desirable possible selves and depression in adult women with eating disorders

7
ORIGINAL ARTICLE Desirable possible selves and depression in adult women with eating disorders Martin G. Erikson Berit Hansson Suzanna Lundblad Received: 8 November 2013 / Accepted: 28 March 2014 / Published online: 13 April 2014 Ó Springer International Publishing Switzerland 2014 Abstract Purpose Possible selves are conceptions of our selves in future states. Previous findings indicated that women with anorexia nervosa tended to have more negative possible selves than a control group, even when rating future situ- ations normally regarded in our society as desirable. The present study investigated whether this was a general pat- tern in women with eating disorders, relating findings on possible selves to depression. Possible selves concerning treatment were also included. Methods Patients with anorexia nervosa (n = 19), buli- mia nervosa (n = 29) or an eating disorder not otherwise specified (EDNOS) (n = 18) and a control group (n = 27) rated the valence of five possible selves on Likert’s scales. Levels of depression were measured among the patients using the Beck Depression Inventory. Results The patients rated the valence of the possible selves significantly less positively and more negatively than did the control group. A strong correlation between valence and depression was found in patients with anorexia nervosa and bulimia nervosa. No such correlation was found in patients with EDNOS. Possible selves concerning future treatment were rated even more negatively. Conclusions The results indicate that, when compared to a non-patient group, eating disorder patients make more negative evaluations of possible selves usually seen as desirable. Depression may be a mediating factor in these evaluations for the anorexia and bulimia patients. Keywords Anorexia nervosa Á Bulimia nervosa Á Eating disorder not otherwise specified Á Possible selves Á Depression Desirable possible selves and depression in adult women with eating disorders In the literature on anorexia nervosa and bulimia nervosa, there is consensus on the importance of patients’ self- concepts for understanding their disorders. The multitude of theoretical approaches to the self in eating disorders research calls for conceptual clarity, where Stein and Corte [1] argued for the use of the social cognitive model [2, 3]. In relation to this model, it has been argued that possible selves theory provides a viable approach to the study and treatment of eating disorders [1, 46]. Possible selves are part of the self-concept; they are the individual’s concrete, idiosyncratic conceptions on his/her own future selves, including conceptions of their value and their probability, thus having a direct influence on meaning making and behavior [710]. Patients with anorexia nervosa or bulimia nervosa have been found to be more likely to formulate negative images of the future [11], and patients with anorexia nervosa, compared with a control group, tended to spontaneously report a larger number of negative possible selves, with a higher negative valence for these possible selves compared with a control group [6]. Much less is known about PsycINFO classification: 3260 Eating Disorders. M. G. Erikson (&) School of Education and Behavioural Sciences, University of Bora ˚s, SE-501 90 Bora ˚s, Sweden e-mail: [email protected] B. Hansson Á S. Lundblad The Anorexia and Bulimia Clinic for Adults, Sahlgrenska University Hospital, Olskroksgatan 30, SE-416 66 Go ¨teborg, Sweden e-mail: [email protected] 123 Eat Weight Disord (2014) 19:145–151 DOI 10.1007/s40519-014-0122-7

Upload: suzanna

Post on 21-Jan-2017

213 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Desirable possible selves and depression in adult women with eating disorders

ORIGINAL ARTICLE

Desirable possible selves and depression in adult womenwith eating disorders

Martin G. Erikson • Berit Hansson •

Suzanna Lundblad

Received: 8 November 2013 / Accepted: 28 March 2014 / Published online: 13 April 2014

� Springer International Publishing Switzerland 2014

Abstract

Purpose Possible selves are conceptions of our selves in

future states. Previous findings indicated that women with

anorexia nervosa tended to have more negative possible

selves than a control group, even when rating future situ-

ations normally regarded in our society as desirable. The

present study investigated whether this was a general pat-

tern in women with eating disorders, relating findings on

possible selves to depression. Possible selves concerning

treatment were also included.

Methods Patients with anorexia nervosa (n = 19), buli-

mia nervosa (n = 29) or an eating disorder not otherwise

specified (EDNOS) (n = 18) and a control group (n = 27)

rated the valence of five possible selves on Likert’s scales.

Levels of depression were measured among the patients

using the Beck Depression Inventory.

Results The patients rated the valence of the possible

selves significantly less positively and more negatively

than did the control group. A strong correlation between

valence and depression was found in patients with anorexia

nervosa and bulimia nervosa. No such correlation was

found in patients with EDNOS. Possible selves concerning

future treatment were rated even more negatively.

Conclusions The results indicate that, when compared to

a non-patient group, eating disorder patients make more

negative evaluations of possible selves usually seen as

desirable. Depression may be a mediating factor in these

evaluations for the anorexia and bulimia patients.

Keywords Anorexia nervosa � Bulimia nervosa � Eating

disorder not otherwise specified � Possible selves �Depression

Desirable possible selves and depression in adult women

with eating disorders

In the literature on anorexia nervosa and bulimia nervosa,

there is consensus on the importance of patients’ self-

concepts for understanding their disorders. The multitude

of theoretical approaches to the self in eating disorders

research calls for conceptual clarity, where Stein and Corte

[1] argued for the use of the social cognitive model [2, 3].

In relation to this model, it has been argued that possible

selves theory provides a viable approach to the study and

treatment of eating disorders [1, 4–6]. Possible selves are

part of the self-concept; they are the individual’s concrete,

idiosyncratic conceptions on his/her own future selves,

including conceptions of their value and their probability,

thus having a direct influence on meaning making and

behavior [7–10].

Patients with anorexia nervosa or bulimia nervosa have

been found to be more likely to formulate negative images

of the future [11], and patients with anorexia nervosa,

compared with a control group, tended to spontaneously

report a larger number of negative possible selves, with a

higher negative valence for these possible selves compared

with a control group [6]. Much less is known about

PsycINFO classification: 3260 Eating Disorders.

M. G. Erikson (&)

School of Education and Behavioural Sciences, University of

Boras, SE-501 90 Boras, Sweden

e-mail: [email protected]

B. Hansson � S. Lundblad

The Anorexia and Bulimia Clinic for Adults, Sahlgrenska

University Hospital, Olskroksgatan 30, SE-416 66 Goteborg,

Sweden

e-mail: [email protected]

123

Eat Weight Disord (2014) 19:145–151

DOI 10.1007/s40519-014-0122-7

Page 2: Desirable possible selves and depression in adult women with eating disorders

self-deficits in patients with an eating disorder not other-

wise specified (EDNOS), although the research shows that

the condition can be as serious as anorexia nervosa or

bulimia nervosa [12–14]. The literature defines subgroups

of EDNOS, one being patients who have previously been

diagnosed with anorexia nervosa or bulimia nervosa and

who are given an EDNOS diagnosis based on sub-threshold

symptoms [12, 13, 15]. Patients with sub-threshold ED-

NOS have been shown to display levels of psychopathol-

ogy not different from the corresponding full criteria

patients [13, 14, 16].

One co-morbidity common in all eating disorders is

depression, and depressed patients have shown patterns of

negative expectations about the future similar to those

found in patients with eating disorders [16]. Previous

results suggest that no statistically significant differences in

levels of depression should be expected between patients

with anorexia nervosa, bulimia nervosa and EDNOS with

sub-threshold anorexia or bulimia symptoms [16]. In rela-

tion to possible selves, depression is known to reduce the

ability to anticipate future positive events by increasing

negative and decreasing positive thinking [17–20]. The

cognitive model of depression formulated by Beck [21, 22]

shares features with the theories of the self on which the

construct of possible selves is based, as it describes

depression as a function of both future and present selves.

One study of possible selves and depression found that

depressed subjects were characterized by having negative

beliefs about themselves rather than by an absence of

positive beliefs [23]. In this study, depression was strongly

connected with feelings of self-denigration, a phenomenon

also found in patients with anorexia nervosa [24, 25].

Further, participants who scored high on depression

reported more negative possible selves, which also corre-

lated with less effective coping strategies; this also accords

with previous findings [10, 26]. Studies have also shown

that possible selves are often complex, in that they have

both negative and positive valence [6, 11, 27].

Less is know about how depressed subjects rate the

positive and negative valence of possible selves that are

usually seen as desirable by subjects not suffering from

depression. Erikson, Hansson and Lundblad [6] found that

almost all patients with anorexia nervosa in their study saw

a range of negative or threatening futures in situations that

are normally regarded as positive by non-clinical groups.

About two-third of patients in this study reported strong

negative emotions and weak positive emotions in relation

to such ‘‘desirable’’ possible selves as meeting with friends.

The patients reporting negative expectations about ‘‘desir-

able’’ futures were asked to spontaneously report possible

selves, which makes it impossible to determine to what

degree fears of negatively rated ‘‘desirable’’ situations were

shared by the participants. Further, very few spontaneous

possible selves in this study [6] were related to treatment or

clinic visits.

The first question we addressed in the present study was

how widespread the tendency is for patients with anorexia

nervosa, as well as patients with bulimia nervosa and those

with EDNOS with sub-threshold anorexia or bulimia, to

regard normally ‘‘desirable’’ possible selves as negative.

This evaluation of ‘‘desirable’’ possible selves was made in

terms of both negative and positive valence. The second

question concerned how different levels of depression can

influence the valence of ‘‘desirable’’ possible selves in

these patient groups and the third how patients rate possible

selves related to treatment situations.

Method

Participants

The patient group consisted of 66 female patients diag-

nosed with eating disorders according to DSM-IV, all of

whom were outpatients at the Anorexia & Bulimia Clinic

for Adults, Sahlgrenska University Hospital, in Gothen-

burg, Sweden. In total, 72 patients were approached; one

declined participation and an additional five were discarded

due to incomplete data. Remaining were 19 patients with

anorexia nervosa in the age range 24–60 years

(Mage = 32.5, SD = 8.6), eight of whom had anorexia

nervosa of the purging type, 29 patients with bulimia in the

age range 25–49 years (Mage = 32.3, SD = 7.3) and 18

patients with EDNOS in the age range 25–52 years

(Mage = 31.1, SD = 7.5). The patients with EDNOS were

selected because they had all previously been diagnosed

with anorexia nervosa or bulimia nervosa, either upon

admittance to the Anorexia & Bulimia Clinic for Adults

Table 1 Background variables for the patient groups

Diagnosis

Anorexia Bulimia EDNOS

(n = 19) (n = 29) (n = 18)

Beck Depression Inventory score

(BDI)

18.3 27.1 25.7

Mean body mass index 17.0 22.3 20.8

Mean time in treatment at A and B

clinic (months)

30.5 11.2 29.5

Number of patients previously

treated at other clinics

13 16 11

Number of patients studying 4 6 1

Number of patients working 7 17 9

Number of patients on sick leave 7 6 8

Number of patients unemployed 1 0 0

146 Eat Weight Disord (2014) 19:145–151

123

Page 3: Desirable possible selves and depression in adult women with eating disorders

(n = 7) or through previous diagnostics at other clinics

(n = 11), and had since undergone a change in symptoms

giving an EDNOS diagnosis––a diagnostic group that

previous research suggests is comparable with bulimia and

anorexia patients, as discussed above. At the time of the

study, 16 EDNOS patients reported that they starved

themselves and six reported that they purged occasionally.

Further, background data on the patients are presented in

Table 1.

The control group consisted of 27 Swedish female

psychology university students in the age range

20–51 years (Mage = 27.7, SD = 7.6). In total, 29 students

were approached and two declined participation. While the

health of the control group was not measured, the controls

can be assumed to be representative of a normally healthy

population of female students.

Material

The instrument, in Swedish, consisted of five predefined

possible selves describing ‘‘desirable’’ situations; an Eng-

lish translation is presented in Table 2. We selected the

situations based on the results reported in Erikson et al. [6]

and based on clinical experience. The common feature was

that the situations included opportunities for something that

would be considered desirable by most people. They were

not situations to be achieved, but situations that could

occur independent of any strivings or intentions. Beside

these five ‘‘desirable’’ possible selves, two more possible

selves related to treatment and clinic visits were included.

All possible selves were formulated so as to be general

enough to fit into anyone’s life, while at the same time

being specific enough to qualify as a possible self. The

situations selected did not involve or imply dealing with

food or eating.

The participants were asked to rate each possible self

in relation to positive and negative feelings associated

with the possible selves on 7-point Likert’s scales, with

values from 0 to 6, thus giving separate measures of

positive and negative valence for each possible self. The

control group was given the same instrument, with the

exception of the two possible selves describing visits to

the clinic. Further, the patients were scored on the Beck

Depression Inventory (BDI) [21, 22]. The control group

was not scored on the BDI, as they had recently studied

depression and measures of depression as part of their

psychology courses.

Procedure

All patients, already diagnosed and admitted as outpatients,

visiting at the clinic during four consecutive weeks were

approached by the clinic’s secretary and informed about

the study in person. Those interested were given further

information by the psychologist or psychiatrist responsible

for their treatment who also administrated the instrument.

Before volunteering, the patients were informed both ver-

bally and in writing that they were to imagine themselves

in the various situations and report how they spontaneously

believe they felt about them. They were also informed that

the test was not part of the treatment and that the results

would not be used to assess or compare individuals, only

groups. Finally, they were informed that the study was

completely voluntary, that their anonymity would be

ensured and that they could withdraw at any time. They

were also told that if they did withdraw, any data provided

by them would be deleted. The participants completed the

instruments at the clinic. Data from three patients with

anorexia nervosa and two patients with EDNOS were

discarded due to incomplete BDI data. No participants

withdrew from the study.

The control group was approached by their lecturer and

was given the same information as the patient group. For

those volunteering, the study was carried out in a classroom

setting. No student withdrew from the study.

The study was carried out in accordance with APA

ethical guidelines and approved by the section for medical

research of the Regional Ethical Review Board at the

University of Gothenburg, as required by Sahlgrenska

University Hospital (approval reference No. 040-07). Only

patients who had initially expressed an interest in the study

when approached in person by the secretary were asked to

participate by the clinical staff. The students in the control

group received no credit or other compensation for their

participation.

Table 2 Predefined possible selves presented to the participants in

random order, to be scored for negative and positive valence

‘‘Desirable’’ possible selves

I meet an old friend on the street who wants me to come

shopping.

I find the phone number of an old friend, with whom I have not

talked for a long time, who would be glad if I called.

A friend gives me a book about something that interests me a lot,

which my friend wants to discuss after I have read it.

A man who seems nice gives me a compliment about my hair.

Someone I care for wants to know my plans for the summer, so

we can do something together.

Possible selves described in relation to visiting the clinic

I am sitting in the waiting room here at the clinic, awaiting an

appointment with my therapist.

I participate in a group session with other patients here at the A

and B clinic.

Eat Weight Disord (2014) 19:145–151 147

123

Page 4: Desirable possible selves and depression in adult women with eating disorders

Analysis

Means were compared using ANOVA, with Bonferroni’s

posthoc tests used for pairwise comparison when applica-

ble. Spearman correlations were two-tailed as there was no

directional hypothesis on which to base one-tailed corre-

lations. Linear regression analyses were used to assess the

influence of assumed multiple predictors. A posthoc power

analysis showed that on the basis of the means and effect

sizes (Cohen’s d) measured, some caution is called for

regarding the comparison between anorexia nervosa

patients and the control group (d = 1.1 for positive pos-

sible selves and d = 1.4 for negative possible selves), as a

sample size of n = 25 would have been required to achieve

statistical power at the 0.80 level. For the comparison

between the control group and the EDNOS patients

(d = 1.4 for positive possible selves and d = 2.0 for neg-

ative possible selves), as well as the bulimia nervosa

patients (d = 0.98 for positive possible selves and d = 2.4

for negative possible selves), statistical power at the rec-

ommended 0.80 level could be achieved with the present

sample size. An alpha level of 0.05 was used for all sta-

tistical tests.

Results

The total means of positive and negative valence for the

five ‘‘desirable’’ possible selves common to the patient

group and the control group are presented in Table 3. The

mean of the positive valence showed significant differ-

ences, F(3, 89) = 7.51, p \ 0.000, g2 = 0.202, where the

pairwise comparison showed that the control group differed

statistically significantly from all three patient groups, as

shown in Table 3. Similarly, the mean of the negative

valence showed significant differences, F(3, 89) = 11.20,

p \ 0.000, g2 = 0.274, where the control group differed

significantly from all three patient groups. There were no

significant differences between the patient groups for either

positive or negative valence.

For depression, as measured by BDI scores, the patient

groups differed significantly, F(3, 63) = 3.83, p = 0.027,

g2 = 0.108, where the pairwise comparisons showed that

patients with anorexia nervosa (MBDI = 18.3, SD = 11.7,

range 4–49) had significantly lower rates of depression

compared with patients with bulimia nervosa

(MBDI = 27.1, SD = 10.9, range 7–41), whereas patients

with EDNOS (MBDI = 25.4, SD = 10.6, range 4–47) did

not differ significantly from the other patient groups. The

correlations between the valence of ‘‘desirable possible

selves’’ and BDI score are presented in Table 4. For

patients with anorexia nervosa, there was a significant

negative correlation between depression and positive

valence, q(17) = -0.567, p = 0.011, and for negative

valence a strong trend toward positive correlation,

q(17) = 0.440, p = 0.059. Similarly, for patients with

bulimia nervosa, there was a significant negative correla-

tion between depression and positive valence, q(27) = -

0.475, p = 0.009, and for negative valence a significant

positive correlation, q(27) = 0.531, p = 0.003. For

patients in the EDNOS group, no significant correlations

were found, with negative correlations of both positive and

negative valence close to zero. Patients in the EDNOS

group who had previously been in treatment for anorexia

nervosa or bulimia nervosa at other clinics did not differ

significantly from those who had their first diagnosis at the

clinic where the study was conducted.

Due to the age distribution of the participants, a

regression analysis was carried out in order to control for

age as an independent variable. The results, presented in

Table 5, indicate that age had a negligible predictive value

on the valence of possible selves, and though the B-coef-

ficients in relation to age for the EDNOS patients were

higher, the results were not statistically significant.

The means of positive and negative valence for the

possible selves described in relation to visits to the clinic

were compared with the overall means for the five

‘‘desirable’’ possible selves. The positive valence of the

Table 3 Means, with standard deviation in parentheses, for the

valence of the ‘‘desirable’’ possible selves

Valence of

‘‘desirable’’

possible selves

Diagnosis

Anorexia Bulimia EDNOS Control

group

Positive 3.7 (1.3) 3.8 (1.3) 3.3 (1.4) 4.8 (0.6)**

Negative 2.5 (1.3) 2.3 (1.3) 2.8 (1.2) 1.1 (0.4)**

** Significant difference at the p \ 0.01 level (two-tailed) when

compared to the patient groups

Table 4 Spearman’s rho correlation between depression, measured

as BDI scores, and positive and negative valence of possible selves

Possible selves Diagnosis

Anorexia Bulimia EDNOS

‘‘Desirable’’ possible selves

Positive valence -0.567* -0.479** -0.032

Negative valence 0.440 0.531** -0.039

Visits to the clinic

Positive valence -0.077 -0.389* 0.279

Negative valence 0.313 0.343 -0.218

** Significant at the 0.01 level (two-tailed)

* Significant at the 0.05 level (two-tailed)

148 Eat Weight Disord (2014) 19:145–151

123

Page 5: Desirable possible selves and depression in adult women with eating disorders

possible selves concerning visits to the clinic (M = 3.2,

SD = 1.5) was significantly lower, F(1, 65) = 6.67,

p = 0.012, g2 = 0.093, than the means of ‘‘desirable pos-

sible selves’’ (M = 3.7, SD = 1.2). There were no signif-

icant differences between the negative valence of the

possible selves concerning visits to the clinic (M = 2.7,

SD = 1.4) and the means for negative valence for ‘‘desir-

able possible selves’’ (M = 2.5, SD = 1.3). No significant

differences between patient groups were found in the dis-

tance between ‘‘desirable’’ possible selves and the possible

selves concerning clinic visits. The correlations between

valence for visits to the clinic and BDI score are presented

in Table 4. For patients with anorexia nervosa, the corre-

lations for both positive and negative valence of visits to

the clinic were not significant. For patients with bulimia

nervosa, there was both a significant negative correlation

between depression and positive valence, q(27) = -0.389,

p = 0.037, and a non-significant trend toward a positive

correlation between negative valence and depression,

q(27) = 0.343, p = 0.068. For patients in the EDNOS

group, no significant correlation was found.

In total, 72 % of the responses to the possible selves

were rated as having both positive and negative valence

(i.e., both negative and positive valence rated above zero).

For the control group, the proportion was 66 %, whereas it

was 75 % for patients with anorexia nervosa, 70 % for

patients with bulimia nervosa and 78 % for patients with

EDNOS.

Discussion

The purpose of the present study was to investigate the

valence of ‘‘desirable’’ possible selves and possible selves

concerning treatment in patients with eating disorders and

to relate these results to rates of depression. The main

finding was that, when compared to the control group, the

patient groups, regardless of diagnosis, were significantly

more negative in their negative ratings of ‘‘desirable’’

possible selves. Correspondingly, the patient groups were

significantly less positive in their positive ratings of these

possible selves. Thus, the present data support and expand

the findings of Erikson et al. [12], suggesting that this is a

general pattern, not only in patients with anorexia nervosa

but also in patients with bulimia nervosa and EDNOS.

While patients with anorexia nervosa had a statistically

significantly lower level of depression compared with

patients with bulimia nervosa, there were no significant

differences in ratings of positive or negative valence

between the patient groups. It has been suggested [28] that

tests of depression in patients with anorexia nervosa may

largely reflect symptoms of starvation rather than actual

depression, but it can at least be concluded that all three

patient groups showed some degree of depression as a co-

morbidity, which supports previous findings [13, 14, 16].

The correlations between depression and valence of

‘‘desirable’’ possible selves showed that patients with

anorexia nervosa and bulimia nervosa tended to regard the

possible selves as more negative and less positive with

increased rates of depression. Whereas a great deal of the

previous research on depression has focused on partici-

pants’ ability to formulate positive and negative futures,

the present results broaden the picture by including

‘‘desirable’’ possible selves, which accords well with the

general pattern as far as patients with anorexia nervosa and

bulimia nervosa are concerned [1, 11].

A more unexpected result was the total lack of corre-

lation between valence and depression for patients with

EDNOS. In other words, patients with EDNOS suffered

equally from depression and had equally negative ratings

of ‘‘desirable’’ futures as the other two patient groups did,

but without the relation between depression and valence

Table 5 Summary of

regression analysis for

independent variables

depression, measured as BDI

scores, and age as predictors for

positive and negative valence of

‘‘desirable’’ possible selves

** Significant at the 0.01 level

* Significant at the 0.05 level

Diagnosis

Anorexia Bulimia EDNOS

B Std.Error B Std.Error B Std.Error

Positive valence

BDI -0.060** 0.020 -0.053** 0.018 -0.003 0.026

Age 0.003 0.027 0.013 0.027 0.054 0.041

R2 0.371 0.249 0.104

F 4.71* 4.30* 0.87

Negative valence

BDI 0.055* 0.023 0.066** 0.020 0.000 0.025

Age -0.003 0.031 -0.004 0.030 -0.034 0.039

R2 0.276 0.298 0.39

F 3.05 5.52** 0.050

Eat Weight Disord (2014) 19:145–151 149

123

Page 6: Desirable possible selves and depression in adult women with eating disorders

found in the other patient groups. One possible explanation

is that some of the patients with EDNOS, while recovering,

had also lost the mechanisms for dealing with anxiety and

life demands they once had in the form of anorexia and

bulimia symptoms. In future research, it may be fruitful to

include measures of anxiety as an additional variable in a

search for possible explanations of EDNOS symptoms. It

may also be worth investigating whether the self-punish-

ment found in patients with anorexia nervosa, as previously

reported [25], might find other outlets when patients with

EDNOS have lost some control over their eating behavior,

thus influencing their ratings of ‘‘desirable’’ possible selves

in this way.

All of the patient groups saw a future visit to the clinic, or

participation in treatment, as lower in positive valence than

their ‘‘desirable’’ possible selves and equally higher in

negative valence. The correlational patterns between

depression and valence were not as clear. For positive

valence, patients with anorexia nervosa showed no corre-

lation at all, whereas patients with bulimia nervosa showed

the same pattern as they did for the ‘‘desirable’’ possible

selves: the more depressed they felt, the less positive and

more negative the valence. Here, the EDNOS group differed

considerably: the more depressed subjects found visiting the

clinic more positive and less negative. This can be seen as a

healthier reaction: they feel ill and are motivated for treat-

ment. Whereas anorexia nervosa is typically connected with

resistance to change [29], less is known about these mech-

anisms in bulimia nervosa. Still, these patients show the

most negative reactions to visiting the clinic.

We believe that the present study underlines the rele-

vance of possible selves as a theoretical approach to our

understanding of eating disorders. One general conclusion

is that the results support the claim that possible selves

should not be regarded as either positive or negative. A

further general conclusion is that futures usually seen as

desirable by most of us can be regarded very differently by

an eating disorder patient. Our findings, combined with

patterns reported in previous research [13, 14, 16], also call

for caution in seeing a move from anorexia nervosa or

bulimia nervosa to EDNOS as a ‘‘recovery’’ in any sim-

plistic terms: while we cannot see whether the participating

patients with EDNOS are on their way to full recovery or

will relapse into anorexia nervosa or bulimia nervosa, the

change in diagnosis does not mean these patients must be

feeling better or find life easier than the average patient

suffering from anorexia nervosa or bulimia nervosa. If

patients were aware that leaving their original diagnosis

will not necessarily make them feel better, they could

develop strategies for dealing with their emotions that do

not involve harmful eating behavior. Such support could be

aimed at giving these patients new positive possible selves

to facilitate coping [10, 26].

Limitations

One weakness of the study is the small sample sizes, in

particular in the EDNOS and anorexia nervosa groups: the

effect sizes measured are not insubstantial but the results

need corroboration. Another limiting factor in the present

study is that many participants had long histories of illness

and younger patients might show quite different patterns.

Thus, similar research on younger patient groups with a

briefer history of illness is called for. Further, the lack of

health data on the control group adds some uncertainty, but

there is no reason to assume that the control group is not

representative of a normal population of female students of

a similar age as the patients. The instrument given to the

patient groups differed from that for the control group in

that two possible selves concerning treatment were inclu-

ded: this calls for caution, since the items about treatment

might affect the patients’ general views about the future by

triggering negative thoughts about their illness. Because

the patients were already in a treatment context when

filling out the instrument, we concluded that the risk was

small, but it must be considered.

I ought to be noted that there were different settings for

the questionnaires (clinical treatment vs. classroom). These

discrepancies may have influenced the outcome of our

observations. Nor did we employ the BDI score from the

control group. Nevertheless, it ought to be clear from the

study design that the control group employed was assigned

a specific role, i.e., that of estimating the valence of the

desirable possible selves.

Conflict of interest On behalf of all authors, the corresponding

author states that there is no conflict of interest.

References

1. Stein KF, Corte C (2007) Identity impairments and the eating

disorders: content and organization of the self-concept in women

with anorexia nervosa and bulimia nervosa. Eur Eat Disord Rev

15:58–69

2. Markus HR (1977) Self-schemata and processing information

about the self. J Pers Soc Psychol 35:63–78

3. Markus HR (1990) Unresolved issues of self-representation.

Cogni Ther Res 14:241–253

4. Knox M (2005) Possible selves and gender. In: Kerpelman J,

Dunckel C (eds) Possible selves: theory, research and application.

Nova Science Publications, New York, pp 61–77

5. Markus H, Hamill R, Sentis K (1987) Thinking fat: self-schemas

for body weight and the processing of weight relevant informa-

tion. J Appl Soc Psychol 17:50–71

6. Erikson MG, Hansson B, Lundblad S (2012) The possible selves

of adult women with anorexia nervosa. Eat Disord 20:288–299

7. Markus HR, Nurius P (1986) Possible selves. Am Psychol

41:954–959

8. Erikson MG (2007) Towards a more specific definition of pos-

sible selves. Rev Gen Psychol 11:348–358

150 Eat Weight Disord (2014) 19:145–151

123

Page 7: Desirable possible selves and depression in adult women with eating disorders

9. Markus HR, Ruvolo A (1989) Possible selves: personalized

representations of goals. In: Pervin LA (ed) Goal concepts in

personality and social psychology. Erlbaum, Hillsdale,

pp 211–241

10. Nurius P (1991) Possible selves and social support: social cog-

nitive resources for coping and striving. In: Howard J, Callero P

(eds) The self-society dynamic: cognitive, emotion, and action.

Cambridge Press, London, pp 239–258

11. Godley J, Tchanturia K, MacLeod A, Schmidt U (2001) Future-

directed thinking in eating disorders. Br J Clin Psychol

40:281–296

12. Fairburn CG, Bohn K (2005) Eating disorder NOS (EDNOS): an

example of the troublesome ‘‘not otherwise specified’’ (NOS)

category in DSM-IV. Behav Res Ther 43:691–701

13. Thomas JJ, Vartanian LR, Brownell KD (2009) The relationship

between eating disorder not otherwise specified (EDNOS) and

officially recognized eating disorders: meta-analysis and impli-

cations for DSM. Psychol Bull 135:407–433

14. Turner H, Bryant-Waugh R, Peveler R (2010) The clinical fea-

tures of EDNOS: relationship to mood, health status and general

functioning. Eat Behav 11:127–130

15. American Psychiatric Association (1994) Diagnostic and statis-

tical manual of mental disorders––DSM-IV, 4th edn. Author,

Washington, DC

16. Moor S, Vartanian LR, Touyz SW, Beumont PJV (2004) Psy-

chopathology of EDNOS patients: to whom do they compare?

Clin Psychol 8:70–75

17. Bjarehed J, Sarkohi A, Andersson G (2010) Less positive or more

negative? future-directed thinking in mild to moderate depres-

sion. Cogn Behav Ther 39:37–45

18. MacLeod AK, Byrne A (1996) Anxiety, depression and the

anticipation of future positive and negative experiences. J Ab-

norm Psychol 105:286–289

19. MacLeod AK, Byrne A, Valentine JD (1996) Affect, emotional

disorder and future- directed thinking. Cogn Emot 10:69–86

20. MacLeod AK, Salaminiou E (2001) Reduced positive future-

thinking in depression: cognitive and affective factors. Cogn

Emot 15:99–107

21. Beck AT, Rush J, Shaw B, Emery G (1979) Cognitive theory of

depression. Guilford Press, New York

22. Beck AT, Steer RA, Garbin MG (1988) Psychometric properties

of the Beck Depression Inventory: twenty-five years of evalua-

tion. Clin Psychol Rev 8:77–100

23. Allen LA, Woolfolk RL, Gara MA, Apter JT (1996) Possible

selves in major depression. J Nerv Ment Dis 184:739–745

24. Bruch H (1974) Eating disorders: obesity, anorexia nervosa and

the person within. Routledge Kegan Paul, London

25. Favaro A, Santonastaso P (2002) The spectrum of self-injurious

behavior in eating disorders. Eat Disord 10:215–225

26. Penland EA, Masten WG, Zelhart P, Fournet GP, Callahan TA

(2000) Possible selves, depression and coping skills in university

students. Pers Individ Differ 29:963–969

27. Erikson MG (2006) Our selves in the future [diss]. Department of

psychology, Lund university, Lund

28. Kennedy SH, Garfinkel PE (1992) Advances in diagnosis and

treatment of anorexia nervosa and bulimia nervosa. Can J Psy-

chiatr 37:309–315

29. Strober M (2004) Managing the chronic, treatment-resistant

patient with anorexia nervosa. Int J Eat Disord 36:245–255

Eat Weight Disord (2014) 19:145–151 151

123