date: july 13, 2018 · a draft director of purchasing’s recommendation memorandum and the four...

54
FINANCE AND ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES DEPARTMENT PURCHASING DIVISION 115 S. Andrews Avenue, Room 212 • Fort Lauderdale, Florida 33301 • 954-357-6066 • FAX 954-357-8535 DATE: July 13, 2018 TO: Evaluation Committee Members Digitally signed by GLENN MARCOS DN: dc=cty, dc=broward, dc=bc, on behalf of ou=Organization, ou=BCC, ou=ETS, GLENN MARCOS ou=ERP, ou=Users, cn=GLENN MARCOS Date: 2018.07.13 17:19:32 -04'00' Brenda J. Billingsley THRU: Brenda J. Billingsley, Director of Purchasing FROM: Nancy Olesen, Purchasing Agent Nancy Olesen Digitally signed by Nancy Olesen DN: dc=cty, dc=broward, dc=bc, ou=Organization, ou=BCC, ou=PU, ou=Users, cn=Nancy Olesen Date: 2018.07.13 15:26:08 -04'00' SUBJECT: Recommendation Memorandum RFP No. PNC2115550P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports REFERENCE: (a) Procurement Code Subsection 21.83.d (b) Procurement Code Subsection 21.30.f.5 In accordance with reference (a), the Director of Purchasing reviews all submittals for responsiveness and recommends to the Evaluation Committee her findings, which the Evaluation Committee may accept or arrive at a different conclusion. Pursuant to Procurement Code Subsection 21.8.b.65, a responsive Bidder [proposer] means a person who has submitted a bid [proposal] which conforms in all material respects to a solicitation. The Request for Proposals (RFP) PNC2115559P1 included two (2) responsiveness requirements, including Lobbyist Registration Certification Form and acknowledgement of “must” addenda. All seven (7) proposers are recommended to be evaluated as responsive to all responsiveness requirements. In accordance with reference (b), the Evaluation Committee determines proposers’ responsibility. Pursuant to Procurement Code Subsection 21.8.b.64, a responsible firm is one that has the capability in all respects to perform fully the contract requirements, and the integrity and reliability which will assure good faith performance. To assist the Evaluation Committee in this determination, information regarding the Office of Economic and Small Business Development goals compliance, the “material” litigation history disclosure, financial information, State of Florida authority to conduct business, affiliated entities, proof of insurance, and licensing responsibility requirements are provided. Six (6) proposers out of seven (7) proposers are recommended to be compliant to all responsibility requirements. Florida Technical Consultants, LLC is being recommended as non-compliant to the goal compliance responsibility requirement. This solicitation has a designated County Business Enterprise (CBE) goal of 25%. A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development, Public Works Department Water and Wastewater Services, the County Attorney’s Office and the Risk Management Division were emailed to proposers with a request that, if a proposer desires to clarify any information provided in their response, they should do so in writing. All written explanations received were subsequently reviewed by staff, as applicable. Mark D. Bogen • Beam Furr • Steve Geller • Dale V.C. Holness • Chip LaMarca • Nan H. Rich • Tim Ryan • Barbara Sharief • Michael Udine Broward County Board of County Commissioners www.broward.org

Upload: others

Post on 03-Aug-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

FINANCE AND ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES DEPARTMENT PURCHASING DIVISION 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 bull Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301 bull 954-357-6066 bull FAX 954-357-8535

DATE July 13 2018

TO Evaluation Committee Members Digitally signed by GLENN MARCOS DN dc=cty dc=broward dc=bc

on behalf of ou=Organization ou=BCC ou=ETSGLENN MARCOS ou=ERP ou=Users cn=GLENN MARCOS Date 20180713 171932 -0400 Brenda J Billingsley THRU Brenda J Billingsley Director of Purchasing

FROM Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Nancy Olesen Digitally signed by Nancy Olesen DN dc=cty dc=broward dc=bc ou=Organization ou=BCC ou=PU ou=Users cn=Nancy Olesen Date 20180713 152608 -0400

SUBJECT Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115550P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

REFERENCE (a) Procurement Code Subsection 2183d (b) Procurement Code Subsection 2130f5

In accordance with reference (a) the Director of Purchasing reviews all submittals for responsiveness and recommends to the Evaluation Committee her findings which the Evaluation Committee may accept or arrive at a different conclusion Pursuant to Procurement Code Subsection 218b65 a responsive Bidder [proposer] means a person who has submitted a bid [proposal] which conforms in all material respects to a solicitation

The Request for Proposals (RFP) PNC2115559P1 included two (2) responsiveness requirements including Lobbyist Registration Certification Form and acknowledgement of ldquomustrdquo addenda All seven (7) proposers are recommended to be evaluated as responsive to all responsiveness requirements

In accordance with reference (b) the Evaluation Committee determines proposersrsquo responsibility Pursuant to Procurement Code Subsection 218b64 a responsible firm is one that has the capability in all respects to perform fully the contract requirements and the integrity and reliability which will assure good faith performance To assist the Evaluation Committee in this determination information regarding the Office of Economic and Small Business Development goals compliance the ldquomaterialrdquo litigation history disclosure financial information State of Florida authority to conduct business affiliated entities proof of insurance and licensing responsibility requirements are provided Six (6) proposers out of seven (7) proposers are recommended to be compliant to all responsibility requirements Florida Technical Consultants LLC is being recommended as non-compliant to the goal compliance responsibility requirement

This solicitation has a designated County Business Enterprise (CBE) goal of 25

A draft Director of Purchasingrsquos Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development Public Works Department Water and Wastewater Services the County Attorneyrsquos Office and the Risk Management Division were emailed to proposers with a request that if a proposer desires to clarify any information provided in their response they should do so in writing All written explanations received were subsequently reviewed by staff as applicable

Mark D Bogen bull Beam Furr bull Steve Geller bull Dale VC Holness bull Chip LaMarca bull Nan H Rich bull Tim Ryan bull Barbara Sharief bull Michael Udine Broward County Board of County Commissioners

wwwbrowardorg

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 2 of 12

After careful review of the information provided and the solicitationrsquos requirements the following recommendations are provided for consideration and final determination by the Evaluation Committee

A RESPONSIVENESS RECOMMENDATION Recommendations regarding the responsiveness of proposers to the requirements are based on the solicitationrsquos criteria

1 Lobbyist Registration - Certification A vendor who has retained a lobbyist(s) to lobby in connection with a competitive solicitation shall be deemed non-responsive unless the firm in responding to the competitive solicitation certifies that each lobbyist retained has timely filed the registration or amended registration required under Section 1-262 Broward County Code of Ordinances

A Lobbyist Registration Certification Form must be completed and returned upon request by the County if not included in the submittal

Name of Firm Recommendation Remarks

Arcadis US Inc Responsive Not Retained

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

Responsive Retained

Carollo Engineers Inc Responsive Not Retained

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

Responsive Not Retained

Hazen and Sawyer PC Responsive Not Retained

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

Responsive Not Retained

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

Responsive Not Retained

Additional Information

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation) has retained Bernie Friedman of Becker amp Poliakoff

2 ldquoMustrdquo Addenda

There were no ldquoMustrdquo Addenda for this RFP

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 3 of 12

B RESPONSIBILITY INFORMATION

The information provided below is intended to inform the Evaluation Committee regarding each proposerrsquos responsibility After careful review of the information provided and the solicitationrsquos requirements the following information is provided for consideration and final determination by the Evaluation Committee

1 Office of Economic and Small Business Development Program

The Broward County Business Opportunity Act of 2012 and the Disadvantaged BusinessEnterprise Program Title 49 Code of Federal Regulations Part 26 establish the Countyrsquospolicies for participation by Small Business Enterprises (SBE) County Business Enterprises (CBE) and Federal Disadvantaged Business Enterprises (DBErsquos) in County contracts

In accordance with the above the (CBEDBESBE) goal participation for this contract is 25

Name of Firm Responsibility Information Remarks

Arcadis US Inc Complies 27

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

Complies 26

Carollo Engineers Inc Complies 25

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

Does not Comply 0

Hazen and Sawyer PC Complies 25

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

Complies 75

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

Complies 30

Additional Information

Florida Technical Consultants LLC initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI) for this solicitation The firm was given three (3) business days to provide documentation demonstrating their good faith efforts to meet the goal Upon review of their good faith efforts OESBD has determined that Florida Technical Consultants LLC did not meet the efforts to meet this goal for this solicitation and is not in compliance with the CBE program requirements

Refer to the OESBD Compliance Memorandum for a report of the proposersrsquo CBE compliance history for projects completed within the last five (5) years of the RFP opening date

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 4 of 12

2 Disclosure of Litigation History The solicitation requests firms to disclose all material cases filed pending or resolved during the last three (3) years prior to the solicitation response due date whether such cases were brought by or against the vendor any parent or subsidiary of the vendor or any predecessor organization It is the responsibility of each proposer to identify and disclose to the County all ldquomaterialrdquo cases ldquoMaterialrdquo cases include cases involving work similar to the scope of work in this solicitation professional negligence malpractice default termination suspension poor performance bankruptcy and business related criminal offenses ldquoMaterialrdquo cases do not include cases that involve garnishment auto negligence personal injury workers compensation foreclosure or a proof of claim filed by the vendor

Name of Firm Responsibility Information Remarks

Arcadis US Inc 29 Disclosed Cases No litigation with Broward County

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

3 Disclosed Cases No litigation with Broward County

Carollo Engineers Inc 0 Disclosed Cases No litigation with Broward County

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

0 Disclosed Cases No litigation with Broward County

Hazen and Sawyer PC 4 Disclosed Cases No litigation with Broward County

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

0 Disclosed Cases No litigation with Broward County

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

3 Disclosed Cases No litigation with Broward County

3 Disclosure of Financial Information The information provided is based on a review by Water and Wastewater ServicesPublic Works Department Each Vendor shall submit its most recent two (2) years of financial statements for review The financial statements are not required to be audited financial statements The annual financial statements shall be in the form of

i Balance sheets income statements and annual reports or ii Tax returns or iii SEC filings

The disclosure of financial information by proposers is a matter of responsibility

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 5 of 12

Name of Firm Responsibility Information Remarks (Current Ratio)

Arcadis US Inc Provided 2017 Financials 160 Provided 2016 Financials 212

Brown and Caldwell Provided 2017 Financials 183 (Corporation) Provided 2016 Financials 178

Provided 2015 Financials 146

Carollo Engineers Inc Provided 2017 Financials 150 Provided 2016 Financials 161 Provided 2015 Financials 164

Florida Technical Consultants Provided 2017 Financials 187 LLC Provided 2016 Financials 164

Hazen and Sawyer PC Provided 2017 Financials 146 Provided 2016 Financials 142

LakdasYohalem Provided 2016 Financials 1511 Engineering Inc Provided 2015 Financials 142271

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Provided 2017 Financials 109 Mathews Consulting a Baxter Provided 2016 Financials 109 amp Woodman Company

Refer to the Financial Review Memorandum for any reportable conditions brought to the attention of the Evaluation Committee

4 Authority to Conduct Business in Florida A Florida corporation or partnership is required to provide evidence with its response that the firm is authorized to transact business in Florida and is in good standing with the Florida Department of State If not with its response such evidence must be submitted to the County upon request by the County

Name of Firm Responsibility Information Remarks

Arcadis US Inc Provided AuthorizedGood Standing

Brown and Caldwell Provided AuthorizedGood Standing (Corporation)

Carollo Engineers Inc Provided AuthorizedGood Standing

Florida Technical Provided AuthorizedGood Standing Consultants LLC

Hazen and Sawyer PC Provided AuthorizedGood Standing

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 6 of 12

LakdasYohalem Provided AuthorizedGood Standing Engineering Inc

Baxter amp Woodman Inc Provided AuthorizedGood Standing dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

5 Affiliated Entities of the Principal(s) All Vendors are required to disclose the names and addresses of ldquoaffiliated entitiesrdquo of the Vendorrsquos principal(s) over the last five (5) years (from the solicitation opening deadline) that have acted as a prime Vendor with the County ldquoAffiliated entitiesrdquo of the principal(s) are those entities related to the Vendor by the sharing of stock or other means of control including but not limited to a subsidiary parent or sibling entity

An Affiliated Entities Certification Form was included in the solicitation and must be completed and returned upon request by the County if not included in the original response

Name of Firm Responsibility Information Remarks

Arcadis US Inc Provided No Affiliates

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

Provided No Affiliates

Carollo Engineers Inc Provided No Affiliates

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

Provided No Affiliates

Hazen and Sawyer PC Provided No Affiliates

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

Provided No Affiliates

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

Provided No Affiliates

6 Insurance Requirements The solicitation indicated the insurance requirements deemed necessary for this project It is not necessary to have this level of insurance in effect at the time of submittal but it is necessary to submit certificates indicating that the firm currently carries the insurance or the vendor needs to submit a letter from the carrier indicating upgrade availability

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 7 of 12

Name of Firm Responsibility Information Remarks

Arcadis US Inc Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

Carollo Engineers Inc Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

Hazen and Sawyer PC Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

Additional Information

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company took exception to Article 831 The firm requested removal of the 831 mold fungus asbestos sexual molestation requirement indicating that this was not insurable

7 Licensing Requirements The solicitation stated that Proposers must provide evidence that they hold a current Professional Engineer license with the State of Florida

Name of Firm Responsibility Information Remarks

Arcadis US Inc Provided Compliant

Brown and Caldwell Provided Compliant (Corporation)

Carollo Engineers Inc Provided Compliant

Florida Technical Provided Compliant Consultants LLC

Hazen and Sawyer PC Provided Compliant

LakdasYohalem Provided Compliant Engineering Inc

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 8 of 12

Baxter amp Woodman Inc Provided Compliant dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

C COUNTY STANDARD TERMS AND CONDITIONS INFORMATION The acceptance of or any exceptions taken to the terms and conditions of the Countyrsquos Agreement shall be considered a part of a Vendorrsquos submittal and will be considered by the Evaluation Committee The applicable Agreement terms and conditions for this solicitation were indicated in the Special Instructions to Vendors Vendors were required to review the applicable terms and conditions and submit the Agreement Exception Form If the Agreement Exception Form is not provided with the submittal it shall be deemed an affirmation by the Vendor that it accepts the Agreement terms and conditions as disclosed in the solicitation If exceptions are taken the Vendor must specifically identify each term and condition with which it is taking an exception

Name of Firm Agree Exceptions

Arcadis US Inc No Article 4 ndash Liquidated Damages

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

Yes None

Carollo Engineers Inc Yes None

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

Yes None

Hazen and Sawyer PC Yes None

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

Yes None

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

No Article asbestosrequirement

831 ndash Mold fungus sexual molestation

D REFERENCES The solicitationrsquos Evaluation Criteria ndash Project Specific Criteria Page 18 Question 3 request that completed references be provided for previous experience and projects Attached are the references as verified by County staff

E PERFORMANCE EVALUATIONS The Broward County Purchasing Division Contracts Central indicates evaluation scores for the proposing firms previously awarded contracts Completed performance evaluations may be provided upon request

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 9 of 12

Attached are Contracts Central performance evaluation history for each vendor as applicable including evaluation type (renewal goals compliance or final) and recommendation for future contracts (yes no or conditional) If a firm has periodic evaluations it will be listed separately

Additional Information In response to the Purchasing Directorrsquos Draft Memorandum to which the vendor can respond within 48 hours to any comments or deficiencies noted in the Purchasing DirectorrsquosDraft Memorandum Brown and Caldwell (Corporation) had a score that was highlighted in bright orange The bright orange highlight indicates that the firm receive an individual scoreof 1 or 2 on an item for that evaluation

F CONE OF SILENCE VIOLATIONS The Cone of Silence for this procurement has been in effect since May 3 2018 which prohibits potential vendors from discussing this solicitation with the Evaluation Committee the County Administrator Deputy County Administrator Assistant County Administrator Assistants to the County Administrator their respective support staff and any other person authorized to evaluate or recommend selection in this procurement process

Upon the first meeting of the Evaluation Committee the Cone of Silence expands to also include County Commissioners and their staff Potential vendors and their representatives are substantially restricted from communicating with County Commissioners and their staff regarding this procurement as stated in the Cone of Silence Ordinance

After application of the Cone of Silence inquiries regarding this solicitation should be directed to the Director of Purchasing or designee The Cone of Silence terminates when the County Commission or other awarding authority takes action which ends the solicitation Vendors are required to certify that they have read understand and will comply with the Cone of Silence Ordinance Section 1-266 Broward County Code of Ordinances

The following is a report of the proposersrsquo Cone of Silence violations

Name of Firm Remarks Violations

Arcadis US Inc Will Comply 1

Brown and Caldwell Will Comply None (Corporation)

Carollo Engineers Inc Will Comply None

Florida Technical Will Comply None Consultants LLC

Hazen and Sawyer PC Will Comply None

LakdasYohalem Engineering Will Comply None Inc

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 10 of 12

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Will Comply None Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

Additional Information

Arcadis US Inc had one violation 2011 - Robert Daoust Principal Scientist Malcolm PirnieArcadis US Inc

Additional Information In response to the Purchasing Directorrsquos Draft Memorandum to which the vendor can respond within 48 hours to any comments or deficiencies noted in the Purchasing DirectorrsquosDraft Memorandum Arcadis US Inc provided information that the cone of silence violationwas from a former employee

G VOLUME OF PREVIOUS WORK - EVALUATION CRITERIA ANDOR TIE BREAK CRITERIA The solicitation states that a number of points will be allocated for volume of previous work of the firm for the past five (5) years The volume of work for each of the proposing firms is as follows

Name of Firm Proposer Reported County Reported Points Allocated

Arcadis US Inc $24988700 $9597102 5 Points

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

$477974497 $477974497 3 Points

Carollo Engineers Inc $214076903 $214076903 5 Points

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

$000 $000 5 Points

Hazen and Sawyer PC

$2164284300 $2221320722 0 Points

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

$5894000 $5894030 5 Points

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

$000 $000 5 Points

Additional Information

5 points allocated to vendors paid $0 to $3000000 3 points allocated to vendors paid $3000001 to $7500000 1 point allocated to vendors paid $7500001 to $10000000 0 points allocated to vendors paid over $10000000

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 11 of 12

H PRINCIPAL BUSINESS LOCATION The solicitation states that a number of points will be allocated for location of the firm The Vendorrsquos principal address in Broward County shall be the Vendorrsquos ldquoPrincipal Addressrdquo as indicated with the Florida Department of State Division of Corporations for at least six (6) months prior to the solicitationrsquos due date A proposer with a principal business location within Broward County will receive five (5) points A proposer not having its principal business location within Broward County will receive zero (0) points

The results are as Proposed Attested Location Verified Points Allocated followsName of Nerve Center in SunBiz Firm

Arcadis US Inc 630 Plaza Drive Suite 10 YES 0 Highlands Ranch CO

Brown and Caldwell 201 North Civic Drive YES 0 (Corporation) Suite 300

Walnut Creek CA

Carollo Engineers 2700 Ygnacio Valley YES 0 Inc Road Suite 300

Walnut Creek CA

Florida Technical 533 East Ocean Avenue YES 0 Consultants LLC Suite 2

Boynton Beach FL

Hazen and Sawyer 4000 Hollywood YES 5 PC Boulevard Suite 750

North Hollywood FL

LakdasYohalem 2211 NE 54th Street YES 5 Engineering Inc Fort Lauderdale FL

Baxter amp Woodman 477 S Rosemary Avenue YES 0 Inc dba Mathews Suite 330 Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company West Palm Beach FL

Additional Information In response to the Purchasing Directorrsquos Draft Memorandum to which the vendor canrespond within 48 hours to any comments or deficiencies noted in the Purchasing Directorrsquos Draft Memorandum Hazen and Sawyer PC principal address as verified in Sunbiz is 4000Hollywood Blvd Suite 750N Hollywood FL 33021

I LOCAL PREFERENCE A vendor is eligible to be considered a local business for Local Preference purposes if it has a physical business address located within the limits of Broward County The vendor must provide a valid business tax receipt issued by Broward County at least one (1) year prior to bid or proposal opening

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 12 of 12

Broward Countyrsquos Local Preference Ordinance specifically excludes the application of a local preference for professional services procured pursuant to Section 287055 FS (CCNA)

J LOCATION - TIE BREAKER A Vendor located within Broward County is eligible for the Location Tie Breaker The County requires a copy of the Broward County Business Tax receipt for a period of time of at least six (6) months prior to the solicitation deadline and it must be provided with its initial submittal

The results are as follows

Name of Firm Eligibility Broward County Tax Receipt

Arcadis US Inc Eligible Provided

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

Eligible Provided

Carollo Engineers Inc Eligible Provided

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

Eligible Provided

Hazen and Sawyer PC Eligible Provided

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

Eligible Provided

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

Eligible Provided

Attachments 1 Vendor Reference Verifications 2 Vendor Performance Evaluations 3 Vendor Responses to Draft Memo

c Bob Melton County Auditor Office of the County Auditor Robert Wilson Title Division Department (Project Manager) Martha Perez-Garviso Purchasing Manager Purchasing Division Finance and Administrative Services Department Glenn Miller Assistant County Attorney Office of the County Attorney Fernando Amuchastegui Assistant County Attorney Office of the County Attorney

BJBGMnomm

Broward County Board of PNC211 5559P1 County Commissioners

BRCWARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LO ~ I DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P 1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis us Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

South Florida Water Management District

Contact Name Rich V irgil PE Title Bureau Chief lnfrabReference date 05142018

Contact Email rvirgilsfwmdgov Contact Phone 561 6826759

Name of Referenced Project S-193 Lock Refurbishment C-41A Canal Bank Stabilization Lake

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

4600000790 1001 2008 UP 12012016 $ 295400000

Vendors role in Project ]rime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Engineering Design and Engineering Services During Construction

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D [] DD c Deliverables []D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [L] D c Turnover D D D0

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget []D D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm [L]D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D 0 D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [] D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via ~AI L VERBAL Verified by ~~ Division WWfD Date ltQamp~(8 All lnformallon provided to Bltoward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate unlrulhful or incorrect statements made In support of this response may be used by the

512gt~11MlflS a lgtasis Of rejection rescission of the award or tenninallon of the contract and ~~lVcrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 of lhe Broward Count~ 41l6tlrelfient Code Y fTmiddot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BR~ltJWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LO R I DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering SeNices for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Saint Petersburg Department of Engineering and Capital Planning

Contact Name Nicole Allen Title CADDGIS Supervi Reference date

Contact Email nicoleallenstpeteorg Contact Phone 727-893-7316

Name of Referenced Project Water Resources Department GIS Data Migration

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

13-03-ARCIT 12092014 UP 09152015 $ 5925000

Vendors role in Project ]rime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again (Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Migration ofwater wastewater and storm water infrastructure information from CAD environment to Esri Local Government Information Model

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D [] D c Deliverables D [] D D

2 Vendors Organization [ZJa Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D [ZJ D c Turnover D D [] D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [ZJ D b Deliverables D D [ZJ D

4 Project completed within budget [ZJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [ZJ D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) [ZJD D D c Regu latory Agency(ies) D D [ZJ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONL rbullbull

Verified via L L VERBAL Verified by Division NlltE~ Date 6(~oatgt 1 8~ All information PfOvided to Bfoward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful oc inCOfrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

512gt9lillll jS a basis 10lt rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and nlll~9rrcrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of lhe Broward Cou~ 42fldtclrhtflent Code middot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BRuWARD1 1 COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering SeNices for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

C ity of Tavares F lorida

Contact Name James Dillon Title Public Works DireltaReference date 05172018

Contact Email jdillontavaresorg Contact Phone 352-455-7718

Name of Referenced Project G IS Modeling and Integration of Utilities Infrastructure

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

060330480000 04012017 UP 10012017 $ 5676000

Vendors role in Project ]rime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Integrate drawings and images depicting pipe infrastructure into a GIS environment for easy retrieval First project of a multi phase program to upgrade the Citys GIS information

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D 0 D c Deliverables D D 0 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D Ill D b Professionalism D D Ill D c Turnover D D 0 D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D Ill D b Deliverables D D Ill D

4 Project completed within budget D D Ill D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D Ill D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D Ill D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY -

Ve rified via L IL VERBAL Verified by fcAJ~ Division llt E1) Date 1 r~ tjlQ t8 All information pwvlded to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incooect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

512G91JlIHIS a basis for rejection rescission or the award or termination or the contract and lnfli~9ncrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 of the Broward CouI)~ 44flamplrelflent Code

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BRd~WARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LO R I DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Miramar

Contact Name Robin E Bain PE Title Project Manager Reference date 05142018

Contact Email rebainmiramarflgov Contact Phone 9548836825

Name of Referenced Project East Water Treatment Plant Replacement Wells and Design-Build

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PO 172624-00 10222017 UP 05142018 $ 56929600

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [ZJYes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Design permitting construction services for new Deep Injection Well and 4 new (replacement) production wells

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy []D D D c Deliverables D []D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D [ZJ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Turnover D D D []

3 Timeliness of a Project D D lZ1 D b Del iverables D D lZ1 D

4 Project completed within budget D D lZ1 D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor( s)Subconsultant( s) D D lZ1 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D lZ1 D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY (

Verified via A IL VER BAL Verified by faltJ~ Division WltEtgt Date 5 ~io l 9 All inlOllllalion pltovided to Broward County is subjecl lo verificalioo VendOt acknowledges lhal lnaccurale unlrulhful or i ncooecl stalemenls made in suppOltI of lhis response may be used by lhe

512gt~llM (lS a basis lot rejeclion rescission of the award or termination of lhe contract and mll~Arrcrve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuanl 10 Section 21119 of lhe Broward Couoty 43Pldtllrbrllent Code Y flmiddot

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Palm Beach County Water Utilities Department

Contact Name Ali Bayat Title Assistant Director Reference date

Contact Email abayatpbcwatercom Contact Phone 561 493 6128

Name of Referenced Project System 8 Water Quality Assessment

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

17-021 CSA21 01 022017 to 01152018 $ 8936000

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again (Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Brown and Caldwell led assessment of contributing causes to low system residuals troubleshooting treatment processes special testing and data analysis improvements to operating protocols monitoringcontrol system and treatment process

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [Z] D b Accuracy D [Z] DD c Deliverables D [Z]D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D [Z] D b Professionalism D D [Z] D c Turnover D [Z] DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D [Z] D

4 Project completed within budget D D [Z] D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Consultant worked collaboratively with operating maintenance engineering and laboratory staff to develop insight into contributing factors and implement improvements

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via _LEMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by tcltJ1~ Division -+LN euro P Date lteh IWt 8 All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the County as a basis for rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and may also serve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward County Procurement Code

BltaWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F L 0 R I D A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood Florida

Contact Name Steve Joseph Title Director Reference date

Contact Email sjosephhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954 921 3522

Name of Referenced Project Distribution System Water Quality Improvement

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

01012016 to 06022017 $ 3000000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again []Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Supported the City with its efforts improve chlorine residuals in areas of its system Analysis included system modeling monitoring optimized operational practices Implemented operational improvements that significantly raised (from approx 05 to 20 mgL) chloramine residuals In the most challenging area of the system

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D D [] D c Deliverables []D D D

2 Vendors Organization [] Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D [] D c Turnover D D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D [] D

4 Project completed within budget []D D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) []D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [] D

Additional Com ments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Effort Included system modoling moniloring and excursion response procedures opllmitallon of stored Inventory management unidirectional flushing pilot assessment and treatment proooss evaluation

Verified via __EMAIL vERBAL Division WW ED Date G Ifgt I 8 All infonmallon pltovided to Broward County Is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of thi s response may be used by lhe County as a basis for rejeclion rescission or the award or tenminatlon of the contract and may also serve as the basis for debanment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 or lhe Broward County Procurement Code

BROWARD t (l)t~ 1 Vendor Reference Verification Form

fl O R I OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of West Palm Beach Florida

Contact Name Jay Kwag Title Project Manager Reference date

Contact Email hjkwagwpborg Contact Phone 561 494 1041

Name of Referenced Project Modeling and Infrastructure General Engineering Consulting Assigments

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

11032014 to HAlt zc1e (on~vi~)

Vendors role in Project 52fPrime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IQves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Planning and General Eng1neerg Servicus 1nctuslve ol Waterwastewater System Master Pian asset management program dovo10pmenV11sset Crt1tcat1ty assessment Mesler PS 115 and sewer cond1hon assessment hydrauhc modeling ol LS 5 and force main sizing water system Capacity Analysis RoPort nydraullc modeling ol operahonat challongos tilt ste11on enatysbulls lac11i1a1e 1nspec11011 or major FM and new develOpmenl 1mpnc1s plpohno design lilt station condbullhon assessment and renabtlilahon (Various ProJecls)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D 0 D b Accuracy D 0D D c Deliverables D D 0 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D Gt D b Professionalism D D ~-- D c Turnover D D Gr D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D B D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget D D r~r D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D c~r D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D 0 D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION F~USE ONLY

__VERBAL Verified via LMAIL Verified by ~J Division ~~~D Date ~ f 2 f~t8 All lnfo11na1t0n pr ()Vl(fed 10 Broward County is svb1et110 ven11ca1ion vendor acknowledges lhll 1naeoura10 unlrulhful 0lt inc0ltrec1 s1a1emen1s medo In support ol 1n1s response may be used Dy the County as a basis fcu rejection re sclsst0n Of 1ho award or 1ormina1lon of l he contract and may also servo as the basis for debarment o f Vendor pursuant lo Section 21 119 of tho ampoward Counly P1ocuremont Code

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A middot

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Michael Low Title Deputy Director Reference date 05172018

Contact Email lowmbbflus Contact Phone 5617426403

Name of Referenced Project Ion Exchange Design Build

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

07022014 to 03212018 $ 100000000

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Carollo handled all of the design and construction of a significant part of the project as a subcontractor to COM Constructors as part of a progressive design build contract

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [Z] D b Accuracy D D [Z] D c Deliverables D D [Z] D

2 Vendors Organization D D [Z] Da Staff expertise b Professionalism D D [Z] D c Turnover D D D [Z]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D [Z] D

4 Project completed within budget D D [Z] D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D [Z] D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [Z] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION F~ COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ~~ Division W -NED Date S-gtozot~ All Information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor aclltnowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

Stii191111X 11s a basis for rejection rescission of the award or termination or the conlact and m~~Arifrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward CounYJ 33Plamptl1til1ent Code Y Imiddot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

B~OWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LORID A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

South Florida Water Management District

Contact Name Greg Coffelt PE Title SFWMD Project Manager Reference date 05172018

Contact Email gcoffeltsfwmdgov Contact Phone 561-682-6853

Name of Referenced Project L-8 Reservoir Inflow Structure and Pump Station

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

4600000861 02152011 to 09192012 $ 144535100

Vendors role in Project [l) Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [l)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Corolla was contracted as an Owners Advisor for a Design-Build contract developed engineering design criteria assisted in RFQ development and evaluation supported RFP technical proposal and cost proposal analysis

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [l] D b Accuracy D [] D D c Deliverables D [] D D

2 Vendors Organization [l]a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D [l] D c Turnover D D D [l]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [l] D b Deliverables D [l] D D

4 Project completed within budget [l] DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [l] D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) [l] DD D c Regu latory Agency(ies) D D D [l]

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Owner Advisor work continued(s) in support of Construction of Pump Station Inflow Gate Structure and levee hardening

Verified via IMAIL __VERBAL Date 5 ( 3 c b() I a All information piovided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that Inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made In support of this response may be used by the

512G9JiIX 11s a basis for rejection rescission or the award or termination or the contract and rllffl~Anampe as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 or the Broward CojlftYi 34~6ttlrbtflent Code Y

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

B0~~AARD ~~t~UNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

Fl ORIOA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Sunrise

Contact Name Luisa Fernanda Arbelaa Title Project Manager Reference date 05162018

Contact Email LArbelaezsunrlseflgov Contact Phone 954-888-6009

Name of Referenced Project City of Sunrise - Springtree WTP Water Stabilization and Solids Handling

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PA 16-003-CE 04072016 to 05292018 $ 50797800

Vendors role in Project ]Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [l]Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Carollo Engineers performed the design study and construction administration services for the City

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D G6 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Carollo Engineers technical knowledge and attenllon lo detall were beneficial lo the pltojad They ecled in lhe C~ys besl Interest In every aspect for lhe d1K8Uon of the projectbull

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via ~MAIL _VERBAL Verified by fc4J~~ Division W fl ED All lnrormalion provided to Broward ltAunty Is oobjoci to vorirtcotion Vendoc ecknowledgu that 1naowrate unlMhfuf 0lt lncocrecl statements rnado In support or this response may be useltI by lhe County as a basis for rejection rescission or the award 0lt termination ol the convect and may also ampOIVe as the babullibull ror debarmont of vondOlt purauont to Section 21119 or the Broward County Proc11oment Code

Bid Sync p 135 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BftQNARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

I l 0 R I 0 A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Florida Technical Consultants

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

VIiiage of Wellington Utilities

Contact Name Bradley Wolak Title Assistant Director Ut11Reference date 5182018

Contact Email bwolakwelllngtonflgov Contact Phone 561-753-2480

Name of Referenced Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 10012017 to Present 3500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vend~ 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again UZfYes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor J_ rJ fJ j(Gr-~k 6 Jti ov1 ~uf-Jiy fgt-r_- syrrzi~ff~ Al

R Q_ d--1 0~l 4 171 i+CI ~~lHI )Please rate your experience with tile Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Applicablereferenced Vendor Improvement

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy B D

DD c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D Db Professionalism D D

c Turnover D DD 3 Timeliness of

a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant(s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Additional Comments (provide on addltjpnal sheetJf needed) bull ~middot$ -JJ fo~~rltjbull lt( c-c_ ~~~ lt fo L1-lfAR- -middot~ I 10 ~ ~

~ bullL ~~ _te_ l~Ilgt~Cef t J ~ l rfbull4 middot r0 laquo r 4111J w f1 rrr- 0r- -i-HIS SECTION(9R COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by fcAJc ~ Division Y-1 IN ED Date 5 ~o w8 All lnfonn1Uon ptollfded to BlOward County le eubjeet to vetfflcatlon Vendor aclltnowledge1 that lneccurale unllJlhfUl or lnconect -bullmenla made In 1UPPort o1 this reopon90 may be uoec1 by the couniy ae a baalS ror re)ectlon re8Claeton Of the award 0t leltmlnatlon Of the contract and may 1l10 MM ae the baale flaquo debarrnont 01 vendor pu11uant to Section 21119 of ll1e Broward County Procurement Codo

BidSync p 18 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F LUFltIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultants LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Palm Beach Public Works

Contact Name Gerry Vazquez Title WRD Technician Reference date 05182018

Contact Email gvazqueztownofpalmbeachcom Contact Phone 772-546-6859

Name of Referenced Project GIS Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 3242014 to Present 13500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [3yenes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

PrwAamprs- favl49z Please rate your experience with the Need a Satlafactory Excellent Not

Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D g- D b Accuracy D Er D c Deliverables g-shyB D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D GJ D b Professionalism D D G- D c Tu mover D D cg- D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D g D b Deliverables D D Qshy D

4 Project completed within budget D D lbJ- D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D El- Db Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [3- D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

BidSync p 17 51232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

120-nWARDLll~ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form fLORllgtA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultant LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Waneya Bryant Title Meter Serv Mgr Reference date 05182018

Contact Email BryantWbbflus Contact Phone 561-742-6427

Name of Referenced Project Boynton Beach Utility GIS Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 12012016 to Present $15000000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

~T~ 5e-r-vtleamp +roM l)h f-es Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D Dc Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ti4 D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ Db Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on addlUonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION~urv USE ONLy u bull

Verified via VEMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by kuJ~ Division W if E D rao(ao8Date 5

All Information provided to Browslaquo COOlty Is Slbject to verfflcation Vendor acKnowledges that lneocurate Untruthful or lncolleel 8tatements made In support d this rfl9pOn98 may be used by 1119 Counly as a batia falt rejection relduion ct Ille award or lemilnlilon of the contract and may al80181Veaa1119 basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 ot Ille Broward CountyProcurement Code

512312018 BidSync p 16

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1

8W1V~isl1War Bid PNC21 15559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Fonn

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Cooper City - middot

Contact Name Michael Bailey PE itle Utilities DlrCity EbullReference date 05011201s

Contact Email MBalleycoopercityflorg Contact Phone (954) 434-5519

Name of Referenced Project City of Cooper City Continuing Professional Services bullContract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

RFQ 2009middot 1 04242009 to Present $ 2 19844200

Vendors role in Project IZJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Since 2009 Hazen has provided Cooper City with engineering services or water and wastewater projects Projects have lnctudeo lhe Pine Island Road Pump Station Lilt S1alions 2 amp 49 Improvements Master Plan Update of the FeaslJl~lty Review of Infrastructure Improvements tor Wastewater and the Eflluent Reuse and Disposal Master Plan

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy 8 D

D ~ D c Deliverables D 0 ~ D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D 0 D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tumover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D GJ- D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D 0 D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) ~D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

bull-rHIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY-

Verified vie EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ct4~ Division ~tUb Date ~ i3~) 0fgt All Information provided to BltCgtWW County 11 wbed ID vamprificalion Velldot adltnowledgu that lnaoewate unlrUhful lncom1ct statemampnla made in wppolt of 11111 response may blt uHd by the

4t2j=~ rejection rHclsslcn of th8 award or lennhallon of Ille eoo1nlct and may also seNamp at tilt basis for dtbarmenl at Vendor puuan1 lo Sectioo 21119 of the Broward COltJi 43

5232018 Bid Sync p24

Broward County Board of PNC211 5559P1

~RiiirilyenlcHUffi~~8CrW~r Bid PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

8DdMARD _ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FL O RIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Fort Lauderdale

Contact Name Rares Patrica PE Title Senior Project Mgr Reference date os1021201s

Contact Email RPetricafortlauderdalegov Contact Phone 9548287150

Name of Referenced Project Stormwater Master Planning and Design Implementation Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

256-11660 04192016 to 04192021 $ 989400000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

vyould you use this vendor again Sves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor The Hazen team Is responsible for delivery of a new stormwaler master plan model a prlorlllzed slormwaterresllency capital Improvements plan and Implementation of designs to address chronic flooding and other slormwater management challenges In the City Primary work tasks Include data collectlon hydrologlclhydraullc modeling and design permitting and construction services for capllal Improvement projects resulting from the revised stormwater master plan (preltmlnary design In seven priority neighborhoods)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION ~R COUNTY USE ONLY

aJ~Verified via pound MA IL _VERBAL Verified by Division W1~tl Date 5 ~3o~ax l S N I informallon p roviltled lo Broward County is sulljecl lo verification Vendor altknowledjj6s lhal inaccurate unlMhlut or lncotreci statements m ade In support of this respon$e may be used by tho

412~-~ rejeclion rescission of the award or termination ol lhe contracl and may also serve as lhe basis for debalment ol Vendor purwant to Section 21119 ol lhe Broward Cou~ 4 3

5232018 Bid Sync p25

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 Br~~~~~rs Bid PNC2115559P1 County t ommissioners

B~uWARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FlOR I CA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

Solicitation PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and s OrganizationFirm Name p

Town of Jupiter

nee

Contact Email davidbjupiterflus Contact Phone (561) 746-5134

Name of Referenced Project Engineering Services for Stormwater and Water Capital Improvements

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount $ 630000000 W17248 (2017 reselection 1012000 to Present (estimated lee-to-date since contract inception) contract number)

Vendors role in Project IZI Prime Vendor osubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again 0Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Descriotion of services orovided bv Vendor Since 2000 Hazen has served as General Consulfant to the Town or Jupiter As General Stormwater and Water Consullant the firm has provided services related to master planning stormwater planning and modeling design NPDES permilling asset management resiliency ratefinancial analysis plan review and construction oversight Water-related capital projs have involved additional system storage and high-service pumping transmission system improvements and RampR at existing facilities

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Verllied via EMAIL _ VERBAL Division WWC D

fo (J-Vv ~ltIvmiddotj Date 5(30(ipf S

Al lnroimallon pngtYICGd 10 Broward Counly Is sub)oel to v8flrcallon vendlaquo acknowledges lhat Inaccurate unlruthlu~ 0t Jnwrrect slatoments made In support ol this response may be used by the 42~~1~0 rojecllon rescission or Ille award or termination or lhe con~acl bullnd mbully also serve as tho basis r0t debarment of Vendor pursuant lo Socllon 21119 of lho Broward Couw 41

5232018 BidSync p 26

a N ~ IL) IL) N u z a_

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLO RI DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Walter Wernecke RA Title Sr Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email WWERNECKEhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Hollywood Marina Restrooms

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

04152015 to Present 7500000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor OSubconsultanVSubcontractor n ~U t1

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

-0 Vgt Description of services provided by VendorO ~ ~ Q) Structural Design and Construction Inspection Services i co Q m ~- c E c0

i E gt Oo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not () uu Appllcable O

E~ referenced Vendor Improvement iii ~sectoO 1 Vendors Quality of Service B mu a Responsive D D

b Accuracy DD c Deliverables D DD

2 Vendors Organization D Da Staff expertise v D b Professionalism~ D D c Turnover D ~D

3 Timeliness of D a Project b Deliverables D ~

4 Pec~~11~$~hinJ~~qt lfr D D 5 Cooperation with f ~

a Your Firm D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D

Al lnfonn1tion pRgttded IO Brwd Cltgtunly lo 1ubjecl IO ibllon vsor ~middot Iha icl-bullmiddot ~ ir-ect slalemenls mode In _ol lhb _ moy ti used by he County as a basis lot rejecUon rnclnlon cl the eward or tonnlnallan of lhl connct 1nd may bullllo 11 the basis for dobalment of Vendor IQtulnl IO SICllOn 21119 at lhe Broword County Procurement Code

Cl ltraquo I() I() I() N ()

Cl z

BRltJWARD ~ middot COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORl OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Davie

Contact Name Emilio DeSimone Title Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email Emilio_DeSimonedavie-fl gov Contact Phone 954-797-1085

Name of Referenced Project Pavillion 5 Linear Park

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

B-17-123 09152015 to 2700000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor O SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es O No If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

0 Description of services provided by Vendor O Q)

iii c Structural Design and Construction Inspection ServicesoQ

CDi-

0cc E gt=gt E ()Oo O () () Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

ii) -e i- Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 111 cs

B ioO

J 1 Vendors Quality of Service Q ()

a Responsive D D b Accuracy D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization []Ll Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D Dtr

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [g D b Deliverables D D ar D

4 Project completed within budget [1tD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) cgD D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via l EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by ~h~ Division WlI Etgt Date 0 f l~o I 8 All lnformaUon provided lO Broward County Is eubJect 10 verifutlon Vendor ecknOMedgoo that lnaocurote unNlhlul or Incorrect statamenle made In aupl)Ort of this reaponse may be used by lho County et o baampla for rejection realtluion of the award or lermlnallon of tho eon1fllcl ond moy olao aorvo os ho basis for debarmont of Vondor purauenl lo Section 21119 of the Broward Counly Procuremen1 Code

0 0 agt a c () z 0

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Terrence Comiskey AIA Title Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email TCOMISKEYhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Van Buren Parking Garage

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PK 14-053 Nov 2014 to Present 8310000

Vendors role in Project t8(Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

o~ Description of services provided by Vendor 1 Q)ltO c Structural Design and Conslructlon Inspection Services 0 Q

0~Jl ccE l E enOo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

gtshy

uu O Improvement Applicable ffireferenced Vendor

~sect 1 Vendors Quality of Service 1 ~

oOau a Responsive D ~ D b Accuracy B D D

D D [- Dc Deliverables

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tum over D D D g

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ D Subcontractor(s )S ubcons u ltant( s)b D D ~ D

c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D yenj D Additional Comments provide on sdditlonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION ~NTY USE ONLY0

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by kW Division W-1-(i~ Date EJo(a~t8 Al lnform1Uon PltOVlded lo Browald Ccxnty It IUbjoct to vorificallon Vendor eoknowfodgea thal lnaewralt U111MhlJI deg inlaquogtlaquobullel amptal11ants made In eupporl of lhls relj)Onse may be used by Iha Counly es a balls l0t rcfecllon rescfuloltI of tho ew1rd or 1ermtnaU0lt1 ol lhbull conllllCI and may elao urve 11 lho basis for dabarmenl of Vondor pursuanl lo Secllon 21 119 of he erowald COUlly CiProcurement Code

~ N ii

00

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 aOWllrp Commficumlref Bid PNC2116615B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Pompano Beach FL

Contact Name Mr A Randolph Brown Title Utilities Director Reference date April 30 2018

Contact Email randolphbrowncopbflcom Contact Phone 954-545-7043

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 201 o Project Amount fees varied

Multiple

Vendors role in Project IKJ Prime Vendor

to 2018

osubconsultanUSubcontractor

(range $10000shy$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D ~ D D c Deliverables D ~ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D ~ D D b Professionalism D D ~ D C Turnover D El DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ 0 b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D [BJ D n c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [XJ o ~

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed) amp~~it -THIS SECTION ~COUNTY USE ONL y-bullbull

Verified via ~AIL __VERBAL Verified by 1lt4 )~ Division N WE O Date 5 faol Z1 18

All lnformotlon providod to BltownrltI Cou nty it aubjoct O verification VendOr acknowledges that lnaccornto untruthful or incorroct 11atomon1s made in support of this response may be used by tho

411p~~)~~J rojoclion roscissioo ol lho award or 1orroinalion of tho contract and roay also s01vo as lhbull basis f0lt d~arroont of VondOf pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward Cou)l1

Bid Sync p 73

40

5232018

Broward County Board of Bid PNC2116659B 1 County Commissioners

B~aWARD gt1- t COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Loxahatchee River Environmental Control District

Contact Name Mr Kris Dean Title Director of Engineering Reference date May 9 2018

Contact Email krisdeanloxahatcheeriverorg Contact Phone 561-747-5700

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 2001 Project Amount fees varied (range $10000shyMultiple to 2018 $250000)

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IR)Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D ~ D D b Accuracy D 0 D D c Deliverables D IBJ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D IB] D D b Professionalism D ~ D D c Turnover D [8J D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D [8J D D b Deliverables D m D D

4 Project completed within budget D ~ D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D ~ D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D Ii] D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D ~ D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SE~ FOR~USE ONLY

Verified via _lEMAIL __VERBAL Verified by ~lt Division fWeb Date I

All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untrulhful or incorrecl slatements made In support of this response may be used by the lJl~~~l~~jSfiir rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and mll~~~ere as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Co)f 10

Broward County Board of Bid PNC21166$9B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A l

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Lake Worth FL

Contact Name Mr Felipe Lofaso TitleAsst Dir Public-ServicesReference date May 9 2018

Contact Email flofasolakeworthorg Contact Phone 561-586-1720

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contract

Contract No Date Services Provided 2014 Project Amount fees varied Multiple to 2018 (range $10000shy

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Services included multiple municipal engineering projects including survey roadway design utility design and coordination (water wastewater stormwater other) along with project management

Needs Satisfactory Excellent NotPlease rate your experience with the Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D GJ D b Accuracy D D Ii] D c Deliverables D Ii] DD

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [i] D c Turnover D D D [X]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D 0 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [X] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION Fe COUNTY USE ONLrbullbull

Verified via MAIL __VERBAL Verified by Division ~wgtgt Date 5~3ol20t8 All information provided to Broward County Is subject lo verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect slalements made in support ol this response may be used by the

OZ~id~~~~j~r rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and m~~~(iirve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Cour~ iG

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - ARCADIS US INC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts

VS0000013130 VS00013130 - ARCADIS US INC Prime Work Auth Vendor SummaryProjects

PURCHASING 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold Procurement No Fixed Contracts FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Favorites Past 5 Years Prime Vendor

Sub Vendor From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 10042017 Purchase Order

Evaluation Purchase Orders 1 POs With A Total Amt Of $20000000 Log Off Paid To Dt ($12132949) Balance $7867051

Contracts Purchase Orders Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx 6192018

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Finish

PURCHASING Weighted Scores Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract FileRoom DashBoard Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number FileRoom Insert

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel Favorites Prime Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Service Evaluation

6132017 YES 486 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Goals Compliance Evaluation

10272016 YES 460 View Docs (0)

6272018

Project Management Information System

Close

Contracts Central Administration

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9130 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-24

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6182018 YES 355 View Docs (1)

Proj Nbr 9320 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-20

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6132018 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9290 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-23

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1122018 YES 494 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-21

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12182017 YES 488 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10162017 YES 473 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

8252017 YES 495 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9321 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-19

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

7112017 YES 476 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-17

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2272017 YES 400 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

10132016 YES 384 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-12

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

5202016 YES 405 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9018 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-06

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10192015 YES 448 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

3202015 YES 385 View Docs (0)

Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL CONSULTANTS

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Project Management Information System

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-04

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12122014 YES 437 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-08

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1242014 YES 423 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-02

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2282014 YES 452 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC

VC0000044184 VC00044184 - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres PS $001 Used $000 Remain $001 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $354848400 Closed 0 Total $000 Total Current Retainage Balance For All Contracts $793370 No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 06292015 Purchase Orders 2 POs With A Total Amt Of $362317900 Paid To Dt ($218795160) Balance $143522740

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 40803 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9058 - DISTRICT 3A POTABLE WATER STORAGE

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1220410P1 - Consultant Engineering Services for Potable Water FixedOpen Contracts Storage Tanks and Pumping Systems Work Auth Prime Vendor CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Periodic Final Finish

Log Off Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type

Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

6232015 8302017 413 Approved 8312017 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard

Enter Vendor Name (or a portion of) Then Click Search - Wilcards Are Permitted (ie wa wawainc) Florida Technical Consultants

Search Reset Finish

No Vendors Found For Your Search Try Again

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41005 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score Go

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0773

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

12122017 YES 430 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

8302016 YES 438 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Final Consultant Evaluation 3142016 YES 478 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0706

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

142016 YES 402 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9016OES - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0731

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

10192015 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0748

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

612015 YES 467 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

2192015 YES 500 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0754

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

252015 YES 409 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0755

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

1242014 YES 415 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8974 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0758

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

6202014 YES 393 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr

WATER amp WASTEWATER

Final Consultant Work Authorization 572014 YES 423 View Docs

(0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

HS0746 ENGINEERING Evaluation

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

4302014 YES 475 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Evaluation 4302014 YES 493 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0710

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

3172014 YES 395 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0753

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

1212014 YES 380 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0763

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

11192013 YES 450 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0775

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 408 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals

Finish

Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed FileRoom DashBoard Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization FileRoom Insert NumberFavorites

Prime Vendor Export To Excel Sub Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0772

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 417 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0771

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

2262013 YES 410 View Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 2: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 2 of 12

After careful review of the information provided and the solicitationrsquos requirements the following recommendations are provided for consideration and final determination by the Evaluation Committee

A RESPONSIVENESS RECOMMENDATION Recommendations regarding the responsiveness of proposers to the requirements are based on the solicitationrsquos criteria

1 Lobbyist Registration - Certification A vendor who has retained a lobbyist(s) to lobby in connection with a competitive solicitation shall be deemed non-responsive unless the firm in responding to the competitive solicitation certifies that each lobbyist retained has timely filed the registration or amended registration required under Section 1-262 Broward County Code of Ordinances

A Lobbyist Registration Certification Form must be completed and returned upon request by the County if not included in the submittal

Name of Firm Recommendation Remarks

Arcadis US Inc Responsive Not Retained

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

Responsive Retained

Carollo Engineers Inc Responsive Not Retained

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

Responsive Not Retained

Hazen and Sawyer PC Responsive Not Retained

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

Responsive Not Retained

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

Responsive Not Retained

Additional Information

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation) has retained Bernie Friedman of Becker amp Poliakoff

2 ldquoMustrdquo Addenda

There were no ldquoMustrdquo Addenda for this RFP

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 3 of 12

B RESPONSIBILITY INFORMATION

The information provided below is intended to inform the Evaluation Committee regarding each proposerrsquos responsibility After careful review of the information provided and the solicitationrsquos requirements the following information is provided for consideration and final determination by the Evaluation Committee

1 Office of Economic and Small Business Development Program

The Broward County Business Opportunity Act of 2012 and the Disadvantaged BusinessEnterprise Program Title 49 Code of Federal Regulations Part 26 establish the Countyrsquospolicies for participation by Small Business Enterprises (SBE) County Business Enterprises (CBE) and Federal Disadvantaged Business Enterprises (DBErsquos) in County contracts

In accordance with the above the (CBEDBESBE) goal participation for this contract is 25

Name of Firm Responsibility Information Remarks

Arcadis US Inc Complies 27

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

Complies 26

Carollo Engineers Inc Complies 25

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

Does not Comply 0

Hazen and Sawyer PC Complies 25

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

Complies 75

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

Complies 30

Additional Information

Florida Technical Consultants LLC initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI) for this solicitation The firm was given three (3) business days to provide documentation demonstrating their good faith efforts to meet the goal Upon review of their good faith efforts OESBD has determined that Florida Technical Consultants LLC did not meet the efforts to meet this goal for this solicitation and is not in compliance with the CBE program requirements

Refer to the OESBD Compliance Memorandum for a report of the proposersrsquo CBE compliance history for projects completed within the last five (5) years of the RFP opening date

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 4 of 12

2 Disclosure of Litigation History The solicitation requests firms to disclose all material cases filed pending or resolved during the last three (3) years prior to the solicitation response due date whether such cases were brought by or against the vendor any parent or subsidiary of the vendor or any predecessor organization It is the responsibility of each proposer to identify and disclose to the County all ldquomaterialrdquo cases ldquoMaterialrdquo cases include cases involving work similar to the scope of work in this solicitation professional negligence malpractice default termination suspension poor performance bankruptcy and business related criminal offenses ldquoMaterialrdquo cases do not include cases that involve garnishment auto negligence personal injury workers compensation foreclosure or a proof of claim filed by the vendor

Name of Firm Responsibility Information Remarks

Arcadis US Inc 29 Disclosed Cases No litigation with Broward County

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

3 Disclosed Cases No litigation with Broward County

Carollo Engineers Inc 0 Disclosed Cases No litigation with Broward County

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

0 Disclosed Cases No litigation with Broward County

Hazen and Sawyer PC 4 Disclosed Cases No litigation with Broward County

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

0 Disclosed Cases No litigation with Broward County

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

3 Disclosed Cases No litigation with Broward County

3 Disclosure of Financial Information The information provided is based on a review by Water and Wastewater ServicesPublic Works Department Each Vendor shall submit its most recent two (2) years of financial statements for review The financial statements are not required to be audited financial statements The annual financial statements shall be in the form of

i Balance sheets income statements and annual reports or ii Tax returns or iii SEC filings

The disclosure of financial information by proposers is a matter of responsibility

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 5 of 12

Name of Firm Responsibility Information Remarks (Current Ratio)

Arcadis US Inc Provided 2017 Financials 160 Provided 2016 Financials 212

Brown and Caldwell Provided 2017 Financials 183 (Corporation) Provided 2016 Financials 178

Provided 2015 Financials 146

Carollo Engineers Inc Provided 2017 Financials 150 Provided 2016 Financials 161 Provided 2015 Financials 164

Florida Technical Consultants Provided 2017 Financials 187 LLC Provided 2016 Financials 164

Hazen and Sawyer PC Provided 2017 Financials 146 Provided 2016 Financials 142

LakdasYohalem Provided 2016 Financials 1511 Engineering Inc Provided 2015 Financials 142271

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Provided 2017 Financials 109 Mathews Consulting a Baxter Provided 2016 Financials 109 amp Woodman Company

Refer to the Financial Review Memorandum for any reportable conditions brought to the attention of the Evaluation Committee

4 Authority to Conduct Business in Florida A Florida corporation or partnership is required to provide evidence with its response that the firm is authorized to transact business in Florida and is in good standing with the Florida Department of State If not with its response such evidence must be submitted to the County upon request by the County

Name of Firm Responsibility Information Remarks

Arcadis US Inc Provided AuthorizedGood Standing

Brown and Caldwell Provided AuthorizedGood Standing (Corporation)

Carollo Engineers Inc Provided AuthorizedGood Standing

Florida Technical Provided AuthorizedGood Standing Consultants LLC

Hazen and Sawyer PC Provided AuthorizedGood Standing

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 6 of 12

LakdasYohalem Provided AuthorizedGood Standing Engineering Inc

Baxter amp Woodman Inc Provided AuthorizedGood Standing dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

5 Affiliated Entities of the Principal(s) All Vendors are required to disclose the names and addresses of ldquoaffiliated entitiesrdquo of the Vendorrsquos principal(s) over the last five (5) years (from the solicitation opening deadline) that have acted as a prime Vendor with the County ldquoAffiliated entitiesrdquo of the principal(s) are those entities related to the Vendor by the sharing of stock or other means of control including but not limited to a subsidiary parent or sibling entity

An Affiliated Entities Certification Form was included in the solicitation and must be completed and returned upon request by the County if not included in the original response

Name of Firm Responsibility Information Remarks

Arcadis US Inc Provided No Affiliates

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

Provided No Affiliates

Carollo Engineers Inc Provided No Affiliates

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

Provided No Affiliates

Hazen and Sawyer PC Provided No Affiliates

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

Provided No Affiliates

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

Provided No Affiliates

6 Insurance Requirements The solicitation indicated the insurance requirements deemed necessary for this project It is not necessary to have this level of insurance in effect at the time of submittal but it is necessary to submit certificates indicating that the firm currently carries the insurance or the vendor needs to submit a letter from the carrier indicating upgrade availability

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 7 of 12

Name of Firm Responsibility Information Remarks

Arcadis US Inc Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

Carollo Engineers Inc Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

Hazen and Sawyer PC Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

Additional Information

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company took exception to Article 831 The firm requested removal of the 831 mold fungus asbestos sexual molestation requirement indicating that this was not insurable

7 Licensing Requirements The solicitation stated that Proposers must provide evidence that they hold a current Professional Engineer license with the State of Florida

Name of Firm Responsibility Information Remarks

Arcadis US Inc Provided Compliant

Brown and Caldwell Provided Compliant (Corporation)

Carollo Engineers Inc Provided Compliant

Florida Technical Provided Compliant Consultants LLC

Hazen and Sawyer PC Provided Compliant

LakdasYohalem Provided Compliant Engineering Inc

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 8 of 12

Baxter amp Woodman Inc Provided Compliant dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

C COUNTY STANDARD TERMS AND CONDITIONS INFORMATION The acceptance of or any exceptions taken to the terms and conditions of the Countyrsquos Agreement shall be considered a part of a Vendorrsquos submittal and will be considered by the Evaluation Committee The applicable Agreement terms and conditions for this solicitation were indicated in the Special Instructions to Vendors Vendors were required to review the applicable terms and conditions and submit the Agreement Exception Form If the Agreement Exception Form is not provided with the submittal it shall be deemed an affirmation by the Vendor that it accepts the Agreement terms and conditions as disclosed in the solicitation If exceptions are taken the Vendor must specifically identify each term and condition with which it is taking an exception

Name of Firm Agree Exceptions

Arcadis US Inc No Article 4 ndash Liquidated Damages

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

Yes None

Carollo Engineers Inc Yes None

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

Yes None

Hazen and Sawyer PC Yes None

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

Yes None

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

No Article asbestosrequirement

831 ndash Mold fungus sexual molestation

D REFERENCES The solicitationrsquos Evaluation Criteria ndash Project Specific Criteria Page 18 Question 3 request that completed references be provided for previous experience and projects Attached are the references as verified by County staff

E PERFORMANCE EVALUATIONS The Broward County Purchasing Division Contracts Central indicates evaluation scores for the proposing firms previously awarded contracts Completed performance evaluations may be provided upon request

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 9 of 12

Attached are Contracts Central performance evaluation history for each vendor as applicable including evaluation type (renewal goals compliance or final) and recommendation for future contracts (yes no or conditional) If a firm has periodic evaluations it will be listed separately

Additional Information In response to the Purchasing Directorrsquos Draft Memorandum to which the vendor can respond within 48 hours to any comments or deficiencies noted in the Purchasing DirectorrsquosDraft Memorandum Brown and Caldwell (Corporation) had a score that was highlighted in bright orange The bright orange highlight indicates that the firm receive an individual scoreof 1 or 2 on an item for that evaluation

F CONE OF SILENCE VIOLATIONS The Cone of Silence for this procurement has been in effect since May 3 2018 which prohibits potential vendors from discussing this solicitation with the Evaluation Committee the County Administrator Deputy County Administrator Assistant County Administrator Assistants to the County Administrator their respective support staff and any other person authorized to evaluate or recommend selection in this procurement process

Upon the first meeting of the Evaluation Committee the Cone of Silence expands to also include County Commissioners and their staff Potential vendors and their representatives are substantially restricted from communicating with County Commissioners and their staff regarding this procurement as stated in the Cone of Silence Ordinance

After application of the Cone of Silence inquiries regarding this solicitation should be directed to the Director of Purchasing or designee The Cone of Silence terminates when the County Commission or other awarding authority takes action which ends the solicitation Vendors are required to certify that they have read understand and will comply with the Cone of Silence Ordinance Section 1-266 Broward County Code of Ordinances

The following is a report of the proposersrsquo Cone of Silence violations

Name of Firm Remarks Violations

Arcadis US Inc Will Comply 1

Brown and Caldwell Will Comply None (Corporation)

Carollo Engineers Inc Will Comply None

Florida Technical Will Comply None Consultants LLC

Hazen and Sawyer PC Will Comply None

LakdasYohalem Engineering Will Comply None Inc

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 10 of 12

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Will Comply None Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

Additional Information

Arcadis US Inc had one violation 2011 - Robert Daoust Principal Scientist Malcolm PirnieArcadis US Inc

Additional Information In response to the Purchasing Directorrsquos Draft Memorandum to which the vendor can respond within 48 hours to any comments or deficiencies noted in the Purchasing DirectorrsquosDraft Memorandum Arcadis US Inc provided information that the cone of silence violationwas from a former employee

G VOLUME OF PREVIOUS WORK - EVALUATION CRITERIA ANDOR TIE BREAK CRITERIA The solicitation states that a number of points will be allocated for volume of previous work of the firm for the past five (5) years The volume of work for each of the proposing firms is as follows

Name of Firm Proposer Reported County Reported Points Allocated

Arcadis US Inc $24988700 $9597102 5 Points

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

$477974497 $477974497 3 Points

Carollo Engineers Inc $214076903 $214076903 5 Points

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

$000 $000 5 Points

Hazen and Sawyer PC

$2164284300 $2221320722 0 Points

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

$5894000 $5894030 5 Points

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

$000 $000 5 Points

Additional Information

5 points allocated to vendors paid $0 to $3000000 3 points allocated to vendors paid $3000001 to $7500000 1 point allocated to vendors paid $7500001 to $10000000 0 points allocated to vendors paid over $10000000

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 11 of 12

H PRINCIPAL BUSINESS LOCATION The solicitation states that a number of points will be allocated for location of the firm The Vendorrsquos principal address in Broward County shall be the Vendorrsquos ldquoPrincipal Addressrdquo as indicated with the Florida Department of State Division of Corporations for at least six (6) months prior to the solicitationrsquos due date A proposer with a principal business location within Broward County will receive five (5) points A proposer not having its principal business location within Broward County will receive zero (0) points

The results are as Proposed Attested Location Verified Points Allocated followsName of Nerve Center in SunBiz Firm

Arcadis US Inc 630 Plaza Drive Suite 10 YES 0 Highlands Ranch CO

Brown and Caldwell 201 North Civic Drive YES 0 (Corporation) Suite 300

Walnut Creek CA

Carollo Engineers 2700 Ygnacio Valley YES 0 Inc Road Suite 300

Walnut Creek CA

Florida Technical 533 East Ocean Avenue YES 0 Consultants LLC Suite 2

Boynton Beach FL

Hazen and Sawyer 4000 Hollywood YES 5 PC Boulevard Suite 750

North Hollywood FL

LakdasYohalem 2211 NE 54th Street YES 5 Engineering Inc Fort Lauderdale FL

Baxter amp Woodman 477 S Rosemary Avenue YES 0 Inc dba Mathews Suite 330 Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company West Palm Beach FL

Additional Information In response to the Purchasing Directorrsquos Draft Memorandum to which the vendor canrespond within 48 hours to any comments or deficiencies noted in the Purchasing Directorrsquos Draft Memorandum Hazen and Sawyer PC principal address as verified in Sunbiz is 4000Hollywood Blvd Suite 750N Hollywood FL 33021

I LOCAL PREFERENCE A vendor is eligible to be considered a local business for Local Preference purposes if it has a physical business address located within the limits of Broward County The vendor must provide a valid business tax receipt issued by Broward County at least one (1) year prior to bid or proposal opening

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 12 of 12

Broward Countyrsquos Local Preference Ordinance specifically excludes the application of a local preference for professional services procured pursuant to Section 287055 FS (CCNA)

J LOCATION - TIE BREAKER A Vendor located within Broward County is eligible for the Location Tie Breaker The County requires a copy of the Broward County Business Tax receipt for a period of time of at least six (6) months prior to the solicitation deadline and it must be provided with its initial submittal

The results are as follows

Name of Firm Eligibility Broward County Tax Receipt

Arcadis US Inc Eligible Provided

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

Eligible Provided

Carollo Engineers Inc Eligible Provided

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

Eligible Provided

Hazen and Sawyer PC Eligible Provided

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

Eligible Provided

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

Eligible Provided

Attachments 1 Vendor Reference Verifications 2 Vendor Performance Evaluations 3 Vendor Responses to Draft Memo

c Bob Melton County Auditor Office of the County Auditor Robert Wilson Title Division Department (Project Manager) Martha Perez-Garviso Purchasing Manager Purchasing Division Finance and Administrative Services Department Glenn Miller Assistant County Attorney Office of the County Attorney Fernando Amuchastegui Assistant County Attorney Office of the County Attorney

BJBGMnomm

Broward County Board of PNC211 5559P1 County Commissioners

BRCWARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LO ~ I DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P 1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis us Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

South Florida Water Management District

Contact Name Rich V irgil PE Title Bureau Chief lnfrabReference date 05142018

Contact Email rvirgilsfwmdgov Contact Phone 561 6826759

Name of Referenced Project S-193 Lock Refurbishment C-41A Canal Bank Stabilization Lake

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

4600000790 1001 2008 UP 12012016 $ 295400000

Vendors role in Project ]rime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Engineering Design and Engineering Services During Construction

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D [] DD c Deliverables []D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [L] D c Turnover D D D0

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget []D D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm [L]D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D 0 D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [] D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via ~AI L VERBAL Verified by ~~ Division WWfD Date ltQamp~(8 All lnformallon provided to Bltoward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate unlrulhful or incorrect statements made In support of this response may be used by the

512gt~11MlflS a lgtasis Of rejection rescission of the award or tenninallon of the contract and ~~lVcrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 of lhe Broward Count~ 41l6tlrelfient Code Y fTmiddot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BR~ltJWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LO R I DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering SeNices for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Saint Petersburg Department of Engineering and Capital Planning

Contact Name Nicole Allen Title CADDGIS Supervi Reference date

Contact Email nicoleallenstpeteorg Contact Phone 727-893-7316

Name of Referenced Project Water Resources Department GIS Data Migration

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

13-03-ARCIT 12092014 UP 09152015 $ 5925000

Vendors role in Project ]rime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again (Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Migration ofwater wastewater and storm water infrastructure information from CAD environment to Esri Local Government Information Model

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D [] D c Deliverables D [] D D

2 Vendors Organization [ZJa Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D [ZJ D c Turnover D D [] D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [ZJ D b Deliverables D D [ZJ D

4 Project completed within budget [ZJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [ZJ D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) [ZJD D D c Regu latory Agency(ies) D D [ZJ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONL rbullbull

Verified via L L VERBAL Verified by Division NlltE~ Date 6(~oatgt 1 8~ All information PfOvided to Bfoward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful oc inCOfrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

512gt9lillll jS a basis 10lt rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and nlll~9rrcrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of lhe Broward Cou~ 42fldtclrhtflent Code middot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BRuWARD1 1 COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering SeNices for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

C ity of Tavares F lorida

Contact Name James Dillon Title Public Works DireltaReference date 05172018

Contact Email jdillontavaresorg Contact Phone 352-455-7718

Name of Referenced Project G IS Modeling and Integration of Utilities Infrastructure

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

060330480000 04012017 UP 10012017 $ 5676000

Vendors role in Project ]rime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Integrate drawings and images depicting pipe infrastructure into a GIS environment for easy retrieval First project of a multi phase program to upgrade the Citys GIS information

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D 0 D c Deliverables D D 0 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D Ill D b Professionalism D D Ill D c Turnover D D 0 D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D Ill D b Deliverables D D Ill D

4 Project completed within budget D D Ill D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D Ill D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D Ill D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY -

Ve rified via L IL VERBAL Verified by fcAJ~ Division llt E1) Date 1 r~ tjlQ t8 All information pwvlded to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incooect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

512G91JlIHIS a basis for rejection rescission or the award or termination or the contract and lnfli~9ncrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 of the Broward CouI)~ 44flamplrelflent Code

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BRd~WARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LO R I DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Miramar

Contact Name Robin E Bain PE Title Project Manager Reference date 05142018

Contact Email rebainmiramarflgov Contact Phone 9548836825

Name of Referenced Project East Water Treatment Plant Replacement Wells and Design-Build

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PO 172624-00 10222017 UP 05142018 $ 56929600

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [ZJYes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Design permitting construction services for new Deep Injection Well and 4 new (replacement) production wells

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy []D D D c Deliverables D []D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D [ZJ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Turnover D D D []

3 Timeliness of a Project D D lZ1 D b Del iverables D D lZ1 D

4 Project completed within budget D D lZ1 D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor( s)Subconsultant( s) D D lZ1 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D lZ1 D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY (

Verified via A IL VER BAL Verified by faltJ~ Division WltEtgt Date 5 ~io l 9 All inlOllllalion pltovided to Broward County is subjecl lo verificalioo VendOt acknowledges lhal lnaccurale unlrulhful or i ncooecl stalemenls made in suppOltI of lhis response may be used by lhe

512gt~llM (lS a basis lot rejeclion rescission of the award or termination of lhe contract and mll~Arrcrve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuanl 10 Section 21119 of lhe Broward Couoty 43Pldtllrbrllent Code Y flmiddot

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Palm Beach County Water Utilities Department

Contact Name Ali Bayat Title Assistant Director Reference date

Contact Email abayatpbcwatercom Contact Phone 561 493 6128

Name of Referenced Project System 8 Water Quality Assessment

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

17-021 CSA21 01 022017 to 01152018 $ 8936000

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again (Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Brown and Caldwell led assessment of contributing causes to low system residuals troubleshooting treatment processes special testing and data analysis improvements to operating protocols monitoringcontrol system and treatment process

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [Z] D b Accuracy D [Z] DD c Deliverables D [Z]D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D [Z] D b Professionalism D D [Z] D c Turnover D [Z] DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D [Z] D

4 Project completed within budget D D [Z] D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Consultant worked collaboratively with operating maintenance engineering and laboratory staff to develop insight into contributing factors and implement improvements

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via _LEMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by tcltJ1~ Division -+LN euro P Date lteh IWt 8 All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the County as a basis for rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and may also serve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward County Procurement Code

BltaWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F L 0 R I D A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood Florida

Contact Name Steve Joseph Title Director Reference date

Contact Email sjosephhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954 921 3522

Name of Referenced Project Distribution System Water Quality Improvement

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

01012016 to 06022017 $ 3000000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again []Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Supported the City with its efforts improve chlorine residuals in areas of its system Analysis included system modeling monitoring optimized operational practices Implemented operational improvements that significantly raised (from approx 05 to 20 mgL) chloramine residuals In the most challenging area of the system

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D D [] D c Deliverables []D D D

2 Vendors Organization [] Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D [] D c Turnover D D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D [] D

4 Project completed within budget []D D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) []D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [] D

Additional Com ments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Effort Included system modoling moniloring and excursion response procedures opllmitallon of stored Inventory management unidirectional flushing pilot assessment and treatment proooss evaluation

Verified via __EMAIL vERBAL Division WW ED Date G Ifgt I 8 All infonmallon pltovided to Broward County Is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of thi s response may be used by lhe County as a basis for rejeclion rescission or the award or tenminatlon of the contract and may also serve as the basis for debanment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 or lhe Broward County Procurement Code

BROWARD t (l)t~ 1 Vendor Reference Verification Form

fl O R I OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of West Palm Beach Florida

Contact Name Jay Kwag Title Project Manager Reference date

Contact Email hjkwagwpborg Contact Phone 561 494 1041

Name of Referenced Project Modeling and Infrastructure General Engineering Consulting Assigments

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

11032014 to HAlt zc1e (on~vi~)

Vendors role in Project 52fPrime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IQves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Planning and General Eng1neerg Servicus 1nctuslve ol Waterwastewater System Master Pian asset management program dovo10pmenV11sset Crt1tcat1ty assessment Mesler PS 115 and sewer cond1hon assessment hydrauhc modeling ol LS 5 and force main sizing water system Capacity Analysis RoPort nydraullc modeling ol operahonat challongos tilt ste11on enatysbulls lac11i1a1e 1nspec11011 or major FM and new develOpmenl 1mpnc1s plpohno design lilt station condbullhon assessment and renabtlilahon (Various ProJecls)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D 0 D b Accuracy D 0D D c Deliverables D D 0 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D Gt D b Professionalism D D ~-- D c Turnover D D Gr D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D B D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget D D r~r D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D c~r D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D 0 D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION F~USE ONLY

__VERBAL Verified via LMAIL Verified by ~J Division ~~~D Date ~ f 2 f~t8 All lnfo11na1t0n pr ()Vl(fed 10 Broward County is svb1et110 ven11ca1ion vendor acknowledges lhll 1naeoura10 unlrulhful 0lt inc0ltrec1 s1a1emen1s medo In support ol 1n1s response may be used Dy the County as a basis fcu rejection re sclsst0n Of 1ho award or 1ormina1lon of l he contract and may also servo as the basis for debarment o f Vendor pursuant lo Section 21 119 of tho ampoward Counly P1ocuremont Code

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A middot

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Michael Low Title Deputy Director Reference date 05172018

Contact Email lowmbbflus Contact Phone 5617426403

Name of Referenced Project Ion Exchange Design Build

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

07022014 to 03212018 $ 100000000

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Carollo handled all of the design and construction of a significant part of the project as a subcontractor to COM Constructors as part of a progressive design build contract

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [Z] D b Accuracy D D [Z] D c Deliverables D D [Z] D

2 Vendors Organization D D [Z] Da Staff expertise b Professionalism D D [Z] D c Turnover D D D [Z]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D [Z] D

4 Project completed within budget D D [Z] D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D [Z] D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [Z] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION F~ COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ~~ Division W -NED Date S-gtozot~ All Information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor aclltnowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

Stii191111X 11s a basis for rejection rescission of the award or termination or the conlact and m~~Arifrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward CounYJ 33Plamptl1til1ent Code Y Imiddot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

B~OWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LORID A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

South Florida Water Management District

Contact Name Greg Coffelt PE Title SFWMD Project Manager Reference date 05172018

Contact Email gcoffeltsfwmdgov Contact Phone 561-682-6853

Name of Referenced Project L-8 Reservoir Inflow Structure and Pump Station

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

4600000861 02152011 to 09192012 $ 144535100

Vendors role in Project [l) Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [l)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Corolla was contracted as an Owners Advisor for a Design-Build contract developed engineering design criteria assisted in RFQ development and evaluation supported RFP technical proposal and cost proposal analysis

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [l] D b Accuracy D [] D D c Deliverables D [] D D

2 Vendors Organization [l]a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D [l] D c Turnover D D D [l]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [l] D b Deliverables D [l] D D

4 Project completed within budget [l] DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [l] D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) [l] DD D c Regu latory Agency(ies) D D D [l]

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Owner Advisor work continued(s) in support of Construction of Pump Station Inflow Gate Structure and levee hardening

Verified via IMAIL __VERBAL Date 5 ( 3 c b() I a All information piovided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that Inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made In support of this response may be used by the

512G9JiIX 11s a basis for rejection rescission or the award or termination or the contract and rllffl~Anampe as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 or the Broward CojlftYi 34~6ttlrbtflent Code Y

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

B0~~AARD ~~t~UNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

Fl ORIOA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Sunrise

Contact Name Luisa Fernanda Arbelaa Title Project Manager Reference date 05162018

Contact Email LArbelaezsunrlseflgov Contact Phone 954-888-6009

Name of Referenced Project City of Sunrise - Springtree WTP Water Stabilization and Solids Handling

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PA 16-003-CE 04072016 to 05292018 $ 50797800

Vendors role in Project ]Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [l]Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Carollo Engineers performed the design study and construction administration services for the City

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D G6 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Carollo Engineers technical knowledge and attenllon lo detall were beneficial lo the pltojad They ecled in lhe C~ys besl Interest In every aspect for lhe d1K8Uon of the projectbull

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via ~MAIL _VERBAL Verified by fc4J~~ Division W fl ED All lnrormalion provided to Broward ltAunty Is oobjoci to vorirtcotion Vendoc ecknowledgu that 1naowrate unlMhfuf 0lt lncocrecl statements rnado In support or this response may be useltI by lhe County as a basis for rejection rescission or the award 0lt termination ol the convect and may also ampOIVe as the babullibull ror debarmont of vondOlt purauont to Section 21119 or the Broward County Proc11oment Code

Bid Sync p 135 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BftQNARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

I l 0 R I 0 A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Florida Technical Consultants

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

VIiiage of Wellington Utilities

Contact Name Bradley Wolak Title Assistant Director Ut11Reference date 5182018

Contact Email bwolakwelllngtonflgov Contact Phone 561-753-2480

Name of Referenced Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 10012017 to Present 3500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vend~ 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again UZfYes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor J_ rJ fJ j(Gr-~k 6 Jti ov1 ~uf-Jiy fgt-r_- syrrzi~ff~ Al

R Q_ d--1 0~l 4 171 i+CI ~~lHI )Please rate your experience with tile Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Applicablereferenced Vendor Improvement

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy B D

DD c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D Db Professionalism D D

c Turnover D DD 3 Timeliness of

a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant(s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Additional Comments (provide on addltjpnal sheetJf needed) bull ~middot$ -JJ fo~~rltjbull lt( c-c_ ~~~ lt fo L1-lfAR- -middot~ I 10 ~ ~

~ bullL ~~ _te_ l~Ilgt~Cef t J ~ l rfbull4 middot r0 laquo r 4111J w f1 rrr- 0r- -i-HIS SECTION(9R COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by fcAJc ~ Division Y-1 IN ED Date 5 ~o w8 All lnfonn1Uon ptollfded to BlOward County le eubjeet to vetfflcatlon Vendor aclltnowledge1 that lneccurale unllJlhfUl or lnconect -bullmenla made In 1UPPort o1 this reopon90 may be uoec1 by the couniy ae a baalS ror re)ectlon re8Claeton Of the award 0t leltmlnatlon Of the contract and may 1l10 MM ae the baale flaquo debarrnont 01 vendor pu11uant to Section 21119 of ll1e Broward County Procurement Codo

BidSync p 18 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F LUFltIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultants LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Palm Beach Public Works

Contact Name Gerry Vazquez Title WRD Technician Reference date 05182018

Contact Email gvazqueztownofpalmbeachcom Contact Phone 772-546-6859

Name of Referenced Project GIS Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 3242014 to Present 13500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [3yenes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

PrwAamprs- favl49z Please rate your experience with the Need a Satlafactory Excellent Not

Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D g- D b Accuracy D Er D c Deliverables g-shyB D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D GJ D b Professionalism D D G- D c Tu mover D D cg- D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D g D b Deliverables D D Qshy D

4 Project completed within budget D D lbJ- D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D El- Db Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [3- D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

BidSync p 17 51232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

120-nWARDLll~ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form fLORllgtA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultant LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Waneya Bryant Title Meter Serv Mgr Reference date 05182018

Contact Email BryantWbbflus Contact Phone 561-742-6427

Name of Referenced Project Boynton Beach Utility GIS Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 12012016 to Present $15000000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

~T~ 5e-r-vtleamp +roM l)h f-es Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D Dc Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ti4 D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ Db Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on addlUonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION~urv USE ONLy u bull

Verified via VEMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by kuJ~ Division W if E D rao(ao8Date 5

All Information provided to Browslaquo COOlty Is Slbject to verfflcation Vendor acKnowledges that lneocurate Untruthful or lncolleel 8tatements made In support d this rfl9pOn98 may be used by 1119 Counly as a batia falt rejection relduion ct Ille award or lemilnlilon of the contract and may al80181Veaa1119 basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 ot Ille Broward CountyProcurement Code

512312018 BidSync p 16

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1

8W1V~isl1War Bid PNC21 15559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Fonn

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Cooper City - middot

Contact Name Michael Bailey PE itle Utilities DlrCity EbullReference date 05011201s

Contact Email MBalleycoopercityflorg Contact Phone (954) 434-5519

Name of Referenced Project City of Cooper City Continuing Professional Services bullContract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

RFQ 2009middot 1 04242009 to Present $ 2 19844200

Vendors role in Project IZJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Since 2009 Hazen has provided Cooper City with engineering services or water and wastewater projects Projects have lnctudeo lhe Pine Island Road Pump Station Lilt S1alions 2 amp 49 Improvements Master Plan Update of the FeaslJl~lty Review of Infrastructure Improvements tor Wastewater and the Eflluent Reuse and Disposal Master Plan

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy 8 D

D ~ D c Deliverables D 0 ~ D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D 0 D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tumover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D GJ- D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D 0 D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) ~D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

bull-rHIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY-

Verified vie EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ct4~ Division ~tUb Date ~ i3~) 0fgt All Information provided to BltCgtWW County 11 wbed ID vamprificalion Velldot adltnowledgu that lnaoewate unlrUhful lncom1ct statemampnla made in wppolt of 11111 response may blt uHd by the

4t2j=~ rejection rHclsslcn of th8 award or lennhallon of Ille eoo1nlct and may also seNamp at tilt basis for dtbarmenl at Vendor puuan1 lo Sectioo 21119 of the Broward COltJi 43

5232018 Bid Sync p24

Broward County Board of PNC211 5559P1

~RiiirilyenlcHUffi~~8CrW~r Bid PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

8DdMARD _ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FL O RIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Fort Lauderdale

Contact Name Rares Patrica PE Title Senior Project Mgr Reference date os1021201s

Contact Email RPetricafortlauderdalegov Contact Phone 9548287150

Name of Referenced Project Stormwater Master Planning and Design Implementation Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

256-11660 04192016 to 04192021 $ 989400000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

vyould you use this vendor again Sves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor The Hazen team Is responsible for delivery of a new stormwaler master plan model a prlorlllzed slormwaterresllency capital Improvements plan and Implementation of designs to address chronic flooding and other slormwater management challenges In the City Primary work tasks Include data collectlon hydrologlclhydraullc modeling and design permitting and construction services for capllal Improvement projects resulting from the revised stormwater master plan (preltmlnary design In seven priority neighborhoods)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION ~R COUNTY USE ONLY

aJ~Verified via pound MA IL _VERBAL Verified by Division W1~tl Date 5 ~3o~ax l S N I informallon p roviltled lo Broward County is sulljecl lo verification Vendor altknowledjj6s lhal inaccurate unlMhlut or lncotreci statements m ade In support of this respon$e may be used by tho

412~-~ rejeclion rescission of the award or termination ol lhe contracl and may also serve as lhe basis for debalment ol Vendor purwant to Section 21119 ol lhe Broward Cou~ 4 3

5232018 Bid Sync p25

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 Br~~~~~rs Bid PNC2115559P1 County t ommissioners

B~uWARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FlOR I CA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

Solicitation PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and s OrganizationFirm Name p

Town of Jupiter

nee

Contact Email davidbjupiterflus Contact Phone (561) 746-5134

Name of Referenced Project Engineering Services for Stormwater and Water Capital Improvements

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount $ 630000000 W17248 (2017 reselection 1012000 to Present (estimated lee-to-date since contract inception) contract number)

Vendors role in Project IZI Prime Vendor osubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again 0Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Descriotion of services orovided bv Vendor Since 2000 Hazen has served as General Consulfant to the Town or Jupiter As General Stormwater and Water Consullant the firm has provided services related to master planning stormwater planning and modeling design NPDES permilling asset management resiliency ratefinancial analysis plan review and construction oversight Water-related capital projs have involved additional system storage and high-service pumping transmission system improvements and RampR at existing facilities

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Verllied via EMAIL _ VERBAL Division WWC D

fo (J-Vv ~ltIvmiddotj Date 5(30(ipf S

Al lnroimallon pngtYICGd 10 Broward Counly Is sub)oel to v8flrcallon vendlaquo acknowledges lhat Inaccurate unlruthlu~ 0t Jnwrrect slatoments made In support ol this response may be used by the 42~~1~0 rojecllon rescission or Ille award or termination or lhe con~acl bullnd mbully also serve as tho basis r0t debarment of Vendor pursuant lo Socllon 21119 of lho Broward Couw 41

5232018 BidSync p 26

a N ~ IL) IL) N u z a_

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLO RI DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Walter Wernecke RA Title Sr Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email WWERNECKEhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Hollywood Marina Restrooms

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

04152015 to Present 7500000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor OSubconsultanVSubcontractor n ~U t1

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

-0 Vgt Description of services provided by VendorO ~ ~ Q) Structural Design and Construction Inspection Services i co Q m ~- c E c0

i E gt Oo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not () uu Appllcable O

E~ referenced Vendor Improvement iii ~sectoO 1 Vendors Quality of Service B mu a Responsive D D

b Accuracy DD c Deliverables D DD

2 Vendors Organization D Da Staff expertise v D b Professionalism~ D D c Turnover D ~D

3 Timeliness of D a Project b Deliverables D ~

4 Pec~~11~$~hinJ~~qt lfr D D 5 Cooperation with f ~

a Your Firm D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D

Al lnfonn1tion pRgttded IO Brwd Cltgtunly lo 1ubjecl IO ibllon vsor ~middot Iha icl-bullmiddot ~ ir-ect slalemenls mode In _ol lhb _ moy ti used by he County as a basis lot rejecUon rnclnlon cl the eward or tonnlnallan of lhl connct 1nd may bullllo 11 the basis for dobalment of Vendor IQtulnl IO SICllOn 21119 at lhe Broword County Procurement Code

Cl ltraquo I() I() I() N ()

Cl z

BRltJWARD ~ middot COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORl OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Davie

Contact Name Emilio DeSimone Title Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email Emilio_DeSimonedavie-fl gov Contact Phone 954-797-1085

Name of Referenced Project Pavillion 5 Linear Park

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

B-17-123 09152015 to 2700000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor O SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es O No If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

0 Description of services provided by Vendor O Q)

iii c Structural Design and Construction Inspection ServicesoQ

CDi-

0cc E gt=gt E ()Oo O () () Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

ii) -e i- Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 111 cs

B ioO

J 1 Vendors Quality of Service Q ()

a Responsive D D b Accuracy D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization []Ll Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D Dtr

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [g D b Deliverables D D ar D

4 Project completed within budget [1tD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) cgD D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via l EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by ~h~ Division WlI Etgt Date 0 f l~o I 8 All lnformaUon provided lO Broward County Is eubJect 10 verifutlon Vendor ecknOMedgoo that lnaocurote unNlhlul or Incorrect statamenle made In aupl)Ort of this reaponse may be used by lho County et o baampla for rejection realtluion of the award or lermlnallon of tho eon1fllcl ond moy olao aorvo os ho basis for debarmont of Vondor purauenl lo Section 21119 of the Broward Counly Procuremen1 Code

0 0 agt a c () z 0

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Terrence Comiskey AIA Title Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email TCOMISKEYhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Van Buren Parking Garage

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PK 14-053 Nov 2014 to Present 8310000

Vendors role in Project t8(Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

o~ Description of services provided by Vendor 1 Q)ltO c Structural Design and Conslructlon Inspection Services 0 Q

0~Jl ccE l E enOo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

gtshy

uu O Improvement Applicable ffireferenced Vendor

~sect 1 Vendors Quality of Service 1 ~

oOau a Responsive D ~ D b Accuracy B D D

D D [- Dc Deliverables

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tum over D D D g

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ D Subcontractor(s )S ubcons u ltant( s)b D D ~ D

c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D yenj D Additional Comments provide on sdditlonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION ~NTY USE ONLY0

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by kW Division W-1-(i~ Date EJo(a~t8 Al lnform1Uon PltOVlded lo Browald Ccxnty It IUbjoct to vorificallon Vendor eoknowfodgea thal lnaewralt U111MhlJI deg inlaquogtlaquobullel amptal11ants made In eupporl of lhls relj)Onse may be used by Iha Counly es a balls l0t rcfecllon rescfuloltI of tho ew1rd or 1ermtnaU0lt1 ol lhbull conllllCI and may elao urve 11 lho basis for dabarmenl of Vondor pursuanl lo Secllon 21 119 of he erowald COUlly CiProcurement Code

~ N ii

00

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 aOWllrp Commficumlref Bid PNC2116615B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Pompano Beach FL

Contact Name Mr A Randolph Brown Title Utilities Director Reference date April 30 2018

Contact Email randolphbrowncopbflcom Contact Phone 954-545-7043

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 201 o Project Amount fees varied

Multiple

Vendors role in Project IKJ Prime Vendor

to 2018

osubconsultanUSubcontractor

(range $10000shy$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D ~ D D c Deliverables D ~ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D ~ D D b Professionalism D D ~ D C Turnover D El DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ 0 b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D [BJ D n c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [XJ o ~

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed) amp~~it -THIS SECTION ~COUNTY USE ONL y-bullbull

Verified via ~AIL __VERBAL Verified by 1lt4 )~ Division N WE O Date 5 faol Z1 18

All lnformotlon providod to BltownrltI Cou nty it aubjoct O verification VendOr acknowledges that lnaccornto untruthful or incorroct 11atomon1s made in support of this response may be used by tho

411p~~)~~J rojoclion roscissioo ol lho award or 1orroinalion of tho contract and roay also s01vo as lhbull basis f0lt d~arroont of VondOf pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward Cou)l1

Bid Sync p 73

40

5232018

Broward County Board of Bid PNC2116659B 1 County Commissioners

B~aWARD gt1- t COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Loxahatchee River Environmental Control District

Contact Name Mr Kris Dean Title Director of Engineering Reference date May 9 2018

Contact Email krisdeanloxahatcheeriverorg Contact Phone 561-747-5700

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 2001 Project Amount fees varied (range $10000shyMultiple to 2018 $250000)

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IR)Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D ~ D D b Accuracy D 0 D D c Deliverables D IBJ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D IB] D D b Professionalism D ~ D D c Turnover D [8J D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D [8J D D b Deliverables D m D D

4 Project completed within budget D ~ D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D ~ D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D Ii] D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D ~ D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SE~ FOR~USE ONLY

Verified via _lEMAIL __VERBAL Verified by ~lt Division fWeb Date I

All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untrulhful or incorrecl slatements made In support of this response may be used by the lJl~~~l~~jSfiir rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and mll~~~ere as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Co)f 10

Broward County Board of Bid PNC21166$9B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A l

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Lake Worth FL

Contact Name Mr Felipe Lofaso TitleAsst Dir Public-ServicesReference date May 9 2018

Contact Email flofasolakeworthorg Contact Phone 561-586-1720

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contract

Contract No Date Services Provided 2014 Project Amount fees varied Multiple to 2018 (range $10000shy

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Services included multiple municipal engineering projects including survey roadway design utility design and coordination (water wastewater stormwater other) along with project management

Needs Satisfactory Excellent NotPlease rate your experience with the Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D GJ D b Accuracy D D Ii] D c Deliverables D Ii] DD

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [i] D c Turnover D D D [X]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D 0 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [X] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION Fe COUNTY USE ONLrbullbull

Verified via MAIL __VERBAL Verified by Division ~wgtgt Date 5~3ol20t8 All information provided to Broward County Is subject lo verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect slalements made in support ol this response may be used by the

OZ~id~~~~j~r rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and m~~~(iirve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Cour~ iG

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - ARCADIS US INC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts

VS0000013130 VS00013130 - ARCADIS US INC Prime Work Auth Vendor SummaryProjects

PURCHASING 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold Procurement No Fixed Contracts FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Favorites Past 5 Years Prime Vendor

Sub Vendor From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 10042017 Purchase Order

Evaluation Purchase Orders 1 POs With A Total Amt Of $20000000 Log Off Paid To Dt ($12132949) Balance $7867051

Contracts Purchase Orders Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx 6192018

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Finish

PURCHASING Weighted Scores Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract FileRoom DashBoard Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number FileRoom Insert

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel Favorites Prime Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Service Evaluation

6132017 YES 486 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Goals Compliance Evaluation

10272016 YES 460 View Docs (0)

6272018

Project Management Information System

Close

Contracts Central Administration

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9130 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-24

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6182018 YES 355 View Docs (1)

Proj Nbr 9320 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-20

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6132018 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9290 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-23

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1122018 YES 494 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-21

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12182017 YES 488 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10162017 YES 473 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

8252017 YES 495 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9321 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-19

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

7112017 YES 476 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-17

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2272017 YES 400 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

10132016 YES 384 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-12

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

5202016 YES 405 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9018 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-06

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10192015 YES 448 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

3202015 YES 385 View Docs (0)

Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL CONSULTANTS

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Project Management Information System

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-04

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12122014 YES 437 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-08

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1242014 YES 423 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-02

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2282014 YES 452 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC

VC0000044184 VC00044184 - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres PS $001 Used $000 Remain $001 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $354848400 Closed 0 Total $000 Total Current Retainage Balance For All Contracts $793370 No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 06292015 Purchase Orders 2 POs With A Total Amt Of $362317900 Paid To Dt ($218795160) Balance $143522740

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 40803 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9058 - DISTRICT 3A POTABLE WATER STORAGE

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1220410P1 - Consultant Engineering Services for Potable Water FixedOpen Contracts Storage Tanks and Pumping Systems Work Auth Prime Vendor CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Periodic Final Finish

Log Off Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type

Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

6232015 8302017 413 Approved 8312017 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard

Enter Vendor Name (or a portion of) Then Click Search - Wilcards Are Permitted (ie wa wawainc) Florida Technical Consultants

Search Reset Finish

No Vendors Found For Your Search Try Again

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41005 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score Go

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0773

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

12122017 YES 430 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

8302016 YES 438 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Final Consultant Evaluation 3142016 YES 478 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0706

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

142016 YES 402 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9016OES - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0731

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

10192015 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0748

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

612015 YES 467 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

2192015 YES 500 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0754

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

252015 YES 409 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0755

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

1242014 YES 415 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8974 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0758

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

6202014 YES 393 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr

WATER amp WASTEWATER

Final Consultant Work Authorization 572014 YES 423 View Docs

(0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

HS0746 ENGINEERING Evaluation

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

4302014 YES 475 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Evaluation 4302014 YES 493 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0710

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

3172014 YES 395 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0753

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

1212014 YES 380 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0763

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

11192013 YES 450 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0775

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 408 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals

Finish

Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed FileRoom DashBoard Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization FileRoom Insert NumberFavorites

Prime Vendor Export To Excel Sub Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0772

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 417 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0771

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

2262013 YES 410 View Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 3: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 3 of 12

B RESPONSIBILITY INFORMATION

The information provided below is intended to inform the Evaluation Committee regarding each proposerrsquos responsibility After careful review of the information provided and the solicitationrsquos requirements the following information is provided for consideration and final determination by the Evaluation Committee

1 Office of Economic and Small Business Development Program

The Broward County Business Opportunity Act of 2012 and the Disadvantaged BusinessEnterprise Program Title 49 Code of Federal Regulations Part 26 establish the Countyrsquospolicies for participation by Small Business Enterprises (SBE) County Business Enterprises (CBE) and Federal Disadvantaged Business Enterprises (DBErsquos) in County contracts

In accordance with the above the (CBEDBESBE) goal participation for this contract is 25

Name of Firm Responsibility Information Remarks

Arcadis US Inc Complies 27

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

Complies 26

Carollo Engineers Inc Complies 25

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

Does not Comply 0

Hazen and Sawyer PC Complies 25

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

Complies 75

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

Complies 30

Additional Information

Florida Technical Consultants LLC initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI) for this solicitation The firm was given three (3) business days to provide documentation demonstrating their good faith efforts to meet the goal Upon review of their good faith efforts OESBD has determined that Florida Technical Consultants LLC did not meet the efforts to meet this goal for this solicitation and is not in compliance with the CBE program requirements

Refer to the OESBD Compliance Memorandum for a report of the proposersrsquo CBE compliance history for projects completed within the last five (5) years of the RFP opening date

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 4 of 12

2 Disclosure of Litigation History The solicitation requests firms to disclose all material cases filed pending or resolved during the last three (3) years prior to the solicitation response due date whether such cases were brought by or against the vendor any parent or subsidiary of the vendor or any predecessor organization It is the responsibility of each proposer to identify and disclose to the County all ldquomaterialrdquo cases ldquoMaterialrdquo cases include cases involving work similar to the scope of work in this solicitation professional negligence malpractice default termination suspension poor performance bankruptcy and business related criminal offenses ldquoMaterialrdquo cases do not include cases that involve garnishment auto negligence personal injury workers compensation foreclosure or a proof of claim filed by the vendor

Name of Firm Responsibility Information Remarks

Arcadis US Inc 29 Disclosed Cases No litigation with Broward County

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

3 Disclosed Cases No litigation with Broward County

Carollo Engineers Inc 0 Disclosed Cases No litigation with Broward County

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

0 Disclosed Cases No litigation with Broward County

Hazen and Sawyer PC 4 Disclosed Cases No litigation with Broward County

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

0 Disclosed Cases No litigation with Broward County

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

3 Disclosed Cases No litigation with Broward County

3 Disclosure of Financial Information The information provided is based on a review by Water and Wastewater ServicesPublic Works Department Each Vendor shall submit its most recent two (2) years of financial statements for review The financial statements are not required to be audited financial statements The annual financial statements shall be in the form of

i Balance sheets income statements and annual reports or ii Tax returns or iii SEC filings

The disclosure of financial information by proposers is a matter of responsibility

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 5 of 12

Name of Firm Responsibility Information Remarks (Current Ratio)

Arcadis US Inc Provided 2017 Financials 160 Provided 2016 Financials 212

Brown and Caldwell Provided 2017 Financials 183 (Corporation) Provided 2016 Financials 178

Provided 2015 Financials 146

Carollo Engineers Inc Provided 2017 Financials 150 Provided 2016 Financials 161 Provided 2015 Financials 164

Florida Technical Consultants Provided 2017 Financials 187 LLC Provided 2016 Financials 164

Hazen and Sawyer PC Provided 2017 Financials 146 Provided 2016 Financials 142

LakdasYohalem Provided 2016 Financials 1511 Engineering Inc Provided 2015 Financials 142271

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Provided 2017 Financials 109 Mathews Consulting a Baxter Provided 2016 Financials 109 amp Woodman Company

Refer to the Financial Review Memorandum for any reportable conditions brought to the attention of the Evaluation Committee

4 Authority to Conduct Business in Florida A Florida corporation or partnership is required to provide evidence with its response that the firm is authorized to transact business in Florida and is in good standing with the Florida Department of State If not with its response such evidence must be submitted to the County upon request by the County

Name of Firm Responsibility Information Remarks

Arcadis US Inc Provided AuthorizedGood Standing

Brown and Caldwell Provided AuthorizedGood Standing (Corporation)

Carollo Engineers Inc Provided AuthorizedGood Standing

Florida Technical Provided AuthorizedGood Standing Consultants LLC

Hazen and Sawyer PC Provided AuthorizedGood Standing

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 6 of 12

LakdasYohalem Provided AuthorizedGood Standing Engineering Inc

Baxter amp Woodman Inc Provided AuthorizedGood Standing dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

5 Affiliated Entities of the Principal(s) All Vendors are required to disclose the names and addresses of ldquoaffiliated entitiesrdquo of the Vendorrsquos principal(s) over the last five (5) years (from the solicitation opening deadline) that have acted as a prime Vendor with the County ldquoAffiliated entitiesrdquo of the principal(s) are those entities related to the Vendor by the sharing of stock or other means of control including but not limited to a subsidiary parent or sibling entity

An Affiliated Entities Certification Form was included in the solicitation and must be completed and returned upon request by the County if not included in the original response

Name of Firm Responsibility Information Remarks

Arcadis US Inc Provided No Affiliates

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

Provided No Affiliates

Carollo Engineers Inc Provided No Affiliates

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

Provided No Affiliates

Hazen and Sawyer PC Provided No Affiliates

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

Provided No Affiliates

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

Provided No Affiliates

6 Insurance Requirements The solicitation indicated the insurance requirements deemed necessary for this project It is not necessary to have this level of insurance in effect at the time of submittal but it is necessary to submit certificates indicating that the firm currently carries the insurance or the vendor needs to submit a letter from the carrier indicating upgrade availability

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 7 of 12

Name of Firm Responsibility Information Remarks

Arcadis US Inc Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

Carollo Engineers Inc Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

Hazen and Sawyer PC Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

Additional Information

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company took exception to Article 831 The firm requested removal of the 831 mold fungus asbestos sexual molestation requirement indicating that this was not insurable

7 Licensing Requirements The solicitation stated that Proposers must provide evidence that they hold a current Professional Engineer license with the State of Florida

Name of Firm Responsibility Information Remarks

Arcadis US Inc Provided Compliant

Brown and Caldwell Provided Compliant (Corporation)

Carollo Engineers Inc Provided Compliant

Florida Technical Provided Compliant Consultants LLC

Hazen and Sawyer PC Provided Compliant

LakdasYohalem Provided Compliant Engineering Inc

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 8 of 12

Baxter amp Woodman Inc Provided Compliant dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

C COUNTY STANDARD TERMS AND CONDITIONS INFORMATION The acceptance of or any exceptions taken to the terms and conditions of the Countyrsquos Agreement shall be considered a part of a Vendorrsquos submittal and will be considered by the Evaluation Committee The applicable Agreement terms and conditions for this solicitation were indicated in the Special Instructions to Vendors Vendors were required to review the applicable terms and conditions and submit the Agreement Exception Form If the Agreement Exception Form is not provided with the submittal it shall be deemed an affirmation by the Vendor that it accepts the Agreement terms and conditions as disclosed in the solicitation If exceptions are taken the Vendor must specifically identify each term and condition with which it is taking an exception

Name of Firm Agree Exceptions

Arcadis US Inc No Article 4 ndash Liquidated Damages

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

Yes None

Carollo Engineers Inc Yes None

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

Yes None

Hazen and Sawyer PC Yes None

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

Yes None

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

No Article asbestosrequirement

831 ndash Mold fungus sexual molestation

D REFERENCES The solicitationrsquos Evaluation Criteria ndash Project Specific Criteria Page 18 Question 3 request that completed references be provided for previous experience and projects Attached are the references as verified by County staff

E PERFORMANCE EVALUATIONS The Broward County Purchasing Division Contracts Central indicates evaluation scores for the proposing firms previously awarded contracts Completed performance evaluations may be provided upon request

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 9 of 12

Attached are Contracts Central performance evaluation history for each vendor as applicable including evaluation type (renewal goals compliance or final) and recommendation for future contracts (yes no or conditional) If a firm has periodic evaluations it will be listed separately

Additional Information In response to the Purchasing Directorrsquos Draft Memorandum to which the vendor can respond within 48 hours to any comments or deficiencies noted in the Purchasing DirectorrsquosDraft Memorandum Brown and Caldwell (Corporation) had a score that was highlighted in bright orange The bright orange highlight indicates that the firm receive an individual scoreof 1 or 2 on an item for that evaluation

F CONE OF SILENCE VIOLATIONS The Cone of Silence for this procurement has been in effect since May 3 2018 which prohibits potential vendors from discussing this solicitation with the Evaluation Committee the County Administrator Deputy County Administrator Assistant County Administrator Assistants to the County Administrator their respective support staff and any other person authorized to evaluate or recommend selection in this procurement process

Upon the first meeting of the Evaluation Committee the Cone of Silence expands to also include County Commissioners and their staff Potential vendors and their representatives are substantially restricted from communicating with County Commissioners and their staff regarding this procurement as stated in the Cone of Silence Ordinance

After application of the Cone of Silence inquiries regarding this solicitation should be directed to the Director of Purchasing or designee The Cone of Silence terminates when the County Commission or other awarding authority takes action which ends the solicitation Vendors are required to certify that they have read understand and will comply with the Cone of Silence Ordinance Section 1-266 Broward County Code of Ordinances

The following is a report of the proposersrsquo Cone of Silence violations

Name of Firm Remarks Violations

Arcadis US Inc Will Comply 1

Brown and Caldwell Will Comply None (Corporation)

Carollo Engineers Inc Will Comply None

Florida Technical Will Comply None Consultants LLC

Hazen and Sawyer PC Will Comply None

LakdasYohalem Engineering Will Comply None Inc

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 10 of 12

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Will Comply None Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

Additional Information

Arcadis US Inc had one violation 2011 - Robert Daoust Principal Scientist Malcolm PirnieArcadis US Inc

Additional Information In response to the Purchasing Directorrsquos Draft Memorandum to which the vendor can respond within 48 hours to any comments or deficiencies noted in the Purchasing DirectorrsquosDraft Memorandum Arcadis US Inc provided information that the cone of silence violationwas from a former employee

G VOLUME OF PREVIOUS WORK - EVALUATION CRITERIA ANDOR TIE BREAK CRITERIA The solicitation states that a number of points will be allocated for volume of previous work of the firm for the past five (5) years The volume of work for each of the proposing firms is as follows

Name of Firm Proposer Reported County Reported Points Allocated

Arcadis US Inc $24988700 $9597102 5 Points

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

$477974497 $477974497 3 Points

Carollo Engineers Inc $214076903 $214076903 5 Points

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

$000 $000 5 Points

Hazen and Sawyer PC

$2164284300 $2221320722 0 Points

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

$5894000 $5894030 5 Points

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

$000 $000 5 Points

Additional Information

5 points allocated to vendors paid $0 to $3000000 3 points allocated to vendors paid $3000001 to $7500000 1 point allocated to vendors paid $7500001 to $10000000 0 points allocated to vendors paid over $10000000

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 11 of 12

H PRINCIPAL BUSINESS LOCATION The solicitation states that a number of points will be allocated for location of the firm The Vendorrsquos principal address in Broward County shall be the Vendorrsquos ldquoPrincipal Addressrdquo as indicated with the Florida Department of State Division of Corporations for at least six (6) months prior to the solicitationrsquos due date A proposer with a principal business location within Broward County will receive five (5) points A proposer not having its principal business location within Broward County will receive zero (0) points

The results are as Proposed Attested Location Verified Points Allocated followsName of Nerve Center in SunBiz Firm

Arcadis US Inc 630 Plaza Drive Suite 10 YES 0 Highlands Ranch CO

Brown and Caldwell 201 North Civic Drive YES 0 (Corporation) Suite 300

Walnut Creek CA

Carollo Engineers 2700 Ygnacio Valley YES 0 Inc Road Suite 300

Walnut Creek CA

Florida Technical 533 East Ocean Avenue YES 0 Consultants LLC Suite 2

Boynton Beach FL

Hazen and Sawyer 4000 Hollywood YES 5 PC Boulevard Suite 750

North Hollywood FL

LakdasYohalem 2211 NE 54th Street YES 5 Engineering Inc Fort Lauderdale FL

Baxter amp Woodman 477 S Rosemary Avenue YES 0 Inc dba Mathews Suite 330 Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company West Palm Beach FL

Additional Information In response to the Purchasing Directorrsquos Draft Memorandum to which the vendor canrespond within 48 hours to any comments or deficiencies noted in the Purchasing Directorrsquos Draft Memorandum Hazen and Sawyer PC principal address as verified in Sunbiz is 4000Hollywood Blvd Suite 750N Hollywood FL 33021

I LOCAL PREFERENCE A vendor is eligible to be considered a local business for Local Preference purposes if it has a physical business address located within the limits of Broward County The vendor must provide a valid business tax receipt issued by Broward County at least one (1) year prior to bid or proposal opening

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 12 of 12

Broward Countyrsquos Local Preference Ordinance specifically excludes the application of a local preference for professional services procured pursuant to Section 287055 FS (CCNA)

J LOCATION - TIE BREAKER A Vendor located within Broward County is eligible for the Location Tie Breaker The County requires a copy of the Broward County Business Tax receipt for a period of time of at least six (6) months prior to the solicitation deadline and it must be provided with its initial submittal

The results are as follows

Name of Firm Eligibility Broward County Tax Receipt

Arcadis US Inc Eligible Provided

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

Eligible Provided

Carollo Engineers Inc Eligible Provided

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

Eligible Provided

Hazen and Sawyer PC Eligible Provided

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

Eligible Provided

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

Eligible Provided

Attachments 1 Vendor Reference Verifications 2 Vendor Performance Evaluations 3 Vendor Responses to Draft Memo

c Bob Melton County Auditor Office of the County Auditor Robert Wilson Title Division Department (Project Manager) Martha Perez-Garviso Purchasing Manager Purchasing Division Finance and Administrative Services Department Glenn Miller Assistant County Attorney Office of the County Attorney Fernando Amuchastegui Assistant County Attorney Office of the County Attorney

BJBGMnomm

Broward County Board of PNC211 5559P1 County Commissioners

BRCWARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LO ~ I DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P 1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis us Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

South Florida Water Management District

Contact Name Rich V irgil PE Title Bureau Chief lnfrabReference date 05142018

Contact Email rvirgilsfwmdgov Contact Phone 561 6826759

Name of Referenced Project S-193 Lock Refurbishment C-41A Canal Bank Stabilization Lake

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

4600000790 1001 2008 UP 12012016 $ 295400000

Vendors role in Project ]rime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Engineering Design and Engineering Services During Construction

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D [] DD c Deliverables []D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [L] D c Turnover D D D0

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget []D D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm [L]D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D 0 D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [] D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via ~AI L VERBAL Verified by ~~ Division WWfD Date ltQamp~(8 All lnformallon provided to Bltoward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate unlrulhful or incorrect statements made In support of this response may be used by the

512gt~11MlflS a lgtasis Of rejection rescission of the award or tenninallon of the contract and ~~lVcrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 of lhe Broward Count~ 41l6tlrelfient Code Y fTmiddot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BR~ltJWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LO R I DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering SeNices for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Saint Petersburg Department of Engineering and Capital Planning

Contact Name Nicole Allen Title CADDGIS Supervi Reference date

Contact Email nicoleallenstpeteorg Contact Phone 727-893-7316

Name of Referenced Project Water Resources Department GIS Data Migration

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

13-03-ARCIT 12092014 UP 09152015 $ 5925000

Vendors role in Project ]rime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again (Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Migration ofwater wastewater and storm water infrastructure information from CAD environment to Esri Local Government Information Model

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D [] D c Deliverables D [] D D

2 Vendors Organization [ZJa Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D [ZJ D c Turnover D D [] D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [ZJ D b Deliverables D D [ZJ D

4 Project completed within budget [ZJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [ZJ D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) [ZJD D D c Regu latory Agency(ies) D D [ZJ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONL rbullbull

Verified via L L VERBAL Verified by Division NlltE~ Date 6(~oatgt 1 8~ All information PfOvided to Bfoward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful oc inCOfrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

512gt9lillll jS a basis 10lt rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and nlll~9rrcrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of lhe Broward Cou~ 42fldtclrhtflent Code middot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BRuWARD1 1 COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering SeNices for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

C ity of Tavares F lorida

Contact Name James Dillon Title Public Works DireltaReference date 05172018

Contact Email jdillontavaresorg Contact Phone 352-455-7718

Name of Referenced Project G IS Modeling and Integration of Utilities Infrastructure

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

060330480000 04012017 UP 10012017 $ 5676000

Vendors role in Project ]rime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Integrate drawings and images depicting pipe infrastructure into a GIS environment for easy retrieval First project of a multi phase program to upgrade the Citys GIS information

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D 0 D c Deliverables D D 0 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D Ill D b Professionalism D D Ill D c Turnover D D 0 D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D Ill D b Deliverables D D Ill D

4 Project completed within budget D D Ill D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D Ill D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D Ill D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY -

Ve rified via L IL VERBAL Verified by fcAJ~ Division llt E1) Date 1 r~ tjlQ t8 All information pwvlded to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incooect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

512G91JlIHIS a basis for rejection rescission or the award or termination or the contract and lnfli~9ncrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 of the Broward CouI)~ 44flamplrelflent Code

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BRd~WARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LO R I DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Miramar

Contact Name Robin E Bain PE Title Project Manager Reference date 05142018

Contact Email rebainmiramarflgov Contact Phone 9548836825

Name of Referenced Project East Water Treatment Plant Replacement Wells and Design-Build

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PO 172624-00 10222017 UP 05142018 $ 56929600

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [ZJYes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Design permitting construction services for new Deep Injection Well and 4 new (replacement) production wells

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy []D D D c Deliverables D []D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D [ZJ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Turnover D D D []

3 Timeliness of a Project D D lZ1 D b Del iverables D D lZ1 D

4 Project completed within budget D D lZ1 D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor( s)Subconsultant( s) D D lZ1 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D lZ1 D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY (

Verified via A IL VER BAL Verified by faltJ~ Division WltEtgt Date 5 ~io l 9 All inlOllllalion pltovided to Broward County is subjecl lo verificalioo VendOt acknowledges lhal lnaccurale unlrulhful or i ncooecl stalemenls made in suppOltI of lhis response may be used by lhe

512gt~llM (lS a basis lot rejeclion rescission of the award or termination of lhe contract and mll~Arrcrve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuanl 10 Section 21119 of lhe Broward Couoty 43Pldtllrbrllent Code Y flmiddot

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Palm Beach County Water Utilities Department

Contact Name Ali Bayat Title Assistant Director Reference date

Contact Email abayatpbcwatercom Contact Phone 561 493 6128

Name of Referenced Project System 8 Water Quality Assessment

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

17-021 CSA21 01 022017 to 01152018 $ 8936000

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again (Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Brown and Caldwell led assessment of contributing causes to low system residuals troubleshooting treatment processes special testing and data analysis improvements to operating protocols monitoringcontrol system and treatment process

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [Z] D b Accuracy D [Z] DD c Deliverables D [Z]D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D [Z] D b Professionalism D D [Z] D c Turnover D [Z] DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D [Z] D

4 Project completed within budget D D [Z] D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Consultant worked collaboratively with operating maintenance engineering and laboratory staff to develop insight into contributing factors and implement improvements

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via _LEMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by tcltJ1~ Division -+LN euro P Date lteh IWt 8 All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the County as a basis for rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and may also serve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward County Procurement Code

BltaWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F L 0 R I D A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood Florida

Contact Name Steve Joseph Title Director Reference date

Contact Email sjosephhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954 921 3522

Name of Referenced Project Distribution System Water Quality Improvement

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

01012016 to 06022017 $ 3000000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again []Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Supported the City with its efforts improve chlorine residuals in areas of its system Analysis included system modeling monitoring optimized operational practices Implemented operational improvements that significantly raised (from approx 05 to 20 mgL) chloramine residuals In the most challenging area of the system

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D D [] D c Deliverables []D D D

2 Vendors Organization [] Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D [] D c Turnover D D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D [] D

4 Project completed within budget []D D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) []D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [] D

Additional Com ments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Effort Included system modoling moniloring and excursion response procedures opllmitallon of stored Inventory management unidirectional flushing pilot assessment and treatment proooss evaluation

Verified via __EMAIL vERBAL Division WW ED Date G Ifgt I 8 All infonmallon pltovided to Broward County Is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of thi s response may be used by lhe County as a basis for rejeclion rescission or the award or tenminatlon of the contract and may also serve as the basis for debanment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 or lhe Broward County Procurement Code

BROWARD t (l)t~ 1 Vendor Reference Verification Form

fl O R I OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of West Palm Beach Florida

Contact Name Jay Kwag Title Project Manager Reference date

Contact Email hjkwagwpborg Contact Phone 561 494 1041

Name of Referenced Project Modeling and Infrastructure General Engineering Consulting Assigments

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

11032014 to HAlt zc1e (on~vi~)

Vendors role in Project 52fPrime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IQves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Planning and General Eng1neerg Servicus 1nctuslve ol Waterwastewater System Master Pian asset management program dovo10pmenV11sset Crt1tcat1ty assessment Mesler PS 115 and sewer cond1hon assessment hydrauhc modeling ol LS 5 and force main sizing water system Capacity Analysis RoPort nydraullc modeling ol operahonat challongos tilt ste11on enatysbulls lac11i1a1e 1nspec11011 or major FM and new develOpmenl 1mpnc1s plpohno design lilt station condbullhon assessment and renabtlilahon (Various ProJecls)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D 0 D b Accuracy D 0D D c Deliverables D D 0 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D Gt D b Professionalism D D ~-- D c Turnover D D Gr D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D B D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget D D r~r D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D c~r D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D 0 D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION F~USE ONLY

__VERBAL Verified via LMAIL Verified by ~J Division ~~~D Date ~ f 2 f~t8 All lnfo11na1t0n pr ()Vl(fed 10 Broward County is svb1et110 ven11ca1ion vendor acknowledges lhll 1naeoura10 unlrulhful 0lt inc0ltrec1 s1a1emen1s medo In support ol 1n1s response may be used Dy the County as a basis fcu rejection re sclsst0n Of 1ho award or 1ormina1lon of l he contract and may also servo as the basis for debarment o f Vendor pursuant lo Section 21 119 of tho ampoward Counly P1ocuremont Code

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A middot

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Michael Low Title Deputy Director Reference date 05172018

Contact Email lowmbbflus Contact Phone 5617426403

Name of Referenced Project Ion Exchange Design Build

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

07022014 to 03212018 $ 100000000

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Carollo handled all of the design and construction of a significant part of the project as a subcontractor to COM Constructors as part of a progressive design build contract

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [Z] D b Accuracy D D [Z] D c Deliverables D D [Z] D

2 Vendors Organization D D [Z] Da Staff expertise b Professionalism D D [Z] D c Turnover D D D [Z]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D [Z] D

4 Project completed within budget D D [Z] D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D [Z] D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [Z] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION F~ COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ~~ Division W -NED Date S-gtozot~ All Information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor aclltnowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

Stii191111X 11s a basis for rejection rescission of the award or termination or the conlact and m~~Arifrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward CounYJ 33Plamptl1til1ent Code Y Imiddot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

B~OWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LORID A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

South Florida Water Management District

Contact Name Greg Coffelt PE Title SFWMD Project Manager Reference date 05172018

Contact Email gcoffeltsfwmdgov Contact Phone 561-682-6853

Name of Referenced Project L-8 Reservoir Inflow Structure and Pump Station

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

4600000861 02152011 to 09192012 $ 144535100

Vendors role in Project [l) Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [l)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Corolla was contracted as an Owners Advisor for a Design-Build contract developed engineering design criteria assisted in RFQ development and evaluation supported RFP technical proposal and cost proposal analysis

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [l] D b Accuracy D [] D D c Deliverables D [] D D

2 Vendors Organization [l]a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D [l] D c Turnover D D D [l]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [l] D b Deliverables D [l] D D

4 Project completed within budget [l] DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [l] D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) [l] DD D c Regu latory Agency(ies) D D D [l]

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Owner Advisor work continued(s) in support of Construction of Pump Station Inflow Gate Structure and levee hardening

Verified via IMAIL __VERBAL Date 5 ( 3 c b() I a All information piovided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that Inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made In support of this response may be used by the

512G9JiIX 11s a basis for rejection rescission or the award or termination or the contract and rllffl~Anampe as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 or the Broward CojlftYi 34~6ttlrbtflent Code Y

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

B0~~AARD ~~t~UNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

Fl ORIOA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Sunrise

Contact Name Luisa Fernanda Arbelaa Title Project Manager Reference date 05162018

Contact Email LArbelaezsunrlseflgov Contact Phone 954-888-6009

Name of Referenced Project City of Sunrise - Springtree WTP Water Stabilization and Solids Handling

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PA 16-003-CE 04072016 to 05292018 $ 50797800

Vendors role in Project ]Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [l]Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Carollo Engineers performed the design study and construction administration services for the City

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D G6 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Carollo Engineers technical knowledge and attenllon lo detall were beneficial lo the pltojad They ecled in lhe C~ys besl Interest In every aspect for lhe d1K8Uon of the projectbull

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via ~MAIL _VERBAL Verified by fc4J~~ Division W fl ED All lnrormalion provided to Broward ltAunty Is oobjoci to vorirtcotion Vendoc ecknowledgu that 1naowrate unlMhfuf 0lt lncocrecl statements rnado In support or this response may be useltI by lhe County as a basis for rejection rescission or the award 0lt termination ol the convect and may also ampOIVe as the babullibull ror debarmont of vondOlt purauont to Section 21119 or the Broward County Proc11oment Code

Bid Sync p 135 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BftQNARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

I l 0 R I 0 A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Florida Technical Consultants

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

VIiiage of Wellington Utilities

Contact Name Bradley Wolak Title Assistant Director Ut11Reference date 5182018

Contact Email bwolakwelllngtonflgov Contact Phone 561-753-2480

Name of Referenced Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 10012017 to Present 3500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vend~ 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again UZfYes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor J_ rJ fJ j(Gr-~k 6 Jti ov1 ~uf-Jiy fgt-r_- syrrzi~ff~ Al

R Q_ d--1 0~l 4 171 i+CI ~~lHI )Please rate your experience with tile Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Applicablereferenced Vendor Improvement

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy B D

DD c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D Db Professionalism D D

c Turnover D DD 3 Timeliness of

a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant(s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Additional Comments (provide on addltjpnal sheetJf needed) bull ~middot$ -JJ fo~~rltjbull lt( c-c_ ~~~ lt fo L1-lfAR- -middot~ I 10 ~ ~

~ bullL ~~ _te_ l~Ilgt~Cef t J ~ l rfbull4 middot r0 laquo r 4111J w f1 rrr- 0r- -i-HIS SECTION(9R COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by fcAJc ~ Division Y-1 IN ED Date 5 ~o w8 All lnfonn1Uon ptollfded to BlOward County le eubjeet to vetfflcatlon Vendor aclltnowledge1 that lneccurale unllJlhfUl or lnconect -bullmenla made In 1UPPort o1 this reopon90 may be uoec1 by the couniy ae a baalS ror re)ectlon re8Claeton Of the award 0t leltmlnatlon Of the contract and may 1l10 MM ae the baale flaquo debarrnont 01 vendor pu11uant to Section 21119 of ll1e Broward County Procurement Codo

BidSync p 18 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F LUFltIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultants LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Palm Beach Public Works

Contact Name Gerry Vazquez Title WRD Technician Reference date 05182018

Contact Email gvazqueztownofpalmbeachcom Contact Phone 772-546-6859

Name of Referenced Project GIS Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 3242014 to Present 13500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [3yenes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

PrwAamprs- favl49z Please rate your experience with the Need a Satlafactory Excellent Not

Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D g- D b Accuracy D Er D c Deliverables g-shyB D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D GJ D b Professionalism D D G- D c Tu mover D D cg- D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D g D b Deliverables D D Qshy D

4 Project completed within budget D D lbJ- D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D El- Db Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [3- D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

BidSync p 17 51232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

120-nWARDLll~ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form fLORllgtA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultant LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Waneya Bryant Title Meter Serv Mgr Reference date 05182018

Contact Email BryantWbbflus Contact Phone 561-742-6427

Name of Referenced Project Boynton Beach Utility GIS Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 12012016 to Present $15000000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

~T~ 5e-r-vtleamp +roM l)h f-es Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D Dc Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ti4 D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ Db Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on addlUonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION~urv USE ONLy u bull

Verified via VEMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by kuJ~ Division W if E D rao(ao8Date 5

All Information provided to Browslaquo COOlty Is Slbject to verfflcation Vendor acKnowledges that lneocurate Untruthful or lncolleel 8tatements made In support d this rfl9pOn98 may be used by 1119 Counly as a batia falt rejection relduion ct Ille award or lemilnlilon of the contract and may al80181Veaa1119 basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 ot Ille Broward CountyProcurement Code

512312018 BidSync p 16

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1

8W1V~isl1War Bid PNC21 15559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Fonn

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Cooper City - middot

Contact Name Michael Bailey PE itle Utilities DlrCity EbullReference date 05011201s

Contact Email MBalleycoopercityflorg Contact Phone (954) 434-5519

Name of Referenced Project City of Cooper City Continuing Professional Services bullContract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

RFQ 2009middot 1 04242009 to Present $ 2 19844200

Vendors role in Project IZJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Since 2009 Hazen has provided Cooper City with engineering services or water and wastewater projects Projects have lnctudeo lhe Pine Island Road Pump Station Lilt S1alions 2 amp 49 Improvements Master Plan Update of the FeaslJl~lty Review of Infrastructure Improvements tor Wastewater and the Eflluent Reuse and Disposal Master Plan

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy 8 D

D ~ D c Deliverables D 0 ~ D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D 0 D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tumover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D GJ- D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D 0 D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) ~D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

bull-rHIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY-

Verified vie EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ct4~ Division ~tUb Date ~ i3~) 0fgt All Information provided to BltCgtWW County 11 wbed ID vamprificalion Velldot adltnowledgu that lnaoewate unlrUhful lncom1ct statemampnla made in wppolt of 11111 response may blt uHd by the

4t2j=~ rejection rHclsslcn of th8 award or lennhallon of Ille eoo1nlct and may also seNamp at tilt basis for dtbarmenl at Vendor puuan1 lo Sectioo 21119 of the Broward COltJi 43

5232018 Bid Sync p24

Broward County Board of PNC211 5559P1

~RiiirilyenlcHUffi~~8CrW~r Bid PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

8DdMARD _ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FL O RIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Fort Lauderdale

Contact Name Rares Patrica PE Title Senior Project Mgr Reference date os1021201s

Contact Email RPetricafortlauderdalegov Contact Phone 9548287150

Name of Referenced Project Stormwater Master Planning and Design Implementation Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

256-11660 04192016 to 04192021 $ 989400000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

vyould you use this vendor again Sves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor The Hazen team Is responsible for delivery of a new stormwaler master plan model a prlorlllzed slormwaterresllency capital Improvements plan and Implementation of designs to address chronic flooding and other slormwater management challenges In the City Primary work tasks Include data collectlon hydrologlclhydraullc modeling and design permitting and construction services for capllal Improvement projects resulting from the revised stormwater master plan (preltmlnary design In seven priority neighborhoods)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION ~R COUNTY USE ONLY

aJ~Verified via pound MA IL _VERBAL Verified by Division W1~tl Date 5 ~3o~ax l S N I informallon p roviltled lo Broward County is sulljecl lo verification Vendor altknowledjj6s lhal inaccurate unlMhlut or lncotreci statements m ade In support of this respon$e may be used by tho

412~-~ rejeclion rescission of the award or termination ol lhe contracl and may also serve as lhe basis for debalment ol Vendor purwant to Section 21119 ol lhe Broward Cou~ 4 3

5232018 Bid Sync p25

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 Br~~~~~rs Bid PNC2115559P1 County t ommissioners

B~uWARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FlOR I CA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

Solicitation PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and s OrganizationFirm Name p

Town of Jupiter

nee

Contact Email davidbjupiterflus Contact Phone (561) 746-5134

Name of Referenced Project Engineering Services for Stormwater and Water Capital Improvements

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount $ 630000000 W17248 (2017 reselection 1012000 to Present (estimated lee-to-date since contract inception) contract number)

Vendors role in Project IZI Prime Vendor osubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again 0Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Descriotion of services orovided bv Vendor Since 2000 Hazen has served as General Consulfant to the Town or Jupiter As General Stormwater and Water Consullant the firm has provided services related to master planning stormwater planning and modeling design NPDES permilling asset management resiliency ratefinancial analysis plan review and construction oversight Water-related capital projs have involved additional system storage and high-service pumping transmission system improvements and RampR at existing facilities

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Verllied via EMAIL _ VERBAL Division WWC D

fo (J-Vv ~ltIvmiddotj Date 5(30(ipf S

Al lnroimallon pngtYICGd 10 Broward Counly Is sub)oel to v8flrcallon vendlaquo acknowledges lhat Inaccurate unlruthlu~ 0t Jnwrrect slatoments made In support ol this response may be used by the 42~~1~0 rojecllon rescission or Ille award or termination or lhe con~acl bullnd mbully also serve as tho basis r0t debarment of Vendor pursuant lo Socllon 21119 of lho Broward Couw 41

5232018 BidSync p 26

a N ~ IL) IL) N u z a_

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLO RI DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Walter Wernecke RA Title Sr Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email WWERNECKEhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Hollywood Marina Restrooms

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

04152015 to Present 7500000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor OSubconsultanVSubcontractor n ~U t1

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

-0 Vgt Description of services provided by VendorO ~ ~ Q) Structural Design and Construction Inspection Services i co Q m ~- c E c0

i E gt Oo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not () uu Appllcable O

E~ referenced Vendor Improvement iii ~sectoO 1 Vendors Quality of Service B mu a Responsive D D

b Accuracy DD c Deliverables D DD

2 Vendors Organization D Da Staff expertise v D b Professionalism~ D D c Turnover D ~D

3 Timeliness of D a Project b Deliverables D ~

4 Pec~~11~$~hinJ~~qt lfr D D 5 Cooperation with f ~

a Your Firm D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D

Al lnfonn1tion pRgttded IO Brwd Cltgtunly lo 1ubjecl IO ibllon vsor ~middot Iha icl-bullmiddot ~ ir-ect slalemenls mode In _ol lhb _ moy ti used by he County as a basis lot rejecUon rnclnlon cl the eward or tonnlnallan of lhl connct 1nd may bullllo 11 the basis for dobalment of Vendor IQtulnl IO SICllOn 21119 at lhe Broword County Procurement Code

Cl ltraquo I() I() I() N ()

Cl z

BRltJWARD ~ middot COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORl OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Davie

Contact Name Emilio DeSimone Title Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email Emilio_DeSimonedavie-fl gov Contact Phone 954-797-1085

Name of Referenced Project Pavillion 5 Linear Park

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

B-17-123 09152015 to 2700000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor O SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es O No If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

0 Description of services provided by Vendor O Q)

iii c Structural Design and Construction Inspection ServicesoQ

CDi-

0cc E gt=gt E ()Oo O () () Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

ii) -e i- Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 111 cs

B ioO

J 1 Vendors Quality of Service Q ()

a Responsive D D b Accuracy D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization []Ll Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D Dtr

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [g D b Deliverables D D ar D

4 Project completed within budget [1tD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) cgD D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via l EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by ~h~ Division WlI Etgt Date 0 f l~o I 8 All lnformaUon provided lO Broward County Is eubJect 10 verifutlon Vendor ecknOMedgoo that lnaocurote unNlhlul or Incorrect statamenle made In aupl)Ort of this reaponse may be used by lho County et o baampla for rejection realtluion of the award or lermlnallon of tho eon1fllcl ond moy olao aorvo os ho basis for debarmont of Vondor purauenl lo Section 21119 of the Broward Counly Procuremen1 Code

0 0 agt a c () z 0

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Terrence Comiskey AIA Title Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email TCOMISKEYhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Van Buren Parking Garage

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PK 14-053 Nov 2014 to Present 8310000

Vendors role in Project t8(Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

o~ Description of services provided by Vendor 1 Q)ltO c Structural Design and Conslructlon Inspection Services 0 Q

0~Jl ccE l E enOo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

gtshy

uu O Improvement Applicable ffireferenced Vendor

~sect 1 Vendors Quality of Service 1 ~

oOau a Responsive D ~ D b Accuracy B D D

D D [- Dc Deliverables

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tum over D D D g

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ D Subcontractor(s )S ubcons u ltant( s)b D D ~ D

c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D yenj D Additional Comments provide on sdditlonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION ~NTY USE ONLY0

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by kW Division W-1-(i~ Date EJo(a~t8 Al lnform1Uon PltOVlded lo Browald Ccxnty It IUbjoct to vorificallon Vendor eoknowfodgea thal lnaewralt U111MhlJI deg inlaquogtlaquobullel amptal11ants made In eupporl of lhls relj)Onse may be used by Iha Counly es a balls l0t rcfecllon rescfuloltI of tho ew1rd or 1ermtnaU0lt1 ol lhbull conllllCI and may elao urve 11 lho basis for dabarmenl of Vondor pursuanl lo Secllon 21 119 of he erowald COUlly CiProcurement Code

~ N ii

00

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 aOWllrp Commficumlref Bid PNC2116615B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Pompano Beach FL

Contact Name Mr A Randolph Brown Title Utilities Director Reference date April 30 2018

Contact Email randolphbrowncopbflcom Contact Phone 954-545-7043

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 201 o Project Amount fees varied

Multiple

Vendors role in Project IKJ Prime Vendor

to 2018

osubconsultanUSubcontractor

(range $10000shy$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D ~ D D c Deliverables D ~ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D ~ D D b Professionalism D D ~ D C Turnover D El DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ 0 b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D [BJ D n c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [XJ o ~

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed) amp~~it -THIS SECTION ~COUNTY USE ONL y-bullbull

Verified via ~AIL __VERBAL Verified by 1lt4 )~ Division N WE O Date 5 faol Z1 18

All lnformotlon providod to BltownrltI Cou nty it aubjoct O verification VendOr acknowledges that lnaccornto untruthful or incorroct 11atomon1s made in support of this response may be used by tho

411p~~)~~J rojoclion roscissioo ol lho award or 1orroinalion of tho contract and roay also s01vo as lhbull basis f0lt d~arroont of VondOf pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward Cou)l1

Bid Sync p 73

40

5232018

Broward County Board of Bid PNC2116659B 1 County Commissioners

B~aWARD gt1- t COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Loxahatchee River Environmental Control District

Contact Name Mr Kris Dean Title Director of Engineering Reference date May 9 2018

Contact Email krisdeanloxahatcheeriverorg Contact Phone 561-747-5700

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 2001 Project Amount fees varied (range $10000shyMultiple to 2018 $250000)

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IR)Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D ~ D D b Accuracy D 0 D D c Deliverables D IBJ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D IB] D D b Professionalism D ~ D D c Turnover D [8J D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D [8J D D b Deliverables D m D D

4 Project completed within budget D ~ D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D ~ D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D Ii] D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D ~ D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SE~ FOR~USE ONLY

Verified via _lEMAIL __VERBAL Verified by ~lt Division fWeb Date I

All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untrulhful or incorrecl slatements made In support of this response may be used by the lJl~~~l~~jSfiir rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and mll~~~ere as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Co)f 10

Broward County Board of Bid PNC21166$9B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A l

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Lake Worth FL

Contact Name Mr Felipe Lofaso TitleAsst Dir Public-ServicesReference date May 9 2018

Contact Email flofasolakeworthorg Contact Phone 561-586-1720

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contract

Contract No Date Services Provided 2014 Project Amount fees varied Multiple to 2018 (range $10000shy

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Services included multiple municipal engineering projects including survey roadway design utility design and coordination (water wastewater stormwater other) along with project management

Needs Satisfactory Excellent NotPlease rate your experience with the Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D GJ D b Accuracy D D Ii] D c Deliverables D Ii] DD

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [i] D c Turnover D D D [X]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D 0 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [X] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION Fe COUNTY USE ONLrbullbull

Verified via MAIL __VERBAL Verified by Division ~wgtgt Date 5~3ol20t8 All information provided to Broward County Is subject lo verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect slalements made in support ol this response may be used by the

OZ~id~~~~j~r rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and m~~~(iirve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Cour~ iG

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - ARCADIS US INC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts

VS0000013130 VS00013130 - ARCADIS US INC Prime Work Auth Vendor SummaryProjects

PURCHASING 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold Procurement No Fixed Contracts FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Favorites Past 5 Years Prime Vendor

Sub Vendor From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 10042017 Purchase Order

Evaluation Purchase Orders 1 POs With A Total Amt Of $20000000 Log Off Paid To Dt ($12132949) Balance $7867051

Contracts Purchase Orders Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx 6192018

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Finish

PURCHASING Weighted Scores Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract FileRoom DashBoard Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number FileRoom Insert

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel Favorites Prime Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Service Evaluation

6132017 YES 486 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Goals Compliance Evaluation

10272016 YES 460 View Docs (0)

6272018

Project Management Information System

Close

Contracts Central Administration

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9130 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-24

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6182018 YES 355 View Docs (1)

Proj Nbr 9320 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-20

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6132018 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9290 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-23

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1122018 YES 494 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-21

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12182017 YES 488 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10162017 YES 473 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

8252017 YES 495 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9321 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-19

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

7112017 YES 476 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-17

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2272017 YES 400 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

10132016 YES 384 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-12

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

5202016 YES 405 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9018 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-06

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10192015 YES 448 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

3202015 YES 385 View Docs (0)

Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL CONSULTANTS

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Project Management Information System

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-04

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12122014 YES 437 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-08

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1242014 YES 423 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-02

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2282014 YES 452 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC

VC0000044184 VC00044184 - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres PS $001 Used $000 Remain $001 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $354848400 Closed 0 Total $000 Total Current Retainage Balance For All Contracts $793370 No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 06292015 Purchase Orders 2 POs With A Total Amt Of $362317900 Paid To Dt ($218795160) Balance $143522740

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 40803 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9058 - DISTRICT 3A POTABLE WATER STORAGE

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1220410P1 - Consultant Engineering Services for Potable Water FixedOpen Contracts Storage Tanks and Pumping Systems Work Auth Prime Vendor CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Periodic Final Finish

Log Off Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type

Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

6232015 8302017 413 Approved 8312017 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard

Enter Vendor Name (or a portion of) Then Click Search - Wilcards Are Permitted (ie wa wawainc) Florida Technical Consultants

Search Reset Finish

No Vendors Found For Your Search Try Again

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41005 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score Go

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0773

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

12122017 YES 430 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

8302016 YES 438 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Final Consultant Evaluation 3142016 YES 478 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0706

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

142016 YES 402 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9016OES - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0731

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

10192015 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0748

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

612015 YES 467 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

2192015 YES 500 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0754

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

252015 YES 409 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0755

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

1242014 YES 415 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8974 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0758

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

6202014 YES 393 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr

WATER amp WASTEWATER

Final Consultant Work Authorization 572014 YES 423 View Docs

(0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

HS0746 ENGINEERING Evaluation

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

4302014 YES 475 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Evaluation 4302014 YES 493 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0710

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

3172014 YES 395 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0753

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

1212014 YES 380 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0763

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

11192013 YES 450 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0775

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 408 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals

Finish

Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed FileRoom DashBoard Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization FileRoom Insert NumberFavorites

Prime Vendor Export To Excel Sub Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0772

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 417 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0771

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

2262013 YES 410 View Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 4: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 4 of 12

2 Disclosure of Litigation History The solicitation requests firms to disclose all material cases filed pending or resolved during the last three (3) years prior to the solicitation response due date whether such cases were brought by or against the vendor any parent or subsidiary of the vendor or any predecessor organization It is the responsibility of each proposer to identify and disclose to the County all ldquomaterialrdquo cases ldquoMaterialrdquo cases include cases involving work similar to the scope of work in this solicitation professional negligence malpractice default termination suspension poor performance bankruptcy and business related criminal offenses ldquoMaterialrdquo cases do not include cases that involve garnishment auto negligence personal injury workers compensation foreclosure or a proof of claim filed by the vendor

Name of Firm Responsibility Information Remarks

Arcadis US Inc 29 Disclosed Cases No litigation with Broward County

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

3 Disclosed Cases No litigation with Broward County

Carollo Engineers Inc 0 Disclosed Cases No litigation with Broward County

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

0 Disclosed Cases No litigation with Broward County

Hazen and Sawyer PC 4 Disclosed Cases No litigation with Broward County

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

0 Disclosed Cases No litigation with Broward County

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

3 Disclosed Cases No litigation with Broward County

3 Disclosure of Financial Information The information provided is based on a review by Water and Wastewater ServicesPublic Works Department Each Vendor shall submit its most recent two (2) years of financial statements for review The financial statements are not required to be audited financial statements The annual financial statements shall be in the form of

i Balance sheets income statements and annual reports or ii Tax returns or iii SEC filings

The disclosure of financial information by proposers is a matter of responsibility

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 5 of 12

Name of Firm Responsibility Information Remarks (Current Ratio)

Arcadis US Inc Provided 2017 Financials 160 Provided 2016 Financials 212

Brown and Caldwell Provided 2017 Financials 183 (Corporation) Provided 2016 Financials 178

Provided 2015 Financials 146

Carollo Engineers Inc Provided 2017 Financials 150 Provided 2016 Financials 161 Provided 2015 Financials 164

Florida Technical Consultants Provided 2017 Financials 187 LLC Provided 2016 Financials 164

Hazen and Sawyer PC Provided 2017 Financials 146 Provided 2016 Financials 142

LakdasYohalem Provided 2016 Financials 1511 Engineering Inc Provided 2015 Financials 142271

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Provided 2017 Financials 109 Mathews Consulting a Baxter Provided 2016 Financials 109 amp Woodman Company

Refer to the Financial Review Memorandum for any reportable conditions brought to the attention of the Evaluation Committee

4 Authority to Conduct Business in Florida A Florida corporation or partnership is required to provide evidence with its response that the firm is authorized to transact business in Florida and is in good standing with the Florida Department of State If not with its response such evidence must be submitted to the County upon request by the County

Name of Firm Responsibility Information Remarks

Arcadis US Inc Provided AuthorizedGood Standing

Brown and Caldwell Provided AuthorizedGood Standing (Corporation)

Carollo Engineers Inc Provided AuthorizedGood Standing

Florida Technical Provided AuthorizedGood Standing Consultants LLC

Hazen and Sawyer PC Provided AuthorizedGood Standing

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 6 of 12

LakdasYohalem Provided AuthorizedGood Standing Engineering Inc

Baxter amp Woodman Inc Provided AuthorizedGood Standing dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

5 Affiliated Entities of the Principal(s) All Vendors are required to disclose the names and addresses of ldquoaffiliated entitiesrdquo of the Vendorrsquos principal(s) over the last five (5) years (from the solicitation opening deadline) that have acted as a prime Vendor with the County ldquoAffiliated entitiesrdquo of the principal(s) are those entities related to the Vendor by the sharing of stock or other means of control including but not limited to a subsidiary parent or sibling entity

An Affiliated Entities Certification Form was included in the solicitation and must be completed and returned upon request by the County if not included in the original response

Name of Firm Responsibility Information Remarks

Arcadis US Inc Provided No Affiliates

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

Provided No Affiliates

Carollo Engineers Inc Provided No Affiliates

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

Provided No Affiliates

Hazen and Sawyer PC Provided No Affiliates

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

Provided No Affiliates

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

Provided No Affiliates

6 Insurance Requirements The solicitation indicated the insurance requirements deemed necessary for this project It is not necessary to have this level of insurance in effect at the time of submittal but it is necessary to submit certificates indicating that the firm currently carries the insurance or the vendor needs to submit a letter from the carrier indicating upgrade availability

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 7 of 12

Name of Firm Responsibility Information Remarks

Arcadis US Inc Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

Carollo Engineers Inc Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

Hazen and Sawyer PC Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

Additional Information

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company took exception to Article 831 The firm requested removal of the 831 mold fungus asbestos sexual molestation requirement indicating that this was not insurable

7 Licensing Requirements The solicitation stated that Proposers must provide evidence that they hold a current Professional Engineer license with the State of Florida

Name of Firm Responsibility Information Remarks

Arcadis US Inc Provided Compliant

Brown and Caldwell Provided Compliant (Corporation)

Carollo Engineers Inc Provided Compliant

Florida Technical Provided Compliant Consultants LLC

Hazen and Sawyer PC Provided Compliant

LakdasYohalem Provided Compliant Engineering Inc

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 8 of 12

Baxter amp Woodman Inc Provided Compliant dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

C COUNTY STANDARD TERMS AND CONDITIONS INFORMATION The acceptance of or any exceptions taken to the terms and conditions of the Countyrsquos Agreement shall be considered a part of a Vendorrsquos submittal and will be considered by the Evaluation Committee The applicable Agreement terms and conditions for this solicitation were indicated in the Special Instructions to Vendors Vendors were required to review the applicable terms and conditions and submit the Agreement Exception Form If the Agreement Exception Form is not provided with the submittal it shall be deemed an affirmation by the Vendor that it accepts the Agreement terms and conditions as disclosed in the solicitation If exceptions are taken the Vendor must specifically identify each term and condition with which it is taking an exception

Name of Firm Agree Exceptions

Arcadis US Inc No Article 4 ndash Liquidated Damages

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

Yes None

Carollo Engineers Inc Yes None

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

Yes None

Hazen and Sawyer PC Yes None

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

Yes None

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

No Article asbestosrequirement

831 ndash Mold fungus sexual molestation

D REFERENCES The solicitationrsquos Evaluation Criteria ndash Project Specific Criteria Page 18 Question 3 request that completed references be provided for previous experience and projects Attached are the references as verified by County staff

E PERFORMANCE EVALUATIONS The Broward County Purchasing Division Contracts Central indicates evaluation scores for the proposing firms previously awarded contracts Completed performance evaluations may be provided upon request

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 9 of 12

Attached are Contracts Central performance evaluation history for each vendor as applicable including evaluation type (renewal goals compliance or final) and recommendation for future contracts (yes no or conditional) If a firm has periodic evaluations it will be listed separately

Additional Information In response to the Purchasing Directorrsquos Draft Memorandum to which the vendor can respond within 48 hours to any comments or deficiencies noted in the Purchasing DirectorrsquosDraft Memorandum Brown and Caldwell (Corporation) had a score that was highlighted in bright orange The bright orange highlight indicates that the firm receive an individual scoreof 1 or 2 on an item for that evaluation

F CONE OF SILENCE VIOLATIONS The Cone of Silence for this procurement has been in effect since May 3 2018 which prohibits potential vendors from discussing this solicitation with the Evaluation Committee the County Administrator Deputy County Administrator Assistant County Administrator Assistants to the County Administrator their respective support staff and any other person authorized to evaluate or recommend selection in this procurement process

Upon the first meeting of the Evaluation Committee the Cone of Silence expands to also include County Commissioners and their staff Potential vendors and their representatives are substantially restricted from communicating with County Commissioners and their staff regarding this procurement as stated in the Cone of Silence Ordinance

After application of the Cone of Silence inquiries regarding this solicitation should be directed to the Director of Purchasing or designee The Cone of Silence terminates when the County Commission or other awarding authority takes action which ends the solicitation Vendors are required to certify that they have read understand and will comply with the Cone of Silence Ordinance Section 1-266 Broward County Code of Ordinances

The following is a report of the proposersrsquo Cone of Silence violations

Name of Firm Remarks Violations

Arcadis US Inc Will Comply 1

Brown and Caldwell Will Comply None (Corporation)

Carollo Engineers Inc Will Comply None

Florida Technical Will Comply None Consultants LLC

Hazen and Sawyer PC Will Comply None

LakdasYohalem Engineering Will Comply None Inc

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 10 of 12

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Will Comply None Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

Additional Information

Arcadis US Inc had one violation 2011 - Robert Daoust Principal Scientist Malcolm PirnieArcadis US Inc

Additional Information In response to the Purchasing Directorrsquos Draft Memorandum to which the vendor can respond within 48 hours to any comments or deficiencies noted in the Purchasing DirectorrsquosDraft Memorandum Arcadis US Inc provided information that the cone of silence violationwas from a former employee

G VOLUME OF PREVIOUS WORK - EVALUATION CRITERIA ANDOR TIE BREAK CRITERIA The solicitation states that a number of points will be allocated for volume of previous work of the firm for the past five (5) years The volume of work for each of the proposing firms is as follows

Name of Firm Proposer Reported County Reported Points Allocated

Arcadis US Inc $24988700 $9597102 5 Points

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

$477974497 $477974497 3 Points

Carollo Engineers Inc $214076903 $214076903 5 Points

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

$000 $000 5 Points

Hazen and Sawyer PC

$2164284300 $2221320722 0 Points

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

$5894000 $5894030 5 Points

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

$000 $000 5 Points

Additional Information

5 points allocated to vendors paid $0 to $3000000 3 points allocated to vendors paid $3000001 to $7500000 1 point allocated to vendors paid $7500001 to $10000000 0 points allocated to vendors paid over $10000000

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 11 of 12

H PRINCIPAL BUSINESS LOCATION The solicitation states that a number of points will be allocated for location of the firm The Vendorrsquos principal address in Broward County shall be the Vendorrsquos ldquoPrincipal Addressrdquo as indicated with the Florida Department of State Division of Corporations for at least six (6) months prior to the solicitationrsquos due date A proposer with a principal business location within Broward County will receive five (5) points A proposer not having its principal business location within Broward County will receive zero (0) points

The results are as Proposed Attested Location Verified Points Allocated followsName of Nerve Center in SunBiz Firm

Arcadis US Inc 630 Plaza Drive Suite 10 YES 0 Highlands Ranch CO

Brown and Caldwell 201 North Civic Drive YES 0 (Corporation) Suite 300

Walnut Creek CA

Carollo Engineers 2700 Ygnacio Valley YES 0 Inc Road Suite 300

Walnut Creek CA

Florida Technical 533 East Ocean Avenue YES 0 Consultants LLC Suite 2

Boynton Beach FL

Hazen and Sawyer 4000 Hollywood YES 5 PC Boulevard Suite 750

North Hollywood FL

LakdasYohalem 2211 NE 54th Street YES 5 Engineering Inc Fort Lauderdale FL

Baxter amp Woodman 477 S Rosemary Avenue YES 0 Inc dba Mathews Suite 330 Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company West Palm Beach FL

Additional Information In response to the Purchasing Directorrsquos Draft Memorandum to which the vendor canrespond within 48 hours to any comments or deficiencies noted in the Purchasing Directorrsquos Draft Memorandum Hazen and Sawyer PC principal address as verified in Sunbiz is 4000Hollywood Blvd Suite 750N Hollywood FL 33021

I LOCAL PREFERENCE A vendor is eligible to be considered a local business for Local Preference purposes if it has a physical business address located within the limits of Broward County The vendor must provide a valid business tax receipt issued by Broward County at least one (1) year prior to bid or proposal opening

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 12 of 12

Broward Countyrsquos Local Preference Ordinance specifically excludes the application of a local preference for professional services procured pursuant to Section 287055 FS (CCNA)

J LOCATION - TIE BREAKER A Vendor located within Broward County is eligible for the Location Tie Breaker The County requires a copy of the Broward County Business Tax receipt for a period of time of at least six (6) months prior to the solicitation deadline and it must be provided with its initial submittal

The results are as follows

Name of Firm Eligibility Broward County Tax Receipt

Arcadis US Inc Eligible Provided

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

Eligible Provided

Carollo Engineers Inc Eligible Provided

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

Eligible Provided

Hazen and Sawyer PC Eligible Provided

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

Eligible Provided

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

Eligible Provided

Attachments 1 Vendor Reference Verifications 2 Vendor Performance Evaluations 3 Vendor Responses to Draft Memo

c Bob Melton County Auditor Office of the County Auditor Robert Wilson Title Division Department (Project Manager) Martha Perez-Garviso Purchasing Manager Purchasing Division Finance and Administrative Services Department Glenn Miller Assistant County Attorney Office of the County Attorney Fernando Amuchastegui Assistant County Attorney Office of the County Attorney

BJBGMnomm

Broward County Board of PNC211 5559P1 County Commissioners

BRCWARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LO ~ I DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P 1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis us Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

South Florida Water Management District

Contact Name Rich V irgil PE Title Bureau Chief lnfrabReference date 05142018

Contact Email rvirgilsfwmdgov Contact Phone 561 6826759

Name of Referenced Project S-193 Lock Refurbishment C-41A Canal Bank Stabilization Lake

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

4600000790 1001 2008 UP 12012016 $ 295400000

Vendors role in Project ]rime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Engineering Design and Engineering Services During Construction

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D [] DD c Deliverables []D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [L] D c Turnover D D D0

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget []D D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm [L]D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D 0 D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [] D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via ~AI L VERBAL Verified by ~~ Division WWfD Date ltQamp~(8 All lnformallon provided to Bltoward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate unlrulhful or incorrect statements made In support of this response may be used by the

512gt~11MlflS a lgtasis Of rejection rescission of the award or tenninallon of the contract and ~~lVcrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 of lhe Broward Count~ 41l6tlrelfient Code Y fTmiddot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BR~ltJWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LO R I DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering SeNices for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Saint Petersburg Department of Engineering and Capital Planning

Contact Name Nicole Allen Title CADDGIS Supervi Reference date

Contact Email nicoleallenstpeteorg Contact Phone 727-893-7316

Name of Referenced Project Water Resources Department GIS Data Migration

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

13-03-ARCIT 12092014 UP 09152015 $ 5925000

Vendors role in Project ]rime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again (Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Migration ofwater wastewater and storm water infrastructure information from CAD environment to Esri Local Government Information Model

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D [] D c Deliverables D [] D D

2 Vendors Organization [ZJa Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D [ZJ D c Turnover D D [] D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [ZJ D b Deliverables D D [ZJ D

4 Project completed within budget [ZJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [ZJ D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) [ZJD D D c Regu latory Agency(ies) D D [ZJ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONL rbullbull

Verified via L L VERBAL Verified by Division NlltE~ Date 6(~oatgt 1 8~ All information PfOvided to Bfoward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful oc inCOfrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

512gt9lillll jS a basis 10lt rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and nlll~9rrcrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of lhe Broward Cou~ 42fldtclrhtflent Code middot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BRuWARD1 1 COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering SeNices for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

C ity of Tavares F lorida

Contact Name James Dillon Title Public Works DireltaReference date 05172018

Contact Email jdillontavaresorg Contact Phone 352-455-7718

Name of Referenced Project G IS Modeling and Integration of Utilities Infrastructure

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

060330480000 04012017 UP 10012017 $ 5676000

Vendors role in Project ]rime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Integrate drawings and images depicting pipe infrastructure into a GIS environment for easy retrieval First project of a multi phase program to upgrade the Citys GIS information

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D 0 D c Deliverables D D 0 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D Ill D b Professionalism D D Ill D c Turnover D D 0 D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D Ill D b Deliverables D D Ill D

4 Project completed within budget D D Ill D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D Ill D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D Ill D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY -

Ve rified via L IL VERBAL Verified by fcAJ~ Division llt E1) Date 1 r~ tjlQ t8 All information pwvlded to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incooect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

512G91JlIHIS a basis for rejection rescission or the award or termination or the contract and lnfli~9ncrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 of the Broward CouI)~ 44flamplrelflent Code

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BRd~WARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LO R I DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Miramar

Contact Name Robin E Bain PE Title Project Manager Reference date 05142018

Contact Email rebainmiramarflgov Contact Phone 9548836825

Name of Referenced Project East Water Treatment Plant Replacement Wells and Design-Build

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PO 172624-00 10222017 UP 05142018 $ 56929600

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [ZJYes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Design permitting construction services for new Deep Injection Well and 4 new (replacement) production wells

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy []D D D c Deliverables D []D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D [ZJ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Turnover D D D []

3 Timeliness of a Project D D lZ1 D b Del iverables D D lZ1 D

4 Project completed within budget D D lZ1 D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor( s)Subconsultant( s) D D lZ1 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D lZ1 D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY (

Verified via A IL VER BAL Verified by faltJ~ Division WltEtgt Date 5 ~io l 9 All inlOllllalion pltovided to Broward County is subjecl lo verificalioo VendOt acknowledges lhal lnaccurale unlrulhful or i ncooecl stalemenls made in suppOltI of lhis response may be used by lhe

512gt~llM (lS a basis lot rejeclion rescission of the award or termination of lhe contract and mll~Arrcrve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuanl 10 Section 21119 of lhe Broward Couoty 43Pldtllrbrllent Code Y flmiddot

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Palm Beach County Water Utilities Department

Contact Name Ali Bayat Title Assistant Director Reference date

Contact Email abayatpbcwatercom Contact Phone 561 493 6128

Name of Referenced Project System 8 Water Quality Assessment

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

17-021 CSA21 01 022017 to 01152018 $ 8936000

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again (Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Brown and Caldwell led assessment of contributing causes to low system residuals troubleshooting treatment processes special testing and data analysis improvements to operating protocols monitoringcontrol system and treatment process

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [Z] D b Accuracy D [Z] DD c Deliverables D [Z]D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D [Z] D b Professionalism D D [Z] D c Turnover D [Z] DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D [Z] D

4 Project completed within budget D D [Z] D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Consultant worked collaboratively with operating maintenance engineering and laboratory staff to develop insight into contributing factors and implement improvements

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via _LEMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by tcltJ1~ Division -+LN euro P Date lteh IWt 8 All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the County as a basis for rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and may also serve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward County Procurement Code

BltaWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F L 0 R I D A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood Florida

Contact Name Steve Joseph Title Director Reference date

Contact Email sjosephhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954 921 3522

Name of Referenced Project Distribution System Water Quality Improvement

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

01012016 to 06022017 $ 3000000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again []Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Supported the City with its efforts improve chlorine residuals in areas of its system Analysis included system modeling monitoring optimized operational practices Implemented operational improvements that significantly raised (from approx 05 to 20 mgL) chloramine residuals In the most challenging area of the system

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D D [] D c Deliverables []D D D

2 Vendors Organization [] Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D [] D c Turnover D D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D [] D

4 Project completed within budget []D D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) []D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [] D

Additional Com ments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Effort Included system modoling moniloring and excursion response procedures opllmitallon of stored Inventory management unidirectional flushing pilot assessment and treatment proooss evaluation

Verified via __EMAIL vERBAL Division WW ED Date G Ifgt I 8 All infonmallon pltovided to Broward County Is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of thi s response may be used by lhe County as a basis for rejeclion rescission or the award or tenminatlon of the contract and may also serve as the basis for debanment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 or lhe Broward County Procurement Code

BROWARD t (l)t~ 1 Vendor Reference Verification Form

fl O R I OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of West Palm Beach Florida

Contact Name Jay Kwag Title Project Manager Reference date

Contact Email hjkwagwpborg Contact Phone 561 494 1041

Name of Referenced Project Modeling and Infrastructure General Engineering Consulting Assigments

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

11032014 to HAlt zc1e (on~vi~)

Vendors role in Project 52fPrime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IQves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Planning and General Eng1neerg Servicus 1nctuslve ol Waterwastewater System Master Pian asset management program dovo10pmenV11sset Crt1tcat1ty assessment Mesler PS 115 and sewer cond1hon assessment hydrauhc modeling ol LS 5 and force main sizing water system Capacity Analysis RoPort nydraullc modeling ol operahonat challongos tilt ste11on enatysbulls lac11i1a1e 1nspec11011 or major FM and new develOpmenl 1mpnc1s plpohno design lilt station condbullhon assessment and renabtlilahon (Various ProJecls)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D 0 D b Accuracy D 0D D c Deliverables D D 0 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D Gt D b Professionalism D D ~-- D c Turnover D D Gr D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D B D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget D D r~r D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D c~r D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D 0 D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION F~USE ONLY

__VERBAL Verified via LMAIL Verified by ~J Division ~~~D Date ~ f 2 f~t8 All lnfo11na1t0n pr ()Vl(fed 10 Broward County is svb1et110 ven11ca1ion vendor acknowledges lhll 1naeoura10 unlrulhful 0lt inc0ltrec1 s1a1emen1s medo In support ol 1n1s response may be used Dy the County as a basis fcu rejection re sclsst0n Of 1ho award or 1ormina1lon of l he contract and may also servo as the basis for debarment o f Vendor pursuant lo Section 21 119 of tho ampoward Counly P1ocuremont Code

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A middot

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Michael Low Title Deputy Director Reference date 05172018

Contact Email lowmbbflus Contact Phone 5617426403

Name of Referenced Project Ion Exchange Design Build

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

07022014 to 03212018 $ 100000000

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Carollo handled all of the design and construction of a significant part of the project as a subcontractor to COM Constructors as part of a progressive design build contract

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [Z] D b Accuracy D D [Z] D c Deliverables D D [Z] D

2 Vendors Organization D D [Z] Da Staff expertise b Professionalism D D [Z] D c Turnover D D D [Z]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D [Z] D

4 Project completed within budget D D [Z] D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D [Z] D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [Z] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION F~ COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ~~ Division W -NED Date S-gtozot~ All Information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor aclltnowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

Stii191111X 11s a basis for rejection rescission of the award or termination or the conlact and m~~Arifrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward CounYJ 33Plamptl1til1ent Code Y Imiddot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

B~OWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LORID A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

South Florida Water Management District

Contact Name Greg Coffelt PE Title SFWMD Project Manager Reference date 05172018

Contact Email gcoffeltsfwmdgov Contact Phone 561-682-6853

Name of Referenced Project L-8 Reservoir Inflow Structure and Pump Station

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

4600000861 02152011 to 09192012 $ 144535100

Vendors role in Project [l) Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [l)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Corolla was contracted as an Owners Advisor for a Design-Build contract developed engineering design criteria assisted in RFQ development and evaluation supported RFP technical proposal and cost proposal analysis

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [l] D b Accuracy D [] D D c Deliverables D [] D D

2 Vendors Organization [l]a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D [l] D c Turnover D D D [l]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [l] D b Deliverables D [l] D D

4 Project completed within budget [l] DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [l] D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) [l] DD D c Regu latory Agency(ies) D D D [l]

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Owner Advisor work continued(s) in support of Construction of Pump Station Inflow Gate Structure and levee hardening

Verified via IMAIL __VERBAL Date 5 ( 3 c b() I a All information piovided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that Inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made In support of this response may be used by the

512G9JiIX 11s a basis for rejection rescission or the award or termination or the contract and rllffl~Anampe as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 or the Broward CojlftYi 34~6ttlrbtflent Code Y

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

B0~~AARD ~~t~UNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

Fl ORIOA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Sunrise

Contact Name Luisa Fernanda Arbelaa Title Project Manager Reference date 05162018

Contact Email LArbelaezsunrlseflgov Contact Phone 954-888-6009

Name of Referenced Project City of Sunrise - Springtree WTP Water Stabilization and Solids Handling

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PA 16-003-CE 04072016 to 05292018 $ 50797800

Vendors role in Project ]Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [l]Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Carollo Engineers performed the design study and construction administration services for the City

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D G6 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Carollo Engineers technical knowledge and attenllon lo detall were beneficial lo the pltojad They ecled in lhe C~ys besl Interest In every aspect for lhe d1K8Uon of the projectbull

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via ~MAIL _VERBAL Verified by fc4J~~ Division W fl ED All lnrormalion provided to Broward ltAunty Is oobjoci to vorirtcotion Vendoc ecknowledgu that 1naowrate unlMhfuf 0lt lncocrecl statements rnado In support or this response may be useltI by lhe County as a basis for rejection rescission or the award 0lt termination ol the convect and may also ampOIVe as the babullibull ror debarmont of vondOlt purauont to Section 21119 or the Broward County Proc11oment Code

Bid Sync p 135 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BftQNARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

I l 0 R I 0 A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Florida Technical Consultants

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

VIiiage of Wellington Utilities

Contact Name Bradley Wolak Title Assistant Director Ut11Reference date 5182018

Contact Email bwolakwelllngtonflgov Contact Phone 561-753-2480

Name of Referenced Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 10012017 to Present 3500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vend~ 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again UZfYes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor J_ rJ fJ j(Gr-~k 6 Jti ov1 ~uf-Jiy fgt-r_- syrrzi~ff~ Al

R Q_ d--1 0~l 4 171 i+CI ~~lHI )Please rate your experience with tile Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Applicablereferenced Vendor Improvement

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy B D

DD c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D Db Professionalism D D

c Turnover D DD 3 Timeliness of

a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant(s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Additional Comments (provide on addltjpnal sheetJf needed) bull ~middot$ -JJ fo~~rltjbull lt( c-c_ ~~~ lt fo L1-lfAR- -middot~ I 10 ~ ~

~ bullL ~~ _te_ l~Ilgt~Cef t J ~ l rfbull4 middot r0 laquo r 4111J w f1 rrr- 0r- -i-HIS SECTION(9R COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by fcAJc ~ Division Y-1 IN ED Date 5 ~o w8 All lnfonn1Uon ptollfded to BlOward County le eubjeet to vetfflcatlon Vendor aclltnowledge1 that lneccurale unllJlhfUl or lnconect -bullmenla made In 1UPPort o1 this reopon90 may be uoec1 by the couniy ae a baalS ror re)ectlon re8Claeton Of the award 0t leltmlnatlon Of the contract and may 1l10 MM ae the baale flaquo debarrnont 01 vendor pu11uant to Section 21119 of ll1e Broward County Procurement Codo

BidSync p 18 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F LUFltIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultants LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Palm Beach Public Works

Contact Name Gerry Vazquez Title WRD Technician Reference date 05182018

Contact Email gvazqueztownofpalmbeachcom Contact Phone 772-546-6859

Name of Referenced Project GIS Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 3242014 to Present 13500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [3yenes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

PrwAamprs- favl49z Please rate your experience with the Need a Satlafactory Excellent Not

Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D g- D b Accuracy D Er D c Deliverables g-shyB D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D GJ D b Professionalism D D G- D c Tu mover D D cg- D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D g D b Deliverables D D Qshy D

4 Project completed within budget D D lbJ- D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D El- Db Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [3- D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

BidSync p 17 51232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

120-nWARDLll~ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form fLORllgtA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultant LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Waneya Bryant Title Meter Serv Mgr Reference date 05182018

Contact Email BryantWbbflus Contact Phone 561-742-6427

Name of Referenced Project Boynton Beach Utility GIS Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 12012016 to Present $15000000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

~T~ 5e-r-vtleamp +roM l)h f-es Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D Dc Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ti4 D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ Db Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on addlUonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION~urv USE ONLy u bull

Verified via VEMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by kuJ~ Division W if E D rao(ao8Date 5

All Information provided to Browslaquo COOlty Is Slbject to verfflcation Vendor acKnowledges that lneocurate Untruthful or lncolleel 8tatements made In support d this rfl9pOn98 may be used by 1119 Counly as a batia falt rejection relduion ct Ille award or lemilnlilon of the contract and may al80181Veaa1119 basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 ot Ille Broward CountyProcurement Code

512312018 BidSync p 16

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1

8W1V~isl1War Bid PNC21 15559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Fonn

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Cooper City - middot

Contact Name Michael Bailey PE itle Utilities DlrCity EbullReference date 05011201s

Contact Email MBalleycoopercityflorg Contact Phone (954) 434-5519

Name of Referenced Project City of Cooper City Continuing Professional Services bullContract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

RFQ 2009middot 1 04242009 to Present $ 2 19844200

Vendors role in Project IZJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Since 2009 Hazen has provided Cooper City with engineering services or water and wastewater projects Projects have lnctudeo lhe Pine Island Road Pump Station Lilt S1alions 2 amp 49 Improvements Master Plan Update of the FeaslJl~lty Review of Infrastructure Improvements tor Wastewater and the Eflluent Reuse and Disposal Master Plan

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy 8 D

D ~ D c Deliverables D 0 ~ D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D 0 D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tumover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D GJ- D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D 0 D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) ~D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

bull-rHIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY-

Verified vie EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ct4~ Division ~tUb Date ~ i3~) 0fgt All Information provided to BltCgtWW County 11 wbed ID vamprificalion Velldot adltnowledgu that lnaoewate unlrUhful lncom1ct statemampnla made in wppolt of 11111 response may blt uHd by the

4t2j=~ rejection rHclsslcn of th8 award or lennhallon of Ille eoo1nlct and may also seNamp at tilt basis for dtbarmenl at Vendor puuan1 lo Sectioo 21119 of the Broward COltJi 43

5232018 Bid Sync p24

Broward County Board of PNC211 5559P1

~RiiirilyenlcHUffi~~8CrW~r Bid PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

8DdMARD _ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FL O RIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Fort Lauderdale

Contact Name Rares Patrica PE Title Senior Project Mgr Reference date os1021201s

Contact Email RPetricafortlauderdalegov Contact Phone 9548287150

Name of Referenced Project Stormwater Master Planning and Design Implementation Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

256-11660 04192016 to 04192021 $ 989400000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

vyould you use this vendor again Sves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor The Hazen team Is responsible for delivery of a new stormwaler master plan model a prlorlllzed slormwaterresllency capital Improvements plan and Implementation of designs to address chronic flooding and other slormwater management challenges In the City Primary work tasks Include data collectlon hydrologlclhydraullc modeling and design permitting and construction services for capllal Improvement projects resulting from the revised stormwater master plan (preltmlnary design In seven priority neighborhoods)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION ~R COUNTY USE ONLY

aJ~Verified via pound MA IL _VERBAL Verified by Division W1~tl Date 5 ~3o~ax l S N I informallon p roviltled lo Broward County is sulljecl lo verification Vendor altknowledjj6s lhal inaccurate unlMhlut or lncotreci statements m ade In support of this respon$e may be used by tho

412~-~ rejeclion rescission of the award or termination ol lhe contracl and may also serve as lhe basis for debalment ol Vendor purwant to Section 21119 ol lhe Broward Cou~ 4 3

5232018 Bid Sync p25

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 Br~~~~~rs Bid PNC2115559P1 County t ommissioners

B~uWARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FlOR I CA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

Solicitation PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and s OrganizationFirm Name p

Town of Jupiter

nee

Contact Email davidbjupiterflus Contact Phone (561) 746-5134

Name of Referenced Project Engineering Services for Stormwater and Water Capital Improvements

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount $ 630000000 W17248 (2017 reselection 1012000 to Present (estimated lee-to-date since contract inception) contract number)

Vendors role in Project IZI Prime Vendor osubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again 0Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Descriotion of services orovided bv Vendor Since 2000 Hazen has served as General Consulfant to the Town or Jupiter As General Stormwater and Water Consullant the firm has provided services related to master planning stormwater planning and modeling design NPDES permilling asset management resiliency ratefinancial analysis plan review and construction oversight Water-related capital projs have involved additional system storage and high-service pumping transmission system improvements and RampR at existing facilities

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Verllied via EMAIL _ VERBAL Division WWC D

fo (J-Vv ~ltIvmiddotj Date 5(30(ipf S

Al lnroimallon pngtYICGd 10 Broward Counly Is sub)oel to v8flrcallon vendlaquo acknowledges lhat Inaccurate unlruthlu~ 0t Jnwrrect slatoments made In support ol this response may be used by the 42~~1~0 rojecllon rescission or Ille award or termination or lhe con~acl bullnd mbully also serve as tho basis r0t debarment of Vendor pursuant lo Socllon 21119 of lho Broward Couw 41

5232018 BidSync p 26

a N ~ IL) IL) N u z a_

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLO RI DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Walter Wernecke RA Title Sr Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email WWERNECKEhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Hollywood Marina Restrooms

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

04152015 to Present 7500000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor OSubconsultanVSubcontractor n ~U t1

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

-0 Vgt Description of services provided by VendorO ~ ~ Q) Structural Design and Construction Inspection Services i co Q m ~- c E c0

i E gt Oo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not () uu Appllcable O

E~ referenced Vendor Improvement iii ~sectoO 1 Vendors Quality of Service B mu a Responsive D D

b Accuracy DD c Deliverables D DD

2 Vendors Organization D Da Staff expertise v D b Professionalism~ D D c Turnover D ~D

3 Timeliness of D a Project b Deliverables D ~

4 Pec~~11~$~hinJ~~qt lfr D D 5 Cooperation with f ~

a Your Firm D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D

Al lnfonn1tion pRgttded IO Brwd Cltgtunly lo 1ubjecl IO ibllon vsor ~middot Iha icl-bullmiddot ~ ir-ect slalemenls mode In _ol lhb _ moy ti used by he County as a basis lot rejecUon rnclnlon cl the eward or tonnlnallan of lhl connct 1nd may bullllo 11 the basis for dobalment of Vendor IQtulnl IO SICllOn 21119 at lhe Broword County Procurement Code

Cl ltraquo I() I() I() N ()

Cl z

BRltJWARD ~ middot COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORl OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Davie

Contact Name Emilio DeSimone Title Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email Emilio_DeSimonedavie-fl gov Contact Phone 954-797-1085

Name of Referenced Project Pavillion 5 Linear Park

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

B-17-123 09152015 to 2700000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor O SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es O No If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

0 Description of services provided by Vendor O Q)

iii c Structural Design and Construction Inspection ServicesoQ

CDi-

0cc E gt=gt E ()Oo O () () Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

ii) -e i- Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 111 cs

B ioO

J 1 Vendors Quality of Service Q ()

a Responsive D D b Accuracy D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization []Ll Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D Dtr

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [g D b Deliverables D D ar D

4 Project completed within budget [1tD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) cgD D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via l EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by ~h~ Division WlI Etgt Date 0 f l~o I 8 All lnformaUon provided lO Broward County Is eubJect 10 verifutlon Vendor ecknOMedgoo that lnaocurote unNlhlul or Incorrect statamenle made In aupl)Ort of this reaponse may be used by lho County et o baampla for rejection realtluion of the award or lermlnallon of tho eon1fllcl ond moy olao aorvo os ho basis for debarmont of Vondor purauenl lo Section 21119 of the Broward Counly Procuremen1 Code

0 0 agt a c () z 0

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Terrence Comiskey AIA Title Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email TCOMISKEYhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Van Buren Parking Garage

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PK 14-053 Nov 2014 to Present 8310000

Vendors role in Project t8(Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

o~ Description of services provided by Vendor 1 Q)ltO c Structural Design and Conslructlon Inspection Services 0 Q

0~Jl ccE l E enOo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

gtshy

uu O Improvement Applicable ffireferenced Vendor

~sect 1 Vendors Quality of Service 1 ~

oOau a Responsive D ~ D b Accuracy B D D

D D [- Dc Deliverables

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tum over D D D g

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ D Subcontractor(s )S ubcons u ltant( s)b D D ~ D

c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D yenj D Additional Comments provide on sdditlonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION ~NTY USE ONLY0

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by kW Division W-1-(i~ Date EJo(a~t8 Al lnform1Uon PltOVlded lo Browald Ccxnty It IUbjoct to vorificallon Vendor eoknowfodgea thal lnaewralt U111MhlJI deg inlaquogtlaquobullel amptal11ants made In eupporl of lhls relj)Onse may be used by Iha Counly es a balls l0t rcfecllon rescfuloltI of tho ew1rd or 1ermtnaU0lt1 ol lhbull conllllCI and may elao urve 11 lho basis for dabarmenl of Vondor pursuanl lo Secllon 21 119 of he erowald COUlly CiProcurement Code

~ N ii

00

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 aOWllrp Commficumlref Bid PNC2116615B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Pompano Beach FL

Contact Name Mr A Randolph Brown Title Utilities Director Reference date April 30 2018

Contact Email randolphbrowncopbflcom Contact Phone 954-545-7043

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 201 o Project Amount fees varied

Multiple

Vendors role in Project IKJ Prime Vendor

to 2018

osubconsultanUSubcontractor

(range $10000shy$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D ~ D D c Deliverables D ~ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D ~ D D b Professionalism D D ~ D C Turnover D El DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ 0 b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D [BJ D n c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [XJ o ~

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed) amp~~it -THIS SECTION ~COUNTY USE ONL y-bullbull

Verified via ~AIL __VERBAL Verified by 1lt4 )~ Division N WE O Date 5 faol Z1 18

All lnformotlon providod to BltownrltI Cou nty it aubjoct O verification VendOr acknowledges that lnaccornto untruthful or incorroct 11atomon1s made in support of this response may be used by tho

411p~~)~~J rojoclion roscissioo ol lho award or 1orroinalion of tho contract and roay also s01vo as lhbull basis f0lt d~arroont of VondOf pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward Cou)l1

Bid Sync p 73

40

5232018

Broward County Board of Bid PNC2116659B 1 County Commissioners

B~aWARD gt1- t COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Loxahatchee River Environmental Control District

Contact Name Mr Kris Dean Title Director of Engineering Reference date May 9 2018

Contact Email krisdeanloxahatcheeriverorg Contact Phone 561-747-5700

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 2001 Project Amount fees varied (range $10000shyMultiple to 2018 $250000)

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IR)Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D ~ D D b Accuracy D 0 D D c Deliverables D IBJ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D IB] D D b Professionalism D ~ D D c Turnover D [8J D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D [8J D D b Deliverables D m D D

4 Project completed within budget D ~ D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D ~ D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D Ii] D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D ~ D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SE~ FOR~USE ONLY

Verified via _lEMAIL __VERBAL Verified by ~lt Division fWeb Date I

All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untrulhful or incorrecl slatements made In support of this response may be used by the lJl~~~l~~jSfiir rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and mll~~~ere as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Co)f 10

Broward County Board of Bid PNC21166$9B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A l

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Lake Worth FL

Contact Name Mr Felipe Lofaso TitleAsst Dir Public-ServicesReference date May 9 2018

Contact Email flofasolakeworthorg Contact Phone 561-586-1720

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contract

Contract No Date Services Provided 2014 Project Amount fees varied Multiple to 2018 (range $10000shy

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Services included multiple municipal engineering projects including survey roadway design utility design and coordination (water wastewater stormwater other) along with project management

Needs Satisfactory Excellent NotPlease rate your experience with the Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D GJ D b Accuracy D D Ii] D c Deliverables D Ii] DD

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [i] D c Turnover D D D [X]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D 0 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [X] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION Fe COUNTY USE ONLrbullbull

Verified via MAIL __VERBAL Verified by Division ~wgtgt Date 5~3ol20t8 All information provided to Broward County Is subject lo verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect slalements made in support ol this response may be used by the

OZ~id~~~~j~r rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and m~~~(iirve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Cour~ iG

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - ARCADIS US INC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts

VS0000013130 VS00013130 - ARCADIS US INC Prime Work Auth Vendor SummaryProjects

PURCHASING 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold Procurement No Fixed Contracts FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Favorites Past 5 Years Prime Vendor

Sub Vendor From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 10042017 Purchase Order

Evaluation Purchase Orders 1 POs With A Total Amt Of $20000000 Log Off Paid To Dt ($12132949) Balance $7867051

Contracts Purchase Orders Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx 6192018

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Finish

PURCHASING Weighted Scores Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract FileRoom DashBoard Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number FileRoom Insert

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel Favorites Prime Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Service Evaluation

6132017 YES 486 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Goals Compliance Evaluation

10272016 YES 460 View Docs (0)

6272018

Project Management Information System

Close

Contracts Central Administration

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9130 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-24

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6182018 YES 355 View Docs (1)

Proj Nbr 9320 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-20

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6132018 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9290 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-23

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1122018 YES 494 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-21

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12182017 YES 488 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10162017 YES 473 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

8252017 YES 495 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9321 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-19

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

7112017 YES 476 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-17

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2272017 YES 400 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

10132016 YES 384 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-12

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

5202016 YES 405 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9018 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-06

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10192015 YES 448 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

3202015 YES 385 View Docs (0)

Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL CONSULTANTS

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Project Management Information System

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-04

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12122014 YES 437 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-08

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1242014 YES 423 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-02

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2282014 YES 452 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC

VC0000044184 VC00044184 - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres PS $001 Used $000 Remain $001 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $354848400 Closed 0 Total $000 Total Current Retainage Balance For All Contracts $793370 No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 06292015 Purchase Orders 2 POs With A Total Amt Of $362317900 Paid To Dt ($218795160) Balance $143522740

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 40803 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9058 - DISTRICT 3A POTABLE WATER STORAGE

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1220410P1 - Consultant Engineering Services for Potable Water FixedOpen Contracts Storage Tanks and Pumping Systems Work Auth Prime Vendor CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Periodic Final Finish

Log Off Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type

Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

6232015 8302017 413 Approved 8312017 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard

Enter Vendor Name (or a portion of) Then Click Search - Wilcards Are Permitted (ie wa wawainc) Florida Technical Consultants

Search Reset Finish

No Vendors Found For Your Search Try Again

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41005 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score Go

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0773

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

12122017 YES 430 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

8302016 YES 438 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Final Consultant Evaluation 3142016 YES 478 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0706

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

142016 YES 402 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9016OES - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0731

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

10192015 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0748

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

612015 YES 467 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

2192015 YES 500 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0754

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

252015 YES 409 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0755

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

1242014 YES 415 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8974 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0758

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

6202014 YES 393 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr

WATER amp WASTEWATER

Final Consultant Work Authorization 572014 YES 423 View Docs

(0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

HS0746 ENGINEERING Evaluation

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

4302014 YES 475 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Evaluation 4302014 YES 493 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0710

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

3172014 YES 395 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0753

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

1212014 YES 380 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0763

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

11192013 YES 450 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0775

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 408 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals

Finish

Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed FileRoom DashBoard Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization FileRoom Insert NumberFavorites

Prime Vendor Export To Excel Sub Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0772

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 417 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0771

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

2262013 YES 410 View Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 5: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 5 of 12

Name of Firm Responsibility Information Remarks (Current Ratio)

Arcadis US Inc Provided 2017 Financials 160 Provided 2016 Financials 212

Brown and Caldwell Provided 2017 Financials 183 (Corporation) Provided 2016 Financials 178

Provided 2015 Financials 146

Carollo Engineers Inc Provided 2017 Financials 150 Provided 2016 Financials 161 Provided 2015 Financials 164

Florida Technical Consultants Provided 2017 Financials 187 LLC Provided 2016 Financials 164

Hazen and Sawyer PC Provided 2017 Financials 146 Provided 2016 Financials 142

LakdasYohalem Provided 2016 Financials 1511 Engineering Inc Provided 2015 Financials 142271

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Provided 2017 Financials 109 Mathews Consulting a Baxter Provided 2016 Financials 109 amp Woodman Company

Refer to the Financial Review Memorandum for any reportable conditions brought to the attention of the Evaluation Committee

4 Authority to Conduct Business in Florida A Florida corporation or partnership is required to provide evidence with its response that the firm is authorized to transact business in Florida and is in good standing with the Florida Department of State If not with its response such evidence must be submitted to the County upon request by the County

Name of Firm Responsibility Information Remarks

Arcadis US Inc Provided AuthorizedGood Standing

Brown and Caldwell Provided AuthorizedGood Standing (Corporation)

Carollo Engineers Inc Provided AuthorizedGood Standing

Florida Technical Provided AuthorizedGood Standing Consultants LLC

Hazen and Sawyer PC Provided AuthorizedGood Standing

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 6 of 12

LakdasYohalem Provided AuthorizedGood Standing Engineering Inc

Baxter amp Woodman Inc Provided AuthorizedGood Standing dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

5 Affiliated Entities of the Principal(s) All Vendors are required to disclose the names and addresses of ldquoaffiliated entitiesrdquo of the Vendorrsquos principal(s) over the last five (5) years (from the solicitation opening deadline) that have acted as a prime Vendor with the County ldquoAffiliated entitiesrdquo of the principal(s) are those entities related to the Vendor by the sharing of stock or other means of control including but not limited to a subsidiary parent or sibling entity

An Affiliated Entities Certification Form was included in the solicitation and must be completed and returned upon request by the County if not included in the original response

Name of Firm Responsibility Information Remarks

Arcadis US Inc Provided No Affiliates

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

Provided No Affiliates

Carollo Engineers Inc Provided No Affiliates

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

Provided No Affiliates

Hazen and Sawyer PC Provided No Affiliates

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

Provided No Affiliates

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

Provided No Affiliates

6 Insurance Requirements The solicitation indicated the insurance requirements deemed necessary for this project It is not necessary to have this level of insurance in effect at the time of submittal but it is necessary to submit certificates indicating that the firm currently carries the insurance or the vendor needs to submit a letter from the carrier indicating upgrade availability

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 7 of 12

Name of Firm Responsibility Information Remarks

Arcadis US Inc Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

Carollo Engineers Inc Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

Hazen and Sawyer PC Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

Additional Information

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company took exception to Article 831 The firm requested removal of the 831 mold fungus asbestos sexual molestation requirement indicating that this was not insurable

7 Licensing Requirements The solicitation stated that Proposers must provide evidence that they hold a current Professional Engineer license with the State of Florida

Name of Firm Responsibility Information Remarks

Arcadis US Inc Provided Compliant

Brown and Caldwell Provided Compliant (Corporation)

Carollo Engineers Inc Provided Compliant

Florida Technical Provided Compliant Consultants LLC

Hazen and Sawyer PC Provided Compliant

LakdasYohalem Provided Compliant Engineering Inc

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 8 of 12

Baxter amp Woodman Inc Provided Compliant dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

C COUNTY STANDARD TERMS AND CONDITIONS INFORMATION The acceptance of or any exceptions taken to the terms and conditions of the Countyrsquos Agreement shall be considered a part of a Vendorrsquos submittal and will be considered by the Evaluation Committee The applicable Agreement terms and conditions for this solicitation were indicated in the Special Instructions to Vendors Vendors were required to review the applicable terms and conditions and submit the Agreement Exception Form If the Agreement Exception Form is not provided with the submittal it shall be deemed an affirmation by the Vendor that it accepts the Agreement terms and conditions as disclosed in the solicitation If exceptions are taken the Vendor must specifically identify each term and condition with which it is taking an exception

Name of Firm Agree Exceptions

Arcadis US Inc No Article 4 ndash Liquidated Damages

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

Yes None

Carollo Engineers Inc Yes None

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

Yes None

Hazen and Sawyer PC Yes None

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

Yes None

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

No Article asbestosrequirement

831 ndash Mold fungus sexual molestation

D REFERENCES The solicitationrsquos Evaluation Criteria ndash Project Specific Criteria Page 18 Question 3 request that completed references be provided for previous experience and projects Attached are the references as verified by County staff

E PERFORMANCE EVALUATIONS The Broward County Purchasing Division Contracts Central indicates evaluation scores for the proposing firms previously awarded contracts Completed performance evaluations may be provided upon request

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 9 of 12

Attached are Contracts Central performance evaluation history for each vendor as applicable including evaluation type (renewal goals compliance or final) and recommendation for future contracts (yes no or conditional) If a firm has periodic evaluations it will be listed separately

Additional Information In response to the Purchasing Directorrsquos Draft Memorandum to which the vendor can respond within 48 hours to any comments or deficiencies noted in the Purchasing DirectorrsquosDraft Memorandum Brown and Caldwell (Corporation) had a score that was highlighted in bright orange The bright orange highlight indicates that the firm receive an individual scoreof 1 or 2 on an item for that evaluation

F CONE OF SILENCE VIOLATIONS The Cone of Silence for this procurement has been in effect since May 3 2018 which prohibits potential vendors from discussing this solicitation with the Evaluation Committee the County Administrator Deputy County Administrator Assistant County Administrator Assistants to the County Administrator their respective support staff and any other person authorized to evaluate or recommend selection in this procurement process

Upon the first meeting of the Evaluation Committee the Cone of Silence expands to also include County Commissioners and their staff Potential vendors and their representatives are substantially restricted from communicating with County Commissioners and their staff regarding this procurement as stated in the Cone of Silence Ordinance

After application of the Cone of Silence inquiries regarding this solicitation should be directed to the Director of Purchasing or designee The Cone of Silence terminates when the County Commission or other awarding authority takes action which ends the solicitation Vendors are required to certify that they have read understand and will comply with the Cone of Silence Ordinance Section 1-266 Broward County Code of Ordinances

The following is a report of the proposersrsquo Cone of Silence violations

Name of Firm Remarks Violations

Arcadis US Inc Will Comply 1

Brown and Caldwell Will Comply None (Corporation)

Carollo Engineers Inc Will Comply None

Florida Technical Will Comply None Consultants LLC

Hazen and Sawyer PC Will Comply None

LakdasYohalem Engineering Will Comply None Inc

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 10 of 12

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Will Comply None Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

Additional Information

Arcadis US Inc had one violation 2011 - Robert Daoust Principal Scientist Malcolm PirnieArcadis US Inc

Additional Information In response to the Purchasing Directorrsquos Draft Memorandum to which the vendor can respond within 48 hours to any comments or deficiencies noted in the Purchasing DirectorrsquosDraft Memorandum Arcadis US Inc provided information that the cone of silence violationwas from a former employee

G VOLUME OF PREVIOUS WORK - EVALUATION CRITERIA ANDOR TIE BREAK CRITERIA The solicitation states that a number of points will be allocated for volume of previous work of the firm for the past five (5) years The volume of work for each of the proposing firms is as follows

Name of Firm Proposer Reported County Reported Points Allocated

Arcadis US Inc $24988700 $9597102 5 Points

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

$477974497 $477974497 3 Points

Carollo Engineers Inc $214076903 $214076903 5 Points

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

$000 $000 5 Points

Hazen and Sawyer PC

$2164284300 $2221320722 0 Points

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

$5894000 $5894030 5 Points

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

$000 $000 5 Points

Additional Information

5 points allocated to vendors paid $0 to $3000000 3 points allocated to vendors paid $3000001 to $7500000 1 point allocated to vendors paid $7500001 to $10000000 0 points allocated to vendors paid over $10000000

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 11 of 12

H PRINCIPAL BUSINESS LOCATION The solicitation states that a number of points will be allocated for location of the firm The Vendorrsquos principal address in Broward County shall be the Vendorrsquos ldquoPrincipal Addressrdquo as indicated with the Florida Department of State Division of Corporations for at least six (6) months prior to the solicitationrsquos due date A proposer with a principal business location within Broward County will receive five (5) points A proposer not having its principal business location within Broward County will receive zero (0) points

The results are as Proposed Attested Location Verified Points Allocated followsName of Nerve Center in SunBiz Firm

Arcadis US Inc 630 Plaza Drive Suite 10 YES 0 Highlands Ranch CO

Brown and Caldwell 201 North Civic Drive YES 0 (Corporation) Suite 300

Walnut Creek CA

Carollo Engineers 2700 Ygnacio Valley YES 0 Inc Road Suite 300

Walnut Creek CA

Florida Technical 533 East Ocean Avenue YES 0 Consultants LLC Suite 2

Boynton Beach FL

Hazen and Sawyer 4000 Hollywood YES 5 PC Boulevard Suite 750

North Hollywood FL

LakdasYohalem 2211 NE 54th Street YES 5 Engineering Inc Fort Lauderdale FL

Baxter amp Woodman 477 S Rosemary Avenue YES 0 Inc dba Mathews Suite 330 Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company West Palm Beach FL

Additional Information In response to the Purchasing Directorrsquos Draft Memorandum to which the vendor canrespond within 48 hours to any comments or deficiencies noted in the Purchasing Directorrsquos Draft Memorandum Hazen and Sawyer PC principal address as verified in Sunbiz is 4000Hollywood Blvd Suite 750N Hollywood FL 33021

I LOCAL PREFERENCE A vendor is eligible to be considered a local business for Local Preference purposes if it has a physical business address located within the limits of Broward County The vendor must provide a valid business tax receipt issued by Broward County at least one (1) year prior to bid or proposal opening

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 12 of 12

Broward Countyrsquos Local Preference Ordinance specifically excludes the application of a local preference for professional services procured pursuant to Section 287055 FS (CCNA)

J LOCATION - TIE BREAKER A Vendor located within Broward County is eligible for the Location Tie Breaker The County requires a copy of the Broward County Business Tax receipt for a period of time of at least six (6) months prior to the solicitation deadline and it must be provided with its initial submittal

The results are as follows

Name of Firm Eligibility Broward County Tax Receipt

Arcadis US Inc Eligible Provided

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

Eligible Provided

Carollo Engineers Inc Eligible Provided

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

Eligible Provided

Hazen and Sawyer PC Eligible Provided

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

Eligible Provided

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

Eligible Provided

Attachments 1 Vendor Reference Verifications 2 Vendor Performance Evaluations 3 Vendor Responses to Draft Memo

c Bob Melton County Auditor Office of the County Auditor Robert Wilson Title Division Department (Project Manager) Martha Perez-Garviso Purchasing Manager Purchasing Division Finance and Administrative Services Department Glenn Miller Assistant County Attorney Office of the County Attorney Fernando Amuchastegui Assistant County Attorney Office of the County Attorney

BJBGMnomm

Broward County Board of PNC211 5559P1 County Commissioners

BRCWARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LO ~ I DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P 1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis us Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

South Florida Water Management District

Contact Name Rich V irgil PE Title Bureau Chief lnfrabReference date 05142018

Contact Email rvirgilsfwmdgov Contact Phone 561 6826759

Name of Referenced Project S-193 Lock Refurbishment C-41A Canal Bank Stabilization Lake

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

4600000790 1001 2008 UP 12012016 $ 295400000

Vendors role in Project ]rime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Engineering Design and Engineering Services During Construction

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D [] DD c Deliverables []D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [L] D c Turnover D D D0

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget []D D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm [L]D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D 0 D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [] D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via ~AI L VERBAL Verified by ~~ Division WWfD Date ltQamp~(8 All lnformallon provided to Bltoward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate unlrulhful or incorrect statements made In support of this response may be used by the

512gt~11MlflS a lgtasis Of rejection rescission of the award or tenninallon of the contract and ~~lVcrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 of lhe Broward Count~ 41l6tlrelfient Code Y fTmiddot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BR~ltJWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LO R I DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering SeNices for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Saint Petersburg Department of Engineering and Capital Planning

Contact Name Nicole Allen Title CADDGIS Supervi Reference date

Contact Email nicoleallenstpeteorg Contact Phone 727-893-7316

Name of Referenced Project Water Resources Department GIS Data Migration

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

13-03-ARCIT 12092014 UP 09152015 $ 5925000

Vendors role in Project ]rime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again (Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Migration ofwater wastewater and storm water infrastructure information from CAD environment to Esri Local Government Information Model

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D [] D c Deliverables D [] D D

2 Vendors Organization [ZJa Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D [ZJ D c Turnover D D [] D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [ZJ D b Deliverables D D [ZJ D

4 Project completed within budget [ZJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [ZJ D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) [ZJD D D c Regu latory Agency(ies) D D [ZJ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONL rbullbull

Verified via L L VERBAL Verified by Division NlltE~ Date 6(~oatgt 1 8~ All information PfOvided to Bfoward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful oc inCOfrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

512gt9lillll jS a basis 10lt rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and nlll~9rrcrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of lhe Broward Cou~ 42fldtclrhtflent Code middot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BRuWARD1 1 COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering SeNices for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

C ity of Tavares F lorida

Contact Name James Dillon Title Public Works DireltaReference date 05172018

Contact Email jdillontavaresorg Contact Phone 352-455-7718

Name of Referenced Project G IS Modeling and Integration of Utilities Infrastructure

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

060330480000 04012017 UP 10012017 $ 5676000

Vendors role in Project ]rime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Integrate drawings and images depicting pipe infrastructure into a GIS environment for easy retrieval First project of a multi phase program to upgrade the Citys GIS information

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D 0 D c Deliverables D D 0 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D Ill D b Professionalism D D Ill D c Turnover D D 0 D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D Ill D b Deliverables D D Ill D

4 Project completed within budget D D Ill D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D Ill D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D Ill D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY -

Ve rified via L IL VERBAL Verified by fcAJ~ Division llt E1) Date 1 r~ tjlQ t8 All information pwvlded to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incooect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

512G91JlIHIS a basis for rejection rescission or the award or termination or the contract and lnfli~9ncrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 of the Broward CouI)~ 44flamplrelflent Code

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BRd~WARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LO R I DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Miramar

Contact Name Robin E Bain PE Title Project Manager Reference date 05142018

Contact Email rebainmiramarflgov Contact Phone 9548836825

Name of Referenced Project East Water Treatment Plant Replacement Wells and Design-Build

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PO 172624-00 10222017 UP 05142018 $ 56929600

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [ZJYes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Design permitting construction services for new Deep Injection Well and 4 new (replacement) production wells

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy []D D D c Deliverables D []D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D [ZJ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Turnover D D D []

3 Timeliness of a Project D D lZ1 D b Del iverables D D lZ1 D

4 Project completed within budget D D lZ1 D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor( s)Subconsultant( s) D D lZ1 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D lZ1 D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY (

Verified via A IL VER BAL Verified by faltJ~ Division WltEtgt Date 5 ~io l 9 All inlOllllalion pltovided to Broward County is subjecl lo verificalioo VendOt acknowledges lhal lnaccurale unlrulhful or i ncooecl stalemenls made in suppOltI of lhis response may be used by lhe

512gt~llM (lS a basis lot rejeclion rescission of the award or termination of lhe contract and mll~Arrcrve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuanl 10 Section 21119 of lhe Broward Couoty 43Pldtllrbrllent Code Y flmiddot

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Palm Beach County Water Utilities Department

Contact Name Ali Bayat Title Assistant Director Reference date

Contact Email abayatpbcwatercom Contact Phone 561 493 6128

Name of Referenced Project System 8 Water Quality Assessment

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

17-021 CSA21 01 022017 to 01152018 $ 8936000

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again (Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Brown and Caldwell led assessment of contributing causes to low system residuals troubleshooting treatment processes special testing and data analysis improvements to operating protocols monitoringcontrol system and treatment process

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [Z] D b Accuracy D [Z] DD c Deliverables D [Z]D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D [Z] D b Professionalism D D [Z] D c Turnover D [Z] DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D [Z] D

4 Project completed within budget D D [Z] D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Consultant worked collaboratively with operating maintenance engineering and laboratory staff to develop insight into contributing factors and implement improvements

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via _LEMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by tcltJ1~ Division -+LN euro P Date lteh IWt 8 All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the County as a basis for rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and may also serve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward County Procurement Code

BltaWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F L 0 R I D A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood Florida

Contact Name Steve Joseph Title Director Reference date

Contact Email sjosephhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954 921 3522

Name of Referenced Project Distribution System Water Quality Improvement

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

01012016 to 06022017 $ 3000000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again []Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Supported the City with its efforts improve chlorine residuals in areas of its system Analysis included system modeling monitoring optimized operational practices Implemented operational improvements that significantly raised (from approx 05 to 20 mgL) chloramine residuals In the most challenging area of the system

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D D [] D c Deliverables []D D D

2 Vendors Organization [] Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D [] D c Turnover D D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D [] D

4 Project completed within budget []D D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) []D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [] D

Additional Com ments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Effort Included system modoling moniloring and excursion response procedures opllmitallon of stored Inventory management unidirectional flushing pilot assessment and treatment proooss evaluation

Verified via __EMAIL vERBAL Division WW ED Date G Ifgt I 8 All infonmallon pltovided to Broward County Is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of thi s response may be used by lhe County as a basis for rejeclion rescission or the award or tenminatlon of the contract and may also serve as the basis for debanment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 or lhe Broward County Procurement Code

BROWARD t (l)t~ 1 Vendor Reference Verification Form

fl O R I OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of West Palm Beach Florida

Contact Name Jay Kwag Title Project Manager Reference date

Contact Email hjkwagwpborg Contact Phone 561 494 1041

Name of Referenced Project Modeling and Infrastructure General Engineering Consulting Assigments

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

11032014 to HAlt zc1e (on~vi~)

Vendors role in Project 52fPrime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IQves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Planning and General Eng1neerg Servicus 1nctuslve ol Waterwastewater System Master Pian asset management program dovo10pmenV11sset Crt1tcat1ty assessment Mesler PS 115 and sewer cond1hon assessment hydrauhc modeling ol LS 5 and force main sizing water system Capacity Analysis RoPort nydraullc modeling ol operahonat challongos tilt ste11on enatysbulls lac11i1a1e 1nspec11011 or major FM and new develOpmenl 1mpnc1s plpohno design lilt station condbullhon assessment and renabtlilahon (Various ProJecls)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D 0 D b Accuracy D 0D D c Deliverables D D 0 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D Gt D b Professionalism D D ~-- D c Turnover D D Gr D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D B D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget D D r~r D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D c~r D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D 0 D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION F~USE ONLY

__VERBAL Verified via LMAIL Verified by ~J Division ~~~D Date ~ f 2 f~t8 All lnfo11na1t0n pr ()Vl(fed 10 Broward County is svb1et110 ven11ca1ion vendor acknowledges lhll 1naeoura10 unlrulhful 0lt inc0ltrec1 s1a1emen1s medo In support ol 1n1s response may be used Dy the County as a basis fcu rejection re sclsst0n Of 1ho award or 1ormina1lon of l he contract and may also servo as the basis for debarment o f Vendor pursuant lo Section 21 119 of tho ampoward Counly P1ocuremont Code

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A middot

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Michael Low Title Deputy Director Reference date 05172018

Contact Email lowmbbflus Contact Phone 5617426403

Name of Referenced Project Ion Exchange Design Build

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

07022014 to 03212018 $ 100000000

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Carollo handled all of the design and construction of a significant part of the project as a subcontractor to COM Constructors as part of a progressive design build contract

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [Z] D b Accuracy D D [Z] D c Deliverables D D [Z] D

2 Vendors Organization D D [Z] Da Staff expertise b Professionalism D D [Z] D c Turnover D D D [Z]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D [Z] D

4 Project completed within budget D D [Z] D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D [Z] D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [Z] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION F~ COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ~~ Division W -NED Date S-gtozot~ All Information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor aclltnowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

Stii191111X 11s a basis for rejection rescission of the award or termination or the conlact and m~~Arifrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward CounYJ 33Plamptl1til1ent Code Y Imiddot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

B~OWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LORID A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

South Florida Water Management District

Contact Name Greg Coffelt PE Title SFWMD Project Manager Reference date 05172018

Contact Email gcoffeltsfwmdgov Contact Phone 561-682-6853

Name of Referenced Project L-8 Reservoir Inflow Structure and Pump Station

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

4600000861 02152011 to 09192012 $ 144535100

Vendors role in Project [l) Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [l)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Corolla was contracted as an Owners Advisor for a Design-Build contract developed engineering design criteria assisted in RFQ development and evaluation supported RFP technical proposal and cost proposal analysis

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [l] D b Accuracy D [] D D c Deliverables D [] D D

2 Vendors Organization [l]a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D [l] D c Turnover D D D [l]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [l] D b Deliverables D [l] D D

4 Project completed within budget [l] DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [l] D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) [l] DD D c Regu latory Agency(ies) D D D [l]

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Owner Advisor work continued(s) in support of Construction of Pump Station Inflow Gate Structure and levee hardening

Verified via IMAIL __VERBAL Date 5 ( 3 c b() I a All information piovided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that Inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made In support of this response may be used by the

512G9JiIX 11s a basis for rejection rescission or the award or termination or the contract and rllffl~Anampe as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 or the Broward CojlftYi 34~6ttlrbtflent Code Y

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

B0~~AARD ~~t~UNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

Fl ORIOA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Sunrise

Contact Name Luisa Fernanda Arbelaa Title Project Manager Reference date 05162018

Contact Email LArbelaezsunrlseflgov Contact Phone 954-888-6009

Name of Referenced Project City of Sunrise - Springtree WTP Water Stabilization and Solids Handling

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PA 16-003-CE 04072016 to 05292018 $ 50797800

Vendors role in Project ]Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [l]Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Carollo Engineers performed the design study and construction administration services for the City

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D G6 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Carollo Engineers technical knowledge and attenllon lo detall were beneficial lo the pltojad They ecled in lhe C~ys besl Interest In every aspect for lhe d1K8Uon of the projectbull

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via ~MAIL _VERBAL Verified by fc4J~~ Division W fl ED All lnrormalion provided to Broward ltAunty Is oobjoci to vorirtcotion Vendoc ecknowledgu that 1naowrate unlMhfuf 0lt lncocrecl statements rnado In support or this response may be useltI by lhe County as a basis for rejection rescission or the award 0lt termination ol the convect and may also ampOIVe as the babullibull ror debarmont of vondOlt purauont to Section 21119 or the Broward County Proc11oment Code

Bid Sync p 135 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BftQNARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

I l 0 R I 0 A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Florida Technical Consultants

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

VIiiage of Wellington Utilities

Contact Name Bradley Wolak Title Assistant Director Ut11Reference date 5182018

Contact Email bwolakwelllngtonflgov Contact Phone 561-753-2480

Name of Referenced Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 10012017 to Present 3500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vend~ 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again UZfYes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor J_ rJ fJ j(Gr-~k 6 Jti ov1 ~uf-Jiy fgt-r_- syrrzi~ff~ Al

R Q_ d--1 0~l 4 171 i+CI ~~lHI )Please rate your experience with tile Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Applicablereferenced Vendor Improvement

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy B D

DD c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D Db Professionalism D D

c Turnover D DD 3 Timeliness of

a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant(s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Additional Comments (provide on addltjpnal sheetJf needed) bull ~middot$ -JJ fo~~rltjbull lt( c-c_ ~~~ lt fo L1-lfAR- -middot~ I 10 ~ ~

~ bullL ~~ _te_ l~Ilgt~Cef t J ~ l rfbull4 middot r0 laquo r 4111J w f1 rrr- 0r- -i-HIS SECTION(9R COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by fcAJc ~ Division Y-1 IN ED Date 5 ~o w8 All lnfonn1Uon ptollfded to BlOward County le eubjeet to vetfflcatlon Vendor aclltnowledge1 that lneccurale unllJlhfUl or lnconect -bullmenla made In 1UPPort o1 this reopon90 may be uoec1 by the couniy ae a baalS ror re)ectlon re8Claeton Of the award 0t leltmlnatlon Of the contract and may 1l10 MM ae the baale flaquo debarrnont 01 vendor pu11uant to Section 21119 of ll1e Broward County Procurement Codo

BidSync p 18 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F LUFltIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultants LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Palm Beach Public Works

Contact Name Gerry Vazquez Title WRD Technician Reference date 05182018

Contact Email gvazqueztownofpalmbeachcom Contact Phone 772-546-6859

Name of Referenced Project GIS Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 3242014 to Present 13500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [3yenes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

PrwAamprs- favl49z Please rate your experience with the Need a Satlafactory Excellent Not

Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D g- D b Accuracy D Er D c Deliverables g-shyB D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D GJ D b Professionalism D D G- D c Tu mover D D cg- D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D g D b Deliverables D D Qshy D

4 Project completed within budget D D lbJ- D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D El- Db Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [3- D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

BidSync p 17 51232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

120-nWARDLll~ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form fLORllgtA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultant LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Waneya Bryant Title Meter Serv Mgr Reference date 05182018

Contact Email BryantWbbflus Contact Phone 561-742-6427

Name of Referenced Project Boynton Beach Utility GIS Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 12012016 to Present $15000000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

~T~ 5e-r-vtleamp +roM l)h f-es Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D Dc Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ti4 D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ Db Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on addlUonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION~urv USE ONLy u bull

Verified via VEMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by kuJ~ Division W if E D rao(ao8Date 5

All Information provided to Browslaquo COOlty Is Slbject to verfflcation Vendor acKnowledges that lneocurate Untruthful or lncolleel 8tatements made In support d this rfl9pOn98 may be used by 1119 Counly as a batia falt rejection relduion ct Ille award or lemilnlilon of the contract and may al80181Veaa1119 basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 ot Ille Broward CountyProcurement Code

512312018 BidSync p 16

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1

8W1V~isl1War Bid PNC21 15559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Fonn

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Cooper City - middot

Contact Name Michael Bailey PE itle Utilities DlrCity EbullReference date 05011201s

Contact Email MBalleycoopercityflorg Contact Phone (954) 434-5519

Name of Referenced Project City of Cooper City Continuing Professional Services bullContract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

RFQ 2009middot 1 04242009 to Present $ 2 19844200

Vendors role in Project IZJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Since 2009 Hazen has provided Cooper City with engineering services or water and wastewater projects Projects have lnctudeo lhe Pine Island Road Pump Station Lilt S1alions 2 amp 49 Improvements Master Plan Update of the FeaslJl~lty Review of Infrastructure Improvements tor Wastewater and the Eflluent Reuse and Disposal Master Plan

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy 8 D

D ~ D c Deliverables D 0 ~ D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D 0 D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tumover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D GJ- D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D 0 D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) ~D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

bull-rHIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY-

Verified vie EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ct4~ Division ~tUb Date ~ i3~) 0fgt All Information provided to BltCgtWW County 11 wbed ID vamprificalion Velldot adltnowledgu that lnaoewate unlrUhful lncom1ct statemampnla made in wppolt of 11111 response may blt uHd by the

4t2j=~ rejection rHclsslcn of th8 award or lennhallon of Ille eoo1nlct and may also seNamp at tilt basis for dtbarmenl at Vendor puuan1 lo Sectioo 21119 of the Broward COltJi 43

5232018 Bid Sync p24

Broward County Board of PNC211 5559P1

~RiiirilyenlcHUffi~~8CrW~r Bid PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

8DdMARD _ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FL O RIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Fort Lauderdale

Contact Name Rares Patrica PE Title Senior Project Mgr Reference date os1021201s

Contact Email RPetricafortlauderdalegov Contact Phone 9548287150

Name of Referenced Project Stormwater Master Planning and Design Implementation Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

256-11660 04192016 to 04192021 $ 989400000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

vyould you use this vendor again Sves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor The Hazen team Is responsible for delivery of a new stormwaler master plan model a prlorlllzed slormwaterresllency capital Improvements plan and Implementation of designs to address chronic flooding and other slormwater management challenges In the City Primary work tasks Include data collectlon hydrologlclhydraullc modeling and design permitting and construction services for capllal Improvement projects resulting from the revised stormwater master plan (preltmlnary design In seven priority neighborhoods)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION ~R COUNTY USE ONLY

aJ~Verified via pound MA IL _VERBAL Verified by Division W1~tl Date 5 ~3o~ax l S N I informallon p roviltled lo Broward County is sulljecl lo verification Vendor altknowledjj6s lhal inaccurate unlMhlut or lncotreci statements m ade In support of this respon$e may be used by tho

412~-~ rejeclion rescission of the award or termination ol lhe contracl and may also serve as lhe basis for debalment ol Vendor purwant to Section 21119 ol lhe Broward Cou~ 4 3

5232018 Bid Sync p25

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 Br~~~~~rs Bid PNC2115559P1 County t ommissioners

B~uWARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FlOR I CA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

Solicitation PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and s OrganizationFirm Name p

Town of Jupiter

nee

Contact Email davidbjupiterflus Contact Phone (561) 746-5134

Name of Referenced Project Engineering Services for Stormwater and Water Capital Improvements

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount $ 630000000 W17248 (2017 reselection 1012000 to Present (estimated lee-to-date since contract inception) contract number)

Vendors role in Project IZI Prime Vendor osubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again 0Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Descriotion of services orovided bv Vendor Since 2000 Hazen has served as General Consulfant to the Town or Jupiter As General Stormwater and Water Consullant the firm has provided services related to master planning stormwater planning and modeling design NPDES permilling asset management resiliency ratefinancial analysis plan review and construction oversight Water-related capital projs have involved additional system storage and high-service pumping transmission system improvements and RampR at existing facilities

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Verllied via EMAIL _ VERBAL Division WWC D

fo (J-Vv ~ltIvmiddotj Date 5(30(ipf S

Al lnroimallon pngtYICGd 10 Broward Counly Is sub)oel to v8flrcallon vendlaquo acknowledges lhat Inaccurate unlruthlu~ 0t Jnwrrect slatoments made In support ol this response may be used by the 42~~1~0 rojecllon rescission or Ille award or termination or lhe con~acl bullnd mbully also serve as tho basis r0t debarment of Vendor pursuant lo Socllon 21119 of lho Broward Couw 41

5232018 BidSync p 26

a N ~ IL) IL) N u z a_

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLO RI DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Walter Wernecke RA Title Sr Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email WWERNECKEhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Hollywood Marina Restrooms

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

04152015 to Present 7500000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor OSubconsultanVSubcontractor n ~U t1

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

-0 Vgt Description of services provided by VendorO ~ ~ Q) Structural Design and Construction Inspection Services i co Q m ~- c E c0

i E gt Oo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not () uu Appllcable O

E~ referenced Vendor Improvement iii ~sectoO 1 Vendors Quality of Service B mu a Responsive D D

b Accuracy DD c Deliverables D DD

2 Vendors Organization D Da Staff expertise v D b Professionalism~ D D c Turnover D ~D

3 Timeliness of D a Project b Deliverables D ~

4 Pec~~11~$~hinJ~~qt lfr D D 5 Cooperation with f ~

a Your Firm D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D

Al lnfonn1tion pRgttded IO Brwd Cltgtunly lo 1ubjecl IO ibllon vsor ~middot Iha icl-bullmiddot ~ ir-ect slalemenls mode In _ol lhb _ moy ti used by he County as a basis lot rejecUon rnclnlon cl the eward or tonnlnallan of lhl connct 1nd may bullllo 11 the basis for dobalment of Vendor IQtulnl IO SICllOn 21119 at lhe Broword County Procurement Code

Cl ltraquo I() I() I() N ()

Cl z

BRltJWARD ~ middot COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORl OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Davie

Contact Name Emilio DeSimone Title Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email Emilio_DeSimonedavie-fl gov Contact Phone 954-797-1085

Name of Referenced Project Pavillion 5 Linear Park

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

B-17-123 09152015 to 2700000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor O SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es O No If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

0 Description of services provided by Vendor O Q)

iii c Structural Design and Construction Inspection ServicesoQ

CDi-

0cc E gt=gt E ()Oo O () () Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

ii) -e i- Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 111 cs

B ioO

J 1 Vendors Quality of Service Q ()

a Responsive D D b Accuracy D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization []Ll Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D Dtr

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [g D b Deliverables D D ar D

4 Project completed within budget [1tD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) cgD D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via l EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by ~h~ Division WlI Etgt Date 0 f l~o I 8 All lnformaUon provided lO Broward County Is eubJect 10 verifutlon Vendor ecknOMedgoo that lnaocurote unNlhlul or Incorrect statamenle made In aupl)Ort of this reaponse may be used by lho County et o baampla for rejection realtluion of the award or lermlnallon of tho eon1fllcl ond moy olao aorvo os ho basis for debarmont of Vondor purauenl lo Section 21119 of the Broward Counly Procuremen1 Code

0 0 agt a c () z 0

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Terrence Comiskey AIA Title Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email TCOMISKEYhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Van Buren Parking Garage

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PK 14-053 Nov 2014 to Present 8310000

Vendors role in Project t8(Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

o~ Description of services provided by Vendor 1 Q)ltO c Structural Design and Conslructlon Inspection Services 0 Q

0~Jl ccE l E enOo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

gtshy

uu O Improvement Applicable ffireferenced Vendor

~sect 1 Vendors Quality of Service 1 ~

oOau a Responsive D ~ D b Accuracy B D D

D D [- Dc Deliverables

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tum over D D D g

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ D Subcontractor(s )S ubcons u ltant( s)b D D ~ D

c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D yenj D Additional Comments provide on sdditlonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION ~NTY USE ONLY0

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by kW Division W-1-(i~ Date EJo(a~t8 Al lnform1Uon PltOVlded lo Browald Ccxnty It IUbjoct to vorificallon Vendor eoknowfodgea thal lnaewralt U111MhlJI deg inlaquogtlaquobullel amptal11ants made In eupporl of lhls relj)Onse may be used by Iha Counly es a balls l0t rcfecllon rescfuloltI of tho ew1rd or 1ermtnaU0lt1 ol lhbull conllllCI and may elao urve 11 lho basis for dabarmenl of Vondor pursuanl lo Secllon 21 119 of he erowald COUlly CiProcurement Code

~ N ii

00

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 aOWllrp Commficumlref Bid PNC2116615B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Pompano Beach FL

Contact Name Mr A Randolph Brown Title Utilities Director Reference date April 30 2018

Contact Email randolphbrowncopbflcom Contact Phone 954-545-7043

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 201 o Project Amount fees varied

Multiple

Vendors role in Project IKJ Prime Vendor

to 2018

osubconsultanUSubcontractor

(range $10000shy$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D ~ D D c Deliverables D ~ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D ~ D D b Professionalism D D ~ D C Turnover D El DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ 0 b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D [BJ D n c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [XJ o ~

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed) amp~~it -THIS SECTION ~COUNTY USE ONL y-bullbull

Verified via ~AIL __VERBAL Verified by 1lt4 )~ Division N WE O Date 5 faol Z1 18

All lnformotlon providod to BltownrltI Cou nty it aubjoct O verification VendOr acknowledges that lnaccornto untruthful or incorroct 11atomon1s made in support of this response may be used by tho

411p~~)~~J rojoclion roscissioo ol lho award or 1orroinalion of tho contract and roay also s01vo as lhbull basis f0lt d~arroont of VondOf pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward Cou)l1

Bid Sync p 73

40

5232018

Broward County Board of Bid PNC2116659B 1 County Commissioners

B~aWARD gt1- t COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Loxahatchee River Environmental Control District

Contact Name Mr Kris Dean Title Director of Engineering Reference date May 9 2018

Contact Email krisdeanloxahatcheeriverorg Contact Phone 561-747-5700

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 2001 Project Amount fees varied (range $10000shyMultiple to 2018 $250000)

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IR)Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D ~ D D b Accuracy D 0 D D c Deliverables D IBJ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D IB] D D b Professionalism D ~ D D c Turnover D [8J D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D [8J D D b Deliverables D m D D

4 Project completed within budget D ~ D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D ~ D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D Ii] D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D ~ D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SE~ FOR~USE ONLY

Verified via _lEMAIL __VERBAL Verified by ~lt Division fWeb Date I

All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untrulhful or incorrecl slatements made In support of this response may be used by the lJl~~~l~~jSfiir rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and mll~~~ere as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Co)f 10

Broward County Board of Bid PNC21166$9B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A l

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Lake Worth FL

Contact Name Mr Felipe Lofaso TitleAsst Dir Public-ServicesReference date May 9 2018

Contact Email flofasolakeworthorg Contact Phone 561-586-1720

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contract

Contract No Date Services Provided 2014 Project Amount fees varied Multiple to 2018 (range $10000shy

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Services included multiple municipal engineering projects including survey roadway design utility design and coordination (water wastewater stormwater other) along with project management

Needs Satisfactory Excellent NotPlease rate your experience with the Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D GJ D b Accuracy D D Ii] D c Deliverables D Ii] DD

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [i] D c Turnover D D D [X]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D 0 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [X] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION Fe COUNTY USE ONLrbullbull

Verified via MAIL __VERBAL Verified by Division ~wgtgt Date 5~3ol20t8 All information provided to Broward County Is subject lo verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect slalements made in support ol this response may be used by the

OZ~id~~~~j~r rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and m~~~(iirve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Cour~ iG

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - ARCADIS US INC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts

VS0000013130 VS00013130 - ARCADIS US INC Prime Work Auth Vendor SummaryProjects

PURCHASING 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold Procurement No Fixed Contracts FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Favorites Past 5 Years Prime Vendor

Sub Vendor From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 10042017 Purchase Order

Evaluation Purchase Orders 1 POs With A Total Amt Of $20000000 Log Off Paid To Dt ($12132949) Balance $7867051

Contracts Purchase Orders Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx 6192018

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Finish

PURCHASING Weighted Scores Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract FileRoom DashBoard Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number FileRoom Insert

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel Favorites Prime Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Service Evaluation

6132017 YES 486 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Goals Compliance Evaluation

10272016 YES 460 View Docs (0)

6272018

Project Management Information System

Close

Contracts Central Administration

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9130 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-24

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6182018 YES 355 View Docs (1)

Proj Nbr 9320 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-20

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6132018 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9290 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-23

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1122018 YES 494 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-21

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12182017 YES 488 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10162017 YES 473 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

8252017 YES 495 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9321 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-19

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

7112017 YES 476 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-17

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2272017 YES 400 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

10132016 YES 384 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-12

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

5202016 YES 405 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9018 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-06

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10192015 YES 448 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

3202015 YES 385 View Docs (0)

Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL CONSULTANTS

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Project Management Information System

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-04

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12122014 YES 437 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-08

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1242014 YES 423 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-02

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2282014 YES 452 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC

VC0000044184 VC00044184 - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres PS $001 Used $000 Remain $001 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $354848400 Closed 0 Total $000 Total Current Retainage Balance For All Contracts $793370 No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 06292015 Purchase Orders 2 POs With A Total Amt Of $362317900 Paid To Dt ($218795160) Balance $143522740

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 40803 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9058 - DISTRICT 3A POTABLE WATER STORAGE

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1220410P1 - Consultant Engineering Services for Potable Water FixedOpen Contracts Storage Tanks and Pumping Systems Work Auth Prime Vendor CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Periodic Final Finish

Log Off Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type

Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

6232015 8302017 413 Approved 8312017 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard

Enter Vendor Name (or a portion of) Then Click Search - Wilcards Are Permitted (ie wa wawainc) Florida Technical Consultants

Search Reset Finish

No Vendors Found For Your Search Try Again

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41005 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score Go

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0773

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

12122017 YES 430 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

8302016 YES 438 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Final Consultant Evaluation 3142016 YES 478 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0706

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

142016 YES 402 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9016OES - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0731

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

10192015 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0748

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

612015 YES 467 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

2192015 YES 500 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0754

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

252015 YES 409 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0755

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

1242014 YES 415 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8974 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0758

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

6202014 YES 393 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr

WATER amp WASTEWATER

Final Consultant Work Authorization 572014 YES 423 View Docs

(0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

HS0746 ENGINEERING Evaluation

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

4302014 YES 475 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Evaluation 4302014 YES 493 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0710

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

3172014 YES 395 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0753

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

1212014 YES 380 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0763

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

11192013 YES 450 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0775

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 408 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals

Finish

Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed FileRoom DashBoard Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization FileRoom Insert NumberFavorites

Prime Vendor Export To Excel Sub Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0772

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 417 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0771

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

2262013 YES 410 View Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 6: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 6 of 12

LakdasYohalem Provided AuthorizedGood Standing Engineering Inc

Baxter amp Woodman Inc Provided AuthorizedGood Standing dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

5 Affiliated Entities of the Principal(s) All Vendors are required to disclose the names and addresses of ldquoaffiliated entitiesrdquo of the Vendorrsquos principal(s) over the last five (5) years (from the solicitation opening deadline) that have acted as a prime Vendor with the County ldquoAffiliated entitiesrdquo of the principal(s) are those entities related to the Vendor by the sharing of stock or other means of control including but not limited to a subsidiary parent or sibling entity

An Affiliated Entities Certification Form was included in the solicitation and must be completed and returned upon request by the County if not included in the original response

Name of Firm Responsibility Information Remarks

Arcadis US Inc Provided No Affiliates

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

Provided No Affiliates

Carollo Engineers Inc Provided No Affiliates

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

Provided No Affiliates

Hazen and Sawyer PC Provided No Affiliates

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

Provided No Affiliates

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

Provided No Affiliates

6 Insurance Requirements The solicitation indicated the insurance requirements deemed necessary for this project It is not necessary to have this level of insurance in effect at the time of submittal but it is necessary to submit certificates indicating that the firm currently carries the insurance or the vendor needs to submit a letter from the carrier indicating upgrade availability

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 7 of 12

Name of Firm Responsibility Information Remarks

Arcadis US Inc Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

Carollo Engineers Inc Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

Hazen and Sawyer PC Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

Additional Information

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company took exception to Article 831 The firm requested removal of the 831 mold fungus asbestos sexual molestation requirement indicating that this was not insurable

7 Licensing Requirements The solicitation stated that Proposers must provide evidence that they hold a current Professional Engineer license with the State of Florida

Name of Firm Responsibility Information Remarks

Arcadis US Inc Provided Compliant

Brown and Caldwell Provided Compliant (Corporation)

Carollo Engineers Inc Provided Compliant

Florida Technical Provided Compliant Consultants LLC

Hazen and Sawyer PC Provided Compliant

LakdasYohalem Provided Compliant Engineering Inc

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 8 of 12

Baxter amp Woodman Inc Provided Compliant dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

C COUNTY STANDARD TERMS AND CONDITIONS INFORMATION The acceptance of or any exceptions taken to the terms and conditions of the Countyrsquos Agreement shall be considered a part of a Vendorrsquos submittal and will be considered by the Evaluation Committee The applicable Agreement terms and conditions for this solicitation were indicated in the Special Instructions to Vendors Vendors were required to review the applicable terms and conditions and submit the Agreement Exception Form If the Agreement Exception Form is not provided with the submittal it shall be deemed an affirmation by the Vendor that it accepts the Agreement terms and conditions as disclosed in the solicitation If exceptions are taken the Vendor must specifically identify each term and condition with which it is taking an exception

Name of Firm Agree Exceptions

Arcadis US Inc No Article 4 ndash Liquidated Damages

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

Yes None

Carollo Engineers Inc Yes None

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

Yes None

Hazen and Sawyer PC Yes None

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

Yes None

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

No Article asbestosrequirement

831 ndash Mold fungus sexual molestation

D REFERENCES The solicitationrsquos Evaluation Criteria ndash Project Specific Criteria Page 18 Question 3 request that completed references be provided for previous experience and projects Attached are the references as verified by County staff

E PERFORMANCE EVALUATIONS The Broward County Purchasing Division Contracts Central indicates evaluation scores for the proposing firms previously awarded contracts Completed performance evaluations may be provided upon request

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 9 of 12

Attached are Contracts Central performance evaluation history for each vendor as applicable including evaluation type (renewal goals compliance or final) and recommendation for future contracts (yes no or conditional) If a firm has periodic evaluations it will be listed separately

Additional Information In response to the Purchasing Directorrsquos Draft Memorandum to which the vendor can respond within 48 hours to any comments or deficiencies noted in the Purchasing DirectorrsquosDraft Memorandum Brown and Caldwell (Corporation) had a score that was highlighted in bright orange The bright orange highlight indicates that the firm receive an individual scoreof 1 or 2 on an item for that evaluation

F CONE OF SILENCE VIOLATIONS The Cone of Silence for this procurement has been in effect since May 3 2018 which prohibits potential vendors from discussing this solicitation with the Evaluation Committee the County Administrator Deputy County Administrator Assistant County Administrator Assistants to the County Administrator their respective support staff and any other person authorized to evaluate or recommend selection in this procurement process

Upon the first meeting of the Evaluation Committee the Cone of Silence expands to also include County Commissioners and their staff Potential vendors and their representatives are substantially restricted from communicating with County Commissioners and their staff regarding this procurement as stated in the Cone of Silence Ordinance

After application of the Cone of Silence inquiries regarding this solicitation should be directed to the Director of Purchasing or designee The Cone of Silence terminates when the County Commission or other awarding authority takes action which ends the solicitation Vendors are required to certify that they have read understand and will comply with the Cone of Silence Ordinance Section 1-266 Broward County Code of Ordinances

The following is a report of the proposersrsquo Cone of Silence violations

Name of Firm Remarks Violations

Arcadis US Inc Will Comply 1

Brown and Caldwell Will Comply None (Corporation)

Carollo Engineers Inc Will Comply None

Florida Technical Will Comply None Consultants LLC

Hazen and Sawyer PC Will Comply None

LakdasYohalem Engineering Will Comply None Inc

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 10 of 12

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Will Comply None Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

Additional Information

Arcadis US Inc had one violation 2011 - Robert Daoust Principal Scientist Malcolm PirnieArcadis US Inc

Additional Information In response to the Purchasing Directorrsquos Draft Memorandum to which the vendor can respond within 48 hours to any comments or deficiencies noted in the Purchasing DirectorrsquosDraft Memorandum Arcadis US Inc provided information that the cone of silence violationwas from a former employee

G VOLUME OF PREVIOUS WORK - EVALUATION CRITERIA ANDOR TIE BREAK CRITERIA The solicitation states that a number of points will be allocated for volume of previous work of the firm for the past five (5) years The volume of work for each of the proposing firms is as follows

Name of Firm Proposer Reported County Reported Points Allocated

Arcadis US Inc $24988700 $9597102 5 Points

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

$477974497 $477974497 3 Points

Carollo Engineers Inc $214076903 $214076903 5 Points

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

$000 $000 5 Points

Hazen and Sawyer PC

$2164284300 $2221320722 0 Points

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

$5894000 $5894030 5 Points

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

$000 $000 5 Points

Additional Information

5 points allocated to vendors paid $0 to $3000000 3 points allocated to vendors paid $3000001 to $7500000 1 point allocated to vendors paid $7500001 to $10000000 0 points allocated to vendors paid over $10000000

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 11 of 12

H PRINCIPAL BUSINESS LOCATION The solicitation states that a number of points will be allocated for location of the firm The Vendorrsquos principal address in Broward County shall be the Vendorrsquos ldquoPrincipal Addressrdquo as indicated with the Florida Department of State Division of Corporations for at least six (6) months prior to the solicitationrsquos due date A proposer with a principal business location within Broward County will receive five (5) points A proposer not having its principal business location within Broward County will receive zero (0) points

The results are as Proposed Attested Location Verified Points Allocated followsName of Nerve Center in SunBiz Firm

Arcadis US Inc 630 Plaza Drive Suite 10 YES 0 Highlands Ranch CO

Brown and Caldwell 201 North Civic Drive YES 0 (Corporation) Suite 300

Walnut Creek CA

Carollo Engineers 2700 Ygnacio Valley YES 0 Inc Road Suite 300

Walnut Creek CA

Florida Technical 533 East Ocean Avenue YES 0 Consultants LLC Suite 2

Boynton Beach FL

Hazen and Sawyer 4000 Hollywood YES 5 PC Boulevard Suite 750

North Hollywood FL

LakdasYohalem 2211 NE 54th Street YES 5 Engineering Inc Fort Lauderdale FL

Baxter amp Woodman 477 S Rosemary Avenue YES 0 Inc dba Mathews Suite 330 Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company West Palm Beach FL

Additional Information In response to the Purchasing Directorrsquos Draft Memorandum to which the vendor canrespond within 48 hours to any comments or deficiencies noted in the Purchasing Directorrsquos Draft Memorandum Hazen and Sawyer PC principal address as verified in Sunbiz is 4000Hollywood Blvd Suite 750N Hollywood FL 33021

I LOCAL PREFERENCE A vendor is eligible to be considered a local business for Local Preference purposes if it has a physical business address located within the limits of Broward County The vendor must provide a valid business tax receipt issued by Broward County at least one (1) year prior to bid or proposal opening

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 12 of 12

Broward Countyrsquos Local Preference Ordinance specifically excludes the application of a local preference for professional services procured pursuant to Section 287055 FS (CCNA)

J LOCATION - TIE BREAKER A Vendor located within Broward County is eligible for the Location Tie Breaker The County requires a copy of the Broward County Business Tax receipt for a period of time of at least six (6) months prior to the solicitation deadline and it must be provided with its initial submittal

The results are as follows

Name of Firm Eligibility Broward County Tax Receipt

Arcadis US Inc Eligible Provided

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

Eligible Provided

Carollo Engineers Inc Eligible Provided

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

Eligible Provided

Hazen and Sawyer PC Eligible Provided

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

Eligible Provided

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

Eligible Provided

Attachments 1 Vendor Reference Verifications 2 Vendor Performance Evaluations 3 Vendor Responses to Draft Memo

c Bob Melton County Auditor Office of the County Auditor Robert Wilson Title Division Department (Project Manager) Martha Perez-Garviso Purchasing Manager Purchasing Division Finance and Administrative Services Department Glenn Miller Assistant County Attorney Office of the County Attorney Fernando Amuchastegui Assistant County Attorney Office of the County Attorney

BJBGMnomm

Broward County Board of PNC211 5559P1 County Commissioners

BRCWARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LO ~ I DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P 1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis us Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

South Florida Water Management District

Contact Name Rich V irgil PE Title Bureau Chief lnfrabReference date 05142018

Contact Email rvirgilsfwmdgov Contact Phone 561 6826759

Name of Referenced Project S-193 Lock Refurbishment C-41A Canal Bank Stabilization Lake

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

4600000790 1001 2008 UP 12012016 $ 295400000

Vendors role in Project ]rime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Engineering Design and Engineering Services During Construction

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D [] DD c Deliverables []D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [L] D c Turnover D D D0

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget []D D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm [L]D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D 0 D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [] D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via ~AI L VERBAL Verified by ~~ Division WWfD Date ltQamp~(8 All lnformallon provided to Bltoward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate unlrulhful or incorrect statements made In support of this response may be used by the

512gt~11MlflS a lgtasis Of rejection rescission of the award or tenninallon of the contract and ~~lVcrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 of lhe Broward Count~ 41l6tlrelfient Code Y fTmiddot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BR~ltJWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LO R I DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering SeNices for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Saint Petersburg Department of Engineering and Capital Planning

Contact Name Nicole Allen Title CADDGIS Supervi Reference date

Contact Email nicoleallenstpeteorg Contact Phone 727-893-7316

Name of Referenced Project Water Resources Department GIS Data Migration

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

13-03-ARCIT 12092014 UP 09152015 $ 5925000

Vendors role in Project ]rime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again (Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Migration ofwater wastewater and storm water infrastructure information from CAD environment to Esri Local Government Information Model

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D [] D c Deliverables D [] D D

2 Vendors Organization [ZJa Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D [ZJ D c Turnover D D [] D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [ZJ D b Deliverables D D [ZJ D

4 Project completed within budget [ZJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [ZJ D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) [ZJD D D c Regu latory Agency(ies) D D [ZJ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONL rbullbull

Verified via L L VERBAL Verified by Division NlltE~ Date 6(~oatgt 1 8~ All information PfOvided to Bfoward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful oc inCOfrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

512gt9lillll jS a basis 10lt rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and nlll~9rrcrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of lhe Broward Cou~ 42fldtclrhtflent Code middot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BRuWARD1 1 COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering SeNices for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

C ity of Tavares F lorida

Contact Name James Dillon Title Public Works DireltaReference date 05172018

Contact Email jdillontavaresorg Contact Phone 352-455-7718

Name of Referenced Project G IS Modeling and Integration of Utilities Infrastructure

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

060330480000 04012017 UP 10012017 $ 5676000

Vendors role in Project ]rime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Integrate drawings and images depicting pipe infrastructure into a GIS environment for easy retrieval First project of a multi phase program to upgrade the Citys GIS information

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D 0 D c Deliverables D D 0 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D Ill D b Professionalism D D Ill D c Turnover D D 0 D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D Ill D b Deliverables D D Ill D

4 Project completed within budget D D Ill D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D Ill D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D Ill D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY -

Ve rified via L IL VERBAL Verified by fcAJ~ Division llt E1) Date 1 r~ tjlQ t8 All information pwvlded to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incooect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

512G91JlIHIS a basis for rejection rescission or the award or termination or the contract and lnfli~9ncrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 of the Broward CouI)~ 44flamplrelflent Code

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BRd~WARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LO R I DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Miramar

Contact Name Robin E Bain PE Title Project Manager Reference date 05142018

Contact Email rebainmiramarflgov Contact Phone 9548836825

Name of Referenced Project East Water Treatment Plant Replacement Wells and Design-Build

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PO 172624-00 10222017 UP 05142018 $ 56929600

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [ZJYes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Design permitting construction services for new Deep Injection Well and 4 new (replacement) production wells

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy []D D D c Deliverables D []D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D [ZJ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Turnover D D D []

3 Timeliness of a Project D D lZ1 D b Del iverables D D lZ1 D

4 Project completed within budget D D lZ1 D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor( s)Subconsultant( s) D D lZ1 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D lZ1 D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY (

Verified via A IL VER BAL Verified by faltJ~ Division WltEtgt Date 5 ~io l 9 All inlOllllalion pltovided to Broward County is subjecl lo verificalioo VendOt acknowledges lhal lnaccurale unlrulhful or i ncooecl stalemenls made in suppOltI of lhis response may be used by lhe

512gt~llM (lS a basis lot rejeclion rescission of the award or termination of lhe contract and mll~Arrcrve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuanl 10 Section 21119 of lhe Broward Couoty 43Pldtllrbrllent Code Y flmiddot

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Palm Beach County Water Utilities Department

Contact Name Ali Bayat Title Assistant Director Reference date

Contact Email abayatpbcwatercom Contact Phone 561 493 6128

Name of Referenced Project System 8 Water Quality Assessment

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

17-021 CSA21 01 022017 to 01152018 $ 8936000

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again (Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Brown and Caldwell led assessment of contributing causes to low system residuals troubleshooting treatment processes special testing and data analysis improvements to operating protocols monitoringcontrol system and treatment process

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [Z] D b Accuracy D [Z] DD c Deliverables D [Z]D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D [Z] D b Professionalism D D [Z] D c Turnover D [Z] DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D [Z] D

4 Project completed within budget D D [Z] D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Consultant worked collaboratively with operating maintenance engineering and laboratory staff to develop insight into contributing factors and implement improvements

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via _LEMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by tcltJ1~ Division -+LN euro P Date lteh IWt 8 All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the County as a basis for rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and may also serve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward County Procurement Code

BltaWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F L 0 R I D A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood Florida

Contact Name Steve Joseph Title Director Reference date

Contact Email sjosephhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954 921 3522

Name of Referenced Project Distribution System Water Quality Improvement

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

01012016 to 06022017 $ 3000000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again []Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Supported the City with its efforts improve chlorine residuals in areas of its system Analysis included system modeling monitoring optimized operational practices Implemented operational improvements that significantly raised (from approx 05 to 20 mgL) chloramine residuals In the most challenging area of the system

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D D [] D c Deliverables []D D D

2 Vendors Organization [] Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D [] D c Turnover D D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D [] D

4 Project completed within budget []D D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) []D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [] D

Additional Com ments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Effort Included system modoling moniloring and excursion response procedures opllmitallon of stored Inventory management unidirectional flushing pilot assessment and treatment proooss evaluation

Verified via __EMAIL vERBAL Division WW ED Date G Ifgt I 8 All infonmallon pltovided to Broward County Is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of thi s response may be used by lhe County as a basis for rejeclion rescission or the award or tenminatlon of the contract and may also serve as the basis for debanment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 or lhe Broward County Procurement Code

BROWARD t (l)t~ 1 Vendor Reference Verification Form

fl O R I OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of West Palm Beach Florida

Contact Name Jay Kwag Title Project Manager Reference date

Contact Email hjkwagwpborg Contact Phone 561 494 1041

Name of Referenced Project Modeling and Infrastructure General Engineering Consulting Assigments

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

11032014 to HAlt zc1e (on~vi~)

Vendors role in Project 52fPrime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IQves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Planning and General Eng1neerg Servicus 1nctuslve ol Waterwastewater System Master Pian asset management program dovo10pmenV11sset Crt1tcat1ty assessment Mesler PS 115 and sewer cond1hon assessment hydrauhc modeling ol LS 5 and force main sizing water system Capacity Analysis RoPort nydraullc modeling ol operahonat challongos tilt ste11on enatysbulls lac11i1a1e 1nspec11011 or major FM and new develOpmenl 1mpnc1s plpohno design lilt station condbullhon assessment and renabtlilahon (Various ProJecls)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D 0 D b Accuracy D 0D D c Deliverables D D 0 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D Gt D b Professionalism D D ~-- D c Turnover D D Gr D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D B D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget D D r~r D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D c~r D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D 0 D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION F~USE ONLY

__VERBAL Verified via LMAIL Verified by ~J Division ~~~D Date ~ f 2 f~t8 All lnfo11na1t0n pr ()Vl(fed 10 Broward County is svb1et110 ven11ca1ion vendor acknowledges lhll 1naeoura10 unlrulhful 0lt inc0ltrec1 s1a1emen1s medo In support ol 1n1s response may be used Dy the County as a basis fcu rejection re sclsst0n Of 1ho award or 1ormina1lon of l he contract and may also servo as the basis for debarment o f Vendor pursuant lo Section 21 119 of tho ampoward Counly P1ocuremont Code

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A middot

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Michael Low Title Deputy Director Reference date 05172018

Contact Email lowmbbflus Contact Phone 5617426403

Name of Referenced Project Ion Exchange Design Build

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

07022014 to 03212018 $ 100000000

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Carollo handled all of the design and construction of a significant part of the project as a subcontractor to COM Constructors as part of a progressive design build contract

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [Z] D b Accuracy D D [Z] D c Deliverables D D [Z] D

2 Vendors Organization D D [Z] Da Staff expertise b Professionalism D D [Z] D c Turnover D D D [Z]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D [Z] D

4 Project completed within budget D D [Z] D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D [Z] D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [Z] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION F~ COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ~~ Division W -NED Date S-gtozot~ All Information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor aclltnowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

Stii191111X 11s a basis for rejection rescission of the award or termination or the conlact and m~~Arifrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward CounYJ 33Plamptl1til1ent Code Y Imiddot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

B~OWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LORID A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

South Florida Water Management District

Contact Name Greg Coffelt PE Title SFWMD Project Manager Reference date 05172018

Contact Email gcoffeltsfwmdgov Contact Phone 561-682-6853

Name of Referenced Project L-8 Reservoir Inflow Structure and Pump Station

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

4600000861 02152011 to 09192012 $ 144535100

Vendors role in Project [l) Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [l)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Corolla was contracted as an Owners Advisor for a Design-Build contract developed engineering design criteria assisted in RFQ development and evaluation supported RFP technical proposal and cost proposal analysis

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [l] D b Accuracy D [] D D c Deliverables D [] D D

2 Vendors Organization [l]a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D [l] D c Turnover D D D [l]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [l] D b Deliverables D [l] D D

4 Project completed within budget [l] DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [l] D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) [l] DD D c Regu latory Agency(ies) D D D [l]

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Owner Advisor work continued(s) in support of Construction of Pump Station Inflow Gate Structure and levee hardening

Verified via IMAIL __VERBAL Date 5 ( 3 c b() I a All information piovided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that Inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made In support of this response may be used by the

512G9JiIX 11s a basis for rejection rescission or the award or termination or the contract and rllffl~Anampe as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 or the Broward CojlftYi 34~6ttlrbtflent Code Y

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

B0~~AARD ~~t~UNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

Fl ORIOA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Sunrise

Contact Name Luisa Fernanda Arbelaa Title Project Manager Reference date 05162018

Contact Email LArbelaezsunrlseflgov Contact Phone 954-888-6009

Name of Referenced Project City of Sunrise - Springtree WTP Water Stabilization and Solids Handling

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PA 16-003-CE 04072016 to 05292018 $ 50797800

Vendors role in Project ]Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [l]Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Carollo Engineers performed the design study and construction administration services for the City

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D G6 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Carollo Engineers technical knowledge and attenllon lo detall were beneficial lo the pltojad They ecled in lhe C~ys besl Interest In every aspect for lhe d1K8Uon of the projectbull

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via ~MAIL _VERBAL Verified by fc4J~~ Division W fl ED All lnrormalion provided to Broward ltAunty Is oobjoci to vorirtcotion Vendoc ecknowledgu that 1naowrate unlMhfuf 0lt lncocrecl statements rnado In support or this response may be useltI by lhe County as a basis for rejection rescission or the award 0lt termination ol the convect and may also ampOIVe as the babullibull ror debarmont of vondOlt purauont to Section 21119 or the Broward County Proc11oment Code

Bid Sync p 135 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BftQNARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

I l 0 R I 0 A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Florida Technical Consultants

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

VIiiage of Wellington Utilities

Contact Name Bradley Wolak Title Assistant Director Ut11Reference date 5182018

Contact Email bwolakwelllngtonflgov Contact Phone 561-753-2480

Name of Referenced Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 10012017 to Present 3500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vend~ 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again UZfYes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor J_ rJ fJ j(Gr-~k 6 Jti ov1 ~uf-Jiy fgt-r_- syrrzi~ff~ Al

R Q_ d--1 0~l 4 171 i+CI ~~lHI )Please rate your experience with tile Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Applicablereferenced Vendor Improvement

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy B D

DD c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D Db Professionalism D D

c Turnover D DD 3 Timeliness of

a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant(s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Additional Comments (provide on addltjpnal sheetJf needed) bull ~middot$ -JJ fo~~rltjbull lt( c-c_ ~~~ lt fo L1-lfAR- -middot~ I 10 ~ ~

~ bullL ~~ _te_ l~Ilgt~Cef t J ~ l rfbull4 middot r0 laquo r 4111J w f1 rrr- 0r- -i-HIS SECTION(9R COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by fcAJc ~ Division Y-1 IN ED Date 5 ~o w8 All lnfonn1Uon ptollfded to BlOward County le eubjeet to vetfflcatlon Vendor aclltnowledge1 that lneccurale unllJlhfUl or lnconect -bullmenla made In 1UPPort o1 this reopon90 may be uoec1 by the couniy ae a baalS ror re)ectlon re8Claeton Of the award 0t leltmlnatlon Of the contract and may 1l10 MM ae the baale flaquo debarrnont 01 vendor pu11uant to Section 21119 of ll1e Broward County Procurement Codo

BidSync p 18 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F LUFltIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultants LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Palm Beach Public Works

Contact Name Gerry Vazquez Title WRD Technician Reference date 05182018

Contact Email gvazqueztownofpalmbeachcom Contact Phone 772-546-6859

Name of Referenced Project GIS Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 3242014 to Present 13500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [3yenes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

PrwAamprs- favl49z Please rate your experience with the Need a Satlafactory Excellent Not

Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D g- D b Accuracy D Er D c Deliverables g-shyB D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D GJ D b Professionalism D D G- D c Tu mover D D cg- D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D g D b Deliverables D D Qshy D

4 Project completed within budget D D lbJ- D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D El- Db Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [3- D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

BidSync p 17 51232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

120-nWARDLll~ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form fLORllgtA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultant LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Waneya Bryant Title Meter Serv Mgr Reference date 05182018

Contact Email BryantWbbflus Contact Phone 561-742-6427

Name of Referenced Project Boynton Beach Utility GIS Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 12012016 to Present $15000000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

~T~ 5e-r-vtleamp +roM l)h f-es Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D Dc Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ti4 D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ Db Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on addlUonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION~urv USE ONLy u bull

Verified via VEMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by kuJ~ Division W if E D rao(ao8Date 5

All Information provided to Browslaquo COOlty Is Slbject to verfflcation Vendor acKnowledges that lneocurate Untruthful or lncolleel 8tatements made In support d this rfl9pOn98 may be used by 1119 Counly as a batia falt rejection relduion ct Ille award or lemilnlilon of the contract and may al80181Veaa1119 basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 ot Ille Broward CountyProcurement Code

512312018 BidSync p 16

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1

8W1V~isl1War Bid PNC21 15559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Fonn

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Cooper City - middot

Contact Name Michael Bailey PE itle Utilities DlrCity EbullReference date 05011201s

Contact Email MBalleycoopercityflorg Contact Phone (954) 434-5519

Name of Referenced Project City of Cooper City Continuing Professional Services bullContract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

RFQ 2009middot 1 04242009 to Present $ 2 19844200

Vendors role in Project IZJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Since 2009 Hazen has provided Cooper City with engineering services or water and wastewater projects Projects have lnctudeo lhe Pine Island Road Pump Station Lilt S1alions 2 amp 49 Improvements Master Plan Update of the FeaslJl~lty Review of Infrastructure Improvements tor Wastewater and the Eflluent Reuse and Disposal Master Plan

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy 8 D

D ~ D c Deliverables D 0 ~ D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D 0 D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tumover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D GJ- D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D 0 D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) ~D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

bull-rHIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY-

Verified vie EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ct4~ Division ~tUb Date ~ i3~) 0fgt All Information provided to BltCgtWW County 11 wbed ID vamprificalion Velldot adltnowledgu that lnaoewate unlrUhful lncom1ct statemampnla made in wppolt of 11111 response may blt uHd by the

4t2j=~ rejection rHclsslcn of th8 award or lennhallon of Ille eoo1nlct and may also seNamp at tilt basis for dtbarmenl at Vendor puuan1 lo Sectioo 21119 of the Broward COltJi 43

5232018 Bid Sync p24

Broward County Board of PNC211 5559P1

~RiiirilyenlcHUffi~~8CrW~r Bid PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

8DdMARD _ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FL O RIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Fort Lauderdale

Contact Name Rares Patrica PE Title Senior Project Mgr Reference date os1021201s

Contact Email RPetricafortlauderdalegov Contact Phone 9548287150

Name of Referenced Project Stormwater Master Planning and Design Implementation Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

256-11660 04192016 to 04192021 $ 989400000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

vyould you use this vendor again Sves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor The Hazen team Is responsible for delivery of a new stormwaler master plan model a prlorlllzed slormwaterresllency capital Improvements plan and Implementation of designs to address chronic flooding and other slormwater management challenges In the City Primary work tasks Include data collectlon hydrologlclhydraullc modeling and design permitting and construction services for capllal Improvement projects resulting from the revised stormwater master plan (preltmlnary design In seven priority neighborhoods)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION ~R COUNTY USE ONLY

aJ~Verified via pound MA IL _VERBAL Verified by Division W1~tl Date 5 ~3o~ax l S N I informallon p roviltled lo Broward County is sulljecl lo verification Vendor altknowledjj6s lhal inaccurate unlMhlut or lncotreci statements m ade In support of this respon$e may be used by tho

412~-~ rejeclion rescission of the award or termination ol lhe contracl and may also serve as lhe basis for debalment ol Vendor purwant to Section 21119 ol lhe Broward Cou~ 4 3

5232018 Bid Sync p25

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 Br~~~~~rs Bid PNC2115559P1 County t ommissioners

B~uWARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FlOR I CA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

Solicitation PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and s OrganizationFirm Name p

Town of Jupiter

nee

Contact Email davidbjupiterflus Contact Phone (561) 746-5134

Name of Referenced Project Engineering Services for Stormwater and Water Capital Improvements

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount $ 630000000 W17248 (2017 reselection 1012000 to Present (estimated lee-to-date since contract inception) contract number)

Vendors role in Project IZI Prime Vendor osubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again 0Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Descriotion of services orovided bv Vendor Since 2000 Hazen has served as General Consulfant to the Town or Jupiter As General Stormwater and Water Consullant the firm has provided services related to master planning stormwater planning and modeling design NPDES permilling asset management resiliency ratefinancial analysis plan review and construction oversight Water-related capital projs have involved additional system storage and high-service pumping transmission system improvements and RampR at existing facilities

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Verllied via EMAIL _ VERBAL Division WWC D

fo (J-Vv ~ltIvmiddotj Date 5(30(ipf S

Al lnroimallon pngtYICGd 10 Broward Counly Is sub)oel to v8flrcallon vendlaquo acknowledges lhat Inaccurate unlruthlu~ 0t Jnwrrect slatoments made In support ol this response may be used by the 42~~1~0 rojecllon rescission or Ille award or termination or lhe con~acl bullnd mbully also serve as tho basis r0t debarment of Vendor pursuant lo Socllon 21119 of lho Broward Couw 41

5232018 BidSync p 26

a N ~ IL) IL) N u z a_

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLO RI DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Walter Wernecke RA Title Sr Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email WWERNECKEhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Hollywood Marina Restrooms

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

04152015 to Present 7500000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor OSubconsultanVSubcontractor n ~U t1

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

-0 Vgt Description of services provided by VendorO ~ ~ Q) Structural Design and Construction Inspection Services i co Q m ~- c E c0

i E gt Oo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not () uu Appllcable O

E~ referenced Vendor Improvement iii ~sectoO 1 Vendors Quality of Service B mu a Responsive D D

b Accuracy DD c Deliverables D DD

2 Vendors Organization D Da Staff expertise v D b Professionalism~ D D c Turnover D ~D

3 Timeliness of D a Project b Deliverables D ~

4 Pec~~11~$~hinJ~~qt lfr D D 5 Cooperation with f ~

a Your Firm D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D

Al lnfonn1tion pRgttded IO Brwd Cltgtunly lo 1ubjecl IO ibllon vsor ~middot Iha icl-bullmiddot ~ ir-ect slalemenls mode In _ol lhb _ moy ti used by he County as a basis lot rejecUon rnclnlon cl the eward or tonnlnallan of lhl connct 1nd may bullllo 11 the basis for dobalment of Vendor IQtulnl IO SICllOn 21119 at lhe Broword County Procurement Code

Cl ltraquo I() I() I() N ()

Cl z

BRltJWARD ~ middot COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORl OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Davie

Contact Name Emilio DeSimone Title Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email Emilio_DeSimonedavie-fl gov Contact Phone 954-797-1085

Name of Referenced Project Pavillion 5 Linear Park

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

B-17-123 09152015 to 2700000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor O SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es O No If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

0 Description of services provided by Vendor O Q)

iii c Structural Design and Construction Inspection ServicesoQ

CDi-

0cc E gt=gt E ()Oo O () () Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

ii) -e i- Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 111 cs

B ioO

J 1 Vendors Quality of Service Q ()

a Responsive D D b Accuracy D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization []Ll Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D Dtr

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [g D b Deliverables D D ar D

4 Project completed within budget [1tD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) cgD D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via l EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by ~h~ Division WlI Etgt Date 0 f l~o I 8 All lnformaUon provided lO Broward County Is eubJect 10 verifutlon Vendor ecknOMedgoo that lnaocurote unNlhlul or Incorrect statamenle made In aupl)Ort of this reaponse may be used by lho County et o baampla for rejection realtluion of the award or lermlnallon of tho eon1fllcl ond moy olao aorvo os ho basis for debarmont of Vondor purauenl lo Section 21119 of the Broward Counly Procuremen1 Code

0 0 agt a c () z 0

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Terrence Comiskey AIA Title Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email TCOMISKEYhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Van Buren Parking Garage

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PK 14-053 Nov 2014 to Present 8310000

Vendors role in Project t8(Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

o~ Description of services provided by Vendor 1 Q)ltO c Structural Design and Conslructlon Inspection Services 0 Q

0~Jl ccE l E enOo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

gtshy

uu O Improvement Applicable ffireferenced Vendor

~sect 1 Vendors Quality of Service 1 ~

oOau a Responsive D ~ D b Accuracy B D D

D D [- Dc Deliverables

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tum over D D D g

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ D Subcontractor(s )S ubcons u ltant( s)b D D ~ D

c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D yenj D Additional Comments provide on sdditlonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION ~NTY USE ONLY0

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by kW Division W-1-(i~ Date EJo(a~t8 Al lnform1Uon PltOVlded lo Browald Ccxnty It IUbjoct to vorificallon Vendor eoknowfodgea thal lnaewralt U111MhlJI deg inlaquogtlaquobullel amptal11ants made In eupporl of lhls relj)Onse may be used by Iha Counly es a balls l0t rcfecllon rescfuloltI of tho ew1rd or 1ermtnaU0lt1 ol lhbull conllllCI and may elao urve 11 lho basis for dabarmenl of Vondor pursuanl lo Secllon 21 119 of he erowald COUlly CiProcurement Code

~ N ii

00

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 aOWllrp Commficumlref Bid PNC2116615B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Pompano Beach FL

Contact Name Mr A Randolph Brown Title Utilities Director Reference date April 30 2018

Contact Email randolphbrowncopbflcom Contact Phone 954-545-7043

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 201 o Project Amount fees varied

Multiple

Vendors role in Project IKJ Prime Vendor

to 2018

osubconsultanUSubcontractor

(range $10000shy$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D ~ D D c Deliverables D ~ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D ~ D D b Professionalism D D ~ D C Turnover D El DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ 0 b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D [BJ D n c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [XJ o ~

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed) amp~~it -THIS SECTION ~COUNTY USE ONL y-bullbull

Verified via ~AIL __VERBAL Verified by 1lt4 )~ Division N WE O Date 5 faol Z1 18

All lnformotlon providod to BltownrltI Cou nty it aubjoct O verification VendOr acknowledges that lnaccornto untruthful or incorroct 11atomon1s made in support of this response may be used by tho

411p~~)~~J rojoclion roscissioo ol lho award or 1orroinalion of tho contract and roay also s01vo as lhbull basis f0lt d~arroont of VondOf pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward Cou)l1

Bid Sync p 73

40

5232018

Broward County Board of Bid PNC2116659B 1 County Commissioners

B~aWARD gt1- t COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Loxahatchee River Environmental Control District

Contact Name Mr Kris Dean Title Director of Engineering Reference date May 9 2018

Contact Email krisdeanloxahatcheeriverorg Contact Phone 561-747-5700

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 2001 Project Amount fees varied (range $10000shyMultiple to 2018 $250000)

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IR)Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D ~ D D b Accuracy D 0 D D c Deliverables D IBJ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D IB] D D b Professionalism D ~ D D c Turnover D [8J D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D [8J D D b Deliverables D m D D

4 Project completed within budget D ~ D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D ~ D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D Ii] D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D ~ D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SE~ FOR~USE ONLY

Verified via _lEMAIL __VERBAL Verified by ~lt Division fWeb Date I

All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untrulhful or incorrecl slatements made In support of this response may be used by the lJl~~~l~~jSfiir rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and mll~~~ere as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Co)f 10

Broward County Board of Bid PNC21166$9B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A l

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Lake Worth FL

Contact Name Mr Felipe Lofaso TitleAsst Dir Public-ServicesReference date May 9 2018

Contact Email flofasolakeworthorg Contact Phone 561-586-1720

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contract

Contract No Date Services Provided 2014 Project Amount fees varied Multiple to 2018 (range $10000shy

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Services included multiple municipal engineering projects including survey roadway design utility design and coordination (water wastewater stormwater other) along with project management

Needs Satisfactory Excellent NotPlease rate your experience with the Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D GJ D b Accuracy D D Ii] D c Deliverables D Ii] DD

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [i] D c Turnover D D D [X]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D 0 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [X] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION Fe COUNTY USE ONLrbullbull

Verified via MAIL __VERBAL Verified by Division ~wgtgt Date 5~3ol20t8 All information provided to Broward County Is subject lo verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect slalements made in support ol this response may be used by the

OZ~id~~~~j~r rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and m~~~(iirve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Cour~ iG

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - ARCADIS US INC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts

VS0000013130 VS00013130 - ARCADIS US INC Prime Work Auth Vendor SummaryProjects

PURCHASING 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold Procurement No Fixed Contracts FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Favorites Past 5 Years Prime Vendor

Sub Vendor From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 10042017 Purchase Order

Evaluation Purchase Orders 1 POs With A Total Amt Of $20000000 Log Off Paid To Dt ($12132949) Balance $7867051

Contracts Purchase Orders Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx 6192018

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Finish

PURCHASING Weighted Scores Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract FileRoom DashBoard Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number FileRoom Insert

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel Favorites Prime Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Service Evaluation

6132017 YES 486 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Goals Compliance Evaluation

10272016 YES 460 View Docs (0)

6272018

Project Management Information System

Close

Contracts Central Administration

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9130 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-24

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6182018 YES 355 View Docs (1)

Proj Nbr 9320 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-20

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6132018 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9290 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-23

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1122018 YES 494 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-21

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12182017 YES 488 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10162017 YES 473 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

8252017 YES 495 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9321 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-19

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

7112017 YES 476 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-17

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2272017 YES 400 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

10132016 YES 384 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-12

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

5202016 YES 405 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9018 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-06

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10192015 YES 448 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

3202015 YES 385 View Docs (0)

Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL CONSULTANTS

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Project Management Information System

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-04

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12122014 YES 437 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-08

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1242014 YES 423 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-02

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2282014 YES 452 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC

VC0000044184 VC00044184 - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres PS $001 Used $000 Remain $001 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $354848400 Closed 0 Total $000 Total Current Retainage Balance For All Contracts $793370 No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 06292015 Purchase Orders 2 POs With A Total Amt Of $362317900 Paid To Dt ($218795160) Balance $143522740

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 40803 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9058 - DISTRICT 3A POTABLE WATER STORAGE

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1220410P1 - Consultant Engineering Services for Potable Water FixedOpen Contracts Storage Tanks and Pumping Systems Work Auth Prime Vendor CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Periodic Final Finish

Log Off Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type

Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

6232015 8302017 413 Approved 8312017 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard

Enter Vendor Name (or a portion of) Then Click Search - Wilcards Are Permitted (ie wa wawainc) Florida Technical Consultants

Search Reset Finish

No Vendors Found For Your Search Try Again

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41005 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score Go

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0773

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

12122017 YES 430 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

8302016 YES 438 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Final Consultant Evaluation 3142016 YES 478 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0706

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

142016 YES 402 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9016OES - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0731

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

10192015 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0748

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

612015 YES 467 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

2192015 YES 500 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0754

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

252015 YES 409 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0755

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

1242014 YES 415 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8974 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0758

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

6202014 YES 393 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr

WATER amp WASTEWATER

Final Consultant Work Authorization 572014 YES 423 View Docs

(0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

HS0746 ENGINEERING Evaluation

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

4302014 YES 475 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Evaluation 4302014 YES 493 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0710

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

3172014 YES 395 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0753

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

1212014 YES 380 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0763

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

11192013 YES 450 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0775

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 408 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals

Finish

Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed FileRoom DashBoard Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization FileRoom Insert NumberFavorites

Prime Vendor Export To Excel Sub Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0772

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 417 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0771

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

2262013 YES 410 View Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 7: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 7 of 12

Name of Firm Responsibility Information Remarks

Arcadis US Inc Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

Carollo Engineers Inc Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

Hazen and Sawyer PC Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

Provided Compliant ndash Has Insurance

Additional Information

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company took exception to Article 831 The firm requested removal of the 831 mold fungus asbestos sexual molestation requirement indicating that this was not insurable

7 Licensing Requirements The solicitation stated that Proposers must provide evidence that they hold a current Professional Engineer license with the State of Florida

Name of Firm Responsibility Information Remarks

Arcadis US Inc Provided Compliant

Brown and Caldwell Provided Compliant (Corporation)

Carollo Engineers Inc Provided Compliant

Florida Technical Provided Compliant Consultants LLC

Hazen and Sawyer PC Provided Compliant

LakdasYohalem Provided Compliant Engineering Inc

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 8 of 12

Baxter amp Woodman Inc Provided Compliant dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

C COUNTY STANDARD TERMS AND CONDITIONS INFORMATION The acceptance of or any exceptions taken to the terms and conditions of the Countyrsquos Agreement shall be considered a part of a Vendorrsquos submittal and will be considered by the Evaluation Committee The applicable Agreement terms and conditions for this solicitation were indicated in the Special Instructions to Vendors Vendors were required to review the applicable terms and conditions and submit the Agreement Exception Form If the Agreement Exception Form is not provided with the submittal it shall be deemed an affirmation by the Vendor that it accepts the Agreement terms and conditions as disclosed in the solicitation If exceptions are taken the Vendor must specifically identify each term and condition with which it is taking an exception

Name of Firm Agree Exceptions

Arcadis US Inc No Article 4 ndash Liquidated Damages

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

Yes None

Carollo Engineers Inc Yes None

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

Yes None

Hazen and Sawyer PC Yes None

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

Yes None

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

No Article asbestosrequirement

831 ndash Mold fungus sexual molestation

D REFERENCES The solicitationrsquos Evaluation Criteria ndash Project Specific Criteria Page 18 Question 3 request that completed references be provided for previous experience and projects Attached are the references as verified by County staff

E PERFORMANCE EVALUATIONS The Broward County Purchasing Division Contracts Central indicates evaluation scores for the proposing firms previously awarded contracts Completed performance evaluations may be provided upon request

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 9 of 12

Attached are Contracts Central performance evaluation history for each vendor as applicable including evaluation type (renewal goals compliance or final) and recommendation for future contracts (yes no or conditional) If a firm has periodic evaluations it will be listed separately

Additional Information In response to the Purchasing Directorrsquos Draft Memorandum to which the vendor can respond within 48 hours to any comments or deficiencies noted in the Purchasing DirectorrsquosDraft Memorandum Brown and Caldwell (Corporation) had a score that was highlighted in bright orange The bright orange highlight indicates that the firm receive an individual scoreof 1 or 2 on an item for that evaluation

F CONE OF SILENCE VIOLATIONS The Cone of Silence for this procurement has been in effect since May 3 2018 which prohibits potential vendors from discussing this solicitation with the Evaluation Committee the County Administrator Deputy County Administrator Assistant County Administrator Assistants to the County Administrator their respective support staff and any other person authorized to evaluate or recommend selection in this procurement process

Upon the first meeting of the Evaluation Committee the Cone of Silence expands to also include County Commissioners and their staff Potential vendors and their representatives are substantially restricted from communicating with County Commissioners and their staff regarding this procurement as stated in the Cone of Silence Ordinance

After application of the Cone of Silence inquiries regarding this solicitation should be directed to the Director of Purchasing or designee The Cone of Silence terminates when the County Commission or other awarding authority takes action which ends the solicitation Vendors are required to certify that they have read understand and will comply with the Cone of Silence Ordinance Section 1-266 Broward County Code of Ordinances

The following is a report of the proposersrsquo Cone of Silence violations

Name of Firm Remarks Violations

Arcadis US Inc Will Comply 1

Brown and Caldwell Will Comply None (Corporation)

Carollo Engineers Inc Will Comply None

Florida Technical Will Comply None Consultants LLC

Hazen and Sawyer PC Will Comply None

LakdasYohalem Engineering Will Comply None Inc

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 10 of 12

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Will Comply None Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

Additional Information

Arcadis US Inc had one violation 2011 - Robert Daoust Principal Scientist Malcolm PirnieArcadis US Inc

Additional Information In response to the Purchasing Directorrsquos Draft Memorandum to which the vendor can respond within 48 hours to any comments or deficiencies noted in the Purchasing DirectorrsquosDraft Memorandum Arcadis US Inc provided information that the cone of silence violationwas from a former employee

G VOLUME OF PREVIOUS WORK - EVALUATION CRITERIA ANDOR TIE BREAK CRITERIA The solicitation states that a number of points will be allocated for volume of previous work of the firm for the past five (5) years The volume of work for each of the proposing firms is as follows

Name of Firm Proposer Reported County Reported Points Allocated

Arcadis US Inc $24988700 $9597102 5 Points

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

$477974497 $477974497 3 Points

Carollo Engineers Inc $214076903 $214076903 5 Points

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

$000 $000 5 Points

Hazen and Sawyer PC

$2164284300 $2221320722 0 Points

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

$5894000 $5894030 5 Points

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

$000 $000 5 Points

Additional Information

5 points allocated to vendors paid $0 to $3000000 3 points allocated to vendors paid $3000001 to $7500000 1 point allocated to vendors paid $7500001 to $10000000 0 points allocated to vendors paid over $10000000

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 11 of 12

H PRINCIPAL BUSINESS LOCATION The solicitation states that a number of points will be allocated for location of the firm The Vendorrsquos principal address in Broward County shall be the Vendorrsquos ldquoPrincipal Addressrdquo as indicated with the Florida Department of State Division of Corporations for at least six (6) months prior to the solicitationrsquos due date A proposer with a principal business location within Broward County will receive five (5) points A proposer not having its principal business location within Broward County will receive zero (0) points

The results are as Proposed Attested Location Verified Points Allocated followsName of Nerve Center in SunBiz Firm

Arcadis US Inc 630 Plaza Drive Suite 10 YES 0 Highlands Ranch CO

Brown and Caldwell 201 North Civic Drive YES 0 (Corporation) Suite 300

Walnut Creek CA

Carollo Engineers 2700 Ygnacio Valley YES 0 Inc Road Suite 300

Walnut Creek CA

Florida Technical 533 East Ocean Avenue YES 0 Consultants LLC Suite 2

Boynton Beach FL

Hazen and Sawyer 4000 Hollywood YES 5 PC Boulevard Suite 750

North Hollywood FL

LakdasYohalem 2211 NE 54th Street YES 5 Engineering Inc Fort Lauderdale FL

Baxter amp Woodman 477 S Rosemary Avenue YES 0 Inc dba Mathews Suite 330 Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company West Palm Beach FL

Additional Information In response to the Purchasing Directorrsquos Draft Memorandum to which the vendor canrespond within 48 hours to any comments or deficiencies noted in the Purchasing Directorrsquos Draft Memorandum Hazen and Sawyer PC principal address as verified in Sunbiz is 4000Hollywood Blvd Suite 750N Hollywood FL 33021

I LOCAL PREFERENCE A vendor is eligible to be considered a local business for Local Preference purposes if it has a physical business address located within the limits of Broward County The vendor must provide a valid business tax receipt issued by Broward County at least one (1) year prior to bid or proposal opening

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 12 of 12

Broward Countyrsquos Local Preference Ordinance specifically excludes the application of a local preference for professional services procured pursuant to Section 287055 FS (CCNA)

J LOCATION - TIE BREAKER A Vendor located within Broward County is eligible for the Location Tie Breaker The County requires a copy of the Broward County Business Tax receipt for a period of time of at least six (6) months prior to the solicitation deadline and it must be provided with its initial submittal

The results are as follows

Name of Firm Eligibility Broward County Tax Receipt

Arcadis US Inc Eligible Provided

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

Eligible Provided

Carollo Engineers Inc Eligible Provided

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

Eligible Provided

Hazen and Sawyer PC Eligible Provided

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

Eligible Provided

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

Eligible Provided

Attachments 1 Vendor Reference Verifications 2 Vendor Performance Evaluations 3 Vendor Responses to Draft Memo

c Bob Melton County Auditor Office of the County Auditor Robert Wilson Title Division Department (Project Manager) Martha Perez-Garviso Purchasing Manager Purchasing Division Finance and Administrative Services Department Glenn Miller Assistant County Attorney Office of the County Attorney Fernando Amuchastegui Assistant County Attorney Office of the County Attorney

BJBGMnomm

Broward County Board of PNC211 5559P1 County Commissioners

BRCWARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LO ~ I DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P 1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis us Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

South Florida Water Management District

Contact Name Rich V irgil PE Title Bureau Chief lnfrabReference date 05142018

Contact Email rvirgilsfwmdgov Contact Phone 561 6826759

Name of Referenced Project S-193 Lock Refurbishment C-41A Canal Bank Stabilization Lake

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

4600000790 1001 2008 UP 12012016 $ 295400000

Vendors role in Project ]rime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Engineering Design and Engineering Services During Construction

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D [] DD c Deliverables []D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [L] D c Turnover D D D0

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget []D D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm [L]D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D 0 D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [] D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via ~AI L VERBAL Verified by ~~ Division WWfD Date ltQamp~(8 All lnformallon provided to Bltoward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate unlrulhful or incorrect statements made In support of this response may be used by the

512gt~11MlflS a lgtasis Of rejection rescission of the award or tenninallon of the contract and ~~lVcrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 of lhe Broward Count~ 41l6tlrelfient Code Y fTmiddot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BR~ltJWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LO R I DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering SeNices for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Saint Petersburg Department of Engineering and Capital Planning

Contact Name Nicole Allen Title CADDGIS Supervi Reference date

Contact Email nicoleallenstpeteorg Contact Phone 727-893-7316

Name of Referenced Project Water Resources Department GIS Data Migration

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

13-03-ARCIT 12092014 UP 09152015 $ 5925000

Vendors role in Project ]rime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again (Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Migration ofwater wastewater and storm water infrastructure information from CAD environment to Esri Local Government Information Model

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D [] D c Deliverables D [] D D

2 Vendors Organization [ZJa Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D [ZJ D c Turnover D D [] D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [ZJ D b Deliverables D D [ZJ D

4 Project completed within budget [ZJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [ZJ D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) [ZJD D D c Regu latory Agency(ies) D D [ZJ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONL rbullbull

Verified via L L VERBAL Verified by Division NlltE~ Date 6(~oatgt 1 8~ All information PfOvided to Bfoward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful oc inCOfrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

512gt9lillll jS a basis 10lt rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and nlll~9rrcrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of lhe Broward Cou~ 42fldtclrhtflent Code middot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BRuWARD1 1 COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering SeNices for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

C ity of Tavares F lorida

Contact Name James Dillon Title Public Works DireltaReference date 05172018

Contact Email jdillontavaresorg Contact Phone 352-455-7718

Name of Referenced Project G IS Modeling and Integration of Utilities Infrastructure

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

060330480000 04012017 UP 10012017 $ 5676000

Vendors role in Project ]rime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Integrate drawings and images depicting pipe infrastructure into a GIS environment for easy retrieval First project of a multi phase program to upgrade the Citys GIS information

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D 0 D c Deliverables D D 0 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D Ill D b Professionalism D D Ill D c Turnover D D 0 D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D Ill D b Deliverables D D Ill D

4 Project completed within budget D D Ill D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D Ill D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D Ill D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY -

Ve rified via L IL VERBAL Verified by fcAJ~ Division llt E1) Date 1 r~ tjlQ t8 All information pwvlded to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incooect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

512G91JlIHIS a basis for rejection rescission or the award or termination or the contract and lnfli~9ncrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 of the Broward CouI)~ 44flamplrelflent Code

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BRd~WARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LO R I DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Miramar

Contact Name Robin E Bain PE Title Project Manager Reference date 05142018

Contact Email rebainmiramarflgov Contact Phone 9548836825

Name of Referenced Project East Water Treatment Plant Replacement Wells and Design-Build

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PO 172624-00 10222017 UP 05142018 $ 56929600

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [ZJYes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Design permitting construction services for new Deep Injection Well and 4 new (replacement) production wells

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy []D D D c Deliverables D []D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D [ZJ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Turnover D D D []

3 Timeliness of a Project D D lZ1 D b Del iverables D D lZ1 D

4 Project completed within budget D D lZ1 D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor( s)Subconsultant( s) D D lZ1 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D lZ1 D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY (

Verified via A IL VER BAL Verified by faltJ~ Division WltEtgt Date 5 ~io l 9 All inlOllllalion pltovided to Broward County is subjecl lo verificalioo VendOt acknowledges lhal lnaccurale unlrulhful or i ncooecl stalemenls made in suppOltI of lhis response may be used by lhe

512gt~llM (lS a basis lot rejeclion rescission of the award or termination of lhe contract and mll~Arrcrve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuanl 10 Section 21119 of lhe Broward Couoty 43Pldtllrbrllent Code Y flmiddot

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Palm Beach County Water Utilities Department

Contact Name Ali Bayat Title Assistant Director Reference date

Contact Email abayatpbcwatercom Contact Phone 561 493 6128

Name of Referenced Project System 8 Water Quality Assessment

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

17-021 CSA21 01 022017 to 01152018 $ 8936000

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again (Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Brown and Caldwell led assessment of contributing causes to low system residuals troubleshooting treatment processes special testing and data analysis improvements to operating protocols monitoringcontrol system and treatment process

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [Z] D b Accuracy D [Z] DD c Deliverables D [Z]D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D [Z] D b Professionalism D D [Z] D c Turnover D [Z] DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D [Z] D

4 Project completed within budget D D [Z] D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Consultant worked collaboratively with operating maintenance engineering and laboratory staff to develop insight into contributing factors and implement improvements

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via _LEMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by tcltJ1~ Division -+LN euro P Date lteh IWt 8 All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the County as a basis for rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and may also serve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward County Procurement Code

BltaWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F L 0 R I D A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood Florida

Contact Name Steve Joseph Title Director Reference date

Contact Email sjosephhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954 921 3522

Name of Referenced Project Distribution System Water Quality Improvement

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

01012016 to 06022017 $ 3000000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again []Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Supported the City with its efforts improve chlorine residuals in areas of its system Analysis included system modeling monitoring optimized operational practices Implemented operational improvements that significantly raised (from approx 05 to 20 mgL) chloramine residuals In the most challenging area of the system

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D D [] D c Deliverables []D D D

2 Vendors Organization [] Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D [] D c Turnover D D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D [] D

4 Project completed within budget []D D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) []D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [] D

Additional Com ments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Effort Included system modoling moniloring and excursion response procedures opllmitallon of stored Inventory management unidirectional flushing pilot assessment and treatment proooss evaluation

Verified via __EMAIL vERBAL Division WW ED Date G Ifgt I 8 All infonmallon pltovided to Broward County Is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of thi s response may be used by lhe County as a basis for rejeclion rescission or the award or tenminatlon of the contract and may also serve as the basis for debanment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 or lhe Broward County Procurement Code

BROWARD t (l)t~ 1 Vendor Reference Verification Form

fl O R I OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of West Palm Beach Florida

Contact Name Jay Kwag Title Project Manager Reference date

Contact Email hjkwagwpborg Contact Phone 561 494 1041

Name of Referenced Project Modeling and Infrastructure General Engineering Consulting Assigments

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

11032014 to HAlt zc1e (on~vi~)

Vendors role in Project 52fPrime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IQves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Planning and General Eng1neerg Servicus 1nctuslve ol Waterwastewater System Master Pian asset management program dovo10pmenV11sset Crt1tcat1ty assessment Mesler PS 115 and sewer cond1hon assessment hydrauhc modeling ol LS 5 and force main sizing water system Capacity Analysis RoPort nydraullc modeling ol operahonat challongos tilt ste11on enatysbulls lac11i1a1e 1nspec11011 or major FM and new develOpmenl 1mpnc1s plpohno design lilt station condbullhon assessment and renabtlilahon (Various ProJecls)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D 0 D b Accuracy D 0D D c Deliverables D D 0 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D Gt D b Professionalism D D ~-- D c Turnover D D Gr D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D B D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget D D r~r D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D c~r D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D 0 D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION F~USE ONLY

__VERBAL Verified via LMAIL Verified by ~J Division ~~~D Date ~ f 2 f~t8 All lnfo11na1t0n pr ()Vl(fed 10 Broward County is svb1et110 ven11ca1ion vendor acknowledges lhll 1naeoura10 unlrulhful 0lt inc0ltrec1 s1a1emen1s medo In support ol 1n1s response may be used Dy the County as a basis fcu rejection re sclsst0n Of 1ho award or 1ormina1lon of l he contract and may also servo as the basis for debarment o f Vendor pursuant lo Section 21 119 of tho ampoward Counly P1ocuremont Code

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A middot

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Michael Low Title Deputy Director Reference date 05172018

Contact Email lowmbbflus Contact Phone 5617426403

Name of Referenced Project Ion Exchange Design Build

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

07022014 to 03212018 $ 100000000

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Carollo handled all of the design and construction of a significant part of the project as a subcontractor to COM Constructors as part of a progressive design build contract

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [Z] D b Accuracy D D [Z] D c Deliverables D D [Z] D

2 Vendors Organization D D [Z] Da Staff expertise b Professionalism D D [Z] D c Turnover D D D [Z]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D [Z] D

4 Project completed within budget D D [Z] D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D [Z] D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [Z] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION F~ COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ~~ Division W -NED Date S-gtozot~ All Information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor aclltnowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

Stii191111X 11s a basis for rejection rescission of the award or termination or the conlact and m~~Arifrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward CounYJ 33Plamptl1til1ent Code Y Imiddot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

B~OWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LORID A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

South Florida Water Management District

Contact Name Greg Coffelt PE Title SFWMD Project Manager Reference date 05172018

Contact Email gcoffeltsfwmdgov Contact Phone 561-682-6853

Name of Referenced Project L-8 Reservoir Inflow Structure and Pump Station

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

4600000861 02152011 to 09192012 $ 144535100

Vendors role in Project [l) Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [l)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Corolla was contracted as an Owners Advisor for a Design-Build contract developed engineering design criteria assisted in RFQ development and evaluation supported RFP technical proposal and cost proposal analysis

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [l] D b Accuracy D [] D D c Deliverables D [] D D

2 Vendors Organization [l]a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D [l] D c Turnover D D D [l]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [l] D b Deliverables D [l] D D

4 Project completed within budget [l] DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [l] D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) [l] DD D c Regu latory Agency(ies) D D D [l]

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Owner Advisor work continued(s) in support of Construction of Pump Station Inflow Gate Structure and levee hardening

Verified via IMAIL __VERBAL Date 5 ( 3 c b() I a All information piovided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that Inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made In support of this response may be used by the

512G9JiIX 11s a basis for rejection rescission or the award or termination or the contract and rllffl~Anampe as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 or the Broward CojlftYi 34~6ttlrbtflent Code Y

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

B0~~AARD ~~t~UNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

Fl ORIOA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Sunrise

Contact Name Luisa Fernanda Arbelaa Title Project Manager Reference date 05162018

Contact Email LArbelaezsunrlseflgov Contact Phone 954-888-6009

Name of Referenced Project City of Sunrise - Springtree WTP Water Stabilization and Solids Handling

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PA 16-003-CE 04072016 to 05292018 $ 50797800

Vendors role in Project ]Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [l]Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Carollo Engineers performed the design study and construction administration services for the City

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D G6 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Carollo Engineers technical knowledge and attenllon lo detall were beneficial lo the pltojad They ecled in lhe C~ys besl Interest In every aspect for lhe d1K8Uon of the projectbull

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via ~MAIL _VERBAL Verified by fc4J~~ Division W fl ED All lnrormalion provided to Broward ltAunty Is oobjoci to vorirtcotion Vendoc ecknowledgu that 1naowrate unlMhfuf 0lt lncocrecl statements rnado In support or this response may be useltI by lhe County as a basis for rejection rescission or the award 0lt termination ol the convect and may also ampOIVe as the babullibull ror debarmont of vondOlt purauont to Section 21119 or the Broward County Proc11oment Code

Bid Sync p 135 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BftQNARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

I l 0 R I 0 A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Florida Technical Consultants

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

VIiiage of Wellington Utilities

Contact Name Bradley Wolak Title Assistant Director Ut11Reference date 5182018

Contact Email bwolakwelllngtonflgov Contact Phone 561-753-2480

Name of Referenced Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 10012017 to Present 3500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vend~ 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again UZfYes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor J_ rJ fJ j(Gr-~k 6 Jti ov1 ~uf-Jiy fgt-r_- syrrzi~ff~ Al

R Q_ d--1 0~l 4 171 i+CI ~~lHI )Please rate your experience with tile Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Applicablereferenced Vendor Improvement

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy B D

DD c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D Db Professionalism D D

c Turnover D DD 3 Timeliness of

a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant(s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Additional Comments (provide on addltjpnal sheetJf needed) bull ~middot$ -JJ fo~~rltjbull lt( c-c_ ~~~ lt fo L1-lfAR- -middot~ I 10 ~ ~

~ bullL ~~ _te_ l~Ilgt~Cef t J ~ l rfbull4 middot r0 laquo r 4111J w f1 rrr- 0r- -i-HIS SECTION(9R COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by fcAJc ~ Division Y-1 IN ED Date 5 ~o w8 All lnfonn1Uon ptollfded to BlOward County le eubjeet to vetfflcatlon Vendor aclltnowledge1 that lneccurale unllJlhfUl or lnconect -bullmenla made In 1UPPort o1 this reopon90 may be uoec1 by the couniy ae a baalS ror re)ectlon re8Claeton Of the award 0t leltmlnatlon Of the contract and may 1l10 MM ae the baale flaquo debarrnont 01 vendor pu11uant to Section 21119 of ll1e Broward County Procurement Codo

BidSync p 18 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F LUFltIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultants LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Palm Beach Public Works

Contact Name Gerry Vazquez Title WRD Technician Reference date 05182018

Contact Email gvazqueztownofpalmbeachcom Contact Phone 772-546-6859

Name of Referenced Project GIS Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 3242014 to Present 13500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [3yenes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

PrwAamprs- favl49z Please rate your experience with the Need a Satlafactory Excellent Not

Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D g- D b Accuracy D Er D c Deliverables g-shyB D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D GJ D b Professionalism D D G- D c Tu mover D D cg- D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D g D b Deliverables D D Qshy D

4 Project completed within budget D D lbJ- D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D El- Db Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [3- D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

BidSync p 17 51232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

120-nWARDLll~ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form fLORllgtA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultant LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Waneya Bryant Title Meter Serv Mgr Reference date 05182018

Contact Email BryantWbbflus Contact Phone 561-742-6427

Name of Referenced Project Boynton Beach Utility GIS Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 12012016 to Present $15000000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

~T~ 5e-r-vtleamp +roM l)h f-es Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D Dc Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ti4 D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ Db Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on addlUonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION~urv USE ONLy u bull

Verified via VEMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by kuJ~ Division W if E D rao(ao8Date 5

All Information provided to Browslaquo COOlty Is Slbject to verfflcation Vendor acKnowledges that lneocurate Untruthful or lncolleel 8tatements made In support d this rfl9pOn98 may be used by 1119 Counly as a batia falt rejection relduion ct Ille award or lemilnlilon of the contract and may al80181Veaa1119 basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 ot Ille Broward CountyProcurement Code

512312018 BidSync p 16

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1

8W1V~isl1War Bid PNC21 15559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Fonn

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Cooper City - middot

Contact Name Michael Bailey PE itle Utilities DlrCity EbullReference date 05011201s

Contact Email MBalleycoopercityflorg Contact Phone (954) 434-5519

Name of Referenced Project City of Cooper City Continuing Professional Services bullContract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

RFQ 2009middot 1 04242009 to Present $ 2 19844200

Vendors role in Project IZJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Since 2009 Hazen has provided Cooper City with engineering services or water and wastewater projects Projects have lnctudeo lhe Pine Island Road Pump Station Lilt S1alions 2 amp 49 Improvements Master Plan Update of the FeaslJl~lty Review of Infrastructure Improvements tor Wastewater and the Eflluent Reuse and Disposal Master Plan

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy 8 D

D ~ D c Deliverables D 0 ~ D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D 0 D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tumover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D GJ- D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D 0 D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) ~D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

bull-rHIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY-

Verified vie EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ct4~ Division ~tUb Date ~ i3~) 0fgt All Information provided to BltCgtWW County 11 wbed ID vamprificalion Velldot adltnowledgu that lnaoewate unlrUhful lncom1ct statemampnla made in wppolt of 11111 response may blt uHd by the

4t2j=~ rejection rHclsslcn of th8 award or lennhallon of Ille eoo1nlct and may also seNamp at tilt basis for dtbarmenl at Vendor puuan1 lo Sectioo 21119 of the Broward COltJi 43

5232018 Bid Sync p24

Broward County Board of PNC211 5559P1

~RiiirilyenlcHUffi~~8CrW~r Bid PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

8DdMARD _ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FL O RIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Fort Lauderdale

Contact Name Rares Patrica PE Title Senior Project Mgr Reference date os1021201s

Contact Email RPetricafortlauderdalegov Contact Phone 9548287150

Name of Referenced Project Stormwater Master Planning and Design Implementation Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

256-11660 04192016 to 04192021 $ 989400000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

vyould you use this vendor again Sves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor The Hazen team Is responsible for delivery of a new stormwaler master plan model a prlorlllzed slormwaterresllency capital Improvements plan and Implementation of designs to address chronic flooding and other slormwater management challenges In the City Primary work tasks Include data collectlon hydrologlclhydraullc modeling and design permitting and construction services for capllal Improvement projects resulting from the revised stormwater master plan (preltmlnary design In seven priority neighborhoods)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION ~R COUNTY USE ONLY

aJ~Verified via pound MA IL _VERBAL Verified by Division W1~tl Date 5 ~3o~ax l S N I informallon p roviltled lo Broward County is sulljecl lo verification Vendor altknowledjj6s lhal inaccurate unlMhlut or lncotreci statements m ade In support of this respon$e may be used by tho

412~-~ rejeclion rescission of the award or termination ol lhe contracl and may also serve as lhe basis for debalment ol Vendor purwant to Section 21119 ol lhe Broward Cou~ 4 3

5232018 Bid Sync p25

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 Br~~~~~rs Bid PNC2115559P1 County t ommissioners

B~uWARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FlOR I CA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

Solicitation PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and s OrganizationFirm Name p

Town of Jupiter

nee

Contact Email davidbjupiterflus Contact Phone (561) 746-5134

Name of Referenced Project Engineering Services for Stormwater and Water Capital Improvements

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount $ 630000000 W17248 (2017 reselection 1012000 to Present (estimated lee-to-date since contract inception) contract number)

Vendors role in Project IZI Prime Vendor osubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again 0Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Descriotion of services orovided bv Vendor Since 2000 Hazen has served as General Consulfant to the Town or Jupiter As General Stormwater and Water Consullant the firm has provided services related to master planning stormwater planning and modeling design NPDES permilling asset management resiliency ratefinancial analysis plan review and construction oversight Water-related capital projs have involved additional system storage and high-service pumping transmission system improvements and RampR at existing facilities

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Verllied via EMAIL _ VERBAL Division WWC D

fo (J-Vv ~ltIvmiddotj Date 5(30(ipf S

Al lnroimallon pngtYICGd 10 Broward Counly Is sub)oel to v8flrcallon vendlaquo acknowledges lhat Inaccurate unlruthlu~ 0t Jnwrrect slatoments made In support ol this response may be used by the 42~~1~0 rojecllon rescission or Ille award or termination or lhe con~acl bullnd mbully also serve as tho basis r0t debarment of Vendor pursuant lo Socllon 21119 of lho Broward Couw 41

5232018 BidSync p 26

a N ~ IL) IL) N u z a_

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLO RI DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Walter Wernecke RA Title Sr Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email WWERNECKEhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Hollywood Marina Restrooms

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

04152015 to Present 7500000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor OSubconsultanVSubcontractor n ~U t1

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

-0 Vgt Description of services provided by VendorO ~ ~ Q) Structural Design and Construction Inspection Services i co Q m ~- c E c0

i E gt Oo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not () uu Appllcable O

E~ referenced Vendor Improvement iii ~sectoO 1 Vendors Quality of Service B mu a Responsive D D

b Accuracy DD c Deliverables D DD

2 Vendors Organization D Da Staff expertise v D b Professionalism~ D D c Turnover D ~D

3 Timeliness of D a Project b Deliverables D ~

4 Pec~~11~$~hinJ~~qt lfr D D 5 Cooperation with f ~

a Your Firm D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D

Al lnfonn1tion pRgttded IO Brwd Cltgtunly lo 1ubjecl IO ibllon vsor ~middot Iha icl-bullmiddot ~ ir-ect slalemenls mode In _ol lhb _ moy ti used by he County as a basis lot rejecUon rnclnlon cl the eward or tonnlnallan of lhl connct 1nd may bullllo 11 the basis for dobalment of Vendor IQtulnl IO SICllOn 21119 at lhe Broword County Procurement Code

Cl ltraquo I() I() I() N ()

Cl z

BRltJWARD ~ middot COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORl OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Davie

Contact Name Emilio DeSimone Title Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email Emilio_DeSimonedavie-fl gov Contact Phone 954-797-1085

Name of Referenced Project Pavillion 5 Linear Park

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

B-17-123 09152015 to 2700000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor O SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es O No If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

0 Description of services provided by Vendor O Q)

iii c Structural Design and Construction Inspection ServicesoQ

CDi-

0cc E gt=gt E ()Oo O () () Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

ii) -e i- Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 111 cs

B ioO

J 1 Vendors Quality of Service Q ()

a Responsive D D b Accuracy D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization []Ll Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D Dtr

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [g D b Deliverables D D ar D

4 Project completed within budget [1tD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) cgD D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via l EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by ~h~ Division WlI Etgt Date 0 f l~o I 8 All lnformaUon provided lO Broward County Is eubJect 10 verifutlon Vendor ecknOMedgoo that lnaocurote unNlhlul or Incorrect statamenle made In aupl)Ort of this reaponse may be used by lho County et o baampla for rejection realtluion of the award or lermlnallon of tho eon1fllcl ond moy olao aorvo os ho basis for debarmont of Vondor purauenl lo Section 21119 of the Broward Counly Procuremen1 Code

0 0 agt a c () z 0

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Terrence Comiskey AIA Title Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email TCOMISKEYhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Van Buren Parking Garage

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PK 14-053 Nov 2014 to Present 8310000

Vendors role in Project t8(Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

o~ Description of services provided by Vendor 1 Q)ltO c Structural Design and Conslructlon Inspection Services 0 Q

0~Jl ccE l E enOo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

gtshy

uu O Improvement Applicable ffireferenced Vendor

~sect 1 Vendors Quality of Service 1 ~

oOau a Responsive D ~ D b Accuracy B D D

D D [- Dc Deliverables

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tum over D D D g

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ D Subcontractor(s )S ubcons u ltant( s)b D D ~ D

c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D yenj D Additional Comments provide on sdditlonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION ~NTY USE ONLY0

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by kW Division W-1-(i~ Date EJo(a~t8 Al lnform1Uon PltOVlded lo Browald Ccxnty It IUbjoct to vorificallon Vendor eoknowfodgea thal lnaewralt U111MhlJI deg inlaquogtlaquobullel amptal11ants made In eupporl of lhls relj)Onse may be used by Iha Counly es a balls l0t rcfecllon rescfuloltI of tho ew1rd or 1ermtnaU0lt1 ol lhbull conllllCI and may elao urve 11 lho basis for dabarmenl of Vondor pursuanl lo Secllon 21 119 of he erowald COUlly CiProcurement Code

~ N ii

00

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 aOWllrp Commficumlref Bid PNC2116615B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Pompano Beach FL

Contact Name Mr A Randolph Brown Title Utilities Director Reference date April 30 2018

Contact Email randolphbrowncopbflcom Contact Phone 954-545-7043

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 201 o Project Amount fees varied

Multiple

Vendors role in Project IKJ Prime Vendor

to 2018

osubconsultanUSubcontractor

(range $10000shy$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D ~ D D c Deliverables D ~ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D ~ D D b Professionalism D D ~ D C Turnover D El DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ 0 b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D [BJ D n c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [XJ o ~

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed) amp~~it -THIS SECTION ~COUNTY USE ONL y-bullbull

Verified via ~AIL __VERBAL Verified by 1lt4 )~ Division N WE O Date 5 faol Z1 18

All lnformotlon providod to BltownrltI Cou nty it aubjoct O verification VendOr acknowledges that lnaccornto untruthful or incorroct 11atomon1s made in support of this response may be used by tho

411p~~)~~J rojoclion roscissioo ol lho award or 1orroinalion of tho contract and roay also s01vo as lhbull basis f0lt d~arroont of VondOf pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward Cou)l1

Bid Sync p 73

40

5232018

Broward County Board of Bid PNC2116659B 1 County Commissioners

B~aWARD gt1- t COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Loxahatchee River Environmental Control District

Contact Name Mr Kris Dean Title Director of Engineering Reference date May 9 2018

Contact Email krisdeanloxahatcheeriverorg Contact Phone 561-747-5700

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 2001 Project Amount fees varied (range $10000shyMultiple to 2018 $250000)

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IR)Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D ~ D D b Accuracy D 0 D D c Deliverables D IBJ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D IB] D D b Professionalism D ~ D D c Turnover D [8J D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D [8J D D b Deliverables D m D D

4 Project completed within budget D ~ D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D ~ D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D Ii] D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D ~ D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SE~ FOR~USE ONLY

Verified via _lEMAIL __VERBAL Verified by ~lt Division fWeb Date I

All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untrulhful or incorrecl slatements made In support of this response may be used by the lJl~~~l~~jSfiir rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and mll~~~ere as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Co)f 10

Broward County Board of Bid PNC21166$9B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A l

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Lake Worth FL

Contact Name Mr Felipe Lofaso TitleAsst Dir Public-ServicesReference date May 9 2018

Contact Email flofasolakeworthorg Contact Phone 561-586-1720

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contract

Contract No Date Services Provided 2014 Project Amount fees varied Multiple to 2018 (range $10000shy

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Services included multiple municipal engineering projects including survey roadway design utility design and coordination (water wastewater stormwater other) along with project management

Needs Satisfactory Excellent NotPlease rate your experience with the Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D GJ D b Accuracy D D Ii] D c Deliverables D Ii] DD

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [i] D c Turnover D D D [X]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D 0 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [X] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION Fe COUNTY USE ONLrbullbull

Verified via MAIL __VERBAL Verified by Division ~wgtgt Date 5~3ol20t8 All information provided to Broward County Is subject lo verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect slalements made in support ol this response may be used by the

OZ~id~~~~j~r rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and m~~~(iirve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Cour~ iG

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - ARCADIS US INC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts

VS0000013130 VS00013130 - ARCADIS US INC Prime Work Auth Vendor SummaryProjects

PURCHASING 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold Procurement No Fixed Contracts FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Favorites Past 5 Years Prime Vendor

Sub Vendor From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 10042017 Purchase Order

Evaluation Purchase Orders 1 POs With A Total Amt Of $20000000 Log Off Paid To Dt ($12132949) Balance $7867051

Contracts Purchase Orders Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx 6192018

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Finish

PURCHASING Weighted Scores Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract FileRoom DashBoard Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number FileRoom Insert

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel Favorites Prime Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Service Evaluation

6132017 YES 486 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Goals Compliance Evaluation

10272016 YES 460 View Docs (0)

6272018

Project Management Information System

Close

Contracts Central Administration

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9130 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-24

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6182018 YES 355 View Docs (1)

Proj Nbr 9320 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-20

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6132018 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9290 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-23

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1122018 YES 494 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-21

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12182017 YES 488 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10162017 YES 473 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

8252017 YES 495 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9321 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-19

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

7112017 YES 476 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-17

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2272017 YES 400 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

10132016 YES 384 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-12

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

5202016 YES 405 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9018 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-06

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10192015 YES 448 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

3202015 YES 385 View Docs (0)

Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL CONSULTANTS

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Project Management Information System

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-04

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12122014 YES 437 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-08

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1242014 YES 423 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-02

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2282014 YES 452 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC

VC0000044184 VC00044184 - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres PS $001 Used $000 Remain $001 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $354848400 Closed 0 Total $000 Total Current Retainage Balance For All Contracts $793370 No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 06292015 Purchase Orders 2 POs With A Total Amt Of $362317900 Paid To Dt ($218795160) Balance $143522740

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 40803 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9058 - DISTRICT 3A POTABLE WATER STORAGE

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1220410P1 - Consultant Engineering Services for Potable Water FixedOpen Contracts Storage Tanks and Pumping Systems Work Auth Prime Vendor CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Periodic Final Finish

Log Off Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type

Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

6232015 8302017 413 Approved 8312017 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard

Enter Vendor Name (or a portion of) Then Click Search - Wilcards Are Permitted (ie wa wawainc) Florida Technical Consultants

Search Reset Finish

No Vendors Found For Your Search Try Again

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41005 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score Go

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0773

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

12122017 YES 430 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

8302016 YES 438 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Final Consultant Evaluation 3142016 YES 478 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0706

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

142016 YES 402 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9016OES - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0731

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

10192015 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0748

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

612015 YES 467 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

2192015 YES 500 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0754

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

252015 YES 409 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0755

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

1242014 YES 415 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8974 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0758

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

6202014 YES 393 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr

WATER amp WASTEWATER

Final Consultant Work Authorization 572014 YES 423 View Docs

(0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

HS0746 ENGINEERING Evaluation

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

4302014 YES 475 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Evaluation 4302014 YES 493 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0710

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

3172014 YES 395 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0753

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

1212014 YES 380 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0763

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

11192013 YES 450 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0775

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 408 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals

Finish

Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed FileRoom DashBoard Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization FileRoom Insert NumberFavorites

Prime Vendor Export To Excel Sub Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0772

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 417 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0771

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

2262013 YES 410 View Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 8: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 8 of 12

Baxter amp Woodman Inc Provided Compliant dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

C COUNTY STANDARD TERMS AND CONDITIONS INFORMATION The acceptance of or any exceptions taken to the terms and conditions of the Countyrsquos Agreement shall be considered a part of a Vendorrsquos submittal and will be considered by the Evaluation Committee The applicable Agreement terms and conditions for this solicitation were indicated in the Special Instructions to Vendors Vendors were required to review the applicable terms and conditions and submit the Agreement Exception Form If the Agreement Exception Form is not provided with the submittal it shall be deemed an affirmation by the Vendor that it accepts the Agreement terms and conditions as disclosed in the solicitation If exceptions are taken the Vendor must specifically identify each term and condition with which it is taking an exception

Name of Firm Agree Exceptions

Arcadis US Inc No Article 4 ndash Liquidated Damages

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

Yes None

Carollo Engineers Inc Yes None

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

Yes None

Hazen and Sawyer PC Yes None

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

Yes None

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

No Article asbestosrequirement

831 ndash Mold fungus sexual molestation

D REFERENCES The solicitationrsquos Evaluation Criteria ndash Project Specific Criteria Page 18 Question 3 request that completed references be provided for previous experience and projects Attached are the references as verified by County staff

E PERFORMANCE EVALUATIONS The Broward County Purchasing Division Contracts Central indicates evaluation scores for the proposing firms previously awarded contracts Completed performance evaluations may be provided upon request

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 9 of 12

Attached are Contracts Central performance evaluation history for each vendor as applicable including evaluation type (renewal goals compliance or final) and recommendation for future contracts (yes no or conditional) If a firm has periodic evaluations it will be listed separately

Additional Information In response to the Purchasing Directorrsquos Draft Memorandum to which the vendor can respond within 48 hours to any comments or deficiencies noted in the Purchasing DirectorrsquosDraft Memorandum Brown and Caldwell (Corporation) had a score that was highlighted in bright orange The bright orange highlight indicates that the firm receive an individual scoreof 1 or 2 on an item for that evaluation

F CONE OF SILENCE VIOLATIONS The Cone of Silence for this procurement has been in effect since May 3 2018 which prohibits potential vendors from discussing this solicitation with the Evaluation Committee the County Administrator Deputy County Administrator Assistant County Administrator Assistants to the County Administrator their respective support staff and any other person authorized to evaluate or recommend selection in this procurement process

Upon the first meeting of the Evaluation Committee the Cone of Silence expands to also include County Commissioners and their staff Potential vendors and their representatives are substantially restricted from communicating with County Commissioners and their staff regarding this procurement as stated in the Cone of Silence Ordinance

After application of the Cone of Silence inquiries regarding this solicitation should be directed to the Director of Purchasing or designee The Cone of Silence terminates when the County Commission or other awarding authority takes action which ends the solicitation Vendors are required to certify that they have read understand and will comply with the Cone of Silence Ordinance Section 1-266 Broward County Code of Ordinances

The following is a report of the proposersrsquo Cone of Silence violations

Name of Firm Remarks Violations

Arcadis US Inc Will Comply 1

Brown and Caldwell Will Comply None (Corporation)

Carollo Engineers Inc Will Comply None

Florida Technical Will Comply None Consultants LLC

Hazen and Sawyer PC Will Comply None

LakdasYohalem Engineering Will Comply None Inc

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 10 of 12

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Will Comply None Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

Additional Information

Arcadis US Inc had one violation 2011 - Robert Daoust Principal Scientist Malcolm PirnieArcadis US Inc

Additional Information In response to the Purchasing Directorrsquos Draft Memorandum to which the vendor can respond within 48 hours to any comments or deficiencies noted in the Purchasing DirectorrsquosDraft Memorandum Arcadis US Inc provided information that the cone of silence violationwas from a former employee

G VOLUME OF PREVIOUS WORK - EVALUATION CRITERIA ANDOR TIE BREAK CRITERIA The solicitation states that a number of points will be allocated for volume of previous work of the firm for the past five (5) years The volume of work for each of the proposing firms is as follows

Name of Firm Proposer Reported County Reported Points Allocated

Arcadis US Inc $24988700 $9597102 5 Points

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

$477974497 $477974497 3 Points

Carollo Engineers Inc $214076903 $214076903 5 Points

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

$000 $000 5 Points

Hazen and Sawyer PC

$2164284300 $2221320722 0 Points

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

$5894000 $5894030 5 Points

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

$000 $000 5 Points

Additional Information

5 points allocated to vendors paid $0 to $3000000 3 points allocated to vendors paid $3000001 to $7500000 1 point allocated to vendors paid $7500001 to $10000000 0 points allocated to vendors paid over $10000000

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 11 of 12

H PRINCIPAL BUSINESS LOCATION The solicitation states that a number of points will be allocated for location of the firm The Vendorrsquos principal address in Broward County shall be the Vendorrsquos ldquoPrincipal Addressrdquo as indicated with the Florida Department of State Division of Corporations for at least six (6) months prior to the solicitationrsquos due date A proposer with a principal business location within Broward County will receive five (5) points A proposer not having its principal business location within Broward County will receive zero (0) points

The results are as Proposed Attested Location Verified Points Allocated followsName of Nerve Center in SunBiz Firm

Arcadis US Inc 630 Plaza Drive Suite 10 YES 0 Highlands Ranch CO

Brown and Caldwell 201 North Civic Drive YES 0 (Corporation) Suite 300

Walnut Creek CA

Carollo Engineers 2700 Ygnacio Valley YES 0 Inc Road Suite 300

Walnut Creek CA

Florida Technical 533 East Ocean Avenue YES 0 Consultants LLC Suite 2

Boynton Beach FL

Hazen and Sawyer 4000 Hollywood YES 5 PC Boulevard Suite 750

North Hollywood FL

LakdasYohalem 2211 NE 54th Street YES 5 Engineering Inc Fort Lauderdale FL

Baxter amp Woodman 477 S Rosemary Avenue YES 0 Inc dba Mathews Suite 330 Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company West Palm Beach FL

Additional Information In response to the Purchasing Directorrsquos Draft Memorandum to which the vendor canrespond within 48 hours to any comments or deficiencies noted in the Purchasing Directorrsquos Draft Memorandum Hazen and Sawyer PC principal address as verified in Sunbiz is 4000Hollywood Blvd Suite 750N Hollywood FL 33021

I LOCAL PREFERENCE A vendor is eligible to be considered a local business for Local Preference purposes if it has a physical business address located within the limits of Broward County The vendor must provide a valid business tax receipt issued by Broward County at least one (1) year prior to bid or proposal opening

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 12 of 12

Broward Countyrsquos Local Preference Ordinance specifically excludes the application of a local preference for professional services procured pursuant to Section 287055 FS (CCNA)

J LOCATION - TIE BREAKER A Vendor located within Broward County is eligible for the Location Tie Breaker The County requires a copy of the Broward County Business Tax receipt for a period of time of at least six (6) months prior to the solicitation deadline and it must be provided with its initial submittal

The results are as follows

Name of Firm Eligibility Broward County Tax Receipt

Arcadis US Inc Eligible Provided

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

Eligible Provided

Carollo Engineers Inc Eligible Provided

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

Eligible Provided

Hazen and Sawyer PC Eligible Provided

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

Eligible Provided

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

Eligible Provided

Attachments 1 Vendor Reference Verifications 2 Vendor Performance Evaluations 3 Vendor Responses to Draft Memo

c Bob Melton County Auditor Office of the County Auditor Robert Wilson Title Division Department (Project Manager) Martha Perez-Garviso Purchasing Manager Purchasing Division Finance and Administrative Services Department Glenn Miller Assistant County Attorney Office of the County Attorney Fernando Amuchastegui Assistant County Attorney Office of the County Attorney

BJBGMnomm

Broward County Board of PNC211 5559P1 County Commissioners

BRCWARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LO ~ I DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P 1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis us Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

South Florida Water Management District

Contact Name Rich V irgil PE Title Bureau Chief lnfrabReference date 05142018

Contact Email rvirgilsfwmdgov Contact Phone 561 6826759

Name of Referenced Project S-193 Lock Refurbishment C-41A Canal Bank Stabilization Lake

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

4600000790 1001 2008 UP 12012016 $ 295400000

Vendors role in Project ]rime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Engineering Design and Engineering Services During Construction

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D [] DD c Deliverables []D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [L] D c Turnover D D D0

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget []D D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm [L]D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D 0 D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [] D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via ~AI L VERBAL Verified by ~~ Division WWfD Date ltQamp~(8 All lnformallon provided to Bltoward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate unlrulhful or incorrect statements made In support of this response may be used by the

512gt~11MlflS a lgtasis Of rejection rescission of the award or tenninallon of the contract and ~~lVcrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 of lhe Broward Count~ 41l6tlrelfient Code Y fTmiddot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BR~ltJWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LO R I DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering SeNices for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Saint Petersburg Department of Engineering and Capital Planning

Contact Name Nicole Allen Title CADDGIS Supervi Reference date

Contact Email nicoleallenstpeteorg Contact Phone 727-893-7316

Name of Referenced Project Water Resources Department GIS Data Migration

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

13-03-ARCIT 12092014 UP 09152015 $ 5925000

Vendors role in Project ]rime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again (Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Migration ofwater wastewater and storm water infrastructure information from CAD environment to Esri Local Government Information Model

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D [] D c Deliverables D [] D D

2 Vendors Organization [ZJa Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D [ZJ D c Turnover D D [] D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [ZJ D b Deliverables D D [ZJ D

4 Project completed within budget [ZJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [ZJ D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) [ZJD D D c Regu latory Agency(ies) D D [ZJ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONL rbullbull

Verified via L L VERBAL Verified by Division NlltE~ Date 6(~oatgt 1 8~ All information PfOvided to Bfoward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful oc inCOfrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

512gt9lillll jS a basis 10lt rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and nlll~9rrcrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of lhe Broward Cou~ 42fldtclrhtflent Code middot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BRuWARD1 1 COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering SeNices for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

C ity of Tavares F lorida

Contact Name James Dillon Title Public Works DireltaReference date 05172018

Contact Email jdillontavaresorg Contact Phone 352-455-7718

Name of Referenced Project G IS Modeling and Integration of Utilities Infrastructure

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

060330480000 04012017 UP 10012017 $ 5676000

Vendors role in Project ]rime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Integrate drawings and images depicting pipe infrastructure into a GIS environment for easy retrieval First project of a multi phase program to upgrade the Citys GIS information

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D 0 D c Deliverables D D 0 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D Ill D b Professionalism D D Ill D c Turnover D D 0 D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D Ill D b Deliverables D D Ill D

4 Project completed within budget D D Ill D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D Ill D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D Ill D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY -

Ve rified via L IL VERBAL Verified by fcAJ~ Division llt E1) Date 1 r~ tjlQ t8 All information pwvlded to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incooect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

512G91JlIHIS a basis for rejection rescission or the award or termination or the contract and lnfli~9ncrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 of the Broward CouI)~ 44flamplrelflent Code

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BRd~WARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LO R I DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Miramar

Contact Name Robin E Bain PE Title Project Manager Reference date 05142018

Contact Email rebainmiramarflgov Contact Phone 9548836825

Name of Referenced Project East Water Treatment Plant Replacement Wells and Design-Build

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PO 172624-00 10222017 UP 05142018 $ 56929600

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [ZJYes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Design permitting construction services for new Deep Injection Well and 4 new (replacement) production wells

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy []D D D c Deliverables D []D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D [ZJ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Turnover D D D []

3 Timeliness of a Project D D lZ1 D b Del iverables D D lZ1 D

4 Project completed within budget D D lZ1 D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor( s)Subconsultant( s) D D lZ1 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D lZ1 D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY (

Verified via A IL VER BAL Verified by faltJ~ Division WltEtgt Date 5 ~io l 9 All inlOllllalion pltovided to Broward County is subjecl lo verificalioo VendOt acknowledges lhal lnaccurale unlrulhful or i ncooecl stalemenls made in suppOltI of lhis response may be used by lhe

512gt~llM (lS a basis lot rejeclion rescission of the award or termination of lhe contract and mll~Arrcrve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuanl 10 Section 21119 of lhe Broward Couoty 43Pldtllrbrllent Code Y flmiddot

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Palm Beach County Water Utilities Department

Contact Name Ali Bayat Title Assistant Director Reference date

Contact Email abayatpbcwatercom Contact Phone 561 493 6128

Name of Referenced Project System 8 Water Quality Assessment

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

17-021 CSA21 01 022017 to 01152018 $ 8936000

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again (Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Brown and Caldwell led assessment of contributing causes to low system residuals troubleshooting treatment processes special testing and data analysis improvements to operating protocols monitoringcontrol system and treatment process

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [Z] D b Accuracy D [Z] DD c Deliverables D [Z]D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D [Z] D b Professionalism D D [Z] D c Turnover D [Z] DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D [Z] D

4 Project completed within budget D D [Z] D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Consultant worked collaboratively with operating maintenance engineering and laboratory staff to develop insight into contributing factors and implement improvements

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via _LEMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by tcltJ1~ Division -+LN euro P Date lteh IWt 8 All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the County as a basis for rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and may also serve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward County Procurement Code

BltaWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F L 0 R I D A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood Florida

Contact Name Steve Joseph Title Director Reference date

Contact Email sjosephhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954 921 3522

Name of Referenced Project Distribution System Water Quality Improvement

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

01012016 to 06022017 $ 3000000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again []Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Supported the City with its efforts improve chlorine residuals in areas of its system Analysis included system modeling monitoring optimized operational practices Implemented operational improvements that significantly raised (from approx 05 to 20 mgL) chloramine residuals In the most challenging area of the system

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D D [] D c Deliverables []D D D

2 Vendors Organization [] Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D [] D c Turnover D D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D [] D

4 Project completed within budget []D D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) []D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [] D

Additional Com ments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Effort Included system modoling moniloring and excursion response procedures opllmitallon of stored Inventory management unidirectional flushing pilot assessment and treatment proooss evaluation

Verified via __EMAIL vERBAL Division WW ED Date G Ifgt I 8 All infonmallon pltovided to Broward County Is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of thi s response may be used by lhe County as a basis for rejeclion rescission or the award or tenminatlon of the contract and may also serve as the basis for debanment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 or lhe Broward County Procurement Code

BROWARD t (l)t~ 1 Vendor Reference Verification Form

fl O R I OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of West Palm Beach Florida

Contact Name Jay Kwag Title Project Manager Reference date

Contact Email hjkwagwpborg Contact Phone 561 494 1041

Name of Referenced Project Modeling and Infrastructure General Engineering Consulting Assigments

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

11032014 to HAlt zc1e (on~vi~)

Vendors role in Project 52fPrime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IQves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Planning and General Eng1neerg Servicus 1nctuslve ol Waterwastewater System Master Pian asset management program dovo10pmenV11sset Crt1tcat1ty assessment Mesler PS 115 and sewer cond1hon assessment hydrauhc modeling ol LS 5 and force main sizing water system Capacity Analysis RoPort nydraullc modeling ol operahonat challongos tilt ste11on enatysbulls lac11i1a1e 1nspec11011 or major FM and new develOpmenl 1mpnc1s plpohno design lilt station condbullhon assessment and renabtlilahon (Various ProJecls)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D 0 D b Accuracy D 0D D c Deliverables D D 0 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D Gt D b Professionalism D D ~-- D c Turnover D D Gr D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D B D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget D D r~r D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D c~r D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D 0 D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION F~USE ONLY

__VERBAL Verified via LMAIL Verified by ~J Division ~~~D Date ~ f 2 f~t8 All lnfo11na1t0n pr ()Vl(fed 10 Broward County is svb1et110 ven11ca1ion vendor acknowledges lhll 1naeoura10 unlrulhful 0lt inc0ltrec1 s1a1emen1s medo In support ol 1n1s response may be used Dy the County as a basis fcu rejection re sclsst0n Of 1ho award or 1ormina1lon of l he contract and may also servo as the basis for debarment o f Vendor pursuant lo Section 21 119 of tho ampoward Counly P1ocuremont Code

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A middot

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Michael Low Title Deputy Director Reference date 05172018

Contact Email lowmbbflus Contact Phone 5617426403

Name of Referenced Project Ion Exchange Design Build

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

07022014 to 03212018 $ 100000000

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Carollo handled all of the design and construction of a significant part of the project as a subcontractor to COM Constructors as part of a progressive design build contract

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [Z] D b Accuracy D D [Z] D c Deliverables D D [Z] D

2 Vendors Organization D D [Z] Da Staff expertise b Professionalism D D [Z] D c Turnover D D D [Z]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D [Z] D

4 Project completed within budget D D [Z] D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D [Z] D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [Z] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION F~ COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ~~ Division W -NED Date S-gtozot~ All Information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor aclltnowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

Stii191111X 11s a basis for rejection rescission of the award or termination or the conlact and m~~Arifrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward CounYJ 33Plamptl1til1ent Code Y Imiddot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

B~OWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LORID A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

South Florida Water Management District

Contact Name Greg Coffelt PE Title SFWMD Project Manager Reference date 05172018

Contact Email gcoffeltsfwmdgov Contact Phone 561-682-6853

Name of Referenced Project L-8 Reservoir Inflow Structure and Pump Station

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

4600000861 02152011 to 09192012 $ 144535100

Vendors role in Project [l) Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [l)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Corolla was contracted as an Owners Advisor for a Design-Build contract developed engineering design criteria assisted in RFQ development and evaluation supported RFP technical proposal and cost proposal analysis

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [l] D b Accuracy D [] D D c Deliverables D [] D D

2 Vendors Organization [l]a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D [l] D c Turnover D D D [l]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [l] D b Deliverables D [l] D D

4 Project completed within budget [l] DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [l] D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) [l] DD D c Regu latory Agency(ies) D D D [l]

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Owner Advisor work continued(s) in support of Construction of Pump Station Inflow Gate Structure and levee hardening

Verified via IMAIL __VERBAL Date 5 ( 3 c b() I a All information piovided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that Inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made In support of this response may be used by the

512G9JiIX 11s a basis for rejection rescission or the award or termination or the contract and rllffl~Anampe as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 or the Broward CojlftYi 34~6ttlrbtflent Code Y

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

B0~~AARD ~~t~UNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

Fl ORIOA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Sunrise

Contact Name Luisa Fernanda Arbelaa Title Project Manager Reference date 05162018

Contact Email LArbelaezsunrlseflgov Contact Phone 954-888-6009

Name of Referenced Project City of Sunrise - Springtree WTP Water Stabilization and Solids Handling

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PA 16-003-CE 04072016 to 05292018 $ 50797800

Vendors role in Project ]Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [l]Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Carollo Engineers performed the design study and construction administration services for the City

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D G6 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Carollo Engineers technical knowledge and attenllon lo detall were beneficial lo the pltojad They ecled in lhe C~ys besl Interest In every aspect for lhe d1K8Uon of the projectbull

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via ~MAIL _VERBAL Verified by fc4J~~ Division W fl ED All lnrormalion provided to Broward ltAunty Is oobjoci to vorirtcotion Vendoc ecknowledgu that 1naowrate unlMhfuf 0lt lncocrecl statements rnado In support or this response may be useltI by lhe County as a basis for rejection rescission or the award 0lt termination ol the convect and may also ampOIVe as the babullibull ror debarmont of vondOlt purauont to Section 21119 or the Broward County Proc11oment Code

Bid Sync p 135 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BftQNARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

I l 0 R I 0 A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Florida Technical Consultants

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

VIiiage of Wellington Utilities

Contact Name Bradley Wolak Title Assistant Director Ut11Reference date 5182018

Contact Email bwolakwelllngtonflgov Contact Phone 561-753-2480

Name of Referenced Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 10012017 to Present 3500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vend~ 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again UZfYes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor J_ rJ fJ j(Gr-~k 6 Jti ov1 ~uf-Jiy fgt-r_- syrrzi~ff~ Al

R Q_ d--1 0~l 4 171 i+CI ~~lHI )Please rate your experience with tile Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Applicablereferenced Vendor Improvement

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy B D

DD c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D Db Professionalism D D

c Turnover D DD 3 Timeliness of

a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant(s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Additional Comments (provide on addltjpnal sheetJf needed) bull ~middot$ -JJ fo~~rltjbull lt( c-c_ ~~~ lt fo L1-lfAR- -middot~ I 10 ~ ~

~ bullL ~~ _te_ l~Ilgt~Cef t J ~ l rfbull4 middot r0 laquo r 4111J w f1 rrr- 0r- -i-HIS SECTION(9R COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by fcAJc ~ Division Y-1 IN ED Date 5 ~o w8 All lnfonn1Uon ptollfded to BlOward County le eubjeet to vetfflcatlon Vendor aclltnowledge1 that lneccurale unllJlhfUl or lnconect -bullmenla made In 1UPPort o1 this reopon90 may be uoec1 by the couniy ae a baalS ror re)ectlon re8Claeton Of the award 0t leltmlnatlon Of the contract and may 1l10 MM ae the baale flaquo debarrnont 01 vendor pu11uant to Section 21119 of ll1e Broward County Procurement Codo

BidSync p 18 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F LUFltIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultants LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Palm Beach Public Works

Contact Name Gerry Vazquez Title WRD Technician Reference date 05182018

Contact Email gvazqueztownofpalmbeachcom Contact Phone 772-546-6859

Name of Referenced Project GIS Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 3242014 to Present 13500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [3yenes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

PrwAamprs- favl49z Please rate your experience with the Need a Satlafactory Excellent Not

Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D g- D b Accuracy D Er D c Deliverables g-shyB D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D GJ D b Professionalism D D G- D c Tu mover D D cg- D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D g D b Deliverables D D Qshy D

4 Project completed within budget D D lbJ- D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D El- Db Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [3- D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

BidSync p 17 51232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

120-nWARDLll~ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form fLORllgtA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultant LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Waneya Bryant Title Meter Serv Mgr Reference date 05182018

Contact Email BryantWbbflus Contact Phone 561-742-6427

Name of Referenced Project Boynton Beach Utility GIS Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 12012016 to Present $15000000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

~T~ 5e-r-vtleamp +roM l)h f-es Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D Dc Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ti4 D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ Db Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on addlUonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION~urv USE ONLy u bull

Verified via VEMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by kuJ~ Division W if E D rao(ao8Date 5

All Information provided to Browslaquo COOlty Is Slbject to verfflcation Vendor acKnowledges that lneocurate Untruthful or lncolleel 8tatements made In support d this rfl9pOn98 may be used by 1119 Counly as a batia falt rejection relduion ct Ille award or lemilnlilon of the contract and may al80181Veaa1119 basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 ot Ille Broward CountyProcurement Code

512312018 BidSync p 16

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1

8W1V~isl1War Bid PNC21 15559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Fonn

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Cooper City - middot

Contact Name Michael Bailey PE itle Utilities DlrCity EbullReference date 05011201s

Contact Email MBalleycoopercityflorg Contact Phone (954) 434-5519

Name of Referenced Project City of Cooper City Continuing Professional Services bullContract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

RFQ 2009middot 1 04242009 to Present $ 2 19844200

Vendors role in Project IZJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Since 2009 Hazen has provided Cooper City with engineering services or water and wastewater projects Projects have lnctudeo lhe Pine Island Road Pump Station Lilt S1alions 2 amp 49 Improvements Master Plan Update of the FeaslJl~lty Review of Infrastructure Improvements tor Wastewater and the Eflluent Reuse and Disposal Master Plan

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy 8 D

D ~ D c Deliverables D 0 ~ D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D 0 D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tumover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D GJ- D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D 0 D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) ~D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

bull-rHIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY-

Verified vie EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ct4~ Division ~tUb Date ~ i3~) 0fgt All Information provided to BltCgtWW County 11 wbed ID vamprificalion Velldot adltnowledgu that lnaoewate unlrUhful lncom1ct statemampnla made in wppolt of 11111 response may blt uHd by the

4t2j=~ rejection rHclsslcn of th8 award or lennhallon of Ille eoo1nlct and may also seNamp at tilt basis for dtbarmenl at Vendor puuan1 lo Sectioo 21119 of the Broward COltJi 43

5232018 Bid Sync p24

Broward County Board of PNC211 5559P1

~RiiirilyenlcHUffi~~8CrW~r Bid PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

8DdMARD _ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FL O RIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Fort Lauderdale

Contact Name Rares Patrica PE Title Senior Project Mgr Reference date os1021201s

Contact Email RPetricafortlauderdalegov Contact Phone 9548287150

Name of Referenced Project Stormwater Master Planning and Design Implementation Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

256-11660 04192016 to 04192021 $ 989400000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

vyould you use this vendor again Sves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor The Hazen team Is responsible for delivery of a new stormwaler master plan model a prlorlllzed slormwaterresllency capital Improvements plan and Implementation of designs to address chronic flooding and other slormwater management challenges In the City Primary work tasks Include data collectlon hydrologlclhydraullc modeling and design permitting and construction services for capllal Improvement projects resulting from the revised stormwater master plan (preltmlnary design In seven priority neighborhoods)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION ~R COUNTY USE ONLY

aJ~Verified via pound MA IL _VERBAL Verified by Division W1~tl Date 5 ~3o~ax l S N I informallon p roviltled lo Broward County is sulljecl lo verification Vendor altknowledjj6s lhal inaccurate unlMhlut or lncotreci statements m ade In support of this respon$e may be used by tho

412~-~ rejeclion rescission of the award or termination ol lhe contracl and may also serve as lhe basis for debalment ol Vendor purwant to Section 21119 ol lhe Broward Cou~ 4 3

5232018 Bid Sync p25

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 Br~~~~~rs Bid PNC2115559P1 County t ommissioners

B~uWARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FlOR I CA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

Solicitation PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and s OrganizationFirm Name p

Town of Jupiter

nee

Contact Email davidbjupiterflus Contact Phone (561) 746-5134

Name of Referenced Project Engineering Services for Stormwater and Water Capital Improvements

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount $ 630000000 W17248 (2017 reselection 1012000 to Present (estimated lee-to-date since contract inception) contract number)

Vendors role in Project IZI Prime Vendor osubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again 0Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Descriotion of services orovided bv Vendor Since 2000 Hazen has served as General Consulfant to the Town or Jupiter As General Stormwater and Water Consullant the firm has provided services related to master planning stormwater planning and modeling design NPDES permilling asset management resiliency ratefinancial analysis plan review and construction oversight Water-related capital projs have involved additional system storage and high-service pumping transmission system improvements and RampR at existing facilities

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Verllied via EMAIL _ VERBAL Division WWC D

fo (J-Vv ~ltIvmiddotj Date 5(30(ipf S

Al lnroimallon pngtYICGd 10 Broward Counly Is sub)oel to v8flrcallon vendlaquo acknowledges lhat Inaccurate unlruthlu~ 0t Jnwrrect slatoments made In support ol this response may be used by the 42~~1~0 rojecllon rescission or Ille award or termination or lhe con~acl bullnd mbully also serve as tho basis r0t debarment of Vendor pursuant lo Socllon 21119 of lho Broward Couw 41

5232018 BidSync p 26

a N ~ IL) IL) N u z a_

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLO RI DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Walter Wernecke RA Title Sr Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email WWERNECKEhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Hollywood Marina Restrooms

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

04152015 to Present 7500000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor OSubconsultanVSubcontractor n ~U t1

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

-0 Vgt Description of services provided by VendorO ~ ~ Q) Structural Design and Construction Inspection Services i co Q m ~- c E c0

i E gt Oo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not () uu Appllcable O

E~ referenced Vendor Improvement iii ~sectoO 1 Vendors Quality of Service B mu a Responsive D D

b Accuracy DD c Deliverables D DD

2 Vendors Organization D Da Staff expertise v D b Professionalism~ D D c Turnover D ~D

3 Timeliness of D a Project b Deliverables D ~

4 Pec~~11~$~hinJ~~qt lfr D D 5 Cooperation with f ~

a Your Firm D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D

Al lnfonn1tion pRgttded IO Brwd Cltgtunly lo 1ubjecl IO ibllon vsor ~middot Iha icl-bullmiddot ~ ir-ect slalemenls mode In _ol lhb _ moy ti used by he County as a basis lot rejecUon rnclnlon cl the eward or tonnlnallan of lhl connct 1nd may bullllo 11 the basis for dobalment of Vendor IQtulnl IO SICllOn 21119 at lhe Broword County Procurement Code

Cl ltraquo I() I() I() N ()

Cl z

BRltJWARD ~ middot COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORl OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Davie

Contact Name Emilio DeSimone Title Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email Emilio_DeSimonedavie-fl gov Contact Phone 954-797-1085

Name of Referenced Project Pavillion 5 Linear Park

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

B-17-123 09152015 to 2700000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor O SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es O No If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

0 Description of services provided by Vendor O Q)

iii c Structural Design and Construction Inspection ServicesoQ

CDi-

0cc E gt=gt E ()Oo O () () Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

ii) -e i- Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 111 cs

B ioO

J 1 Vendors Quality of Service Q ()

a Responsive D D b Accuracy D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization []Ll Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D Dtr

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [g D b Deliverables D D ar D

4 Project completed within budget [1tD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) cgD D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via l EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by ~h~ Division WlI Etgt Date 0 f l~o I 8 All lnformaUon provided lO Broward County Is eubJect 10 verifutlon Vendor ecknOMedgoo that lnaocurote unNlhlul or Incorrect statamenle made In aupl)Ort of this reaponse may be used by lho County et o baampla for rejection realtluion of the award or lermlnallon of tho eon1fllcl ond moy olao aorvo os ho basis for debarmont of Vondor purauenl lo Section 21119 of the Broward Counly Procuremen1 Code

0 0 agt a c () z 0

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Terrence Comiskey AIA Title Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email TCOMISKEYhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Van Buren Parking Garage

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PK 14-053 Nov 2014 to Present 8310000

Vendors role in Project t8(Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

o~ Description of services provided by Vendor 1 Q)ltO c Structural Design and Conslructlon Inspection Services 0 Q

0~Jl ccE l E enOo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

gtshy

uu O Improvement Applicable ffireferenced Vendor

~sect 1 Vendors Quality of Service 1 ~

oOau a Responsive D ~ D b Accuracy B D D

D D [- Dc Deliverables

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tum over D D D g

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ D Subcontractor(s )S ubcons u ltant( s)b D D ~ D

c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D yenj D Additional Comments provide on sdditlonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION ~NTY USE ONLY0

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by kW Division W-1-(i~ Date EJo(a~t8 Al lnform1Uon PltOVlded lo Browald Ccxnty It IUbjoct to vorificallon Vendor eoknowfodgea thal lnaewralt U111MhlJI deg inlaquogtlaquobullel amptal11ants made In eupporl of lhls relj)Onse may be used by Iha Counly es a balls l0t rcfecllon rescfuloltI of tho ew1rd or 1ermtnaU0lt1 ol lhbull conllllCI and may elao urve 11 lho basis for dabarmenl of Vondor pursuanl lo Secllon 21 119 of he erowald COUlly CiProcurement Code

~ N ii

00

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 aOWllrp Commficumlref Bid PNC2116615B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Pompano Beach FL

Contact Name Mr A Randolph Brown Title Utilities Director Reference date April 30 2018

Contact Email randolphbrowncopbflcom Contact Phone 954-545-7043

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 201 o Project Amount fees varied

Multiple

Vendors role in Project IKJ Prime Vendor

to 2018

osubconsultanUSubcontractor

(range $10000shy$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D ~ D D c Deliverables D ~ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D ~ D D b Professionalism D D ~ D C Turnover D El DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ 0 b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D [BJ D n c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [XJ o ~

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed) amp~~it -THIS SECTION ~COUNTY USE ONL y-bullbull

Verified via ~AIL __VERBAL Verified by 1lt4 )~ Division N WE O Date 5 faol Z1 18

All lnformotlon providod to BltownrltI Cou nty it aubjoct O verification VendOr acknowledges that lnaccornto untruthful or incorroct 11atomon1s made in support of this response may be used by tho

411p~~)~~J rojoclion roscissioo ol lho award or 1orroinalion of tho contract and roay also s01vo as lhbull basis f0lt d~arroont of VondOf pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward Cou)l1

Bid Sync p 73

40

5232018

Broward County Board of Bid PNC2116659B 1 County Commissioners

B~aWARD gt1- t COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Loxahatchee River Environmental Control District

Contact Name Mr Kris Dean Title Director of Engineering Reference date May 9 2018

Contact Email krisdeanloxahatcheeriverorg Contact Phone 561-747-5700

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 2001 Project Amount fees varied (range $10000shyMultiple to 2018 $250000)

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IR)Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D ~ D D b Accuracy D 0 D D c Deliverables D IBJ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D IB] D D b Professionalism D ~ D D c Turnover D [8J D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D [8J D D b Deliverables D m D D

4 Project completed within budget D ~ D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D ~ D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D Ii] D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D ~ D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SE~ FOR~USE ONLY

Verified via _lEMAIL __VERBAL Verified by ~lt Division fWeb Date I

All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untrulhful or incorrecl slatements made In support of this response may be used by the lJl~~~l~~jSfiir rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and mll~~~ere as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Co)f 10

Broward County Board of Bid PNC21166$9B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A l

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Lake Worth FL

Contact Name Mr Felipe Lofaso TitleAsst Dir Public-ServicesReference date May 9 2018

Contact Email flofasolakeworthorg Contact Phone 561-586-1720

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contract

Contract No Date Services Provided 2014 Project Amount fees varied Multiple to 2018 (range $10000shy

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Services included multiple municipal engineering projects including survey roadway design utility design and coordination (water wastewater stormwater other) along with project management

Needs Satisfactory Excellent NotPlease rate your experience with the Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D GJ D b Accuracy D D Ii] D c Deliverables D Ii] DD

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [i] D c Turnover D D D [X]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D 0 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [X] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION Fe COUNTY USE ONLrbullbull

Verified via MAIL __VERBAL Verified by Division ~wgtgt Date 5~3ol20t8 All information provided to Broward County Is subject lo verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect slalements made in support ol this response may be used by the

OZ~id~~~~j~r rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and m~~~(iirve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Cour~ iG

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - ARCADIS US INC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts

VS0000013130 VS00013130 - ARCADIS US INC Prime Work Auth Vendor SummaryProjects

PURCHASING 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold Procurement No Fixed Contracts FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Favorites Past 5 Years Prime Vendor

Sub Vendor From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 10042017 Purchase Order

Evaluation Purchase Orders 1 POs With A Total Amt Of $20000000 Log Off Paid To Dt ($12132949) Balance $7867051

Contracts Purchase Orders Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx 6192018

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Finish

PURCHASING Weighted Scores Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract FileRoom DashBoard Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number FileRoom Insert

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel Favorites Prime Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Service Evaluation

6132017 YES 486 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Goals Compliance Evaluation

10272016 YES 460 View Docs (0)

6272018

Project Management Information System

Close

Contracts Central Administration

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9130 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-24

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6182018 YES 355 View Docs (1)

Proj Nbr 9320 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-20

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6132018 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9290 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-23

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1122018 YES 494 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-21

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12182017 YES 488 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10162017 YES 473 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

8252017 YES 495 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9321 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-19

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

7112017 YES 476 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-17

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2272017 YES 400 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

10132016 YES 384 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-12

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

5202016 YES 405 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9018 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-06

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10192015 YES 448 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

3202015 YES 385 View Docs (0)

Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL CONSULTANTS

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Project Management Information System

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-04

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12122014 YES 437 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-08

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1242014 YES 423 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-02

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2282014 YES 452 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC

VC0000044184 VC00044184 - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres PS $001 Used $000 Remain $001 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $354848400 Closed 0 Total $000 Total Current Retainage Balance For All Contracts $793370 No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 06292015 Purchase Orders 2 POs With A Total Amt Of $362317900 Paid To Dt ($218795160) Balance $143522740

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 40803 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9058 - DISTRICT 3A POTABLE WATER STORAGE

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1220410P1 - Consultant Engineering Services for Potable Water FixedOpen Contracts Storage Tanks and Pumping Systems Work Auth Prime Vendor CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Periodic Final Finish

Log Off Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type

Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

6232015 8302017 413 Approved 8312017 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard

Enter Vendor Name (or a portion of) Then Click Search - Wilcards Are Permitted (ie wa wawainc) Florida Technical Consultants

Search Reset Finish

No Vendors Found For Your Search Try Again

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41005 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score Go

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0773

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

12122017 YES 430 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

8302016 YES 438 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Final Consultant Evaluation 3142016 YES 478 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0706

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

142016 YES 402 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9016OES - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0731

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

10192015 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0748

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

612015 YES 467 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

2192015 YES 500 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0754

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

252015 YES 409 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0755

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

1242014 YES 415 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8974 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0758

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

6202014 YES 393 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr

WATER amp WASTEWATER

Final Consultant Work Authorization 572014 YES 423 View Docs

(0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

HS0746 ENGINEERING Evaluation

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

4302014 YES 475 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Evaluation 4302014 YES 493 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0710

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

3172014 YES 395 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0753

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

1212014 YES 380 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0763

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

11192013 YES 450 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0775

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 408 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals

Finish

Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed FileRoom DashBoard Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization FileRoom Insert NumberFavorites

Prime Vendor Export To Excel Sub Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0772

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 417 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0771

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

2262013 YES 410 View Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 9: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 9 of 12

Attached are Contracts Central performance evaluation history for each vendor as applicable including evaluation type (renewal goals compliance or final) and recommendation for future contracts (yes no or conditional) If a firm has periodic evaluations it will be listed separately

Additional Information In response to the Purchasing Directorrsquos Draft Memorandum to which the vendor can respond within 48 hours to any comments or deficiencies noted in the Purchasing DirectorrsquosDraft Memorandum Brown and Caldwell (Corporation) had a score that was highlighted in bright orange The bright orange highlight indicates that the firm receive an individual scoreof 1 or 2 on an item for that evaluation

F CONE OF SILENCE VIOLATIONS The Cone of Silence for this procurement has been in effect since May 3 2018 which prohibits potential vendors from discussing this solicitation with the Evaluation Committee the County Administrator Deputy County Administrator Assistant County Administrator Assistants to the County Administrator their respective support staff and any other person authorized to evaluate or recommend selection in this procurement process

Upon the first meeting of the Evaluation Committee the Cone of Silence expands to also include County Commissioners and their staff Potential vendors and their representatives are substantially restricted from communicating with County Commissioners and their staff regarding this procurement as stated in the Cone of Silence Ordinance

After application of the Cone of Silence inquiries regarding this solicitation should be directed to the Director of Purchasing or designee The Cone of Silence terminates when the County Commission or other awarding authority takes action which ends the solicitation Vendors are required to certify that they have read understand and will comply with the Cone of Silence Ordinance Section 1-266 Broward County Code of Ordinances

The following is a report of the proposersrsquo Cone of Silence violations

Name of Firm Remarks Violations

Arcadis US Inc Will Comply 1

Brown and Caldwell Will Comply None (Corporation)

Carollo Engineers Inc Will Comply None

Florida Technical Will Comply None Consultants LLC

Hazen and Sawyer PC Will Comply None

LakdasYohalem Engineering Will Comply None Inc

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 10 of 12

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Will Comply None Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

Additional Information

Arcadis US Inc had one violation 2011 - Robert Daoust Principal Scientist Malcolm PirnieArcadis US Inc

Additional Information In response to the Purchasing Directorrsquos Draft Memorandum to which the vendor can respond within 48 hours to any comments or deficiencies noted in the Purchasing DirectorrsquosDraft Memorandum Arcadis US Inc provided information that the cone of silence violationwas from a former employee

G VOLUME OF PREVIOUS WORK - EVALUATION CRITERIA ANDOR TIE BREAK CRITERIA The solicitation states that a number of points will be allocated for volume of previous work of the firm for the past five (5) years The volume of work for each of the proposing firms is as follows

Name of Firm Proposer Reported County Reported Points Allocated

Arcadis US Inc $24988700 $9597102 5 Points

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

$477974497 $477974497 3 Points

Carollo Engineers Inc $214076903 $214076903 5 Points

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

$000 $000 5 Points

Hazen and Sawyer PC

$2164284300 $2221320722 0 Points

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

$5894000 $5894030 5 Points

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

$000 $000 5 Points

Additional Information

5 points allocated to vendors paid $0 to $3000000 3 points allocated to vendors paid $3000001 to $7500000 1 point allocated to vendors paid $7500001 to $10000000 0 points allocated to vendors paid over $10000000

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 11 of 12

H PRINCIPAL BUSINESS LOCATION The solicitation states that a number of points will be allocated for location of the firm The Vendorrsquos principal address in Broward County shall be the Vendorrsquos ldquoPrincipal Addressrdquo as indicated with the Florida Department of State Division of Corporations for at least six (6) months prior to the solicitationrsquos due date A proposer with a principal business location within Broward County will receive five (5) points A proposer not having its principal business location within Broward County will receive zero (0) points

The results are as Proposed Attested Location Verified Points Allocated followsName of Nerve Center in SunBiz Firm

Arcadis US Inc 630 Plaza Drive Suite 10 YES 0 Highlands Ranch CO

Brown and Caldwell 201 North Civic Drive YES 0 (Corporation) Suite 300

Walnut Creek CA

Carollo Engineers 2700 Ygnacio Valley YES 0 Inc Road Suite 300

Walnut Creek CA

Florida Technical 533 East Ocean Avenue YES 0 Consultants LLC Suite 2

Boynton Beach FL

Hazen and Sawyer 4000 Hollywood YES 5 PC Boulevard Suite 750

North Hollywood FL

LakdasYohalem 2211 NE 54th Street YES 5 Engineering Inc Fort Lauderdale FL

Baxter amp Woodman 477 S Rosemary Avenue YES 0 Inc dba Mathews Suite 330 Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company West Palm Beach FL

Additional Information In response to the Purchasing Directorrsquos Draft Memorandum to which the vendor canrespond within 48 hours to any comments or deficiencies noted in the Purchasing Directorrsquos Draft Memorandum Hazen and Sawyer PC principal address as verified in Sunbiz is 4000Hollywood Blvd Suite 750N Hollywood FL 33021

I LOCAL PREFERENCE A vendor is eligible to be considered a local business for Local Preference purposes if it has a physical business address located within the limits of Broward County The vendor must provide a valid business tax receipt issued by Broward County at least one (1) year prior to bid or proposal opening

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 12 of 12

Broward Countyrsquos Local Preference Ordinance specifically excludes the application of a local preference for professional services procured pursuant to Section 287055 FS (CCNA)

J LOCATION - TIE BREAKER A Vendor located within Broward County is eligible for the Location Tie Breaker The County requires a copy of the Broward County Business Tax receipt for a period of time of at least six (6) months prior to the solicitation deadline and it must be provided with its initial submittal

The results are as follows

Name of Firm Eligibility Broward County Tax Receipt

Arcadis US Inc Eligible Provided

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

Eligible Provided

Carollo Engineers Inc Eligible Provided

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

Eligible Provided

Hazen and Sawyer PC Eligible Provided

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

Eligible Provided

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

Eligible Provided

Attachments 1 Vendor Reference Verifications 2 Vendor Performance Evaluations 3 Vendor Responses to Draft Memo

c Bob Melton County Auditor Office of the County Auditor Robert Wilson Title Division Department (Project Manager) Martha Perez-Garviso Purchasing Manager Purchasing Division Finance and Administrative Services Department Glenn Miller Assistant County Attorney Office of the County Attorney Fernando Amuchastegui Assistant County Attorney Office of the County Attorney

BJBGMnomm

Broward County Board of PNC211 5559P1 County Commissioners

BRCWARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LO ~ I DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P 1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis us Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

South Florida Water Management District

Contact Name Rich V irgil PE Title Bureau Chief lnfrabReference date 05142018

Contact Email rvirgilsfwmdgov Contact Phone 561 6826759

Name of Referenced Project S-193 Lock Refurbishment C-41A Canal Bank Stabilization Lake

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

4600000790 1001 2008 UP 12012016 $ 295400000

Vendors role in Project ]rime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Engineering Design and Engineering Services During Construction

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D [] DD c Deliverables []D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [L] D c Turnover D D D0

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget []D D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm [L]D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D 0 D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [] D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via ~AI L VERBAL Verified by ~~ Division WWfD Date ltQamp~(8 All lnformallon provided to Bltoward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate unlrulhful or incorrect statements made In support of this response may be used by the

512gt~11MlflS a lgtasis Of rejection rescission of the award or tenninallon of the contract and ~~lVcrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 of lhe Broward Count~ 41l6tlrelfient Code Y fTmiddot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BR~ltJWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LO R I DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering SeNices for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Saint Petersburg Department of Engineering and Capital Planning

Contact Name Nicole Allen Title CADDGIS Supervi Reference date

Contact Email nicoleallenstpeteorg Contact Phone 727-893-7316

Name of Referenced Project Water Resources Department GIS Data Migration

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

13-03-ARCIT 12092014 UP 09152015 $ 5925000

Vendors role in Project ]rime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again (Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Migration ofwater wastewater and storm water infrastructure information from CAD environment to Esri Local Government Information Model

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D [] D c Deliverables D [] D D

2 Vendors Organization [ZJa Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D [ZJ D c Turnover D D [] D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [ZJ D b Deliverables D D [ZJ D

4 Project completed within budget [ZJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [ZJ D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) [ZJD D D c Regu latory Agency(ies) D D [ZJ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONL rbullbull

Verified via L L VERBAL Verified by Division NlltE~ Date 6(~oatgt 1 8~ All information PfOvided to Bfoward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful oc inCOfrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

512gt9lillll jS a basis 10lt rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and nlll~9rrcrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of lhe Broward Cou~ 42fldtclrhtflent Code middot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BRuWARD1 1 COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering SeNices for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

C ity of Tavares F lorida

Contact Name James Dillon Title Public Works DireltaReference date 05172018

Contact Email jdillontavaresorg Contact Phone 352-455-7718

Name of Referenced Project G IS Modeling and Integration of Utilities Infrastructure

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

060330480000 04012017 UP 10012017 $ 5676000

Vendors role in Project ]rime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Integrate drawings and images depicting pipe infrastructure into a GIS environment for easy retrieval First project of a multi phase program to upgrade the Citys GIS information

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D 0 D c Deliverables D D 0 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D Ill D b Professionalism D D Ill D c Turnover D D 0 D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D Ill D b Deliverables D D Ill D

4 Project completed within budget D D Ill D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D Ill D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D Ill D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY -

Ve rified via L IL VERBAL Verified by fcAJ~ Division llt E1) Date 1 r~ tjlQ t8 All information pwvlded to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incooect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

512G91JlIHIS a basis for rejection rescission or the award or termination or the contract and lnfli~9ncrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 of the Broward CouI)~ 44flamplrelflent Code

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BRd~WARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LO R I DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Miramar

Contact Name Robin E Bain PE Title Project Manager Reference date 05142018

Contact Email rebainmiramarflgov Contact Phone 9548836825

Name of Referenced Project East Water Treatment Plant Replacement Wells and Design-Build

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PO 172624-00 10222017 UP 05142018 $ 56929600

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [ZJYes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Design permitting construction services for new Deep Injection Well and 4 new (replacement) production wells

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy []D D D c Deliverables D []D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D [ZJ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Turnover D D D []

3 Timeliness of a Project D D lZ1 D b Del iverables D D lZ1 D

4 Project completed within budget D D lZ1 D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor( s)Subconsultant( s) D D lZ1 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D lZ1 D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY (

Verified via A IL VER BAL Verified by faltJ~ Division WltEtgt Date 5 ~io l 9 All inlOllllalion pltovided to Broward County is subjecl lo verificalioo VendOt acknowledges lhal lnaccurale unlrulhful or i ncooecl stalemenls made in suppOltI of lhis response may be used by lhe

512gt~llM (lS a basis lot rejeclion rescission of the award or termination of lhe contract and mll~Arrcrve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuanl 10 Section 21119 of lhe Broward Couoty 43Pldtllrbrllent Code Y flmiddot

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Palm Beach County Water Utilities Department

Contact Name Ali Bayat Title Assistant Director Reference date

Contact Email abayatpbcwatercom Contact Phone 561 493 6128

Name of Referenced Project System 8 Water Quality Assessment

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

17-021 CSA21 01 022017 to 01152018 $ 8936000

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again (Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Brown and Caldwell led assessment of contributing causes to low system residuals troubleshooting treatment processes special testing and data analysis improvements to operating protocols monitoringcontrol system and treatment process

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [Z] D b Accuracy D [Z] DD c Deliverables D [Z]D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D [Z] D b Professionalism D D [Z] D c Turnover D [Z] DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D [Z] D

4 Project completed within budget D D [Z] D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Consultant worked collaboratively with operating maintenance engineering and laboratory staff to develop insight into contributing factors and implement improvements

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via _LEMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by tcltJ1~ Division -+LN euro P Date lteh IWt 8 All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the County as a basis for rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and may also serve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward County Procurement Code

BltaWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F L 0 R I D A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood Florida

Contact Name Steve Joseph Title Director Reference date

Contact Email sjosephhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954 921 3522

Name of Referenced Project Distribution System Water Quality Improvement

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

01012016 to 06022017 $ 3000000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again []Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Supported the City with its efforts improve chlorine residuals in areas of its system Analysis included system modeling monitoring optimized operational practices Implemented operational improvements that significantly raised (from approx 05 to 20 mgL) chloramine residuals In the most challenging area of the system

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D D [] D c Deliverables []D D D

2 Vendors Organization [] Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D [] D c Turnover D D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D [] D

4 Project completed within budget []D D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) []D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [] D

Additional Com ments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Effort Included system modoling moniloring and excursion response procedures opllmitallon of stored Inventory management unidirectional flushing pilot assessment and treatment proooss evaluation

Verified via __EMAIL vERBAL Division WW ED Date G Ifgt I 8 All infonmallon pltovided to Broward County Is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of thi s response may be used by lhe County as a basis for rejeclion rescission or the award or tenminatlon of the contract and may also serve as the basis for debanment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 or lhe Broward County Procurement Code

BROWARD t (l)t~ 1 Vendor Reference Verification Form

fl O R I OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of West Palm Beach Florida

Contact Name Jay Kwag Title Project Manager Reference date

Contact Email hjkwagwpborg Contact Phone 561 494 1041

Name of Referenced Project Modeling and Infrastructure General Engineering Consulting Assigments

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

11032014 to HAlt zc1e (on~vi~)

Vendors role in Project 52fPrime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IQves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Planning and General Eng1neerg Servicus 1nctuslve ol Waterwastewater System Master Pian asset management program dovo10pmenV11sset Crt1tcat1ty assessment Mesler PS 115 and sewer cond1hon assessment hydrauhc modeling ol LS 5 and force main sizing water system Capacity Analysis RoPort nydraullc modeling ol operahonat challongos tilt ste11on enatysbulls lac11i1a1e 1nspec11011 or major FM and new develOpmenl 1mpnc1s plpohno design lilt station condbullhon assessment and renabtlilahon (Various ProJecls)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D 0 D b Accuracy D 0D D c Deliverables D D 0 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D Gt D b Professionalism D D ~-- D c Turnover D D Gr D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D B D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget D D r~r D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D c~r D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D 0 D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION F~USE ONLY

__VERBAL Verified via LMAIL Verified by ~J Division ~~~D Date ~ f 2 f~t8 All lnfo11na1t0n pr ()Vl(fed 10 Broward County is svb1et110 ven11ca1ion vendor acknowledges lhll 1naeoura10 unlrulhful 0lt inc0ltrec1 s1a1emen1s medo In support ol 1n1s response may be used Dy the County as a basis fcu rejection re sclsst0n Of 1ho award or 1ormina1lon of l he contract and may also servo as the basis for debarment o f Vendor pursuant lo Section 21 119 of tho ampoward Counly P1ocuremont Code

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A middot

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Michael Low Title Deputy Director Reference date 05172018

Contact Email lowmbbflus Contact Phone 5617426403

Name of Referenced Project Ion Exchange Design Build

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

07022014 to 03212018 $ 100000000

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Carollo handled all of the design and construction of a significant part of the project as a subcontractor to COM Constructors as part of a progressive design build contract

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [Z] D b Accuracy D D [Z] D c Deliverables D D [Z] D

2 Vendors Organization D D [Z] Da Staff expertise b Professionalism D D [Z] D c Turnover D D D [Z]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D [Z] D

4 Project completed within budget D D [Z] D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D [Z] D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [Z] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION F~ COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ~~ Division W -NED Date S-gtozot~ All Information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor aclltnowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

Stii191111X 11s a basis for rejection rescission of the award or termination or the conlact and m~~Arifrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward CounYJ 33Plamptl1til1ent Code Y Imiddot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

B~OWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LORID A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

South Florida Water Management District

Contact Name Greg Coffelt PE Title SFWMD Project Manager Reference date 05172018

Contact Email gcoffeltsfwmdgov Contact Phone 561-682-6853

Name of Referenced Project L-8 Reservoir Inflow Structure and Pump Station

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

4600000861 02152011 to 09192012 $ 144535100

Vendors role in Project [l) Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [l)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Corolla was contracted as an Owners Advisor for a Design-Build contract developed engineering design criteria assisted in RFQ development and evaluation supported RFP technical proposal and cost proposal analysis

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [l] D b Accuracy D [] D D c Deliverables D [] D D

2 Vendors Organization [l]a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D [l] D c Turnover D D D [l]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [l] D b Deliverables D [l] D D

4 Project completed within budget [l] DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [l] D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) [l] DD D c Regu latory Agency(ies) D D D [l]

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Owner Advisor work continued(s) in support of Construction of Pump Station Inflow Gate Structure and levee hardening

Verified via IMAIL __VERBAL Date 5 ( 3 c b() I a All information piovided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that Inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made In support of this response may be used by the

512G9JiIX 11s a basis for rejection rescission or the award or termination or the contract and rllffl~Anampe as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 or the Broward CojlftYi 34~6ttlrbtflent Code Y

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

B0~~AARD ~~t~UNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

Fl ORIOA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Sunrise

Contact Name Luisa Fernanda Arbelaa Title Project Manager Reference date 05162018

Contact Email LArbelaezsunrlseflgov Contact Phone 954-888-6009

Name of Referenced Project City of Sunrise - Springtree WTP Water Stabilization and Solids Handling

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PA 16-003-CE 04072016 to 05292018 $ 50797800

Vendors role in Project ]Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [l]Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Carollo Engineers performed the design study and construction administration services for the City

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D G6 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Carollo Engineers technical knowledge and attenllon lo detall were beneficial lo the pltojad They ecled in lhe C~ys besl Interest In every aspect for lhe d1K8Uon of the projectbull

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via ~MAIL _VERBAL Verified by fc4J~~ Division W fl ED All lnrormalion provided to Broward ltAunty Is oobjoci to vorirtcotion Vendoc ecknowledgu that 1naowrate unlMhfuf 0lt lncocrecl statements rnado In support or this response may be useltI by lhe County as a basis for rejection rescission or the award 0lt termination ol the convect and may also ampOIVe as the babullibull ror debarmont of vondOlt purauont to Section 21119 or the Broward County Proc11oment Code

Bid Sync p 135 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BftQNARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

I l 0 R I 0 A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Florida Technical Consultants

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

VIiiage of Wellington Utilities

Contact Name Bradley Wolak Title Assistant Director Ut11Reference date 5182018

Contact Email bwolakwelllngtonflgov Contact Phone 561-753-2480

Name of Referenced Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 10012017 to Present 3500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vend~ 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again UZfYes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor J_ rJ fJ j(Gr-~k 6 Jti ov1 ~uf-Jiy fgt-r_- syrrzi~ff~ Al

R Q_ d--1 0~l 4 171 i+CI ~~lHI )Please rate your experience with tile Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Applicablereferenced Vendor Improvement

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy B D

DD c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D Db Professionalism D D

c Turnover D DD 3 Timeliness of

a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant(s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Additional Comments (provide on addltjpnal sheetJf needed) bull ~middot$ -JJ fo~~rltjbull lt( c-c_ ~~~ lt fo L1-lfAR- -middot~ I 10 ~ ~

~ bullL ~~ _te_ l~Ilgt~Cef t J ~ l rfbull4 middot r0 laquo r 4111J w f1 rrr- 0r- -i-HIS SECTION(9R COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by fcAJc ~ Division Y-1 IN ED Date 5 ~o w8 All lnfonn1Uon ptollfded to BlOward County le eubjeet to vetfflcatlon Vendor aclltnowledge1 that lneccurale unllJlhfUl or lnconect -bullmenla made In 1UPPort o1 this reopon90 may be uoec1 by the couniy ae a baalS ror re)ectlon re8Claeton Of the award 0t leltmlnatlon Of the contract and may 1l10 MM ae the baale flaquo debarrnont 01 vendor pu11uant to Section 21119 of ll1e Broward County Procurement Codo

BidSync p 18 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F LUFltIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultants LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Palm Beach Public Works

Contact Name Gerry Vazquez Title WRD Technician Reference date 05182018

Contact Email gvazqueztownofpalmbeachcom Contact Phone 772-546-6859

Name of Referenced Project GIS Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 3242014 to Present 13500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [3yenes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

PrwAamprs- favl49z Please rate your experience with the Need a Satlafactory Excellent Not

Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D g- D b Accuracy D Er D c Deliverables g-shyB D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D GJ D b Professionalism D D G- D c Tu mover D D cg- D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D g D b Deliverables D D Qshy D

4 Project completed within budget D D lbJ- D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D El- Db Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [3- D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

BidSync p 17 51232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

120-nWARDLll~ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form fLORllgtA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultant LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Waneya Bryant Title Meter Serv Mgr Reference date 05182018

Contact Email BryantWbbflus Contact Phone 561-742-6427

Name of Referenced Project Boynton Beach Utility GIS Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 12012016 to Present $15000000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

~T~ 5e-r-vtleamp +roM l)h f-es Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D Dc Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ti4 D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ Db Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on addlUonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION~urv USE ONLy u bull

Verified via VEMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by kuJ~ Division W if E D rao(ao8Date 5

All Information provided to Browslaquo COOlty Is Slbject to verfflcation Vendor acKnowledges that lneocurate Untruthful or lncolleel 8tatements made In support d this rfl9pOn98 may be used by 1119 Counly as a batia falt rejection relduion ct Ille award or lemilnlilon of the contract and may al80181Veaa1119 basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 ot Ille Broward CountyProcurement Code

512312018 BidSync p 16

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1

8W1V~isl1War Bid PNC21 15559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Fonn

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Cooper City - middot

Contact Name Michael Bailey PE itle Utilities DlrCity EbullReference date 05011201s

Contact Email MBalleycoopercityflorg Contact Phone (954) 434-5519

Name of Referenced Project City of Cooper City Continuing Professional Services bullContract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

RFQ 2009middot 1 04242009 to Present $ 2 19844200

Vendors role in Project IZJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Since 2009 Hazen has provided Cooper City with engineering services or water and wastewater projects Projects have lnctudeo lhe Pine Island Road Pump Station Lilt S1alions 2 amp 49 Improvements Master Plan Update of the FeaslJl~lty Review of Infrastructure Improvements tor Wastewater and the Eflluent Reuse and Disposal Master Plan

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy 8 D

D ~ D c Deliverables D 0 ~ D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D 0 D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tumover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D GJ- D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D 0 D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) ~D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

bull-rHIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY-

Verified vie EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ct4~ Division ~tUb Date ~ i3~) 0fgt All Information provided to BltCgtWW County 11 wbed ID vamprificalion Velldot adltnowledgu that lnaoewate unlrUhful lncom1ct statemampnla made in wppolt of 11111 response may blt uHd by the

4t2j=~ rejection rHclsslcn of th8 award or lennhallon of Ille eoo1nlct and may also seNamp at tilt basis for dtbarmenl at Vendor puuan1 lo Sectioo 21119 of the Broward COltJi 43

5232018 Bid Sync p24

Broward County Board of PNC211 5559P1

~RiiirilyenlcHUffi~~8CrW~r Bid PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

8DdMARD _ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FL O RIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Fort Lauderdale

Contact Name Rares Patrica PE Title Senior Project Mgr Reference date os1021201s

Contact Email RPetricafortlauderdalegov Contact Phone 9548287150

Name of Referenced Project Stormwater Master Planning and Design Implementation Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

256-11660 04192016 to 04192021 $ 989400000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

vyould you use this vendor again Sves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor The Hazen team Is responsible for delivery of a new stormwaler master plan model a prlorlllzed slormwaterresllency capital Improvements plan and Implementation of designs to address chronic flooding and other slormwater management challenges In the City Primary work tasks Include data collectlon hydrologlclhydraullc modeling and design permitting and construction services for capllal Improvement projects resulting from the revised stormwater master plan (preltmlnary design In seven priority neighborhoods)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION ~R COUNTY USE ONLY

aJ~Verified via pound MA IL _VERBAL Verified by Division W1~tl Date 5 ~3o~ax l S N I informallon p roviltled lo Broward County is sulljecl lo verification Vendor altknowledjj6s lhal inaccurate unlMhlut or lncotreci statements m ade In support of this respon$e may be used by tho

412~-~ rejeclion rescission of the award or termination ol lhe contracl and may also serve as lhe basis for debalment ol Vendor purwant to Section 21119 ol lhe Broward Cou~ 4 3

5232018 Bid Sync p25

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 Br~~~~~rs Bid PNC2115559P1 County t ommissioners

B~uWARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FlOR I CA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

Solicitation PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and s OrganizationFirm Name p

Town of Jupiter

nee

Contact Email davidbjupiterflus Contact Phone (561) 746-5134

Name of Referenced Project Engineering Services for Stormwater and Water Capital Improvements

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount $ 630000000 W17248 (2017 reselection 1012000 to Present (estimated lee-to-date since contract inception) contract number)

Vendors role in Project IZI Prime Vendor osubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again 0Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Descriotion of services orovided bv Vendor Since 2000 Hazen has served as General Consulfant to the Town or Jupiter As General Stormwater and Water Consullant the firm has provided services related to master planning stormwater planning and modeling design NPDES permilling asset management resiliency ratefinancial analysis plan review and construction oversight Water-related capital projs have involved additional system storage and high-service pumping transmission system improvements and RampR at existing facilities

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Verllied via EMAIL _ VERBAL Division WWC D

fo (J-Vv ~ltIvmiddotj Date 5(30(ipf S

Al lnroimallon pngtYICGd 10 Broward Counly Is sub)oel to v8flrcallon vendlaquo acknowledges lhat Inaccurate unlruthlu~ 0t Jnwrrect slatoments made In support ol this response may be used by the 42~~1~0 rojecllon rescission or Ille award or termination or lhe con~acl bullnd mbully also serve as tho basis r0t debarment of Vendor pursuant lo Socllon 21119 of lho Broward Couw 41

5232018 BidSync p 26

a N ~ IL) IL) N u z a_

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLO RI DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Walter Wernecke RA Title Sr Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email WWERNECKEhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Hollywood Marina Restrooms

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

04152015 to Present 7500000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor OSubconsultanVSubcontractor n ~U t1

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

-0 Vgt Description of services provided by VendorO ~ ~ Q) Structural Design and Construction Inspection Services i co Q m ~- c E c0

i E gt Oo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not () uu Appllcable O

E~ referenced Vendor Improvement iii ~sectoO 1 Vendors Quality of Service B mu a Responsive D D

b Accuracy DD c Deliverables D DD

2 Vendors Organization D Da Staff expertise v D b Professionalism~ D D c Turnover D ~D

3 Timeliness of D a Project b Deliverables D ~

4 Pec~~11~$~hinJ~~qt lfr D D 5 Cooperation with f ~

a Your Firm D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D

Al lnfonn1tion pRgttded IO Brwd Cltgtunly lo 1ubjecl IO ibllon vsor ~middot Iha icl-bullmiddot ~ ir-ect slalemenls mode In _ol lhb _ moy ti used by he County as a basis lot rejecUon rnclnlon cl the eward or tonnlnallan of lhl connct 1nd may bullllo 11 the basis for dobalment of Vendor IQtulnl IO SICllOn 21119 at lhe Broword County Procurement Code

Cl ltraquo I() I() I() N ()

Cl z

BRltJWARD ~ middot COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORl OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Davie

Contact Name Emilio DeSimone Title Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email Emilio_DeSimonedavie-fl gov Contact Phone 954-797-1085

Name of Referenced Project Pavillion 5 Linear Park

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

B-17-123 09152015 to 2700000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor O SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es O No If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

0 Description of services provided by Vendor O Q)

iii c Structural Design and Construction Inspection ServicesoQ

CDi-

0cc E gt=gt E ()Oo O () () Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

ii) -e i- Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 111 cs

B ioO

J 1 Vendors Quality of Service Q ()

a Responsive D D b Accuracy D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization []Ll Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D Dtr

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [g D b Deliverables D D ar D

4 Project completed within budget [1tD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) cgD D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via l EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by ~h~ Division WlI Etgt Date 0 f l~o I 8 All lnformaUon provided lO Broward County Is eubJect 10 verifutlon Vendor ecknOMedgoo that lnaocurote unNlhlul or Incorrect statamenle made In aupl)Ort of this reaponse may be used by lho County et o baampla for rejection realtluion of the award or lermlnallon of tho eon1fllcl ond moy olao aorvo os ho basis for debarmont of Vondor purauenl lo Section 21119 of the Broward Counly Procuremen1 Code

0 0 agt a c () z 0

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Terrence Comiskey AIA Title Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email TCOMISKEYhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Van Buren Parking Garage

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PK 14-053 Nov 2014 to Present 8310000

Vendors role in Project t8(Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

o~ Description of services provided by Vendor 1 Q)ltO c Structural Design and Conslructlon Inspection Services 0 Q

0~Jl ccE l E enOo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

gtshy

uu O Improvement Applicable ffireferenced Vendor

~sect 1 Vendors Quality of Service 1 ~

oOau a Responsive D ~ D b Accuracy B D D

D D [- Dc Deliverables

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tum over D D D g

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ D Subcontractor(s )S ubcons u ltant( s)b D D ~ D

c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D yenj D Additional Comments provide on sdditlonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION ~NTY USE ONLY0

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by kW Division W-1-(i~ Date EJo(a~t8 Al lnform1Uon PltOVlded lo Browald Ccxnty It IUbjoct to vorificallon Vendor eoknowfodgea thal lnaewralt U111MhlJI deg inlaquogtlaquobullel amptal11ants made In eupporl of lhls relj)Onse may be used by Iha Counly es a balls l0t rcfecllon rescfuloltI of tho ew1rd or 1ermtnaU0lt1 ol lhbull conllllCI and may elao urve 11 lho basis for dabarmenl of Vondor pursuanl lo Secllon 21 119 of he erowald COUlly CiProcurement Code

~ N ii

00

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 aOWllrp Commficumlref Bid PNC2116615B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Pompano Beach FL

Contact Name Mr A Randolph Brown Title Utilities Director Reference date April 30 2018

Contact Email randolphbrowncopbflcom Contact Phone 954-545-7043

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 201 o Project Amount fees varied

Multiple

Vendors role in Project IKJ Prime Vendor

to 2018

osubconsultanUSubcontractor

(range $10000shy$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D ~ D D c Deliverables D ~ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D ~ D D b Professionalism D D ~ D C Turnover D El DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ 0 b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D [BJ D n c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [XJ o ~

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed) amp~~it -THIS SECTION ~COUNTY USE ONL y-bullbull

Verified via ~AIL __VERBAL Verified by 1lt4 )~ Division N WE O Date 5 faol Z1 18

All lnformotlon providod to BltownrltI Cou nty it aubjoct O verification VendOr acknowledges that lnaccornto untruthful or incorroct 11atomon1s made in support of this response may be used by tho

411p~~)~~J rojoclion roscissioo ol lho award or 1orroinalion of tho contract and roay also s01vo as lhbull basis f0lt d~arroont of VondOf pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward Cou)l1

Bid Sync p 73

40

5232018

Broward County Board of Bid PNC2116659B 1 County Commissioners

B~aWARD gt1- t COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Loxahatchee River Environmental Control District

Contact Name Mr Kris Dean Title Director of Engineering Reference date May 9 2018

Contact Email krisdeanloxahatcheeriverorg Contact Phone 561-747-5700

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 2001 Project Amount fees varied (range $10000shyMultiple to 2018 $250000)

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IR)Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D ~ D D b Accuracy D 0 D D c Deliverables D IBJ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D IB] D D b Professionalism D ~ D D c Turnover D [8J D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D [8J D D b Deliverables D m D D

4 Project completed within budget D ~ D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D ~ D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D Ii] D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D ~ D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SE~ FOR~USE ONLY

Verified via _lEMAIL __VERBAL Verified by ~lt Division fWeb Date I

All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untrulhful or incorrecl slatements made In support of this response may be used by the lJl~~~l~~jSfiir rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and mll~~~ere as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Co)f 10

Broward County Board of Bid PNC21166$9B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A l

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Lake Worth FL

Contact Name Mr Felipe Lofaso TitleAsst Dir Public-ServicesReference date May 9 2018

Contact Email flofasolakeworthorg Contact Phone 561-586-1720

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contract

Contract No Date Services Provided 2014 Project Amount fees varied Multiple to 2018 (range $10000shy

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Services included multiple municipal engineering projects including survey roadway design utility design and coordination (water wastewater stormwater other) along with project management

Needs Satisfactory Excellent NotPlease rate your experience with the Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D GJ D b Accuracy D D Ii] D c Deliverables D Ii] DD

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [i] D c Turnover D D D [X]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D 0 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [X] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION Fe COUNTY USE ONLrbullbull

Verified via MAIL __VERBAL Verified by Division ~wgtgt Date 5~3ol20t8 All information provided to Broward County Is subject lo verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect slalements made in support ol this response may be used by the

OZ~id~~~~j~r rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and m~~~(iirve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Cour~ iG

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - ARCADIS US INC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts

VS0000013130 VS00013130 - ARCADIS US INC Prime Work Auth Vendor SummaryProjects

PURCHASING 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold Procurement No Fixed Contracts FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Favorites Past 5 Years Prime Vendor

Sub Vendor From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 10042017 Purchase Order

Evaluation Purchase Orders 1 POs With A Total Amt Of $20000000 Log Off Paid To Dt ($12132949) Balance $7867051

Contracts Purchase Orders Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx 6192018

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Finish

PURCHASING Weighted Scores Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract FileRoom DashBoard Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number FileRoom Insert

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel Favorites Prime Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Service Evaluation

6132017 YES 486 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Goals Compliance Evaluation

10272016 YES 460 View Docs (0)

6272018

Project Management Information System

Close

Contracts Central Administration

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9130 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-24

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6182018 YES 355 View Docs (1)

Proj Nbr 9320 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-20

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6132018 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9290 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-23

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1122018 YES 494 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-21

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12182017 YES 488 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10162017 YES 473 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

8252017 YES 495 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9321 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-19

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

7112017 YES 476 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-17

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2272017 YES 400 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

10132016 YES 384 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-12

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

5202016 YES 405 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9018 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-06

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10192015 YES 448 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

3202015 YES 385 View Docs (0)

Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL CONSULTANTS

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Project Management Information System

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-04

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12122014 YES 437 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-08

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1242014 YES 423 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-02

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2282014 YES 452 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC

VC0000044184 VC00044184 - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres PS $001 Used $000 Remain $001 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $354848400 Closed 0 Total $000 Total Current Retainage Balance For All Contracts $793370 No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 06292015 Purchase Orders 2 POs With A Total Amt Of $362317900 Paid To Dt ($218795160) Balance $143522740

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 40803 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9058 - DISTRICT 3A POTABLE WATER STORAGE

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1220410P1 - Consultant Engineering Services for Potable Water FixedOpen Contracts Storage Tanks and Pumping Systems Work Auth Prime Vendor CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Periodic Final Finish

Log Off Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type

Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

6232015 8302017 413 Approved 8312017 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard

Enter Vendor Name (or a portion of) Then Click Search - Wilcards Are Permitted (ie wa wawainc) Florida Technical Consultants

Search Reset Finish

No Vendors Found For Your Search Try Again

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41005 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score Go

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0773

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

12122017 YES 430 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

8302016 YES 438 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Final Consultant Evaluation 3142016 YES 478 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0706

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

142016 YES 402 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9016OES - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0731

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

10192015 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0748

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

612015 YES 467 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

2192015 YES 500 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0754

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

252015 YES 409 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0755

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

1242014 YES 415 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8974 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0758

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

6202014 YES 393 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr

WATER amp WASTEWATER

Final Consultant Work Authorization 572014 YES 423 View Docs

(0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

HS0746 ENGINEERING Evaluation

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

4302014 YES 475 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Evaluation 4302014 YES 493 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0710

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

3172014 YES 395 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0753

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

1212014 YES 380 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0763

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

11192013 YES 450 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0775

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 408 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals

Finish

Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed FileRoom DashBoard Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization FileRoom Insert NumberFavorites

Prime Vendor Export To Excel Sub Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0772

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 417 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0771

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

2262013 YES 410 View Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 10: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 10 of 12

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Will Comply None Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

Additional Information

Arcadis US Inc had one violation 2011 - Robert Daoust Principal Scientist Malcolm PirnieArcadis US Inc

Additional Information In response to the Purchasing Directorrsquos Draft Memorandum to which the vendor can respond within 48 hours to any comments or deficiencies noted in the Purchasing DirectorrsquosDraft Memorandum Arcadis US Inc provided information that the cone of silence violationwas from a former employee

G VOLUME OF PREVIOUS WORK - EVALUATION CRITERIA ANDOR TIE BREAK CRITERIA The solicitation states that a number of points will be allocated for volume of previous work of the firm for the past five (5) years The volume of work for each of the proposing firms is as follows

Name of Firm Proposer Reported County Reported Points Allocated

Arcadis US Inc $24988700 $9597102 5 Points

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

$477974497 $477974497 3 Points

Carollo Engineers Inc $214076903 $214076903 5 Points

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

$000 $000 5 Points

Hazen and Sawyer PC

$2164284300 $2221320722 0 Points

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

$5894000 $5894030 5 Points

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

$000 $000 5 Points

Additional Information

5 points allocated to vendors paid $0 to $3000000 3 points allocated to vendors paid $3000001 to $7500000 1 point allocated to vendors paid $7500001 to $10000000 0 points allocated to vendors paid over $10000000

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 11 of 12

H PRINCIPAL BUSINESS LOCATION The solicitation states that a number of points will be allocated for location of the firm The Vendorrsquos principal address in Broward County shall be the Vendorrsquos ldquoPrincipal Addressrdquo as indicated with the Florida Department of State Division of Corporations for at least six (6) months prior to the solicitationrsquos due date A proposer with a principal business location within Broward County will receive five (5) points A proposer not having its principal business location within Broward County will receive zero (0) points

The results are as Proposed Attested Location Verified Points Allocated followsName of Nerve Center in SunBiz Firm

Arcadis US Inc 630 Plaza Drive Suite 10 YES 0 Highlands Ranch CO

Brown and Caldwell 201 North Civic Drive YES 0 (Corporation) Suite 300

Walnut Creek CA

Carollo Engineers 2700 Ygnacio Valley YES 0 Inc Road Suite 300

Walnut Creek CA

Florida Technical 533 East Ocean Avenue YES 0 Consultants LLC Suite 2

Boynton Beach FL

Hazen and Sawyer 4000 Hollywood YES 5 PC Boulevard Suite 750

North Hollywood FL

LakdasYohalem 2211 NE 54th Street YES 5 Engineering Inc Fort Lauderdale FL

Baxter amp Woodman 477 S Rosemary Avenue YES 0 Inc dba Mathews Suite 330 Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company West Palm Beach FL

Additional Information In response to the Purchasing Directorrsquos Draft Memorandum to which the vendor canrespond within 48 hours to any comments or deficiencies noted in the Purchasing Directorrsquos Draft Memorandum Hazen and Sawyer PC principal address as verified in Sunbiz is 4000Hollywood Blvd Suite 750N Hollywood FL 33021

I LOCAL PREFERENCE A vendor is eligible to be considered a local business for Local Preference purposes if it has a physical business address located within the limits of Broward County The vendor must provide a valid business tax receipt issued by Broward County at least one (1) year prior to bid or proposal opening

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 12 of 12

Broward Countyrsquos Local Preference Ordinance specifically excludes the application of a local preference for professional services procured pursuant to Section 287055 FS (CCNA)

J LOCATION - TIE BREAKER A Vendor located within Broward County is eligible for the Location Tie Breaker The County requires a copy of the Broward County Business Tax receipt for a period of time of at least six (6) months prior to the solicitation deadline and it must be provided with its initial submittal

The results are as follows

Name of Firm Eligibility Broward County Tax Receipt

Arcadis US Inc Eligible Provided

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

Eligible Provided

Carollo Engineers Inc Eligible Provided

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

Eligible Provided

Hazen and Sawyer PC Eligible Provided

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

Eligible Provided

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

Eligible Provided

Attachments 1 Vendor Reference Verifications 2 Vendor Performance Evaluations 3 Vendor Responses to Draft Memo

c Bob Melton County Auditor Office of the County Auditor Robert Wilson Title Division Department (Project Manager) Martha Perez-Garviso Purchasing Manager Purchasing Division Finance and Administrative Services Department Glenn Miller Assistant County Attorney Office of the County Attorney Fernando Amuchastegui Assistant County Attorney Office of the County Attorney

BJBGMnomm

Broward County Board of PNC211 5559P1 County Commissioners

BRCWARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LO ~ I DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P 1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis us Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

South Florida Water Management District

Contact Name Rich V irgil PE Title Bureau Chief lnfrabReference date 05142018

Contact Email rvirgilsfwmdgov Contact Phone 561 6826759

Name of Referenced Project S-193 Lock Refurbishment C-41A Canal Bank Stabilization Lake

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

4600000790 1001 2008 UP 12012016 $ 295400000

Vendors role in Project ]rime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Engineering Design and Engineering Services During Construction

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D [] DD c Deliverables []D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [L] D c Turnover D D D0

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget []D D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm [L]D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D 0 D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [] D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via ~AI L VERBAL Verified by ~~ Division WWfD Date ltQamp~(8 All lnformallon provided to Bltoward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate unlrulhful or incorrect statements made In support of this response may be used by the

512gt~11MlflS a lgtasis Of rejection rescission of the award or tenninallon of the contract and ~~lVcrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 of lhe Broward Count~ 41l6tlrelfient Code Y fTmiddot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BR~ltJWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LO R I DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering SeNices for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Saint Petersburg Department of Engineering and Capital Planning

Contact Name Nicole Allen Title CADDGIS Supervi Reference date

Contact Email nicoleallenstpeteorg Contact Phone 727-893-7316

Name of Referenced Project Water Resources Department GIS Data Migration

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

13-03-ARCIT 12092014 UP 09152015 $ 5925000

Vendors role in Project ]rime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again (Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Migration ofwater wastewater and storm water infrastructure information from CAD environment to Esri Local Government Information Model

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D [] D c Deliverables D [] D D

2 Vendors Organization [ZJa Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D [ZJ D c Turnover D D [] D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [ZJ D b Deliverables D D [ZJ D

4 Project completed within budget [ZJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [ZJ D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) [ZJD D D c Regu latory Agency(ies) D D [ZJ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONL rbullbull

Verified via L L VERBAL Verified by Division NlltE~ Date 6(~oatgt 1 8~ All information PfOvided to Bfoward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful oc inCOfrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

512gt9lillll jS a basis 10lt rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and nlll~9rrcrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of lhe Broward Cou~ 42fldtclrhtflent Code middot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BRuWARD1 1 COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering SeNices for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

C ity of Tavares F lorida

Contact Name James Dillon Title Public Works DireltaReference date 05172018

Contact Email jdillontavaresorg Contact Phone 352-455-7718

Name of Referenced Project G IS Modeling and Integration of Utilities Infrastructure

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

060330480000 04012017 UP 10012017 $ 5676000

Vendors role in Project ]rime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Integrate drawings and images depicting pipe infrastructure into a GIS environment for easy retrieval First project of a multi phase program to upgrade the Citys GIS information

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D 0 D c Deliverables D D 0 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D Ill D b Professionalism D D Ill D c Turnover D D 0 D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D Ill D b Deliverables D D Ill D

4 Project completed within budget D D Ill D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D Ill D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D Ill D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY -

Ve rified via L IL VERBAL Verified by fcAJ~ Division llt E1) Date 1 r~ tjlQ t8 All information pwvlded to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incooect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

512G91JlIHIS a basis for rejection rescission or the award or termination or the contract and lnfli~9ncrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 of the Broward CouI)~ 44flamplrelflent Code

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BRd~WARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LO R I DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Miramar

Contact Name Robin E Bain PE Title Project Manager Reference date 05142018

Contact Email rebainmiramarflgov Contact Phone 9548836825

Name of Referenced Project East Water Treatment Plant Replacement Wells and Design-Build

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PO 172624-00 10222017 UP 05142018 $ 56929600

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [ZJYes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Design permitting construction services for new Deep Injection Well and 4 new (replacement) production wells

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy []D D D c Deliverables D []D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D [ZJ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Turnover D D D []

3 Timeliness of a Project D D lZ1 D b Del iverables D D lZ1 D

4 Project completed within budget D D lZ1 D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor( s)Subconsultant( s) D D lZ1 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D lZ1 D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY (

Verified via A IL VER BAL Verified by faltJ~ Division WltEtgt Date 5 ~io l 9 All inlOllllalion pltovided to Broward County is subjecl lo verificalioo VendOt acknowledges lhal lnaccurale unlrulhful or i ncooecl stalemenls made in suppOltI of lhis response may be used by lhe

512gt~llM (lS a basis lot rejeclion rescission of the award or termination of lhe contract and mll~Arrcrve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuanl 10 Section 21119 of lhe Broward Couoty 43Pldtllrbrllent Code Y flmiddot

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Palm Beach County Water Utilities Department

Contact Name Ali Bayat Title Assistant Director Reference date

Contact Email abayatpbcwatercom Contact Phone 561 493 6128

Name of Referenced Project System 8 Water Quality Assessment

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

17-021 CSA21 01 022017 to 01152018 $ 8936000

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again (Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Brown and Caldwell led assessment of contributing causes to low system residuals troubleshooting treatment processes special testing and data analysis improvements to operating protocols monitoringcontrol system and treatment process

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [Z] D b Accuracy D [Z] DD c Deliverables D [Z]D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D [Z] D b Professionalism D D [Z] D c Turnover D [Z] DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D [Z] D

4 Project completed within budget D D [Z] D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Consultant worked collaboratively with operating maintenance engineering and laboratory staff to develop insight into contributing factors and implement improvements

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via _LEMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by tcltJ1~ Division -+LN euro P Date lteh IWt 8 All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the County as a basis for rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and may also serve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward County Procurement Code

BltaWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F L 0 R I D A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood Florida

Contact Name Steve Joseph Title Director Reference date

Contact Email sjosephhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954 921 3522

Name of Referenced Project Distribution System Water Quality Improvement

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

01012016 to 06022017 $ 3000000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again []Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Supported the City with its efforts improve chlorine residuals in areas of its system Analysis included system modeling monitoring optimized operational practices Implemented operational improvements that significantly raised (from approx 05 to 20 mgL) chloramine residuals In the most challenging area of the system

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D D [] D c Deliverables []D D D

2 Vendors Organization [] Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D [] D c Turnover D D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D [] D

4 Project completed within budget []D D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) []D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [] D

Additional Com ments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Effort Included system modoling moniloring and excursion response procedures opllmitallon of stored Inventory management unidirectional flushing pilot assessment and treatment proooss evaluation

Verified via __EMAIL vERBAL Division WW ED Date G Ifgt I 8 All infonmallon pltovided to Broward County Is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of thi s response may be used by lhe County as a basis for rejeclion rescission or the award or tenminatlon of the contract and may also serve as the basis for debanment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 or lhe Broward County Procurement Code

BROWARD t (l)t~ 1 Vendor Reference Verification Form

fl O R I OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of West Palm Beach Florida

Contact Name Jay Kwag Title Project Manager Reference date

Contact Email hjkwagwpborg Contact Phone 561 494 1041

Name of Referenced Project Modeling and Infrastructure General Engineering Consulting Assigments

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

11032014 to HAlt zc1e (on~vi~)

Vendors role in Project 52fPrime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IQves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Planning and General Eng1neerg Servicus 1nctuslve ol Waterwastewater System Master Pian asset management program dovo10pmenV11sset Crt1tcat1ty assessment Mesler PS 115 and sewer cond1hon assessment hydrauhc modeling ol LS 5 and force main sizing water system Capacity Analysis RoPort nydraullc modeling ol operahonat challongos tilt ste11on enatysbulls lac11i1a1e 1nspec11011 or major FM and new develOpmenl 1mpnc1s plpohno design lilt station condbullhon assessment and renabtlilahon (Various ProJecls)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D 0 D b Accuracy D 0D D c Deliverables D D 0 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D Gt D b Professionalism D D ~-- D c Turnover D D Gr D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D B D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget D D r~r D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D c~r D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D 0 D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION F~USE ONLY

__VERBAL Verified via LMAIL Verified by ~J Division ~~~D Date ~ f 2 f~t8 All lnfo11na1t0n pr ()Vl(fed 10 Broward County is svb1et110 ven11ca1ion vendor acknowledges lhll 1naeoura10 unlrulhful 0lt inc0ltrec1 s1a1emen1s medo In support ol 1n1s response may be used Dy the County as a basis fcu rejection re sclsst0n Of 1ho award or 1ormina1lon of l he contract and may also servo as the basis for debarment o f Vendor pursuant lo Section 21 119 of tho ampoward Counly P1ocuremont Code

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A middot

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Michael Low Title Deputy Director Reference date 05172018

Contact Email lowmbbflus Contact Phone 5617426403

Name of Referenced Project Ion Exchange Design Build

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

07022014 to 03212018 $ 100000000

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Carollo handled all of the design and construction of a significant part of the project as a subcontractor to COM Constructors as part of a progressive design build contract

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [Z] D b Accuracy D D [Z] D c Deliverables D D [Z] D

2 Vendors Organization D D [Z] Da Staff expertise b Professionalism D D [Z] D c Turnover D D D [Z]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D [Z] D

4 Project completed within budget D D [Z] D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D [Z] D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [Z] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION F~ COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ~~ Division W -NED Date S-gtozot~ All Information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor aclltnowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

Stii191111X 11s a basis for rejection rescission of the award or termination or the conlact and m~~Arifrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward CounYJ 33Plamptl1til1ent Code Y Imiddot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

B~OWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LORID A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

South Florida Water Management District

Contact Name Greg Coffelt PE Title SFWMD Project Manager Reference date 05172018

Contact Email gcoffeltsfwmdgov Contact Phone 561-682-6853

Name of Referenced Project L-8 Reservoir Inflow Structure and Pump Station

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

4600000861 02152011 to 09192012 $ 144535100

Vendors role in Project [l) Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [l)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Corolla was contracted as an Owners Advisor for a Design-Build contract developed engineering design criteria assisted in RFQ development and evaluation supported RFP technical proposal and cost proposal analysis

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [l] D b Accuracy D [] D D c Deliverables D [] D D

2 Vendors Organization [l]a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D [l] D c Turnover D D D [l]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [l] D b Deliverables D [l] D D

4 Project completed within budget [l] DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [l] D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) [l] DD D c Regu latory Agency(ies) D D D [l]

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Owner Advisor work continued(s) in support of Construction of Pump Station Inflow Gate Structure and levee hardening

Verified via IMAIL __VERBAL Date 5 ( 3 c b() I a All information piovided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that Inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made In support of this response may be used by the

512G9JiIX 11s a basis for rejection rescission or the award or termination or the contract and rllffl~Anampe as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 or the Broward CojlftYi 34~6ttlrbtflent Code Y

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

B0~~AARD ~~t~UNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

Fl ORIOA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Sunrise

Contact Name Luisa Fernanda Arbelaa Title Project Manager Reference date 05162018

Contact Email LArbelaezsunrlseflgov Contact Phone 954-888-6009

Name of Referenced Project City of Sunrise - Springtree WTP Water Stabilization and Solids Handling

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PA 16-003-CE 04072016 to 05292018 $ 50797800

Vendors role in Project ]Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [l]Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Carollo Engineers performed the design study and construction administration services for the City

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D G6 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Carollo Engineers technical knowledge and attenllon lo detall were beneficial lo the pltojad They ecled in lhe C~ys besl Interest In every aspect for lhe d1K8Uon of the projectbull

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via ~MAIL _VERBAL Verified by fc4J~~ Division W fl ED All lnrormalion provided to Broward ltAunty Is oobjoci to vorirtcotion Vendoc ecknowledgu that 1naowrate unlMhfuf 0lt lncocrecl statements rnado In support or this response may be useltI by lhe County as a basis for rejection rescission or the award 0lt termination ol the convect and may also ampOIVe as the babullibull ror debarmont of vondOlt purauont to Section 21119 or the Broward County Proc11oment Code

Bid Sync p 135 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BftQNARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

I l 0 R I 0 A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Florida Technical Consultants

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

VIiiage of Wellington Utilities

Contact Name Bradley Wolak Title Assistant Director Ut11Reference date 5182018

Contact Email bwolakwelllngtonflgov Contact Phone 561-753-2480

Name of Referenced Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 10012017 to Present 3500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vend~ 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again UZfYes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor J_ rJ fJ j(Gr-~k 6 Jti ov1 ~uf-Jiy fgt-r_- syrrzi~ff~ Al

R Q_ d--1 0~l 4 171 i+CI ~~lHI )Please rate your experience with tile Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Applicablereferenced Vendor Improvement

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy B D

DD c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D Db Professionalism D D

c Turnover D DD 3 Timeliness of

a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant(s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Additional Comments (provide on addltjpnal sheetJf needed) bull ~middot$ -JJ fo~~rltjbull lt( c-c_ ~~~ lt fo L1-lfAR- -middot~ I 10 ~ ~

~ bullL ~~ _te_ l~Ilgt~Cef t J ~ l rfbull4 middot r0 laquo r 4111J w f1 rrr- 0r- -i-HIS SECTION(9R COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by fcAJc ~ Division Y-1 IN ED Date 5 ~o w8 All lnfonn1Uon ptollfded to BlOward County le eubjeet to vetfflcatlon Vendor aclltnowledge1 that lneccurale unllJlhfUl or lnconect -bullmenla made In 1UPPort o1 this reopon90 may be uoec1 by the couniy ae a baalS ror re)ectlon re8Claeton Of the award 0t leltmlnatlon Of the contract and may 1l10 MM ae the baale flaquo debarrnont 01 vendor pu11uant to Section 21119 of ll1e Broward County Procurement Codo

BidSync p 18 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F LUFltIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultants LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Palm Beach Public Works

Contact Name Gerry Vazquez Title WRD Technician Reference date 05182018

Contact Email gvazqueztownofpalmbeachcom Contact Phone 772-546-6859

Name of Referenced Project GIS Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 3242014 to Present 13500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [3yenes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

PrwAamprs- favl49z Please rate your experience with the Need a Satlafactory Excellent Not

Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D g- D b Accuracy D Er D c Deliverables g-shyB D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D GJ D b Professionalism D D G- D c Tu mover D D cg- D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D g D b Deliverables D D Qshy D

4 Project completed within budget D D lbJ- D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D El- Db Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [3- D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

BidSync p 17 51232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

120-nWARDLll~ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form fLORllgtA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultant LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Waneya Bryant Title Meter Serv Mgr Reference date 05182018

Contact Email BryantWbbflus Contact Phone 561-742-6427

Name of Referenced Project Boynton Beach Utility GIS Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 12012016 to Present $15000000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

~T~ 5e-r-vtleamp +roM l)h f-es Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D Dc Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ti4 D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ Db Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on addlUonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION~urv USE ONLy u bull

Verified via VEMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by kuJ~ Division W if E D rao(ao8Date 5

All Information provided to Browslaquo COOlty Is Slbject to verfflcation Vendor acKnowledges that lneocurate Untruthful or lncolleel 8tatements made In support d this rfl9pOn98 may be used by 1119 Counly as a batia falt rejection relduion ct Ille award or lemilnlilon of the contract and may al80181Veaa1119 basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 ot Ille Broward CountyProcurement Code

512312018 BidSync p 16

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1

8W1V~isl1War Bid PNC21 15559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Fonn

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Cooper City - middot

Contact Name Michael Bailey PE itle Utilities DlrCity EbullReference date 05011201s

Contact Email MBalleycoopercityflorg Contact Phone (954) 434-5519

Name of Referenced Project City of Cooper City Continuing Professional Services bullContract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

RFQ 2009middot 1 04242009 to Present $ 2 19844200

Vendors role in Project IZJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Since 2009 Hazen has provided Cooper City with engineering services or water and wastewater projects Projects have lnctudeo lhe Pine Island Road Pump Station Lilt S1alions 2 amp 49 Improvements Master Plan Update of the FeaslJl~lty Review of Infrastructure Improvements tor Wastewater and the Eflluent Reuse and Disposal Master Plan

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy 8 D

D ~ D c Deliverables D 0 ~ D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D 0 D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tumover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D GJ- D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D 0 D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) ~D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

bull-rHIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY-

Verified vie EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ct4~ Division ~tUb Date ~ i3~) 0fgt All Information provided to BltCgtWW County 11 wbed ID vamprificalion Velldot adltnowledgu that lnaoewate unlrUhful lncom1ct statemampnla made in wppolt of 11111 response may blt uHd by the

4t2j=~ rejection rHclsslcn of th8 award or lennhallon of Ille eoo1nlct and may also seNamp at tilt basis for dtbarmenl at Vendor puuan1 lo Sectioo 21119 of the Broward COltJi 43

5232018 Bid Sync p24

Broward County Board of PNC211 5559P1

~RiiirilyenlcHUffi~~8CrW~r Bid PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

8DdMARD _ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FL O RIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Fort Lauderdale

Contact Name Rares Patrica PE Title Senior Project Mgr Reference date os1021201s

Contact Email RPetricafortlauderdalegov Contact Phone 9548287150

Name of Referenced Project Stormwater Master Planning and Design Implementation Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

256-11660 04192016 to 04192021 $ 989400000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

vyould you use this vendor again Sves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor The Hazen team Is responsible for delivery of a new stormwaler master plan model a prlorlllzed slormwaterresllency capital Improvements plan and Implementation of designs to address chronic flooding and other slormwater management challenges In the City Primary work tasks Include data collectlon hydrologlclhydraullc modeling and design permitting and construction services for capllal Improvement projects resulting from the revised stormwater master plan (preltmlnary design In seven priority neighborhoods)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION ~R COUNTY USE ONLY

aJ~Verified via pound MA IL _VERBAL Verified by Division W1~tl Date 5 ~3o~ax l S N I informallon p roviltled lo Broward County is sulljecl lo verification Vendor altknowledjj6s lhal inaccurate unlMhlut or lncotreci statements m ade In support of this respon$e may be used by tho

412~-~ rejeclion rescission of the award or termination ol lhe contracl and may also serve as lhe basis for debalment ol Vendor purwant to Section 21119 ol lhe Broward Cou~ 4 3

5232018 Bid Sync p25

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 Br~~~~~rs Bid PNC2115559P1 County t ommissioners

B~uWARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FlOR I CA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

Solicitation PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and s OrganizationFirm Name p

Town of Jupiter

nee

Contact Email davidbjupiterflus Contact Phone (561) 746-5134

Name of Referenced Project Engineering Services for Stormwater and Water Capital Improvements

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount $ 630000000 W17248 (2017 reselection 1012000 to Present (estimated lee-to-date since contract inception) contract number)

Vendors role in Project IZI Prime Vendor osubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again 0Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Descriotion of services orovided bv Vendor Since 2000 Hazen has served as General Consulfant to the Town or Jupiter As General Stormwater and Water Consullant the firm has provided services related to master planning stormwater planning and modeling design NPDES permilling asset management resiliency ratefinancial analysis plan review and construction oversight Water-related capital projs have involved additional system storage and high-service pumping transmission system improvements and RampR at existing facilities

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Verllied via EMAIL _ VERBAL Division WWC D

fo (J-Vv ~ltIvmiddotj Date 5(30(ipf S

Al lnroimallon pngtYICGd 10 Broward Counly Is sub)oel to v8flrcallon vendlaquo acknowledges lhat Inaccurate unlruthlu~ 0t Jnwrrect slatoments made In support ol this response may be used by the 42~~1~0 rojecllon rescission or Ille award or termination or lhe con~acl bullnd mbully also serve as tho basis r0t debarment of Vendor pursuant lo Socllon 21119 of lho Broward Couw 41

5232018 BidSync p 26

a N ~ IL) IL) N u z a_

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLO RI DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Walter Wernecke RA Title Sr Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email WWERNECKEhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Hollywood Marina Restrooms

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

04152015 to Present 7500000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor OSubconsultanVSubcontractor n ~U t1

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

-0 Vgt Description of services provided by VendorO ~ ~ Q) Structural Design and Construction Inspection Services i co Q m ~- c E c0

i E gt Oo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not () uu Appllcable O

E~ referenced Vendor Improvement iii ~sectoO 1 Vendors Quality of Service B mu a Responsive D D

b Accuracy DD c Deliverables D DD

2 Vendors Organization D Da Staff expertise v D b Professionalism~ D D c Turnover D ~D

3 Timeliness of D a Project b Deliverables D ~

4 Pec~~11~$~hinJ~~qt lfr D D 5 Cooperation with f ~

a Your Firm D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D

Al lnfonn1tion pRgttded IO Brwd Cltgtunly lo 1ubjecl IO ibllon vsor ~middot Iha icl-bullmiddot ~ ir-ect slalemenls mode In _ol lhb _ moy ti used by he County as a basis lot rejecUon rnclnlon cl the eward or tonnlnallan of lhl connct 1nd may bullllo 11 the basis for dobalment of Vendor IQtulnl IO SICllOn 21119 at lhe Broword County Procurement Code

Cl ltraquo I() I() I() N ()

Cl z

BRltJWARD ~ middot COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORl OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Davie

Contact Name Emilio DeSimone Title Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email Emilio_DeSimonedavie-fl gov Contact Phone 954-797-1085

Name of Referenced Project Pavillion 5 Linear Park

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

B-17-123 09152015 to 2700000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor O SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es O No If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

0 Description of services provided by Vendor O Q)

iii c Structural Design and Construction Inspection ServicesoQ

CDi-

0cc E gt=gt E ()Oo O () () Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

ii) -e i- Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 111 cs

B ioO

J 1 Vendors Quality of Service Q ()

a Responsive D D b Accuracy D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization []Ll Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D Dtr

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [g D b Deliverables D D ar D

4 Project completed within budget [1tD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) cgD D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via l EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by ~h~ Division WlI Etgt Date 0 f l~o I 8 All lnformaUon provided lO Broward County Is eubJect 10 verifutlon Vendor ecknOMedgoo that lnaocurote unNlhlul or Incorrect statamenle made In aupl)Ort of this reaponse may be used by lho County et o baampla for rejection realtluion of the award or lermlnallon of tho eon1fllcl ond moy olao aorvo os ho basis for debarmont of Vondor purauenl lo Section 21119 of the Broward Counly Procuremen1 Code

0 0 agt a c () z 0

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Terrence Comiskey AIA Title Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email TCOMISKEYhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Van Buren Parking Garage

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PK 14-053 Nov 2014 to Present 8310000

Vendors role in Project t8(Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

o~ Description of services provided by Vendor 1 Q)ltO c Structural Design and Conslructlon Inspection Services 0 Q

0~Jl ccE l E enOo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

gtshy

uu O Improvement Applicable ffireferenced Vendor

~sect 1 Vendors Quality of Service 1 ~

oOau a Responsive D ~ D b Accuracy B D D

D D [- Dc Deliverables

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tum over D D D g

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ D Subcontractor(s )S ubcons u ltant( s)b D D ~ D

c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D yenj D Additional Comments provide on sdditlonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION ~NTY USE ONLY0

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by kW Division W-1-(i~ Date EJo(a~t8 Al lnform1Uon PltOVlded lo Browald Ccxnty It IUbjoct to vorificallon Vendor eoknowfodgea thal lnaewralt U111MhlJI deg inlaquogtlaquobullel amptal11ants made In eupporl of lhls relj)Onse may be used by Iha Counly es a balls l0t rcfecllon rescfuloltI of tho ew1rd or 1ermtnaU0lt1 ol lhbull conllllCI and may elao urve 11 lho basis for dabarmenl of Vondor pursuanl lo Secllon 21 119 of he erowald COUlly CiProcurement Code

~ N ii

00

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 aOWllrp Commficumlref Bid PNC2116615B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Pompano Beach FL

Contact Name Mr A Randolph Brown Title Utilities Director Reference date April 30 2018

Contact Email randolphbrowncopbflcom Contact Phone 954-545-7043

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 201 o Project Amount fees varied

Multiple

Vendors role in Project IKJ Prime Vendor

to 2018

osubconsultanUSubcontractor

(range $10000shy$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D ~ D D c Deliverables D ~ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D ~ D D b Professionalism D D ~ D C Turnover D El DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ 0 b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D [BJ D n c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [XJ o ~

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed) amp~~it -THIS SECTION ~COUNTY USE ONL y-bullbull

Verified via ~AIL __VERBAL Verified by 1lt4 )~ Division N WE O Date 5 faol Z1 18

All lnformotlon providod to BltownrltI Cou nty it aubjoct O verification VendOr acknowledges that lnaccornto untruthful or incorroct 11atomon1s made in support of this response may be used by tho

411p~~)~~J rojoclion roscissioo ol lho award or 1orroinalion of tho contract and roay also s01vo as lhbull basis f0lt d~arroont of VondOf pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward Cou)l1

Bid Sync p 73

40

5232018

Broward County Board of Bid PNC2116659B 1 County Commissioners

B~aWARD gt1- t COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Loxahatchee River Environmental Control District

Contact Name Mr Kris Dean Title Director of Engineering Reference date May 9 2018

Contact Email krisdeanloxahatcheeriverorg Contact Phone 561-747-5700

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 2001 Project Amount fees varied (range $10000shyMultiple to 2018 $250000)

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IR)Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D ~ D D b Accuracy D 0 D D c Deliverables D IBJ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D IB] D D b Professionalism D ~ D D c Turnover D [8J D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D [8J D D b Deliverables D m D D

4 Project completed within budget D ~ D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D ~ D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D Ii] D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D ~ D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SE~ FOR~USE ONLY

Verified via _lEMAIL __VERBAL Verified by ~lt Division fWeb Date I

All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untrulhful or incorrecl slatements made In support of this response may be used by the lJl~~~l~~jSfiir rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and mll~~~ere as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Co)f 10

Broward County Board of Bid PNC21166$9B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A l

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Lake Worth FL

Contact Name Mr Felipe Lofaso TitleAsst Dir Public-ServicesReference date May 9 2018

Contact Email flofasolakeworthorg Contact Phone 561-586-1720

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contract

Contract No Date Services Provided 2014 Project Amount fees varied Multiple to 2018 (range $10000shy

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Services included multiple municipal engineering projects including survey roadway design utility design and coordination (water wastewater stormwater other) along with project management

Needs Satisfactory Excellent NotPlease rate your experience with the Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D GJ D b Accuracy D D Ii] D c Deliverables D Ii] DD

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [i] D c Turnover D D D [X]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D 0 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [X] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION Fe COUNTY USE ONLrbullbull

Verified via MAIL __VERBAL Verified by Division ~wgtgt Date 5~3ol20t8 All information provided to Broward County Is subject lo verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect slalements made in support ol this response may be used by the

OZ~id~~~~j~r rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and m~~~(iirve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Cour~ iG

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - ARCADIS US INC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts

VS0000013130 VS00013130 - ARCADIS US INC Prime Work Auth Vendor SummaryProjects

PURCHASING 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold Procurement No Fixed Contracts FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Favorites Past 5 Years Prime Vendor

Sub Vendor From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 10042017 Purchase Order

Evaluation Purchase Orders 1 POs With A Total Amt Of $20000000 Log Off Paid To Dt ($12132949) Balance $7867051

Contracts Purchase Orders Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx 6192018

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Finish

PURCHASING Weighted Scores Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract FileRoom DashBoard Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number FileRoom Insert

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel Favorites Prime Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Service Evaluation

6132017 YES 486 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Goals Compliance Evaluation

10272016 YES 460 View Docs (0)

6272018

Project Management Information System

Close

Contracts Central Administration

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9130 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-24

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6182018 YES 355 View Docs (1)

Proj Nbr 9320 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-20

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6132018 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9290 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-23

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1122018 YES 494 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-21

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12182017 YES 488 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10162017 YES 473 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

8252017 YES 495 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9321 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-19

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

7112017 YES 476 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-17

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2272017 YES 400 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

10132016 YES 384 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-12

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

5202016 YES 405 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9018 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-06

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10192015 YES 448 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

3202015 YES 385 View Docs (0)

Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL CONSULTANTS

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Project Management Information System

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-04

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12122014 YES 437 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-08

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1242014 YES 423 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-02

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2282014 YES 452 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC

VC0000044184 VC00044184 - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres PS $001 Used $000 Remain $001 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $354848400 Closed 0 Total $000 Total Current Retainage Balance For All Contracts $793370 No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 06292015 Purchase Orders 2 POs With A Total Amt Of $362317900 Paid To Dt ($218795160) Balance $143522740

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 40803 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9058 - DISTRICT 3A POTABLE WATER STORAGE

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1220410P1 - Consultant Engineering Services for Potable Water FixedOpen Contracts Storage Tanks and Pumping Systems Work Auth Prime Vendor CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Periodic Final Finish

Log Off Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type

Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

6232015 8302017 413 Approved 8312017 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard

Enter Vendor Name (or a portion of) Then Click Search - Wilcards Are Permitted (ie wa wawainc) Florida Technical Consultants

Search Reset Finish

No Vendors Found For Your Search Try Again

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41005 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score Go

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0773

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

12122017 YES 430 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

8302016 YES 438 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Final Consultant Evaluation 3142016 YES 478 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0706

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

142016 YES 402 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9016OES - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0731

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

10192015 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0748

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

612015 YES 467 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

2192015 YES 500 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0754

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

252015 YES 409 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0755

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

1242014 YES 415 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8974 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0758

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

6202014 YES 393 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr

WATER amp WASTEWATER

Final Consultant Work Authorization 572014 YES 423 View Docs

(0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

HS0746 ENGINEERING Evaluation

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

4302014 YES 475 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Evaluation 4302014 YES 493 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0710

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

3172014 YES 395 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0753

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

1212014 YES 380 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0763

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

11192013 YES 450 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0775

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 408 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals

Finish

Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed FileRoom DashBoard Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization FileRoom Insert NumberFavorites

Prime Vendor Export To Excel Sub Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0772

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 417 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0771

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

2262013 YES 410 View Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 11: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 11 of 12

H PRINCIPAL BUSINESS LOCATION The solicitation states that a number of points will be allocated for location of the firm The Vendorrsquos principal address in Broward County shall be the Vendorrsquos ldquoPrincipal Addressrdquo as indicated with the Florida Department of State Division of Corporations for at least six (6) months prior to the solicitationrsquos due date A proposer with a principal business location within Broward County will receive five (5) points A proposer not having its principal business location within Broward County will receive zero (0) points

The results are as Proposed Attested Location Verified Points Allocated followsName of Nerve Center in SunBiz Firm

Arcadis US Inc 630 Plaza Drive Suite 10 YES 0 Highlands Ranch CO

Brown and Caldwell 201 North Civic Drive YES 0 (Corporation) Suite 300

Walnut Creek CA

Carollo Engineers 2700 Ygnacio Valley YES 0 Inc Road Suite 300

Walnut Creek CA

Florida Technical 533 East Ocean Avenue YES 0 Consultants LLC Suite 2

Boynton Beach FL

Hazen and Sawyer 4000 Hollywood YES 5 PC Boulevard Suite 750

North Hollywood FL

LakdasYohalem 2211 NE 54th Street YES 5 Engineering Inc Fort Lauderdale FL

Baxter amp Woodman 477 S Rosemary Avenue YES 0 Inc dba Mathews Suite 330 Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company West Palm Beach FL

Additional Information In response to the Purchasing Directorrsquos Draft Memorandum to which the vendor canrespond within 48 hours to any comments or deficiencies noted in the Purchasing Directorrsquos Draft Memorandum Hazen and Sawyer PC principal address as verified in Sunbiz is 4000Hollywood Blvd Suite 750N Hollywood FL 33021

I LOCAL PREFERENCE A vendor is eligible to be considered a local business for Local Preference purposes if it has a physical business address located within the limits of Broward County The vendor must provide a valid business tax receipt issued by Broward County at least one (1) year prior to bid or proposal opening

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 12 of 12

Broward Countyrsquos Local Preference Ordinance specifically excludes the application of a local preference for professional services procured pursuant to Section 287055 FS (CCNA)

J LOCATION - TIE BREAKER A Vendor located within Broward County is eligible for the Location Tie Breaker The County requires a copy of the Broward County Business Tax receipt for a period of time of at least six (6) months prior to the solicitation deadline and it must be provided with its initial submittal

The results are as follows

Name of Firm Eligibility Broward County Tax Receipt

Arcadis US Inc Eligible Provided

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

Eligible Provided

Carollo Engineers Inc Eligible Provided

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

Eligible Provided

Hazen and Sawyer PC Eligible Provided

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

Eligible Provided

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

Eligible Provided

Attachments 1 Vendor Reference Verifications 2 Vendor Performance Evaluations 3 Vendor Responses to Draft Memo

c Bob Melton County Auditor Office of the County Auditor Robert Wilson Title Division Department (Project Manager) Martha Perez-Garviso Purchasing Manager Purchasing Division Finance and Administrative Services Department Glenn Miller Assistant County Attorney Office of the County Attorney Fernando Amuchastegui Assistant County Attorney Office of the County Attorney

BJBGMnomm

Broward County Board of PNC211 5559P1 County Commissioners

BRCWARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LO ~ I DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P 1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis us Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

South Florida Water Management District

Contact Name Rich V irgil PE Title Bureau Chief lnfrabReference date 05142018

Contact Email rvirgilsfwmdgov Contact Phone 561 6826759

Name of Referenced Project S-193 Lock Refurbishment C-41A Canal Bank Stabilization Lake

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

4600000790 1001 2008 UP 12012016 $ 295400000

Vendors role in Project ]rime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Engineering Design and Engineering Services During Construction

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D [] DD c Deliverables []D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [L] D c Turnover D D D0

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget []D D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm [L]D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D 0 D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [] D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via ~AI L VERBAL Verified by ~~ Division WWfD Date ltQamp~(8 All lnformallon provided to Bltoward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate unlrulhful or incorrect statements made In support of this response may be used by the

512gt~11MlflS a lgtasis Of rejection rescission of the award or tenninallon of the contract and ~~lVcrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 of lhe Broward Count~ 41l6tlrelfient Code Y fTmiddot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BR~ltJWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LO R I DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering SeNices for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Saint Petersburg Department of Engineering and Capital Planning

Contact Name Nicole Allen Title CADDGIS Supervi Reference date

Contact Email nicoleallenstpeteorg Contact Phone 727-893-7316

Name of Referenced Project Water Resources Department GIS Data Migration

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

13-03-ARCIT 12092014 UP 09152015 $ 5925000

Vendors role in Project ]rime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again (Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Migration ofwater wastewater and storm water infrastructure information from CAD environment to Esri Local Government Information Model

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D [] D c Deliverables D [] D D

2 Vendors Organization [ZJa Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D [ZJ D c Turnover D D [] D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [ZJ D b Deliverables D D [ZJ D

4 Project completed within budget [ZJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [ZJ D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) [ZJD D D c Regu latory Agency(ies) D D [ZJ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONL rbullbull

Verified via L L VERBAL Verified by Division NlltE~ Date 6(~oatgt 1 8~ All information PfOvided to Bfoward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful oc inCOfrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

512gt9lillll jS a basis 10lt rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and nlll~9rrcrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of lhe Broward Cou~ 42fldtclrhtflent Code middot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BRuWARD1 1 COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering SeNices for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

C ity of Tavares F lorida

Contact Name James Dillon Title Public Works DireltaReference date 05172018

Contact Email jdillontavaresorg Contact Phone 352-455-7718

Name of Referenced Project G IS Modeling and Integration of Utilities Infrastructure

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

060330480000 04012017 UP 10012017 $ 5676000

Vendors role in Project ]rime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Integrate drawings and images depicting pipe infrastructure into a GIS environment for easy retrieval First project of a multi phase program to upgrade the Citys GIS information

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D 0 D c Deliverables D D 0 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D Ill D b Professionalism D D Ill D c Turnover D D 0 D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D Ill D b Deliverables D D Ill D

4 Project completed within budget D D Ill D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D Ill D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D Ill D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY -

Ve rified via L IL VERBAL Verified by fcAJ~ Division llt E1) Date 1 r~ tjlQ t8 All information pwvlded to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incooect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

512G91JlIHIS a basis for rejection rescission or the award or termination or the contract and lnfli~9ncrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 of the Broward CouI)~ 44flamplrelflent Code

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BRd~WARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LO R I DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Miramar

Contact Name Robin E Bain PE Title Project Manager Reference date 05142018

Contact Email rebainmiramarflgov Contact Phone 9548836825

Name of Referenced Project East Water Treatment Plant Replacement Wells and Design-Build

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PO 172624-00 10222017 UP 05142018 $ 56929600

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [ZJYes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Design permitting construction services for new Deep Injection Well and 4 new (replacement) production wells

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy []D D D c Deliverables D []D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D [ZJ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Turnover D D D []

3 Timeliness of a Project D D lZ1 D b Del iverables D D lZ1 D

4 Project completed within budget D D lZ1 D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor( s)Subconsultant( s) D D lZ1 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D lZ1 D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY (

Verified via A IL VER BAL Verified by faltJ~ Division WltEtgt Date 5 ~io l 9 All inlOllllalion pltovided to Broward County is subjecl lo verificalioo VendOt acknowledges lhal lnaccurale unlrulhful or i ncooecl stalemenls made in suppOltI of lhis response may be used by lhe

512gt~llM (lS a basis lot rejeclion rescission of the award or termination of lhe contract and mll~Arrcrve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuanl 10 Section 21119 of lhe Broward Couoty 43Pldtllrbrllent Code Y flmiddot

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Palm Beach County Water Utilities Department

Contact Name Ali Bayat Title Assistant Director Reference date

Contact Email abayatpbcwatercom Contact Phone 561 493 6128

Name of Referenced Project System 8 Water Quality Assessment

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

17-021 CSA21 01 022017 to 01152018 $ 8936000

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again (Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Brown and Caldwell led assessment of contributing causes to low system residuals troubleshooting treatment processes special testing and data analysis improvements to operating protocols monitoringcontrol system and treatment process

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [Z] D b Accuracy D [Z] DD c Deliverables D [Z]D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D [Z] D b Professionalism D D [Z] D c Turnover D [Z] DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D [Z] D

4 Project completed within budget D D [Z] D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Consultant worked collaboratively with operating maintenance engineering and laboratory staff to develop insight into contributing factors and implement improvements

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via _LEMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by tcltJ1~ Division -+LN euro P Date lteh IWt 8 All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the County as a basis for rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and may also serve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward County Procurement Code

BltaWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F L 0 R I D A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood Florida

Contact Name Steve Joseph Title Director Reference date

Contact Email sjosephhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954 921 3522

Name of Referenced Project Distribution System Water Quality Improvement

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

01012016 to 06022017 $ 3000000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again []Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Supported the City with its efforts improve chlorine residuals in areas of its system Analysis included system modeling monitoring optimized operational practices Implemented operational improvements that significantly raised (from approx 05 to 20 mgL) chloramine residuals In the most challenging area of the system

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D D [] D c Deliverables []D D D

2 Vendors Organization [] Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D [] D c Turnover D D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D [] D

4 Project completed within budget []D D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) []D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [] D

Additional Com ments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Effort Included system modoling moniloring and excursion response procedures opllmitallon of stored Inventory management unidirectional flushing pilot assessment and treatment proooss evaluation

Verified via __EMAIL vERBAL Division WW ED Date G Ifgt I 8 All infonmallon pltovided to Broward County Is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of thi s response may be used by lhe County as a basis for rejeclion rescission or the award or tenminatlon of the contract and may also serve as the basis for debanment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 or lhe Broward County Procurement Code

BROWARD t (l)t~ 1 Vendor Reference Verification Form

fl O R I OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of West Palm Beach Florida

Contact Name Jay Kwag Title Project Manager Reference date

Contact Email hjkwagwpborg Contact Phone 561 494 1041

Name of Referenced Project Modeling and Infrastructure General Engineering Consulting Assigments

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

11032014 to HAlt zc1e (on~vi~)

Vendors role in Project 52fPrime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IQves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Planning and General Eng1neerg Servicus 1nctuslve ol Waterwastewater System Master Pian asset management program dovo10pmenV11sset Crt1tcat1ty assessment Mesler PS 115 and sewer cond1hon assessment hydrauhc modeling ol LS 5 and force main sizing water system Capacity Analysis RoPort nydraullc modeling ol operahonat challongos tilt ste11on enatysbulls lac11i1a1e 1nspec11011 or major FM and new develOpmenl 1mpnc1s plpohno design lilt station condbullhon assessment and renabtlilahon (Various ProJecls)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D 0 D b Accuracy D 0D D c Deliverables D D 0 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D Gt D b Professionalism D D ~-- D c Turnover D D Gr D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D B D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget D D r~r D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D c~r D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D 0 D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION F~USE ONLY

__VERBAL Verified via LMAIL Verified by ~J Division ~~~D Date ~ f 2 f~t8 All lnfo11na1t0n pr ()Vl(fed 10 Broward County is svb1et110 ven11ca1ion vendor acknowledges lhll 1naeoura10 unlrulhful 0lt inc0ltrec1 s1a1emen1s medo In support ol 1n1s response may be used Dy the County as a basis fcu rejection re sclsst0n Of 1ho award or 1ormina1lon of l he contract and may also servo as the basis for debarment o f Vendor pursuant lo Section 21 119 of tho ampoward Counly P1ocuremont Code

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A middot

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Michael Low Title Deputy Director Reference date 05172018

Contact Email lowmbbflus Contact Phone 5617426403

Name of Referenced Project Ion Exchange Design Build

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

07022014 to 03212018 $ 100000000

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Carollo handled all of the design and construction of a significant part of the project as a subcontractor to COM Constructors as part of a progressive design build contract

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [Z] D b Accuracy D D [Z] D c Deliverables D D [Z] D

2 Vendors Organization D D [Z] Da Staff expertise b Professionalism D D [Z] D c Turnover D D D [Z]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D [Z] D

4 Project completed within budget D D [Z] D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D [Z] D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [Z] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION F~ COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ~~ Division W -NED Date S-gtozot~ All Information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor aclltnowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

Stii191111X 11s a basis for rejection rescission of the award or termination or the conlact and m~~Arifrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward CounYJ 33Plamptl1til1ent Code Y Imiddot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

B~OWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LORID A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

South Florida Water Management District

Contact Name Greg Coffelt PE Title SFWMD Project Manager Reference date 05172018

Contact Email gcoffeltsfwmdgov Contact Phone 561-682-6853

Name of Referenced Project L-8 Reservoir Inflow Structure and Pump Station

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

4600000861 02152011 to 09192012 $ 144535100

Vendors role in Project [l) Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [l)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Corolla was contracted as an Owners Advisor for a Design-Build contract developed engineering design criteria assisted in RFQ development and evaluation supported RFP technical proposal and cost proposal analysis

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [l] D b Accuracy D [] D D c Deliverables D [] D D

2 Vendors Organization [l]a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D [l] D c Turnover D D D [l]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [l] D b Deliverables D [l] D D

4 Project completed within budget [l] DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [l] D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) [l] DD D c Regu latory Agency(ies) D D D [l]

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Owner Advisor work continued(s) in support of Construction of Pump Station Inflow Gate Structure and levee hardening

Verified via IMAIL __VERBAL Date 5 ( 3 c b() I a All information piovided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that Inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made In support of this response may be used by the

512G9JiIX 11s a basis for rejection rescission or the award or termination or the contract and rllffl~Anampe as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 or the Broward CojlftYi 34~6ttlrbtflent Code Y

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

B0~~AARD ~~t~UNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

Fl ORIOA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Sunrise

Contact Name Luisa Fernanda Arbelaa Title Project Manager Reference date 05162018

Contact Email LArbelaezsunrlseflgov Contact Phone 954-888-6009

Name of Referenced Project City of Sunrise - Springtree WTP Water Stabilization and Solids Handling

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PA 16-003-CE 04072016 to 05292018 $ 50797800

Vendors role in Project ]Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [l]Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Carollo Engineers performed the design study and construction administration services for the City

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D G6 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Carollo Engineers technical knowledge and attenllon lo detall were beneficial lo the pltojad They ecled in lhe C~ys besl Interest In every aspect for lhe d1K8Uon of the projectbull

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via ~MAIL _VERBAL Verified by fc4J~~ Division W fl ED All lnrormalion provided to Broward ltAunty Is oobjoci to vorirtcotion Vendoc ecknowledgu that 1naowrate unlMhfuf 0lt lncocrecl statements rnado In support or this response may be useltI by lhe County as a basis for rejection rescission or the award 0lt termination ol the convect and may also ampOIVe as the babullibull ror debarmont of vondOlt purauont to Section 21119 or the Broward County Proc11oment Code

Bid Sync p 135 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BftQNARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

I l 0 R I 0 A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Florida Technical Consultants

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

VIiiage of Wellington Utilities

Contact Name Bradley Wolak Title Assistant Director Ut11Reference date 5182018

Contact Email bwolakwelllngtonflgov Contact Phone 561-753-2480

Name of Referenced Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 10012017 to Present 3500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vend~ 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again UZfYes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor J_ rJ fJ j(Gr-~k 6 Jti ov1 ~uf-Jiy fgt-r_- syrrzi~ff~ Al

R Q_ d--1 0~l 4 171 i+CI ~~lHI )Please rate your experience with tile Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Applicablereferenced Vendor Improvement

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy B D

DD c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D Db Professionalism D D

c Turnover D DD 3 Timeliness of

a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant(s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Additional Comments (provide on addltjpnal sheetJf needed) bull ~middot$ -JJ fo~~rltjbull lt( c-c_ ~~~ lt fo L1-lfAR- -middot~ I 10 ~ ~

~ bullL ~~ _te_ l~Ilgt~Cef t J ~ l rfbull4 middot r0 laquo r 4111J w f1 rrr- 0r- -i-HIS SECTION(9R COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by fcAJc ~ Division Y-1 IN ED Date 5 ~o w8 All lnfonn1Uon ptollfded to BlOward County le eubjeet to vetfflcatlon Vendor aclltnowledge1 that lneccurale unllJlhfUl or lnconect -bullmenla made In 1UPPort o1 this reopon90 may be uoec1 by the couniy ae a baalS ror re)ectlon re8Claeton Of the award 0t leltmlnatlon Of the contract and may 1l10 MM ae the baale flaquo debarrnont 01 vendor pu11uant to Section 21119 of ll1e Broward County Procurement Codo

BidSync p 18 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F LUFltIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultants LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Palm Beach Public Works

Contact Name Gerry Vazquez Title WRD Technician Reference date 05182018

Contact Email gvazqueztownofpalmbeachcom Contact Phone 772-546-6859

Name of Referenced Project GIS Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 3242014 to Present 13500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [3yenes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

PrwAamprs- favl49z Please rate your experience with the Need a Satlafactory Excellent Not

Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D g- D b Accuracy D Er D c Deliverables g-shyB D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D GJ D b Professionalism D D G- D c Tu mover D D cg- D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D g D b Deliverables D D Qshy D

4 Project completed within budget D D lbJ- D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D El- Db Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [3- D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

BidSync p 17 51232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

120-nWARDLll~ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form fLORllgtA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultant LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Waneya Bryant Title Meter Serv Mgr Reference date 05182018

Contact Email BryantWbbflus Contact Phone 561-742-6427

Name of Referenced Project Boynton Beach Utility GIS Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 12012016 to Present $15000000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

~T~ 5e-r-vtleamp +roM l)h f-es Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D Dc Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ti4 D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ Db Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on addlUonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION~urv USE ONLy u bull

Verified via VEMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by kuJ~ Division W if E D rao(ao8Date 5

All Information provided to Browslaquo COOlty Is Slbject to verfflcation Vendor acKnowledges that lneocurate Untruthful or lncolleel 8tatements made In support d this rfl9pOn98 may be used by 1119 Counly as a batia falt rejection relduion ct Ille award or lemilnlilon of the contract and may al80181Veaa1119 basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 ot Ille Broward CountyProcurement Code

512312018 BidSync p 16

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1

8W1V~isl1War Bid PNC21 15559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Fonn

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Cooper City - middot

Contact Name Michael Bailey PE itle Utilities DlrCity EbullReference date 05011201s

Contact Email MBalleycoopercityflorg Contact Phone (954) 434-5519

Name of Referenced Project City of Cooper City Continuing Professional Services bullContract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

RFQ 2009middot 1 04242009 to Present $ 2 19844200

Vendors role in Project IZJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Since 2009 Hazen has provided Cooper City with engineering services or water and wastewater projects Projects have lnctudeo lhe Pine Island Road Pump Station Lilt S1alions 2 amp 49 Improvements Master Plan Update of the FeaslJl~lty Review of Infrastructure Improvements tor Wastewater and the Eflluent Reuse and Disposal Master Plan

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy 8 D

D ~ D c Deliverables D 0 ~ D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D 0 D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tumover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D GJ- D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D 0 D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) ~D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

bull-rHIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY-

Verified vie EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ct4~ Division ~tUb Date ~ i3~) 0fgt All Information provided to BltCgtWW County 11 wbed ID vamprificalion Velldot adltnowledgu that lnaoewate unlrUhful lncom1ct statemampnla made in wppolt of 11111 response may blt uHd by the

4t2j=~ rejection rHclsslcn of th8 award or lennhallon of Ille eoo1nlct and may also seNamp at tilt basis for dtbarmenl at Vendor puuan1 lo Sectioo 21119 of the Broward COltJi 43

5232018 Bid Sync p24

Broward County Board of PNC211 5559P1

~RiiirilyenlcHUffi~~8CrW~r Bid PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

8DdMARD _ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FL O RIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Fort Lauderdale

Contact Name Rares Patrica PE Title Senior Project Mgr Reference date os1021201s

Contact Email RPetricafortlauderdalegov Contact Phone 9548287150

Name of Referenced Project Stormwater Master Planning and Design Implementation Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

256-11660 04192016 to 04192021 $ 989400000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

vyould you use this vendor again Sves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor The Hazen team Is responsible for delivery of a new stormwaler master plan model a prlorlllzed slormwaterresllency capital Improvements plan and Implementation of designs to address chronic flooding and other slormwater management challenges In the City Primary work tasks Include data collectlon hydrologlclhydraullc modeling and design permitting and construction services for capllal Improvement projects resulting from the revised stormwater master plan (preltmlnary design In seven priority neighborhoods)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION ~R COUNTY USE ONLY

aJ~Verified via pound MA IL _VERBAL Verified by Division W1~tl Date 5 ~3o~ax l S N I informallon p roviltled lo Broward County is sulljecl lo verification Vendor altknowledjj6s lhal inaccurate unlMhlut or lncotreci statements m ade In support of this respon$e may be used by tho

412~-~ rejeclion rescission of the award or termination ol lhe contracl and may also serve as lhe basis for debalment ol Vendor purwant to Section 21119 ol lhe Broward Cou~ 4 3

5232018 Bid Sync p25

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 Br~~~~~rs Bid PNC2115559P1 County t ommissioners

B~uWARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FlOR I CA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

Solicitation PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and s OrganizationFirm Name p

Town of Jupiter

nee

Contact Email davidbjupiterflus Contact Phone (561) 746-5134

Name of Referenced Project Engineering Services for Stormwater and Water Capital Improvements

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount $ 630000000 W17248 (2017 reselection 1012000 to Present (estimated lee-to-date since contract inception) contract number)

Vendors role in Project IZI Prime Vendor osubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again 0Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Descriotion of services orovided bv Vendor Since 2000 Hazen has served as General Consulfant to the Town or Jupiter As General Stormwater and Water Consullant the firm has provided services related to master planning stormwater planning and modeling design NPDES permilling asset management resiliency ratefinancial analysis plan review and construction oversight Water-related capital projs have involved additional system storage and high-service pumping transmission system improvements and RampR at existing facilities

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Verllied via EMAIL _ VERBAL Division WWC D

fo (J-Vv ~ltIvmiddotj Date 5(30(ipf S

Al lnroimallon pngtYICGd 10 Broward Counly Is sub)oel to v8flrcallon vendlaquo acknowledges lhat Inaccurate unlruthlu~ 0t Jnwrrect slatoments made In support ol this response may be used by the 42~~1~0 rojecllon rescission or Ille award or termination or lhe con~acl bullnd mbully also serve as tho basis r0t debarment of Vendor pursuant lo Socllon 21119 of lho Broward Couw 41

5232018 BidSync p 26

a N ~ IL) IL) N u z a_

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLO RI DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Walter Wernecke RA Title Sr Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email WWERNECKEhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Hollywood Marina Restrooms

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

04152015 to Present 7500000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor OSubconsultanVSubcontractor n ~U t1

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

-0 Vgt Description of services provided by VendorO ~ ~ Q) Structural Design and Construction Inspection Services i co Q m ~- c E c0

i E gt Oo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not () uu Appllcable O

E~ referenced Vendor Improvement iii ~sectoO 1 Vendors Quality of Service B mu a Responsive D D

b Accuracy DD c Deliverables D DD

2 Vendors Organization D Da Staff expertise v D b Professionalism~ D D c Turnover D ~D

3 Timeliness of D a Project b Deliverables D ~

4 Pec~~11~$~hinJ~~qt lfr D D 5 Cooperation with f ~

a Your Firm D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D

Al lnfonn1tion pRgttded IO Brwd Cltgtunly lo 1ubjecl IO ibllon vsor ~middot Iha icl-bullmiddot ~ ir-ect slalemenls mode In _ol lhb _ moy ti used by he County as a basis lot rejecUon rnclnlon cl the eward or tonnlnallan of lhl connct 1nd may bullllo 11 the basis for dobalment of Vendor IQtulnl IO SICllOn 21119 at lhe Broword County Procurement Code

Cl ltraquo I() I() I() N ()

Cl z

BRltJWARD ~ middot COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORl OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Davie

Contact Name Emilio DeSimone Title Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email Emilio_DeSimonedavie-fl gov Contact Phone 954-797-1085

Name of Referenced Project Pavillion 5 Linear Park

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

B-17-123 09152015 to 2700000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor O SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es O No If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

0 Description of services provided by Vendor O Q)

iii c Structural Design and Construction Inspection ServicesoQ

CDi-

0cc E gt=gt E ()Oo O () () Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

ii) -e i- Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 111 cs

B ioO

J 1 Vendors Quality of Service Q ()

a Responsive D D b Accuracy D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization []Ll Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D Dtr

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [g D b Deliverables D D ar D

4 Project completed within budget [1tD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) cgD D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via l EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by ~h~ Division WlI Etgt Date 0 f l~o I 8 All lnformaUon provided lO Broward County Is eubJect 10 verifutlon Vendor ecknOMedgoo that lnaocurote unNlhlul or Incorrect statamenle made In aupl)Ort of this reaponse may be used by lho County et o baampla for rejection realtluion of the award or lermlnallon of tho eon1fllcl ond moy olao aorvo os ho basis for debarmont of Vondor purauenl lo Section 21119 of the Broward Counly Procuremen1 Code

0 0 agt a c () z 0

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Terrence Comiskey AIA Title Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email TCOMISKEYhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Van Buren Parking Garage

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PK 14-053 Nov 2014 to Present 8310000

Vendors role in Project t8(Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

o~ Description of services provided by Vendor 1 Q)ltO c Structural Design and Conslructlon Inspection Services 0 Q

0~Jl ccE l E enOo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

gtshy

uu O Improvement Applicable ffireferenced Vendor

~sect 1 Vendors Quality of Service 1 ~

oOau a Responsive D ~ D b Accuracy B D D

D D [- Dc Deliverables

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tum over D D D g

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ D Subcontractor(s )S ubcons u ltant( s)b D D ~ D

c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D yenj D Additional Comments provide on sdditlonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION ~NTY USE ONLY0

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by kW Division W-1-(i~ Date EJo(a~t8 Al lnform1Uon PltOVlded lo Browald Ccxnty It IUbjoct to vorificallon Vendor eoknowfodgea thal lnaewralt U111MhlJI deg inlaquogtlaquobullel amptal11ants made In eupporl of lhls relj)Onse may be used by Iha Counly es a balls l0t rcfecllon rescfuloltI of tho ew1rd or 1ermtnaU0lt1 ol lhbull conllllCI and may elao urve 11 lho basis for dabarmenl of Vondor pursuanl lo Secllon 21 119 of he erowald COUlly CiProcurement Code

~ N ii

00

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 aOWllrp Commficumlref Bid PNC2116615B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Pompano Beach FL

Contact Name Mr A Randolph Brown Title Utilities Director Reference date April 30 2018

Contact Email randolphbrowncopbflcom Contact Phone 954-545-7043

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 201 o Project Amount fees varied

Multiple

Vendors role in Project IKJ Prime Vendor

to 2018

osubconsultanUSubcontractor

(range $10000shy$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D ~ D D c Deliverables D ~ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D ~ D D b Professionalism D D ~ D C Turnover D El DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ 0 b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D [BJ D n c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [XJ o ~

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed) amp~~it -THIS SECTION ~COUNTY USE ONL y-bullbull

Verified via ~AIL __VERBAL Verified by 1lt4 )~ Division N WE O Date 5 faol Z1 18

All lnformotlon providod to BltownrltI Cou nty it aubjoct O verification VendOr acknowledges that lnaccornto untruthful or incorroct 11atomon1s made in support of this response may be used by tho

411p~~)~~J rojoclion roscissioo ol lho award or 1orroinalion of tho contract and roay also s01vo as lhbull basis f0lt d~arroont of VondOf pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward Cou)l1

Bid Sync p 73

40

5232018

Broward County Board of Bid PNC2116659B 1 County Commissioners

B~aWARD gt1- t COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Loxahatchee River Environmental Control District

Contact Name Mr Kris Dean Title Director of Engineering Reference date May 9 2018

Contact Email krisdeanloxahatcheeriverorg Contact Phone 561-747-5700

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 2001 Project Amount fees varied (range $10000shyMultiple to 2018 $250000)

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IR)Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D ~ D D b Accuracy D 0 D D c Deliverables D IBJ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D IB] D D b Professionalism D ~ D D c Turnover D [8J D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D [8J D D b Deliverables D m D D

4 Project completed within budget D ~ D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D ~ D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D Ii] D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D ~ D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SE~ FOR~USE ONLY

Verified via _lEMAIL __VERBAL Verified by ~lt Division fWeb Date I

All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untrulhful or incorrecl slatements made In support of this response may be used by the lJl~~~l~~jSfiir rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and mll~~~ere as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Co)f 10

Broward County Board of Bid PNC21166$9B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A l

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Lake Worth FL

Contact Name Mr Felipe Lofaso TitleAsst Dir Public-ServicesReference date May 9 2018

Contact Email flofasolakeworthorg Contact Phone 561-586-1720

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contract

Contract No Date Services Provided 2014 Project Amount fees varied Multiple to 2018 (range $10000shy

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Services included multiple municipal engineering projects including survey roadway design utility design and coordination (water wastewater stormwater other) along with project management

Needs Satisfactory Excellent NotPlease rate your experience with the Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D GJ D b Accuracy D D Ii] D c Deliverables D Ii] DD

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [i] D c Turnover D D D [X]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D 0 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [X] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION Fe COUNTY USE ONLrbullbull

Verified via MAIL __VERBAL Verified by Division ~wgtgt Date 5~3ol20t8 All information provided to Broward County Is subject lo verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect slalements made in support ol this response may be used by the

OZ~id~~~~j~r rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and m~~~(iirve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Cour~ iG

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - ARCADIS US INC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts

VS0000013130 VS00013130 - ARCADIS US INC Prime Work Auth Vendor SummaryProjects

PURCHASING 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold Procurement No Fixed Contracts FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Favorites Past 5 Years Prime Vendor

Sub Vendor From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 10042017 Purchase Order

Evaluation Purchase Orders 1 POs With A Total Amt Of $20000000 Log Off Paid To Dt ($12132949) Balance $7867051

Contracts Purchase Orders Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx 6192018

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Finish

PURCHASING Weighted Scores Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract FileRoom DashBoard Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number FileRoom Insert

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel Favorites Prime Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Service Evaluation

6132017 YES 486 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Goals Compliance Evaluation

10272016 YES 460 View Docs (0)

6272018

Project Management Information System

Close

Contracts Central Administration

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9130 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-24

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6182018 YES 355 View Docs (1)

Proj Nbr 9320 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-20

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6132018 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9290 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-23

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1122018 YES 494 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-21

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12182017 YES 488 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10162017 YES 473 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

8252017 YES 495 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9321 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-19

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

7112017 YES 476 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-17

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2272017 YES 400 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

10132016 YES 384 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-12

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

5202016 YES 405 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9018 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-06

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10192015 YES 448 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

3202015 YES 385 View Docs (0)

Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL CONSULTANTS

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Project Management Information System

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-04

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12122014 YES 437 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-08

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1242014 YES 423 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-02

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2282014 YES 452 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC

VC0000044184 VC00044184 - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres PS $001 Used $000 Remain $001 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $354848400 Closed 0 Total $000 Total Current Retainage Balance For All Contracts $793370 No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 06292015 Purchase Orders 2 POs With A Total Amt Of $362317900 Paid To Dt ($218795160) Balance $143522740

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 40803 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9058 - DISTRICT 3A POTABLE WATER STORAGE

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1220410P1 - Consultant Engineering Services for Potable Water FixedOpen Contracts Storage Tanks and Pumping Systems Work Auth Prime Vendor CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Periodic Final Finish

Log Off Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type

Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

6232015 8302017 413 Approved 8312017 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard

Enter Vendor Name (or a portion of) Then Click Search - Wilcards Are Permitted (ie wa wawainc) Florida Technical Consultants

Search Reset Finish

No Vendors Found For Your Search Try Again

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41005 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score Go

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0773

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

12122017 YES 430 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

8302016 YES 438 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Final Consultant Evaluation 3142016 YES 478 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0706

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

142016 YES 402 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9016OES - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0731

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

10192015 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0748

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

612015 YES 467 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

2192015 YES 500 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0754

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

252015 YES 409 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0755

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

1242014 YES 415 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8974 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0758

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

6202014 YES 393 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr

WATER amp WASTEWATER

Final Consultant Work Authorization 572014 YES 423 View Docs

(0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

HS0746 ENGINEERING Evaluation

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

4302014 YES 475 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Evaluation 4302014 YES 493 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0710

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

3172014 YES 395 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0753

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

1212014 YES 380 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0763

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

11192013 YES 450 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0775

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 408 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals

Finish

Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed FileRoom DashBoard Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization FileRoom Insert NumberFavorites

Prime Vendor Export To Excel Sub Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0772

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 417 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0771

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

2262013 YES 410 View Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 12: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

Recommendation Memorandum RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports July 13 2018 Page 12 of 12

Broward Countyrsquos Local Preference Ordinance specifically excludes the application of a local preference for professional services procured pursuant to Section 287055 FS (CCNA)

J LOCATION - TIE BREAKER A Vendor located within Broward County is eligible for the Location Tie Breaker The County requires a copy of the Broward County Business Tax receipt for a period of time of at least six (6) months prior to the solicitation deadline and it must be provided with its initial submittal

The results are as follows

Name of Firm Eligibility Broward County Tax Receipt

Arcadis US Inc Eligible Provided

Brown and Caldwell (Corporation)

Eligible Provided

Carollo Engineers Inc Eligible Provided

Florida Technical Consultants LLC

Eligible Provided

Hazen and Sawyer PC Eligible Provided

LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

Eligible Provided

Baxter amp Woodman Inc dba Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

Eligible Provided

Attachments 1 Vendor Reference Verifications 2 Vendor Performance Evaluations 3 Vendor Responses to Draft Memo

c Bob Melton County Auditor Office of the County Auditor Robert Wilson Title Division Department (Project Manager) Martha Perez-Garviso Purchasing Manager Purchasing Division Finance and Administrative Services Department Glenn Miller Assistant County Attorney Office of the County Attorney Fernando Amuchastegui Assistant County Attorney Office of the County Attorney

BJBGMnomm

Broward County Board of PNC211 5559P1 County Commissioners

BRCWARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LO ~ I DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P 1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis us Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

South Florida Water Management District

Contact Name Rich V irgil PE Title Bureau Chief lnfrabReference date 05142018

Contact Email rvirgilsfwmdgov Contact Phone 561 6826759

Name of Referenced Project S-193 Lock Refurbishment C-41A Canal Bank Stabilization Lake

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

4600000790 1001 2008 UP 12012016 $ 295400000

Vendors role in Project ]rime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Engineering Design and Engineering Services During Construction

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D [] DD c Deliverables []D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [L] D c Turnover D D D0

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget []D D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm [L]D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D 0 D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [] D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via ~AI L VERBAL Verified by ~~ Division WWfD Date ltQamp~(8 All lnformallon provided to Bltoward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate unlrulhful or incorrect statements made In support of this response may be used by the

512gt~11MlflS a lgtasis Of rejection rescission of the award or tenninallon of the contract and ~~lVcrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 of lhe Broward Count~ 41l6tlrelfient Code Y fTmiddot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BR~ltJWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LO R I DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering SeNices for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Saint Petersburg Department of Engineering and Capital Planning

Contact Name Nicole Allen Title CADDGIS Supervi Reference date

Contact Email nicoleallenstpeteorg Contact Phone 727-893-7316

Name of Referenced Project Water Resources Department GIS Data Migration

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

13-03-ARCIT 12092014 UP 09152015 $ 5925000

Vendors role in Project ]rime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again (Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Migration ofwater wastewater and storm water infrastructure information from CAD environment to Esri Local Government Information Model

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D [] D c Deliverables D [] D D

2 Vendors Organization [ZJa Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D [ZJ D c Turnover D D [] D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [ZJ D b Deliverables D D [ZJ D

4 Project completed within budget [ZJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [ZJ D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) [ZJD D D c Regu latory Agency(ies) D D [ZJ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONL rbullbull

Verified via L L VERBAL Verified by Division NlltE~ Date 6(~oatgt 1 8~ All information PfOvided to Bfoward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful oc inCOfrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

512gt9lillll jS a basis 10lt rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and nlll~9rrcrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of lhe Broward Cou~ 42fldtclrhtflent Code middot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BRuWARD1 1 COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering SeNices for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

C ity of Tavares F lorida

Contact Name James Dillon Title Public Works DireltaReference date 05172018

Contact Email jdillontavaresorg Contact Phone 352-455-7718

Name of Referenced Project G IS Modeling and Integration of Utilities Infrastructure

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

060330480000 04012017 UP 10012017 $ 5676000

Vendors role in Project ]rime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Integrate drawings and images depicting pipe infrastructure into a GIS environment for easy retrieval First project of a multi phase program to upgrade the Citys GIS information

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D 0 D c Deliverables D D 0 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D Ill D b Professionalism D D Ill D c Turnover D D 0 D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D Ill D b Deliverables D D Ill D

4 Project completed within budget D D Ill D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D Ill D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D Ill D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY -

Ve rified via L IL VERBAL Verified by fcAJ~ Division llt E1) Date 1 r~ tjlQ t8 All information pwvlded to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incooect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

512G91JlIHIS a basis for rejection rescission or the award or termination or the contract and lnfli~9ncrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 of the Broward CouI)~ 44flamplrelflent Code

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BRd~WARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LO R I DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Miramar

Contact Name Robin E Bain PE Title Project Manager Reference date 05142018

Contact Email rebainmiramarflgov Contact Phone 9548836825

Name of Referenced Project East Water Treatment Plant Replacement Wells and Design-Build

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PO 172624-00 10222017 UP 05142018 $ 56929600

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [ZJYes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Design permitting construction services for new Deep Injection Well and 4 new (replacement) production wells

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy []D D D c Deliverables D []D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D [ZJ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Turnover D D D []

3 Timeliness of a Project D D lZ1 D b Del iverables D D lZ1 D

4 Project completed within budget D D lZ1 D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor( s)Subconsultant( s) D D lZ1 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D lZ1 D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY (

Verified via A IL VER BAL Verified by faltJ~ Division WltEtgt Date 5 ~io l 9 All inlOllllalion pltovided to Broward County is subjecl lo verificalioo VendOt acknowledges lhal lnaccurale unlrulhful or i ncooecl stalemenls made in suppOltI of lhis response may be used by lhe

512gt~llM (lS a basis lot rejeclion rescission of the award or termination of lhe contract and mll~Arrcrve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuanl 10 Section 21119 of lhe Broward Couoty 43Pldtllrbrllent Code Y flmiddot

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Palm Beach County Water Utilities Department

Contact Name Ali Bayat Title Assistant Director Reference date

Contact Email abayatpbcwatercom Contact Phone 561 493 6128

Name of Referenced Project System 8 Water Quality Assessment

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

17-021 CSA21 01 022017 to 01152018 $ 8936000

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again (Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Brown and Caldwell led assessment of contributing causes to low system residuals troubleshooting treatment processes special testing and data analysis improvements to operating protocols monitoringcontrol system and treatment process

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [Z] D b Accuracy D [Z] DD c Deliverables D [Z]D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D [Z] D b Professionalism D D [Z] D c Turnover D [Z] DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D [Z] D

4 Project completed within budget D D [Z] D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Consultant worked collaboratively with operating maintenance engineering and laboratory staff to develop insight into contributing factors and implement improvements

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via _LEMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by tcltJ1~ Division -+LN euro P Date lteh IWt 8 All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the County as a basis for rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and may also serve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward County Procurement Code

BltaWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F L 0 R I D A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood Florida

Contact Name Steve Joseph Title Director Reference date

Contact Email sjosephhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954 921 3522

Name of Referenced Project Distribution System Water Quality Improvement

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

01012016 to 06022017 $ 3000000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again []Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Supported the City with its efforts improve chlorine residuals in areas of its system Analysis included system modeling monitoring optimized operational practices Implemented operational improvements that significantly raised (from approx 05 to 20 mgL) chloramine residuals In the most challenging area of the system

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D D [] D c Deliverables []D D D

2 Vendors Organization [] Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D [] D c Turnover D D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D [] D

4 Project completed within budget []D D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) []D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [] D

Additional Com ments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Effort Included system modoling moniloring and excursion response procedures opllmitallon of stored Inventory management unidirectional flushing pilot assessment and treatment proooss evaluation

Verified via __EMAIL vERBAL Division WW ED Date G Ifgt I 8 All infonmallon pltovided to Broward County Is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of thi s response may be used by lhe County as a basis for rejeclion rescission or the award or tenminatlon of the contract and may also serve as the basis for debanment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 or lhe Broward County Procurement Code

BROWARD t (l)t~ 1 Vendor Reference Verification Form

fl O R I OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of West Palm Beach Florida

Contact Name Jay Kwag Title Project Manager Reference date

Contact Email hjkwagwpborg Contact Phone 561 494 1041

Name of Referenced Project Modeling and Infrastructure General Engineering Consulting Assigments

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

11032014 to HAlt zc1e (on~vi~)

Vendors role in Project 52fPrime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IQves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Planning and General Eng1neerg Servicus 1nctuslve ol Waterwastewater System Master Pian asset management program dovo10pmenV11sset Crt1tcat1ty assessment Mesler PS 115 and sewer cond1hon assessment hydrauhc modeling ol LS 5 and force main sizing water system Capacity Analysis RoPort nydraullc modeling ol operahonat challongos tilt ste11on enatysbulls lac11i1a1e 1nspec11011 or major FM and new develOpmenl 1mpnc1s plpohno design lilt station condbullhon assessment and renabtlilahon (Various ProJecls)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D 0 D b Accuracy D 0D D c Deliverables D D 0 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D Gt D b Professionalism D D ~-- D c Turnover D D Gr D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D B D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget D D r~r D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D c~r D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D 0 D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION F~USE ONLY

__VERBAL Verified via LMAIL Verified by ~J Division ~~~D Date ~ f 2 f~t8 All lnfo11na1t0n pr ()Vl(fed 10 Broward County is svb1et110 ven11ca1ion vendor acknowledges lhll 1naeoura10 unlrulhful 0lt inc0ltrec1 s1a1emen1s medo In support ol 1n1s response may be used Dy the County as a basis fcu rejection re sclsst0n Of 1ho award or 1ormina1lon of l he contract and may also servo as the basis for debarment o f Vendor pursuant lo Section 21 119 of tho ampoward Counly P1ocuremont Code

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A middot

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Michael Low Title Deputy Director Reference date 05172018

Contact Email lowmbbflus Contact Phone 5617426403

Name of Referenced Project Ion Exchange Design Build

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

07022014 to 03212018 $ 100000000

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Carollo handled all of the design and construction of a significant part of the project as a subcontractor to COM Constructors as part of a progressive design build contract

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [Z] D b Accuracy D D [Z] D c Deliverables D D [Z] D

2 Vendors Organization D D [Z] Da Staff expertise b Professionalism D D [Z] D c Turnover D D D [Z]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D [Z] D

4 Project completed within budget D D [Z] D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D [Z] D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [Z] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION F~ COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ~~ Division W -NED Date S-gtozot~ All Information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor aclltnowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

Stii191111X 11s a basis for rejection rescission of the award or termination or the conlact and m~~Arifrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward CounYJ 33Plamptl1til1ent Code Y Imiddot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

B~OWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LORID A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

South Florida Water Management District

Contact Name Greg Coffelt PE Title SFWMD Project Manager Reference date 05172018

Contact Email gcoffeltsfwmdgov Contact Phone 561-682-6853

Name of Referenced Project L-8 Reservoir Inflow Structure and Pump Station

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

4600000861 02152011 to 09192012 $ 144535100

Vendors role in Project [l) Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [l)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Corolla was contracted as an Owners Advisor for a Design-Build contract developed engineering design criteria assisted in RFQ development and evaluation supported RFP technical proposal and cost proposal analysis

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [l] D b Accuracy D [] D D c Deliverables D [] D D

2 Vendors Organization [l]a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D [l] D c Turnover D D D [l]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [l] D b Deliverables D [l] D D

4 Project completed within budget [l] DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [l] D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) [l] DD D c Regu latory Agency(ies) D D D [l]

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Owner Advisor work continued(s) in support of Construction of Pump Station Inflow Gate Structure and levee hardening

Verified via IMAIL __VERBAL Date 5 ( 3 c b() I a All information piovided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that Inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made In support of this response may be used by the

512G9JiIX 11s a basis for rejection rescission or the award or termination or the contract and rllffl~Anampe as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 or the Broward CojlftYi 34~6ttlrbtflent Code Y

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

B0~~AARD ~~t~UNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

Fl ORIOA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Sunrise

Contact Name Luisa Fernanda Arbelaa Title Project Manager Reference date 05162018

Contact Email LArbelaezsunrlseflgov Contact Phone 954-888-6009

Name of Referenced Project City of Sunrise - Springtree WTP Water Stabilization and Solids Handling

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PA 16-003-CE 04072016 to 05292018 $ 50797800

Vendors role in Project ]Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [l]Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Carollo Engineers performed the design study and construction administration services for the City

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D G6 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Carollo Engineers technical knowledge and attenllon lo detall were beneficial lo the pltojad They ecled in lhe C~ys besl Interest In every aspect for lhe d1K8Uon of the projectbull

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via ~MAIL _VERBAL Verified by fc4J~~ Division W fl ED All lnrormalion provided to Broward ltAunty Is oobjoci to vorirtcotion Vendoc ecknowledgu that 1naowrate unlMhfuf 0lt lncocrecl statements rnado In support or this response may be useltI by lhe County as a basis for rejection rescission or the award 0lt termination ol the convect and may also ampOIVe as the babullibull ror debarmont of vondOlt purauont to Section 21119 or the Broward County Proc11oment Code

Bid Sync p 135 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BftQNARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

I l 0 R I 0 A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Florida Technical Consultants

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

VIiiage of Wellington Utilities

Contact Name Bradley Wolak Title Assistant Director Ut11Reference date 5182018

Contact Email bwolakwelllngtonflgov Contact Phone 561-753-2480

Name of Referenced Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 10012017 to Present 3500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vend~ 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again UZfYes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor J_ rJ fJ j(Gr-~k 6 Jti ov1 ~uf-Jiy fgt-r_- syrrzi~ff~ Al

R Q_ d--1 0~l 4 171 i+CI ~~lHI )Please rate your experience with tile Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Applicablereferenced Vendor Improvement

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy B D

DD c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D Db Professionalism D D

c Turnover D DD 3 Timeliness of

a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant(s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Additional Comments (provide on addltjpnal sheetJf needed) bull ~middot$ -JJ fo~~rltjbull lt( c-c_ ~~~ lt fo L1-lfAR- -middot~ I 10 ~ ~

~ bullL ~~ _te_ l~Ilgt~Cef t J ~ l rfbull4 middot r0 laquo r 4111J w f1 rrr- 0r- -i-HIS SECTION(9R COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by fcAJc ~ Division Y-1 IN ED Date 5 ~o w8 All lnfonn1Uon ptollfded to BlOward County le eubjeet to vetfflcatlon Vendor aclltnowledge1 that lneccurale unllJlhfUl or lnconect -bullmenla made In 1UPPort o1 this reopon90 may be uoec1 by the couniy ae a baalS ror re)ectlon re8Claeton Of the award 0t leltmlnatlon Of the contract and may 1l10 MM ae the baale flaquo debarrnont 01 vendor pu11uant to Section 21119 of ll1e Broward County Procurement Codo

BidSync p 18 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F LUFltIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultants LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Palm Beach Public Works

Contact Name Gerry Vazquez Title WRD Technician Reference date 05182018

Contact Email gvazqueztownofpalmbeachcom Contact Phone 772-546-6859

Name of Referenced Project GIS Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 3242014 to Present 13500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [3yenes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

PrwAamprs- favl49z Please rate your experience with the Need a Satlafactory Excellent Not

Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D g- D b Accuracy D Er D c Deliverables g-shyB D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D GJ D b Professionalism D D G- D c Tu mover D D cg- D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D g D b Deliverables D D Qshy D

4 Project completed within budget D D lbJ- D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D El- Db Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [3- D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

BidSync p 17 51232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

120-nWARDLll~ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form fLORllgtA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultant LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Waneya Bryant Title Meter Serv Mgr Reference date 05182018

Contact Email BryantWbbflus Contact Phone 561-742-6427

Name of Referenced Project Boynton Beach Utility GIS Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 12012016 to Present $15000000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

~T~ 5e-r-vtleamp +roM l)h f-es Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D Dc Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ti4 D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ Db Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on addlUonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION~urv USE ONLy u bull

Verified via VEMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by kuJ~ Division W if E D rao(ao8Date 5

All Information provided to Browslaquo COOlty Is Slbject to verfflcation Vendor acKnowledges that lneocurate Untruthful or lncolleel 8tatements made In support d this rfl9pOn98 may be used by 1119 Counly as a batia falt rejection relduion ct Ille award or lemilnlilon of the contract and may al80181Veaa1119 basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 ot Ille Broward CountyProcurement Code

512312018 BidSync p 16

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1

8W1V~isl1War Bid PNC21 15559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Fonn

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Cooper City - middot

Contact Name Michael Bailey PE itle Utilities DlrCity EbullReference date 05011201s

Contact Email MBalleycoopercityflorg Contact Phone (954) 434-5519

Name of Referenced Project City of Cooper City Continuing Professional Services bullContract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

RFQ 2009middot 1 04242009 to Present $ 2 19844200

Vendors role in Project IZJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Since 2009 Hazen has provided Cooper City with engineering services or water and wastewater projects Projects have lnctudeo lhe Pine Island Road Pump Station Lilt S1alions 2 amp 49 Improvements Master Plan Update of the FeaslJl~lty Review of Infrastructure Improvements tor Wastewater and the Eflluent Reuse and Disposal Master Plan

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy 8 D

D ~ D c Deliverables D 0 ~ D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D 0 D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tumover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D GJ- D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D 0 D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) ~D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

bull-rHIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY-

Verified vie EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ct4~ Division ~tUb Date ~ i3~) 0fgt All Information provided to BltCgtWW County 11 wbed ID vamprificalion Velldot adltnowledgu that lnaoewate unlrUhful lncom1ct statemampnla made in wppolt of 11111 response may blt uHd by the

4t2j=~ rejection rHclsslcn of th8 award or lennhallon of Ille eoo1nlct and may also seNamp at tilt basis for dtbarmenl at Vendor puuan1 lo Sectioo 21119 of the Broward COltJi 43

5232018 Bid Sync p24

Broward County Board of PNC211 5559P1

~RiiirilyenlcHUffi~~8CrW~r Bid PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

8DdMARD _ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FL O RIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Fort Lauderdale

Contact Name Rares Patrica PE Title Senior Project Mgr Reference date os1021201s

Contact Email RPetricafortlauderdalegov Contact Phone 9548287150

Name of Referenced Project Stormwater Master Planning and Design Implementation Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

256-11660 04192016 to 04192021 $ 989400000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

vyould you use this vendor again Sves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor The Hazen team Is responsible for delivery of a new stormwaler master plan model a prlorlllzed slormwaterresllency capital Improvements plan and Implementation of designs to address chronic flooding and other slormwater management challenges In the City Primary work tasks Include data collectlon hydrologlclhydraullc modeling and design permitting and construction services for capllal Improvement projects resulting from the revised stormwater master plan (preltmlnary design In seven priority neighborhoods)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION ~R COUNTY USE ONLY

aJ~Verified via pound MA IL _VERBAL Verified by Division W1~tl Date 5 ~3o~ax l S N I informallon p roviltled lo Broward County is sulljecl lo verification Vendor altknowledjj6s lhal inaccurate unlMhlut or lncotreci statements m ade In support of this respon$e may be used by tho

412~-~ rejeclion rescission of the award or termination ol lhe contracl and may also serve as lhe basis for debalment ol Vendor purwant to Section 21119 ol lhe Broward Cou~ 4 3

5232018 Bid Sync p25

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 Br~~~~~rs Bid PNC2115559P1 County t ommissioners

B~uWARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FlOR I CA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

Solicitation PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and s OrganizationFirm Name p

Town of Jupiter

nee

Contact Email davidbjupiterflus Contact Phone (561) 746-5134

Name of Referenced Project Engineering Services for Stormwater and Water Capital Improvements

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount $ 630000000 W17248 (2017 reselection 1012000 to Present (estimated lee-to-date since contract inception) contract number)

Vendors role in Project IZI Prime Vendor osubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again 0Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Descriotion of services orovided bv Vendor Since 2000 Hazen has served as General Consulfant to the Town or Jupiter As General Stormwater and Water Consullant the firm has provided services related to master planning stormwater planning and modeling design NPDES permilling asset management resiliency ratefinancial analysis plan review and construction oversight Water-related capital projs have involved additional system storage and high-service pumping transmission system improvements and RampR at existing facilities

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Verllied via EMAIL _ VERBAL Division WWC D

fo (J-Vv ~ltIvmiddotj Date 5(30(ipf S

Al lnroimallon pngtYICGd 10 Broward Counly Is sub)oel to v8flrcallon vendlaquo acknowledges lhat Inaccurate unlruthlu~ 0t Jnwrrect slatoments made In support ol this response may be used by the 42~~1~0 rojecllon rescission or Ille award or termination or lhe con~acl bullnd mbully also serve as tho basis r0t debarment of Vendor pursuant lo Socllon 21119 of lho Broward Couw 41

5232018 BidSync p 26

a N ~ IL) IL) N u z a_

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLO RI DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Walter Wernecke RA Title Sr Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email WWERNECKEhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Hollywood Marina Restrooms

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

04152015 to Present 7500000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor OSubconsultanVSubcontractor n ~U t1

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

-0 Vgt Description of services provided by VendorO ~ ~ Q) Structural Design and Construction Inspection Services i co Q m ~- c E c0

i E gt Oo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not () uu Appllcable O

E~ referenced Vendor Improvement iii ~sectoO 1 Vendors Quality of Service B mu a Responsive D D

b Accuracy DD c Deliverables D DD

2 Vendors Organization D Da Staff expertise v D b Professionalism~ D D c Turnover D ~D

3 Timeliness of D a Project b Deliverables D ~

4 Pec~~11~$~hinJ~~qt lfr D D 5 Cooperation with f ~

a Your Firm D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D

Al lnfonn1tion pRgttded IO Brwd Cltgtunly lo 1ubjecl IO ibllon vsor ~middot Iha icl-bullmiddot ~ ir-ect slalemenls mode In _ol lhb _ moy ti used by he County as a basis lot rejecUon rnclnlon cl the eward or tonnlnallan of lhl connct 1nd may bullllo 11 the basis for dobalment of Vendor IQtulnl IO SICllOn 21119 at lhe Broword County Procurement Code

Cl ltraquo I() I() I() N ()

Cl z

BRltJWARD ~ middot COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORl OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Davie

Contact Name Emilio DeSimone Title Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email Emilio_DeSimonedavie-fl gov Contact Phone 954-797-1085

Name of Referenced Project Pavillion 5 Linear Park

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

B-17-123 09152015 to 2700000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor O SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es O No If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

0 Description of services provided by Vendor O Q)

iii c Structural Design and Construction Inspection ServicesoQ

CDi-

0cc E gt=gt E ()Oo O () () Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

ii) -e i- Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 111 cs

B ioO

J 1 Vendors Quality of Service Q ()

a Responsive D D b Accuracy D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization []Ll Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D Dtr

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [g D b Deliverables D D ar D

4 Project completed within budget [1tD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) cgD D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via l EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by ~h~ Division WlI Etgt Date 0 f l~o I 8 All lnformaUon provided lO Broward County Is eubJect 10 verifutlon Vendor ecknOMedgoo that lnaocurote unNlhlul or Incorrect statamenle made In aupl)Ort of this reaponse may be used by lho County et o baampla for rejection realtluion of the award or lermlnallon of tho eon1fllcl ond moy olao aorvo os ho basis for debarmont of Vondor purauenl lo Section 21119 of the Broward Counly Procuremen1 Code

0 0 agt a c () z 0

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Terrence Comiskey AIA Title Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email TCOMISKEYhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Van Buren Parking Garage

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PK 14-053 Nov 2014 to Present 8310000

Vendors role in Project t8(Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

o~ Description of services provided by Vendor 1 Q)ltO c Structural Design and Conslructlon Inspection Services 0 Q

0~Jl ccE l E enOo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

gtshy

uu O Improvement Applicable ffireferenced Vendor

~sect 1 Vendors Quality of Service 1 ~

oOau a Responsive D ~ D b Accuracy B D D

D D [- Dc Deliverables

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tum over D D D g

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ D Subcontractor(s )S ubcons u ltant( s)b D D ~ D

c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D yenj D Additional Comments provide on sdditlonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION ~NTY USE ONLY0

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by kW Division W-1-(i~ Date EJo(a~t8 Al lnform1Uon PltOVlded lo Browald Ccxnty It IUbjoct to vorificallon Vendor eoknowfodgea thal lnaewralt U111MhlJI deg inlaquogtlaquobullel amptal11ants made In eupporl of lhls relj)Onse may be used by Iha Counly es a balls l0t rcfecllon rescfuloltI of tho ew1rd or 1ermtnaU0lt1 ol lhbull conllllCI and may elao urve 11 lho basis for dabarmenl of Vondor pursuanl lo Secllon 21 119 of he erowald COUlly CiProcurement Code

~ N ii

00

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 aOWllrp Commficumlref Bid PNC2116615B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Pompano Beach FL

Contact Name Mr A Randolph Brown Title Utilities Director Reference date April 30 2018

Contact Email randolphbrowncopbflcom Contact Phone 954-545-7043

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 201 o Project Amount fees varied

Multiple

Vendors role in Project IKJ Prime Vendor

to 2018

osubconsultanUSubcontractor

(range $10000shy$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D ~ D D c Deliverables D ~ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D ~ D D b Professionalism D D ~ D C Turnover D El DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ 0 b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D [BJ D n c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [XJ o ~

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed) amp~~it -THIS SECTION ~COUNTY USE ONL y-bullbull

Verified via ~AIL __VERBAL Verified by 1lt4 )~ Division N WE O Date 5 faol Z1 18

All lnformotlon providod to BltownrltI Cou nty it aubjoct O verification VendOr acknowledges that lnaccornto untruthful or incorroct 11atomon1s made in support of this response may be used by tho

411p~~)~~J rojoclion roscissioo ol lho award or 1orroinalion of tho contract and roay also s01vo as lhbull basis f0lt d~arroont of VondOf pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward Cou)l1

Bid Sync p 73

40

5232018

Broward County Board of Bid PNC2116659B 1 County Commissioners

B~aWARD gt1- t COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Loxahatchee River Environmental Control District

Contact Name Mr Kris Dean Title Director of Engineering Reference date May 9 2018

Contact Email krisdeanloxahatcheeriverorg Contact Phone 561-747-5700

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 2001 Project Amount fees varied (range $10000shyMultiple to 2018 $250000)

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IR)Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D ~ D D b Accuracy D 0 D D c Deliverables D IBJ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D IB] D D b Professionalism D ~ D D c Turnover D [8J D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D [8J D D b Deliverables D m D D

4 Project completed within budget D ~ D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D ~ D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D Ii] D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D ~ D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SE~ FOR~USE ONLY

Verified via _lEMAIL __VERBAL Verified by ~lt Division fWeb Date I

All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untrulhful or incorrecl slatements made In support of this response may be used by the lJl~~~l~~jSfiir rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and mll~~~ere as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Co)f 10

Broward County Board of Bid PNC21166$9B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A l

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Lake Worth FL

Contact Name Mr Felipe Lofaso TitleAsst Dir Public-ServicesReference date May 9 2018

Contact Email flofasolakeworthorg Contact Phone 561-586-1720

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contract

Contract No Date Services Provided 2014 Project Amount fees varied Multiple to 2018 (range $10000shy

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Services included multiple municipal engineering projects including survey roadway design utility design and coordination (water wastewater stormwater other) along with project management

Needs Satisfactory Excellent NotPlease rate your experience with the Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D GJ D b Accuracy D D Ii] D c Deliverables D Ii] DD

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [i] D c Turnover D D D [X]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D 0 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [X] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION Fe COUNTY USE ONLrbullbull

Verified via MAIL __VERBAL Verified by Division ~wgtgt Date 5~3ol20t8 All information provided to Broward County Is subject lo verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect slalements made in support ol this response may be used by the

OZ~id~~~~j~r rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and m~~~(iirve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Cour~ iG

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - ARCADIS US INC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts

VS0000013130 VS00013130 - ARCADIS US INC Prime Work Auth Vendor SummaryProjects

PURCHASING 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold Procurement No Fixed Contracts FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Favorites Past 5 Years Prime Vendor

Sub Vendor From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 10042017 Purchase Order

Evaluation Purchase Orders 1 POs With A Total Amt Of $20000000 Log Off Paid To Dt ($12132949) Balance $7867051

Contracts Purchase Orders Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx 6192018

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Finish

PURCHASING Weighted Scores Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract FileRoom DashBoard Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number FileRoom Insert

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel Favorites Prime Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Service Evaluation

6132017 YES 486 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Goals Compliance Evaluation

10272016 YES 460 View Docs (0)

6272018

Project Management Information System

Close

Contracts Central Administration

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9130 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-24

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6182018 YES 355 View Docs (1)

Proj Nbr 9320 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-20

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6132018 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9290 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-23

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1122018 YES 494 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-21

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12182017 YES 488 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10162017 YES 473 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

8252017 YES 495 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9321 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-19

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

7112017 YES 476 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-17

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2272017 YES 400 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

10132016 YES 384 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-12

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

5202016 YES 405 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9018 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-06

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10192015 YES 448 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

3202015 YES 385 View Docs (0)

Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL CONSULTANTS

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Project Management Information System

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-04

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12122014 YES 437 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-08

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1242014 YES 423 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-02

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2282014 YES 452 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC

VC0000044184 VC00044184 - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres PS $001 Used $000 Remain $001 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $354848400 Closed 0 Total $000 Total Current Retainage Balance For All Contracts $793370 No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 06292015 Purchase Orders 2 POs With A Total Amt Of $362317900 Paid To Dt ($218795160) Balance $143522740

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 40803 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9058 - DISTRICT 3A POTABLE WATER STORAGE

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1220410P1 - Consultant Engineering Services for Potable Water FixedOpen Contracts Storage Tanks and Pumping Systems Work Auth Prime Vendor CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Periodic Final Finish

Log Off Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type

Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

6232015 8302017 413 Approved 8312017 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard

Enter Vendor Name (or a portion of) Then Click Search - Wilcards Are Permitted (ie wa wawainc) Florida Technical Consultants

Search Reset Finish

No Vendors Found For Your Search Try Again

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41005 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score Go

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0773

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

12122017 YES 430 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

8302016 YES 438 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Final Consultant Evaluation 3142016 YES 478 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0706

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

142016 YES 402 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9016OES - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0731

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

10192015 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0748

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

612015 YES 467 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

2192015 YES 500 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0754

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

252015 YES 409 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0755

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

1242014 YES 415 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8974 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0758

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

6202014 YES 393 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr

WATER amp WASTEWATER

Final Consultant Work Authorization 572014 YES 423 View Docs

(0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

HS0746 ENGINEERING Evaluation

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

4302014 YES 475 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Evaluation 4302014 YES 493 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0710

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

3172014 YES 395 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0753

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

1212014 YES 380 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0763

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

11192013 YES 450 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0775

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 408 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals

Finish

Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed FileRoom DashBoard Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization FileRoom Insert NumberFavorites

Prime Vendor Export To Excel Sub Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0772

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 417 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0771

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

2262013 YES 410 View Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 13: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

Broward County Board of PNC211 5559P1 County Commissioners

BRCWARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LO ~ I DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P 1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis us Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

South Florida Water Management District

Contact Name Rich V irgil PE Title Bureau Chief lnfrabReference date 05142018

Contact Email rvirgilsfwmdgov Contact Phone 561 6826759

Name of Referenced Project S-193 Lock Refurbishment C-41A Canal Bank Stabilization Lake

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

4600000790 1001 2008 UP 12012016 $ 295400000

Vendors role in Project ]rime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Engineering Design and Engineering Services During Construction

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D [] DD c Deliverables []D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [L] D c Turnover D D D0

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget []D D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm [L]D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D 0 D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [] D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via ~AI L VERBAL Verified by ~~ Division WWfD Date ltQamp~(8 All lnformallon provided to Bltoward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate unlrulhful or incorrect statements made In support of this response may be used by the

512gt~11MlflS a lgtasis Of rejection rescission of the award or tenninallon of the contract and ~~lVcrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 of lhe Broward Count~ 41l6tlrelfient Code Y fTmiddot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BR~ltJWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LO R I DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering SeNices for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Saint Petersburg Department of Engineering and Capital Planning

Contact Name Nicole Allen Title CADDGIS Supervi Reference date

Contact Email nicoleallenstpeteorg Contact Phone 727-893-7316

Name of Referenced Project Water Resources Department GIS Data Migration

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

13-03-ARCIT 12092014 UP 09152015 $ 5925000

Vendors role in Project ]rime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again (Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Migration ofwater wastewater and storm water infrastructure information from CAD environment to Esri Local Government Information Model

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D [] D c Deliverables D [] D D

2 Vendors Organization [ZJa Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D [ZJ D c Turnover D D [] D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [ZJ D b Deliverables D D [ZJ D

4 Project completed within budget [ZJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [ZJ D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) [ZJD D D c Regu latory Agency(ies) D D [ZJ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONL rbullbull

Verified via L L VERBAL Verified by Division NlltE~ Date 6(~oatgt 1 8~ All information PfOvided to Bfoward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful oc inCOfrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

512gt9lillll jS a basis 10lt rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and nlll~9rrcrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of lhe Broward Cou~ 42fldtclrhtflent Code middot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BRuWARD1 1 COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering SeNices for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

C ity of Tavares F lorida

Contact Name James Dillon Title Public Works DireltaReference date 05172018

Contact Email jdillontavaresorg Contact Phone 352-455-7718

Name of Referenced Project G IS Modeling and Integration of Utilities Infrastructure

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

060330480000 04012017 UP 10012017 $ 5676000

Vendors role in Project ]rime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Integrate drawings and images depicting pipe infrastructure into a GIS environment for easy retrieval First project of a multi phase program to upgrade the Citys GIS information

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D 0 D c Deliverables D D 0 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D Ill D b Professionalism D D Ill D c Turnover D D 0 D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D Ill D b Deliverables D D Ill D

4 Project completed within budget D D Ill D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D Ill D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D Ill D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY -

Ve rified via L IL VERBAL Verified by fcAJ~ Division llt E1) Date 1 r~ tjlQ t8 All information pwvlded to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incooect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

512G91JlIHIS a basis for rejection rescission or the award or termination or the contract and lnfli~9ncrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 of the Broward CouI)~ 44flamplrelflent Code

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BRd~WARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LO R I DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Miramar

Contact Name Robin E Bain PE Title Project Manager Reference date 05142018

Contact Email rebainmiramarflgov Contact Phone 9548836825

Name of Referenced Project East Water Treatment Plant Replacement Wells and Design-Build

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PO 172624-00 10222017 UP 05142018 $ 56929600

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [ZJYes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Design permitting construction services for new Deep Injection Well and 4 new (replacement) production wells

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy []D D D c Deliverables D []D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D [ZJ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Turnover D D D []

3 Timeliness of a Project D D lZ1 D b Del iverables D D lZ1 D

4 Project completed within budget D D lZ1 D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor( s)Subconsultant( s) D D lZ1 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D lZ1 D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY (

Verified via A IL VER BAL Verified by faltJ~ Division WltEtgt Date 5 ~io l 9 All inlOllllalion pltovided to Broward County is subjecl lo verificalioo VendOt acknowledges lhal lnaccurale unlrulhful or i ncooecl stalemenls made in suppOltI of lhis response may be used by lhe

512gt~llM (lS a basis lot rejeclion rescission of the award or termination of lhe contract and mll~Arrcrve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuanl 10 Section 21119 of lhe Broward Couoty 43Pldtllrbrllent Code Y flmiddot

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Palm Beach County Water Utilities Department

Contact Name Ali Bayat Title Assistant Director Reference date

Contact Email abayatpbcwatercom Contact Phone 561 493 6128

Name of Referenced Project System 8 Water Quality Assessment

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

17-021 CSA21 01 022017 to 01152018 $ 8936000

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again (Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Brown and Caldwell led assessment of contributing causes to low system residuals troubleshooting treatment processes special testing and data analysis improvements to operating protocols monitoringcontrol system and treatment process

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [Z] D b Accuracy D [Z] DD c Deliverables D [Z]D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D [Z] D b Professionalism D D [Z] D c Turnover D [Z] DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D [Z] D

4 Project completed within budget D D [Z] D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Consultant worked collaboratively with operating maintenance engineering and laboratory staff to develop insight into contributing factors and implement improvements

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via _LEMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by tcltJ1~ Division -+LN euro P Date lteh IWt 8 All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the County as a basis for rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and may also serve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward County Procurement Code

BltaWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F L 0 R I D A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood Florida

Contact Name Steve Joseph Title Director Reference date

Contact Email sjosephhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954 921 3522

Name of Referenced Project Distribution System Water Quality Improvement

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

01012016 to 06022017 $ 3000000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again []Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Supported the City with its efforts improve chlorine residuals in areas of its system Analysis included system modeling monitoring optimized operational practices Implemented operational improvements that significantly raised (from approx 05 to 20 mgL) chloramine residuals In the most challenging area of the system

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D D [] D c Deliverables []D D D

2 Vendors Organization [] Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D [] D c Turnover D D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D [] D

4 Project completed within budget []D D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) []D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [] D

Additional Com ments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Effort Included system modoling moniloring and excursion response procedures opllmitallon of stored Inventory management unidirectional flushing pilot assessment and treatment proooss evaluation

Verified via __EMAIL vERBAL Division WW ED Date G Ifgt I 8 All infonmallon pltovided to Broward County Is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of thi s response may be used by lhe County as a basis for rejeclion rescission or the award or tenminatlon of the contract and may also serve as the basis for debanment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 or lhe Broward County Procurement Code

BROWARD t (l)t~ 1 Vendor Reference Verification Form

fl O R I OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of West Palm Beach Florida

Contact Name Jay Kwag Title Project Manager Reference date

Contact Email hjkwagwpborg Contact Phone 561 494 1041

Name of Referenced Project Modeling and Infrastructure General Engineering Consulting Assigments

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

11032014 to HAlt zc1e (on~vi~)

Vendors role in Project 52fPrime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IQves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Planning and General Eng1neerg Servicus 1nctuslve ol Waterwastewater System Master Pian asset management program dovo10pmenV11sset Crt1tcat1ty assessment Mesler PS 115 and sewer cond1hon assessment hydrauhc modeling ol LS 5 and force main sizing water system Capacity Analysis RoPort nydraullc modeling ol operahonat challongos tilt ste11on enatysbulls lac11i1a1e 1nspec11011 or major FM and new develOpmenl 1mpnc1s plpohno design lilt station condbullhon assessment and renabtlilahon (Various ProJecls)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D 0 D b Accuracy D 0D D c Deliverables D D 0 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D Gt D b Professionalism D D ~-- D c Turnover D D Gr D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D B D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget D D r~r D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D c~r D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D 0 D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION F~USE ONLY

__VERBAL Verified via LMAIL Verified by ~J Division ~~~D Date ~ f 2 f~t8 All lnfo11na1t0n pr ()Vl(fed 10 Broward County is svb1et110 ven11ca1ion vendor acknowledges lhll 1naeoura10 unlrulhful 0lt inc0ltrec1 s1a1emen1s medo In support ol 1n1s response may be used Dy the County as a basis fcu rejection re sclsst0n Of 1ho award or 1ormina1lon of l he contract and may also servo as the basis for debarment o f Vendor pursuant lo Section 21 119 of tho ampoward Counly P1ocuremont Code

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A middot

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Michael Low Title Deputy Director Reference date 05172018

Contact Email lowmbbflus Contact Phone 5617426403

Name of Referenced Project Ion Exchange Design Build

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

07022014 to 03212018 $ 100000000

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Carollo handled all of the design and construction of a significant part of the project as a subcontractor to COM Constructors as part of a progressive design build contract

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [Z] D b Accuracy D D [Z] D c Deliverables D D [Z] D

2 Vendors Organization D D [Z] Da Staff expertise b Professionalism D D [Z] D c Turnover D D D [Z]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D [Z] D

4 Project completed within budget D D [Z] D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D [Z] D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [Z] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION F~ COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ~~ Division W -NED Date S-gtozot~ All Information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor aclltnowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

Stii191111X 11s a basis for rejection rescission of the award or termination or the conlact and m~~Arifrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward CounYJ 33Plamptl1til1ent Code Y Imiddot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

B~OWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LORID A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

South Florida Water Management District

Contact Name Greg Coffelt PE Title SFWMD Project Manager Reference date 05172018

Contact Email gcoffeltsfwmdgov Contact Phone 561-682-6853

Name of Referenced Project L-8 Reservoir Inflow Structure and Pump Station

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

4600000861 02152011 to 09192012 $ 144535100

Vendors role in Project [l) Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [l)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Corolla was contracted as an Owners Advisor for a Design-Build contract developed engineering design criteria assisted in RFQ development and evaluation supported RFP technical proposal and cost proposal analysis

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [l] D b Accuracy D [] D D c Deliverables D [] D D

2 Vendors Organization [l]a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D [l] D c Turnover D D D [l]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [l] D b Deliverables D [l] D D

4 Project completed within budget [l] DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [l] D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) [l] DD D c Regu latory Agency(ies) D D D [l]

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Owner Advisor work continued(s) in support of Construction of Pump Station Inflow Gate Structure and levee hardening

Verified via IMAIL __VERBAL Date 5 ( 3 c b() I a All information piovided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that Inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made In support of this response may be used by the

512G9JiIX 11s a basis for rejection rescission or the award or termination or the contract and rllffl~Anampe as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 or the Broward CojlftYi 34~6ttlrbtflent Code Y

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

B0~~AARD ~~t~UNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

Fl ORIOA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Sunrise

Contact Name Luisa Fernanda Arbelaa Title Project Manager Reference date 05162018

Contact Email LArbelaezsunrlseflgov Contact Phone 954-888-6009

Name of Referenced Project City of Sunrise - Springtree WTP Water Stabilization and Solids Handling

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PA 16-003-CE 04072016 to 05292018 $ 50797800

Vendors role in Project ]Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [l]Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Carollo Engineers performed the design study and construction administration services for the City

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D G6 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Carollo Engineers technical knowledge and attenllon lo detall were beneficial lo the pltojad They ecled in lhe C~ys besl Interest In every aspect for lhe d1K8Uon of the projectbull

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via ~MAIL _VERBAL Verified by fc4J~~ Division W fl ED All lnrormalion provided to Broward ltAunty Is oobjoci to vorirtcotion Vendoc ecknowledgu that 1naowrate unlMhfuf 0lt lncocrecl statements rnado In support or this response may be useltI by lhe County as a basis for rejection rescission or the award 0lt termination ol the convect and may also ampOIVe as the babullibull ror debarmont of vondOlt purauont to Section 21119 or the Broward County Proc11oment Code

Bid Sync p 135 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BftQNARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

I l 0 R I 0 A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Florida Technical Consultants

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

VIiiage of Wellington Utilities

Contact Name Bradley Wolak Title Assistant Director Ut11Reference date 5182018

Contact Email bwolakwelllngtonflgov Contact Phone 561-753-2480

Name of Referenced Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 10012017 to Present 3500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vend~ 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again UZfYes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor J_ rJ fJ j(Gr-~k 6 Jti ov1 ~uf-Jiy fgt-r_- syrrzi~ff~ Al

R Q_ d--1 0~l 4 171 i+CI ~~lHI )Please rate your experience with tile Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Applicablereferenced Vendor Improvement

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy B D

DD c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D Db Professionalism D D

c Turnover D DD 3 Timeliness of

a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant(s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Additional Comments (provide on addltjpnal sheetJf needed) bull ~middot$ -JJ fo~~rltjbull lt( c-c_ ~~~ lt fo L1-lfAR- -middot~ I 10 ~ ~

~ bullL ~~ _te_ l~Ilgt~Cef t J ~ l rfbull4 middot r0 laquo r 4111J w f1 rrr- 0r- -i-HIS SECTION(9R COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by fcAJc ~ Division Y-1 IN ED Date 5 ~o w8 All lnfonn1Uon ptollfded to BlOward County le eubjeet to vetfflcatlon Vendor aclltnowledge1 that lneccurale unllJlhfUl or lnconect -bullmenla made In 1UPPort o1 this reopon90 may be uoec1 by the couniy ae a baalS ror re)ectlon re8Claeton Of the award 0t leltmlnatlon Of the contract and may 1l10 MM ae the baale flaquo debarrnont 01 vendor pu11uant to Section 21119 of ll1e Broward County Procurement Codo

BidSync p 18 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F LUFltIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultants LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Palm Beach Public Works

Contact Name Gerry Vazquez Title WRD Technician Reference date 05182018

Contact Email gvazqueztownofpalmbeachcom Contact Phone 772-546-6859

Name of Referenced Project GIS Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 3242014 to Present 13500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [3yenes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

PrwAamprs- favl49z Please rate your experience with the Need a Satlafactory Excellent Not

Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D g- D b Accuracy D Er D c Deliverables g-shyB D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D GJ D b Professionalism D D G- D c Tu mover D D cg- D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D g D b Deliverables D D Qshy D

4 Project completed within budget D D lbJ- D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D El- Db Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [3- D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

BidSync p 17 51232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

120-nWARDLll~ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form fLORllgtA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultant LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Waneya Bryant Title Meter Serv Mgr Reference date 05182018

Contact Email BryantWbbflus Contact Phone 561-742-6427

Name of Referenced Project Boynton Beach Utility GIS Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 12012016 to Present $15000000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

~T~ 5e-r-vtleamp +roM l)h f-es Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D Dc Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ti4 D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ Db Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on addlUonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION~urv USE ONLy u bull

Verified via VEMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by kuJ~ Division W if E D rao(ao8Date 5

All Information provided to Browslaquo COOlty Is Slbject to verfflcation Vendor acKnowledges that lneocurate Untruthful or lncolleel 8tatements made In support d this rfl9pOn98 may be used by 1119 Counly as a batia falt rejection relduion ct Ille award or lemilnlilon of the contract and may al80181Veaa1119 basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 ot Ille Broward CountyProcurement Code

512312018 BidSync p 16

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1

8W1V~isl1War Bid PNC21 15559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Fonn

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Cooper City - middot

Contact Name Michael Bailey PE itle Utilities DlrCity EbullReference date 05011201s

Contact Email MBalleycoopercityflorg Contact Phone (954) 434-5519

Name of Referenced Project City of Cooper City Continuing Professional Services bullContract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

RFQ 2009middot 1 04242009 to Present $ 2 19844200

Vendors role in Project IZJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Since 2009 Hazen has provided Cooper City with engineering services or water and wastewater projects Projects have lnctudeo lhe Pine Island Road Pump Station Lilt S1alions 2 amp 49 Improvements Master Plan Update of the FeaslJl~lty Review of Infrastructure Improvements tor Wastewater and the Eflluent Reuse and Disposal Master Plan

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy 8 D

D ~ D c Deliverables D 0 ~ D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D 0 D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tumover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D GJ- D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D 0 D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) ~D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

bull-rHIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY-

Verified vie EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ct4~ Division ~tUb Date ~ i3~) 0fgt All Information provided to BltCgtWW County 11 wbed ID vamprificalion Velldot adltnowledgu that lnaoewate unlrUhful lncom1ct statemampnla made in wppolt of 11111 response may blt uHd by the

4t2j=~ rejection rHclsslcn of th8 award or lennhallon of Ille eoo1nlct and may also seNamp at tilt basis for dtbarmenl at Vendor puuan1 lo Sectioo 21119 of the Broward COltJi 43

5232018 Bid Sync p24

Broward County Board of PNC211 5559P1

~RiiirilyenlcHUffi~~8CrW~r Bid PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

8DdMARD _ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FL O RIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Fort Lauderdale

Contact Name Rares Patrica PE Title Senior Project Mgr Reference date os1021201s

Contact Email RPetricafortlauderdalegov Contact Phone 9548287150

Name of Referenced Project Stormwater Master Planning and Design Implementation Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

256-11660 04192016 to 04192021 $ 989400000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

vyould you use this vendor again Sves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor The Hazen team Is responsible for delivery of a new stormwaler master plan model a prlorlllzed slormwaterresllency capital Improvements plan and Implementation of designs to address chronic flooding and other slormwater management challenges In the City Primary work tasks Include data collectlon hydrologlclhydraullc modeling and design permitting and construction services for capllal Improvement projects resulting from the revised stormwater master plan (preltmlnary design In seven priority neighborhoods)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION ~R COUNTY USE ONLY

aJ~Verified via pound MA IL _VERBAL Verified by Division W1~tl Date 5 ~3o~ax l S N I informallon p roviltled lo Broward County is sulljecl lo verification Vendor altknowledjj6s lhal inaccurate unlMhlut or lncotreci statements m ade In support of this respon$e may be used by tho

412~-~ rejeclion rescission of the award or termination ol lhe contracl and may also serve as lhe basis for debalment ol Vendor purwant to Section 21119 ol lhe Broward Cou~ 4 3

5232018 Bid Sync p25

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 Br~~~~~rs Bid PNC2115559P1 County t ommissioners

B~uWARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FlOR I CA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

Solicitation PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and s OrganizationFirm Name p

Town of Jupiter

nee

Contact Email davidbjupiterflus Contact Phone (561) 746-5134

Name of Referenced Project Engineering Services for Stormwater and Water Capital Improvements

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount $ 630000000 W17248 (2017 reselection 1012000 to Present (estimated lee-to-date since contract inception) contract number)

Vendors role in Project IZI Prime Vendor osubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again 0Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Descriotion of services orovided bv Vendor Since 2000 Hazen has served as General Consulfant to the Town or Jupiter As General Stormwater and Water Consullant the firm has provided services related to master planning stormwater planning and modeling design NPDES permilling asset management resiliency ratefinancial analysis plan review and construction oversight Water-related capital projs have involved additional system storage and high-service pumping transmission system improvements and RampR at existing facilities

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Verllied via EMAIL _ VERBAL Division WWC D

fo (J-Vv ~ltIvmiddotj Date 5(30(ipf S

Al lnroimallon pngtYICGd 10 Broward Counly Is sub)oel to v8flrcallon vendlaquo acknowledges lhat Inaccurate unlruthlu~ 0t Jnwrrect slatoments made In support ol this response may be used by the 42~~1~0 rojecllon rescission or Ille award or termination or lhe con~acl bullnd mbully also serve as tho basis r0t debarment of Vendor pursuant lo Socllon 21119 of lho Broward Couw 41

5232018 BidSync p 26

a N ~ IL) IL) N u z a_

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLO RI DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Walter Wernecke RA Title Sr Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email WWERNECKEhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Hollywood Marina Restrooms

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

04152015 to Present 7500000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor OSubconsultanVSubcontractor n ~U t1

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

-0 Vgt Description of services provided by VendorO ~ ~ Q) Structural Design and Construction Inspection Services i co Q m ~- c E c0

i E gt Oo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not () uu Appllcable O

E~ referenced Vendor Improvement iii ~sectoO 1 Vendors Quality of Service B mu a Responsive D D

b Accuracy DD c Deliverables D DD

2 Vendors Organization D Da Staff expertise v D b Professionalism~ D D c Turnover D ~D

3 Timeliness of D a Project b Deliverables D ~

4 Pec~~11~$~hinJ~~qt lfr D D 5 Cooperation with f ~

a Your Firm D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D

Al lnfonn1tion pRgttded IO Brwd Cltgtunly lo 1ubjecl IO ibllon vsor ~middot Iha icl-bullmiddot ~ ir-ect slalemenls mode In _ol lhb _ moy ti used by he County as a basis lot rejecUon rnclnlon cl the eward or tonnlnallan of lhl connct 1nd may bullllo 11 the basis for dobalment of Vendor IQtulnl IO SICllOn 21119 at lhe Broword County Procurement Code

Cl ltraquo I() I() I() N ()

Cl z

BRltJWARD ~ middot COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORl OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Davie

Contact Name Emilio DeSimone Title Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email Emilio_DeSimonedavie-fl gov Contact Phone 954-797-1085

Name of Referenced Project Pavillion 5 Linear Park

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

B-17-123 09152015 to 2700000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor O SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es O No If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

0 Description of services provided by Vendor O Q)

iii c Structural Design and Construction Inspection ServicesoQ

CDi-

0cc E gt=gt E ()Oo O () () Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

ii) -e i- Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 111 cs

B ioO

J 1 Vendors Quality of Service Q ()

a Responsive D D b Accuracy D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization []Ll Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D Dtr

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [g D b Deliverables D D ar D

4 Project completed within budget [1tD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) cgD D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via l EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by ~h~ Division WlI Etgt Date 0 f l~o I 8 All lnformaUon provided lO Broward County Is eubJect 10 verifutlon Vendor ecknOMedgoo that lnaocurote unNlhlul or Incorrect statamenle made In aupl)Ort of this reaponse may be used by lho County et o baampla for rejection realtluion of the award or lermlnallon of tho eon1fllcl ond moy olao aorvo os ho basis for debarmont of Vondor purauenl lo Section 21119 of the Broward Counly Procuremen1 Code

0 0 agt a c () z 0

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Terrence Comiskey AIA Title Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email TCOMISKEYhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Van Buren Parking Garage

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PK 14-053 Nov 2014 to Present 8310000

Vendors role in Project t8(Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

o~ Description of services provided by Vendor 1 Q)ltO c Structural Design and Conslructlon Inspection Services 0 Q

0~Jl ccE l E enOo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

gtshy

uu O Improvement Applicable ffireferenced Vendor

~sect 1 Vendors Quality of Service 1 ~

oOau a Responsive D ~ D b Accuracy B D D

D D [- Dc Deliverables

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tum over D D D g

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ D Subcontractor(s )S ubcons u ltant( s)b D D ~ D

c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D yenj D Additional Comments provide on sdditlonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION ~NTY USE ONLY0

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by kW Division W-1-(i~ Date EJo(a~t8 Al lnform1Uon PltOVlded lo Browald Ccxnty It IUbjoct to vorificallon Vendor eoknowfodgea thal lnaewralt U111MhlJI deg inlaquogtlaquobullel amptal11ants made In eupporl of lhls relj)Onse may be used by Iha Counly es a balls l0t rcfecllon rescfuloltI of tho ew1rd or 1ermtnaU0lt1 ol lhbull conllllCI and may elao urve 11 lho basis for dabarmenl of Vondor pursuanl lo Secllon 21 119 of he erowald COUlly CiProcurement Code

~ N ii

00

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 aOWllrp Commficumlref Bid PNC2116615B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Pompano Beach FL

Contact Name Mr A Randolph Brown Title Utilities Director Reference date April 30 2018

Contact Email randolphbrowncopbflcom Contact Phone 954-545-7043

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 201 o Project Amount fees varied

Multiple

Vendors role in Project IKJ Prime Vendor

to 2018

osubconsultanUSubcontractor

(range $10000shy$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D ~ D D c Deliverables D ~ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D ~ D D b Professionalism D D ~ D C Turnover D El DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ 0 b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D [BJ D n c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [XJ o ~

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed) amp~~it -THIS SECTION ~COUNTY USE ONL y-bullbull

Verified via ~AIL __VERBAL Verified by 1lt4 )~ Division N WE O Date 5 faol Z1 18

All lnformotlon providod to BltownrltI Cou nty it aubjoct O verification VendOr acknowledges that lnaccornto untruthful or incorroct 11atomon1s made in support of this response may be used by tho

411p~~)~~J rojoclion roscissioo ol lho award or 1orroinalion of tho contract and roay also s01vo as lhbull basis f0lt d~arroont of VondOf pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward Cou)l1

Bid Sync p 73

40

5232018

Broward County Board of Bid PNC2116659B 1 County Commissioners

B~aWARD gt1- t COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Loxahatchee River Environmental Control District

Contact Name Mr Kris Dean Title Director of Engineering Reference date May 9 2018

Contact Email krisdeanloxahatcheeriverorg Contact Phone 561-747-5700

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 2001 Project Amount fees varied (range $10000shyMultiple to 2018 $250000)

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IR)Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D ~ D D b Accuracy D 0 D D c Deliverables D IBJ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D IB] D D b Professionalism D ~ D D c Turnover D [8J D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D [8J D D b Deliverables D m D D

4 Project completed within budget D ~ D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D ~ D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D Ii] D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D ~ D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SE~ FOR~USE ONLY

Verified via _lEMAIL __VERBAL Verified by ~lt Division fWeb Date I

All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untrulhful or incorrecl slatements made In support of this response may be used by the lJl~~~l~~jSfiir rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and mll~~~ere as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Co)f 10

Broward County Board of Bid PNC21166$9B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A l

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Lake Worth FL

Contact Name Mr Felipe Lofaso TitleAsst Dir Public-ServicesReference date May 9 2018

Contact Email flofasolakeworthorg Contact Phone 561-586-1720

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contract

Contract No Date Services Provided 2014 Project Amount fees varied Multiple to 2018 (range $10000shy

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Services included multiple municipal engineering projects including survey roadway design utility design and coordination (water wastewater stormwater other) along with project management

Needs Satisfactory Excellent NotPlease rate your experience with the Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D GJ D b Accuracy D D Ii] D c Deliverables D Ii] DD

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [i] D c Turnover D D D [X]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D 0 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [X] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION Fe COUNTY USE ONLrbullbull

Verified via MAIL __VERBAL Verified by Division ~wgtgt Date 5~3ol20t8 All information provided to Broward County Is subject lo verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect slalements made in support ol this response may be used by the

OZ~id~~~~j~r rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and m~~~(iirve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Cour~ iG

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - ARCADIS US INC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts

VS0000013130 VS00013130 - ARCADIS US INC Prime Work Auth Vendor SummaryProjects

PURCHASING 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold Procurement No Fixed Contracts FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Favorites Past 5 Years Prime Vendor

Sub Vendor From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 10042017 Purchase Order

Evaluation Purchase Orders 1 POs With A Total Amt Of $20000000 Log Off Paid To Dt ($12132949) Balance $7867051

Contracts Purchase Orders Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx 6192018

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Finish

PURCHASING Weighted Scores Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract FileRoom DashBoard Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number FileRoom Insert

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel Favorites Prime Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Service Evaluation

6132017 YES 486 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Goals Compliance Evaluation

10272016 YES 460 View Docs (0)

6272018

Project Management Information System

Close

Contracts Central Administration

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9130 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-24

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6182018 YES 355 View Docs (1)

Proj Nbr 9320 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-20

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6132018 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9290 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-23

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1122018 YES 494 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-21

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12182017 YES 488 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10162017 YES 473 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

8252017 YES 495 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9321 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-19

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

7112017 YES 476 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-17

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2272017 YES 400 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

10132016 YES 384 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-12

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

5202016 YES 405 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9018 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-06

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10192015 YES 448 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

3202015 YES 385 View Docs (0)

Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL CONSULTANTS

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Project Management Information System

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-04

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12122014 YES 437 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-08

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1242014 YES 423 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-02

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2282014 YES 452 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC

VC0000044184 VC00044184 - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres PS $001 Used $000 Remain $001 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $354848400 Closed 0 Total $000 Total Current Retainage Balance For All Contracts $793370 No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 06292015 Purchase Orders 2 POs With A Total Amt Of $362317900 Paid To Dt ($218795160) Balance $143522740

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 40803 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9058 - DISTRICT 3A POTABLE WATER STORAGE

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1220410P1 - Consultant Engineering Services for Potable Water FixedOpen Contracts Storage Tanks and Pumping Systems Work Auth Prime Vendor CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Periodic Final Finish

Log Off Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type

Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

6232015 8302017 413 Approved 8312017 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard

Enter Vendor Name (or a portion of) Then Click Search - Wilcards Are Permitted (ie wa wawainc) Florida Technical Consultants

Search Reset Finish

No Vendors Found For Your Search Try Again

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41005 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score Go

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0773

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

12122017 YES 430 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

8302016 YES 438 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Final Consultant Evaluation 3142016 YES 478 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0706

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

142016 YES 402 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9016OES - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0731

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

10192015 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0748

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

612015 YES 467 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

2192015 YES 500 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0754

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

252015 YES 409 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0755

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

1242014 YES 415 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8974 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0758

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

6202014 YES 393 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr

WATER amp WASTEWATER

Final Consultant Work Authorization 572014 YES 423 View Docs

(0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

HS0746 ENGINEERING Evaluation

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

4302014 YES 475 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Evaluation 4302014 YES 493 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0710

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

3172014 YES 395 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0753

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

1212014 YES 380 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0763

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

11192013 YES 450 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0775

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 408 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals

Finish

Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed FileRoom DashBoard Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization FileRoom Insert NumberFavorites

Prime Vendor Export To Excel Sub Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0772

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 417 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0771

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

2262013 YES 410 View Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 14: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BR~ltJWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LO R I DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering SeNices for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Saint Petersburg Department of Engineering and Capital Planning

Contact Name Nicole Allen Title CADDGIS Supervi Reference date

Contact Email nicoleallenstpeteorg Contact Phone 727-893-7316

Name of Referenced Project Water Resources Department GIS Data Migration

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

13-03-ARCIT 12092014 UP 09152015 $ 5925000

Vendors role in Project ]rime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again (Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Migration ofwater wastewater and storm water infrastructure information from CAD environment to Esri Local Government Information Model

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D [] D c Deliverables D [] D D

2 Vendors Organization [ZJa Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D [ZJ D c Turnover D D [] D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [ZJ D b Deliverables D D [ZJ D

4 Project completed within budget [ZJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [ZJ D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) [ZJD D D c Regu latory Agency(ies) D D [ZJ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONL rbullbull

Verified via L L VERBAL Verified by Division NlltE~ Date 6(~oatgt 1 8~ All information PfOvided to Bfoward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful oc inCOfrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

512gt9lillll jS a basis 10lt rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and nlll~9rrcrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of lhe Broward Cou~ 42fldtclrhtflent Code middot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BRuWARD1 1 COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering SeNices for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

C ity of Tavares F lorida

Contact Name James Dillon Title Public Works DireltaReference date 05172018

Contact Email jdillontavaresorg Contact Phone 352-455-7718

Name of Referenced Project G IS Modeling and Integration of Utilities Infrastructure

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

060330480000 04012017 UP 10012017 $ 5676000

Vendors role in Project ]rime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Integrate drawings and images depicting pipe infrastructure into a GIS environment for easy retrieval First project of a multi phase program to upgrade the Citys GIS information

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D 0 D c Deliverables D D 0 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D Ill D b Professionalism D D Ill D c Turnover D D 0 D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D Ill D b Deliverables D D Ill D

4 Project completed within budget D D Ill D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D Ill D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D Ill D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY -

Ve rified via L IL VERBAL Verified by fcAJ~ Division llt E1) Date 1 r~ tjlQ t8 All information pwvlded to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incooect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

512G91JlIHIS a basis for rejection rescission or the award or termination or the contract and lnfli~9ncrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 of the Broward CouI)~ 44flamplrelflent Code

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BRd~WARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LO R I DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Miramar

Contact Name Robin E Bain PE Title Project Manager Reference date 05142018

Contact Email rebainmiramarflgov Contact Phone 9548836825

Name of Referenced Project East Water Treatment Plant Replacement Wells and Design-Build

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PO 172624-00 10222017 UP 05142018 $ 56929600

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [ZJYes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Design permitting construction services for new Deep Injection Well and 4 new (replacement) production wells

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy []D D D c Deliverables D []D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D [ZJ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Turnover D D D []

3 Timeliness of a Project D D lZ1 D b Del iverables D D lZ1 D

4 Project completed within budget D D lZ1 D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor( s)Subconsultant( s) D D lZ1 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D lZ1 D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY (

Verified via A IL VER BAL Verified by faltJ~ Division WltEtgt Date 5 ~io l 9 All inlOllllalion pltovided to Broward County is subjecl lo verificalioo VendOt acknowledges lhal lnaccurale unlrulhful or i ncooecl stalemenls made in suppOltI of lhis response may be used by lhe

512gt~llM (lS a basis lot rejeclion rescission of the award or termination of lhe contract and mll~Arrcrve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuanl 10 Section 21119 of lhe Broward Couoty 43Pldtllrbrllent Code Y flmiddot

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Palm Beach County Water Utilities Department

Contact Name Ali Bayat Title Assistant Director Reference date

Contact Email abayatpbcwatercom Contact Phone 561 493 6128

Name of Referenced Project System 8 Water Quality Assessment

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

17-021 CSA21 01 022017 to 01152018 $ 8936000

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again (Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Brown and Caldwell led assessment of contributing causes to low system residuals troubleshooting treatment processes special testing and data analysis improvements to operating protocols monitoringcontrol system and treatment process

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [Z] D b Accuracy D [Z] DD c Deliverables D [Z]D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D [Z] D b Professionalism D D [Z] D c Turnover D [Z] DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D [Z] D

4 Project completed within budget D D [Z] D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Consultant worked collaboratively with operating maintenance engineering and laboratory staff to develop insight into contributing factors and implement improvements

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via _LEMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by tcltJ1~ Division -+LN euro P Date lteh IWt 8 All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the County as a basis for rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and may also serve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward County Procurement Code

BltaWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F L 0 R I D A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood Florida

Contact Name Steve Joseph Title Director Reference date

Contact Email sjosephhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954 921 3522

Name of Referenced Project Distribution System Water Quality Improvement

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

01012016 to 06022017 $ 3000000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again []Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Supported the City with its efforts improve chlorine residuals in areas of its system Analysis included system modeling monitoring optimized operational practices Implemented operational improvements that significantly raised (from approx 05 to 20 mgL) chloramine residuals In the most challenging area of the system

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D D [] D c Deliverables []D D D

2 Vendors Organization [] Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D [] D c Turnover D D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D [] D

4 Project completed within budget []D D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) []D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [] D

Additional Com ments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Effort Included system modoling moniloring and excursion response procedures opllmitallon of stored Inventory management unidirectional flushing pilot assessment and treatment proooss evaluation

Verified via __EMAIL vERBAL Division WW ED Date G Ifgt I 8 All infonmallon pltovided to Broward County Is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of thi s response may be used by lhe County as a basis for rejeclion rescission or the award or tenminatlon of the contract and may also serve as the basis for debanment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 or lhe Broward County Procurement Code

BROWARD t (l)t~ 1 Vendor Reference Verification Form

fl O R I OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of West Palm Beach Florida

Contact Name Jay Kwag Title Project Manager Reference date

Contact Email hjkwagwpborg Contact Phone 561 494 1041

Name of Referenced Project Modeling and Infrastructure General Engineering Consulting Assigments

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

11032014 to HAlt zc1e (on~vi~)

Vendors role in Project 52fPrime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IQves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Planning and General Eng1neerg Servicus 1nctuslve ol Waterwastewater System Master Pian asset management program dovo10pmenV11sset Crt1tcat1ty assessment Mesler PS 115 and sewer cond1hon assessment hydrauhc modeling ol LS 5 and force main sizing water system Capacity Analysis RoPort nydraullc modeling ol operahonat challongos tilt ste11on enatysbulls lac11i1a1e 1nspec11011 or major FM and new develOpmenl 1mpnc1s plpohno design lilt station condbullhon assessment and renabtlilahon (Various ProJecls)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D 0 D b Accuracy D 0D D c Deliverables D D 0 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D Gt D b Professionalism D D ~-- D c Turnover D D Gr D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D B D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget D D r~r D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D c~r D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D 0 D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION F~USE ONLY

__VERBAL Verified via LMAIL Verified by ~J Division ~~~D Date ~ f 2 f~t8 All lnfo11na1t0n pr ()Vl(fed 10 Broward County is svb1et110 ven11ca1ion vendor acknowledges lhll 1naeoura10 unlrulhful 0lt inc0ltrec1 s1a1emen1s medo In support ol 1n1s response may be used Dy the County as a basis fcu rejection re sclsst0n Of 1ho award or 1ormina1lon of l he contract and may also servo as the basis for debarment o f Vendor pursuant lo Section 21 119 of tho ampoward Counly P1ocuremont Code

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A middot

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Michael Low Title Deputy Director Reference date 05172018

Contact Email lowmbbflus Contact Phone 5617426403

Name of Referenced Project Ion Exchange Design Build

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

07022014 to 03212018 $ 100000000

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Carollo handled all of the design and construction of a significant part of the project as a subcontractor to COM Constructors as part of a progressive design build contract

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [Z] D b Accuracy D D [Z] D c Deliverables D D [Z] D

2 Vendors Organization D D [Z] Da Staff expertise b Professionalism D D [Z] D c Turnover D D D [Z]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D [Z] D

4 Project completed within budget D D [Z] D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D [Z] D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [Z] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION F~ COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ~~ Division W -NED Date S-gtozot~ All Information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor aclltnowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

Stii191111X 11s a basis for rejection rescission of the award or termination or the conlact and m~~Arifrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward CounYJ 33Plamptl1til1ent Code Y Imiddot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

B~OWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LORID A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

South Florida Water Management District

Contact Name Greg Coffelt PE Title SFWMD Project Manager Reference date 05172018

Contact Email gcoffeltsfwmdgov Contact Phone 561-682-6853

Name of Referenced Project L-8 Reservoir Inflow Structure and Pump Station

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

4600000861 02152011 to 09192012 $ 144535100

Vendors role in Project [l) Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [l)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Corolla was contracted as an Owners Advisor for a Design-Build contract developed engineering design criteria assisted in RFQ development and evaluation supported RFP technical proposal and cost proposal analysis

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [l] D b Accuracy D [] D D c Deliverables D [] D D

2 Vendors Organization [l]a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D [l] D c Turnover D D D [l]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [l] D b Deliverables D [l] D D

4 Project completed within budget [l] DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [l] D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) [l] DD D c Regu latory Agency(ies) D D D [l]

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Owner Advisor work continued(s) in support of Construction of Pump Station Inflow Gate Structure and levee hardening

Verified via IMAIL __VERBAL Date 5 ( 3 c b() I a All information piovided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that Inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made In support of this response may be used by the

512G9JiIX 11s a basis for rejection rescission or the award or termination or the contract and rllffl~Anampe as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 or the Broward CojlftYi 34~6ttlrbtflent Code Y

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

B0~~AARD ~~t~UNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

Fl ORIOA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Sunrise

Contact Name Luisa Fernanda Arbelaa Title Project Manager Reference date 05162018

Contact Email LArbelaezsunrlseflgov Contact Phone 954-888-6009

Name of Referenced Project City of Sunrise - Springtree WTP Water Stabilization and Solids Handling

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PA 16-003-CE 04072016 to 05292018 $ 50797800

Vendors role in Project ]Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [l]Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Carollo Engineers performed the design study and construction administration services for the City

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D G6 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Carollo Engineers technical knowledge and attenllon lo detall were beneficial lo the pltojad They ecled in lhe C~ys besl Interest In every aspect for lhe d1K8Uon of the projectbull

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via ~MAIL _VERBAL Verified by fc4J~~ Division W fl ED All lnrormalion provided to Broward ltAunty Is oobjoci to vorirtcotion Vendoc ecknowledgu that 1naowrate unlMhfuf 0lt lncocrecl statements rnado In support or this response may be useltI by lhe County as a basis for rejection rescission or the award 0lt termination ol the convect and may also ampOIVe as the babullibull ror debarmont of vondOlt purauont to Section 21119 or the Broward County Proc11oment Code

Bid Sync p 135 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BftQNARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

I l 0 R I 0 A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Florida Technical Consultants

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

VIiiage of Wellington Utilities

Contact Name Bradley Wolak Title Assistant Director Ut11Reference date 5182018

Contact Email bwolakwelllngtonflgov Contact Phone 561-753-2480

Name of Referenced Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 10012017 to Present 3500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vend~ 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again UZfYes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor J_ rJ fJ j(Gr-~k 6 Jti ov1 ~uf-Jiy fgt-r_- syrrzi~ff~ Al

R Q_ d--1 0~l 4 171 i+CI ~~lHI )Please rate your experience with tile Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Applicablereferenced Vendor Improvement

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy B D

DD c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D Db Professionalism D D

c Turnover D DD 3 Timeliness of

a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant(s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Additional Comments (provide on addltjpnal sheetJf needed) bull ~middot$ -JJ fo~~rltjbull lt( c-c_ ~~~ lt fo L1-lfAR- -middot~ I 10 ~ ~

~ bullL ~~ _te_ l~Ilgt~Cef t J ~ l rfbull4 middot r0 laquo r 4111J w f1 rrr- 0r- -i-HIS SECTION(9R COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by fcAJc ~ Division Y-1 IN ED Date 5 ~o w8 All lnfonn1Uon ptollfded to BlOward County le eubjeet to vetfflcatlon Vendor aclltnowledge1 that lneccurale unllJlhfUl or lnconect -bullmenla made In 1UPPort o1 this reopon90 may be uoec1 by the couniy ae a baalS ror re)ectlon re8Claeton Of the award 0t leltmlnatlon Of the contract and may 1l10 MM ae the baale flaquo debarrnont 01 vendor pu11uant to Section 21119 of ll1e Broward County Procurement Codo

BidSync p 18 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F LUFltIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultants LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Palm Beach Public Works

Contact Name Gerry Vazquez Title WRD Technician Reference date 05182018

Contact Email gvazqueztownofpalmbeachcom Contact Phone 772-546-6859

Name of Referenced Project GIS Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 3242014 to Present 13500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [3yenes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

PrwAamprs- favl49z Please rate your experience with the Need a Satlafactory Excellent Not

Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D g- D b Accuracy D Er D c Deliverables g-shyB D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D GJ D b Professionalism D D G- D c Tu mover D D cg- D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D g D b Deliverables D D Qshy D

4 Project completed within budget D D lbJ- D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D El- Db Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [3- D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

BidSync p 17 51232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

120-nWARDLll~ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form fLORllgtA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultant LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Waneya Bryant Title Meter Serv Mgr Reference date 05182018

Contact Email BryantWbbflus Contact Phone 561-742-6427

Name of Referenced Project Boynton Beach Utility GIS Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 12012016 to Present $15000000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

~T~ 5e-r-vtleamp +roM l)h f-es Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D Dc Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ti4 D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ Db Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on addlUonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION~urv USE ONLy u bull

Verified via VEMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by kuJ~ Division W if E D rao(ao8Date 5

All Information provided to Browslaquo COOlty Is Slbject to verfflcation Vendor acKnowledges that lneocurate Untruthful or lncolleel 8tatements made In support d this rfl9pOn98 may be used by 1119 Counly as a batia falt rejection relduion ct Ille award or lemilnlilon of the contract and may al80181Veaa1119 basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 ot Ille Broward CountyProcurement Code

512312018 BidSync p 16

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1

8W1V~isl1War Bid PNC21 15559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Fonn

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Cooper City - middot

Contact Name Michael Bailey PE itle Utilities DlrCity EbullReference date 05011201s

Contact Email MBalleycoopercityflorg Contact Phone (954) 434-5519

Name of Referenced Project City of Cooper City Continuing Professional Services bullContract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

RFQ 2009middot 1 04242009 to Present $ 2 19844200

Vendors role in Project IZJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Since 2009 Hazen has provided Cooper City with engineering services or water and wastewater projects Projects have lnctudeo lhe Pine Island Road Pump Station Lilt S1alions 2 amp 49 Improvements Master Plan Update of the FeaslJl~lty Review of Infrastructure Improvements tor Wastewater and the Eflluent Reuse and Disposal Master Plan

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy 8 D

D ~ D c Deliverables D 0 ~ D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D 0 D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tumover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D GJ- D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D 0 D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) ~D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

bull-rHIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY-

Verified vie EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ct4~ Division ~tUb Date ~ i3~) 0fgt All Information provided to BltCgtWW County 11 wbed ID vamprificalion Velldot adltnowledgu that lnaoewate unlrUhful lncom1ct statemampnla made in wppolt of 11111 response may blt uHd by the

4t2j=~ rejection rHclsslcn of th8 award or lennhallon of Ille eoo1nlct and may also seNamp at tilt basis for dtbarmenl at Vendor puuan1 lo Sectioo 21119 of the Broward COltJi 43

5232018 Bid Sync p24

Broward County Board of PNC211 5559P1

~RiiirilyenlcHUffi~~8CrW~r Bid PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

8DdMARD _ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FL O RIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Fort Lauderdale

Contact Name Rares Patrica PE Title Senior Project Mgr Reference date os1021201s

Contact Email RPetricafortlauderdalegov Contact Phone 9548287150

Name of Referenced Project Stormwater Master Planning and Design Implementation Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

256-11660 04192016 to 04192021 $ 989400000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

vyould you use this vendor again Sves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor The Hazen team Is responsible for delivery of a new stormwaler master plan model a prlorlllzed slormwaterresllency capital Improvements plan and Implementation of designs to address chronic flooding and other slormwater management challenges In the City Primary work tasks Include data collectlon hydrologlclhydraullc modeling and design permitting and construction services for capllal Improvement projects resulting from the revised stormwater master plan (preltmlnary design In seven priority neighborhoods)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION ~R COUNTY USE ONLY

aJ~Verified via pound MA IL _VERBAL Verified by Division W1~tl Date 5 ~3o~ax l S N I informallon p roviltled lo Broward County is sulljecl lo verification Vendor altknowledjj6s lhal inaccurate unlMhlut or lncotreci statements m ade In support of this respon$e may be used by tho

412~-~ rejeclion rescission of the award or termination ol lhe contracl and may also serve as lhe basis for debalment ol Vendor purwant to Section 21119 ol lhe Broward Cou~ 4 3

5232018 Bid Sync p25

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 Br~~~~~rs Bid PNC2115559P1 County t ommissioners

B~uWARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FlOR I CA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

Solicitation PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and s OrganizationFirm Name p

Town of Jupiter

nee

Contact Email davidbjupiterflus Contact Phone (561) 746-5134

Name of Referenced Project Engineering Services for Stormwater and Water Capital Improvements

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount $ 630000000 W17248 (2017 reselection 1012000 to Present (estimated lee-to-date since contract inception) contract number)

Vendors role in Project IZI Prime Vendor osubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again 0Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Descriotion of services orovided bv Vendor Since 2000 Hazen has served as General Consulfant to the Town or Jupiter As General Stormwater and Water Consullant the firm has provided services related to master planning stormwater planning and modeling design NPDES permilling asset management resiliency ratefinancial analysis plan review and construction oversight Water-related capital projs have involved additional system storage and high-service pumping transmission system improvements and RampR at existing facilities

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Verllied via EMAIL _ VERBAL Division WWC D

fo (J-Vv ~ltIvmiddotj Date 5(30(ipf S

Al lnroimallon pngtYICGd 10 Broward Counly Is sub)oel to v8flrcallon vendlaquo acknowledges lhat Inaccurate unlruthlu~ 0t Jnwrrect slatoments made In support ol this response may be used by the 42~~1~0 rojecllon rescission or Ille award or termination or lhe con~acl bullnd mbully also serve as tho basis r0t debarment of Vendor pursuant lo Socllon 21119 of lho Broward Couw 41

5232018 BidSync p 26

a N ~ IL) IL) N u z a_

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLO RI DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Walter Wernecke RA Title Sr Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email WWERNECKEhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Hollywood Marina Restrooms

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

04152015 to Present 7500000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor OSubconsultanVSubcontractor n ~U t1

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

-0 Vgt Description of services provided by VendorO ~ ~ Q) Structural Design and Construction Inspection Services i co Q m ~- c E c0

i E gt Oo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not () uu Appllcable O

E~ referenced Vendor Improvement iii ~sectoO 1 Vendors Quality of Service B mu a Responsive D D

b Accuracy DD c Deliverables D DD

2 Vendors Organization D Da Staff expertise v D b Professionalism~ D D c Turnover D ~D

3 Timeliness of D a Project b Deliverables D ~

4 Pec~~11~$~hinJ~~qt lfr D D 5 Cooperation with f ~

a Your Firm D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D

Al lnfonn1tion pRgttded IO Brwd Cltgtunly lo 1ubjecl IO ibllon vsor ~middot Iha icl-bullmiddot ~ ir-ect slalemenls mode In _ol lhb _ moy ti used by he County as a basis lot rejecUon rnclnlon cl the eward or tonnlnallan of lhl connct 1nd may bullllo 11 the basis for dobalment of Vendor IQtulnl IO SICllOn 21119 at lhe Broword County Procurement Code

Cl ltraquo I() I() I() N ()

Cl z

BRltJWARD ~ middot COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORl OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Davie

Contact Name Emilio DeSimone Title Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email Emilio_DeSimonedavie-fl gov Contact Phone 954-797-1085

Name of Referenced Project Pavillion 5 Linear Park

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

B-17-123 09152015 to 2700000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor O SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es O No If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

0 Description of services provided by Vendor O Q)

iii c Structural Design and Construction Inspection ServicesoQ

CDi-

0cc E gt=gt E ()Oo O () () Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

ii) -e i- Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 111 cs

B ioO

J 1 Vendors Quality of Service Q ()

a Responsive D D b Accuracy D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization []Ll Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D Dtr

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [g D b Deliverables D D ar D

4 Project completed within budget [1tD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) cgD D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via l EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by ~h~ Division WlI Etgt Date 0 f l~o I 8 All lnformaUon provided lO Broward County Is eubJect 10 verifutlon Vendor ecknOMedgoo that lnaocurote unNlhlul or Incorrect statamenle made In aupl)Ort of this reaponse may be used by lho County et o baampla for rejection realtluion of the award or lermlnallon of tho eon1fllcl ond moy olao aorvo os ho basis for debarmont of Vondor purauenl lo Section 21119 of the Broward Counly Procuremen1 Code

0 0 agt a c () z 0

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Terrence Comiskey AIA Title Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email TCOMISKEYhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Van Buren Parking Garage

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PK 14-053 Nov 2014 to Present 8310000

Vendors role in Project t8(Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

o~ Description of services provided by Vendor 1 Q)ltO c Structural Design and Conslructlon Inspection Services 0 Q

0~Jl ccE l E enOo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

gtshy

uu O Improvement Applicable ffireferenced Vendor

~sect 1 Vendors Quality of Service 1 ~

oOau a Responsive D ~ D b Accuracy B D D

D D [- Dc Deliverables

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tum over D D D g

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ D Subcontractor(s )S ubcons u ltant( s)b D D ~ D

c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D yenj D Additional Comments provide on sdditlonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION ~NTY USE ONLY0

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by kW Division W-1-(i~ Date EJo(a~t8 Al lnform1Uon PltOVlded lo Browald Ccxnty It IUbjoct to vorificallon Vendor eoknowfodgea thal lnaewralt U111MhlJI deg inlaquogtlaquobullel amptal11ants made In eupporl of lhls relj)Onse may be used by Iha Counly es a balls l0t rcfecllon rescfuloltI of tho ew1rd or 1ermtnaU0lt1 ol lhbull conllllCI and may elao urve 11 lho basis for dabarmenl of Vondor pursuanl lo Secllon 21 119 of he erowald COUlly CiProcurement Code

~ N ii

00

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 aOWllrp Commficumlref Bid PNC2116615B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Pompano Beach FL

Contact Name Mr A Randolph Brown Title Utilities Director Reference date April 30 2018

Contact Email randolphbrowncopbflcom Contact Phone 954-545-7043

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 201 o Project Amount fees varied

Multiple

Vendors role in Project IKJ Prime Vendor

to 2018

osubconsultanUSubcontractor

(range $10000shy$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D ~ D D c Deliverables D ~ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D ~ D D b Professionalism D D ~ D C Turnover D El DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ 0 b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D [BJ D n c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [XJ o ~

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed) amp~~it -THIS SECTION ~COUNTY USE ONL y-bullbull

Verified via ~AIL __VERBAL Verified by 1lt4 )~ Division N WE O Date 5 faol Z1 18

All lnformotlon providod to BltownrltI Cou nty it aubjoct O verification VendOr acknowledges that lnaccornto untruthful or incorroct 11atomon1s made in support of this response may be used by tho

411p~~)~~J rojoclion roscissioo ol lho award or 1orroinalion of tho contract and roay also s01vo as lhbull basis f0lt d~arroont of VondOf pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward Cou)l1

Bid Sync p 73

40

5232018

Broward County Board of Bid PNC2116659B 1 County Commissioners

B~aWARD gt1- t COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Loxahatchee River Environmental Control District

Contact Name Mr Kris Dean Title Director of Engineering Reference date May 9 2018

Contact Email krisdeanloxahatcheeriverorg Contact Phone 561-747-5700

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 2001 Project Amount fees varied (range $10000shyMultiple to 2018 $250000)

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IR)Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D ~ D D b Accuracy D 0 D D c Deliverables D IBJ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D IB] D D b Professionalism D ~ D D c Turnover D [8J D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D [8J D D b Deliverables D m D D

4 Project completed within budget D ~ D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D ~ D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D Ii] D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D ~ D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SE~ FOR~USE ONLY

Verified via _lEMAIL __VERBAL Verified by ~lt Division fWeb Date I

All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untrulhful or incorrecl slatements made In support of this response may be used by the lJl~~~l~~jSfiir rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and mll~~~ere as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Co)f 10

Broward County Board of Bid PNC21166$9B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A l

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Lake Worth FL

Contact Name Mr Felipe Lofaso TitleAsst Dir Public-ServicesReference date May 9 2018

Contact Email flofasolakeworthorg Contact Phone 561-586-1720

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contract

Contract No Date Services Provided 2014 Project Amount fees varied Multiple to 2018 (range $10000shy

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Services included multiple municipal engineering projects including survey roadway design utility design and coordination (water wastewater stormwater other) along with project management

Needs Satisfactory Excellent NotPlease rate your experience with the Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D GJ D b Accuracy D D Ii] D c Deliverables D Ii] DD

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [i] D c Turnover D D D [X]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D 0 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [X] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION Fe COUNTY USE ONLrbullbull

Verified via MAIL __VERBAL Verified by Division ~wgtgt Date 5~3ol20t8 All information provided to Broward County Is subject lo verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect slalements made in support ol this response may be used by the

OZ~id~~~~j~r rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and m~~~(iirve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Cour~ iG

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - ARCADIS US INC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts

VS0000013130 VS00013130 - ARCADIS US INC Prime Work Auth Vendor SummaryProjects

PURCHASING 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold Procurement No Fixed Contracts FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Favorites Past 5 Years Prime Vendor

Sub Vendor From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 10042017 Purchase Order

Evaluation Purchase Orders 1 POs With A Total Amt Of $20000000 Log Off Paid To Dt ($12132949) Balance $7867051

Contracts Purchase Orders Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx 6192018

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Finish

PURCHASING Weighted Scores Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract FileRoom DashBoard Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number FileRoom Insert

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel Favorites Prime Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Service Evaluation

6132017 YES 486 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Goals Compliance Evaluation

10272016 YES 460 View Docs (0)

6272018

Project Management Information System

Close

Contracts Central Administration

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9130 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-24

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6182018 YES 355 View Docs (1)

Proj Nbr 9320 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-20

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6132018 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9290 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-23

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1122018 YES 494 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-21

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12182017 YES 488 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10162017 YES 473 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

8252017 YES 495 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9321 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-19

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

7112017 YES 476 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-17

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2272017 YES 400 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

10132016 YES 384 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-12

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

5202016 YES 405 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9018 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-06

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10192015 YES 448 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

3202015 YES 385 View Docs (0)

Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL CONSULTANTS

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Project Management Information System

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-04

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12122014 YES 437 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-08

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1242014 YES 423 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-02

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2282014 YES 452 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC

VC0000044184 VC00044184 - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres PS $001 Used $000 Remain $001 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $354848400 Closed 0 Total $000 Total Current Retainage Balance For All Contracts $793370 No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 06292015 Purchase Orders 2 POs With A Total Amt Of $362317900 Paid To Dt ($218795160) Balance $143522740

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 40803 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9058 - DISTRICT 3A POTABLE WATER STORAGE

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1220410P1 - Consultant Engineering Services for Potable Water FixedOpen Contracts Storage Tanks and Pumping Systems Work Auth Prime Vendor CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Periodic Final Finish

Log Off Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type

Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

6232015 8302017 413 Approved 8312017 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard

Enter Vendor Name (or a portion of) Then Click Search - Wilcards Are Permitted (ie wa wawainc) Florida Technical Consultants

Search Reset Finish

No Vendors Found For Your Search Try Again

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41005 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score Go

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0773

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

12122017 YES 430 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

8302016 YES 438 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Final Consultant Evaluation 3142016 YES 478 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0706

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

142016 YES 402 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9016OES - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0731

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

10192015 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0748

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

612015 YES 467 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

2192015 YES 500 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0754

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

252015 YES 409 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0755

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

1242014 YES 415 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8974 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0758

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

6202014 YES 393 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr

WATER amp WASTEWATER

Final Consultant Work Authorization 572014 YES 423 View Docs

(0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

HS0746 ENGINEERING Evaluation

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

4302014 YES 475 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Evaluation 4302014 YES 493 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0710

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

3172014 YES 395 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0753

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

1212014 YES 380 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0763

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

11192013 YES 450 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0775

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 408 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals

Finish

Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed FileRoom DashBoard Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization FileRoom Insert NumberFavorites

Prime Vendor Export To Excel Sub Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0772

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 417 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0771

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

2262013 YES 410 View Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 15: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BRuWARD1 1 COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering SeNices for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

C ity of Tavares F lorida

Contact Name James Dillon Title Public Works DireltaReference date 05172018

Contact Email jdillontavaresorg Contact Phone 352-455-7718

Name of Referenced Project G IS Modeling and Integration of Utilities Infrastructure

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

060330480000 04012017 UP 10012017 $ 5676000

Vendors role in Project ]rime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Integrate drawings and images depicting pipe infrastructure into a GIS environment for easy retrieval First project of a multi phase program to upgrade the Citys GIS information

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D 0 D c Deliverables D D 0 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D Ill D b Professionalism D D Ill D c Turnover D D 0 D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D Ill D b Deliverables D D Ill D

4 Project completed within budget D D Ill D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D Ill D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D Ill D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY -

Ve rified via L IL VERBAL Verified by fcAJ~ Division llt E1) Date 1 r~ tjlQ t8 All information pwvlded to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incooect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

512G91JlIHIS a basis for rejection rescission or the award or termination or the contract and lnfli~9ncrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 of the Broward CouI)~ 44flamplrelflent Code

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BRd~WARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LO R I DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Miramar

Contact Name Robin E Bain PE Title Project Manager Reference date 05142018

Contact Email rebainmiramarflgov Contact Phone 9548836825

Name of Referenced Project East Water Treatment Plant Replacement Wells and Design-Build

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PO 172624-00 10222017 UP 05142018 $ 56929600

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [ZJYes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Design permitting construction services for new Deep Injection Well and 4 new (replacement) production wells

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy []D D D c Deliverables D []D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D [ZJ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Turnover D D D []

3 Timeliness of a Project D D lZ1 D b Del iverables D D lZ1 D

4 Project completed within budget D D lZ1 D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor( s)Subconsultant( s) D D lZ1 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D lZ1 D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY (

Verified via A IL VER BAL Verified by faltJ~ Division WltEtgt Date 5 ~io l 9 All inlOllllalion pltovided to Broward County is subjecl lo verificalioo VendOt acknowledges lhal lnaccurale unlrulhful or i ncooecl stalemenls made in suppOltI of lhis response may be used by lhe

512gt~llM (lS a basis lot rejeclion rescission of the award or termination of lhe contract and mll~Arrcrve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuanl 10 Section 21119 of lhe Broward Couoty 43Pldtllrbrllent Code Y flmiddot

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Palm Beach County Water Utilities Department

Contact Name Ali Bayat Title Assistant Director Reference date

Contact Email abayatpbcwatercom Contact Phone 561 493 6128

Name of Referenced Project System 8 Water Quality Assessment

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

17-021 CSA21 01 022017 to 01152018 $ 8936000

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again (Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Brown and Caldwell led assessment of contributing causes to low system residuals troubleshooting treatment processes special testing and data analysis improvements to operating protocols monitoringcontrol system and treatment process

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [Z] D b Accuracy D [Z] DD c Deliverables D [Z]D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D [Z] D b Professionalism D D [Z] D c Turnover D [Z] DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D [Z] D

4 Project completed within budget D D [Z] D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Consultant worked collaboratively with operating maintenance engineering and laboratory staff to develop insight into contributing factors and implement improvements

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via _LEMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by tcltJ1~ Division -+LN euro P Date lteh IWt 8 All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the County as a basis for rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and may also serve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward County Procurement Code

BltaWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F L 0 R I D A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood Florida

Contact Name Steve Joseph Title Director Reference date

Contact Email sjosephhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954 921 3522

Name of Referenced Project Distribution System Water Quality Improvement

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

01012016 to 06022017 $ 3000000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again []Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Supported the City with its efforts improve chlorine residuals in areas of its system Analysis included system modeling monitoring optimized operational practices Implemented operational improvements that significantly raised (from approx 05 to 20 mgL) chloramine residuals In the most challenging area of the system

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D D [] D c Deliverables []D D D

2 Vendors Organization [] Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D [] D c Turnover D D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D [] D

4 Project completed within budget []D D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) []D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [] D

Additional Com ments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Effort Included system modoling moniloring and excursion response procedures opllmitallon of stored Inventory management unidirectional flushing pilot assessment and treatment proooss evaluation

Verified via __EMAIL vERBAL Division WW ED Date G Ifgt I 8 All infonmallon pltovided to Broward County Is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of thi s response may be used by lhe County as a basis for rejeclion rescission or the award or tenminatlon of the contract and may also serve as the basis for debanment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 or lhe Broward County Procurement Code

BROWARD t (l)t~ 1 Vendor Reference Verification Form

fl O R I OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of West Palm Beach Florida

Contact Name Jay Kwag Title Project Manager Reference date

Contact Email hjkwagwpborg Contact Phone 561 494 1041

Name of Referenced Project Modeling and Infrastructure General Engineering Consulting Assigments

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

11032014 to HAlt zc1e (on~vi~)

Vendors role in Project 52fPrime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IQves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Planning and General Eng1neerg Servicus 1nctuslve ol Waterwastewater System Master Pian asset management program dovo10pmenV11sset Crt1tcat1ty assessment Mesler PS 115 and sewer cond1hon assessment hydrauhc modeling ol LS 5 and force main sizing water system Capacity Analysis RoPort nydraullc modeling ol operahonat challongos tilt ste11on enatysbulls lac11i1a1e 1nspec11011 or major FM and new develOpmenl 1mpnc1s plpohno design lilt station condbullhon assessment and renabtlilahon (Various ProJecls)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D 0 D b Accuracy D 0D D c Deliverables D D 0 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D Gt D b Professionalism D D ~-- D c Turnover D D Gr D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D B D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget D D r~r D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D c~r D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D 0 D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION F~USE ONLY

__VERBAL Verified via LMAIL Verified by ~J Division ~~~D Date ~ f 2 f~t8 All lnfo11na1t0n pr ()Vl(fed 10 Broward County is svb1et110 ven11ca1ion vendor acknowledges lhll 1naeoura10 unlrulhful 0lt inc0ltrec1 s1a1emen1s medo In support ol 1n1s response may be used Dy the County as a basis fcu rejection re sclsst0n Of 1ho award or 1ormina1lon of l he contract and may also servo as the basis for debarment o f Vendor pursuant lo Section 21 119 of tho ampoward Counly P1ocuremont Code

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A middot

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Michael Low Title Deputy Director Reference date 05172018

Contact Email lowmbbflus Contact Phone 5617426403

Name of Referenced Project Ion Exchange Design Build

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

07022014 to 03212018 $ 100000000

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Carollo handled all of the design and construction of a significant part of the project as a subcontractor to COM Constructors as part of a progressive design build contract

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [Z] D b Accuracy D D [Z] D c Deliverables D D [Z] D

2 Vendors Organization D D [Z] Da Staff expertise b Professionalism D D [Z] D c Turnover D D D [Z]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D [Z] D

4 Project completed within budget D D [Z] D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D [Z] D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [Z] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION F~ COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ~~ Division W -NED Date S-gtozot~ All Information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor aclltnowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

Stii191111X 11s a basis for rejection rescission of the award or termination or the conlact and m~~Arifrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward CounYJ 33Plamptl1til1ent Code Y Imiddot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

B~OWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LORID A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

South Florida Water Management District

Contact Name Greg Coffelt PE Title SFWMD Project Manager Reference date 05172018

Contact Email gcoffeltsfwmdgov Contact Phone 561-682-6853

Name of Referenced Project L-8 Reservoir Inflow Structure and Pump Station

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

4600000861 02152011 to 09192012 $ 144535100

Vendors role in Project [l) Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [l)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Corolla was contracted as an Owners Advisor for a Design-Build contract developed engineering design criteria assisted in RFQ development and evaluation supported RFP technical proposal and cost proposal analysis

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [l] D b Accuracy D [] D D c Deliverables D [] D D

2 Vendors Organization [l]a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D [l] D c Turnover D D D [l]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [l] D b Deliverables D [l] D D

4 Project completed within budget [l] DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [l] D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) [l] DD D c Regu latory Agency(ies) D D D [l]

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Owner Advisor work continued(s) in support of Construction of Pump Station Inflow Gate Structure and levee hardening

Verified via IMAIL __VERBAL Date 5 ( 3 c b() I a All information piovided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that Inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made In support of this response may be used by the

512G9JiIX 11s a basis for rejection rescission or the award or termination or the contract and rllffl~Anampe as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 or the Broward CojlftYi 34~6ttlrbtflent Code Y

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

B0~~AARD ~~t~UNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

Fl ORIOA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Sunrise

Contact Name Luisa Fernanda Arbelaa Title Project Manager Reference date 05162018

Contact Email LArbelaezsunrlseflgov Contact Phone 954-888-6009

Name of Referenced Project City of Sunrise - Springtree WTP Water Stabilization and Solids Handling

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PA 16-003-CE 04072016 to 05292018 $ 50797800

Vendors role in Project ]Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [l]Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Carollo Engineers performed the design study and construction administration services for the City

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D G6 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Carollo Engineers technical knowledge and attenllon lo detall were beneficial lo the pltojad They ecled in lhe C~ys besl Interest In every aspect for lhe d1K8Uon of the projectbull

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via ~MAIL _VERBAL Verified by fc4J~~ Division W fl ED All lnrormalion provided to Broward ltAunty Is oobjoci to vorirtcotion Vendoc ecknowledgu that 1naowrate unlMhfuf 0lt lncocrecl statements rnado In support or this response may be useltI by lhe County as a basis for rejection rescission or the award 0lt termination ol the convect and may also ampOIVe as the babullibull ror debarmont of vondOlt purauont to Section 21119 or the Broward County Proc11oment Code

Bid Sync p 135 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BftQNARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

I l 0 R I 0 A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Florida Technical Consultants

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

VIiiage of Wellington Utilities

Contact Name Bradley Wolak Title Assistant Director Ut11Reference date 5182018

Contact Email bwolakwelllngtonflgov Contact Phone 561-753-2480

Name of Referenced Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 10012017 to Present 3500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vend~ 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again UZfYes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor J_ rJ fJ j(Gr-~k 6 Jti ov1 ~uf-Jiy fgt-r_- syrrzi~ff~ Al

R Q_ d--1 0~l 4 171 i+CI ~~lHI )Please rate your experience with tile Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Applicablereferenced Vendor Improvement

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy B D

DD c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D Db Professionalism D D

c Turnover D DD 3 Timeliness of

a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant(s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Additional Comments (provide on addltjpnal sheetJf needed) bull ~middot$ -JJ fo~~rltjbull lt( c-c_ ~~~ lt fo L1-lfAR- -middot~ I 10 ~ ~

~ bullL ~~ _te_ l~Ilgt~Cef t J ~ l rfbull4 middot r0 laquo r 4111J w f1 rrr- 0r- -i-HIS SECTION(9R COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by fcAJc ~ Division Y-1 IN ED Date 5 ~o w8 All lnfonn1Uon ptollfded to BlOward County le eubjeet to vetfflcatlon Vendor aclltnowledge1 that lneccurale unllJlhfUl or lnconect -bullmenla made In 1UPPort o1 this reopon90 may be uoec1 by the couniy ae a baalS ror re)ectlon re8Claeton Of the award 0t leltmlnatlon Of the contract and may 1l10 MM ae the baale flaquo debarrnont 01 vendor pu11uant to Section 21119 of ll1e Broward County Procurement Codo

BidSync p 18 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F LUFltIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultants LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Palm Beach Public Works

Contact Name Gerry Vazquez Title WRD Technician Reference date 05182018

Contact Email gvazqueztownofpalmbeachcom Contact Phone 772-546-6859

Name of Referenced Project GIS Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 3242014 to Present 13500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [3yenes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

PrwAamprs- favl49z Please rate your experience with the Need a Satlafactory Excellent Not

Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D g- D b Accuracy D Er D c Deliverables g-shyB D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D GJ D b Professionalism D D G- D c Tu mover D D cg- D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D g D b Deliverables D D Qshy D

4 Project completed within budget D D lbJ- D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D El- Db Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [3- D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

BidSync p 17 51232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

120-nWARDLll~ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form fLORllgtA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultant LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Waneya Bryant Title Meter Serv Mgr Reference date 05182018

Contact Email BryantWbbflus Contact Phone 561-742-6427

Name of Referenced Project Boynton Beach Utility GIS Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 12012016 to Present $15000000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

~T~ 5e-r-vtleamp +roM l)h f-es Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D Dc Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ti4 D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ Db Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on addlUonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION~urv USE ONLy u bull

Verified via VEMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by kuJ~ Division W if E D rao(ao8Date 5

All Information provided to Browslaquo COOlty Is Slbject to verfflcation Vendor acKnowledges that lneocurate Untruthful or lncolleel 8tatements made In support d this rfl9pOn98 may be used by 1119 Counly as a batia falt rejection relduion ct Ille award or lemilnlilon of the contract and may al80181Veaa1119 basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 ot Ille Broward CountyProcurement Code

512312018 BidSync p 16

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1

8W1V~isl1War Bid PNC21 15559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Fonn

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Cooper City - middot

Contact Name Michael Bailey PE itle Utilities DlrCity EbullReference date 05011201s

Contact Email MBalleycoopercityflorg Contact Phone (954) 434-5519

Name of Referenced Project City of Cooper City Continuing Professional Services bullContract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

RFQ 2009middot 1 04242009 to Present $ 2 19844200

Vendors role in Project IZJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Since 2009 Hazen has provided Cooper City with engineering services or water and wastewater projects Projects have lnctudeo lhe Pine Island Road Pump Station Lilt S1alions 2 amp 49 Improvements Master Plan Update of the FeaslJl~lty Review of Infrastructure Improvements tor Wastewater and the Eflluent Reuse and Disposal Master Plan

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy 8 D

D ~ D c Deliverables D 0 ~ D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D 0 D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tumover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D GJ- D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D 0 D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) ~D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

bull-rHIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY-

Verified vie EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ct4~ Division ~tUb Date ~ i3~) 0fgt All Information provided to BltCgtWW County 11 wbed ID vamprificalion Velldot adltnowledgu that lnaoewate unlrUhful lncom1ct statemampnla made in wppolt of 11111 response may blt uHd by the

4t2j=~ rejection rHclsslcn of th8 award or lennhallon of Ille eoo1nlct and may also seNamp at tilt basis for dtbarmenl at Vendor puuan1 lo Sectioo 21119 of the Broward COltJi 43

5232018 Bid Sync p24

Broward County Board of PNC211 5559P1

~RiiirilyenlcHUffi~~8CrW~r Bid PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

8DdMARD _ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FL O RIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Fort Lauderdale

Contact Name Rares Patrica PE Title Senior Project Mgr Reference date os1021201s

Contact Email RPetricafortlauderdalegov Contact Phone 9548287150

Name of Referenced Project Stormwater Master Planning and Design Implementation Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

256-11660 04192016 to 04192021 $ 989400000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

vyould you use this vendor again Sves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor The Hazen team Is responsible for delivery of a new stormwaler master plan model a prlorlllzed slormwaterresllency capital Improvements plan and Implementation of designs to address chronic flooding and other slormwater management challenges In the City Primary work tasks Include data collectlon hydrologlclhydraullc modeling and design permitting and construction services for capllal Improvement projects resulting from the revised stormwater master plan (preltmlnary design In seven priority neighborhoods)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION ~R COUNTY USE ONLY

aJ~Verified via pound MA IL _VERBAL Verified by Division W1~tl Date 5 ~3o~ax l S N I informallon p roviltled lo Broward County is sulljecl lo verification Vendor altknowledjj6s lhal inaccurate unlMhlut or lncotreci statements m ade In support of this respon$e may be used by tho

412~-~ rejeclion rescission of the award or termination ol lhe contracl and may also serve as lhe basis for debalment ol Vendor purwant to Section 21119 ol lhe Broward Cou~ 4 3

5232018 Bid Sync p25

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 Br~~~~~rs Bid PNC2115559P1 County t ommissioners

B~uWARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FlOR I CA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

Solicitation PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and s OrganizationFirm Name p

Town of Jupiter

nee

Contact Email davidbjupiterflus Contact Phone (561) 746-5134

Name of Referenced Project Engineering Services for Stormwater and Water Capital Improvements

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount $ 630000000 W17248 (2017 reselection 1012000 to Present (estimated lee-to-date since contract inception) contract number)

Vendors role in Project IZI Prime Vendor osubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again 0Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Descriotion of services orovided bv Vendor Since 2000 Hazen has served as General Consulfant to the Town or Jupiter As General Stormwater and Water Consullant the firm has provided services related to master planning stormwater planning and modeling design NPDES permilling asset management resiliency ratefinancial analysis plan review and construction oversight Water-related capital projs have involved additional system storage and high-service pumping transmission system improvements and RampR at existing facilities

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Verllied via EMAIL _ VERBAL Division WWC D

fo (J-Vv ~ltIvmiddotj Date 5(30(ipf S

Al lnroimallon pngtYICGd 10 Broward Counly Is sub)oel to v8flrcallon vendlaquo acknowledges lhat Inaccurate unlruthlu~ 0t Jnwrrect slatoments made In support ol this response may be used by the 42~~1~0 rojecllon rescission or Ille award or termination or lhe con~acl bullnd mbully also serve as tho basis r0t debarment of Vendor pursuant lo Socllon 21119 of lho Broward Couw 41

5232018 BidSync p 26

a N ~ IL) IL) N u z a_

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLO RI DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Walter Wernecke RA Title Sr Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email WWERNECKEhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Hollywood Marina Restrooms

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

04152015 to Present 7500000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor OSubconsultanVSubcontractor n ~U t1

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

-0 Vgt Description of services provided by VendorO ~ ~ Q) Structural Design and Construction Inspection Services i co Q m ~- c E c0

i E gt Oo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not () uu Appllcable O

E~ referenced Vendor Improvement iii ~sectoO 1 Vendors Quality of Service B mu a Responsive D D

b Accuracy DD c Deliverables D DD

2 Vendors Organization D Da Staff expertise v D b Professionalism~ D D c Turnover D ~D

3 Timeliness of D a Project b Deliverables D ~

4 Pec~~11~$~hinJ~~qt lfr D D 5 Cooperation with f ~

a Your Firm D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D

Al lnfonn1tion pRgttded IO Brwd Cltgtunly lo 1ubjecl IO ibllon vsor ~middot Iha icl-bullmiddot ~ ir-ect slalemenls mode In _ol lhb _ moy ti used by he County as a basis lot rejecUon rnclnlon cl the eward or tonnlnallan of lhl connct 1nd may bullllo 11 the basis for dobalment of Vendor IQtulnl IO SICllOn 21119 at lhe Broword County Procurement Code

Cl ltraquo I() I() I() N ()

Cl z

BRltJWARD ~ middot COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORl OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Davie

Contact Name Emilio DeSimone Title Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email Emilio_DeSimonedavie-fl gov Contact Phone 954-797-1085

Name of Referenced Project Pavillion 5 Linear Park

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

B-17-123 09152015 to 2700000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor O SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es O No If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

0 Description of services provided by Vendor O Q)

iii c Structural Design and Construction Inspection ServicesoQ

CDi-

0cc E gt=gt E ()Oo O () () Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

ii) -e i- Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 111 cs

B ioO

J 1 Vendors Quality of Service Q ()

a Responsive D D b Accuracy D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization []Ll Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D Dtr

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [g D b Deliverables D D ar D

4 Project completed within budget [1tD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) cgD D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via l EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by ~h~ Division WlI Etgt Date 0 f l~o I 8 All lnformaUon provided lO Broward County Is eubJect 10 verifutlon Vendor ecknOMedgoo that lnaocurote unNlhlul or Incorrect statamenle made In aupl)Ort of this reaponse may be used by lho County et o baampla for rejection realtluion of the award or lermlnallon of tho eon1fllcl ond moy olao aorvo os ho basis for debarmont of Vondor purauenl lo Section 21119 of the Broward Counly Procuremen1 Code

0 0 agt a c () z 0

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Terrence Comiskey AIA Title Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email TCOMISKEYhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Van Buren Parking Garage

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PK 14-053 Nov 2014 to Present 8310000

Vendors role in Project t8(Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

o~ Description of services provided by Vendor 1 Q)ltO c Structural Design and Conslructlon Inspection Services 0 Q

0~Jl ccE l E enOo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

gtshy

uu O Improvement Applicable ffireferenced Vendor

~sect 1 Vendors Quality of Service 1 ~

oOau a Responsive D ~ D b Accuracy B D D

D D [- Dc Deliverables

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tum over D D D g

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ D Subcontractor(s )S ubcons u ltant( s)b D D ~ D

c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D yenj D Additional Comments provide on sdditlonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION ~NTY USE ONLY0

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by kW Division W-1-(i~ Date EJo(a~t8 Al lnform1Uon PltOVlded lo Browald Ccxnty It IUbjoct to vorificallon Vendor eoknowfodgea thal lnaewralt U111MhlJI deg inlaquogtlaquobullel amptal11ants made In eupporl of lhls relj)Onse may be used by Iha Counly es a balls l0t rcfecllon rescfuloltI of tho ew1rd or 1ermtnaU0lt1 ol lhbull conllllCI and may elao urve 11 lho basis for dabarmenl of Vondor pursuanl lo Secllon 21 119 of he erowald COUlly CiProcurement Code

~ N ii

00

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 aOWllrp Commficumlref Bid PNC2116615B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Pompano Beach FL

Contact Name Mr A Randolph Brown Title Utilities Director Reference date April 30 2018

Contact Email randolphbrowncopbflcom Contact Phone 954-545-7043

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 201 o Project Amount fees varied

Multiple

Vendors role in Project IKJ Prime Vendor

to 2018

osubconsultanUSubcontractor

(range $10000shy$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D ~ D D c Deliverables D ~ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D ~ D D b Professionalism D D ~ D C Turnover D El DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ 0 b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D [BJ D n c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [XJ o ~

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed) amp~~it -THIS SECTION ~COUNTY USE ONL y-bullbull

Verified via ~AIL __VERBAL Verified by 1lt4 )~ Division N WE O Date 5 faol Z1 18

All lnformotlon providod to BltownrltI Cou nty it aubjoct O verification VendOr acknowledges that lnaccornto untruthful or incorroct 11atomon1s made in support of this response may be used by tho

411p~~)~~J rojoclion roscissioo ol lho award or 1orroinalion of tho contract and roay also s01vo as lhbull basis f0lt d~arroont of VondOf pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward Cou)l1

Bid Sync p 73

40

5232018

Broward County Board of Bid PNC2116659B 1 County Commissioners

B~aWARD gt1- t COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Loxahatchee River Environmental Control District

Contact Name Mr Kris Dean Title Director of Engineering Reference date May 9 2018

Contact Email krisdeanloxahatcheeriverorg Contact Phone 561-747-5700

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 2001 Project Amount fees varied (range $10000shyMultiple to 2018 $250000)

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IR)Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D ~ D D b Accuracy D 0 D D c Deliverables D IBJ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D IB] D D b Professionalism D ~ D D c Turnover D [8J D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D [8J D D b Deliverables D m D D

4 Project completed within budget D ~ D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D ~ D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D Ii] D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D ~ D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SE~ FOR~USE ONLY

Verified via _lEMAIL __VERBAL Verified by ~lt Division fWeb Date I

All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untrulhful or incorrecl slatements made In support of this response may be used by the lJl~~~l~~jSfiir rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and mll~~~ere as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Co)f 10

Broward County Board of Bid PNC21166$9B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A l

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Lake Worth FL

Contact Name Mr Felipe Lofaso TitleAsst Dir Public-ServicesReference date May 9 2018

Contact Email flofasolakeworthorg Contact Phone 561-586-1720

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contract

Contract No Date Services Provided 2014 Project Amount fees varied Multiple to 2018 (range $10000shy

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Services included multiple municipal engineering projects including survey roadway design utility design and coordination (water wastewater stormwater other) along with project management

Needs Satisfactory Excellent NotPlease rate your experience with the Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D GJ D b Accuracy D D Ii] D c Deliverables D Ii] DD

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [i] D c Turnover D D D [X]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D 0 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [X] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION Fe COUNTY USE ONLrbullbull

Verified via MAIL __VERBAL Verified by Division ~wgtgt Date 5~3ol20t8 All information provided to Broward County Is subject lo verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect slalements made in support ol this response may be used by the

OZ~id~~~~j~r rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and m~~~(iirve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Cour~ iG

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - ARCADIS US INC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts

VS0000013130 VS00013130 - ARCADIS US INC Prime Work Auth Vendor SummaryProjects

PURCHASING 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold Procurement No Fixed Contracts FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Favorites Past 5 Years Prime Vendor

Sub Vendor From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 10042017 Purchase Order

Evaluation Purchase Orders 1 POs With A Total Amt Of $20000000 Log Off Paid To Dt ($12132949) Balance $7867051

Contracts Purchase Orders Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx 6192018

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Finish

PURCHASING Weighted Scores Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract FileRoom DashBoard Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number FileRoom Insert

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel Favorites Prime Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Service Evaluation

6132017 YES 486 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Goals Compliance Evaluation

10272016 YES 460 View Docs (0)

6272018

Project Management Information System

Close

Contracts Central Administration

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9130 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-24

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6182018 YES 355 View Docs (1)

Proj Nbr 9320 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-20

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6132018 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9290 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-23

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1122018 YES 494 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-21

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12182017 YES 488 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10162017 YES 473 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

8252017 YES 495 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9321 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-19

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

7112017 YES 476 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-17

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2272017 YES 400 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

10132016 YES 384 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-12

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

5202016 YES 405 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9018 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-06

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10192015 YES 448 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

3202015 YES 385 View Docs (0)

Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL CONSULTANTS

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Project Management Information System

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-04

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12122014 YES 437 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-08

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1242014 YES 423 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-02

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2282014 YES 452 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC

VC0000044184 VC00044184 - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres PS $001 Used $000 Remain $001 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $354848400 Closed 0 Total $000 Total Current Retainage Balance For All Contracts $793370 No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 06292015 Purchase Orders 2 POs With A Total Amt Of $362317900 Paid To Dt ($218795160) Balance $143522740

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 40803 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9058 - DISTRICT 3A POTABLE WATER STORAGE

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1220410P1 - Consultant Engineering Services for Potable Water FixedOpen Contracts Storage Tanks and Pumping Systems Work Auth Prime Vendor CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Periodic Final Finish

Log Off Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type

Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

6232015 8302017 413 Approved 8312017 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard

Enter Vendor Name (or a portion of) Then Click Search - Wilcards Are Permitted (ie wa wawainc) Florida Technical Consultants

Search Reset Finish

No Vendors Found For Your Search Try Again

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41005 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score Go

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0773

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

12122017 YES 430 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

8302016 YES 438 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Final Consultant Evaluation 3142016 YES 478 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0706

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

142016 YES 402 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9016OES - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0731

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

10192015 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0748

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

612015 YES 467 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

2192015 YES 500 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0754

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

252015 YES 409 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0755

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

1242014 YES 415 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8974 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0758

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

6202014 YES 393 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr

WATER amp WASTEWATER

Final Consultant Work Authorization 572014 YES 423 View Docs

(0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

HS0746 ENGINEERING Evaluation

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

4302014 YES 475 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Evaluation 4302014 YES 493 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0710

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

3172014 YES 395 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0753

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

1212014 YES 380 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0763

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

11192013 YES 450 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0775

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 408 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals

Finish

Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed FileRoom DashBoard Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization FileRoom Insert NumberFavorites

Prime Vendor Export To Excel Sub Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0772

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 417 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0771

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

2262013 YES 410 View Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 16: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BRd~WARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LO R I DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Arcadis US Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Miramar

Contact Name Robin E Bain PE Title Project Manager Reference date 05142018

Contact Email rebainmiramarflgov Contact Phone 9548836825

Name of Referenced Project East Water Treatment Plant Replacement Wells and Design-Build

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PO 172624-00 10222017 UP 05142018 $ 56929600

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [ZJYes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments(below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Design permitting construction services for new Deep Injection Well and 4 new (replacement) production wells

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy []D D D c Deliverables D []D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D [ZJ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Turnover D D D []

3 Timeliness of a Project D D lZ1 D b Del iverables D D lZ1 D

4 Project completed within budget D D lZ1 D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor( s)Subconsultant( s) D D lZ1 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D lZ1 D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY (

Verified via A IL VER BAL Verified by faltJ~ Division WltEtgt Date 5 ~io l 9 All inlOllllalion pltovided to Broward County is subjecl lo verificalioo VendOt acknowledges lhal lnaccurale unlrulhful or i ncooecl stalemenls made in suppOltI of lhis response may be used by lhe

512gt~llM (lS a basis lot rejeclion rescission of the award or termination of lhe contract and mll~Arrcrve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuanl 10 Section 21119 of lhe Broward Couoty 43Pldtllrbrllent Code Y flmiddot

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Palm Beach County Water Utilities Department

Contact Name Ali Bayat Title Assistant Director Reference date

Contact Email abayatpbcwatercom Contact Phone 561 493 6128

Name of Referenced Project System 8 Water Quality Assessment

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

17-021 CSA21 01 022017 to 01152018 $ 8936000

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again (Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Brown and Caldwell led assessment of contributing causes to low system residuals troubleshooting treatment processes special testing and data analysis improvements to operating protocols monitoringcontrol system and treatment process

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [Z] D b Accuracy D [Z] DD c Deliverables D [Z]D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D [Z] D b Professionalism D D [Z] D c Turnover D [Z] DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D [Z] D

4 Project completed within budget D D [Z] D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Consultant worked collaboratively with operating maintenance engineering and laboratory staff to develop insight into contributing factors and implement improvements

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via _LEMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by tcltJ1~ Division -+LN euro P Date lteh IWt 8 All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the County as a basis for rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and may also serve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward County Procurement Code

BltaWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F L 0 R I D A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood Florida

Contact Name Steve Joseph Title Director Reference date

Contact Email sjosephhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954 921 3522

Name of Referenced Project Distribution System Water Quality Improvement

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

01012016 to 06022017 $ 3000000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again []Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Supported the City with its efforts improve chlorine residuals in areas of its system Analysis included system modeling monitoring optimized operational practices Implemented operational improvements that significantly raised (from approx 05 to 20 mgL) chloramine residuals In the most challenging area of the system

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D D [] D c Deliverables []D D D

2 Vendors Organization [] Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D [] D c Turnover D D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D [] D

4 Project completed within budget []D D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) []D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [] D

Additional Com ments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Effort Included system modoling moniloring and excursion response procedures opllmitallon of stored Inventory management unidirectional flushing pilot assessment and treatment proooss evaluation

Verified via __EMAIL vERBAL Division WW ED Date G Ifgt I 8 All infonmallon pltovided to Broward County Is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of thi s response may be used by lhe County as a basis for rejeclion rescission or the award or tenminatlon of the contract and may also serve as the basis for debanment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 or lhe Broward County Procurement Code

BROWARD t (l)t~ 1 Vendor Reference Verification Form

fl O R I OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of West Palm Beach Florida

Contact Name Jay Kwag Title Project Manager Reference date

Contact Email hjkwagwpborg Contact Phone 561 494 1041

Name of Referenced Project Modeling and Infrastructure General Engineering Consulting Assigments

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

11032014 to HAlt zc1e (on~vi~)

Vendors role in Project 52fPrime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IQves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Planning and General Eng1neerg Servicus 1nctuslve ol Waterwastewater System Master Pian asset management program dovo10pmenV11sset Crt1tcat1ty assessment Mesler PS 115 and sewer cond1hon assessment hydrauhc modeling ol LS 5 and force main sizing water system Capacity Analysis RoPort nydraullc modeling ol operahonat challongos tilt ste11on enatysbulls lac11i1a1e 1nspec11011 or major FM and new develOpmenl 1mpnc1s plpohno design lilt station condbullhon assessment and renabtlilahon (Various ProJecls)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D 0 D b Accuracy D 0D D c Deliverables D D 0 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D Gt D b Professionalism D D ~-- D c Turnover D D Gr D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D B D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget D D r~r D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D c~r D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D 0 D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION F~USE ONLY

__VERBAL Verified via LMAIL Verified by ~J Division ~~~D Date ~ f 2 f~t8 All lnfo11na1t0n pr ()Vl(fed 10 Broward County is svb1et110 ven11ca1ion vendor acknowledges lhll 1naeoura10 unlrulhful 0lt inc0ltrec1 s1a1emen1s medo In support ol 1n1s response may be used Dy the County as a basis fcu rejection re sclsst0n Of 1ho award or 1ormina1lon of l he contract and may also servo as the basis for debarment o f Vendor pursuant lo Section 21 119 of tho ampoward Counly P1ocuremont Code

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A middot

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Michael Low Title Deputy Director Reference date 05172018

Contact Email lowmbbflus Contact Phone 5617426403

Name of Referenced Project Ion Exchange Design Build

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

07022014 to 03212018 $ 100000000

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Carollo handled all of the design and construction of a significant part of the project as a subcontractor to COM Constructors as part of a progressive design build contract

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [Z] D b Accuracy D D [Z] D c Deliverables D D [Z] D

2 Vendors Organization D D [Z] Da Staff expertise b Professionalism D D [Z] D c Turnover D D D [Z]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D [Z] D

4 Project completed within budget D D [Z] D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D [Z] D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [Z] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION F~ COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ~~ Division W -NED Date S-gtozot~ All Information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor aclltnowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

Stii191111X 11s a basis for rejection rescission of the award or termination or the conlact and m~~Arifrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward CounYJ 33Plamptl1til1ent Code Y Imiddot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

B~OWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LORID A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

South Florida Water Management District

Contact Name Greg Coffelt PE Title SFWMD Project Manager Reference date 05172018

Contact Email gcoffeltsfwmdgov Contact Phone 561-682-6853

Name of Referenced Project L-8 Reservoir Inflow Structure and Pump Station

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

4600000861 02152011 to 09192012 $ 144535100

Vendors role in Project [l) Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [l)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Corolla was contracted as an Owners Advisor for a Design-Build contract developed engineering design criteria assisted in RFQ development and evaluation supported RFP technical proposal and cost proposal analysis

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [l] D b Accuracy D [] D D c Deliverables D [] D D

2 Vendors Organization [l]a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D [l] D c Turnover D D D [l]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [l] D b Deliverables D [l] D D

4 Project completed within budget [l] DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [l] D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) [l] DD D c Regu latory Agency(ies) D D D [l]

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Owner Advisor work continued(s) in support of Construction of Pump Station Inflow Gate Structure and levee hardening

Verified via IMAIL __VERBAL Date 5 ( 3 c b() I a All information piovided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that Inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made In support of this response may be used by the

512G9JiIX 11s a basis for rejection rescission or the award or termination or the contract and rllffl~Anampe as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 or the Broward CojlftYi 34~6ttlrbtflent Code Y

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

B0~~AARD ~~t~UNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

Fl ORIOA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Sunrise

Contact Name Luisa Fernanda Arbelaa Title Project Manager Reference date 05162018

Contact Email LArbelaezsunrlseflgov Contact Phone 954-888-6009

Name of Referenced Project City of Sunrise - Springtree WTP Water Stabilization and Solids Handling

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PA 16-003-CE 04072016 to 05292018 $ 50797800

Vendors role in Project ]Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [l]Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Carollo Engineers performed the design study and construction administration services for the City

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D G6 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Carollo Engineers technical knowledge and attenllon lo detall were beneficial lo the pltojad They ecled in lhe C~ys besl Interest In every aspect for lhe d1K8Uon of the projectbull

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via ~MAIL _VERBAL Verified by fc4J~~ Division W fl ED All lnrormalion provided to Broward ltAunty Is oobjoci to vorirtcotion Vendoc ecknowledgu that 1naowrate unlMhfuf 0lt lncocrecl statements rnado In support or this response may be useltI by lhe County as a basis for rejection rescission or the award 0lt termination ol the convect and may also ampOIVe as the babullibull ror debarmont of vondOlt purauont to Section 21119 or the Broward County Proc11oment Code

Bid Sync p 135 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BftQNARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

I l 0 R I 0 A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Florida Technical Consultants

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

VIiiage of Wellington Utilities

Contact Name Bradley Wolak Title Assistant Director Ut11Reference date 5182018

Contact Email bwolakwelllngtonflgov Contact Phone 561-753-2480

Name of Referenced Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 10012017 to Present 3500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vend~ 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again UZfYes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor J_ rJ fJ j(Gr-~k 6 Jti ov1 ~uf-Jiy fgt-r_- syrrzi~ff~ Al

R Q_ d--1 0~l 4 171 i+CI ~~lHI )Please rate your experience with tile Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Applicablereferenced Vendor Improvement

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy B D

DD c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D Db Professionalism D D

c Turnover D DD 3 Timeliness of

a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant(s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Additional Comments (provide on addltjpnal sheetJf needed) bull ~middot$ -JJ fo~~rltjbull lt( c-c_ ~~~ lt fo L1-lfAR- -middot~ I 10 ~ ~

~ bullL ~~ _te_ l~Ilgt~Cef t J ~ l rfbull4 middot r0 laquo r 4111J w f1 rrr- 0r- -i-HIS SECTION(9R COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by fcAJc ~ Division Y-1 IN ED Date 5 ~o w8 All lnfonn1Uon ptollfded to BlOward County le eubjeet to vetfflcatlon Vendor aclltnowledge1 that lneccurale unllJlhfUl or lnconect -bullmenla made In 1UPPort o1 this reopon90 may be uoec1 by the couniy ae a baalS ror re)ectlon re8Claeton Of the award 0t leltmlnatlon Of the contract and may 1l10 MM ae the baale flaquo debarrnont 01 vendor pu11uant to Section 21119 of ll1e Broward County Procurement Codo

BidSync p 18 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F LUFltIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultants LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Palm Beach Public Works

Contact Name Gerry Vazquez Title WRD Technician Reference date 05182018

Contact Email gvazqueztownofpalmbeachcom Contact Phone 772-546-6859

Name of Referenced Project GIS Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 3242014 to Present 13500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [3yenes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

PrwAamprs- favl49z Please rate your experience with the Need a Satlafactory Excellent Not

Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D g- D b Accuracy D Er D c Deliverables g-shyB D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D GJ D b Professionalism D D G- D c Tu mover D D cg- D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D g D b Deliverables D D Qshy D

4 Project completed within budget D D lbJ- D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D El- Db Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [3- D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

BidSync p 17 51232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

120-nWARDLll~ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form fLORllgtA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultant LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Waneya Bryant Title Meter Serv Mgr Reference date 05182018

Contact Email BryantWbbflus Contact Phone 561-742-6427

Name of Referenced Project Boynton Beach Utility GIS Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 12012016 to Present $15000000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

~T~ 5e-r-vtleamp +roM l)h f-es Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D Dc Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ti4 D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ Db Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on addlUonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION~urv USE ONLy u bull

Verified via VEMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by kuJ~ Division W if E D rao(ao8Date 5

All Information provided to Browslaquo COOlty Is Slbject to verfflcation Vendor acKnowledges that lneocurate Untruthful or lncolleel 8tatements made In support d this rfl9pOn98 may be used by 1119 Counly as a batia falt rejection relduion ct Ille award or lemilnlilon of the contract and may al80181Veaa1119 basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 ot Ille Broward CountyProcurement Code

512312018 BidSync p 16

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1

8W1V~isl1War Bid PNC21 15559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Fonn

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Cooper City - middot

Contact Name Michael Bailey PE itle Utilities DlrCity EbullReference date 05011201s

Contact Email MBalleycoopercityflorg Contact Phone (954) 434-5519

Name of Referenced Project City of Cooper City Continuing Professional Services bullContract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

RFQ 2009middot 1 04242009 to Present $ 2 19844200

Vendors role in Project IZJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Since 2009 Hazen has provided Cooper City with engineering services or water and wastewater projects Projects have lnctudeo lhe Pine Island Road Pump Station Lilt S1alions 2 amp 49 Improvements Master Plan Update of the FeaslJl~lty Review of Infrastructure Improvements tor Wastewater and the Eflluent Reuse and Disposal Master Plan

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy 8 D

D ~ D c Deliverables D 0 ~ D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D 0 D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tumover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D GJ- D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D 0 D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) ~D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

bull-rHIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY-

Verified vie EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ct4~ Division ~tUb Date ~ i3~) 0fgt All Information provided to BltCgtWW County 11 wbed ID vamprificalion Velldot adltnowledgu that lnaoewate unlrUhful lncom1ct statemampnla made in wppolt of 11111 response may blt uHd by the

4t2j=~ rejection rHclsslcn of th8 award or lennhallon of Ille eoo1nlct and may also seNamp at tilt basis for dtbarmenl at Vendor puuan1 lo Sectioo 21119 of the Broward COltJi 43

5232018 Bid Sync p24

Broward County Board of PNC211 5559P1

~RiiirilyenlcHUffi~~8CrW~r Bid PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

8DdMARD _ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FL O RIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Fort Lauderdale

Contact Name Rares Patrica PE Title Senior Project Mgr Reference date os1021201s

Contact Email RPetricafortlauderdalegov Contact Phone 9548287150

Name of Referenced Project Stormwater Master Planning and Design Implementation Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

256-11660 04192016 to 04192021 $ 989400000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

vyould you use this vendor again Sves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor The Hazen team Is responsible for delivery of a new stormwaler master plan model a prlorlllzed slormwaterresllency capital Improvements plan and Implementation of designs to address chronic flooding and other slormwater management challenges In the City Primary work tasks Include data collectlon hydrologlclhydraullc modeling and design permitting and construction services for capllal Improvement projects resulting from the revised stormwater master plan (preltmlnary design In seven priority neighborhoods)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION ~R COUNTY USE ONLY

aJ~Verified via pound MA IL _VERBAL Verified by Division W1~tl Date 5 ~3o~ax l S N I informallon p roviltled lo Broward County is sulljecl lo verification Vendor altknowledjj6s lhal inaccurate unlMhlut or lncotreci statements m ade In support of this respon$e may be used by tho

412~-~ rejeclion rescission of the award or termination ol lhe contracl and may also serve as lhe basis for debalment ol Vendor purwant to Section 21119 ol lhe Broward Cou~ 4 3

5232018 Bid Sync p25

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 Br~~~~~rs Bid PNC2115559P1 County t ommissioners

B~uWARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FlOR I CA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

Solicitation PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and s OrganizationFirm Name p

Town of Jupiter

nee

Contact Email davidbjupiterflus Contact Phone (561) 746-5134

Name of Referenced Project Engineering Services for Stormwater and Water Capital Improvements

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount $ 630000000 W17248 (2017 reselection 1012000 to Present (estimated lee-to-date since contract inception) contract number)

Vendors role in Project IZI Prime Vendor osubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again 0Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Descriotion of services orovided bv Vendor Since 2000 Hazen has served as General Consulfant to the Town or Jupiter As General Stormwater and Water Consullant the firm has provided services related to master planning stormwater planning and modeling design NPDES permilling asset management resiliency ratefinancial analysis plan review and construction oversight Water-related capital projs have involved additional system storage and high-service pumping transmission system improvements and RampR at existing facilities

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Verllied via EMAIL _ VERBAL Division WWC D

fo (J-Vv ~ltIvmiddotj Date 5(30(ipf S

Al lnroimallon pngtYICGd 10 Broward Counly Is sub)oel to v8flrcallon vendlaquo acknowledges lhat Inaccurate unlruthlu~ 0t Jnwrrect slatoments made In support ol this response may be used by the 42~~1~0 rojecllon rescission or Ille award or termination or lhe con~acl bullnd mbully also serve as tho basis r0t debarment of Vendor pursuant lo Socllon 21119 of lho Broward Couw 41

5232018 BidSync p 26

a N ~ IL) IL) N u z a_

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLO RI DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Walter Wernecke RA Title Sr Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email WWERNECKEhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Hollywood Marina Restrooms

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

04152015 to Present 7500000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor OSubconsultanVSubcontractor n ~U t1

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

-0 Vgt Description of services provided by VendorO ~ ~ Q) Structural Design and Construction Inspection Services i co Q m ~- c E c0

i E gt Oo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not () uu Appllcable O

E~ referenced Vendor Improvement iii ~sectoO 1 Vendors Quality of Service B mu a Responsive D D

b Accuracy DD c Deliverables D DD

2 Vendors Organization D Da Staff expertise v D b Professionalism~ D D c Turnover D ~D

3 Timeliness of D a Project b Deliverables D ~

4 Pec~~11~$~hinJ~~qt lfr D D 5 Cooperation with f ~

a Your Firm D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D

Al lnfonn1tion pRgttded IO Brwd Cltgtunly lo 1ubjecl IO ibllon vsor ~middot Iha icl-bullmiddot ~ ir-ect slalemenls mode In _ol lhb _ moy ti used by he County as a basis lot rejecUon rnclnlon cl the eward or tonnlnallan of lhl connct 1nd may bullllo 11 the basis for dobalment of Vendor IQtulnl IO SICllOn 21119 at lhe Broword County Procurement Code

Cl ltraquo I() I() I() N ()

Cl z

BRltJWARD ~ middot COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORl OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Davie

Contact Name Emilio DeSimone Title Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email Emilio_DeSimonedavie-fl gov Contact Phone 954-797-1085

Name of Referenced Project Pavillion 5 Linear Park

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

B-17-123 09152015 to 2700000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor O SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es O No If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

0 Description of services provided by Vendor O Q)

iii c Structural Design and Construction Inspection ServicesoQ

CDi-

0cc E gt=gt E ()Oo O () () Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

ii) -e i- Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 111 cs

B ioO

J 1 Vendors Quality of Service Q ()

a Responsive D D b Accuracy D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization []Ll Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D Dtr

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [g D b Deliverables D D ar D

4 Project completed within budget [1tD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) cgD D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via l EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by ~h~ Division WlI Etgt Date 0 f l~o I 8 All lnformaUon provided lO Broward County Is eubJect 10 verifutlon Vendor ecknOMedgoo that lnaocurote unNlhlul or Incorrect statamenle made In aupl)Ort of this reaponse may be used by lho County et o baampla for rejection realtluion of the award or lermlnallon of tho eon1fllcl ond moy olao aorvo os ho basis for debarmont of Vondor purauenl lo Section 21119 of the Broward Counly Procuremen1 Code

0 0 agt a c () z 0

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Terrence Comiskey AIA Title Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email TCOMISKEYhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Van Buren Parking Garage

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PK 14-053 Nov 2014 to Present 8310000

Vendors role in Project t8(Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

o~ Description of services provided by Vendor 1 Q)ltO c Structural Design and Conslructlon Inspection Services 0 Q

0~Jl ccE l E enOo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

gtshy

uu O Improvement Applicable ffireferenced Vendor

~sect 1 Vendors Quality of Service 1 ~

oOau a Responsive D ~ D b Accuracy B D D

D D [- Dc Deliverables

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tum over D D D g

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ D Subcontractor(s )S ubcons u ltant( s)b D D ~ D

c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D yenj D Additional Comments provide on sdditlonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION ~NTY USE ONLY0

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by kW Division W-1-(i~ Date EJo(a~t8 Al lnform1Uon PltOVlded lo Browald Ccxnty It IUbjoct to vorificallon Vendor eoknowfodgea thal lnaewralt U111MhlJI deg inlaquogtlaquobullel amptal11ants made In eupporl of lhls relj)Onse may be used by Iha Counly es a balls l0t rcfecllon rescfuloltI of tho ew1rd or 1ermtnaU0lt1 ol lhbull conllllCI and may elao urve 11 lho basis for dabarmenl of Vondor pursuanl lo Secllon 21 119 of he erowald COUlly CiProcurement Code

~ N ii

00

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 aOWllrp Commficumlref Bid PNC2116615B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Pompano Beach FL

Contact Name Mr A Randolph Brown Title Utilities Director Reference date April 30 2018

Contact Email randolphbrowncopbflcom Contact Phone 954-545-7043

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 201 o Project Amount fees varied

Multiple

Vendors role in Project IKJ Prime Vendor

to 2018

osubconsultanUSubcontractor

(range $10000shy$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D ~ D D c Deliverables D ~ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D ~ D D b Professionalism D D ~ D C Turnover D El DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ 0 b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D [BJ D n c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [XJ o ~

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed) amp~~it -THIS SECTION ~COUNTY USE ONL y-bullbull

Verified via ~AIL __VERBAL Verified by 1lt4 )~ Division N WE O Date 5 faol Z1 18

All lnformotlon providod to BltownrltI Cou nty it aubjoct O verification VendOr acknowledges that lnaccornto untruthful or incorroct 11atomon1s made in support of this response may be used by tho

411p~~)~~J rojoclion roscissioo ol lho award or 1orroinalion of tho contract and roay also s01vo as lhbull basis f0lt d~arroont of VondOf pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward Cou)l1

Bid Sync p 73

40

5232018

Broward County Board of Bid PNC2116659B 1 County Commissioners

B~aWARD gt1- t COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Loxahatchee River Environmental Control District

Contact Name Mr Kris Dean Title Director of Engineering Reference date May 9 2018

Contact Email krisdeanloxahatcheeriverorg Contact Phone 561-747-5700

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 2001 Project Amount fees varied (range $10000shyMultiple to 2018 $250000)

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IR)Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D ~ D D b Accuracy D 0 D D c Deliverables D IBJ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D IB] D D b Professionalism D ~ D D c Turnover D [8J D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D [8J D D b Deliverables D m D D

4 Project completed within budget D ~ D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D ~ D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D Ii] D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D ~ D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SE~ FOR~USE ONLY

Verified via _lEMAIL __VERBAL Verified by ~lt Division fWeb Date I

All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untrulhful or incorrecl slatements made In support of this response may be used by the lJl~~~l~~jSfiir rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and mll~~~ere as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Co)f 10

Broward County Board of Bid PNC21166$9B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A l

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Lake Worth FL

Contact Name Mr Felipe Lofaso TitleAsst Dir Public-ServicesReference date May 9 2018

Contact Email flofasolakeworthorg Contact Phone 561-586-1720

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contract

Contract No Date Services Provided 2014 Project Amount fees varied Multiple to 2018 (range $10000shy

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Services included multiple municipal engineering projects including survey roadway design utility design and coordination (water wastewater stormwater other) along with project management

Needs Satisfactory Excellent NotPlease rate your experience with the Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D GJ D b Accuracy D D Ii] D c Deliverables D Ii] DD

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [i] D c Turnover D D D [X]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D 0 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [X] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION Fe COUNTY USE ONLrbullbull

Verified via MAIL __VERBAL Verified by Division ~wgtgt Date 5~3ol20t8 All information provided to Broward County Is subject lo verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect slalements made in support ol this response may be used by the

OZ~id~~~~j~r rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and m~~~(iirve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Cour~ iG

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - ARCADIS US INC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts

VS0000013130 VS00013130 - ARCADIS US INC Prime Work Auth Vendor SummaryProjects

PURCHASING 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold Procurement No Fixed Contracts FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Favorites Past 5 Years Prime Vendor

Sub Vendor From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 10042017 Purchase Order

Evaluation Purchase Orders 1 POs With A Total Amt Of $20000000 Log Off Paid To Dt ($12132949) Balance $7867051

Contracts Purchase Orders Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx 6192018

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Finish

PURCHASING Weighted Scores Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract FileRoom DashBoard Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number FileRoom Insert

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel Favorites Prime Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Service Evaluation

6132017 YES 486 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Goals Compliance Evaluation

10272016 YES 460 View Docs (0)

6272018

Project Management Information System

Close

Contracts Central Administration

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9130 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-24

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6182018 YES 355 View Docs (1)

Proj Nbr 9320 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-20

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6132018 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9290 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-23

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1122018 YES 494 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-21

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12182017 YES 488 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10162017 YES 473 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

8252017 YES 495 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9321 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-19

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

7112017 YES 476 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-17

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2272017 YES 400 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

10132016 YES 384 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-12

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

5202016 YES 405 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9018 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-06

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10192015 YES 448 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

3202015 YES 385 View Docs (0)

Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL CONSULTANTS

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Project Management Information System

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-04

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12122014 YES 437 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-08

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1242014 YES 423 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-02

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2282014 YES 452 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC

VC0000044184 VC00044184 - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres PS $001 Used $000 Remain $001 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $354848400 Closed 0 Total $000 Total Current Retainage Balance For All Contracts $793370 No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 06292015 Purchase Orders 2 POs With A Total Amt Of $362317900 Paid To Dt ($218795160) Balance $143522740

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 40803 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9058 - DISTRICT 3A POTABLE WATER STORAGE

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1220410P1 - Consultant Engineering Services for Potable Water FixedOpen Contracts Storage Tanks and Pumping Systems Work Auth Prime Vendor CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Periodic Final Finish

Log Off Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type

Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

6232015 8302017 413 Approved 8312017 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard

Enter Vendor Name (or a portion of) Then Click Search - Wilcards Are Permitted (ie wa wawainc) Florida Technical Consultants

Search Reset Finish

No Vendors Found For Your Search Try Again

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41005 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score Go

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0773

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

12122017 YES 430 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

8302016 YES 438 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Final Consultant Evaluation 3142016 YES 478 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0706

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

142016 YES 402 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9016OES - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0731

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

10192015 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0748

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

612015 YES 467 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

2192015 YES 500 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0754

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

252015 YES 409 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0755

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

1242014 YES 415 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8974 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0758

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

6202014 YES 393 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr

WATER amp WASTEWATER

Final Consultant Work Authorization 572014 YES 423 View Docs

(0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

HS0746 ENGINEERING Evaluation

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

4302014 YES 475 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Evaluation 4302014 YES 493 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0710

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

3172014 YES 395 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0753

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

1212014 YES 380 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0763

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

11192013 YES 450 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0775

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 408 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals

Finish

Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed FileRoom DashBoard Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization FileRoom Insert NumberFavorites

Prime Vendor Export To Excel Sub Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0772

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 417 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0771

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

2262013 YES 410 View Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 17: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Palm Beach County Water Utilities Department

Contact Name Ali Bayat Title Assistant Director Reference date

Contact Email abayatpbcwatercom Contact Phone 561 493 6128

Name of Referenced Project System 8 Water Quality Assessment

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

17-021 CSA21 01 022017 to 01152018 $ 8936000

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again (Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Brown and Caldwell led assessment of contributing causes to low system residuals troubleshooting treatment processes special testing and data analysis improvements to operating protocols monitoringcontrol system and treatment process

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [Z] D b Accuracy D [Z] DD c Deliverables D [Z]D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D [Z] D b Professionalism D D [Z] D c Turnover D [Z] DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D [Z] D

4 Project completed within budget D D [Z] D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Consultant worked collaboratively with operating maintenance engineering and laboratory staff to develop insight into contributing factors and implement improvements

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via _LEMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by tcltJ1~ Division -+LN euro P Date lteh IWt 8 All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the County as a basis for rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and may also serve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward County Procurement Code

BltaWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F L 0 R I D A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood Florida

Contact Name Steve Joseph Title Director Reference date

Contact Email sjosephhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954 921 3522

Name of Referenced Project Distribution System Water Quality Improvement

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

01012016 to 06022017 $ 3000000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again []Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Supported the City with its efforts improve chlorine residuals in areas of its system Analysis included system modeling monitoring optimized operational practices Implemented operational improvements that significantly raised (from approx 05 to 20 mgL) chloramine residuals In the most challenging area of the system

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D D [] D c Deliverables []D D D

2 Vendors Organization [] Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D [] D c Turnover D D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D [] D

4 Project completed within budget []D D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) []D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [] D

Additional Com ments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Effort Included system modoling moniloring and excursion response procedures opllmitallon of stored Inventory management unidirectional flushing pilot assessment and treatment proooss evaluation

Verified via __EMAIL vERBAL Division WW ED Date G Ifgt I 8 All infonmallon pltovided to Broward County Is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of thi s response may be used by lhe County as a basis for rejeclion rescission or the award or tenminatlon of the contract and may also serve as the basis for debanment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 or lhe Broward County Procurement Code

BROWARD t (l)t~ 1 Vendor Reference Verification Form

fl O R I OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of West Palm Beach Florida

Contact Name Jay Kwag Title Project Manager Reference date

Contact Email hjkwagwpborg Contact Phone 561 494 1041

Name of Referenced Project Modeling and Infrastructure General Engineering Consulting Assigments

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

11032014 to HAlt zc1e (on~vi~)

Vendors role in Project 52fPrime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IQves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Planning and General Eng1neerg Servicus 1nctuslve ol Waterwastewater System Master Pian asset management program dovo10pmenV11sset Crt1tcat1ty assessment Mesler PS 115 and sewer cond1hon assessment hydrauhc modeling ol LS 5 and force main sizing water system Capacity Analysis RoPort nydraullc modeling ol operahonat challongos tilt ste11on enatysbulls lac11i1a1e 1nspec11011 or major FM and new develOpmenl 1mpnc1s plpohno design lilt station condbullhon assessment and renabtlilahon (Various ProJecls)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D 0 D b Accuracy D 0D D c Deliverables D D 0 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D Gt D b Professionalism D D ~-- D c Turnover D D Gr D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D B D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget D D r~r D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D c~r D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D 0 D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION F~USE ONLY

__VERBAL Verified via LMAIL Verified by ~J Division ~~~D Date ~ f 2 f~t8 All lnfo11na1t0n pr ()Vl(fed 10 Broward County is svb1et110 ven11ca1ion vendor acknowledges lhll 1naeoura10 unlrulhful 0lt inc0ltrec1 s1a1emen1s medo In support ol 1n1s response may be used Dy the County as a basis fcu rejection re sclsst0n Of 1ho award or 1ormina1lon of l he contract and may also servo as the basis for debarment o f Vendor pursuant lo Section 21 119 of tho ampoward Counly P1ocuremont Code

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A middot

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Michael Low Title Deputy Director Reference date 05172018

Contact Email lowmbbflus Contact Phone 5617426403

Name of Referenced Project Ion Exchange Design Build

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

07022014 to 03212018 $ 100000000

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Carollo handled all of the design and construction of a significant part of the project as a subcontractor to COM Constructors as part of a progressive design build contract

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [Z] D b Accuracy D D [Z] D c Deliverables D D [Z] D

2 Vendors Organization D D [Z] Da Staff expertise b Professionalism D D [Z] D c Turnover D D D [Z]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D [Z] D

4 Project completed within budget D D [Z] D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D [Z] D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [Z] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION F~ COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ~~ Division W -NED Date S-gtozot~ All Information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor aclltnowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

Stii191111X 11s a basis for rejection rescission of the award or termination or the conlact and m~~Arifrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward CounYJ 33Plamptl1til1ent Code Y Imiddot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

B~OWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LORID A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

South Florida Water Management District

Contact Name Greg Coffelt PE Title SFWMD Project Manager Reference date 05172018

Contact Email gcoffeltsfwmdgov Contact Phone 561-682-6853

Name of Referenced Project L-8 Reservoir Inflow Structure and Pump Station

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

4600000861 02152011 to 09192012 $ 144535100

Vendors role in Project [l) Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [l)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Corolla was contracted as an Owners Advisor for a Design-Build contract developed engineering design criteria assisted in RFQ development and evaluation supported RFP technical proposal and cost proposal analysis

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [l] D b Accuracy D [] D D c Deliverables D [] D D

2 Vendors Organization [l]a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D [l] D c Turnover D D D [l]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [l] D b Deliverables D [l] D D

4 Project completed within budget [l] DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [l] D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) [l] DD D c Regu latory Agency(ies) D D D [l]

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Owner Advisor work continued(s) in support of Construction of Pump Station Inflow Gate Structure and levee hardening

Verified via IMAIL __VERBAL Date 5 ( 3 c b() I a All information piovided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that Inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made In support of this response may be used by the

512G9JiIX 11s a basis for rejection rescission or the award or termination or the contract and rllffl~Anampe as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 or the Broward CojlftYi 34~6ttlrbtflent Code Y

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

B0~~AARD ~~t~UNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

Fl ORIOA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Sunrise

Contact Name Luisa Fernanda Arbelaa Title Project Manager Reference date 05162018

Contact Email LArbelaezsunrlseflgov Contact Phone 954-888-6009

Name of Referenced Project City of Sunrise - Springtree WTP Water Stabilization and Solids Handling

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PA 16-003-CE 04072016 to 05292018 $ 50797800

Vendors role in Project ]Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [l]Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Carollo Engineers performed the design study and construction administration services for the City

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D G6 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Carollo Engineers technical knowledge and attenllon lo detall were beneficial lo the pltojad They ecled in lhe C~ys besl Interest In every aspect for lhe d1K8Uon of the projectbull

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via ~MAIL _VERBAL Verified by fc4J~~ Division W fl ED All lnrormalion provided to Broward ltAunty Is oobjoci to vorirtcotion Vendoc ecknowledgu that 1naowrate unlMhfuf 0lt lncocrecl statements rnado In support or this response may be useltI by lhe County as a basis for rejection rescission or the award 0lt termination ol the convect and may also ampOIVe as the babullibull ror debarmont of vondOlt purauont to Section 21119 or the Broward County Proc11oment Code

Bid Sync p 135 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BftQNARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

I l 0 R I 0 A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Florida Technical Consultants

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

VIiiage of Wellington Utilities

Contact Name Bradley Wolak Title Assistant Director Ut11Reference date 5182018

Contact Email bwolakwelllngtonflgov Contact Phone 561-753-2480

Name of Referenced Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 10012017 to Present 3500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vend~ 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again UZfYes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor J_ rJ fJ j(Gr-~k 6 Jti ov1 ~uf-Jiy fgt-r_- syrrzi~ff~ Al

R Q_ d--1 0~l 4 171 i+CI ~~lHI )Please rate your experience with tile Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Applicablereferenced Vendor Improvement

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy B D

DD c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D Db Professionalism D D

c Turnover D DD 3 Timeliness of

a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant(s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Additional Comments (provide on addltjpnal sheetJf needed) bull ~middot$ -JJ fo~~rltjbull lt( c-c_ ~~~ lt fo L1-lfAR- -middot~ I 10 ~ ~

~ bullL ~~ _te_ l~Ilgt~Cef t J ~ l rfbull4 middot r0 laquo r 4111J w f1 rrr- 0r- -i-HIS SECTION(9R COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by fcAJc ~ Division Y-1 IN ED Date 5 ~o w8 All lnfonn1Uon ptollfded to BlOward County le eubjeet to vetfflcatlon Vendor aclltnowledge1 that lneccurale unllJlhfUl or lnconect -bullmenla made In 1UPPort o1 this reopon90 may be uoec1 by the couniy ae a baalS ror re)ectlon re8Claeton Of the award 0t leltmlnatlon Of the contract and may 1l10 MM ae the baale flaquo debarrnont 01 vendor pu11uant to Section 21119 of ll1e Broward County Procurement Codo

BidSync p 18 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F LUFltIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultants LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Palm Beach Public Works

Contact Name Gerry Vazquez Title WRD Technician Reference date 05182018

Contact Email gvazqueztownofpalmbeachcom Contact Phone 772-546-6859

Name of Referenced Project GIS Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 3242014 to Present 13500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [3yenes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

PrwAamprs- favl49z Please rate your experience with the Need a Satlafactory Excellent Not

Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D g- D b Accuracy D Er D c Deliverables g-shyB D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D GJ D b Professionalism D D G- D c Tu mover D D cg- D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D g D b Deliverables D D Qshy D

4 Project completed within budget D D lbJ- D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D El- Db Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [3- D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

BidSync p 17 51232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

120-nWARDLll~ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form fLORllgtA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultant LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Waneya Bryant Title Meter Serv Mgr Reference date 05182018

Contact Email BryantWbbflus Contact Phone 561-742-6427

Name of Referenced Project Boynton Beach Utility GIS Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 12012016 to Present $15000000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

~T~ 5e-r-vtleamp +roM l)h f-es Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D Dc Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ti4 D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ Db Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on addlUonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION~urv USE ONLy u bull

Verified via VEMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by kuJ~ Division W if E D rao(ao8Date 5

All Information provided to Browslaquo COOlty Is Slbject to verfflcation Vendor acKnowledges that lneocurate Untruthful or lncolleel 8tatements made In support d this rfl9pOn98 may be used by 1119 Counly as a batia falt rejection relduion ct Ille award or lemilnlilon of the contract and may al80181Veaa1119 basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 ot Ille Broward CountyProcurement Code

512312018 BidSync p 16

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1

8W1V~isl1War Bid PNC21 15559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Fonn

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Cooper City - middot

Contact Name Michael Bailey PE itle Utilities DlrCity EbullReference date 05011201s

Contact Email MBalleycoopercityflorg Contact Phone (954) 434-5519

Name of Referenced Project City of Cooper City Continuing Professional Services bullContract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

RFQ 2009middot 1 04242009 to Present $ 2 19844200

Vendors role in Project IZJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Since 2009 Hazen has provided Cooper City with engineering services or water and wastewater projects Projects have lnctudeo lhe Pine Island Road Pump Station Lilt S1alions 2 amp 49 Improvements Master Plan Update of the FeaslJl~lty Review of Infrastructure Improvements tor Wastewater and the Eflluent Reuse and Disposal Master Plan

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy 8 D

D ~ D c Deliverables D 0 ~ D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D 0 D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tumover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D GJ- D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D 0 D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) ~D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

bull-rHIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY-

Verified vie EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ct4~ Division ~tUb Date ~ i3~) 0fgt All Information provided to BltCgtWW County 11 wbed ID vamprificalion Velldot adltnowledgu that lnaoewate unlrUhful lncom1ct statemampnla made in wppolt of 11111 response may blt uHd by the

4t2j=~ rejection rHclsslcn of th8 award or lennhallon of Ille eoo1nlct and may also seNamp at tilt basis for dtbarmenl at Vendor puuan1 lo Sectioo 21119 of the Broward COltJi 43

5232018 Bid Sync p24

Broward County Board of PNC211 5559P1

~RiiirilyenlcHUffi~~8CrW~r Bid PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

8DdMARD _ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FL O RIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Fort Lauderdale

Contact Name Rares Patrica PE Title Senior Project Mgr Reference date os1021201s

Contact Email RPetricafortlauderdalegov Contact Phone 9548287150

Name of Referenced Project Stormwater Master Planning and Design Implementation Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

256-11660 04192016 to 04192021 $ 989400000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

vyould you use this vendor again Sves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor The Hazen team Is responsible for delivery of a new stormwaler master plan model a prlorlllzed slormwaterresllency capital Improvements plan and Implementation of designs to address chronic flooding and other slormwater management challenges In the City Primary work tasks Include data collectlon hydrologlclhydraullc modeling and design permitting and construction services for capllal Improvement projects resulting from the revised stormwater master plan (preltmlnary design In seven priority neighborhoods)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION ~R COUNTY USE ONLY

aJ~Verified via pound MA IL _VERBAL Verified by Division W1~tl Date 5 ~3o~ax l S N I informallon p roviltled lo Broward County is sulljecl lo verification Vendor altknowledjj6s lhal inaccurate unlMhlut or lncotreci statements m ade In support of this respon$e may be used by tho

412~-~ rejeclion rescission of the award or termination ol lhe contracl and may also serve as lhe basis for debalment ol Vendor purwant to Section 21119 ol lhe Broward Cou~ 4 3

5232018 Bid Sync p25

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 Br~~~~~rs Bid PNC2115559P1 County t ommissioners

B~uWARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FlOR I CA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

Solicitation PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and s OrganizationFirm Name p

Town of Jupiter

nee

Contact Email davidbjupiterflus Contact Phone (561) 746-5134

Name of Referenced Project Engineering Services for Stormwater and Water Capital Improvements

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount $ 630000000 W17248 (2017 reselection 1012000 to Present (estimated lee-to-date since contract inception) contract number)

Vendors role in Project IZI Prime Vendor osubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again 0Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Descriotion of services orovided bv Vendor Since 2000 Hazen has served as General Consulfant to the Town or Jupiter As General Stormwater and Water Consullant the firm has provided services related to master planning stormwater planning and modeling design NPDES permilling asset management resiliency ratefinancial analysis plan review and construction oversight Water-related capital projs have involved additional system storage and high-service pumping transmission system improvements and RampR at existing facilities

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Verllied via EMAIL _ VERBAL Division WWC D

fo (J-Vv ~ltIvmiddotj Date 5(30(ipf S

Al lnroimallon pngtYICGd 10 Broward Counly Is sub)oel to v8flrcallon vendlaquo acknowledges lhat Inaccurate unlruthlu~ 0t Jnwrrect slatoments made In support ol this response may be used by the 42~~1~0 rojecllon rescission or Ille award or termination or lhe con~acl bullnd mbully also serve as tho basis r0t debarment of Vendor pursuant lo Socllon 21119 of lho Broward Couw 41

5232018 BidSync p 26

a N ~ IL) IL) N u z a_

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLO RI DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Walter Wernecke RA Title Sr Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email WWERNECKEhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Hollywood Marina Restrooms

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

04152015 to Present 7500000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor OSubconsultanVSubcontractor n ~U t1

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

-0 Vgt Description of services provided by VendorO ~ ~ Q) Structural Design and Construction Inspection Services i co Q m ~- c E c0

i E gt Oo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not () uu Appllcable O

E~ referenced Vendor Improvement iii ~sectoO 1 Vendors Quality of Service B mu a Responsive D D

b Accuracy DD c Deliverables D DD

2 Vendors Organization D Da Staff expertise v D b Professionalism~ D D c Turnover D ~D

3 Timeliness of D a Project b Deliverables D ~

4 Pec~~11~$~hinJ~~qt lfr D D 5 Cooperation with f ~

a Your Firm D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D

Al lnfonn1tion pRgttded IO Brwd Cltgtunly lo 1ubjecl IO ibllon vsor ~middot Iha icl-bullmiddot ~ ir-ect slalemenls mode In _ol lhb _ moy ti used by he County as a basis lot rejecUon rnclnlon cl the eward or tonnlnallan of lhl connct 1nd may bullllo 11 the basis for dobalment of Vendor IQtulnl IO SICllOn 21119 at lhe Broword County Procurement Code

Cl ltraquo I() I() I() N ()

Cl z

BRltJWARD ~ middot COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORl OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Davie

Contact Name Emilio DeSimone Title Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email Emilio_DeSimonedavie-fl gov Contact Phone 954-797-1085

Name of Referenced Project Pavillion 5 Linear Park

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

B-17-123 09152015 to 2700000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor O SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es O No If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

0 Description of services provided by Vendor O Q)

iii c Structural Design and Construction Inspection ServicesoQ

CDi-

0cc E gt=gt E ()Oo O () () Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

ii) -e i- Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 111 cs

B ioO

J 1 Vendors Quality of Service Q ()

a Responsive D D b Accuracy D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization []Ll Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D Dtr

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [g D b Deliverables D D ar D

4 Project completed within budget [1tD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) cgD D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via l EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by ~h~ Division WlI Etgt Date 0 f l~o I 8 All lnformaUon provided lO Broward County Is eubJect 10 verifutlon Vendor ecknOMedgoo that lnaocurote unNlhlul or Incorrect statamenle made In aupl)Ort of this reaponse may be used by lho County et o baampla for rejection realtluion of the award or lermlnallon of tho eon1fllcl ond moy olao aorvo os ho basis for debarmont of Vondor purauenl lo Section 21119 of the Broward Counly Procuremen1 Code

0 0 agt a c () z 0

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Terrence Comiskey AIA Title Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email TCOMISKEYhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Van Buren Parking Garage

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PK 14-053 Nov 2014 to Present 8310000

Vendors role in Project t8(Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

o~ Description of services provided by Vendor 1 Q)ltO c Structural Design and Conslructlon Inspection Services 0 Q

0~Jl ccE l E enOo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

gtshy

uu O Improvement Applicable ffireferenced Vendor

~sect 1 Vendors Quality of Service 1 ~

oOau a Responsive D ~ D b Accuracy B D D

D D [- Dc Deliverables

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tum over D D D g

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ D Subcontractor(s )S ubcons u ltant( s)b D D ~ D

c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D yenj D Additional Comments provide on sdditlonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION ~NTY USE ONLY0

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by kW Division W-1-(i~ Date EJo(a~t8 Al lnform1Uon PltOVlded lo Browald Ccxnty It IUbjoct to vorificallon Vendor eoknowfodgea thal lnaewralt U111MhlJI deg inlaquogtlaquobullel amptal11ants made In eupporl of lhls relj)Onse may be used by Iha Counly es a balls l0t rcfecllon rescfuloltI of tho ew1rd or 1ermtnaU0lt1 ol lhbull conllllCI and may elao urve 11 lho basis for dabarmenl of Vondor pursuanl lo Secllon 21 119 of he erowald COUlly CiProcurement Code

~ N ii

00

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 aOWllrp Commficumlref Bid PNC2116615B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Pompano Beach FL

Contact Name Mr A Randolph Brown Title Utilities Director Reference date April 30 2018

Contact Email randolphbrowncopbflcom Contact Phone 954-545-7043

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 201 o Project Amount fees varied

Multiple

Vendors role in Project IKJ Prime Vendor

to 2018

osubconsultanUSubcontractor

(range $10000shy$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D ~ D D c Deliverables D ~ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D ~ D D b Professionalism D D ~ D C Turnover D El DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ 0 b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D [BJ D n c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [XJ o ~

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed) amp~~it -THIS SECTION ~COUNTY USE ONL y-bullbull

Verified via ~AIL __VERBAL Verified by 1lt4 )~ Division N WE O Date 5 faol Z1 18

All lnformotlon providod to BltownrltI Cou nty it aubjoct O verification VendOr acknowledges that lnaccornto untruthful or incorroct 11atomon1s made in support of this response may be used by tho

411p~~)~~J rojoclion roscissioo ol lho award or 1orroinalion of tho contract and roay also s01vo as lhbull basis f0lt d~arroont of VondOf pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward Cou)l1

Bid Sync p 73

40

5232018

Broward County Board of Bid PNC2116659B 1 County Commissioners

B~aWARD gt1- t COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Loxahatchee River Environmental Control District

Contact Name Mr Kris Dean Title Director of Engineering Reference date May 9 2018

Contact Email krisdeanloxahatcheeriverorg Contact Phone 561-747-5700

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 2001 Project Amount fees varied (range $10000shyMultiple to 2018 $250000)

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IR)Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D ~ D D b Accuracy D 0 D D c Deliverables D IBJ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D IB] D D b Professionalism D ~ D D c Turnover D [8J D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D [8J D D b Deliverables D m D D

4 Project completed within budget D ~ D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D ~ D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D Ii] D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D ~ D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SE~ FOR~USE ONLY

Verified via _lEMAIL __VERBAL Verified by ~lt Division fWeb Date I

All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untrulhful or incorrecl slatements made In support of this response may be used by the lJl~~~l~~jSfiir rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and mll~~~ere as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Co)f 10

Broward County Board of Bid PNC21166$9B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A l

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Lake Worth FL

Contact Name Mr Felipe Lofaso TitleAsst Dir Public-ServicesReference date May 9 2018

Contact Email flofasolakeworthorg Contact Phone 561-586-1720

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contract

Contract No Date Services Provided 2014 Project Amount fees varied Multiple to 2018 (range $10000shy

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Services included multiple municipal engineering projects including survey roadway design utility design and coordination (water wastewater stormwater other) along with project management

Needs Satisfactory Excellent NotPlease rate your experience with the Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D GJ D b Accuracy D D Ii] D c Deliverables D Ii] DD

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [i] D c Turnover D D D [X]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D 0 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [X] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION Fe COUNTY USE ONLrbullbull

Verified via MAIL __VERBAL Verified by Division ~wgtgt Date 5~3ol20t8 All information provided to Broward County Is subject lo verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect slalements made in support ol this response may be used by the

OZ~id~~~~j~r rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and m~~~(iirve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Cour~ iG

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - ARCADIS US INC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts

VS0000013130 VS00013130 - ARCADIS US INC Prime Work Auth Vendor SummaryProjects

PURCHASING 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold Procurement No Fixed Contracts FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Favorites Past 5 Years Prime Vendor

Sub Vendor From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 10042017 Purchase Order

Evaluation Purchase Orders 1 POs With A Total Amt Of $20000000 Log Off Paid To Dt ($12132949) Balance $7867051

Contracts Purchase Orders Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx 6192018

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Finish

PURCHASING Weighted Scores Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract FileRoom DashBoard Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number FileRoom Insert

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel Favorites Prime Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Service Evaluation

6132017 YES 486 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Goals Compliance Evaluation

10272016 YES 460 View Docs (0)

6272018

Project Management Information System

Close

Contracts Central Administration

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9130 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-24

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6182018 YES 355 View Docs (1)

Proj Nbr 9320 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-20

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6132018 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9290 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-23

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1122018 YES 494 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-21

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12182017 YES 488 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10162017 YES 473 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

8252017 YES 495 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9321 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-19

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

7112017 YES 476 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-17

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2272017 YES 400 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

10132016 YES 384 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-12

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

5202016 YES 405 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9018 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-06

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10192015 YES 448 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

3202015 YES 385 View Docs (0)

Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL CONSULTANTS

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Project Management Information System

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-04

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12122014 YES 437 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-08

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1242014 YES 423 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-02

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2282014 YES 452 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC

VC0000044184 VC00044184 - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres PS $001 Used $000 Remain $001 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $354848400 Closed 0 Total $000 Total Current Retainage Balance For All Contracts $793370 No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 06292015 Purchase Orders 2 POs With A Total Amt Of $362317900 Paid To Dt ($218795160) Balance $143522740

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 40803 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9058 - DISTRICT 3A POTABLE WATER STORAGE

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1220410P1 - Consultant Engineering Services for Potable Water FixedOpen Contracts Storage Tanks and Pumping Systems Work Auth Prime Vendor CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Periodic Final Finish

Log Off Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type

Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

6232015 8302017 413 Approved 8312017 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard

Enter Vendor Name (or a portion of) Then Click Search - Wilcards Are Permitted (ie wa wawainc) Florida Technical Consultants

Search Reset Finish

No Vendors Found For Your Search Try Again

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41005 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score Go

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0773

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

12122017 YES 430 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

8302016 YES 438 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Final Consultant Evaluation 3142016 YES 478 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0706

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

142016 YES 402 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9016OES - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0731

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

10192015 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0748

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

612015 YES 467 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

2192015 YES 500 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0754

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

252015 YES 409 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0755

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

1242014 YES 415 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8974 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0758

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

6202014 YES 393 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr

WATER amp WASTEWATER

Final Consultant Work Authorization 572014 YES 423 View Docs

(0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

HS0746 ENGINEERING Evaluation

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

4302014 YES 475 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Evaluation 4302014 YES 493 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0710

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

3172014 YES 395 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0753

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

1212014 YES 380 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0763

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

11192013 YES 450 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0775

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 408 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals

Finish

Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed FileRoom DashBoard Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization FileRoom Insert NumberFavorites

Prime Vendor Export To Excel Sub Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0772

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 417 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0771

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

2262013 YES 410 View Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 18: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

BltaWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F L 0 R I D A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood Florida

Contact Name Steve Joseph Title Director Reference date

Contact Email sjosephhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954 921 3522

Name of Referenced Project Distribution System Water Quality Improvement

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

01012016 to 06022017 $ 3000000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again []Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Supported the City with its efforts improve chlorine residuals in areas of its system Analysis included system modeling monitoring optimized operational practices Implemented operational improvements that significantly raised (from approx 05 to 20 mgL) chloramine residuals In the most challenging area of the system

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D D [] D c Deliverables []D D D

2 Vendors Organization [] Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D [] D c Turnover D D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D [] D

4 Project completed within budget []D D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) []D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [] D

Additional Com ments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Effort Included system modoling moniloring and excursion response procedures opllmitallon of stored Inventory management unidirectional flushing pilot assessment and treatment proooss evaluation

Verified via __EMAIL vERBAL Division WW ED Date G Ifgt I 8 All infonmallon pltovided to Broward County Is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of thi s response may be used by lhe County as a basis for rejeclion rescission or the award or tenminatlon of the contract and may also serve as the basis for debanment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 or lhe Broward County Procurement Code

BROWARD t (l)t~ 1 Vendor Reference Verification Form

fl O R I OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of West Palm Beach Florida

Contact Name Jay Kwag Title Project Manager Reference date

Contact Email hjkwagwpborg Contact Phone 561 494 1041

Name of Referenced Project Modeling and Infrastructure General Engineering Consulting Assigments

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

11032014 to HAlt zc1e (on~vi~)

Vendors role in Project 52fPrime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IQves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Planning and General Eng1neerg Servicus 1nctuslve ol Waterwastewater System Master Pian asset management program dovo10pmenV11sset Crt1tcat1ty assessment Mesler PS 115 and sewer cond1hon assessment hydrauhc modeling ol LS 5 and force main sizing water system Capacity Analysis RoPort nydraullc modeling ol operahonat challongos tilt ste11on enatysbulls lac11i1a1e 1nspec11011 or major FM and new develOpmenl 1mpnc1s plpohno design lilt station condbullhon assessment and renabtlilahon (Various ProJecls)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D 0 D b Accuracy D 0D D c Deliverables D D 0 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D Gt D b Professionalism D D ~-- D c Turnover D D Gr D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D B D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget D D r~r D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D c~r D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D 0 D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION F~USE ONLY

__VERBAL Verified via LMAIL Verified by ~J Division ~~~D Date ~ f 2 f~t8 All lnfo11na1t0n pr ()Vl(fed 10 Broward County is svb1et110 ven11ca1ion vendor acknowledges lhll 1naeoura10 unlrulhful 0lt inc0ltrec1 s1a1emen1s medo In support ol 1n1s response may be used Dy the County as a basis fcu rejection re sclsst0n Of 1ho award or 1ormina1lon of l he contract and may also servo as the basis for debarment o f Vendor pursuant lo Section 21 119 of tho ampoward Counly P1ocuremont Code

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A middot

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Michael Low Title Deputy Director Reference date 05172018

Contact Email lowmbbflus Contact Phone 5617426403

Name of Referenced Project Ion Exchange Design Build

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

07022014 to 03212018 $ 100000000

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Carollo handled all of the design and construction of a significant part of the project as a subcontractor to COM Constructors as part of a progressive design build contract

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [Z] D b Accuracy D D [Z] D c Deliverables D D [Z] D

2 Vendors Organization D D [Z] Da Staff expertise b Professionalism D D [Z] D c Turnover D D D [Z]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D [Z] D

4 Project completed within budget D D [Z] D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D [Z] D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [Z] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION F~ COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ~~ Division W -NED Date S-gtozot~ All Information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor aclltnowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

Stii191111X 11s a basis for rejection rescission of the award or termination or the conlact and m~~Arifrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward CounYJ 33Plamptl1til1ent Code Y Imiddot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

B~OWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LORID A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

South Florida Water Management District

Contact Name Greg Coffelt PE Title SFWMD Project Manager Reference date 05172018

Contact Email gcoffeltsfwmdgov Contact Phone 561-682-6853

Name of Referenced Project L-8 Reservoir Inflow Structure and Pump Station

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

4600000861 02152011 to 09192012 $ 144535100

Vendors role in Project [l) Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [l)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Corolla was contracted as an Owners Advisor for a Design-Build contract developed engineering design criteria assisted in RFQ development and evaluation supported RFP technical proposal and cost proposal analysis

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [l] D b Accuracy D [] D D c Deliverables D [] D D

2 Vendors Organization [l]a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D [l] D c Turnover D D D [l]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [l] D b Deliverables D [l] D D

4 Project completed within budget [l] DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [l] D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) [l] DD D c Regu latory Agency(ies) D D D [l]

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Owner Advisor work continued(s) in support of Construction of Pump Station Inflow Gate Structure and levee hardening

Verified via IMAIL __VERBAL Date 5 ( 3 c b() I a All information piovided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that Inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made In support of this response may be used by the

512G9JiIX 11s a basis for rejection rescission or the award or termination or the contract and rllffl~Anampe as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 or the Broward CojlftYi 34~6ttlrbtflent Code Y

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

B0~~AARD ~~t~UNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

Fl ORIOA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Sunrise

Contact Name Luisa Fernanda Arbelaa Title Project Manager Reference date 05162018

Contact Email LArbelaezsunrlseflgov Contact Phone 954-888-6009

Name of Referenced Project City of Sunrise - Springtree WTP Water Stabilization and Solids Handling

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PA 16-003-CE 04072016 to 05292018 $ 50797800

Vendors role in Project ]Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [l]Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Carollo Engineers performed the design study and construction administration services for the City

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D G6 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Carollo Engineers technical knowledge and attenllon lo detall were beneficial lo the pltojad They ecled in lhe C~ys besl Interest In every aspect for lhe d1K8Uon of the projectbull

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via ~MAIL _VERBAL Verified by fc4J~~ Division W fl ED All lnrormalion provided to Broward ltAunty Is oobjoci to vorirtcotion Vendoc ecknowledgu that 1naowrate unlMhfuf 0lt lncocrecl statements rnado In support or this response may be useltI by lhe County as a basis for rejection rescission or the award 0lt termination ol the convect and may also ampOIVe as the babullibull ror debarmont of vondOlt purauont to Section 21119 or the Broward County Proc11oment Code

Bid Sync p 135 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BftQNARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

I l 0 R I 0 A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Florida Technical Consultants

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

VIiiage of Wellington Utilities

Contact Name Bradley Wolak Title Assistant Director Ut11Reference date 5182018

Contact Email bwolakwelllngtonflgov Contact Phone 561-753-2480

Name of Referenced Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 10012017 to Present 3500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vend~ 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again UZfYes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor J_ rJ fJ j(Gr-~k 6 Jti ov1 ~uf-Jiy fgt-r_- syrrzi~ff~ Al

R Q_ d--1 0~l 4 171 i+CI ~~lHI )Please rate your experience with tile Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Applicablereferenced Vendor Improvement

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy B D

DD c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D Db Professionalism D D

c Turnover D DD 3 Timeliness of

a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant(s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Additional Comments (provide on addltjpnal sheetJf needed) bull ~middot$ -JJ fo~~rltjbull lt( c-c_ ~~~ lt fo L1-lfAR- -middot~ I 10 ~ ~

~ bullL ~~ _te_ l~Ilgt~Cef t J ~ l rfbull4 middot r0 laquo r 4111J w f1 rrr- 0r- -i-HIS SECTION(9R COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by fcAJc ~ Division Y-1 IN ED Date 5 ~o w8 All lnfonn1Uon ptollfded to BlOward County le eubjeet to vetfflcatlon Vendor aclltnowledge1 that lneccurale unllJlhfUl or lnconect -bullmenla made In 1UPPort o1 this reopon90 may be uoec1 by the couniy ae a baalS ror re)ectlon re8Claeton Of the award 0t leltmlnatlon Of the contract and may 1l10 MM ae the baale flaquo debarrnont 01 vendor pu11uant to Section 21119 of ll1e Broward County Procurement Codo

BidSync p 18 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F LUFltIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultants LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Palm Beach Public Works

Contact Name Gerry Vazquez Title WRD Technician Reference date 05182018

Contact Email gvazqueztownofpalmbeachcom Contact Phone 772-546-6859

Name of Referenced Project GIS Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 3242014 to Present 13500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [3yenes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

PrwAamprs- favl49z Please rate your experience with the Need a Satlafactory Excellent Not

Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D g- D b Accuracy D Er D c Deliverables g-shyB D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D GJ D b Professionalism D D G- D c Tu mover D D cg- D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D g D b Deliverables D D Qshy D

4 Project completed within budget D D lbJ- D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D El- Db Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [3- D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

BidSync p 17 51232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

120-nWARDLll~ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form fLORllgtA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultant LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Waneya Bryant Title Meter Serv Mgr Reference date 05182018

Contact Email BryantWbbflus Contact Phone 561-742-6427

Name of Referenced Project Boynton Beach Utility GIS Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 12012016 to Present $15000000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

~T~ 5e-r-vtleamp +roM l)h f-es Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D Dc Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ti4 D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ Db Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on addlUonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION~urv USE ONLy u bull

Verified via VEMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by kuJ~ Division W if E D rao(ao8Date 5

All Information provided to Browslaquo COOlty Is Slbject to verfflcation Vendor acKnowledges that lneocurate Untruthful or lncolleel 8tatements made In support d this rfl9pOn98 may be used by 1119 Counly as a batia falt rejection relduion ct Ille award or lemilnlilon of the contract and may al80181Veaa1119 basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 ot Ille Broward CountyProcurement Code

512312018 BidSync p 16

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1

8W1V~isl1War Bid PNC21 15559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Fonn

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Cooper City - middot

Contact Name Michael Bailey PE itle Utilities DlrCity EbullReference date 05011201s

Contact Email MBalleycoopercityflorg Contact Phone (954) 434-5519

Name of Referenced Project City of Cooper City Continuing Professional Services bullContract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

RFQ 2009middot 1 04242009 to Present $ 2 19844200

Vendors role in Project IZJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Since 2009 Hazen has provided Cooper City with engineering services or water and wastewater projects Projects have lnctudeo lhe Pine Island Road Pump Station Lilt S1alions 2 amp 49 Improvements Master Plan Update of the FeaslJl~lty Review of Infrastructure Improvements tor Wastewater and the Eflluent Reuse and Disposal Master Plan

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy 8 D

D ~ D c Deliverables D 0 ~ D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D 0 D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tumover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D GJ- D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D 0 D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) ~D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

bull-rHIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY-

Verified vie EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ct4~ Division ~tUb Date ~ i3~) 0fgt All Information provided to BltCgtWW County 11 wbed ID vamprificalion Velldot adltnowledgu that lnaoewate unlrUhful lncom1ct statemampnla made in wppolt of 11111 response may blt uHd by the

4t2j=~ rejection rHclsslcn of th8 award or lennhallon of Ille eoo1nlct and may also seNamp at tilt basis for dtbarmenl at Vendor puuan1 lo Sectioo 21119 of the Broward COltJi 43

5232018 Bid Sync p24

Broward County Board of PNC211 5559P1

~RiiirilyenlcHUffi~~8CrW~r Bid PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

8DdMARD _ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FL O RIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Fort Lauderdale

Contact Name Rares Patrica PE Title Senior Project Mgr Reference date os1021201s

Contact Email RPetricafortlauderdalegov Contact Phone 9548287150

Name of Referenced Project Stormwater Master Planning and Design Implementation Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

256-11660 04192016 to 04192021 $ 989400000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

vyould you use this vendor again Sves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor The Hazen team Is responsible for delivery of a new stormwaler master plan model a prlorlllzed slormwaterresllency capital Improvements plan and Implementation of designs to address chronic flooding and other slormwater management challenges In the City Primary work tasks Include data collectlon hydrologlclhydraullc modeling and design permitting and construction services for capllal Improvement projects resulting from the revised stormwater master plan (preltmlnary design In seven priority neighborhoods)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION ~R COUNTY USE ONLY

aJ~Verified via pound MA IL _VERBAL Verified by Division W1~tl Date 5 ~3o~ax l S N I informallon p roviltled lo Broward County is sulljecl lo verification Vendor altknowledjj6s lhal inaccurate unlMhlut or lncotreci statements m ade In support of this respon$e may be used by tho

412~-~ rejeclion rescission of the award or termination ol lhe contracl and may also serve as lhe basis for debalment ol Vendor purwant to Section 21119 ol lhe Broward Cou~ 4 3

5232018 Bid Sync p25

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 Br~~~~~rs Bid PNC2115559P1 County t ommissioners

B~uWARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FlOR I CA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

Solicitation PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and s OrganizationFirm Name p

Town of Jupiter

nee

Contact Email davidbjupiterflus Contact Phone (561) 746-5134

Name of Referenced Project Engineering Services for Stormwater and Water Capital Improvements

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount $ 630000000 W17248 (2017 reselection 1012000 to Present (estimated lee-to-date since contract inception) contract number)

Vendors role in Project IZI Prime Vendor osubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again 0Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Descriotion of services orovided bv Vendor Since 2000 Hazen has served as General Consulfant to the Town or Jupiter As General Stormwater and Water Consullant the firm has provided services related to master planning stormwater planning and modeling design NPDES permilling asset management resiliency ratefinancial analysis plan review and construction oversight Water-related capital projs have involved additional system storage and high-service pumping transmission system improvements and RampR at existing facilities

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Verllied via EMAIL _ VERBAL Division WWC D

fo (J-Vv ~ltIvmiddotj Date 5(30(ipf S

Al lnroimallon pngtYICGd 10 Broward Counly Is sub)oel to v8flrcallon vendlaquo acknowledges lhat Inaccurate unlruthlu~ 0t Jnwrrect slatoments made In support ol this response may be used by the 42~~1~0 rojecllon rescission or Ille award or termination or lhe con~acl bullnd mbully also serve as tho basis r0t debarment of Vendor pursuant lo Socllon 21119 of lho Broward Couw 41

5232018 BidSync p 26

a N ~ IL) IL) N u z a_

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLO RI DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Walter Wernecke RA Title Sr Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email WWERNECKEhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Hollywood Marina Restrooms

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

04152015 to Present 7500000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor OSubconsultanVSubcontractor n ~U t1

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

-0 Vgt Description of services provided by VendorO ~ ~ Q) Structural Design and Construction Inspection Services i co Q m ~- c E c0

i E gt Oo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not () uu Appllcable O

E~ referenced Vendor Improvement iii ~sectoO 1 Vendors Quality of Service B mu a Responsive D D

b Accuracy DD c Deliverables D DD

2 Vendors Organization D Da Staff expertise v D b Professionalism~ D D c Turnover D ~D

3 Timeliness of D a Project b Deliverables D ~

4 Pec~~11~$~hinJ~~qt lfr D D 5 Cooperation with f ~

a Your Firm D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D

Al lnfonn1tion pRgttded IO Brwd Cltgtunly lo 1ubjecl IO ibllon vsor ~middot Iha icl-bullmiddot ~ ir-ect slalemenls mode In _ol lhb _ moy ti used by he County as a basis lot rejecUon rnclnlon cl the eward or tonnlnallan of lhl connct 1nd may bullllo 11 the basis for dobalment of Vendor IQtulnl IO SICllOn 21119 at lhe Broword County Procurement Code

Cl ltraquo I() I() I() N ()

Cl z

BRltJWARD ~ middot COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORl OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Davie

Contact Name Emilio DeSimone Title Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email Emilio_DeSimonedavie-fl gov Contact Phone 954-797-1085

Name of Referenced Project Pavillion 5 Linear Park

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

B-17-123 09152015 to 2700000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor O SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es O No If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

0 Description of services provided by Vendor O Q)

iii c Structural Design and Construction Inspection ServicesoQ

CDi-

0cc E gt=gt E ()Oo O () () Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

ii) -e i- Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 111 cs

B ioO

J 1 Vendors Quality of Service Q ()

a Responsive D D b Accuracy D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization []Ll Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D Dtr

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [g D b Deliverables D D ar D

4 Project completed within budget [1tD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) cgD D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via l EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by ~h~ Division WlI Etgt Date 0 f l~o I 8 All lnformaUon provided lO Broward County Is eubJect 10 verifutlon Vendor ecknOMedgoo that lnaocurote unNlhlul or Incorrect statamenle made In aupl)Ort of this reaponse may be used by lho County et o baampla for rejection realtluion of the award or lermlnallon of tho eon1fllcl ond moy olao aorvo os ho basis for debarmont of Vondor purauenl lo Section 21119 of the Broward Counly Procuremen1 Code

0 0 agt a c () z 0

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Terrence Comiskey AIA Title Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email TCOMISKEYhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Van Buren Parking Garage

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PK 14-053 Nov 2014 to Present 8310000

Vendors role in Project t8(Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

o~ Description of services provided by Vendor 1 Q)ltO c Structural Design and Conslructlon Inspection Services 0 Q

0~Jl ccE l E enOo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

gtshy

uu O Improvement Applicable ffireferenced Vendor

~sect 1 Vendors Quality of Service 1 ~

oOau a Responsive D ~ D b Accuracy B D D

D D [- Dc Deliverables

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tum over D D D g

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ D Subcontractor(s )S ubcons u ltant( s)b D D ~ D

c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D yenj D Additional Comments provide on sdditlonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION ~NTY USE ONLY0

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by kW Division W-1-(i~ Date EJo(a~t8 Al lnform1Uon PltOVlded lo Browald Ccxnty It IUbjoct to vorificallon Vendor eoknowfodgea thal lnaewralt U111MhlJI deg inlaquogtlaquobullel amptal11ants made In eupporl of lhls relj)Onse may be used by Iha Counly es a balls l0t rcfecllon rescfuloltI of tho ew1rd or 1ermtnaU0lt1 ol lhbull conllllCI and may elao urve 11 lho basis for dabarmenl of Vondor pursuanl lo Secllon 21 119 of he erowald COUlly CiProcurement Code

~ N ii

00

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 aOWllrp Commficumlref Bid PNC2116615B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Pompano Beach FL

Contact Name Mr A Randolph Brown Title Utilities Director Reference date April 30 2018

Contact Email randolphbrowncopbflcom Contact Phone 954-545-7043

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 201 o Project Amount fees varied

Multiple

Vendors role in Project IKJ Prime Vendor

to 2018

osubconsultanUSubcontractor

(range $10000shy$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D ~ D D c Deliverables D ~ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D ~ D D b Professionalism D D ~ D C Turnover D El DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ 0 b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D [BJ D n c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [XJ o ~

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed) amp~~it -THIS SECTION ~COUNTY USE ONL y-bullbull

Verified via ~AIL __VERBAL Verified by 1lt4 )~ Division N WE O Date 5 faol Z1 18

All lnformotlon providod to BltownrltI Cou nty it aubjoct O verification VendOr acknowledges that lnaccornto untruthful or incorroct 11atomon1s made in support of this response may be used by tho

411p~~)~~J rojoclion roscissioo ol lho award or 1orroinalion of tho contract and roay also s01vo as lhbull basis f0lt d~arroont of VondOf pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward Cou)l1

Bid Sync p 73

40

5232018

Broward County Board of Bid PNC2116659B 1 County Commissioners

B~aWARD gt1- t COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Loxahatchee River Environmental Control District

Contact Name Mr Kris Dean Title Director of Engineering Reference date May 9 2018

Contact Email krisdeanloxahatcheeriverorg Contact Phone 561-747-5700

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 2001 Project Amount fees varied (range $10000shyMultiple to 2018 $250000)

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IR)Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D ~ D D b Accuracy D 0 D D c Deliverables D IBJ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D IB] D D b Professionalism D ~ D D c Turnover D [8J D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D [8J D D b Deliverables D m D D

4 Project completed within budget D ~ D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D ~ D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D Ii] D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D ~ D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SE~ FOR~USE ONLY

Verified via _lEMAIL __VERBAL Verified by ~lt Division fWeb Date I

All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untrulhful or incorrecl slatements made In support of this response may be used by the lJl~~~l~~jSfiir rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and mll~~~ere as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Co)f 10

Broward County Board of Bid PNC21166$9B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A l

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Lake Worth FL

Contact Name Mr Felipe Lofaso TitleAsst Dir Public-ServicesReference date May 9 2018

Contact Email flofasolakeworthorg Contact Phone 561-586-1720

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contract

Contract No Date Services Provided 2014 Project Amount fees varied Multiple to 2018 (range $10000shy

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Services included multiple municipal engineering projects including survey roadway design utility design and coordination (water wastewater stormwater other) along with project management

Needs Satisfactory Excellent NotPlease rate your experience with the Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D GJ D b Accuracy D D Ii] D c Deliverables D Ii] DD

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [i] D c Turnover D D D [X]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D 0 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [X] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION Fe COUNTY USE ONLrbullbull

Verified via MAIL __VERBAL Verified by Division ~wgtgt Date 5~3ol20t8 All information provided to Broward County Is subject lo verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect slalements made in support ol this response may be used by the

OZ~id~~~~j~r rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and m~~~(iirve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Cour~ iG

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - ARCADIS US INC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts

VS0000013130 VS00013130 - ARCADIS US INC Prime Work Auth Vendor SummaryProjects

PURCHASING 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold Procurement No Fixed Contracts FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Favorites Past 5 Years Prime Vendor

Sub Vendor From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 10042017 Purchase Order

Evaluation Purchase Orders 1 POs With A Total Amt Of $20000000 Log Off Paid To Dt ($12132949) Balance $7867051

Contracts Purchase Orders Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx 6192018

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Finish

PURCHASING Weighted Scores Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract FileRoom DashBoard Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number FileRoom Insert

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel Favorites Prime Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Service Evaluation

6132017 YES 486 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Goals Compliance Evaluation

10272016 YES 460 View Docs (0)

6272018

Project Management Information System

Close

Contracts Central Administration

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9130 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-24

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6182018 YES 355 View Docs (1)

Proj Nbr 9320 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-20

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6132018 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9290 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-23

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1122018 YES 494 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-21

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12182017 YES 488 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10162017 YES 473 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

8252017 YES 495 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9321 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-19

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

7112017 YES 476 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-17

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2272017 YES 400 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

10132016 YES 384 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-12

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

5202016 YES 405 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9018 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-06

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10192015 YES 448 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

3202015 YES 385 View Docs (0)

Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL CONSULTANTS

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Project Management Information System

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-04

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12122014 YES 437 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-08

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1242014 YES 423 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-02

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2282014 YES 452 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC

VC0000044184 VC00044184 - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres PS $001 Used $000 Remain $001 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $354848400 Closed 0 Total $000 Total Current Retainage Balance For All Contracts $793370 No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 06292015 Purchase Orders 2 POs With A Total Amt Of $362317900 Paid To Dt ($218795160) Balance $143522740

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 40803 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9058 - DISTRICT 3A POTABLE WATER STORAGE

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1220410P1 - Consultant Engineering Services for Potable Water FixedOpen Contracts Storage Tanks and Pumping Systems Work Auth Prime Vendor CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Periodic Final Finish

Log Off Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type

Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

6232015 8302017 413 Approved 8312017 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard

Enter Vendor Name (or a portion of) Then Click Search - Wilcards Are Permitted (ie wa wawainc) Florida Technical Consultants

Search Reset Finish

No Vendors Found For Your Search Try Again

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41005 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score Go

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0773

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

12122017 YES 430 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

8302016 YES 438 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Final Consultant Evaluation 3142016 YES 478 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0706

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

142016 YES 402 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9016OES - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0731

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

10192015 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0748

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

612015 YES 467 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

2192015 YES 500 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0754

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

252015 YES 409 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0755

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

1242014 YES 415 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8974 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0758

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

6202014 YES 393 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr

WATER amp WASTEWATER

Final Consultant Work Authorization 572014 YES 423 View Docs

(0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

HS0746 ENGINEERING Evaluation

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

4302014 YES 475 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Evaluation 4302014 YES 493 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0710

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

3172014 YES 395 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0753

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

1212014 YES 380 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0763

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

11192013 YES 450 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0775

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 408 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals

Finish

Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed FileRoom DashBoard Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization FileRoom Insert NumberFavorites

Prime Vendor Export To Excel Sub Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0772

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 417 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0771

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

2262013 YES 410 View Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 19: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

BROWARD t (l)t~ 1 Vendor Reference Verification Form

fl O R I OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Brown and Caldwell

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of West Palm Beach Florida

Contact Name Jay Kwag Title Project Manager Reference date

Contact Email hjkwagwpborg Contact Phone 561 494 1041

Name of Referenced Project Modeling and Infrastructure General Engineering Consulting Assigments

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

11032014 to HAlt zc1e (on~vi~)

Vendors role in Project 52fPrime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IQves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Planning and General Eng1neerg Servicus 1nctuslve ol Waterwastewater System Master Pian asset management program dovo10pmenV11sset Crt1tcat1ty assessment Mesler PS 115 and sewer cond1hon assessment hydrauhc modeling ol LS 5 and force main sizing water system Capacity Analysis RoPort nydraullc modeling ol operahonat challongos tilt ste11on enatysbulls lac11i1a1e 1nspec11011 or major FM and new develOpmenl 1mpnc1s plpohno design lilt station condbullhon assessment and renabtlilahon (Various ProJecls)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D 0 D b Accuracy D 0D D c Deliverables D D 0 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D Gt D b Professionalism D D ~-- D c Turnover D D Gr D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D B D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget D D r~r D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D c~r D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D 0 D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION F~USE ONLY

__VERBAL Verified via LMAIL Verified by ~J Division ~~~D Date ~ f 2 f~t8 All lnfo11na1t0n pr ()Vl(fed 10 Broward County is svb1et110 ven11ca1ion vendor acknowledges lhll 1naeoura10 unlrulhful 0lt inc0ltrec1 s1a1emen1s medo In support ol 1n1s response may be used Dy the County as a basis fcu rejection re sclsst0n Of 1ho award or 1ormina1lon of l he contract and may also servo as the basis for debarment o f Vendor pursuant lo Section 21 119 of tho ampoward Counly P1ocuremont Code

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A middot

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Michael Low Title Deputy Director Reference date 05172018

Contact Email lowmbbflus Contact Phone 5617426403

Name of Referenced Project Ion Exchange Design Build

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

07022014 to 03212018 $ 100000000

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Carollo handled all of the design and construction of a significant part of the project as a subcontractor to COM Constructors as part of a progressive design build contract

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [Z] D b Accuracy D D [Z] D c Deliverables D D [Z] D

2 Vendors Organization D D [Z] Da Staff expertise b Professionalism D D [Z] D c Turnover D D D [Z]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D [Z] D

4 Project completed within budget D D [Z] D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D [Z] D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [Z] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION F~ COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ~~ Division W -NED Date S-gtozot~ All Information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor aclltnowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

Stii191111X 11s a basis for rejection rescission of the award or termination or the conlact and m~~Arifrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward CounYJ 33Plamptl1til1ent Code Y Imiddot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

B~OWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LORID A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

South Florida Water Management District

Contact Name Greg Coffelt PE Title SFWMD Project Manager Reference date 05172018

Contact Email gcoffeltsfwmdgov Contact Phone 561-682-6853

Name of Referenced Project L-8 Reservoir Inflow Structure and Pump Station

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

4600000861 02152011 to 09192012 $ 144535100

Vendors role in Project [l) Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [l)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Corolla was contracted as an Owners Advisor for a Design-Build contract developed engineering design criteria assisted in RFQ development and evaluation supported RFP technical proposal and cost proposal analysis

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [l] D b Accuracy D [] D D c Deliverables D [] D D

2 Vendors Organization [l]a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D [l] D c Turnover D D D [l]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [l] D b Deliverables D [l] D D

4 Project completed within budget [l] DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [l] D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) [l] DD D c Regu latory Agency(ies) D D D [l]

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Owner Advisor work continued(s) in support of Construction of Pump Station Inflow Gate Structure and levee hardening

Verified via IMAIL __VERBAL Date 5 ( 3 c b() I a All information piovided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that Inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made In support of this response may be used by the

512G9JiIX 11s a basis for rejection rescission or the award or termination or the contract and rllffl~Anampe as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 or the Broward CojlftYi 34~6ttlrbtflent Code Y

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

B0~~AARD ~~t~UNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

Fl ORIOA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Sunrise

Contact Name Luisa Fernanda Arbelaa Title Project Manager Reference date 05162018

Contact Email LArbelaezsunrlseflgov Contact Phone 954-888-6009

Name of Referenced Project City of Sunrise - Springtree WTP Water Stabilization and Solids Handling

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PA 16-003-CE 04072016 to 05292018 $ 50797800

Vendors role in Project ]Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [l]Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Carollo Engineers performed the design study and construction administration services for the City

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D G6 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Carollo Engineers technical knowledge and attenllon lo detall were beneficial lo the pltojad They ecled in lhe C~ys besl Interest In every aspect for lhe d1K8Uon of the projectbull

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via ~MAIL _VERBAL Verified by fc4J~~ Division W fl ED All lnrormalion provided to Broward ltAunty Is oobjoci to vorirtcotion Vendoc ecknowledgu that 1naowrate unlMhfuf 0lt lncocrecl statements rnado In support or this response may be useltI by lhe County as a basis for rejection rescission or the award 0lt termination ol the convect and may also ampOIVe as the babullibull ror debarmont of vondOlt purauont to Section 21119 or the Broward County Proc11oment Code

Bid Sync p 135 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BftQNARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

I l 0 R I 0 A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Florida Technical Consultants

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

VIiiage of Wellington Utilities

Contact Name Bradley Wolak Title Assistant Director Ut11Reference date 5182018

Contact Email bwolakwelllngtonflgov Contact Phone 561-753-2480

Name of Referenced Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 10012017 to Present 3500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vend~ 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again UZfYes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor J_ rJ fJ j(Gr-~k 6 Jti ov1 ~uf-Jiy fgt-r_- syrrzi~ff~ Al

R Q_ d--1 0~l 4 171 i+CI ~~lHI )Please rate your experience with tile Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Applicablereferenced Vendor Improvement

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy B D

DD c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D Db Professionalism D D

c Turnover D DD 3 Timeliness of

a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant(s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Additional Comments (provide on addltjpnal sheetJf needed) bull ~middot$ -JJ fo~~rltjbull lt( c-c_ ~~~ lt fo L1-lfAR- -middot~ I 10 ~ ~

~ bullL ~~ _te_ l~Ilgt~Cef t J ~ l rfbull4 middot r0 laquo r 4111J w f1 rrr- 0r- -i-HIS SECTION(9R COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by fcAJc ~ Division Y-1 IN ED Date 5 ~o w8 All lnfonn1Uon ptollfded to BlOward County le eubjeet to vetfflcatlon Vendor aclltnowledge1 that lneccurale unllJlhfUl or lnconect -bullmenla made In 1UPPort o1 this reopon90 may be uoec1 by the couniy ae a baalS ror re)ectlon re8Claeton Of the award 0t leltmlnatlon Of the contract and may 1l10 MM ae the baale flaquo debarrnont 01 vendor pu11uant to Section 21119 of ll1e Broward County Procurement Codo

BidSync p 18 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F LUFltIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultants LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Palm Beach Public Works

Contact Name Gerry Vazquez Title WRD Technician Reference date 05182018

Contact Email gvazqueztownofpalmbeachcom Contact Phone 772-546-6859

Name of Referenced Project GIS Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 3242014 to Present 13500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [3yenes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

PrwAamprs- favl49z Please rate your experience with the Need a Satlafactory Excellent Not

Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D g- D b Accuracy D Er D c Deliverables g-shyB D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D GJ D b Professionalism D D G- D c Tu mover D D cg- D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D g D b Deliverables D D Qshy D

4 Project completed within budget D D lbJ- D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D El- Db Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [3- D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

BidSync p 17 51232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

120-nWARDLll~ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form fLORllgtA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultant LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Waneya Bryant Title Meter Serv Mgr Reference date 05182018

Contact Email BryantWbbflus Contact Phone 561-742-6427

Name of Referenced Project Boynton Beach Utility GIS Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 12012016 to Present $15000000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

~T~ 5e-r-vtleamp +roM l)h f-es Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D Dc Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ti4 D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ Db Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on addlUonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION~urv USE ONLy u bull

Verified via VEMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by kuJ~ Division W if E D rao(ao8Date 5

All Information provided to Browslaquo COOlty Is Slbject to verfflcation Vendor acKnowledges that lneocurate Untruthful or lncolleel 8tatements made In support d this rfl9pOn98 may be used by 1119 Counly as a batia falt rejection relduion ct Ille award or lemilnlilon of the contract and may al80181Veaa1119 basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 ot Ille Broward CountyProcurement Code

512312018 BidSync p 16

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1

8W1V~isl1War Bid PNC21 15559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Fonn

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Cooper City - middot

Contact Name Michael Bailey PE itle Utilities DlrCity EbullReference date 05011201s

Contact Email MBalleycoopercityflorg Contact Phone (954) 434-5519

Name of Referenced Project City of Cooper City Continuing Professional Services bullContract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

RFQ 2009middot 1 04242009 to Present $ 2 19844200

Vendors role in Project IZJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Since 2009 Hazen has provided Cooper City with engineering services or water and wastewater projects Projects have lnctudeo lhe Pine Island Road Pump Station Lilt S1alions 2 amp 49 Improvements Master Plan Update of the FeaslJl~lty Review of Infrastructure Improvements tor Wastewater and the Eflluent Reuse and Disposal Master Plan

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy 8 D

D ~ D c Deliverables D 0 ~ D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D 0 D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tumover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D GJ- D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D 0 D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) ~D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

bull-rHIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY-

Verified vie EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ct4~ Division ~tUb Date ~ i3~) 0fgt All Information provided to BltCgtWW County 11 wbed ID vamprificalion Velldot adltnowledgu that lnaoewate unlrUhful lncom1ct statemampnla made in wppolt of 11111 response may blt uHd by the

4t2j=~ rejection rHclsslcn of th8 award or lennhallon of Ille eoo1nlct and may also seNamp at tilt basis for dtbarmenl at Vendor puuan1 lo Sectioo 21119 of the Broward COltJi 43

5232018 Bid Sync p24

Broward County Board of PNC211 5559P1

~RiiirilyenlcHUffi~~8CrW~r Bid PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

8DdMARD _ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FL O RIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Fort Lauderdale

Contact Name Rares Patrica PE Title Senior Project Mgr Reference date os1021201s

Contact Email RPetricafortlauderdalegov Contact Phone 9548287150

Name of Referenced Project Stormwater Master Planning and Design Implementation Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

256-11660 04192016 to 04192021 $ 989400000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

vyould you use this vendor again Sves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor The Hazen team Is responsible for delivery of a new stormwaler master plan model a prlorlllzed slormwaterresllency capital Improvements plan and Implementation of designs to address chronic flooding and other slormwater management challenges In the City Primary work tasks Include data collectlon hydrologlclhydraullc modeling and design permitting and construction services for capllal Improvement projects resulting from the revised stormwater master plan (preltmlnary design In seven priority neighborhoods)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION ~R COUNTY USE ONLY

aJ~Verified via pound MA IL _VERBAL Verified by Division W1~tl Date 5 ~3o~ax l S N I informallon p roviltled lo Broward County is sulljecl lo verification Vendor altknowledjj6s lhal inaccurate unlMhlut or lncotreci statements m ade In support of this respon$e may be used by tho

412~-~ rejeclion rescission of the award or termination ol lhe contracl and may also serve as lhe basis for debalment ol Vendor purwant to Section 21119 ol lhe Broward Cou~ 4 3

5232018 Bid Sync p25

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 Br~~~~~rs Bid PNC2115559P1 County t ommissioners

B~uWARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FlOR I CA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

Solicitation PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and s OrganizationFirm Name p

Town of Jupiter

nee

Contact Email davidbjupiterflus Contact Phone (561) 746-5134

Name of Referenced Project Engineering Services for Stormwater and Water Capital Improvements

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount $ 630000000 W17248 (2017 reselection 1012000 to Present (estimated lee-to-date since contract inception) contract number)

Vendors role in Project IZI Prime Vendor osubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again 0Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Descriotion of services orovided bv Vendor Since 2000 Hazen has served as General Consulfant to the Town or Jupiter As General Stormwater and Water Consullant the firm has provided services related to master planning stormwater planning and modeling design NPDES permilling asset management resiliency ratefinancial analysis plan review and construction oversight Water-related capital projs have involved additional system storage and high-service pumping transmission system improvements and RampR at existing facilities

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Verllied via EMAIL _ VERBAL Division WWC D

fo (J-Vv ~ltIvmiddotj Date 5(30(ipf S

Al lnroimallon pngtYICGd 10 Broward Counly Is sub)oel to v8flrcallon vendlaquo acknowledges lhat Inaccurate unlruthlu~ 0t Jnwrrect slatoments made In support ol this response may be used by the 42~~1~0 rojecllon rescission or Ille award or termination or lhe con~acl bullnd mbully also serve as tho basis r0t debarment of Vendor pursuant lo Socllon 21119 of lho Broward Couw 41

5232018 BidSync p 26

a N ~ IL) IL) N u z a_

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLO RI DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Walter Wernecke RA Title Sr Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email WWERNECKEhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Hollywood Marina Restrooms

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

04152015 to Present 7500000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor OSubconsultanVSubcontractor n ~U t1

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

-0 Vgt Description of services provided by VendorO ~ ~ Q) Structural Design and Construction Inspection Services i co Q m ~- c E c0

i E gt Oo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not () uu Appllcable O

E~ referenced Vendor Improvement iii ~sectoO 1 Vendors Quality of Service B mu a Responsive D D

b Accuracy DD c Deliverables D DD

2 Vendors Organization D Da Staff expertise v D b Professionalism~ D D c Turnover D ~D

3 Timeliness of D a Project b Deliverables D ~

4 Pec~~11~$~hinJ~~qt lfr D D 5 Cooperation with f ~

a Your Firm D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D

Al lnfonn1tion pRgttded IO Brwd Cltgtunly lo 1ubjecl IO ibllon vsor ~middot Iha icl-bullmiddot ~ ir-ect slalemenls mode In _ol lhb _ moy ti used by he County as a basis lot rejecUon rnclnlon cl the eward or tonnlnallan of lhl connct 1nd may bullllo 11 the basis for dobalment of Vendor IQtulnl IO SICllOn 21119 at lhe Broword County Procurement Code

Cl ltraquo I() I() I() N ()

Cl z

BRltJWARD ~ middot COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORl OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Davie

Contact Name Emilio DeSimone Title Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email Emilio_DeSimonedavie-fl gov Contact Phone 954-797-1085

Name of Referenced Project Pavillion 5 Linear Park

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

B-17-123 09152015 to 2700000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor O SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es O No If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

0 Description of services provided by Vendor O Q)

iii c Structural Design and Construction Inspection ServicesoQ

CDi-

0cc E gt=gt E ()Oo O () () Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

ii) -e i- Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 111 cs

B ioO

J 1 Vendors Quality of Service Q ()

a Responsive D D b Accuracy D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization []Ll Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D Dtr

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [g D b Deliverables D D ar D

4 Project completed within budget [1tD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) cgD D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via l EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by ~h~ Division WlI Etgt Date 0 f l~o I 8 All lnformaUon provided lO Broward County Is eubJect 10 verifutlon Vendor ecknOMedgoo that lnaocurote unNlhlul or Incorrect statamenle made In aupl)Ort of this reaponse may be used by lho County et o baampla for rejection realtluion of the award or lermlnallon of tho eon1fllcl ond moy olao aorvo os ho basis for debarmont of Vondor purauenl lo Section 21119 of the Broward Counly Procuremen1 Code

0 0 agt a c () z 0

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Terrence Comiskey AIA Title Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email TCOMISKEYhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Van Buren Parking Garage

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PK 14-053 Nov 2014 to Present 8310000

Vendors role in Project t8(Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

o~ Description of services provided by Vendor 1 Q)ltO c Structural Design and Conslructlon Inspection Services 0 Q

0~Jl ccE l E enOo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

gtshy

uu O Improvement Applicable ffireferenced Vendor

~sect 1 Vendors Quality of Service 1 ~

oOau a Responsive D ~ D b Accuracy B D D

D D [- Dc Deliverables

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tum over D D D g

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ D Subcontractor(s )S ubcons u ltant( s)b D D ~ D

c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D yenj D Additional Comments provide on sdditlonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION ~NTY USE ONLY0

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by kW Division W-1-(i~ Date EJo(a~t8 Al lnform1Uon PltOVlded lo Browald Ccxnty It IUbjoct to vorificallon Vendor eoknowfodgea thal lnaewralt U111MhlJI deg inlaquogtlaquobullel amptal11ants made In eupporl of lhls relj)Onse may be used by Iha Counly es a balls l0t rcfecllon rescfuloltI of tho ew1rd or 1ermtnaU0lt1 ol lhbull conllllCI and may elao urve 11 lho basis for dabarmenl of Vondor pursuanl lo Secllon 21 119 of he erowald COUlly CiProcurement Code

~ N ii

00

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 aOWllrp Commficumlref Bid PNC2116615B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Pompano Beach FL

Contact Name Mr A Randolph Brown Title Utilities Director Reference date April 30 2018

Contact Email randolphbrowncopbflcom Contact Phone 954-545-7043

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 201 o Project Amount fees varied

Multiple

Vendors role in Project IKJ Prime Vendor

to 2018

osubconsultanUSubcontractor

(range $10000shy$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D ~ D D c Deliverables D ~ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D ~ D D b Professionalism D D ~ D C Turnover D El DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ 0 b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D [BJ D n c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [XJ o ~

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed) amp~~it -THIS SECTION ~COUNTY USE ONL y-bullbull

Verified via ~AIL __VERBAL Verified by 1lt4 )~ Division N WE O Date 5 faol Z1 18

All lnformotlon providod to BltownrltI Cou nty it aubjoct O verification VendOr acknowledges that lnaccornto untruthful or incorroct 11atomon1s made in support of this response may be used by tho

411p~~)~~J rojoclion roscissioo ol lho award or 1orroinalion of tho contract and roay also s01vo as lhbull basis f0lt d~arroont of VondOf pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward Cou)l1

Bid Sync p 73

40

5232018

Broward County Board of Bid PNC2116659B 1 County Commissioners

B~aWARD gt1- t COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Loxahatchee River Environmental Control District

Contact Name Mr Kris Dean Title Director of Engineering Reference date May 9 2018

Contact Email krisdeanloxahatcheeriverorg Contact Phone 561-747-5700

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 2001 Project Amount fees varied (range $10000shyMultiple to 2018 $250000)

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IR)Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D ~ D D b Accuracy D 0 D D c Deliverables D IBJ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D IB] D D b Professionalism D ~ D D c Turnover D [8J D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D [8J D D b Deliverables D m D D

4 Project completed within budget D ~ D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D ~ D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D Ii] D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D ~ D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SE~ FOR~USE ONLY

Verified via _lEMAIL __VERBAL Verified by ~lt Division fWeb Date I

All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untrulhful or incorrecl slatements made In support of this response may be used by the lJl~~~l~~jSfiir rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and mll~~~ere as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Co)f 10

Broward County Board of Bid PNC21166$9B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A l

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Lake Worth FL

Contact Name Mr Felipe Lofaso TitleAsst Dir Public-ServicesReference date May 9 2018

Contact Email flofasolakeworthorg Contact Phone 561-586-1720

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contract

Contract No Date Services Provided 2014 Project Amount fees varied Multiple to 2018 (range $10000shy

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Services included multiple municipal engineering projects including survey roadway design utility design and coordination (water wastewater stormwater other) along with project management

Needs Satisfactory Excellent NotPlease rate your experience with the Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D GJ D b Accuracy D D Ii] D c Deliverables D Ii] DD

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [i] D c Turnover D D D [X]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D 0 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [X] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION Fe COUNTY USE ONLrbullbull

Verified via MAIL __VERBAL Verified by Division ~wgtgt Date 5~3ol20t8 All information provided to Broward County Is subject lo verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect slalements made in support ol this response may be used by the

OZ~id~~~~j~r rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and m~~~(iirve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Cour~ iG

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - ARCADIS US INC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts

VS0000013130 VS00013130 - ARCADIS US INC Prime Work Auth Vendor SummaryProjects

PURCHASING 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold Procurement No Fixed Contracts FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Favorites Past 5 Years Prime Vendor

Sub Vendor From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 10042017 Purchase Order

Evaluation Purchase Orders 1 POs With A Total Amt Of $20000000 Log Off Paid To Dt ($12132949) Balance $7867051

Contracts Purchase Orders Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx 6192018

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Finish

PURCHASING Weighted Scores Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract FileRoom DashBoard Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number FileRoom Insert

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel Favorites Prime Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Service Evaluation

6132017 YES 486 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Goals Compliance Evaluation

10272016 YES 460 View Docs (0)

6272018

Project Management Information System

Close

Contracts Central Administration

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9130 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-24

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6182018 YES 355 View Docs (1)

Proj Nbr 9320 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-20

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6132018 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9290 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-23

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1122018 YES 494 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-21

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12182017 YES 488 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10162017 YES 473 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

8252017 YES 495 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9321 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-19

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

7112017 YES 476 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-17

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2272017 YES 400 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

10132016 YES 384 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-12

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

5202016 YES 405 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9018 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-06

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10192015 YES 448 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

3202015 YES 385 View Docs (0)

Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL CONSULTANTS

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Project Management Information System

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-04

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12122014 YES 437 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-08

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1242014 YES 423 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-02

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2282014 YES 452 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC

VC0000044184 VC00044184 - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres PS $001 Used $000 Remain $001 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $354848400 Closed 0 Total $000 Total Current Retainage Balance For All Contracts $793370 No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 06292015 Purchase Orders 2 POs With A Total Amt Of $362317900 Paid To Dt ($218795160) Balance $143522740

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 40803 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9058 - DISTRICT 3A POTABLE WATER STORAGE

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1220410P1 - Consultant Engineering Services for Potable Water FixedOpen Contracts Storage Tanks and Pumping Systems Work Auth Prime Vendor CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Periodic Final Finish

Log Off Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type

Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

6232015 8302017 413 Approved 8312017 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard

Enter Vendor Name (or a portion of) Then Click Search - Wilcards Are Permitted (ie wa wawainc) Florida Technical Consultants

Search Reset Finish

No Vendors Found For Your Search Try Again

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41005 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score Go

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0773

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

12122017 YES 430 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

8302016 YES 438 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Final Consultant Evaluation 3142016 YES 478 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0706

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

142016 YES 402 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9016OES - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0731

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

10192015 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0748

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

612015 YES 467 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

2192015 YES 500 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0754

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

252015 YES 409 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0755

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

1242014 YES 415 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8974 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0758

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

6202014 YES 393 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr

WATER amp WASTEWATER

Final Consultant Work Authorization 572014 YES 423 View Docs

(0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

HS0746 ENGINEERING Evaluation

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

4302014 YES 475 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Evaluation 4302014 YES 493 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0710

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

3172014 YES 395 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0753

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

1212014 YES 380 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0763

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

11192013 YES 450 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0775

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 408 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals

Finish

Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed FileRoom DashBoard Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization FileRoom Insert NumberFavorites

Prime Vendor Export To Excel Sub Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0772

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 417 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0771

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

2262013 YES 410 View Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 20: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A middot

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Michael Low Title Deputy Director Reference date 05172018

Contact Email lowmbbflus Contact Phone 5617426403

Name of Referenced Project Ion Exchange Design Build

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

07022014 to 03212018 $ 100000000

Vendors role in Project D Prime Vendor [Z]SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [Z]Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Carollo handled all of the design and construction of a significant part of the project as a subcontractor to COM Constructors as part of a progressive design build contract

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [Z] D b Accuracy D D [Z] D c Deliverables D D [Z] D

2 Vendors Organization D D [Z] Da Staff expertise b Professionalism D D [Z] D c Turnover D D D [Z]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [Z] D b Deliverables D D [Z] D

4 Project completed within budget D D [Z] D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [Z] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D [Z] D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [Z] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION F~ COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ~~ Division W -NED Date S-gtozot~ All Information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor aclltnowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made in support of this response may be used by the

Stii191111X 11s a basis for rejection rescission of the award or termination or the conlact and m~~Arifrve as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward CounYJ 33Plamptl1til1ent Code Y Imiddot

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

B~OWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LORID A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

South Florida Water Management District

Contact Name Greg Coffelt PE Title SFWMD Project Manager Reference date 05172018

Contact Email gcoffeltsfwmdgov Contact Phone 561-682-6853

Name of Referenced Project L-8 Reservoir Inflow Structure and Pump Station

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

4600000861 02152011 to 09192012 $ 144535100

Vendors role in Project [l) Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [l)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Corolla was contracted as an Owners Advisor for a Design-Build contract developed engineering design criteria assisted in RFQ development and evaluation supported RFP technical proposal and cost proposal analysis

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [l] D b Accuracy D [] D D c Deliverables D [] D D

2 Vendors Organization [l]a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D [l] D c Turnover D D D [l]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [l] D b Deliverables D [l] D D

4 Project completed within budget [l] DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [l] D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) [l] DD D c Regu latory Agency(ies) D D D [l]

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Owner Advisor work continued(s) in support of Construction of Pump Station Inflow Gate Structure and levee hardening

Verified via IMAIL __VERBAL Date 5 ( 3 c b() I a All information piovided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that Inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made In support of this response may be used by the

512G9JiIX 11s a basis for rejection rescission or the award or termination or the contract and rllffl~Anampe as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 or the Broward CojlftYi 34~6ttlrbtflent Code Y

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

B0~~AARD ~~t~UNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

Fl ORIOA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Sunrise

Contact Name Luisa Fernanda Arbelaa Title Project Manager Reference date 05162018

Contact Email LArbelaezsunrlseflgov Contact Phone 954-888-6009

Name of Referenced Project City of Sunrise - Springtree WTP Water Stabilization and Solids Handling

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PA 16-003-CE 04072016 to 05292018 $ 50797800

Vendors role in Project ]Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [l]Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Carollo Engineers performed the design study and construction administration services for the City

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D G6 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Carollo Engineers technical knowledge and attenllon lo detall were beneficial lo the pltojad They ecled in lhe C~ys besl Interest In every aspect for lhe d1K8Uon of the projectbull

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via ~MAIL _VERBAL Verified by fc4J~~ Division W fl ED All lnrormalion provided to Broward ltAunty Is oobjoci to vorirtcotion Vendoc ecknowledgu that 1naowrate unlMhfuf 0lt lncocrecl statements rnado In support or this response may be useltI by lhe County as a basis for rejection rescission or the award 0lt termination ol the convect and may also ampOIVe as the babullibull ror debarmont of vondOlt purauont to Section 21119 or the Broward County Proc11oment Code

Bid Sync p 135 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BftQNARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

I l 0 R I 0 A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Florida Technical Consultants

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

VIiiage of Wellington Utilities

Contact Name Bradley Wolak Title Assistant Director Ut11Reference date 5182018

Contact Email bwolakwelllngtonflgov Contact Phone 561-753-2480

Name of Referenced Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 10012017 to Present 3500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vend~ 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again UZfYes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor J_ rJ fJ j(Gr-~k 6 Jti ov1 ~uf-Jiy fgt-r_- syrrzi~ff~ Al

R Q_ d--1 0~l 4 171 i+CI ~~lHI )Please rate your experience with tile Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Applicablereferenced Vendor Improvement

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy B D

DD c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D Db Professionalism D D

c Turnover D DD 3 Timeliness of

a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant(s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Additional Comments (provide on addltjpnal sheetJf needed) bull ~middot$ -JJ fo~~rltjbull lt( c-c_ ~~~ lt fo L1-lfAR- -middot~ I 10 ~ ~

~ bullL ~~ _te_ l~Ilgt~Cef t J ~ l rfbull4 middot r0 laquo r 4111J w f1 rrr- 0r- -i-HIS SECTION(9R COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by fcAJc ~ Division Y-1 IN ED Date 5 ~o w8 All lnfonn1Uon ptollfded to BlOward County le eubjeet to vetfflcatlon Vendor aclltnowledge1 that lneccurale unllJlhfUl or lnconect -bullmenla made In 1UPPort o1 this reopon90 may be uoec1 by the couniy ae a baalS ror re)ectlon re8Claeton Of the award 0t leltmlnatlon Of the contract and may 1l10 MM ae the baale flaquo debarrnont 01 vendor pu11uant to Section 21119 of ll1e Broward County Procurement Codo

BidSync p 18 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F LUFltIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultants LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Palm Beach Public Works

Contact Name Gerry Vazquez Title WRD Technician Reference date 05182018

Contact Email gvazqueztownofpalmbeachcom Contact Phone 772-546-6859

Name of Referenced Project GIS Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 3242014 to Present 13500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [3yenes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

PrwAamprs- favl49z Please rate your experience with the Need a Satlafactory Excellent Not

Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D g- D b Accuracy D Er D c Deliverables g-shyB D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D GJ D b Professionalism D D G- D c Tu mover D D cg- D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D g D b Deliverables D D Qshy D

4 Project completed within budget D D lbJ- D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D El- Db Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [3- D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

BidSync p 17 51232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

120-nWARDLll~ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form fLORllgtA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultant LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Waneya Bryant Title Meter Serv Mgr Reference date 05182018

Contact Email BryantWbbflus Contact Phone 561-742-6427

Name of Referenced Project Boynton Beach Utility GIS Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 12012016 to Present $15000000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

~T~ 5e-r-vtleamp +roM l)h f-es Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D Dc Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ti4 D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ Db Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on addlUonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION~urv USE ONLy u bull

Verified via VEMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by kuJ~ Division W if E D rao(ao8Date 5

All Information provided to Browslaquo COOlty Is Slbject to verfflcation Vendor acKnowledges that lneocurate Untruthful or lncolleel 8tatements made In support d this rfl9pOn98 may be used by 1119 Counly as a batia falt rejection relduion ct Ille award or lemilnlilon of the contract and may al80181Veaa1119 basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 ot Ille Broward CountyProcurement Code

512312018 BidSync p 16

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1

8W1V~isl1War Bid PNC21 15559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Fonn

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Cooper City - middot

Contact Name Michael Bailey PE itle Utilities DlrCity EbullReference date 05011201s

Contact Email MBalleycoopercityflorg Contact Phone (954) 434-5519

Name of Referenced Project City of Cooper City Continuing Professional Services bullContract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

RFQ 2009middot 1 04242009 to Present $ 2 19844200

Vendors role in Project IZJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Since 2009 Hazen has provided Cooper City with engineering services or water and wastewater projects Projects have lnctudeo lhe Pine Island Road Pump Station Lilt S1alions 2 amp 49 Improvements Master Plan Update of the FeaslJl~lty Review of Infrastructure Improvements tor Wastewater and the Eflluent Reuse and Disposal Master Plan

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy 8 D

D ~ D c Deliverables D 0 ~ D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D 0 D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tumover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D GJ- D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D 0 D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) ~D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

bull-rHIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY-

Verified vie EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ct4~ Division ~tUb Date ~ i3~) 0fgt All Information provided to BltCgtWW County 11 wbed ID vamprificalion Velldot adltnowledgu that lnaoewate unlrUhful lncom1ct statemampnla made in wppolt of 11111 response may blt uHd by the

4t2j=~ rejection rHclsslcn of th8 award or lennhallon of Ille eoo1nlct and may also seNamp at tilt basis for dtbarmenl at Vendor puuan1 lo Sectioo 21119 of the Broward COltJi 43

5232018 Bid Sync p24

Broward County Board of PNC211 5559P1

~RiiirilyenlcHUffi~~8CrW~r Bid PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

8DdMARD _ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FL O RIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Fort Lauderdale

Contact Name Rares Patrica PE Title Senior Project Mgr Reference date os1021201s

Contact Email RPetricafortlauderdalegov Contact Phone 9548287150

Name of Referenced Project Stormwater Master Planning and Design Implementation Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

256-11660 04192016 to 04192021 $ 989400000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

vyould you use this vendor again Sves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor The Hazen team Is responsible for delivery of a new stormwaler master plan model a prlorlllzed slormwaterresllency capital Improvements plan and Implementation of designs to address chronic flooding and other slormwater management challenges In the City Primary work tasks Include data collectlon hydrologlclhydraullc modeling and design permitting and construction services for capllal Improvement projects resulting from the revised stormwater master plan (preltmlnary design In seven priority neighborhoods)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION ~R COUNTY USE ONLY

aJ~Verified via pound MA IL _VERBAL Verified by Division W1~tl Date 5 ~3o~ax l S N I informallon p roviltled lo Broward County is sulljecl lo verification Vendor altknowledjj6s lhal inaccurate unlMhlut or lncotreci statements m ade In support of this respon$e may be used by tho

412~-~ rejeclion rescission of the award or termination ol lhe contracl and may also serve as lhe basis for debalment ol Vendor purwant to Section 21119 ol lhe Broward Cou~ 4 3

5232018 Bid Sync p25

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 Br~~~~~rs Bid PNC2115559P1 County t ommissioners

B~uWARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FlOR I CA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

Solicitation PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and s OrganizationFirm Name p

Town of Jupiter

nee

Contact Email davidbjupiterflus Contact Phone (561) 746-5134

Name of Referenced Project Engineering Services for Stormwater and Water Capital Improvements

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount $ 630000000 W17248 (2017 reselection 1012000 to Present (estimated lee-to-date since contract inception) contract number)

Vendors role in Project IZI Prime Vendor osubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again 0Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Descriotion of services orovided bv Vendor Since 2000 Hazen has served as General Consulfant to the Town or Jupiter As General Stormwater and Water Consullant the firm has provided services related to master planning stormwater planning and modeling design NPDES permilling asset management resiliency ratefinancial analysis plan review and construction oversight Water-related capital projs have involved additional system storage and high-service pumping transmission system improvements and RampR at existing facilities

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Verllied via EMAIL _ VERBAL Division WWC D

fo (J-Vv ~ltIvmiddotj Date 5(30(ipf S

Al lnroimallon pngtYICGd 10 Broward Counly Is sub)oel to v8flrcallon vendlaquo acknowledges lhat Inaccurate unlruthlu~ 0t Jnwrrect slatoments made In support ol this response may be used by the 42~~1~0 rojecllon rescission or Ille award or termination or lhe con~acl bullnd mbully also serve as tho basis r0t debarment of Vendor pursuant lo Socllon 21119 of lho Broward Couw 41

5232018 BidSync p 26

a N ~ IL) IL) N u z a_

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLO RI DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Walter Wernecke RA Title Sr Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email WWERNECKEhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Hollywood Marina Restrooms

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

04152015 to Present 7500000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor OSubconsultanVSubcontractor n ~U t1

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

-0 Vgt Description of services provided by VendorO ~ ~ Q) Structural Design and Construction Inspection Services i co Q m ~- c E c0

i E gt Oo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not () uu Appllcable O

E~ referenced Vendor Improvement iii ~sectoO 1 Vendors Quality of Service B mu a Responsive D D

b Accuracy DD c Deliverables D DD

2 Vendors Organization D Da Staff expertise v D b Professionalism~ D D c Turnover D ~D

3 Timeliness of D a Project b Deliverables D ~

4 Pec~~11~$~hinJ~~qt lfr D D 5 Cooperation with f ~

a Your Firm D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D

Al lnfonn1tion pRgttded IO Brwd Cltgtunly lo 1ubjecl IO ibllon vsor ~middot Iha icl-bullmiddot ~ ir-ect slalemenls mode In _ol lhb _ moy ti used by he County as a basis lot rejecUon rnclnlon cl the eward or tonnlnallan of lhl connct 1nd may bullllo 11 the basis for dobalment of Vendor IQtulnl IO SICllOn 21119 at lhe Broword County Procurement Code

Cl ltraquo I() I() I() N ()

Cl z

BRltJWARD ~ middot COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORl OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Davie

Contact Name Emilio DeSimone Title Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email Emilio_DeSimonedavie-fl gov Contact Phone 954-797-1085

Name of Referenced Project Pavillion 5 Linear Park

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

B-17-123 09152015 to 2700000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor O SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es O No If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

0 Description of services provided by Vendor O Q)

iii c Structural Design and Construction Inspection ServicesoQ

CDi-

0cc E gt=gt E ()Oo O () () Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

ii) -e i- Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 111 cs

B ioO

J 1 Vendors Quality of Service Q ()

a Responsive D D b Accuracy D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization []Ll Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D Dtr

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [g D b Deliverables D D ar D

4 Project completed within budget [1tD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) cgD D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via l EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by ~h~ Division WlI Etgt Date 0 f l~o I 8 All lnformaUon provided lO Broward County Is eubJect 10 verifutlon Vendor ecknOMedgoo that lnaocurote unNlhlul or Incorrect statamenle made In aupl)Ort of this reaponse may be used by lho County et o baampla for rejection realtluion of the award or lermlnallon of tho eon1fllcl ond moy olao aorvo os ho basis for debarmont of Vondor purauenl lo Section 21119 of the Broward Counly Procuremen1 Code

0 0 agt a c () z 0

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Terrence Comiskey AIA Title Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email TCOMISKEYhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Van Buren Parking Garage

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PK 14-053 Nov 2014 to Present 8310000

Vendors role in Project t8(Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

o~ Description of services provided by Vendor 1 Q)ltO c Structural Design and Conslructlon Inspection Services 0 Q

0~Jl ccE l E enOo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

gtshy

uu O Improvement Applicable ffireferenced Vendor

~sect 1 Vendors Quality of Service 1 ~

oOau a Responsive D ~ D b Accuracy B D D

D D [- Dc Deliverables

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tum over D D D g

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ D Subcontractor(s )S ubcons u ltant( s)b D D ~ D

c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D yenj D Additional Comments provide on sdditlonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION ~NTY USE ONLY0

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by kW Division W-1-(i~ Date EJo(a~t8 Al lnform1Uon PltOVlded lo Browald Ccxnty It IUbjoct to vorificallon Vendor eoknowfodgea thal lnaewralt U111MhlJI deg inlaquogtlaquobullel amptal11ants made In eupporl of lhls relj)Onse may be used by Iha Counly es a balls l0t rcfecllon rescfuloltI of tho ew1rd or 1ermtnaU0lt1 ol lhbull conllllCI and may elao urve 11 lho basis for dabarmenl of Vondor pursuanl lo Secllon 21 119 of he erowald COUlly CiProcurement Code

~ N ii

00

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 aOWllrp Commficumlref Bid PNC2116615B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Pompano Beach FL

Contact Name Mr A Randolph Brown Title Utilities Director Reference date April 30 2018

Contact Email randolphbrowncopbflcom Contact Phone 954-545-7043

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 201 o Project Amount fees varied

Multiple

Vendors role in Project IKJ Prime Vendor

to 2018

osubconsultanUSubcontractor

(range $10000shy$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D ~ D D c Deliverables D ~ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D ~ D D b Professionalism D D ~ D C Turnover D El DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ 0 b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D [BJ D n c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [XJ o ~

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed) amp~~it -THIS SECTION ~COUNTY USE ONL y-bullbull

Verified via ~AIL __VERBAL Verified by 1lt4 )~ Division N WE O Date 5 faol Z1 18

All lnformotlon providod to BltownrltI Cou nty it aubjoct O verification VendOr acknowledges that lnaccornto untruthful or incorroct 11atomon1s made in support of this response may be used by tho

411p~~)~~J rojoclion roscissioo ol lho award or 1orroinalion of tho contract and roay also s01vo as lhbull basis f0lt d~arroont of VondOf pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward Cou)l1

Bid Sync p 73

40

5232018

Broward County Board of Bid PNC2116659B 1 County Commissioners

B~aWARD gt1- t COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Loxahatchee River Environmental Control District

Contact Name Mr Kris Dean Title Director of Engineering Reference date May 9 2018

Contact Email krisdeanloxahatcheeriverorg Contact Phone 561-747-5700

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 2001 Project Amount fees varied (range $10000shyMultiple to 2018 $250000)

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IR)Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D ~ D D b Accuracy D 0 D D c Deliverables D IBJ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D IB] D D b Professionalism D ~ D D c Turnover D [8J D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D [8J D D b Deliverables D m D D

4 Project completed within budget D ~ D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D ~ D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D Ii] D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D ~ D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SE~ FOR~USE ONLY

Verified via _lEMAIL __VERBAL Verified by ~lt Division fWeb Date I

All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untrulhful or incorrecl slatements made In support of this response may be used by the lJl~~~l~~jSfiir rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and mll~~~ere as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Co)f 10

Broward County Board of Bid PNC21166$9B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A l

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Lake Worth FL

Contact Name Mr Felipe Lofaso TitleAsst Dir Public-ServicesReference date May 9 2018

Contact Email flofasolakeworthorg Contact Phone 561-586-1720

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contract

Contract No Date Services Provided 2014 Project Amount fees varied Multiple to 2018 (range $10000shy

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Services included multiple municipal engineering projects including survey roadway design utility design and coordination (water wastewater stormwater other) along with project management

Needs Satisfactory Excellent NotPlease rate your experience with the Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D GJ D b Accuracy D D Ii] D c Deliverables D Ii] DD

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [i] D c Turnover D D D [X]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D 0 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [X] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION Fe COUNTY USE ONLrbullbull

Verified via MAIL __VERBAL Verified by Division ~wgtgt Date 5~3ol20t8 All information provided to Broward County Is subject lo verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect slalements made in support ol this response may be used by the

OZ~id~~~~j~r rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and m~~~(iirve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Cour~ iG

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - ARCADIS US INC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts

VS0000013130 VS00013130 - ARCADIS US INC Prime Work Auth Vendor SummaryProjects

PURCHASING 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold Procurement No Fixed Contracts FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Favorites Past 5 Years Prime Vendor

Sub Vendor From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 10042017 Purchase Order

Evaluation Purchase Orders 1 POs With A Total Amt Of $20000000 Log Off Paid To Dt ($12132949) Balance $7867051

Contracts Purchase Orders Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx 6192018

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Finish

PURCHASING Weighted Scores Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract FileRoom DashBoard Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number FileRoom Insert

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel Favorites Prime Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Service Evaluation

6132017 YES 486 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Goals Compliance Evaluation

10272016 YES 460 View Docs (0)

6272018

Project Management Information System

Close

Contracts Central Administration

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9130 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-24

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6182018 YES 355 View Docs (1)

Proj Nbr 9320 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-20

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6132018 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9290 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-23

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1122018 YES 494 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-21

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12182017 YES 488 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10162017 YES 473 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

8252017 YES 495 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9321 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-19

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

7112017 YES 476 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-17

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2272017 YES 400 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

10132016 YES 384 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-12

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

5202016 YES 405 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9018 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-06

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10192015 YES 448 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

3202015 YES 385 View Docs (0)

Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL CONSULTANTS

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Project Management Information System

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-04

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12122014 YES 437 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-08

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1242014 YES 423 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-02

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2282014 YES 452 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC

VC0000044184 VC00044184 - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres PS $001 Used $000 Remain $001 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $354848400 Closed 0 Total $000 Total Current Retainage Balance For All Contracts $793370 No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 06292015 Purchase Orders 2 POs With A Total Amt Of $362317900 Paid To Dt ($218795160) Balance $143522740

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 40803 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9058 - DISTRICT 3A POTABLE WATER STORAGE

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1220410P1 - Consultant Engineering Services for Potable Water FixedOpen Contracts Storage Tanks and Pumping Systems Work Auth Prime Vendor CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Periodic Final Finish

Log Off Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type

Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

6232015 8302017 413 Approved 8312017 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard

Enter Vendor Name (or a portion of) Then Click Search - Wilcards Are Permitted (ie wa wawainc) Florida Technical Consultants

Search Reset Finish

No Vendors Found For Your Search Try Again

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41005 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score Go

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0773

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

12122017 YES 430 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

8302016 YES 438 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Final Consultant Evaluation 3142016 YES 478 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0706

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

142016 YES 402 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9016OES - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0731

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

10192015 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0748

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

612015 YES 467 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

2192015 YES 500 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0754

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

252015 YES 409 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0755

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

1242014 YES 415 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8974 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0758

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

6202014 YES 393 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr

WATER amp WASTEWATER

Final Consultant Work Authorization 572014 YES 423 View Docs

(0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

HS0746 ENGINEERING Evaluation

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

4302014 YES 475 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Evaluation 4302014 YES 493 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0710

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

3172014 YES 395 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0753

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

1212014 YES 380 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0763

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

11192013 YES 450 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0775

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 408 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals

Finish

Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed FileRoom DashBoard Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization FileRoom Insert NumberFavorites

Prime Vendor Export To Excel Sub Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0772

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 417 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0771

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

2262013 YES 410 View Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 21: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

B~OWARD bull COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

F LORID A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

South Florida Water Management District

Contact Name Greg Coffelt PE Title SFWMD Project Manager Reference date 05172018

Contact Email gcoffeltsfwmdgov Contact Phone 561-682-6853

Name of Referenced Project L-8 Reservoir Inflow Structure and Pump Station

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

4600000861 02152011 to 09192012 $ 144535100

Vendors role in Project [l) Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [l)Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Corolla was contracted as an Owners Advisor for a Design-Build contract developed engineering design criteria assisted in RFQ development and evaluation supported RFP technical proposal and cost proposal analysis

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [l] D b Accuracy D [] D D c Deliverables D [] D D

2 Vendors Organization [l]a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D [l] D c Turnover D D D [l]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [l] D b Deliverables D [l] D D

4 Project completed within budget [l] DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [l] D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) [l] DD D c Regu latory Agency(ies) D D D [l]

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Owner Advisor work continued(s) in support of Construction of Pump Station Inflow Gate Structure and levee hardening

Verified via IMAIL __VERBAL Date 5 ( 3 c b() I a All information piovided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that Inaccurate untruthful or incorrect statements made In support of this response may be used by the

512G9JiIX 11s a basis for rejection rescission or the award or termination or the contract and rllffl~Anampe as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21119 or the Broward CojlftYi 34~6ttlrbtflent Code Y

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

B0~~AARD ~~t~UNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

Fl ORIOA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Sunrise

Contact Name Luisa Fernanda Arbelaa Title Project Manager Reference date 05162018

Contact Email LArbelaezsunrlseflgov Contact Phone 954-888-6009

Name of Referenced Project City of Sunrise - Springtree WTP Water Stabilization and Solids Handling

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PA 16-003-CE 04072016 to 05292018 $ 50797800

Vendors role in Project ]Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [l]Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Carollo Engineers performed the design study and construction administration services for the City

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D G6 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Carollo Engineers technical knowledge and attenllon lo detall were beneficial lo the pltojad They ecled in lhe C~ys besl Interest In every aspect for lhe d1K8Uon of the projectbull

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via ~MAIL _VERBAL Verified by fc4J~~ Division W fl ED All lnrormalion provided to Broward ltAunty Is oobjoci to vorirtcotion Vendoc ecknowledgu that 1naowrate unlMhfuf 0lt lncocrecl statements rnado In support or this response may be useltI by lhe County as a basis for rejection rescission or the award 0lt termination ol the convect and may also ampOIVe as the babullibull ror debarmont of vondOlt purauont to Section 21119 or the Broward County Proc11oment Code

Bid Sync p 135 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BftQNARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

I l 0 R I 0 A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Florida Technical Consultants

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

VIiiage of Wellington Utilities

Contact Name Bradley Wolak Title Assistant Director Ut11Reference date 5182018

Contact Email bwolakwelllngtonflgov Contact Phone 561-753-2480

Name of Referenced Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 10012017 to Present 3500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vend~ 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again UZfYes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor J_ rJ fJ j(Gr-~k 6 Jti ov1 ~uf-Jiy fgt-r_- syrrzi~ff~ Al

R Q_ d--1 0~l 4 171 i+CI ~~lHI )Please rate your experience with tile Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Applicablereferenced Vendor Improvement

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy B D

DD c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D Db Professionalism D D

c Turnover D DD 3 Timeliness of

a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant(s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Additional Comments (provide on addltjpnal sheetJf needed) bull ~middot$ -JJ fo~~rltjbull lt( c-c_ ~~~ lt fo L1-lfAR- -middot~ I 10 ~ ~

~ bullL ~~ _te_ l~Ilgt~Cef t J ~ l rfbull4 middot r0 laquo r 4111J w f1 rrr- 0r- -i-HIS SECTION(9R COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by fcAJc ~ Division Y-1 IN ED Date 5 ~o w8 All lnfonn1Uon ptollfded to BlOward County le eubjeet to vetfflcatlon Vendor aclltnowledge1 that lneccurale unllJlhfUl or lnconect -bullmenla made In 1UPPort o1 this reopon90 may be uoec1 by the couniy ae a baalS ror re)ectlon re8Claeton Of the award 0t leltmlnatlon Of the contract and may 1l10 MM ae the baale flaquo debarrnont 01 vendor pu11uant to Section 21119 of ll1e Broward County Procurement Codo

BidSync p 18 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F LUFltIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultants LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Palm Beach Public Works

Contact Name Gerry Vazquez Title WRD Technician Reference date 05182018

Contact Email gvazqueztownofpalmbeachcom Contact Phone 772-546-6859

Name of Referenced Project GIS Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 3242014 to Present 13500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [3yenes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

PrwAamprs- favl49z Please rate your experience with the Need a Satlafactory Excellent Not

Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D g- D b Accuracy D Er D c Deliverables g-shyB D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D GJ D b Professionalism D D G- D c Tu mover D D cg- D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D g D b Deliverables D D Qshy D

4 Project completed within budget D D lbJ- D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D El- Db Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [3- D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

BidSync p 17 51232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

120-nWARDLll~ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form fLORllgtA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultant LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Waneya Bryant Title Meter Serv Mgr Reference date 05182018

Contact Email BryantWbbflus Contact Phone 561-742-6427

Name of Referenced Project Boynton Beach Utility GIS Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 12012016 to Present $15000000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

~T~ 5e-r-vtleamp +roM l)h f-es Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D Dc Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ti4 D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ Db Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on addlUonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION~urv USE ONLy u bull

Verified via VEMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by kuJ~ Division W if E D rao(ao8Date 5

All Information provided to Browslaquo COOlty Is Slbject to verfflcation Vendor acKnowledges that lneocurate Untruthful or lncolleel 8tatements made In support d this rfl9pOn98 may be used by 1119 Counly as a batia falt rejection relduion ct Ille award or lemilnlilon of the contract and may al80181Veaa1119 basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 ot Ille Broward CountyProcurement Code

512312018 BidSync p 16

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1

8W1V~isl1War Bid PNC21 15559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Fonn

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Cooper City - middot

Contact Name Michael Bailey PE itle Utilities DlrCity EbullReference date 05011201s

Contact Email MBalleycoopercityflorg Contact Phone (954) 434-5519

Name of Referenced Project City of Cooper City Continuing Professional Services bullContract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

RFQ 2009middot 1 04242009 to Present $ 2 19844200

Vendors role in Project IZJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Since 2009 Hazen has provided Cooper City with engineering services or water and wastewater projects Projects have lnctudeo lhe Pine Island Road Pump Station Lilt S1alions 2 amp 49 Improvements Master Plan Update of the FeaslJl~lty Review of Infrastructure Improvements tor Wastewater and the Eflluent Reuse and Disposal Master Plan

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy 8 D

D ~ D c Deliverables D 0 ~ D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D 0 D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tumover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D GJ- D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D 0 D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) ~D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

bull-rHIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY-

Verified vie EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ct4~ Division ~tUb Date ~ i3~) 0fgt All Information provided to BltCgtWW County 11 wbed ID vamprificalion Velldot adltnowledgu that lnaoewate unlrUhful lncom1ct statemampnla made in wppolt of 11111 response may blt uHd by the

4t2j=~ rejection rHclsslcn of th8 award or lennhallon of Ille eoo1nlct and may also seNamp at tilt basis for dtbarmenl at Vendor puuan1 lo Sectioo 21119 of the Broward COltJi 43

5232018 Bid Sync p24

Broward County Board of PNC211 5559P1

~RiiirilyenlcHUffi~~8CrW~r Bid PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

8DdMARD _ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FL O RIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Fort Lauderdale

Contact Name Rares Patrica PE Title Senior Project Mgr Reference date os1021201s

Contact Email RPetricafortlauderdalegov Contact Phone 9548287150

Name of Referenced Project Stormwater Master Planning and Design Implementation Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

256-11660 04192016 to 04192021 $ 989400000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

vyould you use this vendor again Sves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor The Hazen team Is responsible for delivery of a new stormwaler master plan model a prlorlllzed slormwaterresllency capital Improvements plan and Implementation of designs to address chronic flooding and other slormwater management challenges In the City Primary work tasks Include data collectlon hydrologlclhydraullc modeling and design permitting and construction services for capllal Improvement projects resulting from the revised stormwater master plan (preltmlnary design In seven priority neighborhoods)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION ~R COUNTY USE ONLY

aJ~Verified via pound MA IL _VERBAL Verified by Division W1~tl Date 5 ~3o~ax l S N I informallon p roviltled lo Broward County is sulljecl lo verification Vendor altknowledjj6s lhal inaccurate unlMhlut or lncotreci statements m ade In support of this respon$e may be used by tho

412~-~ rejeclion rescission of the award or termination ol lhe contracl and may also serve as lhe basis for debalment ol Vendor purwant to Section 21119 ol lhe Broward Cou~ 4 3

5232018 Bid Sync p25

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 Br~~~~~rs Bid PNC2115559P1 County t ommissioners

B~uWARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FlOR I CA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

Solicitation PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and s OrganizationFirm Name p

Town of Jupiter

nee

Contact Email davidbjupiterflus Contact Phone (561) 746-5134

Name of Referenced Project Engineering Services for Stormwater and Water Capital Improvements

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount $ 630000000 W17248 (2017 reselection 1012000 to Present (estimated lee-to-date since contract inception) contract number)

Vendors role in Project IZI Prime Vendor osubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again 0Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Descriotion of services orovided bv Vendor Since 2000 Hazen has served as General Consulfant to the Town or Jupiter As General Stormwater and Water Consullant the firm has provided services related to master planning stormwater planning and modeling design NPDES permilling asset management resiliency ratefinancial analysis plan review and construction oversight Water-related capital projs have involved additional system storage and high-service pumping transmission system improvements and RampR at existing facilities

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Verllied via EMAIL _ VERBAL Division WWC D

fo (J-Vv ~ltIvmiddotj Date 5(30(ipf S

Al lnroimallon pngtYICGd 10 Broward Counly Is sub)oel to v8flrcallon vendlaquo acknowledges lhat Inaccurate unlruthlu~ 0t Jnwrrect slatoments made In support ol this response may be used by the 42~~1~0 rojecllon rescission or Ille award or termination or lhe con~acl bullnd mbully also serve as tho basis r0t debarment of Vendor pursuant lo Socllon 21119 of lho Broward Couw 41

5232018 BidSync p 26

a N ~ IL) IL) N u z a_

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLO RI DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Walter Wernecke RA Title Sr Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email WWERNECKEhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Hollywood Marina Restrooms

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

04152015 to Present 7500000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor OSubconsultanVSubcontractor n ~U t1

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

-0 Vgt Description of services provided by VendorO ~ ~ Q) Structural Design and Construction Inspection Services i co Q m ~- c E c0

i E gt Oo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not () uu Appllcable O

E~ referenced Vendor Improvement iii ~sectoO 1 Vendors Quality of Service B mu a Responsive D D

b Accuracy DD c Deliverables D DD

2 Vendors Organization D Da Staff expertise v D b Professionalism~ D D c Turnover D ~D

3 Timeliness of D a Project b Deliverables D ~

4 Pec~~11~$~hinJ~~qt lfr D D 5 Cooperation with f ~

a Your Firm D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D

Al lnfonn1tion pRgttded IO Brwd Cltgtunly lo 1ubjecl IO ibllon vsor ~middot Iha icl-bullmiddot ~ ir-ect slalemenls mode In _ol lhb _ moy ti used by he County as a basis lot rejecUon rnclnlon cl the eward or tonnlnallan of lhl connct 1nd may bullllo 11 the basis for dobalment of Vendor IQtulnl IO SICllOn 21119 at lhe Broword County Procurement Code

Cl ltraquo I() I() I() N ()

Cl z

BRltJWARD ~ middot COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORl OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Davie

Contact Name Emilio DeSimone Title Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email Emilio_DeSimonedavie-fl gov Contact Phone 954-797-1085

Name of Referenced Project Pavillion 5 Linear Park

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

B-17-123 09152015 to 2700000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor O SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es O No If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

0 Description of services provided by Vendor O Q)

iii c Structural Design and Construction Inspection ServicesoQ

CDi-

0cc E gt=gt E ()Oo O () () Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

ii) -e i- Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 111 cs

B ioO

J 1 Vendors Quality of Service Q ()

a Responsive D D b Accuracy D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization []Ll Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D Dtr

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [g D b Deliverables D D ar D

4 Project completed within budget [1tD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) cgD D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via l EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by ~h~ Division WlI Etgt Date 0 f l~o I 8 All lnformaUon provided lO Broward County Is eubJect 10 verifutlon Vendor ecknOMedgoo that lnaocurote unNlhlul or Incorrect statamenle made In aupl)Ort of this reaponse may be used by lho County et o baampla for rejection realtluion of the award or lermlnallon of tho eon1fllcl ond moy olao aorvo os ho basis for debarmont of Vondor purauenl lo Section 21119 of the Broward Counly Procuremen1 Code

0 0 agt a c () z 0

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Terrence Comiskey AIA Title Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email TCOMISKEYhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Van Buren Parking Garage

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PK 14-053 Nov 2014 to Present 8310000

Vendors role in Project t8(Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

o~ Description of services provided by Vendor 1 Q)ltO c Structural Design and Conslructlon Inspection Services 0 Q

0~Jl ccE l E enOo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

gtshy

uu O Improvement Applicable ffireferenced Vendor

~sect 1 Vendors Quality of Service 1 ~

oOau a Responsive D ~ D b Accuracy B D D

D D [- Dc Deliverables

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tum over D D D g

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ D Subcontractor(s )S ubcons u ltant( s)b D D ~ D

c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D yenj D Additional Comments provide on sdditlonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION ~NTY USE ONLY0

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by kW Division W-1-(i~ Date EJo(a~t8 Al lnform1Uon PltOVlded lo Browald Ccxnty It IUbjoct to vorificallon Vendor eoknowfodgea thal lnaewralt U111MhlJI deg inlaquogtlaquobullel amptal11ants made In eupporl of lhls relj)Onse may be used by Iha Counly es a balls l0t rcfecllon rescfuloltI of tho ew1rd or 1ermtnaU0lt1 ol lhbull conllllCI and may elao urve 11 lho basis for dabarmenl of Vondor pursuanl lo Secllon 21 119 of he erowald COUlly CiProcurement Code

~ N ii

00

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 aOWllrp Commficumlref Bid PNC2116615B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Pompano Beach FL

Contact Name Mr A Randolph Brown Title Utilities Director Reference date April 30 2018

Contact Email randolphbrowncopbflcom Contact Phone 954-545-7043

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 201 o Project Amount fees varied

Multiple

Vendors role in Project IKJ Prime Vendor

to 2018

osubconsultanUSubcontractor

(range $10000shy$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D ~ D D c Deliverables D ~ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D ~ D D b Professionalism D D ~ D C Turnover D El DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ 0 b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D [BJ D n c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [XJ o ~

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed) amp~~it -THIS SECTION ~COUNTY USE ONL y-bullbull

Verified via ~AIL __VERBAL Verified by 1lt4 )~ Division N WE O Date 5 faol Z1 18

All lnformotlon providod to BltownrltI Cou nty it aubjoct O verification VendOr acknowledges that lnaccornto untruthful or incorroct 11atomon1s made in support of this response may be used by tho

411p~~)~~J rojoclion roscissioo ol lho award or 1orroinalion of tho contract and roay also s01vo as lhbull basis f0lt d~arroont of VondOf pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward Cou)l1

Bid Sync p 73

40

5232018

Broward County Board of Bid PNC2116659B 1 County Commissioners

B~aWARD gt1- t COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Loxahatchee River Environmental Control District

Contact Name Mr Kris Dean Title Director of Engineering Reference date May 9 2018

Contact Email krisdeanloxahatcheeriverorg Contact Phone 561-747-5700

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 2001 Project Amount fees varied (range $10000shyMultiple to 2018 $250000)

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IR)Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D ~ D D b Accuracy D 0 D D c Deliverables D IBJ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D IB] D D b Professionalism D ~ D D c Turnover D [8J D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D [8J D D b Deliverables D m D D

4 Project completed within budget D ~ D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D ~ D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D Ii] D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D ~ D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SE~ FOR~USE ONLY

Verified via _lEMAIL __VERBAL Verified by ~lt Division fWeb Date I

All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untrulhful or incorrecl slatements made In support of this response may be used by the lJl~~~l~~jSfiir rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and mll~~~ere as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Co)f 10

Broward County Board of Bid PNC21166$9B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A l

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Lake Worth FL

Contact Name Mr Felipe Lofaso TitleAsst Dir Public-ServicesReference date May 9 2018

Contact Email flofasolakeworthorg Contact Phone 561-586-1720

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contract

Contract No Date Services Provided 2014 Project Amount fees varied Multiple to 2018 (range $10000shy

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Services included multiple municipal engineering projects including survey roadway design utility design and coordination (water wastewater stormwater other) along with project management

Needs Satisfactory Excellent NotPlease rate your experience with the Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D GJ D b Accuracy D D Ii] D c Deliverables D Ii] DD

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [i] D c Turnover D D D [X]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D 0 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [X] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION Fe COUNTY USE ONLrbullbull

Verified via MAIL __VERBAL Verified by Division ~wgtgt Date 5~3ol20t8 All information provided to Broward County Is subject lo verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect slalements made in support ol this response may be used by the

OZ~id~~~~j~r rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and m~~~(iirve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Cour~ iG

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - ARCADIS US INC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts

VS0000013130 VS00013130 - ARCADIS US INC Prime Work Auth Vendor SummaryProjects

PURCHASING 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold Procurement No Fixed Contracts FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Favorites Past 5 Years Prime Vendor

Sub Vendor From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 10042017 Purchase Order

Evaluation Purchase Orders 1 POs With A Total Amt Of $20000000 Log Off Paid To Dt ($12132949) Balance $7867051

Contracts Purchase Orders Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx 6192018

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Finish

PURCHASING Weighted Scores Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract FileRoom DashBoard Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number FileRoom Insert

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel Favorites Prime Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Service Evaluation

6132017 YES 486 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Goals Compliance Evaluation

10272016 YES 460 View Docs (0)

6272018

Project Management Information System

Close

Contracts Central Administration

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9130 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-24

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6182018 YES 355 View Docs (1)

Proj Nbr 9320 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-20

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6132018 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9290 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-23

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1122018 YES 494 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-21

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12182017 YES 488 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10162017 YES 473 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

8252017 YES 495 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9321 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-19

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

7112017 YES 476 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-17

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2272017 YES 400 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

10132016 YES 384 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-12

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

5202016 YES 405 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9018 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-06

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10192015 YES 448 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

3202015 YES 385 View Docs (0)

Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL CONSULTANTS

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Project Management Information System

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-04

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12122014 YES 437 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-08

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1242014 YES 423 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-02

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2282014 YES 452 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC

VC0000044184 VC00044184 - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres PS $001 Used $000 Remain $001 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $354848400 Closed 0 Total $000 Total Current Retainage Balance For All Contracts $793370 No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 06292015 Purchase Orders 2 POs With A Total Amt Of $362317900 Paid To Dt ($218795160) Balance $143522740

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 40803 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9058 - DISTRICT 3A POTABLE WATER STORAGE

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1220410P1 - Consultant Engineering Services for Potable Water FixedOpen Contracts Storage Tanks and Pumping Systems Work Auth Prime Vendor CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Periodic Final Finish

Log Off Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type

Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

6232015 8302017 413 Approved 8312017 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard

Enter Vendor Name (or a portion of) Then Click Search - Wilcards Are Permitted (ie wa wawainc) Florida Technical Consultants

Search Reset Finish

No Vendors Found For Your Search Try Again

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41005 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score Go

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0773

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

12122017 YES 430 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

8302016 YES 438 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Final Consultant Evaluation 3142016 YES 478 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0706

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

142016 YES 402 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9016OES - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0731

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

10192015 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0748

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

612015 YES 467 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

2192015 YES 500 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0754

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

252015 YES 409 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0755

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

1242014 YES 415 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8974 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0758

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

6202014 YES 393 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr

WATER amp WASTEWATER

Final Consultant Work Authorization 572014 YES 423 View Docs

(0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

HS0746 ENGINEERING Evaluation

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

4302014 YES 475 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Evaluation 4302014 YES 493 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0710

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

3172014 YES 395 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0753

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

1212014 YES 380 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0763

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

11192013 YES 450 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0775

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 408 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals

Finish

Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed FileRoom DashBoard Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization FileRoom Insert NumberFavorites

Prime Vendor Export To Excel Sub Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0772

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 417 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0771

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

2262013 YES 410 View Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 22: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

B0~~AARD ~~t~UNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

Fl ORIOA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Carollo Engineers Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Sunrise

Contact Name Luisa Fernanda Arbelaa Title Project Manager Reference date 05162018

Contact Email LArbelaezsunrlseflgov Contact Phone 954-888-6009

Name of Referenced Project City of Sunrise - Springtree WTP Water Stabilization and Solids Handling

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PA 16-003-CE 04072016 to 05292018 $ 50797800

Vendors role in Project ]Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [l]Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Carollo Engineers performed the design study and construction administration services for the City

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D G6 D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

Carollo Engineers technical knowledge and attenllon lo detall were beneficial lo the pltojad They ecled in lhe C~ys besl Interest In every aspect for lhe d1K8Uon of the projectbull

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via ~MAIL _VERBAL Verified by fc4J~~ Division W fl ED All lnrormalion provided to Broward ltAunty Is oobjoci to vorirtcotion Vendoc ecknowledgu that 1naowrate unlMhfuf 0lt lncocrecl statements rnado In support or this response may be useltI by lhe County as a basis for rejection rescission or the award 0lt termination ol the convect and may also ampOIVe as the babullibull ror debarmont of vondOlt purauont to Section 21119 or the Broward County Proc11oment Code

Bid Sync p 135 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BftQNARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

I l 0 R I 0 A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Florida Technical Consultants

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

VIiiage of Wellington Utilities

Contact Name Bradley Wolak Title Assistant Director Ut11Reference date 5182018

Contact Email bwolakwelllngtonflgov Contact Phone 561-753-2480

Name of Referenced Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 10012017 to Present 3500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vend~ 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again UZfYes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor J_ rJ fJ j(Gr-~k 6 Jti ov1 ~uf-Jiy fgt-r_- syrrzi~ff~ Al

R Q_ d--1 0~l 4 171 i+CI ~~lHI )Please rate your experience with tile Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Applicablereferenced Vendor Improvement

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy B D

DD c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D Db Professionalism D D

c Turnover D DD 3 Timeliness of

a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant(s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Additional Comments (provide on addltjpnal sheetJf needed) bull ~middot$ -JJ fo~~rltjbull lt( c-c_ ~~~ lt fo L1-lfAR- -middot~ I 10 ~ ~

~ bullL ~~ _te_ l~Ilgt~Cef t J ~ l rfbull4 middot r0 laquo r 4111J w f1 rrr- 0r- -i-HIS SECTION(9R COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by fcAJc ~ Division Y-1 IN ED Date 5 ~o w8 All lnfonn1Uon ptollfded to BlOward County le eubjeet to vetfflcatlon Vendor aclltnowledge1 that lneccurale unllJlhfUl or lnconect -bullmenla made In 1UPPort o1 this reopon90 may be uoec1 by the couniy ae a baalS ror re)ectlon re8Claeton Of the award 0t leltmlnatlon Of the contract and may 1l10 MM ae the baale flaquo debarrnont 01 vendor pu11uant to Section 21119 of ll1e Broward County Procurement Codo

BidSync p 18 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F LUFltIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultants LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Palm Beach Public Works

Contact Name Gerry Vazquez Title WRD Technician Reference date 05182018

Contact Email gvazqueztownofpalmbeachcom Contact Phone 772-546-6859

Name of Referenced Project GIS Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 3242014 to Present 13500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [3yenes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

PrwAamprs- favl49z Please rate your experience with the Need a Satlafactory Excellent Not

Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D g- D b Accuracy D Er D c Deliverables g-shyB D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D GJ D b Professionalism D D G- D c Tu mover D D cg- D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D g D b Deliverables D D Qshy D

4 Project completed within budget D D lbJ- D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D El- Db Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [3- D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

BidSync p 17 51232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

120-nWARDLll~ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form fLORllgtA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultant LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Waneya Bryant Title Meter Serv Mgr Reference date 05182018

Contact Email BryantWbbflus Contact Phone 561-742-6427

Name of Referenced Project Boynton Beach Utility GIS Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 12012016 to Present $15000000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

~T~ 5e-r-vtleamp +roM l)h f-es Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D Dc Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ti4 D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ Db Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on addlUonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION~urv USE ONLy u bull

Verified via VEMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by kuJ~ Division W if E D rao(ao8Date 5

All Information provided to Browslaquo COOlty Is Slbject to verfflcation Vendor acKnowledges that lneocurate Untruthful or lncolleel 8tatements made In support d this rfl9pOn98 may be used by 1119 Counly as a batia falt rejection relduion ct Ille award or lemilnlilon of the contract and may al80181Veaa1119 basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 ot Ille Broward CountyProcurement Code

512312018 BidSync p 16

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1

8W1V~isl1War Bid PNC21 15559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Fonn

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Cooper City - middot

Contact Name Michael Bailey PE itle Utilities DlrCity EbullReference date 05011201s

Contact Email MBalleycoopercityflorg Contact Phone (954) 434-5519

Name of Referenced Project City of Cooper City Continuing Professional Services bullContract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

RFQ 2009middot 1 04242009 to Present $ 2 19844200

Vendors role in Project IZJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Since 2009 Hazen has provided Cooper City with engineering services or water and wastewater projects Projects have lnctudeo lhe Pine Island Road Pump Station Lilt S1alions 2 amp 49 Improvements Master Plan Update of the FeaslJl~lty Review of Infrastructure Improvements tor Wastewater and the Eflluent Reuse and Disposal Master Plan

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy 8 D

D ~ D c Deliverables D 0 ~ D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D 0 D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tumover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D GJ- D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D 0 D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) ~D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

bull-rHIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY-

Verified vie EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ct4~ Division ~tUb Date ~ i3~) 0fgt All Information provided to BltCgtWW County 11 wbed ID vamprificalion Velldot adltnowledgu that lnaoewate unlrUhful lncom1ct statemampnla made in wppolt of 11111 response may blt uHd by the

4t2j=~ rejection rHclsslcn of th8 award or lennhallon of Ille eoo1nlct and may also seNamp at tilt basis for dtbarmenl at Vendor puuan1 lo Sectioo 21119 of the Broward COltJi 43

5232018 Bid Sync p24

Broward County Board of PNC211 5559P1

~RiiirilyenlcHUffi~~8CrW~r Bid PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

8DdMARD _ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FL O RIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Fort Lauderdale

Contact Name Rares Patrica PE Title Senior Project Mgr Reference date os1021201s

Contact Email RPetricafortlauderdalegov Contact Phone 9548287150

Name of Referenced Project Stormwater Master Planning and Design Implementation Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

256-11660 04192016 to 04192021 $ 989400000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

vyould you use this vendor again Sves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor The Hazen team Is responsible for delivery of a new stormwaler master plan model a prlorlllzed slormwaterresllency capital Improvements plan and Implementation of designs to address chronic flooding and other slormwater management challenges In the City Primary work tasks Include data collectlon hydrologlclhydraullc modeling and design permitting and construction services for capllal Improvement projects resulting from the revised stormwater master plan (preltmlnary design In seven priority neighborhoods)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION ~R COUNTY USE ONLY

aJ~Verified via pound MA IL _VERBAL Verified by Division W1~tl Date 5 ~3o~ax l S N I informallon p roviltled lo Broward County is sulljecl lo verification Vendor altknowledjj6s lhal inaccurate unlMhlut or lncotreci statements m ade In support of this respon$e may be used by tho

412~-~ rejeclion rescission of the award or termination ol lhe contracl and may also serve as lhe basis for debalment ol Vendor purwant to Section 21119 ol lhe Broward Cou~ 4 3

5232018 Bid Sync p25

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 Br~~~~~rs Bid PNC2115559P1 County t ommissioners

B~uWARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FlOR I CA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

Solicitation PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and s OrganizationFirm Name p

Town of Jupiter

nee

Contact Email davidbjupiterflus Contact Phone (561) 746-5134

Name of Referenced Project Engineering Services for Stormwater and Water Capital Improvements

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount $ 630000000 W17248 (2017 reselection 1012000 to Present (estimated lee-to-date since contract inception) contract number)

Vendors role in Project IZI Prime Vendor osubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again 0Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Descriotion of services orovided bv Vendor Since 2000 Hazen has served as General Consulfant to the Town or Jupiter As General Stormwater and Water Consullant the firm has provided services related to master planning stormwater planning and modeling design NPDES permilling asset management resiliency ratefinancial analysis plan review and construction oversight Water-related capital projs have involved additional system storage and high-service pumping transmission system improvements and RampR at existing facilities

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Verllied via EMAIL _ VERBAL Division WWC D

fo (J-Vv ~ltIvmiddotj Date 5(30(ipf S

Al lnroimallon pngtYICGd 10 Broward Counly Is sub)oel to v8flrcallon vendlaquo acknowledges lhat Inaccurate unlruthlu~ 0t Jnwrrect slatoments made In support ol this response may be used by the 42~~1~0 rojecllon rescission or Ille award or termination or lhe con~acl bullnd mbully also serve as tho basis r0t debarment of Vendor pursuant lo Socllon 21119 of lho Broward Couw 41

5232018 BidSync p 26

a N ~ IL) IL) N u z a_

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLO RI DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Walter Wernecke RA Title Sr Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email WWERNECKEhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Hollywood Marina Restrooms

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

04152015 to Present 7500000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor OSubconsultanVSubcontractor n ~U t1

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

-0 Vgt Description of services provided by VendorO ~ ~ Q) Structural Design and Construction Inspection Services i co Q m ~- c E c0

i E gt Oo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not () uu Appllcable O

E~ referenced Vendor Improvement iii ~sectoO 1 Vendors Quality of Service B mu a Responsive D D

b Accuracy DD c Deliverables D DD

2 Vendors Organization D Da Staff expertise v D b Professionalism~ D D c Turnover D ~D

3 Timeliness of D a Project b Deliverables D ~

4 Pec~~11~$~hinJ~~qt lfr D D 5 Cooperation with f ~

a Your Firm D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D

Al lnfonn1tion pRgttded IO Brwd Cltgtunly lo 1ubjecl IO ibllon vsor ~middot Iha icl-bullmiddot ~ ir-ect slalemenls mode In _ol lhb _ moy ti used by he County as a basis lot rejecUon rnclnlon cl the eward or tonnlnallan of lhl connct 1nd may bullllo 11 the basis for dobalment of Vendor IQtulnl IO SICllOn 21119 at lhe Broword County Procurement Code

Cl ltraquo I() I() I() N ()

Cl z

BRltJWARD ~ middot COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORl OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Davie

Contact Name Emilio DeSimone Title Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email Emilio_DeSimonedavie-fl gov Contact Phone 954-797-1085

Name of Referenced Project Pavillion 5 Linear Park

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

B-17-123 09152015 to 2700000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor O SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es O No If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

0 Description of services provided by Vendor O Q)

iii c Structural Design and Construction Inspection ServicesoQ

CDi-

0cc E gt=gt E ()Oo O () () Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

ii) -e i- Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 111 cs

B ioO

J 1 Vendors Quality of Service Q ()

a Responsive D D b Accuracy D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization []Ll Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D Dtr

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [g D b Deliverables D D ar D

4 Project completed within budget [1tD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) cgD D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via l EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by ~h~ Division WlI Etgt Date 0 f l~o I 8 All lnformaUon provided lO Broward County Is eubJect 10 verifutlon Vendor ecknOMedgoo that lnaocurote unNlhlul or Incorrect statamenle made In aupl)Ort of this reaponse may be used by lho County et o baampla for rejection realtluion of the award or lermlnallon of tho eon1fllcl ond moy olao aorvo os ho basis for debarmont of Vondor purauenl lo Section 21119 of the Broward Counly Procuremen1 Code

0 0 agt a c () z 0

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Terrence Comiskey AIA Title Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email TCOMISKEYhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Van Buren Parking Garage

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PK 14-053 Nov 2014 to Present 8310000

Vendors role in Project t8(Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

o~ Description of services provided by Vendor 1 Q)ltO c Structural Design and Conslructlon Inspection Services 0 Q

0~Jl ccE l E enOo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

gtshy

uu O Improvement Applicable ffireferenced Vendor

~sect 1 Vendors Quality of Service 1 ~

oOau a Responsive D ~ D b Accuracy B D D

D D [- Dc Deliverables

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tum over D D D g

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ D Subcontractor(s )S ubcons u ltant( s)b D D ~ D

c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D yenj D Additional Comments provide on sdditlonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION ~NTY USE ONLY0

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by kW Division W-1-(i~ Date EJo(a~t8 Al lnform1Uon PltOVlded lo Browald Ccxnty It IUbjoct to vorificallon Vendor eoknowfodgea thal lnaewralt U111MhlJI deg inlaquogtlaquobullel amptal11ants made In eupporl of lhls relj)Onse may be used by Iha Counly es a balls l0t rcfecllon rescfuloltI of tho ew1rd or 1ermtnaU0lt1 ol lhbull conllllCI and may elao urve 11 lho basis for dabarmenl of Vondor pursuanl lo Secllon 21 119 of he erowald COUlly CiProcurement Code

~ N ii

00

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 aOWllrp Commficumlref Bid PNC2116615B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Pompano Beach FL

Contact Name Mr A Randolph Brown Title Utilities Director Reference date April 30 2018

Contact Email randolphbrowncopbflcom Contact Phone 954-545-7043

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 201 o Project Amount fees varied

Multiple

Vendors role in Project IKJ Prime Vendor

to 2018

osubconsultanUSubcontractor

(range $10000shy$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D ~ D D c Deliverables D ~ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D ~ D D b Professionalism D D ~ D C Turnover D El DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ 0 b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D [BJ D n c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [XJ o ~

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed) amp~~it -THIS SECTION ~COUNTY USE ONL y-bullbull

Verified via ~AIL __VERBAL Verified by 1lt4 )~ Division N WE O Date 5 faol Z1 18

All lnformotlon providod to BltownrltI Cou nty it aubjoct O verification VendOr acknowledges that lnaccornto untruthful or incorroct 11atomon1s made in support of this response may be used by tho

411p~~)~~J rojoclion roscissioo ol lho award or 1orroinalion of tho contract and roay also s01vo as lhbull basis f0lt d~arroont of VondOf pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward Cou)l1

Bid Sync p 73

40

5232018

Broward County Board of Bid PNC2116659B 1 County Commissioners

B~aWARD gt1- t COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Loxahatchee River Environmental Control District

Contact Name Mr Kris Dean Title Director of Engineering Reference date May 9 2018

Contact Email krisdeanloxahatcheeriverorg Contact Phone 561-747-5700

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 2001 Project Amount fees varied (range $10000shyMultiple to 2018 $250000)

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IR)Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D ~ D D b Accuracy D 0 D D c Deliverables D IBJ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D IB] D D b Professionalism D ~ D D c Turnover D [8J D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D [8J D D b Deliverables D m D D

4 Project completed within budget D ~ D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D ~ D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D Ii] D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D ~ D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SE~ FOR~USE ONLY

Verified via _lEMAIL __VERBAL Verified by ~lt Division fWeb Date I

All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untrulhful or incorrecl slatements made In support of this response may be used by the lJl~~~l~~jSfiir rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and mll~~~ere as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Co)f 10

Broward County Board of Bid PNC21166$9B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A l

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Lake Worth FL

Contact Name Mr Felipe Lofaso TitleAsst Dir Public-ServicesReference date May 9 2018

Contact Email flofasolakeworthorg Contact Phone 561-586-1720

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contract

Contract No Date Services Provided 2014 Project Amount fees varied Multiple to 2018 (range $10000shy

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Services included multiple municipal engineering projects including survey roadway design utility design and coordination (water wastewater stormwater other) along with project management

Needs Satisfactory Excellent NotPlease rate your experience with the Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D GJ D b Accuracy D D Ii] D c Deliverables D Ii] DD

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [i] D c Turnover D D D [X]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D 0 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [X] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION Fe COUNTY USE ONLrbullbull

Verified via MAIL __VERBAL Verified by Division ~wgtgt Date 5~3ol20t8 All information provided to Broward County Is subject lo verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect slalements made in support ol this response may be used by the

OZ~id~~~~j~r rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and m~~~(iirve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Cour~ iG

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - ARCADIS US INC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts

VS0000013130 VS00013130 - ARCADIS US INC Prime Work Auth Vendor SummaryProjects

PURCHASING 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold Procurement No Fixed Contracts FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Favorites Past 5 Years Prime Vendor

Sub Vendor From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 10042017 Purchase Order

Evaluation Purchase Orders 1 POs With A Total Amt Of $20000000 Log Off Paid To Dt ($12132949) Balance $7867051

Contracts Purchase Orders Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx 6192018

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Finish

PURCHASING Weighted Scores Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract FileRoom DashBoard Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number FileRoom Insert

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel Favorites Prime Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Service Evaluation

6132017 YES 486 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Goals Compliance Evaluation

10272016 YES 460 View Docs (0)

6272018

Project Management Information System

Close

Contracts Central Administration

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9130 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-24

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6182018 YES 355 View Docs (1)

Proj Nbr 9320 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-20

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6132018 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9290 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-23

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1122018 YES 494 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-21

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12182017 YES 488 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10162017 YES 473 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

8252017 YES 495 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9321 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-19

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

7112017 YES 476 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-17

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2272017 YES 400 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

10132016 YES 384 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-12

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

5202016 YES 405 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9018 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-06

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10192015 YES 448 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

3202015 YES 385 View Docs (0)

Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL CONSULTANTS

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Project Management Information System

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-04

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12122014 YES 437 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-08

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1242014 YES 423 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-02

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2282014 YES 452 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC

VC0000044184 VC00044184 - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres PS $001 Used $000 Remain $001 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $354848400 Closed 0 Total $000 Total Current Retainage Balance For All Contracts $793370 No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 06292015 Purchase Orders 2 POs With A Total Amt Of $362317900 Paid To Dt ($218795160) Balance $143522740

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 40803 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9058 - DISTRICT 3A POTABLE WATER STORAGE

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1220410P1 - Consultant Engineering Services for Potable Water FixedOpen Contracts Storage Tanks and Pumping Systems Work Auth Prime Vendor CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Periodic Final Finish

Log Off Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type

Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

6232015 8302017 413 Approved 8312017 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard

Enter Vendor Name (or a portion of) Then Click Search - Wilcards Are Permitted (ie wa wawainc) Florida Technical Consultants

Search Reset Finish

No Vendors Found For Your Search Try Again

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41005 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score Go

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0773

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

12122017 YES 430 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

8302016 YES 438 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Final Consultant Evaluation 3142016 YES 478 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0706

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

142016 YES 402 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9016OES - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0731

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

10192015 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0748

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

612015 YES 467 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

2192015 YES 500 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0754

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

252015 YES 409 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0755

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

1242014 YES 415 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8974 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0758

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

6202014 YES 393 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr

WATER amp WASTEWATER

Final Consultant Work Authorization 572014 YES 423 View Docs

(0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

HS0746 ENGINEERING Evaluation

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

4302014 YES 475 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Evaluation 4302014 YES 493 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0710

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

3172014 YES 395 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0753

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

1212014 YES 380 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0763

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

11192013 YES 450 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0775

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 408 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals

Finish

Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed FileRoom DashBoard Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization FileRoom Insert NumberFavorites

Prime Vendor Export To Excel Sub Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0772

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 417 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0771

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

2262013 YES 410 View Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 23: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

BftQNARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

I l 0 R I 0 A

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Reference for Florida Technical Consultants

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

VIiiage of Wellington Utilities

Contact Name Bradley Wolak Title Assistant Director Ut11Reference date 5182018

Contact Email bwolakwelllngtonflgov Contact Phone 561-753-2480

Name of Referenced Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 10012017 to Present 3500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vend~ 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again UZfYes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor J_ rJ fJ j(Gr-~k 6 Jti ov1 ~uf-Jiy fgt-r_- syrrzi~ff~ Al

R Q_ d--1 0~l 4 171 i+CI ~~lHI )Please rate your experience with tile Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Applicablereferenced Vendor Improvement

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy B D

DD c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D Db Professionalism D D

c Turnover D DD 3 Timeliness of

a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant(s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Additional Comments (provide on addltjpnal sheetJf needed) bull ~middot$ -JJ fo~~rltjbull lt( c-c_ ~~~ lt fo L1-lfAR- -middot~ I 10 ~ ~

~ bullL ~~ _te_ l~Ilgt~Cef t J ~ l rfbull4 middot r0 laquo r 4111J w f1 rrr- 0r- -i-HIS SECTION(9R COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by fcAJc ~ Division Y-1 IN ED Date 5 ~o w8 All lnfonn1Uon ptollfded to BlOward County le eubjeet to vetfflcatlon Vendor aclltnowledge1 that lneccurale unllJlhfUl or lnconect -bullmenla made In 1UPPort o1 this reopon90 may be uoec1 by the couniy ae a baalS ror re)ectlon re8Claeton Of the award 0t leltmlnatlon Of the contract and may 1l10 MM ae the baale flaquo debarrnont 01 vendor pu11uant to Section 21119 of ll1e Broward County Procurement Codo

BidSync p 18 5232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F LUFltIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultants LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Palm Beach Public Works

Contact Name Gerry Vazquez Title WRD Technician Reference date 05182018

Contact Email gvazqueztownofpalmbeachcom Contact Phone 772-546-6859

Name of Referenced Project GIS Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 3242014 to Present 13500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [3yenes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

PrwAamprs- favl49z Please rate your experience with the Need a Satlafactory Excellent Not

Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D g- D b Accuracy D Er D c Deliverables g-shyB D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D GJ D b Professionalism D D G- D c Tu mover D D cg- D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D g D b Deliverables D D Qshy D

4 Project completed within budget D D lbJ- D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D El- Db Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [3- D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

BidSync p 17 51232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

120-nWARDLll~ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form fLORllgtA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultant LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Waneya Bryant Title Meter Serv Mgr Reference date 05182018

Contact Email BryantWbbflus Contact Phone 561-742-6427

Name of Referenced Project Boynton Beach Utility GIS Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 12012016 to Present $15000000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

~T~ 5e-r-vtleamp +roM l)h f-es Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D Dc Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ti4 D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ Db Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on addlUonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION~urv USE ONLy u bull

Verified via VEMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by kuJ~ Division W if E D rao(ao8Date 5

All Information provided to Browslaquo COOlty Is Slbject to verfflcation Vendor acKnowledges that lneocurate Untruthful or lncolleel 8tatements made In support d this rfl9pOn98 may be used by 1119 Counly as a batia falt rejection relduion ct Ille award or lemilnlilon of the contract and may al80181Veaa1119 basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 ot Ille Broward CountyProcurement Code

512312018 BidSync p 16

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1

8W1V~isl1War Bid PNC21 15559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Fonn

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Cooper City - middot

Contact Name Michael Bailey PE itle Utilities DlrCity EbullReference date 05011201s

Contact Email MBalleycoopercityflorg Contact Phone (954) 434-5519

Name of Referenced Project City of Cooper City Continuing Professional Services bullContract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

RFQ 2009middot 1 04242009 to Present $ 2 19844200

Vendors role in Project IZJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Since 2009 Hazen has provided Cooper City with engineering services or water and wastewater projects Projects have lnctudeo lhe Pine Island Road Pump Station Lilt S1alions 2 amp 49 Improvements Master Plan Update of the FeaslJl~lty Review of Infrastructure Improvements tor Wastewater and the Eflluent Reuse and Disposal Master Plan

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy 8 D

D ~ D c Deliverables D 0 ~ D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D 0 D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tumover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D GJ- D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D 0 D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) ~D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

bull-rHIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY-

Verified vie EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ct4~ Division ~tUb Date ~ i3~) 0fgt All Information provided to BltCgtWW County 11 wbed ID vamprificalion Velldot adltnowledgu that lnaoewate unlrUhful lncom1ct statemampnla made in wppolt of 11111 response may blt uHd by the

4t2j=~ rejection rHclsslcn of th8 award or lennhallon of Ille eoo1nlct and may also seNamp at tilt basis for dtbarmenl at Vendor puuan1 lo Sectioo 21119 of the Broward COltJi 43

5232018 Bid Sync p24

Broward County Board of PNC211 5559P1

~RiiirilyenlcHUffi~~8CrW~r Bid PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

8DdMARD _ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FL O RIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Fort Lauderdale

Contact Name Rares Patrica PE Title Senior Project Mgr Reference date os1021201s

Contact Email RPetricafortlauderdalegov Contact Phone 9548287150

Name of Referenced Project Stormwater Master Planning and Design Implementation Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

256-11660 04192016 to 04192021 $ 989400000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

vyould you use this vendor again Sves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor The Hazen team Is responsible for delivery of a new stormwaler master plan model a prlorlllzed slormwaterresllency capital Improvements plan and Implementation of designs to address chronic flooding and other slormwater management challenges In the City Primary work tasks Include data collectlon hydrologlclhydraullc modeling and design permitting and construction services for capllal Improvement projects resulting from the revised stormwater master plan (preltmlnary design In seven priority neighborhoods)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION ~R COUNTY USE ONLY

aJ~Verified via pound MA IL _VERBAL Verified by Division W1~tl Date 5 ~3o~ax l S N I informallon p roviltled lo Broward County is sulljecl lo verification Vendor altknowledjj6s lhal inaccurate unlMhlut or lncotreci statements m ade In support of this respon$e may be used by tho

412~-~ rejeclion rescission of the award or termination ol lhe contracl and may also serve as lhe basis for debalment ol Vendor purwant to Section 21119 ol lhe Broward Cou~ 4 3

5232018 Bid Sync p25

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 Br~~~~~rs Bid PNC2115559P1 County t ommissioners

B~uWARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FlOR I CA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

Solicitation PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and s OrganizationFirm Name p

Town of Jupiter

nee

Contact Email davidbjupiterflus Contact Phone (561) 746-5134

Name of Referenced Project Engineering Services for Stormwater and Water Capital Improvements

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount $ 630000000 W17248 (2017 reselection 1012000 to Present (estimated lee-to-date since contract inception) contract number)

Vendors role in Project IZI Prime Vendor osubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again 0Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Descriotion of services orovided bv Vendor Since 2000 Hazen has served as General Consulfant to the Town or Jupiter As General Stormwater and Water Consullant the firm has provided services related to master planning stormwater planning and modeling design NPDES permilling asset management resiliency ratefinancial analysis plan review and construction oversight Water-related capital projs have involved additional system storage and high-service pumping transmission system improvements and RampR at existing facilities

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Verllied via EMAIL _ VERBAL Division WWC D

fo (J-Vv ~ltIvmiddotj Date 5(30(ipf S

Al lnroimallon pngtYICGd 10 Broward Counly Is sub)oel to v8flrcallon vendlaquo acknowledges lhat Inaccurate unlruthlu~ 0t Jnwrrect slatoments made In support ol this response may be used by the 42~~1~0 rojecllon rescission or Ille award or termination or lhe con~acl bullnd mbully also serve as tho basis r0t debarment of Vendor pursuant lo Socllon 21119 of lho Broward Couw 41

5232018 BidSync p 26

a N ~ IL) IL) N u z a_

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLO RI DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Walter Wernecke RA Title Sr Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email WWERNECKEhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Hollywood Marina Restrooms

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

04152015 to Present 7500000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor OSubconsultanVSubcontractor n ~U t1

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

-0 Vgt Description of services provided by VendorO ~ ~ Q) Structural Design and Construction Inspection Services i co Q m ~- c E c0

i E gt Oo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not () uu Appllcable O

E~ referenced Vendor Improvement iii ~sectoO 1 Vendors Quality of Service B mu a Responsive D D

b Accuracy DD c Deliverables D DD

2 Vendors Organization D Da Staff expertise v D b Professionalism~ D D c Turnover D ~D

3 Timeliness of D a Project b Deliverables D ~

4 Pec~~11~$~hinJ~~qt lfr D D 5 Cooperation with f ~

a Your Firm D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D

Al lnfonn1tion pRgttded IO Brwd Cltgtunly lo 1ubjecl IO ibllon vsor ~middot Iha icl-bullmiddot ~ ir-ect slalemenls mode In _ol lhb _ moy ti used by he County as a basis lot rejecUon rnclnlon cl the eward or tonnlnallan of lhl connct 1nd may bullllo 11 the basis for dobalment of Vendor IQtulnl IO SICllOn 21119 at lhe Broword County Procurement Code

Cl ltraquo I() I() I() N ()

Cl z

BRltJWARD ~ middot COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORl OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Davie

Contact Name Emilio DeSimone Title Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email Emilio_DeSimonedavie-fl gov Contact Phone 954-797-1085

Name of Referenced Project Pavillion 5 Linear Park

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

B-17-123 09152015 to 2700000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor O SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es O No If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

0 Description of services provided by Vendor O Q)

iii c Structural Design and Construction Inspection ServicesoQ

CDi-

0cc E gt=gt E ()Oo O () () Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

ii) -e i- Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 111 cs

B ioO

J 1 Vendors Quality of Service Q ()

a Responsive D D b Accuracy D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization []Ll Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D Dtr

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [g D b Deliverables D D ar D

4 Project completed within budget [1tD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) cgD D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via l EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by ~h~ Division WlI Etgt Date 0 f l~o I 8 All lnformaUon provided lO Broward County Is eubJect 10 verifutlon Vendor ecknOMedgoo that lnaocurote unNlhlul or Incorrect statamenle made In aupl)Ort of this reaponse may be used by lho County et o baampla for rejection realtluion of the award or lermlnallon of tho eon1fllcl ond moy olao aorvo os ho basis for debarmont of Vondor purauenl lo Section 21119 of the Broward Counly Procuremen1 Code

0 0 agt a c () z 0

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Terrence Comiskey AIA Title Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email TCOMISKEYhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Van Buren Parking Garage

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PK 14-053 Nov 2014 to Present 8310000

Vendors role in Project t8(Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

o~ Description of services provided by Vendor 1 Q)ltO c Structural Design and Conslructlon Inspection Services 0 Q

0~Jl ccE l E enOo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

gtshy

uu O Improvement Applicable ffireferenced Vendor

~sect 1 Vendors Quality of Service 1 ~

oOau a Responsive D ~ D b Accuracy B D D

D D [- Dc Deliverables

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tum over D D D g

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ D Subcontractor(s )S ubcons u ltant( s)b D D ~ D

c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D yenj D Additional Comments provide on sdditlonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION ~NTY USE ONLY0

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by kW Division W-1-(i~ Date EJo(a~t8 Al lnform1Uon PltOVlded lo Browald Ccxnty It IUbjoct to vorificallon Vendor eoknowfodgea thal lnaewralt U111MhlJI deg inlaquogtlaquobullel amptal11ants made In eupporl of lhls relj)Onse may be used by Iha Counly es a balls l0t rcfecllon rescfuloltI of tho ew1rd or 1ermtnaU0lt1 ol lhbull conllllCI and may elao urve 11 lho basis for dabarmenl of Vondor pursuanl lo Secllon 21 119 of he erowald COUlly CiProcurement Code

~ N ii

00

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 aOWllrp Commficumlref Bid PNC2116615B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Pompano Beach FL

Contact Name Mr A Randolph Brown Title Utilities Director Reference date April 30 2018

Contact Email randolphbrowncopbflcom Contact Phone 954-545-7043

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 201 o Project Amount fees varied

Multiple

Vendors role in Project IKJ Prime Vendor

to 2018

osubconsultanUSubcontractor

(range $10000shy$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D ~ D D c Deliverables D ~ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D ~ D D b Professionalism D D ~ D C Turnover D El DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ 0 b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D [BJ D n c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [XJ o ~

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed) amp~~it -THIS SECTION ~COUNTY USE ONL y-bullbull

Verified via ~AIL __VERBAL Verified by 1lt4 )~ Division N WE O Date 5 faol Z1 18

All lnformotlon providod to BltownrltI Cou nty it aubjoct O verification VendOr acknowledges that lnaccornto untruthful or incorroct 11atomon1s made in support of this response may be used by tho

411p~~)~~J rojoclion roscissioo ol lho award or 1orroinalion of tho contract and roay also s01vo as lhbull basis f0lt d~arroont of VondOf pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward Cou)l1

Bid Sync p 73

40

5232018

Broward County Board of Bid PNC2116659B 1 County Commissioners

B~aWARD gt1- t COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Loxahatchee River Environmental Control District

Contact Name Mr Kris Dean Title Director of Engineering Reference date May 9 2018

Contact Email krisdeanloxahatcheeriverorg Contact Phone 561-747-5700

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 2001 Project Amount fees varied (range $10000shyMultiple to 2018 $250000)

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IR)Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D ~ D D b Accuracy D 0 D D c Deliverables D IBJ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D IB] D D b Professionalism D ~ D D c Turnover D [8J D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D [8J D D b Deliverables D m D D

4 Project completed within budget D ~ D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D ~ D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D Ii] D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D ~ D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SE~ FOR~USE ONLY

Verified via _lEMAIL __VERBAL Verified by ~lt Division fWeb Date I

All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untrulhful or incorrecl slatements made In support of this response may be used by the lJl~~~l~~jSfiir rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and mll~~~ere as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Co)f 10

Broward County Board of Bid PNC21166$9B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A l

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Lake Worth FL

Contact Name Mr Felipe Lofaso TitleAsst Dir Public-ServicesReference date May 9 2018

Contact Email flofasolakeworthorg Contact Phone 561-586-1720

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contract

Contract No Date Services Provided 2014 Project Amount fees varied Multiple to 2018 (range $10000shy

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Services included multiple municipal engineering projects including survey roadway design utility design and coordination (water wastewater stormwater other) along with project management

Needs Satisfactory Excellent NotPlease rate your experience with the Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D GJ D b Accuracy D D Ii] D c Deliverables D Ii] DD

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [i] D c Turnover D D D [X]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D 0 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [X] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION Fe COUNTY USE ONLrbullbull

Verified via MAIL __VERBAL Verified by Division ~wgtgt Date 5~3ol20t8 All information provided to Broward County Is subject lo verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect slalements made in support ol this response may be used by the

OZ~id~~~~j~r rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and m~~~(iirve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Cour~ iG

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - ARCADIS US INC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts

VS0000013130 VS00013130 - ARCADIS US INC Prime Work Auth Vendor SummaryProjects

PURCHASING 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold Procurement No Fixed Contracts FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Favorites Past 5 Years Prime Vendor

Sub Vendor From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 10042017 Purchase Order

Evaluation Purchase Orders 1 POs With A Total Amt Of $20000000 Log Off Paid To Dt ($12132949) Balance $7867051

Contracts Purchase Orders Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx 6192018

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Finish

PURCHASING Weighted Scores Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract FileRoom DashBoard Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number FileRoom Insert

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel Favorites Prime Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Service Evaluation

6132017 YES 486 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Goals Compliance Evaluation

10272016 YES 460 View Docs (0)

6272018

Project Management Information System

Close

Contracts Central Administration

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9130 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-24

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6182018 YES 355 View Docs (1)

Proj Nbr 9320 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-20

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6132018 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9290 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-23

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1122018 YES 494 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-21

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12182017 YES 488 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10162017 YES 473 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

8252017 YES 495 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9321 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-19

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

7112017 YES 476 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-17

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2272017 YES 400 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

10132016 YES 384 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-12

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

5202016 YES 405 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9018 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-06

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10192015 YES 448 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

3202015 YES 385 View Docs (0)

Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL CONSULTANTS

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Project Management Information System

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-04

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12122014 YES 437 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-08

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1242014 YES 423 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-02

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2282014 YES 452 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC

VC0000044184 VC00044184 - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres PS $001 Used $000 Remain $001 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $354848400 Closed 0 Total $000 Total Current Retainage Balance For All Contracts $793370 No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 06292015 Purchase Orders 2 POs With A Total Amt Of $362317900 Paid To Dt ($218795160) Balance $143522740

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 40803 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9058 - DISTRICT 3A POTABLE WATER STORAGE

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1220410P1 - Consultant Engineering Services for Potable Water FixedOpen Contracts Storage Tanks and Pumping Systems Work Auth Prime Vendor CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Periodic Final Finish

Log Off Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type

Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

6232015 8302017 413 Approved 8312017 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard

Enter Vendor Name (or a portion of) Then Click Search - Wilcards Are Permitted (ie wa wawainc) Florida Technical Consultants

Search Reset Finish

No Vendors Found For Your Search Try Again

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41005 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score Go

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0773

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

12122017 YES 430 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

8302016 YES 438 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Final Consultant Evaluation 3142016 YES 478 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0706

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

142016 YES 402 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9016OES - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0731

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

10192015 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0748

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

612015 YES 467 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

2192015 YES 500 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0754

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

252015 YES 409 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0755

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

1242014 YES 415 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8974 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0758

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

6202014 YES 393 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr

WATER amp WASTEWATER

Final Consultant Work Authorization 572014 YES 423 View Docs

(0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

HS0746 ENGINEERING Evaluation

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

4302014 YES 475 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Evaluation 4302014 YES 493 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0710

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

3172014 YES 395 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0753

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

1212014 YES 380 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0763

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

11192013 YES 450 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0775

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 408 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals

Finish

Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed FileRoom DashBoard Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization FileRoom Insert NumberFavorites

Prime Vendor Export To Excel Sub Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0772

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 417 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0771

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

2262013 YES 410 View Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 24: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F LUFltIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultants LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Palm Beach Public Works

Contact Name Gerry Vazquez Title WRD Technician Reference date 05182018

Contact Email gvazqueztownofpalmbeachcom Contact Phone 772-546-6859

Name of Referenced Project GIS Project

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 3242014 to Present 13500000

Vendors role in Project []Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again [3yenes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

PrwAamprs- favl49z Please rate your experience with the Need a Satlafactory Excellent Not

Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D g- D b Accuracy D Er D c Deliverables g-shyB D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D GJ D b Professionalism D D G- D c Tu mover D D cg- D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D g D b Deliverables D D Qshy D

4 Project completed within budget D D lbJ- D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D El- Db Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [3- D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

BidSync p 17 51232018

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

120-nWARDLll~ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form fLORllgtA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultant LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Waneya Bryant Title Meter Serv Mgr Reference date 05182018

Contact Email BryantWbbflus Contact Phone 561-742-6427

Name of Referenced Project Boynton Beach Utility GIS Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 12012016 to Present $15000000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

~T~ 5e-r-vtleamp +roM l)h f-es Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D Dc Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ti4 D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ Db Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on addlUonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION~urv USE ONLy u bull

Verified via VEMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by kuJ~ Division W if E D rao(ao8Date 5

All Information provided to Browslaquo COOlty Is Slbject to verfflcation Vendor acKnowledges that lneocurate Untruthful or lncolleel 8tatements made In support d this rfl9pOn98 may be used by 1119 Counly as a batia falt rejection relduion ct Ille award or lemilnlilon of the contract and may al80181Veaa1119 basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 ot Ille Broward CountyProcurement Code

512312018 BidSync p 16

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1

8W1V~isl1War Bid PNC21 15559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Fonn

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Cooper City - middot

Contact Name Michael Bailey PE itle Utilities DlrCity EbullReference date 05011201s

Contact Email MBalleycoopercityflorg Contact Phone (954) 434-5519

Name of Referenced Project City of Cooper City Continuing Professional Services bullContract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

RFQ 2009middot 1 04242009 to Present $ 2 19844200

Vendors role in Project IZJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Since 2009 Hazen has provided Cooper City with engineering services or water and wastewater projects Projects have lnctudeo lhe Pine Island Road Pump Station Lilt S1alions 2 amp 49 Improvements Master Plan Update of the FeaslJl~lty Review of Infrastructure Improvements tor Wastewater and the Eflluent Reuse and Disposal Master Plan

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy 8 D

D ~ D c Deliverables D 0 ~ D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D 0 D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tumover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D GJ- D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D 0 D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) ~D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

bull-rHIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY-

Verified vie EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ct4~ Division ~tUb Date ~ i3~) 0fgt All Information provided to BltCgtWW County 11 wbed ID vamprificalion Velldot adltnowledgu that lnaoewate unlrUhful lncom1ct statemampnla made in wppolt of 11111 response may blt uHd by the

4t2j=~ rejection rHclsslcn of th8 award or lennhallon of Ille eoo1nlct and may also seNamp at tilt basis for dtbarmenl at Vendor puuan1 lo Sectioo 21119 of the Broward COltJi 43

5232018 Bid Sync p24

Broward County Board of PNC211 5559P1

~RiiirilyenlcHUffi~~8CrW~r Bid PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

8DdMARD _ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FL O RIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Fort Lauderdale

Contact Name Rares Patrica PE Title Senior Project Mgr Reference date os1021201s

Contact Email RPetricafortlauderdalegov Contact Phone 9548287150

Name of Referenced Project Stormwater Master Planning and Design Implementation Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

256-11660 04192016 to 04192021 $ 989400000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

vyould you use this vendor again Sves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor The Hazen team Is responsible for delivery of a new stormwaler master plan model a prlorlllzed slormwaterresllency capital Improvements plan and Implementation of designs to address chronic flooding and other slormwater management challenges In the City Primary work tasks Include data collectlon hydrologlclhydraullc modeling and design permitting and construction services for capllal Improvement projects resulting from the revised stormwater master plan (preltmlnary design In seven priority neighborhoods)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION ~R COUNTY USE ONLY

aJ~Verified via pound MA IL _VERBAL Verified by Division W1~tl Date 5 ~3o~ax l S N I informallon p roviltled lo Broward County is sulljecl lo verification Vendor altknowledjj6s lhal inaccurate unlMhlut or lncotreci statements m ade In support of this respon$e may be used by tho

412~-~ rejeclion rescission of the award or termination ol lhe contracl and may also serve as lhe basis for debalment ol Vendor purwant to Section 21119 ol lhe Broward Cou~ 4 3

5232018 Bid Sync p25

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 Br~~~~~rs Bid PNC2115559P1 County t ommissioners

B~uWARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FlOR I CA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

Solicitation PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and s OrganizationFirm Name p

Town of Jupiter

nee

Contact Email davidbjupiterflus Contact Phone (561) 746-5134

Name of Referenced Project Engineering Services for Stormwater and Water Capital Improvements

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount $ 630000000 W17248 (2017 reselection 1012000 to Present (estimated lee-to-date since contract inception) contract number)

Vendors role in Project IZI Prime Vendor osubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again 0Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Descriotion of services orovided bv Vendor Since 2000 Hazen has served as General Consulfant to the Town or Jupiter As General Stormwater and Water Consullant the firm has provided services related to master planning stormwater planning and modeling design NPDES permilling asset management resiliency ratefinancial analysis plan review and construction oversight Water-related capital projs have involved additional system storage and high-service pumping transmission system improvements and RampR at existing facilities

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Verllied via EMAIL _ VERBAL Division WWC D

fo (J-Vv ~ltIvmiddotj Date 5(30(ipf S

Al lnroimallon pngtYICGd 10 Broward Counly Is sub)oel to v8flrcallon vendlaquo acknowledges lhat Inaccurate unlruthlu~ 0t Jnwrrect slatoments made In support ol this response may be used by the 42~~1~0 rojecllon rescission or Ille award or termination or lhe con~acl bullnd mbully also serve as tho basis r0t debarment of Vendor pursuant lo Socllon 21119 of lho Broward Couw 41

5232018 BidSync p 26

a N ~ IL) IL) N u z a_

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLO RI DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Walter Wernecke RA Title Sr Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email WWERNECKEhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Hollywood Marina Restrooms

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

04152015 to Present 7500000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor OSubconsultanVSubcontractor n ~U t1

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

-0 Vgt Description of services provided by VendorO ~ ~ Q) Structural Design and Construction Inspection Services i co Q m ~- c E c0

i E gt Oo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not () uu Appllcable O

E~ referenced Vendor Improvement iii ~sectoO 1 Vendors Quality of Service B mu a Responsive D D

b Accuracy DD c Deliverables D DD

2 Vendors Organization D Da Staff expertise v D b Professionalism~ D D c Turnover D ~D

3 Timeliness of D a Project b Deliverables D ~

4 Pec~~11~$~hinJ~~qt lfr D D 5 Cooperation with f ~

a Your Firm D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D

Al lnfonn1tion pRgttded IO Brwd Cltgtunly lo 1ubjecl IO ibllon vsor ~middot Iha icl-bullmiddot ~ ir-ect slalemenls mode In _ol lhb _ moy ti used by he County as a basis lot rejecUon rnclnlon cl the eward or tonnlnallan of lhl connct 1nd may bullllo 11 the basis for dobalment of Vendor IQtulnl IO SICllOn 21119 at lhe Broword County Procurement Code

Cl ltraquo I() I() I() N ()

Cl z

BRltJWARD ~ middot COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORl OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Davie

Contact Name Emilio DeSimone Title Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email Emilio_DeSimonedavie-fl gov Contact Phone 954-797-1085

Name of Referenced Project Pavillion 5 Linear Park

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

B-17-123 09152015 to 2700000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor O SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es O No If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

0 Description of services provided by Vendor O Q)

iii c Structural Design and Construction Inspection ServicesoQ

CDi-

0cc E gt=gt E ()Oo O () () Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

ii) -e i- Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 111 cs

B ioO

J 1 Vendors Quality of Service Q ()

a Responsive D D b Accuracy D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization []Ll Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D Dtr

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [g D b Deliverables D D ar D

4 Project completed within budget [1tD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) cgD D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via l EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by ~h~ Division WlI Etgt Date 0 f l~o I 8 All lnformaUon provided lO Broward County Is eubJect 10 verifutlon Vendor ecknOMedgoo that lnaocurote unNlhlul or Incorrect statamenle made In aupl)Ort of this reaponse may be used by lho County et o baampla for rejection realtluion of the award or lermlnallon of tho eon1fllcl ond moy olao aorvo os ho basis for debarmont of Vondor purauenl lo Section 21119 of the Broward Counly Procuremen1 Code

0 0 agt a c () z 0

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Terrence Comiskey AIA Title Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email TCOMISKEYhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Van Buren Parking Garage

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PK 14-053 Nov 2014 to Present 8310000

Vendors role in Project t8(Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

o~ Description of services provided by Vendor 1 Q)ltO c Structural Design and Conslructlon Inspection Services 0 Q

0~Jl ccE l E enOo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

gtshy

uu O Improvement Applicable ffireferenced Vendor

~sect 1 Vendors Quality of Service 1 ~

oOau a Responsive D ~ D b Accuracy B D D

D D [- Dc Deliverables

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tum over D D D g

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ D Subcontractor(s )S ubcons u ltant( s)b D D ~ D

c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D yenj D Additional Comments provide on sdditlonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION ~NTY USE ONLY0

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by kW Division W-1-(i~ Date EJo(a~t8 Al lnform1Uon PltOVlded lo Browald Ccxnty It IUbjoct to vorificallon Vendor eoknowfodgea thal lnaewralt U111MhlJI deg inlaquogtlaquobullel amptal11ants made In eupporl of lhls relj)Onse may be used by Iha Counly es a balls l0t rcfecllon rescfuloltI of tho ew1rd or 1ermtnaU0lt1 ol lhbull conllllCI and may elao urve 11 lho basis for dabarmenl of Vondor pursuanl lo Secllon 21 119 of he erowald COUlly CiProcurement Code

~ N ii

00

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 aOWllrp Commficumlref Bid PNC2116615B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Pompano Beach FL

Contact Name Mr A Randolph Brown Title Utilities Director Reference date April 30 2018

Contact Email randolphbrowncopbflcom Contact Phone 954-545-7043

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 201 o Project Amount fees varied

Multiple

Vendors role in Project IKJ Prime Vendor

to 2018

osubconsultanUSubcontractor

(range $10000shy$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D ~ D D c Deliverables D ~ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D ~ D D b Professionalism D D ~ D C Turnover D El DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ 0 b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D [BJ D n c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [XJ o ~

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed) amp~~it -THIS SECTION ~COUNTY USE ONL y-bullbull

Verified via ~AIL __VERBAL Verified by 1lt4 )~ Division N WE O Date 5 faol Z1 18

All lnformotlon providod to BltownrltI Cou nty it aubjoct O verification VendOr acknowledges that lnaccornto untruthful or incorroct 11atomon1s made in support of this response may be used by tho

411p~~)~~J rojoclion roscissioo ol lho award or 1orroinalion of tho contract and roay also s01vo as lhbull basis f0lt d~arroont of VondOf pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward Cou)l1

Bid Sync p 73

40

5232018

Broward County Board of Bid PNC2116659B 1 County Commissioners

B~aWARD gt1- t COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Loxahatchee River Environmental Control District

Contact Name Mr Kris Dean Title Director of Engineering Reference date May 9 2018

Contact Email krisdeanloxahatcheeriverorg Contact Phone 561-747-5700

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 2001 Project Amount fees varied (range $10000shyMultiple to 2018 $250000)

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IR)Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D ~ D D b Accuracy D 0 D D c Deliverables D IBJ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D IB] D D b Professionalism D ~ D D c Turnover D [8J D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D [8J D D b Deliverables D m D D

4 Project completed within budget D ~ D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D ~ D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D Ii] D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D ~ D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SE~ FOR~USE ONLY

Verified via _lEMAIL __VERBAL Verified by ~lt Division fWeb Date I

All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untrulhful or incorrecl slatements made In support of this response may be used by the lJl~~~l~~jSfiir rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and mll~~~ere as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Co)f 10

Broward County Board of Bid PNC21166$9B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A l

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Lake Worth FL

Contact Name Mr Felipe Lofaso TitleAsst Dir Public-ServicesReference date May 9 2018

Contact Email flofasolakeworthorg Contact Phone 561-586-1720

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contract

Contract No Date Services Provided 2014 Project Amount fees varied Multiple to 2018 (range $10000shy

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Services included multiple municipal engineering projects including survey roadway design utility design and coordination (water wastewater stormwater other) along with project management

Needs Satisfactory Excellent NotPlease rate your experience with the Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D GJ D b Accuracy D D Ii] D c Deliverables D Ii] DD

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [i] D c Turnover D D D [X]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D 0 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [X] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION Fe COUNTY USE ONLrbullbull

Verified via MAIL __VERBAL Verified by Division ~wgtgt Date 5~3ol20t8 All information provided to Broward County Is subject lo verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect slalements made in support ol this response may be used by the

OZ~id~~~~j~r rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and m~~~(iirve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Cour~ iG

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - ARCADIS US INC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts

VS0000013130 VS00013130 - ARCADIS US INC Prime Work Auth Vendor SummaryProjects

PURCHASING 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold Procurement No Fixed Contracts FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Favorites Past 5 Years Prime Vendor

Sub Vendor From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 10042017 Purchase Order

Evaluation Purchase Orders 1 POs With A Total Amt Of $20000000 Log Off Paid To Dt ($12132949) Balance $7867051

Contracts Purchase Orders Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx 6192018

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Finish

PURCHASING Weighted Scores Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract FileRoom DashBoard Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number FileRoom Insert

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel Favorites Prime Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Service Evaluation

6132017 YES 486 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Goals Compliance Evaluation

10272016 YES 460 View Docs (0)

6272018

Project Management Information System

Close

Contracts Central Administration

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9130 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-24

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6182018 YES 355 View Docs (1)

Proj Nbr 9320 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-20

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6132018 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9290 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-23

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1122018 YES 494 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-21

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12182017 YES 488 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10162017 YES 473 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

8252017 YES 495 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9321 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-19

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

7112017 YES 476 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-17

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2272017 YES 400 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

10132016 YES 384 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-12

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

5202016 YES 405 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9018 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-06

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10192015 YES 448 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

3202015 YES 385 View Docs (0)

Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL CONSULTANTS

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Project Management Information System

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-04

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12122014 YES 437 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-08

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1242014 YES 423 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-02

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2282014 YES 452 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC

VC0000044184 VC00044184 - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres PS $001 Used $000 Remain $001 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $354848400 Closed 0 Total $000 Total Current Retainage Balance For All Contracts $793370 No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 06292015 Purchase Orders 2 POs With A Total Amt Of $362317900 Paid To Dt ($218795160) Balance $143522740

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 40803 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9058 - DISTRICT 3A POTABLE WATER STORAGE

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1220410P1 - Consultant Engineering Services for Potable Water FixedOpen Contracts Storage Tanks and Pumping Systems Work Auth Prime Vendor CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Periodic Final Finish

Log Off Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type

Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

6232015 8302017 413 Approved 8312017 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard

Enter Vendor Name (or a portion of) Then Click Search - Wilcards Are Permitted (ie wa wawainc) Florida Technical Consultants

Search Reset Finish

No Vendors Found For Your Search Try Again

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41005 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score Go

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0773

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

12122017 YES 430 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

8302016 YES 438 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Final Consultant Evaluation 3142016 YES 478 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0706

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

142016 YES 402 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9016OES - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0731

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

10192015 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0748

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

612015 YES 467 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

2192015 YES 500 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0754

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

252015 YES 409 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0755

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

1242014 YES 415 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8974 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0758

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

6202014 YES 393 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr

WATER amp WASTEWATER

Final Consultant Work Authorization 572014 YES 423 View Docs

(0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

HS0746 ENGINEERING Evaluation

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

4302014 YES 475 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Evaluation 4302014 YES 493 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0710

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

3172014 YES 395 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0753

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

1212014 YES 380 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0763

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

11192013 YES 450 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0775

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 408 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals

Finish

Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed FileRoom DashBoard Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization FileRoom Insert NumberFavorites

Prime Vendor Export To Excel Sub Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0772

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 417 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0771

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

2262013 YES 410 View Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 25: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

120-nWARDLll~ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form fLORllgtA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Florida Technical Consultant LLC

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Boynton Beach Utilities

Contact Name Waneya Bryant Title Meter Serv Mgr Reference date 05182018

Contact Email BryantWbbflus Contact Phone 561-742-6427

Name of Referenced Project Boynton Beach Utility GIS Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

Continuing GIS Services 12012016 to Present $15000000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0 SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

~T~ 5e-r-vtleamp +roM l)h f-es Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 1 Vendors Quality of Service

a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D Dc Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ti4 D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ Db Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D Dc Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

AddlUonal Comments (provide on addlUonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION~urv USE ONLy u bull

Verified via VEMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by kuJ~ Division W if E D rao(ao8Date 5

All Information provided to Browslaquo COOlty Is Slbject to verfflcation Vendor acKnowledges that lneocurate Untruthful or lncolleel 8tatements made In support d this rfl9pOn98 may be used by 1119 Counly as a batia falt rejection relduion ct Ille award or lemilnlilon of the contract and may al80181Veaa1119 basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 21 119 ot Ille Broward CountyProcurement Code

512312018 BidSync p 16

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1

8W1V~isl1War Bid PNC21 15559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Fonn

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Cooper City - middot

Contact Name Michael Bailey PE itle Utilities DlrCity EbullReference date 05011201s

Contact Email MBalleycoopercityflorg Contact Phone (954) 434-5519

Name of Referenced Project City of Cooper City Continuing Professional Services bullContract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

RFQ 2009middot 1 04242009 to Present $ 2 19844200

Vendors role in Project IZJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Since 2009 Hazen has provided Cooper City with engineering services or water and wastewater projects Projects have lnctudeo lhe Pine Island Road Pump Station Lilt S1alions 2 amp 49 Improvements Master Plan Update of the FeaslJl~lty Review of Infrastructure Improvements tor Wastewater and the Eflluent Reuse and Disposal Master Plan

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy 8 D

D ~ D c Deliverables D 0 ~ D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D 0 D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tumover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D GJ- D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D 0 D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) ~D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

bull-rHIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY-

Verified vie EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ct4~ Division ~tUb Date ~ i3~) 0fgt All Information provided to BltCgtWW County 11 wbed ID vamprificalion Velldot adltnowledgu that lnaoewate unlrUhful lncom1ct statemampnla made in wppolt of 11111 response may blt uHd by the

4t2j=~ rejection rHclsslcn of th8 award or lennhallon of Ille eoo1nlct and may also seNamp at tilt basis for dtbarmenl at Vendor puuan1 lo Sectioo 21119 of the Broward COltJi 43

5232018 Bid Sync p24

Broward County Board of PNC211 5559P1

~RiiirilyenlcHUffi~~8CrW~r Bid PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

8DdMARD _ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FL O RIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Fort Lauderdale

Contact Name Rares Patrica PE Title Senior Project Mgr Reference date os1021201s

Contact Email RPetricafortlauderdalegov Contact Phone 9548287150

Name of Referenced Project Stormwater Master Planning and Design Implementation Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

256-11660 04192016 to 04192021 $ 989400000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

vyould you use this vendor again Sves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor The Hazen team Is responsible for delivery of a new stormwaler master plan model a prlorlllzed slormwaterresllency capital Improvements plan and Implementation of designs to address chronic flooding and other slormwater management challenges In the City Primary work tasks Include data collectlon hydrologlclhydraullc modeling and design permitting and construction services for capllal Improvement projects resulting from the revised stormwater master plan (preltmlnary design In seven priority neighborhoods)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION ~R COUNTY USE ONLY

aJ~Verified via pound MA IL _VERBAL Verified by Division W1~tl Date 5 ~3o~ax l S N I informallon p roviltled lo Broward County is sulljecl lo verification Vendor altknowledjj6s lhal inaccurate unlMhlut or lncotreci statements m ade In support of this respon$e may be used by tho

412~-~ rejeclion rescission of the award or termination ol lhe contracl and may also serve as lhe basis for debalment ol Vendor purwant to Section 21119 ol lhe Broward Cou~ 4 3

5232018 Bid Sync p25

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 Br~~~~~rs Bid PNC2115559P1 County t ommissioners

B~uWARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FlOR I CA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

Solicitation PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and s OrganizationFirm Name p

Town of Jupiter

nee

Contact Email davidbjupiterflus Contact Phone (561) 746-5134

Name of Referenced Project Engineering Services for Stormwater and Water Capital Improvements

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount $ 630000000 W17248 (2017 reselection 1012000 to Present (estimated lee-to-date since contract inception) contract number)

Vendors role in Project IZI Prime Vendor osubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again 0Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Descriotion of services orovided bv Vendor Since 2000 Hazen has served as General Consulfant to the Town or Jupiter As General Stormwater and Water Consullant the firm has provided services related to master planning stormwater planning and modeling design NPDES permilling asset management resiliency ratefinancial analysis plan review and construction oversight Water-related capital projs have involved additional system storage and high-service pumping transmission system improvements and RampR at existing facilities

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Verllied via EMAIL _ VERBAL Division WWC D

fo (J-Vv ~ltIvmiddotj Date 5(30(ipf S

Al lnroimallon pngtYICGd 10 Broward Counly Is sub)oel to v8flrcallon vendlaquo acknowledges lhat Inaccurate unlruthlu~ 0t Jnwrrect slatoments made In support ol this response may be used by the 42~~1~0 rojecllon rescission or Ille award or termination or lhe con~acl bullnd mbully also serve as tho basis r0t debarment of Vendor pursuant lo Socllon 21119 of lho Broward Couw 41

5232018 BidSync p 26

a N ~ IL) IL) N u z a_

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLO RI DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Walter Wernecke RA Title Sr Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email WWERNECKEhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Hollywood Marina Restrooms

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

04152015 to Present 7500000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor OSubconsultanVSubcontractor n ~U t1

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

-0 Vgt Description of services provided by VendorO ~ ~ Q) Structural Design and Construction Inspection Services i co Q m ~- c E c0

i E gt Oo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not () uu Appllcable O

E~ referenced Vendor Improvement iii ~sectoO 1 Vendors Quality of Service B mu a Responsive D D

b Accuracy DD c Deliverables D DD

2 Vendors Organization D Da Staff expertise v D b Professionalism~ D D c Turnover D ~D

3 Timeliness of D a Project b Deliverables D ~

4 Pec~~11~$~hinJ~~qt lfr D D 5 Cooperation with f ~

a Your Firm D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D

Al lnfonn1tion pRgttded IO Brwd Cltgtunly lo 1ubjecl IO ibllon vsor ~middot Iha icl-bullmiddot ~ ir-ect slalemenls mode In _ol lhb _ moy ti used by he County as a basis lot rejecUon rnclnlon cl the eward or tonnlnallan of lhl connct 1nd may bullllo 11 the basis for dobalment of Vendor IQtulnl IO SICllOn 21119 at lhe Broword County Procurement Code

Cl ltraquo I() I() I() N ()

Cl z

BRltJWARD ~ middot COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORl OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Davie

Contact Name Emilio DeSimone Title Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email Emilio_DeSimonedavie-fl gov Contact Phone 954-797-1085

Name of Referenced Project Pavillion 5 Linear Park

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

B-17-123 09152015 to 2700000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor O SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es O No If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

0 Description of services provided by Vendor O Q)

iii c Structural Design and Construction Inspection ServicesoQ

CDi-

0cc E gt=gt E ()Oo O () () Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

ii) -e i- Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 111 cs

B ioO

J 1 Vendors Quality of Service Q ()

a Responsive D D b Accuracy D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization []Ll Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D Dtr

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [g D b Deliverables D D ar D

4 Project completed within budget [1tD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) cgD D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via l EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by ~h~ Division WlI Etgt Date 0 f l~o I 8 All lnformaUon provided lO Broward County Is eubJect 10 verifutlon Vendor ecknOMedgoo that lnaocurote unNlhlul or Incorrect statamenle made In aupl)Ort of this reaponse may be used by lho County et o baampla for rejection realtluion of the award or lermlnallon of tho eon1fllcl ond moy olao aorvo os ho basis for debarmont of Vondor purauenl lo Section 21119 of the Broward Counly Procuremen1 Code

0 0 agt a c () z 0

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Terrence Comiskey AIA Title Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email TCOMISKEYhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Van Buren Parking Garage

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PK 14-053 Nov 2014 to Present 8310000

Vendors role in Project t8(Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

o~ Description of services provided by Vendor 1 Q)ltO c Structural Design and Conslructlon Inspection Services 0 Q

0~Jl ccE l E enOo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

gtshy

uu O Improvement Applicable ffireferenced Vendor

~sect 1 Vendors Quality of Service 1 ~

oOau a Responsive D ~ D b Accuracy B D D

D D [- Dc Deliverables

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tum over D D D g

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ D Subcontractor(s )S ubcons u ltant( s)b D D ~ D

c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D yenj D Additional Comments provide on sdditlonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION ~NTY USE ONLY0

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by kW Division W-1-(i~ Date EJo(a~t8 Al lnform1Uon PltOVlded lo Browald Ccxnty It IUbjoct to vorificallon Vendor eoknowfodgea thal lnaewralt U111MhlJI deg inlaquogtlaquobullel amptal11ants made In eupporl of lhls relj)Onse may be used by Iha Counly es a balls l0t rcfecllon rescfuloltI of tho ew1rd or 1ermtnaU0lt1 ol lhbull conllllCI and may elao urve 11 lho basis for dabarmenl of Vondor pursuanl lo Secllon 21 119 of he erowald COUlly CiProcurement Code

~ N ii

00

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 aOWllrp Commficumlref Bid PNC2116615B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Pompano Beach FL

Contact Name Mr A Randolph Brown Title Utilities Director Reference date April 30 2018

Contact Email randolphbrowncopbflcom Contact Phone 954-545-7043

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 201 o Project Amount fees varied

Multiple

Vendors role in Project IKJ Prime Vendor

to 2018

osubconsultanUSubcontractor

(range $10000shy$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D ~ D D c Deliverables D ~ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D ~ D D b Professionalism D D ~ D C Turnover D El DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ 0 b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D [BJ D n c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [XJ o ~

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed) amp~~it -THIS SECTION ~COUNTY USE ONL y-bullbull

Verified via ~AIL __VERBAL Verified by 1lt4 )~ Division N WE O Date 5 faol Z1 18

All lnformotlon providod to BltownrltI Cou nty it aubjoct O verification VendOr acknowledges that lnaccornto untruthful or incorroct 11atomon1s made in support of this response may be used by tho

411p~~)~~J rojoclion roscissioo ol lho award or 1orroinalion of tho contract and roay also s01vo as lhbull basis f0lt d~arroont of VondOf pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward Cou)l1

Bid Sync p 73

40

5232018

Broward County Board of Bid PNC2116659B 1 County Commissioners

B~aWARD gt1- t COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Loxahatchee River Environmental Control District

Contact Name Mr Kris Dean Title Director of Engineering Reference date May 9 2018

Contact Email krisdeanloxahatcheeriverorg Contact Phone 561-747-5700

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 2001 Project Amount fees varied (range $10000shyMultiple to 2018 $250000)

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IR)Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D ~ D D b Accuracy D 0 D D c Deliverables D IBJ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D IB] D D b Professionalism D ~ D D c Turnover D [8J D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D [8J D D b Deliverables D m D D

4 Project completed within budget D ~ D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D ~ D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D Ii] D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D ~ D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SE~ FOR~USE ONLY

Verified via _lEMAIL __VERBAL Verified by ~lt Division fWeb Date I

All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untrulhful or incorrecl slatements made In support of this response may be used by the lJl~~~l~~jSfiir rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and mll~~~ere as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Co)f 10

Broward County Board of Bid PNC21166$9B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A l

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Lake Worth FL

Contact Name Mr Felipe Lofaso TitleAsst Dir Public-ServicesReference date May 9 2018

Contact Email flofasolakeworthorg Contact Phone 561-586-1720

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contract

Contract No Date Services Provided 2014 Project Amount fees varied Multiple to 2018 (range $10000shy

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Services included multiple municipal engineering projects including survey roadway design utility design and coordination (water wastewater stormwater other) along with project management

Needs Satisfactory Excellent NotPlease rate your experience with the Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D GJ D b Accuracy D D Ii] D c Deliverables D Ii] DD

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [i] D c Turnover D D D [X]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D 0 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [X] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION Fe COUNTY USE ONLrbullbull

Verified via MAIL __VERBAL Verified by Division ~wgtgt Date 5~3ol20t8 All information provided to Broward County Is subject lo verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect slalements made in support ol this response may be used by the

OZ~id~~~~j~r rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and m~~~(iirve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Cour~ iG

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - ARCADIS US INC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts

VS0000013130 VS00013130 - ARCADIS US INC Prime Work Auth Vendor SummaryProjects

PURCHASING 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold Procurement No Fixed Contracts FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Favorites Past 5 Years Prime Vendor

Sub Vendor From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 10042017 Purchase Order

Evaluation Purchase Orders 1 POs With A Total Amt Of $20000000 Log Off Paid To Dt ($12132949) Balance $7867051

Contracts Purchase Orders Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx 6192018

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Finish

PURCHASING Weighted Scores Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract FileRoom DashBoard Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number FileRoom Insert

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel Favorites Prime Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Service Evaluation

6132017 YES 486 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Goals Compliance Evaluation

10272016 YES 460 View Docs (0)

6272018

Project Management Information System

Close

Contracts Central Administration

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9130 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-24

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6182018 YES 355 View Docs (1)

Proj Nbr 9320 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-20

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6132018 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9290 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-23

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1122018 YES 494 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-21

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12182017 YES 488 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10162017 YES 473 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

8252017 YES 495 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9321 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-19

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

7112017 YES 476 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-17

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2272017 YES 400 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

10132016 YES 384 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-12

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

5202016 YES 405 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9018 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-06

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10192015 YES 448 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

3202015 YES 385 View Docs (0)

Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL CONSULTANTS

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Project Management Information System

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-04

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12122014 YES 437 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-08

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1242014 YES 423 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-02

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2282014 YES 452 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC

VC0000044184 VC00044184 - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres PS $001 Used $000 Remain $001 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $354848400 Closed 0 Total $000 Total Current Retainage Balance For All Contracts $793370 No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 06292015 Purchase Orders 2 POs With A Total Amt Of $362317900 Paid To Dt ($218795160) Balance $143522740

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 40803 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9058 - DISTRICT 3A POTABLE WATER STORAGE

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1220410P1 - Consultant Engineering Services for Potable Water FixedOpen Contracts Storage Tanks and Pumping Systems Work Auth Prime Vendor CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Periodic Final Finish

Log Off Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type

Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

6232015 8302017 413 Approved 8312017 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard

Enter Vendor Name (or a portion of) Then Click Search - Wilcards Are Permitted (ie wa wawainc) Florida Technical Consultants

Search Reset Finish

No Vendors Found For Your Search Try Again

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41005 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score Go

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0773

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

12122017 YES 430 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

8302016 YES 438 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Final Consultant Evaluation 3142016 YES 478 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0706

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

142016 YES 402 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9016OES - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0731

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

10192015 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0748

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

612015 YES 467 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

2192015 YES 500 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0754

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

252015 YES 409 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0755

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

1242014 YES 415 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8974 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0758

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

6202014 YES 393 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr

WATER amp WASTEWATER

Final Consultant Work Authorization 572014 YES 423 View Docs

(0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

HS0746 ENGINEERING Evaluation

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

4302014 YES 475 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Evaluation 4302014 YES 493 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0710

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

3172014 YES 395 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0753

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

1212014 YES 380 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0763

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

11192013 YES 450 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0775

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 408 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals

Finish

Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed FileRoom DashBoard Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization FileRoom Insert NumberFavorites

Prime Vendor Export To Excel Sub Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0772

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 417 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0771

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

2262013 YES 410 View Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 26: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1

8W1V~isl1War Bid PNC21 15559P1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Fonn

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Cooper City - middot

Contact Name Michael Bailey PE itle Utilities DlrCity EbullReference date 05011201s

Contact Email MBalleycoopercityflorg Contact Phone (954) 434-5519

Name of Referenced Project City of Cooper City Continuing Professional Services bullContract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

RFQ 2009middot 1 04242009 to Present $ 2 19844200

Vendors role in Project IZJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Since 2009 Hazen has provided Cooper City with engineering services or water and wastewater projects Projects have lnctudeo lhe Pine Island Road Pump Station Lilt S1alions 2 amp 49 Improvements Master Plan Update of the FeaslJl~lty Review of Infrastructure Improvements tor Wastewater and the Eflluent Reuse and Disposal Master Plan

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D b Accuracy 8 D

D ~ D c Deliverables D 0 ~ D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D 0 D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tumover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D GJ- D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D 0 D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) ~D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

bull-rHIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY-

Verified vie EMAIL _ VERBAL Verified by ct4~ Division ~tUb Date ~ i3~) 0fgt All Information provided to BltCgtWW County 11 wbed ID vamprificalion Velldot adltnowledgu that lnaoewate unlrUhful lncom1ct statemampnla made in wppolt of 11111 response may blt uHd by the

4t2j=~ rejection rHclsslcn of th8 award or lennhallon of Ille eoo1nlct and may also seNamp at tilt basis for dtbarmenl at Vendor puuan1 lo Sectioo 21119 of the Broward COltJi 43

5232018 Bid Sync p24

Broward County Board of PNC211 5559P1

~RiiirilyenlcHUffi~~8CrW~r Bid PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

8DdMARD _ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FL O RIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Fort Lauderdale

Contact Name Rares Patrica PE Title Senior Project Mgr Reference date os1021201s

Contact Email RPetricafortlauderdalegov Contact Phone 9548287150

Name of Referenced Project Stormwater Master Planning and Design Implementation Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

256-11660 04192016 to 04192021 $ 989400000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

vyould you use this vendor again Sves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor The Hazen team Is responsible for delivery of a new stormwaler master plan model a prlorlllzed slormwaterresllency capital Improvements plan and Implementation of designs to address chronic flooding and other slormwater management challenges In the City Primary work tasks Include data collectlon hydrologlclhydraullc modeling and design permitting and construction services for capllal Improvement projects resulting from the revised stormwater master plan (preltmlnary design In seven priority neighborhoods)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION ~R COUNTY USE ONLY

aJ~Verified via pound MA IL _VERBAL Verified by Division W1~tl Date 5 ~3o~ax l S N I informallon p roviltled lo Broward County is sulljecl lo verification Vendor altknowledjj6s lhal inaccurate unlMhlut or lncotreci statements m ade In support of this respon$e may be used by tho

412~-~ rejeclion rescission of the award or termination ol lhe contracl and may also serve as lhe basis for debalment ol Vendor purwant to Section 21119 ol lhe Broward Cou~ 4 3

5232018 Bid Sync p25

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 Br~~~~~rs Bid PNC2115559P1 County t ommissioners

B~uWARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FlOR I CA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

Solicitation PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and s OrganizationFirm Name p

Town of Jupiter

nee

Contact Email davidbjupiterflus Contact Phone (561) 746-5134

Name of Referenced Project Engineering Services for Stormwater and Water Capital Improvements

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount $ 630000000 W17248 (2017 reselection 1012000 to Present (estimated lee-to-date since contract inception) contract number)

Vendors role in Project IZI Prime Vendor osubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again 0Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Descriotion of services orovided bv Vendor Since 2000 Hazen has served as General Consulfant to the Town or Jupiter As General Stormwater and Water Consullant the firm has provided services related to master planning stormwater planning and modeling design NPDES permilling asset management resiliency ratefinancial analysis plan review and construction oversight Water-related capital projs have involved additional system storage and high-service pumping transmission system improvements and RampR at existing facilities

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Verllied via EMAIL _ VERBAL Division WWC D

fo (J-Vv ~ltIvmiddotj Date 5(30(ipf S

Al lnroimallon pngtYICGd 10 Broward Counly Is sub)oel to v8flrcallon vendlaquo acknowledges lhat Inaccurate unlruthlu~ 0t Jnwrrect slatoments made In support ol this response may be used by the 42~~1~0 rojecllon rescission or Ille award or termination or lhe con~acl bullnd mbully also serve as tho basis r0t debarment of Vendor pursuant lo Socllon 21119 of lho Broward Couw 41

5232018 BidSync p 26

a N ~ IL) IL) N u z a_

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLO RI DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Walter Wernecke RA Title Sr Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email WWERNECKEhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Hollywood Marina Restrooms

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

04152015 to Present 7500000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor OSubconsultanVSubcontractor n ~U t1

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

-0 Vgt Description of services provided by VendorO ~ ~ Q) Structural Design and Construction Inspection Services i co Q m ~- c E c0

i E gt Oo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not () uu Appllcable O

E~ referenced Vendor Improvement iii ~sectoO 1 Vendors Quality of Service B mu a Responsive D D

b Accuracy DD c Deliverables D DD

2 Vendors Organization D Da Staff expertise v D b Professionalism~ D D c Turnover D ~D

3 Timeliness of D a Project b Deliverables D ~

4 Pec~~11~$~hinJ~~qt lfr D D 5 Cooperation with f ~

a Your Firm D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D

Al lnfonn1tion pRgttded IO Brwd Cltgtunly lo 1ubjecl IO ibllon vsor ~middot Iha icl-bullmiddot ~ ir-ect slalemenls mode In _ol lhb _ moy ti used by he County as a basis lot rejecUon rnclnlon cl the eward or tonnlnallan of lhl connct 1nd may bullllo 11 the basis for dobalment of Vendor IQtulnl IO SICllOn 21119 at lhe Broword County Procurement Code

Cl ltraquo I() I() I() N ()

Cl z

BRltJWARD ~ middot COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORl OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Davie

Contact Name Emilio DeSimone Title Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email Emilio_DeSimonedavie-fl gov Contact Phone 954-797-1085

Name of Referenced Project Pavillion 5 Linear Park

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

B-17-123 09152015 to 2700000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor O SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es O No If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

0 Description of services provided by Vendor O Q)

iii c Structural Design and Construction Inspection ServicesoQ

CDi-

0cc E gt=gt E ()Oo O () () Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

ii) -e i- Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 111 cs

B ioO

J 1 Vendors Quality of Service Q ()

a Responsive D D b Accuracy D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization []Ll Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D Dtr

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [g D b Deliverables D D ar D

4 Project completed within budget [1tD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) cgD D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via l EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by ~h~ Division WlI Etgt Date 0 f l~o I 8 All lnformaUon provided lO Broward County Is eubJect 10 verifutlon Vendor ecknOMedgoo that lnaocurote unNlhlul or Incorrect statamenle made In aupl)Ort of this reaponse may be used by lho County et o baampla for rejection realtluion of the award or lermlnallon of tho eon1fllcl ond moy olao aorvo os ho basis for debarmont of Vondor purauenl lo Section 21119 of the Broward Counly Procuremen1 Code

0 0 agt a c () z 0

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Terrence Comiskey AIA Title Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email TCOMISKEYhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Van Buren Parking Garage

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PK 14-053 Nov 2014 to Present 8310000

Vendors role in Project t8(Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

o~ Description of services provided by Vendor 1 Q)ltO c Structural Design and Conslructlon Inspection Services 0 Q

0~Jl ccE l E enOo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

gtshy

uu O Improvement Applicable ffireferenced Vendor

~sect 1 Vendors Quality of Service 1 ~

oOau a Responsive D ~ D b Accuracy B D D

D D [- Dc Deliverables

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tum over D D D g

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ D Subcontractor(s )S ubcons u ltant( s)b D D ~ D

c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D yenj D Additional Comments provide on sdditlonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION ~NTY USE ONLY0

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by kW Division W-1-(i~ Date EJo(a~t8 Al lnform1Uon PltOVlded lo Browald Ccxnty It IUbjoct to vorificallon Vendor eoknowfodgea thal lnaewralt U111MhlJI deg inlaquogtlaquobullel amptal11ants made In eupporl of lhls relj)Onse may be used by Iha Counly es a balls l0t rcfecllon rescfuloltI of tho ew1rd or 1ermtnaU0lt1 ol lhbull conllllCI and may elao urve 11 lho basis for dabarmenl of Vondor pursuanl lo Secllon 21 119 of he erowald COUlly CiProcurement Code

~ N ii

00

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 aOWllrp Commficumlref Bid PNC2116615B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Pompano Beach FL

Contact Name Mr A Randolph Brown Title Utilities Director Reference date April 30 2018

Contact Email randolphbrowncopbflcom Contact Phone 954-545-7043

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 201 o Project Amount fees varied

Multiple

Vendors role in Project IKJ Prime Vendor

to 2018

osubconsultanUSubcontractor

(range $10000shy$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D ~ D D c Deliverables D ~ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D ~ D D b Professionalism D D ~ D C Turnover D El DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ 0 b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D [BJ D n c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [XJ o ~

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed) amp~~it -THIS SECTION ~COUNTY USE ONL y-bullbull

Verified via ~AIL __VERBAL Verified by 1lt4 )~ Division N WE O Date 5 faol Z1 18

All lnformotlon providod to BltownrltI Cou nty it aubjoct O verification VendOr acknowledges that lnaccornto untruthful or incorroct 11atomon1s made in support of this response may be used by tho

411p~~)~~J rojoclion roscissioo ol lho award or 1orroinalion of tho contract and roay also s01vo as lhbull basis f0lt d~arroont of VondOf pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward Cou)l1

Bid Sync p 73

40

5232018

Broward County Board of Bid PNC2116659B 1 County Commissioners

B~aWARD gt1- t COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Loxahatchee River Environmental Control District

Contact Name Mr Kris Dean Title Director of Engineering Reference date May 9 2018

Contact Email krisdeanloxahatcheeriverorg Contact Phone 561-747-5700

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 2001 Project Amount fees varied (range $10000shyMultiple to 2018 $250000)

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IR)Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D ~ D D b Accuracy D 0 D D c Deliverables D IBJ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D IB] D D b Professionalism D ~ D D c Turnover D [8J D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D [8J D D b Deliverables D m D D

4 Project completed within budget D ~ D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D ~ D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D Ii] D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D ~ D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SE~ FOR~USE ONLY

Verified via _lEMAIL __VERBAL Verified by ~lt Division fWeb Date I

All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untrulhful or incorrecl slatements made In support of this response may be used by the lJl~~~l~~jSfiir rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and mll~~~ere as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Co)f 10

Broward County Board of Bid PNC21166$9B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A l

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Lake Worth FL

Contact Name Mr Felipe Lofaso TitleAsst Dir Public-ServicesReference date May 9 2018

Contact Email flofasolakeworthorg Contact Phone 561-586-1720

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contract

Contract No Date Services Provided 2014 Project Amount fees varied Multiple to 2018 (range $10000shy

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Services included multiple municipal engineering projects including survey roadway design utility design and coordination (water wastewater stormwater other) along with project management

Needs Satisfactory Excellent NotPlease rate your experience with the Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D GJ D b Accuracy D D Ii] D c Deliverables D Ii] DD

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [i] D c Turnover D D D [X]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D 0 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [X] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION Fe COUNTY USE ONLrbullbull

Verified via MAIL __VERBAL Verified by Division ~wgtgt Date 5~3ol20t8 All information provided to Broward County Is subject lo verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect slalements made in support ol this response may be used by the

OZ~id~~~~j~r rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and m~~~(iirve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Cour~ iG

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - ARCADIS US INC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts

VS0000013130 VS00013130 - ARCADIS US INC Prime Work Auth Vendor SummaryProjects

PURCHASING 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold Procurement No Fixed Contracts FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Favorites Past 5 Years Prime Vendor

Sub Vendor From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 10042017 Purchase Order

Evaluation Purchase Orders 1 POs With A Total Amt Of $20000000 Log Off Paid To Dt ($12132949) Balance $7867051

Contracts Purchase Orders Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx 6192018

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Finish

PURCHASING Weighted Scores Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract FileRoom DashBoard Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number FileRoom Insert

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel Favorites Prime Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Service Evaluation

6132017 YES 486 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Goals Compliance Evaluation

10272016 YES 460 View Docs (0)

6272018

Project Management Information System

Close

Contracts Central Administration

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9130 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-24

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6182018 YES 355 View Docs (1)

Proj Nbr 9320 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-20

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6132018 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9290 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-23

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1122018 YES 494 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-21

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12182017 YES 488 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10162017 YES 473 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

8252017 YES 495 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9321 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-19

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

7112017 YES 476 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-17

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2272017 YES 400 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

10132016 YES 384 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-12

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

5202016 YES 405 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9018 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-06

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10192015 YES 448 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

3202015 YES 385 View Docs (0)

Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL CONSULTANTS

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Project Management Information System

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-04

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12122014 YES 437 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-08

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1242014 YES 423 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-02

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2282014 YES 452 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC

VC0000044184 VC00044184 - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres PS $001 Used $000 Remain $001 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $354848400 Closed 0 Total $000 Total Current Retainage Balance For All Contracts $793370 No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 06292015 Purchase Orders 2 POs With A Total Amt Of $362317900 Paid To Dt ($218795160) Balance $143522740

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 40803 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9058 - DISTRICT 3A POTABLE WATER STORAGE

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1220410P1 - Consultant Engineering Services for Potable Water FixedOpen Contracts Storage Tanks and Pumping Systems Work Auth Prime Vendor CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Periodic Final Finish

Log Off Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type

Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

6232015 8302017 413 Approved 8312017 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard

Enter Vendor Name (or a portion of) Then Click Search - Wilcards Are Permitted (ie wa wawainc) Florida Technical Consultants

Search Reset Finish

No Vendors Found For Your Search Try Again

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41005 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score Go

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0773

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

12122017 YES 430 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

8302016 YES 438 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Final Consultant Evaluation 3142016 YES 478 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0706

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

142016 YES 402 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9016OES - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0731

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

10192015 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0748

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

612015 YES 467 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

2192015 YES 500 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0754

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

252015 YES 409 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0755

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

1242014 YES 415 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8974 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0758

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

6202014 YES 393 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr

WATER amp WASTEWATER

Final Consultant Work Authorization 572014 YES 423 View Docs

(0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

HS0746 ENGINEERING Evaluation

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

4302014 YES 475 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Evaluation 4302014 YES 493 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0710

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

3172014 YES 395 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0753

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

1212014 YES 380 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0763

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

11192013 YES 450 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0775

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 408 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals

Finish

Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed FileRoom DashBoard Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization FileRoom Insert NumberFavorites

Prime Vendor Export To Excel Sub Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0772

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 417 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0771

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

2262013 YES 410 View Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 27: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

Broward County Board of PNC211 5559P1

~RiiirilyenlcHUffi~~8CrW~r Bid PNC2115559P1 County Commissioners

8DdMARD _ COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FL O RIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and Sawyer

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Fort Lauderdale

Contact Name Rares Patrica PE Title Senior Project Mgr Reference date os1021201s

Contact Email RPetricafortlauderdalegov Contact Phone 9548287150

Name of Referenced Project Stormwater Master Planning and Design Implementation Services

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

256-11660 04192016 to 04192021 $ 989400000

Vendors role in Project [)Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

vyould you use this vendor again Sves ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor The Hazen team Is responsible for delivery of a new stormwaler master plan model a prlorlllzed slormwaterresllency capital Improvements plan and Implementation of designs to address chronic flooding and other slormwater management challenges In the City Primary work tasks Include data collectlon hydrologlclhydraullc modeling and design permitting and construction services for capllal Improvement projects resulting from the revised stormwater master plan (preltmlnary design In seven priority neighborhoods)

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Appllcablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D ~ D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D ~ D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsu ltant( s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D ~ D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION ~R COUNTY USE ONLY

aJ~Verified via pound MA IL _VERBAL Verified by Division W1~tl Date 5 ~3o~ax l S N I informallon p roviltled lo Broward County is sulljecl lo verification Vendor altknowledjj6s lhal inaccurate unlMhlut or lncotreci statements m ade In support of this respon$e may be used by tho

412~-~ rejeclion rescission of the award or termination ol lhe contracl and may also serve as lhe basis for debalment ol Vendor purwant to Section 21119 ol lhe Broward Cou~ 4 3

5232018 Bid Sync p25

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 Br~~~~~rs Bid PNC2115559P1 County t ommissioners

B~uWARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FlOR I CA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

Solicitation PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and s OrganizationFirm Name p

Town of Jupiter

nee

Contact Email davidbjupiterflus Contact Phone (561) 746-5134

Name of Referenced Project Engineering Services for Stormwater and Water Capital Improvements

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount $ 630000000 W17248 (2017 reselection 1012000 to Present (estimated lee-to-date since contract inception) contract number)

Vendors role in Project IZI Prime Vendor osubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again 0Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Descriotion of services orovided bv Vendor Since 2000 Hazen has served as General Consulfant to the Town or Jupiter As General Stormwater and Water Consullant the firm has provided services related to master planning stormwater planning and modeling design NPDES permilling asset management resiliency ratefinancial analysis plan review and construction oversight Water-related capital projs have involved additional system storage and high-service pumping transmission system improvements and RampR at existing facilities

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Verllied via EMAIL _ VERBAL Division WWC D

fo (J-Vv ~ltIvmiddotj Date 5(30(ipf S

Al lnroimallon pngtYICGd 10 Broward Counly Is sub)oel to v8flrcallon vendlaquo acknowledges lhat Inaccurate unlruthlu~ 0t Jnwrrect slatoments made In support ol this response may be used by the 42~~1~0 rojecllon rescission or Ille award or termination or lhe con~acl bullnd mbully also serve as tho basis r0t debarment of Vendor pursuant lo Socllon 21119 of lho Broward Couw 41

5232018 BidSync p 26

a N ~ IL) IL) N u z a_

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLO RI DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Walter Wernecke RA Title Sr Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email WWERNECKEhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Hollywood Marina Restrooms

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

04152015 to Present 7500000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor OSubconsultanVSubcontractor n ~U t1

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

-0 Vgt Description of services provided by VendorO ~ ~ Q) Structural Design and Construction Inspection Services i co Q m ~- c E c0

i E gt Oo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not () uu Appllcable O

E~ referenced Vendor Improvement iii ~sectoO 1 Vendors Quality of Service B mu a Responsive D D

b Accuracy DD c Deliverables D DD

2 Vendors Organization D Da Staff expertise v D b Professionalism~ D D c Turnover D ~D

3 Timeliness of D a Project b Deliverables D ~

4 Pec~~11~$~hinJ~~qt lfr D D 5 Cooperation with f ~

a Your Firm D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D

Al lnfonn1tion pRgttded IO Brwd Cltgtunly lo 1ubjecl IO ibllon vsor ~middot Iha icl-bullmiddot ~ ir-ect slalemenls mode In _ol lhb _ moy ti used by he County as a basis lot rejecUon rnclnlon cl the eward or tonnlnallan of lhl connct 1nd may bullllo 11 the basis for dobalment of Vendor IQtulnl IO SICllOn 21119 at lhe Broword County Procurement Code

Cl ltraquo I() I() I() N ()

Cl z

BRltJWARD ~ middot COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORl OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Davie

Contact Name Emilio DeSimone Title Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email Emilio_DeSimonedavie-fl gov Contact Phone 954-797-1085

Name of Referenced Project Pavillion 5 Linear Park

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

B-17-123 09152015 to 2700000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor O SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es O No If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

0 Description of services provided by Vendor O Q)

iii c Structural Design and Construction Inspection ServicesoQ

CDi-

0cc E gt=gt E ()Oo O () () Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

ii) -e i- Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 111 cs

B ioO

J 1 Vendors Quality of Service Q ()

a Responsive D D b Accuracy D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization []Ll Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D Dtr

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [g D b Deliverables D D ar D

4 Project completed within budget [1tD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) cgD D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via l EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by ~h~ Division WlI Etgt Date 0 f l~o I 8 All lnformaUon provided lO Broward County Is eubJect 10 verifutlon Vendor ecknOMedgoo that lnaocurote unNlhlul or Incorrect statamenle made In aupl)Ort of this reaponse may be used by lho County et o baampla for rejection realtluion of the award or lermlnallon of tho eon1fllcl ond moy olao aorvo os ho basis for debarmont of Vondor purauenl lo Section 21119 of the Broward Counly Procuremen1 Code

0 0 agt a c () z 0

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Terrence Comiskey AIA Title Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email TCOMISKEYhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Van Buren Parking Garage

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PK 14-053 Nov 2014 to Present 8310000

Vendors role in Project t8(Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

o~ Description of services provided by Vendor 1 Q)ltO c Structural Design and Conslructlon Inspection Services 0 Q

0~Jl ccE l E enOo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

gtshy

uu O Improvement Applicable ffireferenced Vendor

~sect 1 Vendors Quality of Service 1 ~

oOau a Responsive D ~ D b Accuracy B D D

D D [- Dc Deliverables

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tum over D D D g

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ D Subcontractor(s )S ubcons u ltant( s)b D D ~ D

c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D yenj D Additional Comments provide on sdditlonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION ~NTY USE ONLY0

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by kW Division W-1-(i~ Date EJo(a~t8 Al lnform1Uon PltOVlded lo Browald Ccxnty It IUbjoct to vorificallon Vendor eoknowfodgea thal lnaewralt U111MhlJI deg inlaquogtlaquobullel amptal11ants made In eupporl of lhls relj)Onse may be used by Iha Counly es a balls l0t rcfecllon rescfuloltI of tho ew1rd or 1ermtnaU0lt1 ol lhbull conllllCI and may elao urve 11 lho basis for dabarmenl of Vondor pursuanl lo Secllon 21 119 of he erowald COUlly CiProcurement Code

~ N ii

00

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 aOWllrp Commficumlref Bid PNC2116615B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Pompano Beach FL

Contact Name Mr A Randolph Brown Title Utilities Director Reference date April 30 2018

Contact Email randolphbrowncopbflcom Contact Phone 954-545-7043

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 201 o Project Amount fees varied

Multiple

Vendors role in Project IKJ Prime Vendor

to 2018

osubconsultanUSubcontractor

(range $10000shy$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D ~ D D c Deliverables D ~ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D ~ D D b Professionalism D D ~ D C Turnover D El DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ 0 b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D [BJ D n c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [XJ o ~

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed) amp~~it -THIS SECTION ~COUNTY USE ONL y-bullbull

Verified via ~AIL __VERBAL Verified by 1lt4 )~ Division N WE O Date 5 faol Z1 18

All lnformotlon providod to BltownrltI Cou nty it aubjoct O verification VendOr acknowledges that lnaccornto untruthful or incorroct 11atomon1s made in support of this response may be used by tho

411p~~)~~J rojoclion roscissioo ol lho award or 1orroinalion of tho contract and roay also s01vo as lhbull basis f0lt d~arroont of VondOf pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward Cou)l1

Bid Sync p 73

40

5232018

Broward County Board of Bid PNC2116659B 1 County Commissioners

B~aWARD gt1- t COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Loxahatchee River Environmental Control District

Contact Name Mr Kris Dean Title Director of Engineering Reference date May 9 2018

Contact Email krisdeanloxahatcheeriverorg Contact Phone 561-747-5700

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 2001 Project Amount fees varied (range $10000shyMultiple to 2018 $250000)

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IR)Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D ~ D D b Accuracy D 0 D D c Deliverables D IBJ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D IB] D D b Professionalism D ~ D D c Turnover D [8J D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D [8J D D b Deliverables D m D D

4 Project completed within budget D ~ D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D ~ D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D Ii] D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D ~ D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SE~ FOR~USE ONLY

Verified via _lEMAIL __VERBAL Verified by ~lt Division fWeb Date I

All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untrulhful or incorrecl slatements made In support of this response may be used by the lJl~~~l~~jSfiir rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and mll~~~ere as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Co)f 10

Broward County Board of Bid PNC21166$9B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A l

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Lake Worth FL

Contact Name Mr Felipe Lofaso TitleAsst Dir Public-ServicesReference date May 9 2018

Contact Email flofasolakeworthorg Contact Phone 561-586-1720

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contract

Contract No Date Services Provided 2014 Project Amount fees varied Multiple to 2018 (range $10000shy

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Services included multiple municipal engineering projects including survey roadway design utility design and coordination (water wastewater stormwater other) along with project management

Needs Satisfactory Excellent NotPlease rate your experience with the Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D GJ D b Accuracy D D Ii] D c Deliverables D Ii] DD

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [i] D c Turnover D D D [X]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D 0 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [X] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION Fe COUNTY USE ONLrbullbull

Verified via MAIL __VERBAL Verified by Division ~wgtgt Date 5~3ol20t8 All information provided to Broward County Is subject lo verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect slalements made in support ol this response may be used by the

OZ~id~~~~j~r rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and m~~~(iirve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Cour~ iG

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - ARCADIS US INC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts

VS0000013130 VS00013130 - ARCADIS US INC Prime Work Auth Vendor SummaryProjects

PURCHASING 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold Procurement No Fixed Contracts FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Favorites Past 5 Years Prime Vendor

Sub Vendor From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 10042017 Purchase Order

Evaluation Purchase Orders 1 POs With A Total Amt Of $20000000 Log Off Paid To Dt ($12132949) Balance $7867051

Contracts Purchase Orders Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx 6192018

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Finish

PURCHASING Weighted Scores Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract FileRoom DashBoard Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number FileRoom Insert

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel Favorites Prime Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Service Evaluation

6132017 YES 486 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Goals Compliance Evaluation

10272016 YES 460 View Docs (0)

6272018

Project Management Information System

Close

Contracts Central Administration

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9130 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-24

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6182018 YES 355 View Docs (1)

Proj Nbr 9320 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-20

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6132018 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9290 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-23

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1122018 YES 494 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-21

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12182017 YES 488 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10162017 YES 473 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

8252017 YES 495 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9321 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-19

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

7112017 YES 476 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-17

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2272017 YES 400 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

10132016 YES 384 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-12

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

5202016 YES 405 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9018 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-06

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10192015 YES 448 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

3202015 YES 385 View Docs (0)

Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL CONSULTANTS

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Project Management Information System

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-04

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12122014 YES 437 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-08

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1242014 YES 423 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-02

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2282014 YES 452 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC

VC0000044184 VC00044184 - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres PS $001 Used $000 Remain $001 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $354848400 Closed 0 Total $000 Total Current Retainage Balance For All Contracts $793370 No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 06292015 Purchase Orders 2 POs With A Total Amt Of $362317900 Paid To Dt ($218795160) Balance $143522740

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 40803 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9058 - DISTRICT 3A POTABLE WATER STORAGE

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1220410P1 - Consultant Engineering Services for Potable Water FixedOpen Contracts Storage Tanks and Pumping Systems Work Auth Prime Vendor CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Periodic Final Finish

Log Off Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type

Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

6232015 8302017 413 Approved 8312017 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard

Enter Vendor Name (or a portion of) Then Click Search - Wilcards Are Permitted (ie wa wawainc) Florida Technical Consultants

Search Reset Finish

No Vendors Found For Your Search Try Again

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41005 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score Go

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0773

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

12122017 YES 430 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

8302016 YES 438 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Final Consultant Evaluation 3142016 YES 478 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0706

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

142016 YES 402 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9016OES - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0731

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

10192015 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0748

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

612015 YES 467 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

2192015 YES 500 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0754

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

252015 YES 409 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0755

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

1242014 YES 415 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8974 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0758

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

6202014 YES 393 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr

WATER amp WASTEWATER

Final Consultant Work Authorization 572014 YES 423 View Docs

(0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

HS0746 ENGINEERING Evaluation

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

4302014 YES 475 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Evaluation 4302014 YES 493 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0710

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

3172014 YES 395 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0753

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

1212014 YES 380 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0763

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

11192013 YES 450 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0775

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 408 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals

Finish

Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed FileRoom DashBoard Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization FileRoom Insert NumberFavorites

Prime Vendor Export To Excel Sub Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0772

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 417 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0771

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

2262013 YES 410 View Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 28: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 Br~~~~~rs Bid PNC2115559P1 County t ommissioners

B~uWARD COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FlOR I CA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

Solicitation PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Hazen and s OrganizationFirm Name p

Town of Jupiter

nee

Contact Email davidbjupiterflus Contact Phone (561) 746-5134

Name of Referenced Project Engineering Services for Stormwater and Water Capital Improvements

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount $ 630000000 W17248 (2017 reselection 1012000 to Present (estimated lee-to-date since contract inception) contract number)

Vendors role in Project IZI Prime Vendor osubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again 0Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Descriotion of services orovided bv Vendor Since 2000 Hazen has served as General Consulfant to the Town or Jupiter As General Stormwater and Water Consullant the firm has provided services related to master planning stormwater planning and modeling design NPDES permilling asset management resiliency ratefinancial analysis plan review and construction oversight Water-related capital projs have involved additional system storage and high-service pumping transmission system improvements and RampR at existing facilities

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D D b Accuracy D D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D D

4 Project completed within budget DD D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D D

Verllied via EMAIL _ VERBAL Division WWC D

fo (J-Vv ~ltIvmiddotj Date 5(30(ipf S

Al lnroimallon pngtYICGd 10 Broward Counly Is sub)oel to v8flrcallon vendlaquo acknowledges lhat Inaccurate unlruthlu~ 0t Jnwrrect slatoments made In support ol this response may be used by the 42~~1~0 rojecllon rescission or Ille award or termination or lhe con~acl bullnd mbully also serve as tho basis r0t debarment of Vendor pursuant lo Socllon 21119 of lho Broward Couw 41

5232018 BidSync p 26

a N ~ IL) IL) N u z a_

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLO RI DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Walter Wernecke RA Title Sr Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email WWERNECKEhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Hollywood Marina Restrooms

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

04152015 to Present 7500000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor OSubconsultanVSubcontractor n ~U t1

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

-0 Vgt Description of services provided by VendorO ~ ~ Q) Structural Design and Construction Inspection Services i co Q m ~- c E c0

i E gt Oo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not () uu Appllcable O

E~ referenced Vendor Improvement iii ~sectoO 1 Vendors Quality of Service B mu a Responsive D D

b Accuracy DD c Deliverables D DD

2 Vendors Organization D Da Staff expertise v D b Professionalism~ D D c Turnover D ~D

3 Timeliness of D a Project b Deliverables D ~

4 Pec~~11~$~hinJ~~qt lfr D D 5 Cooperation with f ~

a Your Firm D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D

Al lnfonn1tion pRgttded IO Brwd Cltgtunly lo 1ubjecl IO ibllon vsor ~middot Iha icl-bullmiddot ~ ir-ect slalemenls mode In _ol lhb _ moy ti used by he County as a basis lot rejecUon rnclnlon cl the eward or tonnlnallan of lhl connct 1nd may bullllo 11 the basis for dobalment of Vendor IQtulnl IO SICllOn 21119 at lhe Broword County Procurement Code

Cl ltraquo I() I() I() N ()

Cl z

BRltJWARD ~ middot COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORl OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Davie

Contact Name Emilio DeSimone Title Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email Emilio_DeSimonedavie-fl gov Contact Phone 954-797-1085

Name of Referenced Project Pavillion 5 Linear Park

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

B-17-123 09152015 to 2700000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor O SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es O No If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

0 Description of services provided by Vendor O Q)

iii c Structural Design and Construction Inspection ServicesoQ

CDi-

0cc E gt=gt E ()Oo O () () Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

ii) -e i- Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 111 cs

B ioO

J 1 Vendors Quality of Service Q ()

a Responsive D D b Accuracy D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization []Ll Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D Dtr

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [g D b Deliverables D D ar D

4 Project completed within budget [1tD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) cgD D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via l EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by ~h~ Division WlI Etgt Date 0 f l~o I 8 All lnformaUon provided lO Broward County Is eubJect 10 verifutlon Vendor ecknOMedgoo that lnaocurote unNlhlul or Incorrect statamenle made In aupl)Ort of this reaponse may be used by lho County et o baampla for rejection realtluion of the award or lermlnallon of tho eon1fllcl ond moy olao aorvo os ho basis for debarmont of Vondor purauenl lo Section 21119 of the Broward Counly Procuremen1 Code

0 0 agt a c () z 0

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Terrence Comiskey AIA Title Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email TCOMISKEYhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Van Buren Parking Garage

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PK 14-053 Nov 2014 to Present 8310000

Vendors role in Project t8(Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

o~ Description of services provided by Vendor 1 Q)ltO c Structural Design and Conslructlon Inspection Services 0 Q

0~Jl ccE l E enOo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

gtshy

uu O Improvement Applicable ffireferenced Vendor

~sect 1 Vendors Quality of Service 1 ~

oOau a Responsive D ~ D b Accuracy B D D

D D [- Dc Deliverables

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tum over D D D g

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ D Subcontractor(s )S ubcons u ltant( s)b D D ~ D

c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D yenj D Additional Comments provide on sdditlonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION ~NTY USE ONLY0

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by kW Division W-1-(i~ Date EJo(a~t8 Al lnform1Uon PltOVlded lo Browald Ccxnty It IUbjoct to vorificallon Vendor eoknowfodgea thal lnaewralt U111MhlJI deg inlaquogtlaquobullel amptal11ants made In eupporl of lhls relj)Onse may be used by Iha Counly es a balls l0t rcfecllon rescfuloltI of tho ew1rd or 1ermtnaU0lt1 ol lhbull conllllCI and may elao urve 11 lho basis for dabarmenl of Vondor pursuanl lo Secllon 21 119 of he erowald COUlly CiProcurement Code

~ N ii

00

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 aOWllrp Commficumlref Bid PNC2116615B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Pompano Beach FL

Contact Name Mr A Randolph Brown Title Utilities Director Reference date April 30 2018

Contact Email randolphbrowncopbflcom Contact Phone 954-545-7043

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 201 o Project Amount fees varied

Multiple

Vendors role in Project IKJ Prime Vendor

to 2018

osubconsultanUSubcontractor

(range $10000shy$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D ~ D D c Deliverables D ~ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D ~ D D b Professionalism D D ~ D C Turnover D El DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ 0 b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D [BJ D n c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [XJ o ~

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed) amp~~it -THIS SECTION ~COUNTY USE ONL y-bullbull

Verified via ~AIL __VERBAL Verified by 1lt4 )~ Division N WE O Date 5 faol Z1 18

All lnformotlon providod to BltownrltI Cou nty it aubjoct O verification VendOr acknowledges that lnaccornto untruthful or incorroct 11atomon1s made in support of this response may be used by tho

411p~~)~~J rojoclion roscissioo ol lho award or 1orroinalion of tho contract and roay also s01vo as lhbull basis f0lt d~arroont of VondOf pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward Cou)l1

Bid Sync p 73

40

5232018

Broward County Board of Bid PNC2116659B 1 County Commissioners

B~aWARD gt1- t COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Loxahatchee River Environmental Control District

Contact Name Mr Kris Dean Title Director of Engineering Reference date May 9 2018

Contact Email krisdeanloxahatcheeriverorg Contact Phone 561-747-5700

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 2001 Project Amount fees varied (range $10000shyMultiple to 2018 $250000)

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IR)Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D ~ D D b Accuracy D 0 D D c Deliverables D IBJ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D IB] D D b Professionalism D ~ D D c Turnover D [8J D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D [8J D D b Deliverables D m D D

4 Project completed within budget D ~ D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D ~ D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D Ii] D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D ~ D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SE~ FOR~USE ONLY

Verified via _lEMAIL __VERBAL Verified by ~lt Division fWeb Date I

All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untrulhful or incorrecl slatements made In support of this response may be used by the lJl~~~l~~jSfiir rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and mll~~~ere as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Co)f 10

Broward County Board of Bid PNC21166$9B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A l

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Lake Worth FL

Contact Name Mr Felipe Lofaso TitleAsst Dir Public-ServicesReference date May 9 2018

Contact Email flofasolakeworthorg Contact Phone 561-586-1720

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contract

Contract No Date Services Provided 2014 Project Amount fees varied Multiple to 2018 (range $10000shy

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Services included multiple municipal engineering projects including survey roadway design utility design and coordination (water wastewater stormwater other) along with project management

Needs Satisfactory Excellent NotPlease rate your experience with the Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D GJ D b Accuracy D D Ii] D c Deliverables D Ii] DD

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [i] D c Turnover D D D [X]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D 0 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [X] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION Fe COUNTY USE ONLrbullbull

Verified via MAIL __VERBAL Verified by Division ~wgtgt Date 5~3ol20t8 All information provided to Broward County Is subject lo verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect slalements made in support ol this response may be used by the

OZ~id~~~~j~r rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and m~~~(iirve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Cour~ iG

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - ARCADIS US INC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts

VS0000013130 VS00013130 - ARCADIS US INC Prime Work Auth Vendor SummaryProjects

PURCHASING 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold Procurement No Fixed Contracts FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Favorites Past 5 Years Prime Vendor

Sub Vendor From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 10042017 Purchase Order

Evaluation Purchase Orders 1 POs With A Total Amt Of $20000000 Log Off Paid To Dt ($12132949) Balance $7867051

Contracts Purchase Orders Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx 6192018

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Finish

PURCHASING Weighted Scores Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract FileRoom DashBoard Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number FileRoom Insert

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel Favorites Prime Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Service Evaluation

6132017 YES 486 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Goals Compliance Evaluation

10272016 YES 460 View Docs (0)

6272018

Project Management Information System

Close

Contracts Central Administration

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9130 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-24

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6182018 YES 355 View Docs (1)

Proj Nbr 9320 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-20

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6132018 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9290 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-23

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1122018 YES 494 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-21

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12182017 YES 488 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10162017 YES 473 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

8252017 YES 495 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9321 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-19

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

7112017 YES 476 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-17

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2272017 YES 400 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

10132016 YES 384 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-12

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

5202016 YES 405 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9018 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-06

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10192015 YES 448 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

3202015 YES 385 View Docs (0)

Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL CONSULTANTS

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Project Management Information System

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-04

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12122014 YES 437 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-08

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1242014 YES 423 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-02

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2282014 YES 452 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC

VC0000044184 VC00044184 - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres PS $001 Used $000 Remain $001 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $354848400 Closed 0 Total $000 Total Current Retainage Balance For All Contracts $793370 No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 06292015 Purchase Orders 2 POs With A Total Amt Of $362317900 Paid To Dt ($218795160) Balance $143522740

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 40803 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9058 - DISTRICT 3A POTABLE WATER STORAGE

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1220410P1 - Consultant Engineering Services for Potable Water FixedOpen Contracts Storage Tanks and Pumping Systems Work Auth Prime Vendor CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Periodic Final Finish

Log Off Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type

Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

6232015 8302017 413 Approved 8312017 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard

Enter Vendor Name (or a portion of) Then Click Search - Wilcards Are Permitted (ie wa wawainc) Florida Technical Consultants

Search Reset Finish

No Vendors Found For Your Search Try Again

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41005 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score Go

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0773

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

12122017 YES 430 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

8302016 YES 438 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Final Consultant Evaluation 3142016 YES 478 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0706

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

142016 YES 402 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9016OES - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0731

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

10192015 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0748

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

612015 YES 467 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

2192015 YES 500 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0754

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

252015 YES 409 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0755

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

1242014 YES 415 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8974 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0758

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

6202014 YES 393 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr

WATER amp WASTEWATER

Final Consultant Work Authorization 572014 YES 423 View Docs

(0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

HS0746 ENGINEERING Evaluation

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

4302014 YES 475 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Evaluation 4302014 YES 493 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0710

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

3172014 YES 395 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0753

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

1212014 YES 380 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0763

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

11192013 YES 450 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0775

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 408 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals

Finish

Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed FileRoom DashBoard Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization FileRoom Insert NumberFavorites

Prime Vendor Export To Excel Sub Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0772

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 417 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0771

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

2262013 YES 410 View Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 29: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

a N ~ IL) IL) N u z a_

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLO RI DA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R211 5559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Walter Wernecke RA Title Sr Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email WWERNECKEhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Hollywood Marina Restrooms

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

04152015 to Present 7500000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor OSubconsultanVSubcontractor n ~U t1

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

-0 Vgt Description of services provided by VendorO ~ ~ Q) Structural Design and Construction Inspection Services i co Q m ~- c E c0

i E gt Oo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not () uu Appllcable O

E~ referenced Vendor Improvement iii ~sectoO 1 Vendors Quality of Service B mu a Responsive D D

b Accuracy DD c Deliverables D DD

2 Vendors Organization D Da Staff expertise v D b Professionalism~ D D c Turnover D ~D

3 Timeliness of D a Project b Deliverables D ~

4 Pec~~11~$~hinJ~~qt lfr D D 5 Cooperation with f ~

a Your Firm D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D

Al lnfonn1tion pRgttded IO Brwd Cltgtunly lo 1ubjecl IO ibllon vsor ~middot Iha icl-bullmiddot ~ ir-ect slalemenls mode In _ol lhb _ moy ti used by he County as a basis lot rejecUon rnclnlon cl the eward or tonnlnallan of lhl connct 1nd may bullllo 11 the basis for dobalment of Vendor IQtulnl IO SICllOn 21119 at lhe Broword County Procurement Code

Cl ltraquo I() I() I() N ()

Cl z

BRltJWARD ~ middot COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORl OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Davie

Contact Name Emilio DeSimone Title Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email Emilio_DeSimonedavie-fl gov Contact Phone 954-797-1085

Name of Referenced Project Pavillion 5 Linear Park

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

B-17-123 09152015 to 2700000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor O SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es O No If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

0 Description of services provided by Vendor O Q)

iii c Structural Design and Construction Inspection ServicesoQ

CDi-

0cc E gt=gt E ()Oo O () () Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

ii) -e i- Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 111 cs

B ioO

J 1 Vendors Quality of Service Q ()

a Responsive D D b Accuracy D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization []Ll Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D Dtr

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [g D b Deliverables D D ar D

4 Project completed within budget [1tD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) cgD D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via l EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by ~h~ Division WlI Etgt Date 0 f l~o I 8 All lnformaUon provided lO Broward County Is eubJect 10 verifutlon Vendor ecknOMedgoo that lnaocurote unNlhlul or Incorrect statamenle made In aupl)Ort of this reaponse may be used by lho County et o baampla for rejection realtluion of the award or lermlnallon of tho eon1fllcl ond moy olao aorvo os ho basis for debarmont of Vondor purauenl lo Section 21119 of the Broward Counly Procuremen1 Code

0 0 agt a c () z 0

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Terrence Comiskey AIA Title Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email TCOMISKEYhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Van Buren Parking Garage

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PK 14-053 Nov 2014 to Present 8310000

Vendors role in Project t8(Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

o~ Description of services provided by Vendor 1 Q)ltO c Structural Design and Conslructlon Inspection Services 0 Q

0~Jl ccE l E enOo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

gtshy

uu O Improvement Applicable ffireferenced Vendor

~sect 1 Vendors Quality of Service 1 ~

oOau a Responsive D ~ D b Accuracy B D D

D D [- Dc Deliverables

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tum over D D D g

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ D Subcontractor(s )S ubcons u ltant( s)b D D ~ D

c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D yenj D Additional Comments provide on sdditlonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION ~NTY USE ONLY0

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by kW Division W-1-(i~ Date EJo(a~t8 Al lnform1Uon PltOVlded lo Browald Ccxnty It IUbjoct to vorificallon Vendor eoknowfodgea thal lnaewralt U111MhlJI deg inlaquogtlaquobullel amptal11ants made In eupporl of lhls relj)Onse may be used by Iha Counly es a balls l0t rcfecllon rescfuloltI of tho ew1rd or 1ermtnaU0lt1 ol lhbull conllllCI and may elao urve 11 lho basis for dabarmenl of Vondor pursuanl lo Secllon 21 119 of he erowald COUlly CiProcurement Code

~ N ii

00

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 aOWllrp Commficumlref Bid PNC2116615B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Pompano Beach FL

Contact Name Mr A Randolph Brown Title Utilities Director Reference date April 30 2018

Contact Email randolphbrowncopbflcom Contact Phone 954-545-7043

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 201 o Project Amount fees varied

Multiple

Vendors role in Project IKJ Prime Vendor

to 2018

osubconsultanUSubcontractor

(range $10000shy$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D ~ D D c Deliverables D ~ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D ~ D D b Professionalism D D ~ D C Turnover D El DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ 0 b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D [BJ D n c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [XJ o ~

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed) amp~~it -THIS SECTION ~COUNTY USE ONL y-bullbull

Verified via ~AIL __VERBAL Verified by 1lt4 )~ Division N WE O Date 5 faol Z1 18

All lnformotlon providod to BltownrltI Cou nty it aubjoct O verification VendOr acknowledges that lnaccornto untruthful or incorroct 11atomon1s made in support of this response may be used by tho

411p~~)~~J rojoclion roscissioo ol lho award or 1orroinalion of tho contract and roay also s01vo as lhbull basis f0lt d~arroont of VondOf pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward Cou)l1

Bid Sync p 73

40

5232018

Broward County Board of Bid PNC2116659B 1 County Commissioners

B~aWARD gt1- t COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Loxahatchee River Environmental Control District

Contact Name Mr Kris Dean Title Director of Engineering Reference date May 9 2018

Contact Email krisdeanloxahatcheeriverorg Contact Phone 561-747-5700

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 2001 Project Amount fees varied (range $10000shyMultiple to 2018 $250000)

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IR)Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D ~ D D b Accuracy D 0 D D c Deliverables D IBJ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D IB] D D b Professionalism D ~ D D c Turnover D [8J D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D [8J D D b Deliverables D m D D

4 Project completed within budget D ~ D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D ~ D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D Ii] D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D ~ D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SE~ FOR~USE ONLY

Verified via _lEMAIL __VERBAL Verified by ~lt Division fWeb Date I

All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untrulhful or incorrecl slatements made In support of this response may be used by the lJl~~~l~~jSfiir rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and mll~~~ere as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Co)f 10

Broward County Board of Bid PNC21166$9B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A l

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Lake Worth FL

Contact Name Mr Felipe Lofaso TitleAsst Dir Public-ServicesReference date May 9 2018

Contact Email flofasolakeworthorg Contact Phone 561-586-1720

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contract

Contract No Date Services Provided 2014 Project Amount fees varied Multiple to 2018 (range $10000shy

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Services included multiple municipal engineering projects including survey roadway design utility design and coordination (water wastewater stormwater other) along with project management

Needs Satisfactory Excellent NotPlease rate your experience with the Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D GJ D b Accuracy D D Ii] D c Deliverables D Ii] DD

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [i] D c Turnover D D D [X]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D 0 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [X] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION Fe COUNTY USE ONLrbullbull

Verified via MAIL __VERBAL Verified by Division ~wgtgt Date 5~3ol20t8 All information provided to Broward County Is subject lo verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect slalements made in support ol this response may be used by the

OZ~id~~~~j~r rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and m~~~(iirve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Cour~ iG

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - ARCADIS US INC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts

VS0000013130 VS00013130 - ARCADIS US INC Prime Work Auth Vendor SummaryProjects

PURCHASING 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold Procurement No Fixed Contracts FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Favorites Past 5 Years Prime Vendor

Sub Vendor From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 10042017 Purchase Order

Evaluation Purchase Orders 1 POs With A Total Amt Of $20000000 Log Off Paid To Dt ($12132949) Balance $7867051

Contracts Purchase Orders Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx 6192018

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Finish

PURCHASING Weighted Scores Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract FileRoom DashBoard Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number FileRoom Insert

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel Favorites Prime Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Service Evaluation

6132017 YES 486 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Goals Compliance Evaluation

10272016 YES 460 View Docs (0)

6272018

Project Management Information System

Close

Contracts Central Administration

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9130 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-24

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6182018 YES 355 View Docs (1)

Proj Nbr 9320 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-20

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6132018 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9290 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-23

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1122018 YES 494 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-21

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12182017 YES 488 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10162017 YES 473 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

8252017 YES 495 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9321 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-19

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

7112017 YES 476 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-17

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2272017 YES 400 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

10132016 YES 384 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-12

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

5202016 YES 405 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9018 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-06

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10192015 YES 448 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

3202015 YES 385 View Docs (0)

Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL CONSULTANTS

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Project Management Information System

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-04

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12122014 YES 437 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-08

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1242014 YES 423 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-02

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2282014 YES 452 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC

VC0000044184 VC00044184 - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres PS $001 Used $000 Remain $001 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $354848400 Closed 0 Total $000 Total Current Retainage Balance For All Contracts $793370 No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 06292015 Purchase Orders 2 POs With A Total Amt Of $362317900 Paid To Dt ($218795160) Balance $143522740

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 40803 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9058 - DISTRICT 3A POTABLE WATER STORAGE

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1220410P1 - Consultant Engineering Services for Potable Water FixedOpen Contracts Storage Tanks and Pumping Systems Work Auth Prime Vendor CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Periodic Final Finish

Log Off Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type

Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

6232015 8302017 413 Approved 8312017 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard

Enter Vendor Name (or a portion of) Then Click Search - Wilcards Are Permitted (ie wa wawainc) Florida Technical Consultants

Search Reset Finish

No Vendors Found For Your Search Try Again

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41005 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score Go

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0773

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

12122017 YES 430 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

8302016 YES 438 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Final Consultant Evaluation 3142016 YES 478 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0706

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

142016 YES 402 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9016OES - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0731

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

10192015 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0748

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

612015 YES 467 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

2192015 YES 500 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0754

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

252015 YES 409 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0755

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

1242014 YES 415 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8974 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0758

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

6202014 YES 393 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr

WATER amp WASTEWATER

Final Consultant Work Authorization 572014 YES 423 View Docs

(0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

HS0746 ENGINEERING Evaluation

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

4302014 YES 475 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Evaluation 4302014 YES 493 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0710

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

3172014 YES 395 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0753

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

1212014 YES 380 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0763

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

11192013 YES 450 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0775

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 408 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals

Finish

Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed FileRoom DashBoard Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization FileRoom Insert NumberFavorites

Prime Vendor Export To Excel Sub Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0772

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 417 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0771

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

2262013 YES 410 View Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 30: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

Cl ltraquo I() I() I() N ()

Cl z

BRltJWARD ~ middot COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORl OA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Town of Davie

Contact Name Emilio DeSimone Title Project Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email Emilio_DeSimonedavie-fl gov Contact Phone 954-797-1085

Name of Referenced Project Pavillion 5 Linear Park

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

B-17-123 09152015 to 2700000

Vendors role in Project Prime Vendor O SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es O No If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

0 Description of services provided by Vendor O Q)

iii c Structural Design and Construction Inspection ServicesoQ

CDi-

0cc E gt=gt E ()Oo O () () Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

ii) -e i- Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor 111 cs

B ioO

J 1 Vendors Quality of Service Q ()

a Responsive D D b Accuracy D D c Deliverables D D D

2 Vendors Organization []Ll Da Staff expertise D D b Professionalism D D D c Turnover D D Dtr

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [g D b Deliverables D D ar D

4 Project completed within budget [1tD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D ~ D c Regulatory Agency(ies) cgD D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet If needed)

THIS SECTION FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Verified via l EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by ~h~ Division WlI Etgt Date 0 f l~o I 8 All lnformaUon provided lO Broward County Is eubJect 10 verifutlon Vendor ecknOMedgoo that lnaocurote unNlhlul or Incorrect statamenle made In aupl)Ort of this reaponse may be used by lho County et o baampla for rejection realtluion of the award or lermlnallon of tho eon1fllcl ond moy olao aorvo os ho basis for debarmont of Vondor purauenl lo Section 21119 of the Broward Counly Procuremen1 Code

0 0 agt a c () z 0

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Terrence Comiskey AIA Title Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email TCOMISKEYhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Van Buren Parking Garage

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PK 14-053 Nov 2014 to Present 8310000

Vendors role in Project t8(Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

o~ Description of services provided by Vendor 1 Q)ltO c Structural Design and Conslructlon Inspection Services 0 Q

0~Jl ccE l E enOo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

gtshy

uu O Improvement Applicable ffireferenced Vendor

~sect 1 Vendors Quality of Service 1 ~

oOau a Responsive D ~ D b Accuracy B D D

D D [- Dc Deliverables

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tum over D D D g

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ D Subcontractor(s )S ubcons u ltant( s)b D D ~ D

c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D yenj D Additional Comments provide on sdditlonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION ~NTY USE ONLY0

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by kW Division W-1-(i~ Date EJo(a~t8 Al lnform1Uon PltOVlded lo Browald Ccxnty It IUbjoct to vorificallon Vendor eoknowfodgea thal lnaewralt U111MhlJI deg inlaquogtlaquobullel amptal11ants made In eupporl of lhls relj)Onse may be used by Iha Counly es a balls l0t rcfecllon rescfuloltI of tho ew1rd or 1ermtnaU0lt1 ol lhbull conllllCI and may elao urve 11 lho basis for dabarmenl of Vondor pursuanl lo Secllon 21 119 of he erowald COUlly CiProcurement Code

~ N ii

00

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 aOWllrp Commficumlref Bid PNC2116615B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Pompano Beach FL

Contact Name Mr A Randolph Brown Title Utilities Director Reference date April 30 2018

Contact Email randolphbrowncopbflcom Contact Phone 954-545-7043

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 201 o Project Amount fees varied

Multiple

Vendors role in Project IKJ Prime Vendor

to 2018

osubconsultanUSubcontractor

(range $10000shy$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D ~ D D c Deliverables D ~ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D ~ D D b Professionalism D D ~ D C Turnover D El DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ 0 b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D [BJ D n c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [XJ o ~

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed) amp~~it -THIS SECTION ~COUNTY USE ONL y-bullbull

Verified via ~AIL __VERBAL Verified by 1lt4 )~ Division N WE O Date 5 faol Z1 18

All lnformotlon providod to BltownrltI Cou nty it aubjoct O verification VendOr acknowledges that lnaccornto untruthful or incorroct 11atomon1s made in support of this response may be used by tho

411p~~)~~J rojoclion roscissioo ol lho award or 1orroinalion of tho contract and roay also s01vo as lhbull basis f0lt d~arroont of VondOf pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward Cou)l1

Bid Sync p 73

40

5232018

Broward County Board of Bid PNC2116659B 1 County Commissioners

B~aWARD gt1- t COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Loxahatchee River Environmental Control District

Contact Name Mr Kris Dean Title Director of Engineering Reference date May 9 2018

Contact Email krisdeanloxahatcheeriverorg Contact Phone 561-747-5700

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 2001 Project Amount fees varied (range $10000shyMultiple to 2018 $250000)

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IR)Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D ~ D D b Accuracy D 0 D D c Deliverables D IBJ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D IB] D D b Professionalism D ~ D D c Turnover D [8J D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D [8J D D b Deliverables D m D D

4 Project completed within budget D ~ D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D ~ D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D Ii] D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D ~ D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SE~ FOR~USE ONLY

Verified via _lEMAIL __VERBAL Verified by ~lt Division fWeb Date I

All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untrulhful or incorrecl slatements made In support of this response may be used by the lJl~~~l~~jSfiir rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and mll~~~ere as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Co)f 10

Broward County Board of Bid PNC21166$9B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A l

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Lake Worth FL

Contact Name Mr Felipe Lofaso TitleAsst Dir Public-ServicesReference date May 9 2018

Contact Email flofasolakeworthorg Contact Phone 561-586-1720

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contract

Contract No Date Services Provided 2014 Project Amount fees varied Multiple to 2018 (range $10000shy

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Services included multiple municipal engineering projects including survey roadway design utility design and coordination (water wastewater stormwater other) along with project management

Needs Satisfactory Excellent NotPlease rate your experience with the Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D GJ D b Accuracy D D Ii] D c Deliverables D Ii] DD

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [i] D c Turnover D D D [X]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D 0 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [X] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION Fe COUNTY USE ONLrbullbull

Verified via MAIL __VERBAL Verified by Division ~wgtgt Date 5~3ol20t8 All information provided to Broward County Is subject lo verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect slalements made in support ol this response may be used by the

OZ~id~~~~j~r rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and m~~~(iirve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Cour~ iG

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - ARCADIS US INC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts

VS0000013130 VS00013130 - ARCADIS US INC Prime Work Auth Vendor SummaryProjects

PURCHASING 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold Procurement No Fixed Contracts FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Favorites Past 5 Years Prime Vendor

Sub Vendor From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 10042017 Purchase Order

Evaluation Purchase Orders 1 POs With A Total Amt Of $20000000 Log Off Paid To Dt ($12132949) Balance $7867051

Contracts Purchase Orders Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx 6192018

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Finish

PURCHASING Weighted Scores Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract FileRoom DashBoard Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number FileRoom Insert

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel Favorites Prime Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Service Evaluation

6132017 YES 486 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Goals Compliance Evaluation

10272016 YES 460 View Docs (0)

6272018

Project Management Information System

Close

Contracts Central Administration

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9130 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-24

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6182018 YES 355 View Docs (1)

Proj Nbr 9320 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-20

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6132018 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9290 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-23

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1122018 YES 494 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-21

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12182017 YES 488 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10162017 YES 473 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

8252017 YES 495 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9321 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-19

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

7112017 YES 476 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-17

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2272017 YES 400 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

10132016 YES 384 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-12

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

5202016 YES 405 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9018 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-06

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10192015 YES 448 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

3202015 YES 385 View Docs (0)

Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL CONSULTANTS

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Project Management Information System

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-04

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12122014 YES 437 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-08

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1242014 YES 423 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-02

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2282014 YES 452 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC

VC0000044184 VC00044184 - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres PS $001 Used $000 Remain $001 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $354848400 Closed 0 Total $000 Total Current Retainage Balance For All Contracts $793370 No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 06292015 Purchase Orders 2 POs With A Total Amt Of $362317900 Paid To Dt ($218795160) Balance $143522740

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 40803 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9058 - DISTRICT 3A POTABLE WATER STORAGE

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1220410P1 - Consultant Engineering Services for Potable Water FixedOpen Contracts Storage Tanks and Pumping Systems Work Auth Prime Vendor CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Periodic Final Finish

Log Off Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type

Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

6232015 8302017 413 Approved 8312017 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard

Enter Vendor Name (or a portion of) Then Click Search - Wilcards Are Permitted (ie wa wawainc) Florida Technical Consultants

Search Reset Finish

No Vendors Found For Your Search Try Again

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41005 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score Go

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0773

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

12122017 YES 430 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

8302016 YES 438 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Final Consultant Evaluation 3142016 YES 478 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0706

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

142016 YES 402 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9016OES - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0731

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

10192015 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0748

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

612015 YES 467 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

2192015 YES 500 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0754

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

252015 YES 409 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0755

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

1242014 YES 415 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8974 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0758

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

6202014 YES 393 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr

WATER amp WASTEWATER

Final Consultant Work Authorization 572014 YES 423 View Docs

(0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

HS0746 ENGINEERING Evaluation

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

4302014 YES 475 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Evaluation 4302014 YES 493 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0710

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

3172014 YES 395 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0753

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

1212014 YES 380 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0763

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

11192013 YES 450 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0775

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 408 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals

Finish

Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed FileRoom DashBoard Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization FileRoom Insert NumberFavorites

Prime Vendor Export To Excel Sub Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0772

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 417 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0771

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

2262013 YES 410 View Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 31: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

0 0 agt a c () z 0

Vendor Reference Verification Form FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

RFP No R2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for LakdasYohalem Engineering Inc

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Hollywood

Contact Name Terrence Comiskey AIA Title Manager Reference date 051518

Contact Email TCOMISKEYhollywoodflorg Contact Phone 954-921-3900

Name of Referenced Project Van Buren Parking Garage

Contract No Date Services Provided Project Amount

PK 14-053 Nov 2014 to Present 8310000

Vendors role in Project t8(Prime Vendor 0SubconsultanUSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again ~es ONo If No please specify In Additional Comments (below)

o~ Description of services provided by Vendor 1 Q)ltO c Structural Design and Conslructlon Inspection Services 0 Q

0~Jl ccE l E enOo Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not

gtshy

uu O Improvement Applicable ffireferenced Vendor

~sect 1 Vendors Quality of Service 1 ~

oOau a Responsive D ~ D b Accuracy B D D

D D [- Dc Deliverables

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D ~ D b Professionalism D D ~ D c Tum over D D D g

3 Timeliness of a Project D D D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget D D ~ D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ D Subcontractor(s )S ubcons u ltant( s)b D D ~ D

c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D yenj D Additional Comments provide on sdditlonal sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION ~NTY USE ONLY0

Verified via EMAIL _VERBAL Verified by kW Division W-1-(i~ Date EJo(a~t8 Al lnform1Uon PltOVlded lo Browald Ccxnty It IUbjoct to vorificallon Vendor eoknowfodgea thal lnaewralt U111MhlJI deg inlaquogtlaquobullel amptal11ants made In eupporl of lhls relj)Onse may be used by Iha Counly es a balls l0t rcfecllon rescfuloltI of tho ew1rd or 1ermtnaU0lt1 ol lhbull conllllCI and may elao urve 11 lho basis for dabarmenl of Vondor pursuanl lo Secllon 21 119 of he erowald COUlly CiProcurement Code

~ N ii

00

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 aOWllrp Commficumlref Bid PNC2116615B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Pompano Beach FL

Contact Name Mr A Randolph Brown Title Utilities Director Reference date April 30 2018

Contact Email randolphbrowncopbflcom Contact Phone 954-545-7043

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 201 o Project Amount fees varied

Multiple

Vendors role in Project IKJ Prime Vendor

to 2018

osubconsultanUSubcontractor

(range $10000shy$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D ~ D D c Deliverables D ~ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D ~ D D b Professionalism D D ~ D C Turnover D El DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ 0 b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D [BJ D n c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [XJ o ~

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed) amp~~it -THIS SECTION ~COUNTY USE ONL y-bullbull

Verified via ~AIL __VERBAL Verified by 1lt4 )~ Division N WE O Date 5 faol Z1 18

All lnformotlon providod to BltownrltI Cou nty it aubjoct O verification VendOr acknowledges that lnaccornto untruthful or incorroct 11atomon1s made in support of this response may be used by tho

411p~~)~~J rojoclion roscissioo ol lho award or 1orroinalion of tho contract and roay also s01vo as lhbull basis f0lt d~arroont of VondOf pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward Cou)l1

Bid Sync p 73

40

5232018

Broward County Board of Bid PNC2116659B 1 County Commissioners

B~aWARD gt1- t COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Loxahatchee River Environmental Control District

Contact Name Mr Kris Dean Title Director of Engineering Reference date May 9 2018

Contact Email krisdeanloxahatcheeriverorg Contact Phone 561-747-5700

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 2001 Project Amount fees varied (range $10000shyMultiple to 2018 $250000)

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IR)Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D ~ D D b Accuracy D 0 D D c Deliverables D IBJ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D IB] D D b Professionalism D ~ D D c Turnover D [8J D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D [8J D D b Deliverables D m D D

4 Project completed within budget D ~ D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D ~ D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D Ii] D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D ~ D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SE~ FOR~USE ONLY

Verified via _lEMAIL __VERBAL Verified by ~lt Division fWeb Date I

All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untrulhful or incorrecl slatements made In support of this response may be used by the lJl~~~l~~jSfiir rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and mll~~~ere as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Co)f 10

Broward County Board of Bid PNC21166$9B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A l

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Lake Worth FL

Contact Name Mr Felipe Lofaso TitleAsst Dir Public-ServicesReference date May 9 2018

Contact Email flofasolakeworthorg Contact Phone 561-586-1720

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contract

Contract No Date Services Provided 2014 Project Amount fees varied Multiple to 2018 (range $10000shy

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Services included multiple municipal engineering projects including survey roadway design utility design and coordination (water wastewater stormwater other) along with project management

Needs Satisfactory Excellent NotPlease rate your experience with the Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D GJ D b Accuracy D D Ii] D c Deliverables D Ii] DD

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [i] D c Turnover D D D [X]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D 0 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [X] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION Fe COUNTY USE ONLrbullbull

Verified via MAIL __VERBAL Verified by Division ~wgtgt Date 5~3ol20t8 All information provided to Broward County Is subject lo verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect slalements made in support ol this response may be used by the

OZ~id~~~~j~r rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and m~~~(iirve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Cour~ iG

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - ARCADIS US INC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts

VS0000013130 VS00013130 - ARCADIS US INC Prime Work Auth Vendor SummaryProjects

PURCHASING 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold Procurement No Fixed Contracts FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Favorites Past 5 Years Prime Vendor

Sub Vendor From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 10042017 Purchase Order

Evaluation Purchase Orders 1 POs With A Total Amt Of $20000000 Log Off Paid To Dt ($12132949) Balance $7867051

Contracts Purchase Orders Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx 6192018

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Finish

PURCHASING Weighted Scores Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract FileRoom DashBoard Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number FileRoom Insert

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel Favorites Prime Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Service Evaluation

6132017 YES 486 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Goals Compliance Evaluation

10272016 YES 460 View Docs (0)

6272018

Project Management Information System

Close

Contracts Central Administration

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9130 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-24

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6182018 YES 355 View Docs (1)

Proj Nbr 9320 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-20

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6132018 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9290 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-23

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1122018 YES 494 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-21

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12182017 YES 488 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10162017 YES 473 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

8252017 YES 495 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9321 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-19

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

7112017 YES 476 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-17

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2272017 YES 400 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

10132016 YES 384 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-12

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

5202016 YES 405 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9018 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-06

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10192015 YES 448 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

3202015 YES 385 View Docs (0)

Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL CONSULTANTS

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Project Management Information System

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-04

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12122014 YES 437 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-08

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1242014 YES 423 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-02

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2282014 YES 452 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC

VC0000044184 VC00044184 - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres PS $001 Used $000 Remain $001 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $354848400 Closed 0 Total $000 Total Current Retainage Balance For All Contracts $793370 No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 06292015 Purchase Orders 2 POs With A Total Amt Of $362317900 Paid To Dt ($218795160) Balance $143522740

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 40803 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9058 - DISTRICT 3A POTABLE WATER STORAGE

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1220410P1 - Consultant Engineering Services for Potable Water FixedOpen Contracts Storage Tanks and Pumping Systems Work Auth Prime Vendor CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Periodic Final Finish

Log Off Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type

Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

6232015 8302017 413 Approved 8312017 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard

Enter Vendor Name (or a portion of) Then Click Search - Wilcards Are Permitted (ie wa wawainc) Florida Technical Consultants

Search Reset Finish

No Vendors Found For Your Search Try Again

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41005 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score Go

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0773

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

12122017 YES 430 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

8302016 YES 438 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Final Consultant Evaluation 3142016 YES 478 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0706

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

142016 YES 402 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9016OES - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0731

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

10192015 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0748

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

612015 YES 467 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

2192015 YES 500 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0754

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

252015 YES 409 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0755

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

1242014 YES 415 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8974 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0758

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

6202014 YES 393 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr

WATER amp WASTEWATER

Final Consultant Work Authorization 572014 YES 423 View Docs

(0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

HS0746 ENGINEERING Evaluation

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

4302014 YES 475 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Evaluation 4302014 YES 493 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0710

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

3172014 YES 395 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0753

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

1212014 YES 380 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0763

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

11192013 YES 450 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0775

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 408 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals

Finish

Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed FileRoom DashBoard Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization FileRoom Insert NumberFavorites

Prime Vendor Export To Excel Sub Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0772

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 417 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0771

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

2262013 YES 410 View Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 32: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

Broward County Board of PNC2115559P1 aOWllrp Commficumlref Bid PNC2116615B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Pompano Beach FL

Contact Name Mr A Randolph Brown Title Utilities Director Reference date April 30 2018

Contact Email randolphbrowncopbflcom Contact Phone 954-545-7043

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 201 o Project Amount fees varied

Multiple

Vendors role in Project IKJ Prime Vendor

to 2018

osubconsultanUSubcontractor

(range $10000shy$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes ONo If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D [] D b Accuracy D ~ D D c Deliverables D ~ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D ~ D D b Professionalism D D ~ D C Turnover D El DD

3 Timeliness of a Project D D [] D b Deliverables D D ~ D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D ~ 0 b Subcontractor( s )Subconsultant( s) D [BJ D n c Regulatory Agency(ies) D [XJ o ~

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed) amp~~it -THIS SECTION ~COUNTY USE ONL y-bullbull

Verified via ~AIL __VERBAL Verified by 1lt4 )~ Division N WE O Date 5 faol Z1 18

All lnformotlon providod to BltownrltI Cou nty it aubjoct O verification VendOr acknowledges that lnaccornto untruthful or incorroct 11atomon1s made in support of this response may be used by tho

411p~~)~~J rojoclion roscissioo ol lho award or 1orroinalion of tho contract and roay also s01vo as lhbull basis f0lt d~arroont of VondOf pursuant to Section 21119 of the Broward Cou)l1

Bid Sync p 73

40

5232018

Broward County Board of Bid PNC2116659B 1 County Commissioners

B~aWARD gt1- t COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Loxahatchee River Environmental Control District

Contact Name Mr Kris Dean Title Director of Engineering Reference date May 9 2018

Contact Email krisdeanloxahatcheeriverorg Contact Phone 561-747-5700

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 2001 Project Amount fees varied (range $10000shyMultiple to 2018 $250000)

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IR)Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D ~ D D b Accuracy D 0 D D c Deliverables D IBJ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D IB] D D b Professionalism D ~ D D c Turnover D [8J D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D [8J D D b Deliverables D m D D

4 Project completed within budget D ~ D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D ~ D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D Ii] D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D ~ D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SE~ FOR~USE ONLY

Verified via _lEMAIL __VERBAL Verified by ~lt Division fWeb Date I

All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untrulhful or incorrecl slatements made In support of this response may be used by the lJl~~~l~~jSfiir rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and mll~~~ere as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Co)f 10

Broward County Board of Bid PNC21166$9B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A l

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Lake Worth FL

Contact Name Mr Felipe Lofaso TitleAsst Dir Public-ServicesReference date May 9 2018

Contact Email flofasolakeworthorg Contact Phone 561-586-1720

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contract

Contract No Date Services Provided 2014 Project Amount fees varied Multiple to 2018 (range $10000shy

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Services included multiple municipal engineering projects including survey roadway design utility design and coordination (water wastewater stormwater other) along with project management

Needs Satisfactory Excellent NotPlease rate your experience with the Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D GJ D b Accuracy D D Ii] D c Deliverables D Ii] DD

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [i] D c Turnover D D D [X]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D 0 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [X] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION Fe COUNTY USE ONLrbullbull

Verified via MAIL __VERBAL Verified by Division ~wgtgt Date 5~3ol20t8 All information provided to Broward County Is subject lo verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect slalements made in support ol this response may be used by the

OZ~id~~~~j~r rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and m~~~(iirve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Cour~ iG

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - ARCADIS US INC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts

VS0000013130 VS00013130 - ARCADIS US INC Prime Work Auth Vendor SummaryProjects

PURCHASING 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold Procurement No Fixed Contracts FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Favorites Past 5 Years Prime Vendor

Sub Vendor From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 10042017 Purchase Order

Evaluation Purchase Orders 1 POs With A Total Amt Of $20000000 Log Off Paid To Dt ($12132949) Balance $7867051

Contracts Purchase Orders Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx 6192018

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Finish

PURCHASING Weighted Scores Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract FileRoom DashBoard Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number FileRoom Insert

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel Favorites Prime Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Service Evaluation

6132017 YES 486 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Goals Compliance Evaluation

10272016 YES 460 View Docs (0)

6272018

Project Management Information System

Close

Contracts Central Administration

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9130 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-24

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6182018 YES 355 View Docs (1)

Proj Nbr 9320 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-20

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6132018 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9290 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-23

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1122018 YES 494 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-21

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12182017 YES 488 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10162017 YES 473 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

8252017 YES 495 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9321 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-19

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

7112017 YES 476 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-17

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2272017 YES 400 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

10132016 YES 384 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-12

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

5202016 YES 405 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9018 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-06

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10192015 YES 448 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

3202015 YES 385 View Docs (0)

Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL CONSULTANTS

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Project Management Information System

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-04

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12122014 YES 437 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-08

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1242014 YES 423 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-02

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2282014 YES 452 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC

VC0000044184 VC00044184 - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres PS $001 Used $000 Remain $001 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $354848400 Closed 0 Total $000 Total Current Retainage Balance For All Contracts $793370 No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 06292015 Purchase Orders 2 POs With A Total Amt Of $362317900 Paid To Dt ($218795160) Balance $143522740

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 40803 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9058 - DISTRICT 3A POTABLE WATER STORAGE

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1220410P1 - Consultant Engineering Services for Potable Water FixedOpen Contracts Storage Tanks and Pumping Systems Work Auth Prime Vendor CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Periodic Final Finish

Log Off Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type

Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

6232015 8302017 413 Approved 8312017 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard

Enter Vendor Name (or a portion of) Then Click Search - Wilcards Are Permitted (ie wa wawainc) Florida Technical Consultants

Search Reset Finish

No Vendors Found For Your Search Try Again

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41005 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score Go

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0773

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

12122017 YES 430 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

8302016 YES 438 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Final Consultant Evaluation 3142016 YES 478 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0706

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

142016 YES 402 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9016OES - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0731

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

10192015 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0748

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

612015 YES 467 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

2192015 YES 500 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0754

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

252015 YES 409 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0755

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

1242014 YES 415 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8974 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0758

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

6202014 YES 393 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr

WATER amp WASTEWATER

Final Consultant Work Authorization 572014 YES 423 View Docs

(0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

HS0746 ENGINEERING Evaluation

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

4302014 YES 475 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Evaluation 4302014 YES 493 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0710

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

3172014 YES 395 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0753

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

1212014 YES 380 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0763

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

11192013 YES 450 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0775

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 408 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals

Finish

Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed FileRoom DashBoard Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization FileRoom Insert NumberFavorites

Prime Vendor Export To Excel Sub Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0772

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 417 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0771

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

2262013 YES 410 View Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 33: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

Broward County Board of Bid PNC2116659B 1 County Commissioners

B~aWARD gt1- t COUNTY Vendor Reference Verification Form

FLORIDA

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

Loxahatchee River Environmental Control District

Contact Name Mr Kris Dean Title Director of Engineering Reference date May 9 2018

Contact Email krisdeanloxahatcheeriverorg Contact Phone 561-747-5700

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contracts

Contract No Date Services Provided 2001 Project Amount fees varied (range $10000shyMultiple to 2018 $250000)

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

Would you use this vendor again IR)Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor

Please rate your experience with the Needs Satisfactory Excellent Not Improvement Applicablereferenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D ~ D D b Accuracy D 0 D D c Deliverables D IBJ D D

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D IB] D D b Professionalism D ~ D D c Turnover D [8J D D

3 Timeliness of a Project D [8J D D b Deliverables D m D D

4 Project completed within budget D ~ D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D ~ D D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D Ii] D D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D ~ D D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SE~ FOR~USE ONLY

Verified via _lEMAIL __VERBAL Verified by ~lt Division fWeb Date I

All information provided to Broward County is subject to verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untrulhful or incorrecl slatements made In support of this response may be used by the lJl~~~l~~jSfiir rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and mll~~~ere as the basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Co)f 10

Broward County Board of Bid PNC21166$9B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A l

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Lake Worth FL

Contact Name Mr Felipe Lofaso TitleAsst Dir Public-ServicesReference date May 9 2018

Contact Email flofasolakeworthorg Contact Phone 561-586-1720

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contract

Contract No Date Services Provided 2014 Project Amount fees varied Multiple to 2018 (range $10000shy

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Services included multiple municipal engineering projects including survey roadway design utility design and coordination (water wastewater stormwater other) along with project management

Needs Satisfactory Excellent NotPlease rate your experience with the Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D GJ D b Accuracy D D Ii] D c Deliverables D Ii] DD

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [i] D c Turnover D D D [X]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D 0 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [X] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION Fe COUNTY USE ONLrbullbull

Verified via MAIL __VERBAL Verified by Division ~wgtgt Date 5~3ol20t8 All information provided to Broward County Is subject lo verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect slalements made in support ol this response may be used by the

OZ~id~~~~j~r rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and m~~~(iirve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Cour~ iG

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - ARCADIS US INC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts

VS0000013130 VS00013130 - ARCADIS US INC Prime Work Auth Vendor SummaryProjects

PURCHASING 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold Procurement No Fixed Contracts FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Favorites Past 5 Years Prime Vendor

Sub Vendor From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 10042017 Purchase Order

Evaluation Purchase Orders 1 POs With A Total Amt Of $20000000 Log Off Paid To Dt ($12132949) Balance $7867051

Contracts Purchase Orders Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx 6192018

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Finish

PURCHASING Weighted Scores Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract FileRoom DashBoard Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number FileRoom Insert

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel Favorites Prime Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Service Evaluation

6132017 YES 486 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Goals Compliance Evaluation

10272016 YES 460 View Docs (0)

6272018

Project Management Information System

Close

Contracts Central Administration

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9130 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-24

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6182018 YES 355 View Docs (1)

Proj Nbr 9320 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-20

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6132018 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9290 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-23

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1122018 YES 494 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-21

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12182017 YES 488 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10162017 YES 473 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

8252017 YES 495 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9321 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-19

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

7112017 YES 476 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-17

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2272017 YES 400 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

10132016 YES 384 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-12

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

5202016 YES 405 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9018 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-06

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10192015 YES 448 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

3202015 YES 385 View Docs (0)

Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL CONSULTANTS

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Project Management Information System

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-04

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12122014 YES 437 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-08

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1242014 YES 423 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-02

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2282014 YES 452 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC

VC0000044184 VC00044184 - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres PS $001 Used $000 Remain $001 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $354848400 Closed 0 Total $000 Total Current Retainage Balance For All Contracts $793370 No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 06292015 Purchase Orders 2 POs With A Total Amt Of $362317900 Paid To Dt ($218795160) Balance $143522740

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 40803 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9058 - DISTRICT 3A POTABLE WATER STORAGE

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1220410P1 - Consultant Engineering Services for Potable Water FixedOpen Contracts Storage Tanks and Pumping Systems Work Auth Prime Vendor CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Periodic Final Finish

Log Off Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type

Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

6232015 8302017 413 Approved 8312017 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard

Enter Vendor Name (or a portion of) Then Click Search - Wilcards Are Permitted (ie wa wawainc) Florida Technical Consultants

Search Reset Finish

No Vendors Found For Your Search Try Again

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41005 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score Go

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0773

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

12122017 YES 430 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

8302016 YES 438 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Final Consultant Evaluation 3142016 YES 478 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0706

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

142016 YES 402 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9016OES - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0731

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

10192015 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0748

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

612015 YES 467 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

2192015 YES 500 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0754

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

252015 YES 409 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0755

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

1242014 YES 415 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8974 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0758

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

6202014 YES 393 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr

WATER amp WASTEWATER

Final Consultant Work Authorization 572014 YES 423 View Docs

(0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

HS0746 ENGINEERING Evaluation

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

4302014 YES 475 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Evaluation 4302014 YES 493 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0710

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

3172014 YES 395 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0753

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

1212014 YES 380 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0763

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

11192013 YES 450 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0775

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 408 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals

Finish

Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed FileRoom DashBoard Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization FileRoom Insert NumberFavorites

Prime Vendor Export To Excel Sub Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0772

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 417 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0771

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

2262013 YES 410 View Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 34: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

Broward County Board of Bid PNC21166$9B1 County Commissioners

Vendor Reference Verification Form F L 0 R I D A l

Broward County Solicitation No and Title

PNC2115559P1 Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

Reference for Mathews Consulting a Baxter amp Woodman Company

OrganizationFirm Name providing reference

City of Lake Worth FL

Contact Name Mr Felipe Lofaso TitleAsst Dir Public-ServicesReference date May 9 2018

Contact Email flofasolakeworthorg Contact Phone 561-586-1720

Name of Referenced Project Various Engineering Services as part of Continuing Services Contract

Contract No Date Services Provided 2014 Project Amount fees varied Multiple to 2018 (range $10000shy

Vendors role in Project IBJ Prime Vendor 0SubconsultantSubcontractor

$250000)

Would you use this vendor again ~Yes O No If No please specify in Additional Comments (below)

Description of services provided by Vendor Services included multiple municipal engineering projects including survey roadway design utility design and coordination (water wastewater stormwater other) along with project management

Needs Satisfactory Excellent NotPlease rate your experience with the Improvement Applicable referenced Vendor

1 Vendors Quality of Service a Responsive D D GJ D b Accuracy D D Ii] D c Deliverables D Ii] DD

2 Vendors Organization a Staff expertise D D 0 D b Professionalism D D [i] D c Turnover D D D [X]

3 Timeliness of a Project D D ~ D b Deliverables D D 0 D

4 Project completed within budget [XJD D D 5 Cooperation with

a Your Firm D D [] D b Subcontractor(s)Subconsultant(s) D D 0 D c Regulatory Agency(ies) D D [X] D

Additional Comments (provide on additional sheet if needed)

THIS SECTION Fe COUNTY USE ONLrbullbull

Verified via MAIL __VERBAL Verified by Division ~wgtgt Date 5~3ol20t8 All information provided to Broward County Is subject lo verification Vendor acknowledges that inaccurate untruthful or incorrect slalements made in support ol this response may be used by the

OZ~id~~~~j~r rejection rescission of the award or termination of the contract and m~~~(iirve as lhe basis for debarment of Vendor pursuant to Section 211 19 of the Broward Cour~ iG

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - ARCADIS US INC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts

VS0000013130 VS00013130 - ARCADIS US INC Prime Work Auth Vendor SummaryProjects

PURCHASING 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold Procurement No Fixed Contracts FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Favorites Past 5 Years Prime Vendor

Sub Vendor From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 10042017 Purchase Order

Evaluation Purchase Orders 1 POs With A Total Amt Of $20000000 Log Off Paid To Dt ($12132949) Balance $7867051

Contracts Purchase Orders Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx 6192018

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Finish

PURCHASING Weighted Scores Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract FileRoom DashBoard Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number FileRoom Insert

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel Favorites Prime Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Service Evaluation

6132017 YES 486 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Goals Compliance Evaluation

10272016 YES 460 View Docs (0)

6272018

Project Management Information System

Close

Contracts Central Administration

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9130 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-24

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6182018 YES 355 View Docs (1)

Proj Nbr 9320 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-20

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6132018 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9290 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-23

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1122018 YES 494 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-21

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12182017 YES 488 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10162017 YES 473 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

8252017 YES 495 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9321 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-19

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

7112017 YES 476 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-17

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2272017 YES 400 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

10132016 YES 384 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-12

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

5202016 YES 405 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9018 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-06

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10192015 YES 448 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

3202015 YES 385 View Docs (0)

Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL CONSULTANTS

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Project Management Information System

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-04

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12122014 YES 437 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-08

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1242014 YES 423 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-02

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2282014 YES 452 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC

VC0000044184 VC00044184 - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres PS $001 Used $000 Remain $001 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $354848400 Closed 0 Total $000 Total Current Retainage Balance For All Contracts $793370 No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 06292015 Purchase Orders 2 POs With A Total Amt Of $362317900 Paid To Dt ($218795160) Balance $143522740

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 40803 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9058 - DISTRICT 3A POTABLE WATER STORAGE

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1220410P1 - Consultant Engineering Services for Potable Water FixedOpen Contracts Storage Tanks and Pumping Systems Work Auth Prime Vendor CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Periodic Final Finish

Log Off Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type

Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

6232015 8302017 413 Approved 8312017 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard

Enter Vendor Name (or a portion of) Then Click Search - Wilcards Are Permitted (ie wa wawainc) Florida Technical Consultants

Search Reset Finish

No Vendors Found For Your Search Try Again

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41005 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score Go

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0773

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

12122017 YES 430 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

8302016 YES 438 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Final Consultant Evaluation 3142016 YES 478 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0706

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

142016 YES 402 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9016OES - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0731

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

10192015 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0748

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

612015 YES 467 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

2192015 YES 500 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0754

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

252015 YES 409 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0755

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

1242014 YES 415 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8974 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0758

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

6202014 YES 393 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr

WATER amp WASTEWATER

Final Consultant Work Authorization 572014 YES 423 View Docs

(0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

HS0746 ENGINEERING Evaluation

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

4302014 YES 475 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Evaluation 4302014 YES 493 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0710

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

3172014 YES 395 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0753

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

1212014 YES 380 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0763

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

11192013 YES 450 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0775

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 408 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals

Finish

Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed FileRoom DashBoard Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization FileRoom Insert NumberFavorites

Prime Vendor Export To Excel Sub Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0772

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 417 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0771

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

2262013 YES 410 View Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 35: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - ARCADIS US INC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts

VS0000013130 VS00013130 - ARCADIS US INC Prime Work Auth Vendor SummaryProjects

PURCHASING 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold Procurement No Fixed Contracts FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Favorites Past 5 Years Prime Vendor

Sub Vendor From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 10042017 Purchase Order

Evaluation Purchase Orders 1 POs With A Total Amt Of $20000000 Log Off Paid To Dt ($12132949) Balance $7867051

Contracts Purchase Orders Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx 6192018

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Finish

PURCHASING Weighted Scores Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract FileRoom DashBoard Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number FileRoom Insert

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel Favorites Prime Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Service Evaluation

6132017 YES 486 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Goals Compliance Evaluation

10272016 YES 460 View Docs (0)

6272018

Project Management Information System

Close

Contracts Central Administration

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9130 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-24

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6182018 YES 355 View Docs (1)

Proj Nbr 9320 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-20

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6132018 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9290 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-23

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1122018 YES 494 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-21

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12182017 YES 488 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10162017 YES 473 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

8252017 YES 495 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9321 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-19

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

7112017 YES 476 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-17

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2272017 YES 400 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

10132016 YES 384 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-12

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

5202016 YES 405 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9018 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-06

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10192015 YES 448 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

3202015 YES 385 View Docs (0)

Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL CONSULTANTS

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Project Management Information System

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-04

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12122014 YES 437 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-08

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1242014 YES 423 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-02

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2282014 YES 452 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC

VC0000044184 VC00044184 - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres PS $001 Used $000 Remain $001 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $354848400 Closed 0 Total $000 Total Current Retainage Balance For All Contracts $793370 No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 06292015 Purchase Orders 2 POs With A Total Amt Of $362317900 Paid To Dt ($218795160) Balance $143522740

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 40803 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9058 - DISTRICT 3A POTABLE WATER STORAGE

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1220410P1 - Consultant Engineering Services for Potable Water FixedOpen Contracts Storage Tanks and Pumping Systems Work Auth Prime Vendor CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Periodic Final Finish

Log Off Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type

Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

6232015 8302017 413 Approved 8312017 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard

Enter Vendor Name (or a portion of) Then Click Search - Wilcards Are Permitted (ie wa wawainc) Florida Technical Consultants

Search Reset Finish

No Vendors Found For Your Search Try Again

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41005 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score Go

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0773

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

12122017 YES 430 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

8302016 YES 438 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Final Consultant Evaluation 3142016 YES 478 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0706

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

142016 YES 402 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9016OES - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0731

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

10192015 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0748

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

612015 YES 467 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

2192015 YES 500 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0754

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

252015 YES 409 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0755

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

1242014 YES 415 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8974 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0758

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

6202014 YES 393 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr

WATER amp WASTEWATER

Final Consultant Work Authorization 572014 YES 423 View Docs

(0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

HS0746 ENGINEERING Evaluation

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

4302014 YES 475 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Evaluation 4302014 YES 493 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0710

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

3172014 YES 395 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0753

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

1212014 YES 380 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0763

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

11192013 YES 450 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0775

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 408 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals

Finish

Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed FileRoom DashBoard Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization FileRoom Insert NumberFavorites

Prime Vendor Export To Excel Sub Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0772

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 417 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0771

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

2262013 YES 410 View Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 36: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Finish

PURCHASING Weighted Scores Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract FileRoom DashBoard Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number FileRoom Insert

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel Favorites Prime Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Service Evaluation

6132017 YES 486 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Goals Compliance Evaluation

10272016 YES 460 View Docs (0)

6272018

Project Management Information System

Close

Contracts Central Administration

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9130 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-24

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6182018 YES 355 View Docs (1)

Proj Nbr 9320 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-20

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6132018 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9290 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-23

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1122018 YES 494 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-21

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12182017 YES 488 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10162017 YES 473 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

8252017 YES 495 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9321 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-19

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

7112017 YES 476 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-17

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2272017 YES 400 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

10132016 YES 384 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-12

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

5202016 YES 405 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9018 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-06

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10192015 YES 448 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

3202015 YES 385 View Docs (0)

Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL CONSULTANTS

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Project Management Information System

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-04

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12122014 YES 437 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-08

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1242014 YES 423 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-02

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2282014 YES 452 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC

VC0000044184 VC00044184 - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres PS $001 Used $000 Remain $001 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $354848400 Closed 0 Total $000 Total Current Retainage Balance For All Contracts $793370 No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 06292015 Purchase Orders 2 POs With A Total Amt Of $362317900 Paid To Dt ($218795160) Balance $143522740

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 40803 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9058 - DISTRICT 3A POTABLE WATER STORAGE

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1220410P1 - Consultant Engineering Services for Potable Water FixedOpen Contracts Storage Tanks and Pumping Systems Work Auth Prime Vendor CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Periodic Final Finish

Log Off Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type

Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

6232015 8302017 413 Approved 8312017 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard

Enter Vendor Name (or a portion of) Then Click Search - Wilcards Are Permitted (ie wa wawainc) Florida Technical Consultants

Search Reset Finish

No Vendors Found For Your Search Try Again

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41005 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score Go

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0773

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

12122017 YES 430 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

8302016 YES 438 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Final Consultant Evaluation 3142016 YES 478 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0706

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

142016 YES 402 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9016OES - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0731

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

10192015 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0748

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

612015 YES 467 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

2192015 YES 500 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0754

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

252015 YES 409 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0755

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

1242014 YES 415 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8974 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0758

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

6202014 YES 393 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr

WATER amp WASTEWATER

Final Consultant Work Authorization 572014 YES 423 View Docs

(0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

HS0746 ENGINEERING Evaluation

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

4302014 YES 475 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Evaluation 4302014 YES 493 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0710

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

3172014 YES 395 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0753

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

1212014 YES 380 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0763

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

11192013 YES 450 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0775

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 408 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals

Finish

Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed FileRoom DashBoard Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization FileRoom Insert NumberFavorites

Prime Vendor Export To Excel Sub Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0772

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 417 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0771

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

2262013 YES 410 View Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 37: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

Project Management Information System

Close

Contracts Central Administration

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

Proj Nbr 9130 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-24

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6182018 YES 355 View Docs (1)

Proj Nbr 9320 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-20

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

6132018 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9290 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-23

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1122018 YES 494 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-21

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12182017 YES 488 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9319 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-18

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10162017 YES 473 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

8252017 YES 495 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9321 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-19

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

7112017 YES 476 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-17

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2272017 YES 400 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

10132016 YES 384 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-12

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

5202016 YES 405 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9018 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-06

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

10192015 YES 448 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Service Evaluation

3202015 YES 385 View Docs (0)

Prime Vendor Dashboard - BROWN amp CALDWELL CONSULTANTS

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Question Rating Distribution View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Scores Highlighted In Orange Contain Answers Rated 1 andor 2 Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Project Management Information System

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-04

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12122014 YES 437 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-08

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1242014 YES 423 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-02

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2282014 YES 452 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC

VC0000044184 VC00044184 - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres PS $001 Used $000 Remain $001 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $354848400 Closed 0 Total $000 Total Current Retainage Balance For All Contracts $793370 No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 06292015 Purchase Orders 2 POs With A Total Amt Of $362317900 Paid To Dt ($218795160) Balance $143522740

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 40803 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9058 - DISTRICT 3A POTABLE WATER STORAGE

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1220410P1 - Consultant Engineering Services for Potable Water FixedOpen Contracts Storage Tanks and Pumping Systems Work Auth Prime Vendor CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Periodic Final Finish

Log Off Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type

Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

6232015 8302017 413 Approved 8312017 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard

Enter Vendor Name (or a portion of) Then Click Search - Wilcards Are Permitted (ie wa wawainc) Florida Technical Consultants

Search Reset Finish

No Vendors Found For Your Search Try Again

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41005 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score Go

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0773

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

12122017 YES 430 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

8302016 YES 438 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Final Consultant Evaluation 3142016 YES 478 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0706

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

142016 YES 402 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9016OES - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0731

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

10192015 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0748

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

612015 YES 467 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

2192015 YES 500 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0754

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

252015 YES 409 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0755

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

1242014 YES 415 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8974 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0758

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

6202014 YES 393 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr

WATER amp WASTEWATER

Final Consultant Work Authorization 572014 YES 423 View Docs

(0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

HS0746 ENGINEERING Evaluation

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

4302014 YES 475 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Evaluation 4302014 YES 493 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0710

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

3172014 YES 395 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0753

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

1212014 YES 380 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0763

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

11192013 YES 450 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0775

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 408 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals

Finish

Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed FileRoom DashBoard Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization FileRoom Insert NumberFavorites

Prime Vendor Export To Excel Sub Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0772

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 417 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0771

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

2262013 YES 410 View Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 38: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

Project Management Information System

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-04

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

12122014 YES 437 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC 13-08

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

1242014 YES 423 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr R1008103R1 - WA Nbr BC13-02

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Service Evaluation

2282014 YES 452 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx[6192018 35813 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC

VC0000044184 VC00044184 - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres PS $001 Used $000 Remain $001 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $354848400 Closed 0 Total $000 Total Current Retainage Balance For All Contracts $793370 No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 06292015 Purchase Orders 2 POs With A Total Amt Of $362317900 Paid To Dt ($218795160) Balance $143522740

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 40803 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9058 - DISTRICT 3A POTABLE WATER STORAGE

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1220410P1 - Consultant Engineering Services for Potable Water FixedOpen Contracts Storage Tanks and Pumping Systems Work Auth Prime Vendor CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Periodic Final Finish

Log Off Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type

Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

6232015 8302017 413 Approved 8312017 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard

Enter Vendor Name (or a portion of) Then Click Search - Wilcards Are Permitted (ie wa wawainc) Florida Technical Consultants

Search Reset Finish

No Vendors Found For Your Search Try Again

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41005 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score Go

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0773

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

12122017 YES 430 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

8302016 YES 438 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Final Consultant Evaluation 3142016 YES 478 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0706

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

142016 YES 402 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9016OES - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0731

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

10192015 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0748

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

612015 YES 467 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

2192015 YES 500 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0754

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

252015 YES 409 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0755

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

1242014 YES 415 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8974 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0758

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

6202014 YES 393 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr

WATER amp WASTEWATER

Final Consultant Work Authorization 572014 YES 423 View Docs

(0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

HS0746 ENGINEERING Evaluation

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

4302014 YES 475 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Evaluation 4302014 YES 493 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0710

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

3172014 YES 395 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0753

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

1212014 YES 380 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0763

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

11192013 YES 450 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0775

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 408 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals

Finish

Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed FileRoom DashBoard Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization FileRoom Insert NumberFavorites

Prime Vendor Export To Excel Sub Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0772

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 417 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0771

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

2262013 YES 410 View Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 39: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

Prime Vendor Dashboard - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC

VC0000044184 VC00044184 - CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres PS $001 Used $000 Remain $001 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $354848400 Closed 0 Total $000 Total Current Retainage Balance For All Contracts $793370 No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 06292015 Purchase Orders 2 POs With A Total Amt Of $362317900 Paid To Dt ($218795160) Balance $143522740

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 40803 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9058 - DISTRICT 3A POTABLE WATER STORAGE

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1220410P1 - Consultant Engineering Services for Potable Water FixedOpen Contracts Storage Tanks and Pumping Systems Work Auth Prime Vendor CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Periodic Final Finish

Log Off Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type

Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

6232015 8302017 413 Approved 8312017 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard

Enter Vendor Name (or a portion of) Then Click Search - Wilcards Are Permitted (ie wa wawainc) Florida Technical Consultants

Search Reset Finish

No Vendors Found For Your Search Try Again

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41005 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score Go

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0773

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

12122017 YES 430 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

8302016 YES 438 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Final Consultant Evaluation 3142016 YES 478 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0706

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

142016 YES 402 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9016OES - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0731

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

10192015 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0748

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

612015 YES 467 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

2192015 YES 500 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0754

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

252015 YES 409 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0755

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

1242014 YES 415 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8974 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0758

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

6202014 YES 393 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr

WATER amp WASTEWATER

Final Consultant Work Authorization 572014 YES 423 View Docs

(0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

HS0746 ENGINEERING Evaluation

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

4302014 YES 475 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Evaluation 4302014 YES 493 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0710

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

3172014 YES 395 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0753

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

1212014 YES 380 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0763

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

11192013 YES 450 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0775

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 408 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals

Finish

Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed FileRoom DashBoard Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization FileRoom Insert NumberFavorites

Prime Vendor Export To Excel Sub Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0772

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 417 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0771

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

2262013 YES 410 View Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 40: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9058 - DISTRICT 3A POTABLE WATER STORAGE

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1220410P1 - Consultant Engineering Services for Potable Water FixedOpen Contracts Storage Tanks and Pumping Systems Work Auth Prime Vendor CAROLLO ENGINEERS INC Projects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Periodic Final Finish

Log Off Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type

Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

6232015 8302017 413 Approved 8312017 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard

Enter Vendor Name (or a portion of) Then Click Search - Wilcards Are Permitted (ie wa wawainc) Florida Technical Consultants

Search Reset Finish

No Vendors Found For Your Search Try Again

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41005 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score Go

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0773

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

12122017 YES 430 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

8302016 YES 438 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Final Consultant Evaluation 3142016 YES 478 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0706

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

142016 YES 402 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9016OES - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0731

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

10192015 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0748

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

612015 YES 467 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

2192015 YES 500 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0754

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

252015 YES 409 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0755

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

1242014 YES 415 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8974 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0758

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

6202014 YES 393 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr

WATER amp WASTEWATER

Final Consultant Work Authorization 572014 YES 423 View Docs

(0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

HS0746 ENGINEERING Evaluation

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

4302014 YES 475 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Evaluation 4302014 YES 493 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0710

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

3172014 YES 395 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0753

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

1212014 YES 380 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0763

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

11192013 YES 450 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0775

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 408 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals

Finish

Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed FileRoom DashBoard Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization FileRoom Insert NumberFavorites

Prime Vendor Export To Excel Sub Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0772

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 417 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0771

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

2262013 YES 410 View Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 41: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

Prime Vendor Dashboard

Enter Vendor Name (or a portion of) Then Click Search - Wilcards Are Permitted (ie wa wawainc) Florida Technical Consultants

Search Reset Finish

No Vendors Found For Your Search Try Again

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41005 PM]

Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score Go

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0773

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

12122017 YES 430 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

8302016 YES 438 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Final Consultant Evaluation 3142016 YES 478 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0706

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

142016 YES 402 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9016OES - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0731

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

10192015 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0748

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

612015 YES 467 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

2192015 YES 500 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0754

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

252015 YES 409 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0755

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

1242014 YES 415 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8974 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0758

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

6202014 YES 393 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr

WATER amp WASTEWATER

Final Consultant Work Authorization 572014 YES 423 View Docs

(0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

HS0746 ENGINEERING Evaluation

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

4302014 YES 475 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Evaluation 4302014 YES 493 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0710

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

3172014 YES 395 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0753

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

1212014 YES 380 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0763

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

11192013 YES 450 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0775

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 408 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals

Finish

Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed FileRoom DashBoard Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization FileRoom Insert NumberFavorites

Prime Vendor Export To Excel Sub Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0772

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 417 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0771

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

2262013 YES 410 View Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 42: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals All Periodic Evals Finish

View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization Number

Export To Excel FinalCompleteRenewal Vendor Performance Evaluations - Past 5 Years

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score Go

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0773

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

12122017 YES 430 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

8302016 YES 438 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Final Consultant Evaluation 3142016 YES 478 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0706

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

142016 YES 402 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9016OES - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0731

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

10192015 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9058 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0748

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

612015 YES 467 View Docs (0)

FC Nbr R0939901R1

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

2192015 YES 500 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0754

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

252015 YES 409 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0755

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Work Authorization Evaluation

1242014 YES 415 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8974 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0758

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

6202014 YES 393 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9167 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr

WATER amp WASTEWATER

Final Consultant Work Authorization 572014 YES 423 View Docs

(0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

HS0746 ENGINEERING Evaluation

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

4302014 YES 475 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Evaluation 4302014 YES 493 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0710

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

3172014 YES 395 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0753

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

1212014 YES 380 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0763

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

11192013 YES 450 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0775

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 408 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals

Finish

Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed FileRoom DashBoard Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization FileRoom Insert NumberFavorites

Prime Vendor Export To Excel Sub Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0772

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 417 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0771

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

2262013 YES 410 View Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 43: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

HS0746 ENGINEERING Evaluation

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Goals Compliance Evaluation Consultant

4302014 YES 475 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 8624 - FC Nbr 8624CONS

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Final Consultant Evaluation 4302014 YES 493 View Docs

(0)

Proj Nbr 8850 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0710

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

3172014 YES 395 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0753

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

1212014 YES 380 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 -WA Nbr HS0763

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

11192013 YES 450 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Renewal Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 414 View Docs (0)

Proj Nbr 9186 - OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0775

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Completed Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 408 View Docs (0)

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41415 PM]

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals

Finish

Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed FileRoom DashBoard Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization FileRoom Insert NumberFavorites

Prime Vendor Export To Excel Sub Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0772

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 417 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0771

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

2262013 YES 410 View Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 44: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

Project Management Information System Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Prime Vendor Dashboard - HAZEN amp SAWYERPC

PO Admin FixedOpen Contracts Work Auth Projects PURCHASING View RenewalPeriodic Extended Columns View Weighted Scores

5 YR FinalCompleteRenewal Evals Archived FinalCompleteRenewal Evals

Finish

Procurement ProjContractAgreementWA Legend Proj Nbr = Project Number FC Nbr = Fixed FileRoom DashBoard Contract Number OE Nbr = Open End Contract Number WA Nbr = Work Authorization FileRoom Insert NumberFavorites

Prime Vendor Export To Excel Sub Vendor Periodic Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboardaspx

ProjContractAgreementWA Overseeing Div Evaluation Type Apprvd Dt Future Score

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0772

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

862013 YES 417 View Docs (0)

OE Nbr 200609110EED1 - WA Nbr HS0771

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

2262013 YES 410 View Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 45: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

Prime Vendor Dashboard - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC

VC0000031066 VC00031066 - LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Open Thres No Threshold 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold 2 OE Total Thres $000 Used $000 Remain $000 Fixed Contracts - Open 1 Total $13000000 Closed 0 Total $000

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years From Begining Of Advantage First PO Issued Date 12082004 Purchase Orders 12 POs With A Total Amt Of $23435000 Paid To Dt ($15934030) Balance $7105970 Vendor Is Certified CBE Start Dt 1172015 End Dt 1172018

Contracts Purchase Orders Sub Vendors Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41506 PM]

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 46: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

Contracts Central Page 1 of 1

Contracts Central Broward County Purchasing Division

Close

Contracts Central Administration Project 9197 - NRWWTP Steel Structure Repair and Replacement

PO Admin Consultant Contract R1007403R1 - North Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant - Structural FixedOpen Contracts Steel Replacement Work Auth Prime Vendor LAKDASYOHALEM ENGINEERING INCProjects PURCHASING

Procurement FileRoom DashBoard Consultant Fixed Contract Evaluations Click To Begin FileRoom Insert

Favorites Prime Vendor Sub Vendor Purchase Order Evaluation

Log Off

Periodic Final Finish

Evaluations Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralEvaluationSummaryaspx

Evaluation Type Using Division TaskPhase Start

Period End Period Score Status Update

Dt Go

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

WATER amp WASTEWATER ENGINEERING

9132013 8122016 143 Approved 1252018 Docs (1)

Periodic Consultant Evaluation

000 Created 6262018 Docs (0)

6272018

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 47: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

Prime Vendor Dashboard - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC

VC0000039051 NO CONVERT - MATHEWS CONSULTING INC Prime Vendor Summary 1 OE Expired Thres No Threshold No Fixed Contracts

No FinalCompletedRenewal Performance Evaluations Over Past 5 Years

No Purchase Orders

Contracts Documents Finish

httpmrnet01ContractsCentralPrimeVendorDashboard_Publicaspx[6192018 41546 PM]

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 48: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

From Torres Leah (Richter) To Olesen Nancy Cc Warriner Kori Pachano Carolina Fernandez Joan Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Friday July 13 2018 111419 AM

Good morning Nancy Thank you for sending the draft Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports We do not have any specific deficiencies to address however we noticed that one of our former employees Robert Daoust is reported to have violated the cone of silence in 2011 We are hopeful that a flagged violation from a former employee that took place 7 years ago does not affect our consideration for this RFP Thank you again for the opportunity to review the draft memo Leah

From Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 425 PM To Torres Leah (Richter) ltLeahTorresarcadiscomgt alperezbrwncaldcom ltalperezbrwncaldcomgt cearlebrwncaldcom ltcearlebrwncaldcomgt efujikawacarollocom ltefujikawacarollocomgt lmuncecarollocom ltlmuncecarollocomgt jbartonfltechinccom ltjbartonfltechinccomgt pdavishazenandsawyercom ltpdavishazenandsawyercomgt jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom ltjwietgrefehazenandsawyercomgt lyelyengineeringcom ltlyelyengineeringcomgt dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom ltdmathewsbaxterwoodmancomgt jkenneybaxterwoodmancom ltjkenneybaxterwoodmancomgt Pachano Carolina ltCarolinaPachanoarcadiscomgt Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject FW Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 49: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure This email and any files transmitted with it are the property of Arcadis and its affiliates All rights including without limitation copyright are reserved This email contains information that may be confidential and may also be privileged It is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) If you are not an intended recipient please note that any form of distribution copying or use of this communication or the information in it is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful If you have received this communication in error please return it to the sender and then delete the email and destroy any copies of it While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure that no software or viruses are present in our emails we cannot guarantee that this email or any attachment is virus free or has not been intercepted or changed Any opinions or other information in this email that do not relate to the official business of Arcadis are neither given nor endorsed by it

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 50: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

From Celia Earle To Olesen Nancy Cc Albert Perez Subject RE Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No

PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - Response Date Friday July 13 2018 112015 AM Attachments BC Response to Recomm Memo PNC2115559P1_071318pdf

Good Morning Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell has reviewed the Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports and has found two discrepancies that are noted in the attached letter

Please review and let us know if you have any questions Please do not hesitate to contact Mr Albert Perez or myself

We will be in attendance at Mondayrsquos meeting

Have a lovely day

Celia

Celia D A Earle PhD Vice President Client Service Manager Brown and Caldwell cearlebrwncaldcom T 9542007615 | C 9546006918 | F 9542007612

For secure or large files please send to my dropbox httpswwwhightailcomuCeliaEarle

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 51: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

1560 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 240 Sunrise FL 33323

T 9542007611 F 9542007612

July 13 2018

Ms Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 South Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301

Subject Recommendation Memorandum for RFP No PNC2115559P1 for Professional Engi-neering Services for Studies and Reports for Broward County Water and Wastewater Services

Dear Ms Olesen

Brown and Caldwell is in receipt of Recommendation Memorandum for the subject RFP that was distributed to the Selection Committee on July 11th 2018 Upon reviewing the Memorandum we identified two discrepancies for which we respectfully request clarification or correction

FFlagged Score for Past Broward County Projects

Brown and Caldwell has completed 15 projects for Broward County for which we have scored Good to Excellent for all For one project (BC 13-24) for which our overall rating was classified Good the score was highlighted in bright orange which gives the perception that there was a deficiency A screen capture of this project in question together with a sampling of our other projects are provided below

We would note that no other consultant was flagged in this manner We request removal of the highlighted score or written clarification of the reason for including the highlight We further re-quest that the Selection Committee be notified of change

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 52: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

ttaaa - -

Albert L Pe Principal

re

Ms Nancy Olesen Broward County Purchasing Division July 13 2018 Page 2

CCriteria for Awarding Principal Business Location Points

It was Brown and Caldwellrsquos understanding that to receive points as a locally headquartered firm the Corporate Headquarters of the firm must be in Broward County The RFQ and County Ordi-nance defines Principal Place of Business as follows ldquoPrincipal Place of business means the nerve center or the center of overall direction control and coordination of the activities of the bidderrdquo In this case the ldquobidderrdquo is the corporate entity not a regional or branch office Our un-derstanding is that in practice and specifically directed by the Countyrsquos Local Attestation Form a corporationrsquos nerve centerrdquo is the place the corporation maintains its headquarters provided that the headquarters is actually the center of the corporationrsquos direction control and coordination

Based on this understanding of the intent and specific requirements of the Countyrsquos local prefer-ence ordinance Brown and Caldwell did not seek points for our Principal Place of Business However upon reviewing the subject memorandum we observed that another national firm (Hazen) that as stated in its proposal (State of Florida Certificate of Status) has its corporate headquarters in New York City was awarded 5 points for having their principal place of business in Broward County This would suggest that in practice having the corporate headquarters in Broward County is not a requirement despite the apparent intent of the ordinance and specific attestation requirements The local preference points awarded to a firm with an out of state cor-porate headquarters is materially significant and provides a competitive advantage without a clear supporting basis Consequently we respectfully request written clarification of the criteria as defined in the Countyrsquos Location Attestation Form for determining when to award these points Depending on the clarification provided we further request the opportunity to revisit whether or not Brown and Caldwell should also be awarded points for this category

We appreciate your attention to the foregoing

Respectfully submitted

Brown and Caldwell

z PE Celia D A Earle PhD -in-Charge Client Service Manager

Albert LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLL LLLLLLLLLL LL LLL LLLLLL LL LLLL LLL LLL Per Princiciciciciciiccciccicicccciiiiiiiiiiicciiipapapapapaaaapaaaa apapapapaaapaapapapap aap aaapaaappapp apppppppppppppppppp l in C

bc response to recomm memo pnc2115559p1_071318docx

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 53: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

From Elizabeth Fujikawa To Olesen Nancy Subject Re Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports Date Thursday July 12 2018 123208 AM

Hi Nancy I noticed Hazen says their headquarters is in Hollywood And they get five points for that Their website says itrsquos in New York Please see the attached

Thanks Liz

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt

Page 54: DATE: July 13, 2018 · A draft Director of Purchasing’s Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting documents ... initially submitted a blank CBE Letter of Intent (LOI)

On Jul 11 2018 at 432 PM Olesen Nancy ltnolesenbrowardorggt wrote

To All Proposers

Attached is the attachment

Thank you Nancy

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

From Olesen Nancy Sent Wednesday July 11 2018 353 PM To leahtorresarcadiscom alperezbrwncaldcom cearlebrwncaldcom efujikawacarollocom lmuncecarollocom jbartonfltechinccom pdavishazenandsawyercom jwietgrefehazenandsawyercom lyelyengineeringcom dmathewsbaxterwoodmancom jkenneybaxterwoodmancom carolinapachanoarcadis-uscom Cc Perez-Garviso Martha ltMPEREZGARVISObrowardorggt Messersmith Carolyn ltCMESSERSMITHbrowardorggt OConnor Dave ltDOCONNORbrowardorggt Subject Purchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - DRAFT - Request for Proposal (RFP) No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports

To All Proposers

Ref RFP No PNC2115559P1 - Professional Engineering Services for Studies and Reports - 48 Hour Review of the Draft Purchasing Directors Recommendation Memorandum

Attached are e-files of the Director of Purchasingrsquos DRAFT Recommendation Memorandum and the four (4) supporting memoranda from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development (OESBD) Water and Wastewater Services County Attorneyrsquos Office and Risk Management for your review Also attached to the DRAFT memorandum are the reference checks and performance evaluations

If any deficiencies are noted in these memoranda concerning your firm you have the opportunity to make an explanation in writing via email of those deficiencies to the undersigned below by noon on Friday July 13 2018

Initial Evaluation Committee Meeting (httpwwwbrowardorgCommissionPagesSunshineMeetingsaspx)

Committee Meeting Date Monday July 16 2018

ltimage001jpggt

Nancy Olesen Purchasing Agent Broward County Purchasing Division 115 S Andrews Avenue Room 212 Fort Lauderdale Fl 33301 Office 954-357-7995 Fax 954-357-8253 nolesenbrowardorg

Customer Care is my priority How am I doing Please contact my Manager Connie Mangan at cmanganbrowardorg with feedback

Under Florida law most e-mail messages to or from Broward County employees or officials are public records available to any person upon request absent an exemption Therefore any e-mail message to or from the County inclusive of e-mail addresses contained therein may be subject to public disclosure

ltPurchasing Director Recommendation Memorandum - Draft Memopdfgt