Download - Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
1/244
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
2/244
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
3/244
Aty, Rssbty,A HAtH CAR
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
4/244
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
5/244
Aty, Rssbty,A HAtH CAR
Cc Rc
b
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
6/244
..cbch, 2008
C : bht : bh
Ch h h.F h cc 2008.
T CCss, h ch jc bc(193/200607). t h jc h :h://.hh.//b. :.@h.
sb: 9789731997162 (c)sb: 9789731997179 (b)
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
7/244
tAb F Ctts
ts CtRbtRs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . FRwR . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1
1. Aty A bt. tH wAy bACt tH AvAAbty F tH by
Autonomy: as Sel-determination against, or as Sel-transcendence
to Others? Anthropological Reections on the Background o BioethicsR h, F (G) . . . . . . . . . . 15
Why the Way we Consider the Body Matters:Reections on our Bioethical Perspectives on the Human Body
s schc, c CG (G) 45
2. Aty A CAR FR tH RsCtvF -F-F Cs-AG
Autonomie als Selbstbestimmung und Frsorge:augezeigt am Beispiel der Sterbehile
wh , t (h) 79
Autonomie und Frsorge Die Perspektive des Rechtsv , G (G) 95
3. CAR FRs F Rssbty?
Te Limits o Discourse Ethics Concerning the Responsibility
toward Nature, Nonhuman Animals, and Future Generationsc , (sA) 129
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
8/244
oward an Ethics o Species Is there a Responsibilityto Preserve the Integrity o (Human) Species?
b , J cc sc Rch (R) 159
Te Principle o Responsibility or Illness and its Applicationin the Allocation o Health Care: A Critical Analysis
H, J cc
sc Rch (R) 191
x Cc . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 221x . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 227
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
9/244
ts CtRbtRs
ugen Huzum J, R, h h hh c cc. H ch h J cc sc Rch. H c, hc, h c jc, c. H ch jc h h c c jc.
Regine ather u F (G).sh c h bch u Cj-c (R). R hh hhc h. sh h Was ist Leben? Philosophische Positionen undPerspektiven (, 2003) Person Die Begrndung menschli-cher Identitt(, 2007).
volker ipp c , c c, c h G (G), , , h Ac s,u . H jc c, -cc h c . H c Patientenautonomie und Lebensschutz Zur Diskussion um eine gesetzli-che Regelung der Sterbehile(G, 2005) FamilienrechtlicherStatus und Solidaritt (- A R pA. w, t, 2008)
arl-wilhelm erks cc Ac Cc C u g(h). H h Verantwortung Ende oder Wandlungeneiner Vorstellung?: Orte und Funktionen der Ethik in unserer Gesellschat
(, 2001), Gott und die Moral: Teologische Ethik heute(,
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
10/244
ts CtRbtRs
1998), c, h F v, Aiming at Happiness: TeMoral eaching in the Catechism o the Catholic Church (,1996).
icolae morar pd p u, usA.H c h 2005 J h h jx c c x -u: q pq. H C hh, c Fc, , A, sj cc h hc (c /
). H h h c h bhcs c .
bogdan laru h hh Ax C J (R) H b. H c J cc sc Rch. H c chc, hc h, h. H h CurrentEthical Controversies in Biotechnology: Individual Autonomy and SocialResponsibility(J, 2008), h c c c ch c ch.
silke schicktanz u Gg(G), h h ch h c hc H c. H ch ch c
, x, hc cc c h c x. sh u-Rc pjc C bcc-CCx, G b - g c. c c- hc c hh c.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
11/244
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
12/244
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
13/244
FRwR
T -c ch h hh hc. T c h h ch h c x g. ,h h hch h h hc ch: h c h q
c ch.T cc q ch : h hg ? w j ? H g h c ? H c ? s, h q h. T c h c c
, h h c hch ( ) cc h h. T, q, : , jc, , , c. h, , o,1 c c q , cc , c , h h, , c c , h h. T h h h h chc c c , , , x g . w jc h , c h h
1 , Autonomy and rust in Bioethics (Cg
, 2002).
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
14/244
bGA AR2
, h c h h c h c h. , h , c c h h h c h h.
A c, xc h h cc ch c, c ch c c.
b . , g c h h h h hx . y, h . c h x: w
h , , , h h h x . b fc c ch h cc . , ch, h h h c . h x: c
h. w h h c h ch h x g - h c. w h h c h h , h h . T h h h ch h c x-- ? w c? c h ? b h h h ch h h h , h c h h h ? h h -c c c c . p , hc , h, c h
hc ch
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
15/244
FRwR 3
h cc. h, h ch c c ( ) c c g
ccc, c h h c h hch h.
h fc q , h, h h h cqc c hch c , h, hch c c. g g . w j h c c c c
c c h h . T h x g g g2 h c .3 ch , h hh c h hch j x c. w
c h ( F h ch x), h h cc c c ch. c h cc, c, c h c hh: h c c h c c
h , c jc ,, . h h h h h c.
2 T , Veranlagung und Verantwortung GenetischeDiagnostik zwischen Selbstbestimmung und Schicksal (b: ,2004).
3 J H, Die Zukunt der menschlichen Natur Au dem Weg
zu einer liberalen Eugenik?(F/.: sh, 2001).
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
16/244
bGA AR4
T - - . T
c c. t c c x c xc c. R h hh h h cc . H c h c , h h hh ch , H,
( ) - . Rg g h c c x . ch, h h h h h cc h h h. b h c cc c hhc, , ,
c. h h h hc chc , c cc c c c ch cc : h h . T h hch h xg g. T g hc , c h h hh . h , h , h , hch h -cc. (. 40) F h h cc h h c . T h h hc cc , c w d
h c h c
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
17/244
FRwR 5
g . (. 39) g h h, c x c , h
hh h h c h h h h .
T x h h h , g . s s h c h hc c h h . sh jc
h h hc h h x hccc h h . h cc, , h, c, c h hc c. T hc c , , j. A
h . A c ccc h x: ! T h h , h c h h , h c c c cc. o x g. T , , c h h . T cc, hch h g, , . F -h c: 1) A h h ; 2) , hch c hc h ; 3) A cc c, c c cc c c ; 4)
A x cc c
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
18/244
bGA AR6
c c. T , h h x c cc c c ( h, h h), h h
g x. T h h c c c, cc . T x h cqc h . T h h h h c hc, c c
hh, hch h c h q cc. h h j c c, q c hhc q.
wh h ch h c hc. F hc c hc, h c h c h
h hc. T h c : , , , j-c (bch & Ch). h c , h, h ch c. T c h h . T cc h h c h, c , h h. g . -w m g gh h h c ch h cc c h c h h . x
j. d
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
19/244
FRwR 7
cx ccc c h . c cc, c c :
h c j , h h q g. T h h h h (. 85).T g g, g . T h c cc h q.
T g g c h h c cc. w c h h h , hch h -. ch c ch, hch (. 89). T h c
c h hch c c h h c.
T x c h q h h G . c , h cc cc h c.v c h cc h c , h cc h h h . c ch q c h h hc ch c c h . h h h h , c h, h c h. Ghg g , -h h c c. T h
h h h
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
20/244
bGA AR8
c, c . T c c h c h hc. T h
c . T h h cc h, hch , h h,h c c . hc h , h c hc j. T h hc c , , hch h , h h
c h h c h . (.105) T h h c -c / c . v -- ( ) c q c h, h c cc , ch c c h . c
h . h hc h h h c h cc c c , h h , h cc h hc h h c . (. 107)
T h c fc cc jc c .v g g g , xg cc jc h h, .. c h, h jc x, jc h h. c ch h jc c hc h h h h jch c cc c. H h c
c hc h J H
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
21/244
FRwR 9
.. A h h ch h c , h , g. T g . Tg
c hc c, hc , h c ch c c cc c, - hh x cc h g , ,ch . T , , h q-
g . j c hc , , jc c cc (J wh). T cqc , c , h h h cc c hh c c , , analogous eeling to moralityh c . (. 143)
b fc c hc c , c, xc h c . h qc hc h c c hc , g q, x , , c. h c h , c x, h ch Gh b, h c h h h . H H cc h h h cc .
c h , h h x c q - -hc. h h q h c c c, c c. T
q h cc hc,
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
22/244
bGA AR10
cc h c hz c . c c , c c c-
c c. T c c c c c , .. g. T h c c h c , g . T q , -
, h , h . (. 160) fc g g.T c c cc c c c x . T c h c x , jgc h h h cqc.
T c c c c c c. b h h c ch. c h. h h x h c . T q - g c h c c ch hh cc. : c h g g g g h h, , c x c h h c h , h h c. c h h
h c c.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
23/244
FRwR 11
h c h , H ch jc h hh c hh c h x h c chq.
T c, fc, q. hccc c c . c c c c. T x g c c (.. , , c.),h h c c h
c ch c h hh c. h h h c h cc c c, c hh hc h c . bc, h c h c h h hhh (.. , ch ,
c.) h c h c h c . A h h h h cc c c h h c h c c . (. 194) T h h c h h c x jc. A h h cqc , ch h ch h h h .H, h c cc. H ch h c h c c c. H c h c. T c jc c
cqc. A h, h
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
24/244
bGA AR12
h h c c c c, c - h h c, h
h c q , .., q cc cc q c .
T g gA R: H h , h h Fch p H, 2006 (Rg , v, wh ). t cc jc
j b CCss, R h ch, hch h c h c (b , H).t h h h c h h h (s schc, c ). h c h h H h c.
Bogdan OlaruJ, c 2008
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
25/244
1Aty A bt.tH wAy bAC t tH AvAAbty
F tH by
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
26/244
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
27/244
Aty: As sF-tRAt AGAst,
R sF-tRAsCC t tHRs?
Ahc Rc h bc bhc
R h
Freiburg University (Germany)
1. IntroductIon
sc h h cc h . F
c, hch h cc c , h, , , cc,, h cc . H h c h , c h, h. h h h c cc, h h, hh c h hc. wh c , h h h c . , h h c c . T, h xc -cc cc hc; h h h c. T hc h hc c. b h h c h ? h cc ? , c c , . c
h c c h h h h
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
28/244
RG AtHR16
cc h .1T . Tg c, h Aq h A
h. F A h sc hh h h h c c h c. A , p z, .
2. capacItIes and personal Interests as basIs
o human IdentIty
g , G ch Q h : c, wc z- ch h ch h. , ch , R .2 H
, c c xc, c, h, , hchc cz cc j . H c g - h h . Cq, h h h h c h ; hh h
c h h c, h h h , h c h. H c c h h h c
1 C. Rg , Person Die Begrndung menschlicher Identitt(: wchch bchch, 2007).
2 ch Q, Personales Leben und menschlicher od PersonaleIdentitt als Prinzip der biomedizinischen Ethik(F/.: sh,
2002), . 193.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
29/244
AtyAs sF-tRAt 17
. c . , , czc , h c h
; cq h c h . h, h h c , c x fc. T h h c . b h c j h h, c .3
C , h cc j
g h h hchc h h . Cq, h h h hch h, G d H Rg 1948 , h h . T c h h
cc h c c . bh c c h h . T, c cc; c c. H q q g . F , c hch h cc h h c . T c , h cc . Identikation mith x h. cz xz . o F , h , ch h x
3 . Q, 2002, . 178: Hch h Fh x b
A .
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
30/244
RG AtHR18
.4 F c , h c c h c . c c
, h h c h h hc.sh h h h h c h c c . A c c h h h c cc.
b , h h c , h c g ?
A c c c - h h x h . A , h xc . b x ? cc c c h . T, g hc chc . c h
cc . T, s xc, , , c cc c . b , h c , s ? ch h , c h cc, h h c c c h c cc? h h cc g g cc, h , , , h , c cc. b . T g - h h h h c c.T, h hch h h c h c h h c. c c, c
4 . Q, 2002, . 267.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
31/244
AtyAs sF-tRAt 19
g - . T g c h fc. h, h h . A
c , h ch cc. h hc ,h c h . h h c. , c h , . T g, . Cq,
c h cc h h . T c c c h ; h , c, c c .5
, u s x, g , h hch xc cc h c
g g - h . T h hcc. H cc c c Gg, J x.6 , g z . A cjc o, uA, c
c c h c c . T cc c h . b c h h h h , h .
5 C. C. sh, Gehl und Urteilskrat Ein Pldoyer r dieemotionale Vernunt(ch: C.H. bc, 20013).
6 J, Philosophie II: Existenzerhellung(b/Hg:
s, 1973) . 201249.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
32/244
RG AtHR20
Th h c cc, h h c c . T h cc cc h. T h
h hch h h c c , h ch h h hchc c c . T c .
y h hc h cc:F h c c h cc h
h h, c h . b cc c, ch, , . h, c h h c hc . h c hc , h x .7 wc h h c c
h c h, jc cc . T c c h hc, ch, h, hcc c cc; x h h . Cq, h cc h c . F h x -, q , , , h c h , h c. c x c hc c. b h h c h h, x . c
7 . Q, 2002, . 56: d pz cc c Gz ,
s ch ch .
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
33/244
AtyAs sF-tRAt 21
jc cc.8 scc h ; c x . c h x c c h c
.9 F c c hch c ccc h hc; , c h h h , h c cc h , . h jc h c , h c h h c h h , h, h , .
A h , hch g : , hh c , c c, , , c h h h c h x h.10 b h h c cc ,
8 . Q, 2002, . 54: b ch ch, .h. b ch s ch.
9 G. b, Das Leib-Seele-Problem Eine Einhrung(s:hh, 1996), . 15: ch, m . mG, Gh s s . ch h ch ch Z
.10 G. b, 1996, . 18-20: m -
p g, G h h , G . w
Ah, hch bch ch , ch , chhch ch, hch . A m R w
h.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
34/244
RG AtHR22
h , ? H , hch , x hc? , hc h cc c c, ch,
. x hc. h c . h, cc c , hc cc c; c h g . cc hch c jc, hch h c h h .
h, h . ch h c h h h Illusion Freiheit. Th h c h x , g , c, c x . T c hhc
.11
Th h c c , h c. T, h h : h h c h h , . A Q, p, , c c c, h, , . A ch h c c
cc h h ; c . Thh c c h h , cc p, p. T cc h h c h h
11 m p, Illusion Freiheit? Mgliche und unmgliche Konse-
quenzen der Hirnorschung(F/.: sh, 2004), . 180.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
35/244
AtyAs sF-tRAt 23
c .12 A J c h, h h h . T c
xc hch c cc.Cq, h h h
c: c x .13 F - . Tg ,, cc c c c ch
12 . , 2004, . 158: ch chg , Hg, , ch, x h; chch ch v g , ch h. h T A c pz
. v h z pc, c z, pch ch.
w h h chch , H, p, g g. dbh ch ch , ch m g
: h , s ch chch v.
13 . , 2004, . 17: s Fh sg Agg gg Zg
Agg gg Z [], , H , ch h ch : ch H , ; h Z , ch
h ch ch .
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
36/244
RG AtHR24
, , x, , , cc. T , h , h h . h chc
; , q. , h c h c hch c g x; .14 h c, q. h c cc, h . c, hh, h h g
ch .15 hh h c c c c, h cc h h cc h .
wh h c h ? wh , x . , x ; . . H - .16 b gh c.17 T, c c c. Ac c x c,c -c c ,
. wh h , jc xc cc c hch , s h , x h h h , hch c
14 . , 2004, . 67.15 . , 2004, . 75: H, ch
, H c .16 . , 2004, . 132, 153.
17 . , 2004, . 172.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
37/244
AtyAs sF-tRAt 25
c.18 T, cc c h h hc hch c h c.
T h jc h c h h. T c x c c. c hc c, c h x h cc hch h c h . A h . Cq, h c
cc c hch h h jc h c .19 h c, h c .20 A h , h
18 . , 2004, . 148.19 . Q, 2002, . 105: A v
A g , bg p bg p p R - . d p , c ,c z . w ch bc. w , ch , ch c, ch A ch .
20 m. Q, 2002, . 57: d g A gg- x T, b , ch v, ch ch g (g, .) . vh ch Rh , chch b Rh bch ch bch ch F . w g,
bg p g bg ,
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
38/244
RG AtHR26
h h . wh , h c c h c jc c. b h h cc
h cc .b ,
q : wh h h hg ? j, h h cc h xh? C h c, hch
g -, ? A c h, h h h , x .T c c h hch c cc: hc . w X b h , h ch , ch h sj ch .21 h cc h, h .
T h ch cqc hc. Fh c , h h h h . A , h h c h c hch
, ch ch , g , p .
p p R c z , . d G c- c Az pz z , bch F chch . h , chbchh ch R ch R .
21 . Q, 2002, . 272.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
39/244
AtyAs sF-tRAt 27
c. T c -c .22 , h c c h c
h . T c hch cqc c c. b hh h hc c h , c h h . bc c h . T, c h h h . T ch h c c ,
c c. Gc xc h h h , cc cc cc. w, , c c cc c c c c hh h h c c hch hc ?
h cc h z c ? , - c cc h g gg. T g g h h chc .
h h c . T x, .23 T hch h c qc x h h
22 . Q, 2002, . 90.23 . Q, 2002, . 116: ch hch
g, R g , - A u: g
c, ch .
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
40/244
RG AtHR28
c . T c h c c hc. b h .
Cq, h h h c h h cc. Acc c, c h , h h cc, xc , h. T h h c. h c, c, c h h h h c
h . A h, h q ghch . T xc x s. A c h c c ch hch h chc hh.24 T q h ch h h hc hh ch
h c. b h, h c cc c . T,, h h , h , c h.
T hch C . g .Cq, h .A ccc h , hh h h . Tc cqc c . A h c g q . b
24 s, Praktische Ethik(s: Rc, 19942), . 237.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
41/244
AtyAs sF-tRAt 29
h, h cc , c x, chc c c. , j
cc h s h hh h w .
3. sel-transcendence as the basIs o Inner
autonomy
h h hc hch h
w c c c c. T, c q : fc h ? h h h h h h ?
F, c c . T ,h c c, h . Th h c c h , h c
h h h h h . j c , hc c c hc. F h g g . T g - . b , c h. cx ch h , h g q x, -, , , g. T qc c c h h h . A h h, h h c c . h cc c,h hc c c ch . b h, xh ch, , ch. wh h h
x .
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
42/244
RG AtHR30
A , , . Rc h h h 8h h c h c h ch: h
q g . b , ghch j c . T h xh. T, h h h h.
c h c.T hc chc h
c cc c xc , h, h c . T c g . , g bg gA H (G), , c c vc z v ch .25 T
cc h ch hch c c cc h h h c c. Th ch h h , ch, h, h h c cc . o, h hc chc .26 T c c c
, c, . T cc h h .
25 J. b, Das Gedchtnis des Krpers Wie Beziehungen und Lebensstileunsere Gene steuern (ch/Zch: , 20054), . 70.
26 J. b, 20054, . 71: , g G [] - bg g bg gg
s.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
43/244
AtyAs sF-tRAt 31
H c cc x . T g h . wh h
, g. T - . T g g . . , , , g . A -
h h , J : ch A. b h, h F A, h h Selbst. ch ch , ch ch Selbstkommunikation z Az .27 T c , , , . ch b ch , F , vh .28 T h h x cc g;29 , gh h h h .
27 J, 19734, . 50, 55.28 F. , Das Wort und die geistigen Realitten: pneumatologische
Fragmente, . . T (F/.: sh, 1980), . 34.29 Hh ,Mit anderen Augen Aspekte einer philosophischen
Anthropologie(sg: R, 1982), . 14: d m g , , ch Ach h A, s s.d x p m R . d c p. d ch ch . ,
ch h .
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
44/244
RG AtHR32
j h h : cc cqc h h. A h cc, q h cc , c, j
. A h c h h c ccc cc h h h . H h h, h h h . A , cc c, x , h .30 A h ; h cc
h h. A h , h c h h cc .
s-, , cc cc c. b h h h h, h
. T c h h g . Tc h h h g h. t h h ; h c h h. T h h c ; c c c . A -cc h hch c c c, hch c xc. sh, c, cc, h, q hch h .
30 C : J. Hc, Religion Die menschlichen Antworten au die
Frage nach Leben und od(ch: ch, 1996), . 162.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
45/244
AtyAs sF-tRAt 33
Cq, g, , x- . F , h c h hch c
cc. Cc cc c g. T h h c. hc,h, c h c ; h c h h c h. Ah h c h , h . hc h
h , h, , c h , h x h .
b h c c h c , c c h? h g g, x c h c. T
c h hh h h .b h h h cjc h c c x c hh cc.T c hch c. c jc, jc c; h , h . T jc jc c c - cc ch c c . A , c c . T , cx hch c.H c c h h . T g g.T h h c q hc . A
, h h h c h
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
46/244
RG AtHR34
h c. T, h x h ,cc cc, , , , .T x hh
.31 T, h q h c c h c h . T h . , h h x .A h x h h h . b h, h hc .
, , h. T h c h cc c c c c . T c . T, x h h cc . c cc c, c h hch ,
h . A h x h h, , c.32 x .T, g g h.
31 H p, 1982, . 50: J p
t, s ch , ch, w b Ac, Ac ch.s vch, j G.
32 H p, 1982, . 10: [F m ] ug s g s d xz. p d-c : d , ( ) bc, . ,
ch ch ch , h .
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
47/244
AtyAs sF-tRAt 35
b g x -. cc cc h h c. Ch h
, , , . T c h c; c . g g xc. h, h c h h h . h
. ch c c h , h . A , c . x cx , .. cc, c, h h h cc c. h c,c h c h . Th, , c c , -
c h h c c. T h w : T h , hch h xc c , h ch cc c. cc , h h .33 h hc c c.
cc hc c h .34 h c, h
33 w , A h b C s, : R. b. & H. t H (.), Ethical Foundations oPalliative Care or Alzheimer Disease(b/: T J H , 2004), . 122.
34 w. d, 2004, 123: T
h h h hch c h .
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
48/244
RG AtHR36
x , c. T ch h . g , g, , x , . T
chc h hch h h h h . T c ; h hch x. T, h h j , c, . . , g c; h h h, h c h h. A h c
, x , . H h c h h .35 T h hc cg , h . Cq, h h, chcc h h c, h h c.
T x h h. T c hc, g g . -h, c h c g -c. T x hch h c c c h
T c h h c h . T h c hh x ( ), h h x h c h h h .
35 . , Der Aubau der menschlichen Person (F/b/w:H, 1994), . 110 : h s , G s G
chh.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
49/244
AtyAs sF-tRAt 37
h ch c. c c h h h h h ch. bh h h x c c
c c. F c c q h . T h c .36
b h x h , , hch h c h h h, h hch h hc c hch h . s,, g. b h jc h . T jc c . T c h c ch h. T , c, . A cq h h h. h x h h c h c c c c .37 b ch , h c .38 A
36 c -p, Phnomenologie der Wahrnehmung(b: G, 1966), . 219: d G c c , , . , vh G, ch ch ch
G A, G vh A ch .
37 c , 1966, . 176: [ ch] ch b G ch, [] , h, jR , ch .
38 w , 2004, . 120: A c h, , c . c
h h hh .
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
50/244
RG AtHR38
cc, c , c, h c , .
b c c, c
, c -cc? , g . T , jg . T x . b cc h cc h h ? h h h, c
x. h h . T hc x, h x h cc .39 T , x g g . Gh .40 T h c h
39 w , 2004, . 119: b c c . F, h c x c , c x . F h c,hch h C, chc h h , hh h h c x h . sc, h c x h h h , h , h h.
40 w. d, 2004, . 119: g, c ; , h h h , , , g . w g c hh c c , h h c h cc j xcc h c . hc c c , h h h cc. T h
c
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
51/244
AtyAs sF-tRAt 39
c hch h h h c .41 T c w d xc- .42 T bodily autonomy
h c h c h hc h .C h (c) c, h h , hh hh c .43 T chc c hch h c h c
h . h cc h c h cc , ,h xc. b x h g h h cc h h ; h cc cc . T h
h c cc . v c , , h c . F h c, h : , c h h . T , , x h xc h in statu nascendij h .
41 w. , 2004, . 122: F c, hcc, c c x ccc h c .
42 w. , 2004, . 125: tc . w , cc . H, g c c c , c h c h . b h h c h .
43 w. , 2004, . 125.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
52/244
RG AtHR40
c; h x h c jc c, .H j q,
. Th h c c h c , h h -cc.44 cc c , , cc . T cc c h . h ,
jc cc c. T c c h . Tc c c .
g , Gh, h ch, .Gh h conditio humana, c g . T
g - . T chcc Gh h h hch h . w c c, h c hh. b h xc h c. o c, c c c-
g , s J, c ch h h h ccc h c
44 w. , 2004, . 123: H, h c c chcc h , c () . h , hh h c c ,
.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
53/244
AtyAs sF-tRAt 41
. H hch h h . j, h c h c , h
cc c, . T x c c - c . c h ; h h c . Th Gh , h h h hc hchc c. T, c h
c . c h hch c h .b ch c h hch h h Gh, x h Hb .
x q h hch c h hch . T
c c , cc wJ, s w, J, c xc: h cc cc. T c h h, jc c h. b c c , h Gh h h h c h h h hch c c,
hch h h .
4. humans wIthIn nature
A -: A g g, . Tg , , . T g -
x . Th h c c ,
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
54/244
RG AtHR42
h cc c hch hc g . T c cc. H h h
. T h .45 b , , h jc g . Tg -, h h , h c chc . T, h c, c, cc h h. A x sch , h h cx h . T h h cc
h h c .46 Tg g ,h h h. t h cc ; , . H h cc h .
5. summaryH c c h
, g -.F, h , . T , h hhc chc . T c h , c , . sc, h
c c q c , h . T, h - Gg. A
45 c , 1966, . 166168.46 mx s, Wesen und Formen der Sympathie (b: F,
1973), . 112114. C. R. F. h, Te Rights o Nature. A H
hc (/: wc , 1989).
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
55/244
AtyAs sF-tRAt 43
g ,h h c h . H h h h . T, h
g. H g c h h , hc h h h h , .
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
56/244
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
57/244
wHy tH wAy w CsR tH by AttRs
Rc bhc c
h H b1
s schcUniversity Medical Center Gttingen (Germany)
1. IntroductIon
h 1970, c hc hc h h jc c c. b h , h c h h hc c c c. cZerreiprobe (1970) h A G b j h c h h hh h . T x
h . bc h x. T A C b h c h c sh (1971), hhh c h h h h hx c c. T Fch h c
1990 g gc h c h . h c h h h c h x h h .2
1 A h h h Philo-sophy, Ethics, and Humanities in Medicine(4 c 2007).
2 . sch,Mit Haut und Haaren Der Krper in der zeitgenssi-
schen Kunst(: , 2002).
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
58/244
s sCHCtAZ46
1970, g c h, q cx : h !, h h
G, b, h s h h x . T cc c h c h , c q , - , cc: wh h , hx c h h h h h ?
h c c h 1970, q -hc . bh x, c c, h q, c x h ccz. H, 1970 questions. -
j - . b, hc j h , c h .3 h 1990 h ch cc h c h cc hc.4 A, c , , c cc
3 A. R. J, A c c c, :Bioethics: An Introduction to the History, Methods, and Practice, 2 , . s. J, A. R. J, R. A. p (s/b//s: J b h, 2007), . 316.
4 s .. t. h, sc h h , : Encyclo-pedia o Bioethics1996, . 1, . 300-305; R. m. Z, :T hc , : Encyclopedia o Bioethics1996, . 1,. 293-300; d. , Te Absent Body(Cg/: u
Chc , 1990).
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
59/244
wHy tH wAy w CsR tH by AttRs 47
h cc. Acc A w5 h c c h cq h xc c ( , )
cc c. T h c.A, c c q c -
c c , c , , c - c cc h h , hhhc h c c hch c cc cc, x ,
, . T, shc6
cc c c , -c hch h , h h c, h c h h c h .7
, c c, hh, c cc cc hc. T, . , h ch hc hc c c c c x jg.8 -. A h h jc jc , -
5 A. w, wh b ? F c h c c , Body & Society6(2000), . 124.
6 . shc, b h hc. Ch h c, : Ethics o the Body Postconventional Challenges, .c & R. (C, /: T p, 2005),. 128.
7 . shc, b h hc. Ch h c, 2005, . 1 .
8 . shc, . 3.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
60/244
s sCHCtAZ48
. F x, h c h h g h h h c h
h, h jc. c, , shc , c, , , .9F g, h .10 cc h h h , cc , .11
w ch c c h c hc. h c, h c h hc j; c, h c h h . Tc hc c c hc c fc c h h h.
H, hc , cc c, h h hc c h cc , h c ch h hh . T c ch ch h hc hch h cc . T c .
g g, hc systematic, processualh hc j
9 . shc, . 7.10 . shc, . 6.11 s .. C. w, R. ch, issue Economies: Blood, Organs
and Cell Lines in Late Capitalism (h: , 2006);m. s & R. m (.) Ethics o the Body, (Cg, m/
: T t , 2005).
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
61/244
wHy tH wAy w CsR tH by AttRs 49
.12 c h c hc , h h h h ccxc, hc c
c. (w - c hh, , c c h). h, c h ; h c cc . T hc c cg, ( -)c. (wh ch c h c: wh h c? wh h ? A : wh jc h?) T,h h c . , cc c c hc (hch ) h h h h h.
, - hc ch, h h, c
hc, h h, c ch h ( , ) gg .C - -g g c c c c h . Hc, hc h hch h c hc, hh c
c c cc h h. h , gg g g xc. b h h cc, c hc h c ch hc. c , c cc
12 s A. , Ethical Judgement Te Use o Science in Ethics (
y: T F , 1955).
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
62/244
s sCHCtAZ50
c .s. Ac hc. A cc h c hh hch . H, ch c cc
. T, c c , ch h c, h cc .13 c h c . h h c cc c c , . T , , c
g, h h h cc h h h . h , h cc h asking q g h x: c, h g. T x c h hc hh c c,14 c hc. T h ch c c hc .
2. the body In ethIcal, socIal and hIstorIcalconsIderatIons o medIcIne
2.1 T i
c, h h h hcjc c c ,
13 . -p , Phenomenology o Perception ( J: TH , 1981).
14 R. , Te Bodies o Women: Ethics, Embodiment and Sexual
Diference(: R, 1994).
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
63/244
wHy tH wAy w CsR tH by AttRs 51
h hc hh.15 wh h chc c cc, c, h c,
c h h h c c. , hc h h cx h h g g, hc . bh c h , c h c , hc h c h, c . Tg
, h h h jc h h c hc . F x, h g, g q-jc c h c hc h , ccc . T cc, hchh c h ,16 h h h h c
h h hc h c h c hc . Acc ,17 h h c C cc c. T c xc h h . b h cx . h h, h c q h .18
15 t. h, sc h h , : Encyclopedia o Bio-ethics,1996, . 1, . 300305.
16 d. , Te Absent Body(Cc/: u Cc p,1990).
17 Idem.18 v. sch, b .
d A c Ac,Allgemeine Zeitschrit r
Philosophie28(2003), . 5169.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
64/244
s sCHCtAZ52
xc , c h , h x c. T hcx h h c, c xc,
h h .19 (T ch h h , c c c .) Acc c x sch20 (1913), h G c , g ( ) . T gg
C , c h h c. , 21 h h c jc xc h .
h h h, ch h c cc c . c, h c hc cc x h c
c, h c c h .T h c cc c hc c .22 Fd H,23 g g
19 . , Te Absent Body, 1990; H.A. F, b : hc c c hc,Journal o Medicine andPhilosophy23(1998), . 533545.
20 . sch, Der Formalismus in der Ethik und die materiale Wert-ethik: neuer Versuch der Grundlegung eines ethischen Personalismus(b:b, 2005).
21 . , Phenomenology o Perception, 1981.22 . Fc, Te Birth o the Clinic: An Archeology o Medical Per-
ception ( y: v b, 1974); b. t, Te Body and SocietyExplorations in Social Teory( y: b bc, 1984).
23 d. H, T : d-
c, Diferences: A Journal o Feminist
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
65/244
wHy tH wAy w CsR tH by AttRs 53
j g. H-, c ccc ch hc h . T cc () x
c h h, c j. . w g ,, h, c c. c- -. w c, c cc h c . h
h c cc h h c h h h, .24Ahh c h h c cc , - c cc hc. w c c h hc c c xc , ,
cc c, h h c,c h h cc, h h.c c c c
c , c hc . T, h c h c.
2.2 b ii ii ii
wh h h h h chq c c . T q h hc ,h c ch q h c cc, . c c
Cultural Studies1(1989), . 343.
24 v. sch, b , 2003.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
66/244
s sCHCtAZ54
c c( h h ), c hch h c chc c .25 T
h xc cc h h h .H, q .
w g c h c cqc chc ,26 , -c , xcc ( ) c c , hch c h h chc h c h .27
F hc , hh, c, h c h h , hh c cc c j h . h, hh, h ch hc h ch hc c h h .T h h c c c, c -c :
1. C c c (.. -) g
25 s . shc, b h hc. Chh c, 2005.
26 p. sj, Regeln r den Menschenpark (F/m.: s-, 1999).
27 . , sv. Z R sj , : Grenzverlue Der Krper als Schnittstelle, A. bh & A. F, (ch: wh F v, 2002),
. 185210.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
67/244
wHy tH wAy w CsR tH by AttRs 55
, q cc c h ;
2. A h , ch h h q h c h w c (c h JCh , h h cc c c).28 T h c:
Nature culture: c c, A -g, x c c .
Human person machine: c c - h hh ch cc.
Human being animal: h A JChc q , x,h c h ch.
Internal external:
c c c q -h x c .
Body mind: C ch h h ch c hhh .
3. T c h q h c :
T h , h h j h .T g h h c ;
28 s .. . , Membranes: Metaphors o Invasion in Nineteenth-Century Literature, Science, and Politics(b/: Jh H
, 1999).
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
68/244
s sCHCtAZ56
T - cc, hch h c hc , c , h ;
Ah ch h , c c h h , h .
. R c c h h c ( , , c , c h, h c) h cc h h
j, , g, .29 A cqc, h c .30 b h xch c.
t c, c, hc c h c h hch h .31 H,
c c c c, c h h g j. F g , c c h c h h c h h h , hh h cc
29 R. . d (.), Die Erndung des Menschen (w: b,1998); R. w, H , : Der Mensch und sein Krper von der Antike bis heute, A.. h (ch: CH bc, 1983), . 209225.
30 t. h, sc h h , : Encyclopedia o Bio-ethics,1996, . 1, . 300.
31 t. schch, Die Erndung der Organtransplantation (F/./
y: C v, 1998).
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
69/244
wHy tH wAy w CsR tH by AttRs 57
g .32 T g q hc h c
h,33 h h c . c cc cc jc - h cc c ,34 xcc c h . T cc c hg ( ) g
hc c h h hch j , . h h cc, h h h c xc: h h , h h, hc jcc,g () - c cc; , h h h, c c
cq c ch, hch h h q, c jc, hc c.
32 s .g. d. J, g : T ,Medical Anthropology Quarterly9(1995), . 335356; .A. sh, xc: Ac g , Medical Anthropology Quarterly, New Series
9(1995), . 357389.33 p. mC, Brain Dead, Brain Absent, Brain Donors: Human
Subjects or Human Objects?(C: w, 1993); d. , Hirnver-panzungen Die erste Unsterblichkeit au Erden (R Hg:Rh, 1993).
34 A. bh & A. F, chR ug, : Grenzverlue Der Krper als Schnittstelle, A. bh & A. F (ch: wh F v, 2002),
. 923.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
70/244
s sCHCtAZ58
T -x c . t w ccc h c h ch.
chc h h h h c c . T g .Ag , g , g -. C, , h h h c
h c h c c, materialization.35 Acc h cG ,36 c c ch h hhh c c h, h c h c c h h h, g -jc h h. h c h
c c-c c, c. hc h : h q h c cc , (c h h) hh h h c h h h
. Cc fc - h c h jc c c
35 A. bh & A. F, 2002, . 923.36 G. , d -c oj
ch w, : Grenzverlue Der Krper als Schnittstelle, A. bh & A. F (ch: wh F v, 2002),
. 211232.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
71/244
wHy tH wAy w CsR tH by AttRs 59
h h , c h ch c ch. sch cc
c ch . T hh H 37 h h h h c c hc h c h :
Th h ch, h h c c cc-c c c. Cq,
g x g hch c ch cc.
cc c c, c c x c c x. j . T h.38 A h g
c. T c c, h . -,
, gcc. T ( cc/c ) - c xc . T c . hc
q, g - c . H, h hch h c xc c c , c c .
37 H. , v , : Grenzverlue Der Krper als Schnittstelle,2002, . 4764.
38 s . shc, b h hc. Ch h
c, 2005, . 5.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
72/244
s sCHCtAZ60
cc h h x h h c h (.. cc ) (.. ,
jc, -). - (c c, c jc) ( cc h c h h ).39
w cc , c h h ,c cc c c c . o , -- cc h . T termini technici chc . T j . T
h h h h , hcc c h .Acc h c , hh c c , c c, c h c.
h x c, c h ( hc) . T , , , c , c c q h h c c hc, .
39 b. G, T , Stanord Encyclopedia o Phi-
losophy, 2005.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
73/244
wHy tH wAy w CsR tH by AttRs 61
3. more than one relatIon:embodIment and autonomy
h hh h h cc , cc (c) c hc.
Acc Rch sh,40 c c c , h , h c (g, , g, , c , c). T x h cxc h h c h h : bh c h , c h x h , c c h c. T c , h c. T , , c cc : gg, chq ch c c x g .s , h c xchch hh . c h , . c c ( c) c xc ( h chq, chh, c.). whsh, c h cc. T cc hch h , hch h h c .41
40 R. s, Perorming Lie (, y: C u, 2000).
41 Idem.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
74/244
s sCHCtAZ62
c, sh c h c h xc h h c h.
hc, , h, h
. H, C , cc - .42 , cc .43 F C, h cc q h x c c (ch h , h ; h h
) hh c h c c (c -c c , , ). b c cc,44 h h content c.45 T c , c C c.46 c cc h hc h chc,
cc c h cch c h h c
42 J. Ch (.), Te Inner Citadel Essays on Individual Autonomy( y/x: x u p, 1989); J. C, R- , , c c ,Philosophical Studies117(2004), . 143-164; . C, p , : Te Stanord Encyclopedia o Philosophy(Z ., c
2007 : T hc Rch , C h s , s , s CA, 2007).
43 . C, , 2007.44 J. Ch, , Ethics
101(1991)/2, . 343359.45 s . C, 2007.46 C. m, , : Handbook o Phenom-
enology and Medicine, s.. (w: A
h, 2001), . 417439.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
75/244
wHy tH wAy w CsR tH by AttRs 63
. sh cc h x h x , g -
,47 c h jc h h x chc . , jh h x chc cc c -g hch . H, c c , -c, Jh R,48 c,
c c h hch c h. R cc , Rc hc ch, h hc h c h h, c . H c-
c c ch cc h h .49
T c c c cq h c cc , c. -x h c h h . b , cc
hc hch . h hc hch h , h c h , c
47 Idem.48 J. R, A Teory o Justice(C A: H
, 1971).
49 C. c, , . 433.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
76/244
s sCHCtAZ64
-c , ccc c h.
w ? c
c, cq cc jc h . h cq h h cc h hc. A h, h c c hch c cc. cc c c jc h
. T , cc cc hc j. T ch c cc, h h xc cc h h hc hc hc. T, c x c -cc cc c h . h
cc c hc c h h c cc h. T ch c hc hc ,h , h c hc h. A , .
t ch h , h cc h . Acc Ch,50 , h h, h c c c c xc . T -
50 J. C (.), Te Inner Citadel Essays on Individual Autonomy,1989; J. C, R , ,
c c , 2004, . 143164.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
77/244
wHy tH wAy w CsR tH by AttRs 65
, h cc h ch c c c. ( ).
h , c h h , x . , h g , - .T h c h hch c c h h c . c h h cc c, c.51 () cc hh cc c c h c, cc hc . T , - . b c c ch h
. w h c , , x q c h h c h .
Acc 1, h . T . T g -c (h hc ) h h, h- h. T c c x x ( g
51 C. c, . 429.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
78/244
s sCHCtAZ66
, , g - ). A , h cc c h h . T c
hchc ; c h x , - - , ( h cc c h x c). b , ch q ch c:
3.1 bi ii
A - c c h . T h cc (.. x c), c c . A x h c/ c c (.. cc, c h ,
). H, h h cc h z , h h q h , h h c.
3.2 r i iii
, h c, c h c h , cc h . T hch h h h h h h c c cx. T c h h jc c h. h c h cc c. F , c h h cc c
h . b c c
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
79/244
wHy tH wAy w CsR tH by AttRs 67
, c.C c c , c c
? A -cc c q c c xc c . , c c- c c. T c cc, c c c . T c h c c c
h h h .3.3 c i iiii
A -cc c c - , c c cc . T, h c cc h : c x,
c ch cc, .v h c h hc , h c hhx, q(ch h c c.). sch h cx , c c z, c c
c. cc c cc c . T z c chcc: h c h c h c c h h . T c h x chc c: c h h . C c h c
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
80/244
s sCHCtAZ68
h. Rc g g .T, h h xc h h. T
c c h c hh h h c c h.T c h h h h ( ) c h h cc h .
3.4 rii i i
A h cc h q h h c h h h. T x cc , c, c c. T c c, h c c. Tc h c , x hch h c cc
c c. T c c -, c h cc hh ch h xc.F , x c. T h c h h . Rc ch c c c c c c
x c, .. hx c.
4. dIscussIon: IncreasIng sensItIvIty orvarIous normatIve perspectIves o the body
wh cc c c h c ? h c, h ch 2 ,
. T
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
81/244
wHy tH wAy w CsR tH by AttRs 69
c x c, , c-c c . bc c, h c
c j h .
cc c - bodily sel-determination h j h h c, h h c h h c. A c ch c c c ( , ,
h), h c . b chh c, c g . F , g, c c -c h h c? A c c ccz
h . T h , h c c h , h jc hh x .52 b , c h c , x h q hh c h h h. H, h c h ( h h h h ) c. g , h c h , h, ? T g
52 s. w, Cc h h
, Health Care Analysis8(2000), . 89201.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
82/244
s sCHCtAZ70
ch, , h ch ( q hch). c
c , -c c cc, ch h c h h , x h .
b h c h . T cc c
c c c c c . Tc q h h h c , .. c. F x, h c h q hh h c h c , , g h h h . T h
x ( ?) h h . t h moral respect or others bodily integrity ch c. c, c h , h g ( c h ). T h h c h h c c.
T g , -. w - g , g, h c . sch c c c - . Cc
c h ch h h
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
83/244
wHy tH wAy w CsR tH by AttRs 71
h c. wh h c , q . F
c, cc j h . t c h , h cc, c c c x c. T c - c hc h h h c (ch c).
T - g g c c h h c h h , h h/h . T c h xc h h .53 T c c h .T care or bodily individuality and its characteristics, h h h c h cc x c cc c ch hh , , c. F c, c
c h c (ch ), (.. h x) h h t( ,
53 H. J, A. d g - Hg, : Identitt,Leiblichkeit, Normativitt: Neue Horizonte anthropologischen Denkens, . 1, A. b, . , . R, d. T (F/.:
sh, 1996), . 357369.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
84/244
s sCHCtAZ72
).54 Tc ch c ch h h ch . h
c, h hc c h h (c) q hh h h x c . , zh h q, h h, h h c c c, hh h, ch h c h c h c, c
c. A, jc: w c h xc c c h cc c.
F, recognition o bodily-constitutedcommunities and bodily cooperation q hh
c cc c c , c, cc ,55 g (g , ). T - - c h x hch
ch c h c . T -
54 s .. J.. H, C. ch, . ., t ,Journal o Neurology Neurosurgery andPsychiatry2005, . 992995.
55 J.. sc, C. Rhs, hc//R. wh : T c c hc, Human Gene Terapy
12(2001), . 8795.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
85/244
wHy tH wAy w CsR tH by AttRs 73
c c c c cc. sc h c, x, hc , h c h cc
h h c h c .F c, h c c h c c cc c c c-. ch h; h h h hch h h, h h: hx xc h xc c
h c.56
5. conclusIons:the loss o sel-evIdent truths
T c c c c h c h . wh
c , hch ? s hc cc h hc hh c,57 c h c . H, , - c cc h cc - g c , ch .
cc h c cc
56 . ccz, . c, . Fz, c h? T c c c , ,Journal o Medicine, Health Careand Philosophy, 11(2008):1, . 5772.
57 u. s, , : Hello Dolly?ber das Klonen, J.s. A, G. b, C. Rg
(F/.: sh, 1998), . 90122.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
86/244
s sCHCtAZ74
cc h , hch , , c h. c hc c h ,
h. cc h h h hc c c g g .F h, h cc h ch c j c h h c ( ). c jj c h c.
T ch hc, c ch , h , h hch c cc, c . wh c cx, - - c c c ( ) . b h , hc
h j h c h ; h . T c c h h cc c h h h c h c h .
H, h c h c h c h h , . T, h x h c cc cc q h .58 o , c h c c h
58 A. bh & A. F, ch
R , 2002, . 923.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
87/244
wHy tH wAy w CsR tH by AttRs 75
1, c c h h hc , : - , .. h , ,
.T - cc
h h . ch hc c h hch x . H, - g : .
acknowledgements
A bjw gg. p, , H m . T h Rch jc Ch bccc
cx, Gc bhc C, h 6h scc sc. 59
59 . , 2002, . 185210.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
88/244
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
89/244
2Aty A CARFR tH RsCtv F
-F-F Cs-AG
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
90/244
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
91/244
At As sbstbstG FRsRG
A b sh1
wh ilburg University (Netherlands)
w d m,
chch chch c, v t h dz, c R pz, p, g Rg, bcch ch h .
m, mg, h Chc Gh, , h R c , Zc Rch H u c . ch . b. ch , z , c
ch . h h ch ch chchch . v : Ach chc b c c zc,
1 b F: K-W Merks, A: s F, :A
May, R Charbonnier(H.), . chch Rgg sg Fg, m
2005, s. 1935.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
92/244
AR-wH Rs80
m g g . vg g , ch, ch , Fch,
G, , , g w, h w .
ch R c ch h ch Q ch h,b C p b H:autonomy, nonmalecence, benecence, justice,
s , sch, Fch Gch.2
, autonomy, .h. A s p. u G A b Zg, hch jch
ch ch chch ch , ch chch . principiumsine qua non, h ch , ch .
A, A Az Fc Z b T A3 R, g m.4 w ggch ch Z, ch
2 v. G Rager, ch h, : x T ch,b. 7, 3. A, 1998, s. 5961.
3 A. A Fc, R A. ch A Fg b pg,:A Autiero, S Goertz,M Striet(H.), ch A. hchhch , 2004,s. 283303.
4 ., 287.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
93/244
At As sbstbstG 81
b, wch . chh ch b, Agg, F- ,
, d R R Ag R . A d s- pgg bg bg A s R. ch bj g R b : F
Rg g ... gg p . d , -g p s g g . g R-g ..., wg g ch ch , ch j sch ch .5
ch A , c Gc , -c c cz w G A s bchchch Z .
sch ch chch chch wch A () h, hbz c w c cc bc-h () ch, ch F
5 3. G bch 1.11.2004, . 7; ://.-.; z p-g 5.11.2004, : ://.j..//
ch/791.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
94/244
AR-wH Rs82
ch chchch Fch (c) sj .
1. wRtsCHtZG R At: At- As sbstbstG AsvRAtwRtCHt
A , gg, pch h, h . s g m.6 d
h b , g b m g g - , Fh w, hc Ac A , Rc ch ch, h h .
g , g G A-
t g pg wg h. v h ch A A ch . Hh v , ch ch chch , , gg j, m , j
. d F Ac -ch ch A sj H. F ch.
d , , , , vg Gch h,
6 A. A Fc, ..., s. 287.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
95/244
At As sbstbstG 83
chch s sj h ch .
ch h, A
Gc v sh F ch Gch ch ch G , F , gg . d sg ch R.
g A g v
ch H. H h ch Ch wch . F bH. bg . s G wch ch h wch ch H h . w , s, F ch chh ch .
A z.b. bc- , zc R, cc c , c cA. ch , ch A b sch.
sch h ch , F , Rch s
, g F , ch F ch ch . F h ch w , c Rc, c c R , ch h. b G A , g, bg h: s h Zh chch
w. A z c vc. d
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
96/244
AR-wH Rs84
j , h Ah.7
Zg g , -
g m Ggchch v . G ch, d G , d cc , (. vc , G 33). w c z.b. z? j Z, ch ch Z ch h
ch, ch h Rc ch w , c F ch chch ch w Gch. h ch ch (R. G). h: w ch wch tch, ch ()ch w ch, h h, F ch
ch, ch ch , , , Gch w . ch h sj, h, j , j h G, . Fch, h G ch , g w: v G s, Fg h, sch ch ch G,
ch s wch, ch, , ch sch bch,
7 vg. Fg : K-W Merks, s A-. wg s G b b, : A. A, s. G, . s (H.), ch A. p g- pg, 2004, . 34-42; : K-W Merks, G .
Tch h h, 1998.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
97/244
At As sbstbstG 85
wch w wch, t g. A sg ch ch , G
ch ch G ch.b A sg s g
h ch ch F, ch andere, chch F, , ch , Gute j H h , chch .
d Hg A - m pg,8 zc. G p G -g sj h t h. , z v
.d v c c - sj ch ch. s h A, sg sj , F m - g, gg ( ). v ch s. A j v. Ach jch, , , g (h ) h sj (.h. G sj) ,
8 A: K-W Merks, --. d -g gg, : J Jans (Hg.), bg g
h , t 1996, s. 6472.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
98/244
AR-wH Rs86
, ch h ch ch ch chchch ch w Gch.
ug sj -
sj ( ich , , ch ). wch h v h , h ch ch j wch h b g . d sj h schch schch.
2. bGRZG bttGv At
A vg , Ach ch wh , j bg Z ch w G.
d z c c c cc bc- Rch.
Rg gh F Rchchh Rchch, v, , , , Gch. ch , g m g :, Gh, h, b, F . . Rch G, chh .
d c F c G w, Zg F .d c F F, A A, ch Fh whh, whh Gch,
Hch.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
99/244
At As sbstbstG 87
c c p bg w, g , ch innerebch
ch s .w g
ch? ch F,
sh h.F g g j
s, G Fg s g . j -ch, ch h , c, Rc , c- t, , Ach h h ch H ch .
Fc, c F z ,h : w ch Fh h s, h sh?
F sg g. d , ch Fh , ch t, s . g . F, m s-s , g , c . d c c , s, g,
, sc, ch T. g j , F g -
mg , s gg ch h . ch ch F () F, ch ch h A h , b F ch , b, Fh ch
g s g , G
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
100/244
AR-wH Rs88
ch h , s h Fh .
A T s pgg g-
: w F g s, Fg R g g bh, ch h Zh s, h?
g F , gg w . d , ch Rch, ch chj, w , c F .
H selbst Rch ch Fh, h F, R g? H g ch ch, ch F. v ch b, F sgch , ch Fh s, h, ch t ch h F ch A
chh ? w s Fh, , , j ch ch: ch?
t s F ch ch Fh, ch ch G Fh.
d A m x Fg s ch Fh ch.
A w Fh. ch g: w s, w Fchh A Rch h. Achch T. w h , , ch F ch s Z chch s, , ch, A , c, c, z uc chch h. ,
ch, s ch.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
101/244
At As sbstbstG 89
A ch ch Rch, ugg s, gs A g,
c z c, c z, - z c z c. d c z .
3. At FRsRGCHt
ch ch ch . A Accc A , c Ac -
. c c z c vc s . ch ch, G A G chchF . G A A- - bz, relationale Autonomie, z -c. c c c,
gg Gg s Fh (ethics o care) c, , ch , h s .
m v Gg g- Z s g Fg. v ch v Gch Rch ch h, j j .
Gh h ch h F vchh s , ch H g g g , ch, G
A g, g , pc ,
, ,
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
102/244
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
103/244
At As sbstbstG 91
Fg .b. g , h wch vch wh ch Z .
ch whh. wch , ch ch A , h w ch ch . Hch wch ch Rch sh j .
Fg g g ch, ch v A
ch h G chch R pc z . v G Fch ch ch ch ch A R ch v.
Fg v ch Rch. Ach Rch F .wh ch vch , ch . jch
c ; c . w c z Fc , b bh Rch. v h ch h A G, ch p, p g ug , s h ch ch bh ch .
3.2 ii i , m z l zhelen, ondern uch, wenn e n der Zeit it, ihr steren zui
c A c -g, x g , v pg- Gh h , ch Ach j
bg g
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
104/244
AR-wH Rs92
A h ch ch ,ch A ch h.
Hh h h F H
, g , ch h ch ch , , b m , , ch ch h h. , Gz zc c . Ac c jch s
ch ( A, h ch b), c Rcc z , R .
c Gzz c c. A c ch A h, ch q h, q, G H ch ch; q,
, G Gchh . Z b: m ug bg, H .
v ch ch Fch h ch bh h. ch ch ch .. j Rch b
ch s (1998; 2004). g gg g w
b , s Gch: ch b H ch G s, h ch sh. s ch h , h A ch h s. Ach
F Fch.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
105/244
At As sbstbstG 93
3.3 ii i az zi, pf, i b bi
ch ,
v , b z.gg g g s . h R ch ch bh , h , ch mg g , ch Chc b h, Fg vgg g
c j c c c h . ch ch j F A .
h: A ch h, h ch ch h .
w g , H-
gg gg s g g b g .11
11 d Fg .b. , G g vg ch. h chch v ch h t A. Hj A c -c Azz c c
G ch h ch hch Gh Z, F h , h (A van Heijst, h vch ... (v Tch Fc t,29.1.2001, -p, ://../c///ch/h/hj.h). v. ch h bj z Z z, F uc , j Z j :Avan Heijst, v z ,c :
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
106/244
AR-wH Rs94
w b , g b . u gg g ,
Gch . w Rch .
A ch ch , ch , . A ch F h, ch .
hch Rx, :J Jans(H.), F Fh c, Fc -w z 65. G, F/
F 2004, s. 251264.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
107/244
At FRsRG
Rch
v
Gttingen University (Germany)
1. tG d g s
A b . A c c z c Rc, F c c - . A jch ch ch h, h h v.
pg g Fg h. F h ch Rc z b A v z F sch ch Rch h (2.), w sh (3.).
2. At FRsRG RCHt1
R g A sg m g, g Ag m R
1 d 2. A g g G g Lipp, F Fg. d m R,
t 2000.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
108/244
vR 96
Rg. s Fg R, Fg m , bg . d
A Ag v , g - g Gg Agg Gch.
2.1 mii, hii
zi v
chch A ch b ch Rch g, . Hgg(Gg, g, ggg,dg .), bg sg.dMndigkeit g Zg R Fgg Ag A-
c A . unmittelbare Handlungsunhigkeit Z ch A Rg , g - . s jg Rg. dBetreuung F, b z- ch h ch, chch ch . d A H H- Rchh ch sch v b. elterliche Sorge h
A, h. H A, chjh () ch.
vchch h ch ch s bg w F
G. s A. 1 2, 3 GG .
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
109/244
At FRsRG 97
F mR g g g. A Hgg v- h chch G h Rch
cz b Rc. d Gz A, ch Gch , Gch ch hch .d p Fg A. 6 GG, A. 8 R, Fh b ch ch A. 6 GG, A. 8
R .2.2 vz i hii
i b
wg g bg sg G A mg Ag G
ch, ch Rchh (), ch h, g Ag g (- Hh, .b. 104 . 2 bGb) ch(bg, 1896 bGb) . s g vg g bg s .
dc H - Hc, j cc H g Fg chchch 7jh c (. 104 . 1bGb). b , Fh b Ach b h j c 14-J zc, 14 J ch ch Rch
tch Ah.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
110/244
vR 98
A A ch j F (ch chch) , ch Gch chch
c H b h v, v .. .
z vz Hh ch h ch chch h bg H, A chch Zch chch A h H.
d dg Fg, , R . J , cc F, zR , 7-j-g . u g-, -, -,g- ggg gg j, Fg, bg g
jg R ,
chchch 7Jh c. Gch, -, g-, - ggg c A c Gz. v-chh h ch ch t j Rch chch A. Ach R Gc c cc A j Rc-
c z. ccc H z z. Gg gg g , .. sg Gch Gchh.
2.3 a b
b h A b ch w . s Hgg -
, g
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
111/244
At FRsRG 99
Z v ch. sch b ch chch , ch ch
g g g Gh v ch h .
d g g bg Z - b vchch A b ch s. vchch ch
g Fg , g H b jc b.d Ag bg vgch ch v , b sch ch. b ch cz F. ( c vc-ch) h h , ch b ch wch
ch vchchg G Ag bg . v- sch j , b g, b . dvchch , bch, .h. ch b .
s H bg H R g,
w cc Hc. cz c b c Handeln im Rechtsver-kehrh ch v ( 1902 bGb) h ( 1903 bGb). A c, b ch ch b , ch
c z . d b
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
112/244
vR 100
F g, vg sch b ch , .h. ch b w g
vchch G A b h.
ch v h ch jch ch , b Selbstschdigung durch aktische Einwirkungen ch. H bg b, g gg. gg b ch chch H
wc, .. c w, z (Bestimmungsbeugnis). c A bg Ag ugg, Zh; .b. ch G wh b. Achch sch b ch h chch ch chch
. b bgg ,
ermchtigt einen Dritten Ag, gg Ggg vg, b ch G d . d G G G-gg Fg b ( 1906
v bGb). J Fhh ch b h hch.
2.4 w w b
Binnenstruktur bg g F g jwh uerungsunhigen b (1901 bGb) b
b wch uerungshigen b,
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
113/244
At FRsRG 101
wh ch ch ( 1901 1 bGb). A 1901 bGb h ch F.
b 1901 bGb h j wh .
b, b wc uerungshigen b G z c , c c A j jwch, sch b ch .
b uerungsunhig h ch h wch , , b ch . F F h 1901 bGb
Z b, c -j sch b .A Gg A A
hch, x wch h c: s ch .b. Hc rztlicheBehandlung Ac b c b , wh ch
sgg . A Zg-h wch b , wch Ac ch , gg g ch bh ch b, h bg g c c z . F bh wch b . v b b cc, c G .
dAuenverhltnis c A vc b pc zc-. s h s b Rch Rchh,
c . d A
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
114/244
vR 102
h G ch b. s Rechtsverkehrmit dem Betreuer G, F A.
Gch Rechtsverkehr mit dem Betreuten. b b. Gch Rchchh vh b. ch b b ch, chg g g ch, ch sch ch 104 . 2, 105 bGb ( Gchh, h)
gg. d m- b, s b h . b b ch A 104 . 2, 105 bGb . d F Gc- b h G ch . , b b h h chch
g . , ug g, .h. A , chchch ch h .
3. At FRsRG A bs:
RbAt R s GAt stRbHF
d bg , bh rztlich indiziert g Patientenautonomie p R g, gg bg -.2 b t G jch h
2 v. Lipp, ch. Z
g Rgg s, 2005, 5, 11 .; aupitz,
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
115/244
At FRsRG 103
. d d3 g ch R h. w ch d , das
geltende Recht (3.13.4), rechtspo-litischen Debattes (3.5).
3.1 di ei r4
Z bg Rg g -, wc p ( )5 zc z ,
ch G , ( sh).6 Zch jh F, ch v hh ccc G.7 d c jch G h .8
Gch A 63. ch J (Jt), 2000, A 12 .; Verrel,Gch C 66. Jt, 2006, C 70 .
3 ch bch sh . .g ://.-.//-.h (s: A 2007); . . . ch F.
4 v. ch Verrel(F. 2), C 13 .5 BGHSt(c bc c) 37,
376 (379); 40, 257 (262).6 BGHSt42, 301 (305); 46, 279 (284 .).7 BGHZ(g bg Z)
154, 205 .; Lipp, Zch Fch (FRZ)2004, 317 .; BGHZ163, 195 . . A. Lipp/Nagel, -, bGH-Rg (m) 2006 (b- d-, 166262).
8 c Lipp, (F. 2), 5 .; Verrel(F. 2),
C 15 ., C 34 .
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
116/244
vR 104
w h ch G ch bh ( 3.2), R v ( 3.3) b
( 3.4) ch Rch .
3.2 zi b l
a Rechtliche Struktur der rztlichen Behandlung
F bg m j bh. ch
s bg vg A , ch b c c z . chch chch v:
Az cc uc, d - h h j . ch, ch h .9
A h h kein bhch. Rch ch bh ch A . J ch h ch , . b h h z c A c Az .10 d p-
bh j h, ch ch ch b bh Z .
9 Z vh Deutsch/Spickhof, ch, 5. A. 2003,R. 16, 187; Uhlenbruck, : /hc, Hch Ach,3. A. 2002, 52 R. 9.
10 BGHZ29, 46 (49 .); BGH Jc wcc (Jw)1980, 1333; BGHJw 1993, 2372 (2373 .); . Laus, : /h
c (F. 9), 61 R. 14 ., 63.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
117/244
At FRsRG 105
vch w (.b. H) ch ch.11
chch G ch bh
ch, , Ach bh . h ch bh Gg. d v, Aunahmebg, A, Durchhrung gg p.12 A - h , h
.13
b A p gg w,h . h
Abwehrrechtgg A gg bg, -ch h Ach bh. F , .b. bhh .14 v
A bh , ch .15 z, c c
cch wch chh.16
11 BGHZ163, 195 (199); Kohte, Ach cch x (Ac)185 (1985), 105 (137 .); Deutsch/Spickhof(F. 9), R. 197.
12 BGHZ154, 205 (210 ., 212); 163, 195 (197); BGHSt37, 376 (378);
Verrel(F. 2), C 37 .13 BGHZ163, 195 (197 .).14 Z v . Spickhof, Jw 2000, 2297 (2298);
aupitz(F. 2), A 25 .15 bGHZ 154, 205 (224); Laus, Jw 1998, 3399 (3400); Spickhof,
Jw 2000, 2297 (2298); aupitz(F. 2), A 23 .16 OLG Karlsruhezc (R) 2003, 104 .; OLG Dsseldor
Zc vcc (vR) 2002, 611; OLG Kln vR 2000,
492; Deutsch/Spickhof(F. 9), R. 12, 198.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
118/244
vR 106
H bGH , , - R , Az b .17 ch, ch
F18 z Gc p ,19 ch vch A .20
b Hile im Sterben und Hile zum Sterben
s, bhg .21 u g . G h ch H b s, H s.22 bh ch G ch A ch . ch h h h jch ehlenden rztli-chen Indikation ch wch h.23
17 BGHZ154, 205 (225).18 Spickhof, Jw 2003, 1701 (1709); aupitz(F. 2), A 24.19 Borasio/Putz/Eisenmenger, d (db) 2003, A
2062 (2064).20 Ankermann, R 1999, 387 (389); Dodegge/Fritsche, J
(J) 2001, 176.21 v. G b (b) ch
sgg 30.4.2004, Z. ., db 2004, A 1298; Schreiber,Fch ch, 1999, 773 .; Opderbecke/Weiauer, R 1998, 395(397); Saliger, ch vjhch G Rchch (v) 2001, 382 (424.).
22 BGHSt40, 257 (260).23 Ankermann, R 1999, 387 (389); Lipp, : /G/
s/s, sh: h ch R?,2002, 37 (52 .); Schwab, : ch bGb (ch
), 4. A. 2002, 1904 bGb R. 38.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
119/244
At FRsRG 107
H Az z, , h . h h h
gg, A m -.24 s p , g g, A ch h h . F sh, .h. t v ( 216 sGb). vhh ch H s bh wch .25
d ug H s
sh H s
F ch chch G h h: s , . H sgg g, m g , ch h.26
d 1. bGH c 1994 -h, G , ch vg Z .27 dAbgrenzungskriterium h 12. Z bch 17.3.2003 Gch ch c28
24 BGHZ163, 195 (197 .); g. Wagenitz, FRZ 2005, 669(671).
25 Z v c Lipp, : p (F. 23),41 .; Huen, Jw 2001, 849 (851).
26 v. BGHSt40, 257 (260); Lipp, (F. 2), 16 .;Verrel(F. 2), C 77 ., C 99 .
27 BGHSt40, 257 (260), H () Rc b, Z. .., R 1985, 38. h Rch (F. 21), Z., ch v h F, t Z .
28 Deutsch, Jw 2003, 1567; Lipp, FRZ 2003, 756.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
120/244
vR 108
chch G Z sh : h vch h h sh .29 ch G x jch
ch 1. s ch ch .30 s g gg g s-g p, . u. gg wg .31 d c h s ch .32 A ch chch G sh s(H s) ch hch . Ach
. ch h Rchchh .33
3.3 d ii pi i v
a Die Augabe des Vertreters
h, A ch h ch ch h ch c. d cc F Rch s ch .34
v bh (.b. ) h A z , c
29 BGHZ154, 205 (214 .).
30 v. BGHSt40, 257 (260 .); Kutzer, Zch Rch(ZR) 2003, 213 .
31 Huen, ZR 2003, 248 (252).32 BGHZ 163, 195 (200 .).33 vg. b Ag 66.
Jt 2006 . h h bh, h://.j..
34 Lipp, d Rg (dRZ) 2000, 231 (233 .); Hing,
Jch sch (Js) 2000, 111 (113 .); Huen, Jw 2001, 849 (850 .).
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
121/244
At FRsRG 109
ch Ach h.35 F Vertreter s Rch hh ch . H ch
g v ,36 vg b g v . vchch ch 1908
A. 1, 1846 bGb s b -ch. ch , Arzt37 G Gchh h A ( 677 .bGb) z., c ,
c p .
38
H p v g, vch . . R. bhch. vg b gg gGh . ch ch , h .39 v Ghh h jch ch Ag, A gg bg - h. h h Rch p gesamten Behandlungsprozessz.
b Handlungsmastab r den Vertreter
v A vc c j , bcch A, b ch 1901 A. 2 3 bGb. Ach
35 Deutsch/Spickhof(F. 9), R. 199; Wagenitz, FRZ 2005, 669 (671).36 1896 A. 2 s. 2 bGb.37 Z vg vg BGHZ29, 46 (52); BGH
Jw 1966, 1855 (1856); Lipp, bchch x (bx) 2002,47 (51) ...
38 Deutsch/Spickhof(F. 9), R. 83.39 BGHZ154, 205 (214); 163, 195 (198); ch/Schwab (F.
23), 1904 bGb R. 38.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
122/244
vR 110
Rh Gh h ch h bch. b ch wch ch. ch, wch h
h ( 665, 1901 A. 3 s. 1 bGb).40 v wch ch,
Agg p .41 v . d bg mutmalichen Willen .42 ch w p jc c cc wch.43 h ch h Entscheidungsma-
stab v.44
F b ch 1901 A. 2 bGb p subjektiveWohlg.d v w v- p, .. c, w cch. Rc p g, w vg p .45 -
g Fg bg b c c cw j wh sch :46 v h ch ,
40 Baumann/Hartmann, d -Z (dZ) 2000,594 (608 .); Lipp, bx 2002, 47 (49).
41 665 bGb . 1901 A. 3 s. 3 bGb.
42 Palandt/Sprau, bGb, 66. A. 2007, 665 bGb R. 6; Czub, :b-R, bc-o bGb, 1.7.2006, 665 bGbR. 16.
43 Hing/Rixen, J (JZ) 2003, 884(892 .).
44 Lipp, FRZ 2004, 317 (322 .).45 Hahne, FRZ 2003, 1619 (1621); Lipp, bx 2002, 47 (49 .).
F BGHZ154, 205 (218 .) cch .
46 Baumann/Hartmann, Z 2000, 594 (609 .).
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
123/244
At FRsRG 111
ch h. s ch , h ch v . Ach h R R
, ch ch h ch R : .47
c Vormundschatliche Genehmigung
g , v Ggg vg g, m- .48 d 12. Z bGH
b 15.3.2003 G j, j Ag 1904 bGb g, - G bg g.49 d u, Ggg v-chch h , h s bch 8.6.2005 :50 Gh c, Az ,
sch ch , v jch H w h ch A . g Ggg h F ch A b h, .h. ch ch w ch . h ch ch, b h A ch h
h ch.51
47 Huen, Jw 2001, 849 .48 Z d ccc G
Lipp, (F. 2), 41 .49 BGHZ154, 205 (219 .).50 BGHZ163, 195 . . A. Lipp/Nagel, m 2006 (b
166262, F. 7).
51 s ch Lipp, FRZ 2004, 322 .
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
124/244
vR 112
d b p G- chch ch, w p s .52 d Ggg
prventiven Kontrolle v sch sg p,53 g, ch h h w p g . Zg GggRchchh v b.54
bGH h Gh F b Gch bch . h ,
ch Bevollmchtigten , ch 1904 A.2 bGb Ghch . bGH h b A 1904 bGb ch h G Ggg v , bch ch ch .
3.4 di pia Formen von Patientenvergungen und ihre rechtliche
Verbindlichkeit
vgg g , p G A ,.b. v g bg.55 A
p zc v, h bh .
52 Huen, ZR 2003, 248 (251 .).53 BGHZ154, 205 (216 ., 223, 227).54 BGHZ154, 205 (218 ., 227); .b. OLG KarlsruheFRZ
2002, 488 (490); Bauer, bx 2002, 60 (62).55 Deutsch/Spickhof(F. 9), R. 199; Wagenitz, FRZ 2005, 669
(671).
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
125/244
At FRsRG 113
Hg g p gg A, h . h . sch
Hc bh .56 Ach h 12. Z g.57 F gantizipierte Einwilligungz. A p G j gg.58 s wg, bh w . d F ch A ch A ,
ch . s A, ch , g g, g Ah w .59
g g p-gg Wnsche, Einstellungen und Werthaltungen p .60 d mg g Rch, v A
. c p
56 z.b. Rc b (F. 21), Z. v. v.; . c Hg b ugg p-, b. 1999, A 2720, Z. 1.1.; aupitz(F. 2), A 105 .; Lipp,RZ 2000, 231 (234).
57 BGHZ154, 205 (210 .).58 Z F aupitz(F. 2), A 28 .; Wagenitz, FRZ 2005,
669 (671); Lipp, : sh (F. 23), 43 .; Hch b ugg pgg, db. 1999, A2720, Z. 6.
59 Rch b (F. 21), Z. v.;Eisenbart, p- sg Gg-h, 2. A. 2000, 67; Baumann/Hartmann, Z 2000, 594 (608.); ch .b. aupitz(F. 2), A 115.
60 vg. .b. Sass/Kielstein, pgg bg-
ch, 2. A. 2003, 50 ., 58; Wagenitz, FRZ 2005, 669 (671).
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
126/244
vR 114
Ah, s chh.61 s ch w .j wh h bch
. b ch G.62 p c. d Grad ihrer
Verbindlichkeit , c v Az s .
b Notwendigkeit der Auslegung einer Patientenvergung
J pgg Agg.63
s A j, ch ch, .h. A, v Agg.64 s tx ch ch ch , g, p (g. 133 bGb). b Fg p pcch, h , ch , c, c. v H h .65
c Patientenvergung und Vertreter
d v pgg g- w p gg G66
61 v pgggenerell , . .b. Laus, Jw 1998, 3399 (3400); Deutsch/Spickhof(F. 9),R. 513 .
62 3.3..63 Palandt/Diederichsen (F. 42), 1896 bGb R. 9 ..; Roth, JZ
2004, 494 (498 .).64 Roth, JZ 2004, 494 (500 .).65 Z A Roth, JZ 2004, 494 (499 .).
66 3.3..
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
127/244
At FRsRG 115
g. d w p g , .b. A pg h bch
. d bGH c A b z- , w b A pg g vg () A Gg .67 b bg g- Fg , vch . h vg gg b Ag ( 1908, 1837, 1908 bGb) . z c bc ( 1896 A. 3 bGb) ( 1908 A. 1 s. 1, 1846 bGb).
Auenverhltnis gg A gg -g v g.68 dg pgg A . d bg c Gz c v-ch, .h. v ch ch w
Az .69 Az vchch .
d Bestellung eines Betreuers trotz Patientenvergung?
pgg bg b Rg nicht entbehrlich. , pgg gg
ch ch, ch.70
67 BGHZ154, 205 (211); 163, 195 (198).68 BGHZ163, 195 (198 .); g. Wagenitz, FRZ 2005, 669
(672).69 Lipp, (F. 2), 35 .70 Lipp, bpx 2002, 47 (51 .); .b. Vosseler, bpx
2002, 240 (241).
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
128/244
vR 116
p cc F v. s b v , F b
vg. w F gg , ch ch . h A ch v h G Fh, b v ch, . , v ch.
3.5 Z ii d i d71
s bch bGH 8.6.200572
F c . d c c uc-h chch G sh gg g 1. s bGH73 . Ach xh Rchchh h jch hch ch H. jch
Strarecht, ch Zch ch v. , h h Z h ch v bh chch , h h ch .74
bc Vorsorgemglichkeiten x zc R-
b vch, ch b v p c .75
71 vg. Lipp, p (F. 2), ; Lipp/Nagel, F Fch (FF) 2005, 83 .
72 BGHZ163, 195 .73 Z bGHs 40, 257 . h F. 27.74 Verrel(F. 2), C 78 .
75 3.3..
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
129/244
At FRsRG 117
R p c v zA g, bg A p ch ch , G
, Rg R -c h. Ach h h ch ch G Rg76kein Handlungsbedar r den Gesetzgeber, hch b chA Rch.
ch h ch R c. F c A
, ch b.
a Reichweite der Patientenvergung
c d g R pgg. q- R m- h ch, F
F , G bg t h .77 Z t ch . d dc J- R bj ch ch cch .78 sch ch h hjch ch Rch ,
F, ch h sh
76 3.4..77 Z pgg 13.9.2004, b-
c. 15/3700 (: q, ), s. 38.78 bch 66. Jt 2006 (F. 2); R 3.
bcz 1.11.2004 (: R-, R), s. 13, 18 ., c .. Lipp, (F.
2), 65 .
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
130/244
vR 118
h h ch , chch .79
b Wirksamkeitsvoraussetzungen r eine Patientenvergung? px pgg
h chch , h bch ch. Z ch ch ch. h chch w ch , ch F ch .80
cc d c ,
schritliche . Z t ch h Beratung.81 sch gch .82 A ch, ch b .83 A ch w .84
aa Schritorm?
ch F h, . Ah h G vch h , ch ch . w ch, hjch G, h ch ch vch cc . G
79 v. b Verrel(F. 2), C 85 .80 sh 3.4..81 Z.b. b- R-p
b s sgg 23.4.2004, - .jz.. (: b- R-pz(R), s. 42 .
82 EK(F. 77), 40 .; . ch RP(F. 81), 42 .83 RP(F. 81), 42 .
84 (F. 77), 41; RP(F. 81), 43.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
131/244
At FRsRG 119
c p G c , H , ch ch sch , .b. h.85
A A q- .b. w ch .86 Z bchh ch sch ch.
Fc : v bh A Ah h, . A b
bch A h F c. d c p-g g g v g g Agg wch. h bch ch Z ch A g b (bggg, 1901 bGb)
bch ( 665 bGb) , h h h c c . zc c , sch ch G ch.
bb Beratungspicht?
Hchch A ch F, ch. chch b ch ch h , v v . - A h ch bh h , ch ch. Z
85 s Zg Roth, JZ 2004, 494(497).
86 EK(F. 77), 42 .
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
132/244
vR 120
A v pggch.87
Gch A
Wahrnehmung des Selbstbestimmungsrechts p; p .88 d Ag w- ch b ch h bg sg p R-gg. bg h ch, b ch A bz z -
. bch ch j , t ch h . H ch hch s ch bh hg F g, p bg g bg sg Gch ch ch ch. bch Interesse des Arztes
ch , A,gg . A . s A ch ;89 ch h w .
. bg g pgg g, v h chch vch h .
c Patientenvergung und Vertreter
t ch, b v ch. s .b. ch
87 RP(F. 81), 42 ., A, ch ch ch.
88 v. aupitz(F. 2), A 28 .
89 Deutsch/Spickhof, (F. 9) R. 197.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
133/244
At FRsRG 121
vch q ch ch chw v z-
w cz b .90b wg bg
: Erstens w p b b-c c 1901 A. 3 . 1, 1901 bGb z. 665 bGb c ch, ch ch .91 z, z Enquete-Kommis-sion ch h G, h h
bg g. Zweitens w 1901 A. 3 s. 1 bGb Ah A;92 vch h. Drittens - cc bgg w p , Ah h .93 v wh ch h h.
d Verahrensregelungen: Konsil und Vormundschatsgericht g R, jg R-
g g , gGgg () , A ()h h h ch, v jch h.94 wh ch vchch
, ch Ach Ghch bch .
90 (F. 77), 41, . ch ReE(F. 78), 23.91 sh 3.3..92 BGHZ154, 205 (216 .).93 v. BVerGE(ch bch)
58, 208 (225); BVerGbx 1998, 144 (145).
94 3.3.c.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
134/244
vR 122
aa Konsil?
Z g, Konsil A, b,pg Agg ,
Genehmigung des Vormundschatsgerichts .G bg g.95 d bg bcch Ac c,96 z c vchch chh .97
d Ag , p d v ,
w . g p Rc vzch: h bh. ch ch , wch vg p . Ag -, , .98 obligatorisches Konsil jc vc w ch , ch
c c , w z zz. d z c 99 ch chch ch.
bb Regelmige Einschaltung des Vormundschatsgerichts?
d Ggg vg b. s ,
b R p sch . ch v
95 EK(F. 77), 44.96 EK(F. 77), 43 .97 EK(F. 77), 44 .98 EK(F. 77), 43 cch ; ReE
(F. 78), 21.
99 ReE(F. 78), 21.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
135/244
At FRsRG 123
q- s Ghch h.100
v b-
gg g, ch A b bh ch w ch .101 w b h ablehnt, ch Ach
A w p -, g F . d gg v b A ch ch h.
F gg ch Ghch ch. A sch sch vz vc w , g , p . bh h vh ch . s b A j , g bg g-
. F R ch chh sch: J ch vc c vcc ; - - s, A b p .102 - ch vchch hc c. Gc z c
ch Zh ; h.103
100 EK(F. 77), 44 .101 s ch ReE(F. 78), 23.102 Z vh ReE(F. 78), 23.103 Zh , Ah
b , . BVerGE 58, 208 (225); BVerG
bx 1998, 144 (145).
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
136/244
vR 124
dc umassende Genehmigungspicht abzulehnen. v- h Rch, .h. Ghch , Az b
w h .104
cc Keine Genehmigungspicht r Bevollmchtigte?
Z gg, Ggg bc z zc -ch . Fch 1904 A. 2 s.2bGb vch h jch ch F.105
vch bch, , Az zh sch w ch, c, p F zc .106 , vc- b z vzc bausdrcklich schritlich ( 1904 A. 2 bGb),
b . bh h challgemeine Missbrauchskontrollech vchch, j g v-. ( 1896 A. 3 bGb) ( 1908 A. 1 s. 1, 1846 bGb).107
ch h Ach Ghch bch h chch b.
c F, v vc
104 sh 3.3.c.105 R (F. 78), 13, 24.106 ReE(F. 78), 24; Ag (AG) p
bjz (z-), bc 10.6.2004, 49 ., ://.j..//-/695/bch_AG_..
107 ReE(F. 78), 24;AG(F. 106), 49 .
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
137/244
At FRsRG 125
ch ch , ch bch w vchch , bh Rh ch.108
3.6 Zur Notwendigkeit einer gesetzlichen Regelung
s bch bGH 8.6.2005109 zivilrecht-lichen Fragen ch . chh g strarechtlichen Grenzen s gg g 1. s bGH110 . ccc c,
Rchchh h , jch c c. d Gz , ccRch . chch R ch ch. G bch , chchch bch c ch.
108 RP(F. 81), 60.109 BGHZ163, 195 .
110 Z bGHs 40, 257 . h F. 27.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
138/244
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
139/244
3CAR FRs F Rssbty?
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
140/244
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
141/244
tH ts F sCRs tHCsCCRG tH Rssbty twAR
AtR, HA AAs,A FtR GRAts1
c Purdue University (USA)
1. IntroductIon
c u 1918-19, x w c: ethics o ultimate ends ethics o responsibility. , c h h h , h Ch h h h h h , h
cc h c.2
h, h h x hc c ch , h c , h h , h h h , G h h h, h .3 h c, h c c the goodnessor perection o the people c h cc
h cc h objective h c
1 T x Romanian Journal o Bioethics F C R s H d Cq?5(2007):3.
2 x w, Politics as a Vocation, . H. Gh C. wh (hh: F , 1965), . 47.
3 .
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
142/244
CA RAR130
g hch h c.4
c w h h hc
hc c h h hh xc . H J, hhc, h h hc h cc c conditions or the persistence o lie in the uturec . A h c h hch h h fc. T,praxish ,
g , g g. g x x .5 Agh , q : h c h h h h x x ?
J c h cc h cc
h c h h xc h c.wh h c , c J. x, c c cc c, c c- c . J hc hch h h h ch h h h. H
c hc, c hc, h ch J? h c h x
4 ., . 45.5 m, R A. m, C G. m,
G A. b. Fc & J , b c- , Nature, 403 (24 F. 2000), . 853-8, ,
t h , International Wildlie, 12 (s./c. 1991), . 5.
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
143/244
tH ts F sCRs tHCs 131
cc jc hch c (c cc) xj? ,
h c , h , ?
h , h hch h q Jg H .. A. m h c. F, H cc hh chc h. c h cc
c hc. h , h cc h H hc . sc, cq h h . , h c h , h , . T cq , , cc h hch rationalizable, h
h h, fcc h cc hc cc .
2. communIcatIve actIon
as source or normatIvIty
u H A, H g cc . T ch h jc g g . q , H H A g. F, g g- g .6 s, x
6 J H, Teory o Communicative Action (: bc
, 1984), . 1, . 378. (H CA.)
-
7/28/2019 Autonomy, Responsability and Self Care
144/244
CA RAR132
j-j jc jc.7 F H, h c jc jc
h c , h jc h jc h h c