dart underground oral hearing report 29s. · pdf file · 2011-12-20dart underground...

Dart Underground

Oral Hearing Report

29S.NA0005

Appendix A

List of Oral Hearing Submissions compiled by the Strategic Infrastructure

Development & Local Authority Project Section of An Bord Pleanala

Dart Underground Oral Hearing Submissions

Day 1: Monday, 22nd November 2010

Applicant’s Submissions

No. Title Presented By

1 Introduction to DART Underground Dick Fearn, Chief Executive –

Iarnród Éireann

2 Background and Need for the Scheme Michael Reidy, Manager –

Strategic & Business

Planning, Iarnród Éireann

3 Economic Appraisal Paul Buchanan – Director,

Colin Buchanan & Partners

Ltd.

4

4 (a)

Planning and Policy Context

Power point presentation

Alan Whelan, Director - Tíros

Resources Ltd.

5 Co-ordination of the

Railway Order Application

(includes Appendices)

Mark Conroy, DART

Underground Environmental

Manager, Iarnród Éireann

Day 2: Tuesday, 23rd November 2010



6 Introduction of Multi-Disciplinary Technical

Consultants

Tim Corcoran – Railway

Order Manager

7 Overview of EIS; Cumulative Impacts &

Interactions

(This statement also contains items to be dealt

with at No. 36 - Cumulative Impacts and

Interactions - and No. 37 – Summary of

Mitigation Measures & Residual Impacts - of

Module 1)

Eddie Feely – EIS Manager

8 Public Consultation Tom Rowley –

Communications Manager for

DART Underground

9

9A

Design Development & Alternatives

Considered

Conor Lavery – Design

Manager, Arup Halcrow Joint

Venture

Associated Powerpoint presentation Peter Muldoon - Project

Manager

10 Order of Applicant’s submissions & Presenters

Names

Day 3: Wednesday, 24th November 2010



10 Response to queries raised by the Inspector Alan Whelan

11 Details of Pearse St . alternatives shown at

public consultation

Irish Rail

12

12a

Description of Railway Order drawings

Associated Powerpoint presentation

Gavin O’Donnell, Railway

Order Drawings Manager

13

13a

Detailed description of Railway Order works


John Flaherty

Conor Lavery

Day 4: Thursday, 25th November 2010



14 Drawing Ref: Railway Works Structures Details

Merrion Square, Entrance Study - Ground Level

/Entrance Study /Entrance Study - Sections

15 Enlarged Version of Running Tunnel /Cross

Passage – Cross Section

Day 5: Friday, 26th November 2010



16

Addendum to Submission no, 13 - Detailed

description of Railway Order works

16a

Addendum to Submission 13a – Associated

Powerpoint Presentation

17 Details of East Wall construction compound

access options shown at public consultations

Day 6: Tuesday, 30th November 2010



18

18A

18B

Construction Strategy, Scheduling &

Programming

Associated Powerpoint Presentation

Associated graphic image

Kevin McManus

19

Ventilation, Fire and Smoke Control

Dr. Peter Woodburn

Day 7: Wednesday, 1st December 2010



20

20A

20B

Property Referencing


Corrigenda

Aidan Ruane, CIÉ Group

Property Management

21

21A

21B

Risk Management Concept

Geotechnics, Soils and Geology

Ground Conditions – Associated Powerpoint

presentation

Roland Bourke, Property

Contols Manager

22

22A

Settlement

Settlement of Permanent Structures and

Utilities – Associated Powerpoint presentation

Simon Fricker

Day 8: Tuesday, 7th December 2010



23

Settlement of permanent structures & utilities

– Clarification for An Bord Pleanála

Simon Fricker

Legal Submissions


24 Legal submission – Response on behalf of the

Applicant in relation to legal matters raised

Conleth Bradley, SC, on

behalf of CIÉ/Irish Rail

25 Judgement from European Court of Human

Rights – Case of Skibinscy V. Poland

Garrett Simons, SC, on behalf

of Spencer Dock

Development Company Ltd

26 Time length of CPO Powers Barry McGee, on behalf of the

Railway Procurement

Agency

Day 9: Wednesday, 8th December 2010



27 Property Protection Scheme Mark Conroy

28

28A

Hydrogeology


Kevin Cullen

29 List of Submissions presented

30

30A

30B

Response to queries raised 24/11/10 to

1/12/10

Appendix A

Appendix B

Conor Lavery (Presented on

9/12/10)

31 Hydrology Dr. Conor Buggy

32

32A

Flood Risk Assessment


Luke Ballantyne

Day 10: Thursday, 9th December 2010



33 Section 9 Corrigenda – Description of table

drawings

34 Set of drawings associated with Response to

queries raised 24/11/10 to 1/12/10 which

was submitted on day 9 (see separate roll of

drawings)

35

35A

Below Ground Noise and Vibration


Richard Greer

Day 11: Friday, 10th December 2010



36 Drainage and Utilities Ross Kinsella

37

37A

37B

Above Ground Noise and Vibration


Appendix A - Corrigendum

Jennifer Harmon

38 Material Assets – Existing and Proposed

Utilities, Corrigenda / Update - Table corrected

on 10.12.10

Day 12: Tuesday, 14th December 2010



39 Summary of Baseline Unattended and Attended

Noise Measurements

40 Transport Model Barry Colleary, National

Transport Authority

41 A0 set of drawings which were submitted as A3

booklet on Day 10 (9.12.10) Section 9.0

Corrigenda / Update – Table corrected

26.11.10 (See separate drawing booklet on

public file table)

42

42A

Traffic and Transportation

Associated Powerpoint Presentation

Donal McDaid, ARUP

Day 13: Wednesday, 15th December 2010



43 Methods for predicting groundborne noise and

vibration from trains and tunnels

Richard Greer

44 Response to An Bord Pleanála queries raised

from 1/12/10 to 10/12/10

Day 14 : Thursday, 16th December 2010

No. Title Presented by

45 ‘Land Use Implications for DART

Underground at Inchicore’

Applicant

46/46A ‘Vertical & Horizontal Ground Movements

associated with Island Street Shaft

Construction’

(46A- Associated Slides & Illustrations)

Simon Fricker

47/47A Archaeological & Cultural Heritage

(47A – Associated Slides & illustrations)

Margaret Gowan

48 Socio-Economics Craig Bullock

Day 15: Friday, 17th December 2010

No. Title Presented by

49 ‘Summary of Baseline Attended & Unattended

Noise Measurements’

Jennifer Harmon

50/50A Retail/Business Impact

(50A – Associated Slides & Illustrations)

Alan Whelan

51/51A Waste Management

(51A – Resource & Waste Management

Associated Slides & Illustrations)

Joyanne Manning

52 Flora & Fauna Carmel Brennan

Day 16: Monday, 10th January 2011



53 Station Planning / Architectural Design /

Urban Integration

Clare Whte and Leszek

Dobrovolsky

53A Accompanying Slides - Station Planning /

Architectural Design / Urban Integration

Clare Whte and Leszek

Dobrovolsky

Day 17: Tuesday, 11th January 2011



53B Platform-Train Interface: Calculation of Gaps Hugh O’Neill

53C Platform-Train Interface: Accessibility Mike Evans

54 Landscape and Visual Assessment Thomas Burns

54A Accompanying Slides - Landscape and Visual

Assessment

Thomas Burns

55 Architectural Heritage David Slattery

55A Accompanying Slides – Architectural Heritage David Slattery

Day 18: Wednesday, 12th January 2011



56 Industrial Heritage Mary McMahon

56A Accompanying Slides – Industrial Heritage Mary McMahon

57 Architectural Design – Responses and

Clarifications

Clare White and Leszek

Dobrovolsky

57A Accompanying Slides – Architectural Heritage –

Responses and Clarifications

Clare White and Leszek

Dobrovolsky

58 Response to Queries raised to date

59 Air Quality and Climate Sinéad White

Day 19: Thursday, 13th January 2011



60 Electromagnetic Compatibility Chris Marshman

61 Human Health Martin Hogan

62 Responses to Supplemental Information

Request

63A Drawings – Soils and Geology

64 Agreement re conditions between Iarnród

Éireann and Dublin City Council. (‘Agreed

Position’ Document)

64A Drawings – Materials (Station Square)

Day 20: Friday 14th January 2011



65/65A/65B/

65C

Response to Queries

65A & B Associated Drawings &

Photographs

65C Schedule of Buildings identified during

settlement assessment

Applicant

66/66A/66B Monitoring

66A Associated Slides

66B Associated Examples

Simon Fricker

67/67A/67B Below Ground Noise & Vibration Example Richard Greer

Calculation

67A Associated Slides/Graphs

67B Procedure for Calculations




68 Cumulative Impacts and Mitigation Measures Eddie Feely

69 Further Information on Interpretation of

Geophysical Survey Data

Applicant

69A Accompanying Drawings – Soils and Geology Applicant

70 Response to ABP request for info on review of

TBM Operation Data

Simon Fricker

70A Accompanying Slides – Information and

Monitoring – TBM Operation Data

Simon Fricker

70B Execution of Special Geotechnical Works –

Bored Piles

Simon Fricker

71 Response to Supplemental Information

Request

National Transport

Authority (Applicant)

72 Clarification on Nature of Proposed Property

Acquisitions at station and shaft sites

Applicant

73 Detail of the DART Underground Property

Protection Scheme

Applicant

74 Response to Queries from ABP and Observers Applicant

74A Accompanying Appendix: Provision of Cycle

Parking at Stations

Applicant

74B Accompanying Appendix: Geotechnical Core

Log Record

Applicant

74C Accompanying Appendix: Determination of

Vertical and Horizontal Movements of Shafts

(Revised Slides)

Applicant

74D Accompanying Photos Applicant

74E Corrigenda – Corrected Table : Settlement of

Permanent Structures and Utilities

Applicant

74F Drawings - Ground Investigation Exploratory

Hole Locations, North Wall ESB Substation

Elevations and North Wall ESB Substation

Ground Level Plan

Applicant

74G Sheriff Street Ramp Traffic – Explanation of

Noise Assessment Methodology

Jennifer Harmon




75 Answers to General Questions from Observers Applicant

76 Response – Determination of Vertical and

Horizontal Movements (Shafts): Validation of

Contours

Applicant

77 Corrigenda (EIS): Below Ground Noise and

Vibration

Applicant

78 Drawings: Scenario – DART Underground is

operational prior to Opening of St. Stephens

Green Station (1 of 2 and 2 of 2; see also larger

drawings submitted)

Applicant

79 Programme and Notice to Treat Applicant

Local Authority (Dublin City Council) Submissions

80 Strategic Planning Context Gerard Meehan

81 Strategic Planning Context Dick Gleeson

Day 23: Friday, 21st January 2011

Submissions from Prescribed Bodies


82 Architecture and Architectural Heritage DoEHLG (G. Browner)

83 National Monuments DoEHLG (C. Desmond)

84 Dublin Bus Submission Dublin Bus

85 Health Service Executive Submission Michelle Convey

86 Railway Procurement Agency Submission Rory O’Connor

Submissions from Public Representatives

No. Presented By

87 Cllr. Cieran Perry

88 Joe Costello TD and Cllr. Emer Costello

89 Joe Costello TD and Emer Cllr. Costello (2)

90 Maureen O’Sullivan TD and Cllr. Marie Metcalfe

91 Ógra Fianna Fáil – Dublin Central (Patrick Martin)

Day 24: Tuesday, 25th January 2011

Submissions from Public Representatives

No. Presented by

92 Mary Lou McDonald (for Mary Lou McDonald and

Cllr. Seamas McGrattan)

Submission - East Wall (from Module 6)

No. Presented By

93 Thomas Seery (for Thomas Seery and Others)


Submissions from General Observers

No. Observer

94 Rail Users Ireland

95 Dargan Project

95A Appendix A: Best Global Practice in Metro

Procurement

95B Appendix B: Code of Practice for Risk Management

of Tunnel Works

95C Appendix C: Accompanying Slides


Submissions from East Wall (North of Sheriff St.)

No. Observer

96 Aidan Foley and Masterlabs Limited

96A Appendix: Report from John Munnis, Audio

Consultant

97 Andrew and Elizabeth Hulton (c/o Tom Hulton)

97A Appendix A: Drawing from DCC file 2219/09 (ABP

ref 29N.233488)

Day 27: Friday, 28th January 2011


No. Observer

98 Adrienne Redmond and Others

99 Anna Flanagan and Others

100 Carmel Cosgrave and Others

101

101A

101B

Ossory Business Park – opening statement by

Brendan Buck, BPS Planning

Michael Kennedy and Declan Rogers submission

Correspondence from Gunne to Mr. Rogers and Mr.

Kennedy dated 14/9/10

Ossory Road Industrial Estate statement by Andrew

Foran, Gunne Auctioneers

101C

Day 28: Tuesday, 1st February 2011


No. Observer

102 Crosbie Properties

103 Daisy Days Childcare

104 Laurence Redmond

105 Michael Muldowney

106 Anne Gahan

107 Phyllis Doyle

108 East Wall Water Sports Group Ltd

109 John Conway

110 Residents of West Road, submission by Brendan

Buck, BPS Planning

Day 29: Wednesday, 2nd February 2011


No. Observer

111 A3 Drawing “Eastern Portal Approach Structures

Potential Haul Routes” submitted by Applicant

112 Elaine & Paul Kenny

113 Ian Hand

114 Martina Kelly & Paul Corrigan

115 Terence Melhorn

116 James Lee

117 Denise Wright

Day 30: Thursday, 3rd February 2011


No. Observer

118 Elizabeth Corrigan, submission by Kevin Glynn

119

119A

Rory O’Meara, submission by Rory Mulcahy BL

Rory O’Meara

120 Deirdre O’Reilly & Karl O’Grady (includes video

received on disc)

Day 31: Wednesday, 9th February 2011


No. Observer

121 Maps Submitted by Applicant

122 Angela Wigglesworth & Others

123 Helen McCabe & Others

124 Joe Mooney

125 Seamus Cummins & Delphine Guine

126 Margaret Roper & Others

127 Tom Hulton

128 Nascadh CDP (includes dvd)

129 Lesley Maher, Zen Hair & Beauty

Day 32: Thursday, 10th February 2011


No. Observer

130 Protect East Wall- List of Submissions

131 Public consultation display drawings submitted by Applicant

132 Protect East Wall – Opening Statement, Brendan Buck, Planning

Consultant

133 Protect East Wall – East Wall, Tony Kelly, Chairman of East Wall

Residents Association, & Dr. Ruth McManus

134 Protect East Wall – Consultation, Angela Broderick, Vice-chairperson of

East Wall Residents Association and Member of Protect East Wall Group

135 Protect East Wall – Planning, Brendan Buck, Planning Consultant

136 Protect East Wall – Construction Strategy, Brendan Buck, Planning

Consultant

137 Protect East Wall – Main areas of Concern, Thomas Hulton, Member of

Protect East Wall Group

Day 33: Friday, 11th February 2011


No. Observer

138 Protect East Wall - Karl Searson – Noise

138A Protect East Wall - Karl Searson – Noise (Associated Graphs &

Tables)

138B Protect East Wall - Karl Searson – Noise (Photos )

138C Protect East Wall - Karl Searson – Noise (DVD Presentation)

139 Protect East Wall – Ian Duckenfield – Vibration

140 Protect East Wall – Andrew Foran – Impact on Property Values

141 Protect East Wall – Brendan Buck / Justin Hughes / John

Morrissey – Policing the Contractor / Enforcement

Day 34: Tuesday, 15th February 2011


No. Observer

142 Protect East Wall - Copy of Meeting Records with Applicant

143 Protect East Wall –Traffic (B.Buck)

143A Supplementary Document – HGV Traffic on East Wall

144 Protect East Wall – Flooding, Water and Sewerage (Caitríona Ní

Cassaithe)

144A Protect East Wall - Photographs of Flood Water in East Wall

144B Protect East Wall - DVD of Flooding in East Wall

145 Protect East Wall – Visual Impact & Architecture

146 Protect East Wall – Human Health

146A Protect East Wall - Letter from Seamus Murphy, School Principal

146B Protect East Wall – Submsn from Prof. Anthony Staines

Day 35: Wednesday, 16th February 2011


No. Observer

147 Protect East Wall – Submission to Dart Underground Oral Hearing

read by Marie Broderick

Protect East Wall – Opening Statement: Brendan Laird, Member of

Protect East Wall Group and Brendan Buck, Planning Consultant

148 Information on West Road Traffic Surveys submitted by Applicant

149 High Court Judgement – Smyth & Anor -V- Railway Procurement

Agency, submitted by Applicant



No. Observer

150 Applicant’s reponse to questions from Protect East Wall –

J.Harmon

151 Parkside North Strand Residents Group – presented by Brian

Harmon on behalf of Dolores Steele



No. Observer

150 Applicant’s reponse to questions from Protect East Wall –

J.Harmon

151 Parkside North Strand Residents Group – presented by Brian

Harmon on behalf of Dolores Steele

Day 38: Tuesday, 22nd February 2011

Submissions from the Docklands Area

No. Observer

158 North Port Dwellers’ Association

158A -Associated Slides/Visual Representations

158B – DVD

158C - Submission by Mary Murphy on behalf of NPDA

159 McDonnell Family Submission

160 Spencer Dock Development Co. Legal Submission – Garret Simons

160A – John Spain & Associates – Site Development History

160B – Slides/Visuals

160C – Appendix 3 – Building Drawings

160D – John Bruder – Site Development Impact

160E – Sean McCormack – Site Development/Valuation Impact

Day 39: Wednesday, 23rd February 2011


No. Observer

160 Spencer Dock Development Co. Ltd

160F –Maps/Drawings from Spencer Dock Masterplan

160G – Definition of a ‘High Building’

160H – SDD Co. Submission on Property Protection Scheme

160I – Mr Brian Madden Brief of Evidence: Engineering Report

160J – Mr Shay Cleary Brief of Evidence: Architecture

160K – Mr Cathal Crimmins Brief of Evidence: Achitectural

Conservation

160L – Mr Daryl Prashad Brief of Evidence: Noise & Vibration

160M – Mr Brian McCann Brief of Evidence: Traffic & Transport

160N - Brian Madden Additional Information/Drawings

160O - A1 Map from Mr McCann’s evidence brief

160P – Mr Dan Boyd Brief of Evidence: Estate Management Impact



No. Observer

161 A3 Drawing – Docklands North Shaft

161A – A1 Version Docklands North Shaft

162 DU Description of Railway Order Drawings – Further Clarification

by Gavin O’Donnell (Booklet of Powerpoint Slides)

162A – A3 Drawings DSK/10635 &10636 – Cross Sections at

Docklands Showing Separate & Composite Property Acquisition

Types

162B – A0 Versions of above drawings



No. Observer

163 James Synott

164 David Hughes Introductory Statement, CV & Qualifications &

Experience

164A –Watford Conference Presentation (J. Bustinduy) Oct 2009

164B – Architectural Portfolio Extracts

164 – Further Examples of previous work

Day 42: Tuesday, 1st March 2011

Module 8 - Submissions from the Pearse Station Area

No. Observer

164 David Hughes/Damian McGarry

164D – Risks of Project to Health, Safety and Property

164E – Lack of Consultation

164F – Environmental Risk Assessment & Risk Management

164G – Risk Assessment Matrix Diagrams

Day 43: Wednesday, 2nd March 2011


No. Observer

165 David Hughes/Damian McGarry – Mr McGarry’s Submission

165A - Appendices to Mr McGarry’s Submission

165B – Mr Hughes’ Submission on Track Alignment & Journey

Times

Day 44: Thursday, 3rd March 2011


No. Observer

165 David Hughes/Damian McGarry

165C – Mr Karl Searson Report – Noise & Vibration

165D – Photos accompanying Mr Searson’s Report

165E – Mr Hughes’ EIS Submission

165F – Mr Hughes Submission – Cost Benefit Analysis

Day 45: Tuesday, 8th March 2011


No. Observer

166 Kevin Humphries TD Submission

167 David Hughes – Photos & Alternative Design Drawings

168 Joint Submission David Hughes & Damien McGarry

169 Carmel McCormack & Residents of Erne Street Upper (Document

No. 1)

169A - Carmel McCormack & Residents of Erne Street Upper

(Documents No. 2&3)

Day 46: Wednesday, 9th March 2011


No. Document Description Submitted by

170 Applicant’s response to Mssrs Hughes,

McGarry et al re: Settlement of permanent

Structures & Utilities in the Pearse Square Area

Applicamt

171 Submission – O’Callaghan Hotels &

Associated Companies – John Spain Associates

presenting

171A – HKR Architects Submission for

O’Callaghan Hotels

171B HKR Visual Representations

(Slides/Drawings etc.)

171C – OCSC Submission for O’Callaghan

Hotels

O’Callaghan Hotels

& Associated

Companies

Day 47: Thursday, 10th March 2011



172 Presentation slides Damien McGarry

173 Compulsory Purchase Order Documentation Damien McGarry

174 174A

Grand Canal Square – Planning Context

Grand Canal Square – Impact on Buildings

Chartered Land

(Represented by

Stephen Little &

Associates)

Chartered Land

174B

Grand Canal Square – Noise and Vibration

(Represented by

O’Connor Sutton

Cronin)

Chartered Land

(Represented by

Marshall Day

Acoustics)

175 175A 175B 175C 175D

Grand Canal Theatre Company

Planning

Slides

Civil Engineering Aspects

Noise and Vibration

Mike Adamson

John Spain

Associates

O’Connor Sutton

Cronin

Marshall Day

Acoustics

Day 48: Friday, 11th March 2011

Module 9 - Submissions from St. Stephen’s Green Area


176 South King Street: Planning Context Chartered Land Ltd.

(Represented by

Stephen Little &

Associates)

177 South King Street Development-Project No.

C487

Chartered Land Ltd.

(Represented by

O’Connor Sutton

Cronin)

178

South King Street Chartered Land Ltd.

(Represented by

Marshall Day

Acoustics)

Day 49: Monday, 14th March 2011



179 Key Issues – PowerPoint presentation Reid Assoc. on

behalf of James

Adams and Sons

Ltd.

180 Railway Order and Environmental Effects Damian O’Regan

180a

St. Stephen’s Green (Dublin) Bill 1877 (216) Damian O’Regan

180b Dublin Transport Authority Act 2008 Damian O’Regan

180c Metro North and Interconnector overlaid on

St. Stephen’s Green

Damian O’Regan

181 Impacts on St. Stephen’s Green Area Peploe’s Wine

Bistro C/o Cunnane

Stratton Reynolds




182 Submission by R Kinhg, Chairman Amethyst

Consultants o.b.o Ampleforth Ltd T/A

Fitzwilliam Hotel

182A – Submission by John Spain Associates

o.b.o Ampleforth

182B – Associated Slides, Drawings & Photos

182C – Submission by Shane Carr (Marshall

Day Acoustics)

182D – Metro North Further Information

request, Fitzwilliam Hotel Impact Assessment

Ampleforth Ltd

183 Submission by John Spain Associates

representing Kildare Street & University Club

183A – Associated Drawings, Photos, Slides

etc

183B – Engineering Report submission by

O’Connor Sutton Cronin Consulting Engineers

Kildare Street &

University Club

184

Submission - Letter to An Bord Pleanala

dated 28.1.11

184A – Brochure & Photo of Cliff House

Hotel/22 St Stephen’s Green North

Ciaran McGrath




185 Response to Queries re Fire Safety &

Legislation

CIE

186 Submission o.b.o. Irish Life Assurances,

Stephen’s Green Centre Residents, Royal

College of Surgeons & Ventasker Ltd

186A - Submission on behalf of Irish Life

Assurances

Tom Phillips &

Associates

187

Submission on behalf of Royal College of

Surgeons

187A – Associated Slides, Drawings & Photos

etc

187B – Marshall Day Acoustics Report

187C – Brian Madden Engineering Report

John Spain

Associates

188 Letter to ABP dated 16.03.11 re Grand canal

Theatre Sound tests

John Spain

Associates

Day 52: Tuesday, 22nd March 2011

Module 10/11 - Submissions from Christchurch-Heuston/Inchicore & War

Memorial Park Area


189 Diageo Site Plan Drawings CIE

190 Responses to questions raised by Protect

East Wall Group

CIE

191

Submission Aifric Ní Chianáin &

Others

Day 53: Wednesday, 23rd March 2011

Module 11 - Submissions from Inchicore & War Memorial Park Area


192 Written Submission/Accompanying Slides,

Visuals etc.

Conor Flood &

Others

193 Written Submission/Accompanying Slides,

Visuals etc

Gerard McGeogh &

Louisa McDonald

194

Written Submission Joseph A Currivan

Day 54: Friday, 25th March 2011



195 Written Submission Niamh Flood, David

Lawless & May

Flood-Lawless

196 Written Submission Paul O’Shea

197

Written Submission Aine Costigan

198 Written Submission Cllr Rebecca

Moynihan

199 Written Submission Seven Oaks

Management

Company

200 Written Submission

200A – ‘Previous Experience’

200B – ‘Impacts of Construction’

200C – ‘Construction of Tunnels’

200D – ‘Proposed Outcomes’

200E – ‘Cumulative Impacts’

200F – Photos/Slides/Illustrations etc

Jo Homewood &

Ned McLoughlin




201 Karl Searson Noise Report for

McGeogh/McDonald &

Homewood/McLoughlin

201A – Associated Photographs

G. McGeogh & L.

McDonald/J.

Homewood & Ned

McLoughlin

202 Grand Canal Theatre Noise & Vibration Test

Proposal

C.I.E.

203

Grand Canal Theatre Noise & Vibration Test

Proposal

203A – Document detailing Qualifications &

Experience of Sound Engineer conducting

tests

Grand Canal

Theatre




204 Written Submission

204A – Associated Photographs/Slides

Inchicore Sports &

Social Club

205 Introductory Submission

205A – History of Inchicore Works & Estate

205B – Presentation of Local Railway History

‘Who We Are’ –Ms Deirdre O’Farrell/Ms.

Chris Bennett

205C – Public Consultation& Participation

205D – Associated Photos, Slides etc

205E – Planning , Station & Environs &

Proposed Future

Inchicore On Track

206

Questions to Applicant from Dr Walsh

Dr Fred Walsh

207 Public Consultation Documents from April

2009 Meetings with Inchicore on Track

C.I.E.

Day 57: Thursday, 31st March 2011



205 INCHICORE ON TRACK SUBMISSION (contd.

From Day 56)

205F – Construction and Operation

205G – Exchange of Correspondence between

Inchicore on Track and the Applicant,

November 2010

205H - Architecture & Built Heritage Part A

205I – Architecture & Built Heritage Part B

Inchicore On Track

Day 58: Friday, 1st April 2011



205 INCHICORE ON TRACK SUBMISSION (contd.

From Day 57)

205J – OTB Engineering Report

205K – Community Gain

205L - Suggested Conditions/Modifications

205M – Closing Statement

Inchicore On Track

208 Ordinance Survey Maps of Inchicore –

1867/1911/1994

209 – In day 60 – 6/4/11 – Louise Carroll

CIE/IE

Day 59: Tuesday, 5th April 2011



210 Photo of old CIE dormitory building, circa

1992

CIE

211 Written submission – Frank Moore Sherling Group

212 Copies of CIE & SHerling Group meeting

records

CIE

213 Aerial Photo & Map of Sherling Steelyard site CIE

214 DVD presentation – Frank Moore Sherling Group

Day 60: Wednesday, 6th April 2011



215 European Court of Justuice Ruling (FINAL)

215A – ECJ Ruling Just Satisfaction

Sherling Group

216 John Spain Associates’ Submission on Draft

Kildare County Development Plan

CIE

217 Sketch of Sherling Steelyard Re-configuration CIE

218 Response to Queries re Safety Standards &

Legislation

CIE

218A – Definition of Hierarchy of Design

Standards

218B – Property Advance Condition Survey

219 Settlement of Permanent Structures &

Utilities: St Stephen’s green

219A - Settlement of Permanent Structures &

Utilities: Heuston

219B - Settlement of Permanent Structures &

Utilities: Inchicore

219C – Scheduled Amendments to Book of

Reference

CIE

220 Letter re West Road Bridge Dublin City Council

221 Statement to hearing re agreement between

RPA/CIA

RPA

209 Written Submission (presented Day 54,

copies received 6/4/11)

Louise Carroll

DAY 62 – Friday, 8th April 2011

Module 12 – Closing Submissions


228 M. O’Donnell Response C.I.E.

229 R. Greer’s Contribution to applicant response C.I.E.

230 Ministerial Brief re Transport Budget O’Callaghan Hotels

231 Closing Legal Submission Spencer Dock

Development

Day 61: Thursday, 7th April 2011

Submissions in relation to Grand Canal

Theatre Noise Tests & Legal

219D 219C – Scheduled Amendments to Book of

Reference

C.I.E.

222 Error- Number not used

223 Demonstration of Train Noise at Grand Canal

Theatre

(disc containing 223 & 223A)

223A – Peutz Review on the methodology of

the Noise Test

223B – Figure 16: Comparison of spectral

content

223C – Millward Brown Lansdowne Focus

group

C.I.E.

224 Marshall Day Acoustics Report Grand Canal

Theatre – Listening tests.

224A – Engineered Acoustic Designs, Report

of Witnessed Listening Tests

224B – Marshall Day Response to questions

raised by Fred Walsh

Grand Canal

Theatre

225 Legal Submission by E. Galligan

225A – Extract from EIA Law and Practise

Grand Canal

Theatre

226 Response to Legal Submissions C.I.E.

227

Disc Version of

218A – Definition of Hierarchy of Design

Standard

Company

232 Inspector’s Closing Questions to Applicant ABP

233 Phase 4 Risk Management Strategy C.I.E.

234 Closing Submission Inchicore on Track

235 Closing Submission – Danielle Conaghan Diageo Ireland

236 Closing Submission Stephen’s Green

Centre/ Stephen’s

Court

237 Closing Submission Royal College of

Surgeons

238 Closing Submission Kildare St. Club

239 Closing Submission Fitzwilliam Hotel

240 Closing Submission Carmel McCormack,

David Hughes &

Upper Erne Street

Residents

241 Closing Submission David Hughes

242 Closing Submission Spencer Dock

Development

Company

243 Closing Submission Protect East Wall

244 Closing Submission West Road

Residents

245 Closing Submission Ossory Business

Park

246 Closing Submission Abercorn Road

Residents

247 Closing Submission Patricia Wainsforth

248 Closing Statement C.I.E.