deanna hoelscher, ph.d, r.d., l.d. - "eat your vegetables! benefits of healthy eating in...
TRANSCRIPT
Eat Your Vegetables! Healthy Eating in Youth
Deanna M. Hoelscher, PhD, RD, LDYouth-Nex Conference
October 10, 2013
• Why do children need a healthy diet?
• What are the recommendations for a healthy diet in youth?
• What do current youth diets look like?
• What can we do to improve them?
Presentation
Definitions
• Nutrition is the science of food, the nutrients, and other substances within food; their action, interaction, & balance in relation to health & disease; and the processes by which the organism ingests, absorbs, transports, uses & excretes food substances.Guthrie & Picciano, 1995
• Nutrition is needed for – Energy– Maintenance of biologic processes– Growth & development
(infants/children/adolescents)
• Nutrients include macronutrients (lipid, protein, carbohydrate), water, vitamins, minerals
• Critical determinant of several of the major causes of death & disability– CVD, Cancer, Type 2 Diabetes,
Obesity
• Modifiable behavior
• “Universal & indispensable human exposure” Kumanyika, 2000
Why is Dietary Intake Important?
Recommendations for Healthy Diets
• U.S. Dietary Guidelines (revised in 2015)• Dietary Reference Intakes• Healthy People 2020 Goals
– Example: http://www.healthypeople.gov/2020/topicsobjectives2020/objectiveslist.aspx?topicId=29
• Leading Health Indicators– Health Indicators Warehouse:
http://www.healthindicators.gov/
• Others
Dietary Issues for Children
• Obesity (HFSS)– Sugary Beverages– Snack consumption
• Fruit and vegetable consumption• Calcium consumption• Meal patterns/timing of foods
Weight Gain for Children at the 95th Percentile from Age 6.5 to 18.5
6 to 7 7 to 8 8 to 9 9 to 10 10 to 11 11 to 12 12 to 13 13 to 14 14 to 15 15 to 16 16 to 17 17 to 1802468
1012141618
BoysGirls
Age in Years
Wei
gh
t D
iffe
ren
ce (
lb)
Source: CDC weight charts, Butte & Ellis, 2003 OW = overweight, N = normal wt
OW/OW
N/OW
N/N
Trends in Weight Status among US Adolescents
Source: Iannotti RJ & Wang J. Trends in physical activity, sedentary behavior, diet, and BMI among US adolescents, 2001-2009. Pediatrics.2013;132(4):606-614
4th grade 8th grade 11th grade0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
25.6
18.8
14.5
23.5
17.5 17.3
23.823
21.6
18 18.4 18.4
2000-02 2004-05 2009-11
Children in Texas Have High Rates of Obesity
Healthy People 2020 Goal, 14.5%
Obesity is > 95th Percentile for BMI by Age/Sex
Sources: Hoelscher et al., 2004; Hoelscher et al., SPAN; Ogden et al., 2012
2001 2005 20093.6
3.8
4
4.2
4.4
4.6
4.8
5
4.29
4.71
4.91
4.31
4.464.61
4.7
4.46
4.1
4.85
4.364.18
Eat fruits (1 never-7>once/day)Eat vegetables (1 never-7>once/day)Eat sweets (1 never-7>once/day)Drink soft drinks (1 never-7>once/day)
Trends in consumption of fruits, vegetables, sweets and sweetened soft drinks
Source: Iannotti RJ & Wang J. Trends in physical activity, sedentary behavior, diet, and BMI among US adolescents, 2001-2009. Pediatrics.2013;132(4):606-614
Trends in Student Food Choices by Grade, SPAN 2000-2002
Question: Yesterday, did you eat.. Grade
4th 1
8th 1.97 (1.45;2.69) 0.000 *
11th2.16 (1.66;2.81) 0.026 †
4th
1
8th 0.88 (0.64;1.21) 0.465 *
11th1.14 (0.81;1.60) 0.162 †
4th 1
8th 1.12 (0.76;1.64) 0.032 *
11th1.58 (1.04;2.41) 0.514 †
4th 1
8th 0.67 (0.52;.85) 0.036 *
11th0.73 (0.55;.98) 0.058 †
4th 1
8th 2.49 (1.75;2.73) 0.001 *
11th1.86 (1.31;2.65) 0.000 †
4th 1
8th 0.45 (0.37;0.55) 0.000 *
11th0.27 (0.21;0.35) 0.113 †
Gravy (either on a food or by itself)?
Peanuts or peanut butter?
Cheese by itself or on your food?
Drink any kind of milk?
ORadj p-value
Hamburger meat, hot dogs, sausage (chorizo), steak, bacon, or ribs?
Any fried meat with a crust, like fried chicken, chicken nuggets, chicken fried steak, fried pork chops, or fried fish?
+ Adjusted odds ratio by gender, race/ethnicity and body mass index; Source: Perez et al., 2007
Trends in Student Food Choices by Grade, SPAN, 2000-2002
+ Adjusted odds ratio by gender, race/ethnicity and body mass index; Source: Perez et al., 2007
Trends in Student Food Choices by Grade, SPAN, 2000-2002
Question: Yesterday did you eat.. Grade
4th 1
8th 1.26 (0.96;1.67) 0.030 *
11th1.48 (1.04;2.09) 0.738 †
4th 1
8th 0.41 (0.32;0.53) 0.000 *
11th0.33 (0.23;0.48) 0.007 †
4th 1
8th 0.73 (0.52;1.02) 0.088 *
11th0.68 (0.43;1.06) 0.467 †
4th 1
8th 0.88 (0.73;1.08) 0.000 *
11th0.54 (0.40;0.72) 0.049 †
4th 1
8th 1.87 (1.46;2.40) 0.000 *
11th1.92 (1.49;2.48) 0.007 †
4th 1
8th 1.37 (0.98;1.91) 0.242 *
11th1.17 (0.91;1.51) 0.111 †
ORadj p-value
Beans such as pinto beans, baked beans, kidney beans, refried beans or pork and beans?
Fruit?
Drink fruit juice?
A frozen dessert?
Sweet rolls, doughnuts, cookies, brownies, pies, or cake?
Any chocolate candy?
+ Adjusted odds ratio by gender, race/ethnicity and body mass index; Source: Perez et al., 2007
• 2 recent studies:– Ebbeling et al., 2012, NEJM
• RCT with 224 overweight/obese adolescents• Intervention was displacement of SSB with non-caloric
beverages, MI• At Year 1 and Year 2, SSB, E in Intervention group• Change in BMI at 1 year, but not 2 years
– Did see changes in Hispanic adolescents at 1 and 2 years
– deRuyter et al., 2012, NEJM• 18 month RCT with 641 normal weight 4-11 year olds• 8 oz of SSB or artificially sweetened beverage• Mean BMI z-score by 0.02 SD units in Intervention
compared to 0.15 SD in control• Weight gain, fat mass significantly less
SSB Consumption in Children and Overweight/Obesity
Availability Mean ± SD MaxVegetable, no potato 12.8 ± 3.8 21Fruit 13.0 ± 4.4 27
Accessibility Mean ± SD MaxVegetable, no potato 1.3 ± 0.9 3Fruit 2.8 ± 0.9 4
Vegetables & fruit in the home
Source: Chen et al., Lunch is in the Bag, unpublished data
Vegetables & fruit in lunches
Top 5 veg. items = 51% of veg. items packed
Carrots (29%)Tomato sauce (13%)Raw tomatoes (8%)
Cucumber (5%)Corn (4%)
Top 5 fruit items = 54% of fruit items packed
Grapes (12%)Applesauce (12%)Strawberries (11%)
Apples (10%)100% juice (9%)
Source: Chen et al., Lunch is in the Bag, unpublished data
Grain ratio: home vs. lunch
0.71
0.29
Home
0.30
0.70
Lunches (overall)
WG only: 22% (n=127) of homes WG only: 10% (n=55) of lunches
Source: Chen et al., Lunch is in the Bag, unpublished data
050
100150200250300350400450
9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19
Age in Years
Tota
l bo
dy b
on
e g
ain
cm
/yr
boys
Bailey, D.A., et al. J. Bone Min. Res. 14:711-715, 1999
girls
Total Body Bone Mineral Content Velocity Curves in Peripubertal Boys and Girls
0
2
4
6
8
10
% in
cre
ase/
year
Lee '94 Lee '95 Bonjour J ohnson Dibba Cadogan
Placebo Ca Supplement
Calcium Supplementation during Adolescence Increases BMD
*p<0.05 Adapted from Weaver, 2002
**
*
*
Trends in Student Meal Consumption by Grade, SPAN, 2000-2002Question: Yesterday, did you... Grade
4th 1
8th 1.05 (0.80;1.36) 0.795 *
11th 1.05 (0.74;1.49) 0.859 †
4th 1
8th 1.13 (0.79;1.61) 0.296 *
11th 1.18 (0.87;1.60) 0.801 †
4th 1
8th 1.61 (1.24;2.11) 0.001 *
11th 2.07 (1.37;3.12) 0.286 †
4th 1
8th 1.01 (0.77;1.33) 0.287 *
11th 0.88 (0.68;1.12) 0.455 †
Have a snack?
Take a vitamin pill?
ORadj p-value
Eat breakfast?
Have more than one meal?
+ Adjusted odds ratio by gender, race/ethnicity and body mass index; Source: Perez et al., 2007
Our Environment is ‘Obesogenic”
20022005
How Much Nutrition Education is Enough?
• Briggs, M., et. al, (2010). Position of the American Dietetic Association, School Nutrition Association, and Society for Nutrition Education: comprehensive school nutrition services. Journal of nutrition education and behavior, 42(6), 360-71. Society for Nutrition Education.
• Kann, L., et. al, (2007). Health Education: Results from the School Health Policies and Programs Study 2006. The Journal of school health, 77(8), 408-34. doi:10.1111/j.1746-1561.2007.00228.
7600 food ads/year153 F&N/ year
WHOA Highest fat and sugar
SLOW Higher in fat and sugar, More processed foods
GO Lowest in fat, no added sugar, WG, V, F, lean meats
GO-SLOW-WHOA
• Nutritional recommendations for school-aged children are relatively well-established; less so for preschool children– Issues: sugary beverages, snacks, F & V, calcium
• Children do not consume adequate diets: what can we do to ensure this?– Behaviorally based nutrition education– Parenting practices– Environmental changes (marketing)
• New directions– Do we need ‘kid foods’?– How can we use natural biologic variations in appetite
to our advantage?– Decreasing food availability – periods of ‘not eating’
Final Thoughts
The test of the morality of a society is what it does for its children.
Dietrich Bonhoeffer
facebook.com/msdcenter
@msdcenter
msdcenter.blogspot.com
THANK YOU
Deanna M. Hoelscher, PhD, RD, [email protected]
UTHealth | The University of Texas Health Science Center at Houston
School of Public Health Austin Regional CampusMichael & Susan Dell Center for Healthy Living1616 Guadalupe | Suite 6.300 | Austin, TX 78701www.msdcenter.orgTwitter: @DeannaHoelscher @DrSteveKelder
Acknowledgements: Deanna M. Hoelscher, PhD; Steven H. Kelder, PhD, Andrew
Springer, DrPH; Guy Parcel, PhD; Cheryl Perry, PhD; Sandra Evans, PhD; Nalini
Ranjit, PhD; Cristina Barroso, DrPH; Roy Allen, MA; Brooks Ballard, MPH; Courtney
Byrd-Williams, PhD; Sherman Chow, MPH; Megan Conklin, MPH; Peter Cribb, MEd;
Joanne Delk, MS; Lupe Garcia, MS; Pam Greer; Alejandra Gonzalez; Kacey Hanson,
MPH; Tiffni Menendez, MPH; Carolyn Smith; Joey Walker, MPH; Jerri Ward, MA, RD
CATCH Supporters: • National Heart Lung and Blood Institute• Centers for Disease Control and Prevention • Texas Department of State Health Services• Robert Wood Johnson Foundation• Paso del Norte Health Foundation• Houston Endowment• Michael & Susan Dell Foundation• RGK Foundation
Acknowledgements and Supporters
VisionHealthy Children in a Healthy World
Mission To serve as the state, national, and international leader in the promotion of healthy living for children and their families.
Vision & Mission
msdcenter.org
Center Social Media Sites
msdcenter
• A tool to guide children and families toward making healthy food choices
• Overall message: foods can fit into a healthy diet and that a healthy diet consists of
GO foods > SLOW foods > WHOA foods• Provides RDA by age for each of the food
categories:– 4-8 years old– 9-13 years old
Note: The GSW list does not contain combination foods such as sandwiches or pizza
GO – SLOW – WHOA (GSW) List