department of school education...

35
Department of School Education Haryana Appropriate Authority (as prescribed under Rule 34 (1) of Haryana School Education Rules-2003) newt=..e:et).t.6 .orste s. s.Nmr Lead me from Darkness to I tee Memo No. 18/10-2012 PS(1) 3-Dec-2012 In exercise of powers conferred under Rule 29 (3) read with Rule 3 of Haryana School Education Rules-2003 Education Department, Haryana hereby permit to add new proposed classes for higher stage. However, it is made clear that such permission will not enable such school to get recognition automatically for which the applicant shall have to fulfill the required conditions. This letter of permission is based on the undertaking given by the applicant as per details given overleaf Any violation of the undertaking automatically nullifies the permission. This permission is further subject to 'No Objection' from the 'Competent Authority' regulating the land use of the proposed site. The permission to add new proposed classes for higher stage is only 'In-principle' approval of the Education Department to allow applicant to initiate steps and provide infrastructure to the new proposed classes of higher stage. Students should not be admitted only on this permission without getting recognition. The recognition will be granted R.T.E. Rules-12 Appendix-II by the Department on fulfillment of prescribed norms as provided in Haryana School Education Rules-2003, in the interest of safety, health and welfare of students and other requirements. * The managing committee shall abide by the provisions of Haryana School Education Rules 2003 (amended) & R.T.E. Reels 2011 and amendments it any thereafter. The Managing shall be liable for disciplinary action in case of violation of any provisions of the rules. PARTICULARS OF THE SCHOOL FOR WHICH THIS PERMISSION TO ADD NEW PROPOSED CLASSES FOR HIGHER STAGE SCHOOL 18 GRANTED Regn. N o. Name of the Individual , Association of Individual, Trust or Company establishing the School Name of the School SS-38/KKR-38 / BOSE / ENG&H D. 3 —Dec-12 Society under societies registration Act 1860 Kurukshetra Police Shiksha Samiti, Police Lines, Kurukshetra Police Vidya Mandir Police Lines, Pilpli (Kurukshetra) Address of the School Village/Town Pipli Panchayat/sector District Name Kurukshetra Stage 11th tol2th Medium English & Hindi Syllabus/Affiliation Board of School Education,Bhiwani,Haryana Details of Land Khewat No. 216 Khasra No. 69 (Khasra/Kila) This Permission is valid upto next two academic sessions Superintendent P.S. \ 2_01 For Director General Secondary Education 2—Haryana Panchkula. District Education Officer Kurukshetra Appropriate Authority as pleated under Rule-34(1)of Haryana School Education Rules - 2003 In CZCZCille of the power conferred by sub-section (1) read with sub-section (2) of section 24 of the Haryana School Education Act, 1995 (Act 12 of 1999), and all other powers enabling in this betel[ the Government of Hogan vide No. GSR 7/H.A. 12/99. 524(1)/2003 notified the Haryana School Education Rules-2003 to regulate education in ail non- Government schools, to promote better organisation and development of school education, the manner of admission to recognised schools, fee structure, uniform code of service conditions for employees, adequate infrastructurel fealties to be provided to pupils andto follow approved course of studies, inthe State of Haryana. • Please see the back of this document _3(6'9 .// 1-` ce-1( crJA

Upload: lamthuy

Post on 03-Apr-2018

309 views

Category:

Documents


9 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Department of School Education Haryanaschooleducationharyana.gov.in/downloads_pdf/daily_orders/2012/T05... · Education Rules-2003 Education Department, Haryana hereby permit to add

Department of School EducationHaryana

Appropriate Authority(as prescribed under Rule 34 (1) of Haryana School Education Rules-2003)

newt=..e:et).t.6.orstes. s.Nmr

Lead me from Darkness to I tee

Memo No. 18/10-2012 PS(1) 3-Dec-2012

In exercise of powers conferred under Rule 29 (3) read with Rule 3 of Haryana SchoolEducation Rules-2003 Education Department, Haryana hereby permit to add new proposedclasses for higher stage. However, it is made clear that such permission will not enable such schoolto get recognition automatically for which the applicant shall have to fulfill the requiredconditions.

This letter of permission is based on the undertaking given by the applicant as per detailsgiven overleaf Any violation of the undertaking automatically nullifies the permission. Thispermission is further subject to 'No Objection' from the 'Competent Authority' regulating theland use of the proposed site.

The permission to add new proposed classes for higher stage is only 'In-principle' approvalof the Education Department to allow applicant to initiate steps and provide infrastructure to thenew proposed classes of higher stage.

Students should not be admitted only on this permission without getting recognition. Therecognition will be granted R.T.E. Rules-12 Appendix-II by the Department on fulfillment ofprescribed norms as provided in Haryana School Education Rules-2003, in the interest of safety,health and welfare of students and other requirements.* The managing committee shall abide by the provisions of Haryana School Education Rules 2003(amended) & R.T.E. Reels 2011 and amendments it any thereafter. The Managing shall be liable fordisciplinary action in case of violation of any provisions of the rules.

PARTICULARS OF THE SCHOOLFOR WHICH THIS PERMISSION TO ADD

NEW PROPOSED CLASSES FOR HIGHER STAGE SCHOOL 18 GRANTED

Regn. N o.

Name of the Individual ,Association of Individual,Trust or Companyestablishing the SchoolName of the School

SS-38/KKR-38 / BOSE / ENG&H D. 3 —Dec-12Society under societies registration Act 1860Kurukshetra Police Shiksha Samiti, Police Lines,Kurukshetra

Police Vidya Mandir Police Lines, Pilpli (Kurukshetra)

Address of the School

Village/Town PipliPanchayat/sector

District Name Kurukshetra

Stage 11th tol2th

Medium English & Hindi

Syllabus/Affiliation Board of School Education,Bhiwani,Haryana

Details of Land

Khewat No. 216 Khasra No. 69(Khasra/Kila)

This Permission is valid upto next two academic sessions

Superintendent P.S. \2_01

For Director General Secondary Education2—Haryana Panchkula.

District Education Officer Kurukshetra

Appropriate Authority as pleated under Rule-34(1)of Haryana School Education Rules - 2003In CZCZCille of the power conferred by sub-section (1) read with sub-section (2) of section 24 of the Haryana SchoolEducation Act, 1995 (Act 12 of 1999), and all other powers enabling in this betel[ the Government of Hogan vide No.GSR 7/H.A. 12/99. 524(1)/2003 notified the Haryana School Education Rules-2003 to regulate education in ail non-Government schools, to promote better organisation and development of school education, the manner of admission torecognised schools, fee structure, uniform code of service conditions for employees, adequate infrastructurel fealties to beprovided to pupils andto follow approved course of studies, inthe State of Haryana.• Please see the back of this document

_3(6'9 .//1-` ce-1(crJA

Page 2: Department of School Education Haryanaschooleducationharyana.gov.in/downloads_pdf/daily_orders/2012/T05... · Education Rules-2003 Education Department, Haryana hereby permit to add

S.No Description Details

aThe area in which the new school is proposedto be estabfished

2.2 Acres

b The approximate number of students likely tobe enrolled in that school

0-100

c

d

The stage of education intended to beimparted in the new school

The particulars including measurements of thebuilding or other structures in which the school

11th to12th

18478 Sq. Ft.

e

is proposed to be run

The Financial resources from which theexpences for the establishment and runningof the school shall to be met.

f The proposed procedure untill its recognition The selection procedure will be adopted tounder these rules,for the selection of the appoint teaching and nonteaching staff as perhead of the school and other teachers and the provisions under Rule 163 of Haryananon teaching staff and the minimum School Education Rules,2003 by consituting aqualification for the recruitment. selection commitee.

g The proposed salary of the staff to be notified Selection Procedure would be as provided inRule 163 of Haryana Education Rules 2003 andother relevant provisions.The minimumqualification would also be as given inAppendix A attached with Haryana SchoolEducation Rule-2003

h Admission,tution and other fees and fundswhich would be levied and collected until its

CLASS I-V VI-VIII IX-X XI-XII

4dmission Fee

recognition under these rules, from thestudents of the proposed new school

Tution Fee

Other Fee

i Any other facility which is proposed to beprovided for students of the proposed newschool

Total Funds

Name Decimation/ The composition of managing committee of

the proposed new school until the newschool is recognized and a new managingcommittee is constituted in accordance withthe scheme of managing committee madeunder these rules-

Note:-The Permission is granted that on the subject to the condition that thr.documents/ Information furnished by the School authorities are factualand not devoid of truth in any way. However, if any information,at any stage,is found contrary to the facts the permission would be revoked forthwith.

Page 3: Department of School Education Haryanaschooleducationharyana.gov.in/downloads_pdf/daily_orders/2012/T05... · Education Rules-2003 Education Department, Haryana hereby permit to add

24 *s- col

HARYANA EDUCATIONSCHOOL EDUCATION DEPARTMENT

ORDERN ° • 5- /5 0 —off !/— pi-Disciplinary matter of Sh. Ran Singh, Block Education Officer (retd.) was

decided vide order No. 5/30-08 HRG-I(1) dated 27.01.2012 and a penalty of

cutting pension to the tune of 2%, along with recovery of loss to the tune of Rs.

75,600/ - caused to the state exchequer from the gratuity and other retiral

benefits, was inflicted upon the incumbent. For deciding the suspension period

from 22.01.2008 to 04.03.2008, a show cause notice was issued vide Memo

No.5/30-2008 HRG I(1) dated 21.08.2012 on the following grounds: -

Why the pay and allowances for the suspension period be not

restricted to whatever have been paid during the suspension period?

Why the suspension period be not treated as non-duty period?

In consequence thereof, he made representation dated 04.09.2012

wherein he stated that the department did not direct the gas agencies to issue

gas connection and as a consequence of that, gas bhattis have to be purchased

from the gas agency. He further submitted that no action has been taken

against the gas agency. He emphasized that in the absence of clear cut

directions from the directorate, the said items have been purchased from

approved gas agency only and all the payments have been made through

cheques. He finally requested that his suspension period should be treated as

duty period. It is specific to mention here that he did not say anything about

the show cause notice given regarding pay and allowances during the

suspension period.

After going through the representation, relevant provisions of The Punjab

Civil Services Rules Volume I Part I and Government instructions issued from

time to time in this regards, it is clear that the charges has been proved

against the incumbent and a penalty has been inflicted as enunciated above.

Hence in view of Rule 7.3(3) of CSR Vol. 1 Part 1, the incumbent shall be

entitled for pay and allowances, restricting the same to whatever has been paid

to him during the said suspension period from 22.01.2008 to 04.03.2008.

Further, the period of suspension from 22.01.2008 to 04.03.2008, shall

be treated as duty period for all other purposes in view of Rule 7.3(5) of CSR

Vol. 1 Part 1.

I order accordingly.

Regd.Rajan)

Sh. Ran Singh, Principal licretary, SchoolBlock Education Officer (Retd.), Education Department, Haryana,Tohana (Fatehabad) Chandigarh

P.T. 0

Page 4: Department of School Education Haryanaschooleducationharyana.gov.in/downloads_pdf/daily_orders/2012/T05... · Education Rules-2003 Education Department, Haryana hereby permit to add

Endst. No. Even Dated Panchkula the 2 - /

A copy is forwarded to the following for information and necessary action.

District Education Officer, Fatehabad.

Official concerned.

Assistant HRG-I (3)/ HRG-I (5) (Local).

Technology Officer (I.T. Cell).

liDeputy Director H G-I0/o Director General Second ry Education,

Haryana, Panchkula

Page 5: Department of School Education Haryanaschooleducationharyana.gov.in/downloads_pdf/daily_orders/2012/T05... · Education Rules-2003 Education Department, Haryana hereby permit to add

3 9-0 :1".t ce-q

S- -GOVERNMENT OF KARYANA AVM! Wag

Office ofDirector School Education

Nxio 1/1€11c1/1 ENiurrFrom Darkness load me to lighte-mail: edusecondary©hry.nic.in

ORDER NO.26/21-2012 PS121 Dated, Panchkula The 29-Nov-2012

The Managing Commitee of Lakshay Public School, Dhansu (Hisar) is hereby approved with the

following members :-

1 Rajesh Kumar President

2 Ramniwas Secretary

3 Monika Devi Joint Secretary

4 Rajender Singh Cashier

5 Subhash Chander HeadMastel/Ex-Officio Member

6 Manju Female Member

7 Neelam Female Member

8 Surajbhan Educationists/Teacher Represer

9 Nathu Ram Parents Representative

10 Sheela Devi Female Member

ENDST NO: EVEN

Read.A copy of the same is send to the following for information

District Education Officer, MuManager, Mamkori Memorial Education Society, VPO,

3. Headmaster, Lakshav Public School. Dhansu (Hisarlv‘. Technology Officer (I.T.)

ANURAG DHALIAJOINT DIRECTOR (ELEMENTARY)

O/o DIRECTOR ELEMENTARY EDUCATIONHARYANA,PANCHKULA

Dated, Panchkula the -tl

& necessary action :-

Dhansu, Teh. & Distt. Hisar.

fi—sUPERINTENDENT PSFOR DIRECTOR SECONDARY EDUCATION

HARYANA , PANCHKUIL=

Page 6: Department of School Education Haryanaschooleducationharyana.gov.in/downloads_pdf/daily_orders/2012/T05... · Education Rules-2003 Education Department, Haryana hereby permit to add

7.4. CP-I4

/2 2—_Direetarsts et School / Rmnm itt fitting

GOVERNMENT OF HARYANA / s qi u ir maw

Directorate School Education1441clei tar au* go irilitintbrw

Load too 'tom Datives. to Light

www.schooleducationharyana.gov.in edusecondaryhryegmail.com

School Code 2263/HSR/8th/BOSE/2012ORDER NO. 26/21-20I2PS(21

ORDER Dated,Panchkula The 29-Nov-2012

In exercise of the powers conferred upon me under rule 34 (1) of Haryana School

Education, Rules, 2003, sanction is hereby accorded to grant permanent recognition to

Lakshav Public School. Dhansu Miser' for class 1 to 8 under BOSE pattern with effect

from 01.04.2012 run by Managing Commitee Mamkori Memorial Education Society. VPO,

Dhansu, Teh. & Distt. Hisar. under following terms and conditions:-

TERMS & CONDITIONS:-1. This Recognition is granted that on the sub condition that the documents/information furnished by the school

BU al and not devoid of truth In any If any information at any stage, Is found contrary to the facts the

2. Thpplication for recognition and display thesession. In case of any change in the fee

xt academic year and will also issue printedlepts nds to e d .

Salary shall be paid as adoration at the time of seeking recognition.No capitation fee and • es that be charged from the children/parents.School a ed on refigion,caste, race, place of bitho any other whimsical.Managing at

.1 .4t aced by different board/council In the same komises.

Managing itt d existing class during the academic session without the prior approval of theaPProThe sch II open Ins the Ins officer authorized by the Director/Appropriate Authority.Recognition so granted shall be reviewed after every 10 years.No financial assistance shall be granted by the Department to the schOol.School premises shall not be used for commercial purppose and anti National activities.Approval of Managing Committee shall be obtained from the appropriate authority In case of any change in the committee.The Managing Committee shall follow the instructions Issued by Govemment/Dkector from time to time and supply the information to theGovt./Department as required.In addition to above the Managing Committee shall abide by the provisions of Haryana School Education Rules, 2003 and amendments ifany thereafter. The Managing Committee shall be liable for disciplinary action In case of violation of any provisions of the rules.School wNI provide ramp within six months othenviserecognition will stands withdrawn.If any Information, at any stage found Contrary to the Facts the recognition would be revoked forthwith.That the number of students In classroom shall not be more than the students calculated on the 10 square feet per student for secondaryand Senior Secondary Schools and 9 Square feet per student fo elementary state.The managing committee shall abide by the provisions of Haryana School Education Rules 2003(amended) & R.T.E. Rules 2011 andamnedments It any thereafter. The Managing shall be liable for diciplinary action In case of violation of any provision of the rules.

Endst. No. EvenRead. A copy is forwarded to the following information and necessary action:-

Deputy Commissioner HisarDistrict Education Officer,HisarSecretary, Haryana Board of School Education, Bhiwani.Manager Mamkori Memorial Education Society. VPO, Dhansu, Teh. & Melt. Hisar.

5. adMaster Lakshav Public School, Dhansu (Hisar)Technology Officer (I.T.)

Ott.: Plot No. 18, Shlkslu 8141111afratalz. 1it4

ANURAG DHALIAJOINT DIRECTOR(ELEMENTARY)

0/o DIRECTOR ELEMENTARY EDUCATIONHARYANA.PANCHKULA

Dated, Panchkula, the -10-1y2...n 1 2._

11)4,1.--S ERIN l'ENDENT (PS)

FOR DIRECTOR GENERAL SECONDARY EDUCATIONHARYANA, PANCHKULA,

70 1I0,114715!)24f A?g-101(0172)-2560253*..0ganAIV i0#2); 28420

3.

and shallto a appropriat uth

Page 7: Department of School Education Haryanaschooleducationharyana.gov.in/downloads_pdf/daily_orders/2012/T05... · Education Rules-2003 Education Department, Haryana hereby permit to add

3o)- rti7 — .7-011_1

OFFICE OF THE DIRECTOR GENERAL SECONDARY EDUCAITON,HARYANA PANCHKULA

Order No. 4/475-2012 HRL (2) Dated, Panchkula, the 28.11.12

Sanction is hereby accorded under Notification No.

15/136-2010 Co(1) dated 26 th April, 2011 to re-employment ofSh. Parkash Chand Ojha, Lecturer in English, Govt. Girls. Sr. Sec.School, Lohari Jattu (Bhiwani) who will be retired on 30.11.2012. Hehas been retained in same institution with effect from 01.12.2012 to31.03.2013 or till the vacancies are filled in by promotion or fresh

recruitment or from the date of actual joining whichever is later on thefollowing terms and conditions:-

There is no adverse remarks regarding integrity during lastthree years service and service record during last three years isgood or better than that.No charge sheet U/R 7 or 8 of Haryana Civil Services(Punishment & Appeal) Rules 1987 is pending against him/her.Medical fitness Certificate from the Government Medical Officer.No case involving moral turpitude is pending and no chargeshave been framed by the competent Court.

5. The salary will be paid as per provisions of CSR Vol-II i.e. lastpay drawn minus pension.

ARUN KUMAR GUPTADIRECTOR GENERAL SECONDARY EDUCATION,

HARYANA, PANCHKULA

Endst. No. Even Dated, Panchkula, the - 2_6 I

A copy is forwarded to the following for information and

necessary action:-

District Education Officer, Bhiwani.Principal, Govt. Girls. Sr. Sec. School, Lohari Jattu (Bhiwani).

\.)1793. fficial concerned.. Technology Officer (Local).

S4Ii-4t/LteiL 4141nte anentFor Director General Secondary Education,

Haryana, Panchkula

Page 8: Department of School Education Haryanaschooleducationharyana.gov.in/downloads_pdf/daily_orders/2012/T05... · Education Rules-2003 Education Department, Haryana hereby permit to add

f

ItTEnr, riTtfa U. 14 four,

,coaaa ar.I D, '

Lead me from ilarkocr

7&__41

ORDER NO.

GOVERNMENT OF HARYANA / Ms4dFd nt,bk

Directorate Elementary EducationTra-T. tur

www.schooleducationharyana.gov.in [email protected]/79-2012-11RC&V(4) DATED, PANCHKULA: 30/112012

The following official(s) is/are hereby transferred/adjusted with immediate effect.

Sr. No Transfer Id Name, Designation Present Place of Posting Transfer/Adjusted to Remarks I 51969 Sh. Pawan Kumar

Sanskrit C&VEmployee IM 081939

GSSS ICadaheri, Distt. GMS Raseen, Distt. Against vacancyKernel 117931 Kernel 119731

2 51970 Smt Predate Kaushik GSSS Tam, Distt Mewat GHS Atta Barota, Against vacancySanskrit C&V 18661 Distt Mewat 18081Employee ID: 001343

Note :-1 The official will be relieved Immediately and An— any case with in 3 days failing which he/she will be

liable for disciplinary aciton, HoweVero,„11. t Is working in Census duty, he/she shall not berelieved till the Census duty is aftiornp

2 No TA/DA and Joining time le to the official if he/she has been shifted on his/herrequest after exercising optkin,

3 No male teacher below tbaage of. „ allowed tojan in the girls schools.4 If there is no vacariCY ,,.jrl school

, for any reason the Incumbent transferred shall

re-join his/her previMIS place , arid also Inflinn 03 concerned branch/computer cell atHQ.If any discrepancy is noticed In this cyder or there ts a violation of transfer policy, It should bebrought to the notice Computer Cell/Concerned branch within three days and the order be notimplemented.

5 In case of mutual transfer, it is directed that before relieving/joining the officials concerned, itmay be ensured that the distance between both the schools is not less than 8 km.

6 In case of urban area stations while implementing the transfer orders, it may be ensured that thetransferee has completed the rural service' der trans*

7 The mutual transfer would be 'effective only when both the employees seeking mutual transfersubmit a consent document to their respective Principals.

DR. ABHE SINGH YADAVDIRECTOR ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

HARYANA, PANCHKULA

ENDST. NO. 25/79-2012-HRC&V(4) DATED, PANCHKULA,

A copy is forwarded to the following for information and necessary action

1 District Education Officer, Concerned.2 Head of the institution, Concerned. It is hereby directed to check consent of both the employees

those are transferred mutually, before their relieving / Joining.3 Official Concerned.4 Secy. OSD/CM5 Sr. PS/EM6 Sr. PS/PSSE

Technology officer (HQ) t't itr_ovosE

SUPERINTENDENT HRC&Vfor DIRECTOR ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

PANCHKULA

-

CMS P149 IF0 Et Fs

Page 9: Department of School Education Haryanaschooleducationharyana.gov.in/downloads_pdf/daily_orders/2012/T05... · Education Rules-2003 Education Department, Haryana hereby permit to add

'Tfrfirf

C,91,9m zn.d Devttiov,

1 n ,1 r,,

36 3 'T._

cm'lIhr rat !A

GOVERNMENT OF HARYANA / 6id II n

Directorate Elementary Educationtffr

www.schooleducationharyana.gov.in [email protected]

ORDER NO. 25/68-2012-HRC&V(4)

The following C&V Teacher is hereby transferred/adjusted with immediate effect.

DATED, PANCHKULA: 30/11/2012

Sr. No Transferld Name , Designation Present Place of Posting Transfer/Adjusted to Remarks

51968 Smt. Mukesh GGHS Rithal, GSSS Ladhot,Kumari Sanskrit (Rohtak) [27651 (Rohtak) 12814JC&VEmployee ID: 081797

Against vacancy

Note :-

1 The official will be relieved immediately and in any case with in 3 days failing which he/she will beliable for disciplinary aciton, However if any official is working in Census duty, he/she shall not berelieved till the Census duty is accomplished.

2 No TA/DA and joining time will be admissible to the offidal if he/she has been shifted on his/herrequest after exercising option.

3 No male teacher below the age of 50 years be allowed to join in the girls schools.4 If there is no vacancy in the destination school for any reason the incumbent transferred shall

re-join his/her previous place of posting and also inform to concerned branch/computer cell atHQ.If any discrepancy is noticed in this order or there is a violation of transfer policy, It should bebrought to the notice of Computer Cell/Concerned branch within three days and the order be notimplemented.

5 In case of mutual transfer, it is directed that before relieving/joining the officials concerned, itmay be ensured that the distance between both the schools is not less than 8 km.

6 In case of urban area stations while implementing the transfer orders, it may be ensured that thetransferee has completed the rural service as per transfer policy.

7 The mutual transfer would be effective only when both the employees seeking mutual transfersubmit a consent document to their respective Principals.

DR. ABHE SINGH YADAVDIRECTOR ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

HARYANA, PANCHKULA

ENDST. NO. 25/68-2012-HERC&V(4)

A copy is forwarded to the following for information and necessary action :-1 District Education Officer, Concerned.2 Head of the institution, Concerned. It is hereby directed to check consent of both the employees

those are transferred mutually, before their relieving / joining.3 Official Concerned.4 Secy. OSD/CM5 Sr. PS/E.M.6 Sr. PS/PSSE71_,BSIDSELi

Technology officer (HQ)

SUPERINTENDENT HRC&V

for DIRECTOR ELEMENTARY EDUCATIONHARYANA, PANCHKULA

Off.: Plot No.11E4 Stikollopttdort, W:1 Tol, :. 91.017Z)-45611.246 Fox: £11(0172)-2160?53999Ctoe OOIO A0172) 216024 1994 '91 (3172) 2560263

DATED PANCHKULA, 1.z ) 2

e

Page 10: Department of School Education Haryanaschooleducationharyana.gov.in/downloads_pdf/daily_orders/2012/T05... · Education Rules-2003 Education Department, Haryana hereby permit to add

2'9 T't C-e-qn••••-"--

9--01)___

DIRECTOR GENERAL SECONDARY EDUCATION, HARYANA,PANCHKULA.

ORDER No. 5/96-2010 HRG-I (1) Dated, Panchkula, the _ - 2_

Smt. Laxmi Dahiya, (Retd.) BEO, Ballabgarh (Faridabad) was charge sheeted

under Rule-8 of Punishment & Appeals rules, 1987 vide order No. 5/96-2010 HRG-I

(1) Dated, 17.07.2010, wherein following charges were leveled against her--

"/TF ft vpsla*ftrfOli fir Afar irwr CP Trror ;Ho 03.022009

voavro;Hogro acom41 9 N-dr fter afgetwa. arlea f0 firqr upwf3JErr aTitOrit, uovril414recommendation tR Girt TO lit OW 11N1 arIPT 11?)

11‘11 TIT'ff 1:14 tIV tiiiitAti *MI Wif$ *1 4fici arprizmicrw/umi Licp wi4* fkz t-Tt Vrt Tire W' at ratt91

She replied to the charge sheet vide representation dated 30.07.2010 and

denied at the charges leveled against her.

The delinquent officer has retired from service on 30.06.2011 but decision

regarding the charges leveled against her could not be taken till her retirement. Even if

at this stage he is held guilty for minor punishment, it can not be made effective

because for minor punishment either an increment of the delinquent can be stopped

or she may be warned for lapses, but both these punishments can not be imposed at

this stage, thus, there appears no justification to proceed further in this matter.

Moreover, there is no financial loss involved.

I have gone through the relevant record of the case and found that keeping in

view of the facts and circumstances of the case and taking into the consideration these

facts that also shows even no financial loss is involVed in this matter andSmt. Laxmi Dahiya has already retired from service on 30.06.2011. Therefore, I, pass

an order to drop the charge-sheet under rule-8 against Smt. Laxmi Dahiya, BEO

(Retd.), Ballabgarh (Faridabad).

I, order accordingly.

(ARUM KUMAR GUPTA)DIRECTOR GENERAL SECONDARY EDUCATION,

HARYANA, PANCHKULARegd. T._To

Smt. Laxmi Dahiya, BEO (Retd.),Ballabgarh (Faridabad).

Endst. No. Even Dated, Panchkula the e5-- /

A copy is forwarded to the following for information and necessary action:-

District Education Officer, Faridabad.

HRG-I(3) (Local).

Superintendent Pension Branch (Local).PS/DSE.

I.T. Cell.Deputy Director G-I

for Director General Seco Education,Haryana, Panc kula

Page 11: Department of School Education Haryanaschooleducationharyana.gov.in/downloads_pdf/daily_orders/2012/T05... · Education Rules-2003 Education Department, Haryana hereby permit to add

g ig-9 ciR-t(

OFFICE OF DIRECTOR ELEMENTARY EDUCATION, HARYANA, PANCHKULA

Order No. 15/97-2005- HRM-I (1) Dated, Panchkula

Sh. Satya Pal, Math Master, (025914) GHS Bhusly, (Karnal) is here by

granted the benefit of notionally pay fixation with effect from 05.03.1993 the

date from his juniors granted the benefit in seniority list of master cadre as on

01-01-06.

Ashwani KumarAdditional Director Educationfor Director Elementary Education

Haryana, Panchkula

Endst. No.Even Dated, Panchkula 4-/ 2A copy is forwarded to the following for information and

necessary action:

Distt. Elementary Education Officer Karnal.

Head Master, GHS Bhusly, (Karnal)

3. Official Concerned

Assistant Director (I.T)

Superintendent HRM-1For Director Elementary Education

aryana, Panchkula

Page 12: Department of School Education Haryanaschooleducationharyana.gov.in/downloads_pdf/daily_orders/2012/T05... · Education Rules-2003 Education Department, Haryana hereby permit to add

Si ItteLniggifILLfor Director Ge al, School Education,

Harya , Panchkula,),o I

OFFICE OF THE DIRECTOR GENERAL, SCHOOL EDUCATION, HARYANA,PANCHKULA

ORDER

No. 4/482-2012 HRL (5) Dated: Panchkula, the 03.12.2012

Sanction is hereby accorded under Notification No. 15/136-2010 Co (1) dated 26thApril, 2011 to re-employment of Smt. Santosh Kumari, Lecturer in Hindi, Govt. SeniorSecondary School, Chhara (Jhajjar) who will retire from service on attaining the age of60 years on 31.12.2012. She will be retained in same institution with immediate effectupto 31.3.2013 or till the new recruitment, whichever is earlier on the following termsand conditions:-

There is no adverse remark regarding integrity during last three years and servicerecord during last three years is good or better than that.No charge sheet under Rule 7 or 8 of the Haryana Civil Services (Punishment &Appeal) Rules, 1987 is pending against her.Medical fitness certificate from the Government Medical Officer.No case involving moral turpitude is pending and no charges have been framed bythe competent Court against her.

5. The salary will be paid as per provisions of CSR Vol-II i.e. last pay drawn minuspension.

ARUN KUMAR GUPTADIRECTOR GENERAL, SCHOOL EDUCATION,

HARYANA, PANCHKULA.

Endst. No. Even Dated, Panchkula, the 04.12.2012.

A copy is forwarded to the following for information and necessary action:-

District Education Officer, Jhajjar.Principal, Govt. Senior Secondary School, Chhara (Jhajjar).

3. Official concerned.t),--technology Officer (Local).

Page 13: Department of School Education Haryanaschooleducationharyana.gov.in/downloads_pdf/daily_orders/2012/T05... · Education Rules-2003 Education Department, Haryana hereby permit to add

Sis9 c-elk ,

HARYANA GOVERNMENTEDUCATION DEPARTMENT

ORDER

Sanction is accorded to the re-imbursement of Medical Charges amounting to

89312/- (Rs. Eighty Nine Thousand Three Hundred Twelve only) to Smt. Asha Rani,

Lecturer Political Science, Govt. Girls. Sr. Sec. School, Buwana (Jind) as noted

treatment of her mother in law at Delhi Heart & Lung Institute, New Delih on the advice

of authorized Medical Attendants:-

Sr.No.

Name ofClaimant

Amount RelationwithPatient

Period of Treatment

1. Smt. Asha Rani Z 89312/- Mother in 04/02/2012 to 11/02/2012Lecturer Political lawScience, Govt. Girls.Sr. Sec. School,Buwana (Jind)

(Rs Eighty Nine Thousand Three Hundred Twelve)The re-imbursement of Medical Charges has been sanctioned under thePunjab/Haryana Services (Medical Attendants) Rules, 1940.It has been certified by the authorized Medical Attendant that the Medicinesprescribed by them was absolutely essential for treatment and recovery of thePatient and that no cheaper substitute was possible.

3. The Head of Account to which the expenditure is debitable may be intimateddirect to the Accountant General (Accounts) Haryana, Chandigarh.

30/11/2012 ARUN KUMAR GUPTAPanchkula SPECIAL SECRETARY TO GOVT. HARYANA

SCHOOL EDUCATION DEPARTMENTPANCHKULA

OFFICE OF THE DIRECTOR GENERAL SECONDARY EDUCATION,HARYANA, PANCHKULA

ENDST. NO 12/163-12 HRL (1) DATED, PANCHKULA, THEA copy is forwarded to the following for information and necessary action:-

District Education Officer, Jind with ref. to his/her Memo No. A-1/2012/1530dated 23/10/20122. The original Medical Bill and vouchers are attachedherewith.The Accountant General (A&E) Haryana, Chandigarh.Principal, Govt. Girls. Sr. Sec. School, Buwana (Jind)Smt. Asha Rani Lecturer Political Science, Govt. Girls. Sr. Sec. School, Buwana(Jind)

5. Superintendent Budget Branch (Local).Technology Officer (IT Cell)

for DIRECTOR GENERAL SECONDARY EDUCATIONtr HARYANA, PANCHKULA

Page 14: Department of School Education Haryanaschooleducationharyana.gov.in/downloads_pdf/daily_orders/2012/T05... · Education Rules-2003 Education Department, Haryana hereby permit to add

SgS4t) c-cq/

OFFICE OF THE DIRECTOR GENERAL SECONDARY EDUCAITON,HARYANA PANCHKULA

Order No. 4/456-2012 HRL (2) Dated, Panchkula, the 02.12.12

Sanction is hereby accorded under Notification No.15/136-2010 Co(1) dated 26 th April, 2011 to re-employment ofSh. Kansi Ram, Lecturer in English, Govt. Sr. Sec. School, Gharaunda(Karnal) who will be retired on 30.11.2012. He has been retained insame institution with effect from 01.12.2012 to 31.03.2013 or till thevacancies are filled in by promotion or fresh recruitment or from the

date of actual joining whichever is later on the following terms andconditions:-

There is no adverse remarks regarding integrity during lastthree years service and service record during last three years isgood or better than that.No charge sheet U/R 7 or 8 of Haryana Civil Services(Punishment & Appeal) Rules 1987 is pending against him/her.Medical fitness Certificate from the Government Medical Officer.No case involving moral turpitude is pending and no chargeshave been framed by the competent Court.

5. The salary will be paid as per provisions of CSR Vol-II i.e. lastpay drawn minus pension.

ARUN KUMAR GUPTADIRECTOR GENERAL SECONDARY EDUCATION,

HARYANA, PANCHKULA

Endst. No. Even Dated, Panchkula, the 12- .1_6 / '1,/

A copy is forwarded to the following for information andnecessary action:-

District Education Officer, Karnal.Principal, Govt. Sr. Sec. School, Gharaunda (Karnal).

3.\..)7facial concerned.. Technology Officer (Local).

Su r n e ent4dFor Director General Secondary Education,

Haryana, Panchkula

Page 15: Department of School Education Haryanaschooleducationharyana.gov.in/downloads_pdf/daily_orders/2012/T05... · Education Rules-2003 Education Department, Haryana hereby permit to add

District Education Officer, Kurukshetra.Principal, DIET, Palwal (Kurukshetra).

3. Official concerned._Technology Officer (Local).

Su a ifiadeidifil4.,for Director General, School Education,

Haryall, , Paichkula,. rriA2. A

36$i 14- oe-l-f31 -1 )t--

OFFICE OF THE DIRECTOR GENERAL, SCHOOL EDUCATION, HARYANA,PANCHKULA

ORDER

No. 4/324-2012 HRL (5) Dated, Panchkula, the 30.11.2012

Sanction is hereby accorded under Notification No. 15/136-2010 Co (1) dated 26thApril, 2011 to re-employment of Shri Jai Gopal, Lecturer in Hindi, DIET, Palwal(Kurukshetra) who has retired from service on attaining the age of superannuation on30.11.2012. He will be retained in same institution with immediate effect upto31.3.2013 or till the new recruitment, whichever is earlier on the following terms andconditions:-

There is no adverse remark regarding integrity during last three years and servicerecord during last three years is good or better than that. •No charge sheet under Rule 7 or 8 of the Haryana Civil Services (Punishment &Appeal) Rules, 1987 is pending against him.Medical fitness certificate from the Government Medical Officer.No case involving moral turpitude is pending and no charges have been framed bythe competent Court against him

5. The salary will be paid . as per provisions of CSR Vol-II i.e. last pay drawn minuspension.

ARUN KUMAR GUPTADIRECTOR GENERAL, SCHOOL EDUCATION,

HARYANA, PANCHKULA.

Endst. No. Even Dated, Panchkula, the 03.12.2012

A copy is forwarded to the following for information and necessary action:-

Page 16: Department of School Education Haryanaschooleducationharyana.gov.in/downloads_pdf/daily_orders/2012/T05... · Education Rules-2003 Education Department, Haryana hereby permit to add

c,eq----- S-//r->-a1 2_

OFFICE OF THE DIRECTOR GENERAL SECONDARY EDUCATION, HARYANA,PANCHKULA

Order No. 3/20-99 Admn. (1) Dated, Panchkula, the 30.11.2012

Consequent upon the posting of Sh. Sanjeev Gulia, Assistant as Section Officer on stop

gap arrangement in the Office of Director General Higher Education, Haryana, Panchkula issued

vide order No. 13665-TA-HR(4T)2012 dated 27.11.2012 by the Director Treasuries & Accounts

Department, Haryana, Chandigarh. He is hereby relieved from his duties today i.e. 03.12.2012

(A.N) to join his new place of posting.

ARUN KUMAR GUPTADIRECTOR GENERAL SECONDARY EDUCATION,

HARYANA, PANCHKULA

Endst. No. Even Dated, Panchkula, the 1,11

A copy is forwarded to the following for information and necessary action:-

The Director Treasuries & Accounts Department, Haryana, Chandigarh with

reference to their order No. 13665-TA-HR(4T)2012 dated 27.11.2012.

Sh. Sanjeev Gulia, Assistant. He is directed to submit his joining report at his

new place of posting immediately.

Director General Higher Education, Haryana, Panchkula.

Director Elementary Education, Haryana, Panchkula.

PS/DSE.

PA/Additional Director Administration.

7. Superintendent Accounts Branch (Local).

tA".-- Technology Officer, IT Cell.

et,Superintendent Admn.

for Director General Secondary Education,aryana, Panchkula

Page 17: Department of School Education Haryanaschooleducationharyana.gov.in/downloads_pdf/daily_orders/2012/T05... · Education Rules-2003 Education Department, Haryana hereby permit to add

2682 c-024

s t--

HARYANA GOVERNMENTSCHOOL EDUCATION DEPARTMENT

ORDER

In terms of Haryana Govt. Letter No. 1/2(27) 30-5-FRI dated 1-8-1980

Sh. Chatar Bhuj Sharma, Lecturer in Political Science, Govt. Sr. Sec. School, Birhi

Kalan (Bhiwani) who has tendered the notice of voluntary retirement from the Govt.

service after putting more than 20 years qualifying service is hereby allowed to retire

voluntarily from Govt. Service with effect from 05.11.2012.

SURINA RAJANChandigarh

PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO GOVT. HARYANADated: 21/11/2012

SCHOOL EDUCATION DEPARTMENT,CHANDIGARH

OFFICE OF THE DIRECTOR GENERAL SECONDARY EDUCATION, HARYANA,PANCHKULA

Endst. No. 3/52-12 HRL (1) Dated, Panchkula, the 2—

A copy is forwarded to the following for information and necessary action:-

Regd.District Education Officer, Bhiwani with ref. to his Memo No. E-1-12/2217-18

dated 22.10.2012. The Service Book of the official is returned herewith.

Principal, Govt. Sr. Sec. School, Birhi Kalan (Bhiwani).

Sh. Chatar Bhuj Sharma, Lecturer in Political Science, Govt. Sr. Sec. School,

Birhi Kalan (Bhiwani).

Accountant General (A&E), Haryana, Chandigarh

5. Superintendent Pension Branch (Local).

Technology Officer, I.T. Cell (Local).

zDEPUTY DIRECT LECTURERS

for DIRECTOR GENERAL SE ONDARY EDUCATION,GS–HARYANA, PANCHKULA

Page 18: Department of School Education Haryanaschooleducationharyana.gov.in/downloads_pdf/daily_orders/2012/T05... · Education Rules-2003 Education Department, Haryana hereby permit to add

g cjp_fDirectorate ni School PAucation / MUM koolb

%Vt. !tottPt tot Poem14111440N Colosto ood Orr

GOVERNMENT OF HARYANA / ftz[17ff kcf)K

Directorate School Educationfir 5`fur Leactme from Darkness to Light

www.schooleducationharyana.gov.in I edusecondaryhryegmail.com

HARYANA GOVERNMENTEDUCATION DEPARTMENT

CHANDIGARHORDER NO. 2/250-2012-HRL(5)

DATED, PANCHKULA: 30/11/2012

Transfer Id 51971

In partial modification of this office order no. 2/250-2012-HRL(5) dated 17/07/2012 Sh.

Satya Narain [0794971 Lecturer in Hindi who was transferred from GSSS Sadalpur Distt. Hisar

114721 to GSSS Dhiranwas Distt. Hisar [1438] is hereby adjusted in GSSS Dhani Peeran Wali,

Distt. Hisar [1407] Against vacancy provided that he has not joined his previous place of posting.

Note :-

1

The official will be relieved immediately and in any case with in 7 days failing which he/she will beliable for disciplinary action.

2 No TA/DA and joining time will be admissible to the official if he/she has been shifted on his/herrequest after exercising option.

3 No male teacher below the age of 50 years be allowed to join in the girls schools.4 If there is no vacancy in the destination school for any reason the incumbent transferred shall

re-join his/her previous of posting and also inform to concerned branch/computer cell at HQ.If any discrepancy is noticed in this order or there is a violation of transfer policy, It should bebrought to the notice of Computer Cell/Concerned branch within three days and the order be notimplemented.

5 In case of urban area stations while implementing the transfer orders, It may be ensured that the

transferee has completed the rural service as per transfer policy.6 Head of the Institution may obtain the consent/affidevit of the official that he/she Is willing to

loose his/her seniority In case of requested transfer orders.

ARUN KUMAR GUPTASPECIAL SECRETARY cum DIRECTOR GENERAL

SECONDARY EDUCATIONHARYANA, PANCHKULA

OFFICE OF DIRECTOR SECONDARY EDUCATION,HARYANA, PANCHKULA

ENDST. NO. EVEN DATED PANCHKULA,

A copy is forwarded to the following for information and necessary action :-1 District Education Officer, Concerned.2 Head of the institution, Concerned. It is hereby directed to check consent of both the employees

those are transferred mutually, before their relieving / joining.3 Official Concerned.4 Secy. OSD/CM5 Sr. PS/E.M.6 Sr. PS/PSSE7 PS/D

echnology officer (HQ)

RI TEND HRLtidrfor DIRECTOR GENERAL SECONDARY EDUCATION

HARYA PANCHKULA9A)1:1r

Off.: Plot No..18, StIlk,h04,14P1, ,,,,PARt., -Fa14:91101721-2560253.

Page 19: Department of School Education Haryanaschooleducationharyana.gov.in/downloads_pdf/daily_orders/2012/T05... · Education Rules-2003 Education Department, Haryana hereby permit to add

36e 5- rc ceAl

Directorate of School Education / ffiMPRIflR9f Pitragl

GOVERNMENT OF HARYANA /half *Hot(

Directorate School Educationsittila4Rii NTIMI

r3raiT, tic-ctRr gat ItraFrftEducation, Culture and Development

rrInt wir =RhRratrrnLead me from Darkness to Light

Off.: Plot No. 1B, Shiksha Sadan, Sector 5, Panchkula, Haryana 134109 (India) - Tel: 91(0172)-2560246 Fax: 91(0172)-2560253reltitelr0 4c g 70 it, RR% IT41, it4L7 5 tiA7FAT-134109 OM) Vil ff : 91 (0172) 2560246 4471: 91 (0172) 2560253

e-mail: eduseconclaryhry®gmail.com - site: www.schooleducationharyasa.gov.in

Order No. 15/54-20112 HRM-I (5) Dated, Panchkula The 03.12.2012

In continuation of this office order No. 15/54-20112 HRM-I (5) dated 17.08.2012

the deputation period of [028442] Smt. Surekha Social Studies Mistress, GSSS Ramgarha

(Panchkula) [3707] to GHS Ghaggar Bir, (Panchkula) [5800] is hereby extended for a

period of four months.

Other terms and conditions of deputation will remain the same.

ABHEY SINGH YADAVDIRECTOR ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

HARYANA PANCHKULA

Endst No. Even Dated Panchkula, the 5 , )2_, / 2—

A copy is forwarded to the following for information and necessary action:-.

• 1. District Elementary Education Officers concerned.Head of Institution concerned. It is directed that the official may be relievedafter expiry of the deputation period.Official Concerned. It is directed that she will join his/her previous place ofposting immediately after the expiry of deputation period of and she will betreated absent from duty in case of non-joining her previous place of posting.

4 echonology Officer.

SUPRINTE ENT HRM-Ifor DIRECTOR ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

HARYANA PANCHKULAQC

Office: Plot No. 1B, Shiksha Sedan, Sector 5, Panchkula, Haryana 134109 (India) - Tel: 91(0172)-2550246 Fax: 91(0172)-2560253.‘0 ItZ01 210•‘1, tefU 5 KttlIi.1-134109 ($1Ti5) Viltf 91 (0172) 256024Tto4u 91 (0172) 2580253 1

Page 20: Department of School Education Haryanaschooleducationharyana.gov.in/downloads_pdf/daily_orders/2012/T05... · Education Rules-2003 Education Department, Haryana hereby permit to add

26W-6

OFFICE OF THE DIRECTOR ELEMENTARY EDUCATION HARYANAPANCHKULA

Order No. 12/71-2012 HRM-II(3) Dated, Panchkula the 3.12.2012

The following guest faculty Master/ Mistress are hereby adjusted

against their names under rule work load and on demand:-

DR. ABHE SINGH YADAV0/o DIRECTOR ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

HARYANA PANCHKULA.

Endst. No. Even Dated, Panchkula theA copy is forwarded to the following for information and necessary

action:-

1.

District Elementary Education Officer, Rewari and Gurgaon.

tV2-. Technology Officer (I.T. Cell).

Superintendes101AVH----for Director Elementary Education, Haryana

Panchkula.

cia/11-

Page 21: Department of School Education Haryanaschooleducationharyana.gov.in/downloads_pdf/daily_orders/2012/T05... · Education Rules-2003 Education Department, Haryana hereby permit to add

OFFICE OF THE DIRECTOR GENERAL SECONDARY EDUCATION,HARYANA PANCHKULA

Order No. 4/478-2012 HRL (1) Dated, Panchkula, the 30.11.2012

Sanction is hereby accorded under Notification No.

15/136-2010 Co (1) dated 26 th April, 2011 to re-employment of

Smt. Nirmala Bai, Lecturer in Political Science, Govt. Sr. Sec. School,Kamania (Mahendergarh) who has been retired on 30.11.2012. Shewill retain in same institution with effect from 01.12.2012 to31.03.2013 or till the vacancies are filled in by promotion or freshrecruitment or from the date of actual joining whichever is later on the

following terms and conditions:-

There is no adverse remarks regarding integrity during lastthree years service and service record during last three years isgood or better than that.No charge sheet U/R 7 or 8 of Haryana Civil Services(Punishment & Appeal) Rules 1987 is pending against him/her.Medical fitness Certificate from the Government Medical Officer.No case involving moral turpitude is pending and no chargeshave been framed by the competent Court.

5. The salary will be paid as per provisions of CSR Vol-II i.e. lastpay drawn minus pension.

ARUN KUMAR GUPTADIRECTOR GENERAL SECONDARY EDUCATION,

HARYANA, PANCHKULA

Endst. No. Even Dated, Panchkula, the — 1) h 2-A copy is forwarded to the following for information and

necessary action:-

District Education Officer, Narnaul.Principal, Govt. Sr. Sec. School, Kamania (Mahendergarh).

3. Official concerned.Technology Officer (Local).

S RIN END44' RLFOR DIRECTOR GENERAL SECONDARY EDUCATION,

PANCHKULA

Page 22: Department of School Education Haryanaschooleducationharyana.gov.in/downloads_pdf/daily_orders/2012/T05... · Education Rules-2003 Education Department, Haryana hereby permit to add

3618 rt et/

OFFICE OF THE DIRECTOR GENERAL SECONDARY EDUCAITON,HARYANA PANCHKULA

Order No. 4/486-2012 HRL (1) Dated, Panchkula, the 30.11.12

Sanction is hereby accorded under Notification No.

15/136-2010 Co(1) dated 26 th April, 2011 to re-employment of

Sh. Udeyvir Singh Yadav, Lecturer in Math, Govt. Sr. Sec. School,Jhajpul (Hisar) who will be retired on 30.11.2012. He has beenretained in same institution with effect from 01.12.2012 to 31.03.2013

or till the vacancies are filled in by promotion or fresh recruitment orfrom the date of actual joining whichever is later on the following

terms and conditions:-

There is no adverse remarks regarding integrity during lastthree years service and service record during last three years isgood or better than that.No charge sheet U/R 7 or 8 of Haryana Civil Services(Punishment & Appeal) Rules 1987 is pending against him/her.Medical fitness Certificate from the Government Medical Officer.No case involving moral turpitude is pending and no chargeshave been framed by the competent Court.

5. The salary will be paid as per provisions of CSR Vol-II i.e. lastpay drawn minus pension.

ARUN KUMAR GUPTADIRECTOR GENERAL SECONDARY EDUCATION,

HARYANA, PANCHKULA

Endst. No. Even Dated, Panchkula, the -

A copy is forwarded to the following for information and

necessary action:-

District Education Officer, Hisar.Principal, Govt. Sr. Sec. School, Jhajpul (Hisar).Official concerned.Technology Officer (Local).

For Directo General Secondary Education,(NY Haryana, Panchkula

Page 23: Department of School Education Haryanaschooleducationharyana.gov.in/downloads_pdf/daily_orders/2012/T05... · Education Rules-2003 Education Department, Haryana hereby permit to add

34' lo cc tf_S-

OFFICE OF DIRECTOR ELEMENTARY EDUCATION HARYANA, PANCHKULA

Order No.: 17/70-2012 HRM-1 (5) Dated, Panchkula, the S o ` ' 2- 6 1-2--

Whereas Sh. Madan Mohan and others filed a Civil Writ Petition No. 3918 of 2012

before Hon'ble High Court praying for grant of higher responsibility on promotion to the post of

Master from the post of JBT and C&V Teacher. The petitioners approached Hon'ble High Court

to issue a writ of mandamus directing the respondents to grant them an additional increment for

discharging the duties and functions of higher responsibilities under Rule 4.4 (a) of the Punjab

Civil Service Rules, Vol.-1 part-1. The writ petition came for hearing before Hon'ble High Court

on 01.03.2010 and Hon'ble Court pleased to pass the following order:

"According to the petitioners, this Court had earlier adjudicated this matter and

allowed the writ petition i.e. CWP No.17301 of 2000 titled as Swaran Singh vs. State of

Haryana, vide its judgment dated 21.02.2002 (Annexure P-2), against which respondent-State

preferred Special Leave Petition before the Supreme Court i.e. Special Leave to Appeal (Civil)

No. 15182 of 2003, which was dismissed by the Supreme Court vide order dated 19.03.2010

(Annexure P-3). On this basis, the petitioners have claimed the relief in the present writ

petition. For this, the petitioners have served a legal notice dated 16.08.2011 (Annexure P-5)

but till date, no decision thereon has been conveyed to the petitioners. Counsel for the

petitioners contends that the petitioners, at this stage, would be satisfied if a direction is issuea

to the Commissioner and Director General, School Education, Haryana-respondent No. 2 to

consider the same within some specified time and pass a speaking order thereon.

Without going into the merits of the case or commenting thereon, the present petition is

disposed of with a direction to the Commissioner and Director General, School Education,

Haryana respondent No. 2 to consider the legal notice dated 16.08.2011(Annexure P-5) served

by the petitioners on him and take a decision thereon within a period of three months from the

date of receipt of a certified copy of this order. In case, the petitioners are held entitled to the

claim made by them, the consequential benefits be released to them within a further period of

two months."

Page 24: Department of School Education Haryanaschooleducationharyana.gov.in/downloads_pdf/daily_orders/2012/T05... · Education Rules-2003 Education Department, Haryana hereby permit to add

That in compliance of the above said directions of Hon'ble High Court, the records of the

petitioners has been sorted out. It has found the name of the petitioners with their service details

are given below as under:-

Petitioner No.

Name of thePetitioners

Date of joiningas JBT withBask Pay

Date ofpromotionas HT/ACP withbasic pay

Date ofpromotion asMaster withBasic Pay

Remarks if any

MadanMohan, GMSGairatpurBass, BlockSohna DistrictGurgaon

27-11-1997Scale 4500-7000 (PB-2 &GP 4200)

l'' ACPawardedw.e.f.1.12.2007Scale PB-2& GP 4600

18-01-2008,Math MasterSeale PB-2 &GP 4600

Petitioner hasalready availedhigher pay scale inthe form of 1 s` ACP

F.D. Instructionsdated 09.04.2010applicable

Manoj Kumar,SS Master

01-02-1999Scale 4500-7000 (PB-2 &GP 4200)

1' ACPawardedw.e.f.01.02.2009Scale PB-2& GP 4600

06-12-2010SS MasterScale PB-2 &GP 4600

.

-do-

RajinderSingh, SSMaster, GMSMirjapur,Block Patodi,DistrictGurgaon

04-02-1999Scale 4500-7000 (PB-2 &GP 4200)

1st ACPawardedw.e.f.01.03.2009Scale PB-2& GP 4600

17-01-2011SS MasterScale PB-2 &GP 4600

-do-

Surender Lal,SS Master,GSSSManesarDistrictGurgaon

01-02-1999Scale 4500-7000 (PB-2 &GP 4200)

1st ACPawardedw.e.f.01.02.2009Scale PB-2& GP 4600

01-07-2011SS MasterScale PB-2 &GP 4600

-d -

Ashok Kumar,SS Master,GHS Balewa,Block Patodi,DistrictGurgaon

21-11-1995Scale 4500-7000 (PB-2 &GP 4200)

lst ACPawardedw.e.f.01.12.2005Scale PB-2& GP 4600

03-07-2009SS MasterScale PB-2 &GP 4600

-do-

Pawan Kumar,SS Master,GHS PattiStation BlockFaruq Nagar,DistrictGurgaon

08-03-1999Scale 4500-7000 (PB-2 &GP 4200)

1st ACPawardedw.e.f.01.04.2009Scale PB-2& GP 4600

06-12-2010SS MasterScale PB-2 &GP 4600

-do-

7. Vinod Kumar,SS Master,GHS PattiStation, BlockFaruq Nagar,DistrictGurgaon

27-11-1995Scale 4500-7000 (PB-2 &GP 4200)

HT11.02.2004

Pay Scale5500-9000

06-10-2010SS Master,respectively,Scale 5500-9000 (PB-2 &GP-4600)

Already gotadditional benefit atthe time ofpromotion as H.T.Moreover the newpromotion has beengranted on the basisof JBT seniority,

_,

W:5'.444014014101ftwav

Page 25: Department of School Education Haryanaschooleducationharyana.gov.in/downloads_pdf/daily_orders/2012/T05... · Education Rules-2003 Education Department, Haryana hereby permit to add

Manoj Kumar,SS Master,

09-03-1999Scale 4500-7000 (PB-2 &GP 4200)

1St ACPawardedw.e.f.01.04.2009Scale PB-2& GP 4600

07-12-2010SS MasterScale PB-2 &GP 4600

-

Petitioner hasalready availedhigher pay scale inthe form of I' ACP

F.D. Instructionsdated 09.04.2010applicable

Sunita, SS 12-03-1997 1S' ACP 26-10-2010 -do-Mistress, Scale 4500- awarded S. S. MistressGGMS Patli, 7000 (PB-2 & w.e.f. Scale PB-2 &Block Farukh GP 4200) 01.04.2007 GP 4600Nagar, District Scale PB-2Gurgaon & GP 4600

10. Maha Nand, 01-12-1997 1s` ACP 27-06-2008 as Petitioner hasSS Master, Scale 4500- awarded HT, 20-12- already availedGSSS 7000 (PB-2 & w.e.f. 2010 as SS higher pay scale inBudhera,District

GP 4200) 01.12.2007Scale PB-2

Master ScalePB-2 & GP

the form of 1 S`Moreover, the

Gurgaon. & GP 4600 4600 promotion to SSMaster has beengranted on the basisof seniority on thepost of JBT.

1 1 . Satish Kumar, 05-03-1999 HT 15-06-2007 as Petitioner hasMath Master, Scale 4500- 15.06.2007 HT, 24-01- availed higher payGHS Nanu 7000 (PB-2 & PB-2 & GP 2008 as Math scale in the form ofKalan, BlockPataudi,DistrictGurgaon

GP 4200) 4600 Master ScalePB-2 & GP4600

HT. Moreover, thepromotion to SSMaster has beengranted on the basisof seniority on thepost of JBT.

Shallu Devi, 28-11-1997 lst ACP 18-01-2008 as Petitioner hasSS Mistress, Scale 4500- awarded Math Master already availedGGHS 7000 (PB-2 & w.e.f. Scale PB-2 & higher pay scale inWazirabad,Block &

GP 4200) 01.12.2007Scale PB-2

GP 4600 . the form of 1° ACP.

DistrictGurgaon

& GP 4600 F.D. instructionsdated 09.04.2010applicable

Mantosh 05-02-1999 1st ACP 30-06-2010 as -do-Kumar, SS Scale 4500- awarded SS MasterMaster, GMS 7000 (PB-2 & w.e.f. Scale PB-2 &Judola, Block GP 4200) 01.03.2009 GP 4600Faruq Nagar,District

Scale PB-2& GP 4600

Gurgaon

Jai Parkash, 26-11-1997 HT 01-11-2010 Petitioner hasMaster, GMSMirchehri

Scale 4500-7000 (PB-2 &

0509-05-2005

+9340600-0 G348P00 availed higher payscale in the form of

Block Babain,District

GP 4200) 5500-9000 HT. Moreover, thepromotion to SS

Kurukshetra Master has beengranted on the basisof seniority on thepost of JBT.

Kaushalaya 27-11-1997 HT 21-10-2010 -do-Devi, SS Scale 4500- 9300-34800Master, GSSS 7000 (PB-2 & 05-02-2004 +4600 GPDudhla- or

Page 26: Department of School Education Haryanaschooleducationharyana.gov.in/downloads_pdf/daily_orders/2012/T05... · Education Rules-2003 Education Department, Haryana hereby permit to add

Morthla,DistrictKurukshetra

GP 4200) 5500-9000

KulvinderSingh, SS

16.03.1999Scale 4500-

1st ACPawarded

07.12.2010 SSMaster

Petitioner hasalready availed

Master, GMS 7000 PB-2 & w.e.f. higher pay scale inImligarh GP-4200 01.04.2009 9300-34800 the form of 1 s` ACP.(Rohtak)

PB-2 & GP-+4600 GP Moreover, the

promotion to SS4600 under1 st ACP

Master has beengranted on the basisof seniority on thepost of JBT

Dalbir Singh,Hindi TeacherS/o Panna Lal,GHS Meoli,Block Pundri

As JBT18.10.1995

Scale 4500-7000

2nd .ACPAwardedw.e.f. 01-01-2012 GP4800 Under

HT 5500/900031-12-2001

Hindi Techer

Higher Pay Scaleawarded w.e.f.01-01-2012 in theform of 2nd ACP.

District rule 13 to 24.01.2008 F.D. InstructionsKaithal the post

JBT in pay5500-9000

dated 09.04.2010applicable

9300/34800and on thebasis ofstagnation inpay scale ofPB-2, GP4600

Lakhvinder As JBT 1st ACP Promotion as Petitioner hasSingh, Hindi 23.11.95 Awarded as Hindi Teacher availed higher payTeacher S/o a JBT w.e.f. 25-01-2008 in scale in the form ofBalwantSingh, GHS

4500-7000 01-12-2005 scale5500/9000

HT. Moreover, thepromotion to SS

Pharal, BlockPundri,DistrictKaithal

-Master has beengranted on the basisof seniority on thepost of JBT.

Baini Ram. As JBT l't ACP Promotion as -do-Hindi TeacherS/o Ram

14.01.1994 Awarded asa JBT w.e.f.

Hindi Teacher15-02-2007 in

Chander, GHS 4500-7000 01-02-2004 scaleKawartan,block Siwan,District

5450-80005500/9000

Kaithal

Ram Kumar,SS Master S/o

As JBT21.08.1998

1st ACPAwarded

Promotion asS.S Master

Petitioner hasalready availed

LachhmanDass, GHSChuhar MajraBlockDistrictPundri,

4500-700001.09.2008

9300-34800

GP 4600

01.07.2010

9300-34800

higher pay scale inthe form of 1 st ACP.Moreover, thepromotion to SS

Kaithal Master has beengranted on the basisof seniority on thepost of JBT.

Raj inder As JBT w.e.f. 1 51 ACP Promotion as -do-Parshad, SSMaster GHS

29.01.1999,4500-7000

grantedw•e.f.

S.S Master08.12.2010

Dariyapur 01.02.2009(Bhiwani) 9300-34800

PB-2 +GP <r

4

Page 27: Department of School Education Haryanaschooleducationharyana.gov.in/downloads_pdf/daily_orders/2012/T05... · Education Rules-2003 Education Department, Haryana hereby permit to add

4600 1

SatyawanSingh, SSMaster, GHSSinghdaragho,Block Hansi-Hisar

As JBT w.e.f.17.11.1995,4500-7000

l st ACPgrantedw•e.f.01.12.2005

PB-2 +GP5450-8000

Revised Payfixed in PB-2 & GP-4600 w.e.f.01.01.2006

Promotion asS.S Master11.07.2006

9300-34800

-do-

Ram NiwasS.S Master,GSSS Kosli,Block Nahar,DistrictRewari

As JBT w.e.f.10.03.1999,4500-7000

.

13.06.2007HT PayScale 5500-9000

Promotion asS.S Master 24-12-2010

Petitioner hasavailed higher payscale in the form ofHT. Moreover, thepromotion to SSMaster has beengranted on the basisof seniority on thepost of JBT.

Dalip SinghS.S. Master,GSSS SukhChain, DistrictSirsa.

As JBT w.e.f.18.01.1994,4500-7000

..

l' ACPawardedw•e.f.01.02.2004,5450-8000Revised Payfixed in PB-2 & GP-4600 w.e.f01.01.2006

Promotion asS.S Master 02-02-2008

Petitioner hasalready availedhigher pay scale inthe form of l' ACP.Moreover, thepromotion to SSMaster has beengranted on the basisof seniority on thepost of JBT.

Pawan KumarS.S Master,GHSAlakpura,BlockBhiwaniKhera, DistrictBhiwani

As JBT w.e.f.29.01.1999,4500-7000..

1 31 ACPgrantedw•e.f.01.02.2009

PB-2 & GP-4600

Promotion asS.S Master 12-05-2011

-do-

The similar matter of additional increment of higher responsibilities came before Hon' b le

Supreme Court of India in Civil appeal No. 6992 of 2004, titled State of Haryana & others versus

Partap Singh & others. Thg judgment dated 22/09/2006 as pronounced by Hon'ble Supreme

Court of India in this Civil Appeal is, hereby, reproduced as under-.

"In all these cases, the basic question involved is whether the respondents herein are

entitled to the benefit of Rule 4.4 of the Punjab Civil Services Rules (hereinafter to be referred

to as the "Rules"), Volume-I, Part-I or not?

For convenient disposal of these cases, the brief facts given in C.A. No. 6305 of 2004

State of Haryana & Anr. v. Tarlochan Lal & Ors. are taken into consideration. The writ

petitioners were appointed as J.B.T. teachers in the Haryana Education Department. They

acquired higher qualifications of B.A3 Inter B.Ed, during the course of their service. A

Page 28: Department of School Education Haryanaschooleducationharyana.gov.in/downloads_pdf/daily_orders/2012/T05... · Education Rules-2003 Education Department, Haryana hereby permit to add

6

notification was issued on 23.7.1957 to the effect that the teachers who have acquired higher

qualiftcations shall be granted higher grade. The writ petitioners who acquired higher

qualifications were given the grade of Social Study Master and subsequently when they were

promoted as Social Study 1Waiter they were granted one increment on account of discharge of

higher responsibility from the date of promotion as Social Study Master and their initial pay in

the promotional grade was fixed under Rule 4.4. Subsequently, the State Government decided

that grant of increment on account of discharge of higher qualifications could not be granted

to the Social Study Masters, the Drawing and Disbursing Officers withdrew the said

increments. The claim of the writ petitioners was that since the increment had been granted

because they were discharging higher responsibility while teaching higher classes in schools,

therefore, under Rule 4.4 of the Rules they were entitled to the said increment and it cannot be

withdrawn.

The matter was contested by the State appellants before the High Court and a plea was

taken that it is immaterial whether the writ petitioners teach in Class VI or Class X , that does

not make any difference, it does not involve discharging of higher responsibility and they were

not promoted on administrative posts. It was also pointed out that they had already been

granted higher pay scale on acquiring higher qualification and therefore, they are not entitled

to one additional increment or pay fixation under Rule 4.4 of the Rules. It was not disputed

that before promotion which was subsequently granted to the writ petitioners, they were

teaching Class I to Class V and on their acquiring higher qualification, they were givers the

grade of Masters and they were asked to teach the students of Class VI to Class X. The

contention of the writ petitioners before the High Court was that since they were discharging

the duties of higher responsibility i.e. for teaching the students of Class VI to Class X,

therefore, they were entitled to one additional increment and fixation of pay under Rule 4.4.

It may be relevant to mention here that the circular dated 23.7.1957 was subsequently

modified by the State of Haryana vide Notification dated 9.3.1990 and thereby it was clarified

in para 6 of the said circular that the benefit which was given in terms of para 2 of 'the

Punjab Government letter dated 23.7.1957 or any subsequent letters/ notifications issued by

the State Government, the mastersAeachers in the Education Department will be placed in the

scales of pay of their respective categories to which they are appointed against the sanctioned

posts and mere possession/acquiring of higher qualifications will not entitle them

automatically to claim higher pay scales, meaning thereby that after issuance of this

notification, acquisition of higher qualification would not entitle the benefit of higher pay

scale i.e. Masters' pay scale. In these writ petitions which were filed in 1998 before the High

Court, perhaps this circular of the State Government dated 9.3.1990 was not brought to the

notice of the Court. Be that as it may, in view of the changed policy of the State of Haryana,

the JBT teachers who acquired higher qualifications were not entitled to the higher pay scale

of Masters. The State Government did not take any steps in pursuance to this circular.

Therefore, by virtue of the earlier circular dated 23.7.1957 those teachers continued in the

higher pay scale of masters. Subsequently they were promoted to the post of Masters, they

again sought the benefit of one more increment by filing writ petitions. But it was not brought

to the notice of the Court that their continuation in the pay scale of Masters was against the

Page 29: Department of School Education Haryanaschooleducationharyana.gov.in/downloads_pdf/daily_orders/2012/T05... · Education Rules-2003 Education Department, Haryana hereby permit to add

policy but they were allowed to continue in the Masters' pay scale and when the regular

promotion to the post of Master was made, they claimed re-fixation of pay scale as per Rule

4.4 of the Rules and that too was allowed by the High Court de hors the fact that the earlier

circular dated 23.7.1957 has since been clarified by the State Government in the subsequent

circular dated 9.3.1990. It was also pointed out by the State Government by filing an affidavit

by Shri Dayal Singh Sangwan, Budget Officer (Schools) before this Court that though these

writ petitioners were granted pay scale of Masters while working on a lower post of JBT

teachers, on acquiring higher qualification of B.A., B.Ed. in terms of the aforesaid circular

dated 23.7.1957 but they were not appointed or promoted to the post of Masters. They were of

course drawing the pay scale of Masters but no regular promotion was given to them. Now

regular promotion having been given, they cannot claim fixation of pay in terms of Rule 4.4 of

the Rules because they are already in the same pay scale of Masters. It was also pointed out

that this will result in heart burning amongst the direct recruits who have been working as

Masters for longer period but would be getting lesser pay than those like the respondents if the

impugned judgment is upheld. It was also pointed out that the respondents were already

getting the functional pay scale of the promotion post of Masters while working in the cadre of

JBT teachers and the pay was also fixed in the higher pay scale and thus on their actual

promotion to the post of Masters they are not entitled to re-fix their pay by granting one

additional increment. Since the respondents were already getting the functional pay scale of

the promotional post from the date of acquiring the qualifications of the promotional post of

Masters, therefore, there is no question of granting the benefit of Rule 4.4 of the Rules to the

respondents.

Learned counsel for the appellants strenuously submitted that once the respondents while

working as JBT teachers having been granted higher pay scale of Masters and now the

regular promotion order was issued, it would not be possible to grant them one more

increment while fixing their pay in the promotional post of Master. The submission of learned

counsel for the appellants appears to be justified. Since the respondents herein were already

functioning in the pay scale of Masters and it was nothing but regularization of their pay

which they were not entitled to because of the change in the policy but they were allowed to

continue and now when the regular promotion is sought to be given to them they cannot get

the double benefit of fixation of pay. As per the rejoinder affidavit filed on behalf of the State

Government by Sh. Dayal Singh Sangwan, Budget Officer (Schools) in the Directorate of

Secondary Education, Haryana, it appears that the respondents on acquiring the higher

qualifkations were granted one additional increment though they were not entitled because by

that time the policy has been changed in 1990 but nobody challenged the earlier judgments by

which the Court allowed them to continue in the functional pay scale of Masters. Now,

because of regular promotion order being issued for the post of Masters, it only amounts to

regularization of the pay scale which they were already drawing i.e. pay scale of Masters.

Thus, granting of one more increment because of regularization of the respondents by

promoting them to the post of Masters, would not entitle them the double benefit, though they

have already got one increment on acquiring the higher educational qualifications and now

Page 30: Department of School Education Haryanaschooleducationharyana.gov.in/downloads_pdf/daily_orders/2012/T05... · Education Rules-2003 Education Department, Haryana hereby permit to add

on regular promotion being given in the Masters' pay scale in which they were already

working, they cannot claim another benefit. Rule 4.4 reads as under:

"4.4. The initial substantive pay of a Government employee who is appointed

substantively to a post on a

time-scale of pay is regulated as follows:-

(a) If he holds a lien on a permanent post, other than a tenure post, or would hold lien

on such a post, had his, lien not been suspended-

when appointment to the new post involves the assumption of duties or

responsibilities of greater importance (as interpreted for the purposes of rule 4.13) than these

attaching to such permanent post, he will draw as initial pay the stage of the time-scale next

above his, substantive pay in respect of the old post;

when appointment to the new post does not involve such assumption, he will draw

as initial pay the stage of the time-scale which is equal to his substantive pay in respect of the

old post, or, if there is no such stage, the stage next below that pay plus personal pay equal to

the difference, and in either case will continue to draw that pay until such time as he would

have received an increment in the time scale of the old post or for the period after which an

increment is earned in the time-scale of the new post, whichever is less. But if the minimum of

the time-scale of the new post is higher than his substantive pay in respect of the old post he

will draw that minimum as initial pay.

(iii) When appointment to the new post is made on his own request under rule 3.17 (a)

and maximum pay in the time-scale of that post is less than his substantive pay in respect of

the old post, he will draw that

maximum as initial pay."

The above rule says that when appointment to the new post involves the assumption of

duties or

responsibilities of greater importance than those attaching to such permanent post, the

incumbent will draw as initial pay the stage of time scale next above his substantive pay in

respect of the old post meaning thereby that the promotion which involves responsibilities of

greater importance then in that case the incumbent will draw as initial pay the stage of time-

scale next above his substantive pay in respect of the old post. That means he will be entitled to

one increment in the old post. But in the present case, the respondents are already drawing the

pay scale of the post of Master i.e. higher post As such, where is the question of granting

them one increment further now? Under rule 4.4 it could have been possible to grant them

fixation if they were continuing in the old scale of JBT teachers and on their promotion to the

post of Master, then certainly they would have been entitled to fixation of pay giving them the

initial-pay the stage of time scale next above their substantive pay in respect of the old post.

But they are already fixed in the pay scale of higher post of Master which though legitimately

they were not entitled to because of the change in the policy but they continued in the higher

pay scale despite the change in the policy and the Government did not take any further steps to

put the house in proper order. Be that as it may, since the respondents were drawing the

higher pay scale on acquiring higher educational qualifications, i.e. the Master's pay scale,

and now only regular orders have been passed, promoting them as Master, there is no

Page 31: Department of School Education Haryanaschooleducationharyana.gov.in/downloads_pdf/daily_orders/2012/T05... · Education Rules-2003 Education Department, Haryana hereby permit to add

9

iuestion of again fixing them next above their substantive pay in respect of the old post. They

are not holding the old post any more and they were not drawing the salary of JBT teachers

i.e. the old post. Therefore, there is no question of granting them the initial pay the stage of

time scale next above their substantive pay in respect of the old post.

In this connection, a reference may be made to the decision of this Court, in the case of State

of Haryana & Ors. v. Sumitra Devi & Ors., reported in 120041 12 SCC 322. wherein the

earlier decisions of this Court on similar controversy were reviewed and it was observed in

paragraph 5 of the judgment as follows :

"It is, therefore, not a case where the petitioners had acquired a qualification prior to

9.3.1990 while acting as teachers or masters. The circular letter dated 9.3.1990 clearly states

that a higher scale of pay would not be admissible to them despite holding a higher

qualification having been appointed on a lower post. Such higher scale of pay was admissible

only to such teachers/ masters who had enhanced their educational qualification during the

course of service. The petitioners, therefore, were not entitled to higher scale of pay. The

learned counsel for the respondents submitted that keeping in view the fact that persons

having similar qualification are getting higher scales of pay, as such this Court should not

interfere with the impugned judgment. The submission of the learned counsel cannot be

accepted for more than one reason. As the persons who'have been granted higher scales of

pay enhanced their qualification while holding their offices they had been allowed to continue

to get a higher scale of pay in view of the concession made by the learned counsel appearing

on behalf of the State. This Court, both in Wazir Singh and Kamal Singh Saharwat as

indicated hereinbefore, in np uncertain terms held that even such holders of such offices

would not automatically be entitled to, on acquisition of a higher qualification, a higher scale

of pay. The petitioners, as noticed, already had higher qualification and thus not entitled to

benefit of any circular whatsoever. Unfortunately, this aspect of the matter has not been taken

into consideration by the High Court. Furthermore, even an order cannot be passed under

Article 142 of the Constitution which will be contrary to the statute or statutory rules."

In this case, the respondents were in the pay scale of JBT teachers and similar claim

was made. This was negatived by this Court. Apart from this, there is another direct decision

on the similar issue, in the case of Union of India & Ors. v. Ashoke Kumar Banerjee, reported

in (1998] 5 SCC 242, wherein Fundamental Rules 22(1)(a)(1) came up for consideration

before this Court. In this case, the respondent was a Junior Engineer In the pay scale of Rs.

1640-2900/- and he was granted the pay scale of Assistant Engineer in the pay scale of Rs.

2000-3500/-. The respondent received the same benefit in advance while working as Junior

Engineer on completion of 15 years service and not actually functioning as Assistant

Engineer. The respondent was held not entitled to further increment & fixation on promotion

to the post of Assistant Engineer in the pay scale of Rs. 2000-3500/-. In that context, their

Lordships held as follows:

" The respondent having received the same benefit in advance, while working as

Junior Engineer and while not actually functioning as an Assistant Engineer, is not entitled to

the same benefit of fresh fitment in the scale of Rs.2000-3 500 when he is promoted as

Assistant Engineer. This is because on actual promotion as Assistant Engineer, he is not being

Page 32: Department of School Education Haryanaschooleducationharyana.gov.in/downloads_pdf/daily_orders/2012/T05... · Education Rules-2003 Education Department, Haryana hereby permit to add

fated into the "time scale of the higher post" as stated in FR 22 (I) (a) (1). That situation was

already over when he got benefit on completion of 15 years. Further, the respondent is a

junior officer in the category of Junior Engineers' and he has already got the benefit of the FR

on completion of 15 years. If he is to be given a second benefit on the basis of the same FR,

then he would be getting more than his seniors, who might have got promoted earlier and

might have got benefit of FR 22(1) (a)(1) only once. Such an anomaly is not intended by FR

22(1) (a) (1)."

Here in the present case, the difference is that the respondents are getting the higher

pay scale i.e. Master pay scale, on acquiring higher educational qualification though in fact

they were not promoted to the post of Masters. In the case of Ashoke Kumar Banerjee (supra)

functional pay of Assistant Engineer in the pay scale of Rs. 2000-3500/- was granted to

incumbent on completion of 15 years of service. Inj identical situation, the Court declined to

grant re-fixation of pay as P er FR 22(1)(a)(1) and same is the position in the present case.

When the respondents were already getting the; functional pay of Masters while working as

JBT teachers, now they have been promoted in the pay scale of Masters. Therefore, they

cannot get another fixation of pay which would amount to double benefit to the persons who

are already working as Masters. Judicial fiat cannot create anomalous position against the

statute. Hence, we allow all these appeals and set aside the impugned judgments of the Punjab

& Haryana High Court. However, whatever benefits, if any, received by the respondents would

not be recovered and they will not be entitled to fixation under Rule 4.4 of the Rules. No order

as to costs."

Again in a bunch of Civil Writ Petitions, mainly No. 3790 of 2006 titled Neelam Bali

and others versus State of Punjab and others, the Division Bench of Hon'ble Punjab and

Haryana High Court vide its decision dated 06.03.2009 has opined the same. The operative part

of this judgment is, hereby reproduced as under:

"In view of the aforesaid discussion, it is held that the petitioners, who were working as

JBT/C & V Cadre (Hindi/Punjabi Teachers etc) in the same pay scale as that of the

promotional post of Master/Mistresses would not be entitled to the grant of one additional

increment on their promotion to the post of Master/Mistresses in the same pay scale on the

ground of assuming higher responsibilities, especially in view of the Instructions dated

22.8.2006 (Annexure R.3) whereby the Administrative Department has categorically stated

that their such aforesaid promotion does not confer any higher responsibility upon them. The

validity of the Instructions dated 22.8.2006 (Annexure R.3), which is challenged in one of the

connected writ petitions, is thus upheld.

Therefore, in view of the above, the main petition bearing CWP No.3790 of 2006 is

dismissed with no order as to costs."

Page 33: Department of School Education Haryanaschooleducationharyana.gov.in/downloads_pdf/daily_orders/2012/T05... · Education Rules-2003 Education Department, Haryana hereby permit to add

11

The Finance department Haryana, Chandigarh has considered the same facts and issued

Memo No. 2/102/2009-2PR (FD), Dated Chandigarh, the 9 th April, 2010. The same authority

issued again guidelines regarding litigation policy vides its memo No. 8/10/2011-3PR(FD) dated

Chandigarh the 15 th December 2011.

Considering all the facts mentioned above the petitioners have not filed any re

-presentation and further it is also crystal clear from the table mentioned above that the petitioners

have already been granted higher pay scale in the form of JST Scale or Assured Career

Progression (ACP) Scales, therefore, they are not entitled to claim additional increment on their

promotion on the post of Head Teacher.

Keeping in view, Civil Services Rules and the judgments of the Hon'ble High

Court and the Supreme Court of India read with instructions issued by the Finance Department

Haryana, the petitioners' claim for granting them increment on promotion is not sustainable,

therefore, the legal notice dated 16.08.2011 has no merits and deserves to be rejected.

I pass an order accordingly.

Director Elements ducation Haryana,Panchkula

Endst. No. Dated:-

A copy is forwarded to the following information:-

The District Elementary Education Officer, Rohtak, Bhiwani, Rewari,

Kurukshetra, Sirsa, Gurgaon, Kaithal, Hisar.

Madan Mohan, Maths Master S/o Cinta Ram, GMS Gairatpur Bass, Block

Sohna District Gurgaon.

Kulvinder Singh, SS Master S/o Devender Singh, GMS Imligarh, Block

Mehan, District Rohtak.

Dalip Singh, SS Master S/o Ajmeer Singh, GSSS Sukh Chain, District

Sirsa.

Dalbir Singh, Hindi Teacher S/o Parma Lal, GHS Meoli, Block Pundri

District Kaithal.

Lakhvinder Singh, Hindi Teacher S/o Balwant Singh, GHS Pharal, Block

Pundri, District Kaithal.

Satyawan Singh, SS Master S/o Nihal Singh, GHS Singhdaragho, Block

Hansi- Hisar.

Baini Ram, hindi Teacher S/o Ram Chander, GHS Kawartan, Block Siwan,

District Kaithal.

Rajender Parshad, SS Master S/o Chander Bhan, GHS Dariapur , block

Siwan, District Bhiwani.

Pawan Kumar, SS Master S/o Kapoor Singh, GHS Alakhpura, Block

Bhiwani Khera, District Bhiwani.

Page 34: Department of School Education Haryanaschooleducationharyana.gov.in/downloads_pdf/daily_orders/2012/T05... · Education Rules-2003 Education Department, Haryana hereby permit to add

41111111.100

Smt. Shalu Devi , SS Mistress W/o Surender Kumar, GGHS Wazirabad..

Block-& District Gurgaon.

Ashok Kumar, SS Master S/o Ram Chander, GHS Balewa, Block. Patodi,

District Gurgaon.

Manoj Kumar, SS Master S/o Om Parkash, GHS Mahaniawas. Block

Patodi, District Gurgaon.

Satish Kumar, Maths Master S/o Jai Dayal Singh, GHS Nanu Kalan, Block

Pataudi, District Gurgaon.

15, Ram Niwas, SS Master S/o Pyeare Lal, GSSS Kosli, Block Nahar, District

Rewari.

Mantosh Kumar, SS Master S/o Ram Kishan , GMS Judola, Block Farud

Nagar, District Gurgaon.

Surender Lal, SS Master S/o Nawal Singh GSSS Manesar., District

Gurgaon.

Rajender Singh, SS Master S/o Hosiar, GMS Mirjapur, Block Patodi,

District Gurgaon.

Manoj Kumar, SS Master Sic) Munshi Ram, GMS Bhonkarkan, Block

Patodi, District Gurgaon.

Pawan Kumar, SS Master S/o Raghbir Singh, GHS Path station , Block

Faruq Nagar, District Gurgaon.

Vinod Kumar, SS Master S/o Dheer Singh, GHS Patli Station , Block

Faruq Nagar, District Gurgaon.

Smt. Sunita, SS Mistress W/o Chandan Kumar, GGMS Patli, Block

Farukh Nagar, District Gurgaon.

Mahanand , SS Master S/o Bhoop Singh, GSSS Budhera, District Gurgaon.

Ram Kumar, SS Master S/o Lachhman Dass, GHS Chuhar Majra, Block

Pundri, District Kaithal.

Jai Parkash, Master S/o Meher Chand GMS Mirchehri Block Babain,

District Kurukshetra.

Smt. Kaushalya Devi, SS Mistress W/o Jai Parkash, GSSS

Morthla, District Kurukshetra.

Head of Institution concerned.

2 .0. IT Cell.

2-41 . C14,901-okitzt 1-101-171- EP. I Cecv Qti -

For Director Elementary Education Haryana,Panchkula

.;1;41--74Deputy D ector Master

Page 35: Department of School Education Haryanaschooleducationharyana.gov.in/downloads_pdf/daily_orders/2012/T05... · Education Rules-2003 Education Department, Haryana hereby permit to add

348 7 celkS

Directorate of School Educarlon I team flan

GOVERNMENT OF HARYANA / • ftzrurr 'i'i

Directorate School Educationf4-ara-zr fOic 11(YRI

#rt-Itt rzet RoarerEducation, Canoe and Development

MR* WOIRVITTWT Lead me from Darkness to Light

www.schooleducationharyana.gov.in I [email protected] GOVERNMENT

EDUCATION DEPARTMENTCHANDIGARH

ORDER NO. 15/68-2008-HRL(1) DATED, PANCHKULA: 30/11/2012

In continuation of this office order no. 15/68-2008-HRL(3) dated 23/08/2012 the following

official who was promoted to the post of Lecturer in History is hereby adjusted against vacancy at

the station mentioned against his name with immediate effect provided that he has not joined his

previous place of posting:-

Sr. Transfer Name , Designation Earlier posted as Now Adjusted to Remarks

No. Id and present place of

Lecturer in Historyposting

1 51978 Sh. Naresh Kumar Master GSSS Kandela, Distt. GSSS Kinana, Distt. Against vacancyMathematics GHS Rajana Jind [1559]

Jind 11551]

Kalan (Jind) [1658]Employee ID: 056093

Note:Other terms and conditions of promotion/CDC orders will be remain same.

SURINA MANPRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO GOVT. HARYANA

SCHOOL EDUCATION DEPARTMENTCHANDIGARH

0/o DIRECTOR GENERAL SECONDARY EDUCATIONHARYANA, PANCHKULA

ENDST. NO. EVEN DATED PANCHKULA, 05/12/2012

A copy is forwarded to the following for information and necessary action :-1 District Education Officer/ District Elementary Education Officer Concerned.

Head of the institution concerned.Official concerned.Secy. OSD/CMSr. PS/E.M.Sr. PS/PSSEPS/DSE

echnology Officer (HQ)

ASS! A DIRER LECTURERfor DIRECTOR GENERAL SECONDARY EDUCATION

(0/ HARYANA, PANCHKULA

/ 4 1141 .91101 1212560246 Fax: 91(0172)-2560253

16122). 2560246 OR 91 (0172) 2560253Off.: Plot No. 10, Sliticatia Sadan.

*MINA 4"$re 40 it . 1:AllOrA

Page 1 of 1