dental office organization: a proposal for change
TRANSCRIPT
SHM 710 Integrated Capstone Project 1
DENTAL OFFICE ORGANIZATION:
A PROPOSAL FOR CHANGE
JONATHAN D. RICHEY
A.T. STILL UNIVERSITY – SCHOOL OF HEALTH MANAGEMENT
28 JULY 2005
SHM 710 Integrated Capstone Project 2
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Title Page.............................................................................................................................1
Table of Contents.................................................................................................................2
Abstract................................................................................................................................4
Dental Office Organization: A Proposal for Change...........................................................5
Introduction..........................................................................................................................5
The Future of Dentistry........................................................................................................5
Organizational System.........................................................................................................6
Open Systems...........................................................................................................6
Subsystems ..............................................................................................................6
Suggestion #1...........................................................................................................6
Organization Culture: Mission.............................................................................................6
Culture........................................................................................................................
6
Mission Statement....................................................................................................7
Suggestion #2...........................................................................................................7
Contingency Approaches.....................................................................................................7
Goal approach..........................................................................................................7
Operative goals........................................................................................................7
Subjective goals.......................................................................................................8
Suggestion #3...........................................................................................................8
Traditions, Rites, and ceremonies........................................................................................8
Traditions.................................................................................................................8
Rites ......................................................................................................................8
Suggestion #4...........................................................................................................9
Organizational Structure......................................................................................................9
Inconsistency............................................................................................................9
Consistency of purpose............................................................................................9
Horizontal Structure...............................................................................................10
Functional Structure...............................................................................................10
Suggestion #5.........................................................................................................10
SHM 710 Integrated Capstone Project 3
Suggestion #6.........................................................................................................10
The External Environment.................................................................................................11
Independence.........................................................................................................11
Suggestion #7.........................................................................................................12
Legitimacy.............................................................................................................12
Isomorphism..........................................................................................................12
Areas for Improvement..........................................................................................12
Suggestion #8. .......................................................................................................13
Information Technology....................................................................................................13
Computers can help................................................................................................13
Outsourcing can save money.................................................................................13
Suggestion #9.........................................................................................................13
Conclusion.........................................................................................................................14
Bibliography......................................................................................................................15
SHM 710 Integrated Capstone Project 4
ABSTRACT
Organizations as diverse as a church, a school, and a dental office have characteristics in
common. They are social entities that are goal oriented, are designed as deliberately structured
and coordinated activity systems, and are linked to the external environment. They are open
systems, subject to the trends of the economy, needing a strong mission statement and
organization configuration, and strategy. In the dental office, the design, information
technology, inter-organizational relationships, and leadership can make it an entity which is
attractive in the declining market for dental offices. The dentist should carryout specific designs
to make his office marketable to the increasingly small number of prospective buyers. Starting
with a mission statement, the office will be able to establish their purpose and goals. They can
then make a long-range plan to become independent and acquire resources in a way which makes
them marketable in the shifting economy. As the office implements their mission-derived goals,
they can accomplish much more as they use measurable goals, practice consistency, and work in
an effort to establish legitimacy and loyalty in all areas of interaction. Developing and
accentuating traditions, rites, and ceremonies will help develop unity and loyalty among staff
members and the dentist. As the hired manager, I examine these issues and construct
suggestions for the dentist.
SHM 710 Integrated Capstone Project 5
DENTAL OFFICE ORGANIZATION: A PROPOSAL FOR CHANGE
INTRODUCTION
Twenty one years ago, a small town dentist bought a practice, opened his door, and began seeing
patients. Starting only with a secretary and an assistant, he gradually expanded his practice to
include hygienists, financial secretaries, and additional dental assistants. Six years later he
moved to a new building and his practice continued to grow along with the burgeoning city.
Now that dentist is thinking about working fewer hours, selling his practice, and retiring with the
profits. He joins the increasing number of dentists retiring at a time when dental schools are
closing their doors – decreasing the pool of new dentists available to buy practices.
To achieve his objective, the dentist has hired a business manager to assist in the desired
transition, as well as fix current problems and prepare the practice for success in the 21st century.
The office manager must assess the office as an open system, subject to the trends of the
economy, appraise the mission, configuration, and strategy of the dental practice, and review the
design, information technology, inter-organizational relationships, and office leadership. As the
hired manager, I am examining these issues and will construct suggestions for the dentist.
THE FUTURE OF DENTISTRY
The ADA's recent report, "The Future of Dentistry," asserts that the United States population is
outdistancing the number of dentists that serve it. The number of dentists per 100,000 persons
declined from 60 to 59 between 1995 and 2000, and is expected to decline more dramatically —
from 59 percent to 54 percent between 2000 and 2020. This decline could result in a shortfall of
16,046 dentists by 2020 (Pride & Morgan, 2003). The shortage has already begun in rural areas
and is expected to worsen. To add to the concern, aging baby boomers, the largest segment of the
U.S. population, are expected to desire and require more dental care than any previous
generation. This has spawned the quick movement of some dentists to find partners and get out
of dentistry quicker than originally planed, including my boss. I was hired and given the task to
bring a successful dental office to maturity quickly in order to sell it and provide the founding
dentist a little retirement fund.
SHM 710 Integrated Capstone Project 6
ORGANIZATIONAL SYSTEM
Open system. A dental office is an open system which must interact with the environment to
survive; it consumes resources and exports resources to the environment. It cannot seal itself off
and must continuously change and adapt to the environment. Supplies come into the office daily
in order to provide the appropriate procedures required in the office. Items are also shipped off
to other companies which make crowns, retainers, and other oral appliances. If the system of
receiving and shipping is ineffective, the necessary procedures will not be able to be carried out
and thereby diminishing productivity of the office. In addition to being an open system, there are
various subsystems within the practice.
Subsystems. The technical core includes those who assist with the technical aspects such as
doing the actual procedures of dentistry. The technical support system helps the office improve
effectiveness by developing procedure protocols and patient flow ideals. The administrative
support function is responsible for the smooth operation and upkeep of the organization,
including the physical and human elements. Management is the last subsystem which is
responsible for coordinating the other parts of the organization. They lead in providing direction,
strategy, goals, and policies for the entire organization or major divisions. Until recently, the
managing was done by the dentist. Finding a happy medium between the dentist leading the
practice and the staff accepting my leadership role may prove to be difficult as there is much
“tradition” within the practice. My hire is a large step for the dentist and the office as a whole.
Suggestion #1 Define staff responsibilities and stewardship.
ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE: MISSION
Culture. Culture is the set of values, guiding beliefs, understandings, and ways of thinking that
is shared by members of an organization (Daft, 2003). It provides employers and staff a sense of
organizational identity and generates a commitment to beliefs and values that are larger than
themselves. The culture appropriate for a dental office is a bureaucratic culture. Such a culture
has an internal focus and a consistency orientation for a stable environment. The dental office
needs a consistent and methodical approach to doing business.
SHM 710 Integrated Capstone Project 7
Mission statement. The dental office developed a mission statement twelve years previous and
included it in the New Employee Handbook (McAuliff, 1993). None of the employees can say
what the mission of the office is, nor do they have any idea what their underlying purpose is.
The mission is not discussed as a part of staff meetings, interviews, or hiring. Many
organizations have a mission statement, but typically people are not committed to it because they
are not involved in developing it; consequently it is not part of the culture. The lack of shared
vision and values is the seed bed of almost all other problems. Updating the mission statement
with the help of staff members in the dental office will help new associates and office veterans;
they will be able to center their efforts on a common goal and principles of service and consistent
work.
Suggestion #2 Update an office mission statement with the contribution of staff members.
CONTINGENCY APPROACHES
Goal approach. Contingency approaches, to measure whether or not the organization is
realizing its mission, focus on different parts of the organization. The goal approach is
concerned with the output side and whether the organization achieves its goals in terms of
desired levels of output – this is the best way for the dental office to evaluate its effectiveness.
For example, an important measure in the dental office is number of new patients in a month.
An operative goal for the office is 10 new patients. This goal is measurable and reflects
activities which the office can perform in order to accomplish it. Once the mission statement is
reevaluated and updated, operative goals can be well defined.
Operative goals. The dental office will benefit from goals concerning overall performance,
resource acquisition, market share, employee development, innovation and productivity.
Targets to reach for communicate legitimacy to the internal and external stakeholders. As a
manager I want the dental office to look good to patients, competitors, suppliers, and the local
community. I also want to develop within the office a sense of pride and commitment within
the office staff. Goals give a sense of direction to organization participants, and are a powerful
way to motivate – especially if everyone is involved in selecting the goals. For example, if the
secretary desires to have each patient begin treatment within 20 minutes of arrival, the office
SHM 710 Integrated Capstone Project 8
staff can discuss it’s relation to the overall mission of providing quality care and define ways to
accomplish it. A mission statement and operative goals are a powerful first step in
communicating legitimacy to external and internal stakeholders and creating a positive
impression.
Subjective goals. An issue to resolve with the goal approach is to identify operative goals for
the organization and how to measure goal attainment. Not all goals are objective. U.S.
corporations indicate top goals as being (1) profitability, (2) growth, (3) market share, (4) social
responsibility, and (5) employee welfare (Shetty, 1979). Dental office goals requiring subjective
assessment might include patient satisfaction and employee loyalty. I have to learn what the
actual goals are by talking with the office staff. Once goals are identified, subjective perceptions
of goal attainment have to be used when quantitative indicators are not available. I will have to
rely on information from customers, competitors, suppliers, and employees as well as my own
intuition when considering subjective goals.
Suggestion #3 Establish operative goals.
TRADITIONS, RITES, AND CEREMONIES
Traditions. An important part of organizational culture includes traditions, rites, and ceremonies
– planned activities that have a purpose of demonstrating company values. One medical office
had the tradition of putting together birthday baskets. Each time an employee has a birthday,
each member of the office staff contribute a gift, or something of meaning to a basket for the
individual. No names are given as to who is the giver of the gift. The person receiving the gifts
opens them in front of everyone during the lunch break with everyone in attendance. The basket
also includes a note declaring a reason why they appreciate the employee. In this tradition and
ceremony, co-workers are drawn closer together and anticipation for each event breeds
excitement and unity.
Rites. The dental office can benefit from two specific rites – rite of renewal and rite of
integration. A rite of renewal would reflect the training and development activities that improve
organization functioning. Monthly, during staff meetings, those who are principle players in
SHM 710 Integrated Capstone Project 9
office performance should be recognized and congratulated. The scheduling staff can be
celebrated for diminishing the number of no-shows. The financial staff can be rewarded and
recognized for decreasing the accounts receivable. Such ceremonies are highly visible and
communicate to all employees the value of diligent work. A rite of integration might include a
spotlight at staff meeting for a new employee. This will contribute to staff unity and
collaboration.
Suggestion #4 Develop and accentuate traditions, rites, and ceremonies.
ORGANIZATION STRUCTURE
Inconsistency. An area of weakness in the dental office is its organizational structure. Office
staff does not have a procedural guide for daily activities and so each situation is dealt with
differently. When questions arise, with regards to office policy, staff collaborate with confidants
within the office and decide what they think is best at the moment instead of following good
practice guidelines. For example, if a patient cancels with less than 24 hours notice, sometimes
the patient is given a charge for not keeping the appointment and sometimes the patient is told,
“Its okay.” This has lead to conflict among office staff and patients who disapprove and revolt -
discrediting the professionalism of the office. After such an episode, everyone denies
responsibility for what occurred because no well established guidelines are set up and no
structure is established for reporting, follow-up, and employee questions. An ideal structure for
a health care office is that of functional structure with horizontal linkages.
Consistency of purpose. For the solo practitioner, consistency of purpose is simple: Be
consistent. If you stop taking new patients over age 60 to keep the practice balanced, that
includes the dentist’s next-door neighbor; otherwise, his employees may wonder if he will make
an exception for others, too. If you do not prescribe narcotics over the phone, ever, then there's
no question when a patient on Friday afternoon swears to my staff that the dentist said he would.
And we don't need an office manager to interpret the vision of the boss to the nurses or to shield
the boss from the receptionist's complaints. We do not have to periodically re-establish an open-
door policy so employees feel comfortable talking directly to the doctor. They're in the dentist’s
SHM 710 Integrated Capstone Project 10
face all day long. If he have offended or confused or exasperated someone, it does not take long
to straighten things out.
Consistency makes it easier over the years to train patients, too. If the dentist consistently sees
patients within fifteen minutes of their appointment time, patients will be readily on time unless
there are justifying circumstances. If the dentist indicates that everyone who is going to have a
crown done will be required to make the ½ down payment at time of tooth preparation and ½
payment at the setting of the new tooth, and actually follows up with it, will collect the money
from the patients or those patients with the intention of not paying will weed themselves out of
the office. These would be very difficult goals to achieve in a practice that is regularly
rescheduling patients because the schedule was overbooked and patients who are told they can
make payments when they want (with no contractual agreement). The blame lies with the
system.
Horizontal structure. In today’s society, there is a shift toward flatter, more horizontal
organizational structures because the fragmenting which vertical structuring causes. Managers
improve horizontal coordination by using information systems, direct contact between
departments, full-time integrators or project manager, task forces, or teams. In the dental office,
workflow should be centered on patient care. Instead of bouncing patients from room to room,
bringing services to the patient can provide a more effective office visit with minor detours to x-
ray or surgery. A patient coordinator/educator can serve as a liaison between patients and their
care ensuring their questions are answered and they are taken care of in a timely manner,
dramatically improving patient satisfaction, thereby diminishing no-shows as well as accounts
receivable. I believe patients are willing to pay for good care.
Functional structure. Particularly for a one dentist office, functional structure is beneficial
because you only need one financial department, one dental assistant department, and one
hygienist department. There is no need to have a secretary and a marketing specialist for each
provider. Functional structure also provides for stability in a relatively stable market. There is
not a need for decentralized decision making which a more divisional structure would provide.
Suggestion #5 Be consistent!
SHM 710 Integrated Capstone Project 11
Suggestion #6 Fortify a functional structure; establish protocols and lines of communication.
THE EXTERNAL ENVIRONMENT
We have evaluated some of the measures which will help buffer the dental practice against
internal ebbs and flows. Now let us turn our focus to the external environment. All the elements
that exist outside the boundary of the organization have the potential to affect all or part of the
organization (Daft, p.30). It is this external environment which prompts the dentist to seek help.
As was mentioned before, the economy has been progressing toward an unfavorable market for
retiring dentists. Careful planning in response to the developing uncertainty is necessary in times
of change. When the environment is stable, organizational focus generally shifts to current
operational problems and day-to-say efficiency. Long-range planning and forecasting are not
needed in a stable environment because the demands in the future will be the same as they are
today. This stability is rarely seen in our world today. There is an increase in environmental
uncertainty which makes planning and forecasting essential. Planning can soften the adverse
impact of environmental shifting and anticipate potential changes by different organizations and
environmental sectors.
Independence. Independence is an essential key to stability in a shaky economy. The US
government recognizes its reliance upon foreign oil and has made steps to try and become more
independent. The dental office can do the same. As it provides additional services such as
yearly checkups, in-house retainer molding, x-ray, and imaging, it will be less dependent upon
other providers of these services. Providing these services, and perhaps monopolizing on such
arrangements can be very attractive and lucrative. The dental providers have attempted to
educate themselves in a way which provides unique services. For example, many people are
interested in cosmetic dentistry. The dentist already does orthodontia and with some additional
training he is able to offer Invisalign® (a clear retainer series which straightens teeth) to his
patients. Being the only dentist in town which offers this service, he has become more
independent of the external environment shift toward invisible cosmetic dentistry. Becoming
resource independent is another area of focus in the dental practice. Manufacturers of dental
crowns and bridges can increase prices beyond reason if they know they are the only firm
available for the service. I believe the office can save more money as it petitions other
SHM 710 Integrated Capstone Project 12
companies for their manufacturing services to drive the prices down. Being an office with a lot
of patients, the bargaining ability is there, it merely needs to be utilized.
Suggestion #7 Make a long-range plan, become more independent and acquire resources
smartly.
Legitimacy. Legitimacy is defined as the general perspective that an organization’s actions are
desirable, proper, and appropriate within the environment’s system of norms, values, and beliefs.
Organizations must fit within the cognitive and emotional expectations of their audience. For
example, I saw a billboard on the side of the road advertising financial planning advice and
savings and retirement options. At the bottom of the billboard however, a statement immediately
turned off my interest in the ad. It said, neither FDIC insured nor bank secure. That statement
does not fit into my concept of good financial advice or savings planning. It did not appear to be
a legitimate offer for financial security. I wondered then, do companies attempt to appear
legitimate, and does it motivate them? I think overall, companies strive to be legitimate. The
billboard announcement was appealing, and the adverse comment was in small print at the
bottom of the board, (probably due to law requirement) making it look legitimate. In the dental
field, legitimacy is important. People walk into the dental office and expect to see certain things;
a comfortable waiting room, magazines, a clean bathroom, prompt and kind service,
ergonomically sound office structure, dentist degrees posted on the wall, and good service rates.
Each of these aspects contributes to the perceived legitimacy of the dental practice.
Isomorphism. Isomorphism is a term closely associated with legitimacy in the business world.
Once a company has established a name for itself, it invisibly pushes toward similarity to other
companies in order to maintain legitimacy with consumers. Being accepted is motivation for
individuals. It can be seen in our personal lives. People strive to appear like others, why do you
think there are such things as trends. A few in Hollywood may set the trend, and the rest of the
world attempts to copy it. The same can be seen when an actor or actress is seen walking down
the red carpet in something outrageously different and not merely a step out of normality but
never before seen. Usually the reviews are negative. The same can be applied to business.
SHM 710 Integrated Capstone Project 13
Areas for improvement. A couple areas in which this dental office needs to work at creating a
sense of legitimacy as well as being accepted more readily are: (1) having the financial
secretary’s office separate from the hallway where patients pass by frequently. Financial matters
are often sensitive matters and should be dealt with in private. The secretary should not walk out
into the waiting room to discuss financial matters with patients in front of other patients. (2)
Once a patient is seated, the patient should not be moved to another room unless to be x-rayed,
and then the patient should be returned to the same room. (3) The doctor’s children should not
run around the office as they please and should not interrupt the dentist during procedures.
There is a sense of distrust when the physician is preoccupied with his surroundings while
drilling in a patient’s mouth.
Suggestion #8 Evaluate what makes a dental office legitimate in society, establish those
standards within the office.
INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY
Computers can help. In an effort to attract potential buyers to the practice, there is a need to
update the 1980’s computer hardware and software of the office. Information technology is
important in dentistry and health care. Tracking health trends and patient information is essential
in this field. Technology can be used to order office material, automate supplies procurement,
assist in decision making, and protect patients from adverse drug interactions by alerting the
dental provider, teaching healthy habits, procedure training, patient record keeping, and office
finance tracking. In the future electronic insurance claims will also be more prevalent, gathering
insurance information and pre-authorizations will also be done electronically.
Outsourcing saves money. Information technology will also enable the dental office to
outsource functions which can be done cheaper by other companies such as billing. It facilitates
smoother transitions for the patient through the office and eliminates the “lost chart” problem.
Potentially I see information technology assisting patients with finding information about the
office, scheduling appointments, refilling prescriptions, and making online payments. All of this
would save on office staff hours, which translate into saved money, and channel employee
expertise to other areas of office improvement and service.
SHM 710 Integrated Capstone Project 14
Suggestion #9 Update computer system.
CONCLUSION
Organizations as diverse as a church, a school, and dental offices have characteristics in
common. They are social entities that are goal oriented, are designed as deliberately structured
and coordinated activity systems, and are linked to the external environment. The dental office
is no exception. It is also an open system, subject to the trends of the economy, needing a strong
mission statement and organization configuration, and strategy of the dental practice. Its design,
information technology, inter-organizational relationships, and leadership can make it an entity
which is attractive in the declining market for dental offices. Starting with a mission statement,
the office will be able to establish their purpose and goals. They can then make a long-range
plan to become independent and acquire resources in a way which makes them marketable in the
shifting economy. As the office implements their mission-derived goals, they can accomplish
much more as they use measurable goals, practice consistency, and work in an effort to establish
legitimacy and loyalty in all areas of interaction. Developing and accentuating traditions, rites,
and ceremonies will help develop unity and loyalty among staff members and the dentist. As the
office manager, I suggest the dentist carryout these specific designs to improve his office and
make it marketable in a very volatile market.
SHM 710 Integrated Capstone Project 15
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Daft, R. L. (2003). Organization Theory and Design. (8th Ed.) United States: South Western
Pride, J. R., & Morgan, A. (2003). The changing demographics of dentistry. Dental Economics
February.
Shetty, Y.K. (1979). New look at corporate goals, California Management Review (22), no. 271-
79.
McAuliff, J.A. (1993). Our Mission Statement. New Employee Handbook: Porterville.