distance learning attempt 1 - george westgeorgewest.info/wp-content/uploads/2015/02/tws.pdfusing the...
TRANSCRIPT
SID: 1136857
MOD001308
1 | P a g e
Distance Learning
Attempt 1
ANGLIA RUSKIN UNIVERSITY
Assignment Coversheet
Student Number: 1136857/1
FACULTY Faculty of Health, Social Care and Education
ASSIGNMENT DETAILS
Module Code / Occ / Year MOD001308 / DL1 / 2013/4
Module Title Technology in the Work Setting
Module Element 010 - ELECTRONIC PORTFOLIO 6000 WORDS OR
EQUIVALENT
To be marked by Submission date (by 5p.m.) 03/01/2014
Submission of this assignment agrees to the following: I understand that the piece of work submitted will be considered as the final and complete
version of my assignment of which I am otherwise the sole author. I understand both the
meaning and consequences of plagiarism and that my work has been appropriately attributed
unless otherwise stated. I have not knowingly allowed another to copy my work.
Mitigation – you have 5 working days after the deadline to submit a claim for mitigating
circumstances. If there are matters or circumstances which have had a serious adverse effect
on your performance in any assessment, you are advised to seek advice from a Student
Adviser. Forms are available from the iCentre.
WORD COUNT: 4,331 Disk included (tick)
ASSESSMENT FEEDBACK - LECTURER TO COMPLETE
Turnitin receipt number
Signature of Marker _______________________ Date ________________
% Mark
(Un-
moderated)
Table of Contents Technology in the work setting .............................................................................................. 3
SID: 1136857
MOD001308
2 | P a g e
Data Collection .................................................................................................................. 3
Data Manipulation ............................................................................................................. 4
Data Analysis .................................................................................................................... 6
Shared Working Data ........................................................................................................ 6
Effectiveness and Value ........................................................................................................ 8
Learning a Skill ................................................................................................................... 10
Description. ..................................................................................................................... 10
Feelings & Thoughts. ....................................................................................................... 11
Evaluation ....................................................................................................................... 12
Analysis ........................................................................................................................... 12
Conclusion ...................................................................................................................... 13
Action Plan ...................................................................................................................... 13
Stitching .............................................................................................................................. 14
References ......................................................................................................................... 18
SID: 1136857
MOD001308
3 | P a g e
Technology in the work setting There are varied ways to collect data from people, including interviews and online collection
methods. This information can be vitally important, including students’ future subject choices
and their expected grades. New technology, such as tablet computers, have changed the
dynamic of the collection of this data, now people can collect data whilst mobile as opposed
to adding this at a later stage. This shows a need to develop the collection methods to meet
the demands of the mobile user.
Data Collection Murray (2013) shows how important this information is, although his experience is based on
the American school system the same model applies. He shows the importance of
standardised quantitative testing and comparing this to qualitative reasons for the
differences of grades.
As well as the collection of data, there is a need to pass this throughout departments. For
assessing students’ progress, as well as showing other values within these data system
(Parke 2012). To achieve this the school utilises methods that have been well established;
using the VLE to make forms to collect information from students, staff and parents or the
Student Information System (SIS) to get their achievement grades or attitude to learning
grades from the teachers.
Student thoughts, information and ideas are also collected through many forms. These are
used to show what they want their GCSE and A Level choices to be, this is used for whole
school planning for the following years’ timetable.
More qualitative information is used to assess the home lives, reading preferences and IT
habits of different cohorts within the school. Spratling, Coke and Minick (2012) outline ways
to help qualitative data collection, some of the techniques are used currently but not all can
be applied when collecting data by computer. All of the perceived information from an
interview setting, or even a group discussion, are missed. This information is valuable
however the investment of both staff time and student time to gain the extra information is
SID: 1136857
MOD001308
4 | P a g e
not viable in the current setting. Some students with particular needs or in exceptional
circumstances are spoken to individually when it comes to important decisions such as
subject choices.
Within this process of planning evaluation of the best tool to collect the data is key. For data
linking to the Student Information System (SIS), such as being dependant on classes and
teaching sets, then a form is designed using Web 2.0 technology and assigned to the
cohorts using the SQL databases that it runs on. Other data may be linked to the year group
or sent to the general public and students alike, therefore a system that supports this whilst
collecting all the information possible is key. This uses the VLE that the school has
purchased called Frog, within this there is a form function which allows multiple types of data
collection methods.
This is not the only means of collecting data, staff perform progression interviews with
students and then enter these results to a form. This allows the emotional data to be
collected, as the staff member is able to add comments on this conversation to the form.
Simpler systems are also used to collect small amounts of data from a small cohort. For
example students who are arranging transport will tell an admin assistant their postcode
when they pay. This is communicated to the transport co-ordinator to add to their planning
system. As the transport fills there is a need for the admin assistant to know what spaces
there are left, showing information flowing both ways. Once this has happened the routes
are planned and information about these sent, via the admin assistant, to the students.
Data Manipulation Different methods are used to turn the data collected into useful information, this is achieved
by either automated electronic methods or by staff manipulating the data.
Student Information
Admin Assistants
Data Manipulation
(Creating Map)Transport Co-
ordinator
Data Analysis Creating RouteSite Manager
Returning Information to
StudentAdmin Assistant
SID: 1136857
MOD001308
5 | P a g e
The existing methods are well known, especially with the teaching staff, who are content with
their part in the collection of student predictive grades. It is collected, using the established
methods, by my department then it is passed to the administration staff. The data is
manipulated, either to be readable or to have come comparison applied. They then pass this
on so that the SLT can assess the finding and report back with the results.
The amount of data is also of concern, not necessarily when talking in the relatively small
scale of a secondary school, but if the principle is applied to a larger environment the costs
to store and process the information would be considerable. Rans (2013) shows that,
depending of the redundancy level of the stored data, cost per terabyte, per year range from
£500 (for a single copy of the data with no backup) to £5,000. Therefore the choice of data to
store becomes more than a usefulness of that data, it becomes a budgetary issue.
Information is what an organisation runs on, if this is compromised through physical
destruction or corruption then there are major ramifications.
The way of sharing information is generally using established technology, Microsoft Office
products Outlook and Excel are well known to many. Using these produces many copies of
the information, as people get an email with the original data in, save this to their documents
to work on and then send this newly edited document on to the next step. This manipulation
of the data, turning it into useful information, is especially important Francisco (2011), as it
allows comparison between members of the cohort and between the current year group and
previous ones.
There are methods that can be put in place to decrease the workload of the data
manipulator, either when designing the collection method or creating automatic processes to
alter the information. Designing a system that produces the desired results, in the correct
Owner of Information
Data Collection IT Department
Data Manipiation
Administration
Data AnalysisSLT
Results
SID: 1136857
MOD001308
6 | P a g e
format is possible. This just takes more time initially, but in the case of recurring events such
as collecting the student grades, it could save hours of work in the long run.
Data Analysis Shen and Cooley (2008) show that data must inform the decision making process, for
example the predicted grades could go on to inform where extra lessons could be added.
Thereby increasing the chances of students gaining qualifications in core subjects. They go
further saying that often this data is only used as a way to ratify the teaching and is not used
to improve the learning of the cohort as they move through the school, only being used after
the students have sat their exam and therefore too late.
Ofsted’s Guidance for the School Data Dashboard (2013) shows that the expected progress
between key stage 2 and their GCSE grades, using the assumption that a level 4 at KS2
should gain at least a C. If this is not the case then expected levels of progress have not
been met and the teaching and learning methods should be assessed. This collected
information allows strategies to be put in place to help these students, Francisco (2011)
shows how the analysis of information is the most important and often missed step in this
process.
Managing this information, although eased by the technologies employed, is still incredibly
difficult. Geri and Geri (2011) ask if collecting the data just because there is an ability to do
so is the correct way to approach the situation. The introduction of technologies such as
Radio Frequency Identification (RFID) tags, swipe cards and web technologies such as
forms mean that there is an ever growing amount of data to decode. Geri and Geri (2011)
show that the relevance and usefulness of the data collected needs to be evaluated, any
data that is deemed unnecessary should not be stored.
Shared Working Data Due to the nature of the transition between main school and 6th form, and the external
students joining this can only be finalised in the first week of the terms. Using an online
SID: 1136857
MOD001308
7 | P a g e
collaboration tool would allow the admin assistants to see if there were spaces for the
different routes and advise the new students starting. This would reduce the amount of
emails the manager, who runs this receives, as he would only need to know the addition.
This is an example of using the read-only functions within the online tools.
These are by no means the only instances of sharing data, but do highlight the different
types that my department. These methods are assessed when the project is conceived
within the office and the best solution is decided by the group.
SID: 1136857
MOD001308
8 | P a g e
Effectiveness and Value The poster created, found in the folder, shows the analysis of each of the different tools that
would be acceptable to be used within the school to collect data from staff, students and
parents. When creating the poster many different tools were investigated, however
Piktochart seemed to allow the best ratio of icons and images to information on the page.
Having to limit the amount of text meant that I was focusing on the important parts of the
content, and evaluating the collection tools fully before beginning. Each of the different tools
were evaluated on a range of aspects, including cost and ease of use. These were
compared using a simple scoring method and a table was produced. This table rates each
aspect out of 10, with the exception of cost as lower cost is better.
Ease of Use Cost* Access Design Total
Google Forms 8 1 8 7 32
Frog VLE 6 7 2 5 16
HTML & SQL 4 1 5 7 25
SurveyMonkey 8 4 3 8 25
*Low values best. (Total calculated with cost – 10)
Graphics and icons were used in the design as this helps the reader to understand what
aspect of the tool they are evaluating at that point. There was a mix of icons that the tool
provides and logos of the different collection tools. I have used the document produced by
the Social Care Institute for Excellence (2011) to help me decide what images to include.
Their advice to stick to one type of image made me decide to use mainly the built in icons,
as these have a similar design throughout.
Lane & Vlcek (n.d.) also have shown several ways that imagery can be used to present
information, but remind the reader that the information is key. Therefore I focussed on the
content of the areas, adding the images at a later stage once this had been set. I mainly
SID: 1136857
MOD001308
9 | P a g e
used the information provided on the different tools websites to evaluate them, also relying
on my own experiences with some of them such as Frog and Google Forms.
The best system was identified as Google Forms, as it performs all the function that the
other contenders do with the addition that it is free. This is a large aspect as the Department
for Education (2013) has shown. Therefore this was considered as the most vital aspect and
as this tool, as well as the rest of the Google Docs suit, are free to education it makes sense
to use this where possible.
SID: 1136857
MOD001308
10 | P a g e
Learning a Skill I decided to investigate the adoption of Google Forms to use as data collection, as this is
one of the only technologies that the students and staff can share, others that were
investigated needed highly specialised knowledge and skills. However there needed to be
more information available to allow staff to teach this to students.
I decided to use Gibbs’ (1988) model of reflection to show my thought processes when
further investigating the different uses of Google Forms within the school.
Description.
To improve the use of Google Docs, which has been the focus of my work Performance
Management, I have investigated using Google Forms to collect data in the form of surveys
and questionnaires. Initially this was only to be completed from an admin area within the
school, but whilst investigating it use it was deemed that the resource could also be used to
fulfil a section within the ICT GCSE. Though my research within the module I was able to
assess other data resources, including SurveyMonkey, HTML & SQL and using the VLE that
the school purchased ‘Frog’. Though they all have their benefits, as detailed earlier, the
flexibility and ease of use of Google Forms is best suited to fulfil the need in the GCSE
course.
To that end I began to investigate all the possible options that could be used within Google
Forms, for information to be used by both the staff creating questionnaires and students in
their ICT course (or for further subjects).
After the first draft of this was created I submitted it to the lead ICT teacher who gave me
some guidance on differentiation, as I had not created many resources for student use I
investigated this more and found information on using images and diagram as Schwonke et
al. (2013) has spoken widely about. This meant that the second draft was far more visual
than the initial.
SID: 1136857
MOD001308
11 | P a g e
After I had created this I was asked to cover a lesson as their ICT teacher was absent, they
were set work on creating a questionnaire as this was a very strong area of knowledge for
myself. I explained the different possible options available on Google Forms using the
projector to demonstrate. I also spoke about the difference between open and closed
questions, showing how best to use text boxes with open questions. I then sent the
document that I had created to the students for them to use as reference material whilst
creating the forms. This meant that Honey and Mumford’s (1992) different learning styles
(auditory, visual and kinaesthetic) would all be fulfilled within the lesson.
If any students had questions, on both what to ask and which tool to use I could provide
assistance. Some students were asking more about the validation tools that were available
on some tools within Google Forms and spent some time looking into this. I decided that this
should then be included in the document so that the more able students were able to
progress further.
Feelings & Thoughts. I have created lots of ‘help sheets’ for use with regard to IT Support however this would be
the first ‘teaching’ style sheet that I have produced so I was a little more nervous. This is why
the document was sent to the lead teacher before it was published to student, so that I could
have some feedback on writing in this style. He replied with some sensible additions to the
document and this helped me by allowing the correct content to be included. Once this had
been altered I was happier for it to be used within the lesson.
I have previously helped cover ICT lessons, but mainly whilst they have been continuing with
already started work. The difference with this instance is that it would be the start of a new
section for the students so I would be delivering content as opposed to helping refine work
already done. This obviously made me a little apprehensive as I have not completed any
official training in classroom or behaviour control. However I was pleased to discover that I
would not be alone in the lesson, a cover teacher would also be there as a way to help with
behaviour. I would still be taking the lead within the lesson but there would be assistance.
SID: 1136857
MOD001308
12 | P a g e
It also helped that I had covered the same group before, so I know a little more about the
students than I would have done previously. I also found out after the lesson that there
should have been Teaching Assistant support in the lesson, however they were on the same
trip as the class teacher. This made me feel better about how the lesson went as there
would have been support even for the full time teacher.
Evaluation I think that the classroom experience has helped me refine the document, as I now have
more knowledge on how it would be used in this setting. The range of abilities demands an
option to progress further, so the option to link to another page could be investigated, as
some of the students saw this option on the system. However having no guidance within
school on this function would increase the students’ independent learning skills. Having to
use the internet to research what this function could be used for would improve their skills for
all their subjects and not simply handing the information to them at that point.
The actual lesson was without major incident, with the cover teacher having to intervene only
once. This gave me confidence and so will allow me to advise the other ICT teachers on how
best to deliver this section in the future. I also feel more confident with volunteering to cover
lessons such as this in the future, however I know that to do this on a regular basis I would
need teacher training.
The document that was created also had minor sections altered as the information and
instant feedback that I gained within the lesson meant that I could refine this almost instantly.
Analysis The whole incident is mainly positive, as I have created a resource that can be used in the
future. However if Google Forms changes dramatically in the near future this will have to be
updated as it would no longer make sense. Therefore I have given a little more work to the
ICT department. However, I feel, that the benefit of this document outweighs the possible
negative that may occur.
SID: 1136857
MOD001308
13 | P a g e
Conclusion The experience that I have gained within the classroom have provided me with more
subjective knowledge that can be put to use when creating other content for the whole of the
VLE. This, along with skills created and developed within the course, allows me to be a far
better creator for this learning site. The skills acquisition alone is useful, but to see this
applied to the real world situation is brilliant as I have gained feedback that I would have not
had without this opportunity.
Action Plan For future occasions, where subject resources are created, I should ensure that I am able to
see how these will be used. As this situation has shown, it is best to view how something is
used before alterations are made as to make the best possible use of that resource. There is
no point fixing something that is working effectively, as this might make it not work as well or
at all.
Therefore in the future I will investigate how each resource or subject area use the item that I
am working on both before I start and throughout the creation process. At the moment I am
really only creating the product on the staff members request and information that they have
provided, then returning it to them once finished. In the future I should take more ownership
of these products, and review their effectiveness once implemented. This will improve the
teaching and learning within the school, as if it is not initially working I can then make further
adjustments and create a product that works for that situation.
SID: 1136857
MOD001308
14 | P a g e
Stitching The data collection methods within the school have changed since I started investigating
Google Forms. No longer is the collection document just processed to a version with the
VLE system, Frog. Now each collection is evaluated to see how it would be best collected,
with the available tools. Some times this is stationary, but if the data is needed to be shared
with more than one member of staff, or no processing is needed, then Google Forms is
used. This evaluation has proved effective over the last few months, new types of collection
have been used whilst completing the module, one of which has a focus on staff using
mobile technology to assess lessons whilst on ‘learning walks’ throughout their department.
This using the technologies from both Google, with the use of Google Forms, and Apple as
the iPad is the mobile technology used to collect. This teaming of technological giants should
prove to be effective in the new venture of data collection in the school.
The inclusion of the initial assessment to the needs of the collection shows a real impact of
my investigations into the different data collection tools, especially the information that is
contained within the effectiveness and value document. The image created in this section
highlights the benefits of online editing and sharing that Google Docs brings.
The tool has also been included in the curriculum, as the year 9 students need to create a
survey within their GCSE coursework. This has been implemented this term and I have been
heavily involved in the background to this section, having created an overview of Google
Forms document for the students and staff to use. At one point I was also asked to deliver
an introduction to data collection to a class and to help them to begin their own surveys
when their teacher was absent. This experience was not only beneficial in improving that
document but also helped me gain confidence to be in front of a class and let me see, first
hand, how the documents and sites that I create on the VLE impact the learning of the
students.
This realisation that the items that I create online are actually used in the real world has
given me renewed drive to strive for more online content so that students can learn
SID: 1136857
MOD001308
15 | P a g e
anywhere and at their own pace. Being in the lesson made me realise just how diverse the
learning speeds of a class can be, and both how taxing and frustrating it can be for staff and
students when some are not able to progress further until others in the class have ‘caught
up’. The push to add online content could allow the high achieving students to carry on,
using methods such as flipping the lesson.
Berrett (2012) shows how this can improve the organic styles of learning. With the traditional
lecture suited to only 25% of the students, who are auditory learners. The increase of
consumer technology has allowed items such as video cameras to be widely available.
These, and other devices, can be used to record information that would normally be
delivered in a lesson and send it to the student to review at their own pace before the lesson.
This would utilise the functions of the VLE to deliver online content throughout the course,
allowing the students to progress at their own rates. Whilst also allowing the teacher to give
more focus to the less able students and not worry that they may be hindering the more
able.
Therefore I have started to develop and area online to deliver the Google Forms section of
the syllabus. This will be used by the staff member and contains the document that was
produced initially within the new skill section. The discussion on differentiation with the head
of ICT was extremely valuable whilst producing this. It allowed me to add in different levels
of each section so that students work on their surveys further and make these more
complex. Being in the lesson demonstrated this idea so much more than a conversation
This will be developed further, adding about other areas of Google Docs and using different
mediums, such as video, to appeal to the visual learners. This system will also be applied to
the other areas within the schools’ VLE.
I initially uploaded my draft to the shared area so that others could look at the introduction. It
was at this point when it was suggested that the focus of the module should be finer than
data use within schools. I realise now just how broad this subject would have been if I had
SID: 1136857
MOD001308
16 | P a g e
continued on this path, as just the collection methods is still a very broad subject to consider.
Other suggestions including some rewording of the initial content was also suggested, to
make it clear to readers who do not work within my field. This was incredibly important to
receive as it reminded me that I needed to keep an open audience in mind when completing
the writing for the module. This can be seen in the extract from the module discussion page
below.
The research on the different collection methods was especially useful when I had to setup
an event for the users of the VLE from multiple schools. This meant that I had a section that
we could set up as a discussion event. However I decided that for the event I would ask my
colleague to present this area with some help to setup the presentation. This allowed me to
keep the whole day in focus whilst utilising the knowledge that I have developed over the
beginning of the module. I also built on our professional relationship, passing the knowledge
SID: 1136857
MOD001308
17 | P a g e
gained on to others, he appreciated the help that I gave and also had a very successful
presentation to other schools and our manager.
In this and other modules I have mentioned the use of Google Docs with tablet computers.
Focus on using these to collect information could reduce the strain of the computer room
booking, especially on weeks where Attitude to Learning (ATL) grades and other data
collection is needed. This is a result of poor planning however the use of the class iPads that
the school has purchased could be used to help with the IT provision at these times.
Students may also be more interested in what is being asked of them if they are using a
newer technology, such as the iPad, as opposed to the older style computer rooms. This
could be investigated further to provide more insight as to how people best respond.
SID: 1136857
MOD001308
18 | P a g e
References Berrett, D., 2012. How ' flipping' the classroom can improve the traditional lecture. Education
Digest, [e-journal] 78 (1), pp.36. Available through: Primo.
Davis, H.C., Carr, L., Hey, J.M.N., Howard, Y., Millard, D., Morris, D. and White, S., 2010.
Bootstrapping a Culture of Sharing to Facilitate Open Educational Resources. Learning
Technologies, IEEE Transactions on, [e-journal] 3 (2), pp.96-109. Available through: IEEE.
Deeks, J.J., Higgins, J.P. and Altman, D.G., 2008; 2008. Analysing Data and Undertaking
Meta-Analyses. [e-book] 2008; 2008. Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of
Interventions. John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. , pp.243-296. Available through: Wiley Online Library
<http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/9780470712184.ch9>.
Department for Education, 2013, Review of Efficiency in the Schools System, Online
Document, Avaliable at: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/review-of-efficiency-in-
the-schools-system Accessed 27/10/13
Francisco, P., 2011. The quest for quality: turning data into information. Nursing economic$,
[e-journal] 29 (2), pp.101-103. Available through: Primo.
Geri, N. and Geri, Y., 2011. The information age measurement paradox: collecting too much
data.(Report). Informing Science: the International Journal of an Emerging Transdiscipline,
[e-journal] 14, pp.47. Available through: Primo.
Gibbs G., 1988, Learning by doing: A guide to teaching and learning methods. Oxford
Further Education Unit, Oxford
Highcliffe School, 2013, online document available at:
http://station1.highcliffe.dorset.sch.uk/intra/pages/policies/Safeguarding%20and%20Child%2
0Protection/5%20Code%20of%20Conduct%20and%20Guidelines%20for%20Safe%20Worki
ng%20Practices%20for%20the%20Protection%20of%20Children%20and%20Staff%20-
%20February%202013.doc 25/10/13
SID: 1136857
MOD001308
19 | P a g e
Hoffman, Steven J., 2010. Teaching the Humanities Online : A Practical Guide to the Virtual
Classroom. [e-book] Armonk, NY, USA: M.E. Sharpe, Inc. Available through: ebrary
<http://site.ebrary.com/lib/anglia/docDetail.action?docID=10453195&ppg=1>.
Honey, P. and Mumford, A., 1992, The manual of learning styles, [e-book] Publisher:
Maidenhead, Available through the Anglia Ruskin University library at:
http://primo.anglia.ac.uk/primo_library/libweb/action/dlDisplay.do?institution=APU&onCampu
s=true&vid=ANG_VU1&group=Guest&docId=APU_LMS_DS000275924 [Accessed
27/11/13]
Lane, R & Vlcek, n.d., Speaking Visually: Eight Roles Pictures Play in Presentation,
Published by: Microsoft Office, Online Docuement, Avaliable online at:
http://www.office.microsoft.com/en-gb/powerpoint-help/speaking-visually-eight-roles-
pictures-play-in-presentation-HA010361422.aspx 30/10/13
Murray, J., 2013. Critical issues facing school leaders concerning data-informed decision-
making. School Leadership & Management, [e-journal] 33 (2), pp.169-177. Available
through: Primo.
Ofsted, 2013. Guidance for the School Data Dashboard, Online Document, Avaliable at:
http://dashboard.ofsted.gov.uk/sdd_guidance.pdf Accessed 14/10/13
Parke, C.S., 2012. Making Use of District and School Data. Practical Assessment, Research
& Evaluation, [e-journal] Available through: Primo.
Rui Cheng, ed. 2009. Information Engineering, 2009. ICIE '09. WASE International
Conference on [on-line] .
Schwonke, R., Ertelt, A., Otieno, C., Renkl, A., Aleven, V. and Salden, R.J.C.M., 2013.
Metacognitive support promotes an effective use of instructional resources in intelligent
tutoring. Learning and Instruction, [e-journal] 23, pp.136-150. Available through: Primo.
SID: 1136857
MOD001308
20 | P a g e
Social Care Institute for Excellence, 2011, How to produce information in an accessable
way, Online Document, Avaliable at :
http://www.scie.org.uk/publications/misc/accessguidelinespublications.pdf Accessed
29/10/13
Spratling, R., Coke, S. and Minick, P., 2012. Qualitative data collection with children.
APPLIED NURSING RESEARCH, [e-journal] 25 (1), pp.47-53. Available through: Primo.
Thomas, R.S., 2009. Data Wise in Action: Stories of Schools Using Data to Improve
Teaching and Learning. School Administrator, [e-journal] 66 (2), pp.52. Available through:
Primo.