determine and design the best alt fred schenkelberg, consultant january 23 rd thru 26 th, 2012 rams...

18
Determine and Design the Best ALT Fred Schenkelberg, Consultant January 23 rd thru 26 th , 2012 RAMS Session 13C

Upload: guillermo-hammonds

Post on 01-Apr-2015

213 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Determine and Design the Best ALT Fred Schenkelberg, Consultant January 23 rd thru 26 th, 2012 RAMS Session 13C

Determine and Designthe Best ALT

Fred Schenkelberg, ConsultantJanuary 23rd thru 26th, 2012

RAMS Session 13C

Page 2: Determine and Design the Best ALT Fred Schenkelberg, Consultant January 23 rd thru 26 th, 2012 RAMS Session 13C

Selection Criteria

Page 3: Determine and Design the Best ALT Fred Schenkelberg, Consultant January 23 rd thru 26 th, 2012 RAMS Session 13C

Selection CriteriaMeaningful Results

Page 4: Determine and Design the Best ALT Fred Schenkelberg, Consultant January 23 rd thru 26 th, 2012 RAMS Session 13C

Selection CriteriaMeaningful ResultsMeasures

Page 5: Determine and Design the Best ALT Fred Schenkelberg, Consultant January 23 rd thru 26 th, 2012 RAMS Session 13C

Threshold

Unrelated

Surrogate

Direct

Meaningful Results:Measures

Page 6: Determine and Design the Best ALT Fred Schenkelberg, Consultant January 23 rd thru 26 th, 2012 RAMS Session 13C

Meaningful ResultsMeasuresCost

Selection Criteria

Page 7: Determine and Design the Best ALT Fred Schenkelberg, Consultant January 23 rd thru 26 th, 2012 RAMS Session 13C

Threshold

Prohibitive

Budget

Inexpensive

Cost

Page 8: Determine and Design the Best ALT Fred Schenkelberg, Consultant January 23 rd thru 26 th, 2012 RAMS Session 13C

Meaningful ResultsMeasuresCostPrecisionDurationSamples

Selection Criteria

Page 9: Determine and Design the Best ALT Fred Schenkelberg, Consultant January 23 rd thru 26 th, 2012 RAMS Session 13C

ALT APPROACHESConsider the alternative ways to conduct the testing

Page 10: Determine and Design the Best ALT Fred Schenkelberg, Consultant January 23 rd thru 26 th, 2012 RAMS Session 13C

Example CaseCapacitor24/7 operationHigh voltage loadOutdoor environment

Insulation breakdown failure mechanism

Let’s consider some ALT options

Page 11: Determine and Design the Best ALT Fred Schenkelberg, Consultant January 23 rd thru 26 th, 2012 RAMS Session 13C

Time Compression

Page 12: Determine and Design the Best ALT Fred Schenkelberg, Consultant January 23 rd thru 26 th, 2012 RAMS Session 13C

Build a Model

Page 13: Determine and Design the Best ALT Fred Schenkelberg, Consultant January 23 rd thru 26 th, 2012 RAMS Session 13C

Given a Model

Peck’s Relationship

Page 14: Determine and Design the Best ALT Fred Schenkelberg, Consultant January 23 rd thru 26 th, 2012 RAMS Session 13C

Step Stress

Page 15: Determine and Design the Best ALT Fred Schenkelberg, Consultant January 23 rd thru 26 th, 2012 RAMS Session 13C

Degradation

Page 16: Determine and Design the Best ALT Fred Schenkelberg, Consultant January 23 rd thru 26 th, 2012 RAMS Session 13C

Example CaseCapacitor24/7 operationHigh voltage loadOutdoor environment

Insulation breakdown failure mechanism

3 viable ALT options

Page 17: Determine and Design the Best ALT Fred Schenkelberg, Consultant January 23 rd thru 26 th, 2012 RAMS Session 13C

SelectAssume a Model

ALT Selection

Page 18: Determine and Design the Best ALT Fred Schenkelberg, Consultant January 23 rd thru 26 th, 2012 RAMS Session 13C

Questions?