doc.: ieee 802.11-20/1109r7 · web viewthe chair (alfred asterjadhi, qualcomm) calls the meeting to...

September, 2020 doc.: IEEE 802.11-20/1109r77

IEEE P802.11Wireless LANs

TGbe 2020 July to September teleconference minutes

Date: 2020-09-15

Author(s):Name Affiliation Address Phone emailDennis Sundman Ericsson [email protected]

Minutes page 1 Dennis Sundman, Ericsson

AbstractThis document contains the minutes for July to September 2020 TGbe teleconferences.

Revisions:- Rev 0: Added references to MAC and PHY sessions held 13th and 15th of July. Added minutes

for joint meeting the 16th of July.- Rev1: Added references to MAC and PHY sessions held 20th to 29th of July. Added minutes

for joint meeting the 30th of July.- Rev2: Added the final results on Motions 120 and 121. Added appendix with the outcome.

Updated some typos.- Rev3: Added references to MAC and PHY sessions held 3rd to 19th August. Added minutes for

joint meeting the 20th of August.- Rev4: Some minor typological updates and revised Motion 123 results.- Rev5: Added references to MAC and PHY sessions held 24th of August to 2nd of September.

Added minutes for joint telco 3rd of September.- Rev6: Added references to MAC and PHY sessions held 9th and 10th of September. Updated

all references to MAC and PHY minutes to the final revisions.- Rev7: Updated references to all MAC sessions.


ContentsMonday 13 July 2020, 19:00 – 21:00 ET......................................................................................................3

Wednesday 15 July 2020, 10:00 – 12:00 ET.................................................................................................3Thursday 16 July 2020, 11:30 – 13:00 ET.....................................................................................................4

Thursday 20 July 2020, 10:00 – 13:00 ET.....................................................................................................8Thursday 22 July 2020, 10:00 – 13:00 ET.....................................................................................................8



Thursday 3 August 2020, 10:00 – 13:00 ET................................................................................................16Thursday 5 August 2020, 10:00 – 13:00 ET................................................................................................16

Thursday 6 August 2020, 19:00 – 22:00 ET................................................................................................16Thursday 17 August 2020, 19:00 – 22:00 ET..............................................................................................16

Thursday 19 August 2020, 10:00 – 13:00 ET..............................................................................................16Thursday 20 August 2020, 10:00 – 13:00 ET..............................................................................................17

Monday 24 August 2020, 10:00 – 13:00 ET................................................................................................24Wednesday 26 August 2020, 10:00 – 13:00 ET..........................................................................................24

Thursday 27 August 2020, 19:00 – 22:00 ET..............................................................................................24Monday 31 August 2020, 19:00 – 22:00 ET................................................................................................24

Wednesday 2 September 2020, 10:00 – 13:00 ET.......................................................................................24Thursday 3 September 2020, 10:00 – 13:00 ET..........................................................................................25

Wednesday 9 September 2020, 10:00 – 13:00 ET.......................................................................................33Thursday 10 September 2020, 19:00 – 22:00 ET........................................................................................33

Appendix 1...................................................................................................................................................34



Monday 13 July 2020, 19:00 – 21:00 ET Split PHY and MAC.

● MAC: https://mentor.ieee.org/802.11/dcn/20/11-20-1079-20-00be-minutes-for-tgbe-mac-ad-hoc-teleconferences-in-july-and-september-2020.docx

● PHY: https://mentor.ieee.org/802.11/dcn/20/11-20-1093-10-00be-minutes-for-tgbe-phy-ad-hoc-cc-july-to-sept-2020.docx

Wednesday 15 July 2020, 10:00 – 12:00 ET Only MAC.



https://mentor.ieee.org/802.11/dcn/20/11-20-1079-20-00be-minutes-for-tgbe-mac-ad-hoc-teleconferences-in-july-and-september-2020.docx


https://mentor.ieee.org/802.11/dcn/20/11-20-1093-10-00be-minutes-for-tgbe-phy-ad-hoc-cc-july-to-sept-2020.docx





Thursday 16 July 2020, 11:30 – 13:00 ET

Introduction1. The Chair, Alfred Asterjadhi (Qualcomm), calls the meeting to order at 11:32 ET. The Chair

notifies that the agenda is 927r9.

2. IEEE 802 and 802.11 IPR policy and procedure. If anyone in this meeting is personally aware of the holder of any patent claims that are potentially essential to implementation of the proposed standard(s) under consideration by this group please speak up now. Nobody speaks/writes up.

3. Attendance reminder.o Participation slide: https://mentor.ieee.org/802-ec/dcn/16/ec-16-0180-05-00EC-ieee-802-

participation-slide.pptxo Please record your attendance during the conference call by using the IMAT system:

1) login to imat, 2) select “802.11 Telecons (<Month>)” entry, 3) select “C/LM/WG802.11 Attendance” entry, 4) click “TGbe <MAC/PHY/Joint> conference call that you are attending.

o If you are unable to record the attendance via IMAT then please send an e-mail to Dennis Sundman ([email protected]) and Alfred Asterjadhi ([email protected])

o Please ensure that the following information is listed correctly when joining the call: "[voter status] First Name Last Name (Affiliation)"

o Participants reported in IMAT: Abouelseoud, Mohamed Sony Corporation Aboulmagd, Osama Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd Aio, Kosuke Sony Corporation Ansley, Carol CommScope Asterjadhi, Alfred Qualcomm Incorporated Au, Kwok Shum Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd B, Hari Ram NXP Semiconductors Baek, SunHee LG ELECTRONICS Bei, Jianwei NXP Semiconductors Bluschke, Andreas Signify Bredewoud, Albert Broadcom Corporation Cao, Rui NXP Semiconductors CHAN, YEE Facebook Chen, Xiaogang Intel Cheng, Paul MediaTek Inc. CHERIAN, GEORGE Qualcomm Incorporated Chitrakar, Rojan Panasonic Asia Pacific Pte Ltd. Choi, Jinsoo LG ELECTRONICS Chu, Liwen NXP Semiconductors CHUN, JINYOUNG LG ELECTRONICS Duan, Ruchen SAMSUNG Fang, Yonggang ZTE TX Inc feng, Shuling MediaTek Inc. Fischer, Matthew Broadcom Corporation Gan, Ming Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd Ghosh, Chittabrata Intel Corporation Grandhe, Niranjan NXP Semiconductors Grigat, Michael Deutsche Telekom AG GUIGNARD, Romain Canon Research Centre France


mailto:[email protected]


https://imat.ieee.org/attendance


https://mentor.ieee.org/802-ec/dcn/16/ec-16-0180-05-00EC-ieee-802-participation-slide.pptx



Guo, Yuchen Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd Hamilton, Mark Ruckus/CommScope Han, Jonghun SAMSUNG Han, Zhiqiang ZTE Corporation Ho, Duncan Qualcomm Incorporated Hsiao, Ching-Wen MediaTek Inc. Hsieh, Hung-Tao MediaTek Inc. Hu, Chunyu Facebook Hu, Glenn Tencent Huang, Guogang Huawei Jang, Insun LG ELECTRONICS Ji, Chenhe Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd Jiang, Jinjing Apple, Inc. Kain, Carl USDoT Kandala, Srinivas SAMSUNG Kedem, Oren Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd Khude, Nilesh NXP Semiconductors Kim, Jeongki LG ELECTRONICS Kim, Myeong-Jin SAMSUNG kim, namyeong LG ELECTRONICS Kim, Sang Gook LG ELECTRONICS Kim, Songhak Kaonmedia Kim, Youhan Qualcomm Incorporated Kishida, Akira Nippon Telegraph and Telephone Corporation

(NTT) Klein, Arik Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd Kneckt, Jarkko Apple, Inc. Koc, Onur VESTEL ELEKTRONIK SANAYI VE

TICARET ANONIM SIRKETI Kwon, Young Hoon NXP Semiconductors Lan, Zhou Broadcom Corporation Lee, Wookbong SAMSUNG Levitsky, Ilya IITP RAS Levy, Joseph InterDigital, Inc. Li, Yiqing Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd Li, Yunbo Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd Lim, Dong Guk LG ELECTRONICS Lin, Wei Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd Lindskog, Erik SAMSUNG Liu, Jianhan MediaTek Inc. Lopez, Miguel Ericsson AB Lou, Hanqing InterDigital, Inc. Lu, Liuming ZTE Corporation Luo, Chaoming Beijing OPPO telecommunications corp., ltd. Ma, Mengyao HUAWEI Memisoglu, Ebubekir Istanbul Medipol University; Vestel Mirfakhraei, Khashayar Cisco Systems, Inc. Monajemi, Pooya Cisco Systems, Inc. Murphy, Rick vLogic, Inc. NANDAGOPALAN, SAI SHANKARCypress Semiconductor Corporation Naribole, Sharan SAMSUNG Nezou, Patrice Canon Research Centre France noh, yujin Newracom Inc. Pare, Thomas MediaTek Inc.



Park, Eunsung LG ELECTRONICS Park, Minyoung Intel Corporation Patil, Abhishek Qualcomm Incorporated Patwardhan, Gaurav Hewlett Packard Enterprise Petrick, Albert InterDigital, Inc. Pettersson, Charlie Ericsson AB Puducheri, Srinath Broadcom Corporation Raissinia, Alireza Qualcomm Incorporated Redlich, Oded HUAWEI RISON, Mark Samsung Cambridge Solution Centre Rosdahl, Jon Qualcomm Technologies, Inc. Roy, Sayak NXP Semiconductors Schelstraete, Sigurd Quantenna Communications, Inc. Sedin, Jonas Ericsson AB Seok, Yongho MediaTek Inc. Sethi, Ankit NXP Semiconductors Shellhammer, Stephen Qualcomm Incorporated Shilo, Shimi HUAWEI Singh, Gurdev SAMSUNG Solaija, Muhammad Sohaib Istanbul Medipol University; Vestel Song, Taewon LG ELECTRONICS Strauch, Paul Qualcomm Incorporated SUH, JUNG HOON Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd Sun, Bo ZTE Corporation Sun, Li-Hsiang InterDigital, Inc. Sun, Yanjun Qualcomm Incorporated Sundman, Dennis Ericsson AB SURACI, FRANK U.S. Department of Homeland Security Tanaka, Yusuke Sony Corporation Tian, Bin Qualcomm Incorporated Tsodik, Genadiy Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd Varshney, Prabodh Nokia Vermani, Sameer Qualcomm Incorporated VIGER, Pascal Canon Research Centre France Wang, Hao Tencent Wang, Huizhao Quantenna Communications, Inc. Wang, Lei Huawei R&D USA Wang, Qi Apple, Inc. Wang, Xiaofei InterDigital, Inc. Wendt, Matthias Signify Wentink, Menzo Qualcomm Wu, Tianyu Apple, Inc. Wullert, John Perspecta Labs Xin, Liangxiao Sony Corporation Xin, Yan Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd Yan, Aiguo Oppo YANG, RUI InterDigital, Inc. Yang, Steve TS MediaTek Inc. Yano, Kazuto Advanced Telecommunications Research

Institute International (ATR) Yee, James MediaTek Inc. yi, yongjiang Futurewei Technologies Young, Christopher Broadcom Corporation Yu, Jian Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd



Yukawa, Mitsuyoshi Canon, Inc. Zhang, Yan NXP Semiconductors

2. Zuo, Xin Tencent

4. Comment regarding Agenda:a. C: I have an updated strawpoll on 1961.b. R: This was not submitted within 24 hours so we take it the next meeting.c. C: I want to defer 596d. C: I want to defer 617e. R: Ok.

Agenda approved with unanimous consent.

5. Announcements:a. Towards TGbe D0.1 Draft – Status and Updates

997r4 TGbe spec text volunteers and status Some discussion and clarifications regarding the spec text volunteers and status. The chair updates the document live. The chair explains the guidelines for R1 vs R2 categorization.

Comments:o C: We should not discuss R2 during R1 (for draft spec text).o C: Simple topics should be clear for R1.o C: Suggestion to follow motion of January for which topic falls

in R1 and R2.o C: Should follow guidline as strictly as possible.o C: I prefer a 50% threshold for SPs.o C: If there are not many motions in a category then implicitly it

should belong in R1.Adjourned at 13:00 ET


https://mentor.ieee.org/802.11/dcn/20/11-20-0997-04-00be-tgbe-spec-text-volunteers-and-status.docx


Thursday 20 July 2020, 10:00 – 13:00 ET Split PHY and MAC.



Thursday 22 July 2020, 10:00 – 13:00 ET Only MAC.








Thursday 29 July 2020, 10:00 – 13:00 ET Only MAC.

● https://mentor.ieee.org/802.11/dcn/20/11-20-1079-20-00be-minutes-for-tgbe-mac-ad-hoc- teleconferences-in-july-and-september-2020.docx



















Thursday 30 July 2020, 10:00 – 13:00 ET

1. The Chair (Alfred Asterjadhi, Qualcomm) calls the meeting to order at 10:02. The agenda can be found in 927r15. A reminder that this call is one with motions.







o Participants reported in IMAT: Aboulmagd, Osama Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd Adhikari, Shubhodeep Broadcom Corporation Agarwal, Peyush Broadcom Corporation Aio, Kosuke Sony Corporation Alayasra, Musab Medipol University; Vestel An, Song-Haur INDEPENDENT Anwyl, Gary MediaTek Inc. Asterjadhi, Alfred Qualcomm Incorporated Au, Kwok Shum Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd B, Hari Ram NXP Semiconductors Baek, SunHee LG ELECTRONICS Baik, Eugene Qualcomm Incorporated Bankov, Dmitry IITP RAS Batra, Anuj Apple, Inc. Bhandaru, Nehru Broadcom Corporation Bredewoud, Albert Broadcom Corporation Cao, Rui NXP Semiconductors Carney, William Sony Corporation chen, jindou Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd Cheng, Paul MediaTek Inc. CHERIAN, GEORGE Qualcomm Incorporated Chu, Liwen NXP Semiconductors CHUN, JINYOUNG LG ELECTRONICS Coffey, John Realtek Semiconductor Corp. Das, Dibakar Intel Corporation Das, Subir Perspecta Labs Inc. Dash, Debashis Apple, Inc. Dave, Brajesh Apple, Inc. Dong, Xiandong Xiaomi Inc. Doostnejad, Roya Intel Corporation









Duan, Ruchen SAMSUNG Fang, Yonggang ZTE TX Inc feng, Shuling MediaTek Inc. Fischer, Matthew Broadcom Corporation Ghaderipoor, Alireza MediaTek Inc. Ghosh, Chittabrata Intel Corporation Guo, Yuchen Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd Han, Jonghun SAMSUNG Han, Zhiqiang ZTE Corporation Handte, Thomas Sony Corporation Hervieu, Lili Cable Television Laboratories Inc. (CableLabs) Ho, Duncan Qualcomm Incorporated Hsieh, Hung-Tao MediaTek Inc. Hu, Chunyu Facebook Huang, Guogang Huawei Huang, Lei Panasonic Asia Pacific Pte Ltd. Huang, Po-Kai Intel Corporation Hwang, Sung Hyun Electronics and Telecommunications Research

Institute (ETRI) Jang, Insun LG ELECTRONICS Ji, Chenhe Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd Jia, Jia Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd jiang, feng Apple Inc. Jiang, Jinjing Apple, Inc. Kain, Carl USDoT Kakani, Naveen Qualcomm Incorporated Kamel, Mahmoud InterDigital, Inc. Kedem, Oren Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd Khorov, Evgeny IITP RAS Kim, Jeongki LG ELECTRONICS Kim, Myeong-Jin SAMSUNG kim, namyeong LG ELECTRONICS Kim, Sang Gook LG ELECTRONICS Klein, Arik Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd Klimakov, Andrey Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd Kneckt, Jarkko Apple, Inc. Ko, Geonjung WILUS Inc. Kondo, Yoshihisa Advanced Telecommunications Research Institute

International (ATR) Kumar, Manish Marvell Semiconductor, Inc. Kwon, Young Hoon NXP Semiconductors Lalam, Massinissa SAGEMCOM BROADBAND SAS Lan, Zhou Broadcom Corporation Lansford, James Qualcomm Incorporated Latif, Imran Quantenna Communications, Inc. Lee, Wookbong SAMSUNG Levitsky, Ilya IITP RAS Levy, Joseph InterDigital, Inc. Li, Guoqing Apple, Inc. Li, Nan ZTE Corporation Li, Yunbo Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd Liang, dandan Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd Liu, Jianfei HUAWEI Liu, Jianhan MediaTek Inc.



Liu, Yong Apple, Inc. Lopez, Miguel Ericsson AB Lou, Hanqing InterDigital, Inc. Lu, Liuming ZTE Corporation Luo, Chaoming Beijing OPPO telecommunications corp., ltd. Lv, kaiying MediaTek Inc. Ma, Li MediaTek Inc. Ma, Mengyao HUAWEI Max, Sebastian Ericsson AB Mirfakhraei, Khashayar Cisco Systems, Inc. Monajemi, Pooya Cisco Systems, Inc. Montreuil, Leo Broadcom Corporation Nguyen, An DHS/CISA noh, yujin Newracom Inc. Palm, Stephen Broadcom Corporation Pare, Thomas MediaTek Inc. Park, Eunsung LG ELECTRONICS Park, Minyoung Intel Corporation Patil, Abhishek Qualcomm Incorporated Patwardhan, Gaurav Hewlett Packard Enterprise Petrick, Albert InterDigital, Inc. Puducheri, Srinath Broadcom Corporation Pulikkoonattu, Rethnakaran Broadcom Corporation Rai, Kapil Qualcomm Incorporated Redlich, Oded HUAWEI Rezk, Meriam Qualcomm Incorporated Rosdahl, Jon Qualcomm Technologies, Inc. Roy, Sayak NXP Semiconductors Sambasivan, Sam AT&T Sedin, Jonas Ericsson AB Seok, Yongho MediaTek Inc. Sethi, Ankit NXP Semiconductors Shilo, Shimi HUAWEI Solaija, Muhammad Sohaib Istanbul Medipol University; Vestel Song, Taewon LG ELECTRONICS Stanley, Dorothy Hewlett Packard Enterprise Startsev, Ivan IITP RAS SUH, JUNG HOON Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd Sun, Bo ZTE Corporation Sun, Li-Hsiang InterDigital, Inc. Sun, Yanjun Qualcomm Incorporated Sundman, Dennis Ericsson AB SURACI, FRANK U.S. Department of Homeland Security Tanaka, Yusuke Sony Corporation Tian, Bin Qualcomm Incorporated Tsodik, Genadiy Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd Urabe, Yoshio Panasonic Corporation Varshney, Prabodh Nokia Verenzuela, Daniel Sony Corporation Verma, Lochan Qualcomm Incorporated Verma, Sindhu Broadcom Corporation Vermani, Sameer Qualcomm Incorporated Wang, Chao Chun MediaTek Inc. Wang, Hao Tencent



Wang, Huizhao Quantenna Communications, Inc. Wang, Lei Huawei R&D USA Wang, Qi Apple, Inc. Wu, Kanke Qualcomm Incorporated Wu, Tianyu Apple, Inc. Wullert, John Perspecta Labs Xin, Yan Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd Yan, Aiguo Oppo Yang, Jay Nokia YANG, RUI InterDigital, Inc. Yang, Steve TS MediaTek Inc. Yano, Kazuto Advanced Telecommunications Research Institute

International (ATR) Yee, James MediaTek Inc. yi, yongjiang Futurewei Technologies Yona, Yair Qualcomm Incorporated Yong, Su Khiong Apple, Inc. Young, Christopher Broadcom Corporation Yu, Jian Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd Yukawa, Mitsuyoshi Canon, Inc. Zein, Nader NEC Laboratories Europe Zeng, Yan Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd Zhang, Yan NXP Semiconductors Zuo, Xin Tencent

4. Announcements: Nothing mentioned.

5. Any objection to proceed with the agenda?C: For the 1961r4, can we defer it to the end of MAP General? ok.C: What is the idea for the D0.1 – Status and Updates discussion? The idea is to finalize the joint items as well as going through the yellow parts.C: The agenda is approved.

Motions (concentrated within the first 90 mins of the call) in document 841r12

1. Approve TG minutes.

Move to approve TGbe minutes of teleconferences listed below:• Teleconferences May-July:

https://mentor.ieee.org/802.11/dcn/20/11-20-0775-06-00be-may-july-tgbe-teleconference-minutes.docx

Move: Dennis Sundman, Second: Edward Au

Discussion: No discussion.

Approved with unanimous consent.

2. Motion 119.

Move to add to the 11be SFD, candidate specification text in 11-20/566r44 that is identified with the following tags:




https://mentor.ieee.org/802.11/dcn/20/11-20-0841-12-00be-tgbe-motions-list-for-teleconferences.pptx


• SP103, SP104, SP105, SP106, SP107, SP108, SP109, SP110, SP111, SP112, SP113, SP114, SP115, SP116, SP117, SP118, SP119, SP120, SP121, SP122, SP123, SP124, SP125, SP126, SP127, SP128, SP129, SP130.

Move: Edward Au, Second: Stephen (Kiwin) Palm


Approved with unanimous consent.

3. Motion 120. (Amended by motion 121)

Move to add to the 11be SFD the following text: • 11be agrees to define mechanisms to support the operation of a Non-STR AP MLD

in R1• The mechanisms are limited to instantiate a Non-STR Non-AP MLD as a Soft AP

that could utilize all its links. The exact language to govern such scope is TBD.

Move: Jinjing Jian, Second: Kaiying Lu

Discussion:C: The Non-STR AP adds complexity to the spec text of R1. I also question the use case for this to be part of R1.C: There is probably needed to put some definition of Soft AP. Probably the node part of this text should be put as informative part.C: A Soft AP should be simplified as an MLD.C: I would like to move to make a motion to amend the motion to remove the “Note:”. See Motion 121. Motion amended.

Preliminary Results: Y/N/Abstain/no-vote: 85/32/24/57 preliminary fails.Final results: Y/N/A: 83/31/22 (72%) motion fails. See Appendix 1 for details.

4. Motion 121.

Move to amend Motion 120 by deleting the following term: “Note:”.

Move: Zhou Lan, Second: Yong Liu

Discission: No discussion.

Preliminary results: Y/N/Abstain/no-vote: 98/15/24/61 preliminary passes.Final results: Y/N/A: 95/15/23 motion passes. See Appendix 1 for details.

Towards TGbe D0.1 Draft – Status and Updates [~30 mins]997r9 TGbe spec text volunteers and status.

a. Updates to the document where cell-rows are marked green and release information is updated. The changes will be seen in r9.

b. Extensive discussion regarding R1/R2 for MAP-Setup.c. Straw poll: R1 vs R2 SP: Do you support that MAP-setup is classified as R1?

Result: Y/N/A: 48/46/20.d. Straw poll: Do you support having MAP-access and TXOP sharing topic under R1 spec

development?Result: Y/N/A: 52/59/13.

e. Straw poll: R1 vs R2 SP 3: Do you support having MAP-Group Management topic under R1 spec development?




Result: Y/N/A: 48/56/18.f. Straw poll: SP4: Which option do you prefer: option 1: All MAP features in R1 (unless

those already decided to be in R2), option 2: all MAP features in R2, option 3: abstainResult: Y/N/A: 53/58/17.

Technical submissions – Straw polls

1. 0674r3 , “Forward compatible OFDMA” – Xiaogang Chen (Intel)

SP

Do you agree that 11be support the design of allowing multiplexing STAs of different amendments in one transmissions with OFDMA?

STAs of different amendments may include HE, EHT and post-EHT STA;- The BW allocated to different STAs that can be mixed in one transmission is

TBD; This feature is targeted for R2.

Discussion:C: Can you modify the text and put post-EHT to its own bullet. Ok.C: Can you delete the s in transmission(s)? Ok.C: Can you add “…OFDMA using frequency domain A-PPDU”? Ok.

New text:Do you agree that 11be support the design of allowing multiplexing STAs of different amendments in one transmission with OFDMA using frequency domain A-PPDU?

STAs of different amendments may include HE, EHT- post-EHT STA is TBD;- The BW allocated to different STAs that can be mixed in one transmission is

TBD; This feature is targeted for R2.

Result: Y/N/A/no-answer: 88/1/36/51

2. 0617r3 , “Multi-AP Operation - Basic Definition” – Oren Kedem (Huawei)

Straw poll 1

Which of the options do you prefer with regards to Multi-AP set definition?- Option1 – One Static group “Multi-AP Candidate Set”- Option 2 – Two groups, one static “Multi-AP Candidate Set” and one Dynamic

group “Multi AP Operation/Active Set”

Discussion:C: We already have AP Candidate Set in the SFD. I think we need the dynamic group.C: Dynamic group per TXOP means too much overhead.C: Is this R1 or R2?A: I don’t want to specify that.C: Can we clarify that this is not intended for the SFD?

Running out of time, we will continue next session.

Adjourned at 12:59.


https://mentor.ieee.org/802.11/dcn/20/11-20-0617-03-00be-multi-ap-operation-basic-definition.pptx

https://mentor.ieee.org/802.11/dcn/20/11-20-0674-03-00be-forward-compatible-ofdma.pptx


Thursday 3 August 2020, 10:00 – 13:00 ET Split PHY and MAC.



Thursday 5 August 2020, 10:00 – 13:00 ET Only MAC.








Thursday 19 August 2020, 10:00 – 13:00 ET Only MAC.




















Thursday 20 August 2020, 10:00 – 13:00 ET

Introduction1. The Chair (Alfred Asterjadhi, Qualcomm) calls the meeting to order at 10:01. The agenda can be

found in 927r23. A reminder that this call is one with motions.







o Participants reported in IMAT: AbidRabbu, Shaima' Istanbul Medipol University; Vestel Aboulmagd, Osama Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd Abushattal, Abdelrahman Istanbul Medipol university ;Vestel Adhikari, Shubhodeep Broadcom Corporation Agarwal, Peyush Broadcom Corporation Aio, Kosuke Sony Corporation Akhmetov, Dmitry Intel Corporation Alayasra, Musab Medipol University; Vestel An, Song-Haur INDEPENDENT Ansley, Carol CommScope Asterjadhi, Alfred Qualcomm Incorporated Au, Kwok Shum Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd Awater, Geert Qualcomm Incorporated Baek, SunHee LG ELECTRONICS Baik, Eugene Qualcomm Incorporated Bankov, Dmitry IITP RAS baron, stephane Canon Research Centre France Bhandaru, Nehru Broadcom Corporation Boldy, David Broadcom Corporation Cao, Rui NXP Semiconductors Cavalcanti, Dave Intel Corporation Chen, Cheng Intel Corporation chen, jindou Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd Chen, Na MaxLinear Corp Cheng, Paul MediaTek Inc. CHERIAN, GEORGE Qualcomm Incorporated Chitrakar, Rojan Panasonic Asia Pacific Pte Ltd. Choi, Jinsoo LG ELECTRONICS Chu, Liwen NXP Semiconductors









Coffey, John Realtek Semiconductor Corp. Das, Subir Perspecta Labs Inc. de Vegt, Rolf Qualcomm Incorporated Ding, Yanyi Panasonic Corporation DOAN, DUNG Qualcomm Incorporated Dong, Xiandong Xiaomi Inc. Doostnejad, Roya Intel Corporation Duan, Ruchen SAMSUNG Eitan, Alecsander Qualcomm Incorporated Erceg, Vinko Broadcom Corporation Fang, Yonggang ZTE TX Inc feng, Shuling MediaTek Inc. Fischer, Matthew Broadcom Corporation Galati Giordano, Lorenzo Nokia Gan, Ming Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd Ghaderipoor, Alireza MediaTek Inc. Ghosh, Chittabrata Intel Corporation Godbole, sachin Broadcom Corporation Gong, Bo Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd Guo, Yuchen Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd Han, Jonghun SAMSUNG Handte, Thomas Sony Corporation Hervieu, Lili Cable Television Laboratories Inc. (CableLabs) Ho, Duncan Qualcomm Incorporated Hong, Hanseul WILUS Inc. Hsieh, Hung-Tao MediaTek Inc. Hu, Chunyu Facebook Hu, Glenn Tencent Huang, Guogang Huawei Huang, Lei Panasonic Asia Pacific Pte Ltd. Huang, Po-Kai Intel Corporation Inohiza, Hirohiko Canon Jang, Insun LG ELECTRONICS Jeon, Eunsung SAMSUNG ELECTRONICS Ji, Chenhe Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd Jia, Jia Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd jiang, feng Apple Inc. Kain, Carl USDoT Kakani, Naveen Qualcomm Incorporated Kamel, Mahmoud InterDigital, Inc. Kandala, Srinivas SAMSUNG Kang, Sugbong Apple, Inc. Kasher, Assaf Qualcomm Incorporated Kedem, Oren Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd Khan, Naseem Leidos Engineering. LLC Khorov, Evgeny IITP RAS Kim, Jeongki LG ELECTRONICS Kim, Myeong-Jin SAMSUNG Kim, Sang Gook LG ELECTRONICS Kim, Sanghyun WILUS Inc Kim, Youhan Qualcomm Incorporated Klein, Arik Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd Klimakov, Andrey Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd Kneckt, Jarkko Apple, Inc.



Ko, Geonjung WILUS Inc. Kumar, Manish Marvell Semiconductor, Inc. Lan, Zhou Broadcom Corporation Lee, Wookbong SAMSUNG Levitsky, Ilya IITP RAS Levy, Joseph InterDigital, Inc. Li, Yiqing Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd Li, Yunbo Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd Liang, dandan Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd Lim, Dong Guk LG ELECTRONICS Lin, Wei Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd LIU, CHENCHEN Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd Liu, Yong Apple, Inc. Lopez, Miguel Ericsson AB Lorgeoux, Mikael Canon Research Centre France Lou, Hanqing InterDigital, Inc. Lu, Liuming ZTE Corporation Luo, Chaoming Beijing OPPO telecommunications corp., ltd. Lv, kaiying MediaTek Inc. Lv, Lily Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd Ma, Li MediaTek Inc. Ma, Mengyao HUAWEI Max, Sebastian Ericsson AB Memisoglu, Ebubekir Istanbul Medipol University; Vestel Mohanty, Bibhu Qualcomm Incorporated Monajemi, Pooya Cisco Systems, Inc. Montreuil, Leo Broadcom Corporation Nakano, Takayuki Panasonic Corporation Naribole, Sharan SAMSUNG Nezou, Patrice Canon Research Centre France Nguyen, An DHS/CISA noh, yujin Newracom Inc. Palm, Stephen Broadcom Corporation Park, Minyoung Intel Corporation Patil, Abhishek Qualcomm Incorporated Patwardhan, Gaurav Hewlett Packard Enterprise Petrick, Albert InterDigital, Inc. Petry, Brian Broadcom Corporation Pettersson, Charlie Ericsson AB porat, ron Broadcom Corporation Puducheri, Srinath Broadcom Corporation Pulikkoonattu, Rethnakaran Broadcom Corporation Raissinia, Alireza Qualcomm Incorporated Redlich, Oded HUAWEI Rege, Kiran Perspecta Labs RISON, Mark Samsung Cambridge Solution Centre Rosdahl, Jon Qualcomm Technologies, Inc. Salman, Hanadi Istanbul Medipol University; VESTEL Sambasivan, Sam AT&T Schelstraete, Sigurd Quantenna Communications, Inc. Sedin, Jonas Ericsson AB Seok, Yongho MediaTek Inc. Sevin, Julien Canon Research Centre France Shellhammer, Stephen Qualcomm Incorporated



Shilo, Shimi HUAWEI Solaija, Muhammad Sohaib Istanbul Medipol University; Vestel Son, Ju-Hyung WILUS Inc. Song, Taewon LG ELECTRONICS Sosack, Robert Molex Incorporated Stanley, Dorothy Hewlett Packard Enterprise SU, HONGJIA Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd SUH, JUNG HOON Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd Sun, Bo ZTE Corporation Sun, Li-Hsiang InterDigital, Inc. Sun, Yanjun Qualcomm Incorporated Sundman, Dennis Ericsson AB SURACI, FRANK U.S. Department of Homeland Security Tanaka, Yusuke Sony Corporation THOUMY, Francois Canon Research Centre France Tian, Bin Qualcomm Incorporated Trainin, Solomon Qualcomm Incorporated Tsodik, Genadiy Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd Urabe, Yoshio Panasonic Corporation Van Zelst, Allert Qualcomm Incorporated Varshney, Prabodh Nokia Verenzuela, Daniel Sony Corporation Verma, Sindhu Broadcom Corporation Vermani, Sameer Qualcomm Incorporated Wang, Chao Chun MediaTek Inc. Wang, Hao Tencent Wang, Lei Huawei R&D USA Wang, Qi Apple, Inc. Wang, Yi-Hsiu Zeku Wilhelmsson, Leif Ericsson AB Wullert, John Perspecta Labs Xin, Yan Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd Yang, Bo Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd Yang, Jay Nokia YANG, RUI InterDigital, Inc. Yang, Steve TS MediaTek Inc. Yano, Kazuto Advanced Telecommunications Research

Institute International (ATR) Yee, James MediaTek Inc. yi, yongjiang Futurewei Technologies Young, Christopher Broadcom Corporation Yu, Jian Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd Zein, Nader NEC Laboratories Europe Zeng, Ruochen NXP Semiconductors ZHANG, JIAYIN HUAWEI Zhang, Yan NXP Semiconductors Zuo, Xin TencentAdditionally reported through e-mail:

- Young Hoon Kwon (NXP)

4. Announcements: No announcements.

5. No objections to approve the agenda with unanimous consent.



Motions (concentrated within the first 90 mins of the call). Document 11-20/0841r17:

1. Motion 122.


• SP131, SP132, SP133, SP134, SP135, SP136, SP137, SP138, SP139, SP140, SP141, SP142, SP143, SP144, SP145, SP146, SP147, SP148, SP149, SP150, SP151, SP152, SP153, SP154, SP155, SP156, SP157, SP158, SP159, SP160, SP161, SP162, SP163, SP164, SP165, SP166, SP167, SP168, SP169, SP170.

Move: Edward Au Second: Bin TianDiscussion: None

Result: Approved with unanimous consent.

Note 1: These are all candidate SFD texts highlighted in yellow that have NOT received a request for further discussionNote 2: SP134 and SP135 were requested to be removed from SP’s author.

2. Motion 123.


• SP169

Move: Ron Porat, Second: Bin TianDiscussion:C: This requires a large table to fit all combinations. I believe it is better to reduce the number of combinations. Therefore, I am against this motion.C: We have chosen to explicitly signal these tables. It did require one additional bit, but no additional complexity at the receiver. So, I disagree with previous speaker. I am for this motion.

Result: Y/N/A: 71/42/28 (62%) Preliminary fails.Final results: Y/N/A: 70/40/27 (63%) motion fails. See Appendix 1 for details.

• Note: These are all candidate SFD texts highlighted in yellow that have received a request for further discussion

Towards TGbe D0.1 Draft–Status and Updates (Edward): https://mentor.ieee.org/802.11/dcn/20/11-20-0997-15-00be-tgbe-spec-text-volunteers-and-status.docx

SP1: Do you support that the “Priority access support for NS/EP services” to be in R1?Result: Y/N/A: 50/61/54.

SP2: Do you support that “MLO-Power save: Power state indication” is in R1?Result: Y/N/A: 63/47/36

Edward goes through the guide for specification drafting: https://mentor.ieee.org/802.11/dcn/20/11-20-1250-00-00be-a-guide-for-specification-drafting.ppt


https://mentor.ieee.org/802.11/dcn/20/11-20-1250-00-00be-a-guide-for-specification-drafting.ppt

https://mentor.ieee.org/802.11/dcn/20/11-20-1250-00-00be-a-guide-for-specification-drafting.ppt




Technical presentations

1. SP: 11-20/0596r1

Straw poll 1:

• Do you agree to use the following text to replace Motion 55 text for better clarification?11be shall define an AP candidate set* as follows:An AP candidate set is a set of APs that can initiate or participate in Multi-AP Coordination.An AP in an AP candidate set can participate as a shared AP in Multi-AP Coordination initiated by a

sharing AP in the same AP candidate set.At least one AP in an AP candidate set shall be capable of being a sharing AP.*Note: The name can be changed.

Result: Y/N/A: 95/1/36

2. SP: 11-20/0617r3

Straw poll 1:

• Which of the options do you prefer with regards to Multi-AP set definition? • Option 1 – One Static group “Multi-AP Candidate Set” • Option 2 – Two groups, one static “Multi-AP Candidate Set” and one

Dynamic group “Multi-AP Operation/Active Set”• Abstain.

Discussion:C: Which problem are you trying to solve with this dynamic grouping?A: The static group may be large. During TXOP sharing only a subset of the group will participating.C: Maybe the term “dynamic” is precise.A: I am not fully aware of the difference between dynamic and semi-static.

Result: Option1/Option2/A: 38/54/27

3. SP: 11-20/0548r3

Straw poll 1:

Do you support that 802.11be will adopt Coordinated UL MU-MIMO as an Multi-AP Coordination scheme for UL transmissions in R2?Note: Not for joint reception.

Result: Y/N/A: 76/6/43

4. 11-20/0576r1, “Coordinated Spatial Reuse Protocol” – Yongho Seok (MediaTek)

Summary: The authors propose an over-the-air protocol to enable coordinated spatial reuse (C-SR). Through simulations they show that C-SR provides higher system throughput (goodput) when transmit power control is applied than when it is not applied.

Discussion:


https://mentor.ieee.org/802.11/dcn/20/11-20-0617-03-00be-multi-ap-operation-basic-definition.pptx

https://mentor.ieee.org/802.11/dcn/20/11-20-0596-01-00be-ap-candidate-set-follow-up.pptx


Yes. Not finished, finish offline/next time.

AoB – No time left for other business.

Adjourn at 13:00 ET.



Monday 24 August 2020, 10:00 – 13:00 ET Split PHY and MAC.



Wednesday 26 August 2020, 10:00 – 13:00 ET Only MAC.





Monday 31 August 2020, 19:00 – 22:00 ET Split PHY and MAC.



Wednesday 2 September 2020, 10:00 – 13:00 ET Only MAC.




















Thursday 3 September 2020, 10:00 – 13:00 ET

Introduction2. The Chair (Alfred Asterjadhi, Qualcomm) calls the meeting to order at 10:01. The agenda can be

found in 927r37.







o Participants reported in IMAT: Abouelseoud, Mohamed Sony Corporation Aboulmagd, Osama Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd Adachi, Tomoko TOSHIBA Corporation Adhikari, Shubhodeep Broadcom Corporation Agarwal, Peyush Broadcom Corporation Aio, Kosuke Sony Corporation An, Song-Haur INDEPENDENT Ansley, Carol CommScope Anwyl, Gary MediaTek Inc. Asterjadhi, Alfred Qualcomm Incorporated Au, Kwok Shum Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd B, Hari Ram NXP Semiconductors Baek, SunHee LG ELECTRONICS Baik, Eugene Qualcomm Incorporated Banerjea, Raja Qualcomm Incorporated Bankov, Dmitry IITP RAS baron, stephane Canon Research Centre France Batra, Anuj Apple, Inc. Bhandaru, Nehru Broadcom Corporation Bluschke, Andreas Signify Bredewoud, Albert Broadcom Corporation Cao, Rui NXP Semiconductors Cariou, Laurent Intel Corporation Carney, William Sony Corporation Chen, Cheng Intel Corporation Chen, Cheng-Ming Qualcomm Incorporated









chen, jindou Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd Chen, Na MaxLinear Corp Cheng, Paul MediaTek Inc. CHERIAN, GEORGE Qualcomm Incorporated Chitrakar, Rojan Panasonic Asia Pacific Pte Ltd. Choi, Jinsoo LG ELECTRONICS Choo, Seungho Senscomm Semiconductor Co., Ltd. Chu, Liwen NXP Semiconductors CHUN, JINYOUNG LG ELECTRONICS Coffey, John Realtek Semiconductor Corp. Das, Dibakar Intel Corporation Das, Subir Perspecta Labs Inc. Dash, Debashis Apple, Inc. Davies, Robert Signify Derham, Thomas Broadcom Corporation de Vegt, Rolf Qualcomm Incorporated Ding, Baokun Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd Dong, Xiandong Xiaomi Inc. Eitan, Alecsander Qualcomm Incorporated ElSherif, Ahmed Qualcomm Incorporated Erceg, Vinko Broadcom Corporation Fang, Yonggang ZTE TX Inc feng, Shuling MediaTek Inc. Fischer, Matthew Broadcom Corporation Gan, Ming Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd Gardner, James Qualcomm Incorporated Ghosh, Chittabrata Intel Corporation GUIGNARD, Romain Canon Research Centre France Guo, Yuchen Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd Han, Jonghun SAMSUNG Han, Zhiqiang ZTE Corporation Handte, Thomas Sony Corporation Hervieu, Lili Cable Television Laboratories Inc. (CableLabs) Ho, Duncan Qualcomm Incorporated Hong, Hanseul WILUS Inc. Hsieh, Hung-Tao MediaTek Inc. Hsu, Chien-Fang MediaTek Inc. Hu, Chunyu Facebook Hu, Glenn Tencent Huang, Guogang Huawei Huang, Lei Guangdong OPPO Mobile Telecommunications

Corp.,Ltd Huang, Po-Kai Intel Corporation Hwang, Sung Hyun Electronics and Telecommunications Research

Institute (ETRI) Inoue, Yasuhiko Nippon Telegraph and Telephone Corporation

(NTT) Jang, Insun LG ELECTRONICS Jeon, Eunsung SAMSUNG ELECTRONICS



Ji, Chenhe Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd Jia, Jia Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd jiang, feng Apple Inc. Jiang, Jinjing Apple, Inc. Jones, Vincent Knowles IV Qualcomm Incorporated Kakani, Naveen Qualcomm Incorporated Kamel, Mahmoud InterDigital, Inc. Kang, Sugbong Apple, Inc. Kedem, Oren Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd Khan, Naseem Leidos Engineering. LLC Khorov, Evgeny IITP RAS Kim, Jeongki LG ELECTRONICS Kim, Myeong-Jin SAMSUNG kim, namyeong LG ELECTRONICS Kim, Sang Gook LG ELECTRONICS Kim, Sanghyun WILUS Inc Kim, Yongho Korea National University of Transportation Kim, Youhan Qualcomm Incorporated Kishida, Akira Nippon Telegraph and Telephone Corporation

(NTT) Klein, Arik Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd Kneckt, Jarkko Apple, Inc. Kondo, Yoshihisa Advanced Telecommunications Research

Institute International (ATR) Kumar, Manish Marvell Semiconductor, Inc. Kwon, Young Hoon NXP Semiconductors Lalam, Massinissa SAGEMCOM BROADBAND SAS Lansford, James Qualcomm Incorporated Lee, Wookbong SAMSUNG Le Houerou, Brice Canon Research Centre France Levitsky, Ilya IITP RAS Levy, Joseph InterDigital, Inc. Li, Nan ZTE Corporation Li, Yiqing Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd Li, Yunbo Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd Lim, Dong Guk LG ELECTRONICS Lin, Wei Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd LIU, CHENCHEN Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd Liu, Yong Apple, Inc. Lopez, Miguel Ericsson AB Lorgeoux, Mikael Canon Research Centre France Lou, Hanqing InterDigital, Inc. Lu, Liuming ZTE Corporation Luo, Chaoming Beijing OPPO telecommunications corp., ltd. Lv, Lily Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd Ma, Li MediaTek Inc. Ma, Mengyao HUAWEI Madpuwar, Girish Broadcom Corporation Memisoglu, Ebubekir Istanbul Medipol University; Vestel



Merlin, Simone Qualcomm Incorporated Mirfakhraei, Khashayar Cisco Systems, Inc. Mohanty, Bibhu Qualcomm Incorporated Monajemi, Pooya Cisco Systems, Inc. Montreuil, Leo Broadcom Corporation Nakano, Takayuki Panasonic Corporation Nezou, Patrice Canon Research Centre France Nguyen, An DHS/CISA noh, yujin Newracom Inc. Nurani Krishnan, Neelakantan Qualcomm Incorporated Palm, Stephen Broadcom Corporation Park, Eunsung LG ELECTRONICS Park, Minyoung Intel Corporation Patil, Abhishek Qualcomm Incorporated Patwardhan, Gaurav Hewlett Packard Enterprise Petrick, Albert InterDigital, Inc. Pettersson, Charlie Ericsson AB porat, ron Broadcom Corporation Puducheri, Srinath Broadcom Corporation Pulikkoonattu, Rethnakaran Broadcom Corporation Rai, Kapil Qualcomm Incorporated Raissinia, Alireza Qualcomm Incorporated Redlich, Oded HUAWEI Rosdahl, Jon Qualcomm Technologies, Inc. Roy, Sayak NXP Semiconductors Salman, Hanadi Istanbul Medipol University; VESTEL Sambasivan, Sam AT&T Sandhu, Shivraj Qualcomm Incorporated Schelstraete, Sigurd Quantenna Communications, Inc. Sedin, Jonas Ericsson AB Seok, Yongho MediaTek Inc. Sethi, Ankit NXP Semiconductors Sevin, Julien Canon Research Centre France Shellhammer, Stephen Qualcomm Incorporated Shilo, Shimi HUAWEI Solaija, Muhammad Sohaib Istanbul Medipol University; Vestel Song, Taewon LG ELECTRONICS Strauch, Paul Qualcomm Incorporated SU, HONGJIA Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd SUH, JUNG HOON Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd Sun, Bo ZTE Corporation Sun, Li-Hsiang InterDigital, Inc. Sun, Yanjun Qualcomm Incorporated Sundman, Dennis Ericsson AB SURACI, FRANK U.S. Department of Homeland Security Tanaka, Yusuke Sony Corporation THOUMY, Francois Canon Research Centre France Tian, Bin Qualcomm Incorporated Torab Jahromi, Payam Facebook



Trainin, Solomon Qualcomm Incorporated Tsodik, Genadiy Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd Urabe, Yoshio Panasonic Corporation Van Nee, Richard Qualcomm Incorporated Van Zelst, Allert Qualcomm Incorporated Varshney, Prabodh Nokia Verma, Lochan Qualcomm Incorporated Verma, Sindhu Broadcom Corporation Vermani, Sameer Qualcomm Incorporated VIGER, Pascal Canon Research Centre France Wang, Chao Chun MediaTek Inc. Wang, Huizhao Quantenna Communications, Inc. Wang, Lei Huawei R&D USA Wang, Qi Apple, Inc. Wentink, Menzo Qualcomm Wu, Kanke Qualcomm Incorporated Wu, Tianyu Apple, Inc. Wullert, John Perspecta Labs Xin, Yan Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd Xue, Qi Qualcomm Incorporated Yang, Jay Nokia YANG, RUI InterDigital, Inc. Yang, Steve TS MediaTek Inc. Yano, Kazuto Advanced Telecommunications Research

Institute International (ATR) Yee, James MediaTek Inc. yi, yongjiang Futurewei Technologies Yong, Su Khiong Apple, Inc. Young, Christopher Broadcom Corporation Yu, Jian Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd Yu, Mao NXP Semiconductors Yukawa, Mitsuyoshi Canon, Inc. ZEGRAR, Salah Eddine Istanbul Medipol University; Vestel Zein, Nader NEC Laboratories Europe Zeng, Yan Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd ZHANG, JIAYIN HUAWEI Zhang, Yan NXP Semiconductors Zhou, Yifan Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd Zou, Tristan Qualcomm Incorporated Zuo, Xin Tencent

o Reported through e-mail: Kaiying Lu

7. Announcements:a. 1269r1 Sep-Nov-tgbe-teleconference-agendas. The Chair goes through the agenda for the

September to November meeting.

8. Some updates regarding revision numbers on presentations. No objections to approve the agenda with unanimous consent.


https://mentor.ieee.org/802.11/dcn/20/11-20-1269-01-00be-sep-nov-tgbe-teleconference-agendas.docx


Motions (concentrated within the first 90 mins of the call) 841r19 TGbe motions list for teleconferences

1. Motion 124Move to add to the 11be SFD, candidate specification text in 11-20/566r59 that is identified with the following tags:

• SP171, SP172, SP173, SP174, SP175, SP176, SP177, SP178, SP179, SP180, SP181, SP182, SP183, SP184, SP185, SP186, SP187, SP188, SP189.

Move: Edward Au, Second: Bin Tian



Note: These are all candidate SFD texts highlighted in yellow that have NOT received a request for further discussion

2. Motion 125Move to define mechanisms to support the operation of a Non-STR AP MLD in R1. The mechanisms are limited to instantiate a Non-STR Non-AP MLD as a Soft AP that could utilize all its links under TBD conditions. The exact language to govern such scope is TBD.

Move: Jinjing Jiang, Second: Kaiying Lu

Discussion:C: I think we have the intention to define a Soft AP. We haven’t decided how many primary channels there are going to be. Naturally there will be some additional complexity. I don’t believe there are any big throughput gains with this. I suggest we wait with this until R2.C: I support this motion. I don’t agree with the previous speaker. I believe there is a significant gain with this.C: Is this an SFD motion?A: Yes.

Preliminary Result: Y/N/A: 104/33/24 Preliminary passesFinal result: Y/N/A: 103/33/24 (75%) motion passes. See Appendix 1 for details.

3. Motion 126Move to amend the following paragraph of the TGbe SFD• The NS/EP Priority Service if supported by a non-AP STA, shall use a TID value (TBD) that

is greater than 7 an action frame to indicate the need for priority access to its associated AP STA and to be included in Release 1 specification.

Move: Subir Das, Second: Vinko Erceg



4. Motion 127Move to add to the 11be SFD, candidate specification text in 11-20/566r59 that is identified with the following tags:

• SP175


https://mentor.ieee.org/802.11/dcn/20/11-20-0841-19-00be-tgbe-motions-list-for-teleconferences.pptx


Move: Ron Porat, Second: Bin Tian

Discussion:C: Some background technical details from Ron Porat.C: This requires 1 byte additional overhead and a large table with many entries, that is actually not needed. I am against this motion.C: I agree with previous speaker that we need to design other things before we can decide this.

Preliminary results: Y/N/A: 87/39/25 Preliminary failsFinal Result: Y/N/A: 87/37/24 motion fails. See Appendix 1 for details.

Note: These are all candidate SFD texts highlighted in yellow that have received a request for further discussion

Towards TGbe D0.1 Draft–Status and Updates (Edward) 997r28 TGbe spec text volunteers and status

1. Recorded discussions in the spec text document.

Technical Submissions-MAP SR1. 590r0 , “Coordinated Spatial Reuse: Focus on Downlink” – Jonghun Han

Summary:

Discussion:C: Slide 4. What about multi-user?A: I am working on that.C: Slide 7. How often do we need these reports?A: Good question. I’m not sure at this point, but I believe it is semi-static.C: Slide 10. How does the STAs know which frequency to send the BA?A: Working on that.C: I think this is a good direction. I support SP1.

Technical Submissions-MAP-Protection1. 643r0 , “MU-RTS in Multi-AP Operation” – Yunbo Li

Summary: Modified MU-RTS through a centralized solution.

Discussion:C: It seems the Sharing AP can reach all Shared STAs. I don’t think this assumption works.A: I do have the intention that the Sharing AP covers all the Shared STAs.C: How do you expect the shared AID space to work in practice?C: Could we still have BSS color collisions? And is that a problem?C: Can you wait with the SP until after presentation 933?A: Yes, sure.

2. 644r0 , “NAV Setting in Multi-AP Operation” – Yunbo Li

Summary: The authors have identified a problem with setting NAVs in UL Multi-AP transmissions. They have two options to solve it.

Discussion:


https://mentor.ieee.org/802.11/dcn/20/11-20-0644-00-00be-nav-setting-in-multi-ap-operation.pptx

https://mentor.ieee.org/802.11/dcn/20/11-20-0643-00-00be-mu-rts-in-multi-ap-operation.pptx

https://mentor.ieee.org/802.11/dcn/20/11-20-0590-00-00be-shared-txop-spatial-reuse-considerations.pptx



C: I believe you should take a step back and look at your assumption.C: Can you go to the option 1, trigger 1 and trigger 2 are TB PPDUs. Why does shared AP send the trigger 2?C: Does not the Sharing AP need to know some information about the Shared AP state?A: Yes.

3. 933r0 , “Hidden Node Protection in Coord. AP TXs” – Dennis Sundman

Summary: The authors have identified that there are two classes of TXOP protection, through a centralized or a distributed protocol.

Discussion:C: I think SP2 is premature since there are many coordinated AP TX schemes.A: Agree.

SP1: Remove “increased”.Y/N/A: 87/4/24

AoB: None.

Adjourned at 12:58.


https://mentor.ieee.org/802.11/dcn/20/11-20-0933-00-00be-hidden-node-protection-in-coordinated-ap-transmissions.pptx


Wednesday 9 September 2020, 10:00 – 13:00 ET Only MAC.

MAC: https://mentor.ieee.org/802.11/dcn/20/11-20-1079-20-00be-minutes-for-tgbe-mac-ad-hoc-teleconferences-in-july-and-september-2020.docx

Thursday 10 September 2020, 19:00 – 22:00 ET Split PHY and MAC.











Appendix 1

Motion 120:

Calculated Results : 85Y, 32N, 24A, [72%]Amended Results : 83Y, 31N, 22A, [72%]

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ [V] Lochan Verma Apple | X | | | [V] Yonggang Fang ZTE TX | X | | | sam sambasivan | X | | | AT&T: VOTER [V] Prabodh Varshney Nokia | X | | | [V] Miguel Lopez Ericsson | X | | | [V] Rui Yang InterDigital | | X | | [V] Jim Lansford Qualcomm | | X | | [VM] Al Petrick Interdigital | | X | | [V] Sang Kim LGE | X | | | [V] Youhan Kim Qualcomm | | X | | [V] Sebastian Max Ericsson | | X | | [V] Joseph Levy InterDigital | | X | | [V] Yongho Seok Mediatek | X | | | [V] Wookbong Lee Samsung | X | | | [V} Zhou Lan Broadcom | X | | | [V] Cheng Chen Intel | | | X | [V] Junghoon Suh Huawei | X | | | [V] Chunyu Hu FB | X | | | [V] Jonas Sedin Ericsson | | | X | [V] Li-Hsiang Sun interdigital | | X | | [V] laurent cariou, Intel | | | X | [V] Yujin Noh Newracom | X | | | [V] Yong Liu Apple | X | | | [V]Manish Kumar nxp_ | X | | | [V] Song H An Independent | | | X | [V] Gaurav Patwardhan HPE | | X | | [V] Bill Carney Sony | X | | | [V] Yanjun Sun Qualcomm | | X | | [V] Jinjing Jiang Apple | X | | | [V] George Cherian Qualcomm | | X | | [V] Chittabrata Ghosh Intel | | X | | [V] dibakar das Intel | | | X | [V] Carl Kain USDOT/Noblis | X | | | [V]Guogang Huang Huawei | X | | | [V]-XIANDONG DONG XIAOMI | | X | | [V] Jason Yuchen Guo Huawei | X | | | [V] Steve TS Yang MediaTek | X | | | [V] Taewon Song LGE | X | | | [A]Jay Yang Nokia | | | X | INVALID VOTE: NON VOTER [V] Ross Jian Yu Huawei | X | | | [P]Ding Yanyi Panasonic | | | X | [V] Bo Sun ZTE | X | | | [V] Shubhodeep Adhikari Broadcom | X | | | [V] Yunbo Li Huawei Technologies | X | | | [V] Harry Wang Tencent | | | X | [V] Rui Du Huawei | X | | | [V] Wei Lin Huawei | X | | | [V] Rob Sun Huawei | X | | | [V] Eunsung Park LGE | X | | | [V] Yoshihisa Kondo ATR | X | | | [V] Sanghyun Kim WILUS | | | X | [V]Mengyao Ma Huawei | X | | | [V] Kazuto Yano ATR | | | X | [V] Myeongjin Kim Samsung | X | | | [V] James Yee, MediaTek | X | | | [V] Insun Jang LGE | X | | | [V] Jeongki Kim LGE | X | | | [V] Chenhe Ji Huawei | X | | | [V] Ming Gan Huawei | X | | | [V] Yifan Zhou Huawei | X | | |



Jindou Chen | X | | | INVALID VOTE: NO MATCH FOUND! [V] Yoshio Urabe Panasonic | | X | | [V] Hongjia Su Huawei | X | | | [V]NanLI ZTE | X | | | V Yusuke Tanaka sony | | | X | [V] Frank Hsu Mediatek | X | | | [V] Dandan Liang Huawei | X | | | [V]HungTao Hsieh Mediatek | X | | | [V] Jiayin Zhang Huawei | X | | | [V] Yang Bo Huawei | | X | | [V] Jia Jia Huawei | X | | | [V] David Yang Huawei | X | | | [V]Liuming LU ZTE | X | | | [V] Osama Aboul-Magd Huawei Technologies | | X | | AN NGUYEN | | | X | DHS/CISA: VOTER [V] Thomas Handte Sony | X | | | [V] Subir Perspecta Labs | | | X | [V] Dennis Sundman Ericsson | | | X | [V] Oded Redlich Huawei | | | X | [V]Jarkko Kneckt Apple | X | | | [V] Massinissa Lalam Sagemcom | | X | | [V] Oren Kedem Huawei | X | | | INVALID VOTE: NON VOTER [V] Genadiy Tsodik Huawei | | | X | [V] Shimi Shilo Huawei | X | | | [V] Albert Bredewoud Broadcom | X | | | [V] Arik Klein Huawei | | X | | [V] Evgeny Khorov IITP RAS | X | | | [V] Ilya Levitsky IITP RAS | X | | | [V] Dana Ciochina Sony | X | | | [V] Assaf Kasher Qualcomm | | X | | [V] YongjiangJohn Yi Futurewei | | X | | [V] Huizhao Wang Quantenna/ON Semi | | | X | [V] Minyoung Park Intel Corp. | | | X | [V] Matthew Fischer Broadcom | X | | | [V] kiwin palm «BRCM» | X | | | [V] Chao-Chun Wang MediaTek | X | | | [V] Lei Wang Futurewei/Huawei | X | | | [V] Young Hoon Kwon NXP | X | | | [V] Pooya Monajemi Cisco | | X | | [V] Duncan Ho Qualcomm | | X | | [V] Ruchen Duan Samsung | X | | | [V] Jianhan Liu Meditak Inc. | X | | | [V] Tianyu Wu Apple | X | | | [V] Khashayar Mirfakhraei Cisco systems | | | X | INVALID VOTE: NON VOTER [V] Rui Cao NXP | | | X | [V] Liangxiao Xin Sony | | | X | [V] Feng Jiang Apple | X | | | [V] Robert Stacey, Intel | | X | | [V] Debashis Dash Apple | X | | | [V] Chris Young Broadcom | X | | | guoqing | X | | | Li, Apple: VOTER [V] Sameer Vermani Qualcomm | | X | | Ron Porat | X | | | Broadcom: VOTER Imran Latif | X | | | Apple: VOTER Brajesh | X | | | Dave, Apple: VOTER [V] Srinivas Kandala Samsung | X | | | [V] Srinath Puducheri Broadcom | X | | | [V] Jon Rosdahl Qualcomm | | X | | [V] Kosuke Aio, Sony | | | X | [V] Abhishek Patil Qualcomm | | X | | [V] Bin Tian Qualcomm | | X | | [V] Sharan Naribole Samsung | X | | | [V] Lei Huang Panasonic | | | X | [V] Sindhu Verma Broadcom | X | | | [V] Yan Zhang NXP | X | | | [v] kaiying lu MediaTek | X | | | [V] Liwen Chu NXP | X | | | [V] Ali Raissinia Qualcomm | | X | | [V] Edward Au Huawei | X | | | [V] Jeff J.Q. Liu Broadcom | X | | | [V] Ahmed Elsherif Qualcomm | | X | | [V] Reza Hedayat Charter | | | X | [V] paul cheng MediaTek | X | | |



[V] Anuj Batra Apple | X | | | Qi Wang | X | | | Apple: VOTER [V] Xiaofei Wang InterDigital | | X | | [V] Naveen Kakani Qualcomm | | X | | Evan Sun | | X | | INVALID VOTE: NO MATCH FOUND! Su Khiong Yong | X | | | Apple: VOTER [V] Thomas Pare Mediatek | X | | | [V] Eugene Baik Qualcomm | | X | |

Motion 121:

Calculated Results : 98Y, 15N, 24A, [86%]Amended Results : 95Y, 15N, 23A, [86%]------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ [V] Lochan Verma Apple | X | | | [V] Yonggang Fang ZTE TX | X | | | sam sambasivan | | | X | AT&T: VOTER [V] Prabodh Varshney Nokia | X | | | [V] Miguel Lopez Ericsson | | | X | [V] Rui Yang InterDigital | X | | | [V] Jim Lansford Qualcomm | X | | | [VM] Al Petrick Interdigital | X | | | [V] Sang Kim LGE | X | | | [V] Youhan Kim Qualcomm | X | | | [V] Sebastian Max Ericsson | X | | | [V] Joseph Levy InterDigital | | | X | [V] Yongho Seok Mediatek | | X | | [V] Wookbong Lee Samsung | X | | | [V} Zhou Lan Broadcom | X | | | [V] Cheng Chen Intel | X | | | [V] Junghoon Suh Huawei | | | X | [V] Yan Xin Huawei | | | X | [V] Xiaogang Chen Intel | | | X | [V] Chunyu Hu FB | X | | | [V] Jonas Sedin Ericsson | X | | | [V] Li-Hsiang Sun interdigital | X | | | [V] laurent cariou, Intel | X | | | [V] Yujin Noh Newracom | | | X | [V] Yong Liu Apple | X | | | [V] Po-Kai Huang Intel | X | | | [V]Manish Kumar nxp_ | X | | | [V] Song H An Independent | | | X | [V] Gaurav Patwardhan HPE | X | | | [V] Bill Carney Sony | | X | | [V] Yanjun Sun Qualcomm | X | | | [V] Jinjing Jiang Apple | X | | | [V] George Cherian Qualcomm | X | | | [V] Chittabrata Ghosh Intel | X | | | [V] dibakar das Intel | X | | | [V] Carl Kain USDOT/Noblis | X | | | [V]Guogang Huang Huawei | X | | | [V]-XIANDONG DONG XIAOMI | X | | | [V] Jason Yuchen Guo Huawei | X | | | [V] Steve TS Yang MediaTek | | X | | [V] Taewon Song LGE | X | | | [A]Jay Yang Nokia | | | X | INVALID VOTE: NON VOTER [V] Ross Jian Yu Huawei | X | | | [P]Ding Yanyi Panasonic | X | | | [V] Bo Sun ZTE | X | | | [V] Shubhodeep Adhikari Broadcom | X | | | [V] Yunbo Li Huawei Technologies | X | | | [V] Harry Wang Tencent | | | X | [V] Rui Du Huawei | X | | | [V] Wei Lin Huawei | X | | | [V] Rob Sun Huawei | X | | | [V] Eunsung Park LGE | | | X | [V] Yoshihisa Kondo ATR | | | X | [V]Mengyao Ma Huawei | X | | | [V] Kazuto Yano ATR | | | X | [V] Myeongjin Kim Samsung | X | | |



[V] James Yee, MediaTek | | X | | [V] Insun Jang LGE | X | | | [V] Jeongki Kim LGE | X | | | [V] Ming Gan Huawei | X | | | Jindou Chen | X | | | INVALID VOTE: NO MATCH FOUND! [V] Yoshio Urabe Panasonic | X | | | [V] Hongjia Su Huawei | X | | | [V]NanLI ZTE | | X | | V Yusuke Tanaka sony | X | | | [V] Frank Hsu Mediatek | | X | | [V] Dandan Liang Huawei | X | | | [V]HungTao Hsieh Mediatek | | X | | [V] Jiayin Zhang Huawei | X | | | [V] Yang Bo Huawei | | X | | [V] Jia Jia Huawei | X | | | [V] David Yang Huawei | X | | | [V]Liuming LU ZTE | | X | | [V] Osama Aboul-Magd Huawei Technologies | | X | | AN NGUYEN | X | | | DHS/CISA: VOTER [V] Thomas Handte Sony | | | X | [V] Subir Perspecta Labs | | | X | [V] Dennis Sundman Ericsson | X | | | [V] Oded Redlich Huawei | | | X | [V]Jarkko Kneckt Apple | X | | | [V] Massinissa Lalam Sagemcom | | | X | [V] Oren Kedem Huawei | X | | | INVALID VOTE: NON VOTER [V] Genadiy Tsodik Huawei | | | X | [V] Shimi Shilo Huawei | | | X | [V] Albert Bredewoud Broadcom | X | | | [V] Arik Klein Huawei | X | | | [V] Evgeny Khorov IITP RAS | X | | | [V] Ilya Levitsky IITP RAS | X | | | [V] Dana Ciochina Sony | X | | | [V] Assaf Kasher Qualcomm | | X | | [V] YongjiangJohn Yi Futurewei | | X | | [V] Huizhao Wang Quantenna/ON Semi | X | | | [V] Minyoung Park Intel Corp. | X | | | [V] Matthew Fischer Broadcom | X | | | [V] kiwin palm «BRCM» | X | | | [V] Chao-Chun Wang MediaTek | X | | | [V] Lei Wang Futurewei/Huawei | X | | | [V] Young Hoon Kwon NXP | X | | | [V] Pooya Monajemi Cisco | | X | | [V] Payam Torab Facebook | | | X | [V] Duncan Ho Qualcomm | X | | | [V] Ruchen Duan Samsung | X | | | [V] Jianhan Liu Meditak Inc. | | X | | [V] Tianyu Wu Apple | X | | | [V] Khashayar Mirfakhraei Cisco systems | X | | | INVALID VOTE: NON VOTER [V] Rui Cao NXP | X | | | [V] Liangxiao Xin Sony | | | X | [V] Feng Jiang Apple | X | | | [V] Debashis Dash Apple | X | | | [V] Chris Young Broadcom | X | | | guoqing | X | | | Li, Apple: VOTER [V] Sameer Vermani Qualcomm | X | | | Ron Porat | X | | | Apple: VOTER Imran Latif | X | | | Broadcom: VOTER Brajesh | X | | | Dave, Apple: VOTER [V] Srinivas Kandala Samsung | X | | | [V] Sai Cypress | X | | | [V] Srinath Puducheri Broadcom | X | | | [V] Kosuke Aio, Sony | X | | | [V] Abhishek Patil Qualcomm | X | | | [V] Bin Tian Qualcomm | X | | | [V] Sharan Naribole Samsung | X | | | [V] Lei Huang Panasonic | | | X | [V] Sindhu Verma Broadcom | X | | | [V] Yan Zhang NXP | X | | | [V] Liwen Chu NXP | X | | | [V] Ali Raissinia Qualcomm | X | | | [V] Edward Au Huawei | | | X | [V] Jeff J.Q. Liu Broadcom | X | | |



[V] Ahmed Elsherif Qualcomm | X | | | [V] Reza Hedayat Charter | | | X | [V] Anuj Batra Apple | X | | | Qi Wang | X | | | Apple: VOTER [V] Xiaofei Wang InterDigital | X | | | Su Khiong Yong | X | | | Apple: VOTER [V] Thomas Pare Mediatek | | X | | [V] Eugene Baik Qualcomm | X | | |

Motion 123:Note that IMAT classifier is not required for voting on the motion.

Calculated Results : 71Y, 42N, 28A, [62%]Amended Results : 70Y, 40N, 27A, [63%]Amended Results [INCL. IMAT]: 54Y, 34N, 25A, [61%]------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ [V] Li-Hsiang Sun interdigital | | | X | IMAT-YES [V] Youhan Kim Qualcomm | X | | | IMAT-YES [V] Al Petrick Interdigital | X | | | IMAT-NO [V] Subir Perspecta Labs | | | X | IMAT-YES [V] Sang Kim LGE | | | X | IMAT-YES sam sambasivan | X | | | IMAT-YES [v] kaiying lu MediaTek | X | | | IMAT-NO [V] Mao Yu NXP | X | | | IMAT-NO [V] Yonggang Fang ZTE TX | | | X | IMAT-YES [V[ Sigurd Schelstraete Quantenna/ON | X | | | IMAT-YES [V] Duncan Ho Qualcomm | X | | | IMAT-YES [V] Abhishek Patil Qualcomm | X | | | IMAT-YES [V] Bin Tian Qualcomm | X | | | IMAT-YES [V} Jarkko Kneckt Apple | X | | | IMAT-NO [V] Rob Sun Huawei | | X | | IMAT-NO [V] Prabodh Varshney Nokia | X | | | IMAT-YES [V] kiwin PALM {BRCM | X | | | IMAT-YES [V] Chittabrata Ghosh Intel | X | | | IMAT-YES [V] Chao-Chun Wang MediaTek | X | | | IMAT-YES [V] Sai Cypress | X | | | IMAT-NO [V]Manish Kumar nxp_ | X | | | IMAT-YES [v] Yujin Noh Newracom | X | | | IMAT-NO [V] Young Hoon Kwon NXP | X | | | IMAT-NO [V] YongjiangJohn Yi Futurewei | | X | | IMAT-YES [V] Lei Wang Futurewei | | X | | IMAT-YES [V] laurent cariou, Intel | X | | | IMAT-NO [V] Yan Xin Huawei | | X | | IMAT-YES [V] George Cherian Qualcomm | X | | | IMAT-YES [V] Joseph Levy InterDigital | | | X | IMAT-YES [V] Po-Kai Huang Intel | X | | | IMAT-YES [V] Steve Shellhammer Qualcomm | X | | | IMAT-YES [V] Yongho Seok MediaTek | X | | | IMAT-YES [V] Pooya Monajemi Cisco | | | X | IMAT-YES [V] Bibhu Mohanty Qualcomm | X | | | IMAT-YES [V] Song H An Independent | | | X | IMAT-YES [V] Junghoon Suh Huawei | | X | | IMAT-NO [V] Eugene Baik Qualcomm | X | | | IMAT-YES [V] Jeff J.Q. Liu Broadcom | X | | | IMAT-NO [V] Yan ZhangNXP | X | | | IMAT-YES Vinko Erceg | X | | | IMAT-YES [V]Guogang Huang Huawei | | X | | IMAT-YES [V] Lei Huang Panasonic | | X | | IMAT-YES [V] Steve TS Yang MediaTek | X | | | IMAT-YES [V]Mengyao Ma Huawei | | X | | IMAT-YES [V] Ross Jian Yu Huawei | | X | | IMAT-YES [V] Ming Gan Huawei | | X | | IMAT-YES [V] Jason Yuchen Guo Huawei | | X | | IMAT-YES [V]Ding Yanyi Panasonic | | X | | IMAT-YES [V] Sindhu Verma Broadcom | X | | | IMAT-YES [V] Shubhodeep Adhikari Broadcom | X | | | IMAT-YES [V] Jia Jia Huawei | | X | | IMAT-YES [v] Lily Lv Huawei | | X | | IMAT-YES [V]Hanseul Hong WILUS | | | X | IMAT-YES [V]Glenn Hu Tencent | | X | | IMAT-YES



[V] David Yang Huawei | | X | | IMAT-NO [V] Wei LinHuawei | | X | | IMAT-YES [V] Yunbo Li Huawei Technologies | | X | | IMAT-YES [V] Rojan Chitrakar Panasonic | | X | | IMAT-YES [v] girish madpuwa broadcom | | | X | IMAT-NO [V] Oren Kedem Huawei | | X | | INVALID VOTE: NON VOTER [V] Dennis Sundman Ericsson | | | X | IMAT-YES [V] Jonas Sedin Ericsson | | | X | IMAT-YES [V] Assaf Kasher Qualcomm | X | | | IMAT-YES [V] Alecsander Eitan Qualcomm | X | | | IMAT-YES [V] Stephane Baron Canon | | | X | IMAT-YES [V] Patrice NEZOU Canon | | | X | IMAT-YES [V] Ilya Levitsky IITP RAS | | X | | IMAT-YES [V] Miguel Lopez Ericsson | | | X | IMAT-YES [V] Oded Redlich Huawei | | X | | IMAT-YES [NV] Mikael Lorgeoux Canon | | | X | INVALID VOTE: NO MATCH FOUND! [V] Thomas Handte Sony | X | | | IMAT-YES [V] Allert van Zelst Qualcomm | X | | | IMAT-YES [V] Shimi Shilo Huawei | | X | | IMAT-YES [V] Genadiy Tsodik Huawei | | X | | IMAT-YES [V] sachin godbole broadcom | X | | | IMAT-YES [V] Mark RISON {Samsung} | | | X | IMAT-NO [V] Evgeny Khorov IITP RAS | | X | | IMAT-NO [V] Arik Klein Huawei | | X | | IMAT-YES [V] David Boldy, Broadcom | X | | | IMAT-YES Solomon Trainin Qualcomm | X | | | IMAT-YES [V] Geert Awater Qualcomm | X | | | IMAT-YES [V]-XIANDONG DONG XIAOMI | | X | | IMAT-YES [V] Sanghyun Kim WILUS | | | X | IMAT-YES [V] Eunsung Park LGE | X | | | IMAT-NO [V] Insun Jang LGE | | | X | IMAT-YES [N] Bo Gong Huawei | | X | | INVALID VOTE: NO MATCH FOUND! [V] Harry Wang Tencent | | X | | IMAT-YES [V] Dongguk Lim LGE | X | | | IMAT-YES [V] Kazuto Yano ATR | | | X | IMAT-YES [V] Jinsoo Choi LGE | X | | | IMAT-YES [V] Yusuke Tanaka Sony | X | | | IMAT-YES [V] Takayuki Nakano Panasonic | | X | | IMAT-YES [V] Yoshio Urabe Panasonic | | X | | IMAT-YES [V] Yifan Zhou Huawei | | X | | IMAT-NO [V] Frank Hsu Mediatek | X | | | IMAT-NO [V]HungTao Hsieh Mediatek | X | | | IMAT-YES [V] Jeongki Kim LGE | | | X | IMAT-YES [V] Dandan Liang | | X | | IMAT-YES [V] Taewon Song LGE | X | | | IMAT-YES [V] Hongjia Su Huawei | | X | | IMAT-YES [V]Chenhe Ji Huawei | | X | | IMAT-YES [V] Myeongjin Kim Samsung | X | | | IMAT-YES [V] Kosuke Aio Sony | X | | | IMAT-YES [PV] Jonghun Han Samsung | X | | | INVALID VOTE: NON VOTER [V] Jiayin Zhang Huawei | | X | | IMAT-YES [V] Rui Du Huawei | | X | | IMAT-NO [V] Bo Sun ZTE | | | X | IMAT-YES [V] John Son WILUS | | X | | IMAT-YES [V] Yang Bo Huawei | | X | | IMAT-YES [V] Yanjun Sun Qualcomm | X | | | IMAT-YES [V] Ron Porat Broadcom | X | | | IMAT-YES [V] Wook Bong Lee Samsung | X | | | IMAT-YES [V] Cheng Chen Intel | X | | | IMAT-YES [V] James Yee, MediaTek | X | | | IMAT-YES [V] Gaurav Patwardhan HPE | | | X | IMAT-YES [V] Minyoung Park Intel | X | | | IMAT-YES [V] Rui Cao NXP | X | | | IMAT-YES [V] Jon Rosdahl Qualcomm | X | | | IMAT-YES [v] Rolf de Vegt Qualcomm | X | | | IMAT-YES [V] Qi Wang Apple | X | | | IMAT-YES [V] Yong Liu Apple | | | X | IMAT-YES [V] Feng Jiang Apple | | X | | IMAT-YES [V] Brian Petry, Broadcom | X | | | IMAT-YES [V] Na Chen, MaxLinear | X | | | IMAT-YES [V] Nehru Bhandaru Broadcom | X | | | IMAT-YES [V] Qi Xue Qualcomm | X | | | IMAT-NO Matthew Fischer | X | | | IMAT-YES



[V] Rui Yang [InterDigital] | | X | | IMAT-YES [V] Edward Au Huawei | | | X | IMAT-YES [V] Carl Kain USDoT/Noblis | | | X | IMAT-YES An Nguyen DHS | | | X | IMAT-YES [V] Osama Aboul-Magd Huawei Technologies | | X | | IMAT-YES [V] Sebastian Max Ericsson | | | X | IMAT-YES [V] VK Jones Qualcomm Inc | X | | | IMAT-NO [V] Dmitry Akhmetov, Intel | X | | | IMAT-YES [V] Srinivas Kandala Samsung | X | | | IMAT-YES [V] Thomas Pare Mediatek | X | | | IMAT-NO [V] Xiaogang Chen Intel | X | | | IMAT-NO [V] Rethna Pulikkoonattu Broadcom | X | | | IMAT-YES [V] Sharan Naribole Samsung | | | X | IMAT-YES [V] Jianhan Liu Meditak Inc. | X | | | IMAT-NO

Motion 125:Calculated Results : 104Y, 33N, 24A, [75%]Amended Results : 103Y, 33N, 24A, [75%]------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ [V] Subir Perspecta Labs | | | X | [V] Matthew Fischer Broadcom | X | | | [V] Al Petrick Interdigital | X | | | [V] Steve Shellhammer Qualcomm | | X | | [V] Yonggang Fang ZTE TX | X | | | [V] Jim Lansford Qualcomm | | X | | [V] Young Hoon Kwon NXP | X | | | [V] Youhan Kim Qualcomm | | X | | [V] Xiaofei Wang InterDigital | | | X | [V] Sigurd Schelstraete ON Semiconductor | | | X | [V] Wook Bong Lee Samsung | X | | | [V] dibakar das Intel | | | X | [V] Yujin Noh Newracom | X | | | yongho seok | X | | | [V] Abhishek Patil Qualcomm | | X | | [V] Yan Xin Huawei | X | | | [V] Prabodh Varshney Nokia | X | | | [V] Yanjun Sun Qualcomm | | X | | [V] laurent cariou, Intel | | | X | [V] Jon Rosdahl Qualcomm | | X | | [V] AN NGUYEN DHS | X | | | [V] YongjiangJohn Yi Futurewei | X | | | [V] Yong Liu Apple | X | | | [V] Huizhao Wang Quantenna/ON Semi | X | | | [V] Gaurav Patwardhan HPE | | X | | [v] Rolf de Vegt Qualcomm | | X | | [V] Bin Tian Qualcomm | | X | | [V] James Yee, MediaTek | X | | | [V] Liwen Chu NXP | X | | | [V] Qi Xue Qualcomm | | X | | [V] Liangxiao Xin Sony | X | | | [V] Edward Au Huawei | X | | | [V] Chittabrata Ghosh Intel | | | X | [V] George Cherian Qualcomm | | X | | [V] sam sambasivan AT&T | | X | | [V] Sameer Vermani Qualcomm | | X | | [V] Pooya Monajemi Cisco | | X | | [V] Lei Wang Futurewei | X | | | [V] Bill Carney Sony | X | | | [V] Junghoon Suh Huawei | X | | | [V] Osama Aboul-Magd Huawei Technologies | X | | | [V] Rui Yang [InterDigital] | X | | | [V] Carol Ansley self | | X | | [V] Alecsander Eitan Qualcomm | | X | | [V] Genadiy Tsodik Huawei | X | | | [V] Stephane Baron Canon | X | | | [V] Jiayin Zhang Huawei | X | | | [V] Oded Redlich Huawei | X | | | [V] Dennis Sundman, Ericsson | | | X | [V] Menzo Wentink Qualcomm | | X | | [V] Assaf Kasher Qualcomm | | X | |



[V] Thomas Handte Sony | X | | | [V] Arik Klein Huawei | | X | | [V] Ilya Levitsky IITP RAS | X | | | [V] Albert Bredewoud Broadcom | X | | | [V] Geert Awater Qualcomm | | X | | [V] Shimi Shilo Huawei | X | | | Solomon Trainin Qualcomm | | X | | [V] Allert van Zelst Qualcomm | | X | | [V] Jonas Sedin Ericsson | X | | | [V] Miguel Lopez Ericsson | X | | | [V] Dana Ciochina Sony | X | | | [V] Evgeny Khorov IITP RAS | X | | | [V] Pascal VIGER Canon | X | | | [V] Massinissa Lalam Sagemcom | | X | | [V] Patrice NEZOU Canon | | | X | [V] Oren Kedem Hauwei | X | | | INVALID VOTE: NON VOTER [V] Shubhodeep Adhikari Broadcom | X | | | [V] Eunsung Park LGE | X | | | [V] Ming GanHuawei | X | | | [V] Ross Jian Yu Huawei | X | | | [V] Jason Yuchen Guo Huawei | X | | | [V] Lei Huang OPPO | X | | | [V]Mengyao Ma Huawei | X | | | [V]HungTao Hsieh Mediatek | X | | | [v] girish madpuwar {Broadcom} | X | | | [V] Rojan Chitrakar Panasonic | | | X | [V] Sindhu Verma Broadcom | X | | | [V] Bo Sun ZTE | X | | | [V]Chenchen LIU Huawei | | | X | [V] Kazuto Yano ATR | | | X | [V] Wei Lin Huawei | X | | | [V] Yifan Zhou Huawei | X | | | [V] Sanghyun Kim WILUS | X | | | [V] Myeongjin Kim Samsung | X | | | [V] Dongguk Lim LGE | X | | | [V] Yusuke Tanaka sony | X | | | [V] Jeongki Kim LGE | X | | | [V] Yunbo Li Huawei Technologies | X | | | [V]-XIANDONG DONG XIAOMI | X | | | [V] Frank Hsu Mediatek | X | | | [V] Yoshio Urabe Panasonic | | | X | [V]Guogang Huang Huawei | X | | | [V] Jinsoo Choi LGE | X | | | [V] Insun Jang LGE | X | | | [V] Takayuki Nakano Panasonic | | | X | [V] Taewon Song LGE | X | | | [V] Hongjia Su Huawei | X | | | [V] Tomoko Adachi Toshiba | | X | | [V] Rob Sun Huawei | X | | | [V] Rui Du Huawei | X | | | [V] Ryuichi Hirata Sony | X | | | [V] Jia jia Huawei | X | | | [V] Yoshihisa Kondo ATR | X | | | [V]Xin Zuo Tencent | X | | | [V] Kosuke Aio Sony | X | | | [V] Akira Kishida NTT | | | X | [V] David Yang Huawei | X | | | [V] Dandan Liang | | | X | [V] John Son WILUS | X | | | [V] Yasuhiko Inoue, NTT | | | X | [V] Ronny Yongho Kim | X | | | [V] Harry Hao Wang Tencent | X | | | Glenn Hu Tencent | X | | | [V] Lochan Verma Apple | X | | | [V] Jarkko Kneckt Apple | X | | | [V] Rethna Pulikkoonattu Broadcom | X | | | [V] Sang Kim LGE | X | | | [V] kiwin palm «BRCM» | X | | | [V] Ron Porat Broadcom | X | | | [V] Qi Wang Apple | X | | | [V] Mohamed Abouelseoud Sony | X | | | [V] Na Chen, MaxLinear | | | X | [V]Lily Lv Huawei | X | | |



Simone Merlin Qualcomm | | X | | [V]Hanseul Hong WILUS | X | | | [V] Chunyu Hu FB | | | X | [V] Jinjing Jiang Apple | X | | | SK Yong | X | | | Zhou Lan | X | | | [V] Cheng Chen Intel | | | X | [V] Chao-Chun Wang MediaTek | X | | | [V] Anuj Batra Apple | X | | | [V] Payam Torab Facebook | | | X | [V]NanLI ZTE | X | | | [V] Yan ZhangNXP | X | | | [V] Minyoung Park Intel | | | X | [V] Ruchen Duan Samsung | X | | | [V] Vinko Erceg Broadcom | X | | | [V] Debashis Dash Apple | X | | | [V] Rui Cao NXP | X | | | [V] Li-Hsiang Sun interdigital | X | | | [V] Duncan Ho Qualcomm | | X | | [V] Ali Raissinia Qualcomm | | X | | [V] Feng Jiang Apple | X | | | [V] Song H An Independent | | | X | [V] Joseph Levy InterDigital | | | X | [V] Naveen Kakani Qualcomm | | X | | gabor bajko | X | | | [V] VK Jones Qualcomm Inc | | X | | [V] Sean Coffey Realtek | | X | | [V] paul cheng MediaTek | X | | | [V] Chris Young Broadcom | X | | | [V] James Gardner - Qualcomm | | X | | [V] Thomas Pare Mediatek | X | | | [V] Ahmed Elsherif Qualcomm | | X | | [V]Liuming LuZTE | X | | | [V] Bibhu Mohanty, Qualcomm | | X | | [V] Xiaogang Chen Intel | | | X | [V] Jianwei Bei NXP | X | | | sai | X | | |

Motion 127:Calculated Results : 87Y, 39N, 25A, [69%]Amended Results : 87Y, 37N, 24A, [70%]------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ [V] Subir Perspecta Labs | | | X | [V] Matthew Fischer Broadcom | X | | | [V] Al Petrick Interdigital | | X | | [V] Steve Shellhammer Qualcomm | X | | | [V] Yonggang Fang ZTE TX | | | X | [V] Jim Lansford Qualcomm | X | | | [V] Young Hoon Kwon NXP | X | | | [V] Youhan Kim Qualcomm | X | | | [V] Xiaofei Wang InterDigital | | X | | [v] kaiying lu MediaTek | X | | | [V] Sigurd Schelstraete ON Semiconductor | X | | | [V] Wook Bong Lee Samsung | X | | | [V] dibakar das Intel | X | | | [V] Yujin Noh Newracom | X | | | yongho seok | X | | | [V] Abhishek Patil Qualcomm | X | | | [V] Yan Xin Huawei | | X | | [V] Prabodh Varshney Nokia | X | | | [V] Yanjun Sun Qualcomm | X | | | [V] laurent cariou, Intel | X | | | [V] Jon Rosdahl Qualcomm | X | | | [V] AN NGUYEN DHS | X | | | [V] YongjiangJohn Yi Futurewei | | X | | [V] Huizhao Wang Quantenna/ON Semi | X | | | [V] Gaurav Patwardhan HPE | X | | | [v] Rolf de Vegt Qualcomm | X | | | [V] Bin Tian Qualcomm | X | | | [V] James Yee, MediaTek | X | | |



[V] Liwen Chu NXP | X | | | [V] Qi Xue Qualcomm | X | | | [V] Edward Au Huawei | | | X | [V] Chittabrata Ghosh Intel | X | | | [V] George Cherian Qualcomm | X | | | [V] Sameer Vermani Qualcomm | X | | | [V] Lei Wang Futurewei | | X | | [V] Junghoon Suh Huawei | | X | | [V] Osama Aboul-Magd Huawei Technologies | | X | | [V] Carol Ansley self | | | X | [V]Manish Kumar nxp_ | X | | | [V] Alecsander Eitan Qualcomm | X | | | [V] Genadiy Tsodik Huawei | | X | | [V] Stephane Baron Canon | | | X | [V] Oren Kedem Huawei | | X | | INVALID VOTE: NON VOTER [V] Jiayin Zhang Huawei | | X | | [V] Oded Redlich Huawei | | X | | [V] Dennis Sundman, Ericsson | X | | | [V] Menzo Wentink Qualcomm | X | | | [V] Assaf Kasher Qualcomm | X | | | [V] Thomas Handte Sony | X | | | [V] Arik Klein Huawei | | X | | [V] Ilya Levitsky IITP RAS | | X | | [V] Albert Bredewoud Broadcom | X | | | [V] Geert Awater Qualcomm | X | | | [V] Shimi Shilo Huawei | | X | | Solomon Trainin Qualcomm | X | | | [V] Allert van Zelst Qualcomm | X | | | [V] Jonas Sedin Ericsson | | | X | [V] Miguel Lopez Ericsson | X | | | [V] Dana Ciochina Sony | X | | | [V] Evgeny Khorov IITP RAS | | X | | [V] Pascal VIGER Canon | | | X | [V] Richard van Nee Qualcomm | X | | | [V] Massinissa Lalam Sagemcom | X | | | [V] Patrice NEZOU Canon | | | X | [V] Shubhodeep Adhikari Broadcom | X | | | [N] Namyeong Kim LGE | | | X | INVALID VOTE: NON VOTER [V] Eunsung Park LGE | X | | | [V] Ming GanHuawei | | X | | [V] Ross Jian Yu Huawei | | X | | [V] Jason Yuchen Guo Huawei | | X | | [V] Lei Huang OPPO | | X | | [V]Mengyao Ma Huawei | | X | | [V]HungTao Hsieh Mediatek | X | | | [v] girish madpuwar {Broadcom} | X | | | [V] Rojan Chitrakar Panasonic | | X | | [V] Sindhu Verma Broadcom | X | | | [V]Chenchen LIU Huawei | | X | | [N] Baokun Ding Huawei | | X | | INVALID VOTE: NON VOTER [V] David Yang Huawei | | X | | [V] Kazuto Yano ATR | | | X | [V] Wei Lin Huawei | | X | | [V] Yifan Zhou Huawei | | X | | [V] Sanghyun Kim WILUS | | | X | [V] Myeongjin Kim Samsung | X | | | [V] Yusuke Tanaka sony | X | | | [V] Jeongki Kim LGE | X | | | [V] Yunbo Li Huawei Technologies | | X | | [V]-XIANDONG DONG XIAOMI | | X | | [V] Frank Hsu Mediatek | X | | | [V] Yoshio Urabe Panasonic | | X | | [V]Guogang Huang Huawei | | X | | [V] Jinsoo Choi LGE | X | | | [V] Steve TS Yang MediaTek | X | | | [V] Insun Jang LGE | X | | | [V] Chenhe Ji Huawei | | X | | [V] Taewon Song LGE | X | | | [V] Hongjia Su Huawei | | X | | [V] Tomoko Adachi Toshiba | | | X | [V] Rob Sun Huawei | | X | | [V] Rui Du Huawei | | X | | [V] Ryuichi Hirata Sony | | | X |



[V] Jia jia Huawei | | X | | [V] Yoshihisa Kondo ATR | X | | | [V]Xin Zuo Tencent | | X | | [V] Kosuke Aio Sony | X | | | [V] Akira Kishida NTT | | | X | [V] John Son WILUS | | | X | [V] Yasuhiko Inoue, NTT | X | | | [V] Harry Hao Wang Tencent | | X | | Glenn Hu Tencent | | X | | [V] Rethna Pulikkoonattu Broadcom | X | | | [V] Sang Kim LGE | X | | | [V] kiwin palm «BRCM» | X | | | [V] Ron Porat Broadcom | X | | | [V] Mohamed Abouelseoud Sony | | | X | [V] Na Chen, MaxLinear | X | | | [V]Lily Lv Huawei | | X | | [V] Po-Kai Huang Intel | X | | | Simone Merlin Qualcomm | X | | | [V]Hanseul Hong WILUS | | | X | [V] Chunyu Hu FB | | | X | Zhou Lan | X | | | [V] Cheng Chen Intel | X | | | [V] Chao-Chun Wang MediaTek | X | | | [V] Anuj Batra Apple | X | | | [V] Payam Torab Facebook | | | X | [V]NanLI ZTE | | | X | [V] Yan ZhangNXP | X | | | [V] Minyoung Park Intel | X | | | [V] Ruchen Duan Samsung | X | | | [V] Vinko Erceg Broadcom | X | | | [V] Debashis Dash Apple | X | | | [V] Rui Cao NXP | X | | | [V] Sai Cypress | | | X | [V] Peyush Agarwal Broadcom | X | | | [V] Li-Hsiang Sun interdigital | | | X | [V] Duncan Ho Qualcomm | X | | | [V] Ali Raissinia Qualcomm | X | | | [V] Feng Jiang Apple | X | | | [V] Song H An Independent | | | X | [V] Joseph Levy InterDigital | | | X | [V] Naveen Kakani Qualcomm | X | | | [V] VK Jones Qualcomm Inc | X | | | [V] Chris Young Broadcom | X | | | [V] James Gardner - Qualcomm | X | | | [V] Thomas Pare Mediatek | X | | | [V] Ahmed Elsherif Qualcomm | X | | | [V]Liuming LuZTE | | | X | [V] Bibhu Mohanty, Qualcomm | X | | | [V] Eugene Baik Qualcomm | X | | | [V] Srinath Puducheri Broadcom | X | | |


doc.: ieee 802.11-20/1109r7 · web viewthe chair (alfred asterjadhi, qualcomm) calls the meeting to...

Documents