Download - Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
-
8/9/2019 Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
1/63
A REPORTON
IMPLICATIONS OF WTO ONINDIAN BANKING
By:
Ashish Chatrath
PGDM 07-09
FT-07-529
-
8/9/2019 Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
2/63
FINAL DISSERTATION
DECLARATION FORM
I hereby declare that the Project work entitled
IMPLICATIONS OF WTO ON INDIAN BANKING
submitted by me for the partial fulfillment of the Post Graduate Diploma in Business
ManagementProgram to Institute for Integrated Learning in Management, Greater
Noida is my own original work and has not been submitted earlier either to IILM GSM
or to any other Institution for the fulfillment of the requirement for any course of study. I
also declare that no chapter of this manuscript in whole or in part is lifted and
incorporated in this report from any earlier / other work done by me or others.
Place : Greater Noida
Date : 23rd April 2009 Signature of Student
Name of Student : Ashish Chatrath
Address : 1804, Gandhi Lane, Islamabad, Amritsar.
-
8/9/2019 Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
3/63
IMPLICATIONS OF WTO ON INDIAN BANKING
Dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements of the
two year full-time Post Graduate Diploma in Business Management
Programme.
Submitted by
Ashish Chatrath
Roll No: FT-07-529
Batch: 2007-2009
Institute for Integrated Learning in Management
Graduate School of Management
16, Knowledge Park
Greater Noida 201 306
Month & Year
-
8/9/2019 Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
4/63
Contents
FINAL DISSERTATION .........................................................................2DECLARATION FORM ..........................................................................2
1. The Project ......................................................... 71.1 Introduction ..................................................................................71.2 Objectives ....................................................................................81.3 Limitations ...................................................................................81.4 Methodology ................................................................................8
2. WTO ...............................................................102.1 Introduction ..............................................................................102.2 WTO & Developing Economies ...................................................102.3 Special& Differential Treatment Under the WTO .......................122.4 Functions of WTO .......................................................................132.5 GENERAL AGREEMENT ON TARIFFS AND TRADE (GATT) ..........13
2.6 WTO & GATT ............................................................................143. GENERAL AGREEMENT ON TRADE IN SERVICES
(GATS) ...................................................................143.1 Principles of GATS ......................................................................153.2 Advantages of GATS ...................................................................173.3 Disadvantages of GATS ..............................................................18
3.4 Modes of GATS .........................................................................193.5 Pillars of GATS ..........................................................................21
3.6 GATS Schedule ...........................................................................213.7 Indias Commitments under GATS .............................................22
4. FINDINGS & OBSERVATIONS ............................. 234. Financial sector & banking service ...............................................234.2 Major reform initiatives in Indian banking sector ....................254.3 Foreign investments in capital of Indian banks .......................274.4 Mergers& Acquisitions in banking sector ..................................294.5 WTO Requirements & Indian Banking ........................................314.6 Regulations for foreign banks in India ........................................334.7 WTO financial services agreement, 1997 banking commitments..........................................................................................................354.8 Banking Services in United States .............................................374.9 Banking services in India & United States ..................................384.10 Banking services in China ........................................................384.11 Challenges against Indian banking sector ...............................46
5. SUGGESTIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS ............ 505.1 WTO & future of Indian Banking Sector .....................................50
6. CONCLUSION .................................................... 537. ANNEXURE ...................................................... 558. REFERENCES .................................................... 63
LIST OF TABLES
-
8/9/2019 Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
5/63
Table
No.
Subject Page
No.Table 1 Foreign investment in public sector banks in 2004
and 2006
28
Table 2 Foreign investment in private sector banks in 2004
and 2006
28
Table 3 Return on Net Worth% of Indian and foreign banks
in 2006 and 2007
43
Table 4 Operating Profit of Indian and foreign banks in 2006
and 2007
44
Table 5 ROA% of Indian and foreign banks in 2006 and 2007 45Table 6 Net Profit of Indian and foreign banks in 2006 and
2007
46
Table 7 Interest Income of Indian and foreign banks in 2006
and 2007
47
Table 8 Total Income of Indian and foreign banks in 2006
and 2007
47
Table 9 TIER I Capital of Indian and foreign banks in 2006
and 2007
48
-
8/9/2019 Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
6/63
The project deals with analyzing the impact of WTO on the Indian
banking sector. The need of growth of the developing economies gives
opportunities to the foreign banking players to enter into the new markets
in new economies and expand their businesses on global level. The entry
of the foreign banks in the developing economies helps them to grow at a
faster pace. Foreign banks also bring with them the latest technology
being used in the developed economies which helps the developing
economies to take advantage of the technological advancements being
used in the other nations. Hence it is very essential for the developing
economies to open their economies for the international trade by allowing
foreign banks to establish their businesses over there.
In this project, the major concern was to analyze the implications
of WTO on the Indian banking system. The future projections have been
made by analyzing the change in the foreign capital investments in public
sector banks and private sector banks from the year 2004 to the year 2006
and by analyzing the change in the earnings or profits earned by the
foreign banks in the year 200 and 2007. The project required a detailed
study of the Indian banking sector with respect to the presence of foreignbanks. The main purpose of the project was to find out the impact of the
agreements governing under WTO which has a direct impact on the Indian
banking sector. GATS (General Agreement on Trade in Services) govern
the negotiations regarding services between the member nations. In
different round of negotiations happened under GATS, Government of India
removed many barriers for the foreign banks to enter into the Indian
banking market. This has proved to be one of the major reasons for the
increase in the growth rate of the Indian economy.
This project will help the reader to know about the change in the
regulations made by RBI for the foreign banks to liberalize the trade in
services in the Indian banking sector. The reader will also come to know
about the future prospects of the Indian banking system and the
improvement in the financial performance of Indian and foreign banks.
ABSTRACT
-
8/9/2019 Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
7/63
1. The Project
1.1 Introduction
The WTO came into existence on January 1, 1995, with many countries
joining it with immediate effect. It has its headquarters in Geneva,
Switzerland. The WTO was born to usher in a new era of global economic
cooperation, reflecting the widespread desire to operate in a fairer and
more open multilateral trading system for the benefit and welfare of
member countries principles.
According to the Planning Commission, the population of India will be 130
crores by the year 2020, out of which 40 percent will be urban, highly
educated, healthier and prosperous as compared to 28 percent in 2004.
Only 40 per cent of the population will be engaged in agriculture as
against 60 percent now. Share of agriculture in GDP will be a nominal 6 per
cent as against 18.5 percent according to Economic Survey 2006-07. Small
and Medium Enterprises (SMEs) will emerge as a vibrant sector and primejob provider. Exports will constitute 35 per cent of GDP as against 15 per
cent at present. The economy will be indeed, market driven, productive
and competitive. In this competitive market, banking system will naturally
have a dominant and controlling role to play and the Indian Financial
System should be inherently strong, functionally diverse and flexible.
WTO has opened up a lot of opportunities to the banks in the
world to enter into the new markets in different economies by lowering
down the trade barriers. This has helped the banking sector to grow at arapid pace which in turn has helped the world economy to grow faster. The
banking sector of any economy plays a vital role in the circulation of
money by facilitating the different modes of payment. Therefore, it is
crucial for every economy to have a sound and healthy financial sector.
WTO has helped in liberalizing the trade between different countries by
facilitating negotiations between different countries. WTO has also played
an important role in setting the global standards for the banks to improve
their performances with the help of investment in other countries. FDIs
(Foreign Direct Investments) and FIIs (Foreign Institutional Investments) inbanking sector of different economies has facilitated the banks to make
-
8/9/2019 Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
8/63
use of the latest technology available in the world and to improve their
profitability by providing better services to the customers. The banking
activities these days are concentrated around major foreign banks, niche
banks, and community-based banks. The quality of assets with the banks
has improved in the past few decades and the Indian banks these days arealso concentrating towards establishing their global presence. Today, the
focus areas of banks for investment and lending are infrastructure,
education, tourism, entertainment, and health services.
1.2 Objectives
To access the role of WTO in helping trade flow of banks with no
undesirable side-effects. To study the organizational structures of banks with global
requirements.
To analyze the simplification and harmonization of international
banking trade procedures to trade in a more effective manner.
To evaluate the implications of WTO and services agreement on
the Indian banking system.
To evaluate the performance of foreign banks in the Indian
economy.
1.3 Limitations
The quantified data regarding banks available may have been
manipulated.
The study is limited and does not cover all banks considering thetime frame.
1.4 Methodology
Usage of Secondary Data: The secondary data has been
collected from the various sources like journals, articles, magazines,newspapers and internet. The magazines studied includes magazines
-
8/9/2019 Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
9/63
dealing in the financial services like Business World, Business India and
newspapers like Financial Times, Economic Times, Business Line,
Financial Review, The Hindu. The data collected was then analyzed in
respect of the impact of policies laid down by WTO and its effects on
the Indian banking sector which indirectly affects the financial sector ofthe whole Indian economy. The data
regarding foreign capital investments in banks was collected with
the help of internet for analyzing the increase in the foreign
investment in both public and private sector banks in India.
Comparative study of performance of Indian banks and
foreign banks in Indian economy: This report also includes a
comparative study of the banking sector of a developed economy i.e.
U.S. economy with the banking sector of the Indian economy. In this,
the foreign capital employed in various banks was studied to know
the liberalization of services and foreign investment allowed in the
capital of the banks in different economies.
-
8/9/2019 Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
10/63
2.1 Introduction
The WTO is an international organization of 151 member countries that is a
forum for negotiating international trade agreements and the monitoring
and regulating body for enforcing agreements. The WTO was created in
1995, by the passage of the provisions of the "Uruguay Round" of the
General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT). Prior to the UruguayRound, GATT focused on promoting world trade by pressuring countries to
reduce
Tariffs. But with the creation of the WTO, this corporate-inspired agenda
was significantly ratcheted up by targeting so-called "non-tariff barriers to
trade" - essentially any national or local protective legislation that might
be construed as impacting trade.
WTO is the only global international organization dealing with the global
rules of trade between nations and ensuring trade flows as smoothly,predictably and freely as possible therefore resulting into a more
prosperous, peaceful and accountable economic world.
2.2 WTO & Developing Economies
The gains accruing to the developing countries from liberalization in world
trade under the multilateral trade regime of the WTO has been an issue
2. WTO
-
8/9/2019 Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
11/63
largely debated. Realizing that the playing field is not level before opening
up for competition, the provisions for Special and Differential Treatment to
developing countries are inherent in the Uruguay Round (UR) Agreements
of the WTO. The preface to the WTO agreement claims that efforts are
designed to ensure a share in the growth in international trade adequatewith the needs of their economic development. The special treatment is
embedded in all the agreements of WTO like the Agreement on Agriculture
(AOA). Trade Related Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS), Trade Related
Investment Measures (TRIMS), Anti-dumping measures, Technical Barriers
to Trade, Agreement on Textiles and Clothing and the Trade in Services.
The concessions given to developing countries are seen in terms of lower
reduction commitments of support, flexibility in terms of export subsidies,
longer time period for reducing the support, implementing TRIPS, TRIMS,
special concessions on Sanitary and Phytosanitary measures technical
barriers to trade, etc.
Recognizing the fact that three-fourths of the membership of the WTO is
formed by the developing countries, and their interests cannot be
neglected, the fourth WTO Ministerial meeting held in Doha in November
2001 launched a comprehensive set of multilateral trade negotiations
known as the Doha Development Agenda. The launch of these negotiations
claimed to ensure that the trading system is relevant and responsive to
the needs of the developing countries. The benefits to the developing
countries from the declaration were expected to be largely in terms ofenhanced market access of the developed country products. The
negotiations on the
Doha agenda did not make much headway at the Cancun ministerial in
September 2003 or at Hong Kong in December 2005, despite the fact that
the negotiations are to be completed before the end of year 2005. But
much credibility of WTO now depends on its ability to provide development
opportunities for developing and least developing countries.
As per the definitions under the WTO, there is no unique definition ofdeveloped and developing economies in the WTO. Members announce
for themselves whether they are developed or developing countries.
However, other members can challenge the decision of a member to make
use of provisions available to developing countries. Developing country
status in the WTO brings certain rights. But a WTO member announcing
itself as a developing country does not automatically mean that it will
benefit from the unilateral preference schemes of some of the developed
country members such as the Generalized System of Preferences (GSP). In
practice, it is the preference giving country which decides the list ofdeveloping countries that will benefit from preferences. However, all
-
8/9/2019 Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
12/63
developing countries that are eligible to benefit from technical assistance
provided by the WTO secretariat and WTO members.
2.3 Special& Differential Treatment Underthe WTO
The special provisions in favor of developing countries are incorporated
into the individual agreements and decisions of the Uruguay Round. Within
each section, the special measures have also been grouped under fourheadings which reflect their general nature; those recognizing the interests
of least developed/developing countries in a general manner; those easing
the rules or number of obligations to be met; those providing longer time-
frames for the implementation of certain obligations and those providing
for technical assistance.
The committee on trade and development periodically review the special
provisions in favor of developing country members and particularly the
LDCs which are included in the multilateral trade agreements.
Agreement:General Agreement on Trade in Services
Special provisions for Developing countries:Within two years of the
entry into force of the agreement, developed country members and to the
extent possible all other members are to establish enquiry points to help
suppliers from developing countries get information on the commercial
and technical aspects of supplying different kinds of services, the
registration of suppliers, the obtaining of professional qualifications and
the availability of services technology.
WTO members are allowed to enter economic integration agreements that
liberalize trade in services, provided the agreement has substantial
sectoral coverage and provides for the eliminations of substantially all
discrimination in the covered sectors. The multilateral nature of the WTO
agreement is especially attractive to small developing countries that would
otherwise have difficult time negotiating many different bilateral trade
agreements. In addition, there are benefits associated with the dispute
settlement of the WTO which provides a legal backup to deal with inter-
-
8/9/2019 Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
13/63
country trade laws which cannot be handled by countries independently.
However, the gains to the developing countries could be accrued only
under the condition that trade is not just sufficiently free but fair,
recognizing the interests of the developing countries.
2.4 Functions of WTO
Administering and implementing the
multilateral trade agreements.
Acting as a forum for multilateral negotiations.
Seeking to resolve trade disputes.
Overseeing national trade policies. Cooperating with other international institutions
involved in global economic presence.
2.5 GENERAL AGREEMENT ON TARIFFSAND TRADE (GATT)
Uruguay Round (1986-1983) marks a watershed, and for the first time,
multilateral trade negotiations under General Agreement in Tariff and
Trade (GATT) encompass not only the traditional goods sector, but alsoextended to three new areas, namely investment, intellectual property
rights and services.
The final act was signed on 1 April 1994, at Marrakech in Morocco, which
resulted in the formation of World Trade Organization (WTO) w.e.f. January
1, 1995 with 123 members, including India. Now there are 151 members
including China, Vietnam and Saudi Arabia.
-
8/9/2019 Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
14/63
2.6 WTO & GATT
Decisions of the Dispute Resolution Mechanism are binding onmember countries. Therefore provides a neutral forum for grievance
redress to all countries irrespective of economic clout.
A rules-based, member-driven organization all decisions aremade by the member governments, and the rules are the outcome of
negotiations among members. In effect, every member country has a
veto, i.e. a no vote from any member can scuttle a deal.
3. GENERAL AGREEMENT ON TRADE INSERVICES (GATS)
The General Agreement on Trade in Services (GATS) came into existenceas a result of the Uruguay Round of negotiations and entered into force on
1 January 1995, with the establishment of the WTO. GATS is the first ever
set of multilateral, legally-enforceable rules covering international trade in
services. The multilateral legal instruments resulting from the Uruguay
Round were treated as a single undertaking. India also signed all the WTO
agreements under the single undertaking rule and GATS is a part of this
whole package. The WTO was born to usher in a new era of global
economic cooperation, reflecting the widespread desire to operate in a
fairer and more open multilateral trading system for the benefit and
welfare of member countries. Like the agreements on goods, GATS
-
8/9/2019 Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
15/63
operates on three levels: the main text containing general principles and
obligations; annexes dealing with rules for specific sectors; and individual
countries specific commitments to provide access to their markets.
The obligations under GATS may be categorized into two groups:
General obligations: General obligations apply directly and
automatically to all member countries of the WTO and it includes most
favored nation (MFN) treatment and transparency.
Conditional obligations: Conditional obligations apply to sectors where
the member country has assumed market access and national treatment
obligations. Under conditional obligations, GATS follows a positive list
approach under which each member is expected to undertake specific
liberalization commitments through a process called "scheduling". Any
commitment can be added or improved at any time autonomously by the
member concerned but it becomes a binding commitment only if it is
scheduled. The Request-Offer approach is the main method of
negotiations, with the starting point for negotiations being the current
schedules of commitment.
3.1 Principles of GATS
The GATS create certain obligations on all members which they must
follow in the implementation of their obligations under the agreement. The
members are free to state in their schedules the services they intend to
bring under the purview of GATS and the terms and conditions of their
commitments. They may also amend them later after appropriate
negotiations with other members. But once they have made their
commitments they are required to adhere to the following principles.
National Treatment: Under the article XVII this means that amember shall treat the persons belonging to all other members the way
-
8/9/2019 Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
16/63
it treat its own nationals. This means it cannot discriminate between
foreigners and its own nationals in a manner. This could also mean that:
Foreign companies cannot be subjected to additional performance
requirements like meeting environment safeguards.
They cannot be compelled to hire or train local staff or builddomestic capacity.
There can be no compulsion regarding technology transfer.
Foreign person must be extended the same tax exemption or
subsidies that are given to domestic companies.
Foreigner can be placed on foreign companies regarding
acquisition of land and other assets.
Members must provide the equal competitive privileges to both
domestic and foreign companies.
Most-Favored Nation Treatment (MFNT): Under Article II,
MFNT means that every member shall treat all others the way it treats
its best friend among them. That is, member shall extend the best of
the trade terms it offers to a member to all others on an equal footing.
While, national treatment obligates a member not to make any
discrimination between its own nationals and foreign nationals, MFNT
requires a member not to discriminate between other member-states
and that it should offer them uniform treatment. This is also referred toas Generalized System of Trade Preferences (GSP). Sometimes MFNT is
offered on the condition of reciprocity, that is State would extend to
another State MFNT only if the latter also commits itself to extend the
same. But under GATS the MFNT has to be unconditional.
Minimum Treatment: Under Article XVI, amember has to extend to all other members a treatment not less
favorable than what it has committed itself under its schedule. But if it
were to offer to any member a better deal than what it has committed
itself under its schedule, then it has to extend to all other members the
same treatment under MFNT clause. If a member modifies its schedule
and either enhances its commitment, then it has to extend the same to
all other members. This may be in terms of number of service suppliers
in the form of quotas, total value or number of operations, or number of
persons, or specific types of legal entities, etc.
Schedule of Specific Commitments: Under Article XX, each member
is required to set out in a schedule the specific commitments it proposes to
-
8/9/2019 Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
17/63
undertake vis--vis other members. With respect to each sector the
schedule shall specify:
Terms, limitations and conditions on market access;
Conditions and qualifications on national treatment; Undertakings relating to additional commitments; and
The date of entry into force of such commitments.
A member may, however, modify or withdraw its commitments in its
schedule after three years have elapsed and by giving a notice to the
Council for Trade in Services (to be established under Article XXIV) within
three months before the intended modification or withdrawal. The
modifying member is required to enter into negotiations with any affected
member for reaching compensatory adjustment, etc. There are provisionsfor dispute settlement through arbitration, etc. However, GATS creates an
obligation on a member State to progressively enhance its commitments
over a period of time.
3.2 Advantages of GATS Economic Performance: An efficient services infrastructure is
must for economic success. Services such as telecommunications,
banking, insurance and transport supply strategically important inputs
for all sectors, goods and services.
Spur of competition would encourage excellence, quality of
output and reduction in prices. This is evident from the recent Indian
experience in cell phone sector.
Access to world-class services would revolutionize the domestic
production.
The benefit of quality services would penetrate down to the
ultimate consumer.
Liberalization of services sector is bound to generate process and
product innovation.
-
8/9/2019 Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
18/63
Protectionism has led to inefficiency. Liberalization would lead to
greater transparency and stability.
It will lead to greater technology transfer as it would be in the
interest of the investor to utilize local manpower by giving the requisite
training.
In short, GATS would bring in (a) FDI; (b) industrialization;
(c)employment; (d) transfer of technology; and (e) generation of wealth.
GATS do not compel any State either to accept or continue to accept any
obligations under the agreement. Is any State feels it would be beneficialby the GATS, it might accept its obligations Any State is free to opt out of
GATS if its interests are adversely affected.
3.3 Disadvantages of GATS
The GATS has attracted considerable opposition from many developed
countries and various commentators for being a device for wholesale
auction of vital service sectors to MNCs of developed countries. The
following are some of the criticisms that are made against GATS.
Though GATS supporters claim that it is a bottom up treaty in
the sense that a member can progressively enhance its commitments
and that there is no compulsion on any State to accept obligations it is
unwilling to, in reality it is said that the GATS never gave any
opportunity for any democratic debate at the local communities, or
regional and national parliaments. Being an imposed one, it is top-
down agreement.
The whole gamut of obligations under the GATS entrenches into
the culture national resources and vital service sectors of developing
countries.
-
8/9/2019 Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
19/63
The past experience of privatization of resources like water in
Bolivia, Argentina and Puerto Rico has proved to be disastrous, Prices of
water had gone up and the poor suffered.
Indian experience with Enron in privatizing power production in
Maharashtra has not been a happy one.
In sectors like health and education, entry of foreign MNCs is
likely to make healthcare and education beyond the reach of the
common man. The quality of services that they boast of would be the
privilege of the rich and the elite.
Agriculture is another sector where poorer countries might sufferirreparably.
There is no evidence that liberalization would lead to increased
FDI and enhanced competition might snuff out local competition.
What are known as commons i.e., forests, watersheds, culture,
arts, etc, would come under the onslaught of profit-oriented
corporations that have little regard for this common heritage of
mankind. This will result in prioritization of markets and profits overpublic interest and well-being.
3.4 Modes of GATSThe GATS sets out four models of supplying services, namely:
Mode I: Cross-border trade
Mode II: Consumption abroad
Mode III: Commercial presence
Mode IV: Presence of natural persons.
MODE I
-
8/9/2019 Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
20/63
Cross-border trade corresponds with the normal form of trade in goods
and maintains a clear geographical separation between seller and buyer.
In this case, services flow from the territory of another member crossing
national frontiers. (e.g. banking or architectural services transmitted via
telecommunications or mail). For instance, a user in India receives servicesfrom abroad through its telecommunications or postal infrastructure. Such
supplies may include consultancy or market research reports, tele-medical
advice, distance training, or architectural drawings.
MODE II
Consumption abroad refers to situations where a service consumer
moves into another members territory to obtain a service (for example, or
nationals of India moved abroad as tourists, students, or patients to
consume the respective services).
MODE III
Commercial presence is the supply of a service through commercial
presence of the foreign supplier in the territory of another WTO member.
In this case, a service supplier of one member establishes a territorial
presence in another members territory to provide a service. (For example,the services provided within India by a locally-established affiliate,
subsidiary, or representative office of a foreign-owned and controlled
company such as bank, hotel group, construction company, etc.).
MODE IV
Presence of natural persons involves the admission of foreign nationals
to another country to provide services there. An annex to the GATS makesit clear, however, that the agreement has nothing to do with individuals
looking for employment in another country, or with citizenship, residence
or employment requirements. The members still have a right to regulate
the entry and stay of the persons concerned, for instance, by requiring
visas. (For example, a foreign national provides a service within India as an
independent supplier such as consultant, health worker or employee of a
service supplier which can be a consultancy firm, hospital, or a
construction company).
-
8/9/2019 Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
21/63
3.5 Pillars of GATSGATS have three main pillars to rest
The first pillar is the framework agreement, which contains basic
obligations applicable to all member countries.
The second pillar is that of national treatment and national
schedules of commitment on market access.
The third pillar constitutes a number of Annexes and attachments
on special situations of individual service sector.
3.6 GATS Schedule
The commitments by the member countries can be scheduled in one of the
following ways:
1. Full commitment: None or No limitations, which implies that the
member does not seek in any way to limit market access or national
treatment through measures inconsistent with Articles XVI or XVII of GATS.
2. Commitment with limitations: The member details the measures
maintained which are inconsistent with market access or national
treatment, and implicitly commits itself to take no other inconsistent
measures.
3. No commitment: Unbound, indicates that the member remains free
to maintain or introduce measures inconsistent with market access or
national treatment.
-
8/9/2019 Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
22/63
4. No commitment technically feasible: Unbound, indicates that in
the sector in question, a particular mode of supply cannot be used.
In banking, no commitment is allowed in Modes 1, 2 and 4. In Mode 3,
grant of branch licenses to foreign banks is subject to a cap of 12 licensesper year both for new and existing banks. Licenses for new foreign banks
may be denied if the share of the assets of foreign banks in the total
banking assets (on and off balance sheet) in India exceeds 15 per cent. In
both insurance and banking, requests received from other countries in
WTO commitments include allowing full market access and national
treatment commitments as well as removal of limitations on foreign equity
participation.
3.7 Indias Commitments under GATS
India is a founder member of WTO and ratified the agreement establishing
the WTO on 30.12.1994. As in the case of other multilateral agreements,
Indias commitments to GATS are guided by the following general
principles in varying degrees:
Gradual Approach: India believes in gradual and step by step
approach and not a Big Bang or short therapy approach.
Human Face: All the reform programs have strong emphasis on
human face and least sacrifice made by the people.
Sovereignty constraint: Indian government tries to minimize
the loss of power for national policy formulation that could result from
international cooperation.
Political Constraint: India is a sovereign democratic republic
with independent judiciary, and all external relations are based on
general political consensus.
Agency constraint: Policies are influenced by the ideology of
the political in power. But once adopted, policies are irreversible.
-
8/9/2019 Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
23/63
Preference for decentralization: India prefers national level
policies that take into account external factors, rather than polled
mechanisms at the international level.
Priority Reforms: Basic purpose of commitment is to strengthen
our economic position and global competitiveness, but not at the cost of
national security, public health and safety, and environmental
protection.
4. Financial sector & banking service
The term financial services is broadly used for a set of services provided
to ensure efficient mobilization and allocation of funds towards the overall
growth of an economy. By directing investment funds to their most
productive use, an efficient financial services sector can significantly
promote growth and income. As a result, the effective provision of these
services is a basic prerequisite for a dynamic and modern economy. Across
most developing countries, including India, financial services constitute a
part of the regulatory system that manages inflow and outflow of foreign
capital, reduces exchange rate volatility and provides credit to socially
desired sectors. Countries such as the United States, Japan, as well as
some members of European Union have, over the years, been vocal
demanders of liberalization of different financial services, arguing that
barriers to entry hinder economic progress and financial stability. They
also have well-developed financial service industries that stand to benefit
from access to international markets. However, the rapid flow of money
out of developing countries in the aftermath of the Latin American crisis in
1980s and the East Asian crisis in 1997, demonstrated that liberalizing
financial markets sans proper planning and management of investment is
not a recipe of success. In fact, given their immense importance in overallstability of an economy, there is a broad disagreement among various
4. FINDINGS & OBSERVATIONS
-
8/9/2019 Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
24/63
countries about further liberalization of financial services. These
disagreements range from both liberalization in additional financial
services sector as well deeper liberalization in a particular sector.
The Indian banking industry is passing through a phase of customersmarket. The customers have more choices in choosing their banks. A
competition has been established within the banks operating in India. With
stiff competition and advancement of technology, the services provided by
banks have become more easy and convenient.
Financial sector reforms were initiated as part of overall economic reforms
in the country and wide ranging reforms covering industry, trade, taxation,
external sector, banking and financial markets have been carried out since
mid 1991. A decade of economic and financial sector reforms has
strengthened the fundamentals of the Indian economy and transformed
the operating environment for banks and financial institutions in the
country. The most significant achievement of the financial sector reforms
has been the marked improvement in the financial health of commercial
banks in terms of capital adequacy, profitability and asset quality as also
greater attention to risk management. Further, deregulation has opened
up new opportunities for banks to increase revenues by diversifying into
investment banking, insurance, credit cards, depository services,
mortgage financing, securitization, etc. At the same time, liberalization has
brought greater competition among banks, both domestic and foreign, aswell as competition from mutual funds, NBFCs, post office, etc. and the
competition will only get stronger, as large global players emerge on the
scene. Increasing competition is squeezing profitability for the banks and
forcing them to work efficiently on shrinking areas. Increase of competition
means greater choice available to consumers, and the increased level of
sophistication and technology in banks. As banks benchmark themselves
against global standards, there has been a marked increase in disclosures
and transparency in bank balance sheets and greater focus on corporate
governance.
Foreign banks in India now have a share of only around 7 per cent of total
banking assets. The RBI has released an ambitious road map for increasing
the presence of foreign banks in India. As per the guidelines, the
aggregate foreign investment from all sources will be allowed up to a
maximum of 74 per cent of the paid up capital of the private bank. The
roadmap is divided into two phases:
First phase (Between March 2005 and March 2009): Foreign bankswill be permitted to establish presence in the Indian economy by way of
-
8/9/2019 Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
25/63
setting up a wholly owned banking subsidiary (WOS) or conversion of the
existing branches into a WOS. Permission for acquisition of shareholding in
Indian private sector banks by eligible foreign banks will be limited to
banks identified by the RBI for restructuring.
Second phase (commencing in April 2009): The RBI may permit
merger or acquisition of any private sector bank in India by a foreign bank.
4.2 Major reform initiatives in Indianbanking sector
Some of the major reform initiatives in the last decade that have changed
the face of the Indian banking and financial sector are:
1. Interest rate deregulation: Interest rates on deposits and lending
have been deregulated with banks enjoying greater freedom to determine
their rates.
2. Adoption of prudential norms in terms of capital adequacy, asset
classification, income recognition, provisioning, exposure limits,investment fluctuation reserve, etc.
3. Reduction in pre-emption lowering of reserve requirements (SLR and
CRR), thus releasing more resources to lend which banks can deploy
profitably.
4. Government equity in banks has been reduced and strong banks have
been allowed to access the capital market for raising additional capital.
5. Banks now enjoy greater operational freedom in terms of opening and
swapping of branches, and banks with a good track record of profitability
have greater flexibility in recruitment.
6. New private sector banks have been set up and foreign banks permitted
to expand their operations in India including through subsidiaries. Banks
have also been allowed to set up Offshore Banking Units in Special
Economic Zones.
-
8/9/2019 Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
26/63
7.New areas have been opened up for bank financing such as insurance,
credit cards, infrastructure financing, leasing, gold banking, besides
investment banking, asset management, factoring, etc.
8. Several new institutions have been set up including the NationalSecurities Depositories Ltd., Central Depositories Services Ltd., Clearing
Corporation of India Ltd., Credit Information Bureau India Ltd.
9. Limits for investment in overseas markets by banks, mutual fund
companies i.e. Asset Management Companies (AMCs) and corporates have
been liberalized. The overseas investment limit for corporates has been
raised to 100% of net worth and the ceiling of $100 million on prepayment
of external commercial borrowings has been removed. AMCs and
corporates can now undertake FRAs (Forward Rate Agreements) with
banks. Indians are allowed to maintain resident foreign currency
(domestic) accounts and full convertibility for deposit schemes of NRIs has
been introduced.
10. Universal Banking has also been introduced in the Indian banking
sector. With banks permitted to diversify into long-term finance and DFIs
(Direct Foreign Investments) into working capital, guidelines have been put
in place for the evolution of universal banks.
11. Technology infrastructure for the payments and settlement system inthe country has been strengthened with electronic funds transfer,
Centralized Funds Management System, Structured Financial Messaging
Solution, Negotiated Dealing System and move towards Real Time Gross
Settlement.
12. Adoption of global standards: Prudential norms for capital
adequacy, asset classification, income recognition and provisioning are
now close to global standards. RBI has introduced Risk Based Supervision
of banks (against the traditional transaction based approach). Bestinternational practices in accounting systems, corporate governance,
payment and settlement systems, etc. are being adopted.
13. Credit delivery mechanism has been reinforced to increase the flow of
credit to priority sectors through focus on micro credit and Self Help
Groups. The definition of priority sector has been widened to include food
processing and cold storage, software upto Rs 1 crore, housing above Rs
10 lakh, selected lending through NBFCs, etc.
-
8/9/2019 Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
27/63
14. RBI guidelines have been issued for putting in place risk management
systems in banks. Risk Management Committees in banks address credit
risk, market risk and operational risk. Banks have specialized committees
to measure and monitor various risks and have been upgrading their risk
management skills and systems.
15. The limit for foreign direct investment in private banks has been
increased from 49% to 74% and the 10% cap on voting rights has been
removed. In addition, the limit for foreign institutional investment in
private banks is 49%.
4.3 Foreign investments in capital ofIndian banks
PUBLIC SECTOR BANKS
Na Name of the Bank No. of
Shares (aas on 31.03.
.2 04)
% to Paid
up C apital
N No. of
Shares (a Oson
31.03.2006)
% T o Paid
up Cacapital
Andhra Bank 2,15,77,223 5.39 8,40,30,646 17.32Bank of Baroda 4,75,40,615 16.14 73,33,56,892 20.13Bank of India 2,37,64,900 4.86 6,44,68,034 13.19Canara Bank 4,36,00,569 10.63 7,49,35,787 18.27Corporation Bank 1,10,83,135 7.72 1,44,47,387 10.07Indian Overseas Bank 11,31,795 0.20 9,49,49,445 17.42
Oriental Bank of
Commerce
2,53,75,968 13.17 4,97,68,926 19.86
Punjab National Bank 2,96,25,795 11.16 6,32,47,778 20.00State Bank of India 6,01,97,755 11.43 6,25,03,693 11.87Syndicate Bank 36,83,407 0.78 6,37,89,100 13.51UCO Bank 6,25,000 0.07 1,45,71,873 1.82Union Bank 5,39,07,074 11.71 10,06,13,918 19.91Vijaya Bank 2,19,71,273 5.06 6,94,62,629 16.02
Table 1: Foreign investment in public sector banks in the year 2004 and 2006.
PRIVATE SECTOR BANKS
-
8/9/2019 Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
28/63
Name of the Bank No. of
Shares (as on
31.03.2004)
% to Paid
up Capital
No. of
Shares (as on
31.03.2006)
% to Paid
up Capital
Centurian Bank 76,73,437 5.37 27,75,78,001 21.67Federal Bank 10,65,637 4.80 1,83,15,281 27.53HDFC Bank 7,67,38,812 27.02 10,22,08,872 32.71ICICI Bank 28,33,78,082 38.63 41,48,16,138 46.63Indusind Bank 1,36,76,792 4.70 3,75,20,769 12.90ING Vysya Bank 46,45,021 20.53 1,55,02,328 17.03Jammu & Kashmir
Bank
77,12,696 15.90 1,45,49,707 29.99
Karnataka Bank 18,98,653 4.68 2,29,13,805 18.88Karur Vysya Bank 9.19,613 5.10 29,43,356 16.35
Kotak Mahindra Bank 94,35,947 7.92 6,45,43,383 20.93UTI Bank 3,31,63,474 14.27 9,69,84,197 34.87
Table 2: Foreign investment in private sector banks in the year 2004 and 2006.
The above tables indicate that the foreign investment in the capital of
Indian banks (Both public and private sector banks) has increased because
of the liberalization policy of the government and WTO norms. This growth
in investment by foreign countries will continue for long and it will also
provide better opportunities for the Indian banks to utilize the foreign
capital efficiently so as to compete strongly with the other banks.Encouraging foreign investment in the Indian banks will also develop
friendly relations with the other countries. The financial subsidiaries of
foreign banks have a big hand in these investments and at appropriate
time they will make their presence felt in many Indian banks after 2009,
whereafter under WTO rules these foreign banks could acquire 74 percent
shares of Indian private banks. The Indian government has acted
thoughtfully by permitting this cap already. In the same spirit the
government intends to amend the Banking Regulation Act to do away with
the restriction of voting rights to maximum 10 percent. These rules andregulations are protected and preserved in the developed countries. The
foreign multinational banks objective is to acquire the local banks
private and public. The banking policy pursued by Indian government has
encouraged the foreign banks to step up pressure. In the meanwhile,
situations are created permitting the foreign banks and their financial
subsidiaries to indulge in trading and services to increase their income and
profits. They are exempted from social banking and agricultural credit.
These burdens are put solely on the public sector banks, sapping their
income and profits. If this adverse playing field continue, they will berendered week and face the risk of being acquired by foreign banks.
-
8/9/2019 Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
29/63
This disturbing banking policy must be changed. Rules and regulations
applicable to public sector banks must be applied to all the banks. Existing
common regulations for payment of interest on savings account should be
governed by common rules ensuring uniform implementation. In the samemanner, common rules should govern service charges. Foreign banks
should not be permitted to establish financial subsidiaries since such
subsidiaries are being used as banking and trading companies. The
globally prevalent regulation of capping on ownership of shares and voting
rights as it exists now in India should not be disturbed. Disinvestment must
be stopped once for all and alternate mechanism of issuing bonds and
preference shares ought to be adopted to strengthen the capital base.
Each Public Sector Bank should further expand by opening new branches
since household savings are increasing significantly as can be seen from
more than 32 percent increase in bank deposits and demand for credit is
about 80 percent of deposits. These measures will go a long way in
strengthening public sector banks and will help tremendously in the
development of the overall Indian economy.
4.4 Mergers& Acquisitions in bankingsector
Whether it is an Industrial Sector or Services Sector, mergers &
acquisitions have become way forward in todays world. In a free market
economy, companies have to keep evolving to remain competitive.
Adaptability to changes in the market becomes a crucial factor for survival.
Banking system is the bloodline of any economy and banks are trustees of
public money. The depositors therefore, have more stakes in the welfare of
banks than the share holders. Failure of a bank has more systemic
implications than say, the failure of a manufacturing company. Laws
governing regulation and supervision of banks in all countries therefore
focus on protecting the interests of depositors.
Mergers and Acquisitions are not an unknown phenomenon in Indian
Banking. The predecessor of State Bank of India, the Imperial Bank of India
was born out of consolidation of three Presidency Banks way back in 1920.
Merger of Times Bank with HDFC Bank was the first of such consolidations
after financial sector reforms ushered in 1991. Merger of Bank of Madura
with ICICI Bank, reverse merger of ICICI with ICICI bank, coming together of
-
8/9/2019 Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
30/63
Centurion Bank and Bank of Punjab to form Centurion Bank of Punjab and
the merger of Lord Krishna Bank and Federal Bank are voluntary efforts by
banks to consolidate and grow.
Hong Kong allowed 100% FDI in banking sector and this facilitated takeover of several banks by Singapore and Taiwanese banks.
Indonesia witnessed large scale infusion of public funds into the banking
system through a specialized restructuring agency. The banks which had
Capital adequacy ratio reduced to below 25% were marked for immediate
closure. Consolidation among banks was actively encouraged and FDI was
allowed up to 99%.
In Malaysia, the Central Bank implemented a well crafted financial master
plan aimed at strengthening the domestic banks by creating a level
playing field for foreign banks and open banking sector to global
competition.
In Singapore, there are 3 main banking groups and they have given boost
to consolidation process not only within the country, but also in South
Korea and Malaysia.
Thailand has implemented a Financial Sector Master Plan aimed at
removing obstructions to Mergers & Acquisitions and also allows FDI flowto strengthen the banking system.
Consolidation or merger can be done with two basic motives:
1. Maximize value for shareholders or stakeholders: All the
activities of any bank will be to earn huge profits to maximize
stakeholders value and the value maximization can only be achieved
through a reduction in cost or an increase in revenue.
1.1 Achieving cost reduction
a) Cost reduction through economy of Scale:
Consolidation helps in scaling in up operations, there by reducing per unit
cost.
b) Cost reduction through economy of Scope: This
is achieved through synergy involved in the ability to offer multiple
products using the same infrastructure. Example: Banks can offer
insurance and investment products using their branch network andthereby achieve economy of scope.
-
8/9/2019 Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
31/63
c) Cost reduction through rationalization of man
power: The merged entity will be able to identify the right persons to
manage critical functions from a larger pool of human resources.
d) Reduction in risk: The merged entity will be able
to reduce credit risk through spreading it across wider geographies orproduct range.
e) Cost reduction through possible reduction in tax
obligations.
f) Cheaper sourcing of inputs with increased
bargaining power with vendors and suppliers.
g) Ability to enter new business areas with reduced
initial cost as compared to a new set up.
1.2 Increasing Revenue
A bigger entity will be able to serve a large customer base. By offering
more services and taking bigger share in the business of the customer,
the bank will be able to increase the
.
2. Non-value maximizing motives: Non-value maximizing motives
could very often be ego factors of personal ambitions of managers. It could
even be to ward of take over by another company.
Indian economy is growing at 8-10% and the growth rate is second only to
that of China. Bank credit has been increasing at a rapid pace of over 30%
in the past 2 to 3 years. The Indian economy is slowly and steadily
integrating with the global economy. The recent report of Tarapore
Committee on Fuller Capital Account Convertibility has laid a road map for
total integration with global financial markets. Trade barriers are getting
removed under WTO and the accord on services would eventually open up
Indian banking system fully to global competition. The road map forpresence of foreign banks in India announced by Reserve Bank of India
envisages a regime after 2009 when foreign banks will be allowed to
operate in India like any other private sector bank in the country.
4.5 WTO Requirements & Indian Banking
-
8/9/2019 Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
32/63
Since 1941 several nations of the world have attempted to evolve a
system under which multilateral trade among nations is carried out
smoothly without any hindrance. Since the first round in 1941 at Geneva
with 23 participant nations, several rounds have been conducted again at
Geneva between 1986 and 1993 with 117 member nations. At the end ofthese meetings, GATT (General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade) gave way
to the establishment of a permanent organization to guide multilateral
trade, namely World Trade Organization. Given the wide variance among
member nations in the state of their economies, member nations were
classified into three categories, namely, developed, developing and least
developed nations. At the end of the Uruguay Round, all members
including India agreed on the following:
To offer the Most Favored Nation (MFN) treatment to all member
countries;
To offer reduced tariffs;
To remove all subsidies to domestic industries and agriculture;
To remove all quantitative restrictions on imports and exports;
To ensure intellectual property rights of member nations; and
To ensure that exports satisfy phytosanitary measures agree on.
Basically, the agreement signed during June 1995 in Geneva givesopportunity for banks in 140 member countries to offer their banking
services to Indian consumers using all or any of the four modes of GATS.
By the same token, Indian banks now have the freedom and opportunity to
enter other member countries of WTO, to provide their services to the
nationals of these countries using any of the four modes. Following this
agreement, Government of India has liberalized shareholding of foreign
banks in Indian banks. Foreign banks are now allowed to pick-up as much
as 74%, of the equity shares of an Indian bank, against only 20% permitted
earlier. As foreign Institutional Investors (FIIs) can hold upto 49%. Till
recently, the RBI has been restricting branch expansion of foreign banks.
All the above actions of Government of India, under the veil of
economic reforms in the financial sector, will have far-reaching
implications to Indian banks. The first implication is that Indian banks will
be expected to take on international banks, some of whose sheer size is
frightening.
To succeed under WTO requirements, Indian banks need much higher
levels of operational efficiency, increase operating income by providing avariety of new services, ensure efficient cost control, take speedy
-
8/9/2019 Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
33/63
commercial decisions and possess knowledge and ability to face
uncertainties and emerging new challenges. After making these
adjustments to retain and further gain in the domestic market, Indian
banks need to aggressively enter other member countries and provide
their services to enable marketing of Indian goods and professionalservices to these countries. The banking system in India, which helped
transform the poor Indian economy of the 1950s to become one of the
largest economies in the world, in terms of Purchasing Power Parity (PPP),
will rise to the occasion and continue to contribute to Indias growth
through its dynamism and expanded activities, not only within India, but in
other member countries of the World Trade Organization.
4.6 R egulations for foreign banks in India
At present, there are 29 foreign banks operating in India with a network of
273 branches and 871 off-site ATMs. The major foreign banks in India are
the Standard Chartered Bank, Citibank, Hong Kong & Shanghai Banking
Corporation, ABN Amro Bank and the Deutsche Bank. The primary activity
of most foreign banks in India had been corporate banking. However, since
mid-1990s, foreign banks added consumer financing to their portfolio and
today the foreign banks offer a wide-range of products such as automobile,
home and household consumer loans as well as credit cards.
Besides foreign banks, there are two large Indian private sector banks in
which the non-resident ownership is very close to the 74 per cent
permitted, which can be considered as incorporated in India but
predominantly foreign-owned banks. These banks together with the
foreign banks, have a combined market share in the deposits, advances
and off-balance-sheet business of 17.46, 18.65 and 76.63 per cent,
respectively. Moreover, there are also about 10 large listed public sector
banks (PSBs) in which the non-resident/FII (Foreign InstitutionalInvestment) shareholding was close to the permitted ceiling of 20 per cent,
as on March 2007. In these PSBs, resident private shareholding would thus
be close to 30 per cent only. In the foreign exchange market, these banks
had a 41 per cent share in the total forex turnover in 2005-06 and this rose
to 52 per cent in the first half of 2007-08.
Another dimension of the foreign banks' functioning in India is the returns
generated from their Indian operations. The net profit per branch for
foreign banks in India for the year 2005-06 was Rs 11.99 crore (Rs 119.9
million) as against the corresponding figure of Rs 0.33 crore (Rs 3.3million) for PSBs.
-
8/9/2019 Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
34/63
For the year 2006-07, the Return on Assets (ROA) of foreign banks was
1.65 percent while the Return on Equity (ROE) was 14.02 percent, as
against the corresponding figures of 0.82 percent and 13.62 percent for
PSBs.
India issues a single class of banking license to banks and hence does not
place any undue restrictions on their operations merely on the ground that
in some countries there are requirements of multiple licenses for dealing in
local currency and foreign currencies with different categories of clientele.
Banks in India, both Indian and foreign, enjoy full and equal access to the
payments and settlement systems and are full members of the clearing
houses and payments system. Before granting any license, RBI may
require to satisfy that the Government or the law of the country in which it
is incorporated does not discriminate in any way against banks from India.
Unlike the restrictive practices of certain foreign countries, India is liberal
in respect of the licensing and operation of the foreign bank branches as
illustrated by the following:
All banks including foreign banks can carry on both retail and
wholesale banking.
Deposit insurance cover is uniformly available to all foreign banks
at a non-discriminatory rate of premium.
The norms for capital adequacy, income recognition and asset
classification are by and large the same. Other prudential norms such
as exposure limits are the same as those applicable to Indian banks.
The branch authorization policy for Indian banks has been made applicable
to foreign banks subject to the following:
Foreign banks are required to bring an assigned capital of US $25
million up front at the time of opening the first branch in India.
Existing foreign banks having only one branch would have to
comply with the above requirement before their request for opening of
second branch is considered.
Foreign banks may submit their branch expansion plan on an
annual basis.
In terms of Indias commitment to WTO, as a part of market access, India
is committed to permit opening of 12 branches of foreign banks every
year. As against these commitments, Reserve Bank of India has permitted
upto 17- 18 branches in the past. The Bank follows a liberal policy where
the branches are sought to be opened in unbanked/under-banked areas.Off-site ATMs are not counted in the above limit. Including off-site ATMs,
-
8/9/2019 Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
35/63
foreign banks are having (as on October 15, 2007) place of business at 933
locations (273 branches + 660 off site ATMs).
The procedure regarding approval of proposals for opening branches of
foreign banks in India has been simplified and streamlined for the sake ofexpeditious disposal. A license under the provisions of B.R. Act, 1949
enables the foreign banks to carry out any activity which is permissible to
a bank in India. This is in contrast with practices adopted in many
countries, where foreign banks can carry out only a limited menu of
activities.
As against the requirements of achieving 40 per cent of net bank credit as
target for lending to priority sector in case of domestic banks, it has been
made mandatory for the foreign banks to achieve the minimum target of
32% of net bank credit for priority sector lending. Within the target of 32%,
two sub targets in respect of advances (a) to small scale sector(minimum
of 10%), and (b) exports (minimum of 12%) have been fixed. The foreign
banks are not mandated for targeted credit in respect of agricultural
advances. There is no regulatory prescription in respect of foreign banks to
open branches in rural and semi-urban centers.
4.7 WTO financial services agreement, 1997 banking commitments
India ratified the agreement establishing the WTO in December 1994. Its
original schedule in the Financial Services Agreement committed foreign
bank presence only through branches at the rate of five licenses per year.
It denied the entry of foreign banks if the market share of assets of foreign
banks exceeds 15 per cent of the total assets of the banking system. It
treated an ATM outside branch premises as a separate branch. India also
invoked a MFN exemption in all areas of financial services meaning that its
offers are based on reciprocity.
India offered to improve upon some of its commitments provided its major
trading partners were also prepared to make substantial improvements in
their stance on the movement of natural persons. It was felt that India
possessed a fair advantage in the availability of skilled manpower in
several hi-tech areas such as computer software, engineering consultancy,
etc. and it was in Indias interest that free movement of these personnel
was allowed into the developed markets abroad. Indias improved
negotiating brief included a liberalized policy on ATMs (i.e., an ATM will not
-
8/9/2019 Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
36/63
be treated as a separate branch) and increasing the number of new
branches to eight.
In the negotiations that took place in June 1995, Indias major trading
partners made the following demands on India:
India should lift its MFN exemptions if other members do the
same.
India should increase the number of licenses and provide a
gradual increase in the market share on assets of the foreign banks.
Market share itself should be defined properly in terms of the
fund-based assets or total assets on and off the balance sheet.
Subsidiaries and joint ventures should be allowed in banking.
Discrimination against foreign banks in terms of higher rate of
taxation, and in placement of surplus funds by public sector units (i.e.
national treatment) should be removed.
Against these considerations, during the final round of negotiations that
was held in December 1997, India made the following commitments:
It deleted MFN exemption in all areas of financial services.
India increased the limit on the number of bank licenses granted
per year from eight to 12 but kept the market share unchanged at 15per cent for foreign banks. But this share of assets is computed as a
total of on- and off-balance sheet basis. Licenses issued for ATMs
installed by foreign banks were not included in the ceiling of 12
licenses.
Foreign banks already operating in India can invest no more than
10 per cent of owned funds in other financial service companies or 30
per cent of the invested companys capital, whichever is lower.
While the entry of foreign banks brings with it benefits, it also carries
certain risks for the host countries. Benefits are in the form of better
quality banking services that are offered by foreign banks themselves and
also through spurring competition and efficiency in the domestic markets.
The arrival of foreign banks with better accounting and disclosure
standards could lead to an improvement in prudential regulations in
domestic markets. The presence of foreign banks with more sophisticated
products could put pressure on domestic supervisory authorities to
augment their quality and size of domestic supervisory staff.
-
8/9/2019 Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
37/63
The entry of foreign banks has also potential risks associated with it.
Another concern relating to foreign entry is that of foreign banks quickly
becoming dominant in the domestic banking system. This fear has led to
Singapore authorities, while announcing a major liberalization programmed
recently, to state explicitly that they wanted local banks to hold at leasthalf of the market. Also, the Philippines has stipulated that the market
share of foreign-majority owned banks should not exceed 30 per cent of
banking industry. Mexico also restricted foreign ownership to 30 per cent
with a cap of individual foreign bank at 5 per cent when it started selling
state-owned commercial banks in the early 1990s, but later these
restrictions were relaxed and finally removed.
4.8 Banking Services in United States
The United States was an original signatory to the GATT and a leading
proponent of the GATTs free-market principles. It continues to be among
the countries urging further discussions on opening markets to trade.
Although decisions in the WTO are by consensus, the United States has a
highly influential role in the WTO, because it is the largest trader in the
world. The U.S. banking sector is deep, competitive, and supported by a
strong economy and prudent supervision. The banking industry serves a
diverse market, providing wholesale and retail financial services to
corporations, small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs), and individuals.
The banking sector includes deposit-taking commercial banks and thrifts.
The U.S. banking sector has mirrored consolidation trends in other major
economies but is still relatively unique in its significant number of regional
and community banks.
According to the World Bank the U.S. banking sector provided credit equal
to 215 percent of GDP in 2004, more than for most OECD and developing
countries. Globally, banking is one of the more mature industries, withglobal banking growth of 6 percent in 2004 (according to a June 2006
USITC report). The United States status as a leader in its domestic and
international development of the banking sector, and the expected steady
but slow growth of banking globally, suggests that room for revenue
growth through new branches is only moderate. In the United States,
however, most regional and large U.S. banks have successfully increased
revenue growth through consolidation.
From end of year 1998-2005 foreign banks assets in the U.S. market grewby 77 percent (versus 67 percent for all FDIC insured assets), with foreign
-
8/9/2019 Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
38/63
banks currently holding approximately 19 percent of total U.S. banking
assets (U.S. Federal Reserve). Foreign banking investment largely reflects
inflow from large multinational banks with appropriate experience, skills,
capital and a customer-base, which enhances the desirability of expanding
cross-border investments.
The long-term demand for banking services in the U.S. market is likely to
continue to increase at a relatively stable rate. Compared to other
developed economies, the U.S. banking sector remains relatively
fragmented, suggesting that that further consolidation of the industry
through mergers and acquisitions is a real possibility. U.S. banks are
standard-bearers in terms of both profitability and efficiency, and the U.S.
banking market is highly competitive.
4.9 Banking services in India & UnitedStates
While 19 U.S. based banks had Indian branches approved between 2003
and October 2007, no Indian banks had received U.S. approval in the
period. Indian banks had applied to set up three branches, two subsidiaries
and nine representative offices in U.S. territory, with some requestspending for more than five years. The regulatory regime in India provided
a level playing field for foreign and domestic banks. Prudential rules were
the same as for local banks, and foreign banks even enjoyed a lower
priority-sector lending requirement of 32 percent of adjusted bank credit
against 40 percent for Indian banks. Foreign banks had 6.1 percent of
deposits and 6.8 percent of advances in the commercial banking system
as at the end of June, 2007. Foreign banks dominated the off-balance
sheet business with a market share of as high as 72.7 percent, and they
had 52 percent of total foreign exchange turnover in the first half of 2007-
08 (April-March) from 41 percent in 2005-06. Foreign banks also recorded
a higher rate of return than local banks from local operations. Net profit
per branch for foreign banks in 2005-06 was 119.9 million rupees ($30.3
million) compared to 3.3 million rupees for local banks.
4.10 Banking services in China
-
8/9/2019 Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
39/63
As an important component to the country's overall economic system, the
Chinas banking industry has seen rapid growth in line with the economic
development of the Peoples Republic of China (PRC). Banks have
historically been, and continue to be, a significant source of capital for the
economy and the primary choice for domestic savings. The Chinesebanking sector comprises broad categories of banking institutions, namely
joint stock commercial banks, urban commercial banks, urban credit
cooperatives, rural credit cooperatives, foreign-invested commercial banks
and other financial institutions.
As of the year 2006 end, the total assets of the Chinas banking
sector amounted to Yuan 43.95 Trillion (US$ 5.812 Trillion), an increase of
Yuan 16.31 Trillion (US$ 2.16 Trillion) from 2003. During the same period,
the total liabilities of the banking sector reached Yuan 41.71 Trillion (US$
5.516 Trillion), an increase of Yuan 15.14 Trillion (US$ 2.0 Trillion).
.
China's banking sector has taken concrete steps already to meet the
challenges brought about by the country's accession to the World Trade
Organization (WTO).
The Shanghai Bank welcomed three international shareholders in the year
2002, including the global banking giant Hong Kong and Shanghai Banking
Corporation (HSBC) and the International Finance Corporation (IFC) underthe World Bank, which hold 8 percent and 7 percent respectively of the
Shanghai Bank's shares.
According to China's WTO accession agreement in 2001, Beijing agreed to
open its banking sector to full foreign competition from December 11,
2006. But Chinese authorities are formulating new regulations that could
hamper the efforts of overseas banks to attract retail customers. The
banking analysts speculated that Beijing has drafted the new rules in a bid
to contain the influence of foreign banks in China, according to theInternational Herald Tribune.
Chinese financial regulators planned to impose tighter restrictions on
foreign banks trying to get a slice of the country's huge pile of local
currency deposits, worth an estimated US$2 trillion. For the more than 70
foreign banks that operate about 230 branches in the country, the new
regulations could limit future expansion plans into smaller second- and
third-tier cities.
-
8/9/2019 Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
40/63
Foreign banks are eyeing entering the potentially lucrative consumer
banking market where they could seek Yuan-denominated deposits, issue
credit cards, and offer home loans. The proposed rules would call for
foreign banks to incorporate in China with a minimum of RMB1 billion, or
US$123.3 million, in capital before they could compete with domesticbanks for retail customers.
Foreigners are facing growing regulatory hurdles across the financial
sector. In September 2006, international firms were denied the opportunity
to acquire domestic brokerages. The China Securities Regulatory
Commission announced it would stop issuing licenses to foreigners to open
new branches in an effort to give domestic players more time to improve
profitability.
The ban appears to alter plans by Beijing to draw on foreign investors'
capital and management expertise to help clean up a sector plagued for
years by poor management and heavy losses. Under its WTO
commitments, China must allow foreign investors to hold stakes of as
much as 49 percent in local brokerages by December 2006. The current
ceiling is 33 percent.
Foreign banks usually set up their branches in China - initially from special
economic zones to coastal areas and then to regional capital cities, as well
as major economic cities in domestic areas. This kind of distribution isconsistent with the country's opening-up initiatives.
Currently, there are more than 30 cities that are permitted to establish
operational foreign institutions, among which foreign financial institutions
are concentrated in Beijing, Shanghai, Guangzhou, Dalian, Shenzhen,
Tianjin and Xiamen. The Japanese Bank took the initial step by setting up
the first representative office of foreign financial institutions in China in
1979. Since then, Chinese banks began taking advantage of foreign
investment. In 1982 the Hongkong Nanyang Commercial Bank established
its first foreign branch in Shenzhen. Xiamen International Bank, the firstSino-foreign joint venture (JV) bank was set up in 1985. With a rapid
increase of foreign investment in China since the 1990s, more and more
foreign financial institutions have entered the Chinese market.
SMEs are becoming valuable clients to both the Chinese and foreign banks.
In comparison with Chinese banks, foreign banks have more experience in
market segmentation, better credit and risk control, good access to the
international market and more simplified procedures for credit approvals,
all of which serve to attract Chinese enterprises as clients.
In 2003, a qualified foreign institutional investors (QFII) scheme wasintroduced to allow foreign institutional investors, such as UBS, Deutsche
-
8/9/2019 Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
41/63
Bank and Citigroup Global and others to engage in the securities sector on
the Chinese mainland. At present there are 50 approved QFII entities.
At the same time, a total of 17 foreign and Chinese banks have been
approved to invest clients' assets overseas under the qualified domestic
institutional investor (QDII) program. So far, they have launched nine QDIIproducts, with sales of 2.3 billion Yuan (USD291 million) in RMB-
denominated transactions and USD87 million in US dollar-based
transactions.
BANKS PERFORMANCE IN INDIAN ECONOMY(Amount in Rs. Crore)
Indian Banks
State Bank of India Canara Bank Punjab National Bank
Net Worth Return % Net Worth Return % Net Worth Return %
566565.24 15.41 165961.04 18.78 162422.5 16.03
Foreign Banks
ABN Amro
Standard Chartered
Bank HSBC
Net Worth Return % Net Worth Return % Net Worth Return %
32077.67 21.63 58853.18 31.35 54987.15 17.6
Table 3: Return on Net Worth% of Indian and foreign banks in 2006 and 2007
The above table shows the total assets employed by few Indian and
foreign banks in Indian banking sector and their return on net worth % for
the year 2007. It is cleared from the table that the return on net worth %
earned by the foreign banks is higher than the Indian banks. State Bank of
India showed a return on net worth of 15.41% with the total assets of Rs.
566565.24 crore whereas ABN Amro showed a return on net worth of
21.63% with the total assets of Rs. 32077.67 crore in the Indian banking
sector. In the same way, Standard Chartered and HSBC have also shown
better returns comparative to the Indian banks. The reason for the better
performance of foreign banks can be updated technology used, risk
management tools, better operational efficiency, relaxation in the
regulations of RBI, etc. Although the Indian banks have a high amount of
investment in the Indian banking sector but the foreign banks have a
competitive edge of better use of the capital as compared to foreign banks
which is the main reason for their better efficiency. (Refer Annexure 1 &
2)
(Amount in Rs. Crore)Indian Banks
-
8/9/2019 Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
42/63
State Bank of India Punjab National Bank
2006 2007 % change 2006 2007 % change
11299.23 9999.94 -11.5 2917.11 3230.65 10.75
Foreign Banks
Citibank HSBC
2006 2007 % change 2006 2007 % change
1577.1 2180.45 38.26 1277.07 1922.39 50.53
Table 4:Operating Profit of Indian and foreign banks in 2006 and 2007
As shown in Table 2, State Bank of India showed a decline in its operating
profit from Rs. 11299.23 crore in the year 2006 to Rs. 9999.94 crore in the
year 2007 i.e. a decrease of 11.5% whereas Punjab National Bank showed
an increase its operating profit from Rs. 2917.11 crore in the year 2006 toRs. 3230.65 crore in the year 2007 i.e. an increase of 10.75%. These
figures depict that the operational efficiency of PNB has increased in the
year 2007 whereas the operational efficiency of SBI has decreased. Now if
we compare the change in operating profit of Indian banks with foreign
banks, it can be clearly identified that the foreign banks enjoy better
operational efficiency as compared to Indian banks. Citibank showed an
increase in its operating profit from Rs. 1577.1 crore in the year 2006 to
Rs. 2180.45 crore in the year 2007 i.e. an increase of 38.26% and HSBC
showed an increase in its operating profit from Rs. 1277.07 crore in the
year 2006 to Rs. 1922.39 crore in the year 2007 i.e. an increase of
50.53%. Therefore, it is cleared from the above data that Indian banks are
falling behind the foreign banks in its operational efficiency. Foreign banks
operational efficiency is higher than the Indian banks which is the reason
for a higher increase in the operating profits of foreign banks when
compared with Indian banks.
(Refer Annexure 3 & 4)
(Amount in Rs. Crore)
Indian Banks
State Bank of India Canara Bank
Punjab National
Bank
Total AssetsROA %Total Assets ROA % Total AssetsROA %
566565.24 0.84 165961.04 0.98 162422.5 1.03
Foreign Banks
ABN Amro
Standard Chartered
Bank HSBC
Total AssetsROA %Total Assets ROA % Total AssetsROA %32077.67 1.37 58853.18 3.06 54987.15 1.82
-
8/9/2019 Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
43/63
Table 5:ROA% (Return on Assets) of Indian and foreign banks in 2006 and 2007
The above table shows the ROA (Return on Assets %) of different banks in
Indian banking market. ROA indicates the ability of the entity to generatepercentage return on the value of assets employed in the market. SBI had
shown ROA of 0.84 in the year 2007 whereas Canara Bank and PNB have
shown ROA of 0.98 and 1.03 respectively in the same year. Now if we have
a look at the ROA of foreign banks operating in India, ABN Amro had shown
ROA of 1.37 in the year 2007 whereas Standard Chartered Bank and HSBC
had shown ROA of 3.06 and 1.82 in the same year. It is clear from the
figures that ROA generated by the foreign banks in India is higher than the
Indian banks operating in the same market. But the value of assets
possessed by the Indian banks in the Indian banking system is higher thanthe value of assets possessed by the foreign banks. But still, foreign banks
have been able to generate very high profits proportionate to the value of
assets owned by them in the Indian market. This depicts that the foreign
banks have used their assets in a better way as compared to Indian banks.
One of the major reasons for their high efficiency in generating better
returns proportionate to their assets is the regulations or benefits enjoyed
by the foreign banks in the Indian banking segment. (Refer Annexure 5
& 6)
(Amount in Rs. Crore)
Indian Banks
State Bank of India Punjab National Bank
2006 2007 % change 2006 2007 % change
4406.67 4541.31 3.06 1439.31 1540.08 7.00
Foreign Banks
Citibank JP Morgan Chase Bank
2006 2007 % change 2006 2007 % change
705.55 900.00 27.56 72.93 106.79 46.43
Table 6: Net Profit of Indian and foreign banks in 2006 and 2007
The table indicates the net profit earned by few Indian and foreign banks
-
8/9/2019 Ashish Chatrath Final Dissertation
44/63
in the years 2006 and 2007 in the Indian banking sector. SBI had reported
the net profit of Rs. 44