Counting output in ways that matter: lessons from
Britain’s Railways…or…
Dr Tim Leunig & Professor Nick Crafts
Why have commuters been neglected since 1945?
Dr Tim Leunig & Professor Nick Crafts
Measuring output
• Passenger journeys
• Passenger miles
Dr Tim LeunigOverhead 3
Counting output correctly
Dr Tim LeunigOverhead 4
Counting output correctly
Measuring output
• Passenger journeys
• Passenger miles
• Rather crude, and not quality adjusted
Dr Tim LeunigOverhead 5
Counting output correctly
Counting output correctly Dr Tim LeunigOverhead 6
Aspects of quality
• Are the trains safe?
• Are the trains fast?
• Are the trains frequent?
• Are the trains on time?
• Can I get a seat?
• Are the sandwiches any good?
Dr Tim LeunigOverhead 7
Fast v frequent
• People want to get from origin to destination, “quickly”
• “Quickly” means the time from when they want to leave until actual arrival
• Train speed and frequency are therefore substitutes and need to be considered together
Counting output correctly
Dr Tim LeunigOverhead 8
Methodology (1)
• Computerise the railway timetable
• Find out how speeds and frequency change over time
• Take into account that trains at some times of day are more important than at others
Counting output correctly
Dr Tim LeunigOverhead 9
How many people want to travel at different times?
0123456789
10m
idn
igh
t
01
:00
02
:00
03
:00
04
:00
05
:00
06
:00
07
:00
08
:00
09
:00
10
:00
11
:00
12
:00
13
:00
14
:00
15
:00
16
:00
17
:00
18
:00
19
:00
20
:00
21
:00
22
:00
23
:00
Re
lati
ve
pa
ss
en
ge
r n
um
be
rs
Counting output correctly
Dr Tim LeunigOverhead 10
Which train to catch?
• Preferred time of travel exogenous
• Take the first train after the time you want to travel
• Except do not take a train that will be overtaken by a later train mid-journey
• No endogeneity of preferred time of travel as a result of train speeds
Counting output correctly
Dr Tim LeunigOverhead 11
Allocating people to trains
Counting output correctly
Which journeys to include?
• Representative selection?
• Major journeys?
Dr Tim LeunigOverhead 12
Counting output correctly
Which journeys matter?
Dr Tim LeunigOverhead 13
Counting output correctly
Which journeys to include
• Representative selection?
• Major journeys?
• Journeys of different types
Dr Tim LeunigOverhead 14
Counting output correctly
5 samples
• Short commuter routes (Surbiton)
• Long commuter routes (Cambridge)
• Long distance routes (Leeds)
• Non-London routes
• Airport connections
Dr Tim LeunigOverhead 15
Counting output correctly
Dr Tim LeunigOverhead 16
Counting output correctly
Dr Tim LeunigOverhead 17
Counting output correctly
Overall result
• Since 1945, long distance trains have become faster
• Shorter distance commuter trains got faster until the earlier 1970s, and have since slowed down to their 1950 levels again
Counting output correctly Dr Tim LeunigOverhead 18
Commuter line quantity
• 375 million commuter journeys into Central London each year, 60m from Waterloo alone
Dr Tim LeunigOverhead 19
Counting output correctly
Passengers per station
Dr Tim LeunigOverhead 20
Counting output correctly
The value of time
• DoT methodology: modal-specific wage values for in work time, standardised for other time
• Rail work time £42/hour
• Commuting time all modes £5.75
• Commuting rail time would be £8
• Might be higher into SW London?Dr Tim LeunigOverhead 21
“Lost” value
• Counterfactual: commuter trains get faster at the same rate as non-commuter trains since 1950
• eg Surbiton-Waterloo 14 mins inc waiting (51mph total, 71mph IV on current frequency)
• Value @£8/hr: £440m (npv £6bn)Dr Tim LeunigOverhead 22
So why hasn’t it happened?
• Politics?
• Technical difficulties?
Dr Tim LeunigOverhead 23
Commuter line politics
• In commuter constituencies, lots of people commute: salience
• Non-commuting home owners gain as house prices reflect service
• Therefore you might expect government to improve these lines
Dr Tim LeunigOverhead 24
Counting output correctly
Commuter line politics
• Most London commuter constituencies vote Conservative
• And some are politically marginal – Croydon, North Kent, South Essex
Dr Tim LeunigOverhead 25
Counting output correctly
Commuter election results
Brighton Con Con Con Con Con Lab/C Lab/C Con Con Con Con Con Con Con Lab Lab Lab
Chelmsford Lab Con Con Con Con Con Con Con Con Con Con Con Con Con Con Con Con
Croydon Lab Con Con Con Con Con Lab Con Con Con Con Con Con Con Lab Lab Con
Reading Lab Lab Lab/C Lab Con Con Lab Con Con Con Con Con Con Con Lab Lab Lab/C
St.Albans Lab Lab Con Con Con Con Con Con Con Con Con Con Con Con Lab Lab Con
Surbiton Con Con Con Con Con Con Con Con Con Con Con Con Con Con LD LD LD
Wimbledon Lab Con Con Con Con Con Con Con Con Con Con Con Con Con Lab Lab Con
Woking Con Con Con Con Con Con Con Con Con Con Con Con Con Con Con Con
1945 1950 1951 1955 1959 1964 1966 1970 1974 1974.5 1979 1983 1987 1992 1997 2001 2005
Dr Tim LeunigOverhead 26
Counting output correctly
Can commuter routes get faster?
• Improve signalling to run more trains per hour (as in 1912)
• Lighter trains accelerate more quickly
• More doors to speed boarding
• Tunnel mainline routes into the centre, (e.g. Waterloo – Bank – Liverpool St) – big time savings
Dr Tim LeunigOverhead 27
Counting output correctly
Why choose HST instead?
• Glamour? Announcing that Britain will enter the High Speed Era with the CTRL or the WCML may get better headlines than announcing 5 minutes off the time to East Croydon.
Dr Tim LeunigOverhead 28
Counting output correctly
Evening Standard
• “The Queen re-ignited the great British love affair with the railways last night as she opened the revitalised St.Pancras station.”
• “History was made at the new St.Pancras International today when the first Eurostar train left for Brussels.”
Dr Tim LeunigOverhead 29
Counting output correctly
Will it happen?
• Eddington talked about building what people will use
• Crossrail is in London (although does not seem designed to maximise output:cost ratio)
Dr Tim LeunigOverhead 30
Counting output correctly
Dr Tim LeunigOverhead 32
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
IVT
eq
uiv
alen
t w
ait
nominal wait
Cost of waiting: nominal to IVT disutility equivalence
The glamour of high speed trains – or why is my train to work so slow?