data analysis markarian 421 – 14.-15.02.2004 crab nebula – 27.01.2004 crab nebula – 15.02.2004...

27
Data Analysis •Markarian 421 – 14.- 15.02.2004 •Crab Nebula – 27.01.2004 •Crab Nebula – 15.02.2004 2 dim plots : false source analysis Miss-pointing study Light Curves Data:

Upload: whitney-hancock

Post on 17-Jan-2016

212 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Data Analysis Markarian 421 – 14.-15.02.2004 Crab Nebula – 27.01.2004 Crab Nebula – 15.02.2004  2 dim plots : false source analysis  Miss-pointing study

Data Analysis

•Markarian 421 – 14.-15.02.2004•Crab Nebula – 27.01.2004•Crab Nebula – 15.02.2004

2 dim plots : false source analysis

Miss-pointing study

Light Curves

Data:

Page 2: Data Analysis Markarian 421 – 14.-15.02.2004 Crab Nebula – 27.01.2004 Crab Nebula – 15.02.2004  2 dim plots : false source analysis  Miss-pointing study

Applied Cuts(David’s Talk)

• 0.12 < LENGTH < 0.32• 0.06 < WIDTH < 0.15• 0.6 < DIST < 1.3• SIZE > 3000 (photons)

Calculate significance: Li&Ma (1983) formula #17 ALPHA(max) = 10 degrees

Page 3: Data Analysis Markarian 421 – 14.-15.02.2004 Crab Nebula – 27.01.2004 Crab Nebula – 15.02.2004  2 dim plots : false source analysis  Miss-pointing study

False source analysis

• Calculate once source independent parameters:

LENGTH, WIDTH, SIZE, etc• For each assumed source position

calculate source dependent parameters: DIST, ALPHA• The movement of the sky (derotation)• The same procedure for ON and OFF

Page 4: Data Analysis Markarian 421 – 14.-15.02.2004 Crab Nebula – 27.01.2004 Crab Nebula – 15.02.2004  2 dim plots : false source analysis  Miss-pointing study

2 dim sky plotCamera coordinates Sky coordinates

Page 5: Data Analysis Markarian 421 – 14.-15.02.2004 Crab Nebula – 27.01.2004 Crab Nebula – 15.02.2004  2 dim plots : false source analysis  Miss-pointing study

2 dim sky plot (N ex)Camera coordinates Sky coordinates

Page 6: Data Analysis Markarian 421 – 14.-15.02.2004 Crab Nebula – 27.01.2004 Crab Nebula – 15.02.2004  2 dim plots : false source analysis  Miss-pointing study

Why is the spot not very narrow?

Center of the camera is not the center of the rotation?

• Divide the ON sample in several sub-samples

• No derotation• Use the whole OFF sample to

calculate significance

Page 7: Data Analysis Markarian 421 – 14.-15.02.2004 Crab Nebula – 27.01.2004 Crab Nebula – 15.02.2004  2 dim plots : false source analysis  Miss-pointing study

Tracking / Miss-pointing

Page 8: Data Analysis Markarian 421 – 14.-15.02.2004 Crab Nebula – 27.01.2004 Crab Nebula – 15.02.2004  2 dim plots : false source analysis  Miss-pointing study

Estimation of the source position in each of the sub-

samples

Several criteria:• Significance• Number of excess events• Alpha plot: signal and background

shape • Alpha plots of the nearby positions

Page 9: Data Analysis Markarian 421 – 14.-15.02.2004 Crab Nebula – 27.01.2004 Crab Nebula – 15.02.2004  2 dim plots : false source analysis  Miss-pointing study

Estimated source positions

Page 10: Data Analysis Markarian 421 – 14.-15.02.2004 Crab Nebula – 27.01.2004 Crab Nebula – 15.02.2004  2 dim plots : false source analysis  Miss-pointing study

First light curve

Markarian 421

Page 11: Data Analysis Markarian 421 – 14.-15.02.2004 Crab Nebula – 27.01.2004 Crab Nebula – 15.02.2004  2 dim plots : false source analysis  Miss-pointing study

Fine binning: 25 samplesNormal spot Abnormal spot (1

run)

Page 12: Data Analysis Markarian 421 – 14.-15.02.2004 Crab Nebula – 27.01.2004 Crab Nebula – 15.02.2004  2 dim plots : false source analysis  Miss-pointing study

Closer look to this sub-sample

2 minutes, 1 Run, no reports in the runbook

First 5633 events Last 5633 events

Page 13: Data Analysis Markarian 421 – 14.-15.02.2004 Crab Nebula – 27.01.2004 Crab Nebula – 15.02.2004  2 dim plots : false source analysis  Miss-pointing study

Following the miss-pointing

Page 14: Data Analysis Markarian 421 – 14.-15.02.2004 Crab Nebula – 27.01.2004 Crab Nebula – 15.02.2004  2 dim plots : false source analysis  Miss-pointing study

Mrk421: 2nd ON sample

• Derotation around the center of the camera

• Displacement from the center of around 0.3 deg

• Roundish spot

Page 15: Data Analysis Markarian 421 – 14.-15.02.2004 Crab Nebula – 27.01.2004 Crab Nebula – 15.02.2004  2 dim plots : false source analysis  Miss-pointing study

Second light curve

Page 16: Data Analysis Markarian 421 – 14.-15.02.2004 Crab Nebula – 27.01.2004 Crab Nebula – 15.02.2004  2 dim plots : false source analysis  Miss-pointing study

Zenith and azimuth angle

Page 17: Data Analysis Markarian 421 – 14.-15.02.2004 Crab Nebula – 27.01.2004 Crab Nebula – 15.02.2004  2 dim plots : false source analysis  Miss-pointing study

Crab: 27th January 2004

Page 18: Data Analysis Markarian 421 – 14.-15.02.2004 Crab Nebula – 27.01.2004 Crab Nebula – 15.02.2004  2 dim plots : false source analysis  Miss-pointing study

Crab: 14th- 15th February 2004

Page 19: Data Analysis Markarian 421 – 14.-15.02.2004 Crab Nebula – 27.01.2004 Crab Nebula – 15.02.2004  2 dim plots : false source analysis  Miss-pointing study

Conclusion / outlook

•All three samples: clear detection

•Weak sources (even Crab!) still difficult to analyze.

•Possible reasons:

miss-pointing

unstable movement

many “dead” pixels

Page 20: Data Analysis Markarian 421 – 14.-15.02.2004 Crab Nebula – 27.01.2004 Crab Nebula – 15.02.2004  2 dim plots : false source analysis  Miss-pointing study

Mrk 421 OFF

Page 21: Data Analysis Markarian 421 – 14.-15.02.2004 Crab Nebula – 27.01.2004 Crab Nebula – 15.02.2004  2 dim plots : false source analysis  Miss-pointing study

ASYMMETRY

Page 22: Data Analysis Markarian 421 – 14.-15.02.2004 Crab Nebula – 27.01.2004 Crab Nebula – 15.02.2004  2 dim plots : false source analysis  Miss-pointing study

Asymmetry: MC photons

73%27%

Page 23: Data Analysis Markarian 421 – 14.-15.02.2004 Crab Nebula – 27.01.2004 Crab Nebula – 15.02.2004  2 dim plots : false source analysis  Miss-pointing study

Asymmetry: MC protons

40%60%

Page 24: Data Analysis Markarian 421 – 14.-15.02.2004 Crab Nebula – 27.01.2004 Crab Nebula – 15.02.2004  2 dim plots : false source analysis  Miss-pointing study

Asymmetry: Mrk 421 ON

44%56%

Page 25: Data Analysis Markarian 421 – 14.-15.02.2004 Crab Nebula – 27.01.2004 Crab Nebula – 15.02.2004  2 dim plots : false source analysis  Miss-pointing study

Asymmetry: Mrk 421 OFF

39%61%

Page 26: Data Analysis Markarian 421 – 14.-15.02.2004 Crab Nebula – 27.01.2004 Crab Nebula – 15.02.2004  2 dim plots : false source analysis  Miss-pointing study

Asymmetry: Crab ON

40%60%

Page 27: Data Analysis Markarian 421 – 14.-15.02.2004 Crab Nebula – 27.01.2004 Crab Nebula – 15.02.2004  2 dim plots : false source analysis  Miss-pointing study

Asymmetry: Crab OFF

38%62%