dated this the 03 rd day of april 2014 before: the...

1

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE

DATED THIS THE 03rd

DAY OF APRIL 2014

BEFORE:

THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ANAND BYRAREDDY

WRIT PETITION Nos.51937-51938 OF 2013 (EDN-EX)

CONNECTED WITH

WRIT PETITION Nos.26338-26364 OF 2013 (EDN-AD)

WRIT PETITION Nos.24702 AND 25191 AND 25192-25478

AND 25829 OF 2013

WRIT PETITION Nos.26124-26128 of 2013 (EDN-AD)


WRIT PETITION Nos.25837-25844/2013 (EDN-AD)


WRIT PETITION Nos. 24610-24674 and 24675 OF 2013 (EDN-

AD)

IN W.P.Nos.51937-51938/2013

BETWEEN:

1. Miss. Srinija Dasari,

Daughter of Sri. D. Ranga Rao,

Aged about 19 years,

2

2. Miss. Patel Mansi Suresh Bhai,

Daughter of Suresh Bhai Patel,


Both are the students studying

in BDA Course in Oxford Dental College,

Bommanahalli, Hosur Road,

Bangalore – 560 068.

…PETITIONERS

( By Shri. Vinod Prasad, Advocate )

AND:

1. Rajiv Gandhi University of

Health Sciences,

4th

‘T’ Block, Jayanagar,

Bangalore -560 011,

Represented by its Registrar.

2. The Oxford Dental College,

Bommanahalli,

Hosur Road,


By its Principal.

3. The State of Karnataka,

By its Secretary, to Health and

Family Welfare (Medical Education

Department) M.S.Building,

Vidhana Soudha,


…RESPONDENTS

(By Shri. N.K.Ramesh, Advocate for Respondent No.1

3

Shri. B. Veerappa, Additional Government Advocate for

Respondent No.3

Respondent No.2 served and unrepresented)

*****

These Writ Petitions filed under Article 226 of the

Constitution of India, praying to direct the first respondent, Rajiv

Gandhi University of Health Sciences to approve the admission of

the petitioners for the BDS course for which they have taken

admission during the academic year 2012-2013 in the second

respondent Oxford Dental College, Bangalore.

IN W.P.Nos.26338-26364/2013

BETWEEN:

1. S.B.Patil Dental College and

Hospital Naubad, Bidar: 585 402,

Represented by its Principal.

2. Mr. Surwase Vijay,

Son of Subhash Rao,

3. Mr. Pokala Akhil,

Son of P. Rajashekhar,

4. Mr. Fathepurkar Aditya,

Son of Avinash,

5. Ms. Haseena T.P,

Daughter of Mammupockr Haji,

6. Ms. QurratulAin Zainab,

Daughter of Khaja Moinuddin Ahmed,

4

7. Ms. Aiman Sidru,

Daughter of Md. Asifuddin,

8. Ms. Raveena Srivastava,

Daughter of Anil Kumar,

9. Ms. Gamini Vijayadurga,

Daughter of G. Nagesh Babu,

10. Ms. K. Lavanya Mahitha,

Daughter of K. Venkat Raman,

11. Ms. Kokkanda Satya Mansha,

Daughter of K. Laxmipathi,

12. Ms. Saradhy Samhitha,

Daughter of S. Pratap Ray,

13. Ms. B. Sayantikar,

Daughter of B.V. Jayaraman,

14. Ms. Sriramla Yamini,

Daughter of Shiman Naragana,

15. Ms. Sumayya Fatema,

Daughter of Mohd. Rafiq Khan,

16. Ms. Pooja Pawar,

Daughter of Dev Singh,

17. Ms. Bethala Swathipriya,

Daughter of Bethala Ramanakumar,

18. Mr. MG Medara Ramakanth,

5

Son of Ramchandraiah,

19. Mr. Mayank Dwivedi,

Son of R.K. Dwivedi,

20. Ms. Boppana Mounica,

Daughter of B. Nageshwar Rao,

21. Ms. Sarangi Mohandas,

Daughter of P.M. Mohandas,

22. Ms. Rajapuram Naya Manusha,

Daughter of R. Sathyanander,

23. Ms. Dara Rani Mrudula,

Daughter of Dara Ratan George,

24. Ms. Vryyatala Priyadarshini,

Daughter of V. Madhusudhan Rao,

25. Mr. Ravipate Ramesh Babu,

Son of R. Venkateshwar Rao,

26. Ms. Shimaila Fatima,

Daughter of Abdul Bari,

27. Singh Supriya,

Daughter of Bhikam Singh,

Petitioners 2 to 27 are all

Aged about 18 years and all are

Students studying in First Year

BDS Course at S.B.Patil Dental

College and Hospital,

Naubad, Bidar – 585 402. …PETITIONERS

6

(By Shri. L.M. Chidanandayya, Advocate)

AND:

1. State of Karnataka

By its Principal Secretary,

Medical Education,

Ministry of Health and Family

Welfare, Vikasa Soudha,


2. The Dental Council of India,

Iwan-E-Galib Marg, Kotla Road,

New Delhi – 110 002,

Represented by its Secretary.

3. Rajiv Gandhi University of Health

Sciences for Karnataka,

4th


Bangalore – 560 041,

Represented by its Registrar. …RESPONDENTS

(By Shri. B. Veerappa, Additional Government Advocate for

Respondent No.1

Shri. N.K. Ramesh, Advocate for Respondent Nos. 2 and 3)

These Writ Petitions filed under Articles 226 and 227 of the

Constitution of India praying to call for the records which

ultimately resulted in passing the impugned communication vide

Annexure-A dated 10.6.2013 passed by the third respondents and

to quash the communication vide Annexure-A dated 10.6.2013

passed by the third respondent disapproving the admissions of

petitioners 2 to 27 for the study of first year BDS Course from the

academic year 2012-2013.

7

IN W.P.Nos. 24702 AND 25191 AND

25192-25478 AND 25829/2013

BETWEEN:

1. D.A. Pandu Memorial R.V. Dental

College [an institution established by

Rastreeya Sikshana Samithi Trust]

No.CA 37, 24th Main,

1st Phase, J.P.Nagar, Bangalore – 560 078,

Represented by its Pricipal,

Dr. M.R. Dinesh,

Son of M.S.Ramshetty,


Resident of Bangalore.

2. Miss. Pamini Vaddavalli,

Venkateswarlu .V,


3. Mr. Huirem Nopur Viyas,

Huirem Nimai Chand Singh,


4. Miss. Ornelya Marissa Fernandes,

Leo Francis Mariano Fernandes,


5. Mr. Ashiq Ajit,

Ajith C Kumar,


6. Miss. Hanan Safiyath Akbar Ali,

P.M. Akbar Ali,

8


7. Miss. Roselent Joseph,

K.J.Joseph,


8. Miss. Namratha Sanchez,

Nelson Christananda,


9. Miss. Thingleiphy Lungleng

Linganung Lungleng,


10. Miss. Akshaya L Reddy,

Laxmi Narayana Reddy B.S.,


11. Miss. Aastha Kamra,

Yogesh Kamra,


12. Miss. Shanta Giri .S,

Daughter of Sarvottam Giri,


13. Mr. Kaushik Raju .M,

Son of Thirumala Raju .M,


Petitioners 2 to 13 are studying in

1st year BDS Course at

D.A. Pandu Memorial

R.V. Dental College,

No.CA 37, 24th Main,

9

1st Phase, J.P.Nagar,


14. Krishnadevaraya College of Dental

Sciences and Hospital,


Represented by its Principal,

Dr. H. Nanda Kumar,

Son of Sri. R. Hanumanthaiah,


Residing at Bangalore.

15. Rituparna Saha,

Bikash Chandra Saha,


16. Khencha Bosai,

Duwang Bosai,


17. Chanum Heankhe,

Heanwang Heankhe,


18. Priyanka .S,

Sunil Kumar Tiwari,


19. Parvati Nair,

N. Pradeep Kumar,


20. Shefali Tripathy,

Sushanta Kumar Tripathy,


10

21. Sravan Kumar,

M. Chandra Shekar,


22. Prasanta Majumder,

Kamalesh Majumder,


23. Polusani Prathik,

P. Madhukar Reddy,


24. Chandrakanth .C,

Chandramohanan Pillai,


25. Manju M.S.,

Manikandan Pillai .T,


26. Lekha Raj .M,

L. Muthuraj,


27. Archana Patil,

Ashok Patil,


28. Aishwarya Jha,

Sri Akhilesh Kr Jha,


29. Khushboo Mishra,

Shambhu Mishra,

11


30. Nikhita Bhalla,

Amitabh Bhalla,


31. Koduri Harshitha Reddy,

K. Ram Mohan Reddy,


32. Namineni Puneetha,

N. Govardhan Babu,


33. Muzamil Nabi,

Hakeem Lh. Nabi,


34. Linthoingambi Devi .N,

N. Tompok Singh,


35. Theertha .M,

Muraleedharan .M,


36. Hema .C,

R. Chandran Unnithan,


37. Amrutha Mary Paulose,

Paulose T.J.,


38. Gladies Thomas,

12

Thomas Chacko,


39. Revathi .D,

Venkata Subba Reddy. D,


40. Radam Rachana,

R. Balakrishna,


41. Reshmi .U,

Ravi P.K.,


42. Tejeswini Ramashetty Amarnath,

R.N. Amarnath,


43. Nafseera N.K.,

Usman C.P.,


44. Rohit,

Jafar Hussain,


45. Megha Mohan,

Mohanan V.K.,


46. Vikas Kumar,

Jitendra Kumar,


13

47. Shanib .T,

Hameed .T,


48. K.B. Arathy,

K.B. Benny,


49. Seemala Jyotsna,

S. Sreerahulu,


50. Vishnu Bose .C,

Chandra Bose A.K.,


51. T.A. Manasa,

T.M. Ashok Kumar,


52. N. Varsha,

P.M. Narayana Swamy,


53. H. Arshada,

R. Hemantraj Savalge,


54. Asha K Joseph,

Aneesh K Joseph,


Petitioners 15 to 54 are studying

In 1st year BDS Course at

Krishnadevaraya College of

14

Dental Sciences and Hospital,


55. Vokkaligara Sangha Dental College and

Hospital, K.R.Road,

V.V. Puram,



Dr. H.C. Usha,

Daughter of N. Nagaraja Reddy,



56. Manasa K.N,

Daughter of K.V. Nanda Kumar,


57. Bhargavi .R,

Daughter of Reddappa K.C,


58. Janet Jose,

Daughter of K.P.Jose,


59. Swetha N.S.,

Daughter of N.P. Sasindran,


60. Anusha .R,

Daughter of Ramanna,


61. Deepika Medhi,

Daughter of Gupta Mani,

15


62. Treasa Richa Roy,

Daughter of Roy Paul,


63. Siddhartha Dhanda,

Son of Mukesh Dhanda,


64. Monica .B,

Daughter of Balakrishna .S,


65. Rakshith M.S.,

Son of Suresh Babu .D,


66. Mouthika Reddy .K,

Daughter of Bhakthavathsala,


67. Nivedhana .S,

Daughter of Shivashankare Gowda,


68. Saijyothi .R,

Daughter of Ramakrishnappa .C,


69. S. Kavya,

Daughter of Sampath Kumar,


70. Dandugudam Manoj Kumar,

16

Son of D. Kanakaiah,


71. Suma M.S. Babu,

Daughter of M.S. Babu,


72. Mah Liqa,

Daughter of K. Mahammod Hussain,


73. Shubhi Gupta,

Daughter of S.S. Gupta,


74. Nikitha .R,

Daughter of D. Ravishankar,


75. Teli Umra,

Daughter of Teli Dutto Camder,


76. Chakraborty Moumita Pradeep,

Daughter of Pradeep Kumar,

Aged about 19years,

77. Priyongboda Roy,

Daughter of Taraknath Roy,


78. Smitha .N,

Daughter of Narayana .C,


17

79. Nameirakpam Chinganbi,

Daughter of Nabir Kumar Singh,


80. Indu Mathur,

Daughter of Rajpal Mathur,


81. Savitha Loganathan,

Daughter of Samuel Loganathan,


82. Prasamita Mishra,

Daughter of Harihara Mishra,


83. Shifa Kauser,

Daughter of Aasif Khan,


84. Kristina Tasing,

Daughter of Tabir Rasing,


85. Trishal R Kanchi,

Son of N. Ravikumar,


86. Monalisha Bose,

Daughter of Pronay Bose,


87. Nancy .R,

Daughter of Raja .K,


18

88. B. Lavanya,

Daughter of B. Chowda Reddy,


89. Farah Shabeer,

Daughter of Usman Shabeer Ahmed,


90. Syog Gajanan Mali,

Daughter of Gajanan Hasuram Mali,


91. K. Sahithya,

Daughter of C.M. Krishna,


92. Nakka Pavani,

Daughter of N.V. Krishna Kumar,


Petitioners no. 56 to 92 are

Studying in 1st year BDS Course,

Vokkaligara Sangha Dental College and

Hospital, K.R.Road, V.V.Puram,


93. College of Dental Sciences,

P.O. Box No.327,

Davanagere – 577 004,

Karnataka, India,


Dr. Vasundara Shivanna,

Daughter of Sri. M.G. Banakar,


19

Residing at Davanagere.

94. Avin Mathew Kurian,

Son of Shri. Kurian Philip,


95. George Mathew,

Son of Mathew E.V.,


96. Jyothy Josekutty,

Daughter of Jose Kutty Thomas,


97. Shetty Aishwarya Narendra,

Daughter of Narendra Shetty,


98. Salva P.M,

Daughter of P.K. Mohiyuddin Kutty,


99. Roney Reji,

Son of Reji Joseph,


100. Aiswarya S Komath,

Daughter of K.B. Sanjeev,


101. Sherin Rose Issac,

Daughter of O.P. Issac,


102. Anumohan,

20

Son of R. Mohanan,


103. Aswin .V,

Son of Vidyadharan,


104. Jeslin Millie James,

Daughter of James Varghese,


105. Edara Sai Charan,

Son of Edara Raghavendra Rao,


106. Linny Maria Varkey,

Daughter of Varkey Kurian,


107. Benvin Iype P James,

Son of James K Pulikkottil,


108. Jyothish K Nath S,

Son of Sudheer .V,


109. Shahna .S,

Daughter of Saidu,


110. Dilgi Divakar,

Daughter of G. Divakar,


21

111. Dessy Daniel,

Daughter of Daniel Thomas,


112. M. Sai Anusha,

Daughter of M. Srinivas,


113. Riya Clara Bessy,

Daughter of Bessy Thomas,


114. Jesna Ann Jose,

Daughter of Jose Mathew,


115. Hari Krishna V.P.,

Son of Pradeep Kumar,


116. Vijay Sajith,

Son of Sajith V,


117. Athira Gireesh,

Daughter of P. Gireeshkumar,


118. Ajay C.R.,

Son of Radhakrishnan C.V.,


119. Priyona John,

Daughter of John T.U.,


22

120. Sherin John Mathew,

Daughter of John Mathew,


121. Evan Cliff Rebello,

Son of Christopher Reballo,


122. Sandra Rose Varghese,

Daughter of Varghese V.P.,


123. Aloys Luke Cherian,

Son of P.M. Cherian,


124. Neethu E Varghese,

Daughter of Varghese E.A.,


125. Aiswarya Madhu,

Daughter of Madhusoodhan Nair,


126. Swetha M.V.,

Daughter of Bhaskaran M.V.,


127. Neha Elizabeth Stephen,

Daughter of Stephen Thomas,


128. Shreya .S,

Daughter of Shekharappa KN,

23


129. Sai Deekshit Kolleboina,

Son of Prasadarao .K,


130. Ajas .S,

Daughter of H. Salahudeen,


131. R. Dhanya,

Daughter of S. Ravikuttan,


132. Jacquilin Mariam Reji,

Daughter of Reji Mathew,


133. Starly B Philips,

Daughter of D.M. Philips,


134. Nova Dominic,

Daughter of Dominic P.K,


135. Angitha .S,

Daughter of N. Sreekumar,


136. Sneha Jerry,

Daughter of Jarison .C,


137. Misha Annie Mathew,

24

Daughter of Mathew Varghese,


138. Raina George,

Daughter of George Zacharias,


139. Joanna Lee,

Daughter of Kurian Varghese,


140. Innu Elsa Varghese,

Daughter of Varghese C.T.,


141. Swaran Unni,

Son of C.S. Sasikumar,


142. Thomas Johnson,

Son of Johnson David,


143. Minna Mary Sunny,

Daughter of Sunny Jacob,


144. Srikireddy Toshitha,

Daughter of Srikireddy Pullareddy,


145. Smily Mathew,

Daughter of K. Mathew,


25

146. Joash Kurian George,

Son of M.K. George,


147. Litta Lalu Thomas

Daughter of Lalu Thomas,


148. Kancheti Chamini,

Daughter of Kancheti Apparao,


149. Asha Mol,

Daughter of Appukuttan Nair P.R.,


150. Aprajeeta Kaushik,

Daughter of Gyanendra Kumar Singh,


151. Jayanta Ghosh,

Son of N.C. Ghosh,


152. Garimaa Surekha,

Daughter of Kamal Surekha,


153. Muhsina .C,

Daughter of Abdullah,


154. Kirstie Sarah Thomas,

Daughter of Thomas Kuruvilla,

Aged about 19years,

26

155. Lalrinnungi Pachuau,

Daughter of Ralkapzula,


156. Muthyapu Jagruthi,

Daughter of Chakrapani,


Petitioners 94 to 156 are

Studying in 1st year BDS Course

At: College of Dental Sciences,

P.O.Box No. 327,

Davanagere – 577 004.

157. Bapuji Dental College and Hospital,

P.O.Box No.326,

Davanagere – 577004,

Karnataka , India,


Dr. K. Sadhshiva Shetty

Son of K. Shivarama Shetty,


Residing at Davanagere.

158. Aksa Kunjumon,

Daughter of Kunjumon .K,


159. Fayas K.A,

Son of Mr. K.M. Abdul Hameed,


160. Justin Paul Antony,

Son of Mr. Paul Antony,

27


161. Jothis Joy,

Daughter of Mr. Joy Mathew,

Aged about 21years,

162. Reetha Mary Sebastian,

Daughter of Mr. Sebastian Joseph,


163. Aneetha Mathew,

Daughter of Mr. A.C. Mathai,


164. Lavanya H.L,

Daughter of Mr. Lingaraj H.L.,


165. Jalad Anusha,

Daughter of Mr. Jaladi Durgaprasadrao,

Aged about 19years,

166. Polimera Prateek,

Son of Mr. Polimera Sudhershan,


167. Parag Partim Sarma,

Son of Mr. Gunindra Sarma,


168. Anumol Alias

Daughter of Mr. E.J. Alias,


169. Pranav Shandilya,

28

Son of Mr. Krishna Kumar,


170. Kaushik Kalita,

Son of Dr. Nani Gopal Kalita,


171. Tiwari Ekta Ramesh,

Daughter of Mr. Tiwari Ramesh K,


172. Adiya Ani,

Daughter of Mr. Ani Kuriakose,


173. Joslin Joseph Manikanam Parambil,

Daughter of Mr. M.V. Joseph,


174. Thomas Podikunju,

Son of Mr. Podikunju T.O.,


175. Puthenpuprayil Susannu Jose,

Daughter of Mr. Pathenpurayil Abraham Jose,


176. Joel Brait,

Son of Mr. Jerry Brait,


177. Ritashna Kaur Kandhari,

Daughter of Mr. Maninder Singh Kandhari,

aged about 19 years

29

178. Rumana .C,

Daughter of Mr. Moidu .C,


179. Precia Meryn Jacob,

Daughter of Mr. James Jacob,


180. Albin Paul,

Son of Mr. Paulson,


181. Anu Salex,

Daughter of Mr. Alexander .T,


182. Greeshma Maria Babu,

Daughter of Mr. Babu Joseph,


183. Minu Ullas,

Daughter of Mr. Ullas P.N.,


184. Pranav M.A.,

Son of Mr. Amil M.J.,


185. Nikhil Raj R.S,

Son of Mr. Rajkumar .V,

Aged about 19years,

186. Hardik Patel,

Son of Mr. Maheshbhai Patel,


30

187. Akshay R Pradeep,

Son of Mr. Pradeep Kumar M.T.,


188. Vyshnav K Santhosh,

Son of Mr. K.K. Santhosh,


189. Sreelekshmi .B,

Daughter of Mr. Mohanan Unnithan .R,


190. Preema George,

Daughter of Mr. K.V. George,


191. Basil George,

Son of Mr. C.J. George,


192. Athulya Annu Jose,

Daughter of Mr. Jijy Joseph,


193. Anandhu Krishnan .E,

Son of Mr. Easwaran Nanpoothiny .S,


194. Vidhun Vinod,

Son of Mr. K. Vinodan,


195. Rahul .C,

Son of Mr. Chandra Shekar .R,

31


196. Divya Jose,

Daughter of Mr. Bijoy Jacob,


197. Keshav Jidge,

Son of Mr. Ramu Jidge,


198. Basetti Vasudeepthi,

Daughter of Mr. B. Hari Babu,


199. Libin Manuvel,

Son of Mr. P.M. Baby,


200. Rishna Mariam John,

Daughter of Mr. John Idvcula,


201. Ann Treasa Thomas,

Daughter of Mr. E.P. Thomas,


202. Glorymol Raju,

Daughter of Mr. Raju Mathew,


203. Sajna Areekkat,

Daughter of Mr. Muhammed Areekkat,


204. Bhawna .K,

32

Daughter of Mr. Krishna Rao .K,


205. James Johny,

Son of Mr. Johny Jacob,


206. Amrutha Anil,

Daughter of Mr. Anil Joseph,



1st year BDS Course at;

Bapuji Dental College and Hospital,

P.O.Box No.326,

Davanagere – 577 004.

207. Sri. Venkateshwara Dental College and

Hospital, [A Unit of Nehru Smaraka Vidya

Kendra Trust, Bangalore],

Kariyappanahalli,

Anekal Road, Banneraghatta,



Dr. C.K. Chandrashekar,

Son of Sri. Late C.N. Karibasappa,



208. Amaljith C.P.,

Son of C.M. Parameshwaran,


209. Anandhu Raj,

Son of Rajendran Pillai,

33


210. Anjali Krishna .S,

Daughter of Radhakrishnan K.V,


211. Anushree Nair .P,

Daughter of Sasidharan,


212. Arjun Sagar,

Son of Sagar Kumar .K,


213. Aswin Kumar,

Son of Kunhi Kelappan,


214. Athil K.P.,

Son of Abdul Majeed K.K.,


215. Bably .M,

Daughter of Aboobacker Siddique,


216. Delin Tom Daniel,

Thomas Daniel,


217. G. Catherin Teena,

Daughter of P. Gabriel,


218. Jyothi Kumari,

34

Daughter of Guliya Banara,


219. Manikandan V.M.,

Son of V.K. Mohan,

Aged about 18years,

220. Mohammed Adhil K.V,

Son of Rasheed K.V.,


221. Nani Monia,

Nani Tatung,


222. Nimmy Susan Philip,

Daughter of George Philip,


223. Revathy .P,

Daughter of Vinod Kumar .P,


224. Ruby Baby,

Daughter of K.M. Baby,


225. Shalini Kumari,

Daughter of Rajded Prasad,


226. Sharon John Philip,

Daughter of John Philip,


35

227. Sharon Mary Thomas,

Daughter of Abraham Thomas,


228. Thasneem T.A.,

Daughter of Ashharuddeen,



1st year BDS Course;

Sri. Venkateshwara Dental College and

Hospital, Kariyappanahalli ,

Anekal Road,

Bannerghatta,


229. Sambhram – K.G.F. College of

Dental Sciences, [A Unit of

Sambhram Charitable Trust]

No.36, D.K. Plantation,

BEML Nagar, Kolar Gold Fields

[K.G.F.] represented by its

Principal, Dr. Vasanth Kumar,

Son of Munisannappa,


Residing at K.G.F.

230. Miss. Sowmiya .K,

Daughter of A.P. Kumaravel,


231. Miss. Khurrath Jabeen,

Daughter of Mohammed Zameer,


36

232. Miss. Trishika Lakshmi,

Daughter of Subramnian,


233. Miss. Minju Annie Mathew,

Daughter of Thomasw Mathew,


234. Miss. Priyamol Prabha,

Daughter of C.P. Prabhakaran,


235. Mr. Harish Prakash,

Son of Prakasan E.M.,


236. Miss. Maneesha Mohan,

Daughter of Mohanan .T,


237. Miss. Resiya K.R.,

Daughter of Rahim K.M.,


238. Miss. Vidhu Pushpan,

Daughter of Pushpangadhan,


239. Mr. Ananthakrishnan C.H.,

Son of Harish Krishnan .R,

Aged about 19years,

240. Mr. Imadur Rahman,

Son of Iman Ali,


37

241. Mr. Subin T.R.,

Son of Radhakrishnan T.P.,


242. Miss. Sokha Odilia,

Daughter of K. Daili,


243. Miss. Manini Monica,

Daughter of Tholi Paul,


244. Mr. Shajamal Al Jakaria,

Son of Alauddin Ahmed,


245. Mr. Mohammed Nisam Jyshin,

Son of Syed Ali,


246. Mr. Aneesh M.R.,

Son of Muralidharan A.N.,


247. Miss. Anjana P.V.,

Daughter of Vinodh Kumar P.S.,


248. Miss. Shruthi R.S.

Daughter of Sreekumar S,


249. Miss. Nabanita Sett,

Daughter of Asoke Kumar Mondal,

38


250. Mr. Souravabrata Mondal,

Son of Shyamal kumar Mondal,


251. Miss. Shilpa Anna John,



252. Miss. Shamima Begum,

Daughter of Samsul Hoque,


253. Mr. Manoj K.N.,

Son of Narayanan P.S,


254. Miss. Neetha S Stalin,

Daughter of Stalin Kumar,


255. Mr. Bopamma Venkata Hemanth,

Ravi Theja,

Son of Bopanna Krishna Mohan,

Age: 18 years,

256. Ms. Jubvena Devi,

Daughter of Mr. Joy Chandra Sharma,

Age: 21 years,

257. Edwin Charly

Son of Charly P.T.,

Age: 19 years,

39

258. Mr. Akash John,

Son of Mr. Shaji John,

Age: 19 years,

259. Mohammed Faisal T.P,

Son of Usmal T.P,

Age: 21 years,

260. Mr. Ramiz Khan,

Son of Shoukat Ali Khan,

Age: 21 years,

Petitioners 230 to 260 are studying

in 1st year BDS Course,

[A Unit of Sambhram Charitable Trust]

No.36, D.K. Plantation,

BEML Nagar, Kolar Gold Fields

[K.G.F.] Sri. Venkateshwara Dental College

And Hospital.

261. Dayananda Sagar College of Dental Sciences

[A Unit of Dayananda Sagar Institutions]

Shavige Malleshwara Hills,

Kumaraswamy Layout,


Represented by its Secretary,

Sri. Galiswamy,

Son of Sri. Galappa,



262. Mr. Mrigank,

Son of Satyendra Kumar,


40

263. Mr. Mithun Sai Kumbha,

Son of Kumbha Srinivas,


264. Miss. Isani Nilimas Salim,

Daughter of Isani Salim V,


265. Lokam Papu,

Lokam Kambe,


266. Miss. Arundhati Sutradhar,

Daughter of Jogendra Nath Sutradhar,


267. Miss. Minhazul Hoque Choudhury,

Daughter of Hamidhul Hoque Choudhury,


268. Mr. Karan Hiral Mehta,

Son of Hiral Madhukar Mehta,


269. Miss. Kajal Tapuria,

Daughter of Bijay Tapuria,


270. Miss. Dishamani Sarma,

Daughter of Baikuntha Sarma,


271. Miss. Nami Longri,

Daughter of Chatu Longri,


41

272. Miss. Naznin Akhtar Islam,

Daughter of Nazinul Islam,


273. Mr. Theodore Sunith Manuel,

Son of Rajkumar S Manuel,


274. Miss. Priyanka Raj,

Daughter of Santosh Kumar Gupta,


Petitioners No.262 to 274 are studying in

I BDS Course at

Dayananda Sagar College of Dental Sciences

[A Unit of Dayananda Sagar Institutions]

Shavige Malleshwara Hills,

Kumaraswamy Layout,


275. K.L.E. Society’s Institute of Dental

Sciences, No.20, Yeshwanthapur Suburb,

2nd

Stage, Tumkur Road,

Bangalore – 560 022, Karnataka,

India.


Dr. Srivatsa .G,

So of Gopalakrishna K.R.,



276. Ms. Jisna Joy,

Daughter of Mr. Joy A Chittilappilly,


42

277. Mr. Salvin Simon,

Son of Mr. Simon,


278. Mr. Adarsh Lal K.P,

Son of Mr. Surendran K.P,


279. Ms. Safeera V.P,

Daughter of Mr. Vatakara,


280. Ms. Ambili K.V,

Daughter of Mr. Kannan K.V,


281. Ms. Manju Mary Thomas,

Daughter of Mr. Thomas Thomas,


282. Ms. R. Lalduhawmi,

Daughter of Mr. Lianmawia,

Aged about 19years,

283. Ms. Deborah Lalrempuii,

Daughter of Mr. Lalremtlung,


284. Mr. Thalhath .M,

Son of Mr. Muhammed Pillai,


285. Mr. Sujin A. Jose,

Son of Mr. A.K.Jose,

43


286. Ms. Disha Pahwa,

Daughter of Mr. Anil Pahwa,


287. Ms. Nayana Manju .K,

Daughter of Mr. K. Venugopalan,


288. Ms. Anetta Thomas,

Daughter of Mr. Thomas V.T,


289. Ms. Soonu Thomas,

Daughter of Mr. Thomas Panamoothil Jacob,


290. Ms. Hepsiba Thomas,

Daughter of Mr. Thomas Chacko,


291. Ms. Blossom Philip,

Daughter of Mr. Phillip Mathew,


292. Ms. Ninnu Muttath,

Daughter of Mr. Peter M. Thomas,


293. Ms. D. Kerthana,

Daughter of Mr. S. Damarai Selvan,

Aged about 18years,

294. Mr. Angshuman Baruah Barman,

44

Son of Mr. Anil Baruah,


295. Ms. Merin Mariam Mathew,

Daughter of Mr. Mathew Thomas C,


296. Mr. Ananthakrishnan .R,

Son of Mr. Radhakrishna .P,


297. Ms. Nikita R Shivapujimath,

Daughter of Mr. Ramalingayya Shivapujimath,


298. Mr. Jabir P.M,

Son of Mr. Basheer P.M,




K.L.E. Society’s Institute of Dental

Sciences, No.20, Yeshwanthapur Suburb,

2nd

Stage, Tumkur Road,

Bangalore – 560 022, Karnataka,

India.

299. Dr. Shyamala Reddy Dental College

Hospital and Research Centre,

111/1, SGR College Main Road,

Unnekolala, Marathahalli Main Road,


Represented by its Chairperson,

Dr. Shyamala Reddy,

Daughter of Shri Reddy,

45



300. Mr. Ambati Flameno,

Son of Mr. Ambati .S,


301. Mr. Anand Kumar Shukla,

Son of Mr. Vinod Kumar Shukla,


302. Mr. Ashish K Soman,

Son of Mr. Soman K.N,


303. Mr. Anmol Golay,

Son of Mr. Dinesh Gole,


304. Mr. Bashiq Basheer,

Son of Mr. Basheer .P,


305. Ms. Dayatar Sofia Yusuf,

Daughter of Mr. Yusuf Bhai,


306. Ms. Deraya Rizwana Salimbhai,

Daughter of Mr. Saleem Bhai,


307. Ms. Dinaha Kamilin,

Daughter of Mr. Yusunayam,


46

308. Ms. Gadde Pujitha,

Daughter of Mr. Srinivas,


309. Ms. Elvamoreen Marbaniang,

Daughter of Mr. Mareein,


310. Mr. Mijum D Lendo,

Son of Mr. Tomi Doke,


311. Ms. Gopika .S,

Daughter of Mr. Hariharan Ayyappa,

Aged about 19years,

312. Mr. Jeffa Zacharia Nixon,

Son of Mr. Nixon Zacharia,


313. Ms. Kuntiyellanna Agari Sindhuja,

Daughter of Mr. Kuntiyeliamai Annagari,


314. Mr. Kailasnath .V,

Son of Mr. Vishwanath Nair .K,


315. Ms. Kolencherry Shruthi Jayson Thomas,

Daughter of Mr. Jayson T,


316. Ms. Noleen Jacob,

Daughter of Mr. Jacob Chacko,


47

317. Ms. Priyanka Venigalla,

Daughter of Mr. Gridhar Rao Venigalli,


318. Mr. Rahul R.B,

Son of Sekhara Vilasam,


319. Ms. Rajkumari Deepti,

Daughter of Mr. Kumarjitha Singh,


320. Ms. Real Tasleem Abdul Sattar,

Daughter of Mr. Real Abdul Sattar,


321. Ms. Riyan Susan Mathew,

Daughter of Mr. Riyan Susan Thomas,


322. Ms. Saiyad Benezir Ikbal Bhai,

Son of Mr. Ikbal Bhai,


323. Ms. Sathya Priya,

Daughter of Mr. K.J. Prabhakaran,


324. Mr. Siva Krishnan A.C,

Son of Mr. Anil Kumar .P,


325. Mr. Stephy Varghese,

Son of Mr. Varghese,

48


326. Ms. Sushma Sathya Bhama,

Daughter of Mr. Balikrishnana .C,


327. Mr. Abad Shibily .M,

Son of Mr. Kunhimoideen,


328. Ms. Byreddy Shravya Reddy,

Daughter of Mr. Byreddy Reddy,


329. Ms. Subhasree Ghosh,

Son of Mr. Barun Ghosh,


330. Ms. Simi Gamlin,

Daughter of Mr. Pogi Gamlin,


331. Mr. Rishin Jackson,

Son of Mr. C.J. Jackson,


332. Mr. Gurucharan,

Son of Mr. Nirajana Ram,


333. Mr. Samudra Devsarma,

Son of Mr. Debaranjam Sarma,


334. Ms. Theerthanjaly .S,

49

Son of Mr. Sunil Kumar,




Dr. Shyamala Reddy Dental College

Hospital and Research Centre,

Kariyappanahalli, Anekal Road,

Banneraghatta,


335. Sri. Hassanamba Dental College and

Hospital, Vidyanagar,

Hassan – 573 201,

Karnataka, India,


Dr. S.R. Ravindra,

Son of B. Shivamurthy,


Residing at Hassan.

336. Mr. Jishnu Chakraborty,

Son of Mr. Amlesh Chakraborty,


337. Miss. Abhishikta Chakrabarty,

Daughter of Mr. Jyoti Prakash,


338. Mr. Kaustav Jana,

Son of Mr. Amal Kumar Jana,

Bahadurpur,


339. Miss. Haritha K Raj,

50

Daughter of Mr. T.K.Raj,

Thekkekezhadath,


340. Miss. Aswani P.K,

Daughter of Pradeep Kumar P.K,

Aged about 18years,

341. Miss. Ann Mary Baby,

Daughter of Mr. Baby K.K,


342. Miss. Hima Manjunath,

Daughter of B.K.Manjunath,


343. Miss. Rishwa H.S,

Daughter of Mr. Abudl Hameed,


344. Mr. Clint Andrews V.A.,

Son of Mr. V.X Antony,


345. Mr. Mohammed Shahin,

Son of Mr. Abdul Nazar,


346. Mr. Muhammed Shanoob P.M,

Son of Mr. Abdul Gafoor,


347. Miss Insha Mohammed,

Daughter of Mr. Mohammed,


51

348. Misss Husna Haris,

Daughter of Mr. Haris P.K,

Aged about 19years,

349. Miss Irin Susan Varghese,

Daughter of Mr. K. Ghee Varghese,


350. Mr. Vishal Kurian,

Son of Mr. P.M. Kuriachan,


351. Miss. Aishwarya Ravindran,

Daughter of Mr. Ravindran,

“Amritam”,


352. Miss. Aswathi M,

Daughter of Mr. Mohanan P.V,


353. Miss Aliya Abdulla Kutty,

Daughter of Mr. M.A. Abdulla Kutty,


354. Miss Fathimath Sreena .M,

Daughter of Mr. Ayamuhaji,


355. Miss Fathima Febin .P,

Daughter of Mr. Noushad .P,


356. Mr. Faseeh M,

52

Son of Mr. Musthafa,


357. Miss. Arya Gladis .B,

Daughter of Mr. D Balaraj,


358. Miss. Annu Ann Jacob,

Daughter of Mr. K.V. Jacob,


359. Miss. Amily V Thomas,

Daughter of Mr. Thomas V.D.,


360. Mr. Mahesh .P,

Son of Mr. Mohanadasan,


361. Miss. Rajilin Prabha Raj,

Daughter of Mr. S. Devaraj,


362. Mr. Sidhu Tom,

Son of Mr. Thomas M.S,


363. Mr. Hussain MD Fahim Tapadar,

Son of Mr. Abdul Khalique,


364. Miss Divya Das .K,

Daughter of Mr. Sivadasan K,


53



Sri Hassanamba Dental College and

Hospital, Vidyanagar, Hassan – 573 201,

Karnataka , India.

365. Sri. Dharmastala Manjunatheswara

College of Dental Sciences and

Hospital, (SDM Education

Society’s) Dhavalnagar, Sattur,

Dharwad – 580 009,


Dr. Srinath L Thakur,

Son of Lakshman Singh,


Residing at Dharwad.

366. Vaz Viana Angelica,

Daughter of Shri. Vaz Victor R H P S


367. Gudipati Mrignaini,

Daughter of Col. G.R.K. Sesha Sai,


368. Ashwini I Rao,

Daughter of Shri. Laxman Rao,


369. Mahadik Vedanti Pravin,

Daughter of Shri Mahadik Pravin Kamalakar,


370. Bhoomika M Gowada,

Daughter of Shri. Manju .H,


54

371. Jain Kshipra Rajesh,

Daughter of Shri. Rajesh Fandulal Jain,


372. Sanghvi Virti Jaysukh,

Daughter of Shri. Sanghvi Jaysukh Hargovind,


373. Aastha Ganjoo,

Daughter of Shri Deepak Ganjoo,


374. Sanjana C.R.,

Daughter of Sri. C. Rajasekhara,


375. Furtado Elisha Gracia,

Daughter of Shri. Furtado Filipe Antonio,


376. Chhaya Kumar,

Daughter of Shri. Satyendra Kumar,


377. Anchal Jain,

Daughter of Shri. Vikramkumar Jain,


378. Akshita Jain,

Daughter of Shri. Uttamchand Jain,


379. Arjun Aravind T.K.,

Son of Shri. Aravindan T.K,

55

Aged about 18years,

380. Abhishek Rakeshbhai Patel,

Son of Shri. Rakeshbhai Arvindbhai Patel,


381. Ashraf Ali,

Son of Shri Asif Ali,


382. Mariya Thomas,

Daughter of Shri Thomas P. J,


383. Murphy Thomas,

Daughter of Shri. Thomas V O,


384. Priya Khyalilal Jain,

Daughter of Shri. Jain Khyalilal Tara Chand,


385. Angelina Lalrohlul,

Daughter of Shri Lalrothanga,


386. Nishita P Biradar,

Daughter of Shri. Panduranga S Biradar,


387. Shromi Roy Choudhury,

Daughter of Shri. Sankar Roy Choudhury,


388. Dipannita Raha,

56

Daughter of Shri Shambhu Raha,


389. Shah Reema Bharat

Daughter of Smt. Chandrika,


390. Amrutha Vinod Yelamali,

Daughter of Shri. Vinod Yelamali,


391. Priyanka Raju Monga,

Daughter of Shri. Raju S Monga,

Aged about 19years,

392. Aditya Satish Shinde,

Son of Shri. Satish Shashikant Shinde,


393. Sattyajeet Prasad Joshi,

Son of Shri. Prasad Prabhakar Joshi,


394. Tippu Thimmaiah C U,

Son of Shri. Uthappa C.K,

Aged about 19years,



Sri. Dharmastala Manjunatheswara College

Of Dental Sciences and Hospital,

Dhavlnagar, Sattur,

Dharwad – 580 009.

57

395. Maratha Mandal’s Nathajirao G Halgekar

Institute of Dental Sciences,

R.S.No.47A/2, Near KSRP Ground,

Bauxite Road, Belgaum – 590 010,


Dr. Ramakant Nayak,

Son of Sri. Nayak,


Residing at Belgaum.

396. Faleiro Docilla Prima,

Daughter of Mr. Melchiades Lucas Faeeiro,

Aged about 19years,

397. Chatim Chaitali Vilas,

Daughter of Mr. Vilas S Chatim,


398. Fernandes Josela,

Daughter of Mr. Joaquim Jose,


399. Viraj V Naik,

Son of Mr. Vivekananda S Naik,

Aged about 19years,

400. Devikrishna D,

Daughter of Smt. Deepa Devadas,


401. Abhishekh Kumar,

Son of Mr. Avinash Chandra Tiwari,


402. D’Costa Hennelon Jesus Joe,

58

Daughter of Mr. Anthony D’Costa,


403. Shaikh Saniya,

Daughter of Mr. Shaikh Vahidulla,


404. Adish Chandrababu,

Son of Mr. Chandrababu .J,


405. Akshay S Shet,

Son of Mr. Shridhar S Shet,


406. Aniket A Kasodekar,

Son of Mrs. Anita Anil Kasodekar,


407. Anjali Bachulkar,

Daughter of Mr. Mohan M Bachulkar,


408. Ankita Pati,

c/o. Ashokkumar,

aged about 19 years,

409. Anurag Parashar,

Son of Mr. Shivakumar Mishra,


410. Trushita K Bhate,

C/o. Kaplieshwar Bhate,

Aged about 19years,

59

411. Chalakkran Aishwarya Pramod,

Daughter of Mr. Pramod Chalakkaran,

Aged about 19years,

412. Chalakkran Chaitanya,

Daughter of Mr. Pramod Chalakkaran,


413. Aaroshi Dhyani,

Daughter of Mr. Rajendraprasad Dhyani,


414. Saylee G Gadkari,

Daughter of Mr. Gangaram Gadkari,

Aged about 19years,

415. Palasha Gawande,

Daughter of Mr. Prasad P Gawande,

Aged about 19years,

416. Ketan Keshav Pai,

Son of Mr. Keshav Pai,


417. Aishwarya Panicker Suresh,

Daughter of Mr. Suresh N Panicker,


418. Tarika Raikar,

Daughter of Mr. Sharadha Chandra Raikar,


419. Rajat Raj Jha,

Son of Mr. Kailash Nath Jha,


60

420. Revathy Vijayanath,

Daughter of Mr. Vijayanath Pilla,


421. Rodrigues Nolcha,

Daughter of Mr. Julio Rodrigues,


422. Shivani Priya,

Daughter of Mr. Anilkumar Singh,


423. Suprabha Patil,

Daughter of Mr. Rajgonda R Patil,


424. Vaz Vivien Indra,

Mr. Gerson E Vaz,


425. Priyanka D Yadav,

Daughter of Mr. Dharmaraj,

Aged about 19years,

426. Aaminbhai Dubaliya,

Son of Mr. Aslam Abdul Dubuliya,

Aged about 19years,

427. Omkar Subhash Pawar,

Son of Mr. Subhash Pawar,


428. Rane Shreeyash,

Son of Mr. Avikshit S Rane,

61




Maratha Mandal’s Nathajirao G Halgekar

Institute of Dental Sciences,

Belgaum.

429. Dental College Hospital and

Research Centre,

Hyderabad Karnataka Development

Education Trust’s,

Humnabad – 585 330,

Bidar District, Karnataka, India,


Dr. H. Mohammed Honnur,

Son of B.K.M. Hussain,


Residing at Bidar.

430. Miss. Chindam Ramyasree,

Daughter of Chindam Ravinder,

Aged about 19years,

431. Miss. Kunkudupala Vaishali,

Daughter of K. Surender,


432. Miss. Umema Simran,

Daughter of Md. Doulth Khan,


433. Miss. Juttiga Sahaja,

Daughter of J. Yugandhar,


62

434. Miss. Punati Nithin P.V,

Daughter of Subba Rao,


435. Miss. Kodirekka Sucharitha,

Daughter of K. Joji,


436. Mr. Syed Mehmood Hussaini,

Son of Syed Kazim Hussaini,


437. Miss. C. Meghana Bardwaj,

Daughter of C.V. Purushotham Rao,


438. Mr. Midde Hussaini,

Son of M.C. Hussain,


439. Mr. Mohammad Fasiuddin,

Son of Md. Shafiuddin,


440. Mr. M. Murali Krishna,

Son of M. Venkateshwarlu,


441. Mr. Mohammed Omer Farooq Ali,

Son of Md. Mahmood Ali,

Aged about 19years,

442. Miss. Syed Habeeb Humira,

Daughter of Syed Nooruddin,

63


443. Miss. Ravipati Jyothsna,

Daughter of R. Srinivas Rao,


444. Miss. Aedla Anusha,

Daughter of Aedla Anujaneyulu,


445. Miss. M. Neha,

Daughter of M. Srinivas Rao,


446. Miss. Gadidasu Surekha Manasa,

Daughter of G. Surendranath,


447. Mr. Mohd Asad Ali Khan,

Son of Md. Muzafeer Ali Khan,


448. Miss. Shaik Farhanaz,

Daughter of Shaik Faizoddin Sab,


449. Miss. Neethu Balakrishnan,

Daughter of Krishnan Balakrishnan,


450. Mr. Shaik Irfan Ali,

Son of Shaik Imam Sab,


451. Mr. Annam Shashivardhan Reddy,

64

Son of Annam Mall Reddy,


452. Mr. N. Shiva Sai,

Son of N. Satyanarayana,


453. Miss. Bibi Zainab,

Daughter of Md. Masthan Shareef,


454. Miss. K. Laxmi Sai Nivedita,

Daughter of K. Ramesh Babu,


455. Miss. Sana Simran,

Daughter of Md. Doulath Khan,


456. Miss. D. Sindu Mai,

Daughter of D. Venkat Rao,

Aged about 18years,

457. Mr. Kadaveeru Srikanth,

Son of K. Sadanand,


458. Miss. Moravineni Swetha,

Daughter of M. Venkateshwara Rao,


459. Miss. Sriramula Niharika,

Daughter of Sriramula Narahari,

Aged about 19years,

65

460. Mr. P. Hannahson,

Son of P. Prasanna Kumar,

Aged about 20years,

461. Mr. Patnaikuni Venkatesh,

Son of P. Jagadeeswara Rao,

Aged about 19years,

462. Miss. Ginne Devi Priya,

Daughter of Ginne Srinivas Reddy,

Aged about 19years,

463. Miss. Sayeeda Banu,

Daughter of Ma Wahab,



1st year BDS Course at:

Dental College Hospital and

Research Centre,

Hyderabad Karnataka Development

Education Trust’s,

Humnabad – 585 330,

Bidar District, Karnataka, India.

464. S.J.M. Dental College and Hospital,

Chitradurga – 577 501,


Dr. M.H. Raghunatha Reddy,

Son of Hema Reddy M.T,

Aged: 45 years,

Resident of Chitradurga.

465. Miss. Riya Daniel,

Daughter of Daniel Simon,

66


466. Mr. Ashwin Manu,

Son of Marcel ARakkal,


467. Mr. Muneer,

Son of Kunhammad,

Aged about 20years,

468. Miss. Sanala K.E.,

Daughter of Kunhabudulla,


469. Miss. Omitta Merlin Thomas,

Daughter of Thomas Abraham,


470. Miss. Archana Vijay .P,

Daughter of Vijaya Kumar .P,

Aged about 19years,

471. Mr. Aravind .A,

Son of Arjunan R.K,


472. Mr. Nanda Kumar V.V.,

Son of Vishwanathan .P,


473. Miss. Salini .K,

Daughter of Satneesan,


474. Miss. Margaret Rossel John,

67

Daughter of John Paul,


475. Mr. Akhil Thomas,

Son of K.P. Thomas,


476. Mr. Milash .M,

Son of Syed Masood Sahib,


477. Miss. Anjitha Vijay .K,

Daughter of Vijayan .T,


478. Mr. B. Umashankar,

Son of D.S. Baba,


479. Miss. Samna N Sadnik,

Daughter of Sadnik A.M,

Aged about 20 yerars,

480. Mr. Arun Antony,

Son of Antony,


481. Mr. Mohan Navnish Shetty,

Son of Mohan Shetty,

Aged about 19years,

482. Mr. Ashique .J,

Son of Jamal A,


68

483. Miss. Jishma A.P,

Daughter of Mohammed Ali A.P.,


484. Miss. Shamitha Balan,

Daughter of Balan T.V,


485. Mr. Godwin .J,

Son of M.V.Joy,


486. Mr. Chaithanya J.R,

Son of Rajendra,


487. Mr. Dadapeer K.R,

Son of mohammed Rafiulla,


488. Mr. Jubin Francis,

Son of Raju Verghese,


489. Miss. Fatheema Ishrath .N,

Daughter of Monudheen,


490. Mr. Gowrishankar .B,

Son of S. Babu,


491. Miss. Salam Jayadevi,

Daughter of Salam Arun Kumar Singh,


69

492. Mr. Sajid I.M,

Son of Maidu,


493. Miss. Jayashree K.M,

Daughter of Masila Mani K,


494. Miss. Finala .M,

Daughter of Abdul Asus,

Aged about 18years,

495. Mr. Abdul Rashid K.P,

Son of Abdul Ansar,

Aged about 20years,

496. Mr. Ridwan Muhammed Rafeek,

Son of Muhammed Rafeek,


497. Mr. Joseph Babu Palatningal,

Son of Babu P.J.,


498. Miss. Christy Mariam Jacob,

Daughter of Sunil Jacob,


499. Miss. Chippy Vijayan,

Daughter of Vijayan Kuznivelli,

Aged about 18years,

500. Miss. Anjana K Johnson,

Daughter of Johnson K.A.,

70


501. Mr. Harshad .K,

Son of Nazeer .K,


502. Miss. Shfna Gafoor .M,

Daughter of Abdul Gafoor .M,


503. Mr. Ribindas C.K,

Son of Balakrishnan C.K,


504. Mr Mohammed Mukthar .M,

Son of Hassan .M,


505. Mr. Mohammed Siyad M.A,

Son of Aboobacker M.A,


506. Miss. Aswani Balakrishnan M.P,

Daughter of Balakrishnan M.P,


507. Miss. Takhellambam Binky Chanu,

Daughter of Takhellambam Ojit,


508. Miss. Georgeena Joseph,

Daughter of Joseph K.C,


509. Miss. Arlin Mathew,

71

Daughter of Mathew Zacharias,


510. Miss. Lavanya .S,

Daughter of Satya Kumar .C,


511. Miss. Amrutha R.K,

Daughter of Jayaprakashan .M,


512. Miss. Drishya Venugopa .C,

Daughter of K. Venugopal,


513. Miss. Liya Mariam Aby,

Daughter of Aby V Kurian,

Aged about 19years,

514. Miss. Neethu Sekhar,

Daughter of Chandrashekaran Nair,

Aged about 20 yers,

515. Mr. Justin Jose,

Son of Jose K. Antony,


516. Miss. Mitali Gedam,

Daughter of Omprakash Gedam,

Aged about 20years,



S.J.M. Dental College Hospital,

Chithradurga – 577 501,

72

Karnataka, India.

517. Amrit Educational and Cultural Society’s

Maaruthi College of Dental Sciences and

Research Centre, No.108,

Hulimavu Tank Bund Road,

BTM Layout,

6th

Stage, 1st Phase,

Kammanhalli,

Bannerghatta Road,



518. Ms. Feba Susan Varghese,

Daughter of E.C. Varghese,


519. Ms. Aparna Ravidas,

Daughter of Ravidas .K,


520. Mr. Sufaid .C,

Son of Subair,


521. Ms. Kavya Suresh,

Daughter of Suresh Babu,


522. Mr. Roni Das,

Son of Rabindra Kumar Das,


523. Mr. Abhijit Datta,

Son of Arunmay Datta,

73


524. Ms. Ori Nalo,

Daughter of Talom Nalo,


525. Mr. Suraj Kumar Mishra,

Son of Binod Kumar Mishra,


526. Mr. Ujjawal Kumar Mishra,

Son of Binod Kumar Mishra,

Aged about 18years,

527. Mr. Bankar Pechimayum,

Son of P. Ingocha Singh,


528. Ms. Anagha .E,

Daughter of E. Ashokan,

Aged about 18years,

529. Ms. Anagha Sivadas,

Daughter of Sivadasan,

Aged about 18years,

530. Mr. Nihal Roshan P.M,

Son of Najeeb,


531. Ms. Phebey A Thomas,

Daughter of Thomas Mathew C.F,


532. Ms. Anjana Menon R,

74

Daughter of Radhakrishna Menon,


533. Mr. Mohammed Suhail C.S,

Son of Shahul Ahmeed .C,

Aged about 18years,

534. Ms. Agnes S.S.,

Daughter of Suresh Kumar A.K.,


535. Mr. Akhil Abraham,

Son of K.K. Abraham,

Aged about 18years,

536. Mr. Sudhin Krishna .S,

Son of Suresh,

Aged about 18years,

537. Mr. Mohammed Arshath Khan .I,

Son of B. Ibrahim,


538. Ms. Devika Krishna E.R,

Daughter of Rajan E.R,


539. Mr. Indrajit .R,

Son of Radhakrishna .K,


540. Ms. Maripurum Sailaja,

Daughter of Marupuru Chenchu Krishnaiah,


75

541. Mr. Jeswin Antony,

Son of Antony D’Cruz,


542. Ms. Annet Shibu,

Daughter of A.V. Shibu,


543. Ms. Saron T.S,

Daughter of Sam George,


544. Ms. Ann Mary P.A,

Daughter of Antony P.J,


545. Mr. Jean Koshy Punnoose,

Son of Punnoose George,

Aged about 18years,

546. Mr. Sangeet Philip Mathew,

Son of K.C. Mathew,


547. Mr. Safariyab K.P,

Son of Ibrahim K.P,

Aged about 18years,

548. Mr. Jibin S.D,

Son of Devasia S.M,


549. Mr. Akshay Ramesh,

Son of Ramesh .S,


76

550. Mr. Renju Roy,

Son of Roy Paul,

Aged about 18years,

551. Ms. Deepaly Pandey,

Daughter of Kamalesh Kumar Pandey,


552. Ms. Neethu Simon,

Daughter of Joshua Simon,


553. Ms. Femina Subair,

Daughter of Subair .P,

Aged about 18years,

554. Mr. Bibin Joseph,

Son of Joseph P.T,

Aged about 19years,

555. Mr. Afin Nizar,

Son of Nizar .S,


556. Mr. Mohammed Riyas .V,

Son of Kunhi Mohammed,


557. Ms. Sona Sajan,

Daughter of Sajan Abraham,


558. Mr. Jis John,

Daughter of T.D. ulahannan,

77


559. Mr. Glinto Jose .T,

Son of T.C. Joshe,

Aged about 18years,

560. Mr. Sijo C Kovelil,

Son of K.C. Chacko,

Aged about 18years,

561. Ms. Shwetha,

Daughter of Ramesh Kishen,


562. Ms. Amalu Mary Sebastian,

Daughter of Sebastian Antony,

Aged about 19years,

563. Mr. Akshay. A,

Son of D.S.Anil Kumar,


564. Mr. Mohammed Nisham .C,

Son of Abdul Rahiam,


565. Mr. Rushi Kirti Kumar Patel,

Son of Kriti Kumar,


566. Ms. Thankam Meenakshi Prakash,

Daughter of P.S. Prakash Kumar,


567. Mr. Hassim Hassan,

78

Son of Hassan K.A,


568. Ms. Precella Mathew,



569. Ms. Ashmita Sinha,

Daughter of Deepak Narayan Sinha,


570. Ms. Muktha Mohan,

Daughter of K.P.Mohanan Nair,


571. Mr. Aby Salim,

Son of S. Salim


572. Ms. Semim Ahmed,

Daughter of Sadiqur Rahaman,


573. Ms. Mounica .K,

Daughter of G. Krishnamurthy,


574. Ms. Rekulapally Maduri Reddy,

Daughter of Rekulapally Prabhakar Reddy,


575. Ms. Pewangtateule Jeme,

Daughter of Pauramduing Jeme,


79

576. Mr. Presenjeet Dey,

Son of Jithendra Dey,


577. Mr. Sharon Johnson,

Son of C.D. Johnson,


578. Ms. Sheela Kumari,

Daughter of Shree Shashi Shanker Sinha,


579. Ms. Remathy .K,

Daughter of T. Kailinghani,

Aged about 18years,

580. Ms. Greeshma . S.R,

Daughter of R.S.Suresh,

Aged about u18 years,

581. Mr. Mohammed Mussim M.P,

Son of Abdul Rahiman,


582. Ms. Archana Menon,

Daughter of Radhakrishna Menon T.B,


583. Mr. Vishnu A.B,

Son of Baiju A.R,


584. Ms. Arpita Chowdhury,

Daughter of Pijus Kanthi Chowdhury,


80

585. Mr. Mohammed Badrmusthafa .M,

Sonof Mohammed Musthafa,


586. Ms. Soumya Joseph,

Daughter of Biju Joseph,


587. Ms. Chayanika Kakoti,

Daughter of Jamunamukh,


588. Ms. Pravallika,

Daughter of Sree Ramaiah,

Aged about 18years,

589. Mr. Dhameliya Ravi Chhaganbhai,

Son of Chhaganbhai Dhameliya,


590. Mr. Suraj Jyoti Changamai,

Son of Suren Changmai,


591. Ms. Jaryir Gibi,

Daughter of Jumjar Gibi,

Aged bout 19 years,

592. Mr. Samriddh Sharma,

Son of Vijayendra Kumar Sharma,


593. Ms. Sudipa Das,

Daughter of Dwijendra K R Das,

81


594. Ms. Kavya Shree,

Daughter of Venkataswamy,


595. Mr. Pranav A.G,

Son of Ajith P.R,




Amrit Educational and Cultural Society’s

Maaruthi College of Dental Sciences and

Research Centre, No.108,

Hulimavu Tank Bund Road,

BTM Layout,

6th

Stage, 1st Phase,

Kammanhalli,

Bannerghatta Road,


596. Sharavathi Dental College and Hospital,

Alkola, T.H.Road,

Shimoga – 577 204,

Represented by its

Secretary, Sri. Siddalinga,

Son of H.M. Dandayya,

Resident of Shimoga.

597. Miss. Sneha Shankar Karajagi,

Daughter of Shankar Karajagi,

Age: 19 years,

598. Miss. Meghna,

82

Daughter of Satnam Singh,

Age: 19 years,

599. Miss. Chelsea George,

Daughter of George Abraham

Age: 20 yeares,

600. Miss. Aswathy B,

Daughter of V. Chandrasekharan Nair,

Age: 18 years,

601. Miss Suchina Chidambaran,

Daughter of Chidambaran,

Age: 25 years,

602. Mr. Rahul Sayanth .R,

Son of Rajan .D.R,

Age:19 years,

603. Mr. Jismon James,

Son of James P.J,

Age: 21 years,

604. Miss. Pinky Soraisam,

Daughter of Ingo Soraisam,

Age: 18 years,

605. Miss. Lissa Tom,

Daughter of Thomas,

Age: 20 years,

606. Miss. Manju Mathunni,

Daughter of Mammen Mathunni,

Age: 19 years,

83

607. Miss. Harsha J Kappan,

Daughter of K.E. Joseph,

Age: 19 years,

608. Miss. Shibila .C,

Daughter of Alikoya .C,

Age: 20 years,

609. Miss. Rooth Joseph,

Daughter of Joseph P.V,

Aged: 20 years,

610. Miss Jimsha .T.K,

Daughter of Unni Krishnan .K,

Age: 21 years,

611. Miss. Josmy .J,

Daughter of Joseph .T,

Age: 22 years,

612. Miss. Rushba C.K,

Daughter of Moosa C.K,

Age: 20 years,

613. Miss. Datia Namratha Reddy,

Daughter of D.V. Sudhakar Reddy,

Age: 18 years,

614. Miss. Talluri Susmitha,

Daughter of Talluri Jayaprakash Babu,

Age: 19 years,

615. Miss. G. Srujana,

Daughter of Gorrumuchu Amarnath,

Age: 19 years,

84

616. Miss. Anamika Kumari,

Daughter of Harendra Kumari,

Age: 19 years,

617. Mr. Shafeequi Mohammed,

Son of Chekku Muhammed,

Age: 21 years,

618. Mr. Nadir Aboobcker,

Son of Aboobcker V.P,

Age: 21 years,

619. Mr Abdul Haseeb,

Son of Basheer K.P,

Age: 19 years,

620. Mr. Marshal Antony M,

Son of S Mathew,

Age: 18 yeas,

621. Miss. Hadendla Divya Naga Lakshmi,

Daughter of N. Balagnagadhara Tilak,

Age: 19 years,

622. Miss. Cicilia Toijam,

Daughter of Opendra Toijom,

Age: 18 years,

623. Miss. Rajakumri Rojita Devi,

Daughter of Rajkumar Robindro Singh,

Age: 19 years,

624. Miss. Chitta Sudha Spandana,

Daughter of Citta Venkata Lakshmi Sesha Girirao,

85

Age: 18 years,

625. Mr. Sai Bhararath .N,

Sonof Nagesha .N,

Aged: 19 years,

626. Mr. T. Jayakrishna,

Son of Krishna Murthy .Y,

Age: 20 years,

627. Mr. Joyson Premkumar .B,

Son of S. Bhagiaraj,

Age: 18 years,

628. Mr. Thiyam Satishkumar Singh,

Son of TH Indrakumar Singh,

Age: 18 years,



Sharavathi Dental College and Hospital,

Alkola, T.H.Road,

Shimoga – 577 204,

629. K.V.G. Dental College and Hospital,

Kurunjibag, Sullia,

Dakshina Kannada – 574 327,

Represented by its

Principal,

Sri. Moksha Nayak.

630. Asheeba Hassan,

Daughter of Ali Hassan,

Age: 19 years,

86

631. Shilpa Soman,

Daughter of K.V.Soman Nair,

19 years,

632. Prajwal M.K,

Sonof Kalika Prasad,


633. Devish Rai B,

Son of Devidas Rai,


634. Shreya M.S.,

Daughter of Sanjeeva Matandoor,


635. Nihas Muhammed,

Son of Ussain Karappakandy,


636. Basil Ayoob K.P,

Son of Ayoob K.P.,


637. Rishikesh,

Son of Harikrishnan .M,


638. Alben Varghese,

Son of Varghese A.V,


639. Mohammed Ribin .M,

Son of Melethil Abdul Kareem,


87

640. Muhammed Asif,

Son of Majeed Ommer Kutty,


641. Atul Krishnan P.S,

Son of Padmakumar,


642. Sareer .K,

Son of Sakkariya,


643. Arya Krishna .K,

Daughter of Krishnadas .K,


644. Archana Balakrishnan,

Daughter of K.T.Balakrishnan,


645. Fulayilath Mol V.P.,

Daughter of Mohammed Ali,


646. Jasmine C.M.

Daughter of Mohammed .C,


647. Anju Rose Mathew,

Daughter of Mathew,


648. Ansaba Sherin T M,

Daughter of Muhammed Basheer,

88


649. Krista Reeba Chandy,

Daughter of Sherry Chandy,


650. Kezia Babu,

Daughter of Babukutty K,


651. Dhiviya Thekkanat,

Daughter of Chandran,


652. Mohamed Iqbal P,

Son of Mohammed Ashraf,


653. Mohammed Hafil P.K,

Son of Aboobacker P.K,


654. Thejus Abraham,

Son of Abraham,


655. Joel Poly,

Son of Poulo Paul,


656. Akhil U,

Son of Udayan R,


657. Pranav Premarajan,

89

Son of Premarajan,


658. Mohammed Mazvin Nihal,

Son of Mohammed V.P.,


659. Retnakumar .S,

Son of Sugathan.K,


660. Jesseh T George,

Son of George T.G,


661. Addanki Lakshmi Tejaswini,

Daughter of A.V.Subba Rao,


662. Sreelakshmi .R,

Daughter of K.N. Rajasekharan Pillai,


663. Tharish H.A,

Son of A.H. Aboo,


664. Siddharth K Das,

Son of Dasan .K,


665. Rainer Varghese O,

Son of O.P. Varghese,


90

666. Ashil M Moithu,

Daughter of M.M. Moithu,


667. Resmi C.S,

Daughter of Sasikumar C,


668. Ankita Sarma,

Daughter of Pabitra Kumar Sarmah,


669. Ajiza Pazhayapattillath,

Daughter of Adhiraja Mohammed Rafi,


670. Harsha Hamsa,

Daughter of N.P. Hamsa,

Aged about 19years,

671. Aliya Izath K.P,

Daughter of Ayoob K.P,


672. Tesa Abraham,

Daughter of V.A. Abraham,


673. Chinchu Javan,

Daughter of Javan Chacko,


674. Reshma J.S,

Daughter of Sathyan P.S,


91

675. Zohni Mohamed,

Daughter of E.K. Mohamed,

Aged about 19years,

676. Anjaly Jayachandran,

Daughter of Jayachandran Nair,


677. Sujitha Ilyas,

Daughter of T.A.Ilyas,


678. Treesa Joseph,

Daughter of N.V. Joseph,

Aged about 19years,

679. Athira P Mohan,

Daughter of P.V. Mohanan,

Aged about 19years,

680. Sulthana A.S,

Daughter of Shamsudheen A A,

Aged about 19years,

681. Hafsa .S,

Daughter of Shabeer Ahmed M M,

Aged about 19years,

682. Reshma Ravi,

D/o. Ravindran Nair,


683. Mumthas K.K,

D/o.Abdul Kareem K K,

92


684. Shalba .C,

D/o. Babu .C,


685. Naseema .N,

D/o. N Abdul Rahiman Arafa,


686. Nasreen P V,

D/o. P.V. Ahamed Basheer,


687. Akhila Maria Sunil,

D/o. Sunil Lawrence,


688. Jinky Merin Thomas,

D/o. Kakkanattukunneelethu Thomas Thomas,


689. Shilpa Jayaraman,

Daughter of Jayaraman P U,


690. Sharin Shahana M,

D/o. Mammy M,


691. Juhaina,

D/o. Beerankutty Amblavam,


692. Aswathi Rajan,

93

D/o. Rajan K P,




K.V.G. Dental College and Hospital,

Kurunjibag, Sullia,

Dakshina Kannada – 574 327,

693. Shri. B.V.V. Sangha’s,

P.M. Nadagouda Memorial Dental College

And Hospital , Bagalkot – 587 101.


Dr. Srinivas Shankarappa Vanaki,

Son of Shankarappa Vanaki,


Resident of Bagalkot.

694. Ms. Libina Mathew,

D/o. Mathuw C.S,

Age: 21 years,

695. Ms. Parvathy Vijaykumar,

D/o. Vijay Kumar,

Age 18 years,

696. Ms. Neethu N,

D/o. K. Nandankumar,

Age 19 years,

697. Ms. Asha Huddar,

D/o. Arun,

Age 18 years,

698. Ms. Nithya T Ajitha,

94

D/o. K. Kamalasanan Pillai,

Age 19 years,

699. Ms. Nair Remya Madhusuthan,

D/o. Madhusuthan,

Age 18 years,

700. Ms. Rincy Mol M.T,

D/o. Tomy M O

Age 20 years,

701. Ms. Jannu Swetha,

D/o. Jannu Babu,

Age 19 years,

702. Ms. Durgkar Umme – A mmara,

D/o. A. Rahim

Age 19 years,

703. Ms.Namrata B Akal,

D/o. Bandappa Akal,

Age 18 years,

704. Ms.Rudagi Akshata Ashok,

D/o. Ashok,

Age 18 years,

705. Ms. Yerate Dhanashri Vishwanath,

D/o. Vishwanath,

Age 18 years,

706. Ms. Sharon Anitha Jacob,

D/o. Jacob Philip,

Age: 19 years,

95

707. Ms. Ramesan Rini,

Kunjachan Ramesan,

Age: 19 years,

708. Ms. P Mikitha,

D/o. Narendrakumar,

Age: 18 years,

709. Ms. Gambhire Pallavi Gopalrao,

D/o. Gopalrao,

Age: 19 years,

710. Ms. Surya S. Nair,

D/o. Suresh Babu,

Age: 19 years,

711. Ms. Konda Bhavya Laya,

D/o. Konda PraveenKumar,

Age: 18 years,

712. Ms. Romya Romy,

D/o. Romy Michael,

Age 19 years,

713. Ms. Aeturu Mounica,

D/o. Aeturu Venkata Suresh Babu,

Age 18years,

714. Ms. Patil Pooja Rajendra,

D/o. Rajendra,

Age 18 years,

715. Ms. Raina N Baby,

D/o. N.M. Baby,

Age 20years,

96

716. Ms. Raiban A,

D/o. Abdul Karim Sahib,

Age 19 years,

717. Mr. K. Srihitha,

D/o. K. Suresh,

Age: 18 years,

718. Ms. Jesani Prakruti Narendra,

D/o. Jesani Narendra,

Age: 18 years,

719. Ms. Shekhawat Shreya Devendra Singh,

D/o. Devendra Singh,

Age: 18 years,

720. Ms. Dara Swasa,

D/o. D Gopi,

Age 19 years,

721. Ms. Shaik Shahanaz,

D/o. Shaik Nagoormeeravali,

Age 18 years,

722. Ms. Valluri Sai Supraja,

D/o. V. Subramanyam,

Age 18 years,

723. Ms. Shintu Mary John,

D/o. Johny Joseph,

Age: 19 years,

724. Ms. M. Chandralekha,

D/o. M. Parphasarathy,

97

Age 19 years,

725. Ms. Kandula Chandana,

D/o. Kondula Pradeep Kumar,

Age 18 years,

726. Ms. Deepti Vishwanath,

D/o. P. Vishwanath,

Age 18 years,

727. Ms. Batchala Venkata Sowmya,

D/o. Batchala Venkata Subbaiah,

Age: 18 years,

728. Ms. M. Akhila,

D/o. M. Ashok Kumar,

Age: 18 years,

729. Mr. Jithin K Baiju,

Son of Baiju Raj,

Age 19 years,

730. Mr. Sanu Philips,

Son of Philip K.V,

Age 18 years,

731. Mr. Bennett Benny,

Son of K.P. Beny,

Age: 18 years,

732. Mr. Jeffin Sebstain Jolley,

Son of Jolly K.D,

Age 18 years,

733. Ms. Gaddipati Saipriyanka,

98

D/o. G Prasad,

Age 18 years,

734. Ms. Annet Mary Scaria,

D/o. M.A. Scaria,

Age 18 years,

735. Ms. Jeeva John,

D/o. Johnson .B,

Age 18 years,

736. Ms. Shaik Aiman H Javed,

D/o. Azam Javed,

Age 18 years,

737. Ms. Saini Amani,

D/o. Saini Madhusudhan,

Age 19years,

738. Ms. Sanam Pritam Chaudhari,

D/o. Pritam B Chaudhari,

Age: 18 years,

739. Ms. Arya Raj,

D/o. Rajan P.K,

Age: 18 years,

740. Ms. Ashitha Panicker,

D/o. V.T. Vivekanad Panicker,

Age 18 years,

741. Ms. Sahadiyya M,

D/o. Mohamed Koya,

Age 20 years,

99

742. Ms. Anju Sebastian,

D/o. Devasia,

Age 19 years,

743. Ms. Jestymol K.K,

D/o. Kuttiyachan Philip,

Age 18 years,

744. Ms. Shijina Ayoob,

D/o. Ayoob Khan,

Age 18 years,

745. Ms. Zenaup Shajahan,

D/o. Shajahan S,

Age 20years,

746. Ms. Honap Gayatri Nagesh,

D/o. Honap Nagesh,

Age 18 years,

747. Ms. Swathi L Nandwadagi,

D/o. Lakshman V Nandwadagi,

Age 18 years,

748. Ms. Sarah Miriyam Cecil,

D/o. Cecil George Mathew,

Age 18 years,

749. Ms. Maria Rose Mathew,

D/o. Mathew,

Age 18 years,

750. Ms. Ajmi Ansari,

D/o. Ansari .A,

Age 18 years,

100

751. Mr. Sharma Prakash Prateek,

Son of Sharma Pawan Kumar,

Age 18years,

752. Mr. Narsipuram Vara Prasad,

Son of Narsipuram Kaemshwar Rao,

Age 20 years,

753. Mr. Tummala Sriharsha,

Son of T.S.V. Prasad,

Age 19years,

754. Mr. Chori Raviteja,

Son of Chori Adam,

Age 18 years,

755. Mr. C.V. Krishna Sailesh,

Son of C Phani Raj,

Age 18 years,

756. Mr. Pagadala Vishnu Vardhan,

Son of Pagadala Venkataraman,

Age 18 years,

757. Mr. Ravutu Chanakya Anu Roy,

Son of Ravutu Venkatswara Rao,

Age 18 years,

758. Mr. Yadav Rvi Harishchandra,

Son of Harishchandra,

Age 19 years,

759. Mr. Vyshnav .A,

Son of Ajayakumar T.C,

101

Age 20 years,

760. Mr. Mohammed Merajuddin,

Son of Mohammed Muneeruddin,

Age 18 years,

761. Mr. Tom J Baby,

Son of Baby John,

Age 18 years,

762. Mr. Al Fakrudeen Farook,

Son of Umarul Farook,

Age 18 years,

763. Mr. Devine Antony E.F,

Son of E.A.Francis,

Age 18 years,

764. Mr. Mohammed Haris P,

Son of Mohammed Haneefa Pookkattil,

Age 18 years,

765. Mr. Abdul Wahad T,

Son of Abdul Majeed T,

Age 19 years,

766. Mr. Budda Srinivas,

Son of Budda Laxman,

Age 18 years,

767. Mr. Abhik Chatterjee,

Son of Bipadtaran Chatterjee,

Age 18 years,

768. Ms. Reshma Simon,

102

D/o.K.V. Simon,

Age 18 years,

769. Ms. Anila Antony,

D/o. Antony P.P.,

Age 18 years,

770. Ms. Vineetha P,

Daughter of Unnikrishnan .P,

Age 18 years,

771. Ms. Salini Anu Thomas,

D/o. K.C.Thomas,

Age 18 years,

772. Ms.Saba Mahveenkhan,

Daughter of Abid Ali Khan,

Age 21 years,

773. Ms. Chavan Priyanka Shashikant,

D/o. Shashikant,

Age 18 years,

774. Mr. Ajnas V.T.K,

Son of Aboobakker,

Age 23 years,

775. Ms. Golase Mayuri V,

Daughter of Vishnu,

Age 19 years,

776. Mr. Syed Sadeq Ali,

Son of Syed Gulam Ali,

Age 18 years,

103

777. Ms. Ekatapure Payal Randhir,

D/o. Randhir,

Age 19 years,

778. Ms. K. Chetana,

D/o. K.C. Venkateshwarlu,

Age 18 years,

Petitioners 694 to 778 are

Studying in 1st year BDS Course

At; Shri. B.V.V. Sangha’s,

P.M. Nadagouda Memorial Dental College

And Hospital , Bagalkot – 587 101.

…PETITIONERS

(By Shri. Madhusudhan R Naik, Senior Advocate for Shri. Omkar

Kambi, Advocate)

AND:


Sciences,

4th








3. State of Karnataka


Medical Education,

Ministry of Health and Family Welfare,

104

Vikasa Soudha,


…RESPONDENTS

(By Shri. N.K. Ramesh, Advocate for Respondent No.1


Respondent No.3)

*****

These Writ Petitions filed under Articles 226 and 227 of

the Constitution of India praying to call for the records fo the

proceedings fromo the respondents and to quash the impugned

communication all of which are dated 10.6.2013 issued by the

respondent vide Annexures K-1 to K-19 and etc;

IN W.P.Nos.26124-26128 /2013

BETWEEN:

1. Sanskruthi R Chinya,

Daughter of Ravi C.R.,

Age: 19 years,

Studying 1st year MBBS from,

Basaveshwara Medical College and Hospital,

S.J.M. Campus, National Highway No.4,

Chitradurga – 577 502.

2. Mownika .K,

Daughter of K. Kumar,

Age: 19 years,





105

3. Jompin Padu,

Daughter of Minjom Padu,

Age: 20 years,





4. Koka Prashanthi Lakshmi,

Daughter of K. Venkatappa,

Age: 20 years,





5. Dasari Krishna Chaitanya Puneet,

Son of Hari Babu,

Age: 20 years,


Adichundhanagiri Institute of Medical Sciences,

Nagamangala Taluk,

Mandya – 571 448.

…PETITIONERS

(By Shri. Madhusudhan R Naik , Senior Advocate for Shri.

Abhishek Malipatil, Advocate)

AND:


Health Sciences for Karnataka,

4th



106


2. State of Karnataka,

Department of Medical Education,

Ministry of Health and Family Welfare,

Vikasa Soudha,


Represented by its Principal Secretary.

3. Basaveshwara Medical College and Hospital,


Chitradurga – 577 502,


4. Adichunchanagiri Institute of Medical Sciences,

Nagamangala Taluk,

Mandya – 571 448,


5. The Medical Council of India,

Pocket No.14, Sector 8,

Dwaraka,

New Delhi – 110077,

Represented by its Secretary. …RESPONDENTS


Shri. B. Veerappa, Additional Government Advocate for R-2 ,

Shri. M.S. Parthasarathi, Advocate for R-3

Smt. M.P. Geetha Devi, Advocate for R-4

Shri. Zulfikir Kumar Shafi, Advocate for R-5)


Constitution of India praying to quash the impugned

communications issued by first respondent dated 12.6.2013 vide

Annexure-A and A1 respectively P1 to 5 and etc;

107

IN W.P.Nos.25650-25716/2013

BETWEEN:

1. Karnataka Professional Colleges

Foundation (Formerly Karnataka

Private Medical and Dental Colleges’

Association) No.132, 2nd

Floor,

17th Cross, 11

th Main, Malleswaram,


Represented by its Executive Secretary,

Mr. R.V. Govinda Rao,


2. A.M.E’s Dental College and Hospital

Bijanagere Road,

Raichur – 584 103,


Dr. Gururaja Rao,

Son of Sri. T.V. Ramachandra Rao,

Age: 63 years,

Resident of Raichur.

3. Navdeep Kaur,

Son of Amrih Singh,

Age 19 years,

4. Gayathri C.S.,

Daughter of Suresh C.R.,

Age: 19 years,

5. Lakshmi Priya,

Daughter of Saji P Sagar,

Age: 19 years,

108

6. Swathy Suresh,

Daughter of Suresh Kumar,

Age: 20 years,

7. Bincy Paulose,

Daughtet of M.S.Paulose,

Age: 19 years,

8. K.V. Priyanka,

Daughter of K.R. Vinod,

Age: 19 years,

9. Ansar Harish,

Son of S.M. Harish,

Age: 19 years,

10. Huiren Ladymonadevi,

Daughter of Huiren Tomba Singh,

Age: 19 years,

11. Mohammed Daleef K.K.,

Son of Abdus Salam,

Age: 20 years,

12. Delma John,

Daughter of John V.J.,

Age: 19 years,

13. Sruthi .B,

Daughter of Bhaskaran,

Age: 19 years,

14. Machambi .S,

Daughter of S. Subahsh Chandra,

109

Age: 19 years,

15. Sandhya .M,

Daughter of Mohanan .T,

Age: 19 years,

16. Megha C.M.,

Daughter of Mohanan .C,

Age: 19 years,

17. Mary Gloria,

Daughter of Shammy John,

Age: 20 years,

18. Rizana Razak,

Daughter of Razak M.S.,

Age: 19 years,

19. Poojitha Agarwal,

Daughter of Dr. Nandkishore,

Age: 19 years,

20. Sathya Kumaresan,

Daughter of P. Kumaresan,

Age: 19 years,

21. Nadar Shyamal Jayakumar,

Daughter of Jayakumar .T,

Age: 19 years,

22. Ayishath Hamna .P,

Daughter of Poonami,

Age: 19 years,

23. Kammara Naveen Kumar,

110

Sonof Kammara Ramudu,

Age: 19 years,

24. Mallu Jyoshna,

Son of Sivanagi Reddy,

Age: 19 years,

25. Neerughanti Karthika,

Son of N. Sangareddy,

Age: 19 years,

26. Shaik Sharveen,

Son of Shaik Babu,

Age: 19 years,

27. Palle Sudharani,

Daughter of P. Sivanagi Reddy,

Age: 19 years,

28. Annie Mohan M.S.,

Daughter of Zarcaria Mohan,

Age: 19 years,

29. Shaik Rabiya Shaheen,

Daughter of Shaikh Mohammed Ayub,

Age: 19 years,

30. Md. Mujeebullah,

Son of Shaikh Mohammed Ayub,

Age: 19 years,

31. Wasim Ali,

Son of Yusuf Ali,

Age: 20 years,

111

32. A. Sai Nikhita,

Daughter of A. Govindarajulu,

Age: 19 years,

33. V. Chaitanya,

Son of V. Mallikarjunachari,

Age: 19 years,

34. Chiluka Pushpavalli,

Daughter of C. Vijayakumar,

Age: 19 years,

35. Goddumarri Sumant Babu,

Son of G. Laxmipathy,

Age: 19 years,

36. Jagatab Manoj,

Son of J. Chandrakumar Rao,

Age: 19 years,

37. Padam Rohit

Daughter of P. Narayana,

Age: 19 years,

Petitioners no.3 to 36 are all

Students studying in 1st year

BDS Course at A.M.E’s Dental

College and Hospital,

Bijanagere Road,

Raichur – 584 103.

38. HKE Society’s

Nijalingappa Institute of Dental

Sciences and Research.

112

Sedam Road,

Gulbarga – 585 105,


Jayashree A Mudda,

Wife of Mudda,

Major, residing at Gulbarga.

39. Amreen Fathima,

Daughter of Abdul Gaffar,


40. G. Snehita,

Daughter of G. Srinivasulu,

Aged 18 years,

41. G. Apoorva Reddy,

Daughter of Laxmikant Reddy,


42. Bontapapalli Shivani,

Son of B. Ashokkumar,


43. Titu M Varkey,

Son of Varkey M.J.,


44. Kanchanakuntla Swathi,

Son of Kanchanakutla Ramareddy,


45. Vanga Hima Sai Reddy,

Son of Vanga Seshi Reddy,


113

46. Miryanam Mounika,

Daughter of M. Gnaneshwar,


47. Mohammed Niyas .K,

Son of Mohammed K Kadamboden,


48. Anusha Kolur,

Daughter of Amresh Kolur,


49. Supriya Patil,

Daughter of Shivaram Reddy,


50. Bashakarala Sai Sruthi,

Daughter of Bashkarala Ashok,


51. Khan Naziya Bano Badruddin,

Badruddin Khan,


52. Khan Baby Aymun Usman,

Daughter of Usman Ahmedkhan,


53. Khan Salman Farukh,

Son of Khan Farukh Mashooque,


54. Sunka Shrish Manohar,

Son of Manohar Shankar Sunka,


114

55. Jaccob P Francis,

Son of Mr. Francis,


56. Mohammed Abdul Sameer,

Son of Mohammed Abdul Rahman,


57. Muskar Kiran Mayee,

Daughter of Mushkar Venkanna,


58. Chitra Bargavi,

Daughter of Chitrala Laxminarayana,


59. Mohammed Abdul Sadik,

Son of Mohammed Abdul Samed,


60. Sakray Shruthi,

Daughter of Sakray Gopalrao,


61. Chintala Navya,

Daughter of Chintala Pratap Reddy,


62. Matada Sreekanth,

Son of M.B.Sekaraiah,


63. D. Suryaprakash,

Son of Bhemappa,

115


64. Machrla Meghan Manohar,

Daughter of Manohar,


65. Zeba Rafat Jahan,

Daughter of Md. Abdul Rab,


66. Khan ARifa Barkutullah,

Daughter of Barkutullah,


67. Kolluru Rama Lakshmi,

Daughter of K. Suresh Kumar,


Petitioners no. 39 to 67 are

All students studying in

1st year BDS Course at

HKE Society’s

S. Nijalingappa Institute of

Dental Sciences and Research.

Sedam Road,

Gulbarga – 585 105. …PETITIONERS

(By Shri. Shashi Kiran Shetty .K, Advocate)

AND:


Health Sciences for Karnataka,

4th



116



Iwan-E-Galib Marg,

Kotla Road,





Medical Education,

Ministry of Health and

Family Welfare,

Vikasa Soudha,

Bangalore – 560 001. …RESPONDENTS



Respondent No.3)



communication dated 10.6.2013 issued by first respondent to

petitioner no.2 vide Annexure-A and etc;

IN W.P.Nos.25837-25844/2013

BETWEEN:

1. M.S.R. Dental College and Hospital

MSRIT Post, MSR Nagar,


Represented by its Principal

Dr. B.V. Sreenivasa Murthy,

117

Son of Late Venkateshaiah,

Aged about 53 years.

2. Tanya Singh,

Daughter of Sri. Y.P. Singh,


Residing at Room No.134,

Triveni Hostel,

MSR Institutions Campus,

MSR Post, MSR Nagar,


3. Tavisha Kashyap,

Daughter of Sri. Pravin Kashyap,



Triveni Hostel,




4. Ambreen Aftab,

Daughter of Dr. Aftab Alam Khan,



Triveni Hostel,




5. S.V. Shruthi,

Daughter of Sri. Ravindra,



Triveni Hostel,

118




6. H. Afreen Fathima,

Daughter of Sri. Habibulla,



Triveni Hostel,




7. Anindita Chakraborthy,

Daughter of Sri. Shibnatha Chakraborty,


Residing at Plot No.5,

4th

Block, Blessing Garden Layout,

Byrathi,


8. Somnath Battacharya,

Son of Sri Debjyothi Battacharya,


No.158, AGS Layout

New BEL Road,

R.M.V. 2nd

Stage,

Sanjayanagar,

Bangalore – 560 094. …PETITIONERS

(By Shri. K. Shashi Kiran Shetty, Advocate)

AND:


119


4th






New Delhi – 110 002.




Medical Education,

Ministry of Health and Family Welfare

Vikasa Soudha,




Respondent No.3)

*****





IN W.P.Nos.25867-25914 /2013

BETWEEN:

1. M.R. Ambedkar Dental College and

Hospital, No.1/36,

120

Cline Road,

Cooke Town, Bangalore – 560 005,


Dr. Hemalatha,

Resident of Bangalore.

2. Sarath .S,

Son of K.T. Sabarisan,

Age: 20 years,

3. Asna Anna James,

Daughter of James Joseph,

Age: 18 years,

4. M.K. Akhila,

Daughter of Vijaya Kumar .R,

Age: 20 years,

5. Nouman Rashid,

Daughter of Humayan Rashid,

Age: 20 years,

6. Uzman Jan,

Son of Mujeeb Ul-Rehman,

Age: 18 years,

7. Athoiba Soubam,

Daughter of Niladhaja Soubham,

Age: 19 years,

8. Joyce Elima Rani .R,

Daughter of M. Raghunathan,

Age: 19 years,

9. Chubamenla Longkumar,

121

Daughter of Ayangba Longkumar,

Age: 19 years,

10. Risha Bhura,

Daughter of Rajendra Kumar,

Age: 19 years,

11. Imtala A.O.,

Daughter of Lanuba A.O.,

Age: 18 years,

12. Nida Hussain Siddique,

Daughter of Abu Hussain Siddique,

Age: 23 years,

13. Naba Usman Modi,

Daughter of Modi M Usman,

Age: 19 years,

14. Nyima Dolma,

Daughter of Tenzin Monlam,

Age: 20 years,

15. Manditoka Reshma,

Daughter of A.R. Balakrishna,

Age: 23 years,

16. Salam Ashis Singh,

Daughter of Arbind Singh,

Age: 20 years,

17. Annamarie Dhon,

Daughter of Julious Dhon,

Age: 19 years,

122

18. Neeseng Ngemu,

Daughter of Kamlang Ngemu,

Age: 19 years,

19. Deepak .S,

Son of Shashidharan Pillai,

Age: 20 years,

20. Sanju Yacob,

Son of Yacob K.P.,

Age: 19 years,

21. Parvathi Haridasan Warrier,

Daughter of Haridasan Warrier,

Age: 19 years,

22. Md. Nur Hussain,

Daughter of Muraduz Zaman,

Age: 21 years,

23. Mahal Waseemakram,

Daughter of Jilani Basha,

Age: 19 years,

24. Sumayah Salma .M,

Daughter of Syed Muneer .A,

Age: 19 years,

25. Pampa Mallick,

Daughter of Akal Chand Mallick,

Age: 20 years,

26. Ashmita Bhattacharya,

Daughter of Ashit Ranjan,

Age: 20 years,

123

27. Haritha Babu H,

Daughter of Ravi P.V.,

Age: 20 years,

28. Keerthi .R,

Daughter of Ramanathnam T.M.,

Age: 19 years,

29. Nainika Krishnan,

Daughter of Ramakrishnan,

Age: 19 years,

30. Lakshmi Sunder,

Daughter of K. Sunder,

Age: 20 years,

31. Julu Thomas,

Daughter of Thomas Joseph,

Age: 19 years,

32. Aneena Anna Rajan,

Daughter of Rajan Mathew,

Age: 19 years,

33. Beulah Hepsiba .M,

Daughter of Mani Mozhi Arasan,

Age: 19 years,

34. Faisal .F,

Son of Faisal Uddin,

Age: 20 years,

35. Preetha Barman,

Daughter of Uttam Kumar Barman,

124

Age: 21 years,

36. Perla Venkata Haripriya,

Daughter of Perla Subba Rao,

Age: 19 years,

37. Manasa B.S.,

Daughter of B.S. Suresh Babu,

Age: 19 years,

38. Mehta Yakshita Hiren,

Daughter of Hiren Shashikanth Mehta,

Age: 18 years,

39. Merin Ann Reji,

Daughter of Reji C Samuel,

Age: 19 years,

40. Diptasri Saha,

Daughter of Uttam Saha ,

Age: 20 years,

41. Brilema Tayang,

Daughter of Solingsa Tayang,

Age: 20 years,

42. Midhun .B,

Son of E.K. Baby,

Age: 20 years,

43. Athira S Ajith,

Daughter of Ajith Kumar A.S.,

Age: 20 years,

44. Shaik Hassan Ali,

125

Son of Shaik Habeebullah,

Age: 18 years,

45. Mohammad Jasheer K.V.,

Son of Md. Samsheer,

Age: 21 years,

46. Azmeena Akhtar Hussain Halari,

Daughter of Akhtar Hussain Halari,

Age: 19 years,

47. Shraddha Jena,

Daughter of Rajendra Kumar Jena,

Age: 21 years,

48. Khumbong Mayum Ranjtha Devi,

Daughter of Kumar Singh,

Age: 20 years,

Petitioners no. 2 to 48 are all

Studying 1st year BDS Course,

From the Ambedkar Dental College and

Hospital, No.1/36, Cline Road,

Cooke Town,

Bangalore – 560 005. …PETITIONERS

(By Shri. Madhusudhana R Naik, Senior Advocate for Shri.

Abhishek Malipatil, Advocate)

AND:



4th



126



Iwan-E-Galib Marg,

Kotla Road, New Delhi – 110 002,




Medical of Health and Family Welfare

Vikasa Soudha,


(By Shri. N.K. Ramesh, Advocate for Respondent No1


Respondent No.3)

These Writ Petitions filed under Article 226 and 227 of the




IN W.P.Nos.24610-24674 and

24675 / 2013

BETWEEN:

Sri. Rajiv Gandhi College of

Dental Sciences,

RGC Campus Cholanagar,

R.T.Nagar Post,


Represented by its

Principal, Dr. Geetha K Patil,

Age: 49 years. …PETITIONER

127

(By Shri. Mahesh R Uppin, Advocate)

AND:

Rajiv Gandhi University of Health

Sciences, 4th ‘T’ Block,

Jayanagar,


By its Registrar. …RESPONDENT

(By Shri. N.K. Ramesh, Advocate)


Constitution of India, praying to quash the letter dated 10.6.2013

vide Annexure-P and the letter dated 12.6.2013 issued by the

Rajiv Gandhi University of Health Science marked as Annexure-

Q by issuing a writ in the nature of certiorari and etc;

These petitions having been heard and reserved on

26.03.2014 and 27.03.2014 and coming on for pronouncement of

orders this day, the Court delivered the following:-

128

ORDER

These petitions are heard and disposed of by this common

order as the issue that arises for consideration is the same.

2. These petitions are brought by the managements and

students of several dental colleges. The institutions involved are

recognized by the Dental Council of India (Hereinafter referred to

as the ‘DCI’, for brevity) and affiliated to the Rajiv Gandhi

University of Health Sciences (Hereinafter referred to as the

‘RGUHS’, for brevity). The said institutions conduct courses

leading to a Bachelor of Dental Surgery degree.

These petitions seek to question the denial of approval of

admissions of the several students, who are also petitioners herein,

to the I year BDS Course for the academic year 2012-13.

It is stated that the following sequence of events are

material in appreciating the present controversy. The eleven judge

bench judgment in TMA Pai Foundation v. The State of

Karnataka, (2002) 8 SCC 481, reiterated and recognized the

129

fundamental right of private managements to impart education in

professional courses. It was laid down that the right to establish

and administer educational institutions of their choice would

inhere the right to admit students, the right to frame a reasonable

fee structure, the right to constitute its governing body and the

right to appoint and exercise discipline and control over its staff.

While also addressing the possibility of exploitation of the

situation by the private institutions, where the demand far

exceeded the supply of seats in the institutions, the Apex court

also indicated the scope of regulation and control of the said

institutions, by the government and other statutory authorities.

The TMA Pai case was followed by two other decisions of

the Apex court in Islamic Academy of Education v. The State of

Karnataka (2003) 6 SCC 697 and PA Inamdar v. State of

Maharashtra ( 2005) 6 SCC 537, wherein the Apex Court has

sought to clarify certain seemingly grey areas in TMA Pai. One

significant clarification was that there could not be a “quota“ of

seats over which the Government could exercise its discretion in

130

selection of candidates, and that all the seats in a private

institution imparting education in professional courses were in the

domain of the management. But in order to accommodate the

reservation policy of the State in the matter of selection of

students for admission, and in that regard, any seat sharing

arrangement between the State government and the managements

was to be by recourse to consensual agreements to be arrived at

from time to time. It was declared that State could not impose its

Reservation policy over the private institutions.

Article 15(5) was inserted by the Constitution 93rd

Amendment Act, 2005, to enable the State legislatures to bring

legislation providing for reservations in private colleges imparting

professional courses. This was in the wake of the Apex Court

enunciating the law in the above mould. The State of Karnataka

has enacted legislation Act No.8 of 2006, Act No.13 of 2006 and

Act No.23 of 2011, by virtue of which there have been consensual

arrangements between the State government and the private

managements over the years in the matter of sharing of seats,

131

which were all placed before the Apex Court from time to time for

approval. For the academic year 2012-13 there was such a

consensual arrangement. But the queer position was that most of

the seats could not be filled up as the influx of students from the

neighbouring States, as in the earlier years- prior to 2003, was no

longer evident. In terms of the consensual arrangement the filling

up of all vacant seats was based on academic eligibility and inter

se merit. It was specifically agreed that admissions could not be

made without exhausting the list of the selected candidates by the

State Government under a Common Entrance Test (CET) and the

management conducted COMED – K – entrance test. It was found

that after filling up the government quota seats and the

management seats pursuant to the entrance tests conducted, there

were yet a large number of unfilled seats, as found at the re-

conciliation made at which time, the Government “surrendered“

the unfilled seats to the Managements. The petitioner -

institutions had admitted students to the same on the basis of their

eligibility without holding any test to ascertain their inter se merit

132

as that was in the opinion of the managements a meaning less

exercise as there were still vacant seats going a begging even

after such further admissions. As there were no rank cards issued

to such students under the secondary admissions, in the absence of

any entrance test- their admissions have not been approved by the

University. It is that which is under challenge in the present

petitions.

3. The learned Senior Advocate, Shri Madhusudhan

R.Naik, appearing on behalf of the counsel for the petitioners in

WP 24702/2013, WP 26124/2013, WP 25867-914/2013, leading

the arguments would point out that while recording a consensus

and terms of agreement a special mention has been made

providing for grant of admissions after exhausting the list of

candidates selected under the CET, COMED-K . The same as

recorded is reproduced for ready reference :

“Note : In so far as admissions to undergraduate

Courses in Dental Sciences [BDS Course]; it has been

the ‘past experience’ of the State Government in

133

Karnataka and; the private managements that, there are

more number of seats available than, the applicants

seeking admissions to these courses, through a

Common Entrance Test, whether in the Government or

the Private Managements’ colleges and; that for the said

reason, years after year; for several years now; the seats

have remained un-filled and wasted in most of the

colleges; including in Government Colleges. It has

now been realized that, such non-filling of fairly large

number of seats; and consequent shortfall in funding

through tuition fees stipulated, results in disturbing and

denying the calculated total required funding, to impart

quality education, and in the process, the ‘students

community’ suffers. Therefore after exhausting all the

merit lists- of KEA, COMED-K or any other

recognized entrance tests for admission to Dental

Courses; it would be permissible to grant ‘admissions’

in the respective Institutions imparting BDS Courses; to

any eligible candidate based only on their ‘academic

merit’ in the qualifying examination; not requiring

appearance in an Entrance Test, for the purpose.”

It is stated that though in the past, the University had

approved admissions made by the institutions, without holding an

134

entrance test to ascertain inter se merit, on payment of a penalty

imposed.

It is contended that the RGUHS had notified the academic

calendar under a notification dated 13.7.2012 setting out, inter-

alia, the tentative last date for approval of admissions, as

31.12.2012 and the conduct of the I year examination as June

2013. The approval of admission of the several students has been

sought well in time. A notification was issued indicating the

commencement of examinations from 21.6.2013. It is just prior to

the examinations that the petitioners were intimated that the

secondary admissions made by the petitioner institutions could not

be approved.

It is contended that it was expected of the university to be

reasonable and communicate the denial of approval of admission

of the students, if any, at the earliest point in time, so as not to

jeopardize the career of several students, who have been admitted,

but the University has on an erroneous reading of the judgment in

135

Priya Gupta vs. State of Chattisgarh (2012) 7 SCC 433, has lead

itself to believe that the admission made of the students, are

impermissible and proceeded with such an extreme step, which is

bound to affect nearly 1000 students from different colleges across

the state.

That since several years, the Private Managements have

been making the admissions, on the basis of the eligibility of the

students in the Board Exams, after the seats that were expected to

be shared on the basis of the consensual arrangements between the

State and the Colleges through their Association, had been filled

to a limited extent and, large number of seats under both

Government and Management categories, fell vacant after the

counseling process and, seats could not be expected to be filled in

any manner, expect as provided under the Note in the consensual

arrangements, which ‘Note’ took into account the special

circumstances, that are germane in so far as Dental Education and

admission process is concerned. That the university itself has

136

been receiving a fee in the form of Fine, imposed on the colleges

for making admissions in the unfilled category, only to the extent

of the approved intake in the college and not beyond, whereby

approval has been granted to the admission of the eligible students

who are similar to the students, who are now sought to be denied

of the their admissions.

That the judgment of the Supreme Court, in Priya Gupta’s

Case has been clearly misread by the authorities who have taken a

narrow view of the present matter; and also the context in which

the judgment has been delivered has not been taken note of. The

Supreme Court in the above judgment, which the University has

used, more out of the fear of penal consequences to its officers on

a ‘purported illegality’, rather than on an appreciation of the

judgment, delivered in the context of adherence to ‘Time

Schedule’ in making admissions, has issued certain directions

concerning strict adherence to the ‘Time schedule’. The Apex

Court nevertheless made certain observations, which seems to

have put the Statutory Authorities on high alert, as to non-

137

adherence of the directions issued in the said judgment concerning

strict implementation of time schedule, but in the present case, the

authorities wishing to err on the safer side, have gravely erred by

putting the academic careers of several students in jeopardy by

playing it safe and not approving the admissions which has been

done for the previous batches of BDS course.

That, under the consensual arrangement for 2012-2013,

which has been worked out in accordance with the enabling

statutes and which has been placed before the Supreme Court for

its approval to work out the same, provides for filling up of all

vacant seats by the Applicants to the Institution, based on

academic eligibility. It is necessary to point out that it was on

account of past experience; while recording consensus and terms

of agreement a special mention was made providing for grant of

admissions after exhausting the list of CET of the State and

entrance test of college managements to the candidates based on

their academic eligibility and inter-se merit. Thus, under authority

138

of the State enactment – Act 23 of 2011, it was specifically

provided for filling up seats based on academic eligibility

prescribed; and as it transpired there were large number of

vacancies; seats remaining vacant, whether under Government

Quota or COMED K Quota.

4. While the learned counsel Shri N.K.Ramesh seeks to

justify the impugned action of the RGUHS.

5. The question that would arise for consideration in the

light of the above facts and circumstances is, Whether the

Institutions could, after a re-conciliation of the vacant seats that

remained on exhaustion of the list of selected candidates under the

several entrance tests conducted, admit students without an

entrance test and without reference to their inter se merit.

6. Before answering this point for consideration, it would

be necessary to refer to the decision of the Apex Court in Priya

Gupta’s case. That was a case where the two appellants therein

had appeared in the pre-medical test conducted by the State of

139

Chattisgarh for the academic year 2006. The results were said to

have been declared in July 2006. The appellants had been

admitted to the course. However, the procedure followed in their

admission came to be questioned, which lead to an enquiry and

adverse finding and consequently their admissions were cancelled

by the State Government. This having been questioned before the

High court, the said court affirmed the fact that the appellants had

been admitted overlooking other more meritorious candidates and

dismissed the petitions, against which the appellants approached

the apex court. The apex court held that though it did not any

merit in the appeal, in the facts and circumstances of that it

permitted the appellants to complete their course as general

candidates subject to payment of Rs.5 lakh each.

In the course of the judgment however, certain observations

and directions were issued which are as follows :

“42. The Medical and Dental Councils of India, the

Governments and the universities are expected to act

in tandem with each other and ensure that the

recognition for starting of the medical courses and

140

grant of admission are strictly within the time-frame

declared by this Court and the Regulations. It has

come to the notice of this Court that despite warnings

having been issued by this Court and despite the

observations made by this Court, that default and

non-adherence to the time schedules shall be viewed

very seriously, matters have not improved.

Persistent defaults by different authorities and

colleges and granting of admission arbitrarily and

with favouritism have often invited criticism from this

Court.

43. In Arvind Kumar Kankane v. State of U.P.,

(2001)8 SCC 355, the Court observed that the

process of counselling cannot go on continuously for

a long period and the resultant chain reaction should

be checked. Some seats may have to be left vacant

per compulsion, but, the process of admission should

stand the test of rationality. There should be

exceptional and fortuitous circumstances to justify

late admission. In Chhavi Mehrotra v. DG of Health

Services, (1994)2 SCC 370 the Court was even

compelled to issue notice of contempt to the Director

General of Health Services as to why proceedings

under the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 be not taken

for non-compliance with the scheme framed by the

141

Court for consideration of applications for transfer of

students between colleges and they be not punished

accordingly.

44. The consistent effort of this Court to direct

corrective measures and adherence to law is not only

being thwarted by motivated action on the part of the

authorities concerned, but there has also been a

manifold increase in arbitrary admissions. Repeated

defaults have resulted in generating more and more

litigation with the passage of time. This Court, thus,

now views this matter with greater emphasis on

directions that should be made to curb incidents of

disobedience.

45. The maxim boni judicis est causas litium

dirimere places an obligation upon the Court to

ensure that it resolves the causes of litigation in the

country. Thus, the need of the hour is that binding

dicta be prescribed and statutory regulations be

enforced, so that all concerned are mandatorily

required to implement the time schedule in its true

spirit and substance. It is difficult and not even

advisable to keep some windows open to meet a

particular situation of exception, as it may pose

impediments to the smooth implementation of laws

142

and defeat the very object of the scheme. These

schedules have been prescribed upon serious

consideration by all concerned. They are to be

applied stricto sensu and cannot be moulded to suit

the convenience of some economic or other interest of

any institution, especially in a matter that is bound to

result in compromise of the abovestated principles.

46. Keeping in view the contemptuous conduct of the

relevant stakeholders, their cannonade on the rule of

merit compels us to state, with precision and

esemplastically, the action that is necessary to

ameliorate the process of selection. Thus, we issue

the following directions in rem for their strict

compliance, without demur and default, by all

concerned;

46.1. The commencement of new courses or increases

in seats of existing courses of MBBS/BDS are to be

approved/recognised by the Government of India by

15th

July of each calendar year for the relevant

academic sessions of that year.

46.2. The Medical Council of India shall, immediately

thereafter, issue appropriate directions and ensure

the implementation and commencement of admission

process within one week thereafter.

143

46.3. After 15th

July of each year, neither the Union

of India nor the Medical or Dental Council of India

shall issue any recognition or approval for the

current academic year. If any such approval is

granted after 15th

July of any year, it shall only be

operate for the next academic year and not in the

current academic year. Once the sanction/approval

is granted on or before 15th

July of the relevant year,

the name of that college and all seats shall be

included in both the first and the second counselling,

in accordance with the Rules.

46.4. Any medical or dental college, or seats thereof,

to which the recognition/approval is issued

subsequent to 15th

July of the respective year shall not

be included in the counselling to be conducted by the

authority concerned and that college would have no

right to make admissions in the current academic

year against such seats.

46.5. The admission to the medical or dental colleges

shall be granted only through the respective

entrance tests conducted by the competitive authority

in the State or the body of the private colleges. These

two are the methods of selection and grant of

144

admission to these courses. However, where there is

a single Board conducting the State examination and

there is a single medical college, then in terms of

Clause 5.1 of the Medical Council of India

Eligibility Certificate Regulations, 2002 the

admission can be given on the basis of 10+2 exam

marks, strictly in order of merit.

46.6. All admissions through any of the stated

selection processes have to be effected only after due

publicity and in consonance with the directions issued

by this Court. We vehemently deprecate the

practice of giving admissions on 30th

September of

the academic year. In fact that is the date by which,

in exceptional circumstances, a candidate duly

selected as per the prescribed selection process is to

join the academic course of MBBS/BDS. Under the

directions of this Court, second counselling should be

the final counselling, as this Court has already held in

Neelu Arora v. Union of India, (2003)3 SCC 366 and

third counselling is not contemplated or permitted

under the entire process of selection/grant of

admission to these professional courses.

46.7. If any seats remain vacant or are surrendered

from all-India quota, they should positively be

145

allotted and admission granted strictly as per the

merit by 15th

September of the relevant year and not

by holding an extended counselling. The remaining

time will be limited to the filling up of the vacant

seats resulting from exceptional circumstances or

surrender of seats. All candidates should join the

academic courses by 30th

September of the academic

year.

46.8. No college may grant admissions without duly

advertising the vacancies available and by publicizing

the same through the internet, newspaper, on the

notice board of the respective feeder schools and

colleges, et. Every effort has to be made by all

concerned to ensure that the admissions are given on

merit and after due publicity and not in a manner

which is ex facie arbitrary and casts the shadow of

favouritism.

46.9. The admissions to all government colleges have

to be on merit obtained in the entrance examination

conducted by the nominated authority, while in the

case of private colleges, the colleges should choose

their option by 30th

April of the relevant year, as to

whether they wish to grant admission on the basis of

the merit obtained in the test conducted by the

146

nominated State authority or they wish to follow the

merit list/rank obtained by the candidates in the

competitive examination collectively held by the

nominated agency for the private colleges. The

option exercised by 30th

April shall not be subject to

change. This choice should also be given by the

colleges which are anticipating grant of recognition,

in compliance with the date specified in these

directions.

47. All these directions shall be complied with by all

concerned, including the Union of India, Medical

Council of India, Dental Council of India, State

Governments, universities, and medical and dental

colleges and the management of the respective

universities or dental and medical colleges. Any

default in compliance with these conditions or attempt

to overreach these directions shall, without fail,

invite the following consequences and penal actions:

47.1 Every body, officer or authority who disobeys or

avoids or fails to strictly comply with these directions

stricto sensu shall be liable for action under the

provisions of the Contempt of Courts Act. Liberty is

granted to any interested party to take out the

147

contempt proceedings before the High Court having

jurisdiction over such institution/State, etc.

47.2. The person, member or authority found

responsible for any violation shall be departmentally

proceeded against and punished in accordance with

the Rules. We make it clear that violation of these

directions or overreaching them by any process shall

tantamount to indiscipline, insubordination,

misconduct and being unworthy of becoming a public

servant.

47.3. Such defaulting authority, member or body shall

also be liable for action by and personal liability to

third parties who might have suffered losses as a

result of such default.

47.4. There shall be due channelization of selection

and admission process with full cooperation and

coordination between the Government of India, State

Government, universities, Medical Council of India or

Dental Council of India and the colleges concerned.

They shall act in tandem and strictly as per the

prescribed schedule. In other words, there should be

complete harmonization with a view to form a

uniform pattern for concerted action, according to the

148

framed scheme, schedule for admission and

regulations framed in this behalf.

47.5. The college which grants admission for the

current academic year, where its

recognition/approval is granted subsequent to 15th

July of the current academic year, shall be liable for

withdrawal of recognition/approval on this ground, in

addition to being liable to indemnify such students

who are denied admission or who are wrongfully

given admission in the college.

47.6. Upon the expiry of one week after holding of the

second counselling, the unfilled seats from all quotas

shall be deemed to have been surrendered in favour of

the respective States and shall be filled thereafter

strictly on the basis of merit obtained in the

competitive entrance test.

47.7. It shall be mandatory on the part of each college

and university to inform the State and the Central

Government/competent authority of the seats which

are lying vacant after each counselling and they

shall furnish the complete details, list of seats filled

and vacant in the respective States, immediately after

each counselling.

149

47.8. No college shall fill up its seats in any other

manner.”

And in the operative portion of the judgment it is, inter-alia,

stated thus :

“With all the humility at our command, we

request the High Courts to ensure strict adherence to

the prescribed time schedule, process of selection and

to the rule of merit. We reiterate what has been stated

by this Court earlier, that except in very exceptional

cases, the High Court may consider it appropriate to

decline interim orders and hear the main petitions

finally, subject to the convenience of the Court. We

may refer to the dictum of this Court in Medical

Council of India v. Rajiv Gandhi University of Health

Sciences, (2004)6 SCC 76, Para 14.”

The indignation of the Apex Court that is reflected in the

above categorical directions issued is apparent. The facts and

circumstances of the present case would have to be kept in view,

150

in reconciling the above directions of the Apex Court which are

generally issued, in dealing with the present petitions.

The grim situation faced by the Dental Colleges in the State

of Karnataka, that mushroomed in the early 2000’s, from the year

2007 is graphically depicted in the following table, as regards the

vacancy position.

Details of Vacant seats of BDS course

Seats Allotted Vacant Seats Sl.No. Year Category Total

Number

of Seats No’s % No’s %

1 2007-

2008

CET

849 266 33.33% 583 68.70%

Comed-K 830 109 13.13% 721 86.87%

2 CET 821 260 31.70% 561 68.30%

2008-

2009

Comed-K 727 32 4.10% 695 95.90%

3 CET 791 420 50.10% 371 49.90%

2009-

2010

Comed-K 727 75 10.30% 652 89.70%

4 CET 798 225 28.20% 573 71.80%

2010-

2011

Comed-K 730 164 22.46% 566 77.53%

5 CET 755 463 61.00% 291 39.00%

2011-

2012

Comed-K 726 83 11.00% 643 89.00%

151

6 CET 837 578 69.00% 259 31.00%

2012-

2013

Comed-K 748 240 32.00% 508 68.00%

Admittedly, the situation for the year 2012-13 was no

different, except that it may be slightly better than the previous

years. If upon reconciliation of the vacant seats remaining after

admissions are made against the select list of candidates under the

entrance tests conducted by the State Government and the

Managements, respectively. If the seats available are lesser in

number than the aspirants seeking admission against those vacant

seats- there can be no doubt that without an entrance test being

conducted to gauge the inter-se merit, no admissions can be made.

However, if the available seats are more than the candidates, who

are otherwise eligible for admission, the holding of a entrance test

to address their inter se merit would be unnecessary and

meaningless. In that view of the matter the RGUHS having

denied approval of the admission of the several student petitioners

at a belated point of time of the academic year, only on the ground

152

that such admissions were made without any ranking being

assigned to the students, in the absence of an entrance test, does

appear to be a ‘knee-jerk’ reaction by RGUHS, as contended by

the petitioners, given the ominous words of caution issued to all

concerned, in the matter of adhering to admission procedures to

professional colleges, by the Apex Court in Priya Gupta’s case.

However, it would be necessary for the managements to fill

up the vacant seats that are available, after re-conciliation with the

select lists at the entrance tests, to maintain complete transparency

in the entire process in the event that an entrance test becomes

necessary to weigh the inter-se merit of the candidates in the event

that there are more eligible candidates than seats. The test to be

conducted would necessarily be in accordance with the

appropriate guidelines that may be issued by the State

Government.

Accordingly, the petitions are allowed. The impugned

Annexures are quashed. The admissions granted to the several

153

students in these petitions are declared as being valid and that they

are entitled to continue their studies on the approval of their

admissions, which the RGUHS shall grant forthwith.

Sd/-

JUDGE

nv*

dated this the 03 rd day of april 2014 before: the...

Documents