dorwy judgment.pdf

8/9/2019 Dorwy Judgment.pdf

1/24Page 1

1

REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 2146 OF 2009

BHIM SINGH & ANR. … APPELLANTS

:Versus:

STATE OF UTTARAKHAND …RESPONDENT

J U D G M E N T

Pinaki Chanda Gh!"#$ J.%

1. T!s "##e"$% ' s#e(!"$ $e")e% "s ee* +!$e, "-"!*s e

/u,-0e* "*, r,er ,"e, 23.43.2445 #"sse, ' e H!-

Cur + U"r"6"*, " N"!*!"$ !* Cr!0!*"$ A##e"$ N.1748

+ 2441 9ere' e H!- Cur 9!$e "(u!!*- e 9 (;

"((use,


2/24Page 2

2

/u,-0e* "*, r,er ,"e, [email protected] #"sse, !* Sess!*s

Tr!"$ N.38 + 155 (*)!(e, "##e$$"* Ns.1 & 2 ere!*

u*,er Se(!* 34@;B + IPC "*, se*e*(e, e0

!0#r!s*0e* +r $!+e% "*, +urer (*)!(e, "$$ e

"##e$$"*s u*,er Se(!* @5;A IPC "*, se*e*(e, e0

r!-rus !0#r!s*0e* +r *e 'e"r "*, " +!*e + Rs.?44>;

e"( + e0. A$$ e "##e$$"*s 9ere "$s (*)!(e, u*,er

Se(!*s 3 & @ + e D9r' Pr!!!* A(% 1581 "*,

se*e*(e, e"( + e0 ree 0*s s!0#$e

!0#r!s*0e* "*, +!*e.

2. Te +"(s $e",!*- !s "##e"$ "re " *e B!0 S!*- S>

+ G)!*, S!*-% res!,e* + V!$$"-e N"$!"*" !* D!sr!(

N"!*!"$ - 0"rr!e, Pre0" De)!


3/24Page 3

&

Su;D!)!s!*"$ M"-!sr"e "u e u**"ur"$ ,e" +

Pre0" De)!. U#* re(e!)!*- !s !*+r0"!*% e M"-!sr"e

"$*- 9! Su;I*s#e(r S!) S!*- Gus"!*


4/24Page 4

4

0e,!"r !* +!*"$!!*- e 0"rr!"-e. Se)er"$ !e0s 9ere

-!)e* !* e "+res"!, 0"rr!"-e. FIR s"es " Pre0" De)!%

(0#$"!*"*s s!ser% $, !0 " 9e* se 9e* e

use + er !*;$"9s "+er 0"rr!"-e% er us"*, B!0

S!*-% A"* S!*-% N"!* S!*-% "$$ s*s + G)!*, S!*- "*,

S0. J"*6! De)! 9!+e + A"* S!*-% use, "u* "*, rure

er ' s"'!*- " se ", ru- *!*- !* ,9r'. e*

se *"rr"e, ese e)e*s er #"re*s e' #ersu",e,

Pre0" "*, $, er ",/us 9! er +"0!$' "*, $!)e 9!

e0 (r,!"$$'. F"er + e (0#$"!*"* 9e)er

(*)!*(e, Pre0" " e 9u$, !0se$+ "$6 er !*;$"9s

"*, se$e !*-s. Te' 9e* e use + e !*;$"9s +

Pre0" "*, r!e, e!r es #ersu",e e0% u !*se", +

se$!*- 0"ers% e' ere, "u*!*-. C*seue*$'%

Pre0" 9"s ",)!se, ",/us erse$+ e s!u"!*.

Tere"+er 9e* se ("0e er #"re*s use * e

(("s!* + R"6!% se $, e0 " B!0 S!*-% A"*

S!*-% N"!* S!*- "*, J"*6! De)! "re re#e"e,$' "u*!*- "*,

rur!*- er. Se +urer $, " e e$,er rer% A"*

S!*- re"e*e, !*su$ er e+re e e*!re )!$$"-e "*,


5/24Page 5

'

#ressur!se, er +r -e!*- ($es "*, er !e0s +r0 er

#"re*s use. O* 27.5.1557 e (0#$"!*"* re(e!)e,

!*+r0"!* " !s s!ser ", ,!e, ,ue ur*!*-. U#*

re(e!)!*- !s !*+r0"!*% e' !00e,!"e$' 9e* e

use + Pre0"s !*;$"9s "*, e' +u*, er ,e",. Se 9"s

(0#$ee$' ur*. Te' 9ere $, " se ", se erse$+ *

+!re.

@. I*)es!-"!* 9"s ,*e ' B!0$" Gu*/'"$% De#u'

Su#er!*e*,e* + P$!(e ;% "*, !* e e)e* + ,e+"u$ !*

#"'0e* + +!*e% +urer s!0#$e !0#r!s*0e* +r +!+ee* ,"'s

e"(. A((use, B!0 S!*- "*, A"* S!*-


6/24Page 6

6

& 2 ere!*= 9ere "$s e$, -u!$' + ++e*(e 34@;B + IPC "*,

+ e0 9ere se*e*(e, u*,er- r!-rus

!0#r!s*0e* +r $!+e. A##e$$"*s 9ere "$s (*)!(e, +r e

++e*(es u*,er Se(!*s 3 & @ + e D9r' Pr!!!* A(%

1581 "*, se*e*(e, u*,er- ree 0*s r!-rus

!0#r!s*0e* "$*- 9! +!*e + Rs.?44>;. I* e e)e* +

,e+"u$ !* #"'0e* + +!*e% e' 9ere u*,er- +urer

s!0#$e !0#r!s*0e* +r +!+ee* ,"'s. H9e)er% "$$ ese

se*e*(es 9ere ,!re(e, ru* (*(urre*$'.

8. A* "##e"$ 9"s #re+erre, ' e "##e$$"*s u*,er Se(!* 37@

+ C,e + Cr!0!*"$ Pr(e,ure% 1573


7/24Page 7

,

("use + ,e"% e 9 ++!(ers Dr. D.K. Js! "*, Dr. H.C.

B" #!*e, " e ("use + ,e" (u$, * e

"s(er"!*e,% e*(e e )!s(er" 9"s #reser)e,. Te )!s(er"

re#r * e Tr!"$ Cur re(r, ,!s($se, " #!e(es +

s0"(% !*es!*e% $!)er% 6!,*e' "*, s#$ee* (*"!*e,

Or-"* C$r I*se(!(!,e "*, E!$e A$($ #!s*s. Te

Au#s' re#r "*, (e0!("$ e"0!*ers re#r 9!

s"e0e* + Dr. D.K. Js! ($e"r$' es"$!se, e +"( "

e ,e(e"se, ,!e, "* u**"ur"$ ,e". -#!nd*+ e H!-

Cur "$s re$!e, * e s"e0e*s + V!r"$ S!*-% rer

+ e ,e(e"se,


8/24Page 8

/

"##e$$"*s e+re er ,e" r *. Te H!- Cur +u*,

" (i")*+ e #rse(u!* ", su++!(!e*$' s9* "s

reu!re, u*,er Se(!* 34@;B IPC " e ,e(e"se, 9"s

su/e( (rue$' "*, "r"ss0e* ' B!0 S!*- "*, A"*

S!*- ' re$'!*- * e s"e0e*s 0",e * " ' P;1

V!r"$ S!*-% P;2 M""* S!*- "*, P;3 Tr!$6 S!*- 9ere

e' s#e(!+!("$$' s"e, " !* e (ere0*' + Dur-u*% A"*

S!*- (0#$"!*e, " e#e*,!ure !*(urre, ' !0 !* e

0"rr!"-e ", * ee* re()ere,. Te!r s"e0e*s 9ere

(rrr"e, ' s"e0e* + Tr!$6 S!*-. Re$'!*- *

Se(!* 113;B + e I*,!"* E)!,e*(e A( 172 re", 9!

#rse(u!* e)!,e*(e% e H!- Cur #!*e, " e

#rse(u!* ", su((ess+u$$' #r)e, ("r-e + ++e*(e

#u*!s"$e u*,er Se(!* @5;A "*, 34@;B + I.P.C. "*, *e

#u*!s"$e u*,er Se(!*s 3 "*, @ + D9r' Pr!!!* A(%

1581 "-"!*s B!0 S!*- "*, A"* S!*-. -#!nd*+ * e

#!* + #r)!*- #r!0!' e9ee* e "u*s "*, ,e" +

e ,e(e"se,% e H!- Cur ,e(!,e, " +!)e 0*s 9"s

#r!0"e e*u- "*, " #resu0#!* u*,er Se(!* 113B

9"s #r)e, e'*, ,u #r)e ("r-e. Thid*+% e +"(


9/24Page 9

9

+ $!)!*- se#"r"e$' ' s9!*- r"!* ("r,s 9"s !00"er!"$.

O* e!*- ur-e, ' e "((use, " e ("r-e +r"0e, '

Tr!"$ Cur !s ,e+e(!)e "*, "$er*"!)e ("r-e (u$, * ")e

ee* +r"0e, !* e 0"**er ! !s ,*e ' Tr!"$ Cur% e

Cur +u*, " ere 9"s * errr !* s"!*- e ++e*(e

*r !* #"r!(u$"rs s"e, !* e ("r-e% *r "*' +"!$ure +

/us!(e "s !s s9* ' e "##e$$"*s. Re$'!*- * Se(!*s

221 "*, Se(!* @8@ + Cr.P.C. e H!- Cur #!*e, "

ere 9"s * errr !* e ("r-e *r ere 9"s "*' +"!$ure +

/us!(e. O* -!*- ru- e e*!re e)!,e*(e * re(r, e

H!- Cur +u*, " u- e *"0es + N"!* S!*- "*,

J"*6! De)! "re 0e*!*e, 9! B!0 S!*- "*, A"* S!*-% *

s#e(!+!( r$e !* "r"ss!*- e ,e(e"se, !s s"e, "-"!*s

e0 "*, "s su( e #ss!!$!' + !0#$!("!* + e!r

*"0es% * sus#!(!*% ("** e ru$e, u. E)e* !* res#e( +

("r-e + ++e*(e #u*!s"$e u*,er Se(!* @5;A "*,

Se(!*s 3 "*, @ + D9r' Pr!!!* A(% 1581% ("r-e

"-"!*s N"!* S!*- "*, J"*6! De)! ", * ee* #r)e,

e'*, re"s*"$e ,u. Bu "s +"r "s (*)!(!* re(r,e,

' e Tr!"$ Cur !* res#e( + B!0 S!*- "*, A"* S!*- !s


10/24Page 10

10

(*(er*e,% e Tr!"$ Cur ", (00!e, * errr !* $"9 !*

(*)!(!*- "*, se*e*(!*- e0 u*,er Se(!* @5;A I.P.C.%

34@;B I.P.C.% "*, *e u*,er Se(!*s 3 "*, @ + D9r'

#r!!!* A(% 1581 "s e ("r-e "-"!*s e0 9"s #r)e,

* e re(r, e'*, "$$ re"s*"$e ,u.

7. Te H!- Cur !* e #rese* 0"er (*)!(e, "##e$$"*

Ns.1 & 2% * e "s!s + (!r(u0s"*!"$ e)!,e*(e !* e

!0#u-*e, /u,-0e*. I "s ee* es"$!se, !* $e",!*-

/u,!(!"$ #re(e,e*s " 9ere e #rse(u!* ("se !s "se,

* (!r(u0s"*!"$ e)!,e*(e% *$' e (!r(u0s"*!"$ e)!,e*(e

+ e !-es r,er ("* s"!s+' e es + #r+ !* "

(r!0!*"$ #rse(u!*. T "se " (*)!(!* * (!r(u0s"*!"$

e)!,e*(e #u +r ' e #rse(u!* su$, es"$!s "

(0#$ee "*, u*r6e* ("!* + e)e*s s " *$' *e

!*+ere*(e (u$, e ,r"9* u +r0 e s"0e "*, !+ 0re

"* *e !*+ere*(e (u$, e ,r"9*% e* e "((use, su$,

e e*!$e, e e*e+! + ,u.

. Te $e"r*e, (u*se$ "##e"r!*- +r e S"e + U"r"6"*,

(*e*,e, " P;1 B!r"$ S!*- ", ("e-r!("$$' s"e,


11/24Page 11

11

* " " 0"rr!"-e + !s s!ser S0. Pre0" De)! 9"s

s$e0*!e, * 7.?.1557 9! B!0 S!*-. E$,er rer +

B!0 S!*-% A"* S!*-% #$"'e, r$e + 0e,!"r !* +!*"$!!*-

e 0"rr!"-e. L"* 9"s "6e* +r 0"rr!"-e. H9e)er *

,e0"*, +r ,9r' 9"s 0",e. Bu !s s!ser ", (0#$"!*e,

9!(e " !s +"0!$' 9"s "u*!*- er "*, ,e0"*,!*- ,9r'.

T!s s"e0e* -!)e* ' P;1 !s +u$$' (rrr"e, ' e

+"er + e ,e(e"se, "$s. Prse(u!* (u*se$ "$s

e"0!*e, P;3 Tr!$6 S!*- e u*($e% 9 s"!, " B!0

S!*- "*, A"* S!*- "$6e, "u ,9r' e+re !0 "*,

ereu#* e e#resse, !s ,!s#$e"sure. Te $e"r*e, (u*se$

"$s "r-ue, " se ,!e, "+er @ 0*s "*, s0e ,"'s +

er 0"rr!"-e !* "* u**"ur"$ 9"'. Furer% ! !s "r-ue, "

s!*(e ere 9"s * 0,e + r"*s#r !* e )!$$"-e " *!-%

e' (u$, * - e use + Pre0" De)!s !*;$"9s *

28.5.1557 "*, *e ,"' 9e* e' re"(e, ' 9"$6!*- *

+ +r "u 1? 60% e' ("0e 6*9 " e ,e", ,'

", ee* se* N"!*!"$ +r #s;0re0. A#"r +r0 e

")e 9!*esses% S0. Pus#" Js!% e Gr"0 Pr","* +

e V!$$"-e 9"s #r,u(e, "s P;@. Se s"e, " e e$,er;


12/24Page 12

12

rer A"* S!*- ("0e er "*, $, er " Pre0" De)!

", se erse$+ * +!re "*, ere"+er se "$*- 9! er

*e!-r% 9e* e!r use "*, s"9 Pre0" De)! $'!*-

ere ",$' ur*. P;@ !*+r0e, D"r-"/! Gus"! S!*-

"u e !*(!,e*. Te $e"r*e, (u*se$ +urer s"e, "

P;? Dr. D.K. Js! e"0!*e, e ,e", ,' * 28.5.1557

"*, !* eer*"$ e"0!*"!* +u*, 54 ur* !*/ur!es * e

,'. Te ,e(e"se, ", ,!e, 8; urs #r!r e"0!*"!*.

S!*(e * ("use + ,e" 9"s )!s!$e +r0 eer*"$

e"0!*"!*% ere+re% )!s(er" + e ,e(e"se, 9"s

#reser)e, +r !*er*"$ e"0!*"!*. Ps;0re0 re#r 9"s

#re#"re, ' Dr. H.C. B" !* 9!( ! 9"s s"e, " e

9"s + e #!*!* " e ,e(e"se, 9"s -!)e* s0e !(

sus"*(e e+re er ,e" ,ue 9!( se ,!e, "*, $"er

* se 9"s ur*. Be("use * eer*"$ re"s* + ,e" 9"s

+u*,% e )!s(er" 9"s se* e S"e L"r"r' +r

(e0!("$ e"0!*"!* "*, ! 9"s +u*, " !( 0"er!"$

9"s #rese* !* e )!s(er". Te (u*se$ +r e S"e% us%

su0!e, " e "((use, r!e, 6!$$ S0. Pre0" De)! '

-!)!*- #!s*us sus"*(e "+er rur!*- er +r ,9r' "*,


13/24Page 13

1&

9e* e' e("0e "##ree*s!)e 9eer se ", ,!e, r

*% e' se er * +!re (*+!r0 er ,e". Tere"+er%

e' !*+r0e, e Gr"0 Pr","* + e V!$$"-e " Pre0"

De)! ", ,!e, ,ue ur*!*- s " e ,e(e"se, !s *

"$e -!)e er ,'!*- ,e($"r"!*.

5. O* e er "*,% e $e"r*e, (u*se$ +r e "##e$$"*s

su0!e, " P;1 B!r"$ "s ",0!e, !* !s s"e0e*

" * ,e0"*, +r ,9r' 9"s 0",e ' "((use, e+re e

0"rr!"-e "*, !+ " "$$ e' 9"*e, ,9r'% e' 9u$,

,e0"*, ! e+re 0"rr!"-e !se$+. N*e + e0 9ere !* "

#s!!* ,e0"*, "*, -!)e ,9r'. B!r"$ ",0!e, !* !s

s"e0e* " e 0"rr!"-e 9"s se$e, )$u*"r!$' ' B!r"$

"*, !s +"er * e!r 9* "((r,. He s"e, " 0"rr!"-e

+ !s s!ser 9"s se$e, ' !s +"er "*, !s 0"rr!"-e 9"s

s$e0*!e, 9! e (*se* + 0e "*, 0' +"er. M'

s!ser ("0e "(6 ur use "+er s0e ,"'s + 0"rr!"-e.

Bu I ("** e$$ "+er 9 0"*' ,"'s se ("0e "(6.

Be("use I 9"s !* H"$,9"*! " !0e. Furer% ! 9"s ur-e,

" P;1 "*, P;2 ")e ",0!e, " * re#rs 9ere


14/24Page 14

14

$,-e, ' e0 #r!r ,e" + Pre0"% 9! res#e(

rure * ,e0"*, + ,9r'. Te Cu*se$ +urer s"!, "%

e (*,u( + e "((use, 9"s + -re" !0#r"*(e% "s e

!*+r0"!* + e ,e" 9"s -!)e* ' A"* S!*- !0se$+

e Gr"0 Pr","* + e V!$$"-e. I+ e' ", 6!$$e, er% e'

9u$, * ")e !*+r0e, er +"0!$' 0e0ers "*, !*se",

9u$, ")e (re0"e, er !00e,!"e$' "+er er ,e".

Cu*se$ ur-e, "% ! "##e"rs " e ,e(e"se, erse$+

(00!e, su!(!,e% ' +!rs (*su0!*- #!s*us sus"*(e

"*, ere"+er se u- se 0!- * ,!e ,ue !s

(*su0#!*% ere+re se ur* erse$+. Le"r*e, Cu*se$

+urer "r-ue, " B!0 S!*-% us"*, + e ,e(e"se,

"s 9 rers. A"* S!*-% e$,er rer + B!0 S!*- !s "

C96!,"r !* P..D. "*, $!)!*- se#"r"e$' 9! !s 9!+e. B!0

S!*- 9"s " )e!($e ,r!)er "*, !s 'u*-er rer N"!*

S!*- 9"s ru**!*- " s#. Tus% ere 9"s * (rre$"!* +

A"* S!*-% N"!* S!*- "*, J"*6! De)! 9! B!0 S!*-. A$$

ree 9ere ,!*- e!r se#"r"e ")("!*s. Te )er $!ss

"*, r"!* ("r,s + "$$ e ree rers% 9!( "re *

re(r,% "re se#"r"e. Tus% ! !s * #r)e, " "$$ ree


15/24Page 15

1'

rers 9ere !*)$)e, !* e ++e*(e. O* e er "*,%

e' ")e e$#e, e #$!(e !* !s ("se ' !*+r0!*- e0.

14. Tus% e #rese* "##e"$ reu!res "* e)"$u"!* "*, "*"$'s!s

+ e (!r(u0s"*!"$ e)!,e*(e * re(r, "*, e s"e0e*s

0",e !* e (urse + !*)es!-"!* "*, #r,u(e, "-"!*s

e "((use, "##e$$"*s.

11. Te +!rs -ru*, + ,e+e*se "6e* ' e "##e$$"*s !* !s

"##e"$ !s " ere !s * s#e(!+!( !*(!,e* + "use r rure

+r ,9r' "*, * #r!r re#r + ,9r' ,e0"*, 9"s +!$e, '

e +"0!$' + e ,e(e"se,. I !s "$s s"e, " ere 9"s

* ,e0"*, + ,9r' 0",e ' e0 e+re 0"rr!"-e "s !s

e)!,e* +r0 e s"e0e*s + P;1 B!r"$ S!*- "*, P;2

M"* S!*-. H9e)er% "s e$, ' !s Cur !* e State of

Himachal Pradesh v. Nikku Ram & Ors.%


16/24Page 16

16

D9r'% ,9r' "*, ,9r'. T!s !s e #"!*+u$re#e!!* 9!( (*+r*s% "*, " !0es "u*s%0"*' #"re*s + " -!r$ (!$, !* !s $' $"*, +urs 9ere% !* -, $, ,"'s e e$!e+ 9"s: "r"

N"r'"su Pu/'"*e r"0e*e er" ,e9""

0",e e+re 0"rr!"-e "*, " e 0"rr!"-e 9"s (*($u,e,

' e (*se* + e 9 #"r!es. Te' "$s 6 e

,e+e*se " * #r!r #$!(e (0#$"!* + ,9r' ,e0"*, 9"s

0",e ' e +"0!$' + e ,e(e"se,. H9e)er% !* $!- + e

,e(!s!* + !s Cur !* S"e + Himachal Pradesh v. Nikku

Ram & Ors.


17/24Page 17

1,

9ere ere. Bu !* e #rese* ("se% P;3 Tr!$6 S!*- "s

("e-r!("$$' s"e, !* !s s"e0e* " e "((use, A"*

S!*- ", (0e !* e (ere0*' + durgud% 9!( !s

(e$er"e, "+er 0"rr!"-e !* 9!( e ", s"e, !* e

#rese*(e + "$$ e #ers*s " e ", * re()ere, e

0*e' e ", s#e* !* e 0"rr!"-e "*, e("0e "*-r'. Te

Ps. ")e "$s s"e, "% e ,e(e"se,% S0. Pre0" De)!

", "$s (0#$"!*e, er +"0!$' 0e0ers 9!(e% re-"r,!*-

"u*s "*, ,e0"*, +r ,9r' ' e +ur "((use, #ers*s.

Tese !*(!,e*s ((urre, s* e+re er ,e" "s se

,!e, 9!!* ? 0*s + er 0"rr!"-e. T!s r"!ses "

#resu0#!*% u*,er Se(!* 113;B + e E)!,e*(e A(% "s

,9r' ,e" #u*!s"$e u*,er Se(!* 34@;B + I.P.C. A

(*/!* re",!*- + Se(!* 113B + e E)!,e*(e A( "*,

Se(!* 34@;B + I.P.C. s9s " ere 0us e 0"er!"$

s9 " s* e+re er ,e" e )!(!0 9"s su/e(e,

(rue$' r "r"ss0e*. Te #rse(u!* "s ru$e u e

#ss!!$!' + " *"ur"$ r "((!,e*"$ ,e" s "s r!*- !

9!!* e #ur)!e9 + ,e" ((urr!*- er9!se "* !*

*r0"$ (!r(u0s"*(es. Te #rse(u!* !s $!-e, s9


18/24Page 18

1/

" s* e+re e ((urre*(e ere 9"s (rue$' r

"r"ss0e* +r r !* (**e(!* 9! e ,e0"*, +r ,9r'.

I* er 9r,s% *$' 9e* e #rse(u!* #r)es " s*

e+re er ,e"% e $",' 9"s su/e(e, (rue$' r

"r"ss0e* +r r !* (**e(!* 9! "*' ,e0"*, +r ,9r'

"s $"!, ,9* ' !s Cur !* Kaliyaperumal and Anr. s.

State of !amil Nadu


19/24Page 19

19

su!(!,e ' " 0"rr!e, 90"*. U*$!6e "s !* Se(!* 34@;B

9ere e (ur s"$$ #resu0e ,9r' ,e"% 9e* e

#rse(u!* "s es"$!se, e !*-re,!e*s% u*,er Se(!*

113A + e E)!,e*(e A(% ,!s(re!* "s ee* (*+erre,

u#* e Cur 9ere!* ! "s ee* #r)!,e, " e Cur

0"' #resu0e "e0e* + su!(!,e. Tere+re e *us $!es

* e "((use, reu e #resu0#!*% "*, !* ("se +

Se(!* 113;B + e E)!,e*(e A( re$""$e Se(!* 34@B

+ IPC% e *us #r)e s!+s e($us!)e$' "*, e")!$' *

e "((use, "s e$, !* "ansilal v. State of Haryana


20/24Page 20

20

su!(!,e 9"s (00!e, 9!!* 7 'e"rs + 0"rr!"-e% "s e$, !*

#ur$achan Singh v. Satpal Singh 1554 Cr!. LJ ?82%?71


21/24Page 21

21

#ers* +r0 ,'!*- 9u$, ")e "6e* e ,e(e"se, #ers*

e *e"res s#!"$% "*, 9u$, * ")e 9"!e, +r er

,!e. Te "r-u0e* #u +r9"r, ' e $e"r*e, (u*se$ +r e

"((use, " e ,e(e"se, +!rs (*su0e, #!s* "*, e*

* e!*- "##ree*s!)e + er ,e"% se se erse$+ * +!re%

!s +urer #r)e, 9r*-% "s "*' re"s*"$e 0"* 9u$, r'

s")e !s 9!+e !+ su( " s!u"!* "r!se. e* +"(s "re ($e"r% !

!s !00"er!"$ 9eer 0!)e 9"s #r)e,. Ase*(e + 0!)e

,es * re"6 e $!*6 !* e ("!* + (!r(u0s"*(es

(**e(!*- e "((use, 9! e (r!0e "s e$, ' !s Cur

!* %ulakh Ra v. Staish Kumar'


22/24Page 22

22

(!r(u0s"*(es. I+ ere !s " s*"# !* e ("!*% e "((use, !s

e*!$e, e*e+! + ,u. #urpreet Singh v. State of

Haryana


23/24Page 23

2&


24/24

24

1. Tus% !* $!- + e ")e% ere !s * 0!ss!*- $!*6 !* e

(!r(u0s"*!"$ e)!,e*(e #u +r ' e #rse(u!*% "*,

e*(e e "((use, "re * e*!$e, e*e+! + ,u. Te

-u!$ + e "((use, #ers*s !.e. e "##e$$"* Ns.1 & 2

ere!*% u*,er Se(!* 34@;B IPC "s ee* su((ess+u$$'

es"$!se,. e% ere+re% +!*, * !*+!r0!' !* e !0#u-*e,

/u,-0e* #"sse, ' e H!- Cur. T!s "##e"$ !s

"((r,!*-$' ,!s0!sse,. Tere s"$$ e * r,er "s (ss.

............................................J M.. E3a*

............................................J Pinaki Chanda Gh!"#

N#5 D#*hiF#37a+ 11$ 201'.

dorwy judgment.pdf

Documents