Download - Conferenza REALCORP 2010
CO
RP
20
10
AN OPERATIONAL MODEL
TOWARDS
PLAYFUL PUBLIC PARTICIPATION
REA
L
CO
RP
Viviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
Università della Basilicata
CO
RP
20
10
Doctorate school in:
Science and Methods for
European Cities and Territory
University of Study of Basilicata - PotenzaR
EA
L
CO
RP
Viviana Lanza [email protected]
Lucia Tilio [email protected]
European Cities and Territory
Laboratory of Engineer of
Urban and Territorial System
AN OPERATIONAL MODEL TOWARDS
PLAYFUL PUBLIC PARTICIPATION
CO
RP
20
10
REA
L
CO
RP
SUMMARY
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
Introduction
Renovated approach in rational planning
CO
RP
20
10
How to get better planning process? R+P
Study case
Result and further workREA
L
CO
RP
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
Participation process arises from necessity to break down cultural barrier
both for administrators and for subjects involved in participation process
SO
ME C
ON
SID
ER
ATIO
NS
AB
OU
T
PA
RTIC
IP
ATIO
N I
N P
LA
NN
IN
GS
OM
E C
ON
SID
ER
ATIO
NS
AB
OU
T
PA
RTIC
IP
ATIO
N I
N P
LA
NN
IN
G
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
Participation process arises from necessity to break down cultural barrier
both for administrators and for subjects involved in participation process
SO
ME C
ON
SID
ER
ATIO
NS
AB
OU
T
PA
RTIC
IP
ATIO
N I
N P
LA
NN
IN
GS
OM
E C
ON
SID
ER
ATIO
NS
AB
OU
T
PA
RTIC
IP
ATIO
N I
N P
LA
NN
IN
G
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
To build this CHANGE it is important consider several aspects: in particular,
what kind of tools to use, where to participate, how to participate.
SO
ME C
ON
SID
ER
ATIO
NS
AB
OU
T
PA
RTIC
IP
ATIO
N I
N P
LA
NN
IN
GS
OM
E C
ON
SID
ER
ATIO
NS
AB
OU
T
PA
RTIC
IP
ATIO
N I
N P
LA
NN
IN
G
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
WHAT kind of tools to use?
Decision making tools, and in particular technological ones, are effective to
create a COMMON KNOWLEDGE BASE and to organize and manage the
process, making it transparent and making possible to repeat in the time.
SO
ME C
ON
SID
ER
ATIO
NS
AB
OU
T
PA
RTIC
IP
ATIO
N I
N P
LA
NN
IN
G
WHAT?WHAT?
SO
ME C
ON
SID
ER
ATIO
NS
AB
OU
T
PA
RTIC
IP
ATIO
N I
N P
LA
NN
IN
G
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
It is important to CHOOSE RIGHT PLACE (physical or virtual): comfortable
environments where people can talk and have a confrontation; where it is
possible to organize meetings, with different kind of people, making
everyone at oneself ease.
WHERE to participate?
SO
ME C
ON
SID
ER
ATIO
NS
AB
OU
T
PA
RTIC
IP
ATIO
N I
N P
LA
NN
IN
G
everyone at oneself ease.
WHERE?WHERE?
SO
ME C
ON
SID
ER
ATIO
NS
AB
OU
T
PA
RTIC
IP
ATIO
N I
N P
LA
NN
IN
G
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
HOW to participate?
Sharing moments have to take into account, preferring an INFORMAL
APPROACH, based on the concrete representation and exemplification, in
order to illustrate concepts and themes concerning the discussion.
SO
ME C
ON
SID
ER
ATIO
NS
AB
OU
T
PA
RTIC
IP
ATIO
N I
N P
LA
NN
IN
G
HOW?HOW?
SO
ME C
ON
SID
ER
ATIO
NS
AB
OU
T
PA
RTIC
IP
ATIO
N I
N P
LA
NN
IN
G
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
WHERE?WHERE?
HOW?HOW?
WHAT?WHAT?
SO
ME C
ON
SID
ER
ATIO
NS
AB
OU
T
PA
RTIC
IP
ATIO
N I
N P
LA
NN
IN
G
NEW WAY to make PLANNING and to make PARTICIPATION, joining
the rational planning approach with the Playful Public Participation one.
WHERE?WHERE?
SO
ME C
ON
SID
ER
ATIO
NS
AB
OU
T
PA
RTIC
IP
ATIO
N I
N P
LA
NN
IN
G
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
A decision making process that uses a participation process and is supported
from Playful Public Participation principles is the KEY of this NEW WAY to
make planning, and so participation planning.
REN
OV
ATED
AP
PR
OA
CH
IN
RA
TIO
NA
L
PLA
NN
IN
G
Rational Rational planning planning approachapproach
Playful Public Playful Public Participation Participation approachapproach
REN
OV
ATED
AP
PR
OA
CH
IN
RA
TIO
NA
L
PLA
NN
IN
G
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
REN
OV
ATED
AP
PR
OA
CH
IN
RA
TIO
NA
L
PLA
NN
IN
GR
EN
OV
ATED
AP
PR
OA
CH
IN
RA
TIO
NA
L
PLA
NN
IN
G
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
REN
OV
ATED
AP
PR
OA
CH
IN
RA
TIO
NA
L
PLA
NN
IN
GR
EN
OV
ATED
AP
PR
OA
CH
IN
RA
TIO
NA
L
PLA
NN
IN
G
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
REN
OV
ATED
AP
PR
OA
CH
IN
RA
TIO
NA
L
PLA
NN
IN
GR
EN
OV
ATED
AP
PR
OA
CH
IN
RA
TIO
NA
L
PLA
NN
IN
G
KNOWLEDGEKNOWLEDGE
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
The new planning asks for interaction between two kinds of knowledge, that
one of EXPERTS and technicians subjects and that one tested. Tested
knowledge, that planners have to make explicit, is CITIZENS’ KNOWLEDGE,
important because citizens live experiences, situations and contexts.
REN
OV
ATED
AP
PR
OA
CH
IN
RA
TIO
NA
L
PLA
NN
IN
G
KNOWLEDGEKNOWLEDGE
REN
OV
ATED
AP
PR
OA
CH
IN
RA
TIO
NA
L
PLA
NN
IN
G
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
RATIONALITY in planning
supports the planning process
in all its phases with several
techniques and methodological
approaches; in our vision, the
reference term is to consider
The key idea of PLAYFUL
PUBLIC PARTICIPATION is to
generate pleasure and joy to
involve citizens in public
participatory processes. With
Playful Participation it is
REN
OV
ATED
AP
PR
OA
CH
IN
RA
TIO
NA
L
PLA
NN
IN
G
reference term is to consider
plan as a decision process, and
to adopt a PROCEDURAL
approach, where knowledge
grows in an incremental way,
considering logical
consequences and linking
decision evaluation to the strict
process itself.
Playful Participation it is
possible stimulate and involve
citizens in serious public
participatory processes. In the
playful public participation
concept, the union among
dialogue, comparison, design
and fun is the secret and
special ingredient.
REN
OV
ATED
AP
PR
OA
CH
IN
RA
TIO
NA
L
PLA
NN
IN
G
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
REN
OV
ATED
AP
PR
OA
CH
IN
RA
TIO
NA
L
PLA
NN
IN
G
METHODOLOGY PRINCIPLES
REN
OV
ATED
AP
PR
OA
CH
IN
RA
TIO
NA
L
PLA
NN
IN
G
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
HO
W T
O G
ET B
ETTER
PLA
NN
IN
G
PR
OC
ES
S? R
+P
HO
W T
O G
ET B
ETTER
PLA
NN
IN
G
PR
OC
ES
S? R
+P
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
HO
W T
O G
ET B
ETTER
PLA
NN
IN
G
PR
OC
ES
S? R
+P
HO
W T
O G
ET B
ETTER
PLA
NN
IN
G
PR
OC
ES
S? R
+P
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
HO
W T
O G
ET B
ETTER
PLA
NN
IN
G
PR
OC
ES
S? R
+P
EX-ANTE
HO
W T
O G
ET B
ETTER
PLA
NN
IN
G
PR
OC
ES
S? R
+P
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
HO
W T
O G
ET B
ETTER
PLA
NN
IN
G
PR
OC
ES
S? R
+P
EX-ANTE
HO
W T
O G
ET B
ETTER
PLA
NN
IN
G
PR
OC
ES
S? R
+P
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
HO
W T
O G
ET B
ETTER
PLA
NN
IN
G
PR
OC
ES
S? R
+P
EX-ANTE EX-POST
HO
W T
O G
ET B
ETTER
PLA
NN
IN
G
PR
OC
ES
S? R
+P
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
HO
W T
O G
ET B
ETTER
PLA
NN
IN
G
PR
OC
ES
S? R
+P
EX-ANTE EX-POST
HO
W T
O G
ET B
ETTER
PLA
NN
IN
G
PR
OC
ES
S? R
+P
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
HO
W T
O G
ET B
ETTER
PLA
NN
IN
G
PR
OC
ES
S? R
+P
EX-ANTE EX-POST
ON-GOING
HO
W T
O G
ET B
ETTER
PLA
NN
IN
G
PR
OC
ES
S? R
+P
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
HO
W T
O G
ET B
ETTER
PLA
NN
IN
G
PR
OC
ES
S? R
+P
EX-ANTE EX-POST
ON-GOING
HO
W T
O G
ET B
ETTER
PLA
NN
IN
G
PR
OC
ES
S? R
+P
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
The increase of importance of communicative aspects in urban planning has
been led the participation, and moreover the e-participation, to hold a role
more and more decisive in planning process (Hajer, 2001).
The aim of Public Administrations, in the “Information Society”, is to establish a
rapid, direct and transparent relation with citizens.
The Information and Communication Technologies (ICT), therefore, play a
PA
RTIC
IP
ATIO
N P
RO
CES
S I
N W
EB
2.0
The Information and Communication Technologies (ICT), therefore, play a
fundamental role into building consensus in democratic processes, giving more
relevance to citizens in need to be involved in decisional process (Tambouris, et
al, 2007).
PA
RTIC
IP
ATIO
N P
RO
CES
S I
N W
EB
2.0
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
SH
AR
IN
G T
OO
LS
SO
CIA
L T
OO
LS
DEC
IS
IO
N T
OO
LS
MA
PP
IN
G T
OO
LS
E-PARTICIPATION TOOLS
PA
RTIC
IP
ATIO
N P
RO
CES
S I
N W
EB
2.0
SH
AR
IN
G T
OO
LS
SO
CIA
L T
OO
LS
DEC
IS
IO
N T
OO
LS
MA
PP
IN
G T
OO
LS
PA
RTIC
IP
ATIO
N P
RO
CES
S I
N W
EB
2.0
PLA
NN
IN
G P
UB
LIC
SP
AC
ES
FO
R Y
OU
NG
CITIZ
EN
S
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
REQUEST
PLA
NN
IN
G P
UB
LIC
SP
AC
ES
FO
R Y
OU
NG
CITIZ
EN
S
SUPPLY
��A A problemproblem in planning??in planning??
SIM
ULA
TIO
N O
F P
LA
NN
IN
G P
RO
CES
S
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
Operators in contextof young policies
Research Group
SIM
ULA
TIO
N O
F P
LA
NN
IN
G P
RO
CES
S
20-24
15-19 25-34Young people
WH
AT K
IN
D O
F T
OO
LS
?
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
SurveysSurveys
Focus Focus groupgroup
WH
AT K
IN
D O
F T
OO
LS
?
Social Social networkingnetworking
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
Distributed
also through
Results helpful during
WH
AT K
IN
D O
F T
OO
LS
?S
UR
VEY
S
3 3 kindskinds of surveysof surveys
��forfor 1515--19 19 yearsyears oldold citizenscitizens
��for 20for 20--24 24 yearsyears oldold citizenscitizens
��forfor 2525--34 34 yearsyears oldold citizenscitizens
Results helpful during
context analysis in
focus group
WH
AT K
IN
D O
F T
OO
LS
?S
UR
VEY
S
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
BRAINSTORMING
WH
AT K
IN
D O
F T
OO
LS
?FO
CU
S G
RO
UP
BRAINSTORMING
WH
AT K
IN
D O
F T
OO
LS
?FO
CU
S G
RO
UP
STU
DY
CA
SE:
PLA
NN
IN
G P
UB
LIC
SP
AC
ES
FO
R Y
OU
NG
CITIZ
EN
S
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
��Focus Group Focus Group ActivitiesActivities
��SWOT SWOT AnalysisAnalysis
��LocalizationLocalization throughthrough Google Google MapsMaps
��ProblemsProblems and and ObjectivesObjectives TreeTree
��LogicalLogical FrameworkFramework ApproachApproach
WH
AT K
IN
D O
F T
OO
LS
?FO
CU
S G
RO
UP
STU
DY
CA
SE:
PLA
NN
IN
G P
UB
LIC
SP
AC
ES
FO
R Y
OU
NG
CITIZ
EN
SW
HA
T K
IN
D O
F T
OO
LS
?FO
CU
S G
RO
UP
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
��Focus Group Focus Group ActivitiesActivities
��SWOT SWOT AnalysisAnalysis
��LocalizationLocalization throughthrough Google Google MapsMaps
��ProblemsProblems and and ObjectivesObjectives TreeTree
��LogicalLogical FrameworkFramework ApproachApproach
WH
AT K
IN
D O
F T
OO
LS
?FO
CU
S G
RO
UP
WH
AT K
IN
D O
F T
OO
LS
?FO
CU
S G
RO
UP
STU
DY
CA
SE:
PLA
NN
IN
G P
UB
LIC
SP
AC
ES
FO
R Y
OU
NG
CITIZ
EN
S
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
��FacebookFacebook GroupGroup
��Spread Spread diffusiondiffusion amongamong youngsyoungs
��OnOn--line line surveyssurveys
��Report Report ofof activitiesactivities
WH
AT K
IN
D O
F T
OO
LS
?S
OC
IA
L N
ETW
OR
KIN
GS
TU
DY
CA
SE:
PLA
NN
IN
G P
UB
LIC
SP
AC
ES
FO
R Y
OU
NG
CITIZ
EN
SW
HA
T K
IN
D O
F T
OO
LS
?S
OC
IA
L N
ETW
OR
KIN
G
RES
ULTS
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
��ImproveImprove qualityquality of of youngyoung people life people life throughthrough 5 5 strategiesstrategies
�� ImportanceImportance ofof youngyoung citizenscitizens contributioncontribution toto PA PA activitiesactivities
�� So, So, citizenscitizens wantwant toto participateparticipate!!!! !!!! ☺☺☺☺☺☺☺☺
RES
ULTS
UR
BA
N L
AB
OF P
AR
TIC
IP
ATIO
N
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
UR
BA
N L
AB
OF P
AR
TIC
IP
ATIO
N
ActivitiesActivities in in progress!!! progress!!!
☺☺☺☺☺☺☺☺
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
��An An initiativeinitiative byby UniversityUniversity
�� InvolvementInvolvement ofof citizenscitizens and and institutionsinstitutions
UR
BA
N L
AB
OF P
AR
TIC
IP
ATIO
N
�� InvolvementInvolvement ofof citizenscitizens and and institutionsinstitutions
�� StartingStarting dayday: 10: 10thth May 2010May 2010
�� 4 4 meetingsmeetings forfor eacheach lablab
�� ResultsResults toto presentpresent toto PAPA
UR
BA
N L
AB
OF P
AR
TIC
IP
ATIO
N
HO
W T
O I
NV
OLV
E?
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
��NewspapersNewspapers toto informinform
��BrochuresBrochures toto diffusediffuse
HO
W T
O I
NV
OLV
E?
�� PostersPosters to to promotepromote
�� Facebook for Facebook for allall
A B
RA
ND
TO
ID
EN
TIFY
?
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
��A A piecepiece of puzzle to of puzzle to watchwatch the the
towntown and design the master and design the master planplan
A B
RA
ND
TO
ID
EN
TIFY
?
towntown and design the master and design the master planplan
togethertogether
��People to participatePeople to participate
��A color for A color for eacheach lablab
AC
TIV
ITIES
FO
R A
N R
+P
AP
PR
OA
CH
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
1° MEETING
2°MEETING
3°MEETING
STA
RT
CONTEXT ANALYSIS CONTEXT ANALYSIS AND AND
KNOWLEDGE FRAMEWORKKNOWLEDGE FRAMEWORK
PROBLEMS PROBLEMS
AC
TIV
ITIES
FO
R A
N R
+P
AP
PR
OA
CH
4° MEETING
EN
D
OBJECTIVES TREEOBJECTIVES TREE
INTERVENTION POLICIESINTERVENTION POLICIES
EVALUATIONEVALUATION
DEFINITIONDEFINITION
PROBLEMS TREEPROBLEMS TREE
KNOWLEDGEKNOWLEDGE
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
AC
TIV
ITIES
FO
R A
N R
+P
AP
PR
OA
CH
A
CTIV
ITIES
FO
R A
N R
+P
AP
PR
OA
CH
AC
TIV
ITIES
FO
R A
N R
+P
AP
PR
OA
CH
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
AC
TIV
ITIES
FO
R A
N R
+P
AP
PR
OA
CH
PlayingPlaying to to buildbuild a a problemproblem treetree
togethertogether
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia TilioW
EB
2.0
SU
PP
OR
T A
ND
PA
RTIC
IP
ATIO
N K
IT
SH
AR
IN
G T
OO
LS
Boxnet
SlideshareS
OC
IA
L T
OO
LS
Blog and Chat
Ning
DEC
IS
IO
N T
OO
LS
Survey with
Google Docs
MA
PP
IN
G T
OO
LS
Google Maps
Google Earth
E-PARTICIPATION TOOLS
WEB
2.0
SU
PP
OR
T A
ND
E-P
AR
TIC
IP
ATIO
N K
IT
SH
AR
IN
G T
OO
LS
Slideshare
Youtube
FlickR
SO
CIA
L T
OO
LS
DEC
IS
IO
N T
OO
LS
MA
PP
IN
G T
OO
LS
Google Earth
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
SH
AR
IN
G T
OO
LS
SH
AR
IN
G T
OO
LS
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
SH
AR
IN
G T
OO
LS
SH
AR
IN
G T
OO
LS
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
SO
CIA
L T
OO
LS
SO
CIA
L T
OO
LS
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
SO
CIA
L T
OO
LS
SO
CIA
L T
OO
LS
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
DEC
IS
IO
N T
OO
LS
DEC
IS
IO
N T
OO
LS
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
MA
PP
IN
G T
OO
LS
MA
PP
IN
G T
OO
LS
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
AN
ALY
SIS
TO
OLS
AN
ALY
SIS
TO
OLS
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
SO
CIA
L T
OO
LS
SO
CIA
L T
OO
LS
An Operational Model towards Playful Public ParticipationViviana Lanza and Lucia Tilio
ThankThank youyou
CO
RP
20
10
andand
stay stay tunedtuned!!! !!!
Viviana Lanza [email protected]
Lucia Tilio [email protected]
REA
L
CO
RP