darryl martin innovation and the development of the modern six-string guitar

Upload: fabio-carrilho

Post on 02-Jun-2018

218 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/10/2019 Darryl Martin Innovation and the Development of the Modern Six-String Guitar

    1/25

    Innovation and the Development of the Modern Six-String GuitarAuthor(s): Darryl MartinSource: The Galpin Society Journal, Vol. 51 (Jul., 1998), pp. 86-109Published by: Galpin SocietyStable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/842762.

    Accessed: 11/11/2014 04:43

    Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at.http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp

    .JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of

    content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms

    of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected].

    .

    Galpin Societyis collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to The Galpin Society

    Journal.

    http://www.jstor.org

    This content downloaded from 143.107.252.153 on Tue, 11 Nov 2014 04:43:30 AMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/action/showPublisher?publisherCode=galhttp://www.jstor.org/stable/842762?origin=JSTOR-pdfhttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/stable/842762?origin=JSTOR-pdfhttp://www.jstor.org/action/showPublisher?publisherCode=gal
  • 8/10/2019 Darryl Martin Innovation and the Development of the Modern Six-String Guitar

    2/25

    DARRYL

    MARTIN

    Innovation

    n d

    t h e

    Development

    t h e o d e r n

    Six string

    u i t a r

    INTRODUCTION

    ALITTLE

    over 100

    years ago,

    Orville Gibson

    -

    a

    violin,

    mandolin and

    guitar

    maker

    in

    Kalamazoo,

    Michigan

    -

    made a

    development

    to the

    six

    string guitar

    which is seen

    by many

    writers as

    defining

    the

    difference

    between the

    guitar

    used

    in

    serious 'art'

    music on

    the

    one

    hand,

    and

    'folk'

    music

    on the other. This

    adaptation

    was the

    use of

    steel

    strings

    on

    an

    instrument

    specifically designed

    to take

    the

    extra tension

    in

    place

    of the

    otherwise

    universal

    gut.

    This was

    not the first occasion that steel

    strings

    had been

    used on

    members of the guitar and lute family. In the late sixteenth and

    seventeenth

    centuries the bandora

    and

    orpharion

    were both

    wire

    strung,

    and

    frequently

    played

    music

    composed

    for the

    gut-strung

    lute. Metal

    strings

    were also used on

    the cittern

    and

    other members

    of that

    family

    -

    the

    Neapolitan

    mandolin,

    and

    the

    chitarra battente.

    A

    similar

    approach

    to

    that

    of Gibson can

    be found

    in

    several

    battentes

    which have

    been

    converted from

    gut-strung

    baroque guitars.

    It

    was not Gibson's

    intention to

    design

    an

    instrument

    suitable

    for folk

    or

    light

    music. Gibson

    designed

    his

    guitar

    to be

    a member

    of

    the

    group

    of

    instruments

    playing

    together

    as mandolin

    orchestras,

    needing

    the

    steel

    strings

    to

    help

    blend

    the

    sound,

    and to

    provide

    greater

    volume. This

    paper

    will discuss

    how the

    European

    makers

    of

    gut

    (and

    later

    nylon)

    strung

    instruments,

    and

    the American makers have

    independently

    progressed

    the

    design

    of their

    instruments

    throughout

    the late-

    nineteenth

    and twentieth

    centuries

    to

    the

    present

    day

    where the

    two

    traditions

    are

    regaining

    closer ties.

    THE NINETEENTH-CENTURY

    EUROPEAN

    GUITAR

    The

    modern

    guitar

    with

    six

    single

    strings

    developed

    in

    the last

    quarter

    of

    the

    eighteenth

    century, replacing

    the

    five-course

    (pairs

    of

    strings)

    baroque guitar.

    In the

    early part

    of

    the

    nineteenth

    century

    the instrument

    was

    being

    made

    throughout

    Europe,

    with established

    schools

    in

    London,

    86

    This content downloaded from 143.107.252.153 on Tue, 11 Nov 2014 04:43:30 AMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 8/10/2019 Darryl Martin Innovation and the Development of the Modern Six-String Guitar

    3/25

    Paris, Vienna,

    and also

    in

    Italy, Germany

    and

    Spain.

    The

    guitar

    had

    a

    great popularity,

    reflected in the

    publication

    of

    a

    great

    deal of

    music

    for

    the

    instrument.

    The

    major

    virtuosi of the instrument

    had

    widespread

    reputations

    and

    often travelled to

    perform

    in

    the

    major

    cities of

    Europe.

    A number of these

    performers

    have left

    tutors,

    giving

    modern scholars

    information

    about their

    playing techniques,

    and due

    to

    the

    difficult nature of

    guitar playing

    technique,

    it

    is these

    performers

    who have also left the

    majority

    of

    the

    guitar

    music

    of

    the

    period.

    The

    instruments of the time are

    generally

    smaller than

    the

    classical

    guitar

    of

    today;

    the

    string

    length

    generally

    measuring

    about 630

    mm,1

    though

    standard

    pitch2 examples

    can be

    found

    with

    string

    lengths

    ranging from 605-10 mm3 to 650 mm.4 The body shapes tended to

    follow

    relatively

    similar

    proportions,

    but the end of

    the

    eighteenth

    and

    beginning

    of the

    nineteenth centuries saw the first

    major

    innovation

    since the

    standardisation

    of six

    single strings,

    with the

    introduction

    of

    'fan

    barring'

    under

    the lower half

    of the soundboard

    and the

    bridge.

    This

    barring

    arrangement

    first

    originated

    in

    Spain,

    in the

    last two

    decades

    of

    the

    eighteenth century,

    and

    appears

    in

    instruments of

    makers

    such as

    Pages

    and

    Benedid,

    both

    working

    in

    Cadiz.

    In

    about

    1819 Louis

    Panormo

    began

    to use a similar

    barring arrangement

    in his

    guitars built in London [see

    Fig.

    1].

    Panormo's label makes reference to

    this

    barring,

    referring

    to the

    instruments as

    'The

    only guitars

    built

    in

    the

    Spanish style'.

    Some of the

    credit for the

    use of this

    innovation

    in

    his

    instruments

    may

    belong

    to

    the

    celebrated Catalan

    born

    virtuoso

    Fernando Sor. Panormo

    also used a

    raised

    fingerboard,

    rather

    than the

    flush

    fingerboard

    found

    commonly

    on

    other instruments

    of the

    period.

    Elsewhere

    in

    Europe,

    the

    guitar

    retained

    the

    lateral

    cross

    barring

    that had

    been

    developed centuries before and used in the lute and

    baroque

    guitar.

    In

    this

    barring

    three or four

    bars are

    placed

    at

    right

    angles

    to

    the

    soundboard

    grain,

    often with

    the bar

    above the

    bridge

    set

    at an

    angle.

    This

    gives

    a

    larger

    vibrating

    area

    to the bass

    side

    [see

    Fig.

    2].

    1

    For

    example

    the

    standard

    nstruments rom the

    Lacote

    (Paris)

    and Panormo

    (London)

    workshops.

    2

    This is

    not to

    imply

    that

    there was

    a constant

    pitch

    standard

    hroughout

    Europethat allguitarsweretunedto, butrather efers o instrumentswhich were

    not built as

    specific

    high

    pitch

    instruments uch as

    Terz

    guitars,

    which

    aretuned a

    minor

    third

    high

    (to

    be

    played

    n

    duets

    with

    standard

    models).

    3

    The

    'Legnani'

    model instruments

    built

    by

    Staufer

    n

    Vienna

    (see

    the

    Galpin

    Society

    Made

    for

    Music

    Exhibition

    Catalogue

    (London,

    1986),

    and 1822

    (EUCHMI,

    No.770).

    4

    Guitars

    by

    Gennaro

    Fabricatore,

    Naples,

    1818

    (see

    the

    Galpin Society

    Made

    for

    Music

    Exhibition

    Catalogue,

    No.29),

    and 1822

    (EUCHMI,

    No.770).

    87

    This content downloaded from 143.107.252.153 on Tue, 11 Nov 2014 04:43:30 AMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 8/10/2019 Darryl Martin Innovation and the Development of the Modern Six-String Guitar

    4/25

    a

    FIG. I

    Panormo,

    UCHMI

    No. 2014

    k z z D

    FIG.2

    Lac3te,

    UCHMI

    No. 2521

    Note: All illustrations re drawn rom the

    top

    of the

    soundboard,

    he

    soundboard

    drawnas

    if it

    were

    transparent,

    he

    bass

    strings

    are therefore o the left-handside.

    In both of these

    types

    of

    designs

    the width acrossthe lower bout

    is

    approximately

    12 ,5

    it was

    not until

    shortly

    after

    1850 that the next

    major

    step originated,

    with the

    guitar

    as

    designed

    by

    Antonio

    Torres,

    which forms the

    basis,

    with little

    alteration,

    for most

    of

    the classical

    guitarsbeing

    made

    to

    this

    day.6

    Torres

    used a

    650

    mm

    string ength,

    and

    larger

    body

    dimensions,

    the width across he lower bout

    being

    close to

    14 [see Fig. 3]. The body was also made deeper. The fan barring

    covered

    all of the lower area of the

    soundboard,

    rather than

    being

    concentrated

    near the centre line

    as occurs

    in the

    instruments

    of

    Panormo.

    In

    addition to these

    large

    concert

    guitars,

    which have been

    used almost

    without

    exception,

    and little

    variation,

    for all

    concert

    classical

    guitars

    built to the middle of the twentieth

    century,

    Torres

    also

    built smaller

    guitars, ypical

    of

    the earlier nstruments f the

    century

    with

    5The

    lower bout

    measurement is

    commonly

    used

    as a reference when

    discussing

    he size of

    a

    guitar

    as a

    simple comparative

    device

    when

    referring

    o

    different

    models.

    Generally

    he maxim

    'bigger

    s best'

    (within reason)

    applies

    n

    the

    opinion

    of both

    makers

    and

    players.

    Since

    American

    guitar

    makers

    nvariably

    quote

    lower bout measurements

    n

    inches,

    especially

    n

    publicity,

    I shall follow

    the same convention.

    6

    See

    Jose

    Romanillos: Antonio de Torres.GuitarMaker His

    Life

    & Work

    (Shaftesbury,

    987),

    Part

    1,

    Chapter

    4.

    88

    This content downloaded from 143.107.252.153 on Tue, 11 Nov 2014 04:43:30 AMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 8/10/2019 Darryl Martin Innovation and the Development of the Modern Six-String Guitar

    5/25

    string lengths

    of

    approximately

    605

    mm,

    and

    friction

    pegs

    rather

    than

    modern

    style

    guitar

    geared

    tuners.7

    FIG.

    3.

    Torres

    THE

    NINETEENTH-CENTURY

    AMERICAN

    GUITAR

    In

    the

    1830s,

    Christian

    Friedrich

    Martin,

    who

    had worked

    as a

    foreman

    in

    the

    Viennese

    workshop

    of

    Johan

    Georg

    Staufer,

    left

    Europe

    for

    America.

    Much of

    Staufer's

    eputation

    oday

    is

    due to his

    famed

    worker;

    as well

    as

    one of

    his

    inventions,

    the

    arpeggione8

    a bowed

    guitar

    -

    an

    instrument most

    notable

    for

    a famous

    sonata by Schubert, nowadays

    commonly

    played

    on

    the

    viola.

    Many

    features

    which can

    be

    found on

    the

    guitars

    of

    today

    -

    the

    floating ingerboard

    bove

    the

    soundboard,9

    he

    bolt-on

    adjustable

    neck,10

    and the

    six-on-a-side

    tuners11

    were

    all

    developed

    and used on

    Staufer'snstruments,

    most

    notably

    on

    the

    Luigi

    7

    The

    use

    of friction

    pegs

    rather han

    tuners

    also

    occurs

    on

    some

    of

    Torres'

    larger guitars

    as

    well,

    suggesting

    their use

    was

    strictly

    according

    to

    financial

    considerations.For full

    details

    about the

    instruments

    built

    by

    Torres,

    and his

    designandworkingmethods,see Romanillos:Antoniode Torres. he secondpart

    of this

    book

    dealswith

    all

    aspects

    of

    the

    instruments

    made

    by

    Torres.

    8

    A

    surviving

    arpeggione

    s

    now in the

    Musikinstrumenten

    Museum,

    Berlin.

    9

    Found

    n

    almostall

    archtopguitars

    built this

    century.

    This

    very

    invention

    was

    used on

    the

    (in)famous

    'tilt-neck'

    Fender

    Stratocaster

    uitars

    n

    the

    1970s.

    11

    Found n the

    instruments f

    Paul

    Bigsby,

    and

    particularly

    hose of

    the

    Fender

    Company.

    89

    This content downloaded from 143.107.252.153 on Tue, 11 Nov 2014 04:43:30 AMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 8/10/2019 Darryl Martin Innovation and the Development of the Modern Six-String Guitar

    6/25

    Legnani

    model.12

    Legnani

    was a famous

    guitar

    virtuoso of the

    early

    nineteenth

    century,

    and

    this model is an

    early example

    of

    'Celebrity

    advertising'.13

    Another

    pupil

    of

    Staufer

    -

    Johann

    Schertzer

    -

    has left

    surviving

    10

    string guitars,

    with 4

    sub-bass

    strings going

    from the

    bridge

    to a headstock

    (attached

    between a column from the

    guitar body

    and the

    standard

    peghead).

    This

    design

    possibly

    formed the

    concept

    basis

    of the

    Gibson

    company's much-promoted

    Harp

    Guitar

    in

    the first

    quarter

    of

    the twentieth

    century.

    Martin worked for

    Staufer,

    probably

    during

    the

    early

    1820s,

    leaving

    in

    1825 to return to his home

    town

    of

    Markneukirchen

    by

    1826,

    when he

    was named

    in

    a

    legal dispute

    with members of

    the violin-makers

    guild.14

    As an

    eventual result

    of

    this

    dispute

    Martin,

    and a number of other

    guitar

    makers from the town, moved to the United States. Martin arrived in

    1833,

    setting up

    a

    shop

    in

    New York

    City.

    Martin's

    earliest instruments were

    essentially

    identical to the

    instruments he had been

    building

    in

    Staufer's

    workshop,

    and

    featuring

    many

    of

    the innovations first

    developed by

    Staufer

    -

    the

    bolt-on

    adjustable

    neck,

    floating

    fingerboard,

    and six-on-a-side tuners

    are

    all

    found on

    early

    Martin

    instruments.15s

    Many

    of his earliest

    American

    made

    guitars

    have a

    distinctive

    decoration,

    using inlayed

    semi-circles

    of

    mother-of-pearl

    and abalone around the soundhole

    and

    edge

    of the

    soundboard. On his most elaborate

    examples

    he used ivory for the

    bridge, fingerboard

    and

    head.16

    12

    See

    the

    Galpin

    Society

    Made

    or

    MusicExhibition

    Catalogue,

    No.31,

    for a

    photograph

    of

    a

    Legnani

    model

    Staufer

    uitar.

    13

    It is

    not, however,

    the

    only

    example

    of it. Fernando

    Sor,

    the Catalan

    guitarist iving

    in

    Parishas

    signed

    a

    number

    of

    guitars

    by

    Rene Lac6te

    examples

    now survive

    in

    the

    Edinburgh University

    Collection

    of Historic

    Musical

    Instruments,

    Cat.

    No.2521;

    and in

    privateownership

    (exhibited

    at the London

    Early

    MusicInstrumentMakers

    Exhibition,

    1991).

    Soralso lent his name to the

    instruments

    of

    Louis

    Panormo of London.

    However,

    in neither

    case is the

    instrument

    known,

    then

    or

    now,

    as

    a

    'Sor

    model'.

    14

    This,

    and further information about the

    early

    life

    of

    C.

    E Martin

    comes

    from

    George

    Gruhn

    and Walter

    Carter;

    AcousticGuitarsand

    Other Fretted

    Instruments

    a

    Photographicistory

    San

    Francisco,

    1993);

    and Walter

    Carter;The

    Martin

    Book

    London,

    1995).

    15

    The constructionmethods were

    probably

    essentially

    he same as

    well.

    This

    seems to have been

    overlooked

    by

    modern researchers

    who are

    tracing

    constructionevidencein earlynineteenth-centuryguitars.The Martincompany

    is still

    in

    family ownership

    and has sufferedno

    major upheavals

    or

    workshop

    disasters.

    Therefore,

    much

    evidence

    concerning

    original

    construction

    methods

    probably

    very

    similar o those used

    by

    the

    company

    oday

    is

    still

    available.

    16

    The finest collection of

    surviving

    Staufer-Martin

    uitars belongs

    to the

    American collector

    Scott

    Chinery.

    A

    number of these instruments

    have

    been

    photographed

    and

    published

    n

    Vintage

    Guitar

    Gallery, anuary

    1995

    (including

    a

    feature

    on the

    collector),

    andJuly

    1995.

    90

    This content downloaded from 143.107.252.153 on Tue, 11 Nov 2014 04:43:30 AMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 8/10/2019 Darryl Martin Innovation and the Development of the Modern Six-String Guitar

    7/25

    In

    1839 Martin moved

    from

    New

    York

    City

    to

    Nazareth,

    Pennsylvania,

    nd

    from 1840

    to

    at

    least

    1851

    formed

    a

    partnership

    with

    John

    Coupa.17

    Martin

    started o

    change

    his

    designs

    and

    began

    to

    develop

    the

    instruments hat

    can be consideredas the distinctive

    American

    guitar.

    The width of the upperbout wasreduced,the six-on-a-side tunersgave

    way

    to

    three-each-side

    uners,

    and the interior

    barringchanged,

    as

    the

    maker

    started o

    develop

    what

    is

    now known

    as

    X-barring,

    which

    has

    become

    the

    standard

    or

    all

    steel-strung

    lat

    top

    acoustic

    guitars oday.

    An

    example

    of

    the

    developing

    X-barred

    guitar

    rom this

    period

    can

    be

    seen

    at the

    EdinburghUniversity

    Collection of

    Historic

    Musical

    nstruments.18

    [see

    Fig.

    4]

    The lower bouts

    of this

    instrumentmeasure

    12

    across.

    By

    1852

    Martin had

    standardised is

    instruments nto model

    numbers,

    the

    larger

    the

    body

    the

    lower the

    number,19and soon after he had

    standardised

    is

    decoration

    (this

    time in

    reverse,

    he

    higher

    the

    number,

    the

    more elaborate

    decoration).

    The

    above-mentioned

    guitar,

    though

    built before

    Martinhad

    standardisedhe

    body

    sizes,

    corresponds

    o a

    size

    2,

    the

    second

    largest

    of

    the 1852

    models

    (the

    largest

    being

    size

    1

    at

    123/4 ).20

    In

    1854 size

    0 was

    introduced,

    at

    13'2 .

    The next

    increase n

    body

    size

    occurred

    n

    1877

    when size 00

    was

    introduced,

    with

    a lower

    bout

    14%

    wide.

    By

    this

    time the

    gut-strung parlor' uitar

    of

    Americawas

    more-or-less

    the same size asthe gut-strung classical' uitar hat Torreshaddeveloped

    in

    Europe.

    The

    more

    radical of

    Johan

    Staufer's

    deas

    -

    The

    floating

    17

    Coupa

    was a

    guitar

    teacher

    n New

    York who

    acted as

    Martin's

    agent

    and

    salesroom.

    The actual

    construction of

    the

    guitars

    was

    entirely

    the

    work

    of

    Martin.

    1

    This

    instrument

    (Catalogue No.768)

    is

    illustrated

    n

    Volume 1 of

    the

    EUCHMI

    catalogue,

    p.46

    (with

    incorrect

    attribution).

    The

    features

    mentioned

    in

    the

    text

    suggest

    the

    instrument

    was

    built

    in

    1845-50. This

    guitar

    is more

    elaboratehan mostMartinguitarsof the

    period,

    particularly

    he decorative

    nlay

    aroundthe

    soundhole,

    and

    it retains

    he

    six-on-a-side

    tuners,

    suggesting

    t

    may

    havebeen a

    special

    order.

    There

    is no

    label inside the

    instrument,

    but

    that

    should

    not be

    seen as

    suspicious

    although

    Martin

    usually

    ixed the

    label

    on

    the

    inside

    of the

    back of

    the

    guitar,

    nstruments

    hat retain

    original

    cases

    sometimesshow

    the

    label on

    the case

    rather han

    the

    guitar

    tself.

    19

    This

    seems

    surprising

    t

    first,

    since most

    people

    would

    expect

    a

    biggerbody

    to have

    a

    higher

    number.

    Almost

    certainly

    his is a

    throwback o

    Martin's ime

    in

    Europe

    when

    wire

    (and

    possibly

    also

    gut?)

    was numbered

    n that

    fashion

    -

    the

    thicker he wire the lowerthe gaugenumber.

    2()

    The

    Edinburgh

    University

    Collection also

    possesses

    guitar

    of

    this

    size

    (with

    model

    28

    decoration),

    Catalogue

    No.291,

    illustrated n

    Volume 1

    of

    the

    EUCHMI

    Catalogue,

    page

    46.

    Though

    the

    instrument is

    labelled

    'C.

    E

    MARTIN &

    CO.

    /

    NEW

    YORK',

    the

    instrument was

    built in

    Nazareth

    sometime

    between

    1870 and

    1898

    -

    Martin

    instruments

    were

    distributed

    rom

    New York

    until

    1898,

    when the

    change

    to

    Nazareth

    was also

    reflected

    on the

    instrument

    abels.

    91

    This content downloaded from 143.107.252.153 on Tue, 11 Nov 2014 04:43:30 AMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 8/10/2019 Darryl Martin Innovation and the Development of the Modern Six-String Guitar

    8/25

    II I I

    FIG.4.

    C.

    E

    Martin,

    EUCHMI

    No.

    768

    fingerboard,

    bolt-on

    adjustable

    neck,

    and

    six-on-a-side tuners had all

    been droppedby Martin as standard ppointments althoughsome were

    still available nd

    used

    on

    special

    orders

    as late as

    1898).

    Exterior-wise,

    the late instruments

    of Torresand

    Martinwere similar.

    On

    the

    interior,

    the

    fan-barring

    of Torres

    was

    very

    different o the

    X-barring

    of

    Martin,

    and

    it

    would not be for another

    50

    years

    hat

    X-barring

    would come into

    its own on

    steel-strung

    instruments.

    Writing

    from the historical

    perspective

    offered at the end of the

    twentieth

    century,

    t is

    fair

    to

    say

    that,

    although very popular

    in

    their

    time,

    the

    gut-strung

    X-barred

    instruments

    are not as successful

    as fan-barred

    guitars.

    C.

    E

    (Chris)

    Martin

    IV,

    the

    great-great-great-greatrandson

    of Christian

    Friedrich,

    and the

    present

    head

    of

    C.

    E

    Martin&

    Co.,

    tried

    to

    introduce

    a line of

    modern

    classical

    guitars

    with

    X-barring,

    only

    to find

    they

    were

    very

    poor sounding.21

    THE

    TWENTIETH CENTURY

    The

    Martin

    company

    was not alone

    in

    making guitars

    n

    nineteenth-

    century America,

    nor

    for that

    matter were

    they

    even the

    biggest

    company.

    That distinction

    belongs

    to

    Lyon

    and

    Healy,

    manufacturing

    guitars

    under the

    Washburn label. In 1889

    they

    boasted

    25,000

    instrumentsbuilt since

    they

    commenced

    manufacturing quarter

    of a

    century

    earlier,

    and

    claimedto be

    making

    100,000

    guitars

    a

    year by

    the

    21

    See

    Walter

    Carter,The

    Martin

    Book,

    p.16.

    92

    This content downloaded from 143.107.252.153 on Tue, 11 Nov 2014 04:43:30 AMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 8/10/2019 Darryl Martin Innovation and the Development of the Modern Six-String Guitar

    9/25

    turn of the

    century,

    a

    figure

    probably

    greatly exaggerated,

    but

    even

    taking exaggeration

    into

    account

    they

    were

    producing

    much more

    than

    all

    other

    makers.22

    The

    Martin

    company

    were

    making perhaps

    200

    guitars

    a

    year.

    The

    major

    difference between

    the

    companies

    was

    that

    Martin were

    making

    quality

    guitars,

    whilst

    Lyon

    and

    Healy

    were

    producing mostly budget

    mail-order instruments. Other makers at

    the

    end of the

    nineteenth

    century

    included

    Bauer, Bohmann, Waldo,

    the

    Larson

    Brothers,

    and Orville

    Gibson.

    Although

    I

    have

    given

    credit to

    Gibson

    for

    developing

    the

    steel-strung

    guitar,

    it

    is

    important

    to consider

    the claim

    of

    the Larson Brothers. Carl

    and

    August

    Larson

    were

    born in

    Sweden and moved to

    Chicago

    in

    the

    1880s.

    By

    the

    mid 1890s

    they

    were

    building guitars

    for various

    companies, some under the Champion name, others for a teacher named

    Robert

    Maurer,

    who

    in

    1900 sold his

    factory

    to

    Carl Larson and two

    partners

    (who

    were soon

    replaced by August

    in

    that

    year).

    From the

    outset,

    the Larsons built

    flat

    top

    guitars

    designed

    for

    steel

    strings,

    and

    might

    have

    actually

    built

    guitars

    using

    steel

    strings

    as

    standard

    prior

    to

    Gibson.

    Certainly

    Gibson set

    up

    in

    business before the

    Larsons,

    and

    there

    is no firm

    information

    about Gibson's instrument

    making

    activities

    before his

    earliest

    surviving

    instrument

    -

    a

    ten

    string

    (five

    course)

    mandolin-guitar

    (tuned

    to

    the five

    highest

    strings

    of a

    guitar)

    -

    in 1894.

    Gibson

    certainly

    deserves the credit for innovation -

    although

    the

    guitars

    of the

    Larson Brothers were

    specifically

    designed

    for

    steel

    strings

    with the

    construction

    designed

    accordingly,

    Gibson

    took

    the

    guitar

    in

    a new

    direction,

    based on the violin

    and

    mandolin.

    Orville Gibson

    was born in

    Chateaugay,

    New York

    State

    in

    1856,23

    the

    son of

    English

    immigrants.

    In

    his

    early

    adulthood he

    left

    New

    York,

    moving

    west to

    Kalamazoo,

    Michigan,

    where he was

    first

    listed

    in the

    City Directory

    in

    1881. His

    profession

    was

    that of a

    clerk,

    firstly

    at a shoe

    store, and later at a restaurant. It was probably during the 1880s that

    Gibson

    began

    to make

    musical

    instruments. He

    certainly

    made

    instruments

    as an amateur

    before

    launching

    his

    full-time

    business

    in

    1896,

    the

    year

    he

    was

    listed

    in

    the

    city

    directory

    as a

    'manufacturer of

    musical

    instruments',

    having

    his

    shop

    (and

    residence)

    in

    the

    centre of the

    town. His

    amateur

    activities were

    intended as

    a serious

    pursuit

    -

    Gibson

    no doubt

    considered himself

    to be an

    instrument

    maker

    long

    before he

    was able to

    give

    up

    his

    other

    employment.24

    His

    first

    surviving

    instrument was the

    10

    string

    mandolin-guitar

    mentioned

    above,

    and that

    instrument has all the characteristics found in his later instruments. The

    following

    year

    -

    still

    before

    being

    listed as a full

    time

    instrument

    maker

    -

    22

    See

    Gruhnand

    Carter:

    Acoustic

    Guitars,

    p.29-30.

    23

    All

    of the

    biographical

    nformation

    about Gibson

    comes from

    Walter

    Carter:

    GibsonGuitars

    100 Years

    f

    an

    Americancon

    Los

    Angeles,

    1994).

    24

    This

    situation

    s

    not

    uncommon,

    even

    today.

    93

    This content downloaded from 143.107.252.153 on Tue, 11 Nov 2014 04:43:30 AMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 8/10/2019 Darryl Martin Innovation and the Development of the Modern Six-String Guitar

    10/25

    Gibson filed

    his

    patent

    for a

    mandolin,

    the

    patent

    being

    issued

    on

    1

    February

    1898.25 The

    patent

    contains what

    is

    perhaps

    the

    most

    far-

    reaching

    innovation

    of

    the twentieth

    century

    acoustic

    guitar

    -

    the

    top

    and

    bottom of the instrument are carved rather

    than flat

    (as

    found

    on the

    soundboards

    of other mandolins and

    guitars),

    or made

    up

    of

    many

    ribs

    (as

    on

    the

    Neapolitan

    style

    mandolin

    -

    the

    only type

    available

    before

    Gibson).

    The

    patent

    was for more

    than

    that

    -

    Gibson

    specified

    that the

    neck and rims

    (sides)

    are carved

    out of a

    single piece

    of

    wood,

    rather

    than

    bent to

    shape,

    and

    the

    neck

    was

    made hollow

    under the

    fingerboard

    to

    increase the air

    cavity.26

    It was

    Gibson's

    intention

    that

    the

    body

    of the

    instrument should

    be free of all

    stresses,

    an

    idea

    which was

    probably

    a

    mistaken

    understanding

    of

    violin

    design.

    But Gibson

    clearly

    believed that

    the concept produced a superior tone - despite the much larger amount

    of work

    required,

    almost

    all of Orville

    Gibson's

    surviving

    instruments

    are

    built

    in

    this

    manner.

    Gibson made a

    variety

    of

    instruments

    -

    there

    is

    a

    surviving

    zither,

    a

    lyre-mandolin,27

    guitars,28

    mandocellos,

    and two

    types

    of

    mandolin

    which

    he referred to as

    Style

    A and

    Style

    E These

    two

    mandolin

    styles

    form

    the standard

    designs

    still used

    today.

    Orville

    Gibson's instruments

    have characteristics

    which

    make

    them

    easy

    to

    identify.

    The

    first

    is the carved

    top

    -

    a distinctive

    shape

    which

    does

    not

    follow the

    general

    contours as found

    in

    violins,

    but rather

    is

    a

    convex curve to within about

    /2-1

    of the sides before

    becoming

    concave

    to

    the

    edge.

    The carved

    backs are flat

    over most

    of their

    area,

    the

    curve

    starting

    within

    1-12

    of the

    sides.

    The

    sides

    are,

    of

    course,

    carved

    rather

    than

    bent

    -

    as

    indicated

    in

    the

    patent

    -

    and flow

    smoothly

    into

    the

    neck rather

    than

    having

    the more usual

    joint

    found

    in

    other

    guitars.

    The

    wood

    used

    for the back and

    sides

    is

    usually

    American

    walnut.

    The

    decoration

    often features

    an

    inlaid star

    and crescent

    (reputedly

    done

    by

    a

    Turkish

    man

    living

    in

    Kalamazoo),

    and

    the

    better models

    have a

    black-

    stained soundboard with inlay around the oval soundhole, an edge

    banding

    of

    alternate

    pieces

    of

    ebony

    and mother

    of

    pearl,

    and an

    inlaid

    scratchplate

    motif

    between

    the

    soundhole

    and

    the

    bridge,

    often

    in

    the

    25

    U.S.

    Patent598245.

    26

    For a full

    discussion

    on the

    technical

    details of

    Orville

    Gibson's

    paper,

    see

    Darryl

    Martin:

    Tension

    Free Instruments

    The

    Guitarand

    Mandolin

    Designs

    of

    OrvilleGibson.

    Paper

    read at the

    Colloquium

    on Historical

    Musical

    Instrument

    Acoustics

    and

    Technology,

    Edinburgh,August

    1997.

    27The labelinsidethe earlyGibsoncompany nstrumentshowsa photograph

    of Orville Gibson's

    head

    surrounded

    y

    a

    lyre

    mandolin.

    In 1976

    an

    original

    yre-

    mandolin

    was

    taken

    to the Gibson

    company

    for restoration

    work,

    and

    inside

    this

    instrument

    was the label

    mentioned

    above,

    showing

    that

    Gibson

    made

    at least

    two

    of these

    instruments.

    See Carter

    Gibson,

    .30.

    28

    The

    earliest

    dated

    guitar

    known

    to me

    is

    1898

    (collection

    of Scott

    Chinery,

    see

    Vintage

    Guitar

    Gallery, anuary

    1995,

    for

    a

    photo

    (and

    some

    discussion)

    f this

    instrument.

    94

    This content downloaded from 143.107.252.153 on Tue, 11 Nov 2014 04:43:30 AMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 8/10/2019 Darryl Martin Innovation and the Development of the Modern Six-String Guitar

    11/25

    shape

    of

    a

    butterfly.

    However the most

    distinctive feature

    is

    the sheer

    size

    of

    the

    instruments. The

    string

    length

    is standardised

    at

    approximately

    243/4

    (629

    mm),

    and the

    width across the lower

    bout

    is

    16-17 .

    A

    similar

    feature is found is his

    mandolins,

    where

    the

    string

    length

    of

    Gibson's instruments is 15

    (381

    mm),

    rather than the more usual

    13 .

    The

    body

    was

    accordingly larger,

    the

    width

    across

    the widest

    point might

    measure

    11 ,

    rather than a

    typical Neapolitan style

    mandolin's

    73/4 .

    On

    10

    October

    1902,

    five

    Kalamazoo businessmen

    bought

    out

    Orville

    Gibson

    and formed what was then

    known as the 'Gibson

    Mandolin-

    Guitar

    Manufacturing

    Co.,

    Limited'.

    This

    company

    has,

    through

    the

    century,

    become

    renowned as one of the best

    makers

    of

    all the

    types

    of

    fretted

    instruments

    they

    have

    built. Orville

    was

    initially

    paid

    to act as

    a

    consultant, showing others how to make the instruments, but soon found

    the

    job

    not

    to

    his

    liking.

    At

    the

    beginning,

    the

    instruments were

    essentially

    identical

    to those of

    Orville Gibson the

    luthier,

    and built

    in

    the

    same manner.

    The

    Company

    introduced its first

    catalogue

    in

    1903

    emphasising

    all

    of the

    virtues

    of

    Orville's carved bodies. There

    were

    five

    initial

    product

    lines

    -mandolins,

    mandolas,

    mandocellos,

    guitars

    and

    harp

    guitars.

    The Gibson

    Company slowly

    started to

    change

    some of

    Orville's

    construction

    methods,

    particularly

    on

    the

    mandolin

    product

    line

    where

    the

    F

    style

    mandolin

    had lost a

    body

    point

    by

    1910.29

    The

    string length

    was also reduced to the

    present-day

    standard of

    13%7

    The Gibson

    Company

    claimed

    to

    take

    a

    standard

    13

    scale as

    found on a violin

    and

    added

    %7

    or the

    width

    of

    the

    frets).

    The

    other

    changes

    found their

    way

    onto

    guitars

    as

    well

    -

    the

    sides were bent in

    the

    normal

    fashion rather

    than

    being

    carved,

    the air

    cavity

    under

    the

    fingerboard

    was

    removed,

    the

    curve

    over

    the

    soundboard

    began

    to

    follow the

    general

    shape

    of a

    violin,

    29

    The

    F

    style

    mandolin s

    the

    industry

    tandard

    or

    high

    quality

    designs oday.

    It

    is

    very

    distinctive

    the modern

    instrument

    having

    two

    points

    on the

    lower

    (treble)

    side,

    one

    forming

    a

    sharp

    upper

    bout,

    the other close to the bottom of

    the

    instrument.

    On the

    bassside the

    upper

    bout is in the

    form of

    an

    open

    scroll

    towards

    he

    direction

    of

    the

    fingerboard.

    The

    pre-1910

    mandolin had an

    extra

    body point

    just

    below

    the scroll

    on

    the bass

    side,

    opposite

    the

    upper

    treble

    point.

    The

    two

    upper points

    and

    scroll

    (though

    going away

    from the

    fingerboard)

    re

    found on

    an

    instrument

    known as

    a

    Guitarpa

    essentially

    a

    harp guitar

    with

    super-treble

    trings

    at a

    higher pitch

    on the

    treble

    side.

    A

    Guitarpa

    was

    shown at

    the

    Great

    Exhibition

    at

    Crystal

    Palace,

    London, 1851,

    (see

    Peter

    and

    Ann

    Mactaggart

    eds):

    Musical

    nstrumentsn

    the

    1851

    Exhibition

    Welwyn,

    1986),

    plate

    14 for anillustration), nd it hasbeen suggested hat it was thisinstrumentwhich

    formed

    the basis

    of

    Orville

    Gibson's

    original

    design.

    This

    authorwill

    pursue

    this

    suggestion

    in a

    future

    article. The

    Martin

    company

    made

    four

    harp guitars

    between

    1902 and

    1911

    which

    follow

    the

    Guitarpaconcept

    quite closely,

    in

    having

    the

    harp

    strings

    passing

    over

    a

    second

    neck,

    giving

    an initial

    appearance

    f

    a

    double

    neck

    guitar.

    See

    Carter:

    Martin,

    pp.36-37

    for an

    illustration nd

    details.

    The

    Guitarpa

    tself

    probably

    originated

    as a

    development

    of the

    harp-lute

    or

    dital

    harp,

    as

    made

    by

    Edward

    Light

    n

    London

    early

    n

    the

    eighteenth

    century.

    95

    This content downloaded from 143.107.252.153 on Tue, 11 Nov 2014 04:43:30 AMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 8/10/2019 Darryl Martin Innovation and the Development of the Modern Six-String Guitar

    12/25

    and

    the

    essentially

    lat back

    was

    replacedby

    a curved

    one,

    similar

    n

    contour to that of the

    soundboard.

    The

    inlaid

    scratchplate

    as

    replaced

    by

    an elevated

    one

    (for

    which the

    Gibson

    Company

    alsoheld

    a

    Patent).

    Some

    guitarbody

    sizesalso

    ncreased,

    with

    the

    appearance

    n the

    1904

    catalogue

    of the

    'special

    auditorium'model,

    being

    18 across he lower bout. The

    Style

    U

    Harp guitars

    were even

    wider

    at

    183/4 .30

    hat

    the

    guitar

    was still

    being thought

    of

    as

    a memberof

    the mandolin

    amily

    can

    be

    seen

    in the

    design

    of

    the

    Company's

    tyle

    O guitar

    which features

    Style

    F

    type

    scroll

    on the bass

    upper

    bout

    and

    corresponding

    utaway

    ending

    in

    a

    sharp

    point,

    allowing

    access o the

    higher

    rets,

    on the treble ide.

    The Gibson

    Company

    was

    alone

    in

    the

    field of

    carved

    top guitars.

    The Martin

    Company

    were

    continuing

    to

    make their

    flat

    top

    guitars, having introduced a larger body size - 000, a 15 wide

    special-order

    instrument first

    appearing

    in

    1902. All of the

    Martin

    guitars

    retained

    gut stringing.

    The Larson

    Brothers,

    manufacturing

    under

    a

    variety

    of

    brand names

    -

    none

    of

    them

    their own

    -

    were

    continuing

    with their

    steel-strung

    instruments,

    including

    harp

    guitars

    built

    along very

    different

    lines

    to

    the

    Gibson

    type.

    The

    Larson

    design

    featured a

    long

    'extention

    horn'

    on the

    bass

    side

    -

    the

    back

    and sides of the same

    pieces

    of

    rosewood,

    and the

    soundboard

    of

    spruce

    with an additional soundhole.

    This horn extended

    from

    the bassupper bout and curved towards the peghead where it had its

    own

    peghead

    (holding

    six sub-bass

    strings)

    attached to the

    side of

    the

    headstock.

    Lyon

    and

    Healy

    continued

    making

    their

    instruments

    until

    production

    ceased on

    guitars (though

    continued

    on

    pianos

    and

    harps)

    in 1928.

    The

    major

    reason

    for the

    ever

    increasing

    body

    sizes on

    these

    early

    guitars

    was

    an

    attempt

    to

    get

    increased

    volume. Volume

    appears

    o be

    an

    over-riding

    concern

    of

    guitar

    makers,

    resulting

    n

    a

    great

    many

    of

    the innovations n both the steel and gut/nylon strunginstruments.In

    the

    late

    nineteenth and

    early

    twentieth

    century

    the

    guitar

    had to

    compete

    with other instruments

    the 5

    string banjo

    was

    very popular

    in the

    nineteenth

    century,

    and

    the mandolin

    rose to the

    fore around

    the

    turn

    of the

    century.

    Perhaps

    the most extreme

    example

    of

    body

    size

    occurs

    years

    later,

    with a

    Larson Brothers

    'Prairie

    State'

    guitar,

    nicknamed

    (by

    dealer

    George

    Gruhn)

    the

    'Big

    Boy'

    which has a

    width

    of

    21

    across

    he

    lower

    bout and

    is

    6%

    deep.31

    Despite

    the

    large

    sound

    30

    As shown

    and described n the

    Company's

    Catalogue

    H' of

    1912. The

    harp

    guitar

    was

    highly regarded,

    nd

    was

    displayed

    ver

    the centre

    pages.

    See Carter:

    Gibson,

    .55.

    31

    Gruhn

    at one time owned

    a

    guitar

    of this model

    and

    kept

    it as his

    personal

    instrument.

    The

    instrument

    was

    recently

    sold

    to Scott

    Chinery. They

    are

    illustrated

    n Gruhn and Carter:

    Acoustic

    Guitars,

    p.272,

    and

    in

    Vintage

    Guitar

    Gallery,anuary

    1995,

    p.12.

    96

    This content downloaded from 143.107.252.153 on Tue, 11 Nov 2014 04:43:30 AMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 8/10/2019 Darryl Martin Innovation and the Development of the Modern Six-String Guitar

    13/25

    the model had little

    impact,

    due to

    the

    difficulties

    involved in

    playing

    the instrument.

    The

    guitar

    had another

    competitor

    in

    the

    years

    around and

    following

    the Great

    War,

    with

    the

    development

    of a

    new

    type

    of

    banjo,

    with

    four

    strings

    tuned in fifths like a

    mandolin.

    The

    Gibson

    company

    paid

    little

    attention

    to this

    trend,

    and

    in

    the

    early

    1920s came

    up

    with a

    number

    of

    guitar

    innovations

    which are

    taken

    for

    granted today.

    The

    first,

    and

    most

    important,

    was the

    development

    of

    the

    adjustable

    truss

    rod,

    invented

    by

    Gibson

    employee

    Thaddeus

    Joseph

    (Ted)

    McHugh,

    the

    patent

    filed on

    5

    April

    1921 and

    granted

    on 27

    February

    1923.32

    The

    adjustable

    truss

    rod

    is

    a circular metal rod inserted into a curved slot

    in

    the

    guitar

    (or

    other fretted

    instrument)

    neck,

    securely

    fastened at one

    end,

    with a thread and nut at the other.

    By

    tightening

    this nut, the rod

    has more

    pressure

    on

    it,

    counteracting

    the tension of the

    strings.

    A

    second

    innovation,

    filed for

    and

    patented

    slightly

    earlier,

    was the

    height-adjustable

    compensated

    bridge.

    The

    adjustment

    rod and

    bridge

    are

    both

    standard

    on

    archtop

    and electric

    guitars

    today.

    The

    height

    adjustment

    has a self

    explanatory purpose,

    but the

    string length

    compensation

    takes

    into

    account the

    physics

    of

    the

    string,

    where a

    thicker

    string

    needs to be

    slightly longer

    than a

    thinner

    string

    for

    the

    fretting to have true intonation.

    The next

    innovation was a

    new model of

    guitar,

    designed

    as

    part

    of

    a new

    family

    of

    instruments,

    comprising

    mandolin, mandola,

    mandocello and

    guitar,

    and known

    as the

    Style

    5

    family.33

    These

    instruments,

    which are

    visually

    different,

    are

    associated with one

    man,

    Gibson's acoustic

    engineer

    Lloyd

    Loar,

    and

    were made

    between

    1922

    and

    1924. The mandolin

    and mandola

    retain the

    general

    body

    shape

    of

    the

    two-point

    instruments built from

    1910,

    but

    feature

    a

    longer

    neck

    with 14 frets

    clear of

    the

    body,

    a raised

    fingerboard,

    and

    f

    holes,

    rather

    than the

    earlier oval

    holes. The

    mandocello has

    the

    same

    body

    shape

    as

    the

    guitar,

    both 16

    wide at the

    lower

    bout,

    and

    featuring

    a raised

    fingerboard,

    f

    holes,

    a

    tailpiece

    to

    hold

    the

    32

    Patent

    Number

    1446758.

    33

    Each

    type

    of

    instrument

    was

    given

    its own

    initial,

    n

    many

    casesbasedon

    the

    earlierdesignations sedby the GibsonCompany.The mandolinwasbuiltin the

    fancy

    scroll

    version

    as the

    F5,

    the mandola was

    referred to as

    the

    H5,

    the

    mandocello

    the

    K5,

    and the

    guitar

    the L5. Gibson

    were

    also

    making

    Master

    Model

    (Style

    5)

    banjos,

    for

    example

    the TB5

    (tenor

    banjo)

    and RB5

    (regular

    banjo

    with 5

    strings).

    The

    banjos

    could

    not

    be

    tuned

    during

    construction

    and

    thereforeare

    not

    signed

    by

    Loar.There is

    also at least

    one A5

    model,

    a

    mandolin

    using

    the

    symmetrical

    A

    body shape

    but

    subjected

    o the

    same acoustical

    ests,

    which was

    signedby

    Loar

    and has survived.

    97

    This content downloaded from 143.107.252.153 on Tue, 11 Nov 2014 04:43:30 AMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 8/10/2019 Darryl Martin Innovation and the Development of the Modern Six-String Guitar

    14/25

    strings,34

    and 14 clear frets on the

    neck.35

    The

    biggest

    contribution

    occurs

    in

    the

    construction

    where

    all

    of the

    major parts

    -

    the

    soundboard,

    back,

    two

    soundbars,

    fholes

    and air chamber were

    'tuned'

    -

    adjusted

    so

    that each element

    was

    tuned,

    literally,

    to a

    specific

    note on

    an

    equal-tempered

    scale based on a' = 440 Hz

    (our

    modern

    pitch).36

    This

    process

    was carried

    out

    by

    trial

    and

    error,

    but was

    scrupulously

    followed.

    Each

    instrument,

    when

    completed,

    was

    tested

    and had

    a

    label,

    signed

    by

    Loar,

    inserted

    into the

    instrument

    to

    confirm

    it

    having passed

    the acoustic tests.

    There were about 350

    Loar-signed

    instruments,

    approximately

    250

    of

    them

    mandolins,

    and these instruments

    are

    considered

    by

    collectors

    today

    to be the ultimate

    designed

    instrument

    family.

    Lloyd

    Loar left

    Gibson at the end

    of 1924 over a

    disagreement

    concerning another innovation of his - electric instruments. The Style

    5 instruments

    were ahead

    of their

    time,

    but

    the electric

    instruments

    even

    more so. The

    general concepts

    of Loar's

    design

    would

    not be used

    particularly

    until the

    1980s,

    and

    though

    the

    Gibson

    company

    showed

    the instruments

    to their

    teacher-agents they

    met with little

    success

    and

    were not considered

    financially

    viable to manufacture.

    In

    fact,

    the

    Style

    5 instruments

    themselves

    were not

    particularly

    viable.

    Although

    no one

    would

    question

    their

    quality,

    they

    were built

    at a time when

    the

    tenor

    banjo

    was

    at the

    height

    of it's

    popularity,

    and with start

    up

    costs

    taken

    into account the models

    put

    Gibson into an

    extremely

    bad financial

    position.

    Elsewhere

    in America

    saw the

    development

    of another

    new

    innovative

    type

    of

    guitar.

    Marketed

    under the name

    National,

    the 'resonator

    guitar'

    dispensed

    with

    the idea

    of a

    vibrating

    wooden

    soundboard,

    and

    instead

    used

    something

    similar

    to

    a

    loudspeaker

    concept,

    the

    guitar's

    bridge

    being

    mounted

    on an aluminium

    cone

    which

    vibrated.

    The

    resulting

    instrument

    had

    a much

    louder volume than

    the standard

    guitar,

    as well

    as

    a noticeably different tone. The earlier guitars were built with square

    necks,

    to be

    placed

    face

    up

    on the

    player's

    knees and

    played

    with

    a steel

    bar

    sliding

    across the

    strings

    in

    imitation

    of

    Hawaiian

    music,

    by

    then

    very

    4

    The

    tailpiece

    is an innovation

    that comes

    from

    the

    mandolins,

    which

    in turn

    has

    a

    history

    that can be traced

    back to

    violin

    family

    instruments

    and

    early

    steel-

    strung

    fretted instruments

    such as the cittern

    and chittara

    battente.

    The main

    advantage

    is that the

    tailpiece

    supports

    the

    strings

    from

    the end of

    the

    guitar

    rather than the bridge which would have the risk of being torn off by

    the

    tension

    of the

    strings.

    The earlier

    scroll

    body

    style

    O

    guitar

    also

    has a

    tailpiece,

    as do

    earlier

    harp

    guitars.

    The earliest

    instruments

    by

    the Gibson

    company,

    and those

    by

    Orville

    Gibson

    himself,

    had a

    bridge

    that was

    glued

    to the

    soundboard,

    with

    the

    strings

    anchored

    through

    the

    bridge by

    small

    tapered pins.

    35

    The scroll

    body Style O

    guitars

    had a

    cutaway

    on the treble

    side,

    and

    15 clear

    frets to

    the

    body

    join,

    but the

    standard

    Gibson

    guitars

    had

    only

    12

    frets clear.

    36

    See

    Carter:

    Gibson,

    pp.82-84.

    98

    This content downloaded from 143.107.252.153 on Tue, 11 Nov 2014 04:43:30 AMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 8/10/2019 Darryl Martin Innovation and the Development of the Modern Six-String Guitar

    15/25

    popular

    n the

    United States.37

    he

    roundneck

    panish-style uitars

    were

    introduceda

    year

    ater.The idea of the resonator

    guitar

    camefrom

    John

    Dopyera,

    who

    applied

    for a

    patent

    on 9

    April

    1927.38

    The

    new

    production

    instruments

    were built with the

    bridge resting

    on three

    aluminium cones, now known as the tri-cone system. Wood was

    dispensed

    with

    altogether,

    he

    sides,

    back

    and neck

    being

    made of

    nickel

    plated

    'German

    silver',

    often

    heavily engraved. Following

    a business

    upheaval,

    a

    new instrumentwith a

    wooden

    body

    and the

    bridge resting

    on a

    single

    cone was

    developed,

    underthe brandname Dobro.

    In

    1929 the

    WallStreetCrash

    provided

    he

    catalyst

    o

    plunge

    America

    into the

    depression,

    orcing

    Gibson to start

    making

    wooden

    toys

    to

    get

    enough

    turnover

    o avoid

    bankruptcy,

    nd Martinmade

    (although

    never

    sold) rosewoodjewellery.However,despitethe financialconstraints n

    consumers,

    he

    1930s

    probably

    tandas the most

    innovative

    period

    in

    the

    history

    of

    the

    guitar,

    at

    least

    n

    regard

    o the introductionof new

    models

    which

    havehad a

    lasting

    effect

    on

    the

    guitar.

    The

    first,

    and

    probably

    most far

    reaching,

    innovation was the

    development

    of

    the electric

    guitar.

    This was

    originally

    another

    attempt

    to make a

    louder,

    more

    successfulHawaiian

    nstrument.The

    principle

    of

    the

    guitar

    pickup

    is

    fairly

    simple

    -

    a

    magnet

    (or

    group

    of

    magnets)

    is

    surrounded

    by

    a

    very

    thin

    copper

    wire,

    wound around t

    many

    times,39

    throughwhich the vibrationsof the stringsare turned into an electric

    current

    which then is sent to

    an

    amplifier.

    The

    earliest

    commercially

    made

    electric

    (Hawaiian)

    uitar

    s

    referred o as the

    'Fryingpan',

    due to

    its

    shape,

    and was

    introduced

    by

    the

    Rickenbacker

    Company

    in

    1931.

    The

    first

    Electric

    Spanish

    guitars

    (as

    most

    American

    companies

    tend to

    refer o

    guitars

    played

    n

    the

    normal or

    'Spanish' tyle)

    came soon after.40

    The

    use of a

    pickup

    eliminatedthe

    need for an acoustic

    chamber

    -

    to

    avoidfeedback

    a

    solid

    body

    guitar

    s more

    desirable.

    37

    A

    number of

    Hawaiian

    guitars

    were built

    by

    different

    manufacturers.

    Many

    designs

    were

    developments

    of

    the standard

    guitar,

    however,

    others

    were

    specifically

    or

    this

    playing

    technique, having

    a

    body

    that extended the

    whole

    length

    of

    the

    instrument n

    an

    attempt

    o

    increase he

    volume.

    Ukeleles were also

    very popular

    at

    this

    time.

    The

    manufacture

    of

    Hawaiian

    nstruments

    was

    the

    initial

    reason

    the

    Martin

    Company

    started

    putting

    steel

    strings

    on

    their

    guitars.

    This

    process

    was

    completed

    at Martin

    by

    1930

    when

    all

    instruments

    Hawaiian

    andSpanish had steelstringsas standard.

    38

    See

    Gruhn and Carter:

    Acoustic

    Guitars,

    pp.225-229

    for a

    history

    of the

    resonator

    guitar

    and the

    various

    family

    feuds and

    Companies

    associatedwith

    these

    instruments.

    39

    A

    typical

    Fender

    Stratocaster

    ickup

    of

    1954-55

    has

    about

    8350

    turns of

    wire.

    See Andre

    Duchossoir,

    TheFender

    tratocaster

    Milwaukee,

    1989).

    40

    An

    early

    example

    of

    a

    Rickenbacker electric

    guitar

    can be seen at the

    Horniman

    Museum, London,

    Catalogue

    No.M52-1992.

    99

    This content downloaded from 143.107.252.153 on Tue, 11 Nov 2014 04:43:30 AMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 8/10/2019 Darryl Martin Innovation and the Development of the Modern Six-String Guitar

    16/25

    Guitarists

    are

    by

    nature

    very

    conservative

    in

    approach,

    and

    the

    introduction

    of a successful electric

    pickup

    did

    not mean that acoustic

    guitars

    would

    lose

    popularity.

    The

    typical

    use of the

    archtop

    guitar

    (for

    example

    the

    Lloyd

    Loar

    L5

    guitar)

    was

    in

    jazz

    combos and

    orchestras,

    and was

    usually

    confined

    to a

    rhythm

    role due to the volume limitations.

    Despite

    the

    depression,

    Gibson introduced

    their

    largest,

    fanciest,

    and

    most

    expensive

    archtop

    model,

    the

    Super

    400,

    in

    1934.41

    This model was

    18

    wide across

    the lower

    bout,

    a full

    2

    inches wider than

    the Loar

    model

    L5,

    which

    in turn was advanced to 17 wide.

    The

    top

    of the

    instrument

    was braced

    in a X

    pattern,

    unlike the earlier

    parallel

    barring

    on the L5

    [see

    Figs.

    5 and

    6].

    FIG.

    5.

    Gibson,

    Super

    00

    FIG.

    6.

    Gibson,

    L5

    Elsewhere

    Martin,

    having

    lagged

    behind

    in the

    design

    of new

    instruments

    for

    many years,

    and

    having

    just

    switched

    from

    gut

    to

    steel

    stringing,

    started

    to

    develop

    new models.

    The

    first

    was the OM

    (Orchestra

    Model),

    introduced

    in

    1929,

    featuring

    a

    14 fret

    neck and

    a

    modified 000

    body

    (it

    retained

    the same

    width but was

    shorter

    in

    length).

    The second

    new model

    was the

    'D',

    15%

    wide at

    the lower

    bout,

    with

    a

    waist

    nearly

    as wide as

    the

    upper

    bout.

    The D

    in

    the

    model

    designation

    stood for

    Dreadnought,

    named

    after the

    British

    battleship

    built

    in 1906.

    The

    X-barring

    inside the instrument was by this time fully established

    [see

    Fig.

    7].

    Despite

    the introduction

    of the

    14 fret neck on

    the

    OM

    and

    other

    models,

    the

    D instruments were

    initially

    built

    with a

    12

    fret

    neck.

    41

    For a full

    history

    of the

    Super

    400,

    and the

    relatedversions

    of the

    L5 see

    Thomas A.

    Van Hoose:

    The

    Gibson

    Super

    400,

    Art

    of

    the Fine

    Guitar

    (San

    Francisco,

    991).

    100

    This content downloaded from 143.107.252.153 on Tue, 11 Nov 2014 04:43:30 AMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 8/10/2019 Darryl Martin Innovation and the Development of the Modern Six-String Guitar

    17/25

    1 7 7 7 7

    FIG.

    7.

    Martin&

    Co,

    D

    Model

    The first D models were made

    in

    1931,

    and

    by

    1933

    they

    were

    popular

    enough

    to be ordered

    by

    Gene

    Autry,

    a

    popular

    film

    singing

    star,

    who

    asked orhis instrument o be decoratedn the Company'smostexpensive

    style.

    This instrument s the first

    D45,

    and

    is

    probably

    he most

    valuable

    guitar

    ever made.42

    Only

    91

    pre-war

    D45s

    exist

    -

    the first

    2,

    and a later

    special

    order

    with a

    12

    fret

    neck,

    the remainderwith the

    standard

    4 fret

    neck.

    It is this model

    which

    has

    turned

    around he

    fortunes

    on the Martin

    company,

    and s the

    industry teel-strung

    lat

    top

    standard

    oday.

    Gibson was awareof the

    improvement

    n the

    fortunes

    of

    the Martin

    company,

    and

    introduced

    two models to

    compete.

    The

    first

    was the

    SuperJumbo 200. This instrumentwas, like the D45, built with the

    Western

    cowboy type player

    n mind. The

    SJ200

    had

    a

    noticeably

    wider

    body

    than the

    D45,

    measuring

    16'8

    (later 17 )

    across he lower

    bout.

    The

    first

    nstrumentwas built

    in

    1934 for

    singing cowboy Ray

    Corrigan,

    a western film actor who has

    genuine

    ties to the real 'wild

    west',

    befriending

    William 'Buffalo

    Bill'

    Cody

    in

    Milwaukee,

    and then

    working

    in

    the real-estate business with

    Wyatt

    Earp.43

    Most

    other

    big-name singing cowboys

    purchased

    similar

    instruments

    soon after.

    42Thiswasnot the mostvaluable

    guitar

    when

    new,

    but would almost

    certainly

    fetch a record

    price

    for a

    guitar

    were it to ever come onto

    the

    market,

    even

    without

    the

    ownership

    connection. Pre-war

    D45

    guitars

    are

    commonly

    considered

    he most valuable ommon

    production

    vintage

    guitars.

    43

    See

    Vintage

    Guitar

    Gallery,April

    1995

    for more

    details

    about

    this

    guitar

    and

    the life of

    Ray Corrigan.

    The

    article s written

    by

    the

    collectorHank

    Risan,

    who

    now

    owns this

    guitar.

    101

    This content downloaded from 143.107.252.153 on Tue, 11 Nov 2014 04:43:30 AMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 8/10/2019 Darryl Martin Innovation and the Development of the Modern Six-String Guitar

    18/25

    Gibson also

    introduced the Advanced

    Jumbo,

    a

    16

    wide

    Dreadnought-

    shaped guitar

    aimed

    to

    compete

    directly

    against

    the Martin instruments.

    The

    X-barring

    of the

    Martin

    guitars

    was also featured

    on these

    instruments.

    Gibson also introduced the hybrid

    jazz

    electric guitar with the ES150

    model,

    first

    produced

    in 1937. The model featured

    a

    fairly

    standard

    archtop jazz guitar

    (with

    spruce

    soundboard,

    as

    on all

    the

    acoustic

    archtops)

    with

    a

    built-in

    electric

    pickup.

    A

    year

    later a fancier

    17 wide

    model,

    the

    ES250,

    was introduced. The

    pickup

    used a

    single

    bar

    magnet

    and

    is

    referred

    to this

    day

    as the

    'Charlie Christian

    pickup',

    after the

    musician who

    popularised

    it. The move was a

    major step

    forward for the

    guitar

    (and guitarists),

    as for the

    first

    time the instrument

    could be used as

    a single melodic

    line solo instrument

    in

    the

    jazz bands, competing

    with

    trumpets

    and

    saxophones.

    At the end of the decade

    archtop guitars

    were

    being regularly

    built with a

    cutaway

    on the

    treble side at the

    upper

    bout

    to allow

    easy

    access to the

    upper

    frets.

    Nearly

    all

    archtop

    and electric

    guitars

    make

    use of

    that

    innovation

    today.

    Until

    the

    beginning

    of the 1930s

    Europe

    had little

    involvement

    in

    any

    great

    innovations

    on the

    guitar.

    The classical instrument

    as

    developed

    by

    Torres

    was

    being

    refined

    in

    Spain

    and elsewhere

    by

    makers

    such as

    Manual

    Ramirez,

    Santos

    Hernandez,

    Miguel Simplico,

    Hermann

    Hauser

    and Robert Bouchet.44 Both Hauser in Germany, and Bouchet in France

    used a

    barring

    arrangement

    in

    some

    of

    their

    instruments

    following

    a

    Torres

    design

    with several

    of the fan struts

    passing

    through

    an

    aperture

    in

    the

    upper

    harmonic

    bar,

    Bouchet

    with such success

    it is often

    considered

    his

    own invention.45

    [See

    Fig.

    8.]

    The next

    innovative

    step

    in

    Europe

    occurred

    when the

    Paris based Selmer

    company,

    under the

    direction

    of

    the

    Italian

    guitarist

    and

    instrument

    maker Mario

    Maccafferi,

    introduced

    their

    range

    of instruments

    in

    1932.46

    The first

    period

    lasted

    less

    than two

    years

    before

    Maccaferri

    left,

    and

    saw the introduction

    of

    four

    standard

    guitar

    models

    -

    a normal

    Spanish

    style

    classical

    guitar;

    a 'Concert'

    model

    classical

    guitar

    featuring

    a

    D-shaped

    soundhole

    and treble

    upper

    bout

    cutaway;

    and

    steel

    string guitars

    -

    the

    'Jazz'

    model,

    built

    identically

    to

    the

    'Concert'

    gut-strung

    model,

    and

    an 'Orchestra'

    model.

    The

    steel-strung

    guitars

    have

    floating

    bridges,47

    and

    strings

    attached

    to the

    tailpieces

    as

    found

    in

    the

    American-made

    jazz

    archtop

    guitars.

    One

    particular

    44

    See

    Romanillos:

    Antonio

    de

    Torres,

    Part

    1, Chapter

    4

    for details.

    45

    See

    Guitar

    nternational,

    ovember

    1986.

    This issue

    of the

    magazine

    eatured

    an

    obituary

    of Bouchet

    and details

    of

    his

    work.

    46

    For

    a

    good

    outline

    history

    of

    these

    guitars,

    and the

    history

    of the

    company

    see

    Vintage

    Guitar

    Gallery,

    April

    1994.

    47A

    'floatingbridge'

    is one

    in

    which

    the base

    of the

    bridge

    is not

    glued

    to the

    soundboard,

    but

    is

    shaped

    o fit and held

    against

    t

    by

    the

    pressure

    f

    the

    strings,

    similar

    o

    that of a violin.

    102

    This content downloaded from 143.107.252.153 on Tue, 11 Nov 2014 04:43:30 AMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 8/10/2019 Darryl Martin Innovation and the Development of the Modern Six-String Guitar

    19/25

    FIG.8. Bouchet

    innovation

    was the use

    of

    an internal

    resonator o

    increase he volume.

    The instruments

    were all built

    with flat

    tops (though appear

    arched

    due

    to the curved

    soundboard

    barring)

    and were

    initially

    built

    with

    12

    fret

    necks.The fame of theseinstruments anbe attributedo the gypsy azz

    guitarist

    Django

    Reinhardt,

    who

    used a

    'Jazz'

    model

    from 1933 until his

    death

    in

    1953.

    Many jazz guitarists

    used these

    instruments

    on

    the

    strength

    on Reinhardt's

    erformances.

    After

    Maccaferri eft the

    company

    a number

    of

    changes

    were

    made to the

    instruments,

    particularly

    he

    abandonment

    of

    the internal

    resonator,

    he increase rom

    12 to 14 clear

    fretson the

    neck,

    and

    the

    increase

    n

    string

    ength

    from 640

    mm

    to

    670

    mm. This is the

    longest string length

    of

    any

    standard

    wentieth-century

    guitar.48

    The

    period

    from the late 1930s saw the

    rise of several

    ndependent

    American luthiers

    making

    totally

    hand-crafted

    archtop guitars.

    The

    Strombergs

    father

    Charles,

    and son

    Elmer

    -

    started

    making archtop

    guitars

    n

    the

    early

    1930s,

    as did the New Yorkmaker

    ohn

    D'Angelico.49

    Both of

    these

    workshops

    commenced

    by building

    instruments

    that

    basically copied

    Gibson

    designs

    but later evolved their

    own models.

    Although

    much of their

    design

    was evolved from the

    work of

    previous

    48

    Occasionallyother makershave- sed the samelength,for exampleRichard

    Schneider,

    working

    to

    the

    designs

    of Dr.

    Michael

    Kasha

    (see

    Tom and

    Mary

    Anne Evans:

    Guitars:

    rom

    he

    Renaissance

    o Rock

    New

    Yorkand

    London,

    1977),

    and

    was

    even

    slightly

    exceeded

    (672 mm)

    in a

    nineteenth-century

    guitar by

    Miguel

    Moya,

    see Romanillos:

    Antoniode

    Torres,

    .117.

    49

    For a

    history

    ofJohn

    D'Angelico

    and

    a

    discussionof

    his instruments ee Paul

    William Schmidt:

    Acquired

    f

    the

    Angels:

    The

    livesand

    works

    f

    master

    uitar

    makers

    JohnD'Angelico

    nd

    ames

    L.

    D'Aquisto

    Metuchen

    N.J.

    and

    London,

    1991).

    103

    This content downloaded from 143.107.252.153 on Tue, 11 Nov 2014 04:43:30 AMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 8/10/2019 Darryl Martin Innovation and the Development of the Modern Six-String Guitar

    20/25

    archtop

    builders,

    these makers were

    able to

    make

    instruments

    as custom-

    ordered

    by players.

    The

    Strombergs

    developed

    a standard

    model which

    was

    larger

    than the Gibson

    Super

    400

    -

    the

    Stromberg

    'Master 400'

    measures

    19

    across the lower

    bout,

    their smaller 'Deluxe'

    measuring

    17% .

    D'Angelico

    retained the

    18

    and 17 models to match

    Gibson,

    but also

    made a number of custom instruments a full

    19

    wide. These

    instruments

    were often

    amplified

    (as

    were the Gibson L5 and

    Super

    400)

    by

    floating pickups

    attached to the

    end

    of

    the

    fingerboard

    so that the

    vibrations

    of

    the

    soundboard were

    not

    impeded.

    The second World War

    interrupted

    most

    guitar making,

    but about this

    time

    the

    major

    innovation of

    the classical

    guitar

    world

    occurred

    when

    Albert

    Augustine developed

    and

    perfected

    the

    nylon

    classical

    guitar

    string. Of all the innovations mentioned, this is probably the most

    successful.

    It was soon

    adopted by nearly

    all classical

    guitar players

    and

    50

    years

    after

    the invention is used almost without

    exception

    todays5.

    The

    advantages

    of

    nylon

    are that the

    strings

    have a

    higher

    breaking

    strain

    (can

    be

    tuned

    higher

    before

    they

    break),

    whereas

    gut

    was

    nearing

    its

    limits

    at

    modern

    pitch,

    the

    strings

    tend to be

    truer,51

    they

    are

    non-hygroscopic,

    thus

    retaining

    their

    tuning

    better,

    and were

    cheaper

    and

    readily

    available.52

    Perhaps the post war years up to 1963 mark the greatest number of

    innovative

    changes

    to the

    guitar,

    almost all of

    which

    have

    survived and

    in

    many

    cases

    define the

    guitar today.

    The

    earlier

    period

    of

    development

    concerned

    the American

    popular

    instrument.

    Shortly

    after the

    war saw

    the

    development

    of the

    first electric

    solidbody spanish

    guitar

    built

    in

    5

    do not know of

    any

    classical

    uitarist

    who

    plays

    with

    gut

    strings

    nowadays,

    with the

    exception

    of

    period

    instrument

    performers

    either

    playing

    copies,

    or

    originalnineteenth-centurynstruments, r early wentieth-century uitars.This

    is

    perhaps

    unfortunatebecause

    gut produces

    a

    different

    ound which

    most

    people

    tend

    to

    prefer

    o

    nylon,

    and this is an

    example

    of

    players

    uffering

    a loss of tone

    quality

    for convenience

    and ease. It

    would,

    of

    course,

    be

    'unauthentic'

    o

    play

    modern

    pieces

    on

    a

    gut

    strung

    instrument,

    but

    it

    would

    be

    interesting

    o hear

    early

    twentieth-century

    music

    played

    on

    a

    gut strung guitar.

    So

    successful

    has

    been

    the

    development

    of

    nylon

    strings

    hat

    many

    lutenistsuse

    nylon

    rather han

    gut

    on

    lutes,

    vihuelas

    and

    baroque

    guitars.

    51

    Trueness

    of a

    string

    is

    easily

    checked

    by

    playing

    a

    harmonic at the twelfth

    fretand then playinga frettednote at the samefret. The pitch of a stringthatis

    'true'

    will

    be

    identical.Defects

    in the

    string

    would

    cause differences

    which have

    obvious

    implications

    or the

    tuning

    of

    the

    guitar

    when

    played,

    particularly

    t

    the

    higher

    frets. It

    must

    be

    said that

    nylon

    is

    by

    no mean