Determinants of FDI inflows to Vietnam in the context of China trade war and pandemic
1
Abstract:
With a strong speed of growth rate, Vietnam becomes one of the most promised
emerging markets for FDI investment among Asian nations. That creates
motivation for research to study the business opportunities of Vietnam in terms of
a fast-growing economy to cope with the global rapid growth. However, the
context of the key determinants for the FDI impacts in Vietnam is still rare and
out of date. Especially, the world economy has changed dramatically under the
attack of COVID 19 and US-China war trade, leading to the gap with the
previous research results applied to the theory. Therefore, the research
highlighted the main features of the Vietnam economy in terms of import and
export in the comparison with China. After review, the OLI framework and
Dunning’s International Production theory applied to test the fundamentals of the
potential content to advance the locational advantages.
2
Table of ContentsChapter 1 : Introduction, Aims and Objective 5
1.1. Background 5
1.2. Aims and Objective of the Research 7
1.3. Expected Contributions 9
1.4. Research Outline 10
Chapter 2 : Literature Review 13
2.1. Advantages and disadvantages of Dunning OLI Framework 1000 13
2.1.1. Ownership sub- paradigm 14
2.1.2. Location sub- paradigm 14
2.1.3. Internationalization sub paradigm 15
2.1.4. Limitation 16
2.2. Application of Dunning International Production theory in Vietnam 17
2.2.2. Resource- seeking strategies 17
2.2.3. Market- seeking strategies 100 18
2.2.4. Efficiency- seeking strategies 20
2.2.5. Asset- seeking strategies 21
2.3. Historical information 22
2.3.1. FDI flows in Vietnam 22
2.3.2 FDI flows in in China 23
2.3.2 Global economic shocks 24
2.4. China- US trade war and pandemic on FDI inflows 25
2.4.1. China-US trade war 25
2.4.2. Covid-19 pandemic 26
3
2.4.3. The linkage of these crisis on FDI 27
2.5. Economic elements of Vietnam during economic crisis 29
2.5.1. Overview 29
2.5.2 Vietnam economy during economic crisis 30
2.5.3 Key investors in FDI inflows 32
2.5.4 Impact of Covid 19 on consumption expenditure by sectors. 33
Chapter 3 : Methodology 35
3.1 Research approach 35
3.2 Hypotheses 36
3.3 Research method 37
3.4 Data collection 37
3.5 Data analyst 40
3.6 Ethical issues 41
3.7 Limitation 42
Chapter 4 : Data 42
4.1. trading activities countries 42
4.1.1 Inflow trade 42
4.1.1 Outflow trade 43
Chapter 5 . Results 44
5.1. The relationship between locational factors with the international production
theory 44
5.1.1 Resource seeking strategies 44
5.1.2 Market seeking elements 45
5.1.3 Efficiency seeking strategy. 45
5.1.4 Strategic asset-seeking strategy 46
4
Chapter 6 . Findings, Analysis and Discussion 47
6.1 Vietnam’s trade performance 47
6.1.1 Vietnam becomes attractive place for relocation factory 47
6.1.2 The risk of Vietnam during the trade war 50
6.1.3 Main trade categories of Vietnam to China and America 54
6.1.4 Main majors impacted by the Covid 57
6.2. Application of Dunning International Theory in Vietnam 61
6.2.1 Resource-seeking strategies 61
6.2.2 Market seeking elements 62
6.2.3 Efficiency-seeking strategy. 64
6.2.4 Strategic asset-seeking. 66
Chapter 7 : Conclusions 67
Chapter 8 : Reference 71
List of tables and figures
Table 1: Descriptive statistics of FDI net inflows in period of 2010-2020. Source: World
Bank (2020) and Trading Economics (2020).
Table 2: Descriptive statistics of FDI net outflow in period of 2010-2020. Source: World
Bank (2020) and Trading Economics (2020).
Table 3: Correlation of FDI and resource-seeking strategies. Source: author’s
calculation
Table 4: Correlation of FDI inflows and market-seeking strategies. Souce: Worldbank,
(2020)
Table 5: Correlation of FDI inflows and Efficiency -seeking strategies. Source: Molisa
(2020)
5
Table 6: Correlation of FDI inflows and Strategic -seeking strategies. Source: Ho et al.,
(2020)
Figure 1. Global FDI inflows and by group of economies (2008-2019) 5
Figure 2: historical FDI flows in Vietnam. Source: Foreign Investment Agency from
VietnamNews (2017) 22
Figure 3: the GDP growth of China over the year. Souce: China’s National Bureau of
Statistics from BBC (2020). 23
Figure 4: GDP growth rate prediction of the Southeast Asia countries in 2020. Source:
Asian Development Bank from Vietnam Briefing, 2020. 28
Figure 5: Impact on shopping and out-of-home activities due to coronavirus COVID-19
among urban citizens in Vietnam in 2020. Source: Statista, 2020. 33
Figure 6: Change in consumption expenditure due to coronavirus COVID-19 outbreak
among Vietnamese in 2020 compared to 2019, by sector. Source: Statista, 2020. 34
Figure 7: import of Vietnam with main countries between 2010 and 2020. Sourrce: UN
trade and Vietnam Custom (2020). 49
Figure 8: Trade impact of the Coronavirus epidemic until 2020. Source: UNTAD, 2020.
50
Figure 9: export of Vietnam with main countries between 2010 and 2020. 53
Figure 10: trading categories between Vietnam and China, United State between 2010
and 2020. Source: UN trade and Vietnam Custom (2020). 55
Figure 11: growth rate of main export categories between Vietnam and China, United
State in 2010 - 2020. Source: UN trade and Vietnam Custom (2020). 55
Figure 12: Contribution to GDP by industry in Vietnam. Source: Statista, 2020. 57
Figure 13: International tourist trend and scenarios for 2020. Source: UNWTO, 2020. 58
Figure 14: Accumulated registered projects and total registered investment by sectors to
May 2020. Source FIA, 2020. 60
Figure 15: Annual growth rate of energy sector of the world, 2017–2020. Source:
UNTAD, 2020. 61
6
TOPIC: Determinants of FDI inflows to Vietnam in the context of China trade war and pandemic
Chapter 1 : Introduction, Aims and Objectives
1.1. BackgroundGlobalization and strategic alliances between countries has resulted in massive
Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) inflows to emerging countries in recent years.
Moreover, FDI is considered the most effective ways to access advanced
technology and knowledge with minimal cost as well as utilizing country
resources in the absence of domestic capital. Therefore, attracting inward FDI is
an important strategy of developing countries to deal with the lack of capital and
knowledge to reach the highest speed of development.
In recent years, global FDI flows have been falling, 2018 recorded a decrease of
13 percent to USD 1.3 trillion. The three consecutive year’s fall in FDI was mainly
due to the fall in FDI flows to developed economies reaching the lowest point
since 2004, declining by 27 percent (UNCTAD, 2019).
Figure 1. Global FDI inflows and by group of economies (2008-2019)
Source: UNCTAD, 2020
7
However, FDI inflows to developing countries has been rising slightly, the figure
increased by 2 percent in 2019. Due to fall in FDI flows to developed countries,
the contribution of developing countries in global FDI increased to 54 per cent
(UNCTAD, 2019), which implies the important role of developing countries in the
global investment.
In 20th century, Vietnam is one of the most outstanding emerging economies in
South- East Asia. Since the Economic Reform in 1986 to joining WTO in 2007
until now, globalization has been an important factor of Vietnam development,
together with several economic liberalization policies as well as regulations (e.g
the Law of Foreign Investment in 1988 and 1996), boosting the country inward
FDI, reaching 15.5 billion USD in 2018 (The World Bank, 2020a).
Due to the China- US dispute1 since 2018, there has been growing desire of
MNEs to transfer capital away from China to avoid risks of higher taxes and
tariffs exporting goods manufactured in China. Moreover, in early 2020, the
outbreak of Coronavirus begin from China has cause bad impacts on the global
supply chain as well as economic development. Because of the pandemic and
China is closed, the supply chain is broken, many country leaders realize that the
world should reduce the dependence on manufacturing in China. Having the
similar country advantages as China: low- cost labor, FDI attract policies,
geographical benefits, signing in many FTAs, Vietnam is a good choice to move
capital outside China.
1.2. Aims and Objective of the ResearchAs discussed above, China is losing its location advantages therefore investors
and researchers are concerning whether moving capital to Vietnam is a right
strategy. The main purpose of this research is to understanding the determinants
of FDI including economic and non- economic factors. Based on that, the author
would like to focus more on the location advantages to explain the drivers of FDI
inflows to Vietnam. Furthermore, the research would give out the perspective of
1 The dispute has seen the US and China impose tariffs on hundreds of billion dollars on one another's goods. So far, the US has slapped tariffs on US$250 billion worth of Chinese products. China, in turn, has set tariffs on US$110 billion worth of US goods (Federation of American Scientists, 2019).
8
FDI in the future in the context of China- US trade war, the opportunities and
risks for country economic development and suggest some strategic solutions for
policy- maker. The specific research objectives include:
Objective 1: Evaluate how much location factors affect the motivations of FDI
inflows in Vietnam by quantitative method.
Objective 2: Evaluate the context of US- China dispute and Covid19 pandemic
and the impacts on FDI in Vietnam as well as the opportunities.
By achieving these objectives, the author would like to carry out the changes in
FDI inflows in the context of economic shocks.
Objective 3: Give suggestions for investors and policy makers in the next 5 years
based on the research results.
In order to find the determinants of FDI inflows, this study will evaluate the
economics and non- economics factors that attract capital to Vietnam based on
Dunning OLI Framework as well as explain the motivations of investors based on
Dunning international production theory. Relating to above objectives, these
research questions would be answered:
Question 1: What are the most important factors determine the motivations of
FDI inflows to Vietnam?
Question 2: What are the impacts of the dispute and pandemic on FDI inflows?
Question 3: Why will the US- China trade war and Covid19 pandemic bring
opportunities for Vietnam?
Question 4: How will the country response to these economic shocks?
Question 5: How should investors and policy – makers facing with those
changes?
1.3. Expected ContributionsThe foundation of research in FDI is Dunning (1993) Eclectric Theory and
International Production theory. Due to the importance of FDI in global economic
9
development, there have been several studies working on this topic based on
Dunning’s theoretical framework. For example, Franco et al. (2008) stated in their
research that there are four motivations for firms to invest abroad to look for
Ownership, Location and Internationalization Advantages. In 2011, Wadhwa
published a further article using quantitative method to evaluate the impact of
four motivations on FDI inflows to emerging markets. There are other authors
study the impact of specific factors on FDI. Kayalvizhi and Thenmozhi (2017)
implied that innovation, culture and government drive FDI inflows to emerging
markets while another study gives prominence to volatility and employment as
determinants of FDI inflows.
In general, the existing study determinants of FDI inflows in emerging markets
and in Vietnam still have limitation due to difference approaches, limited research
area allowance and different methods. Moreover, existing studies that evaluate
the impacts of China trade war and pandemic on FDI flows to Vietnam are still
rare. This research aims to fulfil these gaps. It will apply both qualitative and
quantitative methods to evaluate the factors impact on FDI to explain why some
factors are more important than the others. Therefore, this research is expected
to contribute persuasive results to answer the question: “Which really are the
determinants of FDI in Vietnam in the context of economic shocks?” and “How do
these factors affect investors’ decision?” for further studies. In addition to the
academic contribution, this study also provide investors and policy- makers some
strategic suggestions to gain success in investments as well as attracting FDI.
Because of the fast changes in the global market and the impacts of economic
shocks are unexpected and unpredictable, investors and government have to
cope with those change quickly. This research will help by evaluating the impact
of China trade war and pandemic on FDI inflows to Vietnam. Moreover,
suggestions based on these findings are expected to be used for further strategic
planning.
1.4. Research OutlineThis research will be divided into six chapters with the main contents as below:
10
Chapter 1: Introduction, Aim and Objectives
This chapter gives out the overview of the research topic and briefly
explains why it is important to conduct the research. The chapter includes
four parts: the general background of global FDI and FDI inflow to
emerging countries especially Vietnam, the main aims and objectives of
the research interpreted by research questions, the results contributed to
fill the gap of previous articles and the structure of the research.
Chapter 2: Literature Review
The previous research articles about FDI and international business will
be reviewed in this chapter to provide the theoretical background for the
topic. This chapter will focus on Dunning Eclectic Paradigm and
International trade theory and other researches about FDI based on these
theories. Moreover, it will point out the gap of these researches and the
way this research fill in those gaps.
Chapter 3: Methodology
This chapter explains the method of collecting data, the sources of data
using in this research. It justifies the research approach and mixed
methods using to analyze collected data and interpret the results.
Chapter 4: Data and Results
Collected data of all the factors affect FDI in Vietnam are summarized and
analyzed using Stata to points out which factors are the determinants. FDI
data since the trade war and pandemic are also analyzed. The results will
be interpreted based on quantitative standard. Moreover, this research
also combines quantitative and qualitative method to evaluate the results.
Chapter 5: Findings and Discussion
This chapter will show the findings from the results of data analysis and
research questions will be answered. It firstly points out the determinants
of FDI inflows to Vietnam and explains why the factors are significant. The
11
opportunities from the China trade war and pandemic are discussed in this
chapter. Finally, some suggestions for policy- makers and investors will be
given.
Chapter 6: Conclusions
This is the last chapter of the research, summarizing the main ideas,
research results, conclusion and recommendation. This chapter also
provide directions for further researches in FDI sector.
12
Chapter 2 : Literature ReviewThis chapter aims to provide the background knowledge of the research, the
theories and information which are highly relevant to the topic chosen.
Specifically, the literature reviews are well- addressed the deep understanding of
Dunning’s Eclectic Paradigm or OLI framework and international production
theory and the significance of these theories on defining the determinants of FDI
inflows to Vietnam. Moreover, the works of literature explain the context of China
trade war and pandemic as well as the impacts on Vietnam’s FDI inflows.
2.1. Advantages and disadvantages of Dunning OLI Framework 1000With the fast growth economy, the flows of foreign investment transferred from
developed nations into the emerging markets. In fact, the FDI capital for
developed countries has dropped 27% in 2018 by the research of UNTAD
(2019). The research of Rugman (2002) presented that the growth of
internalisation theory consists of the concept of FDI. While Dunning (1981)
argued about the development of globalisation theory is only the part of FDI
framework. The author also investigated the Dunning Eclectic paradigm to
analyst determinants of FDI and the performance of MNEs in the global market.
Due to the rapid changes in the globalisation, the OLI Framework has developed
through several types of research in response to those changes (Narula, 2010).
For example, Li et al. (2010) have expanded the OLI framework to evaluate the
impact of the September 11st terrorist attack on MNE’s performances. The OLI
framework implies that the interaction of three useful sub- paradigm: ownership
advantages (O), location advantages (L) and internalisation advantages (I)
determine the international business strategies of MNEs.
2.1.1. Ownership sub- paradigm
Ownership advantage points out the competitive advantages of the firms seeking
for expanding to foreign markets. The better the competitive advantages of the
FDI, the more the firms seem to engage with the oversea business entity. Those
competitive advantages could be a trademark, economy of scale, cost-efficiency,
etc. which can be transferred across countries and cannot be obtained by any
13
competitors. According to Dunning, if other factors remain unchanged, the firms
hold more competitive advantages than competitors in-home or host countries
are more likely to succeed in expanding their production globally (Dunning,
2000). The other benefit of the owner is the ability to obtain tangible resources,
technological innovations, or implemental effectiveness in which local entities
could advance. On the other hand, the transaction cost theory implies that the
cost of transferring funds and services across countries is the determinant of
MNE strategies (Greve and Argote, 2015). Therefore, this sub- paradigm only
suggests doing FDI when the benefits of expanding to new countries outweigh
the transaction cost.
2.1.2. Location sub- paradigm
Location advantage focuses on choosing investment places since there is
another country, which holds more benefits than the home country such as
geographical advantage, cheap labour, materials, individual taxes and tariff.
Based on these criteria, the selection of foreign countries to set up a business
line plays an essential role for a firm to achieve long-term financial benefits and
business strategy (Narula, 2010). For example, a firm created much more
resources and revenues than the requirements. They could utilise those
materials combining with their strength to enter the foreign market and discover
their specific benefits by engaging in FDI. Moreover, the sub-paradigm viewed as
external elements to get a decision about the potential nations to investment.
2.1.3. Internationalization sub paradigm
Internationalisation advantage is to answer the question of whether the company
should produce and run the business itself or cooperate with a third party. The
report of Johanson and Vahlne (2017) emphasised the deep understanding of
foreign business influences on future commitment with the business
environment. The idea of the international business advantage came along with
the ownership sub-paradigm when the company believed to expand its affection
in the foreign market by a private corporation such as strategic engagement
contracts with local partners. A company assumed to hold internalisation
14
advantage when it can self- handle more effectively than transfer to the external
company does. If a company does not have this advantage, they should license
their business to another company in the host country, who thoroughly
understands the market and skilled labours to improve the excellent quality.
Therefore, the competitive advantage starts with implementable and conceptual
contracts to manage profit from the oversea market. However, using outsourcing
needs to be concerned about the financial effectiveness and product quality to
ensure cut-off cost than the insource production line.
To sum up, each stage of economic growth required different conditions to
achieve comparative advantages with other nations. The listed elements could
be converted into two main types such as push elements (ownership and
internationalism elements) and pull elements (locational elements), relying on the
historical development and economic conditions of specific markets. Among
these factors, Vietnam could apply the locational advantages to attract foreign
investment flows since the government could be able to control the elements
through the location sub- paradigm (Nguyen et al., 2016). Therefore, the
locational determinants of FDI are going to carry out in the analysis of
Vietnamese conditions.
2.1.4. Limitation
The practical concept of OLI determinants explained clearly the entry approach
strategies of MNEs but limited in figure out the recommendations for the
international firms (Dunning, 1993). It explains that the firm deals with the
abundance of numerable OLI components and business targets, which involved
with different activities such as policy, market value, hi-tech innovation, business
performance, etc. which together may affect competitive advantage. Besides,
based on the research of Root (1994), the entry-mode strategies present the
highest risk of external investment directly involved with joint venture and FDI
activities. By the way, the business entities may suffer from the high risks of the
new markets.
15
2.2. Application of Dunning International Production theory in Vietnam Based on the theory of Dunning (1981), multinational corporations have typical
benefits to survive during the adapting period in foreign countries such as stable
capital, innovative technology, etc. To select a suitable investment location, the
locational determinants of Vietnam is investigated in term of the research.
Therefore, this section included the conceptual practice of investment
development path to understand the phase of investment development. Then, it
classified foreign direct investment (FDI) selections of international companies
into four types of advantages such as resource-seeking, market-seeking,
efficiency-seeking, asset-seeking (Dunning, 1998). The combination of those
motives draws the foundation for firms to set up a global approach. The Dunning
International Production theory is going to explain in Vietnam to show the
potential resources of the nation in attracting FDI.
2.2.2. Resource- seeking strategies
One of the reasons for oversea investment relates to seeking natural resources,
new materials, labour, and other types of resources. It is probably those
resources presenting more affordable cost or is not available in the home
country. It could be related to “location advantages” from the OLI Framework
(Dunning, 1993) which mentions the activities of seeking advantages in another
country. These resources may be the primary material for production companies
to run business. The public funds relate to natural assets such as natural
products, labour, land. By the way, companies can improve their sustainable
competitive advantages through reducing costs and maximizing revenues for
human resources. It required the oversea nations to offer a massive number of
employees at a low price.
In the case of Vietnam, the nation presented as young and cheap labour cost,
attracting more and more foreign investors (Lim, 2017). Vietnam has a large
population of 95,540,395 in 2019 with the majority are at labour age. A well-
planned education system provides the country with a well-educated and large
16
workforce. Dunning’s term of resource- seeking mentioned unskilled labour, but
according to further research, both unskilled and skilled workers are potential for
MNEs expanding to a new market (Franco et al., 2008). Also, unskilled workers
could train, and they will bring back higher value to the company. As Dunning
has updated his theory, that “location advantages” do not only allow firms to
access to better resources, it also helps to promote MNEs’ ownership
advantages (Dunning, 2001). However, the nation achieves an impressive raise
in GDP that also affected the minimum wages of 5.7% in 2020 (Samuel, 2019).
Investors should research about the target labour cost before carrying out market
entry.
2.2.3. Market- seeking strategies 100
Market-seeking is the motivation of MNEs that want to expand to a higher
potential market or follow customers and suppliers to save costs as well as
prevent competitors from occupying those markets (Franco et al., 2008). Three
critical factors are defining a country's economic growth and market size: Gross
domestic product (GDP), population growth, and export (Wadhwa and S, 2011).
Half of the Vietnamese are under 35 years old which means a sizeable
empowered consumer market (Bernardi and Floyd, 2018). According to Dunning
(2001), market size is an essential factor for FDI flow. Besides, the country’s
GDP is increasing rapidly in a recent decade along with raising minimum wages
leading to a growth rate of the middle-income class.
Moreover, because of the low level of domestic production, the Vietnamese
government has been applying policies to encourage importing goods and FDI to
respond to the rising demand. It also helps to increase the average household
consumption per capita of 5-8 percent per year (Statista, 2020). Therefore,
Vietnam is a rapidly developing market with high purchasing ability, which is a
huge advantage for investors.
However, investing in specific ownership or a foreign country to provide products
to the new markets may cause the lack of demand in the home countries, as well
as the new market, has more potential needs (Eden and Dai, 2010). The
17
products or services require adjustment to adapt to local desires and market
trends. A direct appearance in a domestic market is necessary for the
multinational companies to understand the local market. One of the signature
cases about successful local customisation is Nestle Vietnam. The firm has
entered Vietnam since 1912, but it failed to catch up with the taste of coffee in
Vietnam. However, the gain group attempted to enter Vietnam again in 1992
through a joint venture with a local company and created La Vie. By the way, the
firm adopts the taste of domestic customers and changes the coffee ingredients
to match the market needs. As a result, the company has achieved considerable
succession with 89% of customer satisfaction (Nestle Vietnam, 2020). Besides,
there is the market risk that may affect the decision of corporate governance in
the company. Vietnam is a developing nation attracting various international
companies, which may lead to a lack of revenue or increase the competitive
market for new companies.
2.2.4. Efficiency- seeking strategies
Another type of strategy regards efficiency in improving the importance of
existing business abroad nation. Efficiency seekers enhance effectiveness by
reinforcing the advantages of economic scale and scope from the differentiation
between diverse countries (Dunning, 1993). Improvement describes from
distinction from diversified available resources in multiple nations. Notably, the
essential business operation such as governance, innovational, or strategy
creation located in developed countries while adding profits from human forces
and resource relations mostly came from developing nations. Efficiency seeking
tactics motivates the feature endowments between diversified nations to
withdrawn benefit for business implementation (Lim et al., 2015).
Nevertheless, multinational companies may reduce tax through diversified
taxation systems for business development (Chen, 2018). However, the local
government should control the different business activities to avoid the tax
burden. For example, the research of KPMG (2020) stated that the corporate tax
of Vietnam is 20%, which is lower than the tax rates of central investment nations
18
such as Korea (25%), Japan (30%) in 2020. Also, the adjustment of the
corporate tax from 25% (before 2014) to 20% (2014 – 2020) of Vietnam
governance motives multiple international companies to put their footprint in the
emerging market.
2.2.5. Asset- seeking strategies
Asset seeking strategies concentrate on the longstanding engagement through
FDI to prevent resources taken by other international competitors. Focus on the
enhancement of strategic assets will support the firm to obtain its future target.
Vital resources typically describe as intangible resources such has knowledge
and the unique capability of the enterprise. The primary type of necessary
provisions such as acknowledge, expertise, etc. frequently often through
acquired the assets of international organisations. By the way, the strategy
focuses on future value and considers the current or short-term losses as
investment capital (Pak, 2002). The main reason for that is to sustainable
competitive advantages or preventing the achievement of other competitors. It is
necessary to keep business information confidentially from the rivals (Groh and
Wich, 2012).
It disputes that individual business enterprises can apply strategic resources
seeks to build a connection with local governance for their long-term purposes
(Lim, 2017). Notably, Vietnam is a communist country with developing a legal
system that may be affected by political power. The real estate sector motive by
the impact of the authority department since the land law, investment law, and
bidding law is confused and conflicted for investors. Therefore, developers must
build an excellent personal relationship with political influencers to process
application documents and to reach their future targets. The nation's motives to
classify and improve the legal system to generate a productive business
environment.
19
2.3. Historical information
2.3.1. FDI flows in Vietnam
After the economic reforms in the late 1980s, Vietnam utilised different methods
to attract investment resources from other nations. Vietnam issued the new legal
structure to encourage FDI injections such as the establishment of hi-tech parks
and industrial clusters, a corporation with other governments for strategic
alliances, free tariffs, and land use fees, etc. The change in legal structures and
investment procedures leads to a favorable business environment for inbound
FDI and attracted various foreign investment. For example, the Japanese
government decided to support FDI inflows for Vietnam in a long-term
perspective. Nevertheless, there is some problem in the implementation of the
FDI inflows, specifically in the cut-off lobbying costs and the low operation of
oversea funds, and the lack of experience to control the cash flow of these FDI
criteria (Tri and Anh, 2016).
Figure 2a: historical FDI flows in Vietnam. Source: Foreign Investment Agency
from VietnamNews (2017)
20
● By geography
With over 38 percent for the FDI inflows, Ha Noi passed the financial spot of
Vietnam – Ho Chi Minh to become to lead FDI in 2019. The city became the new
FDI attraction hubs in Asia with the fast growth in GDP per capita with over
$5,100 US Dollar, huge GDP contribution with 16.5 percent (figure 2b). However,
the policy of expanding area by merging nearby provinces challenged the city to
build up suitable future master plan.
In the other hand, Ho Chi Minh was a new bright star, remaining as the lead of
FDI capital previously. Regarding to Customs News (2020), the city attracted
nearly 7,500 projects with the total FDI investment of $8.3 billion USD in 2019.
Arise demand for diversification investment motivated investors from developed
nations such as Japan, EU and US to find a new market with less risk and fast
turnover. Ho Chi Minh concentrated on qualified labour resource, technological
innovation and completed infrastructure, creating promising condition for FDI
growth.
21
Figure 2b: Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh’s geography. Source: GSO (2020)
2.3.2 FDI flows in in China
The China government opened for FDI strategy since 1979 and dramatically
grew since then. In the 2000s, the nation has passed many developed countries
and become the leader for FDI attraction by the vast local market and affordable
labour cost (Zhang and Corrie, 2018). Moreover, the nation created various
investment prospects by offer liberalisation plans, the fast growth of technological
trend and free trading area. Due to the rapid growth of the domestic economy,
investment to China brings a wide range of benefits. It could be substantial local
consumers, fully enlargement production business. Besides, business investors
could locate in the prime area connecting with other nations, skilled labour at a
low ratio, etc. However, some disadvantages need to consider, such as
government corruption, unclarified legal situation, lack of intelligent creation
22
protection, etc. (Ali and Guo, 2005). Therefore, the GDP growth of China
expected to drop nearly 7% in 2020 (BBC, 2020).
Figure 3: the GDP growth of China over the year. Souce: China’s National
Bureau of Statistics from BBC (2020).
2.3.2 Global economic shocks
The macro economy experiences the change in the business criteria and
variables, resulting in the shift in financial profits and economic portrayals such
as corruption, joblessness, and inflation (Investopedia, 2019). The global
economy has faced with the two most significant crisis in the development
history, which are the Great depression in 1993 and the financial crisis in 2008.
One of the devastating economic shocks was the Great Depression, which
disturbs the growth of manufacturing production at the beginning of the 1900s
from the United State. By the way, Eichngreen (2014) believed the crisis had
become a typical example of the global crisis to show the weakening economic
system. It started with a significant decline in the stock market in the United
States. It spread out the international stock crash, responding to a 15% reduction
in the global gross domestic product (GDP).
23
The global commercial trading market observed the second fall as the most
precarious crisis in 2008 since the Great Depression. The downturn started from
the dropping in the real estate market and winged quickly to the bank business
through a subprime mortgage loan, then affecting the entire financial system in
the United States and global banking system through bridging transactions. Many
bank corporations fell due to their dependence on credit loans. For example, the
most well-known case is Lehman Brothers, which contributed 5% of the global
derivative revenue (Wiggins and Metrick, 2014). The commercial enterprise
emphatically replied on the housing mortgage loans and failed in sustainable
liquidity ratio.
2.4. China- US trade war and pandemic on FDI inflows
2.4.1. China-US trade war
The economic battle between the United States and China started in March 2018
when the Trump President decided to tax 50 billion USD on the Chinese import
product based on Commercial Trading Law in 1984. The action explained as the
effort of the US government to stop China from stealing technological innovation
and bad commercial trades. In April 2018, the American government set tariffs
barriers imposes steel and aluminum from China, Europe (Washington Post,
2018). As a result, the trading profit between the United States and China
decreased at 100 billion USD. Moreover, the high taxation ratio created a
negative impact on the economic performance of China and responded to nearly
a 6% deduce in forecast income in 2020 (Paszak, 2020).
Regarding that decision, President Trump believed that the aluminum tariffs
weaken intellectual property rights by a joint venture with multinational
corporations to increase capital. By the way, foreign firms have access to the
intelligent database to share advanced technologies. The action aimed to cope
with the “Made in China 2025” strategies of the China government for robotic
manufacturing processes and increasing the market share of Chinese products
worldwide.
24
2.4.2. Covid-19 pandemic
The pandemic is the global disease with a high speed of infection and untypical
symptoms to identify. In March 2020, the World Health Organization (WHO)
announced COVID-19 becoming a global pandemic. With over six million of
infected cases, most of the nations have locked the boundaries and isolated with
foreigners. The fact of the United States is the strongest affection by over 1.7
million of positive cases and over 100,000 death cases. That directly influences
in the economic wealth of international business when there are lack of trading
activities, no consumer demand, no outdoor activities, no oversea flights, etc.
(The New York Time, 2020).
In Vietnam, the first case reported in January 2020. Until May 2020, the countries
presented over 300 positive cases, 279 recoveries, and no related death. The
country has stood out as one of the best nations for epidemic management
operation in the world by taken strict action since the starting stage of the disease
to protect citizens.
2.4.3. The linkage of these crisis on FDI
Since logistic barriers for the trade war and excellent performance during the
pandemic, there were various researchers suggested the high potential
beneficiation of Vietnam through shifting manufacturing line from China to other
Southeast countries and low trading expenses (Vu and Nguyen, 2019). The
optimistic influence caused the relocation of factories from China to Vietnam. The
Chinese Yen and US dollars firmly in contradiction of value, following by the
value of the Vietnam Dong. Therefore, Vietnam could save costs from
outsourcing industrial material supply from China at low cost, export products to
the United States at more reasonable prices, and obtain more shares from the
absence of Chinese goods in the market. According to Financial Times (2019),
even the global economy faces a new crisis, the ware of FDI inflows to Vietnam
will continue to increase and enhance the local business. For example, Samsung
diversified its manufacturing line to Vietnam due to the FDI attraction policy and
the complicated political situation of China. Regarding to Vietnam Investment
25
Review (2017), Samsung invested in Vietnam with the amount of USD $17.3
billion which is ten-fold higher than 2012. The Biggest corporation of Korea
contributed to the fast growth socioeconomic of Vietnam with a large amount of
capital, transferred technology, and GDP contribution. Particularly, the
corporation boosted the local economy by the contribution of 99 and 75 percent
in the export value of Thai Nguyen and Bac Ninh, respectively. At the same time,
the firm benefited from the local government with special tariffs discounts, cheap
labour cost land, and other support services. Therefore, the firm expanded its
footprint in the emerging market with the increasing employees at 160,000, equal
to 30 percent of the international human resource.
However, there is a high probability of Vietnam to become a transit station for
Chinese products exporting the United States. For example, steel products from
China have transferred to Vietnam and re-export to the American market under
Vietnamese merchandise. According to Reuters (2018), the Department of
Commercial in American slaps heavy import duties on Vietnamese steel initially
manufactured in China at 456%.
2.4.4. Future world growth after pandemic
In the financial crisis in 2008, the commercial entities have aware of the role of
corporate governance in regulating liquidity ratio conditions (Mills and Haines,
2015). Presently, the worldwide recession utilises complicated undertakings
affecting the global supply chain and financial regulations. The global supply
chains have suffered the most from the non-stop growth of trade war, and
pandemic will high potential of a new economic crisis. The pandemic
phenomenon predicts damage to future economic development. Manufactory
industries experience the most solid negative influence by countering trading
implementation and factory establishment in oversea nations (Cortina et al.,
2018). The second impact involves the high risk of financial crisis relates to high
liquidity demand and restrict loan conditions. Cutting expenses for innovation and
research activities shifts to the production line. The limitation fund for creative
and technology entities creates an inheritance of outdated capacity, resulting in
26
the pathetic progression. Due to the experience from Financial Crisis 2008-2009,
the regulatory framework supports a positive impact on financial sustainability.
The practice aims to defend the financial crisis and sustain monetary stability
(Davies and Green, 2013). Comparing with other emerging market within South
East Asia, Vietnam obtained the best performance in remaining the growth rate
at nearly 5% during the crisis.
Figure 4: GDP growth rate prediction of the Southeast Asia countries in 2020.
Source: Asian Development Bank from Vietnam Briefing, 2020.
2.5. Economic elements of Vietnam during economic crisis
2.5.1. Overview
Vietnam is rich in developing nations that have opened for business transactions
since 1986 and had an impressive growth rate of GDP with nearly seven percent
in 2017 from logistic and production business. However, the new market has
converted from agricultural economy to industrial industry has created
advantages for investors since they have more experience with technological and
intelligent knowledge (Dunning, 2000) as to ownership sub- paradigm.
Besides, the developing country offers cheap labor costs with a young and high-
educated population, improving infrastructure with multiple international airports,
seaports, and great ways to create a worldwide network. To support economic
27
development, the government promotes particular tax reforms for reducing
corporate taxes and increasing business clearness. By the way, the MNEs could
classify the features of the new market in improving competitive advantages as
location sub-paradigm.
Moreover, Vietnam has taken part in a different global economic corporation. It
involved various Free Trade Agreement (FTA) with multiple nations and groups
of nations such as Korean, European, WTO, APEC, etc. Vietnam presents as a
motivating country to attract international enterprised for development, invention,
and reinforcement. It matches with the idea of internationalisation sub paradigm
when MNEs could obtain global advantages to control their business in the host
nations.
2.5.2 Vietnam economy during economic crisis
Regarding the Dunning eclectic paradigm (1998), China has lost the L factor for
the country's definite advantages such as economic, social, and political stability.
In which, the economy suffers from the trading war and the source of a
pandemic. At the same time, setting premium tariffs and create fences with the
US affecting on the society and investment policy of the country. It becomes the
entry barrier for the investors to this market. The FDI flows switched to other
nations. The report of Paszak (2020) in the Warsaw Institute showed that the
United States recognised the growth of imported goods from other countries such
as Taiwan and Canada with eight billion USD, Vietnam with over 16 billion USD.
In the list of stock of direct foreign investment, Vietnam was 22nd of the most
attractive country for FDI inflows in 2017, increasing 26 ranks since 2012 (The
World Factbook, 2017). Due to the trade war, Vietnam FDI has experienced
significant growth at 7.2% in the first semi-annual 2019. There is no doubt that
the Vietnam economy achieved a massive beneficiary from the trade war
between the United States and China. It creates both opportunities and threats of
the Vietnam economy with FDI flows that will classify in the following content.
Tien and Anh (2019) believed that the US and China economic conflict would
bring benefit to Vietnam by the relocation of US manufactories and investment
28
flow, creating new business orientation. Also, China used to be the leading
suppliers for the United States market, but it is not favourable during the trade
war. Therefore, factors relocate to other neighbour markets in South East Asia
such as Vietnam, Campuchia, and Lao. As stated in this research about the
Dunning International Production theory, Vietnam consists of all the needs for
resource, asset, efficiency, and strategic seekers that potentially profitable
market for investors. For example, the article of Nhan Dan News (2020)
presented that the companies from United States, Japan, and Europe planned to
transfer business lines out of China to avoid the negative effect of the trade war
and increase labour price of China. Mainly, the Japanese government released
2.2 billion USD to support its entities to relocate production to other Southeast
Asia countries.
Besides, there are potential risks that Vietnam should consider before the FDI
movement. Vietnam imports and export heavily depends on the two gain
economies. Notably, most of the import goods and materials came from China to
the trade pressure of the United States and China strongly effect on Vietnam
commercial business. Since Vietnam benefits from the trade war, it raises
concerns about the influence of China on the Vietnam economy. For instance,
the Huawei has banned by the US government, which China may produce low-
cost items to avoid tax for high-value products. By the way, the Chinese
government can subsidies the manufacturing costs to attract investors. This may
limit the FDI into Vietnam. Moreover, Vietnam related to the resources from
China for manufacturing and trading business is unable to take steady action to
defend the power of China.
2.5.3 Key investors in FDI inflows
With the advantage of geographic features and national conditions, there are four
main countries contributing the most for the FDI inflows of Vietnam including
Korean, Japan, China, and the United State.
29
⮚ Korea is the top FDI investment in Vietnam. To 1H/2020, the total valid
investment projects of the nation are 8,785 with total charter capital is 68,159
million US dollars (MPI, 2020). However, each project scale is at a small size of
around 9.3 million US dollars. The big enterprise from Korea such as Samsung,
LG and Lotte has a huge contribution to the development of Vietnam.
⮚ The second investor was Japan with over 4,500 projects, equating to 59,940
million US dollars. Most project is a huge scale with around 13 million US Dollars
for each. Japanese corporations have entered the Vietnam market since the
early stage with the appearance of Honda, Toyota, etc. with high-quality
products.
⮚ The accumulated projects of China to Vietnam were around 3,000, with the total
charter capital was $21,000 million US Dollar, equating to around 5% of the total
registered capital in Vietnam. The nation mostly invested in real estate, finance,
and infrastructure under direct or contractual investment.
⮚ With the encouraging policy for FDI in Vietnam and the ongoing trade war with
China, there are more and more big multinational corporations of United State-
related manufacturing lines to Vietnam. The total valid investment project of
United State entities to Vietnam was over 1,000 with over 9,300 million US Dollar
in term of total charter capital.
Investment projects Total charter capital (million US Dollars)
Korea 8,785 68,159Japan 4,500 59,940China 3,000 21,000
United States 1,000 9,300
Table: Main inward FDI nations to Vietnam. Source: MPI, 2020.
2.5.4 Impact of Covid 19 on consumption expenditure by sectors.
The COVID 19 pandemic has no sign of a break, leading to multiple negative
impacts in terms of the economy and social healthy systems. Regarding the
30
research of Statista (2020) about the effect of COVID 19, the strong impact of
COVID reflected through the drop-down demand for visiting supermarkets and
grocery stores and wet markets (50%) and changed to online shopping activities
(25%). It results in a significant decrease in demand for leasing commercial real
estate for displaying products (figure 6).
It matched with the research about the customer behaviors after COVID 19.
People preferred to shop online and delivery service with an increase of 20%
(figure 5). Following the increase in transportation and household sector for 12%
and 11%, respectively. However, the social distancing directly affected the
communications with the decrease of -21%, entertainment, and dining industries
dropped to -19% compared with 2019. All the service industries included
hospitality, tourism, and entertainment, etc suffered from the COVID 19 affection
Figure 5: Impact on shopping and out-of-home activities due to coronavirus
COVID-19 among urban citizens in Vietnam in 2020. Source: Statista, 2020.
31
Figure 6: Change in consumption expenditure due to coronavirus COVID-19
outbreak among Vietnamese in 2020 compared to 2019, by sector. Source:
Statista, 2020.
32
Chapter 3 : Methodology
3.1 Research approachThe target of the report is to test hypotheses between independent such as
locational factors and dependent variables such as resource, market, efficiency,
and asset seeking approaches. Since the global economy faced with a potential
new crisis from the global pandemic. Therefore, it is important to review the issue
from the macro to the micro-scale to justify the Vietnam economic position. By
the way, the research adopted the deductive approach to give overview opinions
than a particular result (Saunders et al., 2012). It explained Jonker and Pennink
(2010) that researchers and implement hypotheses and test the results through a
research approach. It causes the deduction method to perform unique functions
such as examining the relationship between variables, therefore the connection
between the location factors and the four advantages will classify. Based on the
topic area, the deductive method is going to investigate to prove the positive
connection between independent and dependent variables.
3.2 HypothesesAfter review the research questions and objectives, these include the
determinants of FDI inflows, the US-China trade war, and global pandemic
creating opportunities for FDI in Vietnam. The research will test the relationship
between locational factors in four types of advantages in the Dunning
international production theory including resource-seeking, market-seeking,
efficiency-seeking, asset-seeking (Dunning, 1998). The set of hypotheses
presented below:
H1: locational determinants create positive impact on the resource-seeking
strategies.
H2: locational determinants create positive impact on the market -seeking
strategies.
H3: locational determinants create positive impact on the efficiency -seeking
strategies.
33
H4: locational determinants create positive impact on the asset -seeking
strategies.
3.3 Research methodThe section function is to find a situation research method to conduct an analyst
data to prove the correlation of hypothesizes is the basic step of methodology. In
the study of Peffers et al. (2007), there are two types of data including quantity
and qualitative concepts. In which, quality research prefers to non-numerical data
and words such as interviews (Saunders et al., 2012). On the other hand, a
quantitative approach related to a substitute for data collection methods that
concentrate on mathematical data such as surveys and questioners. Regarding
the research, the quantitative approach applied to test significant the impact of
FDI inflows in Vietnam under the economic shocks. To be specific, the
quantitative approach applied to test the correlation of locational determinants on
the four factors of the Dunning International Production theory. The study of
Kothari, (2004) identified that the quantitative data with survey strategy could
able to support the researcher to conduct and analyse descriptively statistics.
3.4 Data collection3.4.1 Type of data
The economic crisis including the United States-China trade war and COVID 19
strongly affected the worldwide economic and financial system including
Vietnam. Through the review, secondary data of economic factors supports
giving a solution for Vietnam to sustain its competitive advantages. The type of
data presented to the past researches, reports, and reading by other authors and
scholars, which involved with the topic of the paper. Currently, the United
Kingdom and other nations practiced the concept of social distance; therefore, it
is a limitation to conduct the primary data (Chen et al., 2020). Regarding the
reason, secondary data provisions to answer the research questions and cover
the objectives (Saunder et al., 2012). The research focused on trustable sources
of secondary information from government official data, which obtained from the
General Statistical Office (GSO), Ministry of Planning, and Investment of Vietnam
34
(MPI) through online websites and yearbook. However, these sources of data are
lack of issued lack of information in the differentiation between accumulated FDI
and FDI inflows, no implementation capital (Nguyen et al., 2016). Therefore, the
data sources from other consistent worldwide data took into account such as
OECD, The World Bank, UNCTAD, etc.
3.4.2 Sampling
Choosing an accurate sample supports for effective data collection (Wilson,
2014). Stated in the research of Saunder et al. (2012), the Convenience
sampling method related with the random selection of easy target sampling to
match with the research topic. Regarding the topic area, the research covered
various perspectives of FDI, which select the random sample with the best
choice for selecting suitable data within the limited timing. Aiming to understand
the research area, the sample focus on the cumulative FDI, GDP growth rate,
graduated high school employees, average salary, etc. In which, the group of
variables will split into four sets presenting for the top FDI investment nations
including China, the United State, Japan, and Korea.
3.4.3 Variables and measures
The dataset will conduct to serve the purpose of research; this section aims to
explain the variables and measures. To understand the effect of economic
shocks, the dependent factor will be the FDI features. The number of investment
projects and the cumulative FDI inflows from the main sources of investment
nations. The research samples collected in the period of 2010-2020.
In addition, dependent variables are resource-seeking, market-seeking,
efficiency-seeking, and strategic asset-seeking strategy. Data of dependent
variables will obtain through Vietnam legislative sources (GOS and MPI)
combining with the worldwide database such as OECD, The World Bank,
UNCTAD, Trading Economics. The mix between different groups of data set
brings a widen view about the switch of FDI flows into Vietnam, then, predicting
35
future scenarios for the Vietnam economy. The specific contents of each factor
took into account as below:
+ To test the relationship of a locational factor with the resource-seeking
strategies, the production and distribution resources such as electricity, water,
and factors applied. It presents the available resources of the oil industry in
Vietnam. The exploring mineral resources estimated in the number of project
developments, registered capital, and implemental capital for the public
government databases.
+ In terms of market-seeking elements, the variable is the growth rate and capital
of GDP, aiming to highlight the effectiveness of domestic economic performance
in the five years’ periods. GDP per capita, government debt to GDP, and fiscal
expenditure represent the local market scale in Vietnam and the efficiency in
trading activities of Vietnam with other nations. A high growth rate and a fast
developing market will attract more and more foreign investors.
+ Variable of efficiency-seeking method related to labor factors. The ratio of
skilled workforces is used to scale of educational and quality of current human
resources of Vietnam (Pham, 2002). Moreover, the average salary also included
estimating the labour expenses. The effectiveness of working capacity measured
by the earning per labour.
+ Strategic asset-seeking strategy innovation applied the technical factors. This
variable shows the stage of the invention of Vietnam. The variable scales based
on the number of authors and articles participating in scientific and humanities
researches in Vietnam.
3.5 Data analyst The effective data analyst will support to create reliability outcomes and support
for proving the hypothesis, therefore, the role of data collection is extremely
important (Bromley, 1986). In the scale of the research, the data analysis aims to
test the positive relationship between the dependent and independent variables
to approve the research topic. The data analysis method follows the concept of
36
Creswell (2003) about the univariate analysis. Particularly, the practice of
univariate analyst to prove the relationship between individual variables such as
the locational factors and the four factors. In which, these variables will compare
through the growth rate year over year.
The study will apply the univariate analysis to statistical analyst the hypothesis
with the calculation of Weighted Mean, Standard Deviation, Covariance, and
Correlation to test the relationship between variables. In the statistical theory, the
covariance test presents for the positive or negative covariance between two
factors. In addition, the correlation reflects the strength of the relationship
between variables.
After that, the Excel analysis utilized to run the analyst test based on the
formula below:
⮚ Standard deviation: ¿√❑
⮚ Variance: ❑2 ¿∑❑
❑
(x i – μ )❑
❑
⮚ Covariance: Cov (x , y )=∑❑
❑
(x i – x )∗( yi – y )❑
⮚ Correlation coefficient:
r=n∑
❑
❑
xy−∑❑
❑
x∑❑
❑
y
❑
3.6 Ethical issues The research used public online data from statistical global organizations and
Vietnam government official websites; it requires the legal permission to use the
databases. By the way, data authors need to recognise in the reference list. If the
required data source is not available, the form of permission request needs to
submit the data author for access and use. The secondary data conduct to serve
37
for the purpose of the research and must protect from anonymous access, loss,
or destruction (Tripathy, 2013). The data collection support to keep in encrypted
files in computers. The researcher also needs to ensure the secondary data are
appropriate and match with the topic area.
3.7 Limitation The selection of the deductive approach and secondary data sources causes of
reflection of the biases for the research such as the absence of new information.
Utilisation of quantitative data limited the accessibility to enter non-numerous
data and create challenges to acknowledge to the content of a phenomenon.
Moreover, the application of secondary data from different sources may cause
conflicts in the covariance between factors and the author has no power to test
the legitimacy of data. The original database did not conduct for the research
topic; therefore, the combination of different data sources may not logical and not
strong enough to investigate the topic issues. Therefore, the documents may lack
authenticity and not representative of the entire population. The future researcher
should include a qualitative method combining with primary data to present more
convincible results.
38
Chapter 4 : Data
4.1. trading activities countries
4.1.1 Inflow trade According to table 1, the import level of the United States takes lead the market
in terms of average value, following by China with 324.7 billion US dollars and
222.7 billion US dollars for the period of 2010-2020, respectively (World Bank,
2020). Korea is the nation presented the least imported goods or services with
10.7 billion US Dollar. Moreover, the United States and China also the top of
sampling units in the scale of a wide range. Particularly, the range of the United
States was 258.7 billion US dollars while China performed 139.2 billion US
dollars. It presented the leading role of America in the global trading economy. In
the scale of Vietnam, the nation presented the effective import value with 11.9
billion US Dollar from 2010 to 2020.
Table 1: Descriptive statistics of FDI net inflows in period of 2010-2020.
Source: World Bank (2020) and Trading Economics (2020).
4.1.1 Outflow trade In table 2, even China achieved a really good performance in exporting activities
with 112.8 billion US Dollars on average, only equal one-third of exporting goods
and services of the US in a total period of 2010-2020 (World Bank, 2020). The
United States' position was nearly incompatible with the average export of 293.7
39
billion US dollars. It reflected the stronger competitive advantages of the United
States in the trade war with China by the trading value. BBC (2020) claimed that
America attempted to boost power to maximise its global power in front of China.
Table 2: Descriptive statistics of FDI net outflow in period of 2010-2020 .
Source: World Bank (2020) and Trading Economics (2020).
40
Chapter 5 . Results
5.1. The relationship between locational factors with the international production theory
5.1.1 Resource seeking strategiesFrom the result of table 3, it is clear to see the strong relationship between the
FDI inflows created a positive impact on the performance of resource-seeking
planning. In which, the correlation between the FDI inflows and the resource
factors achieved 0.75 and 0.72 in terms of total projects and registered capital,
respectively. It reflected the effective in mobilization locational factors for
resource production schemes.
FDI net
inflows
Total resource
projects
Accumulated
register capital
FDI net inflows 1 FDI net inflows
Total resource
projects0.752 1
Total resource
projects
Accumulated
register capital0.720 0.960 1
Accumulated
register capital
Table 3: Correlation of FDI and resource-seeking strategies. Source:
author’s calculation
5.1.2 Market seeking elementsThe flow of FDI into the Vietnam business market was in the same line with the
growth of GDP per capita, government debt to GDP, and fiscal expenditure with
a correlation of 0.59 and 0.65 and 0.56. in which, the connection between FDI
inflows and the fiscal expenditure showed the part of FDI used for social benefits
such as unemployment, retirement plan, etc. of the government to a citizen due
to the pandemic.
FDI net
inflows
GDP per
capita
Government debt to
GDP
Fistal
expendire
41
FDI net inflows 1
GDP per capita 0.594 1
Government debt to
GDP 0.658 0.893 1
Fiscal expenditure 0.568 0.997 0.892 1
Table 4: Correlation of FDI inflows and market-seeking strategies. Souce:
Worldbank, (2020)
5.1.3 Efficiency seeking strategy.The outcome of the impact of the locational element on the efficiency-seeking
strategy did not really strong even there was a positive correlation between these
factors. It presented in the correlation with the average income of skilled labor.
The faster rise of average salary than the flow of FDI could be the main reason
for the medium strength of the relationship between the two variables.
FDI net
inflows
Skilled
employees
Average income
(USD/ year)
Working capacity
(VND/ labours)
FDI net inflows 1
Skilled employees 0.508 1
Average income (USD/
year) 0.522 0.998 1
Working capacity (VND/
labours) 0.556 0.966 0.970 1
Table 5: Correlation of FDI inflows and Efficiency -seeking strategies.
Source: Molisa (2020)
5.1.4 Strategic asset-seeking strategyThere was a weak relationship in the linkage of locational factors on the strategic
asset-seeking tactics through a number of authors and articles for social science
researches. The input of FDI in Vietnam does not courage the new innovational
creation in term of technical factors.
FDI net inflows No of researchers No of articles
42
FDI net inflows 1
No of researchers 0.359 1
No of articles 0.386 0.997 1
Table 6: Correlation of FDI inflows and Strategic -seeking strategies.
Source: Ho et al., (2020)
43
Chapter 6 . Findings, Analysis and Discussion
6.1 Vietnam’s trade performance
6.1.1 Vietnam becomes attractive place for relocation factoryFrom table 1 and 2, it described the main trading activities including import and
export between Vietnam and the main partners. The presented the role of China
and the United State in Vietnam’s economy. While China is the biggest supplier,
the United States' performance as the largest export market for Vietnam.
Specifically, the imported good of China to Vietnam increased triple times in the
beginning period of 2010 at $20 billion USD and estimated to reach $75 billion
USD at the end of 2020. Japan and Korea will geographic advantages with short
distance following with around $18 billion USD to $20 billion USD in both trading
activities in recent years.
From the point of view, Vietnam presented the surplus trade with America and
the extra deficit with China. Since the US increased tariffs to hence the
international business of China, a wide range of Chinese firms were losing
market share with other Southeast Asia nations such as Vietnam. In the study of
Vu and Nguyen (2019), the authors believed that the pandemics and trade war
could bring multiple benefits and threatens to Vietnam by the switch of the
production line from China such as Samsung (Korea), Apple, and Nike
(America), Daikin (Japan), etc. For instance, Nike is the typical case for the
benefit of manufacturing relocation. Regarding to the article of Intouch Quality
(2019), the global footwear chain decided to move its production chain to
Vietnam since 2010 with 37 percent, taking over the China-based factories with
34 percent in market shares. In 2018, the gap between the two factoring nations
has been extended with over 21% by the increasing to 47 percent and reducing
to 26 percent for the Vietnamese and Chinese manufactories, respectively.
Firstly, the Vietnam economy takes advantage of the trend of the relocation of
factories to other Southeast nations (Tien and Anh, 2019). Based on the
44
research of Asian Development Bank from Vietnam Briefing (2020), Vietnam is
the top nations in Southeast Asia achieved the highest positive growth rate in
GDP with 4.8% while the other nations decreased such as Thailand (-4.8%),
Singapore (0.2%) and Malaysia (0.5%) in 2020. In the past 20 years, the growth
rate of Vietnam always remained over 5%, presenting the young and fast-
developing economy. It showed that even the international business faced with a
new crisis, the demand for trade in Vietnam will be continuous growth. Moreover,
the increasing wage in the basic salary of China increased the product cost
which is one of the main reasons for the relocation of international companies in
this nation (Vina Capital, 2018).
By the way, Vietnam caught the attention of investors with attractive offers to the
relocation of manufactories. Vietnam with stable policy and government
management creates a safe and sound business environment. Additionally, the
labor cost in Vietnam is still cheap with a high knowledge level. Another attractive
factor includes the geographic location next to China and the South Pacific,
convinced for companies to transfer machines and production lines to Vietnam
as well as export goods to other nations through seaports. The investment policy
of Vietnam offers a different range of discounts such as free tariff for Corporate
Income Tax in the first 4 years of investment for industrial zones and other tax
discounts with relaxing investment schemes. While the Chinese government set
restraining rules for investors in manufacturing, electronics, and supplements
OECD, (2019). With all of the reasons, there is no doubt that Vietnam creates an
ideal atmosphere for a sustainable business raise.
Regarding import operation, China leads the market over the last decade with 3
times since 2010 (figure 7). In the study of Chowdhury and Mavrotas (2006), the
inflow of FDI presented for the flow of FDI injecting into a country, which foreign
firms undertaking direct investment in the host country. In terms of the
investment amount, China ranked 7th in the top nations for new FDI registered
capital. China enterprises contributed over 3,000 accumulated projects in
Vietnam with the total charter capital at $21 billion US Dollar, approximating
45
about 5% in the total FDI capital. It followed the study of Zhang and Corrie (2018)
about the strategic management of China to invest in developing nations in the
2000s. Even it is a good sign to gain more foreign capital from China into
Vietnam market, it remains a high probability of anti-Chinese products due to the
bad reputation of China in term of product qualities (Vina Capital, 2018).
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 Est 2020
$0
$10,000,000,000
$20,000,000,000
$30,000,000,000
$40,000,000,000
$50,000,000,000
$60,000,000,000
$70,000,000,000
$80,000,000,000
Import value
China Japan Korea USA
Figure 7: import of Vietnam with main countries between 2010 and 2020.
Sourrce: UN trade and Vietnam Custom (2020).
6.1.2 The risk of Vietnam during the trade warThe export goods to the United States expected to reach $62 billion USD,
becoming the leader in the export partner of Vietnam with a surplus of $48 billion
USD in 2020 (figure 9). China ranked in the second rank with $41 billion USD in
expecting export value in 2020. Vietnam’s exports to China grew by 0.3 percent
over the same period. It can be seen that the increase in Vietnam’s exports to
China is much lower than the increase in Vietnam’s exports to the United States.
Moreover, due to the trade war between the two gain economies, Vietnam with
trade reliability with the two countries deals with a wide range of issues including
the risk of direct competition with China and transiting of Chinese products to the
US market.
46
Moreover, in the table (Figure 8), UNCTAD (2020) highlighted that the
developing nations replying on automatic precision, technology, and technical
factories. In which, Vietnam with the industrialist strategy is at the top of the
impacted economy by the global pandemic with $2.3 billion USD, listed as the
fifth of most trading damage (UNTAD, 2020). China presented as the biggest
manufacturing center of the world, therefore, shut down production disturbs the
regional and global supply chain and created a hard time for depending countries
to find replaceable methods. Currently, the second wave of the disease has
nearby passed and most nations resume the international flight routes. For
example, Vietnam reopened international commercial flights since 15th
September. It encouraged the country to attract foreign tourists and investors to
support for recover economy. Moreover, it benefited from the swift waves to
developing nations.
Europe
an U
nition
United
Stat
esJa
panKore
a
Vietna
m
Singap
ore
United
King
dom
Mexico
Switzerl
and
Malays
ia
Thaila
nd
Canad
a
Turkey
India
Indon
esia
-
5,000
10,000
15,000
20,000 million USD
Figure 8: Trade impact of the Coronavirus epidemic until 2020. Source: UNTAD,
2020.
● In term of export goods to China
47
The first challenge is the increased export of China to Vietnam, leading to a trade
deficit that threatens local business firms attracting customers. China still
remains the competitive advantage by advanced technologies and infrastructure
which could support international firms to outsourcing their products easily. While
Vietnam is a developing nation with under completing infrastructures and
economies, which concern investors to enter the market. The other limitation
related to the US tariff on Chinese products will be switch to import of other
nations such as Vietnam to share the tax cost. Lastly, the biggest issue deal with
goods that could not export to the United States will domestically consume in
China, narrowed the export market for Vietnam. It explained the dropped of 0.43
billion USD in export value to China market.
Moreover, there is another apprehension about Vietnam to become the yard of
China in order to transfer its product to another market for tariff deduction. The
concern is that Vietnam may be turned into China's ‘backyard’, which may result
in adverse consequences. By ‘exporting’ models such as cross-border economic
cooperation zones, Chinese businesses may seek to move out obsolete
technologies from their countries to reduce pollution. Thus, it will be difficult for
Vietnam to avoid receiving outdated technologies from China. The Vinh Tan coal-
fired power plants in Binh Thuan province and Formosa steel mills in Ha Tinh
province are such examples. Furthermore, by being seen as China’s backyard,
Vietnam runs the risks of being subject to more punitive US measures in the
future.
● Export to the United States
The most trouble to Vietnam is becoming a convenient transit platform for
Chinese products to avoid the high tariffs of the States on China (Washington
Post, 2018). The idea supported by the research of Paszak (2020) by the case
study of China’s steel elated into Vietnam and labeled as Vietnamese products
before shifting to the United States. The report of Vietnam Insider (2019) pointed
48
out that Vietnam’s steel industry got pressure by a maximum of 400 percent of
the tax charge on the cold-rolled product to America.
However, the technological product is mostly heavy and difficult for
transportation, which could limit the illegal transport to Vietnam in order to defend
the high tariffs of the United States. Moreover, America kept tracking the transit
product of China to other nations to prevent illegally imported items. From the
point of Vietnam, the nation may suffer from the raise tariff of the United States
but it has improved the business environment, attracting more and more US
enterprises for FDI projects. Not only the US, but the other developed nations
from Europe and the United Kingdom also showed their interests in Vietnam after
shifting away from China. For example, Vietnam has joined EVFTA in 2019,
which offered new trading opportunities with the global market, reduce reliance
on the United States during the sensitive timing. Moreover, the US government
promoted the campaign to defend the trade deficit with Vietnam, regarding
encourage Vietnam to import the United State goods and solving market entry
barriers such as tariffs, custom policies, geophysical distances, etc.
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 Est 2020
$0
$10,000,000,000
$20,000,000,000
$30,000,000,000
$40,000,000,000
$50,000,000,000
$60,000,000,000
$70,000,000,000
Export value
China Japan Korea USA
Figure 9: export of Vietnam with main countries between 2010 and 2020.
Source: UN trade and Vietnam Custom (2020).
49
6.1.3 Main trade categories of Vietnam to China and America
● Main export items to China
The main export product to China included electronic equipment such as
computers and phones with a value of $5.4 and $3.7 billion USD, up 36% and
50% year over year in 2020 (figure 2). With the fast growth rate in exporting,
Vietnam factories replaced the role of manufactories of China in producing
basic materials and basic compositions for manufactories in China. However,
these types of products easily processed and could easily replace by other
nations with cheaper labour costs and more attractive tariff policy. In addition,
China with gain international supply chain networks, and a professional
management system supported the nation to compete with other Asian nations
such as Vietnam. In the near future, the export market of Vietnam will be
narrow and threaten by the expansion of China, mostly in textile fibers and
electronic industries.
● Main export items to the United States
The main export items to America including textile fibers (20%), computer
(14%) and phones (19%), machinery (9%), wood products (8%), vegetables
(3%), and seafood (2%) for the first haft 2020 (figure 10). Regarding the figure
3, the export situation of textile fibers to the United States reached over $6
billion USD in the first haft of 2020, dropping 12% compared with 2019 (figure
11). While, the following most export categories belonging to technological
products such as computers and phones with nearly $4.5 billion USD and $4
billion USD, respectively. The import of computers and phones in the United
States increased impressively at 190% and 5.2%, respectively. In addition,
there is also a significant surge of machinery with $2.9 billion USD, up 73%
YoY. The increase in technological products and machinery supply, which was
the key export goods of China previously, suddenly becoming the main export
products of Vietnam. It leads to the concern for the US government about the
ability of Vietnam to increase the level of inventory in a short period.
50
China United State$0.00
$1.00
$2.00
$3.00
$4.00
$5.00
$6.00
$7.00
Textile fibers Computers and equiqments Phones and equiqments Machinery Wood products Vegetables Seafoods
Figure 10: trading categories between Vietnam and China, United State between
2010 and 2020. Source: UN trade and Vietnam Custom (2020).
Figure 11: growth rate of main export categories between Vietnam and China,
United State in 2010 - 2020. Source: UN trade and Vietnam Custom (2020).
Vietnam beneficiated from the war trade between the US and China; therefore,
the Chinese products which charged high tariff in US could be factored and
51
consumed in Vietnam (Ha and Phuc, 2019). By the way, Vietnam is able to
export the surplus products to the United States, obtaining the remaining market
share of China in the United State. Moreover, the demand for production leads to
FDI attraction, job requirements, and gain GDP for the host countries.
6.1.4 Main majors impacted by the CovidRegarding figure 12, the Vietnam economy based on the agricultural and
industrial major with a large portion of the total GDP. By the way, Vietnam
applied technological innovation from developed nations such as Taiwan,
Singapore, Korean to increasing the ration of industry and reducing agricultural
major (ILO, 2018). By the way, Vietnam could set the strategic plan on export-
oriented sectors. The content below delivered the performances of three main
sectors influencing them in term of the FDI.
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 20200
20
40
60
80
100
120
43.44 36.94 36.73 37.27 38.74 39.04 39.73 40.92 41.26 41.12 41.64
37.3932.13 32.24 33.56 33.19 33.21 33.25 33.72 33.4 34.23 34.49
19.17
18.38 19.57 19.22 17.96 17.7 16.99 16.32 15.34 14.68 13.96
Agriculture, forestry and fishing Industry (including construction) Services
Figure 12: Contribution to GDP by industry in Vietnam. Source: Statista,
2020.
● Services
Regarding figure 11, The service industry used to take a big part of the economic
growth in Vietnam with over 14% - 19% in total GDP in the period of 2010 to
2019. During the period, Vietnam tourism is one of the most attractive investment
52
sectors for foreign investors. For example, the Swiss-Belhotel International chain
has planned to establish at least 10 high-end hotels; Centrara Hotels and
Resorts planned to open 20 new hotels in Vietnam (Cong Thuong News, 2019).
However, the accumulated projects only 880 projects with over $12 billion USD
in the total registered investment to May 2020 (FIA, 2020). In addition, the
pandemic has frozen the demand for service major including hospitality,
transportation, tourism, causing the drop-off service major at 13% in 2020
(Statista, 2020). In which, tourism is one of the service industries suffered the
most by a comprehensive crisis. During the pandemic, the Vietnam government
practiced quarantine society campaigns including restrictions of festivals and a
crowded group of people, no travel events. It directly damaged the tourism
industry with a negative growth rate of -98.2% for the international tourists in the
first 4 months of 2020 (Vietnam Tourism department, 2020). Since Vietnam
handles the second wave of the pandemic, the gate for international travelers still
closed. The total number of international tourists to Vietnam in 2020 will
decrease by about -90% year over year with a total of only 3.7 million arrivals
(ACB, 2020).
From the future predication, 50 million to 1.1 billion fewer international tourist
arrivals US$ 910 billion to US$ 1.2 trillion loss in export revenues from tourism
100 to 120 million direct tourism jobs at risk as shown in figure 13 One of the
typical cases got affected the Covid-19 pandemic was Thailand. The nation lost
nearly 40 million tourists annually. Through encourage tourism and exports, the
Thai currency improved its strength against US dollars, however, tourists to
Thailand decreases due to the expensive cost and effected of the Covid-19
pandemic.
53
Figure 13: International tourist trend and scenarios for 2020. Source: UNWTO,
2020.
● Industry
Among the investment sectors, the industry attracted the most number of
projects and total registered investment with over 14,700 accumulated projected
and $220 billion USD in 2020, which is much higher the hospitality and
agriculture, forestry, and fishing industries (Figure 13). In the study of Minh et al.
(2020), FDI investment concentrated in the fast return majors, quick capital
recovery, simple production process, therefore, the industrial business attracted
for manufacturing basic materials for the initial steps of technological production.
Moreover, the government concentrated on attracting FDI for the industrial and
constructing majors. Therefore, the industrial investment has more promotions,
free tariffs, and another discount to boost foreign investment.
● Agriculture, forestry and fishing
The agricultural sectors got less FDI investment than the others. In which, the
accumulated registered projects were at 503 with the accumulated investment at
3.5 billion in 2020 (figure 14). Due to the government policy, the sector predicted
to lose its portion in the GDP and replaced by the industrial majors. It was a part
54
of industrialization, which is the process of increasing the share of industry in all
economic sectors of an economic region or economy (Tuan, 2006).
Industry hospitality Agriculture, forestry and fishing
0
2000
4000
6000
8000
10000
12000
14000
16000
-
50,000
100,000
150,000
200,000
250,000
No. of projects Total registered investment (mil USD)
Figure 14: Accumulated registered projects and total registered investment by
sectors to May 2020. Source FIA, 2020.
6.2. Application of Dunning International Theory in Vietnam
6.2.1 Resource-seeking strategiesThe research of UNTAD (2020) emphasized that the energy level of the world will
drop -55% in 2020 (Figure 15). It results from the drop in the export level relating
to the down in energy demand and commodity prices in various developing
nations export. In the first hypothesis, the locational element contributed to the
resource-seeking strategy with a strong impact on the flow of FDI to Vietnam,
resulting in a correlation level at 0.7, which was highly involved. This locational
factor involved with the available resource of a nation, which could support it to
attract investment. The abundance of natural resources has a strong impact on
the level of foreign investment in terms of developing countries like Vietnam in
the International theory. It supported the nation to stand out the market since the
other more developed nations in terms of resource price. For example, some
type of resources in developed nations such as China and America offered a
55
higher price than Vietnam due to the currency value, which results in less
attractive in terms of investment. It against the results of Deng (2003) about the
influence of national resources in the FDI inflow. The conflict between the two
results came from the indicates to measure the resource impact. Particularly, the
research of Deng (2003) concentrated on the natural agricultural resources while
the exploration took into account the factor of water, electricity, and mineral
resources to represent the natural supply of a specified nation. By the way, Deng
(2003) extracted the water, electricity, and mineral resources into the contribution
of ordinary supplements. Besides, the author applied the dataset for the variable
in the context of the sum of FDI inflows connecting with the basic salary. It also
contributed to the gap between the two results. To sum up, the outcomes of the
hypothesis satisfied the need for the International Development theory in the
Vietnam market. resource exploitation played a vital role in attracting FDI
investment in developing nations like Vietnam. Through promoting the domestic
resource and followed the resource-based view model, Vietnam will be able to
maximize its competitive advantages.
2017 2018 2029 2020
-60-50-40-30-20-10
0102030
%
Figure 15: Annual growth rate of energy sector of the world, 2017–2020. Source:
UNTAD, 2020.
56
6.2.2 Market seeking elementsThe flow of FDI into the Vietnam business market was in the same line with the
growth of GDP per capita, government debt to GDP, and fiscal expenditure with
a correlation of 0.59 and 0.65 and 0.56. in which, the connection between FDI
inflows and the fiscal expenditure showed the part of FDI used for social benefits
such as unemployment, retirement plan, etc. of the government to a citizen due
to the pandemic.
The other hypothesis about the key element could attract FDI injections to
Vietnam including the market-seeking strategy. The specified local conditions
involved with the market seeking process consisted of the scale of this study
such as the growth of GDP per capita, government debt to GDP, and fiscal
expenditure of a country. GDP per capita is found to have an average strength
connecting with the FDI inflows, Government debt to GDP presented to have a
more positive effect on foreign investment level, and the fiscal expenditure has a
similar correlation with the growth of FDI inputs. There is a positive effect of 0.66
and 0.57 for Government debt to GDP and fiscal expenditure, respectively. It
matched with the previous study’s outcomes of Root (1994), who agreed in a
combination of the market seeking effect including the GDP per capita relating to
the labour cost, government debts, and fiscal expenditure relating to the stability
of a market to invest. However, the outcomes of the study presented the effect
contributing to the domestic factors which could affect the FDI attraction. The
domestic market size of Vietnam presented through the performance of GDP per
capita has a small effect on attracting FDI stocks. The reason came from the
developing nation as Vietnam tending to reply to the resources of the developed
nations nearby such as China, Thailand, etc. due to the limited capacity in self-
production and lack of technology. The report of Vu and Nguyen (2019)
reinforced that Vietnam replied on other nations to perform trade business and
compulsory to remain a vulnerable gateway for exchanging business. It has
proved by the trade deficit of Vietnam with Chinese import products. However,
Vietnam potentially attracted the multinational entities with a target regional
market segment to sustain growth in the business for a long-term vision.
57
Moreover, the research of Tien and Anh (2019) added that the small economies
have better presentation than the fully developed nations in the interchange
acceleration. It against the study of the concept of the IDP theory with the idea
that the weak economy lacked the capacity to encourage FDI without considering
the seeking resource strategies by Dunning in 1998. Especially, the less
developed nations such as Vietnam could be able to impress the well-developed
nations through the strong growth of the export level. In addition, the FDI aligned
with increasing levels of government debt and fiscal expenditure when the local
government needs to spend more to invest in the public infrastructure,
transportation, and education to attract qualified foreign companies. In
conclusion, hypothesis two accepted the results. There was a positive
relationship with the market-seeking strategies on the improvement of FDI entries
in Vietnam. The outcomes reflected the locational indicators bridging with the
seeking market strategies of the added FDI to Vietnam. The small economies
attracted the investors from the high level of export, which was a lack in the
developed nations (Davies and Green, 2013).
6.2.3 Efficiency-seeking strategy.The outcome of the impact of the locational element on the efficiency-seeking
strategy did not really strong even there was a positive correlation between these
factors. It presented in the correlation with the average income of skilled labor.
The faster rise of average salary than the flow of FDI could be the main reason
for the medium strength of the relationship between the two variables.
Hypothesis three specified that locational elements complicated with the seeking
strategies could get a huge amount of FDI capital. In terms of efficiency-seeking
tactics, the main components consisted of skilled employees, average income
(USD/ year), working capacity (VND/ labours) in the Vietnam region. The paper
emphasized the role of experienced employees in the line with the average
income and working capacity to review the effectiveness of human resources in
the production line. It resulted a positive relationship between the efficiency-
seeking component of the FDI performance. Groh and Wich, (2012) sustained
58
that the quality of human resources and stability of the financial market take an
irreplaceable role in terms of attracting inward FDI. To sum up, the third
hypothesis reviewed the optimistic connection between variables, plus, the
specified localization elements created a strong link with the efficiency of FDI
seeking strategies, potentially encourage the FDI level. Especially, the working
performance of the labour and the salary were one of the attractiveness for
foreign investors.
Besides, Letto-Gillies (2007) found that seeking efficiency strategy and the
expanded revenue could process through the achievement of international
business implementation. In which, the practical framework of both licensing and
direct production brings a competitive advantage for the firm. In the case of
investment license, the Vietnam government offered different cases to custom
the market entry requirement for investors depending on business criteria. By
achieving the investment license, the investors could qualify for the corporate
income tax (CIT) and encouraged location in the hi-tech parks, industrial parks,
or specific economic zones. In case of huge factoring projects, the incentive
portfolio can be extended up to 15 years if the business achieves the global
competitive advantage with the sum of profit over 20 trillion VND annually within
five years from the year of recorded revenue.
6.2.4 Strategic asset-seeking.The last hypothesis related to the asset-seeking strategies by the performance of
innovation factors to attract FDI as much as possible. The correlation between
variables achieved a weak relationship with an average of 0.36. The locational
element represented for the innovational stage of Vietnam. The outcome clearly
disagreed about the role of strategic asset-seeking with the creational activities,
which could not interest FDI inflows. It showed the lack of evidence about the link
between the innovation such as the scientific articles in Vietnam and the FDI
inputs. Therefore, the implementation of innovational researches was not able to
take into account due to the lack of impact on the level of FDI inflows. The results
agreed by the study of Tri and Anh (2016) about the absence of a core
59
relationship between the impact of innovation on the FDI performance in the case
of Vietnam.
However, the study of Galan et al., (2007) contracted with the result about the
absent evidence of the innovational impact on the foreign funds. The author
clarified that setting an effective market entry model requiring the combination of
the other factors with the operation of asset-seeking strategy to make investment
judgment. However, the sampling size of the research conducted from a
developed country, which may cause a conflict between results since there is a
lack of database about the innovational performance in terms of developing
nations. In fact, the FDI into developing countries mostly paid attention to the
local resources such as various tax discounts and cheap labour to reduce the
production cost, then applying home country’s innovation for the automatic
production line in host countries.
In conclusion, the report described the key elements, which the nation could use
to sustain the locational advantages. Besides, a small nation as Vietnam easily
improved the level of foreign capital by applying policies to promote a wealthy
business environment, educational level of labours, investment in innovational
works.
60
Chapter 7 : ConclusionsIn general, firms in developed nations have less development market and high
competition, tends to look for an emerging market with fast growth development
and fewer rivals. It explained by the study of Kim (2005) about the “blue ocean”
theory. In addition, by the capital fund from FDI activities, the local government
could improve technological application and human resource quality. At the same
time, foreign countries could use the locational advantage for business
operations such as cheap labour costs, natural resources, tax promotion, etc.
Therefore, the practice of FDI attraction is the key growth for both foreign and
domestic markets to achieve impressive growth in sustainable development.
Besides, the China-US trade war motivated the multinational firms to switch their
production line to other Asian nations to avoid the tax penalty from Trump’s
government. Plus, the COVID 19 disease highly potential started from China
created unpredictable chaos for the global financial market and hypothetically led
to a new crisis for the global financial business. The lock-down measures spread
out the world and direct harm economic implementation, forcing businesses to
find a new strategy to cut costs and seek new supply sources (Brinca et al.,
2020). It is no doubt that China lost its locational advantages to other nations.
Therefore, Vietnam benefited from the trade war and pandemic with similar
economic conditions as China such as cheap labour cost, stable political
conditions, rich resources, etc., creating a suitable environment to move the
capital from China. Since then, the research has highlighted the main features of
global trade under the difficult period from the pandemic and trade dispute. After
that, the Dunning’s international theory concept has practiced clarifying the main
locational advantages of Vietnam to attract the new shifting FDI from China.
7.1 Impact of the trade war and the pandemic on FDI inflowsIn terms of historical FDI flows, Vietnam presented impressive growth from the
fiscal policies and an open economy for investment to promote foreign capital.
Especially, the nation benefited from the shift of production line from China with
similar economic and political conditions. However, the lobby fee and unclear
61
legal system created concerns for foreign investors. On the other hand, China is
the leader in FDI attraction with a vast systematic business network across the
world and completely developed infrastructure and supported services.
Correspondingly, China also needed to deal with government corruption and
other related issues.
The world has faced the two big financial crises in the past including the Great
depression in 1993 and the financial crisis in 2008, which took the global
economy a long time to recover. Currently, there was a potential economy
dispute from the expansion of Covid19 disease and the trade war between the
two biggest economies including the United States and China. In which, China
has been locked down due to the Covid19 pandemic for a certain period and the
tariff penalty from the US, causing the waves of moving FDI to other nearby
nations with similar business environments. On the other hand, Vietnam with a
well-prepared scheme to hence the spread of the disease in the beginning stage
and attracted FDI strategies, delightful advantage from the shift of FDI flows from
China. However, it presented the extraordinary possibility of Vietnam turn to a
transit station for Chinese goods shipping the United States. However, Vietnam
replied on the supply resource from China, creating difficulties for the
government to slap on transferring Chinese products to Vietnam. In addition, the
four main nations injected capital into Vietnam including Korea, Japan, China,
and the United States. It is a must for the political leaders to remain the peaceful
relationship with the big nations without offensive both sides.
7.2 Dunning’s theories The research overview undertook from various available articles from
Vietnamese and foreign scholars in order to show the principle concept of
Dunning’s theory of foreign investment. It provided the different approaches of
the FDI with the purpose of the foreign and host nations in the role of FDI as well
as the advantages and disadvantages of each method. Among different FDI
theories and models, the Dunning OLI framework and Dunning International
Production theory can be considered as the most suitable and modern for the
62
Vietnam case. In which, the International Production theory has provided a clear
view of the application of FDI in a macro perception. Particularly, through the
literature review, the research listed the previous studies about the main features
of the two concepts. In the OLI model, the three sub-paradise including
ownership, location, and internationalism (Eden and Dai, 2010). Depending on
the stage of development, the nation required push factors such as ownership
and internationalism, or pull factors such as locational elements. After conduction
of previous researches, the paper has chosen locational elements in the OLI
model to Vietnam. The reason for the international firms chose FDI rather than
other alternative development paths relating to the internalization of production.
The research found out that the production location could support the firms to
localise their products and dominated the foreign market with a realistic market-
entry strategy. Regarding the International Production theory, the paper pointed
out the decision making process of the foreign firms to select the suitable
investment market through resources, market, efficiency, and asset seeking
strategies (Dunning, 1998). The combination of these factors is the key
motivation for firms to set up foreign subsidiaries.
In addition, the target of the research is to test the International Production
framework during the COVID 19 pandemic and trade war. It presented that there
was a lack of literature about the International Production theory and locational
strategies in Vietnam during economic disputes. It has processed the forecast of
the correlation between locational elements and the International Production
framework to select significant factors affecting FDI performance. The research
has conducted data from the local and international published databases
including GSO, UNTAD, the World Bank, etc. to scale the connection between
location-specific factors and the development process. It concluded that
resource-seeking, market-seeking, and efficiency-seeking play are in the light of
the FDI attraction and benefited for Vietnam economy. The predication for the
International Production element involving with strategic asset-seeking is not
included with the purpose of the research.
63
7.3 RecommendationThe research has investigated both internal and external factors, which
contented the possibility to impact on the level of FDI inputs. However, there are
some of the perspectives to discuss further in future studies. Particularly, the next
paper should review the sampling size before starting a conduction to ensure a
similar set of databases in line with the topic areas for the most accurate results.
Moreover, the other researches should examine the national growth by the
increase in sample size or innovating new approaches such as comparing
different timing stages of a nation to review the change before and after the
Covid19 pandemic. In addition, the International Production theory may deeply
investigate by breaking into various stages with specific FDI inflow and outflows
from certain nations. It might also be interesting to focus on identifying how
different forms of resource richness influence the growth of inward FDI stocks.
With the stress-out of the relationship between the US and China, foreign
investors tent to find a new promised market with stable financial and political
status as Vietnam. However, the high corruption level with the completed legal
systems threatens the investment to enter the market. Therefore, Vietnam needs
to clear out the legal frameworks for Investment Law and related Law and
clarified the corporate governance systems. In specific, the nation needed to
restructure the investment structure to defend bureaucracy and boosted
investment process. Moreover, the competition also came from the other nearby
emerging markets with similar economic conditions such as Indonesia, Laos,
Cambodia, etc. Therefore, improving investment in high tech zone and industrial
zone gains the technological application level, which will help Vietnam to stand
out with other developing nations.
Word count: 14,526.
64
Chapter 8 : Reference- Ali, S., & Guo, W. (2005). Determinants of FDI in China. Journal of global
business and technology, 1(2), 21-33.
- Brinca, P., Duarte, J. B., & Faria-e-Castro, M. (2020). Measuring Sectoral Supply
and Demand Shocks during COVID-19. FRB St. Louis Working Paper, (2020-
011).
- Bromley, D. B. (1986) The Case-Study Method in Psychology and Related
Disciplines. Chichester: Wiley
- Chen, K. (2018). “The Research on the Insurance Industry’s Tax Burden in China
under the Background of Change from Business Tax to VAT”. Modern Economy,
9(4), 734-749.
- Cortina, J. J., Didier, T., & Schmukler, S. (2018). Corporate Borrowing and Debt
Maturity: The Effects of Market Access and Crises. Centre for Economic Policy
Research.
- Cozby, P.C. (2001). Measurement Concepts. Methods in Behavioral
Research (7th ed.). California: Mayfield Publishing Company.
- Creswell, J. W. (2003). Research Design. In: Qualitative, Quantitative and Mixed
Methods Approaches. London: SAGE Publications Ltd.
- Customsnews (2020). FDI capital still flowing into Ho Chi Minh City. Available at:
https://customsnews.vn/fdi-capital-still-flowing-into-ho-chi-minh-city-
14409.html#:~:text=In%202018%20and%202019%2CHo,the%20same
%20period%20in%202018. [Accessed on 04/10/2020]
65
- Davies, H., & Green, D. (2013). Global financial regulation: The essential guide
(Now with a Revised Introduction). John Wiley & Sons.
- Deng, P. (2003). Foreign Investment by Multinationals from Emerging Countries:
The Case
- Dunning, J. H. (1998). Location and the multinational enterprise: a neglected
factor?. Journal of international business studies, 29(1), 45-66.
- Dunning, John H. (1981), International Production and the Multinational
Enterprise, London: George Allen and Unwin.
- Eden, L., & Dai, L. (2010). Rethinking the O in Dunning’s OLI/eclectic paradigm.
Multinational Business Review.
- Eichengreen, B. (2014). Hall of mirrors: The great depression, the great
recession, and the uses-and misuses-of history. Oxford University Press.
- Financial Times (2019). ““US-China trade war gives Vietnam a winning streak”,
23 June. Avaiable at: https://www.ft.com/content/4bce1f3c-8dda-11e9-a1c1-
51bf8f989972. (Retrieved: 5 June 2020).
- Galan, J. I., Gonzalez-Benito, J., & Zuñiga-Vincente, J. A. (2007). Factors
determining the location decisions of Spanish MNEs: an analysis based on the
investment development path. Journal of International Business Studies, 38(6),
975-997.
- Groh, A. P., & Wich, M. (2012). Emerging economies' attraction of foreign direct
investment. Emerging Markets Review, 13(2), 210-229.
66
- GSO Vietnam (2020). “Preliminary Imports and exports by country group, country
and territory In 2019”. Available at: https://www.gso.gov.vn/default_en.aspx?
tabid=626&idmid=&ItemID=19109. (Retrieved: 30 May 2020).
- Investopedia (2019) “What is an Economic Shock?”, Investopedia, 11 October.
Available at: https://www.investopedia.com/terms/e/economic-shock.asp.
(Retrieved: 5 June 2020).
- Johanson, J., & Vahlne, J. E. (2017). The internationalization process of the firm
—a model of knowledge development and increasing foreign market
commitments. In International business (pp. 145-154). Routledge.
- Jonker, J. and Pennink, B. (2010). A concise Guide for Master and PhD Students
in Managment Science. In: The Essence of Research Methodology. Berlin:
Springer-Verlag.
- Kim, W. C. (2005). Blue ocean strategy: from theory to practice. California
management review, 47(3), 105-121.
- Kothari, C. R. (2004). Research methodology: Methods and techniques. New
Age International.
- KPMG. (2020). “Corporate tax rates table - KPMG Vietnam - KPMG
International”. Avaiable at:https://home.kpmg/xx/en/home/services/tax/tax-tools-
and-resources/tax-rates-online/corporate-tax-rates-table.html. (Retrieved: 30 May
2020).
- Kumar, R. (2019). Research methodology: A step-by-step guide for beginners.
Sage Publications Limited.
67
- Lammers, W. J. (2017). The Investment Development Path: Is It Relevant For
Designing Foreign Direct Investment Policies?.
- Lim, G. (2017). What do Malaysian firms seek in Vietnam?. Journal of Asia-
Pacific Business, 18(2), 131-150.
- Mills, A., & Haines, P. (2015). Essential strategies for financial services
compliance. John Wiley & Sons.
- Nestle Vietnam. (2020). “Sending the best of Nestle Vietnam to the world”.
Available at https://www.nestle.com.vn/sites/g/files/pydnoa216/files/2019-12/IMS-
Brochure-5Mb_0.pdf (Accessed: 29 May 2020).
- Nguyen, A. T. K., & Le, N. H. (2016). Introduction to the Theoretical Framework
of Dunning’s Investment Development Path. VNU Journal of Science: Economics
and Business, 32(5E).
- Nhan Dan News (2020). “Receiving the movement of FDI inflow”. Available at:
https://en.nhandan.org.vn/business/item/8655602-receiving-the-movement-of-fdi-
inflow.html. (Retrieved: 30 May 2020).
- Pak, Y. S. (2002). The effect of strategic motives on the choice of entry modes:
An empirical test of international franchisers. Multinational Business Review,
10(1), 28.
- Paszak, P. (2020). “China-U.S. Trade War: Origins, Course and Consequences”.
Warsaw Institute. Available at: https://warsawinstitute.org/china-u-s-trade-war-
origins-course-and-consequences/. (Retrieved: 30 May 2020).
68
- Peffers, K., Tuunanen, T., Rothenberger, M. A., & Chatterjee, S. (2007). A design
science research methodology for information systems research. Journal of
management information systems, 24(3), 45-77.
- Reuters (2018) “U.S. slaps heavy duties on Chinese steel shipped from
Vietnam?”, Reuter, 22 May. Available at: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-
trade-steel/u-s-slaps-heavy-duties-on-chinese-steel-shipped-from-vietnam-
idUSKCN1IM28C. (Retrieved: 5 June 2020).
- Root, F. R. (1994). Entry strategies for international markets. Jossey-Bass.
- Rugman, A. M. (Ed.). (2002). International Business: Theory of the multinational
enterprise (Vol. 1). Taylor & Francis.
- Samuel, P. (2019). “Vietnam to Increase Minimum Wage from January 2020”.
Vietnam Briefing, 28, November. Avaiable at:
https://www.vietnam-briefing.com/news/vietnam-increase-minimum-wage-
january-2020.html/. (Retrieved: 29 May 2020).
- Saunders, M., Lewis, P., & Thornhill, A. (2012). Research methodologies for
business students.
- The New York Times (2020). “Here Comes the Coronavirus Pandemic – Now,
after many fire drills, the world may be facing a real fire.” The New York Times.
29 February. Available at:
https://www.nytimes.com/2020/02/29/opinion/sunday/corona-virus-usa.html
(Retrieved: 30 May 2020).
69
- The World Factbook (2017). “Country comparison :: stock of direct foreign
investment - at home”. Available at: https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-
world-factbook/rankorder/2198rank.html (Retrieved: 30 May 2020).
- Tien, N. H., & Anh, D. B. H. (2019). Vietnam’s international trade policy in the
context of China-US trade war. International journal of commerce and
management research, 5(3), 92-95.
- Tri, V. T., & Anh, N. D. (2016). Experiences of Vietnam in FDI Promotion: Some
Lessons for Myanmar.
- UNCTAD (2020). Coronavirus outbreak has cost global value chains $50 billion
in exports Avaiable at: https://unctad.org/en/pages/newsdetails.aspx?
OriginalVersionID=2297 (Retrieved: 14 September 2020)
- UNCTAD (2020). The Covid-19 Shock to Developing Countries: Towards a
“whatever it takes” programme for the two-thirds of the world’s population being
left behind. Avaiable at:
https://unctad.org/en/PublicationsLibrary/gds_tdr2019_covid2_en.pdf (Retrieved:
14 September 2020)
- Vietnam Investment Review (2017). Samsung: a journey of initiative and
innovation. Available at: https://www.vir.com.vn/samsung-a-journey-of-initiative-
and-innovation-54925.html. [Accessed from: 20/09/2020].
- VietNamNet News (2020) “Vietnam Enjoys Benefits of Apple Moving AirPods Pro
Manufacturing from China.”, VietNamNet, 27 May. Available
at: vietnamnet.vn/en/sci-tech-environment/vietnam-enjoys-benefits-of-apple-
70
moving-airpods-pro-manufacturing-from-china-643191.html. (Retrieved: 28 May
2020).
- Vu, T. H., & Nguyen, T. L. P. (2019). Changes in Vietnam-China Trade in the
Context of China’s Economic Slowdown: Some Analysis and Implications.
- Washington Post. (2018). “Trump imposes steel and aluminum tariffs on the
E.U., Canada and Mexico”. Available at:
https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/trump-imposes-steel-and-
aluminum-tariffs-on-the-european-union-canada-and-mexico/
2018/05/31/891bb452-64d3-11e8-a69c-b944de66d9e7_story.html. (Retrieved:
30 May 2020).
- Wiggins, R., Piontek, T., & Metrick, A. (2014). The Lehman brothers bankruptcy
a: overview. Yale Program on Financial Stability Case Study.
- Wilson, J. (2014). Essentials of business research: A guide to doing your
research project. Sage.
- World Bank. (2020). The World Bank in Vietnam. Available at:
https://www.worldbank.org/en/country/vietnam. (Retrieved: 24 June 2020)
- World Bank (2020). GDP per capita (current US$) – Vietnam: World Bank
national accounts data, and OECD National Accounts data files. Avaiable from:
https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.PCAP.CD?locations=VN.
(Retrieved: 24 July 2020)
- Zhang, X., & Corrie, B. P. (2018). History of Foreign investment in China. In
Investing in China and Chinese Investment Abroad (pp. 3-12). Springer,
Singapore.
71
- BBC (2020). China's virus-hit economy shrinks for first time in decades. Avaiable
at: https://www.bbc.com/news/business-52319936. (Retrieved: 24 Jyly 2020)
- Vietnam Briefing (2020). Vietnam’s Economy to Grow Fastest in Southeast Asia
Despite COVID-19: ADB. Avaiable at:
https://www.vietnam-briefing.com/news/vietnams-economy-grow-fastest-
southeastasia-despite-covid-19.html/. (Retrieved: 24 July 2020)
- MOLISA (2020). Deputy Minister Doan Mau Diep responded to the press about
the indicators that are causing social attention on labor and employment.
Avaiable at: http://www.molisa.gov.vn/Pages/tintuc/chitiet.aspx?
tintucID=28360#:~:text=T%E1%BB%AB%20c%C6%A1%20s%E1%BB%9F
%20d%E1%BB%AF%20li%E1%BB%87u,2018%20l
%C3%A0%2058%2C60%25. (Retrieved: 24 July 2020).
- VietnamNews (2017). Foreign investment surges 52%. Available at:
https://vietnamnews.vn/economy/380955/foreign-investment-surges-52.html.
(Retrieved: 24 July 2020)
- Ho, M. T., Vuong, T. T., Pham, T. H., Luong, A. P., Nguyen, T. N., & Vuong, Q.
H. (2020). The Internal Capability of Vietnam Social Sciences and Humanities: A
Perspective from the 2008–2019 Dataset. Publications, 8(2), 32.
- Chen, H., Xu, W., Paris, C., Reeson, A., & Li, X. (2020). Social distance and
SARS memory: impact on the public awareness of 2019 novel coronavirus
(COVID-19) outbreak. medRxiv.
72
- MPI, (2020). Report on foreign direct investment in the first 6 months of 2020.
Available at: http://www.mpi.gov.vn/en/Pages/tinbai.aspx?
idTin=47764&idcm=122. (Retrieved: 24 July 2020)
- Statista (2020). Impact on shopping and out-of-home activities due to
coronavirus COVID-19 among urban citizens in Vietnam in 2020. Available at:
https://www.statista.com/statistics/1102863/vietnam-impact-on-shopping-after-
covid-19-outbreak/.(Retrieved: 24 July 2020)
- Statista (2020). Change in consumption expenditure due to coronavirus COVID-
19 outbreak among Vietnamese in 2020 compared to 2019, by sector. Available
at: https://www.statista.com/statistics/1102839/vietnam-consumer-spending-
after-covid-19-by-sector/.(Retrieved: 24 July 2020)
- Trading Economics (2020). Vietnam Foreign Direct Investment. Available at:
https://tradingeconomics.com/vietnam/foreign-direct-investment.(Retrieved: 24
July 2020)
- UN Trade (2020), Total of all HS commodities of Vietnam. Available at:
https://comtrade.un.org/data.(Retrieved: 24 July 2020)
- Vietnam Custom (2020). Preliminary assessment of Vietnam international
merchandise trade performance in 2020. Available at:
https://www.customs.gov.vn/Lists/EnglishNews/ViewDetails.aspx?
ID=735&Category=News%20and%20Events&language=en-US.(Retrieved: 24
July 2020)
73
- Statista (2020). Contribution to GDP by industry in Vietnam. Available at:
https://www.statista.com/statistics/444611/vietnam-gdp-distribution-across-
economic-sectors/. (Retrieved: 24 July 2020).
- UNWTO (2020). International tourist trend and scenarios for 2020. Available at:
https://webunwto.s3.eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/s3fs-public/2020-05/UNWTO_B
arom20_02_May.pdf. (Retrieved: 24 July 2020).
- FIA (2020). Foreign investment attraction in 2020. Available at:
http://fia.mpi.gov.vn/tinbai/6357/Tinh-hinh-thu-hut-dau-tu-nuoc-ngoai-5-thang-
dau-nam-2020. (Retrieved: 24 July 2020).
- UNTAD (2020). Trade and development report 2020: from global pandemic to
prosperity for all: avoiding another lost decade. Available at:
https://unctad.org/system/files/official-document/tdr2020_en.pdf. (Retrieved: 24
July 2020).