1
Tools for Effective Teaming:
Coaching Families and Colleagues in Early
Childhood
Barbara Hanft MA, OTR, FAOTAChapel Hill, North Carolina
July 2008
2
Goals for today
Illustrate how coaching families and colleagues promotes children’s participation in home and community life
Discuss the key components of coaching- observation-action-reflection
Review communication and interpersonal skills that support effective coaching partnerships
3
Coaching, through reflection, emphasizes learning to:
“do with”
instead of
“do to” partners.
Mattingly & Fleming, 1994
4
Your role as coach…
Building partner’s competence by refining a partner’s skills/knowledge through guiding and self-discovery
and
Assisting partner to identify and implement strategies to help a child participate in early childhood settings/programs
5
Continuation
Observation
Action
Reflection
Initiation
Evaluation
Key components of Coaching (Hanft, Rush, & Shelden, 2004)
Resolution
6
Readiness for coaching.
I offer objective feedback to colleagues.
I am open to suggestions from colleagues.
It’s helpful when a colleague sees what I do and gives me feedback.
7
Process is interactive and cycles back and forth between….
Observation
Action
Reflection
8
Visual learning
partner observes coach partner observes peers
partner watches video partner reads an article and/or looks at illustration
Auditory learning
partner summarizes feedback from coach partner narrates actions watching a video partner listens to audiotape partner talks to another partner
Kinesthetic learning
partner keeps journal of actions/reflections partner rehearses actions in mind
partner practices actions partner demonstrates actions to others
Actions……
9
Coaching skills… supporting observation, action & reflection
Observe: actions, reactions, interactions
Listen: attend, acknowledge, associate
Respond: probe, summarize, feedback/info, problem solve
Plan: clarify, identify action/strategies
10
Video Vignette: Jacob
Observe how Heidi (PT) interacts with Holly (mother) using-
Observation:
Action:
Reflection:
11
Observations are outcome related and include-
Colleague’s behaviorNonverbal communication, comments, interaction and actions in response to events, others and the coach
Reactions of others to the learneracceptance of learner’s actions
Physical and social environment # 1-3 on Coaching Self Assessment
12
Listening …
Attending to present interactions direct eye contact, positive facial expressions, an open body posture, close proximity to the speaker, being quiet
Acknowledgingrespond verbally and nonverbally without agreeing or disagreeing with colleague
Associatinglink colleague’s communication to desired outcomes, your ITP mission and guiding principles www.nectac.org
# 4-9 on Coaching Self Assessment
13
Respond to learners by:
Asking probing questions
Facilitating problem-solving/coping
Summarizing discussion and actions
Sharing information, resources, support and feedback
# 10-18 on Coaching Self Assessment
14
Ask open-ended questions (#11)
Invite discussion: “What do you think might work to help us
develop functional outcomes with families?”
Rather than decide direction: “This is what I think we should do…..”
When it’s time for direction, start with what’s going right.“I’ve noticed --- is really working well.“When you ---, Carly really sits still longer.”
15
How professionals talk affects How professionals talk affects caregiver participationcaregiver participation
Indirect behavior: praise/encouragement, ask ?, accepting feelings/ideas
Encourages caregivers to initiate and structure interactions- BUT-
95% of praise was about child, not caregiver actions
96% of questions were close-ended
Direct behavior: giving info, directing, criticizing
Leads to professionals giving more info Brady et al, 2004. JEI, 26(2), pp.146-159
16
Responding: Examples of open-ended questions
1. Recall or gather information
Tell me about…
Tell me more….
What did you want to happen?
What happened when …..?
What did you do/say when……?
What went well?
Where does that most often occur?
When did you first notice this?
17
2. Compare new info/experiences with previous ones
How did you decide to do this?What types of support will you need?What do you think about…?How do you feel about….?
3. Apply new info to change behavior
What would you do differently next time? How might you go about doing that?What would happen if…..?
18
GROW questions → decisions (# 19-20 on Coaching self-assessment)
G- goal oriented: situation specificWhat did you plan for? What happened?
R- reality: partners state what they saw, heard, feltWho was involved? What triggered Cory’s outburst? How did you react?
O- options: explore alternativesWhat have you tried? What else might work? What actions could lead to a different outcome? How can I support you?
W- Who is going to do what by when?Be careful about asking “why” questions
Whitmore, 1996
19
Planning
Clarify the purpose and mutually agreed upon outcomes for the coaching relationship
Determine who needs to do what, before and during the next coaching conversation
Identify strategies for how colleague will acquire/refine knowledge
# 19-21 on Coaching Self Assessment
20
Coaching colleagues….
Peer coaching is a confidential process through which two + colleagues work together to:
Reflect on what they are doing
Refine current skills & build new ones
Share ideas with one another
Solve problems Robbins, 1991, p.1
21
Components of effective peer coaching….
Voluntarily supported by entire team as part of life-long learning.
Flexible formats (expert/reciprocal approaches; spontaneous/planned)
Colleagues desire for additional knowledge/skill are matched with appropriate coach.
Peer coaches understand adult learning and interaction.
Chapter 7 in Hanft, Rush & Shelden, 2004
22
Reciprocal peer coaching:
Colleagues observe one another and reflect together by sharing feedback re: a mutually agreed upon topic
Colleagues are at similar levels of learning and want to learn/apply new info/skills
Can be planned or spontaneous
23
Spontaneous peer coaching
Look for opportunities-
Team meetings
Informal talk during lunch (“bump-intos”)
Planning home & community visits
In-services and other PD events
Use video, audiotape, phone, email
to ask probing questions to prompt reflection-Wh questions- Who, what, where, when
Be careful asking “Why”
24
Peer Coaching Vignette: Jason’s Play time
Spontaneous coaching in team meeting
25
Expert peer coaching:
Coach shares specialized knowledge & experience with others
May be external consultant or internal staff
Usually time and place is planned
26
Align coach-colleague experience and knowledge
Do I know what my colleague really hopes to master?
Do I understand a colleague’s context for applying the skills/knowledge I plan to prompt him or her to acquire?
Do I have the expertise to guide this colleague?
knowledge of evidence-based practices and experience using them?
27
Assist colleague to refine knowledge/skill.
What frequency and intensity of coaching sessions are needed to help a colleague reach his or her goals?
How often will a colleague need follow-up once his or her goals are met?
How will the principles of adult learning be addressed for each colleague?
What mix of coaching strategies will help? e.g., demo, observation, print resources
28
(1+1) Coaching…..
Based on conversations of personal discovery
Improves an individual’s performance within a specific context
Process for improving skill, trying new approaches, resolving challenges and building collegial relationships
29
Cramer & Stivers. (2007). Practical strategies for challenging collaborations. Teaching Exceptional Children, 39(6), 4-8 Hanft & Shepherd. (2008). Collaborating for student success. Bethesda, MD: AOTA.Hanft, Rush, & Shelden. (2004). Coaching Families and Colleagues in Early Childhood. Baltimore, MD: Brookes Publishing. Fisher, R. & Shapiro, D. (2005). Beyond reason: Using emotions as you negotiate. NY: Penguin Books.Hollingsworth, H. (2001). We need to talk: Communication strategies for effective collaboration. Teaching Exceptional Children, 33(5), 4-8.Mattingly & Fleming. (1994). Clinical reasoning. Philadelphia: F.A. Davis.Robbins, (1991). How to plan and implement a peer coaching program. Reston, VA: ASCD.Whitmore, J. (1996). Coaching for performance. London: Nicholas Brealery.