debate: fevar is the best option for aortic neck < 9mm ... · verhagen veith 2015 - engage. mt...

18
MT 2016 DEBATE: FEVAR is the best option for aortic neck < 9mm Against Matt Thompson St Georges Vascular Institute, London, UK

Upload: others

Post on 24-Jul-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: DEBATE: FEVAR is the best option for aortic neck < 9mm ... · Verhagen Veith 2015 - ENGAGE. MT 2016 Bifurcated Endografts and Endoanchors 4y FU. MT 2016 EVAR and Parallel Grafts for

MT 2016

DEBATE: FEVAR is the best option for aortic neck < 9mm

Against

Matt Thompson

St Georges Vascular Institute, London, UK

Page 2: DEBATE: FEVAR is the best option for aortic neck < 9mm ... · Verhagen Veith 2015 - ENGAGE. MT 2016 Bifurcated Endografts and Endoanchors 4y FU. MT 2016 EVAR and Parallel Grafts for

MT 2016

Consultancy fees, Speakers bureau, Research funding

Medtronic

Endologix

Financial Disclosure Slide

Page 3: DEBATE: FEVAR is the best option for aortic neck < 9mm ... · Verhagen Veith 2015 - ENGAGE. MT 2016 Bifurcated Endografts and Endoanchors 4y FU. MT 2016 EVAR and Parallel Grafts for

MT 2016

DEBATE: FEVAR is the best option for aortic neck < 9mm

AGAINST

Page 4: DEBATE: FEVAR is the best option for aortic neck < 9mm ... · Verhagen Veith 2015 - ENGAGE. MT 2016 Bifurcated Endografts and Endoanchors 4y FU. MT 2016 EVAR and Parallel Grafts for

MT 2016

DEBATE: FEVAR is the best option for aortic neck < 9mm

AGAINST

FEVR is ONE option for aortic neck < 9mm

Page 5: DEBATE: FEVAR is the best option for aortic neck < 9mm ... · Verhagen Veith 2015 - ENGAGE. MT 2016 Bifurcated Endografts and Endoanchors 4y FU. MT 2016 EVAR and Parallel Grafts for

MT 2016

Mode of repair

Technical feasibility

Peri-operative outcome

Durability

Life expectancy

Treatment for Short Neck AAA – It’s Complicated

Page 6: DEBATE: FEVAR is the best option for aortic neck < 9mm ... · Verhagen Veith 2015 - ENGAGE. MT 2016 Bifurcated Endografts and Endoanchors 4y FU. MT 2016 EVAR and Parallel Grafts for

MT 2016

Page 7: DEBATE: FEVAR is the best option for aortic neck < 9mm ... · Verhagen Veith 2015 - ENGAGE. MT 2016 Bifurcated Endografts and Endoanchors 4y FU. MT 2016 EVAR and Parallel Grafts for

MT 2016

Is There a Standard AAA with 9mm Neck ???

Page 8: DEBATE: FEVAR is the best option for aortic neck < 9mm ... · Verhagen Veith 2015 - ENGAGE. MT 2016 Bifurcated Endografts and Endoanchors 4y FU. MT 2016 EVAR and Parallel Grafts for

MT 2016

One size does not fit all

Need to tailor the

endovascular repair to

the clinical situation and

aortic morphology

Page 9: DEBATE: FEVAR is the best option for aortic neck < 9mm ... · Verhagen Veith 2015 - ENGAGE. MT 2016 Bifurcated Endografts and Endoanchors 4y FU. MT 2016 EVAR and Parallel Grafts for

MT 2016

Custom Made Fenestrated Grafts

Good treatment for many

Technically challenging – good success

Large profile

Significant “turn down” rate

(30%+)(manufacturing constraints,

morphology)

Delay to treatment – 3 months

Type 1 endoleak 4.6%

Banno et al JVS 2014; 60: 31

Globalstar Circ 2012; 125: 2707

Page 10: DEBATE: FEVAR is the best option for aortic neck < 9mm ... · Verhagen Veith 2015 - ENGAGE. MT 2016 Bifurcated Endografts and Endoanchors 4y FU. MT 2016 EVAR and Parallel Grafts for

MT 2016

Bifurcated endovascular graft

Stapled prosthesis

CHEVAR

CHEVAS

Options Apart From Fenestrated Grafts……

Page 11: DEBATE: FEVAR is the best option for aortic neck < 9mm ... · Verhagen Veith 2015 - ENGAGE. MT 2016 Bifurcated Endografts and Endoanchors 4y FU. MT 2016 EVAR and Parallel Grafts for

MT 2016

Bifurcated Endografts

4y FU

Verhagen Veith 2015 - ENGAGE

Page 12: DEBATE: FEVAR is the best option for aortic neck < 9mm ... · Verhagen Veith 2015 - ENGAGE. MT 2016 Bifurcated Endografts and Endoanchors 4y FU. MT 2016 EVAR and Parallel Grafts for

MT 2016

Bifurcated Endografts and Endoanchors

4y FU

Page 13: DEBATE: FEVAR is the best option for aortic neck < 9mm ... · Verhagen Veith 2015 - ENGAGE. MT 2016 Bifurcated Endografts and Endoanchors 4y FU. MT 2016 EVAR and Parallel Grafts for

MT 2016

EVAR and Parallel Grafts for Juxta-Renal AAA

Near universal applicability – no wait

Suited to angulated aorta

Results better than expected – durability?

Issue is seal – gutters / endoleaks

Pericles Registry – Type 1 2.9%

Donas et al Ann Surg 2015; 262: 546

Page 14: DEBATE: FEVAR is the best option for aortic neck < 9mm ... · Verhagen Veith 2015 - ENGAGE. MT 2016 Bifurcated Endografts and Endoanchors 4y FU. MT 2016 EVAR and Parallel Grafts for

MT 2016

EVAS and Parallel Grafts

Page 15: DEBATE: FEVAR is the best option for aortic neck < 9mm ... · Verhagen Veith 2015 - ENGAGE. MT 2016 Bifurcated Endografts and Endoanchors 4y FU. MT 2016 EVAR and Parallel Grafts for

MT 2016

Is fEVAR the Best Option in Short Neck AAA

Good option if………….

Minimal aortic angulation

Single – non diseased visceral vessels

Large caliber iliacs

Need long term durability

Wait 3 months for treatment

Page 16: DEBATE: FEVAR is the best option for aortic neck < 9mm ... · Verhagen Veith 2015 - ENGAGE. MT 2016 Bifurcated Endografts and Endoanchors 4y FU. MT 2016 EVAR and Parallel Grafts for

MT 2016

Choose Wisely – Many Different Options !!!!

Page 17: DEBATE: FEVAR is the best option for aortic neck < 9mm ... · Verhagen Veith 2015 - ENGAGE. MT 2016 Bifurcated Endografts and Endoanchors 4y FU. MT 2016 EVAR and Parallel Grafts for

MT 2016

DEBATE: FEVAR is the best option for aortic neck < 9mm

AGAINST

FEVR is ONE option for aortic neck < 9mm

Page 18: DEBATE: FEVAR is the best option for aortic neck < 9mm ... · Verhagen Veith 2015 - ENGAGE. MT 2016 Bifurcated Endografts and Endoanchors 4y FU. MT 2016 EVAR and Parallel Grafts for

MT 2016

DEBATE: FEVAR is the best option for aortic neck < 9mm

Against

Matt Thompson

St Georges Vascular Institute, London, UK