8/2/2019 Decision Directing Oil and Gas Lease Force Majeure Case to go to Federal Arbitration in Alexander et al. vs. Chesap

1/19

YGL[IK Q[@[IQ KLQ[]LA[ AFY][GF][EI]G KLQ[]LA[ FB GIT \F]C. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

@]JIGI @JIU@GKI]3 NLAE@IJ

@JIU@GKI]3 D@]\ @JJIG3 N@]QAE@@JJIG3 @G[EFG\ @JRI]G@_3 OIGGLBI]@JRI]G@_3 B]@GC @NM]FQI3 IJL_@MI[E@NM]FQI3 E@]FJK M@][_3 IJLQ@MI[EM@][_3 O@NIQ MIE]N@G3 KF]IIGMIE]N@G3 IKT@]K MIGGI[[3 DJF]L@MIGGI[[3 @GG MJFKDI[[3 N@[[ MFDK@G3OF@GGI MFDK@G3 ]LAE@]K M]@Y[LD@N3N@]L@ M]@Y[LD@N3 O@NIQ M]FTG `q[}yq{ii fb {ei M}ftg B`nlj| [}yq{3MI]G@KI[[I M]FTG `q [}yq{ii fb {ei

M}ftg B`nlj| [}yq{3 L]IGI MYKGI\3NLAE@IJ MYLGLQCLQ3 N@]LC@\ MYLGLQCLQ3[LNF[E\ MY]GI[[3 G@GA\ MY]GI[[3CLNMI]J\ @' MY]]LQ3 [EFN@Q P'A@]XIG[I]3 KL@GI E' A@]XIG[I]3OYKL[E A@[JLG3 Q[IXEIG A@[JLG3 M]IGK@A@[JLG3 OYQ[LG AJ@]C3 OFG AJ@]C3 K@GIAJ@]C3 OIBB]I\ AFJIN@G3 M]IGK@AFJIN@G3 O@NIQ AFJJLGQ3 OYKL[EAFJJLGQ3 D@\JF]K AFG]@K `q ` [}yq{ii fb{ei Afg}`k Jlrlgd [}yq{3 [I]]\ AFG]@K `q `[}yq{ii fb {ei Afg}`k Jlrlgd [}yq{3 TLJJL@N I'AF]QFG* O]3 OYKL[E @' AF]QFG3 O@NIQ R'A]@LG* O]'3 NLAEIJJI N' A]@LG3 Q[IRIGA]FQQIG3 NLAE@IJ K$@JFLQLF3 M]\QFGK@RLQ3 ]FQI K@RLQ3 N@]C KINI[]FQ3

@JRLG KINLGD3 TLJJL@N F' ILAEEF]G3KF]F[E\ I' ILAEEF]G3 CIRLG [' IR@GIC3M]IGK@ N' IR@GIC3 OFQIXE N'B@M]ID@Q3 OYKL[E @' B@M]ID@Q3 ]FMI][B@]GE@N3 J@]]\ BI]DYQFG3 KIMF]@EBI]DYQFG3 M@]M@]@ B]IAEI[[I3 C@]IGJ' D@]]L[\3 X@YJ I' D]IIG3 M@]M@]@ I'D]IIG3 ]LAE@]K DYNMJI3 XIK]FDY[LI]]I_3 ]YQQIJJ @' E@NLJ[FG3D]@AI @' E@NLJ[FG3 JLGK@ E@NNFGK3OFEG N' E@GQIG3 C@[E\ J' E@GQIG3]F\LAI @GG E@]BF]K3 INN@E@]QE.E@]GI]3 O@NIQ E@]_LGQCL3Q@GK]@ E@]_LGQCL3 O@NIQ ELKFAC3

A`qi 1?00.ar.88185.KGE.@[M Kfaynig{ =; Bljik 81&=8&0= X`di 0 fb 0

8/2/2019 Decision Directing Oil and Gas Lease Force Majeure Case to go to Federal Arbitration in Alexander et al. vs. Chesap

2/19

XI[I] ELKFAC3 DIF]DI ELKFAC3 @JJIGEFXCLGQ3 N@]\ [@][@GL@G3 CIG[EFTIJJ3 ILJIIG EFTIJJ3 D@]\ EYKFAC3]FMLG EYKFAC3 ]F\ EYE[@3 N@]D@]I[EYE[@3 IJL_@MI[E O' EYG[3 K@JI

O@ACQFG3 X@[]LAL@ @' O@ACQFG3 M]\AI O'O@ACQFG3 NLAEIJJI OIGCLGQ.X@]@Q[@G3NLAE@IJ OF\AI3 C@[EJIIG OF\AI3GF]N@ OF\AI3 N@YKI CJFQQGI] `q[}yq{ii fb {ei N`yki Cjfqqgi} ]irfa`mji[}yq{3 ]FMI][ T' CJFQQGI]3 C@[EJIIGCJFQQGI]3 Q[IXEIG O' CN@G3 Q[IXEIGCN@G* LL3 DJF]L@ A' CG@XX3 E@]FJKCG@XX3 G@GA\ CFM\J@]_3 T@J[I]CFM\J@]_3 E@]FJK CFQ[I]3 OF@GCFQ[I]3 Q[IXEIG O' CY[GI\* O]'3 EIG]\

CTL@[CFTQCL3 JMC X]FXI][LIQ* LGA'3A@[E\ J@GGLGD3 NLAE@IJ J@GGLGD3@G[EFG\ JLXC@3 GI[[LI JLXC@3 KIGLQI@]N@DGF3 [FGL K@MJ@G3 ]FMI][ ]'JF]K3 J@T]IGAI ]' N@LI]3 JLGI[[IN@]QAE@JJ3 TLJJL@N N@]QAE@JJ3 QAF[[NAPYIIG3 K@RI NFJ\GI@YU3 OYJLINFGIJJ3 N@[[EIT NFGIJJ3 @JIU NYIEJ3

@GG N@]LI NYIEJ3 KIM]@E NYQC@3 @GL[@G@MI]3 GIT@]C R@JJI\ DFJB AJYM* LGA'3

@G[EFG\ N' GLI[F3 @G[EFG\ N' GLI[F* LLL3OFQIXE GLI[F3 OF\AI GLI[F3 GLAFJIGLI[F3 [EFN@Q O' FRIG3 KL@GGI O' X@LDI3CIRLG A' X@LDI3 I@]J X@YDE3 D@JIX@YDE3 ]L[@ XI@AFAC3 AE@]JIQXI@]Q@JJ3 ]Y[E IJJIG XI@]Q@JJ3NLAE@IJ XI]]\3 G@GA\ XI]]\3 Q@U[FGB]@GCJLG `q [}yq{ii fb {ei B}`gcjlg T' `gkQyz`ggi B' Q`u{fg B`nlj| [}yq{ k`{ikGfrinmi} 2* =88=3 J@]]\ I' XI[I]QFG3]IMIAA@ XI[I]QFG bf}ni}j| cgftg `q]IMIAA@ Q[]II[I]3 B]@GAIQ XELJJI\3O@QFG XLXEI]3 KF]F[E\ N@I ]@XX3M]IGK@ ]EFKIQ3 KFYDJ@Q ]EFKIQ3JYALJJI ]EFKIQ3 N@]D@]I[ N']LAE@]KQ `q ` [}yq{ii bf} {ei ]lae`}kqB`nlj| [}yq{3 ]@\NFGK ]' ]LAE@]KQ `q `[}yq{ii bf} {ei ]lae`}kq B`nlj| [}yq{3 JIJ@GKI' ]LKI] `q ` [}yq{ii fb {ei Jij`gk ]lki} `gk

. = .

A`qi 1?00.ar.88185.KGE.@[M Kfaynig{ =; Bljik 81&=8&0= X`di = fb 0

8/2/2019 Decision Directing Oil and Gas Lease Force Majeure Case to go to Federal Arbitration in Alexander et al. vs. Chesap

3/19

N`}of}li R' ]lki} Kiaj`}`{lfg `gk [}yq{3N@]OF]LI R' ]LKI] `q ` [}yq{ii fb {eiJij`gk ]lki} `gk N`}of}li R' ]lki} Kiaj`}`{lfg`gk [}yq{3 M]L@G ]LIAEI]Q3 L]IGI]LIAEI]Q3 @GK]IT O' ]FMLGQFG3

@][EY] T' ]FMLGQFG `q [}yq{ii fb {ei@}{ey} T' ]fmlgqfg Jlrlgd [}yq{ k`{ik 9&05&823M]YAI ]' ]FMLGQFG `q [}yq{ii fb {ei M}yai]' ]fmlgqfg Jlrlgd [}yq{ k`{ik 9&=4&823Q[IRIG I' ]FMLGQFG3 D@]\ ]FACTIJJ3OI@GLGI ]FACTIJJ3 D@]\ I' ]F_IJJI3AEI]\J Q@AAF bf}ni}j| cgftg `q AEI]\JLGQLGD@3 EIJIG Q@AAF3 OFEG Q@AAF3NLCI Q@AAF3 QYQ@G O' Q@YGKI]Q3 D@]\QAEFFGFRI]3 EIJIG QAEFFGFRI]3GLAC QAEFFGFRI]3 QY_@GGI \@GY__L3

C@]IG @' AFYJ[I]3 QYQ@G GLAEFJQFG3DJIGG QAF[[3 K@RLK QE@BI]3 Q[IXEIGQE@BI]3 OF@G QE@RI]3 ]@\ QE@RI]3

@JF\QYLQ I' QELXN@G3 X@[]LAL@ QELXN@G3Q[IXEIG QELXN@G3 R@JI]LI O' QELXN@G3CIGGI[E T' QEF][3 ]YQQIJJ QEFYJ[IQ3AE@K QEFTI]Q3 OYKL[E QEFTI]Q3 CIRLGQJ@YDE[I]3 KFYDJ@Q QX@]CQ3O@APYIJLGI QX@]CQ3 CIGGI[E

@JIU@GKI] `q Ftgi}3 RI]G@ @JIU@GKI]`q Ftgi}3 M]L@G A@LG3 JYALGK@ E@GMY]\`q @knlglq{}`{f} fb {ei Iq{`{i fb ]fmi}{E`gmy}|3 Q[' GLAC$Q BF]IQ[* JJA3 K@RLKQ[@AC `q xy}ae`qi} fb X}fxi}{| ay}}ig{j|ftgik m| CIGGI[E " RI]G@ @JIU@GKI]3]FQI Q[@AC `q xy}ae`qi} fb x}fxi}{|ay}}ig{j| ftgik m| CIGGI[E " RI]G@

@JIU@GKI]3 MIGO@NLG Q[I]GMI]D3 KIMQ[FYDE[FG3 [LN Q[FYDE[FG3 M]L@GQ[FY[3 OFQIXE B' Q[FY[3 N@]AL@ Q[FY[3AJ@YKI Q[]LBI3 KL@GI Q[]LBI3 @GG@N@]LI QYJJLR@G3 J@Y]IGAI QYJJLR@G3

@GG@ Q_@G[F3 @]X@K Q_@G[F3 ]LAE@]K[@\JF]3 RI]K@ [@\JF]3 KF]@ I'[]YIQK@LJ3 OIQQI []YIQK@LJ* O]'3 OFEG[]YIQK@LJ3 ]@JXE []YIQK@LJ3J@Y]IGAI [Y]GI]3 OF@G RLJJIAAF3OFQIXE RLJJIAAF3 K@GLIJ ]' RFYDE3JLGK@ ]' RFYDE3 E@]FJK R]@MIJ `jqf

. 1 .

A`qi 1?00.ar.88185.KGE.@[M Kfaynig{ =; Bljik 81&=8&0= X`di 1 fb 0

8/2/2019 Decision Directing Oil and Gas Lease Force Majeure Case to go to Federal Arbitration in Alexander et al. vs. Chesap

4/19

cgftg `q E@]FJK R@]MIJ3 C@]IG @YGI3]@JXE T@JCI]3 M]L@G T@GAC3 DI]@JKT@GAC3 DJIGG T@GAC3 O@APYIJLGIT@GAC3 CIRLG T@GAC3 [@N@]@ T@GAC3T@GK@ T@GAC3 DI]@JK TIIK3 N@][LG@

TIIK3 N@]LFG TILQQI3 DIF]DL@TIQ[D@[I3 ]FDI] TIQ[D@[I3 M@]M@]@TLJJI[[3 ]LAE@]K TLJJI[[3 ]FMI][ J'TFFKMY]G3 K@GLIJ TFFK]YBB3 \RFGGITFFK]YBB3 KFG@JK _LNNI]3 N@]\_LNNI]3 M]L@G _F]G3 OI]]LGI _F]G3

@K@N Q' MY]AE* O]' `q Af.[}yq{ii fb {eiMy}ae* O}' B`nlj| [}yq{3 DI][]YKI Q' MY]AE`q Af.[}yq{ii fb {ei My}ae* O}' B`nlj| [}yq{3A@]J X' KI\F3 KL@GI KI\F3 K@GLIJ X'BJ@G@D@G3 J@Y]LI D@GFYGD3 Q[IRIG

D@GFYGD3 O@AC D]FM3 KFG@JK J' XI]]\lgklrlky`jj| `gk `q Af.[}yq{ii fb {ei Q`gk}` J'Xi}}| ]irfa`mji Jlrlgd [}yq{3 Q@GK]@ J'XI]]\ lgklrlky`jj| `gk `q Af.[}yq{ii fb {eiQ`gk}` J' Xi}}| ]irfa`mji Jlrlgd [}yq{3]LAE@]K @' ]LKDIT@\* O]'3 OF\AI @'TEL[I3 XI[I] A' TEL[I3 CIGGI[EEI]_J.MI[_3 `gk JFYLQI EI]_J.MI[_*

Xj`lg{lbbq*

.r.1?00AR185

AEIQ@XI@CI @XX@J@AEL@* JJA `gkQ[@[FLJE\K]F YQ@ FGQEF]IX]FXI][LIQ* LGA'*

Kibigk`g{q'. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

@XXI@]@GAIQ? FB AFYGQIJ?

AFYDEJLG " DI]E@][* JJX XI[I] E' MFYN@G* IQP'@{{f}gi|q bf} Xj`lg{lbbq ]FMI][ ]' OFGIQ* IQP'0< Aeig`gdf Q{}ii{X'F' Mfu =81