© NERC All rights reserved
UK Shale gas: How much gas? How safe to extract?
Prof Mike Stephenson
British Geological Survey
© NERC All rights reserved
Two main questions
• How much gas is there?o Is it worth investing?
o Is it worth thinking about risks and regulation if gas extraction never happens?
• How safe is it to extract?o What are the main risks?
o What science can be done to understand risks
© NERC All rights reserved
How much gas is there? Reserve and resource
• Resource figure -amount of gas in the ground (some of which might never be accessible)
• Reserve figure -more sophisticated measure - amount of gas that you might be able extract given economics and other factors.
• Recovery factor - proportion of the total gas resource that can be extracted and is often expressed as a percentage
© NERC All rights reserved
How much gas is there? Variation in estimates and recovery factors
• BGS approximate reserve estimates for DECC in 2010 - 5.3 tcf (150 BCM)
• Advanced Resources (2011) which listed 97 tcf GIP and 20 tcf recoverable resources for the UK
• Cuadrilla’s Lancashire licence their 1200 square kilometres licence area 200 tcf GIP
• IGas acreage first estimate GIIP 800mmboe, then changed to c.1,600mmboe (millions barrels of oil equivalent - 9.23 tcf)
• Eden Energy 7 licences in South Wales GIIP) – 34.198 tcf ; Recoverable Volume – 12.799 tcf of gas’.
• Dart Energy Original Gas in Place (OGIP) of 65.56 tcf
© NERC All rights reserved
How safe to extract?
© NERC All rights reserved
Main hazards/concerns
• Earthquakes
• Integrity of well casing and groundwater contamination
• Radioactivity
• Transportation of equipment, materials and wastes to and from the site;
• Emissions to air
• Noise
• Large volumes of water for fracking
• Surface spillages of chemicals and waste waters
© NERC All rights reserved
• Largest on 1 April
• magnitude 2.3
• felt >50 people
© NERC All rights reserved
Comparison of signals
• Comparison of signals from the 1 April and 27 May
• Waveforms very similar, so similar origin
BGS concluded that the earthquakes were a direct consequence of the fluid injection during fracking
© NERC All rights reserved
Management of future tremors
• Cuadrilla commissioned reports on the tremors
• DECC commissioned an expert group to look at the reports and make recommendations• Small pre-injection and monitoring before the main
injection.
• Growth direction should be monitored and monitoring system for automatic locations and magnitudes of any seismic events in near real-time.
• Operations should be stopped and remedial action instituted, if events of magnitude 0.5 ML or above are detected.
• UK Govt yet to make a decision and recommendations
© NERC All rights reserved
Groundwater and rock stress baseline studies
• How background methane is there in groundwater?
• Which rocks are stressed already so should be avoided for fracking
© NERC All rights reserved
Commons Select Committee Call for evidence on the ‘Impact of Shale Gas on Energy Markets’
• What are the estimates for the amount of shale gas in place in the UK, Europe, and the rest of the world, and what proportion is recoverable?
• Why are the estimates for shale gas so changeable?
• What are the prospects for offshore shale gas in the UK Continental Shelf?
• Should the UK consider setting up a wealth fund with the tax revenue from shale gas?
• What have been the effects of shale gas on the LNG industry?
• Could shale gas lead to the emergence of a single, global gas market?
• What are the effects on investment in lower-carbon energy technologies?
• What is the potential impact on climate change objectives of greater use of shale gas?
© NERC All rights reserved
Conclusions
• Resources and reserves estimates in Britain and Europe vary widely
• This is affecting investor confidence; also policy makers aren't sure what to do….
• Main British environmental concern has been earthquakes. Studies recommend ‘traffic light’ system to manage tremors
• BGS has initiated groundwater and rock stress baseline studies
• Commons Select Committee Call
• 14th Licensing Round
© NERC All rights reserved
Extra slides for discussion?
© NERC All rights reserved
Shale basics • Grey or black, soft• Fine grained• 70% of the world’s surface
rocks are sedimentary; 50% of those are shale.
• Contain ~95 % of the organic matter in sedimentary rocks
1 mm
What is shale gas?
© NERC All rights reserved
Where does the organic material come from?
Land plant material and seawater algae collect in mud
Older, deeper shale layer
What is shale gas?
© NERC All rights reserved
500 m
0 m
What is shale gas?
• Shale buried
• Biological decay – biogenic methane
• Organic matter ‘cooked’ – thermogenic methane
Old deep shale layer
Burial over millions of years
© NERC All rights reserved
Conventional and unconventional
Conventional and unconventional
© NERC All rights reserved
Sand grain
Sand graingas
gas
0.25mm
shalesandstone
Conventional and unconventional
© NERC All rights reserved
Adsorbed gas and gas in pores
• Pore space gas
• Adsorbed gas
• calculation of gas in place per unit volume
• We have to measure how much shale
Phytoclast
Pyrite
Conventional and unconventional
© NERC All rights reserved
Shale layer
sandstone
Cap rockConventional: Trap
Unconventional:Continuous
accumulation
Conventional and unconventional
© NERC All rights reserved
Fracking basics
• Cracks the shale
• High pressure water or nitrogen, 350-700 bar (350 to 700 atmospheres)
Conventional and unconventional
© NERC All rights reserved
Contamination from fracking?Osborn et al. 2011, PNAS
• Studied:• Methane in
shallow water wells in shale gas areas
• measured methane content and
δ13C
© NERC All rights reserved
Not peer reviewedDec 2011
Molofsky et al. 2011
© NERC All rights reserved Molofsky et al. 2011
© NERC All rights reserved
The Blackpool region - low seismicity even
for the UK.
2.5 in 1970 5 km south-west of Blackpool.
number of smaller earthquake
immediately offshore.
The magnitude 3.7 Ulverston earthquake
28 April 2009
Blackpool seismicity
© NERC All rights reserved
How much gas is there? Complex terminology
Terms for resources and reserves
Term Acronym Summary
Resource‘How much gas is in the ground’
Original gas in place OGIP Total volume of gas
Gas (initially) in place GIIP/GIP Total volume of gas
Ultimately recoverable Total recoverable volume
Technically recoverable
Limited by technology
Economically recoverable
Limited by economics
Reserve‘How much gas could be extracted’
Reserves Total producible gas
Proved reserves 1P Probability of reserves (proven)
Median figure of reserves
2P Proven and probable
High figure of reserves 3P Proved, probable and possible
© NERC All rights reserved
Damage very unlikely to have been caused by earthquake