digital transformation in pharma: organizing for sustained success
TRANSCRIPT
Across Health Webinar
15/04/2023 1Across Health Webinar
Edwin de Fouw, MD, Across Health Netherlands and NordicsChristian Helsengreen, Senior Consultant, Across Health
View recorded webinar: http://bit.ly/1E4ebGP
Digital Transformation in Pharma:organising for sustained success
Focused “fusion” consulting
• 70+ strong consultancy
• Focus on innovative customer-centric approaches (e-powering traditional channels – “fusion”)
• Holistic approach: From strategy to implementation & success metrics/ KPIs
• Unique offering in the industry
• Global footprint (9 markets)• Projects in emerging markets (LATAM, Russia,
Turkey, China)
• Life sciences focus
15/04/2023 2
Extensive experience at regional/global level
AND
local execution power
Across Health Webinar
15/04/2023 Across Health Webinar 3
Agenda
• Digital maturity and challenges in Pharma• Digital transformation• Sustaining the momentum
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
KEYSTATISTICS
CURRENTADOPTION
KEYCHALLENGES
FUTUREOF DIGITAL
Defining digital transformation: reassembly of resources to grow
15/04/2023 Across Health Webinar 4
Source:?
Accenture 2014
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
KEYSTATISTICS
CURRENTADOPTION
KEYCHALLENGES
FUTUREOF DIGITAL
In the digital revolution, digital is the norm
Across Health Webinar15/04/2023 5
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
KEYSTATISTICS
CURRENTADOPTION
KEYCHALLENGES
FUTUREOF DIGITAL
15/04/2023 6Across Health Webinar
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
KEYSTATISTICS
CURRENTADOPTION
KEYCHALLENGES
FUTUREOF DIGITAL
0 1 2 3 4 5
3%
12%
24%
44%
17%
1%
15/04/2023 Across Health Webinar 7
Overall, only 18% of pharma staff are satisfied with their current digital activities – and this number has not changed in the last 5 years
ExtremelySatisfied
ExtremelyDissatisfied
18%
copyright © Across Health, 2014
N= 302
The (very) long fuse for digital transformation in healthcare…
15/04/2023 Across Health Webinar 8
A long fuse/big bang in pharma?
9
Now 2016
15/04/2023 Across Health Webinar
10
DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION IN PHARMA enables all customer facing stakeholders to optimally integrate all channels in the mix to allow for increased and improved customer engagement, thereby creating value, revenue and efficiencies. It builds the fertile ground for digital health or mhealth which may disrupt the pharma business model
15/04/2023 Across Health Webinar
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
KEYSTATISTICS
CURRENTADOPTION
KEYCHALLENGES
FUTUREOF DIGITAL
Four Types of Digital Maturity
15/04/2023 Across Health Webinar 11
Source: The Digital Advantage: How digital leaders outperform their peers in every industry (Cap Gemini and MIT Sloan Management 2014)
Digital Beginners• Simple digital capabilities• Unaware of opportunities• Small investments• No effective transformation
management in place
Fashionistas• Many sexy digital applications• No vision of gaining synergies• Motivated by digital change –
But the strategy is not founded on how to maximise business benefits
• Maturity differences between corporate HQ, local subsidiaries and business units
Digirati• Truly understands how to drive
value with digital transformation• Combine a transformative vision,
careful governance and engagement with sufficient investments in new opportunities
• Digital culture is the lever for fast exploitation of new opportunities
• Continuously advantage their digital competitive advantage
Conservatives• Favour prudence over innovation• Acknowledge the need for a strong
unifying vision, governance and engagement
• Sceptical about the value of new digital trends
• Often miss valuable opportunities
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
KEYSTATISTICS
CURRENTADOPTION
KEYCHALLENGES
FUTUREOF DIGITAL
15/04/2023 Across Health Webinar 12
The Fashionista
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
KEYSTATISTICS
CURRENTADOPTION
KEYCHALLENGES
FUTUREOF DIGITAL
The digital advantage – Capgemini 2013
Across Health Webinar
Digital maturity by industry: In pharma, transformation management intensity is low
15/04/2023 13
Maturity Breakdown by Industry: a significant % of fashionistas
15/04/2023 Across Health Webinar 14
Source: The Digital Advantage: How digital leaders outperform their peers in every industry (Cap Gemini and MIT Sloan Management 2014)
Most Pharma senior executives believe digital health will have transformed their business model by 20201
15/04/2023 Across Health Webinar 15
You need to be here before 2020 – and the journey must start now!
1: In 2013, Arthur D Little interviewed over 50 senior pharma executives from around the world for its report Impact of Digital Health on the Pharmaceutical Industry – Will Business Models be Reshaped by Digital Health?
Top challenges of digital transformation: did we get to the digital campaign stage yet?
15/04/2023 Across Health Webinar 16
Source: ALTIMETER, 2014: State of Digital Transformation
customers
The challenge: Pharma is suffering from change fatigue
15/04/2023 Across Health Webinar 17
15/04/2023 18
Agenda
Across Health Webinar
• Digital maturity and challenges in Pharma• Digital transformation• Sustaining the momentum
Change needs to happen at 4 levels…
15/04/2023 Across Health Webinar 19
I. People, organization and culture
II. Business and technology processes
III. Channel integration
IV. Measurement and metrics
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
KEYSTATISTICS
CURRENTADOPTION
KEYCHALLENGES
FUTUREOF DIGITALhttp://mindset.com.au/services/lead-manage-change/change-management/
Transformational change has an organizational focus: ROI of change is really created if we focus on the mindset
15/04/2023 Across Health Webinar 20
15/04/2023 Across Health Webinar 21
Successful change requires 4 key conditions to be met…
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
KEYSTATISTICS
CURRENTADOPTION
KEYCHALLENGES
FUTUREOF DIGITAL
Gathering and Sharing Insights: Set the agenda for change
• Communicate a compelling need for change• Build experiential awareness
• Silicon Valley trips, Peter Hinssen, “Rep MC case”, etc.
• Align senior management• CEO ownership/endorsement
• Know your starting point:• Know your CUSTOMER: Cross-channel
Navigator• Know your EMPLOYEES: Multichannel
Barometer (n= 300)• Compare yourself with your industry peers
• Technology audit
15/04/2023 Across Health Webinar 22
Create experiential awareness:Take a fictitious brand...Develop a multichannel offering
15/04/2023 Across Health Webinar 23
And segment your target audience (3 groups of 154 reps)
15/04/2023 Across Health Webinar 24
Week 1 Week 3Week 2
Group 3
Group 2
Group 1
And show the results during a company-wide meeting
15/04/2023 Across Health Webinar 25
Group 2Repetition
Group 3Multi-channel
Group 1Mono-channel
N = 24
N= 34
N= 49
15%* 22%* 32%*
* Conversion rate
Innovation: Clear Vision and Goals
Craft a MEASURABLE vision with a clear business intent
“By 2018, one-third of our customer contacts (measured as MC equivalents) will come from digital contacts, resulting in a superior
customer engagement vs our competitors”
• Involve the entire organization: • The days of the PILOT for 1 TA or brand are over
III. Channel integration
IV. Measurement and metrics
15/04/2023 Across Health Webinar 26
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
KEYSTATISTICS
CURRENTADOPTION
KEYCHALLENGES
FUTUREOF DIGITAL
All values shown are illustrative only
Impact is rescaled to allow direct comparison Multichannel EQuivalent
The graphs and tables are similar to performance maps, but the Rep is ALWAYS set at 1.00the Rep is ALWAYS set at 1.00
MULTICHANNEL Equivalence metrics allow for comparison of the impact of all channels in the mix…and setting of a clear intent
MC equivalent impact
15/04/2023 Across Health Webinar 27
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
KEYSTATISTICS
CURRENTADOPTION
KEYCHALLENGES
FUTUREOF DIGITAL
(III) Channel integration & (IV) Metrics: The rise of 360° New Normal strategy
• Simple digital initiatives• Brand driven• No integration with the
business model
• Lack of synergy with the rest of the mix
• Little long term vision• Focus on sexy initiatives:
social/app• Pilot thinking• Agency driven
• Optimize digital presence to get a higher engagement
• MC as the solution to reach or frequency challenges optimizing marketing spend
• Local or fragmented solutions often without involvement of the Rep
• Limited personalisation• Basic automation
• One shared view of the customer bridging online-offline worlds.
• Building customer profiles with relevant data from online and offline
• Rep/MSL leverages digital opps. as part of daily work.
• Marketing automation allows for near 1-on-1 communication
Isolated DIGITAL tactics
FashionistaInitiatives
MC (Pilot) campaigns
Beyond the campaign:360° New Normal strategy
EmergentOptimized
Integrated
What is the transformation needed?
15/04/2023 Across Health Webinar 28
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
KEYSTATISTICS
CURRENTADOPTION
KEYCHALLENGES
FUTUREOF DIGITAL
(I) People, Organisation and Culture & (II) Bizz/Tech process The rise of 360° New Normal strategy
• Agency driven –outsourced
• Innovation focused team
• Driven by the (few) visionary elements
• Dedicated resources – “the digital team”, CoE - often supported by external expertise
• Cross functional and cross company buy-in with significant investments.
• Cross affiliate plans, KPIs & targets in place
• Full orchestration and control by in-house people
• The ‘new normal’ skills, capabilities & mindset are in place among all customer facing stakeholder
• Full alignment with IT, Legal, Regulatory etc.
Isolated DIGITAL tactics
FashionistaInitiatives
MC (Pilot) campaigns
Beyond the campaign:360° New Normal strategy
In the meantime…..digital health incubation is ongoing
EmergentOptimized
Integrated
• Isolated structures• No organizational
integration or sharing processes
15/04/2023 Across Health Webinar 29
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
KEYSTATISTICS
CURRENTADOPTION
KEYCHALLENGES
FUTUREOF DIGITAL
The organizational roadmap
• Build a 3-year organizational roadmap
Customer facing
Organisational Foundation
15/04/2023 Across Health Webinar 30
OrganizationCurrently: Digital is a separate service unit – the Digital team, Centre of Excellence, etc.
• Digital roles and capability are centralized• Reporting structure through one head of digital
15/04/2023 Across Health Webinar 31
DH
OrganizationSooner rather than later…
• Full integration of digital in the organization• Find and empower Digital Ambassadors• The honeycomb is the real transformation
15/04/2023 Across Health Webinar 32
Commercial effectiveness / Organizational effectiveness
as theleader of the governance model
The level of internal expertise is dropping again – and arguably has not moved ahead since 2009
15/04/2023 Across Health Webinar 33
Do you feel that you have sufficient knowledge of all opportunities
offered by the internet for your business activities?
KEYCHALLENGES
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%
4%
4%
2%
1%
2%
4%
24%
20%
24%
18%
16%
21%
27%
31%
42%
44%
36%
38%
31%
34%
21%
30%
34%
25%
14%
10%
10%
8%
12%
12%
Totally insufficient
Insufficient
Between sufficient and insufficient
Sufficient
More than sufficient (expert)
copyright © Across Health, 2014
46%
37%
N= 302
34
Integrated Execution: mobilising the organization
15/04/2023 Across Health Webinar
Build the capability to change: • Training & hiring
• Consider the role of HR
• The emergence of the new marketer• Ensure proper foundational investment:
• Get the technological capability in place• Align IT & Business
Business & Marketing
Technology
DATA
35
Skills training in digital is ‘learning by doing’
15/04/2023 Across Health Webinar
….hence the urgency!True transformational MC programs should enhance skills & processes; not just bring results
36
Case 1: Regional Digital Education partnership
• GM’s endorsed• Awareness/buy-in sessions• Skills: Best practice sharing, MC planning and business
integration• Annual business planning optimization• Assessment of business plans and coaching sessions • Toolkits help to get (re-)started • Ongoing sharing and coaching to drive business results
15/04/2023 Across Health Webinar
37
Case 2: European Digital Transformation
• Senior Management endorsed - company-led• Platform selection & implementation• Toolkits to get started and follow best practices
Across Health:• Building skills and capabilities:
• Best practice sharing, MC planning processes, business integration, metrics and reporting
• Execution and deployment: • Ensure organizational learning and adoption of skills &
capabilities• Stakeholder alignment & sharing
15/04/2023 Across Health Webinar
3838
Real transformation is…..
“Digital, e-, interactive, online” job titles no longer exist
15/04/2023 Across Health Webinar
15/04/2023 39
Agenda
Across Health Webinar
• Digital maturity and challenges in Pharma• Digital transformation• Sustaining the momentum
15/04/2023 Across Health Webinar 40
Successful change requires 4 key conditions to be met…
41
But… sustain the momentum of change
• Measure, monitor and iterate• Multichannel EQ and customer engagement as key measures of
success• Set internal adoption KPIs• Cross company engagement…involve training and internal
communication• Incentives and rewards…from the top down
• Incentivise the rep to make full use of all the channels at his disposal• Incentivise medical and marketing to do the same
• Facilitate and maintain change by means of gamification• Measure progress and reward• The Across Health Multichannel simulator is available
15/04/2023 Across Health Webinar
Organizations don’t changeIndividuals change – one person at a time
15/04/2023 Across Health Webinar 42
43
Digital Transformation: Conclusion
• It takes time! 2020 is closer than we think• Build and share the agenda for change• Set a clear measurable business intent • Change mindset• Build the capability for change• Hire the right people• Choose partners that bring both business results and
change• Sustain the transformation: measure, monitor, iterate
15/04/2023 Across Health Webinar
44
• If you were to apply channel preferences rigorously, you would get:
15/04/2023 Across Health Webinar
So what is the effect?
• And a highly motivated workforce
26% reduction/reallocation in FF cost*(even higher for medical)
Increased satisfaction
*) Assumptions:Costs: 100€/F2F call across Europe and 25€/MC contact1000 target HCPs and an optimum of 8 calls/year(8 F2F calls for offline, 4 calls & 4 MC for mix and 2 calls + 6 MC for digital segment)
45
“The end (of the beginning)”
15/04/2023 Across Health Webinar
15/04/2023 Across Health Webinar
Thank You!View recorded webinar: http://bit.ly/1E4ebGP
46
DISCLAIMER:
Current presentation is confidential. All proposed concepts and ideas presented here are intellectual property of Across Health, and are to be used in collaboration with Across Health.