11
Making it stickLecture 6.1
University of Alberta
ALES 204
Nancy Bray
1
2
Housekeeping
1.Assignment #1 grades will be released on Wednesday
2.Labs this week are in Arts 1-18
3.Mid-term. 30 multiple choice. Approx. 1 question per each lecture, 1 question per each chapter/assigned reading
3
Active and passive voice
ActiveActive PassivePassive
The owners did not vaccinate the cats
The cats were not vaccinated (by zombies)
The dogs ate the bottle caps The bottle caps were eaten (by zombies)
We recommend you eat more spinach
The recommendation (by zombies) was to eat more spinach
We will close the park at 11 pm. The park will be closed at 11pm (by zombies).
4
Lecture Outline
1.Why do some things stick?
2.The curse of knowledge
3.How to make things stick:
a.Simplicityb.Unexpectednessc.Concretenessd.Credibilitye.Emotionsf. Stories
5
1. Why do some things stick?
66
Examples: Urban myths The library at X university
is about to collapse because engineers forgot to take into account weight of books (false)
Don’t flush when sitting on an airline toilet. It could disembowel you. (false)
6
77
Example: The refugee myth One ambiguous fact
appeared in the Toronto Star on March 11, 2004.
“A single person receives $1,890 from the federal government as start-up allowance, along with $580 monthly social assistance, depending on how soon the person is able to find employment."
7
8
Letter to the editor
"I also found it interesting that the federal government provides a single refugee with a monthly allowance of $1,890 and each can also get an additional $580 in social assistance for a total of $2,470. This compares very well to a single pensioner who ... can only receive a monthly maximum of $1,012 in old age pension. Maybe our pensioners should apply as refugees."
99
The beginning Letter was sent to reporter,
editor, and 100 other recipients
Report tried to correct mistake by contacting writer, but e-mail account had been erased
Toronto Star published the article without checking the facts
9
10
The furor
Toronto Star bombarded with e-mails about the letter
They investigated and discovered their error
The Ombudsman wrote apology stating that refugees did not make more than pensioners
11
It was too late...
From 2004-2007, the letter appeared over 50 times in Canadian newspapers
Sometimes twice or three times in the same newspaper
1212
One editor wrote: A friend sent me an e-mail
the other day that floored me. I figured the e-mail had to be a gag, a typical Canadian-style exaggeration aimed at separating one’s leg from one’s body by tickling the funny-bone. But then I read it again – and realized it was simply too ludicrous to be untrue. (Bob Groeneveld, Langley Advance)
13
No one checkedNone of the newspapers checked with government sources to confirm the fact
1414
Government issues fact sheet In 2006, the Canadian
government issues a fact sheet
Has no impact
14
1515
The myth goes international In 2007, the original e-mail
was altered to fit the American context, but kept the Canadian dollar figures
Began to circulate in the U.S.
In 2008, e-mail appeared in Australia
In 2012, e-mail reappeared in the U.K.
16
Why is this idea so sticky?
17
How can you make your ideas stick?
18
2. The Curse of Knowledge
1919
The Curse
19
20
2. How to Make Things Stick
21
SimpleSimple ideas stick
22
Example #1“No plan survives contact with the enemy”
22
23
Commander’s Intent Form
If we do nothing else during tomorrow’s mission, we must ________
The single, most important thing that we must do tomorrow is _______.
24
Clinton’s 1992 election Campaign
Example #2It’s the economy, stupid
25
Example #3 - Refugees“Refugees get more money than pensioners”
2626
Remember
26
2727
Exercise
In one sentence, write down the most important thing that you hope your readers remember from your fact sheet.
If the reader remembers one thing from my fact sheet, it should be _________________.
27
28
UnexpectedSurprise gets our attention
29
Example #1
30
Example #2
3131
Example #3
Identify a gap in knowledge and seek to fill it
Create curiosity by asking a question and then answer the question
Example: Which famous restaurant was found to have slime in the ice machine?
3232
Remember
32
3333
Concreteness
34
Example #1Correct portion size of meat = size of a deck of cards
3535
Example #2
Simulation of prejudice
Jane Elliott’s experiment
(Watch: http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/divided/etc/synopsis.html)
35
36
Example #3 - Refugees“a single pensioner receives a monthly maximum of $1,012 in old age pension”
3737
Remember
3838
Exercise
Look at your fact sheet. Are there statistics which you could make concrete?
38
3939
Credibility
39
40
No one believed them; then they won the Nobel Prize
Example #1Marshall and Warren discover the real causes of ulcers
4141
Remember
41
4242
Emotions
43
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=suRDUFpsHus
Example #1Don Draper (on Mad Men) pitches the carrousel
4444
Example #2
Don’t mess with Texas campaign
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IhahJVkehUc
44
Example #3
I am Canadian ad
4545
46
Example #4 - Refugees“Maybe our pensioners should apply as refugees”
4747
Remember
47
4848
Stories
49
Example #1Jared and Subway
5050
Remember
50
5151
SUCCES(S)
Simple
Unexpected
Concrete
Credible
Emotion
Stories
51
52
Why is Gangnam Style so sticky?
5353
Take away
Know the difference between active and passive voice
Know what the curse of knowledge is.
Know the six elements to make it stick.
For further reading (not required): Made to Stick by Chip & Dan Heath
53
54
Photo Credits
Conversation by search engine people blog sticky pudding by JMC Photos airline toilet by jshyun Toronto Star front page curse stone by Tiggrrr42 s by Leo Reynolds army commander by USAG-Humphreys economy-stupid by James Carville apple core by roger.karlsson simple by Ferran. u by chrisinplymouth minivan by redteam southwest airlines by xplan303ex newspaper headline by Semper Eadem MCMLXXXII surprise by trinity c by chrisinplymouth meat as deck of cards by Unhindered by Talent martin luther king jr by U.S. Embassy New Delhi sharing by cheesy42 exercise by Sebastian Fritzon c by cobalt123 Marshall and Warren win the Nobel prize giving advice by WAstateDNR - Department of Natural Resources e by chrisinplymouth Jon Hamm (Don Draper) from AMC Don’t mess with Texas campaign You deserve a break today campaign s by mag3737 Jared and Subway campaign storytelling by Squiggle glue by t. Murse refugees by United Nations Photos Gangnam Style Official Cover Take away by Jim Moran