ALICYCLOBACILLUSReview12/12/06
Ian HowardTechnical Manager – Raw Materials
2© gerber juice company ltd 2006
Gerber
• Were called “Gerber Foods Soft Drinks ltd”now we are “Gerber Juice co ltd”
• Pack for supermarkets• 2 factories in UK, 2 in Germany, 1 in Poland, 1
in France, 1 in Turkey• Emig is part of the group• Annual AJC purchase ~ MT
3© gerber juice company ltd 2006
Summary
• Properties of ACB• Previous incidents• Current issues• My observations• ACB – going forward• Summary
4© gerber juice company ltd 2006
Alicyclobacillus• Spore forming bacteria, VERY Heat
resistant• Grows in acidic conditions, pH 2.5 to 6• Needs to be warm, >20C but optimum 45C• Not pathogenic• Taint producer:
– Bromophenols - antiseptic / mouthwash– Guaiacol - hammy, smoky bacon
• Very little visible evidence of growth in thefinished product
5© gerber juice company ltd 2006
Alicyclobacillus – cont.• More than 15 species in the genus• Alicyclobacillus acidoterrestris most often
implicated in spoilage incidents• Taints are not always produced• It has been identified in:
– Fruit juices and concentrates– Sugar syrups– Pectins, acids, thickeners– Teas
• WATER !!
6© gerber juice company ltd 2006
Incidents – AIJN questionnaire 2005• 68 questionnaires returned – world wide• 45% had a problem in the last 3 years with
alicyclobacillus ( ACB)• 18 companies identified APPLE as the
source of the problem• 4 identified orange,• ALL other sources: 11
7© gerber juice company ltd 2006
Is it such a big problem?
8© gerber juice company ltd 2006
GERBER - ACB results since 1/June/06
No77China 3
No00156China 1YESYesUK
YESYESYES
Deliverieshalted ?
No1143440China 2
2
1
412001
ACBHigh
No245664China 4
No178Germany 3No1158Germany 2
No32211Germany 1Yes0102Poland 5No276677Poland 4No0178Poland 3No0044Poland 2No145258Poland 1
Taint injuice ?
ACBMedium
ACBLow
ACB NotDetected
NumberofDeliveries
Supplier
9© gerber juice company ltd 2006
Why Is There ACB in Apple JuiceConcentrate ?
• Contaminated fruit• Dirty flume water• Inadequate washing and sorting• Inappropriate use of evaporator water• Over reliance on Ultra Filtration• Inadequate sterilisation of the plant• Poor testing
10© gerber juice company ltd 2006
Contaminated Fruit• ACB is ubiquitous in soil• Wind blown dust• Fruit picked up from the ground• Fruit stored on the ground• “Dirty” lorries• Twigs and leaves
“ACB is not IN the fruit it is ON the fruit”
11© gerber juice company ltd 2006
12© gerber juice company ltd 2006
Flume Water – Alicyclobacillus Soup• Change frequency?
– Hourly?– 8 hourly?– Daily?– Weekly ( whether it needs it or not ) ?
• On what basis is it changed ?– When it looks dirty?– When it does not interfere with production?– Cost of the “clean” water?– Cost of getting rid of it?– When the levels of ACB have risen to a point
where they start to overwhelm the fruit washingstation ?
13© gerber juice company ltd 2006
Inadequate washing and sorting• No Fruit rotation under the “clean” water
sprays• No controls on quantity of fruit being rinsed
or sorted• Poorly positioned water sprays• Use of untreated evaporator water• No in-place cleaning of the picking belts
“Once the fruit is in the mill it is damagelimitation there after”
14© gerber juice company ltd 2006
Poland
15© gerber juice company ltd 2006
Poland
16© gerber juice company ltd 2006
Poland
17© gerber juice company ltd 2006
Turkey
18© gerber juice company ltd 2006
19© gerber juice company ltd 2006
20© gerber juice company ltd 2006
21© gerber juice company ltd 2006
Turkey
22© gerber juice company ltd 2006
Turkey
23© gerber juice company ltd 2006
Evaporator Water• Everybody uses it somewhere in the plant• It often contains ACB, >1000 spores /ml• An Evaporator is an ideal place to grow ACB• How often should it be tested for the
presence of ACB?– Daily?– Weekly?– Every season?– Never?
24© gerber juice company ltd 2006
Evaporator Water cont.
• It should be tested regularly with a reliableand sensitive method to ensure that– EITHER it is free of ACB under all plant
conditions– OR the treatment it receives continues to
be effective
• Evaporator Water should be handled andused with care
25© gerber juice company ltd 2006
Filtration• Ultra Filtration can remove ACB spores from
the juice stream but these items ofequipment are run to produce juice of aspecified turbidity NOT an absence of ACB
• Dedicated ACB filters can be very effective
• They should not be able to be bypassed
26© gerber juice company ltd 2006
Plant Cleaning and Sterilisation
• Does a hot solution of sodium hydroxide killACB spores?
PROBABLY NOT
Sterilisation and cleaning are not the same.
27© gerber juice company ltd 2006
Sterilants
3.530300Peraceticacid
>5104,000Hydrogenperoxide
>5540Chlorinedioxide
6101000Hypochlorite
LogReductions
Timeminutes
Concentrationppm
Substance
28© gerber juice company ltd 2006
Plant Cleaning and Sterilisation – cont.
• Temperature – concentration – contact time– Verification is necessary to demonstrate
that the cleaning and sterilisation regimewill remove or significantly reduce ACB
• The important areas of the plant need to betargeted and monitored by regular testing
29© gerber juice company ltd 2006
Testing for ACB• IFU 12, February 2006
This method is gaining wide acceptance asthe method to use
• If another method is in use then it should becompared with IFU 12. There can be BIGdifferences in sensitivity
• A positive control must be performed witheach batch of samples
• Rapid methods have their place but theirsensitivities can be low which can give theuser a false sense of security!
30© gerber juice company ltd 2006
Issues from Recent Audits of AppleProcessors
• Unacceptable unloading practices “wetunloading”
• Inadequate washing / fluming• Inadequate sorting – in one company none
at all!• Use of untreated evaporator water• No effective ACB testing program• Non proven sanitising regimes• Poor ACB testing methods• Over reliance on specialist ACB filters
31© gerber juice company ltd 2006
“Wet Unloading ”(Use of Water Jets to Wash Fruit Out of
Delivery Trucks)
“A fruit unloading system and atruck washing facility utilising thesame water”
32© gerber juice company ltd 2006
Wet Unloading – cont.• How is it possible to avoid contaminating the
fruit with:Diesel residuesAutomotive greasesTyre and break residuesAnything the truck has driven through onits way to the factory??
• “A completely unacceptable way tohandle a foodstuff”
33© gerber juice company ltd 2006
no
no
yes
no
yes
Equiv.
no
no
ISO9000
Cargill
Cargill
Cargill
IFU 12
IFU 12
IFU 12
IFU 12
InHouse
ACBmethodused
8 hourly
weekly
weekly
weekly
8 hourly
8 hourly
daily
weekly
Flumewaterchange
yesyesTwiceChem.Nonepoordry8
yesnonevernonepoorpoorwet7
yesnosomeChem.OKpoordry6
yesyesoncenopoorpoorwet5
yesyesdailyUVpoorV poordry4
nononevernopoorpoordry3
yesnonevernopoorpoorwet2
yesnonevernopoorpoorwet1
ACBfilters?
Microlabonsite?
Evap.watertested ?
Evap.watertreated?
Fruitsorting
Fruitwashing
Wetordry
8 Polish factories
34© gerber juice company ltd 2006
ACB Code of Best Practice• Gerber has approached the AIJN to help it
organise the production of a Code of BestPractice for the Control of ACB for the juiceindustry.
• The first meeting of the working group, 30th
Oct• It is hoped to have the document completed
early next year
35© gerber juice company ltd 2006
Summary• The control of ACB requires a systematic
approach to reduce / eliminate theorganism at
ALL STEPS IN THE PROCESS OFPROVIDING APPLE JUICE FOR THECONSUMER
– Good Manufacturing Practice by the packer ie Gerber Juice !
36© gerber juice company ltd 2006
Summary cont.
• It cannot be solved just by the installation ofa specialist filter
• The method used to test for ACB must besensitive and reliable
• All the control measures and systems needto be challenged and shown to be effective
• If you don’t look you don’t see!