Transcript
Page 1: ASME BPVC Pressure Vessel Consul1ng Services 2019 ASME ... · Stresses were classified according to ASME Sec1on VIII, Div. 2. The The evaporator was fabricated with several different

ASMEBPVCPressureVesselConsul1ngServicesASMESec1onVIII,Division2StressandFa1gueAnalysis

1|172019

www.Predic1veEngineering.com

Overthelast20+years,Predic1veEngineeringhastackledsomeofthemostcomplexapplica1onsoftheASMEBPVCSec1onVIII,Division2“Design-by-Analysis”specifica1ons.

•  Stressandfa1gueanalysisoflarge-diameternuclearwasterecyclingvesselsunderNQA-1requirements•  Vesselswithinternalpipingandstructuressubjectedtosloshing,seismicandadded-masseffects•  Transientthermal-fa1gueofthick-walledtanks•  LiZingandtransporta1onanalyses•  BucklinganalysisviaASMEformulas,EulerianandNonlinearmethods•  Differen1althermal-stressanalysisofheatexchangeshavingmixedmaterials

Withinthisbodyofpressurevesselconsul1ngwork,wehaveappliedthefollowingcodes:•  ASMEBPVCSec1onVIII,Division2stressandfa1gue•  ASCE4-98withadded-massapplica1onsfornormalmodesanalysis•  ASCE7-02,AISIN690andABS

Totakeourengineeringworktothenextlevel,ourpressurevesselconsultantshavewri`encustomsoZwareforstressandfa1gueevalua1onofthinandthick-walledpressurevesselsandwhenneededbeenabletoperformop1miza1onstudiesonvesselsviaExcelspreadsheetviaourFEAsoZware’sapplica1onprograminginterface.

Insummary,ourcarefulandme1culousanalysisworkhasallowedustoclassifytanksandvesselsas“fit-for-service”thatwouldtypicallyhaverequiredextensivereworkbyhand-calcula1ons.Clientscometouswhentheyneedhigh-qualityworkexecutedanddocumentedtowithstandthemostrigorousreviewswhetherDOE,Bechtel,GEWaterandGasorSpaceX.

Page 2: ASME BPVC Pressure Vessel Consul1ng Services 2019 ASME ... · Stresses were classified according to ASME Sec1on VIII, Div. 2. The The evaporator was fabricated with several different

ASMEBPVCPressureVesselConsul1ngServicesASMESec1onVIII,Division2StressandFa1gueAnalysis

2|172019

www.Predic1veEngineering.com

Alargediameterspray-dryingchamberwasanalyzedforseismic,windandliZing.ApplicablecodeswereASCE7-02withreferencetotheUBCandANSIA58.1.TheliZingstressrequirementswereborrowedfromASME,Sec1onVIII,Division2.Themodelwashighlyidealizedandallowedsec1onstobeop1mizedforseismicandliZing.

Page 3: ASME BPVC Pressure Vessel Consul1ng Services 2019 ASME ... · Stresses were classified according to ASME Sec1on VIII, Div. 2. The The evaporator was fabricated with several different

ASMEBPVCPressureVesselConsul1ngServicesASMESec1onVIII,Division2StressandFa1gueAnalysis

3|172019

www.Predic1veEngineering.com

Thick-wall,high-pressureliquidoxygen(LOX)tanksexperiencethermalfa1guecondi1onsnotrarelyseeninnormalpressurevessels.Stressclassifica1onrequiredourcompleteASMEsoZwarearsenal.MembranestresseswerecalculatedusingstandardASMEstresslineariza1on.

Page 4: ASME BPVC Pressure Vessel Consul1ng Services 2019 ASME ... · Stresses were classified according to ASME Sec1on VIII, Div. 2. The The evaporator was fabricated with several different

ASMEBPVCPressureVesselConsul1ngServicesASMESec1onVIII,Division2StressandFa1gueAnalysis

4|172019

www.Predic1veEngineering.com

Seismic,thermal,deadweight,nozzleandpressureanalyseswereperformedonaseriesoflarge-scale(e.g.,300”diameter)nuclearwasteprocessingvesselsfortheDOE.EngineeringworkwasapprovedunderASMESec1onVIII,Div.2,ASCE4-98forSeismicAnalysisofNuclear-RelatedEquipmentandassociatedNQA-1requirements.

Page 5: ASME BPVC Pressure Vessel Consul1ng Services 2019 ASME ... · Stresses were classified according to ASME Sec1on VIII, Div. 2. The The evaporator was fabricated with several different

ASMEBPVCPressureVesselConsul1ngServicesASMESec1onVIII,Division2StressandFa1gueAnalysis

5|172019

www.Predic1veEngineering.com

A100foot-longtubeandshellevaporatorwasanalyzedforstressanddeflec1onbasedonjointlydevelopedtransporta1onloads.StresseswereclassifiedaccordingtoASMESec1onVIII,Div.2.Theevaporatorwasfabricatedwithseveraldifferentmaterialtypes,eachwithdifferentASMEDivision1materialallowables.ThevesselwasconstrainedwithasaddlesupportnearthetoptubesheetwithaSchnabelconnec1onatthebaseoftheskirt.

Page 6: ASME BPVC Pressure Vessel Consul1ng Services 2019 ASME ... · Stresses were classified according to ASME Sec1on VIII, Div. 2. The The evaporator was fabricated with several different

ASMEBPVCPressureVesselConsul1ngServicesASMESec1onVIII,Division2StressandFa1gueAnalysis

6|172019

www.Predic1veEngineering.com

Off-ShoreProcessingPlalorm:SloshingAnalysis

ThesloshingloadsforthisvesselwerecalculatedperASCE4-98,SeismicAnalysisofSafety-RelatedStructures.Fromthesecalcula1ons,threeloadingcondi1onswerederived:HorizontalImpulsiveMode,HorizontalSloshing(Convec1veMode)andVer1calFluidResponseMode(Breathing).Handcalcula1onsweredonealongwithSmoothPar1cleHydrodynamics(SPH)tosimulatethesloshingevent.Analy1calandnumericalresultscorrelatedandthevesselwasclassified“fit-for-service”.

Page 7: ASME BPVC Pressure Vessel Consul1ng Services 2019 ASME ... · Stresses were classified according to ASME Sec1on VIII, Div. 2. The The evaporator was fabricated with several different

ASMEBPVCPressureVesselConsul1ngServicesASMESec1onVIII,Division2StressandFa1gueAnalysis

7|172019

www.Predic1veEngineering.com

Thermal-StressFa1gueAnalysisofBoiler

AnASMEthermalfa1gueanalysiswasperformedonahigh-temperaturefluegassteamgenerator(i.e.,boiler).Giventhelargethermalgradientsbetweenthefluegasinletandoutlet,thethicktubesheetpresentedapar1cularthermal-stresschallenge.Thevesselpassedbasedonpeakalterna1ngstress(Sa)perFigure5.110.2.1.

Page 8: ASME BPVC Pressure Vessel Consul1ng Services 2019 ASME ... · Stresses were classified according to ASME Sec1on VIII, Div. 2. The The evaporator was fabricated with several different

ASMEBPVCPressureVesselConsul1ngServicesASMESec1onVIII,Division2StressandFa1gueAnalysis

8|172019

www.Predic1veEngineering.com

Some1mesourbestworkistoop1mizeadesignintosomethingcompact,efficientandrobust.TheabovemodelrepresentsauniquetypeofASMEpressurevesselthatmustwithstandhighpressureswhilesimultaneouslyhavingalargesurfaceareaforheattransferrequirements.

Page 9: ASME BPVC Pressure Vessel Consul1ng Services 2019 ASME ... · Stresses were classified according to ASME Sec1on VIII, Div. 2. The The evaporator was fabricated with several different

ASMEBPVCPressureVesselConsul1ngServicesASMESec1onVIII,Division2StressandFa1gueAnalysis

9|172019

www.Predic1veEngineering.com

High-pressuremanifoldcas1ngsarenotuncommoninmarineandchemicalprocessingapplica1ons.Usually,itisenoughtoperformastandardhydrosta1ctest(UCD-99)attwicethemaximumallowablepressurebutinthiscase,ourclient’sclient(USGovernment)requestedthattheirhigh-pressurehydraulicmanifoldcas1ngsalsomeetASMEDesign-by-Analysisspecifica1onsincludingprotec1onagainstplas1ccollapse.StandardASMESec1onVIII,Division2rulescanbemetwithlinearsta1canalysisbutplas1ccollapseassumesthatthecas1ngmustholdtogetherunder2.4xthedesignload.ThislastrequirementwasmetbyperformingacompletenonlinearstressanalysisusingLS-DYNA.

Page 10: ASME BPVC Pressure Vessel Consul1ng Services 2019 ASME ... · Stresses were classified according to ASME Sec1on VIII, Div. 2. The The evaporator was fabricated with several different

ASMEBPVCPressureVesselConsul1ngServicesASMESec1onVIII,Division2StressandFa1gueAnalysis

10|172019

www.Predic1veEngineering.com

Shownaboveisatubeandshellheatexchangercoupledtopipingsystem.Thesystemismountedonastructuresteelframe(notshown).Thermalandstressanalysiscalcula1onswereperformedperASMEVIII,Div.2todeterminethermalandstressmargins.Someop1miza1onworkwasdoneonthelowerpipingsystemduetowindloadingeffectsperASCE7-02.

Page 11: ASME BPVC Pressure Vessel Consul1ng Services 2019 ASME ... · Stresses were classified according to ASME Sec1on VIII, Div. 2. The The evaporator was fabricated with several different

ASMEBPVCPressureVesselConsul1ngServicesASMESec1onVIII,Division2StressandFa1gueAnalysis

11|172019

www.Predic1veEngineering.com

Shellandtubeheatexchangerforaboilingtube,dual-vesselevapora1vesystem.Themainshellwas1taniumwiththetubingofSA-240.DesignandanalysisworkperformedfortheDedertCorpora1on.

Page 12: ASME BPVC Pressure Vessel Consul1ng Services 2019 ASME ... · Stresses were classified according to ASME Sec1on VIII, Div. 2. The The evaporator was fabricated with several different

ASMEBPVCPressureVesselConsul1ngServicesASMESec1onVIII,Division2StressandFa1gueAnalysis

12|172019

www.Predic1veEngineering.com

ShellandtubeheatexchangerperASMESec1onVIII,Div.2analyzedfordesign,opera1ng,bucklingandseismicloading.Thefinaldesignofthevesselrequired14designitera1onsduetointernalbaffleconstraintstopreventbuckling.Thefinalbucklinganalysiswasdonebygeometric,nonlinearanalysistoconfirmsafetymargins.

Page 13: ASME BPVC Pressure Vessel Consul1ng Services 2019 ASME ... · Stresses were classified according to ASME Sec1on VIII, Div. 2. The The evaporator was fabricated with several different

ASMEBPVCPressureVesselConsul1ngServicesASMESec1onVIII,Division2StressandFa1gueAnalysis

13|172019

www.Predic1veEngineering.com

Formaldehydereactoranalyzedforthermalandmechanicalperformance.ASMESec1onVIII,Div.2coderequirementsoninternalshellandtubeheatexchanger.

Page 14: ASME BPVC Pressure Vessel Consul1ng Services 2019 ASME ... · Stresses were classified according to ASME Sec1on VIII, Div. 2. The The evaporator was fabricated with several different

ASMEBPVCPressureVesselConsul1ngServicesASMESec1onVIII,Division2StressandFa1gueAnalysis

14|172019

www.Predic1veEngineering.com

VerylargeASMEvesselanalyzedfortube-sheetstressesarisingfromdual-materialtube-bundlewithlikewisedualmaterialshell.Thermal-stressanalysiswasperformedtoclassifysystemunderASMEstressandfa1guerequirements.

Page 15: ASME BPVC Pressure Vessel Consul1ng Services 2019 ASME ... · Stresses were classified according to ASME Sec1on VIII, Div. 2. The The evaporator was fabricated with several different

ASMEBPVCPressureVesselConsul1ngServicesASMESec1onVIII,Division2StressandFa1gueAnalysis

15|172019

www.Predic1veEngineering.com

AcomplexliZinganalysiswasperformedtoverifythatanalreadybuiltvesselsystemwouldnotexceedASMESec1onVIII,Div.1allowables.Theslingsandspreaderbarwereidealizedwithbeamelementsandpinnedconnec1ons.

Page 16: ASME BPVC Pressure Vessel Consul1ng Services 2019 ASME ... · Stresses were classified according to ASME Sec1on VIII, Div. 2. The The evaporator was fabricated with several different

ASMEBPVCPressureVesselConsul1ngServicesASMESec1onVIII,Division2StressandFa1gueAnalysis

16|172019

www.Predic1veEngineering.com

ShownaboveisaFEAmodelofaneightpassenger,deep-diving(depth1,200’)luxurysubmarine.Stressresultswereverifiedbystraingaugingofthesubmarineduringitssubmersibleproof-test.Giventheclosecorrela1onofthestressresultstothedivetest,itbecomethefirsthumanoccupancysubmersiblecer1fiedbytheAmericanBureauofShipping(ABS)viathefiniteelementmethod.

Page 17: ASME BPVC Pressure Vessel Consul1ng Services 2019 ASME ... · Stresses were classified according to ASME Sec1on VIII, Div. 2. The The evaporator was fabricated with several different

ASMEBPVCPressureVesselConsul1ngServicesASMESec1onVIII,Division2StressandFa1gueAnalysis

17|172019

www.Predic1veEngineering.com

AboutPredic-veEngineering

o BasedinPortland,Oregono 20+yearsexperiencewithFEMAP,NX

NastranandLS-DYNA.o Focusedonsimula1onofcomplexstructur

es andsystemswheretherightanswerisfundamental.

o Referencescanbeobtainedatourwebsite:www.PredictiveEngineering.com


Top Related