-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
1/167
iAbaxendtie, WA 22302
d November IS87
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
2/167
.
Q
1.0
2.0
3.0
4.0
.O
2.1 War Deaumd2.2 Resourcus2.3 Probkm in Meetinreta of Ikvelopitq Co2.4 Current Smtw of Rural W
3.1 Techaolonv Coa~iruntions Evaluated33 Shallow W&r T&k Depth Application83.3 Intermediate/I&p Water Table Depth Apt%atioar3.3.1 Low Flow (N 30 mwey)
3.3 Key lepua Data AmuAptiow
y ~AtpMi8OA bSi843 Aarlysis Procaduw~
ASSE!iSMEMT AND SENSITIWR ANALYSES5.1s35.3, 5.4555.65.75.5.95.10
6.0 m~UsIONs
scenario8 AAdyzedPv we-cycle cost competitiwmrrr at 20 LPCD coMumptionxI3comulAption
Pv Amy CON VtwiatiowPV Array Cost on PV Ma&t Size
V
1-If::r-2l-22-2232-42-2-s3-23-23-J::3-63-63.4-l
S-1
s-13S-15S-17S-21S-235-256-1
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
3/167
meal
of the ?hotovolaicsupport of t&e pro-ucces8 of this project.Jones aad Dr.in Ntttioaal
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
4/167
FENDICESA: tK%r supply Tecboo terimtiotts.1 IAtroductioAA.2 WelbA3 H8AclputApsA-3.1 P-P +yge3CONS
A.4 volmiuTYP=A.42 PdOtAUtacr, uristicsA.4.3 COSlSA.5 Iutem8I Combwiou En
En Aa8lysis Graphical Output
A-2A-2A-2A-4A-4A-6A-6A-6A-IIA-J2A-12A-12A-14A-16A-16A-lA-O
A-20A-20A-22
Q-l
Vi
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
5/167
.
0
tIISllIVVvlVIIVIIIDCXwXIIXI112-1;:,3-13-23-33-43-Sf-63-7
4-I
s-7S-85-9
&earriog Enlwted md Sensitivity An8lys~ COaductdLife-Cycle Cost Competitiveneu (20 Ipcd)Life-Cycb Cart Compatitiveaw (40 lpcd)Least Wrter Cost Technologii For Various Villr~e SirwrUnder An, ConditionsSensitivity pb (20 Iprd)Sensitivity Aealysb (40 @cd)Regional PV Pum Systema Potential Demand DistributionPoteatirl Popubtio nod by Handpumps, PV and Qias8bW8tar Cost Vub~ion with PV Amy Cost (20 Ipcd)W8ter Cast Variation with PV Amy Cost (40 @cd)Impact of PV Amy Cost oo Potential PV DemradNumber of Peraonv Without Acan to Safe W8ter (1983)RM 1 Water Consumption by RA* Rcgio~l Water Table DepPV- or Diesel-Bwd Run1 W8ter Supply System WithStonas and Smndpipe DistributionHandpump-Based Rural Water Supply SystemSh8lkw W8ter T8blo Confi8untionaIatermediaa/Dwp W8ter Tmbb Coafi utittiotu (4 30 Et/SaDsrax+dMe/DaepW8ter Trble Coafi untion8 (> 30 ma/
m/d8y and S.2 to 7.0 kWh/m*/&y
%enrrias Enlurtcd md Sensitivity Analyses Conducted-t Of Wltdt (20 @Cd)Pbr Capit Capit Cost (20 lpcd)Liftt-Cycb Cost Competitiveasrr (20 Ipad)ness (40 IpcrQVarious Vilbfg8 SiwCmpital Coat Comparison of?%ndpump and PV RWS ProjectStmitivity Antdysis (20 @cd)ibsitivity Amlysim (40 Ipcd)S-IO Estiamtioa of Forsntial Muket for PV W8ter
nrl PV Pumping Systems PotentY Demand Distributionirl Population Served by ?i8nCpumps. PV, md DiesebS-13 Prelimiarry Estinute of Pumpin System SptcifiutionsS-14 Vlaiability of PV Pumpi System Specificrtions
IOI2I4I416I6If;::2-33-l3::3-s3-7-,,s4-25-ls-23-2s-43-65-I
s-10S-12s-14d-16S-183-18S-205-21
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
6/167
S-ISS-16S-17A-lA-2A-3A-4A-5A-6A-7A-A-A-IO-11A-12A-13A-14
Viii
I-22s-22S-24A-lA-2A-3A-6A-5
::A-IOA-12A-13A-IS
A-21A-21A-23A-23A-24A-26
-30A-31A-32
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
7/167
OFPHOTO IESELS FORPXECWtVE SUMMARY
tioa eJtMliM8 the role for pbtovola~to rural commonit
nuul Wmmunitia4 mubd ohs world.
lrltivo to hwdpum
r. DetermiItehowtheiniti8lco8tofoPv compare3 with that of ater supply (RWS) system nsing hnndpum~.
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
8/167
::.
2
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
9/167
3. Eatimatt~ the potential market for PV-powered RW OWSLfUn stems ia tlwt PV system9
The threePUw% pv PUarCS, icr amsidet8d ia th corn tive analymis, hMd-
I.
bout 40 liten/upit8/day. U the vilbaodpump, chea two ot man,cofnpowatr am the hradpump ~UX! he wall.b rlsaa aa k supported byThe principd httnagump system
2. tartoonaof
at n bwer mte. Alt+mately,
3
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
10/167
J
.
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
11/167
1..*
2.
3.
, io emmeWest Africao cotmtribI, where wrlb cast
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
12/167
ad Eest Africa)
Tbi8owsisadrtuatlof~5. Sensitivity uwalysiu terdemandsof2Oand4Olpcdbyvaryia~thefollowi* pmmete
1. I fuel cast I/liter. Tbia rtfkcts sihwions here fwl delivery ia dif-frmlt md costly.2.
for&out II Qysofthe3. of the bae-caxe4. Reduction in hndpump life f usedtoenluatetheimpsctoaPV aompetitiveneffs of shorter5. Artdudonir~ ysb Iiftt from20to10ye8rs.6. for PV and diesel systema to tasun wry hi7. Amductbaio 8/hour to wcount for situmtiam wkrewa duea not occur duri
. A reduction in pumps md standpipes to reflect wmter9. pipe to assess he impact of 8
pips rpproximately equal to the cum-SO@ ater abbrysta1q6k0ursperforPvJmddii1
6
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
13/167
..
D UCH TICS
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
14/167
UC nc
0
.
8
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
15/167
ir 6-7 kWh/ma/day, PV would be tbt preferred tech-
ns. A9 in the prorrv#llmttand
for evm rmalbrPV ir competitivees8 occurs at inctsuin~lyExhibit VI rhows wmpetitive tesrwsts, per apitr initial apiaI cola, and wr-etitarunder 8Vt~&3(hSt conditions. When water consumption iramof .44/m8, or rboutY-tor rbout S13.6o/per~oa p8r year. cost is r&out S0.93/mg,
t W&fw Cast Tr+
WP-P 0-1.000 20PlWtovolt8iU 1,ooo - 2,ow 19 - 24biers! w 2.m 6 - IO
tetrtnbbdepthtivity of Pv competiti to a nombsr uf vui-
.
9
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
16/167
0
a
10
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
17/167
D
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
18/167
D
.
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
19/167
l
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
20/167
.
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
21/167
e poputatioa can be served coet effectively by I; tsr rupply systems.preliminuy eStimrof the order of 259AdditbIkd~y, Nda 3s millioa penoar perfor this new pamlotion is ly 10h4wPWyear. 3-hcoaa of PV.Exhibit X shows the uumber of iodiv expected to be served bypumps. PV, and diesel water supply syrt ill continue to serve th*roup. The handpumps will serve mainly ths rhalfow well mukeL1 It should beaoted that the merkct &mattewnce services in Nfdb have a per operatincould likely repExhibits XI and XII show the sensitivity ofcost for 2Q- md 404pcd demand, respectivelyof PVifumMP*113 Mwp.
ges in installed PVcase assumptions. The
Three important coaclwioas emerge from the
2.
ths to be wwed by BUdbIS market segment my further.ter from tu3n-
%ote that he prese didwind power which, ia~sui , miels. A wind technology competltlvenusother pu cr sources such aster mom ly than 3V or dies-beyond the acope of this study.
15
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
22/167
ATER COST VARI ITH PV ARRAY COST
II I
ATER COST VARI RRAY COST
16
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
23/167
IIII b
17
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
24/167
0 .0
18
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
25/167
wffsr; and R.ion by the Waited
1-l
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
26/167
plication, the focm on pumpina technologyter supply syvem.
pdorxrlMct of tJM pumps, PV, and diesels
1. Dttermiw dieselsfor ropplyi viilrgtSiXt, ttr
bOWth8 CoIt of WlY cornSupplY ( w-m tocb such3. Estimlitt the poteatiml ket fat tems.4. .Identify tJbe uactimml sphf.iitiom of PV- red RWS systems 10 that W systemsmaaufrsturen can desi 0 productt to bate1
lbefocuBofth3lilh thiSOR cammuniter soluem.1.3 A
tbc study ruula will8cls lo meet the rtquirtmtatll00 PV murufactwensupply market
n wbo develop prod-A preliminary es-
8f unities ia. I ruwrct
1-2
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
27/167
iaba the jor problems in math
in Appendix A.tt modelII isis
1-3
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
28/167
.
.
.
.
2-l
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
29/167
2.0tld cumatly Irck
priority for both multihttr8l dewmtntr.
8tar
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
30/167
1s 35ii 95040 $520 6590 190
PO 2090 - 2020-wIS = 3015 - 30S-20
2-3
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
31/167
tobeculiedmor8th88 5 liters/
tly convenient tole often revert to
2.2. Wrter Resource,
p. 29.
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
32/167
Ziucond, kcrl ia%titu~au should be sacOuni@d and &V81Oped to 8USUN the IMCIH-saq mana~emcot to iartali aad maintain pumpinfj systems. As the Worldeluded. The h&hut potttatirl for s~taiaability is achisv8d when the corn
nta from commuai
2.4 Cumnt Shtua of Rud Water Supply
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
33/167
. __, .-./ j / I
fouadinA dir A.
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
34/167
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
35/167
3.0
1. f
2.
3-2
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
36/167
3-3
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
37/167
Y
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
38/167
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
39/167
kpump to the awe cow
3.32ieu/B
p. 33.
3-6
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
40/167
I---- l-----l
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
41/167
,v33 OS
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
42/167
7.h
10
1
1 t
3-9
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
43/167
t
II.1
Qi
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
44/167
:
3-11
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
45/167
- I
.
3-12
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
46/167
A key mpand when they
ter supplied daily per person is th8 Wile across rlt three watersupply systems bein8 evaluated. Therefore, the benefit accruing to an iOb ility of water. is the umt across all tcchnologitt.mc es would supply 20 liters per capita per dry to aThe time spent by villrg rthcring the nme sccoss all t. Therefore. the of collec#r. Water collection time is cornter point, and water collection time. Water collec-is the timu spent pumpin the water. in the cas8
ttr collection time is the amount of time spent byter container to fill.1o
iw bvels are attained by usinb 8quipmsnt performao I systems. For exrmp
Also, in the asc of PV,aJ1 hree techno
8 intO ter effort to pump the ter
for VLOM pump for lift3 up to 25 meters. Development of VLOMlifts will k undertaken in the future.
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
47/167
J kn
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
48/167
.2 911)Thi8 procsdura by thWorld I&ink in it3 sternoutlined in Exhibit 4-l btw
fw the ysil fall into th tegor-ie!K
2.
3.
e
4-3
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
49/167
- initial upirrl- uuwiligd apikl cm
with Foimoa input
wifwtybiited.
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
50/167
could include diesel fwl at. PV my c~@t, inrolatioa, pump rfficim-ad o*hr uipawat, Irbr carts, etc.totus I-2-3 Rato wp wDduct theties of tJaemodel is @m
@Lotuswbpment tion, Tatus 1-2-3; Re
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
51/167
S.01.1
ld
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
52/167
TfR
-=Z
I I
PER CAPITA CAPIT COST
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
53/167
:tD.
5-3
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
54/167
U TIC
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
55/167
meten. At lI1
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
56/167
CH CTEA3%TlC
5-6
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
57/167
,.*: . ,
W Life-Cycle Cwt CompctitiwlKu rt 4-OLPCD Comumptioaof iaformatioo Exhibit S-4 for her ter
ter than the al-of 20 lpcd. Vil-on in&&on andh PV is competitive tsoooccurs in ranalter vil ml !
5-7
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
58/167
. 1.
(---1--------*~1~-- #) u mn -----------------1--+
-Ei 22.00 - 0.46 6- 11
tier tin ---~---------I---,1.35 905- 13s: - 0.60
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
59/167
s.4 Chpital Cost of Cost-Compstitiw Water Supply Techno
ia the exhibit.cQnditiom (inlmis 20 lpcd, the ava cost of water from awn8umption lavas l3.b0/pema/year.
The exhibits also ahow that the initial
lady more than hmnd-
0.3s - t:: 2017 - 240.19 - 0.3s 6-9
ll coadithlrr 2Om
5-9
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
60/167
. . . .
\. .;
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
61/167
distribution wtwmrk.%e PV RWS rystam CoIt could8ystem mt
5-11
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
62/167
0 loo0
S-12
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
63/167
Saositivity A flw20LFcBConsumptioa
when villrge size u 8
VILLAOE POPULATION SIZE0 1000 4ooo
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
64/167
titiv
410 LPCOmay
4AT WAlR8 oo(cPeaD.V. YIRY
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
65/167
-
-
p
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
66/167
.5-16
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
67/167
5.7 Let Eatimata for PV RWS Systems
5-17
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
68/167
11
5-18 -
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
69/167
.
5-19
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
70/167
REGIONAndean CountribsCcntml AmericaEquatoriai AfricaEast AfricaFar Eart and PacificIndian SubcontinentLatin America (N.E.C.PMiddle EastSahel
A A B c D EWATER AVERAGE PV POWER VATER NO. OFINSOtAilON GEMAND VILLAGE SIZE SYSTEM DEMAND Me/DAY VILLAGE!KWH/MJ!DAY O-KD) (18 OF PERSONS) SIZE dWp) PER VILLAGE #
5 40 500 1211 m4 43 300 WI? 12 3335 m 1300 1574 26 18462s m fsoo Ml7 30 66635 40 Sal 1211 m!i 40 !500 121 m 740aJ4 40 300 Qou ;2 33334 m luoo 2R25 36 1164376 20 IS00 15. 30 4647Total/Averap 706 1453 22 194128Minimum 300 9011 I2M;~rimum IlttXl 2725 36 a-Notes: A From ma&et potential trtimation table (Exhibit S-101B. Awm p ovillagc sire mngc in Exhibit S -IO.C. Estimated as in column I in Exhibit S-W.D. Villap size times pet capita demand.E. Chtcntial mulation served by PV (column H in Exhibit 2-W/village sko N.E.C. - not clscwh :tc cxmri&rcd
* .- . ..
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
71/167
from I kdepth of to 36 mfhlay ofsrymnis 1.5
5-21
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
72/167
./ _ .
TER COST VARIATION WITH PV ARRAY COST
R COST VARIATION RRAY COST
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
73/167
Smsitivity to tv
5-23
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
74/167
I co
5-24
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
75/167
s.cc
5-25
p.-._. - - -
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
76/167
6.0 co USIONS
es of fewer than I
. 6-l
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
77/167
tiou to providia dpumpa, the ache-obtain other benefits such It mor8 conwajaat tar wurce thxtincrmenmlly for tlrillin
et tables. l-hue nyntemn a with 300 to 2,OUO
A number of importrnt institutional
0
0
expected denund for8upply or inconvenientcommunity resort to usdemand estimate rcill incur uonmunt be educxted oa raspoosibb
useful in educ8tia
relinble mriateof the communl
6-2
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
78/167
.
number of field
6-3
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
79/167
v.---, *- .9 \.. I
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
80/167
. Republic of the Philippiacr,
. J., .
AfWlO8. March 6. 1935.
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
81/167
No. I, Gemvo, I9
R-3
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
82/167
ATER Y ?ION
. . 1
-/
. I
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
83/167
./, \ :
/-..
t --F
I
A-l
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
84/167
,-.. /, /
Al lk?
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
85/167
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
86/167
A.3 Handpumpst common ru
A-3.1 Pump VWTher8 are
pump. Exhibit Aofco
ia.th88 Q Pump forcem of Pump.
to water txbk kve
Tlwforwpumpi8ar
A-4
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
87/167
T
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
88/167
sxpdricxsa in devrlopiavaitrbk from the field,laaintatutQce ia
mxlQtewQc8 ryamn latiwl probkm Whet thrn mhkuu iLQboramfy t8na of pump&!wQducted ill th8 wNDP/World k Hmdpump ProjectI.uK) houn. Field trige there uc I .I failu&own in Exhibit A
I2 - 40 IO - 24 1 Lo
ia Exhibit A-5..
1 6.
-6
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
89/167
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
90/167
ter.* There are y cQmmerc~ly bk systems and moru t arupplied worldwide.term cot&t of a photovolmicpump, rod optional equipment and batteries.is produced. The DC elecinclude power conditioninmry include the convenioa of DCpaemlly aed for iatcrmedirte-ter demand applications.
There are two basic types of water pumtx displrcemeet (volumetric) pumpa rndpumps. The mast commonpirton pump, (jrckpumgl),mmoa motoritsd pumpa thetlw criteria for de&dindepth ofvolume intioprl ir lbowr in Exhibit A-6.
M recommen
dir Nrtioanl
A-8
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
91/167
If d Pum
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
92/167
.
. f
I-
P-rn
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
93/167
r
. .
* I _i,0.I
.$
I//
. .
GW)
.subawrved -mrbk for iatemediatatlum 30 m/dtAy. ofwith nabmerged cant
motor systemsore suit-imdftowsamnkomt8t field rxpetiemrb!o as DC or AC systems. lb8 tread with DC robtnmibks b toemu %tus!rt8ssmmotor design 6om to a brushes DC motor which mctuires brush
l J, A.Y. MC y. hmotml cot8mtuticrtictt. b 1987.Pirud hiMay 44, 1987, p.v-5.
A-11
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
94/167
0
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
95/167
A-13
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
96/167
es of the ICE that
referred for maller
in txisten), the volunw
. . ._ .
.
A-14
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
97/167
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
98/167
.
lowe* fuel-to-puma-set is offset by i QCYtiOQ m Iosses) ofve lity.4.5.3 krfo ct? twisti
.e recent emergence of
roblems and coats in tcr
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
99/167
n
A-%7
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
100/167
25 I.276 S6d Parfo tom
.
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
101/167
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
102/167
cwtl, not including fuel, would*
ter fable 9th ic.sel mping
b J ---- __ . . .
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
103/167
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
104/167
d includes %eservem thecry life is a functio 1%e b cmxmvatively prcity.d Distribution Pipes
ta used for PV- or diesel-
more conven~n
A-22
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
105/167
------ --- __ 0
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
106/167
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
107/167
A.
c.D.E.
F.
J..
L...
0..
Q.s
mot0 P IlQClUn, & OR mtem
irect drive
dud otor [ ix-year.v.
immter-
ter 011 timotes provided by Dr.e trip
except wile noted.
w-25
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
108/167
15
4
.s
1
QB
laes
4
t100
.34
3
3SOF6#
4a
50.
2
.5
0
1
360 3581 30
70 10 0
6 365
8 0 1095
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
109/167
.. tion d gum Il-
c. Direct &iv0 4.5. ted on rt he 0% the
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
110/167
5: 0
0
0
0
0
VI$CI
0
Q
90
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
111/167
A.B.
c.D.
E.
F.6.
Esti :M provided by Dr. Robert Roche,e submersible dc (.-with iaverter) mot0Includes 1.25 for itWallati0~ costsPV Projects, Meridian Co
sets (A.Y.tion of lint nald,tX81
k estimates for Volanpdl d India Mark II handpumps, provided by(Grundfasequivalent
N one tripes show on
R-29. - . -. -- -- .r
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
112/167
3 6 9 12 15 11. 30 30 30 30 302. Pump 20 20 20
__-_-__-_-------_-_-___________eo__p____------------------~-~--------
oa 220.
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
113/167
t./1
.i8 .
6.7.
2 4 61. 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10
a5 25 2s3. oil (9)
meat 20 y----_ -------_--------------------~ ---------~-~-~-------~-------~ -----~-~Resent Worthof Items 1-7 5s 170.
RR 0 I 30. POPmail)
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
114/167
. _
/ .-
6- (A)hOUE3hOUC31.5
Components
L_ i370xo-6 C)
1825 hours3.
./ .l ,/
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
115/167
. SYSTEM CONFIGURATIONS.
Deep WellComponentsz CIESELENGINE
Failure Rate:System Failure:
520x 10-* (C)2346~JO-~hourshours
.
'
A. UNDP/Worid Bank Handpump Project laboratory endu nce tests. Average of pumptested. Data supplied by Dr. Robert Roche, World Bank.B. Module failure rates are on the order o f I - 1.5 x IQ-6 (&unders, John, T)re Con-
atrator Option. ,June/luly 1984). Calculatednents) due in part to redundaIIel connections.C. lure rate data estimates based on: p D. W., G. M. Pittler, R. E. Shelton, etReliability Prediction and Demot&d round Electronic Equipment. Tech-Report No. RADC-TR-68-280, elogment Center, Griffiss Air ForceB New York, December. 1%8; ircmft Company, Nonelectric ReliabilityNotebook. Technical Report No. RAJX-m-75-22, Xome Air Development Center,Griffiss Air Force Base, New York, Jauuary 1975.
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
116/167
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
117/167
.I\
.\ ,./ ;/
description of the Lotus prog s @SUM. @VLCIQKUP, @SQRT, @IF,for R description of these functions.
er point (per hour)
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
118/167
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
119/167
-3
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
120/167
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
121/167. . \
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
122/167
,-. \-
, . .,
. _I : .
B-6
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
123/167
. ,1 , w, * _ r I , . :I,, -. *- < r- C c . - ,I*
,,/: _ / 1\ _ I\ 1. _ '.' \ .,- _ . .I 'i: '.j__~._ --
.
e nt f Cer VW dter over
=(
/ Y , I
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
124/167
I
. ,- - _.._ -..
wo t each ti!3 tern with Poison input andnen rvice, tion
(loads/hour) ,LOA
Arrival (trips/ht) /-X PLOADUSEHXS .Collct/NP (min/trip) VLRATIE),CMlct/SP (mia/trip) P
Total time/SF (min/l)An iterative procedure is
ximum number served
ximum num
iven byLO
ndpump ZL.2))
VE
No. of wclh f8 ed with no
+0.9)) e
e
.-.-Y.* . . . : , , / I; / ,;
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
125/167
I . . .,- *.---$ ~ \, ) ,, - ~\, - / J r;-, .y -.-.. , . , . . , - - : .; *.. /. :- ,_--- -
No. of wells needed ifDiesel uued more ho/ I.
n/dw diesel
Storage volume (mJ)
Number of wells required W./ONumber of wells tequircd
-+
= 4-P
inso:. hn)LNO 9
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
126/167
. ;
,I-
0.
B4
b
I.
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
127/167
-.;
PV y cost ($9 = @IF(K=
Well cost ($9
GV ELSEE)
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
128/167
. - _I : . /.
1,a , ,> , .. X * li
i #,I/ .: : , . ,. 1
.
, .: ,,- . . . ; . J:- __ _ ::*. .-;7 ;- ::
dwmv@II
Civil work cast (
PV
B-12
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
129/167
Pump cost (
Civil work cast (
Ihtttry CWt ($/y ) - +BAlTERPV hat. COst @/yeFump O&M cost (
To a cost (S/year)
L.l)@
B-13
,
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
130/167
-
D
.
.
=a
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
131/167
//
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
132/167
HERIDIAG CORPORATIONPARATIVE EVALUATIOW OF WATER SUPPLY SYSTEMS
PS US. PV PUMPS VS. DIESEL PFOR
RURAL WAlER SUPPLY APRIL 7, 1987-.--_.__---__-._._.-___________________ _--------.-.----..-.-.---.---.--.-.-.---.-.INPUT DATA
STAI'dDPIPE USE ~FFICIEWCY
.--.-"_-_-.--..---.-.----CAPITAL COSTS - PV P
LPCD 5 #ka1!/#2/DAY - MIA20 LPCD
::iiLPCD 10HOURSS/HA f iiHOURTRIP 2:HOURS ;13/HR
-_-----------_-.-__________________p ARRAY9.00500 7.751000 7.50 BASED ON DIESEL PUMP>I000 7.25
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
133/167
VA
: ::
I:
: I
;: :: :
.
;
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
134/167
.
I, :
c-3
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
135/167
.\ . 1/ 6 .; - ,,. ----,- _/. --
wNnNBhwtnQ-w~wNhomwP-f-O-.-NO~-wwww. . . . . . . * . . . . . . .eu-Qw0wcnmh0whOnwNmnwwmmwwhhP=.QQQ
m .n
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
136/167
. .
3403503603703803904001042043040ix470
5005105205305405505605705805906006lQr6:ti630640650660670680690700710728730740750760770
130.38132.29134.16136.01137.84139.64141.42143.18144.91146.63148.Z.2150.00151.66153.30154.92156.52158.11159.69161.25162.79164.32165.83167.33168.82170.29171.76173.21
198.89180.28181.66
187.08188.4189.7191.05192.35193.65194.94196.21
2.612.652.682.722.762.792.832.862.902.932.973.003.033.073.103
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
137/167
,
C-6
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
138/167
SlZE DF POPU: SERVE0 PtO. OF NO. OFST WELLS WELLSNEEDED NEEDED DIESELPER DIESEL IF DIESEL HRS/DAY ENGINEOE USE LIFELPCO DIESEL YEARS-----------------_--____________________------------------------ --_-__--___-______--____________________------28 1 110 360 fi i! i 5.00 105.00 101 1 1 5.006 13.20 : : t 5.00 ii11.60 57.60 5.00 10: :! 1 ! 1 5.00.00 IOO
-------__---_-___-_-----------*-----------------------------------~------------------------------------.------------~-----
7ERES
4
- _____ _ _ ___________________ ~
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
139/167
CONFlClJRATlONS
T:i OAlLt ENERGY P USEREQUIRED S/DAYNT D BATTERY SPEAKKUtl/DAY L. HRS)--------------------_____D______________------------------------------------------------------- m-v-.--20 1 7 1 : 2.73 5.45 0.61 5.00
!i:
10.90.45 21.800.90 2.42.21 5.00.00: 16.35 32.70 .63 5.008
121.80 43.60 .84 5.00
:8 ?? : 27.25 109.004.50 12.11.06 5.00.00-------------o------------------------------------.*------------------------------------------.----.--
PW-BATTERY EMT SIZES. DF T UNIT UNITPE ATER Ep PW ARRAY BATTERYIbw SlS K-mm "----------le"-------------------------------~--------------------------------
20 B 606 128:
256 1:2180 512173 I 768 f :1024
:: 10900 :i 12111056 2561281 1;:_-----__--------------------------------------------------------------------------
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
140/167
PONEldT SIZESINALPUPIP STORAGE DIESEL PIPINGSZZE WOLUPlE ENGIN LEWGTKW w3 K---e---rmwe-we _--____-___-_--____-_______________o____-----------------
20 1 0.3s 7 3 1280.781.57 3 25651238 4 1E1281:o 1:: 10 2561
_-__-__---_-------_---------*-----------~-------------------------------
l7& CAPITAL COSTS OF HA
68 6560 :x 16400203
-__--_-_-_--_-_---_-----------------------------
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
141/167
: Ia. 0
.CY* I **IOF PER CAPITAPS CAPITAL COST
\ . . . Y .- i. :IS .
TOTA: PW SYSTEf I COST ($---"------""""""""""""""""""""" """"""""""""""""""""""" """""""""""""""""""""""""""""20 1 5000 1679$716573 9966 5000 258629931 5000 406969897 5of.w 548969863 5000 687689829 5000 8243099657 5000 149073--"""""*"""""~""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""--"-------------------------
BE
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
142/167
I / .._
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
143/167
HO. OFPER CAP. ATER P STORAGE DIESEL PIPING STANDPIPE ELL TOTAL?OIsJTS COST COST COST COST COST COST SYSTEM# I $ I I f S COST (S)""""""""""""""""."""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""-"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""20 : 1633 2683 5720 768 150 5003 15955
1741 3795 5720 1537 300 5000 180921957 5367 5720 3073 600f 2389173 6573589 5960720 6147610 120000lo 3685605 12000485 62004co 15367683 3000500
~~.~~~~~~~~~~
8 10:t t_
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
144/167
UALlZED COSTS OF HA P SYSTEPER ATER ii TOTALDE INT COST/YEAR
""""""-""""""""""""""""""-""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""20 1 133 587 17367 1175 346 I:8 la9i534 234 692 200 3775801 35? 1038 56628 1068 469 1384 0": 7550:8 2669335 5873 3460730 100000 18875437
""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""AVER :OLlECI;O
t-3IE COSTO/YEAR S/YEAR""""I""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""-""""20 1f 00 t
ii ii 0"
:: 0 x""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
145/167
i .
VOT KT COSTS OF
D TS SYST !ES)Cl
T!z """"""""""""""""""""_____D______ """""""""""""""""2 1 253 357s:i11 199 332 538 5975299 207 756 7976223 97 99621 756 238 118 119212E 1069 5186 997 315 2232 21504""""""""""""""""""""_________________o__""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
146/167
a.&--m3
:I
: :,
C-15
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
147/167
TOT IT COSTS OF P TTEWV P S?STI
?lV4CO:>I COST
P SVSTKM1
n COST COST COSTL
--
COSTO --~ *
20 ii 231 ii 85231231 K23191 ! 162
:181 1705
t :: 26331 1~~.~~~~~~~~-.-
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
148/167
IT COSTS OF 'lIESE1 P SYSTEMS
PERDEOFiTER PER CAPITA PEINT
""""""I""""""""""""""""""- """""""""""""""""""""20 : 13.85 1.90.62 1.044 .44 0.61x 3.35.83 C.46.39
:oo 2.52.87 0.34.26I.
. .
20 LITERS PER C YnIw-ASYST;SELECTED (PV) (DIESEL)""""""""""~""""""""i"""""""" """""""""""""""""""I"""""""""""""""""""""
1 110ii :: 1.181.181.18660 :: 1.1853: 1.18:8 1.18.18
: 720 i BATTERYATTERY 1 :1440 28 8ATTERY t2160 25 i: BATTERY :28803600 :: 10 BATTERY
I
7:oo 21 t BATTERY :BATTERY f 1~-_______________I____~------------
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
149/167
_ ,/
, I
ANALYS
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
150/167
.0.:
0.8
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
.
COST OF WATER--
l-
, -.-
WELL COST: $500DEPTH: 5 mDWAND: 20 lpcd
I I 1 i II I
D-l
. -
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
151/167
,/
!- .
.
--
-_
.
.
DEPTH: 20 mOEHAND: 20 lgicd
Y3236to24D261s 1?I -i141216
a i
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
152/167
. I
I,.-I ,
ELL COST: $l,WODEPTH: 20 mDEfflNO: 40 lpcd
w
?h
1.2
1.1
1
0224
0.0
0.7
0.8
as
0.4
u
0.20
0 w/4 + w/s
PER CAPITA CAPITAL C
P
I,-.. - .. ..-
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
153/167
- -_
-A_
4
-
PER CAPITA CAP!--ALs.0sa.uc30282B2422201116141210
WELL COST: 02,500DEPTH: 20 m
D-5
./ ---
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
154/167
:I .,.- .-
ELL COST: X2,500DETTH: 20 mDEfW'iD: SC lpc3
0 04
0 4 Q
O-6
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
155/167
-- ---,
- -I -- ,,-. ,g
Q.1
0 L
WSLL COST: $5,000OEPTH: 20 mDERANO: 20 lpcd
0 2 4
w/4 + w/rJ
ER CAPITX
D-7d-- ~2/-. _-- /l
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
156/167
/ : -1,I-.
,
ELL COST: $5,000DEPTH: 20 mDEbtAND: 40 lpcd
PER CAPlTA C
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
157/167
,,: , I: _ --. _ i -_ ,*I , -/ i
WELL COST: $5,000DEPTH: 40 mDEMAND: 20 lpcd1.2
1.1
1
0.0
OS
a7
0.0
0.5
9.4
0.S
0.2
0.1
0
ER CAPlTA C
D-9
/ !,
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
158/167
WELL COST: $5,000DEPTH: 40 mDEMAND: 40 lpcd
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
159/167
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
160/167
George RhodesPlbuquerqua,Jlack and Weatcb
bonneville Power Adcrtlanb. OR 99208h Bunkernternational PrograRural Elec. Cd6sachllsettsgton, DC 200Xdlifornia Energy Co iesion
al/Poly Universityttn: A. Dickerson09
enter for Engr.
Puerto Rico 00908ropoulo
.
Dlst-2
LightY~hn Hoffarer0. Box 108890969Cleveland State Wniversityttn: Peter P. POYountain College
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
161/167
I _.. .9- .--. y c - I_- -.- .T.-. ,
,& ..
. ontrol0.
Dfst-3
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
162/167
, I-- ,,. ,
I- ,i . I
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
163/167
. . I
, ,> ,_
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
164/167
D. olliarento.A5852-B
Dit-6,- - .
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
165/167
I/
.,, .
.A--4
. -:--_. . .__* . .---
uthority (2)
--
Dist-7
# .
I -
,/ _ . t
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
166/167
C 7, - - --. -. _--- ,: _-- -,.: - -
-
8/2/2019 Comparative Assessment Photovoltaics Handpumps Diesels Rural Water Supply 1987B
167/167
.