Download - A Mr 410142010 Eng
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
1/48
in"isible"icimsMIgRAntS on tHEMo!E In ME#ICo
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
2/48
a3*9> i39*73&93& & '& ;**39 + 2.8 3 79*7, *'*7 &3
&9;9 3 7* 9&3 150 397* &3 9*7797* 7 *'*7 &3 ' 3&93.
a3*9> i39*73&93& P'&93
F79 '* 3 2010 '>
a3*9> i39*73&93& P'&93
i39*73&93& s*7*9&7&9
P*9*7 b*3*33 h*
1 e&93 s97**9
l33 #c1$ 0D#
!39* K3
a3*9> i39*73&93&,
i39*73&93& s*7*9&7&9, !39* K3
a 79 7**7;*. '&93 >79, '9
&> '* 7*7* '> &3> *9 ,
&&33 &3 9*&3 7*, '9 39 +7 7*&*.
* >79 *7 7*6*9 9&9 & * '* 7*9*7*
3 3
&3> 9*7 79&3*, 7 +7 7*-* 3 9*7 '&93,7 +7 97&3&93 7 &&9&93, 77 &'*.
Cover photo: o3* + 9* &3 7&39 97&;* 9
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
3/48
CONENS
LI$% !f %e#M$ 3
Me%h!d!L!g* 4
1/INrOd!CION 5
2/hE dANgErS Of hE jO!rNE% 11
KIdA""Ig, %h#eA%$ Ad A$$A&L% 11
'I!Lece AgAI$% MIg#A% !Me 15
MI$$Ig !# KILLed 18
3/Ab!SES d!rINg mIgrAION ChECkS 21
ece$$I'e f!#ce 23
e%!#%I! 24
4/rEpArIAION, rEmEd%, rEdrESS ANd prOECION 27
'!L&%A#* #e"A%#IA%I! 27
#Igh% %! If!#MA%I! Ad LegAL Ad'Ice 28
fILIg A c!M"LAI% 28
%eM"!#A#* 'I$A$ 29
I'e$%IgA%I! 30
%he A%I!AL h&MA #Igh%$ c!MMI$$I! 31
5/INErNAIONAl ANd NAIONAl lA# 33
I%e#A%I!AL h&MA #Igh%$ LA 33
LegAL f#AMe!#K I MeIc! 34
6/CONCl!SIONS ANd rECOmmENdAIONS 37
#ec!MMedA%I!$ 39
ed!%e$ 42
I: AM# 41/014/2010 A:? I:(:( A 2010
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
4/48
BA23*89>I39*73&9.43&1
I have a family... and I made them a
promise that I must fulfil... This is
a journey full of suffering but when
I get to my destination everythingwill be better.
M %
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
5/48
lIS Of ErmS
CDH P @ H> ' C@>>@
(C@>V @ D@ H>@, CDH)
@@>@ @ > @
> @>. I 5 I@
2005 @ @> @ @
@J >. CDH @J
@ @ @>@ @> >J @
@ @ @- @. I CDH
@ @ @ @>,
>J @ >
@ @>>@
@J @ >J . CDH
@>>@ J @ >
J J @ /@ >
@ J @@M @.
CDH @>>@ @ .
C%A'ED P @ C@ @ @ @
D>@ (C@@ @ V
D>V, C%A'ED).
F @ P F @ (@>J
F @ F I@
AJ), @> @J @
#J @ J, @J @>
J @J @ J
G @@ " ( @) @
@ #@ @@ @
> @ > .1
FE+I#'A P F @@M % @
+@ C> @> C (FT E @ D@
+@ @ # J @,
FE+I#'A)
G@ B P G@ B (G@ B
@V #) > >
@ J @ #@
@ @ @ >, @
, @ < @ , J@,
@ @ @. 144
16 G@ B , >J @
@ @ @> @ @ @.
A @ @> > @ J
. J @ @K @ J
@ >@ @ 2 J C@>>@
@ J # @ I@. I#
@ 47 >@ @ @
@J. %J I# @ F @
@K N@ J < @
>O.3
I#*E'E P @ I @ @>
(I@ @ #, I#*E'E)
I > P # @ @ @
>@ @ @ > @J.
"G P 1974 G @@ " ("J
G @V, "G) @J
('>@ "J G @V, '"G)
@ @@ @ @ >@.
GE P A@J GM %
(@T G @ E@,
GE) @ #@M 31 F
D. J @ @
@ @- > @
@>> J @ > @.
G' P F A@J GM %
(@T G 'W, G')
@ @ @
> @, >
@ ; @K >; -
@ @; - >; >
@; > @>> J
@ >@.
EG%B P #J @ I@ (T
G@V, EG%B) @ @
>>@ @ @ >@,
J @ @ @,
@, @ @ @@ @
>.
IN"ISIblE "ICImS
MIg#A%$ ! %he M!'e I MeIc!
I: AM# 41/014/2010 A:? I:(:( A 2010
3
Left: M&> & & * /*> M*=
& * S&* R;* '* &* * &> *&*, &>
&'* & ** & '*
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
6/48
IN"ISIblE "ICImS
MIg#A%$ ! %he M!'e I MeIc!
A:? I:(:( A 2010 I: AM# 41/014/2010
4
BA23*89>I39*73&9.43&1
mEhOdOlOg%
A>J I@ #@ 2008
2009 @ @ >,
@ > @K@, @
@M , J, >,
>> @ C@, >> @ @
H> ' C@>>@
@. D #@ CJ
@ C, %, @ +K ,
@ @ @ #@ ,
>@J @ > J @.
A>J I@ @ @ J @ 110
> @ 2009.
> @ @ @ J J
G% > @
@>> > @
#@, J >@ @.
> @ @ @> @ @
@ @@.
Main routes taken by the thousands
of migrants, mainly from Central America,who travel through Mexico every year on
their way to the USA
M& * &* '>
& M*=
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
7/48
1/INrOd!CION
D%; +: ( :(: ?; +( *( + (
: : ;? h &: +' ;+
)? : (+ (+ :+ : =( -;: : :
);. h : -( (=(? - : :( :(* ;:
= = *:? (. h :+ : :( ?
*: -- :(: *;+ - I =( *(? +;.
h (+ :(: - I ++ =(: (+ =;+ : .
# (@ >), 27-J-@ @ >, @ J J @, A>JI@ , 2009
EJ J, @ @ @ @>, >
@ #@ @ >@
>. #@ J 10
C A>, >@J @> E @, G>,
H@ @ . >@J
@ * @ @ @ @>
@J J . @J @ @
>@ @ @.
#@ @ @ @ @
@ @ @ @ >,
@ @ >@ @ @ #
J @ @ @ *A @ @ @, @@>, @
@ @ #@ @
@.
@@ @ @ @>
> > C A> @
@ @: @J, J, < @
@@J >@ @ < @
@ . J @ >J > @
>
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
8/48
.5 % @> @
. % 12 18 J @ , @>@ , @> 10.6
D > @ @
>, J @
. I J, > @K@,
- >M >
J @ > @ @>, J
@ @ J >
@J. F@ >, BS @
# @, C@ , @ 828
>
#J 2007 FJ 2008.7 I @> 3,924
@ . 1,266
@ >@ (, , @@ @
); 475 J M @ @ @
@-@@ @ H> '
C@>>@ (C@>V @ D@
H>@, CDH). @ @> @ @
@>@ @ .8
H> , J @
J @
@ > , . I J >@ > @ @ > @
@, @ @ @ @J.
D @ J @
J @ J @
@ (@- @) @ >
@ < .
H> @ @
@@ > @>>
@ @>>. @ @@ @
, @ @ J J @
@@ @ @@ @,
>@ @@ @>>> @ @@
@ > @ >@ . @ @
@ > > @
@ .
I @> , JJ >
@ @ @ >. I #
2008, @ > C@ @
IN"ISIblE "ICImS
MIg#A%$ ! %he M!'e I MeIc!
A:? I:(:( A 2010 I: AM# 41/014/2010
6
S=**->*&- J ( *& &*)
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
9/48
@ @ @ > @ @ > @ @ @
>.10 @ @ , @ @ @
> @ >
@ @ > @@. H@, A>J
I@ @ >J @
> @ @ > C@
@ @ @@ J
@ J @ >.
I >M < @ >
@ @ J> >.
> < @
. E @> >> @J
J @@ @ , #@M
> @> @ @
>, @ @@ J >
@ @ J @ J >J @
@ @J @ @ @ > @>
> .
I 2009, CDH @
@> > @ @ @
> J > , .
I: AM# 41/014/2010 A:? I:(:( A 2010
M&
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
10/48
@ @ , @ @
@, >J 9,758 > @ @ 2008
2009, 57 .14 @
#@
> @ @J @ >@
@ @ J
@ @ J >,
C, %, @, +K
>.
#J @ @>> J >
@ @ > @
@@ @ , >J
. I @ @ @
@ > @ @J,
@> J
@@ @ > @M @ @ J.
H@, >, >@
@ @ @@, J
@>M @ @@ >.
# @> >@
@ @K > @, >@ 15,000
@ @
@@ @ #@M J @
>
@ @ >
@ @ #@. H@,
J > J
@, # @> @@
@ @>@, > @ ,
>.
# @> @>@
@ >M . F@ >,
# >
*A, >@ @
@@> @ .15 #@
J > ,
I@ C@@ @
@@ @ ' @ A # @ @ F> (* # @
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
11/48
@ @ @J J >
#@ J @ J @
>. F@ >, >@ @ @
>@ > @, @@ @>
@ >@ > >@
C A> > @
@ @ @@
. I @, @ >K @
@ >@
@@ @ @> @>
@.
A>J I@M ,
, > @
@ @ @J @ >J
@, J @
@ J >. H@, >J
@ @ @ ,
@ @ @> , J @
@ @>J .
"@- @ J G%,
I-A> C@>>@ @ H> '
* > >> @ >
> @, @ @
@ > @
>@ J> >@ @. H@,
@ @ J @
> J J > @ J
, J @ J @>@, @>
J @. , @ ,
>@ @. @ @ @
@ @ @,
@, @, > @
, J > @
>J. I @ @>>@ @
@ @ @>J @
@ @ @ , @@
> @ @ >
#@.
IN"ISIblE "ICImS
MIg#A%$ ! %he M!'e I MeIc!
I: AM# 41/014/2010 A:? I:(:( A 2010
9
A 5*
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
12/48
A:? I:(:( A 2010 I: AM# 41/014/2010
M& /5 + * ** &, *
/*> M*= & *&5 * +&* &* &. & &> ;;*
& *&* * * + * **& &
* *+& &> *=** * & * .
BH&0*L47*3?
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
13/48
2/hE dANgErS
Of hE jO!rNE%
EJ J, @ @ > > @ > .
E@@ @
>J > @ > @ @ @
@ @ @. C
@ @ @
J > @>
>. @> ,
/@ @ J @-
@ >, #@M
@@ @ @ , @
> .
kIdNAppINg, hrEAS ANd ASSA!l
>M @ @ #@ @>
@ @ @> @ >
@ @> @> >@
@. I >J J, @ '>V (@
>) @ >J >.
I @> 2008, 35 @ >
J > > @>
+K . J V @ > > @
@ @> F A@J GM %
(@T G 'W, G')
, @ @ @ > J
@ @> @ @J @ @ .
I, '>V @ IK
# D@ C. F@> , @ @K@ @ > @
>> @
@ @ @
@ . I D> 2008, '>V
@ H@. @ @>@
@ >> @ >
@ @.
@> > @ J I@ J @ >K J
J @J
> @ @ I# @ @
< @ @ > .
% > J < @ @
@, I# > > @ @
. J @ @
>J, J K >@ 100
> >. > @ @
@ > @ C
A> @ *A @ @
J @ >@J @ J @>. @
@ @ > @
@ @ @J @ @ >.
> G% @ J. "< @
@ @ P @ @ @K
@@ @ > @ @ @M
@>J @ @ @ @
P @ @> @ @>
. # @>16
* '@ @ > @
> @ J @K
> > #@.
>T2!3!4/! '2!4/ #/45%3 4/ "% ! "53%33
M%8#/, !2'%9 /%2!4%$ "9 42!3!4/! '!'
%47/2+3 6/6%$ 35''' !$ 42!&+'
%23/3 !$ $25'3, 74 #/!"/2!4/ /& 4% /#!,
5#!, 34!4% !$ &%$%2! !54/24%3. T%3%
2!#4#%3 !2% $2%#49 2%!4%$ 4/ 4% 23% #!3%3 /&
6/%#% !'!34 7/% !$ #$2%, %3%#!9 !/'
4% /24%2 !$ 3/54%2 "/2$%23, !$ !4 42!34
IN"ISIblE "ICImS
MIg#A%$ ! %he M!'e I MeIc!
I: AM# 41/014/2010 A:? I:(:( A 2010
11
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
14/48
/43. A3 35#, 549 &/2 5! 2'43 !"53%3
!'!34 '2!43 3 2!!4. W4 4% %26!36%%33
/& #/2254/ !4 ! %6%3 /& '/6%2%4 !$ 4% #/3%
2%!4/3 4!4 !9 !54/24%3 !6% 74 '!'
%47/2+3, #$%#%3 /& %84/24/, 2!% !$ !33!54 /&
'2!43 #/45%. T% !*/249 /& 4% #!3%3 3%% 4/
"% !'!34 '2!43 &2/ G5!4%!!, E S!6!$/2,
H/$52!3 !$ N#!2!'5!.?
'@ @ * '@ @ > @>, 24 # 200917
H@, 2009 @ J
CDH @ @@ J
# @ @ @ @> @
@M @@ @
> >@ J.18 CDH
238 > @ 198 @ >
2008 FJ 2009. I >
@ 9,758 > @
J @ @ @ @ @
@>
A:? I:(:( A 2010 I: AM# 41/014/2010
M& E S&&, M&5&& M5&>, &'&
&*, &* *& & &* * & * * %*&, &
& &, * 5*; &>, J* 2009.
BA23*89>I39*73&9.43&1(P-494:R
.&74R&2E7*?A77.41&)
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
15/48
@ . A @ @ @ J
- N@JO. CDH ,N @ J 10 > (8,478)
> L
, , , , @ > @ >@
@ J > >
@>.
% 12 %@ 2008, @ 60 > @>
E @, H@ @>
@ J @
@ @ @ ' " G,
. CDH >@J @>
G> >. H @ @ 9 %@
2008, @ > @ @
@ @ J @ J @
> > @. A ,
@ @ >
. @ @@< > @ @ J
@ @ @ @>.
> @ @ @@< > @ @ @
J J >> @ (
@@@ > ). > > @
@ . @ > >
.19 >
@ , @ @@,
J @ @> @ @ , @
@ >, > @ @
@ >
> @ @ > @ @
@ @ . F > @
@ @ I#
. I >
@ , >
> > @ @ .
, >
@ J @ I# @ J.
IN"ISIblE "ICImS
MIg#A%$ ! %he M!'e I MeIc!
I: AM# 41/014/2010 A:? I:(:( A 2010
13
D& R&*? E5& *+ H& 2004. H *& +
*& * !SA *&. * J* * B* P& * P'* >
* M&* ** & &, &
*5*&*.
BA23*89>I39*73&9.43&1(P-494:R.&74R&2E7*?A77.41&)
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
16/48
CDH @> > @M
@ @ @>@ @ J @ @>
. H@, A>J I@
, @ @ J @ J
@ @@ .
I J 2007, 12 > P @ ,
@> > P @J
@ @ @
@>> @ @. % >
@ @> F A@
@ G, @ @ >M
(A NH>@ C>@O).
A @ @ @ @ @
@ > @ > , F
@ @ . H @> @ @
@ @ , @ @> >
@ @ 40 > @ > J
> J > . I
@ @ @ @ >
J J, @
>@J , @ >@ @. A
J @J, > @ @
@ @ F @ 18 @
> >, J
>. F @ @
@ @. > @ ,
>>J @ @ @
J I#.
I D> 2007 CDH
@>>@ (065/2007) @
@> @> @ > @
> J @ @ @
F @ >, @
@. H@, @ A>J I@M
@ J
@.
@ @J >
@ >> @ @ @>>J
@@< @ @ @ > @
@>J @ @ > .
@ J > @ @>@,
IN"ISIblE "ICImS
MIg#A%$ ! %he M!'e I MeIc!
A:? I:(:( A 2010 I: AM# 41/014/2010
14
M5& 5* *& F&* A*/& S&* G*&,
C& I=*5*, O&=&& &*, 10 J&&> 2007. F&*
S&* & '** *&** & &* '> &
& & ++& '*&* +
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
17/48
@>J @ @ @ >,
@ @, @ >J @ > @> . H@,
@ @ @ J @
@ > @ @ >
@ >J @ @ F >
@ @ @ F @ @. A
@, CDH @>>@
@ @ @ >,
@ @ @
@ @ @ @.
I > 2008, #@ (@ >)
@ J@ > @> @ @
C J G@ B
@
>@ > @ @
@ @ M @ >. H
@ @ > ,
>.
A J, @ J
> @ @ J @
@. A J , @ >
. #@ J > J @
>M (C # H@
#@) A, C , J F
HJ> +RKK #. % 13 > 2008,
#@ @> J
@@ @ C> # @
C GE.20 H @ @ @
G@ B @ J >
@ >>. I@ @ @
@ > >
. H@, #@, @ @
> @ > @J
> @, @> >M
, @@ . H @
@ @J @ @ @
@ @ @ ; @ @
@@ .
E > @>
@ J @ @, J
J @ > @ >
@ @, >J . A ,> @ @ @ @ @
>, @ @ @ @
@>> >.
"IOlENCE AgAINS mIgrAN #OmEN
>F2/ A22!'! I $%#$%$ 4/ 4!+% 4% 42!. M!9 %/%
3!$, J J
@> @ @ @> @
@, J J
@.
#J @> > @> @
@ J @ @
@J < @ @
@> @. @>@ J @ >
# @> @ @ @ #
@ @>, @
@ #@. @ A>J I@M @ J @.
# J
I@ J , ,
J @
" A@ >
@ A, @ @@@ >@
@J @. B@ @@
@ @ @ @ J
>M . D @ @
@ > @
@ GE @, .
% 10 2009, A (@ >)
@ @ @ @> G>,
@> @> .
@ @J @> G> @,
@ @ @ @ > J
@ @ +K, @@@ @
> > @
@. A @ J 10
> > @ > @
@ J @@ > @ @ @
> @ @ @ J @> @
. % @ > > @ @
@ @J @ . A
> J J J
@. A @
@ J . J @ >K J
@ J > @ I#
@ @ .
A, J > @>,
I#M >@ >@ >M
@ . D @ @
> @> , J >
@ @ J@@ @ >
@ @ @ @ @ @>
>K J , @J,
@ > @ @>. A@ @
> , @J >
>@ @ @ J >
@ @J, > @ @
>K @> @ @ @.
>A 4% 4% 4%9 37/2% !4 53, 3!%$ 53, 53%$ !$
+#+%$ 53 ! /6%2 !$ 4 53 74 ! 7, 4%9 #/6%2%$
/52 %9%3 !$ /543 4%9 +%$ 9 &2%$ "%#!53%
3% $$=4 !6% !9 [2%!46%3 4/ % %2 !$ 3%
#/5$=4 '6% 4% [/% 5"%23, 3/ 4%9 3/4 %2
47#% 4% %!$ !$ 4%9 %&4 %2 "%%$' &2/4 /&
% &/2 42%% /523 4/ 4$!4% %... T% !#% 4%9
%$ % #!46% 3 ! "', $!2+, $249 /53% 4!4 3%%$
"!$. T% 47/ $!93 I 7!3 4%2% I 3%4 / 4% '2/5$
74 / "!+%4. T%9 /9 '!6% % 3/%4' 4/ %!4
/#% !$ ! 44% 7!4%2. T% % 7/ +$!%$ %
!3/ 342%$ % !+%$ !$ 2!%$ %. I 4!4 !#%,
I %!2$ 4% 7/% 4% 4% /!3, #2%3 !$ '2/!3
/& /4%2 %/%?.
@ @> @ 2009 CDH @ @
(I@ @ #, I#*E'E)
C I @ @> (I@ E
#) >
A @ @ > J@@
@ > @> @
IN"ISIblE "ICImS
MIg#A%$ ! %he M!'e I MeIc!
I: AM# 41/014/2010 A:? I:(:( A 2010
17
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
20/48
@. @ J C
F>J @ (D@@ I F>, DIF) @ @ >@J @
@> >
@> @ > > @
@ > @ @
> @ @. I , @ @
@ @ > @ < @ @ @ J
@ @ @
@ @@>.
mISSINg Or kIllEd
I FJ 2009 @ @ @
@ @ C@>> @ ' @ D
D # (C@>S F>
# F@ J D@, C%FA#IDE)
@ #@. ' >@ 700
>, C%FA#IDE @ @ 293
@ #@
@ @ J #
@ @ @>@
@.24
H @ > @ > @ @ @> @
@> @ @ > . @
@ > @ P @ @
@> P J
> @ @
@>. I @, # @
J >@ @
> @ * @. F@ >, J
2010, # > @
750 # >
@ @ *A 2009.25
@J @, @ GE @
@ @ @MJ @ . I J
@ @ @J, @ @
@> @J @>.
H@, >J @ @ J
@>@ @ > J @.
@>>, @>@ @
J @ @ @ GE @ @,
@ @ @ @ @>@
J @ @@@ . I
@M J @ @> @
@ , @J >J , C
, @ @ @ > @
> @ @ @,
GE > @ >J J. H@,
@ @ > @ @ >J
@ #@, @ ,
> @J, @ @
J @ .
I >@ , C A> @
@ @ J
@J @ @
@ @- @ @ @ .
@ J J >
@ >
@>> >@ @ @> @ >.
@ @ @ ,
JK @ > >
@ @>, @>@
@ @ > @ > @
@> @ @ @> A>J
I@ J @-@ -
# @ @ J @
>, @ > @
IN"ISIblE "ICImS
MIg#A%$ ! %he M!'e I MeIc!
A:? I:(:( A 2010 I: AM# 41/014/2010
18
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
21/48
@ > @ @ @ @.
H@, J @K @ @
@ @ @ @ >,
@ @ @ >
>.
# @> @ @ J
@ >. A , @
@- @ > >
@ @ @ @>J > @ G@ B.
@ @-@ > >@
@ @ @
@>@ @ @ @ @
@. I 2009, C @>
@ C%FA#IDEM @ > @
, > @ J @
.
I: AM# 41/014/2010 A:? I:(:( A 2010
R'' &* ;* * 5
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
22/48
A:? I:(:( A 2010 I: AM# 41/014/2010
#& & & &@ ** *& B&&, "*&?
&*. #* & &* 5 &' * +;* &
&;* M*= * * !SA.
BA23*89>I39*73&9.43&1(P-494:R.&
74R&2E7*?A77.41&)
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
23/48
3/Ab!SES d!rINg
mIgrAION ChECkS
D *:(: >:: )? : m>*( (;::
- (:. I: =(: (=(? :, );: *:? (
: =.
'S F@, >M , @
> @ @ J
@ > @@
> @ 10 J,
. #@J J @ @K
@@ @ @ >@ @ J
I# @ >J @ @ @ J
> @ @ .
> @ @
>@ @@> @ @@
J @ @J . F@
>, 2009, I# @
@ @ . > @
> @ > @.
> J > > @
@ @ >M
@ >@ @ @.
I FJ 2010, I# @> A>J
I@ @ I# @ >
@ > @@ @ @
@ @ > @ ,
@ @> I#
2007 2009 @ @ @@
@> J CDH.26
@ J I@ #
@ @ @ J >, >J @
@@. % 31 # 2008, I@
#, # @@-@, @
A, C , C
I, % , @ @> @J @
>. E @, @ @>>J
@ " > >J,
J I# @ J 50 >>
@ # J > @.
A@ @ @@ @ J,
> @ , J @
> > @, @ > @
@. J @ @ @@
, @
> @ >. A > >@ @
> @ I# >@
@ % > J
N@> @@, @ @ >
@ @ I#/J @@O.27
> @ @> @>
@ @ @ @ @ @
@ ->. > @
@J @ @.
A @ J @ , @
@ @ >M , I# @
@ CDH J
" > @ >@J J
. D @@ J
@ @>>J @
@ J @> @ @ ,
J @> >
J @ @J .
A@ @ CDH @>>@ (029/2009)
@ 6 #J 2009, J @K
@ @
@ @ . CDH @
@ @ J @ J >@
@ J @ >@ > @@ @
J @ J @ J I# @
@ @ , @ @
> >@ @ >, @
@ > > @ . I
@>> J J @ @ @
@J @ . H@,
IN"ISIblE "ICImS
MIg#A%$ ! %he M!'e I MeIc!
I: AM# 41/014/2010 A:? I:(:( A 2010
21
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
24/48
@J >@ J >
@ J @, @ @ J. @ @ @ @ .
@, @J G', @ @
> @ @ .
I# @ @ @@ @ J
@ >, >
>@ >@ @.
F @ @ J >@ @ J
@ @@ @ I#, @ J
@ > @
@ @ >@ @
@J.28 H@, @ @
@ @ @ @. F@
>, @ J @ @ >
@K@ @>@
@@ @ @ @@.
A@ I# F @ @
< >@ @ @ @ @@ @
@ @@ @ @K@,
@@ > @.29
A@K @ > @ I# @ F
@ J @ @ @
@ > > J @
@.30 I# @ @> @
@ @ J . A@ @
J , > @@ J
@>@.31 C @> J A>J
I@ @ @K@ @
> @ @ @J @.
I > @ >@
@@ @@, J > @
>>J @ @> @.32 %
@, J @ J
> @J J @ >
@ @ @> P J @ @
@J @ @ @@ P
> @ >
@ @ I#.
I 2006, CDH @>>@
@ G', #J @ D,
> @ @, > > @
@@ N@ @> J @
@ @ >@ @> @ @
#@ @J @ > @
IN"ISIblE "ICImS
MIg#A%$ ! %he M!'e I MeIc!
A:? I:(:( A 2010 I: AM# 41/014/2010
22
de%e%I!%= >?=+= =, ? > > +>< =>+>?= = +
F=?+ >+. %=
=?=?>C + +
F?=G (alojados). h@ ?= =?
> +>< > +> >+> ?< >+
+ >+>= =?
C = +> >
>> = M C
= >=. I>+ +
== @ +>@= > >>
=+> > +?>=
>> C > = ?=>, ==++>= + @
+>@= > >> + ?++
= > >+. % & c@> >
#>= > c =>+>= >+> + += + +=?
==> == . d=> +=?
>> ?++ +=>
C I>+ +>= @=>
>> > >
=> >?=.
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
25/48
O.33 I @ @>> I#
@ @ > @ .34
>T3 49% /& %'! '2!4/ #%#+ "9 5!54/2%$
!'%43 7/ !6% /4 2%#%6%$ 4% !2/2!4% 42!',
#2%!4%3 ! #!4% 7# '2!43 !2% 35"*%#4%$ 4/
/4%2 49%3 /& !"53%3, 35# !3 3%85! !33!54,
2#!9 !'!34 7/% !$ #$2%, 93#!
*529, 2/""%29 !$ %84/24/, !/'34 /4%23.?
CDH, G '@>>@ 13, 17 @> 2006
D @@ @ J
> @ @ @>
C, I# @ @ @
@ J >, @
@@ @ @ @
@ @ @@.35 I, A>J
I@M @
@@ J I# F @ @
2006, @ @ @@
@ @>> @
>. A >@J @ > >@
>>J , J @> @ ,
.
E$CESSI"E fOrCE
% 9 J 2009, @ @ J
@ < J @ 45 > @>
E @, G>, H@, E@
C.36 > @. % > @
N@ O. >
> > @ @ @
@ . H@, @ >
@ @ I# @ J
@ @> C A> ,
J > @> J
> @. C GE @
@ @ @ @ J >
> @ . @ @
> @.
@ > @ .
% 18 > 2009 > @
C@>R, C , @@< > J
>J @ @.
@ > @ @, J
@ @ , @ @. >
@ @ >.
A@ @ , @ J
>, J >
@ @ @ @@
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
26/48
@ @ > J I#
@ @ @ @ @
>M @ J
K @ @@. H
@ @ >J J J
@J @ @
@ @ @ @ @ J.38
@> @ > @
>, I# @ @ @ @>
@ @ > @ >
@ @ @ >.
CDH @ @@ J @ ;
J @ . I#
@J @.
E$OrION
* 2008, J @ #@ @
J @ 10 J @. I J
@K J @ J @
>@ @ @> @ @
IN"ISIblE "ICImS
MIg#A%$ ! %he M!'e I MeIc!
A:? I:(:( A 2010 I: AM# 41/014/2010
24
A *'* + * M*=& N&;>
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
27/48
> > >@>
@ @ @ >@J @>> @ .39
I2008, J @ J @
@ @ >@ @ .
, @@ @ >> @
>J @ @ @ J @
>@
J @ @ @ @ >
@@ > ->,
@, @ @.
% 8 J 2007, H@ (@ >),
> @> H@, @ J @ @
C H@, C , @
'. @ @@< > , @ 500
@ (@>J *$39) @ > @ .
% @ @ @ @ H@M
> @ @ >@ >@J. H@
@ @ @ @ >M
> @ @ @ @
>. H@ @>
CDH. >J @ @ CDH
@ @ CDH @
@ < @ .
% 24 J 2007, @J # (@
>) C H@, C
, @> W *> G>, J
@ J @. @ @ >
@ @ >@J.
J @ @ J @ CDH.
CDH @>@ @>
>JM @ , @
@ @ @
@@. CDH @
@.
% 28 2009, #J, @- #
@ >M B,
+K , J@ > >
J J > @>. #J
@ A>J I@ >
@ @ .
@ , @>
@ @ >. H
> @ 200 @
(@>J *$20) @ @ >M @J
I@ @ @ J J @
.40
% 23 J 2010, F @
@ J >@ 100
>. @> A, C
, @ C I, % . A@ @
>, @> > @ @
> @ @ @,
@ @. A @ @
>M @@, @ > @
@ > J @ @ @J
@ @@ @ J
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
28/48
A:? I:(:( A 2010 I: AM# 41/014/2010
A* + * G5 B*& C&5& &* *& +
& ** + &&*. * G5 B*&
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
29/48
4/rEpArIAION,
rEmEd%, rEdrESS
ANd prOECION
DI- ( (: : : ( ( *(:, (? :
:? = -; : : :. I- = + (( : :
: : : : *(:, : +:
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
30/48
rIgh O INfOrmAION ANd
lEgAl Ad"ICEA@ @ I# @ @
%@ 2009, >@ @ > @
@>@, @
@@, @> @ > @ @@
@J @.41 # @ @
@> @ @ J @ J>
> >@. H@, @ @ @
@ @ @ @ > >J
@ , J @ @
@> @>.
% @, >M @
@ @ J @@ J I# @.
# @J @>
J @ @K >
@K@. +J >
@ J @ >
@K@. I @, >
@K@ J @J @ @
@ @
> >J .
C A> @ @ J
@ , J
@ @ @ @
>.
#@ @ @ @ @>@ @ @
M . J @ @ @
@>@, >
, @ @ , >@
@, @ , , J>
@ @>. I# @>
A>J I@ @ @J @
@>@. H@, @ @ >
J A>J I@ @
@ @ J
I# @ @> J
@>@ @ , @ @
@J @.
I#, @@ I@
%K@ @ #@ *ICEF ( *
CM F), @ @
C @@ % @
@ >
@ . @ @
@ @ > .
H@, @ J A>J
I@ I# @ @
@ > @>@ @
. A >>
@ > @ @ @
@J @ @ .
I# @ @ @ @ @>@
@ > @, @
@@ @ @ @>@ @
J @ @ > @ @ P
> >J @ @ > @> P
@J > @ @ J @
@. I# @ @
>M @ > @>@.
@ @@>
> @ > @ @
-@. @ J
> >J @ > > @ @
@> @ @@ @
> @ .
fIlINg A COmplAIN
>T% C/44%% 2%#/%$3 4!4 4% S4!4% !249
3/5$ %352% 4!4: (!) I %'3!4/ !$ 2!#4#%,
'2!4 7/2+%23 !$ %"%23 /& 4%2 &!%3,
#5$' 4/3% ! 22%'5!2 345!4/, !6% 4% 3!%
2'43 !3 !4/!3 /& 4% S4!4% !249 4/ &% #/!43
!$ !6% !##%33 4/ 2%$2%33 %#!33 "%&/2% 4%
#/5243; (") A9 %23/ 7/3% 2'43 /2 &2%%$/3, !3
2%#/'%$ 43 C/6%4/, !6% "%% 6/!4%$ !9
/"4! %&&%#46% 2%$2%33
T% C/44%% 2%#/%$3 4!4 4% S4!4% !249
3/5$ #/45% !$ 34% 5 43 %&&/243 4/ !$$2%33 !3 !
!44%2 /& 52'%#9 4% 2/"% /& -42%!4%4 !$
/4%2 !#43 /& 6/%#% !'!34 '2!4 7/2+%23 !$ 4%2
&!%3, 2%'!2$%33 /& 7/ 3 2%3/3"%. I !24#5!2,
4% C/44%% 52'%3 4% S4!4% !249 4/ %352% 4!4
35# !#43 !2% 6%34'!4%$ !$ 4% #5243 "2/5'4 4/
42! !$ 53%$.?
C@ @@ @ * C@>> @ @@ @ ' @ A # @ @ F>,
#@, 20 D> 2006
IN"ISIblE "ICImS
MIg#A%$ ! %he M!'e I MeIc!
A:? I:(:( A 2010 I: AM# 41/014/2010
28
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
31/48
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
32/48
. J @J @
@ . %J @ @ F @@> %
.
IN"ESIgAION
>A M%8#! %!3!4 &!2%2 7/ 3%%+3 2%%$9 &2/
4% *534#% 3934% 3 /&4% /4 34%%$ 4/ !$ 42%!4%$
6%29 //29, "54 &/2 ! '2!4 4 3 &!2 7/23%.?
F @T, FJ #T CV@ H> ' C, C, 2009
E > @> GE,
@ >J @ @ J
@ @@ @ .
D @@ @ @
J P @ > >K @
> @ > @
>@J P @ @>@ @
@@ @ @ @ @
>.
I J, @ > >@ J @ >
@ @> @ @ > @>
GE @ G'. A>@ @ >
J A>J I@ @ J
@J
J @ @> J
@@ @ @ @ @ @
@ J JJ. @ J @
@ @ @ >
@> @ @J @
, @ > @ >
> @> @ @
>J @@.
F@ >, @ 31 J 2008, @ G>
> @ J @ J >>
@ F I@ AJ (A F
IV, AFI) J @> @
C I, % , J >
@> G' @
>@J . @ >@
@> >, J
@ . >
> @ @@@ @ @@ @ @>@
@ @>, @ @
@ @@ @ @. >
@ J @ AFI .
G' @ < @ > >@ , J
> J @ > @
. G' @ .
I @ > @,
> >J @ @> @
@ @ @ . H@,
A>J I@ @ @ J
> @ @ @
@ @@. A @
J A>J I@
@ >>.
I 2009, @ J J>
>@ @ -
> -@@
> @>>@ @
CDH @ @ . H@, @ >
@ @
@ @ @ @ @ >@ -@ J @ > @
@ @@ @ @ @> J
J @ @
@>> .
I 2006, # @> @> *
# @> @ J
I@ C @ >
@> > J
@K > @, > @ G', @
@ > J @
> @> @
J @ @ @ >
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
33/48
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
34/48
A:? I:(:( A 2010 I: AM# 41/014/2010
A & & & &@ **, *& B&&, "*&? &*.
C*& A*& & ;* * & & > &; * &*
+ & ++&, *> &* & + && '>
& & & 5 ++&.
BA23*89>I39*73&9.43&1(P-494:R.&74R&2E7*?A77.41&)
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
35/48
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
36/48
#@ @ @ @ @ @> > @ >
@ @ @> @@. F@
>, @ @ #
@J
@ @.O #@ @ @
@ A 22 @ # @ N@O @ @ @
@ .55 A>J I@
@ @ #@M
J @@ @ @> @ @
@> J @@.56
A 2003 @J @@ J I-A> C@ @
H> ', @ #
@>, @
@@ @ >
@ >.57 @ , J >
@, @ > @ @
> , > >
@ @ > .58
C@ > @@
@ ( 8) @
>,
@ @ .59
@ >
#@ @ @
@ > @@ @ >@ J
@ > @ @ @J. I
2008, * '@ @ @
> @ @@ @ #@. H
@>> , N@ @>
>J @ > @@, >@
.O H @
@ @ > @ @
@ @@ @ @
@ > @@ >
@ @ @ @
.60
I 2009, # @> @ >>
@>>@ J * H> ' C@N@ @ @
@ > @> @ >,
J J @ /
@ >J @ @>
@J @ @@ @ /;
@ @ @
@ -> @ >.O61
lEgAl frAmE#Ork IN mE$ICO
I 2007, @ > C@ @>
@ @@ , > @ J,
@ >
>>J @ # C@@, @
@ ( @
@@) @> .62 @@
@ @> C@@ @ @
> @ @@
@ @ > @
@> #@. D @ @>>>
@ @> >@ @ @
@ #@M @ @@,
@ >K.
, #@M C@@
>@ @ @
@. @ J, >@>
@> @J, @
@@ (A 11). C@@ @
@ @ @
@ C@@
(A 33).63 @ @-
>@; @ @ J ,
@ @ @>>@; @
@ >J. I 2003, @
C@ @ @ @ D>@ (C@@
@ V D>V,
C%A'ED) @ @>@
@ >@ @ >@,
@ @ @ @. I @,
J 10.1 @ 2007 @ D@> ,
> @ @J, J @>>
IN"ISIblE "ICImS
MIg#A%$ ! %he M!'e I MeIc!
A:? I:(:( A 2010 I: AM# 41/014/2010
34
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
37/48
@> @, N @ @
> #@.O64 J 1.7 @ @
H> ' @>> @ @>> @>
@ @ N@>@ > J @
@ >M @>J
@ @>>>.65
#@ > @@ @ @
@ @ > >@.
I D> 2009, #@ @J >
C> @ G@ F@> @ #@
D@> (GF#D) 2010. @ > @
GF#D @ 2010.
I: AM# 41/014/2010 A:? I:(:( A 2010
C*& A*& & * +* &, 5* ** & *
+ * , A& 5&>, "*&?
&*,
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
38/48
D# =(: : *( :
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
39/48
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
40/48
J @ @ @@ @
@ @> .I, @>M @ D@>
@>>> @ @ >M
#@. H@, @
J @ @-@ @
> @ , @
@ >@ @ @,
@ , @ .
#J @ @
@> @ @ @> >J
>. F @@ @, @ @
> @ @ @>> @ >J
@ @ > @>>
>. F @ @ @ @ J >
>@ @ @> @ J @ .
I@ J @@ >
@ >J >
. I-A> C@ @ H> '
J > >
@ @, @
>,
@ @ .
> #@ >
@> > @ @ , @ >@
@ @ @ @ @
@, @ > @ >J
.
"< @ @ @ @
@@>. @ @
, > @
@@ @ >
@ @ @ @ >M
> .
rECOmmENdAIONS
A>J I@ @ #@M
@ @ @-@ @>
>>@ @ @ , @@
@>, @ , @
@ > #@. I ,
@ > @ @, >
>J @ @>> > J
@- @.
$%#eg%heIg #e$"ec% f!# %he #Igh%$ !fMIg#A%$
A>J I@ @ #J @
I@, @ #@ ,
@>, @ H> ' C@>>@
@ C@ @ @ @
D>@ @:
1. @>@ @@ @ @ >
>@ , > @,
> .
C@> J @> >@
>.
2. D> #@ C A>,
@ C A> @
@J, @>@ @ > @ @
> @ J ,
>, > @ @>
.
fILIg c!M"LAI%$ Ad I'e$%IgA%I!
A>J I@ @ ,
@ #@ , F @,
F A@J GM %, A@J
GM % @ @:
3. E @
@@ @ @ >.
'@> A 67 @ G @@ " ("J
G @V, "G) A 201 @
@J ('>@ "J G
@V, '"G) @ >,
@ @ @, @ @ /@
IN"ISIblE "ICImS
MIg#A%$ ! %he M!'e I MeIc!
A:? I:(:( A 2010 I: AM# 41/014/2010
38
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
41/48
@> @ @ ,
@ @ >> @@ @ @.
4. E @ @ , @
@ @ @-
@, @>J, >J J
, @ @ @ @ @
> @.
5. D@ >> @ >
@ @ @ @ @>@ @
@ @ J
@ @ > < @ .
6. F @ @ >
@@ @>> @
> @ @ @
@ J >J
@ @ J @ >
@ , , @
> J.
$e&AL 'I!Lece Ad %he #Igh%$ !f !MeAd chILd#e
A>J I@ @ @ #@
, #J @ J, F
A@J GM %, A@J GM
%, F @@M % @
+@ C> @> C, @ I @
@>, F>J @ (D@@ I
F>, DIF), H #J
@> @:
8. E > @ >J @ @
@ @ @ >
J@@ . E@ @ > @
@ >> @ @ @ @
@ , @, @ @
> @ @ @ ->K
@ @ @ .
9. ' > @ > @
@ > @ @ .
A$$I$%Ace Ad !'e#$Igh%
A>J I@ @ #J @
I@, @ #@ , @
H> ' C@>>@ G@ B @:
10. E >, @ >@@ @
G@ B, J @ @,
@ @ ,
@ @ >.
11. E @ H> ' C@>>@
@ @>, > @@ @
@ @ @ @ @
>, @ @,
@ > . C@>>@
@ J @ @
> J
@>>@.
gA%he# Ad "&BLI$h #eLIABLe dA%A
A>J I@ @ #J @
I@, @ #@ ,
@>, @ H> ' C@>>@,
F A@J GM %
@@ % @
I (I@ @ ET J G@T,
IEGI) @:
12. G, @ K
@ @ @
> P , @
@ ->, @ , H@ ,
IN"ISIblE "ICImS
MIg#A%$ ! %he M!'e I MeIc!
I: AM# 41/014/2010 A:? I:(:( A 2010
39
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
42/48
> @ @J @
@ @ @ > @ >> @ @ >@ @ @ @J
@, @ @
J .
17. '@> A 33 @ C@@ @
@ @@ J @ @ @, @
@ .
18. '>@ @
@ @ I@ C@@ @
@@ @ ' @ A # @ @ F>.
MIg#A%$E #Igh%$ defede#$
A>J I@ @ #J @
I@, @ #@ ,
@>, #J @ J,
@ H> ' C@>>@, F
A@J GM % @:
19. '@K @ @< @ >M
. @ @
@ @ > >
@ @
@ @ @ C@
> @
@ > @ > @ @
@ @ @ >.
#ec!MMedA%I!$ %! %he g!'e#Me%$ !feL $AL'Ad!#, g&A%eMALA, h!dA$ AdIcA#Ag&A
21. @ @-@@ @
>@ @@ @ @
>, @ @ @
>, @
@ > @ .
22. C@-@ > #@ @>
@ @> > @>>
> @ #@;
23. D> J, @-@@
@J, @>@ >@ @>>
@ @, J
@>. @>@ @ J
IN"ISIblE "ICImS
MIg#A%$ ! %he M!'e I MeIc!
A:? I:(:( A 2010 I: AM# 41/014/2010
40
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
43/48
>M , @ @
J > #@, @ @> @ #@, @ @
@> @ .
24. @ @ @
#@, J >@ >
, @ J @ >
@ @ .
25. I @@ # @,
@ >> @ > @
@J @ @ @ @>
# @ @ @ @>@ @ @
@>> > @J
#@, @ @
@ @ @- @.
26. I @@ @J #
@, @ > >
@ @ @ > @ >. @
@ @ @ @ > >.
IN"ISIblE "ICImS
MIg#A%$ ! %he M!'e I MeIc!
I: AM# 41/014/2010 A:? I:(:( A 2010
41
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
44/48
ENdNOES
1 "J @T F, A 7, +III.
2 '>@ I@ EG%B, A 55.
3 '"G, A 195.
4 #. B@> '. "J (1999), M'2!# 9 SIDA %
C%42/!2#!, M8#/ 9 EEUU, #>@, C,
#S@; @ #@ H> (1998), P!2! /3
5% / %'!2/. U 35%/ %#/ #%!3, ,
G>; M5*%2%3 5% C25! F2/4%2!3(2006),
*IFE#.
5 > @ @@> @
@ @ J> @ @ @
K.
6 I@ @ #V, C@ E@
#@@, B/%4 %35! $% %34!$34#!3 '2!4/2!3,
2009;
://.>.@.>//2009/B@E09.,
5 # 2010.
7 C5!24/ I&/2% S/"2% ! S45!#/ $% /3 D%2%#/3
H5!/3 $% /3 M'2!4%3 % T2!34/ /2 M8#/, BS,
@ #, H> F@
F@ @ , @, C@, 23 #J 2008.
8 @ I (I@ @
ET J G@T, IEGI) @J @
>@- .
9 @ F A@ @ A>J
I@M @, S4!$' 5 &/2 *534#% !$ $'49 @
H5! 2'43 $%&%$%23 M%8#/(A#' 41/032/2009).
10 S%!!2/ J5$#! $% ! F%$%2!# 9 35 G!#%4!, +III,
J 2008, .389,: 1./. 33/2008.
11 , @ >, A 2 @ I@ C@
@ C @ '.
12 141 @ A@J %@ @ I-
A> C@ @ H> 'M : NA
@ > J @
J > @ (@ >,
@ @ @ @ @
@ ) @ @@J @ , @ @ ,
@ < @ @ @@
@ @ @ @ J C@@.O
> @ V%35% R/$2'5%, 29 J
1988. C @.4, .172. @ >
@ G/$% C25, 20 J 1989, C @. 5,
181, 182 187.
13 , @ >, G C@>> 31 @ *
H> ' C@>>, @>>
>@@ M >>@ @ I@
C@ @ C @ '. @, *
C@>> @ E>@ @ D>@
@>, G C@>> 19.
14 I&/2% E3%#! $% ! C/3 N!#/! D% L/3
D%2%#/3 H5!/3 3/"2% /3 C!3/3 $% S%#5%342/ % #/42!
$% M'2!4%3, 2009; ,://..@.>/IF%'#E/E/E#
., 1 # 2010.
15 I 2009, A>J I@ @
@ @@ @ @
>, # C
A>, *A @@ @
@, J!%$ 74/54 *534#%: I'2!4/ $%4%4/
4% USA;
://.>J.@/>>@-@/
.@?=1641031.
16 * C@>> @ @@ @ ' @ A
# @ @ F> @J
@ >@@ >>@ @ I@ C@@ @ @@ @ ' @
A # @ @ F> J
.
17 A/H'C/11/7/A.2, . 65.
18 I&/2% E3%#! $% ! C/3 N!#/! D% L/3
D%2%#/3 H5!/3 3/"2% /3 C!3/3 $% S%#5%342/ % #/42!
$% M'2!4%3.
19 CDH @>>@ 50/2009, A 2009;
://..@.>/@>/2009/050.>,
1 # 2010.
20 C @J @
.
21 " #@, L!3 F2/4%2!3 $% ! V5%2!"$!$: G%%2/,
M'2!# 9 D%2%#/3 S%85!%3 9 R%2/$5#46/3, 2002.
@ 1999 @, #. B@> '. "J,
M'2!# 9 SIDA % C%42/!2#!, M8#/ 9 EEUU,
#>@, C, #S@. I *
D@> F @ @> (*IFE#), * H
C@>>@ @ ' (*HC') CDH.
22 G ! G DTK, >@
>M'2!# 9 G%%2/, S! S!6!$/2, E S!6!$/2, 19-20 J
2007.
23 I&/2% E3%#! $% ! C/3 N!#/! D% L/3
D%2%#/3 H5!/3 3/"2% /3 C!3/3 $% S%#5%342/ % #/42!$% M'2!4%3, A@.
24 NE @ U@, 293 @U@ >@ @
@ #S@O, L! J/2!$!; ,
://.@.>.>/2009/02/13/.?@
=@&=0291, 1 # 2010.
25 L! J/2!$!, 3 J 2010,
://.@.>.>/>/2010/01/03/>-
>--750->@---K----2009,
5 # 2010.
26 " @> I#, 2 # 2010, % @.
C'11/D'1/ 2010.
IN"ISIblE "ICImS
MIg#A%$ ! %he M!'e I MeIc!
A:? I:(:( A 2010 I: AM# 41/014/2010
42
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
45/48
27 I# J @ * A@ 109/2007 (I: A#'
41/014/2007), %@ @ I#/300/08, 15 #J 2008.
28 "G A 151 '"G A 195.
29 N'V >@ @ @ @@
@ @ @O, "G A 151, + 156.
30 '"G A 196.
31 "G A 73 98.
32 "G A 198.
33 CDH, G '@>>@ 13, 17 @>
2006.
34 I # 2010, I# @> A>J I@
2009 @
(%@ I@ C@@) @ @ @ @
12 @@ @ @ >. @ @>@ @ @@> @
@>. " @> I#, 2 # 2010, %
@. C'11/D'1/ 2010.
35 I# @ @> A>J I@
@ @ J,
>, @ @ @@ @ @@
@ J @ < > @@ @ J
J @ >, J @> . "
@> I#, 2 # 2010, % @. C'11/D'1/ 2010.
36 *A 11/09 (I: A#' 41/002/2009), 15 J 2009.
37 , @ >, * B @ * @F@ F> J " E@> %.
38 ' @ @ C@ EJ D
(CED) F @ @< @ F >
@ J >
J A>J I@ @ @ @-
*A C. A>J
I@M @>>@ @
@ @ @K @J J J,
@J @@ @ @
>> @ @ @
J. @ @ CED @ @
@ @ @ @ @ @>J @ J @ @ >>
@ @ J @ @ @ @.
39 C#/C/#E/C%/1, 8 D> 2006, 32 33.
40 I #, @ @ @ @, @> 90
>> @ > @ @ B,
@@ . A > @ , @
@ @ J @ @ @
> .
41 NAC*E'D% @ > @>
@>@ @ >@ I@
@ #VO, D!2/ O! $% ! F%$%2!#,
7/10/2009, A 15.
42 @ >J @ >
@ A 8 @
* D@ @ H> '; A 2 @ I@ C@ @ C @ '; A
14 @ C@@ @ % C,
I> @ D > @ >; A 8
@ I@ C@@ @ @@ @ A
@ @> E@ D; A 25 @
A> C@@ @ H> '. A 11 @
* B G @ ' @
'>J '@ @ +> @ G@ +@@ @
I@ H> ' " @ +@@ @
I@ H> " : N'> @
@ @@ @ @ >
@ @@ @ @ >
>M @ @@ @ @
@ : () E @ ;
() A, @> @ @ >
; () A @ @>@ @
@@ @ >>.O
43 S4!$' 5 &/2 *534#% !$ $'49 @ H5! 2'43
$%&%$%23 M%8#/(A#' 41/032/2009; M%8#/: N%7
2%/243 /& 5! 2'43 6/!4/3 "9 4% 4!29(I:
A#' 41/058/2009); W/%=3 3425''% &/2 *534#% !$
3!&%49: V/%#% 4% &!9 M%8#/(I: A#'
41/021/2008); M%8#/: L!73 74/54 *534#%: H5! 2'43
6/!4/3 !$ 549 4% 5"# 3%#5249 !$ #2!
*534#% 3934%(I: A#' 41/002/2007); M%8#/:
I$'%/53 7/% !$ 4!29 *534#%(I: A#'
41/033/2004); M%8#/: U&!2 42!3: 53!&% #/6#4/3
(I: A#' 41/007/2003); M%8#/: I4/%2!"% +'3 @
10 9%!23 /& !"$5#4/3 !$ 52$%2 /& 7/% C5$!$
J52% !$ C5!5! (I: A#' 41/026/2003).
44 "G A 67 '"G A 201.
45 C#/C/#E/1, 18 @> 2005, >@ @
C@>> @ ' @ #, 2006.
46 C'# 189/2007 @ J I# @ 20 # 2007.
47 @ @ @ @> F
@@M % @ @ > @>
(FT E V @ @@
@ >, FE+I#).
48 I 2009, @-@@ > @>
>M , @ @< @ '@
@ A >M .
://..@.>/@/>@/.>,
1 # 2010.
49 H> ' C@>>, G C@>>:
E@J> @ I@ C@ @
C @ ' > @ ,
> @> 31),
> @
C@ @ J@ 74 4% /7%2 /2 %&&%#46% #/42/
@ J, %6% &@ @J @
IN"ISIblE "ICImS
MIg#A%$ ! %he M!'e I MeIc!
I: AM# 41/014/2010 A:? I:(:( A 2010
43
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
46/48
J (G C@>> 31).
@ @ @ C@ >
@ >@ K (G C@>> 15). @ J
J @ @ @ @ @ J @
@ @ >>@ @@ (G C@>> 8).
50 > @ @ >
> @ @ @K >
@ >. I
@ @ >,
, @J @@ @ @@ @ >
. * @ > , > >
> : * C@@
@ %K C> (2000), @@@
> @ # J ", A (2000),
@@@ @ , C
(2000).
@ @@@, @ @@@, @
@ @@ @
@@@ @ @ , @@
@ @ >, >
. J @ @@
@ @@@ J
@ >@J @ @ / 4% '2/5$3 4!4J
> > @ > @ @ > 30, CE'D, 01/10/2004, 18.
52 C'C/GC/2005/6 23, 24
53 CEDA, G '@>>@ 24, @>
, . 6.
54 CEDA G '@>>@ 26, # @>,
. 25().
55 NE E@ *V R
@ @@ @, >> J
@ @, @@ @ J
> K @.O A 33 @
# C@@.
56 A 27 @ * + C@@ @ " @
, J #@ @ 25 > 1974,
@> @ @
@-> @ J.
57 A@J %@ %C-18/03, N C@@
' @ *@> #O, I-A>
C@ @ H> ', 17 2003.
58 A@J %@ %C-18/03, N C@@
' @ *@> #O, I-A>
C@ @ H> ', %@, 1 2.
59 N> @, @ @
> @ , , @ J
@ @ , > @ > @>, @ @ @ @
@ > @ > @@ @ @
>@ @ J [email protected]
A@J %@ %C-18/03, N C@@ '
@ *@> #O, I-A> C@ @
H> ', %@, . 144.
60 A/H'C/11/7/A.2, 24 # 2009, .92.
61 A/H'C/11/27, * @ ' '@ @
@> 2008-2012,
://.@>@.@.>/@/@/'%
G'A#AACI%A"DEDE'ECH%H*#A%2008-
2012.
66 C%A'ED @>@ >V @@
@ >, B@T 073/2009, #S@ D.F.,
13 @ 2009; :
://.@.@.>/@.,
17 # 2010.
IN"ISIblE "ICImS
MIg#A%$ ! %he M!'e I MeIc!
A:? I:(:( A 2010 I: AM# 41/014/2010
44
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
47/48
-
8/11/2019 A Mr 410142010 Eng
48/48
in"isible "icimsmigrans on he mo"e in me$ico
e;*7> >*&7, 9*3 + 9&3 + ** 97&;* 97 m*= 3* + 9* 9 &3*7 3 9* 9** &3 &7*
&3 *++*9;*> *3* 9*
79*93 + 9* & 3;'*, 9*7
;* 7&7*> *&7.
m7&39 3 m*= &7* +&3 & &7 &3 79 7 +** '>
+7 9* 7*3'* +7 &'*. * +**7& &3
9&9* &979* &;* 39*39> +&* 9 3;*9&9* &'* &&397&39 79> &3 *++*9;*>, *9* 9*7 39*73&93&
'&93 9 . a3*9> i39*73&93& 7*79 *3 +7 9* 9 &'* &&39 9*.
A*67< I7*5&73&I7*5&73& S*5*7&5&7P*7*5 B**63 H386*
1 E&673 S75**7L33 "C1# 0D"7* K3
.&*67