dorman, t - dialectics

8/11/2019 Dorman, T - Dialectics

1/8

The purpose of confusion in laws and regulations is to cause cognitivedissonance. This is a state of mind where conflicts remain unresolved. Itweakens the subjects with its prolonged uncertainty. People are then subject tobreaking down and having paradoxical conversions. This can be found inresearching the phenomenon of brain washing. It is a potent device for control.Some references on this can be found in the following article.

DIALECTICS (and the Fate of Medicine)By Thomas Dorman, M.D.2000 By DORMAN PUBLISHING

IntroductionIn this article, I shall attempt to survey the use of an intellectual process, the dialectic. I will survey a broad

perspective of the subject, concentrating on the failure of philosophy and its harm to our civiliation. I willthen finish the article with a look at the special case of medicine in the context of the dialectical tool ! howmedicine is being destroyed, how the dialectical tool is used increasingly for the purpose, and I will hint yetagain at my increasing conviction that there is a plan behind this evil.1If we, who are savvy, can recognieits purpose and identify its means of operation, there is a chance that we can preserve the wonders of our

civiliation.

"s I happen to practice medicine #full time$, as I am dedicated to my work and love helping people #andyet have to make a living$, it is not mysterious that I am striving to preserve this freedom for my patients, formyself, for my progeny, and for humanity. %o man and no family live in isolation form society. Therefore, thewelfare of society is essential to our own welfare, let alone the need for exchange through the generations

for the other members of our species.

&e exchange produce, manufactured goods, know!how, and ultimately the sharing of a genetic pool. "yn

'and expressed this concept well with her brief aphorism There is no conflict between rational men. "s we

can see, conflict abounds. So what is wrong( The lack of rationality amongst most men.

If I, through this newsletter, can contribute one drop of rationality to the ocean of irrationality, my efforts will

be rewarded. " rational society is one in which individuals respect each other, exchange with each other formutual benefit, strive together for essential inherent joint interests #such as national defense$ and care for

each other based on respect and self!interest. This is the 'epublican form of government that the foundersof this country gave us in )**+.2The more I study the matter, the more I come to realie that that 'epublicangift was uniue.3It is the first instance in history where these laisse faire precepts of rationality were madethe foundation of a country, a society, a nation- although fragments of them were available from the history of

&estern iviliation before beginning with the /agna arta #)0)1$.

The Diaectic"s many terms and concept in our civiliation do, this hails to the 2reeks. 3ialectic #also called dialectics$was originally a form of logical argumentation where two or more sides of a subject were reviewed beforeconclusions were drawn. %owadays, it is a philosophical concept of evolution applied to diverse fields

including thought, nature and history.

"mong the classical 2reek thinkers, the meanings of dialectic ranged from a techniue of refutation and

debate, through a method for systematic evaluation of definitions, to the investigation and classification of therelationships between specific and general concepts. 4rom the time of the Stoic philosophers until the end of

the 5uropean /iddle "ges, dialectic was more or less closely identified with the discipline of formal logic.

Immanuel 6ant #)*07 ! )897$ denoted by Transcendental 3ialectic, the endeavor of exposing the illusion

involved in attempting to use the categories and the principals of understanding beyond the bounds ofphenomena and possible experience. 2eorg &ilhelm 4redrich :agel #)**9 ! )8;)$ identified dialectic as thetendency of a notion to pass over into its own negation as the result of conflict between its inherent

contradictory aspects.

6arl /arx!"#and 4riedrich 5ngels adopted :agelritannica to show you howthe concept itself is muddleheaded. If you felt a little embarrassed reading the last paragraph, not uiteunderstanding it, please ! join the club. 4rom my point of view, the fact that it is gobbledygook is what I am
http://www.afn.org/~govern/dorman.html#note1http://www.afn.org/~govern/dorman.html#note1http://www.afn.org/~govern/dorman.html#note1http://www.afn.org/~govern/dorman.html#note1http://www.afn.org/~govern/dorman.html#note2http://www.afn.org/~govern/dorman.html#note2http://www.afn.org/~govern/dorman.html#note2http://www.afn.org/~govern/dorman.html#note1http://www.afn.org/~govern/dorman.html#note1http://www.afn.org/~govern/dorman.html#note2http://www.afn.org/~govern/dorman.html#note2http://www.afn.org/~govern/dorman.html#note1


2/8

trying to convey.

Diaectic Conte%&orar' seThe modern usage of the dialectic has developed from a 2reek form of debate, that was uite sensible,

through a sesuipedalian philosophical rehash by the two famous 2erman philosophers followed by :agelinto a philosophical so!called tool. :agel


3/8

It is important for all of us. &e are all mortals, we are all subject to disease, and we may all reuiremedical attention. I think, however, that is it particularly important for doctors to understand this issue. Thedoctor who is swept into a misunderstanding of his role as a :ippocratic healer may, probably inadvertently,

develop habits of treatment that may not be in his customerBpatientlair government in >ritain, have increasingly demobilied

and decommissioned the military. =&e no longer need defense against the Soviet Cnion, which hascollapsed.= &rong. The military might of the ommunist 5mpire has not diminished.,There is subtlety incamouflaging their strength. They are pretending that there are no longer closed ones in 'ussia. Disitors

do, however, report their existence. This is where military development progresses apace.

The Soviets< ability to distort perceptions in the &est has improved #if that is the correct word$ by an order

of magnitude since the introduction of perestroika. This =renewal= coincided with /ikhail 2orbachev


4/8

The human animal is different from other creatures. It has a mind. In order to use people as a humanresource it is =necessary= #from the point of view of those who would control us$ to do something about thisindependent mind. In other words, to suppress it. It is somewhat difficult to suppress the independence ofpeople who have been reared free. The obvious recourse is to wait patiently and train the next generation.

@es, =train= is the correct word, and for this Skinnerian or Pavlovian techniues are used. 2/"21"22

I have discussed this issue in the past. It is called operant conditioning. "n essential part of this is the

dialectic techniue. 4or instance, in the town where I live, I recently saw a new notice on the highway =3o notdrink and drive? ero tolerance under 0)=. I have come to recognie that the word education means dumbingdown, and the words =ero tolerance= mean control, through the dialectic techniue, with fear. I firstencountered this cunning expression in the context of the supposed control of sexual molestation of patientsby doctors, which turned out to be a cleverly imposed dialectical techniue of compelling doctors to abandontheir personal relationships with their patients and kowtow to authoritarian mandates. The fact that awoman


5/8

independence and robustness are impaired. The whole gamut of human misery, disease and failure can, atsome time or other, afflict people. In these vulnerable phases, our normal societal habit is to rely on family."n extended family is the community. It is here that the concepts of laisse!faire independence arevulnerable. 3oes the man who is #hopefully temporarily$ ill lose his rights( 3oes he lose his dignitas, as I

discussed in a recent newsletter(2.

&ith the advent of effective medicine, sometime around the turn of the 09th century, the ancient medical

tradition has assumed a new and greater role because of the new scientific tools that came its way. Thisprofession has the potential of controlling a lot of society because of its now important role in the affairs ofthe weak. It is interesting that in bygone eras it was the priesthood that played that role.3/%otice how thesignificance of the church is declining as that of =scientific= medicine is ascending and particularly that ofpsychiatry. Is this a coincidence( @ou be the judge. Hust as the church controlled belief in order to maintainits power, so we find that the state has to control medicine for the same purpose. This is a scourge of our

era. In a curious way it is also a side effect of the scientific method, the new effectiveness of medicine.

%ow you will understand the background for the reason that medicine is coming under control of the

bureaucrats for the first time in human history. It is our generation of physicians who are facing the first majorchallenge to the :ippocratic principle. It is true that the notions of the philosopher king in Platonic medicinehail back to the 2reek area. It is, however, in these days that we are hearing that the :ippocratic Eath needs

to be revised.

&hy now, two and one!half millennia after its enunciation( &e are facing the issue of control through thedialectical techniue. This is a challenge no generation of physicians has faced since :ippocrates< times.

The destruction of %edicine&hat needs to be destroyed #from the hopeful controllers< point of view$? )$ The confidence the physician

has in himself, 0$ his independent thinking, ;$ his absolute commitment to his patientBclient, 7$ the privacy ofthe relationship because 7$ the dignity of the individual is predicated on maintaining secrecy regarding is

weaknesses.

&e all have weaknesses. The medicaliation of the mind, of education, of moralityBimmorality of habits

and vices, even of criminality, were necessary to wrest moral support from the priesthood, exemplified in theconfessional. %ow in the secular realm, the patient becomes a human resource #notice the significance ofwords($ for the %ew &orld Erder agenda. It is my belief that this task allocated to the linton administration

was just that. 3ue to the valiant efforts of The "ssociation of "merican Physicians and Surgeons, the :illaryplan of )GG; failed. This administration has used the techniue of gradualism to introduce the same horrors

piecemeal. They have also revved up the propaganda machine.

4or instance, I recently encountered a physician at a meeting who was outraged that 7* of "mericans

=can


6/8

here is This oingThe Hacobins brought on the 4rench 'evolution to the then most civilied 5uropean country in )*G;.

'obespierreooks, a

division of 2ood %ews Publishers, &estchester, IA +9)1;. )G8+,

IS9+/:/.1/,:3,.:#.
http://www.afn.org/~govern/dorman.html#note7http://www.afn.org/~govern/dorman.html#note7http://www.afn.org/~govern/dorman.html#note7mailto:[email protected]://www.afn.org/~govern/dorman.html#note7http://www.afn.org/~govern/dorman.html#note7http://www.afn.org/~govern/dorman.html#note7mailto:[email protected]


7/8

$ I have slightly paraphrased these definitions from the recent

issueof 5ncyclopedia >ritannica. &eb?http?BBwww.britannica.com

,ambodiaeacon 3r. Eklahoma ity, E6 *;)0*. Ph?

791!*8G!;881. 899!+10!))77. 4ax 791!*8G!+190. IS9+ 1:#,##-:/31:!.

)) Target the &est? Terrorism in the world today. @ossef >otansky.

)GG;. SPI >ooks. Shapolsky Publishers, Inc. );+ &. 00nd St. %ew

@ork,%@ )99)). IS9+ 1:#$1,1:2$.:-.

124inancial Terrorism? :ighjacking "merica under the threat of

bankruptcy. Hohn 4. /c/annus. )GG;. The Hohn >irch Society. P.E. >ox8979. "ppleton, &I 17G); Ph? 7)7!*7G!;*89. IS9+ 1:--1/1/:/2:1.

13The >lack >ook of ommunism? rimes, terror, repression.

StMphaneourtis, et. al. :arvard Cniversity Press. ambridge, /". Aondon,

5ngland )GGG. IS9+ /:$,!:/,$/-:,.

1! Syndrome of ontrol. Aindsey &illiams, )G8+. "vailable from

&orthPublishing o. P.E. >ox G). The 3alles, E' G*918. "vailable from

P.E.>ox *, 6asilof, "6 GG+)9

1#Sun Tsu. The "rt of &ar. 5dited by Samuel >. 2riffith. Exford

Cniversity Press, Aondon, )G+;

1$Psychic &arfare, 4act or 4iction( "n investigation into the use

ofthe mind as a military weapon. 5dited by Hohn &hite. )G88. The

5uarian Press. IS9+ /:-#/3/:$!!:2.

1,:umanist /anifestos, Ene and Two. Premetheus >ooks. *99 5.

"mhurstSt., >uffalo, %@ )70)1. )G;; #:umanist /anifesto Ene$ )G*;

#:umanist/anifesto Two$. IS9+ /:-,.,#:/13:$.

1-:umanist /anifesto 0999? " call for a new planetary humanism.

3rafted by Paul 6urt. Premetheus >ooks 1G Hohn 2lenn 3r.,

"mhurst,%@. )7008!0)G*. 0999. IS9+ 1:#,3.2:,-3:;.

1.4act, 4iction and 4raud. Sept. )GGG, Dol. 7?G. >rainwashing and

3umbing 3own? "ction #2erald "tkinson$. T. 3orman. &eb Site?http?BBwww.dormanpub.com.

2/>rain &ashing in the :igh School. 5. /errill 'oot.

3evin!Easics in 5ducation? I. The Aeipig onnection. Paolo Aeonni.

"vailable from 5missary Publications. G091 lackamas 'd., N)**+.

lackamas, E' G*9)1 #19;!807!0919$. )GG8. Published by The

3elphianPress. 09G19 S& 'ock reek 'd. Sheridan, E' G*;*8.

225ducating for the %ew &orld Erder. >.6. 5akman. :alcyon :ouse,

Portland, E' )GG). IS9+ /:-.!2/:2,-:2.

23 4act, 4iction and 4raud? ontrol of 3octoring? Through the

dialectic with sex. Huly )GG0. T.3orman. &eb Site?http?BBwww.dormanpub.com.

2!&ho 4inanced :itler? The secret funding of :itler


8/8

5pstein.)GG+. arroll and 2raf Publishers, Inc. )G &. 0)st St. %ew @ork,%@

)99)9!+891. IS9+ /,-$,:/$,,:#.

2$http?BBwww.carnell.comBenvironmentOhealthBalar

2,Trashing the 5conomy. 'on "rnold and "lan 2ottlieb. 4ree

5nterprise Press. >ellevue, &" )GG7. IS9+ /:.3.#,:1:1,:;.

2-/edical Sentinel? The official journal of The "ssociation of

"merican Physicians and Surgeons. )+9) %. Tucson >lvd., Ste G.Tucson, "K 81*)+ Ph? 899!+;1!))G+. &eb pagehttp?BBwww.aapsonline.org.

2.4act, 4iction and 4ad in /odern /edicine. Dol 1, %o ;. /arch0999.

3/2allileo? Inaugerating the "ge of 'eason, Part ;. 3avid:arriman

in The Intellectual "ctivist? "n objectivist review. Dol.)7?1 /ay

0999. TI" Publications, Inc. P.E. >ox 0+0, Aincroft, %H9**;8!90+0.

31This is a peculiarity of the tax code introduced by the

'ooseveltadministration called The /cerran!4erguson act.

32The dialectic in action here is the argument about fees- the

hidden agenda, the synthesis is control.

33The 3angers of Socialied /edicine. 5dited by Hacob 2.

:ornbergerand 'ichard /. 5beling. The 4uture of 4reedom 4oundation. ));19'andom :ills 'd., Ste 899. 4airfax, D" 009;9 IS9+ /:.$!/!!,:/:$.

3!The "ppalling Story of Ineptitude, /alfeasance, %eglect, and

"rrogance? /edicine on trial. harles >. Inlander, Aowell S. Aevin

and 5d &einer. Prentice!:all Press. %@ )G88. IS9+ /:13:#,3#!!:/.

3#/ediacracy? "merican parties and politics in the communications

age. 6evin P. Phillips. 3ouble 3ay and o., Inc. 2arden ity, %@

)G*1. IS9+ /:3-#:/!.!#:#.

3$The /edical /afia? :ow to get out of i t alive and take back

yourhealth and wealth. 2uylaine Aanctt. "vailable from P.E. >ox 00;.

/organ, DT 9181; Ph? 890!8G1!7G)7. 4ax 890!8G1!7++G. )GG1.

IS9+

/:.$!!12$:/:-

3,'obespierre? The Doice of Dirtue. Etto H. Scott. /ason J

AipscombPublishers. %ew @ork )G*7. IS>% 9!88791!98;!).

3-&e the living. "yn 'and )G8G "ngelika 4ilms J video, 0)119

ExnardSt N0G9, &oodland :ills " G);+*.

3.Trashing the 5conomy. 'on "rnold and "lan 2ottlieb. 4ree

5nterprise Press. >ellevue, &" )GG7. IS9+ /:.3.#,:1:1,:;.

!/ Target the &est? Terrorism in the world today. @ossef >otansky.

)GG;. SPI >ooks. Shapolsky Publishers, Inc. );+ &. 00nd St. %ew

@ork,%@ )99)). IS9+ 1:#$1,1:2$.:-.

!1Secret 'ecords 'evealed? The men, the money and the methods

behindthe %ew &orld Erder. 3ennis Aaurence uddy, Ph.3. :earthstone

Publishing, Atd. 199 >eacon 3r. Eklahoma ity, E6 *;)0*. Ph?

791!*8G!;881. 899!+10!))77. 4ax 791!*8G!+190. IS9+ 1:#,##-:/31:!.

C9 than

dorman, t - dialectics

Documents