domesticating individually-owned controlled foreign corporations...

65
Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations Post-Tax Reform Restructuring CFCs for U.S. Taxpayers, Mitigating Tax Liability, Section 962 Election, Transition Tax Today’s faculty features: Presenting a live 90-minute webinar with interactive Q&A 1pm Eastern | 12pm Central | 11am Mountain | 10am Pacific THURSDAY, JUNE 20, 2019 Paula Brunoro-Borokhov, Principal, Brunoro Law, San Diego William R. Skinner, Partner, Fenwick & West, Mountain View, Calif. The audio portion of the conference may be accessed via the telephone or by using your computer's speakers. Please refer to the instructions emailed to registrants for additional information. If you have any questions, please contact Customer Service at 1-800-926-7926 ext. 1. NOTE: If you are seeking CPE credit , you must listen via your computer — phone listening is no longer permitted.

Upload: others

Post on 05-Jun-2020

5 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled

Foreign Corporations Post-Tax ReformRestructuring CFCs for U.S. Taxpayers, Mitigating Tax Liability, Section 962 Election, Transition Tax

Today’s faculty features:

Presenting a live 90-minute webinar with interactive Q&A

1pm Eastern | 12pm Central | 11am Mountain | 10am Pacific

THURSDAY, JUNE 20, 2019

Paula Brunoro-Borokhov, Principal, Brunoro Law, San Diego

William R. Skinner, Partner, Fenwick & West, Mountain View, Calif.

The audio portion of the conference may be accessed via the telephone or by using your computer's

speakers. Please refer to the instructions emailed to registrants for additional information. If you

have any questions, please contact Customer Service at 1-800-926-7926 ext. 1.

NOTE: If you are seeking CPE credit, you must listen via your computer — phone listening is no

longer permitted.

Page 2: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

Tips for Optimal Quality

Sound Quality

If you are listening via your computer speakers, please note that the quality

of your sound will vary depending on the speed and quality of your internet connection.

If the sound quality is not satisfactory, you may listen via the phone: dial

1-866-961-9091 and enter your PIN when prompted. Otherwise, please

send us a chat or e-mail [email protected] immediately so we can address the

problem.

If you dialed in and have any difficulties during the call, press *0 for assistance.

NOTE: If you are seeking CPE credit, you must listen via your computer — phone

listening is no longer permitted.

Viewing Quality

To maximize your screen, press the F11 key on your keyboard. To exit full screen,

press the F11 key again.

FOR LIVE EVENT ONLY

Page 3: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

Continuing Education Credits

In order for us to process your continuing education credit, you must confirm your

participation in this webinar by completing and submitting the Attendance

Affirmation/Evaluation after the webinar.

A link to the Attendance Affirmation/Evaluation will be in the thank you email

that you will receive immediately following the program.

For additional information about continuing education, call us at 1-800-926-7926

ext. 2.

FOR LIVE EVENT ONLY

Page 4: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

Program Materials

If you have not printed the conference materials for this program, please

complete the following steps:

• Click on the ^ symbol next to “Conference Materials” in the middle of the left-

hand column on your screen.

• Click on the tab labeled “Handouts” that appears, and there you will see a

PDF of the slides for today's program.

• Double click on the PDF and a separate page will open.

• Print the slides by clicking on the printer icon.

FOR LIVE EVENT ONLY

Page 5: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

:

Domesticating Closely Held CFCs: Planning Strategies and Issues

Strafford Webinar – June 2019

Page 6: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

Presented By:

Paula Brunoro-BorokhovBrunoro Law, APC

600 W. Broadway, Ste 700San Diego, CA 92101

(619) [email protected]

Paula’s practice is focused in assistingbusinesses and individuals with business and taxrelated matters, where her diverse back- ground,strong analytical and communication skills,come into play.

Paula has vast experience assisting domesticclients in all sorts of tax controversy matters andtax planning for individuals and families.

As general counsel, she assists clients with avariety of complex business and corporateissues. She also handles international businessand tax matters, including tax planning formultinational families and businesses,international tax audits, offshore voluntarydisclosures, cross border transactions, transferpricing, tax treaties, and foreign tax credit.

Paula also provides guidance and representationto US clients transacting businesses overseasand foreign clients with assets or businessrelations in the US.

6

Page 7: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

I. Key Changes to CFC Rules

7

Page 8: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

1. Elimination of Voting Control Requirement:

I.R.C. Section 951(b)❑ Expansion of the definition of “US Shareholder”: 10% or more of vote or value.❑ US person holding only non-voting preferred shares now falls under the

definition of a “US Shareholder” for CFC purposes.

Example: USShareholder

Foreign Company

5% voting + 3% value + 8% non-voting preferred

❑ Prior law: not a US Shareholder❑ T.C.J.A: US Shareholder – value of voting and non-voting >10%

8

Page 9: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

2. 30-day Rule Repeal: I.R.C Section 951(a)(1)

❑ Pre-T.C.J.A: Foreign corporation needed to be a CFC for an uninterrupted period of at least 30 days.

❑ T.C.J.A: U.S Shareholder is subject to US tax on its prorated share of Subpart F income even if foreign corporation is only a CFC for a single day in the year, provided the US Shareholder owned the CFC on the last day of CFC’s tax year

9

Page 10: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

3. Stock Attribution Rules: I.R.C Sections 951(b), 957(a),

958(a) and 318(a)

❑ General Rule: Take into account shares owned directly, indirectly and constructively by US persons.

❑ Repeal of I.R.C Section 958(b)(4), which generally prevented downward stock attribution from a foreign shareholder to a domestic subsidiary.

Example

US Person

ForeignSubsidiary

Foreign Parent100%

49%

51%

➢ US Person is treated as owning all of the foreign parent’s stock in the foreign subsidiary.

➢ Foreign Subsidiary is a CFC➢ US Person Subpart F inclusion is

limited to its directly held stock and stock owned indirectly through foreign entities.

10

Page 11: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

3.1 Stock Attribution Rules: I.R.C Sections 951(b),

957(a), 958(a) and 318(a)

Foreign Investors

Foreign Parent

US Corporation

Foreign Subsidiary

100%

100%

80%

Example 2

20%

➢ USC is treated as owning all of the stock of FS (20% directly and 80% constructively) under IRC 318(a), causing FS to be a CFC

➢ USC inclusion of Subpart F income is limited to its pro rata share in respect of its directly held stock (20%)

11

Page 12: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

3.2 Stock Attribution Rules: I.R.C Sections 951(b),

957(a), 958(a) and 318(a)

Foreign Investors

Foreign Parent

US Corporation

Foreign Subsidiary

90%

100%

100%

Example 3

➢ USC constructively owns all of FS stock

➢ USC has no direct or indirect ownership in FS and no Subpart F income

➢ FS is also a CFC as to USP➢ USP must include its pro rata share

of Subpart F income

US Person

10%

12

Page 13: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

4. Stock Attribution Rules: Notice 2018-13

❑ Exception to the filing requirements for Form 5471 with respect to certain constructive owners of CFCs.

❑ Exception from Category 5 filing solely because that US person is considered to own the stock of the CFC owned by a foreign person by means of the downward rule.

US Person Non-US Investors

Foreign Parent

US CorporationForeign

Subsidiary

5% 95%

100%100%

13

Page 14: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

5. Transition Tax: I.R.C 965

❑ General Rule: deemed repatriation tax on the previously untaxed E&P of certain foreign subsidiaries by causing a one-time increase in the Subpart F income of such subsidiaries.

US Person

SFCSubpart F Income

951(a)(1) inclusion

❑ Specified Foreign Corporation: CFC or any foreign corporation (other than a PFIC) in which a domestic corporation is a 10% or greater US Shareholder.

14

Page 15: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

5.1 Transition Tax: I.R.C 965

❑ Applies to the taxable year of the CFC that begins before January 1 2018.

❑ Applies to both corporate and noncorporate US Shareholders.

❑ Existing FTC can be used to offset the transition tax.

❑ Payment can be spread over 8 years upon election.

❑ The amount of the repatriation: "higher of E&P" as at November 2, 2017 or 31 December, 2017, but the FTCs associated with that E&P may not be already fixed, or the amount of other FTCs that can be offset against the transitional tax.

15

Page 16: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

5.2 Transition Tax: I.R.C Section 965

❑ I.R.C Section 965 allows deductions to offset a portion of the inclusion such that the repatriated earnings are effectively taxed at one of two rates.

❑ Cash and equivalents: rate of 15.5%

❑ Remaining earnings: rate of 8%

Untaxed Foreign Earnings

16

Page 17: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

6. Territorial System: 100% Dividends Received

Deduction

❑ I.R.C 245A: 100% dividends received deduction to C Corporations who are US Shareholders of a SFC.

❑ Gain recognized by a C Corporation on the sale or exchange of stock in a foreign corporation held for more than one year that is treated as a dividend under Section 1248 is treated as a dividend for purposes of the 100% DRD.

❑ No FTC allowed.

❑ Hybrid dividends do not qualify for the DRD.

17

Page 18: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

7. GILTI: I.R.C Sections 951A and 250

❑ GILTI is the excess of the US Shareholder’s aggregate net tested income over a routine return of 10% on its aggregate pro rata share of the depreciable tangible property of the CFC.

❑ Tested income does not include ECI, Subpart F, foreign oil and gas income, high taxed exception income if elected (18.9%) and related party dividends.

❑ 10% routine return applied to the average of the aggregate adjusted basis of depreciable tangible property used in a trade or business to produce teste income as of the end of each quarter.

❑ GILTI is included in gross income in the same manner as Subpart F and is allocated among CFCs in proportion to their share of GILTI.

18

Page 19: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

7.1 GILTI: I.R.C Sections 951A and 250

19

Page 20: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

7.2 GILTI: Foreign Tax Credits

❑ Deemed paid FTC under I.R.C Section 960 allowed for foreign taxes properly attributable to tested income

❑ Deemed paid credit is limited to 80% of the product of the domestic corporation’s inclusion percentage multiplied by the aggregate tested foreign income taxes

❑ GILTI is separately basketed (other than passive)

❑ No carryovers or carrybacks

❑ I.R.C. Section 78 gross-up for 100% of the deemed paid foreign income taxes

20

Page 21: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

7.3 GILTI: Deduction for GILTI

❑ New I.R.C Section 250 provides a deduction for GILTI and Foreign-DerivedIntangible Income (FDII) of a Domestic Corporation (not a RIC, REIT or S-Corp) - It does not apply to Individuals

❑ Conceptually, provides a 10.5% minimum rate on GILTI (increased to13.125% after 2025) and a 13.125% (increased to 16.406%) rate onforeign derived income from intangibles held in the U.S

❑ Mechanics - deduction equal to the sum of 37.5% of foreign-derivedintangible income plus 50% of GILTI (limited to taxable income)

❑ For GILTI - Since 80% FTC allowed, if foreign tax rate is higher than13.125%, generally no residual U.S. tax (potentially subject to expenseallocation)

21

Page 22: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

7.4 GILTI: Examples (no foreign tax)

Assumptions:

US Corp holds 100% of one CFC

Tax Year 2019FTC Credit CalcSec. 960 Credit

Tax Rate in Effect 21% Inclusion Percentage (900/1000) 0.90

QBAINet CFC Tested Income

1000.001000.00

904 Limitation

900.00Tested Foreign Income Taxes (0%) 0.00

FSI

GILTI

78 Gross Up (100%)Deductions (ignoring other allocations)

0.00-450.00

Net CFC Tested Income 1000.00

Tax Rate (21%)

450.00

Less: 10% of QBAI -100.00 94.50

GILTI InclusionSection 78 Gross Up

900.000.00 Tentative Tax 94.50

Deduction Allowed (50%) -450.00 FTC Allowed 0.00

Net TaxableTentative Tax (21 %)

450.0094.50

Net Tax 94.50 10

22

Page 23: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

7.5 GILTI: Examples (foreign tax)

23

Page 24: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

8. Foreign Derived Intangible Income

❑ FDII is the portion of a domestic corporation’s deemed intangible income, which is derived from non-US sources.

❑ Rate is lower than domestic corporate tax rate.

❑ The income of the US company that exceeds the 10% return on the depreciable tangible assets of the company and which is "foreign" in nature is taxed at an effective rate of 13.125% (16.406% starting 2026).

❑ Available only to US Corporations.

US Parent

Foreign Subsidiary

Non-US Investors

24

Page 25: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

8.1 Foreign Derived Intangible Income

Example

US Parent

Foreign Manufacturer

Foreign Service Co

Foreign Distributor

GI: $110Taxes: $0QBAI: $0

➢ FDII: $110➢ Deemed Deduction: 37.5% x 110 = $41.45➢ FDII Tax: (110-41.45) x 21% = $14.44➢ FTC: $0➢ FDII taxation after FTC: $14.44➢ Effective tax rate on FDII: 14.44/110 = 13.125%

25

Page 26: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

9. Section 367(a)(3) Repeal

❑ Transfers of property used in an active trade or business no longer qualify as a non-recognition transfer.

26

Page 27: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned
Page 28: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

Domesticating Closely Held CFCs:

Planning Strategies and Issues

Presented as part of Strafford Webinar

June 2019

By William Skinner

Page 29: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

29

William R. Skinner, Esq. is a tax partner

with Fenwick & West LLP, in Mountain

View, CA. He graduated from Stanford

Law School and was recognized as a Rising

Star in Tax by California Super Lawyers.

He focuses his practice on U.S.

international corporate taxation, M&A

taxation and tax controversies.

William R. Skinner

Partner, Tax Group

Phone: 650.335.7669

Fax: 650.938.5200

E-mail:

[email protected]

Emphasis:

International Tax

Tax Planning

Tax Controversy

Page 30: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

TAX GROUP

II. The Section 962 Election

30

Page 31: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

TAX GROUP

The Section 962 Election – Why May it Now Be Necessary

▪ GILTI has harsh effects on US individuals and other non-C corporation shareholders of CFCs for several reasons:

• Treatment of GILTI as ordinary income rather than qualified dividend income – See Rodriguez v. Commissioner, 137 T.C. 174 (2013) and SIH Partners LLP v. Commissioner, 150 TC No. 3 (2018).

• Broad scope of GILTI as including most if not all CFC income

• Inability of an individual to claim an indirect credit under section 960(a) for entity-level foreign taxes

▪ An individual with a CFC generating significant income will need to consider Section 962 as one of the possible planning alternatives for these harsh results.

31

Page 32: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

TAX GROUP

GILTI – Impact of a Section 962 Election

▪ Section 962 allows an election to be made by a United States shareholder

that is an individual to be taxed at corporate rates on subpart F income

and GILTI.

▪ Where the Section 962 election is made, the United States shareholder’s

tax on subpart F income / GILTI is limited to the following:

• The maximum rate of tax that would apply to the amount of subpart F income under Section 11 of the Code if it were received by a domestic corporation, less

• Any indirect credit that would be allowed to such a domestic corporation with respect to the subpart F income under Section 960.

▪ For calculating the hypothetical corporate tax on GILTI, the proposed

Section 250 regulations make the 50% deduction available.

32

Page 33: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

TAX GROUP

GILTI – Impact of a Section 962 Election

▪ Section 962(d). Actual dividends by a CFC out of its earnings that were taxed under Section 962 are tax-free PTI distributions only to the extent of the amount of tax paid under Section 962(a).

▪ Any amounts in excess of the Section 962(d) PTI are not excluded from gross income under Section 959(a) and hence constitute taxable dividends.

▪ Treatment of dividends as ordinary income or qualified dividend income appears to depend on whether the foreign corporation is or is not a Qualified Foreign Corporation under Section 1(h)(11)(C). See Barry Smith v. Commissioner, 151 TC No. 5 (2018).

33

Page 34: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

TAX GROUP

Section 962 Election – Example 1

▪ US Shareholder owns stock of a Singapore CFC that generates $100 of tested income taxed at 15%.

▪ What are the effects of electing Section 962?

34

CFC

Singapore

CFC has no QBAI = $0

Net Income $100

Foreign Tax <$15>

E&P $85

US

Shareholder

Assume CFC Earns Solely Tested Income

100%

US Shareholder Owns Only One CFC

Page 35: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

TAX GROUP

Example of a Section 962 Election –

Sing CFC with 15% Tax Rate

35

Without Section 962(a) With Section 962 Election

GILTI $100 GILTI $100

Foreign Tax ($15.00) Foreign Tax ($15.00)

Net GILTI $85.00 Net GILTI $85.00

Shareholder Tax at 37% ($31.45)

After Tax Income $53.55 Hypothetical Corporate Tax $10.50

Tax Rate 46% Less Indirect Credit ($12.00)

Net Tax under Sec. 962(a) $0.00

Initial Tax Rate 15%

Additional Tax on Dividend

Distribution $85.00

Less Section 962(d) PTI $0.00

Net Dividend $85.00

Tax at Ordinary Rates ($31.45)

After Tax Income $53.55

Tax Rate - On Repatriation 46%

Page 36: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

TAX GROUP

Section 962 Election – Example 2

With Qualified Dividend income

▪ US Shareholder owns stock of a UK CFC that generates $100 of tested income taxed at 15%. Assume UK CFC is qualified foreign corporation for purposes of Section 1(h)(11)(C).

▪ What are the effects of electing Section 962?

36

CFC

UK

CFC has no QBAI = $0

Net Income $100

Foreign Tax <$15>

E&P $85

US

Shareholder

Assume CFC Earns Solely Tested Income

100%

US Shareholder Owns Only One CFC

Page 37: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

TAX GROUP

Example of a Section 962 Election –

UK CFC with 15% Tax Rate & 1(h)(11)

37

Without Section 962(a) With Section 962 Election

GILTI $100 GILTI $100

Foreign Tax ($15.00) Foreign Tax ($15.00)

Net GILTI $85.00 Net GILTI $85.00

Shareholder Tax at 37% ($31.45)

After Tax Income $53.55 Hypothetical Corporate Tax $10.50

Tax Rate 46% Less Indirect Credit ($12.00)

Net Tax under Sec. 962(a) $0.00

Initial Tax Rate 15%

Additional Tax on Dividend

Distribution $85.00

Less Section 962(d) PTI $0.00

Net Dividend $85.00

Tax at 1(h)(11) Rates ($17.00)

After Tax Income $68.00

Tax Rate - On Repatriation 32%

Page 38: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

TAX GROUP

Section 962 Election – Example 3

Low-Taxed CFC

▪ US Shareholder owns stock of a Bermuda CFC that generates $100 of tested income taxed at 2%.

▪ What are the effects of electing Section 962?

38

CFC

Bermuda

CFC has no QBAI = $0

Net Income $100

Foreign Tax <$2>

E&P $98

US

Shareholder

Assume CFC Earns Solely Tested Income

100%

US Shareholder Owns Only One CFC

Page 39: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

TAX GROUP

Example of a Section 962 Election –

Bermuda CFC with 2% Tax Rate

39

Without Section 962(a) With Section 962 Election

GILTI $100 GILTI $100

Foreign Tax ($2.00) Foreign Tax ($2.00)

Net GILTI $98.00 Net GILTI $98.00

Shareholder Tax at 37% ($36.26)

After Tax Income $61.74 Hypothetical Corporate Tax $10.50

Tax Rate 38% Less Indirect Credit ($1.60)

Net Tax under Sec. 962(a) $8.90

Initial Tax Rate 11%

Additional Tax on Dividend

Distribution $98.00

Less Section 962(d) PTI ($8.90)

Net Dividend $89.10

Tax at Ordinary Rates ($32.97)

After Tax Income $56.13

Tax Rate - On Repatriation 44%

Page 40: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

TAX GROUP

Other Relevant Issues in Actual Repatriation

▪ In addition to federal income taxes of actual dividends, several other taxes may be triggered by an actual repatriation of earnings from a closely CFC:

• Foreign withholding taxes (which may or may not be creditable)

• State income taxes

• 3.8% Medicare contribution tax

▪ Accumulated Earnings Tax should also be considered (note – PHC cannot apply to a foreign corporation).

40

Page 41: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

TAX GROUP

Example 1 with SALT and Foreign Taxes

▪ In addition to basic facts, assume that Singapore imposes a 10% dividend withholding tax. Shareholder resides in the state of California (13.3% top rate) and is subject to Medicare contribution tax.

41

CFC

Singapore

CFC has no QBAI = $0

Net Income $100

Foreign Tax <$15>

E&P $85

US

Shareholder

Assume CFC Earns Solely Tested Income

100%

US Shareholder Owns Only One CFC

Page 42: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

TAX GROUP

Example 1 with Additional Taxes – No Section 962

42

Without Section 962(a)

GILTI $100

Foreign Tax ($15.00)

Net GILTI $85.00

Shareholder Tax at 37% ($31.45)

After Tax Income $53.55

Initial Tax Rate 46%

Distribution of Cash $85.00

Less Sing WHT at 10% ($8.50)

Net Cash $76.50

Less Cal Tax at 13.3% ($10.17)

Less NIIT at 3.8% ($2.91)

Plus Sec. 960(b) Credit against GILTI $8.50

After Tax Cash $40.47

Shareholder Taxes ($13.08)

Total Tax Rate on Repatriation 60%

Page 43: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

TAX GROUP

Example 1 with Additional Taxes – Section 962

Election

43

With Section 962 Election

GILTI $100

Foreign Tax ($15.00)

Net GILTI $85.00

Hypothetical Corporate Tax $10.50

Less Indirect Credit ($12.00)

Net Tax under Sec. 962(a) $0.00

Initial Tax Rate 15%

Additional Tax on Dividend

Distribution $85.00

Less Section 962(d) PTI $0.00

Net Dividend $85.00

Less Sing WHT at 10% ($8.50)

Net Cash $76.50

Less Cal tax at 13.3% ($10.17)

Less NIIT at 3.8% ($2.91)

Fed Tax at Ordinary Rates ($31.45)

FTC For Sing Taxes $8.50

After tax cash $40.47

Total Tax Rate on Repatriation 60%

Page 44: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

TAX GROUP

GILTI – Election Mechanics

▪ Only an individual, estate or trust that is a United States shareholder as defined in Section 951(b) is permitted to make the Section 962 election.

▪ Partnerships and S corporations are not eligible. However, individuals owning through a pass-through entity that are themselves United States shareholders are permitted to make the Section 962 election.

▪ The election is made annually.

▪ The election applies to all controlled foreign corporations owned by the individual; you cannot select particular CFCs for the election.

44

Page 45: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

TAX GROUP

Section 962 Election Mechanics

▪ S Corp cannot elect Section 962 because it is not an individual.

▪ Father can elect as a 958(b) shareholder of >10%. Son can also elect as a 958(b)

shareholder of >10%.

▪ Cousin cannot elect because not a 10% United States shareholder in own right

45

S Corp

Son

5%

Father Cousin

CFC

90% 5%

GILTI/Subpart F Income

Page 46: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

TAX GROUP

Interaction of Section 962 with Section 956 Investments

▪ What is the impact of Section 956 in the post-TCJA environment? How does Section 956 interact with Section 962 election?

46

CFC

Shareholder

$125 Loan

$100 GILTI PTI (§962)

$50 Untaxed E&P

Page 47: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

TAX GROUP

Interaction of Section 956 & Section 962

▪ As to the $100 of Section 962 PTI, it appears that the full $100 is available to exclude the Section 956 investment from gross income. See Section 962(d) (referring to Section 959(a)(1), not Section 959(a)(2)).

▪ As to the $25 section 956 investment in excess of PTI, Section 956 continues to apply because Shareholder is not a C corporation eligible for Section 245A.

▪ Questions:

• If Shareholder elects Section 962 with respect to the $25 Section 956 inclusion, is the hypothetical C Corporation tax under Section 962(a)(1) zero because of Section 245A?

• Note FTC regulations turn off the indirect credit on Section 956 amounts.

47

Page 48: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned
Page 49: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

III. Domestication and restructuring

strategies of CFCs for U.S. taxpayers

49

Page 50: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

1. Check the box: treat FC as US Partnership

❑ File Form 8832 to treat the foreign company as a partnership for US tax purposes to avoid CFC status.

❑ US shareholders would be taxed on the underlying income on a flow-through basis.

❑ US shareholders would be able to claim foreign tax credits.

❑ Drawbacks?

❑ Election could trigger a deemed liquidation of the company.

❑ US owners could recognize taxable gain on the deemed sale of their shares.

❑ Not all foreign business entities are eligible.

50

Page 51: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

1.1 Check the box: turning subs into branches

❑ Regs. Sec. 1.318-1(b)(1): a corporation cannot be considered to own its own stock by virtue of the attribution rules.

❑ Turn FS into a branch.

❑ FP can’t own its own stock. USCo cannotbe considered as owning FP’s stock.

❑ Formerly deemed CFC are one entity from US perspective.

❑ Option 2: turn US sub into a branch.

51

Page 52: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

2. Contribute Foreign stock to US Corporation

❑ If US Corporation owns at least 10% of the foreign company, the US tax rate on GILTI is reduced from 37% to 10.5% and possibly down to 2-3% or less after the 80% FTC is taken into account.

❑ Subsequent distributions of foreign income is potentially eligible for the 100% DRD under Section 245A.

❑ Drawbacks?

❑ Two levels of tax on subsequent sale at a gain.

❑ Accumulated earnings and personal holding company taxes.

❑ Taxation in foreign country.

52

Page 53: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

3. Contribute Foreign stock to PPLI

❑ Assets go into a life insurance policy that allows owner to borrow from the death benefits while alive.

❑ Drawbacks?

❑ Complicated

❑ Relinquish of control

❑ Costs

53

Page 54: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

4. Estate Planning Options

❑ Check the box: Obsolete with the repeal of the 30-day rule.

❑ Harvesting Gains

❑ Segregating non-US assets

❑ Avoiding or minimizing US situs assets

❑ Two tier blocker structure

54

Page 55: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

4.1 Two tier Blocker Structure

50%

❑ Avoid US estate tax, provide step-up in basis and avoid substantial Subpart F income to US beneficiaries.

Foreign Grantor

Trust

Top Tier –Foreign Entity 1

Top Tier –Foreign Entity 2

Lower Tier –Foreign Entity 1

US Investment Portfolio

100%100%

50%

55

Page 56: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

TAX GROUP

IV. Additional Practical Issues

in Domestication Transactions

56

Page 57: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

TAX GROUP

Section 962 PTI Ordering Rules

▪ Section 962(d) is subject to the same ordering rules as other PTI –i.e., LIFO ordering of Section 959(c)(1), followed by LIFO ordering Section 959(c)(2) accounts.

▪ Where shareholder has both Section 962(d) PTI and other PTI, the source of the distribution will be critical.

▪ There is no priority for fully taxed PTI in advance of Section 962 PTI.

▪ However, Notice 2019-1’s priority rule for all Section 965 PTI can be helpful in allowing Section 965 PTI to be distributed before Section 962(d) amounts.

57

Page 58: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

TAX GROUP

Section 962 PTI Ordering Rules

▪ Unlike normal LIFO ordering rule, Section 965 PTI of $400 is distributed first

and results in an exclusion of $300 from gross income.

▪ Next $100 can also be distributed tax-free before Sec. 962(d) amounts are

distributed.

58

CFC

Shareholder

Distributes $300

2017 $400 Section 965 PTI

2018-2019 $200 GILTI / §962 PTI

Page 59: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

TAX GROUP

Section 962 PTI Ordering Rules

▪ C Corporation as a successor in interest under Section 959(d) has $400 of Section 965

PTI. C Corporation also has $200 of GITLI PTI. CFC can distribute $600 to C

Corporation tax-free as a PTI distribution.

▪ However, under normal Section 301(c) rules, C Corporation appears to have $200 of

E&P due to the GILTI. See GLAM 2015-3. This comes out of C Corporation first.

59

CFC

Shareholder

$400 §965

InclusionContributes

on 1/1/2018C Corp

Blocker

CFC

$200 GILTI

$400 965 PTI

$200 GILTI PTI

Page 60: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

TAX GROUP

Ownership of a Foreign Branch / Flow-through Entity

▪ Direct foreign business activities remain subject to worldwide

taxation subject to a foreign tax credit, as under pre-2018 law.

▪ A new FTC basket applies to income “attributable to” foreign

branches, as provided under regulations. Sec. 904(d)(2)(J).

▪ Foreign business income generally is not eligible for the 20%

deduction for pass-through income because of limitation to income

effectively connected with a US trade or business. Section

199A(c)(3)(A)(i).

• However, income from providing sales and services to foreign

customers as part of a US trade or business may qualify for the

reduced rate of tax on pass-through income.

60

Page 61: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

TAX GROUP

S Corporation – Flow-Through Structure

▪ Through F Reorganization, shareholder domesticates CFC into a branch of an S corporation.

▪ What are the pros and cons of S Corporation structure?

61

Shareholder

S Corp

F DRE

10% WHT on Distributors

20% Tax Rate

Page 62: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

TAX GROUP

Considerations in S Corporation / Flow-Through

Pros:

▪Allows direct credit for foreign entity level taxes. No second level US federal income tax

on actual distribution of profits.

▪No AET / PHC issues.

▪No Medicare contribution tax if individual actively participates.

▪Consider whether Section 199A applies to foreign income that is effectively connected

income with a QTOB.

Cons:

▪No deferral of residual US tax

▪No deferral of state tax

▪Gives up benefit of tax-free repatriation of Section 965 PTI

62

Page 63: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

TAX GROUP

New High-Taxed Exception for GILTI

▪ New proposed regulations (REG 101828-19) allow the taxpayer to elect

to exclude from GILTI tested income subject to a rate of at least 90% of

the C Corporation rate (18.9%).

▪ In the case of high-taxed CFCs, this new rule may considered in lieu of

Section 962. Does it yield a better result?

63

Shareholder

UK CFCTested Income

20% Foreign Tax

Page 64: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

TAX GROUP

Any Questions

William R. Skinner

Partner, Tax Group

Fenwick & West LLP

(650) 335-7669

[email protected]

64

Page 65: Domesticating Individually-Owned Controlled Foreign Corporations …media.straffordpub.com/products/domesticating-individually-owned... · 20-06-2019  · Domesticating Individually-Owned

65

Thank You

William R. Skinner, Partner, Tax Group

Fenwick & West LLP

(650) 335-7669

[email protected]

Paula Brunoro-Borokhov, Principal

Brunoro Law, APC

(619) 394-8681

[email protected]

65