doc 58;indictment 06272013.pdf

8/14/2019 Doc 58;Indictment 06272013.pdf

1/76

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURTDISTRICT OF MASSACHUSETTS

UNITED STATES OF AMERICACrim. No.- v. -Viola t ions :18 U.S.C. 2332a - Use of a Weapon

DZHOKHAR A. TSARNAEV, of Mass Dest ruc t ion and Conspiracy;a /k /a Jahar Tsa rn i , 18 U.S.C. 2332f - Bombing of aPlace of Publ ic Use and Conspiracy;Defendant . 18 U.S.C. 844 i) n) Malicious Dest ruc t ion of Propertyand Conspiracy;

18 U.S.C. 924 c) - Use of aFirearm During and in Rela t ion to aCrime of Violence;18 U.S.C. 924 j ) - Use of aFirearm During and in Rela t ion to aCrime of Violence Causing Death;18 U.S.C. 2119 2) - CarjackingResul t ing in Ser ious Bodi ly In ju ry ;18 U.S.C. 1951 - In t e r fe renceWith Commerce by Threats o rViolence ;18 U.S.C. 2 - Aiding andAbett ing;18 U.S.C. s 981 a) 1) G) For fe i tu re .

The Grand Jury charges t ha t :At a l l t imes re l evan t t o t h i s Ind ic tment , unless otherwise

indica ted:GENER L LLEG TIONS

1. DZHOKHAR A. TSARNAEV was a n a tu r a l i z ed United Sta t e sc i t i z e n r es id ing i n Cambridge, Massachuset ts .

2. Tamerlan Tsarnaev was a Russian c i t i z e n r es id ing inCambridge, Massachuse t t s .

Case 1:13-cr-10200-GAO Document 58 Filed 06/27/13 Page 1 of 74


2/76

3. The 117 t h running of the Boston Marathon ( theMarathon ) took place on Apri l 15, 2013. The Marathon i s anannual race t ha t a t t r a c t s thousands of runners from a l l o v e r theUnited Sta tes and the world. I t i s normal ly held on Pa t r io t sDay, a Massachuset ts hol iday t ha t ce lebra tes American pa t r io t i smand independence. Every year , f r iends and family members of therunners , and t ens of thousands of others , l i ne the race course tocheer on the runners and enjoy the race .

4. Many runners and t he i r family members t r a v e l to theBoston, Massachuset ts area from other s t a t e s and coun t r i e s ands tay a t loca l a rea ho te l s , ea t a t loca l a rea res t au ran t s , andshop a t loca l area bus inesses .

5. The f i na l s t r e t c h of the Boston Marathon runs eastwardalong the cen te r of Boyls ton S t re e t in Boston from HerefordSt ree t to the f in i sh l ine , which i s loca ted between Exeter andDartmouth Stree t s . ow metal ba r r i e r s l i ne both edges of thes t r e e t and separa te the spec ta to r s from the runners . Manybus inesses l i ne the s t r e e t s of the Marathon route . In the areanear the f i n i s h l i ne , bus inesses are loca ted on both s ide s ofBoylston St ree t , inc luding res t au ran t s , a department s to re , aho te l , and var ious r e t a i l s to res .

6. On Apri l 15, 2013, a t approximately 2:49 p.m. , whilethe Marathon was st ll underway, two improvised explos ive devices( IEDs ) exploded on the nor th s ide of Boyls ton St r e e t a long the

-2



3/76

Marathon 's f i na l s t r e t c h . The f i r s t exploded in f ront ofMarathon Spor t s l oca t ed a t 671 Boyls ton St r e e t and the secondexploded in f ront of the Forum res t au ran t loca ted a t 755Boylston Stree t . The IEDs were placed near the metal b a r r i e r swhere hundreds of spec ta to r s were watching runners approach thef in i sh l ine . Each explos ion k i l l ed a t l ea s t one person, maimed,burned, and wounded scores o f o ther s and damaged publ ic andpr iva te proper ty inc lud ing proper ty owned by people andbusinesses in the loca t ions where the explos ions occurred.

7. The IEDs t ha t exploded a t the Marathon werecons t ruc ted from pre ssure cookers, low explos ive powder,shrapnel adhesive , and o ther mate r ia l s . They were concealedi ns ide black backpacks.

8. Insp i re magazine i s an English language onl inepub l i ca t ion of al-Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula . Volume One ofInsp i re magazine, which i s dated summer 2010, conta ins d e t a i l edins t ruc t ions for cons t ruc t ing IEDs us ing pre ssure cookers ,explosive powder from f i reworks, shrapne l adhesive , and othe rmater ia l s . IEDs cons t ruc ted in t h i s manner a re designed to shredf lesh s ha t t e r bone, and cause extreme pa in and su f fe r ing aswell as death.

9. On Apri l 18, 2013, a t approximately 5:00 p.m. , theFederal Bureau of Inves t iga t ion ( FBI ) publ i shed on i t s web s i t ephotographs of Tamerlan Tsarnaev and DZHOKHAR A TSARNAEV

-3



4/76

i den t i fy ing them as the two i nd iv idua l s suspec ted of detonat ingIEDs a t the Marathon. ( I t did not i d e n t i fy them by name becauselaw enforcement had not ye t l ea rn ed t h e i r names). Thesephotographs were widely disseminated on t e l e v i s i o n and elsewhere .

10. On Apri l 19, 2013, while DZHOKH R A. TS RN EV washiding from p o l i c e in a drydocked boat in a Watertown,Massachuset ts backyard , he wrote a message on an i ns ide wal l andbeams of the boa t t h a t sa id (among othe r th ings ) : The U.s.Government i s k i l l i n g our i nnocen t c iv i l i a ns ; I c a n ' t s tand tosee such e v i l go unpunished; We Muslims a re one body, you hur tone you hur t us a l l ; Now I d o n ' t l i k e k i l l i n g innocen t peoplet i s fo rb idden in Is lam but due t o sa id [ u n in t e l l i g ib l e ] t i s

a l lowed ; and Stop k i l l i n g our innocen t peop le and we w i l ls top.

- 4



5/76

COUNT ONEConspiracy to Use A Weapon

Of Mass estruct ion Result ing in Death(18 U.S.C. 2332a(a) 2

11. The Grand Jury r ea l leges and incorpora tes by re fe renceparagraphs 1 through 10 and fur the r charges tha t :

12. From a t l e a s t in or about February 2013, up to andinc luding on or about Apri l 19, 2013, in the D i s t r i c t ofMassachuset ts and elsewhere, the defendant ,

DZHOKHAR A TSARNAEVknowingly conspi red with Tamerlan Tsarnaev to use a weapon ofmass des t ruc t ion , namely, a des t ruc t ive dev ice as def ined byT i t l e 18, United Sta t e s Code, Sect ion 921, without lawfulau tho r i ty , aga ins t a person and proper ty in the United Sta tes ,and 1) such proper ty was used in i n t e r s t a t e and fore ign commerceand in an ac t i v i t y t ha t a f f ec t s i n t e r s t a t e and fore ign commerce;

2) the mail and a f a c i l i t y of i n t e r s t a t e and fo re ign commercewere used in fur therance of the offense; 3) a perpe t ra tort raveled in and caused another to t r ave l in i n t e r s t a t e andfore ign commerce in fur therance of the of fense ; and 4) theoffense, and the r e su l t s of the offense , a f fec t ed i n t e r s t a t e andfore ign commerce.

13. The conspi racy re su l t ed in a t l e a s t one per son s death;spec i f i ca l ly , t r e s u l t e d i n the dea ths of Krys t le MarieCampbell, Off ice r Sean Col l ie r , Lingzi Lu, and Mart in Richard.

-5



6/76

OVERT ACTS

14. In fur therance of the conspiracy, and to e f f e c t i t si l l ega l object , DZHOKHAR A TSARNAEV the defendant , and TamerlanTsarnaev committed the fol lowing ove r t ac t s , among others , in theD is t r i c t of Massachuset ts and elsewhere:

15. At a t ime unknown to the Grand Jury , but before on orabout Apri l 15, 2013, DZHOKHAR A TSARNAEV downloaded to h iscomputer a d i g i t a l copy of a book en t i t l ed , The Sl ic ing Sword,Against the One Who Forms Allegiances With the Disbe l ievers andTakes Them as Suppor ters Ins tead of Allah, His Messenger and TheBel ievers . The ve rs ion t ha t DZHOKHAR A TSARNAEV downloaded hada foreword by Anwar Al-Awlaki, who was a well-known al-Qaedapropagandist . This pub l ica t ion di rec t s Muslims not to give t he i ra l legiance to governments t ha t invade Muslim l ands .

16. At a t ime unknown to the Grand Jury , but before on orabout Apri l 15, 2013, DZHOKHAR A TSARNAEV downloaded to h iscomputer a pub l ica t ion en t i t l ed Defense of the Muslim Lands, theFi r s t Obliga t ion After Imam, by Abdullah Azzam, who i s alsoknown as the Father of Global J ihad . This pub l ica t ionadvocates violence designed to t e r ro r i z e the perce ived enemies ofIslam, among o ther th ings .

17. At a t ime unknown to the Grand Jury , but before on o rabout Apri l 15, 2013, DZHOKHAR A TSARNAEV downloaded to h iscomputer a d i g i t a l copy of the publ ica t ion , J ihad and the

-6



7/76

Effec ts of In ten t ion Upon I t . The ve rs ion he downloaded waspubl ished by an ex t remis t web forum c a l l e d At-Tibyanpubl ica t ions . The pub l ica t ion g l o r i f i e s martyrdom in the serv iceof v io len t j ihad .

18. At a t ime unknown to the Grand Jury , bu t before on o rabout Apri l IS 2013 DZHOKHAR A TSARNAEV downloaded to h iscomputer a copy of Volume One of Insp i re magazine which includesin s t ruc t ions on how to bu i ld IEDs using pre ssure cookers o rsec t ions of pipe, explos ive powder from f i reworks , and shrapnelamong o ther th ings .

19. On o r about February 6 2013 Tamerlan Tsarnaevt r ave led to Phantom Fireworks in Seabrook New Hampshire andpurchased 48 mortars con ta in ing approximately e igh t pounds of lowexplos ive powder.

20. On o r about March 20 2013 DZHOKHAR A TSARNAEV andTamerlan Tsarnaev t r av e l ed t o a f i r i ng range in Manchester NewHampshire where DZHOKHAR A TSARNAEV ren ted two mm handgunspurchased 200 rounds of ammunition and engaged in t a rg e tprac t ice with Tamerlan Tsarnaev for approximately one hour.

21. On o r about A p r i l S , 2013 Tamerlan Tsarnaev used thei n t e rne t to o rde r e lec t ron ic components t ha t could be adapted fo ruse in making IEDs and those components were de l ive red by theUnited Sta tes Pos ta l Serv ice to the Cambridge Massachuset tsres idence shared by DZHOKHAR A TSARNAEV and Tamerlan Tsarnaev.

- 7



8/76

22. On o r about Apri l 14 2013 DZHOKH R A. TS RN EV openeda prepaid c e l l phone account under the name Jahar Tsarni .

23. On Apr i l 15 2013 a t approximately 2:40 p.m. TamerlanTsarnaev walked to the f ron t of Marathon Spor t s a t 671 Boyls tonSt ree t , where he placed a backpack concea l ing an lED cons t ruc tedfrom a pressure cooker low explos ive powder shrapne l , adhesivee lec t ron ic components and o ther mate r ia l s , among a dense crowdof Marathon spec ta to r s t h a t inc luded men women and chi ldren .

24. On Apr i l 15 2013 a t approximately 2:40 p .m. DZHOKH RA. TS RN EV walked to the f ron t of the Forum r e s t au r an t a t 755Boyls ton St ree t , where he placed a backpack conceal ing an lEDcons t ruc ted from a pressure cooker low exp los ive powdershrapnel , adhesive e lec t ron ic components and o th e r mater ia l s ,among a dense crowd of Marathon spec ta to r s t ha t inc luded menwomen and ch i ld ren .

25. On Apri l 15 2013 a t approximately 2:48 p.m. DZHOKH RA. TS RN EV c a l l e d Tamerlan Tsarnaev using h i s prepa id c e l l phoneand spoke to him fo r seve ra l seconds.

26. On Apri l 15 2013 a t approximately 2:49 p .m. secondsa f t e r DZHOKH R A. TS RN EV completed h is phone c a l l to TamerlanTsarnaev Tamerlan Tsarnaev detonated the bomb he had placed inf ront of Marathon Spor t s , k i l l i n g Krys t l e Marie Campbell andmaiming and s e r io u s ly i n ju r in g many o ther s .

-8



9/76

27. On Apri l 15, 2013, a t approximately 2:49 p.m. , secondsa f t e r Tamerlan Tsarnaev de tona ted the bomb he had placed in f rontof Marathon Spor ts on Boylston St ree t , DZHOKHAR A TSARNAEVdetonated the bomb he had placed in f ron t of the Forum r es tau ran ton Boylston St ree t , k i l l i ng Lingzi Lu and Mart in Richard, andmaiming and se r ious ly in ju r ing many o ther s .

28. On o r before Apr i l 18, 2013, DZHOKHAR A TSARNAEVs tored in h is co l l ege dormitory room h i s computer and a backpackcontain ing f i reworks t ha t had been emptied of low explos ivepowder.

29. On Apri l 18, 2013, a t approximately 8:45 p.m. , a fewhours a f t e r t e l e v i s i o n s t a t i ons and o ther media begandissemina t ing a photograph of DZHOKHAR A TSARNAEV t ha ti d e n t i f i e d him as a suspec t in the Marathon bombings, DZHOKHAR ATSARNAEV sen t a t e x t message to a col lege c lassmate and closef r i end t ha t read, I f you want u can go to my room and take whatyou want.

30. On Apri l 18, 2013, a t approximately 10:00 p.m.,DZHOKHAR A TSARNAEV and Tamerlan Tsarnaev armed themselves withf ive IEDs, a Ruger P95 mm semiautomatic handgun, ammunition forthe Ruger, a machete, and a hunting kni fe , and drove in t he i rHonda Civic to the Massachuset ts I n s t i t u t e of Technology ( MIT )in Cambridge, Massachuset ts .

-9



10/76

31. On Apri l 18, 2013, a t approximately 10:25 p.m. , in thev ic in i ty of 32 Vassar St ree t in Cambridge, Massachuset ts ,DZHOKHAR A. TSARNAEV and Tamerlan Tsarnaev murdered Sean Col l i e ran MIT Pol ice Off ice r by shoot ing him in the head a t c lose rangewith a Ruger P95 mm semiautomatic handgun, and at tempted tos tea l h is s e rv ice weapon.

32. On Apri l 18, 2013, a t approximately 11:00 p.m., in thev ic in i ty of 60 Brigh ton Avenue in Boston, Massachuset ts , DZHOKHARA. TSARNAEV and Tamerlan Tsarnaev car jacked D.M. 's l easedMercedes ML350 by poin t ing a gun a t D.M. and th rea ten ing to k i l lhim. They ind ica ted to D.M. t h a t they in tended to dr ive hisvehic le to Manhattan.

33. Afte r ca r j ack ing and kidnaping D.M., DZHOKHAR A.TSARNAEV and Tamerlan Tsarnaev forced him to dr ive to Watertown,Massachuset ts , where they re t r i eved a por tab le GPS device andothe r i tems from t h e i r Honda Civic . Then they forced D.M. todr ive to a gas s t a t i on in order to ill the Mercedes 's gas tank.

34. While DZHOKHAR A. TSARNAEV and Tamerlan Tsarnaev weresearch ing fo r a gas s t a t i on they drove D.M. to a Bank of Americabranch in Watertown Square and forced D.M. to hand over h isAutomatic Te l l e r Machine ( ATM ) deb i t card and persona li de n t i f i c a t i on number ( PIN ) . Then DZHOKHAR A. TSARNAEV usedthe ATM card and PIN to withdraw $800 from D.M. 's Bank of Americaaccount aga ins t D.M. 's wi l l .

-10



11/76

35. On Apri l 19 2013 a t approximately 12:15 a .m. D Mescaped from the Mercedes and ca l l ed 911. DZHOKH R A TS RN EVand Tamerlan Tsarnaev then drove to the v i c i n i t y of Laurel St ree tand Dexter Avenue in Watertown Massachuset ts where o f f i c e r s ofthe Watertown Pol ice Department loca ted them and t r i e d toapprehend them.

36. On Apri l 19 2013 a t approximately 12:43 a .m.DZHOKH R A TS RN EV and Tamerlan Tsarnaev began f i r i ng a t theo f f i c e r s t ry ing to apprehend them and used four IEDs aga ins tthem one of which was made from a pre ssure cooker low explosivepowder shrapne l and o ther mate r ia l s .

37. On Apri l 19 2013 a t approximately 12:50 a .m. a f t e ra t tempt ing to shoot bomb and k i l l o r d isab le the lawenforcement of f i c e r s who were t ry ing to apprehend them TamerlanTsarnaev was t a ck led by t h ree Watertown po l ice of f i c e r sSergeant Je f f rey Pugl iese Sergeant John MacLellan and OfficerJohn Reynolds and s t rugg led with them as they t r i ed tohandcuff him. DZHOKH R A TS RN EV reen te red the Mercedes anddrove t d i r e c t ly a t the t h ree po l ice of f i c e r s .

38. When DZHOKH R A TS RN EV drove the Mercedes a t thethree po l i ce of f i c e r s he ba re ly missed Sergeant Je f f r e yPugliese who was a t t empt ing to drag Tamerlan Tsarnaev to safe ty .Then DZHOKH R A TS RN EV ran over Tamerlan Tsarnaev se r ious lyin ju r ing him and con t r ibu t ing to h i s death .

-11



12/76

39. In the course of making h i s escape in the MercedesDZHOKH R A TS RN EV a l so caused Richard Donohue a Massachuset tsBay Transpor ta t ion Author i ty of f i c e r to su s t a i n se r ious bodi lyin jury .

40. Afte r escaping in the Mercedes DZHOKH R A TS RN EVabandoned the car on Spruce s t r e e t in Watertown smashed both ofh is ce l l phones and hid in a drydocked boa t in a Watertownbackyard un t i l he was captured by po l ice .

All i n v i o l a t i o n of Ti t l e 18 United Sta tes Code Sect ion2332a a) 2)

- 1 2



13/76

COUNT TWO:Use o f a eapon o f Mass Destruct ionResult ing in Death; Aiding and Abett ing

(18 U.S.C. 2332a(a) 2); 18 U.S.C. 2)41. The Grand Jury r ea l l eges and i ncorpora t e s by re fe rence

paragraphs 1 through 10 and fu r the r charges t ha t :42. On o r about Apri l 15, 2013, in the D i s t r i c t of

Massachuse t t s and elsewhere , the defendant ,DZHOKHAR A. TSARNAEV

knowingly, and without lawful au thor i ty , used a weapon of massdes t ruc t ion , namely, a des t ruc t ive device as def ined in Ti t l e 18,United Sta tes Code, Sect ion 921, aga ins t a person and proper tywi th in the Uni ted Sta tes , and: (1) such prope r ty was used ini n t e r s t a t e and fore ign commerce and in an a c t i v i t y t h a t a f f e c t si n t e r s t a t e and fore ign commerce; and (2) the offense , and ther e s u l t s of the offense , a f f ec t ed i n t e r s t a t e and fo re ign commerce,to wit , DZHOKHAR A. TSARNAEV and Tamerlan Tsarnaev producedexp los ive bombs from pre ssure cookers, low explos ive powder, b a l lbear ings , na i l s , adhesives , e l ec t r o n i c components, and othe rmate r ia l s , then Tamerlan Tsarnaev, aided and abe t ted by DZHOKHARA. TSARNAEV placed and detonated one such bomb ( Pressure CookerBomb #1 ) in the v i c i n i t y of 671 Boyls ton S t re e t in Boston,Massachuset ts , which resu l t ed in a premature end to the BostonMarathon and damage to Marathon Spor t s and o ther proper ty .

-13



14/76

43. The Grand Jury fu r the r charges t h a t the o f fensere su l t ed in a t l e a s t one p e r s o n s death ; sp e c i f i c a l l y , tr esu l ted in the death o f Kryst le Marie Campbel l .

All in v i o l a t i o n o f Ti t l e 18, United S ta t e s Code, Sect ion2332a a) 2) , and Ti t l e 18, United Sta tes Code, Sect ion 2.

- 14



15/76

COUNT THREE:Possess ion and Use o f a Firearm

During and in Relat ion to a Crime o f ViolenceResul t ing in Death; Aiding and Abett ing(18 U.S.C. 924(c) j ) ; 18 U.S.C. 2)

44. The Grand Jury r e a l leges and i ncorpora t e s by re fe renceparagraphs 1 through 10 and fu r the r charges tha t :

45. On o r about Apri l 15, 2013, in the D i s t r i c t ofMassachuse t t s and elsewhere , the defendant ,

DZHOKHAR A TSARNAEVduring and in r e l a t i o n to a cr ime of v io lence for which he may beprosecuted in a cour t of the United Sta tes (namely, use of aweapon of mass des t ruc t ion as charged in Count Two of t h i sIndic tment) , did knowingly use and car ry a f i rearm and did, infur therance of such crime, knowingly possess sa id f i rearm towit , a bomb cons t ruc ted from a pressure cooker, low explos ivepowder, and o ther mate r ia l s ( Pressure Cooker Bomb #1 )

46. The Grand Jury fu r the r charges t h a t the f i rearm wasdischarged.

47. The Grand Jury fu r the r charges t ha t the f i rearm was ades t ruc t ive device as def ined in 18 U.S.C. 921(a) (4) (A).

48. The Grand Jury fu r the r charges t ha t DZHOKHAR ATSARNAEV in the course of committ ing the v io l a t i on a l l eged int h i s count, caused the dea th of a person through the use of thef irearm, and the k i l l i ng was a murder as def ined in Ti t l e 18,

-15



16/76

United Sta tes Code, Section j spec i f i ca l ly , he caused thedeath of Kryst le Marie Campbell.

All in vio la t ion of Ti t le 18, United Sta tes Code, Sect ions924 c) (1) (A) i) ( i i i ) , 924 c) (1) (B) i i ) , 924 c) (1) (C) i i ) , and924 j) 1), and Ti t le 18, United Sta tes Code, Section 2.

- 16



17/76

COUNT FOUR:Use o a Weapon f Mass Destruct ionResult ing in Death; Aiding and Abett ing

(18 U.S.C. s 2332a{a) (2); 18 U.S.C. s 2)49. The Grand Jury r ea l l eges and incorpora tes by re fe rence

paragraphs 1 through 10 and fu r the r charges tha t :50. On o r about Apri l 15, 2013, in the Di s t r i c t of

Massachuset ts , and elsewhere , the defendant ,DZHOKHAR A TSARNAEV

knowingly, and without lawful au thor i ty used a weapon of massdes t ruc t ion namely, a des t ruc t ive device as def ined by Ti t l e 18,United Sta tes Code, Sect ion 921, aga ins t a person and proper tywi th in the United Sta tes and: (1) such prope r ty was used ini n t e r s t a t e and fore ign commerce and in an a c t i v i t y t ha t a f f e c t si n t e r s t a t e and fore ign commerce; and (2) the offense and there su l t s of the offense af fec ted i n t e r s t a t e and fore ign commerce,to wit DZHOKHAR A TSARNAEV and Tamerlan Tsarnaev producedexplos ive bombs from pre ssure cookers, low exp los ive powder, ba l lbear ings na i l s adhesives e l ec t r o n i c components, and othe rma te r i a l s then DZHOKHAR A TSARNAEV placed and detonated onesuch bomb ( Pressure Cooker Bomb #2 ) in the v i c i n i t y of 755Boyls ton St ree t in Boston, Massachuset ts , which resu l t ed in apremature end to the Boston Marathon and damage to the Forumr es tau ran t and o ther proper ty .

-17



18/76

51. The Grand Jury f u r th e r charges t h a t the o f fenser esu l ted in a t l e a s t one person s death; s pe c i f i c a l l y , tr esu l ted in the deaths of Lingzi u and Mart in Richard .

All in v i o l a t i o n of Ti t l e 18, United S ta t e s Code, Sect ion2332a a) 2), and Ti t l e 18, United Sta tes Code, Sect ion 2.

-18



19/76

OUNT FIVE:Possess ion and Use o a FirearmDuring and in Relat ion to a Crime o ViolenceResult ing in Death; Aiding and Abett ing

(18 U.S.C. 924(c) & j); 18 U.S.C. 2)52. The Grand Jury r ea l l eges and incorpora tes by re fe rence

paragraphs 1 through 10 and fu r the r charges t ha t :53. On o r about Apri l 15, 2013, in the Di s t r i c t of

Massachusetts and elsewhere , the defendant ,DZHOKHAR A TSARNAEV

during and in r e l a t i o n to a crime of v io lence fo r which he may beprosecuted in a cour t of the United Sta tes (namely, use of aweapon of mass des t ruc t ion as charged in Count Four of t h i sIndic tment) , did knowingly use and car ry a f i rearm and did, infu r therance of such crime, knowingly possess s a id f i rearm, towit a bomb cons t ruc ted from a pressure cooker, low explos ivepowder, and o ther mate r ia l s ( Pressure Cooker Bomb #2 )

54. The Grand Jury fu r the r charges t ha t the f i rearm wasdischarged.

55. The Grand Jury fu r the r charges t h a t the f i rearm was ades t ruc t ive device as def ined in 18 U.S.C. 921(a) (4) (A).

56. The Grand Jury fu r the r charges t ha t DZHOKHAR ATSARNAEV in the course of committing the v i o l a t i o n a l l eged int h i s count, caused the dea th of a person through the use of thef i rearm, and the k i l l i n g was a murder as def ined in Ti t l e 18,

-19



20/76

United Sta tes Code, Sect ion 1111; spec i f i c a l l y he caused thedeaths of Lingzi Lu and Martin Richard.

All in v io l a t i on of Ti t l e 18, United Sta tes Code, Sect ions924 {c} {1} {A} {i} {i i i} 924 {c} {1} { } {i i} 924 c ) {1} { } {i i} and924{j} {1}, and Ti t l e 18, United Sta tes Code, Section 2.

- 20



21/76

OUNT SIXConspiracy to Bomb a Place o f

ubl ic Use Resul t ing in Death18 U.S.C. 2332f a) 1) c

57. The Grand Jury rea l leges and i ncorpora t e s by re fe renceparagraphs 1 through 10 and 14 through 40 and fu r the r chargestha t :

58. From a t l ea s t in o r about February 2013, up to andincluding on o r about Apri l 19, 2013, in the D i s t r i c t ofMassachusetts and elsewhere , the defendant ,

DZHOKHAR A TSARNAEVknowingly conspired with Tamerlan Tsarnaev unlawful ly to del iverplace d i scharge and detona te an explos ive and o ther l e tha ldevice in in to and aga ins t a place of publ ic use 1) with thei n t en t to cause dea th and se r ious bodi ly in ju ry and 2) with thei n t en t to cause extens ive des t ruc t ion of such place where suchdes t ruc t ion r e s u l t s in and i s l i ke ly to r e su l t in major economiclo s s .

59. The Grand Jury fu r the r charges t ha t the offense tookplace in the United Sta tes and 1) t was committed in an at temptto compel the United Sta tes to do and abs ta in from doing any ac tand 2) a vic t im was a na t iona l of ano ther s t a t e and the offensehad a subs tan t i a l e f f e c t on i n t e r s t a t e and fore ign commerce.

60. The Grand Jury fu r the r charges tha t the offenser esu l ted in the dea th o f a t l ea s t one personj spec i f ica l ly t

-21



22/76

resu l ted in the deaths of Kryst le Marie Campbell, Officer SeanCol l ier Lingzi Lu, and Martin Richard.

All in vio la t ion of Ti t l e 18, United Sta tes Code, Sect ions2332f a) 1), 2332f a) 2) and 2332f c) .

-22



23/76

OUNT SEVENBombing o f Place o f Public UseResult ing in Death; Aiding and Abett ing

(18 u.s.c. 2332f a ) 1) c) ; 18 U .S .C . 2)61. The Grand Jury r ea l l eges and i ncorpora t e s by re fe rence

paragraphs 1 through 10 and f u r th e r charges t ha t :62. On o r about Apri l 15, 2013, in the D i s t r i c t of

Massachuse t t s and elsewhere , the defendant ,DZHOKH R A. TSARNAEV

knowingly and unlawfu l ly de l ivered , placed, d ischarged, and

detonated an explos ive and o ther l e tha l device ( Pressure CookerBomb #1 ) in , in to , and aga ins t a place o f publ i c use (1) withthe i n t en t to cause dea th and se r ious bodi ly in ju ry , and (2) withthe i n t en t to cause ex tens ive des t ruc t ion o f such place , wheresuch des t ruc t ion r e s u l t s in and i s l i ke ly to r e su l t in majoreconomic lo s s , to wit , Tamerlan Tsarnaev, a ided and abe t t ed byDZHOKH R A. TSARNAEV placed Pressure Cooker Bomb #1 in f ront ofMarathon Sports loca ted a t 671 Boyls ton St ree t , Boston,Massachuset ts , and then detonated i t , causing ex tens ivedes t ruc t ion to Marathon Sports and o ther places of pub l ic use.

63. The Grand Jury f u r th e r charges t ha t the of fense tookplace in the uni t ed Sta tes , and t h a t (1) t was committed in anat tempt to compel the United Sta tes to do and abs ta in from doingany ac t , and (2) a vic t im of the o f fense was a na t iona l ofano ther s t a t e and the o f fense had a su b s t a n t i a l e f f e c t oni n t e r s t a t e and fo re ign commerce.

-23



24/76

64. The Grand Jury fu r the r charges t h a t the o f fenser esu l ted in the dea th of a t l e a s t one person j sp e c i f i c a l l y , tr esu l ted in the dea th of Kryst le Marie Campbell.

All i n v i o l a t i o n of Ti t l e 18, United s t a t e s Code, Sect ion2332f a) 1) c), and Ti t l e 18, United S ta t e s Code, Sect ion 2.

-24



25/76

OUNT EIGHT:Possess ion and Use o f a Firearm

During and in Relat ion to a Crime o f ViolenceResul t ing in Death; Aiding and Abett ing(18 U.S.C. 924 (c) j ) ; 18 U.S.C. 2)

65. The Grand Jury r ea l l eges and i ncorpora t e s by re fe renceparagraphs 1 through 10 and f u r th e r charges tha t :


DZHOKHAR A. TSARNAEVduring and in r e l a t i o n to a cr ime of v io lence fo r which he may beprosecu ted in a cour t of the United S ta t e s (namely, bombing of aplace of publ ic use, as charged in Count Seven o f t h i sInd ic tment ) , did knowingly use and ca r ry a f i rearm, and did , infu r therance o f such crime, knowingly possess s a id f i rearm, towit , a bomb cons t ruc ted from a pressure cooker , low exp los ivepowder, and o ther mate r i a l s ( Pressure Cooker Bomb #1 ) .

67. The Grand Jury f u r th e r charges t ha t the f i rearm wasdischarged.

68. The Grand Jury fu r the r charges t ha t the f i rearm was ades t ruc t ive dev ice as def ined in 18 U.S.C. 921(a) (4) (A).

69. The Grand Jury f u r th e r charges t ha t DZHOKHAR A.TSARNAEV in the course o f committ ing the v i o l a t i o n a l l eged int h i s count , caused the death of a person through the use of thef i rea rm, and the k i l l i n g was a murder as def ined in Ti t l e 18,

-25



26/76

United Sta tes Code, Section j spec i f i ca l ly , he caused thedeath of Kryst le Marie Campbell.

All in vio la t ion of Ti t le 18, United Sta tes Code, Sect ions924 c) 1) A) i) ( i i i , 924 c) 1) B) i L) , 924 c) 1) C) i i , and924 j) 1), and Ti t le 18, United Sta tes Code, Section 2.

- 2 6



27/76

OUNT NINBombing of a Place o f Public UseResult ing in Death; Aiding and Abett ing

(18 U .S .C . 2332f a ) 1) c) ; 18 U.S .C . 2)70. The Grand Jury r ea l l eges and incorpora tes by re fe rence

paragraphs 1 through 10 and fu r the r charges tha t :71. On o r about Apri l 15, 2013, in the D i s t r i c t of

Massachusetts and elsewhere , the defendant ,DZHOKHAR A. TSARNAEV

knowingly and unlawful ly de l ivered placed discharged andde tona ted an exp los ive and o ther l e tha l device ( Pressure CookerBomb 2 11 in in to and agains t a place of publ ic use (1) withthe i n t en t to cause dea th and se r ious bodi ly in ju ry and (2) withthe i n t en t to cause ex tens ive des t ruc t ion of such place wheresuch des t ruc t ion r e s u l t s in and i s l i ke ly to r e s u l t in majoreconomic lo s s to wit DZHOKHAR A. TSARNAEV placed Pressure

Cooker Bomb 2 in f ron t of the Forum res t au ran t l oca t ed a t 755Boyls ton S t re e t Boston, Massachuset ts , and then detonated i tcausing ex tens ive des t ruc t ion to the Forum res t au ran t and othe rplaces of publ i c use .

72. The Grand Jury fu r the r charges t ha t the offense tookplace in the United S ta t e s and t ha t (1) t was committed in anat tempt to compel the un i ted S ta tes to do and abs ta in from doingany ac t and (2) a vic t im of the o f fense was a na t iona l ofanother s t a t e and the offense had a subs tan t i a l e f f e c t oni n t e r s t a t e and fore ign commerce.

-27



28/76

73. The Grand Jury fu r the r charges t h a t the o f fenser esu l ted in the dea th of a t l e a s t one person; sp e c i f i c a l l y , tr esu l ted in the deaths of Lingzi Lu and Mart in Richard.

All in v i o l a t i o n o f Ti t l e 18, United S ta t e s Code, Sect ion2332f a) 1) c) , and T i t l e 18, United S ta t e s Code, Sect ion 2.

-28



29/76

OUNT TEN:Possess ion and Use o f a Firearm

During and in Relat ion to a Crime o f ViolenceResul t ing in Death; Aiding and Abett ing

(18 U.S.C. 924(c) & j ) ; 18 U.S.C. 2)74. The Grand Jury r ea l l eges and incorpora tes by re fe rence



during and in r e l a t i o n to a crime of vio lence for which he may beprosecuted in a cour t of the United Sta tes (namely, bombing of aplace of publ ic use , as charged in Count Nine of t h i sIndic tment) , did knowingly use and car ry a f i rearm and did, infur therance of such crime, knowingly possess sa id f i rearm, towit a bomb cons t ruc ted from a pressure cooker, low explos ivepowder, and o ther mate r ia l s ( Pressure Cooker Bomb #2 ) .



78. The Grand Jury fu r the r charges t ha t DZHOKHAR ATSARNAEV in the course o f committing the v io l a t i on a l l eged int h i s count, caused the death of a person through the use of thef i rearm, and the k i l l i n g was a murder as def ined in Ti t l e 18,

-29



30/76

United Sta tes Code, Sec t ion 1111; s pe c i f i c a l l y , he caused thedeath of Lingzi Lu and Martin Richard.

All i n v io l a t i on of Ti t l e 18, United Sta tes Code, Sect ions924 c) 1) A) i ) ( iii , 924 c) 1) B) i i ) , 924 c) 1) C) i i ) , and924 j ) 1), and Ti t l e 18, United Sta tes Code, Sec t ion 2.

- 3 0



31/76

COUNT ELEVENConspiracy to Malic ious ly Destroy Property

Result ing in Personal Injury and Death18 U.S.C. 844 i ) n)

79. The Grand Jury r e a l leges and i ncorpora t e s by re fe renceparagraphs 1 through 10 and 14 through 40 and fu r t h e r chargest ha t :

80. From a t l ea s t in o r about February 2013, up to andincluding on o r about Apri l 19, 2013, in the Di s t r i c t ofMassachuset ts and elsewhere, the defendant ,

DZHOKH R A. TSARNAEVknowingly conspired with Tamerlan Tsarnaev to mal ic ious ly damageand des t roy by means of f i r e and an exp los ive a bui ld ingveh ic le and o ther r e a l and personal proper ty used in i n t e r s t a t eand foreign commerce and in an a c t i v i t y a f fec t ing i n t e r s t a t e andforeign commerce.

81. The Grand Jury f u r th e r charges t ha t the o f fenser esu l ted in persona l i n ju r y t o a t l e a s t one person ; spec i f i ca l lyt r esu l ted in persona l i n ju r y to many persons who were

par t i c ipa t ing in viewing, and pass ing by the Boston Marathon.82. The Grand Jury f u r th e r charges t ha t the o f fense

r esu l ted in the dea th of a t l e a s t one person; sp e c i f i c a l l y tr esu l ted in the deaths of Kryst le Marie Campbell, Off i ce r SeanCol l i e r Lingzi Lu, and Mart in Richard.

All in v i o l a t i o n of Ti t l e 18, United S ta t e s Code, Sect ions844 i) and 844 n) .

-31



32/76

COUNT TWELVE:Malic ious Destruct ion of Property Result ing inPersonal Injury and Death; Aiding and Abetting

(18 U.S.C. 844{ i ) ; 18 U.S.C. 2)83. The Grand Jury r ea l l eges and incorpora tes by re fe rence

paragraphs 1 through 10 and fu r the r charges tha t :84. On o r about Apri l 15, 2013, in the D i s t r i c t of


mal ic ious ly damaged and dest royed and a t tempted to damage anddes t roy by means of f i r e and an explos ive a bui ld ing vehic leand other r e a l and persona l proper ty used in i n t e r s t a t e andfo re ign commerce and in an ac t i v i t y a f f e c t i n g i n t e r s t a t e andfo re ign commerce, to wit Tamerlan Tsarnaev, a ided and abe t ted byDZHOKHAR A TSARNAEV placed and detonated an exp los ive( Pressure Cooker Bomb #1 ) in the v i c i n i t y of 671 BoylstonSt ree t in Boston, Massachuset ts tha t resu l t ed in a premature endto the Boston Marathon and damage to Marathon Sports and otherbus iness proper ty .

85. The Grand Jury fu r the r charges t ha t the offenser esu l ted in persona l i n ju ry to a t l e a s t one person; spec i f i ca l lyt r esu l ted in persona l i n ju r y to many persons who were

par t i c ipa t ing in viewing, and pass ing by the Boston Marathon.86. The Grand Jury fu r the r charges t ha t the offense

r esu l ted in the dea th of a t l eas t one person; s pe c i f i c a l l y tr esu l ted in the death of Krys t le Marie Campbell.

-32



33/76

All in v i o l a t i o n of Ti t l e 18 Uni ted S ta t e s Code Sect ion844 i ) , and T i t l e 18 Uni ted Sta tes Code Sect ion 2.

- 3 3



34/76

OUNT THIRTEEN:Possess ion and Use o f a Firearm

During and in Relat ion to a Crime o f ViolenceResult ing in Death; Aiding and Abett ing

(18 U.S.C. 924 (c) & j ) ; 18 U.S.C. 2)87. The Grand Jury r ea l l eges and i ncorpora t e s by re fe rence



dur ing and in r e l a t i o n to a cr ime of v io lence for which he may beprosecuted in a cour t of the United S ta t e s (namely, malic iousdes t ruc t ion of prope r ty as charged in Count Twelve of t h i sIndic tment) , did knowingly use and car ry a f i rearm and did, infur therance of such crime, knowingly possess sa id f i rearm, towit a bomb cons t ruc ted from a pressure cooker, low explos ivepowder, and o ther mate r ia l s ( Pressure Cooker Bomb #1 )



91. The Grand Jury fu r the r charges t ha t DZHOKHAR ATSARNAEV in the course of committ ing the v io l a t i on a l l eged int h i s count, caused the dea th of a person through the use of thef irearm, and the k i l l i n g was a murder as def ined i n T i t l e 18,

- 3 4



35/76

United Sta tes Code, Sect ion 1111; spec i f ica l ly , he caused thedeath of Krys t le Marie Campbell.

All i n v io l a t i on of T i t l e 18, United Sta t e s Code, Sec t ions924 c) 1) A) i) i i i ) , 924 c) 1) B) i i ) , 924 c) 1) C) i i ) , and924 j) 1), and T i t l e 18, United Sta t e s Code, Sect ion 2.

-3 5



36/76

COUNT FOURTEEN:Malicious Des t ruc t ion o f P rope r ty R esu l t ing inPersonal In j u ry and Death; Aiding and Abet t ing

(18 U.S.C. 844( i ) ; 18 U.S.C. 2)92. The Grand Jury r ea l l eges and incorpora tes by re fe rence

paragraphs 1 through 10 and fu r the r charges t h a t :93. On o r about Apr i l 15, 2013, in the Di s t r i c t of

Massachuse t t s and elsewhere , the defendan t ,DZHOKH R A. TSARNAEV,

malic ious ly damaged and des t royed , and a t tempted to damage and

des t roy, by means of f i r e and an explos ive , a bui ld ing , veh ic le ,and o the r r e a l and persona l p rope r ty used in i n t e r s t a t e andfore ign commerce and in an a c t i v i t y a f f ec t i n g i n t e r s t a t e andfore ign commerce, to wit , DZHOKH R A. TS RN EV placed anddetonated an explos ive ~ r e s s u r e Cooker Bomb #2 ) in thev i c i n i t y of 755 Boyls ton St ree t i n Boston, Massachuset ts t ha tr esu l t ed in a premature end to the Boston Marathon and damage tothe Forum r e s t au r an t and o t h e r business prope r ty .

94. The Grand Jury fu r the r charges t ha t the of fenser esu l t ed in pe r sona l i n ju r y to a t l e a s t one person ; spec i f i ca l ly ,t r e s u l t ed in pe r sona l i n ju r y to many persons who were

par t i c ipa t ing in , viewing, and pass ing by the Boston Marathon.95. The Grand Jury f u r t h e r charges t h a t the of fense

r esu l t ed in the dea th of a t l e a s t one person; sp e c i f i c a l l y , tr esu l t ed in the dea ths of Lingzi Lu and Mart in Richard .

- 3 6



37/76

All i n v io la t ion of Ti t l e 18 United S ta t e s Code Sect ion844 i ) , and Ti t l e 18 United Sta tes Code Sect ion 2.

- 3 7



38/76

OUNT FIFTEEN:Possess ion and Use of a FirearmDuring and in Relat ion to a Crime of ViolenceResult ing in Death; Aiding and Abett ing

(18 U.S.C. 924{c) & j ) ; 18 U.S.C. 2)96. The Grand Jury r ea l l eges and i ncorpora t e s by re fe rence

paragraphs 1 through 10 and f u r th e r charges t ha t :97. On o r about Apri l 15, 2013, in the Di s t r i c t of


during and in r e l a t i o n to a cr ime of vio lence fo r which he may beprosecu ted in a cour t of the United Sta tes (namely, mal ic iousdes t ruc t ion of proper ty , as charged in Count Fourteen of t h i sInd ic tment , did knowingly use and ca r ry a f i rearm, and did , infur therance of such crime, knowingly possess s a id f i rearm, towit , a bomb cons t ruc ted from a pressure cooker , low exp los ivepowder, and o ther mate r i a l s ( Pressure Cooker Bomb #2 ) .


99. The Grand Jury f u r th e r charges t ha t the f i rearm was ades t ruc t ive dev ice as def ined in 18 U.S.C. 921(a) 4) (A).

100. The Grand Jury f u r th e r charges t h a t DZHOKHAR A.TSARNAEV in the course of commit t ing the v i o l a t i o n a l l eged int h i s count , caused the death of a person through the use of thef i rea rm, and the k i l l i n g was a murder as def ined in T i t l e 18,

-38



39/76

united Sta tes Code, Section 1111; spec i f i ca l ly , he caused thedeath of Lingzi Lu and Martin Richard.

All in v io l a t i on of Ti t l e 18, United Sta tes Code, Sect ions924 c) 1) A) i) i i i ) , 924 c) 1) B) i i ) , 924 c) 1) C) i i ) , and924 j) 1), and Ti t l e 18, United Sta tes Code, Sect ion 2.

-39



40/76

OUNT SIXTEEN:Possess ion and Use of a Firearm

During and in Relat ion to a Crime o f ViolenceResult ing in Death; Aiding and Abett ing{IS U.S.C. 924{c} { j } IS U.S.C. 2}

101. The Grand Jury r e a l leges and i ncorpora t e s by re fe renceparagraphs 1 through 10 and fu r the r charges t ha t :

102. On o r about Apri l 18, 2013, in the Di s t r i c t ofMassachuse t t s and elsewhere , the defendan t ,

DZHOKHAR A. TSARNAEVduring and in r e l a t i o n to a cr ime of vio lence fo r which he may beprosecu ted in a cour t of the uni t ed Sta tes namely, consp i racy touse a weapon of mass des t ruc t ion , as charged in Count One of t h i sInd ic tment , did knowingly use and ca r ry a f i rearm namely, aRuger P95 9mm semiautomat ic handgun) , and did , in fu r therance ofsuch crime, knowingly possess s a id f i rearm.

103. The Grand Jury fu r the r charges t h a t the f i rearm wasbrandished .


105. The Grand Jury fu r the r charges t ha t DZHOKHAR A.TSARNAEV in the course of committ ing the v i o l a t i o n a l l eged int h i s count, caused the death of a person through the use of thef i rearm, and the k i l l i ng was a murder as def ined i n T i t l e 18,United S ta t e s Code, Sect ion 1111; s pe c i f i c a l l y , he caused thedeath of Off i ce r Sean C o l l i e r .

-40



41/76

All in v io l a t i on of Ti t l e 18, United Sta tes Code, Sect ions924 c) (1) (A) i ) , i i ) i i i ) , 924 c) (1) (C) i ) , and 924 j ) 1),and Ti t l e 18, United Sta tes Code, Sect ion 2.

-41



42/76

COUNT SEVENTEEN:Possess ion and Use of Firearm

During and in Relat ion to Crime of ViolenceResult ing in Death; Aiding and Abett ingu.s U.S.C. 924 (c) j ) ; lS U.S.C. 2)106. The Grand Jury r e a l leges and i ncorpora t e s by re fe rence


Massachuse t t s and elsewhere , the defendan t ,DZHOKHAR A. TSARNAEV

during and in r e l a t i o n to a cr ime of v io lence for which he may beprosecu ted in a cour t of the United S ta t e s namely, consp i racy tobomb a place o f pUbl ic use, as charged in Count Six of t h i sInd ic tment , did knowingly use and ca r ry a f i rearm namely, aRuger P95 9mm semiautomat ic handgun) , and did , in fu r therance ofsuch crime, knowingly possess sa id f i rearm.

108. The Grand Jury f u r th e r charges t h a t the f i rearm wasbrandished .


110. The Grand Jury fu r the r charges t h a t DZHOKHAR A.TSARNAEV in the course of committ ing the v i o l a t i o n a l leged int h i s count , caused the death of a person through the use of thef i rearm, and the k i l l i n g was a murder as def ined i n T i t l e 18,United S ta t e s Code, Sect ion 1111; sp e c i f i c a l l y , he caused thedeath of Off i ce r Sean C o l l i e r .

- 42



43/76

All i n v io l a t i on of Ti t l e 18, United Sta tes Code, Sect ions924 (c) (1) (A) i ) , (i i ) i i i ) , 924 (c) (1) (C) i ) , and 924 j ) (1) ,and Ti t l e 18, United Sta tes Code, Sect ion 2.

-43



44/76

OUNT EIGHTEEN:Possess ion and Use o f a Firearm

During and in Relat ion to a Crime o f ViolenceResul t ing in Death; Aiding and Abett ing

(18 U.S.C. 924 (c) & j ) ; 18 U.S.C. 2)111. The Grand Jury r e a l leges and i ncorpora t e s by re fe rence


Massachuse t t s and elsewhere , the defendan t ,DZHOKHAR A. TSARNAEV

during and in r e l a t i on to a cr ime o f vio lence fo r which he may beprosecu ted in a cour t o f the uni t ed Sta tes namely, consp i racymal ic ious ly to des t roy proper ty , as charged in Count Eleven oft h i s Indictment , d i d knowingly use and c a r ry a f i rearm namely,a Ruger P95 mm semiautomatic handgun), and did , in fur theranceof such crime, knowingly possess s a id f i rearm.

113. The Grand Jury f u r th e r charges t h a t the f i rearm wasbrandished.


115. The Grand Jury fu r the r charges t h a t DZHOKHAR A.TSARNAEV in the course o f committ ing the v i o l a t i o n a l l eged int h i s count , caused the death of a person through the use of thefi rearm, and the k i l l i n g was a murder as def ined in T i t l e 18,United Sta tes Code, Sect ion 1111; sp e c i f i c a l l y , he caused thedea th o f Off i ce r Sean C o l l i e r .

-44



45/76

All in v io la t ion of Ti t le 18, United Sta tes Code, Sections924 (c) (1) (A) i ) , (i i ) ( i i i ) , 924 (c) (1) (C) i ) , and 924 j ) (1) ,and Ti t le 18, United Sta tes Code, Sect ion 2.

-45



46/76

OUNT NIN T NCarjacking Result ing n

Serious Bodi ly Injury; Aiding and Abett ing18 U.S.C. 2119 2); 18 U.S.C. 2)

116. The Grand Jury r ea l l eges and i ncorpora t e s by re fe renceparagraphs 1 through 10 and fu r the r charges t ha t :

117. On o r about Apri l 18, 2013, in the D i s t r i c t ofMassachuset t s and elsewhere, the defendant ,

DZHOKH R A. TSARNAEVwith the i n t e n t to cause death and se r ious bod i ly harm, knowinglytook and a t tempted to t ake from the person and presence o f D.M.,by fo rce and violence and by i n t imida t ion a motor vehic le t ha thad been t r anspor t ed shipped, and rece ived in i n t e r s t a t e andforeign commerce, t ha t i s a 2013 Mercedes ML350 bear ingMassachuset t s l i cense p l a t e 137N71 and VIN 4JGDA5HB1DA193885.

118. The Grand Jury f u r th e r charges t h a t the o f fenser esu l ted in se r ious bod i ly in ju ry to Off ice r Richard Donohue.

All in v i o l a t i o n o f Ti t l e 18, United S ta t e s Code, Sect ion2119 2) , and T i t l e 18, United Sta tes Code, Sect ion 2.

-46



47/76

COUNT TWENTYPossess ion and Use o a Firearm

During and in Relat ion oa Crime o Violence; Aiding and Abett ing

18 U.S.C. 924 c); 18 U.S.C. 2)119. The Grand Jury r ea l l eges and i ncorpora t e s by re fe rence


Massachuse t t s and elsewhere , the defendant ,DZHOKHAR A. TSARNAEV,

during and in r e l a t i o n to a cr ime of vio lence fo r which he may beprosecu ted in a cour t of the United Sta tes namely, car jack ing ,as charged in Count Nineteen of t h i s Ind ic tment ) , did knowinglyuse and ca r ry a f i rearm namely, a Ruger P95 mm semiautomatichandgun), and did , in fu r therance of such cr ime, knowinglypossess sa id f i rearm.

121. The Grand Jury fu r the r charges t h a t the f i rearm wasbrandished .

All i n v i o l a t i o n o f Ti t l e 18, United S ta t e s Code, Sect ions924 c) 1) A) i ) i i ) and 924 c) 1) C) i ) , and T i t l e 18, Uniteds t a t e s Code, Sect ion 2.

-47



48/76

COUNT TWENTY-ONEInter ference With Commerce

by Threats and Violence; Aiding and Abett ing(18 U S C 1951; 18 U S C 2)

122. The Grand Jury r ea l l eges and incorpora tes by re fe renceparagraphs 1 through 10 and fu r the r charges t ha t :


DZHOKH R A. TSARNAEV,committed a robbery t ha t in some way and degree obst ruc teddelayed, and a f f ec t ed commerce, to wit DZHOKH R A. TS RN EVunlawfu l ly took and obta ined persona l prope r ty cons i s t ing ofe ight hundred d o l l a r s from the person and in the presence ofD.M., aga ins t h is wi l l by means of ac tua l and threa tened force ,vio lence and f ea r of in ju ry immediate and fu tu re to h i s personand proper ty by fo rc ing D.M. to provide h is Bank of AmericaAutomatic Te l l e r Machine ( ATM ) deb i t card and persona li de n t i f i c a t i on number ( PIN ) to DZHOKH R A. TSARNAEV, who thenand the re used the TM card and PIN to ob ta in e igh t hundredd o l l a r s from the Bank of America branch l oca t ed a t 39 Main St ree tin Watertown, Massachuset ts .

All in v i o l a t i o n of Ti t l e 18, United S ta t e s Code, Sect ion1951, and Ti t l e 18, United Sta tes Code, Sect ion 2.

-48



49/76

COUNT TWENTY TWO:Possess ion and Use o a FirearmDuring and in Relat ion o

a Crime o Violence; Aiding and Abett ing18 U.S.C. 924 c); 18 U.S.C. 2)



DZHOKHAR A. TSARNAEV,during and in r e l a t i o n to a cr ime of vio lence fo r which he may beprosecu ted in a cour t of the United Sta tes namely, i n t e r fe rencewith commerce by t h r e a t s and vio lence , as charged in CountTwenty-One of t h i s Ind ic tment ) , d id knowingly use and ca r ry af i rearm namely, a Ruger P95 mm semiautomatic handgun), and did ,in fur therance of such crime, knowingly possess sa id f i rearm.

126. The Grand Jury f u r th e r charges t h a t the f i rearm wasbrandished .

All i n v i o l a t i o n of Ti t l e 18, United S ta t e s Code, Sect ion924 c) 1) A) i ) i i ) and 924 c) 1) C) i ) , and T i t l e 18, UnitedSta tes Code, Sect ion 2.

-49



50/76

COUNT TWENTY THREE:Use of Weapon of Mass Destruct ion;

Aiding and Abett ing18 U.S.C. 2332a a) 2); 18 U.S.C. 2)

127. The Grand Jury r ea l l eges and i nco rpora t es by re fe renceparagraphs 1 th rough 10 and fu r the r charges t ha t :

128. On o r about Apri l 19, 2013, in the D i s t r i c t ofMassachuset ts and elsewhere , the defendant ,

3

DZHOKH R A. TSARNAEV,knowingly, and without lawful au tho r i ty , used a weapon of mass

des t ruc t ion , namely, a des t ruc t ive dev ice as de f ined in T i t l e 18,United Sta tes Code, Sec t ion 921, aga ins t a person and prope r tywi th in the United Sta t e s , and: 1) such proper ty was used ini n t e r s t a t e and fo re ign commerce and in an a c t i v i t y t ha t a f fec t si n t e r s t a t e and fo re ign commerce; and 2) the of fense , and ther e s u l t s of the offense , a f fec ted i n t e r s t a t e and fore ign commerce,to wit , DZHOKH R A. TS RN EV and Tamerlan Tsarnaev used anexplos ive dev ice cons t ruc t ed from a pres su re cooker , lowexplos ive powder, and o the r mate r i a l s ( Pressure Cooker Bomb

11 ) , aga ins t law enforcement of f i ce r s in the v i c i n i t y of Laure lSt ree t and Dexter Avenue in Watertown, Massachuset ts , re su l t i ngin damage to proper ty used in an a c t i v i t y t ha t a f f ec t s in t e r s t a t eand fore ign commerce and in the closure of bus inesses , as theGovernor of Massachuset ts and o the r publ ic o f f i c i a l s askedr e s iden t s in Watertown, Boston, and elsewhere in Massachuset ts to

-5 0



51/76

a s s i s t law enforcement y remaining indoors while the of f i ce r sat tempted to apprehend DZHOKH R A TSARNAEV

All i n v i o l a t i on of Ti t l e 18, United S ta t e s Code, Sec t ion2332a a) 2), and T i t l e 18, United Sta tes Code, Sec t ion 2.

5 1 -



52/76

COUNT TWENTY FOUR:Possess ion and Use o a Firearm

During and in Relat ion oa Crime o Violence; Aiding and Abett ing

18 U.S.C. 924 c); 18 U.S.C. 2)129. The Grand Jury r e a l leges and i ncorpora t e s by re fe rence

paragraphs 1 through 10 and fu r the r charges t ha t :130. On o r about Apri l 19, 2013, in the Di s t r i c t of

Massachuse t t s and elsewhere , the defendant ,DZHOKHAR A. TSARNAEV,

during and i n r e l a t i o n to a cr ime of v io lence fo r which he may beprosecu ted in a cour t of the United Sta tes (namely, use of aweapon of mass des t ruc t ion , as charged in Count Twenty-Three oft h i s Indictment) , d id knowingly use and ca r ry a f i rearm, and did ,in fu r therance o f such crime, knowingly possess s a id f i rearm, towit , a Ruger P95 mm semiautomatic handgun ( the Ruger ) and abomb cons t ruc ted from a pressure cooker, low exp los ive powder,and othe r mater ia l s ( Pressure Cooker Bomb #3 ) .

131. The Grand Jury f u r th e r charges t h a t a f i rearm wasbrandished; s pe c i f i c a l l y , the Ruger and Pressure Cooker Bomb 3were brandished .

132. The Grand Jury fu r the r charges t h a t a f i rearm wasdischarged; s pe c i f i c a l l y , the Ruger and Pressure Cooker Bomb 3were discharged .

-52



53/76

133. The Grand Ju ry f u r t h e r charges t h a t t h e f i rearm,namely, Pres s u re Cooker Bomb 3, was a d e s t r u c t i v e dev ice asdef ined in 18 U.S.C. s 921(a) (4) (A).

All in v i o l a t i o n o f T i t l e 18, Uni ted St a t e s Code, Sect ions924 (c) (1) (A) i ) , i i ) , i i i ) , 924 (c) (1) (B) i) i i ) , and924(c) (1) (C) i ) i i ) , and T i t l e 18, Uni ted St a t e s Code, Sect ion2 .

-5 3



54/76

OUNT TWENTY FIVE:Use o f a Weapon o f Mass Destruct ion;

Aiding and Abetting18 U.S.C. 2332a a) 2) ; 18 U.S.C. 2)

134. The Grand Jury r ea l l eges and i ncorpora t e s by re fe renceparagraphs 1 through 10 and f u r th e r charges t ha t :


DZHOKH R A. TSARNAEVknowingly, and withou t lawful au thor i ty used a weapon of massdes t ruc t ion namely, a des t ruc t ive dev ice as def ined in Ti t l e 18,United Sta tes Code, Sect ion 921, aga ins t a person and proper tywi th in the Uni ted Sta tes and: (1) such prope r ty was used ini n t e r s t a t e and fore ign commerce and in an a c t i v i t y t h a t a f f e c t si n t e r s t a t e and fore ign commerce; and (2) the offense and ther e su l t s of the offense af fec ted i n t e r s t a t e and fore ign commerce,to wit , DZHOKH R A. TS RN EV and Tamerlan Tsarnaev used anexp los ive device cons t ruc ted from a sec t ion of p ipe lowexp los ive powder, and o ther mate r i a l s ( p ipe Bomb #1 ) aga ins tlaw enforcement of f i c e r s i n the v i c i n i t y of Laure l S t re e t andDexter Avenue in Watertown, Massachuset ts , r e su l t i n g i n damage toproper ty used in an a c t i v i t y t ha t a f f e c t s i n t e r s t a t e and fo re igncommerce and in the c losure of bus inesses as the Governor ofMassachuse t t s and o ther publ ic o f f i c i a l s asked r es iden ts inWatertown, Boston, and e lsewhere to a s s i s t law enforcement by

-54



55/76

remaining indoors while the of f i ce r s a t tempted to captureDZHOKH R A TSARNAEV

All i n v i o l a t i o n of T i t l e 18, United s t a t e s Code, Sec t ion2332a a) 2), and T i t l e 18, United St a t e s Code, Sec t ion 2.

5 5 -



56/76

COUNT TWENTY-SIX:Possess ion and Use o f a Firearm

During and in Rela t ion Toa Crime o f Violence ; Aiding and Abet t ing

(18 U.S.C. 924(c); 18 U.S.C. 2)136. The Grand Jury r ea l l eges and i ncorpora t e s by re fe rence

paragraphs 1 through 10 and fu r the r charges t h a t :137. On o r about Apri l 19, 2013, in the D i s t r i c t o f


during and in r e l a t i o n to a cr ime o f vio lence fo r which he may beprosecu ted in a co u r t o f the United Sta tes (namely, use o f aweapon of mass des t ruc t ion , as charged in Count Twenty-Five oft h i s Ind ic tment ) , d id knowingly use and ca r ry a f i rearm, and did ,in fu r therance o f such crime, knowingly possess s a id f i rearm, towit , a Ruger P95 mm semiautomatic handgun ( the Ruger ) and abomb cons t ruc ted from a sec t ion of pipe, low exp los ive powder,and othe r ma te r i a l s ( Pipe Bomb #1 ) .

138. The Grand Jury fu r the r charges t h a t a f i rearm wasbrandished; sp e c i f i c a l l y , the Ruger and Pipe Bomb #1 werebrandished .

139. The Grand Jury f u r th e r charges t h a t a f i rearm wasdischarged; sp e c i f i c a l l y , the Ruger and Pipe Bomb #1 weredischarged.

-56



57/76

140. The Grand Jury fu r the r charges t ha t the f i rearm,namely, Pipe Bomb 1, was a dest ruc t ive device as def ined in 18U.S.C. s 921(a) (4) (A).

All i n v io l a t i on of Ti t l e 18, United Sta tes Code, Sect ions924 (c) (1) (A) i ) , (i i ) , and (i i i ) , 924 (c) (1) (B) ( i ) ( i i) ,924(c) (1) (C) ( i ) i i ) , and Ti t l e 18, United Sta tes Code, Sect ion2.

-57



58/76

OUNT TWENTY SEVEN:Use o a Weapon Of Mass Destruct ion;

Aiding and Abett ing18 U.S.C. 2332a; 18 U.S.C. 2)

141. The Grand Ju ry r ea l l eges and i nco rpora t es by referenceparagraphs 1 through 10 and fur the r charges tha t :

142. On o r about Apri l 19, 2013, in the D i s t r i c t ofMassachuset ts and elsewhere, the defendant ,

DZHOKH R A. TSARNAEV,knowingly, and without lawful au tho r i ty used a weapon of massdest ruc t ion namely, a des t ruc t ive device as def ined in T i t l e 18,United Sta tes Code, Sect ion 921, aga ins t a person and proper tywith in the United Sta t e s and: (1) such proper ty was used ini n t e r s t a t e and fo re ign commerce and in an a c t i v i t y t ha t af fec t si n t e r s t a t e and fore ign commerce; and (2) the of fense and ther e s u l t s of the of fense a f fec t ed i n t e r s t a t e and fore ign commerce,to wit DZHOKH R A. TS RN EV and Tamerlan Tsarnaev used anexplosive device cons t ruc t ed from a sec t ion of pipe lowexplosive powder, and o the r ma te r i a l s ( Pipe Bomb #2 11 agains tlaw enforcement of f i ce r s in the v i c i n i t y of Laurel St r e e t andDexter Avenue in Watertown, Massachuset ts , r e s u l t i ng in damage toproper ty used in an a c t i v i t y t ha t a f f ec t s i n t e r s t a t e and fore igncommerce and in the closure of bus inesses as the Governor ofMassachuset ts and o the r publ ic o f f i c i a l s asked r e s iden t s inWatertown, Boston, and elsewhere to a s s i s t law enforcement by

-58



59/76

remaining indoors while the of f i ce r s a t tempted to captureDZHOKH R A TSARNAEV

All i n v i o l a t i o n of T i t l e 18, United s t a t e s Code, Sec t ion2332a a) 2), and T i t l e 18, United St a t e s Code, Sec t ion 2.

5 9 -



60/76

COUNT TWENTY EIGHT:Possess ion and Use o a FirearmDuring and in Relat ion To

a Crime o Violence; Aiding and Abetting18 U.S.C. 924 c); 8 U.S.C. 2)



DZHOKHAR A. TSARNAEV,during and in r e l a t i on to a cr ime of vio lence fo r which he may beprosecu ted in a cour t of the United Sta tes (namely, use of aweapon of mass des t ruc t ion , as charged in Count Twenty-Seven oft h i s Indictment) , d id knowingly use and ca r ry a f i rearm, and did ,in fu r therance o f such crime, knowingly possess s a id f i rearm, towit , a Ruger P95 mm semiautomatic handgun ( the Ruger ) and abomb cons t ruc ted from a sec t ion of pipe, low exp los ive powder,and othe r mater ia l s ( Pipe Bomb #2 ) .

145. The Grand Jury fu r the r charges t h a t a f i rearm wasbrandished; s pe c i f i c a l l y , the Ruger and Pipe Bomb 2 werebrandished .

146. The Grand Jury fu r the r charges t ha t a f i rearm wasdischarged; s pe c i f i c a l l y , the Ruger and Pipe Bomb #2 weredischarged.

-60



61/76

147. The Grand Jury fu r the r charges tha t the f i rearm,namely, Pipe Bomb 2, was a dest ruct ive device as def ined in 18U.S.C. 921(a) (4) (A).

All in v io la t ion of Ti t l e 18, United Sta tes Code, Sect ions924 (c ) (1) (A) i ) , ( i i ) , and i i i ) , 924 (c) (1) (B) ( i ) ( i i) ,924(c) (1) (C) (i) i i ) , and Ti t l e 18, United Sta tes Code, Sect ion2.

-61



62/76

OUNT TWENTY NINE:Use o a Weapon Of Mass Destruct ion;

Aiding and Abett ing18 U.S.C. 2332a; 18 U.S.C. 2)

148. The Grand Jury r e a l leges and i ncorpora t e s by re fe renceparagraphs 1 through 10 and fu r the r charges tha t :

149. On o r about Apr i l 19, 2013, in the Di s t r i c t ofMassachusetts and elsewhere, the defendant ,

DZHOKH R A. TSARNAEVknowingly, and withou t lawful au thor i ty used a weapon of massdes t ruc t ion namely, a des t ruc t ive dev ice as de f ined i n T i t l e 18,United Sta tes Code, Sect ion 921, aga ins t a person and prope r tywi th in the United St a t e s and: (1) such prope r ty was used ini n t e r s t a t e and fo re ign commerce and in an a c t i v i t y t h a t a f f e c t si n t e r s t a t e and fore ign commerce; and (2) the offense and ther e s u l t s of the offense a f f ec t ed i n t e r s t a t e and fore ign commerce,to wit , DZHOKH R A. TS RN EV and Tamerlan Tsarnaev used anexp los ive dev ice cons t ruc t ed from a sec t ion of pipe lowexplosive powder, and o ther mate r i a l s ( p ipe Bomb #3 ) aga ins tlaw enforcement of f i c e r s in the v i c i n i t y of Laure l and DexterSt ree t s in Watertown, Massachuset ts , r e su l t i n g i n damage toproper ty used in an a c t i v i t y t h a t a f f e c t s i n t e r s t a t e and fore igncommerce and in the c losure of bus inesses a s the Governor ofMassachuset ts and o ther publ ic o f f i c i a l s asked r es iden t s inWatertown, Boston, and elsewhere to a s s i s t law enforcement by

- 62



63/76

remaining indoors while the o f f i c e r s a t tempted to cap tu reDZHOKH R A TSARNAEV

All in v io l a t i on of Ti t l e 18, United S ta t e s Code, Sect ion2332a a) 2), and Ti t l e 18, United Sta tes Code, Sect ion 2.

63 -



64/76

OUNT THIRTYPossess ion and Use o a FirearmDuring and in Relat ion To

a Crime o Violence; Aiding and Abetting18 U.S.C. 924 c); 18 U.S.C. 2)



DZHOKHAR A. TSARNAEV,during and in r e l a t i on to a cr ime o f vio lence fo r which he may beprosecu ted in a cour t of the United Sta tes (namely, use of aweapon of mass des t ruc t ion , as charged in Count Twenty-Nine oft h i s Indic tment) , d id knowingly use and ca r ry a f i rearm, and did ,in fur therance o f such crime, knowingly possess s a id f i rearm, towit , a Ruger P95 mm semiautomatic handgun ( the Ruger ) and abomb cons t ruc ted from a sec t ion of pipe , low explos ive powder,and o the r ma te r i a l s ( Pipe Bomb #3 ) .

152. The Grand Jury f u r t h e r charges t h a t a f i rearm wasbrandished; sp e c i f i c a l l y , the Ruger and Pipe Bomb 3 werebrandished .

153. The Grand Jury fu r the r charges t h a t the f i rearm,namely, the Ruger, was discharged .

154. The Grand Jury f u r t h e r charges t h a t the f i rearm,namely, Pipe Bomb #3, was a des t ruc t ive dev ice as def ined in 18U.S.C. s 921(a) (4) (A).

- 64



65/76

Al l i n v i o l a t i o n o f T i t l e 18, Uni t ed S t a t e s Code, Sec t i on s924 c) 1) A) i ) , i L) , and iii), 924 c) 1) B) i ) ( i L) ,924 c) 1) C) i ) ii), and T i t l e 18, Uni ted S t a t e s Code, Sec t i on2.

-65



66/76

NOTI E OF SPECI L FINDINGS155. The Grand Jury r ea l l eges and incorpora tes by re fe rence

the genera l a l l ega t ions in paragraphs 1 through 10 as w el l as thea l l ega t ions in Counts One through Ten and Twelve through Eighteenof t h i s Ind ic tment as i f fu l l y s e t f o r t h he re in . The Grand Juryfu r the r a l l eges t h a t the defendant , DZHOKH R A. TSARNAEV withrespec t to the Counts spec i f i ed a f t e r each a l l ega t ion :

a . was 18 years o f age o r o lde r a t the t ime of the o f fense18 U.S.C. 3591 a) 2)) Counts One through Ten and Twelve

through Eighteen)b. i n t e n t i o n a l l y k i l l e d Kryst le Marie Campbell 18 U.S.C.

3591 a) 2) A)) Counts One, Two Three, Six , Seven, Eight ,Twelve, and Thir teen

c. i n t e n t i o n a l l y k i l l e d Off i ce r Sean C o l l i e r 18 U.S.C. 3591 a) 2) A)) Counts One, Six , Sixteen, Seventeen, Eighteen)

d. i n t e n t i o n a l l y k i l l e d Lingzi Lu 18 U.S.C. 3591 a) 2) A)) Counts One, Four, Five , Six, Nine, Ten,Fourteen, and Fif teen

e . i n t e n t i o n a l l y k i l l e d Mart in Richard 18 U.S.C. 3591 a) 2) A)) Counts One, Four, Five , Six, Nine, Ten,Fourteen, and Fif teen

f . i n t e n t i o n a l l y i n f l i c t ed se r ious bodi ly i n ju r y t h a tr esu l t ed in the dea th o f Kryst le Marie Campbell 18 U.S.C.

- 6 6



67/76

3591 a) 2) B)) Counts One, Two Three, Six, Seven, Eight ,Twelve, and Thir teen

g. i n t e n t i o n a l l y i n f l i c t e d se r ious bodi ly i n ju r y t h a tr esu l t ed in the dea th o f Off i ce r Sean Col l i e r 18 U.S.C. 3591 a) 2) B)) Counts One, Six , Sixteen, Seventeen, Eighteen)

h. i n t e n t i o n a l l y i n f l i c t e d se r ious bodi ly i n ju r y t ha tr esu l t ed in the dea th of Lingzi Lu 18 U.S.C. 3591 c) 2) B))

Counts One, Four, Five, Six , Nine, Ten, Fourteen , and Fif teeni . i n t e n t i o n a l l y i n f l i c t ed se r ious b o d i l y i n ju r y t ha t

r esu l t ed in the dea th o f Mart in Richard Counts One, Four, Five,Six, Nine, Ten, Fourteen , and Fif teen

j . i n t e n t i o n a l l y p a r t i c ip a t e d i n an ac t , contemplat ing t ha tthe l i f e of a person would be taken or in tend ing t h a t l e tha lfo rce would be used in connect ion with a person, o the r than oneof the p a r t i c i p a n t s i n the of fense , and Krys t l e Marie Campbelldied as a d i r e c t r e s u l t of the ac t 18 U.S.C. 3591 a) 2) C))

Counts One, Two Three, Six , Seven, Eight , Twelve, andThir teen)

k. i n t e n t i o n a l l y p a r t i c ip a t e d i n an ac t , contemplat ingt ha t the l i f e of a person would be taken o r in tend ing t ha t l e t h a lfo rce would be used in connect ion with a person , o the r than oneof the p a r t i c i p a n t s in the of fense , and Off i ce r Sean Col l i e r diedas a d i r e c t r e s u l t of the ac t 18 U.S.C. 3591 a) 2) C)) CountsOne, Six, Sixteen, Seventeen, Eighteen)

- 6 7



68/76

1. i n t e n t i o n a l l y p a r t i c ip a t e d i n an ac t , contemplat ingt ha t the l i f e of a person would be t aken o r in tend ing t h a t l e t h a lforce would be used in connec t ion wi th a person, o ther than oneof the p a r t i c i p a n t s in the offense , and Lingzi Lu died as ad i r e c t r e su l t of the ac t 18 U.S.C. 3591 a) 2) C)) Counts One,Four, Five, Six, Nine, Ten, Four teen, and Fif teen

m. i n t e n t i o n a l l y p a r t i c i p a t e d in an ac t , contemplat ing t h a tthe l i f e of a person would be taken o r in tending t h a t l e tha lforce would be used in connect ion wi th a person, o ther than oneof the p a r t i c i p a n t s in the of fense , and Mart in Richard died as ad i r e c t r e s u l t of the a c t 18 U.S.C. 3591 a) 2) C)) Counts One,Four, Five, Six , Nine, Ten, Fourteen, and Fif teen

n. i n t e n t i o n a l l y and s pe c i f i c a l l y engaged in an ac t ofviolence , knowing t h a t the ac t c rea t ed a grave r i s k of death to aperson, o ther than one of the p a r t i c i p a n t s i n the of fense , sucht ha t p a r t i c i p a t i o n in the ac t co n s t i t u t ed a r eck les s dis regardfor human l i f e , and Kryst le Marie Campbell died as a d i r e c tr e s u l t of the a c t 18 U.S.C. 3591 a) 2) D)) Counts One, TwoThree, Six , Seven, Eight , Twelve, and Thir teen

o. i n t e n t i o n a l l y and s pe c i f i c a l l y engaged in an ac t ofviolence , knowing t h a t the ac t c rea t ed a grave r i s k of death to aperson, o ther than one of the p a r t i c i p a n t s in the of fense , sucht ha t pa r t i c ipa t i on i n the ac t co n s t i t u t ed a r eck les s dis regardfo r human l i f e , and Off ice r Sean Col l i e r died as a d i r e c t r e s u l t

-68



69/76

of the ac t 18 U.S.C. 3591 a) 2) D)) Counts One, Six, Sixteen,Seventeen, Eighteen)

p. i n t e n t iona l ly and s pe c i f i c a l l y engaged in an ac t ofviolence , knowing t ha t the ac t crea ted a grave r i s k of dea th to aperson, o ther than one of the p a r t i c i p a n t s in the offense , sucht ha t pa r t i c ipa t i on in the ac t cons t i tu t ed a r eck les s dis regardfor human l i f e , and Lingzi Lu died as a d i r e c t r e su l t of the ac t

18 U.S.C. 3591 a) 2) D)) Counts One, Four, Five, Six , Nine,Ten, Fourteen, and Fif teen

q. i n t e n t iona l ly and s pe c i f i c a l l y engaged in an ac t ofviolence , knowing t ha t the ac t crea ted a grave r i s k of death to aperson, o ther than one of the p a r t i c i p a n t s in the offense , sucht ha t pa r t i c ipa t i on in the ac t cons t i tu t ed a r eck les s dis regardfor human l i f e , and Mart in Richard died as a d i rec t r e su l t of theac t 18 U.S.C. 3591 a) 2) D)) Counts One, Four, Five, Six,Nine, Ten, Fourteen , and Fif teen

r . knowingly crea ted a grave r i s k of dea th to one o r morepersons in add i t ion to the v ic t im of the offense in thecommission of the offense and in escaping apprehension for thev io la t ion of the offense 18 U.S.C. 3592 c) 5)) Counts nethrough Ten and Twelve through Fif teen

s . committed the of fense in an espec ia l ly heinous , crue land depraved manner in tha t t involved ser ious phys ica l abuse to

- 6 9



70/76

the vic t im (18 U.S.C. 3592(c) (6)) (Counts One through Ten andTwelve through Fif teen)

t . committed the o f fense a f t e r su b s t a n t i a l planning andpremedi ta t ion to cause the death of a person and commit an ac t oft e r ror i sm (18 U.S.C. 3592(c) (9)) (Counts One through Ten andTwelve through Fif teen)

u. i n t e n t i o n a l l y k i l l e d and a t tempted to k i l l more thanone person in a s ing le cr imina l episode (18 U.S.C. 3592(c) (16))(Counts One through Ten and Twelve through Fif teen) .

156. The Grand Jury r ea l l eges and i ncorpora t e s by re fe rencethe genera l a l l ega t ions in paragraphs 1 through 10 as wel l as thea l lega t ions in Counts One through Ten and Twelve through Eighteenof t h i s Ind ic tmen t as i f fu l l y s e t fo r th he re in . The Grand Juryfu r the r a l l eges , with re spec t t o the Counts s p ec i f i ed a f t e r eacha l lega t ion :

v. The death , and i n ju r y resu l t ing in death , of Krys t leMarie Campbell occurred dur ing the commission and a t temptedcommission of , and dur ing the immediate f l i gh t from thecommission of (1) an offense under 18 U.S.C. 2332a (use of aweapon of mass d es t r u c t i o n ) , and (2) 18 U.S.C. 844(i )

des t ruc t ion of prope r ty a f f ec t i n g i n t e r s t a t e commerce byexplos ives) (18 U.S.C. 3592(c) (1)) (Counts One, Two andTwelve)

-70



71/76

w. The death , and i n ju r y resu l t ing in death , of Off i ce rSean C o l l i e r occur red dur ing the commission and at temptedcommission of , and dur ing the immediate f l i gh t from thecommission of an offense under 18 U.S.C. 2332a use of a weaponof mass des t ruc t ion) 18 U.S.C. 3592 c) I ) ) Count One

x. The death , and in ju ry resu l t ing in death , of Lingzi Luoccurred dur ing the commission and a t tempted commission of , andduring the immediate f l i gh t from the commission of I) an offenseunder 18 U.S.C. 2332a use of a weapon of mass des t ruc t ion) ,and 2) 18 U.S.C. 844{i) des t ruc t ion of prope r ty a f f ec t i n gi n t e r s t a t e commerce by exp los ives ) 18 U.S.C. 3592{c) I ) )

Counts One, Four, and Fourteen)y. The death , and i n ju r y resu l t ing in death , of Mart in

Richard occurred dur ing the commission and at tempted commissionof , and during the immediate f l i g h t from the commission of I) anoffense under 18 U.S.C. 2332a use of a weapon of massdes t ruc t ion) , and 2) 18 U.S.C. 844{i) des t ruc t ion of proper tyaf fec t ing i n t e r s t a t e commerce by explos ives) 18 U.S.C. 3592{c) I ) ) Counts One, Four and Fourteen) and

z . The vic t im, Mart in Richard, was p a r t i c u l a r l y vulnerabledue to youth 18 U.S.C. 3592{c) I I ) ) Counts One, Four, Five,Six , Nine, Ten, Fourteen , and Fi f t een) .

- 71



72/76

FORFEITURE ALLEGATION157. As a r e su l t of planning and perpe t ra t ing Federa l crimes

of t e r ro r i sm aga ins t the United Sta tes as def ined in 18 U.S.C. 2332b g) 5) and as a l leged in Counts One, Two, Four, Six, Seven,Nine, Eleven, Twelve, Fourteen , Twenty-Three, Twenty-Five,Twenty-Seven, and Twenty-Nine of t h i s Ind ic tment , the defendant ,DZHOKHAR A. TSARNAEV s ha l l fo r fe i t to the United S ta t e spursuant to Ti t l e 18, United Sta tes Code, Sect ions 981 a) 1) G)and Ti t l e 28, United Sta tes Code, Sect ion 2461:

a . a l l r i gh t t i t l e and i n t e re s t in a l l a s se t s fo re ignand domest ic ;

b. a l l r i gh t titl and i n t e re s t in a l l a s se t s fo re ignand domestic, acqui red and mainta ined with the i n t en tand for the purpose of support ing planning ,conduct ing , and concea l ing a Federal crime of t e r ror i smagains t the United Sta tes c i t i z e ns and r es iden ts ofthe United Sta tes and t he i r propertYi and

c . a l l r i gh t titl and i n t e re s t in a l l a s se t s fo re ignand domestic, derived from, involved in and used andin tended to be used to commit a Federal crime oft e r ro r i sm aga ins t the United Sta tes c i t i z e ns andr es iden ts of the United S ta t e s and t h e i r proper ty ;inc luding but not l imi ted to a sum of money

-72



73/76

rep re sen t ing the va lue o f the prope r ty descr ibed aboveas being sub jec t to fo r f e i t u re .

Ti t l e 18, United Sta tes Code, Sect ions 981 a) 1) G) and2332b g) 5) and T i t l e 28, United Sta tes Code, Sect ion 2461.)

- 73



74/76

A TRUE BILL

ILLIAM D WEINREBLOKE CH KR V RTY

N DINE PELLEGRINIAss i s t an t U.s. Attorneys

DISTRICT OF MASSACHUSETTS; June 27, 2013Returned i n to the Dis t r i c t Court by the Grand Ju ro rs and

f i l ed .

DEPUTY CLERK

74-



75/76

------------

45 (5/97) - (Revised V.S.D C MA 3/25/2011)ICriminal Case Cover Sheet u.S. District Court - District of Massachuset

Category No.lace of Offense: _ Investigat ing Agency FBICity _BostoDCounty Suffolk -

_ Related Case Information:Superseding Ind.! Inf.Same DefendantMagistrate Judge Case NumberSearch Warrant Case NumberR 201R40 from District of

1 3 C 1 C I O ~ C O ~ W I e ? )Case No.

New Defendant -13-2106-MBB

Defendant Information:Defendant Name DzhokharTsarnaev- - Juvenile: D Y e s [{]No

Is this person an attorney and/or a member of any state/federal bar: D Y e s [{] NoAlias NameAddress (City State)Birthdate(Yr only : 1993 SSN(last4#): _ Sex M Race: White Nationality: USADefense Counsel if known: FederalPublic Defender Service AddressBar NumberLl.S, Attorney Information:

William Weinreb, Aloke ChakravartyAUSA Bar Number if applicableInterpreter: D Y e s [{] No List language and/or dialect:Victims: [ ]Yes D N o If yes, are there multiple crimevictims under 18USC377I(d)(2)Matter to be SEALED: D Y e s [{] No

DWarrant Requested D Regular Process [{] In CustodyLocation Status:Arrest Date 04/l9/2013

[{]Already in Federal Custody as of 04/l9/2013 in FMC-DevensD Already in State Custody at DServing Sentence 0 .waiting TrialD O n Pretrial Release: Ordered by: onCharging Document: DComplaint D Information [{] IndictmentTotal # of Counts: petty - DMisdemeanor [ZjFelony 23

Continue on Page 2 for Entry ofU.S.C. CitationsI hereby certify that the case numbers of any prior proceedings before a Magist rate Judge areaccurately set forth above. / 4 j I\ , ,

Date: 06/27/2013 Signature of AUSA: f \ /11 \ L1I'L

Case 1:13-cr-10200-GAO Document 58-1 Filed 06/27/13 Page 1 of 2


76/76

JS 45 5/97) Revised U.S.D.C. MA 1217105 Page 2 of2 or Reverse

District Court Case Number To be filled in by deputy clerk):Name of Defendant Dzhokhar Tsamaev

u.s.c. CitationsDescription o Offense Charged

Use of a Weapon of Mass Destruction Resulting inDeath and Conspiracy

Count Numbers1 2 4 23 25 27 29

Bombing of a Place of Public Use Resulting in Deathand Conspiracy 6 7 9Malicious Destruction of Property Resulting in Deathand Conspiracy II, 12 14Use and Carrying of a Firearm During and In Relation toa Crime of Violence Resulting in Death 3 5 8 10 13 15 16-18Carjacking Resulting in Serious Bodily Injury 19Use and Carrying of a Firearm During and In Relation toa Crime of Violence 20,22,24,26,28,30Interference With Commerce by Threats Or Violence

21

Set 13 _

Set 14 _

Case 1:13-cr-10200-GAO Document 58-1 Filed 06/27/13 Page 2 of 2

doc 58;indictment 06272013.pdf

Documents