discourse analysis if you are having trouble making sense of your interview data, you might want to...

7
Discourse Analysis If you are having trouble making sense of your interview data, you might want to consider employing what researchers call “discourse analysis.” Below are some notes from Dryzek (1997) Dryzek, John S.(1997) Politics of the Earth: Environmental Discourses. New York: Oxford University Press. Chap. 1 Making Sense of Earth’s Politics: A Discourse Approach “A discourse is a shared way of looking at the world. Its adherents will therefore use a particular kind of language when talking about events, which in turn rests on some common definitions, judgements, assumptions, and contentions.” (p. xii). A discourse approach is useful because language matters: “…the way we construct, interpret, discuss, and analyze environmental problems has all kinds of consequences” (p. 9). Consider these changes in meaning over time: Marshy lands = swamps to wetlands Frontier to be subdued to wilderness to be protected and cherished Austrialia and New Zealand: European colonization and “Acclimatisation Societies” what was once sought after as desirable exotics are now forms of biological pollution to be erradicated. “Population” only 200 years old as a concept Whales as creatures with rights

Upload: ralph-shields

Post on 27-Dec-2015

214 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Discourse Analysis If you are having trouble making sense of your interview data, you might want to consider employing what researchers call “discourse

Discourse AnalysisIf you are having trouble making sense of your interview data, you might want to consider employing what researchers call “discourse analysis.” Below are some notes from Dryzek (1997)

Dryzek, John S.(1997) Politics of the Earth: Environmental Discourses. New York: Oxford University Press.

Chap. 1 Making Sense of Earth’s Politics: A Discourse Approach

“A discourse is a shared way of looking at the world. Its adherents will therefore use a particular kind of language when talking about events, which in turn rests on some common definitions, judgements, assumptions, and contentions.” (p. xii).

A discourse approach is useful because language matters: “…the way we construct, interpret, discuss, and analyze environmental problems has all kinds of consequences” (p. 9). Consider these changes in meaning over time:

Marshy lands = swamps to wetlandsFrontier to be subdued to wilderness to be protected and cherishedAustrialia and New Zealand: European colonization and “Acclimatisation Societies” what was once sought after as desirable exotics are now forms of biological pollution to be erradicated.“Population” only 200 years old as a conceptWhales as creatures with rights

Page 2: Discourse Analysis If you are having trouble making sense of your interview data, you might want to consider employing what researchers call “discourse

Discourse Analysis

Source: Dryzek 1997, p. 20

Page 3: Discourse Analysis If you are having trouble making sense of your interview data, you might want to consider employing what researchers call “discourse

• Flowchart Showing the Typical Process of Content Analysis Research from The Content Analysis Guidebook      

• Sites dedicated to content analysis• Text Analysis Info

Harald Klein's site provides useful information regarding software for text analysis. • The Content Analysis Guidebook Online

An extensive site that supports users of Neuendorf's The Content Analysis Guidebook. • Resources Related to Content Analysis and Text Analysis

Matthias Romppel's rather large and useful site. • Content Analysis

The Writing Center at Colorado State University offers an online primer. • Practical Resources for Assessing and Reporting Intercoder Reliability in Content Analysis Research Projects

Matthew Lombard (Temple U.), Jennifer Snyder-Duch (Carlow College), and Cheryl Campanella Bracken (Cleveland State U.) maintain this most useful resource.

• Content Analysis in Politcal Research Kenneth Janda (Northwestern U.) offers resources for political scientists.

• Video Content Analysis HomepageRainer Lienhart provides useful information regarding computerized video/audio analysis.

• Content Analysis and Qualitative ResearchPart of G. David Garson's online statistics notebook (click here to visit the notebook's top page).

• Analysis of Media Texts: Content AnalaysisA page of links to content analysis resources.

Page 4: Discourse Analysis If you are having trouble making sense of your interview data, you might want to consider employing what researchers call “discourse
Page 5: Discourse Analysis If you are having trouble making sense of your interview data, you might want to consider employing what researchers call “discourse
Page 6: Discourse Analysis If you are having trouble making sense of your interview data, you might want to consider employing what researchers call “discourse
Page 7: Discourse Analysis If you are having trouble making sense of your interview data, you might want to consider employing what researchers call “discourse

Source: Robson (2002: 59)