Cluster Report ‘Climate, Energy and Mobility’
ERA-LEARN, Discussion paper
15.05.2019
Tour de Table
ERA-LEARN Thematic Analysis
Page 2
first-name LAST-NAME BADGE/TABLE which-networks-and-initiatives-are-you-representing
Lucie BEAUMEL GREEN VEHICLES INITIATIVE European Green Vehicles Initiative Association
Beata BIBROWSKA JPI URBAN EUROPE JPI URBAN EUROPE
Karen BÖHME JPI URBAN EUROPE JPI Urban Europe, EXPAND, SUGI
Jonas BYLUND JPI URBAN EUROPE JPI Urban Europe
Almudena CARRERO ACT,ERA.MIN, ERA4CS, AXIS, GEOTHERMIA, SOLAR ERANET, BIODIVERSCEN,
Evelyn ECHEVERRIA German Federal Ministry of Research and Innovation, NKS-Umwelt
Jan-Arne EILERTSEN ERA-LEARN ERA-LEARN
Michael ERDMANN EUROFUSION EUROfusion Coordinator Unit
Hans Arne FRØYSTEIN EURAMET/ EMPIR EURAMET eV and EMPIR
Emilia GENANGELI EUROFUSION EUROfusion Administration
Enrique GIRON CLEAN HYDROGEN Clean Hydrogen
Charles GIRY-DELOISON JPI CULTURAL HERITAGE JPI Cultural Heritage
Ken GUY
Maurice HANEGRAAF TNO
Angus HUNTER ERA-LEARN ERA-LEARN
Christophe JOST OCEANERA-NET OCEANERA-NET Cofund
Karoliina KOHO BANOS CSA BANOS CSA
Carina LEMKE FORESTVALUE ForestValue
Bruno MASTANTUONO CLEAN SKY JU Clean Sky JU
Angels ORDUNA-CAO SPIRE CPPP SPIRE cPPP
Ragnhild RØNNEBERG ERA NET ACT ERA NET ACT (Accellerating CCS technologies)
Julija SAKOVICA
Helen SPENCE-JACKSON EIT-KIC CLIMATE EIT Climate KIC
Piotr SWIATEK Team drafting Co-Funded Partnerhip in HUE Cluster 4
Mª Ángeles VALBUENA
Chris YOUNG BESTF / DEMOWIND BESTF and DemoWind ERA-NETs
Eleni ZIKA BBI JU Biobased Industries Joint Undertaking
Background
Partnership analyses in relation to the cluster ‘Climate, Energy and Mobility’ under Pillar II “Global Challenges and Industrial Competitiveness” of Horizon Europe (Commission proposal):
ERA-LEARN Thematic Analysis
Page 3
The intervention areas of the cluster ‘Climate,
Energy and Mobility’:
▬ Climate science and solutions
▬ Energy supply
▬ Energy systems and grids
▬ Buildings and industrial facilities in energy
transition
▬ Communities and cities
▬ Industrial competitiveness in transport
▬ Clean transport and mobility
▬ Smart mobility
▬ Energy storage
The cluster includes 52 fully relevant
partnerships, networks or governance
structures:
▬ 26 P2Ps (21 ERA-NET Cofunds, 2 JPIs, 2 EJP
Cofunds, 1 Art 185 initiative)
▬ 2 cPPPs
▬ 5 Art 187
▬ 9 ETIPs
▬ 6 ETPs
▬ 3 EIT-KICs
▬ 1 EIPs
Overview current networks and governance structures
ERA-LEARN Thematic Analysis
Page 4
▬ large variety of partnerships
(only omission is FET
Flagships).
▬ most populated area is
‘energy supply’ - broad
range of partnership types.
▬ least populated area is
‘buildings and industrial
facilities in energy
transition’.
▬ ERA-NET Cofunds are
more frequent in the climate
and energy sub-clusters.
▬ The mobility sub-cluster is
dominated by A187s and
ETPs.
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Climate science andsolutions
Energy supply Energy systems andgrids
Buildings andindustrial facilities in
Energy Transition
Communities andCities
IndustrialCompetitiveness in
Transport
Clean transport andmobility
Smart mobility Energy Storage
Nr. and Type of Fully Relevant Networks per Intervention Area
ERIC
EIP
ETP/ETIP
ERA-NET Cofund
JPI
EJP
FET
cPPP
EIT
A185
A187
Overview current partnerships related to the interventions areas
ERA-LEARN Thematic Analysis
Page 5
▬ Two of the nine intervention
areas (climate science and
solutions, energy supply)
have a relatively high
concentration of
partnerships
▬ Significant number of
partnerships that are cross-
cutting (links to at least two
intervention areas)
▬ A187 ECSEL, EIP Smart
Cities & Communities and
JPI Urban Europe are the
most cross-cutting
Connections between partnerships and networks to the sub-cluster ‘Climate’
ERA-LEARN Thematic Analysis
Page 6
Formal Connection:
Several JPIs and their
associated Cofunds
Existing collaboration:
Lack of evidence of
collaboration between
partnerships that appear to
have some synergy
CLIMATE
P2Ps PPPs
Article 185EMPIRPRIMA
ERA-NET CofundACTAXIS
EN-SUGIERA4CS
ERA-PLANETFACCE ERA-GAS
Waterworks2015Waterworks2017
SC5-21-2019-2020LC-SFS-20-2019
SFS-31-2019LC-CLA-09-2019
JPIClimateFACCE
Urban EuropeWater
EIPSmart Cities and
Communities
Water
Art. 187CleanSky2
ECSELFCH
cPPPEeBEGVI
ETIP/ETPETP WssTP
ETIP ZEP
EIT-KICClimate
ERICECCSEL
LifeWatch
EMSOICOS
Eur-Argo
FET
EJP
Connections between partnerships and networks to the sub-cluster ‘Energy’
ERA-LEARN Thematic Analysis
Page 7
Formal Connection:
JPI Urban Europe and its
Cofunds
Existing collaboration:
Geothermica ERA-NET Cofund
is represented on the Steering
Board of ETIP Deep
Geothermal
ENERGY
P2Ps PPPs
Article 185EMPIR
ERA-NET CofundACT
BESTF3
CSP ERANETDemowind
Demowind2ENSCC
EN-SUGIERANet SmartGridPlus
EN SGplusRegSysGEOERA
GEOTHERMICAOCEAN-ERA-NET Cofund
SOLAR-ERA.NET CofundSolar Cofund2
LC-SC3-ES-9-2019
JPIUrban Europe
EIPSmart Cities and
Communities
Art. 187ECSELFCH
cPPPEeBFoF
ETIPBioenergy
Deep Geothermal
OceanPhotovoltaics PV Sec
RHCSNET
SNETPWind
ZEP
EIT-KICInnoEnergy
ERICECCSEL
EJPCONCERT
EUROfusion
FET
Coordinating
influence of
the SET-Plan
Connections between partnerships and networks to the sub-cluster ‘Mobility’
ERA-LEARN Thematic Analysis
Page 8
Formal Connection:
JPI Urban Europe and its
Cofunds
Art. 187s and cPPPs that were
derived from their associated
ETPs
Existing collaboration:
JPI Urban Europe and JPI
Climate have collaborated (with
NORFACE) to implement T2S
(ERA-NET Cofund on
‘transformations to
sustainability’)
MOBILITY
P2Ps PPPs
Article 185AAL2
EMPIR
ERA-NET CofundEMEurope
ENSCCENSUF
EN-SUGIERANet SmartGridPlus
EN SGplusRegSysT2S
MG-4-6-2019
JPIUrban Europe
Climate
EIPActive and Healthy Aging
Raw Materials
Smart Cities and Communities
Art. 187CleanSky2
ECSELFCH
SESARShift2Rail
cPPPFoF
EGVI
ETPACAREALICE
ERRACERTRAC
Waterborne
EIT-KICInnoEnergy
Urban Mobility
FET
EJP
ERIC
Main observations and questions
Main observations:
▬ All types of partnerships/networks (apart from FET Flagships) are represented in this Cluster
▬ With some notable exceptions, the apparent level of connectivity between the various networks and partnerships
is weak.
▬ Apart from the energy sub-cluster (where the coordinating influence of the SET-Plan is apparent), the
connections between the P2P and non-P2P world are limited.
Questions to consider:
▬ What is the level of synergy, cooperation and engagement between JPI Climate, the Climate KIC and other
partnerships that are aimed at reducing climate impacts
▬ Are there any frameworks (like the SET-Plan) that could foster more collaborative activity between the P2Ps and
the other partnerships/networks in the mobility areas
▬ What would be the benefits of strengthening cooperation between partnerships/networks that appear to have
synergies
▬ What are the main barriers to collaboration between partnerships that have synergetic objectives, activities
and/or stakeholders and the critical enabling factors for such collaboration
ERA-LEARN Thematic Analysis
Page 9
Thank you.
Session 1: Conclusions
▬Are there any important aspects missing in the Discussion Paper?
▬What have been the main strengths and achievements of the existing partnership
landscape?
▬What have been the main challenges?
ERA-LEARN Thematic Analysis
Page 11
Session 2: Guiding Questions
Past and current experiences
▬ What kind of interactions did/do you have with other (P2P, PPP) networks and which are these networks?
▬ How did/does this contribute to achieving your partnership’s objectives and/or improve performance?
Ideas for future developments
▬ What are the challenges of the new partnership proposal?
▬ How could cooperation between different types of partnerships be improved to support the reformation of the
partnership landscape?
▬ How can your partnership contribute to increase coherence in the partnership landscape?
▬ Which actions need to be taken? By whom?
ERA-LEARN Thematic Analysis
Page 12