Download - Bio Fuel Production - FSU
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
Bio Fuel Production
Reference: Donald L. Klass, Biomass for Renewable Energy, Fuels and Chemicals, Academic Press, 1998.
http://www.energy.kth.se/compedu/webcompedu/media/Lecture_notes/S1B11C2.pdf
http://www.energy.kth.se/compedu/webcompedu/media/Lecture_notes/BiomassCombustionStudyPack.pdf
Source: Miroslav Petrov @ KTH
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
Conversion Methods
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
Fuel from the Forest?
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
Gasifiers Types
Source: Ohlström M. et al. “New concepts for biofuels in transportation”, VTT research notes 2074, Technical Research Center of Finland, Espoo 2001.
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
NG-based or Wood-based MethanolSynthetic methanol from natural gas or biomass:
Source: Ohlström M. et al. “New concepts for biofuels in transportation”, VTT research notes 2074, Technical Research Center of Finland, Espoo 2001.
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
Steam Reforming and Water-Gas-Shift
Gas mixture for fuel synthesis (syngas) can be produced from hydrocarbon reforming with steam, or from biomass gasification (preferably oxygen-blown gasification to avoid the presence of inert nitrogen).
steam-methane reforming: CH4 + H2O CO + 3H2 (very endothermic)
The product gas is in reality a mixture of CO, CO2, H2, water vapours, and traces of reactants. It has a high energy value.
Product gas from biomass gasification needs to be enriched with hydrogen to the required molar ratio CO/H2 for the methanation reaction to proceed. This is done by the “water-gas-shift” reaction, where a certain part of the CO in the product gas is sacrificed to produce H2.
water-gas-shift reaction: CO + H2O CO2 + H2 (slightly exothermic)
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
Methanol Synthesis
The syngas after the water-gas-shift reaction is fed to the methanol reactor vessel, where on the surface of catalysts the CO and CO2 react with H2 to form CH3OH mixed with water, also denoted as MeOH.
The methanol is then distilled out, which is an energy demanding process.
methanol synthesis: CO + 2H2 CH3OH (exothermic)CO2 + 3H2 CH3OH + H2O (slightly exothermic)
If hydrogen from additional source is added to the process, so that carbon is not sacrificed to produce hydrogen, the methanol yield can be doubled.
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
Problems with Methanol FuelMethanol is a perfect fuel for gasoline (Otto) engines or gas turbines. However, there are several major disadvantages with it:
• Very toxic
• Good solvent dilutes old deposits in the fuel system and washes them to the engine, destroys rubber hoses/gaskets/seals…
• Corrosive to certain steels
• Lower energy per mass/volume ratio compared to gasoline ( ~ two times lower energy value)
• Difficult cold start of the engine due to low vapour pressure
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
Dimethyl-ether
Dimethyl ether (DME), CH3OCH3, is a perfect fuel for diesel engines, allowing for high-efficiency energy conversion with very low pollution levels. DME is gaseous at normal conditions, but is a liquid at 6 bar pressure, similar to LPG (propane/butane). The absence of a direct C-C chemical bond in the molecule allows for clean combustion with very low CO emissions and almost without soot formation.
DME synthesis reaction: 2CH3OH CH3OCH3 (exothermic)
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
DME synthesisDME yield and conversion efficiency for a hypothetic DME production plant in Sweden, based on biomass gasification:
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
Fischer-Tropsch Reactions
Source: Mozaffarian, M., Zwart, R.W.R. “Feasibility of biomass/ waste-related SNG production technologies”, report nr: ECN-C--03-066, Dutch Ministry of Economic Affairs, 2003.
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
Methanation Reactions
Source: Mozaffarian, M., Zwart, R.W.R. “Feasibility of biomass/ waste-related SNG production technologies”, report nr: ECN-C--03-066, Dutch Ministry of Economic Affairs, 2003.
(exothermic reactions)
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
Avoiding Formation of Pure Carbon
Source: Mozaffarian, M., Zwart, R.W.R. “Feasibility of biomass/ waste-related SNG production technologies”, report nr: ECN-C--03-066, Dutch Ministry of Economic Affairs, 2003.
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
Biomass Pyrolysis
• Pyrolysis is the direct conversion of biomass to liquid (termed bio-oilor bio-crude), solid and gaseous fractions, by heating the biomass in absence of air to around 500°C
• Optimized fast pyrolysis (flash pyrolysis) can be used to produce predominantly bio-oil, enabling the conversion of biomass to liquid biofuel with an efficiency of up to 75%.
• The problems are the very unstable structure of the bio-oil, its water content, and certain corrosive activity.
C10H14O6 + heat energy aCO + bCxHy + cCnHmOq + dC gas partly condensible char residue
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
Biomass Pyrolysis Process
crushing<8 mm
drying< 10 % Heating
~ 1 s~ 500 C
Combustion of CO and char residue
Condensa-tion of productgases
Product: 60 -70 % per initialenergy and mass content
particle separation
Residues from the forest industries: wood chips, sawdust, bark, etc...
heat
FORESTERA™ - pyrolysis reactor
gases
non-condensiblegases
heat
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
SolvolysisSolvolysis, followed by catalytic hydrotreatment, is another thermochemical method, aiming at the direct production of liquid hydrocarbons of higher quality than the pyrolysis oil.
The solvolysis process comprises simple dissolving of the wood in acidified organic solvents, at certain temperature and pressure. After that the solvent is evaporated under vacuum and recycled.
Water generated during the solvolysis is also evaporated. The solvolysisproduct is very viscous and has about 22% O2 content. It is then subjected to catalytic hydrotreatment (hydrodeoxyge-nation) at about 350-370oC under pressurised H2 atmosphere.
The final product is composed of a mixture of hydrocarbons with very low oxygen content, the heavy fractions prevailing. Further development and optimization of the process is necessary.
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
Biogas production
Source: Mozaffarian, M., Zwart, R.W.R. “Feasibility of biomass/ waste-related SNG production technologies”, report nr: ECN-C--03-066, Dutch Ministry of Economic Affairs, 2003.
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
Farm-scale Biogas Plant
Source: Nordic Folkecenterfor Renewable Energy, Kammersgaardsvej 16, 7760 Hurup Thy, Denmark.
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
Biogas YieldTypically around 50-60% of the initial energy content in the material will be converted to biogas in a well-designed and properly operated digester. The resultant product gas mixture consists of CH4 (60-65%), CO2 (the rest), and small amounts of water vapours, H2S, NH3, and some organics that give bad odour. The gas is a ready fuel for stationary CHP boilers or piston engines, but should be cleaned and upgraded to minimum 95% methane if used as automotive fuel.
Source: Nordic Folkecenter for Renewable Energy, Kammersgaardsvej 16, 7760 Hurup Thy, Denmark.
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
Biogas Yield from Various Bio-material
Unofficial figures for typical average biogas yield from various biowaste types
Source: Nordic Folkecenterfor Renewable Energy, Kammersgaardsvej 16, 7760 Hurup Thy, Denmark.
For CH4
1Nm3 ~10.54 kWh
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
Biogas Production Example
Source: Nordic Folkecenter for Renewable Energy, Kammersgaardsvej 16, 7760 Hurup Thy, Denmark.
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
Biogas Production ExampleThree different digester cases for different raw material mixtures:
Source: Nordic Folkecenter for Renewable Energy, Kammersgaardsvej 16, 7760 Hurup Thy, Denmark.
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
Horizontal Biogas DigesterThe typical horizontal biogas digester for smaller-scale applications:
Source: Nordic Folkecenter for Renewable Energy, Kammersgaardsvej 16, 7760 Hurup Thy, Denmark.
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
Vertical biogas digesterVertical biogas digesters are usually used for larger-scale centralized biogas plants:
Source: Nordic Folkecenterfor Renewable Energy, Kammersgaardsvej 16, 7760 Hurup Thy, Denmark.
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
Biogas from agricultural productsFresh grass can be digested for biogas production together with organic wastes:
Crops
Organic residues
Quality control and separation of unwanted material
Outsortedmaterial
Sterilizing at 70 oC for 1 hour
Pretreatment, mixing, and separation of inert material
Sand, etc.
Biogas to cars and buses
Cleaning & upgrading of biogas to fuel quality
Digestion at 37 oC for 20 days
Biogas from sewage treatment
Surplus gas to heat and power generation
Sludge to the fields as fertilizer
Crops
Organic residues
Quality control and separation of unwanted material
Outsortedmaterial
Sterilizing at 70 oC for 1 hour
Pretreatment, mixing, and separation of inert material
Sand, etc.
Biogas to cars and buses
Cleaning & upgrading of biogas to fuel quality
Digestion at 37 oC for 20 days
Biogas from sewage treatment
Surplus gas to heat and power generation
Sludge to the fields as fertilizer
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
Upgrading of Biogas Quality
Scrubbing of acidic gases (H2S):
• Dry oxidation process – adding air in the biogas to oxidise the hydrogen sulphide to elementary sulphur;
• Adsorption using iron oxides;
• Liquid phase oxidation process: physical absorption by solvents (NaOH), or chemical absorption and forming or precipitates (FeCl3).
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
Upgrading of Biogas Quality
Scrubbing of CO2:
Physical absorption – using water at high pressures;
Chemical absorption – using mono-ethanolamines (MEA) or alkaline solutions;
Adsorption on solid surfaces – using silica, alumina, activated carbon, etc.;
•Membrane separation;
•Cryogenic separation;
•Chemical conversion method.
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
Ethanol Energy
Source: Michael Wang, Argonne National Laboratory
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
Starch and Sugar based feedstock: Corn and Barley and food processing waste streams such as potato and brewery waste
Cellulosic feedstock: Agricultural crop residues, forestry wood wastes, mill residues, urban wood waste, paper manufacturing wastes, waste paper and energy crops.
Cellulosic biomass ethanol provides about four units of energy for every unit of fossil fuel energy used to produce it – a significantly higher ratio than for other renewable fuels, such as corn ethanol. The large positive net energy balance for cellulosic biomass ethanol compared to corn ethanol is due to the fact that relatively little fossil energy is used in the creation of cellulosic biomass and in the biomass to ethanol conversion process. However, unlike starch based crops, such as corn, this biomass waste is often burned (ethanol production solves this problem), and does not have market value other than as feedstock for energy production. In addition, biomass resources such as wood waste, and certain dedicated biomass ethanol crops (such as switch grass) are not nearly as energy intensive to produce as starch crops.
Ethanol Production
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
Ethanol Production via FermentationMicroorganisms responsible for ethanol production are facultative, i.e. they can grow with or without oxygen. These are of the saccharomyces type, similar to common yeast cultures.
The ethanol-producing process is actually anaerobic, where fermentable carbon sources (hexose/pentose sugars like glucose/fructose) are oxidised, and excess electrons are transferred to organic acceptor molecules instead of to oxygen. Ethanol is thereby produced as a waste product instead of water.
If air is allowed to enter the fermentation process in sufficient quantities, the microbial metabolism will switch to aerobic (more efficient) process, and ethanol production will stop.
Thus, microorganisms produce ethanol when growth parameters do not support an oxidative metabolic process, thereby requiring a less efficient pathway resulting in ethanol as a waste product.
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
Ethanol from Complex Sugars
Starch (a glucose polymer) must be broken down into simple sugars - maltose and glucose - before the fermentation process can be applied. This can be accomplished by microorganisms of the amylases type, which are produced by the germinating seeds during malting of barley, or added artificially in fungal form. This is the way to produce ethanol from cereals, corn, potatoes, etc.
Cellulose and its derivatives (also a glucose polymer) can also be broken down into simple sugars, however with some difficulties. Lignin remains as a residue. The cellulose can be treated by twomain methods: acid hydrolysis and enzymatic hydrolysis. Acid hydrolysis is a well-developed method, however expensive, low-efficient and polluting. Enzymatic hydrolysis is promising, but needs further development and cost reduction.
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
Integrated Ethanol ProductionThe IBUS concept from Elsam A/S in Denmark:
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
Ethanol from Agricultural CropsEthanol can be produced from starch via the following process:
wheatmilling
Water and enzymes
yeastcarbon dioxide
Malting and saccharifi-cation
Fermen-tation
Ethanol 99.5%
absolutisation distillation Fodder drying
Fodder for animals
wheatmilling
Water and enzymes
yeastcarbon dioxide
Malting and saccharifi-cation
Fermen-tation
Ethanol 99.5%
absolutisation distillation Fodder drying
Fodder for animals
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
Ethanol Production Steps
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
Breaking Complex SugarsLiquefaction and saccharification of cellulose into C5-C6 sugars, which can undergo fermentation:
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
Cellulose Ethanol Production
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
Ethanol as Automotive FuelEthanol is a perfect fuel for Otto engines and gas turbines. There are though some small problems, like:
• Difficult cold start of the engine due to low vapour pressure,
• Might be aggressive to certain steels and rubbers,
• Energy per mass/volume ratio lower than gasoline, but slightly better than methanol!
The Brazilian example The Brazilian example –– fuel from sugar cane: fuel from sugar cane:
• 5x106 ha of sugar cane production 24.106 t of sugar and 14x106 m3 of ethanol
• 4 million cars driving on pure ethanol, the rest of the countryfleet uses gasoline with 24% ethanol mixed in it
• 600 000 direct jobs related to ethanol production (from agriculture to final fuel distribution)
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
Vegetable Oils
Vegetable oils (plant oils) are a ready liquid fuel produced by nature, replacement to fossil diesel.
They can be directly extracted from the seeds of the oil-producing plants by simple extraction methods:
• Cold pressing followed by filtration, or
• Warm pressing followed by extraction by organic solvents (methanol, gasoline, etc.) and purification.
Examples of plants with high oil content are: oil palm, sunflower, canola (raps), soy, peanuts, linseed, hemp, jojoba, and many others.
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
The Oil Palm
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
Oil Palm Plantations
Source: Fedepalma - Colombia
World production of palm oil – thousands of hectares:
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
Palm Oil Extraction Process
Source: www.fao.org
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
12991012121019olives
12789311901000rapeseed
1248731163978opium poppy
1137951059890peanuts
1107711026863cocoa (cacao)
102714952800sunflowers
100705940790tung oil tree
83585779655safflower
74522696585sesame
61430572481mustard seed
57402536450coriander
57401534449pumpkin seed
56393524440euphorbia
51362482405hazelnuts
51359478402linseed (flax)
US gal/acrelbs oil/acrelitres oil/hakg oil/haCrop
Highest Vegetable Oil Yields
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
Highest Vegetable Oil Yields
Source: http://journeytoforever.org/
US gal/acrelbs oil/acrelitres oil/hakg oil/haCrop
635446559505000oil palm
287201826892260coconut
282198026382217avocado
255179523922010brazil nuts
240168522461887macadamia nuts
202142018921590jatropha
194136518181528jojoba
191134417911505pecan nuts
151106114131188castor beans
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
The Canola (raps) Plant
The canola (rape seed, raps, colza) is the oil plant of the northern climate, with yields of around 1 – 2 m3 of oil per hectare.
Source: www.svenskraps.se
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
Straight oils or biodiesel?
Plant oils can be used in two different forms:
• Raw straight vegetable oils (SVO), the only treatment is filtering;
• Chemically converted into esters = biodiesel.
Use of SVO in burners or engines is difficult due to high viscosity, danger of polymerization, wax sedimentation, coking at fuel injectors, etc.
Biodiesel avoids all these by having physical properties very close to those of fossil diesel, however the presence of residues of methanol and alkali might be a problem.
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
BiodieselBiodiesel production is a chemical process for trans-esterification of the complex triglyceride molecule of the vegetable oil. The result is a mixture of fatty esters with properties close to fossil diesel. The biggest disadvantage of biodiesel is its high cost!
Sustainable Energy Science and Engineering Center
Well-to-Wheels AnalysisTypical efficiencies for different powertrain alternatives:
Source: http://ies.jrc.cec.eu.int/