designing writing - teaching · 11/11/2015 · pragmatic iconic analogic canonic pragmatic...
TRANSCRIPT
THE NEED OF ARCHITECTURAL RESEARCH A C A D E M I C & P R A C T I S E
UNTAR DISCUSSION 2015-11-03
THE “FACE” OF INDOARCH TODAYS
GLASS HIGH-RISE BUILDING PHENOMENA IN BIG CITIES
NEW YORK LONDON
JAPAN INDONESIA
AIRPORT PHENOMENA IN BIG CITIES
NEW YORK LONDON
JAPAN INDONESIA
AIRPORT PHENOMENA IN BIG CITIES
NEW YORK LONDON
JAPAN INDONESIA
MODERN HOUSE PHENOMENA IN BIG CITIES
NEW YORK LONDON
JAPAN INDONESIA
CHINA TOWN PHENOMENA IN BIG CITIES
NEW YORK
JAPAN INDONESIA
LONDON
PADANG RESTO PHENOMENA IN INDONESIA
GREEK STYLE PHENOMENA IN INDONESIA
“BEDAH”-RUMAH PHENOMENA IN INDONESIA
“TRADITIONAL-THEME” PHENOMENA IN INDONESIA
RECENT “CONDITION” OF INDOARCH PRACTISE & ACADEMIC
HOW TO “REACT” TO ARCHIPHENOMENA ? PRACTISE & ACADEMIC
“AWARDS” PHENOMENA
REACTION TO “AWARDS” PHENOMENA
RESEARCH ON “AWARDS” PHENOMENA
RESEARCH ON “AWARDS” PHENOMENA
“AWARDS” PHENOMENA
REACTION TO “AWARDS” PHENOMENA
RESEARCH ON “AWARDS” PHENOMENA
RESEARCH ON “AWARDS” PHENOMENA
CHURCH COMMUNICATION PHENOMENA
RESEARCH ON “CHURCH COMMUNICATION” PHENOMENA
“AWARDS” PHENOMENA
RESEARCH ON “AWARDS” PHENOMENA
CRITICAL THINKING IN ARCHITECTURE PRACTISE & ACADEMIC
CRITICAL THINKING
SOCRATES CRITICAL THINKING
IS IT TRUE ?
IS IT GOOD ?
IS IT GOING TOBE
USEFUL?
SOCRATES CRITICAL THINKING
EINSTEIN’S CRITICAL THINKING
BLOOMS’S CRITICAL THINKING
TWO KINDS OF THINKING
CRITICAL THINKING STAGES
CRITICAL THINKING AND CULTURE PRACTISE & ACADEMIC
SYNCHRONIC DIAGRAM OF CULTURE
core culture
behaviour
doing & making
language
ritualisation
livelyhood
organization
space
place
ultimate achievement
knowing & creating
character
COLISSION OF CULTURES
1. INLUENCING
CIVILIZATION 1
INDO CULTURE OTHER CULTURE
2 2. INFLUENCING
KNOWLEDGE
3 3. INFLUENCING
BEHAVIOUR
C O N D I T I O N O F W E A K C U L T U R E
more proud when using foreign language
more proud when using foreign language C O N D I T I O N O F W E A K C U L T U R E
more proud when using foreign language C O N D I T I O N O F W E A K C U L T U R E
1935
CRITICAL THINKING ON CULTURAL ISSUES
2015
CRITICAL ISSUES ON THE CULTURE OF THINKING ?
HOW TO “VALUE” ARCHITECTURAL THINKING PRACTISE & ACADEMIC
STANDARD OF ACHIEVEMENT
STANDARD OF ULTIMATE ACHIEVEMENT
STANDARD FOR BENCH MARK VALUE
STANDARD CREATIVITY OR ANTI STANDARD ?
HOW TO “VALUE” ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN PRACTISE & ACADEMIC
TYPE OF ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN
PRAGMATIC
ICONIC
ANALOGIC
CANONIC
PRAGMATIC
TYPOLOGIC
ANALOGIC
SYNTACTIC 1960 1987
BROADBENT
DEEP STRUCTURE 0F ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN
CLIMATE
BEHAVIOUR
CULTURAL
RESOURCES
HILLIER - 1972
FIT TO ITS INHABITANTS
FIT TO ITS COMMUNITY’S VALUES
FIT TO ITS SITE
FIT TO ITS CLIMATE
“FITNESS” TO THE STANDARD VALUE ?
NEW YORK LONDON
JAPAN INDONESIA
“FITNESS” TO THE STANDARD VALUE ?
STANDARD TO “VALUE” ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN PRACTISE & ACADEMIC
BASIC REFERENCES TO JUDGE ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN
HUMAN
NATURE
NATURE REFERENCES TO JUDGE ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN
NIGHT AND DAY ROTATION
HUMAN REFERENCES TO JUDGE ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN
[ALMOST] SIMETRICAL FRONT-SIDE-BACK
REFERENCES TO JUDGE ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN
REFERENCES TO JUDGE ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN
balance orientation
part - whole hierarchy
repetition
datum
rythm
axis
top-down
front-back
right-left
far-near
STANDARD TO “VALUE” ARCHITECTURAL WRITINGS PRACTISE & ACADEMIC
T SHIRTS COLLECTION FOR MASTER STUDENTS
WHAT YOU KNOW HOW MUCH YOU KNOW
PHILOSOPHY IS A MUST
DOCTORAL EDUCATION
KNOWLEDGE POSITION
Philosophy Mapping Typomorphological Approach
French Italian England
Quatremere d Quincy
Abbe Laugier
Louis Durand, Poete
August Comte Ferdinand de Saussure
Tricart Camillo Sitte
Saverio Muratori
Gianfranco Cannigia
Aldo Rossi
Carlo Aymonimo
Conzen Jean Castex
Phillip Panerai
KNOWLEDGE POSITION
Philosophy
Structuralist Typomorphology
Structure/system Tissue
Structure of Arch. Type
Transformation Transformation
Deep-structure Propelling
Surface-structure Pathologist
Relation Whole-parts
Sychronic Relation at one time
Diachronic Transformation
Binnary-opposition Individual-communal
PO
INT
S IN
TH
ES
IS/D
ISS
ER
TAT
ION
WR
ITIN
GS
PHENOMENA
ISSUE/PROBLEMS
RESEARCH QUESTION – [HYPO]THESIS
OBJECTIVES - CONTRIBUTION
THEORITICAL STANCE
OPERATIONALIZATION - METHODS
INTEGRATING TO CASE STUDY
DISCUSSION - RESULTS
CONCLUSION
JOU
RN
AL
WR
ITIN
G S
TAG
ES
REFERENCES
INTRODUCTION
State of The Arts Research Formulation
Research Objective
MATERIALS & METHODS
DISCUSSION
RESULT
CONCLUSION
ABSTRACT & KEYWORDS
TITLE
citation Main
component
of
manuscript
EXAMPLES [RUDY TRISNO JOURNAL- ISI THOMSON REUTERS]
INTRODUCTION The 2nd Vatican Council delivered a decision about renewing the liturgy that is associated with the local value. This decision triggered many new form of Church that did not necessarily follow a certain style and has made Catholic Church’s form became very diverse [1,2]. The Catholic Church should express the sacred liturgy not creating a new form that will eventually fade the sacred value. This issue has generated Pope Benedict to create a congregation under direct supervision from the Cardinal Llovera to avoid the fading of the sacred form in the Catholic Church [3,4]. This issue has become very important to be discussed because it was directly related with the relationship between liturgy function and the Catholic Church’s sacred form [5,6]. From the description above, this study discussed and analysed all of the relationship in the function of the liturgy process and the sacred expression in the Catholic Church in detail. This study brought forward a new alternative approach that elaborates and integrates the sacred liturgy function approach with the expression form in the Catholic Church. The purpose from this study are: firstly, to observe the beneficial relationship between the function and the form in the case study; Secondly, to elaborate a new way to understand the relationship between the function and the form in the architecture context; Thirdly, to give a specific input for all of the stakeholders about the form of the Catholic Church that is in line with the Catholic value; Fourth, to positioned the development of the sacred form of the Catholic Church in the context of post 2nd Vatican Council.
STATE OF THE ARTS
RESEARCH FORMULATION
NOVELTY
RESEARCH OBJECTIVE
RESEARCH CONTRIBUTION
EXAMPLES [RUDY TRISNO JOURNAL- ISI THOMSON REUTERS]
ABSTRACT
This study aims to explore the relationship between the sacred function from the liturgy process and the expression form in the Catholic Church after the 2nd Vatican Council in Santo Matias Rasul Church, Jakarta. Jakarta is the pioneer for the growth and it has the largest number of Catholic Church. The method used in this study were: Firstly, recording the Santo Matias Rasul Church’s building and then re-draw the church in detail so that the architectural building and the ornament can be analyzed. Secondly, the relationship between the sacred function concept, liturgy process and form expression concept were used. The analysis between these three items were triangulated with the user in Santo Matias Rasul Church . The result of the study conclude that the relationship between the sacred function and the expression form in Santo Matias Rasul Church were shown from the building element that accommodates the sacred function activities from the liturgy process. Hence, if the building element were present and completed it could be said that the whole architecture from Santo Matias Rasul church radiates the sacred expression that is in line with the Catholic value. Key Words : Relation, Function, Form, Expression, Sacred
OBJECTIVE
METHODS
RESULT
CONCLUSION
PHENOMENA
PHENOMENA
ME
EDUCATING AS
WELL AS BRING
BENEFICIAL TO
THE SOCIETY
RESEARCH
APPLICATION
PUBLICATION
PHENOMENA
RESEARCH CULTURE
PURNAMA SALURA
SOURCE : INTERNET
[email protected] @purnamasalura www.purnamasalura.com
DOING RESEARCH