disclaimer - · pdf fileord chris impellitteri ([email protected])...

51
Disclaimer The views expressed in this presentation are those of the individual authors and do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of the US EPA. Mention of trade names or commercial products does not constitute endorsement or recommendation for use

Upload: dinhnguyet

Post on 28-Mar-2018

226 views

Category:

Documents


4 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

Disclaimer

The views expressed in this presentation are those of the individual authors and do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of the US EPA. Mention of trade names or commercial products does not constitute endorsement or recommendation for use

Page 2: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

Overview

• What the presentation doesn’t cover:

–  Toxicology –  Health research –  Regulatory Aspects

• What this presentation does cover:

Research to support… • Source/Site characterization and Remediation

– Analytical Methods for non-DW matrices – Sampling and analytical issues

Page 3: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

CHEMICALSATPFASSITES….PFOA/PFOSANDSOMUCHMORE!

3

Page 4: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

PFASsentertheenvironment…

Photo Courtesy: USEPA, USGS, Artsyltech, West basin, Royer, DuPont

Consumer products use/disposal

Other discharges

Sources

Direct use in the environment

WWTP

Risk Management

Landfill

Voluntary, Institutional, and Regulatory Controls

Environment

Page 5: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

Common PFAS Structures

Page 6: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

MorePFAS

Backe et al. 2013 ES&T

Perfluoroalkyl Sulfonates

Perfluoroalkyl Carboxylates

Fluorotelomer Sulfonamide Amines

Fluorotelomer Sulfonates

Fluorotelomer Betaines

Page 7: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

MorePFASStructures

Sulfonamides

Phosphate esters

Telomer Acids

Phosphinic/phosphonic

F

F

F

F F

F OF

P-OO

OH

n = 4,6,8

F

F

F

F F

FF P

O

RR

n = 2,4,6

R = OH, H

S O

O N CF3(CF2)7

R

CH2CH2COOH

R = methyl, ethyl

C C CF

F

F

F F

FCH2

CF

O

OH

n = 4,6,8

Page 8: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

PFASs … More than just PFOA and PFOS

8

Page 9: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

PFAS Degradation & Stability: Fluorotelomer alcohol example

The C-F bond is very stable & tends not to degrade under natural conditions.

Consequently, when PFAS degrade, it is usually at/near the non-fluorinated group.

PFAS generally are manufactured with a non-fluorinated terminus group to anchor to intended substrate (e.g., fabric or carbon backbone).

Relatively few classes of compounds are detected commonly in the environment (highlighted in yellow).

Most degradation intermediates are very short-lived or even just inferred.

Degradation mechanisms and pathways are complex & only partially understood with many unknowns remaining.

Other classes of PFAS (e.g. sulfonamides, PAPs) have similarly complex and challenging degradation mechanisms and pathways.

Carboxylic acid Telomer alcohol

Unsat. telomer acid Telomer acid

Sec alcohol

Unsat. acid

Telomer acid

Unsat. telomer acid

Carboxylic acid

Carboxylic acid

Carboxylic acid 2H acid

9

Page 10: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

Co-contaminants at PFAS sites •  Fire Training and Emergency Response sites

•  BTEX •  Chlorinated solvents •  1,4 dioxane •  Surfactants and AFFF components

•  Manufacturing – production and secondary •  PFAS Residuals from product formulation/production •  Non-PFAS Surfactants, solvents

•  Metal Plating •  Metals •  Solvents

•  Co-contaminants are important:

• Co-contaminants can impact analytical methods •  The impact of co-contaminants on treatment systems targeting PFAS • May be regulated or targeted for remediation as well • May provide evidence regarding environmental conditions and performance

of treatment systems.

Page 11: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

ANALYTICALMETHODS

11

Page 12: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

Overview: PFASs Analytical Methods

•  PFAAs Methods

Drinking Water: EPA Method 537 Version 1.1 •  Six (6) PFAS for the UCMR3 + 8 additional PFAS •  Finished (treated) drinking water samples… only!

Media other than drinking water: •  EPA OLEM, OW, and ORD currently conducting a multi-laboratory validation

effort to establish EPA method(s) for non-DW media •  Until standard methods are complete - Each commercial lab has their own

•  Performance data is needed similar to that validating Method 537 •  Data from different laboratories (different methods) may not be comparable •  QA/QC comparable to 537 should be included regardless of the method along with

prescreening supplies and QA controls

•  PFAS precursors – EPA ORD, EPA Region 5, and others are developing methods in non-DW matrices (surface waters, groundwaters, wastewater, biosolids, soils, sediments, etc).

•  PFAS unknowns from transformations, degradation, new formulations, etc– EPA ORD and others are developing methods to identify unknown PFAS in environmental samples

Page 13: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

EPAMethod537•  DrinkingWaterOnly

•  SolidphaseextracCon(SPE)followedbyLC/MS/MSanalysis

•  14TargetAnalytes:– 9PFCAs-PFHxA,PFHpA,PFOA,PFNA,PFDA,PFUnA,PFDoA,PFTriA,andPFTreA

– 3PFSAs-PFBS,PFHxS,andPFOS– 2precursors-N-EtFOSAA,andN-MeFOSAA

•  3SurrogateStandardsMPFHxA,MPFDA,MN-EtFOSAA

•  3Internalstandards13C-PFOA,13C-PFOS,d3-N-MeFOSAA

Page 14: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

EPAMethod537protocol

Evaporate Internal Standard 1 ml 96% MeOH

LC/MS/MS

250 ml 250

ml

Surrogate 10 ml/Minute 4 ml MeOH Elute

Courtesy of William Lipps, Shimadzu

Page 15: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

Method537QuanCtaCon/Surrogates

Time3.00 3.50 4.00 4.50 5.00 5.50 6.00 6.50 7.00 7.50 8.00 8.50 9.00 9.50 10.00 10.50

%

0

100

020817leva7 24: MRM of 2 Channels ES- 713 > 669 (PFTreA669)

9.88e4

10.67

MNEtFOSAA, S

MPFHxA, S

MNMeFOSAA, IS

MPFOS, ISMNEtFOSSA, S

MPFOA, IS

T

T T

S S

S

Courtesy of Larry Zintek, EPA

Targetcompound(T)usinginternalstandardquanCtaCon

•  SuscepCbletomatrixinterferencethataffectstheinternalstandards(IS)•  Generallylessofaproblemfordrinkingwater

•  Maybeanissuefor“dirCer”matrices

Surrogatestandards(S)

•  UsedtomonitortheanalyCcalmethod

•  Notusedto“correct”concentraCon

•  Comparetargetanalyterecoveryinmatrixspikestothesurrogates.

Page 16: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

Method5371.1-Performancedata

Fourwatermatrices:Reagentwater(lowspike),Reagentwater(highspike),Chlorinatedgroundwater,HighTOC(5mg/L)groundwater.7replicatesofeachmatrix

70

80

90

100

110

120

130

meanrecovery(%)

PFOA PFOS 13C-PFHxA NEtFOSAA d5-NEtFOSAA

Mean recovery (error bars are %RSD)

Page 17: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

WhynotuseEPAMethod537forMatricesotherthanDrinkingWater?

•  Method537isadrinkingwatermethod!–  Notdemonstratedforothermatrices–  Co-contaminantsimpactmethods

•  QuanCtaConismoredifficultindirCermatrices– OnlyoneSRMtransiCon=lessconfirmaCon–  InternalStandardsignalsuppressionandenhancementcanbeanissue

•  537requiresSolidPhaseExtracCon–  Challengingforwiderangeofanalytesofinterestinoneanalysis–  Pre-filtersampleswithparCculates(Biaslowresults)–  Timeconsuming

•  Limitednumberofsurrogatestomimictheextendedanalytetargets

•  ConcentraConbyevaporaCngtodryness–  LosevolaClePFAS–  Concentratesmatrixinterferences

Page 18: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

Method Validation for ground, surface, and wastewaters •  24 PFASs (including all target analytes in EPA Method 537)

•  Methods under consideration (all using LC/MS/MS) •  Direct injection •  Solid phase extraction (with and without labeled internal standard correction)

•  Direct injection •  Similar to draft EPA Reg 5 SOP •  Targeting DL’s in 10’s ng/L •  Phase 1: 5 internal (EPA) lab validation •  Phase 2: 10 external lab validation

•  Schedule: •  Assess methods through Winter 2017-Summer 2018 •  Publish draft method in Fall 2018

EPA PFAS Methods Validation

Page 19: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

Method Validation for solids (soil, sediment, sludge) •  Same 24 PFAS •  Commence in Spring 2018 •  Working toward early 2019 for draft methods •  Target DL’s in the 0.1 - 2.5 ug/kg range

Sampling/Storage needs •  Holding time studies •  Sample vessel materials •  Standard operating procedures for field sampling

EPA Points of Contact: OLEM Schatzi Fitz-James ([email protected]) Region 3 Cynthia Caporale ([email protected]) ORD Chris Impellitteri ([email protected]) Communications Michelle Latham ([email protected])

EPA PFAS Methods Validation

Page 20: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

ASTMMethod7979-17•  EnvironmentalWaters(notdrinkingwater)

•  DirectInjecConanalysisbyLC/MS/MSissimilartoReg5SOPasthefirstmethodevaluatedbyEPAworkgroup

•  30TargetAnalytes:–  11PFCAs-PFBA,PFPeA,PFHxA,PFHpA,PFOA,PFNA,PFDA,PFUnA,PFDoA,PFTriA,PFTreA

–  7PFSAs-PFBS,PFPeS,PFHxS,PFHpS,PFOS,PFNA,PFDS–  12precursors–4:2FTS,6:2FTS,8:2FTS,6:2FTCA,7:3FTCA,8:2FTCA,10:2FTCA,6:2FTUCA,8:2FTUCA,n-MeFOSAA,n-EtFOSAA,FOSA

•  Surrogatestandards(isotopic-labeledtargetanalytes):–  7PFCAs-MPFBA,MPFHxA,MPFOA,MPFNA,MPFDA,MPFUnA,MPFDoA

–  2PFSAs-MPFHxS,MPFOS

–  UsedtomonitoranalyCcalmethod,notusedto“correct”thedata

•  QuanCtaConwith2SRMsandionraCos

Page 21: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

ASTM7979-17Protocol

10 µL Acetic Acid

LC/MS/MS

5 ml

Surrogate

Courtesy of William Lipps, Shimadzu

5 mL MeOH

Page 22: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

ASTMPFASQUANTITATION

Time8.05 8.10 8.15 8.20 8.25 8.30 8.35 8.40 8.45 8.50 8.55 8.60 8.65 8.70 8.75 8.80 8.85

%

0

100

8.05 8.10 8.15 8.20 8.25 8.30 8.35 8.40 8.45 8.50 8.55 8.60 8.65 8.70 8.75 8.80 8.85

%

0

10082316lev4 14: MRM of 3 Channels ES-

498.9 > 98.9 (PFOS98.7)1.06e5

8.59

8.458.47

82316lev4 14: MRM of 3 Channels ES- 498.9 > 79.9 (PFOS79.7)

1.51e58.59

8.468.40 8.40

Time8.05 8.10 8.15 8.20 8.25 8.30 8.35 8.40 8.45 8.50 8.55 8.60 8.65 8.70 8.75 8.80 8.85

%

0

100

8.05 8.10 8.15 8.20 8.25 8.30 8.35 8.40 8.45 8.50 8.55 8.60 8.65 8.70 8.75 8.80 8.85

%

0

1008231608004_18 14: MRM of 3 Channels ES-

498.9 > 98.9 (PFOS98.7)1.36e5

8.60

8.40

8.39

8.23

8.458.46

8.47

8.62

8.64

8231608004_18 14: MRM of 3 Channels ES- 498.9 > 79.9 (PFOS79.7)

1.52e58.60

8.40

8.38

8.24

8.45

8.62

Ion Ratio-1.41 Ion Ratio-1.35

Quantitation Ion

Confirmation Ion

Calibration Sample

Courtesy of Larry Zintek, EPA

•  BecauseofdirCermatrices–use2SRMtransiConsorMRM

– MeasureconfirmatorytransiConandionraCos–  ExampleforPFOS,samesamples.IonRaCoDifferenceis4.3%andwithinTolerance

Page 23: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

ASTM7979Performancedata

FourforCfiedmatrices:Reagentwater,Riverwater,WWTPeffluent,andWWTPinfluent*.6replicatesofeachmatrix.

*PFOSnotshownbecausethematrixhadbackgroundconcentraConcomparabletospikeconcentraCon

Mean recovery (error bars are %RSD)

70

80

90

100

110

120

130

mean recovery

(%)

PFOA MPFOA PFOS MPFOS 8:2 FTCA MPFNA

Page 24: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

ASTMD7968

•  Environmentalsolids:soil,sediment,sludge,etc

•  SolventextracCon,analysisbyLC/MS/MS

•  30TargetAnalytes:–  11PFCAs-PFBA,PFPeA,PFHxA,PFHpA,PFOA,PFNA,PFDA,PFUnA,PFDoA,PFTriA,PFTreA

–  7PFSAs-PFBS,PFPeS,PFHxS,PFHpS,PFOS,PFNA,PFDS–  12precursors–4:2FTS,6:2FTS,8:2FTS,6:2FTCA,7:3FTCA,8:2FTCA,10:2FTCA,6:2FTUCA,8:2FTUCA,n-MeFOSAA,n-EtFOSAA,FOSA

•  Surrogatestandards(isotopic-labeledtargetanalytes):–  7PFCAs-MPFBA,MPFHxA,MPFOA,MPFNA,MPFDA,MPFUnA,MPFDoA

–  2PFSAs-MPFHxS,MPFOS

–  UsedtomonitoranalyCcalmethod,notusedto“correct”thedata

•  QuanCtaConwith2SRMsandionraCos

Page 25: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

Tumble 1 hr

ASTMD7968protocol

20 µL NH4OH

LC/MS/MS

Surrogate

Courtesy of William Lipps, Shimadzu

10 mL MeOH 2 g sample

10 µL Acetic Acid

Page 26: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

ASTMD7968PerformanceData

FourASTMsoilmatrices:CL-1,CH-1,SP-1,andML-1.6replicatesofeachmatrix.*PFOSnotshownforSP-1andML-1becausethematriceshadbackgroundconcentraConcomparabletospikeconcentraCon.

50

60

70

80

90

100

110

120

130

mean recovery

(%)

PFOA MPFOA PFOS MPFOS 8:2 FTCA MPFNA

Mean recovery (error bars are %RSD)

Page 27: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

ResearchMethods

•  ORDlaboratoriesandotherresearchgroupshavedevelopedmethodstoanalyzerelevantmatricesforvariousPFAS

•  Thesemethodsmayworkforyourstudy/site

•  Todecide:– ReadandunderstandtheSOP– Reviewperformancedata

– ReviewandimplementQA/QCmeasures

Page 28: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

DoDMethods

•  CommercialLabsaccreditedbyDoDQSM5.1– AccreditaConcanbewithdrawn–checkifcurrent– NotclearwhatperformanceandQA/QCinformaConwasprovidedforaccreditaCon

•  SOPs:– Varyfromcommerciallabtocommerciallab– OqencitedasconfidenCalbusinessinformaCon

•  Manycommerciallabsuse“ModifiedMethod537”– ModificaConsarenotpermiredbyMethod537– NodatatoshowmodificaConswork

Page 29: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

AnExampleCommercialMethod

Isotope addition

Bottle rinse

Elute

Internal Standard

Reconstitute in solvent

LC/MS/MS

Sample concentration

Extraction using SPE

Page 30: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

CommercialMethods

•  AnalyteconcentraConsare“corrected”forisotoperecovery–  Ifrecovery<100%,concentraConsincrease–  If>100%,concentraConsdecrease– Somelabs“correct”withverylowrecoveries

•  MayormaynotuseconfirmaConionandionraCos–readtheSOP

•  PerformanceDataisneededtoproperlyevaluateanymethodandtheQA/QCofthelaboratory.Thisdataisrarelyprovided.

Page 31: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

Precursors

u  PFAAsaremorecommonlymeasuredu  PrecursorsmassmaybesubstanCalu  AirexposureandoxidaCveremediaConforotherchemicalsmayconvert

precursorstoPFAAsoverCmeorduringtreatment

PFAS = Per- & Polyfluoroalkyl Substances includes PFOA or PFOS and precursors

PFAAs = Perfluorinated alkyl acids includes PFOA and PFOS

Etc.

PFAS Product (e.g. AFFF)

contains

Precursor A

Precursor B

Aerobicallyoxidized PFAAs

+ ??

PFAAs

Page 32: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

TransformaContoformPFOA

(ModifiedfromWangetal.,2009)

Stable

Stable Stable

GC/MS/MS LC/MS/MS

Page 33: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

AnalysisofPrecursors•  NRMRLSOPsforEnvironmentalWaters(notDW)andsolids

•  Methods–  Water-SPE,analysisbyGC/MS/MS

–  Solids–solventextracCon,analysisbyGCMS/MS

•  Analytes:–  FluorotelomerAlcohols(FTOHs)-4:2,6:2,8:2,7:2s,5:1,6:1,7:1,8:1,9:1,10:1,and11:1

–  Fluorotelomermonomers-6:2FluorotelomerAcrylate(6:2FTAc),6:2FluorotelomerMethacrylate(6:2FTMAc),8:2FTAc,8:2FTMac,10:2FTAc,and10:2FTMac

–  Perfluoro-1-octanesulfonamido-ethanol(FOSE)-2-N-ethylFOSE(N-EtFOSE),and2-N-MethylFOSE(N-MeFOSE)

•  Surrogatestandards-8:2MFTOHandd7-MeFOSE

•  QuanCtaConsimilartoASTMmethod–monitoring2SRMsandevaluaCngionraCos

Page 34: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

TotalOxidizablePrecursors(TOP)assay•  DevelopedbyHoutzetal•  AvailablefromsomecontractlaboratoriesandunderevaluaConatORD•  Nostandardmethodscurrentlyexist

•  BulkPrecursorconcentraConcanbeesCmatedby: C2–C1=precursors

•  DoesnotidenCfyindividualprecursorcompounds

1

2

Measure PFAA concentration (C1)

Persulfate Hydroxide Heat 6 hrs

Measure PFAA concentration (C2)

Page 35: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

Non-TargetedMethodsExploreUnknowncompoundsusingHighresoluConmassspectrometry

apeakinachromatogramandtoulCmatelypredicttheidenCtyofthisunknown

↓  IniCally,themassspectrometerassignsamassforeachpeakobserved,forexample179.9846Daltons(Da)

↓  Soqwarethencalculatestheexactnumberandtypeofatomsneededtoachievethatmeasuredmass,exampleC3HF5O3(needthisnumberandtypeofatomstoweighthismuch)

↓  SoqwareandfragmentaConexperimentsallowdeterminaConofmostlikelystructure:

↓  Withmass,formula,andstructuredetermined,idenCtycanbeassignedbysearchingagainstdatabasesofknowncompounds

↓  SearchforstandardsfromcommercialsourcestoconfirmidenCficaConifpossible

O

FF

F

FF

OH

O

Molecular Formula: C3HF5O3

Monoisotopic Mass: 179.984585 Da[M-H]-: 178.977308 Da

Page 36: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

SAMPLINGGUIDANCE

Page 37: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

Sampling and Laboratory Considerations

•  Solvent contamination is source dependent and can be consistent and/or sporadic •  Laboratory supplies

•  Polypropylene vials and centrifuge tubes (from mold release or cross contamination from other production processes)

•  LC vial caps and septa (e.g. PTFE/silicone) •  LC and SPE pump equipment, pump head seals (graphitized Teflon) •  PTFE tubing •  Low binding pipette tips

•  Use of PFAS-containing equipment (gloves, coats, collection gear, etc) also an issue

•  Many common laboratory/field materials and sampling

equipment contain PFAS (pipette tips, filters, vials, etc)

•  Other chemicals which may be present

•  e.g., AFFF sites may have hydrocarbons, chlorinated solvents, glycols, and other AFFF components as well as residuals from previous remediation efforts

•  Research needed to evaluate professional judgement:

•  Volatile PFAS may be lost depending on the sampling methods.

•  PFAS stratification? •  PFAS may sorb to sampling equipment

possibly distorting measured concentration

37

Page 38: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

Sampling and Analytical issues

Lessons learned from ORD Tech Support for on-going preliminary site investigations:

•  Sampling approach and equipment not evaluated for PFAS

•  Low sample density – heterogeneity unknown

• Co-contaminants not sampled at the same time

• Many conducted by federal partners with limited input from EPA

•  Site characterization and source identification affected by: • Many PFAS-products used with varying formulations, chemistries, etc •  Lengthy time in the environment could result in transformations •  Co-contaminants present •  Remediation technologies used to clean up other chemicals may impact PFASs

concentrations and distributions

38

Page 39: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

PFAS Sampling

•  Information is evolving! – check for updates often

• Sample integrity

– The collected sample should represent the matrix sampled

– Don’t add PFAS to your sample – Don’t remove PFAS from your sample

• Non-ideal situations

– Historical wells may contain fluorocarbons – Safety trade-offs with issues of cross contamination

Page 40: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

AccuratePFASSampling:CrossContaminaNon

• Don’t add analytes to your sample

• PFAS found in many common field supplies and equipment

• Fluoropolymers – equipment, seals, sample caps and bottles • Water proof paper and PPE • Personal care products • Surface treatment on aluminum foil, food wrappers

• Sunscreens

Avoid using these items if not specifically screened for PFAS!

Page 41: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

Sampling Procedure Precautions: PPE

Personal Protective Equipment (PPE)

• Preferred – well washed clothing

• Uncoated Tyvek ok, coated Tyvek may contain PFAS

• Stain repellent clothing contains PFAS

• Water Repellent clothing

– PFAS based treatments have many trade names such as Gore-tex, weatheredge, DWR, Omni-tech

– Claims of “PFOS free” may contain C6 PFAS – Read labels and product descriptions carefully – Rubber, polyurethane, and PVC - ok

Page 42: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

Sampling Procedure Precautions: Equipment

Sampling Equipment and supplies

•  No teflon or PTFE permitted

•  Fluoropolymers – generally no

•  Aluminum foil may have PFAS surface treatment

•  No Decon 90, sharpies, post-it notes, waterproof field papers or books

•  Avoid chemical ice packs

Acceptable materials

•  HDPE, polypropylene, and silicone materials

•  Alconox or Liquinox

•  Ball point pens

• Water ice – double bag in polyethylene bags

Page 43: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

Sampling Procedure Precautions

Other

•  Food packaging may contain PFAS treatments – don’t eat on site, and wash hands before returning to site

•  Frequent nitrile glove changes

•  Collect field blanks

•  Field spiked blanks used by some

•  Avoid re-using equipment - previous use may have involved PFAS materials

Best practice

•  Pretest materials and products for PFAS contamination

•  Keep separate from “normal” sampling supplies

Page 44: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

PFAS Sampling Guidance

• Cross-EPA workgroup –  Generic SOP for groundwater sampling external review soon –  SOPs for surface water, soil, etc to follow

•  Interim Guideline on the Assessment and Management of Perfluoroalkyl and Polyfluoroalkyl Substances (PFAS)Contaminated Sites Guidelines – Gov’t of State of Western Australia

• US States – Department of Environmental Protection, Massachusetts – New Hampshire Department of Environmental Services

Page 45: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

Conclusions

•  Significant investment in PFAS related research is starting to show results. Standardized methods and sampling approaches are being developed currently.

•  Source control (in the form of pretreatment or elimination of source) is the most cost effective means of managing the risk of these chemicals.

•  More research is needed to develop better cost models for treating PFAS in drinking water and other environmental media.

•  Treatment and remediation technologies are needed for a wide variety of media under a wide variety of environmental conditions

•  Careful science-based decisions are needed to evaluate replacement and alternatives to PFAS-based chemistries.

Page 46: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

Acknowledgements

•  Regions

§  Jane Dolan (Reg 1) §  Dave Einan (Reg 10) §  Kim Prestbo (Reg 10) §  Kira Lynch (Reg 10) §  Diana Cutt (Reg 2) §  Chuck Maurice (Reg 5) §  Jan Szaro (Reg 1) §  Carol Braverman (Reg 5) §  Cindy Caporale (Reg 3) §  Barry Pepich (Reg 10) §  Karin Lethe-Fedderson (Reg 10)

46

•  OLEM

§  Schatzi Fitz-James §  Linda Gaines §  Linda Fiedler §  Jed Costanza

•  ORD

§  Chris Impellitteri §  Gerard Henderson §  Jennifer Goetz §  Jody Shoemaker §  Jim Voit

Page 47: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

References Chemistry

•  Buck et al. 2011. Integrated Environmental Assessment and Management. 4:513-541

•  Backe et al. 2013. Environmental Science and Technology. 47: 5226�5234

•  Wang et al.  2017. Environmental Science and Technology. 51:2508-18

•  Liu and Avendano. 2013. Environment International. 61:98-114

•  ITRC Fact sheets (http://www.itrcweb.org/Team/Public?teamID=78)

•  http://www.cluin.org/pfas

•  https://www.epa.gov/pfas/basic-information-about-and-polyfluoroalkyl-substances-pfass#tab-1

Analytical Methods

•  Method 537 1.1

•  ASTM D7979-17 and D7968-17

•  NRMRL SOPs – contact Marc Mills

•  TOP assay - Houtz and Sedlak. 2012. Environmental Science & Tech. 46(17): 9342-9349.

•  PIGE - Srivastava, A., et al. Journal of Radioanalytical and Nuclear Chemistry 302.3 (2014): 1461-1464.

•  https://www.epa.gov/pfas/and-polyfluoroalkyl-substances-pfass-what-epa-doing 47

Page 48: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

References Sampling Guidance

•  Cross-EPA workgroup

–  Generic SOP for groundwater sampling external review soon

–  SOPs for surface water, soil, etc to follow

•  Interim Guideline on the Assessment and Management of Perfluoroalkyl and Polyfluoroalkyl Substances (PFAS)Contaminated Sites Guidelines – Gov’t of State of Western Australia (https://www.der.wa.gov.au/images/documents/your-environment/contaminated-sites/guidelines/Guideline-on-Assessment-and-Management-of-PFAS-.pdf)

•  ITRC and DOD in development

•  US States

–  Department of Environmental Protection, Massachusetts

–  New Hampshire Department of Environmental Sciences

48

Page 49: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

Disclaimer

TheviewsexpressedinthispresentaConarethoseoftheindividualauthorsanddonotnecessarilyreflecttheviewsandpoliciesoftheUSEPA.MenConoftradenamesorcommercialproductsdoesnotconsCtuteendorsementorrecommendaConforuse

Page 50: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

OxidaCvetransformaContoformPFOA

(ModifiedfromWangetal.,2009)Stable

Stable

Stable

Page 51: Disclaimer -  · PDF fileORD Chris Impellitteri (impellitteri.christopher@epa.gov) Communications Michelle Latham (latham.michelle@epa.gov) EPA PFAS Methods Validation . ASTM

OxidaCveTransformaContoformPFOS

Perfluoroalkyl sulfonamide (FOSA)

SO2NH2

N-alkyl perfluoroalkyl sulfonamidoacetic acid

(RFOSAA)

SO2N(R)CH2COO-

Perfluoroalkyl sulfonamidoacetic acid (FOSAA)

SO2NHCH2COO-

Perfluorooctane sulfonic acid (PFOS)

SO3-

N-alkyl perfluoroalkyl sulfonamido ester/urethane monomer

SO2N(R)CH2CH2OCOM M = acrylate, methacrylate, urethane

N-alkyl perfluoroalkyl sulfonamidoethanol (RFOSE)

SO2N(R)CH2CH2OH R = methyl, ethyl

Ester / Urethane Polymer

Stable