![Page 1: Active exterior cloaking - Purdue University · 2012. 7. 4. · Active exterior cloaking Fernando Guevara Vasquez University of Utah June 18 2012 Conference in honor of Gunther Uhlmann,](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081621/61282db13fc5315f1440f820/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Active exterior cloaking
Fernando Guevara VasquezUniversity of Utah
June 18 2012Conference in honor of Gunther Uhlmann, UC Irvine
Collaborators
Graeme W. Milton (University of Utah)
Daniel Onofrei (University of Houston)
Fernando Guevara Vasquez, Active exterior cloaking 1/28
![Page 2: Active exterior cloaking - Purdue University · 2012. 7. 4. · Active exterior cloaking Fernando Guevara Vasquez University of Utah June 18 2012 Conference in honor of Gunther Uhlmann,](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081621/61282db13fc5315f1440f820/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Cloaking types
Interior/Exterior: Is the object hidden inside or outside a device?Passive/Active: Are sources needed to cloak?
• Passive Interior• Transformation based cloaking: Leonhardt; Cummer, Pendry,
Schurig, Smith; Greenleaf, Kurylev, Lassas, Uhlmann; Farhat,Enoch, Guenneau; Kohn, Onofrei, Shen, Vogelius, Weinstein;Cai, Chettiar, Kildishev, Shalaev; . . .
• Plasmonic cloaking: Alu, Engheta.
• Passive Exterior• Anomalous resonances: McPhedran, Milton, Nicorovici.• Complementary media: Lai, Chen, Zhang, Chan.• Plasmonic cloaking: Alu, Engheta, . . .
• Active Interior: Miller
• Active Exterior:• Onofrei, Ren: integral equation framework• This work: (Laplace and) Helmholtz equations.
Fernando Guevara Vasquez, Active exterior cloaking 2/28
![Page 3: Active exterior cloaking - Purdue University · 2012. 7. 4. · Active exterior cloaking Fernando Guevara Vasquez University of Utah June 18 2012 Conference in honor of Gunther Uhlmann,](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081621/61282db13fc5315f1440f820/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Helmholtz equation∆u+ k2u = 0
Fernando Guevara Vasquez, Active exterior cloaking 3/28
![Page 4: Active exterior cloaking - Purdue University · 2012. 7. 4. · Active exterior cloaking Fernando Guevara Vasquez University of Utah June 18 2012 Conference in honor of Gunther Uhlmann,](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081621/61282db13fc5315f1440f820/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Active interior cloaking
−20 0 20−20
0
20
−20 0 20−20
0
20
−20 0 20−20
0
20
Proposed by Miller 2001, but well known in acoustics since the 60s(Malyuzhinets; Jessel and Mangiante;. . .)
Fernando Guevara Vasquez, Active exterior cloaking 4/28
![Page 5: Active exterior cloaking - Purdue University · 2012. 7. 4. · Active exterior cloaking Fernando Guevara Vasquez University of Utah June 18 2012 Conference in honor of Gunther Uhlmann,](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081621/61282db13fc5315f1440f820/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Green’s identity
Let D be a domain in Rd (d = 2 or 3) with Lipschitz boundary.
ud(x) =
∫∂D
dSy {−(n(y) · ∇yui(y))G(x, y) + ui(y)n(y) · ∇yG(x, y)}
=
{−ui(x), if x ∈ D0, otherwise,
where the Green’s function for the Helmholtz equation is
G(x, y) =
i4H
(1)0 (k|x− y|) in 2D
eik|x−y|
4π|x− y|in 3D
we get a single and double layer potential on ∂D so that
• ui + ud = 0 in D
• ud = 0 in Rd\D.
Fernando Guevara Vasquez, Active exterior cloaking 5/28
![Page 6: Active exterior cloaking - Purdue University · 2012. 7. 4. · Active exterior cloaking Fernando Guevara Vasquez University of Utah June 18 2012 Conference in honor of Gunther Uhlmann,](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081621/61282db13fc5315f1440f820/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Active interior cloaking
−20 0 20−20
0
20
−20 0 20−20
0
20
−20 0 20−20
0
20
• With Green’s identities: The object is completely surroundedby the cloak.
• To get exterior cloaking: replace the single and double layerpotential in Green’s identities by a few devices.
Fernando Guevara Vasquez, Active exterior cloaking 6/28
![Page 7: Active exterior cloaking - Purdue University · 2012. 7. 4. · Active exterior cloaking Fernando Guevara Vasquez University of Utah June 18 2012 Conference in honor of Gunther Uhlmann,](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081621/61282db13fc5315f1440f820/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Active exterior cloaking (in 2D)
Devices’ field udev must satisfy Helmholtz equation withSommerfeld radiation condition. For point-like devices located atpositions xj:
ud(x) =
ndev∑j=1
∞∑m=−∞bj,mVm(x− xj),
where the radiating solutions to the Helmholtz equation are
Vm(x) ≡ H(1)m (k |x|) exp[im arg(x)].
Fernando Guevara Vasquez, Active exterior cloaking 7/28
![Page 8: Active exterior cloaking - Purdue University · 2012. 7. 4. · Active exterior cloaking Fernando Guevara Vasquez University of Utah June 18 2012 Conference in honor of Gunther Uhlmann,](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081621/61282db13fc5315f1440f820/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Designing devices that mimic Green’s identities
udev ≈ 0
γ
δ
αudev ≈ −uinc
We need:
(a) udev(x) ≈ −uinc(x) for |x| 6 α
(b) udev(x) ≈ 0 for |x| > γ
Since utot = ui + ud + uscat,
(a) ⇒ utot(x) ≈ 0 for |x| 6 α
(b) ⇒ utot(x) ≈ uinc(x) for |x| > γ
Caveats
• We need to know the incident field in advance, from e.g.sensors.
• Information from sensors needs to travel faster than incidentfield (OK for acoustics. For electromagnetics: periodicity?)
• Need very accurate reproduction of incident field(OK in controlled environments like MRI?)
Fernando Guevara Vasquez, Active exterior cloaking 8/28
![Page 9: Active exterior cloaking - Purdue University · 2012. 7. 4. · Active exterior cloaking Fernando Guevara Vasquez University of Utah June 18 2012 Conference in honor of Gunther Uhlmann,](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081621/61282db13fc5315f1440f820/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Finding the coefficients numerically
γ
pαj
αpγj
(a’) udev(x) ≈ −uinc(x) for |x| = α
(b’) udev(x) ≈ 0 for |x| = γ
Construct matrices A, B s.t.Ab = [udev(p
α1 ), . . . ,udev(p
αNα)]
T ,
Bb = [udev(pγ1 ), . . . ,udev(p
γNγ)]
T ,
where b ∈ C(2M+1)D
≡ device coefficients.
1. Find b0 = argmin ‖Ab+ uinc(|x| = |α|)‖22 (enforce (a’))
2. Find b∗ = argminAb=Ab0
‖Bb‖22 (enforce (b’))
Fernando Guevara Vasquez, Active exterior cloaking 9/28
![Page 10: Active exterior cloaking - Purdue University · 2012. 7. 4. · Active exterior cloaking Fernando Guevara Vasquez University of Utah June 18 2012 Conference in honor of Gunther Uhlmann,](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081621/61282db13fc5315f1440f820/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Cloaking for one single frequency
Inactive devices Active devices
−20 0 20−20
0
20
−20 0 20−20
0
20
c = 3× 108m/s, λ = 12.5cm, ω/(2π) = 2.4GHzα = 2λ, δ = 5λ, γ = 10λ.
Fernando Guevara Vasquez, Active exterior cloaking 10/28
![Page 11: Active exterior cloaking - Purdue University · 2012. 7. 4. · Active exterior cloaking Fernando Guevara Vasquez University of Utah June 18 2012 Conference in honor of Gunther Uhlmann,](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081621/61282db13fc5315f1440f820/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Scattering reduction
Perc
entr
educ
tion
1.2 2.4 3.610
−6
10−4
10−2
ω/(2π) in GHz
c = 3× 108m/s, λ0 = 12.5cm, ω/(2π) ∈ [1.2, 3.6]GHz
Fernando Guevara Vasquez, Active exterior cloaking 11/28
![Page 12: Active exterior cloaking - Purdue University · 2012. 7. 4. · Active exterior cloaking Fernando Guevara Vasquez University of Utah June 18 2012 Conference in honor of Gunther Uhlmann,](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081621/61282db13fc5315f1440f820/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Devices for many frequencies (pulse)
By superposition principle: sum device fields for many ω to getcloaking in a bandwidth (i.e. in the time domain).
Fernando Guevara Vasquez, Active exterior cloaking 12/28
![Page 13: Active exterior cloaking - Purdue University · 2012. 7. 4. · Active exterior cloaking Fernando Guevara Vasquez University of Utah June 18 2012 Conference in honor of Gunther Uhlmann,](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081621/61282db13fc5315f1440f820/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Green cloak devices idea
∂D1
x2
∂D2
x1x4
∂D4
x3
∂D3
Idea The contribution of portion ∂Dj to the single and doublelayer potentials in Green’s formula is replaced by a multipolarsource located at xj /∈ ∂D.
Fernando Guevara Vasquez, Active exterior cloaking 13/28
![Page 14: Active exterior cloaking - Purdue University · 2012. 7. 4. · Active exterior cloaking Fernando Guevara Vasquez University of Utah June 18 2012 Conference in honor of Gunther Uhlmann,](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081621/61282db13fc5315f1440f820/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Graf’s addition formula
The Green’s function G(x, y) can be written as a superposition ofsources located at xj:
G(x, y) =i
4H
(1)0 (k
∣∣x− xj − (y − xj)∣∣)
=i
4
∞∑m=−∞Vm(x− xj)Um(y − xj),
where the entire cylindrical waves are
Um(x) ≡ Jm(k |x|) exp[im arg(x)]
and the sum converges uniformly in compact subsets of∣∣x− xj∣∣ > ∣∣y − xj
∣∣.Use summation formula to “move” monopoles and dipoles from aportion of the boundary to the corresponding xj.
Fernando Guevara Vasquez, Active exterior cloaking 14/28
![Page 15: Active exterior cloaking - Purdue University · 2012. 7. 4. · Active exterior cloaking Fernando Guevara Vasquez University of Utah June 18 2012 Conference in honor of Gunther Uhlmann,](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081621/61282db13fc5315f1440f820/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Green cloak devices
The device field
ud(x) =
ndev∑j=1
∞∑m=−∞bj,mVm(x− xj),
with
bj,m =
∫∂Dj
dSy{(−n(y) · ∇yui(y))Um(y − xj)
+ ui(y)n(y) · ∇yUm(y − xj)}
converges (uniformly in compact subsets) outside of the region
R =
ndev⋃l=1
B
(xl, sup
y∈∂Dl|y − xl|
).
Fernando Guevara Vasquez, Active exterior cloaking 15/28
![Page 16: Active exterior cloaking - Purdue University · 2012. 7. 4. · Active exterior cloaking Fernando Guevara Vasquez University of Utah June 18 2012 Conference in honor of Gunther Uhlmann,](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081621/61282db13fc5315f1440f820/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
A specific configuration
With D = B(0,σ) and devices |xj| = δ:
x2
x3
x1σ
D
δ
• Gray disks have radius: r(σ, δ) = ((σ− δ/2)2 + 3δ2/4)1/2.
• Largest disk in cloaked region radius: reff(σ, δ) = δ− r(σ, δ).
• Largest cloaked region (σ∗ = δ/2):r∗eff(δ) = (1 −
√3/2)δ ≈ 0.13δ.
Fernando Guevara Vasquez, Active exterior cloaking 16/28
![Page 17: Active exterior cloaking - Purdue University · 2012. 7. 4. · Active exterior cloaking Fernando Guevara Vasquez University of Utah June 18 2012 Conference in honor of Gunther Uhlmann,](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081621/61282db13fc5315f1440f820/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Green’s formula SVD
Dev
ice’
sfi
eldud
−20 0 20−20
0
20
−20 0 20−20
0
20
Tot
alfi
eldui+ud+us
−20 0 20−20
0
20
−20 0 20−20
0
20
Fernando Guevara Vasquez, Active exterior cloaking 17/28
![Page 18: Active exterior cloaking - Purdue University · 2012. 7. 4. · Active exterior cloaking Fernando Guevara Vasquez University of Utah June 18 2012 Conference in honor of Gunther Uhlmann,](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081621/61282db13fc5315f1440f820/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Cloak performance
‖ui + ud‖/‖ui‖ on |x| = (1 −√
3/2)δ ‖ud‖/‖ui‖ on |x| = 2δ(p
erce
nt)
5 25 5010
−5
10−4
10−3
10−2
10−1
100
101
(per
cen
t)
5 25 5010
−15
10−10
10−5
100
(a): δ (in λ) (b): δ (in λ)
• blue: SVD method with M(δ) terms
• red: Green’s identity method with M(δ) terms
• green: Green’s identity method with 2M(δ) terms
Fernando Guevara Vasquez, Active exterior cloaking 18/28
![Page 19: Active exterior cloaking - Purdue University · 2012. 7. 4. · Active exterior cloaking Fernando Guevara Vasquez University of Utah June 18 2012 Conference in honor of Gunther Uhlmann,](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081621/61282db13fc5315f1440f820/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Size of the “throats”
cut-off |ud(x)| = 100 cut-off |ud(x)| = 5
(dev
ice
rad
ius
/δ
)
5 25 500.55
0.6
0.65
0.7
0.75
0.8
0.85
0.9
(dev
ice
rad
ius
/δ
)
5 25 500.55
0.6
0.65
0.7
0.75
0.8
0.85
0.9
(a): δ (in λ) (b): δ (in λ)
Estimated device radius relative to δ for different values of δ.
Fernando Guevara Vasquez, Active exterior cloaking 19/28
![Page 20: Active exterior cloaking - Purdue University · 2012. 7. 4. · Active exterior cloaking Fernando Guevara Vasquez University of Utah June 18 2012 Conference in honor of Gunther Uhlmann,](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081621/61282db13fc5315f1440f820/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Cloaking for Helmholtz equation in 3D
With D =tetrahedron inscribed in B(0,σ), devices |xj| = δ:
(a) suboptimal, σ = δ/5 (b) optimal, σ = δ/3
• Radius of gray balls: r(σ, δ) =((σ− δ
3
)2+ 8
9δ2) 1
2. (green)
• Largest ball in cloaked region: reff(σ, δ) = δ− r(σ, δ). (red)
• Largest cloaked region: r∗eff =(
1 − 2√
23
)δ ≈ 0.057δ.
Fernando Guevara Vasquez, Active exterior cloaking 20/28
![Page 21: Active exterior cloaking - Purdue University · 2012. 7. 4. · Active exterior cloaking Fernando Guevara Vasquez University of Utah June 18 2012 Conference in honor of Gunther Uhlmann,](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081621/61282db13fc5315f1440f820/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
z = −2σ z = −σ z = 0 z = σ z = 2σud
utot
(act
ive)
utot
(in
acti
ve)
Fernando Guevara Vasquez, Active exterior cloaking 21/28
![Page 22: Active exterior cloaking - Purdue University · 2012. 7. 4. · Active exterior cloaking Fernando Guevara Vasquez University of Utah June 18 2012 Conference in honor of Gunther Uhlmann,](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081621/61282db13fc5315f1440f820/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
|ud| = 100 |ud| = 5
Contours of |ud| (gray) and |ud + ui| = 10−2 (red).
Fernando Guevara Vasquez, Active exterior cloaking 22/28
![Page 23: Active exterior cloaking - Purdue University · 2012. 7. 4. · Active exterior cloaking Fernando Guevara Vasquez University of Utah June 18 2012 Conference in honor of Gunther Uhlmann,](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081621/61282db13fc5315f1440f820/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
δ = 6λ δ = 12λ
δ = 18λ δ = 24λ
Cross-section of level set |ud| > 102 (black) and of the region R(shades of gray) on the sphere |x| = σ for the optimal σ = δ/3.
Fernando Guevara Vasquez, Active exterior cloaking 23/28
![Page 24: Active exterior cloaking - Purdue University · 2012. 7. 4. · Active exterior cloaking Fernando Guevara Vasquez University of Utah June 18 2012 Conference in honor of Gunther Uhlmann,](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081621/61282db13fc5315f1440f820/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Main ingredients for Helmholtz 3D active cloaking
• Green’s identity: mono- and dipole density on ∂D reproducesincident field ui in D.
• Device Ansatz:
ud(x) =
ndev∑l=1
∞∑n=0
n∑m=−n
bl,n,mVmn (x− xl).
• Movable source: (Graf’s Identity)
G(x, y) = linear combination of Vmn (x− xl).
Fernando Guevara Vasquez, Active exterior cloaking 24/28
![Page 25: Active exterior cloaking - Purdue University · 2012. 7. 4. · Active exterior cloaking Fernando Guevara Vasquez University of Utah June 18 2012 Conference in honor of Gunther Uhlmann,](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081621/61282db13fc5315f1440f820/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Main ingredients for Maxwell active cloaking
• Stratton-Chu Formula: magnetic and electric dipole densityon ∂D reproduces incident field Ei,Hi in D.
• Device Ansatz:
Ed(x) =
ndev∑l=1
∞∑n=1
n∑m=−n
al,n,m∇×((x− xl)Vmn (x− xl))
+bl,n,m∇×∇×((x− xl)Vmn (x− xl))
• Movable source: (vector addition theorem)
G(x, y)p = linear combination of
∇×((x− xl)Vmn (x− xl)),
∇×∇×((x− xl)Vmn (x− xl)), and
∇Vmn (x− xl).
(REU with Michael Bentley)Fernando Guevara Vasquez, Active exterior cloaking 25/28
![Page 26: Active exterior cloaking - Purdue University · 2012. 7. 4. · Active exterior cloaking Fernando Guevara Vasquez University of Utah June 18 2012 Conference in honor of Gunther Uhlmann,](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081621/61282db13fc5315f1440f820/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Directionality with stationary phase method
u(x) = exp[ikd · x]
y∗
d
x
(with Leonid Kunyansky)Fernando Guevara Vasquez, Active exterior cloaking 26/28
![Page 27: Active exterior cloaking - Purdue University · 2012. 7. 4. · Active exterior cloaking Fernando Guevara Vasquez University of Utah June 18 2012 Conference in honor of Gunther Uhlmann,](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081621/61282db13fc5315f1440f820/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Directionality with stationary phase method
u(x) = 0
y∗
d
x
y∗∗
(with Leonid Kunyansky)Fernando Guevara Vasquez, Active exterior cloaking 26/28
![Page 28: Active exterior cloaking - Purdue University · 2012. 7. 4. · Active exterior cloaking Fernando Guevara Vasquez University of Utah June 18 2012 Conference in honor of Gunther Uhlmann,](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081621/61282db13fc5315f1440f820/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Future work
• Time domain problems (active control of waves)
• Approximate Green’s identities with a few devices whileenforcing a constraint (e.g. penalize size of devices)
Fernando Guevara Vasquez, Active exterior cloaking 27/28
![Page 29: Active exterior cloaking - Purdue University · 2012. 7. 4. · Active exterior cloaking Fernando Guevara Vasquez University of Utah June 18 2012 Conference in honor of Gunther Uhlmann,](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081621/61282db13fc5315f1440f820/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
Thank you!
Fernando Guevara Vasquez, Active exterior cloaking 28/28