defendants’ deposition designations and objections …€¦ · cum. cum. imp improper counter lc...
TRANSCRIPT
DEFENDANTS’ DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS AND OBJECTIONS FOR USE AT TRIAL
Index to Objections:
A Authenticity
EPA Excluded Pursuant to Agreement
LC Legal Conclusion
ME Misstates Evidence
AA Asked and Answered EPO. Excluded Pursuant to Court Order LPN Lack of Personal Knowledge MT Mischaracterizes
Testimony Amb. Ambiguous F Foundation NP Non‐Responsive NR Non‐Responsive
Arg. Argumentative H Hearsay P Predicate S Speculation
C Compound I Inadmissible Priv. Privileged UP Unduly Prejudicial COT Counsel is Testifying IC Improper Characterization R Relevance V VagueCum. Cum. IMP Improper Counter LC Legal Conclusion W Exhibit Withdrawn
EOT Expert Opinion Testimony L Leading M Misleading Please note: brackets indicate partial objections to enhance readability for the Court.
I. Witness: Cassarino, Craig (Corporate Rep. for Ampenergo Inc.)
Defendants’ Designations
Plaintiffs’ Objections
Plaintiffs’ Counter
Designations
Third Party Objections
Third Party Counter
Designations
Defendants’ Objections
Defendants’ Rebuttals
Plaintiffs’ Objections
Third Party Objections
Court’s Ruling
9:5‐9:16 11:13‐12:3 15:11‐17:3 23:14‐24:12 24:22‐25:8 29:14‐29:23 32:20‐34:11 42:14‐43:13 53:6‐53:18 57:13‐57:23 60:1‐61:6 69:5‐70:22 76:16‐77:3 77:22‐79:22 87:2‐89:9 94:22‐95:10 95:21‐97:14 98:6‐98:13 98:17‐100:18 102:13‐102:20
15:19‐16:9 R; 16:20‐17:3 R; 23:14‐24:12 R; 32:20‐34:11 R; 42:14‐ 43:13 H; 53:6‐18 R; 57:13‐23 H; 60:1‐61:6 R, H; 87:8‐12 R, LC; 97:3‐7 EOT; 102:18‐20 H, EOT; 103:14‐17 H; 104:4‐105:7 R; 107:1‐14 H, S; 112:21‐114:4 H, R; 122:4‐123:6 R, EOT;
23:5‐10 34:20‐35:1 35:6‐12 37:10‐13 37:19‐38:3 38:11‐13 43:14‐16 47:1‐11 47:15‐48:13 57:13‐60:20 61:4‐16 61:17‐63:9 63:10‐15 64:9‐21 65:3‐10 66:14‐68:1 70:23‐71:2 73:2‐17 75:1‐7 79:23‐80:16
Defendants’ Objections to Plaintiffs: 23:5‐10 IMP 34:20‐35:1 IMP 35:6‐12 IMP 37:10‐13 IMP 37:19‐38:3 IMP 38:11‐13 IMP 47:1‐11 IMP 47:15‐48:13 IMP 58:10‐59:23 IMP 61:17‐63:15 IMP 65:3‐10 IMP 66:14‐68:1 IMP 70:23‐71:2 IMP 73:2‐17 IMP 75:1‐7 IMP, C 79:23‐80:21 IMP 82:7‐11 IMP;
Defendants’ Rebuttals to Plaintiffs: 35:2‐5 37:14‐18 38:4‐10 38:14‐23 49:5‐8 63:16‐64:8 75:8‐76:1 81:21‐23 86:15‐19 105:10‐106:1 112:8‐20 118:12‐18 128:13‐18 129:19‐130:7
Page 001 of 014
Case 1:16-cv-21199-CMA Document 325-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 06/27/2017 Page 1 of 14
Defendants’ Designations
Plaintiffs’ Objections
Plaintiffs’ Counter
Designations
Third Party Objections
Third Party Counter
Designations
Defendants’ Objections
Defendants’ Rebuttals
Plaintiffs’ Objections
Third Party Objections
Court’s Ruling
103:14‐103:17 104:4‐105:7 106:9‐107:14 112:21‐114:4 119:6‐119:19 122:4‐123:6 123:14‐124:11 131:22‐133:2 145:16‐146:7 148:6‐148:16 155:14‐155:22 162:20‐163:7 164:12‐164:20 165:6‐166:1 169:20‐171:9 178:7‐178:22 180:22‐183:15 183:20‐185:12 186:11‐186:15 187:8‐187:13 195:11‐198:14 198:20‐199:5 202:9‐202:12 202:17‐203:1 208:13‐209:20 210:6‐210:14 210:23‐214:8 214:10‐214:14 214:16‐215:4 215:6‐215:20 215:22‐216:9 216:11‐217:8 218:12‐220:3 220:11‐220:15 220:19‐221:16 221:18‐222:2 223:21‐224:5 225:16‐227:19 241:13‐242:2 245:1‐245:13
123:14‐124:11 R; 131:22‐133:2 A, R; 145:16‐146:7 A; 148:6‐16 H, R; 180:22‐183:15 R, S; 183:20‐185:12 R, S; 186:11‐15 A, H, R; 187:8‐13 A, H, R; 195:11‐198:14 A, R; 202:9‐12 R, P; 202:17‐203:1 R; 208:13‐209:20 P, S, R; 210:6‐14 A, P, R; 210:23‐212:12 A, R, S; 212:13‐213:3 A, P, R; 213:4‐214:8 A, P, R; 214:10‐14 P, A, R; 214:16‐215:4 A, H, R, P; 215:6‐20 H, P, S; 215:20 R, S; 215:22‐23 R, S; 216:11‐217:8 R; 218:16‐23 H,
80:17‐21 82:7‐11 82:13‐83:7 86:10‐13 87:12‐89:9 97:15‐98:4 105:8‐9 108:16‐109:12 111:1‐22 111:23‐112:7 116:8‐117:9 120:12‐121:5 127:17‐22 128:19‐21 129:4‐18 130:8‐16 146:8‐19 155:23‐156:10 161:6‐13 166:22‐167:11 168:3‐6 194:19‐195:10 202:14‐16 214:9 214:15 215:5 215:21 216:10 221:17 221:18‐222:11 229:15‐230:15 235:21‐236:20
82:13‐83:7 IMP; 86:10‐13 IMP; 97:15‐98:4 IMP; 105:8‐9 IMP; 108:16‐109:12 IMP; 111:1‐22 IC, IMP; 111:23‐112:7 IMP; 116:8‐117:9 IMP; 120:12‐121:5 IMP, F; 127:17‐22 IMP, F; 128:19‐21 IMP, F; 129:4‐18 IMP, F, R, H; 130:8‐16 IMP, H; 155:23‐156:10 IMP, R; 168:3‐6 IMP; 194:19‐195:10 IMP, R; 229:15‐230:15 IMP; 235:21‐236:20 IMP
Page 002 of 014
Case 1:16-cv-21199-CMA Document 325-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 06/27/2017 Page 2 of 14
Defendants’ Designations
Plaintiffs’ Objections
Plaintiffs’ Counter
Designations
Third Party Objections
Third Party Counter
Designations
Defendants’ Objections
Defendants’ Rebuttals
Plaintiffs’ Objections
Third Party Objections
Court’s Ruling
R; 220:11‐15 A, H, P; 220:19‐23 A, H, P; 221:1‐12 H, S, P; 221:13‐16 A, H, P, S; 221:18‐222:2 A, H, P, S; 223:21‐224:5 R; 225:16‐226:23 H, R; 227:1‐19 A, H, R; 241:18‐242:2 P
Page 003 of 014
Case 1:16-cv-21199-CMA Document 325-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 06/27/2017 Page 3 of 14
2. Witness: Childress, Jamie (Corporate Rep. for Boeing) Defendants’ Designations
Plaintiffs’ Objections
Plaintiffs’ Counter
Designations
Third Party Objections
Third Party Counter
Designations
Defendants’ Objections
Defendants’ Rebuttals
Plaintiffs’ Objections
Third Party Objections
Court’s Ruling
1:11‐13 7:9‐12 10:3‐6 11:14‐18 13:9‐14 15:1‐4 15:15‐21 16:3‐7 18:25‐19:4 22:15‐23 24:25‐25:8 31:7‐13 31:15‐18 32:17‐24 34:1‐3 34:5 34:7‐12 34:16‐22 37:10‐14 37:16‐20 38:9‐13 39:10‐41:6 41:19‐42:4 42:9‐11 43:3‐19 43:24‐44:2 44:14‐45:4 45:12‐15 45:17‐21 46:13‐47:14 47:16‐21 47:22‐48:17 48:19‐21 48:23‐50:22 51:17‐52:11 52:15‐53:6 54:9‐10 55:6‐12
31:11‐13 L, P; 32:17‐24 R; 34:1‐3 R; 34:7‐12 R; 34:16‐22 R; 37:10‐14 H, R; 37:16‐20 H, R; 38:9‐13 H, R; 39:10‐41:6 EOT, R; 41:19‐42:4 H, R; 42:9‐11 H, R; 43:3‐19 A, R; 43:24‐44:2 A, EOT, R; 44:14‐45:4 A, EOT, R; 45:12‐15 L, EOT, R; 45:17‐21 L, EOT, R; 46:13‐25 A, EOT, H, R; 47:1‐10 EOT, R; 47:11‐14 L, EOT, R; 47:22‐48:17 EOT, R; 48:19‐21 P, EOT, R; 48:19‐21 EOT, R; 51:17‐52:8 EOT, R; 52:15‐53:6 EOT, R;
10:21‐25 17:14‐18:24 19:19‐20:3 20:6‐10 20:22‐21:10 21:17‐22:3 22:5‐14 26:1‐3 26:12‐25 29:10‐16 31:14 33:8‐10 33:22‐25 34:4 34:6 36:13‐37:1 37:15 45:5‐11 45:16 47:15 48:18 52:13 56:7 69:4 71:12 72:11 75:14‐18 84:2‐5 84:7‐13 84:21‐85:5 85:21‐25 90:1‐7 91:16‐20 92:5‐22 96:6‐21 98:16‐22 99:5 99:20‐100:3
Defendants’ Objections to Plaintiffs: 22:1‐14 H, FRE 1004; 33:8‐10 R, FRE 403; 33:22‐25 R, FRE 403; 84:21‐24 H; 84:25‐85:5 AA; 85:21‐25 AA; 90:1‐4 AA; 99:5‐Exhibit 8 R, IMP; 99:20‐100:3 R, IMP; 100:13‐19 R, IMP; 100:20‐101:7 R, LPN, S, IMP; 102:11‐18 & Exhibit 9 R, H, IMP; 103:3‐2, 6‐14 R, IMP; 103‐15‐25 & Exhibit 10 R, IMP, H Exhibit; 104:1‐13 R, IMP; 104:22‐105:1 R, IMP; 105:21‐106:10 R, IMP; 106:17‐107:1 R, IMP; 107:24‐108:17 R, IMP; 110:10‐13 AA; 113:9‐13 AA; 124:9‐25 & Exhibit 14 R, IMP; 125:19‐126:14 R, IMP, S, LPN
Defendants’ Rebuttals to Plaintiffs: 26:8‐11 52:12, 14 93:25‐94:23
Page 004 of 014
Case 1:16-cv-21199-CMA Document 325-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 06/27/2017 Page 4 of 14
Defendants’ Designations
Plaintiffs’ Objections
Plaintiffs’ Counter
Designations
Third Party Objections
Third Party Counter
Designations
Defendants’ Objections
Defendants’ Rebuttals
Plaintiffs’ Objections
Third Party Objections
Court’s Ruling
56:1‐6 57:12‐58:21 58:23‐59:21 68:25‐69:3 69:5‐12 70:5‐71:9 72:8‐10 72:12 96:23‐97:7 97:9‐22 136:17‐25 137:2 137:4‐6 137:8‐14 137:15‐138:1 139:24‐140:25
54:9‐10 H, R; 55:6‐12 EOT, R; 56:1‐6 EOT, R; 57:12‐58:21 EOT, R; 58:23‐59:21 EOT, R; 68:25‐69:3 EOT, P, R; 69:5‐12 EOT, P, R; 70:5‐71:9 EOT, R; 72:8‐10 EOT, R; 72:12 EOT, R; 96:23‐97:7 H, R; 97:9‐22 H, R; 136:17‐25 EOT, R; 137:2 EOT, R; 137:4‐6 EOT, R; 137:8‐14 EOT, R;
100:13‐101:7 102:11‐18 103:3‐4 103:6‐18 103:22‐104:13 104:22‐105:1 105:21‐106:10 106:17‐107:1 107:24‐108:7 108:9‐13 108:15‐17 110:10‐13 110:15‐17 110:23‐111:4 111:6‐25 112:2 112:8‐24 113:1‐3 113:5 113:9‐11 113:13 114:1 114:3 114:11‐115:12 115:19‐22 117:17‐118:5 124:9‐25 125:19‐126:7 126:9‐11 126:14 137:1 137:3 137:7
Page 005 of 014
Case 1:16-cv-21199-CMA Document 325-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 06/27/2017 Page 5 of 14
3. Witness: Fabiani, Fulvio Defendants’ Designations
Plaintiffs’ Objections
Plaintiffs’ Counter
Designations
Third Party Objections
Third Party Counter
Designations
Defendants’ Objections
Defendants’ Rebuttals
Plaintiffs’ Objections
Third Party Objections
Court’s Ruling
6:25‐7:4 7:24‐8:10 11:22‐12:22 13:23‐14:1 26:22‐28:1 30:19‐30:21 32:21‐33:21 34:12‐34:17 35:1‐35:4 35:6‐35:14 35:24‐38:9 38:17‐39:10 40:4‐40:16 46:10‐47:25 48:2‐48:14 49:21‐50:7 59:10‐60:3 74:20‐75:8 82:6‐82:19 82:21‐84:6 84:16‐84:19 85:3‐85:6 86:13‐86:16 87:7‐88:17 88:19‐89:7 90:14‐91:21 93:8‐94:20 96:13‐99:8 100:8‐100:22 102:17‐109:3 109:17‐110:14 111:11‐113:8 113:24‐114:3 114:11‐119:4 120:5‐121:21 122:5‐123:2 123:5‐124:1 124:7‐125:1
11:22‐12:22 R; 26:22‐28:1 R; 32:21‐33:21 R; 34:12‐17 L, R; 35:1‐4 R; 35:6‐14 L, R, AA; 35:24‐38:9 R; 40:13‐16 R, AA; 82:6‐19 agreement between USQL and IH in summer or fall of 2013, ended in either March or April 2016; 86:13‐16 L 128:20‐130:5 R
44:14‐17 44:18‐20 44:22‐23 44:25 45:5‐6 45:13‐19 45:22‐23 75:10‐76:5 85:7‐86:5 86:19‐87:6 89:8‐90:1 95:18‐96:12
11:22‐12:22 R;26:22‐28:1 R; 102:17‐103:4 R; 128:20‐130:5 R; 130:14‐131:2 R; 132:21‐133:10 R
86:17‐87:689:8‐90:13
Defendants’ Objections to Plaintiffs: 44:14‐45:23 IC 75:10‐76:5 IC 85:7‐86:5 IC 89:8‐90:1 IC 95:18‐96‐12 IC Defendants’ Objections to Third Party Defendants: 89:8‐90:13 IMP
Page 006 of 014
Case 1:16-cv-21199-CMA Document 325-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 06/27/2017 Page 6 of 14
Defendants’ Designations
Plaintiffs’ Objections
Plaintiffs’ Counter
Designations
Third Party Objections
Third Party Counter
Designations
Defendants’ Objections
Defendants’ Rebuttals
Plaintiffs’ Objections
Third Party Objections
Court’s Ruling
128:12‐128:16 128:20‐130:5 130:14‐131:2 132:21‐133:10 135:22‐138:13 138:16‐139:12 140:13‐141:14 141:17‐142:19 142:25‐144:16 148:1‐148:11 148:12‐148:25
Page 007 of 014
Case 1:16-cv-21199-CMA Document 325-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 06/27/2017 Page 7 of 14
4. Witness: Rossi, Andrea (Corporate Rep. for JM Products) Defendants’ Designations
Plaintiffs’ Objections
Plaintiffs’ Counter
Designations
Third Party Objections
Third Party Counter
Designations
Defendants’ Objections
Defendants’ Rebuttals
Plaintiffs’ Objections
Third Party Objections
Court’s Ruling
5:22‐6:1 6:14‐23 7:11‐8:6 8:19‐9:11 16:17‐17:2 17:6‐18:20 20:10‐23:4 24:13‐26:13 27:24‐28:23 32:14‐17 40:24‐41:2 44:2‐45:25 49:1‐14 55:25‐56:3 59:18‐61:6 61:9‐18 63:25‐64:10 65:8‐16 66:22‐67:18 72:7‐20 72:24‐74:1 74:21‐24 78:5‐79:9 79:23‐80:8 81:21‐82:14 83:20‐85:1 87:1‐10 90:1‐24 91:17‐92:5 92:19‐93:8 93:21‐94:21 108:1‐109:20 110:3‐111:4 111:11‐19 111:24‐112:7 120:20‐121:17 122:24‐124:11 125:1‐8
8:19 ‐24 Amb.; 16:17‐17:2 R; 17:6‐19 R; 18:14‐20 AA, P, R; 22:16‐23:4 R; 24:13‐26:13 R; 27:24‐28:23 R; 32:14‐17 R; 32:14‐17 R, H; 59:18‐61:6 H; 61:9‐18 H; 72:24‐74:1 R; 74:21‐24 R; 81:21‐82:14 R; 83:20‐85:1 R; 87:1‐10 R; 90:1‐24 R; 91:17‐92:5 R; 110:3‐13 R; 111:11‐19 R; 111:24‐112:7 R; 144:23‐145:8 R; 152:12‐20 R; 154:20‐155:23 R; 157:22‐158:2 R; 168:15‐24 R, S, Arg.; 178:11‐15 R; 181:4‐20 R; 201:2‐19 R; 233:22‐235:8 R; 236:2‐7 R;
7:8‐10 8:11‐13 8:15‐18 15:25‐16:16 18:22‐25 19:2‐16 27:8‐19 27:22 31:23‐32:13 32:18‐22 34:3‐35:17 36:1‐37:22 40:24‐42:2 42:17‐43:2 43:5‐6 46:1‐11 51:7‐15 61:7 64:11‐14 65:17‐66:9 68:6‐10 68:12 68:14‐21 79:10‐22 80:9‐19 95:1–07 203:21‐204:20 207:6‐22 249:4
8:19‐24 A;17:17‐ 18:20 AA; 21:25‐22:12 R; 22:23‐23:1 AA; 23:2‐4 R, Fact not in dispute; 24:13‐24 AA; 27:24‐28:19 Arg., MT; 59:22‐60:7 S, H; 60:14‐61:6 S, H; 61:9‐18 H, M; 72:24‐74:1 R; 74:21‐24 R; 110:3‐12 – Confusing; 111:11‐19 R; 111:24‐112:7 R
80:14‐1985:10‐86:1 203:21‐ 204:20 207:6‐22
Defendants’ Objections to Plaintiffs: 8:11‐13 IMP 8:15‐18 IMP 15:25‐16:16 IMP 18:22‐19:16 IMP 27:8‐19 IMP 27:22 IMP 32:18‐22 IMP 34:3‐35:17 IMP 36:1‐37:22 IMP 41:3‐42:2 IMP 42:17‐43:6 IMP 46:‐1‐11 IMP 51:7‐15 IMP 65:17‐66:9 IMP 68:6‐21 IMP 79:10‐22 IMP 95:1‐7 IMP 203:21‐204:20 IMP 207:6‐22 IMP Defendants’ Objections to Third Party Defendants: 80:14‐19 IMP 85:10‐86:1 IMP 203:21‐204:20 IMP 207:6‐22 IMP
Defendants’ Rebuttals to Plaintiffs: 19:17‐20:9 26:14‐27:6 32:23‐33:11 33:21‐34:2 35:18‐25 42:3‐6 50:16‐51:6 66:10‐20 206:4‐207:5 Defendants’ Rebuttals to Third Party Defendants: 80:20‐81:8 85:2‐9 202:22‐203:20 206:4‐207:5
19:17‐20:9 IMP, Arg., R; 26:14‐27:6 IMP, Arg., R; 32:23‐33:11 IMP, Arg., R; 35:18‐25 IMP, R; 42:3‐6 AA, Arg., Cum.; 50:16‐51:6 Confusing, Unintelligble; 66:10‐20 R, MT; 206:4‐8 AA, Cum.; 206:9‐22 M, Confusing, MT; 206:23‐207:2 AA; 207:3‐5 R
80:20‐81:8 R;85:2‐9 Cum.; 203:3‐6 M, Confusing; 203:7‐20 R; 206:4‐8 AA, Cum.; 206:9‐22 M, Confusing, MT; 206:23‐207:2 AA; 207:3‐5 R
Page 008 of 014
Case 1:16-cv-21199-CMA Document 325-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 06/27/2017 Page 8 of 14
Defendants’ Designations
Plaintiffs’ Objections
Plaintiffs’ Counter
Designations
Third Party Objections
Third Party Counter
Designations
Defendants’ Objections
Defendants’ Rebuttals
Plaintiffs’ Objections
Third Party Objections
Court’s Ruling
125:19‐22 128:16‐23 129:14‐130:8 130:17‐131:4 131:25‐132:11 134:10‐25 136:11‐137:5 142:5‐14 142:17‐18 143:12‐144:8 144:23‐145:8 147:9‐21 148:2‐149:3 151:3‐8 151:21‐25 152:12‐20 153:13‐154:6 154:20‐155:23 156:9‐157:11 157 157:22‐158:2 160:2‐161:12 161:18‐162:7 163:24‐164:2 164:8‐15 167:20‐23 168:13‐24 178:11‐15 181:4‐20 186:14‐22 188:1‐17 189:17‐25 192:14‐193:10 194:2‐195:13 200:4‐14 201:2‐19 205:12‐22 232:24‐233:16 233:22‐235:8 236:2‐7 236:12‐21
236:12‐21 R; 237:12‐15 R; 239:7‐14 R
Page 009 of 014
Case 1:16-cv-21199-CMA Document 325-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 06/27/2017 Page 9 of 14
Defendants’ Designations
Plaintiffs’ Objections
Plaintiffs’ Counter
Designations
Third Party Objections
Third Party Counter
Designations
Defendants’ Objections
Defendants’ Rebuttals
Plaintiffs’ Objections
Third Party Objections
Court’s Ruling
237:12‐15 237:20‐24 238:8‐15 239:7‐14 240:10‐241:7 245:14‐247:7 248:23‐249:3 251:10‐252:24 254:1‐256:1
Page 010 of 014
Case 1:16-cv-21199-CMA Document 325-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 06/27/2017 Page 10 of 14
5. Witness: Rossi, Andrea (Corporate Rep. for Leonardo Corp.)
Defendants’ Designations
Plaintiffs’ Objections
Plaintiffs’ Counter
Designations
Third Party Objections
Third Party Counter
Designations
Defendants’ Objections
Defendants’ Rebuttals
Plaintiffs’ Objections
Third Party Objections
Court’s Ruling
6:8‐12 7:9‐11 7:20‐8:1 15:10‐20 16:5‐9 16:10‐17:4 18:10‐25 19:7‐21 21:17‐25 22:24‐23:7 27:25‐28:10 28:20‐29:16 30:24‐31:21 33:16‐34:16 35:8‐23 37:16‐38:14 41:16‐43:18 43:19‐45:14 45:18‐46:15 46:19‐47:14 48:5‐21 57:19‐58:13 59:4‐14 60:9‐62:14 62:18‐63:3 63:22‐64:19 64:25‐65:10 68:10‐69:15 70:2‐23 72:7‐73:5 73:23‐74:1 77:13‐24 81:11‐19 82:2‐13 82:15‐15 82:20‐20 83:12‐19 84:7‐85:5
27:25‐28:10 R; 142:18‐22 R; 145:9‐18 R; 146:1‐3 R; 148:21‐24 R; 206:16‐207:20 R; 232:1‐4 R; 235:12‐236:7 R; 238:1‐16 R; 239:4‐19 R; 239:22‐240:1 R; 254:24‐255:12 R; 263:7‐20 R; 273:10‐274:5 AA, R; 274:16‐19 AA, R; 275:16‐19 R; 275:21‐276:2 R; 276:9‐25 R; 277:3‐ 8 R; 286:23‐287:5 R; 302:20‐304:17 R; 311:19‐312:13 R; 313:1‐314:1 R; 314:17‐315:8 R; 316:24‐318:25 AA, R;
6:13‐24; 19:1‐6; 59:15‐18; 82:14; 118:22‐119:22; 155:23‐156:6; 156:8‐157:5; 183:9‐184:15; 201:18‐25; 210:3‐5; 212:12; 212:14; 220:20‐24; 221:5‐222:4; 222:5‐223:16; 231:16; 238:17‐18; 239:20; 265:4‐5; 280:8‐16; 288:19; 319:7‐320:12;
Defendants’ Objections to Plaintiffs: 6:13‐24 IMP 118:22‐119:22 IMP 155:23‐157:5 IMP 201:18‐25 IMP 210:3‐5 IMP, R 212:12 IMP, R 212:14 IMP, R 220:20‐223:16 IMP 231:16 IMP 239:20 IMP, R 238:17‐18 IMP, R 280:8‐16 IMP 288:19 IMP, R 319:7‐320:12 IMP
Defendants’ Rebuttals to Plaintiffs: 7:1‐5
Page 011 of 014
Case 1:16-cv-21199-CMA Document 325-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 06/27/2017 Page 11 of 14
Defendants’ Designations
Plaintiffs’ Objections
Plaintiffs’ Counter
Designations
Third Party Objections
Third Party Counter
Designations
Defendants’ Objections
Defendants’ Rebuttals
Plaintiffs’ Objections
Third Party Objections
Court’s Ruling
87:4‐10 88:3‐11 88:22‐89:5 89:8‐10 89:14‐90:18 94:18‐96:2 97:3‐23 98:24‐99:17 100:11‐16 100:18‐23 101:5‐15 102:21‐103:22 105:2‐5 105:8‐18 107:13‐25 113:11‐114:7 115:6‐19 116:1‐18 117:1‐118:21 120:1‐3 122:4‐15 127:6‐9 128:16‐22 129:8‐24 130:1‐16 132:7‐133:19 134:24‐135:4 135:21‐136:23 138:19‐139:11 142:18‐22 145:9‐18 146:1‐3 146:10‐147:11 147:25‐148:24 149:3‐12 150:22‐151:7 151:20‐152:13 153:10‐13 154:2‐18 159:11‐25 160:1‐9
Page 012 of 014
Case 1:16-cv-21199-CMA Document 325-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 06/27/2017 Page 12 of 14
Defendants’ Designations
Plaintiffs’ Objections
Plaintiffs’ Counter
Designations
Third Party Objections
Third Party Counter
Designations
Defendants’ Objections
Defendants’ Rebuttals
Plaintiffs’ Objections
Third Party Objections
Court’s Ruling
160:11‐23 160:24‐162:16 172:18‐22 176:6‐177:23 180:11‐181:7 182:14‐19 188:25‐191:19 193:10‐14 193:20‐194:9 195:3‐196:2 196:13‐197:13 198:23‐201:4 201:6‐17 206:16‐207:20 207:24‐208:14 209:1‐210:2 210:6‐21 210:22‐212:11 212:13‐13 212:15‐19 213:13‐24 215:24‐217:12 219:20‐220:10 220:16‐19 223:20‐224:13 224:19‐225:13 226:3‐7 227:11‐19 230:22‐231:15 231:18‐232:4 233:18‐24 235:1‐3 235:12‐236:7 238:1‐16 239:4‐19 239:22‐240:1 240:14‐18 240:23‐241:5 242:4‐10 242:18‐243:2 243:10‐25
Page 013 of 014
Case 1:16-cv-21199-CMA Document 325-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 06/27/2017 Page 13 of 14
Defendants’ Designations
Plaintiffs’ Objections
Plaintiffs’ Counter
Designations
Third Party Objections
Third Party Counter
Designations
Defendants’ Objections
Defendants’ Rebuttals
Plaintiffs’ Objections
Third Party Objections
Court’s Ruling
244:9‐21 246:20‐248:8 254:24‐255:12 261:17‐262:16 263:7‐20 264:5‐265:3 265:6‐15 265:17‐266:25 271:22‐272:10 272:22‐273:8 273:10‐274:5 274:16‐19 275:5‐19 275:21‐276:2 276:9‐25 277:3‐8 277:10‐17 281:22‐282:1 283:8‐17 284:14‐25 286:23‐287:5 287:7‐14 288:1‐8 288:10‐18 290:20‐292:12 292:14‐294:10 296:8‐297:19 300:15‐301:16 302:4‐12 302:20‐304:17 305:10‐13 311:19‐312:13 313:1‐314:1 314:17‐315:8 316:24‐318:25 322:1‐20 232:1‐20
Page 014 of 014
Case 1:16-cv-21199-CMA Document 325-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 06/27/2017 Page 14 of 14