A review of excised biopsy tract histology for primary bone tumours: Is excision necessary?
Price A, Maxwell C, Beardsall J, Jeys L
Background• Biopsy tracts are excised at the point of definitive
surgery.
• Theoretical risk of malignant seeding of the biopsy tract.
• Cases of malignant seeding of the needle biopsy tracts in other malignancies.
• Insufficient evidence to suggest that biopsy tracts pose a risk to local recurrence
• Case reports and small studies are conflicting.
Aims1. To investigate how frequently biopsy
tract excision is carried out at ROH.
2. To establish the incidence of seeding of biopsy tracts in our patients.
3. Evaluate whether certain tumour types are more likely to seed a biopsy tract.
4. Determine whether the excision of biopsy tracts reduces the rate of local recurrence.
Methods• A retrospective analysis of 278 patients with
primary bone tumours• 1/1/08-31/12/09 • Minimum 3 years follow up.
Histology reports for all patients were reviewed.
The database was used to find:• Diagnosis• Age at diagnosis• Type and date of biopsy• Type and date of surgical procedure• Local recurrence, metastases and death.
Statistical analysis was carried out using Statsview (Berkley, California).
278Primary bone tumours
between 2008-2009
203Surgery recorded at
ROH
109Biopsy tract excised
108Negative biopsy tract
histology
1Positive biopsy tract
histology
94Biopsy tract not
commented upon in pathology report
75No surgery recorded at
ROH
Patient selection
203 patients at ROH• Mean age at diagnosis was 33yrs
(range 3-90yrs).• 88% underwent needle biopsy as the
method of biopsy.• Wide range of definitive surgical
procedures.
109 had a biopsy tract excision
94 did not have a tract excision mentioned
– 45 amputations - ?tract excised– The remainder could not be identified at
the time of surgery?– Average time from biopsy to procedure
for these patients 4mths
109 patients with excised biopsy tract
• The primary diagnosis varied considerably
• 108 patients had no evidence of seeding.
• 1 patient had histological evidence of seeding within the biopsy tract:
“..along the needle track, a 3mm solid nodule of high grade sarcoma similar to the high grade
component of the intraosseous tumour. This nodule most likely represents an implant.”
One case of malignant infiltration• 72yr old with dedifferentiated
chondrosarcoma of the distal femur.
• Needle biopsy 20 days prior to EPR and excision of the biopsy tract.
• Large local recurrence within 5 months of diagnosis.
• The patient died 10 months later with metastatic disease.
Local recurrence rates
• The group who did not have a biopsy tract excision had less LR than the excised group
9 vs. 19%, p=0.04
• This probably reflects a higher rate of amputation in the non biopsy group.
• Not excising the tract does not necessarily increase the risk of local recurrence.
Time to local recurrence
0
.2
.4
.6
.8
1
Cum
. S
urv
ival
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40Time
Event Times (tract)
Cum. Survival (tract)
Event Times (No tract)
Cum. Survival (No tract)
Kaplan-Meier Cum. Survival Plot for TimeToLRCensor Variable: LrcensorGrouping Variable: Tract?
Survival
0
.2
.4
.6
.8
1
Cum
. Sur
viva
l
0 10 20 30 40 50 60Time
Event Times (tract)
Cum. Survival (tract)
Event Times (No tract)
Cum. Survival (No tract)
Kaplan-Meier Cum. Survival Plot for TimeAliveCensor Variable: CensoredGrouping Variable: Tract?
Discussion• Our study shows that biopsy tract excision was not commented upon in 46%
cases, of those 48% underwent amputation.
• 49 patients (24%) had no biopsy tract excised at definitive surgery, as it may be that the tract was difficult to locate.
• Local recurrence rate was lower in patients who did not undergo biopsy excision, however, this is most likely to be due to the large number of amputations carried out in this group.
• Survival and time to LR recurrence remained the same in both groups.
• We have since become aware of three previous incidences of biopsy tract seeding in patients at the ROH between 1996-1999. These were all in chrondrosarcomas.
Conclusion• Removal of biopsy tract remains the gold
standard.
• Association between local recurrence and biopsy tracts is difficult to confirm.
• The biopsy tract may be at higher risk in tumours such as chondrosarcomas which do not receive chemotherapy.
Take home messageOverall the rate of seeding in our cohort is low.
This reassures us that the patient is unlikely to be compromised if identification or removal of the biopsy tract proves difficult.
References 1. A. Jalgaonkar, S. J. Dawson-Bowling, A. T. Mohan, B. Spiegelberg, A. Sai Identification of the biopsy track in
musculoskeletal tumour surgery: A novel technique using India ink Bone Joint J February 2013 95-B:250-253.2. A Jalgaonkar, A Mohan, R Pollock, J Skinner, S Cannon, T Briggs et al Preoperative biopsy tract identification using
India ink skin tattoo in tumour surgery Bone Joint J February 2013 95-B:250-253.3. R. Pollock and P Stalley Biopsy of musculo-skeletal tumours, beware the danger J Bone Joint Surg Br 2004 vol. 86-B
no. SUPP IV 484 4. S Saghieh, K Masrouha, K Musallam, R Mahfouz, M Abboud, N Khoury et al The risk of local recurrence along the
core-needle biopsy tract in patients with bone sarcomas Iowa Orthop J. 2010; 30: 80–83.5. Schwartz HS, Spengler DM. Ann Surg Oncol. Needle tract recurrences after closed biopsy for sarcoma: three cases
and review of the literature. 1997 Apr-May;4(3):228-36.6. Kaffenberger BH, Wakely PE Jr, Mayerson JL. Local recurrence rate of fine-needle aspiration biopsy in primary high-
grade sarcomas. J Surg Oncol. 2010 Jun 1;101(7):618-21. doi: 10.1002/jso.21552.7. Ribeiro MB, Oliveira CRG, Filippi RZ, Baptista AM, Caiero MT, Saito CF et al. Histopathological study on biopsy track
in malignant musculoskeletal tumors. ActaOrtop Bras. [online]. 2009; 17(5):279-81. Available from URL: http://www.scielo.br/aob.
8. Lemsawatdikul K, Gooding CA, Twomey EL, Kim GE, Goldsby RE, Cohen I, O'Donnell RJ. Seeding of osteosarcoma in the biopsy tract of a patient with multifocal osteosarcoma. Pediatr Radio. 2005 Jul;35(7):717-21. Epub 2005 Mar 9
9. Davies NM, Livesley PJ, Cannon SR .Recurrence of an osteosarcoma in a needle biopsy track. J Bone Joint Surg Br. 1993 Nov;75(6):977-8.
10. Bickels J, Jelinek J, Shmookler B, Neff R, Malawer M Biopsy of Musculoskeltal Tumors Current concepts Clinical orthopaedics and related research Numer 368 pp212-219
11. C F Loughran, C R Keeling Seeding of tumour cells following breast biopsy: a literature review Br J Radiol. 2011 October; 84(1006): 869–874.