove.Id.at*17.ThecourtsaidMidwest’sbroadcondemnationoftheIDOTandTollwayprogramsasfailingtocreatea“light”and“diffuse”burdenforthirdpartieswasnotpersuasive.Id.ThecourtnotedthattheDBEprograms,whichsetDBEgoalsononlysomecontractsandallowthosegoalstobewaivedifnecessary,mayendupforeclosingoneofseveralopportunitiesforanon‐DBEspecialtysubcontractorlikeMidwestFence.Id.But,therewasnoevidencethattheyimposetheentireburdenonthatsubcontractorbyshuttingitoutofthemarketentirely.Id.However,thecourtfoundthatMidwestFence’spointthatsubcontractorsappeartobearadisproportionateshareoftheburdenascomparedtoprimecontractors“istroubling.”Id.at*17.
Althoughtheevidenceshoweddisparitiesinboththeprimecontractingandsubcontractingmarkets,underthefederalregulations,individualcontractgoalsaresetonlyforcontractsthathavesubcontractingpossibilities.Id.ThecourtpointedoutthatsomeDBEsareabletobidonprimecontracts,butthenecessarilysmallsizeofDBEsmakesthatdifficultinmostcases.Id.
But,accordingtothecourt,intheendtherecordshowsthattheproblemMidwestFenceraisesislargely“theoretical.”Id.at*18.NotallcontractshaveDBEgoals,sosubcontractorsareonanevenfootingforthosecontractswithoutsuchgoals.Id.IDOTandtheTollwaybothuseneutralmeasuresincludingsomedesignedtomakeprimecontractsmoreassessabletoDBEs.Id.ThecourtnotedthatDBEtruckingandmaterialsupplierscounttowardfulfillmentofacontract’sDBEgoal,eventhoughtheyarenotusedaslineitemsincalculatingthecontractgoalinthefirstplace,whichopensupcontractswithDBEgoalstonon‐DBEsubcontractors.Id.
ThecourtstatedthatifMidwestFence“hadpresentedevidenceratherthantheoryonthispoint,theresultmightbedifferent.”Id.at*18.“EvidencethatsubcontractorswerebeingfrozenoutofthemarketorbearingtheentireburdenoftheDBEprogramwouldlikelyrequireatrialto
![Page 296: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/296.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 170
determineataminimumwhetherIDOTortheTollwaywereadheringtotheirresponsibilitytoavoidoverconcentrationinsubcontracting.”Id.at*18.ThecourtconcludedthatMidwestFence“hasshownhowtheIllinoisprogramcouldyieldthatresultbutnotthatitactuallydoesso.”Id.
InlightoftheIDOTandTollwayprograms’mechanismstopreventsubcontractorsfromhavingtobeartheentireburdenoftheDBEprograms,includingtheuseofDBEmaterialsandtruckingsuppliersinsatisfyinggoals,effortstodrawDBEsintoprimecontracting,andothermechanisms,accordingtothecourt,MidwestFencedidnotestablishagenuinedisputeoffactonthispoint.Id.at*18.Thecourtstatedthatthe“theoreticalpossibilityofa‘mismatch’couldbeaproblem,butwehavenoevidencethatitactuallyis.”Id.at*18.
Therefore,thecourtconcludedthatIDOTandtheTollwayDBEprogramsarenarrowlytailoredtoservethecompellingstateinterestinremedyingdiscriminationinpubliccontracting.Id.at*18.Theyincluderace‐andgender‐neutralalternatives,setgoalswithreferencetoactualmarketconditions,andallowforfront‐endwaivers.Id.“Sofarastherecordbeforeusshows,theydonotundulyburdenthirdpartiesinserviceofremedyingdiscrimination”,accordingtothecourt.Therefore,MidwestFencefailedtopresentagenuinedisputeoffact“onthispoint.”Id.
Petition for a Writ of Certiorari.MidwestFencefiledaPetitionforaWritofCertioraritotheUnitedStatesSupremeCourtin2017,andCertiorariwasdenied.2017WL497345(2017).
3. Dunnet Bay Construction Company v. Borggren, Illinois DOT, et al., 799 F.3d 676, 2015 WL 4934560 (7th Cir. 2015), cert. denied, Dunnet Bay Construction Co. v. Blankenhorn, Randall S., et al., 2016 WL 193809 (Oct. 3, 2016).
DunnetBayConstructionCompanysuedtheIllinoisDepartmentofTransportation(IDOT)assertingthattheIllinoisDOT’sDBEProgramdiscriminatesonthebasisofrace.ThedistrictcourtgrantedsummaryjudgementtoIllinoisDOT,concludingthatDunnetBaylackedstandingtoraiseanequalprotectionchallengebasedonrace,andheldthattheIllinoisDOTDBEProgramsurvivedtheconstitutionalandotherchallenges.799F.3dat679.(See2014WL552213,C.D.Ill.Fed.12,2014)(SeesummaryofdistrictdecisioninSectionE.below).TheCourtofAppealsaffirmedthegrantofsummaryjudgmenttoIDOT.
DunnetBayengagesingeneralhighwayconstructionandisownedandcontrolledbytwowhitemales.799F.3dat679.Itsaverageannualgrossreceiptsbetween2007and2009wereover$52million.Id.IDOTadministersitsDBEProgramimplementingtheFederalDBEProgram.IDOTestablishedastatewideaspirationalgoalforDBEparticipationof22.77%.Id.at680.UnderIDOT’sDBEProgram,ifabidderfailstomeettheDBEcontractgoal,itmayrequestamodificationofthegoal,andprovidedocumentationofitsgoodfaitheffortstomeetthegoal.Id.at681.Theserequestsformodificationarealsoknownas“waivers.”Id.
TherecordshowedthatIDOThistoricallygrantedgoalmodificationrequestorwaivers:in2007,itgranted57of63pre‐awardgoalmodificationrequests;thesixotherbiddersultimatelymetthecontractgoalwithpost‐bidassistance.Id.at681.In2008,IDOTgranted50ofthe55pre‐awardgoalmodificationrequests;theotherfivebiddersultimatelymettheDBEgoal.Incalendaryear2009,IDOTgranted32of58goalmodificationrequests;theothercontractors
![Page 297: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/297.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 171
ultimatelymetthegoals.Incalendaryear2010,IDOTreceived35goalmodificationrequests;itgranted21ofthemanddeniedtherest.Id.
DunnetBayallegedthatIDOThadtakenthepositionnowaiverswouldbegranted.Id.at697‐698.IDOTrespondedthatitwasnotitspolicytonotgrantwaivers,butinsteadIDOTwouldaggressivelypursueobtainingtheDBEparticipationintheircontractgoals,includingthatwaiversweregoingtobereviewedatahighleveltomakesuretheappropriatedocumentationwasprovidedinorderforawaivertobeissued.Id.
TheU.S.FHWAapprovedthemethodologyIDOTusedtoestablishastatewideoverallDBEgoalof22.77%.Id.at683,698.TheFHWAreviewedandapprovedtheindividualcontractgoalssetforworkonaprojectknownastheEisenhowerprojectthatDunnetBaybidonin2010.Id.DunnetBaysubmittedtoIDOTabidthatwasthelowestbidontheproject,butitwassubstantiallyoverthebudgetestimatefortheproject.Id.at683‐684.DunnetBaydidnotachievethegoalof22%,butthreeotherbidderseachmettheDBEgoal.Id.at684.DunnetBayrequestedawaiverbasedonitsgoodfaitheffortstoobtaintheDBEgoal.Id.at684.Ultimately,IDOTdeterminedthatDunnetBaydidnotproperlyexercisegoodfaitheffortsanditsbidwasrejected.Id.at684‐687,699.
Becauseallthebidswereoverbudget,IDOTdecidedtorebidtheEisenhowerproject.Id.at687.TherewerefourseparateEisenhowerprojectsadvertisedforbids,andIDOTgrantedoneofthefourgoalmodificationrequestsfromthatbidletting.DunnetBaybidononeoftherebidprojects,butitwasnotthelowestbid;itwasthethirdoutoffivebidders.Id.at687.DunnetBaydidmeetthe22.77%contractDBEgoal,ontherebidprospect,butwasnotawardedthecontractbecauseitwasnotthelowest.Id.
DunnetBaythenfileditslawsuitseekingdamagesaswellasadeclaratoryjudgementthattheIDOTDBEProgramisunconstitutionalandinjunctivereliefagainstitsenforcement.
ThedistrictcourtgrantedtheIDOTDefendants’motionforsummaryjudgementanddeniedDunnetBay’smotion.Id.at687.ThedistrictcourtconcludedthatDunnetBaylackedArticleIIIstandingtoraiseanequalprotectionchallengebecauseithasnotsufferedaparticularizedinjurythatwascalledbyIDOT,andthatDunnetBaywasnotdeprivedoftheabilitytocompeteonanequalbasis.Id.DunnetBayConstructionCompanyv.Hannig,2014WL552213,at*30(C.D.Ill.Feb.12,2014).
EvenifDunnetBayhadstandingtobringanequalprotectionclaim,thedistrictcourtheldthatIDOTwasentitledtosummaryjudgment.ThedistrictcourtconcludedthatDunnetBaywasheldtothesamestandardsaseveryotherbidder,andthuscouldnotestablishthatitwasthevictimofracialdiscrimination.Id.at687.Inaddition,thedistrictcourtdeterminedthatIDOThadnotexceededitsfederalauthorityunderthefederalrulesandthatDunnetBay’schallengetotheDBEProgramfailedundertheSeventhCircuitCourtofAppealsdecisioninNorthernContracting,Inc.v.Illinois,473F.3d715,721(7thCir.2007),whichinsulatesastateDBEProgramfromaconstitutionalattackabsentashowingthatthestateexceededitsfederalauthority.Id.at688.(SeediscussionofthedistrictcourtdecisioninDunnetBaybelowinSectionE).
![Page 298: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/298.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 172
Dunnet Bay lacks standing to raise an equal protection claim.ThecourtfirstaddressedtheissuewhetherDunnetBayhadstandingtochallengeIDOT’sDBEProgramonthegroundthatitdiscriminatedonthebasisofraceintheawardofhighwayconstructioncontracts.
ThecourtfoundthatDunnetBayhadnotestablishedthatitwasexcludedfromcompetitionorotherwisedisadvantagedbecauseofrace‐basedmeasures.Id.at690.NothinginIDOT’sDBEProgram,thecourtstated,excludedDunnetBayfromcompetitionforanycontract.Id.IDOT’sDBEProgramisnota“setasideprogram,”inwhichnon‐minorityownedbusinessescouldnotevenbidoncertaincontracts.Id.UnderIDOT’sDBEProgram,allcontractors,minorityandnon‐minoritycontractors,canbidonallcontracts.Id.at690‐691.
Thecourtsaidtheabsenceofcompleteexclusionfromcompetitionwithminority‐orwomen‐ownedbusinessesdistinguishedtheIDOTDBEProgramfromothercasesinwhichthecourtruledtherewasstandingtochallengeaprogram.Id.at691.DunnetBay,thecourtfound,hasnotallegedandhasnotproducedevidencetoshowthatitwastreatedlessfavorablythananyothercontractorbecauseoftheraceofitsowners.Id.Thislackofanexplicitpreferencefromminority‐ownedbusinessesdistinguishestheIDOTDBEProgramfromothercases.Id.UnderIDOT’sDBEProgram,allcontractorsaretreatedalikeandsubjecttothesamerules.Id.
Inaddition,thecourtdistinguishedothercasesinwhichthecontractorswerefoundtohavestandingbecauseinthosecasesstandingwasbasedinpartonthefacttheyhadlostanawardofacontractforfailingtomeettheDBEgoalorfailingtoshowgoodfaithefforts,despitebeingthelowbiddersonthecontract,andthesecondlowestbidderwasawardedthecontract.Id.at691.Incontrastwiththesecaseswheretheplaintiffshadstanding,thecourtsaidDunnetBaycouldnotestablishthatitwouldhavebeenawardedthecontractbutforitsfailuretomeettheDBEgoalordemonstrategoodfaithefforts.Id.at692.
TheevidenceestablishedthatDunnetBay’sbidwassubstantiallyovertheprogramestimatedbudget,andIDOTrebidthecontractbecausethelowbidwasovertheprojectestimate.Id.Inaddition,DunnetBayhadbeenleftofftheForBiddersListthatissubmittedtoDBEs,whichwasanotherreasonIDOTdecidedtorebidthecontract.Id.
ThecourtfoundthatevenassumingDunnetBaycouldestablishitwasexcludedfromcompetitionwithDBEsorthatitwasdisadvantagedascomparedtoDBEs,itcouldnotshowthatanydifferenceintreatmentwasbecauseofrace.Id.at692.Forthethreeyearspreceding2010,theyearitbidontheproject,DunnetBay’saveragegrossreceiptswereover$52million.Id.Therefore,thecourtfoundDunnetBay’ssizemakesitineligibletoqualifyasaDBE,regardlessoftheraceofitsowners.Id.DunnetBaydidnotshowthatanyadditionalcostsorburdensthatitwouldincurarebecauseofrace,buttheadditionalcostsandburdensareequallyattributabletoDunnetBay’ssize.Id.DunnetBayhadnotestablished,accordingtothecourt,thatthedenialofequaltreatmentresultedfromtheimpositionofaracialbarrier.Id.at693.
DunnetBayalsoallegedthatitwasforcedtoparticipateinadiscriminatoryschemeandwasrequiredtoconsiderraceinsubcontracting,andthusarguedthatitmayassertthird‐partyrights.Id.at693.Thecourtstatedthatithasnotadoptedthebroadviewofstandingregardingassertingthird‐partyrights.Id.ThecourtconcludedthatDunnetBay’sclaimedinjuryofbeingforcedtoparticipateinadiscriminatoryschemeamountstoachallengetothestate’sapplication
![Page 299: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/299.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 173
ofafederallymandatedprogram,whichtheSeventhCircuitCourtofAppealshasdetermined“mustbelimitedtothequestionofwhetherthestateexceededitsauthority.”Id.at694,quoting,NorthernContracting,473F.3dat720‐21.ThecourtfoundDunnetBaywasnotdeniedequaltreatmentbecauseofracialdiscrimination,butinsteadanydifferenceintreatmentwasequallyattributabletoDunnetBay’ssize.Id.
ThecourtstatedthatDunnetBaydidnotestablishcausationalorredressability.Id.at695.ItfailedtodemonstratethattheDBEProgramcauseditanyinjuryduringthefirstbidprocess.Id.IDOTdidnotawardthecontracttoanyoneunderthefirstbidandre‐letthecontract.Id.Therefore,DunnetBaysufferednoinjurybecauseoftheDBEProgram.Id.ThecourtalsofoundthatDunnetBaycouldnotestablishredressabilitybecauseIDOT’sdecisiontore‐letthecontractredressedanyinjury.Id.
Inaddition,thecourtconcludedthatprudentiallimitationsprecludeDunnetBayfrombringingitsclaim.Id.at695.Thecourtsaidthatalitigantgenerallymustasserthisownlegalrightsandinterests,andcannotresthisclaimtoreliefonthelegalrightsorinterestsofthirdparties.Id.ThecourtrejectedDunnetBay’sattempttoasserttheequalprotectionrightsofanon‐minority‐ownedsmallbusiness.Id.at695‐696.
Dunnet Bay did not produce sufficient evidence that IDOT’s implementation of the Federal
DBE Program constitutes race discrimination as it did not establish that IDOT exceeded its
federal authority.ThecourtsaidthatinthealternativetodenyingDunnetBaystanding,evenifDunnetBayhadstanding,IDOTwasstillentitledtosummaryjudgment.Id.at696.ThecourtstatedthattoestablishanequalprotectionclaimundertheFourteenthAmendment,DunnetBaymustshowthatIDOT“actedwithdiscriminatoryintent.”Id.
ThecourtestablishedthestandardbasedonitspreviousrulingintheNorthernContractingv.IDOTcasethatinimplementingitsDBEProgram,IDOTmayproperlyrelyon“thefederalgovernment’scompellinginterestinremedyingtheeffectsofpastdiscriminationinthenationalconstructionmarket.”Id.,at697,quotingNorthernContracting,473F.3dat720.Significantly,thecourtheldfollowingitsNorthernContractingdecisionasfollows:“[A]stateisinsulatedfrom[aconstitutionalchallengeastowhetheritsprogramisnarrowlytailoredtoachievethiscompellinginterest],absentashowingthatthestateexceededitsfederalauthority.”Id.quotingNorthernContracting,473F.3dat721.
DunnetBaycontendsthatIDOTexceededitsfederalauthoritybyeffectivelycreatingracialquotasbydesigningtheEisenhowerprojecttomeetapre‐determinedDBEgoalandeliminatingwaivers.Id.at697.DunnetBayassertsthatIDOTexceedsitsauthorityby:(1)settingthecontract’sDBEparticipationgoalat22%withouttherequiredanalysis;(2)implementinga“no‐waiver”policy;(3)preliminarilydenyingitsgoalmodificationrequestwithoutassessingitsgoodfaithefforts;(4)denyingitameaningfulreconsiderationhearing;(5)determiningthatitsgoodfaitheffortswereinadequate;and(6)providingnowrittenorotherexplanationofthebasisforitsgood‐faith‐effortsdetermination.Id.
InchallengingtheDBEcontractgoal,DunnetBayassertsthatthe22%goalwas“arbitrary”andthatIDOTmanipulatedtheprocesstojustifyapreordainedgoal.Id.at698.ThecourtstatedDunnetBaydidnotidentifyanyregulationorotherauthoritythatsuggestspoliticalmotivations
![Page 300: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/300.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 174
matter,providedIDOTdidnotexceeditsfederalauthorityinsettingthecontractgoal.Id.DunnetBaydoesnotactuallychallengehowIDOTwentaboutsettingitsDBEgoalonthecontract.Id.DunnetBaydidnotpointtoanyevidencetoshowthatIDOTfailedtocomplywiththeapplicableregulationprovidingonlygeneralguidanceoncontractgoalsetting.Id.
TheFHWAapprovedIDOT’smethodologytoestablishitsstatewideDBEgoalandapprovedtheindividualcontractgoalsfortheEisenhowerproject.Id.at698.DunnetBaydidnotidentifyanypartoftheregulationthatIDOTallegedlyviolatedbyreevaluatingandthenincreasingitsDBEcontractgoal,byexpandingthegeographicareausedtodetermineDBEavailability,byaddingpavementpatchingandlandscapingworkintothecontractgoal,byincludingitemsthathadbeensetasideforsmallbusinessenterprises,orbyanyothermeansbywhichitincreasedtheDBEcontractgoal.Id.
Thecourtagreedwiththedistrictcourt’sconclusionthatbecausethefederalregulationsdonotspecifyaprocedureforarrivingatcontractgoals,itisnotapparenthowIDOTcouldhaveexceededitsfederalauthority.Id.at698.
ThecourtfoundDunnetBaydidnotpresentsufficientevidencetoraiseareasonableinferencethatIDOThadactuallyimplementedano‐waiverpolicy.Id.at698.ThecourtnotedIDOThadgrantedwaiversin2009andin2010thatamountedto60%ofthewaiverrequests.Id.ThecourtstatedthatIDOT’srecordofgrantingwaiversrefutesanysuggestionofano‐waiverpolicy.Id.at699.
ThecourtdidnotagreewithDunnetBay’schallengethatIDOTrejecteditsbidwithoutdeterminingwhetherithadmadegoodfaithefforts,pointingoutthatIDOTinfactdeterminedthatDunnetBayfailedtodocumentadequategoodfaithefforts,andthusithadcompliedwiththefederalregulations.Id.at699.ThecourtfoundIDOT’sdeterminationthatDunnetBayfailedtoshowgoodfaitheffortswassupportedintherecord.Id.ThecourtnotedthereasonsprovidedbyIDOT,includedDunnetBaydidnotutilizeIDOT’ssupportiveservices,andthattheotherbiddersallmettheDBEgoal,whereasDunnetBaydidnotcomeclosetothegoalinitsfirstbid.Id.at699‐700.
ThecourtsaidtheperformanceofotherbiddersinmeetingthecontractgoalislistedinthefederalregulationsasaconsiderationwhendecidingwhetherabidderhasmadegoodfaitheffortstoobtainDBEparticipationgoals,andwasaproperconsideration.Id.at700.ThecourtsaidDunnetBay’seffortstosecuretheDBEparticipationgoalmayhavebeenhinderedbytheomissionofDunnetBayfromtheForBidList,butfoundtherebiddingofthecontractremediedthatoversight.Id.
Conclusion.Thecourtaffirmedthedistrictcourt’sgrantofsummaryjudgementtotheIllinoisDOT,concludingthatDunnetBaylacksstanding,andthattheIllinoisDBEProgramimplementingtheFederalDBEProgramsurvivedtheconstitutionalandotherchallengesmadebyDunnetBay.
Petition for a Writ of Certiorari Denied.DunnetBayfiledaPetitionforaWritofCertioraritotheUnitedStatesSupremeCourtinJanuary2016.TheSupremeCourtdeniedthePetitiononOctober3,2016.
![Page 301: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/301.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 175
4. Associated General Contractors of America, San Diego Chapter, Inc. v. California Department of Transportation, et al., 713 F.3d 1187 (9th Cir. 2013)
TheAssociatedGeneralContractorsofAmerica,Inc.,SanDiegoChapter,Inc.,(“AGC”)soughtdeclaratoryandinjunctivereliefagainsttheCaliforniaDepartmentofTransportation(“Caltrans”)anditsofficersonthegroundsthatCaltrans’DisadvantagedBusinessinitialEnterprise(“DBE”)programunconstitutionallyprovidedrace‐andsex‐basedpreferencestoAfricanAmerican,NativeAmerican‐,Asian‐PacificAmerican‐,andwomen‐ownedfirmsoncertaintransportationcontracts.ThefederaldistrictcourtupheldtheconstitutionalityofCaltrans’DBEprogramimplementingtheFederalDBEProgramandgrantedsummaryjudgmenttoCaltrans.ThedistrictcourtheldthatCaltrans’DBEprogramimplementingtheFederalDBEProgramsatisfiedstrictscrutinybecauseCaltranshadastrongbasisinevidenceofdiscriminationintheCaliforniatransportationcontractingindustry,andtheprogramwasnarrowlytailoredtothosegroupsthatactuallysuffereddiscrimination.ThedistrictcourtheldthatCaltrans’substantialstatisticalandanecdotalevidencefromadisparitystudyconductedbyBBCResearchandConsulting,providedastrongbasisinevidenceofdiscriminationagainstthefournamedgroups,andthattheprogramwasnarrowlytailoredtobenefitonlythosegroups.713F.3dat1190.
TheAGCappealedthedecisiontotheNinthCircuitCourtofAppeals.TheNinthCircuitinitiallyheldthatbecausetheAGCdidnotidentifyanyofthememberswhohavesufferedorwillsufferharmasaresultofCaltrans’program,theAGCdidnotestablishthatithadassociationalstandingtobringthelawsuit.Id.Mostsignificantly,theNinthCircuitheldthateveniftheAGCcouldestablishstanding,itsappealfailedbecausetheCourtfoundCaltrans’DBEprogramimplementingtheFederalDBEProgramisconstitutionalandsatisfiedtheapplicablelevelofstrictscrutinyrequiredbytheEqualProtectionClauseoftheUnitedStatesConstitution.Id.at1194‐1200.
Court Applies Western States Paving Co. v. Washington State DOT decision.In2005theNinthCircuitCourtofAppealdecidedWesternStatesPavingCo.v.WashingtonStateDepartmentofTransportation,407F.3d.983(9thCir.2005),whichinvolvedafacialchallengetotheconstitutionalvalidityofthefederallawauthorizingtheUnitedStatesDepartmentofTransportationtodistributefundstoStatesfortransportation‐relatedprojects.Id.at1191.ThechallengeintheWesternStatesPavingcasealsoincludedanas‐appliedchallengetotheWashingtonDOTprogramimplementingthefederalmandate.Id.Applyingstrictscrutiny,theNinthCircuitupheldtheconstitutionalityofthefederalstatuteandthefederalregulations(theFederalDBEProgram),butstruckdownWashingtonDOT’sprogrambecauseitwasnotnarrowlytailored.Id.,citingWesternStatesPavingCo.,407F.3dat990‐995,999‐1002.
InWesternStatesPaving,theNinthCircuitannouncedatwo‐prongedtestfor“narrowtailoring”:
“(1) the state must establish the presence of discrimination within itstransportation contracting industry, and (2) the remedial program must belimitedtothoseminoritygroupsthathaveactuallysuffereddiscrimination.”Id.1191,citingWesternStatesPavingCo.,407F.3dat997‐998.
![Page 302: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/302.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 176
Evidence gathering and the 2007 Disparity Study.OnMay1,2006,Caltransceasedtouserace‐andgender‐consciousmeasuresinimplementingtheirDBEprogramonfederallyassistedcontractswhileitgatheredevidenceinanefforttocomplywiththeWesternStatesPavingdecision.Id.at1191.CaltranscommissionedadisparitystudybyBBCResearchandConsultingtodeterminewhethertherewasevidenceofdiscriminationinCalifornia’stransportationcontractingindustry.Id.TheCourtnotedthatdisparityanalysisinvolvesmakingacomparisonbetweentheavailabilityofminority‐andwomen‐ownedbusinessesandtheiractualutilization,producinganumbercalleda“disparityindex.”Id.Anindexof100representsstatisticalparitybetweenavailabilityandutilization,andanumberbelow100indicatesunderutilization.Id.Anindexbelow80isconsideredasubstantialdisparitythatsupportsaninferenceofdiscrimination.Id.
TheCourtfoundtheresearchfirmandthedisparitystudygatheredextensivedatatocalculatedisadvantagedbusinessavailabilityintheCaliforniatransportationcontractingindustry.Id.at1191.TheCourtstated:“Basedonreviewofpublicrecords,interviews,assessmentsastowhetherafirmcouldbeconsideredavailable,forCaltranscontracts,aswellasnumerousotheradjustments,thefirmconcludedthatminority‐andwomen‐ownedbusinessesshouldbeexpectedtoreceive13.5percentofcontactdollarsfromCaltransadministeredfederallyassistedcontracts.”Id.at1191‐1192.
TheCourtsaidtheresearchfirm“examinedover10,000transportation‐relatedcontractsadministeredbyCaltransbetween2002and2006todetermineactualDBEutilization.Thefirmassesseddisparitiesacrossavarietyofcontracts,separatelyassessingcontractsbasedonfundingsource(stateorfederal),typeofcontract(primeorsubcontract),andtypeofproject(engineeringorconstruction).”Id.at1192.
TheCourtpointedoutakeydifferencebetweenfederallyfundedandstatefundedcontractsisthatrace‐consciousgoalswereinplaceforthefederallyfundedcontractsduringthe2002–2006period,butnotforthestatefundedcontracts.Id.at1192.Thus,theCourtstated:“statefundedcontractsfunctionedasacontrolgrouptohelpdeterminewhetherpreviousaffirmativeactionprogramsskewedthedata.”Id.
Moreover,theCourtfoundtheresearchfirmmeasureddisparitiesinalltwelveofCaltrans’administrativedistricts,andcomputedaggregatedisparitiesbasedonstatewidedata.Id.at1192.Thefirmevaluatedstatisticaldisparitiesbyraceandgender.TheCourtstatedthatwithinandacrossmanycategoriesofcontracts,theresearchfirmfoundsubstantialstatisticaldisparitiesforAfricanAmerican,Asian–Pacific,andNativeAmericanfirms.Id.However,theresearchfirmfoundthattherewerenotsubstantialdisparitiesfortheseminoritiesineverysubcategoryofcontract.Id.TheCourtnotedthatthedisparitystudyalsofoundsubstantialdisparitiesinutilizationofwomen‐ownedfirmsforsomecategoriesofcontracts.Id.Afterpublicationofthedisparitystudy,theCourtpointedouttheresearchfirmcalculateddisparityindicesforallwomen‐ownedfirms,includingfemaleminorities,showingsubstantialdisparitiesintheutilizationofallwomen‐ownedfirmssimilartothosemeasuredforwhitewomen.Id.
TheCourtfoundthatthedisparitystudyandCaltransalsodevelopedextensiveanecdotalevidence,by(1)conductingtwelvepublichearingstoreceivecommentsonthefirm’sfindings;(2)receivinglettersfrombusinessownersandtradeassociations;and(3)interviewing
![Page 303: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/303.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 177
representativesfromtwelvetradeassociationsand79owners/managersoftransportationfirms.Id.at1192.TheCourtstatedthatsomeoftheanecdotalevidenceindicateddiscriminationbasedonraceorgender.Id.
Caltrans’ DBE Program.CaltransconcludedthattheevidencefromthedisparitystudysupportedaninferenceofdiscriminationintheCaliforniatransportationcontractingindustry.Id.at1192‐1193.Caltransconcludedthatithadsufficientevidencetomakerace‐andgender‐consciousgoalsforAfricanAmerican‐,Asian–PacificAmerican‐,NativeAmerican‐,andwomen‐ownedfirms.Id.TheCourtstatedthatCaltransadoptedtherecommendationsofthedisparityreportandsetanoverallgoalof13.5percentfordisadvantagedbusinessparticipation.Caltransexpectedtomeetone‐halfofthe13.5percentgoalusingrace‐neutralmeasures.Id.
CaltranssubmitteditsproposedDBEprogramtotheUSDOTforapproval,includingarequestforawaivertoimplementtheprogramonlyforthefouridentifiedgroups.Id.at1193.TheCaltrans’DBEprogramincluded66race‐neutralmeasuresthatCaltransalreadyoperatedorplannedtoimplement,andsubsequentproposalsincreasedthenumberofrace‐neutralmeasuresto150.Id.TheUSDOTgrantedthewaiver,butinitiallydidnotapproveCaltrans’DBEprogramuntilin2009,theDOTapprovedCaltrans’DBEprogramforfiscalyear2009.
District Court proceedings.AGCthenfiledacomplaintallegingthatCaltrans’implementationoftheFederalDBEProgramviolatedtheFourteenthAmendmentoftheU.S.Constitution,TitleVIoftheCivilRightsAct,andotherlaws.Ultimately,theAGConlyarguedanas‐appliedchallengetoCaltrans’DBEprogram.ThedistrictcourtonmotionsofsummaryjudgmentheldthatCaltrans’programwas“clearlyconstitutional,”asit“wassupportedbyastrongbasisinevidenceofdiscriminationintheCaliforniacontractingindustryandwasnarrowlytailoredtothosegroupswhichhadactuallysuffereddiscrimination.Id.at1193.
Subsequent Caltrans study and program.WhiletheappealbytheAGCwaspending,CaltranscommissionedanewdisparitystudyfromBBCtoupdateitsDBEprogramasrequiredbythefederalregulations.Id.at1193.InAugust2012,BBCpublisheditsseconddisparityreport,andCaltransconcludedthattheupdatedstudyprovidedevidenceofcontinuingdiscriminationintheCaliforniatransportationcontractingindustryagainstthesamefourgroupsandHispanicAmericans.Id.CaltranssubmittedamodifiedDBEprogramthatisnearlyidenticaltotheprogramapprovedin2009,exceptthatitnowincludesHispanicAmericansandsetsanoverallgoalof12.5percent,ofwhich9.5percentwillbeachievedthroughrace‐andgender‐consciousmeasures.Id.TheUSDOTapprovedCaltrans’updatedprograminNovember2012.Id.
Jurisdiction issue.Initially,theNinthCircuitCourtofAppealsconsideredwhetherithadjurisdictionovertheAGC’sappealbasedonthedoctrinesofmootnessandstanding.TheCourtheldthattheappealisnotmootbecauseCaltrans’newDBEprogramissubstantiallysimilartothepriorprogramandisallegedtodisadvantageAGC’smembers“inthesamefundamentalway”asthepreviousprogram.Id.at1194.
TheCourt,however,heldthattheAGCdidnotestablishassociationalstanding.Id.at1194‐1195:TheCourtfoundthattheAGCdidnotidentifyanyaffectedmembersbynamenorhasitsubmitteddeclarationsbyanyofitsmembersattestingtoharmtheyhavesufferedorwillsuffer
![Page 304: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/304.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 178
underCaltrans’program.Id.at1194‐1195.BecauseAGCfailedtoestablishstanding,theCourthelditmustdismisstheappealduetolackofjurisdiction.Id.at1195.
Caltrans’ DBE Program held constitutional on the merits.TheCourtthenheldthatevenifAGCcouldestablishstanding,itsappealwouldfail.Id.at1194‐1195.TheCourtheldthatCaltrans’DBEprogramisconstitutionalbecauseitsurvivestheapplicablelevelofscrutinyrequiredbytheEqualProtectionClauseandjurisprudence.Id.at1195‐1200.
TheCourtstatedthatrace‐consciousremedialprogramsmustsatisfystrictscrutinyandthatalthoughstrictscrutinyisstringent,itisnot“fatalinfact.”Id.at1194‐1195(quotingAdarandConstructors,Inc.v.Peña,515U.S.200,237(1995)(AdarandIII)).TheCourtquotedAdarandIII:“Theunhappypersistenceofboththepracticeandthelingeringeffectsofracialdiscriminationagainstminoritygroupsinthiscountryisanunfortunatereality,andgovernmentisnotdisqualifiedfromactinginresponsetoit.”Id.(quotingAdarandIII,515U.S.at237.)
TheCourtpointedoutthatgender‐consciousprogramsmustsatisfyintermediatescrutinywhichrequiresthatgender‐consciousprogramsbesupportedbyan‘exceedinglypersuasivejustification’andbesubstantiallyrelatedtotheachievementofthatunderlyingobjective.Id.at1195(citingWesternStatesPaving,407F.3dat990n.6.).
TheCourtheldthatCaltrans’DBEprogramcontainsbothrace‐andgender‐consciousmeasures,andthatthe“entireprogrampassesstrictscrutiny.”Id.at1195.
A. Application of strict scrutiny standard articulated in Western States Paving.TheCourtheldthattheframeworkforAGC’sas‐appliedchallengetoCaltrans’DBEprogramisgovernedbyWesternStatesPaving.TheNinthCircuitinWesternStatesPavingdevisedatwo‐prongedtestfornarrowtailoring:(1)thestatemustestablishthepresenceofdiscriminationwithinitstransportationcontractingindustry,and(2)theremedialprogrammustbe“limitedtothoseminoritygroupsthathaveactuallysuffereddiscrimination.”Id.at1195‐1196(quotingWesternStatesPaving,407F.3dat997–99).
1. Evidence of discrimination in California contracting industry.TheCourtheldthatinEqualProtectioncases,courtsconsiderstatisticalandanecdotalevidencetoidentifytheexistenceofdiscrimination.Id.at1196.TheU.S.SupremeCourthassuggestedthata“significantstatisticaldisparity”couldbesufficienttojustifyrace‐consciousremedialprograms.Id.at*7(citingCityofRichmondv.J.A.CrosonCo.,488U.S.469,509(1989)).TheCourtstatedthatalthoughgenerallynotsufficient,anecdotalevidencecomplementsstatisticalevidencebecauseofitsabilitytobring“thecoldnumbersconvincinglytolife.”Id.(quotingInt’lBhd.ofTeamstersv.UnitedStates,431U.S.324,339(1977)).
TheCourtpointedoutthatWashingtonDOT’sDBEprogramintheWesternStatesPavingcasewasheldinvalidbecauseWashingtonDOThadperformednostatisticalstudiesanditofferednoanecdotalevidence.Id.at1196.TheCourtalsostatedthattheWashingtonDOTusedanoversimplifiedmethodologyresultinginlittleweightbeinggivenbytheCourttothepurporteddisparitybecauseWashington’sdata“didnotaccountfortherelativecapacityofdisadvantagedbusinessestoperformwork,nordiditcontrolforthefactthatexistingaffirmativeactionprogramsskewedthepriorutilizationofminoritybusinessesinthestate.”Id.(quotingWestern
![Page 305: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/305.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 179
StatesPaving,407F.3dat999‐1001).TheCourtsaidthatitstruckdownWashington’sprogramafterdeterminingthattherecordwasdevoidofanyevidencesuggestingthatminoritiescurrentlysuffer–orhaveeversuffered–discriminationintheWashingtontransportationcontractingindustry.”Id.
Significantly,theCourtheldinthiscaseasfollows:“Incontrast,Caltrans’affirmativeactionprogramissupportedbysubstantialstatisticalandanecdotalevidenceofdiscriminationintheCaliforniatransportationcontractingindustry.”Id.at1196.TheCourtnotedthatthedisparitystudydocumenteddisparitiesinmanycategoriesoftransportationfirmsandtheutilizationofcertainminority‐andwomen‐ownedfirms.Id.TheCourtfoundthedisparitystudy“accountedforthefactorsmentionedinWesternStatesPavingaswellasothers,adjustingavailabilitydatabasedoncapacitytoperformworkandcontrollingforpreviouslyadministeredaffirmativeactionprograms.”Id.(citingWesternStates,407F.3dat1000).
TheCourtalsoheld:“Moreover,thestatisticalevidencefromthedisparitystudyisbolsteredbyanecdotalevidencesupportinganinferenceofdiscrimination.Thesubstantialstatisticaldisparitiesalonewouldgiverisetoaninferenceofdiscrimination,seeCroson,488U.S.at509,andcertainlyCaltrans’statisticalevidencecombinedwithanecdotalevidencepassesconstitutionalmuster.”Id.at1196.
TheCourtspecificallyrejectedtheargumentbyAGCthatstrictscrutinyrequiresCaltranstoprovideevidenceof“specificacts”of“deliberate”discriminationbyCaltransemployeesorprimecontractors.Id.at1196‐1197.TheCourtfoundthattheSupremeCourtinCrosonexplicitlystatesthat“[t]hedegreeofspecificityrequiredinthefindingsofdiscrimination…mayvary.”Id.at1197(quotingCroson,488U.S.at489).TheCourtconcludedthatarulerequiringastatetoshowspecificactsofdeliberatediscriminationbyidentifiedindividualswouldruncontrarytothestatementinCrosonthatstatisticaldisparitiesalonecouldbesufficienttosupportrace‐consciousremedialprograms.Id.(citingCroson,488U.S.at509).TheCourtrejectedAGC’sargumentthatCaltrans’programdoesnotsurvivestrictscrutinybecausethedisparitystudydoesnotidentifyindividualactsofdeliberatediscrimination.Id.
TheCourtrejectedasecondargumentbyAGCthatthisstudyshowedinconsistentresultsforutilizationofminoritybusinessesdependingonthetypeandnatureofthecontract,andthuscannotsupportaninferenceofdiscriminationintheentiretransportationcontractingindustry.Id.at1197.AGCarguedthateachofthesesubcategoriesofcontractsmustbeviewedinisolationwhenconsideringwhetheraninferenceofdiscriminationarises,whichtheCourtrejected.Id.TheCourtfoundthatAGC’sargumentoverlookstherationaleunderpinningtheconstitutionaljustificationforremedialrace‐consciousprograms:theyaredesignedtorootout“patternsofdiscrimination.”Id.quotingCroson,488U.S.at504.
TheCourtstatedthattheissueisnotwhetherCaltranscanshowunderutilizationofdisadvantagedbusinessesineverymeasuredcategoryofcontract.Butrather,theissueiswhetherCaltranscanmeettheevidentiarystandardrequiredbyWesternStatesPavingif,lookingattheevidenceinitsentirety,thedatashowsubstantialdisparitiesinutilizationofminorityfirmssuggestingthatpublicdollarsarebeingpouredinto“asystemofracialexclusionpracticedbyelementsofthelocalconstructionindustry.”Id.at1197quotingCroson488U.S.at492.
![Page 306: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/306.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 180
TheCourtconcludedthatthedisparitystudyandanecdotalevidencedocumentapatternofdisparitiesforthefourgroups,andthatthestudyfoundsubstantialunderutilizationofthesegroupsinnumerouscategoriesofCaliforniatransportationcontracts,whichtheanecdotalevidenceconfirms.Id.at1197.TheCourtheldthisissufficienttoenableCaltranstoinferthatthesegroupsaresystematicallydiscriminatedagainstinpublicly‐fundedcontracts.Id.
Third,theCourtconsideredandrejectedAGC’sargumentthattheanecdotalevidencehaslittleornoprobativevalueinidentifyingdiscriminationbecauseitisnotverified.Id.at*9.TheCourtnotedthattheFourthandTenthCircuitshaverejectedtheneedtoverifyanecdotalevidence,andtheCourtstatedtheAGCmadenopersuasiveargumentthattheNinthCircuitshouldholdotherwise.Id.
TheCourtpointedoutthatAGCattemptedtodiscounttheanecdotalevidencebecausesomeaccountsascribeminorityunderutilizationtofactorsotherthanovertdiscrimination,suchasdifficultieswithobtainingbondingandbreakingintothe“goodolboy”networkofcontractors.Id.at1197‐1198.TheCourtheld,however,thatthefederalcourtsandregulationshaveidentifiedpreciselythesefactorsasbarriersthatdisadvantageminorityfirmsbecauseofthelingeringeffectsofdiscrimination.Id.at1198,citingWesternStatesPaving,407andAGCCII,950F.2dat1414.
TheCourtfoundthatAGCignoresthemanyincidentsofracialandgenderdiscriminationpresentedintheanecdotalevidence.Id.at1198.TheCourtsaidthatCaltransdoesnotclaim,andtheanecdotalevidencedoesnotneedtoprove,thateveryminority‐ownedbusinessisdiscriminatedagainst.Id.TheCourtconcluded:“ItisenoughthattheanecdotalevidencesupportsCaltrans’statisticaldatashowingapervasivepatternofdiscrimination.”Id.TheindividualaccountsofdiscriminationofferedbyCaltrans,accordingtotheCourt,metthisburden.Id.
Fourth,theCourtrejectedAGC’scontentionthatCaltrans’evidencedoesnotsupportaninferenceofdiscriminationagainstallwomenbecausegender‐baseddisparitiesinthestudyarelimitedtowhitewomen.Id.at1198.AGC,theCourtsaid,misunderstandsthestatisticaltechniquesusedinthedisparitystudy,andthatthestudycorrectlyisolatestheeffectofgenderbylimitingitsdatapooltowhitewomen,ensuringthatstatisticalresultsforgender‐baseddiscriminationarenotskewedbydiscriminationagainstminoritywomenonaccountoftheirrace.Id.
Inaddition,afterAGC’searlyincorrectobjectionstothemethodology,theresearchfirmconductedafollow‐upanalysisofallwomen‐ownedfirmsthatproducedadisparityindexof59.Id.at1198.TheCourtheldthatthisindexisevidenceofasubstantialdisparitythatraisesaninferenceofdiscriminationandissufficienttosupportCaltrans’decisiontoincludeallwomeninitsDBEprogram.Id.at1195.
2. Program tailored to groups who actually suffered discrimination.TheCourtpointedoutthatthesecondprongofthetestarticulatedinWesternStatesPavingrequiresthataDBEprogrambelimitedtothosegroupsthatactuallysuffereddiscriminationinthestate’scontractingindustry.Id.at1198.TheCourtfoundCaltrans’DBEprogramislimitedtothoseminoritygroupsthathaveactuallysuffereddiscrimination.Id.TheCourtheldthatthe2007disparitystudyshowed
![Page 307: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/307.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 181
systematicandsubstantialunderutilizationofAfricanAmerican‐,NativeAmerican‐,Asian‐PacificAmerican‐,andwomen‐ownedfirmsacrossarangeofcontractcategories.Id.at1198‐1199.Id.Thesedisparities,accordingtotheCourt,supportaninferenceofdiscriminationagainstthosegroups.Id.
CaltransconcludedthatthestatisticalevidencedidnotsupportaninferenceofapatternofdiscriminationagainstHispanicorSubcontinentAsianAmericans.Id.at1199.CaliforniaappliedforandreceivedawaiverfromtheUSDOTinordertolimitits2009programtoAfricanAmerican,NativeAmerican,Asian‐PacificAmerican,andwomen‐ownedfirms.Id.TheCourtheldthatCaltrans’program“adherespreciselytothenarrowtailoringrequirementsofWesternStates.”Id.
TheCourtrejectedtheAGCcontentionthattheDBEprogramisnotnarrowlytailoredbecauseitcreatesrace‐basedpreferencesforalltransportation‐relatedcontracts,ratherthandistinguishingbetweenconstructionandengineeringcontracts.Id.at1199.TheCourtstatedthatAGCcitednocasethatrequiresastatepreferenceprogramtoprovideseparategoalsfordisadvantagedbusinessparticipationonconstructionandengineeringcontracts.Id.TheCourtnotedthattothecontrary,thefederalguidelinesforimplementingthefederalprograminstructstatesnottoseparatedifferenttypesofcontracts.Id.TheCourtfoundthereare“soundpolicyreasonstonotrequiresuchparsing,includingthefactthatthereissubstantialoverlapinfirmscompetingforconstructionandengineeringcontracts,asprimeandsubcontractors.”Id.
B. Consideration of race–neutral alternatives.TheCourtrejectedtheAGCassertionthatCaltrans’programisnotnarrowlytailoredbecauseitfailedtoevaluaterace‐neutralmeasuresbeforeimplementingthesystemofracialpreferences,andstatedthelawimposesnosuchrequirement.Id.at1199.TheCourtheldthatWesternStatesPavingdoesnotrequirestatestoindependentlymeetthisaspectofnarrowtailoring,andinsteadfocusesonwhetherthefederalstatutesufficientlyconsideredrace‐neutralalternatives.Id.
Second,theCourtfoundthatevenifthisrequirementdoesapplytoCaltrans’program,narrowtailoringonlyrequires“serious,goodfaithconsiderationofworkablerace‐neutralalternatives.”Id.at1199,citingGrutterv.Bollinger,539U.S.306,339(2003).TheCourtfoundthattheCaltransprogramhasconsideredanincreasingnumberofrace‐neutralalternatives,anditrejectedAGC’sclaimthatCaltrans’programdoesnotsufficientlyconsiderrace‐neutralalternatives.Id.at1199.
C. Certification affidavits for Disadvantaged Business Enterprises.TheCourtrejectedtheAGCargumentthatCaltrans’programisnotnarrowlytailoredbecauseaffidavitsthatapplicantsmustsubmittoobtaincertificationasDBEsdonotrequireapplicantstoasserttheyhavesuffereddiscriminationinCalifornia.Id.at1199‐1200.TheCourtheldthecertificationprocessemployedbyCaltransfollowstheprocessdetailedinthefederalregulations,andthatthisisanimpermissiblecollateralattackonthefacialvalidityoftheCongressionalActauthorizingtheFederalDBEProgramandthefederalregulationspromulgatedbytheUSDOT(TheSafe,Accountable,Flexible,EfficientTransportationEquityAct:ALegacyforUsers,Pub.L.No.109‐59,§1101(b),119Sect.1144(2005)).Id.at1200.
D. Application of program to mixed state‐ and federally‐funded contracts.TheCourtalsorejectedAGC’schallengethatCaltransappliesitsprogramtotransportationcontractsfundedby
![Page 308: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/308.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 182
bothfederalandstatemoney.Id.at1200.TheCourtheldthatthisisanotherimpermissiblecollateralattackonthefederalprogram,whichexplicitlyrequiresgoalstobesetformix‐fundedcontracts.Id.
Conclusion.TheCourtconcludedthattheAGCdidnothavestanding,andthatfurther,Caltrans’DBEprogramsurvivesstrictscrutinyby:1)havingastrongbasisinevidenceofdiscriminationwithintheCaliforniatransportationcontractingindustry,and2)beingnarrowlytailoredtobenefitonlythosegroupsthathaveactuallysuffereddiscrimination.Id.at1200.TheCourtthendismissedtheappeal.Id.
5. Braunstein v. Arizona DOT, 683 F.3d 1177 (9th Cir. 2012)
BraunsteinisanengineeringcontractorthatprovidedsubsurfaceutilitylocationservicesforADOT.BraunsteinsuedtheArizonaDOTandothersseekingdamagesundertheCivilRightsAct,pursuantto§§1981and1983,andchallengingtheuseofArizona’sformeraffirmativeactionprogram,orrace‐andgender‐consciousDBEprogramimplementingtheFederalDBEProgram,allegingviolationoftheequalprotectionclause.
Factual background.ADOTsolicitedbidsforanewengineeringanddesigncontract.Sixfirmsbidontheprimecontract,butBraunsteindidnotbidbecausehecouldnotsatisfyarequirementthatprimecontractorscomplete50percentofthecontractworkthemselves.Instead,Braunsteincontactedthebiddingfirmstoaskaboutsubcontractingfortheutilitylocationwork.683F.3dat1181.AllsixfirmsrejectedBraunstein’sovertures,andBraunsteindidnotsubmitaquoteorsubcontractingbidtoanyofthem.Id.
Aspartofthebid,theprimecontractorswererequiredtocomplywithfederalregulationsthatprovidestatesreceivingfederalhighwayfundsmaintainaDBEprogram.683F.3dat1182.Underthiscontract,theprimecontractorwouldreceiveamaximumof5pointsforDBEparticipation.Id.at1182.Allsixfirmsthatbidontheprimecontractreceivedthemaximum5pointsforDBEparticipation.AllsixfirmscommittedtohiringDBEsubcontractorstoperformatleast6percentofthework.OnlyoneofthesixbiddingfirmsselectedaDBEasitsdesiredutilitylocationsubcontractor.ThreeofthebiddingfirmsselectedanothercompanyotherthanBraunsteintoperformtheutilitylocationwork.Id.DMJMwonthebidforthe2005contractusingAztectoperformtheutilitylocationwork.AztecwasnotaDBE.Id.at1182.
District Court rulings.BraunsteinbroughtthissuitinfederalcourtagainstADOTandemployeesoftheDOTallegingthatADOTviolatedhisrighttoequalprotectionbyusingraceandgenderpreferencesinitssolicitationandawardofthe2005contract.ThedistrictcourtdismissedasmootBraunstein’sclaimsforinjunctiveanddeclaratoryreliefbecauseADOThadsuspendeditsDBEprogramin2006followingtheNinthCircuitdecisioninWesternStatesPavingCo.v.WashingtonStateDOT,407F.3d9882(9thCir.2005).ThisleftonlyBraunstein’sdamagesclaimsagainsttheStateandADOTunder§2000d,andagainstthenamedindividualdefendantsintheirindividualcapacitiesunder§§1981and1983.Id.at1183.
ThedistrictcourtconcludedthatBraunsteinlackedArticleIIIstandingtopursuehisremainingclaimsbecausehehadfailedtoshowthatADOT’sDBEprogramhadaffectedhimpersonally.Thecourtnotedthat“Braunsteinwasaffordedtheopportunitytobidonsubcontractingwork,and
![Page 309: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/309.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 183
theDBEgoaldidnotserveasabarriertodoingso,norwasitanimpedimenttohissecuringasubcontract.”Id.at1183.ThedistrictcourtfoundthatBraunstein’sinabilitytosecureutilitylocationworkstemmedfromhispastunsatisfactoryperformance,nothisstatusasanon‐DBE.Id.
Lack of standing. TheNinthCircuitCourtofAppealsheldthatBraunsteinlackedArticleIIIstandingandaffirmedtheentryofsummaryjudgmentinfavorofADOTandtheindividualemployeesofADOT.TheCourtfoundthatBraunsteinhadnotprovidedanyevidenceshowingthatADOT’sDBEprogramaffectedhimpersonallyorthatitimpededhisabilitytocompeteforutilitylocationworkonanequalbasis.Id.at1185.TheCourtnotedthatBraunsteindidnotsubmitaquoteorabidtoanyoftheprimecontractorsbiddingonthegovernmentcontract.Id.
TheCourtalsopointedoutthatBraunsteindidnotseekprospectivereliefagainstthegovernment“affirmativeaction”program,notingthedistrictcourtdismissedasmoothisclaimsfordeclaratoryandinjunctivereliefsinceADOThadsuspendeditsDBEprogrambeforehebroughtthesuit.Id.at1186.Thus,Braunstein’ssurvivingclaimswerefordamagesbasedonthecontractatissueratherthanprospectiverelieftoenjointheDBEProgram.Id.Accordingly,theCourtheldhemustshowmorethanthatheis“ableandready”toseeksubcontractingwork.Id.
TheCourtfoundBraunsteinpresentednoevidencetodemonstratethathewasinapositiontocompeteequallywiththeothersubcontractors,noevidencecomparinghimselfwiththeothersubcontractorsintermsofpriceorothercriteria,andnoevidenceexplainingwhythesixprospectiveprimecontractorsrejectedhimasasubcontractor.Id.at1186.TheCourtstatedthattherewasnothingintherecordindicatingtheADOTDBEprogramposedabarrierthatimpededBraunstein’sabilitytocompeteforworkasasubcontractor.Id.at1187.TheCourtheldthattheexistenceofaracialorgenderbarrierisnotenoughtoestablishstanding,withoutaplaintiff’sshowingthathehasbeensubjectedtosuchabarrier.Id.at1186.
TheCourtnotedBraunsteinhadexplicitlyacknowledgedpreviouslythatthewinningbidderonthecontractwouldnothirehimasasubcontractorforreasonsunrelatedtotheDBEprogram.Id.at1186.Atthesummaryjudgmentstage,theCourtstatedthatBraunsteinwasrequiredtosetforthspecificfactsdemonstratingtheDBEprogramimpededhisabilitytocompeteforthesubcontractingworkonanequalbasis.Id.at1187.
Summary judgment granted to ADOT.TheCourtconcludedthatBraunsteinwasunabletopointtoanyevidencetodemonstratehowtheADOTDBEprogramadverselyaffectedhimpersonallyorimpededhisabilitytocompeteforsubcontractingwork.Id.TheCourtthusheldthatBraunsteinlackedArticleIIIstandingandaffirmedtheentryofsummaryjudgmentinfavorofADOT.
6. Northern Contracting, Inc. v. Illinois, 473 F.3d 715 (7th Cir. 2007)
InNorthernContracting,Inc.v.Illinois,theSeventhCircuitaffirmedthedistrictcourtdecisionupholdingthevalidityandconstitutionalityoftheIllinoisDepartmentofTransportation’s(“IDOT”)DBEProgram.PlaintiffNorthernContractingInc.(“NCI”)wasawhitemale‐ownedconstructioncompanyspecializingintheconstructionofguardrailsandfencesforhighwayconstructionprojectsinIllinois.473F.3d715,717(7thCir.2007).Initially,NCIchallengedthe
![Page 310: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/310.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 184
constitutionalityofboththefederalregulationsandtheIllinoisstatuteimplementingtheseregulations.Id.at719.ThedistrictcourtgrantedtheUSDOT’sMotionforSummaryJudgment,concludingthatthefederalgovernmenthaddemonstratedacompellinginterestandthatTEA‐21wassufficientlynarrowlytailored.NCIdidnotchallengethisrulingandtherebyforfeitedtheopportunitytochallengethefederalregulations.Id.at720.NCIalsoforfeitedtheargumentthatIDOT’sDBEprogramdidnotserveacompellinggovernmentinterest.Id.ThesoleissueonappealtotheSeventhCircuitwaswhetherIDOT’sprogramwasnarrowlytailored.Id.
IDOTtypicallyadoptedanewDBEplaneachyear.Id.at718.InpreparingforFiscalYear2005,IDOTretainedaconsultingfirmtodetermineDBEavailability.Id.Theconsultantfirstidentifiedtherelevantgeographicmarket(Illinois)andtherelevantproductmarket(transportationinfrastructureconstruction).Id.Theconsultantthendeterminedavailabilityofminority‐andwomen‐ownedfirmsthroughanalysisofDun&Bradstreet’sMarketplacedata.Id.ThisinitiallistwascorrectedforerrorsinthedatabysurveyingtheD&Blist.Id.Inlightofthesesurveys,theconsultantarrivedataDBEavailabilityof22.77percent.Id.Theconsultantthenranaregressionanalysisonearningsandbusinessinformationandconcludedthatintheabsenceofdiscrimination,relativeDBEavailabilitywouldbe27.5percent.Id.IDOTconsideredthis,alongwithotherdata,includingDBEutilizationonIDOTs“zerogoal”experimentconductedin2002to2003,inwhichIDOTdidnotuseDBEgoalson5percentofitscontracts(1.5%utilization)anddataofDBEutilizationonprojectsfortheIllinoisStateTollHighwayAuthoritywhichdoesnotreceivefederalfundingandwhosegoalsarecompletelyvoluntary(1.6%utilization).Id.at719.Onthebasisofallofthisdata,IDOTadopteda22.77percentgoalfor2005.Id.
DespitethefacttheNCIforfeitedtheargumentthatIDOT’sDBEprogramdidnotserveacompellingstateinterest,theSeventhCircuitbrieflyaddressedthecompellinginterestprongofthestrictscrutinyanalysis,notingthatIDOThadsatisfieditsburden.Id.at720.Thecourtnotedthat,post‐Adarand,twoothercircuitshaveheldthatastatemayrelyonthefederalgovernment’scompellinginterestinimplementingalocalDBEplan.Id.at720‐21,citingWesternStatesPavingCo.,Inc.v.WashingtonStateDOT,407F.3d983,987(9thCir.2005),cert.denied,126S.Ct.1332(Feb.21,2006)andSherbrookeTurf,Inc.v.MinnesotaDOT,345F.3d964,970(8thCir.2003),cert.denied,541U.S.1041(2004).ThecourtstatedthatNCIhadnotarticulatedanyreasontobreakranksfromtheothercircuitsandexplainedthat“[i]nsofarasthestateismerelycomplyingwithfederallawitisactingastheagentofthefederalgovernment….Ifthestatedoesexactlywhatthestatuteexpectsittodo,andthestatuteisconcededforpurposesoflitigationtobeconstitutional,wedonotseehowthestatecanbethoughttohaveviolatedtheConstitution.”Id.at721,quotingMilwaukeeCountyPaversAssociationv.Fielder,922F.2d419,423(7thCir.1991).ThecourtdidnotaddresswhetherIDOThadanindependentinterestthatcouldhavesurvivedconstitutionalscrutiny.
InaddressingthenarrowlytailoredprongwithrespecttoIDOT’sDBEprogram,thecourtheldthatIDOThadcomplied.Id.ThecourtconcludeditsholdinginMilwaukeethatastateisinsulatedfromaconstitutionalattackabsentashowingthatthestateexceededitsfederalauthorityremainedapplicable.Id.at721‐22.ThecourtnotedthattheSupremeCourtinAdarandConstructorsv.Pena,515U.S.200(1995)didnotseizetheopportunitytooverrulethatdecision,explainingthattheCourtdidnotinvalidateitsconclusionthatachallengetoastate’sapplicationofafederallymandatedprogrammustbelimitedtothequestionofwhetherthestateexceededitsauthority.Id.at722.
![Page 311: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/311.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 185
ThecourtfurtherclarifiedtheMilwaukeeopinioninlightoftheinterpretationsoftheopinionsofferedinbytheNinthCircuitinWesternStatesandEighthCircuitinSherbrooke.Id.ThecourtstatedthattheNinthCircuitinWesternStatesmisreadtheMilwaukeedecisioninconcludingthatMilwaukeedidnotaddressthesituationofanas‐appliedchallengetoaDBEprogram.Id.at722,n.5.Relatedly,thecourtstatedthattheEighthCircuit’sopinioninSherbrooke(thattheMilwaukeedecisionwascompromisedbythefactthatitwasdecidedunderthepriorlaw“whenthe10percentfederalset‐asidewasmoremandatory”)wasunconvincingsinceallrecipientsoffederaltransportationfundsarestillrequiredtohavecompliantDBEprograms.Id.at722.FederallawmakesmoreclearnowthatthecompliancecouldbeachievedevenwithnoDBEutilizationifthatweretheresultofagoodfaithuseoftheprocess.Id.at722,n.5.ThecourtstatedthatIDOTinthiscasewasactingasaninstrumentoffederalpolicyandNCI’scollateralattackonthefederalregulationswasimpermissible.Id.at722.
Theremainderofthecourt’sopinionaddressedthequestionofwhetherIDOTexceededitsgrantofauthorityunderfederallaw,andheldthatallofNCI’sargumentsfailed.Id.First,NCIchallengedthemethodbywhichthelocalbasefigurewascalculated,thefirststepinthegoal‐settingprocess.Id.NCIarguedthatthenumberofregisteredandprequalifiedDBEsinIllinoisshouldhavesimplybeencounted.Id.Thecourtstatedthatwhilethefederalregulationslistseveralexamplesofmethodsfordeterminingthelocalbasefigure,Id.at723,theseexamplesarenotintendedasanexhaustivelist.Thecourtpointedoutthatthefifthiteminthelistisentitled“AlternativeMethods,”andstates:“Youmayuseothermethodstodetermineabasefigureforyouroverallgoal.AnymethodologyyouchoosemustbebasedondemonstrableevidenceoflocalmarketconditionsandbedesignatedtoultimatelyattainagoalthatisrationallyrelatedtotherelativeavailabilityofDBEsinyourmarket.”Id.(citing49CFR§26.45(c)(5)).Accordingtothecourt,theregulationsmakeclearthat“relativeavailability”means“theavailabilityofready,willingandableDBEsrelativetoallbusinessready,willing,andabletoparticipate”onDOTcontracts.Id.ThecourtstatedNCIpointedtonothinginthefederalregulationsthatindicatedthatarecipientmustsonarrowlydefinethescopeoftheready,willing,andavailablefirmstoasimplecountofthenumberofregisteredandprequalifiedDBEs.Id.ThecourtagreedwiththedistrictcourtthattheremedialnatureofthefederalschememilitatesinfavorofamethodofDBEavailabilitycalculationthatcastsabroadernet.Id.
Second,NCIarguedthattheIDOTfailedtoproperlyadjustitsgoalbasedonlocalmarketconditions.Id.Thecourtnotedthatthefederalregulationsdonotrequireanyadjustmentstothebasefigure,butsimplyproviderecipientswithauthoritytomakesuchadjustmentsifnecessary.Id.Accordingtothecourt,NCIfailedtoidentifyanyaspectoftheregulationsrequiringIDOTtoseparateprimecontractoravailabilityfromsubcontractoravailability,andpointedoutthattheregulationsrequirethelocalgoaltobefocusedonoverallDBEparticipation.Id.
Third,NCIcontendedthatIDOTviolatedthefederalregulationsbyfailingtomeetthemaximumfeasibleportionofitsoverallgoalthroughrace‐neutralmeansoffacilitatingDBEparticipation.Id.at723‐24.NCIarguedthatIDOTshouldhaveconsideredDBEswhohadwonsubcontractsongoalprojectswheretheprimecontractordidnotconsiderDBEstatus,insteadofonlyconsideringDBEswhowoncontractsonno‐goalprojects.Id.at724.ThecourtheldthatwhiletheregulationsindicatethatwhereDBEswinsubcontractsongoalprojectsstrictlythroughlowbidthiscanbecountedasrace‐neutralparticipation,theregulationsdidnotrequireIDOTtosearchforthisdata,forthepurposeofcalculatingpastlevelsofrace‐neutralDBEparticipation.
![Page 312: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/312.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 186
Id.Accordingtothecourt,therecordindicatedthatIDOTusednearlyallthemethodsdescribedintheregulationstomaximizetheportionofthegoalthatwillbeachievedthroughrace‐neutralmeans.Id.
ThecourtaffirmedthedecisionofthedistrictcourtupholdingthevalidityoftheIDOTDBEprogramandfoundthatitwasnarrowlytailoredtofurtheracompellinggovernmentalinterest.Id.
7. Western States Paving Co. v. Washington State DOT, 407 F.3d 983 (9th Cir. 2005), cert. denied, 546 U.S. 1170 (2006)
ThiscaseoutoftheNinthCircuitstruckdownastate’simplementationoftheFederalDBEProgramforfailuretopassconstitutionalmuster.InWesternStatesPaving,theNinthCircuitheldthattheStateofWashington’simplementationoftheFederalDBEProgramwasunconstitutionalbecauseitdidnotsatisfythenarrowtailoringelementoftheconstitutionaltest.TheNinthCircuitheldthattheStatemustpresentitsownevidenceofpastdiscriminationwithinitsownboundariesinordertosurviveconstitutionalmusterandcouldnotmerelyrelyupondatasuppliedbyCongress.TheUnitedStatesSupremeCourtdeniedcertiorari.Theanalysisinthedecisionalsoisinstructiveinparticularastotheapplicationofthenarrowlytailoredprongofthestrictscrutinytest.
PlaintiffWesternStatesPavingCo.(“plaintiff”)wasawhitemale‐ownedasphaltandpavingcompany.407F.3d983,987(9thCir.2005).InJulyof2000,plaintiffsubmittedabidforaprojectfortheCityofVancouver;theprojectwasfinancedwithfederalfundsprovidedtotheWashingtonStateDOT(“WSDOT”)undertheTransportationEquityActforthe21stCentury(“TEA‐21”).Id.
CongressenactedTEA‐21in1991andaftermultiplerenewals,itwassettoexpireonMay31,2004.Id.at988.TEA‐21establishedminimumminority‐ownedbusinessparticipationrequirements(10%)forcertainfederally‐fundedprojects.Id.TheregulationsrequireeachstateacceptingfederaltransportationfundstoimplementaDBEprogramthatcomportswiththeTEA‐21.Id.TEA‐21indicatesthe10percentDBEutilizationrequirementis“aspirational,”andthestatutorygoal“doesnotauthorizeorrequirerecipientstosetoverallorcontractgoalsatthe10percentlevel,oranyotherparticularlevel,ortotakeanyspecialadministrativestepsiftheirgoalsareaboveorbelow10percent.”Id.
TEA‐21setsforthatwo‐stepprocessforastatetodetermineitsownDBEutilizationgoal:(1)thestatemustcalculatetherelativeavailabilityofDBEsinitslocaltransportationcontractingindustry(onewaytodothisistodividethenumberofready,willingandableDBEsinastatebythetotalnumberofready,willingandablefirms);and(2)thestateisrequiredto“adjustthisbasefigureupwardordownwardtoreflecttheprovencapacityofDBEstoperformwork(asmeasuredbythevolumeofworkallocatedtoDBEsinrecentyears)andevidenceofdiscriminationagainstDBEsobtainedfromstatisticaldisparitystudies.”Id.at989(citingregulation).Astateisalsopermittedtoconsiderdiscriminationinthebondingandfinancingindustriesandthepresenteffectsofpastdiscrimination.Id.(citingregulation).TEA‐21requiresageneralized,“undifferentiated”minoritygoalandastateisprohibitedfromapportioningtheir
![Page 313: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/313.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 187
DBEutilizationgoalamongdifferentminoritygroups(e.g.,betweenHispanics,blacks,andwomen).Id.at990(citingregulation).
“Astatemustmeetthemaximumfeasibleportionofthisgoalthroughrace‐[andgender‐]neutralmeans,includinginformationalandinstructionalprogramstargetedtowardallsmallbusinesses.”Id.(citingregulation).Race‐andgender‐consciouscontractgoalsmustbeusedtoachieveanyportionofthecontractgoalsnotachievablethroughrace‐andgender‐neutralmeasures.Id.(citingregulation).However,TEA‐21doesnotrequirethatDBEparticipationgoalsbeusedoneverycontractoratthesameleveloneverycontractinwhichtheyareused;rather,theoveralleffectmustbeto“obtainthatportionoftherequisiteDBEparticipationthatcannotbeachievedthroughrace‐[andgender‐]neutralmeans.”Id.(citingregulation).
Aprimecontractormustuse“goodfaithefforts”tosatisfyacontract’sDBEutilizationgoal.Id.(citingregulation).However,astateisprohibitedfromenactingrigidquotasthatdonotcontemplatesuchgoodfaithefforts.Id.(citingregulation).
UndertheTEA‐21minorityutilizationrequirements,theCitysetagoalof14percentminorityparticipationonthefirstprojectplaintiffbidon;theprimecontractorthusrejectedplaintiff’sbidinfavorofahigherbiddingminority‐ownedsubcontractingfirm.Id.at987.InSeptemberof2000,plaintiffagainsubmittedabidonaprojectfinancedwithTEA‐21fundsandwasagainrejectedinfavorofahigherbiddingminority‐ownedsubcontractingfirm.Id.Theprimecontractorexpresslystatedthatherejectedplaintiff’sbidduetotheminorityutilizationrequirement.Id.
PlaintifffiledsuitagainsttheWSDOT,ClarkCounty,andtheCity,challengingtheminoritypreferencerequirementsofTEA‐21asunconstitutionalbothfaciallyandasapplied.Id.Thedistrictcourtrejectedbothofplaintiff’schallenges.ThedistrictcourtheldtheprogramwasfaciallyconstitutionalbecauseitfoundthatCongresshadidentifiedsignificantevidenceofdiscriminationinthetransportationcontractingindustryandtheTEA‐21wasnarrowlytailoredtoremedysuchdiscrimination.Id.at988.Thedistrictcourtrejectedtheas‐appliedchallengeconcludingthatWashington’simplementationoftheprogramcomportedwiththefederalrequirementsandthestatewasnotrequiredtodemonstratethatitsminoritypreferenceprogramindependentlysatisfiedstrictscrutiny.Id.PlaintiffappealedtotheNinthCircuitCourtofAppeals.Id.
TheNinthCircuitconsideredwhethertheTEA‐21,whichauthorizestheuseofrace‐andgender‐basedpreferencesinfederally‐fundedtransportationcontracts,violatedequalprotection,eitheronitsfaceorasappliedbytheStateofWashington.
Thecourtappliedastrictscrutinyanalysistoboththefacialandas‐appliedchallengestoTEA‐21.Id.at990‐91.Thecourtdidnotapplyaseparateintermediatescrutinyanalysistothegender‐basedclassificationsbecauseitdeterminedthatit“wouldnotyieldadifferentresult.”Id.at990,n.6.
Facial challenge (Federal Government).Thecourtfirstnotedthatthefederalgovernmenthasacompellinginterestin“ensuringthatitsfundingisnotdistributedinamannerthatperpetuatestheeffectsofeitherpublicorprivatediscriminationwithinthetransportationcontracting
![Page 314: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/314.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 188
industry.”Id.at991,citingCityofRichmondv.J.A.CrosonCo.,488U.S.469,492(1989)andAdarandConstructors,Inc.v.Slater(“AdarandVII”),228F.3d1147,1176(10thCir.2000).Thecourtfoundthat“[b]othstatisticalandanecdotalevidencearerelevantinidentifyingtheexistenceofdiscrimination.”Id.at991.ThecourtfoundthatalthoughCongressdidnothaveevidenceofdiscriminationagainstminoritiesineverystate,suchevidencewasunnecessaryfortheenactmentofnationwidelegislation.Id.However,citingboththeEighthandTenthCircuits,thecourtfoundthatCongresshadampleevidenceofdiscriminationinthetransportationcontractingindustrytojustifyTEA‐21.Id.ThecourtalsofoundthatbecauseTEA‐21setforthflexiblerace‐consciousmeasurestobeusedonlywhenrace‐neutraleffortswereunsuccessful,theprogramwasnarrowlytailoredandthussatisfiedstrictscrutiny.Id.at992‐93.Thecourtaccordinglyrejectedplaintiff’sfacialchallenge.Id.
As‐applied challenge (State of Washington).PlaintiffallegedTEA‐21wasunconstitutionalas‐appliedbecausetherewasnoevidenceofdiscriminationinWashington’stransportationcontractingindustry.Id.at995.TheStateallegedthatitwasnotrequiredtoindependentlydemonstratethatitsapplicationofTEA‐21satisfiedstrictscrutiny.Id.TheUnitedStatesintervenedtodefendTEA‐21’sfacialconstitutionality,and“unambiguouslyconcededthatTEA‐21’sraceconsciousmeasurescanbeconstitutionallyappliedonlyinthosestateswheretheeffectsofdiscriminationarepresent.”Id.at996;seealsoBr.fortheUnitedStatesat28(April19,2004)(“DOT’sregulations…aredesignedtoassistStatesinensuringthatrace‐consciousremediesarelimitedtoonlythosejurisdictionswherediscriminationoritseffectsareaproblemandonlyasalastresortwhenrace‐neutralreliefisinsufficient.”(emphasisinoriginal)).
ThecourtfoundthattheEighthCircuitwastheonlyothercourttoconsideranas‐appliedchallengetoTEA‐21inSherbrookeTurf,Inc.v.MinnesotaDOT,345F.3d964(8thCir.2003),cert.denied124S.Ct.2158(2004).Id.at996.TheEighthCircuitdidnotrequireMinnesotaandNebraskatoidentifyacompellingpurposefortheirprogramsindependentofCongress’snationwideremedialobjective.Id.However,theEighthCircuitdidconsiderwhetherthestates’implementationofTEA‐21wasnarrowlytailoredtoachieveCongress’sremedialobjective.Id.TheEighthCircuitthuslookedtothestates’independentevidenceofdiscriminationbecause“tobenarrowlytailored,anationalprogrammustbelimitedtothosepartsofthecountrywhereitsrace‐basedmeasuresaredemonstrablyneeded.”Id.(internalcitationsomitted).TheEighthCircuitreliedonthestates’statisticalanalysesoftheavailabilityandcapacityofDBEsintheirlocalmarketsconductedbyoutsideconsultingfirmstoconcludethatthestatessatisfiedthenarrowtailoringrequirement.Id.at997.
ThecourtconcurredwiththeEighthCircuitandfoundthatWashingtondidnotneedtodemonstrateacompellinginterestforitsDBEprogram,independentfromthecompellingnationwideinterestidentifiedbyCongress.Id.However,thecourtdeterminedthatthedistrictcourterredinholdingthatmerecompliancewiththefederalprogramsatisfiedstrictscrutiny.Id.Rather,thecourtheldthatwhetherWashington’sDBEprogramwasnarrowlytailoredwasdependentonthepresenceorabsenceofdiscriminationinWashington’stransportationcontractingindustry.Id.at997‐98.“IfnosuchdiscriminationispresentinWashington,thentheState’sDBEprogramdoesnotservearemedialpurpose;itinsteadprovidesanunconstitutionalwindfalltominoritycontractorssolelyonthebasisoftheirraceorsex.”Id.at998.ThecourtheldthataSixthCircuitdecisiontothecontrary,TennesseeAsphaltCo.v.Farris,942F.2d969,970(6thCir.1991),misinterpretedearliercaselaw.Id.at997,n.9.
![Page 315: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/315.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 189
Thecourtfoundthatmoreover,evenwherediscriminationispresentinastate,aprogramisnarrowlytailoredonlyifitappliesonlytothoseminoritygroupswhohaveactuallysuffereddiscrimination.Id.at998,citingCroson,488U.S.at478.ThecourtalsofoundthatinMontereyMechanicalCo.v.Wilson,125F.3d702,713(9thCir.1997),ithad“previouslyexpressedsimilarconcernsaboutthehaphazardinclusionofminoritygroupsinaffirmativeactionprogramsostensiblydesignedtoremedytheeffectsofdiscrimination.”Id.InMontereyMechanical,thecourtheldthat“theoverlyinclusivedesignationofbenefitedminoritygroupswasa‘redflagsignalingthatthestatuteisnot,astheEqualProtectionClauserequires,narrowlytailored.’”Id.,citingMontereyMechanical,125F.3dat714.Thecourtfoundthatothercourtsareinaccord.Id.at998‐99,citingBuildersAss’nofGreaterChi.v.CountyofCook,256F.3d642,647(7thCir.2001);AssociatedGen.ContractorsofOhio,Inc.v.Drabik,214F.3d730,737(6thCir.2000);O’DonnellConstr.Co.v.DistrictofColumbia,963F.2d420,427(D.C.Cir.1992).Accordingly,thecourtfoundthateachoftheprincipalminoritygroupsbenefitedbyWSDOT’sDBEprogrammusthavesuffereddiscriminationwithintheState.Id.at999.
ThecourtfoundthatWSDOT’sprogramcloselytrackedthesampleUSDOTDBEprogram.Id.WSDOTcalculateditsDBEparticipationgoalbyfirstcalculatingtheavailabilityofready,willingandableDBEsintheState(dividingthenumberoftransportationcontractingfirmsintheWashingtonStateOfficeofMinority,WomenandDisadvantagedBusinessEnterprisesDirectorybythetotalnumberoftransportationcontractingfirmslistedintheCensusBureau’sWashingtondatabase,whichequaled11.17%).Id.WSDOTthenupwardlyadjustedthe11.17percentbasefigureto14percent“toaccountfortheprovencapacityofDBEstoperformwork,asreflectedbythevolumeofworkperformedbyDBEs[duringacertaintimeperiod].”Id.AlthoughDBEsperformed18percentofworkonStateprojectsduringtheprescribedtimeperiod,Washingtonsetthefinaladjustedfigureat14percentbecauseTEA‐21reducedthenumberofeligibleDBEsinWashingtonbyimposingmorestringentcertificationrequirements.Id.at999,n.11.WSDOTdidnotmakeanadjustmenttoaccountfordiscriminatorybarriersinobtainingbondingandfinancing.Id.WSDOTsimilarlydidnotmakeanyadjustmenttoreflectpresentorpastdiscrimination“becauseitlackedanystatisticalstudiesevidencingsuchdiscrimination.”Id.
WSDOTthendeterminedthatitneededtoachieve5percentofits14percentgoalthroughrace‐consciousmeansbasedona9percentDBEparticipationrateonstate‐fundedcontractsthatdidnotincludeaffirmativeactioncomponents(i.e.,9%participationcouldbeachievedthroughrace‐neutralmeans).Id.at1000.TheUSDOTapprovedWSDOTgoal‐settingprogramandthetotalityofits2000DBEprogram.Id.
Washingtonconcededthatitdidnothavestatisticalstudiestoestablishtheexistenceofpastorpresentdiscrimination.Id.Itargued,however,thatithadevidenceofdiscriminationbecauseminority‐ownedfirmshadthecapacitytoperform14percentoftheState’stransportationcontractsin2000butreceivedonly9percentofthesubcontractingfundsoncontractsthatdidnotincludeanaffirmativeaction’scomponent.Id.ThecourtfoundthattheState’smethodologywasflawedbecausethe14percentfigurewasbasedontheearlier18percentfigure,discussedsupra,whichincludedcontractswithaffirmativeactioncomponents.Id.Thecourtconcludedthatthe14percentfiguredidnotaccuratelyreflecttheperformancecapacityofDBEsinarace‐neutralmarket.Id.ThecourtalsofoundtheStateconcededasmuchtothedistrictcourt.Id.
![Page 316: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/316.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 190
ThecourtheldthatadisparitybetweenDBEperformanceoncontractswithanaffirmativeactioncomponentandthosewithout“doesnotprovideanyevidenceofdiscriminationagainstDBEs.”Id.ThecourtfoundthattheonlyevidenceuponwhichWashingtoncouldrelywasthedisparitybetweentheproportionofDBEfirmsintheState(11.17%)andthepercentageofcontractsawardedtoDBEsonrace‐neutralgrounds(9%).Id.However,thecourtdeterminedthatsuchevidencewasentitledto“littleweight”becauseitdidnottakeintoaccountamultitudeofotherfactorssuchasfirmsize.Id.
Moreover,thecourtfoundthattheminimalstatisticalevidencewasinsufficientevidence,standingalone,ofdiscriminationinthetransportationcontractingindustry.Id.at1001.ThecourtfoundthatWSDOTdidnotpresentanyanecdotalevidence.Id.ThecourtrejectedtheState’sargumentthattheDBEapplicationsthemselvesconstitutedevidenceofpastdiscriminationbecausetheapplicationswerenotproperlyintherecord,andbecausetheapplicantswerenotrequiredtocertifythattheyhadbeenvictimsofdiscriminationinthecontractingindustry.Id.Accordingly,thecourtheldthatbecausetheStatefailedtoprofferevidenceofdiscriminationwithinitsowntransportationcontractingmarket,itsDBEprogramwasnotnarrowlytailoredtoCongress’scompellingremedialinterest.Id.at1002‐03.
Thecourtaffirmedthedistrictcourt’sgrantonsummaryjudgmenttotheUnitedStatesregardingthefacialconstitutionalityofTEA‐21,reversedthegrantofsummaryjudgmenttoWashingtonontheas‐appliedchallenge,andremandedtodeterminetheState’sliabilityfordamages.
ThedissentarguedthatwheretheStatecompliedwithTEA‐21inimplementingitsDBEprogram,itwasnotsusceptibletoanas‐appliedchallenge.
8. Sherbrooke Turf, Inc. v. Minnesota DOT, and Gross Seed Company v. Nebraska Department of Roads, 345 F.3d 964 (8th Cir. 2003), cert. denied, 541 U.S. 1041 (2004)
ThiscaseisinstructiveinitsanalysisofstateDOTDBE‐typeprogramsandtheirevidentiarybasisandimplementation.ThiscasealsoisinstructiveinitsanalysisofthenarrowlytailoredrequirementforstateDBEprograms.InupholdingthechallengedFederalDBEProgramatissueinthiscasetheEighthCircuitemphasizedtherace‐,ethnicity‐andgender‐neutralelements,theultimateflexibilityoftheProgram,andthefacttheProgramwastiedcloselyonlytolabormarketswithidentifieddiscrimination.
InSherbrookeTurf,Inc.v.MinnesotaDOT,andGrossSeedCompanyv.NebraskaDepartmentofRoads,theU.S.CourtofAppealsfortheEighthCircuitupheldtheconstitutionalityoftheFederalDBEProgram(49CFRPart26).ThecourtheldtheFederalProgramwasnarrowlytailoredtoremedyacompellinggovernmentalinterest.Thecourtalsoheldthefederalregulationsgoverningthestates’implementationoftheFederalDBEProgramwerenarrowlytailored,andthestateDOT’simplementationoftheFederalDBEProgramwasnarrowlytailoredtoserveacompellinggovernmentinterest.
SherbrookeandGrossSeedbothcontendedthattheFederalDBEProgramonitsfaceandasappliedinMinnesotaandNebraskaviolatedtheEqualProtectioncomponentoftheFifthAmendment’sDueProcessClause.TheEighthCircuitengagedinareviewoftheFederalDBE
![Page 317: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/317.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 191
ProgramandtheimplementationoftheProgrambytheMinnesotaDOTandtheNebraskaDepartmentofRoads(“NebraskaDOR”)underastrictscrutinyanalysisandheldthattheFederalDBEProgramwasvalidandconstitutionalandthattheMinnesotaDOT’sandNebraskaDOR’simplementationoftheProgramalsowasconstitutionalandvalid.Applyingthestrictscrutinyanalysis,thecourtfirstconsideredwhethertheFederalDBEProgramestablishedacompellinggovernmentalinterest,andfoundthatitdid.ItconcludedthatCongresshadastrongbasisinevidencetosupportitsconclusionthatrace‐basedmeasureswerenecessaryforthereasonsstatedbytheTenthCircuitinAdarand,228F.3dat1167‐76.Althoughthecontractorspresentedevidencethatchallengedthedata,theyfailedtopresentaffirmativeevidencethatnoremedialactionwasnecessarybecauseminority‐ownedsmallbusinessesenjoynon‐discriminatoryaccesstoparticipationinhighwaycontracts.Thus,thecourtheldtheyfailedtomeettheirultimateburdentoprovethattheDBEProgramisunconstitutionalonthisground.
Finally,SherbrookeandGrossSeedarguedthattheMinnesotaDOTandNebraskaDORmustindependentlysatisfythecompellinggovernmentalinteresttestaspectofstrictscrutinyreview.Thegovernmentargued,andthedistrictcourtsbelowagreed,thatparticipatingstatesneednotindependentlymeetthestrictscrutinystandardbecauseundertheDBEProgramthestatemuststillcomplywiththeDOTregulations.TheEighthCircuitheldthatthisissuewasnotaddressedbytheTenthCircuitinAdarand.TheEighthCircuitconcludedthatneitherside’spositionisentirelysound.
ThecourtrejectedthecontentionofthecontractorsthattheirfacialchallengestotheDBEProgrammustbeupheldunlesstherecordbeforeCongressincludedstrongevidenceofracediscriminationinconstructioncontractinginMinnesotaandNebraska.Ontheotherhand,thecourtheldavalidrace‐basedprogrammustbenarrowlytailored,andtobenarrowlytailored,anationalprogrammustbelimitedtothosepartsofthecountrywhereitsrace‐basedmeasuresaredemonstrablyneededtotheextentthatthefederalgovernmentdelegatesthistailoringfunction,asastate’simplementationbecomesrelevanttoareviewingcourt’sstrictscrutiny.Thus,thecourtleftthequestionofstateimplementationtothenarrowtailoringanalysis.
Thecourtheldthatareviewingcourtapplyingstrictscrutinymustdetermineiftherace‐basedmeasureisnarrowlytailored.Thatis,whetherthemeanschosentoaccomplishthegovernment’sassertedpurposearespecificallyandnarrowlyframedtoaccomplishthatpurpose.ThecontractorshavetheultimateburdenofestablishingthattheDBEProgramisnotnarrowlytailored.Id.ThecompellinginterestanalysisfocusedontherecordbeforeCongress;thenarrow‐tailoringanalysislooksattherolesoftheimplementinghighwayconstructionagencies.
Fordeterminingwhetherarace‐consciousremedyisnarrowlytailored,thecourtlookedatfactorssuchastheefficacyofalternativeremedies,theflexibilityanddurationoftherace‐consciousremedy,therelationshipofthenumericalgoalstotherelevantlabormarket,andtheimpactoftheremedyonthirdparties.Id.UndertheDBEProgram,astatereceivingfederalhighwayfundsmust,onanannualbasis,submittoUSDOTanoverallgoalforDBEparticipationinitsfederally‐fundedhighwaycontracts.See,49CFR§26.45(f)(1).Theoverallgoal“mustbebasedondemonstrableevidence”astothenumberofDBEswhoareready,willing,andabletoparticipateascontractorsorsubcontractorsonfederally‐assistedcontracts.49CFR§26.45(b).Thenumbermaybeadjustedupwardtoreflectthestate’sdeterminationthatmoreDBEswould
![Page 318: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/318.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 192
beparticipatingabsenttheeffectsofdiscrimination,includingrace‐relatedbarrierstoentry.See,49CFR§26.45(d).
Thestatemustmeetthe“maximumfeasibleportion”ofitsoverallgoalbyrace‐neutralmeansandmustsubmitforapprovalaprojectionoftheportionitexpectstomeetthroughrace‐neutralmeans.See,49CFR§26.45(a),(c).Ifrace‐neutralmeansareprojectedtofallshortofachievingtheoverallgoal,thestatemustgivepreferencetofirmsithascertifiedasDBEs.However,suchpreferencesmaynotincludequotas.49CFR§26.45(b).Duringthecourseoftheyear,ifastatedeterminesthatitwillexceedorfallshortofitsoverallgoal,itmustadjustitsuseofrace‐consciousandrace‐neutralmethods“[t]oensurethatyourDBEprogramcontinuestobenarrowlytailoredtoovercometheeffectsofdiscrimination.”49CFR§26.51(f).
Absentbadfaithadministrationoftheprogram,astate’sfailuretoachieveitsoverallgoalwillnotbepenalized.See,49CFR§26.47.Ifthestatemeetsitsoverallgoalfortwoconsecutiveyearsthroughrace‐neutralmeans,itisnotrequiredtosetanannualgoaluntilitdoesnotmeetitsprioroverallgoalforayear.See,49CFR§26.51(f)(3).Inaddition,DOTmaygrantanexemptionorwaiverfromanyandallrequirementsoftheProgram.See,49CFR§26.15(b).
Likethedistrictcourtsbelow,theEighthCircuitconcludedthattheUSDOTregulations,ontheirface,satisfytheSupremeCourt’snarrowingtailoringrequirements.First,theregulationsplacestrongemphasisontheuseofrace‐neutralmeanstoincreaseminoritybusinessparticipationingovernmentcontracting.345F.3dat972.Narrowtailoringdoesnotrequireexhaustionofeveryconceivablerace‐neutralalternative,butitdoesrequireseriousgoodfaithconsiderationofworkablerace‐neutralalternatives.345F.3dat971,citingGrutterv.Bollinger,539U.S.306.
Second,therevisedDBEprogramhassubstantialflexibility.Astatemayobtainwaiversorexemptionsfromanyrequirementsandisnotpenalizedforagoodfaithefforttomeetitsoverallgoal.Inaddition,theprogramlimitspreferencestosmallbusinessesfallingbeneathanearningsthreshold,andanyindividualwhosenetworthexceeds$750,000.00cannotqualifyaseconomicallydisadvantaged.See,49CFR§26.67(b).Likewise,theDBEprogramcontainsbuilt‐indurationallimits.345F.3dat972.AstatemayterminateitsDBEprogramifitmeetsorexceedsitsannualoverallgoalthroughrace‐neutralmeansfortwoconsecutiveyears.Id.;49CFR§26.51(f)(3).
Third,thecourtfound,theUSDOThastiedthegoalsforDBEparticipationtotherelevantlabormarkets.Theregulationsrequirestatestosetoverallgoalsbaseduponthelikelynumberofminoritycontractorsthatwouldhavereceivedfederalassistedhighwaycontractsbutfortheeffectsofpastdiscrimination.See,49CFR§26.45(c)‐(d)(Steps1and2).Thoughtheunderlyingestimatesmaybeinexact,theexerciserequiresstatestofocusonestablishingrealisticgoalsforDBEparticipationintherelevantcontactingmarkets.Id.at972.
Finally,CongressandDOThavetakensignificantsteps,thecourtheld,tominimizetherace‐basednatureoftheDBEProgram.Itsbenefitsaredirectedatallsmallbusinessesownedandcontrolledbythesociallyandeconomicallydisadvantaged.WhileTEA‐21createsapresumptionthatmembersofcertainracialminoritiesfallwithinthatclass,thepresumptionisrebuttable,wealthyminorityownersandwealthyminority‐ownedfirmsareexcluded,andcertificationisavailabletopersonswhoarenotpresumptivelydisadvantagedthatdemonstrateactualsocial
![Page 319: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/319.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 193
andeconomicdisadvantage.Thus,raceismaderelevantintheProgram,butitisnotadeterminativefactor.345F.3dat973.Forthesereasons,thecourtagreedwiththedistrictcourtsthattherevisedDBEProgramisnarrowlytailoredonitsface.
SherbrookeandGrossSeedalsoarguedthattheDBEProgramasappliedinMinnesotaandNebraskaisnotnarrowlytailored.UndertheFederalProgram,statessettheirowngoals,basedonlocalmarketconditions;theirgoalsarenotimposedbythefederalgovernment;nordorecipientshavetotiethemtoanyuniformnationalpercentage.345F.3dat973,citing64Fed.Reg.at5102.
ThecourtanalyzedwhatMinnesotaandNebraskadidinconnectionwiththeirimplementationoftheFederalDBEProgram.MinnesotaDOTcommissionedadisparitystudyofthehighwaycontractingmarketinMinnesota.ThestudygroupdeterminedthatDBEsmadeup11.4percentoftheprimecontractorsandsubcontractorsinahighwayconstructionmarket.Ofthisnumber,0.6percentwereminority‐ownedand10.8percentwomen‐owned.Baseduponitsanalysisofbusinessformationstatistics,theconsultantestimatedthatthenumberofparticipatingminority‐ownedbusinesswouldbe34percenthigherinarace‐neutralmarket.Therefore,theconsultantadjusteditsDBEavailabilityfigurefrom11.4percentto11.6percent.Basedonthestudy,MinnesotaDOTadoptedanoverallgoalof11.6percentDBEparticipationforfederally‐assistedhighwayprojects.MinnesotaDOTpredictedthatitwouldneedtomeet9percentofthatoverallgoalthroughraceandgender‐consciousmeans,basedonthefactthatDBEparticipationinStatehighwaycontractsdroppedfrom10.25percentin1998to2.25percentin1999whenitspreviousDBEProgramwassuspendedbytheinjunctionbythedistrictcourtinanearlierdecisioninSherbrooke.MinnesotaDOTrequiredeachprimecontractbiddertomakeagoodfaithefforttosubcontractaprescribedportionoftheprojecttoDBEs,anddeterminedthatportionbasedonseveralindividualizedfactors,includingtheavailabilityofDBEsintheextentofsubcontractingopportunitiesontheproject.
Thecontractorpresentedevidenceattackingthereliabilityofthedatainthestudy,butitfailedtoestablishthatbetterdatawereavailableorthatMinnesotaDOTwasotherwiseunreasonableinundertakingthisthoroughanalysisandrelyingonitsresults.Id.TheprecipitousdropinDBEparticipationwhennorace‐consciousmethodswereemployed,thecourtconcluded,supportsMinnesotaDOT’sconclusionthatasubstantialportionofitsoverallgoalcouldnotbemetwithrace‐neutralmeasures.Id.Onthatrecord,thecourtagreedwiththedistrictcourtthattherevisedDBEProgramservesacompellinggovernmentinterestandisnarrowlytailoredonitsfaceandasappliedinMinnesota.
InNebraska,theNebraskaDORcommissionedadisparitystudyalsotoreviewavailabilityandcapabilityofDBEfirmsintheNebraskahighwayconstructionmarket.Theavailabilitystudyfoundthatbetween1995and1999,whenNebraskafollowedthemandatory10percentset‐asiderequirement,9.95percentofallavailableandcapablefirmswereDBEs,andDBEfirmsreceived12.7percentofthecontractdollarsonfederallyassistedprojects.AfterapportioningpartofthisDBEcontractingtorace‐neutralcontractingdecisions,NebraskaDORsetanoverallgoalof9.95percentDBEparticipationandpredictedthat4.82percentofthisoverallgoalwouldhavetobeachievedbyrace‐and‐genderconsciousmeans.TheNebraskaDORrequiredthatprimecontractorsmakeagoodfaithefforttoallocateasetportionofeachcontract’sfundstoDBEsubcontractors.TheEighthCircuitconcludedthatGrossSeed,likeSherbrooke,failedto
![Page 320: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/320.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 194
provethattheDBEProgramisnotnarrowlytailoredasappliedinNebraska.Therefore,thecourtaffirmedthedistrictcourts’decisionsinGrossSeedandSherbrooke.(Seedistrictcourtopinionsdiscussedinfra.).
Recent District Court Decisions
9. Midwest Fence Corporation v. United States DOT and Federal Highway Administration, the Illinois DOT, the Illinois State Toll Highway Authority, et al., 84 F. Supp. 3d 705, 2015 WL 1396376 (N.D. Ill, 2015), affirmed, 840 F.3d 932 (7th Cir. 2016).226
InMidwestFenceCorporationv.USDOT,theFHWA,theIllinoisDOTandtheIllinoisStateTollHighwayAuthority,CaseNo.1:10‐3‐CV‐5627,UnitedStatesDistrictCourtfortheNorthernDistrictofIllinois,EasternDivision,PlaintiffMidwestFenceCorporation,whichisaguardrail,bridgerailandfencingcontractorownedandcontrolledbywhitemaleschallengedtheconstitutionalityandtheapplicationoftheUSDOT,DisadvantagedBusinessEnterprise(“DBE”)Program.Inaddition,MidwestFencesimilarlychallengedtheIllinoisDepartmentofTransportation’s(“IDOT”)implementationoftheFederalDBEProgramforfederally‐fundedprojects,IDOT’simplementationofitsownDBEProgramforstate‐fundedprojectsandtheIllinoisStateTollwayHighwayAuthority’s(“Tollway”)separateDBEProgram.
Thefederaldistrictcourtin2011issuedanOpinionandOrderdenyingtheDefendants’MotiontoDismissforlackofstanding,denyingtheFederalDefendants’MotiontoDismisscertainCountsoftheComplaintasamatteroflaw,grantingIDOTDefendants’MotiontoDismisscertainCountsandgrantingtheTollwayDefendants’MotiontoDismisscertainCounts,butgivingleavetoMidwesttorepleadsubsequenttothisOrder.MidwestFenceCorp.v.UnitedStatesDOT,IllinoisDOT,etal.,2011WL2551179(N.D.Ill.June27,2011).
MidwestFenceinitsThirdAmendedComplaintchallengedtheconstitutionalityoftheFederalDBEProgramonitsfaceandasapplied,andchallengedtheIDOT’simplementationoftheFederalDBEProgram.MidwestFencealsosoughtadeclarationthattheUSDOTregulationshavenotbeenproperlyauthorizedbyCongressandadeclarationthatSAFETEA‐LUisunconstitutional.MidwestFencesoughtrelieffromtheIDOTDefendants,includingadeclarationthatstatestatutesauthorizingIDOT’sDBEProgramforState‐fundedcontractsareunconstitutional;adeclarationthatIDOTdoesnotfollowtheUSDOTregulations;adeclarationthattheIDOTDBEProgramisunconstitutionalandotherreliefagainsttheIDOT.TheremainingCountssoughtreliefagainsttheTollwayDefendants,includingthattheTollway’sDBEProgramisunconstitutional,andarequestforpunitivedamagesagainsttheTollwayDefendants.Thecourtin2012grantedtheTollwayDefendants’MotiontoDismissMidwestFence’srequestforpunitivedamages.
22649CFRPart26(ParticipationbyDisadvantagedBusinessEnterprisesinDepartmentofTransportationFinancialAssistancePrograms(“FederalDBEProgram”).SeetheTransportationEquityActforthe21stCentury(TEA‐21)asamendedandreauthorized(“MAP‐21,”“SAFETEA”and“SAFETEA‐LU”),andtheUnitedStatesDepartmentofTransportation(“USDOT”or“DOT”)regulationspromulgatedtoimplementTEA‐21theFederalregulationsknownasMovingAheadforProgressinthe21stCenturyAct(“MAP‐21”),PubL.112‐141,H.R.4348,§1101(b),July6,2012,126Stat405.;precededbyPubL.109‐59,TitleI,§1101(b),August10,2005,119Stat.1156;precededbyPubL.105‐178,TitleI,§1101(b),June9,1998,112Stat.107.
![Page 321: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/321.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 195
Equal protection framework, strict scrutiny and burden of proof.Thecourtheldthatunderastrictscrutinyanalysis,theburdenisonthegovernmenttoshowbothacompellinginterestandnarrowlytailoring.84F.Supp.3dat720.Thegovernmentmustdemonstrateastrongbasisinevidenceforitsconclusionthatremedialactionisnecessary.Id.SincetheSupremeCourtdecisioninCroson,numerouscourtshaverecognizedthatdisparitystudiesprovideprobativeevidenceofdiscrimination.Id.Thecourtstatedthataninferenceofdiscriminationmaybemadewithempiricalevidencethatdemonstratesasignificantstatisticaldisparitybetweenthenumberofqualifiedminoritycontractorsandthenumberofsuchcontractorsactuallyengagedbythelocalityorthelocality’sprimecontractors.Id.Thecourtsaidthatanecdotalevidencemaybeusedincombinationwithstatisticalevidencetoestablishacompellinggovernmentalinterest.Id.
Inadditiontoproviding“hardproof”tobackitscompellinginterest,thecourtstatedthatthegovernmentmustalsoshowthatthechallengedprogramisnarrowlytailored.Id.at720.Whilenarrowtailoringrequires“serious,goodfaithconsiderationofworkablerace‐neutralalternatives,”thecourtsaiditdoesnotrequire“exhaustionofeveryconceivablerace‐neutralalternative.”Id.,citingGrutterv.Bollinger,539U.S.306,339(2003);Fischerv.Univ.ofTexasatAustin,133S.Ct.2411,2420(2013).
Oncethegovernmentalentityhasshownacceptableproofofacompellinginterestinremedyingpastdiscriminationandillustratedthatitsplanisnarrowlytailoredtoachievethisgoal,thepartychallengingtheaffirmativeactionplanbearstheultimateburdenofprovingthattheplanisunconstitutional.84F.Supp.3dat721.Tosuccessfullyrebutthegovernment’sevidence,achallengermustintroduce“credible,particularizedevidence”ofitsown.Id.
Thiscanbeaccomplished,accordingtothecourt,byprovidinganeutralexplanationforthedisparitybetweenDBEutilizationandavailability,showingthatthegovernment’sdataisflawed,demonstratingthattheobserveddisparitiesarestatisticallyinsignificant,orpresentingcontrastingstatisticaldata.Id.Conjectureandunsupportedcriticismsofthegovernment’smethodologyareinsufficient.Id.
Standing.ThecourtfoundthatMidwesthadstandingtochallengetheFederalDBEProgram,IDOT’simplementationofit,andtheTollwayProgram.Id.at722.Thecourt,however,didnotfindthatMidwesthadpresentedanyfactssuggestingitsinabilitytocompeteonanequalfootingfortheTargetMarketProgramcontracts.TheTargetMarketProgramidentifiedavarietyofremedialactionsthatIDOTwasauthorizedtotakeincertainDistricts,whichincludedindividualcontractgoals,DBEparticipationincentives,aswellasset‐asides.Id.at722‐723.
ThecourtnotedthatMidwestdidnotidentifyanycontractsthatweresubjecttotheTargetMarketProgram,noridentifyanyset‐asidesthatwereinplaceinthesedistrictsthatwouldhavehindereditsabilitytocompeteforfencingandguardrailswork.Id.at723.MidwestdidnotallegethatitwouldhavebidoncontractssetasidepursuanttotheTargetMarketProgramhaditnotbeenpreventedfromdoingso.Id.BecausenothingintherecordMidwestprovidedsuggestedthattheTargetMarketProgramimpededMidwest’sabilitytocompeteforworkintheseDistricts,thecourtdismissedMidwest’sclaimrelatingtotheTargetMarketProgramforlackofstanding.Id.
![Page 322: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/322.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 196
Facial challenge to the Federal DBE Program.Thecourtfoundthatremedyingtheeffectsofraceandgenderdiscriminationwithintheroadconstructionindustryisacompellinggovernmentalinterest.ThecourtalsofoundthattheFederalDefendantshavesupportedtheircompellinginterestwithastrongbasisinevidence.Id.at725.TheFederalDefendants,thecourtsaid,presentedanextensivebodyoftestimony,reports,andstudiesthattheyclaimprovidedthestrongbasisinevidencefortheirconclusionthatraceandgender‐basedclassificationsarenecessary.Id.ThecourttookjudicialnoticeoftheexistenceofCongressionalhearingsandreportsandthecollectionofevidencepresentedtoCongressinsupportoftheFederalDBEProgram’s2012reauthorizationunderMAP‐21,includingbothstatisticalandanecdotalevidence.Id.
Thecourtalsoconsideredareportfromaconsultantwhoreviewed95disparityandavailabilitystudiesconcerningminority‐andwomen‐ownedbusinesses,aswellasanecdotalevidence,thatwerecompletedfrom2000to2012.Id.at726.Sixty‐fourofthestudieshadpreviouslybeenpresentedtoCongress.Id.Thestudiesexamineprocurementforover100publicentitiesandfundingsourcesacross32states.Id.Theconsultant’sreportopinedthatmetricssuchasfirmrevenue,numberofemployees,andbondinglimitsshouldnotbeconsideredwhendeterminingDBEavailabilitybecausetheyareall“likelytobeinfluencedbythepresenceofdiscriminationifitexists”andcouldpotentiallyresultinabuilt‐indownwardbiasintheavailabilitymeasure.Id.
Tomeasuredisparity,theconsultantdividedDBEutilizationbyavailabilityandmultipliedby100tocalculatea“disparityindex”foreachstudy.Id.at726.Thereportfound66percentofthestudiesshowedadisparityindexof80orbelow,thatis,significantlyunderutilizedrelativetotheiravailability.Id.Thereportalsoexamineddatathatshowedlowerearningsandbusinessformationratesamongwomenandminorities,evenwhenvariablessuchasageandeducationwereheldconstant.Id.Thereportconcludedthatthedisparitieswerenotattributabletofactorsotherthanraceandsexandwereconsistentwiththepresenceofdiscriminationinconstructionandrelatedprofessionalservices.Id.
ThecourtdistinguishedtheFederalCircuitdecisioninRotheDev.Corp.v.Dep’t.ofDef.,545F.3d1023(Fed.Cir.2008)wheretheFederalCircuitCourtheldinsufficienttherelianceononlysixdisparitystudiestosupportthegovernment’scompellinginterestinimplementinganationalprogram.Id.at727,citingRothe,545F.3dat1046.ThecourtherenotedtheconsultantreportsupplementsthetestimonyandreportspresentedtoCongressinsupportoftheFederalDBEProgram,whichcourtshavefoundtoestablisha“strongbasisinevidence”tosupporttheconclusionthatrace‐andgender‐consciousactionisnecessary.Id.
ThecourtfoundthroughtheevidencepresentedbytheFederalDefendantssatisfiedtheirburdeninshowingthattheFederalDBEProgramstandsonastrongbasisinevidence.Id.at727.TheMidwestexpert’ssuggestionthatthestudiesusedinconsultant’sreportdonotproperlyaccountforcapacity,thecourtstated,doesnotcompelthecourttofindotherwise.ThecourtquotingAdarandVII,228F.3dat1173(10thCir.2000)saidthatgeneralcriticismofdisparitystudies,asopposedtoparticularevidenceunderminingthereliabilityoftheparticulardisparitystudiesrelieduponbythegovernment,isoflittlepersuasivevalueanddoesnotcompelthecourttodiscountthedisparityevidence.Id.Midwestfailedtopresent“affirmativeevidence”thatnoremedialactionwasnecessary.Id.
![Page 323: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/323.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 197
Federal DBE Program is narrowly tailored.Oncethegovernmenthasestablishedacompellinginterestforimplementingarace‐consciousprogram,itmustshowthattheprogramisnarrowlytailoredtoachievethisinterest.Id.at727.Indeterminingwhetheraprogramisnarrowlytailored,courtsexamineseveralfactors,including(a)thenecessityforthereliefandefficacyofalternativerace‐neutralmeasures,(b)theflexibilityanddurationoftherelief,includingtheavailabilityofwaiverprovisions,(c)therelationshipofthenumericalgoalstotherelevantlabormarket,and(d)theimpactofthereliefontherightsofthirdparties.Id.Thecourtstatedthatcourtsmayalsoassesswhetheraprogramis“overinclusive.”Id.at728.ThecourtfoundthateachoftheabovefactorssupportstheconclusionthattheFederalDBEProgramisnarrowlytailored.Id.
First,thecourtsaidthatunderthefederalregulations,recipientsoffederalfundscanonlyturntorace‐andgender‐consciousmeasuresaftertheyhaveattemptedtomeettheirDBEparticipationgoalthroughrace‐neutralmeans.Id.at728.Thecourtnotedthatrace‐neutralmeansincludemakingcontractingopportunitiesmoreaccessibletosmallbusinesses,providingassistanceinobtainingbondingandfinancing,andofferingtechnicalandothersupportservices.Id.Thecourtfoundthattheregulationsrequireserious,goodfaithconsiderationofworkablerace‐neutralalternatives.Id.
Second,thefederalregulationscontainprovisionsthatlimittheFederalDBEProgram’sdurationandensureitsflexibility.Id.at728.ThecourtfoundthattheFederalDBEProgramlastsonlyaslongasitscurrentauthorizingactallows,notingthatwitheachreauthorization,CongressmustreevaluatetheFederalDBEPrograminlightofsupportingevidence.Id.ThecourtalsofoundthattheFederalDBEProgramaffordsrecipientsoffederalfundsandprimecontractorssubstantialflexibility.Id.at728.Recipientsmayapplyforexemptionsorwaivers,releasingthemfromprogramrequirements.Id.PrimecontractorscanapplytoIDOTfora“goodfaitheffortswaiver”onanindividualcontractgoal.Id.
Thecourtstatedtheavailabilityofwaiversisparticularlyimportantinestablishingflexibility.Id.at728.ThecourtrejectedMidwest’sargumentthatthefederalregulationsimposeaquotainlightoftheProgram’sexplicitwaiverprovision.Id.Basedontheavailabilityofwaivers,coupledwithregularcongressionalreview,thecourtfoundthattheFederalDBEProgramissufficientlylimitedandflexible.Id.
Third,thecourtsaidthattheFederalDBEProgramemploysatwo‐stepgoal‐settingprocessthattiesDBEparticipationgoalsbyrecipientsoffederalfundstolocalmarketconditions.Id.at728.ThecourtpointedoutthattheregulationsdelegategoalsettingtorecipientsoffederalfundswhotailorDBEparticipationtolocalDBEavailability.Id.ThecourtfoundthattheFederalDBEProgram’sgoal‐settingprocessrequiresstatestofocusonestablishingrealisticgoalsforDBEparticipationthatarecloselytiedtotherelevantlabormarket.Id.
Fourth,thefederalregulations,accordingtothecourt,containprovisionsthatseektominimizetheProgram’sburdenonnon‐DBEs.Id.at729.Thecourtpointedoutthefollowingprovisionsaimtokeeptheburdenonnon‐DBEsminimal:theFederalDBEProgram’spresumptionofsocialandeconomicdisadvantageisrebuttable;raceisnotadeterminativefactor;intheeventDBEsbecome“overconcentrated”inaparticularareaofcontractwork,recipientsmusttake
![Page 324: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/324.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 198
appropriatemeasurestoaddresstheoverconcentration;theuseofrace‐neutralmeasures;andtheavailabilityofgoodfaitheffortswaivers.Id.
ThecourtsaidMidwest’sprimaryargumentisthatthepracticeofstatestoawardprimecontractstothelowestbidder,andthefactthefederalregulationsprescribethatDBEparticipationgoalsbeappliedtothevalueoftheentirecontract,undulyburdensnon‐DBEsubcontractors.Id.at729.MidwestarguedthatbecausemostDBEsaresmallsubcontractors,settinggoalsasapercentageofallcontractdollars,whilerequiringaremedytocomeonlyfromsubcontractingdollars,undulyburdenssmaller,specializednon‐DBEs.Id.ThecourtfoundthatthefactinnocentpartiesmaybearsomeoftheburdenofaDBEprogramisitselfinsufficienttowarranttheconclusionthataprogramisnotnarrowlytailored.Id.ThecourtalsofoundthatstrongpolicyreasonssupporttheFederalDBEProgram’sapproach.Id.
ThecourtstatedthatcongressionaltestimonyandtheexpertreportfromtheFederalDefendantsprovideevidencethattheFederalDBEProgramisnotoverlyinclusive.Id.at729.Thecourtnotedthereportobservedstatisticallysignificantdisparitiesinbusinessformationandearningsratesinall50statesforallminoritygroupsandfornon‐minoritywomen.Id.
ThecourtsaidthatMidwestdidnotattempttorebuttheFederalDefendants’evidence.Idat729.Therefore,becausetheFederalDBEProgramstandsonastrongbasisinevidenceandisnarrowlytailoredtoachievethegoalofremedyingdiscrimination,thecourtfoundtheProgramisconstitutionalonitsface.Id.at729.ThecourtthusgrantedsummaryjudgmentinfavoroftheFederalDefendants.Id.
As‐applied challenge to IDOT’s implementation of the Federal DBE Program.InadditiontochallengingtheFederalDBEProgramonitsface,Midwestalsoarguedthatitisunconstitutionalasapplied.Id.at730.ThecourtstatedbecausetheFederalDBEProgramisappliedtoMidwestthroughIDOT,thecourtmustexamineIDOT’simplementationoftheFederalDBEProgram.Id.FollowingtheSeventhCircuit’sdecisioninNorthernContractingv.IllinoisDOT,thecourtsaidthatwhethertheFederalDBEProgramisunconstitutionalasappliedisaquestionofwhetherIDOTexceededitsauthorityinimplementingit.Id.at730,citingNorthernContracting,Inc.v.Illinois,473F.3d715at722(7thCir.2007).Thecourt,quotingNorthernContracting,heldthatachallengetoastate’sapplicationofafederallymandatedprogrammustbelimitedtothequestionofwhetherthestateexceededitsauthority.Id.
IDOTnotonlyappliestheFederalDBEProgramtoUSDOT‐assistedprojects,butitalsoappliestheFederalDBEProgramtostate‐fundedprojects.Id.at730.Thecourt,therefore,helditmustdeterminewhethertheIDOTDefendantshaveestablishedacompellingreasontoapplytheIDOTProgramtostate‐fundedprojectsinIllinois.Id.
ThecourtpointedoutthattheFederalDBEProgramdelegatesthenarrowtailoringfunctiontothestate,andthus,IDOTmustdemonstratethatthereisademonstrableneedfortheimplementationoftheFederalDBEProgramwithinitsjurisdiction.Id.at730.Accordingly,thecourtassessedwhetherIDOThasestablishedevidenceofdiscriminationinIllinoissufficientto(1)supportitsapplicationoftheFederalDBEProgramtostate‐fundedcontracts,and(2)demonstratethatIDOT’simplementationoftheFederalDBEProgramislimitedtoaplacewhererace‐basedmeasuresaredemonstrablyneeded.Id.
![Page 325: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/325.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 199
IDOT’s evidence of discrimination and DBE availability in Illinois.TheevidencethatIDOThaspresentedtoestablishtheexistenceofdiscriminationinIllinoisincludedtwostudies,onethatwasdonein2004andtheotherin2011.Id.at730.Thecourtsaidthatthe2004studyuncovereddisparitiesinearningsandbusinessformationratesamongwomenandminoritiesintheconstructionandengineeringfieldsthatthestudyconcludedwereconsistentwithdiscrimination.IDOTmaintainedthatthe2004studyandthe2011studymustbereadinconjunctionwithoneanother.Id.Thecourtfoundthatthe2011studyprovidedevidencetoestablishthedisparityfromwhichIDOT’sinferenceofdiscriminationprimarilyarises.Id.
The2011studycomparedtheproportionofcontractingdollarsawardedtoDBEs(utilization)withtheavailabilityofDBEs.Id.at730.Thestudydeterminedavailabilitythroughmultiplesources,includingbidderslists,prequalifiedbusinesslists,andothermethodsrecommendedinthefederalregulations.Id.ThestudyappliedNAICScodestodifferenttypesofcontractwork,assigninggreaterweighttocategoriesofworkinwhichIDOThadexpendedthemostmoney.Id.at731.Thisresultedina“weighted”DBEavailabilitycalculation.Id.
The2011studyexaminedprimeandsubcontractsandanecdotalevidenceconcerningraceandgenderdiscriminationintheIllinoisroadconstructionindustry,includingone‐on‐oneinterviewsandasurveyofmorethan5,000contractors.Id.at731.The2011study,thecourtsaid,containedaregressionanalysisofprivatesectordataandfounddisparitiesinearningsandbusinessownershipratesamongminoritiesandwomen,evenwhencontrollingforrace‐andgender‐neutralvariables.Id.
ThestudyconcludedthattherewasastatisticallysignificantunderutilizationofDBEsintheawardofbothprimeandsubcontractsinIllinois.Id.at731.Forexample,thecourtnotedthedifferencethestudyfoundinthepercentageofavailableprimeconstructioncontractorstothepercentageofprimeconstructioncontractsunder$500,000,andthepercentageofavailableconstructionsubcontractorstotheamountofpercentageofdollarsreceivedofconstructionsubcontracts.Id.
IDOTpresentedcertainevidencetomeasureDBEavailabilityinIllinois.Thecourtpointedoutthatthe2004studyandtwosubsequentGoal‐SettingReportswereusedinestablishingIDOT’sDBEparticipationgoal.Id.at731.The2004studyarrivedatIDOT’s22.77percentDBEparticipationgoalinaccordancewiththetwo‐stepprocessdefinedinthefederalregulations.Id.Thecourtstatedthe2004studyemployedaseven‐step“customcensus”approachtocalculatebaselineDBEavailabilityundersteponeoftheregulations.Id.
TheprocessbeginsbyidentifyingtherelevantmarketsinwhichIDOToperatesandthecategoriesofbusinessesthataccountforthebulkofIDOTspending.Id.at731.TheindustriesandcountiesinwhichIDOTexpendsrelativelymorecontractdollarsreceiveproportionatelyhigherweightsintheultimatecalculationofstatewideDBEavailability.Id.Thestudythencountsthenumberofbusinessesintherelevantmarkets,andidentifieswhichareminority‐andwomen‐owned.Id.Toensuretheaccuracyofthisinformation,thestudyprovidesthatittakesadditionalstepstoverifytheownershipstatusofeachbusiness.Id.Understeptwooftheregulations,thestudyadjustedthisfigureto27.51percentbasedonCensusBureaudata.Id.Accordingtothestudy,theadjustmenttakesintoaccountitsconclusionthatbaselinenumbersareartificiallylowerthanwhatwouldbeexpectedinarace‐neutralmarketplace.Id.
![Page 326: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/326.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 200
IDOTusedseparateGoal‐SettingReportsthatcalculatedIDOT’sDBEparticipationgoalpursuanttothetwo‐stepprocessinthefederalregulations,drawingfrombidderslists,DBEdirectories,andthe2011studytocalculatebaselineDBEavailability.Id.at731.ThestudyandtheGoal–SettingReportsgavegreaterweighttothetypesofcontractworkinwhichIDOThadexpendedrelativelymoremoney.Id.at732.
Court rejected Midwest arguments as to the data and evidence.ThecourtrejectedthechallengesbyMidwesttotheaccuracyofIDOT’sdata.Forexample,Midwestarguedthattheanecdotalevidencecontainedinthe2011studydoesnotprovediscrimination.Id.at732.Thecourtstated,however,whereanecdotalevidencehasbeenofferedinconjunctionwithstatisticalevidence,itmaylendsupporttothegovernment’sdeterminationthatremedialactionisnecessary.Id.Thecourtnotedthatanecdotalevidenceonitsowncouldnotbeusedtoshowageneralpolicyofdiscrimination.Id.
ThecourtrejectedanotherargumentbyMidwestthatthedatacollectedafterIDOT’simplementationoftheFederalDBEProgrammaybebiasedbecauseanythingobservedaboutthepublicsectormaybeaffectedbytheDBEProgram.Id.at732.Thecourtrejectedthatargumentfindingpost‐enactmentevidenceofdiscriminationpermissible.Id.
Midwest’smainobjectiontotheIDOTevidence,accordingtothecourt,isthatitfailedtoaccountforcapacitywhenmeasuringDBEavailabilityandunderutilization.Id.at732.MidwestarguedthatIDOT’sdisparitystudiesfailedtoruleoutcapacityasapossibleexplanationfortheobserveddisparities.Id.
IDOTarguedthatonprimecontractsunder$500,000,capacityisavariablethatmakeslittledifference.Id.at732‐733.Primecontractsofvaryingsizesunder$500,000weredistributedtoDBEsandnon‐DBEsalikeatapproximatelythesamerate.Id.at733.IDOTalsoarguedthatthroughregressionanalysis,the2011studydemonstratedfactorsotherthandiscriminationdidnotaccountforthedisparitybetweenDBEutilizationandavailability.Id.
ThecourtstatedthatdespiteMidwest’sargumentthatthe2011studytookinsufficientmeasurestoruleoutcapacityasarace‐neutralexplanationfortheunderutilizationofDBEs,theSupremeCourthasindicatedthataregressionanalysisneednottakeintoaccount“allmeasurablevariables”toruleoutrace‐neutralexplanationsforobserveddisparities.Id.at733,quotingBazemorev.Friday,478U.S.385,400(1986).
Midwest criticisms insufficient, speculative and conjecture – no independent statistical
analysis; IDOT followed Northern Contracting and did not exceed the federal regulations.ThecourtfoundMidwest’scriticismsinsufficienttorebutIDOT’sevidenceofdiscriminationordiscreditIDOT’smethodsofcalculatingDBEavailability.Id.at733.First,thecourtsaid,the“evidence”offeredbyMidwest’sexpertreports“isspeculativeatbest.”Id.ThecourtfoundthatforareasonablejurytofindinfavorofMidwest,Midwestwouldhavetocomeforwardwith“credible,particularizedevidence”ofitsown,suchasaneutralexplanationforthedisparity,orcontrastingstatisticaldata.Id.ThecourtheldthatMidwestfailedtomaketheshowinginthiscase.Id.
![Page 327: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/327.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 201
Second,thecourtstatedthatIDOT’smethodofcalculatingDBEavailabilityisconsistentwiththefederalregulationsandhasbeenendorsedbytheSeventhCircuit.Id.at733.Thefederalregulations,thecourtsaid,approveavarietyofmethodsforaccuratelymeasuringready,willing,andavailableDBEs,suchastheuseofDBEdirectories,CensusBureaudata,andbidderslists.Id.Thecourtfoundthatthesearethemethodsthe2011studyadoptedincalculatingDBEavailability.Id.
ThecourtsaidthattheSeventhCircuitCourtofAppealsapprovedthe“customcensus”approachasconsistentwiththefederalregulations.Id.at733,citingtoNorthernContractingv.IllinoisDOT,473F.3dat723.ThecourtnotedtheSeventhCircuitrejectedtheargumentthatavailabilityshouldbebasedonasimplecountofregisteredandprequalifiedDBEsunderIllinoislaw,findingnorequirementinthefederalregulationsthatarecipientmustsonarrowlydefinethescopeofready,willing,andavailablefirms.Id.Thecourtalsorejectedthenotionthatanavailabilitymeasureshoulddistinguishbetweenprimeandsubcontractors.Id.at733‐734.
Thecourtheldthatthroughthe2004and2011studies,andGoal–SettingReports,IDOTprovidedevidenceofdiscriminationintheIllinoisroadconstructionindustryandamethodofDBEavailabilitycalculationthatisconsistentwithboththefederalregulationsandtheSeventhCircuitdecisioninNorthernContractv.IllinoisDOT.Id.at734.ThecourtsaidthatinresponsetotheSeventhCircuitdecisionandIDOT’sevidence,Midwestofferedonlyconjectureabouthowthesestudiessupposedfailuretoaccountforcapacitymayormaynothaveimpactedthestudies’result.Id.
ThecourtpointedoutthatalthoughMidwest’sexpert’sreports“castdoubtonthevalidityofIDOT’smethodology,theyfailedtoprovideanyindependentstatisticalanalysisorotherevidencedemonstratingactualbias.”Id.at734.Withoutthisshowing,thecourtstated,therecordfailstodemonstratealackofevidenceofdiscriminationoractualflawsinIDOT’savailabilitycalculations.Id.
Burden on non–DBE subcontractors; overconcentration.Thecourtaddressedthenarrowtailoringfactorconcerningwhetheraprogram’sburdenonthirdpartiesisundueorunreasonable.ThepartiesdisagreedaboutwhethertheIDOTprogramresultedinanoverconcentrationofDBEsinthefencingandguardrailindustry.Id.at734‐735.IDOTpreparedanoverconcentrationstudycomparingthetotalnumberofprequalifiedfencingandguardrailcontractorstothenumberofDBEsthatalsoperformthattypeofworkanddeterminedthatnooverconcentrationproblemexisted.Midwestpresenteditsevidencerelatingtooverconcentration.Id.at735.ThecourtfoundthatMidwestdidnotshowIDOT’sdeterminationthatoverconcentrationdoesnotexistamongfencingandguardrailcontractorstobeunreasonable.Id.at735.
ThecourtstatedthefactIDOTsetscontractgoalsasapercentageoftotalcontractdollarsdoesnotdemonstratethatIDOTimposesanundueburdenonnon‐DBEsubcontractors,buttothecontrary,IDOTisactingwithinthescopeofthefederalregulationsthatrequiresgoalstobesetinthismanner.Id.at735.Thecourtnotedthatitrecognizessettinggoalsasapercentageoftotalcontractvalueaddressesthewidespread,indirecteffectsofdiscriminationthatmaypreventDBEsfromcompetingasprimesinthefirstplace,andthatasharingoftheburdenbyinnocentparties,herenon‐DBEsubcontractors,ispermissible.Id.ThecourtheldthatIDOTcarriedits
![Page 328: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/328.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 202
burdeninprovidingpersuasiveevidenceofdiscriminationinIllinois,andfoundthatsuchsharingoftheburdenispermissiblehere.Id.
Use of race–neutral alternatives.ThecourtfoundthatIDOTidentifiedseveralrace‐neutralprogramsitusedtoincreaseDBEparticipation,includingitsSupportiveServices,Mentor–Protégé,andModelContractorPrograms.Id.at735.Theprogramsprovideworkshopsandtrainingthathelpsmallbusinessesbuildbondingcapacity,gainaccesstofinancialandprojectmanagementresources,andlearnaboutspecificprocurementopportunities.Id.IDOTconductedseveralstudiesincludingzero‐participationgoalscontractsinwhichtherewasnoDBEparticipationgoal,andfoundthatDBEsreceivedonly0.84percentofthetotaldollarvalueawarded.Id.
ThecourtheldIDOTwascompliantwiththefederalregulations,notingthatintheNorthernContractingv.IllinoisDOTcase,theSeventhCircuitfoundIDOTemployedalmostallofthemethodssuggestedintheregulationstomaximizeDBEparticipationwithoutresortingtorace,includingprovidingassistanceinobtainingbondingandfinancing,implementingasupportiveservicesprogram,andprovidingtechnicalassistance.Id.at735.ThecourtagreedwiththeSeventhCircuit,andfoundthatIDOThasmadeserious,goodfaithconsiderationofworkablerace‐neutralalternatives.Id.
Duration and flexibility.ThecourtpointedoutthatthestatestatutethroughwhichtheFederalDBEProgramisimplementedislimitedindurationandmustbereauthorizedeverytwotofiveyears.Id.at736.ThecourtreviewedevidencethatIDOTgranted270ofthe362goodfaithwaiverrequeststhatitreceivedfrom2006to2014,andthatIDOTgranted1,002post‐awardwaiversonover$36millionincontractingdollars.Id.ThecourtnotedthatIDOTgrantedtheonlygoodfaitheffortswaiverthatMidwestrequested.Id.
ThecourtheldtheundisputedfactsestablishedthatIDOTdidnothavea“no‐waiverpolicy.”Id.at736.Thecourtfoundthatitcouldnotconcludethatthewaiverprovisionswereimpermissiblyvague,andthatIDOTtookintoconsiderationthesubstantialguidanceprovidedinthefederalregulations.Id.at736‐737.BecauseMidwest’sownexperiencedemonstratedtheflexibilityoftheFederalDBEPrograminpractice,thecourtsaiditcouldnotconcludethattheIDOTprogramamountstoanimpermissiblequotasystemthatisunconstitutionalonitsface.Id.at737.
ThecourtagainstatedthatMidwesthadnotpresentedanyaffirmativeevidenceshowingthatIDOT’simplementationoftheFederalDBEProgramimposesanundueburdenonnon‐DBEs,failstoemployrace‐neutralmeasures,orlacksflexibility.Id.at737.Accordingly,thecourtgrantedIDOT’smotionforsummaryjudgment.
Facial and as–applied challenges to the Tollway program.TheIllinoisTollwayProgramexistsindependentlyoftheFederalDBEProgram.MidwestchallengedtheTollwayProgramasunconstitutionalonitsfaceandasapplied.Id.at737.LiketheFederalandIDOTDefendants,theTollwaywasrequiredtoshowthatitscompellinginterestinremedyingdiscriminationintheIllinoisroadconstructionindustryrestsonastrongbasisinevidence.Id.TheTollwayreliedona2006disparitystudy,whichexaminedthedisparitybetweentheTollway’sutilizationofDBEsandtheiravailability.Id.
![Page 329: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/329.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 203
Thestudyemployeda“customcensus”approachtocalculateDBEavailability,andexaminedtheTollway’scontractdatatodetermineutilization.Id.at737.The2006studyreportedstatisticallysignificantdisparitiesforallraceandsexcategoriesexamined.Id.Thestudyalsoconductedan“economy‐wideanalysis”examiningotherraceandsexdisparitiesinthewiderconstructioneconomyfrom1979to2002.Id.Controllingforrace‐andgender‐neutralvariables,thestudyshowedasignificantnegativecorrelationbetweenaperson’sraceorsexandtheirearningpowerandabilitytoformabusiness.Id.
Midwest’s challenges to the Tollway evidence insufficient and speculative.In2013,theTollwaycommissionedanewstudy,whichthecourtnotedwasnotcomplete,buttherewasan“economy‐wideanalysis”similartotheanalysisdonein2006thatupdatedcensusdatagatheredfrom2007to2011.Id.at737‐738.Theupdatedcensusanalysis,accordingtothecourt,controlledforvariablessuchaseducation,ageandoccupationandfoundlowerearningsandratesofbusinessformationamongwomenandminoritiesascomparedtowhitemen.Id.at738.
MidwestattackedtheTollway’s2006studysimilartohowitattackedtheotherstudieswithregardtoIDOT’sDBEProgram.Id.at738.Forexample,Midwestattackedthe2006studyasbeingbiasedbecauseitfailedtotakeintoaccountcapacityindeterminingthedisparities.Id.TheTollwaydefendedthe2006studyarguingthatcapacitymetricsshouldnotbetakenintoaccountbecausetheTollwayassertedtheyarethemselvesaproductofindirectdiscrimination,theconstructionindustryiselasticinnature,andthatfirmscaneasilyrampuporratchetdowntoaccommodatethesizeofaproject.Id.TheTollwayalsoarguedthatthe“economy‐wideanalysis”revealedanegativecorrelationbetweenanindividual’sraceandsexandtheirearningpowerandabilitytoownorformabusiness,showingthattheunderutilizationofDBEsisconsistentwithdiscrimination.Id.at738.
TosuccessfullyrebuttheTollway’sevidenceofdiscrimination,thecourtstatedthatMidwestmustcomeforwardwithaneutralexplanationforthedisparity,showthattheTollway’sstatisticsareflawed,demonstratethattheobserveddisparitiesareinsignificant,orpresentcontrastingdataofitsown.Id.at738‐739.Again,thecourtfoundthatMidwestfailedtomakethisshowing,andthattheevidenceofferedthroughtheexpertreportsforMidwestwasfartoospeculativetocreateadisputedissueoffactsuitablefortrial.Id.at739.Accordingly,thecourtfoundtheTollwayDefendantsestablishedastrongbasisinevidencefortheTollwayProgram.Id.
Tollway Program is narrowly tailored.AstodeterminingwhethertheTollwayProgramisnarrowlytailored,MidwestalsoarguedthattheTollwayProgramimposedanundueburdenonnon‐DBEsubcontractors.LikeIDOT,theTollwaysetsindividualcontractgoalsasapercentageofthevalueoftheentirecontractbasedontheavailabilityofDBEstoperformparticularlineitems.Id.at739.
Thecourtreiteratedthatsettinggoalsasapercentageoftotalcontractdollarsdoesnotdemonstrateanundueburdenonnon‐DBEsubcontractors,andthattheTollway’smethodofgoalsettingisidenticaltothatprescribedbythefederalregulations,whichthecourtalreadyfoundtobesupportedbystrongpolicyreasons.Id.at739.Thecourtstatedthatthesharingofaremedialprogram’sburdenisitselfinsufficienttowarranttheconclusionthattheprogramisnotnarrowlytailored.Id.at739.ThecourtheldtheTollwayProgram’sburdenonnon‐DBEsubcontractorstobepermissible.Id.
![Page 330: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/330.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 204
Inaddressingtheefficacyofrace‐neutralmeasures,thecourtfoundtheTollwayimplementedrace‐neutralprogramstoincreaseDBEparticipation,includingaprogramthatallowssmallercontractstobeunbundledfromlargerones,aSmallBusinessInitiativethatsetsasidecontractsforsmallbusinessesonarace‐neutralbasis,partnershipswithagenciesthatprovidesupportservicestosmallbusinesses,andotherprogramsdesignedtomakeiteasierforsmallercontractorstodobusinesswiththeTollwayingeneral.Id.at739‐740.ThecourtheldtheTollway’srace‐neutralmeasuresareconsistentwiththosesuggestedunderthefederalregulationsandfoundthattheavailabilityoftheseprograms,whichmirrorIDOT’s,demonstratesserious,goodfaithconsiderationofworkablerace‐neutralalternatives.Id.at740.
Inconsideringtheissueofflexibility,thecourtfoundtheTollwayProgram,liketheFederalDBEProgram,providesforwaiverswhereprimecontractorsareunabletomeetDBEparticipationgoals,buthavemadegoodfaitheffortstodoso.Id.at740.LikeIDOT,thecourtsaidtheTollwayadherestothefederalregulationsindeterminingwhetherabidderhasmadegoodfaithefforts.Id.AsundertheFederalDBEProgram,theTollwayProgramalsoallowsbidderswhohavebeendeniedwaiverstoappeal.Id.
From2006to2011,thecourtstated,theTollwaygrantedwaiversonapproximately20percentofthe200primeconstructioncontractsitawarded.Id.at740.BecausetheTollwaydemonstratedthatwaiversareavailable,routinelygranted,andawardedordeniedbasedonguidancefoundinthefederalregulations,thecourtfoundtheTollwayProgramsufficientlyflexible.Id.
Midwestpresentednoaffirmativeevidence.ThecourtheldtheTollwayDefendantsprovidedastrongbasisinevidencefortheirDBEProgram,whereasMidwest,didnotcomeforwardwithanyconcrete,affirmativeevidencetoshakethisfoundation.Id.at740.ThecourtthusheldtheTollwayProgramwasnarrowlytailoredandgrantedtheTollwayDefendants’motionforsummaryjudgment.Id.
Notice of Appeal.Atthetimeofthisreport,MidwestFenceCorporationhasfiledaNoticeofAppealtotheUnitedStatesCourtofAppealsfortheSeventhCircuit,whichappealispending.
10. Geyer Signal, Inc. v. Minnesota, DOT, 2014 WL 1309092 (D. Minn. March 31, 2014)
InGeyerSignal,Inc.,etal.v.MinnesotaDOT,USDOT,FederalHighwayAdministration,etal.,CaseNo.11‐CV‐321,UnitedStatesDistrictCourtfortheDistrictCourtofMinnesota,theplaintiffsGeyerSignal,Inc.anditsownerfiledthislawsuitagainsttheMinnesotaDOT(MnDOT)seekingapermanentinjunctionagainstenforcementandadeclarationofunconstitutionalityoftheFederalDBEProgramandMinnesotaDOT’simplementationoftheDBEProgramonitsfaceandasapplied.GeyerSignalsoughtaninjunctionagainsttheMinnesotaDOTprohibitingitfromenforcingtheDBEProgramor,alternatively,fromimplementingtheProgramimproperly;adeclaratoryjudgmentdeclaringthattheDBEProgramviolatestheEqualprotectionelementoftheFifthAmendmentoftheUnitedStatesConstitutionand/ortheEqualProtectionclauseoftheFourteenthAmendmenttotheUnitedStatesConstitutionandisunconstitutional,or,inthealternativethatMinnesotaDOT’simplementationoftheProgramisanunconstitutionalviolationoftheEqualProtectionClause,and/orthattheProgramisvoidforvagueness;andotherrelief.
![Page 331: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/331.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 205
Procedural background.PlaintiffGeyerSignalisasmall,family‐ownedbusinessthatperformstrafficcontrolworkgenerallyonroadconstructionprojects.GeyerSignalisafirmownedbyaCaucasianmale,whoalsoisanamedplaintiff.
SubsequenttothelawsuitfiledbyGeyerSignal,theUSDOTandtheFederalHighwayAdministrationfiledtheirMotiontopermitthemtointerveneasdefendantsinthiscase.TheFederalDefendant‐IntervenorsrequestedinterventiononthecaseinordertodefendtheconstitutionalityoftheFederalDBEProgramandthefederalregulationsatissue.TheFederalDefendant‐IntervenorsandtheplaintiffsfiledaStipulationthattheFederalDefendant‐Intervenorshavetherighttointerveneandshouldbepermittedtointerveneinthematter,andconsequentlytheplaintiffsdidnotcontesttheFederalDefendant‐Intervenor’sMotionforIntervention.TheCourtissuedanOrderthattheStipulationofIntervention,agreeingthattheFederalDefendant‐Intervenorsmayinterveneinthislawsuit,beapprovedandthattheFederalDefendant‐Intervenorsarepermittedtointerveneinthiscase.
TheFederalDefendantsmovedforsummaryjudgmentandtheStatedefendantsmovedtodismiss,orinthealternativeforsummaryjudgment,arguingthattheDBEProgramonitsfaceandasimplementedbyMnDOTisconstitutional.TheCourtconcludedthattheplaintiffs,GeyerSignalanditswhitemaleowner,KevinKissner,raisednogenuineissueofmaterialfactwithrespecttotheconstitutionalityoftheDBEProgramfaciallyorasapplied.Therefore,theCourtgrantedtheFederalDefendantsandtheStatedefendants’motionsforsummaryjudgmentintheirentirety.
Plaintiffsallegedthatthereisinsufficientevidenceofacompellinggovernmentalinteresttosupportarace‐basedprogramforDBEuseinthefieldsoftrafficcontrolorlandscaping.(2014WL1309092at*10)Additionally,plaintiffsallegedthattheDBEProgramisnotnarrowlytailoredbecauseit(1)treatstheconstructionindustryasmonolithic,leadingtoanoverconcentrationofDBEparticipationintheareasoftrafficsignalandlandscapingwork;(2)allowsrecipientstosetcontractgoals;and(3)setsgoalsbasedonthenumberofDBEsthereare,nottheamountofworkthoseDBEscanactuallyperform.Id.*10.PlaintiffsalsoallegedthattheDBEProgramisunconstitutionallyvaguebecauseitallowsprimecontractorstousebidsfromDBEsthatarehigherthanthebidsofnon‐DBEs,providedtheincreaseinpriceisnotunreasonable,withoutdefiningwhatincreasedcostsare“reasonable.”Id.
Constitutional claims.TheCourtstatesthatthe“heartofplaintiffs”claimsisthattheDBEProgramandMnDOT’simplementationofitareunconstitutionalbecausetheimpactofcuringdiscriminationintheconstructionindustryisoverconcentratedinparticularsub‐categoriesofwork.”Id.at*11.TheCourtnotedthatbecauseDBEsare,bydefinition,smallbusinesses,plaintiffscontendthey“simplycannotperformthevastmajorityofthetypesofworkrequiredforfederally‐fundedMnDOTprojectsbecausetheylackthefinancialresourcesandequipmentnecessarytoconductsuchwork.”Id.
Asaresult,plaintiffsclaimedthatDBEsonlycompeteincertainsmallareasofMnDOTwork,suchastrafficcontrol,trucking,andsupply,buttheDBEgoalsthatprimecontractorsmustmeetarespreadoutovertheentirecontract.Id.PlaintiffsassertedthatprimecontractorsareforcedtodisproportionatelyuseDBEsinthosesmallareasofwork,andthatnon–DBEsinthoseareas
![Page 332: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/332.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 206
ofworkareforcedtobeartheentireburdenof“correctingdiscrimination”,whilethevastmajorityofnon‐DBEsinMnDOTcontractinghaveessentiallynoDBEcompetition.Id.
PlaintiffsthereforearguedthattheDBEProgramisnotnarrowlytailoredbecauseitmeansthatanyDBEgoalsareonlybeingmetthroughafewareasofworkonconstructionprojects,whichburdennon‐DBEsinthosesectorsanddonotalleviateanyproblemsinothersectors.Id.at#11.
PlaintiffsbroughttwofacialchallengestotheFederalDBEProgram.Id.PlaintiffsallegethattheDBEProgramisfaciallyunconstitutionalbecauseitis“fatallypronetooverconcentration”whereDBEgoalsaremetdisproportionatelyinareasofworkthatrequirelittleoverheadandcapital.Id.at11.Second,plaintiffsallegedthattheDBEProgramisunconstitutionallyvaguebecauseitrequiresprimecontractorstoacceptDBEbidseveniftheDBEbidsarehigherthanthosefromnon‐DBEs,providedtheincreasedcostis“reasonable”withoutdefiningareasonableincreaseincost.Id.
Plaintiffsalsobroughtthreeas‐appliedchallengesbasedonMnDOT’simplementationoftheDBEProgram.Id.at12.First,plaintiffscontendedthatMnDOThasunconstitutionallyappliedtheDBEProgramtoitscontractingbecausethereisnoevidenceofdiscriminationagainstDBEsingovernmentcontractinginMinnesota.Id.Second,theycontendedthatMnDOThassetimpermissiblyhighgoalsforDBEparticipation.Finally,plaintiffsarguedthattotheextenttheDBEFederalProgramallowsMnDOTtocorrectforoverconcentration,ithasfailedtodoso,renderingitsimplementationoftheProgramunconstitutional.Id.
A. Strict scrutiny.ItisundisputedthatstrictscrutinyappliedtotheCourt’sevaluationoftheFederalDBEProgram,whetherthechallengeisfacialoras‐applied.Id.at*12.Understrictscrutiny,a“statute’srace‐basedmeasures‘areconstitutionalonlyiftheyarenarrowlytailoredtofurthercompellinggovernmentalinterests.’”Id.at*12,quotingGrutterv.Bollinger,539U.S.306,326(2003).
TheCourtnotesthattheDBEProgramalsocontainsagenderconsciousprovision,aclassificationtheCourtsaysthatwouldbesubjecttointermediatescrutiny.Id.at*12,atn.4.BecauseraceisalsousedbytheFederalDBEProgram,however,theProgrammustultimatelymeetstrictscrutiny,andtheCourtthereforeanalyzestheentireProgramforitscompliancewithstrictscrutiny.Id.
B. Facial challenge based on overconcentration.TheCourtsaysthatinordertoprevailonafacialchallenge,theplaintiffmustestablishthatnosetofcircumstancesexistunderwhichtheFederalDBEProgramwouldbevalid.Id.at*12.TheCourtstatesthatplaintiffsbeartheultimateburdentoprovethattheDBEProgramisunconstitutional.Idat*.
1. Compelling governmental interest.TheCourtpointsoutthattheEighthCircuitCourtofAppealshasalreadyheldthefederalgovernmenthasacompellinginterestinnotperpetuatingtheeffectsofracialdiscriminationinitsowndistributionoffederalfundsandinremediatingtheeffectsofpastdiscriminationinthegovernmentcontractingmarketscreatedbyitsdisbursements.Id.*13,quotingAdarandConstructors,Inc.v.Slater,228F.3d1147,1165(10thCir.2000).Theplaintiffsdidnotdisputethatremedyingdiscriminationinfederaltransportationcontractingisacompellinggovernmentalinterest.Id.at*13.Inaccessingtheevidenceofferedin
![Page 333: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/333.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 207
supportofafindingofdiscrimination,theCourtconcludedthatdefendantshavearticulatedacompellinginterestunderlyingenactmentoftheDBEProgram.Id.
Second,theCourtstatesthatthegovernmentmustdemonstrateastrongbasisintheevidencesupportingitsconclusionthatrace‐basedremedialactionwasnecessarytofurtherthecompellinginterest.Id.at*13.Inassessingtheevidenceofferedinsupportofafindingofdiscrimination,theCourtconsidersbothdirectandcircumstantialevidence,includingpost‐enactmentevidenceintroducedbydefendantsaswellastheevidenceinthelegislativehistoryitself.Id.ThepartychallengingtheconstitutionalityoftheDBEProgrambearstheburdenofdemonstratingthatthegovernment’sevidencedidnotsupportaninferenceofpriordiscrimination.Id.
Congressional evidence of discrimination: disparity studies and barriers.PlaintiffsarguedthattheevidencerelieduponbyCongressinreauthorizingtheDBEProgramisinsufficientandgenerallycritiquethereports,studies,andevidencefromtheCongressionalrecordproducedbytheFederalDefendants.Id.at*13.But,theCourtfoundthatplaintiffsdidnotraiseanyspecificissueswithrespecttotheFederalDefendants’profferedevidenceofdiscrimination.Id.*14.PlaintiffshadarguedthatnopartycouldeveraffordtoretainanexperttoanalyzethenumerousstudiessubmittedasevidencebytheFederalDefendantsandfindalloftheflaws.Id.*14.FederalDefendantshadproffereddisparitystudiesfromthroughouttheUnitedStatesoveraperiodofyearsinsupportoftheFederalDBEProgram.Id.at*14.Basedonthesestudies,theFederalDefendants’consultantconcludedthatminoritiesandwomenformedbusinessesatdisproportionatelylowerratesandtheirbusinessesearnstatisticallylessthanbusinessesownedbymenornon‐minorities.Id.at*6.
TheFederalDefendants’consultantalsodescribedstudiessupportingtheconclusionthatthereiscreditdiscriminationagainstminority‐andwomen‐ownedbusinesses,concludedthatthereisaconsistentandstatisticallysignificantunderutilizationofminority‐andwomen‐ownedbusinessesinpubliccontracting,andspecificallyfoundthatdiscriminationexistedinMnDOTcontractingwhennorace‐consciouseffortswereutilized.Id.*6.TheCourtnotesthatCongresshadconsideredaplethoraofevidencedocumentingthecontinuedpresenceofdiscriminationintransportationprojectsutilizingFederaldollars.Id.at*5.
TheCourtconcludedthatneitheroftheplaintiffs’contentionsestablishedthatCongresslackedasubstantialbasisintheevidencetosupportitsconclusionthatrace‐basedremedialactionwasnecessarytoaddressdiscriminationinpublicconstructioncontracting.Id.at*14.TheCourtrejectedplaintiffs’argumentthatbecauseCongressfoundmultipleformsofdiscriminationagainstminority‐andwomen‐ownedbusiness,thatevidenceshowedCongressfailedtoalsofindthatsuchbusinessesspecificallyfacediscriminationinpubliccontracting,orthatsuchdiscriminationisnotrelevanttotheeffectthatdiscriminationhasonpubliccontracting.Id.
TheCourtreferencedthedecisioninAdarandConstructors,Inc.228F.3dat1175‐1176.InAdarand,theCourtfoundevidencerelevanttoCongressionalenactmentoftheDBEProgramtoincludethatbothrace‐basedbarrierstoentryandtheongoingrace‐basedimpedimentstosuccessfacedbyminoritysubcontractingenterprisesarecausedeitherbycontinuingdiscriminationorthelingeringeffectsofpastdiscriminationontherelevantmarket.Id.at*14.
![Page 334: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/334.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 208
TheCourt,citingagainwithapprovalthedecisioninAdarandConstructors,Inc.,foundtheevidencepresentedbythefederalgovernmentdemonstratestheexistenceoftwokindsofdiscriminatorybarrierstominoritysubcontractingenterprises,bothofwhichshowastronglinkbetweenracialdisparitiesinthefederalgovernment’sdisbursementsofpublicfundsforconstructioncontractsandthechannelingofthosefundsduetoprivatediscrimination.Id.at*14,quoting,AdarandConstructors,Inc.228F.3dat1167‐68.Thefirstdiscriminatorybarriersaretotheformationofqualifiedminoritysubcontractingenterprisesduetoprivatediscrimination.Id.Theseconddiscriminatorybarriersaretofaircompetitionbetweenminorityandnon‐minoritysubcontractingenterprises,againduetoprivatediscrimination.Id.Bothkindsofdiscriminatorybarriersprecludeexistingminorityfirmsfromeffectivelycompetingforpublicconstructioncontracts.Id.
Accordingly,theCourtfoundthatCongress’considerationofdiscriminatorybarrierstoentryforDBEsaswellasdiscriminationinexistingpubliccontractingestablishastrongbasisintheevidenceforreauthorizationoftheFederalDBEProgram.Id.at*14.
Court rejects Plaintiffs’ general critique of evidence as failing to meet their burden of proof.
TheCourtheldthatplaintiffs’generalcritiqueofthemethodologyofthestudiesrelieduponbytheFederalDefendantsissimilarlyinsufficienttodemonstratethatCongresslackedasubstantialbasisintheevidence.Id.at*14.TheCourtstatedthattheEighthCircuitCourtofAppealshasalreadyrejectedplaintiffs’argumentthatCongresswasrequiredtofindspecificevidenceofdiscriminationinMinnesotainordertoenactthenationalProgram.Id.at*14.
Finally,theCourtpointedoutthatplaintiffshavefailedtopresentaffirmativeevidencethatnoremedialactionwasnecessarybecauseminority‐ownedsmallbusinessesenjoynon‐discriminatoryaccesstoandparticipationinhighwaycontracts.Id.at*15.Thus,theCourtconcludedthatplaintiffsfailedtomeettheirultimateburdentoprovethattheFederalDBEProgramisunconstitutionalonthisground.Id.at*15,quotingSherbrookeTurf,Inc.,345F.3dat971–73.
Therefore,theCourtheldthatplaintiffsdidnotmeettheirburdenofraisingagenuineissueofmaterialfactastowhetherthegovernmentmetitsevidentiaryburdeninreauthorizingtheDBEFederalProgram,andgrantedsummaryjudgmentinfavoroftheFederalDefendantswithrespecttothegovernment’scompellinginterest.Id.at*15.
2. Narrowly tailored.TheCourtstatesthatseveralfactorsareexaminedindeterminingwhetherrace‐consciousremediesarenarrowlytailored,andthatnumerousFederalCourtshavealreadyconcludedthattheDBEFederalProgramisnarrowlytailored.Id.at*15.PlaintiffsinthiscasedidnotdisputethevariousaspectsoftheFederalDBEProgramthatcourtshavepreviouslyfoundtodemonstratenarrowlytailoring.Id.Instead,plaintiffsargueonlythattheFederalDBEProgramisnotnarrowlytailoredonitsfacebecauseofoverconcentration.
Overconcentration.Plaintiffsarguedthatiftherecipientsoffederalfundsuseoverallindustryparticipationofminoritiestosetgoals,yetlimitactualDBEparticipationtoonlydefinedsmallbusinessesthatarelimitedintheworktheycanperform,thereisnowaytoavoidoverconcentrationofDBEparticipationinafew,limitedareasofMnDOTwork.Id.at*15.Plaintiffsassertedthatsmallbusinessescannotperformmostofthetypesofworkneededor
![Page 335: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/335.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 209
necessaryforlargehighwayprojects,andiftheyhadthecapitaltodoit,theywouldnotbesmallbusinesses.Id.at*16.Therefore,plaintiffsarguedtheDBEProgramwillalwaysbeoverconcentrated.Id.
TheCourtstatesthatinorderforplaintiffstoprevailonthisfacialchallenge,plaintiffsmustestablishthattheoverconcentrationitidentifiesisunconstitutional,andthattherearenocircumstancesunderwhichtheFederalDBEProgramcouldbeoperatedwithoutoverconcentration.Id.TheCourtconcludesthatplaintiffs’claimfailsonthebasisthattherearecircumstancesunderwhichtheFederalDBEProgramcouldbeoperatedwithoutoverconcentration.Id.
First,theCourtfoundthatplaintiffsfailtoestablishthattheDBEProgramgoalswillalwaysbefulfilledinamannerthatcreatesoverconcentration,becausetheymisapprehendthenatureofthegoalsettingmandatedbytheDBEProgram.Id.at*16.TheCourtstatesthatrecipientssetgoalsforDBEparticipationbasedonevidenceoftheavailabilityofready,willingandableDBEstoparticipateonDOT‐assistedcontracts.Id.TheDBEProgram,accordingtotheCourt,necessarilytakesintoaccount,whendetermininggoals,thattherearecertaintypesofworkthatDBEsmayneverbeabletoperformbecauseofthecapitalrequirements.Id.Inotherwords,ifthereisatypeofworkthatnoDBEcanperform,therewillbenodemonstrableevidenceoftheavailabilityofready,willingandableDBEsinthattypeofwork,andthosenon‐existentDBEswillnotbefactoredintothelevelofDBEparticipationthatalocalitywouldexpectabsenttheeffectsofdiscrimination.Id.
Second,theCourtfoundthateveniftheDBEProgramcouldhavetheincidentaleffectofoverconcentrationinparticularareas,theDBEProgramfaciallyprovidesamplemechanismsforarecipientoffederalfundstoaddresssuchaproblem.Id.at*16.TheCourtnotesthatarecipientretainssubstantialflexibilityinsettingindividualcontractgoalsandspecificallymayconsiderthetypeofworkinvolved,thelocationofthework,andtheavailabilityofDBEsfortheworkoftheparticularcontract.Id.Ifoverconcentrationpresentsitselfasaproblem,theCourtpointsoutthatarecipientcanaltercontractgoalstofocuslessoncontractsthatrequireworkinanalreadyoverconcentratedareaandinsteadinvolveothertypesofworkwhereoverconcentrationofDBEsisnotpresent.Id.
ThefederalregulationsalsorequirecontractorstoengageingoodfaitheffortsthatrequirebreakingoutthecontractworkitemsintoeconomicallyfeasibleunitstofacilitateDBEparticipation.Id.Therefore,theCourtfound,theregulationsanticipatethepossibleissueidentifiedbyplaintiffsandrequireprimecontractorstosubdivideprojectsthatwouldotherwisetypicallyrequiremorecapitalorequipmentthanasingleDBEcanacquire.Id.Also,theCourt,statesthatrecipientsmayobtainwaiversoftheDBEProgram’sprovisionspertainingtooverallgoals,contractgoals,orgoodfaithefforts,if,forexample,localconditionsofoverconcentrationthreatenoperationoftheDBEProgram.Id.
TheCourtalsorejectsplaintiffsclaimthat49CFR§26.45(h),whichprovidesthatrecipientsarenotallowedtosubdividetheirannualgoalsinto“group‐specificgoals”,butrathermustprovideforparticipationbyallcertifiedDBEs,asevidencethattheDBEProgramleadstooverconcentration.Id.at*16.TheCourtnotesthatothercourtshaveinterpretedthisprovisiontomeanthatrecipientscannotapportionitsDBEgoalamongdifferentminoritygroups,and
![Page 336: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/336.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 210
thereforetheprovisiondoesnotappeartoprohibitrecipientsfromidentifyingparticularoverconcentratedareasandremedyingoverconcentrationinthoseareas.Id.at*16.And,eveniftheprovisionoperatedasplaintiffssuggested,thatprovisionissubjecttowaiveranddoesnotaffectarecipient’sabilitytotailorspecificcontractgoalstocombatoverconcentration.Id.at*16,n.5.
TheCourtstateswithrespecttooverconcentrationspecifically,thefederalregulationsprovidethatrecipientsmayuseincentives,technicalassistance,businessdevelopmentprograms,mentor‐protégéprograms,andotherappropriatemeasuresdesignedtoassistDBEsinperformingworkoutsideofthespecificfieldinwhichtherecipienthasdeterminedthatnon‐DBEsareundulyburdened.Id.at*17.AllofthesemeasurescouldbeusedbyrecipientstoshiftDBEsfromareasinwhichtheyareoverconcentratedtootherareasofwork.Id.at*17.
Therefore,theCourtheldthatbecausetheDBEProgramprovidesnumerousavenuesforrecipientsoffederalfundstocombatoverconcentration,theCourtconcludedthatplaintiffs’facialchallengetotheProgramfails,andgrantedtheFederalDefendants’motionforsummaryjudgment.Id.
C. Facial challenged based on vagueness.TheCourtheldthatplaintiffscouldnotmaintainafacialchallengeagainsttheFederalDBEProgramforvagueness,astheirconstitutionalchallengestotheProgramarenotbasedintheFirstAmendment.Id.at*17.TheCourtstatesthattheEighthCircuitCourtofAppealshasheldthatcourtsneednotconsiderfacialvaguenesschallengesbaseduponconstitutionalgroundsotherthantheFirstAmendment.Id.
TheCourtthusgrantedFederalDefendants’motionforsummaryjudgmentwithrespecttoplaintiffs’facialclaimforvaguenessbasedontheallegationthattheFederalDBEProgramdoesnotdefine“reasonable”forpurposesofwhenaprimecontractorisentitledtorejectaDBEs’bidonthebasisofpricealone.Id.
D. As‐Applied Challenges to MnDOT’s DBE Program: MnDOT’s program held narrowly tailored.Plaintiffsbroughtthreeas‐appliedchallengesagainstMnDOT’simplementationoftheFederalDBEProgram,allegingthatMnDOThasfailedtosupportitsimplementationoftheProgramwithevidenceofdiscriminationinitscontracting,setsinappropriategoalsforDBEparticipation,andhasfailedtorespondtooverconcentrationinthetrafficcontrolindustry.Id.at*17.
1. Alleged failure to find evidence of discrimination. TheCourtheldthatastate’simplementationoftheFederalDBEProgrammustbenarrowlytailored.Id.at*18.ToshowthatastatehasviolatedthenarrowtailoringrequirementoftheFederalDBEProgram,theCourtsaysachallengermustdemonstratethat“betterdatawasavailable”andtherecipientoffederalfunds“wasotherwiseunreasonableinundertaking[its]thoroughanalysisandinrelyingonitsresults.”Id.,quotingSherbrookTurf,Inc.at973.
Plaintiffs’expertcritiquedthestatisticalmethodsusedandconclusionsdrawnbytheconsultantforMnDOTinfindingthatdiscriminationagainstDBEsexistsinMnDOTcontractingsufficienttosupportoperationoftheDBEProgram.Id.at*18.Plaintiffs’expertalsocritiquedthemeasuresofDBEavailabilityemployedbytheMnDOTconsultantandthefacthemeasureddiscriminationinbothprimeandsubcontractingmarkets,insteadofsolelyinsubcontractingmarkets.Id.
![Page 337: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/337.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 211
Plaintiffs present no affirmative evidence that discrimination does not exist.TheCourtheldthatplaintiffs’disputeswithMnDOT’sconclusionthatdiscriminationexistsinpubliccontractingareinsufficienttoestablishthatMnDOT’simplementationoftheFederalDBEProgramisnotnarrowlytailored.Id.at*18.First,theCourtfoundthatitisinsufficienttoshowthat“datawassusceptibletomultipleinterpretations,”instead,plaintiffsmust“presentaffirmativeevidencethatnoremedialactionwasnecessarybecauseminority‐ownedsmallbusinessesenjoynon‐discriminatoryaccesstoandparticipationinhighwaycontracts.”Id.at*18,quotingSherbrookeTurf,Inc.,345F.3dat970.Here,theCourtfound,plaintiffs’experthasnotpresentedaffirmativeevidenceuponwhichtheCourtcouldconcludethatnodiscriminationexistsinMinnesota’spubliccontracting.Id.at*18.
Asforthemeasuresofavailabilityandmeasurementofdiscriminationinbothprimeandsubcontractingmarkets,bothofthesepracticesareincludedinthefederalregulationsaspartofthemechanismsforgoalsetting.Id.at*18.TheCourtfoundthatitwouldmakelittlesensetoseparateprimecontractorandsubcontractoravailability,whenDBEswillalsocompeteforprimecontractsandanysuccesswillbereflectedintherecipient’scalculationofsuccessinmeetingtheoverallgoal.Id.at*18,quotingNorthernContracting,Inc.v.Illinois,473F.3d715,723(7thCir.2007).BecausethesefactorsarepartofthefederalregulationsdefiningstategoalsettingthattheEighthCircuitCourtofAppealshasalreadyapprovedinassessingMnDOT’scompliancewithnarrowtailoringinSherbrookeTurf,theCourtconcludedthesecriticismsdonotestablishthatMnDOThasviolatedthenarrowtailoringrequirement.Id.at*18.
Inaddition,theCourtheldthesecriticismsfailtoestablishthatMnDOTwasunreasonableinundertakingitsthoroughanalysisandrelyingonitsresults,andconsequentlydonotshowlackofnarrowtailoring.Id.at*18.Accordingly,theCourtgrantedtheStatedefendants’motionforsummaryjudgmentwithrespecttothisclaim.
2. Alleged inappropriate goal setting.PlaintiffssecondchallengewastotheaspirationalgoalsMnDOThassetforDBEperformancebetween2009and2015.Id.at*19.TheCourtfoundthatthegoalsettingviolationstheplaintiffsallegedarenotthetypesofviolationsthatcouldreasonablybeexpectedtorecur.Id.PlaintiffsraisednumerousargumentsregardingthedataandmethodologyusedbyMnDOTinsettingitsearliergoals.Id.But,plaintiffsdidnotdisputethateverythreeyearsMnDOTconductsanentirelynewanalysisofdiscriminationintherelevantmarketandestablishesnewgoals.Id.Therefore,disputesoverthedatacollectionandcalculationsusedtosupportgoalsthatarenolongerineffectaremoot.Id.Thus,theCourtonlyconsideredplaintiffs’challengestothe2013–2015goals.Id.
Plaintiffsraisedthesamechallengestothe2013–2015goalsasitdidtoMnDOT’sfindingofdiscrimination,namelythatthegoalsrelyonmultipleapproachestoascertaintheavailabilityofDBEsandrelyonameasurementofdiscriminationthataccountsforbothprimeandsubcontractingmarkets.Id.at*19.BecausethesechallengesidentifyonlyadifferentinterpretationofthedataanddonotestablishthatMnDOTwasunreasonableinrelyingontheoutcomeoftheconsultants’studies,plaintiffshavefailedtodemonstrateamaterialissueoffactrelatedtoMnDOT’snarrowtailoringasitrelatestogoalsetting.Id.
3. Alleged overconcentration in the traffic control market. Plaintiffs’finalargumentwasthatMnDOT’simplementationoftheDBEProgramviolatestheEqualProtectionClausebecause
![Page 338: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/338.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 212
MnDOThasfailedtofindoverconcentrationinthetrafficcontrolmarketandcorrectforsuchoverconcentration.Id.at*20.MnDOTpresentedanexpertreportthatreviewedfourdifferentindustriesintowhichplaintiffs’workfallsbasedonNAICscodesthatfirmsconductingtrafficcontrol‐typeworkidentifythemselvesby.Id.Afterconductingadisproportionalitycomparison,theconsultantconcludedthattherewasnotstatisticallysignificantoverconcentrationofDBEsinplaintiffs’typeofwork.
Plaintiffs’expertfoundthatthereisoverconcentration,butrelieduponsixothercontractorsthathavepreviouslybidonMnDOTcontracts,whichplaintiffsbelieveperformthesametypeofworkasplaintiff.Id.at*20.But,theCourtfoundplaintiffshaveprovidednoauthorityforthepropositionthatthegovernmentmustconformitsimplementationoftheDBEProgramtoeveryindividualbusiness’self‐assessmentofwhatindustrygrouptheyfallintoandwhatotherbusinessesaresimilar.Id.
TheCourtheldthattorequiretheStatetorespondtoandadjustitscalculationsonaccountofsuchachallengebyasinglebusinesswouldplaceanimpossibleburdenonthegovernmentbecauseanindividualbusinesscouldalwaysmakeanargumentthatsomeoftheotherentitiesintheworkareathegovernmenthasgroupeditintoarenotalike.Id.at*20.This,theCourtstates,wouldrequirethegovernmenttorunendlessiterationsofoverconcentrationanalysestosatisfyeachbusinessthatnon‐DBEsarenotbeingundulyburdenedinitsself‐definedgroup,whichwouldbequiteburdensome.Id.
BecauseplaintiffsdidnotshowthatMnDOT’srelianceonitsoverconcentrationanalysisusingNAICscodeswasunreasonableorthatoverconcentrationexistsinitstypeofworkasdefinedbyMnDOT,ithasnotestablishedthatMnDOThasviolatednarrowtailoringbyfailingtoidentifyoverconcentrationorfailingtoaddressit.Id.at*20.Therefore,theCourtgrantedtheStatedefendants’motionforsummaryjudgmentwithrespecttothisclaim.
III. Claims Under 42 U.S.C. § 1981 and 42 U.S.C. § 2000.BecausetheCourtconcludedthatMnDOT’sactionsareincompliancewiththeFederalDBEProgram,itsadherencetothatProgramcannotconstituteabasisforaviolationof§1981.Id.at*21.Inaddition,becausetheCourtconcludedthatplaintiffsfailedtoestablishaviolationoftheEqualProtectionClause,itgrantedthedefendants’motionsforsummaryjudgmentonthe42U.S.C.§2000dclaim.
Holding.Therefore,theCourtgrantedtheFederalDefendants’motionforsummaryjudgmentandtheStates’defendants’motiontodismiss/motionforsummaryjudgment,anddismissedalltheclaimsassertedbytheplaintiffs.
11. Dunnet Bay Construction Company v. Gary Hannig, in its official capacity as Secretary of Transportation for the Illinois DOT and the Illinois DOT, 2014 WL 552213 (C.D. Ill. 2014), affirmed, Dunnet Bay Construction Co. v. Borggren, Illinois DOT, et al., 799 F.3d 676, 2015 WL 4934560 (7th Cir. 2015).
InDunnetBayConstructionCompanyv.GaryHannig,initsofficialcapacityasSecretaryoftheIllinoisDOTandtheIllinoisDOT,2014WL552213(C.D.Ill.Feb.12,2014),plaintiffDunnetBayConstructionCompanybroughtalawsuitagainsttheIllinoisDepartmentofTransportation(IDOT)andtheSecretaryofIDOTinhisofficialcapacitychallengingtheIDOTDBEProgramand
![Page 339: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/339.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 213
itsimplementationoftheFederalDBEProgram,includinganallegedunwritten“nowaiver”policy,andclaimingthattheIDOT’sprogramisnotnarrowlytailored.
Motion to Dismiss certain claims granted.IDOTinitiallyfiledaMotiontoDismisscertainCountsoftheComplaint.TheUnitedStatesDistrictCourtgrantedtheMotiontoDismissCountsI,IIandIIIagainstIDOTprimarilybasedonthedefenseofimmunityundertheEleventhAmendmenttotheUnitedStatesConstitution.TheOpinionheldthatclaimsinCountsIandIIagainstSecretaryHannigofIDOTinhisofficialcapacityremainedinthecase.
Inaddition,theotherCountsoftheComplaintthatremainedinthecasenotsubjecttotheMotiontoDismiss,soughtdeclaratoryandinjunctivereliefanddamagesbasedonthechallengetotheIDOTDBEProgramanditsapplicationbyIDOT.PlaintiffDunnetBayallegedtheIDOTDBEProgramisunconstitutionalbasedontheunwrittenno‐waiverpolicy,requiringDunnetBaytomeetDBEgoalsanddenyingDunnetBayawaiverofthegoalsdespiteitsgoodfaithefforts,andbasedonotherallegations.DunnetBaysoughtadeclaratoryjudgmentthatIDOT’sDBEprogramdiscriminatesonthebasisofraceintheawardoffederal‐aidhighwayconstructioncontractsinIllinois.
Motions for Summary Judgment.SubsequenttotheCourt’sOrdergrantingthepartialMotiontoDismiss,DunnetBayfiledaMotionforSummaryJudgment,assertingthatIDOThaddepartedfromthefederalregulationsimplementingtheFederalDBEProgram,thatIDOT’simplementationoftheFederalDBEProgramwasnotnarrowlytailoredtofurtheracompellinggovernmentalinterest,andthattherefore,theactionsofIDOTcouldnotwithstandstrictscrutiny.2014WL552213at*1.IDOTalsofiledaMotionforSummaryJudgment,allegingthatallapplicableguidelinesfromthefederalregulationswerefollowedwithrespecttotheIDOTDBEProgram,andbecauseIDOTisfederallymandatedanddidnotabuseitsfederalauthority,IDOT’sDBEProgramisnotsubjecttoattack.Id.
IDOTfurtherassertedinitsMotionforSummaryJudgmentthatthereisnoEqualProtectionviolation,claimingthatneithertherejectionofthebidbyDunnetBay,northedecisiontore‐bidtheproject,wasbaseduponDunnetBay’srace.IDOTalsoassertedthat,becauseDunnetBaywasrelyingontherightsofothersandwasnotdeniedequalopportunitytocompeteforgovernmentcontracts,DunnetBaylackedstandingtobringaclaimforracialdiscrimination.
Factual background.PlaintiffDunnetBayConstructionCompanyisownedbytwowhitemalesandisengagedinthebusinessofgeneralhighwayconstruction.IthasbeenqualifiedtoworkonIDOThighwayconstructionprojects.Inaccordancewiththefederalregulations,IDOTpreparedandsubmittedtotheUSDOTforapprovalaDBEProgramgoverningfederallyfundedhighwayconstructioncontracts.Forfiscalyear2010,IDOTestablishedanoverallaspirationalDBEgoalof22.77percentforDBEparticipation,anditprojectedthat4.12percentoftheoverallgoalcouldbemetthroughraceneutralmeasuresandtheremaining18.65percentwouldrequiretheuseofrace‐consciousgoals.2014WL552213at*3.IDOTnormallyachievedsomewherebetween10and14percentparticipationbyDBEs.Id.TheoverallaspirationalgoalwasbaseduponastatewidedisparitystudyconductedonbehalfofIDOTin2004.
UtilizationgoalsundertheIDOTDBEProgramDocumentaredeterminedbaseduponanassessmentforthetypeofwork,locationofthework,andtheavailabilityofDBEcompaniesto
![Page 340: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/340.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 214
doapartofthework.Id.at*4.Eachpayitemforaproposedcontractisanalyzedtodetermineifthereareatleasttwoready,willing,andableDBEstoperformthepayitem.Id.ThecapacityoftheDBEs,theirwillingnesstoperformtheworkintheparticulardistrict,andtheirpossessionofthenecessaryworkforceandequipmentarealsofactorsintheoveralldetermination.Id.
Initially,IDOTcalculatedtheDBEgoalfortheEisenhowerProjecttobe8percent.WhengoalswerefirstsetontheEisenhowerProject,takingintoaccounteveryitemlistedforwork,themaximumpotentialgoalforDBEparticipationfortheEisenhowerProjectwas20.3percent.Eventually,anoverallgoalofapproximately22percentwasset.Id.at*4.
Atthebidopening,DunnetBay’sbidwasthelowestreceivedbyIDOT.ItslowbidwasoverIDOT’sestimatefortheproject.DunnetBay,initsbid,identified8.2percentofitsbidforDBEs.ThesecondlowbidderprojectedDBEparticipationof22percent.DunnetBay’sDBEparticipationbiddidnotmeetthepercentageparticipationinthebiddocuments,andthusIDOTconsideredDunnetBay’sgoodfaitheffortstomeettheDBEgoal.IDOTrejectedDunnetBay’sbiddeterminingthatDunnetBayhadnotdemonstratedagoodfaithefforttomeettheDBEgoal.Id.at*9.
TheCourtfoundthatalthoughitwasthelowbidderfortheconstructionproject,DunnetBaydidnotmeetthegoalforparticipationofDBEsdespiteitsallegedgoodfaithefforts.IDOTcontendeditfollowedallapplicableguidelinesinhandlingtheDBEProgram,andthatbecauseitdidnotabuseitsfederalauthorityinadministeringtheProgram,theIDOTDBEProgramisnotsubjecttoattack.Id.at*23.IDOTfurtherassertedthatneitherrejectionofDunnetBay’sbidnorthedecisiontore‐bidtheProjectwasbasedonitsraceorthatofitsowners,andthatDunnetBaylackedstandingtobringaclaimforracialdiscriminationonbehalfofothers(i.e.,smallbusinessesoperatedbywhitemales).Id.at*23.
TheCourtfoundthatthefederalregulationsrecommendanumberofnon‐mandatory,non‐exclusiveandnon‐exhaustiveactionswhenconsideringabidder’sgoodfaitheffortstoobtainDBEparticipation.Id.at*25.ThefederalregulationsalsoprovidethestateDOTmayconsidertheabilityofotherbidderstomeetthegoal.Id.
IDOT implementing the Federal DBE Program is acting as an agent of the federal government
insulated from constitutional attack absent showing the state exceeded federal authority.TheCourtheldthatastateentitysuchasIDOTimplementingacongressionallymandatedprogrammayrely“onthefederalgovernment’scompellinginterestinremedyingtheeffectsofpassdiscriminationinthenationalconstructionmarket.”Id.at*26,quotingNorthernContractingCo.,Inc.v.Illinois,473F.3d715at720‐21(7thCir.2007).Intheseinstances,theCourtstated,thestateisactingasanagentofthefederalgovernmentandis“insulatedfromthissortofconstitutionalattack,absentashowingthatthestateexceededitsfederalauthority.”Id.at*26,quotingNorthernContracting,Inc.,473F.3dat721.TheCourtheldthataccordingly,any“challengetoastate’sapplicationofafederallymandatedprogrammustbelimitedtothequestionofwhetherthestateexceededitsauthority.”Id.at*26,quotingNorthernContracting,Inc.,473.F.3dat722.Therefore,theCourtidentifiedthekeyissueasdeterminingifIDOTexceededitsauthoritygrantedunderthefederalrulesorifDunnetBay’schallengesareforeclosedbyNorthernContracting.Id.at*26.
![Page 341: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/341.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 215
TheCourtfoundthatIDOTdidinfactemployathoroughprocessbeforearrivingatthe22percentDBEparticipationgoalfortheEisenhowerProject.Id.at*26.TheCourtalsoconcluded“becausethefederalregulationsdonotspecifyaprocedureforarrivingatcontractgoals,itisnotapparenthowIDOTcouldhaveexceededitsfederalauthority.AnychallengeonthisfactorfailsunderNorthernContracting.”Id.at*26.Therefore,theCourtconcludedthereisnobasisforfindingthattheDBEgoalwasarbitrarilysetorthatIDOTexceededitsfederalauthoritywithrespecttothisfactor.Id.at*27.
The “no‐waiver” policy.TheCourtheldthattherewasnotano‐waiverpolicyconsideringallthetestimonyandfactualevidence.Inparticular,theCourtpointedoutthatawaiverwasinfactgrantedinconnectionwiththesamebidlettingatissueinthiscase.Idat*27.TheCourtfoundthatIDOTgrantedawaiveroftheDBEparticipationgoalforanotherconstructioncontractoronadifferentcontract,butunderthesamebidlettinginvolvedinthismatter.Id.
Thus,theCourtheldthatDunnetBay’sassertionthatIDOTadopteda“no‐waiver”policywasunsupportedandcontrarytotherecordevidence.Id.at*27.TheCourtfoundtheundisputedfactsestablishedthatIDOTdidnothavea“no‐waiver”policy,andthatIDOTdidnotexceeditsfederalauthoritybecauseitdidnotadopta“no‐waiver”policy.Id.Therefore,theCourtagainconcludedthatanychallengebyDunnetBayonthisfactorfailedpursuanttotheNorthernContractingdecision.
IDOT’s decision to reject Dunnet Bay’s bid based on lack of good faith efforts did not exceed
IDOT’s authority under federal law.TheCourtfoundthatIDOThassignificantdiscretionunderfederalregulationsandisoftencalledupontomakea“judgmentcall”regardingtheeffortsofthebidderintermsofestablishinggoodfaithattempttomeettheDBEgoals.Id.at*28.TheCourtstateditwasunabletoconcludethatIDOTerredindeterminingDunnetBaydidnotmakeadequategoodfaithefforts.Id.TheCourtsurmisedthatthestrongestevidencethatDunnetBaydidnottakeallnecessaryandreasonablestepstoachievetheDBEgoalisthatitsDBEparticipationwasunder9percentwhileotherbidderswereabletoreachthe22percentgoal.Id.Accordingly,theCourtconcludedthatIDOT’sdecisionrejectingDunnetBay’sbidwasconsistentwiththeregulationsanddidnotexceedIDOT’sauthorityunderthefederalregulations.Id.
TheCourtalsorejectedDunnetBay’sargumentthatIDOTfailedtoprovideDunnetBaywithawrittenexplanationastowhyitsgoodfaitheffortswerenotsufficient,andthusthereweredeficiencieswiththereconsiderationofDunnetBay’sbidandeffortsasrequiredbythefederalregulations.Id.at*29.TheCourtfounditwasunabletoconcludethatatechnicalviolationsuchastoprovideDunnetBaywithawrittenexplanationwillprovideanyrelieftoDunnetBay.Id.Additionally,theCourtfoundthatbecauseIDOTrebidtheproject,DunnetBaywasnotprejudicedbyanydeficiencieswiththereconsideration.Id.
TheCourtemphasizedthatbecauseofthedecisiontorebidtheproject,IDOTwasnotevenrequiredtoholdareconsiderationhearing.Id.at*24.BecausethedecisiononreconsiderationastogoodfaitheffortsdidnotexceedIDOT’sauthorityunderfederallaw,theCourtheldDunnetBay’sclaimfailedundertheNorthernContractingdecision.Id.
Dunnet Bay lacked standing to raise an equal protection claim.TheCourtfoundthatDunnetBaywasnotdisadvantagedinitsabilitytocompeteagainstaraciallyfavoredbusiness,and
![Page 342: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/342.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 216
neitherIDOT’srejectionofDunnetBay’sbidnorthedecisiontorebidwasbasedontheraceofDunnetBay’sownersoranyclass‐basedanimus.Idat*29.TheCourtstatedthatDunnetBaydidnotpointtoanyotherbusinessthatwasgivenacompetitiveadvantagebecauseoftheDBEgoals.Id.DunnetBaydidnotciteanycaseswhichinvolveplaintiffsthataresimilarlysituatedtoit‐businessesthatarenotatacompetitivedisadvantageagainstminority‐ownedcompaniesorDBEs‐andhavebeendeterminedtohavestanding.Id.at*30.
TheCourtconcludedthatanycompanysimilarlysituatedtoDunnetBayhadtomeetthesameDBEgoalunderthecontract.Id.DunnetBay,theCourtheld,wasnotatacompetitivedisadvantageand/orunabletocompeteequallywiththosegivenpreferentialtreatment.Id.
DunnetBaydidnotpointtoanothercontractorthatdidnothavetomeetthesamerequirementsitdid.TheCourtthusconcludedthatDunnetBaylackedstandingtoraiseanequalprotectionchallengebecauseithadnotsufferedaparticularizedinjurythatwascausedbyIDOT.Id.at*30.DunnetBaywasnotdeprivedoftheabilitytocompeteonanequalbasis.Id.Also,basedontheamountofitsprofits,DunnetBaydidnotqualifyasasmallbusiness,andtherefore,itlackedstandingtovindicatetherightsofahypotheticalwhite‐ownedsmallbusiness.Id.at*30.BecausetheCourtfoundthatDunnetBaywasnotdeniedtheabilitytocompeteonanequalfootinginbiddingonthecontract,DunnetBaylackedstandingtochallengetheDBEProgrambasedontheEqualProtectionClause.Id.at*30.
Dunnet Bay did not establish equal protection violation even if it had standing.TheCourtheldthatevenifDunnetBayhadstandingtobringanequalprotectionclaim,IDOTstillisentitledtosummaryjudgment.TheCourtstatedtheSupremeCourthasheldthatthe“injuryinfact”inanequalprotectioncasechallengingaDBEProgramisthedenialofequaltreatmentresultingfromtheimpositionofthebarrier,nottheultimateinabilitytoobtainthebenefit.Id.at*31.DunnetBay,theCourtsaid,impliedthatbutforthealleged“no‐waiver”policyandDBEgoalswhichwerenotnarrowlytailoredtoaddressdiscrimination,itwouldhavebeenawardedthecontract.TheCourtagainnotedtherecordestablishedthatIDOTdidnothavea“no‐waiver”policy.Id.at*31.
TheCourtalsofoundthatbecausethegravamenofequalprotectionliesnotinthefactofdeprivationofarightbutintheinvidiousclassificationofpersons,itdoesnotappearDunnetBaycanassertaviableclaim.Id.at*31.TheCourtstateditisunawareofanyauthoritywhichsuggeststhatDunnetBaycanestablishanequalprotectionviolationevenifitcouldshowthatIDOTfailedtocomplywiththeregulationsrelatingtotheDBEProgram.Id.TheCourtsaidthatevenifIDOTdidemploya“no‐waiverpolicy,”suchapolicywouldnotconstituteanequalprotectionviolationbecausethefederalregulationsdonotconferspecificentitlementsuponanyindividuals.Id.at*31.
Inordertosupportanequalprotectionclaim,theplaintiffwouldhavetoestablishitwastreatedlessfavorablythananotherentitywithwhichitwassimilarlysituatedinallmaterialrespects.Id.at*51.Basedontherecord,theCourtstateditcouldonlyspeculatewhetherDunnetBayoranotherentitywouldhavebeenawardedacontractwithoutIDOT’sDBEProgram.But,theCourtfounditneednotspeculateastowhetherDunnetBayoranothercompanywouldhavebeenawardedthecontract,becausewhatisimportantforequalprotectionanalysisisthatDunnetBaywastreatedthesameasotherbidders.Id.at*31.EverybidderhadtomeetthesamepercentagegoalforsubcontractingtoDBEsormakegoodfaithefforts.Id.BecauseDunnetBay
![Page 343: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/343.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 217
washeldtothesamestandardsaseveryotherbidder,itcannotestablishitwasthevictimofdiscriminationpursuanttotheEqualProtectionClause.Id.Therefore,IDOT,theCourtheld,isentitledtosummaryjudgmentonDunnetBay’sclaimsundertheEqualProtectionClauseandunderTitleVI.
Conclusion.TheCourtconcludedIDOTisentitledtosummaryjudgment,holdingDunnetBaylackedstandingtoraiseanequalprotectionchallengebasedonrace,andthatevenifDunnetBayhadstanding,DunnetBaywasunabletoshowthatitwouldhavebeenawardedthecontractintheabsenceofanyviolation.Id.at*32.Anyotherfederalclaims,theCourtheld,wereforeclosedbytheNorthernContractingdecisionbecausethereisnoevidenceIDOTexceededitsauthorityunderfederallaw.Id.Finally,theCourtfoundDunnetBayhadnotestablishedthelikelihoodoffutureharm,andthuswasnotentitledtoinjunctiverelief.
12. M.K. Weeden Construction v. State of Montana, Montana Department of Transportation, et al., 2013 WL 4774517 (D. Mont.) (September 4, 2013)
Thiscaseinvolvedachallengebyaprimecontractor,M.K.WeedenConstruction,Inc.(“Weeden”)againsttheStateofMontana,MontanaDepartmentofTransportationandothers,totheDBEProgramadoptedbyMDTimplementingtheFederalDBEProgramat49CFRPart26.WeedensoughtanapplicationforTemporaryRestrainingOrderandPreliminaryInjunctionagainsttheStateofMontanaandtheMDT.
Factual background and claims.Weedenwasthelowdollarbidderwithabidof$14,770,163.01ontheArrowCreekSlideProject.Theprojectreceivedfederalfunding,andassuch,wasrequiredtocomplywiththeUSDOT’sDBEProgram.2013WL4774517at*1.MDThadestablishedanoverallgoalof5.83percentDBEparticipationinMontana’shighwayconstructionprojects.OntheArrowCreekSlideProject,MDTestablishedaDBEgoalof2percent.Id.
PlaintiffWeeden,althoughitsubmittedthelowdollarbid,didnotmeetthe2percentDBErequirement.2013WL4774517at*1.Weedenclaimedthatitsbidreliedupononly1.87percentDBEsubcontractors(althoughthecourtpointsoutthatWeeden’sbidactuallyidentifiedonly.81percentDBEsubcontractors).Weedenwastheonlybidderoutofthesixbidderswhodidnotmeetthe2percentDBEgoal.Theotherfivebiddersexceededthe2percentgoal,withbidsrangingfrom2.19percentDBEparticipationto6.98percentDBEparticipation.Id.at*2.
WeedenattemptedtoutilizeagoodfaithexceptiontotheDBErequirementundertheFederalDBEProgramandMontana’sDBEProgram.MDT’sDBEParticipationReviewCommitteeconsideredWeeden’sgoodfaithdocumentationandfoundthatWeeden’sbidwasnon‐compliantastotheDBErequirement,andthatWeedenfailedtodemonstrategoodfaitheffortstosolicitDBEsubcontractorparticipationinthecontract.2013WL4774517at*2.WeedenappealedthatdecisiontotheMDTDBEReviewBoardandappearedbeforetheBoardatahearing.TheDBEReviewBoardaffirmedtheCommitteedecisionfindingthatWeeden’sbidwasnotincompliancewiththecontractDBEgoalandthatWeedenhadfailedtomakeagoodfaithefforttocomplywiththegoal.Id.at*2.TheDBEReviewBoardfoundthatWeedenhadreceivedaDBEbidfortrafficcontrol,butWeedendecidedtoperformthatworkitselfinordertoloweritsbidamount.Id.at*2.Additionally,theDBEReviewBoardfoundthatWeeden’smassemailto158DBE
![Page 344: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/344.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 218
subcontractorswithoutanyfollowupwasaproformaeffortnotcreditedbytheReviewBoardasanactiveandaggressiveefforttoobtainDBEparticipation.Id.
PlaintiffWeedensoughtaninjunctioninfederaldistrictcourtagainstMDTtopreventitfromlettingthecontracttoanotherbidder.WeedenclaimedthatMDT’sDBEProgramviolatedtheEqualProtectionClauseoftheU.S.ConstitutionandtheMontanaConstitution,assertingthattherewasnosupportingevidenceofdiscriminationintheMontanahighwayconstructionindustry,andtherefore,therewasnogovernmentinterestthatwouldjustifyfavoringDBEentities.2013WL4774517at*2.WeedenalsoclaimedthatitsrighttoDueProcessundertheU.S.ConstitutionandMontanaConstitutionhadbeenviolated.Specifically,WeedenclaimedthatMDTdidnotprovidereasonablenoticeofthegoodfaitheffortrequirements.Id.
No proof of irreparable harm and balance of equities favor MDT.First,theCourtfoundthatWeedendidnotproveforacertaintythatitwouldsufferirreparableharmbasedontheCourt’sconclusionthatinthepastfouryears,Weedenhadobtainedsixstatehighwayconstructioncontractsvaluedatapproximately$26million,andthatMDThad$50millionmoreinhighwayconstructionprojectstobeletduringtheremainderof2013alone.2013WL4774517at*3.Thus,theCourtconcludedthatasdemonstratedbyitspastperformance,WeedenhasthecapacitytoobtainotherhighwayconstructioncontractsandthusthereislittleriskofirreparableinjuryintheeventMDTawardstheProjecttoanotherbidder.Id.
Second,theCourtfoundthebalanceoftheequitiesdidnottipinWeeden’sfavor.2013WL4774517at*3.WeedenhadassertedthatMDTandUSDOTrulesregardinggoodfaitheffortstoobtainDBEsubcontractorparticipationareconfusing,non‐specificandcontradictory.Id.TheCourtheldthatitisobvioustheotherfivebidderswereabletomeetandexceedthe2percentDBErequirementwithoutanydifficultywhatsoever.Id.TheCourtfoundthatWeeden’sbidisnotresponsivetotherequirements,thereforeisnotandcannotbethelowestresponsiblebid.Id.Thebalanceoftheequities,accordingtotheCourt,donottiltinfavorofWeeden,whodidnotmeettherequirementsofthecontract,especiallywhennumerousotherbiddersablydemonstratedanabilitytomeetthoserequirements.Id.
No standing.TheCourtalsoquestionedwhetherWeedenraisedanyseriousissuesonthemeritsofitsequalprotectionclaimbecauseWeedenisaprimecontractorandnotasubcontractor.SinceWeedenisaprimecontractor,theCourthelditisclearthatWeedenlacksArticleIIIstandingtoassertitsequalprotectionclaim.Id.at*3.TheCourtheldthataprimecontractor,suchasWeeden,isnotpermittedtochallengeMDT’sDBEProjectasifitwereanon‐DBEsubcontractorbecauseWeedencannotshowthatitwassubjectedtoaracialorgender‐basedbarrierinitscompetitionfortheprimecontract.Id.at*3.BecauseWeedenwasnotdeprivedoftheabilitytocompeteonequalfootingwiththeotherbidders,theCourtfoundWeedensufferednoequalprotectioninjuryandlacksstandingtoassertanequalprotectionclaimasitwereanon‐DBEsubcontractor.Id.
Court applies AGC v. California DOT case; evidence supports narrowly tailored DBE program.Significantly,theCourtfoundthatevenifWeedenhadstandingtopresentanequalprotectionclaim,MDTpresentedsignificantevidenceofunderutilizationofDBE’sgenerally,evidencethatsupportsanarrowlytailoredraceandgenderpreferenceprogram.2013WL4774517at*4.Moreover,theCourtnotedthatalthoughWeedenpointsoutthatsomebusinesscategoriesin
![Page 345: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/345.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 219
Montana’shighwayconstructionindustrydonothaveahistoryofdiscrimination(namely,thecategoryofconstructionbusinessesincontrasttothecategoryofprofessionalbusinesses),theNinthCircuit“hasrecentlyrejectedasimilarargumentrequiringtheevidenceofdiscriminationineverysinglesegmentofthehighwayconstructionindustrybeforeapreferenceprogramcanbeimplemented.”Id.,citingAssociatedGeneralContractorsv.CaliforniaDept.ofTransportation,713F.3d1187(9thCir.2013)(holdingthatCaltrans’DBEprogramsurvivedstrictscrutiny,wasnarrowlytailored,didnotviolateequalprotection,andwassupportedbysubstantialstatisticalandanecdotalevidenceofdiscrimination).
TheCourtstatedthatparticularlyrelevantinthiscase,“theNinthCircuitheldthatCalifornia’sDBEprogramneednotisolateconstructionfromengineeringcontractsorprimefromsubcontractstodeterminewhethertheevidenceineachandeverycategorygivesrisetoaninferenceofdiscrimination.”Id.at4,citingAssociatedGeneralContractorsv.CaliforniaDOT,713F.3dat1197.Instead,accordingtotheCourt,California–and,byextension,Montana–“isentitledtolookattheevidence‘initsentirety’todeterminewhetherthereare‘substantialdisparitiesinutilizationofminorityfirms’practicedbysomeelementsoftheconstructionindustry.”2013WL4774517at*4,quotingAGCv.CaliforniaDOT,713F.3dat1197.TheCourt,alsoquotingthedecisioninAGCv.CaliforniaDOT,said:“ItisenoughthattheanecdotalevidencesupportsCaltrans’statisticaldatashowingapervasivepatternofdiscrimination.”Id.at*4,quotingAGCv.CaliforniaDOT,713F.3dat1197.
TheCourtpointedoutthatthereisnoallegationthatMDThasexceededanyfederalrequirementordoneotherthancompliedwithUSDOTregulations.2013WL4774517at*4.Therefore,theCourtconcludedthatgiventhesimilaritiesbetweenWeeden’sclaimandAGC’sequalprotectionclaimagainstCaliforniaDOTintheAGCv.CaliforniaDOTcase,itdoesnotappearlikelythatWeedenwillsucceedonthemeritsofitsequalprotectionclaim.Id.at*4.
Due Process claim.TheCourtalsorejectedWeeden’sbaldassertionthatithasaprotectedpropertyrightinthecontractthathasnotbeenawardedtoitwherethegovernmentagencyretainsdiscretiontodeterminetheresponsivenessofthebid.TheCourtfoundthatMontanalawrequiresthatanawardofapubliccontractforconstructionmustbemadetothelowestresponsiblebidderandthattheapplicableMontanastatuteconfersuponthegovernmentagencybroaddiscretionintheawardofapublicworkscontract.Thus,alowerbiddersuchasWeedenrequiresnovestedpropertyrightinacontractuntilthecontracthasbeenawarded,whichhereobviouslyhadnotyetoccurred.2013WL4774517at*5.Inanyevent,theCourtnotedthatWeedenwasgrantednotice,hearingandappealforMDT’sdecisiondenyingthegoodfaithexceptiontotheDBEcontractrequirement,andthereforeitdoesnotappearlikelythatWeedenwouldsucceedonitsdueprocessclaim.Id.at*5.
Holding and Voluntary Dismissal.TheCourtdeniedplaintiffWeeden’sapplicationforTemporaryRestrainingOrderandPreliminaryInjunction.Subsequently,WeedenfiledaNoticeofVoluntaryDismissalWithoutPrejudiceonSeptember10,2013.
![Page 346: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/346.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 220
13. Associated General Contractors of America, San Diego Chapter, Inc. v. California Department of Transportation, et al., U.S.D.C., E.D. Cal. Civil Action No. S‐09‐1622, Slip Opinion (E.D. Cal. April 20, 2011), appeal dismissed based on standing, on other grounds Ninth Circuit held Caltrans’ DBE Program constitutional, Associated General Contractors of America, San Diego Chapter, Inc. v. California Department of Transportation, et al., 713 F.3d 1187 (9th Cir. 2013)
ThiscaseinvolvedachallengebytheAssociatedGeneralContractorsofAmerica,SanDiegoChapter,Inc.(“AGC”)againsttheCaliforniaDepartmentofTransportation(“Caltrans”),totheDBEprogramadoptedbyCaltransimplementingtheFederalDBEProgramat49CFRPart26.TheAGCsoughtaninjunctionagainstCaltransenjoiningitsuseoftheDBEprogramanddeclaratoryrelieffromthecourtdeclaringtheCaltransDBEprogramtobeunconstitutional.
Caltrans’DBEprogramseta13.5percentDBEgoalforitsfederally‐fundedcontracts.The13.5percentgoal,asimplementedbyCaltrans,includedutilizinghalfrace‐neutralmeansandhalfrace‐consciousmeanstoachievethegoal.SlipOpinionTranscriptat42.Caltransdidnotincludeallminoritiesintherace‐consciouscomponentofitsgoal,excludingHispanicmalesandSubcontinentAsianAmericanmales.Id.at42.Accordingly,therace‐consciouscomponentoftheCaltransDBEprogramappliedonlytoAfricanAmericans,NativeAmericans,AsianPacificAmericans,andwhitewomen.Id.
CaltransestablishedthisgoalanditsDBEprogramfollowingadisparitystudyconductedbyBBCResearch&Consulting,whichincludedgatheringstatisticalandanecdotalevidenceofraceandgenderdisparitiesintheCaliforniaconstructionindustry.SlipOpinionTranscriptat42.
Thepartiesfiledmotionsforsummaryjudgment.ThedistrictcourtissueditsrulingatthehearingonthemotionsforsummaryjudgmentgrantingCaltrans’motionforsummaryjudgmentinsupportofitsDBEprogramanddenyingthemotionforsummaryjudgmentfiledbytheplaintiffs.SlipOpinionTranscriptat54.ThecourtheldCaltrans’DBEprogramapplyingandimplementingtheprovisionsoftheFederalDBEProgramisvalidandconstitutional.Id.at56.
ThedistrictcourtanalyzedCaltrans’implementationoftheDBEprogramunderthestrictscrutinydoctrineandfoundtheburdenofjustifyingdifferenttreatmentbyethnicityorgenderisonthegovernment.ThedistrictcourtappliedtheNinthCircuitCourtofAppealsrulinginWesternStatesPavingCompanyv.WashingtonStateDOT,407F.3d983(9thCir.2005).Thecourtstatedthatthefederalgovernmenthasacompellinginterest“inensuringthatitsfundingisnotdistributedinamannerthatperpetuatestheeffectsofeitherpublicorprivatediscriminationwithinthetransportationcontractingindustry.”SlipOpinionTranscriptat43,quotingWesternStatesPaving,407F.3dat991,citingCityofRichmondv.J.A.CrosonCompany,488U.S.469(1989).
ThedistrictcourtpointedoutthattheNinthCircuitinWesternStatesPavingandtheTenthCircuitCourtofAppealsandtheEighthCircuitCourtofAppealshaveupheldthefacialvalidityoftheFederalDBEProgram.
ThedistrictcourtstatedthatbasedonWesternStatesPaving,thecourtisrequiredtolookattheCaltransDBEprogramitselftoseeifthereisastrongbasisinevidencetoshowthatCaltransisactingforaproperpurposeandiftheprogramitselfhasbeennarrowlytailored.SlipOpinion
![Page 347: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/347.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 221
Transcriptat45.Thecourtconcludedthatnarrowtailoring“doesnotrequireexhaustionofeveryconceivablerace‐neutralalternative,butitdoesrequireserious,good‐faithconsiderationofworkablerace‐neutralalternatives.”SlipOpinionTranscriptat45.
ThedistrictcourtidentifiedtheissuesaswhetherCaltranshasestablishedacompellinginterestsupportedbyastrongbasisinevidenceforitsprogram,anddoesCaltrans’race‐consciousprogrammeetthestrictscrutinyrequired.SlipOpinionTranscriptat51‐52.ThecourtalsophrasedtheissueaswhethertheCaltransDBEprogram,“whichdoesgivepreferencebasedonraceandsex,whetherthatprogramisnarrowlytailoredtoremedytheeffectsofidentifieddiscrimination…”,andwhetherCaltranshascompliedwiththeNinthCircuit’sguidanceinWesternStatesPaving.SlipOpinionTranscriptat52.
Thedistrictcourtheld“thatCaltranshasdonewhattheNinthCircuithasrequiredittodo,whatthefederalgovernmenthasrequiredittodo,andthatitclearlyhasimplementedaprogramwhichissupportedbyastrongbasisinevidencethatgivesrisetoacompellinginterest,andthatitsrace‐consciousprogram,theaspectoftheprogramthatdoesimplementrace‐consciousalternatives,itdoesunderastrict‐scrutinystandardmeettherequirementthatitbenarrowlytailoredassetforthinthecaselaw.”SlipOpinionTranscriptat52.
Thecourtrejectedtheplaintiff’sargumentsthatanecdotalevidencefailedtoidentifyspecificactsofdiscrimination,finding“therearenumerousinstancesofspecificdiscrimination.”SlipOpinionTranscriptat52.ThedistrictcourtfoundthataftertheWesternStatesPavingcase,Caltranswenttoaraciallyneutralprogram,andtheevidenceshowedthattheprogramwouldnotmeetthegoalsofthefederally‐fundedprogram,andthefederalgovernmentbecameconcernedaboutwhatwasgoingonwithCaltrans’programapplyingonlyrace‐neutralalternatives.Id.at52‐53.ThecourtthenpointedoutthatCaltransengagedinan“extensivedisparitystudy,anecdotalevidence,bothofwhichiswhatwasmissing”intheWesternStatesPavingcase.Id.at53.
ThecourtconcludedthatCaltrans“didexactlywhattheNinthCircuitrequired”andthatCaltranshasgone“asfarasisrequired.”SlipOpinionTranscriptat53.
Thecourtheldthatasamatteroflaw,theCaltransDBEprogramis,underWesternStatesPavingandtheSupremeCourtcases,“clearlyconstitutional,”and“narrowlytailored.”SlipOpinionTranscriptat56.ThecourtfoundtherearesignificantdifferencesbetweenCaltrans’programandtheprogramintheWesternStatesPavingcase.Id.at54‐55.InWesternStatesPaving,thecourtsaidtherewerenostatisticalstudiesperformedtotryandestablishthediscriminationinthehighwaycontractingindustry,andthatWashingtonsimplycomparedtheproportionofDBEfirmsinthestatewiththepercentageofcontractingfundsawardedtoDBEsonrace‐neutralcontractstocalculateadisparity.Id.at55.
ThedistrictcourtstatedthattheNinthCircuitinWesternStatesPavingfoundthistobeoversimplifiedandentitledtolittleweight“becauseitdidnottakeintoaccountfactorsthatmayaffecttherelativecapacityofDBEstoundertakecontractingwork.”SlipOpinionTranscriptat55.Whereas,thedistrictcourtheldthe“disparitystudyusedbyCaltranswasmuchmorecomprehensiveandaccountedforthisandotherfactors.”Id.at55.ThedistrictnotedthattheStateofWashingtondidnotintroduceanyanecdotalinformation.Thedifferenceinthiscase,the
![Page 348: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/348.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 222
districtcourtfound,“isthatthedisparitystudyincludesbothextensivestatisticalevidence,aswellasanecdotalevidencegatheredthroughsurveysandpublichearings,whichsupportthestatisticalfindingsoftheunderutilizationfacedbyDBEswithouttheDBEprogram.Addtothattheanecdotalevidencesubmittedinsupportofthesummaryjudgmentmotionaswell.AndthisevidencebeforetheCourtclearlysupportsafindingthatthisprogramisconstitutional.”Id.at56.
Thecourtheldthatbecause“Caltrans’DBEprogramisbasedonsubstantialstatisticalandanecdotalevidenceofdiscriminationintheCaliforniacontractingindustryandbecausetheCourtfindsthatitisnarrowlytailored,theCourtupholdstheprogramasconstitutional.”SlipOpinionTranscriptat56.
ThedecisionofthedistrictcourtwasappealedtotheNinthCircuitCourtofAppeals.TheNinthCircuitdismissedtheappealbasedonlackofstandingbytheAGC,SanDiegoChapter,butruledonthemeritsonalternativegroundsholdingconstitutionalCaltrans’DBEProgram.SeediscussionaboveofAGC,SDCv.Cal.DOT.
14. Geod Corporation v. New Jersey Transit Corporation, et al., 746 F. Supp.2d 642, 2010 WL 4193051 (D. N. J. October 19, 2010)
Plaintiffs,whitemaleownersofGeodCorporation(“Geod”),broughtthisactionagainsttheNewJerseyTransitCorporation(“NJT”)allegingdiscriminatorypracticesbyNJTindesigningandimplementingtheFederalDBEProgram.746F.Supp2dat644.TheplaintiffsallegedthattheNJT’sDBEprogramviolatedtheUnitedStatesConstitution,42U.S.C.§1981,TitleVIoftheCivilRightsActof1964,42U.S.C.§2000(d)andstatelaw.ThedistrictcourtpreviouslydismissedthecomplaintagainstallDefendantsexceptforNJTandconcludedthatagenuineissuematerialfactexistedonlyastowhetherthemethodusedbyNJTtodetermineitsDBEgoalsduring2010weresufficientlynarrowlytailored,andthusconstitutional.Id.
New Jersey Transit Program and Disparity Study.NJTreliedontheanalysisofconsultantsfortheestablishmentoftheirgoalsfortheDBEprogram.Thestudyestablishedtheeffectsofpastdiscrimination,thedistrictcourtfound,bylookingatthedisparityandutilizationofDBEscomparedtotheiravailabilityinthemarket.Id.at648.Thestudyusedseveraldatasetsandaveragedthefindingsinordertocalculatethisratio,including:(1)theNewJerseyDBEvendorList;(2)aSurveyofMinority‐OwnedBusinessEnterprises(SMOBE)andaSurveyofWomen‐OwnedEnterprises(SWOBE)asdeterminedbytheU.S.CensusBureau;and(3)detailedcontractfilesforeachracialgroup.Id.
Thecourtfoundthestudydeterminedanaverageannualutilizationof23percentforDBEs,andtoexaminepastdiscrimination,severalanalyseswereruntomeasurethedisparityamongDBEsbyrace.Id.at648.TheStudyfoundthatallbutonecategorywasunderutilizedamongtheracialandethnicgroups.Id.AllgroupsotherthanAsianDBEswerefoundtobeunderutilized.Id.
Thecourtheldthatthetestutilizedbythestudy,“conductedtoestablishapatternofdiscriminationagainstDBEs,provedthatdiscriminationoccurredagainstDBEsduringthepre‐qualificationprocessandinthenumberofcontractsthatareawardedtoDBEs.Id.at649.The
![Page 349: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/349.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 223
courtfoundthatDBEsaremorelikelythannon‐DBEstobepre‐qualifiedforsmallconstructioncontracts,butarelesslikelytopre‐qualifyforlargerconstructionprojects.Id.
Forfiscalyear2010,thestudyconsultantfollowedthe“three‐stepprocesspursuanttoUSDOTregulationstoestablishtheNJTDBEgoal.”Id.at649.First,theconsultantdetermined“thebasefigurefortherelativeavailabilityofDBEsinthespecificindustriesandgeographicalmarketfromwhichDBEandnon‐DBEcontractorsaredrawn.”Id.Indeterminingthebasefigure,theconsultant(1)definedthegeographicmarketplace,(2)identified“therelevantindustriesinwhichNJTransitcontracts,”and(3)calculated“theweightedavailabilitymeasure.”Id.at649.
Thecourtfoundthatthestudyconsultantusedpoliticaljurisdictionalmethodsandvirtualmethodstopinpointthelocationofcontractsand/orcontractorsforNJT,anddeterminedthatthegeographicalmarketplaceforNJTcontractsincludedNewJersey,NewYorkandPennsylvania.Id.at649.TheconsultantusedcontractfilesobtainedfromNJTanddataobtainedfromDun&BradstreettoidentifytheindustrieswithwhichNJTcontractsinthesegeographicalareas.Id.TheconsultantthenusedexistingandestimatedexpendituresintheseparticularindustriestodetermineweightscorrespondingtoNJTcontractingpatternsinthedifferentindustriesforuseintheavailabilityanalysis.Id.
TheavailabilityofDBEswascalculatedbyusingthefollowingdata:UnifiedCertificationProgramBusinessDirectoriesforthestatesofNewJersey,NewYorkandPennsylvania;NJTVendorList;Dun&Bradstreetdatabase;2002SurveyofSmallBusinessOwners;andNJTPre‐QualificationList.Id.at649‐650.Theavailabilityrateswerethen“calculatedbycomparingthenumberofready,willing,andableminorityandwomen‐ownedfirmsinthedefinedgeographicmarketplacetothetotalnumberofready,willing,andablefirmsinthesamegeographicmarketplace.Id.TheavailabilityratesineachindustrywereweighedinaccordancewithNJTexpenditurestodetermineabasefigure.Id.
Second,theconsultantadjustedthebasefigureduetoevidenceofdiscriminationagainstDBEprimecontractorsanddisparitiesinsmallpurchasesandconstructionpre‐qualification.Id.at650.Thediscriminationanalysisexamineddiscriminationinsmallpurchases,discriminationinpre‐qualification,tworegressionanalyses,anEssexCountydisparitystudy,marketdiscrimination,andpreviousutilization.Id.at650.
TheFinalRecommendationsReportnotedthatthereweresizeabledifferencesinthesmallpurchasesawardstoDBEsandnon‐DBEswiththeawardstoDBEsbeingsignificantlysmaller.Id.at650.DBEswerealsofoundtobelesslikelytobepre‐qualifiedforcontractsover$1millionincomparisontosimilarlysituatednon‐DBEs.Id.Theregressionanalysisusingthedummyvariablemethodyieldedanaverageestimateofadiscriminatoryeffectof‐28.80percent.Id.Thediscriminationregressionanalysisusingtheresidualdifferencemethodshowedthatonaverage12.2percentofthecontractamountdisparityawardedtoDBEsandnon‐DBEswasunexplained.Id.
Theconsultantalsoconsideredevidenceofdiscriminationinthelocalmarketinaccordancewith49CFR§26.45(d).TheFinalRecommendationsReportcitedinthe2005EssexCountyDisparityStudysuggestedthatdiscriminationinthelabormarketcontributedtotheunexplainedportion
![Page 350: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/350.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 224
oftheself‐employment,employment,unemployment,andwagegapsinEssexCounty,NewJersey.Id.at650.
TheconsultantrecommendedthatNJTfocusonincreasingthenumberofDBEprimecontractors.Becausequalitativeevidenceisdifficulttoquantify,accordingtotheconsultant,onlytheresultsfromtheregressionanalyseswereusedtoadjustthebasegoal.Id.Thebasegoalwasthenadjustedfrom19.74percentto23.79percent.Id.
Third,inordertopartitiontheDBEgoalbyrace‐neutralandrace‐consciousmethods,theconsultantanalyzedtheshareofallDBEcontractdollarswonwithnogoals.Id.at650.Healsoperformedtwodifferentregressionanalyses:oneinvolvingpredictedDBEcontractdollarsandDBEreceiptsifthegoalwassetatzero.Id.at651.ThesecondmethodutilizedpredictedDBEcontractdollarswithgoalsandpredictedDBEcontractdollarswithoutgoalstoforecasthowmuchfirmswithgoalswouldreceivehadtheynotincludedthegoals.Id.Theconsultantaveragedhisresultsfromallthreemethodstoconcludethatthefiscalyear2010NJTaportionoftherace‐neutralDBEgoalshouldbe11.94percentandaportionoftherace‐consciousDBEgoalshouldbe11.84percent.Id.at651.
Thedistrictcourtappliedthestrictscrutinystandardofreview.Thedistrictcourtalreadydecided,inthecourseofthemotionsforsummaryjudgment,thatcompellinginterestwassatisfiedasNewJerseywasentitledtoadoptthefederalgovernment’scompellinginterestinenactingTEA‐21anditsimplementingregulations.Id.at652,citingGeodv.N.J.TransitCorp.,678F.Supp.2d276,282(D.N.J.2009).Therefore,thecourtlimiteditsanalysistowhetherNJT’sDBEprogramwasnarrowlytailoredtofurtherthatcompellinginterestinaccordancewith“itsgrantofauthorityunderfederallaw.”Id.at652citingNorthernContracting,Inc.v.IllinoisDepartmentofTransportation,473F.3d715,722(7thCir.2007).
Applying Northern Contracting v. Illinois. Thedistrictcourtclarifieditspriorrulingin2009(see678F.Supp.2d276)regardingsummaryjudgment,thatthecourtagreedwiththeholdinginNorthernContracting,Inc.v.Illinois,that“achallengetoastate’sapplicationofafederallymandatedprogrammustbelimitedtothequestionofwhetherthestateexceededitsauthority.”Id.at652quotingNorthernContracting,473F.3dat721.ThedistrictcourtinGeodfollowedtheSeventhCircuitexplanationthatwhenastatedepartmentoftransportationisactingasaninstrumentoffederalpolicy,aplaintiffcannotcollaterallyattackthefederalregulationsthroughachallengetoastate’sprogram.Id.at652,citingNorthernContracting,473F.3dat722.Therefore,thedistrictcourtheldthattheinquiryislimitedtothequestionofwhetherthestatedepartmentoftransportation“exceededitsgrantofauthorityunderfederallaw.”Id.at652‐653,quotingNorthernContracting,473F.3dat722andcitingalsoTennesseeAsphaltCo.v.Farris,942F.2d969,975(6thCir.1991).
ThedistrictcourtfoundthattheholdingandanalysisinNorthernContractingdoesnotcontradicttheEighthCircuit’sanalysisinSherbrookeTurf,Inc.v.MinnesotaDepartmentofTransportation,345F.3d964,970‐71(8thCir.2003).Id.at653.ThecourtheldthattheEighthCircuit’sdiscussionofwhethertheDBEprogramsasimplementedbytheStateofMinnesotaandtheStateofNebraskawerenarrowlytailoredfocusedonwhetherthestateswerefollowingtheUSDOTregulations.Id.at653citingSherbrookeTurf,345F.3d973‐74.Therefore,“onlywhenthestateexceedsitsfederalauthorityisitsusceptibletoanas‐appliedconstitutionalchallenge.”Id.
![Page 351: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/351.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 225
at653quotingWesternStatesPavingCo.,Inc.v.WashingtonStateDepartmentofTransportation,407F.3d983(9thCir.2005)(McKay,C.J.)(concurringinpartanddissentinginpart)andcitingSouthFloridaChapteroftheAssociatedGeneralContractorsv.BrowardCounty,544F.Supp.2d1336,1341(S.D.Fla.2008).
Thecourtheldtheinitialburdenofprooffallsonthegovernment,butoncethegovernmenthaspresentedproofthatitsaffirmativeactionplanisnarrowlytailored,thepartychallengingtheaffirmativeactionplanbearstheultimateburdenofprovingthattheplanisunconstitutional.Id.at653.
InanalyzingwhetherNJT’sDBEprogramwasconstitutionallydefective,thedistrictcourtfocusedonthebasisofplaintiffs’argumentthatitwasnotnarrowlytailoredbecauseitincludesinthecategoryofDBEsracialorethnicgroupsastowhichtheplaintiffsallegedNJThadnoevidenceofpastdiscrimination.Id.at653.Thecourtfoundthatmostofplaintiffs’argumentscouldbesummarizedasquestioningwhetherNJTpresenteddemonstrableevidenceoftheavailabilityofready,willingandableDBEsasrequiredby49CFR§26.45.Id.ThecourtheldthatNJTfollowedthegoalsettingprocessrequiredbythefederalregulations.Id.ThecourtstatedthatNJTbeganthisprocesswiththe2002disparitystudythatexaminedpastdiscriminationandfoundthatallofthegroupslistedintheregulationswereunderutilizedwiththeexceptionofAsians.Id.at654.Incalculatingthefiscalyear2010goals,theconsultantusedcontractfilesanddatafromDun&BradstreettodeterminethegeographicallocationcorrespondingtoNJTcontractsandthenfurtherfocusedthatinformationbyweightingtheindustriesaccordingtoNJT’suse.Id.
TheconsultantusedvariousmethodstocalculatetheavailabilityofDBEs,including:theUCPBusinessDirectoriesforthestatesofNewJersey,NewYorkandPennsylvania;NJTVendorList;Dun&Bradstreetdatabase;2002SurveyofSmallBusinessOwners;andNJTPre‐QualificationList.Id.at654.ThecourtstatedthatNJTonlyutilizedoneoftheexampleslistedin49CFR§26.45(c),theDBEdirectoriesmethod,informulatingthefiscalyear2010goals.Id.
Thedistrictcourtpointedout,however,theregulationsstatethatthe“examplesareprovidedasastartingpointforyourgoalsettingprocessandthattheexamplesarenotintendedasanexhaustivelist.Id.at654,citing46CFR§26.45(c).Thecourtconcludedtheregulationsclarifythatothermethodsorcombinationsofmethodstodetermineabasefiguremaybeused.Id.at654.
ThecourtstatedthatNJThadusedthesemethodsinsettinggoalsforprioryearsasdemonstratedbythereportsfor2006and2009.Id.at654.Inaddition,thecourtnotedthattheSeventhCircuitheldthatacustomcensus,theDun&Bradstreetdatabase,andtheIDOT’slistofDBEswereanacceptablecombinationofmethodswithwhichtodeterminethebasefigureforTEA‐21purposes.Id.at654,citingNorthernContracting,473F.3dat718.
Thedistrictcourtfoundthattheexpertwitnessforplaintiffshadnotconvincedthecourtthatthedatawerefaulty,andthetestimonyattrialdidnotpersuadethecourtthatthedataorregressionanalysesrelieduponbyNJTwereunreliableorthatanothermethodwouldprovidemoreaccurateresults.Id.at654‐655.
![Page 352: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/352.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 226
Thecourtindiscussingsteptwoofthegoalssettingprocesspointedoutthatthedataexaminedbytheconsultantislistedintheregulationsasproperevidencetobeusedtoadjustthebasefigure.Id.at655,citing49CFR§26.45(d).ThesedataincludedevidencefromdisparitystudiesandstatisticaldisparitiesintheabilityofDBEstogetpre‐qualification.Id.at655.Theconsultantstatedthatevidenceofsocietaldiscriminationwasnotusedtoadjustthebasegoalandthattheadjustmenttothegoalwasbasedonthediscriminationanalysis,whichcontrolsforsizeoffirmandeffectofhavingaDBEgoal.Id.at655.
ThedistrictcourtthenanalyzedNJT’sdivisionoftheadjustedgoalintorace‐consciousandrace‐neutralportions.Id.at655.Thecourtnotedthatnarrowlytailoringdoesnotrequireexhaustionofeveryconceivablerace‐neutralalternative,butinsteadrequiresserious,goodfaithconsiderationofworkablerace‐neutralalternatives.Id.at655.ThecourtagreedwithWesternStatesPavingthatonly“whenrace‐neutraleffortsproveinadequatedotheseregulationsauthorizeaStatetoresorttorace‐consciousmeasurestoachievetheremainderofitsDBEutilizationgoal.”Id.at655,quotingWesternStatesPaving,407F.3dat993‐94.
ThecourtfoundthatthemethodsutilizedbyNJThadbeenusedbyitonpreviousoccasions,whichwereapprovedbytheUSDOT.Id.at655.ThemethodsusedbyNJT,thecourtfound,alsocompliedwiththeexampleslistedin49CFR§26.51,includingarrangingsolicitations,timesforthepresentationofbids,quantities,specifications,anddeliveryschedulesinwaysthatfacilitateDBEparticipation;providingpre‐qualificationassistance;implementingsupportiveservicesprograms;andensuringdistributionofDBEdirectories.Id.at655.ThecourtheldthatbasedonthesereasonsandfollowingtheNorthernContracting,Inc.v.Illinoislineofcases,NJT’sDBEprogramdidnotviolatetheConstitutionasitdidnotexceeditsfederalauthority.Id.at655.
However,thedistrictcourtalsofoundthatevenundertheWesternStatesPavingCo.,Inc.v.WashingtonStateDOTstandard,theNJTprogramstillwasconstitutional.Id.at655.AlthoughthecourtfoundthattheappropriateinquiryiswhetherNJTexceededitsfederalauthorityasdetailedinNorthernContracting,Inc.v.Illinois,thecourtalsoexaminedtheNJTDBEprogramunderWesternStatesPavingCo.v.WashingtonStateDOT.Id.at655‐656.ThecourtstatedthatunderWesternStatesPaving,aCourtmust“undertakeanas‐appliedinquiryintowhether[thestate’s]DBEprogramisnarrowlytailored.”Id.at656,quotingWesternStatesPaving,407F.3dat997.
Applying Western States Paving.ThedistrictcourtthenanalyzedwhethertheNJTprogramwasnarrowlytailoredapplyingWesternStatesPaving.Underthefirstprongofthenarrowlytailoringanalysis,aremedialprogramisonlynarrowlytailoredifitsapplicationislimitedtothoseminoritygroupsthathaveactuallysuffereddiscrimination.Id.at656,citingWesternStatesPaving,407F.3dat998.Thecourtacknowledgedthataccordingtothe2002FinalReport,theratiosofDBEutilizationtoDBEavailabilitywas1.31.Id.at656.However,thecourtfoundthattheplaintiffs’argumentfailedasthefactsinWesternStatesPavingweredistinguishablefromthoseofNJT,becauseNJTdidreceivecomplaints,i.e.,anecdotalevidence,ofthelackofopportunitiesforAsianfirms.Id.at656.NJTemployeestestifiedthatAsianfirmsinformallyandformallycomplainedofalackofopportunitytogrowandindicatedthattheDBEProgramwasassistingwiththisissue.Id.Inaddition,plaintiff’sexpertconcededthatAsianfirmshavesmalleraveragecontractamountsincomparisontonon‐DBEfirms.Id.
![Page 353: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/353.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 227
TheplaintiffreliedsolelyontheutilizationrateasevidencethatAsiansarenotdiscriminatedagainstinNJTcontracting.Id.at656.Thecourtheldthiswasinsufficienttoovercometheconsultant’sdeterminationthatdiscriminationdidexistagainstAsians,andthusthisgroupwasproperlyincludedintheDBEprogram.Id.at656.
ThedistrictcourtrejectedPlaintiffs’argumentthatthefirststepofthenarrowtailoringanalysiswasnotmetbecauseNJTfocusesitsprogramonsub‐contractorswhenNJT’sexpertidentified“primecontracting”astheareainwhichNJTprocurementsevidencediscrimination.Id.at656.Thecourtheldthatnarrowtailoringdoesnotrequireexhaustionofeveryconceivablerace‐neutralalternativebutitdoesrequireserious,goodfaithconsiderationofworkablerace‐neutralalternatives.Id.at656,citingSherbrookTurf,345F.3dat972(quotingGrutterv.Bollinger,539U.S.306,339,(2003)).Initseffortstoimplementrace‐neutralalternatives,thecourtfoundNJTattemptedtobreaklargercontractsupinordertomakethemavailabletosmallercontractorsandcontinuestodosowhenlogisticallypossibleandfeasibletotheprocurementdepartment.Id.at656‐657.
ThedistrictcourtfoundNJTsatisfiedthethirdprongofthenarrowlytailoredanalysis,the“relationshipofthenumericalgoalstotherelevantlabormarket.”Id.at657.Finally,underthefourthprong,thecourtaddressedtheimpactonthird‐parties.Id.at657.Thecourtnotedthatplacingaburdenonthirdpartiesisnotimpermissibleaslongasthatburdenisminimized.Id.at657,citingWesternStatesPaving,407F.3dat995.Thecourtstatedthatinstanceswillinevitablyoccurwherenon‐DBEswillbebypassedforcontractsthatrequireDBEgoals.However,TEA‐21anditsimplementingregulationscontainprovisionsintendedtominimizetheburdenonnon‐DBEs.Id.at657,citingWesternStatesPaving,407F.3dat994‐995.
ThecourtpointedouttheNinthCircuitinWesternStatesPavingfoundthatinclusionofregulationsallowingfirmsthatwerenotpresumedtobeDBEstodemonstratethattheyweresociallyandeconomicallydisadvantaged,andthusqualifiedforDBEprograms,aswellasthenetworthlimitations,weresufficienttominimizetheburdenonDBEs.Id.at657,citingWesternStatesPaving,407F.3dat955.ThecourtheldthattheplaintiffsdidnotprovideevidencethatNJTwasnotcomplyingwithimplementingregulationsdesignedtominimizeharmtothirdparties.Id.
Therefore,evenifthedistrictcourtutilizedtheas‐appliednarrowtailoringinquirysetforthinWesternStatesPaving,NJT’sDBEprogramwouldnotbefoundtoviolatetheConstitution,asthecourthelditwasnarrowlytailoredtofurtheracompellinggovernmentalinterest.Id.at657.
15. Geod Corporation v. New Jersey Transit Corporation, et seq. 678 F.Supp.2d 276, 2009 WL 2595607 (D.N.J. August 20, 2009)
PlaintiffsGeodanditsofficers,whoarewhitemales,suedtheNJTandstateofficialsseekingadeclarationthatNJT’sDBEprogramwasunconstitutionalandinviolationoftheUnitedStates5thand14thAmendmenttotheUnitedStatesConstitutionandtheConstitutionoftheStateofNewJersey,andseekingapermanentinjunctionagainstNJTforenforcingorutilizingitsDBEprogram.TheNJT’sDBEprogramwasimplementedinaccordancewiththeFederalDBEProgramandTEA‐21and49CFRPart26.
![Page 354: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/354.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 228
ThepartiesfiledcrossMotionsforSummaryJudgment.TheplaintiffGeodchallengedtheconstitutionalityofNJT’sDBEprogramformultiplereasons,includingallegingNJTcouldnotjustifyestablishingaprogramusingrace‐andsex‐basedpreferences;theNJT’sdisparitystudydidnotprovideasufficientfactualpredicatetojustifytheDBEProgram;NJT’sstatisticalevidencedidnotestablishdiscrimination;NJTdidnothaveanecdotaldataevidencinga“strongbasisinevidence”ofdiscriminationwhichjustifiedarace‐andsex‐basedprogram;NJT’sprogramwasnotnarrowlytailoredandover‐inclusive;NJTcouldnotshowanexceedinglypersuasivejustificationforgenderpreferences;andthatNJT’sprogramwasnotnarrowlytailoredbecauserace‐neutralalternativesexisted.Inopposition,NJTfiledaMotionforSummaryJudgmentassertingthatitsDBEprogramwasnarrowlytailoredbecauseitfullycompliedwiththerequirementsoftheFederalDBEProgramandTEA‐21.
Thedistrictcourtheldthatstatesandtheiragenciesareentitledtoadoptthefederalgovernments’compellinginterestinenactingTEA‐21anditsimplementingregulations.2009WL2595607at*4.Thecourtstatedthatplaintiff’sargumentthatNJTcannotestablishtheneedforitsDBEprogramwasa“redherring,whichisunsupported.”TheplaintiffdidnotquestiontheconstitutionalityofthecompellinginterestoftheFederalDBEProgram.Thecourtheldthatallstates“inheritthefederalgovernments’compellinginterestinestablishingaDBEprogram.”Id.
ThecourtfoundthatestablishingaDBEprogram“isnotcontingentuponastateagencydemonstratinganeedforsame,asthefederalgovernmenthasalreadydoneso.”Id.Thecourtconcludedthatthisreasoningrenderedplaintiff’sassertionsthatNJT’sdisparitystudydidnothavesufficientfactualpredicateforestablishingitsDBEprogram,andthatnoexceedinglypersuasivejustificationwasfoundtosupportgender‐basedpreferences,aswithoutmerit.Id.ThecourtheldthatNJTdoesnotneedtojustifyestablishingitsDBEprogram,asithasalreadybeenjustifiedbythelegislature.Id.
Thecourtnotedthatbothplaintiff’sanddefendant’sargumentswerebasedonanallegedsplitintheFederalCircuitCourtsofAppeal.PlaintiffGeodreliesonWesternStatesPavingCompanyv.WashingtonStateDOT,407F.3d983(9thCir.2005)forthepropositionthatanas‐appliedchallengetotheconstitutionalityofaparticularDBEprogramrequiresademonstrationbytherecipientoffederalfundsthattheprogramisnarrowlytailored.Idat*5.Incontrast,theNJTreliedprimarilyonNorthernContracting,Inc.v.StateofIllinois,473F.3d715(7thCir.2007)forthepropositionthatifaDBEprogramcomplieswithTEA‐21,itisnarrowlytailored.Id.
ThecourtviewedthevariousFederalCircuitCourtofAppealsdecisionsasfactspecificdeterminationswhichhaveledtothepartiesdistinguishingcaseswithoutanysubstantivedifferenceintheapplicationoflaw.Id.
ThecourtreviewedthedecisionsbytheNinthCircuitinWesternStatesPavingandtheSeventhCircuitofNorthernContracting.InWesternStatesPaving,thedistrictcourtstatedthattheNinthCircuitheldforaDBEprogramtopassconstitutionalmuster,itmustbenarrowlytailored;specifically,therecipientoffederalfundsmustevidencepastdiscriminationintherelevantmarketinordertoutilizeraceconsciousDBEgoals.Id.at*5.TheNinthCircuit,accordingtodistrictcourt,madeafactspecificdeterminationastowhethertheDBEprogramcompliedwithTEA‐21inordertodecideiftheprogramwasnarrowlytailoredtomeetthefederalregulation’s
![Page 355: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/355.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 229
requirements.Thedistrictcourtstatedthattherequirementthatarecipientmustevidencepastdiscrimination“isnothingmorethanarequirementoftheregulation.”Id.
ThecourtstatedthattheSeventhCircuitinNorthernContractingheldarecipientmustdemonstratethatitsprogramisnarrowlytailored,andthatgenerallyarecipientisinsulatedfromthissortofconstitutionalattackabsentashowingthatthestateexceededitsfederalauthority.Id.,citingNorthernContracting,473F.3dat721.ThedistrictcourtheldthatimplicitinNorthernContractingisthefactonemaychallengetheconstitutionalityofaDBEprogram,asitisapplied,totheextentthattheprogramexceedsitsfederalauthority.Id.
Thecourt,therefore,concludedthatitmustdeterminefirstwhetherNJT’sDBEprogramcomplieswithTEA‐21,thenwhetherNJTexceededitsfederalauthorityinitsapplicationofitsDBEprogram.Inotherwords,thedistrictcourtstateditmustdeterminewhethertheNJTDBEprogramcomplieswithTEA‐21inordertodeterminewhethertheprogram,asimplementedbyNJT,isnarrowlytailored.Id.
ThecourtpointedoutthattheEighthCircuitCourtofAppealsinSherbrookTurf,Inc.v.MinnesotaDOT,345F.3d964(8thCir.2003)foundMinnesota’sDBEprogramwasnarrowlytailoredbecauseitwasincompliancewithTEA‐21’srequirements.TheEighthCircuitinSherbrook,accordingtothedistrictcourt,analyzedtheapplicationofMinnesota’sDBEprogramtoensurecompliancewithTEA‐21’srequirementstoensurethattheDBEprogramimplementedbyMinnesotaDOTwasnarrowlytailored.Id.at*5.
ThecourtheldthatTEA‐21delegatestoeachstatethatacceptsfederaltransportationfundstheresponsibilityofimplementingaDBEprogramthatcomportswithTEA‐21.InordertocomportwithTEA‐21,thedistrictcourtstatedarecipientmust(1)determineanappropriateDBEparticipationgoal,(2)examineallevidenceandevaluatewhetheranadjustment,ifany,isneededtoarriveattheirgoal,and(3)iftheadjustmentisbasedoncontinuingeffectsofpastdiscrimination,providedemonstrableevidencethatislogicallyanddirectlyrelatedtotheeffectforwhichtheadjustmentissought.Id.at*6,citingWesternStatesPavingCompany,407F.3dat983,988.
First,thedistrictcourtstatedarecipientoffederalfundsmustdetermine,atthelocallevel,thefigurethatwouldconstituteanappropriateDBEinvolvementgoal,basedontheirrelativeavailabilityofDBEs.Id.at*6,citing49CFR§26.45(c).Inthiscase,thecourtfoundthatNJTdiddetermineabasefigurefortherelativeavailabilityofDBEs,whichaccountedfordemonstrableevidenceoflocalmarketconditionsandwasdesignedtoberationallyrelatedtotherelativeavailabilityofDBEs.Id.ThecourtpointedoutthatNJTconductedadisparitystudy,andthedisparitystudyutilizedNJT’sDBElistsfromfiscalyears1995‐1999andCensusDatatodetermineitsbaseDBEgoal.Thecourtnotedthattheplaintiffs’argumentthatthedatausedinthedisparitystudywerestalewaswithoutmeritandhadnobasisinlaw.Thecourtfoundthatthedisparitystudytookintoaccounttheprimaryindustries,primarygeographicmarket,andraceneutralalternatives,thenadjusteditsgoaltoencompassthesecharacteristics.Id.at*6.
ThecourtstatedthattheuseofDBEdirectoriesandCensusdataarewhatthelegislatureintendedforstateagenciestoutilizeinmakingabaseDBEgoaldetermination.Id.Also,thecourtstatedthat“perhapsmoreimportantly,NJT’sDBEgoalwasapprovedbytheUSDOTeveryyear
![Page 356: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/356.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 230
from2002until2008.”Id.at*6.Thus,thecourtfoundNJTappropriatelydeterminedtheirDBEavailability,whichwasapprovedbytheUSDOT,pursuantto49CFR§26.45(c).Id.at*6.ThecourtheldthatNJTdemonstrateditsoverallDBEgoalisbasedondemonstrableevidenceoftheavailabilityofready,willing,andableDBEsrelativetoallbusinessesready,willing,andabletoparticipateinDOTassistedcontractsandreflectsitsdeterminationofthelevelofDBEparticipationitwouldexpectabsenttheeffectsofdiscrimination.Id.
Alsoofsignificance,thecourtpointedoutthatplaintiffsdidnotprovideanyevidencethatNJTdidnotsetaDBEgoalbasedupon49C.F.§26.45(c).ThecourtthusheldthatgenuineissuesofmaterialfactremainonlyastowhetherareasonablejurymayfindthatthemethodusedbyNJTtodetermineitsDBEgoalwassufficientlynarrowlytailored.Id.at*6.
Thecourtpointedoutthattodeterminewhatadjustmenttomake,thedisparitystudyexaminedqualitativedatasuchasfocusgroupsonthepre‐qualificationstatusofDBEs,workingwithprimecontractors,securingcredit,anditseffectonDBEparticipation,aswellasprocurementofficerinterviewstoanalyze,andcompareandcontrasttheirrelationshipswithnon‐DBEvendorsandDBEvendors.Id.at*7.ThisqualitativeinformationwasthencomparedtoDBEbidsandDBEgoalsforeachyearinquestion.NJT’sadjustmenttoitsDBEgoalalsoincludedananalysisoftheoveralldisparityratio,aswellas,DBEutilizationbasedonrace,genderandethnicity.Id.Adecompositionanalysiswasalsoperformed.Id.
ThecourtconcludedthatNJTprovidedevidencethatit,ataminimum,examinedthecurrentcapacityofDBEstoperformworkinitsDOT‐assistedcontractingprogram,asmeasuredbythevolumeofworkDBEshaveperformedinrecentyears,aswellasutilizingthedisparitystudyitself.Thecourtpointedoutthereweretwomethodsspecificallyapprovedby49CFR§26.45(d).Id.
ThecourtalsofoundthatNJTtookintoaccountraceneutralmeasurestoensurethatthegreatestpercentageofDBEparticipationwasachievedthroughraceandgender‐neutralmeans.Thedistrictcourtconcludedthat“critically,”plaintiffsfailedtoprovideevidenceofanother,moreperfect,methodthatcouldhavebeenutilizedtoadjustNJT’sDBEgoal.Id.at*7.ThecourtheldthatgenuineissuesofmaterialfactremainonlyastowhetherNJT’sadjustmenttoitsDBEgoalissufficientlynarrowlytailoredandthusconstitutional.Id.
NJT,thecourtfound,adjusteditsDBEgoaltoaccountfortheeffectsofpastdiscrimination,notingthedisparitystudytookintoaccounttheeffectsofpastdiscriminationinthepre‐qualificationprocessofDBEs.Id.at*7.Thecourtquotedthedisparitystudyasstatingthatitfoundnon‐trivialandstatisticallysignificantmeasuresofdiscriminationincontractamountsawardedduringthestudyperiod.Id.at*8.
Thecourtfound,however,thatwhatwas“gravelycritical”aboutthefindingofthepasteffectsofdiscriminationisthatitonlytookintoaccountsixgroupsincludingAmericanIndian,Hispanic,Asian,blacks,womenand“unknown,”butdidnotincludeananalysisofpastdiscriminationfortheethnicgroup“Iraqi,”whichisnowagroupconsideredtobeaDBEbytheNJT.Id.Becausethedisparityreportincludedacategoryentitled“unknown,”thecourtheldagenuineissueofmaterialfactremainsastowhether“Iraqi”islegitimatelywithinNJT’sdefinedDBEgroupsandwhetherademonstrablefindingofdiscriminationexistsforIraqis.Therefore,thecourtdenied
![Page 357: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/357.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 231
bothplaintiffs’anddefendants’MotionsforSummaryJudgmentastotheconstitutionalityofNJT’sDBEprogram.
ThecourtalsoheldthatbecausethelawwasnotclearlyestablishedatthetimeNJTestablisheditsDBEprogramtocomplywithTEA‐21,theindividualstatedefendantswereentitledtoqualifiedimmunityandtheirMotionforSummaryJudgmentastothestateofficialswasgranted.Thecourt,inaddition,heldthatplaintiff’sTitleVIclaimsweredismissedbecausetheindividualdefendantswerenotrecipientsoffederalfunds,andthattheNJTasaninstrumentalityoftheStateofNewJerseyisentitledtosovereignimmunity.Therefore,thecourtheldthattheplaintiff’sclaimsbasedontheviolationof42U.S.C.§1983weredismissedandNJT’sMotionforSummaryJudgmentwasgrantedastothatclaim.
16. South Florida Chapter of the Associated General Contractors v. Broward County, Florida, 544 F. Supp.2d 1336 (S.D. Fla. 2008)
Plaintiff,theSouthFloridaChapteroftheAssociatedGeneralContractors,broughtsuitagainsttheDefendant,BrowardCounty,FloridachallengingBrowardCounty’simplementationoftheFederalDBEProgramandBrowardCounty’sissuanceofcontractspursuanttotheFederalDBEProgram.PlaintifffiledaMotionforaPreliminaryInjunction.ThecourtconsideredonlythethresholdlegalissueraisedbyplaintiffintheMotion,namelywhetherornotthedecisioninWesternStatesPavingCompanyv.WashingtonStateDepartmentofTransportation,407F.3d983(9thCir.2005)shouldgoverntheCourt’sconsiderationofthemeritsofplaintiffs’claim.544F.Supp.2dat1337.Thecourtidentifiedthethresholdlegalissuepresentedasessentially,“whethercompliancewiththefederalregulationsisallthatisrequiredofDefendantBrowardCounty.”Id.at1338.
TheDefendantCountycontendedthatasarecipientoffederalfundsimplementingtheFederalDBEProgram,allthatisrequiredoftheCountyistocomplywiththefederalregulations,relyingoncaselawfromtheSeventhCircuitinsupportofitsposition.544F.Supp.2dat1338,citingNorthernContractingv.Illinois,473F.3d715(7thCir.2007).Theplaintiffsdisagreed,andcontendedthattheCountymusttakeadditionalstepsbeyondthoseexplicitlyprovidedforinthefederalregulationstoensuretheconstitutionalityoftheCounty’simplementationoftheFederalDBEProgram,asadministeredintheCounty,citingWesternStatesPaving,407F.3d983.ThecourtfoundthattherewasnocaselawonpointintheEleventhCircuitCourtofAppeals.Id.at1338.
NinthCircuitApproach:WesternStates.ThedistrictcourtanalyzedtheNinthCircuitCourtofAppealsapproachinWesternStatesPavingandtheSeventhCircuitapproachinMilwaukeeCountyPaversAssociationv.Fiedler,922F.2d419(7thCir.1991)andNorthernContracting,473F.3d715.ThedistrictcourtinBrowardCountyconcludedthattheNinthCircuitinWesternStatesPavingheldthatwhetherWashington’sDBEprogramisnarrowlytailoredtofurtherCongress’sremedialobjectivedependsuponthepresenceorabsenceofdiscriminationintheState’stransportationcontractingindustry,andthatitwaserrorforthedistrictcourtinWesternStatesPavingtoupholdWashington’sDBEprogramsimplybecausethestatehadcompliedwiththefederalregulations.544F.Supp.2dat1338‐1339.ThedistrictcourtinBrowardCountypointedoutthattheNinthCircuitinWesternStatesPavingconcludeditwouldbenecessaryto
![Page 358: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/358.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 232
undertakeanas‐appliedinquiryintowhetherthestate’sprogramisnarrowlytailored.544F.Supp.2dat1339,citingWesternStatesPaving,407F.3dat997.
Inafootnote,thedistrictcourtinBrowardCountynotedthattheUSDOT“appearsnottobeofonemindonthisissue,however.”544F.Supp.2dat1339,n.3.Thedistrictcourtstatedthatthe“UnitedStatesDOThas,inanalysispostedonitsWebsite,implicitlyinstructedstatesandlocalitiesoutsideoftheNinthCircuittoignoretheWesternStatesPavingdecision,whichwouldtendtoindicatethatthisagencymaynotconcurwiththe‘opinionoftheUnitedStates’asrepresentedinWesternStates.”544F.Supp.2dat1339,n.3.ThedistrictcourtnotedthattheUnitedStatestookthepositionintheWesternStatesPavingcasethatthe“statewouldhavetohaveevidenceofpastorcurrenteffectsofdiscriminationtouserace‐consciousgoals.”544F.Supp.2dat1338,quotingWesternStatesPaving.
TheCourtalsopointedoutthattheEighthCircuitCourtofAppealsinSherbrookeTurf,Inc.v.MinnesotaDepartmentofTransportation,345F.3d964(8thCir.2003)reachedasimilarconclusionasinWesternStatesPaving.544F.Supp.2dat1339.TheEighthCircuitinSherbrooke,likethecourtinWesternStatesPaving,“concludedthatthefederalgovernmenthaddelegatedthetaskofensuringthatthestateprogramsarenarrowlytailored,andlookedtotheunderlyingdatatodeterminewhetherthoseprogramswere,infact,narrowlytailored,ratherthansimplyrelyingonthestates’compliancewiththefederalregulations.”544F.Supp.2dat1339.
SeventhCircuitApproach:MilwaukeeCountyandNorthernContracting.ThedistrictcourtinBrowardCountynextconsideredtheSeventhCircuitapproach.TheDefendantsinBrowardCountyagreedthattheCountymustmakealocalfindingofdiscriminationforitsprogramtobeconstitutional.544F.Supp.2dat1339.TheCounty,however,tookthepositionthatitmustmakethisfindingthroughtheprocessspecifiedinthefederalregulations,andshouldnotbesubjecttoalawsuitifthatprocessisfoundtobeinadequate.Id.Insupportofthisposition,theCountyreliedprimarilyontheSeventhCircuit’sapproach,firstarticulatedinMilwaukeeCountyPaversAssociationv.Fiedler,922F.2d419(7thCir.1991),thenreaffirmedinNorthernContracting,473F.3d715(7thCir.2007).544F.Supp.2dat1339.
BasedontheSeventhCircuitapproach,insofarasthestateismerelydoingwhatthestatuteandfederalregulationsenvisageandpermit,theattackonthestateisanimpermissiblecollateralattackonthefederalstatuteandregulations.544F.Supp.2dat1339‐1340.Thisapproachconcludesthatastate’sroleinthefederalprogramissimplyasanagent,andinsofar“asthestateismerelycomplyingwithfederallawitisactingastheagentofthefederalgovernmentandisnomoresubjecttobeingenjoinedonequalprotectiongroundsthanthefederalcivilservantswhodraftedtheregulations.”544F.Supp.2dat1340,quotingMilwaukeeCountyPavers,922F.2dat423.
TheNinthCircuitaddressedtheMilwaukeeCountyPaverscaseinWesternStatesPaving,andattemptedtodistinguishthatcase,concludingthattheconstitutionalityofthefederalstatuteandregulationswerenotatissueinMilwaukeeCountyPavers.544F.Supp.2dat1340.In2007,theSeventhCircuitfollowedupthecritiquesmadeinWesternStatesPavingintheNorthernContractingdecision.Id.TheSeventhCircuitinNorthernContractingconcludedthatthemajorityinWesternStatesPavingmisreaditsdecisioninMilwaukeeCountyPaversasdidtheEighthCircuitCourtofAppealsinSherbrooke.544F.Supp.2dat1340,citingNorthernContracting,473
![Page 359: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/359.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 233
F.3dat722,n.5.ThedistrictcourtinBrowardCountypointedoutthattheSeventhCircuitinNorthernContractingemphasizedagainthatthestateDOTisactingasaninstrumentoffederalpolicy,andaplaintiffcannotcollaterallyattackthefederalregulationsthroughachallengetothestateDOT’sprogram.544F.Supp.2dat1340,citingNorthernContracting,473F.3dat722.
ThedistrictcourtinBrowardCountystatedthatothercircuitshaveconcurredwiththisapproach,includingtheSixthCircuitCourtofAppealsdecisioninTennesseeAsphaltCompanyv.Farris,942F.2d969(6thCir.1991).544F.Supp.2dat1340.ThedistrictcourtinBrowardCountyheldthattheTenthCircuitCourtofAppealstookasimilarapproachinEllisv.Skinner,961F.2d912(10thCir.1992).544F.Supp.2dat1340.ThedistrictcourtinBrowardCountyheldthattheseCircuitCourtsofAppealhaveconcludedthat“whereastateorcountyfullycomplieswiththefederalregulations,itcannotbeenjoinedfromcarryingoutitsDBEprogram,becauseanysuchattackwouldsimplyconstituteanimpropercollateralattackontheconstitutionalityoftheregulations.”544F.Supp.2dat1340‐41.
ThedistrictcourtinBrowardCountyheldthatitagreedwiththeapproachtakenbytheSeventhCircuitCourtofAppealsinMilwaukeeCountyPaversandNorthernContractingandconcludedthat“theappropriatefactualinquiryintheinstantcaseiswhetherornotBrowardCountyhasfullycompliedwiththefederalregulationsinimplementingitsDBEprogram.”544F.Supp.2dat1341.Itissignificanttonotethattheplaintiffsdidnotchallengetheas‐appliedconstitutionalityofthefederalregulationsthemselves,butratherfocusedtheirchallengeontheconstitutionalityofBrowardCounty’sactionsincarryingouttheDBEprogram.544F.Supp.2dat1341.ThedistrictcourtinBrowardCountyheldthatthistypeofchallengeis“simplyanimpermissiblecollateralattackontheconstitutionalityofthestatuteandimplementingregulations.”Id.
ThedistrictcourtconcludedthatitwouldapplythecaselawassetoutintheSeventhCircuitCourtofAppealsandconcurringcircuits,andthatthetrialinthiscasewouldbeconductedsolelyforthepurposeofestablishingwhetherornottheCountyhascompliedfullywiththefederalregulationsinimplementingitsDBEprogram.544F.Supp.2dat1341.
Subsequently,therewasaStipulationofDismissalfiledbyallpartiesinthedistrictcourt,andanOrderofDismissalwasfiledwithoutatrialofthecaseinNovember2008.
17. Western States Paving Co. v. Washington DOT, USDOT & FHWA, 2006 WL 1734163 (W.D. Wash. June 23, 2006) (unpublished opinion)
ThiscasewasbeforethedistrictcourtpursuanttotheNinthCircuit’sremandorderinWesternStatesPavingCo.WashingtonDOT,USDOT,andFHWA,407F.3d983(9thCir.2005),cert.denied,546U.S.1170(2006).Inthisdecision,thedistrictcourtadjudicatedcrossMotionsforSummaryJudgmentonplaintiff’sclaimforinjunctionandfordamagesunder42U.S.C.§§1981,1983,and§2000d.
BecausetheWSDOTvoluntarilydiscontinueditsDBEprogramaftertheNinthCircuitdecision,supra,thedistrictcourtdismissedplaintiff’sclaimforinjunctivereliefasmoot.Thecourtfound“itisabsolutelyclearinthiscasethatWSDOTwillnotresumeorcontinuetheactivitytheNinthCircuitfoundunlawfulinWesternStates,”andcitedspecificallytotheinformationallettersWSDOTsenttocontractorsinformingthemoftheterminationoftheprogram.
![Page 360: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/360.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 234
Second,thecourtdismissedWesternStatesPaving’sclaimsunder42U.S.C.§§1981,1983,and2000dagainstClarkCountyandtheCityofVancouverholdingneithertheCityortheCountyactedwiththerequisitediscriminatoryintent.ThecourtheldtheCountyandtheCityweremerelyimplementingtheWSDOT’sunlawfulDBEprogramandtheiractionsinthisrespectwereinvoluntaryandrequirednoindependentactivity.ThecourtalsonotedthattheCountyandtheCitywerenotpartiestotheprecisediscriminatoryactionsatissueinthecase,whichoccurredduetotheconductofthe“Statedefendants.”Specifically,theWSDOT—andnottheCountyortheCity—developedtheDBEprogramwithoutsufficientanecdotalandstatisticalevidence,andimproperlyreliedontheaffidavitsofcontractorsseekingDBEcertification“whoaverredthattheyhadbeensubjectto‘generalsocietaldiscrimination.’”
Third,thecourtdismissedplaintiff’s42U.S.C.§§1981and1983claimsagainstWSDOT,findingthembarredbytheEleventhAmendmentsovereignimmunitydoctrine.However,thecourtallowedplaintiff’s42U.S.C.§2000dclaimtoproceedagainstWSDOTbecauseitwasnotsimilarlybarred.ThecourtheldthatCongresshadconditionedthereceiptoffederalhighwayfundsoncompliancewithTitleVI(42U.S.C.§2000detseq.)andthewaiverofsovereignimmunityfromclaimsarisingunderTitleVI.Section2001specificallyprovidesthat“aStateshallnotbeimmuneundertheEleventhAmendmentoftheConstitutionoftheUnitedStatesfromsuitinFederalcourtforaviolationof…TitleVI.”ThecourtheldthatthislanguageputtheWSDOTonnoticethatitfacedprivatecausesofactionintheeventofnoncompliance.
ThecourtheldthatWSDOT’sDBEprogramwasnotnarrowlytailoredtoserveacompellinggovernmentinterest.Thecourtstressedthatdiscriminatoryintentisanessentialelementofaplaintiff’sclaimunderTitleVI.TheWSDOTarguedthatevenifsovereignimmunitydidnotbarplaintiff’s§2000dclaim,WSDOTcouldbeheldliablefordamagesbecausetherewasnoevidencethatWSDOTstaffknewoforconsciouslyconsideredplaintiff’sracewhencalculatingtheannualutilizationgoal.Thecourtheldthatsincethepolicywasnot“faciallyneutral”—andwasinfact“specificallyraceconscious”—anyresultingdiscriminationwasthereforeintentional,whetherthereasonfortheclassificationwasbenignoritspurposeremedial.Assuch,WSDOT’sprogramwassubjecttostrictscrutiny.
InorderforthecourttoupholdtheDBEprogramasconstitutional,WSDOThadtoshowthattheprogramservedacompellinginterestandwasnarrowlytailoredtoachievethatgoal.ThecourtfoundthattheNinthCircuithadalreadyconcludedthattheprogramwasnotnarrowlytailoredandtherecordwasdevoidofanyevidencesuggestingthatminoritiescurrentlysufferorhavesuffereddiscriminationintheWashingtontransportationcontractingindustry.ThecourtthereforedeniedWSDOT’sMotionforSummaryJudgmentonthe§2000dclaim.TheremedyavailabletoWesternStatesremainsforfurtheradjudicationandthecaseiscurrentlypending.
18. Northern Contracting, Inc. v. Illinois, 2005 WL 2230195 (N.D. Ill., 2005), affirmed, 473 F.3d 715 (7th Cir. 2007)
Thisdecisionisthedistrictcourt’sorderthatwasaffirmedbytheSeventhCircuitCourtofAppeals.ThisdecisionisinstructiveinthatitisoneoftherecentcasestoaddressthevalidityoftheFederalDBEProgramandlocalandstategovernments’implementationoftheprogramasrecipientsoffederalfunds.Thecasealsoisinstructiveinthatthecourtsetforthadetailed
![Page 361: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/361.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 235
analysisofrace‐,ethnicity‐,andgender‐neutralmeasuresaswellasevidentiarydatarequiredtosatisfyconstitutionalscrutiny.
Thedistrictcourtconductedatrialafterdenyingtheparties’MotionsforSummaryJudgmentinNorthernContracting,Inc.v.StateofIllinois,IllinoisDOT,andUSDOT,2004WL422704(N.D.Ill.March3,2004),discussedinfra.Thefollowingsummarizestheopinionofthedistrictcourt.
NorthernContracting,Inc.(the“plaintiff”),anIllinoishighwaycontractor,suedtheStateofIllinois,theIllinoisDOT,theUnitedStatesDOT,andfederalandstateofficialsseekingadeclarationthatfederalstatutoryprovisions,thefederalimplementingregulations(“TEA‐21”),thestatestatuteauthorizingtheDBEprogram,andtheIllinoisDBEprogramitselfwereunlawfulandunconstitutional.2005WL2230195at*1(N.D.Ill.Sept,8,2005).
UnderTEA‐21,arecipientoffederalfundsisrequiredtomeetthe“maximumfeasibleportion”ofitsDBEgoalthroughrace‐neutralmeans.Id.at*4(citingregulations).IfarecipientprojectsthatitcannotmeetitsoverallDBEgoalthroughrace‐neutralmeans,itmustestablishcontractgoalstotheextentnecessarytoachievetheoverallDBEgoal.Id.(citingregulation).[ThecourtprovidedanoverviewofthepertinentregulationsincludingcompliancerequirementsandqualificationsforDBEstatus.]
Statistical evidence. Tocalculateits2005DBEparticipationgoals,IDOTfollowedthetwo‐stepprocesssetforthinTEA‐21:(1)calculationofabasefigurefortherelativeavailabilityofDBEs,and(2)considerationofapossibleadjustmentofthebasefiguretoreflecttheeffectsoftheDBEprogramandthelevelofparticipationthatwouldbeexpectedbutfortheeffectsofpastandpresentdiscrimination.Id.at*6.IDOTengagedinastudytocalculateitsbasefigureandconductacustomcensustodeterminewhetheramorereliablemethodofcalculationexistedasopposedtoitspreviousmethodofreviewingabidder’slist.Id.
IncompliancewithTEA‐21,IDOTusedastudytoevaluatethebasefigureusingasix‐partanalysis:(1)thestudyidentifiedtheappropriateandrelevantgeographicmarketforitscontractingactivityanditsprimecontractors;(2)thestudyidentifiedtherelevantproductmarketsinwhichIDOTanditsprimecontractorscontract;(3)thestudysoughttoidentifyallavailablecontractorsandsubcontractorsintherelevantindustrieswithinIllinoisusingDun&Bradstreet’sMarketplace;(4)thestudycollectedlistsofDBEsfromIDOTand20otherpublicandprivateagencies;(5)thestudyattemptedtocorrectforthepossibilitythatcertainbusinesseslistedasDBEswerenolongerqualifiedor,alternatively,businessesnotlistedasDBEsbutqualifiedassuchunderthefederalregulations;and(6)thestudyattemptedtocorrectforthepossibilitythatnotallDBEbusinesseswerelistedinthevariousdirectories.Id.at*6‐7.Thestudyutilizedastandardstatisticalsamplingproceduretocorrectforthelattertwobiases.Id.at*7.Thestudythuscalculatedaweightedaveragebasefigureof22.7percent.Id.
IDOTthenadjustedthebasefigurebasedupontwodisparitystudiesandsomereportsconsideringwhethertheDBEavailabilityfigureswereartificiallylowduetotheeffectsofpastdiscrimination.Id.at*8.OnestudyexamineddisparitiesinearningsandbusinessformationratesasbetweenDBEsandtheirwhitemale‐ownedcounterparts.Id.AnotherstudyincludedasurveyreportingthatDBEsarerarelyutilizedinnon‐goalsprojects.Id.
![Page 362: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/362.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 236
IDOTconsideredthreereportspreparedbyexpertwitnesses.Id.at*9.Thefirstreportconcludedthatminority‐andwomen‐ownedbusinesseswereunderutilizedrelativetotheircapacityandthatsuchunderutilizationwasduetodiscrimination.Id.Thesecondreportconcluded,aftercontrollingforrelevantvariablessuchascreditworthiness,“thatminoritiesandwomenarelesslikelytoformbusinesses,andthatwhentheydoformbusinesses,thosebusinessesachievelowerearningsthandidbusinessesownedbywhitemales.”Id.Thethirdreport,againcontrollingforrelevantvariables(education,age,maritalstatus,industryandwealth),concludedthatminority‐andfemale‐ownedbusinesses’formationratesarelowerthanthoseoftheirwhitemalecounterparts,andthatsuchbusinessesengageinadisproportionateamountofgovernmentworkandcontractsasaresultoftheirinabilitytoobtainprivatesectorwork.Id.
IDOTalsoconductedaseriesofpublichearingsinwhichanumberofDBEownerswhotestifiedthatthey“wererarely,ifever,solicitedtobidonprojectsnotsubjecttodisadvantaged‐firmhiringgoals.”Id.Additionally,witnessesidentified20primecontractorsinIDOTDistrict1alonewhorarelyorneversolicitedbidsfromDBEsonnon‐goalsprojects.Id.TheprimecontractorsdidnotrespondtoIDOT’srequestsforinformationconcerningtheirutilizationofDBEs.Id.
Finally,IDOTreviewedunremediatedmarketdatafromfourdifferentmarkets(theIllinoisStateTollHighwayAuthority,theMissouriDOT,CookCounty’spublicconstructioncontracts,anda“non‐goals”experimentconductedbyIDOTbetween2001and2002),andconsideredpastutilizationofDBEsonIDOTprojects.Id.at*11.Afteranalyzingallofthedata,thestudyrecommendedanupwardadjustmentto27.51percent.However,IDOTdecidedtomaintainitsfigureat22.77percent.Id.
IDOT’srepresentativetestifiedthattheDBEprogramwasadministeredona“contract‐by‐contractbasis.”Id.ShetestifiedthatDBEgoalshavenoeffectontheawardofprimecontractsbutthatcontractsareawardedexclusivelytothe“lowestresponsiblebidder.”IDOTalsoallowedcontractorstopetitionforawaiverofindividualcontractgoalsincertainsituations(e.g.,wherethecontractorhasbeenunabletomeetthegoaldespitehavingmadereasonablegoodfaithefforts).Id.at*12.Between2001and2004,IDOTreceivedwaiverrequestson8.53percentofitscontractsandgrantedthreeoutoffour;IDOTalsoprovidedanappealprocedureforadenialfromawaiverrequest.Id.
IDOTimplementedanumberofrace‐andgender‐neutralmeasuresbothinitsfiscalyear2005planandinresponsetothedistrictcourt’searliersummaryjudgmentorder,including:
1. A“promptpaymentprovision”initscontracts,requiringthatsubcontractorsbepaidpromptlyaftertheycompletetheirwork,andprohibitingprimecontractorsfromdelayingsuchpayments;
2. AnextensiveoutreachprogramseekingtoattractandassistDBEandothersmallfirmsenterandachievesuccessintheindustry(includingretaininganetworkofconsultantstoprovidemanagement,technicalandfinancialassistancetosmallbusinesses,andsponsoringnetworkingsessionsthroughoutthestatetoacquaintsmallfirmswithlargercontractorsandtoencouragetheinvolvementofsmallfirmsinmajorconstructionprojects);
![Page 363: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/363.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 237
3. Reviewingthecriteriaforprequalificationtoreduceanyunnecessaryburdens;
4. “Unbundling”largecontracts;and
5. AllocatingsomecontractsforbiddingonlybyfirmsmeetingtheSBA’sdefinitionofsmallbusinesses.
Id.(internalcitationsomitted).IDOTwasalsointheprocessofimplementingbondingandfinancinginitiativestoassistemergingcontractorsobtainguaranteedbondingandlinesofcredit,andestablishingamentor‐protégéprogram.Id.
ThecourtfoundthatIDOTattemptedtoachievethe“maximumfeasibleportion”ofitsoverallDBEgoalthroughrace‐andgender‐neutralmeasures.Id.at*13.ThecourtfoundthatIDOTdeterminedthatrace‐andgender‐neutralmeasureswouldaccountfor6.43percentofitsDBEgoal,leaving16.34percenttobereachedusingrace‐andgender‐consciousmeasures.Id.
Anecdotal evidence. AnumberofDBEownerstestifiedtoinstancesofperceiveddiscriminationandtothebarrierstheyface.Id.TheDBEownersalsotestifiedtodifficultiesinobtainingworkintheprivatesectorand“unanimouslyreportedthattheywererarelyinvitedtobidonsuchcontracts.”Id.TheDBEownerstestifiedtoareluctancetosubmitunsolicitedbidsduetotheexpenseinvolvedandidentifiedspecificfirmsthatsolicitedbidsfromDBEsforgoalsprojectsbutnotfornon‐goalsprojects.Id.Anumberofthewitnessesalsotestifiedtospecificinstancesofdiscriminationinbidding,onspecificcontracts,andinthefinancingandinsurancemarkets.Id.at*13‐14.Onewitnessacknowledgedthatallsmallfirmsfacedifficultiesinthefinancingandinsurancemarkets,buttestifiedthatitisespeciallyburdensomeforDBEswho“frequentlyareforcedtopayhigherinsuranceratesduetoracialandgenderdiscrimination.”Id.at*14.TheDBEwitnessesalsotestifiedtheyhaveobstaclesinobtainingpromptpayment.Id.
Theplaintiffcalledanumberofnon‐DBEbusinessownerswhounanimouslytestifiedthattheysolicitbusinessequallyfromDBEsandnon‐DBEsonnon‐goalsprojects.Id.Somenon‐DBEfirmownerstestifiedthattheysolicitbidsfromDBEsonagoalsprojectforworktheywouldotherwisecompletethemselvesabsentthegoals;otherstestifiedthatthey“occasionallyawardworktoaDBEthatwasnotthelowbidderinordertoavoidscrutinyfromIDOT.”Id.Anumberofnon‐DBEfirmownersaccusedoffailingtosolicitbidsfromDBEsonnon‐goalsprojectstestifiedanddeniedtheallegations.Id.at*15.
Strict scrutiny. Thecourtappliedstrictscrutinytotheprogramasawhole(includingthegender‐basedpreferences).Id.at*16.Thecourt,however,setforthadifferentburdenofproof,findingthatthegovernmentmustdemonstrateidentifieddiscriminationwithspecificityandmusthavea“‘strongbasisinevidence’toconcludethatremedialactionwasnecessary,beforeitembarksonanaffirmativeactionprogram…Ifthegovernmentmakessuchashowing,thepartychallengingtheaffirmativeactionplanbearsthe‘ultimateburden’ofdemonstratingtheunconstitutionalityoftheprogram.”Id.Thecourtheldthatchallengingparty’sburden“canonlybemetbypresentingcredibleevidencetorebutthegovernment’sproffereddata.”Id.at*17.
Tosatisfystrictscrutiny,thecourtfoundthatIDOTdidnotneedtodemonstrateanindependentcompellinginterest;however,aspartofthenarrowlytailoredprong,IDOTneededtoshow“that
![Page 364: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/364.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 238
thereisademonstrableneedfortheimplementationoftheFederalDBEProgramwithinitsjurisdiction.”Id.at*16.
ThecourtfoundthatIDOTpresented“anabundance”ofevidencedocumentingthedisparitiesbetweenDBEsandnon‐DBEsintheconstructionindustry.Id.at*17.Theplaintiffarguedthatthestudywas“erroneousbecauseitfailedtolimititsDBEavailabilityfigurestothosefirms…registeredandpre‐qualifiedwithIDOT.”Id.TheplaintiffalsoallegedthecalculationsoftheDBEutilizationratewereincorrectbecausethedataincludedIDOTsubcontractsandprimecontracts,despitethefactthatthelatterareawardedtothelowestbidderasamatteroflaw.Id.Accordingly,theplaintiffallegedthatIDOT’scalculationofDBEavailabilityandutilizationrateswasincorrect.Id.
Thecourtfoundthatotherjurisdictionshadutilizedthecustomcensusapproachwithoutsuccessfulchallenge.Id.at*18.Additionally,thecourtfound“thattheremedialnatureofthefederalstatutescounselsforthecastingofabroadernetwhenmeasuringDBEavailability.”Id.at*19.ThecourtfoundthatIDOTpresented“anarrayofstatisticalstudiesconcludingthatDBEsfacedisproportionatehurdlesinthecredit,insurance,andbondingmarkets.”Id.at*21.Thecourtalsofoundthatthestatisticalstudieswereconsistentwiththeanecdotalevidence.Id.Thecourtdidfind,however,that“therewasnoevidenceofevenasingleinstanceinwhichaprimecontractorfailedtoawardajobtoaDBEthatofferedthelowbid.This…is[also]supportedbythestatisticaldata…whichshowsthatatleastatthelevelofsubcontracting,DBEsaregenerallyutilizedatarateinlinewiththeirability.”Id.at*21,n.31.Additionally,IDOTdidnotverifytheanecdotaltestimonyofDBEfirmownerswhotestifiedtobarriersinfinancingandbonding.However,thecourtfoundthatsuchverificationwasunnecessary.Id.at*21,n.32.
Thecourtfurtherfound:
That such discrimination indirectly affects the ability of DBEs to compete forprimecontracts,despitethefactthattheyareawardedsolelyonthebasisoflowbid,cannotbedoubted:‘[E]xperienceandsizearenotrace‐andgender‐neutralvariables…[DBE]constructionfirmsaregenerallysmallerandlessexperiencedbecauseofindustrydiscrimination.’
Id.at*21,citingConcreteWorksofColorado,Inc.v.CityandCountyofDenver,321F.3d950(10thCir.2003).
ThepartiesstipulatedtothefactthatDBEutilizationgoalsexceedDBEavailabilityfor2003and2004.Id.at*22.IDOTalleged,andthecourtsofound,thatthehighutilizationongoalsprojectswasduetothesuccessoftheDBEprogram,andnottoanabsenceofdiscrimination.Id.ThecourtfoundthatthestatisticaldisparitiescoupledwiththeanecdotalevidenceindicatedthatIDOT’sfiscalyear2005goalwasa“‘plausiblelower‐boundestimate’ofDBEparticipationintheabsenceofdiscrimination.”Id.ThecourtfoundthattheplaintiffdidnotpresentpersuasiveevidencetocontradictorexplainIDOT’sdata.Id.
Theplaintiffarguedthatevenifacceptedatfacevalue,IDOT’smarketplacedatadidnotsupporttheimpositionofrace‐andgender‐consciousremediesbecausetherewasnoevidenceofdirectdiscriminationbyprimecontractors.Id.ThecourtfoundfirstthatIDOT’sindirectevidenceof
![Page 365: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/365.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 239
discriminationinthebonding,financing,andinsurancemarketswassufficienttoestablishacompellingpurpose.Id.Second,thecourtfound:
[M]ore importantly, plaintiff fails to acknowledge that, in enacting its DBEprogram,IDOTactednottoremedyitsownpriordiscriminatorypractices,butpursuanttofederallaw,whichbothauthorizedandrequiredIDOTtoremediatetheeffectsofprivatediscriminationonfederally‐fundedhighwaycontracts.Thisis a fundamental distinction … [A] state or local government need notindependentlyidentifyacompellinginterestwhenitsactionscomeinthecourseofenforcingafederalstatute.
Id.at*23.
ThecourtdistinguishedBuildersAss’nofGreaterChicagov.CountyofCook,123F.Supp.2d1087(N.D.Ill.2000),aff’d256F.3d642(7thCir.2001),notingthattheprograminthatcasewasnotfederally‐funded.Id.at*23,n.34.
Thecourtalsofoundthat“IDOThasdoneitsbesttomaximizetheportionofitsDBEgoal”throughrace‐andgender‐neutralmeasures,includinganti‐discriminationenforcementandsmallbusinessinitiatives.Id.at*24.Theanti‐discriminationeffortsincluded:aninternetwebsitewhereaDBEcanfileanadministrativecomplaintifitbelievesthataprimecontractorisdiscriminatingonthebasisofraceorgenderintheawardofsub‐contracts;andrequiringcontractorsseekingprequalificationtomaintainandproducesolicitationrecordsonallprojects,bothpublicandprivate,withandwithoutgoals,aswellasrecordsofthebidsreceivedandaccepted.Id.Thesmallbusinessinitiativeincluded:“unbundling”largecontracts;allocatingsomecontractsforbiddingonlybyfirmsmeetingtheSBA’sdefinitionofsmallbusinesses;a“promptpaymentprovision”initscontracts,requiringthatsubcontractorsbepaidpromptlyaftertheycompletetheirwork,andprohibitingprimecontractorsfromdelayingsuchpayments;andanextensiveoutreachprogramseekingtoattractandassistDBEandothersmallfirmsDBEandothersmallfirmsenterandachievesuccessintheindustry(includingretaininganetworkofconsultantstoprovidemanagement,technicalandfinancialassistancetosmallbusinesses,andsponsoringnetworkingsessionsthroughoutthestatetoacquaintsmallfirmswithlargercontractorsandtoencouragetheinvolvementofsmallfirmsinmajorconstructionprojects).Id.
Thecourtfound“[s]ignificantly,plaintiffdidnotquestiontheefficacyorsincerityoftheserace‐andgender‐neutralmeasures.”Id.at*25.Additionally,thecourtfoundtheDBEprogramhadsignificantflexibilityinthatutilizedcontract‐by‐contractgoalsetting(withoutafixedDBEparticipationminimum)andcontainedwaiverprovisions.Id.ThecourtfoundthatIDOTapproved70percentofwaiverrequestsalthoughwaiverswererequestedononly8percentofallcontracts.Id.,citingAdarandConstructors,Inc.v.Slater“AdarandVII”,228F.3d1147,1177(10thCir.2000)(citingforthepropositionthatflexibilityandwaiverarecriticallyimportant).
ThecourtheldthatIDOT’sDBEplanwasnarrowlytailoredtothegoalofremedyingtheeffectsofracialandgenderdiscriminationintheconstructionindustry,andwasthereforeconstitutional.
![Page 366: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/366.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 240
19. Northern Contracting, Inc. v. State of Illinois, Illinois DOT, and USDOT, 2004 WL 422704 (N.D. Ill. March 3, 2004)
ThisistheearlierdecisioninNorthernContracting,Inc.,2005WL2230195(N.D.Ill.Sept.8,2005),seeabove,whichresultedintheremandofthecasetoconsidertheimplementationoftheFederalDBEProgrambytheIDOT.ThiscaseinvolvesthechallengetotheFederalDBEProgram.TheplaintiffcontractorsuedtheIDOTandtheUSDOTchallengingthefacialconstitutionalityoftheFederalDBEProgram(TEA‐21and49CFRPart26)aswellastheimplementationoftheFederalProgrambytheIDOT(i.e.,theIDOTDBEProgram).ThecourtheldvalidtheFederalDBEProgram,findingthereisacompellinggovernmentalinterestandthefederalprogramisnarrowlytailored.ThecourtalsoheldthereareissuesoffactregardingwhetherIDOT’sDBEProgramisnarrowlytailoredtoachievethefederalgovernment’scompellinginterest.ThecourtdeniedtheMotionsforSummaryJudgmentfiledbytheplaintiffandbyIDOT,findingtherewereissuesofmaterialfactrelatingtoIDOT’simplementationoftheFederalDBEProgram.
ThecourtinNorthernContracting,heldthatthereisanidentifiedcompellinggovernmentalinterestforimplementingtheFederalDBEProgramandthattheFederalDBEProgramisnarrowlytailoredtofurtherthatinterest.Therefore,thecourtgrantedtheFederaldefendants’MotionforSummaryJudgmentchallengingthevalidityoftheFederalDBEProgram.Inthisconnection,thedistrictcourtfollowedthedecisionsandanalysisinSherbrookeTurf,Inc.v.MinnesotaDepartmentofTransportation,345F.3d964(8thCir.2003)andAdarandConstructors,Inc.v.Slater,228F.3d1147(10thCir.2000)(“AdarandVII”),cert.grantedthendismissedasimprovidentlygranted,532U.S.941,534U.S.103(2001).Thecourtheld,likethesetwoCourtsofAppealsthathaveaddressedthisissue,thatCongresshadastrongbasisinevidencetoconcludethattheDBEProgramwasnecessarytoredressprivatediscriminationinfederally‐assistedhighwaysubcontracting.ThecourtagreedwiththeAdarandVIIandSherbrookeTurfcourtsthattheevidencepresentedtoCongressissufficienttoestablishacompellinggovernmentalinterest,andthatthecontractorshadnotmettheirburdenofintroducingcredibleparticularizedevidencetorebuttheGovernment’sinitialshowingoftheexistenceofacompellinginterestinremedyingthenationwideeffectsofpastandpresentdiscriminationinthefederalconstructionprocurementsubcontractingmarket.2004WL422704at*34,citingAdarandVII,228F.3dat1175.
Inaddition,thecourtanalyzedthesecondprongofthestrictscrutinytest,whetherthegovernmentprovidedsufficientevidencethatitsprogramisnarrowlytailored.Inmakingthisdetermination,thecourtlookedatseveralfactors,suchastheefficacyofalternativeremedies;theflexibilityanddurationoftherace‐consciousremedies,includingtheavailabilityofwaiverprovisions;therelationshipsbetweenthenumericalgoalsandrelevantlabormarket;theimpactoftheremedyonthirdparties;andwhethertheprogramisover‐or‐under‐inclusive.Thenarrowtailoringanalysiswithregardtotheas‐appliedchallengefocusedonIDOT’simplementationoftheFederalDBEProgram.
First,thecourtheldthattheFederalDBEProgramdoesnotmandatetheuseofrace‐consciousmeasuresbyrecipientsoffederaldollars,butinfactrequiresonlythatthegoalreflecttherecipient’sdeterminationofthelevelofDBEparticipationitwouldexpectabsenttheeffectsofthediscrimination.49CFR§26.45(b).Thecourtrecognized,asfoundintheSherbrookeTurfandAdarandVIIcases,thattheFederalRegulationsplacestrongemphasisontheuseofrace‐neutral
![Page 367: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/367.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 241
meanstoincreaseminoritybusinessparticipationingovernmentcontracting,thatalthoughnarrowtailoringdoesnotrequireexhaustionofeveryconceivablerace‐neutralalternative,itdoesrequire“serious,goodfaithconsiderationofworkablerace‐neutralalternatives.”2004WL422704at*36,citingandquotingSherbrookeTurf,345F.3dat972,quotingGrutterv.Bollinger,539U.S.306(2003).ThecourtheldthattheFederalregulations,whichprohibittheuseofquotasandseverelylimittheuseofset‐asides,meetthisrequirement.ThecourtagreedwiththeAdarandVIIandSherbrookeTurfcourtsthattheFederalDBEProgramdoesrequirerecipientstomakeaseriousgoodfaithconsiderationofworkablerace‐neutralalternativesbeforeturningtorace‐consciousmeasures.
Second,thecourtfoundthatbecausetheFederalDBEProgramissubjecttoperiodicreauthorization,andrequiresrecipientsofFederaldollarstoreviewtheirprogramsannually,theFederalDBEschemeisappropriatelylimitedtolastnolongerthannecessary.
Third,thecourtheldthattheFederalDBEProgramisflexibleformanyreasons,includingthatthepresumptionthatwomenandminorityaresociallydisadvantagedisdeemedrebuttedifanindividual’spersonalnetworthexceeds$750,000.00,andafirmownedbyindividualwhoisnotpresumptivelydisadvantagedmayneverthelessqualifyforsuchstatusifthefirmcandemonstratethatitsownersaresociallyandeconomicallydisadvantaged.49CFR§26.67(b)(1)(d).ThecourtfoundotheraspectsoftheFederalRegulationsprovideampleflexibility,includingrecipientsmayobtainwaiversorexemptionsfromanyrequirements.RecipientsarenotrequiredtosetacontractgoaloneveryUSDOT‐assistedcontract.Ifarecipientestimatesthatitcanmeettheentiretyofitsoverallgoalsforagivenyearthroughrace‐neutralmeans,itmustimplementtheProgramwithoutsettingcontractgoalsduringtheyear.Ifduringthecourseofanyyearinwhichitisusingcontractgoalsarecipientdeterminesthatitwillexceeditsoverallgoals,itmustadjusttheuseofrace‐consciouscontractgoalsaccordingly.49CFR§26.51(e)(f).RecipientsalsoadministeringaDBEProgramingoodfaithcannotbepenalizedforfailingtomeettheirDBEgoals,andarecipientmayterminateitsDBEProgramifitmeetsitsannualoverallgoalthroughrace‐neutralmeansfortwoconsecutiveyears.49CFR§26.51(f).Further,arecipientmayawardacontracttoabidder/offerorthatdoesnotmeettheDBEParticipationgoalssolongasthebidderhasmadeadequategoodfaitheffortstomeetthegoals.49CFR§26.53(a)(2).Theregulationsalsoprohibittheuseofquotas.49CFR§26.43.
Fourth,thecourtagreedwiththeSherbrookeTurfcourt’sassessmentthattheFederalDBEProgramrequiresrecipientstobaseDBEgoalsonthenumberofready,willingandabledisadvantagedbusinessinthelocalmarket,andthatthisexerciserequiresrecipientstoestablishrealisticgoalsforDBEparticipationintherelevantlabormarkets.
Fifth,thecourtfoundthattheDBEProgramdoesnotimposeanunreasonableburdenonthirdparties,includingnon‐DBEsubcontractorsandtaxpayers.ThecourtfoundthattheFederalDBEProgramisalimitedandproperlytailoredremedytocuretheeffectsofpriordiscrimination,asharingoftheburdenbypartiessuchasnon‐DBEsisnotimpermissible.
Finally,thecourtfoundthattheFederalDBEProgramwasnotover‐inclusivebecausetheregulationsdonotprovidethateverywomanandeverymemberofaminoritygroupisdisadvantaged.Preferencesarelimitedtosmallbusinesseswithaspecificaverageannualgrossreceiptoverthreefiscalyearsof$16.6millionorless(atthetimeofthisdecision),and
![Page 368: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/368.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 242
businesseswhoseowners’personalnetworthexceed$750,000.00areexcluded.49CFR§26.67(b)(1).Inaddition,afirmownedbyawhitemalemayqualifyassociallyandeconomicallydisadvantaged.49CFR§26.67(d).
ThecourtanalyzedtheconstitutionalityoftheIDOTDBEProgram.ThecourtadoptedthereasoningoftheEighthCircuitinSherbrookeTurf,thatarecipient’simplementationoftheFederalDBEProgrammustbeanalyzedunderthenarrowtailoringanalysisbutnotthecompellinginterestinquiry.Therefore,thecourtagreedwithSherbrookeTurfthatarecipientneednotestablishadistinctcompellinginterestbeforeimplementingtheFederalDBEProgram,butdidconcludethatarecipient’simplementationoftheFederalDBEProgrammustbenarrowlytailored.ThecourtfoundthatissuesoffactremainintermsofthevalidityoftheIDOT’sDBEProgramasimplementedintermsofwhetheritwasnarrowlytailoredtoachievetheFederalGovernment’scompellinginterest.Thecourt,therefore,deniedthecontractorplaintiff’sMotionforSummaryJudgmentandtheIllinoisDOT’sMotionforSummaryJudgment.
20. Sherbrooke Turf, Inc. v. Minnesota DOT, 2001 WL 1502841, No. 00‐CV‐1026 (D. Minn. 2001) (unpublished opinion), affirmed 345 F.3d 964 (8th Cir. 2003)
SherbrookeinvolvedalandscapingservicecontractorownedandoperatedbyCaucasianmales.ThecontractorsuedtheMinnesotaDOTclaimingtheFederalDBEprovisionsoftheTEA‐21areunconstitutional.Sherbrookechallengedthe“federalaffirmativeactionprograms,”theUSDOTimplementingregulations,andtheMinnesotaDOT’sparticipationintheDBEProgram.TheUSDOTandtheFHWAintervenedasFederaldefendantsinthecase.Sherbrooke,2001WL1502841at*1.
TheUnitedStatesDistrictCourtinSherbrookereliedsubstantiallyontheTenthCircuitCourtofAppealsdecisioninAdarandConstructors,Inc.v.Slater,228F.3d1147(10thCir.2000),inholdingthattheFederalDBEProgramisconstitutional.Thedistrictcourtaddressedtheissueof“randominclusion”ofvariousgroupsasbeingwithinthePrograminconnectionwithwhethertheFederalDBEProgramis“narrowlytailored.”ThecourtheldthatCongresscannotenactanationalprogramtoremedydiscriminationwithoutrecognizingclassesofpeoplewhosehistoryhasshownthemtobesubjecttodiscriminationandallowingstatestoincludethosepeopleinitsDBEProgram.
ThecourtheldthattheFederalDBEProgramattemptstoavoidthe“potentiallyinvidiouseffectsofprovidingblanketbenefitstominorities”inpart,
byrestrictingastate’sDBEpreferencetoidentifiedgroupsactuallyappearinginthetargetstate. Inpractice, thismeansMinnesotacanonlycertifymembersofoneoranothergroupaspotentialDBEsiftheyarepresentinthelocalmarket.Thisminimizesthechancethatindividuals—simplyonthebasisoftheirbirth—willbenefit fromMinnesota’sDBEprogram. Ifagroup isnotpresent in thelocalmarket, or if they are found in such small numbers that they cannot beexpected to be able to participate in the kinds of construction work TEA‐21covers,thatgroupwillnotbeincludedintheaccountingusedtosetMinnesota’soverallDBEcontractinggoal.
![Page 369: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/369.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 243
Sherbrooke,2001WL1502841at*10(D.Minn.).
Thecourtrejectedplaintiff’sclaimthattheMinnesotaDOTmustindependentlydemonstratehowitsprogramcomportswithCroson’sstrictscrutinystandard.Thecourtheldthatthe“Constitutioncallsoutfordifferentrequirementswhenastateimplementsafederalaffirmativeactionprogram,asopposedtothoseoccasionswhenastateorlocalityinitiatestheProgram.”Id.at*11(emphasisadded).ThecourtinafootnoteruledthatTEA‐21,beingafederalprogram,“relievesthestateofanyburdentoindependentlycarrythestrictscrutinyburden.”Id.at*11n.3.ThecourtheldstatesthatestablishDBEprogramsunderTEA‐21and49CFRPart26areimplementingaCongressionally‐requiredprogramandnotestablishingalocalone.Assuch,thecourtconcludedthatthestateneednotindependentlyproveitsDBEprogrammeetsthestrictscrutinystandard.Id.
21. Gross Seed Co. v. Nebraska Department of Roads, Civil Action File No. 4:00CV3073 (D. Neb. May 6, 2002), affirmed 345 F.3d 964 (8th Cir. 2003)
TheUnitedStatesDistrictCourtfortheDistrictofNebraskaheldinGrossSeedCo.v.Nebraska(withtheUSDOTandFHWAasInterveners),thattheFederalDBEProgram(codifiedat49CFRPart26)isconstitutional.ThecourtalsoheldthattheNebraskaDepartmentofRoads(“NebraskaDOR”)DBEProgramadoptedandimplementedsolelytocomplywiththeFederalDBEProgramis“approved”bythecourtbecausethecourtfoundthat49CFRPart26andTEA‐21wereconstitutional.
Thecourtconcluded,similartothecourtinSherbrookeTurf,thattheStateofNebraskadidnotneedtoindependentlyestablishthatitsprogrammetthestrictscrutinyrequirementbecausetheFederalDBEProgramsatisfiedthatrequirement,andwasthereforeconstitutional.ThecourtdidnotengageinathoroughanalysisorevaluationoftheNebraskaDORProgramoritsimplementationoftheFederalDBEProgram.ThecourtpointsoutthattheNebraskaDORProgramisadoptedincompliancewiththeFederalDBEProgram,andthattheUSDOTapprovedtheuseofNebraskaDOR’sproposedDBEgoalsforfiscalyear2001,pendingcompletionofUSDOT’sreviewofthosegoals.Significantly,however,thecourtinitsfindingsdoesnotethattheNebraskaDORestablisheditsoverallgoalsforfiscalyear2001baseduponanindependentavailability/disparitystudy.
ThecourtupheldtheconstitutionalityoftheFederalDBEProgrambyfindingtheevidencepresentedbythefederalgovernmentandthehistoryofthefederallegislationaresufficienttodemonstratethatpastdiscriminationdoesexist“intheconstructionindustry”andthatracialandgenderdiscrimination“withintheconstructionindustry”issufficienttodemonstrateacompellinginterestinindividualareas,suchashighwayconstruction.ThecourtheldthattheFederalDBEProgramwassufficiently“narrowlytailored”tosatisfyastrictscrutinyanalysisbasedagainontheevidencesubmittedbythefederalgovernmentastotheFederalDBEProgram.
![Page 370: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/370.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 244
G. Recent Decisions and Authorities Involving Federal Procurement That May Impact DBE and MBE/WBE Programs
1. Rothe Development, Inc. v. U.S. Dept. of Defense, U.S. Small Business Administration, et al., 836 F3d 57, 2016 WL 4719049 (D.C. Cir. 2016), cert. denied, 2017 WL 1375832 (2017), affirming on other grounds, Rothe Development, Inc. v. U.S. Dept. of Defense, U.S. Small Business Administration, et al., 107 F.Supp. 3d 183 (D.D.C. 2015)
Inasplitdecision,themajorityofathree‐judgepaneloftheUnitedStatesCourtofAppealsfortheDistrictofColumbiaCircuitupheldtheconstitutionalityofsection8(a)oftheSmallBusinessAct,whichwaschallengedbyPlaintiff‐AppellantRotheDevelopmentInc.(Rothe).RotheallegedthatthestatutorybasisoftheUnitedStatesSmallBusinessAdministration’s8(a)businessdevelopmentprogram(codifiedat15U.S.C.§637),violateditsrighttoequalprotectionundertheDueProcessClauseoftheFifthAmendment.836F.3d57,2016WL4719049,at*1.Rothecontendsthestatutecontainsaracialclassificationthatpresumescertainracialminoritiesareeligiblefortheprogram.Id.Thecourtheld,however,thatCongressconsideredandrejectedstatutorylanguagethatincludedaracialpresumption.Id.Congress,accordingtothecourt,choseinsteadtohingeparticipationintheprogramonthefaciallyrace‐neutralcriterionofsocialdisadvantage,whichitdefinedashavingsufferedracial,ethnic,orculturalbias.Id.
ThechallengedstatuteauthorizestheSmallBusinessAdministration(SBA)toenterintocontractswithotherfederalagencies,whichtheSBAthensubcontractstoeligiblesmallbusinessesthatcompeteforthesubcontractsinashelteredmarket.Id*1.Businessesownedby“sociallyandeconomicallydisadvantaged”individualsareeligibletoparticipateinthe8(a)program.Id.Thestatutedefinessociallydisadvantagedindividualsaspersons“whohavebeensubjectedtoracialorethnicprejudiceorculturalbiasbecauseoftheiridentityasamemberofagroupwithoutregardtotheirindividualqualities.”Id.,quoting15U.S.C.§627(a)(5).
The Section 8(a) statute is race‐neutral.ThecourtrejectedRothe’sallegations,findinginsteadthattheprovisionsoftheSmallBusinessActthatRothechallengesdonotontheirfaceclassifyindividualsbyrace.Id*1.ThecourtstatedthatSection8(a)usesfaciallyrace‐neutraltermsofeligibilitytoidentifyindividualvictimsofdiscrimination,prejudice,orbias,withoutpresumingthatmembersofcertainracial,ethnic,orculturalgroupsqualifyassuch.Id.Thecourtsaidthatmakesthisstatutedifferentfromotherstatutes,whichexpresslylimitparticipationincontractingprogramstoracialorethnicminoritiesorspecificallydirectthirdpartiestopresumethatmembersofcertainracialorethnicgroups,orminoritiesgenerally,areeligible.Id.
Incontrasttothestatute,thecourtfoundthattheSBA’sregulationimplementingthe8(a)programdoescontainaracialclassificationintheformofapresumptionthatanindividualwhoisamemberofoneoffivedesignatedracialgroupsissociallydisadvantaged.Id*2,citing13C.F.R.§124.103(b).Thiscase,thecourtheld,doesnotpermitittodecidewhethertherace‐basedregulatorypresumptionisconstitutionallysound,becauseRothehaselectedtochallengeonlythestatute.Id.Rothe’sdefinitionoftheracialclassificationitattacksinthiscase,accordingtothecourt,doesnotincludetheSBA’sregulation.Id.
![Page 371: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/371.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 245
Becausethecourtheldthestatute,unliketheregulation,lacksaracialclassification,andbecauseRothehasnotallegedthatthestatuteisotherwisesubjecttostrictscrutiny,thecourtappliedrational‐basisreview.Idat*2.Thecourtstatedthestatute“readilysurvives”therationalbasisscrutinystandards.Id*2.Thecourt,therefore,affirmedthejudgmentofthedistrictcourtgrantingsummaryjudgmenttotheSBAandtheDepartmentofDefense,albeitondifferentgrounds.Id.
Thus,thecourtheldthecentralquestiononappealiswhetherSection8(a)warrantsstrictjudicialscrutiny,whichthecourtnotedthepartiesandthedistrictcourtbelievethatitdid.Id*2.Rothe,thecourtsaid,advancedonlythetheorythatthestatute,onitsface,Section8(a)oftheSmallBusinessAct,containsaracialclassification.Id*2.
Thecourtfoundthatthedefinitionoftheterm“sociallydisadvantaged”doesnotcontainaracialclassificationbecauseitdoesnotdistributeburdensorbenefitsonthebasisofindividualclassifications,itisrace‐neutralonitsface,anditspeaksofindividualvictimsofdiscrimination.Id*3.Onitsface,thecourtstatedthetermenvisionsaindividual‐basedapproachthatfocusesonexperienceratherthanonagroupcharacteristic,andthestatuterecognizesthatnotallmembersofaminoritygrouphavenecessarilybeensubjectedtoracialorethnicprejudiceorculturalbias.Id.Thecourtsaidthatthestatutedefinitionoftheterm“socialdisadvantaged”doesnotprovideforpreferentialtreatmentbasedonanapplicant’srace,butratheronanindividualapplicant’sexperienceofdiscrimination.Id*3.
Thecourtdistinguishedcasesinvolvingsituationsinwhichdisadvantagednon‐minorityapplicantscouldnotparticipate,butthecourtsaidtheplaintermsofthestatutepermitindividualsinanyracetobeconsidered“sociallydisadvantaged.”Id*3.Thecourtnoteditskeypointisthatthestatuteiseasilyreadnottorequireanygroup‐basedracialorethnicclassification,statingthestatutedefinessociallydisadvantagedindividualsasthoseindividualswhohavebeensubjectedtoracialorethnicprejudiceorculturalbias,notthoseindividualswhoaremembersorgroupsthathavebeensubjectedtoprejudiceorbias.Id.
ThecourtpointedoutthattheSBA’simplementationofthestatute’sdefinitionmaybebasedonaracialclassificationiftheregulationscarryitoutinamannerthatgivespreferencebasedonraceinsteadofindividualexperience.Id*4.But,thecourtfound,RothehasexpresslydisclaimedanychallengetotheSBA’simplementationofthestatute,andasaresult,theonlyquestionbeforethemiswhetherthestatuteitselfclassifiesbasedonrace,whichthecourtheldmakesnosuchclassification.Id*4.Thecourtdeterminedthestatutorylanguagedoesnotcreateapresumptionthatamemberofaparticularracialorethnicgroupisnecessarilysociallydisadvantaged,northatawhitepersonisnot.Id*5.
Thedefinitionofsocialdisadvantage,accordingtothecourt,doesnotamounttoaracialclassification,foritultimatelyturnsonabusinessowner’sexperienceofdiscrimination.Id*6.Thestatutedoesnotinstructtheagencytolimitthefieldtocertainracialgroups,ortoracialgroupsingeneral,nordoesittelltheagencytopresumethatanyonewhoisamemberofanyparticulargroupis,bythatmembershipalone,sociallydisadvantaged.Id.
ThecourtnotedthattheSupremeCourtandthiscourt’sdiscussionsofthe8(a)programhaveidentifiedtheregulations,notthestatute,asthesourceofitsracialpresumption.Id*8.Thecourt
![Page 372: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/372.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 246
distinguishedSection8(d)oftheSmallBusinessActascontainingarace‐basedpresumption,butfoundinthe8(a)programtheSupremeCourthasexplainedthattheagency(notCongress)presumesthatcertainracialgroupsaresociallydisadvantaged.Id.at*7.
The SBA statute does not trigger strict scrutiny.Thecourtheldthatthestatutedoesnottriggerstrictscrutinybecauseitisrace‐neutral.Id*10.ThecourtpointedoutthatRothedoesnotarguethatthestatutecouldbesubjectedtostrictscrutiny,evenifitisfaciallyneutral,onthebasisthatCongressenacteditwithadiscriminatorypurpose.Id*9.IntheabsenceofsuchaclaimbyRothe,thecourtdetermineditwouldnotsubjectafaciallyrace‐neutralstatutetostrictscrutiny.Id.Theforeseeabilityofraciallydisparateimpact,withoutinvidiouspurpose,thecourtstated,doesnottriggerstrictconstitutionalscrutiny.Id.
Becausethestatutedoesnottriggerstrictscrutiny,thecourtfoundthatitneednotanddoesnotdecidewhetherthedistrictcourtcorrectlyconcludedthatthestatuteisnarrowlytailoredtomeetacompellinginterest.Id*10.Instead,thecourtconsideredwhetherthestatuteissupportedbyarationalbasis.Id.Thecourtheldthatitplainlyissupportedbyarationalbasis,becauseitbearsarationalrelationtosomelegitimateend.Id*10.
Thestatute,thecourtstated,aimstoremedytheeffectsofprejudiceandbiasthatimpedebusinessformationanddevelopmentandsuppressfaircompetitionforgovernmentcontracts.Id.Counteractingdiscrimination,thecourtfound,isalegitimateinterest,andincertaincircumstancesqualifiesascompelling.Id*11.Thestatutoryscheme,thecourtsaid,isrationallyrelatedtothatend.Id.
Thecourtdeclinedtoreviewthedistrictcourt’sadmissibilitydeterminationsastotheexpertwitnessesbecauseitstatedthatitwouldaffirmthedistrictcourt’sgrantofsummaryjudgmentevenifthedistrictcourtabuseditsdiscretioninmakingthosedeterminations.Id*11.Thecourtnotedtheexpertwitnesstestimonyisnotnecessaryto,norinconflictwith,itsconclusionthatSection8(a)issubjecttoandsurvivesrational‐basisreview.Id.
Other issues.Thecourtdeclinedtoreviewthedistrictcourt’sadmissibilitydeterminationsastotheexpertwitnessesbecauseitstatedthatitwouldaffirmthedistrictcourt’sgrantofsummaryjudgmentevenifthedistrictcourtabuseditsdiscretioninmakingthosedeterminations.Id*11.Thecourtnotedtheexpertwitnesstestimonyisnotnecessaryto,norinconflictwith,itsconclusionthatSection8(a)issubjecttoandsurvivesrational‐basisreview.Id.
Inaddition,thecourtrejectedRothe’scontentionthatSection8(a)isanunconstitutionaldelegationoflegislativepower.Id*11.BecausetheargumentispremisedontheideathatCongresscreatedaracialclassification,whichthecourthashelditdidnot,Rothe’salternativeargumentondelegationalsofails.Id.
Dissenting Opinion.Therewasadissentingopinionbyoneofthethreemembersofthecourt.ThedissentingjudgestatedinherviewthattheprovisionsoftheSmallBusinessActatissuearenotfaciallyrace‐neutral,butcontainaracialclassification.Id*12.ThedissentingjudgesaidthattheactprovidesmembersofcertainracialgroupsanadvantageinqualifyingforSection8(a)’scontractpreferencebyvirtueoftheirrace.Id*13.
![Page 373: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/373.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 247
ThedissentingopinionpointedoutthatallthepartiesandthedistrictcourtfoundthatstrictscrutinyshouldbeappliedindeterminingwhethertheSection8(a)programviolatesRothe’srighttoequalprotectionofthelaws.Id*16.Intheviewofthedissentingopinionthestatutorylanguageincludesaracialclassification,andtherefore,thestatuteshouldbesubjecttostrictscrutiny.Id*22.
2. Rothe Development Corp. v. U.S. Dept. of Defense, et al., 545 F.3d 1023 (Fed. Cir. 2008)
AlthoughthiscasedoesnotinvolvetheFederalDBEProgram(49CFRPart26),itisananalogouscasethatmayimpactthelegalanalysisandlawrelatedtothevalidityofprogramsimplementedbyrecipientsoffederalfunds,includingtheFederalDBEProgram.Additionally,itunderscorestherequirementthatrace‐,ethnic‐andgender‐basedprogramsofanynaturemustbesupportedbysubstantialevidence.InRothe,anunsuccessfulbidderonafederaldefensecontractbroughtsuitallegingthattheapplicationofanevaluationpreference,pursuanttoafederalstatute,toasmalldisadvantagedbidder(SDB)towhomacontractwasawarded,violatedtheEqualProtectionclauseoftheU.S.Constitution.ThefederalstatutechallengedisSection1207oftheNationalDefenseAuthorizationActof1987andasreauthorizedin2003.Thestatuteprovidesagoalthat5percentofthetotaldollaramountofdefensecontractsforeachfiscalyearwouldbeawardedtosmallbusinessesownedandcontrolledbysociallyandeconomicallydisadvantagesindividuals.10U.S.C.§2323.CongressauthorizedtheDepartmentofDefense(“DOD”)toadjustbidssubmittedbynon‐sociallyandeconomicallydisadvantagedfirmsupwardsby10percent(the“PriceEvaluationAdjustmentProgram”or“PEA”).
Thedistrictcourtheldthefederalstatute,asreauthorizedin2003,wasconstitutionalonitsface.Thecourtheldthe5percentgoalandthePEAprogramasreauthorizedin1992andappliedin1998wasunconstitutional.ThebasisofthedecisionwasthatCongressconsideredstatisticalevidenceofdiscriminationthatestablishedacompellinggovernmentalinterestinthereauthorizationofthestatuteandPEAprogramin2003.CongresshadnotdocumentedorconsideredsubstantialstatisticalevidencethattheDODdiscriminatedagainstminoritysmallbusinesseswhenitenactedthestatutein1992andreauthorizeditin1998.Theplaintiffappealedthedecision.
TheFederalCircuitfoundthatthe“analysisofthefacialconstitutionalityofanactislimitedtoevidencebeforeCongresspriortothedateofreauthorization.”413F.3d1327(Fed.Cir.2005)(affirminginpart,vacatinginpart,andremanding324F.Supp.2d840(W.D.Tex.2004).ThecourtlimiteditsreviewtowhetherCongresshadsufficientevidencein1992toreauthorizetheprovisionsin1207.Thecourtheldthatforevidencetoberelevanttoastrictscrutinyanalysis,“theevidencemustbeproventohavebeenbeforeCongresspriortoenactmentoftheracialclassification.”TheFederalCircuitheldthatthedistrictcourterredinrelyingonthestatisticalstudieswithoutfirstdeterminingwhetherthestudieswerebeforeCongresswhenitreauthorizedsection1207.TheFederalCircuitremandedthecaseanddirectedthedistrictcourttoconsiderwhetherthedatapresentedwassooutdatedthatitdidnotprovidetherequisitestrongbasisinevidencetosupportthereauthorizationofsection1207.
OnAugust10,2007theFederalDistrictCourtfortheWesternDistrictofTexasinRotheDevelopmentCorp.v.U.S.Dept.ofDefense,499F.Supp.2d775(W.D.Tex.Aug10,2007)issuedits
![Page 374: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/374.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 248
OrderonremandfromtheFederalCircuitCourtofAppealsdecisioninRothe,413F.3d1327(FedCir.2005).Thedistrictcourtupheldtheconstitutionalityofthe2006ReauthorizationofSection1207oftheNationalDefenseAuthorizationActof1987(10USC§2323),whichpermitstheU.S.DepartmentofDefensetoprovidepreferencesinselectingbidssubmittedbysmallbusinessesownedbysociallyandeconomicallydisadvantagedindividuals(“SDBs”).Thedistrictcourtfoundthe2006Reauthorizationofthe1207Programsatisfiedstrictscrutiny,holdingthatCongresshadacompellinginterestwhenitreauthorizedthe1207Programin2006,thattherewassufficientstatisticalandanecdotalevidencebeforeCongresstoestablishacompellinginterest,andthatthereauthorizationin2006wasnarrowlytailored.
Thedistrictcourt,amongitsmanyfindings,foundcertainevidencebeforeCongresswas“stale,”thattheplaintiff(Rothe)failedtorebutotherevidencewhichwasnotstale,andthatthedecisionsbytheEighth,NinthandTenthCircuitsinthedecisionsinConcreteWorks,AdarandConstructors,SherbrookeTurfandWesternStatesPaving(discussedaboveandbelow)wererelevanttotheevaluationofthefacialconstitutionalityofthe2006Reauthorization.
2007 Order of the District Court (499 F.Supp.2d 775). IntheSection1207Act,Congresssetagoalthat5percentofthetotaldollaramountofdefensecontractsforeachfiscalyearwouldbeawardedtosmallbusinessesownedandcontrolledbysociallyandeconomicallydisadvantagedindividuals.Inordertoachievethatgoal,CongressauthorizedtheDODtoadjustbidssubmittedbynon‐sociallyandeconomicallydisadvantagedfirmsupto10percent.10U.S.C.§2323(e)(3).Rothe,499F.Supp.2d.at782.PlaintiffRothedidnotqualifyasanSDBbecauseitwasownedbyaCaucasianfemale.AlthoughRothewastechnicallythelowestbidderonaDODcontract,itsbidwasadjustedupwardby10percent,andathirdparty,whoqualifiedasaSDB,becamethe“lowest”bidderandwasawardedthecontract.Id.Rotheclaimsthatthe1207ProgramisfaciallyunconstitutionalbecauseittakesraceintoconsiderationinviolationoftheEqualProtectioncomponentoftheDueProcessClauseoftheFifthAmendment.Id.at782‐83.Thedistrictcourt’sdecisiononlyreviewedthefacialconstitutionalityofthe2006Reauthorizationofthe2007Program.
ThedistrictcourtinitiallyrejectedsixlegalargumentsmadebyRotheregardingstrictscrutinyreviewbasedontherejectionofthesameargumentsbytheEighth,Ninth,andTenthCircuitCourtsofAppealintheSherbrookeTurf,WesternStatesPaving,ConcreteWorks,AdarandVIIcases,andtheFederalCircuitCourtofAppealinRothe.Rotheat825‐833.
ThedistrictcourtdiscussedandcitedthedecisionsinAdarandVII(2000),SherbrookeTurf(2003),andWesternStatesPaving(2005),asholdingthatCongresshadacompellinginterestineradicatingtheeconomicrootsofracialdiscriminationinhighwaytransportationprogramsfundedbyfederalmonies,andconcludingthattheevidencecitedbythegovernment,particularlythatcontainedinTheCompellingInterest(a.k.a.theAppendix),morethansatisfiedthegovernment’sburdenofproductionregardingthecompellinginterestforarace‐consciousremedy.Rotheat827.BecausetheUrbanInstituteReport,whichpresenteditsanalysisof39stateandlocaldisparitystudies,wascross‐referencedintheAppendix,thedistrictcourtfoundthecourtsinAdarandVII,SherbrookeTurf,andWesternStatesPaving,alsoreliedonitinsupportoftheircompellinginterestholding.Id.at827.
![Page 375: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/375.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 249
ThedistrictcourtalsofoundthattheTenthCircuitdecisioninConcreteWorksIV,321F.3d950(10thCir.2003),establishedlegalprinciplesthatarerelevanttothecourt’sstrictscrutinyanalysis.First,Rothe’sclaimsfordeclaratoryjudgmentontheracialconstitutionalityoftheearlier1999and2002Reauthorizationsweremoot.Second,thegovernmentcanmeetitsburdenofproductionwithoutconclusivelyprovingtheexistenceofpastorpresentracialdiscrimination.Third,thegovernmentmayestablishitsowncompellinginterestbypresentingevidenceofitsowndirectparticipationinracialdiscriminationoritspassiveparticipationinprivatediscrimination.Fourth,oncethegovernmentmeetsitsburdenofproduction,Rothemustintroduce“credible,particularized”evidencetorebutthegovernment’sinitialshowingoftheexistenceofacompellinginterest.Fifth,Rothemayrebutthegovernment’sstatisticalevidencebygivingarace‐neutralexplanationforthestatisticaldisparities,showingthatthestatisticsareflawed,demonstratingthatthedisparitiesshownarenotsignificantoractionable,orpresentingcontrastingstatisticaldata.Sixth,thegovernmentmayrelyondisparitystudiestosupportitscompellinginterest,andthosestudiesmaycontrolfortheeffectthatpre‐existingaffirmativeactionprogramshaveonthestatisticalanalysis.Id.at829‐32.
BasedonConcreteWorksIV,thedistrictcourtdidnotrequirethegovernmenttoconclusivelyprovethatthereispervasivediscriminationintherelevantmarket,thateachpresumptivelydisadvantagedgroupsufferedequallyfromdiscrimination,orthatprivatefirmsintentionallyandpurposefullydiscriminatedagainstminorities.Thecourtfoundthattheinferenceofdiscriminatoryexclusioncanarisefromstatisticaldisparities.Id.at830‐31.
ThedistrictcourtheldthatCongresshadacompellinginterestinthe2006Reauthorizationofthe1207Program,whichwassupportedbyastrongbasisintheevidence.ThecourtreliedinsignificantpartuponsixstateandlocaldisparitystudiesthatwerebeforeCongresspriortothe2006Reauthorizationofthe1207Program.ThecourtbasedthisevidenceonitsfindingthatSenatorKennedyhadreferencedthesedisparitystudies,discussedandsummarizedfindingsofthedisparitystudies,andRepresentativeCynthiaMcKinneyalsocitedthesamesixdisparitystudiesthatSenatorKennedyreferenced.Thecourtstatedthatbasedonthecontentofthefloordebate,itfoundthatthesestudieswereputbeforeCongresspriortothedateoftheReauthorizationofSection1207.Id.at838.
Thedistrictcourtfoundthatthesesixstateandlocaldisparitystudiesanalyzedevidenceofdiscriminationfromadiversecross‐sectionofjurisdictionsacrosstheUnitedStates,and“theyconstituteprimafacieevidenceofanation‐widepatternorpracticeofdiscriminationinpublicandprivatecontracting.”Id.at838‐39.Thecourtfoundthatthedatausedinthesesixdisparitystudiesisnot“stale”forpurposesofstrictscrutinyreview.Id.at839.ThecourtdisagreedwithRothe’sargumentthatallthedatawerestale(datainthestudiesfrom1997through2002),“becausethisdatawasthemostcurrentdataavailableatthetimethatthesestudieswereperformed.”Id.Thecourtfoundthatthegovernmentalentitiesshouldbeabletorelyonthemostrecentlyavailabledatasolongasthosedataarereasonablyup‐to‐date.Id.Thecourtdeclinedtoadopta“bright‐linerulefordeterminingstaleness.”Id.
ThecourtreferredtothereliancebytheNinthCircuitandtheEighthCircuitontheAppendixtoaffirmtheconstitutionalityoftheUSDOTMBE[nowDBE]Program,andrejectedfiveyearsasabright‐lineruleforconsideringwhetherdataare“stale.”Id.atn.86.Thecourtalsostatedthatit“acceptsthereasoningoftheAppendix,whichthecourtfoundstatedthatforthemostpart“the
![Page 376: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/376.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 250
federalgovernmentdoesbusinessinthesamecontractingmarketsasstateandlocalgovernments.Therefore,theevidenceinstateandlocalstudiesoftheimpactofdiscriminatorybarrierstominorityopportunityincontractingmarketsthroughoutthecountryisrelevanttothequestionofwhetherthefederalgovernmenthasacompellinginteresttotakeremedialactioninitsownprocurementactivities.”Id.at839,quoting61Fed.Reg.26042‐01,26061(1996).
ThedistrictcourtalsodiscussedadditionalevidencebeforeCongressthatitfoundinCongressionalCommitteeReportsandHearingRecords.Id.at865‐71.ThecourtnotedSBAReportsthatwerebeforeCongresspriortothe2006Reauthorization.Id.at871.
ThedistrictcourtfoundthatthedatacontainedintheAppendix,theBenchmarkStudy,andtheUrbanInstituteReportwere“stale,”andthecourtdidnotconsiderthosereportsasevidenceofacompellinginterestforthe2006Reauthorization.Id.at872‐75.ThecourtstatedthattheEighth,NinthandTenthCircuitsreliedontheAppendixtoupholdtheconstitutionalityoftheFederalDBEProgram,citingtothedecisionsinSherbrookeTurf,AdarandVII,andWesternStatesPaving.Id.at872.ThecourtpointedoutthatalthoughitdoesnotrelyonthedatacontainedintheAppendixtosupportthe2006Reauthorization,thefacttheEighth,Ninth,andTenthCircuitsreliedonthesedatatoupholdtheconstitutionalityoftheFederalDBEProgramasrecentlyas2005,convincedthecourtthatabright‐linestalenessruleisinappropriate.Id.at874.
AlthoughthecourtfoundthatthedatacontainedintheAppendix,theUrbanInstituteReport,andtheBenchmarkStudywerestaleforpurposesofstrictscrutinyreviewregardingthe2006Reauthorization,thecourtfoundthatRotheintroducednoconcrete,particularizedevidencechallengingthereliabilityofthemethodologyorthedatacontainedinthesixstateandlocaldisparitystudies,andotherevidencebeforeCongress.ThecourtfoundthatRothefailedtorebutthedata,methodologyoranecdotalevidencewith“concrete,particularized”evidencetothecontrary.Id.at875.Thedistrictcourtheldthatbasedonthestudies,thegovernmenthadsatisfieditsburdenofproducingevidenceofdiscriminationagainstAfricanAmericans,AsianAmericans,HispanicAmericans,andNativeAmericansintherelevantindustrysectors.Id.at876.
ThedistrictcourtfoundthatCongresshadacompellinginterestinreauthorizingthe1207Programin2006,whichwassupportedbyastrongbasisofevidenceforremedialaction.Id.at877.Thecourtheldthattheevidenceconstitutedprimafacieproofofanationwidepatternorpracticeofdiscriminationinbothpublicandprivatecontracting,thatCongresshadsufficientevidenceofdiscriminationthroughouttheUnitedStatestojustifyanationwideprogram,andtheevidenceofdiscriminationwassufficientlypervasiveacrossraciallinestojustifygrantingapreferencetoallfivepurportedlydisadvantagedracialgroups.Id.
Thedistrictcourtalsofoundthatthe2006Reauthorizationofthe1207Programwasnarrowlytailoredanddesignedtocorrectpresentdiscriminationandtocounterthelingeringeffectsofpastdiscrimination.Thecourtheldthatthegovernment’sinvolvementinbothpresentdiscriminationandthelingeringeffectsofpastdiscriminationwassopervasivethattheDODandtheDepartmentofAirForcehadbecomepassiveparticipantsinperpetuatingit.Id.ThecourtstateditwaslawofthecaseandcouldnotbedisturbedonremandthattheFederalCircuit
![Page 377: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/377.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 251
inRotheIIIhadheldthatthe1207Programwasflexibleinapplication,limitedindurationanditdidnotundulyimpactontherightsofthirdparties.Id.,quotingRotheIII,262F.3dat1331.
Thedistrictcourtthusconductedanarrowlytailoredanalysisthatreviewedthreefactors:
1. Theefficacyofrace‐neutralalternatives;
2. Evidencedetailingtherelationshipbetweenthestatednumericalgoalof5percentandtherelevantmarket;and
3. Over‐andunder‐inclusiveness.
Id.ThecourtfoundthatCongressexaminedtheefficacyofrace‐neutralalternativespriortotheenactmentofthe1207Programin1986andthattheseprogramswereunsuccessfulinremedyingtheeffectsofpastandpresentdiscriminationinfederalprocurement.Id.ThecourtconcludedthatCongresshadattemptedtoaddresstheissuesthroughrace‐neutralmeasures,discussedthosemeasures,andfoundthatCongress’adoptionofrace‐consciousprovisionswerejustifiedbytheineffectivenessofsuchrace‐neutralmeasuresinhelpingminority‐ownedfirmsovercomebarriers.Id.Thecourtfoundthatthegovernmentseriouslyconsideredandenactedrace‐neutralalternatives,buttheserace‐neutralprogramsdidnotremedythewidespreaddiscriminationthataffectedthefederalprocurementsector,andthatCongresswasnotrequiredtoimplementorexhausteveryconceivablerace‐neutralalternative.Id.at880.Rather,thecourtfoundthatnarrowtailoringrequiresonly“serious,goodfaithconsiderationofworkablerace‐neutralalternatives.”Id.
Thedistrictcourtalsofoundthatthe5percentgoalwasrelatedtotheminoritybusinessavailabilityidentifiedinthesixstateandlocaldisparitystudies.Id.at881.Thecourtconcludedthatthe5percentgoalwasaspirational,notmandatory.Id.at882.Thecourtthenexaminedandfoundthattheregulationsimplementingthe1207Programwerenotover‐inclusiveforseveralreasons.
November 4, 2008 decision by the Federal Circuit Court of Appeals. OnNovember4,2008,theFederalCircuitCourtofAppealsreversedthejudgmentofthedistrictcourtinpart,andremandedwithinstructionstoenterajudgment(1)denyingRotheanyreliefregardingthefacialconstitutionalityofSection1207asenactedin1999or2002,(2)declaringthatSection1207asenactedin2006(10U.S.C.§2323)isfaciallyunconstitutional,and(3)enjoiningapplicationofSection1207(10U.S.C.§2323).
TheFederalCircuitCourtofAppealsheldthatSection1207,onitsface,asreenactedin2006,violatedtheEqualProtectioncomponentoftheFifthAmendmentrighttodueprocess.ThecourtfoundthatbecausethestatuteauthorizedtheDODtoaffordpreferentialtreatmentonthebasisofrace,thecourtappliedstrictscrutiny,andbecauseCongressdidnothavea“strongbasisinevidence”uponwhichtoconcludethattheDODwasapassiveparticipantinpervasive,nationwideracialdiscrimination—atleastnotontheevidenceproducedbytheDODandreliedonbythedistrictcourtinthiscase—Section1207failedtomeetthisstrictscrutinytest.545F.3dat1050.
![Page 378: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/378.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 252
Strict scrutiny framework. TheFederalCircuitCourtofAppealsrecognizedthattheSupremeCourthasheldagovernmentmayhaveacompellinginterestinremedyingtheeffectsofpastorpresentracialdiscrimination.545F.3dat1036.ThecourtcitedthedecisioninCroson,488U.S.at492,thatitis“beyonddisputethatanypublicentity,stateorfederal,hasacompellinginterestinassuringthatpublicdollars,drawnfromthetaxcontributionsofallcitizens,donotservetofinancetheevilofprivateprejudice.”545F.3d.at1036,quotingCroson,488U.S.at492.
Thecourtheldthatbeforeresortingtorace‐consciousmeasures,thegovernmentmustidentifythediscriminationtoberemedied,publicorprivate,withsomespecificity,andmusthaveastrongbasisofevidenceuponwhichtoconcludethatremedialactionisnecessary.545F.3dat1036,quotingCroson,488U.S.at500,504.Althoughthepartychallengingthestatutebearstheultimateburdenofpersuadingthecourtthatitisunconstitutional,theFederalCircuitstatedthatthegovernmentfirstbearsaburdentoproducestrongevidencesupportingthelegislature’sdecisiontoemployrace‐consciousaction.545F.3dat1036.
Evenwherethereisacompellinginterestsupportedbystrongbasisinevidence,thecourtheldthestatutemustbenarrowlytailoredtofurtherthatinterest.Id.Thecourtnotedthatanarrowtailoringanalysiscommonlyinvolvessixfactors:(1)thenecessityofrelief;(2)theefficacyofalternative,race‐neutralremedies;(3)theflexibilityofrelief,includingtheavailabilityofwaiverprovisions;(4)therelationshipwiththestatednumericalgoaltotherelevantlabormarket;(5)theimpactofreliefontherightsofthirdparties;and(6)theoverinclusivenessorunderinclusivenessoftheracialclassification.Id.
Compelling interest – strong basis in evidence. TheFederalCircuitpointedoutthatthestatisticalandanecdotalevidencereliefuponbythedistrictcourtinitsrulingbelowincludedsixdisparitystudiesofstateorlocalcontracting.TheFederalCircuitalsopointedoutthatthedistrictcourtfoundthatthedatacontainedintheAppendix,theUrbanInstituteReport,andtheBenchmarkStudywerestaleforpurposesofstrictscrutinyreviewofthe2006Authorization,andtherefore,thedistrictcourtconcludedthatitwouldnotrelyonthosethreereportsasevidenceofacompellinginterestforthe2006reauthorizationofthe1207Program.545F.3d1023,citingtoRotheVI,499F.Supp.2dat875.SincetheDODdidnotchallengethisfindingonappeal,theFederalCircuitstatedthatitwouldnotconsidertheAppendix,theUrbanInstituteReport,ortheDepartmentofCommerceBenchmarkStudy,andinsteaddeterminedwhethertheevidencereliedonbythedistrictcourtwassufficienttodemonstrateacompellinginterest.Id.
Six state and local disparity studies. TheFederalCircuitfoundthatdisparitystudiescanberelevanttothecompellinginterestanalysisbecause,asexplainedbytheSupremeCourtinCroson,“[w]herethereisasignificantstatisticaldisparitybetweenthenumberofqualifiedminoritycontractorswillingandabletoperformaparticularserviceandthenumberofsuchcontractorsactuallyengagedby[a]localityorthelocality’sprimecontractors,aninferenceofdiscriminatoryexclusioncouldarise.”545F.3dat1037‐1038,quotingCroson,488U.S.C.at509.TheFederalCircuitalsocitedtothedecisionbytheFifthCircuitCourtofAppealsinW.H.ScottConstr.Co.v.CityofJackson,199F.3d206(5thCir.1999)thatgivenCroson’semphasisonstatisticalevidence,othercourtsconsideringequalprotectionchallengestominority‐participationprogramshavelookedtodisparityindices,ortocomputationsofdisparitypercentages,indeterminingwhetherCroson’sevidentiaryburdenissatisfied.545F.3dat1038,quotingW.H.Scott,199F.3dat218.
![Page 379: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/379.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 253
TheFederalCircuitnotedthatadisparitystudyisastudyattemptingtomeasurethedifference‐ordisparity‐betweenthenumberofcontractsorcontractdollarsactuallyawardedminority‐ownedbusinessesinaparticularcontractmarket,ontheonehand,andthenumberofcontractsorcontractdollarsthatonewouldexpecttobeawardedtominority‐ownedbusinessesgiventheirpresenceinthatparticularcontractmarket,ontheotherhand.545F.3dat1037.
Staleness. TheFederalCircuitdeclinedtoadoptaperserulethatdatamorethanfiveyearsoldarestaleperse,whichrejectedtheargumentputforthbyRothe.545F.3dat1038.Thecourtpointedoutthatthedistrictcourtnotedothercircuitcourtshavereliedonstudiescontainingdatamorethanfiveyearsoldwhenconductingcompellinginterestanalyses,citingtoWesternStatesPavingv.WashingtonStateDepartmentofTransportation,407F.3d983,992(9thCir.2005)andSherbrookeTurf,Inc.v.MinnesotaDepartmentofTransportation,345F.3d964,970(8thCir.2003)(relyingontheAppendix,publishedin1996).
TheFederalCircuitagreedwiththedistrictcourtthatCongress“shouldbeabletorelyonthemostrecentlyavailabledatasolongasthatdataisreasonablyup‐to‐date.”545F.3dat1039.TheFederalCircuitaffirmedthedistrictcourt’sconclusionthatthedataanalyzedinthesixdisparitystudieswerenotstaleattherelevanttimebecausethedisparitystudiesanalyzeddatapertainedtocontractsawardedasrecentlyas2000oreven2003,andbecauseRothedidnotpointtomorerecent,availabledata.Id.
Before Congress. TheFederalCircuitfoundthatforevidencetoberelevantinthestrictscrutinyanalysis,it“mustbeproventohavebeenbeforeCongresspriortoenactmentoftheracialclassification.”545F.3dat1039,quotingRotheV,413F.3dat1338.TheFederalCircuithadissueswithdeterminingwhetherthesixdisparitystudieswereactuallybeforeCongressforseveralreasons,includingthattherewasnoindicationthatthesestudiesweredebatedorreviewedbymembersofCongressorbyanywitnesses,andbecauseCongressmadenofindingsconcerningthesestudies.545F.3dat1039‐1040.However,thecourtdetermineditneednotdecidewhetherthesixstudieswereputbeforeCongress,becausethecourtheldinanyeventthatthestudiesdidnotprovideasubstantiallyprobativeandbroad‐basedstatisticalfoundationnecessaryforthestrongbasisinevidencethatmustbethepredicatefornation‐wide,race‐consciousaction.Id.at1040.
ThecourtdidnotethatfindingsregardingdisparitystudiesaretobedistinguishedfromformalfindingsofdiscriminationbytheDOD“whichCongresswasemphaticallynotrequiredtomake.”Id.at1040,footnote11(emphasisinoriginal).TheFederalCircuitcitedtheDeanv.CityofShreveportcasethatthe“governmentneednotincriminateitselfwithaformalfindingofdiscriminationpriortousingarace‐consciousremedy.”545F.3dat1040,footnote11quotingDeanv.CityofShreveport,438F.3d448,445(5thCir.2006).
Methodology. TheFederalCircuitfoundthatthereweremethodologicaldefectsinthesixdisparitystudies.Thecourtfoundthattheobjectionstotheparametersusedtoselecttherelevantpoolofcontractorswasoneofthemajordefectsinthestudies.545F.3dat1040‐1041.
Thecourtstatedthatingeneral,“[a]disparityratiolessthan0.80”—i.e.,afindingthatagivenminoritygroupreceivedlessthan80percentoftheexpectedamount—“indicatesarelevantdegreeofdisparity,”and“mightsupportaninferenceofdiscrimination.”545F.3dat1041,
![Page 380: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/380.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 254
quotingthedistrictcourtopinioninRotheVI,499F.Supp.2dat842;andcitingEngineeringContractorsAssociationofSouthFlorida,Inc.v.MetropolitanDadeCounty,122F.3d895,914(11thCir.1997).Thecourtnotedthatthisdisparityratioattemptstocalculatearatiobetweentheexpectedcontractamountofagivenrace/gendergroupandtheactualcontractamountreceivedbythatgroup.545F.3dat1041.
Thecourtconsideredtheavailabilityanalysis,orbenchmarkanalysis,whichisutilizedtoensurethatonlythoseminority‐ownedcontractorswhoarequalified,willingandabletoperformtheprimecontractsatissueareconsideredwhenperformingthedenominatorofadisparityratio.545F.3dat1041.Thecourtcitedtoanexpertusedinthecasethata“crucialquestion”indisparitystudiesistodevelopacrediblemethodologytoestimatethisbenchmarkshareofcontractsminoritieswouldreceiveintheabsenceofdiscriminationandthetouchstoneformeasuringthebenchmarkistodeterminewhetherthefirmisready,willing,andabletodobusinesswiththegovernment.545F.3dat1041‐1042.
ThecourtconcludedthecontentionbyRothe,thatthesixstudiesmisappliedthis“touchstone”ofCrosonanderroneouslyincludedminority‐ownedfirmsthatweredeemedwillingorpotentiallywillingandable,withoutregardtowhetherthefirmwasqualified,wasnotadefectthatsubstantiallyundercuttheresultsoffourofthesixstudies,because“thebulkofthebusinessesconsideredinthesestudieswereidentifiedinwaysthatwouldtendtoestablishtheirqualifications,suchasbytheirpresenceoncitycontractrecordsandbidderlists.”545F.3dat1042.Thecourtnotedthatwithregardtothesestudiesavailableprimecontractorswereidentifiedviacertificationlists,willingnesssurveyofchambermembershipandtradeassociationmembershiplists,publicagencyandcertificationlists,utilizedprimecontractor,bidderlists,countyandothergovernmentrecordsandothertypelists.Id.
Thecourtstateditwaslessconfidentinthedeterminationofqualifiedminority‐ownedbusinessesbythetwootherstudiesbecausetheavailabilitymethodologyemployedinthosestudies,thecourtfound,appearedlesslikelytohaveweededoutunqualifiedbusinesses.Id.However,thecourtstateditwasmoretroubledbythefailureoffiveofthestudiestoaccountofficiallyforpotentialdifferencesinsize,or“relativecapacity,”ofthebusinessincludedinthosestudies.545F.3dat1042‐1043.
Thecourtnotedthatqualifiedfirmsmayhavesubstantiallydifferentcapacitiesandthusmightbeexpectedtobringinsubstantiallydifferentamountsofbusinessevenintheabsenceofdiscrimination.545F.3dat1043.TheFederalCircuitreferredtotheEleventhCircuitexplanationsimilarlythatbecausefirmsarebigger,biggerfirmshaveabiggerchancetowinbiggercontracts,andthusonewouldexpectthebigger(onaverage)non‐MWBEfirmstogetadisproportionatelyhigherpercentageoftotalconstructiondollarsawardedthanthesmallerMWBEfirms.545F.3dat1043quotingEngineeringContractorsAssociation,122F.3dat917.Thecourtpointedoutitsissueswiththestudiesaccountingfortherelativesizesofcontractsawardedtominority‐ownedbusinesses,butnotconsideringtherelativesizesofthebusinessesthemselves.Id.at1043.
Thecourtnotedthatthestudiesmeasuredtheavailabilityofminority‐ownedbusinessesbythepercentageoffirmsinthemarketownedbyminorities,insteadofbythepercentageoftotalmarketplacecapacitythosefirmscouldprovide.Id.Thecourtsaidthatforadisparityratioto
![Page 381: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/381.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 255
haveasignificantprobativevalue,thesametimeperiodandmetric(dollarsornumbers)shouldbeusedinmeasuringtheutilizationandavailabilityshares.545F.3dat1044,n.12.
Thecourtstatedthatwhiletheseparametersrelatingtothefirmsizemayhaveensuredthateachminority‐ownedbusinessinthestudiesmetacapacitythreshold,theseparametersdidnotaccountfortherelativecapacitiesofbusinessestobidformorethanonecontractatatime,whichfailurerenderedthedisparityratioscalculatedbythestudiessubstantiallylessprobativeontheirown,ofthelikelihoodofdiscrimination.Id.at1044.Thecourtpointedoutthatthestudiescouldhaveaccountedforfirmsizeevenwithoutchangingthedisparityratiomethodologiesbyemployingregressionanalysistodeterminewhethertherewasastatisticallysignificantcorrelationbetweenthesizeofafirmandtheshareofcontractdollarsawardedtoit.545F.3dat1044citingtoEngineeringContractorsAssociation,122F.3dat917.Thecourtnotedthatonlyoneofthestudiesconductedthistypeofregressionanalysis,whichincludedtheindependentvariablesofafirm‐ageofacompany,ownereducationlevel,numberofemployees,percentofrevenuefromtheprivatesectorandownerexperienceforindustrygroupings.Id.at1044‐1045.
Thecourtstated,to“beclear,”thatitdidnotholdthatthedefectsintheavailabilityandcapacityanalysesinthesesixdisparitystudiesrenderthestudieswhollyunreliableforanypurpose.Id.at1045.Thecourtsaidthatwherethecalculateddisparityratiosarelowenough,thecourtdoesnotforeclosethepossibilitythataninferenceofdiscriminationmightstillbepermissibleforsomeoftheminoritygroupsinsomeofthestudiedindustriesinsomeofthejurisdictions.Id.Thecourtrecognizedthataminority‐ownedfirm’scapacityandqualificationsmaythemselvesbeaffectedbydiscrimination.Id.Thecourtheld,however,thatthedefectsitnoteddetracteddramaticallyfromtheprobativevalueofthesixstudies,andinconjunctionwiththeirlimitedgeographiccoverage,renderedthestudiesinsufficienttoformthestatisticalcoreofthestrongbasisandevidencerequiredtoupholdthestatute.Id.
Geographic coverage. Thecourtpointedoutthatwhereasmunicipalitiesmustnecessarilyidentifydiscriminationintheimmediatelocalitytojustifyarace‐basedprogram,thecourtdoesnotthinkthatCongressneedstohavehadevidencebeforeitofdiscriminationinall50statesinordertojustifythe1207program.Id.Thecourtstressed,however,thatinholdingthesixstudiesinsufficientinthisparticularcase,“wedonotnecessarilydisapproveofdecisionsbyothercircuitcourtsthathaverelied,directlyorindirectly,onmunicipaldisparitystudiestoestablishafederalcompellinginterest.”545F.3dat1046.Thecourtstatedinparticular,theAppendixreliedonbytheNinthandTenthCircuitsinthecontextofcertainrace‐consciousmeasurespertainingtofederalhighwayconstruction,referencestheUrbanInstituteReport,whichitselfanalyzedover50disparitystudiesandreliedforitsconclusionsonover30ofthosestudies,afarbroaderbasisthanthesixstudiesprovidedinthiscase.Id.
Anecdotal evidence. Thecourtheldthatgivenitsholdingregardingstatisticalevidence,itdidnotreviewtheanecdotalevidencebeforeCongress.Thecourtdidpointout,however,thattherewasnotevidencepresentedofasingleinstanceofallegeddiscriminationbytheDODinthecourseofawardingaprimecontract,ortoasingleinstanceofallegeddiscriminationbyaprivatecontractoridentifiedastherecipientofaprimedefensecontract.545F.3dat1049.ThecourtnotedthislackofevidenceinthecontextoftheopinioninCrosonthatifagovernmenthasbecomeapassiveparticipantinasystemofracialexclusionpracticedbyelementsofthelocal
![Page 382: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/382.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 256
constructionindustry,thenthatgovernmentmaytakeaffirmativestepstodismantletheexclusionarysystem.545F.3dat1048,citingCroson,488U.S.at492.
TheFederalCircuitpointedoutthattheTenthCircuitinConcreteWorksnotedtheCityofDenverofferedmorethandollaramountstolinkitsspendingtoprivatediscrimination,butinsteadprovidedtestimonyfromminoritybusinessownersthatgeneralcontractorswhousethemincityconstructionprojectsrefusetousethemonprivateprojects,withtheresultthatDenverhadpaidtaxdollarstosupportfirmsthatdiscriminatedagainstotherfirmsbecauseoftheirrace,ethnicityandgender.545F.3dat1049,quotingConcreteWorks,321F.3dat976‐977.
Inconcluding,thecourtstatedthatitstresseditsholdingwasgroundedintheparticularitemsofevidenceofferedbytheDOD,and“shouldnotbeconstruedasstatingblanketrules,forexampleaboutthereliabilityofdisparitystudies.AstheFifthCircuithasexplained,thereisno‘precisemathematicalformula’toassessthequantumofevidencethatrisestotheCroson‘strongbasisinevidence’benchmark.’”545F.3dat1049,quotingW.H.ScottConstr.Co.,199F.3dat218n.11.
Narrowly tailoring. TheFederalCircuitonlymadetwoobservationsaboutnarrowlytailoring,becauseitheldthatCongresslackedtheevidentiarypredicateforacompellinginterest.First,itnotedthatthe1207Programwasflexibleinapplication,limitedinduration,andthatitdidnotundulyimpactontherightsofthirdparties.545F.3dat1049.Second,thecourtheldthattheabsenceofstronglyprobativestatisticalevidencemakesitimpossibletoevaluateatleastoneoftheothernarrowlytailoringfactors.WithoutsolidbenchmarksfortheminoritygroupscoveredbytheSection1207,thecourtsaiditcouldnotdeterminewhetherthe5percentgoalisreasonablyrelatedtothecapacityoffirmsownedbymembersofthoseminoritygroups—i.e.,whetherthatgoaliscomparabletotheshareofcontractsminoritieswouldreceiveintheabsenceofdiscrimination.”545F.3dat1049‐1050.
3. Rothe Development, Inc. v. U.S. Dept. of Defense and Small Business Administration, 107 F. Supp. 3d 183, 2015 WL 3536271 (D.D.C. 2015), affirmed on other grounds, 836 F.3d 57, 2016 WL 4719049 (D.C. Cir. 2016).
PlaintiffRotheDevelopment,Inc.isasmallbusinessthatfiledthisactionagainsttheU.S.DepartmentofDefense(“DOD”)andtheU.S.SmallBusinessAdministration(“SBA”)(collectively,“Defendants”)challengingtheconstitutionalityoftheSection8(a)Programonitsface.
TheconstitutionalchallengethatRothebringsinthiscaseisnearlyidenticaltothechallengebroughtinthecaseofDynaLanticCorp.v.UnitedStatesDepartmentofDefense,885F.Supp.2d237(D.D.C.2012).TheplaintiffinDynaLanticsuedtheDOD,theSBA,andtheDepartmentofNavyallegingthatSection8(a)wasunconstitutionalbothonitsfaceandasappliedtothemilitarysimulationandtrainingindustry.SeeDynaLantic,885F.Supp.2dat242.DynaLantic’scourtdisagreedwiththeplaintiff’sfacialattackandheldtheSection8(a)Programasfaciallyconstitutional.SeeDynaLantic,885F.Supp.2dat248‐280,283‐291.(SeealsodiscussionofDynaLanticinthisAppendixbelow.)
ThecourtinRothestatesthattheplaintiffRothereliesonsubstantiallythesamerecordevidenceandnearlyidenticallegalargumentsasintheDynaLanticcase,andurgesthecourttostrikedowntherace‐consciousprovisionsofSection8(a)ontheirface,andthustodepartfrom
![Page 383: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/383.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 257
DynaLantic’sholdinginthecontextofthiscase.2015WL3536271at*1.BoththeplaintiffRotheandtheDefendantsfiledcross‐motionsforsummaryjudgmentaswellasmotionstolimitorexcludetestimonyofeachother’sexpertwitnesses.ThecourtconcludesthatDefendants’expertsmeettherelevantqualificationstandardsundertheFederalRules,andthereforedeniesplaintiffRothe’smotiontoexcludeDefendants’experttestimony.Id.Bycontrast,thecourtfoundsufficientreasontodoubtthequalificationsofoneofplaintiff’sexpertsandtoquestionthereliabilityofthetestimonyoftheother;consequently,thecourtgrantstheDefendants’motionstoexcludeplaintiff’sexperttestimony.
Inaddition,thecourtinRotheagreeswiththecourt’sreasoninginDynaLantic,andthusthecourtinRothealsoconcludesthatSection8(a)isconstitutionalonitsface.Accordingly,thecourtdeniesplaintiff’smotionforsummaryjudgmentandgrantsDefendants’cross‐motionforsummaryjudgment.
DynaLantic Corp. v. Department of Defense. ThecourtinRotheanalyzedtheDynaLanticcase,andagreedwiththefindings,holdingandconclusionsofthecourtinDynaLantic.See2015WL3536271at*4‐5.ThecourtinRothenotedthatthecourtinDynaLanticengagedinadetailedexaminationofSection8(a)andtheextensiverecordevidence,includingdisparitystudiesonracialdiscriminationinfederalcontractingacrossvariousindustries.Id.at*5.ThecourtinDynaLanticconcludedthatCongresshadacompellinginterestineliminatingtherootsofracialdiscriminationinfederalcontracting,fundedbyfederalmoney,andalsothatthegovernmenthadestablishedastrongbasisinevidencetosupportitsconclusionthatremedialactionwasnecessarytoremedythatdiscrimination.Id.at*5.Thisconclusionwasbasedonthefindingthegovernmentprovidedextensiveevidenceofdiscriminatorybarrierstominoritybusinessformationandminoritybusinessdevelopment,aswellassignificantevidencethat,evenwhenminoritybusinessesarequalifiedandeligibletoperformcontractsinbothpublicandprivatesectors,theyareawardedthesecontractsfarlessoftenthantheirsimilarlysituatednon‐minoritycounterparts.Id.at*5,citingDynaLantic,885F.Supp.2dat279.
ThecourtinDynaLanticalsofoundthatDynaLantichadfailedtopresentcredible,particularizedevidencethatunderminedthegovernment’scompellinginterestorthatdemonstratedthatthegovernment’sevidencedidnotsupportaninferenceofpriordiscriminationandthusaremedialpurpose.2015WL3536271at*5,citingDynaLantic,at279.
Withrespecttonarrowtailoring,thecourtinDynaLanticconcludedthattheSection8(a)Programisnarrowlytailoredonitsface,andthatsinceSection8(a)race‐consciousprovisionswerenarrowlytailoredtofurtheracompellingstateinterest,strictscrutinywassatisfiedinthecontextoftheconstructionindustryandinotherindustriessuchasarchitectureandengineering,andprofessionalservicesaswell.Id.ThecourtinRothealsonotedthatthecourtinDynaLanticfoundthatDynaLantichadthusfailedtomeetitsburdentoshowthatthechallengeprovisionswereunconstitutionalinallcircumstancesandheldthatSection8(a)wasconstitutionalonitsface.Id.
Defendants’ expert evidence.OneofDefendants’expertsusedregressionanalysis,claimingtohaveisolatedtheeffectinminorityownershiponthelikelihoodofasmallbusinessreceivinggovernmentcontracts,specificallyusinga“logitmodel”toexaminegovernmentcontractingdatainordertodeterminewhetherthedatashowanydifferenceintheoddsofcontractsbeingwon
![Page 384: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/384.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 258
byminority‐ownedsmallbusinessesrelativetoothersmallbusinesses.2015WL3536271at*9.Theexpertcontrolledforothervariablesthatcouldinfluencetheoddsofwhetherornotagivenfirmwinsacontract,suchasbusinesssize,age,andlevelofsecurityclearance,andconcludedthattheoddsofminority‐ownedsmallfirmsandnon‐8(a)SDBfirmswinningcontractswerelowerthansmallnon‐minorityandnon‐SDBfirms.Id.Inaddition,theDefendants’expertfoundthatnon‐8(a)minority‐ownedSDBsarestatisticallysignificantlylesslikelytowinacontractinindustriesaccountingfor94.0%ofcontractactions,93.0%ofdollarsawarded,andinwhich92.2%ofnon‐8(a)minority‐ownedSDBsareregistered.Id.Also,theexpertfoundthatthereisnoindustrywherenon‐8(a)minority‐ownedSDBshaveastatisticallysignificantadvantageintermsofwinningacontractfromthefederalgovernment.Id.
ThecourtrejectedRothe’scontentionthattheexpertopinionisbasedoninsufficientdata,andthatitsanalysisofdatarelatedtoasubsetoftherelevantindustrycodesistoonarrowtosupportitsscientificconclusions.Id.at*10.Thecourtfoundconvincingtheexpert’sresponsetoRothe’scritiqueabouthisdataset,explainingthat,fromamathematicalperspective,excludingcertainNAICScodesandanalyzingdataatthethree‐digitlevelactuallyincreasesthereliabilityofhisresults.Theexpertoptedtousecodesatthethree‐digitlevelasacompromise,balancingtheneedtohavesufficientdataineachindustrygroupingandtherecognitionthatmanyfirmscanswitchproductionwithinthebroaderthree‐digitcategory.Id.TheexpertalsoexcludedcertainNAICSindustrygroupsfromhisregressionanalysesbecauseofincompletedata,irrelevance,orbecausedataissuesinagivenNAICSgrouppreventedtheregressionmodelfromproducingreliableestimates.Id.Thecourtfoundthattheexpert’sreasoningwithrespecttotheexclusionsandassumptionshemakesintheanalysisarefullyexplainedandscientificallysound.Id.
Inaddition,thecourtfoundthatpost‐enactmentevidencewasproperlyconsideredbytheexpertandthecourt.Id.Thecourtfoundthatnearlyeverycircuittoconsiderthequestionoftherelevanceofpost‐enactmentevidencehasheldthatreviewingcourtsneednotlimitthemselvestotheparticularevidencethatCongressrelieduponwhenitenactedthestatuteatissue.Id.,citingDynaLantic,885F.Supp.2dat257.
Thus,thecourtheldthatpost‐enactmentevidenceisrelevanttoconstitutionalreview,inparticular,followingthecourtinDynaLantic,whenthestatuteisover30yearsoldandtheevidenceusedtojustifySection8(a)isstaleforpurposesofdeterminingacompellinginterestinthepresent.Id.,citingDynaLanticat885F.Supp.2dat258.ThecourtalsopointsoutthatthestatuteitselfcontemplatesthatCongresswillreviewthe8(a)Programonacontinuingbasis,whichrenderstheuseofpost‐enactmentevidenceproper.Id.
ThecourtalsofoundDefendants’additionalexpert’stestimonyasadmissibleinconnectionwiththatexpert’sreviewoftheresultsofthe107disparitystudiesconductedthroughouttheUnitedStatessincetheyear2000,allbut32ofwhichweresubmittedtoCongress.Id.at*11.ThisexperttestifiedthatthedisparitystudiessubmittedtoCongress,takenasawhole,providestrongevidenceoflarge,adverse,andoftenstatisticallysignificantdisparitiesbetweenminorityparticipationinbusinessenterpriseactivityandtheavailabilityofthosebusinesses;thedisparitiesarenotexplainedsolelybydifferencesinfactorsotherthanraceandsexthatareuntaintedbydiscrimination;andthedisparitiesareconsistentwiththepresenceofdiscriminationinthebusinessmarket.Id.at*12.
![Page 385: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/385.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 259
ThecourtrejectsRothe’scontentionstoexcludethisexperttestimonymerelybasedontheargumentbyRothethatthefactualbasisfortheexpert’sopinionisunreliablebasedonallegedflawsinthedisparitystudiesorthatthefactualbasisfortheexpert’sopinionsareweak.Id.ThecourtstatesthatevenifRothe’scontentionsarecorrect,anattackontheunderlyingdisparitystudiesdoesnotnecessitatetheremedyofexclusion.Id.
Plaintiff’s expert’s testimony rejected.Thecourtfoundthatoneofplaintiff’sexpertswasnotqualifiedbasedonhisownadmissionsregardinghislackoftraining,education,knowledge,skillandexperienceinanystatisticaloreconometricmethodology.Id.at*13.Plaintiff’sotherexpertthecourtdeterminedprovidedtestimonythatwasunreliableandinadmissibleashispreferredmethodologyforconductingdisparitystudies“appearstobewelloutsideofthemainstreaminthisparticularfield.”Id.at*14.Theexpert’smethodologyincludedhisassertionthattheonlyproperwaytodeterminetheavailabilityofminority‐ownedbusinessesistocountthosecontractorsandsubcontractorsthatactuallyperformorbidoncontracts,whichthecourtrejectedasnotreliable.Id.
The Section 8(a) Program is constitutional on its face.ThecourtfoundpersuasivethecourtdecisioninDynaLantic,andheldthatinasmuchasRotheseekstore‐litigatethelegalissuespresentedinthatcase,thiscourtdeclinesRothe’sinvitationtodepartfromtheDynaLanticcourt’sconclusionthatSection8(a)isconstitutionalonitsface.Id.at*15.
ThecourtreiterateditsagreementwiththeDynaLanticcourtthatracialclassificationsareconstitutionalonlyiftheyarenarrowlytailoredmeasuresthatfurthercompellinggovernmentalinterest.Id.at*17.Todemonstrateacompellinginterest,thegovernmentdefendantsmustmaketwoshowings:firstthegovernmentmustarticulatealegislativegoalthatisproperlyconsideredacompellinggovernmentalinterest,andsecondthegovernmentmustdemonstrateastrongbasisinevidencesupportingitsconclusionthatrace‐basedremedialactionwasnecessarytofurtherthatinterest.Id.at*17.Insodoing,thegovernmentneednotconclusivelyprovetheexistenceofracialdiscriminationinthepastorpresent.Id.Thegovernmentmayrelyonbothstatisticalandanecdotalevidence,althoughanecdotalevidencealonecannotestablishastrongbasisinevidenceforthepurposesofstrictscrutiny.Id.
Ifthegovernmentmakesbothshowings,theburdenshiftstotheplaintifftopresentcredible,particularizedevidencetorebutthegovernment’sinitialshowingofacompellinginterest.Id.Onceacompellinginterestisestablished,thegovernmentmustfurthershowthatthemeanschosentoaccomplishthegovernment’sassertedpurposearespecificallyandnarrowlyframedtoaccomplishthatpurpose.Id.
ThecourtheldthatthegovernmentarticulatedandestablishedcompellinginterestfortheSection8(a)Program,namely,remedyingrace‐baseddiscriminationanditseffects.Id.Thecourtheldthegovernmentalsoestablishedastrongbasisinevidencethatfurtheringthisinterestrequiresrace‐basedremedialaction–specifically,evidenceregardingdiscriminationingovernmentcontracting,whichconsistedofextensiveevidenceofdiscriminatorybarrierstominoritybusinessformationandforcefulevidenceofdiscriminatorybarrierstominoritybusinessdevelopment.Id.at*17,citingDynaLantic,885F.Supp.2dat279.
![Page 386: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/386.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 260
ThegovernmentdefendantsinthiscaserelieduponthesameevidenceasintheDynaLanticcaseandthecourtfoundthatthegovernmentprovidedsignificantevidencethatevenwhenminoritybusinessesarequalifiedandeligibletoperformcontractsinboththeprivateandpublicsectors,theyareawardedthesecontractsfarlessoftenthantheirsimilarlysituatednon‐minoritycounterparts.Id.at*17.ThecourtheldthatRothehasfailedtorebuttheevidenceofthegovernmentwithcredibleandparticularizedevidenceofitsown.Id.at*17.Furthermore,thecourtfoundthatthegovernmentdefendantsestablishedthattheSection8(a)Programisnarrowlytailoredtoachievetheestablishedcompellinginterest.Id.at*18.
Thecourtfound,citingagreementwiththeDynaLanticcourt,thattheSection8(a)Programsatisfiesallsixfactorsofnarrowtailoring.Id.First,alternativerace‐neutralremedieshaveprovedunsuccessfulinaddressingthediscriminationtargetedwiththeProgram.Id.Second,theSection8(a)Programisappropriatelyflexible.Id.Third,Section8(a)isneitherovernorunder‐inclusive.Id.Fourth,theSection8(a)Programimposestemporallimitsoneveryindividual’sparticipationthatfulfilledthedurationalaspectofnarrowtailoring.Id.Fifth,therelevantaspirationalgoalsforSDBcontractingparticipationarenumericallyproportionate,inpartbecausetheevidencepresentedestablishedthatminorityfirmsareready,willingandabletoperformworkequaltotwotofivepercentofgovernmentcontractsinindustriesincludingbutnotlimitedtoconstruction.Id.Andsix,thefactthattheSection8(a)Programreservescertaincontractsforprogramparticipantsdoesnot,onitsface,createanimpermissibleburdenonnon‐participatingfirms.Id.;citingDynaLantic,885F.Supp.2dat283‐289.
Accordingly,thecourtconcurredcompletelywiththeDynaLanticcourt’sconclusionthatthestrictscrutinystandardhasbeenmet,andthattheSection8(a)Programisfaciallyconstitutionaldespiteitsrelianceonrace‐consciouscriteria.Id.at*18.Thecourtfoundthatonbalancethedisparitystudiesonwhichthegovernmentdefendantsrelyreveallarge,statisticallysignificantbarrierstobusinessformationamongminoritygroupsthatcannotbeexplainedbyfactorsotherthanrace,anddemonstratethatdiscriminationbyprimecontractors,privatesectorcustomers,suppliersandbondingcompaniescontinuestolimitminoritybusinessdevelopment.Id.at*18,citingDynaLantic,885F.Supp.2dat261,263.
Moreover,thecourtfoundthattheevidenceclearlyshowsthatqualified,eligibleminority‐ownedfirmsareexcludedfromcontractingmarkets,andaccordinglyprovidespowerfulevidencefromwhichaninferenceofdiscriminatoryexclusioncouldarise.Id.at*18.ThecourtconcurredwiththeDynaLanticcourt’sconclusionthatbasedontheevidencebeforeCongress,ithadastrongbasisinevidencetoconcludetheuseofrace‐consciousmeasureswasnecessaryin,atleast,somecircumstances.Id.at*18,citingDynaLantic,885F.Supp.2dat274.
Inaddition,inconnectionwiththenarrowtailoringanalysis,thecourtrejectedRothe’sargumentthatSection8(a)race‐consciousprovisionscannotbenarrowlytailoredbecausetheyapplyacrosstheboardinequalmeasures,forallpreferredraces,inallmarketsandsectors.Id.at*19.ThecourtstatedthepresumptionthataminorityapplicantissociallydisadvantagedmayberebuttediftheSBAispresentedwithcredibleevidencetothecontrary.Id.at*19.Thecourtpointedoutthatanypersonmaypresentcredibleevidencechallenginganindividual’sstatusassociallyoreconomicallydisadvantaged.Id.ThecourtsaidthatRothe’sargumentisincorrectbecauseitisbasedonthemisconceptionthatnarrowtailoringnecessarilymeansaremedythatislaser‐focusedonasinglesegmentofaparticularindustryorarea,ratherthanthecommon
![Page 387: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/387.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 261
understandingthatthe“narrowness”ofthenarrow‐tailoringmandaterelatestotherelationshipbetweenthegovernment’sinterestandtheremedyitprescribes.Id.
Conclusion.Thecourtconcludedthatplaintiff’sfacialconstitutionalchallengetotheSection8(a)Programfailed,thatthegovernmentdefendantsdemonstratedacompellinginterestforthegovernment’sracialclassification,thepurportedneedforremedialactionissupportedbystrongandunrebuttedevidence,andthattheSection8(a)programisnarrowlytailoredtofurtheritscompellinginterest.Id.at*20.
4. DynaLantic Corp. v. United States Dept. of Defense, et al., 885 F.Supp.2d 237, 2012 WL 3356813 (D.D.C., 2012), appeals voluntarily dismissed, United States Court of Appeals, District of Columbia, Docket Numbers 12‐5329 and 12‐5330 (2014)
Plaintiff,theDynaLanticCorporation(“DynaLantic”),isasmallbusinessthatdesignsandmanufacturesaircraft,submarine,ship,andothersimulatorsandtrainingequipment.DynaLanticsuedtheUnitedStatesDepartmentofDefense(“DoD”),theDepartmentoftheNavy,andtheSmallBusinessAdministration(“SBA”)challengingtheconstitutionalityofSection8(a)oftheSmallBusinessAct(the“Section8(a)program”),onitsfaceandasapplied:namely,theSBA’sdeterminationthatitisnecessaryorappropriatetosetasidecontractsinthemilitarysimulationandtrainingindustry.2012WL3356813,at*1,*37.
TheSection8(a)programauthorizesthefederalgovernmenttolimittheissuanceofcertaincontractstosociallyandeconomicallydisadvantagedbusinesses.Id.at*1.DynaLanticclaimedthattheSection8(a)isunconstitutionalonitsfacebecausetheDoD’suseoftheprogram,whichisreservedfor“sociallyandeconomicallydisadvantagedindividuals,”constitutesanillegalracialpreferenceinviolationoftheequalprotectioninviolatingitsrighttoequalprotectionundertheDueProcessClauseoftheFifthAmendmenttotheConstitutionandotherrights.Id.at*1.DynaLanticalsoclaimedtheSection8(a)programisunconstitutionalasappliedbythefederaldefendantsinDynaLantic’sspecificindustry,definedasthemilitarysimulationandtrainingindustry.Id.
AsdescribedinDynaLanticCorp.v.UnitedStatesDepartmentofDefense,503F.Supp.2d262(D.D.C.2007)(seebelow),thecourtpreviouslyhaddeniedMotionsforSummaryJudgmentbythepartiesanddirectedthemtoproposefutureproceedingsinordertosupplementtherecordwithadditionalevidencesubsequentto2007beforeCongress.503F.Supp.2dat267.
The Section 8(a) Program.TheSection8(a)programisabusinessdevelopmentprogramforsmallbusinessesownedbyindividualswhoarebothsociallyandeconomicallydisadvantagedasdefinedbythespecificcriteriasetforthinthecongressionalstatuteandfederalregulationsat15U.S.C.§§632,636and637;see13CFR§124.“Sociallydisadvantaged”individualsarepersonswhohavebeen“subjectedtoracialorethnicprejudiceorculturalbiaswithinAmericansocietybecauseoftheiridentitiesasmembersofgroupswithoutregardtotheirindividualqualities.”13CFR§124.103(a);seealso15U.S.C.§637(a)(5).“Economicallydisadvantaged”individualsarethosesociallydisadvantagedindividuals“whoseabilitytocompeteinthefreeenterprisesystemhasbeenimpairedduetodiminishedcapitalandcreditopportunitiesascomparedtoothersinthesameorsimilarlineofbusinesswhoarenotsociallydisadvantaged.”13CFR§124.104(a);seealso15U.S.C.§637(a)(6)(A).DynaLanticCorp.,2012WL3356813at*2.
![Page 388: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/388.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 262
Individualswhoaremembersofcertainracialandethnicgroupsarepresumptivelysociallydisadvantaged;suchgroupsinclude,butarenotlimitedto,BlackAmericans,HispanicAmericans,NativeAmericans,Indiantribes,AsianPacificAmericans,NativeHawaiianOrganizations,andotherminorities.Id.at*2quoting15U.S.C.§631(f)(1)(B)‐(c);seealso13CFR§124.103(b)(1).Allprospectiveprogramparticipantsmustshowthattheyareeconomicallydisadvantaged,whichrequiresanindividualtoshowanetworthoflessthan$250,000uponenteringtheprogram,andashowingthattheindividual’sincomeforthreeyearspriortotheapplicationandthefairmarketvalueofallassetsdonotexceedacertainthreshold.2012WL3356813at*3;see13CFR§124.104(c)(2).
Congresshasestablishedan“aspirationalgoal”forprocurementfromsociallyandeconomicallydisadvantagedindividuals,whichincludesbutisnotlimitedtotheSection8(a)program,offivepercentofprocurementsdollarsgovernmentwide.See15U.S.C.§644(g)(1).DynaLantic,at*3.Congresshasnot,however,establishedanumericalgoalforprocurementfromtheSection8(a)programspecifically.SeeId.EachfederalagencyestablishesitsowngoalbyagreementbetweentheagencyheadandtheSBA.Id.DoDhasestablishedagoalofawardingapproximatelytwopercentofprimecontractdollarsthroughtheSection8(a)program.DynaLantic,at*3.TheSection8(a)programallowstheSBA,“wheneveritdeterminessuchactionisnecessaryandappropriate,”toenterintocontractswithothergovernmentagenciesandthensubcontractwithqualifiedprogramparticipants.15U.S.C.§637(a)(1).Section8(a)contractscanbeawardedona“solesource”basis(i.e.,reservedtoonefirm)orona“competitive”basis(i.e.,betweentwoormoreSection8(a)firms).DynaLantic,at*3‐4;13CFR124.501(b).
Plaintiff’s business and the simulation and training industry.DynaLanticperformscontractsandsubcontractsinthesimulationandtrainingindustry.Thesimulationandtrainingindustryiscomposedofthoseorganizationsthatdevelop,manufacture,andacquireequipmentusedtotrainpersonnelinanyactivitywherethereisahuman‐machineinterface.DynaLanticat*5.
Compelling interest.TheCourtrulesthatthegovernmentmustmaketwoshowingstoarticulateacompellinginterestservedbythelegislativeenactmenttosatisfythestrictscrutinystandardthatracialclassificationsareconstitutionalonlyiftheyarenarrowlytailoredmeasuresthatfurthercompellinggovernmentalinterests.”DynaLantic,at*9.First,thegovernmentmust“articulatealegislativegoalthatisproperlyconsideredacompellinggovernmentinterest.”Id.quotingSherbrookeTurfv.Minn.DOT.,345F.3d964,969(8thCir.2003).Second,inadditiontoidentifyingacompellinggovernmentinterest,“thegovernmentmustdemonstrate‘astrongbasisinevidence’supportingitsconclusionthatrace‐basedremedialactionwasnecessarytofurtherthatinterest.”DynaLantic,at*9,quotingSherbrooke,345F.3d969.
Afterthegovernmentmakesaninitialshowing,theburdenshiftstoDynaLantictopresent“credible,particularizedevidence”torebutthegovernment’s“initialshowingofacompellinginterest.”DynaLantic,at*10quotingConcreteWorksofColorado,Inc.v.CityandCountyofDenver,321F.3d950,959(10thCir.2003).ThecourtpointsoutthatalthoughCongressisentitledtonodeferenceinitsultimateconclusionthatrace‐consciousactioniswarranted,itsfact‐findingprocessisgenerallyentitledtoapresumptionofregularityanddeferentialreview.DynaLantic,at*10,citingRotheDev.Corp.v.U.S.Dep’tofDef.(“RotheIII“),262F.3d1306,1321n.14(Fed.Cir.2001).
![Page 389: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/389.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 263
ThecourtheldthatthefederalDefendantsstateacompellingpurposeinseekingtoremediateeitherpublicdiscriminationorprivatediscriminationinwhichthegovernmenthasbeena“passiveparticipant.”DynaLantic,at*11.TheCourtrejectedDynaLantic’sargumentthatthefederalDefendantscouldonlyseektoremedydiscriminationbyagovernmentalentity,ordiscriminationbyprivateindividualsdirectlyusinggovernmentfundstodiscriminate.DynaLantic,at*11.TheCourtheldthatitiswellestablishedthatthefederalgovernmenthasacompellinginterestinensuringthatitsfundingisnotdistributedinamannerthatperpetuatestheeffectofeitherpublicorprivatediscriminationwithinanindustryinwhichitprovidesfunding.DynaLantic,at*11,citingWesternStatesPavingv.WashingtonStateDOT,407F.3d983,991(9thCir.2005).
TheCourtnotedthatanypublicentity,stateorfederal,hasacompellinginterestinassuringthatpublicdollars,drawnfromthetaxdollarsofallcitizens,donotservetofinancetheevilsofprivateprejudice,andsuchprivateprejudicemaytaketheformofdiscriminatorybarrierstotheformationofqualifiedminoritybusinesses,precludingfromtheoutsetcompetitionforpubliccontractsbyminorityenterprises.DynaLanticat*11quotingCityofRichmondv.J.A.CrosonCo.,488U.S.469,492(1995),andAdarandConstructors,Inc.v.Slater,228F.3d1147,1167‐68(10thCir.2000).Inaddition,privateprejudicemayalsotaketheformof“discriminatorybarriers”to“faircompetitionbetweenminorityandnon‐minorityenterprises...precludingexistingminorityfirmsfromeffectivelycompetingforpublicconstructioncontracts.”DynaLantic,at*11,quotingAdarandVII,228F.3dat1168.
Thus,theCourtconcludedthatthegovernmentmayimplementrace‐consciousprogramsnotonlyforthepurposeofcorrectingitsowndiscrimination,butalsotopreventitselffromactingasa“passiveparticipant”inprivatediscriminationintherelevantindustriesormarkets.DynaLantic,at*11,citingConcreteWorksIV,321F.3dat958.
Evidence before Congress.TheCourtanalyzedthelegislativehistoryoftheSection8(a)program,andthenaddressedtheissueastowhethertheCourtislimitedtotheevidencebeforeCongresswhenitenactedSection8(a)in1978andreviseditin1988,orwhetheritcouldconsiderpost‐enactmentevidence.DynaLantic,at*16‐17.TheCourtfoundthatnearlyeverycircuitcourttoconsiderthequestionhasheldthatreviewingcourtsmayconsiderpost‐enactmentevidenceinadditiontoevidencethatwasbeforeCongresswhenitembarkedontheprogram.DynaLantic,at*17.TheCourtnotedthatpost‐enactmentevidenceisparticularlyrelevantwhenthestatuteisoverthirtyyearsold,andevidenceusedtojustifySection8(a)isstaleforpurposesofdeterminingacompellinginterestinthepresent.Id.TheCourtthenfollowedthe10thCircuitCourtofAppeals’approachinAdarandVII,andreviewedthepost‐enactmentevidenceinthreebroadcategories:(1)evidenceofbarrierstotheformationofqualifiedminoritycontractorsduetodiscrimination,(2)evidenceofdiscriminatorybarrierstofaircompetitionbetweenminorityandnon‐minoritycontractors,and(3)evidenceofdiscriminationinstateandlocaldisparitystudies.DynaLantic,at*17.
TheCourtfoundthatthegovernmentpresentedsufficientevidenceofbarrierstominoritybusinessformation,includingevidenceonrace‐baseddenialofaccesstocapitalandcredit,lendingdiscrimination,routineexclusionofminoritiesfromcriticalbusinessrelationships,particularlythroughclosedor“oldboy”businessnetworksthatmakeitespeciallydifficultforminority‐ownedbusinessestoobtainwork,andthatminoritiescontinuetoexperiencebarriers
![Page 390: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/390.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 264
tobusinessnetworks.DynaLantic,at*17‐21.TheCourtconsideredaspartoftheevidentiarybasisbeforeCongressmultipledisparitystudiesconductedthroughouttheUnitedStatesandsubmittedtoCongress,andqualitativeandquantitativetestimonysubmittedatCongressionalhearings.Id.
TheCourtalsofoundthatthegovernmentsubmittedsubstantialevidenceofbarrierstominoritybusinessdevelopment,includingevidenceofdiscriminationbyprimecontractors,privatesectorcustomers,suppliers,andbondingcompanies.DynaLantic,at*21‐23.TheCourtagainbasedthisfindingonrecentevidencesubmittedbeforeCongressintheformofdisparitystudies,reportsandCongressionalhearings.Id.
State and local disparity studies.AlthoughtheCourtnotedtherehavebeenhundredsofdisparitystudiesplacedbeforeCongress,theCourtconsidersinparticularstudiessubmittedbythefederalDefendantsof50disparitystudies,encompassingevidencefrom28statesandtheDistrictofColumbia,whichhavebeenbeforeCongresssince2006.DynaLantic,at*25‐29.TheCourtstateditreviewedthestudieswithafocusontwoindicatorsthatothercourtshavefoundrelevantinanalyzingdisparitystudies.First,theCourtconsideredthedisparityindicescalculated,whichwasadisparityindex,calculatedbydividingthepercentageofMBE,WBE,and/orDBEfirmsutilizedinthecontractingmarketbythepercentageofM/W/DBEfirmsavailableinthesamemarket.DynaLantic,at*26.TheCourtsaidthatnormally,adisparityindexof100demonstratesfullM/W/DBEparticipation;theclosertheindexistozero,thegreatertheM/W/DBEdisparityduetounderutilization.DynaLantic,at*26.
Second,theCourtreviewedthemethodbywhichstudiescalculatedtheavailabilityandcapacityofminorityfirms.DynaLantic,at*26.TheCourtnotedthatsomecourtshavelookedcloselyatthesefactorstoevaluatethereliabilityofthedisparityindices,reasoningthattheindicesarenotprobativeunlesstheyarerestrictedtofirmsofsignificantsizeandwithsignificantgovernmentcontractingexperience.DynaLantic,at*26.TheCourtpointedoutthatalthoughdiscriminatorybarrierstoformationanddevelopmentwouldimpactcapacity,theSupremeCourtdecisioninCrosonandtheCourtofAppealsdecisioninO’DonnellConstructionCo.v.DistrictofColumbia,etal.,963F.2d420(D.C.Cir.1992)“requiretheadditionalshowingthateligibleminorityfirmsexperiencedisparities,notwithstandingtheirabilities,inordertogiverisetoaninferenceofdiscrimination.”DynaLantic,at*26,n.10.
Analysis: Strong basis in evidence.Basedonananalysisofthedisparitystudiesandotherevidence,theCourtconcludedthatthegovernmentarticulatedacompellinginterestfortheSection8(a)programandsatisfieditsinitialburdenestablishingthatCongresshadastrongbasisinevidencepermittingrace‐consciousmeasurestobeusedundertheSection8(a)program.DynaLantic,at*29‐37.TheCourtheldthatDynaLanticdidnotmeetitsburdentoestablishthattheSection8(a)programisunconstitutionalonitsface,findingthatDynaLanticcouldnotshowthatCongressdidnothaveastrongbasisinevidenceforpermittingrace‐consciousmeasurestobeusedunderanycircumstances,inanysectororindustryintheeconomy.DynaLantic,at*29.
TheCourtdiscussedandanalyzedtheevidencebeforeCongress,whichincludedextensivestatisticalanalysis,qualitativeandquantitativeconsiderationoftheuniquechallengesfacingminoritiesfromallbusinesses,andanexaminationoftheirrace‐neutralmeasuresthathave
![Page 391: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/391.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 265
beenenactedbypreviousCongresses,buthadfailedtoreachtheminorityownedfirms.DynaLantic,at*31.TheCourtsaidCongresshadspentdecadescompilingevidenceofracediscriminationinavarietyofindustries,includingbutnotlimitedtoconstruction.DynaLantic,at*31.TheCourtalsofoundthatthefederalgovernmentproducedsignificantevidencerelatedtoprofessionalservices,architectureandengineering,andotherindustries.DynaLantic,at*31.TheCourtstatedthatthegovernmenthastherefore“establishedthatthereareatleastsomecircumstanceswhereitwouldbe‘necessaryorappropriate’fortheSBAtoawardcontractstobusinessesundertheSection8(a)program.DynaLantic,at*31,citing15U.S.C.§637(a)(1).
Therefore,theCourtconcludedthatinresponsetoplaintiff’sfacialchallenge,thegovernmentmetitsinitialburdentopresentastrongbasisinevidencesufficienttosupportitsarticulated,constitutionallyvalid,compellinginterest.DynaLantic,at*31.TheCourtalsofoundthattheevidencefromaroundthecountryissufficientforCongresstoauthorizeanationwideremedy.DynaLantic,at*31,n.13.
Rejection of DynaLantic’s rebuttal arguments.TheCourtheldthatsincethefederalDefendantsmadetheinitialshowingofacompellinginterest,theburdenshiftedtotheplaintifftoshowwhytheevidencereliedonbyDefendantsfailstodemonstrateacompellinggovernmentalinterest.DynaLantic,at*32.TheCourtrejectedeachofthechallengesbyDynaLantic,includingholdingthat:thelegislativehistoryissufficient;thegovernmentcompiledsubstantialevidencethatidentifiedprivateracialdiscriminationwhichaffectedminorityutilizationinspecificindustriesofgovernmentcontracting,bothbeforeandaftertheenactmentoftheSection8(a)program;anyflawsintheevidence,includingthedisparitystudies,DynaLantichasidentifiedinthedatadonotrisetothelevelofcredible,particularizedevidencenecessarytorebutthegovernment’sinitialshowingofacompellinginterest;DynaLanticcitednoauthorityinsupportofitsclaimthatfraudintheadministrationofrace‐consciousprogramsissufficienttoinvalidateSection8(a)programonitsface;andCongresshadstrongevidencethatthediscriminationissufficientlypervasiveacrossraciallinestojustifygrantingapreferenceforallfivegroupsincludedinSection8(a).DynaLantic,at*32‐36.
Inthisconnection,theCourtstateditagreedwithCrosonanditsprogenythatthegovernmentmayproperlybedeemeda“passiveparticipant”whenitfailstoadjustitsprocurementpracticestoaccountfortheeffectsofidentifiedprivatediscriminationontheavailabilityandutilizationofminority‐ownedbusinessesingovernmentcontracting.DynaLantic,at*34.Intermsofflawsintheevidence,theCourtpointedoutthattheproponentoftherace‐consciousremedialprogramisnotrequiredtounequivocallyestablishtheexistenceofdiscrimination,norisitrequiredtonegateallevidenceofnon‐discrimination.DynaLantic,at*35,citingConcreteWorkIV,321F.3dat991.Rather,astrongbasisinevidenceexists,theCourtstated,whenthereisevidenceapproachingaprimafaciecaseofaconstitutionalorstatutoryviolation,notirrefutableordefinitiveproofofdiscrimination.Id,citingCroson,488U.S.500.Accordingly,theCourtstatedthatDynaLantic’sclaimthatthegovernmentmustindependentlyverifytheevidencepresentedtoitisunavailing.Id.DynaLantic,at*35.
Also,intermsofDynaLantic’sargumentsaboutflawsintheevidence,theCourtnotedthatDefendantsplacedintherecordapproximately50disparitystudieswhichhadbeenintroducedordiscussedinCongressionalHearingssince2006,whichDynaLanticdidnotrebutorevendiscussanyofthestudiesindividually.DynaLantic,at*35.DynaLanticassertedgenerallythatthe
![Page 392: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/392.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 266
studiesdidnotcontrolforthecapacityofthefirmsatissue,andwerethereforeunreliable.Id.TheCourtpointedoutthatCongressneednothaveevidenceofdiscriminationinall50statestodemonstrateacompellinginterest,andthatinthiscase,thefederalDefendantspresentedrecentevidenceofdiscriminationinasignificantnumberofstatesandlocalitieswhich,takentogether,representsabroadcross‐sectionofthenation.DynaLantic,at*35,n.15.TheCourtstatedthatwhilenotallofthedisparitystudiesaccountedforthecapacityofthefirms,manyofthemdidcontrolforcapacityandstillfoundsignificantdisparitiesbetweenminorityandnon‐minorityownedfirms.DynaLantic,at*35.Inshort,theCourtfoundthatDynaLantic’s“generalcriticism”ofthemultitudeofdisparitystudiesdoesnotconstituteparticularevidenceunderminingthereliabilityoftheparticulardisparitystudiesandthereforeisoflittlepersuasivevalue.DynaLantic,at*35.
IntermsoftheargumentbyDynaLanticastorequiringproofofevidenceofdiscriminationagainsteachminoritygroup,theCourtstatedthatCongresshasastrongbasisinevidenceifitfindsevidenceofdiscriminationissufficientlypervasiveacrossraciallinestojustifygrantingapreferencetoallfivedisadvantagedgroupsincludedinSection8(a).TheCourtfoundCongresshadstrongevidencethatthediscriminationissufficientlypervasiveacrossraciallinestojustifyapreferencetoallfivegroups.DynaLantic,at*36.Thefactthatspecificevidencevaries,tosomeextent,withinandbetweenminoritygroups,wasnotabasistodeclarethisstatutefaciallyinvalid.DynaLantic,at*36.
Facial challenge: Conclusion.TheCourtconcludedCongresshadacompellinginterestineliminatingtherootsofracialdiscriminationinfederalcontractingandhadestablishedastrongbasisofevidencetosupportitsconclusionthatremedialactionwasnecessarytoremedythatdiscriminationbyprovidingsignificantevidenceinthreedifferentarea.First,itprovidedextensiveevidenceofdiscriminatorybarrierstominoritybusinessformation.DynaLantic,at*37.Second,itprovided“forceful”evidenceofdiscriminatorybarrierstominoritybusinessdevelopment.Id.Third,itprovidedsignificantevidencethat,evenwhenminoritybusinessesarequalifiedandeligibletoperformcontractsinboththepublicandprivatesectors,theyareawardedthesecontractsfarlessoftenthantheirsimilarlysituatednon‐minoritycounterparts.Id.TheCourtfoundtheevidencewasparticularlystrong,nationwide,intheconstructionindustry,andthattherewassubstantialevidenceofwidespreaddisparitiesinotherindustriessuchasarchitectureandengineering,andprofessionalservices.Id.
As‐applied challenge.DynaLanticalsochallengedtheSBAandDoD’suseoftheSection8(a)programasapplied:namely,theagencies’determinationthatitisnecessaryorappropriatetosetasidecontractsinthemilitarysimulationandtrainingindustry.DynaLantic,at*37.Significantly,theCourtpointsoutthatthefederalDefendants“concedethattheydonothaveevidenceofdiscriminationinthisindustry.”Id.Moreover,theCourtpointsoutthatthefederalDefendantsadmittedthatthere“isnoCongressionalreport,hearingorfindingthatreferences,discussesormentionsthesimulationandtrainingindustry.”DynaLantic,at*38.ThefederalDefendantsalsoadmitthattheyare“unawareofanydiscriminationinthesimulationandtrainingindustry.”Id.Inaddition,thefederalDefendantsadmitthatnoneofthedocumentstheyhavesubmittedasjustificationfortheSection8(a)programmentionsoridentifiesinstancesofpastorpresentdiscriminationinthesimulationandtrainingindustry.DynaLantic,at*38.
![Page 393: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/393.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 267
ThefederalDefendantsmaintainthatthegovernmentneednottieevidenceofdiscriminatorybarrierstominoritybusinessformationanddevelopmenttoevidenceofdiscriminationinanyparticularindustry.DynaLantic,at*38.TheCourtconcludesthatthefederalDefendants’positionisirreconcilablewithbindingauthorityupontheCourt,specifically,theUnitedStatesSupremeCourt’sdecisioninCroson,aswellastheFederalCircuit’sdecisioninO’DonnellConstructionCompany,whichadoptedCroson’sreasoning.DynaLantic,at*38.TheCourtholdsthatCrosonmadeclearthegovernmentmustprovideevidencedemonstratingtherewereeligibleminoritiesintherelevantmarket.DynaLantic,at*38.TheCourtheldthatabsentanevidentiaryshowingthat,inahighlyskilledindustrysuchasthemilitarysimulationandtrainingindustry,thereareeligibleminoritieswhoarequalifiedtoundertakeparticulartasksandareneverthelessdeniedtheopportunitytothrivethere,thegovernmentcannotcomplywithCroson’sevidentiaryrequirementtoshowaninferenceofdiscrimination.DynaLantic,at*39,citingCroson,488U.S.501.TheCourtrejectsthefederalgovernment’spositionthatitdoesnothavetomakeanindustry‐basedshowinginordertoshowstrongevidenceofdiscrimination.DynaLantic,at*40.
TheCourtnotesthattheDepartmentofJusticehasrecognizedthatthefederalgovernmentmusttakeanindustry‐basedapproachtodemonstratingcompellinginterest.DynaLantic,at*40,citingCortezIIIServiceCorp.v.NationalAeronautics&SpaceAdministration,950F.Supp.357(D.D.C.1996).InCortez,theCourtfoundtheSection8(a)programconstitutionalonitsface,butfoundtheprogramunconstitutionalasappliedtotheNASAcontractatissuebecausethegovernmenthadprovidednoevidenceofdiscriminationintheindustryinwhichtheNASAcontractwouldbeperformed.DynaLantic,at*40.TheCourtpointedoutthattheDepartmentofJusticehadadvisedfederalagenciestomakeindustry‐specificdeterminationsbeforeofferingset‐asidecontractsandspecificallycautionedthemthatwithoutsuchparticularizedevidence,set‐asideprogramsmaynotsurviveCrosonandAdarand.DynaLantic,at*40.
TheCourtrecognizedthatlegislationconsideredinCroson,AdarandandO’Donnellwereallrestrictedtooneindustry,whereasthiscasepresentsadifferentfactualscenario,becauseSection8(a)isnotindustry‐specific.DynaLantic,at*40,n.17.TheCourtnotedthatthegovernmentdidnotproposeanalternativeframeworktoCrosonwithinwhichtheCourtcananalyzetheevidence,andthatinfact,theevidencethegovernmentpresentedinthecaseisindustryspecific.Id.
TheCourtconcludedthatagencieshavearesponsibilitytodecideiftherehasbeenahistoryofdiscriminationintheparticularindustryatissue.DynaLantic,at*40.AccordingtotheCourt,itneednottakeaparty’sdefinitionof“industry”atfacevalue,andmaydeterminetheappropriateindustrytoconsiderisbroaderornarrowerthanthatproposedbytheparties.Id.However,theCourtstated,inthiscasethegovernmentdidnotarguewithplaintiff’sindustrydefinition,andmoresignificantly,itprovidednoevidencewhatsoeverfromwhichaninferenceofdiscriminationinthatindustrycouldbemade.DynaLantic,at*40.
Narrowly tailoring.Inadditiontoshowingstrongevidencethatarace‐consciousprogramservesacompellinginterest,thegovernmentisrequiredtoshowthatthemeanschosentoaccomplishthegovernment’sassertedpurposearespecificallyandnarrowlyframedtoaccomplishthatpurpose.DynaLantic,at*41.TheCourtconsideredseveralfactorsinthenarrowlytailoringanalysis:theefficacyofalternative,race‐neutralremedies,flexibility,over‐orunder‐
![Page 394: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/394.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 268
inclusivenessoftheprogram,duration,therelationshipbetweennumericalgoalsandtherelevantlabormarket,andtheimpactoftheremedyonthirdparties.Id.
TheCourtanalyzedeachofthesefactorsandfoundthatthefederalgovernmentsatisfiedallsixfactors.DynaLantic,at*41‐48.TheCourtfoundthatthefederalgovernmentpresentedsufficientevidencethatCongressattemptedtouserace‐neutralmeasurestofosterandassistminorityownedbusinessesrelatingtotherace‐consciouscomponentinSection8(a),andthattheserace‐neutralmeasuresfailedtoremedytheeffectsofdiscriminationonminoritysmallbusinessowners.DynaLantic,at*42.TheCourtfoundthattheSection8(a)programissufficientlyflexibleingrantingrace‐consciousreliefbecauseraceismaderelevantintheprogram,butitisnotadeterminativefactororarigidracialquotasystem.DynaLantic,at*43.TheCourtnotedthattheSection8(a)programcontainsawaiverprovisionandthattheSBAwillnotacceptaprocurementforawardasan8(a)contractifitdeterminesthatacceptanceoftheprocurementwouldhaveanadverseimpactonsmallbusinessesoperatingoutsidetheSection8(a)program.DynaLantic,at*44.
TheCourtfoundthattheSection8(a)programwasnotover‐andunder‐inclusivebecausethegovernmenthadstrongevidenceofdiscriminationwhichissufficientlypervasiveacrossraciallinestoallfivedisadvantagedgroups,andSection8(a)doesnotprovidethateverymemberofaminoritygroupisdisadvantaged.DynaLantic,at*44.Inaddition,theprogramisnarrowlytailoredbecauseitisbasednotonlyonsocialdisadvantage,butalsoonanindividualizedinquiryintoeconomicdisadvantage,andthatafirmownedbyanon‐minoritymayqualifyassociallyandeconomicallydisadvantaged.DynaLantic,at*44.
TheCourtalsofoundthattheSection8(a)programplacesanumberofstrictdurationallimitsonaparticularfirm’sparticipationintheprogram,placestemporallimitsoneveryindividual’sparticipationintheprogram,andthataparticipant’seligibilityiscontinuallyreassessedandmustbemaintainedthroughoutitsprogramterm.DynaLantic,at*45.Section8(a)’sinherenttimelimitandgraduationprovisionsensurethatitiscarefullydesignedtoendureonlyuntilthediscriminatoryimpacthasbeeneliminated,andthusitisnarrowlytailored.DynaLantic,at*46.
Inlightofthegovernment’sevidence,theCourtconcludedthattheaspirationalgoalsatissue,allofwhichwerelessthanfivepercentofcontractdollars,arefaciallyconstitutional.DynaLantic,at*46‐47.Theevidence,theCourtnoted,establishedthatminorityfirmsareready,willing,andabletoperformworkequaltotwotofivepercentofgovernmentcontractsinindustriesincludingbutnotlimitedtoconstruction.Id.TheCourtfoundtheeffectsofpastdiscriminationhaveexcludedminoritiesfromformingandgrowingbusinesses,andthenumberofavailableminoritycontractorsreflectsthatdiscrimination.DynaLantic,at*47.
Finally,theCourtfoundthattheSection8(a)programtakesappropriatestepstominimizetheburdenonthirdparties,andthattheSection8(a)programisnarrowlytailoredonitsface.DynaLantic,at*48.TheCourtconcludedthatthegovernmentisnotrequiredtoeliminatetheburdenonnon‐minoritiesinordertosurvivestrictscrutiny,butalimitedandproperlytailoredremedytocuretheeffectsofpriordiscriminationispermissibleevenwhenitburdensthirdparties.Id.TheCourtpointstoanumberofprovisionsdesignedtominimizetheburdenonnon‐minorityfirms,includingthepresumptionthataminorityapplicantissociallydisadvantagedmayberebutted,anindividualwhoisnotpresumptivelydisadvantagedmayqualifyforsuch
![Page 395: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/395.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 269
status,the8(a)programrequiresanindividualizeddeterminationofeconomicdisadvantage,anditisnotopentoindividualswhosenetworthexceeds$250,000regardlessofrace.Id.
Conclusion.TheCourtconcludedthattheSection8(a)programisconstitutionalonitsface.TheCourtalsoheldthatitisunabletoconcludethatthefederalDefendantshaveproducedevidenceofdiscriminationinthemilitarysimulationandtrainingindustrysufficienttodemonstrateacompellinginterest.Therefore,DynaLanticprevailedonitsas‐appliedchallenge.DynaLantic,at*51.Accordingly,theCourtgrantedthefederalDefendants’MotionforSummaryJudgmentinpart(holdingtheSection8(a)programisvalidonitsface)anddenieditinpart,andgrantedtheplaintiff’sMotionforSummaryJudgmentinpart(holdingtheprogramisinvalidasappliedtothemilitarysimulationandtrainingindustry)anddenieditinpart.TheCourtheldthattheSBAandtheDoDareenjoinedfromawardingprocurementsformilitarysimulatorsundertheSection8(a)programwithoutfirstarticulatingastrongbasisinevidencefordoingso.
Appeals voluntarily dismissed, and Stipulation and Agreement of Settlement Approved and
Ordered by District Court.ANoticeofAppealandNoticeofCrossAppealwerefiledinthiscasetotheUnitedStatesCourtofAppealsfortheDistrictofColumbiabytheUnitedStatusandDynaLantic:DocketNumbers12‐5329and12‐5330.Subsequently,theappealswerevoluntarilydismissed,andthepartiesenteredintoaStipulationandAgreementofSettlement,whichwasapprovedbytheDistrictCourt(Jan.30,2014).Thepartiesstipulatedandagreedinteralia,asfollows:(1)theFederalDefendantswereenjoinedfromawardingprimecontractsundertheSection8(a)programforthepurchaseofmilitarysimulationandmilitarysimulationtrainingcontractswithoutfirstarticulatingastrongbasisinevidencefordoingso;(2)theFederalDefendantsagreedtopayplaintiffthesumof$1,000,000.00;and(3)theFederalDefendantsagreedtheyshallrefrainfromseekingtovacatetheinjunctionenteredbytheCourtforatleasttwoyears.
TheDistrictCourtonJanuary30,2014approvedtheStipulationandAgreementofSettlement,andSoOrderedthetermsoftheoriginal2012injunctionmodifiedasprovidedintheStipulationandAgreementofSettlement.
5. DynaLantic Corp. v. United States Dept. of Defense, et al., 503 F. Supp.2d 262 (D.D.C. 2007)
DynaLanticCorp.involvedachallengetotheDOD’sutilizationoftheSmallBusinessAdministration’s(“SBA”)8(a)BusinessDevelopmentProgram(“8(a)Program”).InitsOrderofAugust23,2007,thedistrictcourtdeniedbothparties’MotionsforSummaryJudgmentbecausetherewasnoinformationintherecordregardingtheevidencebeforeCongresssupportingits2006reauthorizationoftheprograminquestion;thecourtdirectedthepartiestoproposefutureproceedingstosupplementtherecord.503F.Supp.2d262,263(D.D.C.2007).
Thecourtfirstexplainedthatthe8(a)Programsetsagoalthatnolessthan5percentoftotalprimefederalcontractandsubcontractawardsforeachfiscalyearbeawardedtosociallyandeconomicallydisadvantagedindividuals.Id.Eachfederalgovernmentagencyisrequiredtoestablishitsowngoalforcontractingbutthegoalsarenotmandatoryandthereisnosanctionforfailingtomeetthegoal.Uponapplicationandadmissionintothe8(a)Program,smallbusinessesownedandcontrolledbydisadvantagedindividualsareeligibletoreceive
![Page 396: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/396.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX B, PAGE 270
technological,financial,andpracticalassistance,andsupportthroughpreferentialawardofgovernmentcontracts.Forthepastfewyears,the8(a)ProgramwastheprimarypreferentialtreatmentprogramtheDODusedtomeetits5percentgoal.Id.at264.
ThiscasearosefromaNavycontractthattheDODdecidedtoawardexclusivelythroughthe8(a)Program.Theplaintiffownedasmallcompanythatwouldhavebidonthecontractbutforthefactitwasnotaparticipantinthe8(a)Program.AftermultiplejudicialproceedingstheD.C.Circuitdismissedtheplaintiff’sactionforlackofstandingbutgrantedtheplaintiff’smotiontoenjointhecontractprocurementpendingtheappealofthedismissalorder.TheNavycancelledtheproposedprocurementbuttheD.C.Circuitallowedtheplaintifftocircumventthemootnessargumentbyamendingitspleadingstoraiseafacialchallengetothe8(a)programasadministeredbytheSBAandutilizedbytheDOD.TheD.C.Circuitheldtheplaintiffhadstandingbecauseoftheplaintiff’sinabilitytocompeteforDODcontractsreservedto8(a)firms,theinjurywastraceabletotherace‐consciouscomponentofthe8(a)Program,andtheplaintiff’sinjurywasimminentduetothelikelihoodthegovernmentwouldinthefuturetrytoprocureanothercontractunderthe8(a)Programforwhichtheplaintiffwasready,willing,andabletobid.Id.at264‐65.
Onremand,theplaintiffamendeditscomplainttochallengetheconstitutionalityofthe8(a)Programandsoughtaninjunctiontopreventthemilitaryfromawardinganycontractformilitarysimulatorsbasedupontheraceofthecontractors.Id.at265.Thedistrictcourtfirstheldthattheplaintiff’scomplaintcouldbereadonlyasachallengetotheDOD’simplementationofthe8(a)Program[pursuantto10U.S.C.§2323]asopposedtoachallengetotheprogramasawhole.Id.at266.Thepartiesagreedthatthe8(a)Programusesrace‐consciouscriteriasothedistrictcourtconcludeditmustbeanalyzedunderthestrictscrutinyconstitutionalstandard.Thecourtfoundthatinordertoevaluatethegovernment’sproffered“compellinggovernmentinterest,”thecourtmustconsidertheevidencethatCongressconsideredatthepointofauthorizationorreauthorizationtoensurethatithadastrongbasisinevidenceofdiscriminationrequiringremedialaction.ThecourtcitedtoWesternStatesPavinginsupportofthisproposition.Id.ThecourtconcludedthatbecausetheDODprogramwasreauthorizedin2006,thecourtmustconsidertheevidencebeforeCongressin2006.
ThecourtcitedtotherecentRothedecisionasdemonstratingthatCongressconsideredsignificantevidentiarymaterialsinitsreauthorizationoftheDODprogramin2006,includingsixrecentlypublisheddisparitystudies.Thecourtheldthatbecausetherecordbeforeitinthepresentcasedidnotcontaininformationregardingthis2006evidencebeforeCongress,itcouldnotruleontheparties’MotionsforSummaryJudgment.Thecourtdeniedbothmotionsanddirectedthepartiestoproposefutureproceedingsinordertosupplementtherecord.Id.at267.
![Page 397: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/397.jpg)
APPENDIX C.
Quantitative Analysis
![Page 398: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/398.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX C, PAGE 1
APPENDIX C. Quantitative Analysis
Figure C‐1. Percentage of workers 25 and older with at least a four‐year college degree, Denver and the United States, 2012‐2016
Note:
**/++ Denotes that the difference in proportions between the minority group and non‐Hispanic whites (or between women and men) is statistically significant at the 95% confidence levels for Denver and the United States as a whole, respectively.
† Denotes that significant differences in proportions were not reported due to small sample size.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting from 2012‐2016 ACS 5% Public Use Microdata sample. The raw data extract was obtained through the IPUMS program of the MN Population Center: http://usa.ipums.org/usa/.
FigureC‐1indicatesthat,comparedtonon‐HispanicwhiteAmericansworkinginDenver,smallerpercentagesofBlackAmericans,AsianPacificAmericans,HispanicAmericans,andNativeAmericanshavefour‐yearcollegedegrees.Incontrast,comparedtonon‐HispanicwhiteAmericansandmen,alargerpercentageofSubcontinentAsianAmericansandwomenworkinginDenverhavefour‐yearcollegedegrees,respectively.
![Page 399: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/399.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX C, PAGE 2
Figure C‐2. Percent representation of minorities in various industries in Denver, 2012‐2016
Note: *, ** Denotes that the difference in proportions between minority workers in the specified industry and all industries is statistically significant at the 90% and 95% confidence level, respectively.
The representation of minorities among all Denver workers is 5 percent for Black Americans, 19 percent for Hispanic Americans, 4 percent for Asian Pacific Americans, 1 percent for Subcontinent Asian Americans, 1 percent for Other race minorities, and 30 percent for all minorities considered together.
Workers in the finance, insurance, real estate, legal services, accounting, advertising, architecture, management, and scientific research industries were combined to one category of Architecture & Engineering; Workers in the rental and leasing, travel, investigation, waste remediation, arts, entertainment, recreation, accommodations, food services, and select other services were combined into one category of Other services; Workers in child day care services, barber shops, beauty salons, nail salons, and other personal were combined into one category of childcare, hair, and nails.
Source: BBC Research & Consulting from 2012‐2016 ACS 5% Public Use Microdata sample. The raw data extract was obtained through the IPUMS program of the MN Population Center: http://usa.ipums.org/usa/.
FigureC‐2indicatesthattheDenverindustrieswiththehighestrepresentationsofminorityworkersareconstruction;otherservices;andchildcare,hair,andnails.TheDenverindustrieswiththelowestrepresentationsofminorityworkersareextractionandagriculture;education;andarchitectureandengineering.
![Page 400: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/400.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX C, PAGE 3
Figure C‐3. Percent representation of women in various industries in Denver, 2012‐2016
Note: ** Denotes that the difference in proportions between women workers in the specified industry and all industries is statistically significant at the 95% confidence level.
The representation of women among all Denver workers is 46 percent.
Workers in the finance, insurance, real estate, legal services, accounting, advertising, architecture, management, and scientific research industries were combined to one category of Architecture & Engineering; Workers in the rental and leasing, travel, investigation, waste remediation, arts, entertainment, recreation, accommodations, food services, and select other services were combined into one category of Other services; Workers in child day care services, barber shops, beauty salons, nail salons, and other personal were combined into one category of childcare, hair, and nails.
Source: BBC Research & Consulting from 2012‐2016 ACS 5% Public Use Microdata sample. The raw data extract was obtained through the IPUMS program of the MN Population Center: http://usa.ipums.org/usa/.
FigureC‐3indicatesthattheDenverindustrieswiththehighestrepresentationsofwomenworkersarechildcare,hair,andnails;healthcare;andeducation.TheDenverindustrieswiththelowestrepresentationsofwomenworkersareextractionandagriculture;manufacturing;andconstruction.
![Page 401: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/401.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX C, PAGE 4
Figure C‐4. Race/ethnicity and gender of workers in study‐related industries and all industries, Denver and the United States, 2012‐2016
Note: ** Denotes that the difference in proportions between workers in each study‐related industry and workers in all industries is statistically significant at the 95% confidence level.
Source: BBC Research & Consulting from 2012‐2016 ACS 5% Public Use Microdata sample. The raw data extract was obtained through the IPUMS program of the MN Population Center: http://usa.ipums.org/usa/.
FigureC‐4indicatesthattherearesmallerpercentagesofAsianPacificAmericans,BlackAmericans,andwomenworkingintheDenverconstructionindustrythaninallindustriesconsideredtogether.Inaddition,therearesmallerpercentagesofBlackAmericans,HispanicAmericans,andwomenworkingintheprofessionalservicesindustrythaninallindustriesconsideredtogether.Finally,thereisalargerpercentageofwomenworkinginthegoodsandservicesindustrythanallindustriesconsideredtogether.
Denver
Race/ethnicity
Black American 4.5 % 1.8 % ** 3.5 % ** 5.1 %
Asian Pacific American 2.7 % 1.0 % ** 2.5 % 2.5 %
Subcontinent Asian American 0.4 % 0.0 % 1.3 % ** 0.9 %
Hispanic American 14.2 % 28.1 % ** 6.8 % ** 13.4 %
Native American 1.1 % 1.6 % 0.8 % 1.1 %
Other race minority 0.4 % 0.4 % 0.4 % 0.4 %
Total minority 23.4 % 32.9 % 15.3 % 23.4 %
Non‐Hispanic white 76.6 % 67.1 % ** 84.7 % ** 76.6 %
Total 100.0 % 100.0 % 100.0 % 100.0 %
Gender
Women 45.5 % 10.9 % ** 43.9 % ** 35.3 % **
Men 54.5 % 89.1 % ** 56.1 % ** 64.7 % **
Total 100.0 % 100.0 % 100.0 % 100.0 %
United States
Race/ethnicity
Black American 10.9 % 6.2 % ** 9.0 % ** 10.8 % **
Asian Pacific American 3.4 % 1.2 % ** 4.4 % ** 3.2 % **
Subcontinent Asian American 0.7 % 0.2 % ** 1.9 % ** 0.9 % **
Hispanic American 10.7 % 15.0 % ** 7.0 % ** 10.9 % **
Native American 1.2 % 1.6 % ** 0.9 % ** 1.0 % **
Other race minority 0.4 % 0.4 % 0.4 % 0.5 %
Total minority 27.3 % 24.5 % 23.6 % 27.2 %
Non‐Hispanic white 72.7 % 75.5 % ** 76.4 % ** 72.8 %
Total 100.0 % 100.0 % 100.0 % 100.0 %
Gender
Women 46.5 % 9.9 % ** 46.0 % ** 31.9 % **
Men 53.5 % 90.1 % ** 54.0 % ** 68.1 % **
Total 100.0 % 100.0 % 100.0 % 100.0 %
All Industries
(n=59,067)
All Industries
(n=6,832,970)
Construction
(n=480,280)
(n=4,770)
Construction
Goods &
Services
(n=9,187)
Goods &
Services
(n=926,709)
Professional
Services
(n=370,271)
(n=5,758)
Professional
Services
![Page 402: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/402.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX C, PAGE 5
Figure C‐5. Percent representation of minorities in construction occupations in Denver, 2012‐2016
Note: * Denotes that the difference in proportions between minority workers in the specified occupation and all construction occupations considered together is statistically significant at the 90% confidence level.
† Denotes that significant differences in proportions were not reported due to small sample size.
The representation of minorities among all Denver construction workers is 2 percent for Black Americans, 39 percent for Hispanic Americans, 1 percent for Asian Pacific Americans, 0 percent for Subcontinent Asian Americans, 1 percent for Native Americans, 0 percent for Other race minorities, and 43 percent for all minorities considered together.
Data on plasterers and stucco masons are not presented, because none were found in the study area sample.
Crane and tower operators, dredge, excavating and loading machine operators, paving, surfacing and tamping equipment operators and other construction equipment operators were combined into the single category of miscellaneous construction equipment operators.
Source: BBC Research & Consulting from 2012‐2016 ACS 5% sample. The raw data extract was obtained through the IPUMS program of the MN Population Center: http://usa.ipums.org/usa/.
FigureC‐5indicatesthattheDenverconstructionoccupationswiththehighestrepresentationsofminorityworkersarecementmasonandterrazzoworkers;roofers;anddrywallinstallers,ceilingtileinstallers,andtapers.TheDenverconstructionoccupationswiththelowestrepresentationsofminorityworkersaresheetmetalworkers;ironandsteelworkers;andsecretaries.
![Page 403: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/403.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX C, PAGE 6
Figure C‐6. Percent representation of women in selected construction occupations in Denver, 2012‐2016
Note: *, ** Denotes that the difference in proportions between women workers in the specified occupation and all construction occupations considered together is statistically significant at the 90% and 95% confidence level, respectively.
† Denotes that significant differences in proportions were not reported due to small sample size.
The representation of women among all Denver construction workers is 10 percent.
Data on plasterers and stucco masons are not presented, because none were found in the study area sample.
Crane and tower operators, dredge, excavating and loading machine operators, paving, surfacing and tamping equipment operators and other construction equipment operators were combined into the single category of miscellaneous construction equipment operators.
Source: BBC Research & Consulting from 2012‐2016 ACS 5% sample. The raw data extract was obtained through the IPUMS program of the MN Population Center: http://usa.ipums.org/usa/.
FigureC‐6indicatesthattheDenverconstructionoccupationswiththehighestrepresentationsofwomenworkersaresecretaries;painters;andsheetmetalworkers.TheDenverconstructionoccupationswiththelowestrepresentationsofwomenworkersarebrickmasons,blockmasons,andstonemasons;cementmasonsandterrazzoworkers;ironandsteelworkers;andhelpers.
![Page 404: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/404.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX C, PAGE 7
Figure C‐7. Percentage of workers who worked as a manager in each study‐related industry, Denver and the United States, 2012‐2016
Note:
*, ** Denotes that the difference in proportions between the minority group and non‐Hispanic whites (or between women and men) is statistically significant at the 90% and 95% confidence level, respectively.
† Denotes that significant differences in proportions were not reported due to small sample size.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting from 2012‐2016 ACS 5% Public Use Microdata sample. The raw data extract was obtained through the IPUMS program of the MN Population Center: http://usa.ipums.org/usa/.
FigureC‐7indicatesthat,comparedtonon‐HispanicwhiteAmericans,smallerpercentagesofBlackAmericans,HispanicAmericans,andNativeAmericansworkasmanagersintheDenverconstructionindustry.SmallerpercentagesofBlackAmericans,AsianPacificAmericans,andHispanicAmericansworkasmanagersintheDenverprofessionalservicesindustry.Inaddition,smallerpercentagesofBlackAmericans,AsianPacificAmericans,HispanicAmericans,andNativeAmericansworkasmanagersintheDenvergoodsandservicesindustry.Inaddition,comparedtomen,asmallerpercentageofwomenworkasmanagersintheDenvergoodsandservicesindustry.Incontrast,alargerpercentageofwomenthanmenworkasmanagersintheDenverconstructionindustry.
Denver
Race/ethnicity
Black American 5.6 % ** 6.2 % ** 3.7 % **
Asian Pacific American 12.2 % 5.8 % ** 4.4 % **
Subcontinent Asian American 0.0 % † 9.0 % 9.7 %
Hispanic American 2.6 % ** 6.4 % ** 2.5 % **
Native American 3.9 % ** 11.3 % 3.3 % **
Other Race Minority 6.9 % † 0.0 % † 0.0 % *
Non‐Hispanic white 16.8 % 9.8 % 8.6 %
Gender
Women 14.5 % ** 8.7 % 6.3 % *
Men 10.5 % 9.5 % 7.3 %
All individuals 10.9 % 9.2 % 6.9 %
United States
Race/ethnicity
Black American 5.0 % ** 4.4 % ** 2.2 % **
Asian Pacific American 10.4 % 6.7 ** 5.7 %
Subcontinent Asian American 14.3 % ** 9.4 9.2 % **
Hispanic American 3.1 % ** 5.5 ** 2.3 % **
Native American 5.8 % ** 6.5 ** 3.3 % **
Other Race Minority 6.3 % ** 5.8 ** 3.9 % **
Non‐Hispanic white 10.5 % 9.1 % 5.9 %
Gender
Women 10.0 % ** 6.9 % ** 4.3 % **
Men 8.0 % 9.1 % 5.2 %
All individuals 10.9 % 8.1 % 4.9 %
Construction
Goods &
Services
Goods &
Services
Construction
Professional
Services
Professional
Services
![Page 405: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/405.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX C, PAGE 8
Figure C‐8. Mean annual wages, Denver and the United States, 2012‐2016
Note:
The sample universe is all non‐institutionalized, employed individuals aged 25‐64 that are not in school, the military, or self‐employed.
**/++ Denotes statistically significant differences from non‐Hispanic whites (for minority groups) or from men (for women) at the 95% confidence level for Denver and the United States as a whole, respectively.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting from 2012‐2016 ACS 5% Public Use Microdata sample. The raw data extract was obtained through the IPUMS program of the MN Population Center: http://usa.ipums.org/usa/.
FigureC‐8indicatesthat,comparedtonon‐HispanicwhiteAmericans,BlackAmericans,HispanicAmericans,NativeAmericans,andotherraceminoritiesinDenverexhibitlowermeanannualwages.Inaddition,womeninDenverexhibitlowermeanannualwagesthanmen.Incontrast,comparedtonon‐HispanicwhiteAmericans,SubcontinentAsianAmericansexhibithighermeanannualwages.
![Page 406: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/406.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX C, PAGE 9
Figure C‐9. Predictors of annual wages (regression), Denver, 2012‐2016
Note:
The regression model includes 45,861 observations.
The sample universe is all non‐institutionalized, employed individuals aged 25‐64 that are not in school, the military, or self‐employed.
For ease of interpretation, the exponentiated form of the coefficients is displayed in the figure.
*, ** Denotes statistical significance at the 90% and 95% confidence levels, respectively.
The referent for each set of categorical variables is as follows: non‐Hispanic whites for the race variables, high school diploma for the education variables, manufacturing for industry variables.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting from 2012‐2016 ACS 5% Public Use Microdata sample. The raw data extract was obtained through the IPUMS program of the MN Population Center: http://usa.ipums.org/usa/.
FigureC‐9indicatesthat,comparedtobeinganon‐HispanicwhiteAmericaninDenver,beingBlackAmerican,AsianPacificAmerican,SubcontinentAsianAmerican,HispanicAmerican,NativeAmerican,orotherraceminorityisrelatedtolowerannualwages,evenafteraccountingforvariousotherpersonalcharacteristics.(Forexample,themodelindicatesthatbeingBlackAmericanisassociatedwithmakingapproximately$0.76foreverydollarthatanon‐HispanicwhiteAmericanmakes,allelsebeingequal.)Inaddition,beingawomanisrelatedtolowerannualwagescomparedtobeingamaninDenver,evenafteraccountingforvariousotherpersonalcharacteristics.
Variable
Constant 7425.547 **
Black American 0.764 **
Asian Pacific American 0.869 **
Subcontinent Asian American 0.913 **
Hispanic American 0.877 **
Native American 0.850 **
Other minority group 0.862 *
Women 0.800 **
Less than high school education 0.836 **
Some college 1.153 **
Four‐year degree 1.560 **
Advanced degree 2.047 **
Disabled 0.799 **
Military experience 0.998
Speaks English well 1.260 **
Age 1.067 **
Age‐squared 0.999 **
Married 1.114 **
Children 1.023 **
Number of people over 65 in household 0.891 **
Public sector worker 1.067 **
Manager 1.275 **
Part time worker 0.350 **
Extraction and agriculture 1.340 **
Construction 0.882 **
Wholesale trade 0.969
Retail trade 0.714 **
Transportation, warehouse, & information 1.010
Professional services 1.051 **
Education 0.618 **
Health care 1.001
Other services 0.692 **
Public administration and social services 0.837 **
Exponentiated
Coefficient
![Page 407: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/407.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX C, PAGE 10
Figure C‐10. Predictors of annual wages (regression), United States, 2012‐2016
Note:
The regression model includes 4,032,836 observations.
The sample universe is all non‐institutionalized, employed individuals aged 25‐64 that are not in school, the military, or self‐employed.
For ease of interpretation, the exponentiated form of the coefficients is displayed in the figure.
** Denotes statistical significance at the 95% confidence level.
The referent for each set of categorical variables is as follows: non‐Hispanic whites for the race variables, high school diploma for the education variables, manufacturing for industry variables, and Northeast for region variables.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting from 2012‐2016 ACS 5% Public Use Microdata sample. The raw data extract was obtained through the IPUMS program of the MN Population Center: http://usa.ipums.org/usa/.
FigureC‐10indicatesthat,comparedtobeinganon‐HispanicwhiteAmericanintheUnitedStates,beingBlackAmerican,AsianPacificAmerican,SubcontinentAsianAmerican,HispanicAmerican,NativeAmerican,orotherraceminorityisrelatedtolowerannualwages,evenafteraccountingforvariousotherpersonalcharacteristics.(Forexample,themodelindicatesthatbeingBlackAmericanisassociatedwithmakingapproximately$0.86foreverydollarthatanon‐HispanicwhiteAmericanmakes,allelsebeingequal.)Inaddition,beingawomanisrelatedtolowerannualwagescomparedtobeingaman,evenafteraccountingforvariousotherpersonalcharacteristics.
Variable
Constant 7784.638 **
Black American 0.856 **
Asian Pacific American 0.958 **
Subcontinent Asian American 0.976 **
Hispanic American 0.911 **
Native American 0.881 **
Other minority group 0.908 **
Women 0.781 **
Less than high school education 0.854 **
Some college 1.197 **
Four‐year degree 1.669 **
Advanced degree 2.307 **
Disabled 0.794 **
Military experience 0.999
Speaks English well 1.353 **
Age 1.058 **
Age‐squared 0.999 **
Married 1.121 **
Children 1.011 **
Number of people over 65 in household 0.905 **
Midwest 0.881 **
South 0.895 **
West 0.986 **
Public sector worker 1.109 **
Manager 1.305 **
Part time worker 0.363 **
Extraction and agriculture 0.958 **
Construction 0.930 **
Wholesale trade 0.967 **
Retail trade 0.751 **
Transportation, warehouse, & information 1.031 **
Professional services 1.062 **
Education 0.657 **
Health care 1.000
Other services 0.710 **
Public administration and social services 0.824 **
Exponentiated
Coefficient
![Page 408: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/408.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX C, PAGE 11
Figure C‐11. Home Ownership Rates, Denver and the United States, 2012‐2016
Note:
The sample universe is all households.
**, ++ Denotes statistically significant differences from non‐Hispanic whites at the 95% confidence level for Denver and the United States as a whole, respectively.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting from 2012‐2016 ACS 5% Public Use Microdata sample. The raw data extract was obtained through the IPUMS program of the MN Population Center: http://usa.ipums.org/usa/.
FigureC‐11indicatesthat,comparedtonon‐HispanicwhiteAmericans,smallerpercentagesofBlackAmericans,AsianPacificAmericans,SubcontinentAsianAmericans,HispanicAmericans,andNativeAmericansinDenverownhomes.
![Page 409: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/409.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX C, PAGE 12
Figure C‐12. Median home values, Denver and the United States, 2012‐2016
Note:
The sample universe is all owner‐occupied housing units.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting from 2012‐2016 ACS 5% Public Use Microdata sample. The raw data extract was obtained through the IPUMS program of the MN Population Center: http://usa.ipums.org/usa/.
FigureC‐12indicatesthatBlackAmerican,AsianPacificAmerican,HispanicAmerican,NativeAmerican,andotherraceminorityhomeownersinDenverownhomesoflowermedianvaluesthannon‐HispanicwhiteAmericanhomeowners.Incontrast,SubcontinentAsianAmericanhomeownersinDenverownhomesofhighermedianvaluesthannon‐HispanicwhiteAmericanhomeowners.
![Page 410: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/410.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX C, PAGE 13
Figure C‐13. Denial rates of conventional purchase loans for high‐income households, Denver and the United States, 2016
Note:
High‐income borrowers are those households with 120% or more of the HUD area median family income (MFI).
Source:
FFIEC HMDA data. The raw data extract was obtained from the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau HMDA data tool: http://www.consumerfinance.gov/hmda/explore.
FigureC‐13indicatesthatin2016BlackAmericans;AsianAmericans;HispanicAmericans;NativeAmericans;andNativeHawaiianorOtherPacificIslandersinDenverweredeniedconventionalhomepurchaseloansatagreaterratethannon‐HispanicwhiteAmericans.
![Page 411: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/411.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX C, PAGE 14
Figure C‐14. Percent of conventional home purchase loans that were subprime, Denver and the United States, 2016
Source:
FFIEC HMDA data 2016. The raw data extract was obtained from the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau HMDA data tool: http://www.consumerfinance.gov/hmda/explore.
FigureC‐14indicatesthatin2016BlackAmericans;HispanicAmericans;NativeAmericans;andNativeHawaiianorOtherPacificIslandersinDenverwereawardedsubprimeconventionalhomepurchaseloansatagreaterratethannon‐HispanicwhiteAmericans.
![Page 412: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/412.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX C, PAGE 15
Figure C‐15. Business loan denial rates, Mountain Division and the United States, 2003
Note:
** Denotes that the difference in proportions from businesses owned by non‐Hispanic white men is statistically significant at the 95% confidence level.
The Mountain Census Division consists of Arizona, Colorado, Idaho, New Mexico, Montana, Utah, Nevada, and Wyoming.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting from 2003 Survey of Small Business Finance.
FigureC‐15indicatesthat,in2003,BlackAmerican‐ownedbusinessesintheUnitedStatesweredeniedbusinessloansatagreaterratethanbusinessesownedbynon‐Hispanicwhitemen.
![Page 413: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/413.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX C, PAGE 16
Figure C‐16. Businesses that did not apply for loans due to fear of denial, Mountain Division and the United States, 2003
Note:
** Denotes that the difference in proportions from businesses owned by non‐Hispanic white men is statistically significant at the 95% confidence level.
The Mountain Census Division consists of Arizona, Colorado, Idaho, New Mexico, Montana, Utah, Nevada, and Wyoming.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting from 2003 Survey of Small Business Finance.
FigureC‐16indicatesthat,in2003,BlackAmerican‐,HispanicAmerican‐,andnon‐Hispanicwhitewoman‐ownedbusinessesintheUnitedStatesweremorelikelythanbusinessesownedbynon‐Hispanicwhitementonotapplyforbusinessloansduetoafearofdenial.
![Page 414: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/414.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX C, PAGE 17
Figure C‐17. Mean values of approved business loans, Mountain Division and the United States, 2003
Note:
**, ++ Denotes statistically significant differences from non‐Hispanic white men (for minority groups and women) at the 95% confidence level for the United States as a whole and the South Atlantic Division, respectively.
The Mountain Census Division consists of Arizona, Colorado, Idaho, New Mexico, Montana, Utah, Nevada, and Wyoming.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting from 2003 Survey of Small Business Finance.
FigureC‐17indicatesthat,in2003,minority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesintheUnitedStateswhoreceivedbusinessloanswereapprovedforloansthatwereworthlessthanthosethatbusinessesownedbynon‐Hispanicwhitemenreceived.
![Page 415: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/415.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX C, PAGE 18
Figure C‐18. Self‐employment rates in study‐related industries, Denver and the United States, 2012‐2016
Note:
*, ** Denotes that the difference in proportions between the minority group and non‐Hispanic whites (or between women and men) is statistically significant at the 90% and 95% confidence level, respectively.
† Denotes that significant differences in proportions were not reported due to small sample size.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting from 2012‐2016 ACS 5% Public Use Microdata samples. The raw data extract was obtained through the IPUMS program of the MN Population Center: http://usa.ipums.org/usa/.
FigureC‐18indicatesthat,comparedtonon‐HispanicwhiteAmericans,BlackAmericans,AsianPacificAmericans,andHispanicAmericansexhibitedlowerratesofself‐employment(i.e.,businessownership)intheDenverconstructionindustry;BlackAmericans,AsianPacificAmericans,SubcontinentAsianAmericans,andHispanicAmericansexhibitedlowerratesofself‐employmentintheDenverprofessionalservicesindustry;andBlackAmericans,SubcontinentAsianAmericans,andHispanicAmericansexhibitedlowerratesofself‐employmentintheDenvergoodsandservicesindustry.Inaddition,womenworkingintheDenverconstructionindustryexhibitedlowerratesofself‐employmentthanmen.
Denver
Race/ethnicity
Black American 14.3 % ** 7.9 % ** 6.8 % **
Asian Pacific American 17.9 % * 7.8 % ** 11.3 %
Subcontinent Asian American 0.0 % † 3.3 % ** 5.8 % **
Hispanic American 11.8 % ** 11.8 % ** 10.3 % **
Native American 18.2 % 15.5 % 16.3 %
Other Race Minority 23.9 % † 4.8 % † 6.6 %
Non‐Hispanic white 27.3 % 20.0 % 14.2 %
Gender
Women 16.4 % ** 19.4 % ** 13.3 %
Men 21.4 % 16.9 % 12.5 %
All individuals 20.9 % 17.9 % 12.8 %
United States
Race/ethnicity
Black American 17.8 % ** 8.2 % ** 7.3 % **
Asian Pacific American 23.2 % ** 11.5 % ** 11.4 % **
Subcontinent Asian American 22.9 % ** 7.5 % ** 8.4 % **
Hispanic American 17.7 % ** 11.4 % ** 12.0 % **
Native American 18.4 % ** 15.4 % ** 14.1 %
Other Race Minority 23.1 % 13.5 % ** 13.4 %
Non‐Hispanic white 26.1 % 18.9 % 14.4 %
Gender
Women 16.1 % ** 15.2 % ** 12.7 % **
Men 24.0 % 16.7 % 13.0 %
All individuals 23.2 % 16.0 % 12.9 %
Construction
Construction
Goods &
Services
Goods &
Services
Professional
Services
Professional
Services
![Page 416: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/416.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX C, PAGE 19
Figure C‐19. Predictors of business ownership in construction (probit regression), Denver, 2012‐2016
Note:
The regression includes 4,740 observations.
*,** Denote statistical significance at the 90% and 95% confidence levels, respectively.
Subcontinent Asian omitted from regression due to small sample size.
The referent for each set of categorical variables is as follows: high school diploma for the education variables and non‐Hispanic whites for the race variables.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting from 2012‐2016 ACS 5% Public Use Microdata samples. The raw data extract was obtained through the IPUMS program of the MN Population Center: http://usa.ipums.org/usa.
FigureC‐19indicatesthat,comparedtobeinganon‐HispanicwhiteAmericaninDenver,beingHispanicAmericanisrelatedtoalowerlikelihoodofowningaconstructionbusiness,evenafteraccountingforvariousotherpersonalcharacteristics.Inaddition,comparedortobeingamaninDenver,beingawomanisrelatedtoalowerlikelihoodofowningaconstructionbusiness,evenafteraccountingforvariousotherpersonalcharacteristics.
Variable
Constant ‐2.5441 **
Age 0.0576 **
Age‐squared ‐0.0004 **
Married 0.0149
Disabled 0.0686
Number of children in household ‐0.0172
Number of people over 65 in household 0.1727 **
Owns home ‐0.0775
Home value ($000s) 0.0003 **
Monthly mortgage payment ($000s) 0.0086
Interest and dividend income ($000s) 0.0031
Income of spouse or partner ($0000s) 0.0012 **
Speaks English well 0.3470 **
Less than high school education ‐0.0863
Some college ‐0.0381
Four‐year degree ‐0.1920 **
Advanced degree ‐0.3448 **
Black American ‐0.3021
Asian Pacific American ‐0.1058
Subcontinent Asian American 0.0000 **
Hispanic American ‐0.3820 **
Native American ‐0.1239
Other minority group 0.1749
Women ‐0.4076 **
Coefficient
![Page 417: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/417.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX C, PAGE 20
Figure C‐20. Disparities in business ownership rates for Denver construction workers, 2012‐2016
Note: The benchmark figure can only be estimated for records with observed (rather than imputed) dependent variable values. Thus, the study team made comparisons between actual and benchmark self‐employment rates only for the subset of the sample for which the dependent variable was observed.
Analyses are limited to those groups that showed negative coefficients that were statistically significant in the regression model.
Source: BBC Research & Consulting from 2012‐2016 ACS 5% Public Use Microdata samples. The raw data extract was obtained through the IPUMS program of the MN Population Center: http://usa.ipums.org/usa/.
FigureC‐20indicatesthatHispanicAmericansownconstructionbusinessesinDenverataratethatis31percentthatofsimilarly‐situatednon‐HispanicwhiteAmericans.Inaddition,non‐HispanicwhitewomenownconstructionbusinessesinDenverataratethatis59percentthatofsimilarly‐situatednon‐Hispanicwhitemen.
Group
Hispanic American 11.7% 38.0% 31
Non‐Hispanic white women 17.9% 30.3% 59
Self‐Employment Rate Disparity Index
Actual Benchmark (100 = Parity)
![Page 418: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/418.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX C, PAGE 21
Figure C‐21. Predictors of business ownership in professional services (regression), Denver, 2012‐2016
Note:
The regression includes 8,873 observations.
*, ** Denote statistical significance at the 90% and 95% confidence levels, respectively.
The referent for each set of categorical variables is as follows: high school diploma for the education variables and non‐Hispanic whites for the race variables.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting from 2012‐2016 ACS 5% Public Use Microdata samples. The raw data extract was obtained through the IPUMS program of the MN Population Center: http://usa.ipums.org/usa/.
FigureC‐21indicatesthat,comparedtobeinganon‐HispanicwhiteAmericaninDenver,beingBlackAmerican,AsianPacificAmerican,orSubcontinentAsianAmericanisrelatedtoalowerlikelihoodofowningaprofessionalservicesbusiness,evenafteraccountingforvariousotherpersonalcharacteristics.Incontrast,comparedortobeingamaninDenver,beingawomanisrelatedtoagreaterlikelihoodofowningaprofessionalservicesbusiness,evenafteraccountingforvariousotherpersonalcharacteristics.
Variable
Constant ‐3.8493 **
Age 0.0500 **
Age‐squared ‐0.0003 *
Married ‐0.0259
Disabled ‐0.0293
Number of children in household 0.0271
Number of people over 65 in household 0.0826 *
Owns home ‐0.2009 **
Home value ($000s) 0.0004 **
Monthly mortgage payment ($000s) 0.0022
Interest and dividend income ($000s) 0.0018 *
Income of spouse or partner ($0000s) 0.0009 **
Speaks English well 0.8884 **
Less than high school education 0.2545
Some college 0.2036 **
Four‐year degree 0.3517 **
Advanced degree 0.3078 **
Black American ‐0.3617 **
Asian Pacific American ‐0.4676 **
Subcontinent Asian American ‐0.7729 **
Hispanic American ‐0.1151
Native American 0.0590
Other minority group ‐0.8808
Women 0.1113 **
Coefficient
![Page 419: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/419.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX C, PAGE 22
Figure C‐22. Disparities in business ownership rates for Denver professional services workers, 2012‐2016
Note: The benchmark figure can only be estimated for records with observed (rather than imputed) dependent variable values. Thus, the study team made comparisons between actual and benchmark self‐employment rates only for the subset of the sample for which the dependent variable was observed.
Analyses are limited to those groups that showed negative coefficients that were statistically significant in the regression model.
Source: BBC Research & Consulting from 2012‐2016 ACS 5% Public Use Microdata samples. The raw data extract was obtained through the IPUMS program of the MN Population Center: http://usa.ipums.org/usa/.
FigureC‐22indicatesthatBlackAmericansownprofessionalservicesbusinessesinDenverataratethatis54percentthatofsimilarly‐situatednon‐HispanicwhiteAmericans.AsianPacificAmericansownprofessionalservicesbusinessesinDenverataratethatis48percentthatofsimilarly‐situatednon‐HispanicwhiteAmericans;andSubcontinentAsianAmericansownprofessionalservicesbusinessesinDenverataratethatis25percentthatofsimilarly‐situatednon‐HispanicwhiteAmericans.
Group
Black American 8.2% 15.2% 54
Asian Pacific American 8.0% 16.5% 48
Subcontinent Asian American 3.5% 13.8% 25
Self‐Employment Rate Disparity Index
Actual Benchmark (100 = Parity)
![Page 420: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/420.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX C, PAGE 23
Figure C‐23. Predictors of business ownership in goods and services (regression), Denver, 2012‐2016
Note:
The regression includes 10,137 observations.
*, ** Denote statistical significance at the 90% and 95% confidence levels, respectively.
The referent for each set of categorical variables is as follows: high school diploma for the education variables and non‐Hispanic whites for the race variables.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting from 2012‐2016 ACS 5% Public Use Microdata samples. The raw data extract was obtained through the IPUMS program of the MN Population Center: http://usa.ipums.org/usa/.
FigureC‐23indicatesthat,comparedtobeinganon‐HispanicwhiteAmericaninDenver,beingaBlackAmericanorSubcontinentAsianAmericanisrelatedtoalowerlikelihoodofowningagoodsandservicesbusiness,evenafteraccountingforvariousotherpersonalcharacteristics.
Variable
Constant ‐2.5382 **
Age 0.0415 **
Age‐squared ‐0.0003 **
Married ‐0.0511
Disabled 0.1126
Number of children in household 0.0347
Number of people over 65 in household 0.0839 *
Owns home ‐0.2004 **
Home value ($000s) 0.0004 **
Monthly mortgage payment ($000s) 0.0180
Interest and dividend income ($000s) 0.0040 **
Income of spouse or partner ($0000s) 0.0005
Speaks English well 0.1168
Less than high school education ‐0.0882
Some college 0.0256
Four‐year degree ‐0.0011
Advanced degree ‐0.0198
Black American ‐0.3303 **
Asian Pacific American ‐0.1358
Subcontinent Asian American ‐0.4132 *
Hispanic American ‐0.0577
Native American 0.1731
Other minority group ‐0.1338
Women 0.0330
Coefficient
![Page 421: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/421.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX C, PAGE 24
Figure C‐24. Disparities in business ownership rates for Denver goods and services workers, 2012‐2016
Note: The benchmark figure can only be estimated for records with observed (rather than imputed) dependent variable values. Thus, the study team made comparisons between actual and benchmark self‐employment rates only for the subset of the sample for which the dependent variable was observed.
Analyses are limited to those groups that showed negative coefficients that were statistically significant in the regression model.
Source: BBC Research & Consulting from 2012‐2016 ACS 5% Public Use Microdata samples. The raw data extract was obtained through the IPUMS program of the MN Population Center: http://usa.ipums.org/usa/.
FigureC‐24indicatesthatBlackAmericansowngoodsandservicesbusinessesinDenverataratethatis57percentthatofsimilarly‐situatednon‐HispanicwhiteAmericans.Inaddition,SubcontinentAsianAmericansowngoodsandservicesbusinessesinDenverataratethatis47percentthatofsimilarly‐situatednon‐HispanicwhiteAmericans.
Group
Black American 7.3% 12.8% 57
Subcontinent Asian American 5.4% 11.4% 47
Self‐Employment Rate Disparity Index
Actual Benchmark (100 = Parity)
![Page 422: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/422.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX C, PAGE 25
Figure C‐25. Rates of business closure, expansion, and contraction, Colorado and the United States, 2002‐2006
Note:
Data only include only privately‐held businesses.
Equal Gender Ownership refers to those businesses for which ownership is split evenly between women and men.
Statistical significance of these results cannot be determined, because sample sizes were not reported.
Source:
Lowrey, Ying. 2010. “Race/Ethnicity and Establishment Dynamics, 2002‐2006.” U.S. Small Business Administration Office of Advocacy. Washington D.C.
Lowrey, Ying. 2014. "Gender and Establishment Dynamics, 2002‐2006." U.S. Small Business Administration Office of Advocacy. Washington D.C.
FigureC‐25indicatesthatminority‐ownedbusinessesinColoradoshowhigherclosureratesthannon‐HispanicwhiteAmerican‐ownedbusinesses.Woman‐ownedbusinessesinColoradoshowhigherclosureratesthanbusinessesownedbymen.Inaddition,BlackAmerican‐andAsianAmerican‐ownedbusinessesinColoradoshowlowerexpansionratesandhighercontractionratesthannon‐HispanicwhiteAmerican‐ownedbusinesses.
![Page 423: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/423.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX C, PAGE 26
Figure C‐26. Mean annual business receipts (in thousands), Denver‐Aurora, CO CSA and the United States, 2012
Note:
Includes employer and non‐employer firms. Does not include publicly‐traded companies or other firms not classifiable by race/ethnicity and gender.
Source:
2012 Survey of Business Owners, part of the U.S. Census Bureau’s 2012 Economic Census.
FigureC‐26indicatesthat,in2012,BlackAmerican‐;AsianAmerican‐;HispanicAmerican‐;AmericanIndianandAlaskanNative‐;andNativeHawaiianandOtherPacificIslander‐ownedbusinessesintheDenver‐AuroraCSAshowedlowermeanannualbusinessreceiptsthannon‐HispanicwhiteAmerican‐ownedbusinesses.Inaddition,woman‐ownedbusinessesintheDenver‐AuroraCSAshowedlowermeanannualbusinessreceiptsthanbusinessesownedbymen.
![Page 424: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/424.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX C, PAGE 27
Figure C‐27. Mean annual business owner earnings, Denver and the United States, 2012‐2016
Note:
The sample universe is business owners age 16 and older who reported positive earnings. All amounts in 2016 dollars.
**, ++ Denotes statistically significant differences from non‐Hispanic whites (for minority groups) or from men (for women) at the 95% confidence level for Denver and the United States as a whole, respectively.
† Denotes that significant differences in proportions were not reported due to small sample size.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting from 2012‐2016 ACS 5% Public Use Microdata sample. The raw data extract was obtained through the IPUMS program of the MN Population Center: http://usa.ipums.org/usa/.
FigureC‐27indicatesthattheownersofBlackAmerican‐,HispanicAmerican‐,andNativeAmerican‐ownedbusinessesinDenverearnlessonaveragethantheownersofnon‐HispanicwhiteAmerican‐ownedbusinesses.Inaddition,theownersofwoman‐ownedbusinessesintheDenverearnlessonaveragethantheownersofbusinessesownedbymen.
![Page 425: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/425.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX C, PAGE 28
Figure C‐28. Predictors of business owner earnings (regression), Denver, 2012‐2016
Note:
The regression includes 5,113 observations.
For ease of interpretation, the exponentiated form of the coefficients is displayed in the figure.
The sample universe is business owners age 16 and older who reported positive earnings. All amounts in 2016 dollars.
** Denotes statistical significance at the 95% confidence level.
The referent for each set of categorical variables is as follows: high school diploma for the education variables and non‐Hispanic whites for the race variables.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting from 2012‐2016 ACS 5% Public Use Microdata sample. The raw data extract was obtained through the IPUMS program of the MN Population Center: http://usa.ipums.org/usa/.
FigureC‐28indicatesthat,comparedtobeinganownerofabusinessownedbynon‐HispanicwhiteAmericansormeninDenver,beingBlackAmericanorawomanisrelatedtosignificantlylowerearnings,evenafteraccountingforvariousotherbusinessandpersonalcharacteristics.
Variable
Constant 531.365 **
Age 1.166 **
Age‐squared 0.998 **
Married 1.224 **
Speaks English well 1.065
Disabled 0.627 **
Less than high school 0.528 **
Some college 0.925
Four‐year degree 1.246 **
Advanced degree 1.549 **
Black American 0.530 **
Asian Pacific American 1.143
Subcontinent Asian American 2.220 **
Hispanic American 1.005
Native American 0.723
Other race minority 0.854
Women 0.539 **
Exponentiated
Coefficient
![Page 426: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/426.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX C, PAGE 29
Figure C‐29. Predictors of business owner earnings (regression), United States, 2012‐2016
Note:
The regression includes 436,401 observations.
For ease of interpretation, the exponentiated form of the coefficients is displayed in the figure.
The sample universe is business owners age 16 and over who reported positive earnings. All amounts in 2015 dollars.
*, ** Denotes statistical significance at the 90% and 95% confidence level, respectively.
The referent for each set of categorical variables is as follows: high school diploma for the education variables and non‐Hispanic whites for the race variables.
Source:
BBC Research & Consulting from 2011‐2015 ACS 5% Public Use Microdata sample. The raw data extract was obtained through the IPUMS program of the MN Population Center: http://usa.ipums.org/usa/.
FigureC‐29indicatesthat,comparedtobeingtheownerofanon‐HispanicwhiteAmerican‐ownedbusinessintheUnitedStates,beinganownerofaBlackAmerican‐orNativeAmerican‐ownedbusinessisrelatedtolowerearnings,evenafteraccountingforvariousotherbusinessandpersonalcharacteristics.Inaddition,comparedtobeingtheownerofabusinessownedbymenintheUnitedStates,beinganownerofawoman‐ownedbusinessisrelatedtolowerearnings,evenafteraccountingforvariousotherbusinessandpersonalcharacteristics.
Variable
Constant 550.652 **
Age 1.148 **
Age‐squared 0.999 **
Married 1.242 **
Speaks English well 1.143 **
Disabled 0.583 **
Less than high school 0.746 **
Some college 1.044 **
Four‐year degree 1.311 **
Advanced degree 1.894 **
Black American 0.820 **
Asian Pacific American 1.084 **
Subcontinent Asian American 1.154 **
Hispanic American 1.040 **
Native American 0.682 **
Other race minority 1.115 *
Women 0.527 **
Exponentiated
Coefficient
![Page 427: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/427.jpg)
APPENDIX D.
Qualitative Information about Marketplace Conditions
![Page 428: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/428.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 1
APPENDIX D. Qualitative Information about Marketplace Conditions
AppendixDpresentsqualitativeinformationthatthestudyteamcollectedandanalyzedthroughthepublicengagementprocessfortheCityandCountyofDenver(theCity)DisparityStudy.BBCcollectedpublictestimonyfromstakeholdersusingavarietyofmethodsandconductedin‐depthinterviewswithbusinessownersandtradeassociationrepresentativesintheregion.Intotal,morethan100businessandtradeassociationrepresentativesprovidedwrittenorspokencommentstothestudyteam.AppendixDsummarizesthekeythemesandinsightsthatemergedfromthosecommentsandisdividedintothefollowing13sections:
A. Introduction. ThissectiondescribesthepublicengagementprocessforgatheringandanalyzingthequalitativeinformationsummarizedinAppendixD.
B. Background on Denver businesses. Thissectiondescribesthecharacteristicsofthebusinesseswhoseownersorrepresentativesprovidedpublictestimonyorgaveaninterviewforthedisparitystudy.Thissectionpresentsinformationonbusinesstype,businesssize,businessformation,andcurrenteconomicconditionsinDenver
C. Keys to business success. Thissectionpresentsbusinessowners’andrepresentatives’perspectivesonthekeystobusinesssuccessintheDenvermarketplace.
D. Doing business as a prime contractor or subcontractor. Thissectiondescribesbusinesses’mixofprimecontractandsubcontractwork,theirexperiencesinthoseroles,andhowtheyobtaintheirwork.
E. Potential barriers to doing business in Denver. ThissectiondescribesthebarriersthatbusinessesfaceintheDenvermarketplaceanddetailsaboutwhetherrace‐orgender‐baseddiscriminationmaybecontributingtothosebarriers.
F. Work with the City and other public organizations.Thissectiondescribesbusinessowners’experiencesworkingwithorattemptingtoworkwiththeCityofDenverandotherpublicorganizationsintheregion.
G. Allegations of unfair treatment. Thissectiondocumentsbusinessowners’andrepresentatives’experienceswithunfairtreatmentbycustomers,primecontractors,orotherpartieswhenbiddingonorperformingcontractwork.
H. Insights regarding race‐/ethnicity‐ or gender‐based discrimination. ThissectionpresentsinformationaboutanyexperiencesbusinessownersorrepresentativeshavehadwithdiscriminationinthePennsylvaniamarketplaceandhowthatbehavioraffectsminority‐,woman‐,LGBT‐,veteran‐ordisabled‐ownedbusinesses.
![Page 429: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/429.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 2
I. Insights regarding business assistance programs. Thissectiondescribesbusinessowners’opinionsaboutbusinessassistanceprogramsandotherstepstoremovebarriersforsmallbusinessdevelopmentinDenver.
J. Insights regarding contracting processes. Thissectioncapturesbusinessownersandrepresentatives’feedbackabouttheCommonwealth’sandPennDOT’scontractingprocessesandprocurementpolicies.
K. Insights regarding minority‐ and woman‐owned business programs. Thissectionpresentsinformationaboutbusinesses’experienceswithminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessprogramsandtheCity’sprogram.
L. Insights regarding certification. Thissectionpresentsinformationaboutbusinesses’experienceswithcertificationprocesses,includingtheCity’scertificationprocess.
M. Other insights and recommendations regarding City contracting and programs. ThissectionpresentsadditionalcommentsandsuggestionsfortheCitytoconsider.
A. Introduction
Throughoutthestudyperiod,businessownersandmanagers;tradeassociationrepresentatives;andotherinterestedpartieshadtheopportunitytodiscusstheirexperiencesworkingintheDenvermarketplaceandprovidepublictestimony.Thoseinsightswerecollectedthroughseveraldifferentchannels:
Participatinginanin‐depthinterview;
Participatinginanavailabilitysurvey;
Providingoralorwrittentestimonyduringapublicmeeting;and
Submittingwrittentestimonyviaemail.
FromSeptember2017throughSeptember2018,thestudyteamusedavarietyofpublicengagementmethodstogatherthosecommentsandfacilitatedseveralpublicmeetingsaboutthedisparitystudy.Thestudyteam’spublicengagementstrategyconsistedofthefollowing:
In‐depth interviews. Thestudyteamconductedin‐depthinterviewswithrepresentativesofbusinessesandtradeassociationsinDenver.Theinterviewsincludeddiscussionsaboutinterviewees’perceptionsofandexperienceswithgovernmentcontracting;theCity’sMinority‐andWomen‐ownedBusinessEnterprise(MWBE),EmergingBusinessEnterprise(EBE),SmallBusinessEnterprise(SBE),andFederalDisadvantagedBusinessEnterprise(DBE)Programs;andbusinesses’experiencesworkingorattemptingtoworkwithpublicagenciesintheregion.In‐depthinterviewcommentsareidentifiedinAppendixDbyrandominterviewnumbers(i.e.,#1,#2,#3,etc.).
Availability surveys.Thestudyteamconductedavailabilitysurveysforthedisparitystudyin2017and2018.Asapartoftheavailabilitysurveys,thestudyteamaskedbusinessownersandmanagerswhethertheircompanieshaveexperiencedbarriersordifficultiesstartingor
![Page 430: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/430.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 3
expandingbusinessesintheirindustriesorwithobtainingworkintheDenvermarketplace.ThestudyteamanalyzedthoseresponsesandincludedillustrativeexamplesofthedifferentcommenttypesandthemesinAppendixD.AvailabilitysurveycommentsareindicatedthroughoutAppendixDbytheprefix“AS.”
Publicmeetings.ThestudyteamsolicitedwrittenandverbaltestimonyatpublicmeetingsheldintheDenverregioninlate2017.Thestudyteamreviewedandanalyzedallpubliccommentsfromthosemeetings.Publicmeetingcommentsaredenotedbytheprefix“PT”throughoutAppendixD.
Written testimony.Throughoutthestudy,interestedpartieshadtheopportunitytosubmitwrittentestimonydirectlytothestudyteamviaemail.Allwrittentestimonyreceivedbyemailwasanalyzedbythestudyteam.Writtentestimonyisindicatedbytheprefix“WT”throughoutAppendixD.
B. Background on Denver Businesses
PartBsummarizesinformationrelatedto:
Howbusinessesbecomeestablished;
Challengesinstarting,operating,andgrowingabusiness;
Typesofworkthatbusinessesperform;
Sizeofbusinesses;
Capabilityofbusinessestoperformdifferenttypesandsizesofcontracts;
Localeffectsoftheeconomicdownturn;
Currenteconomicconditions;and
Businessowners’experiencespursingpublicandprivatesectorwork.
How businesses become established.Mostintervieweesreportedthattheircompanieswerestarted(orpurchased)byindividualswithconnectionsintheirrespectiveindustries.
Many interviewees worked in the industry or a related industry before starting their own
businesses, or have worked for many years in the industry.[e.g.,#4,#16,#30] Forexample:
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthathestartedthefirmbyhimselfandhasalwaysbeenthesoleownerandmanagerofthefirm.Headdedthathestartedhisfirm27yearsagoandhasbeenworkinginhisindustryforover40years.[#3]
TheBlackAmericanmalebusinessownersaidthatheworkedfor18yearsinengineeringandhas"beenasmallbusinessownerforabouteight[or]nineyearsnow."[PT#1c]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringfirmreportedthatsheispresidentandCEOofthefirm.Shesaidthatshefoundedthecompany
![Page 431: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/431.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 4
about10yearsagoandnotedthatsheworkedforanumberofengineeringfirmsbeforestartingherown.[#5]
TheSubcontinentAsianAmericanmaleownerofaspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthathestartedthecompanyalmost10yearsagoaftermovingtotheUnitedStates.HeaddedthatheusedtoownabusinessinPakistanandpreferstobe“hisownboss.”[#18]
ThesamebusinessownersaidthatsomeofhisrelativesintheU.S.havethesametypeofcompany,soitdidn’ttakelongforhimtofigureoutwhatheneededtodotogetstarted.[#18]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaconstructionfirmstatedthatheistheownerandpresidentofthecompany.Headded,“IstartedthebusinessbecauseIwantedtobemyownbossandmyfatherhadthissametypeofbusinessinDenver.IlearnedeverythingIknowfromhim.”[#24]
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“Thecompanywasformedaboutfiveyearsago.ThereasonIstarteditwasbecauseIwantedtostartmyownbusiness.Ididn’twanttohavesomeoneelsebossingmearound.Notevenmyfather.Ilearnedmyskillsfromhimandwantedtobelikehim.”[#24]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaconstruction‐relatedfirmreportedthathehasbeenpresidentofthecompanyfornineyears.Hesaidthathisbusinessmergedwithanotherengineeringcompanyafewyearsago,andnotedthathisprimaryresponsibilityaspresidentisbusinessdevelopment.[#25]
Whenaskedwhyhestartedthefirm,thesamebusinessownerstatedthathewas“laidofffromanotherengineeringcompanywhentheeconomysloweddown.”Hesaid,“Ilookedaroundforawhileforanotherposition,butdecidedthatIcouldandshouldstartmyowncompany.”[#25]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaconstructionservicesfirmreportedthatheispresidentofthecompanyandthathefoundeditin2008.Hecontinued,“IstartedthiscompanyafterIwaslaidofffromanothercommercialmechanicalemployer.Iwantedtobemoreincontrolofmysuccess.”[#31]
Whenaskedtodescribetheformationofhisfirm,thesamebusinessownerstated,“Iwantedtohavesomethingofmyown.Afterbeinglaidoff,Ithoughtmyowncompanygrowthwouldbemorepredictable[and]notdependonhowmuchmoneyanothercompanywasmaking.”[#31]
Whenaskedhowhecametobetheownerofthefirm,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmstated,“Iactuallystartedmyownbusinessinthe[mid‐1970s]duringabusinessdownturn.Ihadbeenlaidofffromanumberoffirms,soIjuststarteddoingkitchenremodels,deckadditions,houseadditions,singlefamilyhouses,whateverIcouldfind.Imovedintopublicwork,andmy
![Page 432: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/432.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 5
firstprojectwasfortheDenverUrbanRenewalAuthority,thenIhadacontractwith[RegionalTransportationDistrict].”[#22]
Thesamebusinessownerwentontosaythatthecompanyinitspresentformbeganinthemid‐1990s.Headded,“Ireallytransitionedintopublicworkwhentheybuilttheairport,andthatwasinthelate1980swhenthefirst[anti‐discrimination]ordinancewasestablished.Ijoinedforceswithotherminorityarchitectsandcontractororganizations….Asaresultofthat,wegotsomeworkattheairport.Theairportworkandtheordinancereallyhelpedourfirmgrowuntil9/11.Wehadalotofcontractsthatjuststopped[then],sowelaidoffpeople.Itwasverypainful.”[#22]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofanengineeringcompanystatedthathehasbeenpresidentofthecompanysinceitsfoundingover20yearsago.Headded,“Iusedtoworkfor[acityintheDenverarea]….Workingthereandothergovernmentplaces,it’seasytogetin,butnottomoveup.Afterafewyearsthere,Imovedto[workatan]engineeringcompany.Ihaveover40yearsofengineeringexperienceinpublicandprivatecompanies.Iknewitwastimetostartmyowncompanymanyyearsago.”[#26]
Whenaskedabouttheformationofhisfirm,thesamebusinessownersaid,“Iwantedtostartmyowncompany…tobetheboss.Ihadsatisfactoryexperiencesworkingfor[acityintheDenverarea]andthe…engineeringcompany.But,Ireallyfeltitwastimeformyowncompanyandnotworkingforsomeoneelse.”[#26]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andESB‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmreportedthatheismajorityownerandfounderofthefirm.Theotherowner,heexplained,isanon‐Hispanicwhitefemale.Hesaidthatheformedthecompanyafterabout30yearsofexperienceasacontractfurniturerepresentative.[#9]
Thesamebusinessowneradded,“Iwasasalesmanagerforalightingpolemanufacturerforaboutthreeorfouryears,[then]decidedIshouldstartmyownbusiness….Itwasacombinationofobservationinthemarketplacealongwithresearchthatledmetodiscoveramarketin[ourparticular]market,anichethatIthoughtwecouldfulfill.”[#9]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmreportedthatthecompanywasfoundedalmost40yearsagobyanon‐Hispanicwhitemale.Henotedthatthefounderstillownsthefirm.[#21a]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmreportedthatheisthepresident,principalengineer,andmajorityownerofthefirm.Hesaidthatbeforestartinghisownfirminthelate1980s,hepreviouslyservedasvicepresidentofanothersimilarfirm.[#14]
Whenaskedwhyhestartedthefirm,thesamebusinessownerreportedthathewantedtocaptureupcomingworkatthenewDenverInternationalAirport.HesaidthathegothisMBEcertificationaboutayearafterstartingthecompany,whichenabledthefirmtosecurecontractswiththem.[#14]
![Page 433: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/433.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 6
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaidthatsheisinchargeofbusinessdevelopment,contractanddepartmentmanagementatthefirm.Regardingthefirm’sbackground,shesaid,“Thefounderstarteditfromscratchbecausehewantedtobehisownboss.Hehadworkedformanyothercompaniesandfelthehadenoughexperiencetobesuccessfulonhisown.[He]didrunthebusinessforabout12yearsandwitnessedmuchsuccess.”[#28]
Thesamebusinessrepresentativecontinued,“Thefounderpromotedoneofhismanagers[to]presidentaboutsevenyearsago,buthasstayed[withthecompany]inaleadershiprole,similartoaCEOinmanyothercompanies.Hiscurrentdutiesincludeoverseeingcompanygrowth.”[#28]
TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmstatedthatheworkedinthecablingindustryformanyyearsbeforedecidingtostarthisowncompany.Headded,“IstartedthiscompanybecauseIfeltveryconfidentIcoulddothejobasboss,justas[well]assomeofthemanagersIworkedwithatlargercompanies.”[#32a]
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“Istartedthiscompany[over10]yearsago.Ittookabouttwoyearsinthedevelopmentandresearchphase.IwantedtobemyownbossandfeltasthoughIhadenoughcontactsintheindustry.Ihaveworkedinthiscapacityforothercompaniesforabout20years.”[#32a]
Whenaskedtodescribetheformationofthefirm,thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmreportedthatshestartedthecompanyalmost20yearsagoandworkedintheindustrypriortothat.[#20]
One business assistance organization representative discussed the organization’s formation.TheNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationreportedthatshehasbeenwiththeorganizationforaboutfiveyears.Whenaskedabouttheorganization’sformation,shesaid,“Whentheorganizationstartedintheearly90swewerejustaroundtheDenvermetroarea.Overtimethatstartedtogrowintoaregionalfocus,[and]thenin2013wetookagiantleapacrossthecountry….By2015weexpandedourinfluencethroughtheNationalCenterforAmericanIndianEnterpriseDevelopment.”[#37]
Some business owners gave a wide variety of reasons for starting their own businesses.Forexample:
Whenaskedhowthefirmstarted,theHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmstated,“Ilostmyjobandwasoutofworkforacouplemonths,[and]mycousinaskedmetohelphercleanahouseforaconstructioncompany.Atthattime,Ididn’tevenknowaboutanopportunitylikethat.[Itwas]afterhelpingher[that]Idecidedtostartabusiness.”Shereportedthatshestartedthefirmover10yearsago.[#35]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofagoodsandservicesfirmreportedthathestartedthefirmsixyearsago.Heexplainedthatthefirmbeganasasidehobbybeforeturninginto
![Page 434: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/434.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 7
acommercialventure.Hesaid,“Initially,westartedasanonlinestore,andafterwegotsomeinitialattentionandwentviral,westarteddoingcustomcommissionsanditjustkindofbloomedfromthere.”[#10]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmreportedthatsheissoleownerofthefirmandthatherresponsibilitiesinclude“businessdevelopment,finances,payroll,humanresources,”and“anythingelserequiredtokeepthebusinessgoing.”[#27]
Thesamebusinessownerwentontosaythatthefirmstartedabouteightyearsago.Sheadded,“Mydaughterusedtoowna…companyandIworkedforherasthepayrollclerk.Myhusbandworkedforherastheaccountant.[After]shedied…myhusbandandIweregoingtotakeoverhercompany,butunfortunatelythefinancesofthatcompanywerenotsound.Infact,weprobablywouldhavehadtofilebankruptcy,sowestartedanewcompanydoing[similar]work.”[#27]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthatsheisownerandpresidentofthefirm,whichshestartedover25yearsagoafterleavingajobshewasn’tsatisfiedwith.Sheadded,“Ireviewthedesignworkthatiscominginfrommystaff….I’minchargeofeverything.Ioccasionallywillmanageprojects.Iwilldosomeofourlargerprojectsastheprincipalincharge.”[#12]
Whenaskedaboutthecircumstancesofthefirm’sfounding,thesamebusinessownersaid,“Ihadbeenworkinginaplanningenvironmentdowntowninasmallcompany….Ineededtotravelforthejob,andIdidn’treallylikethejob….Inadditiontothat,mybossdidreallyinappropriatethings,butofcourseI[was]justwas20yearsold…andthoughtitwasthecourseofdoingbusiness.”[#12]
Shecontinued,“So,allthosethingsledtothecreationofmyfirm.Ireallydidn’tlikedoingplanningwork,andIhadworkedinsmall‐scaleresidentialconstructionpriortothat,whichIenjoyedmore.Myhusband,whoreallyencouragedme,hadacorporatejobatthetimesotherewassomeflexibilitywithinourfamily.That’swhatmademegetitstarted.IstillhavethebusinessplanthatIwrote.”[#12]
TheNativeAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,SDB‐,SDVOSB‐,andHUBZone‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmreportedthathisfirmhasbeeninbusinessforalmost30years.Regardinghowhisfirmbecameestablished,hesaidthatshortlyafterstartingthefirmhewasintriguedbyamagazinearticleabout[hisfield].Hestated,“IflewtoChicagoandlookedatthemanufacturers[ofthatproduct].…”Henotedthatthiswasanuntappedmarketatthetime,andreportedthatthefirmeventuallyexpandedtheirservices.[#39]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedgeneralcontractingfirmreportedthatsheholdsavarietyofrolesatthefirm,including“CEO,janitor,billing/invoicing,[and]frontdesk.”Sheaddedthatshestartedthecompanyabouttwoyearsago.[#19]
![Page 435: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/435.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 8
ThesamebusinessownerwentontosaythatshewasCOOofmanymajorhospitalsbeforestartingthefirm.Sheexplained,“IstartedfeelingthatIwantedsomethingmore,soIstartedlookingaroundtofindacompanytobuy….[I]startedtobuyanotherstripingcompany,butdiscoveredthefinancialsjustdidn’tlookright.Numbers…justdidn’taddup.So,Istartedthiscompany.”[#19]
Shecontinued,“Ididn’tknowanythingabout[myfield].”Sheadded,“Thisjustfellintomylap.Originally,Ithoughtaboutstartinganinvestmentcompany.Thenwithmoreresearch,becausetherearenotalotof…companiesavailable[inmyfield],Irealizeditwasanopportunityformetostartmyownbusiness.[Ihave]noregretsorsecondthoughtsatall.”[#19]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleownerofanarchitecturalengineeringfirmstatedthatheispresidentandseniorpartnerofthefirmaswellasco‐founder.Hesaidthathestudiedarchitectureandengineeringincollegeandgotlicensedinbothdisciplines.HeaddedthatheandhiswifemovedtoColoradowhenshepursuedagraduatedegree,andthathejoinedalocalfirmthatdidbotharchitectureandengineeringbeforestartinghisownfirmalongsideanon‐Hispanicwhitemalecolleaguemanyyearsago.[#16]
ThesamebusinessowneraddedthathispartnerhadcontactsatColoradoStateUniversitythatwerecriticaltogettingthebusinessstarted.Henotedthatheissemi‐retired,andthathisformerpartnerhaslongsinceretired.Hewentontosaythatbecauseheistheonlyarchitectatthefirmheoverseesalldesignfunctions.[#16]
TheBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionsupplyfirmsaidthathestartedatthefirmasoperationsmanager.Whenaskedhowhecametobeownerofthefirm,hesaid,“Istartedthecompanywithfourotherindividualsin[thelate1990s],sotherewerefiveofus.OvertheyearsIboughttheothersout.Thelastbuyoutwasabout[twoyears]ago.”HewentontosaythattheotherfounderswerealsoBlackAmericanmales.[#36]
Whenaskedwhytheydecidedtostartthefirm,theBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionsupplyfirmsaid,“MypartnersandIwerelookingforanopportunity,andonepartnerattendedaneventwherehelearnedaboutapossibleopportunitywith[alargefirm].Westartedtalkingto[thisfirm]andtheysaidtheyweregoingtosellsomestoresandtheywantedtogetminoritiesintothatbusiness….Theconversationledtousbuyingsomeoftheirstores,andthat’swhenwestarted[thecompany].”[#36]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleownerofaspecialtycontractingfirmexplainedthatheformedhiscompanyinpursuitofabetterbalancebetweenhisworkandhishomelife.Henoted,"Istartedoffrunningmybusiness,doingeverythingmyself,andeventuallygottoapointwhereIcouldhireemployeesanddelegatethework."[#4]
Thesameownerwentontoadd,"Iworkedasanelectricianforacoupleofthebig[contractingfirms]intown,andIfeltlikeIgottothehighestpointIcouldwiththem."[#4]
![Page 436: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/436.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 9
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaprofessionalservicesfirmstatedthathestartedhisownfirmbecause"[he]wantedtohavebettercontrolover[his]risks.”Headded,“Iwantedtohavethecommunityasthecenterofwhywe'reinbusiness,andtobeabletousetechnologytoabetterextentthantheenvironmentIhadbeenatbefore."[#3]
Whenaskedhowthefirmstarted,thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemaleco‐ownerofaspecialtyservicesfirmsaidthatwhenherdaughterwasyoungshebegan[creatingaproduct]forherandherfriends.Afterdoingthisformanyyears,shesaid,“IjustthoughtitwasreallyfunandIhadbeeninaccountingfor35years,[so]onedayIdecidedIwantedtodothisinsteadofaccounting.”Shenotedthattheotherco‐ownerisalsoanon‐Hispanicwhitefemale.[#8]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedspecialtyservicesfirmreportedthatthefirmwasfoundedbyanon‐Hispanicwhitemalein2005.Whenaskedwhythefirmwasformed,hesaidthattheownerhadapreviousbusiness,andstartedthecurrentfirmbecausehewantedtore‐entertheindustry.[#34]
TheBlackAmericanveteranmaleownerofageneralcontractingcompanyreportedthathestartedhisbusinessalmost10yearsagoandistheonlyownerofthefirm.HesaidthathemovedtoColoradotostartabusinessshortlyafterleavingthemilitary,andadded,“Iknewafewpeoplehere,andtheyknewalotofpeoplelookingforsomeonetoworkonprojects.Ihaveplentyofworkthatkeepsmeverybusy.”[#29]
Thesamebusinessownerwentontosay,“WhenImovedhere,IknewIneededsomethingtodotomakemoney.Iknowaboutconstruction.Ilearneditfrommyfatherasaboy,andIhavebeendoingitforyears.”[#29]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmsaidshejoinedthefirmasco‐ownerin2004alongsideafamilymember.Shesaidthefamilymemberformedthecompanyafterworkingforseveralconstructioncompaniespreviously.[#2]
Thesamebusinessco‐owneradded,“Iresearchedalotofthings.ItalkedtopeopleIwasconnectedwith,goodpeoplewithintheCityofDenverthathelpeduswithquestions.There’ssomuchoutthere,butalotofpeopledon’twantyoutosucceedandthey’llkindof…makeitalittlebitharder[togettheinformation].”[#2]
Whenaskedhowherbusinessbecameestablished,thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringfirmcommentedthatshedecidedtostartthecompanyafterhavingherfirstchild.Sheexplained,“WhenIcamebackfrommymaternityleave,[mypreviousemployer]hadmovedallofmystuffoutofthecorneroffice[andinto]asharedoffice.[Theyalso]informedmethatIhadbeenremovedfromthebonuspoolbecauseIwasnolongerconsideredaseriousemployee,becauseIonlyworked36hoursaweekinsteadof40.”[#5]
Thesamebusinessownerwentontosaythatafterleavingthecompanysheknew“there[had]tobeabetterway.”Shesaid,“There[was]awayI[could]beanengineerandamom,”andnoted,“Theconcept[ofmyfirm]isthatit’sapartofthewhole.Idonotintendtosuck
![Page 437: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/437.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 10
thelifeoutofmyemployees.Iintendtobeanassettothem.Mygoalistoprovideallthefinancialsecuritythateveryoneofmyindividualemployeesneedsaswellasthetimeoffthattheyneed.”[#5]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthatheisprimarilyresponsibleforthegeneralhealthandwellbeingofthefirm,includingmarketingandbilling.Theotherco‐owner,hereported,isalsoaBlackAmericanmale.Hesaidthatthefirmopenedabouttwoyearsagoafterheworkedforaplumbingcompany.Hesaid,“Wesaw[that]the…companywereferred[customers]towasreallytakingadvantageofhomeowners,andtheyweren’treallydoingagoodjob.”[#7]
Thesamebusinessco‐ownersaidthatatthatpointhecalledacolleagueandaskedifhewantedtostartacompanywithhim.Hewentontosay,“Wegottogetherandwentthroughallthecertifications,theclasses…courses,[and]filedforourbusinessID….Then[we]justgotstartedbymarketingwithexisting[companies]andlettingthemknowthatwewouldtakecareoftheircustomers.”[#7]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofanSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthatsheis51percentownerofthefirm.Theotherowner,sheadded,isanon‐Hispanicwhitemaleandlicensedarchitect.Shestatedthatshewasinitiallyhiredalmost20yearsagotodobilling,butthatherdutiesevolveduntilshefinallyboughtintothecompany.Shesaidthatshenowmanagesalladministrativeduties.[#15a]
Some business owners reported that they inherited or work for a family‐owned business.Forexample:
TheBlackAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaidherfatherstartedthebusinessover40yearsago.Beingafamily‐ownedbusiness,shecommented,“Everyoneisanemployee,whetheryoulikeitornot.”Shesaidsheworkedinmediamanagementandsalesaftergraduatingcollege,andstartedatthefirmafterbeingaskedtoreviewitsmarketingmaterials.[#13]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmstatedthatthefirmwasstartedover60yearsagobyanon‐Hispanicwhitemale,andthatthefirmisstillownedbythesamefamily.[#23a]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaspecialtyservicesfirmstatedthathisfatherstartedthebusinessover20yearsagoandthathetookoveraspresidentabout10yearsago.Henotedthathehasalwaysbeeninvolvedinthebusiness,andadded,“Whenmyfatherfoundedthebusiness,therewasalwaysaconsiderationofmetakingoversomedayasthepresident.”[#30]
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“Iwasalwaysinvolvedinthebusinessgrowingup.Ilearnedeveryjobthatthecompanyperforms.IneverthoughtIwoulddoanythingelse.”Hesaidthathebecamepresidentofthefirmaftergraduatingcollege.[#30]
![Page 438: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/438.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 11
Challenges in starting, operating, and growing a business.Interviewees’commentsaboutthechallengesinstarting,operating,andgrowingabusinessvaried.
Business owners and representatives reported lack of access to capital or high cost of
materials as a challenge in starting, sustaining, or growing their business, among other
challenges.[e.g.,#3c,AS#39,PT#3c]Forexample:
Regardingtheriskassociatedwithstartingasmallbusiness,thefemalerepresentativeofasmallbusinesssaid,“[With]smallbusinessowners,ittakesaspecialperson…togointothatandtakealltheriskandwhathaveyou….Itisacrosstheboard…peoplenotwantingtobeowners.”[PT#2b]
Regardingchallengesthatnewfirmssuchashisfacewhenstartingorgrowingabusinessinthelocalmarketplace,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaconstructionservicesfirmstated,“Ihavetheexperiences,expertise,andlicensingnecessarytobuildandcontinuetogrowmybusiness,[but]Icoulduseassistancein…thebondingarea.”[#31]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmstated,“Atfirst,itwasdifficultobtainingfinancingandbonding.Themoreworkwecompleted,theeasierthatbecame.Iknowrightnowcompaniesarefacingworkforceshortagesthat[are]affectingtheirabilitytostartsomejobs.Oneofthebenefitsofhavingourtypeofbusinessmodel[isthat]wearen’talwaysouttherelookingforpersonnel.Wehavehiredthemasemployees,andtheyareherereadytowork.”[#28]
TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmstated,“Startupshaveproblemsobtainingfinancing.”[#22]
Asurveyrespondentsaid,“It'sdifficultforasmallcompanytobreakintoworkinthearea.”[AS#37]
A few business assistance organization representatives discussed start‐up challenges faced by
member firms.Commentsinclude:
TheNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaid,“Ithinkoverall,ourcommunityfacesanuphillbattle.Whetheryouareminority‐ownedorwoman‐owned,therearebarrierslikefinancingtogetabusinessupandrunning,andthenit’shardtocompetewithpeoplewhoarealreadyestablished.Thecertificationprocessisabarrierbecauseit’sverycumbersome.Iftherewasawayyoucoulddomoreofitonline,itcertainlywouldhelp.Andthefactthattheairportcertificationisdifferentfrom[RegionalTransportationDistrict]…ifthoseagenciescouldcommunicatemorewitheachother,itmighthelptogetmorecompaniescertified.”[#37]
Whenaskedwhatchallengesmembersfaceinstartingorgrowingabusiness,andifthereareadditionaldifficultiesforminoritiesorwomen,thesamebusinessassociationrepresentativesaid,“Theobviousoneiscapital,andit’sachallengeanysmallbusinessisgoingtoencounter.Andthenwaitingtogetpaid.Youneedmoneytopayemployeesand
![Page 439: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/439.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 12
purchasesuppliesforaproject.Theytellmethey’dlovetobeonaschoolprojector[RegionalTransportationDistrictproject]but,unfortunately,theycan’twait90daystogetpaid.Youneedalotofcashflowtopayemployeeseveryweekforthreeorfourmonthswhileyouwaitforyourmoney.Gettingloansforequipmenttogrowtheirbusinessisalsoachallenge.WeencouragethemtoapplywiththeSBAorNativeAmericanBank,ordifferentorganizationsthatmighthelptheminwaysthatatraditionalbankmightnotbeableto.”[#37]
Whenaskedwhatchallengeshismembersfaceinstartingorgrowingabusiness,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaidthatnewmembersoftendonotknow“where[to]start.”Headded,“Wehavealotofgreatresourcesandweencouragememberstousethem,likethe[Denver]MetroChamber[ofCommerce],theSBA,etcetera.”[#33]
Thesamebusinessassistanceorganizationrepresentativecontinued,“TheMinoritySupplierDevelopmentCouncilisagreatresource[too].Localbanksprovideresources.Aproblemforusthough,isthatimmigrantsbringlanguagechallenges.AsiansarecursedbecausethereisnoonesinglelanguagelikeSpanish.YouhaveCantonese,Japanese,Vietnamese,Hindi…thereareeasily25ormorelanguages.Tryingtosecureloans[and]workingwithpublicagenciestogettheirbusinessstartedismorepronouncedintheimmigrantAsianpopulation.”[#33]
Many survey respondents commented on high rent costs as a barrier for new firms.[e.g.,AS#31,AS#41,AS#54]Commentsinclude:
Asurveyrespondentsaid,“Themainbarrieristhepriceofrent.I'velookedalloverDenverandtherewasnothingsmallenoughforme.Itakealittleover700squarefeet,andIcouldn'taffordtorent.Thereisnothingsmallenoughtolowerthecostofrent.”[AS#42]
RegardingbarriersordifficultiesinDenverassociatedwithstartingorexpandingthebusiness,asurveyrespondentcommented,“Commercialrentpricesaretooexpensive.”[AS#35]
One business assistance association representative noted that high housing costs deter
potential work force.TheNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaidit’sdifficulttofindqualifiedemployeesintheDenvermetroarea.Sheadded,“Andtryingtoattractworkforcefromanotherareadoesn’tworkbecausehousingistooexpensive.”[#37]
One survey respondent indicated that some customers prefer to work with more established
businesses.Asurveyrespondentsaid,“We'veencounteredclientswhohavenotbeenwillingtoworkwithnewsmallbusinesses.”[AS#13]
One business owner reported on early challenges with business partners.TheHispanicAmericanmaleownerofaspecialtycontractingfirmstatedthathebeganhiscompanyasthesoleownerbuttookonapartnerwhenthefirmwasyoung.HeexplainedthathereliedonthepartnertoassistwithMBEcertification,thoughthepartnerwouldnothelpduetohispolitical
![Page 440: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/440.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 13
stance.Thefounderthendecidedtobuyouthispartnertoonceagainbethesoleownerofthefirm.[#4]
Another business owner indicated that the decision to start a business can be one of the
biggest challenges of business start‐up.TheHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmsaidthatdecidingtostartabusinessisahugestepwithalotofrisk.HeaddedthatSBE/MBE/WBEsshouldconsiderbusinessclosuretobeanon‐optionatfirst.[#14]
Many survey respondents reported facing tax‐related challenges.SomereportedonhighpropertytaxesintheDenverareaamongotherrelatedissues.[e.g.,AS#32,AS#52,AS#59]Forexample:
Regardingtaxes,asurveyrespondentsaid,“Youarekillinguswithpropertytax.Wecan'tbuynewequipment.Denveritselfhasyouthtax.Allthosetaxesmakeus[un]competitivewithothercompanies….”[AS#58]
Asurveyrespondentsaid,“Propertytaxesaresohighthatwe'removingthebusiness.”[AS#60]
Asurveyrespondentstated,“MyonlycomplaintisgettingtaxbillsayearlateronoldprojectsfromDenver.Ifeelthosetaxesshouldbeputinthebidsinitially.[AS#28]
Types of work that businesses perform.Intervieweesdiscussedwhetherandwhyovertimetheirfirmschangedthetypesofworkthattheyperform.
Some interviewees indicated that their companies have changed, evolved, or expanded their
lines of work over time, or conducted a wide range of services. Forexample:
TheSubcontinentAsianAmericanmaleownerofaspecialtycontractingfirmstatedthatheperformsservicesforresidentialcustomersstatewide,andcommentedthatthereisnojobtoosmallforhisfirm.[#18]
TheNativeAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,SDB‐,SDVOSB‐,andHUBZone‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmreportedthathisfirmexpandeditsproductsandservicestoincludeofficesuppliesandprinting.Whenaskedwhy,hesaidthesupplyindustrywasconsolidating,whichprovidedanopportunityforhimtoenterthemarketasa“nicheplayer.”Headdedthathespecificallytargetscompanieswithatleast15officeworkers,tribesthroughoutthenation,andthefederalgovernment.Hewentontosaythatthefirm’sgrowthcanbeattributedto“knowingwhere[they]aregoing,”andcommented,“Wedon’tjustgetonthehighway.Wehavearoadmapthatwewanttofocuson.”[#39]
Whenaskedabouttheservicesofferedbyhisfirm,theBlackAmericanveteranmaleownerofageneralcontractingcompanystatedthathisfirmperforms“alltypes”ofresidentialwork,includingelectrical,drywall,plumbing,andhomerepairs.[#29]
![Page 441: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/441.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 14
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringfirmreportedthathercompanyoffersstructuralengineeringanalysis,structuralconstructiondocumentsandspecifications,andconstructionadministrationasitrelatestostructures.[#5]
Whenaskedaboutthegrowthofherfirm,thesamebusinessownersaidtheyhavegrownmuchslowerthanothersintheindustryduetohowspecializedtheyareasastructuralengineeringcompany.[#5]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmstatedthathisfirmprovidesgeotechnicalandenvironmentalservices,includingconstructioninspection,bridgeinspection,andmaterialstesting.Hesaidthatthepercentageofworkinthevarioussectorsvariesfromyear‐to‐yeardependingonthetypesofprojectsinthemarket.[#14]
Whenaskedabouttheservicesofferedbythefirm,theHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmreportedthattheydoavarietyofservicesforcommercialandresidentialclients.[#35]
Whenaskedabouttheservicesofferedbythefirm,thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“Thecompanydoesenvironmentalconsulting.However,weareveryuniqueinthatweprovidealltypesofcivilsiteservices,whichincludeearthwork,demolitionanddismantlement,constructionsitecleanup,andotherservicesacustomermightneed.”[#28]
Whenaskedabouttheproductsandservicesofferedbythefirm,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofagoodsandservicesfirmreportedthattheyareacustomprojectshop.Hestated,“Wedoalittlebitofeverything.”[#10]
Whenaskedwhatproductsandservicesthefirmoffers,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmreportedthatthecompanyprovidespreconstructionanddesignassist,design‐build,construction,baggagehandlingsystems,andspecialprojectsservices.Henotedthattheshareofbusinessforeachaccountvariesyearlyasitcanbeimpactedbyaverylargeproject.[#21a]
Many trade association and business assistance organization representatives discussed
membership and the services offered by their organization.Forexample:
Whenaskedwhatservicestheorganizationoffersmembersandwhynewmemberswouldwanttogetinvolved,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationreportedthattheyofferopportunitiesformembers,especiallyspecialtycontractors,todeveloprelationshipswitheachother.Heexplained,“Thenumberonereasonaspecialtycontractorwouldjoinourorganizationwouldbetohaveabetterrelationshipandtostarttofigureouthowtoworkwiththosegeneralcontractorsagain.”[#40]
Thesametradeassociationrepresentativecontinued,“So,whenapublicprojectinDenvercomesoutforbidorproposal,theyalreadyknowwhatthatgeneralcontractorwantsin
![Page 442: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/442.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 15
termsofprequalification…estimates…drawingsandmodeling,andstaffing,andwhattheirwholeprogramissotheycanbeasophisticatedpartner.Andthenthesuppliers,obviously,wanttosupplytothespecialtycontractorsuptothegeneralcontractors.”[#40]
Hewentontosaythatinsum,theorganizationoffersspecialtycontractors“educationandtraining”and“provide[s]networking”forgeneralcontractors.Regardingnetworking,hesaid,“Wesurveyourmembers[and]knowourcustomersandreally,whatdifferentiatesus[fromother]constructionassociation[s]inthemarket…isthatwemakeitveryeasy…tomeettheexactpersonyouneedtomeetwithinafirmtodobusinesswiththem.”[#40]
Whenaskedtodescribetheorganization’sservices,theNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaid,“WeareatradeassociationwhosemissionistoassistcommercethatbenefitsAmericanIndiancommunitiesthrougheconomicdevelopment.”[#37]
Thesamebusinessassistanceorganizationrepresentativecontinued,“Weprovidetrainingandcommunitydevelopmentprogramssuchastaxworkshops,businesslegislationworkshops…mortgagetraining,healthequityprograms,entrepreneurialprograms,plusweserveasaresourceforournon‐nativemembers,andmore.We’vepartneredwiththeNationalCenterforAmericanIndianEnterpriseDevelopmentandtheAmericanIndianProcurementTechnicalAssistanceCentertohelpAmericanIndianbusinesseswithgovernmentcontracts.Oneofourlongestlegaciesistheannual…achievementawards,supportingandrecognizingAmericanIndianscholars,businesses,nonprofits,andprofessionals.”[#37]
Regardingtheorganization’smembership,shesaid,“Ourmembershipincludescompaniesinvolvedinclothingandaccessories,likeNativeAmericanjewelry;businessandprofessionalservices;construction;foodanddining;legaland[finance];governmentagencies;andtribalentities.”[#37]
Whenaskedwhattypesofbusinessestheorganizationserves,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationstated,“Themembershipincludeslargecorporations,largeengineeringfirms,B2Bs,smallerbusinesses,andrestaurants.Inaddition,therearemajoracademicpartnersandcompaniesinthehealthcaresector.Wealsohaveaconcessionaireat[DenverInternationalAirport],andwe’reveryproudofthat.”[#33]
Whenaskedifmanyoftheorganization’smembersworkintransportation‐relatedconstructionorengineering,thesamebusinessassistanceorganizationrepresentativestatedthatafewoftheirmembersworkontransportation‐relatedconstruction.Hesaid,“Wehave[amemberwhois]aconcessionaireattheairport.Wehaveafewengineers,butIcouldprobablycountononehandhowfewAsianengineersthereare.When[RegionalTransportationDistrict]ortheairportreachouttous,wefranklystrugglewithgettingattendees.”[#33]
TheHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationreportedthattheorganizationhelpsadvocateonbehalfofminority‐andwomen‐ownedsmallbusinesses,as
![Page 443: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/443.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 16
wellasforsomelargerprimecontractors.Heexplained,“Inmanyways,wearetheconnectorbetweenoursmallbusinesses,theminority‐andwomen‐ownedbusinesses,andtheprimes,aswellaspublicentities,thecity,publicschools,[RegionalTransportationDistrict],CDOT,andtheairport.”[#11]
Thesametradeassociationrepresentativecontinued,“Wetrytogatherinformationfromthosevariouspublicentitiesandprovidethatinformationtoourmembers.Wealsolookforprivateworkand[other]opportunitiesandensurethatourmembershipisawareofthoseopportunities.”Hesaidthatmostmembersareinvolvedintheconstructionindustry,butnoted,“Wehavesomeprintshops,marketingfolks,consultants,andothersoftskillslikeHRconsultants….”[#11]
Whenaskedaboutthetypesofworkmembersperform,hesaidthatmembersworkontransportation‐relatedconstructionandengineeringwork.Heexplained,“Theydobothverticalandhorizontalworkaswellasprofessionaldesign.OneofthethingsthatwearealsoworkingonistryingtoattractmoreprofessionalservicesfirmstoourorganizationbecauseIthinkithasalwaysbeenknownasconstruction….Therearealotofprofessionalservicescompaniesouttherethatcouldbenefitfromourorganization,anditwouldbenefitbothsidesbecausethenyougettoknowwho'sactuallydesigningtheengineering…andthenwho’sbuildingit.”[#11]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthatshehasbeenwiththeorganizationforover25years.Shedescribedtheorganizationasabusinessassociationforhorizontalandverticalengineeringfirmsintheprivatesector.”Shesaid,“Besidestransportation,bridges,[and]roads,[members]arealso[working]withwaterinfrastructure.That’swhatIconsiderhorizontal,butthere’salsotheverticalside.”[#38]
Whenaskedwhattheorganizationoffersitsmembers,thesametradeassociationrepresentativesaid,“Wedoalotofnetworkingevents,educationalprogramming,[and]anythingdealingwiththebusinesssideofengineering.”Shesaidthatmembersseekmembershipwithherassociation“becausetheyknow[theassociation]canhelpthemwiththebusinessside[ofthings].”Engineersgotoschooltobeengineersinthetechnicalside.Theydon’tgotoschooltolearnabouthowtorunabusiness.”[#38]
Shecontinued,“Wehelpthemwiththattransitionfrombeingtechnicalexpertstorunningtheirbusiness,[tobecome]businesspeople….Theylooktousforthosewaysinwhichtheycan…growtheirbusinessesandbeastrongbusinessentity.”[#38]
Many interviewees reported stable work types or little or no change in the type of work they
do.[e.g.,#6,#7,#9,#12,#15a,#16,#19,#20,#22,#23a,#24,#25,#26,#27,#31,#32a,#34,#36]
Employment size of businesses.Businessownersandrepresentativeswereaskedaboutthenumberofpeopletheyemployandiftheiremploymentsizefluctuates.Manydiscussedtheirfirms’growthincomparisontoothersintheindustry.
![Page 444: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/444.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 17
TheSubcontinentAsianAmericanmaleownerofaspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthatheisthesoleemployeeofhiscompany.Whenaskedwhathedoesifajobistoobig,heindicatedthathehiresindependentcontractors.Heexplained,“IhavemanyfellowcontractorsthatIuseinthatsituation.”[#18]
Whenaskedaboutthegrowthofhiscompany,thesamebusinessownersaidthathisbusinessiscurrentlyveryprofitableandthathehasthecapitaltobuildanewprimarybusinesslocation.Hewentontocommentthatmostothercontractorsheworkswitharealsoprivatecontractorswithfirmsofsimilarsize.[#18]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmreportedthatherfirmhastwoemployees,includingherself.Whenaskedtodescribethefirm’sgrowth,shesaid,“I’vebeeninbusiness[over10]yearsandstillonlyhavetwoemployees,soI’mnotgrowing.”Shelaternotedthatsheseesalotofsmallfirmslikehersthatarealsonotgrowing.[#35]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andESB‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmreportedthatthefirmconsistsofonlytwoemployees,includinghimself.Regardinghowhisfirm’sgrowthcomparestoothersintheindustry,heindicatedthatthefirmisdoingaswellasothers.Henotedthatthey’veseenconsistentandsteadygrowthsince2011.[#9]
TheBlackAmericanveteranmaleownerofageneralcontractingcompanyreportedthatheistheonlyemployeeofthefirm.Heexplained,“IfIneedhelp,IwillhirepeopleIknowthatcandothejob.Therearemanyindependentcontractorsoutthere.”[#29]
Whenaskedaboutthefirm’sgrowth,thesamebusinessownersaidthatheissatisfiedwiththeamountandtypeofworkhereceives.Headded,“Iusedtohaveanofficein[acityintheDenverarea],[but]movedtheofficeintomyhousefortheconvenienceoftakingcareofpaperworkanytimeofthedayornight.Iworksixdaysperweek,andthat’sthewayothercontractorsareworkingnow.ThereisalotofworkinDenverrightnow.Weallfeelwehavetotakefulladvantageofitwhilewecan.”[#29]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofanengineeringcompanystated,“Iusedtohavefiveemployeesandapartner,andacontractdrafter.Butasthingshavesloweddown,Ileteveryoneelsego….I’monlyplanningtoworkanother4[to]5years.”[#26]
Whenaskedhowthegrowthofhiscompanycomparestoothersintheindustry,thesamebusinessownersaid,“Ihaveseenasteady,slowdownturnintheworkIdo….AsIlaidoffemployees,Imovedtoasmalleroffice…atthesamephysicaladdress.Iknowtherearealotofotherhigh‐endresidentialengineersdoingverywell,[but]IamsatisfiedwithwhereIamnowinmycareer.”[#26]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemaleco‐ownerofaspecialtyservicesfirmreportedthatsheandtheotherco‐owneraretheonlyemployeesofthecompany.Regardingthefirm’sgrowth,shesaid,“With[ourlineofwork],it’skindoflikewhenyoufindadentistandstaywithadentist.I’mgettingsomeothercustomersfromotherbusinesses,butmostlyit’snew
![Page 445: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/445.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 18
customersthatarecomingtome.Newbusinessesareaskingfortheirworktobedonehere.”[#8]
Whenaskedhowmanyemployeeshisfirmhas,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaconstructionservicesfirmstated,“Iamtheownerandtheprimaryworker,[but]Ihavehiredahelperbecausethereisjustsomuchworkrightnow.So,thetotalnumber[ofemployees]istwo.ThisissatisfactoryformerightnowbecauseIworkoutofmyhome.”[#31]
Regardingthegrowthofhiscompany,thesamebusinessownerstated,“Allsmallindependentbusinesseslikemineareexperiencingverygoodgrowthrightnow.Iwasoffforaboutsix‐monthslastyearbecauseofsurgery[and]I’mjustnowgettingbacktothelevelIwanttobe.I’mverypleasedaboutthatbecausemymarketingcomesfromwordofmouth.Idon’tevenhaveawebsitetoadvertise.”[#31]
Whenaskedhowmanyemployeeshiscompanyhas,theHispanicAmericanmaleownerofanengineeringfirmreportedthattheycurrentlyhavefouremployees,allofwhicharelicensedprofessionalengineers.[#16]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofagoodsandservicesfirmreportedthatthefirmhasfivefull‐timeemployees.Hesaidthathebelievesthefirm’sgrowthrateishigherthantheindustryaverage.Heexplained,“We’reaveryagilecompany,andsowekindofgowherethemarketis.Andwegrowtomeettheneedsofourconsumersandourclients.So,whileothercompaniesmightspecializeinjustonething,wedon’tnecessarilyspecialize.Wegeneralizeinalotofwayssowecanbettersuitwhatourcustomersneedfortheirspecificprojects.”[#10]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthatthefirmhasfivefull‐timeemployees,includingherself.Sheaddedthatthefirmhasonepart‐timeemployeeandonecontractemployee.Whenaskedhowthegrowthofherfirmcomparestoothersintheindustry,shesaidtheirgrowthis“conservative.”Sheexplained,“Wehaven’ttriedtopushourgrowthreallyaggressively,butall[professionalserviceswork]tendstofolloweconomiccycles….We’rethesameastherestoftheworldinthatcapacity,oratleasttherestoftheindustry.”[#12]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmreportedthatthefirmcurrentlyhasfivefull‐timeemployees.Shesaid,“IwishIcouldhiremore.It’shardtofindpeoplethatwanttostandoutintheweatherdirectingtraffic.”[#27]
Regardingthegrowthofherfirm,thesamebusinessownerstatedthatsheissatisfied.Sheexplained,“WegetalotofworkfromCDOTbecauseofalloftheprojectsaroundthestatethatneedtheserviceweprovide.Idon’tseethatslowingdownatall.Therearesofew…companies[inourfield],[so]wereallydon’tmarket.[Clients]cometous.Thereisalotofrepeatbusinessbecausewedoagoodjob.Idon’tbelieveIcouldtakeonmuchmoreworkbecauseIdon’thavethestaffrightnow.”[#27]
![Page 446: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/446.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 19
TheHispanicAmericanmaleownerofaspecialtycontractingfirmstatedthathisfirmhassevenemployees,allofwhomworkfulltime.Hewentontosaythatthegrowthofhiscompanyhasbeensteady.Headded,"Ithinkweareanichetypeoffirmthatisnotcomparabletoageneralfirm[intheindustry]….Iwouldsaywe'recomparabletoa[specialty]contractorintermsofgrowth."[#4]
Thesamefirmownerreportedthathetriestokeephisfirm'sgrowthincheck.Heexplained,“Idon'tmarket[tootherfirms]becauseIfeellikeI'mgoingtogettoobusyandI'llhavetohirepermanentguysandgetmoretruckstokeepupwiththatflowofevenservicework.”Hewentontoexplainthatthefirmdoeshopetogrowinthefuturewhentheyhavetheappropriateresources.[#4]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringfirmreportedthatshehasfourpart‐timeemployeesandfourfull‐timeemployees.[#5]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedgeneralcontractingfirmstatedthatherfirmhasfivefull‐timeemployees,includingherself,andsixpart‐timeemployees.Sheaddedthatsheispleasedwiththesteadygrowthofhercompany,andcommented,“IneedtomakesurethatIamconstantlyawareofthatgrowth.Itwouldbedangerousgrowingtoofast,agreeingoncontracts,andnothavinglabororequipmenttosatisfythescope.”[#19]
Whenaskedhowhercompany’sgrowthcomparestoothersintheindustry,thesamebusinessownerstated,“Ihaveoneverylargecompetitorthathasbeenaroundfor[almost]30years.I’mnotsurehowtheirgrowthis,[but]Ibelieveourgrowthisabovetherestbecausewedoepoxy,whichisrequiredforCDOTjobs.Thosemachinesareexpensive,andIdon’tbelievetheothersmallcompanieshavethatequipment.”[#19]
Whenaskedaboutthefirm’semploymentsize,theAsian‐PacificAmericanfemalerepresentativeofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmsaid,“Wecurrentlyhave12employeesworkingforusfulltime.Ikeeptrackofthatverycloselytomakesurewehaveallweneedfortheworkweget.Mostoftheemployeeshavebeenaroundforatleasttwoyears.”[#32b]
Whenaskedabouthisfirm’semploymentsize,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaconstruction‐relatedfirmreportedthattheycurrentlyhaveeightfull‐timeemployeesand“sixjuniorengineers.”Hecommented,“Whenwemerged,[mypartner]camewiththreetotalemployees.Wehaveastronggroupthatworkswelltogether.”[#25]
Whenaskedtodescribethegrowthofhiscompany,thesamebusinessownerstated,“ThecurrentlocationiswhereIhavealwayshadmyoffice.Wegotbiggerspaceintheofficebuildingwhenwemerged.”Headded,“Thislocationistheonlyoffice.”[#25]
Whenaskedtodescribethegrowthofhisfirm,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmsaid,“Iamverypleasedwiththegrowthwehaverightnow,[but]Ibelieveopportunities[maybe]slowingdownsome.
![Page 447: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/447.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 20
That’sbasedonconversationswehavewithanothercablingcompany.However,wehaven’tfeltanyimpactyet.”[#32a]
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“Ihaveheardfromother…companiesthattheirworkisslowingdownconsiderably,and[that]theamountsofthecontractsaregettingsmaller.Weconcentrateonmakingsureourcustomerissatisfied.Thatiswhymostofourbusinesscomesfromwordofmouth.”Headded,“Thecompanyhasnevermissedadeadline….Ourannualrevenuesareabout$2million.”[#32a]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthathisfirmhas10full‐timeemployeesand15part‐timeemployees.Regardinghisfirm’sgrowthcomparedtothecompetition,hesaid,“Somehavegrownalotfasterthanwehavebecauseweconcentrateonaparticulartypeofcustomer,andwedon’tmarketinthesamewaythatotherfirmsdo.Wedon’tuseGooglemarketing[or]payforanalytics.Ourbusinessmodelisbasicallyreferralsandwordofmouth.”[#7]
Thesamebusinessco‐owneradded,“We’renotaggressivelytryingtogrowintoalargercompany.Wewanttostayasmallbusinessbecauseit’sawayforustodeliverwhatwesaywewanttodeliverasasmallbusiness,[whichis]enablingtheownertogoseeeverysinglecustomer.Weknow[that]ifwegrowintoalargerbusiness,thatwon’tbepossible.”[#7]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE,SBE,andESB‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmreported,“Icurrentlyemploy17staff.”[WT#15]
Whenaskedaboutthefirm’semploymentsize,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedspecialtyservicesfirmreportedthatthefirmhas25employees.[#34]
Regardingthefirm’sgrowth,thesamebusinessownersaidthatithasbeengrowingsteadilysincetheendoftherecession.Whenaskedwhatgotthemthroughtherecession,heresponded,“Goingdigital[did].”[#34]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmreportedthatthefirmemploysabout28people.Shesaidthatthefirmisnotmeetingitsgrowthpotentialbecauseshedoesnotpursuemanycontractsnationwide.Sheexplainedthatsheisthinkingaboutretirementanddoesnotwanttojeopardizeherhouseandretirementsavingstogrowthefirm.[#20]
TheBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionsupplyfirmreportedthatthefirmhas“roughly40employees…fiveof[which]arepart‐time.”[#36]
Whenaskedaboutthefirm’sgrowth,thesamebusinessownerstated,“Theretailportionhasbeenfairlysteady.Theonlywaytogrowthatistoinvestinmorelocations.Thewholesalebusinesshasbeendifficultatbest.Atonetimewewerecertifiedwith[RegionalTransportationDistrict],butweoutgrewtheirprogram[and]lostthatcontract.Thatwasabitofasetback.”[#36]
![Page 448: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/448.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 21
Hecontinued,“Nowitgoesupanddownwiththeeconomy.WehavealotofbigcompetitorsouttherethathavemorebuyingpowerthanIdo.I’minasecondarypositionwhenIgotothe[supplier]becauseIdon’thaveenoughvolumetogetadirectcontract.Withoutadirectcontract,you’reatapricedisadvantage.I’moneortwocentsovercostbecauseIhavetogothroughajobber.”[#36]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmsaidthathestartedhisfirmbyhimself,thoughoverthenextthreetofouryearsitgrewto10employees.Sincethen,headded,hisfirmhasgrowntoitscurrentsizeof48employees.[#14]
Whenaskedaboutthegrowthofthefirm,thesamebusinessownersaidthatitisclosetotheaverageforhisindustry.Henotedthatseveralotherminority‐ownedfirmsinhisindustryhavegrownfaster,thoughhesaidthatheattributesthatgrowthtotheirhireofformerCDOTemployees.[#14]
TheBlackAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmstatedthathercompanyhasaworkforceof25to50employees.Shelateraddedthatthecompanygrewtotwolocations.[#13]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmreported,“Thereareabout200employeesinthecompany.Aboutfive[yearsago]wechangedthebusinessmodeltoonethatprovidedfull‐servicetocustomers[with]ateamapproachtocompletingprojects.Thecompanywillself‐performmostoftheprojectsawarded,whichmeanswedotheworkfromstarttofinish.Thetypesofpositionswehaveincludedesign,estimating,construction,andprojectmanagement.”[#28]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmreportedthatthecompanyhas567employees,whichincludestheirUtahandArizonaoffices.[#21d]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmdescribedthefirm’sgrowthasaboveaveragefortheindustry.Hesaidthatthefirmwasawardeda$75millionproject10yearsafteritsfounding.Yearslater,headded,thefirmwasawardedthelargestdesign‐buildprojectinNorthAmericaatthattime.By2016,hesaidthattheyperformedover$2billionoflargecommercialandindustrialinstallationprojectsintheU.S.andabroad.[#21a]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmsaidthatthefirmhasroughly10,000nationwideemployees,withabout600ofthoseinColorado.Headdedthattheirgrowthisaboveaveragebecausetheyareoneofthelargestelectricaldistributorsinthecountry.[#23a]
A number of companies reported that they expand and contract their employment size
depending on work opportunities or market conditions.Somereportedusingsubcontractors,whenneeded,toincreaseresources.[e.g.,#18]Forexample:
![Page 449: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/449.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 22
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofanSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaidthatthefirmcurrentlyhassixemployeesandisintheprocessofhiringtwomore.[#15a]
Whenaskedaboutthefirm’sgrowthcomparedtoothersintheindustry,thesamebusinessco‐ownercommentedthatgrowthhasbeen“flat.”Shesaidthatthefirmhasnotbouncedbackfromtherecession.Sheadded,“It’sachallengeforsmallfirmstoovercometheperceptionof[not]beingabletocompletethework.Peopleareafraidwewillgetoverloadedandbeunabletocompletethework,[though]we’venevermissedadeadline.”[#15a]
TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthatthefirmhaseightemployees.Whenaskedtodescribethefirm’sgrowth,hesaid,“WhenIfirststartedmycompanyIwasasoleproprietor,andIslowlyaddedoneortwopeople.Andthenin[theearly1980s]Itookonapartner….Thatlastedaboutfouryearsandwegotintolargerprojects.In[themid‐1990s]thecompanytookonadifferentcorporatestructurewhenItookonfourpartners.Wegrewtoabout20[employees]until9/11,thenthefirmshranktoabout10….”[#22]
Whenaskedhowthegrowthofhisfirmcomparestootherfirmsintheindustry,thesamebusinessownerstated,“That’stoughtosay.Itseemslikethelargerfirmsgetlargerandthesmallerfirmsgetsmaller.Ifyou’rea100‐plusfirm,you’readdingpeople.Ifyou’re20orless,you’relosingpeople.”[#22]
Whenaskedthefirm’semploymentsize,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaspecialtyservicesfirmsaid,“Wecurrentlyhave13full‐timeemployees,[and]oneofthoseemployeeshasbeenwiththecompanysincemyfatherstartedit.”[#30]
Whenaskedaboutthegrowthofthefirm,thesamebusinessownersaid,“Wedidopenabranchin[anotherstate]severalyearsagobecauseweweregettingalotofworkdownthere,[but]unfortunatelythatdriedupbecausecompaniesfinditeasiertoprintin‐house.Weonlyhave[one]locationnow.Wewereonlyin[anotherstate]foraboutayear.”Regardingmanagingmultiplelocations,hesaid,“It’shardtomanagemorethanonesite.Thedemandsofmanagingemployees,financials,andmarketingtodifferenttypesofcustomersismorethanafull‐timejob….Eventhoughweclosedin[anotherstate]…everythingisrighthereatthehomeoffice,andit’seasiertomanage.”[#30]
Whenaskedhowthefirm’sgrowthcomparestoothersintheindustry,hesaid,“Weareoneofthelastbig[companiesinourfield].Wecontinuetodevelopbusinessrelationshipstostayinbusiness.”[#30]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmreportedthathercompanyemploys45people.Shesaidithasgoneashighas50full‐timeemployeeswhentheyhaveincreasedworkloads.Whenaskedaboutthegrowthofhercompany,shesaidthey'vegrownatarateslowerthanotherfirms.[#2]
![Page 450: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/450.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 23
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaconstructionfirmstated,“Iamtheonlyemployeeofmycompany.”Headdedthatifajobis“toobig,”hewillhireotherelectricalcontractorsasneeded.[#24]
Whenaskedaboutthefirm’sgrowth,thesamebusinessownersaid,“Iamverysatisfiedwiththegrowthofmycompany.I’vealwaysworkedoutofmyhome.Itallowsmetospendtimewithmy[family].”[#24]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleowneroraprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthatheemployedsixorsevenpeoplefiveyearsafterthefoundingofhisfirm.Henowemploysfourpeople,attributingthedeclinetotherecessionin2008.[#3]
Thesamefirmownerwentontosaythatfirmsheisfamiliarwithhaveexperiencedsignificantgrowthinrecentyears.Headded,"I'mnotasinterestedingrowthasIaminmaintainingthetypeofworkthatwedo.Ihaveneverhadadesiretohaveabiggerfirm."Heattributedthispreferenceforhavingasmallfirmtothehighdegreeofspecializationofsmallerfirms.Healsonoted,"Itrytostaffforacomfortablelevel.I'mnotinthehabitofhiringpeopleandthenlayingthemoff."[#3]
One business owner indicated that the firm’s employment size sometime fluctuates
seasonally.TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedgeneralcontractingfirmsaid,“Whenthingsareslow,Ikeepthepart‐timeemployeesbusydoingmaintenance.Ijustcan’taffordtolosethem.Thisworkcanbeseasonal,andworkforceistightrightnow.”[#19]
A trade association representative reported that most member firms have 30 employees or
less.Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaid,“Wehave260‐memberfirmsthroughoutthestatethatemployover11,500people.”Whenaskedaboutthesizeofmemberfirms,shesaid,“Seventy‐fivepercentofourmembersare30peopleorless.They’recomfortablebeingthatsmallsize,butatthesametimetheyneedtobesurethatthey’reinapositiontobeasuccessfulbusiness.So,theylooktousforthat.”[#38]
Capability of businesses to perform different types and sizes of contracts. Businessownersandrepresentativesdiscussedthetypes,sizes,andlocationsofcontractsthattheirfirmsperform.Contractsizesrangefrom$100totensofmillionsofdollars.Commentsinclude:
TheBlackAmericanveteranmaleownerofageneralcontractingcompanystated,“Mycontractsareusually$15,000uptoabout$30,000.”[#29]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofagoodsandservicesfirmstatedthattheyusuallyworkdirectlywithclientsandthatordersrangebetween$10,000and$30,000.[#10]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaconstructionfirmstated,“[I]workonsmallandlargejobs.Thejobsmycompanyperformsareapproximately$30,000to$50,000.Itdependsonthejob,butifit’stoobigIwillhireotherelectricalcontractors.Therearelotsofindependentcontractorsoutthere,andIworkwithmanyofthem.”[#24]
![Page 451: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/451.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 24
Regardinghisfirm’sannualrevenue,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofanengineeringcompanysaid,“Therevenuesvary.Wedon’tmakealotofmoney,but[it’s]enough.”[#25]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaidthatherpreferredcontractsizeis7,000to50,000squarefeet.[#35]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedspecialtyservicesfirmreportedthattheircontractsrangefrom$100to$100,000.[#34]
Whenaskedaboutthesizesofcontractshisfirmpursues,theBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthattheybidcontractsranginganywherefrom$5,000to$100,000.[#7]
Regardingthesizesofcontractshisfirmpursues,theBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andESB‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmreportedthattheyhavecompletedcontractsrangingfrom$100toaround$350,000.[#9]
Thesamebusinessownerlatersaid,“We’veworkedwithacoupleofprimes[where]theprojectswerereally,reallysmallinrelationtosomeoftheotherprojectsthatwe’vedone.[Forexample],$10,000or$15,000versus$100,000or$250,000[contracts].”[#9]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaspecialtyservicesfirmsaid,“[Our]contractsrangefrom$500to$500,000insize,[though]thoseverylargecontractsarehardtocomebynow.[#30]
Whenaskedwhatsizecontractsherfirmbidsonorperforms,thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthatherfirm’sdesignbudgetsrangefrom$2,000to$15,000.Sheadded,“Thenourconstructionobservationfeesprobablyrunaboutthesame.Wehaveconstructionfeesthatrunupto$30,000.Theprojectswebuildrangeinvaluefrom$20,000uptohalfamilliondollars….”[#12]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleownerofaspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthathisfirmonlyobtainsbusinessintheFrontRange.Headded,"Atfirst,mybiggestcontractwas$50,000,thenitwas$100,000,thenitwas$200,000,andnowit's$300,000.Rightaroundthat$300,000or$500,000markisaboutmylimitrightnow,asfaraskeepingupwithlaborwagesandmaterialcostsandothercosts."Headded,"Idon'twanttogrowtoomuchbecauseIdon'twanttogettoapointwhereItrytotackleamillion‐dollarjobanddon'thavethebackingforit."[#4]
Whenaskedaboutthetypesandsizesofcontractsherfirmpursues,thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringfirmsaid,“Thelargestcontractwe’vehadwasjustshyof$300,000,and[that]lastedforthreeyears.”Shecontinued,“Rightnow,ourlargestcontractis$200,000.Ithinkwecouldgoupto$500,000beforewestarttobecrushedundertheload[ofwork].”[#5]
![Page 452: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/452.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 25
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthattheirfirm'slargestcontractwasover$1million,whichhedescribedasbeingdifficultforafirmwithonlyfouremployees.Thefirm'saveragecontractsrangefrom$250,000to$500,000perproject.[#3]
Whenaskedwhatsizesofcontracts/ordersthefirmbidsonorperforms,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“Thefeerangeisanywherefrom$5,000to$1million.”[#22]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedgeneralcontractingfirmstated,“Lastyearwehad120projectsand$4millioninrevenue….Weperformanythingfrom$500to$1,000jobsallthewayuptoasingleprojectsizeof$1.7million.”[#19]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“Ourcontractsizesareabout$2million.Wearedefinitelylookingtogrowthatnumberbycontinuingtoseekotherprojects.I’mnotsureiftherearesimilarcompaniesthathaveadoptedthismodelofself‐performingthework.”Shewentontocomment,“Ourcompanyreputationspeaksforitself.Weoftenaresoughtafterforotherprojectwork.”[#28]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmreportedthathisfirmcanhandlecontractsrangingfromafewthousanddollarstomillionsofdollars.[#14]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmreportedthatthefirm’scontractsaregenerallyintherangeof$1millionto$2million.Sheaddedthattheyonlydotimeandmaterials(T&M)contractsandavoid“hardbids.”[#20]
Whenaskedaboutthesizesofcontractshisfirmpursues,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofanengineeringcompanystated,“Theirsizesareinthemillions[ofdollars].”[#26]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmreportedthatherfirmbidsonprojectsrangingfrom$50,000to$4million.[#2]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofanSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthatthefirmbidsoncontractsrangingfrom$100,000to$30million,andthattenantimprovementcanrangeupto$50million.[#15a]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmsaidthecompanyhasgrowntobecomeatop‐rankedcontractorinColoradoandtheUnitedStatesingeneral.Hesaidtheymainlydolargeandsmallcommercialandindustrialprojects;theirfive‐yearaverageisalmost$82millioninrevenues.[#21a]
One business owner reported not bidding often due to the nature of the firm’s work.TheBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionsupplyfirmsaid,
![Page 453: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/453.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 26
“Becauseitisawholesaletypecommodity,therearenotalotofthingsyoubidon.If…it’sliketheCityandCountyofDenverputtingoutabidfor[oneofourproducts],webidonthatofcourse.Also,theothermunicipalitiesputoutbidsaswellforfuelthatwewilltrytobidon.Therestofthecommercialmarketdoesn’thavealineitem.”Headded,“Someofthebigtransportationcompaniesmighthavebidopportunities,buttheyareoutofreachforusbecausethey’renationalinscope.”[#36]
A trade association representative reported that members perform a wide range of contract
sizes.TheBlackAmericanfemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthatthecontractsmemberfirmsbidonrangefromtensofthousandsofdollarstomillionsofdollars.Shesaidthelargestcontractamongmemberstodatewasvaluedatover$90million,andaddedthat60to75percentofherchapter’smembersareengagedintransportation‐relatedconstructionandengineeringwork.[#6]
Many firms reported working on contracts throughout City and County of Denver.SomefirmsreportedworkingonlyintheDenvermetroarea,whileothersreportedworkingstatewideandoutofstate.Forexample:
Regardingtheareaswherehisfirmperforms,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofanengineeringcompanysaid,“Itrytostayinthemetroarea,includingthemountains.”[#26]
Regardingtheareaswherehisfirmperforms,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaconstructionfirmstated,“ItrytostayintheDenvermetroarea,butwillworkaroundthestate.”[#24]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaconstruction‐relatedfirmstated,“WeprefertoworkintheDenvermetroarea,butwilltravelaroundthestate[ifnecessary].”[#25]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmreportedthatthefirmservicestheDenvermetroarea,andareasrangingnorthandsouthofDenver.[#35]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemaleco‐ownerofaspecialtyservicesfirmreportedthatthecompanyworksinnorthernandsouthernareasofthestate.[#8]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmreportedthatthefirmisheadquarteredintheDenverarea.SheindicatedthattheyworkonlyintheDenvermetroarea.[#20]
Regardingtheregionswherethefirmworks,theBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionsupplyfirmreportedthatthefirmisheadquarteredinDenverandservicestheI‐25corridor,“about80milesnorthandsouthoftheDenvermetroarea.”[#36]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedspecialtyservicesfirmreportedthatthefirmisheadquarteredandconductsmostoftheirbusinessintheDenvermetroarea.Hewentontosaythattheyhaveoneout‐of‐stateclient.[#34]
![Page 454: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/454.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 27
Thenon‐HispanicwhitemaleownerofaprofessionalservicesfirmstatedthathisfirmworksintheCityofDenverandincommunitiesalongtheFrontRange,aswellasdoingworkwiththeColoradoDepartmentofTransportation,theColoradoDivisionofWildlifeandtheDenverWaterDepartment.[#3]
Thesameownerreportedthathisfirmhasdoneasmallnumberofinternationalprojects,butthefirmnolongerpursuesthoseprojectsduetodifficultiesreceivingpayment.[#3]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthathisfirmisheadquarteredinParkerandthattheyseekbusinessasfarawaythroughoutthestate.HeaddedthattheyalsodoalotofworkalongtheFrontRange,Denvermetroarea,andotherareas.[#7]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmsaidthathercompanyseeksbusinessonlyinColorado,specificallytheDenvermetroarea.Shewentontosaythattheyhaveperformedinotherareasofthestate.[#2]
Regardingtheregionswherehisfirmperforms,theHispanicAmericanmaleownerofanarchitecturalengineeringfirmreportedthattheyareheadquarteredinBoulderandgenerallyperformworkalongtheFrontRange.Headdedthattheyusedtodoworkinseveralstates,butcurrentlyonlyhavelicensesinColoradoandCalifornia.[#16]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthattheyseekbusinessalongtheFrontRangeand“upintothemountains,”butgoasfarasNewMexicoorWyoming,oranywherein“thearidwest.”ShereportedthatthefirmislocatedinDenver.[#12]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedgeneralcontractingfirmreported,“[We]workalloverthestateandarestartingtodojobsinWyoming.”[#19]
Whenaskedabouttheregionswhereherfirmworks,thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringfirmsaidthatshehaslicensesin19states.Sheaddedthatthey’veproposedonprojectsinMongolia,Qatar,andGuam,thoughtheyhaveyettoworkinternationally.ShereportedthatherfirmislocatedinDenverwithoneofficelocation.[#5]
TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmsaid,“WehavestarteddoingworkinCaliforniaoverthelastfewmonths.Thatadditiontothecompanyhasbeengoodsofar.”[#32a]
Whenaskedwheresheworks,theHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofanSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmstatedthattheydoworkstatewideandarelicensedinnumerousotherstates.Denver,sheadded,isthefirm’ssolelocation.Shewentontosaythattheyhaveregularnationwideworkforoneoftheirclients.[#15a]
![Page 455: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/455.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 28
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmsaidthatthefirmdoesbusinessnationwideandisheadquarteredinTexas.[#23a]
Whenaskedaboutthefirm’sservicearea,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaspecialtyservicesfirmstated,“Wewillprovide[our]servicetoanycompanyoranyoneacrossthenation,[and]wehaveprovidedthisserviceacrossthenation.”HelateraddedthatthefirmisheadquarteredintheDenverarea.[#30]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmreportedthathisfirmworksnationally.HesaidthathisfirmisheadquarteredintheDenverarea,butalsohasofficesinotherColoradocities.Hewentontosaythatthemajorityofhisout‐of‐stateworkiswiththeU.S.FishandWildlifeService.[#14]
A few business owners and representatives reported that their firms also work internationally.Forexample:
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmreportedthatthecompanyhasofficesinColorado,Utah,andArizona,andhasperformedworkthroughouttheWesternUnitedStatesandinternationally.[#21a]
Whenaskedwhatregionsthefirmworksin,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“WenormallyworkintheDenvermetroarea.Theonlytimeweventureoutiswhenalocalclienthasaprojectinanotherstate.WehavedoneprojectsasfarawayasTaiwan,butthatwasthroughalocalpharmaceuticalcompany…Someofthefederalprojectmanagerscoverwideregions,andthattakesustootherstates.We’vehadprojectsinTexas,NorthDakota,etcetera.”Headdedthatthefirm’ssolelocationisintheDenvermetroarea.[#22]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andESB‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmreportedthatthefirm’ssoleheadquartersisinDenver.Headded,“OurprimarymarketisNorthAmerica,althoughwehavedoneacoupleofprojectsoutsideofthatmarket.One[was]inAustraliaandoneinGermany.”[#9]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofagoodsandservicesfirmreportedthatthefirmoperatesinternationally.Headdedthatthefirm’ssolelocationisinColorado.[#10]
Some trade association and business assistance organization representatives reported on the
regions where they seek members, and where members primarily work.Forexample:
Whenaskedhowfartheorganizationtypicallyseeksmembers,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationreportedthattheorganization’smembersareconcentratedwithintheDenvermetroarea.HenotedthattheorganizationhashadeventswithColoradoStateUniversityinFortCollins,andthattheyalsohaveeventsinColoradoSprings.HewentontosaythattheorganizationisheadquarteredinDenver.[#33]
![Page 456: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/456.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 29
Thesamebusinessassistanceorganizationrepresentativecontinued,“Membershipoverthelastfouryearshasgrownapproximately10percent.Moreimportantly,wehaveexpandedourpositionandbrandacrosstheUnitedStates,andalso…international[ly]…duetoafocusedeffortoninternationaltrade[and]workingwithourconsularoffices.ThereareconsularofficesforJapan,Taiwan,andSingaporewhicharelookingtobuildaconsularofficehere.WealsohavearelationshipwiththeconsularofficeofthePeople’sRepublicofChinawhichisbasedinChicago.Wegoondelegationtrips[andare]lookingatpotentiallygoingtoVietnamlaterthisyear.”[#33]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaid,“The[heaviest]concentration[ofmembers]isalongtheFrontRangefromFortCollinstoColoradoSprings…butwehavemembersandprovideprogramsorhavemeetingsinotherparts[of]thestate,whetherit’snorth,south,[orthe]WesternSlope.”[#38]
Whenaskedhowfartheorganizationtypicallyseeksmembers,aNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaid,“WeserveIndiancommunitiesaroundtheUnitedStates,andhaveafewcontactsabroad.”[#37]
Whenaskedwheretheorganizationisheadquartered,thesamebusinessassistanceorganizationrepresentativereportedthattheyarebasedinDenver.However,shenotedthattheyserveIndiancommunitiesthroughoutthecountry.[#37]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationreportedthattheorganizationservesthegreaterColoradoarea.[#40]
TheHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationreportedthattheorganizationislocatedinDenver,andthatmostmembersarefromtheDenvermetroarea,thoughtheyhavemembersasfarsouthasPueblo,andasfarnorthasFortCollins.Headded,“OneofthegoalsthatwehopetoexplorewithinthenextyearisdoinganopenhouseintheColoradoSprings/Puebloarea,andpossiblyuptoFortCollinsandGreeleytointroduceourorganizationandwhatweareallabout.”[#11]
Whenaskedwheretheorganization’smembersreside,theBlackAmericanfemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthatbecauseit’sanationalorganization,membersarenationwidethrough35activechapters.Shenotedthatsomemembersworkinternationally.[#6]
Whenaskedaboutherlocalchapterspecifically,thesametradeassociationrepresentativesaid,“WehaveatleastonememberdowninColoradoSprings.WehadamemberfromWyomingatonepoint,too….Someofourmembershavemembershipsinotherstates[too],[in]citieslikeSeattle[and]Boston.”[#6]
Local effects of the economic downturn.Afewintervieweessharedcommentsabouttheirexperienceswiththebarriersandchallengesassociatedwiththeeconomicdownturn.Forexample:
![Page 457: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/457.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 30
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“Ithinkbetween2008and2009ourgrossrevenuedroppedby50percent,andtonsofarchitecture…engineeringandconstructioncompanieswentoutofbusinessintheGreatRecession.Itwasvery,verysignificant.Companiessay,‘Yeah,wemadeitthrough,’andthat’sabigdeal.Everyonejustlimpedalong.WeweremakingitonHailMaryprayers[and]notreallyanythingelse.Thenin2011[through2012]thingsstartedtoreallypickup,andthenit’sjustbeen[great]sincethen.”[#12]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthatduetotherecessionin2008hisfirmhadtoreducethenumberofemployeesfrom"sixorseven"tofour,andthatnumberhas"remainedatthatlevelsincethattime."[#3]
Thesamefirmownerexplainedthatpublicsectorworkwasslowforhisfirmuntilabouttwoyearsago,butbeforethattheyhadmoreprivatesectorwork.Hestated,"Itwasabouttwoyearsagothatwesawthemarketstarttocomeoutoftherecessioninawaythatimpactedus.Ithinktheprivatesectorspendingwaspickingupfasterthan[in]thepublicsector."[#3]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmsaid,“The[hiring]issue…comesfromthelossoftalentandexperience,andknowledgethatwehadasaresultofthe2008[recession].Ithinkit’sfinallycaughtup.”Sheadded,“Ithinkwenowhaveallofthese…peopleintheconstructionsidethatdon’tknowhowtodrawdrawings….So,onbigsetsofdrawings,theyburydetails.Theydon’tdetailthingsproperly….”[PT#3d]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedspecialtyservicesfirmstated,“Therearefewercompanies[inmybusiness]duetotherecession,andeverythingismoredigital.”[#34]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleownerofanarchitecturalengineeringfirmsaidthatthecompanyusedtohave14employeesinsteadoffour,buttheywereforcedtodownsizeduringtherecession.[#16]
Current economic conditions.Mostintervieweesreportedagoodorimprovingeconomyinthemarketplace.[e.g.,#20,#21a,#35,#37,#39]Severaldescribedlocalmarketplaceconditionsas“booming.”Commentsinclude:
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“Marketplaceconditionsaregreat.Therejustseemstobesomanyopportunitiesavailable.Notonlyforacompanylikeoursthatselfperforms,but[for]thosetraditionalconstructioncompanies.Ihaveheardthatitisstrongintheprivatesector[with]residentialbuildingtoo.Wejustdon’tseethingsslowingdownintheconstructionareaatall…anytimesoon.Ibelieve[if]you…haveagoodreputationoutthere[then]youcanfindwork.”[#28]
Whenaskedaboutlocalmarketplaceconditions,thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmstated,“Thereissomuchworkoutthere,[so]Iwould
![Page 458: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/458.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 31
describethemarketplaceconditionsasverygood.Rightnow,ourcompanygoesfromonecontracttoanother,[and]Idon’tbelieveanyother…company[inourfield]isexperiencingdifficultyorlackofwork.”[#27]
Whenaskedaboutthemarketplaceconditions,thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmcommentedthatthereiswork“everywhere”inthelocalmarketplace.Shesaid,“Youcan’treallycomplainthatyou’renotmakingmoney.I’mcomplainingthatwecan’tdopublicsectorwork,butwe’redoinggreat[otherwise].You’dhavetobeamoroninthisindustrytobedoingpoorlyrightnow,butayearfromnow,itcouldbeawholedifferentstory.”[#12]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedgeneralcontractingfirmstated,“Thereisalotofworkoutthere.Notjustgovernment,butprivateworkbecausetheeconomyissogood.”Shecontinued,“Mybusinessmodelisflexible.Idon’tneedjustthebigjobsallofthetime[because]thecompanycandosmall[projects]too.”[#19]
Regardingcurrentmarketplaceconditions,theBlackAmericanveteranmaleownerofageneralcontractingcompanysaid,“Thereissomuchworkouttherenow[thatit’s]besttotakefulladvantageofit.Ihopeitdoesn’tslowdownanytimesoon.”[#29]
Regardingoverallmarketplaceconditions,theHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthatduetoalargenumberofongoingprojectsinthelocalmarketplace,hefeelsthereisalotofcompetitionthatexistsbetweencompaniesandcontractors.Headded,“Therearealotofnew,emergingbusinesses,andwe'reseeingthat.Thatiswhyweputalotoffocusonrelationship‐buildingandtrainingtomakesurethatfolksarepreparedtodotheworkwhentheygetthework.”[#11]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthatmarketplaceconditionshavebeensteadilyimprovingoverthepastseveralyears,especiallyintheprivatesector.Hestated,“ConstructionintheDenverareahasstayedatasteadyrateofgrowth,andprivateownersprimarilyworkforthesebigcommercialbuildings….Andthere’salotofflexibilityoverwhomyoucanselect.Youmightknowalotof…companies,butyou’relike,‘Theyarebusyrightnow.Theseotherguysarenot.Theyhavegottheirall‐starsuperintendentavailable.Iwantthemonmyjob….’”[#40]
Whenaskedtodescribecurrentmarketplaceconditions,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmstated,“Ibelievethemarketplaceconditionsareverygood.Companiesarelookingtoincreasetheirtechnologyallthetime,[and]increasingtechnologyincludesaddingnewequipmentandsystems.”Hewentontosay,“Idon’tknowhowothercompaniesinthisindustryaredoing,[butit’s]agoodtimeforus.”[#32a]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmindicatedthatcurrentmarketplaceconditionsaregood.HestatedthatthereiscurrentlyalotofworkintheDenvermetroareainboththeprivatesectorandpublicsector.Henotedthatthefirmisverybusy.[#23a]
![Page 459: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/459.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 32
Thesamebusinessrepresentativelatersaid,“We’reinanextremelyhotspot.PartsofCaliforniaareprettytoughforustoday.OntheEastCoastthereisnotmuchyoucandowhenyou’reasbuiltoutastheyare.Seattle,SanFrancisco,Denver,Dallas,[and]Austinareprettyhottoday.”[#23a]
Whenaskedaboutcurrentmarketplaceconditions,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaconstructionservicesfirmstated,“Thingsareverygoodrightnow.Idon’tknowanysmallcompanythatis[struggling]togetjobs.Havingagoodreputationgoesalongway.Iknowit’sbusyonthepublicsidetoo[because]Iseealltheconstructioncranesaroundtown.”[#31]
WhenaskedaboutcurrentmarketplaceconditionsinColorado,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofagoodsandservicesfirmstated,“Wedowhatwecantoworkwithlocalbusinesseswheneverandhoweverpossible….Iwouldsayfromwhatwe’reseeing,therearealotoflocalbusinessescomingtousforourmanufacturingservices.”[#10]
Themalerepresentativeofanon‐Hispanicwhitemale‐ownedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthatcurrently“thereisahigherlevelofpublicsectorworkthan[we]wouldnormallysee”becauseoftheirfirm’scontinuedinvolvementwithairportprojects.Headded,“Theairporthasamassiveimpactontheentiremarketbecausethesearemonstrousprojects…[andthe]privatesectorisbooming….”[#1a]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleownerofaspecialtycontractingfirmstated,"Ithinkourlocalmarketplaceisatanall‐timehighinwork….Therearealotofpeoplehere,andthatgenerallydrivesourserviceindustryreallywell….Themarket'sbetterthanI'veeverseenit."[#4]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedspecialtyservicesfirmstatedthatmarketplaceconditionsinthelocalareaareexcellentinallsectors.[#34]
Whenaskedaboutlocalmarketplaceconditions,theHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmsaidtheyaregood.Shenoted,“ThebondprogramthatgotapprovedbyvotersinNovemberfortheCityandCountyofDenverisexcellent[becauseitwillbenefitnewconstructionwork].”[#2]
Thesamebusinessco‐ownercontinued,“Marketplaceconditionsarepositivelyimpactedbytheoverallgrowththatwehaveseenwithinthemetroarea,andbecausemany…oftheothergovernmententitiesareputtingtheirmoneytowardsreconstructingandimprovingroads.[This]haspositivelyimpactedthemarketplaceconditions.”[#2]
Whenaskedaboutcurrentmarketplaceconditions,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaconstructionfirmstated,“ItissobusynowintheDenverarea.Ifyouwanttowork,youcanfindit.”Healsonotedthebenefitofhavingagoodreputation,andsaid,“[If]acompanyhas…agoodreputationoutthere…theworkwillcome.”[#24]
Apublicmeetingparticipantindicatedthatcurrentmarketplaceconditionsaregood.Shecommented,“Thewomen’smovementhasjustbeenonfiretheselastcoupleofyears,and
![Page 460: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/460.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 33
womenhavebeenenteringintobusinessownershiporentrepreneurshipataveryhighrate.”[PT#4]
TheSubcontinentAsianAmericanmaleownerofaspecialtycontractingfirmindicatedthatmarketplaceconditionsinhisindustryaregood.Hestatedthatheisnotinterestedingrowingthecompanyanylargeratthistime,andaddedthathehasenoughbusinessnowasitis.Hewentontocommentthathedoesnotwanttogrowhiscompanylargerbecausethequalityofhisworkmaysuffer.[#18]
Whenaskedaboutlocalmarketplaceconditions,theHispanicAmericanmaleownerofanarchitecturalengineeringfirmstated,“Therealwaysseemstobeworkavailable.”Hereiteratedthattheyhadtodownsizeaftertherecession,butnotedthattheywereabletosurviveonsmallprojects.[#16]
Some interviewees and survey respondents reported that while economic conditions are good,
a lack of qualified labor presents challenges.[e.g.,AS#49]Forexample:
Whenaskedtodescribelocalmarketplaceconditions,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmstated,“Theconditionsarerobust,[but]it’shardtogetpeopletobid.Youcan’tfindsubsandsubscan’tfindworkers.Thepublicsectoris25percentmoreactivethantheprivatesector.”[#22]
Asurveyrespondentsaidthereis“oversaturationinColorado,”andadded,“Laborforceisthehardestissue.”[AS#23]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaid,“There’salotofworkgoingonjustinDenveralone.There’salotofworkoutthere,andthatcompetesagainstalltheotherworkthatisintheprivatesector….Allwehaveto[dois]lookaround,andweseebuildingsand…multi‐familydevelopmentgoingup.That’sacompetitioninaway,fortalent.That’sthebiggestconcernthatalotofpeoplehave,is[whether]there[is]enoughtalenttodoalloftheseprojects.It’stight,[and]it’sveryhardtofindpeople.”[#38]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaid,“Thebiggestthing[firms]aresayingisthatthecityisabouttodoa[tremendous]amountofworkandthere’snotenoughqualityminority‐certifiedfirmstodeliver15,20,25,or30percentofthecity’sbuildingsthatthey’rebuildinginthenextfiveyears.There’sjustnotenough.Andwedesperatelywouldlikethecitytoactuallydoanassessment….”[#40]
Thesametradeassociationrepresentativecontinued,“Butifthat’sonly12percentandnot30percent…we’regoingtostartrunningintoproblemswhenweforceahighernumberthantheminorityfirmcapacitycanhandle,whilewegothroughthislarge,largebubble.Andthishappenedwhen[DenverInternationalAirport]wasbuiltin1995….Wehave[some]ofourmembersonthe[CityandCountyofDenver’s]goalcommittee.But…it’sscaryforusto…raiseourhandandsay,‘Maybeyououghttoreevaluatethegoal,’becauseitcanlooklikewe’reanti‐minorityandthat’sthefurthestfromthecase.[So],ournaturalinclinationistojustsitbackandsay,‘Well,weseethisproblemcomingbutwe’renotsurewhattodoaboutit.’”[#40]
![Page 461: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/461.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 34
Helatersaid,“Probablythebiggestissueoutthereistheworkforceitself,andthefactthatwe’vegonefrom104,000to172,000[employees].Weshouldprobablybeataroundsome180,000to185,000employeesbasedontheamountofconstructioninthemarket.”[#40]
Asurveyrespondentreported,“Thebiggestchallengetodayisstaffing.There'snotrainedworkforcereadilyavailabletohire.”[AS#14]
One business owner said that while marketplace conditions are good, his firm struggles to stay
competitive as a small business.Whenaskedaboutlocalmarketplaceconditions,theBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionsupplyfirmsaidthathissegmentoftheindustryislesssupportiveofsmallbusinessesasitwaswhenhestartedthefirm.However,headded,“Themarketisgreat,[but]everybody[is]busybutme….Youdon’tseealotofnewfolkstryingtogetintothisbusiness.It’smostlymultigenerationalbusinesses,andtheyarebeingboughtoutbybiggercompanies….Myvolumeistothepointwheremypricingisstillnotwhereitshouldbetocompeteonavolumebasis.Thebigguysarebuyingbytherailcar….”[#36]
Some business assistance organization representatives commented on current marketplace
conditions and its effect on members.Forexample:
Whenaskedabouttheoverallconditionsinthemarketplace,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaidthatmanymembersarestrugglingwithemployeerecruitmentandretainage.Hesaid,“Withthelowunemployment,mymemberstellmetheyhavetroublefindingandretainingemployees.Wehaveaveryhealthylocaleconomy,[and]ourexportsaregreat.Ouroveralltradeeconomiesaregood.Thatdoestrickledowntoourmembers,butthesmallestonesarestruggling.”[#33]
Whenaskedtodescribetheoverallmarketconditionsformembers,theNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaid,“WehaveseenalotofgrowthintheDenvermetroarea,andeverybodywantstogetinontheaction.[However],thebigstruggleisfindingemployees,sothatislimitingtheopportunities…theyareeventurningdownwork.Andtryingtoattractworkforcefromanotherareadoesn’tworkbecausehousingistooexpensive.”[#37]
Some interviewees indicated that current economic and marketplace conditions are poor, or
slowing down.Oneintervieweeindicatedthatpoormarketplaceconditionsareduetofewprimecontractorswillingtoengagesmall,minoritybusinesses.Commentsinclude:
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaconstruction‐relatedfirmreportedthat“theeconomyisstartingtoslowdown.”Headdedthattheprojectstheybidonare“muchsmaller”thanthosefromafewyearsago.[#25]
Thesamebusinessownerlaternotedthathiscompanyonlyworksintheprivatesector,sohecanonlyspeakinregardstothat.Hesaid,“Therearealotofapartmentsandcommercialbuildingprojectsgoingon,[and]wehavebeenverysuccessfulinthatarea.EventhoughI
![Page 462: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/462.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 35
thinkthingsareslowingdown,theprivateworkcankeepyouverybusy.”Headded,“Youjusthavetogetoutthereandsellyourselfandwhatyourcompanycando.”[#25]
Regardingthecurrenteconomicconditions,thefemaleownerofasmallbusinessindicatedthatchallengesexistforsmallbusinessownersintheDenvermarketplace.[PT#2b]
Regardingmarketplaceconditionsinhisindustry,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaspecialtyservicesfirmsaid,“Unfortunately,thenumberofordersandthesizeofcontractshavesloweddownconsiderably.Technologyadvanceshavegivencompaniesanopportunitytodotheirown[work]in‐house.Iftheneedsofacustomeraresmallenough,andnotaverylargejob,theyfinditmoreeconomicaltodoitthemselves.”[#30]
A trade association representative indicated that conditions in the local marketplace can be a
barrier for some members.Whenaskedaboutlocalmarketplaceconditions,theBlackAmericanfemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationcommented,“Nodoubt,theyaretight.”Shecontinued,“It’sveryinterestingtoseeandhearfromsmallbusinessesthattheyhaveachoiceofwhichprojectstheywanttoparticipateon.Iheardthatsomeprimeswererequestingcertaincriteria,whetherbondingorwhathaveyou,andthesubelectedoutofparticipatingontheprojectandwenttoadifferentproject….[This]issomethingyoudon’thearofoften,orseeoften.”[#6]
Thesametradeassociationrepresentativesaidthatthereis“minimumparticipation”ofprimecontractors,asthey“electnottoparticipateinthespacewhereownerentitiesarerequiringgoalsforminorityparticipation.”Sheadded,“They’drathernotdealwiththat.Somefinditlabor‐intensiveintheamountofdocumentation,andjustthesteps[needed]toengagesmall,minoritybusinesses.”[#6]
Shewentontosay,“I’vebeentoacoupleofhiringfairswhereIwalkedaroundasifIwerelookingforajob,andinquiredwithdifferentfolks,[asking],‘DoyouparticipateinprojectsthatrequireDBEs[or]MWBEs?’Andtheywouldsay,‘Oh,no.That’stoomuchwork.’”Shecontinued,“They’llletyouknowrightupfront.Theythinkit’stoomuchwork,orthey’vehadtrouble,ortheysaythere’stoomuchworkoutforthemtodowhattheyneedtoinordertogothatrouteandpursuethosekindsofcontracts.”[#6]
Many interviewees discussed whether local marketplace conditions have changed in recent
years.Mostindicatedthatconditionshavechangedsignificantly.Forexample:
Regardingchangesinmarketplaceconditions,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“In10yearswe’vegonefromarecessiontothisincredibleexpansion.Ithoughtthingsweregoingtotankfouryearsago,butitjustkeepsgoing.”[#22]
TheBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionsupplyfirmsaid,“Thebigguysaregettingbiggerandthesmallguysaregettingsmaller.[Alargefirm]justgotbought,andtheywerehuge…everyone’sbuyingeachotherup.Irememberwhentheybrokeup[afirm]andalltheopportunitiesthatcreated,[and]nowwe’rebacktowhereitstarted.”[#36]
![Page 463: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/463.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 36
Whenaskedifandhowmarketplaceconditionshavechanged,thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringfirmsaidthatthe“booming”economyofDenverhasmadeallthedifferenceforherfirm.Shewentontosay,“Theyestimatethat$10billionisgoingtocomeinoverthenext10years.Usuallyonlythefirstfractionofthatworkisindesign,whiletherestisconstruction,maintenance,andoperation.”[#5]
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“Inotherwords,this$10billionworthofworkisprobablygoingtobetwoyears’worthofworkinthedesignfield,soI’malreadylookingaheadandtryingtopositionmyselftogetfederalworksothatwhenthesecityprojectswanedown,I’llbestartingtobringinfederalworkaroundthecountrythatwillhelp[to]keepuswhereIdon’thavetolayanybodyoff.”[#5]
Whenaskedifmarketplaceconditionshavechangedinrecentyears,theBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthattheprivatesectorhasbecomemoresaturatedinthelastyearandahalf.Headded,“It’sreallyhappenedalongsidethegrowthofColorado.Lotsofcompaniesarecominginfromoutofstate.Yourunintothemandtheysay[they’re]fromTexas[or]Kansas.”Hewentontosay,“They’relatetojobsbecausetheydon’tknowhowtogetthere.They[don’t]knowadifferentwaythanthehighwaybecausethey’reallnew.So,it’saninfluxofpeoplethatarecomingin.”[#7]
Whenaskedtodescribecurrentmarketplaceconditionsinthelocalarea,theHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmsaid,“Ialwaystellourguys…thatthere’soneconstantinallthis,andthatis[that]thingsarealwayschanging.So…ifthere’saclientouttherethatyou’vebeentryingtoget[workwith],justbepatientenoughandyou’llgetin….He’seithergonnabegone,orsomebodyelseisgonnabeinhisplace[togivebusiness].”[#14]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaconstruction‐relatedfirmsaid,“Ithinkourfirmcompares[to]otherlocalengineeringcompanies,butIbelievetheeconomyisstartingtoslowdown.Webidonsomeprojectsandwinthem,butthesizeofthoseprojectsismuchsmallerthanafewyearsago,andgetting[even]smaller.”[#25]
Whenaskedifmarketplaceconditionshavechangedinrecentyears,theHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofanSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaidthat“bigfirms”haverecentlybeenacquiringsmallerfirms,leadingtoarchitecturalfirmsgettingbigger,onaverage.[#15a]
Thesamebusinessco‐ownerwentontocomment,“[In]alltheyearswehavebeeninbusiness,even[during]theworstdownturn,weneverlaidanybodyoffbecausetherewasn’tmoneyforthesalaries.Wediddecreaseeveryoneto90percentoftheirsalary,butitwasadecisionmadebythegroup.Inabigfirm,you’dneverhavetheopportunitytohelpmakethatdecision.”[#15a]
Whenaskedaboutanychangesinmarketplaceconditions,thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmsaid,“Thereisan
![Page 464: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/464.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 37
enormousamountofworkalongtheFrontRange,butithasalsobroughtinalotofout‐of‐statecontractorswhoarenowvyingforbusinesswithlocalcompanies,especiallysmallbusinesses.”[#20]
Regardingpastandcurrentmarketplaceconditions,theBlackAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmstated,“I’veseenrecession,depression,nowork,toomuchwork,[and]youknow,theboomrightnow.So,I’veseenallofit.”[#13]
Themalerepresentativeofanon‐Hispanicwhitemale‐ownedprofessionalservicesfirmsaidthatmarketplaceconditionshavebeenprettystableandthatthenatureoftheworkhasremainedaboutthesame.However,henoted,“Itebbsandflowsthroughtheyears,dependingontheeconomics.”[#1a]
TheSubcontinentAsianAmericanmaleownerofaspecialtycontractingfirmsaidthatconditionshavenotchangedmuchsincehestartedhisbusinessalmost10yearsago.HewentontonotethattherehasalwaysbeensteadyworkinDenver.[#18]
Whenaskedwhatchangeshehasseeninmarketplaceconditions,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmstated,“Otherthanthespeedofbusiness,there’snotmuchIcanthinkof.Thingshappenalotfasterthantheyusedto,[and]technologydrivesthat.Expectationshavemovedupquiteabit[becauseof]culture.Peoplewantthingstoday.”[#23a]
TheNativeAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,SDB‐,SDVOSB‐,andHUBZone‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmreportedthathehasnotnoticedanychangesinmarketplaceconditions.[#39]
A few trade association and business assistance organization representatives discussed
changes in local marketplace conditions.Commentsinclude:
Whenaskedifshehasnoticedanyrecentchangesinmarketplaceconditions,theNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaid,“Inthelast18months,theissueofnotenoughemployeesandpeopleturningdowncontracts[hasincreased].”[#37]
Whenaskedaboutanyrecentchangesinmarketplaceconditions,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationnotedthatheseesmoreandmorepublicopportunitiesandisseekingwaystogetmoremembersinvolved.However,hecommented,“Togetintoa[DenverInternationalAirport]concourseitisatleasta$2millionbuild,thenyouroverheadandeverythingelse[ontopofthat].Thathurdleisprohibitiveformany,manyfolks.”[#33]
Whenaskedaboutchangesinmarketplaceconditions,theHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthathehasseengrowthamongsomeoftheminority‐andwomen‐ownedbusinessesthatcomprisetheorganization’smembership.Heexplained,“Ihaveseensomegrowthintheirbusinesses,whichhasbeenwonderfultosee
![Page 465: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/465.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 38
happen,tothepointwheretheycanbeprimes.Maybenotontheverylargestprojects,buttheyareprimesandtheyarecompetingoutofthatmarketplace.”[#11]
Thesametradeassociationrepresentativecontinued,“Iseeexpansionofbusinesses.Iseefolkswhocaremore.I'malsoseeing,ontheprimes'side,morerespecttowardsthecertificationprocessandtheneedforgoalsettingandtheirwillingnesstoparticipateinthoseprograms.Notjustbecauseitisarequirement,butbecausetheyalsoaretryingtobuildmorecapacityinourcommunity,andthewaytodothatiswithoursmallbusinessesandcertifiedfirms.”[#11]
Some business owners and representatives discussed whether marketplace conditions differ
between the public sector and private sector.Commentsinclude:
Regardinglocalmarketplaceconditions,theHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaid,“Intheprivatesectorthereisalotofopportunity,buttherearemoresmallcompaniesdoing[herlineofwork].Inthepublicsectorthereisalsoalotofwork,butnotasmuchcompetitionfor[herlineofwork]becauseitrequirescertification.”Sheadded,“Theyareaboutthesame.Rightnow[CityandCountyofDenver]isgettingalotofwork[with]themuseum,theconventioncenter,andtheairport.”[#35]
Whenaskedifmarketplaceconditionsdifferinthepublicsectorversustheprivatesector,thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringfirmindicatedthatconditionsarebetterinthepublicsectorduetoDBE/MWBEcontractgoals.Shesaid,“PublicprimesarebecomingawareofandcomplyingwithMWBEandDBErequirements.Privatesector[primes]havenosuchrequirements,andworkwiththeir‘good[ol’]boy’partnerswhomthey’veworkedwithforthepast25years….Ihavenochanceofwinningthatwork.”[#5]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmsaidthatmarketplaceconditionsdifferineachsector.Heexplained,“Intheprivatesector,thelocalmarketplaceissaturatedwithcompaniesthatdowhatIdo.It’sverycompetitiveandit’sallaboutrelationshipsthatyoubuildasfarasreferrals.Inthepublicsector,Idon’tfeelit’sthatcompetitiveatall.Ithinkit’sjustgiventoacertaingroupofcompanies,and[ifthat]groupofcompanies…can’tdothework,theysubitout.”[#7]
Whenaskedifmarketplaceconditionsdifferineachsector,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthattheydo.Heexplained,“Thereismorescrutinyinthepublicsector.Intheprivatesectortheyjustslapsomethingtogether.Thereisprobablya25percentsurchargeforpublicworkbecauseofallthepaperwork,butbecauseofthatthereislessrisk.”[#22]
Whenaskedifmarketplaceconditionsdifferbetweensectors,theNativeAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,SDB‐,SDVOSB‐,andHUBZone‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmindicatedthattheydonot.Hesaid,“Ithinktheeconomyissuchthatpeople,whetheryouareprivateorpublic…arestilllookingatvalue.Youstillhavetobecompetitive.Theyhavetohaveacomfortlevel.It’sthesamewhetherit’spublicorprivate.”[#39]
![Page 466: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/466.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 39
Whenaskedifcurrentmarketplaceconditionsdifferbetweensectors,thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemaleco‐ownerofaspecialtyservicesfirmreportedthatasfarasshecantell,theydonot.Shewentontosaythatanyrecentchangesinmarketplaceconditionshavenotbeennoticeable.[#8]
Whenaskedifmarketplaceconditionsarethesameinbothsectors,theBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andESB‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmreportedthattheyare.Headded,“Ithinkwithalltheprojectsthatwehavegoingonrightnow…[with]whatDenver’stryingtodowithmobility,Ithinkitisgreat.”[#9]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmsaidthatmarketplaceconditionsintheDenverareadonotdifferbetweensectors.Hecommentedthatbothsectorsare“booming.”[#23a]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmreportedthatmarketplaceconditionsareexcellentinbothsectors.However,hecommented,“Itseemswheneveryouhaveaboom,morecontractorsmovein,whichgenerateslowermargins.”[#21a]
One trade association representative noted that marketplace conditions do differ between
sectors.TheHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationexplained,“Inthepublicsectoryouhavegoalsthattheentityistryingtoachieve,sothereforetheprimesaremorededicatedintryingtoachievethosegoalsandbringingoncertifiedfirms.However,Iamseeingmoreactivitywiththeprimesintheprivatesectorastheytakealongsomeofthecertifiedprogramswiththemonthose[privatesector]jobsaswell.”[#11]
Business owners’ experiences pursuing public and private sector work.Intervieweesdiscussedtheirexperienceswiththepursuitofpublicandprivatesectorwork.Somediscussedthedifferencesbetweenpublicandprivatesectorwork.Forexample:
TheBlackAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmnotedthatitiseasiertoperformpublicsectorworkbecauseofherfamiliaritywithitandtherelationshipsthatshehasforged.Sheadded,“It’sadifferentapproachtoprivateworkinhowyoubid,whichbecomesmoreaboutcoststhanrelationships.”[#13]
Whenaskedaboutthedifferencesbetweenworkinginthepublicsectorversustheprivatesector,thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthatshepreferspublicsectorwork.Sheexplained,“Intheprivatesector,therearetwospacesyoucanworkin.Oneistheresidentialspace,[which]we’resuperfamiliarwith….Butalotofprivatesectorworkinvolvesdevelopers,anddevelopersaretheclientswedon’treallywanttoworkforandwhobasicallytendtobe[difficulttoworkwith].They’reveryaggressive,verypricedriven,[and]verydeadlinedriven.”[#12]
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“Mostofthetimewhenwe’veworkedforgovernmententities,the[publicrepresentatives]haveatleastknownwhatthey’redoing.Theyunderstandthey’regoingtobuildasculpturepark.”Shenotedhoweverthatit’seasierto
![Page 467: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/467.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 40
secureprivatesectorworkbecausethepublicsectorisdependentuponpastperformanceonsimilarprojects.[#12]
Whenaskedhowhegoesaboutsecuringworkandifitdiffersbetweensectors,theNativeAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,SDB‐,SDVOSB‐,andHUBZone‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmsaid,“Youmustidentifythedepartmentandpersonthathandlesyourcommodityandservices,andthenworkthroughthemazetoreachouttothem.”Heexplainedthattopenetratethe“maze,”hegenerallyreachesouttospecializeddepartmentstohelpguidehimthroughtheprocess.Henoted,“Westaywithinourdisciplines,sowedon’treachoutanddootherdisciplinesthatwearenotreallysureof.”[#39]
Thesamebusinessowneradded,“Wegoafterprivate,government,andtribe[work].We’vebeeninbusinessfor[almost30]years,so[we]focusongovernmentcontractorsandtribes.”Heexplainedthathedirectshiseffortsinthiswayduetohisfamiliaritywiththemarketplace.[#39]
Regardingdifferencesbetweenpublicsectorandprivatesectorwork,hesaid,“Withthegovernment,youhavetodotthei’sandcrossthet’smore.Couldbemoreregulationsonthegovernmentside.”Hewentontosaythathisexperienceinbothsectorshasbeengood,ashastheprofitabilityineach.Henotedthathedoesnotregardonesectormorefavorablythantheother.[#39]
TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthathisfirmusedtofocusonprivatesectorworkuntil9/11,when“alotofcontracts…juststopped.”Hesaid,“Allthedevelopersjustwalkedawayfromprojectsandleftarchitects,engineers,andcontractorsholdingthebag.Idecidedthentofocusonpublicwork,becauseapublicentitywouldneverstartaprojectunlesstheyhadthemoneycomingin.”[#22]
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“Theotherthingaboutpublicclientsisthatyou’reusuallydealingwithprofessionals[like]architects,engineers,[and]contractorsthathavebeentrainedinthosefields,sotheyknowtheprocess.Allprivatedevelopersareconcernedaboutismakingmoneyintheend.Theyareimpatientanddon’thavemuchappreciationfortheprocess.So,wemadetheshiftandIgotcertifiedasan[SBA]8(a)withthefederalgovernment,andwestilldoalotoffederalwork.”[#22]
Helaterreportedthatanadvantagetopublicsectorworkisthatitismore“stable.”However,henoted,“Inaway,thepublicsectorismoredifficultinthatit’saveryrigorousprocess.Onceyoumastertheprocess,itbecomeseasierovertime….So,inthatrespect,thepublicsectoris[fairer.]”Incontrast,hereportedthatprivatesectorworkis“riskierbecauseit’smoredemanding.”Headded,“Plansaremoreincomplete.”[#22]
Thefemalerepresentativeofanon‐Hispanicwhitemale‐ownedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthatpublicsectorprojectshavespecificgoalstomeetand“boxestocheck”thatinformthedynamicsofateamforaproject.Sheexplainedthatincomparison,privatesectorprojectsaremorerelationship‐orientedandbasedonqualificationsratherthanthelogisticsofteamformation.Shenotedthatintheprivatesector,theirfirmismorelikelyto
![Page 468: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/468.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 41
talkaboutwhytheyarethebestfirmratherthanfocusingonpublicrequirementsthatmustbemetforworkinthepublicsector.[#1b]
Whenaskedaboutthedifferencesbetweenpublicsectorandprivatesectorwork,theBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andESB‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmsaid,“Intheprivatesector,someoftheprojectsare[basedon]bid,butsomearerelational.Someonemaylikewhatwe’redoingandaskforapriceonit.Theymaygetthreebidsandthensaywewonthebid.”Hesaidthatthisisincontrasttopublicsectorwork,wherealloftheworkisbidout.[#9]
Thesamebusinessownerlatersaidthattheprocessofgettingworkismoredifficultinthepublicsector,largelyduetothe“backandforth”natureofsecuringaproject.Hesaid,“Ontheprivateside,youmayhaveanentitythat’sgoingtodoaproject….There’sanownerthere[and]youhaveanopportunitytogetwiththeownertogetinvolvedwiththeproject.Thenthere’sacontractor,[and]youhaveanotheropportunity.”[#9]
Hecontinued,“[However],onthepublicsideyouendupwithfourorfiveprimecontractors.Yougothroughthewholeprocess,butwhenyougettothecontractorpartyouhave…fiveprimeswhoarebiddingonthesameproject,andfourofthosefivearen’tgonnagetit.Ifyouweresmartandhadtheresources,youwouldprovidepricingtoallofthem.”[#9]
Themalerepresentativeofanon‐Hispanicwhitemale‐ownedprofessionalservicesfirmreported,“Ithinkthattheprivatesectorismuchmorebasedonpurequalificationsandyourabilitytoshowthatyoucanmeettheirschedule,budget,andthelead’sexpectations.”[#1a]
Thesamebusinessrepresentativestatedthatobtainingworkintheprivatesectorisbasedonafirm’squalifications,butsometimestheworkismoredollar‐driventhanpublicsectorwork.[#1a]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemaleco‐ownerofaspecialtyservicesfirmsaidthatit’smoredifficulttogetworkinthepublicsectorthantheprivatesector.Sheexplained,“Comingfromafinancebackground,Ibelievethatonceacompanyorpublicsectorpersongetsmarriedto[aparticularcompany],ittakesquiteabittogetthemtodecidetogowithsomebodyelse.Forinstance,theycanhavecomplaintsforyears,butitmaybetoomuchofanefforttochangevendors.”[#8]
Thesamebusinessco‐owneraddedthatdoingworkinthepublicsectoriseasierthanintheprivatesector.Sheindicatedthatpublicsectorworktendstobelesscomplicatedthanprivatesectorwork,andsaid,“WhenweworkedwiththeCityofLongmont,theyhadtheirdesign,anditwasmyjobto[decide]howwe[would]solve[their]problem.’”[#8]
Whenaskedifit’seasierorhardertoreceivepaymentforpublicsectorwork,shestatedthatit’smucheasier.Sheexplained,“Theyhavepaymentcardswhenthey’reordering.Theyputdowntheirdeposit,andwhentheycometopickituptheypaytheirentirepayment.[In
![Page 469: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/469.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 42
theprivatesector],asinglepersonmayorderfourthingsandsaytheywillpayinaweekandahalfwhentheycangetuphere.”[#8]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,"Ourprivatesectorworkseemstofocusalotaroundcontractorswhileourpublicsectorclientsseemtovalueengineeringmorethanaprivatesectorclient…."Headdedthatattimespublicsectorclientswilltakealowcontractbidwithoutconsideringthatsomeonewithmoreexpertiseandahigherpricemayprovideabetterproduct.Hewentontosaythattherearenotsignificantdifferencesbetweenpublicandprivatesectorwork.[#3]
Whenaskedaboutthedifferencesbetweenpublicsectorandprivatesectorwork,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmstated,“Therereallyisn’tthatmuchdifferenceworkingintheprivateorpublicsectors.Youworkonthebid,reviewtomakesureyou’veincludedeverything,andsubmit.Wearestartingtogetrecognizedasaqualitycompany,andthatreputationgoesalongway.”[#32a]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleownerofaspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthatthebiddingprocessintheprivate‐andpublic‐sectorsareessentiallythesame.Headdedthatwagesarethemostnoticeabledifferencebetweenthetwosectors,explainingthat"InthepublicsectorwepayDavis‐Baconwages.Intheprivatesector,itvaries."[#4]
Thesamebusinessowneralsonoted,"Ithinkbothsectorshavetheirtrade‐offs.Ithinkasfaras[workingwith]management,it'seasierinthepublicsector.Butasfarastheamountofpaperwork,it'sharder."[#4]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringfirmsaid,“The[nature]oftheconstructionsectormixofworkhaschanged.EveryoneislookingforMWBEsrightnow,whichhasmadeahugedifference.IftheydoawaywiththisMWBEprogram,alltheseMWBEfirmswillfail.”[#5]
Thesamebusinessownerlatersaid,“Itisnexttoimpossibletogetworkinthepublicsectorbecausepublicworkisthisgiantthingthat[noteveryonecan]break…into[or]sink[their]teethinto….Iinterviewedfor[apublicsectorproject]andIsaidwecanhandleprojectsof$500,000.AndtheguysatthereandlookedatmelikeIwasoutofmymind,andhesaidtheycouldn’tbreakitupintosomethingthatsmall.”[#5]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedgeneralcontractingfirmsaidthatshedoesnotseesubstantialdifferenceswhenworkinginthepublicsectorversustheprivatesector.Sheexplained,“Mycompanyhasbeenveryfortunateingettingworkinbothsectors.[Our]positivereputationisoutthere….Thetypeofworkthecompanydoesisbasicallythesame[acrosssectors].Theworkdependsonwhattheownerwants.”[#19]
Thesamebusinessownerwentontosaythatthepaymentstructureisdifferentbetweensectorsandthatdifferentmaterialisused.Shesaid,“Adjustmentsaremadebasedonthe
![Page 470: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/470.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 43
customer.Wehaveamixofcustomersandsizesofcontracts.Wecouldn’tjustdosmalljobsandsucceed.”[#19]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“Idon’tthinkthereareconsiderabledifferencesinworkingeitherpublicorprivate.Thereisalwayssomeonecomingouttoinspectyourwork,andtherearedeadlines.Themunicipalitieswehavebeenworkingwithpayonatimelybasissolongasthepaperworkissubmittedcorrectlyandtimely.”[#28]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmsaidthatthereisnodifferenceasasupplierinattemptingtodoworkinonesectorcomparedtotheother.Hecommented,“Aconstructionprojectisaconstructionproject.”[#23a]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmsaidthatworkineachsectorissimilarandcommentedthatthefirmissuccessfulinbothsectors.Hewentontosaythatoneminordifferenceisthatthereisgenerallymorepaperworkinvolvedinthepublicsector.[#21a]
Thesamebusinessrepresentativeadded,“Boththeprivatesectorandpublicsector[havetheir]ownchallenges,butthepublicsectorismorerigidintermsofpoliciesandprocedures.However,theprivatesectorworkcanalsohaverigidpoliciesandprocedures,dependingontheclient.”[#21a]
Whenaskedifthereareanysubstantialdifferencesbetweenworkinginthepublicsectorversustheprivatesector,theBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionsupplyfirmsaidthattherearenosuchdifferencesinhislineofwork.Heexplained,“Itallcomesbacktogettingtheorder,executingitandmakingsureyourcustomerissatisfied.”[#36]
Whenaskedifthereareanydifferenceswhenworkinginthepublicsectorversustheprivatesector,theHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaidthatbasedonherexperiencewithonepublicsectorjob,shedoesnotseeany.Sheexplained,“[I]getaschedule,seehowmanypeopleIneed,makesuretheworkisgood,andthengetpaid.”[#35]
Whenaskedifherprocessofgettingworkdiffersbetweensectors,thesamebusinessownersaid,“Inthepublicsector,itishardertogettoknowtherightpeopleforthebigcontractor.Someofmycompetitorshavepeoplewhodotheestimatingandtheycangiveabetterprice.Idoallofmy[own]estimating.Intheprivatesector,itismoreaboutwhoknowsme.”Sheaddedthatitiseasiertogetworkintheprivatesectorbecauseshehasbeenworkingtherelonger.[#35]
Shelateradded,“Doingtheworkisstressfulinbothsectors….Ithinkthat’sbecausethereismorecompetitionforthisworkintheprivatesector.Alotofcompanieswon’tgetcertified.”[#35]
![Page 471: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/471.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 44
Many interviewees indicated that their firms conduct both public sector and private sector
work.[e.g.,#13,#15a,#16,#28,#30]Forexample:
TheBlackAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaidthat“probably90[percent]”ofherworkisinthepublicsector.Shesaidhergoalistoachieve20percentprivatesectorworkby2019.Whenaskedwhyshe’sstrivingformoreprivatesectorwork,shesaidshehastodiversifyherportfoliobecausemanypublicsectoropportunitiesinwhichshepreviouslysupplementedherbusinesshavebeenmovedordelayed.[#13]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringfirmsaid,“Inthefirsteightyearsofmybusiness,90percentofitwasprivatesector.Inthelasttwoyears,80percentispublic.”Shewentontosaythatthisratioconstantlychangesbecauseofthesizeofherbusiness.Sheexplained,“Becausewearesosmall,whenIgetabigcontractitdominates.Askmeinsixmonthswhatproportionofourworkispublicsectorversusprivate,andit[may]betheotherwayaround.”[#5]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmreportedthathisfirmworksmainlyinthepublicsector.Hesaidthatduetoalargeamountofavailablepublicsectorwork,roughly80percentofhisfirm’sworkcurrentlycomesfromthepublicsector.[#14]
Whenaskedifthisamountofpublicsectorworkvariesyearly,thesamebusinessownercommented,“It’salwaysajugglingact.”Hesaidthatitalldependsonpublicsectoragencies’fundstosupportpublicprojects.Hewentontosaythatitisimportanttohaveabalanceofpublicandprivatesectorworkbecausetherearealways“upsanddowns”regardingthehealthofbothsectors.[#14]
Whenaskedwhatproportionofhisworkcomesfromeachsector,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmstatedthat60percentcomesfrompublicsectorand40percentfromtheprivatesector.Hesaidtherehasbeenatrendtowardspublicworkthatisdrivenbytheeconomy.[#22]
Whenaskedifthismixofworkvariesyear‐to‐year,thesamebusinessownerreportedthatitdoes.Heexplained,“Itdependsontheeconomy.Inarecessionyouwillsurviveonpublicsectorwork.[And]actually,wedobetterinarecession.Duringthegoodtimes,thebigfirmsdoalotofprivatework[like]thecasinos[and]hotels.Whentheeconomygoessouth,theyjumpbackintothepublicsectorandittakesthemawhiletogettraction.Meanwhilewe’retherehummingalongdoingpublicwork.”[#22]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmreportedthatcurrentlythefirmperformsmostlyinthepublicsector.However,henotedthatthisisbecauseofalargeDenverInternationalAirportcontract,andcommentedthattheyusuallyperformmoreprivatesectorwork.[#21a]
Thefemalerepresentativeofanon‐Hispanicwhitemale‐ownedprofessionalservicesfirmnotedthatpublicsectorworkrepresentsapproximately40percentoftheirprojects,with
![Page 472: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/472.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 45
aviationworkrepresentingabout35percentofthatpercentage.Meanwhile,shesaidprivatesectorworkrepresentsabout60percentoftheirprojects.[#1b]
Whenaskedwhatproportionofhisfirm’sworkcomesfromthepublicsectorversustheprivatesector,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmstated,“Ibelieveourprojectworkisclosetobeing50percentpublicand50percentprivate.Wehaveanongoingtwo‐year[publicsector]contract…todo…desktopsupport.Thathappenedasaresultofacontractwewontoinstall5,000feetofcablefor[thesameclient].Theylikethewaywework[and]wehavenevermissedadeadline.Iwouldreallyliketogetafewmoreofthoseongoingservicecontracts,andwecontinuetobidonthem.Webidinthepublicandprivatesector.”[#32a]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedgeneralcontractingfirmreportedthatherfirmperformsinbothsectors.Shesaid,“Therearesomanyprojectsgoingonnow[and]thereisconsiderablepublicworkoutthere.However,Idon’tshyawayfromaparkinglotjob.”Shecontinued,“Thecompanybusinesscycledoesn’tvaryyeartoyear,itvariesbyseason.Oursmallerjobsareusuallyinthewintermonths.”[#19]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaprofessionalservicesfirmexplainedthattheirprojectsdonotdiffermuchbetweenpublicsectorandprivatesectorwork.Headded,"Basicallyweliketoenvisionourselvesasanextensionoftheclient'sstaff,whetherthatbeapublicsectororaprivatesectorclient.Mostofourworkisinthepublicsectorhowever."[#3]
Thesamefirmowneralsonotedthattheirproportionsofpublicandprivatesectorworkvaryeachyearbasedonwhatpublicprojectsarehappeningatthetime.Heexplained,"Itiseasierforustogetworkinthepublicsectorbecausewearespecialized."[#3]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleownerofaspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthathisfirmdoesabout40percentoftheirworkinthepublicsectorand60percentintheprivatesector.Healsonotedthatthemixofpublicandprivatesectorworkhasbeenrelativelyconsistentovertheyears.[#4]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andESB‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmreportedthatabout70percentofhisfirm’sworkcomesfromtheprivatesector.Whenaskediftherehasbeenatrendtowardsorawayfromprivatesectorwork,hesaidthatithasremainedthesameforawhile.[#9]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthat80to85percentofherfirm’sworkisintheprivatesectorwhile15to20percentisinthepublicsector.Shereportedthatthismixhasbeensteadyyear‐to‐year,andcommentedthattheyaretryingtoincreasetheirpublicsectorwork.[#12]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthat90percentofhisfirm’sworkcomesfromtheprivatesector.Hesaidthathisfirmhastrendedawayfrompublicsectorworkduetothedifficultytheyhavetryingtogeton
![Page 473: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/473.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 46
vendorlistsasaprime.Headded,“Forschoolboards…cities[and]municipalities,theprocessisjustdaunting….”[#7]
Themalerepresentativeofanon‐Hispanicwhitemale‐ownedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthatpublicsectorprojectsaremorechallengingtoworkonasasubcontractorduetoprimeconsultants’inclinationtohiresmall,minority‐,andwomen‐ownedsubcontractorsfirst.[#1a]
Whenaskedwhatpercentageofthefirm’sworkcomesfromeachsector,thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemaleco‐ownerofaspecialtyservicesfirmreportedthatthemajorityoftheirworkisintheprivatesector.Sheadded,“Iwouldsayprobablylessthaneightpercentcomesfromthepublicsector.”[#8]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmreportedthatherfirmworksalmostexclusivelyintheprivatesector.[#35]
TheBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionsupplyfirmreportedthat99percentofhisworkhasbeenintheprivatesectorsincelosingaRegionalTransportationDistrictcontract.[#36]
Trade association and businesses assistance organization representatives reported a healthy
number of members working in each sector.[e.g.,#6]Forexample:
Whenaskedwhatpercentageofmembers’workcomesfromthepublicsectorversustheprivatesector,theNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationindicatedthatbetween50and90percentofmembers’workisinthepublicsector.”[#37]
Whenaskedifthismixofworkvariesyear‐to‐year,thesamebusinessassistanceorganizationrepresentativesaid,“Thereisalotofpublicworkrightnow.Acoupleofyearsagotherewasaburstofmarijuana‐relatedconstruction,butthathassloweddown.Soyes,itdoesvary.”[#37]
TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationreportedthatwhilemostmembersworkintheprivatesector,onelong‐timememberhasregularcontractswithRegionalTransportationDistrict.[#33]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationreportedthatmembersworkinbothsectors.Sheadded,“Someofthe[smallfirms]thataredoingworkinthepublicsectorarealsodoingworkintheprivatesector.IalwaysencouragetheMWBEs,oranyofthem…todoworkintheprivatesectortoo.You’vegottohaveyourfootinboth[sectors].That[canbe]hardforasmallfirm.”[#38]
TheHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationreportedthatmostmemberfirmsworkinthepublicsector.Headded,“Thepublicsectorhasgoalsontheirprojects,andsothereisarequirementforthebigguystohavesubcontractorsthatarecertified,andsoalotofthemareinthatarena.”[#11]
![Page 474: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/474.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 47
Thesametradeassociationrepresentativeaddedthatsomemembershaveneverworkedforapublicentity,oronlyworkforonepublicentityinsteadofbranchingout.Heexplained,“Forinstance,doingworkattheairportcanbeverydifficultandalotmoreexpensivethandoingaprojectatareccenteror[withDenverPublicSchools].Andso,forthemtodoworkattheairport,Ialwaysremindthem,‘Makesureyouknowallthecostsassociatedbeforeyougooutthereandbidonsomething.’”[#11]
Helatersaidthathebelievestheretobeatrendformoreprivatesectorworkamongmembers.Heexplained,“Ithinkasfolkshavedevelopedrelationshipsandyoudogoodwork,[theprimecontractors]wanttotakeyouontheirwork,whetheritispublicorprivate.[#11]
Some interviewees reported that they prefer public sector work to private sector, or that there
are benefits to public sector work.Forexample:
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaprofessionalservicesfirmstatedthattherearebenefitstoworkinginthepublicsector.Heexplained,"Theprivatesectorcanbemoredemandingschedule‐wise.It'sbeenourexperiencethatsometimestheprivatesectorisnotasorganizedastheyshouldbe,andthatthescheduledemandscanbegreater.Sometimesthoseintheprivatesectordonotknowwhattheyreallywant."[#3]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleownerofaspecialtycontractingfirmstated,“Inthepublicsector,Ibelievetheemployeesseemuchmoregratificationnotonlyinthepaybutalsointheworkenvironment.Ithinktheyfeelmuchmoreappreciated….[Theyseem]alittlemoreexcitedtoworkpubliclythanprivately.Ithinkthere'sasafetystandardthatalsomakesthemfeelmoresecure.”[#4]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmstated,“Mostofourworknowcomesfromthepublicsector.Countiesandmunicipalitiesinthisareaarelookingtoupgrademanystructuresandfacilities.Ibelieve[it’s]becausewehaveaself‐performingbusinessmodel[that]weareaskedtobidonthosejobs.Thefactthatwehavein‐housestafftohandlethebeginningtotheendisanattractiveoptionforthem.”[#28]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmreportedthatforthetypeofworkhiscompanydoes,itiseasiertogetworkinthepublicsector.[#14]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthatpaymentisfasterinthepublicsectorwhichcanleadtomoreprofitability.[#7]
Some trade association representatives indicated that there are advantages to working in the
public sector.Forexample:
Whenaskedifmembersworkmoreofteninthepublicsectororprivatesector,theBlackAmericanfemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationreportedthatmembersmostoftenworkinthepublicsector.Shecommented,“Itisin[thepublicsector]thattheyaregivenan
![Page 475: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/475.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 48
opportunitythroughthegoalsandprogramsthatareinplace.Theycanbuildtheircapacity,theirexpertise,andtheirknowledgebase,andthenfeelmorecomfortabletoexpandintotheprivatesector.We’veseenthathappenalot.We’vealsoseenalotoffolkswhoprefertostayinthepublicspace.”[#6]
TheHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthatpaymentismorereliablewhenworkingwithpublicentities.Hecommented,“Thepaymenttakeslongertogetsometimes,butyouaregoingtogetit.”[#11]
A few business owners reported working exclusively in the public sector.Forexample:
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmsaidalltheirworkisinthepublicsector,mostlyonindustrialprojectssuchasrestorationandnewconstruction.SheaddedthatthisworktakesplaceacrossseveraldifferentcountiesaroundtheDenvermetroarea.[#2]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmstated,“Allofourcompany’sworkcomesfromthepublicsector,specificallyCDOT.”Weworkprimarilyonhighways.ThoseroadsaretheresponsibilityofCDOT.Thatiswhytheyhireus.”[#27]
Thesamebusinessownerwentontosay,“[CDOT]know[s]thequalityofourwork.Theykeepusverybusy.Wedon’thavealotofemployees,[so]sometimesthereareprojectsavailablethatwedon’tgoafterbecauseofthenumberofpeoplewehaveonstaff.Fortunately,wehaveenoughtogetthejobdone[mostofthetime].”[#27]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmreportedthatherfirmworksonlyasasubcontractoronpublicsectorcontractsatDenverInternationalAirport.[#20]
Some interviewees reported that they prefer private sector work to public sector, or that there
are benefits to private sector work.[e.g.,#1b,#10,#15a,#24,#30]Manysaidthatpaymentisconsiderablyfasterintheprivatesector.Forexample:
TheBlackAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmstated,“Theprivatesectoriseasybecausedecisionsarefast,”comparedtothepublicsector.Sheadded,“Youdon’thavetogothroughalotofiterationsofthings.”[#13]
Thesamebusinessownerwentontosay,“EveniftheprivatesectorrequiresanRFI,areplyisgenerallyreceivedwithin48hours.”Shesaidinthepublicsectoritcantake30to45daysforareply,andadded,“Therewasadelayofupto90daysforanRFIreplyfromapublicsectorbusiness.Overtheyears[responsetime]dependsonwhothegeneralcontractororprojectmanageris.”[#13]
Thefemalerepresentativeofanon‐Hispanicwhitemale‐ownedprofessionalservicesfirmnotedthatgettingworkinthepublicsectorismoredifficultbecauseofallofthefactorsinvolvedincontractingoutcertainportionsoftheprojectandachievingcertaingoalsinthe
![Page 476: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/476.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 49
hiringofteammembers.Shementionedthatsometimesherfirmgetspassedoverorhastodelegateoutaportionoftheprojecttoanotherbusinessinordertomeetmandatedrequirements.[#1b]
Themalerepresentativeofanon‐Hispanicwhitemale‐ownedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthatprivatesectorprojectsaremuchmorestraightforwardthanpublicsectorprojects,astherearemoredirectchannelsofcommunicationanddecision‐making.Hestatedthatpublicsectorprojectscostmore“becausetheprojectsgetextendedoverlongerperiodsoftime,andtherearemultiplereviewsandprocessesthatyouhavetogothrough.”Headded,“Whenthatstartstoextendovermonths,itjustbecomesahighlyinefficientprocess….”[#1a]
Thesamebusinessrepresentativewentontoexplainthat,unlikepublicsectorprojects,privatesectorprojectstypicallyhaveapointpersonwhoisresponsibleforcommunicatingdecisionsandisempoweredtomakedecisionsonthespot,ratherthanspendingtimedeliberatingandnegotiating.Herecommendedthattheprocessbeimprovedby“empowering…projectmanagerstomakedecisions.”[#1a]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmsaidtherearestarkdifferencesingettingprivatesectorworkversuspublicsectorwork.Heexplained,“Intheprivatesector,ifthecustomertrustsyouandyoucandothework,that’swhatit’sallabout.Itmattersifyouhaveagoodreputation.Inthepublicsector,it’smorewhoyouknowthanwhatyouknow,ortheexperiencesyouhaveorwhatqualities…orwhatqualificationsyoubring.Allofthoseaspectsaresecondarybecauseyoucan’tevenshowyourqualificationsbecauseyoucan’tgetinthedoor.”[#7]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleownerofanarchitecturalengineeringfirmreportedthattheymainlyfocusontheprivatesector,thoughtheycurrentlyhaveacontractwithBoulderCounty.Hewentontosaythatreceivingpaymentisneveranissueintheprivatesector.[#16]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaconstructionservicesfirmsaid,“Workingintheprivatesectorforahomeownerorasmallbusiness,likeamomandpopstore,willgetyoupaidmuchquickerthangoingthroughlargecontractors.”[#31]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmindicatedthatprivatesectorworkcanbeadvantageousduetolesspaperwork.Hesaid,“Thereismorepaperwork[involved]onpublicsectorjobs.”[#23b]
TheBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionsupplyfirmindicatedthatitiseasiertogetworkintheprivatesectorbecausethecontractsareprice‐based.[#36]
One business assistance organization representative reported that most small member firms
work mainly in the private sector.TheNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaid,“Thesmallfirmsworkprimarilyintheprivatesector.Whenwetrytotellpeopletheyhavetogoaftercontractswiththecityorstate,thebiggestconcernisthatit’s
![Page 477: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/477.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 50
cumbersometogetthroughthepaperwork.Theyoftensaythatforwhattheydo,thehasslewon’tpayoffinopportunities.So,theychoosenottodoit,especiallysincetheycangetcontractsmorequicklyintheprivatesector.Weareencouragingthemtofullylookatthefullportfolioofworktheycanpursue,andthatincludespublic[work].”[#37]
Thesamebusinessassistanceorganizationrepresentativelatercommentedthatmemberspreferprivatesectorworkbecause“theycanturnadollarquicker.”Sheadded,“Therearemorerestrictionsinthepublicsectorthatyouwon’tencounterintheprivate,likewhatkindsofwindowsordoorhardwareyou’reallowedtouse.”[#37]
Some business owners reported working exclusively in the private sector.Commentsinclude:
TheSubcontinentAsianAmericanmaleownerofaspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthatheonlyworksintheprivatesector.Hewentontosaythatheprefersprivatesectorworkbecausedecisionsaremadequicklyandpaymentisalmostimmediate.[#18]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaconstruction‐relatedfirmreportedthatallofhisworkcomesfromtheprivatesector.Hesaid,“Privatejobsarestilloutthere,theyarejustgettingsmaller.Ihavebidonpublicworkafewtimes,buthaven’tbeensuccessful.Theagency[or]departmentdoesn’tsharewithyouwhyyourbidwasn’taccepted.Afteraperiodoftime[of]nothearingfromthem,youjustassumeyourcompanydidn’tgetthejob.Anyway,youarenotifiedalmostimmediatelyintheprivatesectorifyougotthejob,andyouarepaidquickly.”[#25]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofanengineeringcompanyreportedthatallofhisworkcomesfromtheprivatesectorviaresidentialconstructionprojects.Headded,“[I]haveneverworkedfor[and]wouldneverworkfortheCityofDenver.Iworkedforcitygovernmentsbefore[startingmyfirm],[and]Idon’tlikeit.”[#26]
TheBlackAmericanandveteranmaleownerofageneralcontractingcompanyreportedthatallofhisworkisresidentialandintheprivatesector.Hestated,“IhaveheardfromothercontractorsthathavetriedtodoworkwithDenverforalongtime,and[nocontractscome]outoftheirattempts.So,whyshouldIeventrytogetworktherewhenIhavemorethanenoughthewayIrunmybusiness?”[#29]
One interviewee said that his firm is limited to private sector work because of its low capacity.Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaconstructionservicesfirmstated,“Myfirmdoesn’thavethecapacitytoworkinthepublicsector.Allofmyworkcomesfromprivatecontracts,andthatishowImakealiving.”[#31]
Several trade association and business assistance organization representatives commented on
members’ experiences pursuing public and private sector work.Forexample:
Regardingthedifferencesbetweenpublicandprivatesectorwork,theNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaid,“Obviouslyintheprivatesectorthingsmovequicker,butitismoreuncertain.Thepublic
![Page 478: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/478.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 51
sectormovesalotslower,butthereismorecertaintythatthefundingwillbethere,theprojectwillfinish,andyouwilleventuallygetpaid.”[#37]
Thesamebusinessassistanceorganizationrepresentativelatersaid,“Relationshipsareimportantinboth[sectors],butinthepublicsectorthebuyerismorereluctanttodeveloparelationshipbecausetheydon’twanttobeseenashavingapreference.[So],theytendtogobywhat’sonpaper.”Shesaid,“IftherearenoDBEgoals,it’smore[drivenby]relationship[s].”[#37]
Sheadded,“When[members]doworkinthepublicsector,theyknowtheywilleventuallygetpaid,andthatisreassuring.Intheprivatesectorthereismoreliability….WhenworkingwiththeNativeAmericantribes,youreallyhavetoknowwhatyou’redoing.Inadditiontostrongrelationships,youneedtounderstandthetriballegalissues,becausetherearenorecoursesifsomethinggoesawry.Ifthetribedoesn’twanttopayyouforsomereason,that’syourproblem.Idon’tseeithappeningalot,butthere’salwaysthatrisk.”[#37]
TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationstated,“Inthepublicsectorthereismoreofacashcrunchbecausetheypaysoslow.Private[sectorwork]ismorestraightforward.”Headded,“Privateworkhaslesspaperworkandregulations.Thoseeatupalotoftimeforasmallbusiness.”[#33]
Thesamebusinessassistanceorganizationrepresentativewentontosaythatinthepublicsector“thereismorelipserviceregardingminorityprograms[than]follow‐through.”[#33]
Whenaskedifthereareanysubstantialdifferencesbetweenworkinginthepublicsectorversustheprivatesector,theBlackAmericanfemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationreportedthatthereare.Shesaid,“Theessenceofhavingtheprogramsinplace,thecompliance…reporting,themanagementofit,theoversight,allofthosethingsmakethepublicsectorexperiencedifferent.”Shenotedthatthiscanmakeiteasierormoredifficultforfirms,dependingonhowwelltheirengagementandhabitslineupwithprogramrequirementsandcompliance.[#6]
Inaddition,whenaskedwhichsectoriseasierformemberstosecureworkin,thesametradeassociationrepresentativesaid,“Theopportunitiesintheprogramhaveallowed[members]tocomeinandhaveaspacetoperformatgroundlevel,oratalevelwheretheycancomeinandthengrow.”Sheaddedthatsheisunsureifthereisthesame“tolerance”fornewfirmsintheprivatesector,andsaid,“Intermsofprocessesinplacetosupport[newfirms],I’mnotsurethatexistsintheprivatesector,atleastnottothedegreethatourprogramsdo.”[#6]
Regardingthedifferencesbetweenpublicsectorandprivatesectorwork,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaid,“Yougetoverinthepublicarena,andtobefair,alotoftheadjustmentsthatmakelogicalsensecan’tbedonebecauseeveryonehastohaveanequalshot….Typically,thepublicagencycan’tjustgoanddesigntheprojectandgetsomeearlynumbersfromacoupleofgeneralcontractors.Lateron,theyhavea
![Page 479: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/479.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 52
muchmorelinearprocesswherethey’vehiredthearchitect[andgot]thedrawingstoacertainpoint,andthentakeproposals.”[#40]
Thesametradeassociationrepresentativecontinued,“OneofthethingsI’llsay[CityandCountyofDenver]isdoingbetteristhey’reusingsomedesign‐build/at‐risk[bids]andnotjustalowbidenvironmentsotheycangetsomeofthoseprivatesectoradvantagesintheirprojects….Theconventioncenterisagoodexample.Theybroughtinthearchitect,butthey’llgetacertainamountofdesignandthentheywilldoasolicitationforacontractor,atleastatthegeneralcontractorlevel,andsoon.”[#40]
WhenaskedaboutMWBEmembers’experiencesworkinginbothsectors,hesaid,“Ifthey’recompetent,certification…isagoodwaytogetinvolvedinthepublic[sector].But,therearemany,manyfirmsonthelistthatgetcertifiedandneverdoasinglejob.We’restilltryingtofigurethatout.”[#40]
Some interviewees discussed how the profitability of public sector and private sector work
compare.Responsesastowhetherpublicsectororprivatesectorworkismoreprofitablewerebroad.Forexample:
Whenaskediftherearedifferencesintheprofitabilityofpublicsectorversusprivatesectorwork,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“Itdepends.Ifyou’redoingTacoBellsorautodealerships,it’sprobablyhighlyprofitablebecauseyouhaveaniche.Inthepublicsectoryourprofitisprobablymorepredictable….Intheprivatesector,you’resubjecttothewhimofthedeveloper.Theymaynotgettheirfinancingsotheworkstopsandyoumaynevergetyourmoney.Or,themarketchangesandtheprojectshavetochange,andyoueithermakethechangesothedevelopercangettheirmoney,oryoudon’tandyouloseyourmoney.Inthepublicsectorthereisalotofscrutiny[inthe]scope[of]services,soit’sfarmorepredictable.”[#22]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthattheprofitabilitydoesdifferbetweensectors.Heexplained,“There’smoreprofitinthepublicsectorbecauseyoudon’thavetogofightforyourmoney.You’renotgoingtogosuethepublicsectorfornotpayingyou.You’renotgoingtohavetomarketasmuchinthepublicsector[either].Intheprivatesector[however],it’sallmarketingandyouhavetogochasedownyourdollar….It’sdifferentinthepublicsector[because]there’sasettime,net30[or]net60,andyourmoney’scomingtoyou.Soyes,everyonewouldprefertoworkinthepublicsector[becauseofthat].”[#7]
Whenaskedifprofitabilitydiffersbetweenthepublicandprivatesectors,theBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andESB‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmsaidthatitdoes.Heexplained,“Ithinkyouhavealittlemoreleewayontheprivateside.Ifsomebodylikesyourproduct,they’vesetastandardforwhattheywant.Onthepublicside,theysay,‘Itneedstobesomethingsimilartothis,’andthereareavarietyofqualitieswithinthat.”[#9]
![Page 480: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/480.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 53
Themalerepresentativeofanon‐Hispanicwhitemale‐ownedprofessionalservicesfirmstatedthatprivatesectorprojectsaremoreprofitablethanpublicsectorprojects.Heattributedthisdifferencetothelowercostoffacilitation,theshorterandmoreconcentratedtimeframeforeachproject,andthemorestraightforwardprocess,withfewer“layersofpeople”associatedwithprivateprojects.[#1a]
Whenaskedtodescribethefirm’sexperienceattemptingtogetworkinthepublicandprivatesectors,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedspecialtyservicesfirmsaid,“Itisprettymuchthesameforboth.Wejustidentifywhatprojectsareneeded.Whetherit’sanindividual,acorporation,orapublicentity,theyallhaveabudget.Youquotethemaprice….Wearewillingtoworkwiththemifourpricedoesn’tmeettheirexpectations.”[#34]
Thesamebusinessrepresentativeadded,“Inthepublicsector,itsometimestakeslongertogetadecisionbecauseyoudon’talwaysknowexactlywhothedecisionmakeris.[Forexample],it[couldbe]someoneinadepartmentorinpurchasing.Inbothsectors,timeisakeyelement.Everyonewantsthingsfaster.Sometimesyouhavethecustomerwithleadtimeandanotherwhoneedssomethingtomorrow.Wetrytoworkwithbothatthesametime.”[#34]
Whenaskedifitiseasiertogetworkinonesectorcomparedtotheother,hesaidthatitiseasiertosecureprivatesectorworkbecausetheyhavemorerelationshipsinthatsector.Helaternotedthattheexperienceofperformingworkdoesnotdifferbetweensectors.[#34]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmstatedthatprofitabilitydoesnotdifferbetweensectors.Heexplained,“Ithinkthatforthemostpartit’sprettyclose.It’spartofthebiddingprocess[and]you’restillcompetingagainsteveryonelookingatthesamework.It’sprettysimilar.”[#23a]
Thesamebusinessrepresentativewentontosay,“Onapublicjobthere’smoreinfluencefromaroundthecountry.There’salotofstateworkandcityworkwherepeoplefromoutsidethestatearebiddingon[it],andsometimestheydothingsthataredifferentfromourprofitabilitystandpoint.”[#23a]
TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmstated,“Theprofitabilitybetweenprivateandpublicisn’tanydifferent,atleastnotinthecablingindustry.”[#32a]
TheNativeAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,SDB‐,SDVOSB‐,andHUBZone‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmreportedthatprofitabilityineachsectorisaboutthesame,anddescribedhisprofitsas“good.”[#39]
TheBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionsupplyfirmsaid,“Inbothsectorsthemarginsarereallysqueezed.Peoplewillbidapennyovertheircostandcarrythepaperfor30days.”Headded,“InthepublicsectorImightbeabletocompeteiftheybrokeitintosmallerquantities.”[#36]
![Page 481: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/481.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 54
Regardingeachsector’sprofitability,thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedstructuralengineeringfirmsaidthattheprofitabilitydoesnotdiffer,thoughthepublicsectorcanbemoredifficultifabusinessownerisnotpreparedforitsmoretime‐consumingnature.Shecommented,“Publicsectorprojectsrequiresomuchmoremeetingtime,butifyou’resmart,youputthattimeinyourcontractandyou’reokay.”[#5]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemaleco‐ownerofaspecialtyservicesfirmreportedthatprofitabilityisgenerallythesameinbothsectors.Shenotedthatinthepublicsectorshecanwriteoffpartofanexpenseasadonation.Sheexplained,“Icanwriteoffpartoftheirbillasdonationbywayofadiscount….Idid[this]withtheschooldistrict.”[#8]
Whenaskedifprofitabilitydiffersbetweensectors,thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthatforherfirmitdoesnot.Sheexplained,“Ithinkthat’salittlebitonus….Weneedtobesmartinhowwewrite.Ithinkalotofpeoplelosetheirshirts,butIhaven’tbeeninbusinessfor[over25]yearsbygivingstuffaway.”[#12]
Whenaskedifprofitabilitygenerallydiffersbetweensectors,theHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmsaidthatprofitabilitydependsonhowwellyounegotiateacontract,notwhetheritispublicorprivatesectorwork.[#14]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedspecialtyservicesfirmindicatedthatprofitabilitydoesnotdifferbetweensectors.Hesaid,“Thekeytoprofitability,whetherpublicorprivate,isunderstandingwhattheclientwantsandiftheirbudgetisrealistic.Iftheirbudgetisnotrealistic,wewillthendiscussoptionswiththeclientthatfitintheirbudget.”[#34]
Whenaskedifprofitabilitydiffersbetweensectors,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmsaiditisaboutthesame“inthelongrun.”Heexplained,“Thereareyearswhenwehavebetterprofitsthanothers,andalotofitprobablyhasmoretodowiththe[factthatthe]privatesectorallowsyoutodothingsthatthepublicsectordoesn't.Forexample,valueengineering.Thepublicsectorhasaspecandyoucan’tchangethat.”[#21a]
Whenaskedifprofitabilitydiffersbetweensectors,theHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmstated,“Itdepends.It’samatterofinsurancecosts…[and]howmanyhoursIneedtospendintheofficedoingpaperwork.Italsodependsonhowoftenwehavetolookforthatprimeifwehavequestionsthatneedanswers.”[#35]
Trade association and business assistance organization representatives also discussed the
profitability of each sector.Afewindicatedthatprofitmarginsareeasiertomanageintheprivatesector.Forexample:
![Page 482: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/482.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 55
Whenaskedifprofitabilitydiffersbetweensectors,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaid,“That’satoughone.Icanthinkofcompaniesthatworkinthepublic[sectorthat]areveryprofitable.However,intheprivatesectorthebusinessownercanbettermanagehisprofitmargins.It’snotasconstrained.”[#33]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthatmanyofhermembersthataresmallfirmsconcentrateonprivatesectorworkbecauseitismoreprofitableforthem.Shesaid,“Ithinkitdependsonthediscipline,[but]rightnowontheverticalsidethere’salotofprivatework….That’swherethey’vedevelopedtherelationships,butit’svaried.Youcouldimaginehowmanyclientstheyhaveversus…just[having]theCityandCountyofDenver,or…CDOT.”[#38]
Whenaskedabouttheprofitabilityofbothsectors,theBlackAmericanfemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthattheprofitabilitygenerallydiffers.Sheexplained,“Inthepublicsectorwetalkaboutbreakingtheprojectdownintosmaller,morefeasiblepackages.Whereasintheprivatesector,ifyoucandothework,youcanjustdothework.There’saspaceforbothandthere’sconsiderationforboth.Breakingprojectsdowncanbegoodforsmallfirmsthatneedtheopportunity.”Sheaddedthatthereshouldstillbe“meaningfulopportunitiesfor[larger]firmsthat…canhandlemorework.”[#6]
TheHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthatprofitabilitydiffersbetweensectors.Hesaidthatinthepublicarenatherearesometimesunforeseencostssuchasbondingandinsurancethatsmallfirmsmaynotknowabout.[#11]
Whenaskedifprofitabilitydiffersbetweenpublicsectorandprivatesectorwork,theNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationstatedthatitdoesnot,butnotedthatthe“speedatwhichacompanygetspaid”does.Shereiteratedthatpaymentisfasterintheprivatesector.[#37]
C. Keys to Business Success
Thestudyteamaskedfirmownersandrepresentativesaboutbarrierstodoingbusinessandaboutkeystobusinesssuccess.Topicsthatinterviewersdiscussedwithbusinessownersandrepresentativesincluded:
Keystosuccessingeneral;
Relationship‐building;
Employees;
Equipment,materials,orproducts;
Competitivepricing(pricingorcredit);
Financingandaccesstocapital;
Bonding;
Insurance;and
![Page 483: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/483.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 56
Otherkeystobusinesssuccess.
Keys to success in general. Manybusinessownersandrepresentativesexpressedthekeyfactorstosuccessasprofessionalism,communication,teamwork,training,experience,andreliability.[e.g.,#12]Examplesofrelatedandotherfactorsinclude:
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaprofessionalservicesfirmcitedcommunication,customerserviceandexperienceaskeystosuccessintheirlineofwork.Hestated,"Ifourclientswantsomethingdone,theyknowthatthey'llgetmeoroneofmystaffmembersonthephone….Atourfirmwehaveapersonalrelationshipwitheachandeveryoneofourclients….Wekeeptheminformedastotheprogressoftheworkaswellasproblemswemayencounter….Theyalsoknowthatweareworkinghardforthem,thatwearepleasanttoworkwith,andthatwebringgoodideastothetable…."[#3]
Whenaskedwhatittakesforafirmtobecompetitiveinherindustry,theHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmsaidthatownersmustpayattentiontosafety,asworkers’compensationcostshaveabigimpactonacompany’sbid.Sheexplained,“Ifyourworkers’compensation[costs]aretwiceortriplethatofyourcompetitor,thenthat’showmuchmore[money]youhavetoputintoyourbids.Materialscostthesameforeverybody.Overhead[costs]varybytheentity,[but]laboriswhatfluctuatesthemost.So,safetyisatremendouspartofit.”[#2]
Whenaskedwhatittakesforafirmtobecompetitiveinhislineofbusiness,theBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andESB‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmsaidittakestherightpricing,therightproduct,andproductsthatareunique.Heexplained,“Therearealotof[product]providersinthemarketplace,andoftenasuccessfulmanufacturerwillcomealong,soeverybodycarriesthatsamestyle.Butifyoureallywanttobedifferent,youhavetohavesomethingthat’sdifferentthanstylesthatotherfirmshaveaninterestin.”[#9]
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“Havingsomethingdifferentcanbebothanadvantageandadisadvantage.Asanexample,almosteverythingtheCityofDenverdoesisbasedonastandardthatwasdonebackinthe1950s.Butthemarkethaschangedalotsincethen.Youstillneeda300‐pound[product]that[will]lastfor50years,butnowpeoplearelookingforexperientialenvironments[and]thingsthatareunique.Andso,ifothersareonlyallowingformoretraditionalstylestohappen,thenitmakesitdifficultforsomeonewhohasuniquestufftobemoresuccessfulindoingworkwiththecity.”[#9]
Whenaskedwhatittakesforafirmtobecompetitiveinhislineofwork,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofagoodsandservicesfirmsaidittakes“agility”tobecompetitive.Headded,“Italsorequiresbeinguptodate,becausealotofthingsmoveatthespeedoftheinternet….Somethingmaybeveryhotandverypopularoneday,[but]itmightfizzleanddiethenextweek.So,it’sbeingpreparedandup‐to‐dateonwhatispopularsothatwecanmovequicklyenoughandcapitalizeonthoseopportunities.”[#10]
Whenaskedwhatittakesforafirmtobecompetitiveinhislineofbusiness,theHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirm
![Page 484: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/484.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 57
saidthatbecauseengineeringworkisbasedonqualifications,asuccessfulfirmmusthavegoodqualifications.Headdedthattobecompetitive,firmsalsoneedto[understand]whatclients’needsare.[#14]
Whenaskedwhatittakesforafirmtobecompetitiveinherindustry,thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaidthatitcomesdownto“exposure.”Sheadded,“IfIcanconvinceyoutohireme,you’llseeourcompetence,butIcan’tgetyoutohiremeifyoucan’tseeme.”[#5]
ThesamebusinessowneralsosaidthatsheattendsseveralexposandtradefairsthatoccurbecauseoftheMWBErequirement.Shecommented,“Ican’temphasizeenough[that]thereisnoplaceIcangotogetthetypeofexposure[that]beingaMWBEfirmgivesme.EvenifIgotomytradepartnersormyprofessionalnetworks,Imightgetinfrontof[them],butthey’renotrequiredtohireaMBWE….Ifthey’veusedthesamefirmforthelast15years,whywouldtheyconsiderhiringsomeoneelse?”[#5]
Whenaskedwhatittakesforafirminherindustrytobecompetitiveinthelocalmarketplace,thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemaleco‐ownerofaspecialtyservicesfirmreportedthatfirmsshouldhaveknowledgeonhowtoobtaincontractsandhowtomarkettothepublicsector.[#8]
Whenaskedwhatittakesforafirmtobecompetitiveinhislineofwork,theBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmsaidthatmarketingiskey.Headded,“Forone,wehavetomarketbetterwithourplumbers….Rightnow,it’sreallycompetitive…sodoingthatandtryingtogetontheinsurancecompany’spreferredvendorlist…isreallyimportant,eventhoughitisanotherdauntingtask.”[#7]
Whenaskedwhatittakestobecompetitiveinhisindustry,theHispanicAmericanmaleownerofanarchitecturalengineeringfirmstated,“Inordertobecompetitiveinthislineofbusinessyoumustbeknowledgeable;[youmust]listentowhattheclientwants;stayup‐to‐dateonconstructionpractices[regarding]whatcanandcan’tbedone,andcommunicatethatclearlytotheclient.Mostcritical[is]know[ing]whentosay,‘Ican’tdothat.’”[#16]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedgeneralcontractingfirmsaid,“Youneedtoproveyourcompanycandothework,whetherit’sprivateormunicipal.Also,becausewehavedifferenttypesofequipment,ourcompanycandothingssmallcompaniescan’t.Wehavepositionedourselvesforagreatfuture.”[#19]
Whenaskedwhatmakesfirmsinherindustrycompetitive,theHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofanSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“Afull‐timemarketing[and]businessdevelopmentperson,but[wedon’t]havethemoneyforthat.Wehadapart‐timemarketingpersonseveralyearsago,butcouldn’taffordhersalary….Ittakesfourorfiveyearsformarketingseedstogerminate,andsmallfirmsareonashoestringbudget.”[#15a]
![Page 485: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/485.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 58
Importance of a good reputation.Manynotedtheimportanceofagoodreputation.[e.g.,#5,#18,#19,#25,#28,#31,#32a]Businessownersalsodiscussedtheimportanceofexperience,qualitywork,andotherkeyfactors.[e.g.,#12,#39]Commentsinclude:
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaprofessionalservicesfirmhighlightedtheimportanceofbothrelationship‐buildingandexpertise.Heexplained,“Ourclientsareourbestmarketers.Wehadoneclientrecentlyrecommendourfirmtoalargeprimeconsultant.Theclientrecommendedthattheprime…includeusintheirteambecauseweknewmoreaboutthefacilitiesthananyothersubthattheycouldthinkof.”[#3]
Whenaskedwhatittakesforafirmtobecompetitiveinhislineofwork,theBlackAmericanveteranmaleownerofageneralcontractingcompanystated,“I’magoodcontractorwithagreatreputation.Wordofmouthgoesalongway.Peopletalk.I’maskedifIcoulddojobswhenIhaven’tevenmetthepeople,becauseIhaveagoodreputation.”[#29]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthathisfirm’sreputationwithprimeshelpsthemtosecuresubcontractingwork.Headded,“Theprimescontactusbecauseofourmilitaryandminoritystatus,andtheyknowthatwedoverypersonalwork.Theyknowwe’llgooutthere,asowners,onthebeginningandtheendofjobstomakesureit’sdonecorrectly.”[#7]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaconstructionfirmsaid,“ThereisalotofworkoutthereandIhaveagoodreputation,andmuchofmyworkisrepeatcustomersandwordofmouth.IbelieveIamdoingaswellasotherindependentcontractors.”[#24]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmstated,“Ofcourse,thereputationyourcompany…goesalongwaytogettingjobs.Ourreputationisverygood.”[#27]
Whenaskedwhatittakesforafirmtobecompetitiveintheindustry,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmstated,“Inourlineofbusiness,it’svalue.[Wehavetoget]materialsthereontime.Ourcontractorswantnothingmorethantogettheirmaterialsexactlywhentheywantthem.Inordertodothat,wehavetohaveaprettyheftylineupofgoodsintheback,readytogo.”[#23a]
Thesamebusinessrepresentativeadded,“And[there’s]knowledge.Whenyouthinkabouttheintricaciesofanelectricalprojecttoday,theyaremuchmorecomplexthantheyusedtobe.So,[wehavetomake]surewehavequalitypeopleonstafftoanswertechnicalquestions,andaprojectmanagementteamtomakesurethatcustomersgetwhatevertheywant.”[#23a]
Whenaskedwhatittakesforafirmtobecompetitiveinherlineofbusiness,thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmstated,“Thekeythingsforafirmtobecompetitiveinthislineofbusinessiscostandreputation.”[#20]
![Page 486: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/486.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 59
A trade association representative commented on the importance of members’ work quality
and performance.Whenaskedwhatittakesformemberfirmstobecompetitiveinthelocalmarketplace,theBlackAmericanfemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthatqualityworkandperformancearekey.Sheadded,“It’sonethingtobeagreatwidgetmaker,butinthisdayandage[it’s]incrediblyimportanttohaveastrongbackoffice.It’sincrediblyimportanttohavealevelofeducationandexpertiseaboutyourownscopes,andwherethey’reheadedinthefuture.”[#6]
Thesametradeassociationrepresentativecontinued,“Bigdataissuchabigpartofwhat’sdrivingalotofthedecisionsinmunicipalities,owneragencies,etcetera.Oursmallbusinessesreallyneedtoknowhowthat’sgoingtorolldowntothem,howrequirementsaregoingtochange,howdeliverymechanismsaregoingtochange,howengagementmechanismsaregoingtochange….”[#6]
Relationship‐building.Acrossindustries,mostbusinessownersandrepresentativesidentifiedrelationship‐buildingasakeycomponenttosuccess.
Whether easy or difficult to achieve, many considered relationship‐building a key to business
success.[e.g.,#13,#19,#33,#35,#37,#39]Forexample:
Themalerepresentativeofanon‐Hispanicwhitemale‐ownedprofessionalservicesfirmstated,“We’reaconsultingfirmandtheabilitytointerfacewithclientsandtounderstandtheirneedsandtoberesponsivetotheirneedsisthekeytobeingsuccessful….”[#1a]
Thesamebusinessrepresentativereportedthattheirprivatesectorbusinesscomesprimarilyfromword‐of‐mouthreferralsandthatclientsseekthefirmbecauseofitscapabilitiesforspecificprojects.[#1a]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaprofessionalservicesfirmnotedthatclientreferralsleadtonewbusinessforhiscompany,especiallyasasubcontractor.Heexplained,“Ourbestmarketersareourclients….We’reasmallfirm…so[clients]wouldsuggestthatmaybeanotherfirmcouldbetheprimeandwecouldbethesub….”[#3]
Thesamebusinessownerwentontosaythatmostofhisfirm’ssubcontractingworkiswithrepeatclients.Hesaid,“Theyfindoutthatwecandotheworkforalotless…soitmakesthemmorecost‐competitive,andwefrequentlyhavemoreexpertiseintheareathantheydo.”[#3]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“Whenyougetintothedesignsideofit,it’sallaboutrelationshipsandcommunication.[It’s]becauseyouhavetobeabletocommunicatetomeyourvision,andIhavetobeabletotakethatvisionandgodomywork.Intermsofbeingcompetitive,it’saboutrelationshipfirst,reputationsecond,competence…ormaybeprice,third.”[#5]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmsaid,“It’samatterofmaintainingrelationships.Beingabusinessownerisnotapart‐timecommitment.Istayverybusyrunningthisbusiness.”[#27]
![Page 487: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/487.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 60
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmstatedthatbecauserepeatbusinessisvitaltothecompany’ssuccess,theyhavealonghistorywithmanyoftheircustomers.[#23b]
One business owner noted the importance of relationship‐building in public sector
contracting.TheNativeAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,SDB‐,SDVOSB‐,andHUBZone‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmsaidthatrelationshipsareespeciallyimportantinpublicsectorcontracting.Heexplainedthatsomebuyersareaccustomedtodealingwithparticularsuppliersandaremorecomfortablecontinuingthatrelationship.[#39]
Some trade association representatives commented on the importance of relationship‐
building to members’ success.[e.g.,#6]Forexample,theHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthathebelievesrelationship‐buildingisoneofthekeystogettingworkintheindustry.Hecontinued,“Ifirmlybelieve[that]onceyoudeveloprelationships,whensomeoneneedssomethingtheyaregoingtocallpeopletheyhavebuiltarelationshipwith….Itdoesnotmatterwhetheritisapublicsectorjoborprivatesector[job].Notalltheprimesself‐performeverything.Manyoftheprimessuboutalotoftheirwork.Whentheyneedasubcontractor,theyarejustlookingforsomebodywhotheyhavefaithinandwhocandothework.Ithasnothingtodowithcertificationwhenitisintheprivatesector.”[#11]
Employees.Businessownersandrepresentativessharedcommentsabouttheimportanceofqualifiedemployees.Manyintervieweesandsurveyrespondentsindicatedthathigh‐qualityworkersareakeytobusinesssuccessandsometimesdifficulttofind. [e.g.,#28,#40,AS#3,AS#4,AS#6,AS#8,AS#14,AS#17,AS#21,AS#23,AS#24,AS#25,AS#29,AS#30,AS#33,AS#41,AS#45,AS#50,AS#53,AS#56,AS#57,PT#3d]Forexample:
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmsaid,“Inmycase,themajoritemincreasingmycostsislabor.Itisgettingharderandhardertofindqualified,experiencedlaborers.”Sheadded,“Laborisabigissueinthismarket.Itisveryhardtofindtherightpeople.Millennialsdonothavethesameworkethicaspastgenerations.Inaddition,toofewpeoplearegettingtrainedinskilledtrades.”[#20]
Thesamebusinessownerlatersaid,“FromthecompanysideIhavetheexperienceandexpertise,butfindingqualifiedemployeeswiththerightexpertiseisincreasinglydifficult.”[#20]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmindicatedthatit’sdifficulttofindpersonnelandlabor.Sheexplained,“Iwenttothe[ColoradoStateUniversity]careerfairthisyeartryingtorecruitbecausetherearelaborissues…andIcoulddefinitelyseethoseyoung,malegraduatesgravitatingtowardsthebigger,male‐ownedfirms.”[#12]
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“Theschoolsareperpetuatingthat.ThatwashowitwaswhenIwenttoschool.[Schoolssay],‘Youneedtogoworkforthesebigfirms,[they’re]therealthing.’Youcouldseethatalphamalesatthiscareerfairwereallheadingtotalkto
![Page 488: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/488.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 61
themandalotoffemalescameandtalkedtous.It’shardforusnottobepigeon‐holedasanall‐femalecompany.”[#12]
TheBlackAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaidhermainconcernisfindingaskilledworkforce.Shesaidthereisastigmaassociatedwithworkingconstruction,andnotedthatlittleisdonetoalleviatethatperception,particularlywithBlackAmericans.[#13]
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“It’sreallyhardtofindthosewhowanttogothroughtheapprenticeshipprogram,andreallybepipefitters,sheetmetalworkers,andplumbers,andallthosethings.It’sjustnotwhatpeoplethinkofasacareer.”[#13]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmstatedthatitcanbedifficulttofindqualifiedcraftspeople.Heexplained,“Colorado’seconomyismorediversifiedthanitwasinthe80s,sothereismorepressureontheworkforce.Everyoneiscompetingforworkforce.”[#21a]
Asurveyrespondentsaid,“Laborresources[arescarce].Itisastruggletofindemployees,andweareshort‐staffed.”[AS#9]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaidthatfindinggoodgeotechnicalengineershasalwaysbeenachallenge.Hesaidthatthisisbecausegeotechnicalengineersneedanadvanceddegree,andthatmostcivilengineeringstudentsgotoworkrightaftertheygettheirundergraduatedegree.Headdedthatgeotechnicalengineeringisveryspecialized,andthatmostpeoplepreferawiderrangeofopportunities.[#14]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedgeneralcontractingfirmstated,“Iknowthelabormarketisverytightrightnow,butIknowhowtotreatmypeopleandtheystayaround.I’veevensetupabonusprogram,anditisworking.”[#19]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmsaidthatshewishesshecouldhiremoreemployees.Sheexplained,“Ihavegonethroughmanysourcestofindemployees….Imightfindoneortwoemployeeshereorthere,buttheyjustdon’tstaywhenthereareothertypesofworkoutthere.”[#27]
Thesamebusinessownerlatersaid,“Theonlyproblemmycompanyisexperiencingisthelackofavailableemployees.Thelabormarketissotight[that]wecan’tfindanyonethatwillstayaroundlongterm.”Sheadded,“[And]thatisnotabarrierexperiencedbecauseofrace,ethnicity,[or]gender.Theworkforceisjustnotthere.”[#27]
TheBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionsupplyfirmsaid,“Findingdriversrightnowisdefinitelyaproblem.Maybeit’sjustmymindset.WhatkindoftalentwillIbeabletoattractasaBlackowner?Wouldtheyratherworkforsomeonewhotheythinkhasmorelongevity?[Ifso],thatstartstoshrinktheemployeepool.”[#36]
![Page 489: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/489.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 62
Whenaskedaboutbarriersregardinglaborandpersonnel,theHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofanSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaidthatfindingsomeonewhowantstoworkforasmallfirmisachallenge.Sheexplained,“Thereisaperceptionthatthefirmwillgooutofbusiness.We’vehadthreeindividualswhowouldhavebeenfabulousfits,[but]theywentbacktotheirfirms[afterthey]wereofferedraisesandotheraccommodations.”[#15a]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmreportedthatthefirmdoesfacebarriersinfindingemployeeswiththeappropriateexperienceandexpertise.Heexplained,“Technologyischangingsorapidly.Findingemployeeswiththerightexperienceandexpertiseisachallenge.”Headded,“[There’s]notenoughyoungpeople…enteringourfield.”[#23b]
A few trade association representatives commented on the importance of quality labor for
member firms.Onenotedthatmembershavenoissuesfindingqualitypersonnel,whereasanotherreporteditisoneoftheirmembership’sbiggestchallenges.Forexample:
TheBlackAmericanfemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthatmembersselectsubcontractorsthroughrelationshipsandcapabilities.Sheadded,“EspeciallyasaDBE,youwanttomakesureyouhaveagoodteamoffolksthatyoucanbringonfordifferentprojects.Youwanttobeabletotrustyourworkandtrustyourpeople.”[#6]
TheHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationindicatedthatmembershavenoissuesfindingpersonnelwithadequateexperienceandexpertise.[#11]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthatoneofthebiggestchallengeshermembersfaceinthemarketplaceisfindingqualifiedemployees.Shesaid,“Tenyearsago,wehadarecession[and]peoplelefttheindustry….Engineershaveverytransferrableskills.Theycangointootherthings[like]business,finance,a…varietyofthings,[so]theydon’tcomeback.”[#38]
Regardingstudentsthatarestudyingengineering,thesametradeassociationrepresentativesaid,“There’safairnumberofpeople,students,goingintoscienceandengineering.But…[alot]wouldrathergointoaerospace,biotech,[or]IT,[where]theycanmakeawholelotmoremoneythanbeingacivilengineer.Civilengineers’salarystartingoutisatthebottomofthebarrel.”[#38]
Some business assistance organization representatives indicated that member firms struggle
to find quality employees.Onerepresentativenotedthatsomepotentialworkersfacelanguage‐relatedbarriers.Forexample:
TheNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaidthatformembers,“thebigstruggleisfindingemployees.”Shereiteratedthatthislimitsopportunitiesbecausesomemembers“areeventurningdownwork”duetoashortageofqualifiedworkers.Sheaddedthatthelackofemployeesisaproblemforallmembers,notonlythoseinconstruction.[#37]
![Page 490: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/490.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 63
Whenaskedaboutbarriersthatmembersfaceregardingpersonnel/labor,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationstated,“Alotofmembers,especiallyintherestaurantindustry,arehavingtroublehiringduetotheimpactofthemarijuanaindustry.Whyworkat10to$17anhourinarestaurantwhentheycanmake$35ormore?”[#33]
Thesamebusinessassistanceorganizationrepresentativecontinued,“Languagecanalsobeaproblembecauseimmigrantsusetheirnativelanguageinthebackroomofarestaurant,soEnglishspeakersmaybeuncomfortable.[However],thatischangingbecauseoftheshortageofworkers.YounowseeMexicansworkinginaChineserestaurant.”[#33]
Whenaskedaboutbarriersregardingexperienceandexpertise,hecommentedthatwhileimmigrantmembershavegoodexperienceandexpertise,theystillfacebarriersduetolanguagechallenges.[#33]
One business owner reported that employee recruitment is a challenge when competing
against larger firms.TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaidthatitisdifficultforafirmhissizetocompetewithlarge,60‐personfirmsforemployees,ashisfirmisviewedaslessstableinthelongterm.[#22]
Some business owners indicated that hiring good employees is not a challenge for their firm.Commentsinclude:
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmindicatedthathiringgoodemployeesisnotachallengeforfirmsinherindustryinthelocalmarketplace.[#2]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleownerofanarchitecturalandengineeringfirmreportedthathisfirmhasnoproblemsretaininggoodengineers.Hewentontocomment,“Thegoodoneshavethegumptiontogooutandlookforthekindofjobtheywant.Iftheydon’tknowtheformulaforcalculatingloadsoffthetopoftheirhead,[we’re]notinterestedinthem.”[#16]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofagoodsandservicesfirmreportedthatfindingqualityemployeesisnotanissueforthefirm.[#10]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmindicatedthatfindinggoodemployeesisnotabarrierforherfirm.Shestated,“[On]occasionswhenIneedtohire,IcontactMiCasaResourceCenterandalsocheckwithfriendsandfamily.”[#35]
Equipment, materials, or products.Someintervieweesdiscussedequipmentandmaterialsneeds,andtheimportanceofhavingtherightoperationalequipmentandmaterialsatareasonablecost.[e.g.,#2,#33,#34]Forexample:
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedgeneralcontractingfirmindicatedthathavingtherightoperationalequipmentata
![Page 491: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/491.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 64
reasonablecostgivesherfirmanadvantageoverothersintheindustry.Shereportedthattheirequipmentismaintainedin‐house,whichallowsthemtokeepmaintenancecostsdown.Othersintheindustry,sheexplained,havetotaketheirequipmenttooutsidecompaniestohavethemaintenanceworkdone.[#19]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringfirmreportedthatherfirmdoesnothaveahugeinvestmentinequipment.However,sheadded,“Don’tgetmewrong,Ispentover$20,000lastyearinsoftwaremaintenance,andthat’sjuststandardupkeep.That’snotbecausewehadaproblem.That’sjustthepriceoflicensureforthesoftwareandlicensesthatwehold.”[#5]
Regardinghowtostaycompetitiveinhisindustry,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaspecialtyservicesfirmsaid,“Youhavetobeextremelyflexibleinwhatyouprinttobecompetitivethesedays.Ourmachinery[triestobe]flexible.Thereareonlyoneortwomachinesthatcoulddo[the]manydifferent…typesofjobsouttherenow.”[#30]
Regardingequipment,theBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionsupplyfirmsaid,“It’sterriblyexpensive.I’mprobablylookingatatrucklease,whichofcourseismoreexpensive.”[#36]
A business assistance organization representative commented on the high cost of construction
equipment.TheNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationstated,“Someoftheconstructionequipmentisveryexpensive.Wehavearelationshipwith[anationalrentalfirm],andtheysometimesgiveusaheads‐upwhentheyaresellingtheirequipmentatanauction.”[#37]
For some interviewees, equipment is not needed or is not a challenge to obtain for their firm.[e.g.,#12,#22]Commentsinclude:
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofanSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmindicatedthatthefirmhasnoissuesacquiringtheequipmentthattheyneed.[#15a]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmindicatedthatacquiringequipmentisnotanissueforthefirm.Headdedthattheyhavenoissuesobtaininginventoryorothermaterialsandsupplies.Heexplained,“Mostlarge…wholesalersstaywellstocked.Theonlybarrierforanycontractordoingbusinesswithusismeetingourcreditstandards.”[#23b]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmreportedthatequipmentisnotanissueforthefirmbecausetheygenerallyuseprimecontractors’equipmentonprojects.Sheaddedthattheyhavenoissuesobtaininginventoryorothermaterialsandsupplies.[#20]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmstatedthatsubcontractorswhocanmeetasupplier’screditrequirementsshouldhavenoproblemobtainingnecessarymaterialsandsupplies.However,henotedthatiftheycannotmeetthecreditrequirementstheyfaceabarriertodoingbusiness.[#21a]
![Page 492: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/492.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 65
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmreportedthatshehasnoproblemsgettingtheequipmentsheneeds.Sheaddedthatshehasnoissuesobtaininginventoryorothermaterialsandsupplies,andnotedthatshehasanMWBE‐certifiedcontactwhosellshercleaningsupplies.[#35]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofagoodsandservicesfirmreportedthatobtainingnecessaryequipmentisnotachallengeforthefirm.[#10]
One trade association representative said that small firms sometimes get equipment “through
their prime.”TheHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthatheisnotawareofmembersexperiencingbarriersrelatedtoequipment.Headded,“Alotofourguys,smallguys,willgothroughtheirprimetogettheequipmentthattheyneed,especiallyforspecificprojects.”[#11]
Competitive pricing.Businessownersandrepresentativesdiscussedtheneedforcompetitivepricingandcreditwhenseekingbusinesssuccess.[e.g.,#20,#34]However,forsome,stayingcompetitiveisachallenge.Forexample:
TheBlackAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaidthatcostandpricingareimportantfactorstobusinesssuccess.Sheadded,“MBEsareoftenconcernedthattheywon’tgetthejobunlesstheycutthemselvesoffatthekneesregardingpricing.”Shesaidshehasbeenadvisedtoanalyzehowmuchitreallycoststorunherbusinessasopposedtoonlytellingcustomerswhattheywanttohear.[#13]
TheNativeAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,SDB‐,SDVOSB‐,andHUBZone‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmsaidthathehasexperiencedafew“upsanddowns”sincestartingthefirm,thoughhestucktohisbusinessplan.Hewentontosay,“Youstillhavetocompeteonprice,andIwill.CorporateAmerica’sperceptionisthatsmallbusinessesareunabletocompete,butwe’vebeenabletodefythatbecausewecancompeteonserviceandtechnology.”HealsonotedthathehasaGSAScheduleContractwiththefederalgovernment,whichhebelievescontributestohiscompetitiveness.[#39]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleownerofaspecialtycontractingfirmhighlightedtheimportanceofcompetitivepricingasvitalinrunningasuccessfulbusiness.Heexplained,"Ittakesthewillingnesstoacceptsmallprofit….Mostpeople’sbiggestmistakeshappenwhentheyputtheirbottomlineastheirnumberonepriority.Iftheydon'tmake30,40,50percentprofitonthejob,they'redone.They'rereadytohangitupandthey'renotwillingtodotheworkandpaythepricethatittakestogettothatlevel.Tobesuccessful,youhavetobedisciplinedenoughtostayasteadycourse,[one]thatwillnotgetyourichovernight.”[#4]
TheBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionsupplyfirmsaidthatinhisindustrymaterialsandsuppliesareveryexpensive,whichmeanshehastobuytheminlargequantitiestogetfavorablepricing.Henotedthatthislargevolumecreatesastorageissue,whichisalsoexpensive.[#36]
![Page 493: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/493.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 66
One business assistance organization representative noted the importance of competitive
pricing for goods and services firms.TheNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationreportedthatcompetitivepricingisakeytobusinesssuccess,especiallyforgoodsandservicesfirms.[#37]
Financing and access to capital.Manyfirmownersreportedthatobtainingfinancingwaschallengingandimportantinestablishingandgrowingtheirbusinesses.[e.g.,#12,#21a,#28,#35,#36]Someindicatedthatfinancingwasnecessarytopurchaseequipmentorsurvivepoormarketconditions.Commentsinclude:
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmsaidobtainingfinancingwasachallengewhenshestartedherbusiness.Shesaidthefirstbanksheapproachedforalineofcreditturnedherdown.Shesaidthesecondbanksheapproached,alocalbank,grantedherthelineofcreditandhasbeenherbankeversince.[#2]
TheBlackAmericanandveteranmaleownerofageneralcontractingcompanystated,“WhenIfirstmovedhere,gettingfinancingwasachallenge.Ididn’thavealotofcredit….Ineededcashforsuppliesandupdatedequipment.ButbecauseIhavemoneycominginnow,thatisn’tanissueanymore.”[#29]
Whenaskedaboutfinancing,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmsaidthatfinancingcanbeaproblemforfirmsofallsizesiftheyhavecashflowissues.[#23b]
Whenaskedwhatittakestobecompetitiveinhisindustry,theBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionsupplyfirmsaid,“Alotofmoney.Youneedtobeverywellcapitalizedbecause[you]needtobeabletobuyacommodityatagoodprice,thenholditlongenoughtomakemoney.Inordertobeadistributoryou’regoingtoneedstorage…andthetruckstodeliver[myproduct]areveryexpensive.”[#36]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmsaid,“Obtainingfinancingasasmallbusinesshasbeenanissue.Thewaythatbanksevaluatesmallbusinessesmakesalineofcreditarealchallenge.IdonothavemuchW‐2incomebecauseIjustutilizebusinessincometohelppaythemortgage…andtheydonotcountthatasincome.”[#20]
One business assistance organization representative reported on his own challenges in
obtaining financing as a small business owner.Whenaskedwhatittakesforafirmtobecompetitiveinthelocalmarketplace,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationstated,“Itboilsdowntofinancialresourcesandcapacity.Ihaveasmallbusinessmyself,soIspeakfromexperience.Ittakesahighlevelofintegrity,professionalism,[and]accountability.Beingabletosecurea2to$4millionloantoenterintotheairportorhavethecapacitythroughemployees…isverydifficult.”[#33]
Some business owners indicated that financing has not been a challenge. [e.g.,#8,#22]Forexample:
![Page 494: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/494.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 67
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringfirmsaidthat,toherknowledge,obtainingfinancingisnotabarriertofirmsinthelocalmarketplace.[#5]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andESB‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmreportedthathisfirmisself‐fundedandthatfinancingisnotabarrier.[#9]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmsaidthatfinancingisnotaproblemforhisfirm.[#14]
Bonding.Businessownersandrepresentativesreportedontheiraccesstobonding.Someexperiencesreportedarepositive,somearenegative.Forsome,bondingismisunderstoodornotobtainable.
For more established businesses, bonding is obtainable. But for newer, smaller, and poorly
capitalized businesses, securing bonding is difficult.[e.g.,#28,#31]Commentsinclude:
TheBlackAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaidherfirmisrepresentedbyagoodbondingcompanyandhavehadnoclaims.Shesaidthecityrequiresabondforcontractsover$50,000,andsaidthebondingcompanyconsidersthelevelofriskwhenitcomestocollectingoninvoices,payingsuppliers,andwhetherafirmhasalineofcreditasabackupintheeventofnon‐payment.[#13]
Thesamebusinessowneradded,“It’sdifferentifyouareaminority‐ownedbusiness….It’sjustthewayoftheworld.Youknow,ifIcoulddoamagicwandandchangeit,andmakeeverybodyequal,Iwould,butthat’snothowitworks.It’sjustdifferent.”[#13]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedgeneralcontractingfirmstatedthatherexposuretopotentialbarriersislimited.Sheexplained,“WhenIfirststartedmybusiness,mybondinglimitswereverylow.Thatcanbeveryprohibitivebecauseyouknowyoucandobiggerwork,butlowlimitsessentiallykeepyourrevenuesatacap.”Shesaidthatshewasabletoacquireadditionalbondinglimitsthroughabankshehadanestablishedrelationshipwith.[#19]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andESB‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmsaid,“Bondingisalwaysaquestionforusbecausewetendtobesuppliersandinstallers,andnormallythatinvolvescompaniesthataremuchlargerinsize.”Hewentontocomment,“YoucanmarkN/A[forbondingontheproposal],buthowisthatinterpreted?Aretheyinterpreting[that]it’snotavailableor[that]you’renotthesizetobeabletobond,or[that]youdon’thaveabondingcapability?”[#9]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaconstructionservicesfirmstated,“It’sdifficulttogetlargeliabilityinsurancecoverageand…bonding.[Because]mycompanyissmall,insurancecompaniesandbondingcompaniesdon’twanttotakethechance.EventhoughIhavetheexperience,itisdifficult.”[#31]
![Page 495: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/495.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 68
Other interviewees reported little or no problems obtaining bonds, or that bonding was not
required in their industry.[e.g.,#5,#14,#35]Forexample:
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmsaid,“I’vebeenabletosecureandobtainbondingwhenneeded,butIhaven’trecentlyhadtobond.ItisabigreasonwhyIsticktosubcontracting.”[#20]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmindicatedthatbondingisnotanissueforherfirm,andsaiditisusuallynotrequiredinherindustry.[#2]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmreportedthatintheirindustrybondingisnotrequired.[#23b]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemaleco‐ownerofaspecialtyservicesfirmreportedthatbondingisnotrequiredinherindustry.[#8]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleownerofanarchitecturalengineeringfirmreportedthathehasneverhadtobondforanything.[#16]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringfirmsaidthat,toherknowledge,obtainingbondingisnotabarriertofirmsinthelocalmarketplace.[#5]
Insurance.Thestudyteamaskedbusinessownersandrepresentativeswhetherinsurancerequirementsandobtaininginsurancepresentedbarrierstobusinesssuccess.
Some could secure insurance, but the challenge of sustaining it, especially for small
businesses, is reported to be a barrier.[e.g.,#36,#38]Forexample:
Inregardstoobtaininginsurance,thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringfirmsaid,“Healthinsuranceisabarrier.Tryingtoattractqualitypeopleawayfromlargerfirmsandbeingabletoprovidebenefitsisahugebarrierforsmallbusinesses.”[#5]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleownerofanengineeringfirmsaidthatsustainingprofessionalliabilityinsurancehasalwaysbeenchallengingforhisfirmduetoitshighcost.[#16]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmsaid,“Insuranceisabigissueworkingat[DenverInternationalAirport]becauseIpayalmostdoubleformygeneralliability[there],butwithoutitIcan’tworkattheAirport.”[#20]
Regardingbarrierstoworkinginthelocalmarketplace,asurveyrespondentsaid,“It'simpossibletomeetrequirementstoevenstartthebiddingprocess[duetorequired]insurancecoverage.”[AS#16]
![Page 496: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/496.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 69
Regardinginsurancerequirements,thenon‐HispanicwhitefemalerepresentativeofaHispanicAmericanfemale‐ownedDBE‐,ACDBE‐,MWBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedconsultingfirmsaid,“Thecity[requires]minoritybusinesspartnerstocarryinsuranceattheleveloftheprimecontractors.Asaself‐fundedstartup,insuranceatthislevelisdifficulttoafford,particularlyasaMWBEonanon‐callcontractat[DenverInternationalAirport].”[WT#7]
Some interviewees reported that insurance requirements or obtaining insurance were
not barriers, but indicated that insurance is an important, and sometimes costly, business
expense.[e.g.,#23b,#35]Forexample:
Regardinginsurance,theHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmsaiditisveryimportanttoworkwithqualityinsurancecompaniesthatknowyourfirmwell.Shesaid,“It’samatterofhavingthe[right]networktomakesureyou’regettingthemostaccurateinformation[about]whatyouneed.It’sexpensivewhenyoustart,butitpaysoff.Itreallydoes.”[#2]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andESB‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmreportedthathisfirmfacesnobarriersregardinginsurance.[#9]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmsaidthathisfirmalwaysshopsaroundforthebestinsuranceratesandindicatedthatacquiringinsuranceisnotaproblem.Hewentontosaythatiftheygetalargeprojectthatrequiresanincreaseinliabilityinsurance,suchas$3millioninsteadof$1million,itusuallyrequiresachangeincarrierbecausesomecarriershaveacaponwhattheywillcover.[#14]
TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthathehasnotexperiencedanybarriersordiscriminationregardingobtaininginsuranceorinsurancerequirements.Hecommented,“Justpaywhattheyask.”[#22]
Other keys to business success.Severalbusinessownersandrepresentativesmentionedkeystosuccessthatdonotfallintotheabovecategories.Oneintervieweenotedtheimportanceofkeepingupwithtechnologicaladvancementsintheindustry.Commentsinclude:
Whenaskedwhatittakesforafirmtobecompetitiveinhislineofbusiness,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmsaid,“I'dsay[it’s]innovation,consistentprocesses…trainedstaff,andgoodmanagement.That'showyou'dbemorecompetitive.Ifyou'renotontopofyourgame,youcan'tmakeit.”[#21a]
Thesamebusinessrepresentativecontinued,“Thetechnologiesthatarecomingoutaregoingtobewaybeyondwhatthey'veeverbeen.Alotofdifferentcontrolsystemsaredonecompletelydifferentnow.Youcan'tjustputinalightfixtureanymore.Youhavetobuildaprogrammedcomputerbeforeyoucanturnthatlighton,soit'sgettingprettytechnical.”[#21a]
![Page 497: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/497.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 70
Whenaskedwhatittakesforafirmtobecompetitiveinhislineofbusiness,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“[Ittakes]creativity.Thinkingoutsidethebox.Bringinginnovativesolutionstothetable,evenintheRFPstage.”[#22]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmsaidthatlearningeachpublicagency’sprocessisakeytobusinesssuccess.HesaidthatworkingwithCDOTiseasiestforhisfirmbecausetheyareveryfamiliarwiththeirprocessesandpeople.[#14]
Whenaskedwhatittakesforafirmtobecompetitiveintheindustry,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofaspecialtyservicesfirmstated,“[It’s]price,capabilities,abilitytomeetdeadlinesoneverythingfromweddingstoseminarsinKeystone.Weworkdailyonallofthesefactors.”[#34]
Whenaskedwhatittakesforafirmtobecompetitiveinherlineofwork,theHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaid,“[It’s]whoyouknow,[andhaving]goodreferences,certification,andaccessibilitytoopportunities.”[#35]
A trade association representative said that monitoring a firm’s growth is a key to business
success.TheHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthatinorderforafirmtobecompetitiveinthelocalmarketplace,ownersneedtoensurethattheycarefullymonitorthegrowthoftheirfirm.Hestated,“Ifyougrowtoofastandnotwisely,youaregoingtoloseyourbusiness.Ihaveseenthathappen.Oryouslidebackwards,soitisamatterofknowinghowtogrowyourbusiness.Donottaketoomuchthatyoucannothandle[it].”[#11]
D. Doing Business as a Prime Contractor or Subcontractor
Businessownersandrepresentativesdiscussed:
Mixofprimecontractandsubcontractwork;
Challengesforsmallandminority‐andwomen‐ownedbusinesseswhenseekingworkasprimecontractors/consultants;
Challengesforsmallandminority‐andwomen‐ownedbusinesseswhenseekingworkassubcontractors.
Mix of prime contract and subcontract work.Businessownersdescribedtheirexperienceworkingasprimecontractorsand/orsubcontractors.
A number of firms that the study team interviewed reported that they work as both prime
contractors and as subcontractors/subconsultants, and discussed their experiences.[e.g.,#1b,#4,#7,#8,#12,#13,#15a,#16,#26]Forexample:
![Page 498: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/498.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 71
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedgeneralcontractingfirmstatedthatherfirm“subcontractsabout98percentofthetime.”Sheadded,“Occasionallytherewillbeajobthatweprime,butnotveryoften.”[#19]
Whenaskedaboutthefirm’sworkasaprimeorsubcontractor,thesamebusinessownerstated,“Customersarestartingtoknowwhattypeofqualityofworkwedo.[Wedon’t]haveproblemsinfindingwork.”Sheaddedsheisnetworkingwithcompaniesthatcouldpossiblyusetheirservices.[#19]
TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“Iwouldsaythatwe’reprime90percentandsub10percent.”Whenaskedwhyhisfirmtypicallyfunctionsasaprimecontractor,hestated,“It’sthatwholeissuethatwe’reonlyhiredbyengineersonalargeprojecttosatisfytheirgoal.Weeatatthetablewhereaneight‐personfirmisinvited.[#22]
Whenaskedifprimesthatusehimonpublicsectorworkalsousehimonprivatesectorwork,thesamebusinessownersaid,“Nope.Mostofthebigprimesweworkwithdon’tdoprivatesectorwork.”Whenaskedifhemarketsthefirmtoprimes,hesaid,“Yes,atthenetworkingevents.It’sbeenverysuccessfulforus.”[#22]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthathisfirmworksasaprimecontractor75percentofthetimeandasasubcontractor25percentofthetime.[#3]
Thesamefirmownerexplainedthatsometimeshisfirmbeginsacontractbidasaprimecontractorthenteamsupwithanotherfirmtogetthecontract.Hestated,"Acommonexperienceforusisthatwewouldconsiderrespondingasaprime…thenapotentialprimecontactsusandasksifwewouldliketoteam[up]withthemasasubandreducethecompetition."[#3]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthatherfirmworksmostoftenasaprimecontractor.Whenaskedhowthefirmfindsworkasasubcontractor,shesaidtheyuseRockyMountainBidNet.Sheexplained,“YoucanidentifywhohasdownloadedRFPsforanygivenproject,thenyoucancallthemupandschmoozethem,andtellthemthatyou’dliketobeontheirteam.Wedothatsometimes.We’lljustrandomlycoldcallarchitectsandtrytobeontheirteams.”[#12]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmreportedthatthefirmperformsasbothaprimecontractorandsubcontractor.Henotedthatthismixofworkvariesyearly.[#21a]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmindicatedthatherfirmworksasbothaprimecontractorandasubcontractor.Shelaternotedthattheyprefertoworkasaprimecontractor.[#2]
![Page 499: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/499.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 72
TheHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmreportedthathiscompanyperformsanequalamountofprimecontractandsubcontractwork.[#14]
Thesamebusinessowneraddedthattheyusuallyperformcertainspecializedworkasasubcontractor.Hesaidthattheirconstructionmanagementworkisoftenperformedasaprimecontractor.[#14]
Most trade association and business assistance organization representatives said that
members work as both prime contractors and subcontractors.[e.g.,#6,#33,#40]Onesaidthatmostperformassubcontractorsbecausetheylackthe“resources”toworkasaprime.Commentsinclude:
Whenaskedifmembersworkasbothprimecontractorsandsubcontractors,theNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaid,“Obviouslytherearenotasmanyprimecontractorsbecauseittakesalotofresources….Themajorityaresubs.”[#37]
Thesamebusinessassistanceorganizationrepresentativecontinued,“Ithinkmanypeoplefindasweetspotregardingtheircompanysize.Forthosewhowanttogrowandeventuallyprime,itcantakealongtime.WeencouragethemtodeveloparelationshipwiththeSBAandtakeadvantageoftheirprograms,likethe[SBA]8(a),iftheywanttogrowtheircompanies.”[#37]
Whenaskedhowmembersgetonprojectsassubcontractors,shesaid,“Usuallythey’reoutnetworking.They’llcometooneofoureventsandaskmetomakeintroductions.They’llgoouttothecommunitythemselves.Sometimesamemberwillprovideavenue.[Alargesub]recentlyhadanopenhouseandintroducedmemberstoprimesandothersubs.”Shenoted,“Constructionisrelationship‐based.”[#37]
TheHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationreportedthatcertifiedmembersmostlyperformassubcontractors.Whenaskedhowmembersfindthissubcontractwork,hesaidthatit’susuallythroughprimecontractoroutreach.Heexplained,“Typically,whentheyaregettingreadytoputtheirpackagestogether,primesreachouttofirmsthattheyhaverelationshipswithandtalktothemaboutsubmittingabidproposaltobepartofateam.Fortherecord,theydosendcommunicationsouttoallcertifiedfirms,butthepersonal[out]reachisonlytofirmsthattheyhaverelationshipswith.”[#11]
Whenaskedifmembersprefertoworkwithsomeprimesoverothers,thesametradeassociationrepresentativesaid,“Alotofithastodowithpromptpay,costofmaterials,andavariousnumberofotherthings.”[#11]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationreportedthatmembersworkasbothprimecontractorsandsubcontractors.[#38]
![Page 500: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/500.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 73
Some business owners said they sometimes hire second‐tier subcontractors when they are
hired as a sub.[e.g.,#21a]Otherssaidtheydonot.[e.g.,#2,#20]Commentsfromthein‐depthinterviewsinclude:
Regardingsecond‐tiersubcontractors,thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemaleco‐ownerofaspecialtyservicesfirmreportedthatshewillsometimeshiresecond‐tiersubcontractors.[#8]
Whenaskedhowsheselectsthesefirms,thesamebusinessco‐ownersaidthatherfirststepistoobtainasampleandchecktheirproduct’squality.[#8]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmreportedthathiscompanydoeshiresecond‐tiersubcontractors.[#14]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringfirmreportedthatshehires“specialty”subcontractorstoperformassecond‐tiersubcontractorstoherfirm.Sheadded,“Wetypicallyfocusoncommercial,industrial,andtransit‐relateddesign,butIknowpeoplewhocan[bea]subcontractorontheportionsofworkwedon’tdo.”[#5]
Whenaskedhowsheselectsthesesecond‐tiersubcontractors,thesamebusinessownercommented,“I’mgoingtosteerbusinesstosomebodywhoisgoingtosteerbusinesstome.”[#5]
Whenaskedifhisfirmhiressecond‐tiersubcontractors,theBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andESB‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmreportedthathisfirmalwayssubsouttheinstallationservicestoothersmallbusiness.[#9]
Whenaskedhowheselectsthesesubcontractors,thesamebusinessownersaidheusuallyworkswiththosewhoseworkethicandcapabilitiesarefamiliar.Heexplained,“Becauseofwhatwedo,wehavetoknowthepeoplethataregoingtowork.So,wehavetwodifferentsubcontractorsthatweworkwith,andoneofthemwe’veworkedwithsincetheinceptionofourbusiness.Thesecondcompanyisonethatwe’vedoneworkwithoverthelasttwoyears.”[#9]
Hewentontosay,“Weworkwithalotofdifferententities,soweworkwithlandscapearchitects,developers,andcommercialpropertymanagementfirms.Andsometimes,particularlywiththecommercialpropertymanagementandthedevelopmentfirms,wemayhavesomebodywhoreallywantstouseourproduct.Theymay[askifwecan]handle[it].Hesaidthathemightinterviewafewfirmsthattheyhavedonebusinesswithandinvitethemtoworkwiththemonthatparticularproject.[#9]
TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthatheoccasionallyhiressecond‐tiersubcontractors.Heexplained,“Buildingsystemsubs,structural,mechanical,[and]electrical.Generally,it’swhenanengineeringfirmistheprimeandtheywantustodothebuilding,sowedoeverythingassociatedwiththebuilding.”[#22]
![Page 501: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/501.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 74
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedspecialtyservicesfirmreportedthattheirprocessforselectingsub‐vendorsisdrivenbywhatthecustomerwants.Hesaidthatthecompanydependsonrelationshipstofindsuppliersthatcarryspecificitemsthatcustomersmightneed[#34]
Thesamebusinessrepresentativelatersaidthattherearesub‐vendorsthattheytrytouseallthetime.Regardingthesesub‐vendors,hesaid,“Weallknowwhatneedstogetdone,andweknowthequalityoftheirproduct.”[#34]
Whenaskedifsheeverhiredsecond‐tiersubcontractors,theHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmstated,“For[one]projectIhiredanMWBEsupplierformy…products.”Whenaskedhowsheselectedthissubcontractor,shesaid,“[Iknew]themthroughthemeetingsIgoto….”[#35]
Some firms that the study team interviewed reported that they primarily work as prime
contractors/consultants or prefer prime contracting work.[e.g.,#2,#4,#7,#15a]Forexample:
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofagoodsandservicesfirmreportedthatthefirmworksexclusivelyasaprimecontractor.Heexplained,“It’sextraordinarilyrarethatwearesubcontractedoutwithsomeoneelse.Weusuallyworkdirectlywiththepeople.Thenatureoftheindustryissuchthatthereareveryspecificneedsthatpeoplehave,andeithertheydon’tknowwhattheyneedorit’snotsomethingthatcanbefarmedout.So,it’seasiertofindthepersonwhocantakecareofthethingforyouratherthangoshoppingaroundforvendors.”[#10]
TheNativeAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,SDB‐,SDVOSB‐,andHUBZone‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmstatedthathiscompanyis“allprime.”[#39]
Thefemalerepresentativeofanon‐Hispanicwhitemale‐ownedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthatherfirmpreferstobeaprimecontractor,asitinvolvesmoreclientinteractionandmoreresponsibilitytoensurethatthedeliverablesandtherequirementsoftheclientaremet.[#1b]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemaleco‐ownerofaspecialtyservicesfirmreportedthattheymainlyworkasaprimecontractor,thoughtherehavebeencaseswheretheyservedasasubcontractor.Sheaddedthattheirroledependsonthescopeoftheproject.[#8]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaconstruction‐relatedfirmreportedthatthecompanyisalmostalwaystheprimecontractoronthecontractstheypursue.Headded,“Ican’timagineaprojectsolargethatwe…wouldrequireanadditionalengineeringcompany.”Heexplained,“Engineeringcompaniesareusuallytheupfrontpiecethatdesignsthejobfromtheowner’svision.Itreallyisn’tnecessarytobringinmorethanthatinitialcompany.”Hewentontosaythattheyhaveneverusedasubcontractor,andcommented,“Wehavealltheassistanceweneedfromourownstaff.”[#25]
![Page 502: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/502.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 75
Thefemalerepresentativeofanon‐Hispanicwhitemale‐ownedprofessionalservicesfirmindicatedthatshepreferstoworkasaprimecontractor.Whenshedoesworkasasubcontractor,shesaidthereislittledifferenceworkingwithpublicsectorversusprivatesectorprimes.Shelatersaidthatprivatesectorprimesexpecthertobeamentorinadditionto“getting[her]workdone.”[#13]
TheSubcontinentAsianAmericanmaleownerofaspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthatheworksprimarilyasaprimecontractor.Headdedthathesometimeshiresothercontractorstoassisthim,asneeded,andcommented,“ItrustthecompaniesIhaveworkedwithbefore,andItrytousethemwhenIhaveabiggerjob.”Hewentontosay,“Idon’tknowifthecompaniesIusearecertified,Ijustwantsomeonethatcandothejob.”[#18]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmindicatedthatheprefersprimecontractingworkbecauseitallowsformorecontrolovertheprojectandoftenincludesfasterpayment.[#14]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmindicatedthatthefirmworksmostlyasaprimecontractor.Whenaskedhowtheyselectsubcontractors,hereportedthattheyselectthroughaqualificationprocess“tomakesurethatwhateverworktheyperform,they'requalifiedtodo[it]anddon'tgetthemselvesintrouble,or[thefirm]introuble.”Henotedthatthisprocessisthesameforbothpublicandprivatesectorwork.[#21a]
TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmindicatedthatheprefersprimecontractwork.Whenaskedhowhehiressubcontractors,hesaid,“Weselectoursubsbasedontheirknowledgeoftheprojecttype,iftheyhaveworkedwiththeclientbefore,ifthey’veworkedwithusbefore,andtheirfees.That’sthesameforprivateaswellaspublicsectorwork.”Henotedthatintheprivatesectorhedoesn’thavetoconsidergoalswhenhiringsubcontractors,whileinthepublicsectorhedoes.[#22]
Whenaskedifheusesthesamesubcontractorsonmultipleprojects,thesamebusinessownersaid,“Yes,it’sdrivenbygoodrelationships.IknowI’mgoingtogetthebestservice.[Iusethemif]theyaregoingtoberesponsive,theyaregoodsolidperformers,[and]they’renotgoingtogetmeintrouble.”[#22]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthattheyalwaysworkasaprimecontractor“ontheresidentialside,”whichaccountsformostofthefirm’swork.Regardingsubcontracting,shesaid,“Theroleofsubsonbigprojectsfor[myfield]isaprettyundesirablerolebecauseyouareveryfardownstreamintheprocess[of]workingondeadlines….You’rethelastpersonwhogetsthedrawingset.”[#12]
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“IhavemadeitapriorityforourcompanythatIwon’thavemystaffworkalldaySaturdayandSundaytomeetsomedeveloper’sgoal.Also,[that]typeofworkmeanszerocreativity.….So,wereallyshyawayfromthatsubcontractorwork.Wehavenotpursueditbecausewearemoreinterestedindoingcreativework.”She
![Page 503: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/503.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 76
added,“Ongovernmentcontractsit’sthesamething.Wehavea[DenverPublicSchools]contract,andwe’realwayslast[receivingthedrawings].”[#12]
Whenaskedifherfirmhiressubcontractors,shereportedthattheyneversuboutdesignwork,thoughtheypartnerwithothertypesoffirms.Sheadded,“Alotoftimes,we’llhavetheclienthireacivil[engineer]orsomeoneforthethingsthatwecan’tdoratherthanadministercontracts.We’reasmallcompany[and]wejusttelltheowner,‘Youknowwhat?Youneedtohirethecivilengineer.Youcanhirethemyourselves.I’lldothereportweneedorprovidetheinformation,andyoucanjustpayhimandthenwewon’tmarkhimup….’So,wedon’tputtogetherbigteams.Wehaven’thadthatexperienceyet.”[#12]
Some firms said they do not hire subcontractors.[e.g.,#34,#36]Commentsinclude:
Whenaskedifthefirmworksmainlyasaprimecontractororsubcontractor,theHispanicAmericanmaleownerofanarchitecturalengineeringfirmstated,“Weprefertocontractdirectlywiththeownerofaproject.Ifasubcontractorisneeded,wewillrecommendafirmtotheowner,buttheclienthastohirethemdirectly.Onrareoccasionswesubtoanarchitect,butwouldrathercontractdirectlywiththeowner.”[#16]
Whenaskedifheworksprimarilyasaprimecontractororsubcontractor,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaconstructionservicesfirmstated,“I’mnotinterestedinthoseroles.Iworkedforalargemechanicalcompanyandsawfirst‐handthedifficultiesbothofthoseentitieshadintryingtosatisfytheowner.Thewaymycompanyworksissomeonecallsme,Iinvestigatewhatexactlytheywantmetodo,[and]Iagreetodothejobandgetpaid.”[#31]
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“Ifthejobistoobig,occasionallyIwillaskotherindependentcontractorsiftheyareinterestedinworkingwithme.Occasionally,IwillgetacallfromanotherindependentcontractorandhewillaskmeifI’minterested.Thatarrangementworksbestformeatthisstageinmybusiness.”[#31]
TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmstated,“Wedon’tprimeorsubcontractprojects.Wearehiredtodothe[work]andwehavetheemployeestodotheentirejob.Ican’timaginewhenacompanywouldcallusinasaprimeorsubcontractor.Thetypeofworkwedoisdonebyuscompletely.”[#32a]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaconstructionfirmstated,“Iamanindependent[contractor].Idon’tworkwithprimesorsubs.WhenIneedhelponaproject,IwillcallothersthatIhavedoneworkwithonotherprojects.”[#24]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“Thefirmhasthebusinessmodelofself‐performingcontractsnow.Wedon’treallyhaveprimeandsubrelationshipsanymore.Thereareoccasionswhenwedohavetohiresubstodoaparticularpieceofajob,butthoseinstancesarereallybecomingfewerandfewer.Wehavefoundthattheself‐performingmodelallowsustobemoreincontrolofthescheduleandquality.”[#28]
![Page 504: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/504.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 77
Thesamebusinessrepresentativecontinued,“[We]don’t[anticipate]goingbacktothetraditionalprocessofactingasaprimeandfindingsubstoworkunderthecompany.Ifwedidgobacktothetraditionalmodelandfoundthatweneededsubsforcontracts,wewouldusthosewehaveusedbefore.Ibelievesomeofthemarecertified,butIdon’tknow[forsure].”Sheadded,“Wehavebeenintheconstructionbusinessforalongtime.Wehavealistofsubsthatwewouldreachouttoanddetermineiftheywouldbeinterestedintheproject.”[#28]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofanengineeringcompanyindicatedthatheworksmainlyasaprimecontractor.Hesaid,“IamaprincipleengineerontheresidentialworkIdo.Idon’tworkwithprimesorsubs.Asanengineer,Iaminchargeofmyprojects.”[#26]
TheBlackAmericanandveteranmaleownerofageneralcontractingcompanyindicatedthatheworksmainlyasaprimecontractor.Hesaid,“Iworkformyselfandgetmyowncontracts.Idon’tconsidertheindividualsandcompaniesthatworkformeassubcontractors.Weareallindependentcontractors.TheyjustdowhatIaskthemtodoandIpaythem.”[#29]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmsaidthatthefirmisneitheraprimenorasubcontractor.Heexplainedthattheysellmainlytosubcontractors,andonlytoprimes“when[we’re]told[we]haveto.”Hewentontosaythattheymainlyselltosubcontractorsbecausesubsperformthemajorityofelectricalwork.[#23a]
Whenaskedifthecompanyworksasaprimecontractororsubcontractor,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaspecialtyservicesfirmsaid,“Ourcompanydoesn’thavethosetypesofbusinessrelationships.Ourworkisbetweenacustomerandthecompany.Wehaveneverworkedinthatway,andIcan’timaginethattypeofbusinessmodelinthefutureatall[dueto]thetypeofworkwedo.”[#30]
Many business owners and representatives discussed their firms’ efforts to include MBEs,
WBEs, and other small businesses in contracts, and shared experiences working with these
firms.MostreportedsolicitingSBE/MBE/WBEsmallbusinessesforbidsorquotes.Commentsinclude:
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmreported,“We’vehiredsubstodosomeasbestosjobsthataretoolarge.Wetypicallystickwithminoritysubs,andthenweusesubsthatdon’thaveabadreputationwiththeBBBorYelp,orthingslikethat.But,it’sprimarilysmallbusinesssubsthatweuse.”[#7]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmreportedthattheydosolicitSBE/MBE/WBEsubsforbids,mainlywhentherearecontractgoals.Hesaidtheyhaverelationshipswithsomecertifiedfirms,andthatothersapproachthemforopportunities.Hewentontosaythatifthereisaneedandtheyarequalified,theywillbehired.[#21a]
![Page 505: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/505.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 78
Thesamebusinessrepresentativelaterindicatedthatthefirmdoesnotmakethesesamesolicitationsforprivatesectorwork.However,henotedthatthereareMWBEstheyuseforprivateworkduetotheirexpertise.[#21a]
Whenaskedifthefirm’sexperiencesworkingwithSBE/MBE/WBEsubsversusnon‐SBE/MBE/WBEsubsdiffer,hereportedthattheydonotbecausethefirmholdsallsubcontractorstothesamestandard.Heexplained,“Wehaveaconsistentwayofenforcingourpoliciesandprocedures,andmakingsurethattheybondtheirworkifit'sanythingover$50,000….That's[just]companypolicy.”[#21a]
TheNativeAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,SDB‐,SDVOSB‐,andHUBZone‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmsaidthatwhenhedoescontractout,hedoessowith“peopleofcolorwhen[hisfirm]can.”Headded,“Ithinkthatisimportant.”Henotedthathedoesbusinesswithsubcontractorsheknowsandhasarelationshipwith.[#39]
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“Youstillhavetocompete.Thesubstillhastobecompetitive[and]havetheirresume.JustbecausesomeoneisBlack,Hispanic,orIndiandoesn’tmeantheyaregoingtodobusinesswithme….Asubisasub.Itdoesn’tmatterwhatcolortheyare.Theyeitherdotheworkortheydon’tdothework.”Headdedthathetakesthesameapproachforhiringsubcontractorsinboththepublicsectorandprivatesector.[#39]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmreportedthatheoftensolicitsMBE/WBE/SBEfirmsforbidsandquotes.Hesaidthathehasbuiltreciprocalsubcontractorrelationshipsovermanyyears,andnotedthatheusessomeofthesamesubcontractorsforbothpublicsectorandprivatesectorwork.Forexample,hesaidthathefrequentlyusesaparticularWBE‐certifieddrillingcompanybecausetheyhaveappropriateequipment.[#14]
WhenaskedhowoftenhesolicitsSBE/MBE/WBEsubsforbids/quotes,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthathefrequentlydoes.Whenaskedhowhegoesaboutthis,hesaid,“Usuallyatnetworkingevents,andtheyalsogenerallyfindme.Theymarketthemselvestome.”[#22]
WhenaskedwhyhesolicitsSBE/MBE/WBEsubcontractors,thesamebusinessownersaidthatheisgenerallyexpectedtohelpmeetthegoalswithhissubcontractorsonpublicprojects.Hewentontoadd,“Iknowwhatit’sliketobeaDBE/MWBE/SBE.”Henotedthathehasusedthesamecertifiedsubsforbothpublicandprivatesectorwork,andthatheexperiencesnodifferenceswhenworkingwithcertifiedsubsversusnon‐certifiedsubs.[#22]
Thefemalerepresentativeofanon‐Hispanicwhitemale‐ownedprofessionalservicesfirmindicatedthatshemakeseffortstoincludeothersmallbusinessesincontracts.Shesaidit’simportantto“reachbackandhelppeoplethebestasyoucan,oratleastgivethemanopportunity.”Shewentontocomment,“Ican’tguaranteeyouajob,butIcandefinitelyguaranteeyouanopportunity.”[#13]
![Page 506: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/506.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 79
Whenaskedaboutherexperienceworkingwithminority‐andwomen‐ownedfirmsversusnon‐Hispanicwhitemale‐ownedfirms,thesamebusinessownersaid,“It’saccesstocapital.IfindthatmySBEsarewhitefirmswithmoreaccesstocapital.Theyjust[haveit].TheyhavealowerbondingratethantheMBEsthatweworkwith.”[#13]
ThesamebusinessowneraddedthattheexpenseofhiringMBE/WBEfirmsishigherthanitisfornon‐Hispanicwhitefirms.Sheadded,“They’llhavemoreopportunitiesintheprivatesectorthanmyMBEs[or]WBEs…sotheyhaveworkedmoreandknowdifferentpeople.”[#13]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofanSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaidthatthefirmusesaselectgroupofsubcontractorsthattheyarefamiliarwithindisciplineslikeelectrical,HVAC,andplumbing.Sheexplainedthatthesesubcontractorsaregenerallysmallfirms,andadded,“Intheend,itisveryprice‐generated.”Shewentontosaythattheydonotcheckcertificationsbecausetheydoverylittlepublicwork.[#15a]
WhenaskedifshesolicitsMBEs,WBEs,andothersmallsubcontractorsforquotesassecond‐tiersubs,thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringfirmsaid,“IalwaystrytohireaMWBE,[and]Ifindquitefrankly[that]Igetbetterservice.Theytakemeseriously.WhenI[try]tohirealargerfirm,I’mjustsuch[a]smallpotatotothemthatIdon’tgetservice.”[#5]
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“SometimesI’llputoutanRFP….Forinstance,recentlyIhadaprojectinNorthDenverthatmyclientwantedasoilengineer[for],soIwroteupanRFPandsentitouttothreecompaniesthatIhaddonebusinesswithbefore….[WhenI]gottheirproposalsback…itbecameveryclearwhomtohire.Anothertime,forresidentialwork,IjustwenttothepersonI[knewwas]competent.Thatwasforaprivatecontract.”[#5]
WhenaskedifshesolicitsSBE/MBE/WBEsubsforbids/quotes,theHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmreportedthatsheusedanMWBE‐certifiedcleaningsuppliescompanyonheronlypublicsectorcontract.SheaddedthatshealsousesMWBEfirmsonprivatework.WhenaskedwhyshesolicitshelpfromMWBEcompanies,shesaidit’sbecauseshe“know[s]whatit’sliketobeanMWBEcompany.”[#35]
WhenaskediftheprocessofutilizingSBE/MBE/WBEsubcontractorsdiffersfromnon‐SBE/MBE/WBEsubcontractors,thesamebusinessownersaid,“Itisthesame,[though]thereismorepaperworktouseanSBE/MBE/WBEonapublicproject.”Sheaddedthattheysometimesusethesamesubcontractorsrepeatedlybecause“[they]trusteachother.”[#35]
Thefemalerepresentativeofanon‐Hispanicwhitemale‐ownedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthatthefirmlooksforminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessestoworkassubcontractors.SheexplainedthatthefirmusesalistpublishedontheCityandCountyofDenverwebsite,butnotesthatthelistisnotoftenupdated.[#1b]
![Page 507: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/507.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 80
TheHispanicAmericanmaleownerofaspecialtycontractingfirmstatedthathisfirmdoeshireSBE/MBE/WBEsubconsultantswhenthereisarequirementinplace.Henotedthatthisdoesnothappenoften,however,astherearerarelygoalsonbidsthathisfirmpursues.Healsoaddedthatforprivate‐sectorprojects,hisfirmhasneverbeenrequiredtoseekoutsubconsultantswithspecificcertifications.[#4]
Whenaskedaboutherworkasaprimeorsubcontractor,theHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedgeneralcontractingfirmsaidthatshedoesnotspecificallytargetMBE/WBEorSBEcompanieswhenhiringsubcontractors.Shestated,“[Myfirm]doesn’tusesubsthatoften.Iamlookingforcompaniesthatcandotheworkofthescope.Ihavethesamephilosophyforpublicandprivatework.Therearenotthatmany…companies[inmyfield]outthere.Wearetryingtobuildagoodreputation.”[#19]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andESB‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmstated,“IthinkI’veworkedwithanSBE‐,WBE‐,[or]MBE‐certifiedfirmmaybeoncesofar,butthepotentialdoesexisttodo[moreof]that.”[#9]
Whenaskedabouthisfirm’seffortstoincludeminority‐andwomen‐ownedfirmsincontracts,themalerepresentativeofanon‐Hispanicwhitemale‐ownedfirmsaidmanyfirmsincludedonthelistpublishedbytheCityandCountyofDenverarenotableorinterestedindoingthework.[#1a]
WhenaskedifthefirmsolicitsSBE/MBE/WBEsforbids/quotes,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmstatedthatthefirmdoesnotsolicitbidsbecausetheyfunctionasasupplier.Therefore,headded,contractorsapproachthemforbusiness.Hewentontosaythatthefirmdoesnotaskaboutcertificationbecausethecertificationstatusoffirmstheysupplytoisirrelevanttothem.[#23a]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmreported,“Therehavenotbeenanyjobsintheprivatesectorbecausetheroadworkresponsibilitiesarehandledbymunicipalities.Asaresultofthetypeofworkwedo,thereisnoneedtosolicitSBE,MBE,[or]WBEcompanies.”[#27]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedspecialtyservicesfirmsaidthattheyarenotawareiftheirsub‐vendorsarecertifiedfirms.Hecommented,“We’veneveraskedwhoownsthebusinessoriftheywerecertified….It’sprobablysomethingweshouldaskaboutwithothervendorsweknow….”[#34]
Regardingfindingsubcontractorsinthepublicsectorversustheprivatesector,theBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmsaid,“Publicsectorsubstypicallyalreadyhaveacontractagreementwithaschooldistrictoracity,orsomethinglikethat.Theprivatesectorisprettymuchgeneralmarketing,andthere’snosetformatwithintheprivatesector.Inthepublicsector,usuallyyouhaveasetpricepointandsetstandards.”[#7]
![Page 508: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/508.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 81
Whenaskedifhisfirmusesthesamesubcontractorsinbothsectors,thesamebusinessco‐ownersaidthattheyrarelydo.Heexplained,“Onoccasionwewill,butwetypicallyusepublicsectorsubsbecausetheyunderstandtheworkenvironmentinthepublicsector.Theyunderstandwhat…whatcertificationsyoumusthave,thestandardsyoumusthave,andthingsofthatnature.”[#7]
Trade association and business assistance organization representatives also discussed member
firms’ efforts to include DBEs and other small businesses in contracts.Mostindicatedthatmembersmakeagenuineefforttoincludesuchfirms.Forexample:
WhenaskedifmemberssolicitDBEsubsforbids/quotes,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaidthattheydo.HenotedthatthefrequencyinwhichtheysolicitDBEsubsis“afunctionofhowoftentheygetcontractswiththebigprimes.”Headded,“WhentheydosolicitDBEs,theyrelyonanetworkofcohortsbecausesmallbusinessesfeelmorecomfortableworkingwithanothersmallbusiness.”HewentontosaythatmembersusingDBEsubsdosoforbothpublicandprivatesectorwork.[#33]
TheNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationreportedthatmembersdosolicitbids/quotesfromDBEsubs,andnotedthat“the[organization]isveryinvestedintheDBEprogram.”Sheadded,“[Members]willfirstdodirectsolicitations.Ifthey’renotgettingtheresponsetheywant,theywillcontactmebecausethe[organization]hasadatabasethatidentifiesmembersbykeywords.So,basedonthekeywordsIcansendouttargetedsolicitations.Ifthatdoesn’twork,theAmericanIndianProcurementTechnicalAssistanceCenterwilljumpinthereandhelpcontactDBEs.So,wehaveacouplelayersinouroutreach.”[#37]
Whenaskedwhymemberschoosetosolicitbids/quotesfromcertifiedfirms,thesamebusinessassistanceorganizationrepresentativesaid,“It’stohelpmeetthegoals.Butit’salsotohelpmembersofthe[organization]becausetheyrememberhowharditwastostartacompany.”Shealsonoted,“Forthepublicworktheyselectsubsbasedontherequirementsoftheproject,andtheycheckwhetherpotentialsubshaveeverworkedonapublicproject…[andif]theyknowtheexpectations….Intheprivatesectortheyaremoreopentogivingpeopleashot.”[#37]
Whenaskedaboutmembers’experiencesworkingwithDBEsubscomparedwithnon‐DBEsubs,shesaid,“Ifthey’reworkingwithDBEsubsonapublicproject,theyknowthosepeopleareprettyfamiliarwiththeworkprocesses.Iftheyuseanon‐DBEonapublicproject,theyask[themselves],‘Whatisthelearningcurvegoingtobe?’”[#37
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationreportedthatmembersworkingasprimecontractorsfindothersmallbusinessestoteamwithbyattendingnetworkingevents.Sheadded,“Wehavemeetingsallthetime.That’soneofthebenefitsofbelongingtoanorganizationlikeours.You’repartofamembership,andnetworkingopportunitiesareavailablewiththepeoplethatyouwanttoteamwith,thatgoaftertheworkthatyou’reinterestedin,whetherit’sCDOTorwhetherit’stheCityandCountyofDenver.”[#38]
![Page 509: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/509.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 82
ThesametradeassociationrepresentativelaternotedthatitcanbedifficultformemberstofindDBEsubcontractorsspecifically.Shesaid,“[Members]needtohavethem.Theyneedtomeetthegoals,sothey’relookingforthemandthenumberisshrinking.IhaveanumberofMWBEsthathavebeensoldtolargecompanies.”Shecontinued,“We’vegotalotofcertifiedfirms,buttheymaynotbeenoughinallthedifferentdisciplinestogetagoodpoolofpeoplegoingafterthatwork.Andbecausethere’ssomuchworkoutthere,youwouldevenhaveless.”[#38]
ShewentontosaythatmanylargeprimesmeetDBEgoalsbyusinggeotechnicalfirms,becausetheprimesdonotprovidethoseservices.Sheadded,“Youknow[that]whentheyhavetomeetthegoal,that’showthey’regoingtodoit.[However],someofthose[geotechnicalfirms]havegrownquitewellovertheyears,andoneinparticularhasalreadygraduated.Asecondonewillgraduate[inthe]nextfewyears.”[#38]
Whenaskedwhatmembers’experienceshavebeenworkingwithDBEsubsversusnon‐DBEsubs,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthatmembersfirstlookforfirmsthatarecapableofthework.Heexplained,“Iftheyfindafirmthat’scompetent,theyhavetobecarefulorthey’lljustworkthemrightoutofbusiness.Becausethey’resogood,they’llgivethemalltheworktheyhave,andthey[may]givethemmorethantheycanhandle….They’llgrowthemoutoftheprogram.”[#40]
TheBlackAmericanfemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidtherelationalandtrustaspectofselectingsubsissimilarinbothsectors,thoughcertifiedbusinesseshaveasomewhatdifferentapproachinthepublicsectorbecausetheywanttogiveopportunitiestoothersmallandminority‐ownedbusinesses.Shesaid,“Ithinkthefirstpersonthey’relookingforissomebodyjustlikethem,somebodywhoisalsocertified,maybeanunderutilizedfirm[that]canuseanopportunity.That’snotnecessarilythefirstgo‐toforprimes.”[#6]
Thesametradeassociationrepresentativeaddedthatthisefforttochooseandworkwithotherminorityandunderutilizedfirmsistomaintainthelevelofparticipationthattheythemselvesbringtotheproject.Sheadded,“Iftheysubouttoanon‐DBE,[it]diminishestheamountofparticipationthattheprimeisgoingtoget.Anotherfactoristhefactthatmentor‐protégésandjointventuringisbeingpromotedmoreso[recently].Finally,Ithinkthe…mentalityofpayingitforwardanddoingthesameforothersisagrowing[trend].”ShelaternotedthatmemberssolicitDBEbidsbygoingthroughtheDBE/MWBEdirectories.[#6]
Whenaskedaboutmembers’experiencesworkingwithDBEsubscomparedtonon‐DBEsubs,shesaidthatmemberexperiencesvary.Sheadded,“BeingaDBEandengagingorsubbingouttoaDBEandgettingtheopportunitytodothepaperworkfromadifferentperspectiveandreviewitcanbehelpful.Theyknowwhattoexpect[regardingpaperwork].Asfarassubbingouttoanon‐DBEexcessively,it’sgoingtobeaprojectthat’shighlyspecialized…orafirmthatcanhelpbolstertheDBE’sstatus.So,ifI’maDBEandI’msubbingsomeworkouttoa[non‐DBE]…thathasaparticularlooktoittoo.”[#6]
![Page 510: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/510.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 83
A few business owners said that certifications are irrelevant when soliciting other contractors.Forexample:
WhenaskedifhesolicitsSBE/MBE/WBEfirms,theBlackAmericanandveteranmaleownerofageneralcontractingcompanyreportedthatallofhisworkisintheprivatesectorandthatcertificationsdonotmattertohim.Heexplained,“Idon’tworkonpublicjobs,[so]Idon’tknowifanyoftheothercontractorsIusehavethosecertifications.IjustusethepeoplethatIknowthatcandothework.IfIdon’tlikethewaysomeonedoesaprojectthatI’vehiredthemtodo,Iwon’tusethemagain.”[#29]
Whenaskedifheusesthesamecontractorsallthetime,thesamebusinessownersaid,“Ofcourse….Idon’tgoouttryingtofindotherstodotheworkwhenIknowwhatI’mgettingwiththecontractorsIhaveusedbefore.”[#29]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofagoodsandservicesfirmreportedthatthefirmdoesnotmakedistinctionsaboutwhotheyaregoingtoworkwithbasedongender,race,ethnicity,orcertificationstatus.Hestated,“We’veworkedacrossthespectrum.Theindustryispredominantly…whitemale‐ownedcompanies,butthereareanumberof[other]peoplethatwedoworkwith.”[#10]
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“Oneofthem,forinstance,isownedbyawomaninSeattle,Washington.She’soneofourfavoriteclientsactually.[But]dowedistinguish?Notsomuch.It’srarethatthatevercomesupasafactor.Butitis[also]raretohaveanythingbutthatmaindemographicjustbecausethat’showtheindustryisbrokendown.”[#10]
One business owner described her experiences working with MBEs as positive, and described
such experiences as mentorship opportunities.TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmsaidthatshelikestomentorMBEsandhelpthemfigureouthowtobettertheirbusiness.Sheadded,“Asfarasanon‐minorityornon‐certifiedcompany,Ithinktheyhavetheresourcesandknowledge[necessary]andit’sdifferent[forthem],butIdon’tfeelit’sinanywaydiscriminatory,orharder,forthenon‐minorityfirmsthantheminoritytogettheexperience,training,andcertificationstheyneed.”[#2]
Other businesses reported preferring subcontracting opportunities, being limited to
subcontract‐based work or having difficulty breaking into the prime contracting arena.[e.g.,#19]Commentsinclude:
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringfirmreportedthatherfirmneverworksasaprimeoncityorcountyprojects.Whenaskedwhy,shecommented,“Wedon’treallyhaveprojectmanagementinourskillset,andweprovideonething,whichisstructuralengineering.”ShelatercommentedthatshehasneverworkedwithanMBE/WBE/SBEprimecontractor.[#5]
Whenaskedhowshemarketsherfirmtoprimes,thesamebusinessownersaidthatshereviewsplanholderslistsandthenmarketsbysendinganemailorcallingthemandsettingupameeting.Shealsonotedthatshenetworkswithprofessionalorganizations.[#5]
![Page 511: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/511.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 84
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaprofessionalservicesfirmnotedthatalthoughhisfirmworksmainlyasaprimecontractor,thereareadvantagesworkingasasubcontractor.Heexplained,"Whatwereallyliketodoistheengineering,andtheothercompany[can]beresponsibleformanagementoftheproject."[#3]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andESB‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmreportedthathisfirmhasneverworkedasaprimecontractor.Headded,“We’vealwaysbeenasuborasupplier,oraninstaller.”Hesaidthathegetssubcontractworkthrougheitherapreexistingrelationshiporwhenaspecialtyproductisneeded.Heexplained,“Inthecaseof[a]propertymanagementfirm,theymaycallusandsay,‘Hey,weneed10[specialtyproducts],’or‘Oh,bytheway,canyouinstallthese?’”[#9]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmreportedthatthefirmonlyperformsasasubcontractor.Whenaskedwhy,shesaidthatthattheyare“toosmall”todoprimecontractwork.[#35]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmreportedthatherfirmalwaysoperatesasasubcontractorbecauseofthetypeofworktheydo.Shesaid,“Wearealwaysthesubcontractor,justbythenatureofwhatwedo.Wearehiredbyaprimetohandlethatportionoftheircontract.”[#27]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmstated,“Ionlydosubcontractingwork.Idon’thavethecapacity,bonding,insurance,[or]lineofcredittodoprimeworkbecausetheprojectsaretoolarge.Ialsoneverhiresubcontractors.”[#20]
A trade association representative commented that most members are limited to subcontract
work because they lack the capacity and bonding ability to prime.TheBlackAmericanfemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationreportedthatmostmembersworkassubcontractorsratherthanprimes.However,shenoted,“Wehavehadanincreaseintheamountof[prime]opportunities.”ShewentontosaythatCDOTis“lookingatprojectsforthelatterhalfoftheyearwhereDBEsorESBEswillbeabletoprimeon…projectsforthefirsttimeever,”andcommented,“Thatwasahugewinforus….”[#6]
Whenaskedwhymostmemberfirmsaresubcontractorsratherthanprimes,thesametradeassociationrepresentativesaidthatmostmembersare“stillbuildingcapacity,”andarelimitedtosubcontractwork“duetobondingrequirementsandcapacityrequirements.”[#6]
A business assistance organization representative reported that most members are limited to
subcontract work.TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationstatedthatmostmembersworkassubcontractorsbecausetheylackthecapacitytoperformasprimecontractors.Whenaskedifprimesthatusemembersonpublicsectorworkalsousethemonprivatesectorwork,hesaidthattheydo.[#33]
Whenaskedhowmembersidentifyprimecontractorstoworkwith,hesaidthatmembersdoingpublicworkgotooutreacheventstolearnaboutprojectsandmeetkeycontractors.Headded
![Page 512: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/512.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 85
thatmembersalsogotobidopenings,andthatsomeareverysuccessfulatsecuringpublicwork.[#33]
Some interviewees discussed how working with MBEs, WBEs, and other small businesses
compare to working with non‐certified firms.AfewindicatedthatworkingwithSBE/MBE/WBEprimecontractorshasbenefits.Commentsinclude:
Thenon‐HispanicwhitemaleownerofaprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthathecannotdifferentiatebetweenSBE/MBE/WBEandnon‐SBE/MBE/WBEprimecontractorsorsubcontractors.[#3]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleownerofaspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthatbasedonhisexperience,SBE/MBE/WBEprimecontractorstendtobemoreorganizedthannon‐certifiedprimes.Hestated,“Badmoneymanagementtypicallyendsupbeingthebiggestissuewithnon‐certifiedprimes,whichtricklesdowntoalotofotherissues.Ithinkthey'renotheldtoanystandard,sotheygooffoftheirhip.”[#4]
Describinghisexperiences,theBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE/MBE/WBE/SBE/ESB‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmsaid,“MyexperienceworkingwithSBE,MBE,[and]WBEfirmshasbeencloudedbythefactthat,foralotoftheprojectsthathavebeengoingonprobablyforthelast,I’dsay,sixorsevenyears,we’vegonetotheoutreachmeetings,we’veprovidedlinecards,weprovidedconversationsaboutourcapabilitiesandwhatwe[can]do,[but]wehavebeenunsuccessfulinwinninganyofthosebids….Andinoneparticularinstance,ourcategoryofproductwasactuallyawardedtoadrywallcontractorbyanSBEprime.”[#9]
Whenaskedaboutherexperiencesworkingwithcertifiedprimes,theHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaid,“IthinkIhaveonlyworkedwithoneSBE/MBE/WBEprime,andthatwasdoingfinalcleanona[project]inBoulder.Ihavejustgottentoknowthemandhopetoworkwiththemonotherjobs.”[#35]
Whenaskedtodescribethefirm’sexperienceworkingwithcertifiedprimescomparedwithnon‐certifiedprimes,thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthatherfirmisonateamwithanMBEprimeintheproposalphase,sotheyhaveyettocompleteanyworkwiththem.Shesaidthatthusfarshehasnotobservedanydifferences.[#12]
A few business assistance organization representatives discussed members’ experiences
working with DBEs and other small businesses.Commentsinclude:
Whenaskedaboutmembers’experiencesworkingwithDBEprimesversusnon‐DBEprimes,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationstatedthatbecauseDBEprimesaresmaller,“nimbler,”andrequirelesspaperwork,thereisanadvantagetoworkingwiththem.Headdedthatthereis“lessoverheadandbureaucracy”aswell.[#33]
![Page 513: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/513.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 86
Whenaskedaboutmembers’experiencesworkingwithDBEprimesversusnon‐DBEprimes,theNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaid,“IftheyworkwithaNativeAmerican‐ownedprime,Ithinktheprimehasalittlemorepatiencebecausetheywanttogetthemtothepointofsuccess.Theywillsometimesevenprovideadditionalresourcestohelpthemgetwheretheyneedtogo,becausetheyaremoreinvestedinNativeAmericancompanies.”[#37]
Challenges for small and minority‐ and women‐owned businesses when seeking work as prime contractors/consultants.Businessownersdescribedtheirexperiencesandanychallengestheyfacedwhenseekingprimecontracting/consultingopportunities.
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“Thereisnoopportunity,inmyopinion,withinthediversityprogramforminority‐ownedfirmstogetprimework.What[minoritysubcontractors]bidoutisscopedsolargethatafirmofourswouldn’tbequalifiedtodothat.Therearedefinitelywayssomeprojectscouldbebrokendownintosmallerprojectssothattheycouldbringinfirmsthatdon’thavecapacitytodo$3millionwork.”[#12]
Apublicmeetingparticipantsaid,“Todayit’shardertobeaminoritywoman‐ownedbusinessthaneverintheCityandCountyofDenver.Idon’tevenknowhowsmallbusinessesdoit.IlookatthewayIstarted,andthehoopsandthewallsandtheobstaclesthatasmallbusiness[has]toputupwithtodaytoactuallybefunctional,[and]it’salmostimpossible.Imean,Icouldnotdoitagain….”[PT#4]
Thesamepublicmeetingparticipantcontinued,“Anotherchallengethatsmallerbusinesseshaveis[thatif]youhaveafirmthatsells$200,000[or]$100,000intotalrevenue,howdoyouputthatbusinesstocompetewithafirmthatfallsinthesamecategorythatsells$10million[or]$12millionayear?Itdoesnotmakesense.”[PT#4]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmsaid,“Therearelargerfirmsthatalwayshaveaconnectiontogetrightinonabid,andyoufindyourselffightinganuphillbattle.Evenonceyougetin,thebidclosedortheyalreadyhaveasmallgroupthey’regoingtoselectfrom.So,ifyoudon’tknowanyoneyou’remostlikelynotgoingtogetachancetobid.”[#7]
One trade association representative commented that a “catch‐22” prevents new and small
firms from bidding as a prime on public agency contracts.TheHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthatexperiencerequirementspreventthesefirmsfrombiddingonsomeprojects,saying,“Wellifyou'veneverdoneschoolconstruction,youdonotgettocheckthatbox.[And]ifyoudonotcheckthatbox,youdonotgetmovedtothenextlevel.[Somepublicagencies]continuetousethesamefolksallthetimebecausetheyaretheonlyoneswhohaveexperience.”[#11]
Some mentioned barriers including a preference on some jobs for large primes with greater
resources, prompt payment issues, and other challenges. [e.g.,#12,#15b,#35,WT#3]Forexample:
![Page 514: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/514.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 87
TheNativeAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,SDB‐,SDVOSB‐,andHUBZone‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmsaidthatinhisindustrytherearesometimesconsequencesforbuyersthatdeviatefromnormsandbuyfromsmallmanufacturers,particularlyifproblemsarise.Heexplainedthatthereisaperceptionwithincorporationsthatfewerproblemsarisewhenworkingwithlarger,moreestablishedcompanies.[#39]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaid,“Becausemycompanyisverysmall,findingaprojectinthepublicsectorthatissmallenoughformeisdifficult.”[#35]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andESB‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmsaidthathethinkshisfirmissometimesdismissedbecausetheyareasmallerfirm.Headded,“Wedon’thavethebrandnamelikeoneofthebigthree[competitor]companies.Iwouldsaythatthe[products]wedooffercompetesquitefavorablywiththebigguys.”[#9]
Regarding“oncall”contracts,thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaWBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“I’minvitedtoparticipateonan‘oncall’contractasasubconsultant[and]Ihavetosignaformcalledletterofintent.And…Igetthoseblank,soIhavenowayofevertracking…whattheirprojectedparticipationofmyfirmisorhowmyfirmisgoingtocontributetothegoalthathasbeenset….ButIdon’thaveany[information].Idon’tknowifit’sonepercent.Idon’tknowifit’shalf[a]percent.”[PT#3c]
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“Theyhavetomeetagoal,butthey'renotgonnatellmewhatpercent.Ifthegoalis10percent,they'renotgonnatellme.”Sheadded,“Ihavenowayofknowingwhat[thepercent]is,andthere'sthisreallycrazyexpectationthatI’mjustgonnasign[theforms].Imean…I’vebeendoingit[though].Isigntheblankforms.”[PT#3c]
Asurveyrespondentsaid,“[It’s]difficulttogetinthemixofbigmunicipalworkwhenlargerfirmshavedoneamillionof[thoseprojects].”[AS#36]
Apublicmeetingparticipantsaid,“AreallybigproblemthatIsee[is]letterofintent,whichsaysthatwe’regoingtoprovidethisamountofmoneyforthistypeofopportunitytominoritybusinesses….Ithinkwhathappensisthattheletter[s]ofintentaren’tbeingmetinallcases.I’mnotsayingeveryoneofthe,butnotinallcases.Now,theDSBOwillsaythere’sbeenagoodfaitheffort.”[PT#4]
A trade association representative said that high overhead costs make it difficult for small
engineering firms to be competitive.TheHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthatrelationship‐buildingiswhatmakesfirmsmostcompetitiveinconstruction‐relatedindustries.However,henotedthatsmallengineeringfirmsareatadisadvantageincompetingwithlargerfirmsbecauseofoverheadcosts.Hestated,“Theproblemwithengineeringis[that]asmall,certifiedengineeringfirmcan’tcompetewiththelargerguysonmostprojects.Foraschooltheycancompetewiththem,buttheoverheadcostiswhatprohibitsthemfrombeingtrulycompetitivebecausetheyaresmaller.”[#11]
![Page 515: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/515.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 88
A few business owners and representatives described “on‐call” contracts as barriers
preventing small businesses from working as prime contractors.Commentsinclude:
TheHispanicAmericanfemalerepresentativeofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid“on‐call”contractsisabarrierforherfirm.Sheexplained,“[It’s]awaytocircumventeverythingwe’repayingforasataxpayerinallthesesmallbusinesses….‘Oncall’contractshavenogoals,norepresentativeorder101,absolutelynoaccesstoparticipation.”[PT#3b]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“[CityandCountyofDenver]haveon‐callcontracts.So,whenasmall,littlepieceof[work]needstogetdone,theyhavefiveon‐call[firms]thatworkforthem,firmsthatcandecidewhat12shrubsneedtogointhisbed.”Shecontinued,“Itwouldbeperfecttosetasidethreeofthoseon‐callcontractsforfirmsthathadn’tworkedfortheCityofDenverbefore….”[#12]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“On‐callcontractsareoftenusedasaworkaroundforcitystaffwhowanttoavoidtheeffortofputtingprojectsouttobid.Indoingso,opportunitiesarelostforSBE/MWBE/DBEfirms.Theselectingandawardingofindividualon‐callprojectsisnotopenforpublicreview.”[WT#3]
TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“Therehavenotbeenmanyprojectsthathavebeenissuedfromthedefinedpoolforarchitectstoprime.IbelievethisisbecauseDenverhason‐callarchitecturalservicecontractsthattheyusetodosmallprojects.”[WT#2]
Some interviewees reported that they try to avoid working with some subcontractors.Forexample:
Whenaskediftherearesubcontractorsthathewillnotworkwith,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmstated,“Theone[subcontractor]Iwillneverworkwithagainwillremainanonymous.Idon’tthinkithasanythingtodowiththeMWBEclassification,it’smoreaboutthe[contractor’s]personality.[Theywere]verydifficulttoworkwith.”[#22]
Themalerepresentativeofanon‐Hispanicwhitemale‐ownedprofessionalservicesfirmsaidtherearesubcontractorshisfirmwillnotworkwith,butdidnotspecifybetweenminority‐orwoman‐ownedsubsversusothersubs.Hesaidrelationshipsandpasthistoryareveryimportanttohisfirm.Headdedthatcollaborativerelationshipsarecritical,andnotedthatforcingthoserelationshipsforotherreasonscanhindertheprogressofaproject.[#1a]
Regardingsubcontractorsthathiscompanychoosesnottoworkwith,theHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmsaidthattherearesomedrillingcompaniesthathisfirmwillnotworkwithbecausetheydonothavetherighttypeofequipmentforhisindustry.Hewentontoindicatethathe
![Page 516: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/516.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 89
rarelyworkswithsubcontractorsfocusedinresidentialwork.Hesaidthatmanyofthesesubcontractorsarenotawareofpublicsectorrequirementsforroadandbridgework.[#14]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthattherearesubshisfirmwillnotworkwithbecausetheyeitherhaveunethicalbusinesspracticesorareconsideredunreliable.[#7]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmreportedthattherearesubcontractorsthattheywillnotworkwith.Heexplained,“It’smorealongourgeneralbusinesspracticesregardingcreditreferencesandcreditterms.”[#23a]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmreportedthattherearesubcontractorsthefirmwillnotworkwith,“primarilybecausetheydon'thavetheabilitytodothejob.”Headded,“It'sallbasedon[qualifications],andtheyareprettyconsistentthroughoutthecompany.”[#21a]
TheNativeAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,SDB‐,SDVOSB‐,andHUBZone‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmstated,“IfIfeeltheyarenotqualified,Iamnotgoingtoworkwiththem.I’vedoneworkonthereservationbeforefora…project,andItrytomakesureIhaveapersonofcolorworkingthatbecauseIthinktherewillbelessconflict,orupsanddowns.ButI’vealsousedCaucasians,[so]it’snotnecessarilythecolor.”Headdedthat“Caucasians”sometimeshavetoearnthetrustoftribes.[#39]
A trade association representative indicated that members’ relationships with hired
subcontractors have improved in recent years.Whenaskediftherearesubsthatmemberswillnotworkwith,theBlackAmericanfemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaid,“Yearsago,IwouldhearmoreofthatthanI’mhearingnow.Ithinkwiththeincreaseofsupport[and]servicesthathavebeenoffered,thisdoesn’thappenasmuchasitusedto.”[#6]
One interviewee reported facing challenges finding qualified subcontractors when the need
arose.Thefemalerepresentativeofanon‐Hispanicwhitemale‐ownedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthatononeoccasionthefirmhiredasmallminority‐ownedbusinessasasubcontractor,butfoundthebusinesswastoosmallandunqualifiedforthework.Shewentontonotethatitisdifficultforherfirmtosubcontractoutforprojectsinthepublicsector.Sheexplainedthatthediversityrequirementsdonotaccountforhowmanyfirmsareactuallycapableofdoingtheworkspecifictotheprojects.Therefore,shenoteditischallengingtomeetthediversityrequirementsandensurethattheprojectsaredonebythosewithrelevantexperience.[#1b]
Thesamebusinessrepresentativeadded,“We[hadbeen]toldinpreviouscontractsthatwedidn’tgetitbecauseourdiversityplanwasn’tstrongenoughandweonlyincludedonespecificfirmandgavethemalargerole.Andtheysaidtheywantedustoincludefivefirmsandgivelotsofpeopleroles.”ShealsomentionedthatthefirmsubcontractedouttoafirminDallasbecausenominority‐orwomen‐ownedfirmswerequalified,andthefirmneededtomeetthetechnical
![Page 517: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/517.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 90
minorityrequirements.Sheexplained,“You’rehurtingbusinessesinthecitybecauseofthatrequirement.Nowwe’regoingoutofstate.”[#1b]
Challenges for small and minority‐ and women‐owned businesses when seeking work as subcontractors.Businessownersandrepresentativesdescribedtheirexperiencesandanychallengestheyfacedwhenseekingsubcontractingopportunities.
Themalerepresentativeofanon‐Hispanicwhitemale‐ownedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“Whenyouhaveparticipationrequirementsforsmallbusinessrequirements,thentheeasiestthingfortheprimefirmistonotimpacttheirworkload.Thenwearealwaysinthepositionofhowtocompetewithsmallerorminority‐orwomen‐ownedbusinesses.Theprimefirmsdon’twanttodecreasetheirwork,andsoit’seasierforthemtojustsay,‘We’regoingtohavetheengineeringdonebyasmallbusiness.’”[#1a]
Thefemalerepresentativeofaminority‐andwomen‐ownedbusinessstatedthatlargeprimesoftenargueforlowerparticipationgoalsthanthosesetbyMayorHancock.Shesaid,"Theyadvocatethisgoalandsay,well,there’snocapacity….Howcansomeonetellmewhatmytopcapacityisthatdoesn’tevenknowme,mycompany,myemployees,ourgrowthstrategy?"Shecommentedthatthisbehaviorisabarriertominority‐andwomen‐ownedbusinessesattemptingtogrow.[PT#1b]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmsaiditcanbedifficultforminoritiestogetlinesofcredittopurchaseequipmentforsubcontractjobs.Shenotedthatstripingrequiresexpensiveequipment,andadded,“Therearevarious…companieswhoarenon‐minorityandhaveallthisequipment,andthereareveryfewminoritycompaniesinthatworkcode.So,it’salotmoredifficultforthemtogettothatpointwhenthey’restartingbecausethisequipmentissoexpensive.Theexperienceisthere,it’sjustamatteroffindingtherightpieceofequipmenttohelpthemout.”[#2]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andESB‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmreportedthatsometimeshewillresupplypotentialprimeswiththeinformationtheyrequest,thoughit’s“exhausting”tosubmitinformationagain.Hecommented,“I’vedonethisfivetimeswiththisparticularprimeandIdidn’tgetselectedthepreviousfourtimes,sowhyshouldIredothis?Chancesarewe’renotgoingtogetanythingoutofit.”[#9]
TheHispanicAmericanfemalerepresentativeofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“Therearebarriersinaccesstoallprimes.It’sabarrier….[Aprime]whohas[a]$173millioncontractattheairport[meets]theirDBEgoalswiththesamevendor[and]withcheaplaborat$8.50anhour.That’swhattheypaythedriversinthevans,andtheypaylessforthepeoplethatpushthewheelchairs.”[PT#3b]
Thesamebusinessrepresentativecontinued,“Wecannotoperatewith,norwouldweoperateunderthattypeofsituationinourcommunitiestoofferthosetypeofwages.Wewouldn’tbeleftstanding.Thoseindividualsthataremakingthosewages…areEthiopians.Ifthat’snotaformofculturalandethnicoppression,Idon’tknowwhatis….[Theselargeprimes]tellustheseindividualscanliveontips[andthat]they'reallowedtotaketips.It’sa
![Page 518: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/518.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 91
barrierforcompetitivewagesandourabilitytoanswerRFPs.It’sawayforgiganticcorporationstoundermineourdollars,ourbids,[and]ournumbers.”[PT#3b]
TheBlackAmericanfemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthatoneofthebiggestchallengesforminority‐andwomen‐ownedfirmsisfiguringouthowtomakepointsofcontactwithprimes,andknowinghowto“getin.”Sheexplained,“Therearesomanydifferentgroupsoutthere.Itcanbedifficultforthemtoknowwhotoalignthemselveswithand[how]tofindopportunitiestobuildrelationships,andrapport,withdifferentprimes.”[#6]
Thesametradeassociationrepresentativecontinued,“Knowingthedifferentnuancesandbuildingrelationshipswithavarietyofteamscanbedifficult,[especially]becausealotofsmallbusinessescan’ttaketimeawayfromtheir[firms]toattendallthesedifferentevents.It’slikedarnedifyoudo,darnedifyoudon’t….Theydon’thavethelevelofsupportofalargerbusinessorabackoffice,soitcanbeacatch‐22.”[#6]
Whenaskedhowhisfirmfindsoutaboutsubcontractingwork,theBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmsaid,“We’llknowofajoborthey’llcontactusthroughmyco‐ownerormyself,andthenwe’llsubmitabidtothemforustodotheworkviaXactimate,whichisthesystemweuse.”[#7]
Whenaskedifhisfirmpreferstoworkwithsomeprimecontractorsoverothers,thesamebusinessco‐ownersaidthatthereare.Headded,“Weliketousethembecauseoftheirlevelofworkanddetail,andbecausetheydowhattheysaythey’regoingtodowhentheysaythey’regoingtodoit.”[#7]
Apublicmeetingparticipantsaid“ittakesalotmorecapitaltoworkoutattheairport”forminorityandwomenbusinessowners.[PT#4]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofanSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaidthatthecompanyrelieson“wordofmouth”tosecuresubcontractingwork.Shesaidthatthefirmisrarelyaskedtobeondesign‐buildteams,andadded,“Itisusuallywordofmouth.Acontractorwillcallandindicatetheyarepursuingaproject,theninquirewhetherweareinterestedortoobusy.”[#15a]
One trade association representative discussed small businesses’ lack of resources as a barrier
to securing work.Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthatsmallbusinessescanbeatadisadvantagebecauseoftheirlackofresourceswhentryingtogetonprojects.Heexplained,“Thebigbusinesseshavededicatedbusinessdevelopmentpeople.Thesearepeoplethatknowhowtobuild,buttheyalsohavesalesskillsandthey’regoingoutforthespecialtycontractorsandcallingonthe[big]generalcontractors.So,thatisahugedisadvantageforsmallbusinessesbecausetheydon’thave[those]level[s]ofresourcesorsophisticationasalargecompany,andonepersoniswearingallthehats…doingfinanceandestimating,andrunningthefieldoperations.”[#40]
Some interviewees reported that they try to avoid working with some prime contractors.Forexample:
![Page 519: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/519.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 92
Themalerepresentativeofanon‐Hispanicwhitemale‐ownedprofessionalservicesfirmsaidtherearesomeprimeshisfirmrefusestoworkwith.Heexplained,“Therearesomefirmsthatareextremelydifficulttoworkwith….Iftheprimedoesn’tkeeptheprojectundercontrol,theneverybodycanbespendingalotoftimeandmoneyonthingsthattheyshouldn’tbespendingtimeandmoneyon,andthosewon’tbesuccessfulprojects,financially,toanybodyworkingonthem.”[#1a]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthattherearesomeprimecontractorshisfirmtriestoavoidworkingwith.Heexplained,“Someofthemhaveunethicalbusinesspractices,andsomearelateallthetimeandtheiremployeesareprettyinconsistentinthelevelofservicetheygive.Sometimeswehaveissueswithpayment,too.”[#7]
Whenaskediftherearesomeprimecontractorsthathewon’tworkwith,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmstated,“Yes,therearesomewhoarenotveryethical.Theymakeitdifficult.They’renotresponsivetoourneeds.Theyhaveacorporatementality[and]arenotprofessional.”[#22]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaprofessionalservicesfirmstatedthatinresponsetoabadexperiencewithaprimehe"wouldjustbeasdiplomaticas[he]couldbynotteamingupwiththemagain."[#3]
Whenaskedifthereareprimecontractorsshepreferstonottoworkwith,theBlackAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaidthereisaprominentgeneralcontractorsheworkedforpreviouslywithquestionablebusinesspracticesconcerningfieldchangeorders.Shesaidthegeneralcontractorallowedchangeorderstoaccumulateandavoidedmeetingstodiscussmatters,andoftendisputedthepriceafterherfirmcompletedthework.[#13]
Thesamebusinessownersaidherfirmacceptedadiscountedsettlementafteralmostayearofnegotiatingwiththegeneralcontractor.ShestatedthattheDSBOwashelpful,however,andconcludedthatherfirmandthegeneralcontractordidnot“mixwelltogether.”[#13]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmreportedthattherearenoprimecontractorsthathisfirmavoids.Henotedthathisfirmiscurrentlybuildingrelationshipswithnewprimes,andthathisfirmrecentlysecuredworkwithoneofthem.[#14]
ThesamebusinessowneraddedthatthereareveryfewSBE,MBE,orWBEprimesinhissegmentoftheindustrybecausetheprojectsaresolarge.Heexplainedthatthereareseveralcontractsinthebillion‐dollarrangeandthattherearenoSBE,MBE,orWBEprimeswiththecapacitytodothoseprojects.[#14]
Whenaskedifthereareprimeorsubcontractorsthatherfirmchoosesnottoworkwith,theHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedgeneralcontractingfirmsaid,“I’vedevelopedgoodrelationshipswiththem,andalotofmy
![Page 520: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/520.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 93
businessisrepeatbusiness.However,thereisoneprimeIwillnotworkwithagain.IhavetoldthemthatandI’drathernotsaywhothisis,buttheygetalotofwork.Ijustdon’tliketheirbusinesspracticesorbusinessethics,andIwon’tcompromiseminetoworkwiththem.”[#19]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmindicatedthatshewillnotworkwithsomeprimesbecausesheisn’tyet“prepared”todoso.Shesaid,“Onecompanythatwasmentoringmetookmealongtoameetingwith[anationalcontractor],andIlearneditwasgoodIdidn’thaveacontractwiththem.”Sheexplained,“Ilistenedtoeverythingthatwasinthecontract[suchas]safety,andthisandthat,andIsawwhatallthebigcompaniesexpect.IsawIwasn’tpreparedyet.Itwasagoodlesson.”[#35]
Some trade association and business assistance organization representatives commented on
members’ preferences to work with certain prime contractors.
Whenaskedifmemberstrytoavoidworkingwithcertainprimecontractors,theBlackAmericanfemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationindicatedthattheysometimesdo.Shesaidthatsomemembershavetalkedaboutprimesthatarechallengingtoworkwith.[#6]
Whenaskedifthereareprimesthatmemberswon’tworkwith,theNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaid,“Asfarasconstructiongoes,Ican’tthinkofany.WithlargecorporationstherearesomethathavetakenpoliticalpositionsthatgoagainstthevaluesofIndiancountry,andpeopledon’twanttoworkwiththem.”Sheaddedthatmembersprefertoworkwithprimecontractorsthat“givebacktothecommunity.”[#37]
E. Potential Barriers to Doing Business in Denver
Inadditiontobarrierssuchasaccesstocapital,bonding,andinsurancethatmaylimitfirms’abilitytoworkwithpublicagencies,intervieweesdiscussedotherissuesrelatedtoworkingforpublicagencies.Topicsincluded:
Learningaboutpublicsectoropportunitiesasaprimeorasubcontractor;
Opportunitiestomarketthefirm;
Accesstocapitalandobtainingfinancing;
Bondingrequirementsandobtainingbonds;
Insurancerequirementsandobtaininginsurance;
Prequalificationrequirements;
Licensingandpermits;
Sizeandspanofcontracts;
Anyunnecessarilyrestrictivecontractspecifications;
![Page 521: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/521.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 94
Prevailingwage,projectlaboragreements,oranyrequirementstouseunionworkers;
Biddingprocesses;and
Timelypaymentbytheagencyorprime.
Learning about public sector opportunities as a prime or a subcontractor. Businessownersandrepresentativesreportedchallengestolearningaboutavailableworkinthepublicsector.Forexample:
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaspecialtyservicesfirmsaid,“IhavetriedtocontacttheCityofDenver,[but]itisimpossibletofindtherightpersontotalkto.Iknowthattheyuse[myproducts]formanyoftheirdepartmentsandagencies,[but]wheneverIhavecalledIgettherunaround.Someonetakesamessage,but[I]never[get]areturncall.”[#30]
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“Ihaven’tfiguredoutifit’sprocurementoranotherdepartment,butsomeoneis[usingmyproducts].I’msureiftheydoitin‐houseit’smoreexpensivethanwewouldquotethem.I’veevenaskedthepeoplefromthestateiftheyhaveacontactIcancall,andtheycan’ttellmeacontactpersoneither.”[#30]
Whenaskedifitiseasyordifficulttofindoutaboutpublicsectorworkopportunities,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedspecialtyservicesfirmsaid,“Publicagenciesareallmoreofachallengethanprivatecompaniesbecauseit’shardertofindoutwhotherightcontactis.”[#34]
Whenaskedhowthefirmlearnsaboutworkopportunities,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmstated,“WesubscribetoBidNet.TheofficealsochecksallthewebsitesweeklytoseewhatRFPsandRFQsareoutthere.Thewebsitesalsolistplanholders,soifweareinterestedwecanreachouttothosepeople.Theotherwayistogotothe[pre‐bid]conferenceandmeetpeople.”[#22]
RegardingbarriersordifficultiesinDenverassociatedwithexpandingthebusiness,asurveyrespondentsaid,“Experienceisnottheissue.However,havingbiddingopportunities…[has]beenaproblem.”[AS#8]
Some trade association and business assistance organization representatives commented on
opportunities for members to learn about public sector work.Forexample:
Whenaskedhowmemberslearnaboutpublicsectoropportunities,theBlackAmericanfemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationcommented,“Iftheybuiltarelationshipwithinthatnetwork,thenthey’realreadykindoftiedinandheythengetprivatesectorworkfromthat.Ourpartnershipsaremainlyinthepublicsector,sowedon’ttypicallyseehowthey’reengagingoutsideofthepublicsector.”[#6]
Thesametradeassociationrepresentativeaddedthatrelationship‐buildingisthebiggestpartofthemarketingprocess.Shenoted,“Alotofthemarketingthatisdonewithour
![Page 522: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/522.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 95
members…comesthroughourmonthlymembershipmeetingswherewebringintheprimeprojectteamsorthekeydecisionmakers,andallowthemtosharedetailsnotonlyofcurrentprojects,butalsoinregardstoupcomingprojects.”Shecontinued,“Wehaveaverystrongnetworkingplatform.Alotofourmembersenduphavingmeetings[withprimes]immediatelyaftersomeofthesemembershipmeetings….”[#6]
TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaidthattheorganizationputsinformationontheirwebsite,releasesemailnewsletters,andusessocialmediatodisseminateinformationaboutpublicsectorworkopportunitiestomembers.[#33]
TheNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaidthattheCityandCountyofDenverisdoingagoodjobwithelectronicnotifications.However,shenotedthatmemberscomplainaboutBidNet,whichgathersfederal,state,andlocalgovernmentRFPsfromacrossthecountry.ShesaidthatBidNetonlygiveslimitedinformationforfree,andcommented,“[Members]don’twanttopay$299iftheycan’tuseit.”[#37]
Some interviewees indicated that learning about available work in the public sector is easy.[e.g.,#14,#33]Commentsinclude:
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andESB‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmsaid,“Wegetnotificationsallthetimeaboutprojectsthataregoingonintheoutreach.Weseeinformationinthepaper.Wearereferredtodifferentprojectsbecauseofourcontactsinthecommunity,andjustbybeinginvolvedinthecommunity.”[#9]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaid,“For[CityandCountyofDenver],I’mcertifiedandtheyemailopportunities.”[#35]
Opportunities to market the firm.Businessownersandrepresentativessharedarangeofmarketingexperience.Somereportedbeingconstrainedbytheirownmarketingeffortsorhavinglimitedaccesstogoodmarketingopportunities.Anumberreportedthatword‐of‐mouthreferralsaretheextentoftheirmarketing.[e.g.,#20,AS#2]Forexample:
Whenaskedhowthefirmmarketsitself,thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthattheyhaveawebsiteandadvertisein50to80homemagazines.Sheadded,“We’vepartneredwiththemagazines,andwe’reanactiveparticipantwiththem.Wealsousesignsonourconstructionsites.”[#12]
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“WepursuepublicsectorworkthroughRockyMountainBidNet,andthroughschmoozingarchitects,whichisagiantwasteoftime.[It]doesn’teverseemtowork.And[werelyon]wordofmouth.Referralsaccountfor50to60percentofourwork.”[#12]
![Page 523: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/523.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 96
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedgeneralcontractingfirmsaidthatwhenbusinessisslowshe“sendsoutsomeofthestaffwithflyersdescribingthe[work]thecompanycando.”Sheadded,“ThatisagoodmarketingpiecethatIdon’tbelieveother…companiesaredoing.”[#19]
Thesamebusinessownerwentontosaythatsheis“workingonawebsite,”thoughshehasn’thadtimetofinishityet.Sheadded,“WejoinedColorado[Contractors]AssociationbecauseIwanttomakesureothercompaniesknowI’minthisindustry.”[#19]
Whenaskedhowshemarketsthefirm,theHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaid,“Igoto[TheBlueBook]events,meetings,outreachevents,[andrelyon]word‐of‐mouthandreferrals.”Sheadded,“Fortheprivatesector,TheBlueBooksendsmeopportunitiestobid,andIalsogetreferrals.”[#35]
Whenaskedifshemarketsthefirmtoprimecontractors,thesamebusinessownerindicatedthatshedoes.Shesaid,“LastSeptember[I]didtheTurnerUniversityclasses,andI’vedonesomeKiewitclasses….Igotodifferentmeetingswheretheytalkaboutprojectsthatarecomingup.Ifindoutthecontractorthatwillbeinvolved,andItalktothem.UptonowIjusthavetheone…contract.”[#35]
Whenaskedhowthefirmmarketsitself,theHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmstatedthatsomeemployeesaretaskedwithbusinessdevelopmentandattendfunctionsandbriefingspresentedbyagenciessuchasCDOT,DenverInternationalAirport,andCityandCountyofDenver.HeaddedthattheseemployeesalsobelongtonumerousprofessionalassociationssuchasColoradoContractorsAssociation,AmericanCouncilofEngineeringCompanies,andHispanicContractorsofColorado.[#14]
Whenaskedifhemarketsthefirmtoprimecontractors,thesamebusinessownerindicatedthatitisnotnecessary.Hesaidthathehaslong‐standingrelationshipswithmultiplelargeengineeringfirms.[#14]
Whenaskedhowhisfirmmarketsitself,theHispanicAmericanmaleownerofanarchitecturalengineeringfirmstated,“Wehavebeenaroundalongtime,somostofourworkcomesbywordofmouth,eitherfromcustomersorreferralsfromotherengineerswhodon’tdothistypeofwork.”[#16]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andESB‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmsaidthathisfirmnetworksthroughavarietyofassociations,includingtheUrbanLandInstitute(ULI).Headdedthathisfirmalsoexhibitsatlocal,regional,andnationaltradeshowsandwritesamonthlynewsletter.[#9]
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“Weblogandweattempt,wherepossible,tospeakatassociationsorevents….Inadditiontothat,weattendintroductorymeetingsforallofthedifferentprojectsthatpeoplearedoingwithcontractors,withthecity,andfindoutwhatotherorganizationsareinvolvedinsomeofthoseprojects.Finally,wehostorparticipatein
![Page 524: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/524.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 97
lunch‐and‐learnsatanarchitecturaloffice,usually,orotherplaceswhenwegettheopportunitytodoso.”[#9]
Whenaskedhowthefirmmarketsitself,theHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofanSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaidthattheyemployanhourlyconsultantwhoisveryfamiliarwiththeindustrytomarketthefirm,usuallyviacoldcalls.Shenotedthatrepeatbusinessiskey,andcommented,“Almosteveryonewhohasuseduswilluseusagainwhentheopportunityarises.”[#15a]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthathisfirmmarketsitselfprimarilythroughHomeAdvisorandthroughreferralsfromplumbersandHVACcompanies.Hewentontosay,“Wepayareferralfee.”[#7]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaprofessionalservicesfirmstated,"Ourclientsareourbestmarketers."Hewentontoexplainthatmuchoftheirbusinessisduetowordofmouthandreferralsfrompastclients.[#3]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleownerofaspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthathedoesnotmarkethisbusiness.Heexplainedthathestillworkswiththesameclientsthatheworkedwithwhenhefirstbeganhisbusiness,butnewbusinesstypicallycomesfromword‐of‐mouthreferrals.[#4]
Regardingthefirm’smarketingefforts,thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemaleco‐ownerofaspecialtyservicesfirmreportedthattheymarketthroughonlinepresencessuchasFacebook,andthatsomecustomerscometoherbecauseofword‐of‐mouthreferrals.[#8]
Whenaskedhowhemarketsthefirm,theSubcontinentAsianAmericanmaleownerofspecialtycontractingfirmstatedthathedoesnot.Heexplainedthathisjobscomefromword‐of‐mouthreferrals,andthatbecausehehasbeenaroundforalmost10yearshisreputationforqualityworkiswellknown.Hewentontosaythathehasasignonhistruckshowinghiscompany’sphonenumber,andcommented,“That’senough.”[#18]
Whenaskedhowhisfirmmarketsitself,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofanengineeringcompanystated,“Myexperienceisthatbuildersareveryloyaltoengineerstheyhaveworkedwithbefore.So,[it’s]wordofmouth.”[#26]
Whenaskedaboutthefirm’smarketing,theBlackAmericanveteranmaleownerofageneralcontractingcompanyreportedthathedoesnotmarketthefirm.Heexplained,“PeopleknowwhattypeofworkIdo,andit’sthroughwordofmouth.Ihaven’thadanyproblemgettingwork.”[#29]
Whenaskedhowthefirmmarketsitself,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaconstruction‐relatedfirmstated,“Ourcompanyhasagreatreputationintheindustry.However,wedoaconsiderableamountofnetworking.WebelongtotheRotary[ClubofDenver],[NationalSocietyofProfessionalEngineers],andtheDenverMayor’staskforceforbetteringsmallbusiness.”[#25]
![Page 525: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/525.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 98
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmreportedthatthecompanyhasamarketingstaffchargedwithstayinginformedofplannedconstructionprojects.Henotedthattheyalsohaveexcellentrelationshipswithawiderangeofgeneralcontractorsthatcontactthemregardingopportunities.Headdedthattheyarealsoinvolvedinanumberofconstructiontradeassociations.[#21a]
Whenaskedhowthefirmmarketsitself,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmsaid,“Wehaveoutsidesalesrepresentativesassignedtoaccountstodevelopandmaintainrelationships.Thecompanyalsobelongstoasmany…associationsaspossible.”[#23a]
Whenaskedtodescribehowthefirmmarketsitself,theBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionsupplyfirmsaid,“Basically,theretaildivisionhaspeoplewhogooutandknockondoors.Iknockondoors[too].Insidesalespeoplecallcustomers.So,it’salotofB2Bsales.WejoinedtheAssociatedGeneralContractors…about18monthsago,andIhaveasalespersonwhoattendstheirevents.[Still],weprobablyneedtogetalittlemoreactive.”[#36]
TheHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthat,universally,theirmembersspendalotoftimemarketingbothinthepublicandprivatesectors.Headded,“Iknowfirmsthatdoalotofprivatesectorwork.IknowfirmsthatdorepeatedworkatCoors[BrewingCompany]becausethey'vedonegoodworkandtheycontinuetomarket….Theyalsowilldoworkwith[RegionalTransportationDistrict]andCDOTatthesametime,soitalldependsonwheretheyfoundalittlefooting.Butthoseareprobablybiggerorganizationsthathavetheopportunitytospendsometimeonmarketinganddevelopmentofwork.Asmallshopdoesnothavethatopportunity…[which]iswhyorganizationslikeoursprovideabigbenefittothem.”[#11]
A trade association representative said that one barrier for small businesses in the
marketplace is understanding how to market.Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaid,“Theirabilitytomarket,tolearnhowtomarket,[and]toknowwhentostartthatmarketing[isachallenge].I’vehadsomethatdoworkforsomeoftheentitiesbecauseoftheirMWBEprograms,like…CDOTwiththeirESBprogram,[and]they’llliterallytellme[thatthey]don’thavetomarketanymore…becausefirmswanttopartner[then].”[#38]
Thesametradeassociationrepresentativecontinued,“It’snotagoodthingthattheydon’tknowhowtomarkettoother[places].Atthesametime,they’resmall.It’shardtobeabletodoallthingstoexpandtheirclientbasebecausetheydon’thaveenoughbodies,and…alotoftimes…they’restretched.”[#38]
A business assistance organization representative reported on members’ efforts to market to
prime contractors.TheNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationreportedthatmembersdomarketthemselvestoprimecontractors.Shesaid,“Theyuseoureventsandourwebsite….Theyactivelymonitorprojectsinthepipelineandtheprimesthataregoingafterthework,andtrytoconnectwiththem.ItalsohelpsiftheprimemakesNativeAmericancompaniesapriority.”Sheadded,“Theestablishedcompanieshaveagoodsuccessrate,butnewcompanieshavedifficultiesgettingtheirfootinthedoor.”[#37]
![Page 526: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/526.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 99
One business owner reported adjusting the firm’s marketing strategy in hopes of improving its
effectiveness.Whenaskedhowherfirmmarketsitself,thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringfirmsaid,“I’mgoingthroughawholemarketingupheavalrightnowandjustturningeverythingonits[head].Whatwe’vedonehistorically[formarketing]is…makecontactsthroughtheprofessionalsocietiesofwhichIamamember,[though]Iamnolongerusingthatasamarketingstrategy.”[#5]
Thesamebusinessownerwentontosay,“We…subscribetoacoupleofagenciesthatgatherinformationoncapitalimprovementprojectsthatarecomingupforvariousagenciesandprivateentities….TheypublishmemossayinganRFPisoutfor[a]project,andthatthere’sapre‐proposalmeetingonsuchandsuchadate.Ihaveamarketingpersonwholookseverydaytoseewhatprojectsarecomingupandifithasastructuralcomponenttoit.Ifso,weputanemailblastouttoalloftheplanholdersintroducingourfirm….Wehooksomepeoplethatway.”[#5]
Another business owner reported relying on repeat business and being disillusioned by the
fact that there are “fewer and fewer” opportunities in the marketplace for new work.Whenaskedhowthefirmmarketsitself,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaspecialtyservicesfirmstated,“Mostofourworkcomesfromrepeatbusiness.Thefactthatwehavebeenaround[over30]yearshelpsinpromotingourbusiness.Occasionally,thereisaninquiryaboutmakingacustom[product],[but]thoseinquiriesarebecomingfewerandfewer.Theentire…industryisslowingdownbecausethereareotheroptionstocommunicatewithcustomers.”[#30]
Some business owners reported minimal challenges when marketing. Forexample:
Whenaskedaboutthefirm’smarketingefforts,thenon‐HispanicwhitemaleownerofagoodsandservicesfirmsaidthattheyprimarilymarketonlinethroughsocialmediaviaFacebookAds,GoogleAds,andoccasionallythroughadsonYouTubeandInstagram.[#10]
TheBlackAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaidherfirm“[doesn’t]reallymarketfor[themselves].”Sheadded,“Wereallyhavebenefitedfromgreatclients,wordofmouthkindofstuff….Peoplefindusmoreoftenthanusmarketingourselves.”[#13]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmsaidthatthereisnomarketinginvolved,asherfirmisall"hardbid."[#2]
Prequalification requirements.Publicagencies,includingstateagencies,sometimesrequireconstructioncontractorstoprequalifyinordertobidorproposeongovernmentcontracts.
Many business owners and representatives reported that prequalification requirements in the
public sector present barriers to obtaining or performing work, including for the City and
County of Denver.[e.g.,#7,#24,AS#44]Forexample:
Regardingprequalificationrequirements,theHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmsaid,“Idohavefriendswhohavehadsomesortofbarrierswith,not[necessarily]theprequalification,but…thelicensingportion[neededto]workwithinthecity.”[#2]
![Page 527: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/527.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 100
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmstatedthatshesometimesavoidsopportunitiesbecausetheprequalificationrequirementsareso“onerous.”Sheexplained,“Biggeneralcontractorsdonotdifferentiate[prequalificationrequirements]betweenlargeandsmallbusinesses.”[#20]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmstatedthatsomesubcontractorsdohaveproblemsmeetingprequalificationrequirementsbecausetheylackthefinancialdepthandexperienceforaparticulartypeofconstructionproject.[#21a]
Whenaskedaboutbarriersordiscriminationregardingprequalificationrequirements,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaidthatprequalificationrequirementshavebeenabarrier.[#22]
One trade association representative noted that while there are a lot of opportunities for “the
small guys” to bid projects with public agencies, requirements can prevent them from doing
so.TheHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaid,“[DenverPublicSchools],forexample,willsay,‘[Tell]metheexperienceyouhaveinbuildingorworkinginschoolconstruction.’Wellifyou'veneverdoneschoolconstruction,youdonotgettocheckthatbox.[And]ifyoudonotcheckthatbox,youdonotgetmovedtothenextlevel.Andso,asacatch‐22,youcontinuetousethesamefolksallthetimebecausetheyaretheonlyoneswhohaveexperience.”[#11]
Some interviewees, however, indicated that prequalification requirements are not a barrier,
or are not standard in their industry.[e.g.,#9,#10,#23b,#33,#36,#37]Forexample:
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthatallpublicagenciesshehasworkedwithrequiredprequalification.Sheexplained,“Youhavetosubmitthisproposalthathasalotofqualifyinginformation,[suchas]resumes[and]howmuchinsuranceyouhave.We’reusedtosubmittingthatstuff.We’recomfortabledoingthat.”[#12]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmreportedthatprequalificationrequirementsarenotabarrierforhisfirm.[#14]
Whenaskedaboutprequalificationrequirements,thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringfirmsaid,“Wegetproposalsandwesubmitproposals.Becausewe[actas]consultantstotheprimes,wedon’tgetbonded[or]prequalified.”[#5]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemaleco‐ownerofaspecialtyservicesfirmreportedthatprequalificationwasnotrequiredforanyofthepublicsectorworksheperformedthusfar.[#8]
![Page 528: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/528.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 101
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofanSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthatprequalificationisnotnecessaryforthefirmbecausetheyarequalifications‐based.[#15a]
Licensing and permits.Certainlicenses,permits,andcertificationsarerequiredforbothpublicandprivatesectorprojects.Thestudyteamdiscussedwhetherlicenses,permitsandcertificationspresentedbarrierstodoingbusiness.
Many business owners and representatives reported that obtaining licenses and permits is not
overly difficult or not required in their industry.[e.g.,#8,#12,#20,#35]Forexample:
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthatobtaininglicensesandpermitsisnotabarrierforhisfirm.[#7]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andESB‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmindicatedthathisfirmfacesnobarrierswithlicensingorpermits.[#9]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofanSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthattheyhavenoissuesobtainingrequiredlicensesandpermits.[#15a]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmreportedthatwhilespeciallicensingisrequiredinhisindustry,itisnotabarrierforthefirmortheiremployees.[#21a]
TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthatobtaininglicensesandpermitsarenotabarrierforthefirm.[#22]
A number of interviewees and survey respondents reported that obtaining licensing or permits
could be more of a barrier for small and minority‐ and women‐owned businesses than larger
firms.[e.g.,AS#18,AS#55]Forexample:
RegardingbarrierswithlicensingthroughCityandCountyofDenver,asurveyrespondentcommented,“Theirtestingprocessforlicensingisnotveryfriendlytowardsanybodythathasadisability.”[AS#22]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmstatedthatherfemalecolleaguestruggledtoobtainlicensureforsidewalkrepairs.Sheexplained,“Youhavetogoandgetthelicenseandshowthatyouarenotonlycapable,thatthebusinessiscapable,butalsothatthepersoniscapableofdoingthework.”[#2]
Thesamebusinessco‐ownercontinued,“Whenthatfemalebusinessownerapplied[forthelicense],shewasturned[down]becauseshehadn’tdonetheworkherselfdespitehavingacompanywherethereareworkerswhodoknowhowtodoit.”Shewentontosaythatsomelicensesrequireaboutfiveyears’experience,whichcanbedifficultfornewerfirmstodemonstrate.[#2]
![Page 529: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/529.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 102
Regardinglicensesrequiredintheirindustry,asurveyrespondentsaid,“Havingtosecurelicensesforeachcityorcountytodoworkversusotherstates[isabarrier].”[AS#29]
Regardingobtainingpermitsintheconstructionindustry,asurveyrespondentreported,“Gettingpermitsforconstructionisverydifficult.It'snotaneasyprocess.”[AS#48]
RegardingbarriersordifficultiesinDenver,asurveyrespondentcommented,“Thepermitprocesstakesalongtime.”[AS#11]
Asurveyrespondentdescribedtheprocessofobtainingpermitsas“difficult.”[AS#27]
One business assistance organization representative said that obtaining licensing and permits
is challenging for all firms.TheNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationcommentedthatthetimeittakestogetsomelicensesandpermitsis“waytoolong,”thoughshesaidthisistrueforeveryone,notjustminorities.[#37]
Size and span of contracts. Intervieweeshadarangeofcommentsastowhetherthesizeofcontractspresentedabarriertobidding.
Some business owners reported being restricted by contract size or that the size and length of
contracts they typically secure do not reflect their capability to perform larger, longer‐term
jobs.[e.g.,#28]Forexample:
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringfirmsaid,“There’snoreasonthatyoucan’tputouta$2billioncontractandhavetheHVACasaset‐aside…thestructuralasaset‐aside,orthenorthterminalasaset‐aside.Youcouldbreakitupgeographically[or]byspecialty,[or]byphasing.Ijustthinkthattherearesomanymissedopportunities[for]smallbusinessset‐asides[likethose].”[#5]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“[Contract]officersfurtherstackthedeckinfavorofincumbentsbyassemblinglargeprojectpackagesthatsmaller[firms]can’tcompeteon,andagainbringinthesame‘goodol’boy’consultantsastheyalwayshave.BreakingprojectsdownintosmallercomponentswouldmakeCityofDenverprojectsaccessibletoamuchwiderrangeofDBE/WBE/SBEconsultants.”[WT#11]
One business owner indicated that clients sometimes avoid working with small businesses
because of their small size.TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andESB‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmindicatedthatsomecustomersandbuyersavoiddoingbusinesswithsmallfirmsbecause“there’sastigmaoutthereaboutsmallbusiness.”[#9]
A business assistance organization representative indicated that unbundling large contracts
would benefit members.TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaid,“Letthemdemonstratetheirperformance,thentheycantacklealargeramount.Providetheopportunityforthemtosay,‘ThisiswhatIdo,andIcandoitwell.’”[#33]
![Page 530: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/530.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 103
Any unnecessarily restrictive contract specifications.Thestudyteamaskedbusinessownersandrepresentativesifcontractspecificationspresentedabarriertobidding,particularlyonpublicsectorcontracts.
Some business owners and representatives indicated that some specifications are overly
restrictive, do not make sense, or present barriers.Onebusinessownercomparedcomplyingwithspecificationsto“jumpingthroughhoops.”Forexample:
Thenon‐HispanicwhitemaleownerofaprofessionalservicesfirmreportedonanissuehehadwhenworkingwiththeColoradoDepartmentofTransportation.Heexplained,“Wehadbeenselectedforourthirdnon‐project‐specificcontractandthecontractingofficertoldmethatwehadtwoprojects,andthatshouldbethelimit.[Theysaid],‘Donotbothercomingbackforafourth.’WehavenotworkedforCDOTsince….Youshouldbeselectedintermsofyourqualifications,notonhowmanycontractsyouhavedoneornot….”[#3]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaid,“Itishardertogetonpublicsectorworkbecausemanyoftheprojectsaresobig….Therearealotmorerequirements,likeasafetyprogram.”Whenaskedifshefacesbarrierswithunnecessarilyrestrictivecontractspecifications,shestated,“Yes,thespecificationsaretoobigandcomplicated.”[#35]
Whenaskedifhehasfacedanybarriersordiscriminationregardingunnecessarilyrestrictivecontractspecificationsorbiddingprocedures,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaidthathehas.Heexplained,“It’sthejumpingthroughhoops,askingforfinancials,[and]the[required]experiencelevel.Wegotadebrieffrom[DenverPublicSchools]workwepursued.TherearelargefirmsthatspecializeinK‐12work.Wegotmarkeddownbecausewedon’tdo20schoolsayear.Doingaschoolisnodifferentfromdoingafirestationintermsofwhattheclientneedsandwhattheusersneed.Theybuilditintotheir‘goodol’boys’network.”[#22]
Some trade association and business assistance organization representatives indicated that
restrictive contract specifications are more of a barrier for small businesses than large firms.Forexample:
Whenaskedifsheisawareofunnecessarilyrestrictivecontractspecificationsorbiddingproceduresasbarriersformembers,theNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationstated,“Wedefinitelyseethatwhenbidsrequirethingslikeacertainfont,acertainformat,submittedinanenvelope.Smallbusinessesdon’thavedepartmentsdedicatedtothosetypesofdetails.”[#37]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthatthebiggestbarriersmallbusinessesfaceis“onerouscontractlanguage.”Shewentontosay,“[Publicagenciesare]askingpeopletoputtheirfirmsonthelinewithoutinsurancecoverage.They’lltakeontheresponsibility,[but]theycan’thavethatkindofinsurancecoverage.”[#38]
![Page 531: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/531.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 104
A small number of other interviewees reported no barriers resulting from overly restrictive
specifications.[e.g.,#7,#15a,#21a,#33]Forexample:
TheHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmsaidthatwhencontractspecificationsandbiddingproceduresareunnecessarilyrestrictive,theyjustpresenttheirratesandwhattheywilldoforthatprice.Heindicatedthatitisnotabarrierforhisfirm.[#14]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmstatedthatheisnotawareofanybarriersregardingunnecessarilyrestrictivecontractspecifications.[#23b]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmreportedthatshehasnoissueswithunnecessarilyrestrictivecontractspecifications.[#20]
Prevailing wage, project labor agreements, or any requirements to use union workers.Contractorsdiscussedprevailingwagerequirementsthatgovernmentagenciesplaceoncertainpubliccontracts.Theyalsodiscussedotherwage‐andunion‐relatedtopics.
Some firms said that prevailing wage requirements are fair and requirements for union
workers are not a barrier when working on public projects.Examplesfollow:
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmsaidshedoesnotworkwithunionsanddoesnotperceiveworkingwithunionstobeabarrierforherfirmorfirmsinthelocalmarketplace.[#2]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmstatedthatheisnotawareofanyissuesregardingworkingwithunions.Thefirm,henoted,workswithunionandopenshopcompanies.[#23a]
Thesamebusinessrepresentativeaddedheisnotawareofdiscriminationbasedonbeingaunionornon‐unionemployer.Bothunionandnon‐unionemployers,hesaid,arestrugglingtofindworkersduetoalowunemploymentrateand“boomers”retiringfromtheconstructionindustry.[#23a]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmindicatedthatrequirementsforusingunionworkersisnotabarrierforhisfirm.[#14]
Some trade association and business assistance organization representatives said that
prevailing wage requirements and requirements to use union workers are not barriers for
members.[e.g.,#37]Forexample,regardingunionlabor,theHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthatwhilehehasnotwitnesseddiscriminationbasedonrace,ethnicity,orgender,hehasnoticedthatunionshopswillnotworkwithnon‐unionshops,andviceversa.[#11]
![Page 532: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/532.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 105
Another trade association representative described prevailing wage requirements as a barrier
for some member firms.Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationindicatedthatprevailingwagerequirementscanbeabarrierformembersthatseekworkinthepublicsector.[#40]
A survey respondent indicated that prevailing wage requirements and requirements to use
union workers are barriers. Regardingbarriersordifficultiesforthefirminthelocalmarketplace,asurveyrespondentsaid,“Itishardtocompeteagainstnon‐unionwithunioncontracting.”[AS#1]
Bidding processes.Intervieweessharedanumberofcommentsaboutbiddingprocesses.
Many business owners and representatives said that procedures for bidding present a barrier
to obtaining work or put larger firms at an advantage.[e.g.,#7]Forexample:
Whenaskedaboutbarriersordiscriminationinthebiddingprocess,theBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionsupplyfirmstated,“Whenwebidonlubricantsfor[CityandCountyofDenver]awhileback,IgotreallyaggressiveandIlostitbyabout$1,000.Wewerecompetingagainstpeoplewhobuy[ourproductinlargevolume].Itwasstrictlyprice,therewasnootherconsideration.Whyaren’ttheytryingtostrengthenallsectorsoftheeconomy?It’sthesamepeoplewhogetthesamebusiness.Therehastobesomethingforminoritywholesalecommodityfolks.”[#36]
Thesamebusinessownerlatersaid,“WesubmittedabidtoJeffersonCountyandIthinkwewerecompetitive,buttheywentwiththeincumbent.Theysayit’saboutprice,butIthinkit’saboutothermitigatingfactorssotheycancontinuetodowhatthey’vealwaysdone.”[#36]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaid,“Thebidprocessforalloftheagenciesrequiresalotofpaperwork.[Also],theywantsomanythingslikeinsurance,asafetyprogram,andbonding.”Sheaddedthatshedoesnotconsiderthebiddingprocessabarrier,thoughitistimeconsuming.[#35]
Thefemalerepresentativeofanon‐Hispanicwhitemale‐ownedprofessionalservicesfirmexpressedherfrustrationwiththecurrentbiddingprocedure.Shestatedherperceptionisthatthegoalscommitteehasbecomeawayforsomememberstogetadvancenoticeofprojectstheythenbidon,ratherthanfulfillingthepurposeofacitydiversitygoalscommittee.[#1c]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“Letmejustsayoneotherthing,andthisspeakstothecity,andsomethinghastobedone.Theprocurementofficeisdiscriminatingseverelyagainstus….[In]98percentofthebidsI’vebeenin,they’llstandupandthey’llsayyes,thisisRepresentativeOrder101,butthereisn’tagoalonthisprojectorinthisbid.Sotherefore,justsignupthe…forms.Don’tbeconcernedaboutit[and]don’tworryaboutit.”[PT#3a]
![Page 533: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/533.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 106
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“TheprocurementdepartmentofthecityandcountyofDenverisseverelytakingstepstogooutandensurethattherepresentativeorderisnotencouraged….It’scompletelyimpotent.”[PT#3a]
Whenaskedaboutbarriersordiscriminationinthebiddingprocess,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmstated,“It’shardtocompeteforprofessionalservicesbecausethescopeisusuallynotwell‐defined.Whenacontractorbidsonsomething,theyhaveasetofdesigndocuments.Allwegetisstatementslike,‘Wewantabuildingthatmakesusfeelcomfortable,that’scoolinthesummertime,wherewecangetinandoutsafely.Howmuchisthatgoingtocostus?’”[#22]
Some business assistance organization representatives reported on challenges members face
in the bid process.Forexample:
Whenaskedifsheisawareofbarriersinbiddingprocessesthataffectmembers,theNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationstated,“Sometimesonthelargerprojects,[bidprocessareabarrier]becauseitrequiresalotofmoneytomeetalltherequirements.”Shelatersuggestedthatpublicagenciesprovidebidprocesstrainingorsimilarassistance.[#37]
Whenaskedaboutbarriersordiscriminationthathismembersfaceregardingbiddingprocesses,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationstated,“Memberscomplainthattheagenciesseemtohavepreferredcontractors,andthosecompaniessomehowseemtogetmostofthework.It’shardforanewcompanytogetintotheloop.”[#33]
One trade association representative discussed whether prime contractors conduct sincere
outreach to DBEs, or only reach out to “check off” a requirement.TheHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationcommentedthathisperceptionisthatthisvariesfromprojecttoproject.Hestated,“Ithinktherearetimeswhenitisverymuch…justcheckingtheboxoff.”Hesaidthishappensmoreoftenthanheiscomfortablewith,andadded,“I’llhearsomeofthegood,certifiedfirmssaytheydidn'tget[notified]orthattheyweren’taskeduntiltwodaysbeforeitwasdue,[sothey]donothavetimetosubmitaproposal.”[#11]
Short deadlines to submit bids/proposals or no feedback. Afewreportedveryshortbidding/proposaldeadlinesonsomeprojects.[e.g.,#28]Somecommentedonalackoffollow‐upregardingopportunitiesorlostbids.Forinstance:
TheNativeAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,SDB‐,SDVOSB‐,andHUBZone‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmsaidthatsometimesRFQdeadlinesaretooshort.Heexplainedthatattimes,theyonlyhave24hourstorespond.[#39]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmreportedthatwhileshegetsalotofsolicitationsfromprimecontractors,thereisno“follow‐up”afterwards.[#20]
![Page 534: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/534.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 107
TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmsaid,“Thetypeofassistance[we]needismorefollow‐upfromthecustomer.Weneverhearfromanyonewhyourbidwasn’taccepted.Itfeelslikeweareinthedarkwhensubmitting.”[#32a]
One trade association representative recalled members’ experiences with short deadlines in
the bidding process.TheHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthatcertifiedfirms“saytheydidn'tget[notified],orthattheyweren’taskeduntiltwodaysbeforeitwasdue”tosubmitaproposalandbid.[#11]
Some interviewees reported no knowledge of barriers within the bidding process.Forexample:
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmstatedthatheisnotawareofanydiscriminationinthebiddingprocess.Headdedthatheisnotawareofdiscriminationinthefactorspublicagenciesorothersusetomakecontractawards.[#23b]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthatshehasnotexperienceddiscriminationorbarriersinthebiddingprocess.[#12]
A trade association representative commented that in his own experience, City and County of
Denver’s bid process is “relatively easy.”TheHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidheisnotsureifCityandCountyofDenver’sbidprocessiseasierorharderthanotherpublicagencies,thoughinhisownexperiencehefindsittoberelativelyeasy.[#11]
Timely payment by the agency or prime.Intervieweesoftenmentionedslowpaymentornon‐paymentbythecustomerorprimecontractorasabarriertosuccessinbothpublicandprivatesectorwork.[e.g.,PT#3c,PT#4]Forexample:
TheBlackAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmstatedthatpublicsectorpaymentscanbeheldupifinvoicingiswrong,insurancecertificatesarenotintact,orifprevailingwagesarenotpaid.Shesaidthatmanytimesherfirmisnotmadeawarethatpaymentswillbeheld,andsaidtheprocesscantake45to60daystoresolve.[#13]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleownerofaspecialtycontractingfirmreportedproblemsrelatedtotimelypayment.Hestated,"InDenverIliterallywillwaituptosixmonthsforpayments.Evenifit'sjusttheretainerattheend,itstilldoesn'tcomeinuntilsixmonthsaftertheprojectisdone.So,itistough."Hewentontosay,"Idon'tthinkpaymenthasbeenanissueofdiscrimination.Ithinkit'sjustpoormoneymanagementandlackofintegritywhenthereareissuesinthatmatter."[#4]
Thesamefirmownerreported,"I'vehadonegeneralcontractor[intheprivatesector]notpaymeandcontinuallynotpayme.AndIhavetogoafterhim,continually.I'venoticedthatsomeofhisothersubswerenothavingthesameissue."[#4]
![Page 535: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/535.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 108
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“I’mveryfortunatethatwe’vehadlongrelationshipswithbankingbusinessesthatwehavealineofcredit.Youusethatentirelineofcredit.Why?Becauseyou'realwayspaidlate.Youareneverpaidontime.Youhavetoutilizethatmoney.Itcostsyouandsothenyoustartdowntheroadofpayingfordollarstosubsidizethecontractthatyoualreadyhaveaverysmallmarginofprofit,andImeanskinnymarginofprofiton.”[PT#3a]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmsaid,“Someprimeswillpayyouupfrontbasedonnegotiatedprices[while]somewillliterallyonlypayyouiftheygetpaid,evenwhenit[wasn’t]negotiatedthatway.”Hecontinued,“They’lljustnotpayyou.They’llsay,‘Hey,wedidn’tgetallourmoneysowecanonlypayyouacertainamount,eventhoughweagreedupfrontto[payyou]infull.’Itendsupthatwehavetotakeonthecourt,andforus,thatgetsexpensiveasasmallbusiness.”[#7]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmreportedthatpaymenthasbeendelayedacoupleoftimes,andaswithmostmunicipalities,itissometimeshardtofindsomeonetomakedecisionsaboutinvoices.Hecommented,“Toomuchbureaucracy.Itwouldbehelpfuliftheyhadapolitepersonthatcanmakeadecision.”[#21a]
Business owners and representatives indicated that slow payment can be damaging to
companies.Intervieweesreportedthatpaymentissuesmighthaveagreatereffectonsmallorpoorlycapitalizedbusinesses.[e.g.,#7,#40,PT#3a,PT#4]Forexample,theBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“OnsomeprojectsIhavehadpaymentissues.Ihaveexperiencedwaittimesofuptoandbeyond50days,andwastoldbyonecontractorthatIwas‘highmaintenance’whenIaddressedthepaymentissues.”[WT#12]
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“Ihavealsohadissueswhereinvoicesdidnotgetprocessedatall.Manyoftheseprimeshavefiguredoutthattheycanplayalotofgameswiththepaymentstosmallminority‐andwomen‐ownedfirms.Thisisasneakywaytosqueezethemfinanciallytothepointofbeggingtogetpaid.Andifyouspeakup,youareblacklistedandwilldoa‘whispercampaign’totheirbuddiesatotherconstructionfirmsorarchitecturalfirmsintheregion.”[WT#12]
Some trade association and business assistance organization representatives reported that
members struggle to receive timely payment in the public sector.[e.g.,#6,#40]Forexample,whenaskedtodescribemembers’experiencesgettingpaidonpublicwork,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationstatedthatallpublicworktakeslongertopaythanprivatework.Headded,“Therearequiteafewsubswhotellmetheyare60to90daysout,anditreallyimpactscashflow.Theaccountsreceivablecycleisjusttoolong,andthey’rereallystressedout.”[#33]
A number of business owners reported no experience with late or untimely payments by
public agencies or primes.[e.g.,#15a,WT#3]Forexample:
![Page 536: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/536.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 109
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmreportedthatthefirmhasnoissueswithuntimelypaymentbyprimesonpublicsectorprojects.Shecommented,“OneoftheprimesI’veworkedwithforyearsfrequentlyhelpswithcashflowissues.”[#20]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemaleco‐ownerofaspecialtyservicesfirmstatedthatshehasneverwitnessedanypaymentdiscrimination.Shealsoindicatedthatshehasnotexperiencedanylateoruntimelypaymentsbyagenciesorprimes.[#8]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andESB‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmreportedthathisexperiencesgettingpaidonprojectswithCityandCountyofDenverhavebeengenerallypositive.[#9]
TheBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionsupplyfirmreportedthatheneverhadproblemsgettingpaidbyRegionalTransportationDistrict.Heexplained,“Inthisindustryyougetpaidrightaway.Everybodyknowstherefinersarethebigguys,andtheypayin10days.”[#36]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmstatedthatheneverhasissuesgettingpaid.Helaternoted,“PaymentsfromCDOTsometimeslagalittle,butnotverymuch.”[#14]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmstated,“Sofar,Ihaven’thadproblemsgettingpaidontime.”[#35]
One trade association representative reported on methods that could be used to enforce
prompt payments.TheHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationstated,“IfI'mdoingabuildingandweareworkingonthesidewalk,whenthesidewalkisdoneandthecityhasapprovedthesidewalkbeingdone,paymentshouldbeissued.Itshouldnotbetiedintomultipleitemsbytheprime.Theconcernaboutthatmethodisitmeanstherearemultiplesubmissionsofitemsandthecitylikestotakeoneitematatimeandlumpitalltogether,andthenpaytheprimeallofit.ButlikeIsaid,ifsignaturesaremissingoffapieceofthedocumentation,theneverythingisheldup.”[#11]
F. Work with the City and Other Public Organizations
Intervieweesdiscussedthefollowingtopics:
ExperiencesworkingwithCityandCountyofDenverorotherpublicagencies;
LearningaboutprimeandsubcontractopportunitieswithCityandCountyofDenver;and
Recommendationsforimprovingstateagencies’bidding,contracts,promptpaymentandotherprocesses.
Experiences working with City and County of Denver or other public agencies. IntervieweesspokeabouttheirexperienceswithpublicagenciesingeneralandwithCityandCountyofDenverinparticular.
![Page 537: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/537.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 110
Many business owners and representatives interviewed reported working with City and
County of Denver or other public agencies. [e.g.,#4,#13,#39,WT#8,WT#12,WT#14]Forexample:
TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedworkingfor“justabouteverybody”intheDenverarea.[#22]
Whenaskedaboutthenatureoftheseprojects,thesamebusinessownersaid,“Abigpartofourpracticeison‐callservices.We’vealsogoneafteranimalshelters,libraries,vehiclemaintenancecenters,cityhalls,historicpreservation,aviation,andofficerenovation.”HeaddedthatthefirmwasaprimecontractorformostofthepublicworkheperformedintheDenverarea.[#22]
Thefemalerepresentativeofanon‐Hispanicwhitemale‐ownedprofessionalservicesfirmreported,“Mostofourdealingswiththecityactuallytakeplaceattheairport.WeactuallydoworkundertheCityandCountyofDenverarchitecturalon‐call,butourmaincommercialworkisactuallylarge‐scaleofficebuildingsandlarge‐scalecommercialshoppingdevelopmentsliketheCherryCreekMall.”[#1b]
Themalerepresentativeofanon‐Hispanicwhitemale‐ownedprofessionalservicesfirmstatedthattheirfirmwas“ontheCityofDenveron‐call,”andhasworkedonfivetosevenotherpublicagencyprojectsinadditiontoworkingontheDenverAirport.[#1d]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmreportedthattheyworkprimarilywithDenverInternationalAirport(DIA)andotherairportsaroundthecountrybyinstallingandmaintainingspecialtymachinery.ShelatersaidthatshesubcontractsconsistentlyonDIAprojects,andthatthisworkisthemajorityofherfirm’sbusiness.[#20]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitemaleownerofaprofessionalservicesfirmreportedworkingwithseveralpublicagenciesintheDenverarea.HestatedthathisfirmhasworkedwiththeCityandCountyofDenver,theColoradoDepartmentofTransportation,theColoradoDivisionofWildlife,theDenverWaterDepartment,andasasubconsultantatDenverInternationalAirport.HeaddedthathisfirmhasdoneworkinandforFortCollins,Windsor,Greeley,Longmont,Erie,HighlandsRanch,theCityofCastleRock,andColoradoSpringsUtilities.[#3]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmreportedthatcurrentlythefirm’slargestprimecontractiswithCityandCountyofDenver.HeaddedthatthefirmhasalsoworkedwithDenverInternationalAirport,DenverWater,DenverWastewaterManagement,andanumberoffederalandotherlocal/stateagencies.[#21a]
Whenaskedaboutthenatureoftheprojects,thesamebusinessrepresentativereportedthatpublicprojectsincludeworkforairports,municipalbuildings,correctionalfacilities,andwatertreatmentfacilities,amongothers.Headdedthatthefirmperformsasbothaprimecontractorandsubcontractorontheseprojects.[#21a]
![Page 538: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/538.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 111
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmreportedthatherfirmhasworkedwiththeCityandCountyofDenver,DouglasCounty,AdamsCounty,CastleRock,thetownofParker,thetownofSuperior,andCDOT.Whenaskedifshebidasaprimeorsubcontractorwiththeseagencies,shesaidshebidmostlyasaprime,thoughshedidsomeworkasasubcontractor.[#2]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andESB‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmreportedthathisfirmhasworkedwithseveralpublicagenciesintheDenverarea,includingDenverPublicWorks,DenverTransportation&Mobility,DenverEnvironmentalHealth,andDenverPublicSchools.HeaddedthatthefirmhasalsoworkedwithCDOTandRegionalTransportationDistrict.[#9]
Regardingherfirm’sworkwithpublicagenciesintheDenverarea,thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthatherfirmworkedasaprimeforCityofLoneTreeandMetro[UrbanLand]Conservancy,andasasubcontractorforDenverPublicSchools.[#12]
ThesamebusinessowneraddedthatthefirmalsoworkedforDenverHousingAuthorityonafewsmallprojects.Shewentontosay,“TheotherthingIshouldsayis[that]we’vedonelotsofquasi‐publicwork.Thingslikechurches.We’veworkedforHudsonGardens,[which]isaplacethat’spublic,butit’snotapublicagency….They’republicplaces.”[#12]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedgeneralcontractingfirmreportedthathercompanyhasdonealotofworkforpublicagencies,includingforCDOT.Shesaid,“Iworkedfor[Denver]PublicWorksasasubforthemontheperiphery,[though]I’veneverbeenaprimeforthem.Ididbidonalarge…jobandlostbythelittlestamount.”Shecommented,“Everybidyousubmitgivesyouexperiencesandhowtorespondtothenextone.”[#19]
Whenaskedaboutherfirm’sexperienceworkingwithpublicagenciesinDenver,thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmstated,“Wehavedonesomejobsfor[Denver]PublicWorks….Theprojectresultwasfine.Nothingstandsoutabouttheworkortheinteractionswiththestaff.However,wedoalotofworkforothergovernmentalagenciesaroundthemetroarea.ExampleswouldbeDouglasCounty,Boulder[ValleySchoolDistrict],andCityofFruita.Ibelievetheyfind[that]ourworkisqualityand[our]completionistimely.”[#28]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringfirmreportedthatherfirmmostlybidsasasubcontractoronCityandCountyofDenverprojectsandforotherpublicagencies.[#5]
TheBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionsupplyfirmsaidthathisonlypublicsectorworkwasacontractwithRegionalTransportationDistrictyearsago,and“onesmallcontractwith[DenverInternationalAirport].”HeaddedthatheattemptedtogetworkwithCityandCountyofDenver,Aurora,DenverPublicSchools,andCityofEnglewoodwithnosuccess.[#36]
![Page 539: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/539.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 112
TheHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmreportedthathisfirmhasworkedwithmanypublicagencies,includingCityandCountyofDenver,DenverPublicSchools,DouglasCounty,DouglasCountySchoolDistrict,JeffersonCounty,JeffersonCountySchoolDistrict,andCDOT.Headdedthathisfirmhasanon‐callcontractsasaprimecontractorwithCityandCountyofDenverinthepast.[#14]
Thesamebusinessownersaidthecompany’sveryfirstprojectwasforDenverWater.However,hesaidthathisfirmnolongercontractswithDenverWaterbecausetheynowrequireacertifiedProjectManagementProfessional(PMP)ontheteam,whichhisfirmlacks.Hecommented,“So,thatDenverWaterworkwentaway.”[#14]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthathisfirmtypicallyseeksasbestosandmoldprimecontractworkwhenpursuingworkwithpublicagencies,andadded,“Typically,thecityalreadyhasavendorthey’regoingtocallrightawaytodo[mytypeofwork].Theyhavevendorstheywillcallinsteadofbiddingthatworkoutbecauseit’smore[so]emergencywork.”Conversely,hereportedthathisfirmhasworkedasaprimecontractoronprojectsinAurora,Golden,andBroomfield.[#7]
WhenaskedwhichpublicagenciesthefirmhasworkedorattemptedtoworkwithintheDenverarea,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmstated,“Iwouldsayallofthem….WeworkwithDenverWater,[RegionalTransportationDistrict],CityofDenver,schools,[and]theairport.”Hereportedthattheysupplycomponentsforhighways,dams,airports,andschools.Helaternotedthatasasupplier,thefirmdoesnotworkdirectlywithCityofDenverortheairport.[#23a]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE,SBE,andESB‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmstated,“WehaveperformedcivilengineeringconsultingservicesfornumerousclientsincludingCDOT,[RegionalTransportationDistrict],theCityandCountyofDenverandmanyothermunicipalities.”[WT#15]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmreportedthatherfirmworksexclusivelywithCDOT.”[#27]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofanSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaidthatthefirmusedtodoworkforJeffersonCountySchoolDistrict,butbecausethefirmhasnotpassedabondinyears,theyhavehadnorecentopportunities.[#15a]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaidthatshehasattemptedtoworkwithallpublicagenciesintheDenverarea,thoughshehasonlyhadonepubliccontract.[#35]
Whenaskedaboutthecompany’sexperiencesworkingintheprivateandpublicsectors,thenon‐HispanicwhitemaleownerofaspecialtyservicesfirmsaidthathisfirmdoesworkforColoradoPublicEmployeesRetirementAssociation(PERA)aboutonceayear.Henoted,“That’stheonlypublicworkwedo.Everythingelseisintheprivatesector.”[#30]
![Page 540: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/540.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 113
Trade association and business assistance organization representatives indicated that
members work for a wide range of Denver public agencies, and discussed members’
experiences pursuing the work.Commentsinclude:
TheNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaid,“TheyworkwithCDOT,[RegionalTransportationDistrict],DenverPublicSchools,[DenverInternationalAirport],highereducationsystems,DenverHousingAuthority,DenverWater…prettymuchallofthem.”Regardingthenatureofthiswork,shesaidmembersdoawidevarietyofconstruction,bothverticalandhorizontal,plusgoodsandservices.Shenotedthatmostmembersbidassubcontractors.[#37]
Whenaskedhowmanymembersworkontransportation‐relatedconstructionorengineeringwork,thesamebusinessassistanceorganizationrepresentativesaid,“Wehavequiteafew.Someofthemworkonprojectslikethe[RegionalTransportationDistrict]raillineoutto[DenverInternationalAirport]andCDOTprojects.Thereisalsoatrendoftribesstartingtheirownconstructioncompaniesandgoingafterconstructionprojects.[A]tribeoutofOregonpartneredwith[alocalprime]forprojectsinthisregion,andtheyarealsodoingworkinMontana.”[#37]
Whenaskedaboutmembers’experiencesingettingworkwithpublicagenciesinDenver,theBlackAmericanfemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthat“CDOT…historicallyhashadaverychallengingtime,andnotsogoodofareputationasitpertainstoengagingsmallbusinesses.”However,shenoted,“Overthepastthreetofiveyears,theyhavebroughtonanewteamthathasbeenveryfocused,dedicatedtorebranding,reporting,and…restructuringtheirprogramtothepointnowwhereyou’reseeingalotoftraction….”[#6]
TheHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationreportedthatprimecontractormembersgenerallybidonlarge,verticalconstructionprojectswithCityandCountyofDenver,DenverInternationalAirport,CDOT,andDenverPublicSchools.HesaidthattheirMWBEcommunityusuallybidasfirst‐tiersubsonmanyofthecontracts.[#11]
ThesametradeassociationrepresentativelatersaidthatCityandCountyofDenverismoredifficulttoworkwiththanotherpublicagenciesbecausetheyhavemultiplecertificationprogramswithinoneentity.Heexplained,“[Denverrecognizes]MWBE,SBE,DBE,[and]EBE[certifications],andsoitisharderforfolkstoknowexactlywhichprogramisbeingimplementedonthatparticularbid.CDOTand[RegionalTransportationDistrict]aremainlyDBE.Theyhavenolocalprogram….So,IwouldsaytheCity'sisalittlebitmoredifficultjustforthemagnitudeofworkandthe[certification]programsthatareinplace.”[#11]
TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaid,“Idohaveamemberwhodoesalotofthe[RegionalTransportationDistrict]lightingprojects,hasbeenaroundalongtime,andhasworkedasasubforsomeofthemajorprimes.[However],about90percentofoursmallbusinessmembersdoprivatework.”[#33]
![Page 541: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/541.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 114
Some business owners reported not working for City and County of Denver, or that such work
is slowing down. [e.g.,#7,#24]Forexample:
WhenaskedifheeverworkedwithpublicagenciesintheDenverarea,theSubcontinentAsianAmericanmaleownerofaspecialtycontractingfirmstatedthatheandaBlackAmericancontractorbidonacontractwiththeZoobutneverheardback.Hesaidthattheyspenthourscollectinginformationforthebidandultimatelydecidedtolowballitjusttogettheirfootinthedoor.Hecommented,“[Ithink]theyalreadyhadthecompanypickedout,andwantedtoworkwithsomeonetheykneworhadworkedwithbefore.”[#18]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaconstruction‐relatedfirmreportedthathiscompanyhasbeenunsuccessfulinpursuingpublicsectorwork.Heexplained,“[We]respondedtobidsfromtheCityofDenver,specifically[Denver]PublicWorks,duringthetimethecompanywas[a]certified[SBE].Weneverwonanyofthosebids,[and]stoppedrespondingafterthe[SBE]certificationlapsed.”[#25]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemaleco‐ownerofaspecialtyservicesfirmreportedthatwhilethefirmhasneverworkedwithanypublicagenciesinCityandCountyofDenver,they’veworkedwithCityofLongmont,CityofBerthoud,andalocalschooldistrict.[#8]
Thesamebusinessco‐ownerlateraddedthatsheneversubmittedabidforthework.Instead,shesaidthattheentitiesreachedouttoher.Sheexplained,“Theycontactedme.Ihavenoideahowtocontactpublicentitiesforcontracts.Theyjustsaid,‘Hey,weneedanew[vendorforherproduct].Canyoudothisjobforusandhaveitreadybythe[deadline]?’”ShewentontosaythatsheworkedasaprimeonprojectsforCityofLongmont.[#8]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofanengineeringcompanyreportedthathehasneverworkedforand“wouldneverworkfortheCityofDenver.”Hesaidthathehadanegativeexperienceworkingwithacitygovernmentbeforestartinghisownfirm.[#26]
WhenaskedifhehasworkedwithorattemptedtoworkwithanypublicagenciesintheDenverarea,theBlackAmericanveteranmaleownerofageneralcontractingcompanyreportedthathehasnot.Headded,“Idon’twanttoworkforthegovernment.”[#29]
A number of business owners and representatives discussed positive experiences while
working with City and County of Denver or other public agencies.[e.g.,#39]Forexample:
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmstatedthatherfirmhas“agoodpartnership”withCDOT.[#27]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmstated,“WeabsolutelyloveworkingwiththeCityandCountyofDenver.TheDepartmentofPublicWorks…personnelareexcellenttoworkwith.Thecityimplementsanhonestyandtransparencyprotocolwitheverybodythey’reworkingwith,andthatreflectsalot.”[#2]
![Page 542: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/542.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 115
Thesamebusinessco‐ownercontinued,“WearemorethanecstatictocontinuetoworkwiththeCityandCountyofDenver.It’soneofthebest,ifnotthebest,governmententitiestoworkforasaprimeandasasub.”[#2]
Themalerepresentativeofawoman‐ownedspecialtyservicesfirmsaid,“Denversupportedusandawardedawonderfulcontract….Thishasbeenawonderfulthingforourbusinessandwearethankful.WithoutDenverlookingtofindsmaller,locallyownedbusinesses,wewouldneverhavebeenabletoadd150additionalemployeestoourroster.”[WT#1]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedgeneralcontractingfirmstatedthatherexperiencewithDenverParksandRecreationwasverypositivebecauseoftheagency’sinvolvement.Shecontinued,“With[Denver]ParksandRec,theyhada…jobin[apublicpark].Theywouldtalkwithuseverydaybecausethejobwassovisibletotheneighborhood.”[#19]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmindicatedthathisexperiencesworkingwithCityandCountyofDenverandotherpublicagenciesintheDenverarea,includingCDOT,havebeenpositive.[#14]
Whenaskedaboutthefirm’sexperienceasasupplierworkingwithCityofDenver,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmsaid,“[Subcontractors]checktheirboxesandwegetthemeverythingtheyneed.[It’s]notdifficult.”[#23b]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmstatedthatworkingwithCityandCountyofDenverandDenverInternationalAirporthasbeenpositiveoverall.Hesaidthathehasnotheardofany“nightmares.”[#21a]
One business assistance organization representative reported positively on members’
experiences working with Denver public agencies.TheNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaid,“[DenverInternationalAirport]and[CityandCountyofDenver]areveryresponsive.DenverPurchasinghasbeenexcellentaboutsendingflyersoutabouttheirevents,andtheystayincontact.DenverHousingAuthorityhasreallyfocusedondevelopingtheirrelationshipwithusthelastcoupleyears.”[#37]
Some business owners and representatives discussed challenges they face when working with
or trying to get work with City and County of Denver or other public agencies. Forexample,untimelypayments,paperworkissuesandotherbarriersfollow:
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE,SBE,andESB‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“Ourexperienceworkingwiththe[CityandCountyofDenver]hasbeenchallenging,particularlyoverthepastfewyears.Mybiggestconcernispromptpayment,orlackthereof.Allofourcontracts,unfortunately,arepaywhengetpaid.Myfirmistypicallyasecond‐tiersub.Itiscommonplaceformyfirmtowaitsixmonthsormoreforpaymentfrom[CityandCountyofDenver].Wewererecentlypaidonworkweperformedtwoyearsago.”[WT#15]
![Page 543: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/543.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 116
Asurveyrespondentsaid,“Foracompanyjuststartingout,saythefirst24[to]36months,itisimpossibleforacompanytoworkforapublicentity.It'sthequalificationsandRFQs,becausethecompanydoesn'thaveaproventrackrecord.”[AS#44]
RegardingchallengesthathesometimesfaceswhentryingtoworkwithDenverpublicagencies,theNativeAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,SDB‐,SDVOSB‐,andHUBZone‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmsaid,“Sometimeswithpublicagenciesit’shardertoworkthroughthemazetogetanswerstoyourquestions.”[#39]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofagoodsandservicesfirmreportedthatthefirm’sworkisalmostexclusivelyintheprivatesector.HenotedthattheybrieflyattemptedtodoworkwithpublicagenciesintheDenverarea,andcommented,“Therewasmorepaperworkthanwereallywantedtodo….Itwasn’t[necessarily]adeterrent.Itwasmore[that]we[would]comebacktoitbecausetherewerelower[hanging]fruit.”[#10]
TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmstated,“Themunicipalitiesandpublicagenciesthatrequireproposalsarethemostdifficult,sowegenerallydon’tdothatbecausewearealwayshigh….Irefusetolowball.We’vecomeintriple.Ithinkthefolkswhoaresuccessfullowballit,andthencomeinwithlotsofchangeorders.”HelaterindicatedthathehadanegativeexperienceworkingwithDenverPublicSchools.[#22]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleownerofaspecialtycontractingfirmreportedproblemswithcommunicationandtimelinelimitations.Hestated,"TheonlyrecommendationIhave[fortheCityofDenver]isthatduringthetermofwork,changeordersneedtobeprocessedinaquickermanner…[because]wehaveatimeline.When[they]arenotprocessedquickenougheverybodyrunslate."[#4]
RegardingworkwithCityandCountyofDenver,asurveyrespondentstated,“It’sbeenalittlebitdifficult.Justthewaytheyconductbusiness,they'renotsmallbusiness‐friendly.[Thereis]alotofbureaucracy,and[theyare]notreallyopentosmallbusiness.”[AS#51]
Asurveyrespondentsaid,“Thepeopleinchargeonlyhelppeopletheyknow.We'veparticipatedincitycommittees,butweren'tsuccessfulingettingcontracts.It'simpossibletomeetrequirementstoevenstartthebiddingprocess[duetorequired]insurancecoverage.[AS#16]
Apublicmeetingparticipantsaid,“Ifyouareplanningtodoworkwith[CityandCountyofDenver]…you’vegottohaveatleast$60,000to$100,000incash,withpaymentsbeingreallyslow.”Sheadded,“Youarecommittingsuicideforyourbusiness,somakesureyouhavecash.Ihavecontractshere.I’lltellyoubecauseIknow.”[PT#4]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐andSBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmstated,“Weareverydisappointedasa[certified]contractor.Wefinallygetacontractwith[CityandCountyofDenver],butwenevergotanyrequestsforpricing.ThisisafailingeffortbytheCitytoprovideopportunitiestocontractdirectlywithsmallbusinesses.”[WT#14]
![Page 544: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/544.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 117
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofanSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaidthatitisdifficulttosecurepublicsectorworkwithoutMBEorWBEcertification.Sheaddedthatthefirm’sSBEcertificationdoesnotsetthefirmapartbecause“toomany”firmshavethecertification.[#15a]
Regardingthefirm’sworkwithCDOT,theHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedgeneralcontractingfirmcommentedthattheircontracthadunclearspecifications.Sheexplained,“Theywouldn’ttellyouaboutthespecsuntilyoumadeamistake.Theywouldtalktoyouthen,notaheadoftime.Itwasjustnotpartoftheinformationtheyprovided.”Shewentontosay,“Someoftheinformationcomesfromtheredbookorthegreenbook.Thoseareguidelinesforconstructionprojects.It’salwayschanging.”[#19]
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“Ididalarge…project,[but]unfortunatelyit[had]threedifferentcontractors…threedifferentspecs,andthreedifferentCDOTinspectors,[allonthe]sameroad.Threedifferentprimeswonthejobandtheyselectedusforalloftheroad.Itwas10milesandthespecschangedwitheachprime.”Shecommented,“Itwasbizarreworkinglikethat.Astemperatureschangedandtheapplicationrateschanged…itwasalmostlikeeachwasitsownlittleminiproject,butourlinesconnected.”[#19]
TheBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“Ihavebeenonseveralprojectsthatare[CityandCountyofDenver]projects.Myworkisusuallywiththeprimecontractor.IhavefoundtheCityofDenvertobearatherdifferenttypeofentitytoworkwith.[There’sa]lotofstufftogothrough.Keepingtrackofallofthecertificationsandgettingpassedaroundtodifferentpeoplewhentryingtogetinformationabout[work]opportunities[canbeachallenge].”[WT#12]
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“Itcanbecomerathercumbersome,andasaresult,IdonotpursuemuchCityofDenverwork.”Headded,however,“Withthenewordinancesthatwerediscussedatthelast[ConstructionEmpowermentInitiative]meeting,itissomethingImayreconsiderifthosebecomelaw.”[WT#12]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmsaid,“Sometimes…CDOTrunsoutofmoneyandcancelsataskorder.Thenyouhavepeople[just]standingaround.”However,helatersaid,“Ithinkit’seasiesttofindoutaboutworkwithCDOTbecauseweknowalotof[theirrepresentatives],andwecancallthemand…seethemrightaway.”[#14]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmsaidthatshetriedtogetworkwithpublicagenciesotherthanDenverInternationalAirportwithnosuccess.Shecommented,“Itisveryhardtogetafootinthedoorwithotherpublicentities.”[#20]
ThesamebusinessownercontinuedbysayingsheattemptedtoworkwithCDOT,RegionalTransportationDistrict,andDenverWaterintheareasofconstructionmanagementandlaborsupport.Shenoted,however,thatshedoesnothavetherelationshipstobidasasubcontractorinthoseindustries.[#20]
![Page 545: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/545.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 118
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaspecialtyservicesfirmsaid,“Theproblemwehavefacedisfindingouthowtobreakintothecityandothergovernmententities,tosellourproduct.I’msuretheyprobablyusethesamevendorstheyhavealwaysused,and[are]notinterestedinfindingoutifthereissomethingmorecompetitiveavailable.”[#30]
TheBlackAmericanandveteranmaleownerofaDBE‐andMBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmsaid,“MoreneedstobedonetoincludeMWBEsintelecommunicationprocurementsattheairport.”[WT#13]
A few trade association and business assistance organization representatives discussed
challenges members sometimes face when working with or trying to work with City and
County of Denver and other public agencies.Forexample:
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthatmanymembersfinditdifficulttogetworkwithpublicagenciesinDenver.Shesaid,“Ithinksomeofthemfeelliketheopportunitiesaren’tthere….Somefeelthattheykeepgivingworktothesamefirmsoverandover,[and]Iknowthatthisisn’tjustwith[theCityandCountyof]Denver….Someprojectmanagersarecomfortablewithacertainfirm,andthat’salltheywanttodobusinesswith.”Sheaddedthatcontractadministratorsfinditeasytoworkwithfirmstheyalreadyknow,andcommented,“Theyknowthem,soit’slessriskontheirpart[and]lessthattheyhavetomanage.[#38]
Whenaskedtodescribemembers’experiencesattemptingtogetworkwiththesepublicagencies,theNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaid,“Ithinkgettingthatfirstcontractisthebigchallenge.Oncetheygetthefirstone,they’re[okay].Ifthey’vebeenworkingintheprivatesector,they’renotusedtoalltherules.Ihadamemberwhosubmittedabidandputitinanenvelopeasrequired.Whenheturneditin,theytookitoutoftheenvelopeandstampedit,butdidn’tputitbackintheenvelope,andhewasdisqualified.So,thatwasashock.”Shelateradded,“WehaveadifficulttimegettingresponsesfromDenverWater.”[#37]
Regardingmembers’experiencesworkingwithCityandCountyofDenver,theBlackAmericanfemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaid,“Unfortunately,alotofthecommentsIhearare[that]it’samessoverthere[and]theydon’tknowwhatthey’redoing….Therearesomanyquestions[regarding]theorganization,theadministrationofthedepartments,[etcetera],andit’sbeenachallenge.”[#6]
Some interviewees and survey respondents discussed challenges specific to small businesses
when pursuing work with City and County of Denver or other public agencies.Commentsinclude:
TheBlackAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaidworkingwithinthepublic‐schoolsystemisdifficult.Shesaidthepresenceofchildrenandrelativesafetyconcernsaddstothechallenge,andsaid,“Youhavetoapproachitadifferentway.Andthey,admittedly,willtellyouthiswhenyoucomeonboard.[They’llsay],‘Hey,thisisnotgoingtobethecityandcounty.It’snotgoingtobeaspleasantasyouthinkitmightbe.’”[#13]
![Page 546: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/546.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 119
RegardinghiseffortstogetworkwithpublicagenciesintheDenverarea,theBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionsupplyfirmsaid,“Forcommodities,youhavetoputinthetimeandefforttosubmityourbid.[However],thevolumesaresuchthatthelargecompaniesbenefitbecausetheygetabetterpricefortheproductandcanmakemoney.”[#36]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaconstructionfirmindicatedthathehasnotpursuedworkwithpublicagencies.Hesaid,“Ihaveheardthatyouhavetojumpthroughalltypesofhoopstoworkonpublicprojects.I’dratherstayasanindependentcontractor.”Hecontinued,“I’veheardyouhavetogotopre‐bidmeetings,trytobuildarelationshipwithothercompaniesthataregoingaftertheproject,[and]theydon’tnotifyyouifyougotitornot.And[most]importantly,youdon’tgetpaidinatimelybasis….[So],I’dratherstayasanindependentcontractor.”[#24]
TheNativeAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,SDB‐,SDVOSB‐,andHUBZone‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmsaidthereisanegativeperceptionthatsmallbusinessescannotcompeteagainstlargerfirms“becausetheydon’thavetheinfrastructureinplacetocompete,”orbecause“theydon’thavetheexperienceorqualifications.”Henotedthatsmallbusinessesaremorelikelytohavequalificationswiththeirkeypeopleratherthanthefirmasawhole.[#39]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofanSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaidthatsmallfirmsareviewedasriskierandpotentiallyunabletofinishaproject.Shesaidthatthisperceptionispresentinthepublicsectoraswellastheprivatesector.[#15a]
Whenaskedabouthisfirm’sexperienceattemptingtoworkwithpublicagenciesintheDenverarea,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmsaid,“Denverhasitsowntechnologydepartment.Thatdepartmentdoesallofthedatacommunicationsfortheentirecity,[but]therehasnotbeenanopportunitytogetanyofthatwork.Ifthateverchanges,wearereadytocableinstall,providetechnicalsupport,[and]anythingelse.Rightnow[though],wedon’tseethathappening.However,municipalitiesarealwayslookingtocontrolandreducecosts,[so]thatcouldbesomethinginthefuture.”[#32a]
Asurveyrespondentnoted,“WorkintheDenverarea,aswellastheDenverInternationalAirportarea,allseemtobecontrolledbythesamegeneralcontractor.”[AS#10]
Some trade association and business assistance organization representatives indicated that
small businesses face unique challenges when pursuing work with City and County of Denver
and other public agencies.Commentsinclude:
Regardinglackofexperienceasabarriertoperformingpublicsectorwork,theNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaid,“Ihaveheardthatcomeup.Oneofthethingswetrytodoisencouragethemtostartoutwithaverysmallcontracttogettheirfootinthedoor.I’vealsoheardthatsometimesthereisarequirementforextensiveexperiencedoingaprojectlikeaschool,andforasmallbusinessthat’sabarrier.”[#37]
![Page 547: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/547.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 120
TheHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaid,“[Denver]justputthroughanewproposal,ormaybeanordinance,spellingoutthepromptpayguidelinesandreinforcingwhatwealreadyhadinplace.Buttheissueisforacertifiedfirmthatmaybeathird‐orfourth‐tier[subcontractor].Theydotheirwork[then]theyhavetosubmitthepaperworktogetpaid.Ifsomebodydidn'tsubmittheirpaperworkonthesamepackagecorrectly,thewholepackageishelduntilthenextcycle,untilallthepaperworkiscorrected.”[#11]
Thesametradeassociationrepresentativecontinued,“Wedonothaveagoodsystem….Whenworkisdoneandcompleted…theapprovedpaymentshouldbemade.Thepaymentsmadetothesetiersubcontractorswhodidtheworkshouldalsobewithinacertainamountoftime.Ithinkitisgoingtogetbetter.Butasmallbusinesscannotholdintheiraccountsreceivable60[or]90days.Theycannotholdpayrollback60or90dayswhilewaitingforpaymentfromthecity.”[#11]
WhenaskedaboutchallengesthatsmallbusinessesfacewhenpursuingworkwithCityandCountyofDenverorotherpublicagencies,thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthatdelayingcontractsafterteamshavebeenformedandcontractshavebeensignedisdamagingtosmallbusinesses.Sheadded,“Whatisthatsmallfirmsupposedtodo?Theygearedup[and]wereready….They[then]havetoput[staff]onanotherjob.”[#38]
Thesametradeassociationrepresentativesaidthat,intheseinstances,aprimecontractorfindsanothersubcontractorthatmightnotbeaDBE.Shecommented,“Sometimes…Idonotbelievethatpublicentitiesunderstandbusinessatall,andwhatthosefirmshavetogothrough.”[#38]
Shelatersaid,“Imetwithawomanlastnight[whoowns]afirmof17people.Shetriestoprimeasmuchaspossible.She’sonotherpeople’steams,butshewantstobeaprime….Theclientselectionpool[needsto]givethosefirmsanopportunitytoreallybeinchargeoftheirowndestiny.Ithinkthat’spartof[what]publicentities[don’tunderstandabout]business.[#38]
Some business owners and representatives indicated that there is not enough local firm
participation in the public sector and with City and County of Denver specifically.[e.g.,WT#1,WT#9,PT#3a]Forexample:
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofanengineeringfirmstated,“Wehaveenormousfirmsinthiscommunitythathavetremendouscapacitythatarenot100percentutilizedbythecity.”[PT#2a]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemalerepresentativeofaWBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“[In]Denverinparticular,youseegiantcompaniesbegintocome[inandgetlargeprojects].…[Theybring]theirconsultantsandtheirgiantMBEsoutofChicagothatmeetthe…qualifiersattheairport.[Afirmfrom]Chicagowona$30millionprojectmanagementcontract….”[PT#3b]
![Page 548: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/548.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 121
TheBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaidthat“manyconstruction/engineering/architecturalfirms”intheregiongivehisfirma“hardtime”whenhejustifieshisfees,andoftenturntoout‐of‐statetalent.Heexplained,“It'snotthattheydon'thavethebudgetorthemoney,theyjustdon'twanttoproperlycompensatethedynamiclocaltalent….”[WT#12]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmsaidthatincreasedworkalongtheFrontRangehasattracted“out‐of‐statecontractors”thatarecompetingwithlocalfirms,“especiallysmallbusinesses.”[#20]
Thesamebusinessownerlatersaid,“IjustlostabigcontractopportunitybecausetherewasnorequirementforlocalMWBEparticipation.Becauseoflosingthiscontract,Iwillhavetolayoff14employees.Thewinningbiddertoldmethatbecausetherewasnoincentivetousealocalcompany,theysawnovalueinusingmycompany.”[#20]
ShesaidthatshebelievesDenverInternationalAirportismarketingheavilytoout‐of‐statecompanieswithnopreferenceforlocalcompanies.Shestated,“TheCityandCountyofDenverand[DIA]needtohavealocalrequirementontheircontracts.Ithinktheyshouldaddincentivestocontractorsthatutilizelocalsubcontractors.”[#20]
Some interviewees spoke about their positive experiences with outreach efforts by City and
County of Denver and other public agencies.[e.g.,#5,#13,#35]Forexample:
TheHispanicAmericanmaleownerofaspecialtycontractingfirmstatedthatrelativetoothercitiesandcountieshehasworkedfor,itiseasierforhimtofindoutaboutworkopportunitiesfromtheCityandCountyofDenverandDenverPublicLibraries.Hereportedthattheseentitiesaremorecommunicativethanothers,specificallyviaemail.[#4]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmsaidthatit’srelativelyeasytofindoutaboutworkopportunitieswithCityandCountyofDenver.Intheprivatesector,headded,workopportunitiesaremoredependentonrelationshipswithprimespursuingthattypeofwork.[#21a]
Thesamebusinessrepresentativelatersaid,“Ifyou'reawareofwheretogo,youcanprettymuchfindwhatthecityisdoing.Andtheyalwayshaveoutreachevents.WerecentlyattendedonefortheNationalWesternComplex.”[#21a]
A trade association representative spoke positively about members’ experiences with public
agency outreach.TheHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthatmembersgetalotoftheirinformationaboutupcomingjobsorprojectsthroughpublicagencyoutreach.Hesaidthatthereareseveralgeneralcontractorswhoalsodotheirownoutreachandinvitetheirmembershiptoattendpresentations.Headded,“Manytimes,theairportwillhaveoutreacheventsandyouwanttotakealookandseewhotheprimesareatanyoneofthosemeetings.Youwanttoknowthefolksthataretherebecausethosearethefolkswhoareformingteamsandthosearethefolksthatthesmallerguysinourmembershipwanttotalkto.”[#11]
![Page 549: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/549.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 122
ThesametradeassociationrepresentativelatersaidthatdiscoveringworkopportunitiesiseasiestforDenverInternationalAirport.HeexplainedthatDIACommerceHubhelpspromoteandconductoutreachoncontractingopportunitiesavailableattheairport.[#11]
Some interviewees reported limited outreach from the City and County of Denver and other
related challenges regarding outreach efforts.[e.g.,#6,#23b,WT#12,PT#3b,PT#4]Examplesfollow:
TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaMWBE‐certifiedconsultingfirmsaid,“Recentlywehaveinvestedmuchmoretimeandenergyintopursuingstateandfederalopportunitiesrelatedtoourbusiness,[though]wehaveyettobeawardedprojectsthroughtheseavenues….ItismyhopethattheStateofColoradocontinuestosupportsmalland[MWBEs]inthefuture,particularlythosewhoembraceandadoptcorporatecitizenshipprinciplesbeneficialtothecommunity.Thusfar,Ihavealsofounditabitdifficulttotrackdownpotential/applicablestateRFPsusingtheinformationresourcesavailable….IwouldlovetohavemoreexposuretoinformationaroundRFPsthatwouldfitourskillsetandcapabilities,aswellasourstatusasaminority‐ownedsmallbusiness.”[WT#6]
Regardingthecity’soutreachefforts,thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaWBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“Thestaffatthecityisoverwhelmedwiththeirtasks.They'reunderstaffed,andthecity’sgrowing[at]anexplosivepace….Ithinktheydon’thaveenoughpeopletodeliverworldclassservicesfromaworldclasscity.Andwe’reseeing…maybenotaspromptpublicnotificationforthesemeetings[asthereshouldbe].”[PT#3c]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andESB‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmsaid,“IfI’vealreadybeentoanoutreach[event]andprovidedthenecessaryinformation,butthenwedon’tgetinvitedtoparticipate,myquestionis,‘Why?’”Hecontinued,“[If]we’vedonethethingsthatyou’veaskedustodotoparticipate,[whyaren’twe]seeinganyfeedback?”[#9]
Themalerepresentativeofaconstructionservicesfirmsaid,“Asaprospectivevendor,Ihavegonetoalloftheevents[and]metthepeopleIneededtomeet.Ifollowedupwithanemailthankingthemfortheirtime,[and]setupmeetingswiththemandhadgreatconversationsaboutuspartneringwiththemforfuturebusiness.Ihavestatedtimeandtimeagainwearelookingforalong‐termrelationship[ratherthan]aone‐offbusinessdeal.[However],wepartways,shakehandsandwesaywewillgettogetheragain.[I]send[a]follow‐upemail…askingforanotherappointment,andcallandleaveavoicemailto[no]avail.Weeksgo[byand]noresponseviaemailorphonecall.”Hecommented,“Whatwouldyouthinkwithnofurtherreplyfromthem?”[WT#4]
TheBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionsupplyfirmsaidthateventhoughhewascertifiedwithseveralagencies,hedidnotgetautomaticnoticesregardingopportunitiesinhismarket.[#36]
![Page 550: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/550.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 123
Some business owners and representatives commented on how late/untimely payments from
City and County of Denver or other public entities impact the success of firms.[e.g.,WT#3,WT#15,AS#26,PT#3a,PT#3c]Forexample:
RegardingherworkwithpublicagenciesingeneralinDenver,theHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedgeneralcontractingfirmsaid,“Allmunicipalityworkischallenging,andthenthereisalwayswaitingtobepaid.Thecitypaymentmighttakemonths.”Sheadded,“TheprimesIworkwithmakesureI’mnotwaitingtoolong,andwillmakepaymenttothecompanybeforetheyarepaid.”[#19]
Apublicmeetingparticipantsaidthat“payments[are]reallyslow”whenworkingwithCityofDenver.Sheaddedthatitcantake“uptotwoyearstogetyourmoneyback.”[PT#4]
Whenaskedtodescribethefirm’sexperiencegettingpaidonworkwithpublicagencies,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“Itreallyvaries.Itdependsontheagency.Thefirstpaymentisgenerallypainfulbecauseyouhavetounderstandtheirprocess.Everyoneisdifferent…theyallbreakthingsoutdifferently,evenwithindifferentDenverdepartments.Wehavebattledover$140on$10,000worthofworkbecauseofratesthathavechanged,andit’sintheirfavor.”[#22]
Whenaskedaboutthefirm’sexperiencegettingpaidonpublicsectorwork,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmcommented,“Itcanbeslowerthanothers.”[#23a]
Regardingthefirm’sexperiencegettingpaidonpublicsectorwork,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmstatedthatgettingpaidonpublicsectorworkcanbeslowbecausebothprimecontractorsandsubcontractorsarepaidbeforesuppliersgetspaid.[#23b]
RegardinguntimelypaymentfromCityandCountyofDenver,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmsaid,“Recentlytherewasadelayonaproject,anditfilteredallthewaydowntooursubs,andtheirsubs,becausethosesubswereapproachingus[asking],‘Howcomeyou'renotpaying?’”Hecontinued,“Thesituationbotheredmebecausewehavealwayspaidoursubsontime.Ilookedintoitandfound[thatCityofDenver]hadhelduppayment.”Headded,“Theydidfinallyreleasepayment,withinterest.”[#21a]
A few trade association and business assistance organization representatives discussed how
late/untimely payments from City and County of Denver or other public agencies impact
members’ success.[e.g.,#33]Commentsinclude:
RegardinglatepaymentsbyCityandCountyofDenver,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaid,“Thatreallyaffects[firms],especiallyminority[and]woman‐ownedcertifiedbusiness[es].Theyareasmallbusinessandtheycan’tsufferthecashflowofwaiting…60or90daysforpayment.Theyneedpaymentevery30days.[#40]
![Page 551: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/551.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 124
TheBlackAmericanfemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationreportedthatmembersareoftennotpaidontimewhenworkingonCityandCountyofDenverprojects.Sheexplained,“Oneofourmembersinparticularshared[that]ithadtakenseveralmonthsforthemtogettheirpayment.Iwanttosay[itwas]ninemonthsorsomething.”Sheadded,“Otherstalkaboutthedifferentstepsinternally,likenotknowingwhatthestatusisbecauseyoucallintoonedepartmentandthey’resayingthattheydon’thaveit,ortheydon’tknowandit’skindofarunaround.”[#6]
Thesametradeassociationrepresentativewentontosay,“Ifafirmisnewer,they’renotclearonwhattheprocessis.Ifthey’remoreseasonedcontractors,they’vebeenaroundtheblockenoughtohavelearnedwhattheprocessisorisn’t,andtheyhavejustkindofaccepteditbecausethat’sthewaythecityworks….Someareveryhesitanttocomeforwardandsayanythingbecausetheydon’twantanyretaliation.”[#6]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthatpromptpaymentisanissueformembersworkingwithCityandCountyofDenverasbothprimecontractorsandsubcontractors.[#38]
Learning about prime and subcontract opportunities with City and County of Denver and Other Public Agencies.FirmsdiscussedlearningaboutprimeandsubcontractopportunitieswithCityandCountyofDenverandhowitcomparestootherpublicagencies.Someindicatedthatitisdifficultforthemtolearnaboutprimeorsubcontractopportunities.[e.g.,WT#12]Othersreportedeffectivewaysoflearningaboutpotentialsubcontracting,orthatprimecontractorsreachouttothem.Forexample:
RegardinglearningaboutworkopportunitieswiththeCityandCountyofDenver,apublicmeetingparticipantsaid,“Theprocessformehasbeenreally,reallyfrustrating.It’sbeenmanyyearsthatI’vebeentryingtoworkwiththeCityandCountyofDenver,andI’mreadytoserve.”Hecontinued,“Iservemycommunity[and]Idoitwell.Wehaveagoodnetworkofindividuals,reallygoodpeoplewhoarecommittedandwanttodothingsforourcommunities.[However],thatprocesstocomeonboardwiththeCityandCountyofDenverhasbeen…reallycumbersome.”[PT#4]
TheBlackAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaidittakes“twoorthreephonecalls”togetintouchwithsomeoneatthecity.Sheaddedthatothermunicipalitieshaveamuchslowerresponsetime,sosheviewsherlocalexperiencewiththecitysomewhatfavorably.Shewentontosaythatherpositiverelationshipwithprimecontractorshasallowedhertogettheprocesspushedthroughmoreswiftly.[#13]
Thesamebusinessownerlatersaiditismoredifficulttofindworkwiththestatebecauseoftheextensivetimerequiredtoreviewopportunitiesthroughtheirbidmanagementtool,BidNet.Shesaid,“Yougottapaythesubscriptionprice….Andifyou’reasmallfirmjuststartingoff,you’repayingasubscriptionjusttolookatthescreentoseetheproject,anddon’tevengettobid.”Shewentontosay,“[It’s]easierwiththeCityandCountyofDenverbecausenotonlydotheyemailyou[aboutopportunities],theyputitontheirwebsite.”[#13]
![Page 552: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/552.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 125
Thenon‐HispanicwhitemaleownerofaprofessionalservicesfirmstatedthatheispleasedwithhoweasytheCityandCountyofDenvermakeslearningaboutprojects.Healsoreportedthatheispleasedwithotheragencies,saying,"WegetcommunicationsfromDenverPublicSchoolsthatannounceopportunities…[the]CityofAurorahasstaffthatwillcallustomakeusawareof[projects]….TheDenvermetroareaisanunusuallygoodplaceforanengineertowork,whichisbasedonmyexperienceworking[inthisfield]forover40years."[#3]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmsaidfindingoutaboutupcomingprojectswithpublicagencieswasrelativelythesameacrosstheboard.However,shenotedthatforCityandCountyofDenver,firmsalsohavetocheckthewebsite.ShesaidthatforotherpublicagenciesshegetsnotificationsthroughBidNet,andadded,“Youhavetogoinmanuallytothe[CityandCountyof]Denverwebsiteforwork.Otherentities,themajorityofthemifnotall,gothroughtheBidNetnetworkwhereyoupayforasubscriptionandyougetemails[relevant]toyourcodes.”[#2]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmsaiditishardertofindoutaboutCityandCountyofDenveropportunitiesversusthoseofotherpublicagencies.Heexplained,“Itisalittleharderbecausebythetimeit’spublishedoryoufindout,it’salreadybeenbidonby[what]Icalltheinsiders.Theygetnotifiedwellbeforethebidgoesout,andthebidisusuallytailoredtooneofthosecompanies.”[#7]
WhenaskedifitiseasierorhardertofindoutaboutworkopportunitieswithCityandCountyofDenverversusotherpublicagencies,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmsaidthatthereisnotmuchdifferencebetweenpublicagencieswhenitcomestofindingoutaboutworkopportunities.[#23a]
Some trade association and business assistance organization representatives compared
City and County of Denver’s outreach to other public agencies’.SomeindicatedthatmembersstruggletolearnaboutpublicsectorprimeandsubcontractopportunitiesinDenver.[e.g.,#38]Forexample,whenaskedaboutprimecontractopportunitieswithpublicagenciesinDenver,theBlackAmericanfemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaid,“WithCDOT,you’regoingtostartseeingmoreprimingopportunitiesbecausethat’ssomethingthat’sontheirtable,somethingthey’vebeenconsideringandmakingroomforwiththeirbudgets,withtheallocationofprojectsandallofthat.”[#6]
Thesametradeassociationrepresentativecontinued,“WiththeCityandCountyofDenver,I’venotnecessarilyseenasmuchopportunityforpriming.Thereareafewhereandthere,butIdon'tknowwhattheirprogramlookslikeintermsofdedicatedfocus.Isthere[even]aninitiativethatsupportsthat?”[#6]
ShewentontosaythattheCityandCountyofDenverDGSusuallykeepsmembersup‐to‐dateregardingopportunities,andadded,“Everyweek,ifnotmorethanonceaweek,wearegettingcommunications.Wearebroadcastingthoseonourwebsiteandourpublications,sowhatwegetwecertainlypasson[toothers].”ShenotedthatRegionalTransportationDistrictandCDOTalsokeepherorganizationintheloopregardingopportunities.[#6]
![Page 553: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/553.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 126
One business assistance organization representative said that although agencies do a good job
of promoting opportunities, the opportunities are rare.TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaid,“Thereareopportunities,buttheyarefewandfarbetween.Caseinpoint,[DenverPublicSchools],theairportexpansion,[and]theNationalWesternComplex.Engagingwiththeseprojectsischallengingforthem.I’vegottenfeedbackfrommembersthatwhile[DenverPublicSchools]saysthey’rereachingouttodiversecommunities,quitecynically,itislipservice.Thecompaniesinourmemberfamilyarenotseeingit.”[#33]
Inregardstolearningaboutworkopportunitieswithpublicagencies,thesamebusinessassistanceorganizationrepresentativestated,“Overall,theagenciesalldoagoodjobofgettinginformationout,andit’salsoontheirwebsites.Oneoftheareasthatshouldbegivenmoreweightisopportunitiestoprovideprofessionalserviceslikemarketingandgraphicdesign.TheseopportunitiesareequallyimportanttoourMWBEs.A$10,000or$20,000jobisveryattractivetoasmallbusiness.”Headded,“[Agenciesshould]sliceoutdifferentsize[d]work.”[#33]
For some, learning about contract opportunities is not a barrier.[e.g.,#20]Forexample:
Whenaskedifit’seasyordifficulttofindoutaboutCityandCountyofDenverworkopportunities,thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringfirmsaid,“IthinktheCityandCountyofDenverhasmoreinformationavailableabouttheirprojectsthanprettymuchanyoneelse.Icangoouttothe[Denver]website,seewhatisthere,seewhatprojectsI’vebidon,andseewhatprojectsarepending.”[#5]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedgeneralcontractingfirmsaid,“IamalwaysonBidNetand[iSqFt]researchingwhatwouldbethebestbidstogoafter.”[#19]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemaleco‐ownerofaspecialtyservicesfirmreportedthatsheisnotawareofanypotentialbarrierstolearningaboutopportunitiesinthelocalmarketplace.However,shenoted,“Ifthere’samagiclistofpeoplethatgetflyersandbroadcastemails,I’mnotonit.”[#8]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmsaidthathisfirmprimarilydoesqualifications‐basedengineeringwork.Becauseofthis,headded,theysubmitproposalsratherthanbids.HewentontosaythatCDOTworkistheeasiesttosecurebecausetheyworkoftenwiththeagencyandknowtheirprocesses.Therefore,headded,hiscompany’sproposalisverytargeted.Henoted,“Onceyouknowtheprocess,it’seasy.”[#14]
One business assistance organization representative reported positively on City and County of
Denver’s outreach regarding work opportunities.TheNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationstated,“TheCityandCountyofDenverdoagreatjobtellingfolksthatsomethingiscomingdownthepike.”However,shenotedthatintheprivatesector“it’smuchhardertogetthatinformation.”[#37]
![Page 554: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/554.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 127
Recommendations for improving state agencies’ bidding, contracts, prompt payment, and other processes. Anumberofbusinessownersandrepresentativescommentedonormadesuggestionsforimprovingotherstateagencyprocedures.
WhenaskedifshehasanyrecommendationsforCityandCountyofDenvertoimproveitsnotificationorbidprocesses,theHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaid,“Theprojectplanshavesomanypages,andsomuchdoesnotapplytous.Justhaveasectionaboutthecleaning.[And]please,justputwhatweneedinthefront.Lookingthrougheverythingtakesalotoftime.”[#35]
WhenaskedifshehasanyrecommendationsrelatedtoimprovingtheadministrationofcontractsorpaymentmethodsbyCityandCountyofDenver,thesamebusinessownersaid,“[When]Isendaninvoice,[it]hastogotodifferentplaces,thentheysendusacheck,whichisanotherfive‐daydelay.Itwouldbenicetohavedirectdeposit[so]Idon’thavetoaskwhenthecheckiscoming.”[#35]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmsaiditwouldbehelpfultobenotifiedbyemailorfaxofCityandCountyofDenverbiddingopportunities.SheaddedthatasofnowCityandCountyofDenveronlynotifyofopportunitiesquarterly,andsaidit'sinconvenientandinefficientthatthereisnotaplaceforfirmstocheckforworkonaregularbasis.[#2]
Thesamebusinessco‐ownerwentontosaythatgettingpaidiseasythroughCityandCountyofDenverbecauseit'sdoneonlinewhileotheragenciesdon'tutilizeonlinepayments.Shealsonotedthatasaprimecontractorshehashadnoissuesgettingpaidacrossseveralagencies.Whenaskedifthisisthecaseforsubcontractwork,shestated,“Wearesometimespaid60to90daysaftertheprimesarepaid,"andcommented,"Generalcontractorsliketoworkontheirsubcontractor’smoney."Shesuggestedthatpublicagenciesfollow‐upwithgeneralcontractorsthatdonotcomplywithpromptpaymentguidelines.[#2]
WhenaskedifhehasanyrecommendationsforCityandCountyofDenvertoimproveitsnotificationorbidprocesses,theBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionsupplyfirmsaid,“Thereisalottheycoulddo.Whenyouregisterwiththemyou’resupposedtogetbidnotificationswhensomethingcomesupinyourNAICScode,butyoudon’t.Ihavetogoinquireallthetime.I’vetriedtogetinto[RegionalTransportationDistrict’s]automaticsystemforyears,buthaven’tbeensuccessful.SamethingwithDenver.AndIknowthey’reouttherebuyingsmallerquantitiesofthings,buttheynevertellyouaboutthoseopportunities.Whenyou’rerunningabusiness,youdon’thavetimetoknockonthatdoortimeaftertime.”[#36]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmstatedthatCityandCountyofDenvershouldimprovetheirnotificationandbidprocesses.Shesaid,“Whycan’t[firms]goonRockyMountainBidNetlikeeverybodyelse?YouhavetogoonWork4Denver,[but]thereseemtometobetonsofprojectsthatnevershowup[there],suchas,[alocalpublicprojectinmyneighborhood].Iliveinthis
![Page 555: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/555.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 128
neighborhoodandIworkinthisneighborhood.Allofasudden,thishugeprojectwastakingplacethatIhadnoideaabout.[#12]
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“So,findingtheworkishard.Ithinktonsofworkdoesn’tevergothrough[Work4Denver].Theyhaveon‐callservicesforarchitectsandlandscapearchitects,whichishowtheirsmallprojectsareaddressed.So,thesebigfirmsgettheseon‐callcontracts.Irealizeitwouldbemoreworkfor[CityandCountyofDenver],butsomeofthesesmallerprojectswouldreallybeagreatwaytobringinnewbloodratherthanusingthesameold…whitemale‐ownedplayersoverandoveragain.”ShealsodescribedtheDenverPublicSchoolsbidprocessas“arduous,”andindicatedthatitshouldbestreamlined.[#12]
Whenaskedifhehasanysuggestionsforimprovingtheadministrationofcontractsorpaymentmethods,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmstated,“Yes.Thefederalgovernmenthasagreatsystem.Theyhaveacontractmanagerandtheyhaveaprojectmanager.Alotofmunicipalandstateagencieshaveaprojectmanager,andyouknowwhothatis,[but]thenyourinvoicegoesintotheaccountingdepartmentandyoudon’tknowwhothatpersonis.Itmaysitonsomeone’sdeskandtheymaynotevenknowwhatthecontractis.”[#22]
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“Afteritsitsontheirdeskforaweek,theygobacktotheprojectmanagerandask,‘Whatisthis?’Theprojectmanagerhastoexplainittothem.So[then]theygobackandcrunchthenumbers,andsay,‘It’s$5off,havethemresubmitit.’Thepromptpayordinancedoesn’tkickinuntiltheyapprovetheinvoice.Inthefederalworldyousendittoboth,sotheytalktoeachotherandyouknowwhothatcontractmanageris.Andtheyareusuallyatthemeetings,sotheyknowwhatisgoingonwiththeproject.IftheyhadthatatDenver,thestate,[orRegionalTransportationDistrict],itwouldbesomuchbetter.”[#22]
WhenaskedhowCityandCountyofDenverandDenverInternationalAirportbidprocessescomparetootherpublicagencies’,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmstated,“Thereis…theissueofdeliverymethods.Someallowdesign‐buildor[constructionmanager/generalcontractor],[but]otherswon'tdoanythingbutdesign,bid,build.Thebidprocessisdifferentforeachdeliverymethod.”[#21a]
Thesamebusinessrepresentativelatersaid,“Gettingchangeordersapprovedinatimelymannerwouldhelp.Itgoesbacktothefactthateveryonecansay,‘No,’butnoonewillsay,‘Yes.’It'sgettingthechangeordersapprovedsoyoucanbillforthem[that’simportant].We'recomingoutofpocketforlongperiodsoftime,financingachangeorder,andcan'tgetitapproved.”[#21a]
RegardinguntimelypaymentbyCityandCountyofDenver,thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE,SBE,andESB‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“Thereisalwaysareason,adisputeontheprime’sinvoice,pendingchangeorders,etcetera.Thebottomlineis[that]cashflowconcernsareresultinginsmallbusinessesclosingshoporallowinglargerfirmstopurchasetheminfiresales.Ihaveadvocatedforconsiderationof
![Page 556: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/556.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 129
DBEsubconsultantpaymentwaiversrequiringpaymentamaximumof60daysfromsubinvoiceacceptance.PromptpaymentfromtheCityandourclientsisthebestwaytosupportsmalldisadvantagedbusinessesinmyopinion.”[WT#15]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaid,“IfIcouldmakeanysuggestionstohelpimprovetheprogram,Iwouldrecommend…Denverrequirethatbusinessesthathavetomeetgoals[also]havesomerequirementstotrynewwomen‐orminority‐ownedbusinesses[togive]othercompanies…achancetocompete.”Sheadded,“HaveDenverrequiremorepercentageforwomenversusminorityintheconstructionindustry.Ibelievethatiswherethereisthemostdisparity.”[WT#5]
WhenaskedifhehasanyrecommendationsforCityandCountyofDenvertoimproveitsnotificationorbidprocesses,theHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmsaidthattheyshouldpostcontactinformationforprojectmanagerssomewhereontheirwebsite.Hecommented,“Youneedtoknowwho’scallingtheshots.”[#14]
Thesamebusinessownerlatersaidthatbettercommunicatingagencypersonnelchangesonprojectswouldbehelpful.Hesaidthatwhenapersonnelchangeoccurshiscompanyspendsalotoftimetryingtofigureoutwhothereplacementis.[#14]
WhenaskedifhehasanyrecommendationsonhowtoimprovetheadministrationofcontractsorpaymentmethodsforpublicagencieswithinCityandCountyofDenver,theBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andESB‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmsaidthatheisfairlyhappywiththecurrentsystem.Headded,“Although,ontheprivatesidewenormally[get]adepositfortheorderthatwedo.Wehaveneveraskedacityforadeposit.Butiftheywerewillingtodothat,we’llgladlyacceptit.”[#9]
RegardingwaystoimprovecontractingprocessesbyCityandCountyofDenverandDenverInternationalAirport,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmstated,“Sometimestheyneedinsurancerequirementsorotherdocuments,andI’llhavetoprovidethosetothemsothesubgetspaid.Iwishtheywoulddothatonthefrontendratherthanthebackend.”[#23b]
Regardingtimelypayments,theBlackAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmindicatedthatstateandlocalpublicentitiesshouldfollowinthefederalgovernment’sfootsteps.Shesaidthefederalgovernmentisthebestentityatpayinginatimelymanner.[#13]
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“The[federalgovernmentdoes]thebestofgettingyourmoneyrightnow.Itusedtobetheopposite.Theyweretheworstatgettingyouyourcash,butnowtheyarereallygoodatgettingelectronicpaymentsinfairlyquickly.”Sheconcluded,“Ithinkwe’rejuststuckinthepublicsystemofit’sgoingtotake45daysto90days,to120days.Andonceyougetto120,you’re[thinking],‘Oh,goodgrief.’”[#13]
![Page 557: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/557.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 130
Apublicmeetingparticipantsaid,“The[CityofDenver’s]paymentprocess[is]soconvoluted.Ican’ttellyouhowmanytimesIhadtoreviseapayapplicationbecausedifferentpeoplewantedtoseethings.It’snotastreamlinedprocess,andeverybodyhastheirpreferences….We’vehadtocalldifferentpeopleindifferentdepartments,andIspendhoursandhoursandhoursonthephonetryingtotrackdownsomethingthatshouldbereallyeasy.”[PT#4]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmsaidthatfederalgovernmentcontracting“seemstobealittlefairer,”andexplained,“Theyhavemorechecksandbalancesbecauseoffraudthathasgoneonovertheyearswithgovernmentcontracting.It’sdaunting,butonceyougetthere,theyareprettysetsteps[suchas]meetthesecriteria,thenextcriteria,andthenextcriteria….It’sprettystraightforward.Theyhaveset‐asidesforminorities,forwomen,forveterans,thingslikethat.So,it’salittlebitfairer.”[#7]
Thesamebusinessco‐ownerlatersaiditwouldbehelpfulifCityandCountyofDenvermadechangestoitsprocurementprocesses.Hesaid,“Itwouldbegreatiftheysentouttheirpre‐bidscopeofwork,whattheyrequire,andthenfollow[ed]upwithdeadlinedatesofwhenthebidisturnedin,andalsodeadlinedatesofwhentheywillselectthebidderandmakeitallpublic[ly]accessible.Itwouldbenicetoknowhowtheypicktheirvendors….That’dbenicetoknowbecauseitwouldallowotherpeopleapplyingforabidonthosejobstoknowwhatthey’relackingandhowtopreparethemselvesforthenext[incoming]bid….”Hewentontosay,“Ithinkiftheydidthat,someofthecompaniesthatgetthebidstheyreceivemightnotgetmultiplebids.”[#7]
Some trade association and business assistance organization representatives discussed ways
City and County of Denver can improve its bidding procedures and other procurement
processes.Forexample:
WhenaskedifshehasrecommendationstoimprovetheadministrationofcontractsorpaymentmethodswithDenverpublicagencies,theNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaid,“Perhapspayingbycreditcard,orotherdigitalpaymentprocesseslikeelectronicfundstransfer[wouldbehelpful].Thatwouldbesomuchfasterthanputtingacheckinthemail.”[#37]
WhenaskedifhehasanyrecommendationsfortheCityandCountyofDenvertoimproveitsnotificationorbidprocess,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaid,“Becausesomanyprofessionalbusinessesaremembersofchambersofcommerce,IwouldasktheCityandCounty[ofDenver]toleveragethoserelationshipsandpushmoreopportunitiesoutthroughthosechannels.”[#33]
ThesamebusinessassistanceorganizationrepresentativeaddedthattheDenversmallbusinessofficedoesnotcollectrobustdataregardingpaymentstosubs,likeRegionalTransportationDistrictdoeswithitsE2form.Hestated,“Itwouldseemtomethatthesecitysubsshouldbeonareportablelist,[and]perhapsinanidealsituationsomeoneismonitoringthat.”[#33]
![Page 558: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/558.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 131
TheHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsuggestedthatCityandCountyofDenverimplementaprogramthatmimicsthenotificationandbidprocessesofDenverInternationalAirport’sCommerceHUB,whichpromotesopportunitiesattheairport.[#11]
Thesametradeassociationrepresentativelatersaid,“MostoftheDBEprogramsinthe[CityandCountyofDenver]andfromCDOTarealways…horizontalwork.Theyareusuallylargedollarprojects,mostofwhichareattheairport.Ourcertifiedfirmscannotcompeteinthatarenaunlesstherearemandatorysubcontractoropportunities.”[#11]
WhenaskedhowpaymentprocessesbyCityandCountyofDenvercanbeimproved,theBlackAmericanfemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsuggestedthattherebebetterinternalcommunication.Shesaid,“Publicworks,DSBO,auditing,andwhoeverelsetouchesthepayoutallneedtogetinthesameroomanddeterminewhatpointofentryandpointofcontactwillbehad.”Shewentontocomment,“Whatplatformcantheyusesoeverybodygetsthesameinformationatthesametime?”[#6]
A trade association representative suggested that City and County of Denver require prime
contractors to use subcontractors they have never partnered with before.Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthatmembersenjoyaprocurementbonusofferedbyCDOT,andindicatedthatCityandCountyofDenvermightdowellinadoptingasimilarpractice.SheexplainedthatCDOToffersaprocurementbonuswhenfirmstrytodoworkwithasubcontractorthatthey’veneverworkedwithbefore.Shesaid,“They…gothroughtheprocessofhavingallthesepeoplesubmitproposals.”However,shenotedthat“they[still]havetheirfavorites,andthat’swhotheywant.”[#38]
Regardingpaymentprocesses,thesametradeassociationrepresentativesaidthatasystemtotrackpaymentswouldbehelpfulforsmallfirms.Shesaid,“Ithink[something]likeTextura[wouldbehelpful].I’mconfused[asto]whythe[CityandCountyofDenver]hasallowedTexturatobeusedfordesignprofessionalsand[not]publicworks.Whyisthat?[It’s]agoodtrackingmechanism.”[#38]
Shelatersaid,“Designprofessionalsatastatelevel[and]federallevelneedtobeselectedfirstonqualifications….Theprocurementmethodisknownasqualifications‐basedselection,[and]wewanttoseethatatacitylevelandacountylevel….[Instead],theyareallaboutlowbid.”Sheadded,“Whynot…selectwhoyouthinkisthemostqualifiedthroughwhatevercriteriayouhave,then…sitdownanddiscussscope?”[#38]
One business owner suggested that City and County of Denver implement “tiered contracts”
like CDOT.Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaMWBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedengineeringfirmsaid,“Wetalkalotatourcompanyaboutwinningmeaningfulwork.ThismeansnotbeingmerelyaplaceholdersubconsultantinordertofulfilltheMWBE/DBErequirements…butbeingabletowinworkwhereweactuallygettoshowcaseourabilitiesandourexpertise.OneofthebestwayswearecurrentlyabletowinmeaningfulworkisthroughtheCDOT[tiered]contract[s].ThistieredapproachbyCDOT[is]focusedonbringinginandsupportingsmallerfirmsthattraditionallyhaven’tbeensuccessfulproposingonCDOTprojects.”[WT#8]
![Page 559: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/559.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 132
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“Beingtheprimeconsultantonthiscontracthasallowedustowinafairlysubstantial…intersectionupgradeproject,andwearehopingforfutureprojectsaswell.Irecommend[that]CityandCountyofDenverdosomethingsimilartoCDOT.Splitsomeofthecontinuingservicescontractsintosmalltierandlargetiercontracts.Denvercanthentargetsmallerbusinesseswithinthesmalltiercontract,therebyprovidingtheopportunityformeaningfulworkforsmallbusinesseswithinDenver.”[WT#8]
Another business owner said there is an “artificial cap” on the size of contracts awarded to
professional services firms.TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“Ifyou’rearound…afive‐yearcontract,ifyou’rereachinganywhere[from]$1.5[or]$3million,you’re…goingtoseethatartificialcap.You’regonnaseewhatthey’regivinginDenvertosmallbusinessunlessyou’reintrucking,unlessyou’reintrafficcontrol,[or]unlessyou’reinconstruction.Ifyou’reprofessionalservices,you'regoingto…verymuchsee…acapthat’sgiventous.”[PT#3a]
G. Allegations of Unfair Treatment
Intervieweesdiscussedpotentialareasofunfairtreatment,including:
Deniedopportunitytobid;
Bidshoppingandbidmanipulation;
Treatmentbyprimecontractorsandcustomersduringperformanceofthework;
Unfavorableworkenvironmentforminoritiesorwomen;and
Anydoublestandardsforminority‐orwoman‐ownedfirmswhenperformingwork.
Denied opportunity to bid. Theinterviewteamaskedbusinessownersandrepresentativesiftheyexperienceddenialoftheopportunitytobid.
Many interviewees indicated that they did not experience or have knowledge of denial of
opportunities to bid.[e.g.,#4,#15a,#36]Forexample:
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andESB‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmreportedthathehasneverbeendeniedanopportunitytosubmitabidorpricequote.However,henotedthatinsomecaseshedoesnotreceivethesolicitationsthatotherpotentialfirmsreceive.Heexplained,“Bythetimewedofindoutaboutit,we’reaweekawayfromwhentheinformationisdue.Normally,ifyouworkwithinaprojectlikethatyouneedthreeweeksoramonthtodeterminewhatitisthatyou’reaskingfor[and]seewhereyoufigureintoit….”[#9]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringfirmreportedthatshehasneverbeendeniedtheopportunitytosubmitapricequotetoaprime.[#5]
TheBlackAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaidshehasneverbeendeniedtheopportunitytobid,butcommented,“For[this]industry,youloseabout20percent[ofwhat]youthrow…againstthewall.”[#13]
![Page 560: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/560.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 133
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmreportedthatshehasnotbeendeniedtheopportunitytosubmitabidorpricequotetoaprimecontractor.Shecommentedthatherproblemiswinningbids,notbeingdeniedtheopportunitytobid.[#35]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmreportedthathehasnotexperiencedanyunfairdenialofbidopportunities.[#14]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmstatedthattheirfirmhasneverbeendeniedtheopportunitytosubmitapricequotetoacustomer.[#23a]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmstatedthatshehasneverbeendeniedtheopportunitytosubmitabidorpricequotetoaprimecontractor.[#20]
Whenaskedifthefirmhaseverbeendeniedtheopportunitytosubmitabidorpricequotetoaprime,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmstated,“Therearetimeswhenwe'returneddowntogetonajobbecauseofwhateverreason.Wemaynothavetheresumetodoaspecificjob,eventhoughIthinkwedo.Theownerortheclientmaynotthinkso,sotherearetimeswegetrejectedaswell.”[#21a]
Most trade association and business assistance organization representatives reported no
knowledge of members being denied bid opportunities.Forexample:
TheHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthathehasnotheardofmemberfirmsbeingdeniedtheopportunitytosubmitabidorpricequotetoaprime.[#11]
Whenaskedifhehaseverheardofmembersbeingdeniedtheopportunitytosubmitabidorpricequotetoaprime,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationstatedthathehasnot.[#33]
Whenaskedifmembershaveeverbeendeniedbidopportunities,theBlackAmericanfemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationreportedthat,toherknowledge,theyhavenot.[#6]
Other interviewees reported being denied opportunities to bid, or not knowing, but suspecting, denial of opportunity for bid might have occurred.[e.g.,#14,#18]Forexample:
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthathisfirmwasdeniedtheopportunitytosubmitabid.Heexplained,“Weweretold,byanon‐minorityprime,thatweweren’tpartoftheirgroupandcouldnotbid.[Wewere]notpartoftheprimarygroupofcontractorsthattheyuse.Idon’tknowwhy.Maybebecausethey’dmetusinpersonandtheynoticedwedidn’tlooklikeeveryoneelsewhowasinthe
![Page 561: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/561.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 134
room.That’stheonlythingIcouldthinkof.Itrynottogothere,butthat’stheonlythingIsawthatwasobviouslydifferent.”[#7]
Thesamebusinessco‐ownerlatersharedanexampleofatimewhenhisfirmwasnotinvitedtothetabletobid.Hesaid,“Therewasacompanythatweknowbecauseweknowalotofthepeoplewhodothesameworkthatwedo.So,wewenttobidonajobinDenverataschoolonanasbestosjob.Weheardaboutitthroughanemployeeoftheschool,[and]whenwe[inquiredabout]bid[ding]…[we]didn’tgetacallback.Andthen[we]foundoutfromanothercompanythat’salittlebitlargerthanusandthathasitsownconnections,thattheygotthebidtwoweeksprior.”[#7]
Hecontinued,“Wefinallygotacallthreeweekslaterthatsaid,‘Oh,thebidjustclosed,’butweknewthefirmhadalreadystartedworkonthejob.”HewentontosaythathetoldDenverPublicSchoolsthatheheardtheprojecthadalreadybegun,andtheyrespondedthatitmusthavebeenamistakeandthatpaperworkmayhavegottenlost.Headded,“Eitherway,weknewwhywedidn’tgetit[because]theotherfirmtolduswhytheygotit.Theyknewasuperintendent,andthat’showtheygotthejob.”[#7]
Whenaskedifherfirmhaseverbeendeniedtheopportunitytosubmitabidorpricequotetoaprime,thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthatprimeshavetoldherfirmthattheydonotwanttopartner.Sheexplained,“Theysaynoallthetime,butIthinkit’sdifferentthanwithcontractorswhomightwanttogetthreedrywallquotes.That’snothowRFPsinarchitecturework,typically.Theywon’tgetquotesbecausethequoteisnotthemostimportantthing.It’saboutthefancyproposal.Thedocumentthattheyputtogether,orthat…weputtogether.Alotoftimestheyalreadyhavealandscapearchitect.They’reusingthesameonethatthey’vealwaysused.”[#12]
Thesamebusinessownerlatersaidthatshedoesbelievethatsomefirmsaredeniedopportunitiestobidduetodiscrimination.Sheexplained,“Idefinitelyfeelliketherearepowerstructuresthatarewhite,male‐dominated….[Somemaythink],‘What’sthatgirldoing?Whatdoessheknow?’”[#12]
Whenaskedifhehaseverbeendeniedtheopportunitytosubmitabidorpricequotetoaprime,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmstated,“Yes,sometimestheprimehasalreadyselectedsomeoneelsewhodoeswhatwedo.”[#22]
One business assistance organization representative indicated that some members are denied
bid opportunities.Whenaskedifshehasknowledgeofmembersbeingdeniedtheopportunitytosubmitabidorpricequotetoaprime,theNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationstated,“Onthepublicsectorside,I’veheardfrommemberswhosaytheirbidwasrejectedbecausetheydidn’tusetherightcolorink,theydidn’tputitinafolder,andotherlittlethings.Whenitcomestotheprimesdirectly,it’stheissuesthatopportunitiesareoutthere,butthesmallcompanydidn’thearaboutthem.Bythetimetheyhear,theopportunitiesarealreadyfilled.That’swhenIremindthemhowimportant
![Page 562: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/562.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 135
relationship‐buildingis.Theyconstantlyhavetoremindtheprimesthatthey’rethere.[Ifthey’re]outofsight,[they’re]outofmind.”[#37]
Bid shopping and bid manipulation.Businessownersandrepresentativesoftenreportedbeingconcernedaboutbidshopping,bidmanipulation,andtheunfairdenialofcontractsandsubcontractsthroughthosepractices.
Many interviewees indicated that bid shopping and/or bid manipulation exists or they felt
that it might be prevalent.[e.g.,#21a,#36,WT#5]Forexample:
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmsaid,“Bidshoppingisverycommonandpitssmallbusinessesagainsteachother.”Shewentontosaythatsheisnotawareofbidmanipulation.[#20]
Regardingbidshoppingandbidmanipulation,theBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmsaid,“Inthepublicsector,certainvendorsarecontactedwellbeforethebidcomesout,andthey’vetoldmeaboutit.Iplayedgolfwiththemandtheysaid,‘Ohyeah…Iwastoldaboutthattwomonthsagobutwejustdidn’twanttodoit[because]it’stoosmall,’or,‘Weknowanothercompanygotthatbidalready,[so]don’twasteyourtimeapplying.’”[#7]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andESB‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmstatedthathesuspectsthatbidshoppingandmanipulationoccur.Hesaid,“IwasatanoutreachmeetingandoneofthethingsthatIwastoldwasthatifyouwanttoparticipateinthis,youdoaboothandtheprimes[willbe]aroundand…stopandtalktoanybody.AndInoticedthatoneprimespentbasically95percentofhistimetalkingtoaparticularbusinessandthattheonlywaythatIcouldgethimtocomeoverandtalktousaboutwhatwe’redoingwasactuallytograbtheguyandstophimashewaswalkingby….Hegaveme30secondswhereashejustspentanhourwiththisothervendor.Whatdoesitallmean?Idon'tknow.”[#9]
Themalerepresentativeofawoman‐ownedspecialtyservicesfirmsaid,“Ourgeneralcommentisthatinthecommercialofficebuildingjanitorialmarket,largeofficebuildingmanagershirenationalfirmsundernationalbids.Someofthesefirmswinonpricebycheating….”Heexplained,“Weconfirmedthatabidderforoneoftheprojectshaslegal/union/regulatoryactionagainstthemin[four]differentnationalmarkets.Manybidprojectsonanationalpricestructurearewillingtolosemoneyinsomemarketswherewagesarehigher,astheyareabletomakeupforitinothercities,takingtheprofitandmoneyoutofthelocaleconomy.”[WT#1]
Whenaskedaboutbarriersordiscriminationregardingbidshopping,theHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaid,“Theyjusttellyou,‘Yourbidistoohigh.Thankyouverymuch,goodbye.’”[#35]
Whenaskedaboutbarriersordiscriminationrelatedtobidshopping,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmstated,“Ithappensallthetimewithus.”Headded,“Ithappensmoresoinprivatework….
![Page 563: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/563.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 136
Evenwiththefederalgovernmenttheyhavetochoosebasedonqualifications,andsotheychoseseveralfirmstodoon‐callworkandtheybideachspecifictaskorder.Wetoldthem,‘Youcan’tdothat.Youcan’tbidusagainsteachother.’Theycomebackwith,‘We’vealreadyselectedonqualifications,butweusebestvaluebecauseoftheBrooksAct.’Buttheyalwaysgaveittothelowestbidder.”[#22]
Regardingbidshoppingandbidmanipulation,theNativeAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,SDB‐,SDVOSB‐,andHUBZone‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmsaid,“Ithinkthatabuyerisgoingtohavepresetperceptions,anditcouldmakeadifferencewhen[choosingabidder].”Hewentontorecallasituationwhereheaskedtobidandthebuyerproceededtomakeapurchasewithouthisbid.Henoted,“Thathappensmoresowiththegovernment.”[#39]
One business assistance organization representative indicated that members may have
experienced bid manipulation.Whenaskedifmembersfaceanybarriersordiscriminationrelatedtobidshopping,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaidthathehasheardofmembersquittingpublicworkbecausethesamecompaniesalwaysseemtogetthecontracts.Hestated,“That’swhysomememberswon’tplayinthatspace.”[#33]
Thesamebusinessassistanceorganizationrepresentativealsosaid,“Memberssaytheyoftendon’tbidbecausetheyalreadyknowthattheCityandCounty[ofDenver]willtakethelowbid,notthebestbid.”[#33]
Another business assistance organization representative said that members have not
acknowledged the presence of bid manipulation.TheNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationreportedthatshehasnotheardfrommembersthatbidshoppingorbidmanipulationispresentintheDenvermarketplace.[#37]
Several interviewees do not perceive bid manipulation and/or bid shopping as prevalent, or
are not bothered by it.Forinstance:
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmindicatedthatshedoesnotperceivetheretobeanybidmanipulationorbidshopping.[#27]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmreportedthatheisnotawareofanyissuessurroundingbidshoppingorbidmanipulation.[#23b]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthatshehasnotexperienceddiscriminationorbarriersinregardstobidmanipulation.[#12]
A few interviewees discussed whether there are unfair denials of contract awards or unfair
termination of contracts in the marketplace.Whilesomesaidtheyareunawareofsuchdenials,[e.g.,#5,#11,#23b,#35]othersreportedfirsthandexperienceofunfairtreatment.Commentsinclude:
![Page 564: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/564.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 137
TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“TherewasoneinstancewhenwewereasubtoanengineeringfirmthatcontractswithDenverPublicWorks.Wewereontheteambecausetheyhadtomeetgoals.WewereaskedtodothedesignandtheDenverprojectmanagerdidn’tlikethedesign.Insteadofworkingwithustochangethedesignoralterit,heinstructedtheengineeringcompanytohirethisfirmoutof[LosAngeles]todothedesign.And[so]wewerekickedofftheteam.”[#22]
TheBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionsupplyfirmstatedthatunfairdenialofcontractssometimesoccursbecauseagenciesdonotenforcetheirdiversityprograms.[#36]
TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“AspecificexampleofwhatIbelievetobediscriminationisthatwhenwehadanon‐call…contractwithDenvermanyyearsago,wewereaskedtodo[a]short‐termprojecttoenablethethenvacant[public]buildingtobeusedasatemporaryeventvenue.”[WT#2]
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“AfterItouredthebuilding,Igavemyprofessionalopinionthatthereweretoomanylifesafetyissuestoovercomethatitwouldrequiremuchmoretimeandmoneythan[CityandCountyofDenver]hadtospendontheproject.Eventually,alarger…firmthatalsohadanon‐callcontractwasgiventhecommissiontoupgradethebuilding.”[WT#2]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmstatedthathebelievestheretobeunfairdenialsofcontractawardsandunfairterminationofcontractsinthemarketplace.[#7]
TheNativeAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,SDB‐,SDVOSB‐,andHUBZone‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmcommentedthatmunicipalitiessometimes“taketheroadofleastresistance”whenitcomestofactorspublicagenciesorothersusetomakecontractawards.[#39]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmreportedthathehasnotexperiencedanyunfairdenialofcontractrewardsorunfairterminationofcontracts.[#14]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmstated,“No….Idon'tseediscrimination.Iseeabusinesscommunityandabusinessatmospherewhereifyoudon’tdogoodwork,you’renotgoingtogetthework.”[#21a]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofanSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaidthatshehasnoknowledgeofanyunfairdenialsofcontractawardsorunfairterminationofcontractsinthemarketplace.[#15a]
![Page 565: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/565.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 138
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmstatedthatshehasneverexperiencedanyissueswithunfairterminationofcontracts.[#20]
One business assistance organization representative discussed members’ experiences with
unfair denials of contract awards and unfair termination of contracts. TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaidthathehadheardofunfairdenialofcontractawardsamongmembers.Regardingunfairterminationofcontracts,hesaidthathehasalsoheardofit,andnotedthatmembersfeelthereisnorecourse.HereportedthatonememberwasremovedfromaDenverprojectbecausetheprojectmanagerwantedtoworkwithacompanyoutofLosAngeles.[#33]
Treatment by prime contractors and customers during performance of the work.Anumberofbusinessownersandrepresentativesdescribedtheirexperienceswithunfairtreatmentbycontractorsandcustomersduringperformanceofwork,orwithapprovalofwork.[e.g.,#2#22]Forexample:
TheBlackAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaidthatwomeninconstructionareoftenquestionedabouttheirabilitiesandknowledgeofthework,andcommented,“They’llneveraskanyguyin[the]room[those]questions.”Shelatersaidthatinherexperience,younger,college‐agedwomenbecomediscouragedbecauseofthistreatment.[#13]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthatshehasabsolutelyexperienceddiscriminationandbarriersregardinghowsheistreatedduringperformanceofwork.Sheexplained,“Icangoonaconstructionsite.Inowhavegrayhair.Icangooutwithmysonwho’s[inhismid‐20s]andwe’llbetalkingtosomebodyinthefieldaboutsomeconstructiontechnique,andtheireyeswillimmediatelygotowardsthatmaleeventhoughI’vebeendoingthisfor30years.Thepresumptionisthattheguyisgoingtohavesomethingmoremeaningfultosay,whichistotallynottrue.Idon’tthinkthisisparticulartotheCityofDenver.Ithinkthatsocietyingeneralisresistanttowomenbeingauthorityfiguresintheworldofconstruction.”[#12]
Whenaskedaboutanyunfairtreatmentbyprimecontractorsorcustomersduringperformanceofwork,theBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmsaid,“ThishappenswhenIhavetofigureoutwhichemployeeIcansendtoaparticularjob.IfIwanttogetagoodreferralfromthemandgetmorework,Ihavetothink,‘Arewesending[ourwhiteemployee]or[ourHispanicemployee]?’”Hecontinued,“We[maybe]can’tsend[ourHispanicemployee]to[a]jobbecausewemightnotgetanymorebusiness.”[#7]
Thesamebusinessco‐ownercontinued,“Togetabid,wesend[theotherco‐owner’s]wifebecauseshe’sCaucasian,toturninourpaperwork.”Hewentontocomment,“We’relearningtoplaythegame.It’snotworthit,asasmallbusiness,tofightit.”[#7]
Regardinganyunfairtreatmentofthefirmduringperformanceofwork,thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemaleco‐ownerofaspecialtyservicesfirmstatedthatshebelievesherfirmhas
![Page 566: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/566.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 139
experiencedgender‐baseddiscrimination.Sheexplained,“Whenpeopleseeacorporationthat’sdoing[mylineofwork],theydon’texpecttowalkinandseethatit’sawoman‐ownedcompanyandawoman‐runcompany.Acouplecustomershavenotstayedherewhentheyrealizedthat.”[#8]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmreportedthatheisawareofinstanceswheresomeprimestreatsubcontractorsunfairly.Henotedthatthefirmstrivestotreattheirsubsequitably.[#21a]
One business owner commented that some MWBE firms choose to “suffer quietly” on the
jobsite to avoid harassment.TheBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“Ihaveoftenhadrudecommentsandremarksmadetomewhileonlocation….Someofthefieldconstructionworkersaretheworst,andthemostignorant.Withsomefirms,ifyoucomplainoraddresstheissueshead‐on,youareviewedassensitiveandtheywillgooutoftheirwaytomakeyourlifehellthenexttimetheseeyou.That'swhymanyMWBEfirms‘sufferquietly’sotheycancontinueinbusiness.”[WT#12]
One business assistance organization representative reported on barriers faced by members
related to unfair treatment.Whenaskedifmembersfaceanybarriersordiscriminationrelatedtotreatmentbyprimesorcustomersduringperformanceofwork,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaid,“[It’s]notonly[among]theminoritycommunity,butalsowomen.”Hecontinuedtostatethatminorityandwomenmembers“probably”alsofaceproblemswithapprovalofwork.[#33]
Many interviewees reported little or no experiences with unfair treatment by prime
contractors and customers during performance of work, or with approval of work. [e.g.,#20]Forexample:
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmstated,“Wehaveneverhadanyissueswithprimeswe’veworkedwith.Theyjustwantthejobdonecorrectly.”[#27]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andESB‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmreportedthathehasnotexperiencedpoortreatmentbyprimesorcustomersduringperformanceofwork.[#9]
Whenaskedaboutbarriersordiscriminationregardingtreatmentbyprimesorcustomersduringperformanceofwork,theHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaidthatsheisnottreatedunfairlyorotherwisepoorly.[#35]
Regardingapprovaloftheworkbyprimesorcustomers,thesamebusinessownerstated,“SofarIhaven’thadanyproblems.AfterIcleansomething,Itendtoaskthemtowalktheprojectwithmeandapprove[of]whatIdid.Peoplehavebeenveryhonest.”[#35]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmreportedthathehasnotexperiencedunfairtreatmentbyprimecontractors
![Page 567: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/567.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 140
orcustomers.Headdedthatapprovalofhisfirm’sworkbyprimecontractorsandcustomershasnotbeenanissueeither.[#14]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmreportednoknowledgeofunfairtreatmentbyprimecontractorsorcustomersduringperformanceofwork.Headdedthatheisnotawareofdiscriminationinapprovalofworkbyprimesorcustomers.[#23b]
Whenaskedifhehaseverexperiencedanyunfairtreatmentbyaprimeorcustomerduringperformanceofwork,orwithapprovalofwork,theBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionsupplyfirmsaid,“Oncewegetsomeoneforacustomer,Idon’tthinkthereareanyproblems.”[#36]
One business assistance organization representative indicated that members do not
experience unfair treatment by prime contractors or customers.TheNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationreportedthatmembershavenotcomplainedaboutunfairtreatmentbyprimecontractorsorcustomers,oraboutissueswithapprovalofwork.[#37]
Unfavorable work environment for minorities or women.Businessownersandrepresentativesdiscussedwhetherthereareunfavorableworkenvironmentsspecificallyforminoritiesorwomen.
A number of businesses reported experiences with unfavorable work environments for
minorities or women. Forexample:
TheBlackAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaid,“Ihadaguythatsaidtomysuperintendent,whowaswhite,[during]alunchbreak[while]theguyswerewalkingoff.He[said],‘Oh,itlooksliketheMexicanDayParade.’”Sheaddedthatquestionsareoftenaskedaboutwhetherornottheyarequalifiedorlegal.Shewentontosay,“Ihavetosaythatifyoureportit,thecityisverygood…they’reverysupportive.That,I’llgiveacrosstheboardinalltheagencies.”[#13]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“Iwouldsaybecausewe’veworkedintheconstructionspaceforyearsteamingwithcontractorstobuildourprojects,architectsandengineersareabilliontimesmoresexistthancontractorsare.ArchitectsandengineerstomearesomeofthemostunbelievablysexistmenI’veevermet.”[#12]
Thesamebusinessowneralsosaid,“Ithinkintermsofracialharassment,mostofthepeoplewhobuildourprojects[thatfacethat]areimmigrants.Ihaveheardclientssayhorriblethings…notthatoften,butoccasionally.”Sheadded,“Withinouroffice,wearedeeplycommittedtosupportingtheworkforcethat’sinthefieldandtreatingthemwithabsoluterespect.That’sreallyimportantinourcompany.”[#12]
Shecontinued,“Intermsofsexism,I’vehadyoungfemalesworkherewhohavecomplainedaboutbeingogledoutinthefield.I’mlike,‘Well,thenjustwearmoreclothes.Cover
![Page 568: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/568.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 141
yourselfupmore.Ifyou’regoingtogooutonajobsiteinshortshorts,whichIdon’tcare,youcandothatifyouwantto,butpeopleareprobablygoingtolookatyourlegs….Youneedtogetoverthat.’”[#12]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleownerofaspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthathehasbeendiscriminatedagainstbecauseofhisethnicity.Hestated,"IalwaysgetacertainlookwhenIsitinaroom….IalwaysgetthefeelingthatIneedtoprovemyself."Toavoidtensioninmeetings,hecommented,"I'veevengonetothepointwhereI'vetakenaCaucasianemployeewithmetokindofeasethatissue."Healsonoted,"Ibelieve[discrimination]ismoreofaproblemintheprivatesectorthanthepublicsector."[#4]
Thesamebusinessowneraddedthatdiscriminationhasaffectedhisinteractionswithothercontractorsandclients.Hesaid,“Ihavecomeuponjobswhere…assoonas[contractors]metme,IfeltlikeIwasbrushedoff.Iwastakenseriouslywhiletheyweretalkingtomeonthephoneandemailingme,butassoonaswe[met],IfeltlikeIwasnot[takenseriously].I'llbesittingatmydeskintheofficeandsomebodywillwalkintotalkbusinessandI'mnotthefirstpersontheywalkto,eventhoughI'matthebiggestdesk.They'llwalkuptosomebodyelseand[assume]thatthey'rethebossor…theowner…."[#4]
Hewentontosaythatheexperiencedmorediscriminationwhenheworkedasanemployeeofothercompanies.Hestated,"ItfeltlikeIwasn'tallowedtogooncertainjobsorbeincertainareasofthebuilding.Ithinkitwasmainly[tokeep]mefrombeingthefaceofthecompany….Theywanttoshowadifferentcolorinfront,andtheydon'tcarewhatyoulooklikeintheback,doingthework…."[#4]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmsaid,“Itsoundsbad,butalotofpeopledon’twantcertainminoritygroupsontheirproperty…mainlytheHispanicminoritygroup.WehirealotofHispanics.Igrewupin[California],soIgrewupwithalotofMexicans….And[in]thecurrent,Iguess,politicalenvironment,ifyoucometoajobsiteandit’sfiveHispanics,typicallyyou…getlookeddownonbecausetheythinkyouhavesomeillegalimmigrantsworkingforyou,and[that]you’repayingthem$2anhourorsomethingcrazylikethat.”[#7]
Thesamebusinessco‐ownercontinued,“Rather,ifIshowuptoajobsitewithfivewhiteguys,I’mtreatedcompletelydifferently.Nowit’sseenasaprofessionalenvironment.Ihaveprofessionalworkersandthehomeowners,oreventhesmallbusinesses,feelmorecomfortablewithcertainworkers.It’sastigmathat’scomingaround.Ibelieveit’srelatedtothelastyearandahalf’spoliticalenvironment.Before,Hispanicswereconsideredhardworkers.Nowpeoplethinkthey’restealingjobs.So,it’saffectedus.IliterallyhavetoknowwhatjobI’mbiddingonbecauseyougetpartofthejobandthenyougetpaidonthesecondhalfofthejob.IfIhavethewrongemployees,Iwillnotgetthesecondhalfofthejob.Ijustwon’tgetit….So,youreallyhavetoknowwhoyou’rebiddingwith,andIhavetoplaythatgame,unfortunately,ifIwanttostayinbusiness.”[#7]
Whenaskedifhehasexperiencedanydiscriminationintheformofoffensivecommentsorbehavior,hesaid,“You’llhearjokeslike,‘Theysaidyouguysarelazy,buteverytimeIturn
![Page 569: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/569.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 142
aroundyouguysarebiddingonsomething,’[referringto]Blackguys.They’retoldthatBlackmenarelazy….We’veheardthatoneandwesortoflaughitoff.Youwanttosaysomethingbutyoudon’t,becauseit’snotworthit.”Headdedthatthishappensinboththepublicandprivatesector,andsaidthatitistheinspectorswhomakethejokesinthepublicsector.[#7]
Whenaskedifshehasanyknowledgeofunfavorableworkenvironmentsforminoritiesorwomen,thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringfirmsaidthatshehasexperiencedoffensivecommentsandbehaviorbecauseofhergender.Sheaddedthatshehasreceivedmailaddressedtoasimilarmalenamebecausethesenderassumesthattheyarewritingtoaman.[#5]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“Wereceivedour[certifications]andhavebeenpursuingpublicsectorworkeversince.Thishasprovedextremelychallenging,anddespitethesuccesseshighlightedonourwebsiteandonourSOQ,Ifeelthatgenderdiscriminationisrampant,notonlyintheCityofDenver,butthroughouttheFrontRangeofColoradoandmostlikelythroughoutthecountry.”[WT#11]
Apublicmeetingparticipantsaid,“Hispanicpeopleseemtobenowthefocusondoingthelowerthinginthecommunity….Imean,[it’s]true.”[PT#4]
One business assistance organization representative commented that unfavorable work
environments for minorities and women are “probably underreported.”TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaidthathehasheardofunfavorableworkenvironmentsforminoritiesandwomen.Headded,“Therealityisit’sprobablyunderreportedbecausecompaniesareafraidofretaliation.”[#33]
A trade association representative said that race “absolutely plays a role” when it comes to
getting work opportunities.TheBlackAmericanfemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaid,“Wewouldliketothinkit’sgone,butraceabsolutelyplaysaroleinopportunitiesthatareprovided….Onethingaboutracism[isthat]it’snotsomethingthatyoucanwearorsee,soyou’renotquitesurewhatresidesbehindtheeyesofeachpersonyouseeorencounter.”[#6]
Thesametradeassociationrepresentativecontinued,“It’sveryinterestingtoseehow[or]ifalotofwhatisreallyhappeningiscaptured,because[of]…thesubtletiesthroughwhichalotofthesethingsaretakingplace….There’snodoubtthatracismstillexists.Withthiscurrentadministration,there’sbeensucharesurgenceofit.Before,itseemedlikewehadsomuchmoreunity.Unfortunately,alotofpeoplehavehadtheboldnesstocomeforwardwiththeirtrueself,theirtruesetofbeliefs.”[#6]
Others reported no experience with unfavorable work environment for minorities or women. [e.g.,#11,#14,#22,#23a,#32b,#35]Forexample:
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmreportedthatshehasnothadanypersonalexperienceswithbarriersrelatedto
![Page 570: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/570.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 143
discriminatorytreatment.Sheadded,“Ihonestlydon’tthinkthere[arebarriers]forDBEs,MBEs,andSBEsifyou[fit]yourcompanywiththebestprofessionals.”[#2]
Thesamebusinessco‐ownerwentontosaythatfinancingwasachallengewhenshestartedherbusiness,thoughshedidnotfeeldiscriminatedagainstbasedonherraceorgender.Shesaidshewasmetwithdifficultiesbecauseshewasjuststartingoutasasmallbusiness,andadded,“Whenyou’resmall,youhavealotmoredebtthanthey…probably[want]tosee….I…believethat[somebanks]have…safeguardsinplace.[Banksmaythink],‘Weseeyourgrowingpotential,butwedon’tfeelcomfortablewithyou.’”[#2]
Shelaterstatedthatshebelievesrace/ethnicityandgenderdiscriminationcancreatepotentialbarriers.However,shenotedthattheDBE,MBE,andSBEprogramsreducethediscriminatorybehaviorsignificantly.[#2]
Whenaskedifhehasexperiencedorisawareofanyunfavorableworkenvironmentsforminoritiesorwomen,theBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionsupplyfirmsaid,“Notblatantly.Oneofmysalesguyshadmeetingswithsomelargetransportationcompanies.It’sfunnytoseehowthedynamicchangeswhenI’maround.Hejokedwithmeafteronemeetingsayinghedidn’twantmetoattendagain.”[#36]
Whenaskedaboutpotentialbarriersordiscriminationbasedonrace,ethnicity,orgender,theSubcontinentAsianAmericanmaleownerofaspecialtycontractingfirmstatedthathehasnotexperiencedanysuchbarriers.Headdedthathehasnotheardofanyothercontractorsexperiencingrelatedbarriersordiscriminationeither.[#18]
Whenaskedifrace,ethnicity,orgenderdiscriminationaffectshisbusinessopportunities,theBlackAmericanveteranmaleownerofageneralcontractingcompanystated,“Idon’tdopublicwork.AlmostallofmycustomersareBlack.Ihaven’thadanyproblemsthathaveaffectedmysuccess.”[#29]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andESB‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmreportednoexperiencewithunfavorableworkenvironmentsforminoritiesorwomen.[#9]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleownerofanengineeringfirmreportedthat,tohisknowledge,hehasnotexperiencedanyrace/ethnicity‐baseddiscrimination.[#16]
Regardingunfavorableworkenvironmentsforminoritiesorwomen,theHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofanSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaidthatthefirmhasnotexperiencedany.[#15a]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaconstructionservicesfirmstated,“Ihaven’thadanyexperiencesofdiscriminationbasedonrace,ethnicity,[or]gender.”However,hewentontocomment,“I’mnotinapositiontodiscussthatarea.”[#31]
![Page 571: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/571.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 144
TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmstated,“Therehavebeennoinstancesexperiencedofdiscrimination,byme,oranyofmyemployees.”[#32a]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmreportedthatshehasneverexperiencedanyunfavorableworkenvironmentsforminoritiesorwomen.[#20]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmsaidthathehasnotheardoforexperiencedoffensivecomments,behavior,orracialorsexualharassmentofSBE/MBE/WBEoruncertifiedminority‐orwomen‐ownedfirmsinthelocalmarketplace.[#21a]
Any double standards for minority‐ or woman‐owned firms when performing work.Intervieweesdiscussedwhetherthereweredoublestandardsforminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesses.
A number of business owners and representatives reported double standards based on race,
ethnicity, or gender.Forexample:
Whenaskedabouthisexperiencesworkingwithminority‐ownedprimecontractors,theBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmsaid,“Minorityprimesaretypicallysmallbusinesses,and[they]seemtotakemorecareintheirworkethicthannon‐minorityprimesbecausetheyknowyousortofgetonechancetomakeamistake.So,minorityprimesseemtoworkbetter.”[#7]
Thesamebusinessco‐ownerlatersaid,“Ican’tputmyfingeronit,butanolderCaucasianmalewillgetperceiveddifferentlyonjobsitesthana[young]Blackmale.Itjustiswhatitis.Idon'tknowifthat’sanagething.[Maybe]theythinkhe’llbemoreexperienced[just]becauseofhisage.”[#7]
Regardingdoublestandardsbasedongender,hesaid,“[On]alotofjobsiteswehaveafemaleonourteamasaleadonabatement,and…theyconstantlyquestionherqualificationssolelybecauseshe’sawoman.Therewasnootherreasontoquestionitbecausetheydon’tquestionanyoneelse’squalificationsthatthey’venevermet,buttheyquestionhers.Theywanttoseeherprojectmanagementcertificates[and]wanttoseeherlogs.Theyneveraskforlogsbecauseit’sawasteoftime,buttheydidthattoher.”[#7]
TheNativeAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,SDB‐,SDVOSB‐,andHUBZone‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmindicatedthatdoublestandardsdoexistforminorities.Heexplained,“Ithinkitcouldbealittlebitharderifyouareapersonofcolorbecauseofpresetnotionsthatsomebodymighthave,orbeliefstheymighthave.Ithinktherearealwaysgoingtobebarriersoutthere,andthefencemightbealittlebithigherforapersonofcolorsometimes[because]you[haveto]proveyourselfmore.”[#39]
![Page 572: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/572.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 145
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaid“beingawomanintheconstructionindustry”means“youarenottakenseriouslyandnotgivenopportunitiestoproveyourself.”[WT#5]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“BackinthedayafterIleft[myprevious]jobandwantedtoworkforaprestigiousdowntownfirm,theyofferedmeajobasamarketinggirl.Iwaslike,‘WellIdon’twanttowriteproposalsandbeasecretary.Iwanttolearnconstructiondetails.’So,Iturneddown[the]job.Iremembermyfatherwasfuriouswithme,butIwaslike,‘I’mgoingtobeinatightskirtandI’mgoingtogethiredfor[non‐technicalskills],nottobealandscapearchitect.’”[#12]
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“Someoftheyoungwomenwhoworkformestated,‘Wewantedtoworkforyoubecauseweknewwe’dgetequalexposureontheconstructionside,whereasifweworkedforamale‐ownedfirmasfemalesontheconstructionside,itwouldbeharder.’”Shelateradded,“Ifyou’reapersonofcolororafemale,youhavetobetwiceasgood.Weknowthat.Awhitemalecandosomething[wrong]andpeoplearelike,‘Oh,that’sfine.’”[#12]
TheBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionsupplyfirmsaid,“Thereisabiasforsurewithfolksregardingaminority‐ownedbusinessaslessqualified.Butestablishedcustomersdon’tdropmewhentheyfindoutthebusinessisminority‐owned.”[#36]
Thesamebusinessownerlateradded,“Ithinktheyshowamajoritycompanymoreleniencywhentheymakeamistake.Ifaminoritymakesamistake,it’sblownwayoutofproportion.Everybodymakesmistakes.Theyshould[just]lookatwhatyoudid[and]fixit.”[#36]
For a few business owners, double standards did not exist, or were less prevalent than before.[e.g.,#5,#21a,#23a]Forexample:
Whenaskedaboutdoublestandards,unfairtreatment,andstereotypicalattitudestowardsminoritiesandwomeninthelocalmarketplace,theBlackAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmstated,“Idon’tthinkthey’rehappeningasmuchastheyusedto.Ithinkwe’vegottenbetter.But,I…rememberpeopleputnoosesuponajobsite.”[#13]
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“Ithinkit’sgoodtohavechange.Ithinkit’salsobadtohavepeopleinthesamespotfor30or40years,withthesameattitude30yearsagoasthey[have]now.”Shesaidshewouldliketoseemorediversityinthecity,saying,“I’dliketoseemorediversityonthecity‐sideinthoseroles,notinthetypicalrolesofDSBO,butintheactualprocurementprojectmanagers.”[#13]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleownerofaspecialtycontractingfirmreportedbeingdiscriminatedagainst,particularlyintheprivatesector,butnoted,“It'snotasbadasitwas
![Page 573: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/573.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 146
20yearsago.Generationsgobyandpeoplearechanging.IsawitmoreasayoungeradultthanIdonow."[#4]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmstatedthatdoublestandardinperformancearenotanissueforhisfirm.[#14]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofanSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaidthatthefirmhasnotexperiencedanydoublestandardswhenperformingwork.[#15a]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmreportedthatshehasneverexperiencedanyissueswithdoublestandardsinperformance.[#20]
Some business owners discussed whether there is a fair playing field in the Denver
marketplace.Commentsinclude:
TheBlackAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmindicatedthatthereisnotafairplayingfieldinthelocalmarketplace.However,shenotedthatcertifications“sortof[get]youasemi‐levelplayingfield.”[#13]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemaleco‐ownerofaspecialtyservicesfirmsaidthatshefeelsmale‐ownedbusinesseshaveanadvantage.Sheadded,“Iknowpeoplearemoreapttorefertoamale‐basedcompany.I’veheardfromsomebodywhousedtodo[mylineofwork],anddoorsopenedforhimlikecrazywhenpeoplefoundoutwhathedid.”[#8]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedgeneralcontractingfirmsaidthatwhilesheisrelativelynewtoherindustry,shenolongerseesherlackofexperienceandexpertiseasanissue.Shestated,“IrecognizeIamnewtothisindustry.Constructionisstillawhiteman’sworld.TherehavebeentimeswhenI’vegonetoapre‐conandtheyhavenotaddressedme.Justonegentleman[maybe],butitdoesn’tbothermeanymorebecauseIgetthework.Thereisstillplentyofworktobehad.I’dsay99percentofthecontractorsoutthereareveryopen.”[#19]
TheBlackAmericanmaleandveteranownerofaDBE‐,ACDBE‐,WMBE‐,SBE‐,SBEC‐,andSDVOSB‐certifiedspecialtyservicesfirmsaid,“Asownerofasmall…companyinthemetroareaIfinditamazingthat[acorporation]currentlyworkingat[DenverInternationalAirport]hasbeenthereover20years.Surelyacontractofthatsizeshouldhaveenrichedtheownerswellabovetheestablishedthresholdofgraduationeligibility.”[WT#9]
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“ThereasonthatIwasgivenisthatnoothercompanycandosuchamassivejob.Well,Ibelievethatafewsmallcompaniesfromthisareacould.Itappearsthatforsomereasonsomecompaniesarebeingallowedtomonopolizetheirpositionswhileotherssitonthesidelines.Thisisindirectconflictwiththewaytheruleswerewritten….Greedandelitismruletheday.”[WT#9]
![Page 574: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/574.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 147
One trade association representative stated that minority‐ and women‐owned firms “do not
have a level playing field in today's environment.”TheHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationaddedthatcertificationgivesthesefirmsanopportunityto“getapieceofthepie”onpublicprojects.[#11]
H. Insights Regarding Race‐/Ethnicity‐ or Gender‐Based Discrimination
Thestudyteamaskedintervieweesaboutwhethertheyexperiencedorwereawareofotherpotentialformsofdiscriminationaffectingminoritiesorwomen,orminority‐andwomen‐ownedbusinesses.ThispartofAppendixJexaminestheirdiscussionof:
Anystereotypicalattitudesaboutminoritiesorwomen(orMBE/WBE/DBEs);
Anyevidenceofa“goodol’boy”networkorotherclosednetworks;
Anyotherallegationsofdiscriminatorytreatment;and
Factorsthataffectopportunitiesforminoritiesorwomentoenterandadvanceintheindustry.
Any stereotypical attitudes about minorities or women (or MBE/WBE/DBEs).Anumberofbusinessownersandrepresentativesreportedonstereotypesthatnegativelyaffectminority‐andwomen‐ownedfirms.[e.g.,#7,WT#5]Forexample:
Whenaskedaboutanystereotypicalattitudesonthepartofcustomersorbuyers,thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringfirmcommentedthatitisjustbasedon“nuance.”Sheadded,“Peoplewillsaythingslike,‘Oh,thatgirlengineer….’Noonewouldeversay,‘Oh,thatboyengineer,’[or]‘Oh,thatboydoctor.’”[#5]
TheBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“IcantrulysaythatIhaveexperiencedracialdiscriminationintheDenver,[Colorado]region.IhavehadmanysituationswhereIhavedonemarketingtoarchitectural/engineering/constructionfirmsandhaveimmediatelyfeltthenegativeracialvibeofbeinganAfricanAmericanmale.WithsomepeopleIhavecomeacross,themindsetisthistypeof…workistobedonebyawhitemanonly…notapersonofcolororawoman.”[WT#12]
Thesamebusinessownerlatersaid,“Ihaveexperiencedbarriersputinplacetoblockmefromgainingaccesstosomeofthebetterprojectsinthisregion,[both]privateandpublic.Ihavehadsituationswhereaconstructioncompanyoranarchitecturalfirmappearstobeveryinterestedinthequalityof[my]workIdoonlytodiscoverthat[it]wasdonebyatalentedAfricanAmericanmanandnotawhiteman.Atthatpoint,everythingchanges.IfIwasaskedtosubmitaproposal,suddenlyIdonotgetreturnedphonecallsoransweredemails,ortheproposalgetsstrungalongforweeksandmonths.”[WT#12]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmstatedthatshedoesbelievethereisdiscriminationinregardstostereotypicalattitudesonthepartofcustomersandbuyers.Shesaidthatoftenpeopleaskherwhat
![Page 575: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/575.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 148
flowerstoplant,andneverask[whatsheknows]inregardstoconcreteorotherconstructionaspects.Sheadded,“Iknowalotaboutflowers.Iknowwaymoreaboutflowersthanmostpeople,but[also]Iknowalotaboutconcreteandpavers,andregulationsaroundbuildingswimmingpools.Theexpectationisthatifyou’reagirl,you[only]planttheflowers[and]makesuretheflowersarereallypretty.”[#12]
TheBlackAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaidshelostallofhermanagerswithinamonthofhertakingoverthecompany.Shesaidtheytoldher,“Welikeyou.Wejustdon’tthinkyoucanmakeit.”Sheattributedgreatclients,generalcontractors,andtheCityofDenvertoherbeingabletopickherselfbackupandmoveforward.Sheaddedthatworkingona“keyproject”alsohelped.[#13]
Thesamebusinessownerlatersaidhadaleadershippositiononanadvisorycommitteeforaconstructioneducationproviderandsaidtherewasresistancetotheideaofawomenleadingthecommittee.[#13]
Whenaskedifheisawareofanystereotypicalattitudesinthemarketplaceregardingminoritiesorwomen,theBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionsupplyfirmstatedthatheisconvincedtheyexist,fromfinancingtohiringemployees.[#36]
TheSubcontinentAsianAmericanmaleownerofaspecialtycontractingfirmsaidthathehasexperiencedstereotypicalattitudesfromsomecustomersbasedonhisnamealone.Hesaidthathechangedthenameofhiscompanytosoundless“foreign”duetothis,andadded,“Therewasnothingspecificallysaid[bycustomers],Ijustfeltthatpeopledidn’tknowaboutmebecausethenamewasforeign.”Hewentontosaythathebelievestherearestill“rawfeelings”surroundingthe9/11terroristattacksthathavecausedpeopletoviewhimdifferently.[#18]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemaleco‐ownerofaspecialtyservicesfirmsaid,“Whenpeopleaskwhodoesmy[work]andIsay,‘Ido’,Ithinktheyaresurprised.Itellthem,‘Idon’tneedabig,burlymantodoit.Icandoitmyselfbypushingabutton.’”[#8]
Thesamebusinessco‐ownerwentontosaythatstereotypicalattitudesdoexistwhenitcomestowomen‐ownedbusinesses.Sheadded,“That’swhytherearesomanywomen‐ownedgroups[workingwithotherwomen].It’seasiertotalktowomenaboutit.It’salmostcliqueytryingtoholdontoalittlepartofthemarket.”[#8]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmsaid,“Ioperateinaman’sworldandoftenfacecredibilityissues,evenaftermanyyearsinbusinessandagreattrackrecord.”Sheadded,“Thisistrueformanywomensmallbusinessownersintheconstructionindustry.”[#20]
Regardingdiscriminationfacedbywomenintheconstructionindustry,theHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedgeneralcontractingfirmsaid,“Ithinkthereismorespeculation.NotbecauseI’maminority,butmorebecause
![Page 576: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/576.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 149
I’mawoman….Itisdifficulttoworkintheconstructionindustryasawoman.”Sheadded,“ThemoreI’moutthere,themorecomfortableothercontractorsfeel.Theyhavelearnedmyqualityofwork.”[#19]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andESB‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmsaidthathedoesbelievetherearesomestereotypicalattitudesonthepartofcustomersandbuyersregardingsmallbusinessesandminority‐ownedbusinesses.Hesaid,“Ibelievewehavereallygoodproducts,andanybodythat’sworkedwithuswouldrecommendusforotherwork.ButIalsoknowthatthere’sastigmaoutthereaboutsmallbusinessesandminoritybusinessesinparticular.”[#9]
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“But,we’vetriedtostayabovethat.Wedon’tgointoplacessaying,‘Youshouldgiveusapieceofbusinessbecausewe’reasmallbusinessorwe’reaminority‐ownedbusiness.’Wewanttobeabletocompetewitheverybodyelsethat’scompetingonthebasisoftheproductsthatwehave,theservicesthatweprovide,thepricingthatweprovide,andwhatwecanbringtothetable.”[#9]
Some trade association and business assistance organization representatives discussed
whether members experience any stereotypical attitudes on the part of customers or buyers.Forexample:
TheHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidhehasseendiscriminationagainstwomen‐andminority‐ownedfirmsinregardstostereotypicalattitudesonthepartofcustomersandbuyers.Heexplained,“Thishappensespeciallyinindustrieswhereminority[firms]are[underrepresented].[Becauseofthatunderrepresentation],youhearcommentsthatminoritiesdonotknowwhattheyaredoing.”[#11]
Whenaskedaboutmembers’experienceswithstereotypicalattitudesonthepartofcustomersandbuyers,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaidthatstereotypicalattitudesarestillaproblem,especiallyforimmigrants.Headdedthatsmallbusinessesareseenasriskierduetocapitalandworkforcechallenges.[#33]
Some interviewees reported no experience with stereotypes that negatively affected minority‐
or women‐owned firms.[e.g.,#15a,#21a,#23a,#28,#32a,#32b]Forexample:
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthathewasnotawareofanydiscriminationaffectingminority‐orwomen‐ownedfirmsinthelocalmarketplace.[#3]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaconstruction‐relatedfirmstatedthathehasnotexperiencedanydiscriminationbasedonrace,ethnicity,orgenderthathasinterferedwithsmallbusinesses’success.Headded,“Ihaveneverheardofanysituationsthathaveinterferedwiththesuccessofminoritycompanies.”[#25]
![Page 577: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/577.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 150
TheHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmstatedthatstereotypicalattitudesonthepartofcustomersandbuyersisnotanissueforhisfirm.[#14]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofanSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthatshehasnotexperiencedanystereotypicalattitudesbyprimecontractorsorcustomersintheindustry.[#15a]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmreportedthatshehasnotexperiencedstereotypicalattitudesthatnegativelyaffectminority‐orwomen‐ownedfirms.[#35]
Any “good ol’ boy” network or other closed networks. Manybusinessownersandrepresentativesreportedtheexistenceofa“goodol’boy”networkorotherclosednetworks.[e.g.,WT#11,WT#12,PT#3c]Forexample:
TheHispanicAmericanmaleownerofaspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthathehasexperienced"goodol'boy"networks.Hestated,"Iworkedfora[different]firmandIsawdiscriminationwithintheirnetworksthere.Thatwasoneofthethingsthatpushedmeto[start]myownbusiness.IknewthattherewasapointwhereIwasn'tallowed.Ibelieveitwasbecauseofthecolorofmyskin,forobviousreasons."Hecontinued,"SinceI'vebeeninbusinessonmyownIhaven'tnoticeditasmuch,mainlybecauseI'mdealingwithitonadifferentlevel,butit'sstillthere.Thegood‐old‐boynetworksarethere,andtheymakeitprettyobviousifsomeonefromtheoutsideistryingtogetin.”[#4]
TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“Intheprivatesectorit’sthe“goodol’boy”club.Wearenotapproachedaboutopportunities.Inthepublicsector,opportunitiesaremoretransparent.”[#22]
TheBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionsupplyfirmstatedthat“goodol’boy”networksdoexist.Headded,“Evenwhencompaniesfailtomeetgoals,theystillgetcontracts.Therearenopenalties.”[#36]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmstatedshebelieves“100percent”thatthe“goodol’boy”networkexists.Sheexplained,“IthinkthatmyexperiencewiththeCityofDenveristhatit’sadiverseworkforce.Ithinkthatthepersonwhorunsparksandrecplanningisaprettyoldschoolsexistmale,butIthinkit’stheincumbencyoftheestablishedplayers,whichhappentobewhite,male‐owned,that’stheproblem.”[#12]
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“[CityandCountyofDenver]likesthoseplayersbecausethey’regoingtogetareliableproduct.Iunderstandthat.Nocityemployeewantstobeatworkat11p.m.becausetheyhiredthisstart‐upcompanyandthestart‐upcompanydidacrappyjob.Igetthat.Butitseemsliketheycoulddiversifyalittlebitmore…particularlytomaketheprojectssmallenoughsothatnewercompaniescandothem.Also,tocreatemoreopportunitiesforminoritiesandwomentogetinthegameinsteadof
![Page 578: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/578.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 151
justtobeasubcontractoranddothe[lessdesirable]workonsomebigproject,becausethat’showthesystemworksnow.”[#12]
TheNativeAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,SDB‐,SDVOSB‐,andHUBZone‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmreportedthatheisawareofthe“goodol’boy”networkandacknowledgeditsexistenceintheDenvermarketplace.[#39]
Whenaskedabout“goodol’boy”networksorotherclosednetworks,theBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andESB‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmsaidthathedoesbelievetheyexist.Headded,“Basedontheproductswedo[and]theservicesweprovide,andwherewe’repricedinthemarket,wecancompeteonalevelplayingfield.[However],we[sometimes]don’tgetinvitedtothetable….Wemaynotwinaprojectalways,but…wewantto[atleast]beabletohaveaconversation.AndI’dsaytherehavebeenmanyinstanceswherewe’veneverhadthatconversation.”[#9]
TheBlackAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaid,“Theprivatesectorisverymuchiftheyworkedwithyoubefore,they’llworkwithyouagain.It’sreallyahardmarkettogetinto….It’sreallylikeaclub.”[#13]
Regarding“goodol’boy”networks,theBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthathehaswitnessedthemonjobsites.Hesaid,“Therearethe‘goodol’boys’thatwillgettogetherandtalkinacorner…[and]theycomebackandsay,‘We’llgiveyouthispiece,’andsomeoneelsetakestheirbiggerpiece.Wemaysay,‘Waitaminute.Wedidn’tbidonthissmallpiece.Webidon[thebigone],’butthey’llinterruptandsay,‘Well,that’swhatwehaveleft.’Andyoulook,andit’sjustyouandanotherminority[withthesmallpiece].”[#7]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmindicatedthatclosednetworksexistintheDenvermarketplace.Shesaid,“Youneverareasked[bylargeprimecontractors]toparticipate,or…askedtojoinateamwithanumberthatwillbringyouonastheymaydowithotherpartners.[It’sbecause]theyhaveotherpartnersthatthey’vebeeninbusinesswithalongtime….”[PT#3a]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaid,“Itseemsasthoughthemostdifficultpartofpenetratingthe‘goodol’boy’worldisbeingawomanintheconstructionindustry.Youarenottakenseriouslyandnotgivenopportunitiestoproveyourself.Therearealotofeventsthatpromotedoingbusinesswithwomen‐ownedandminority‐ownedbusinesses,butitneverdevelopsintoanything.”[WT#5]
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“Mylatestexperiencewaswithanelectricalcompanythatwasawardedsomeof[a]DenverInternationalAirport…project.Supposedly,theytookasmallerpartofthetradethatweperformandhadmycompanyandavarietyofothersbidthejob.Wespentalotoftimeandmoneyontheproposal,[but]foundoutthroughthegrapevinethatitwasjusta‘mock’exercisetoseewhowouldbeacontender….Iwasveryoffendedthatitwasnotanactualbid.”[WT#5]
![Page 579: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/579.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 152
TheSubcontinentAsianAmericanmaleownerofaspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthatthereisa“goodol’boy”networkintheDenverarea.HesaidthathelostabidforaZooprojectduetoaclosednetwork,andaddedthatit’scommonforbusinessestoworkwithotherbusinessesthatthey’veworkedwithpreviously.[#18]
Regardingherexperienceswiththe“goodol’boy”network,thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemaleco‐ownerofaspecialtyservicesfirmsaid,“Inmyindustry,[the‘goodol’boy’network]isawful,awful….Iworkedwithagentlemanon[a]project.HedidtheprocessformebecausemyclientwantedsomethingIdon’tdo.Thismandidtheembroideryandhiswifedidthegraphicsandeverythingelse.WhileIwasspeakingwithhim,hiswifeleftand[wentinto]theembroideryroomandwasn’tinvolvedinthespeaking….HespokedowntomelikeIwasacharlatan,ornoviceorsomething.”[#8]
Thesamebusinessco‐ownerwentontosaythatshequitalocalchamberofcommercebecauseitwasa“testosterone‐filledgroup.”Sheexplained,“Whentheyshowup,it’sadrinkingpartyandeverybodyhastohavetheirmartinisortheirginandtonics[to]talkaboutbusiness.Ireallydidgetacceptedbythewomenatthechamber,butmostof[them]workforthechamber.”[#8]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaconstruction‐relatedfirmstatedthathehasnotexperiencedanybarriers.However,henoted,“Mostcompanies[and]ownerslikeworkingwithcompaniestheyhaveworkedwithbefore.”[#25]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmstatedthatthe“goodol’boy”networkexistsandthatitcreatescredibilityissuesforherfirm.[#20]
A trade association representative stated that he believes the “good ol’ boy” network does
exist.TheHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationexplained,“Itisrelationship‐driven,andI[donot]wanttousethatterm…becauseofwhat‘goodoldboy’networktypicallymeanstomostofus,[whichis]Anglomen.Butintheconstructionworld,itcouldalsomeanaprimethatusestheexactsamecertifiedfirmseverysingletime.Andthatisa‘goodoldboy’network[too].Noonecanpenetrateintothat.”[#11]
Some interviewees said they do not encounter closed networks or think they are a thing of the
past.Forexample:
TheHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmstatedthatthe“goodol’boy”networkisnotanissueforhisfirm.[#14]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofanSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthatshehasnotexperiencedany“goodol’boy”networksorotherclosednetworks.[#15a]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmstatedthatheisnotawareofa“goodol’boy”networkorotherclosednetworks.[#23a]
![Page 580: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/580.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 153
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmreportedthatshehasnotexperiencedthe“goodol’boy”networkoranyotherclosednetworks.[#35]
Any other allegations of discriminatory treatment.Someintervieweeshadcommentsrelatedtotopicsnotdiscussedabove.Forexample:
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmindicatedthathisfirmsometimesfacesdiscriminationwhenpursingpublicsectorbidopportunities.Hesaid,“It’swhoyouknow,andifyouknowtherightperson,theycanwalkyouthroughtheirfrontdoorandgetyoutositdownwiththecorrectpersoninordertosubmityourbid.Ifyoudon’t,thenthegatekeeper,dependingonwhereyoubid,willlookatyouandsaythebidisclosed.[They’ll]literallylookatyouand[have]noothercriteria.”[#7]
Thesamebusinessco‐ownercontinued,“Then,someonecancomebehindyouaweeklaterandstillbidonit.Andforus,there’snorealrecourse[there].We’renotgoingtocomplainbecausewe’renotgoingtoburnabridge.We’reasmallbusiness,andunfortunately,wedon’thavetheabilitytogocomplain.Becauseifyoucomplain,theyremember[it].Therearenosecretcomplaints.”[#7]
TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“Thiswasawhileback.ItwasaninstancewhereIhadadisputewith[a]CityofDenverarchitect.Wewereona[publicsector]projectandIdidn’tagreewithwhatthe…architectwasaskingustodo,soIaskedformediationbecauseIdidn’tthinkwewerebeingtreatedfairly.[A]managerof[Denver]PublicWorkswasthemediator.Ifeltbrowbeateninthemeetingbecausehewasn’tanindependentperson.So,itneverwentanywhereandIfeltIwaswastingmytime.”[#22]
TheBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“SomeyearsagoIattendedacommercialrealestatebusinessnetworkingbreakfastandmarketingeventandwasamazedattheextremelackofculturaldiversity….Thereweresomewomenthere.Iwaswell‐dressed…as[my]counterparts[were].Ihadnicemarketingmaterialsandbusinesscards,as[didmy]counterparts.WhenIenteredthemaindininghallatthebighoteltheeventwasheldat,IwasgreetedwithsomeveryrudestaresandpeopleignoringmeasIapproachedthemtointroducemyself.”[WT#12]
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“AttheendoftheeventwhileIleaving,Idiscoveredthatsomeofmyhigh‐endprofessionallyprintedmarketingmaterialswereinthetrashwiththefoodremainders[of]people'splates.ThisisjustasmallexampleofwhatIhaveexperienced.Ihavehaddirectcommentsmadetomelike,‘Isthisreallyyourwork?’or…someracialcommentmadeundertheperson'sbreathastheywalkbyme.”[WT#12]
Some trade association and business assistance organization representatives had comments
regarding additional unfair or discriminatory treatment that members experience.Forexample:
![Page 581: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/581.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 154
TheBlackAmericanfemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaid,“Someofourmembershaveverbalizedtomethedifferentdiscriminatoryexperiencesthey’vehad,[and]someofthemdon’tknowhowtonavigatethroughsomeofthoseexperiences.Somehavebeeninthegamelongenoughtokindofknowhowtofinesse…andhowtomaketheirwaythrough,[but]insomeway,shape,orform,alotofthemhaveexperienceddiscrimination,overtly.”[#6]
TheHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidhebelievesachallengeinconstruction‐relatedindustriesisthattheformsarenotbilingual.Heexplained,“WehavealotofSpanish‐speakingfirmsthatareAmericancitizensseekingwork,buttheyhavetohiresomebodytofillouttheirpaperworkforthem.[It]putsthematanunfairdisadvantage.”[#11]
TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationstated,“Ibelieveminoritiesandwomenareunfairlyheldtoahigherstandard.”[#33]
Many business owners and representatives had comments related to price discrimination
and/or discrimination in payments.Forexample:
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaidthatshehasexperiencedpayment‐relatedissuesthatshesuspectsarerootedindiscrimination.Sheexplained,“There’sonedeveloperwhoI’malwayswaitingontogetpaid…whoprobablytakesadvantageofourcompanyalittlebitmorebecausehe’slike,‘Yeah,they’regirls….’Ithinkthatoverallwithclients,societymakesitfeeleasiertotakeadvantageofwomen.”[#12]
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“I’vehadtobereallygoodtomyemployees,butit’sdifficultwithclientswhoarealwaystryingtonickelanddimeus.Ijusttriedtogetreallytoughaboutthatbecauseitshowsthere’ssignificantwagedisparityinarchitectureandengineeringbetweenmenandwomen.Studyafterstudyshowsthat.Wealwayslookatourworkandgo,‘Ifwewereamale‐ownedfirm,howmuchwouldwehavechargedforthis?Didweundercharge?’Becausewe’rewomen,wearesocializedtobenice.”[#12]
TheBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaidthatsomeprimecontractorswill“blacklist”minority‐andwomen‐ownedfirmsthatcomplainaboutlatepayment.Heexplained,“Andifyouspeakup…[they]willdoa‘whispercampaign’totheirbuddiesatotherconstruction…orarchitecturalfirmsintheregion.”[WT#12]
Whenaskedifheisawareofpricediscriminationinobtainingfinancing,bonding,materialsandsupplies,orotherproductsorservices,theBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionsupplyfirmsaidthataftermanyyearsofbusiness,heisstillforcedtogetamoreexpensiveSBAloanratherthanatraditionalloan.[#36]
Whenaskedaboutpricediscrimination,thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemaleco‐ownerofaspecialtyservicesfirmreportedthatshehasneverhadtodealwithbondingandthatshehasexperiencednodiscriminationinfinancingwithherbank.[#8]
![Page 582: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/582.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 155
TheHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmstatedthatpricediscriminationisnotanissueforhisfirm.[#14]
Whenaskedifhehaswitnessedorexperiencedanypricediscriminationinobtainingfinancing,bonding,materialsorsupplies,theBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthathehasnot.[#7]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofanSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmstatedthatthefirmhasnotencounteredanypricediscriminationordiscriminationinpayments.[#15a]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmstatedthatheisnotawareofdiscriminationintimelypaymentsbycustomersorprimes.Hewentontocomment,“Slowpaymentsarenotjustaminoritiesissue.”[#23b]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmsaidthatpricediscrimination“encompasses”allsmallbusinessissues.[#20]
WhenaskedifheisawareofdiscriminationinpaymentsbeingaproblemforSBE/MBE/WBEoruncertifiedminority‐orwomen‐ownedfirmsinthelocalmarketplace,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmstated,“No.It’snotbecauseafirmisonethingoranother.Paymentsaresometimesslowforallofus.Sometimeswewaitalongtime…90[or]120days.”[#21a]
Some trade association and business assistance organization representatives commented on
discrimination related to price or payments.Forexample:
TheHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthathehasheardmentionofdiscriminationinpaymentsfrommembersbutdoesnotbelievethatslowpaymentrelatestotherace/ethnicityofbusinessowners:“Idonotthinkthatwithslowpayment,ethnicityhas[anything]todowithit.Itisjustaprocess.”[#11]
TheNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaidthatwhileslowpaymentonpublicworkisanissue,shedoesnotbelieveitisduetodiscrimination.[#37]
Some interviewees commented on whether there is any governmental resistance to use of
SBE/MBE/WBE firms.Commentsinclude:
WhenaskedifheisawareofanygovernmentresistancetotheuseofDBEs,theBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionsupplyfirmstated,“Notoutwardly.Theyalltouttheirprogramandsaytheywanttodobusinesswithyou.Theirwebsitesevensaytheybelieveinadiversesuppliernetwork…butitdoesn’thappen.Thentheybundlecontracts,andthat’saformofexclusion.”[#36]
TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaidthatheisawareofgovernmentalresistancetouseofSBE/MBE/WBE
![Page 583: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/583.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 156
firms.HeexplainedthathewasremovedfromaDenverPublicWorksprojectbecausetheprojectmanagerwantedtoworkwithafirmoutofLosAngeles.[#22]
WhenaskedifheisawareofgovernmentalresistancetouseofSBE/MBE/WBEsbeingaproblemforSBE/MBE/WBEoruncertifiedminority‐orwomen‐ownedfirmsinthelocalmarketplace,eitherintheprivatesectororthepublicsector,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmstated,“Nothingisfartherfromthetruth.Governmenthas[contract]goals.”[#21a]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmstatedthatgovernmentalresistancetouseofSBE/MWBEsisnotanissuewhenprojectshavegoals.Shesaidthatwhenprojectsdonothavegoalsitisanissuebecauseprimeshavenoincentivetousecertifiedfirms.[#20]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmstatedthatshebelievesthereisnogovernmentalresistancetotheuseofSBE/MBE/WBEs.[#12]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmreportedthatheisnotawareofanygovernmentalresistancetouseofSBE/MBE/WBEs.[#23a]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmreportedthatsheisnotawareofanygovernmentalresistancetotheuseofSBE/MBE/WBEfirms.[#35]
Some trade association and business assistance organization representatives also discussed
whether there is governmental resistance to the use of DBEs.Forexample:
TheHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthatsomepublicagencieswithinCityandCountyofDenverhavewantedtogetridofgoalsbecausethetechnicalskillsrequiredforsomeprojectsaretoospecificandtheavailabilityofDBE‐certifiedcontractorswiththenecessaryskillsislow.Publicagencies,hecontinued,arethenfacedwithnotreachingtheirDBEgoals.[#11]
Thesametradeassociationrepresentativeadded,“Ithinkitcomesprimarilyfromtheownershipofthedepartments.Iremember[Denver]BotanicGardensnotwantingtouseanycertifiedfirms,[and]Iremember[Denver]PublicWorksfightingonthose[too].Ithinktheresistanceisthere.”[#11]
WhenaskedifthereisgovernmentresistancetouseofDBEs,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationstated,“Notovertresistance,butourminoritycommunityisgoingtobethemajorityinnottoomanyyears….Somepeopleareuncomfortablewiththat.”[#33]
One business owner said he considered changing his last name to be less ethnic‐sounding.Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaconstructionfirmsaid,“Iworkonprivatejobs[and]I
![Page 584: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/584.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 157
haven’texperiencedanybarriers,[though]theonlythingthatIhavethoughtaboutwaschangingmylastnamebecauseitis[MiddleEastern].Idon’tbelieveIhavebeendeniedwork,butit’sjustafeeling[thatitmaybepossible].Fortunately,oncepeopleworkwithmeandknowmyqualityofwork,theydon’thaveaproblem.”[#24]
Factors that affect opportunities for minorities or women to enter and advance in the industry.Someintervieweesdiscussedwhethertherearefactorsthataffecttheabilityofminoritiesandwomentoenterandadvanceintheindustry.Forexample:
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaidlargeprimecontractorsinherindustryopensmalloffices“tocomplywitheverysinglebitofcategoryofmixedcodeswhichthey…couldpotentiallyhaveworktiedto”anddefinetheofficesas“theofficeofsmallbusiness,civilrights,[or]outreach,[etcetera].”[PT#3a]
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“Whateverthebusinessis,theyhavethatinternallyandtheyendupdoingthatworkinsidetheproject.Theygatherour…competitivebidsbecauseyouhavetocompete.”Sheadded,“Youhavetogiveup[becauseyou’regiving]yourunitnumbersandyourlaborhours,andyourdollaramountsrightwhenyousitdownandmeetwiththem.Andthosearethenumbersthatthey’regonnagoinwith.”[PT#3a]
Whenaskedifanyrace,ethnicity,orgenderdiscriminationaffectsbusinessopportunitiesforminoritiesorwomen,thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmsaid,“Ihavenotexperiencedanydiscriminationintheareaoflimitedbusinessopportunities.”[#27]
Whenaskedifsheisawareofanybarriersordiscriminationbasedonrace,ethnicity,orgenderintheDenvermarketplace,thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“Wehavebeeninbusinesssolonginthismetroarea,[and]wearenotawareofanydiscriminatoryobstacles.Wehaveworkedwithmanyminoritiesandhavenotheardofanyofthosepractices.”[#28]
Thesamebusinessrepresentativecontinued,“Weareallawarethatcompaniesliketoworkwithpeopleandcompaniestheyknow.Isupposetherearesomethatfeelitisdifficulttogetlargecontractsbecausetheymightbeaminority.Ihaven’theardofthatsituation,butIdoknowthatpeoplelikeworkingwithpeopletheyknow,thattheyhaveworkedwithbefore,and[that]producequalitywork.”[#28]
TheNativeAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,SDB‐,SDVOSB‐,andHUBZone‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmsaid,“Ithinktheperceptionofasmallbusinessisthey’renotgoingtobeabletocompetewiththelargebusinesses…becausetheydon’thavetheinfrastructureinplacetocompete,ortheydon’thavetheexperienceorqualifications.Theymighthavethequalificationswiththeirkeypeople,butasafirmtheymaynot.Ithinkalsoasapersonofcolor,sometimesit’salittlebitharder.”[#39]
A few trade association representatives discussed whether minority‐ and women‐owned firms
face additional barriers not experienced by other firms.Forexample:
![Page 585: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/585.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 158
Whenaskedifmembersfaceanybarriersordiscriminationbasedonrace,ethnicity,orgender,thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaid,“We’veheardof…somebarriersfor…minority‐andwomen‐ownedbusinesses,[suchas]obtainingfinancing,bondingrequirements,[and]insurancerequirements.”Shesaidthatobtainingfinancingandmeetinginsurancerequirementsareespeciallydifficultforminority‐andwomen‐ownedbusinessesintheDenvermarketplace,andcommented,“Iknowalotoftheprimesreallyworkwellwiththesmallfirmsbecausetheyneedthem….Theyneedthemtomeetthegoals[and]tobeagoodpartner.”[#38]
TheHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidhebelievesthereareadditionaldifficultiesandbarriersforsmallbusinessesaswellasminority‐andwoman‐ownedfirmsinthemarketplace.Heexplained,“Alotofthisworkisrelationship‐driven.Primestendtoutilizethesamefirmsthattheyhavehadrelationshipswith,anditishardfornewerfirmstobreakintothatandgetmorework.I’mabelieverthattheonlywaytobuildcapacityis…tofindawaytocreateopportunitiesfornewstartupsorfolkswhohavebeenthereforawhileandwanttoenterintothepublicarenaorprivatesector,ormovefromresidentialtocommercial.Whenthelargerguysarelimitingexposuretonewfirms,itisverydifficultforthemtogetin.”[#11]
Whenaskedifsmall,minority‐orwomen‐ownedfirmsfaceadditionalbarriersnotfacedbyotherfirms,theBlackAmericanfemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationindicatedthatadditionalbarriersdoexist.Shestated,“Withthenewadministrationandthechallengesofthecivilrightsprograms,ithasbeen…interestingtoseehowithasbeeninterpretedbyanumberofprimes,orjustdifferentpeople,period.”Shesaidthatitisdifficultto“provethereisdiscrimination,”or“bias,”andcommented,“It’sinterestingtoseehowit’sbeingrepackaged.”[#6]
ThesametradeassociationrepresentativeaddedthatherorganizationmetwithacivilrightsteamattheU.S.DOTinWashington,D.C.todiscusskeepingprogramsinplacethatbenefitminority‐andwomen‐ownedbusinesses.Shesaid,“AlotofDOTswillpulloutiftheyhavetheopportunityto[doso],andthat’swhythere’ssuchastrongappreciation[between]usandCDOT.”[#6]
I. Insights Regarding Business Assistance Programs
Thestudyteamaskedbusinessownersandrepresentativesabouttheirviewsofpotentialrace‐andgender‐neutralmeasuresthatmighthelpsmallbusinessesandminority‐andwomen‐ownedbusinesses,obtainworkintheDenvercontractingindustry.Intervieweesdiscussedvarioustypesofpotentialmeasuresand,inmanycases,maderecommendationsforspecificprogramsandprogramtopics.ThefollowingpagesofthisAppendixreviewcommentspertainingto:
Knowledgeofprogramsingeneral;
Technicalassistanceandsupportservices;
On‐the‐jobtraining;
Mentor‐protégérelationships;
![Page 586: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/586.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 159
Jointventurerelationships;
Financingassistance;
Bondingassistance;
Assistanceinobtainingbusinessinsurance;and
Assistanceinusingemergingtechnology.
Knowledge of programs in general. Thestudyteamreportedontheirawarenessofandexperienceswithbusinessassistanceprogram.
Most interviewees reported having knowledge of or participation in business assistance
programs.Somefoundprogramshelpfulwhileothersindicatedtheywereunimpressedbytheprograms’helpfulness.Forexample:
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmsaidsheisawareoftrainingprogramsofferedthatshefindshelpful.Shesaid,“Ibelieveatonepointtherewas…trainingregardingestimatingcontractlanguage…bonding.Itwasbackwhenwefirststarted.Justrecently,inthepasttwotothreeyears,I’vechangedwhatIneedinternallyandhavefocusedmoreonfinancialclasses.”[#2]
Thesamebusinessco‐ownerwentontosay,“Ihonestlythink[trainingprograms]arevaluable.Forme,ithasnotworkedtopursue[moretrainings]becauseofthetimingoftheworkshops.Eventhoughyoudoneedtofocusonyourbusiness,mymainfocusismy[family].Back[whenIfirststartedmybusiness],westruggledabitmorebecauseIdidn’tattendthose[trainings].”Sheaddedthatshefindsgreatvalueintheinformationofferedviaherassociationmemberships.[#2]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleownerofaspecialtycontractingfirmreported,"WhenIfirststarted[myfirm]IdidseeanSBEcounselor.TheyguidedmeonhowtogetSBEcertifiedandthingsofthatnature.ThenIwenttoanSBEconference.Ithinktheyareveryhelpful."[#4]
Regardingbusinessassistanceprograms,theBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andESB‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmsaid,“IjustattendedonerecentlyonNACIScodes.[Itfocusedon]makingsurethatyourcodesareright.Thatwasreallyagoodexamplebecausewedidfindacategorythatwemayfitinto.”[#9]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmsaidthatbeforestartinghisbusinessheattendedasix‐weekcourseofferedbytheDenverMetroChamberofCommerce.Hesaidthatthecoursehelpedhimmakethefinaldecisiontomoveforwardwithstartinghisownbusiness.[#14]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofagoodsandservicesfirmstated,“WeregularlygetnewslettersthatcomearoundfromtheBoulderandBroomfieldChambersofCommerce.Therearefrequentworkshops,soIamawareofthem.Ihaven’tattendedanyofthem,butitseemsliketherearegoodresourcesavailable.”Hecommentedonspecificeventsthathe
![Page 587: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/587.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 160
imaginesarehelpful,thoughhedoesnotparticipate,includinga“BoulderStartupWeek”eventthatfocusesonnetworking.Headded,“Thereareallsortsofresourcesforfindingfinancingorformeetingothermembersofthecommunity,andjustkindofhelpingtogrowthebusiness.”[#10]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmreportedknowingofseveraltypesofbusinessassistancethatshedoesnottakeadvantageof.Shesaidthatsheisawareoftechnicalassistance,financingassistance,on‐the‐jobtraining,andsmallbusinessstart‐upassistance,thoughhasneverutilizedany.[#20]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmcommentedthatmanystart‐upscoulduseassistanceinbusinessfinancing,purchasing,andsafety.[#21a]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmreportedthatshecompletedasix‐weekprogramdesignedforMWBEcompaniesat[acorporate‐baseduniversity].Shesaidtheprogramreviewedtheessentialsofconstructionmanagement,includinghowtoreadanRFP,applyingforcredit,marketing,safety,sustainability,andmanaginginsuranceandbonding.SheaddedthatshehasattendedtheHispanicContractorsofColoradobiddingworkshop.[#35]
RegardingprogramsandresourcesthatareparticularlyhelpfultoMBE/WBEfirms,thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaidthatshehasparticipatedwithHispanicContractorsofColoradoandothertradeassociations.[#12]
Thesamebusinessowneradded,“TheotherresourcethatIfeltisareallygoodresourceisPTAC,whichIthinkisStateofColoradoorfederal,orcombined.That’sanexcellentresource.Theircounselorsarereallyhelpfulinhelpingyouunderstandthepublicsectorgame.Theladywhohelpedmethere,I’dgiveherashoutoutamilliontimesover.”[#12]
RegardingtheDenverInternationalAirportCommerceHubandSBO,apublicmeetingparticipantsaid,“Thelackofcommunicationwas[poor].I[made]anappointmentwithahigherofficialjusttoaskpublicknowledge,andIwastold,‘Wecan’ttellyouthis,wecan’ttellyouthis,wecan’ttellyouthis.’So,itseemstomethateventhoughwehaveorganizationstohelpus,theyarenotcomingforwardwiththehelp.Andsometimesmaybetheyareintimidated[to]nottogiveusthehelp.So,thatwasoneofthebiggestfrustrationsI’vehad.”[PT#4]
A few trade association and business assistance organization representatives reported on their
organizations’ offered programs.Somediscussedotherprogramsorservicesavailabletomembers.Forexample:
Whenaskedaboutthebusinessassistanceofferedtomembers,thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaid,“Oneofthekeythingswehaveisaleadershipdevelopmentprogram,anditstartsatthepre‐supervisorylevel.”Shecontinued,
![Page 588: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/588.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 161
“Wejuststarted…amanagementone[thisyear],andthat[covers]alotofHRandcommunicationskills[for]thosethataredevelopingintheircareer.We’reabusinessorganization,sonotallengineersare…interestedinbeingabusiness.Theyworkforabusiness,butthey[might]not[be]interestedinmanagingabusiness.[#38]
Thesametradeassociationrepresentativeaddedthattheorganizationalsooffersmanagementeducationandlegaleducation.Shenoted,“Employmentlawisabigthing.Understandingbothsides[isimportant],andsowehavethosekindsofprograms.”[#38]
TheHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaid,“Becausewedoourgeneralmembershipmeetingsonamonthlybasis,wegetthebigguysin.Wealsogivepresentationsbysomeofthebiggerprojectsateachoneofourdinners,anditallowsourmembershiptohavedirectaccesswithdecision‐makersforthesebigprojects.Theprimesalsoattendthedinners,whichallowsourmemberstodeveloprelationshipswiththosefolksthatarekeyinmakingdecisionsonwhotheywanttoinvitetobidonworkthattheyaredoing….Anotherarmofourorganizationisthetrainingopportunitiesweoffer.Wehaveacontractoracademywhereweofferclasses[and]trainingsformembersandnon‐members,employees,andowners…atminimalcost.Theclassesaretaughtbyindustryexperts,whichmakesthemmoreapplicabletotheday‐to‐daybusinessofourmembers.”[#11]
Regardingpotentialmeasuresorprogramsthatcanbenefitmembers,theBlackAmericanfemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthatsheisabigproponentofbusinesseducationandtraining.ShesaidthatRegionalTransportationDistrict’sorientationregardingcontractterminationhelpssubcontractorstounderstandtheirresponsibilitiesandexpectations.[#6]
Whenaskedaboutpotentialmeasuresorprogramssheisawareofthatseemparticularlyhelpfultosmallbusinessesincluding,minority‐andwomen‐ownedfirms,theNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaid,“WeencourageourmemberstogetinvolvedwiththeNationalCenterforAmericanIndianEnterpriseDevelopmentandtheAmericanIndianProcurementTechnicalAssistanceCenter,aswellastheSmallBusinessAdministrationandtheColoradoMinorityBusinessOffice.”[#37]
Whenaskedwhythesearehelpful,thesamebusinessassistanceorganizationrepresentativestatedthatNationalCenterforAmericanIndianEnterpriseDevelopment(NCAIED)andAmericanIndianProcurementTechnicalAssistanceCenter(PTAC)areculturallyattunedtomembers’needs,andthattheSBAandColoradoMinorityBusinessOffice(MBO)focuswellontheneedsofsmallbusinessesingeneral.[#37]
Shelateradded,“Therewasapersonwhocameinanddidtrainingonworkers’comp.Thereisalsoacontacton[a]humanrightscommissionwhooccasionallycomes[totheorganization]andspeakstomembers.”[#37]
TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationstatedthattheorganizationpromotestrainingprovidedbytheDenverMetroChamberofCommerce,SBA,SmallBusinessDevelopmentCenters,andtheMinoritySupplier
![Page 589: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/589.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 162
DevelopmentCouncilintheareasofmarketanalysis,businessplanning,financialplanning,marketingandsales,socialmedia,hiringandmanagingemployees,capitalformation,accountingsystems,andcommunityengagement.[#33]
A few interviewees discussed small business assistance offered by local universities and other
educational institutions.[e.g.,#33]Forexample:
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmreportedthatsheparticipatedinabondingcourseatTurnerUniversity.[#35]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthatsheattendedacareerfairhostedbyColoradoStateUniversity.[#12]
Others reported having little or no knowledge of assistance programs in general and/or not
participating in any programs.[e.g.,#23b,#24,#31,#34]Afewindicatedthatavailableprogramsarenothelpful.Forexample:
Whenaskedifanyassistanceprogramsareparticularlyhelpfultosmallbusinesses,theHispanicAmericanmaleownerofanarchitecturalengineeringfirmstatedthathehasnotusedanyprograms,noteventhoseofferedbytheSmallBusinessAdministration.Heexplainedthatthemosthelpfulthingsforhisfirmhavebeenseminarsconductedbytheprofessionalassociationstowhichtheyaremembers.[#16]
TheSubcontinentAsianAmericanmaleownerofaspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthatheisunawareofanyprogramsavailabletosmallorcertifiedcompanies.Hewentontocommentthatindividualswhowanttostartabusinessneedtounderstandthatitisafull‐timejobandthathelpisn’talwaysavailable.Headded,“Igotnohelp.[I]hadtolearnitthehardway.Agoodexample[ofthat]isabidwesubmittedfor…theZoo.Itwouldhavebeennicetoknow[why]we[lost].”[#18]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthatheisnotawareofanyprogramsthatareparticularlyhelpfulforsmallbusinesses.Headded,“It’sdifficulttogetinformationonhowtoapply….Yougotosmallbusinesseventsandthey’resortofawasteoftime.”[#7]
TheBlackAmericanandveteranmaleownerofageneralcontractingcompanystated,“Idon’tthinkthereareanyresourcesouttherethatcouldhelpanewbusinesstomakesureyou’redoingthingsright.It’strialanderror.You’vegottokeepworkingonittomakethebusinesssuccessful.”[#29]
Whenaskedifheisawareofpotentialmeasuresorprogramsthatbenefitsmallbusinesses,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaconstruction‐relatedfirmstatedthatheisnotawareofspecificprograms.However,hesaid,“Ibelieve[that]ifthecitywantstoreallyassistinsmallbusinessgrowth,therearesomestepstoimplement.”[#25]
![Page 590: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/590.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 163
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“Thereneedstobesomeway[for]smallbusinesses[to]networkwithbiggercompanies,[and]not[with]justanetworking[or]outreachevent.[Thecityshouldalso]assistinmakingsurethattheycanmentorthesmallbusiness.”Regardingcurrentmentor‐protégéprograms,hesaid,“Thereneedstobesomething[with]morethanfourorfivegroups.Itshouldbeaneffortinmakingsurerelationshipsareformedandkept.”[#25]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemaleco‐ownerofaspecialtyservicesfirmstatedthatsheisnotawareofprogramsthatareparticularlyhelpfultosmallbusinessesasidefromthosethroughtheSBA.Sheadded,“IusedalotofcontactinformationfromtheBoulder[SmallBusinessDevelopmentCenter].Mybusinessbroker,mybusinessattorney,andmyfinanceguywereallfromtheSBA.”Shewentontosaythatshecalledthecountyforinformation,thoughnoonereachedouttoherafterwards.[#8]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofanSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthatthefirmneverneededhelpfrombusinessassistanceprogramsbecausesheandtheotherownerhaveastrongbusinessbackground.[#15a]
Asurveyrespondentsaid,“Thesmallbusinessorganizationisajoke.Whenwestartedourbusiness,wewenttothemandtheytoldusweweretooyounganddidnothaveenoughexperience.”[AS#34]
Technical assistance and support services.Thestudyteamdiscusseddifferenttypesoftechnicalassistanceandotherbusinesssupportprograms.Someintervieweesreportedwhethertechnicalassistanceandsupportservicesarehelpful.
A number of business owners and representatives reported that technical assistance and
support services are helpful.[e.g.,#1c,#9,#21a,#25,#28]Forexample:
Whenaskedifsheisawareofanytechnicalassistanceandsupportservices,theHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaid,“IhaveattendedworkshopsatMiCasaResourceCenter,completed…USDOTBondingEducationProgramand[a]TurnerUniversity[course].”Sheadded,“Ilearnedbookkeepingincollege,andafriendtaughtmeestimating.”[#35]
Themalerepresentativeofanon‐Hispanicwhitemale‐ownedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthataccountingsoftwarehasbeenhelpful,notablyinmaintainingpaymentschedules.Hedidnotethatitwouldbemorehelpfulifthesoftwareallowedbillingbylaborcategoryratherthanbyperson.[#1d]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmstatedthathelpfultrainingthroughtheCityandCountyofDenverincludedtopicsonestimating,contractlanguage,payrollprocedures,andbonding.[#2]
Apublicmeetingparticipantsaid,“In2010whentheeconomyplummeted,[I]was[in]phaseoneofthesmallbusinessentrepreneuriallearningprocess….SincethenIhavegone
![Page 591: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/591.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 164
throughMiCasa[andhave]takenadvantageofsomeincredibleresources[suchas]businessplanning,redevelopment,everything.”[PT#4]
Regardingtechnicalassistanceandothersupportservices,thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringfirmsaid,“IthinkthatmarketingprogramsforMBE,WBE,[and]SBEbusinesses[tobetter]understandthemarketplacewouldbeveryhelpful.”[#5]
TheBlackAmericanveteranmaleownerofageneralcontractingcompanyindicatedthattechnicalassistanceandsupportserviceswouldbehelpful.Hesaid,“Havingthattypeofresource,likeabusinessconsultant,couldbehelpfulforsmallbusinessesthatarestrugglingwithallofthework,likebookkeeping,thatisnecessaryforsuccess.”[#29]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedgeneralcontractingfirmcommentedonthebenefitsoftechnicalassistanceandsupportservices.Shesaid,“Itcouldbeveryhelpfulforbusinessesto[learn],beforetheystartabusiness,theback‐officeelementsofbookkeeping,estimating,andknowledge[ofhow]torespondtoabid.”[#19]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmsaid,“Tohaveavailableabusinesscoachthatcouldassistinallareasofsmallbusiness[wouldbehelpful].TherehavebeenquestionsIhadtofindanswerstoonmyown.Anexamplewouldbewhentostartofferingbenefitstoemployees.Acoachcouldhelpinidentifyingtherighttime.Thatcoachcouldbeespeciallyhelpfulforbrandnewcompanies.”[#27]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmreportedthattheNationalElectricalContractorsAssociation(NECA)hasahelpfulapprenticeship.Hewentontocomment,“It’sthenewpeoplecominginwhoaretechsavvy.”[#23a]
TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmstated,“Iwouldliketoseesometypeoftechnicalassistanceforsmallbusinesses,especiallystart‐ups.IhavebusinessexperienceandknowwheretogotogetwhatIneed.However,Ibelieveit’sdifficultforsmallbusinessestoknowwheretogetthehelptheyneedtosucceed.Actually,I’mreallysurprisedthatDenverdoesn’thaveadepartmentthatnot[only]certifiesyourcompany,but[also]give[s]…assistance.”[#32a]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofagoodsandservicesfirmstated,“Therewereaseriesofworkshopsnottoolongagodoing[searchengineoptimization]which[were]veryhelpful,[theyalsodiscussed]howtorefineanonlinebusinesstostayrelevantandstaycurrentwiththeconstantlychangingtechnology….”[#10]
Whenaskedabouttechnicalassistanceprograms,theBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionsupplyfirmsaid,“Therewasaprogramthathelpedusgetintobusiness,butthoseprogramsdon’texistanymore.Theyarefocusedonbigbusinesses[now].”[#36]
![Page 592: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/592.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 165
Some trade association and business assistance organization representatives commented on
the helpfulness of technical assistance and other support services for members.[e.g.,#33]
TheNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaidthattheNationalCenterforAmericanIndianEnterpriseDevelopment(NCAIED)andAmericanIndianProcurementTechnicalAssistanceCenter(PTAC)offermanyhelpfultechnicalassistanceandsupportservices.[#37]
TheHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthattechnicalassistanceandsupportservicesareextremelyhelpfulforsmallbusinesses.Healsonotedthatapprenticeshipsarehelpful.[#11]
A few business owners and representatives do not find technical assistance programs useful,
or are unaware of such programs.Forexample:
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthatheisnotawareofanytechnicalassistanceprograms.[#7]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofaspecialtyservicesfirmreportedthatheisnotawareofanytechnicalassistanceorsupportservices.[#34]
Whenaskedabouttechnicalassistanceandsupportservices,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaidthatheisawareofsuchassistance,butnotedthatit’snotalwayshelpful.Heexplained,“Smallbusinessesaresavvyoncetheygettothepointofdoingpublicwork.IwasfairlywellestablishedbeforeImovedintopublicwork.”[#22]
On‐the‐job training programs. Intervieweesdiscussedtheirperceptionsofandexperienceswithon‐the‐jobtrainingprograms.
Some interviewees felt that on‐the‐job training programs would be useful or had participated
in such programs.[e.g.,#9,#23a,and#21a]Commentsinclude:
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andESB‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmindicatedthaton‐the‐jobtrainingprogramswouldbehelpful,especiallyiftheyfocusonjobsitesafety.[#9]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmindicatedthaton‐the‐jobtrainingprogramsarehelpful.Hesaidthatheisfamiliarwithon‐the‐jobtrainingforelectricalapprenticesconductedbytheIndependentElectricalContractors(IEC)andtheNationalElectricalContractorsAssociation(NECA).[#23a]
Whenaskedabouton‐the‐jobtrainingprograms,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmreportedthatConstructionIndustryTrainingCouncil(CITC)andIndependentElectricalContractors(IEC)havebigeffortstorecruitminoritiesandwomenfortheirtrainingprograms.[#21a]
![Page 593: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/593.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 166
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthatheisnotawareofanyon‐the‐jobtrainingprograms.[#7]
Mentor‐protégé relationships.Businessownersandrepresentativesreportedontheirexperienceswithmentor‐protégéprograms.Manyviewedtheprogramsashelpful. [e.g.,#7,#6,#9,#22,#25,AS#40]Forexample:
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmstatedthatmentor‐protégérelationshipsareveryhelpful,andsaidshewishesshehadhadamentor.Sheexplained,“Ithinkthat’sprobablybeenoneofmyhardeststruggles.Therehavebeenlittlepiecesofmentorshipfromdifferentpeople,butbecauseI’mprobablyinthefirst10ofwomen‐owned[companiesinmyfield]inDenvertherereallyhasn’tbeenanyonetogoto.”[#12]
Thesamebusinessowneradded,“Ithink[OfficeofEconomicDevelopment]inDenverhasmentorshipopportunities.Idon’tthinkwe’veappliedfortheOEDone,butwewouldlovetobementoredbyanarchitecturefirmwhowouldtakeusundertheirwingandhandussomeoftheirdevelopmentwork.Eventhoughwecomplainaboutdevelopmentwork,wewoulddoit.Tohaveagoodmentorwouldbesoworthit.”[#12]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedgeneralcontractingfirmdiscussedthebenefitsofamentor‐protégérelationshipandhoweffectiveon‐the‐jobtrainingcouldbeforsmallbusinesses.Shestated,“Iappliedforthecity’smentor‐protégéprogram,butwasnotacceptedbecauseIhadnotbeeninbusinesslongenough.Ibelievethebenefitsofamentor‐protégéprogramandon‐the‐jobtrainingcouldsavesignificanttimeinmakingsuretoconductyourbusinessthemostprofitablewaypossible.Aformalprogramorinformalprogramcouldgivethesmallbusinessowneraplacetogetassistance.IalsolookedatandappliedfortheCDOTprogramandwasunsuccessful,[but]I’llkeeptrying.”[#19]
Thefemalerepresentativeofanon‐Hispanicwhitemale‐ownedprofessionalservicesfirmnotedthatamentor‐protégéprogramwouldbehelpful.Shenotedthatalthoughtheirfirmdoesnotwantto,theyoftenhelptheirsubcontractorsdoaccountingandtracktheirtime.[#1b]
Themalerepresentativeofanon‐Hispanicwhitemale‐ownedprofessionalservicesfirmstatedthatamoreformalmentoringarrangementthatcreditsthementoringfirmwouldbehelpfulforhisbusiness.Hereportedthat,“Ifyoureallylookatthespecificsofwhomentoredandstartedafirmthatgrewandbecameasuccessfulfirmintheirownright,wedid.There’snocreditforthat.”[#1a]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringfirmsaid,“Itwould…behelpfultohaveamentor‐protégéprogramforthoseinthedesignfield[similartotheprogram]intheconstructionfield….”[#5]
TheNativeAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,SDB‐,SDVOSB‐,andHUBZone‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmreportedthathehasparticipatedasboththementorandprotégéin
![Page 594: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/594.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 167
mentor‐protégéprograms,andindicatedthatsuchprogramsarehelpfultosmallbusinesses.[#39]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofanSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmindicatedthatmorementor‐protégéprogramsshouldbeavailabletosmallbusinessownersintheDenvermarketplace.[PT#2c]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmsaidthatmentor‐protégérelationshipsareveryhelpful,buthardtofind.[#23a]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmstatedthatshehasonlyhad“unofficial”mentor‐protégérelationshipswiththeprimessheworkswithfrequently.Shesaidthattheserelationshipshavebeenbeneficial.[#20]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaidthatshehasaninformalmentor‐protégérelationshipwithanotherconstructioncleanupcompany.[#35]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofaspecialtyservicesfirmreportedthatthefirmhasnotparticipatedinanymentor‐protégéprograms,butindicatedthatsuchprogramsmightbehelpfultoemployees.[#34]
Some trade association and business assistance organization representatives reported on the
helpfulness of mentor‐protégé programs for members.[e.g.,#33]Onerepresentativenotedtheirorganization’seffortstorecruitfirmsfortheSBA’smentor‐protégéprogram.Commentsinclude:
WhenaskedaboutprogramsorinitiativesbyhisorganizationthatcouldbenefitSBE‐andMWBE‐certifiedmembers,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaid,“Wetalkedabout…amentorshiptypeofasituationwhichwouldbeevenmorebeefy.Buthowcouldweputthattogetherwiththecity’sguidancesoitworked?[#40]
Thesametradeassociationrepresentativecontinued,“Rightnow,there’snoincentiveintheordinanceotherthanyouget…agoldstarifyoudoamentorship.Itdoesn’tchangethepercentage….Andthenallthewhile,youhavethe,whatI’llcallforlackofabetterterm,themajoritysubs.[They’re]thenon‐minoritysubcontractorswhocanbuildthesebuildingsandthey’resittingonthesidelines,andwe’renotemployingthemtomentorupwiththesebecause…nowhereinthesystemthatmakesthatthepathofleastresistance.”[#40]
TheNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationreportedthattheorganizationrecruitscompaniesfortheSmallBusinessAdministration’smentor‐protégéprogram.Shenotedthatone‐memberfirmisalsopartofCDOT’smentor‐protégéprogram.[#37]
![Page 595: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/595.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 168
TheHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationstated,“Mentor‐protégé[programs]donewellareextremelyhelpfultoemergingbusinesses.”[#11]
One business owner said private relationships are more valuable than mentor‐protégé
relationships.TheBlackAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaidshedoesn’tbelievementor‐protégéprogramsareashelpfulasgenuineprivaterelationships.Shesaiditwouldbemoreeffectivetoinviteageneralcontractororprojectmanagertolunchandaskthemforadviceabouttheneedsoftheorganization.Shewentontoreiteratethatitisimportanttobuildprivaterelationships,andsaidsheisconvincedthatschedulingtimeonceaquarterwithothercontractorsandtappingintotheirknowledgeismorevaluable.[#13]
Thesamebusinessowneralsosaidageneralcontractoronaprojectprovidedmanagementhelptoensurehersuccessaftershetookoverhercompany.Afterlearningwhatherfirm’scapacitywas,thegeneralcontractorhelpedtoidentifyotheropportunitiesthatcarriedherforanothercoupleofyears.[#13]
Joint venture relationships.Afewintervieweesshowedinterestinjointventurerelationships.[e.g.,#12]Morefacedchallengeswithjointventurerelationships,havenotparticipatedinthem,orfindnovalueinthem.Forexample:
TheHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmsaidthatduringtheconstructionofDenverInternationalAirportheparticipatedinajointventurewithalargeengineeringfirmthathewaspartownerof.[#14]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmstatedthatheisfamiliarwithjointventuresbetweenlargefirms,butnotforsmallbusinessesspecifically.[#23a]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmsaidthatshehasneverparticipatedinajointventurerelationship.Whenaskedwhy,shesaidthatsheisnotinterestedduetotheirlegal“risk.”Shewentontocommentthatsheishappytobeasubcontractoronly.[#20]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofanSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthatthefirmparticipatedinajointventureinthepast,butdidnotgetanyworkoutofit.[#15a]
One trade association representative said that joint venture relationships would benefit
smaller firms.TheHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthatjointventurescanhelpsmallfirmsbuildnecessaryexperience.However,henoted,“Theriskneedstobeinproportionto[eachfirm’s]contributiontoitandnotafifty‐fiftyagreementinorder[forthejointventure]tobe[successful].”[#11]
Financing assistance.Thestudyteamaskedintervieweesaboutfinancingassistanceandrelatedprograms.Mostindicatedthatsuchprogramsarehelpful.[e.g.,#11,#21a,#23a,#39]Forexample:
![Page 596: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/596.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 169
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthatheisawareoffinanceassistanceprograms.However,hesaidthathedidnotreceivemuchinformationafterinquiringaboutthem.[#7]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmstatedthatheattendedafinancingassistancecourseattheDenverMetroChamberofCommercethatfocusedoncashflow.[#14]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“Itwould[be]helpfulforusandI’msurecouldbeveryhelpfulforsomesmallbusinessorstart‐upbusinessesto…[have]aresourcelistofcompaniesthatprovidebookkeepingandfinancingassistance….Anareaourcompanystillstruggleswithiscertifiedpayroll.Regularandongoingclassesinthatareaconductedbythecity,sinceit’sarequirement,wouldbehelpfultoo.”[#28]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmindicatedthatfinancingassistancecanbehelpful.Shenoted,“Therearenonprofitorganizationsgivingloans,[suchas]ColoradoEnterpriseFund,Accion,[and]mpowered.”[#35]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofanSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthatmemberstakeadvantageoffinancingassistancefromtheorganization’sbanksandcreditunionmembers,usuallyintheformofbusinessloansandestablishingbusinessaccounts.[#33]
TheBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionsupplyfirmindicatedthatfinancingassistanceishelpful,andnotedthathecurrentlyhasanSBAloan.[#36]
TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaidthathecurrentlyhasanSBAloanonhisbuilding.HenotedthatwithanSBAguaranteeontheloan,thelenderofferedlongertermsforrepayment,whichcauseshismonthlypaymentstobelower.[#22]
A business assistance organization representative discussed members’ options for financing
assistance.Whenaskedifsheisawareofanyhelpfulfinancingassistanceprograms,theNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaid,“Obviously[thereis]theSBA,butthereisalwaysaneedforfinancialtraining.Itwouldbehelpfultohaveanonlinedatabasewherepeoplecouldgoandfindoutwhoisdoingdifferentkindsoftraining.”Sheadded,“Thestate’sMinorityBusinessOfficeisanothergoodresource,buttheyneedmoresupport.PerhapstheycouldcollaboratewiththeCityandCounty[ofDenver].”[#37]
Bonding assistance.Businessownersandrepresentativesreportedonbondingassistanceashelpful.[e.g.,#13,PT#4]Forexample:
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthattheyparticipatedinabondingassistanceprogram.Regarding
![Page 597: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/597.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 170
thefirm’sparticipation,shesaid,“Itwasaconstruction‐orientedbondingprogram.IthinkitwasputonbytheNationalHighway[TrafficSafetyAdministration].Theyhaveiteveryyear[andit]wasavaluablewayformetolearnhowtowritepublicsectorproposalsandgoafterpublicwork….Itwas…gearedmoretowardscontractorsthanarchitects,butwe’vereallytriedtotakeadvantageofclassesandprogramsputonbyvariouspartsofthepublicsectorand…tradeorganizations,tolearnasmuchaspossible.”[#12]
Whenaskedifshehasanyknowledgeofbondingassistance,thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmsaid,“Yearsago,oneoftheprimesIfrequentlyworkwithhelpedmewithbondingthroughtheirbondingcompany.”[#20]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaidthatshehasutilizedtheUSDOTBondingEducationProgram,andindicatedthatitwashelpful.[#35]
A few trade association and business assistance organization representatives commented on
the helpfulness of bonding assistance for members.Forexample:
Whenaskedifshehasanyknowledgeofbondingassistance,theNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaidthattheysendmemberstotheU.S.DepartmentofTransportationBondingEducationProgramclasses.Sheadded,“Wealsohaveaguywho’saretiredformerCEOofaconstructioncompanywhocomesinanddoesbondingworkshops.”[#37]
Whenaskedaboutbondingassistance,theHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaid,“Ifthecitycouldcomeupwithabondingprogramwhere[firms]couldpayintoit,Ithink[it]wouldbeextremelyhelpfultoalotofoursmallfirmsthatcannotgetbondingontheirown,sinceittakesthreetofiveyearsofgoodfinancialrecordstoachievebonding.”[#11]
A business assistance organization representative noted that she is unaware of any bonding
assistance for members.TheNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaidthatassistanceinobtainingbusinessinsurancewouldbehelpfultomembers,thoughsheisnotawareofanysuchassistancecurrently.[#37]
Assistance in obtaining business insurance.Afewbusinessownersandrepresentativessaidthatassistanceobtainingbusinessinsurancewouldbehelpfultosmallbusinesses.[e.g.,#2,AS#16]Othersreportednoneedforinsurance‐relatedassistance.[e.g.,#15a]Forexample,theBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthatheisnotawareofanyprogramsthatassistinobtainingbusinessinsurance,butindicatedthatsuchprogramswouldbehelpful.[#7]
Assistance in using emerging technology.Someintervieweessaidthatassistanceusingemergingtechnologywouldbehelpful.[e.g.,#9,#11,#37]Othersindicatedthattheyhavenoneedforemergingtechnologyassistance.[e.g.,#15a]Commentsinclude:
![Page 598: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/598.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 171
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmreportedthatshereceivedcomputertrainingatMiCasaResourceCenterandlearnedLCPtrackeratCOMTOColorado.Sheexplained,“Theyweregivingaclassaboutitanditisgoodtoknow.When[aclient]movedtotheirnewoffice,Igotthe…contractbecausetheprimeuse[d]LCPtracker….IgotthecontractbecauseIknewhowtouseit.”[#35]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmsaid,“Ourcompanyistryingtokeepupwithemergingtechnology,sowehavealotoflunchandlearnswherevendorscomeinandmakepresentations.The[CityandCountyofDenver]couldprobablypartnerwithRedRocksCommunityCollegeorothereducationalinstitutionstoprovideassistanceinusingemergingtechnology.”[#21a]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthatheisnotawareofanyprogramsthatassistinusingemergingtechnology.[#7]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofaspecialtyservicesfirmindicatedthatfurtherassistanceinusingemergingtechnologymaybehelpful.Hesaid,“Keepingupwithnewtechnologiesisachallenge,butwehavepeopleatthecompanywhoarestayingontopofthat….Itgivesusacompetitiveadvantage.”[#34]
J. Insights Regarding Contracting Processes
Insightsdiscussedincludethefollowingtopics:
Contractcomplianceandenforcement;
Solicitationsandprocurements;
Informationonpublicagencycontractingproceduresandbiddingopportunities;
Perceptionsofelectronicbidding,registration,andonlinedirectoryofpotentialsubcontractors;
Pre‐bidconferenceswheresubcontractorscanmeetprimecontractors;
Distributionoflistsofplanholdersorotherlistsofpossibleprimebidderstopotentialsubcontractors.
Otheragencyoutreachsuchasvendorfairsandevents;
Streamliningorsimplificationofbiddingprocedures;
Breakinguplargecontractsintosmallerpieces(unbundling);
Priceorevaluationpreferencesforsmallbusinesses;
Smallbusinessset‐asides;
Mandatorysubcontractingminimums;
Smallbusinesssubcontractinggoals;and
Formalcomplaintandgrievanceprocedures.
![Page 599: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/599.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 172
Contract compliance and enforcement. AfewbusinessownersandrepresentativesdiscussedcomplianceandenforcementofCityandCountyofDenvercontracts.Forexample:
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmsaidsheoncesignedablankletterofintentforageneralcontractorthatlaterrefusedtoutilizeherfirmonaproject.Shesaidthegeneralcontractortoldher,“Ohno,wemadeamistake.Weonlyshowedyouasasubifweneededyoutomeetourgoal.”[#2]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringfirmstatedthatthereshouldbebetterenforcementregardingprimecontractors’effortstomeetMWBErequirements.Shesaid,“Ifyou’regoingtohaveaprogramthatrequirescompliance,someoneisgoingtohavetomonitorittomakesurethebigprimesaremeetingthecompliance.Thatmeansyouneedbootsonthegroundtoactuallydothework.Thereneedstobesomesortofseriousrepercussionsfornotmeetingtherequirements.”[#5]
Solicitations and procurements. Someintervieweesreportedontheirexperienceswithsolicitationandprocurementprocesses.
Comments related to solicitations and procurements are broad. Forexample:
Regardingsolicitationsandprocurements,theBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmsaid,“It’sa‘goodol’boys’club.”Heexplained,“Theytalktoeachotheraboutupcomingbids,upcomingcontracts,andupcomingwork….That’swhyIwishthattherewasabetterplaceforthecitytohostsomething.[Thecityshould]say,‘Hey,herearethequalifications.Bid,’andthat’sit.Butbythetimeitdoesgettotheirbidprocess,thevendorsusuallyalreadyselected.”[#7]
Apublicmeetingparticipantsaid,“Ifeelalotoftimesthatthesolicitationsandtheprogramsthatwehaveestablished…feellikeit’sawelfaresystem.AndthereasonwhyIsaythatisbecausetheamountsofthecontractorthevaluesofthecontactkeepyouhere.You’renevergoingtogoandbeabig[business]here,soitprohibitsyoufromgrowing.Itjustkeepsyouatthislevel.”Sheadded,“Thebigissue…is[getting]minoritycompanies[togrow].Ithinkthat’sahugeproblembecauseyoucannevergetanopportunitytogrow.”[PT#4]
Thesamepublicmeetingparticipantcontinued,“Iknowthatwehavetheset‐asideprogramon…butthere’snotverymanycontactsinthere.And…[with]thedefinedselectionpoolfortheprofessionalservicesthisyear,theykeptthedollarvalueatthesamedollarvalueasitwaslasttime.Ithinkitwasan$11millioncontract….Butalltheprimes,becauseofthegrowthoftheairportandalltheactivitieshappening,theircontractorsquadrupled.Oneprojectmanagementcontractwentfrom$25milliontolike$45million[or]$90million.So,theircontractvaluesincrease,butthedefinedselectionpoolcontractsremainedthesame.Sothat’swhatImeanbythatwelfaresystem.We’rejustgoingtodowhatwehavetodotomeettheminimumrequirement[withoutletting]peoplegrowandbecomeeconomically…big.”[PT#4]
![Page 600: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/600.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 173
Regardingsolicitations,thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmstated,“Igetalotofsolicitationsfromprimecontractors,butthereisnofollow‐up.”[#20]
RegardingCityandCountyofDenver’snotificationandbidprocesses,theBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andESB‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmsaid,“TheywillpoststuffonRockyMountainBidNet,[but]whatIdon’talwaysseearethebidresults.They’llaskyoutoapplythroughthat,butwhenthebidtabscomeoutthey’renotposted.[Iftheyare],Ineverseethem.Youcangobackinandtryandfindthatproject,butalotoftimesthetabulationsortheawardinformationisn’tthere.Iknowtheypostthemontheirwebsites,butit’sanotherstepintheprocess,andasasmallbusinessyoudon’talwayshavethetimetolookforthatstuffintwoorthreedifferentplaces.”[#9]
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“AnotherthingI’vediscoveredisthatthepurchasingpersonwhoworkswith[our]categoryusuallydoesnotgotothecertificationlistandsay,‘Herearethebusinessesthatarecertifiedinthiscategory.Let’ssendthemasolicitationforthisproject,’whichwouldbehelpful.You’recertifiedwiththecityalready,sowhynotusethedirectoryorlistthatthecitymaintainsalreadytosolicitresponsesforprojects?Inoneinstance,IwenttotalktotheCityofDenverpurchasingagentandIexplainedthatwearecertifiedanddidnotgetasolicitationforaproject.Shetoldmetogotoanotherdepartmentforthat,soIaskedherhowshechosetosendpeoplethesolicitation….Shesaiditwasdependentonwhosecardshehadinherdeskdrawer.”[#9]
One business owner suggested that City and County of Denver be more transparent regarding
solicitation and procurement.TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmsuggestedthatCityandCountyofDenverbemoretransparentinitssolicitationandprocurementprocesses.Hesaidthatbythetimebidsareopentothepublic,“thevendors[are]usuallyalreadyselected.”[#7]
Information on public agency contracting procedures and bidding opportunities.Someintervieweesreportedonhowwellinformationisdisseminatedregardingpublicagencycontractingproceduresandbiddingopportunities.Forexample:
Whenaskedifhehadanydirectexperienceorwasawareofanyinformationonpublicagencycontractingproceduresandbiddingopportunitiesthatmightbenefitallsmallbusinesses,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaidthathegetsassistanceregardingfederalworkfromtheProcurementTechnicalAssistanceCenter(PTAC).[#22]
TheBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionsupplyfirmsaidthathedoesnotreceiveelectronicnoticesaboutopportunitieseventhoughheholdsseveralcertifications.[#36]
A trade association representative commented on his organization’s gathering of information
regarding contract opportunities for members.TheHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthatreceivinginformationonpublicagencycontractingproceduresandbiddingopportunitiesisveryhelpful.Hesaidtheorganizationtriestogatherthisinformationfor
![Page 601: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/601.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 174
members,andexplainedthatmanysmallbusinessownersdonotunderstandallthepublicrequirementsneededtosubmitasuccessfulbid.[#11]
Perceptions of electronic bidding, registration, and online directory of potential subcontractors. Mostbusinessownersandrepresentativessaidthatonlineservicesarehelpful,or“okay.”[e.g.,#28,#37]Forexample:
Regardingonlineregistrationwithpublicagenciesasapotentialbidder,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmsaid,“TheCityofDenverisreallygoodaboutthat.Theschooldistrictsareallgoodaboutthat[too].Ifyouwanttogetontheirlist,youcandothat.”[#21a]
TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmindicatedthatonlineregistrationasapotentialbidderishelpful.Hesaid,“Weareonlinewithalotofagencies.TheProcurementTechnicalAssistanceCenter(PTAC)willevendosearchesforcompanies.”[#22]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmindicatedthatelectronicbiddingandonlineregistrationasapotentialsubcontractorishelpful.ShesaidthatsheisregisteredwithRegionalTransportationDistrict,CityandCountyofDenver,andwithConnect2DOTforCDOT.[#35]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmsaidthatmostagenciesnowhaveinformationonpublicagencycontractingproceduresandbiddingopportunitiesontheirwebsite.Henotedthatthissaveshisfirmalotoftime.[#14]
ThesamebusinessownerlatersaidthatheisregisteredwithallpublicagenciesinDenvertoreceivebiddinginformationelectronically.[#14]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmreportedthatthefirmmaintainsitsownsubcontractordirectory.[#23a]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmsaidthatshetaughtherselfhowtoregisteronlinewithpublicagenciesandthatshereceivesinformationregularly.[#20]
A few interviewees had negative experiences with registration and online directories. Forexample:
TheBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionsupplyfirmsaid,“Everyonesaystogoon‐lineandregisteryourbusiness,butIdon’tthinkthemajorcompaniesgotheretofindyou.”[#36]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmreportedawarenessofanelectronicdirectoryofpotentialsubcontractors.Hesaid,“Wegotalistthatshowedushowtogoontothegovernmentwebsiteandfindsubs,[but]thenyouhaveto
![Page 602: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/602.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 175
contactthemonyourownandseeiftheywouldliketopartnerwithyou.There’sno[actual]program.There’sjustalistandaphonenumbertocall.”[#7]
Pre‐bid conferences where subcontractors can meet prime contractors.Businessownersandrepresentativesdiscussedthehelpfulnessofpre‐bidconferences.
Some saw the advantages of pre‐bid conferences.[e.g.,#25]Afewreportedonroomforimprovement.Commentsinclude:
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringfirmsuggestedtherebeasysteminplacetohelpprimesandsubcontractorsidentifyeachotheratpre‐bidconferencessothattheycaneasilycommunicateregardingworkingtogether.Shewentontosay,“Thinkabouthowmucheasieritwouldbeifeveryprimehadtowearapinknametagandeverysubcontractorhadtowearabluenametag….That[way]whenIwalkin,Iknowinstantlywhomytargetsare….[Because]currently…Idon’tknowwhothesepeopleareaswegothroughthesepre‐bidmeetings.I’vebeentohundredsofpre‐bidmeetings,orpre‐proposalmeetings,andIdon’tknowwhotogoupandtalkto….”[#5]
Whenaskedaboutpre‐bidconferences,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaidthatheattends“all”ofthem,andnotedthattheyareverybeneficialbecausetheyallowhimtomeetotherteamspursuingprojects.Hecommented,“Wegota[publicsector]contractbecauseIattendedeventsandspokewithalltheteamspursuingtheproject.”[#22]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmreportedthatshedoesattendpre‐bidconferencesandnotedthatherfirstpublicprojectwasawardedbyattendingone.[#35]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmstated,“Pre‐bidconferences,wheresubcontractorscanmeetprimecontractors,areheldoftenandourcompanyattendsmanyofthem.Thereisgoodinformationatthesemeetingsandthattheyarealsonetworkingopportunities.”[#21a]
TheBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionsupplyfirmsaidthathehasgonetoafewpre‐bidconferencestolearnaboutmajorprojects.However,hesaidthatifthereisnolineiteminaconstructionbudgetforhisproductsthathelpprimesmeetgoals,theyarenotinterestedinusinghisfirm.[#36]
Some business assistance organization representatives commented on the helpfulness of pre‐
bid conferences.Commentsinclude:
TheNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationindicatedthatpre‐bidconferencesarehelpful,andcommented,“Wesendoutflyerswereceivefrompublicentities.Atourexpowealsooffermatchmaking.”[#37]
![Page 603: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/603.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 176
TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationstatedthatpre‐bidconferencesareakeywayformemberstolearnaboutpublicsectoropportunities.[#33]
Some interviewees indicated that pre‐bid conferences are not helpful, not available, or they
choose not to attend them. Forexample:
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthatheisnotawareofanypre‐bidconferences.However,heindicatedthatsuchconferenceswouldbehelpfulifavailabletohisfirm.[#7]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmsaidthatpre‐bidconferencesareoftenjust“lipservice.”Heexplained,“They’redoingitsotheycangetthepublicentityofftheirback.”Hewentontosaythatthevalueoftheseeventsislearningwhoisalreadyontheteamandwhattheirneedsaregoingtobe.[#14]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmstated,“Iusedtoattendpre‐bidconferencesregularly,andsometimesstilldo,butthey’renotveryusefulforwhatIdosinceI’mveryspecialized.”[#20]
Distribution of lists of plan holders or other lists of possible prime bidders to potential subcontractors.Businessownersandrepresentativesdiscussedthehelpfulnessofplanholders’lists.Mostfoundthemhelpful.[e.g.,#21a]Forexample:
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmsaidthatshedoesnotuseplanholderslistsbecausetheyarenotuseful.Sheexplained,“TheywouldbemoreusefuliftheCityandCountyofDenverand[DenverInternationalAirport]hadagoaltoutilizelocalcompanies,because[then]out‐of‐townfirmscomingintotheDenvermarketwouldhaveincentivetoknowmycompany.”[#20]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmreportedthatshedoesuseonlineplanholdersliststofindprimebidders.[#35]
Other agency outreach such as vendor fairs and events.Manybusinessownersandrepresentativesdiscussedthehelpfulnessofoutreacheventssuchasvendorfairs.
Many interviewees reported that they support agency outreach such as training seminars,
conferences, networking events, and vendor fairs and attend them regularly.[e.g.,#21a]Forexample:
TheBlackAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaidbecauseofthe“smallknitcommunity”whenseekingsubcontractorsforpublicsectorjobs,recruitingisoftenthroughwordofmouth.Shesaidsheattendsoutreacheventstonetworkandfindoutthestatusofvariousbusinesses,andaddedthatclientssometimeshaverecommendationsbasedonpastprojects.[#13]
![Page 604: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/604.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 177
TheHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmindicatedthathisfirmhasattendedoutreacheventsorganizedbyCityandCountyofDenverandCDOTtolearnaboutupcomingcontractingopportunities.[#14]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmindicatedthatagencyoutreachishelpful.Shestatedthatsheattendsallagencyoutreacheventsthatshecan.[#35]
Some trade association and business assistance organization representatives discussed the
helpfulness of agency outreach for members.[e.g.,#40]Forexample:
TheNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationindicatedthatagencyoutreachbenefitsmembers,andcommented,“Wesendoutalloftheagencyoutreachinformation,andwealsoinvitethemtoourexpototalktoourmembers.”[#37]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthatthebestwayforsubcontractorstomarketthemselvestoprimesistoattendnetworkingevents.[#38]
TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationstatedthattheorganizationpromotesagencyoutreachandMinoritySupplierDevelopmentCouncilevents.Hesaidtheyalsopartnerwiththeotherminoritychamberstodojobfairsandotherevents.[#33]
Others indicated that they faced challenges in attending outreach events, do not support their
usefulness, or are unaware of their existence.Forexample:
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthatheisnotawareofanyvendorfairsorsimilarevents.[#7]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmstatedthatshehasattendedvendorfairs,butconsidersthem“forshow”becauseshebelievestheprimesalreadyknowwhotheyaregoingtouse.Shesaidthatshenolongerattendsvendorfairsforthisreason.[#20]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmsaidthatheisnotawareofanyagencyoutreachsuchasvendorfairsorevents.[#23b]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofaspecialtyservicesfirmsaidthatheisnotawareofagencyoutreachsuchasvendorfairs.[#34]
Streamlining or simplification of bidding procedures. Someintervieweesindicatedthatstreamliningorsimplificationofbiddingprocedureswouldbehelpful.[e.g.,#37]Otherssuggestedthatshorteningthetimeittakestobidwouldbeanimprovementforsmallbusinessestryingtomanagetheirtimeefficiently.Forexample:
Whenaskedaboutsimplifyingbiddingprocedures,theBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andESB‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmsaid,“It’smyunderstandingthatthey’vebeendoingthatintermsofbreakingthecontractsup.Iguess
![Page 605: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/605.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 178
theonethingthatIwouldsaybasedonwherewenormallyfitwithinthescheduleisthatourstuffisalwaysthelastpartthat’sgoingtogointoaproject.”[#9]
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“Ifitisgoingtotaketwoorthreeyearsbeforeourpartisneeded,it’sreallydifficulttoanticipatewhatthemarket’sgoingtodothreeyearsfromnow.Asanexample,whenthePresidentannouncedthathewouldbeaddingthemarketforsteel,allmymanufacturersstartedsaying,‘Well,we’regoingtotakea5percentincrease,’or,‘We’remonitoringthesituation.’So,ifIhavetobidacontractwheremypartistwoyearsorevensixmonthsdowntheroad,IhavenoearthlyideawhatthatwillcostandI’mnotsurethatanybodyelsedoeseither.”[#9]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaidthatstreamliningbiddingprocedureswouldbehelpfulinmaneuveringagencycontracting.[#28]
Whenaskedifbiddingproceduresshouldbestreamlined,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmindicatedthattheyshould.Hesaid,“Sometimessomeofthebiddingproceduresandsomeofthebidforms,andallofthat,aresocumbersome.Youspendalotoftimedoingthatinsteadofdoingthebid.”[#21a]
Whenaskedifstreamliningorsimplifyingbiddingprocedureswouldbehelpful,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“Thatwouldbegreat.Itjustseemsliketherearealotofformstobefilledout,evenintheRFQstage,thatcouldbewaiveduntilcontractnegotiation.”[#22]
Breaking up large contracts into smaller pieces (unbundling).Thesizeofcontractsandunbundlingofcontractsweretopicsofinteresttomanyinterviewees.
Most business owners and representatives indicated that breaking up large contracts into
smaller components would be helpful.[e.g.,#12,#13,#20,#25,#33,WT#9,WT#11]Afewmentionedthatitallowsforsmallerfirmstoperformasprimecontractorsratherthansubcontractors.Commentsinclude:
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringfirmindicatedthatshesupportstheunbundlingoflargecontracts.[#5]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“Whenourfirmstarted,wetookfulladvantageoftheprojectssetasideforSBE‐certifiedfirms.[However],Ihaven’tseenapoolofprojectsrecentlyforthosefirms.”[#28]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedgeneralcontractingfirmstated,“Theonlywaysmallbusinessesaregoingtogrowistobreak‐upsomeoftheverylargeprojectsandmakethosesmallbusinessset‐asides.Thatwouldbehelpfulbecausetheywouldonlybecompetingwithanothersmallbusiness.”[#19]
![Page 606: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/606.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 179
TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaiditwouldbehelpfulifCityandCountyofDenverbrokeuplargecontractsintosmallerpieces,becauseitwouldallowhimtheopportunitytobidasaprimecontractorratherthanasub.[#22]
TheBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionsupplyfirmindicatedthathesupportstheunbundlingofpublicsectorcontracts.Hesaidthatinhisindustry“publicagenciesbundleeverythingtogetherbecausetheysaythatgetsthemthebestvalueforthetaxpayer.”Hecommented,“Itmakesitimpossibleforasmallbusinesstocompete.”[#36]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmindicatedthatunbundlinglargecontractswouldbenefitherfirm.Shesaid,“Becausemycompanyisverysmall,findingaprojectinthepublicsectorthatissmallenoughformeisdifficult.”[#35]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaid,“Denver[should]requirethatbusinessesthathavetomeetgoals…breakdowntheworkintosmallerjobsizesforsmallercertifiedbusinessestohaveanopportunityandabilitytobid.[Forexample]$50,000to$200,000sizejobs.”[WT#5]
Some trade association and business assistance organization representatives agreed that
unbundling large contracts would benefit members.[e.g.,#6]Forexample:
TheNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationindicatedthatunbundlinglargecontractswouldbenefitmembers.Shesaid,“Therewasoneparticularinstancewhere[apublicagency]wantedacompanytoservealargenumberofclientsatacertainlevel,anditwastoomuchforasmallcompanytotakeon.So,theydroppedout.Theymakethepackagestoobigforasmallbusiness.”[#37]
TheHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationstated,“Thebreakingdownofcontractstosmallerdollarsizesisextremelyhelpfultoourbusinessesingainingexperience.”[#11]
One interviewee discussed his firm’s efforts to unbundle contracts as a prime contractor.
Regardingunbundlingcontracts,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmsaid,“Wetaketheprojectgoalandwebreakitdown.Andwetakethebudgets,andseewhatmakessense,butthenwehavetofititintothewholeschemeandkeepthesubcontractorwithintheirability.So,wedoalotofthatdownstream.”[#21a]
Price or evaluation preferences for small businesses. Someintervieweeshadcommentsonpriceorevaluationpreferences.Forexample:
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmsaidthatheisnotawareofanyprogramsorinitiativespertainingtopriceorevaluationpreferencesforsmallbusinesses.[#23a]
![Page 607: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/607.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 180
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmsaidthatsheisnotawareofpriceorevaluationpreferences,butnotedthatshewouldliketoseepointsawardedtobidsthatincludelocalsmallbusinesses.[#20]
A business assistance organization representative noted that her organization shares
information on price/evaluation preferences with members.Whenaskedifmembersareknowledgeableofpriceorevaluationpreferences,theNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaidthattheycoverthetopicattheirexpo.[#37]
Small business set‐asides.Thestudyteamdiscussedtheconceptofsmallbusinessset‐asides,aprogramthatlimitsthebiddingofcertaincontractstofirmsqualifyingassmallbusinesses,withbusinessownersandrepresentatives.
Some business owners and representatives supported small business set‐asides.[e.g.,#5,#22,WT#11]Forexample:
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedgeneralcontractingfirmstated,“[I’m]notsureaboutgoalsonprojects,butIhaveheardit’snotgoingwell.However,set‐asidescouldclearuptheissuesofgoalssetting.Anexamplewouldbeifaprojecthasa15percentgoalandyoumakethatportionaset‐aside.Itcouldbeanopportunityforsmallbusinessestocompetewitheachother.”[#19]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmstatedthatshe“isfor”smallbusinessset‐asides.Sheexplained,“Youdon’twanttoconcentratepowerinthehandsofafewrich,old,whitemen.Throughgenerationsthere’llalwaysbenewstart‐ups,andthosenewcompaniesneedtogetachance.Thatisparticularlytrueinasituationofwomenandpeopleofcolor,becausetheyhavelessaccesstofinancing.That’sprovenoverandoveragain.So,ifyouaretryingtostartacompanyasapersonofcolororasafemale,youhavetostartoutwithsmallcontractsbecauseyoucan’tgetthatbusinessloanforamilliondollars.”[#12]
Trade association and business assistance organization representatives generally agreed that
small business set‐asides benefit member firms.Forexample:
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationindicatedthatsmallbusinessset‐asideswouldbehelpfulformembers.Shesaid,“Itrytoencourage[theCityandCountyofDenver]tohaveanopportunityforsmallfirmstobeprimes….Thataddsvaluetothefirm.”[#38]
TheHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationindicatedthathesupportssmallbusinessset‐asides.Hesaid,“The[CityandCountyofDenver]puttheEBEprograminitsordinancefourorfiveyearsago,andnoprojectshavebeenissuedunderthatprogram.Theyweresupposedtobesmalldollars,andonlysmallguysthatwerecertifiedEBEscouldbidonitso[they]onlybid…against[their]owncompetitionfortheseprojects.Theywouldbeissued.You'dgettheopportunitytoworkfor[CityandCountyofDenverand]learnthepaperworkonasmall‐scaleproject.Ican'timaginethatnotbeing
![Page 608: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/608.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 181
trulysuccessfulandbeneficialtothesmallbusinesses,butwedonotknowbecausethereneverwereanyissued.”[#11]
TheNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationindicatedthatsmallbusinessset‐asidesbenefitcertifiedmembers.[#37]
Others expressed concerns regarding small business set‐asides, did not support them, or were
not familiar with them.Forexample:
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“AlthoughDenverprovidesset‐asidesforDBE/WBE/MBE/SBEcontractorsandconsultants,thedeckisstillstackedagainstus….ThecontractingofficerswhowritetheRFPsstackthemheavilyinfavorofincumbents.Thelanguagetheyusetodothisis‘pastperformance’fortheexactprojecttype….Thismayberelevantforveryspecificprojecttypes,[like]playgrounds,butformostlandscapeapplicationsthisiswaylessso.Thelandscapearoundajudicialbuildingisn’tsubstantiallydifferentthan…privatesectorofficebuildings.Byspecifyingpastperformanceinasuperspecificprojecttypeashighlyimportanttobeasuccessfulcompetitor,thesame‘goodol’boys’getthework.”[WT#11]
Whenaskedaboutthehelpfulnessofsmallbusinesssetasides,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaidthathehasgottenon‐callcontractsthroughDenver’ssmallbusinessset‐asideprogram.However,hedescribedtheprojectsinthatpoolas“small,”andnotedthathisfirmiscapableofdoinglargerprojects.Hewentontosaythatthelargerprojectsalwaysgotobigfirms.[#22]
WhenaskedifhesolicitsSBE/MBE/WBEsubcontractorsforbidsorquotes,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofanengineeringcompanystated,“Idon’tbelieveinthoseset‐asideprograms.IwillonlyworkwithpeopleIknow,andtheyaren’tinthatcertifiedprogram.”[#26]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmsaidthatheisnotawareofanyprogramsorinitiativespertainingtosmallbusinesssetasides.[#23a]
Mandatory subcontracting minimums.Someintervieweessupportedaminimumlevelofsubcontractingonprojects,indicatingitwouldbehelpfultotheirfirm.[e.g.,WT#11]Forexample:
Whenaskedaboutmandatorysubcontractingminimums,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“Theyareneeded.”[#22]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmindicatedthatmandatorysubcontractingminimumsbenefithisfirmbyensuringthatlargecompaniesdonotgetallofthework.[#14]
![Page 609: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/609.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 182
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmindicatedthatmandatorysubcontractingminimumswouldbenefitherfirmandothersmall,disadvantagedbusinesses.Shesaid,“Primeconsultantsintheprofessionalservicesofdesigndon’tunderstandthereisaproblemwithdiversityorinclusivity.Manypersonallyviewthemselvesaspoliticallyprogressiveandnon‐discriminatory.[However],itdoesn’toccurtothemtoincludeSBE/MWBE/DBEfirmsonprojectteams,unlesscompelled.”[WT#3]
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“Ihaveworkedwithseveraldesignfirmsthatcomplementmyfirm’sworkandendorseustootherfirms.However,unlessaprojecthasaspecificgoalassignedtoit,thosesamedesignfirmswillnotincludeSBE/MWBE/DBEfirmsintheirproposals.Theirgoalistosimplymeettheparticipationgoal,butnotexceedit.ManylargeprimeconsultantsvieweverydollarallocatedtoSBE/MWBE/DBEfirmsasalossofrevenueforthem.Theydonotviewitasabenefitorenrichingtheirteamorworkproduct.SomeprimeconsultingfirmsbarelyconcealtheirfrustrationoverperceivedlossesofrevenuebecausetheyhavetoworkwithSBE/MWBE/DBEfirms.”[WT#3]
Shewentontosay,“Therearediscrepanciesbetweenwhatseniormanagementatlargedesignfirmssayandtheirpractices.Atseniorlevels,mostalldesignfirmsclaimtoappreciateworkingwithdiverseteams.[But]inpractice,projectmanagersarerewardedformaximizingrevenuesintheshort‐term.Therefore,sharingscopeandfeewithSBE/MWBE/DBEfirmsconflictswiththemetricbywhichtheyareevaluated.Itdoesn’tmatterifanSBE[or]MWBE/DBEfirmissuperiorineveryway[because]itisnotintheprojectmanager’sbestinteresttoworkwithacertifiedfirm.”[WT#3]
One trade association representative stated that small business subcontracting minimums are
“absolutely necessary.”Whenaskedaboutmandatorysubcontractingminimums,theHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaid,“Thatiswhatgoal‐settingdoes,andIthinkitisabsolutelynecessary.[However],thecaveattothatistherearesomescopesofworkwherewehavenocertifiedfirms.”[#11]
A few interviewees were unfamiliar with mandatory subcontracting minimums, or
downplayed their helpfulness.Commentsinclude:
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmsaidthatheisnotawareofanyprogramsorinitiativespertainingtomandatorysubcontractingminimums.[#23a]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaidthatmandatorysubcontractingminimumsarenotideal,thoughtheyare“betterthannothing.”[#12]
Small business subcontracting goals.Intervieweesdiscussedtheconceptofsettingcontractgoalsforsmallbusinessparticipationinpubliccontracts.
![Page 610: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/610.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 183
Several business owners and representatives voiced approval for small business
subcontracting goals.Someexpressedthatgoalsshouldbesetorexpanded.[e.g.,#22]Forexample:
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmsaidthat,asasubcontractor,herfirmhas“benefitedfromsmallbusinesssubcontractinggoals.”[#20]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmstatedthatsmallbusinesssubcontractinggoalsforDBE/MWBEfirmsarecriticalforhisbusinessbecausetheyensurethatthelargecompaniesdonotgetallofthework.[#14]
Regardingsmallbusinesscontractinggoals,apublicmeetingparticipantstated,“Everycontractshouldhaveagoal.”[PT#4]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“Sothestrugglesinbeingaminoritywomanownedbusinessisthatinrealitybecause…oftheseprograms,theprimeisn’tinterestedinyouunlessthereisagoal.Thenwhenyouhavearelationshipwiththem,theywanttoutilizeyouforwork,butyou'recapped.Youknowyou'regoingtobecapped.Ontopofallofthat,youhavetohavethefinancialcapabilitiestoholdyourown.”[PT#3a]
Regardinghowsmallbusinesssubcontractinggoalsareset,thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaWBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“ThegoalscommitteeatDPSdoessetbothconstructionandprofessional[servicesgoals].Andyouhear…fromthebigcontractorsaswell[that]thesedisciplinesareatcapacity,andeverybodyjusttakes[them]attheirwordwhenthere'snomechanisminplacetoactuallytrackthat.”Sheadded,“Iwouldthinkinthisdayandage…thatthereshouldbetoolsouttheresothattheycantellwho’satcapacity.”[PT#3c]
Thesamebusinessrepresentativecontinued,“Andtome…it’sinsultingtohavesomebody[tell]me…everybody’satcapacity.WhenI[wantto]growmyfirm,don’tyoutellmethatI’matcapacity….That’snotadecisionthatyoucanmakeforme,becauseifIgetabigcontractandaprojectthatIreally[wantto]workon,I’mgoingtogohiresomebody,andthat’showIgrowmyfirm.”[PT#3c]
Some trade association representatives indicated that small business subcontracting goals
benefit membership.Forexample:
Regardingsmallbusinesssubcontractinggoals,theHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaid,“Itallowsawidergroupofsmallbusinessfolkstoparticipateandcompete.Thatisreallytrulyalevelplayingfieldforsmallbusinesses.Whenitistherequirement,there'sacapofwhatsizeyoucanbe.”[#11]
TheBlackAmericanfemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaid,“Ifthere’sno[DBE]goal,therewillprobablybenooutreachevent[or]preconstructionmeetings,andnoway
![Page 611: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/611.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 184
forthefirmstofindoutaboutopportunitiesearlyenoughtogetengagedandbuildrapport.So,ifyou’renotalreadyintheknow,[then]youdon’tknow.”[#6]
ThesametradeassociationrepresentativesaidthatsomemembersusethesameDBEsubsforbothpublicandprivatesectorprojects.Sheadded,“Therearefourthatcometomindrightaway.They’veestablishedanameforthemselvesonthesepublicprojects,[so]alotoftheteamsthathaveengagedthempulledthemintotheirprivateprojectstoo.”[#6]
Some interviewees indicated that small business subcontracting goals put their firms at a
disadvantage.Somesaidthatgoalsaresometimesabusedorusedforthewrongreasons.[e.g.,#11]Forexample:
Themalerepresentativeofanon‐Hispanicwhitemale‐ownedprofessionalservicesfirmdescribedhisfrustrationwithcontractorswho,whentryingtomeetunrealisticgoals,simplypassthesegoalsontosubcontractorswhomaynothavetheappropriateexperienceorexpertise.HewentontodescribetheprocessinSanFrancisco,wherethecityidentifieswhatpartsoftheprojectscanbedonebysmall,minority‐orwoman‐ownedbusinessesandspecificallycontractsthosepartstothosefirms.HenotesthattheCityofSanFranciscodoesnotleavethejobofachievingsubcontractinggoalstoprimeandsubcontractors.[#1a]
Thefemalerepresentativeofanon‐Hispanicwhitemale‐ownedprofessionalservicesreporteda“superhugedisconnect”betweentheDenverOfficeofSmallBusinessOpportunity(DSBO)GoalsCommitteeandtheactualworkforceavailable.Shestatedthatthereisthereisahighernumberofminority‐andwomen‐ownedfirmsonthecommitteethantheyarerepresentingintheworkforce.Thismakesherfeellike“theMWBEcommunityhasbasicallybandedtogethertotryandgetthehighestgoalpossibleonanyprojectthatcomesoutofCityandCountyofDenver,regardlessofthesizeandhowitwillbenefittheproject.”Sheaddedthattherearenorulesrestrictinggoalcommitteemembersfrombiddingonaprojecttheysetgoalsfor.[#1c]
Asurveyrespondentcommented,“Ithinkthey'reputtingextremepressuresonDBE[s]byincreasingthequotasinalreadyconstrainedmarkets.They'retakingonmoreworkthantheycanhandle.”[AS#19]
Asurveyrespondentstated,“Beingoutbidisfrustrating.Beingasmallercompany,opportunityshouldbebasedonmerit,notonthebasisofourdiversity/owner.”[AS#2]
Asurveyrespondentindicatedthatcontractgoalsputtheirfirmatadisadvantage,saying,“Notbeingwomen‐owned/minorityisadisadvantage.”[AS#22]
Formal complaint and grievance procedures.Someintervieweesdiscussedformalcomplaintandgrievanceprocedures.
Some business owners did not find complaint procedures helpful, had no experience with the
procedures, or feared retribution. Forexample:
![Page 612: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/612.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 185
TheNativeAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,SDB‐,SDVOSB‐,andHUBZone‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmsaiditwouldbehelpfulifCityandCountyofDenver“weremorewillingtomeetandreallydiscuss[issues].”[#39]
Whenaskedforherthoughtsonformalcomplaintandgrievanceprocedures,thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“Ithinkyouhavetobereallycarefulwithprogramslikethatbecauseyoucangetblacklisted.Ithinkit’sgood,butIthinkthatwithwhistleblowers,it’sjusttough.”[#12]
Onthetopicofformalcomplaintandgrievanceprocedures,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmexplainedthathemadeacomplaintonaDenverPublicWorksprojectthatwasnotresolvedbecauseitwasnotaddressedbyanimpartialindividual.[#22]
K. Insights Regarding Minority‐ and Woman‐owned Business Programs
Interviewees,participantsinpublichearings,andotherindividualsmadeanumberofcommentsaboutrace‐andgender‐basedmeasuresthatpublicagenciesuse,includingMBE/WBEandDBEcontractgoalsandcommentsregarding:
FederalDBEProgramatCityandCountyofDenver,andotherrace‐andgender‐basedprograms;and
AnyissuesregardingCityandCountyofDenverorotherpublicagencymonitoringandenforcementofitsprograms.
Federal DBE Program in City and County of Denver, and other race‐ and gender‐based programs. BusinessownersandrepresentativesprovidedinsightsonCityandCountyofDenver’simplementationoftheFederalDBEProgramandotherrace‐andgender‐basedprograms.Forexample:
ApublicmeetingparticipantindicatedthatherexperiencewiththeSBA8(a)programhasbeenpositive.Shesaid,“Ifyou’re8(a)certified,youcangetpaidinsevendays.Andiftheyhaveadispute,theyhaveonlysevendaystotakecareofthatdispute.”[PT#4]
TheBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionsupplyfirmreportedthatthefirmjustreceiveditsSBA8(a)certification.Henotedthatheconsiderstheprogrameffective,andsaid,“Theyatleasthaveamechanisminplacetoeventheplayingfield.Idon’tknowwhytheairportand[RegionalTransportationDistrict]aren’tforcedtousethisprogramwhentheygetfederaldollarsfortheirtransportationprojects.”[#36]
WhenaskedabouttheFederalDBEProgram,MWBE,andSBEprogramsandtheirimplementationbyCityandCountyofDenver,theHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedgeneralcontractingfirmsaid,“Alltheseprogramsarethesame.Ican’trecognizeanydifferences.Ididn’tevenknowIwasn’tcertifiedwiththefederalgovernmentuntilsomeonesaiditwasn’tthesame.”She
![Page 613: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/613.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 186
continued,“Forsmallbusinessesthataretryingtogrowtheirbusiness,theseprogramsareachallengetounderstandbecausetheyallhavedifferentrequirements.”[#19]
WhenaskedaboutCityandCountyofDenver’simplementationoftheFederalDBEProgram,thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmsaid,“I’macertifiedDBEandIknowthatprogramkicksinwhenthefederalgovernmentputsmoneyintoalocalproject.[However],reciprocalcertificationofcompaniescomingtoColoradofromotherstatesshouldbemoredifficult.”[#20]
A few trade association and business assistance organization representatives commented on
topics related to the Federal DBE Program and its implementation by City and County of
Denver.Forexample:
WhenaskedifshehasanyrecommendationstoimprovetheFederalDBEProgram,theBlackAmericanfemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthatnationalandlocalbestpracticesshouldbereviewed.Sheadded,“Theyshouldseewhetherornotfolksareattendingnationalcomplianceconferencesorotherprogramsthatcouldassistinthedevelopmentofarobustprogram.Wearerightinthemiddleofbillionsofdollars’worthofprojectsrightnow,andthere’salotthatneedstobedone.”[#6]
WhenaskedaboutmembersthathaveexperiencedtheCityandCountyofDenver’simplementationoftheFederalDBEProgram,thesametradeassociationrepresentativesaidthatmembersinvolvedintheprogramspeakhighlyofaDenverDivisionofSmallBusinessOpportunity(DSBO)representative.Shewentontosay,“She’sdoneareallygoodjobintermsofconnectingwiththecommunityandbeingthefaceofthedepartment,andmakingsurethatshe’sinsertedherselfinthecommunityforustoknowthatthey’rehere,they’relistening.She’smadesomechangesonherlevelwhereshecould,soIdowanttomakesurethat’sacknowledged….She’sprovidedcommunityrepresentationfortheoffice.”[#6]
WhenaskedifmembershaveanyexperiencewiththeFederalDBEProgramanditsimplementationbyCityandCountyofDenver,andifshehasanyrecommendationsforimprovement,theNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaid,“Wehavemembersthathaveparticipatedinthatthrough[DenverInternationalAirport]andtheCityandCounty[ofDenver].”Sheadded,“AnythingthatcouldbedonetostreamlinethewholeDBEprogramwouldbebeneficial.”[#37]
Whenaskedifshehasanycommentsorrecommendationsaboutanyothercurrentorpotentialrace/ethnicity/gender‐basedprograms,thesamebusinessassistanceorganizationrepresentativesaid,“Theyhavebeenreallygoodaboutcomingtous,andweneedtomakesurethatcontinueswhenpeopleatagencieschange.Fromthetopdown,theyneedtomakeacommitmenttohaveapresenceinthecommunity.Peoplearemorecomfortableapproachingthemwhenthey’reonourturf.”[#37]
Whenaskedifhehasanycommentsorrecommendationsaboutanycurrentorpotentialrace/ethnicity/gender‐basedprograms,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaid,“WhatIwouldsayisthatthe[CityandCountyof
![Page 614: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/614.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 187
Denver]hasanopportunitytobealeaderandbeinnovative.Ihopetheyfollowthrough.”[#33]
Any issues regarding City and County of Denver or other public agency monitoring and enforcement of its programs. SomeintervieweeshadcommentsregardingtheimplementationoftheFederalDBEProgramorotherrace‐andgender‐basedprograms,includingreportingbyprimecontractorsorabuseof“goodfaithefforts”processes,“fronts”and“pass‐throughs.”
Businesses reported their insights, both positive and negative, regarding monitoring and
enforcement of race‐ and gender‐based programs. Forexample:
Themalerepresentativeofanon‐Hispanicwhitemale‐ownedprofessionalservicesfirmsaidheisfrustratedwiththeminority‐andgender‐basedrequirements.Henotedthatthepercentagesofprojectsthatarerequiredtobefilledbyminority‐orwoman‐ownedsubsdonotmatchupwiththenumberofminority‐orwoman‐ownedsubswhohaveeitheraninterestintheprojectortheskillsandexperiencenecessarytocompletetheproject.Hesaidthisdiscrepancymakesitdifficulttocontractoutworktominority‐orwoman‐ownedbusinessesastherearenotenoughwillingandablefirmswiththosecertifications.[#1a]
Thesamebusinessrepresentativestatedthatbeingchosenasasubcontractorinpublicsectorworkischallenging,expressingthathisfirmischosensecondtominority‐andwomen‐ownedfirmswhomeetatechnicalrequirement.[#1a]
Thefemalerepresentativeofanon‐Hispanicwhitemale‐ownedprofessionalservicesfirmindicatedthatherfirmisfrustratedbecausetheycannot“[check]theboxes”likeaminority‐orwoman‐ownedfirm,whichshefeelsimpedestheiropportunitytosubmitabidorpricequotetoaprime.Shesaid,“Primefirmsfirstgotoanyfirmsthatmeetthoserequirements,andtheniftheyfeellikenoneofthemarecapable,thentheywillcometous.”[#1b]
TheHispanicAmericanfemalerepresentativeofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“I’vebeeneverywhereinthis[country]…doingbusinessdevelopment.[In]thelastthreeyears[inDenver]Ihave…experiencedprimesnotcallingaDBEfirmback.Ihavenevereverinallmylast20yearsexperiencedthat[previously].”[PT#3b]
TheBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionsupplyfirmreportedthatthereshouldbebettercomplianceandenforcementofrace‐andgender‐basedprogramsonpartofCityandCountyofDenver.[#36]
A trade association representative said there needs to be better compliance monitoring.TheBlackAmericanfemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationreportedthatthereisaneedforbetterpublicagencytrainingoncompliancemonitoring,especiallyforsomeDenverDivisionofSmallBusinessOpportunity(DSBO)staff.[#6]
![Page 615: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/615.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 188
Many business owners and representatives commented on false reporting of MBE/WBE/DBE
participation, “fronts,” negative issues with or falsifying “good faith efforts.”Somereportednegativeperceptionsorknowledgeof“goodfaithefforts.”Forexample:
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“Iunderstanditseffortstotrytomakesurethatpeoplearen’tlying,[but]Ithinkalotofpeoplewithintheprogramarelying.It’s51percentownedbythewoman,butit’sreallythehusbandbehindthescenesdoingit.IfeeltherearealotoffakeWBEsoutthere,butwe’rearealWBE.There’snomanheretellingmewhattodo.”[#12]
TheBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionsupplyfirmstatedthatpublicagenciesshouldbeverystringentwithwhotheyletintothecertificationprogram.Hecommentedthatheissuspiciousofacoupleofwoman‐ownedcompaniesthathebelievescouldbe“fronts.”[#36]
Themalerepresentativeofanon‐Hispanicwhitemale‐ownedprofessionalservicesfirmstated,“There’sasmallcollectionoffirmsthathavedecidedthattheyarenotgoingtogrowbeyondacertainpointsothat[they]canremainMBEs,WBEsorSBEs.Ithinkthisdiscouragesotherfirmsfromsaying,‘I’mwillingtostepoutandstartmyownfirmsandwork,’becausethey’recompetingwiththisfirmthathasbeenasmallbusinessoraminoritybusinessfor20years.Andinsomecases,thatfirmis,andthemakeupofthefirmhaschangedfromitsinitialyears,andthepeoplewhooriginallyfoundeditmayormaynotevenbethereanymore.But,thefactistherewasaconsciousdecisiontostaybelowthecaptonotgraduateoutoftheprogram.”[#1a]
Thesamemalerepresentativerecommendeda“sunsetrule”andre‐applicationrequirementforDBEcertification.ThisprocesswouldincludeatimelimitsetonDBEcertification,andafterthecertificationexpirestherewouldbeadesignatedwaitingperiodbeforethefirmcouldre‐apply.Hereportsthatthisstructurewouldresultinasmallerpoolofsubcontractorsandwouldbetterincentivizesmallbusinessgrowth.[#1a]
Regardingnegativeissueswith“goodfaithefforts”processes,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“Iknowforafactthattherewereseveralprojectmanagersthatdidnotwanttoworkwith[SBA]8(a)companies.Thenthereis[DenverPublicSchools].Andbytheway,wedon’tworkwithDPSanymore.Iknowaguywhousedtohavehisowncontractingfirm,andnowheworksfor[anationalcontractor]wherehe’saprojectmanager,sohe’sinapositiontohiresubconsultants.HegotintoasituationonaDPSprojectwherehewashavingtroublemeetingthegoal,andhetoldDPS[aboutit].TheDPSprojectmanagersaidnottoworryaboutitastheywouldtakecareofit.”Healsosaid,“Thereis[an]instancewherewewerekickedoffofateambecausetheDenverPublicWorksprojectmanagerwantedtoworkwithanarchitecturalfirmoutof[LosAngeles].Theyobviouslydidn’tmeettheirgoal,sosomebodydidsomething.”[#22]
Thesamebusinessownerlateradded,“Acontractorhadanon‐call[contract]at[DenverInternationalAirport].TheywerenewtoDIAandhadanoverallgoalontheirproject.They
![Page 616: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/616.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 189
gotdifferentdirectivesfromdifferentprojectmanagersregardinghowtomanagebidsforthatcontract,sotheyusethegoalstotheiradvantage.”[#22]
WhenaskedifhewasawareofSBE/MBE/WBEfrontsorfraudbeingaproblemforminority‐orwoman‐ownedfirmsinthelocalmarketplace,thesamebusinessownerstated,“Yes.ThereisanMWBEwhosepersonalitymakeshimverydifficulttoworkwith.Ithinkheisafront.Othersareawareofit[too],butturnablindeye.”[#22]
Asurveyrespondentsaid,“Denverseemstousesomefavoredcontractorsonsomeoftheirprojects.Oneparticularcontractorisshownasasmall,woman‐ownedbusiness,butIbelieveitisnolongerasmallbusinessasitrelatestotheirdollarvolumeofwork.”[AS#12]
TheNativeAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,SDB‐,SDVOSB‐,andHUBZone‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmsaidthathehasbeenaskedtopartnerwithbig‐boxstoresonprojects,butdeclinedbecausehefelttheywouldusehiscompanyasa“pass‐through.”Hewentontosaythathecanbecompetitiveonhisown.[#39]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmsaidthathebelievestheretobefalsereportingofSBEandMBE/WBEparticipation.Hestated,“Iknowforafactthatit’shappening.”HesaidthatheknowsofaformerCityofDenveremployeewhotriedto“exposeit,”butwasfiredfordoingso.Heexplainedthat,accordingtothisformercityemployee,bigcompaniessometimesacquireminorityfirmsand“saytheyareminority[now],orsaythatthey’re[now]thisorthat.”Hecontinued,“So,heexposedthatinDenver.Itwasinthenewspaper,actually….HesaiditwasrampantinDenver.It’sbeenthatwayforyears.”[#7]
TheBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“Someofthesefirmshaveyougothroughtheproposalexerciseknowingfullwelltheyneverhadanyintentionofprovidingyouwiththeopportunityatall.Irefertotheseas‘almostopportunities.’Someofthesebigfirmsonlywanttogothroughthemotionsandchecktheminoritybox.Ihavehadseveralsituationsofthis,onlytolaterfindoutthatanotherphotographer…wasgiventheprojectandsubmittedaproposalmuchhigherthanmine[with]qualityofwork…atthesamelevelasmineorless.Ihavealsobeengiventheopportunityto"hurryup"andsubmitadetailedproposalfora“potential”project,onlytodiscoverthat[the]firmrequestingtheproposalissecretlyshoppingmyproposalbecausetheydon'tunderstandhowtoproperlyputtogetheracompletescopeofwork.”[WT#12]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmstated,“Thegoodfaitheffortprocessisasham.Igetalotofsolicitationsfromprimecontractors,butthereisnofollow‐up.Anexampleisjetbridgecontracts.Thereareonlythreemanufacturers,andtheseprojectsareveryexpensive.Thereisoftena15percentDBEgoal,buttherearenoMWBEcompaniesthatarebigenough.So,theysaytheyhavetriedtofindMWBEsknowingfullwellthatitisimpossible.”[#20]
Regarding“fronts”orfraud,thesamebusinessownersaid,“Thisdoesoccur.Acertifiedwomanrecentlygota$10millionconstructionmanagementcontractandsubbedout$8millioninHVACtoalargemajoritycontractor.”[#20]
![Page 617: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/617.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 190
Whenaskedaboutfalsereportingof“goodfaithefforts,”thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmindicatedthatitdoesoccur.Hesaid,“I’veheardandprobablyseenit,butwehaveneverparticipated,norwouldwedoit.”[#21a]
Trade association and business assistance organization representatives generally agreed that
“fronts” and fraud do exist in the Denver marketplace.Commentsinclude:
TheHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidhedoesbelievethatDBE“fronts”andfraudexist.Hesaid,“Therearefirmsthatgetcertifiedthatshouldneverhavebeencertifiedbecausetheylied.”Heindicatedthathehasfirsthandexperienceoffirmsattemptingtodothis.[#11]
WhenaskedifheisawareofanyfalsereportingofDBEparticipationorfalsifyingof“goodfaithefforts,”thesametradeassociationrepresentativesaid,“Iquestionpass‐throughsandtheutilizationofcertifiedfirms[forthatpurpose].Forexample,whensomeonesays,‘I’mgoingtouseyoufororderingmysupplies….’[They’rereallysaying],‘I'lluseyourname…[and]I'macceptingdelivery.I'macceptingalltheriskforalloftheproducts,andyoureallyaren'ttakinganyriskotherthanlettingmecountyouonmyparticipationlevelforthefulldollaramount.’”[#11]
TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaidthathehearsaboutDBE“fronts”andfraudfromthegeneralpublic,thoughnotfromtheorganization’smembers.[#33]
Others reported no knowledge of “fronts,” or false reporting of “good faith efforts.”Forexample:
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmstatedthatheisnotawareofSBE/MBE/WBE“fronts”orfalsereportingof“goodfaithefforts.”[#23a]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmreportedthatsheisnotawareofany“fronts,”orfalsereportingof“goodfaithefforts.”[#35]
One business assistance organization representative indicated that members do not
experience “fronts,” or other fraud.TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationreportedthathehasnotheardmembersdiscuss“fronts,”orfalsereportingof“goodfaithefforts.”[#33]
L. Insights Regarding Certification
BusinessownersandrepresentativesdiscussedtheprocessforDBE,MBE,WBE,andSBEcertificationandothercertifications,includingcommentsrelatedto:
Knowledgeofcertificationopportunities;
![Page 618: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/618.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 191
Easeordifficultyofbecomingcertified;
Advantagesanddisadvantagesofcertification;and
Experienceregardingthecertificationprocessandanyrecommendationsforimprovement.
Knowledge of certification opportunities. Someintervieweesreportedawareness,orthatlearningaboutcertificationwasrelativelyeasy.Anumberoftheircommentsfollow:
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedgeneralcontractingfirmstatedthatshedidresearchabouttheavailablecertificationsbeforeshestartedhercompany.Sheaddedthatshecompletedtheapplicationsassoonasshecouldforlocalandstatecertifications,andcommented,“I’mlookingtofindoutaboutthefederalsmallbusinesscertifications.”[#19]
Regardinghisfirm’scertifications,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmcommented,“IlookedintocertificationassoonasIstartedmybusiness.WhenIwaseligible,I[pursuedcertification].”[#32a]
Whenaskedwhyshedecidedtocertifythefirm,theHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaid,“IheardtheCitywasgoingtodoalotofconstructionandcontractorswouldneedcertifiedcompanies,sothat’swhyIgotcertified.”[#35]
Thefemalerepresentativefromanon‐Hispanicwhitemale‐ownedprofessionalservicesfirmindicatedthatsheisawareofsmallbusinesscertificationwithDenver,butadded,“We’reasmallbusinessfederally,butwehavenoCityandCountyofDenverdesignation.”[#1b]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“ThecompanybecameSBE‐certifiedwhenitwasmadeavailableintheCityofDenver.Thatwasabout11yearsago.Ourcompanyknewtheimportanceandthepossiblebenefitsofcertification.WorkingonDenver…projectscouldbringinalotofbusiness.Wearemajority‐owned,sowewerenoteligibleforanyoftheothercertifications.”[#28]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitemaleownerofaprofessionalservicesfirmstatedthathisfirmpreviouslyheldanSBEcertificationbut,althoughtheystillqualify,hehasnotupdatedthecertificationanditisnolongercurrent.[#3]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringfirmnotedthatherfirmalsoholdsEBE,ESB,EDWOSB,andWOSBcertifications.[#5]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmnotedthatherfirmrecentlybecameanEmergingSmallBusiness(ESB)throughCDOT.[#2]
![Page 619: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/619.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 192
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmstatedthatshehasbeencertifiedasaDBEformanyyears.Sheexplained,“Mydaughterhadthatcertificationwhenshehadherbusiness.MuchoftheworksheperformedwasforCDOT.MyhusbandandIfeltitwouldbeinthebestinteresttocontinuewiththatcertification.ThecompanydoesalotofworkforCDOT,andit’sarequirementforthatwork.”[#27]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthathisfirmisnotcurrentlycertified,thoughtheyarepursuingSBA8(a)certification.Headdedthattheyareawareofothercertificationoptionsandwillpursuemoreinthenearfuture.[#7]
Whenaskedifthefirmholdsanystateorlocalagencycertification,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaconstruction‐relatedfirmreportedthattheydonotcurrentlyholdanycertifications.However,henotedthattheyusedtobeSBE‐certifiedandchosenottorenewastheydidnotseeanybenefit.[#25]
Whenaskedifthefirmholdsanystateorlocalagencycertification,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofanengineeringcompanyreportedthathedoesnot.Headded,“Idon’tbelieveinthoseprograms.Ibelievesomeonethathastheskillsshouldstandontheirskills[and]not[depend]onsomegovernmentprogramthatgivesthemwork.”[#26]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaconstructionservicesfirmstatedthatheisnotinterestedincertifications.Heexplained,“Ihaveheardaboutthosecertificationsandhavelookedintoapplying,[but]Idon’tthinkitwouldbethebestmoveformycompany.Weareverysmallandthatallowsmetobemoreincontrol.Idon’tthinkIwouldbesuccessfulbecause…ourcapacitytoperformistoolimitedforthosejobs.”[#31]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofanSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaidthatshetriedtoobtainWBEcertificationbutwasdeniedbecausesheisnotalicensedarchitect.Shenotedthateventhoughsheisnotalicensedarchitect,shehasthebusinessbackgroundtorunthecompany.[#15a]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedgoodsandservicesfirmstatedthatthefirmisawareofcertificationandtheMWBEprogram,butsaidtheprocessofcertificationisirrelevanttothembecausetheyarenoteligibleanditdoesnotimpacthowtheydobusinesswithsubcontractors.[#23b]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitemaleownerofagoodsandservicesfirmindicatedthatheisinterestedinSBEcertificationbuthasnotpursueditduetotimeconstraints.[#10]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleownerofanarchitecturalengineeringfirmreportedthathehasneverpursuedcertificationbecausehestayedbusywithoutit.[#16]
Most trade association and business assistance organization representatives indicated that
members are aware of and often participate in certification programs.Forexample:
![Page 620: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/620.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 193
TheHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthathebelieves90percentoftheorganization’sminorityandwoman‐ownedbusinessesarecertifiedwiththestateoralocalagencyasaDBE.[#11]
TheBlackAmericanfemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationreportedthatmostoftheirmembersareDBE‐certified.Sheadded,“Theyareusuallyontheirwaytogettingcertified[ifthey’renotalready],butforthemostpartourmembershaveDBE‐[or]MWBE‐certifiedbusinessesalready.”[#6]
TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationstatedthatcertifiedmembersareprobablycertifiedwithallagencies,alongwiththeMinoritySupplierDevelopmentCouncil.Regardingwhymemberscertify,hesaid,“Somebusinessesseetheopportunitytoprovidetheirservicesto[RegionalTransportationDistrict],theairport,or[largecorporations],butcertificationisn’taguaranteethatyou’llgetanything.Culturally,Asiansaremorereticenttopromotethemselves,[and]somemembersbelievethatcertificationistargetedtowardsacertaintypeofminority,so[forthem],thevalueisjustnotthere.”[#33]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationindicatedthatmostmemberspursuingcertificationdosoiftheyanticipateworkingforCDOT.ShesaidthatmembersnotseekingDBE,MBE,orWBEcertificationdosobecause“they’renotinterestedindoingworkforCDOT,andvice‐versa.”[#38]
Regardingnetworthlimitstostaycertifiedwithsomepublicentities,thesametradeassociationrepresentativesaid,“If[smallbusinesses]findit’stoodifficulttodobusiness,theyhavetoweigh[whether]itisworthputtingineffort[tocertify]because[theagencyis]goingtorestricthowmuchmoneytheycanmake.”Sheadded,“Iknow…someofthepublicentitiesputacaponhowmuchraisesyoucangetwithinyourcompany.”[#38]
WhenaskedifmembersarecertifiedwithastateoralocalagencyasaDBE,theNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaid,“WedohavequiteafewDBEs.Whentheyjoin[us],weimmediatelyputthemintouchwiththeAmericanIndianProcurementTechnicalAssistanceCenter,whichonlyworkswithAmericanIndians.Wesetupanintroduction,[then]theywillstartthecertificationprocess.”[#37]
Thesamebusinessassistanceorganizationrepresentativecontinued,“Wedothattoensuretheyareatthetableforopportunities.Whentheygetcertified…whetherDBE,MWBE,SBE…theystartinteractingwiththeagenciesandlearnaboutthesupporttheyoffer.Thegoalistoletthemknowthey’renotouttherealone,andifthey’recertifiedwecanalsotrackhowmanyhavebeensuccessfulingettingopportunities.”[#37]
One trade association representative discussed his organization’s efforts to recruit more
minority‐ and women‐owned firms.Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthatonly19oftheir565membershavecertification.Hesaidthathisorganizationstartedadiversitycommitteeinearly2018inanefforttorecruitmoreminority‐andwomen‐ownedfirms.[#40]
![Page 621: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/621.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 194
Thesametradeassociationrepresentativelatercommented,“Thereareminorityorwomenownedfirmsthatarenotcertifiedandthey’rejustknockingitoutoftheparkanddoinggoodwork[withoutit].Honestly,workingforapublicagencyisnotforeverybody.”[#40]
A few interviewees reported having no knowledge or not enough knowledge of certification
programs.[e.g.,#23b,#31]Forexample:
TheBlackAmericanveteranmaleownerofageneralcontractingcompanyreportedthatheisnotawareofanycertificationsavailabletohisfirm.Headded,“Ihaven’tlookedintoit,[but]Ihearditwasapainand[that]youdon’tgetanyworkanyway.IhavedecidedthisisthebestwayIcouldkeepmybusinessgoing.Idon’tbelievethereareadvantagestothatprogram.”[#29]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemaleco‐ownerofaspecialtyservicesfirmreportedthatthefirmholdsnocertificationsatthistime,thoughtheyareinterestedinlearningmoreaboutcertificationopportunities.[#8]
Regardingcertificationopportunities,apublicmeetingparticipantsaid,“Istillbelievethatthereisabiggapincontactingthesmallbusiness[es]thatjustmovedhere.[They]don’tunderstandwheretogoforcertification.[Theymayknow]thisothercompanyandthey’vestarteddoingsomeworkwiththem…butthey’rehavingahardtime[growing].”[PT#4]
Whenaskedifheisawareofcertificationopportunities,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaspecialtyservicesfirmsaid,“Thefirmhasnocertifications,[but]Ihavelookedintothatpossibility….Myresearchindicatedthatthosecertificationswereforconstructioncompanies[and]wedon’tdoconstruction.Weprovideaproduct.”[#30]
Thesamebusinessownerlatersaid,“Ihaveheardaboutthecertificationprogramsavailabletosmallandminoritycompanies,[but]I’veneverconsideredthatcertificationformycompany.Ihavenotheardofanyassistanceprograms,likeamentor‐protégéprogram,thatwouldbeavailableformytypeofbusinessbecauseIamnotcertified.Therefore,Idon’tbelievemy…companywouldbeeligibleforbusinessassistance.”[#30]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofaspecialtyservicesfirmreportedthatthefirmhasnoexperiencewithanycertificationprograms.However,henotedthatthefirmisinterestedinpursuingcertificationiftheyareeligible.[#34]
Ease or difficulty of becoming certified.Anumberofintervieweescommentedonhoweasyordifficultitwastobecomecertified.
Many interviewees reported difficulties with the DBE, MBE/WBE, and SBE certification and/or
renewal process.Somebusinessownersandrepresentativesindicatedthatthecertificationprocesswasdifficult,timeconsumingorproblematic.[e.g.,#35]Forexample:
TheSubcontinentAsianAmericanmaleownerofaspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthathisfirmhasnosmallbusinesscertifications.Hecommentedthatthecertificationprocess
![Page 622: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/622.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 195
seemstorequiretoomucheffort,andnotedthathedoesnotpersonallyknowofanyfirmthathasprofitedfromcertification.[#18]
Whenaskedifhisfirmiscertifiedwithastateorlocalagency,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaconstructionfirmsaid,“Ilookedintogettingcertifiedbecauseafewothercontractorshadmentionedit.Ilookedintoitandtheamountofpaperworkthathadtobecompletedwastoomuch,soIneverhaveattemptedthecertification.”[#24]
Whenaskedifcertificationwaseasyordifficulttoachieve,thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringfirmsaid,“Itwasn’tdifficultbecausethereweren’tanyhardquestions.It’snotlikeIhadatesttostudyfor.Itwasjustalotofpersonalinformation,andnowthatCDOT’sbeenhackedand…theCityandCountyofDenverwashackedlastyear,[I’mconcerned].”[#5]
Thesameintervieweewentontosaythatshe’s“veryconcerned”abouttheamountofinformationthatisonfileforherfirmduetothecertificationprocess.Shestated,“Nownotonlyismypersonalinformationoutthere,[like]mySocialSecuritynumber[and]allofmyincome…[but]myhusband’sinformation…andmychildren’sSocial[Securitynumbers]areoutthere[too],andI’mveryconcernedaboutthat.Ireallyfeellike[publicagencies]putusinanexceptionallyvulnerableposition.It’sveryconcerning.Idon’tknowwhogetsthatinformation[or]howtightlycontrolledthatinformationis,andnowIknowit’sbeenhackedatleasttwice.Ifeellikemylivelihoodcouldbesweptoffthemapinaheartbeat.It’svery,veryconcerningtome.”[#5]
Regardingthecertificationprocess,apublicmeetingparticipantsaid,“Ihadtogoback[and]borrowmoneytopayforit.Andinthemeantime,myapplicationexpired.[But]withinadayIresubmittedeverything,becauseIwasprepared….So,Iamveryresilient.”[PT#4]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaconstruction‐relatedfirmsaid,“[We]hadtheSBEcertificationwiththecityforoneyearanditwasapaininthebutt….Itwasaverylongprocesstogetcertified,[andtherewere]questionsIdidn’tthinkwerenecessary.Anexamplewouldbetheproofofmoniesusedtostartyourbusiness.Whyisthatimportant?Inevergotanyworkwiththecertification.”[#25]
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“ItwashardtofindoutabouttheSBEprojects….Ithought[there]wouldbeadatabaseofprojectsforthatcertification,butthereisnot.Afteroneyear…IreceivednotificationthatIneededtorenew,[and]Idecideditwasn’tworththeeffort.Iwasdisappointedthattherewerenobenefitstothecertificationbecauseitwassuchalongprocess.Infact,noneofmycolleaguesthatclaimtobecertifiedhavegottenbenefitfromtheprogram.”[#25]
Some trade association and business assistance organization representatives described the
certification process as a barrier.[e.g.,#11]Commentsinclude:
Whenaskedifthereareanydisadvantagestocertification,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationstated,“Notsomuch[with]the
![Page 623: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/623.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 196
certificationitself,[but]perhapsthedisadvantageisintheprocess.Navigatingthedocuments,website,[and]bureaucracyisespeciallyhardforstart‐ups.”Henotedthattheprocessisespeciallydifficultforimmigrantsduetolanguagechallenges,andthereforetheyavoidit.[#33]
Whenaskedabouttheeaseordifficultyofthecertificationprocess,theBlackAmericanfemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthatthereisalotofpaperwork,whichcanbeverylabor‐intensiveforapplicantsnotusedtosuchdocumentation.Sheadded,“Inallfairness,theinformationtheyaskforincludesbasicbusinessdocumentsthatoneshouldalreadyhaveinplace.Andifthebusinessownerdoesnothavethatinplace,itwouldbehelpfultogetitorganizedanyway.Theprocesspreparesyouforwhatyou’regoingtoencounter,whatotherprimesaregoingtoaskfor,whattheDOTsaregoingtoaskfor,andcontractualrequirements.”[#6]
TheBlackAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaidshehadtohireanemployeeresponsibleforcompletingcertificationapplicationsandmaintainingcertificationstatus.Shecommented,“Sheliterallydoesthemall,andshedoesagreatjob.”[#13]
Ofthecertificationprocess,thesamebusinessownerwentontosay,“Youcannotfeeloffended,orbeannoyed[bythepersonalinformationrequired]….[It’sthe]priceyouhavetopaytogetafootinthedoor.”Sheaffirmedthatthecertificationshavehelpedherbusiness“immensely,”andthatmorerecognitionisachievedwiththem.Shestatedthathergoalistohavemoreprivateopportunities,andfindsthefirmisgettingclosertothatgoalasaresultoftheircertifications.[#13]
TheAsian‐PacificAmericanfemalerepresentativeofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmstated,“Icompletedtheapplicationforcertification.Itwaslengthyandittooksometimetogatheralloftheinformationneededtosubmit,butIguessitwasworthwhile….Thoughwehaven’tgottenanyworkdirectlywiththecity,becauseofthecertification,[yet].”[#32b]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleownerofaspecialtycontractingfirmexpressedhisdesiretobecomecertifiedasanMBE.Hestated,“Ihavenotcompletedallthepaperwork,butitwouldbereallynicetobeabletofindsomebodythatcanhelpmeandguidemethroughthatprocess.Unfortunately,IleanedonthepartnerItookon,[…]myaccountant,tohelpoutwiththeMBEstuff,buthispoliticalstancekepthimfrompursuingthat.So,Imadethedeterminationlastyeartoterminateourrelationship….Thisyear,I'monmyownagain…."[#4]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmsaid,“Ilookedintothecitycertificationsrecently,butdecidedagainstitbecausetheapplicationwassolengthy.Wegetplentyofworkwiththeonewehave.”[#27]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“IcanonlyspeaktotheSBEcertification,[but]itwasn’tahardprocess,justlengthy.Whenit’stimetorenew,thestaffthatworksonthatrenewal,
![Page 624: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/624.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 197
theaccountingdepartment,dreadsitbecauseofthepaperworkinvolved….However,itisworthitinthelong‐term.”[#28]
Whenaskedifthecertificationprocessisdifficult,theHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaid,“Thefirsttimeitisdifficultbecauseofthepaperwork.Renewingiseasy,Icandothaton‐linebyjustscanningthings.”[#35]
One business assistance organization representative commented that the “rigor” of the
certification process makes it “more legitimate.”WhenaskedheropiniononDBEcertifications,theNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaid,“It’shardtoacquire,butwetellpeopletheyneedtorespectthefactthatitisarigorousprocess,becauseitmakestheprogrammorelegitimate.Ifit’stooeasy,anyonewouldjumpinthere.So,thefactthatitiscumbersomeshouldbelookedatinapositiveway.Itmakessuretherightpeopleareinplaceforopportunities.”[#37]
A few interviewees said that the certification process was easy, or they reported that they
received assistance with the process. [e.g.,#15a]Forexample:
Whenaskedabouttheeaseordifficultyofthecertificationprocess,theHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedgeneralcontractingfirmstatedthatthecertificationprocessis“good,”andnoteasyorhard.Sheadded,“Ihaven’tbeenabletoidentifyadisadvantageofcertification.Theanalystthatwasassignedtomyapplicationwasincredible,verycalming.Heaskedrelevantquestions[and]explainedeverything,andthewhybehindeverything,whichIappreciate[d].”[#19]
Whenaskedifthecertificationprocessiseasyordifficult,theBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andESB‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmsaid,“Ithinkit’srelativelyeasy.However,…becauseoftheproductareathatwe’rein,it’snotaseasilydefined.”Hewentontosaythattheindustryinwhichheworksisveryspecificandcanbedifficulttocategorize.[#9]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmsaiditwashelpfultoaskquestionsoftheDBEcertifier,andnowsheencouragesotherfriendsthatareminoritybusinessownerstoaskquestions"rightoffthebat."Sheadded,“There’sjustsomuchoutthere,andIdon’tthinkIevertookadvantageofthatportionof[certificationbenefits]that’savailableatnocost,orminimalcost.[Certification]isanexcellenttoolforustohave.”[#2]
Thesamebusinessco‐ownerwentontosaythecertificationprocesswaseasyforherfirmbecausewhensheapplieditwasalessinvolvedprocess.However,shenotedthatafirmofhercurrentsizeapplyingforcertificationtodaywouldundergomuchmorescrutiny.[#2]
Whenaskedifacquiringandmaintainingcertificationiseasyordifficult,theHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmsaidthathecannotthinkofanymajorissueswiththecertificationprocessorwithcertificationrenewals.Hewentontocomment,“It’snotabigdeal.”[#14]
![Page 625: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/625.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 198
Whenaskedifthecertificationprocessiseasyordifficult,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmstated,“Idon’tthinkit’soverlycumbersome.Ijusthavetorenew.”Whenaskedifhehasanysuggestionstoimprovetheprocess,hestated,“No,Idon’tthinkso.Thestaffisalwaysveryhelpful.”[#22]
Advantages and disadvantages of certification.InterviewsincludedbroaddiscussionofwhetherandhowDBE,MBE/WBE,andSBEcertificationorothercertificationprogramshelpedsubcontractorsobtainworkfromprimecontractors.
Many of the owners and representatives of certified firms indicated that certification is
advantageous.Forexample:
Whenaskediftherearebenefitstobeingcertified,theNativeAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,SDB‐,SDVOSB‐,andHUBZone‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmstatedthatthereare.Hesaid,“Itallowsyoutoworkthroughthemazeofacorporation…municipality,orgovernmentandlocatethecontacts.Sometimesyouaregivenopportunitiestocompete[otherwise].”Headdedthatheknowsofnodisadvantagestocertification.[#39]
Whenaskedabouthercertifications,theBlackAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaid,“Certifications[are]goodinthesensethatitgetsmyfootinthedoorversusthebigguys,itsortsofgetsyouasemi‐levelplayingfield.”Shewentontosay,“Yourtalentkindofgetsyouwhereyouneedtobe.”[#13]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmstatedthathebecamecertifiedbecauseitprovideshisfirmwithmoreworkopportunities.Whenaskedaboutotherbenefitstocertification,hesaid“Theadvantageistheyhaveaccesstoprojectsthatyouprobablywouldhaveatoughtimegetting[otherwise],especiallywhenitcomestoinfrastructure,taxpayer‐supportedprojects.”[#14]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedgeneralcontractingfirmstatedthatshe“believesthecertificationmakesadifferenceforthejobs[they]goafter,likeCDOTandothergovernmentopportunities.”[#19]
TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmstated,“We’recertifiedbecausethereismoreopportunity.We’realsoabletoteamwithlargerfirmsforlargeprojects.”[#22]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmstatedthatsheattainedthefirm’scertificationsearlyonbecausetheyarekeytosecuringpublicwork.[#20]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andESB‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmsaidthathebelievesthebenefitsofcertificationincludeopeningupnewdoorsforbusinesses,especiallywithotherorganizationsthatdoworkwiththecity.Heexplained,“Forthepeoplethatdohavecitycontractsand[who]wereonceinthesameposition[asmyfirm],youwouldhopethattheymightbealittlemoreopenaboutinviting
![Page 626: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/626.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 199
youintoseeifyoucanpartnerorteamtogetheronacityproject…andsupport[eachother].”[#9]
Whenaskedaboutthecertificationprocess,theAsian‐PacificAmericanfemalerepresentativeofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmstated,“Ibelieveitaddscredibilitytoyourcompanywhenyouhavethosecertifications.”[#32b]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmreportedthatshehasnotexperiencedanydisadvantagesofcertification.Shesaid,“Certificationshavegiven[myfirm]morevisibilitywithlargerbusinessesandhashelpedtoprovidetrainingresourcesatminimalcosts.”Sheaddedthatthecertificationshavealsogiventhefirmanadvantageinthemarket,specificallybyallowingtheirproposalstostandout.Shewentontosay,"[Certification]givesyouthecapabilityofgetting[arole]withinalargemultimillion‐dollarproject."[#2]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringfirmsaid,“FornineyearsIneversawacontractthathadaWBE[requirement],withoneexception,andthatwastheColoradoSpringsAirport.Wedida[projectthere].Iwouldsayuptothispoint,for99percentofmybusiness…certifications[havebeen]useless.However,thathaschanged.”[#5]
Thesamebusinessownerwentontosaythatherfirm’scertificationshavebecomeveryhelpfulinrecentyearsbecausepublicsectorcontractsrequireMWBEparticipation.Shenotedthatthiscauseshercompanytobesoughtafterasasubcontractor,andsaid,“ThislastyearIhavewonfourproposals.IwasonwinningteamsoffourproposalsbecauseIwasaWBE.Two[were]with[Denver]andtwo[were]withCDOT.”[#5]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleownerofaspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthatprimecontractorssometimesexpressinterestinhiringhisfirmasasubcontractor,thoughtheyloseinterestafterrealizingheisnotMBEcertified.[#4]
Many trade association and business assistance organization representatives discussed the
advantages of DBE/MBE/WBE/SBE certification.Commentsinclude:
Whenaskediftherearebenefitstocertification,theHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationstated,“Becausewedonothavealevelplayingfieldintoday'senvironment,certificationgrantsourfolksanopportunitytogetapieceofthepieofpublicdollarsonpublicprojects.”[#11]
Thesametradeassociationrepresentativelatersaid,“Ihaveheardsomecompaniesdonotlikethelabelingthatcomeswithit,butIdonotseeanydisadvantages….ThewayIlookatitisifyouareseekingprivatework,yourworkspeaksforitselfwhetheryouarecertifiedornot.Andifyouareseekingpublicwork,certificationallowsyoutheopportunitytomakesurethatmorefolksaregettingapartinsomeofthatwork.”[#11]
Whenaskedifthereareanybenefitstocertification,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaid,“Thefirmsthatarecertifiedcertainlysaythatit
![Page 627: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/627.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 200
hashelpedthem.Ifyouarecertifiedandyouhavegoodexperienceinconstruction,yourphoneisringing.Theyaresayingitisapositiveexperiencebecausetheygetseriousconsiderationfromgeneralcontractors….The[certified]specialtycontractorsdeliveringwork[are]gettingalotofseriousconsideration….”[#40]
Thesametradeassociationrepresentativecontinued,“[Certification]isagoodwaytomakesurethattheygetattractiveprojectsthatareoutthere,[but]theystillneedtoknowhowtodothebusiness.Theystillneedtobeableto[manage]cashflow[and]thepayroll.Theystillneedtobeabletodoallthosethings,butitcertainlyhasbeenafootinthedoortogetthemgoing.Now,ifthey’renotgoodatconstruction,thenitwon’tlastverylong.”[#40]
TheBlackAmericanfemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthatcertificationisadvantageousbecauseitallowsbusinessestoparticipateinspacestheyotherwisewouldnothavebeenabletoparticipatein.Sheaddedthatsomeoftheresourcesincludeavailabilityfromtransportation‐relatedagenciesaswellasotherlocaltradeassociations,whichallprovideconnectivityresourcesandpartnershipsformemberstoget“pluggedin.”[#6]
Whenaskedifthereareanybenefitstocertification,thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaid,“Ithinkitdoeshavethepotentialtogetpeopletoseethesefirms[and]recognizethey’rethere….There’sapoolofpeoplethatthoseprimescangotoandsay,‘Thecityor[otheragencyhas]lookedatthem,[so]thereforetheymaybeaviablecompany.’”[#38]
TheNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaidthatcertificationallowsfirmsto“[interface]withtheagenciesand[take]advantageoftheirresources.”Sheadded,“Also,[there’s]theadvantageoftheDBEgoalswhenpursuingaproject.”[#37]
Some expressed mixed feelings, indicated that there are limited advantages, or even
disadvantages, to certification.Othersreportedonstereotypingofcertifiedbusinessesorthe“stigma”associatedwithcertification.Forexample:
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andESB‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmsaid,“IperhapshaveadifferentpointofviewthanmostinthatIbelievethattheremaybeastigmaattachedtoabusinessthat’scertified….Ithinkperhapsthere’safeelingouttherethatyou’rebeinggivensomething.But,myexperiencebothonthefederalsideandonthissideisthatyou[give]probablymore[effort]asacertifiedbusinessbecausethebusinessdoesn’tcometoyou.You[may]havetheknowledgeandexpertise,butyou’llalsohavetobeabletomarketandhavetherightproductandbeintherightplaceforthingstohappenforyou.”[#9]
TheBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“IhavehadsituationswhereIhavebeenaskedtolowermyfeetogetaproject,onlytofindoutotherswereabletoincreasetheirfeesorproposal.Thejustificationisthatyouare
![Page 628: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/628.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 201
asmallDBE/MWBEfirmandthatyoumaynothavethesamequalityasa‘regular’firm,wheninfactyourproductissuperiortothe‘regular’firm.”[WT#12]
TheBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionsupplyfirmsaidthathehopedcertificationwouldcreatebusinessopportunitiesforhisfirm,thoughithasn’tbeenashelpfulashehoped;hehasonlyreceivedonepublicsectorcontract.Hecommentedthatpublicagenciesareunwillingtocreateopportunitiessmallenoughforcertifiedfirmstocompetitivelybid.[#36]
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“Ireallyhavemixedfeelingsabout[certification].Yougothroughallthehoopstogetcertified,andthennotmuchhappens.AsaBlackmale,whydoIhavetogothroughthebackdoorwhileeveryoneelsegoesthroughthefrontdoortogetbusiness?Theydon’tgiveyouanyrealassistance,justtechnicalassistancelikewedon’tknowwhatwe’redoing.Yougothroughallofthat,andyoustillhavetocompetedollarfordollar.Weneedtheseprogramsbecausetheeconomyneedsdiversity.”[#36]
Headded,“Youcan’tjustleavepeoplebehind.Thereshouldbeawaytohelpusgettotherightlevel,butitdoesn’tseemtobethere.TheonlytimecertificationworkedformewaswhenIhadthecontractwith[RegionalTransportationDistrict].Andthen[when]you’resuccessful[you]gooverthesizestandard.It’sacrazyprocessthattheysendusthrough.”Insum,hesaid,“Thedisadvantageisthatyouhavetogothroughthewholeprocessanddiscloseeverythinginordertogetintotheprogram,anditmayormaynothelpyou.”[#36]
Whenaskedaboutthebenefitsofcertification,theHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaid,“It’sbeenabout10percenteffective.I’veonlyhadoneprojectthatusedmycertification.”[#35]
Asurveyrespondentindicatedthattheircertificationhasyettobenefitthefirm,saying,“Ihavebeenin[the]MWBE[program]andhavevirtuallynocontracts.”[AS#15]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthatcertificationhasneverledtonewworkforthefirm.Sheexplained,“Ithinkit’sjustawasteoftimeandmoney…fillingoutallthoseforms,preparingallthosefinancialstatements.We’vegottenputonprojectteamsacoupletimesbecausetheywantfillthatslot,butwe’venevergottenanyworkoutofit.”[#12]
Whenaskedifthereareanydisadvantagestocertification,theHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmsaidthatonedisadvantageisthatyouhavetoconstantlyrenewcertifications.Healsosaid,“[Certification]kindofdevaluesthecompany,becauseifyouwanttosellittosaysomebodyinternallywho’scomingupthroughtheranks,ifthey’renotminoritythentheylosethosecontracts….Andthat’sabignegative.”[#14]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleco‐ownerofanSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmindicatedthatthefirm’sSBEcertificationisnotashelpfulastheyhadhoped.HesaidthatDenverPublicSchoolsis“verybig”onSBEutilization,thoughtheymostoftenuse
![Page 629: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/629.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 202
engineeringfirms.HewentontosaythattheyhavenotbeensuccessfulatobtainingworkwithDenverPublicSchools.[#15b]
Regardingdisadvantagestocertification,thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringfirmsaid,“Thereareonlydisadvantageswhenaprimemakesasweepingjudgmentthatafirmonlyholdsacertificationbecausetheycan’tgetwork[otherwise].”[#5]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmreportedthatshereceivedhercertificationslastyear.However,shesaid,“IhavenotbeenawardedanyworkfromtheCityandCountyofDenvertothispoint.Ihavespentalotoftimeandmoneytryingtolearnthesystemofdoingbusinesswithgovernmentagencies,[but]thusfarhavenotsucceeded.”[WT#5]
Whenaskedifthereareanydisadvantagestocertification,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthatthereare.Heexplained,“Inthearchitecture[and]engineeringworld,thereisstilldiscriminationagainstminorityfirms.Therewerecertainagenciesthatwereveryfriendlyin[SBA]8(a)andDBEprograms,buttherewereotheragenciesthatfeltlikeitwasamandatethattheyhadtodo,andtheyfeltminority[architectureandengineering]firmswerelesscapableofdoingthework.TheissueIhavewith[the]Denvercertificationprocessisthatit’sdesignedasasmallbusinessprogram,[and]thecurrentordinancesizelimitishalfoftheSBAsizestandard.”[#22]
Some trade association and business assistance organization representatives discussed
whether there are disadvantages to certification.Mostindicatedthatthereare.[e.g.,#40]Forexample:
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthatonedisadvantageofcertificationisthatcertifiedfirmsoftenfeelthattheydonothavetomarketanymore.SheaddedthatifaDBEdoesnotknowthetimelineonalargeproject,theyshouldatleastknowthatitiscomingandwhotheprimaryprimeswillbe,andcommented,“Ithink[DBEs]waittoolateforsomeofthose[conversationswithprimes]tohappen.”[#38]
Whenaskedifthereareanydisadvantagestocertification,theBlackAmericanfemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaid,“Personally,formyownbusinessIgrappledwithbecomingaDBEbecauseIdidnotwanttolabelmyselfasdisadvantagedinanyway,shape,orform.Butinlearningmore,Icametounderstandmoreoftheadvantages,andthat’swhathelpedtoswaymydecision.”[#6]
Thesametradeassociationrepresentativeadded,“Therecanbedisadvantagesifyou’reenteringintocertificationwiththeideathatyou’regoingtobecoddled.Atsomepoint,you’vegottotakethetrainingwheelsoff.Itcanbetoughwhenyou’renotintheDBEspacebecausetheprivatesectordoesnotallowforasmuchparticipation,orasmuchmeaningfulparticipation[as]inthe[public]world….Theyoughttobelookingatbuildingtheirnetworkoutsideofthepublicspacesothatwhentheydogettothepointofgraduation,it’s
![Page 630: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/630.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 203
amoreseamlesstransition….[If]theydon’thavethatintheirstrategicplanorintheirtransitionalplan,itmakesforatoughtransition.”[#6]
One trade association representative indicated that certification can stunt a firm’s growth.Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthathebelievestheprocessofgettingcertifiedcan“slowpeopledown.”Heexplained,“It’sagovernmentprocess,sosomepeoplesay,‘IfI’mgettingenoughworkoverhereintheprivatesector,whywouldIwanttogotocityhallandgetonthewebsiteandfigureouthowto…gothroughtheapplicationprocess?’[#40]
Thesametradeassociationrepresentativecontinued,“Then…therearesizelimits.Ifyouwanttobeacertainsizetobecertified,youhavetostayunderacertainamountofassetsorrevenuelevel.So,ifmygoalistogethere,whywouldIgodosomethingthatsaysIhavetostay[belowlimits]?”[#40]
Experience regarding the certification process and any recommendations for improvement. Intervieweesmaderecommendationsforanumberofimprovementstothecertificationprocess.Afewindicatedthattheprocessisfineasitis.Forexample:
Whenaskedhowthecertificationprocesscanbeimproved,theHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmsaidthatthecertificationprocesshasalreadyimprovedduetotheonlinefacilitationofforms.[#2]
Whenaskedaboutthecertificationprocess,theNativeAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,SDB‐,SDVOSB‐,andHUBZone‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmreportedthattherequesteddocumentationisnecessary,andthathehasnoproblemswiththeinformationrequiredoramountoftimeittakestocompletetheapplication.Hecommented,“Ifyouwanttogetcertified,youworkthroughtheprocess.”[#39]
Whenaskedifhehasanyrecommendationsonhowtoimprovethecertificationprocess,thesamebusinessownersaid,“Itwouldbeniceifthereweremorepeopleinvolvedintheinfrastructuretoassistwithprocessingcertificationapplications.Whetheritisamunicipalityorstate,orcorporation,sometimestheydon’thaveanadequatenumberofemployeestoanswerquestionsandworkthroughtheapplications.”[#39]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmindicatedthatthecertificationprocessshouldbestreamlined.Shesaidthattheprocesstakestoolong,andnotedthatshemissedoutonopportunitiesduetocertificationdelays.[#35]
Whenaskedifthecertificationprocessiseasyordifficult,thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmdescribedtheprocessastime‐consuming,butnoteditwouldfeel“worthit”ifitproducedwork.[#12]
Regardingwaystoimprovethecertificationprocess,theHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedgeneralcontractingfirmstated,“Iamintherenewalperiod.Everyonehasbeenamazingtosendmeextensionlettersautomatically,but
![Page 631: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/631.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 204
wehavebeenextendedforawhile.So,it’sbeenalongprocessandnothinghaschanged.Iamthesamestructure,exactsamefinancials,so…Ithoughtitwouldbealittlefaster.[#19]
TheBlackAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaidsheappreciatestheonlineaspectofthecertificationprocessandtheabilitytouploaddocuments.Shesaid,“Ithinkit’sgreatthatit’smostlyonlinenow,andwecanuploadstuff.Thatissomuchbetterthanbeforewhenitwasjustallpaper.Thatwasawful.So,themoreyoucandoelectronically,thebetteroffweare.”[#13]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedgeneralcontractingfirmsaid,“[My]recommendationwouldbetoprovideassistancetomakesuresmallbusinessesunderstandhowtheprocessworks.Theassistancedependsonthelevelofunderstandingthatsmallbusinesshasaboutdoingworkwithpublicentities.”[#19]
Whenaskedifhehasanyrecommendationsonhowtoimprovethecertificationprocess,theBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andESB‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmsaid,“Ithinktheprocessisprettystraightforward.Ithinkintermsofbecomingcertified,theprocessisprobablythewayitneedstobe.Ican’tthinkofanythingthatwouldbedonedifferently.”[#9]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofanSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaidthatCityandCountyofDenvershouldaddarchitecturalprojectstotheSBEselectionpool.ShealsosaidthatthecityshouldrecognizehercompanyasaWBEbecauseshehasmajorityownership,runsthefinancialrisk,andhasthemanagementbackgroundtorunthebusiness.Sheexplainedthatallshelacksisanarchitecturallicense.[#15a]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleco‐ownerofanSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaidthatCityandCountyofDenvershouldmodifytheSBEdesignationtobemoreexclusivetosmallbusinesses.Hesaid,“Thewayitstandsrightnow,Ithinkifyoubill$4millionorlessyou'reanSBE,andthat’sprettymuch80percentofthearchitectsinDenver.”[#15b]
TheAsian‐PacificAmericanfemalerepresentativeofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmsaid,“Iamtheoneatthecompanythatcompletesthecertificationrenewals.Ibelievetherehastobesomewaytoshortenthatapplication.Theinformationwesubmitisreallythesamethatwesubmittedtheyearbefore,andtheyearbeforethat.Forsmallcompanies,itisverytime‐consuming.”[#32b]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitemaleownerofagoodsandservicesfirmsuggestedthattheSBEprogrambebetterpromotedtocreatemoreawarenessofitandhowtocertify.[#10]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofaspecialtyservicesfirmreportedthatCityandCountyofDenvershoulddoabetterjobofgettingthewordoutaboutcertificationopportunities.[#34]
WhenaskedabouthisexperiencewiththeDBE,MWBE,andSBEprograms,andifhehasanycommentsorrecommendationstoimprovethem,theBlackAmericanmaleownerofa
![Page 632: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/632.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 205
DBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionsupplyfirmsaid,“It’salotofeffort,butyougetnodirectbenefit.I’vecertifiedwith[CityandCountyofDenver]sinceIfirststartedthebusiness[almost20yearsago].Everyyearyouhavetosubmityourfinancialandaffidavits,butIdon’tgetanything.”[#36]
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“IwantedtogetintotheACDBEprogramattheairportbecauseofmyretailexperience.Atonetimethatprogramwasprettysuccessful,butrightnowallthebigconcessionairesarecontrollingtheairport.Sonow,I’mjustmanagingwhatIhave.”[#36]
Many trade association and business assistance organization representatives indicated that
there is room for improvement in the certification process.Afewsuggestedmeansofimprovement.Commentsinclude:
RegardingwaystoimprovetheDBEcertificationprocess,theHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthatCityandCountyofDenvershouldofferworkshopstoassistsmallbusinessesthroughoutthecertificationprocess.Hecommented,“Whydoesasmallbusinesshavetopayaconsultanttohelpthemlearnhowtogetcertifiedwhenalotofitcanbedonethroughthecityprovidingworkshopstohelpfirmsdothat?”[#11]
Thesametradeassociationrepresentativelatersaid,“Havingtutorialworkshopswouldbeextremelybeneficialtoourbusinesses.Onceyouareonajob,what[is]require[d]?What'sthepaperwork?Howisitfilledout?Informationonprevailingwage[and]allofthosethingscanbesohelpfulandwouldcutalotoftheangstthatgoesonbetweenthebusinessesandtheownersinthosearenas….”[#11]
Whenaskedifshehasanyrecommendationstoimprovethecertificationprocess,theBlackAmericanfemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaiditwouldbehelpfultogivefirmsbetternoticeonwhattoexpectfromtheprocess.Sheexplained,“Allowingsmallbusinessesto[better]knowwhattheirrolesandresponsibilitiesare,whattheirrightsareasaDBE,andgivingthem…educationasfarastheordinance,ortheCFR…wouldbeagreatadditiontotheprocess.”[#6]
Regardingwaystoimprovethecertificationprocess,theNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaid,“Iwouldnotclassifyitaseasyordifficult.[It’s]justcumbersome.[Isuggestto]speeduptheprocess,makeitquickerbecauseittakestoomuchtimeforasmallbusinessownerwhoiswearingmanyhats….[Itcan]take90daystohearbackfromthemtofindoutifyouweresuccessful.”[#37]
Thesamebusinessassistanceorganizationrepresentativecontinued,“Domoreonline,thatwouldcertainlyhelp.Atthe[organization]Iamtheonlystaffperson,andIdon’tworkfull‐time.So,wehadtoautomatemanyofourprocessesandthathasallowedustodomore.I’veheardthat[CityandCountyofDenver]cutbackonstaffinvolvedwithcertification,andthat’swhyittakessolong.Automationcouldreallyhelpwithcertification.Thosewhodogetcertifiedalwayssaythey’regladtheydidit.”[#37]
![Page 633: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/633.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 206
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthatthecertificationprocessshouldrequirelesspaperwork.Shecommented,“Istheinformation[asked]fortrulyimportant?”Shewentontosay,“Sometimesit’san[incredible]amountofinformation,andthenyoukindof…wonder[if]somebodyisreallylookingthrougheverysinglepage[ofthethickpacket].Youknow,that’sprobablynotthecase.So[intheend],they’resubmittingalotmoreinformationthantheyreallymightneed[to].”[#38]
Whenaskedifhehasanyrecommendationstoimprovethecertificationprocess,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationstated,“Iappreciatethattheprocessisinplacebecauseitverifiesthatcompaniesaretrulyminority‐orwoman‐owned.Perhaps[itcanbe]streamline[d].AlotofAsianbusinessesarecash‐base[d]anddon’tkeepbooksliketheyshould.IthinkIwouldarguethatcertificationfolksshouldmakesomeaccommodationregardingthedocumentationtheyrequire.”Hewentontocomment,“DBEcertificationcanbeveryonerousanddoesnotguaranteework.”[#33]
M. Other Insights and Recommendations Regarding City Contracting and Programs
BusinessownersandrepresentativesprovidedothersuggestionsforCityandCountyofDenverandotherpublicagenciestoimprovetheirsmallbusinessorDBE,MBE/WBE,andSBEprograms,oranyotherinsightsorrecommendations.Forexample:
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmsaidthathiscompanyhashadagreatdealofexperiencewithSBE/MBE/WBEprograms.Whenaskedifhehasanysuggestionsonhowtoimprovetheprograms,hesaid,“Iwouldreviewtheprogram,evaluatethecompaniesthathavegraduated,andwhathelpedthemgraduate….Thewholepremiseofthisprogramistogetpeopletobecomebusinessesthatdon'tneedtobeonagoallist,right?”Hecontinued,“Thenevaluatethat,andtrytousethatfortheothercompanies.Usethemasexamples.”[#21a]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringservicesfirmsaidthatitwouldbehelpfulifpublicagenciesensuredthatprimesaresincereintheiroutreachefforts.Heexplained,“Telluswhatyouneed,whatyouwantinthebidorproposal.It’sfrustratingtogotoanevent,betoldthatthey’relookingforfolkstodoacertainscope,thenrunintoacompetitorattheeventwhotellsyoutheyalreadyhaveacontractforthatscope.”[#14]
WhenaskedifhehadanycommentsorrecommendationsregardinghisexperiencewithSBE/MBE/WBEoranyotherstateprogram,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaidhewouldliketoseeDenvergobacktothefullSBAsizestandardsforarchitectsbecausesomuchmoreworkissubcontractedouttoengineers,leavingaverysmallpercentageforarchitects.[#22]
Thesamebusinessownerwentontosay,“[DenverPublicSchools]recentlywentthroughtheMWBEprocess,butIthinkthey’rewhereDenverwasinthe90s.Projectmanagersareresistingittoothandnail.TheylikeworkingwiththeirpreferredfirmsandarenotgoingtolookatanMWBE.Theircultureneedstochange.”[#22]
![Page 634: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/634.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 207
Heconcluded,“[CityandCountyofDenver]needstotalktoothermunicipalitiesaboutthesuccessoftheMWBEprogram,[like]Aurora,Lakewood,Arvada,[because]noneofthemhaveprograms.Theyjustsaydisadvantagedbusinessesareencouragedtoapply,butthat’sit.”[#22]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“Wehavegonesofarbackwards….Andit’snot[because]thesmallbusinessofficeisn’tattemptingtodoajob.It’sthat…theyareattemptingtodoajob,butit’snotcomingtogether.It’snotconnecting….”[PT#3a]
TheBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“WithallofthegrowthandCityofDenverprojectsthatwillbeginconstructionin2018andbeyond,itwillbeimperativeforthisregiontolookforwaystocreatetrueopportunitiesforallofthefirmsinthisregion,regardlessofgenderorrace….Ifthenew[ConstructionEmpowermentInitiativeordinances]becomelaw,itwilldefinitelyhelp.”[WT#12]
Thesamebusinessowneradded,“However,ifmanyofthemajorprimesinthisregioncontinuetheircurrentbusinesspractices,itisgoingtobeverydifficultformanyoftheseprojectstomeettheirsmallbusinessgoals,letaloneexceedthem.IfeeltheMWBEprogramshouldstayinplacebecauseitgivesminority‐andwomen‐ownedfirmsaccesstoopportunitytheyotherwisewouldnothaveaccessto.”[WT#12]
TheBlackAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmrecommendedthatMBE/WBEfirmstrytonotgetaheadofthemselves.Shesaid,“You’renotgonnagetthatmillion‐dollarcontractifallyou’vedoneis$10,000.Butwhatyoucandoisgetten$25,000contracts,anditcouldbeonthesameprojectifthingsaresplitapart.”Shesaidshewouldliketoseethecityunbundlelargecontractstohelpthemachievethatgoal,andmentionedthatlargersubsdonotoftencaretoperformcertainworkthatcouldbeofferedtoanMBEorWBE.[#13]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionfirmsaidminorityanddisadvantagedfirmsshould“notuse[their]statusasadisadvantage,”andadded,“Therearesomanypeoplewhocanhelp.It’sjustamatterofaskingandgettingyourfootouttherewhereyouwanttodowork.IfyouwanttodoworkwiththeCityandCountyofDenver,gotothecitybuildingsandaskquestions….”[#2]
Whenaskedifshehasanycommentsorrecommendationsaboutanyothercurrentorpotentialrace/ethnicity/gender‐basedprograms,theHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaid,“MiCasaResourceCenterishelpingtheSpanish‐speakingcommunity.WhenIwastakingclasses,Inoticedtherearealotmorewomentryingtostartbusinesses,but[CityandCountyofDenver]isnotgivingthemtheopportunitytobid.Documentationisabigissue[too],[because]someofthemdon’thaveSocialSecuritynumbers.Theyworkandpaytaxes,sotheyshouldhaveopportunities.”[#35]
![Page 635: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/635.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 208
Thesamebusinessownerwentontocomment,“IhavearelationshipwithanMWBEcompanythatsellscleaningsupplies.Wewanttolearnhowwecanpartnerandbidonprojectstogetherbecausewedidthaton[apublicsectorproject],anditwasgoodforbothofus.Whocanhelpuswiththat?”[#35]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleownerofaspecialtycontractingfirmimpliedalackofknowledgeabouttheprogramandthecertificationprocess.Healsonotedthathedoesnotknowhowtheminority‐businessrequirementsareenforced.Forpublicsectorprojectswithgoals,hecommented,"Ithinkthepublicsectorisutilizingtheleast[numberofSBE/WBE/MBEfirms]theycangetawaywith….Anditmaynotevenbepoliced."[#4]
Whenaskedifshehasanyotherinsightsorrecommendations,thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringfirmreiteratedthatlargepubliccontractsshouldbeunbundled.Shesaid,“MybiggestcomplaintabouthowtheCityofDenverdoesbusinessisthattheyhaveallthisworkandratherthangothroughandsay,‘Wecanbreakthisupintosmallerpiecesthatmorefirmscanhandle,’they[instead]putthewholeturkeyoutandthentheywantsomebodywhocanswallowaturkeywhole.Smallbusinessescanonlydoagoodjobontheportionoftheprojectthattheycandountiltheygetbigger.Mybiggestcomplaintaboutpublicprojectsistheydon’tbreakthemupintosmallenoughpieces.”[#5]
RegardinghowMWBEfirmsareperceivedvalue‐wise,thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofanSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“[If]theMWBE[owner]isretiring,thevalueoftheirfirmgoesoutthedoorwiththemunless[they]canbereplacedbyanotherminorityorwomenowner.”[PT#2c]
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“Bybeingaprime,youincreaseyourvalueof…expertise.So…theamountthatyou'regoingtoloseifyouselltosomeonewho’snotanMWBEisnotasgreatifyoucandemonstrateyou'reaprime.”Sheadded,“That’sbeenmyhangup[and]that’swhyI’mstressingsomuchwiththecity.Weneedtoprovidemoreopportunitiesforsmallbusinessownerstohavevalueintheirfirm.Notonlyfortheexistingowner,butwhenthey'rereadytoretireandmoveon.”[PT#2c]
Thesamebusinessownerwentontosay,“Nowgranted,makingajumpfromasubconsultanttoaprimeishuge,andthereneedstobesomeguidanceandmentors….But,weneedtohavethoseopportunities,andthecityhasnotrespondedinthatwaythistimearoundatall.”[PT#2c]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmstatedthathewouldliketoseemoretransparencyinthecityandstateagenciesofDenver.Hesaid,“Wewanttoknowwho,what,when,where,andhow….Just[be]transparent.Thatway,itgivesyoutheabilitytoseewhatyouneed[and]whatyou’relacking.Alotofminoritiesdon’twantahandout.Theyjustwanttoknow…what[they]needtodotogetthere.”[#7]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andEBE‐certifiedgeneralcontractingfirmsuggestedthatapublicentity,perhapsCityandCountyofDenver,
![Page 636: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/636.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 209
“developadatabaseofavailableequipment.”Sheexplained,“Ifacompanyhasa$1millionwaterblasterandisnotusingit,andthereisasmallcompanythatcouldusetheequipment,thatcompanycouldgotothedatabaseandcontacttheownerofthatequipmentandcontractwiththemtouseit.[Or],maybeitwouldbeanopportunitytosubwiththecompanytodosomeoftheworkwiththemachine.”[#19]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andESB‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmsaid,“Myrecommendationwouldbetolookatwhentheproductisgoingtogetusedintheproject,andallowforadjustmentsbasedonthecurrentmarketconditions….I’mguessingifIwouldhavetobidaprojectwheremypartcomesintoplaytwotothreeyearsbeforetheyneedit…I’mgoingtopriceitwayuptotryandtakecareofwhatI’mhearingmayhappeninthemarket,whichmaymakemenon‐competitiveagainstthosepeoplethatdon’tdothat.”[#9]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmsaid,“Monitoringthegoodfaitheffortsisreallyimportantas[abuse]isoftenusedtoeliminatesmallbusinesses.Andcertificationshouldbekeptstringentastherearecompanieswhogamethesystembyhidingassets.”[#20]
ThesamebusinessowneralsosaidthatshehasheardrumorsthatCityandCountyofDenverandDenverInternationalAirportmight“split”theMWBEprogramintoseparateMBEandWBEcertifications.ShesaidthatitshouldremainMWBE.[#20]
Whenaskedforanyotherinsightsorrecommendations,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofagoodsandservicesfirmsaiditwouldbehelpfulifbusinessesknewwhichmailinglisttobeon.Heexplained,“Itwouldbehelpfulifeverythingwereinawell‐curatedlistofwhatiscurrentandwhat’swhere.Ifit’sfragmentedintoabunchofdifferentsites,thenit’salwayshardtonavigate.Itwouldbehelpfulifthoseresourceswereallinonecentralizedlocation,likeahubwherewegotoforallthemostcurrentinfo.”[#10]
Thesamebusinessowneralsosaidthathewouldbemorelikelytotakepartinbusinessassistanceprogramsandworkshopsiftheywereofferedmoreoften.Heexplained,“Iknowtheyhavesomethatareonceaquarter,somethatareonceayear,andifyoumissit,yougottacatchthenextone.Also,sometimestheclassesfillup.Capsontheprogramcanalsolimititsometimes.”Regardingthedisseminationofinformationregardingbusinessassistanceprogramsandevents,hesaid,“Twitterisusefulintoday’ssociety….Ifyou’repushingbyemail,thenyoumayaswellpushbysocialmedia.”[#10]
TheAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“Professionalserviceengineeringfirmshaveprospered,grown,andgraduatedfromDenver’sMWBEprogram.WBEarchitecturalfirmshavealsoprosperedandgraduated.NotsomuchforMBEarchitecturalfirms.”[WT#2]
TheNativeAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,SDB‐,SDVOSB‐,andHUBZone‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmcommented,“Ithinkasagroup…ifaBlackpersonweretowalkuptocorporateAmericaandknockonthedoorandnobodyanswered,Ithinktheyarealittlemoreaggressiveasanethnicgrouptofindawaytogetin.HispanicsandAsiansarethe
![Page 637: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/637.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 210
sameway,whereas[if]anIndianorNativeAmericanwalksupandknocksonthedoorandnobodyanswers,they’llturnaroundandwalkaway….Ithinkitstartsbacktowhenyouisolateanethnicgrouponareservationlikethegovernmentdid,andyou’reusedtothewelfareandplacedonanislandwheretheywilltakecareofyou,youdon’thavethatpushandarenotusedtocompetingasotherethnicgroupsareusedtocompeting….”[#39]
A trade association representative commented on the importance of work opportunities for
minority companies, especially Black American‐owned firms. TheBlackAmericanfemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaid,“It’sverycriticalrightnowfortheowneragencies,municipalities,etcetera,toreallytakealookattheirprogramsandprojectstoensurethat,alongwiththeincreaseinopportunitiesorcontractsandprojects,there’salsoanincreaseinopportunitiesforminorities.”[#6]
Thesametradeassociationrepresentativelatersaid,“Iwasatameetingrecentlywithanotherminoritygroup.Theyaskedmetocomeandspeakbeforesomefolksattheairport,andinthemeeting,theypresentedsomefindings.Onefinding,whichwasprettyastonishingtome,wasthattherewaslessthan1percentAfricanAmericanparticipationoutoftheairport….Soyes,there’sahugedisparity,andthere’salsoahugeneedfortheseprogramsforcapacity‐buildingandsupportiveservices,etcetera.”[#6]
Another trade association representative suggested that City and County of Denver offer a
“minority business recruiter” to assist minority companies with securing quality labor.Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationreiteratedthatthereisalackofqualifiedworkersintheconstructionindustry,andsaid,“We’vesaidto…the[CityandCountyofDenver],‘Ifyou’dinvestalongwithus,wecouldhelptheminorityfirmsgetalotmoreemployees.’Wehaven’theardbackonthat,andIjustthinkthathelpingthosefirmsbeeffectiveinfindingmoreemployeesthatarepartiallytrainedisgoingtobesuperimportantnomatterwhat’sdone.”[#40]
Thesametradeassociationrepresentativeadded,“Weputinaproposaltothecitytopotentiallygetaminoritybusinessrecruiterthatwouldspecificallystartrecruitingfortheseminorityfirmstohelpthembeefuptheircompaniesaswell.Wewoulddiscountourtraining,butalsotherewouldbesomemoneyinthereforthesefirmstobeabletotakea201‐leveltraining[course].”[#40]
Some interviewees discussed what should be done to enhance the availability or participation
of small and disadvantaged businesses in City and County of Denver’s contracting.Forexample:
TheBlackAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaidthatduringthenextroundofbigjobs,theconsiderationshouldbegiventothefirmsthathavethecapacitytoperformwork.SheaddedthatshewouldliketoseemoreoutreachtotheMBE/WBEcommunitytodetermineiftheycanmeettherequirements.[#13]
WhenaskedifhehasanyotherrecommendationsforCityandCountyofDenverorotherstateagenciesintheDenverarea,theBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionsupplyfirmsaid,“Someofthegoalsontheseprojectsareso
![Page 638: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/638.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 211
small,andtheysaythey’resmallbecausetherearenoqualifiedbusinessesoutthere.So,theycontinuetoshrinkgoalsontheprojectsbecauseofthat.And[therefore]theyareshrinkingsmallbusinessesoutofexistence.”[#36]
Thesamebusinessowneralsosaid,“Youhavetoenforcecompliance.Youneedtoexpandgoalsandgivemorecompaniesanopportunitytogetwork.Ittakestimeandmoneytogetcertified,andnotbeinggivenanopportunityiscriminal.”[#36]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaid,“Gettingmyfirstopportunitywas…slow.I’vebeencertifiedforsixyearsandhaveoneproject.”Shereiterated,“[CityandCountyofDenver]need[s]tobreak‐upcontracts.Rightnow,theprimesjustlookforonebigcompanytodoeverything.Iftheywouldbreak‐upthecontracts,morecompaniescouldgetwork.”[#35]
Thesamebusinessownerwentontosay,“[Thereshouldbe]moretrainingofcertifiedbusiness[es].Wegoinblind.Wedon’tknoweverythingthebigcontractorswillrequire,[and]wedon’tknowwhattoask.SomeofthetrainingshouldalsobeinSpanish.”[#35]
Whenaskedwhatelse,ifanything,shouldbedonetoenhancetheavailabilityandparticipationofallsmallbusinessesintheDenvermarketplace,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“Theredoesneedtobeaculturechangeattheagencies,[but]Idon’tknowhowtodothat…Therewasaplanningprojectattheairport.Theplannerfor[aDenveragency]wasaskedaboutthepreviousgoalforanon‐callplanningproject,andshesaidshedidn’tthinkithadagoal.Well,thereasonitdidn’thaveagoalwasbecauseplanningwasn’tpartofthelastdisparitystudy…itwasjustdesignandconstruction.So,becausetherewasnogoalbefore,shethoughtthegoalshouldbelow.Iwasshockedatthatstatement.Ithinkthepeoplewhomakethesedecisionsdon’tknowwhattheMWBEprogramisabout.Theyhaveanegativepreconception.IknowthereareMWBEsouttherethatcandowhattheagencieswanttodo.”[#22]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,"Ithinkthatitwouldbenicetohavesomeprogramorsomerecognitionforfirmsthathaveminoritiesorwomenemployees….Ithinkitwouldhelpmoreminoritiesultimatelydeveloptheirownfirms."Henotedthatmostbusinessfoundershaveexperienceintheirfieldbeforestartingtheirownbusiness,andsaidhethoughtthistypeofprogramwouldmakeiteasierforminoritiesandwomentogainexpertiseinafield.[#3]
Thesamefirmowneralsorecommendedamentoringprogramconnectingstudentsandfirms.Hesaid,"IthinkthatitwouldbeniceifentitiessuchastheCityofDenvercouldteamupwith[localuniversities]toencourageminoritiestogetintotheeducationtheyneedforthecareerthey'dliketoenter."Henotedthatthereislingeringsexismandracisminschoolsandthoughtaprogramconnectingstudentswiththesefirmswouldhelpto"counteractsomeoftheobviousarchaicattitudesthatexist."[#3]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleownerofaspecialtycontractingfirmreported,"IthinktherequirementsforpublicworktoutilizeentitieswithSBE/MBE/WBEcertificationsisabig
![Page 639: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/639.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 212
factor[inincreasingprogramparticipation].Ifthere'snotarequirement,then[participation]willgoaway…nobody'sgoingtotakethatextrastepanddothatextrapaperworkifthere'snorequirement."[#4]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstruction‐relatedfirmreiterated,“TheCityandCountyofDenverand[DenverInternationalAirport]needtohavealocalrequirementontheircontracts.Ithinktheyshouldaddincentivestocontractorsthatutilizelocalsubcontractors.”[#20]
RegardingwaystoenhancetheavailabilityandparticipationofsmallbusinessesintheDenvermarketplace,thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemaleco‐ownerofaspecialtyservicesfirmsaid,“Itwouldbehelpfuliftheinformationwasjustmorereadilyavailable.[Forexample],theSBAcouldhavesaid,‘Hey,bytheway,you’reawoman‐ownedcompany.Here’salist.Seeifyoucangetonthislist….’WhenItalktowomenwhoowncompanies,theytellmetochatwithotherwomen‐ownedbusinessesbecauseitwillhelpmegetbusiness.”[#8]
Thesamebusinessco‐ownercontinued,“AndIwouldlikethat,butIwouldalsoliketogetpublicsectorbusinesswithcontractsthatarerepetitiveand[that]Icanrelyon[for]constantincome.IknewaboutgoingtoSBAbecauseofmybusinessknowledge,butnoonetoldmeIshouldgetonalistandbecertified.Iwanttoserveeverybody,notjustthepeoplethatareinmygenderorinmyrace.Iwanttobeabletoserveeverybodyandhavetheopportunitytobidforwork.”[#8]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedengineeringfirmindicatedthatdisadvantagedbusinessprogramsshouldreceivemorefunding.Shewentontocomment,“[CityandCountyofDenvershould]takeMWBE[and]SBEparticipationseriously.Putyourmoneywhereyourmouthis.It’sanimportantprogram.Ithinkit’salmostasimportantasschoollunchprograms….Ifwecanjusthelpeverybodybecomethebestthatindividualcanbebyeducation,byprogramslikethisMWBE[program],weareallgoingtoliveinabetterworld.”[#5]
Thesamebusinessownerwentontosay,“IthinktheCityandCounty[ofDenver]coulddomoretoadvertisetheneedforsmallbusinessparticipationandtheneedforwomen‐ownedbusinessesandeducation.Weneedmorewomeninsmallbusinessestostart,tobeawareofwhattheycando,andtobeawareoftheservicesthatareavailabletothem.Thathastocomethrough.Ihadnoidea[of]alltheservicesthatwereavailabletome.”[#5]
WhenaskedwhatshouldbedonetoenhancetheavailabilityandparticipationofsmallbusinessesintheDenvermarketplace,theBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthatthereshouldbeadditional,centrallocationswherepre‐bidscanbesubmitted.Healsosaidthatprequalificationsshouldbeclearlydefinedsothatcontractorsknowwhatqualificationstheyneedtopursueiftheywanttobid.Hewentontosay,“Theycould[also]keepup…alistofawardedbidsandwhotheywereawardedto,sortoflikehowthefederalgovernmentdoesit.”[#7]
WhenaskedifhehasanysuggestionsonhowtoenhancetheavailabilityandparticipationofsmallbusinessesinCityandCountyofDenver’scontracting,thenon‐Hispanicwhite
![Page 640: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/640.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 213
maleownerofaconstruction‐relatedfirmstated,“Atrueliaisonthatcouldguidebusinessestoopportunitieswouldbeveryhelpful.”[#25]
RegardinghisnegativeexperiencewithSBEcertification,thesamebusinessowneralsosaid,“Ibelievethereshouldbeaneffortforthosecertifiedbusinessestogetprojects,oratleast[forthemtobe]taughthowtosubmitbidsthatcouldleadtowinningaproject.”[#25]
TheBlackAmericanveteranmaleownerofageneralcontractingcompanysaid,“Ifthecityreallywantstohelpsmallbusinessesgrow,theyneedtoputtogetheradepartmentthat[specializesin]answer[ing]smallbusinessquestions.”[#29]
Whenaskedwhatshouldbedonetoenhancetheavailabilityandparticipationofsmallbusinesses,includingSBE/MBE/WBEs,intheDenvermarketplace,theHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofanSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaidthatanewsletteraboutavailablecontractingopportunitieswouldbehelpful.[#15a]
RegardingwhatshouldbedonetoenhancetheavailabilityandparticipationofsmallbusinessesintheDenvermarketplace,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofagoodsandservicesfirmsuggestedthatsmallbusinesseshaveaccessto“hackerspaces.”Heexplained,“Hackerspacesareessentiallycommunityworkshopsandyoupayamonthlysubscriptionfee….It’sabunchofpooledtools[available],sothatmightbelasercuttersand3Dprinterswheretheoldbloodandthenewbloodgettogetherandkindofmingleandmakethings.”[#10]
Thesamebusinessownercontinued,“It’sjustagoodcommunityspaceforwhateversortofprojectsyouwanttoworkon.UpinLongmont,forinstance,theyhavetheTinkerMill.It’soneofthebest‐fundedinColorado.It’soneofthebiggest[too]….Theyhaveallkindsoffacilitiesthere,includingahamradiotowerupontheroofofthebuilding.Longmont’sbeenveryaccommodatingforthem,buttheyhavealloftheengineersfromIBMandfrom,youknow,LockheedMartinandBoeingwhogointheretoworkontheircarbonfiberbicyclesthattheybuiltthemselves,or…theirwindkayaksthatthey’vebeenfiber‐glassingthemselves.Thenyouhavepeoplecomingintothesamespacewhohavenevertouchedatoolofanykindintheirlife.They[mightsay],‘Iwanttolearnhowtosolder.Iwanttolearnhowtomakestainedglass.’Andso,it’sjustthisgreatfusionofnewideasandoldideascombinedwithallthetechnologythat…thecommunityhasbeenabletoputtogether.”[#10]
Hewentontosay,“Hackerspacesarekindoftheupcomingandtrendything.It’sagreatplacebecauseyouhavealotofwould‐beentrepreneursjumpingintothescenethereandgettingtheirstart.Andthat’swhereyoucanreally,reallymakeadifference.Itcouldbe[aresourcetodistribute]aflieroflocalworkshopscomingupfortheCityofDenver[on]howtofileyourpaperwork[or]howtodoaccounting….Evenbasicstuffwouldhelpthosepeopletremendously.”[#10]
RegardingwaystoimprovetheavailabilityandparticipationofsmallanddisadvantagedbusinessesintheDenvermarketplace,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmstated,“Therearealotofcontractorsthatuse
![Page 641: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/641.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 214
Subguard,wheretheytakeoutthebondratherthanthesubcontractor.Andthereasonthattheydoitisbecausetheycanactfasterontheirbondthantheycanonthesubcontractor’sbond.So,theyconsideritabetterprocessforthem,becausetheycouldfireyouquickerthanifyouhaveyourownbond.”[#21a]
Thesamebusinessrepresentativecontinued,“Ifthe[CityandCountyofDenver]movedforwardwithsomethinglikethat,itmighthelptheminoritycommunitybeabletodobigger,broaderwork.[However],itstilldoesn'tkeepthemorkeepusfrombeingcarefulaboutbringingsomebodyonboard,eventhoughtheycanpostabond.Thatdoesn'tmeanthattheycandothework.So,it'smoreimportanttomakesuretheycandothework,becauseiftheycan’t,it'sonlygoingtohurtthemandus.”[#21a]
Some trade association and business assistance organization representatives discussed ways
to enhance the availability or participation of small and disadvantaged businesses in Denver
contracting.Forexample:
Whenaskedwhat,ifanything,shouldbedonetoenhancetheavailabilityandparticipationofallsmallbusinessesintheDenvermarketplace,theNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaid,“Maketheprocessquickertogetthrough.Anythingthat’sautomatedonline[wouldhelp]so[smallbusinesses]canaccessiteveningsandweekends…onoff‐hours.TheyneedtocheckaroundthecountryandfindbestpracticesinNewYork,Chicago,etcetera.”[#37]
WhenaskedifhehasanysuggestionsonhowtoenhancetheavailabilityandparticipationofsmallbusinessesintheDenvermarketplace,theHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaid,“Mystrongestrecommendationfor[CityandCountyofDenver]isauniformoutreacheffortacross[allpublicagencies].Thiswouldhelpalotofourcertifiedbusinessesbecausedoingworkwith[Denver]Zooisalotdifferentthandoing[Denver]PublicWorks,orDenverWastewaterManagementbecauseofthedifferentoutreachefforts….[This]createsahindranceasfarassmallbusinessesthataretryingtogrowandnotjustconstantlydoingworkwithoneentitythewholetime.”[#11]
Thesametradeassociationrepresentativecontinued,“The[EmergingBusinessEnterprise]programseriouslyneedstobelookedatandputinplace,andthedepartmentsandowners[shouldbe]heldaccountabletodoit…[and]heldaccountablefornotdoingit.Itissadwhen[CityandCountyofDenver]putsareportoutandthere'szeroparticipation[byEBEs]onit.”[#11]
A few interviewees shared comments related to outreach efforts and procurement
notifications from the City and County of Denver.Forexample:
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmsuggestedthatCityandCountyofDenverandotherstateagenciesestablishacentralweblocationforpre‐bidandtraininginformation.Heexplained,“Itwouldbegreattologonandseeupcomingsmallbusinessevents.[Weneed]acentrallocationwhereyoucanlogon,look,read,understand,andmaybeapplyonline,andthenattend[an]eventtogetthetraining.”[#7]
![Page 642: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/642.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 215
Thesamebusinessco‐ownercontinued,“Rightnow,youreallyhavetogosearch.Yougotothiswebsiteanditgivesyouthelinktoanotherwebsite.Thenyouhavetogotoadifferentwebsiteorgodowntothecity[and]fillout[a]formandsomeonewillcontactyoulater.[Or],youcall[a]numberandyouhavetoleaveavoicemailandsomeonewillcallyouback.Andifyoudon’tansweryourphonerightthenandthere,that’sit.[You]startbackoveragain.”[#7]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemaleco‐ownerofaspecialtyservicesfirmsuggestedthatCityandCountyofDenverandotherpublicagenciesbetternotifysmallbusinessesofupcomingjobandcontractopportunities.Sheexplained,“Ifthere’salistthatsaysinordertoreceiveabid,youhavetohavethiskindofcertification,thatwouldbehelpful.Whenyour[publicsector]contractis[ending]intwomonthsandyouneedtogetanewcontract,[anotification]wouldbehelpful.”[#8]
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaDBE‐,MBE‐,WBE‐,SBE‐,andESB‐certifiedgoodsandservicesfirmsaid,“Iwouldliketoseethemintegratewithinthepurchasingandprocurementareawiththesmallbusinessandeconomicdevelopmentpeoplesothattheyareusingtheresourcesthattheyhavewhenthey’resolicitingforprojects.”[#9]
Thesamebusinessownerexplained,“They’veaskedustofilloutallthisinformationtogetcertified,butthentheydon’tusetheinformation.Thatseemslikealotofmissedopportunities.Myexperienceinworkingwithfederalagenciesisthattheyusethatstuff.Theyusethoselistsandwillsay,‘We’vegot15people,sowe’llsenditoutto10peoplethistimeandthenexttimewe’lltakethose10offorfiveoffandsendouttothatnextgroup,andkeeprotatingthrough.’”[#9]
Whenaskedwhatcanbedonetoimprovetheparticipationofsmallbusinessesinthelocalmarketplace,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemaleownerofaspecialtyservicesfirmsaid,“Ibelieveifthecitywantstohelpsmallbusinesses,theyneedtoreachouttootherbusinesses,beyondtheirpreferredvendorlist,forproductsandsupplies.Idon’tbelievetheagencieswithinthecitygovernmentdoalltheycantoreachouttoothersmallbusinessesoutsideoftheircurrentvendorlist.Ibelievemycompanycouldbeverycompetitiveinpriceformany…jobs.”[#30]
A few public meeting participants shared comments regarding the disparity study.Forexample:
Amalepublicmeetingparticipantstatedthatotherbusinessownersareskepticalofthedisparitystudy.Hesaid,"AlotofpeoplethatIknow,theydon’trespondbecausetheydon’ttrusttheprocess….Theydon’thaveanyconfidenceinthesystem."Headdedthathehopesthedisparitystudy'sfindingswillholdcompaniesaccountabletomeetingDBEparticipationgoals.[PT#1a]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaWBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“Ireallyhopeasaproductofthisprocessthatwebecome…collective,[and]webecomecreativeandvisionarysothatothercitieslooktousandsay,‘Youknowwhat?Denvertriedthisandthiswassuccessful,andnowDenversetsthebar.’”Sheadded,“Andlet’s…setthe
![Page 643: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/643.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 216
barforwhatisgoodandrightandwhatpromotessmallbusiness,andletSanFranciscoandLosAngelesandWashingtonlooktous.”[PT#3c]
Apublicmeetingparticipantsaid,“Whenthestatedidoneof[theirdisparitystudies],theyhadagovernor’sdisparityresolutionoversightcommittee.Andunlessthemayorengageswith[thedisparity]committee,it’sgoingtogonowhere.Isatonthatcommitteeforthegovernorandheappointedtheindividualsonit,andtheyhadpowerbecausetheytalkedtohimdirectlytomakerealchanges.Andoneoftherealchangeswasthatiftheemployeesweren’tincentivizedtomeetthosegoals,itisn’tgoingtohappen.”[PT#4]
Some trade association and business assistance organization representatives shared
comments regarding the disparity study.Commentsinclude:
Regardingapastdisparitystudy,theBlackAmericanfemalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaid,“Oneofthethingsthatconcernsme…isthefactthatwehaveanordinance,andwe’vehadsomeactionitemsfromthelastdisparitystudy,[but]there’sbeennocomplianceorreportingmechanismattachedtothemtoensurethatthey’retakingplace.So,we’reonthesametrajectory…asaresult.”[#6]
Thesametradeassociationrepresentativecontinued,“Fortheitemsthatmayhavebeenrecommendedinthelastdisparitystudy,therereallyhastobesomestrongfollow‐up,becauseastheysay,ifyou’renotpartofthesolutionyouarepartoftheproblem.So,eveniftheCityandCounty[ofDenver]werenotdoingegregiousthings,thelackoffollow‐upandimplementationofprocessimprovementscancertainlybehurtingmorethanhelping.”[#6]
WhenaskedifshehasanyotherrecommendationsforCityandCountyofDenverorotherpublicagencies,theNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaid,“IthinkDenverhasdoneagreatjobofallocatingresourcestotheirdiversityprogram.It’snotjustlipservicelikeI’veseeninotherpartsofthecountry,wheretheysaytheycareaboutdiversitybutdon’tputanyresourcesbehindit.Thedisparitystudyaloneisatestamenttotheircommitment.Andlastweektheybroughtdepartmentheadstotalktothe[organization].Thatwasreallygreat.”[#37]
Access to capital and obtaining financing. Somebusinessownersandrepresentativesreportedchallengessecuringfinancing,andcommentedonhowitimpactstheirabilitytosecurework.[e.g.,#23b]Forexample:
Whenaskedaboutbarriersordiscriminationinobtainingfinancing,theHispanicAmericanfemaleco‐ownerofanSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“Earlyon,wetriedtogetanSBAloan.Itwashorrible,sowefinallywentconventional,andstilldo.”[#15a]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmstatedthatobtainingfinancingisaproblemforalotofcontractors,notjustMWBEs.[#21a]
TheBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionsupplyfirmsaid,“Whenwegotintothebusinessitwasn’tcheap,but[wewere]guaranteedthe
![Page 644: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/644.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 217
loan,so[that]wasprettyeasy.Sincethen,ithasbeenverydifficultwhenyou’retryingtofinancethingsthataren’trealestate.EventhoughI’vebeeninbusinessalongtime,youwouldthinkI’dbereadyforaregularbankingloan,buttheyinsistIgothroughtheSBA.Andofcourse,that’sexpensive.IfeelI’mreadyforprimetime,buttheregularbankerstieyourhandswithexpensivefinancing.”[#36]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaidthatshehas“absolutely”facedbarrierswithfinancing.Sheexplained,“IwentthroughaperiodwhereIwasgoingtotrytobuyabuilding.Iwaslookingforfinancing,[and]IthinkIwouldhavegottenbetteroptionsifIweremale.IthinkIwaslookeddownupon.Peopleweren’tblatantlyrudetomeandturningmeaway,butIfelttherewasjustalittlebitofweirdredlininggoingon.”[#12]
A few trade association and business assistance organization representatives discussed access
to capital as a barrier for members.[e.g.,#38]Commentsinclude:
TheHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationsaidthatmembersexperiencebarriersinobtainingfinancing,specificallywithaccesstocapital.Heexplained,“[Somemembers]justdonothavethesame[opportunity]tobeabletoaccesscapitalintheconstructionindustry.SomeofthatIthinkisjustinherited,[and]someofitisjusttrulythebanksorfinancialinstitutionfeelingthattheyareatgreaterriskbasedonthemember’sethnicity.Someofthatis[also]thefirmjust…notyet[having]afinancialtrackrecord.”[#11]
Whenaskedifsheisawareofobtainingfinancingasbeingabarrierformembers,theNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationsaid,“Accesstocapitalisalwaysatopic,especiallyforsmallbusinesses.WereferthemtotheSBA,theNativeAmericanBank,andotherresourcesforsmallbusinesses.”[#37]
Other firms stated that access to capital has not been a barrier.[e.g.,#5,#35]Forexample:
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthataccesstocapitalandobtainingfinancingisnotabarrierforhisfirm.[#7]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemaleco‐ownerofaspecialtyservicesfirmreportedthatsheisnotawareofanypotentialbarrierstoobtainingfinancingforherfirmorotherfirmsinthelocalmarketplace.[#8]
TheHispanicAmericanmaleownerofanengineeringfirmstatedthathehasneverhadproblemsobtainingfinancing.[#16]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthatshehasnotexperienceddiscriminationinregardstoobtainingfinancing,bonding,materialsandsupplies,orotherproductsorservices.[#12]
![Page 645: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/645.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 218
Whenaskedifhehasfacedanybarriersordiscriminationinobtainingfinancing,theAsian‐PacificAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmsaid,“It’snotaproblemformyfirm,[and]I’vebeeninbusinessmanyyears.”[#22]
Bonding requirements and obtaining bonds.Somebusinessownersandrepresentativesreportedchallengeswithsecuringbonds.Forexample,thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmsaid,“Idon'twanttocallitdiscrimination.Iknowthattherearelimitations,especiallyunderbonding.It’safactthat[certifiedfirms]can’tgetabond,whichlimitsusandourabilitytohirethatsub.It'snotbecausethecityrequiresustobondit,it'sbecauseourpoliciesrequirethatwebondpeoplesothattheycan'thurtus.So,ourfinancialpeoplealsodictatewhatwe'reallowedtodo.”[#21a]
Some trade association and business assistance organization representatives described
bonding requirements and obtaining bonds as barriers for member firms.[e.g.,#38]Commentsinclude:
Whenaskedifsheisawareofbondingrequirementsorobtainingbondsasbarrierstomembers’success,theNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationstated,“Itisanissue,butIdon’tthinkit’sbecauseofdiscrimination.Theyjustdon’thavetheeducation.”Shewentontosay,“WehaveamemberwhodoesbondingworkshopswiththeU.S.DepartmentofTransportation,andtheyareverygood.”[#37]
TheHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationreportedthatsomemembershavementionedthatbondingrequirementsandobtainingbondsareabarrier.[#11]
For some business owners, bonding requirements and obtaining bonds is not a barrier.[e.g.,#16,#23b]Forexample:
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthathisfirmhasnoissuesmeetingbondingrequirementsorobtainingbonds.[#7]
Whenaskedaboutbarriersordiscriminationregardingbondingrequirementsandobtainingbonds,theHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmsaid,“FormanyyearsIdidn’tneedabond,butwhenItalkedto[alargeprime]aboutaproject,theysaidIneededabond.So,IattendedtheUSDOTBondingEducation[Program]andthat’swhereImet[someoneto]helpmegetabond.”However,sheadded,“Ididn’tneeditbecause[thelargeprime]didn’tgivemethecontract,butnowIknowwhotogotoifIneedabond.”[#35]
Insurance requirements and obtaining insurance.Anumberofbusinessesreportedontheirdifficultiessecuringinsurance.Commentsinclude:
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitemalerepresentativeofamajority‐ownedconstructionservicesfirmsaidthatobtainingworkers’compinsuranceissometimesachallengeforsmallcontractorsiftheydon’thavetherightsafetyprocessesinplace.[#21a]
![Page 646: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/646.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX D, PAGE 219
Whenaskedaboutbarriersordiscriminationregardinginsurancerequirementsandobtaininginsurance,theBlackAmericanmaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionsupplyfirmstated,“It’sexpensive,butthat’smoreafunctionoftheindustrythandiscrimination.”[#36]
Thesamebusinessownerlatersaid,“Ifyou’regoingtodobusinessat[DenverInternationalAirport],theywantyoutohavea$10millioninsurancepolicy,andthat’sexpensive.Youneedasizeablecontracttocoverthecost.”[#36]
Regardingbarriersordifficultiesinthelocalmarketplaceforthefirm,asurveyrespondentcommented,“Insurancepremiumsarehigh.”[AS#29]
One business assistance organization representative reported that insurance requirements can
be a barrier for members.Whenaskedifsheisawareofinsurancerequirementsorobtaininginsuranceasbarriersformembers,theNativeAmericanfemalerepresentativeofabusinessassistanceorganizationstated,“Thisisanissue.Thepremiumsaretoohigh,soit’snotworthgoingafterthework.[Forexample]the$10millionumbrellaat[DenverInternationalAirport].”[#37]
For some, insurance requirements and obtaining insurance is not a barrier.[e.g.,#23b,#36]Forexample:
TheBlackAmericanmaleco‐ownerofaveteran‐ownedspecialtycontractingfirmreportedthathisfirmhasnoissueswithinsurancerequirementsorobtaininginsurance.[#7]
Thenon‐Hispanicwhitefemaleco‐ownerofaspecialtyservicesfirmreportedthatsheisnotawareofanypotentialbarrierstoobtaininginsuranceforherfirmorotherfirmsinthelocalmarketplace.[#8]
TheHispanicAmericanfemaleownerofaDBE‐,MWBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedconstructionservicesfirmreportedthatshehasnoproblemsobtainingtheinsurancesheneeds.[#35]
Thenon‐HispanicwhitefemaleownerofaDBE‐,WBE‐,andSBE‐certifiedprofessionalservicesfirmreportedthatinsurancerequirementsandobtaininginsurancehaveneverbeenbarriersforherfirm.Shewentontosaythatshehasagoodrelationshipwithherinsuranceagent.[#12]
A trade association representative indicated that members do not face insurance‐related
barriers.TheHispanicAmericanmalerepresentativeofatradeassociationreportedthathehasnotheardofinsurancerequirementsandobtaininginsuranceasbarriersformembers.[#11]
![Page 647: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/647.jpg)
APPENDIX E.
Availability Analysis Approach
![Page 648: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/648.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX E, PAGE 1
APPENDIX E. Availability Analysis Approach
BBCResearch&Consulting(BBC)usedacustomcensusapproachtoanalyzetheavailabilityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedforconstruction;professionalservices;andgoodsandservicesprimecontractsandsubcontractsthattheCityandCountyofDenver(theCity)awards.AppendixEexpandsontheinformationpresentedinChapter5todescribe:
A. Availabilitydata;
B. Representativebusinesses;
C. Availabilitysurveyinstrument;
D. Surveyexecution;and
E. Additionalconsiderations.
A. Availability Data
BBCcontractedwithCustomerResearchInternational(CRI)toconducttelephonesurveyswiththousandsofbusinessestablishmentsthroughouttherelevantgeographicmarketareaforCitycontracting,whichBBCidentifiedasAdams,Arapahoe,Boulder,Broomfield,Denver,Douglas,andJeffersonCountiesinColorado.BusinessestablishmentsthatCRIsurveyedwerebusinesseswithlocationsintherelevantgeographicmarketareathatthestudyteamidentifiedasdoingworkinfieldscloselyrelatedtothetypesofcontractsandprocurementsthattheCityawardedbetweenJuly1,2011andJune30,2016(i.e.,thestudyperiod).Thestudyteambeganthesurveyprocessbydeterminingtheworkspecializations,orsubindustries,foreachrelevantCityprimecontractandsubcontractandidentifying8‐digitDun&Bradstreet(D&B)workspecializationcodesthatbestcorrespondedtothosesubindustries.ThestudyteamthencollectedinformationaboutlocalbusinessestablishmentsthatD&Blistedashavingtheirprimarylinesofbusinesswithinthoseworkspecializations.1
Aspartofthetelephonesurveyeffort,thestudyteamattemptedtocontact7,320localbusinessestablishmentsthatperformworkthatisrelevanttoCitycontracting.Thattotalincluded3,578constructionestablishments,2,346professionalservicesestablishments,and1,396goodsandservicesestablishments.Thestudyteamwasabletosuccessfullycontact2,635ofthosebusinessestablishments(1,168businessestablishmentsdidnothavevalidphonelistings).Ofbusinessestablishmentsthatthestudyteamcontactedsuccessfully,897establishmentscompletedavailabilitysurveys.
1Inmanycases,BBCpurchasedinformationaboutmultiplelocationsofasinglebusinessandcalledallofthoselocations.BBC’smethodforconsolidatinginformationfordifferentestablishmentsthatwereassociatedwiththesamebusinessisdescribedlaterinAppendixE.
![Page 649: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/649.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX E, PAGE 2
B. Representative Businesses
TheobjectiveofBBC’savailabilityapproachwasnottocollectinformationabouteachandeverybusinessthatisoperatingintherelevantgeographicmarketarea.Instead,itwastocollectinformationfromalarge,unbiasedsubsetoflocalbusinessesthatappropriatelyrepresentstheentirerelevantbusinesspopulation.ThatapproachallowedBBCtoestimatetheavailabilityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinanaccurate,statistically‐validmanner.Inaddition,BBCdidnotdesigntheresearcheffortsothatthestudyteamwouldcontacteverylocalbusinesspossiblyperformingconstruction;professionalservices;andgoodsandserviceswork.Instead,BBCdeterminedthetypesofworkthatweremostrelevanttoCitycontractingbyassessingprimecontractandsubcontractdollarsthatwenttodifferenttypesofbusinessesduringthestudyperiod.
FigureE‐1liststhe8‐digitworkspecializationcodeswithinconstruction;professionalservices;andgoodsandservicesthatweremostrelatedtothecontractandprocurementdollarsthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiod,andthatBBCincludedaspartoftheavailabilityanalysis.Thestudyteamgroupedthosespecializationsintodistinctsubindustries,whicharepresentedasheadingsinFigureE‐1.
C. Availability Survey Instrument
BBCcreatedanavailabilitysurveyinstrumenttocollectinformationfromrelevantbusinessestablishmentslocatedintherelevantgeographicmarketarea.Asanexample,thesurveyinstrumentthatthestudyteamusedwithconstructionestablishmentsispresentedattheendofAppendixE.Thestudyteammodifiedtheconstructionsurveyinstrumentslightlyforusewithestablishmentsworkinginotherindustriesinordertoreflecttermsmorecommonlyusedinthoseindustries(e.g.,thestudyteamsubstitutedthewords“primecontractor”and“subcontractor”with“primeconsultant”and“subconsultant”whensurveyingprofessionalservicesestablishments).2
Survey structure.Theavailabilitysurveyincluded15sections,andCRIattemptedtocoverallsectionswitheachbusinessestablishmentthatthestudyteamsuccessfullycontactedandthatwaswillingtocompleteasurvey.
1. Identification of purpose.ThesurveysbeganbyidentifyingtheCityasthesurveysponsoranddescribingthepurposeofthestudy.(e.g.,“TheCityisconductingasurveytodevelopalistofcompaniesinterestedinprovidingconstruction‐relatedservicestotheCityandCountyofDenver.”)
2BBCalsodevelopedafaxande‐mailversionofthesurveyinstrumentforbusinessestablishmentsthatpreferredtocompletethesurveyinthoseformats.
![Page 650: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/650.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX E, PAGE 3
Figure E‐1. Subindustries included in the availability analysis
Industry Code Industry Description Industry Code Industry Description
Construction
Bridge construction Electrical equipment and supplies (continued)16229901 Bridge construction 50630104 Transformers, electric
16220000 Bridge, tunnel, and elevated highway construction 50840701 Controlling instruments and accessories
50630000 Electrical apparatus and equipment
Building construction15420000 Nonresidential construction, nec Electrical work
15410000 Industrial buildings and warehouses 17319903 General electrical contractor
76992500 Miscellaneous building item repair services 76290200 Electrical equipment repair services
15419909 Renovation, remodeling and repairs: industrial buildings
15420101 Commercial and office building, new construction Elevators and conveyors15420103 Commercial and office buildings, renovation and repair 76992501 Elevators: inspection, service, and repair
15420400 Specialized public building contractors 17969901 Elevator installation and conversion
15420100 Commercial and office building contractors 35340100 Elevators and equipment
Carpet and floors Environmental cleaning
17520000 Floor laying and floor work, nec 17990801 Asbestos removal and encapsulation
17990800 Decontamination services
Concrete and related products 73499901 Chemical cleaning services
14420102 Construction sand mining 49590302 Environmental cleanup services
32720303 Concrete products, precast, nec
14230000 Crushed and broken granite Fencing, guardrails and signs29510201 Asphalt and asphaltic paving mixtures (not from refineries) 16110100 Highway signs and guardrails
50320000 Brick, stone, and related material
32720000 Concrete products, nec Heavy construction
50320101 Asphalt mixture 16110000 Highway and street construction
50320503 Concrete building products 16290000 Heavy construction, nec
14420000 Construction sand and gravel
29510000 Asphalt paving mixtures and blocks Heavy construction equipment73530000 Heavy construction equipment rental
Electrical equipment and supplies 50820303 Cranes, construction
36340110 Heating units, for electric appliances 50820102 Road construction and maintenance machinery
50630103 Power transmission equipment, electric 73539901 Cranes and aerial lift equipment, rental or leasing
76290201 Electrical equipment repair, high voltage 35310000 Construction machinery
50840703 Measuring and testing equipment, electrical 73539902 Earth moving equipment, rental or leasing
50630205 Electrical construction materials
![Page 651: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/651.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX E, PAGE 4
Figure E‐1. Subindustries included in the availability analysis (continued)
Industry Code Industry Description Industry Code Industry Description
Construction (continued)
Highway and street construction Lawn, garden, and irrigation supplies (continued)49590100 Road, airport, and parking lot maintenance service 50830308 Irrigation equipment
16110206 Sidewalk construction 35240200 Lawn and garden mowers and accessories
17710202 Sidewalk contractor 50830203 Lawn machinery and equipment
16110202 Concrete construction: roads, highways, sidewalks, etc.
16110204 Highway and street paving contractor Masonry, drywall and stonework17710201 Curb construction 17419903 Concrete block masonry laying
16119901 General contractor, highway and street construction 17420101 Drywall
16110201 Airport runway construction 17420201 Acoustical and ceiling work
16110200 Surfacing and paving 17420104 Plastering, plain or ornamental
17710200 Curb and sidewalk contractors
17719902 Concrete repair Other construction materials16110205 Resurfacing contractor 28510105 Paints, asphalt or bituminous
17410102 Retaining wall construction
Other construction services
Industrial equipment and machinery 34490000 Miscellaneous metalwork
35190000 Internal combustion engines, nec 16230200 Communication line and transmission tower construction
50849914 Recycling machinery and equipment
50840700 Instruments and control equipment Painting50849905 Hydraulic systems equipment and supplies 17210303 Pavement marking contractor
35699914 Robots, assembly line: industrial and commercial 17210100 Residential painting
17210200 Commercial painting
Landscape architecture07810000 Landscape counseling and planning Parking services
75210200 Indoor parking services
Landscape services 75210100 Outdoor parking services
07829903 Landscape contractors 75210202 Parking garage
07829902 Highway lawn and garden maintenance services 75210101 Parking lots
Lawn, garden, and irrigation supplies Plumbing and HVAC35230500 Turf and grounds equipment 17110000 Plumbing, heating, air‐conditioning
50870501 Sprinkler systems 35850000 Refrigeration and heating equipment
50830201 Garden machinery and equipment, nec 35850300 Heating equipment, complete
35240000 Lawn and garden equipment 35850200 Refrigeration equipment, complete
![Page 652: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/652.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX E, PAGE 5
Figure E‐1. Subindustries included in the availability analysis (continued)
Industry Code Industry Description Industry Code Industry Description
Construction (continued)
Plumbing and HVAC (continued) Water, sewer, and utility lines (continued)17110301 Fire sprinkler system installation 16239906 Underground utilities contractor
17110401 Mechanical contractor 16239903 Pipe laying construction
16230300 Water and sewer line construction
Roofing 16290505 Waste water and sewage treatment plant construction
17610000 Roofing, siding, and sheetmetal work 16230000 Water, sewer, and utility lines
Street cleaning Windows and doors49590101 Snowplowing 52110201 Doors, storm: wood or metal
34420402 Garage doors, overhead: metal
Structural metals 50310300 Doors and windows
34490101 Bars, concrete reinforcing: fabricated steel 52110200 Door and window products
52110203 Garage doors, sale and installation
Traffic flagging and safety 17930000 Glass and glazing work
73899921 Flagging service (traffic control)
Wrecking, demolition, excavation, drilling
Trucking, hauling and storage 17950000 Wrecking and demolition work
42139904 Heavy hauling, nec 17959902 Demolition, buildings and other structures
42129905 Dump truck haulage 73530102 Oil well drilling equipment, rental or leasing
42129912 Steel hauling, local 16110203 Grading
42120000 Local trucking, without storage 16290401 Land leveling
17999906 Core drilling and cutting
Water, sewer, and utility lines 17949901 Excavation and grading, building construction
16239904 Pipeline construction, nsk 16290400 Land preparation construction
16290500 Industrial plant construction
Professional Services
Advertising, marketing and public relations Business services and consulting73119901 Advertising consultant 87420107 Quality assurance consultant
87480302 Telecommunications consultant
Architectural and design services 87210200 Accounting services, except auditing
87120000 Architectural services
73891801 Design, commercial and industrial Construction management87120101 Architectural engineering 87420402 Construction project management consultant
87120100 Architectural engineering 87419902 Construction management
![Page 653: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/653.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX E, PAGE 6
Figure E‐1. Subindustries included in the availability analysis (continued)
Industry Code Industry Description Industry Code Industry Description
Professional Services (continued)
Engineering Human resources and job training services87110402 Civil engineering 73630101 Employee leasing service
87110404 Structural engineering 73630000 Help supply services
87119909 Professional engineer 73630100 Labor resource services
87110400 Construction and civil engineering
87110000 Engineering services Medical testing, laboratories, and pharmaceutical services80710100 Testing laboratories
Environmental services and transportation planning87480204 Traffic consultant Surveying and mapmaking87480200 Urban planning and consulting services 87130000 Surveying services
87420410 Transportation consultant
Testing services
Finance and accounting 73890200 Inspection and testing services
73229901 Adjustment bureau, except insurance 73890203 Building inspection service
87420401 Banking and finance consultant
87489903 Employee programs administration
Goods
Automobiles Food50120208 Trucks, commercial 51410000 Groceries, general line
50120200 Commercial vehicles
55119901 Automobiles, new and used Furniture57129904 Office furniture
Cleaning and janitorial supplies 50210100 Office and public building furniture
51690400 Specialty cleaning and sanitation preparations 50210106 Office furniture, nec
39910302 Brushes, household or industrial 25310000 Public building and related furniture
35890200 Commercial cleaning equipment
50870304 Janitors' supplies Office equipment and supplies26770000 Envelopes
Communications equipment 51120000 Stationery and office supplies
38120000 Search and navigation equipment 25990203 Carts, restaurant equipment
59990602 Communication equipment 59991402 Photocopy machines
50650409 Video equipment, electronic 26210600 Stationary, envelope and tablet papers
36630000 Radio and t.v. communications equipment
48130101 Data telephone communications
![Page 654: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/654.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX E, PAGE 7
Figure E‐1. Subindustries included in the availability analysis (continued)
Source: BBC Research & Consulting.
Industry Code Industry Description Industry Code Industry Description
Goods (continued)
Other goods Uniforms (continued)76992000 Customizing services 23260100 Work uniforms
56990103 Work clothing
Petroleum and petroleum products 56990100 Uniforms and work clothing
59840000 Liquefied petroleum gas dealers29110000 Petroleum refining Vehicle parts and supplies51719901 Petroleum bulk stations 37130100 Truck bodies and parts
51720000 Petroleum products, nec 50149901 Automobile tires and tubes
50140000 Tires and tubes
Uniforms 50130119 Truck parts and accessories
56990102 Uniforms 50630100 Transformers and transmission equipment
23110300 Men's and boys' uniforms 37140000 Motor vehicle parts and accessories
Services
Cleaning and janitorial services Security systems73490104 Janitorial service, contract basis 17310400 Safety and security specialization
73829901 Burglar alarm maintenance and monitoring
Communication services 36990502 Security control equipment and systems
76220100 Communication equipment repair 17310403 Fire detection and burglar alarm systems specialization17310402 Closed circuit television installation
Computer and IT services 17310401 Access control systems specialization
73790203 Online services technology consultants 73829904
73790201 Computer hardware requirements analysis
Towing servicesOther services 75490301 Towing service, automotive
79229902 Concert management service
Vehicle repair shops
Printing and copying 75380104 Truck engine repair, except industrial
35790107 Mailing machines 75390102 Automotive springs, rebuilding and repair
27310203 Pamphlets: publishing and printing 75320402 Body shop, trucks
27590000 Commercial printing, nec
Security guard services73810100 Guard services
Confinement surveillance systems maintenance and
monitoring
![Page 655: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/655.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX E, PAGE 8
2. Verification of correct business name.Thesurveyorverifiedthatheorshehadreachedthecorrectbusiness.Ifthebusinessnamewasnotcorrect,surveyorsaskediftherespondentknewhowtocontactthecorrectbusiness.CRIthenfollowedupwiththecorrectbusinessbasedonthenewcontactinformation(seeareas“X”and“Y”oftheavailabilitysurveyinstrumentattheendofAppendixE).
3. Verification of work related to relevant projects.Thesurveyoraskedconstructionbusinesseswhethertheorganizationdoesworkorprovidesmaterialsrelatedtoconstruction,maintenance,ordesign(QuestionA1).Surveyorscontinuedthesurveywithbusinessesthatresponded“yes”tothatquestion.
4. Verification of for‐profit business status.Thesurveyoraskedwhethertheorganizationwasafor‐profitbusinessasopposedtoagovernmentornonprofitorganization(QuestionA2).Surveyorscontinuedthesurveywithbusinessesthatresponded“yes”tothatquestion.
5. Confirmation of main lines of business.BusinessesconfirmedtheirmainlinesofbusinessaccordingtoD&B(QuestionA3a).IfD&B’sworkspecializationcodeswereincorrect,businessesdescribedtheirmainlinesofbusiness(QuestionsA3b).Businesseswerealsoaskedtoidentifytheothertypesofworkthattheyperformbeyondtheirmainlinesofbusiness(QuestionA3c).BBCcodedinformationonmainlinesofbusinessandadditionaltypesofworkintoappropriate8‐digitD&Bworkspecializationcodes.
6. Locations and affiliations.Thesurveyoraskedbusinessownersormanagersiftheirbusinesseshadotherlocations(QuestionA4).Thestudyteamalsoaskedbusinessownersormanagersiftheirbusinessesweresubsidiariesoraffiliatesofotherbusinesses(QuestionsA5andA6).
7. Past bids or work with government agencies and private sector organizations.Thesurveyoraskedaboutbidsandworkonpastgovernmentandprivatesectorcontracts.CRIaskedthosequestionsinconnectionwithprimecontractsandsubcontracts(QuestionsB1andB2).3
8. Interest in future work.Thesurveyoraskedaboutbusinesses’interestinfutureworkwiththeCityandtheDenverInternationalAirport.CRIaskedthosequestionsinconnectionwithbothprimecontractsandsubcontracts(QuestionsB3throughB6).4
9. Geographic area.ThesurveyoraskedwhetherbusinessesperformworkorservecustomersthroughoutDenver.(QuestionC1).
10. Year established.Thesurveyoraskedbusinessestoidentifytheapproximateyearinwhichtheywereestablished(QuestionD1).
11. Largest contracts.Thestudyteamaskedbusinessestoidentifythevalueofthelargestprimecontractsandsubcontractsonwhichtheyhadbidorhadbeenawardedduringthepastfiveyears.(QuestionD2).5
3Goodsandservicesproviderswereaskedquestionsaboutsubcontractwork.4Goodsandservicesproviderswereaskedquestionsaboutsubcontractwork.5Goodsandservicesproviderswereaskedquestionsaboutsubcontractwork.
![Page 656: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/656.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX E, PAGE 9
12. Ownership.Thesurveyoraskedwhetherbusinesseswereatleast51percentownedandcontrolledbyminoritiesorwomen(QuestionsE1andE2).Ifbusinessesindicatedthattheywereminority‐owned,theywerealsoaskedabouttherace/ethnicityofthebusiness’sownership(QuestionE3).Thestudyteamconfirmedthatinformationthroughseveralotherdatasourcesincluding:
Cityvendordata;
Citycertificationdata;
Cityreview;and
InformationfromD&Bandothersources.
13. Business revenue.Thesurveyoraskedseveralquestionsaboutbusinesses’sizeintermsoftheirrevenues.Forbusinesseswithmultiplelocations,thebusinessrevenuesectionofthesurveyalsoaskedabouttheirrevenuesandnumberofemployeesacrossalllocations(QuestionsF1throughF3).
14. Potential barriers in the marketplace.Thesurveyoraskedanopen‐endedquestionconcerninggeneralinsightsaboutconditionsinthelocalmarketplace(QuestionG1).Inaddition,thesurveyincludedaquestionaskingwhetherrespondentswouldbewillingtoparticipateinafollow‐upinterviewaboutconditionsinthelocalmarketplace(QuestionG2).
15. Contact information.Thesurveyconcludedwithquestionsabouttheparticipant’snameandpositionwiththeorganization(QuestionsH1andH2).
D. Survey Execution
CRIconductedallsurveysin2017and2018.Tominimizenon‐response,CRImadeuptofiveattemptsduringdifferenttimesofthedayandondifferentdaysoftheweektoreacheachbusinessestablishment.CRIattemptedtosurveyanavailablecompanyrepresentativesuchastheowner,manager,orotherofficerwhocouldprovideaccurateanddetailedresponsestosurveyquestions.
Establishments that the study team successfully contacted.FigureE‐2presentsthedispositionofthe7,320businessestablishmentsthatthestudyteamattemptedtocontactforavailabilitysurveysandhowthatnumberresultedinthe2,644establishmentsthatthestudyteamwasabletosuccessfullycontact.
Non‐working or wrong phone numbers.SomeofthebusinesslistingsthatthestudyteampurchasedfromD&BandthatCRIattemptedtocontactwere:
Duplicatephonenumbers(77listings);
Non‐workingphonenumbers(920listings);or
Wrongnumbersforthedesiredbusinesses(162listings).
![Page 657: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/657.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX E, PAGE 10
Somenon‐workingphonenumbersandwrongnumbersresultedfrombusinessesgoingoutofbusinessorchangingtheirnamesandphonenumbersbetweenthetimethatD&Blistedthemandthetimethatthestudyteamattemptedtocontactthem.
Figure E‐2. Disposition of attempts to survey business establishments
Note:
Availability analysis results are based on a representative, unbiased, and statistically‐valid subset of the relevant business population.
Source:
2017‐18 availability surveys.
Working phone numbers.AsshowninFigureE‐2,therewere6,161businessestablishmentswithworkingphonenumbersthatCRIattemptedtocontact.CRIwasunsuccessfulincontactingmanyofthosebusinessesforvariousreasons:
CRIcouldnotreachanyoneafterfiveattemptsatdifferenttimesofthedayandondifferentdaysoftheweekfor3,130establishments.
CRIcouldnotreacharesponsiblestaffmemberafterfiveattemptsatdifferenttimesofthedayondifferentdaysoftheweekfor333establishments.
CRIcouldnotconducttheavailabilitysurveyduetolanguagebarriersfor54establishments.
Aftertakingthoseunsuccessfulattemptsintoaccount,CRIwasabletosuccessfullycontact2,644businessestablishments.
Establishments included in the availability database. FigureE‐3presentsthedispositionofthe2,644businessestablishmentsthatCRIsuccessfullycontactedandhowthatnumberresultedinthe597businessesthatthestudyteamincludedintheavailabilitydatabaseandthatthestudyteamconsideredpotentiallyavailableforCitywork.
Establishments not interested in discussing availability for City work.Ofthe2,644businessestablishmentsthatthestudyteamsuccessfullycontacted,1,637establishmentswerenotinterestedindiscussingtheiravailabilityforCitywork.Inaddition,thestudyteamsentfaxore‐mailavailabilitysurveysuponrequestbutdidnotreceivecompletedsurveysfrom101establishments.Intotal,906successfully‐contactedbusinessestablishmentscompletedavailabilitysurveys.
Establishments available for City work.ThestudyteamonlydeemedaportionofthebusinessestablishmentsthatcompletedavailabilitysurveysasavailablefortheprimecontractsandsubcontractsthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiod.Thestudyteamexcludedmanyofthebusinessestablishmentsthatcompletedsurveysfromtheavailabilitydatabaseforvariousreasons:
Beginning list 7,320
Less duplicate phone numbers 77
Less non‐working phone numbers 920
Less wrong number/business 171
Unique business listings with working phone numbers 6,152
Less no answer 3,130
Less could not reach responsible staff member 333
Less language barrier 54
Establishments successfully contacted 2,635
Number of
businesses
![Page 658: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/658.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX E, PAGE 11
BBCexcluded38establishmentsthatindicatedthattheirbusinesseswerenotinvolvedinrelevantcontractingwork.
BBCexcluded12establishmentsthatindicatedthattheirorganizationswerenotfor‐profitbusinesses.
BBCexcluded23establishmentsthatindicatedthattheirbusinesseswereinvolvedinrelevantworkbutreportedthattheirmainlinesofbusinesswereoutsideofthestudyscope.
BBCexcluded203establishmentsthatreportednotbeinginterestedineitherprimecontractingorsubcontractingopportunitieswiththeCity.
BBCexcluded14businessestablishmentthatreportedbeingestablishedin2017orlater.ThatbusinessestablishmentwouldnothavebeenavailableforcontractelementsthattheCityawardedduringthestudyperiod.
Nineteenestablishmentsrepresenteddifferentlocationsofthesamebusinesses.Priortoanalyzingresults,BBCcombinedresponsesfrommultiplelocationsofthesamebusinessintoasingledatarecord.
Afterthoseexclusions,BBCcompiledadatabaseof597businessesthatwereconsideredpotentiallyavailableforCitywork.
Figure E‐3. Disposition of successfully contacted business establishments
Note:
Availability analysis results are based on a representative, unbiased, and statistically‐valid subset of the relevant business population.
Source:
2017‐18 availability surveys.
Coding responses from multi‐location businesses.Responsesfromdifferentlocationsofthesamebusinesswerecombinedintoasinglesummarydatarecordaccordingtoseveralrules:
Ifanyoftheestablishmentsreportedbiddingorworkingonacontractwithinaparticularsubindustry,thestudyteamconsideredthebusinesstohavebidorworkedonacontractinthatsubindustry.
Thestudyteamcombinedthedifferentrolesofwork(i.e.,primecontractororsubcontractor)thatestablishmentsofthesamebusinessreportedintoasingleresponse.Forexample,ifoneestablishmentreportedthatitworksasaprimecontractorandanotherestablishmentreportedthatitworksasasubcontractor,thenthestudyteamconsidered
Establishments successfully contacted 2,635
Less establishments not interested in discussing availability for work 1,637
Less unreturned fax/email surveys 101
Establishments that completed interviews about firm characteristics 897
Less no relevant work 38
Less not a for‐profit business 12
Less line of work outside scope 23
Less no interest in future work 194
Less established after study period 14
Less multiple establishments 19
Establishments potentially available for City work 597
Number of
Establishments
![Page 659: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/659.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX E, PAGE 12
thebusinessasavailableforbothprimecontractsandsubcontractswithintherelevantsubindustry.
Exceptwhentherewerelargediscrepanciesamongindividualresponsesregardingestablishmentdates,BBCusedtheearliestfoundingdatethatestablishmentsofthesamebusinessprovided.Incasesoflargediscrepancies,BBCfollowedupwiththebusinessestablishmentstoobtainaccurateestablishmentdateinformation.
BBCconsideredthelargestcontractthatanyestablishmentsofthesamebusinessreportedhavingbidorworkedonasthebusiness’relativecapacity(i.e.,thelargestcontractforwhichthebusinesscouldbeconsideredavailable).
BBCdeterminedthenumberofemployeesforbusinessesbycalculatingthemodeorthemeanofresponsesfromitsestablishments.
BBCconsideredthelargestrevenuetotalthatanyestablishmentsofthesamebusinessreportedasthebusiness’srevenuecap(forpurposesofdeterminingstatusasapotentialDisadvantagedBusinessEnterprise).
BBCcodedbusinessesasminority‐orwoman‐ownedifthemajorityofitsestablishmentsreportedsuchstatus.
E. Additional Considerations
BBCmadeseveraladditionalconsiderationsrelatedtoitsapproachtomeasuringavailabilitytoensurethatestimatesoftheavailabilityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesforCityworkwereaccurateandappropriate.
Not providing a count of all businesses available for City work.ThepurposeoftheavailabilityanalysiswastoprovidepreciseandrepresentativeestimatesofthepercentageofCitycontractingdollarsforwhichminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesareready,willing,andabletoperform.TheavailabilityanalysisdidnotprovideacomprehensivelistingofeverybusinessthatcouldbeavailableforCityworkandshouldnotbeusedinthatway.FederalcourtshaveapprovedBBC’sapproachtomeasuringavailability.Inaddition,federalregulationsaroundminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessprogramsrecommendsimilarapproachestomeasuringavailabilityfororganizationsimplementingbusinessassistanceprograms.
Not basing the availability analysis on certification directories, prequalification lists, or bidders lists. Federalguidancearoundmeasuringtheavailabilityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesrecommendsdividingthenumberofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesinanorganization’scertificationdirectorybythetotalnumberofbusinessesinthemarketplace(forexample,asreportedinUnitedStatesCensusdata).Asanotheroption,organizationscouldusealistofprequalifiedbusinessesorabidderslisttoestimatetheavailabilityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesforitsprimecontractsandsubcontracts.TheprimaryreasonwhyBBCrejectedsuchapproacheswhenmeasuringtheavailabilityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessesforCityworkisthatdividingasimpleheadcountofcertifiedbusinessesbythetotalnumberofbusinessesdoesnotaccountforbusinesscharacteristicsthatarecrucialtoestimatingavailabilityaccurately.ThemethodologythatBBCusedinthisstudytakesacustomcensusapproachtomeasuringavailabilityandaddsseverallayersofrefinementtoasimpleheadcountapproach.Forexample,theavailabilitysurveysthat
![Page 660: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/660.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX E, PAGE 13
thestudyteamconductedprovideddataonqualifications,relativecapacity,andinterestinCityworkforeachbusiness,whichallowedBBCtotakeamoredetailedapproachtomeasuringavailability.Courtcasesinvolvingimplementationsofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinessprogramshaveapprovedtheuseofsuchapproachestomeasuringavailability.
Selection of specific subindustries.Definingsubindustriesbasedonspecificworkspecializationcodes(e.g.,D&Bindustrycodes)isastandardstepinanalyzingbusinessesinaneconomicsector.Governmentandprivatesectoreconomicdataaretypicallyorganizedaccordingtosuchcodes.Aswithanysuchresearch,therearelimitationswhenchoosingspecificD&Bworkspecializationcodestodefinesetsofestablishmentstobesurveyed.Forexample,someindustrycodesareimpreciseandoverlapwithotherbusinessspecialties.Somebusinessesspanseveraltypesofwork,evenataverydetailedlevelofspecificity.Thatoverlapcanmakeclassifyingbusinessesintosinglemainlinesofbusinessdifficultandimprecise.Whenthestudyteamaskedbusinessownersandmanagerstoidentifytheirmainlinesofbusiness,theyoftengavebroadanswers.Forthoseandotherreasons,BBCcollapsedworkspecializationcodesintobroadersubindustriestomoreaccuratelyclassifybusinessesintheavailabilitydatabase.
Non‐response. Ananalysisofnon‐responseconsiderswhetherbusinessesthatwerenotsuccessfullysurveyedaresystematicallydifferentfromthosethatweresuccessfullysurveyedandincludedinthefinaldataset.Thereareopportunitiesfornon‐responsebiasinanysurveyeffort.Thestudyteamconsideredthepotentialfornon‐responsedueto:
Researchsponsorship;
Workspecializations;and
Languagebarriers.
Research sponsorship.SurveyorsintroducedthemselvesbyidentifyingtheCityasthesurveysponsor,becausebusinessesmaybelesslikelytoanswersomewhatsensitivebusinessquestionsifthesurveyorwasunabletoidentifythesponsor.Inpastsurveyefforts—particularlythoserelatedtoavailabilityanalyses—BBChasfoundthatidentifyingthesponsorsubstantiallyincreasesresponserates.
Work specializations.Businessesinhighlymobilefields,suchastrucking,maybemoredifficulttoreachforavailabilitysurveysthanbusinessesmorelikelytoworkoutoffixedoffices(e.g.,engineeringbusinesses).Thatassertionsuggeststhatresponseratesmaydifferbyworkspecialization.Simplycountingallsurveyedbusinessesacrossworkspecializationstoestimatetheavailabilityofminority‐andwoman‐ownedbusinesseswouldleadtoestimatesthatwerebiasedinfavorofbusinessesthatcouldbeeasilycontactedbytelephone.However,workspecializationasapotentialsourceofnon‐responsebiasintheBBCavailabilityanalysisisminimized,becausetheavailabilityanalysisexaminesbusinesseswithinparticularworkfieldsbeforecalculatingoverallavailabilityestimates.Thus,thepotentialforbusinessesinhighlymobilefieldstobelesslikelytocompleteasurveyislessimportant,becausethestudyteamcalculatedavailabilityestimateswithinthosefieldsbeforecombiningtheminadollar‐weightedfashionwithavailabilityestimatesfromotherfields.Workspecializationwouldbeagreatersourceofnon‐responsebiasifparticularsubsetsofbusinesseswithinaparticularfieldwerelesslikelythanothersubsetstobeeasilycontactedbytelephone.
![Page 661: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/661.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX E, PAGE 14
Language barriers.ThestudyteammadethedecisiontoonlyincludebusinessesabletocompletetheavailabilitysurveyinEnglishintheavailabilityanalysis.Businessesunabletocompletethesurveyduetolanguagebarriersrepresentedlessthanonepercentofcontactedbusinesses.
Response reliability.Businessownersandmanagerswereaskedquestionsthatmaybedifficulttoanswerincludingquestionsabouttheirrevenues.Forthatreason,thestudyteamcollectedcorrespondingD&Binformationfortheirestablishmentsandaskedrespondentstoconfirmthatinformationorprovidemoreaccurateestimates.Further,respondentswerenottypicallyaskedtogiveabsolutefiguresfordifficultquestionssuchasrevenueandcapacity.Rather,theyweregivenrangesofdollarfigures.BBCexploredthereliabilityofsurveyresponsesinanumberofways.
Certification lists.BBCrevieweddatafromtheavailabilitysurveysinlightofinformationfromothersourcessuchasvendorinformationthatthestudyteamcollectedfromtheCity.Forexample,certificationdatabasesincludedataontherace/ethnicityandgenderofbusinessowners.Thestudyteamcomparedsurveyresponsesconcerningbusinessownershipwithsuchinformation.
Contract data.BBCexaminedCitycontractdatatofurtherexplorethelargestcontractsandsubcontractsawardedtobusinessesthatparticipatedintheavailabilitysurveysforthepurposesofassessingcapacity.BBCcomparedsurveyresponsesaboutthelargestcontractsthatbusinesseswonduringthepastfiveyearswithactualCitycontractdata.
City review.TheCityreviewedcontractandvendordatathatthestudyteamcollectedandcompiledaspartoftheavailabilityanalysisandprovidedfeedbackregardingitsaccuracy.
![Page 662: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/662.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX E, PAGE 15
Availability Survey Instrument [Construction]
Hello. My name is [interviewer name] from Customer Research International. We are calling on behalf of the City and County of Denver. This is not a sales call. The City is conducting a survey to develop a list of companies interested in providing construction-related services to the City and County of Denver. The survey should take between 10 and 15 minutes to complete. Who can I speak with to get the information that we need from your firm?
[AFTER REACHING AN APPROPRIATELY SENIOR STAFF MEMBER, THE INTERVIEWER SHOULD RE-INTRODUCE THE PURPOSE OF THE SURVEY AND BEGIN WITH QUESTIONS]
[IF ASKED, THE INFORMATION DEVELOPED IN THESE INTERVIEWS WILL ADD TO EXISTING DATA ON COMPANIES INTERESTED IN WORKING WITH THE AGENCY]
X1. I have a few basic questions about your company and the type of work you do. Can you confirm that this is [firm name]?
1=RIGHT COMPANY – SKIP TO A1
2=NOT RIGHT COMPANY
99=REFUSE TO GIVE INFORMATION – TERMINATE
Y1. What is the name of this firm?
1=VERBATIM
Y2. Can you give me any information about [new firm name]?
1=Yes, same owner doing business under a different name – SKIP TO Y4
2=Yes, can give information about named company
3=Company bought/sold/changed ownership – SKIP TO Y4
98=No, does not have information – TERMINATE
99=Refused to give information – TERMINATE
![Page 663: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/663.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX E, PAGE 16
Y3. Can you give me the complete address or city for [new firm name]?
[NOTE TO INTERVIEWER - RECORD IN THE FOLLOWING FORMAT]:
. STREET ADDRESS
. CITY
. STATE
. ZIP
1=VERBATIM
Y4. Can you give me the name of the owner or manager of [new firm name]?
[ENTER UPDATED NAME]
1=VERBATIM
Y5. Can I have a telephone number for him/her?
[ENTER UPDATED PHONE]
1=VERBATIM
Y6. Do you work for this new company?
1=YES
2=NO – TERMINATE
A1. First, I want to confirm that your firm does work or provides materials related to construction, maintenance, or design. Is that correct?
[NOTE TO INTERVIEWER – INCLUDES ANY WORK RELATED TO CONSTRUCTION, MAINTENENCE OR DESIGN SUCH AS BUILDING FACILITIES, PAVING AND CONCRETE, TUNNELS, BRIDGES AND ROADS AND OTHER CONSTRUCTION-RELATED PROJECTS. IT ALSO INCLUDES TRUCKING AND HAULING]
[NOTE TO INTERVIEWER – INCLUDES HAVING DONE WORK, TRYING TO SELL THIS WORK, OR PROVIDING MATERIALS]
1=Yes
2=No – TERMINATE
![Page 664: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/664.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX E, PAGE 17
A2. Let me confirm that [firm name/new firm name] is a for-profit business, as opposed to a non-profit organization, a foundation, or a government office. Is that correct?
1=Yes, a business
2=No, other – TERMINATE
A3a. Let me also confirm what kind of business this is. The information we have from Dun & Bradstreet indicates that your main line of business is [SIC Code description]. Is that correct?
[NOTE TO INTERVIEWER – IF ASKED, DUN & BRADSTREET OR D&B, IS A COMPANY THAT COMPILES INFORMATION ON BUSINESSES THROUGHOUT THE COUNTRY]
1=Yes – SKIP TO A3c
2=No
98=(DON'T KNOW)
99=(REFUSED)
A3b. What would you say is the main line of business at [firm name/new firm name]?
[NOTE TO INTERVIEWER – IF RESPONDENT INDICATES THAT FIRM’S MAIN LINE OF BUSINESS IS “GENERAL CONSTRUCTION” OR GENERAL CONTRACTOR,” PROBE TO FIND OUT IF MAIN LINE OF BUSINESS IS CLOSER TO BUILDING CONSTRUCTION OR HIGHWAY AND ROAD CONSTRUCTION.]
1=VERBATIM
A3c. What other types of work, if any, does your business perform?
(ENTER VERBATIM RESPONSE)
1=VERBATIM
A4. Is this the sole location for your business, or do you have offices in other locations?
1=Sole location
2=Have other locations
98=(DON'T KNOW)
99=(REFUSED)
![Page 665: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/665.jpg)
BBC RESEARCH & CONSULTING—FINAL REPORT APPENDIX E, PAGE 18
A5. Is your company a subsidiary or affiliate of another firm?
1=Independent – SKIP TO B1
2=Subsidiary or affiliate of another firm
98=(DON'T KNOW) – SKIP TO B1
99=(REFUSED) – SKIP TO B1
A6. What is the name of your parent company?
1=VERBATIM
98=(DON'T KNOW)
99=(REFUSED)
B1. Next, I have a few questions about your company’s role in doing work or providing materials related to construction, maintenance, or design. During the past five years, has your company submitted a bid or received an award for any part of a contract as either a prime contractor or subcontractor?
1=Yes
2=No – SKIP TO B3
98=(DON'T KNOW) – SKIP TO B3
99=(REFUSED) – SKIP TO B3
B2. Were those bids or awards to work as a prime contractor, a subcontractor, a trucker/hauler, a supplier, or any other roles?
[MULTIPUNCH]
1=Prime contractor
2=Subcontractor
3=Trucker/hauler
4=Supplier (or manufacturer)
5= Other - SPECIFY ___________________
98=(DON'T KNOW)
99=(REFUSED)
![Page 666: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/666.jpg)
![Page 667: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/667.jpg)
![Page 668: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/668.jpg)
![Page 669: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/669.jpg)
![Page 670: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/670.jpg)
![Page 671: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/671.jpg)
![Page 672: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/672.jpg)
![Page 673: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/673.jpg)
![Page 674: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/674.jpg)
![Page 675: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/675.jpg)
![Page 676: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/676.jpg)
![Page 677: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/677.jpg)
![Page 678: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/678.jpg)
![Page 679: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/679.jpg)
![Page 680: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/680.jpg)
![Page 681: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/681.jpg)
![Page 682: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/682.jpg)
![Page 683: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/683.jpg)
![Page 684: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/684.jpg)
![Page 685: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/685.jpg)
![Page 686: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/686.jpg)
![Page 687: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/687.jpg)
![Page 688: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/688.jpg)
![Page 689: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/689.jpg)
![Page 690: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/690.jpg)
![Page 691: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/691.jpg)
![Page 692: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/692.jpg)
![Page 693: DENVER 2018 DISPARITY STUDY...1) DSBO Ordinance Extension – the DSBO ordinance will be extended for eight months, through December 1, 2019, to finalize changes to the ordinance,](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022062403/6109bed55960660758264b8c/html5/thumbnails/693.jpg)