Attention and Consciousness “Millions of items … are present to my senses which never properly enter into my experience. Why? Because they have no interest for me. My experience is what I agree to attend to … each of us literally chooses, by his ways of attending to things, what sort of a universe he shall appear to himself to inhabit”
William James, 1890, Principles of Psychology
Sensory Systems modulated by Attentional Systems
a Single Photon
a Single molecule
a Single Hair Cell--”pin drop”
What is Attention’s Goal?
Truthful perception of the world is neither required nor necessarily attempted
Conscious experiences focus on gathering information quickly
Details are filled-in to give a sense of continuity to our perceptions
This is the point of attention in general, i.e., to concentrate on what is important
A distinction between attention and consciousness
A common sense distinction between attention and consciousness:
We can ask someone to ‘please pay attention’ but not to ‘please be conscious’. In general, however, when people pay attention to something, they generally become conscious of it.
The common sense distinction between attention and consciousness suggests that there are attentional control mechanisms that often determine what will or will not become conscious …
A distinction between attention and consciousness
A common sense distinction between attention and consciousness:
We can ask someone to ‘please pay attention’ but not to ‘please be conscious’. In general, however, when people pay attention to something, they generally become conscious of it.
The common sense distinction between attention and consciousness suggests that there are attentional control mechanisms that often determine what will or will not become conscious …
Selective attention: voluntary and automatic
In the real world, voluntary and automatic attention are generally mixed. For example, we can train ourselves to pay attention to the new ringtone we found for our cell phone.
When it rings and we suddenly pay attention to it, is that voluntary or automatic?
Visual areas involved in active and passive viewing extend to the parietal lobe
Consciousness William James (1890):
Consciousness is a constantly moving stream of thoughts, feelings, and emotions
Consciousness can be viewed as our subjective awareness of mental events
Functions of consciousness: Monitoring mental events Control: consciousness allows us to formulate and
reach goals Consciousness may have evolved to direct or
control behavior in adaptive ways
Libet’s Half-second Delay
Electrically stimulated patients’ somatosensory cortices during surgery Minimum level of stimulation necessary At this intensity, ½ second of continuous
stimulation before any perception Shorter stimulation requires greater intensity
What Happens to the Lag?
Reaction times can be 200 ms, recognition can take 300-400 ms, but Libet’s delay is 500 ms… Our body responds before we are conscious
of why it is responding Subjective referral: after neuronal
adequacy is reached, the event is referred back to the point at which it occurred
Cortex and Consciousness The dorsolateral prefrontal cortex is
activated during conscious control tasks Subjects asked to name the ink color in the
Stroop task below have difficulty when the word name and color are different
This color-naming task was associated with activation of the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex
Stroop Task
xxxxxxxx
xxxxxxxx
xxxxxxxx
xxxx
xxxx
xxxx
xxxxxxxx
xxxx
xxxx
xxxxxxxx
xxxx
xxxx
xxxx
xxxx
xxxx
xxxx
xxxxxxxx
xxxx
Stroop Task
BlueGreen
RedYellow
BlackRed
Blue
Yellow
Green
BlackBrown
Brown
Blue
RedBlack
Green
Yellow
Brown
Blue
Red
Black
BrownGreen
Yellow
Stroop Task
BlueGreen
RedYellow
BlackRed
Blue
Yellow
Green
BlackBrown
Brown
Blue
RedBlack
Green
Yellow
Brown
Blue
Red
Black
BrownGreen
Yellow
Attention Our conscious awareness is limited in capacity
and we are aware of only a small amount of the stimuli around us at any one time
Attention refers to the process by which we focus our awareness
Three functions of attentional processes: Orienting function toward the environment Control of the content of consciousness
• I will think about this issue but not that one…
Maintaining alertness
The brain basis of conscious experience
Binding features into conscious objects
The concept of feature binding -- combining color, location, shape, and the like into a single neuronal assembly -- is often necessary for visual consciousness. Treisman suggested that an attentional spotlight was required to combine different aspects of a stimulus into a reportable event.
Treisman’s spotlight for binding visual features
Divided Attention Divided attention refers to a
task in which a person is asked to attend to two tasks at the same time Subject may be asked to listen to
one conversation (shadowing) delivered via the left ear
Some information on the other channel (right ear) is processed (as shown in priming tasks)
Central Attention: not just sensory/perceptual
Message 1 Message 2GREEN MARKEGGS BACKFINE ANDRICE HAM
Subjects occasionally reported“green eggs and ham”
This shouldn’t happen if message 2 were completely filtered out—no central attention process..
Attention and the Brain
Michael I. Posner Two attention systems; two functions
Anterior frontal lobe system• Tasks requiring awareness (planning or writing)
Posterior parietal lobe system• Tasks involving visuospatial abilities (playing Tetris,
vigilance tasks)
Reticular Activating System RASArousal
Flow of Consciousness Day-dreams are shifts in attention
toward internal thoughts and imagined scenarios College students may spend as much as
50% of their waking time in a day-dream Beeper studies of high-school students
have noted the predominance of negative thoughts when students are with their families as opposed to others
Psychodynamic View of Consciousness
Freud argued that three mental systems form consciousness Conscious: mental events that you
are aware of Preconscious: Mental events that
can be brought into awareness Unconscious: Mental events that are
inaccessible to awareness; events are actively kept out of awareness
TOT Demonstration
Heavy, broad-bladed knife or hatchet used especially by butchers
Crystalline sugar occurring naturally in fruits, honey, etc.
The independent candidate that ran against Clinton and Bush I.
Do any of these questions put the answer on the tip of your tongue?
Subliminal Perception Notion that brief exposure to sub-threshold stimuli can
influence awareness Study: subjects are shown aggressive (A) or positive (B)
stimuli and then rate a neutral stimulus (C) Subjects shown panel A first subsequently rated the boy in
panel C more negatively
(Figure adapted from Eagle, 1959)
Unconscious Cognitive Processes Information-processing view can be extended to
analyses of unconscious processes Notion is that many brain mechanisms operate
in parallel Some of these mechanisms operate outside of the
level of consciousness Functional significance of unconscious
mechanisms: Are efficient and rapid Can operate simultaneously Operate in the absence of consciousness?
The brain basis of conscious experience
Unconscious comparisons
How can we investigate conscious experience?
Consciousness has been used a a variable, with experiments designed to compare conscious and unconscious conditions in the same experiment using the same stimuli.
Backward masking is used to compare conscious and unconscious perception. Subjects do not perceive the smiling face, but the unconscious face still primes behavior and brain activity
Blindsight People with damage to the central portion
of the occipital cortex are blind in the sense that they are unable to
see objects placed before them are able to provide partial information about
the geometric shape of an object (blindsight) Blindsight may involve a primitive visual
system in the midbrain
Neurology of Consciousness Consciousness is distributed
throughout the brain Hindbrain and midbrain are
important for arousal and for sleep
Damage to the reticular formation can lead to coma
Prefrontal cortex is key for conscious control of information processing
Sleep and Dreaming Behavioral characteristics of sleep
Minimal movement Stereotyped prone posture Require a high degree of stimulation to
arouse organism Physiological characteristics of sleep
Brain wave activity (seen in the EEG) Paralysis of muscles (seen in the EMG) Cardiovascular changes (alternating cycles
of arousal)
Function of Sleep
Memory consolidation Energy conservation Preservation from predators Restoring bodily functions
Sleep deprivation can alter immune function and lead to early death
Sleep deprivation can also lead to hallucinations and perceptual disorder
REM Sleep
Characteristics of REM sleep Presence of rapid-eye-movements Presence of dreaming Increased autonomic nervous system activity EEG resembles that of awake state (beta
wave) Motor paralysis (except for diaphragm)
Dreaming
Psychoanalytic view: Dreams represent a window into the unconscious The latent content (meaning) can be inferred from the
manifest content (the actual dream) Cognitive view: Dreams are constructed from the
daily issues of the dreamer Biological view: Dreams represent the attempt of
the cortex to interpret the random neural firing of the brain during sleep
Altered States of Consciousness
Changes in consciousness can be brought on by Meditation Hypnosis Drug ingestion Religious experiences
The brain basis of conscious experience
Conscious events recruit widespread brain activation
There are many sources of evidence suggesting that the more we are conscious of some event, from visual perception to motor control, the more cortical activity we are likely to find.
Results of an fMRI experiment: brain activation during a sensorimotor task where subjects were asked to tap along with the sound of a metronome. Once trained on the task, the scientists varied the pace of the metronome by 3, 7, or 20%. Cortical activity increased dramatically as a function of the unpredictability of the tapping task.
The brain basis of conscious experience
Fast cortical interactions may be needed for conscious events
It is believed that rhythmic synchrony between different brain regions may signal cooperative and competitive interactions between neuronal populations needed to perform tasks, particularly those that are conscious and under voluntary control.
A summary and some hypotheses
Selective attention to a visual stimulus seems to be guided by parts of the frontal and parietal lobes
Conscious cognition can be shown to recruit frontoparietal regions
Thus selective attention can be thought of as an act of focusing brain resources on visual cortex -- particularly the region where feature analysis and construction seems to take place.
Conscious cognition can be seen as going in the opposite direction, a visual object serving to mobilize cortical regions far beyond visual cortex alone.